God-debateIlkwaenChung

7/28/2019 God-debateIlkwaenChung

1/46

60

: 2013 6 1() 10~12

: /

:

:

: ()

:

2013 ()


2/46

60

: 2013 6 1() 10~12

: /

:

:

: () :

2013 ()


3/46

[ ]

2013 6 1

9:40

10:00

10:30

11:00

:

11:30

12:00

[ ]

1 ()

() 1

() 16

2 ()

:

() 22

() 40


4/46

()

- 1 -

1)

(, )

1.

2. 1)

2)

3.

4. : 1) -

2)

3)

4)

5.

1.

, .

, .

.

. 3 .

, ,

.

. .

1) , 2013 5

24-25 .


5/46

/////// ////

- 2 -

, .

.

, , ,

. . .

.

,

, , ,

. , ,

.

, .

. .(Nancy Murphy, 1990)

.

(Bentley)

.

(R. Boyle) (Kepler) .

. (Deism)

.

. .

, ,

. ,

.

. ,

.

.

.

,

.


6/46

()

- 3 -

2.

,

. ,

.

. ,

, .

,

.

1)

, . ,

, , .( , ,

, pp. 139-187)

. ,

.

.

. .

.

.( , , ,

p143)

1) .

2)

3) .

4) ,

.

5)

6) .( 4) 5) )

. ,

, ,

.


7/46

/////// ////

- 4 -

,

,

.

, .

.

.

. .2)

.

.

.

.

,

. .

. (Hartshone, C.)

.( , , , p. 148 )

.

,

? .

.

, .

, .

.

.

.

2) .

. .

. . . .


8/46

()

- 5 -

.(Hick, John, A critque of the 'second

argument', in The many faced argument, ed. Hick and McGill, pp.345-5,

, p. 145-149 )

.

.

. .

?

? . .

,

. .

.

.

.

.

?

.

.

2)

.

.

.

.

. , , ,

. ,

.

, .(

, , p. 150-151)

, (Craig)

. ,


9/46

/////// ////

- 6 -

( ) .

.( 19

.)(( , , p. 151)

.

1) .

2) .

3) .( p.151, originally

Craig, William, The Kalam Cosmological Argument, New York: Barnes & Noble,

1979, p.63)

. ?

. .

.

. .

.

. .

,

. , .

. . .

.

,

. , .

.

.

.

.

. .

? ?

, ,

,

. .


10/46

()

- 7 -

.

.

.( )

? .

.

, .

? ?

.

.

. .

? ?

.

? ?

3.

, . .

, ,

. .

.

, .

, .

.

, .

.

?

? , ? ?

.


11/46

/////// ////

- 8 -

(foundationalism)

. .

.

. . .(

, p.193)

?

,

.

.

, .

.

.

. .

. .

,

, ,

. ?

. , ,

, .

, ,

. .

.

. .

.

.

. ?

.

,

.

.

.

. ,


12/46

()

- 9 -

. ,

.

.

. . , . ,

. ,

,

, ,

.

.

.

.

.

.

. .

.

, .

.

, .

.

. ,

.

.

.

. , .

, .

.

,

, . ,

.


13/46

/////// ////

- 10 -

4. : 3)

.

. ,

.

. ,

. ,

.

.

1) -

1900

.(Planck, M., 1967a[1900], On

an improvement of Wiens Equation for the spectrum, The Old Quantum

Theory, by D. Terr Haar, Pergamon Press, 1967, pp. 7981[1900

ber eine Verbesserung der Wienschen Spektralgleichung,

Verhandlungen der Deutschen Physikalischen Gesellschaft 2: 202204).

h 2h, 3h. . .

.

.

, 0h, 0.1 v. 0.2h

. . 1h 1.2h, 1.5h . . .

. .

. ,

,

.

.

. 5 1905 radiation law

.

,

.

3) John Polkinghorn . , , .


14/46

()

- 11 -

. . ,

fluorescence , ,

associated

, . ,

,

(Einstein, 1965: 368, originally Einstein, A., 1905, ber einen Erzeugung und

Verwandlung des Lichtes betreffenden heuristishcen Gesichtspunkt, Ann. Physik

17)

.

.

. .

. .

,

. ?

?

.

. , .

.

?

.

,

.

.

.

, ,

?

. ,

.


15/46

/////// ////

- 12 -

2)

. .

.

.

. ,

.

- .

. .

. .

.

, . ,

. ,

. .

.

.

? , ,

?

3)

. .

, .

.

. .

, .

. .

. .

4)

.

?

, .


16/46

()

- 13 -

,

.

,

. . ,

,

.

