Top Banner
GRAHAM HILL Foreword by  SCOT M KNIGHT RESHAPING OUR CONVERSATI ONS, RENEWING OUR MISSION, REVITALIZING OUR CHURCHES GLOBAL CHURCH
37

GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

Aug 07, 2018

Download

Documents

Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 136

G R A H A M H I L LForeword by S C O T M 983139 K N I G H T

R E S H A P I N G O U R C O N V E R S A T I O N S

R E N E W I N G O U R M I S S I O N

R E V I T A L I Z I N G O U R C H U R C H E S

G L O B A LC H U R C H

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 236

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 336

G L O B A L

C H U R C H

R E S H A P I N G O U R C O N V E R S A T I O N S

R E N E W I N G O U R M I S S I O N

R E V I T A L I Z I N G O U R C H U R C H E S

G R A H A M H I L LForeword by S C O M 983139 K N I G H

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 436

InterVarsity Press

PO Box 1048625104862810486241048624 Downers Grove IL 98309410486249830931048625983093-104862510486281048626983094

ivpresscom

emailivpresscom

copy104862610486241048625983094 by Graham Hill

All rights reserved No part of this book may be reproduced in any form without written permission from

InterVarsity Press

InterVarsity Pressreg is the book-publishing division of InterVarsity Christian FellowshipUSAreg a movement of

students and faculty active on campus at hundreds of universities colleges and schools of nursing in the United

States of America and a member movement of the International Fellowship of Evangelical Students For

information about local and regional activities visit intervarsityorg

All Scripture quotations unless otherwise indicated are taken from the Holy Bible odayrsquos New International

Versiontrade Copyright copy 1048626104862410486241048625 by International Bible Society All rights reserved

Cover design David Fassett

Interior design Beth McGill

Images orange water color square copy kentarcajuaniStockphoto

icons of Copenhagen Brussells Austria Israel Cuba Portugal Budapest Ireland Berlin and France

copy artefyiStockphoto

blue under water copy Achim PrilliStockphoto

ISBN 10486331048631983096-1048624-9830969830911048624983096-10486281048624983096983093-1048628 (print)

ISBN 10486331048631983096-1048624-9830969830911048624983096-104863310486331048624983091-983094 (digital)

Printed in the United States of America As a member of the Green Press Initiative InterVarsity Press is committed to protecting the environmentand to the responsible use of natural resources o learn more visit greenpressinitiativeorg

Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data

Hill Graham Reverend

GlobalChurch reshaping our conversations renewing our mission revitalizing our churches Graham Hill

foreword by Scot McKnight

pages cm

Includes index

ISBN 10486331048631983096-1048624-9830969830911048624983096-10486281048624983096983093-1048628 (casebound alk paper)

1048625 Church 1048626 GlobalizationmdashReligious aspectsmdashChristianity I itle II itle Global Church

BV98309410486241048624983091H9830931048628 104862610486241048625983093

10486269830941048633mdashdc1048626983091

104862610486241048625983093104862498309198309410486241048625983093

P 1048626983091 10486261048626 10486261048625 10486261048624 10486251048633 1048625983096 10486251048631 1048625983094 1048625983093 10486251048628 1048625983091 10486251048626 10486251048625 10486251048624 1048633 983096 1048631 983094 983093 1048628 983091 1048626 1048625

Y 983091983093 9830911048628 983091983091 9830911048626 9830911048625 9830911048624 10486261048633 1048626983096 10486261048631 1048626983094 1048626983093 10486261048628 1048626983091 10486261048626 10486261048625 10486261048624 10486251048633 1048625983096 10486251048631 1048625983094

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 536

C O N T E N T S

List of Figures and ables 983097

Foreword by Scot McKnight 983089983089

983089 Introduction Being Salt Light and a City 983089983091

Part 983089 Salt Reshaping Our Conversations

983090 Glocalizing Conversations 983090983091

Part 983090 Light Renewing Our Mission

983091 Contextualizing Mission 983092983093

983092 Liberating People 983094983097

983093 Showing Hospitality 983097983095

983094 Embracing the Spirit 983089983089983097

983095 Caring for Creation 983089983093983095

983096 Living Ethically 983089983096983091

983097 ransforming Neighborhoods 983090983089983093

Part 983091 City Revitalizing Our Churches

983089983088 Indigenizing Faith 983090983091983095

983089983089 Devouring Scripture 983090983095983093

983089983090 Renewing Education 983091983088983089

983089983091 Practicing Servantship 983091983091983095

983089983092 Recovering Community 983091983094983091

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 636

983089983093 Developing Spirituality and Discipleship 983091983096983091

983089983094 GlobalChurch Embracing a New Narrative 983092983089983093

Appendix 983089 GlobalChurch Project Video Series 983092983093983089

Appendix 983090 Study Guide 983092983093983091

Appendix 983091 Who Are hese Majority World

and Indigenous hinkers 983092983096983089

Appendix 983092 Resources and Glossary at

heGlobalChurchProjectcom 983092983097983091

Author Index 983092983097983093

Subject Index 983092983097983097

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 736

I N T R O D U C T I O N

B983141983145983150983143 S983137983148983156 L983145983143983144983156 983137983150983140 983137 C983145983156 983161

By 9830909830889830901048629 fully two-thirds of Christians will live in

Africa Latin America and Asia Te ldquoaverage

Christianrdquo today is female black and lives in a

Brazilian favela or an African village

SEPHE N BEVANS

Majority World and indigenous churches are redefining twenty-first-

century Christianity Western churches must decide how theyrsquoll respond

Stephen Bevans puts it well

We are now living in a ldquoworld churchrdquo where the vast majority of Christians are

[from the Majority World] David Barrettrsquos statistical studies have basically con-

firmed this shi and Philip Jenkins has predicted that by 1048626104862410486261048629 fully two-thirds

of Christians will live in Africa Latin America and Asia Scholars are fairly

unanimous in acknowledging the accuracy of the facts Te ldquoaverage Christianrdquo

today is female black and lives in a Brazilian favela or an African village983089

Some statistics illustrate this shi in twenty-first-century global Christi-

anity Te Pew Research Centerrsquos report Global Christianity analyzes the size

and distribution of the worldrsquos Christian population Te report maps the

changes over the last century (1048625104863310486251048624 to 1048626104862410486251048624) It concludes ldquoA century ago the

Global North (commonly defined as North America Europe Australia Japan

1Stephen B Bevans Roger Schroeder and L J Luzbetak ldquoMissiology Afer Bosch Reverencing a

Classic by Moving Beyondrdquo International Bulletin o Missionary Research 983090983097 no 983090 (983090983088983088983093) 983094983097

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 836

10486251048628 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

and New Zealand) contained more than four times as many Christians as the

Global South (the rest of the world) oday the Pew Forum study finds more

than 10486251048627 billion Christians live in the Global South [10486301048625983077 of all Christians livein Asia Africa and Latin America] compared with about 104863210486301048624 million in the

Global North (10486271048633983077)rdquo1048626 Tat is an astounding shi in only one hundred years983091

Using the World Christian Database Philip Jenkins offers table 10486251048625

ldquoChanging distribution of Christian believersrdquo

Table 983089983089 Changing distribution of Christian believers 983089983097983088983088 to 983090983088983093983088 (number of Christiansin millions)

983089983097983088983088 983089983097983095983088 983090983088983089983088 983090983088983093983088Africa 983089983088 983089983092983091 983092983097983091 983089983088983091983089

Asia 983090983090 983097983094 983091983093983090 983094983088983089

North America 983095983097 983090983089983089 983090983096983094 983091983091983091

Latin America 983094983090 983090983095983088 983093983092983092 983094983093983093

Europe 983091983096983089 983092983097983090 983093983096983096 983093983091983088

Oceania 983093 983089983096 983090983096 983091983096

Total 983093983093983096 983089983090983091983088 983090983090983097983089 983091983089983096983096

Source Philip Jenkins The Next Christendom The Coming of Global Christianity 983091rd ed (Oxford Oxford Uni-

versity Press 983090983088983089983089) 983091 Data is taken from World Christian Database wwwworldchristiandatabaseorgwcd

Christianity in North America Europe and Oceania grew from 104862810486301048629

million in 1048625104863310486241048624 to 104863310486241048626 million in 1048626104862410486251048624983092 Tis number is likely to shrink to

104863310486241048625 million by 1048626104862410486291048624

Christianity in Africa Asia and Latin America grew from 10486331048628 million in

1048625104863310486241048624 to 1048625104862710486321048633 billion in 1048626104862410486251048624 Tis number is likely to grow to 1048626104862610486321048631 billion by

1048626104862410486291048624

Letrsquos take China for example Professor Fenggang Yang of Purdue University

makes an important prediction If current rates of growth continue within one

generation China will have more Christians than any other nation on earth

In 1048625104863310486281048633 Protestant churches in China had one million members In 1048626104862410486251048624 that

number was 10486291048632 million (compare that with 10486281048624 million in Brazil and 10486271048630 million

2Pew Research Center Global Christianity A Report on the Size and Distribution o the Worldrsquos Chris-

tian Population December 1048625983097 98309098308810486251048625 wwwpeworumorg9830909830881048625104862510486259830901048625983097global-christianity-exec3See David B Barrett George Kurian and odd M Johnson World Christian Encyclopedia A

Comparative Survey o Churches and Religions in the Modern World 983090nd ed 983090 vols (New York

Oxord University Press 9830909830889830881048625) 1048625983090-1048625983093 and wwwglobalchristianityorg4Oceania includes Australia and Micronesian Melanesian and Polynesian countries

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 936

Introduction 10486251048629

in South Africa) By 1048626104862410486261048629 there are likely to be 104862510486301048624 million Christians in China

By 1048626104862410486271048624 this number is likely to be 104862610486281048631 million (outnumbering Christians in

Mexico Brazil and the United States) In an interview with the elegraphFenggang Yang says ldquoMao thought he could eliminate religion He thought he

had accomplished this Itrsquos ironicmdashthey didnrsquot Tey actually failed completelyrdquo1048629

Philip Jenkins concludes

We are currently living through one of the transforming moments in the

history of religion worldwide Over the last five centuries the story of Chris-

tianity has been inextricably bound up with that of Europe and European-

derived civilizations overseas above all in North America Until recently theoverwhelming majority of Christians have lived in white nations Over the

last century however the center of gravity in the Christian world has shied

inexorably away from Europe southward to Africa and Latin America and

eastward toward Asia oday the largest Christian communities on the planet

are to be found in those regions1048630

What does all this mean for the mission and theology and worship and

communities of the church worldwide And what does it mean particularlyfor the Western church

In Matthew 104862910486251048627-10486251048630 Jesus provides three remarkable images of the churchmdash

salt light and a city Jesus confronts his disciples with a missional description

of the church Te church in mission is the salt of the earth the light of the

world and a city set on a hill Te churchrsquos purpose is to let its ldquolight shine

before others that they may see your good deeds and glorify your Father in

heavenrdquo Te purpose of the churchrsquos missionary nature is the worship andglorification of the Father and Son and Holy Spirit983095

Te church is another city constituted by every tribe language people

5om Phillips ldquoChina on Course to Become lsquoWorldrsquos Most Christian Nationrsquo Within 1048625983093 Yearsrdquo

elegraph April 1048625983097 98309098308810486251048628 wwwtelegraphcouknewsworldnewsasiachina1048625983088104863110486319830949830889830901048627China-on

-course-to-become-worlds-most-Christian-nation-within-1048625983093-yearshtml See Fenggang Yang and

Joseph B amney eds Conucianism and Spiritual raditions in Modern China and Beyond Re-

ligion in Chinese Societies (Boston Brill 9830909830881048625983090) Fenggang Yang and Graeme Lang eds Social

Scientific Studies o Religion in China Methodology Teories and Findings (Leiden Brill 98309098308810486251048625)

Fenggang Yang Religion in China Survival and Revival Under Communist Rule (Oxord Oxord

University Press 9830909830881048625983090)6Philip Jenkins Te Next Christendom Te Coming o Global Christianity 1048627rd ed (Oxord Ox-

ord University Press 98309098308810486251048625) 10486257J Driver Images o the Church in Mission (Scottdale PA Herald 10486259830979830971048631) 10486251048631983088-9830961048625 Graham Hill Salt

Light and a City Introducing Missional Ecclesiology (Eugene OR Wip and Stock 9830909830881048625983090) xiii

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1036

10486251048630 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

and nation Te church must cultivate a distinct social existence shaping its

community and mission around its commitment to plurality and diversity

and unity1048632 God calls his church to be a global and missional ldquocity on a hillrdquoTis is a church constituted and enriched and represented by Western and

indigenous and Majority World peoples

Tose of us in the West need a new narrative Itrsquos time to abandon our

flawed Eurocentric and Americentric worldviews We need a new global

and missional narrative and for that we must turn to the churches of Ma-

jority World and indigenous cultures Tey can help us explore what it

means to be a global missional community Many Christian communitiesin Majority World and indigenous contexts have been wrestling with these

issues for generations Marginalization and persecution and alienation have

been their lot Yet somehow in spite of or because of that they have flour-

ished In fact theyrsquove grown exponentially

So whom am I talking about when I refer to Majority World and indig-

enous Christians Majority World Christians are those in Africa Asia the

Caribbean Eastern Europe Latin America the Middle East and Oceania

1048633

I use the term Majority World because the majority of the worldrsquos population

is in those cultures today Te majority of the church is in those cultures too

I donrsquot use the terms non-Western or Tird World or Developing World Tese

terms use Western cultures as their point of reference Tey imply Western

8Barry A Harvey Another City An Ecclesiological Primer or a Post-Christian World (New York

rinity 1048625983097983097983097) 9830901048627-9830909830939I donrsquot deal with the diasporas in this book For example Irsquove made no mention o Hispanic

Portuguese or Asian minorities in the United States United Kingdom Canada Europe Austra-lia and so on Irsquom aware that right now Latin American and Chinese diasporas are active in

evangelism and mission in Europe in the same way in which the Filipino or the Salvadoran dias-

poras carry on mission in the United States Irsquove chosen not to include voices rom the diasporas

mainly because there are so many worthy contributors in that group and I donrsquot have the space

to treat them well in this book In the uture I hope that I (or someone else) will write a book

exploring what we can learn rom the diasporas Hispanic minorities or example are making

significant contributions to the theological and missiological conversation in the United States

that are relevant to this subject Methodist historian Justo L Gonzaacutelez and Pentecostal theologian

Eldin Villaantildee are examples In Mantildeana Gonzaacutelez describes the shape and orm o a theology

developed in the Hispanic margin o the United States In Out o Every ribe and Nation he shows

what would be implied in listening to minorities within a denominational setting Villaantildeersquos Te

Liberating Spirit is a milestone in the reflection about the relationship between pneumatology and

social ethics See Justo L Gonzaacutelez Out o Every ribe and Nation Christian Teology at the

Ethnic Roundtable (Nashville Abingdon 1048625983097983097983090) Gonzaacutelez Mantildeana Christian Teology rom a

Hispanic Perspective (Nashville Abingdon 1048625983097983097983088) Eldin Villaantildee Te Liberating Spirit oward

an Hispanic American Pentecostal Social Ethic (Grand Rapids Eerdmans 10486259830979830971048627)

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1136

Introduction 10486251048631

superiority or centricity Te term Global South is too limiting given the

breadth of the group I am engaging Majority World seems to work best

In 1048626104862410486241048628 Te Lausanne Forum for World Evangelization in PattayaTailand voted unanimously that the phrase Majority World Church replace

other terms People from all over the globe participated in this forum

imothy C ennent agrees that this is the best phrase ldquoIt helps to highlight

the basic point that Africa Asia and Latin America are where the majority

of the worldrsquos Christians are now locatedrdquo9830891048624 I expand the phrase Majority

World beyond Africa Asia and Latin America to include the Caribbean

Eastern Europe Oceania and the Middle EastIndigenous and First Nations peoples are ldquothose ethnic groups that were

indigenous to a territory prior to being incorporated into a national state

and who are politically and culturally separate from the majority ethnic

identity of the state that they are a part ofrdquo Tis includes people groups like

the Australian Aborigines and American Indians983089983089

Te aim of this book is to help Western churches rediscover what it means

to be salt light and a city by engaging in global missional conversations odo this Western Christians need to enter into conversation with Majority

World and indigenous Christians Listening to others helps us grow in our

understanding and practice of mission and church and theology For far too

long wersquove marginalized or ignored Majority World and indigenous voices

We must truly become a GlobalChurch

Tis aim shapes the bookrsquos structure as summarized below

P983137983154983156 1048625 S983137983148983156 R983141983155983144983137983152983145983150983143 O983157983154 C983151983150983158983141983154983155983137983156983145983151983150983155

ldquoYou are the salt of the earth But if the salt loses its saltiness how can it be made

salty again It is no longer good for anything except to be thrown out and

trampled underfootrdquo Globally and locally you are the salt of the earth Be salt

Salt preserves seasons flavors and purifies We are salt when we glorify

the Father Son and Holy Spirit in our mission worship faith hope truth

and love We are salt when we reject a Eurocentric or Americentric vision

10imothy C ennent Teology in the Context o World Christianity How the Global Church Is

Influencing the Way We Tink About and Discuss Teology (Grand Rapids Zondervan 9830909830889830881048631) xx11Douglas Sanders ldquoIndigenous Peoples Issues o Definitionrdquo International Journal o Cultural

Property 983096 no 1048625 (1048625983097983097983097) 1048628

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1236

10486251048632 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

of the church and become the global missional church Christ envisioned

In part one I show how Western conversations are impoverished and

insufficient in isolation from indigenous and Majority World Christians Weenhance our ldquosaltinessrdquo through local-global ( glocal ) exchanges o do this

we must reshape our conversations We need global and local exchanges that

we characterize by mutuality respect partnership and symbiosis Such ex-

changes help us learn from each other whether wersquore in Western indig-

enous or Majority World settings It helps us stay ldquosaltyrdquo It enables us to

pursue global missional theology and practice Globally and locally we can

pursue missional vitality and truly be ldquothe salt of the earthrdquo

P983137983154983156 1048626 L983145983143983144983156 R983141983150983141983159983145983150983143 O983157983154 M983145983155983155983145983151983150

ldquoYou are the light of the world A city on a hill cannot be hidden Neither do

people light a lamp and put it under a bowl Instead they put it on its stand and

it gives light to everyone in the house In the same way let your light shine

before others that they may see your good deeds and glorify your Father in

heavenrdquo (Mt 104862910486251048628-10486251048631) Globally and locally you are the light of the world Be lightLight illuminates reveals and dispels darkness Te church is light when

it does good deedsmdashhealing and liberating and redemptive deeds Itrsquos light

when its being and faith and deeds bring glorify to the Father Te church

is light when it participates in Godrsquos redemptive mission in the world as a

global missional community

o do this we must renew our mission In part two I explore how indig-

enous and Majority World Christians teach us to renew mission We renew

mission through contextualization liberation hospitality Spirit empow-

erment creation care ethics and the transformation of neighborhoods

P983137983154983156 1048627 C983145983156983161 R983141983158983145983156983137983148983145983162983145983150983143 O983157983154 C983144983157983154983139983144983141983155

You are a city set on a hill ldquoA city on a hill cannot be hiddenrdquo Globally and

locally you are a city set on a hill Be a city set on a hill

Tis means that we are an alternative and countercultural movement We

have a distinct culture and politic and social existence We are a people

gathered from every tribe language people and nation We are in the world

but not of the world We are in the world but distinct from the world We are

within the world and for the sake of the world

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1336

Introduction 10486251048633

o be this kind of alternative city or culture we must renew our mission

community ethics and worship We need to pursue the revitalization of our

churches so that they are distinct And by distinct I mean an alternative city(altera civitas)

We are a ldquocity on a hillrdquo that witnesses to Jesus Christ and his eternal kingdom

when we are a global missional church In part three I demonstrate how indig-

enous and Majority World Christians teach us to revitalize churches We revi-

talize churches by indigenizing faith devouring Scripture renewing education

practicing servantship (servant leadership) recovering community and devel-

oping spirituality and discipleship We inspire our churches when we developour theology and practices relating to beauty and the arts9830891048626

In the final chapter I wrap things up by addressing an important question

In light of all the material covered in this book what would it now look like

to engage in global missional theology ecclesiology interpretation history

pneumatology worship and education

Herersquos how you can get the most out of this book

Community You can read this book alone in a small group with somefriends at home or at a coffee shop or as part of a ministry team However

you get a lot more out of this book when you read it with others ogether

you can think about the bookrsquos implications What do the chapters mean for

your ministry church agency family or team

GlobalChurch Project video series Irsquove made a video series to go along with

this book Appendix one has the details

Study guide Yoursquoll get a lot more out of this book if you spend time

working through the study guide in appendix two ry to do this in a group

Te study guide includes reflection questions suggested practices and

Further Reading

Characters As you read this book yoursquoll come across names and people

yoursquove never heard of before For a glimpse of who they are and what issues

concern them see appendix three

My website o help you get the most out of this book Irsquove included more

resources on my website TeGlobalChurchProjectcom Tese include

videos reading lists important links a glossary and other resources Irsquove

12Irsquove put a separate chapter on the theme o beauty and the arts on my website Itrsquos additional to

this book

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1436

10486261048624 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

also provided ways that you can contact me See appendix four

In my first book Salt Light and a City I developed a missional theology

of the church I did this in conversation with twelve theologians from the fourmajor Christian traditions Tat volume offered a window into the thought of

European and American theologians It showed how they are making sense

of the nature and mission of the church in their Western cultural context

Te book that yoursquore now reading takes a different approach I have

stepped away from European and American voices I now ask What can

those in the Majority World and indigenous cultures teach us in the West

What can they teach us about the churchrsquos mission worship theology andcommunity Te quality and quantity of material coming out of the Ma-

jority World is astonishing Any theology that ignores the insights of indig-

enous and Majority World Christians is deficient and impoverished

White middle-class European North American tertiary-educated men

dominate Western theology Tey dominate the Western missional conver-

sation I know I fit that profile Tis group still monopolizes missional church

conferences and seminars Tey get all the book contracts In fact this groupstill controls theology and the church in many settings But this is changing

New voices are rising Tese include women minorities the poor indigenous

groups and Majority World leaders Missional conversations arenrsquot attentive

to the Spirit and to Godrsquos mission if they ignore these voices Majority World

and indigenous churches oen have extraordinary missional vitality Openness

to other voices needs to happen now It is time for Western churches theol-

ogies and mission to mature and to reflect Godrsquos global mission

In this book I could have consulted the work of many thousands of in-

digenous and Majority World thinkers and writers and practitioners But I

have limited myself to a sample of those who speak directly to its themes

Tese African Asian Eastern European Middle Eastern Caribbean Latin

American First Nation and indigenous thinkers challenge us Tey dare us

to examine our theologies and missions and churches And they inspire us

to renew the worship and community and mission of Jesusrsquo church Tey

stir us to think in fresh ways about what it means to be salt light and a city

Tey help us become a global missional churchmdasha truly GlobalChurch

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1536

PA R T O N E

S A L TReshaping Our Conversations

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1636

G L O C A L I Z I N G

C O N V E R S A T I O N S

H983151983159 D983151 W983141 D983141983158983141983148983151983152

G983148983151983139983137983148 C983151983150983158983141983154983155983137983156983145983151983150983155983103

Rather than taking one contextual version of the Gospel and imposing

it as the Gospel throughout the world via the missionary enterprise

the shapers of Mission as ransformation have recognized the

plurality of localities that has created an intercontextual

ldquopan-localrdquo global phenomenon in theology

AL IZON

The International Society for Urban Mission (ISUM) is a group of urban

missionaries who are passionate about cultivating hope and love and re-newal in cities Irsquove connected with this group for some years ISUM held its

first annual Summit on Integral Urban Mission in Bangkok Tailand Te

team from Urban Neighbours of Hope (UNOH) under the leadership of

my Australian friends Ash and Anj Barker organized much of the summit

UNOH teams covenant with God and each other to ldquolive out our passion for

loving God and neighbour Focus on releasing neighbourhoods from urban

poverty Grow through equipping each other neighbours and the broader

church to radically follow Jesus and join Godrsquos Kingdom coming UNOH

workers live and serve in small responsive neighbourhood-based teamsrdquo983089

1See wwwunohorg

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1736

10486261048628 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

Tis summit involved interactive participatory hands-on immersion op-

portunities keynotes lectures and workshops Keynote speakers came from

Africa Australia Myanmar New Zealand North America the PhilippinesSouth America Tailand and First Nations A few hundred Majority World

and Western thinkers and activists came together for those days Tey explored

the theology and practices of integral transformational and urban mission

Tese thinkers and activists pursued a range of aims1048626 Tis included col-

laboration between urban Christians from a variety of backgrounds (Ma-

jority World and Western theologians activists ecumenicals Pentecostals

evangelicals colleges church movements and development agencies) Teyaimed for collective action and thought in an international and integral

context Tey sought to gain mutual understanding for a comprehensive

picture of urban mission around the globe Tey encouraged information

sharing and best practicesmdashlearning from our mistakes and seeking solu-

tions Tey developed recommendations and calls to action to the broader

church Working groups wrote briefing papers aer each summit based on

key issues in urban mission And they endeavored to build trust wisdomand inspiration to better engage our new urban world

Majority World and Western leaders participated in discussion prayer

integral mission and working groups Te goal was to grapple with key issues

and ask key questions How do we recruit equip and sustain urban mission

today How do we release church movements among the urban poor How

can we immerse ourselves in and transform urban neighborhoods How do

we empower urban children and young people How does the church serve

and liberate the oppressedmdashand others suffering from urban injustice What

needs to happen for poorer urban centers to develop economically socially

and spiritually How do we join God in the challenges and opportunities of

multifaith cities

Workshops included urban gardening child protection and collaborating

with local churches in urban mission Workshops also included organic

church growth and mission as well as developing NGO and government

partnerships Groups considered the good the bad and the ugly of short-

term urban mission teams

2Tese aims are detailed at ldquoInternational Society or Urban Mission Summitrdquo httpnewurbanworld

orgsummit

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1836

Glocalizing Conversations 10486261048629

Te summit was a thrilling example of how Majority World and Western

leaders can cooperate It was a time to come together in an environment of

mutual learning and enrichment It was a window into how local contextsand global themes can enrich each other Tis resulted from ISUMrsquos com-

mitment to ldquosolidarity fellowship and insight between urban Christian

leaders in the Western and Majority Worldsrdquo

Te summit was a success due to ISUMrsquos core values What are they983091 Christ-

honoring urban mission values bottom-up grassroots perspectivesmdashrather

than top-down distanced perspectives It allows local theology to reveal new

insights and perspectives about Godrsquos activity It shares insights and experi-ences through narratives embedded within urban poor communities and cities

It cultivates ongoing practical and personal solidarity with the worldrsquos urban

poor Tis Spirit-empowered urban mission honors networks relationships

and partnerships It sees such relationships as the primary method of serving

together It listens to and amplifies the voices of the urban poormdashespecially

those from the Majority World and in particular the 1048625104862410486281048624 window cities It is

attentive to signs of the kingdom of God Urban mission that glorifies God iswilling to reflect and respond with active and sacrificial commitment It shares

and extends the life of the body of Christ among the urban poor

Tis summit was a milestone in urban missiology It enriched communi-

cation between Western and Majority World thinker-activists Tis resulted

from the aims and values Irsquove mentioned Effective urban mission needs to

be a conversation on many levels It is attentive to context and immersed in

local settings It appreciates global and universal missional themes It culti-

vates dialogue between these local-global (glocal) realities It involves

mutual learning between Western and Majority World thinker-activists

Moreover solidarity between all parties is a defining feature Tis solidarity

is due to a compelling vision of the kingdom of God

Tese collaborative glocal features of the ISUM urban mission summit

in Bangkok are critical for the aims of this book GlobalChurch

Majority World indigenous and Western leaders thinkers and churches

can stretch and enrich each other But they need to be open and attentive to

each other Tey need learning postures and open hearts and minds Tey

3ldquoAbout ISUMrdquo httpnewurbanworldorgabout

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1936

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2036

Glocalizing Conversations 10486261048631

always rooted in the local and particularmdashas local churches embody the

gospel and witness to Christ Tese churches forge their own theological

understandings as they do mission together Tey engage in transformationalpractices among the people in their settings Tey enjoy worship mission

and community in their local and particular context Ideally the result is

unique contextual theologies and missions

Simultaneously global conversations form Tey form because of this

multitude of local theologies and practices Local conversations inform and

enrich other local conversations catalyzing global themes and voices izon

observes that the global ldquoowes its existence to local contexts Sharedconvictions among the theologies and practices of local contextual realities

give shape to its global dimensionsrdquo1048629

Majority World indigenous and Western theologies are equally contextual

Tey are equally culture bound Tey are equally particular to their time and

location At times they are all enlightened or myopic liberating or con-

straining humanizing or objectifying beautiful or offensive prophetic or

tepid Te local particular and cultural shape all these theologies Converselythese particular theologies feed and influence global conversations Tere is

no place then for ethnocentrism colonialism or elitism Tere is no place

for theological missional cultural or institutionalized arrogance

Multiple local contexts and voices come togethermdashintentionally or notmdashto

form global themes and theologies Conversely these global realities shape

local contexts oday local contexts must grapple with ldquoan emerging global

culture ie the interacting realities of modernity postmodernity and the

phenomenon of globalizationrdquo1048630 Hence the interdependent and symbiotic

relationship between the localparticular and the globaluniversal We call this

interdependent relationship between the local and the global glocalization

Te global church needs a thrilling glocal exchange We need one that we

characterize by mutuality respect partnership and symbiosis Such ex-

change helps Majority World indigenous and Western churches learn from

each other It enables them to pursue missional theology and practice o-

gether the church becomes a ldquocity on a hillrdquo

5Ibid 10486259830886Ibid 9830961048628

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2136

10486261048632 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

W983144983137983156 R983141983153983157983145983154983141983155 G983148983151983139983137983148983145983162983137983156983145983151983150983103

Te glocal exchange described above needs to be broader than transforma-

tional mission Tis is necessary if the church is to develop a robust inter-cultural and glocal missional ecclesiology

In my first book Salt Light and a City I outlined the foundational

themes of missional ecclesiology983095 Majority World and Western leaders

need to engage these themes in local and contextual ways Teir insights can

then enrich global conversations Tese global conversations in turn shape

local understandings and practices Tis way a glocal appreciation of these

themes emergesLocal regional and global theologies and practices are thereby enriched

Te church becomes healthier and more missionalmdasha truer expression of

the kingdom Te church becomes a fuller witness to Christ his passion for

the nations and his ability to bring unity in diversity

Stephen Bevans and Roger Schroeder outline the six constants of mission

Tese are our theologies about Jesus the church the end times salvation

human nature and culture Bevans and Schroeder describe the relationshipbetween these six and their historical cultural and theological contexts Tis is

why they call these six constants in context Our understanding of these six

constants develops in relation to local and global movements Sometimes local

voices influence our understandings of these six Other times it is regional or

global voices For all of us local regional and global influences are at play at

once Collectively they form our appreciation of the six constants of mission1048632

Here are eight theological themes that the church can develop through

processes of glocalization I presented these in my book Salt Light and a City

Tey are vital to the churchrsquos health mission community and future We

could add many other themes to these eight but these will suffice for now1048633

Scripture Te Scriptures are the infallible authoritative Word of God

Christrsquos Spirit has inspired them Tey have absolute and final authority in

all aspects of corporate and individual faith ethics conduct and witness

Christians interpret and apply Scripture in local contexts and in particular

7Graham Hill Salt Light and a City Introducing Missional Ecclesiology (Eugene OR Wip and

Stock 9830909830881048625983090) 10486251048628983097-983090104863110486288Stephen B Bevans and Roger Schroeder Constants in Context A Teology o Mission or oday

American Society o Missiology Series (Maryknoll NY Orbis 9830909830889830881048628) part one9Tese points first appeared in my book Salt Light and a City xxii-xxiv

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2236

Glocalizing Conversations 10486261048633

social settings Conversely we learn from the interpretations and readings

of other groups

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our local- global theology of Scripture and biblical interpretation

Evangelicalism Pentecostalism missional movements and so forth I

have charismatic missional and evangelical convictions Glocal conversa-

tions help me understand and practice these convictions better

I will use evangelicalism as an example Michael Horton says that our

beliefs and practices are evangelical when they are ldquocommitted to the suffi-

ciency of Scripture the priesthood of all believers the total lostness ofhumans the sole mediation of Christ the gracious efficacy and finality of

Godrsquos redemptive work in Christ through election propitiation calling and

keeping Te linchpin for all of this was the doctrine of justification by grace

alone through faith alone because of Christ alonerdquo9830891048624

Such convictions are necessary if we are to be faithful to the gospel and

to a biblical vision of church and mission Te gospel defines Godrsquos purposes

for humanity the church and the universe Te triune God controls thechurch He is its Lord and Savior Sanctifier and Liberator Master and King

He is completely sovereign over its nature affairs mission and history God

is the churchrsquos only source of grace election atonement salvation and per-

severance Te churchrsquos justification and hope are by grace alone through

faith alone by Christ alone

Herersquos the challenge I face My understanding of evangelicalism is

Western I am a product of the Western theological tradition and my Western

evangelical heritage Much of this is wonderful But I need indigenous and

Majority World evangelicals and others to help me expand and reshape

these insights Te same would be true if I were a Pentecostal

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of our theological traditions and convictions

Jesus Christ We must center our theology on Jesus Christ the Lord of

the church Te church needs to reflect on the person and work of Christ

and respond to him Tis means gathering and going in the name and power

of Christ It means allowing Christrsquos Spirit to shape our community and

10Michael Horton ldquoEvangelical Arminiansrdquo Modern Reormation 1048625 no 1048627 (1048625983097983097983090) 10486251048631

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2336

10486271048624 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

identity and mission It means developing our Christology ecclesiology and

missiology concurrently Te early church developed these three areas and

more in a concurrent and integrated way Tere was no linear progressionTe same is true in the contemporary global church

How can the glocal church best explore its nature structure mission and

hope Trough the centrality and the lordship of Christ

Majority World and indigenous Christians help us appreciate Jesus and

his mission afresh Tey show us how Jesus identifies with the marginalized

outcast oppressed rejected and broken He prefers them We find him

among ldquothe least of theserdquoGlocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of who Jesus Christ is How does it help us appreciate him better

What has Jesus done for and in his church and his world What does he care

about What individual and corporate responsibilities has he given us How

do we express these at local regional and global levels

Te Spirit Missional ecclesiology is inadequate without pneumatological

foundations In other words our theology of church and Spirit go togetherTe Spirit creates and animates the church He empowers it to witness to

Jesus and his gospel Te Spirit enables the church to be a missional trans-

formational community He shapes the church into an alternative society

embodying the reign of God Te church exists for the glory and mission of

Christ Te power and presence of the Spirit enables this mission worship

and glorification

Te Spirit pours out gis on the local-global church ldquofor the common

goodrdquo and ldquoto equip his people for works of service so that the body of Christ

may be built uprdquo Tis includes but isnrsquot limited to the ministry gis mani-

festation gis and motivational gis (1048625 Cor 104862510486261048631 Eph 104862810486251048625-10486251048626 Rom 104862510486261048630-1048632)

Te Spirit forms the glocal church He empowers it for service and

witness He fills it with Christrsquos empowering presence He leads it into the

missio Deimdashthe mission of the Father Son and Holy Spirit

Recently Pentecostal and renewalist movements have grown dramati-

cally in the Majority World Tey have increased in status size and influence

Many have matured theologically Te churches of the West must take notice

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of the power and presence of the Spirit

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2436

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048625

Te rinity Tere are clear limitations to the analogy between the

church and the rinity Te church can only image the rinity Yet the

church is at its best when it reflects the relational and missional passionof the rinity

What is the source and inspiration of the churchrsquos local-global mission

Ultimately it is the missional nature passion and actions of the Father Son

and Holy Spirit Godrsquos nature is missional His passion is infectious His

actions are historical redemptive and eternal Te rinity invites the

church into a sending community Te Father sends the Son Te Father

and Son send the Spirit Finally the rinity sends the church in missioninto the world

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of the rinity How does it enable our participation in the mission

and community of the triune God

Association and dialogue Tese need to happen across denominational

cultural ethnic gender and theological traditions and divides Authentic

dialogue is indispensable to the health and mission of the church What dothose marginal to the life of the church have to say to us What do ldquoothersrdquo

have to teach us Other ethnicities and cultures Other socioeconomic

groups Other ages and genders Other theological and confessing tradi-

tions Other persons from times long gone

We need to listen Share Be vulnerable Be authentic Open up to crit-

icism correction and change

We need more than dialogue We need communion and association It is

possible in a qualified way to say that God is present in all the various forms

of the church (ie the various theological ecclesiological sociocultural his-

torical and other permutations of the church) We discern this presence

through attention to Scripture history tradition culture and the Spirit Dis-

cernment involves critical dialogue theological exchange biblical study and

real relationship Only the Spirit of Jesus can enable this

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of association and dialogue

Mission and the missio Dei Te church is missional at its core It serves

obeys and images a missionary God David Bosch says ldquoTe churchrsquos mission

is not secondary to its being the church exists in being sent and in building up

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2536

10486271048626 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

itself for its missionrdquo He goes on to say ldquoEcclesiology does not precede missi-

ology there cannot be church without an intrinsic missionary dimensionrdquo983089983089

Jesus is Lord Lord of his church and Lord of his world His mission de-termines and forms the church His mission shapes the nature purposes

structures ministries and activities of his church Majority World and in-

digenous thinkers help us understand the implications of this mission Tey

help us form glocal theologies of mission Tey reveal ldquomission in context

as transformationrdquo9830891048626

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of mission and the missio Dei Church theology and practice Glocal conversations can inform and

enrich many aspects of the church (when practiced well) Teologies and

practices benefit from robust and critical glocal conversations Tese con-

versations enrich many areas (community spirituality discipleship liturgy

worship hospitality eco-justice education social ethics servantship lib-

eration place suffering beauty and so on)

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-standing of these many dimensions of church and mission

Glocal processes shape these eight themes and their practices We need

to facilitate and enable these conversations and processes Tis is urgent It

must be a priority No theology of mission or missional ecclesiology is ad-

equate without glocal conversations983089983091

T983144983141 L983151983139983137983148 983137983150983140 G983148983151983138983137983148 E983150983154983145983139983144 E983137983139983144 O983156983144983141983154

Glocalization takes the localparticular context and globaluniversal themes

seriously Contextual and global conversations enter an enriching and in-

forming relationship Tese two always have an active and symbiotic rela-

tionship Tis is true whether we deliberately put them into conversation or

not Te local shapes the global and the global shapes the local Many local

11David J Bosch Believing in the Future oward a Missiology o Western Culture (New York

rinity 1048625983097983097983093) 104862798309012izon ransormation Afer Lausanne 1048631-98309713Not all o these themes are dealt with in this present volume since either (1048625) I have dealt with them

in my book Salt Light and a City (983090) they are not all key themes in the writings o the thirty-five

Majority World thinkers considered in this volume or (1048627) there is not adequate space in a book

this size

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2636

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048627

voices converge to form global conversations and theologies Using the Phil-

ippines as a case study izon illustrates this by showing the interdepen-

dence between local and global themes in mission983089983092Dialogue between local and global conversations is critical Kōsuke

Koyama wrote an important book on contextual mission called Water Buffalo

Teology Koyama is a Japanese missionary who served in Chiang Mai

Tailand He writes of the joys and challenges of doing local particular water

buffalo theology He considers the relationship between local theology global

missional themes and transforming cultures ldquoWater Buffalo Teology sees

certain specific challenges Contextualization of theology implies two criticalmovements First to articulate Jesus Christ in culturally appropriate com-

municatively apt words and second to criticize reform dethrone or oppose

culture if it is found to be against what the name of Jesus Christ stands forrdquo9830891048629

Kōsuke Koyama challenges us to recognize what we bring to the task of

local theology For him it was doing theology in Tailand while being Jap-

anese We also need to notice the particular culture wersquore located in as we do

the work of theology Tis means we avoid speaking of an ldquoAsian theologyrdquoldquoAfrican theologyrdquo and the like We need to cultivate local theologies that

engage regional and global themes But these theologies must be ldquodistinctly

localrdquo and a ldquotheology from belowrdquo9830891048630

Simultaneously we need to pursue a reformation of theology and

practice ldquoin the global contextrdquo Tis means entering ldquothe disturbing spa-

ciousness of Jesus Christrdquo Jesus calls us to reject enmity and exceptionalism

We seem him present in our culture language stories and relationships

But we also choose to embrace the ldquootherrdquo We choose to see him present

in other culturesmdashshaping a global people to serve and worship him

joining in his mission983089983095

Kōsuke Koyama roots the gospel in the local contextual and particular

Tis is why he roots his water buffalo theology in Northern Tai culture He

is careful not to say ldquoHere is how you contextualize in your settingrdquo Instead

14izon ransormation Afer Lausanne 1048631-10486251048627 10486251048628983097-98309098308898309015Kōsuke Koyama Water Buffalo Teology 983090983093th anniversary ed (Maryknoll NY Orbis 1048625983097983097983097)

xiii-xv16Kōsuke Koyama ldquoTe Asian Approach to Christrdquo Missiology 1048625983090 no 1048628 (10486259830979830961048628) 10486281048627983093-104862798309617Kōsuke Koyama ldquoReormation in the Global Context Te Disturbing Spaciousness o Jesus Christrdquo

Currents in Teology and Mission 1048627983088 no 983090 (9830909830889830881048627) 10486251048625983097-983090983096

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2736

10486271048628 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

he tells us a story Itrsquos the story of how he contextualized theology in northern

Tailand while being open to global conversations Koyama asks us to form

our own local expressions of church mission and theology At the same timewe must stay attentive to what God is saying and doing beyond that context

Tis way local and global and particular and universal become mutually

enriching conversation partners

G983148983151983139983137983148983145983162983137983156983145983151983150 983137983150983140 H983145983155983156983151983154983145983139983137983148983148983161 S983145983148983141983150983139983141983140 V983151983145983139983141983155

Glocal theologies and conversations pay attention to voices that powers in-

stitutions religions and societies have silenced R S Sugirtharajah pushesback a little on izonrsquos ideas Sugirtharajah says that the church should

privilege local conversations He emphasizes the local contextual and post-

colonial reading of biblical texts9830891048632

Te church needs to listen Te church ought to be attentive to the

theologies and biblical interpretations of groups that cultures and reli-

gions have ignored Historically powerful secular and religious forces

have silenced these groups Tey have marginalized oppressed and colo-nized them It is time for the church to address this injustice We must

start listening to important but silenced voices We need to privilege the

voices of the former victims of Western colonialism We need to develop

postcolonial biblical interpretations theologies and expressions of church

and mission

How do we take such perspectives seriously as we develop glocal conver-

sations How do these themes help us foster vital relationships between local

and global voices

It is time for us to embrace values that enable conversations with those

oen ignored by the church We need values that help us learn from these

groups and individuals

Valuing equal partnership Colonizing powers oppressed silenced and

colonized certain groups At times the church was complicit Tese colo-

nized groups have become ldquoconfident indomitable and indispensable

partners in the dialogue and collaboration with the dispossessed and disad-

18R S Sugirtharajah Asian Biblical Hermeneutics and Postcolonialism Contesting the Interpreta-

tions Te Bible and Liberation Series (Maryknoll NY Orbis 1048625983097983097983096) 1048625983093-1048625983094

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2836

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048629

vantaged in the Westrdquo9830891048633 Tis calls for attentiveness to these voices and re-

sponsiveness to their prophetic challenges It also demands a critical evalu-

ation of colonial readings of Scripture Colonial models of theology andchurch and mission are no longer the benchmark Te global church must

examine them afresh

Valuing equal status Tose on the margins have now taken their rightful

place on the global stage Tey have claimed appropriate and equal status at

the table Subaltern readings of theology church and mission are invaluable

contributors to global theological conversations Tis means that we esteem

them But we also test themWhat do we mean by subaltern Subalterns are those who are down-

trodden and silenced (or have been treated this way in the past) Dominant

or colonizing groups treat them as invisible nonentities Tey enjoy limited

or no access to power Sometimes these are women certain tribal and ethnic

groups and those considered ldquountouchablerdquo In Voices from the Margin Su-

girtharajah provides a platform for postcolonial subaltern readings of

Scripture and theology Tese readings challenge colonialmdashoen Westernmdashreadings of Bible and theology and cultures Tey claim equal status with

other ways of doing theology10486261048624

Valuing equal identity People groups need freedom to explore their new

and emerging identities Tese emerge in response to local and global influ-

ences Local culture is not the only thing at work here Global forces also

shape identity as do imported practices ideas readings rituals and tech-

nologies But each group should be free to explore and construct their par-

ticular forms of Christian identity

Valuing equal interpretations ldquoPostcolonialism is concerned with the

question of cultural and discursive dominationrdquo Colonialism led to op-

pressive and controlling forms of culture and discourse Tese were usually

not contextual or indigenous Western powers for instance brought co-

lonial forms of theology church biblical interpretation and mission1048626983089

Postcolonialism calls for alternative ways of approaching these things Tose

19Ibid 104862598309420R S Sugirtharajah Voices rom the Margin Interpreting the Bible in the Tird World (Maryknoll

NY Orbis 10486259830979830971048625)21Sugirtharajah Asian Biblical Hermeneutics and Postcolonialism 10486251048631

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2936

10486271048630 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

who were once marginalized oppressed and silenced need to lead these fresh

approaches in their own settings Tese then influence global conversations

We need to support the new readings and insights and experiments from thesegroups o be genuine this support must be both critical and collegial

Valuing equal empowerment Sugirtharajah says that postcolonialism is

valuable when it empowers actual communities and real people Post-

colonial thought empowers when it addresses the difficulties hopes and

experiences of ordinary people It should never be about power plays and

the clever use of language Itrsquos pointless if itrsquos obsessed with forming newmdash

and ldquocolonizingrdquomdashtheories Itrsquos a waste of time if itrsquos a self-indulgent pursuitof new and hybrid identities Rather ldquothe worth and credibility of post-

colonial criticism will be judged by how it orchestrates the unique and

fragile and imagined claims of one community against anotherrdquo Empow-

erment happens in a variety of ways One way is contributing equally to

global conversations10486261048626

Al izon examines postcolonialism in the Philippines He says that it can

teach the global church a lot about healthy local-global conversations Fil-ipino contextual theology resists many Western forms of mission and the-

ology It finds them patronizing and controlling Tis indigenous theology

values prophetic sociopolitical engagement in institutions and the society

at large It emphasizes ministry to whole persons and communities It con-

structs a Filipino theology of beauty and mission and worship and com-

munity And it fosters indigenous theological approaches to the spirit world

and cosmology

izon says that postcolonial theology has played a constructive role in

the Philippines But he is uncomfortable with the label postcolonialism He

prefers to describe historical events as ldquobeyond colonialismrdquo And he says

that global conversations enrich local theologies and vice versa1048626983091

Postcolonial thought informs our understanding of the relationship be-

tween the local and global It also shows how theology can emerge at the

intersection between the localparticular and the globaluniversal It re-

minds us that worthwhile glocalization listens to all voices Tis includes

heeding those that have been historically silenced

22Ibid 983090104862823izon ransormation Afer Lausanne 1048625983088983090 10486259830941048631-9830961048631

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3036

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048631

G983148983151983139983137983148983145983162983137983156983145983151983150 983137983150983140 983156983144983141 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

C983151983150983139983148983157983140983145983150983143 R983141983142983148983141983139983156983145983151983150983155

How do we go about developing a model for glocal conversations izon hasrecently provided a useful model that is instructive as we seek to learn from

the Majority World It has at least two key features

First the local is in the global (globalization from below) Global theologies

and ideas have origins in many particular local contexts In that sense glo-

balization is from below Global ideas have local roots Ideas about integral

mission liberation theology and missional church have local origins Tey

have their roots in the prayers hopes discoveries mission and theologiesof thousands of local communities ldquoTe global does not cannot exist

without the localmdashbut the coming together of localities creates a global re-

ality that becomes greater than the sum of its parts it creates a gestalt entity

to which localities make themselves accountablerdquo1048626983092

Second the global is in the local (panlocalization from above) Te con-

cerns and voices of multitudes of locales form global conversations Tese

global discussions can provide a ldquopositive accountabilityrdquo back to local con-texts Tis is true when they enrich affirm serve guide and strengthen local

contexts It is also true when they avoid homogenization control impo-

sition and judgment Glocalization is best when it sees itself as interde-

pendent deeply connected with the local10486261048629

Tatrsquos a helpful starting point But we need to go further Besides izonrsquos

proposals Irsquom convinced that robust glocal conversations cultivate six core

practices

983089 Glocal theology practices its values We root glocal theology in core

values Tese values include solidarity understanding and mutual learning

Do we value fellowship with Christians of all cultures Do we value learning

from them

We prove our values through our practices What practices emerge out of

these values We need to collaborate act collectively and share information

We must find ways to foster grassroots perspectives and local theologies We

need to share stories and learnings and cultivate networks relationships and

partnerships We need attentiveness to local voices and global themes We

24Ibid 9830901048625983088-1048625104862825Ibid 98309010486251048628-1048625983096

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3136

10486271048632 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

ought to find ways to put these local and global voices into conversation

Mutual learning humility and solidarity are key Worthwhile glocal con-

versations can never be merely theoretical or academic It is up to us to rootour values in our practices

983090 Glocal theology practices humility (and it tells a new narrative) We

have noted that the local is in the global and the global is in the local Te

two are interdependent Tey form each other reciprocally Since this is the

case we must practice humility Tere is no place for ethnocentrism colo-

nialism or theological and cultural arrogance I have seen these unhealthy

postures far too oen in Western settingsRecently I attended a missional leadership conference On that occasion

the keynote speakermdasha leading missional author and speakermdashsaid that

North American missional conversations and innovations hold the key to

the future of the Western church Tis Euro American view is wrong (Irsquom

being kind o be frank itrsquos complete nonsense) Itrsquos arrogant and Euro

Americanndashcentric And itrsquos completely out of step with what is happening in

the glocal church We need a new narrativeIn June 1048626104862410486251048627 Te Center for the Study of Global Christianity reported

the top 10486261048624 countries where Christianity has the highest percentage growth

rate Nineteen of the top twenty are in Asia and Africa Eleven of them are

in Muslim majority countries Not a single country from Europe or North

America makes the top twenty list10486261048630

Itrsquos time to cultivate a new narrative Te future of the church is emerging

from the Majority World Rather than North America the churches of

Eastern Asia Western Africa the Arabian Peninsula and other parts of the

Majority World reveal the future of the global church We need the contribu-

tions of all contexts Western indigenous and Majority World All con-

tribute to glocal conversations All are important as we learn from each

other about mission theology and faith But letrsquos stop pretending that North

Americans and Europeans will reveal the future of the global church Letrsquos

start listening to what God is saying about the future of the global church

And hersquos speaking to us through the churches of Asia Africa Latin America

26Russ Mitchell ldquoTe op 983090983088 Countries Where Christianity Is Growing the Fastestrdquo Disciple All

Nations (blog) August 983090983093 98309098308810486251048627 httpsdiscipleallnationswordpresscom98309098308810486251048627983088983096983090983093the-top

-983090983088-countries-where-christianity-is-growing-the-astest

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3236

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048633

Muslim majority settings and so on We must cultivate a new glocal nar-

rativemdashone soaked in humility

Glocal theology must be humble theology Meek theology Receptive the-ology Discerning theology Prayerful theology Dialogical theology De-

pendent theology A theology that celebrates the interdependence between

the localparticular and the globaluniversal

983091 Glocal theology practices expansiveness Glocalization is by nature

comprehensive Local and global influences permeate much of our lives Tese

glocal forces shape our theologies and churches whether we like it or not

But intentionality is also important We need to commit to an expansiveapproach to glocal theology How do we deliberately cultivate glocal conver-

sations in our biblical interpretation Do we foster them in our under-

standing of the person and work of Christ How does glocalization shape

the way the Spirit empowers and constitutes the church How can it form

our understanding of the nature and mission of the rinity How does it

influence the way we practice fellowship and conversation across denomi-

national cultural ethnic economic sociocultural political gender andtheological divides How might it shape our theologies of mission com-

munity beauty spirituality suffering discipleship hospitality eco-justice

place education social ethics Christian leadership and so forth

983092 Glocal theology practices attention Glocal theology doesnrsquot need to

accept all the assumptions or assertions of postcolonial or Majority World

thought But it does need to engage with them and take them seriously

Postcolonial theology for instance gives the marginalized and colonized

and forgotten and silenced both dignity and voice Our glocal conversations

must also include and esteem these groups We need to be attentive to

others weak and powerful female and male dominant and downtrodden

old and young rich and poor privileged and marginalized influential and

subaltern educated and illiterate We need to practice the art of attention

being especially attentive to those who are different to us

983093 Glocal theology practices embrace What do colonial ethnocentric or

Western-centric perspectives do Tey silence Tey control Tey com-

modify Tey institutionalize Tey colonize Tey domesticate Tey replace

Tey import Tey exclude Tey do these things to the beliefs experiences

and practices of other cultures A worthwhile glocal theology refuses to do

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3336

10486281048624 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

these things Instead it adopts a responsive humble celebratory open in-

clusive and embracing attitude

983094 Glocal theology practices discernment Finally we need discernmentas we engage these ideas and practices Discernment is a huge topic thatrsquos

hard to cover comprehensively in a few words Discernment happens when

the Spirit of Christ and his Word renew our minds Te Spirit grants us

spiritual wisdom as we meditate on him and his Word and as we practice

discipleship to Jesus Christ Romans 10486251048626 provides guidance we need (1048625) to be

transformed by the renewal of our minds (1048626) to serve Christrsquos body and (1048627)

to put love into action Discernment also happens in conversation both lo-cally and glocally

I pray these core values and six practices come across in the following

chapters of GlobalChurch

Glocalization can never be just theoretical Are we committed to moving

glocalization from an abstract idea to a living communion Are we deter-

mined to construct a missional theology of the church in the context of

glocal conversations Tis must involve dialogue between Majority Worldindigenous and Western scholars activists and groups

Will glocalization be an abstract notion Or will it be a formative and

genuine communion between local regional and global voices Glocal dy-

namics are at play whether we like it or not Teyrsquore in our churches the-

ologies and missions But we can choose to relinquish isolationist colonial

parochial and arrogant approaches Instead we can adopt responsive dia-

logical learning humble and embracing postures

Trough healthy approaches to glocalization the Spirit challenges us to

value local contexts We immerse ourselves in local and particular commu-

nities and conversations He inspires us to open ourselves to global theo-

logical conversations He rouses us to value the symbiotic relationship be-

tween the localparticular and the globaluniversal

Trough glocal relationships the Spirit leads us to put local contextual

theologies into conversation with global ones He prompts us to explore the

ways in which the local is in the glocal and the global is in the local He per-

suades us to pursue collaboration and dialogue and mutual learning We

engage with Christians from different backgrounds and cultures ecumen-

icals Pentecostals evangelicals and so on from Western indigenous and

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3436

Glocalizing Conversations 10486281048625

Majority World contexts He motivates us to express solidarity between all

parties We appreciate our unity in diversity

Trough glocal conversations the Spirit moves us to ensure that unity andsolidarity emerge from a compelling vision of Jesusrsquo kingdom and gospel

and person He challenges us to share information theology and practices

He urges us to learn from each othermdashour successes and mistakes We seek

glocal solutions

Te Spirit calls us to develop glocal conversations about Christian ideas

and practices Tese include Scripture Evangelicalism ecumenism Pente-

costalism Jesus Christ the Holy Spirit God the Father the rinity com-munity spirituality discipleship liturgy worship hospitality prayer eco-

justice education social ethics Christian leadership gospel and culture

beauty place suffering liberation and so forth

Finally through glocal conversations the Spirit leads us to adopt a new

posture Tis is a responsive humble celebratory open inclusive and em-

bracing attitude to the ldquootherrdquo We do this as a new people made up of every

tribe and language and people and nationTere are dangers in glocalization Sugirtharajah warns of the commodi-

fication of local contextual practices and theologies When this happens

they are ldquosmoothed out of their primary contexts concerns and contesta-

tions travel across borders and become objects of analysis and scrutiny

within an alien secondary contextrdquo1048626983095

Itrsquos common for those of us who are Western to make mistakes when we

wrestle with Majority World and indigenous ideas Sugirtharajah mentions

our tendency to commodify reduce and institutionalize these ideas We also

risk doing these things (1048625) We apply them in noncontextual prescriptive ways

(1048626) We ignore their meanings in their original setting (1048627) We glamorize or

idealize their proponents or their contexts (1048628) We demonize those persons or

contexts (1048629) We disregard them as irrelevant rhetorical or minority discourse

Kevin J Vanhoozer says that we can fall into three traps when we glo-

calize theology (1048625) We can underestimate the theological significance of

local cultures (1048626) We can homogenize cultures and theologies exaggerating

27R S Sugirtharajah ldquoextual ake-Aways Tird World exts in Western Metropolitan Centresrdquo

Black Teology in Britain A Journal o Contextual Praxis 983090 (1048625983097983097983097) 10486271048627 10486271048631 Edward W Said Te

World the ext and the Critic (Cambridge MA Harvard University Press 10486259830979830961048627) 9830901048627983097

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3536

10486281048626 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

ldquothe onerdquo (1048627) We can overemphasize cultural particularity exaggerating ldquothe

manyrdquo and pursue ldquotheological ethnificationrdquo10486261048632

My hope is that GlobalChurch does not fall into the traps Sugirtharajahand Vanhoozer describe I hope that what unfolds in the following chapters

is respectful and discerning I hope it leads to further mutually enriching

conversations between people of different cultures

You the reader face the same challenges You face them in your personal

life ministry context and missional engagements

Will you treat the themes in this book as abstract theoretical notions

Will this be a temporary infatuation a flirtation with the ldquootherrdquo that dissi-pates as suddenly as it arrived Or will glocal conversations become an en-

riching and formative orientation in your life Will glocal conversations

bring fresh approaches to theology faith mission church and worship Will

conversations with other cultures and theologies become for you a com-

pelling way of life

My prayer is that glocal conversations will help the church be a global

visible alternative ldquocity set upon a hillrdquo a truly GlobalChurch

28Craig Ott and Harold A Netland Globalizing Teology Belie and Practice in an Era o World

Christianity (Grand Rapids Baker Academic 983090983088983088983094) 1048625983090983093

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3636

Page 2: GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 236

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 336

G L O B A L

C H U R C H

R E S H A P I N G O U R C O N V E R S A T I O N S

R E N E W I N G O U R M I S S I O N

R E V I T A L I Z I N G O U R C H U R C H E S

G R A H A M H I L LForeword by S C O M 983139 K N I G H

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 436

InterVarsity Press

PO Box 1048625104862810486241048624 Downers Grove IL 98309410486249830931048625983093-104862510486281048626983094

ivpresscom

emailivpresscom

copy104862610486241048625983094 by Graham Hill

All rights reserved No part of this book may be reproduced in any form without written permission from

InterVarsity Press

InterVarsity Pressreg is the book-publishing division of InterVarsity Christian FellowshipUSAreg a movement of

students and faculty active on campus at hundreds of universities colleges and schools of nursing in the United

States of America and a member movement of the International Fellowship of Evangelical Students For

information about local and regional activities visit intervarsityorg

All Scripture quotations unless otherwise indicated are taken from the Holy Bible odayrsquos New International

Versiontrade Copyright copy 1048626104862410486241048625 by International Bible Society All rights reserved

Cover design David Fassett

Interior design Beth McGill

Images orange water color square copy kentarcajuaniStockphoto

icons of Copenhagen Brussells Austria Israel Cuba Portugal Budapest Ireland Berlin and France

copy artefyiStockphoto

blue under water copy Achim PrilliStockphoto

ISBN 10486331048631983096-1048624-9830969830911048624983096-10486281048624983096983093-1048628 (print)

ISBN 10486331048631983096-1048624-9830969830911048624983096-104863310486331048624983091-983094 (digital)

Printed in the United States of America As a member of the Green Press Initiative InterVarsity Press is committed to protecting the environmentand to the responsible use of natural resources o learn more visit greenpressinitiativeorg

Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data

Hill Graham Reverend

GlobalChurch reshaping our conversations renewing our mission revitalizing our churches Graham Hill

foreword by Scot McKnight

pages cm

Includes index

ISBN 10486331048631983096-1048624-9830969830911048624983096-10486281048624983096983093-1048628 (casebound alk paper)

1048625 Church 1048626 GlobalizationmdashReligious aspectsmdashChristianity I itle II itle Global Church

BV98309410486241048624983091H9830931048628 104862610486241048625983093

10486269830941048633mdashdc1048626983091

104862610486241048625983093104862498309198309410486241048625983093

P 1048626983091 10486261048626 10486261048625 10486261048624 10486251048633 1048625983096 10486251048631 1048625983094 1048625983093 10486251048628 1048625983091 10486251048626 10486251048625 10486251048624 1048633 983096 1048631 983094 983093 1048628 983091 1048626 1048625

Y 983091983093 9830911048628 983091983091 9830911048626 9830911048625 9830911048624 10486261048633 1048626983096 10486261048631 1048626983094 1048626983093 10486261048628 1048626983091 10486261048626 10486261048625 10486261048624 10486251048633 1048625983096 10486251048631 1048625983094

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 536

C O N T E N T S

List of Figures and ables 983097

Foreword by Scot McKnight 983089983089

983089 Introduction Being Salt Light and a City 983089983091

Part 983089 Salt Reshaping Our Conversations

983090 Glocalizing Conversations 983090983091

Part 983090 Light Renewing Our Mission

983091 Contextualizing Mission 983092983093

983092 Liberating People 983094983097

983093 Showing Hospitality 983097983095

983094 Embracing the Spirit 983089983089983097

983095 Caring for Creation 983089983093983095

983096 Living Ethically 983089983096983091

983097 ransforming Neighborhoods 983090983089983093

Part 983091 City Revitalizing Our Churches

983089983088 Indigenizing Faith 983090983091983095

983089983089 Devouring Scripture 983090983095983093

983089983090 Renewing Education 983091983088983089

983089983091 Practicing Servantship 983091983091983095

983089983092 Recovering Community 983091983094983091

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 636

983089983093 Developing Spirituality and Discipleship 983091983096983091

983089983094 GlobalChurch Embracing a New Narrative 983092983089983093

Appendix 983089 GlobalChurch Project Video Series 983092983093983089

Appendix 983090 Study Guide 983092983093983091

Appendix 983091 Who Are hese Majority World

and Indigenous hinkers 983092983096983089

Appendix 983092 Resources and Glossary at

heGlobalChurchProjectcom 983092983097983091

Author Index 983092983097983093

Subject Index 983092983097983097

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 736

I N T R O D U C T I O N

B983141983145983150983143 S983137983148983156 L983145983143983144983156 983137983150983140 983137 C983145983156 983161

By 9830909830889830901048629 fully two-thirds of Christians will live in

Africa Latin America and Asia Te ldquoaverage

Christianrdquo today is female black and lives in a

Brazilian favela or an African village

SEPHE N BEVANS

Majority World and indigenous churches are redefining twenty-first-

century Christianity Western churches must decide how theyrsquoll respond

Stephen Bevans puts it well

We are now living in a ldquoworld churchrdquo where the vast majority of Christians are

[from the Majority World] David Barrettrsquos statistical studies have basically con-

firmed this shi and Philip Jenkins has predicted that by 1048626104862410486261048629 fully two-thirds

of Christians will live in Africa Latin America and Asia Scholars are fairly

unanimous in acknowledging the accuracy of the facts Te ldquoaverage Christianrdquo

today is female black and lives in a Brazilian favela or an African village983089

Some statistics illustrate this shi in twenty-first-century global Christi-

anity Te Pew Research Centerrsquos report Global Christianity analyzes the size

and distribution of the worldrsquos Christian population Te report maps the

changes over the last century (1048625104863310486251048624 to 1048626104862410486251048624) It concludes ldquoA century ago the

Global North (commonly defined as North America Europe Australia Japan

1Stephen B Bevans Roger Schroeder and L J Luzbetak ldquoMissiology Afer Bosch Reverencing a

Classic by Moving Beyondrdquo International Bulletin o Missionary Research 983090983097 no 983090 (983090983088983088983093) 983094983097

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 836

10486251048628 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

and New Zealand) contained more than four times as many Christians as the

Global South (the rest of the world) oday the Pew Forum study finds more

than 10486251048627 billion Christians live in the Global South [10486301048625983077 of all Christians livein Asia Africa and Latin America] compared with about 104863210486301048624 million in the

Global North (10486271048633983077)rdquo1048626 Tat is an astounding shi in only one hundred years983091

Using the World Christian Database Philip Jenkins offers table 10486251048625

ldquoChanging distribution of Christian believersrdquo

Table 983089983089 Changing distribution of Christian believers 983089983097983088983088 to 983090983088983093983088 (number of Christiansin millions)

983089983097983088983088 983089983097983095983088 983090983088983089983088 983090983088983093983088Africa 983089983088 983089983092983091 983092983097983091 983089983088983091983089

Asia 983090983090 983097983094 983091983093983090 983094983088983089

North America 983095983097 983090983089983089 983090983096983094 983091983091983091

Latin America 983094983090 983090983095983088 983093983092983092 983094983093983093

Europe 983091983096983089 983092983097983090 983093983096983096 983093983091983088

Oceania 983093 983089983096 983090983096 983091983096

Total 983093983093983096 983089983090983091983088 983090983090983097983089 983091983089983096983096

Source Philip Jenkins The Next Christendom The Coming of Global Christianity 983091rd ed (Oxford Oxford Uni-

versity Press 983090983088983089983089) 983091 Data is taken from World Christian Database wwwworldchristiandatabaseorgwcd

Christianity in North America Europe and Oceania grew from 104862810486301048629

million in 1048625104863310486241048624 to 104863310486241048626 million in 1048626104862410486251048624983092 Tis number is likely to shrink to

104863310486241048625 million by 1048626104862410486291048624

Christianity in Africa Asia and Latin America grew from 10486331048628 million in

1048625104863310486241048624 to 1048625104862710486321048633 billion in 1048626104862410486251048624 Tis number is likely to grow to 1048626104862610486321048631 billion by

1048626104862410486291048624

Letrsquos take China for example Professor Fenggang Yang of Purdue University

makes an important prediction If current rates of growth continue within one

generation China will have more Christians than any other nation on earth

In 1048625104863310486281048633 Protestant churches in China had one million members In 1048626104862410486251048624 that

number was 10486291048632 million (compare that with 10486281048624 million in Brazil and 10486271048630 million

2Pew Research Center Global Christianity A Report on the Size and Distribution o the Worldrsquos Chris-

tian Population December 1048625983097 98309098308810486251048625 wwwpeworumorg9830909830881048625104862510486259830901048625983097global-christianity-exec3See David B Barrett George Kurian and odd M Johnson World Christian Encyclopedia A

Comparative Survey o Churches and Religions in the Modern World 983090nd ed 983090 vols (New York

Oxord University Press 9830909830889830881048625) 1048625983090-1048625983093 and wwwglobalchristianityorg4Oceania includes Australia and Micronesian Melanesian and Polynesian countries

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 936

Introduction 10486251048629

in South Africa) By 1048626104862410486261048629 there are likely to be 104862510486301048624 million Christians in China

By 1048626104862410486271048624 this number is likely to be 104862610486281048631 million (outnumbering Christians in

Mexico Brazil and the United States) In an interview with the elegraphFenggang Yang says ldquoMao thought he could eliminate religion He thought he

had accomplished this Itrsquos ironicmdashthey didnrsquot Tey actually failed completelyrdquo1048629

Philip Jenkins concludes

We are currently living through one of the transforming moments in the

history of religion worldwide Over the last five centuries the story of Chris-

tianity has been inextricably bound up with that of Europe and European-

derived civilizations overseas above all in North America Until recently theoverwhelming majority of Christians have lived in white nations Over the

last century however the center of gravity in the Christian world has shied

inexorably away from Europe southward to Africa and Latin America and

eastward toward Asia oday the largest Christian communities on the planet

are to be found in those regions1048630

What does all this mean for the mission and theology and worship and

communities of the church worldwide And what does it mean particularlyfor the Western church

In Matthew 104862910486251048627-10486251048630 Jesus provides three remarkable images of the churchmdash

salt light and a city Jesus confronts his disciples with a missional description

of the church Te church in mission is the salt of the earth the light of the

world and a city set on a hill Te churchrsquos purpose is to let its ldquolight shine

before others that they may see your good deeds and glorify your Father in

heavenrdquo Te purpose of the churchrsquos missionary nature is the worship andglorification of the Father and Son and Holy Spirit983095

Te church is another city constituted by every tribe language people

5om Phillips ldquoChina on Course to Become lsquoWorldrsquos Most Christian Nationrsquo Within 1048625983093 Yearsrdquo

elegraph April 1048625983097 98309098308810486251048628 wwwtelegraphcouknewsworldnewsasiachina1048625983088104863110486319830949830889830901048627China-on

-course-to-become-worlds-most-Christian-nation-within-1048625983093-yearshtml See Fenggang Yang and

Joseph B amney eds Conucianism and Spiritual raditions in Modern China and Beyond Re-

ligion in Chinese Societies (Boston Brill 9830909830881048625983090) Fenggang Yang and Graeme Lang eds Social

Scientific Studies o Religion in China Methodology Teories and Findings (Leiden Brill 98309098308810486251048625)

Fenggang Yang Religion in China Survival and Revival Under Communist Rule (Oxord Oxord

University Press 9830909830881048625983090)6Philip Jenkins Te Next Christendom Te Coming o Global Christianity 1048627rd ed (Oxord Ox-

ord University Press 98309098308810486251048625) 10486257J Driver Images o the Church in Mission (Scottdale PA Herald 10486259830979830971048631) 10486251048631983088-9830961048625 Graham Hill Salt

Light and a City Introducing Missional Ecclesiology (Eugene OR Wip and Stock 9830909830881048625983090) xiii

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1036

10486251048630 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

and nation Te church must cultivate a distinct social existence shaping its

community and mission around its commitment to plurality and diversity

and unity1048632 God calls his church to be a global and missional ldquocity on a hillrdquoTis is a church constituted and enriched and represented by Western and

indigenous and Majority World peoples

Tose of us in the West need a new narrative Itrsquos time to abandon our

flawed Eurocentric and Americentric worldviews We need a new global

and missional narrative and for that we must turn to the churches of Ma-

jority World and indigenous cultures Tey can help us explore what it

means to be a global missional community Many Christian communitiesin Majority World and indigenous contexts have been wrestling with these

issues for generations Marginalization and persecution and alienation have

been their lot Yet somehow in spite of or because of that they have flour-

ished In fact theyrsquove grown exponentially

So whom am I talking about when I refer to Majority World and indig-

enous Christians Majority World Christians are those in Africa Asia the

Caribbean Eastern Europe Latin America the Middle East and Oceania

1048633

I use the term Majority World because the majority of the worldrsquos population

is in those cultures today Te majority of the church is in those cultures too

I donrsquot use the terms non-Western or Tird World or Developing World Tese

terms use Western cultures as their point of reference Tey imply Western

8Barry A Harvey Another City An Ecclesiological Primer or a Post-Christian World (New York

rinity 1048625983097983097983097) 9830901048627-9830909830939I donrsquot deal with the diasporas in this book For example Irsquove made no mention o Hispanic

Portuguese or Asian minorities in the United States United Kingdom Canada Europe Austra-lia and so on Irsquom aware that right now Latin American and Chinese diasporas are active in

evangelism and mission in Europe in the same way in which the Filipino or the Salvadoran dias-

poras carry on mission in the United States Irsquove chosen not to include voices rom the diasporas

mainly because there are so many worthy contributors in that group and I donrsquot have the space

to treat them well in this book In the uture I hope that I (or someone else) will write a book

exploring what we can learn rom the diasporas Hispanic minorities or example are making

significant contributions to the theological and missiological conversation in the United States

that are relevant to this subject Methodist historian Justo L Gonzaacutelez and Pentecostal theologian

Eldin Villaantildee are examples In Mantildeana Gonzaacutelez describes the shape and orm o a theology

developed in the Hispanic margin o the United States In Out o Every ribe and Nation he shows

what would be implied in listening to minorities within a denominational setting Villaantildeersquos Te

Liberating Spirit is a milestone in the reflection about the relationship between pneumatology and

social ethics See Justo L Gonzaacutelez Out o Every ribe and Nation Christian Teology at the

Ethnic Roundtable (Nashville Abingdon 1048625983097983097983090) Gonzaacutelez Mantildeana Christian Teology rom a

Hispanic Perspective (Nashville Abingdon 1048625983097983097983088) Eldin Villaantildee Te Liberating Spirit oward

an Hispanic American Pentecostal Social Ethic (Grand Rapids Eerdmans 10486259830979830971048627)

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1136

Introduction 10486251048631

superiority or centricity Te term Global South is too limiting given the

breadth of the group I am engaging Majority World seems to work best

In 1048626104862410486241048628 Te Lausanne Forum for World Evangelization in PattayaTailand voted unanimously that the phrase Majority World Church replace

other terms People from all over the globe participated in this forum

imothy C ennent agrees that this is the best phrase ldquoIt helps to highlight

the basic point that Africa Asia and Latin America are where the majority

of the worldrsquos Christians are now locatedrdquo9830891048624 I expand the phrase Majority

World beyond Africa Asia and Latin America to include the Caribbean

Eastern Europe Oceania and the Middle EastIndigenous and First Nations peoples are ldquothose ethnic groups that were

indigenous to a territory prior to being incorporated into a national state

and who are politically and culturally separate from the majority ethnic

identity of the state that they are a part ofrdquo Tis includes people groups like

the Australian Aborigines and American Indians983089983089

Te aim of this book is to help Western churches rediscover what it means

to be salt light and a city by engaging in global missional conversations odo this Western Christians need to enter into conversation with Majority

World and indigenous Christians Listening to others helps us grow in our

understanding and practice of mission and church and theology For far too

long wersquove marginalized or ignored Majority World and indigenous voices

We must truly become a GlobalChurch

Tis aim shapes the bookrsquos structure as summarized below

P983137983154983156 1048625 S983137983148983156 R983141983155983144983137983152983145983150983143 O983157983154 C983151983150983158983141983154983155983137983156983145983151983150983155

ldquoYou are the salt of the earth But if the salt loses its saltiness how can it be made

salty again It is no longer good for anything except to be thrown out and

trampled underfootrdquo Globally and locally you are the salt of the earth Be salt

Salt preserves seasons flavors and purifies We are salt when we glorify

the Father Son and Holy Spirit in our mission worship faith hope truth

and love We are salt when we reject a Eurocentric or Americentric vision

10imothy C ennent Teology in the Context o World Christianity How the Global Church Is

Influencing the Way We Tink About and Discuss Teology (Grand Rapids Zondervan 9830909830889830881048631) xx11Douglas Sanders ldquoIndigenous Peoples Issues o Definitionrdquo International Journal o Cultural

Property 983096 no 1048625 (1048625983097983097983097) 1048628

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1236

10486251048632 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

of the church and become the global missional church Christ envisioned

In part one I show how Western conversations are impoverished and

insufficient in isolation from indigenous and Majority World Christians Weenhance our ldquosaltinessrdquo through local-global ( glocal ) exchanges o do this

we must reshape our conversations We need global and local exchanges that

we characterize by mutuality respect partnership and symbiosis Such ex-

changes help us learn from each other whether wersquore in Western indig-

enous or Majority World settings It helps us stay ldquosaltyrdquo It enables us to

pursue global missional theology and practice Globally and locally we can

pursue missional vitality and truly be ldquothe salt of the earthrdquo

P983137983154983156 1048626 L983145983143983144983156 R983141983150983141983159983145983150983143 O983157983154 M983145983155983155983145983151983150

ldquoYou are the light of the world A city on a hill cannot be hidden Neither do

people light a lamp and put it under a bowl Instead they put it on its stand and

it gives light to everyone in the house In the same way let your light shine

before others that they may see your good deeds and glorify your Father in

heavenrdquo (Mt 104862910486251048628-10486251048631) Globally and locally you are the light of the world Be lightLight illuminates reveals and dispels darkness Te church is light when

it does good deedsmdashhealing and liberating and redemptive deeds Itrsquos light

when its being and faith and deeds bring glorify to the Father Te church

is light when it participates in Godrsquos redemptive mission in the world as a

global missional community

o do this we must renew our mission In part two I explore how indig-

enous and Majority World Christians teach us to renew mission We renew

mission through contextualization liberation hospitality Spirit empow-

erment creation care ethics and the transformation of neighborhoods

P983137983154983156 1048627 C983145983156983161 R983141983158983145983156983137983148983145983162983145983150983143 O983157983154 C983144983157983154983139983144983141983155

You are a city set on a hill ldquoA city on a hill cannot be hiddenrdquo Globally and

locally you are a city set on a hill Be a city set on a hill

Tis means that we are an alternative and countercultural movement We

have a distinct culture and politic and social existence We are a people

gathered from every tribe language people and nation We are in the world

but not of the world We are in the world but distinct from the world We are

within the world and for the sake of the world

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1336

Introduction 10486251048633

o be this kind of alternative city or culture we must renew our mission

community ethics and worship We need to pursue the revitalization of our

churches so that they are distinct And by distinct I mean an alternative city(altera civitas)

We are a ldquocity on a hillrdquo that witnesses to Jesus Christ and his eternal kingdom

when we are a global missional church In part three I demonstrate how indig-

enous and Majority World Christians teach us to revitalize churches We revi-

talize churches by indigenizing faith devouring Scripture renewing education

practicing servantship (servant leadership) recovering community and devel-

oping spirituality and discipleship We inspire our churches when we developour theology and practices relating to beauty and the arts9830891048626

In the final chapter I wrap things up by addressing an important question

In light of all the material covered in this book what would it now look like

to engage in global missional theology ecclesiology interpretation history

pneumatology worship and education

Herersquos how you can get the most out of this book

Community You can read this book alone in a small group with somefriends at home or at a coffee shop or as part of a ministry team However

you get a lot more out of this book when you read it with others ogether

you can think about the bookrsquos implications What do the chapters mean for

your ministry church agency family or team

GlobalChurch Project video series Irsquove made a video series to go along with

this book Appendix one has the details

Study guide Yoursquoll get a lot more out of this book if you spend time

working through the study guide in appendix two ry to do this in a group

Te study guide includes reflection questions suggested practices and

Further Reading

Characters As you read this book yoursquoll come across names and people

yoursquove never heard of before For a glimpse of who they are and what issues

concern them see appendix three

My website o help you get the most out of this book Irsquove included more

resources on my website TeGlobalChurchProjectcom Tese include

videos reading lists important links a glossary and other resources Irsquove

12Irsquove put a separate chapter on the theme o beauty and the arts on my website Itrsquos additional to

this book

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1436

10486261048624 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

also provided ways that you can contact me See appendix four

In my first book Salt Light and a City I developed a missional theology

of the church I did this in conversation with twelve theologians from the fourmajor Christian traditions Tat volume offered a window into the thought of

European and American theologians It showed how they are making sense

of the nature and mission of the church in their Western cultural context

Te book that yoursquore now reading takes a different approach I have

stepped away from European and American voices I now ask What can

those in the Majority World and indigenous cultures teach us in the West

What can they teach us about the churchrsquos mission worship theology andcommunity Te quality and quantity of material coming out of the Ma-

jority World is astonishing Any theology that ignores the insights of indig-

enous and Majority World Christians is deficient and impoverished

White middle-class European North American tertiary-educated men

dominate Western theology Tey dominate the Western missional conver-

sation I know I fit that profile Tis group still monopolizes missional church

conferences and seminars Tey get all the book contracts In fact this groupstill controls theology and the church in many settings But this is changing

New voices are rising Tese include women minorities the poor indigenous

groups and Majority World leaders Missional conversations arenrsquot attentive

to the Spirit and to Godrsquos mission if they ignore these voices Majority World

and indigenous churches oen have extraordinary missional vitality Openness

to other voices needs to happen now It is time for Western churches theol-

ogies and mission to mature and to reflect Godrsquos global mission

In this book I could have consulted the work of many thousands of in-

digenous and Majority World thinkers and writers and practitioners But I

have limited myself to a sample of those who speak directly to its themes

Tese African Asian Eastern European Middle Eastern Caribbean Latin

American First Nation and indigenous thinkers challenge us Tey dare us

to examine our theologies and missions and churches And they inspire us

to renew the worship and community and mission of Jesusrsquo church Tey

stir us to think in fresh ways about what it means to be salt light and a city

Tey help us become a global missional churchmdasha truly GlobalChurch

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1536

PA R T O N E

S A L TReshaping Our Conversations

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1636

G L O C A L I Z I N G

C O N V E R S A T I O N S

H983151983159 D983151 W983141 D983141983158983141983148983151983152

G983148983151983139983137983148 C983151983150983158983141983154983155983137983156983145983151983150983155983103

Rather than taking one contextual version of the Gospel and imposing

it as the Gospel throughout the world via the missionary enterprise

the shapers of Mission as ransformation have recognized the

plurality of localities that has created an intercontextual

ldquopan-localrdquo global phenomenon in theology

AL IZON

The International Society for Urban Mission (ISUM) is a group of urban

missionaries who are passionate about cultivating hope and love and re-newal in cities Irsquove connected with this group for some years ISUM held its

first annual Summit on Integral Urban Mission in Bangkok Tailand Te

team from Urban Neighbours of Hope (UNOH) under the leadership of

my Australian friends Ash and Anj Barker organized much of the summit

UNOH teams covenant with God and each other to ldquolive out our passion for

loving God and neighbour Focus on releasing neighbourhoods from urban

poverty Grow through equipping each other neighbours and the broader

church to radically follow Jesus and join Godrsquos Kingdom coming UNOH

workers live and serve in small responsive neighbourhood-based teamsrdquo983089

1See wwwunohorg

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1736

10486261048628 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

Tis summit involved interactive participatory hands-on immersion op-

portunities keynotes lectures and workshops Keynote speakers came from

Africa Australia Myanmar New Zealand North America the PhilippinesSouth America Tailand and First Nations A few hundred Majority World

and Western thinkers and activists came together for those days Tey explored

the theology and practices of integral transformational and urban mission

Tese thinkers and activists pursued a range of aims1048626 Tis included col-

laboration between urban Christians from a variety of backgrounds (Ma-

jority World and Western theologians activists ecumenicals Pentecostals

evangelicals colleges church movements and development agencies) Teyaimed for collective action and thought in an international and integral

context Tey sought to gain mutual understanding for a comprehensive

picture of urban mission around the globe Tey encouraged information

sharing and best practicesmdashlearning from our mistakes and seeking solu-

tions Tey developed recommendations and calls to action to the broader

church Working groups wrote briefing papers aer each summit based on

key issues in urban mission And they endeavored to build trust wisdomand inspiration to better engage our new urban world

Majority World and Western leaders participated in discussion prayer

integral mission and working groups Te goal was to grapple with key issues

and ask key questions How do we recruit equip and sustain urban mission

today How do we release church movements among the urban poor How

can we immerse ourselves in and transform urban neighborhoods How do

we empower urban children and young people How does the church serve

and liberate the oppressedmdashand others suffering from urban injustice What

needs to happen for poorer urban centers to develop economically socially

and spiritually How do we join God in the challenges and opportunities of

multifaith cities

Workshops included urban gardening child protection and collaborating

with local churches in urban mission Workshops also included organic

church growth and mission as well as developing NGO and government

partnerships Groups considered the good the bad and the ugly of short-

term urban mission teams

2Tese aims are detailed at ldquoInternational Society or Urban Mission Summitrdquo httpnewurbanworld

orgsummit

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1836

Glocalizing Conversations 10486261048629

Te summit was a thrilling example of how Majority World and Western

leaders can cooperate It was a time to come together in an environment of

mutual learning and enrichment It was a window into how local contextsand global themes can enrich each other Tis resulted from ISUMrsquos com-

mitment to ldquosolidarity fellowship and insight between urban Christian

leaders in the Western and Majority Worldsrdquo

Te summit was a success due to ISUMrsquos core values What are they983091 Christ-

honoring urban mission values bottom-up grassroots perspectivesmdashrather

than top-down distanced perspectives It allows local theology to reveal new

insights and perspectives about Godrsquos activity It shares insights and experi-ences through narratives embedded within urban poor communities and cities

It cultivates ongoing practical and personal solidarity with the worldrsquos urban

poor Tis Spirit-empowered urban mission honors networks relationships

and partnerships It sees such relationships as the primary method of serving

together It listens to and amplifies the voices of the urban poormdashespecially

those from the Majority World and in particular the 1048625104862410486281048624 window cities It is

attentive to signs of the kingdom of God Urban mission that glorifies God iswilling to reflect and respond with active and sacrificial commitment It shares

and extends the life of the body of Christ among the urban poor

Tis summit was a milestone in urban missiology It enriched communi-

cation between Western and Majority World thinker-activists Tis resulted

from the aims and values Irsquove mentioned Effective urban mission needs to

be a conversation on many levels It is attentive to context and immersed in

local settings It appreciates global and universal missional themes It culti-

vates dialogue between these local-global (glocal) realities It involves

mutual learning between Western and Majority World thinker-activists

Moreover solidarity between all parties is a defining feature Tis solidarity

is due to a compelling vision of the kingdom of God

Tese collaborative glocal features of the ISUM urban mission summit

in Bangkok are critical for the aims of this book GlobalChurch

Majority World indigenous and Western leaders thinkers and churches

can stretch and enrich each other But they need to be open and attentive to

each other Tey need learning postures and open hearts and minds Tey

3ldquoAbout ISUMrdquo httpnewurbanworldorgabout

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1936

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2036

Glocalizing Conversations 10486261048631

always rooted in the local and particularmdashas local churches embody the

gospel and witness to Christ Tese churches forge their own theological

understandings as they do mission together Tey engage in transformationalpractices among the people in their settings Tey enjoy worship mission

and community in their local and particular context Ideally the result is

unique contextual theologies and missions

Simultaneously global conversations form Tey form because of this

multitude of local theologies and practices Local conversations inform and

enrich other local conversations catalyzing global themes and voices izon

observes that the global ldquoowes its existence to local contexts Sharedconvictions among the theologies and practices of local contextual realities

give shape to its global dimensionsrdquo1048629

Majority World indigenous and Western theologies are equally contextual

Tey are equally culture bound Tey are equally particular to their time and

location At times they are all enlightened or myopic liberating or con-

straining humanizing or objectifying beautiful or offensive prophetic or

tepid Te local particular and cultural shape all these theologies Converselythese particular theologies feed and influence global conversations Tere is

no place then for ethnocentrism colonialism or elitism Tere is no place

for theological missional cultural or institutionalized arrogance

Multiple local contexts and voices come togethermdashintentionally or notmdashto

form global themes and theologies Conversely these global realities shape

local contexts oday local contexts must grapple with ldquoan emerging global

culture ie the interacting realities of modernity postmodernity and the

phenomenon of globalizationrdquo1048630 Hence the interdependent and symbiotic

relationship between the localparticular and the globaluniversal We call this

interdependent relationship between the local and the global glocalization

Te global church needs a thrilling glocal exchange We need one that we

characterize by mutuality respect partnership and symbiosis Such ex-

change helps Majority World indigenous and Western churches learn from

each other It enables them to pursue missional theology and practice o-

gether the church becomes a ldquocity on a hillrdquo

5Ibid 10486259830886Ibid 9830961048628

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2136

10486261048632 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

W983144983137983156 R983141983153983157983145983154983141983155 G983148983151983139983137983148983145983162983137983156983145983151983150983103