.

.

. ,

. ,

.

. ,

. .

,

, .

,

,

.

. .

, , ,

. ,

.

. ,

. , , ,

. ,

.

.


17/46

/////// ////

- 14 -

5.

.

.

.

? ? ?

?

,

.

.

. .

.

. ,

,

.

. .


18/46

()

- 15 -

()

2 , , .

. A, B, C , .

(1) .

(2) .

(3) .

(4) synchronically diachronically .

,

. , -

. .

, ,

.

.

, .

. . ,

. ,

.

- .

,

.

- .

.

.

? .

, , .

.

.

. .


19/46

/////// ////

- 16 -

: - , , God-debate -

(, )

1. -

-

. .

.

(Bentley)

. (R. Boyle)

(Kepler) .

?

(Needhams Grand Question) .

Joseph Needham

.

.

. - 150

.4)

:

.

.

,

. .

(Protestant Buddhism)

. -

.

.

.5)

4) 40, 2009. http://www.budreview.com/news/articleView.html?idxno=8735) Ilkwaen Chung, Paradoxie der weltgestaltenden Weltentsagung im Buddhismus. Ein


20/46

: ()

- 17 -

()

, ,

,

.6)

2. (gods delusion)

6,000 .

. ,

20

, ,

.

() (gods delusion),

() ,

: (: SFC ,

2013) .7)

. 2013

(gods delusion) - God-debate -

.8)

.

,

.

.

. .

. .

,

Zugang aus der Sicht der mimetischen Theorie Rene Girards, Beitrage zur mimetischen

Theorie 28 (Munster, Germany: Lit Verlag, 2010), p. 109.

6) Winston L. King, A Thousand Lives Away. Buddhism in Contemporary Burma

(Berkeley: Asian Humanities Press. 1964), p. 145.

7) , :

(: SFC , 2013).8) 2013 , , 2013, pp. 213-22.


21/46

/////// ////

- 18 -

. ,

. .

.

.

.

. .

?

?

?

, .

. ,

. ,

.

(gods delusion) -

God-debate - (The God Delusion)

, , , .

9.11

. , -

- .

. (The Dawkins Confusion.

Naturalism 'ad absurdum') .

- ,

.

.9) C. (John Lennox)

?

, , ,

.

-

,

9) Alvin Plantinga, "The Dawkins Confusion. Naturalism 'ad absurdum,'" ChristianityToday, March/April 2007.March/April 2007.


22/46

: ()

- 19 -

.

4. :

.

. . , .

.

,

. ,

.

.

,

.

.

3.

20

.10)

R. Hooykass .

,

.

. , ,

. 19

()

.

(perichoresis)

(perichoresis and interpenetration of matter).

Faraday Clerk Maxwell ()

, (Butterfly Effect)

10) , -

, , MDiv , 1996. 4) ,pp.32-34 .


23/46

/////// ////

- 20 -

.

, , ,

, , ,

, . 20

( )

.

Clerk Maxwell , Clerk Maxwell Michael

Faraday .

Michael Faraday, Clerk Maxwell

.

. 20

Thomas F. Torrance Cleark Maxwell

. Colin Gunton M. Faraday

(perichoresis)

. (perichoresis)

.

.

,

, , ()

.

John Polkinghorne ,

. .

.

,

.

, ,

.

- .

, .

. , .


24/46

: ()

- 21 -

.

. .

, .

. .

.

.

. , , ,

.

, . .

.

.

? ?

?

.


25/46

/////// ////

- 22 -

:

(, )

1.

2. :

3. : vs. 1)

2)

4. 1)

2)

3)

4)

5. 1)

2)

3)

6. 1) ?

2)

7.

1.

100 , , , ,

.1)

1) 2011 100

(Jernimo, Garcia and Mitcham 2013), (WheatenCollege) 2012 .


26/46

: ()

- 23 -

54 , 100

. , ,

.

. 1990 ,

,

.

(The Technological Society) .

,

.

(Propaganda)

.

.

.

,

.

.

(Ellul 1981/1982: vi-vii).

.2)

.3) , .

.

.

(Ellul 1981: 306) .

.

2) (David W. Gill)

(Ellul, 1981/1982: vii).

3) .

,

.

(Ellul 1981/1982: 202; Ellul and Trude-Chastenet 1992:54, cf.

Vanderburg 2004/2010: 173).

. .


27/46

/////// ////

- 24 -

.

, .

,

.

1

, .

. 3

. 4 , 5

.

.

2. :

. 18(1930)

,

(Vanderburg 2004/2010: 33, 41).

, ,

(Vanderburg 2004/2010: 41-43).