Te glocal exchange described above needs to be broader than transforma-

tional mission Tis is necessary if the church is to develop a robust inter-cultural and glocal missional ecclesiology

In my first book Salt Light and a City I outlined the foundational

themes of missional ecclesiology983095 Majority World and Western leaders

need to engage these themes in local and contextual ways Teir insights can

then enrich global conversations Tese global conversations in turn shape

local understandings and practices Tis way a glocal appreciation of these

themes emergesLocal regional and global theologies and practices are thereby enriched

Te church becomes healthier and more missionalmdasha truer expression of

the kingdom Te church becomes a fuller witness to Christ his passion for

the nations and his ability to bring unity in diversity

Stephen Bevans and Roger Schroeder outline the six constants of mission

Tese are our theologies about Jesus the church the end times salvation

human nature and culture Bevans and Schroeder describe the relationshipbetween these six and their historical cultural and theological contexts Tis is

why they call these six constants in context Our understanding of these six

constants develops in relation to local and global movements Sometimes local

voices influence our understandings of these six Other times it is regional or

global voices For all of us local regional and global influences are at play at

once Collectively they form our appreciation of the six constants of mission1048632

Here are eight theological themes that the church can develop through

processes of glocalization I presented these in my book Salt Light and a City

Tey are vital to the churchrsquos health mission community and future We

could add many other themes to these eight but these will suffice for now1048633

Scripture Te Scriptures are the infallible authoritative Word of God

Christrsquos Spirit has inspired them Tey have absolute and final authority in

all aspects of corporate and individual faith ethics conduct and witness

Christians interpret and apply Scripture in local contexts and in particular

7Graham Hill Salt Light and a City Introducing Missional Ecclesiology (Eugene OR Wip and

Stock 9830909830881048625983090) 10486251048628983097-983090104863110486288Stephen B Bevans and Roger Schroeder Constants in Context A Teology o Mission or oday

American Society o Missiology Series (Maryknoll NY Orbis 9830909830889830881048628) part one9Tese points first appeared in my book Salt Light and a City xxii-xxiv

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2236

Glocalizing Conversations 10486261048633

social settings Conversely we learn from the interpretations and readings

of other groups

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our local- global theology of Scripture and biblical interpretation

Evangelicalism Pentecostalism missional movements and so forth I

have charismatic missional and evangelical convictions Glocal conversa-

tions help me understand and practice these convictions better

I will use evangelicalism as an example Michael Horton says that our

beliefs and practices are evangelical when they are ldquocommitted to the suffi-

ciency of Scripture the priesthood of all believers the total lostness ofhumans the sole mediation of Christ the gracious efficacy and finality of

Godrsquos redemptive work in Christ through election propitiation calling and

keeping Te linchpin for all of this was the doctrine of justification by grace

alone through faith alone because of Christ alonerdquo9830891048624

Such convictions are necessary if we are to be faithful to the gospel and

to a biblical vision of church and mission Te gospel defines Godrsquos purposes

for humanity the church and the universe Te triune God controls thechurch He is its Lord and Savior Sanctifier and Liberator Master and King

He is completely sovereign over its nature affairs mission and history God

is the churchrsquos only source of grace election atonement salvation and per-

severance Te churchrsquos justification and hope are by grace alone through

faith alone by Christ alone

Herersquos the challenge I face My understanding of evangelicalism is

Western I am a product of the Western theological tradition and my Western

evangelical heritage Much of this is wonderful But I need indigenous and

Majority World evangelicals and others to help me expand and reshape

these insights Te same would be true if I were a Pentecostal

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of our theological traditions and convictions

Jesus Christ We must center our theology on Jesus Christ the Lord of

the church Te church needs to reflect on the person and work of Christ

and respond to him Tis means gathering and going in the name and power

of Christ It means allowing Christrsquos Spirit to shape our community and

10Michael Horton ldquoEvangelical Arminiansrdquo Modern Reormation 1048625 no 1048627 (1048625983097983097983090) 10486251048631

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2336

10486271048624 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

identity and mission It means developing our Christology ecclesiology and

missiology concurrently Te early church developed these three areas and

more in a concurrent and integrated way Tere was no linear progressionTe same is true in the contemporary global church

How can the glocal church best explore its nature structure mission and

hope Trough the centrality and the lordship of Christ

Majority World and indigenous Christians help us appreciate Jesus and

his mission afresh Tey show us how Jesus identifies with the marginalized

outcast oppressed rejected and broken He prefers them We find him

among ldquothe least of theserdquoGlocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of who Jesus Christ is How does it help us appreciate him better

What has Jesus done for and in his church and his world What does he care

about What individual and corporate responsibilities has he given us How

do we express these at local regional and global levels

Te Spirit Missional ecclesiology is inadequate without pneumatological

foundations In other words our theology of church and Spirit go togetherTe Spirit creates and animates the church He empowers it to witness to

Jesus and his gospel Te Spirit enables the church to be a missional trans-

formational community He shapes the church into an alternative society

embodying the reign of God Te church exists for the glory and mission of

Christ Te power and presence of the Spirit enables this mission worship

and glorification

Te Spirit pours out gis on the local-global church ldquofor the common

goodrdquo and ldquoto equip his people for works of service so that the body of Christ

may be built uprdquo Tis includes but isnrsquot limited to the ministry gis mani-

festation gis and motivational gis (1048625 Cor 104862510486261048631 Eph 104862810486251048625-10486251048626 Rom 104862510486261048630-1048632)

Te Spirit forms the glocal church He empowers it for service and

witness He fills it with Christrsquos empowering presence He leads it into the

missio Deimdashthe mission of the Father Son and Holy Spirit

Recently Pentecostal and renewalist movements have grown dramati-

cally in the Majority World Tey have increased in status size and influence

Many have matured theologically Te churches of the West must take notice

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of the power and presence of the Spirit

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2436

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048625

Te rinity Tere are clear limitations to the analogy between the

church and the rinity Te church can only image the rinity Yet the

church is at its best when it reflects the relational and missional passionof the rinity

What is the source and inspiration of the churchrsquos local-global mission

Ultimately it is the missional nature passion and actions of the Father Son

and Holy Spirit Godrsquos nature is missional His passion is infectious His

actions are historical redemptive and eternal Te rinity invites the

church into a sending community Te Father sends the Son Te Father

and Son send the Spirit Finally the rinity sends the church in missioninto the world

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of the rinity How does it enable our participation in the mission

and community of the triune God

Association and dialogue Tese need to happen across denominational

cultural ethnic gender and theological traditions and divides Authentic

dialogue is indispensable to the health and mission of the church What dothose marginal to the life of the church have to say to us What do ldquoothersrdquo

have to teach us Other ethnicities and cultures Other socioeconomic

groups Other ages and genders Other theological and confessing tradi-

tions Other persons from times long gone

We need to listen Share Be vulnerable Be authentic Open up to crit-

icism correction and change

We need more than dialogue We need communion and association It is

possible in a qualified way to say that God is present in all the various forms

of the church (ie the various theological ecclesiological sociocultural his-

torical and other permutations of the church) We discern this presence

through attention to Scripture history tradition culture and the Spirit Dis-

cernment involves critical dialogue theological exchange biblical study and

real relationship Only the Spirit of Jesus can enable this

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of association and dialogue

Mission and the missio Dei Te church is missional at its core It serves

obeys and images a missionary God David Bosch says ldquoTe churchrsquos mission

is not secondary to its being the church exists in being sent and in building up

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2536

10486271048626 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

itself for its missionrdquo He goes on to say ldquoEcclesiology does not precede missi-

ology there cannot be church without an intrinsic missionary dimensionrdquo983089983089

Jesus is Lord Lord of his church and Lord of his world His mission de-termines and forms the church His mission shapes the nature purposes

structures ministries and activities of his church Majority World and in-

digenous thinkers help us understand the implications of this mission Tey

help us form glocal theologies of mission Tey reveal ldquomission in context

as transformationrdquo9830891048626

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of mission and the missio Dei Church theology and practice Glocal conversations can inform and

enrich many aspects of the church (when practiced well) Teologies and

practices benefit from robust and critical glocal conversations Tese con-

versations enrich many areas (community spirituality discipleship liturgy

worship hospitality eco-justice education social ethics servantship lib-

eration place suffering beauty and so on)

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-standing of these many dimensions of church and mission

Glocal processes shape these eight themes and their practices We need

to facilitate and enable these conversations and processes Tis is urgent It

must be a priority No theology of mission or missional ecclesiology is ad-

equate without glocal conversations983089983091

T983144983141 L983151983139983137983148 983137983150983140 G983148983151983138983137983148 E983150983154983145983139983144 E983137983139983144 O983156983144983141983154

Glocalization takes the localparticular context and globaluniversal themes

seriously Contextual and global conversations enter an enriching and in-

forming relationship Tese two always have an active and symbiotic rela-

tionship Tis is true whether we deliberately put them into conversation or

not Te local shapes the global and the global shapes the local Many local

11David J Bosch Believing in the Future oward a Missiology o Western Culture (New York

rinity 1048625983097983097983093) 104862798309012izon ransormation Afer Lausanne 1048631-98309713Not all o these themes are dealt with in this present volume since either (1048625) I have dealt with them

in my book Salt Light and a City (983090) they are not all key themes in the writings o the thirty-five

Majority World thinkers considered in this volume or (1048627) there is not adequate space in a book

this size

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2636

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048627

voices converge to form global conversations and theologies Using the Phil-

ippines as a case study izon illustrates this by showing the interdepen-

dence between local and global themes in mission983089983092Dialogue between local and global conversations is critical Kōsuke

Koyama wrote an important book on contextual mission called Water Buffalo

Teology Koyama is a Japanese missionary who served in Chiang Mai

Tailand He writes of the joys and challenges of doing local particular water

buffalo theology He considers the relationship between local theology global

missional themes and transforming cultures ldquoWater Buffalo Teology sees

certain specific challenges Contextualization of theology implies two criticalmovements First to articulate Jesus Christ in culturally appropriate com-

municatively apt words and second to criticize reform dethrone or oppose

culture if it is found to be against what the name of Jesus Christ stands forrdquo9830891048629

Kōsuke Koyama challenges us to recognize what we bring to the task of

local theology For him it was doing theology in Tailand while being Jap-

anese We also need to notice the particular culture wersquore located in as we do

the work of theology Tis means we avoid speaking of an ldquoAsian theologyrdquoldquoAfrican theologyrdquo and the like We need to cultivate local theologies that

engage regional and global themes But these theologies must be ldquodistinctly

localrdquo and a ldquotheology from belowrdquo9830891048630

Simultaneously we need to pursue a reformation of theology and

practice ldquoin the global contextrdquo Tis means entering ldquothe disturbing spa-

ciousness of Jesus Christrdquo Jesus calls us to reject enmity and exceptionalism

We seem him present in our culture language stories and relationships

But we also choose to embrace the ldquootherrdquo We choose to see him present

in other culturesmdashshaping a global people to serve and worship him

joining in his mission983089983095

Kōsuke Koyama roots the gospel in the local contextual and particular

Tis is why he roots his water buffalo theology in Northern Tai culture He

is careful not to say ldquoHere is how you contextualize in your settingrdquo Instead

14izon ransormation Afer Lausanne 1048631-10486251048627 10486251048628983097-98309098308898309015Kōsuke Koyama Water Buffalo Teology 983090983093th anniversary ed (Maryknoll NY Orbis 1048625983097983097983097)

xiii-xv16Kōsuke Koyama ldquoTe Asian Approach to Christrdquo Missiology 1048625983090 no 1048628 (10486259830979830961048628) 10486281048627983093-104862798309617Kōsuke Koyama ldquoReormation in the Global Context Te Disturbing Spaciousness o Jesus Christrdquo

Currents in Teology and Mission 1048627983088 no 983090 (9830909830889830881048627) 10486251048625983097-983090983096

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2736

10486271048628 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

he tells us a story Itrsquos the story of how he contextualized theology in northern

Tailand while being open to global conversations Koyama asks us to form

our own local expressions of church mission and theology At the same timewe must stay attentive to what God is saying and doing beyond that context

Tis way local and global and particular and universal become mutually

enriching conversation partners

G983148983151983139983137983148983145983162983137983156983145983151983150 983137983150983140 H983145983155983156983151983154983145983139983137983148983148983161 S983145983148983141983150983139983141983140 V983151983145983139983141983155

Glocal theologies and conversations pay attention to voices that powers in-

stitutions religions and societies have silenced R S Sugirtharajah pushesback a little on izonrsquos ideas Sugirtharajah says that the church should

privilege local conversations He emphasizes the local contextual and post-

colonial reading of biblical texts9830891048632

Te church needs to listen Te church ought to be attentive to the

theologies and biblical interpretations of groups that cultures and reli-

gions have ignored Historically powerful secular and religious forces

have silenced these groups Tey have marginalized oppressed and colo-nized them It is time for the church to address this injustice We must

start listening to important but silenced voices We need to privilege the

voices of the former victims of Western colonialism We need to develop

postcolonial biblical interpretations theologies and expressions of church

and mission

How do we take such perspectives seriously as we develop glocal conver-

sations How do these themes help us foster vital relationships between local

and global voices

It is time for us to embrace values that enable conversations with those

oen ignored by the church We need values that help us learn from these

groups and individuals

Valuing equal partnership Colonizing powers oppressed silenced and

colonized certain groups At times the church was complicit Tese colo-

nized groups have become ldquoconfident indomitable and indispensable

partners in the dialogue and collaboration with the dispossessed and disad-

18R S Sugirtharajah Asian Biblical Hermeneutics and Postcolonialism Contesting the Interpreta-

tions Te Bible and Liberation Series (Maryknoll NY Orbis 1048625983097983097983096) 1048625983093-1048625983094

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2836

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048629

vantaged in the Westrdquo9830891048633 Tis calls for attentiveness to these voices and re-

sponsiveness to their prophetic challenges It also demands a critical evalu-

ation of colonial readings of Scripture Colonial models of theology andchurch and mission are no longer the benchmark Te global church must

examine them afresh

Valuing equal status Tose on the margins have now taken their rightful

place on the global stage Tey have claimed appropriate and equal status at

the table Subaltern readings of theology church and mission are invaluable

contributors to global theological conversations Tis means that we esteem

them But we also test themWhat do we mean by subaltern Subalterns are those who are down-

trodden and silenced (or have been treated this way in the past) Dominant

or colonizing groups treat them as invisible nonentities Tey enjoy limited

or no access to power Sometimes these are women certain tribal and ethnic

groups and those considered ldquountouchablerdquo In Voices from the Margin Su-

girtharajah provides a platform for postcolonial subaltern readings of

Scripture and theology Tese readings challenge colonialmdashoen Westernmdashreadings of Bible and theology and cultures Tey claim equal status with

other ways of doing theology10486261048624

Valuing equal identity People groups need freedom to explore their new

and emerging identities Tese emerge in response to local and global influ-

ences Local culture is not the only thing at work here Global forces also

shape identity as do imported practices ideas readings rituals and tech-

nologies But each group should be free to explore and construct their par-

ticular forms of Christian identity

Valuing equal interpretations ldquoPostcolonialism is concerned with the

question of cultural and discursive dominationrdquo Colonialism led to op-

pressive and controlling forms of culture and discourse Tese were usually

not contextual or indigenous Western powers for instance brought co-

lonial forms of theology church biblical interpretation and mission1048626983089

Postcolonialism calls for alternative ways of approaching these things Tose

19Ibid 104862598309420R S Sugirtharajah Voices rom the Margin Interpreting the Bible in the Tird World (Maryknoll

NY Orbis 10486259830979830971048625)21Sugirtharajah Asian Biblical Hermeneutics and Postcolonialism 10486251048631

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2936

10486271048630 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

who were once marginalized oppressed and silenced need to lead these fresh

approaches in their own settings Tese then influence global conversations

We need to support the new readings and insights and experiments from thesegroups o be genuine this support must be both critical and collegial

Valuing equal empowerment Sugirtharajah says that postcolonialism is

valuable when it empowers actual communities and real people Post-

colonial thought empowers when it addresses the difficulties hopes and

experiences of ordinary people It should never be about power plays and

the clever use of language Itrsquos pointless if itrsquos obsessed with forming newmdash

and ldquocolonizingrdquomdashtheories Itrsquos a waste of time if itrsquos a self-indulgent pursuitof new and hybrid identities Rather ldquothe worth and credibility of post-

colonial criticism will be judged by how it orchestrates the unique and

fragile and imagined claims of one community against anotherrdquo Empow-

erment happens in a variety of ways One way is contributing equally to

global conversations10486261048626

Al izon examines postcolonialism in the Philippines He says that it can

teach the global church a lot about healthy local-global conversations Fil-ipino contextual theology resists many Western forms of mission and the-

ology It finds them patronizing and controlling Tis indigenous theology

values prophetic sociopolitical engagement in institutions and the society

at large It emphasizes ministry to whole persons and communities It con-

structs a Filipino theology of beauty and mission and worship and com-

munity And it fosters indigenous theological approaches to the spirit world

and cosmology

izon says that postcolonial theology has played a constructive role in

the Philippines But he is uncomfortable with the label postcolonialism He

prefers to describe historical events as ldquobeyond colonialismrdquo And he says

that global conversations enrich local theologies and vice versa1048626983091

Postcolonial thought informs our understanding of the relationship be-

tween the local and global It also shows how theology can emerge at the

intersection between the localparticular and the globaluniversal It re-

minds us that worthwhile glocalization listens to all voices Tis includes

heeding those that have been historically silenced

22Ibid 983090104862823izon ransormation Afer Lausanne 1048625983088983090 10486259830941048631-9830961048631

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3036

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048631

G983148983151983139983137983148983145983162983137983156983145983151983150 983137983150983140 983156983144983141 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

C983151983150983139983148983157983140983145983150983143 R983141983142983148983141983139983156983145983151983150983155

How do we go about developing a model for glocal conversations izon hasrecently provided a useful model that is instructive as we seek to learn from

the Majority World It has at least two key features

First the local is in the global (globalization from below) Global theologies

and ideas have origins in many particular local contexts In that sense glo-

balization is from below Global ideas have local roots Ideas about integral

mission liberation theology and missional church have local origins Tey

have their roots in the prayers hopes discoveries mission and theologiesof thousands of local communities ldquoTe global does not cannot exist

without the localmdashbut the coming together of localities creates a global re-

ality that becomes greater than the sum of its parts it creates a gestalt entity

to which localities make themselves accountablerdquo1048626983092

Second the global is in the local (panlocalization from above) Te con-

cerns and voices of multitudes of locales form global conversations Tese

global discussions can provide a ldquopositive accountabilityrdquo back to local con-texts Tis is true when they enrich affirm serve guide and strengthen local

contexts It is also true when they avoid homogenization control impo-

sition and judgment Glocalization is best when it sees itself as interde-

pendent deeply connected with the local10486261048629

Tatrsquos a helpful starting point But we need to go further Besides izonrsquos

proposals Irsquom convinced that robust glocal conversations cultivate six core

practices

983089 Glocal theology practices its values We root glocal theology in core

values Tese values include solidarity understanding and mutual learning

Do we value fellowship with Christians of all cultures Do we value learning

from them

We prove our values through our practices What practices emerge out of

these values We need to collaborate act collectively and share information

We must find ways to foster grassroots perspectives and local theologies We

need to share stories and learnings and cultivate networks relationships and

partnerships We need attentiveness to local voices and global themes We

24Ibid 9830901048625983088-1048625104862825Ibid 98309010486251048628-1048625983096

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3136

10486271048632 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

ought to find ways to put these local and global voices into conversation

Mutual learning humility and solidarity are key Worthwhile glocal con-

versations can never be merely theoretical or academic It is up to us to rootour values in our practices

983090 Glocal theology practices humility (and it tells a new narrative) We

have noted that the local is in the global and the global is in the local Te

two are interdependent Tey form each other reciprocally Since this is the

case we must practice humility Tere is no place for ethnocentrism colo-

nialism or theological and cultural arrogance I have seen these unhealthy

postures far too oen in Western settingsRecently I attended a missional leadership conference On that occasion

the keynote speakermdasha leading missional author and speakermdashsaid that

North American missional conversations and innovations hold the key to

the future of the Western church Tis Euro American view is wrong (Irsquom

being kind o be frank itrsquos complete nonsense) Itrsquos arrogant and Euro

Americanndashcentric And itrsquos completely out of step with what is happening in

the glocal church We need a new narrativeIn June 1048626104862410486251048627 Te Center for the Study of Global Christianity reported

the top 10486261048624 countries where Christianity has the highest percentage growth

rate Nineteen of the top twenty are in Asia and Africa Eleven of them are

in Muslim majority countries Not a single country from Europe or North

America makes the top twenty list10486261048630

Itrsquos time to cultivate a new narrative Te future of the church is emerging

from the Majority World Rather than North America the churches of

Eastern Asia Western Africa the Arabian Peninsula and other parts of the

Majority World reveal the future of the global church We need the contribu-

tions of all contexts Western indigenous and Majority World All con-

tribute to glocal conversations All are important as we learn from each

other about mission theology and faith But letrsquos stop pretending that North

Americans and Europeans will reveal the future of the global church Letrsquos

start listening to what God is saying about the future of the global church

And hersquos speaking to us through the churches of Asia Africa Latin America

26Russ Mitchell ldquoTe op 983090983088 Countries Where Christianity Is Growing the Fastestrdquo Disciple All

Nations (blog) August 983090983093 98309098308810486251048627 httpsdiscipleallnationswordpresscom98309098308810486251048627983088983096983090983093the-top

-983090983088-countries-where-christianity-is-growing-the-astest

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3236

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048633

Muslim majority settings and so on We must cultivate a new glocal nar-

rativemdashone soaked in humility

Glocal theology must be humble theology Meek theology Receptive the-ology Discerning theology Prayerful theology Dialogical theology De-

pendent theology A theology that celebrates the interdependence between

the localparticular and the globaluniversal

983091 Glocal theology practices expansiveness Glocalization is by nature

comprehensive Local and global influences permeate much of our lives Tese

glocal forces shape our theologies and churches whether we like it or not

But intentionality is also important We need to commit to an expansiveapproach to glocal theology How do we deliberately cultivate glocal conver-

sations in our biblical interpretation Do we foster them in our under-

standing of the person and work of Christ How does glocalization shape

the way the Spirit empowers and constitutes the church How can it form

our understanding of the nature and mission of the rinity How does it

influence the way we practice fellowship and conversation across denomi-

national cultural ethnic economic sociocultural political gender andtheological divides How might it shape our theologies of mission com-

munity beauty spirituality suffering discipleship hospitality eco-justice

place education social ethics Christian leadership and so forth

983092 Glocal theology practices attention Glocal theology doesnrsquot need to

accept all the assumptions or assertions of postcolonial or Majority World

thought But it does need to engage with them and take them seriously

Postcolonial theology for instance gives the marginalized and colonized

and forgotten and silenced both dignity and voice Our glocal conversations

must also include and esteem these groups We need to be attentive to

others weak and powerful female and male dominant and downtrodden

old and young rich and poor privileged and marginalized influential and

subaltern educated and illiterate We need to practice the art of attention

being especially attentive to those who are different to us

983093 Glocal theology practices embrace What do colonial ethnocentric or

Western-centric perspectives do Tey silence Tey control Tey com-

modify Tey institutionalize Tey colonize Tey domesticate Tey replace

Tey import Tey exclude Tey do these things to the beliefs experiences

and practices of other cultures A worthwhile glocal theology refuses to do

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3336

10486281048624 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

these things Instead it adopts a responsive humble celebratory open in-

clusive and embracing attitude

983094 Glocal theology practices discernment Finally we need discernmentas we engage these ideas and practices Discernment is a huge topic thatrsquos

hard to cover comprehensively in a few words Discernment happens when

the Spirit of Christ and his Word renew our minds Te Spirit grants us

spiritual wisdom as we meditate on him and his Word and as we practice

discipleship to Jesus Christ Romans 10486251048626 provides guidance we need (1048625) to be

transformed by the renewal of our minds (1048626) to serve Christrsquos body and (1048627)

to put love into action Discernment also happens in conversation both lo-cally and glocally

I pray these core values and six practices come across in the following

chapters of GlobalChurch

Glocalization can never be just theoretical Are we committed to moving

glocalization from an abstract idea to a living communion Are we deter-

mined to construct a missional theology of the church in the context of

glocal conversations Tis must involve dialogue between Majority Worldindigenous and Western scholars activists and groups

Will glocalization be an abstract notion Or will it be a formative and

genuine communion between local regional and global voices Glocal dy-

namics are at play whether we like it or not Teyrsquore in our churches the-

ologies and missions But we can choose to relinquish isolationist colonial

parochial and arrogant approaches Instead we can adopt responsive dia-

logical learning humble and embracing postures

Trough healthy approaches to glocalization the Spirit challenges us to

value local contexts We immerse ourselves in local and particular commu-

nities and conversations He inspires us to open ourselves to global theo-

logical conversations He rouses us to value the symbiotic relationship be-

tween the localparticular and the globaluniversal

Trough glocal relationships the Spirit leads us to put local contextual

theologies into conversation with global ones He prompts us to explore the

ways in which the local is in the glocal and the global is in the local He per-

suades us to pursue collaboration and dialogue and mutual learning We

engage with Christians from different backgrounds and cultures ecumen-

icals Pentecostals evangelicals and so on from Western indigenous and

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3436

Glocalizing Conversations 10486281048625

Majority World contexts He motivates us to express solidarity between all

parties We appreciate our unity in diversity

Trough glocal conversations the Spirit moves us to ensure that unity andsolidarity emerge from a compelling vision of Jesusrsquo kingdom and gospel

and person He challenges us to share information theology and practices

He urges us to learn from each othermdashour successes and mistakes We seek

glocal solutions

Te Spirit calls us to develop glocal conversations about Christian ideas

and practices Tese include Scripture Evangelicalism ecumenism Pente-

costalism Jesus Christ the Holy Spirit God the Father the rinity com-munity spirituality discipleship liturgy worship hospitality prayer eco-

justice education social ethics Christian leadership gospel and culture

beauty place suffering liberation and so forth

Finally through glocal conversations the Spirit leads us to adopt a new

posture Tis is a responsive humble celebratory open inclusive and em-

bracing attitude to the ldquootherrdquo We do this as a new people made up of every

tribe and language and people and nationTere are dangers in glocalization Sugirtharajah warns of the commodi-

fication of local contextual practices and theologies When this happens

they are ldquosmoothed out of their primary contexts concerns and contesta-

tions travel across borders and become objects of analysis and scrutiny

within an alien secondary contextrdquo1048626983095

Itrsquos common for those of us who are Western to make mistakes when we

wrestle with Majority World and indigenous ideas Sugirtharajah mentions

our tendency to commodify reduce and institutionalize these ideas We also

risk doing these things (1048625) We apply them in noncontextual prescriptive ways

(1048626) We ignore their meanings in their original setting (1048627) We glamorize or

idealize their proponents or their contexts (1048628) We demonize those persons or

contexts (1048629) We disregard them as irrelevant rhetorical or minority discourse

Kevin J Vanhoozer says that we can fall into three traps when we glo-

calize theology (1048625) We can underestimate the theological significance of

local cultures (1048626) We can homogenize cultures and theologies exaggerating

27R S Sugirtharajah ldquoextual ake-Aways Tird World exts in Western Metropolitan Centresrdquo

Black Teology in Britain A Journal o Contextual Praxis 983090 (1048625983097983097983097) 10486271048627 10486271048631 Edward W Said Te

World the ext and the Critic (Cambridge MA Harvard University Press 10486259830979830961048627) 9830901048627983097

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3536

10486281048626 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

ldquothe onerdquo (1048627) We can overemphasize cultural particularity exaggerating ldquothe

manyrdquo and pursue ldquotheological ethnificationrdquo10486261048632

My hope is that GlobalChurch does not fall into the traps Sugirtharajahand Vanhoozer describe I hope that what unfolds in the following chapters

is respectful and discerning I hope it leads to further mutually enriching

conversations between people of different cultures

You the reader face the same challenges You face them in your personal

life ministry context and missional engagements

Will you treat the themes in this book as abstract theoretical notions

Will this be a temporary infatuation a flirtation with the ldquootherrdquo that dissi-pates as suddenly as it arrived Or will glocal conversations become an en-

riching and formative orientation in your life Will glocal conversations

bring fresh approaches to theology faith mission church and worship Will

conversations with other cultures and theologies become for you a com-

pelling way of life

My prayer is that glocal conversations will help the church be a global

visible alternative ldquocity set upon a hillrdquo a truly GlobalChurch

28Craig Ott and Harold A Netland Globalizing Teology Belie and Practice in an Era o World

Christianity (Grand Rapids Baker Academic 983090983088983088983094) 1048625983090983093

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3636

Page 3: GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 336

G L O B A L

C H U R C H

R E S H A P I N G O U R C O N V E R S A T I O N S

R E N E W I N G O U R M I S S I O N

R E V I T A L I Z I N G O U R C H U R C H E S

G R A H A M H I L LForeword by S C O M 983139 K N I G H

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 436

InterVarsity Press

PO Box 1048625104862810486241048624 Downers Grove IL 98309410486249830931048625983093-104862510486281048626983094

ivpresscom

emailivpresscom

copy104862610486241048625983094 by Graham Hill

All rights reserved No part of this book may be reproduced in any form without written permission from

InterVarsity Press

InterVarsity Pressreg is the book-publishing division of InterVarsity Christian FellowshipUSAreg a movement of

students and faculty active on campus at hundreds of universities colleges and schools of nursing in the United

States of America and a member movement of the International Fellowship of Evangelical Students For

information about local and regional activities visit intervarsityorg

All Scripture quotations unless otherwise indicated are taken from the Holy Bible odayrsquos New International

Versiontrade Copyright copy 1048626104862410486241048625 by International Bible Society All rights reserved

Cover design David Fassett

Interior design Beth McGill

Images orange water color square copy kentarcajuaniStockphoto

icons of Copenhagen Brussells Austria Israel Cuba Portugal Budapest Ireland Berlin and France

copy artefyiStockphoto

blue under water copy Achim PrilliStockphoto

ISBN 10486331048631983096-1048624-9830969830911048624983096-10486281048624983096983093-1048628 (print)

ISBN 10486331048631983096-1048624-9830969830911048624983096-104863310486331048624983091-983094 (digital)

Printed in the United States of America As a member of the Green Press Initiative InterVarsity Press is committed to protecting the environmentand to the responsible use of natural resources o learn more visit greenpressinitiativeorg

Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data

Hill Graham Reverend

GlobalChurch reshaping our conversations renewing our mission revitalizing our churches Graham Hill

foreword by Scot McKnight

pages cm

Includes index

ISBN 10486331048631983096-1048624-9830969830911048624983096-10486281048624983096983093-1048628 (casebound alk paper)

1048625 Church 1048626 GlobalizationmdashReligious aspectsmdashChristianity I itle II itle Global Church

BV98309410486241048624983091H9830931048628 104862610486241048625983093

10486269830941048633mdashdc1048626983091

104862610486241048625983093104862498309198309410486241048625983093

P 1048626983091 10486261048626 10486261048625 10486261048624 10486251048633 1048625983096 10486251048631 1048625983094 1048625983093 10486251048628 1048625983091 10486251048626 10486251048625 10486251048624 1048633 983096 1048631 983094 983093 1048628 983091 1048626 1048625

Y 983091983093 9830911048628 983091983091 9830911048626 9830911048625 9830911048624 10486261048633 1048626983096 10486261048631 1048626983094 1048626983093 10486261048628 1048626983091 10486261048626 10486261048625 10486261048624 10486251048633 1048625983096 10486251048631 1048625983094

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 536

C O N T E N T S

List of Figures and ables 983097

Foreword by Scot McKnight 983089983089

983089 Introduction Being Salt Light and a City 983089983091

Part 983089 Salt Reshaping Our Conversations

983090 Glocalizing Conversations 983090983091

Part 983090 Light Renewing Our Mission

983091 Contextualizing Mission 983092983093

983092 Liberating People 983094983097

983093 Showing Hospitality 983097983095

983094 Embracing the Spirit 983089983089983097

983095 Caring for Creation 983089983093983095

983096 Living Ethically 983089983096983091

983097 ransforming Neighborhoods 983090983089983093

Part 983091 City Revitalizing Our Churches

983089983088 Indigenizing Faith 983090983091983095

983089983089 Devouring Scripture 983090983095983093

983089983090 Renewing Education 983091983088983089

983089983091 Practicing Servantship 983091983091983095

983089983092 Recovering Community 983091983094983091

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 636

983089983093 Developing Spirituality and Discipleship 983091983096983091

983089983094 GlobalChurch Embracing a New Narrative 983092983089983093

Appendix 983089 GlobalChurch Project Video Series 983092983093983089

Appendix 983090 Study Guide 983092983093983091

Appendix 983091 Who Are hese Majority World

and Indigenous hinkers 983092983096983089

Appendix 983092 Resources and Glossary at

heGlobalChurchProjectcom 983092983097983091

Author Index 983092983097983093

Subject Index 983092983097983097

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 736

I N T R O D U C T I O N

B983141983145983150983143 S983137983148983156 L983145983143983144983156 983137983150983140 983137 C983145983156 983161

By 9830909830889830901048629 fully two-thirds of Christians will live in

Africa Latin America and Asia Te ldquoaverage

Christianrdquo today is female black and lives in a

Brazilian favela or an African village

SEPHE N BEVANS

Majority World and indigenous churches are redefining twenty-first-

century Christianity Western churches must decide how theyrsquoll respond

Stephen Bevans puts it well

We are now living in a ldquoworld churchrdquo where the vast majority of Christians are

[from the Majority World] David Barrettrsquos statistical studies have basically con-

firmed this shi and Philip Jenkins has predicted that by 1048626104862410486261048629 fully two-thirds

of Christians will live in Africa Latin America and Asia Scholars are fairly

unanimous in acknowledging the accuracy of the facts Te ldquoaverage Christianrdquo

today is female black and lives in a Brazilian favela or an African village983089

Some statistics illustrate this shi in twenty-first-century global Christi-

anity Te Pew Research Centerrsquos report Global Christianity analyzes the size

and distribution of the worldrsquos Christian population Te report maps the

changes over the last century (1048625104863310486251048624 to 1048626104862410486251048624) It concludes ldquoA century ago the

Global North (commonly defined as North America Europe Australia Japan

1Stephen B Bevans Roger Schroeder and L J Luzbetak ldquoMissiology Afer Bosch Reverencing a

Classic by Moving Beyondrdquo International Bulletin o Missionary Research 983090983097 no 983090 (983090983088983088983093) 983094983097

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 836

10486251048628 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

and New Zealand) contained more than four times as many Christians as the

Global South (the rest of the world) oday the Pew Forum study finds more

than 10486251048627 billion Christians live in the Global South [10486301048625983077 of all Christians livein Asia Africa and Latin America] compared with about 104863210486301048624 million in the

Global North (10486271048633983077)rdquo1048626 Tat is an astounding shi in only one hundred years983091

Using the World Christian Database Philip Jenkins offers table 10486251048625

ldquoChanging distribution of Christian believersrdquo

Table 983089983089 Changing distribution of Christian believers 983089983097983088983088 to 983090983088983093983088 (number of Christiansin millions)

983089983097983088983088 983089983097983095983088 983090983088983089983088 983090983088983093983088Africa 983089983088 983089983092983091 983092983097983091 983089983088983091983089

Asia 983090983090 983097983094 983091983093983090 983094983088983089

North America 983095983097 983090983089983089 983090983096983094 983091983091983091

Latin America 983094983090 983090983095983088 983093983092983092 983094983093983093

Europe 983091983096983089 983092983097983090 983093983096983096 983093983091983088

Oceania 983093 983089983096 983090983096 983091983096

Total 983093983093983096 983089983090983091983088 983090983090983097983089 983091983089983096983096

Source Philip Jenkins The Next Christendom The Coming of Global Christianity 983091rd ed (Oxford Oxford Uni-

versity Press 983090983088983089983089) 983091 Data is taken from World Christian Database wwwworldchristiandatabaseorgwcd

Christianity in North America Europe and Oceania grew from 104862810486301048629

million in 1048625104863310486241048624 to 104863310486241048626 million in 1048626104862410486251048624983092 Tis number is likely to shrink to

104863310486241048625 million by 1048626104862410486291048624

Christianity in Africa Asia and Latin America grew from 10486331048628 million in

1048625104863310486241048624 to 1048625104862710486321048633 billion in 1048626104862410486251048624 Tis number is likely to grow to 1048626104862610486321048631 billion by

1048626104862410486291048624

Letrsquos take China for example Professor Fenggang Yang of Purdue University

makes an important prediction If current rates of growth continue within one

generation China will have more Christians than any other nation on earth

In 1048625104863310486281048633 Protestant churches in China had one million members In 1048626104862410486251048624 that

number was 10486291048632 million (compare that with 10486281048624 million in Brazil and 10486271048630 million

2Pew Research Center Global Christianity A Report on the Size and Distribution o the Worldrsquos Chris-

tian Population December 1048625983097 98309098308810486251048625 wwwpeworumorg9830909830881048625104862510486259830901048625983097global-christianity-exec3See David B Barrett George Kurian and odd M Johnson World Christian Encyclopedia A

Comparative Survey o Churches and Religions in the Modern World 983090nd ed 983090 vols (New York

Oxord University Press 9830909830889830881048625) 1048625983090-1048625983093 and wwwglobalchristianityorg4Oceania includes Australia and Micronesian Melanesian and Polynesian countries

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 936

Introduction 10486251048629

in South Africa) By 1048626104862410486261048629 there are likely to be 104862510486301048624 million Christians in China

By 1048626104862410486271048624 this number is likely to be 104862610486281048631 million (outnumbering Christians in

Mexico Brazil and the United States) In an interview with the elegraphFenggang Yang says ldquoMao thought he could eliminate religion He thought he

had accomplished this Itrsquos ironicmdashthey didnrsquot Tey actually failed completelyrdquo1048629

Philip Jenkins concludes

We are currently living through one of the transforming moments in the

history of religion worldwide Over the last five centuries the story of Chris-

tianity has been inextricably bound up with that of Europe and European-

derived civilizations overseas above all in North America Until recently theoverwhelming majority of Christians have lived in white nations Over the

last century however the center of gravity in the Christian world has shied

inexorably away from Europe southward to Africa and Latin America and

eastward toward Asia oday the largest Christian communities on the planet

are to be found in those regions1048630

What does all this mean for the mission and theology and worship and

communities of the church worldwide And what does it mean particularlyfor the Western church

In Matthew 104862910486251048627-10486251048630 Jesus provides three remarkable images of the churchmdash

salt light and a city Jesus confronts his disciples with a missional description

of the church Te church in mission is the salt of the earth the light of the

world and a city set on a hill Te churchrsquos purpose is to let its ldquolight shine

before others that they may see your good deeds and glorify your Father in

heavenrdquo Te purpose of the churchrsquos missionary nature is the worship andglorification of the Father and Son and Holy Spirit983095

Te church is another city constituted by every tribe language people

5om Phillips ldquoChina on Course to Become lsquoWorldrsquos Most Christian Nationrsquo Within 1048625983093 Yearsrdquo

elegraph April 1048625983097 98309098308810486251048628 wwwtelegraphcouknewsworldnewsasiachina1048625983088104863110486319830949830889830901048627China-on

-course-to-become-worlds-most-Christian-nation-within-1048625983093-yearshtml See Fenggang Yang and

Joseph B amney eds Conucianism and Spiritual raditions in Modern China and Beyond Re-

ligion in Chinese Societies (Boston Brill 9830909830881048625983090) Fenggang Yang and Graeme Lang eds Social

Scientific Studies o Religion in China Methodology Teories and Findings (Leiden Brill 98309098308810486251048625)

Fenggang Yang Religion in China Survival and Revival Under Communist Rule (Oxord Oxord

University Press 9830909830881048625983090)6Philip Jenkins Te Next Christendom Te Coming o Global Christianity 1048627rd ed (Oxord Ox-

ord University Press 98309098308810486251048625) 10486257J Driver Images o the Church in Mission (Scottdale PA Herald 10486259830979830971048631) 10486251048631983088-9830961048625 Graham Hill Salt

Light and a City Introducing Missional Ecclesiology (Eugene OR Wip and Stock 9830909830881048625983090) xiii

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1036

10486251048630 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

and nation Te church must cultivate a distinct social existence shaping its

community and mission around its commitment to plurality and diversity

and unity1048632 God calls his church to be a global and missional ldquocity on a hillrdquoTis is a church constituted and enriched and represented by Western and

indigenous and Majority World peoples

Tose of us in the West need a new narrative Itrsquos time to abandon our

flawed Eurocentric and Americentric worldviews We need a new global

and missional narrative and for that we must turn to the churches of Ma-

jority World and indigenous cultures Tey can help us explore what it

means to be a global missional community Many Christian communitiesin Majority World and indigenous contexts have been wrestling with these

issues for generations Marginalization and persecution and alienation have

been their lot Yet somehow in spite of or because of that they have flour-

ished In fact theyrsquove grown exponentially

So whom am I talking about when I refer to Majority World and indig-

enous Christians Majority World Christians are those in Africa Asia the

Caribbean Eastern Europe Latin America the Middle East and Oceania

1048633

I use the term Majority World because the majority of the worldrsquos population

is in those cultures today Te majority of the church is in those cultures too

I donrsquot use the terms non-Western or Tird World or Developing World Tese

terms use Western cultures as their point of reference Tey imply Western

8Barry A Harvey Another City An Ecclesiological Primer or a Post-Christian World (New York

rinity 1048625983097983097983097) 9830901048627-9830909830939I donrsquot deal with the diasporas in this book For example Irsquove made no mention o Hispanic

Portuguese or Asian minorities in the United States United Kingdom Canada Europe Austra-lia and so on Irsquom aware that right now Latin American and Chinese diasporas are active in

evangelism and mission in Europe in the same way in which the Filipino or the Salvadoran dias-

poras carry on mission in the United States Irsquove chosen not to include voices rom the diasporas

mainly because there are so many worthy contributors in that group and I donrsquot have the space

to treat them well in this book In the uture I hope that I (or someone else) will write a book

exploring what we can learn rom the diasporas Hispanic minorities or example are making

significant contributions to the theological and missiological conversation in the United States

that are relevant to this subject Methodist historian Justo L Gonzaacutelez and Pentecostal theologian

Eldin Villaantildee are examples In Mantildeana Gonzaacutelez describes the shape and orm o a theology

developed in the Hispanic margin o the United States In Out o Every ribe and Nation he shows

what would be implied in listening to minorities within a denominational setting Villaantildeersquos Te

Liberating Spirit is a milestone in the reflection about the relationship between pneumatology and

social ethics See Justo L Gonzaacutelez Out o Every ribe and Nation Christian Teology at the

Ethnic Roundtable (Nashville Abingdon 1048625983097983097983090) Gonzaacutelez Mantildeana Christian Teology rom a

Hispanic Perspective (Nashville Abingdon 1048625983097983097983088) Eldin Villaantildee Te Liberating Spirit oward

an Hispanic American Pentecostal Social Ethic (Grand Rapids Eerdmans 10486259830979830971048627)

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1136

Introduction 10486251048631

superiority or centricity Te term Global South is too limiting given the

breadth of the group I am engaging Majority World seems to work best

In 1048626104862410486241048628 Te Lausanne Forum for World Evangelization in PattayaTailand voted unanimously that the phrase Majority World Church replace

other terms People from all over the globe participated in this forum

imothy C ennent agrees that this is the best phrase ldquoIt helps to highlight

the basic point that Africa Asia and Latin America are where the majority

of the worldrsquos Christians are now locatedrdquo9830891048624 I expand the phrase Majority

World beyond Africa Asia and Latin America to include the Caribbean

Eastern Europe Oceania and the Middle EastIndigenous and First Nations peoples are ldquothose ethnic groups that were

indigenous to a territory prior to being incorporated into a national state

and who are politically and culturally separate from the majority ethnic

identity of the state that they are a part ofrdquo Tis includes people groups like

the Australian Aborigines and American Indians983089983089

Te aim of this book is to help Western churches rediscover what it means

to be salt light and a city by engaging in global missional conversations odo this Western Christians need to enter into conversation with Majority

World and indigenous Christians Listening to others helps us grow in our

understanding and practice of mission and church and theology For far too

long wersquove marginalized or ignored Majority World and indigenous voices

We must truly become a GlobalChurch

Tis aim shapes the bookrsquos structure as summarized below

P983137983154983156 1048625 S983137983148983156 R983141983155983144983137983152983145983150983143 O983157983154 C983151983150983158983141983154983155983137983156983145983151983150983155

ldquoYou are the salt of the earth But if the salt loses its saltiness how can it be made

salty again It is no longer good for anything except to be thrown out and

trampled underfootrdquo Globally and locally you are the salt of the earth Be salt

Salt preserves seasons flavors and purifies We are salt when we glorify

the Father Son and Holy Spirit in our mission worship faith hope truth

and love We are salt when we reject a Eurocentric or Americentric vision

10imothy C ennent Teology in the Context o World Christianity How the Global Church Is

Influencing the Way We Tink About and Discuss Teology (Grand Rapids Zondervan 9830909830889830881048631) xx11Douglas Sanders ldquoIndigenous Peoples Issues o Definitionrdquo International Journal o Cultural

Property 983096 no 1048625 (1048625983097983097983097) 1048628

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1236

10486251048632 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

of the church and become the global missional church Christ envisioned

In part one I show how Western conversations are impoverished and

insufficient in isolation from indigenous and Majority World Christians Weenhance our ldquosaltinessrdquo through local-global ( glocal ) exchanges o do this

we must reshape our conversations We need global and local exchanges that

we characterize by mutuality respect partnership and symbiosis Such ex-

changes help us learn from each other whether wersquore in Western indig-

enous or Majority World settings It helps us stay ldquosaltyrdquo It enables us to

pursue global missional theology and practice Globally and locally we can

pursue missional vitality and truly be ldquothe salt of the earthrdquo

P983137983154983156 1048626 L983145983143983144983156 R983141983150983141983159983145983150983143 O983157983154 M983145983155983155983145983151983150

ldquoYou are the light of the world A city on a hill cannot be hidden Neither do

people light a lamp and put it under a bowl Instead they put it on its stand and

it gives light to everyone in the house In the same way let your light shine

before others that they may see your good deeds and glorify your Father in

heavenrdquo (Mt 104862910486251048628-10486251048631) Globally and locally you are the light of the world Be lightLight illuminates reveals and dispels darkness Te church is light when

it does good deedsmdashhealing and liberating and redemptive deeds Itrsquos light

when its being and faith and deeds bring glorify to the Father Te church

is light when it participates in Godrsquos redemptive mission in the world as a

global missional community

o do this we must renew our mission In part two I explore how indig-

enous and Majority World Christians teach us to renew mission We renew

mission through contextualization liberation hospitality Spirit empow-

erment creation care ethics and the transformation of neighborhoods

P983137983154983156 1048627 C983145983156983161 R983141983158983145983156983137983148983145983162983145983150983143 O983157983154 C983144983157983154983139983144983141983155

You are a city set on a hill ldquoA city on a hill cannot be hiddenrdquo Globally and

locally you are a city set on a hill Be a city set on a hill

Tis means that we are an alternative and countercultural movement We

have a distinct culture and politic and social existence We are a people

gathered from every tribe language people and nation We are in the world

but not of the world We are in the world but distinct from the world We are

within the world and for the sake of the world

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1336

Introduction 10486251048633

o be this kind of alternative city or culture we must renew our mission

community ethics and worship We need to pursue the revitalization of our

churches so that they are distinct And by distinct I mean an alternative city(altera civitas)

We are a ldquocity on a hillrdquo that witnesses to Jesus Christ and his eternal kingdom

when we are a global missional church In part three I demonstrate how indig-

enous and Majority World Christians teach us to revitalize churches We revi-

talize churches by indigenizing faith devouring Scripture renewing education

practicing servantship (servant leadership) recovering community and devel-

oping spirituality and discipleship We inspire our churches when we developour theology and practices relating to beauty and the arts9830891048626

In the final chapter I wrap things up by addressing an important question

In light of all the material covered in this book what would it now look like

to engage in global missional theology ecclesiology interpretation history

pneumatology worship and education

Herersquos how you can get the most out of this book

Community You can read this book alone in a small group with somefriends at home or at a coffee shop or as part of a ministry team However

you get a lot more out of this book when you read it with others ogether

you can think about the bookrsquos implications What do the chapters mean for

your ministry church agency family or team

GlobalChurch Project video series Irsquove made a video series to go along with

this book Appendix one has the details

Study guide Yoursquoll get a lot more out of this book if you spend time

working through the study guide in appendix two ry to do this in a group

Te study guide includes reflection questions suggested practices and

Further Reading

Characters As you read this book yoursquoll come across names and people

yoursquove never heard of before For a glimpse of who they are and what issues

concern them see appendix three

My website o help you get the most out of this book Irsquove included more

resources on my website TeGlobalChurchProjectcom Tese include

videos reading lists important links a glossary and other resources Irsquove

12Irsquove put a separate chapter on the theme o beauty and the arts on my website Itrsquos additional to

this book

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1436

10486261048624 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

also provided ways that you can contact me See appendix four

In my first book Salt Light and a City I developed a missional theology

of the church I did this in conversation with twelve theologians from the fourmajor Christian traditions Tat volume offered a window into the thought of

European and American theologians It showed how they are making sense

of the nature and mission of the church in their Western cultural context

Te book that yoursquore now reading takes a different approach I have

stepped away from European and American voices I now ask What can

those in the Majority World and indigenous cultures teach us in the West

What can they teach us about the churchrsquos mission worship theology andcommunity Te quality and quantity of material coming out of the Ma-

jority World is astonishing Any theology that ignores the insights of indig-

enous and Majority World Christians is deficient and impoverished

White middle-class European North American tertiary-educated men

dominate Western theology Tey dominate the Western missional conver-

sation I know I fit that profile Tis group still monopolizes missional church

conferences and seminars Tey get all the book contracts In fact this groupstill controls theology and the church in many settings But this is changing

New voices are rising Tese include women minorities the poor indigenous

groups and Majority World leaders Missional conversations arenrsquot attentive

to the Spirit and to Godrsquos mission if they ignore these voices Majority World

and indigenous churches oen have extraordinary missional vitality Openness

to other voices needs to happen now It is time for Western churches theol-

ogies and mission to mature and to reflect Godrsquos global mission

In this book I could have consulted the work of many thousands of in-

digenous and Majority World thinkers and writers and practitioners But I

have limited myself to a sample of those who speak directly to its themes

Tese African Asian Eastern European Middle Eastern Caribbean Latin

American First Nation and indigenous thinkers challenge us Tey dare us

to examine our theologies and missions and churches And they inspire us

to renew the worship and community and mission of Jesusrsquo church Tey

stir us to think in fresh ways about what it means to be salt light and a city

Tey help us become a global missional churchmdasha truly GlobalChurch

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1536

PA R T O N E

S A L TReshaping Our Conversations

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1636

G L O C A L I Z I N G

C O N V E R S A T I O N S

H983151983159 D983151 W983141 D983141983158983141983148983151983152

G983148983151983139983137983148 C983151983150983158983141983154983155983137983156983145983151983150983155983103

Rather than taking one contextual version of the Gospel and imposing

it as the Gospel throughout the world via the missionary enterprise

the shapers of Mission as ransformation have recognized the

plurality of localities that has created an intercontextual

ldquopan-localrdquo global phenomenon in theology

AL IZON

The International Society for Urban Mission (ISUM) is a group of urban

missionaries who are passionate about cultivating hope and love and re-newal in cities Irsquove connected with this group for some years ISUM held its

first annual Summit on Integral Urban Mission in Bangkok Tailand Te

team from Urban Neighbours of Hope (UNOH) under the leadership of

my Australian friends Ash and Anj Barker organized much of the summit

UNOH teams covenant with God and each other to ldquolive out our passion for

loving God and neighbour Focus on releasing neighbourhoods from urban

poverty Grow through equipping each other neighbours and the broader

church to radically follow Jesus and join Godrsquos Kingdom coming UNOH

workers live and serve in small responsive neighbourhood-based teamsrdquo983089

1See wwwunohorg

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1736

10486261048628 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

Tis summit involved interactive participatory hands-on immersion op-

portunities keynotes lectures and workshops Keynote speakers came from

Africa Australia Myanmar New Zealand North America the PhilippinesSouth America Tailand and First Nations A few hundred Majority World

and Western thinkers and activists came together for those days Tey explored

the theology and practices of integral transformational and urban mission

Tese thinkers and activists pursued a range of aims1048626 Tis included col-

laboration between urban Christians from a variety of backgrounds (Ma-

jority World and Western theologians activists ecumenicals Pentecostals

evangelicals colleges church movements and development agencies) Teyaimed for collective action and thought in an international and integral

context Tey sought to gain mutual understanding for a comprehensive

picture of urban mission around the globe Tey encouraged information

sharing and best practicesmdashlearning from our mistakes and seeking solu-

tions Tey developed recommendations and calls to action to the broader

church Working groups wrote briefing papers aer each summit based on

key issues in urban mission And they endeavored to build trust wisdomand inspiration to better engage our new urban world

Majority World and Western leaders participated in discussion prayer

integral mission and working groups Te goal was to grapple with key issues

and ask key questions How do we recruit equip and sustain urban mission

today How do we release church movements among the urban poor How

can we immerse ourselves in and transform urban neighborhoods How do

we empower urban children and young people How does the church serve

and liberate the oppressedmdashand others suffering from urban injustice What

needs to happen for poorer urban centers to develop economically socially

and spiritually How do we join God in the challenges and opportunities of

multifaith cities

Workshops included urban gardening child protection and collaborating

with local churches in urban mission Workshops also included organic

church growth and mission as well as developing NGO and government

partnerships Groups considered the good the bad and the ugly of short-

term urban mission teams

2Tese aims are detailed at ldquoInternational Society or Urban Mission Summitrdquo httpnewurbanworld

orgsummit

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1836

Glocalizing Conversations 10486261048629

Te summit was a thrilling example of how Majority World and Western

leaders can cooperate It was a time to come together in an environment of

mutual learning and enrichment It was a window into how local contextsand global themes can enrich each other Tis resulted from ISUMrsquos com-

mitment to ldquosolidarity fellowship and insight between urban Christian

leaders in the Western and Majority Worldsrdquo

Te summit was a success due to ISUMrsquos core values What are they983091 Christ-

honoring urban mission values bottom-up grassroots perspectivesmdashrather

than top-down distanced perspectives It allows local theology to reveal new

insights and perspectives about Godrsquos activity It shares insights and experi-ences through narratives embedded within urban poor communities and cities

It cultivates ongoing practical and personal solidarity with the worldrsquos urban

poor Tis Spirit-empowered urban mission honors networks relationships

and partnerships It sees such relationships as the primary method of serving

together It listens to and amplifies the voices of the urban poormdashespecially

those from the Majority World and in particular the 1048625104862410486281048624 window cities It is

attentive to signs of the kingdom of God Urban mission that glorifies God iswilling to reflect and respond with active and sacrificial commitment It shares

and extends the life of the body of Christ among the urban poor

Tis summit was a milestone in urban missiology It enriched communi-

cation between Western and Majority World thinker-activists Tis resulted

from the aims and values Irsquove mentioned Effective urban mission needs to

be a conversation on many levels It is attentive to context and immersed in

local settings It appreciates global and universal missional themes It culti-

vates dialogue between these local-global (glocal) realities It involves

mutual learning between Western and Majority World thinker-activists

Moreover solidarity between all parties is a defining feature Tis solidarity

is due to a compelling vision of the kingdom of God

Tese collaborative glocal features of the ISUM urban mission summit

in Bangkok are critical for the aims of this book GlobalChurch

Majority World indigenous and Western leaders thinkers and churches

can stretch and enrich each other But they need to be open and attentive to

each other Tey need learning postures and open hearts and minds Tey

3ldquoAbout ISUMrdquo httpnewurbanworldorgabout

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1936

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2036

Glocalizing Conversations 10486261048631

always rooted in the local and particularmdashas local churches embody the

gospel and witness to Christ Tese churches forge their own theological

understandings as they do mission together Tey engage in transformationalpractices among the people in their settings Tey enjoy worship mission

and community in their local and particular context Ideally the result is

unique contextual theologies and missions

Simultaneously global conversations form Tey form because of this

multitude of local theologies and practices Local conversations inform and

enrich other local conversations catalyzing global themes and voices izon

observes that the global ldquoowes its existence to local contexts Sharedconvictions among the theologies and practices of local contextual realities

give shape to its global dimensionsrdquo1048629

Majority World indigenous and Western theologies are equally contextual

Tey are equally culture bound Tey are equally particular to their time and

location At times they are all enlightened or myopic liberating or con-

straining humanizing or objectifying beautiful or offensive prophetic or

tepid Te local particular and cultural shape all these theologies Converselythese particular theologies feed and influence global conversations Tere is

no place then for ethnocentrism colonialism or elitism Tere is no place

for theological missional cultural or institutionalized arrogance

Multiple local contexts and voices come togethermdashintentionally or notmdashto

form global themes and theologies Conversely these global realities shape

local contexts oday local contexts must grapple with ldquoan emerging global

culture ie the interacting realities of modernity postmodernity and the

phenomenon of globalizationrdquo1048630 Hence the interdependent and symbiotic

relationship between the localparticular and the globaluniversal We call this

interdependent relationship between the local and the global glocalization

Te global church needs a thrilling glocal exchange We need one that we

characterize by mutuality respect partnership and symbiosis Such ex-

change helps Majority World indigenous and Western churches learn from

each other It enables them to pursue missional theology and practice o-

gether the church becomes a ldquocity on a hillrdquo

5Ibid 10486259830886Ibid 9830961048628

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2136

10486261048632 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

W983144983137983156 R983141983153983157983145983154983141983155 G983148983151983139983137983148983145983162983137983156983145983151983150983103

Te glocal exchange described above needs to be broader than transforma-

tional mission Tis is necessary if the church is to develop a robust inter-cultural and glocal missional ecclesiology

In my first book Salt Light and a City I outlined the foundational

themes of missional ecclesiology983095 Majority World and Western leaders

need to engage these themes in local and contextual ways Teir insights can

then enrich global conversations Tese global conversations in turn shape

local understandings and practices Tis way a glocal appreciation of these

themes emergesLocal regional and global theologies and practices are thereby enriched

Te church becomes healthier and more missionalmdasha truer expression of

the kingdom Te church becomes a fuller witness to Christ his passion for

the nations and his ability to bring unity in diversity

Stephen Bevans and Roger Schroeder outline the six constants of mission

Tese are our theologies about Jesus the church the end times salvation

human nature and culture Bevans and Schroeder describe the relationshipbetween these six and their historical cultural and theological contexts Tis is

why they call these six constants in context Our understanding of these six

constants develops in relation to local and global movements Sometimes local

voices influence our understandings of these six Other times it is regional or

global voices For all of us local regional and global influences are at play at

once Collectively they form our appreciation of the six constants of mission1048632

Here are eight theological themes that the church can develop through

processes of glocalization I presented these in my book Salt Light and a City

Tey are vital to the churchrsquos health mission community and future We

could add many other themes to these eight but these will suffice for now1048633

Scripture Te Scriptures are the infallible authoritative Word of God

Christrsquos Spirit has inspired them Tey have absolute and final authority in

all aspects of corporate and individual faith ethics conduct and witness

Christians interpret and apply Scripture in local contexts and in particular

7Graham Hill Salt Light and a City Introducing Missional Ecclesiology (Eugene OR Wip and

Stock 9830909830881048625983090) 10486251048628983097-983090104863110486288Stephen B Bevans and Roger Schroeder Constants in Context A Teology o Mission or oday

American Society o Missiology Series (Maryknoll NY Orbis 9830909830889830881048628) part one9Tese points first appeared in my book Salt Light and a City xxii-xxiv

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2236

Glocalizing Conversations 10486261048633

social settings Conversely we learn from the interpretations and readings

of other groups

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our local- global theology of Scripture and biblical interpretation

Evangelicalism Pentecostalism missional movements and so forth I

have charismatic missional and evangelical convictions Glocal conversa-

tions help me understand and practice these convictions better

I will use evangelicalism as an example Michael Horton says that our

beliefs and practices are evangelical when they are ldquocommitted to the suffi-

ciency of Scripture the priesthood of all believers the total lostness ofhumans the sole mediation of Christ the gracious efficacy and finality of

Godrsquos redemptive work in Christ through election propitiation calling and

keeping Te linchpin for all of this was the doctrine of justification by grace

alone through faith alone because of Christ alonerdquo9830891048624

Such convictions are necessary if we are to be faithful to the gospel and

to a biblical vision of church and mission Te gospel defines Godrsquos purposes

for humanity the church and the universe Te triune God controls thechurch He is its Lord and Savior Sanctifier and Liberator Master and King

He is completely sovereign over its nature affairs mission and history God

is the churchrsquos only source of grace election atonement salvation and per-

severance Te churchrsquos justification and hope are by grace alone through

faith alone by Christ alone

Herersquos the challenge I face My understanding of evangelicalism is

Western I am a product of the Western theological tradition and my Western

evangelical heritage Much of this is wonderful But I need indigenous and

Majority World evangelicals and others to help me expand and reshape

these insights Te same would be true if I were a Pentecostal

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of our theological traditions and convictions

Jesus Christ We must center our theology on Jesus Christ the Lord of

the church Te church needs to reflect on the person and work of Christ

and respond to him Tis means gathering and going in the name and power

of Christ It means allowing Christrsquos Spirit to shape our community and

10Michael Horton ldquoEvangelical Arminiansrdquo Modern Reormation 1048625 no 1048627 (1048625983097983097983090) 10486251048631

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2336

10486271048624 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

identity and mission It means developing our Christology ecclesiology and

missiology concurrently Te early church developed these three areas and

more in a concurrent and integrated way Tere was no linear progressionTe same is true in the contemporary global church

How can the glocal church best explore its nature structure mission and

hope Trough the centrality and the lordship of Christ

Majority World and indigenous Christians help us appreciate Jesus and

his mission afresh Tey show us how Jesus identifies with the marginalized

outcast oppressed rejected and broken He prefers them We find him

among ldquothe least of theserdquoGlocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of who Jesus Christ is How does it help us appreciate him better

What has Jesus done for and in his church and his world What does he care

about What individual and corporate responsibilities has he given us How

do we express these at local regional and global levels

Te Spirit Missional ecclesiology is inadequate without pneumatological

foundations In other words our theology of church and Spirit go togetherTe Spirit creates and animates the church He empowers it to witness to

Jesus and his gospel Te Spirit enables the church to be a missional trans-

formational community He shapes the church into an alternative society

embodying the reign of God Te church exists for the glory and mission of

Christ Te power and presence of the Spirit enables this mission worship

and glorification

Te Spirit pours out gis on the local-global church ldquofor the common

goodrdquo and ldquoto equip his people for works of service so that the body of Christ

may be built uprdquo Tis includes but isnrsquot limited to the ministry gis mani-

festation gis and motivational gis (1048625 Cor 104862510486261048631 Eph 104862810486251048625-10486251048626 Rom 104862510486261048630-1048632)

Te Spirit forms the glocal church He empowers it for service and

witness He fills it with Christrsquos empowering presence He leads it into the

missio Deimdashthe mission of the Father Son and Holy Spirit

Recently Pentecostal and renewalist movements have grown dramati-

cally in the Majority World Tey have increased in status size and influence

Many have matured theologically Te churches of the West must take notice

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of the power and presence of the Spirit

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2436

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048625

Te rinity Tere are clear limitations to the analogy between the

church and the rinity Te church can only image the rinity Yet the

church is at its best when it reflects the relational and missional passionof the rinity

What is the source and inspiration of the churchrsquos local-global mission

Ultimately it is the missional nature passion and actions of the Father Son

and Holy Spirit Godrsquos nature is missional His passion is infectious His

actions are historical redemptive and eternal Te rinity invites the

church into a sending community Te Father sends the Son Te Father

and Son send the Spirit Finally the rinity sends the church in missioninto the world

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of the rinity How does it enable our participation in the mission

and community of the triune God

Association and dialogue Tese need to happen across denominational

cultural ethnic gender and theological traditions and divides Authentic

dialogue is indispensable to the health and mission of the church What dothose marginal to the life of the church have to say to us What do ldquoothersrdquo

have to teach us Other ethnicities and cultures Other socioeconomic

groups Other ages and genders Other theological and confessing tradi-

tions Other persons from times long gone

We need to listen Share Be vulnerable Be authentic Open up to crit-

icism correction and change

We need more than dialogue We need communion and association It is

possible in a qualified way to say that God is present in all the various forms

of the church (ie the various theological ecclesiological sociocultural his-

torical and other permutations of the church) We discern this presence

through attention to Scripture history tradition culture and the Spirit Dis-

cernment involves critical dialogue theological exchange biblical study and

real relationship Only the Spirit of Jesus can enable this

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of association and dialogue

Mission and the missio Dei Te church is missional at its core It serves

obeys and images a missionary God David Bosch says ldquoTe churchrsquos mission

is not secondary to its being the church exists in being sent and in building up

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2536

10486271048626 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

itself for its missionrdquo He goes on to say ldquoEcclesiology does not precede missi-

ology there cannot be church without an intrinsic missionary dimensionrdquo983089983089

Jesus is Lord Lord of his church and Lord of his world His mission de-termines and forms the church His mission shapes the nature purposes

structures ministries and activities of his church Majority World and in-

digenous thinkers help us understand the implications of this mission Tey

help us form glocal theologies of mission Tey reveal ldquomission in context

as transformationrdquo9830891048626

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of mission and the missio Dei Church theology and practice Glocal conversations can inform and

enrich many aspects of the church (when practiced well) Teologies and

practices benefit from robust and critical glocal conversations Tese con-

versations enrich many areas (community spirituality discipleship liturgy

worship hospitality eco-justice education social ethics servantship lib-

eration place suffering beauty and so on)

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-standing of these many dimensions of church and mission

Glocal processes shape these eight themes and their practices We need

to facilitate and enable these conversations and processes Tis is urgent It

must be a priority No theology of mission or missional ecclesiology is ad-

equate without glocal conversations983089983091

T983144983141 L983151983139983137983148 983137983150983140 G983148983151983138983137983148 E983150983154983145983139983144 E983137983139983144 O983156983144983141983154

Glocalization takes the localparticular context and globaluniversal themes

seriously Contextual and global conversations enter an enriching and in-

forming relationship Tese two always have an active and symbiotic rela-

tionship Tis is true whether we deliberately put them into conversation or

not Te local shapes the global and the global shapes the local Many local

11David J Bosch Believing in the Future oward a Missiology o Western Culture (New York

rinity 1048625983097983097983093) 104862798309012izon ransormation Afer Lausanne 1048631-98309713Not all o these themes are dealt with in this present volume since either (1048625) I have dealt with them

in my book Salt Light and a City (983090) they are not all key themes in the writings o the thirty-five

Majority World thinkers considered in this volume or (1048627) there is not adequate space in a book

this size

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2636

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048627

voices converge to form global conversations and theologies Using the Phil-

ippines as a case study izon illustrates this by showing the interdepen-

dence between local and global themes in mission983089983092Dialogue between local and global conversations is critical Kōsuke

Koyama wrote an important book on contextual mission called Water Buffalo

Teology Koyama is a Japanese missionary who served in Chiang Mai

Tailand He writes of the joys and challenges of doing local particular water

buffalo theology He considers the relationship between local theology global

missional themes and transforming cultures ldquoWater Buffalo Teology sees

certain specific challenges Contextualization of theology implies two criticalmovements First to articulate Jesus Christ in culturally appropriate com-

municatively apt words and second to criticize reform dethrone or oppose

culture if it is found to be against what the name of Jesus Christ stands forrdquo9830891048629

Kōsuke Koyama challenges us to recognize what we bring to the task of

local theology For him it was doing theology in Tailand while being Jap-

anese We also need to notice the particular culture wersquore located in as we do

the work of theology Tis means we avoid speaking of an ldquoAsian theologyrdquoldquoAfrican theologyrdquo and the like We need to cultivate local theologies that

engage regional and global themes But these theologies must be ldquodistinctly

localrdquo and a ldquotheology from belowrdquo9830891048630

Simultaneously we need to pursue a reformation of theology and

practice ldquoin the global contextrdquo Tis means entering ldquothe disturbing spa-

ciousness of Jesus Christrdquo Jesus calls us to reject enmity and exceptionalism

We seem him present in our culture language stories and relationships

But we also choose to embrace the ldquootherrdquo We choose to see him present

in other culturesmdashshaping a global people to serve and worship him

joining in his mission983089983095

Kōsuke Koyama roots the gospel in the local contextual and particular

Tis is why he roots his water buffalo theology in Northern Tai culture He

is careful not to say ldquoHere is how you contextualize in your settingrdquo Instead

14izon ransormation Afer Lausanne 1048631-10486251048627 10486251048628983097-98309098308898309015Kōsuke Koyama Water Buffalo Teology 983090983093th anniversary ed (Maryknoll NY Orbis 1048625983097983097983097)

xiii-xv16Kōsuke Koyama ldquoTe Asian Approach to Christrdquo Missiology 1048625983090 no 1048628 (10486259830979830961048628) 10486281048627983093-104862798309617Kōsuke Koyama ldquoReormation in the Global Context Te Disturbing Spaciousness o Jesus Christrdquo

Currents in Teology and Mission 1048627983088 no 983090 (9830909830889830881048627) 10486251048625983097-983090983096

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2736

10486271048628 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

he tells us a story Itrsquos the story of how he contextualized theology in northern

Tailand while being open to global conversations Koyama asks us to form

our own local expressions of church mission and theology At the same timewe must stay attentive to what God is saying and doing beyond that context

Tis way local and global and particular and universal become mutually

enriching conversation partners

G983148983151983139983137983148983145983162983137983156983145983151983150 983137983150983140 H983145983155983156983151983154983145983139983137983148983148983161 S983145983148983141983150983139983141983140 V983151983145983139983141983155

Glocal theologies and conversations pay attention to voices that powers in-

stitutions religions and societies have silenced R S Sugirtharajah pushesback a little on izonrsquos ideas Sugirtharajah says that the church should

privilege local conversations He emphasizes the local contextual and post-

colonial reading of biblical texts9830891048632

Te church needs to listen Te church ought to be attentive to the

theologies and biblical interpretations of groups that cultures and reli-

gions have ignored Historically powerful secular and religious forces

have silenced these groups Tey have marginalized oppressed and colo-nized them It is time for the church to address this injustice We must

start listening to important but silenced voices We need to privilege the

voices of the former victims of Western colonialism We need to develop

postcolonial biblical interpretations theologies and expressions of church

and mission

How do we take such perspectives seriously as we develop glocal conver-

sations How do these themes help us foster vital relationships between local

and global voices

It is time for us to embrace values that enable conversations with those

oen ignored by the church We need values that help us learn from these

groups and individuals

Valuing equal partnership Colonizing powers oppressed silenced and

colonized certain groups At times the church was complicit Tese colo-

nized groups have become ldquoconfident indomitable and indispensable

partners in the dialogue and collaboration with the dispossessed and disad-

18R S Sugirtharajah Asian Biblical Hermeneutics and Postcolonialism Contesting the Interpreta-

tions Te Bible and Liberation Series (Maryknoll NY Orbis 1048625983097983097983096) 1048625983093-1048625983094

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2836

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048629

vantaged in the Westrdquo9830891048633 Tis calls for attentiveness to these voices and re-

sponsiveness to their prophetic challenges It also demands a critical evalu-

ation of colonial readings of Scripture Colonial models of theology andchurch and mission are no longer the benchmark Te global church must

examine them afresh

Valuing equal status Tose on the margins have now taken their rightful

place on the global stage Tey have claimed appropriate and equal status at

the table Subaltern readings of theology church and mission are invaluable

contributors to global theological conversations Tis means that we esteem

them But we also test themWhat do we mean by subaltern Subalterns are those who are down-

trodden and silenced (or have been treated this way in the past) Dominant

or colonizing groups treat them as invisible nonentities Tey enjoy limited

or no access to power Sometimes these are women certain tribal and ethnic

groups and those considered ldquountouchablerdquo In Voices from the Margin Su-

girtharajah provides a platform for postcolonial subaltern readings of

Scripture and theology Tese readings challenge colonialmdashoen Westernmdashreadings of Bible and theology and cultures Tey claim equal status with

other ways of doing theology10486261048624

Valuing equal identity People groups need freedom to explore their new

and emerging identities Tese emerge in response to local and global influ-

ences Local culture is not the only thing at work here Global forces also

shape identity as do imported practices ideas readings rituals and tech-

nologies But each group should be free to explore and construct their par-

ticular forms of Christian identity

Valuing equal interpretations ldquoPostcolonialism is concerned with the

question of cultural and discursive dominationrdquo Colonialism led to op-

pressive and controlling forms of culture and discourse Tese were usually

not contextual or indigenous Western powers for instance brought co-

lonial forms of theology church biblical interpretation and mission1048626983089

Postcolonialism calls for alternative ways of approaching these things Tose

19Ibid 104862598309420R S Sugirtharajah Voices rom the Margin Interpreting the Bible in the Tird World (Maryknoll

NY Orbis 10486259830979830971048625)21Sugirtharajah Asian Biblical Hermeneutics and Postcolonialism 10486251048631

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2936

10486271048630 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

who were once marginalized oppressed and silenced need to lead these fresh

approaches in their own settings Tese then influence global conversations

We need to support the new readings and insights and experiments from thesegroups o be genuine this support must be both critical and collegial

Valuing equal empowerment Sugirtharajah says that postcolonialism is

valuable when it empowers actual communities and real people Post-

colonial thought empowers when it addresses the difficulties hopes and

experiences of ordinary people It should never be about power plays and

the clever use of language Itrsquos pointless if itrsquos obsessed with forming newmdash

and ldquocolonizingrdquomdashtheories Itrsquos a waste of time if itrsquos a self-indulgent pursuitof new and hybrid identities Rather ldquothe worth and credibility of post-

colonial criticism will be judged by how it orchestrates the unique and

fragile and imagined claims of one community against anotherrdquo Empow-

erment happens in a variety of ways One way is contributing equally to

global conversations10486261048626

Al izon examines postcolonialism in the Philippines He says that it can

teach the global church a lot about healthy local-global conversations Fil-ipino contextual theology resists many Western forms of mission and the-

ology It finds them patronizing and controlling Tis indigenous theology

values prophetic sociopolitical engagement in institutions and the society

at large It emphasizes ministry to whole persons and communities It con-

structs a Filipino theology of beauty and mission and worship and com-

munity And it fosters indigenous theological approaches to the spirit world

and cosmology

izon says that postcolonial theology has played a constructive role in

the Philippines But he is uncomfortable with the label postcolonialism He

prefers to describe historical events as ldquobeyond colonialismrdquo And he says

that global conversations enrich local theologies and vice versa1048626983091

Postcolonial thought informs our understanding of the relationship be-

tween the local and global It also shows how theology can emerge at the

intersection between the localparticular and the globaluniversal It re-

minds us that worthwhile glocalization listens to all voices Tis includes

heeding those that have been historically silenced

22Ibid 983090104862823izon ransormation Afer Lausanne 1048625983088983090 10486259830941048631-9830961048631

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3036

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048631

G983148983151983139983137983148983145983162983137983156983145983151983150 983137983150983140 983156983144983141 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

C983151983150983139983148983157983140983145983150983143 R983141983142983148983141983139983156983145983151983150983155

How do we go about developing a model for glocal conversations izon hasrecently provided a useful model that is instructive as we seek to learn from

the Majority World It has at least two key features

First the local is in the global (globalization from below) Global theologies

and ideas have origins in many particular local contexts In that sense glo-

balization is from below Global ideas have local roots Ideas about integral

mission liberation theology and missional church have local origins Tey

have their roots in the prayers hopes discoveries mission and theologiesof thousands of local communities ldquoTe global does not cannot exist

without the localmdashbut the coming together of localities creates a global re-

ality that becomes greater than the sum of its parts it creates a gestalt entity

to which localities make themselves accountablerdquo1048626983092

Second the global is in the local (panlocalization from above) Te con-

cerns and voices of multitudes of locales form global conversations Tese

global discussions can provide a ldquopositive accountabilityrdquo back to local con-texts Tis is true when they enrich affirm serve guide and strengthen local

contexts It is also true when they avoid homogenization control impo-

sition and judgment Glocalization is best when it sees itself as interde-

pendent deeply connected with the local10486261048629

Tatrsquos a helpful starting point But we need to go further Besides izonrsquos

proposals Irsquom convinced that robust glocal conversations cultivate six core

practices

983089 Glocal theology practices its values We root glocal theology in core

values Tese values include solidarity understanding and mutual learning

Do we value fellowship with Christians of all cultures Do we value learning

from them

We prove our values through our practices What practices emerge out of

these values We need to collaborate act collectively and share information

We must find ways to foster grassroots perspectives and local theologies We

need to share stories and learnings and cultivate networks relationships and

partnerships We need attentiveness to local voices and global themes We

24Ibid 9830901048625983088-1048625104862825Ibid 98309010486251048628-1048625983096

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3136

10486271048632 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

ought to find ways to put these local and global voices into conversation

Mutual learning humility and solidarity are key Worthwhile glocal con-

versations can never be merely theoretical or academic It is up to us to rootour values in our practices

983090 Glocal theology practices humility (and it tells a new narrative) We

have noted that the local is in the global and the global is in the local Te

two are interdependent Tey form each other reciprocally Since this is the

case we must practice humility Tere is no place for ethnocentrism colo-

nialism or theological and cultural arrogance I have seen these unhealthy

postures far too oen in Western settingsRecently I attended a missional leadership conference On that occasion

the keynote speakermdasha leading missional author and speakermdashsaid that

North American missional conversations and innovations hold the key to

the future of the Western church Tis Euro American view is wrong (Irsquom

being kind o be frank itrsquos complete nonsense) Itrsquos arrogant and Euro

Americanndashcentric And itrsquos completely out of step with what is happening in

the glocal church We need a new narrativeIn June 1048626104862410486251048627 Te Center for the Study of Global Christianity reported

the top 10486261048624 countries where Christianity has the highest percentage growth

rate Nineteen of the top twenty are in Asia and Africa Eleven of them are

in Muslim majority countries Not a single country from Europe or North

America makes the top twenty list10486261048630

Itrsquos time to cultivate a new narrative Te future of the church is emerging

from the Majority World Rather than North America the churches of

Eastern Asia Western Africa the Arabian Peninsula and other parts of the

Majority World reveal the future of the global church We need the contribu-

tions of all contexts Western indigenous and Majority World All con-

tribute to glocal conversations All are important as we learn from each

other about mission theology and faith But letrsquos stop pretending that North

Americans and Europeans will reveal the future of the global church Letrsquos

start listening to what God is saying about the future of the global church

And hersquos speaking to us through the churches of Asia Africa Latin America

26Russ Mitchell ldquoTe op 983090983088 Countries Where Christianity Is Growing the Fastestrdquo Disciple All

Nations (blog) August 983090983093 98309098308810486251048627 httpsdiscipleallnationswordpresscom98309098308810486251048627983088983096983090983093the-top

-983090983088-countries-where-christianity-is-growing-the-astest

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3236

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048633

Muslim majority settings and so on We must cultivate a new glocal nar-

rativemdashone soaked in humility

Glocal theology must be humble theology Meek theology Receptive the-ology Discerning theology Prayerful theology Dialogical theology De-

pendent theology A theology that celebrates the interdependence between

the localparticular and the globaluniversal

983091 Glocal theology practices expansiveness Glocalization is by nature

comprehensive Local and global influences permeate much of our lives Tese

glocal forces shape our theologies and churches whether we like it or not

But intentionality is also important We need to commit to an expansiveapproach to glocal theology How do we deliberately cultivate glocal conver-

sations in our biblical interpretation Do we foster them in our under-

standing of the person and work of Christ How does glocalization shape

the way the Spirit empowers and constitutes the church How can it form

our understanding of the nature and mission of the rinity How does it

influence the way we practice fellowship and conversation across denomi-

national cultural ethnic economic sociocultural political gender andtheological divides How might it shape our theologies of mission com-

munity beauty spirituality suffering discipleship hospitality eco-justice

place education social ethics Christian leadership and so forth

983092 Glocal theology practices attention Glocal theology doesnrsquot need to

accept all the assumptions or assertions of postcolonial or Majority World

thought But it does need to engage with them and take them seriously

Postcolonial theology for instance gives the marginalized and colonized

and forgotten and silenced both dignity and voice Our glocal conversations

must also include and esteem these groups We need to be attentive to

others weak and powerful female and male dominant and downtrodden

old and young rich and poor privileged and marginalized influential and

subaltern educated and illiterate We need to practice the art of attention

being especially attentive to those who are different to us

983093 Glocal theology practices embrace What do colonial ethnocentric or

Western-centric perspectives do Tey silence Tey control Tey com-

modify Tey institutionalize Tey colonize Tey domesticate Tey replace

Tey import Tey exclude Tey do these things to the beliefs experiences

and practices of other cultures A worthwhile glocal theology refuses to do

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3336

10486281048624 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

these things Instead it adopts a responsive humble celebratory open in-

clusive and embracing attitude

983094 Glocal theology practices discernment Finally we need discernmentas we engage these ideas and practices Discernment is a huge topic thatrsquos

hard to cover comprehensively in a few words Discernment happens when

the Spirit of Christ and his Word renew our minds Te Spirit grants us

spiritual wisdom as we meditate on him and his Word and as we practice

discipleship to Jesus Christ Romans 10486251048626 provides guidance we need (1048625) to be

transformed by the renewal of our minds (1048626) to serve Christrsquos body and (1048627)

to put love into action Discernment also happens in conversation both lo-cally and glocally

I pray these core values and six practices come across in the following

chapters of GlobalChurch

Glocalization can never be just theoretical Are we committed to moving

glocalization from an abstract idea to a living communion Are we deter-

mined to construct a missional theology of the church in the context of

glocal conversations Tis must involve dialogue between Majority Worldindigenous and Western scholars activists and groups

Will glocalization be an abstract notion Or will it be a formative and

genuine communion between local regional and global voices Glocal dy-

namics are at play whether we like it or not Teyrsquore in our churches the-

ologies and missions But we can choose to relinquish isolationist colonial

parochial and arrogant approaches Instead we can adopt responsive dia-

logical learning humble and embracing postures

Trough healthy approaches to glocalization the Spirit challenges us to

value local contexts We immerse ourselves in local and particular commu-

nities and conversations He inspires us to open ourselves to global theo-

logical conversations He rouses us to value the symbiotic relationship be-

tween the localparticular and the globaluniversal

Trough glocal relationships the Spirit leads us to put local contextual

theologies into conversation with global ones He prompts us to explore the

ways in which the local is in the glocal and the global is in the local He per-

suades us to pursue collaboration and dialogue and mutual learning We

engage with Christians from different backgrounds and cultures ecumen-

icals Pentecostals evangelicals and so on from Western indigenous and

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3436

Glocalizing Conversations 10486281048625

Majority World contexts He motivates us to express solidarity between all

parties We appreciate our unity in diversity

Trough glocal conversations the Spirit moves us to ensure that unity andsolidarity emerge from a compelling vision of Jesusrsquo kingdom and gospel

and person He challenges us to share information theology and practices

He urges us to learn from each othermdashour successes and mistakes We seek

glocal solutions

Te Spirit calls us to develop glocal conversations about Christian ideas

and practices Tese include Scripture Evangelicalism ecumenism Pente-

costalism Jesus Christ the Holy Spirit God the Father the rinity com-munity spirituality discipleship liturgy worship hospitality prayer eco-

justice education social ethics Christian leadership gospel and culture

beauty place suffering liberation and so forth

Finally through glocal conversations the Spirit leads us to adopt a new

posture Tis is a responsive humble celebratory open inclusive and em-

bracing attitude to the ldquootherrdquo We do this as a new people made up of every

tribe and language and people and nationTere are dangers in glocalization Sugirtharajah warns of the commodi-

fication of local contextual practices and theologies When this happens

they are ldquosmoothed out of their primary contexts concerns and contesta-

tions travel across borders and become objects of analysis and scrutiny

within an alien secondary contextrdquo1048626983095

Itrsquos common for those of us who are Western to make mistakes when we

wrestle with Majority World and indigenous ideas Sugirtharajah mentions

our tendency to commodify reduce and institutionalize these ideas We also

risk doing these things (1048625) We apply them in noncontextual prescriptive ways

(1048626) We ignore their meanings in their original setting (1048627) We glamorize or

idealize their proponents or their contexts (1048628) We demonize those persons or

contexts (1048629) We disregard them as irrelevant rhetorical or minority discourse

Kevin J Vanhoozer says that we can fall into three traps when we glo-

calize theology (1048625) We can underestimate the theological significance of

local cultures (1048626) We can homogenize cultures and theologies exaggerating

27R S Sugirtharajah ldquoextual ake-Aways Tird World exts in Western Metropolitan Centresrdquo

Black Teology in Britain A Journal o Contextual Praxis 983090 (1048625983097983097983097) 10486271048627 10486271048631 Edward W Said Te

World the ext and the Critic (Cambridge MA Harvard University Press 10486259830979830961048627) 9830901048627983097

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3536

10486281048626 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

ldquothe onerdquo (1048627) We can overemphasize cultural particularity exaggerating ldquothe

manyrdquo and pursue ldquotheological ethnificationrdquo10486261048632

My hope is that GlobalChurch does not fall into the traps Sugirtharajahand Vanhoozer describe I hope that what unfolds in the following chapters

is respectful and discerning I hope it leads to further mutually enriching

conversations between people of different cultures

You the reader face the same challenges You face them in your personal

life ministry context and missional engagements

Will you treat the themes in this book as abstract theoretical notions

Will this be a temporary infatuation a flirtation with the ldquootherrdquo that dissi-pates as suddenly as it arrived Or will glocal conversations become an en-

riching and formative orientation in your life Will glocal conversations

bring fresh approaches to theology faith mission church and worship Will

conversations with other cultures and theologies become for you a com-

pelling way of life

My prayer is that glocal conversations will help the church be a global

visible alternative ldquocity set upon a hillrdquo a truly GlobalChurch

28Craig Ott and Harold A Netland Globalizing Teology Belie and Practice in an Era o World

Christianity (Grand Rapids Baker Academic 983090983088983088983094) 1048625983090983093

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3636

Page 4: GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 436

InterVarsity Press

PO Box 1048625104862810486241048624 Downers Grove IL 98309410486249830931048625983093-104862510486281048626983094

ivpresscom

emailivpresscom

copy104862610486241048625983094 by Graham Hill

All rights reserved No part of this book may be reproduced in any form without written permission from

InterVarsity Press

InterVarsity Pressreg is the book-publishing division of InterVarsity Christian FellowshipUSAreg a movement of

students and faculty active on campus at hundreds of universities colleges and schools of nursing in the United

States of America and a member movement of the International Fellowship of Evangelical Students For

information about local and regional activities visit intervarsityorg

All Scripture quotations unless otherwise indicated are taken from the Holy Bible odayrsquos New International

Versiontrade Copyright copy 1048626104862410486241048625 by International Bible Society All rights reserved

Cover design David Fassett

Interior design Beth McGill

Images orange water color square copy kentarcajuaniStockphoto

icons of Copenhagen Brussells Austria Israel Cuba Portugal Budapest Ireland Berlin and France

copy artefyiStockphoto

blue under water copy Achim PrilliStockphoto

ISBN 10486331048631983096-1048624-9830969830911048624983096-10486281048624983096983093-1048628 (print)

ISBN 10486331048631983096-1048624-9830969830911048624983096-104863310486331048624983091-983094 (digital)