, 20 1932

.4)

(Vanderburg 2004/2010: 45).

,

(schizophrenic) (Ellul 1981/1982:

174) .

4) 1929, (Ellul and Troude-Chastenet 1994/2005: 55).


28/46

: ()

- 25 -

,

. ,

.

(Vanderburg 2004/2010:

45).

,

. ,

(Vanderburg 2004/2010: 71).

.

.

.

. (Ellul

1948/2008: 41),

.

, ,

(Ellul 1948/2008: 62-63).

, .

.

3. : vs.

. , , , ,

, .

,

.

,

.


29/46

/////// ////

- 26 -

1)

.

(1954/1964) (Ellul 1981/1982: v).

,

(Ellul 1981/1982: 228-229).

.

. .

.

(Martin Heidegger)

.

. 1980

(Empirical Turn)

.5)

.

. ,

, , .

.

1980

.

.

, .

.

2)

5) 2006a .


30/46

: ()

- 27 -

. 70 ( 1974)6),

1980

, .7)

,

.

.

( 2003)

.

, .

2010 .

vs. , vs. , vs.

, vs. 'X' .

.

,

.

.

,

.

. [ ]

.

( 2010: 144).

(D. Wennemann)

.

.

(Wennemann 1990: 188).

(2005)

:

6) 1974

.7) (2001, 2002) .


31/46

/////// ////

- 28 -

.

, .

, ,

. ,

.

4.

,

, .

.

(Ellul

1981) .

1)

,

()

. , ,

.

, , ?

.

(dialectician) ( 7).

.

, . .

,

. (, Burgman )

.

, . ,

.

.


32/46

: ()

- 29 -

(Ellul 1981: 293-294).

.

. .

.

. .

(Wennemann

1990: 183). (totality) ,

(Wenneman 1990: 182).

2)

.

,

.

, .8) ,

, . ,

, .

.

,

.

. (Ellul 1981: 306).

.

. ,

, , (Ellul 1981: 306).9)

8)

(Niebuhr 1951/2007) .

.

( 2010: 30-33).

9)

,

( 2003: 31, 284). .


33/46

/////// ////

- 30 -

, .

3)

.

. --- .

, .

,

.

? . ,

. , , ,

, , , , .

.

.

(Ellul 1981: 299).

(Ellul 1981:

300). , .

.

,

.

.

, ,

. .

,

(Ellul 1981: 301).

, ,

(Ellul 1981: 302; cf. Ellul 1981/1982: 211).

,

. .

. . . . .

.

.

,

,


34/46

: ()

- 31 -

.

,

(Ellul 1981: 302-303).

(Parousia) (Ellul 1981: 303-304).

,

. ,

.

, .

4)

,

.

.

.

. .

.

(Ellul 1981: 294-295; 1981/1982: 207-208).

(Ellul and Troude- Chastenet: 55).

.

(Ellul 1981: 296).

.

.

. ,

.

(Ellul 1981: 297).

,

(Ellul 1981: 296).

,

. ,

.


35/46

/////// ////

- 32 -

.

. ,

.

(Wennemann 1990: 183).

(viscerally) (Ellul 1981/1982: 203).

.

.

.

. .

,

.

5.

(

2006b; 2009),

, , .

,

.

1)

. (technique)

(technology), .

,

) (Ellul 1954/1964: xxv).

.

.

, ,

, , , , (Ellul

1954/1964: 79-147).

.


36/46

: ()

- 33 -

.

, .

. , ,

, , .

2)

.

,

.

(Winner 1977: 43).

.

(Vanderburg 2004/2010: 108-109).

. ,

.

3)

.

.

, (Ellul 1954/1064: 21,

110).

.

, .

. ,

,

.

,

.

.

(The Technological Bluff)(1988/1990)


37/46

/////// ////

- 34 -

.

,

.

,

, .10)

.

. ,

.

6.

1) ?

.

, , .

(Ellul, 1988/1990: 411).

, ?

, .

.

,

. .

,

. .

.

10) Son 2013 .


38/46

: ()

- 35 -

(Ellul 1954/1964: xxvii-xxviii).

, () ,

.

.

. ,

.

.

.

,

?

.

(Son 2004: 170-172).

.

(monocracy),

. , 11) (technocracy)

. (technocrat)

. . , (Ellul 1992: 38).

, .

(Ellul 1981/1982: 117-138;

Vanderburg 2004/2010: 59, 127) .

, ,

.

(Ellul 1981/1982: 208).

.

.

11) Nomenklatura. .


39/46

/////// ////

- 36 -

.

(Ellul 1970: 170).