Printed in the United States of America As a member of the Green Press Initiative InterVarsity Press is committed to protecting the environmentand to the responsible use of natural resources o learn more visit greenpressinitiativeorg

Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data

Hill Graham Reverend

GlobalChurch reshaping our conversations renewing our mission revitalizing our churches Graham Hill

foreword by Scot McKnight

pages cm

Includes index

ISBN 10486331048631983096-1048624-9830969830911048624983096-10486281048624983096983093-1048628 (casebound alk paper)

1048625 Church 1048626 GlobalizationmdashReligious aspectsmdashChristianity I itle II itle Global Church

BV98309410486241048624983091H9830931048628 104862610486241048625983093

10486269830941048633mdashdc1048626983091

104862610486241048625983093104862498309198309410486241048625983093

P 1048626983091 10486261048626 10486261048625 10486261048624 10486251048633 1048625983096 10486251048631 1048625983094 1048625983093 10486251048628 1048625983091 10486251048626 10486251048625 10486251048624 1048633 983096 1048631 983094 983093 1048628 983091 1048626 1048625

Y 983091983093 9830911048628 983091983091 9830911048626 9830911048625 9830911048624 10486261048633 1048626983096 10486261048631 1048626983094 1048626983093 10486261048628 1048626983091 10486261048626 10486261048625 10486261048624 10486251048633 1048625983096 10486251048631 1048625983094

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 536

C O N T E N T S

List of Figures and ables 983097

Foreword by Scot McKnight 983089983089

983089 Introduction Being Salt Light and a City 983089983091

Part 983089 Salt Reshaping Our Conversations

983090 Glocalizing Conversations 983090983091

Part 983090 Light Renewing Our Mission

983091 Contextualizing Mission 983092983093

983092 Liberating People 983094983097

983093 Showing Hospitality 983097983095

983094 Embracing the Spirit 983089983089983097

983095 Caring for Creation 983089983093983095

983096 Living Ethically 983089983096983091

983097 ransforming Neighborhoods 983090983089983093

Part 983091 City Revitalizing Our Churches

983089983088 Indigenizing Faith 983090983091983095

983089983089 Devouring Scripture 983090983095983093

983089983090 Renewing Education 983091983088983089

983089983091 Practicing Servantship 983091983091983095

983089983092 Recovering Community 983091983094983091

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 636

983089983093 Developing Spirituality and Discipleship 983091983096983091

983089983094 GlobalChurch Embracing a New Narrative 983092983089983093

Appendix 983089 GlobalChurch Project Video Series 983092983093983089

Appendix 983090 Study Guide 983092983093983091

Appendix 983091 Who Are hese Majority World

and Indigenous hinkers 983092983096983089

Appendix 983092 Resources and Glossary at

heGlobalChurchProjectcom 983092983097983091

Author Index 983092983097983093

Subject Index 983092983097983097

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 736

I N T R O D U C T I O N

B983141983145983150983143 S983137983148983156 L983145983143983144983156 983137983150983140 983137 C983145983156 983161

By 9830909830889830901048629 fully two-thirds of Christians will live in

Africa Latin America and Asia Te ldquoaverage

Christianrdquo today is female black and lives in a

Brazilian favela or an African village

SEPHE N BEVANS

Majority World and indigenous churches are redefining twenty-first-

century Christianity Western churches must decide how theyrsquoll respond

Stephen Bevans puts it well

We are now living in a ldquoworld churchrdquo where the vast majority of Christians are

[from the Majority World] David Barrettrsquos statistical studies have basically con-

firmed this shi and Philip Jenkins has predicted that by 1048626104862410486261048629 fully two-thirds

of Christians will live in Africa Latin America and Asia Scholars are fairly

unanimous in acknowledging the accuracy of the facts Te ldquoaverage Christianrdquo

today is female black and lives in a Brazilian favela or an African village983089

Some statistics illustrate this shi in twenty-first-century global Christi-

anity Te Pew Research Centerrsquos report Global Christianity analyzes the size

and distribution of the worldrsquos Christian population Te report maps the

changes over the last century (1048625104863310486251048624 to 1048626104862410486251048624) It concludes ldquoA century ago the

Global North (commonly defined as North America Europe Australia Japan

1Stephen B Bevans Roger Schroeder and L J Luzbetak ldquoMissiology Afer Bosch Reverencing a

Classic by Moving Beyondrdquo International Bulletin o Missionary Research 983090983097 no 983090 (983090983088983088983093) 983094983097

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 836

10486251048628 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

and New Zealand) contained more than four times as many Christians as the

Global South (the rest of the world) oday the Pew Forum study finds more

than 10486251048627 billion Christians live in the Global South [10486301048625983077 of all Christians livein Asia Africa and Latin America] compared with about 104863210486301048624 million in the

Global North (10486271048633983077)rdquo1048626 Tat is an astounding shi in only one hundred years983091

Using the World Christian Database Philip Jenkins offers table 10486251048625

ldquoChanging distribution of Christian believersrdquo

Table 983089983089 Changing distribution of Christian believers 983089983097983088983088 to 983090983088983093983088 (number of Christiansin millions)

983089983097983088983088 983089983097983095983088 983090983088983089983088 983090983088983093983088Africa 983089983088 983089983092983091 983092983097983091 983089983088983091983089

Asia 983090983090 983097983094 983091983093983090 983094983088983089

North America 983095983097 983090983089983089 983090983096983094 983091983091983091

Latin America 983094983090 983090983095983088 983093983092983092 983094983093983093

Europe 983091983096983089 983092983097983090 983093983096983096 983093983091983088

Oceania 983093 983089983096 983090983096 983091983096

Total 983093983093983096 983089983090983091983088 983090983090983097983089 983091983089983096983096

Source Philip Jenkins The Next Christendom The Coming of Global Christianity 983091rd ed (Oxford Oxford Uni-

versity Press 983090983088983089983089) 983091 Data is taken from World Christian Database wwwworldchristiandatabaseorgwcd

Christianity in North America Europe and Oceania grew from 104862810486301048629

million in 1048625104863310486241048624 to 104863310486241048626 million in 1048626104862410486251048624983092 Tis number is likely to shrink to

104863310486241048625 million by 1048626104862410486291048624

Christianity in Africa Asia and Latin America grew from 10486331048628 million in

1048625104863310486241048624 to 1048625104862710486321048633 billion in 1048626104862410486251048624 Tis number is likely to grow to 1048626104862610486321048631 billion by

1048626104862410486291048624

Letrsquos take China for example Professor Fenggang Yang of Purdue University

makes an important prediction If current rates of growth continue within one

generation China will have more Christians than any other nation on earth

In 1048625104863310486281048633 Protestant churches in China had one million members In 1048626104862410486251048624 that

number was 10486291048632 million (compare that with 10486281048624 million in Brazil and 10486271048630 million

2Pew Research Center Global Christianity A Report on the Size and Distribution o the Worldrsquos Chris-

tian Population December 1048625983097 98309098308810486251048625 wwwpeworumorg9830909830881048625104862510486259830901048625983097global-christianity-exec3See David B Barrett George Kurian and odd M Johnson World Christian Encyclopedia A

Comparative Survey o Churches and Religions in the Modern World 983090nd ed 983090 vols (New York

Oxord University Press 9830909830889830881048625) 1048625983090-1048625983093 and wwwglobalchristianityorg4Oceania includes Australia and Micronesian Melanesian and Polynesian countries

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 936

Introduction 10486251048629

in South Africa) By 1048626104862410486261048629 there are likely to be 104862510486301048624 million Christians in China

By 1048626104862410486271048624 this number is likely to be 104862610486281048631 million (outnumbering Christians in

Mexico Brazil and the United States) In an interview with the elegraphFenggang Yang says ldquoMao thought he could eliminate religion He thought he

had accomplished this Itrsquos ironicmdashthey didnrsquot Tey actually failed completelyrdquo1048629

Philip Jenkins concludes

We are currently living through one of the transforming moments in the

history of religion worldwide Over the last five centuries the story of Chris-

tianity has been inextricably bound up with that of Europe and European-

derived civilizations overseas above all in North America Until recently theoverwhelming majority of Christians have lived in white nations Over the

last century however the center of gravity in the Christian world has shied

inexorably away from Europe southward to Africa and Latin America and

eastward toward Asia oday the largest Christian communities on the planet

are to be found in those regions1048630

What does all this mean for the mission and theology and worship and

communities of the church worldwide And what does it mean particularlyfor the Western church

In Matthew 104862910486251048627-10486251048630 Jesus provides three remarkable images of the churchmdash

salt light and a city Jesus confronts his disciples with a missional description

of the church Te church in mission is the salt of the earth the light of the

world and a city set on a hill Te churchrsquos purpose is to let its ldquolight shine

before others that they may see your good deeds and glorify your Father in

heavenrdquo Te purpose of the churchrsquos missionary nature is the worship andglorification of the Father and Son and Holy Spirit983095

Te church is another city constituted by every tribe language people

5om Phillips ldquoChina on Course to Become lsquoWorldrsquos Most Christian Nationrsquo Within 1048625983093 Yearsrdquo

elegraph April 1048625983097 98309098308810486251048628 wwwtelegraphcouknewsworldnewsasiachina1048625983088104863110486319830949830889830901048627China-on

-course-to-become-worlds-most-Christian-nation-within-1048625983093-yearshtml See Fenggang Yang and

Joseph B amney eds Conucianism and Spiritual raditions in Modern China and Beyond Re-

ligion in Chinese Societies (Boston Brill 9830909830881048625983090) Fenggang Yang and Graeme Lang eds Social

Scientific Studies o Religion in China Methodology Teories and Findings (Leiden Brill 98309098308810486251048625)

Fenggang Yang Religion in China Survival and Revival Under Communist Rule (Oxord Oxord

University Press 9830909830881048625983090)6Philip Jenkins Te Next Christendom Te Coming o Global Christianity 1048627rd ed (Oxord Ox-

ord University Press 98309098308810486251048625) 10486257J Driver Images o the Church in Mission (Scottdale PA Herald 10486259830979830971048631) 10486251048631983088-9830961048625 Graham Hill Salt

Light and a City Introducing Missional Ecclesiology (Eugene OR Wip and Stock 9830909830881048625983090) xiii

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1036

10486251048630 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

and nation Te church must cultivate a distinct social existence shaping its

community and mission around its commitment to plurality and diversity

and unity1048632 God calls his church to be a global and missional ldquocity on a hillrdquoTis is a church constituted and enriched and represented by Western and

indigenous and Majority World peoples

Tose of us in the West need a new narrative Itrsquos time to abandon our

flawed Eurocentric and Americentric worldviews We need a new global

and missional narrative and for that we must turn to the churches of Ma-

jority World and indigenous cultures Tey can help us explore what it

means to be a global missional community Many Christian communitiesin Majority World and indigenous contexts have been wrestling with these

issues for generations Marginalization and persecution and alienation have

been their lot Yet somehow in spite of or because of that they have flour-

ished In fact theyrsquove grown exponentially

So whom am I talking about when I refer to Majority World and indig-

enous Christians Majority World Christians are those in Africa Asia the

Caribbean Eastern Europe Latin America the Middle East and Oceania

1048633

I use the term Majority World because the majority of the worldrsquos population

is in those cultures today Te majority of the church is in those cultures too

I donrsquot use the terms non-Western or Tird World or Developing World Tese

terms use Western cultures as their point of reference Tey imply Western

8Barry A Harvey Another City An Ecclesiological Primer or a Post-Christian World (New York

rinity 1048625983097983097983097) 9830901048627-9830909830939I donrsquot deal with the diasporas in this book For example Irsquove made no mention o Hispanic

Portuguese or Asian minorities in the United States United Kingdom Canada Europe Austra-lia and so on Irsquom aware that right now Latin American and Chinese diasporas are active in

evangelism and mission in Europe in the same way in which the Filipino or the Salvadoran dias-

poras carry on mission in the United States Irsquove chosen not to include voices rom the diasporas

mainly because there are so many worthy contributors in that group and I donrsquot have the space

to treat them well in this book In the uture I hope that I (or someone else) will write a book

exploring what we can learn rom the diasporas Hispanic minorities or example are making

significant contributions to the theological and missiological conversation in the United States

that are relevant to this subject Methodist historian Justo L Gonzaacutelez and Pentecostal theologian

Eldin Villaantildee are examples In Mantildeana Gonzaacutelez describes the shape and orm o a theology

developed in the Hispanic margin o the United States In Out o Every ribe and Nation he shows

what would be implied in listening to minorities within a denominational setting Villaantildeersquos Te

Liberating Spirit is a milestone in the reflection about the relationship between pneumatology and

social ethics See Justo L Gonzaacutelez Out o Every ribe and Nation Christian Teology at the

Ethnic Roundtable (Nashville Abingdon 1048625983097983097983090) Gonzaacutelez Mantildeana Christian Teology rom a

Hispanic Perspective (Nashville Abingdon 1048625983097983097983088) Eldin Villaantildee Te Liberating Spirit oward

an Hispanic American Pentecostal Social Ethic (Grand Rapids Eerdmans 10486259830979830971048627)

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1136

Introduction 10486251048631

superiority or centricity Te term Global South is too limiting given the

breadth of the group I am engaging Majority World seems to work best

In 1048626104862410486241048628 Te Lausanne Forum for World Evangelization in PattayaTailand voted unanimously that the phrase Majority World Church replace

other terms People from all over the globe participated in this forum

imothy C ennent agrees that this is the best phrase ldquoIt helps to highlight

the basic point that Africa Asia and Latin America are where the majority

of the worldrsquos Christians are now locatedrdquo9830891048624 I expand the phrase Majority

World beyond Africa Asia and Latin America to include the Caribbean

Eastern Europe Oceania and the Middle EastIndigenous and First Nations peoples are ldquothose ethnic groups that were

indigenous to a territory prior to being incorporated into a national state

and who are politically and culturally separate from the majority ethnic

identity of the state that they are a part ofrdquo Tis includes people groups like

the Australian Aborigines and American Indians983089983089

Te aim of this book is to help Western churches rediscover what it means

to be salt light and a city by engaging in global missional conversations odo this Western Christians need to enter into conversation with Majority

World and indigenous Christians Listening to others helps us grow in our

understanding and practice of mission and church and theology For far too

long wersquove marginalized or ignored Majority World and indigenous voices

We must truly become a GlobalChurch

Tis aim shapes the bookrsquos structure as summarized below

P983137983154983156 1048625 S983137983148983156 R983141983155983144983137983152983145983150983143 O983157983154 C983151983150983158983141983154983155983137983156983145983151983150983155

ldquoYou are the salt of the earth But if the salt loses its saltiness how can it be made

salty again It is no longer good for anything except to be thrown out and

trampled underfootrdquo Globally and locally you are the salt of the earth Be salt

Salt preserves seasons flavors and purifies We are salt when we glorify

the Father Son and Holy Spirit in our mission worship faith hope truth

and love We are salt when we reject a Eurocentric or Americentric vision

10imothy C ennent Teology in the Context o World Christianity How the Global Church Is

Influencing the Way We Tink About and Discuss Teology (Grand Rapids Zondervan 9830909830889830881048631) xx11Douglas Sanders ldquoIndigenous Peoples Issues o Definitionrdquo International Journal o Cultural

Property 983096 no 1048625 (1048625983097983097983097) 1048628

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1236

10486251048632 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

of the church and become the global missional church Christ envisioned

In part one I show how Western conversations are impoverished and

insufficient in isolation from indigenous and Majority World Christians Weenhance our ldquosaltinessrdquo through local-global ( glocal ) exchanges o do this

we must reshape our conversations We need global and local exchanges that

we characterize by mutuality respect partnership and symbiosis Such ex-

changes help us learn from each other whether wersquore in Western indig-

enous or Majority World settings It helps us stay ldquosaltyrdquo It enables us to

pursue global missional theology and practice Globally and locally we can

pursue missional vitality and truly be ldquothe salt of the earthrdquo

P983137983154983156 1048626 L983145983143983144983156 R983141983150983141983159983145983150983143 O983157983154 M983145983155983155983145983151983150

ldquoYou are the light of the world A city on a hill cannot be hidden Neither do

people light a lamp and put it under a bowl Instead they put it on its stand and

it gives light to everyone in the house In the same way let your light shine

before others that they may see your good deeds and glorify your Father in

heavenrdquo (Mt 104862910486251048628-10486251048631) Globally and locally you are the light of the world Be lightLight illuminates reveals and dispels darkness Te church is light when

it does good deedsmdashhealing and liberating and redemptive deeds Itrsquos light

when its being and faith and deeds bring glorify to the Father Te church

is light when it participates in Godrsquos redemptive mission in the world as a

global missional community

o do this we must renew our mission In part two I explore how indig-

enous and Majority World Christians teach us to renew mission We renew

mission through contextualization liberation hospitality Spirit empow-

erment creation care ethics and the transformation of neighborhoods

P983137983154983156 1048627 C983145983156983161 R983141983158983145983156983137983148983145983162983145983150983143 O983157983154 C983144983157983154983139983144983141983155

You are a city set on a hill ldquoA city on a hill cannot be hiddenrdquo Globally and

locally you are a city set on a hill Be a city set on a hill

Tis means that we are an alternative and countercultural movement We

have a distinct culture and politic and social existence We are a people

gathered from every tribe language people and nation We are in the world

but not of the world We are in the world but distinct from the world We are

within the world and for the sake of the world

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1336

Introduction 10486251048633

o be this kind of alternative city or culture we must renew our mission

community ethics and worship We need to pursue the revitalization of our

churches so that they are distinct And by distinct I mean an alternative city(altera civitas)

We are a ldquocity on a hillrdquo that witnesses to Jesus Christ and his eternal kingdom

when we are a global missional church In part three I demonstrate how indig-

enous and Majority World Christians teach us to revitalize churches We revi-

talize churches by indigenizing faith devouring Scripture renewing education

practicing servantship (servant leadership) recovering community and devel-

oping spirituality and discipleship We inspire our churches when we developour theology and practices relating to beauty and the arts9830891048626

In the final chapter I wrap things up by addressing an important question

In light of all the material covered in this book what would it now look like

to engage in global missional theology ecclesiology interpretation history

pneumatology worship and education

Herersquos how you can get the most out of this book

Community You can read this book alone in a small group with somefriends at home or at a coffee shop or as part of a ministry team However

you get a lot more out of this book when you read it with others ogether

you can think about the bookrsquos implications What do the chapters mean for

your ministry church agency family or team

GlobalChurch Project video series Irsquove made a video series to go along with

this book Appendix one has the details

Study guide Yoursquoll get a lot more out of this book if you spend time

working through the study guide in appendix two ry to do this in a group

Te study guide includes reflection questions suggested practices and

Further Reading

Characters As you read this book yoursquoll come across names and people

yoursquove never heard of before For a glimpse of who they are and what issues

concern them see appendix three

My website o help you get the most out of this book Irsquove included more

resources on my website TeGlobalChurchProjectcom Tese include

videos reading lists important links a glossary and other resources Irsquove

12Irsquove put a separate chapter on the theme o beauty and the arts on my website Itrsquos additional to

this book

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1436

10486261048624 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

also provided ways that you can contact me See appendix four

In my first book Salt Light and a City I developed a missional theology

of the church I did this in conversation with twelve theologians from the fourmajor Christian traditions Tat volume offered a window into the thought of

European and American theologians It showed how they are making sense

of the nature and mission of the church in their Western cultural context

Te book that yoursquore now reading takes a different approach I have

stepped away from European and American voices I now ask What can

those in the Majority World and indigenous cultures teach us in the West

What can they teach us about the churchrsquos mission worship theology andcommunity Te quality and quantity of material coming out of the Ma-

jority World is astonishing Any theology that ignores the insights of indig-

enous and Majority World Christians is deficient and impoverished

White middle-class European North American tertiary-educated men

dominate Western theology Tey dominate the Western missional conver-

sation I know I fit that profile Tis group still monopolizes missional church

conferences and seminars Tey get all the book contracts In fact this groupstill controls theology and the church in many settings But this is changing

New voices are rising Tese include women minorities the poor indigenous

groups and Majority World leaders Missional conversations arenrsquot attentive

to the Spirit and to Godrsquos mission if they ignore these voices Majority World

and indigenous churches oen have extraordinary missional vitality Openness

to other voices needs to happen now It is time for Western churches theol-

ogies and mission to mature and to reflect Godrsquos global mission

In this book I could have consulted the work of many thousands of in-

digenous and Majority World thinkers and writers and practitioners But I

have limited myself to a sample of those who speak directly to its themes

Tese African Asian Eastern European Middle Eastern Caribbean Latin

American First Nation and indigenous thinkers challenge us Tey dare us

to examine our theologies and missions and churches And they inspire us

to renew the worship and community and mission of Jesusrsquo church Tey

stir us to think in fresh ways about what it means to be salt light and a city

Tey help us become a global missional churchmdasha truly GlobalChurch

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1536

PA R T O N E

S A L TReshaping Our Conversations

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1636

G L O C A L I Z I N G

C O N V E R S A T I O N S

H983151983159 D983151 W983141 D983141983158983141983148983151983152

G983148983151983139983137983148 C983151983150983158983141983154983155983137983156983145983151983150983155983103

Rather than taking one contextual version of the Gospel and imposing

it as the Gospel throughout the world via the missionary enterprise

the shapers of Mission as ransformation have recognized the

plurality of localities that has created an intercontextual

ldquopan-localrdquo global phenomenon in theology

AL IZON

The International Society for Urban Mission (ISUM) is a group of urban

missionaries who are passionate about cultivating hope and love and re-newal in cities Irsquove connected with this group for some years ISUM held its

first annual Summit on Integral Urban Mission in Bangkok Tailand Te

team from Urban Neighbours of Hope (UNOH) under the leadership of

my Australian friends Ash and Anj Barker organized much of the summit

UNOH teams covenant with God and each other to ldquolive out our passion for

loving God and neighbour Focus on releasing neighbourhoods from urban

poverty Grow through equipping each other neighbours and the broader

church to radically follow Jesus and join Godrsquos Kingdom coming UNOH

workers live and serve in small responsive neighbourhood-based teamsrdquo983089

1See wwwunohorg

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1736

10486261048628 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

Tis summit involved interactive participatory hands-on immersion op-

portunities keynotes lectures and workshops Keynote speakers came from

Africa Australia Myanmar New Zealand North America the PhilippinesSouth America Tailand and First Nations A few hundred Majority World

and Western thinkers and activists came together for those days Tey explored

the theology and practices of integral transformational and urban mission

Tese thinkers and activists pursued a range of aims1048626 Tis included col-

laboration between urban Christians from a variety of backgrounds (Ma-

jority World and Western theologians activists ecumenicals Pentecostals

evangelicals colleges church movements and development agencies) Teyaimed for collective action and thought in an international and integral

context Tey sought to gain mutual understanding for a comprehensive

picture of urban mission around the globe Tey encouraged information

sharing and best practicesmdashlearning from our mistakes and seeking solu-

tions Tey developed recommendations and calls to action to the broader

church Working groups wrote briefing papers aer each summit based on

key issues in urban mission And they endeavored to build trust wisdomand inspiration to better engage our new urban world

Majority World and Western leaders participated in discussion prayer

integral mission and working groups Te goal was to grapple with key issues

and ask key questions How do we recruit equip and sustain urban mission

today How do we release church movements among the urban poor How

can we immerse ourselves in and transform urban neighborhoods How do

we empower urban children and young people How does the church serve

and liberate the oppressedmdashand others suffering from urban injustice What

needs to happen for poorer urban centers to develop economically socially

and spiritually How do we join God in the challenges and opportunities of

multifaith cities

Workshops included urban gardening child protection and collaborating

with local churches in urban mission Workshops also included organic

church growth and mission as well as developing NGO and government

partnerships Groups considered the good the bad and the ugly of short-

term urban mission teams

2Tese aims are detailed at ldquoInternational Society or Urban Mission Summitrdquo httpnewurbanworld

orgsummit

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1836

Glocalizing Conversations 10486261048629

Te summit was a thrilling example of how Majority World and Western

leaders can cooperate It was a time to come together in an environment of

mutual learning and enrichment It was a window into how local contextsand global themes can enrich each other Tis resulted from ISUMrsquos com-

mitment to ldquosolidarity fellowship and insight between urban Christian

leaders in the Western and Majority Worldsrdquo

Te summit was a success due to ISUMrsquos core values What are they983091 Christ-

honoring urban mission values bottom-up grassroots perspectivesmdashrather

than top-down distanced perspectives It allows local theology to reveal new

insights and perspectives about Godrsquos activity It shares insights and experi-ences through narratives embedded within urban poor communities and cities

It cultivates ongoing practical and personal solidarity with the worldrsquos urban

poor Tis Spirit-empowered urban mission honors networks relationships

and partnerships It sees such relationships as the primary method of serving

together It listens to and amplifies the voices of the urban poormdashespecially

those from the Majority World and in particular the 1048625104862410486281048624 window cities It is

attentive to signs of the kingdom of God Urban mission that glorifies God iswilling to reflect and respond with active and sacrificial commitment It shares

and extends the life of the body of Christ among the urban poor

Tis summit was a milestone in urban missiology It enriched communi-

cation between Western and Majority World thinker-activists Tis resulted

from the aims and values Irsquove mentioned Effective urban mission needs to

be a conversation on many levels It is attentive to context and immersed in

local settings It appreciates global and universal missional themes It culti-

vates dialogue between these local-global (glocal) realities It involves

mutual learning between Western and Majority World thinker-activists

Moreover solidarity between all parties is a defining feature Tis solidarity

is due to a compelling vision of the kingdom of God

Tese collaborative glocal features of the ISUM urban mission summit

in Bangkok are critical for the aims of this book GlobalChurch

Majority World indigenous and Western leaders thinkers and churches

can stretch and enrich each other But they need to be open and attentive to

each other Tey need learning postures and open hearts and minds Tey

3ldquoAbout ISUMrdquo httpnewurbanworldorgabout

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1936

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2036

Glocalizing Conversations 10486261048631

always rooted in the local and particularmdashas local churches embody the

gospel and witness to Christ Tese churches forge their own theological

understandings as they do mission together Tey engage in transformationalpractices among the people in their settings Tey enjoy worship mission

and community in their local and particular context Ideally the result is

unique contextual theologies and missions

Simultaneously global conversations form Tey form because of this

multitude of local theologies and practices Local conversations inform and

enrich other local conversations catalyzing global themes and voices izon

observes that the global ldquoowes its existence to local contexts Sharedconvictions among the theologies and practices of local contextual realities

give shape to its global dimensionsrdquo1048629

Majority World indigenous and Western theologies are equally contextual

Tey are equally culture bound Tey are equally particular to their time and

location At times they are all enlightened or myopic liberating or con-

straining humanizing or objectifying beautiful or offensive prophetic or

tepid Te local particular and cultural shape all these theologies Converselythese particular theologies feed and influence global conversations Tere is

no place then for ethnocentrism colonialism or elitism Tere is no place

for theological missional cultural or institutionalized arrogance

Multiple local contexts and voices come togethermdashintentionally or notmdashto

form global themes and theologies Conversely these global realities shape

local contexts oday local contexts must grapple with ldquoan emerging global

culture ie the interacting realities of modernity postmodernity and the

phenomenon of globalizationrdquo1048630 Hence the interdependent and symbiotic

relationship between the localparticular and the globaluniversal We call this

interdependent relationship between the local and the global glocalization

Te global church needs a thrilling glocal exchange We need one that we

characterize by mutuality respect partnership and symbiosis Such ex-

change helps Majority World indigenous and Western churches learn from

each other It enables them to pursue missional theology and practice o-

gether the church becomes a ldquocity on a hillrdquo

5Ibid 10486259830886Ibid 9830961048628

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2136

10486261048632 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

W983144983137983156 R983141983153983157983145983154983141983155 G983148983151983139983137983148983145983162983137983156983145983151983150983103

Te glocal exchange described above needs to be broader than transforma-

tional mission Tis is necessary if the church is to develop a robust inter-cultural and glocal missional ecclesiology

In my first book Salt Light and a City I outlined the foundational

themes of missional ecclesiology983095 Majority World and Western leaders

need to engage these themes in local and contextual ways Teir insights can

then enrich global conversations Tese global conversations in turn shape

local understandings and practices Tis way a glocal appreciation of these

themes emergesLocal regional and global theologies and practices are thereby enriched

Te church becomes healthier and more missionalmdasha truer expression of

the kingdom Te church becomes a fuller witness to Christ his passion for

the nations and his ability to bring unity in diversity

Stephen Bevans and Roger Schroeder outline the six constants of mission

Tese are our theologies about Jesus the church the end times salvation

human nature and culture Bevans and Schroeder describe the relationshipbetween these six and their historical cultural and theological contexts Tis is

why they call these six constants in context Our understanding of these six

constants develops in relation to local and global movements Sometimes local

voices influence our understandings of these six Other times it is regional or

global voices For all of us local regional and global influences are at play at

once Collectively they form our appreciation of the six constants of mission1048632

Here are eight theological themes that the church can develop through

processes of glocalization I presented these in my book Salt Light and a City

Tey are vital to the churchrsquos health mission community and future We

could add many other themes to these eight but these will suffice for now1048633

Scripture Te Scriptures are the infallible authoritative Word of God

Christrsquos Spirit has inspired them Tey have absolute and final authority in

all aspects of corporate and individual faith ethics conduct and witness

Christians interpret and apply Scripture in local contexts and in particular

7Graham Hill Salt Light and a City Introducing Missional Ecclesiology (Eugene OR Wip and

Stock 9830909830881048625983090) 10486251048628983097-983090104863110486288Stephen B Bevans and Roger Schroeder Constants in Context A Teology o Mission or oday

American Society o Missiology Series (Maryknoll NY Orbis 9830909830889830881048628) part one9Tese points first appeared in my book Salt Light and a City xxii-xxiv

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2236

Glocalizing Conversations 10486261048633

social settings Conversely we learn from the interpretations and readings

of other groups

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our local- global theology of Scripture and biblical interpretation

Evangelicalism Pentecostalism missional movements and so forth I

have charismatic missional and evangelical convictions Glocal conversa-

tions help me understand and practice these convictions better

I will use evangelicalism as an example Michael Horton says that our

beliefs and practices are evangelical when they are ldquocommitted to the suffi-

ciency of Scripture the priesthood of all believers the total lostness ofhumans the sole mediation of Christ the gracious efficacy and finality of

Godrsquos redemptive work in Christ through election propitiation calling and

keeping Te linchpin for all of this was the doctrine of justification by grace

alone through faith alone because of Christ alonerdquo9830891048624

Such convictions are necessary if we are to be faithful to the gospel and

to a biblical vision of church and mission Te gospel defines Godrsquos purposes

for humanity the church and the universe Te triune God controls thechurch He is its Lord and Savior Sanctifier and Liberator Master and King

He is completely sovereign over its nature affairs mission and history God

is the churchrsquos only source of grace election atonement salvation and per-

severance Te churchrsquos justification and hope are by grace alone through

faith alone by Christ alone

Herersquos the challenge I face My understanding of evangelicalism is

Western I am a product of the Western theological tradition and my Western

evangelical heritage Much of this is wonderful But I need indigenous and

Majority World evangelicals and others to help me expand and reshape

these insights Te same would be true if I were a Pentecostal

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of our theological traditions and convictions

Jesus Christ We must center our theology on Jesus Christ the Lord of

the church Te church needs to reflect on the person and work of Christ

and respond to him Tis means gathering and going in the name and power

of Christ It means allowing Christrsquos Spirit to shape our community and

10Michael Horton ldquoEvangelical Arminiansrdquo Modern Reormation 1048625 no 1048627 (1048625983097983097983090) 10486251048631

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2336

10486271048624 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

identity and mission It means developing our Christology ecclesiology and

missiology concurrently Te early church developed these three areas and

more in a concurrent and integrated way Tere was no linear progressionTe same is true in the contemporary global church

How can the glocal church best explore its nature structure mission and

hope Trough the centrality and the lordship of Christ

Majority World and indigenous Christians help us appreciate Jesus and

his mission afresh Tey show us how Jesus identifies with the marginalized

outcast oppressed rejected and broken He prefers them We find him

among ldquothe least of theserdquoGlocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of who Jesus Christ is How does it help us appreciate him better

What has Jesus done for and in his church and his world What does he care

about What individual and corporate responsibilities has he given us How

do we express these at local regional and global levels

Te Spirit Missional ecclesiology is inadequate without pneumatological

foundations In other words our theology of church and Spirit go togetherTe Spirit creates and animates the church He empowers it to witness to

Jesus and his gospel Te Spirit enables the church to be a missional trans-

formational community He shapes the church into an alternative society

embodying the reign of God Te church exists for the glory and mission of

Christ Te power and presence of the Spirit enables this mission worship

and glorification

Te Spirit pours out gis on the local-global church ldquofor the common

goodrdquo and ldquoto equip his people for works of service so that the body of Christ

may be built uprdquo Tis includes but isnrsquot limited to the ministry gis mani-

festation gis and motivational gis (1048625 Cor 104862510486261048631 Eph 104862810486251048625-10486251048626 Rom 104862510486261048630-1048632)

Te Spirit forms the glocal church He empowers it for service and

witness He fills it with Christrsquos empowering presence He leads it into the

missio Deimdashthe mission of the Father Son and Holy Spirit

Recently Pentecostal and renewalist movements have grown dramati-

cally in the Majority World Tey have increased in status size and influence

Many have matured theologically Te churches of the West must take notice

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of the power and presence of the Spirit

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2436

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048625

Te rinity Tere are clear limitations to the analogy between the

church and the rinity Te church can only image the rinity Yet the

church is at its best when it reflects the relational and missional passionof the rinity

What is the source and inspiration of the churchrsquos local-global mission

Ultimately it is the missional nature passion and actions of the Father Son

and Holy Spirit Godrsquos nature is missional His passion is infectious His

actions are historical redemptive and eternal Te rinity invites the

church into a sending community Te Father sends the Son Te Father

and Son send the Spirit Finally the rinity sends the church in missioninto the world

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of the rinity How does it enable our participation in the mission

and community of the triune God

Association and dialogue Tese need to happen across denominational

cultural ethnic gender and theological traditions and divides Authentic

dialogue is indispensable to the health and mission of the church What dothose marginal to the life of the church have to say to us What do ldquoothersrdquo

have to teach us Other ethnicities and cultures Other socioeconomic

groups Other ages and genders Other theological and confessing tradi-

tions Other persons from times long gone

We need to listen Share Be vulnerable Be authentic Open up to crit-

icism correction and change

We need more than dialogue We need communion and association It is

possible in a qualified way to say that God is present in all the various forms

of the church (ie the various theological ecclesiological sociocultural his-

torical and other permutations of the church) We discern this presence

through attention to Scripture history tradition culture and the Spirit Dis-

cernment involves critical dialogue theological exchange biblical study and

real relationship Only the Spirit of Jesus can enable this

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of association and dialogue

Mission and the missio Dei Te church is missional at its core It serves

obeys and images a missionary God David Bosch says ldquoTe churchrsquos mission

is not secondary to its being the church exists in being sent and in building up

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2536

10486271048626 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

itself for its missionrdquo He goes on to say ldquoEcclesiology does not precede missi-

ology there cannot be church without an intrinsic missionary dimensionrdquo983089983089

Jesus is Lord Lord of his church and Lord of his world His mission de-termines and forms the church His mission shapes the nature purposes

structures ministries and activities of his church Majority World and in-

digenous thinkers help us understand the implications of this mission Tey

help us form glocal theologies of mission Tey reveal ldquomission in context

as transformationrdquo9830891048626

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of mission and the missio Dei Church theology and practice Glocal conversations can inform and

enrich many aspects of the church (when practiced well) Teologies and

practices benefit from robust and critical glocal conversations Tese con-

versations enrich many areas (community spirituality discipleship liturgy

worship hospitality eco-justice education social ethics servantship lib-

eration place suffering beauty and so on)

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-standing of these many dimensions of church and mission

Glocal processes shape these eight themes and their practices We need

to facilitate and enable these conversations and processes Tis is urgent It

must be a priority No theology of mission or missional ecclesiology is ad-

equate without glocal conversations983089983091

T983144983141 L983151983139983137983148 983137983150983140 G983148983151983138983137983148 E983150983154983145983139983144 E983137983139983144 O983156983144983141983154

Glocalization takes the localparticular context and globaluniversal themes

seriously Contextual and global conversations enter an enriching and in-

forming relationship Tese two always have an active and symbiotic rela-

tionship Tis is true whether we deliberately put them into conversation or

not Te local shapes the global and the global shapes the local Many local

11David J Bosch Believing in the Future oward a Missiology o Western Culture (New York

rinity 1048625983097983097983093) 104862798309012izon ransormation Afer Lausanne 1048631-98309713Not all o these themes are dealt with in this present volume since either (1048625) I have dealt with them

in my book Salt Light and a City (983090) they are not all key themes in the writings o the thirty-five

Majority World thinkers considered in this volume or (1048627) there is not adequate space in a book

this size

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2636

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048627

voices converge to form global conversations and theologies Using the Phil-

ippines as a case study izon illustrates this by showing the interdepen-

dence between local and global themes in mission983089983092Dialogue between local and global conversations is critical Kōsuke

Koyama wrote an important book on contextual mission called Water Buffalo

Teology Koyama is a Japanese missionary who served in Chiang Mai

Tailand He writes of the joys and challenges of doing local particular water

buffalo theology He considers the relationship between local theology global

missional themes and transforming cultures ldquoWater Buffalo Teology sees

certain specific challenges Contextualization of theology implies two criticalmovements First to articulate Jesus Christ in culturally appropriate com-

municatively apt words and second to criticize reform dethrone or oppose

culture if it is found to be against what the name of Jesus Christ stands forrdquo9830891048629

Kōsuke Koyama challenges us to recognize what we bring to the task of

local theology For him it was doing theology in Tailand while being Jap-

anese We also need to notice the particular culture wersquore located in as we do

the work of theology Tis means we avoid speaking of an ldquoAsian theologyrdquoldquoAfrican theologyrdquo and the like We need to cultivate local theologies that

engage regional and global themes But these theologies must be ldquodistinctly

localrdquo and a ldquotheology from belowrdquo9830891048630

Simultaneously we need to pursue a reformation of theology and

practice ldquoin the global contextrdquo Tis means entering ldquothe disturbing spa-

ciousness of Jesus Christrdquo Jesus calls us to reject enmity and exceptionalism

We seem him present in our culture language stories and relationships

But we also choose to embrace the ldquootherrdquo We choose to see him present

in other culturesmdashshaping a global people to serve and worship him

joining in his mission983089983095

Kōsuke Koyama roots the gospel in the local contextual and particular

Tis is why he roots his water buffalo theology in Northern Tai culture He

is careful not to say ldquoHere is how you contextualize in your settingrdquo Instead

14izon ransormation Afer Lausanne 1048631-10486251048627 10486251048628983097-98309098308898309015Kōsuke Koyama Water Buffalo Teology 983090983093th anniversary ed (Maryknoll NY Orbis 1048625983097983097983097)

xiii-xv16Kōsuke Koyama ldquoTe Asian Approach to Christrdquo Missiology 1048625983090 no 1048628 (10486259830979830961048628) 10486281048627983093-104862798309617Kōsuke Koyama ldquoReormation in the Global Context Te Disturbing Spaciousness o Jesus Christrdquo

Currents in Teology and Mission 1048627983088 no 983090 (9830909830889830881048627) 10486251048625983097-983090983096

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2736

10486271048628 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

he tells us a story Itrsquos the story of how he contextualized theology in northern

Tailand while being open to global conversations Koyama asks us to form

our own local expressions of church mission and theology At the same timewe must stay attentive to what God is saying and doing beyond that context

Tis way local and global and particular and universal become mutually

enriching conversation partners

G983148983151983139983137983148983145983162983137983156983145983151983150 983137983150983140 H983145983155983156983151983154983145983139983137983148983148983161 S983145983148983141983150983139983141983140 V983151983145983139983141983155

Glocal theologies and conversations pay attention to voices that powers in-

stitutions religions and societies have silenced R S Sugirtharajah pushesback a little on izonrsquos ideas Sugirtharajah says that the church should

privilege local conversations He emphasizes the local contextual and post-

colonial reading of biblical texts9830891048632

Te church needs to listen Te church ought to be attentive to the

theologies and biblical interpretations of groups that cultures and reli-

gions have ignored Historically powerful secular and religious forces

have silenced these groups Tey have marginalized oppressed and colo-nized them It is time for the church to address this injustice We must

start listening to important but silenced voices We need to privilege the

voices of the former victims of Western colonialism We need to develop

postcolonial biblical interpretations theologies and expressions of church

and mission

How do we take such perspectives seriously as we develop glocal conver-

sations How do these themes help us foster vital relationships between local

and global voices

It is time for us to embrace values that enable conversations with those

oen ignored by the church We need values that help us learn from these

groups and individuals

Valuing equal partnership Colonizing powers oppressed silenced and

colonized certain groups At times the church was complicit Tese colo-

nized groups have become ldquoconfident indomitable and indispensable

partners in the dialogue and collaboration with the dispossessed and disad-

18R S Sugirtharajah Asian Biblical Hermeneutics and Postcolonialism Contesting the Interpreta-

tions Te Bible and Liberation Series (Maryknoll NY Orbis 1048625983097983097983096) 1048625983093-1048625983094

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2836

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048629

vantaged in the Westrdquo9830891048633 Tis calls for attentiveness to these voices and re-

sponsiveness to their prophetic challenges It also demands a critical evalu-

ation of colonial readings of Scripture Colonial models of theology andchurch and mission are no longer the benchmark Te global church must

examine them afresh

Valuing equal status Tose on the margins have now taken their rightful

place on the global stage Tey have claimed appropriate and equal status at

the table Subaltern readings of theology church and mission are invaluable

contributors to global theological conversations Tis means that we esteem

them But we also test themWhat do we mean by subaltern Subalterns are those who are down-

trodden and silenced (or have been treated this way in the past) Dominant

or colonizing groups treat them as invisible nonentities Tey enjoy limited

or no access to power Sometimes these are women certain tribal and ethnic

groups and those considered ldquountouchablerdquo In Voices from the Margin Su-

girtharajah provides a platform for postcolonial subaltern readings of

Scripture and theology Tese readings challenge colonialmdashoen Westernmdashreadings of Bible and theology and cultures Tey claim equal status with

other ways of doing theology10486261048624

Valuing equal identity People groups need freedom to explore their new

and emerging identities Tese emerge in response to local and global influ-

ences Local culture is not the only thing at work here Global forces also

shape identity as do imported practices ideas readings rituals and tech-

nologies But each group should be free to explore and construct their par-

ticular forms of Christian identity

Valuing equal interpretations ldquoPostcolonialism is concerned with the

question of cultural and discursive dominationrdquo Colonialism led to op-

pressive and controlling forms of culture and discourse Tese were usually

not contextual or indigenous Western powers for instance brought co-

lonial forms of theology church biblical interpretation and mission1048626983089

Postcolonialism calls for alternative ways of approaching these things Tose

19Ibid 104862598309420R S Sugirtharajah Voices rom the Margin Interpreting the Bible in the Tird World (Maryknoll

NY Orbis 10486259830979830971048625)21Sugirtharajah Asian Biblical Hermeneutics and Postcolonialism 10486251048631

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2936

10486271048630 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

who were once marginalized oppressed and silenced need to lead these fresh

approaches in their own settings Tese then influence global conversations

We need to support the new readings and insights and experiments from thesegroups o be genuine this support must be both critical and collegial

Valuing equal empowerment Sugirtharajah says that postcolonialism is

valuable when it empowers actual communities and real people Post-

colonial thought empowers when it addresses the difficulties hopes and

experiences of ordinary people It should never be about power plays and

the clever use of language Itrsquos pointless if itrsquos obsessed with forming newmdash

and ldquocolonizingrdquomdashtheories Itrsquos a waste of time if itrsquos a self-indulgent pursuitof new and hybrid identities Rather ldquothe worth and credibility of post-

colonial criticism will be judged by how it orchestrates the unique and

fragile and imagined claims of one community against anotherrdquo Empow-

erment happens in a variety of ways One way is contributing equally to

global conversations10486261048626

Al izon examines postcolonialism in the Philippines He says that it can

teach the global church a lot about healthy local-global conversations Fil-ipino contextual theology resists many Western forms of mission and the-

ology It finds them patronizing and controlling Tis indigenous theology

values prophetic sociopolitical engagement in institutions and the society

at large It emphasizes ministry to whole persons and communities It con-

structs a Filipino theology of beauty and mission and worship and com-

munity And it fosters indigenous theological approaches to the spirit world

and cosmology

izon says that postcolonial theology has played a constructive role in

the Philippines But he is uncomfortable with the label postcolonialism He

prefers to describe historical events as ldquobeyond colonialismrdquo And he says

that global conversations enrich local theologies and vice versa1048626983091

Postcolonial thought informs our understanding of the relationship be-

tween the local and global It also shows how theology can emerge at the

intersection between the localparticular and the globaluniversal It re-

minds us that worthwhile glocalization listens to all voices Tis includes

heeding those that have been historically silenced

22Ibid 983090104862823izon ransormation Afer Lausanne 1048625983088983090 10486259830941048631-9830961048631

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3036

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048631

G983148983151983139983137983148983145983162983137983156983145983151983150 983137983150983140 983156983144983141 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

C983151983150983139983148983157983140983145983150983143 R983141983142983148983141983139983156983145983151983150983155

How do we go about developing a model for glocal conversations izon hasrecently provided a useful model that is instructive as we seek to learn from

the Majority World It has at least two key features

First the local is in the global (globalization from below) Global theologies

and ideas have origins in many particular local contexts In that sense glo-

balization is from below Global ideas have local roots Ideas about integral

mission liberation theology and missional church have local origins Tey

have their roots in the prayers hopes discoveries mission and theologiesof thousands of local communities ldquoTe global does not cannot exist

without the localmdashbut the coming together of localities creates a global re-

ality that becomes greater than the sum of its parts it creates a gestalt entity

to which localities make themselves accountablerdquo1048626983092

Second the global is in the local (panlocalization from above) Te con-

cerns and voices of multitudes of locales form global conversations Tese

global discussions can provide a ldquopositive accountabilityrdquo back to local con-texts Tis is true when they enrich affirm serve guide and strengthen local

contexts It is also true when they avoid homogenization control impo-

sition and judgment Glocalization is best when it sees itself as interde-

pendent deeply connected with the local10486261048629

Tatrsquos a helpful starting point But we need to go further Besides izonrsquos

proposals Irsquom convinced that robust glocal conversations cultivate six core

practices

983089 Glocal theology practices its values We root glocal theology in core

values Tese values include solidarity understanding and mutual learning

Do we value fellowship with Christians of all cultures Do we value learning

from them

We prove our values through our practices What practices emerge out of

these values We need to collaborate act collectively and share information

We must find ways to foster grassroots perspectives and local theologies We

need to share stories and learnings and cultivate networks relationships and

partnerships We need attentiveness to local voices and global themes We

24Ibid 9830901048625983088-1048625104862825Ibid 98309010486251048628-1048625983096

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3136

10486271048632 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

ought to find ways to put these local and global voices into conversation

Mutual learning humility and solidarity are key Worthwhile glocal con-

versations can never be merely theoretical or academic It is up to us to rootour values in our practices

983090 Glocal theology practices humility (and it tells a new narrative) We

have noted that the local is in the global and the global is in the local Te

two are interdependent Tey form each other reciprocally Since this is the

case we must practice humility Tere is no place for ethnocentrism colo-

nialism or theological and cultural arrogance I have seen these unhealthy

postures far too oen in Western settingsRecently I attended a missional leadership conference On that occasion

the keynote speakermdasha leading missional author and speakermdashsaid that

North American missional conversations and innovations hold the key to

the future of the Western church Tis Euro American view is wrong (Irsquom

being kind o be frank itrsquos complete nonsense) Itrsquos arrogant and Euro

Americanndashcentric And itrsquos completely out of step with what is happening in

the glocal church We need a new narrativeIn June 1048626104862410486251048627 Te Center for the Study of Global Christianity reported

the top 10486261048624 countries where Christianity has the highest percentage growth

rate Nineteen of the top twenty are in Asia and Africa Eleven of them are

in Muslim majority countries Not a single country from Europe or North

America makes the top twenty list10486261048630

Itrsquos time to cultivate a new narrative Te future of the church is emerging

from the Majority World Rather than North America the churches of

Eastern Asia Western Africa the Arabian Peninsula and other parts of the

Majority World reveal the future of the global church We need the contribu-

tions of all contexts Western indigenous and Majority World All con-

tribute to glocal conversations All are important as we learn from each

other about mission theology and faith But letrsquos stop pretending that North

Americans and Europeans will reveal the future of the global church Letrsquos

start listening to what God is saying about the future of the global church

And hersquos speaking to us through the churches of Asia Africa Latin America

26Russ Mitchell ldquoTe op 983090983088 Countries Where Christianity Is Growing the Fastestrdquo Disciple All

Nations (blog) August 983090983093 98309098308810486251048627 httpsdiscipleallnationswordpresscom98309098308810486251048627983088983096983090983093the-top

-983090983088-countries-where-christianity-is-growing-the-astest

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3236

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048633

Muslim majority settings and so on We must cultivate a new glocal nar-

rativemdashone soaked in humility

Glocal theology must be humble theology Meek theology Receptive the-ology Discerning theology Prayerful theology Dialogical theology De-

pendent theology A theology that celebrates the interdependence between

the localparticular and the globaluniversal

983091 Glocal theology practices expansiveness Glocalization is by nature

comprehensive Local and global influences permeate much of our lives Tese

glocal forces shape our theologies and churches whether we like it or not

But intentionality is also important We need to commit to an expansiveapproach to glocal theology How do we deliberately cultivate glocal conver-

sations in our biblical interpretation Do we foster them in our under-

standing of the person and work of Christ How does glocalization shape

the way the Spirit empowers and constitutes the church How can it form

our understanding of the nature and mission of the rinity How does it

influence the way we practice fellowship and conversation across denomi-

national cultural ethnic economic sociocultural political gender andtheological divides How might it shape our theologies of mission com-

munity beauty spirituality suffering discipleship hospitality eco-justice

place education social ethics Christian leadership and so forth

983092 Glocal theology practices attention Glocal theology doesnrsquot need to

accept all the assumptions or assertions of postcolonial or Majority World

thought But it does need to engage with them and take them seriously

Postcolonial theology for instance gives the marginalized and colonized

and forgotten and silenced both dignity and voice Our glocal conversations

must also include and esteem these groups We need to be attentive to

others weak and powerful female and male dominant and downtrodden

old and young rich and poor privileged and marginalized influential and

subaltern educated and illiterate We need to practice the art of attention

being especially attentive to those who are different to us

983093 Glocal theology practices embrace What do colonial ethnocentric or

Western-centric perspectives do Tey silence Tey control Tey com-

modify Tey institutionalize Tey colonize Tey domesticate Tey replace

Tey import Tey exclude Tey do these things to the beliefs experiences

and practices of other cultures A worthwhile glocal theology refuses to do

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3336

10486281048624 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

these things Instead it adopts a responsive humble celebratory open in-

clusive and embracing attitude

983094 Glocal theology practices discernment Finally we need discernmentas we engage these ideas and practices Discernment is a huge topic thatrsquos

hard to cover comprehensively in a few words Discernment happens when

the Spirit of Christ and his Word renew our minds Te Spirit grants us

spiritual wisdom as we meditate on him and his Word and as we practice

discipleship to Jesus Christ Romans 10486251048626 provides guidance we need (1048625) to be

transformed by the renewal of our minds (1048626) to serve Christrsquos body and (1048627)

to put love into action Discernment also happens in conversation both lo-cally and glocally

I pray these core values and six practices come across in the following

chapters of GlobalChurch

Glocalization can never be just theoretical Are we committed to moving

glocalization from an abstract idea to a living communion Are we deter-

mined to construct a missional theology of the church in the context of

glocal conversations Tis must involve dialogue between Majority Worldindigenous and Western scholars activists and groups

Will glocalization be an abstract notion Or will it be a formative and

genuine communion between local regional and global voices Glocal dy-

namics are at play whether we like it or not Teyrsquore in our churches the-

ologies and missions But we can choose to relinquish isolationist colonial

parochial and arrogant approaches Instead we can adopt responsive dia-

logical learning humble and embracing postures

Trough healthy approaches to glocalization the Spirit challenges us to

value local contexts We immerse ourselves in local and particular commu-

nities and conversations He inspires us to open ourselves to global theo-

logical conversations He rouses us to value the symbiotic relationship be-

tween the localparticular and the globaluniversal

Trough glocal relationships the Spirit leads us to put local contextual

theologies into conversation with global ones He prompts us to explore the

ways in which the local is in the glocal and the global is in the local He per-

suades us to pursue collaboration and dialogue and mutual learning We

engage with Christians from different backgrounds and cultures ecumen-

icals Pentecostals evangelicals and so on from Western indigenous and

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3436

Glocalizing Conversations 10486281048625

Majority World contexts He motivates us to express solidarity between all

parties We appreciate our unity in diversity

Trough glocal conversations the Spirit moves us to ensure that unity andsolidarity emerge from a compelling vision of Jesusrsquo kingdom and gospel

and person He challenges us to share information theology and practices

He urges us to learn from each othermdashour successes and mistakes We seek

glocal solutions

Te Spirit calls us to develop glocal conversations about Christian ideas

and practices Tese include Scripture Evangelicalism ecumenism Pente-

costalism Jesus Christ the Holy Spirit God the Father the rinity com-munity spirituality discipleship liturgy worship hospitality prayer eco-

justice education social ethics Christian leadership gospel and culture

beauty place suffering liberation and so forth

Finally through glocal conversations the Spirit leads us to adopt a new

posture Tis is a responsive humble celebratory open inclusive and em-

bracing attitude to the ldquootherrdquo We do this as a new people made up of every

tribe and language and people and nationTere are dangers in glocalization Sugirtharajah warns of the commodi-

fication of local contextual practices and theologies When this happens

they are ldquosmoothed out of their primary contexts concerns and contesta-

tions travel across borders and become objects of analysis and scrutiny

within an alien secondary contextrdquo1048626983095

Itrsquos common for those of us who are Western to make mistakes when we

wrestle with Majority World and indigenous ideas Sugirtharajah mentions

our tendency to commodify reduce and institutionalize these ideas We also

risk doing these things (1048625) We apply them in noncontextual prescriptive ways

(1048626) We ignore their meanings in their original setting (1048627) We glamorize or

idealize their proponents or their contexts (1048628) We demonize those persons or

contexts (1048629) We disregard them as irrelevant rhetorical or minority discourse

Kevin J Vanhoozer says that we can fall into three traps when we glo-

calize theology (1048625) We can underestimate the theological significance of

local cultures (1048626) We can homogenize cultures and theologies exaggerating

27R S Sugirtharajah ldquoextual ake-Aways Tird World exts in Western Metropolitan Centresrdquo

Black Teology in Britain A Journal o Contextual Praxis 983090 (1048625983097983097983097) 10486271048627 10486271048631 Edward W Said Te

World the ext and the Critic (Cambridge MA Harvard University Press 10486259830979830961048627) 9830901048627983097

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3536

10486281048626 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

ldquothe onerdquo (1048627) We can overemphasize cultural particularity exaggerating ldquothe

manyrdquo and pursue ldquotheological ethnificationrdquo10486261048632

My hope is that GlobalChurch does not fall into the traps Sugirtharajahand Vanhoozer describe I hope that what unfolds in the following chapters

is respectful and discerning I hope it leads to further mutually enriching

conversations between people of different cultures

You the reader face the same challenges You face them in your personal

life ministry context and missional engagements

Will you treat the themes in this book as abstract theoretical notions

Will this be a temporary infatuation a flirtation with the ldquootherrdquo that dissi-pates as suddenly as it arrived Or will glocal conversations become an en-

riching and formative orientation in your life Will glocal conversations

bring fresh approaches to theology faith mission church and worship Will

conversations with other cultures and theologies become for you a com-

pelling way of life

My prayer is that glocal conversations will help the church be a global

visible alternative ldquocity set upon a hillrdquo a truly GlobalChurch

28Craig Ott and Harold A Netland Globalizing Teology Belie and Practice in an Era o World

Christianity (Grand Rapids Baker Academic 983090983088983088983094) 1048625983090983093

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3636

Page 5: GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 536

C O N T E N T S

List of Figures and ables 983097

Foreword by Scot McKnight 983089983089

983089 Introduction Being Salt Light and a City 983089983091

Part 983089 Salt Reshaping Our Conversations

983090 Glocalizing Conversations 983090983091

Part 983090 Light Renewing Our Mission

983091 Contextualizing Mission 983092983093

983092 Liberating People 983094983097

983093 Showing Hospitality 983097983095

983094 Embracing the Spirit 983089983089983097

983095 Caring for Creation 983089983093983095

983096 Living Ethically 983089983096983091

983097 ransforming Neighborhoods 983090983089983093

Part 983091 City Revitalizing Our Churches

983089983088 Indigenizing Faith 983090983091983095

983089983089 Devouring Scripture 983090983095983093

983089983090 Renewing Education 983091983088983089

983089983091 Practicing Servantship 983091983091983095

983089983092 Recovering Community 983091983094983091

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 636

983089983093 Developing Spirituality and Discipleship 983091983096983091

983089983094 GlobalChurch Embracing a New Narrative 983092983089983093

Appendix 983089 GlobalChurch Project Video Series 983092983093983089

Appendix 983090 Study Guide 983092983093983091

Appendix 983091 Who Are hese Majority World

and Indigenous hinkers 983092983096983089

Appendix 983092 Resources and Glossary at

heGlobalChurchProjectcom 983092983097983091

Author Index 983092983097983093

Subject Index 983092983097983097

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 736

I N T R O D U C T I O N

B983141983145983150983143 S983137983148983156 L983145983143983144983156 983137983150983140 983137 C983145983156 983161

By 9830909830889830901048629 fully two-thirds of Christians will live in

Africa Latin America and Asia Te ldquoaverage

Christianrdquo today is female black and lives in a

Brazilian favela or an African village

SEPHE N BEVANS

Majority World and indigenous churches are redefining twenty-first-

century Christianity Western churches must decide how theyrsquoll respond

Stephen Bevans puts it well

We are now living in a ldquoworld churchrdquo where the vast majority of Christians are

[from the Majority World] David Barrettrsquos statistical studies have basically con-

firmed this shi and Philip Jenkins has predicted that by 1048626104862410486261048629 fully two-thirds

of Christians will live in Africa Latin America and Asia Scholars are fairly

unanimous in acknowledging the accuracy of the facts Te ldquoaverage Christianrdquo

today is female black and lives in a Brazilian favela or an African village983089

Some statistics illustrate this shi in twenty-first-century global Christi-

anity Te Pew Research Centerrsquos report Global Christianity analyzes the size

and distribution of the worldrsquos Christian population Te report maps the

changes over the last century (1048625104863310486251048624 to 1048626104862410486251048624) It concludes ldquoA century ago the

Global North (commonly defined as North America Europe Australia Japan

1Stephen B Bevans Roger Schroeder and L J Luzbetak ldquoMissiology Afer Bosch Reverencing a

Classic by Moving Beyondrdquo International Bulletin o Missionary Research 983090983097 no 983090 (983090983088983088983093) 983094983097

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 836

10486251048628 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

and New Zealand) contained more than four times as many Christians as the

Global South (the rest of the world) oday the Pew Forum study finds more

than 10486251048627 billion Christians live in the Global South [10486301048625983077 of all Christians livein Asia Africa and Latin America] compared with about 104863210486301048624 million in the

Global North (10486271048633983077)rdquo1048626 Tat is an astounding shi in only one hundred years983091

Using the World Christian Database Philip Jenkins offers table 10486251048625

ldquoChanging distribution of Christian believersrdquo

Table 983089983089 Changing distribution of Christian believers 983089983097983088983088 to 983090983088983093983088 (number of Christiansin millions)

983089983097983088983088 983089983097983095983088 983090983088983089983088 983090983088983093983088Africa 983089983088 983089983092983091 983092983097983091 983089983088983091983089

Asia 983090983090 983097983094 983091983093983090 983094983088983089

North America 983095983097 983090983089983089 983090983096983094 983091983091983091

Latin America 983094983090 983090983095983088 983093983092983092 983094983093983093

Europe 983091983096983089 983092983097983090 983093983096983096 983093983091983088

Oceania 983093 983089983096 983090983096 983091983096

Total 983093983093983096 983089983090983091983088 983090983090983097983089 983091983089983096983096

Source Philip Jenkins The Next Christendom The Coming of Global Christianity 983091rd ed (Oxford Oxford Uni-

versity Press 983090983088983089983089) 983091 Data is taken from World Christian Database wwwworldchristiandatabaseorgwcd

Christianity in North America Europe and Oceania grew from 104862810486301048629

million in 1048625104863310486241048624 to 104863310486241048626 million in 1048626104862410486251048624983092 Tis number is likely to shrink to

104863310486241048625 million by 1048626104862410486291048624

Christianity in Africa Asia and Latin America grew from 10486331048628 million in

1048625104863310486241048624 to 1048625104862710486321048633 billion in 1048626104862410486251048624 Tis number is likely to grow to 1048626104862610486321048631 billion by

1048626104862410486291048624

Letrsquos take China for example Professor Fenggang Yang of Purdue University

makes an important prediction If current rates of growth continue within one

generation China will have more Christians than any other nation on earth

In 1048625104863310486281048633 Protestant churches in China had one million members In 1048626104862410486251048624 that

number was 10486291048632 million (compare that with 10486281048624 million in Brazil and 10486271048630 million

2Pew Research Center Global Christianity A Report on the Size and Distribution o the Worldrsquos Chris-

tian Population December 1048625983097 98309098308810486251048625 wwwpeworumorg9830909830881048625104862510486259830901048625983097global-christianity-exec3See David B Barrett George Kurian and odd M Johnson World Christian Encyclopedia A

Comparative Survey o Churches and Religions in the Modern World 983090nd ed 983090 vols (New York

Oxord University Press 9830909830889830881048625) 1048625983090-1048625983093 and wwwglobalchristianityorg4Oceania includes Australia and Micronesian Melanesian and Polynesian countries

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 936

Introduction 10486251048629

in South Africa) By 1048626104862410486261048629 there are likely to be 104862510486301048624 million Christians in China

By 1048626104862410486271048624 this number is likely to be 104862610486281048631 million (outnumbering Christians in

Mexico Brazil and the United States) In an interview with the elegraphFenggang Yang says ldquoMao thought he could eliminate religion He thought he

had accomplished this Itrsquos ironicmdashthey didnrsquot Tey actually failed completelyrdquo1048629

Philip Jenkins concludes

We are currently living through one of the transforming moments in the

history of religion worldwide Over the last five centuries the story of Chris-

tianity has been inextricably bound up with that of Europe and European-

derived civilizations overseas above all in North America Until recently theoverwhelming majority of Christians have lived in white nations Over the

last century however the center of gravity in the Christian world has shied

inexorably away from Europe southward to Africa and Latin America and

eastward toward Asia oday the largest Christian communities on the planet

are to be found in those regions1048630

What does all this mean for the mission and theology and worship and

communities of the church worldwide And what does it mean particularlyfor the Western church

In Matthew 104862910486251048627-10486251048630 Jesus provides three remarkable images of the churchmdash

salt light and a city Jesus confronts his disciples with a missional description

of the church Te church in mission is the salt of the earth the light of the

world and a city set on a hill Te churchrsquos purpose is to let its ldquolight shine

before others that they may see your good deeds and glorify your Father in

heavenrdquo Te purpose of the churchrsquos missionary nature is the worship andglorification of the Father and Son and Holy Spirit983095

Te church is another city constituted by every tribe language people

5om Phillips ldquoChina on Course to Become lsquoWorldrsquos Most Christian Nationrsquo Within 1048625983093 Yearsrdquo

elegraph April 1048625983097 98309098308810486251048628 wwwtelegraphcouknewsworldnewsasiachina1048625983088104863110486319830949830889830901048627China-on

-course-to-become-worlds-most-Christian-nation-within-1048625983093-yearshtml See Fenggang Yang and

Joseph B amney eds Conucianism and Spiritual raditions in Modern China and Beyond Re-

ligion in Chinese Societies (Boston Brill 9830909830881048625983090) Fenggang Yang and Graeme Lang eds Social

Scientific Studies o Religion in China Methodology Teories and Findings (Leiden Brill 98309098308810486251048625)

Fenggang Yang Religion in China Survival and Revival Under Communist Rule (Oxord Oxord

University Press 9830909830881048625983090)6Philip Jenkins Te Next Christendom Te Coming o Global Christianity 1048627rd ed (Oxord Ox-

ord University Press 98309098308810486251048625) 10486257J Driver Images o the Church in Mission (Scottdale PA Herald 10486259830979830971048631) 10486251048631983088-9830961048625 Graham Hill Salt

Light and a City Introducing Missional Ecclesiology (Eugene OR Wip and Stock 9830909830881048625983090) xiii

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1036

10486251048630 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

and nation Te church must cultivate a distinct social existence shaping its

community and mission around its commitment to plurality and diversity

and unity1048632 God calls his church to be a global and missional ldquocity on a hillrdquoTis is a church constituted and enriched and represented by Western and

indigenous and Majority World peoples

Tose of us in the West need a new narrative Itrsquos time to abandon our

flawed Eurocentric and Americentric worldviews We need a new global

and missional narrative and for that we must turn to the churches of Ma-

jority World and indigenous cultures Tey can help us explore what it

means to be a global missional community Many Christian communitiesin Majority World and indigenous contexts have been wrestling with these

issues for generations Marginalization and persecution and alienation have

been their lot Yet somehow in spite of or because of that they have flour-

ished In fact theyrsquove grown exponentially

So whom am I talking about when I refer to Majority World and indig-

enous Christians Majority World Christians are those in Africa Asia the

Caribbean Eastern Europe Latin America the Middle East and Oceania

1048633

I use the term Majority World because the majority of the worldrsquos population

is in those cultures today Te majority of the church is in those cultures too

I donrsquot use the terms non-Western or Tird World or Developing World Tese

terms use Western cultures as their point of reference Tey imply Western

8Barry A Harvey Another City An Ecclesiological Primer or a Post-Christian World (New York

rinity 1048625983097983097983097) 9830901048627-9830909830939I donrsquot deal with the diasporas in this book For example Irsquove made no mention o Hispanic

Portuguese or Asian minorities in the United States United Kingdom Canada Europe Austra-lia and so on Irsquom aware that right now Latin American and Chinese diasporas are active in

evangelism and mission in Europe in the same way in which the Filipino or the Salvadoran dias-

poras carry on mission in the United States Irsquove chosen not to include voices rom the diasporas

mainly because there are so many worthy contributors in that group and I donrsquot have the space

to treat them well in this book In the uture I hope that I (or someone else) will write a book

exploring what we can learn rom the diasporas Hispanic minorities or example are making

significant contributions to the theological and missiological conversation in the United States

that are relevant to this subject Methodist historian Justo L Gonzaacutelez and Pentecostal theologian

Eldin Villaantildee are examples In Mantildeana Gonzaacutelez describes the shape and orm o a theology

developed in the Hispanic margin o the United States In Out o Every ribe and Nation he shows

what would be implied in listening to minorities within a denominational setting Villaantildeersquos Te

Liberating Spirit is a milestone in the reflection about the relationship between pneumatology and

social ethics See Justo L Gonzaacutelez Out o Every ribe and Nation Christian Teology at the

Ethnic Roundtable (Nashville Abingdon 1048625983097983097983090) Gonzaacutelez Mantildeana Christian Teology rom a

Hispanic Perspective (Nashville Abingdon 1048625983097983097983088) Eldin Villaantildee Te Liberating Spirit oward

an Hispanic American Pentecostal Social Ethic (Grand Rapids Eerdmans 10486259830979830971048627)

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1136

Introduction 10486251048631

superiority or centricity Te term Global South is too limiting given the

breadth of the group I am engaging Majority World seems to work best

In 1048626104862410486241048628 Te Lausanne Forum for World Evangelization in PattayaTailand voted unanimously that the phrase Majority World Church replace

other terms People from all over the globe participated in this forum

imothy C ennent agrees that this is the best phrase ldquoIt helps to highlight

the basic point that Africa Asia and Latin America are where the majority

of the worldrsquos Christians are now locatedrdquo9830891048624 I expand the phrase Majority

World beyond Africa Asia and Latin America to include the Caribbean

Eastern Europe Oceania and the Middle EastIndigenous and First Nations peoples are ldquothose ethnic groups that were

indigenous to a territory prior to being incorporated into a national state

and who are politically and culturally separate from the majority ethnic

identity of the state that they are a part ofrdquo Tis includes people groups like

the Australian Aborigines and American Indians983089983089

Te aim of this book is to help Western churches rediscover what it means

to be salt light and a city by engaging in global missional conversations odo this Western Christians need to enter into conversation with Majority

World and indigenous Christians Listening to others helps us grow in our

understanding and practice of mission and church and theology For far too

long wersquove marginalized or ignored Majority World and indigenous voices

We must truly become a GlobalChurch

Tis aim shapes the bookrsquos structure as summarized below

P983137983154983156 1048625 S983137983148983156 R983141983155983144983137983152983145983150983143 O983157983154 C983151983150983158983141983154983155983137983156983145983151983150983155

ldquoYou are the salt of the earth But if the salt loses its saltiness how can it be made

salty again It is no longer good for anything except to be thrown out and

trampled underfootrdquo Globally and locally you are the salt of the earth Be salt

Salt preserves seasons flavors and purifies We are salt when we glorify

the Father Son and Holy Spirit in our mission worship faith hope truth

and love We are salt when we reject a Eurocentric or Americentric vision

10imothy C ennent Teology in the Context o World Christianity How the Global Church Is

Influencing the Way We Tink About and Discuss Teology (Grand Rapids Zondervan 9830909830889830881048631) xx11Douglas Sanders ldquoIndigenous Peoples Issues o Definitionrdquo International Journal o Cultural

Property 983096 no 1048625 (1048625983097983097983097) 1048628

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1236

10486251048632 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

of the church and become the global missional church Christ envisioned

In part one I show how Western conversations are impoverished and

insufficient in isolation from indigenous and Majority World Christians Weenhance our ldquosaltinessrdquo through local-global ( glocal ) exchanges o do this

we must reshape our conversations We need global and local exchanges that

we characterize by mutuality respect partnership and symbiosis Such ex-

changes help us learn from each other whether wersquore in Western indig-

enous or Majority World settings It helps us stay ldquosaltyrdquo It enables us to

pursue global missional theology and practice Globally and locally we can

pursue missional vitality and truly be ldquothe salt of the earthrdquo

P983137983154983156 1048626 L983145983143983144983156 R983141983150983141983159983145983150983143 O983157983154 M983145983155983155983145983151983150

ldquoYou are the light of the world A city on a hill cannot be hidden Neither do

people light a lamp and put it under a bowl Instead they put it on its stand and

it gives light to everyone in the house In the same way let your light shine

before others that they may see your good deeds and glorify your Father in

heavenrdquo (Mt 104862910486251048628-10486251048631) Globally and locally you are the light of the world Be lightLight illuminates reveals and dispels darkness Te church is light when

it does good deedsmdashhealing and liberating and redemptive deeds Itrsquos light

when its being and faith and deeds bring glorify to the Father Te church

is light when it participates in Godrsquos redemptive mission in the world as a

global missional community

o do this we must renew our mission In part two I explore how indig-

enous and Majority World Christians teach us to renew mission We renew

mission through contextualization liberation hospitality Spirit empow-

erment creation care ethics and the transformation of neighborhoods

P983137983154983156 1048627 C983145983156983161 R983141983158983145983156983137983148983145983162983145983150983143 O983157983154 C983144983157983154983139983144983141983155

You are a city set on a hill ldquoA city on a hill cannot be hiddenrdquo Globally and

locally you are a city set on a hill Be a city set on a hill

Tis means that we are an alternative and countercultural movement We

have a distinct culture and politic and social existence We are a people

gathered from every tribe language people and nation We are in the world

but not of the world We are in the world but distinct from the world We are

within the world and for the sake of the world

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1336

Introduction 10486251048633

o be this kind of alternative city or culture we must renew our mission

community ethics and worship We need to pursue the revitalization of our

churches so that they are distinct And by distinct I mean an alternative city(altera civitas)

We are a ldquocity on a hillrdquo that witnesses to Jesus Christ and his eternal kingdom

when we are a global missional church In part three I demonstrate how indig-

enous and Majority World Christians teach us to revitalize churches We revi-

talize churches by indigenizing faith devouring Scripture renewing education

practicing servantship (servant leadership) recovering community and devel-

oping spirituality and discipleship We inspire our churches when we developour theology and practices relating to beauty and the arts9830891048626

In the final chapter I wrap things up by addressing an important question

In light of all the material covered in this book what would it now look like

to engage in global missional theology ecclesiology interpretation history

pneumatology worship and education

Herersquos how you can get the most out of this book

Community You can read this book alone in a small group with somefriends at home or at a coffee shop or as part of a ministry team However

you get a lot more out of this book when you read it with others ogether

you can think about the bookrsquos implications What do the chapters mean for

your ministry church agency family or team

GlobalChurch Project video series Irsquove made a video series to go along with

this book Appendix one has the details

Study guide Yoursquoll get a lot more out of this book if you spend time

working through the study guide in appendix two ry to do this in a group

Te study guide includes reflection questions suggested practices and

Further Reading

Characters As you read this book yoursquoll come across names and people

yoursquove never heard of before For a glimpse of who they are and what issues

concern them see appendix three

My website o help you get the most out of this book Irsquove included more

resources on my website TeGlobalChurchProjectcom Tese include

videos reading lists important links a glossary and other resources Irsquove

12Irsquove put a separate chapter on the theme o beauty and the arts on my website Itrsquos additional to

this book

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1436

10486261048624 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

also provided ways that you can contact me See appendix four

In my first book Salt Light and a City I developed a missional theology

of the church I did this in conversation with twelve theologians from the fourmajor Christian traditions Tat volume offered a window into the thought of

European and American theologians It showed how they are making sense

of the nature and mission of the church in their Western cultural context

Te book that yoursquore now reading takes a different approach I have

stepped away from European and American voices I now ask What can

those in the Majority World and indigenous cultures teach us in the West

What can they teach us about the churchrsquos mission worship theology andcommunity Te quality and quantity of material coming out of the Ma-

jority World is astonishing Any theology that ignores the insights of indig-

enous and Majority World Christians is deficient and impoverished

White middle-class European North American tertiary-educated men

dominate Western theology Tey dominate the Western missional conver-

sation I know I fit that profile Tis group still monopolizes missional church

conferences and seminars Tey get all the book contracts In fact this groupstill controls theology and the church in many settings But this is changing

New voices are rising Tese include women minorities the poor indigenous

groups and Majority World leaders Missional conversations arenrsquot attentive

to the Spirit and to Godrsquos mission if they ignore these voices Majority World

and indigenous churches oen have extraordinary missional vitality Openness

to other voices needs to happen now It is time for Western churches theol-

ogies and mission to mature and to reflect Godrsquos global mission

In this book I could have consulted the work of many thousands of in-

digenous and Majority World thinkers and writers and practitioners But I

have limited myself to a sample of those who speak directly to its themes

Tese African Asian Eastern European Middle Eastern Caribbean Latin

American First Nation and indigenous thinkers challenge us Tey dare us

to examine our theologies and missions and churches And they inspire us

to renew the worship and community and mission of Jesusrsquo church Tey

stir us to think in fresh ways about what it means to be salt light and a city

Tey help us become a global missional churchmdasha truly GlobalChurch

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1536

PA R T O N E

S A L TReshaping Our Conversations

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1636

G L O C A L I Z I N G

C O N V E R S A T I O N S

H983151983159 D983151 W983141 D983141983158983141983148983151983152

G983148983151983139983137983148 C983151983150983158983141983154983155983137983156983145983151983150983155983103

Rather than taking one contextual version of the Gospel and imposing

it as the Gospel throughout the world via the missionary enterprise

the shapers of Mission as ransformation have recognized the

plurality of localities that has created an intercontextual

ldquopan-localrdquo global phenomenon in theology

AL IZON

The International Society for Urban Mission (ISUM) is a group of urban

missionaries who are passionate about cultivating hope and love and re-newal in cities Irsquove connected with this group for some years ISUM held its

first annual Summit on Integral Urban Mission in Bangkok Tailand Te

team from Urban Neighbours of Hope (UNOH) under the leadership of

my Australian friends Ash and Anj Barker organized much of the summit

UNOH teams covenant with God and each other to ldquolive out our passion for

loving God and neighbour Focus on releasing neighbourhoods from urban

poverty Grow through equipping each other neighbours and the broader

church to radically follow Jesus and join Godrsquos Kingdom coming UNOH

workers live and serve in small responsive neighbourhood-based teamsrdquo983089

1See wwwunohorg

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1736

10486261048628 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

Tis summit involved interactive participatory hands-on immersion op-

portunities keynotes lectures and workshops Keynote speakers came from

Africa Australia Myanmar New Zealand North America the PhilippinesSouth America Tailand and First Nations A few hundred Majority World

and Western thinkers and activists came together for those days Tey explored

the theology and practices of integral transformational and urban mission

Tese thinkers and activists pursued a range of aims1048626 Tis included col-

laboration between urban Christians from a variety of backgrounds (Ma-

jority World and Western theologians activists ecumenicals Pentecostals

evangelicals colleges church movements and development agencies) Teyaimed for collective action and thought in an international and integral

context Tey sought to gain mutual understanding for a comprehensive

picture of urban mission around the globe Tey encouraged information

sharing and best practicesmdashlearning from our mistakes and seeking solu-

tions Tey developed recommendations and calls to action to the broader

church Working groups wrote briefing papers aer each summit based on

key issues in urban mission And they endeavored to build trust wisdomand inspiration to better engage our new urban world

Majority World and Western leaders participated in discussion prayer

integral mission and working groups Te goal was to grapple with key issues

and ask key questions How do we recruit equip and sustain urban mission

today How do we release church movements among the urban poor How

can we immerse ourselves in and transform urban neighborhoods How do

we empower urban children and young people How does the church serve

and liberate the oppressedmdashand others suffering from urban injustice What

needs to happen for poorer urban centers to develop economically socially

and spiritually How do we join God in the challenges and opportunities of

multifaith cities

Workshops included urban gardening child protection and collaborating

with local churches in urban mission Workshops also included organic

church growth and mission as well as developing NGO and government

partnerships Groups considered the good the bad and the ugly of short-

term urban mission teams

2Tese aims are detailed at ldquoInternational Society or Urban Mission Summitrdquo httpnewurbanworld

orgsummit

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1836

Glocalizing Conversations 10486261048629

Te summit was a thrilling example of how Majority World and Western

leaders can cooperate It was a time to come together in an environment of

mutual learning and enrichment It was a window into how local contextsand global themes can enrich each other Tis resulted from ISUMrsquos com-

mitment to ldquosolidarity fellowship and insight between urban Christian

leaders in the Western and Majority Worldsrdquo

Te summit was a success due to ISUMrsquos core values What are they983091 Christ-

honoring urban mission values bottom-up grassroots perspectivesmdashrather

than top-down distanced perspectives It allows local theology to reveal new

insights and perspectives about Godrsquos activity It shares insights and experi-ences through narratives embedded within urban poor communities and cities

It cultivates ongoing practical and personal solidarity with the worldrsquos urban

poor Tis Spirit-empowered urban mission honors networks relationships

and partnerships It sees such relationships as the primary method of serving

together It listens to and amplifies the voices of the urban poormdashespecially

those from the Majority World and in particular the 1048625104862410486281048624 window cities It is

attentive to signs of the kingdom of God Urban mission that glorifies God iswilling to reflect and respond with active and sacrificial commitment It shares

and extends the life of the body of Christ among the urban poor

Tis summit was a milestone in urban missiology It enriched communi-

cation between Western and Majority World thinker-activists Tis resulted

from the aims and values Irsquove mentioned Effective urban mission needs to

be a conversation on many levels It is attentive to context and immersed in

local settings It appreciates global and universal missional themes It culti-

vates dialogue between these local-global (glocal) realities It involves

mutual learning between Western and Majority World thinker-activists

Moreover solidarity between all parties is a defining feature Tis solidarity

is due to a compelling vision of the kingdom of God

Tese collaborative glocal features of the ISUM urban mission summit

in Bangkok are critical for the aims of this book GlobalChurch

Majority World indigenous and Western leaders thinkers and churches

can stretch and enrich each other But they need to be open and attentive to

each other Tey need learning postures and open hearts and minds Tey

3ldquoAbout ISUMrdquo httpnewurbanworldorgabout

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1936

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2036

Glocalizing Conversations 10486261048631

always rooted in the local and particularmdashas local churches embody the

gospel and witness to Christ Tese churches forge their own theological

understandings as they do mission together Tey engage in transformationalpractices among the people in their settings Tey enjoy worship mission

and community in their local and particular context Ideally the result is

unique contextual theologies and missions

Simultaneously global conversations form Tey form because of this

multitude of local theologies and practices Local conversations inform and

enrich other local conversations catalyzing global themes and voices izon

observes that the global ldquoowes its existence to local contexts Sharedconvictions among the theologies and practices of local contextual realities

give shape to its global dimensionsrdquo1048629

Majority World indigenous and Western theologies are equally contextual

Tey are equally culture bound Tey are equally particular to their time and

location At times they are all enlightened or myopic liberating or con-

straining humanizing or objectifying beautiful or offensive prophetic or

tepid Te local particular and cultural shape all these theologies Converselythese particular theologies feed and influence global conversations Tere is

no place then for ethnocentrism colonialism or elitism Tere is no place

for theological missional cultural or institutionalized arrogance

Multiple local contexts and voices come togethermdashintentionally or notmdashto

form global themes and theologies Conversely these global realities shape

local contexts oday local contexts must grapple with ldquoan emerging global

culture ie the interacting realities of modernity postmodernity and the

phenomenon of globalizationrdquo1048630 Hence the interdependent and symbiotic

relationship between the localparticular and the globaluniversal We call this

interdependent relationship between the local and the global glocalization

Te global church needs a thrilling glocal exchange We need one that we

characterize by mutuality respect partnership and symbiosis Such ex-

change helps Majority World indigenous and Western churches learn from

each other It enables them to pursue missional theology and practice o-

gether the church becomes a ldquocity on a hillrdquo

5Ibid 10486259830886Ibid 9830961048628

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2136

10486261048632 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

W983144983137983156 R983141983153983157983145983154983141983155 G983148983151983139983137983148983145983162983137983156983145983151983150983103

Te glocal exchange described above needs to be broader than transforma-

tional mission Tis is necessary if the church is to develop a robust inter-cultural and glocal missional ecclesiology

In my first book Salt Light and a City I outlined the foundational

themes of missional ecclesiology983095 Majority World and Western leaders

need to engage these themes in local and contextual ways Teir insights can

then enrich global conversations Tese global conversations in turn shape

local understandings and practices Tis way a glocal appreciation of these

themes emergesLocal regional and global theologies and practices are thereby enriched

Te church becomes healthier and more missionalmdasha truer expression of

the kingdom Te church becomes a fuller witness to Christ his passion for

the nations and his ability to bring unity in diversity

Stephen Bevans and Roger Schroeder outline the six constants of mission

Tese are our theologies about Jesus the church the end times salvation

human nature and culture Bevans and Schroeder describe the relationshipbetween these six and their historical cultural and theological contexts Tis is

why they call these six constants in context Our understanding of these six

constants develops in relation to local and global movements Sometimes local

voices influence our understandings of these six Other times it is regional or

global voices For all of us local regional and global influences are at play at

once Collectively they form our appreciation of the six constants of mission1048632

Here are eight theological themes that the church can develop through

processes of glocalization I presented these in my book Salt Light and a City

Tey are vital to the churchrsquos health mission community and future We

could add many other themes to these eight but these will suffice for now1048633

Scripture Te Scriptures are the infallible authoritative Word of God

Christrsquos Spirit has inspired them Tey have absolute and final authority in

all aspects of corporate and individual faith ethics conduct and witness

Christians interpret and apply Scripture in local contexts and in particular

7Graham Hill Salt Light and a City Introducing Missional Ecclesiology (Eugene OR Wip and

Stock 9830909830881048625983090) 10486251048628983097-983090104863110486288Stephen B Bevans and Roger Schroeder Constants in Context A Teology o Mission or oday

American Society o Missiology Series (Maryknoll NY Orbis 9830909830889830881048628) part one9Tese points first appeared in my book Salt Light and a City xxii-xxiv

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2236

Glocalizing Conversations 10486261048633

social settings Conversely we learn from the interpretations and readings

of other groups

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our local- global theology of Scripture and biblical interpretation

Evangelicalism Pentecostalism missional movements and so forth I

have charismatic missional and evangelical convictions Glocal conversa-

tions help me understand and practice these convictions better

I will use evangelicalism as an example Michael Horton says that our

beliefs and practices are evangelical when they are ldquocommitted to the suffi-

ciency of Scripture the priesthood of all believers the total lostness ofhumans the sole mediation of Christ the gracious efficacy and finality of

Godrsquos redemptive work in Christ through election propitiation calling and

keeping Te linchpin for all of this was the doctrine of justification by grace

alone through faith alone because of Christ alonerdquo9830891048624

Such convictions are necessary if we are to be faithful to the gospel and

to a biblical vision of church and mission Te gospel defines Godrsquos purposes

for humanity the church and the universe Te triune God controls thechurch He is its Lord and Savior Sanctifier and Liberator Master and King

He is completely sovereign over its nature affairs mission and history God

is the churchrsquos only source of grace election atonement salvation and per-

severance Te churchrsquos justification and hope are by grace alone through

faith alone by Christ alone

Herersquos the challenge I face My understanding of evangelicalism is

Western I am a product of the Western theological tradition and my Western

evangelical heritage Much of this is wonderful But I need indigenous and

Majority World evangelicals and others to help me expand and reshape

these insights Te same would be true if I were a Pentecostal

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of our theological traditions and convictions

Jesus Christ We must center our theology on Jesus Christ the Lord of

the church Te church needs to reflect on the person and work of Christ

and respond to him Tis means gathering and going in the name and power

of Christ It means allowing Christrsquos Spirit to shape our community and

10Michael Horton ldquoEvangelical Arminiansrdquo Modern Reormation 1048625 no 1048627 (1048625983097983097983090) 10486251048631

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2336

10486271048624 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

identity and mission It means developing our Christology ecclesiology and

missiology concurrently Te early church developed these three areas and

more in a concurrent and integrated way Tere was no linear progressionTe same is true in the contemporary global church

How can the glocal church best explore its nature structure mission and

hope Trough the centrality and the lordship of Christ

Majority World and indigenous Christians help us appreciate Jesus and

his mission afresh Tey show us how Jesus identifies with the marginalized

outcast oppressed rejected and broken He prefers them We find him

among ldquothe least of theserdquoGlocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of who Jesus Christ is How does it help us appreciate him better

What has Jesus done for and in his church and his world What does he care

about What individual and corporate responsibilities has he given us How

do we express these at local regional and global levels

Te Spirit Missional ecclesiology is inadequate without pneumatological

foundations In other words our theology of church and Spirit go togetherTe Spirit creates and animates the church He empowers it to witness to

Jesus and his gospel Te Spirit enables the church to be a missional trans-

formational community He shapes the church into an alternative society

embodying the reign of God Te church exists for the glory and mission of

Christ Te power and presence of the Spirit enables this mission worship

and glorification

Te Spirit pours out gis on the local-global church ldquofor the common

goodrdquo and ldquoto equip his people for works of service so that the body of Christ

may be built uprdquo Tis includes but isnrsquot limited to the ministry gis mani-

festation gis and motivational gis (1048625 Cor 104862510486261048631 Eph 104862810486251048625-10486251048626 Rom 104862510486261048630-1048632)