(active pessimism)

(Ellul 1970: 181).

.

2)

,

.

.

,

.

.

.

.

, ,

.

.

, ,

. .

.

.

. ,

.

. .

.

(Wenneman 1991: 68).

,

,


40/46

: ()

- 37 -

. , .

,

.

.

, .

.

, (Ellul 1981/1982: 202).

.12) .

.

.

,

.

7.

,

.

.

. ,

. . (dialogue)

. ,

, .

, .

, .

.

12) 1968 ,

(Vanderburg 2004/2010: 96). (1988/19990: xiii).


41/46

/////// ////

- 38 -

< >

(2001). . 54. 273-294.(2002). . .

(2003). : . .

(2006a). : . 87:

137-164.

(2006b). : . .

(2009). . . .

. 64-74.

(2010). . .(2005). : .

.

(1974). . 18 12: 95-107.

Christians, Clifford G. and Jay M. Van Hook(eds.)(1981). Jacques Ellul:

Interpretive Essays. Illinois U. P..

Ellul, Jacques(1948/2008). . . .

(1954/1964). The Technological Society. trans. by J. Wilkinson. New

York: Vintage.

(1970). The Meaning of the City. trans. by Dennis Pardee. Michigan:

Eerdmans. : .

(2013.) .

(1977/1980). The Technological System. trans. by J. Neugroschel. New

York: Continuum.

(1981). Epilogue: On Dialectic. Jacques Ellul: Interpretive Essays.

Clifford G. Christians and Jay M. Van Hook eds. Illinois U. P..

191-308.

(1981/1982). In Season Out of Season. trans. by Lani K. Niles. Harper

& Row. . (2002). .

(1988/1990). The Technological Bluff. trans. by Geoffrey W. Bromiley.

Michigan: Eerdmans.

(1992). "Technology and Democracy." Democracy in a Technological

Society. Landon Winner ed. Dortrecht: Kluwer. 35-50.

Ellul, Jacques and Patrick Troude-Chastenet(1994/2005). Jacques Ellul on


42/46

: ()

- 39 -

Politics, Technology, and Christianity: Conversation with Patrick

Troude-Chastenet. Oregon: Wipf & Stock.

Jernimo, Helena M., Jos Lus Garcia, and Carl Mitcham(eds.)(2013). Jacques

Ellul and the Technological Society in the 21st Century. Springer.

Niebuhr, Richard(1951/2007). . . IVP.

Son, Wha-Chul(2004). "A Confrontation of Jacques Ellul's Philosophy of

Technology and the Constructivist Approach to Technology." Studies in

Science and Theology, Vol 9. Lund: ESSSAT. 165-177.

(2013). Are We Still Pursuing Efficiency Principle?: Inteperting

Jacques Ellul's Efficiency Principle." Jacques Ellul and the

Technological Society in the 21st Century. Helena M. Jernimo, Jos

Lus Garcia, and Carl Mitcham eds. Springer. 49-62.

Vanderburg, Willem H.(2004/2010). , .

. .

Wennemann, D. J. (1990). "An Interpretation of Jacques Ellul's Dialectical

Method." Broad and Narrow Interpretation of Philosophy of Technology.

Paul T. Durbin ed. Amsterdam: Kluwer. 181-192.

(1991). "Freedom and Dialectic in Ellul's Thought." Research in

Philosophy and Technology. Vol. 11. 67-75.Winner, Langdon(1977). Autonomous Technology: Technics-out-of-Control as

a Theme in Political Thought. Massachusetts: MIT.

. (2000). .


43/46

/////// ////

- 40 -

: 13) :

(, )

1.

( )

.

.

, , , , ,

.

.

.

. .

.

.

, ,

. ( , , ,

1954/ 1964/ 1996) .

.14)

.

13) (Jacque Ellul) ,

.

, .

14)

, ,

, ,

, , .


44/46

: : ()

- 41 -

15)

. .

1)

.

2)

.

3) .

2.

.

.

[ ] (, 10)

.

.

.

. .

.

.

. , .

. (

, , , 1982/ 2012, 326).

. ,

, , .

15) (C. S. Lewis)

3 10 . .


45/46

/////// ////

- 42 -

. .

.

. ,

( , 325).

.

.

.

.

( , 324). ,

.

.

(

, 325). . ( , 327).

( , 326).

3.

,

. .

.

( , 448).

()

.


46/46

: : ()

.

.

.

.

.

.

50 30 ?

?

? ?

?

? ?

?

?

?

?

?

?

2

?

,

(motivation) (empowering)

(frame)

. .

God-debateIlkwaenChung

Documents