Te Spirit forms the glocal church He empowers it for service and

witness He fills it with Christrsquos empowering presence He leads it into the

missio Deimdashthe mission of the Father Son and Holy Spirit

Recently Pentecostal and renewalist movements have grown dramati-

cally in the Majority World Tey have increased in status size and influence

Many have matured theologically Te churches of the West must take notice

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of the power and presence of the Spirit

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2436

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048625

Te rinity Tere are clear limitations to the analogy between the

church and the rinity Te church can only image the rinity Yet the

church is at its best when it reflects the relational and missional passionof the rinity

What is the source and inspiration of the churchrsquos local-global mission

Ultimately it is the missional nature passion and actions of the Father Son

and Holy Spirit Godrsquos nature is missional His passion is infectious His

actions are historical redemptive and eternal Te rinity invites the

church into a sending community Te Father sends the Son Te Father

and Son send the Spirit Finally the rinity sends the church in missioninto the world

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of the rinity How does it enable our participation in the mission

and community of the triune God

Association and dialogue Tese need to happen across denominational

cultural ethnic gender and theological traditions and divides Authentic

dialogue is indispensable to the health and mission of the church What dothose marginal to the life of the church have to say to us What do ldquoothersrdquo

have to teach us Other ethnicities and cultures Other socioeconomic

groups Other ages and genders Other theological and confessing tradi-

tions Other persons from times long gone

We need to listen Share Be vulnerable Be authentic Open up to crit-

icism correction and change

We need more than dialogue We need communion and association It is

possible in a qualified way to say that God is present in all the various forms

of the church (ie the various theological ecclesiological sociocultural his-

torical and other permutations of the church) We discern this presence

through attention to Scripture history tradition culture and the Spirit Dis-

cernment involves critical dialogue theological exchange biblical study and

real relationship Only the Spirit of Jesus can enable this

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of association and dialogue

Mission and the missio Dei Te church is missional at its core It serves

obeys and images a missionary God David Bosch says ldquoTe churchrsquos mission

is not secondary to its being the church exists in being sent and in building up

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2536

10486271048626 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

itself for its missionrdquo He goes on to say ldquoEcclesiology does not precede missi-

ology there cannot be church without an intrinsic missionary dimensionrdquo983089983089

Jesus is Lord Lord of his church and Lord of his world His mission de-termines and forms the church His mission shapes the nature purposes

structures ministries and activities of his church Majority World and in-

digenous thinkers help us understand the implications of this mission Tey

help us form glocal theologies of mission Tey reveal ldquomission in context

as transformationrdquo9830891048626

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of mission and the missio Dei Church theology and practice Glocal conversations can inform and

enrich many aspects of the church (when practiced well) Teologies and

practices benefit from robust and critical glocal conversations Tese con-

versations enrich many areas (community spirituality discipleship liturgy

worship hospitality eco-justice education social ethics servantship lib-

eration place suffering beauty and so on)

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-standing of these many dimensions of church and mission

Glocal processes shape these eight themes and their practices We need

to facilitate and enable these conversations and processes Tis is urgent It

must be a priority No theology of mission or missional ecclesiology is ad-

equate without glocal conversations983089983091

T983144983141 L983151983139983137983148 983137983150983140 G983148983151983138983137983148 E983150983154983145983139983144 E983137983139983144 O983156983144983141983154

Glocalization takes the localparticular context and globaluniversal themes

seriously Contextual and global conversations enter an enriching and in-

forming relationship Tese two always have an active and symbiotic rela-

tionship Tis is true whether we deliberately put them into conversation or

not Te local shapes the global and the global shapes the local Many local

11David J Bosch Believing in the Future oward a Missiology o Western Culture (New York

rinity 1048625983097983097983093) 104862798309012izon ransormation Afer Lausanne 1048631-98309713Not all o these themes are dealt with in this present volume since either (1048625) I have dealt with them

in my book Salt Light and a City (983090) they are not all key themes in the writings o the thirty-five

Majority World thinkers considered in this volume or (1048627) there is not adequate space in a book

this size

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2636

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048627

voices converge to form global conversations and theologies Using the Phil-

ippines as a case study izon illustrates this by showing the interdepen-

dence between local and global themes in mission983089983092Dialogue between local and global conversations is critical Kōsuke

Koyama wrote an important book on contextual mission called Water Buffalo

Teology Koyama is a Japanese missionary who served in Chiang Mai

Tailand He writes of the joys and challenges of doing local particular water

buffalo theology He considers the relationship between local theology global

missional themes and transforming cultures ldquoWater Buffalo Teology sees

certain specific challenges Contextualization of theology implies two criticalmovements First to articulate Jesus Christ in culturally appropriate com-

municatively apt words and second to criticize reform dethrone or oppose

culture if it is found to be against what the name of Jesus Christ stands forrdquo9830891048629

Kōsuke Koyama challenges us to recognize what we bring to the task of

local theology For him it was doing theology in Tailand while being Jap-

anese We also need to notice the particular culture wersquore located in as we do

the work of theology Tis means we avoid speaking of an ldquoAsian theologyrdquoldquoAfrican theologyrdquo and the like We need to cultivate local theologies that

engage regional and global themes But these theologies must be ldquodistinctly

localrdquo and a ldquotheology from belowrdquo9830891048630

Simultaneously we need to pursue a reformation of theology and

practice ldquoin the global contextrdquo Tis means entering ldquothe disturbing spa-

ciousness of Jesus Christrdquo Jesus calls us to reject enmity and exceptionalism

We seem him present in our culture language stories and relationships

But we also choose to embrace the ldquootherrdquo We choose to see him present

in other culturesmdashshaping a global people to serve and worship him

joining in his mission983089983095

Kōsuke Koyama roots the gospel in the local contextual and particular

Tis is why he roots his water buffalo theology in Northern Tai culture He

is careful not to say ldquoHere is how you contextualize in your settingrdquo Instead

14izon ransormation Afer Lausanne 1048631-10486251048627 10486251048628983097-98309098308898309015Kōsuke Koyama Water Buffalo Teology 983090983093th anniversary ed (Maryknoll NY Orbis 1048625983097983097983097)

xiii-xv16Kōsuke Koyama ldquoTe Asian Approach to Christrdquo Missiology 1048625983090 no 1048628 (10486259830979830961048628) 10486281048627983093-104862798309617Kōsuke Koyama ldquoReormation in the Global Context Te Disturbing Spaciousness o Jesus Christrdquo

Currents in Teology and Mission 1048627983088 no 983090 (9830909830889830881048627) 10486251048625983097-983090983096

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2736

10486271048628 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

he tells us a story Itrsquos the story of how he contextualized theology in northern

Tailand while being open to global conversations Koyama asks us to form

our own local expressions of church mission and theology At the same timewe must stay attentive to what God is saying and doing beyond that context

Tis way local and global and particular and universal become mutually

enriching conversation partners

G983148983151983139983137983148983145983162983137983156983145983151983150 983137983150983140 H983145983155983156983151983154983145983139983137983148983148983161 S983145983148983141983150983139983141983140 V983151983145983139983141983155

Glocal theologies and conversations pay attention to voices that powers in-

stitutions religions and societies have silenced R S Sugirtharajah pushesback a little on izonrsquos ideas Sugirtharajah says that the church should

privilege local conversations He emphasizes the local contextual and post-

colonial reading of biblical texts9830891048632

Te church needs to listen Te church ought to be attentive to the

theologies and biblical interpretations of groups that cultures and reli-

gions have ignored Historically powerful secular and religious forces

have silenced these groups Tey have marginalized oppressed and colo-nized them It is time for the church to address this injustice We must

start listening to important but silenced voices We need to privilege the

voices of the former victims of Western colonialism We need to develop

postcolonial biblical interpretations theologies and expressions of church

and mission

How do we take such perspectives seriously as we develop glocal conver-

sations How do these themes help us foster vital relationships between local

and global voices

It is time for us to embrace values that enable conversations with those

oen ignored by the church We need values that help us learn from these

groups and individuals

Valuing equal partnership Colonizing powers oppressed silenced and

colonized certain groups At times the church was complicit Tese colo-

nized groups have become ldquoconfident indomitable and indispensable

partners in the dialogue and collaboration with the dispossessed and disad-

18R S Sugirtharajah Asian Biblical Hermeneutics and Postcolonialism Contesting the Interpreta-

tions Te Bible and Liberation Series (Maryknoll NY Orbis 1048625983097983097983096) 1048625983093-1048625983094

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2836

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048629

vantaged in the Westrdquo9830891048633 Tis calls for attentiveness to these voices and re-

sponsiveness to their prophetic challenges It also demands a critical evalu-

ation of colonial readings of Scripture Colonial models of theology andchurch and mission are no longer the benchmark Te global church must

examine them afresh

Valuing equal status Tose on the margins have now taken their rightful

place on the global stage Tey have claimed appropriate and equal status at

the table Subaltern readings of theology church and mission are invaluable

contributors to global theological conversations Tis means that we esteem

them But we also test themWhat do we mean by subaltern Subalterns are those who are down-

trodden and silenced (or have been treated this way in the past) Dominant

or colonizing groups treat them as invisible nonentities Tey enjoy limited

or no access to power Sometimes these are women certain tribal and ethnic

groups and those considered ldquountouchablerdquo In Voices from the Margin Su-

girtharajah provides a platform for postcolonial subaltern readings of

Scripture and theology Tese readings challenge colonialmdashoen Westernmdashreadings of Bible and theology and cultures Tey claim equal status with

other ways of doing theology10486261048624

Valuing equal identity People groups need freedom to explore their new

and emerging identities Tese emerge in response to local and global influ-

ences Local culture is not the only thing at work here Global forces also

shape identity as do imported practices ideas readings rituals and tech-

nologies But each group should be free to explore and construct their par-

ticular forms of Christian identity

Valuing equal interpretations ldquoPostcolonialism is concerned with the

question of cultural and discursive dominationrdquo Colonialism led to op-

pressive and controlling forms of culture and discourse Tese were usually

not contextual or indigenous Western powers for instance brought co-

lonial forms of theology church biblical interpretation and mission1048626983089

Postcolonialism calls for alternative ways of approaching these things Tose

19Ibid 104862598309420R S Sugirtharajah Voices rom the Margin Interpreting the Bible in the Tird World (Maryknoll

NY Orbis 10486259830979830971048625)21Sugirtharajah Asian Biblical Hermeneutics and Postcolonialism 10486251048631

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2936

10486271048630 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

who were once marginalized oppressed and silenced need to lead these fresh

approaches in their own settings Tese then influence global conversations

We need to support the new readings and insights and experiments from thesegroups o be genuine this support must be both critical and collegial

Valuing equal empowerment Sugirtharajah says that postcolonialism is

valuable when it empowers actual communities and real people Post-

colonial thought empowers when it addresses the difficulties hopes and

experiences of ordinary people It should never be about power plays and

the clever use of language Itrsquos pointless if itrsquos obsessed with forming newmdash

and ldquocolonizingrdquomdashtheories Itrsquos a waste of time if itrsquos a self-indulgent pursuitof new and hybrid identities Rather ldquothe worth and credibility of post-

colonial criticism will be judged by how it orchestrates the unique and

fragile and imagined claims of one community against anotherrdquo Empow-

erment happens in a variety of ways One way is contributing equally to

global conversations10486261048626

Al izon examines postcolonialism in the Philippines He says that it can

teach the global church a lot about healthy local-global conversations Fil-ipino contextual theology resists many Western forms of mission and the-

ology It finds them patronizing and controlling Tis indigenous theology

values prophetic sociopolitical engagement in institutions and the society

at large It emphasizes ministry to whole persons and communities It con-

structs a Filipino theology of beauty and mission and worship and com-

munity And it fosters indigenous theological approaches to the spirit world

and cosmology

izon says that postcolonial theology has played a constructive role in

the Philippines But he is uncomfortable with the label postcolonialism He

prefers to describe historical events as ldquobeyond colonialismrdquo And he says

that global conversations enrich local theologies and vice versa1048626983091

Postcolonial thought informs our understanding of the relationship be-

tween the local and global It also shows how theology can emerge at the

intersection between the localparticular and the globaluniversal It re-

minds us that worthwhile glocalization listens to all voices Tis includes

heeding those that have been historically silenced

22Ibid 983090104862823izon ransormation Afer Lausanne 1048625983088983090 10486259830941048631-9830961048631

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3036

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048631

G983148983151983139983137983148983145983162983137983156983145983151983150 983137983150983140 983156983144983141 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

C983151983150983139983148983157983140983145983150983143 R983141983142983148983141983139983156983145983151983150983155

How do we go about developing a model for glocal conversations izon hasrecently provided a useful model that is instructive as we seek to learn from

the Majority World It has at least two key features

First the local is in the global (globalization from below) Global theologies

and ideas have origins in many particular local contexts In that sense glo-

balization is from below Global ideas have local roots Ideas about integral

mission liberation theology and missional church have local origins Tey

have their roots in the prayers hopes discoveries mission and theologiesof thousands of local communities ldquoTe global does not cannot exist

without the localmdashbut the coming together of localities creates a global re-

ality that becomes greater than the sum of its parts it creates a gestalt entity

to which localities make themselves accountablerdquo1048626983092

Second the global is in the local (panlocalization from above) Te con-

cerns and voices of multitudes of locales form global conversations Tese

global discussions can provide a ldquopositive accountabilityrdquo back to local con-texts Tis is true when they enrich affirm serve guide and strengthen local

contexts It is also true when they avoid homogenization control impo-

sition and judgment Glocalization is best when it sees itself as interde-

pendent deeply connected with the local10486261048629

Tatrsquos a helpful starting point But we need to go further Besides izonrsquos

proposals Irsquom convinced that robust glocal conversations cultivate six core

practices

983089 Glocal theology practices its values We root glocal theology in core

values Tese values include solidarity understanding and mutual learning

Do we value fellowship with Christians of all cultures Do we value learning

from them

We prove our values through our practices What practices emerge out of

these values We need to collaborate act collectively and share information

We must find ways to foster grassroots perspectives and local theologies We

need to share stories and learnings and cultivate networks relationships and

partnerships We need attentiveness to local voices and global themes We

24Ibid 9830901048625983088-1048625104862825Ibid 98309010486251048628-1048625983096

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3136

10486271048632 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

ought to find ways to put these local and global voices into conversation

Mutual learning humility and solidarity are key Worthwhile glocal con-

versations can never be merely theoretical or academic It is up to us to rootour values in our practices

983090 Glocal theology practices humility (and it tells a new narrative) We

have noted that the local is in the global and the global is in the local Te

two are interdependent Tey form each other reciprocally Since this is the

case we must practice humility Tere is no place for ethnocentrism colo-

nialism or theological and cultural arrogance I have seen these unhealthy

postures far too oen in Western settingsRecently I attended a missional leadership conference On that occasion

the keynote speakermdasha leading missional author and speakermdashsaid that

North American missional conversations and innovations hold the key to

the future of the Western church Tis Euro American view is wrong (Irsquom

being kind o be frank itrsquos complete nonsense) Itrsquos arrogant and Euro

Americanndashcentric And itrsquos completely out of step with what is happening in

the glocal church We need a new narrativeIn June 1048626104862410486251048627 Te Center for the Study of Global Christianity reported

the top 10486261048624 countries where Christianity has the highest percentage growth

rate Nineteen of the top twenty are in Asia and Africa Eleven of them are

in Muslim majority countries Not a single country from Europe or North

America makes the top twenty list10486261048630

Itrsquos time to cultivate a new narrative Te future of the church is emerging

from the Majority World Rather than North America the churches of

Eastern Asia Western Africa the Arabian Peninsula and other parts of the

Majority World reveal the future of the global church We need the contribu-

tions of all contexts Western indigenous and Majority World All con-

tribute to glocal conversations All are important as we learn from each

other about mission theology and faith But letrsquos stop pretending that North

Americans and Europeans will reveal the future of the global church Letrsquos

start listening to what God is saying about the future of the global church

And hersquos speaking to us through the churches of Asia Africa Latin America

26Russ Mitchell ldquoTe op 983090983088 Countries Where Christianity Is Growing the Fastestrdquo Disciple All

Nations (blog) August 983090983093 98309098308810486251048627 httpsdiscipleallnationswordpresscom98309098308810486251048627983088983096983090983093the-top

-983090983088-countries-where-christianity-is-growing-the-astest

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3236

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048633

Muslim majority settings and so on We must cultivate a new glocal nar-

rativemdashone soaked in humility

Glocal theology must be humble theology Meek theology Receptive the-ology Discerning theology Prayerful theology Dialogical theology De-

pendent theology A theology that celebrates the interdependence between

the localparticular and the globaluniversal

983091 Glocal theology practices expansiveness Glocalization is by nature

comprehensive Local and global influences permeate much of our lives Tese

glocal forces shape our theologies and churches whether we like it or not

But intentionality is also important We need to commit to an expansiveapproach to glocal theology How do we deliberately cultivate glocal conver-

sations in our biblical interpretation Do we foster them in our under-

standing of the person and work of Christ How does glocalization shape

the way the Spirit empowers and constitutes the church How can it form

our understanding of the nature and mission of the rinity How does it

influence the way we practice fellowship and conversation across denomi-

national cultural ethnic economic sociocultural political gender andtheological divides How might it shape our theologies of mission com-

munity beauty spirituality suffering discipleship hospitality eco-justice

place education social ethics Christian leadership and so forth

983092 Glocal theology practices attention Glocal theology doesnrsquot need to

accept all the assumptions or assertions of postcolonial or Majority World

thought But it does need to engage with them and take them seriously

Postcolonial theology for instance gives the marginalized and colonized

and forgotten and silenced both dignity and voice Our glocal conversations

must also include and esteem these groups We need to be attentive to

others weak and powerful female and male dominant and downtrodden

old and young rich and poor privileged and marginalized influential and

subaltern educated and illiterate We need to practice the art of attention

being especially attentive to those who are different to us

983093 Glocal theology practices embrace What do colonial ethnocentric or

Western-centric perspectives do Tey silence Tey control Tey com-

modify Tey institutionalize Tey colonize Tey domesticate Tey replace

Tey import Tey exclude Tey do these things to the beliefs experiences

and practices of other cultures A worthwhile glocal theology refuses to do

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3336

10486281048624 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

these things Instead it adopts a responsive humble celebratory open in-

clusive and embracing attitude

983094 Glocal theology practices discernment Finally we need discernmentas we engage these ideas and practices Discernment is a huge topic thatrsquos

hard to cover comprehensively in a few words Discernment happens when

the Spirit of Christ and his Word renew our minds Te Spirit grants us

spiritual wisdom as we meditate on him and his Word and as we practice

discipleship to Jesus Christ Romans 10486251048626 provides guidance we need (1048625) to be

transformed by the renewal of our minds (1048626) to serve Christrsquos body and (1048627)

to put love into action Discernment also happens in conversation both lo-cally and glocally

I pray these core values and six practices come across in the following

chapters of GlobalChurch

Glocalization can never be just theoretical Are we committed to moving

glocalization from an abstract idea to a living communion Are we deter-

mined to construct a missional theology of the church in the context of

glocal conversations Tis must involve dialogue between Majority Worldindigenous and Western scholars activists and groups

Will glocalization be an abstract notion Or will it be a formative and

genuine communion between local regional and global voices Glocal dy-

namics are at play whether we like it or not Teyrsquore in our churches the-

ologies and missions But we can choose to relinquish isolationist colonial

parochial and arrogant approaches Instead we can adopt responsive dia-

logical learning humble and embracing postures

Trough healthy approaches to glocalization the Spirit challenges us to

value local contexts We immerse ourselves in local and particular commu-

nities and conversations He inspires us to open ourselves to global theo-

logical conversations He rouses us to value the symbiotic relationship be-

tween the localparticular and the globaluniversal

Trough glocal relationships the Spirit leads us to put local contextual

theologies into conversation with global ones He prompts us to explore the

ways in which the local is in the glocal and the global is in the local He per-

suades us to pursue collaboration and dialogue and mutual learning We

engage with Christians from different backgrounds and cultures ecumen-

icals Pentecostals evangelicals and so on from Western indigenous and

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3436

Glocalizing Conversations 10486281048625

Majority World contexts He motivates us to express solidarity between all

parties We appreciate our unity in diversity

Trough glocal conversations the Spirit moves us to ensure that unity andsolidarity emerge from a compelling vision of Jesusrsquo kingdom and gospel

and person He challenges us to share information theology and practices

He urges us to learn from each othermdashour successes and mistakes We seek

glocal solutions

Te Spirit calls us to develop glocal conversations about Christian ideas

and practices Tese include Scripture Evangelicalism ecumenism Pente-

costalism Jesus Christ the Holy Spirit God the Father the rinity com-munity spirituality discipleship liturgy worship hospitality prayer eco-

justice education social ethics Christian leadership gospel and culture

beauty place suffering liberation and so forth

Finally through glocal conversations the Spirit leads us to adopt a new

posture Tis is a responsive humble celebratory open inclusive and em-

bracing attitude to the ldquootherrdquo We do this as a new people made up of every

tribe and language and people and nationTere are dangers in glocalization Sugirtharajah warns of the commodi-

fication of local contextual practices and theologies When this happens

they are ldquosmoothed out of their primary contexts concerns and contesta-

tions travel across borders and become objects of analysis and scrutiny

within an alien secondary contextrdquo1048626983095

Itrsquos common for those of us who are Western to make mistakes when we

wrestle with Majority World and indigenous ideas Sugirtharajah mentions

our tendency to commodify reduce and institutionalize these ideas We also

risk doing these things (1048625) We apply them in noncontextual prescriptive ways

(1048626) We ignore their meanings in their original setting (1048627) We glamorize or

idealize their proponents or their contexts (1048628) We demonize those persons or

contexts (1048629) We disregard them as irrelevant rhetorical or minority discourse

Kevin J Vanhoozer says that we can fall into three traps when we glo-

calize theology (1048625) We can underestimate the theological significance of

local cultures (1048626) We can homogenize cultures and theologies exaggerating

27R S Sugirtharajah ldquoextual ake-Aways Tird World exts in Western Metropolitan Centresrdquo

Black Teology in Britain A Journal o Contextual Praxis 983090 (1048625983097983097983097) 10486271048627 10486271048631 Edward W Said Te

World the ext and the Critic (Cambridge MA Harvard University Press 10486259830979830961048627) 9830901048627983097

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3536

10486281048626 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

ldquothe onerdquo (1048627) We can overemphasize cultural particularity exaggerating ldquothe

manyrdquo and pursue ldquotheological ethnificationrdquo10486261048632

My hope is that GlobalChurch does not fall into the traps Sugirtharajahand Vanhoozer describe I hope that what unfolds in the following chapters

is respectful and discerning I hope it leads to further mutually enriching

conversations between people of different cultures

You the reader face the same challenges You face them in your personal

life ministry context and missional engagements

Will you treat the themes in this book as abstract theoretical notions

Will this be a temporary infatuation a flirtation with the ldquootherrdquo that dissi-pates as suddenly as it arrived Or will glocal conversations become an en-

riching and formative orientation in your life Will glocal conversations

bring fresh approaches to theology faith mission church and worship Will

conversations with other cultures and theologies become for you a com-

pelling way of life

My prayer is that glocal conversations will help the church be a global

visible alternative ldquocity set upon a hillrdquo a truly GlobalChurch

28Craig Ott and Harold A Netland Globalizing Teology Belie and Practice in an Era o World

Christianity (Grand Rapids Baker Academic 983090983088983088983094) 1048625983090983093

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3636

Page 6: GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 636

983089983093 Developing Spirituality and Discipleship 983091983096983091

983089983094 GlobalChurch Embracing a New Narrative 983092983089983093

Appendix 983089 GlobalChurch Project Video Series 983092983093983089

Appendix 983090 Study Guide 983092983093983091

Appendix 983091 Who Are hese Majority World

and Indigenous hinkers 983092983096983089

Appendix 983092 Resources and Glossary at

heGlobalChurchProjectcom 983092983097983091

Author Index 983092983097983093

Subject Index 983092983097983097

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 736

I N T R O D U C T I O N

B983141983145983150983143 S983137983148983156 L983145983143983144983156 983137983150983140 983137 C983145983156 983161

By 9830909830889830901048629 fully two-thirds of Christians will live in

Africa Latin America and Asia Te ldquoaverage

Christianrdquo today is female black and lives in a

Brazilian favela or an African village

SEPHE N BEVANS

Majority World and indigenous churches are redefining twenty-first-

century Christianity Western churches must decide how theyrsquoll respond

Stephen Bevans puts it well

We are now living in a ldquoworld churchrdquo where the vast majority of Christians are

[from the Majority World] David Barrettrsquos statistical studies have basically con-

firmed this shi and Philip Jenkins has predicted that by 1048626104862410486261048629 fully two-thirds

of Christians will live in Africa Latin America and Asia Scholars are fairly

unanimous in acknowledging the accuracy of the facts Te ldquoaverage Christianrdquo

today is female black and lives in a Brazilian favela or an African village983089

Some statistics illustrate this shi in twenty-first-century global Christi-

anity Te Pew Research Centerrsquos report Global Christianity analyzes the size

and distribution of the worldrsquos Christian population Te report maps the

changes over the last century (1048625104863310486251048624 to 1048626104862410486251048624) It concludes ldquoA century ago the

Global North (commonly defined as North America Europe Australia Japan

1Stephen B Bevans Roger Schroeder and L J Luzbetak ldquoMissiology Afer Bosch Reverencing a

Classic by Moving Beyondrdquo International Bulletin o Missionary Research 983090983097 no 983090 (983090983088983088983093) 983094983097

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 836

10486251048628 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

and New Zealand) contained more than four times as many Christians as the

Global South (the rest of the world) oday the Pew Forum study finds more

than 10486251048627 billion Christians live in the Global South [10486301048625983077 of all Christians livein Asia Africa and Latin America] compared with about 104863210486301048624 million in the

Global North (10486271048633983077)rdquo1048626 Tat is an astounding shi in only one hundred years983091

Using the World Christian Database Philip Jenkins offers table 10486251048625

ldquoChanging distribution of Christian believersrdquo

Table 983089983089 Changing distribution of Christian believers 983089983097983088983088 to 983090983088983093983088 (number of Christiansin millions)

983089983097983088983088 983089983097983095983088 983090983088983089983088 983090983088983093983088Africa 983089983088 983089983092983091 983092983097983091 983089983088983091983089

Asia 983090983090 983097983094 983091983093983090 983094983088983089

North America 983095983097 983090983089983089 983090983096983094 983091983091983091

Latin America 983094983090 983090983095983088 983093983092983092 983094983093983093

Europe 983091983096983089 983092983097983090 983093983096983096 983093983091983088

Oceania 983093 983089983096 983090983096 983091983096

Total 983093983093983096 983089983090983091983088 983090983090983097983089 983091983089983096983096

Source Philip Jenkins The Next Christendom The Coming of Global Christianity 983091rd ed (Oxford Oxford Uni-

versity Press 983090983088983089983089) 983091 Data is taken from World Christian Database wwwworldchristiandatabaseorgwcd

Christianity in North America Europe and Oceania grew from 104862810486301048629

million in 1048625104863310486241048624 to 104863310486241048626 million in 1048626104862410486251048624983092 Tis number is likely to shrink to

104863310486241048625 million by 1048626104862410486291048624

Christianity in Africa Asia and Latin America grew from 10486331048628 million in

1048625104863310486241048624 to 1048625104862710486321048633 billion in 1048626104862410486251048624 Tis number is likely to grow to 1048626104862610486321048631 billion by

1048626104862410486291048624

Letrsquos take China for example Professor Fenggang Yang of Purdue University

makes an important prediction If current rates of growth continue within one

generation China will have more Christians than any other nation on earth

In 1048625104863310486281048633 Protestant churches in China had one million members In 1048626104862410486251048624 that

number was 10486291048632 million (compare that with 10486281048624 million in Brazil and 10486271048630 million

2Pew Research Center Global Christianity A Report on the Size and Distribution o the Worldrsquos Chris-

tian Population December 1048625983097 98309098308810486251048625 wwwpeworumorg9830909830881048625104862510486259830901048625983097global-christianity-exec3See David B Barrett George Kurian and odd M Johnson World Christian Encyclopedia A

Comparative Survey o Churches and Religions in the Modern World 983090nd ed 983090 vols (New York

Oxord University Press 9830909830889830881048625) 1048625983090-1048625983093 and wwwglobalchristianityorg4Oceania includes Australia and Micronesian Melanesian and Polynesian countries

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 936

Introduction 10486251048629

in South Africa) By 1048626104862410486261048629 there are likely to be 104862510486301048624 million Christians in China

By 1048626104862410486271048624 this number is likely to be 104862610486281048631 million (outnumbering Christians in

Mexico Brazil and the United States) In an interview with the elegraphFenggang Yang says ldquoMao thought he could eliminate religion He thought he

had accomplished this Itrsquos ironicmdashthey didnrsquot Tey actually failed completelyrdquo1048629

Philip Jenkins concludes

We are currently living through one of the transforming moments in the

history of religion worldwide Over the last five centuries the story of Chris-

tianity has been inextricably bound up with that of Europe and European-

derived civilizations overseas above all in North America Until recently theoverwhelming majority of Christians have lived in white nations Over the

last century however the center of gravity in the Christian world has shied

inexorably away from Europe southward to Africa and Latin America and

eastward toward Asia oday the largest Christian communities on the planet

are to be found in those regions1048630

What does all this mean for the mission and theology and worship and

communities of the church worldwide And what does it mean particularlyfor the Western church

In Matthew 104862910486251048627-10486251048630 Jesus provides three remarkable images of the churchmdash

salt light and a city Jesus confronts his disciples with a missional description

of the church Te church in mission is the salt of the earth the light of the

world and a city set on a hill Te churchrsquos purpose is to let its ldquolight shine

before others that they may see your good deeds and glorify your Father in

heavenrdquo Te purpose of the churchrsquos missionary nature is the worship andglorification of the Father and Son and Holy Spirit983095

Te church is another city constituted by every tribe language people

5om Phillips ldquoChina on Course to Become lsquoWorldrsquos Most Christian Nationrsquo Within 1048625983093 Yearsrdquo

elegraph April 1048625983097 98309098308810486251048628 wwwtelegraphcouknewsworldnewsasiachina1048625983088104863110486319830949830889830901048627China-on

-course-to-become-worlds-most-Christian-nation-within-1048625983093-yearshtml See Fenggang Yang and

Joseph B amney eds Conucianism and Spiritual raditions in Modern China and Beyond Re-

ligion in Chinese Societies (Boston Brill 9830909830881048625983090) Fenggang Yang and Graeme Lang eds Social

Scientific Studies o Religion in China Methodology Teories and Findings (Leiden Brill 98309098308810486251048625)

Fenggang Yang Religion in China Survival and Revival Under Communist Rule (Oxord Oxord

University Press 9830909830881048625983090)6Philip Jenkins Te Next Christendom Te Coming o Global Christianity 1048627rd ed (Oxord Ox-

ord University Press 98309098308810486251048625) 10486257J Driver Images o the Church in Mission (Scottdale PA Herald 10486259830979830971048631) 10486251048631983088-9830961048625 Graham Hill Salt

Light and a City Introducing Missional Ecclesiology (Eugene OR Wip and Stock 9830909830881048625983090) xiii

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1036

10486251048630 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

and nation Te church must cultivate a distinct social existence shaping its

community and mission around its commitment to plurality and diversity

and unity1048632 God calls his church to be a global and missional ldquocity on a hillrdquoTis is a church constituted and enriched and represented by Western and

indigenous and Majority World peoples

Tose of us in the West need a new narrative Itrsquos time to abandon our

flawed Eurocentric and Americentric worldviews We need a new global

and missional narrative and for that we must turn to the churches of Ma-

jority World and indigenous cultures Tey can help us explore what it

means to be a global missional community Many Christian communitiesin Majority World and indigenous contexts have been wrestling with these

issues for generations Marginalization and persecution and alienation have

been their lot Yet somehow in spite of or because of that they have flour-

ished In fact theyrsquove grown exponentially

So whom am I talking about when I refer to Majority World and indig-

enous Christians Majority World Christians are those in Africa Asia the

Caribbean Eastern Europe Latin America the Middle East and Oceania

1048633

I use the term Majority World because the majority of the worldrsquos population

is in those cultures today Te majority of the church is in those cultures too

I donrsquot use the terms non-Western or Tird World or Developing World Tese

terms use Western cultures as their point of reference Tey imply Western

8Barry A Harvey Another City An Ecclesiological Primer or a Post-Christian World (New York

rinity 1048625983097983097983097) 9830901048627-9830909830939I donrsquot deal with the diasporas in this book For example Irsquove made no mention o Hispanic

Portuguese or Asian minorities in the United States United Kingdom Canada Europe Austra-lia and so on Irsquom aware that right now Latin American and Chinese diasporas are active in

evangelism and mission in Europe in the same way in which the Filipino or the Salvadoran dias-

poras carry on mission in the United States Irsquove chosen not to include voices rom the diasporas

mainly because there are so many worthy contributors in that group and I donrsquot have the space

to treat them well in this book In the uture I hope that I (or someone else) will write a book

exploring what we can learn rom the diasporas Hispanic minorities or example are making

significant contributions to the theological and missiological conversation in the United States

that are relevant to this subject Methodist historian Justo L Gonzaacutelez and Pentecostal theologian

Eldin Villaantildee are examples In Mantildeana Gonzaacutelez describes the shape and orm o a theology

developed in the Hispanic margin o the United States In Out o Every ribe and Nation he shows

what would be implied in listening to minorities within a denominational setting Villaantildeersquos Te

Liberating Spirit is a milestone in the reflection about the relationship between pneumatology and

social ethics See Justo L Gonzaacutelez Out o Every ribe and Nation Christian Teology at the

Ethnic Roundtable (Nashville Abingdon 1048625983097983097983090) Gonzaacutelez Mantildeana Christian Teology rom a

Hispanic Perspective (Nashville Abingdon 1048625983097983097983088) Eldin Villaantildee Te Liberating Spirit oward

an Hispanic American Pentecostal Social Ethic (Grand Rapids Eerdmans 10486259830979830971048627)

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1136

Introduction 10486251048631

superiority or centricity Te term Global South is too limiting given the

breadth of the group I am engaging Majority World seems to work best

In 1048626104862410486241048628 Te Lausanne Forum for World Evangelization in PattayaTailand voted unanimously that the phrase Majority World Church replace

other terms People from all over the globe participated in this forum

imothy C ennent agrees that this is the best phrase ldquoIt helps to highlight

the basic point that Africa Asia and Latin America are where the majority

of the worldrsquos Christians are now locatedrdquo9830891048624 I expand the phrase Majority

World beyond Africa Asia and Latin America to include the Caribbean

Eastern Europe Oceania and the Middle EastIndigenous and First Nations peoples are ldquothose ethnic groups that were

indigenous to a territory prior to being incorporated into a national state

and who are politically and culturally separate from the majority ethnic

identity of the state that they are a part ofrdquo Tis includes people groups like

the Australian Aborigines and American Indians983089983089

Te aim of this book is to help Western churches rediscover what it means

to be salt light and a city by engaging in global missional conversations odo this Western Christians need to enter into conversation with Majority

World and indigenous Christians Listening to others helps us grow in our

understanding and practice of mission and church and theology For far too

long wersquove marginalized or ignored Majority World and indigenous voices

We must truly become a GlobalChurch

Tis aim shapes the bookrsquos structure as summarized below

P983137983154983156 1048625 S983137983148983156 R983141983155983144983137983152983145983150983143 O983157983154 C983151983150983158983141983154983155983137983156983145983151983150983155

ldquoYou are the salt of the earth But if the salt loses its saltiness how can it be made

salty again It is no longer good for anything except to be thrown out and

trampled underfootrdquo Globally and locally you are the salt of the earth Be salt

Salt preserves seasons flavors and purifies We are salt when we glorify

the Father Son and Holy Spirit in our mission worship faith hope truth

and love We are salt when we reject a Eurocentric or Americentric vision

10imothy C ennent Teology in the Context o World Christianity How the Global Church Is

Influencing the Way We Tink About and Discuss Teology (Grand Rapids Zondervan 9830909830889830881048631) xx11Douglas Sanders ldquoIndigenous Peoples Issues o Definitionrdquo International Journal o Cultural

Property 983096 no 1048625 (1048625983097983097983097) 1048628

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1236

10486251048632 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

of the church and become the global missional church Christ envisioned

In part one I show how Western conversations are impoverished and

insufficient in isolation from indigenous and Majority World Christians Weenhance our ldquosaltinessrdquo through local-global ( glocal ) exchanges o do this

we must reshape our conversations We need global and local exchanges that

we characterize by mutuality respect partnership and symbiosis Such ex-

changes help us learn from each other whether wersquore in Western indig-

enous or Majority World settings It helps us stay ldquosaltyrdquo It enables us to

pursue global missional theology and practice Globally and locally we can

pursue missional vitality and truly be ldquothe salt of the earthrdquo

P983137983154983156 1048626 L983145983143983144983156 R983141983150983141983159983145983150983143 O983157983154 M983145983155983155983145983151983150

ldquoYou are the light of the world A city on a hill cannot be hidden Neither do

people light a lamp and put it under a bowl Instead they put it on its stand and

it gives light to everyone in the house In the same way let your light shine

before others that they may see your good deeds and glorify your Father in

heavenrdquo (Mt 104862910486251048628-10486251048631) Globally and locally you are the light of the world Be lightLight illuminates reveals and dispels darkness Te church is light when

it does good deedsmdashhealing and liberating and redemptive deeds Itrsquos light

when its being and faith and deeds bring glorify to the Father Te church

is light when it participates in Godrsquos redemptive mission in the world as a

global missional community

o do this we must renew our mission In part two I explore how indig-

enous and Majority World Christians teach us to renew mission We renew

mission through contextualization liberation hospitality Spirit empow-

erment creation care ethics and the transformation of neighborhoods

P983137983154983156 1048627 C983145983156983161 R983141983158983145983156983137983148983145983162983145983150983143 O983157983154 C983144983157983154983139983144983141983155

You are a city set on a hill ldquoA city on a hill cannot be hiddenrdquo Globally and

locally you are a city set on a hill Be a city set on a hill

Tis means that we are an alternative and countercultural movement We

have a distinct culture and politic and social existence We are a people

gathered from every tribe language people and nation We are in the world

but not of the world We are in the world but distinct from the world We are

within the world and for the sake of the world

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1336

Introduction 10486251048633

o be this kind of alternative city or culture we must renew our mission

community ethics and worship We need to pursue the revitalization of our

churches so that they are distinct And by distinct I mean an alternative city(altera civitas)

We are a ldquocity on a hillrdquo that witnesses to Jesus Christ and his eternal kingdom

when we are a global missional church In part three I demonstrate how indig-

enous and Majority World Christians teach us to revitalize churches We revi-

talize churches by indigenizing faith devouring Scripture renewing education

practicing servantship (servant leadership) recovering community and devel-

oping spirituality and discipleship We inspire our churches when we developour theology and practices relating to beauty and the arts9830891048626

In the final chapter I wrap things up by addressing an important question

In light of all the material covered in this book what would it now look like

to engage in global missional theology ecclesiology interpretation history

pneumatology worship and education

Herersquos how you can get the most out of this book

Community You can read this book alone in a small group with somefriends at home or at a coffee shop or as part of a ministry team However

you get a lot more out of this book when you read it with others ogether

you can think about the bookrsquos implications What do the chapters mean for

your ministry church agency family or team

GlobalChurch Project video series Irsquove made a video series to go along with

this book Appendix one has the details

Study guide Yoursquoll get a lot more out of this book if you spend time

working through the study guide in appendix two ry to do this in a group

Te study guide includes reflection questions suggested practices and

Further Reading

Characters As you read this book yoursquoll come across names and people

yoursquove never heard of before For a glimpse of who they are and what issues

concern them see appendix three

My website o help you get the most out of this book Irsquove included more

resources on my website TeGlobalChurchProjectcom Tese include

videos reading lists important links a glossary and other resources Irsquove

12Irsquove put a separate chapter on the theme o beauty and the arts on my website Itrsquos additional to

this book

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1436

10486261048624 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

also provided ways that you can contact me See appendix four

In my first book Salt Light and a City I developed a missional theology

of the church I did this in conversation with twelve theologians from the fourmajor Christian traditions Tat volume offered a window into the thought of

European and American theologians It showed how they are making sense

of the nature and mission of the church in their Western cultural context

Te book that yoursquore now reading takes a different approach I have

stepped away from European and American voices I now ask What can

those in the Majority World and indigenous cultures teach us in the West

What can they teach us about the churchrsquos mission worship theology andcommunity Te quality and quantity of material coming out of the Ma-

jority World is astonishing Any theology that ignores the insights of indig-

enous and Majority World Christians is deficient and impoverished

White middle-class European North American tertiary-educated men

dominate Western theology Tey dominate the Western missional conver-

sation I know I fit that profile Tis group still monopolizes missional church

conferences and seminars Tey get all the book contracts In fact this groupstill controls theology and the church in many settings But this is changing

New voices are rising Tese include women minorities the poor indigenous

groups and Majority World leaders Missional conversations arenrsquot attentive

to the Spirit and to Godrsquos mission if they ignore these voices Majority World

and indigenous churches oen have extraordinary missional vitality Openness

to other voices needs to happen now It is time for Western churches theol-

ogies and mission to mature and to reflect Godrsquos global mission

In this book I could have consulted the work of many thousands of in-

digenous and Majority World thinkers and writers and practitioners But I

have limited myself to a sample of those who speak directly to its themes

Tese African Asian Eastern European Middle Eastern Caribbean Latin

American First Nation and indigenous thinkers challenge us Tey dare us

to examine our theologies and missions and churches And they inspire us

to renew the worship and community and mission of Jesusrsquo church Tey

stir us to think in fresh ways about what it means to be salt light and a city

Tey help us become a global missional churchmdasha truly GlobalChurch

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1536

PA R T O N E

S A L TReshaping Our Conversations

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1636

G L O C A L I Z I N G

C O N V E R S A T I O N S

H983151983159 D983151 W983141 D983141983158983141983148983151983152

G983148983151983139983137983148 C983151983150983158983141983154983155983137983156983145983151983150983155983103

Rather than taking one contextual version of the Gospel and imposing

it as the Gospel throughout the world via the missionary enterprise

the shapers of Mission as ransformation have recognized the

plurality of localities that has created an intercontextual

ldquopan-localrdquo global phenomenon in theology

AL IZON

The International Society for Urban Mission (ISUM) is a group of urban

missionaries who are passionate about cultivating hope and love and re-newal in cities Irsquove connected with this group for some years ISUM held its

first annual Summit on Integral Urban Mission in Bangkok Tailand Te

team from Urban Neighbours of Hope (UNOH) under the leadership of

my Australian friends Ash and Anj Barker organized much of the summit

UNOH teams covenant with God and each other to ldquolive out our passion for

loving God and neighbour Focus on releasing neighbourhoods from urban

poverty Grow through equipping each other neighbours and the broader

church to radically follow Jesus and join Godrsquos Kingdom coming UNOH

workers live and serve in small responsive neighbourhood-based teamsrdquo983089

1See wwwunohorg

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1736

10486261048628 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

Tis summit involved interactive participatory hands-on immersion op-

portunities keynotes lectures and workshops Keynote speakers came from

Africa Australia Myanmar New Zealand North America the PhilippinesSouth America Tailand and First Nations A few hundred Majority World

and Western thinkers and activists came together for those days Tey explored

the theology and practices of integral transformational and urban mission

Tese thinkers and activists pursued a range of aims1048626 Tis included col-

laboration between urban Christians from a variety of backgrounds (Ma-

jority World and Western theologians activists ecumenicals Pentecostals

evangelicals colleges church movements and development agencies) Teyaimed for collective action and thought in an international and integral

context Tey sought to gain mutual understanding for a comprehensive

picture of urban mission around the globe Tey encouraged information

sharing and best practicesmdashlearning from our mistakes and seeking solu-

tions Tey developed recommendations and calls to action to the broader

church Working groups wrote briefing papers aer each summit based on

key issues in urban mission And they endeavored to build trust wisdomand inspiration to better engage our new urban world

Majority World and Western leaders participated in discussion prayer

integral mission and working groups Te goal was to grapple with key issues

and ask key questions How do we recruit equip and sustain urban mission

today How do we release church movements among the urban poor How

can we immerse ourselves in and transform urban neighborhoods How do

we empower urban children and young people How does the church serve

and liberate the oppressedmdashand others suffering from urban injustice What

needs to happen for poorer urban centers to develop economically socially

and spiritually How do we join God in the challenges and opportunities of

multifaith cities

Workshops included urban gardening child protection and collaborating

with local churches in urban mission Workshops also included organic

church growth and mission as well as developing NGO and government

partnerships Groups considered the good the bad and the ugly of short-

term urban mission teams

2Tese aims are detailed at ldquoInternational Society or Urban Mission Summitrdquo httpnewurbanworld

orgsummit

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1836

Glocalizing Conversations 10486261048629

Te summit was a thrilling example of how Majority World and Western

leaders can cooperate It was a time to come together in an environment of

mutual learning and enrichment It was a window into how local contextsand global themes can enrich each other Tis resulted from ISUMrsquos com-

mitment to ldquosolidarity fellowship and insight between urban Christian

leaders in the Western and Majority Worldsrdquo

Te summit was a success due to ISUMrsquos core values What are they983091 Christ-

honoring urban mission values bottom-up grassroots perspectivesmdashrather

than top-down distanced perspectives It allows local theology to reveal new

insights and perspectives about Godrsquos activity It shares insights and experi-ences through narratives embedded within urban poor communities and cities

It cultivates ongoing practical and personal solidarity with the worldrsquos urban

poor Tis Spirit-empowered urban mission honors networks relationships

and partnerships It sees such relationships as the primary method of serving

together It listens to and amplifies the voices of the urban poormdashespecially

those from the Majority World and in particular the 1048625104862410486281048624 window cities It is

attentive to signs of the kingdom of God Urban mission that glorifies God iswilling to reflect and respond with active and sacrificial commitment It shares

and extends the life of the body of Christ among the urban poor

Tis summit was a milestone in urban missiology It enriched communi-

cation between Western and Majority World thinker-activists Tis resulted

from the aims and values Irsquove mentioned Effective urban mission needs to

be a conversation on many levels It is attentive to context and immersed in

local settings It appreciates global and universal missional themes It culti-

vates dialogue between these local-global (glocal) realities It involves

mutual learning between Western and Majority World thinker-activists

Moreover solidarity between all parties is a defining feature Tis solidarity

is due to a compelling vision of the kingdom of God

Tese collaborative glocal features of the ISUM urban mission summit

in Bangkok are critical for the aims of this book GlobalChurch

Majority World indigenous and Western leaders thinkers and churches

can stretch and enrich each other But they need to be open and attentive to

each other Tey need learning postures and open hearts and minds Tey

3ldquoAbout ISUMrdquo httpnewurbanworldorgabout

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1936

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2036

Glocalizing Conversations 10486261048631

always rooted in the local and particularmdashas local churches embody the

gospel and witness to Christ Tese churches forge their own theological

understandings as they do mission together Tey engage in transformationalpractices among the people in their settings Tey enjoy worship mission

and community in their local and particular context Ideally the result is

unique contextual theologies and missions

Simultaneously global conversations form Tey form because of this

multitude of local theologies and practices Local conversations inform and

enrich other local conversations catalyzing global themes and voices izon

observes that the global ldquoowes its existence to local contexts Sharedconvictions among the theologies and practices of local contextual realities

give shape to its global dimensionsrdquo1048629

Majority World indigenous and Western theologies are equally contextual

Tey are equally culture bound Tey are equally particular to their time and

location At times they are all enlightened or myopic liberating or con-

straining humanizing or objectifying beautiful or offensive prophetic or

tepid Te local particular and cultural shape all these theologies Converselythese particular theologies feed and influence global conversations Tere is

no place then for ethnocentrism colonialism or elitism Tere is no place

for theological missional cultural or institutionalized arrogance

Multiple local contexts and voices come togethermdashintentionally or notmdashto

form global themes and theologies Conversely these global realities shape

local contexts oday local contexts must grapple with ldquoan emerging global

culture ie the interacting realities of modernity postmodernity and the

phenomenon of globalizationrdquo1048630 Hence the interdependent and symbiotic

relationship between the localparticular and the globaluniversal We call this

interdependent relationship between the local and the global glocalization

Te global church needs a thrilling glocal exchange We need one that we

characterize by mutuality respect partnership and symbiosis Such ex-

change helps Majority World indigenous and Western churches learn from

each other It enables them to pursue missional theology and practice o-

gether the church becomes a ldquocity on a hillrdquo

5Ibid 10486259830886Ibid 9830961048628

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2136

10486261048632 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

W983144983137983156 R983141983153983157983145983154983141983155 G983148983151983139983137983148983145983162983137983156983145983151983150983103

Te glocal exchange described above needs to be broader than transforma-

tional mission Tis is necessary if the church is to develop a robust inter-cultural and glocal missional ecclesiology

In my first book Salt Light and a City I outlined the foundational

themes of missional ecclesiology983095 Majority World and Western leaders

need to engage these themes in local and contextual ways Teir insights can

then enrich global conversations Tese global conversations in turn shape

local understandings and practices Tis way a glocal appreciation of these

themes emergesLocal regional and global theologies and practices are thereby enriched

Te church becomes healthier and more missionalmdasha truer expression of

the kingdom Te church becomes a fuller witness to Christ his passion for

the nations and his ability to bring unity in diversity

Stephen Bevans and Roger Schroeder outline the six constants of mission

Tese are our theologies about Jesus the church the end times salvation

human nature and culture Bevans and Schroeder describe the relationshipbetween these six and their historical cultural and theological contexts Tis is

why they call these six constants in context Our understanding of these six

constants develops in relation to local and global movements Sometimes local

voices influence our understandings of these six Other times it is regional or

global voices For all of us local regional and global influences are at play at

once Collectively they form our appreciation of the six constants of mission1048632

Here are eight theological themes that the church can develop through

processes of glocalization I presented these in my book Salt Light and a City

Tey are vital to the churchrsquos health mission community and future We

could add many other themes to these eight but these will suffice for now1048633

Scripture Te Scriptures are the infallible authoritative Word of God

Christrsquos Spirit has inspired them Tey have absolute and final authority in

all aspects of corporate and individual faith ethics conduct and witness

Christians interpret and apply Scripture in local contexts and in particular

7Graham Hill Salt Light and a City Introducing Missional Ecclesiology (Eugene OR Wip and

Stock 9830909830881048625983090) 10486251048628983097-983090104863110486288Stephen B Bevans and Roger Schroeder Constants in Context A Teology o Mission or oday

American Society o Missiology Series (Maryknoll NY Orbis 9830909830889830881048628) part one9Tese points first appeared in my book Salt Light and a City xxii-xxiv

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2236

Glocalizing Conversations 10486261048633

social settings Conversely we learn from the interpretations and readings

of other groups

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our local- global theology of Scripture and biblical interpretation

Evangelicalism Pentecostalism missional movements and so forth I

have charismatic missional and evangelical convictions Glocal conversa-

tions help me understand and practice these convictions better

I will use evangelicalism as an example Michael Horton says that our

beliefs and practices are evangelical when they are ldquocommitted to the suffi-

ciency of Scripture the priesthood of all believers the total lostness ofhumans the sole mediation of Christ the gracious efficacy and finality of

Godrsquos redemptive work in Christ through election propitiation calling and

keeping Te linchpin for all of this was the doctrine of justification by grace

alone through faith alone because of Christ alonerdquo9830891048624

Such convictions are necessary if we are to be faithful to the gospel and

to a biblical vision of church and mission Te gospel defines Godrsquos purposes

for humanity the church and the universe Te triune God controls thechurch He is its Lord and Savior Sanctifier and Liberator Master and King

He is completely sovereign over its nature affairs mission and history God

is the churchrsquos only source of grace election atonement salvation and per-

severance Te churchrsquos justification and hope are by grace alone through

faith alone by Christ alone

Herersquos the challenge I face My understanding of evangelicalism is

Western I am a product of the Western theological tradition and my Western

evangelical heritage Much of this is wonderful But I need indigenous and

Majority World evangelicals and others to help me expand and reshape

these insights Te same would be true if I were a Pentecostal

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of our theological traditions and convictions

Jesus Christ We must center our theology on Jesus Christ the Lord of

the church Te church needs to reflect on the person and work of Christ

and respond to him Tis means gathering and going in the name and power

of Christ It means allowing Christrsquos Spirit to shape our community and

10Michael Horton ldquoEvangelical Arminiansrdquo Modern Reormation 1048625 no 1048627 (1048625983097983097983090) 10486251048631

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2336

10486271048624 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

identity and mission It means developing our Christology ecclesiology and

missiology concurrently Te early church developed these three areas and

more in a concurrent and integrated way Tere was no linear progressionTe same is true in the contemporary global church

How can the glocal church best explore its nature structure mission and

hope Trough the centrality and the lordship of Christ

Majority World and indigenous Christians help us appreciate Jesus and

his mission afresh Tey show us how Jesus identifies with the marginalized

outcast oppressed rejected and broken He prefers them We find him

among ldquothe least of theserdquoGlocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of who Jesus Christ is How does it help us appreciate him better

What has Jesus done for and in his church and his world What does he care

about What individual and corporate responsibilities has he given us How

do we express these at local regional and global levels

Te Spirit Missional ecclesiology is inadequate without pneumatological

foundations In other words our theology of church and Spirit go togetherTe Spirit creates and animates the church He empowers it to witness to

Jesus and his gospel Te Spirit enables the church to be a missional trans-

formational community He shapes the church into an alternative society

embodying the reign of God Te church exists for the glory and mission of

Christ Te power and presence of the Spirit enables this mission worship

and glorification

Te Spirit pours out gis on the local-global church ldquofor the common

goodrdquo and ldquoto equip his people for works of service so that the body of Christ

may be built uprdquo Tis includes but isnrsquot limited to the ministry gis mani-

festation gis and motivational gis (1048625 Cor 104862510486261048631 Eph 104862810486251048625-10486251048626 Rom 104862510486261048630-1048632)

Te Spirit forms the glocal church He empowers it for service and

witness He fills it with Christrsquos empowering presence He leads it into the

missio Deimdashthe mission of the Father Son and Holy Spirit

Recently Pentecostal and renewalist movements have grown dramati-

cally in the Majority World Tey have increased in status size and influence

Many have matured theologically Te churches of the West must take notice

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of the power and presence of the Spirit

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2436

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048625

Te rinity Tere are clear limitations to the analogy between the

church and the rinity Te church can only image the rinity Yet the

church is at its best when it reflects the relational and missional passionof the rinity

What is the source and inspiration of the churchrsquos local-global mission

Ultimately it is the missional nature passion and actions of the Father Son

and Holy Spirit Godrsquos nature is missional His passion is infectious His

actions are historical redemptive and eternal Te rinity invites the

church into a sending community Te Father sends the Son Te Father

and Son send the Spirit Finally the rinity sends the church in missioninto the world

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of the rinity How does it enable our participation in the mission

and community of the triune God

Association and dialogue Tese need to happen across denominational

cultural ethnic gender and theological traditions and divides Authentic

dialogue is indispensable to the health and mission of the church What dothose marginal to the life of the church have to say to us What do ldquoothersrdquo

have to teach us Other ethnicities and cultures Other socioeconomic

groups Other ages and genders Other theological and confessing tradi-

tions Other persons from times long gone

We need to listen Share Be vulnerable Be authentic Open up to crit-

icism correction and change

We need more than dialogue We need communion and association It is

possible in a qualified way to say that God is present in all the various forms

of the church (ie the various theological ecclesiological sociocultural his-

torical and other permutations of the church) We discern this presence

through attention to Scripture history tradition culture and the Spirit Dis-

cernment involves critical dialogue theological exchange biblical study and

real relationship Only the Spirit of Jesus can enable this

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of association and dialogue

Mission and the missio Dei Te church is missional at its core It serves

obeys and images a missionary God David Bosch says ldquoTe churchrsquos mission

is not secondary to its being the church exists in being sent and in building up

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2536

10486271048626 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

itself for its missionrdquo He goes on to say ldquoEcclesiology does not precede missi-

ology there cannot be church without an intrinsic missionary dimensionrdquo983089983089

Jesus is Lord Lord of his church and Lord of his world His mission de-termines and forms the church His mission shapes the nature purposes

structures ministries and activities of his church Majority World and in-

digenous thinkers help us understand the implications of this mission Tey

help us form glocal theologies of mission Tey reveal ldquomission in context

as transformationrdquo9830891048626

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of mission and the missio Dei Church theology and practice Glocal conversations can inform and

enrich many aspects of the church (when practiced well) Teologies and

practices benefit from robust and critical glocal conversations Tese con-

versations enrich many areas (community spirituality discipleship liturgy

worship hospitality eco-justice education social ethics servantship lib-

eration place suffering beauty and so on)

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-standing of these many dimensions of church and mission

Glocal processes shape these eight themes and their practices We need

to facilitate and enable these conversations and processes Tis is urgent It

must be a priority No theology of mission or missional ecclesiology is ad-

equate without glocal conversations983089983091

T983144983141 L983151983139983137983148 983137983150983140 G983148983151983138983137983148 E983150983154983145983139983144 E983137983139983144 O983156983144983141983154

Glocalization takes the localparticular context and globaluniversal themes

seriously Contextual and global conversations enter an enriching and in-

forming relationship Tese two always have an active and symbiotic rela-

tionship Tis is true whether we deliberately put them into conversation or

not Te local shapes the global and the global shapes the local Many local

11David J Bosch Believing in the Future oward a Missiology o Western Culture (New York

rinity 1048625983097983097983093) 104862798309012izon ransormation Afer Lausanne 1048631-98309713Not all o these themes are dealt with in this present volume since either (1048625) I have dealt with them

in my book Salt Light and a City (983090) they are not all key themes in the writings o the thirty-five

Majority World thinkers considered in this volume or (1048627) there is not adequate space in a book

this size

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2636

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048627

voices converge to form global conversations and theologies Using the Phil-

ippines as a case study izon illustrates this by showing the interdepen-

dence between local and global themes in mission983089983092Dialogue between local and global conversations is critical Kōsuke

Koyama wrote an important book on contextual mission called Water Buffalo

Teology Koyama is a Japanese missionary who served in Chiang Mai

Tailand He writes of the joys and challenges of doing local particular water

buffalo theology He considers the relationship between local theology global

missional themes and transforming cultures ldquoWater Buffalo Teology sees

certain specific challenges Contextualization of theology implies two criticalmovements First to articulate Jesus Christ in culturally appropriate com-

municatively apt words and second to criticize reform dethrone or oppose

culture if it is found to be against what the name of Jesus Christ stands forrdquo9830891048629

Kōsuke Koyama challenges us to recognize what we bring to the task of

local theology For him it was doing theology in Tailand while being Jap-

anese We also need to notice the particular culture wersquore located in as we do

the work of theology Tis means we avoid speaking of an ldquoAsian theologyrdquoldquoAfrican theologyrdquo and the like We need to cultivate local theologies that

engage regional and global themes But these theologies must be ldquodistinctly

localrdquo and a ldquotheology from belowrdquo9830891048630

Simultaneously we need to pursue a reformation of theology and

practice ldquoin the global contextrdquo Tis means entering ldquothe disturbing spa-

ciousness of Jesus Christrdquo Jesus calls us to reject enmity and exceptionalism

We seem him present in our culture language stories and relationships

But we also choose to embrace the ldquootherrdquo We choose to see him present

in other culturesmdashshaping a global people to serve and worship him

joining in his mission983089983095

Kōsuke Koyama roots the gospel in the local contextual and particular

Tis is why he roots his water buffalo theology in Northern Tai culture He

is careful not to say ldquoHere is how you contextualize in your settingrdquo Instead

14izon ransormation Afer Lausanne 1048631-10486251048627 10486251048628983097-98309098308898309015Kōsuke Koyama Water Buffalo Teology 983090983093th anniversary ed (Maryknoll NY Orbis 1048625983097983097983097)

xiii-xv16Kōsuke Koyama ldquoTe Asian Approach to Christrdquo Missiology 1048625983090 no 1048628 (10486259830979830961048628) 10486281048627983093-104862798309617Kōsuke Koyama ldquoReormation in the Global Context Te Disturbing Spaciousness o Jesus Christrdquo

Currents in Teology and Mission 1048627983088 no 983090 (9830909830889830881048627) 10486251048625983097-983090983096

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2736

10486271048628 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

he tells us a story Itrsquos the story of how he contextualized theology in northern

Tailand while being open to global conversations Koyama asks us to form

our own local expressions of church mission and theology At the same timewe must stay attentive to what God is saying and doing beyond that context

Tis way local and global and particular and universal become mutually

enriching conversation partners

G983148983151983139983137983148983145983162983137983156983145983151983150 983137983150983140 H983145983155983156983151983154983145983139983137983148983148983161 S983145983148983141983150983139983141983140 V983151983145983139983141983155

Glocal theologies and conversations pay attention to voices that powers in-

stitutions religions and societies have silenced R S Sugirtharajah pushesback a little on izonrsquos ideas Sugirtharajah says that the church should

privilege local conversations He emphasizes the local contextual and post-

colonial reading of biblical texts9830891048632

Te church needs to listen Te church ought to be attentive to the

theologies and biblical interpretations of groups that cultures and reli-

gions have ignored Historically powerful secular and religious forces

have silenced these groups Tey have marginalized oppressed and colo-nized them It is time for the church to address this injustice We must

start listening to important but silenced voices We need to privilege the

voices of the former victims of Western colonialism We need to develop

postcolonial biblical interpretations theologies and expressions of church

and mission

How do we take such perspectives seriously as we develop glocal conver-

sations How do these themes help us foster vital relationships between local

and global voices

It is time for us to embrace values that enable conversations with those

oen ignored by the church We need values that help us learn from these

groups and individuals

Valuing equal partnership Colonizing powers oppressed silenced and

colonized certain groups At times the church was complicit Tese colo-

nized groups have become ldquoconfident indomitable and indispensable

partners in the dialogue and collaboration with the dispossessed and disad-

18R S Sugirtharajah Asian Biblical Hermeneutics and Postcolonialism Contesting the Interpreta-

tions Te Bible and Liberation Series (Maryknoll NY Orbis 1048625983097983097983096) 1048625983093-1048625983094

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2836

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048629

vantaged in the Westrdquo9830891048633 Tis calls for attentiveness to these voices and re-

sponsiveness to their prophetic challenges It also demands a critical evalu-

ation of colonial readings of Scripture Colonial models of theology andchurch and mission are no longer the benchmark Te global church must

examine them afresh

Valuing equal status Tose on the margins have now taken their rightful

place on the global stage Tey have claimed appropriate and equal status at

the table Subaltern readings of theology church and mission are invaluable

contributors to global theological conversations Tis means that we esteem

them But we also test themWhat do we mean by subaltern Subalterns are those who are down-

trodden and silenced (or have been treated this way in the past) Dominant

or colonizing groups treat them as invisible nonentities Tey enjoy limited

or no access to power Sometimes these are women certain tribal and ethnic

groups and those considered ldquountouchablerdquo In Voices from the Margin Su-

girtharajah provides a platform for postcolonial subaltern readings of

Scripture and theology Tese readings challenge colonialmdashoen Westernmdashreadings of Bible and theology and cultures Tey claim equal status with

other ways of doing theology10486261048624

Valuing equal identity People groups need freedom to explore their new

and emerging identities Tese emerge in response to local and global influ-

ences Local culture is not the only thing at work here Global forces also

shape identity as do imported practices ideas readings rituals and tech-

nologies But each group should be free to explore and construct their par-

ticular forms of Christian identity

Valuing equal interpretations ldquoPostcolonialism is concerned with the

question of cultural and discursive dominationrdquo Colonialism led to op-

pressive and controlling forms of culture and discourse Tese were usually

not contextual or indigenous Western powers for instance brought co-

lonial forms of theology church biblical interpretation and mission1048626983089

Postcolonialism calls for alternative ways of approaching these things Tose

19Ibid 104862598309420R S Sugirtharajah Voices rom the Margin Interpreting the Bible in the Tird World (Maryknoll

NY Orbis 10486259830979830971048625)21Sugirtharajah Asian Biblical Hermeneutics and Postcolonialism 10486251048631

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2936

10486271048630 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

who were once marginalized oppressed and silenced need to lead these fresh

approaches in their own settings Tese then influence global conversations

We need to support the new readings and insights and experiments from thesegroups o be genuine this support must be both critical and collegial

Valuing equal empowerment Sugirtharajah says that postcolonialism is

valuable when it empowers actual communities and real people Post-

colonial thought empowers when it addresses the difficulties hopes and

experiences of ordinary people It should never be about power plays and

the clever use of language Itrsquos pointless if itrsquos obsessed with forming newmdash

and ldquocolonizingrdquomdashtheories Itrsquos a waste of time if itrsquos a self-indulgent pursuitof new and hybrid identities Rather ldquothe worth and credibility of post-

colonial criticism will be judged by how it orchestrates the unique and

fragile and imagined claims of one community against anotherrdquo Empow-

erment happens in a variety of ways One way is contributing equally to

global conversations10486261048626

Al izon examines postcolonialism in the Philippines He says that it can

teach the global church a lot about healthy local-global conversations Fil-ipino contextual theology resists many Western forms of mission and the-

ology It finds them patronizing and controlling Tis indigenous theology

values prophetic sociopolitical engagement in institutions and the society

at large It emphasizes ministry to whole persons and communities It con-

structs a Filipino theology of beauty and mission and worship and com-

munity And it fosters indigenous theological approaches to the spirit world

and cosmology

izon says that postcolonial theology has played a constructive role in

the Philippines But he is uncomfortable with the label postcolonialism He

prefers to describe historical events as ldquobeyond colonialismrdquo And he says

that global conversations enrich local theologies and vice versa1048626983091

Postcolonial thought informs our understanding of the relationship be-

tween the local and global It also shows how theology can emerge at the

intersection between the localparticular and the globaluniversal It re-

minds us that worthwhile glocalization listens to all voices Tis includes

heeding those that have been historically silenced

22Ibid 983090104862823izon ransormation Afer Lausanne 1048625983088983090 10486259830941048631-9830961048631

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3036

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048631

G983148983151983139983137983148983145983162983137983156983145983151983150 983137983150983140 983156983144983141 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

C983151983150983139983148983157983140983145983150983143 R983141983142983148983141983139983156983145983151983150983155

How do we go about developing a model for glocal conversations izon hasrecently provided a useful model that is instructive as we seek to learn from

the Majority World It has at least two key features

First the local is in the global (globalization from below) Global theologies

and ideas have origins in many particular local contexts In that sense glo-

balization is from below Global ideas have local roots Ideas about integral

mission liberation theology and missional church have local origins Tey

have their roots in the prayers hopes discoveries mission and theologiesof thousands of local communities ldquoTe global does not cannot exist

without the localmdashbut the coming together of localities creates a global re-

ality that becomes greater than the sum of its parts it creates a gestalt entity

to which localities make themselves accountablerdquo1048626983092

Second the global is in the local (panlocalization from above) Te con-

cerns and voices of multitudes of locales form global conversations Tese

global discussions can provide a ldquopositive accountabilityrdquo back to local con-texts Tis is true when they enrich affirm serve guide and strengthen local

contexts It is also true when they avoid homogenization control impo-

sition and judgment Glocalization is best when it sees itself as interde-

pendent deeply connected with the local10486261048629

Tatrsquos a helpful starting point But we need to go further Besides izonrsquos

proposals Irsquom convinced that robust glocal conversations cultivate six core

practices

983089 Glocal theology practices its values We root glocal theology in core

values Tese values include solidarity understanding and mutual learning

Do we value fellowship with Christians of all cultures Do we value learning

from them

We prove our values through our practices What practices emerge out of

these values We need to collaborate act collectively and share information

We must find ways to foster grassroots perspectives and local theologies We

need to share stories and learnings and cultivate networks relationships and

partnerships We need attentiveness to local voices and global themes We

24Ibid 9830901048625983088-1048625104862825Ibid 98309010486251048628-1048625983096

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3136

10486271048632 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

ought to find ways to put these local and global voices into conversation

Mutual learning humility and solidarity are key Worthwhile glocal con-

versations can never be merely theoretical or academic It is up to us to rootour values in our practices

983090 Glocal theology practices humility (and it tells a new narrative) We

have noted that the local is in the global and the global is in the local Te

two are interdependent Tey form each other reciprocally Since this is the

case we must practice humility Tere is no place for ethnocentrism colo-

nialism or theological and cultural arrogance I have seen these unhealthy

postures far too oen in Western settingsRecently I attended a missional leadership conference On that occasion

the keynote speakermdasha leading missional author and speakermdashsaid that

North American missional conversations and innovations hold the key to

the future of the Western church Tis Euro American view is wrong (Irsquom

being kind o be frank itrsquos complete nonsense) Itrsquos arrogant and Euro

Americanndashcentric And itrsquos completely out of step with what is happening in

the glocal church We need a new narrativeIn June 1048626104862410486251048627 Te Center for the Study of Global Christianity reported

the top 10486261048624 countries where Christianity has the highest percentage growth

rate Nineteen of the top twenty are in Asia and Africa Eleven of them are

in Muslim majority countries Not a single country from Europe or North

America makes the top twenty list10486261048630

Itrsquos time to cultivate a new narrative Te future of the church is emerging

from the Majority World Rather than North America the churches of

Eastern Asia Western Africa the Arabian Peninsula and other parts of the

Majority World reveal the future of the global church We need the contribu-

tions of all contexts Western indigenous and Majority World All con-

tribute to glocal conversations All are important as we learn from each

other about mission theology and faith But letrsquos stop pretending that North

Americans and Europeans will reveal the future of the global church Letrsquos

start listening to what God is saying about the future of the global church

And hersquos speaking to us through the churches of Asia Africa Latin America

26Russ Mitchell ldquoTe op 983090983088 Countries Where Christianity Is Growing the Fastestrdquo Disciple All

Nations (blog) August 983090983093 98309098308810486251048627 httpsdiscipleallnationswordpresscom98309098308810486251048627983088983096983090983093the-top

-983090983088-countries-where-christianity-is-growing-the-astest

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3236

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048633

Muslim majority settings and so on We must cultivate a new glocal nar-

rativemdashone soaked in humility

Glocal theology must be humble theology Meek theology Receptive the-ology Discerning theology Prayerful theology Dialogical theology De-

pendent theology A theology that celebrates the interdependence between

the localparticular and the globaluniversal

983091 Glocal theology practices expansiveness Glocalization is by nature

comprehensive Local and global influences permeate much of our lives Tese

glocal forces shape our theologies and churches whether we like it or not

But intentionality is also important We need to commit to an expansiveapproach to glocal theology How do we deliberately cultivate glocal conver-

sations in our biblical interpretation Do we foster them in our under-

standing of the person and work of Christ How does glocalization shape

the way the Spirit empowers and constitutes the church How can it form

our understanding of the nature and mission of the rinity How does it

influence the way we practice fellowship and conversation across denomi-

national cultural ethnic economic sociocultural political gender andtheological divides How might it shape our theologies of mission com-

munity beauty spirituality suffering discipleship hospitality eco-justice

place education social ethics Christian leadership and so forth

983092 Glocal theology practices attention Glocal theology doesnrsquot need to

accept all the assumptions or assertions of postcolonial or Majority World

thought But it does need to engage with them and take them seriously

Postcolonial theology for instance gives the marginalized and colonized

and forgotten and silenced both dignity and voice Our glocal conversations

must also include and esteem these groups We need to be attentive to

others weak and powerful female and male dominant and downtrodden

old and young rich and poor privileged and marginalized influential and

subaltern educated and illiterate We need to practice the art of attention

being especially attentive to those who are different to us

983093 Glocal theology practices embrace What do colonial ethnocentric or

Western-centric perspectives do Tey silence Tey control Tey com-

modify Tey institutionalize Tey colonize Tey domesticate Tey replace

Tey import Tey exclude Tey do these things to the beliefs experiences

and practices of other cultures A worthwhile glocal theology refuses to do

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3336

10486281048624 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

these things Instead it adopts a responsive humble celebratory open in-

clusive and embracing attitude

983094 Glocal theology practices discernment Finally we need discernmentas we engage these ideas and practices Discernment is a huge topic thatrsquos

hard to cover comprehensively in a few words Discernment happens when

the Spirit of Christ and his Word renew our minds Te Spirit grants us

spiritual wisdom as we meditate on him and his Word and as we practice

discipleship to Jesus Christ Romans 10486251048626 provides guidance we need (1048625) to be

transformed by the renewal of our minds (1048626) to serve Christrsquos body and (1048627)

to put love into action Discernment also happens in conversation both lo-cally and glocally

I pray these core values and six practices come across in the following

chapters of GlobalChurch

Glocalization can never be just theoretical Are we committed to moving

glocalization from an abstract idea to a living communion Are we deter-

mined to construct a missional theology of the church in the context of

glocal conversations Tis must involve dialogue between Majority Worldindigenous and Western scholars activists and groups

Will glocalization be an abstract notion Or will it be a formative and

genuine communion between local regional and global voices Glocal dy-

namics are at play whether we like it or not Teyrsquore in our churches the-

ologies and missions But we can choose to relinquish isolationist colonial

parochial and arrogant approaches Instead we can adopt responsive dia-

logical learning humble and embracing postures

Trough healthy approaches to glocalization the Spirit challenges us to

value local contexts We immerse ourselves in local and particular commu-

nities and conversations He inspires us to open ourselves to global theo-

logical conversations He rouses us to value the symbiotic relationship be-

tween the localparticular and the globaluniversal

Trough glocal relationships the Spirit leads us to put local contextual

theologies into conversation with global ones He prompts us to explore the

ways in which the local is in the glocal and the global is in the local He per-

suades us to pursue collaboration and dialogue and mutual learning We

engage with Christians from different backgrounds and cultures ecumen-

icals Pentecostals evangelicals and so on from Western indigenous and

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3436

Glocalizing Conversations 10486281048625

Majority World contexts He motivates us to express solidarity between all

parties We appreciate our unity in diversity

Trough glocal conversations the Spirit moves us to ensure that unity andsolidarity emerge from a compelling vision of Jesusrsquo kingdom and gospel

and person He challenges us to share information theology and practices

He urges us to learn from each othermdashour successes and mistakes We seek

glocal solutions

Te Spirit calls us to develop glocal conversations about Christian ideas

and practices Tese include Scripture Evangelicalism ecumenism Pente-

costalism Jesus Christ the Holy Spirit God the Father the rinity com-munity spirituality discipleship liturgy worship hospitality prayer eco-

justice education social ethics Christian leadership gospel and culture

beauty place suffering liberation and so forth

Finally through glocal conversations the Spirit leads us to adopt a new

posture Tis is a responsive humble celebratory open inclusive and em-

bracing attitude to the ldquootherrdquo We do this as a new people made up of every

tribe and language and people and nationTere are dangers in glocalization Sugirtharajah warns of the commodi-

fication of local contextual practices and theologies When this happens

they are ldquosmoothed out of their primary contexts concerns and contesta-

tions travel across borders and become objects of analysis and scrutiny

within an alien secondary contextrdquo1048626983095

Itrsquos common for those of us who are Western to make mistakes when we

wrestle with Majority World and indigenous ideas Sugirtharajah mentions

our tendency to commodify reduce and institutionalize these ideas We also

risk doing these things (1048625) We apply them in noncontextual prescriptive ways

(1048626) We ignore their meanings in their original setting (1048627) We glamorize or

idealize their proponents or their contexts (1048628) We demonize those persons or

contexts (1048629) We disregard them as irrelevant rhetorical or minority discourse

Kevin J Vanhoozer says that we can fall into three traps when we glo-

calize theology (1048625) We can underestimate the theological significance of

local cultures (1048626) We can homogenize cultures and theologies exaggerating

27R S Sugirtharajah ldquoextual ake-Aways Tird World exts in Western Metropolitan Centresrdquo

Black Teology in Britain A Journal o Contextual Praxis 983090 (1048625983097983097983097) 10486271048627 10486271048631 Edward W Said Te

World the ext and the Critic (Cambridge MA Harvard University Press 10486259830979830961048627) 9830901048627983097

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3536

10486281048626 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

ldquothe onerdquo (1048627) We can overemphasize cultural particularity exaggerating ldquothe

manyrdquo and pursue ldquotheological ethnificationrdquo10486261048632

My hope is that GlobalChurch does not fall into the traps Sugirtharajahand Vanhoozer describe I hope that what unfolds in the following chapters

is respectful and discerning I hope it leads to further mutually enriching

conversations between people of different cultures

You the reader face the same challenges You face them in your personal

life ministry context and missional engagements

Will you treat the themes in this book as abstract theoretical notions

Will this be a temporary infatuation a flirtation with the ldquootherrdquo that dissi-pates as suddenly as it arrived Or will glocal conversations become an en-

riching and formative orientation in your life Will glocal conversations

bring fresh approaches to theology faith mission church and worship Will

conversations with other cultures and theologies become for you a com-

pelling way of life

My prayer is that glocal conversations will help the church be a global

visible alternative ldquocity set upon a hillrdquo a truly GlobalChurch

28Craig Ott and Harold A Netland Globalizing Teology Belie and Practice in an Era o World

Christianity (Grand Rapids Baker Academic 983090983088983088983094) 1048625983090983093

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3636

Page 7: GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 736

I N T R O D U C T I O N

B983141983145983150983143 S983137983148983156 L983145983143983144983156 983137983150983140 983137 C983145983156 983161

By 9830909830889830901048629 fully two-thirds of Christians will live in

Africa Latin America and Asia Te ldquoaverage

Christianrdquo today is female black and lives in a

Brazilian favela or an African village

SEPHE N BEVANS

Majority World and indigenous churches are redefining twenty-first-

century Christianity Western churches must decide how theyrsquoll respond

Stephen Bevans puts it well

We are now living in a ldquoworld churchrdquo where the vast majority of Christians are

[from the Majority World] David Barrettrsquos statistical studies have basically con-

firmed this shi and Philip Jenkins has predicted that by 1048626104862410486261048629 fully two-thirds

of Christians will live in Africa Latin America and Asia Scholars are fairly

unanimous in acknowledging the accuracy of the facts Te ldquoaverage Christianrdquo

today is female black and lives in a Brazilian favela or an African village983089

Some statistics illustrate this shi in twenty-first-century global Christi-

anity Te Pew Research Centerrsquos report Global Christianity analyzes the size

and distribution of the worldrsquos Christian population Te report maps the

changes over the last century (1048625104863310486251048624 to 1048626104862410486251048624) It concludes ldquoA century ago the

Global North (commonly defined as North America Europe Australia Japan

1Stephen B Bevans Roger Schroeder and L J Luzbetak ldquoMissiology Afer Bosch Reverencing a

Classic by Moving Beyondrdquo International Bulletin o Missionary Research 983090983097 no 983090 (983090983088983088983093) 983094983097

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 836

10486251048628 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

and New Zealand) contained more than four times as many Christians as the

Global South (the rest of the world) oday the Pew Forum study finds more

than 10486251048627 billion Christians live in the Global South [10486301048625983077 of all Christians livein Asia Africa and Latin America] compared with about 104863210486301048624 million in the

Global North (10486271048633983077)rdquo1048626 Tat is an astounding shi in only one hundred years983091

Using the World Christian Database Philip Jenkins offers table 10486251048625

ldquoChanging distribution of Christian believersrdquo

Table 983089983089 Changing distribution of Christian believers 983089983097983088983088 to 983090983088983093983088 (number of Christiansin millions)

983089983097983088983088 983089983097983095983088 983090983088983089983088 983090983088983093983088Africa 983089983088 983089983092983091 983092983097983091 983089983088983091983089

Asia 983090983090 983097983094 983091983093983090 983094983088983089

North America 983095983097 983090983089983089 983090983096983094 983091983091983091

Latin America 983094983090 983090983095983088 983093983092983092 983094983093983093

Europe 983091983096983089 983092983097983090 983093983096983096 983093983091983088

Oceania 983093 983089983096 983090983096 983091983096

Total 983093983093983096 983089983090983091983088 983090983090983097983089 983091983089983096983096

Source Philip Jenkins The Next Christendom The Coming of Global Christianity 983091rd ed (Oxford Oxford Uni-

versity Press 983090983088983089983089) 983091 Data is taken from World Christian Database wwwworldchristiandatabaseorgwcd

Christianity in North America Europe and Oceania grew from 104862810486301048629

million in 1048625104863310486241048624 to 104863310486241048626 million in 1048626104862410486251048624983092 Tis number is likely to shrink to

104863310486241048625 million by 1048626104862410486291048624

Christianity in Africa Asia and Latin America grew from 10486331048628 million in

1048625104863310486241048624 to 1048625104862710486321048633 billion in 1048626104862410486251048624 Tis number is likely to grow to 1048626104862610486321048631 billion by

1048626104862410486291048624

Letrsquos take China for example Professor Fenggang Yang of Purdue University

makes an important prediction If current rates of growth continue within one

generation China will have more Christians than any other nation on earth

In 1048625104863310486281048633 Protestant churches in China had one million members In 1048626104862410486251048624 that

number was 10486291048632 million (compare that with 10486281048624 million in Brazil and 10486271048630 million

2Pew Research Center Global Christianity A Report on the Size and Distribution o the Worldrsquos Chris-

tian Population December 1048625983097 98309098308810486251048625 wwwpeworumorg9830909830881048625104862510486259830901048625983097global-christianity-exec3See David B Barrett George Kurian and odd M Johnson World Christian Encyclopedia A

Comparative Survey o Churches and Religions in the Modern World 983090nd ed 983090 vols (New York

Oxord University Press 9830909830889830881048625) 1048625983090-1048625983093 and wwwglobalchristianityorg4Oceania includes Australia and Micronesian Melanesian and Polynesian countries

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 936

Introduction 10486251048629

in South Africa) By 1048626104862410486261048629 there are likely to be 104862510486301048624 million Christians in China

By 1048626104862410486271048624 this number is likely to be 104862610486281048631 million (outnumbering Christians in

Mexico Brazil and the United States) In an interview with the elegraphFenggang Yang says ldquoMao thought he could eliminate religion He thought he

had accomplished this Itrsquos ironicmdashthey didnrsquot Tey actually failed completelyrdquo1048629

Philip Jenkins concludes

We are currently living through one of the transforming moments in the

history of religion worldwide Over the last five centuries the story of Chris-

tianity has been inextricably bound up with that of Europe and European-

derived civilizations overseas above all in North America Until recently theoverwhelming majority of Christians have lived in white nations Over the

last century however the center of gravity in the Christian world has shied

inexorably away from Europe southward to Africa and Latin America and

eastward toward Asia oday the largest Christian communities on the planet

are to be found in those regions1048630

What does all this mean for the mission and theology and worship and

communities of the church worldwide And what does it mean particularlyfor the Western church

In Matthew 104862910486251048627-10486251048630 Jesus provides three remarkable images of the churchmdash

salt light and a city Jesus confronts his disciples with a missional description

of the church Te church in mission is the salt of the earth the light of the

world and a city set on a hill Te churchrsquos purpose is to let its ldquolight shine

before others that they may see your good deeds and glorify your Father in

heavenrdquo Te purpose of the churchrsquos missionary nature is the worship andglorification of the Father and Son and Holy Spirit983095

Te church is another city constituted by every tribe language people

5om Phillips ldquoChina on Course to Become lsquoWorldrsquos Most Christian Nationrsquo Within 1048625983093 Yearsrdquo

elegraph April 1048625983097 98309098308810486251048628 wwwtelegraphcouknewsworldnewsasiachina1048625983088104863110486319830949830889830901048627China-on

-course-to-become-worlds-most-Christian-nation-within-1048625983093-yearshtml See Fenggang Yang and

Joseph B amney eds Conucianism and Spiritual raditions in Modern China and Beyond Re-

ligion in Chinese Societies (Boston Brill 9830909830881048625983090) Fenggang Yang and Graeme Lang eds Social

Scientific Studies o Religion in China Methodology Teories and Findings (Leiden Brill 98309098308810486251048625)

Fenggang Yang Religion in China Survival and Revival Under Communist Rule (Oxord Oxord

University Press 9830909830881048625983090)6Philip Jenkins Te Next Christendom Te Coming o Global Christianity 1048627rd ed (Oxord Ox-

ord University Press 98309098308810486251048625) 10486257J Driver Images o the Church in Mission (Scottdale PA Herald 10486259830979830971048631) 10486251048631983088-9830961048625 Graham Hill Salt

Light and a City Introducing Missional Ecclesiology (Eugene OR Wip and Stock 9830909830881048625983090) xiii

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1036

10486251048630 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

and nation Te church must cultivate a distinct social existence shaping its

community and mission around its commitment to plurality and diversity

and unity1048632 God calls his church to be a global and missional ldquocity on a hillrdquoTis is a church constituted and enriched and represented by Western and

indigenous and Majority World peoples

Tose of us in the West need a new narrative Itrsquos time to abandon our

flawed Eurocentric and Americentric worldviews We need a new global

and missional narrative and for that we must turn to the churches of Ma-

jority World and indigenous cultures Tey can help us explore what it

means to be a global missional community Many Christian communitiesin Majority World and indigenous contexts have been wrestling with these

issues for generations Marginalization and persecution and alienation have

been their lot Yet somehow in spite of or because of that they have flour-

ished In fact theyrsquove grown exponentially

So whom am I talking about when I refer to Majority World and indig-

enous Christians Majority World Christians are those in Africa Asia the

Caribbean Eastern Europe Latin America the Middle East and Oceania

1048633

I use the term Majority World because the majority of the worldrsquos population

is in those cultures today Te majority of the church is in those cultures too

I donrsquot use the terms non-Western or Tird World or Developing World Tese

terms use Western cultures as their point of reference Tey imply Western

8Barry A Harvey Another City An Ecclesiological Primer or a Post-Christian World (New York

rinity 1048625983097983097983097) 9830901048627-9830909830939I donrsquot deal with the diasporas in this book For example Irsquove made no mention o Hispanic

Portuguese or Asian minorities in the United States United Kingdom Canada Europe Austra-lia and so on Irsquom aware that right now Latin American and Chinese diasporas are active in

evangelism and mission in Europe in the same way in which the Filipino or the Salvadoran dias-

poras carry on mission in the United States Irsquove chosen not to include voices rom the diasporas

mainly because there are so many worthy contributors in that group and I donrsquot have the space

to treat them well in this book In the uture I hope that I (or someone else) will write a book

exploring what we can learn rom the diasporas Hispanic minorities or example are making

significant contributions to the theological and missiological conversation in the United States

that are relevant to this subject Methodist historian Justo L Gonzaacutelez and Pentecostal theologian

Eldin Villaantildee are examples In Mantildeana Gonzaacutelez describes the shape and orm o a theology

developed in the Hispanic margin o the United States In Out o Every ribe and Nation he shows

what would be implied in listening to minorities within a denominational setting Villaantildeersquos Te

Liberating Spirit is a milestone in the reflection about the relationship between pneumatology and

social ethics See Justo L Gonzaacutelez Out o Every ribe and Nation Christian Teology at the

Ethnic Roundtable (Nashville Abingdon 1048625983097983097983090) Gonzaacutelez Mantildeana Christian Teology rom a

Hispanic Perspective (Nashville Abingdon 1048625983097983097983088) Eldin Villaantildee Te Liberating Spirit oward

an Hispanic American Pentecostal Social Ethic (Grand Rapids Eerdmans 10486259830979830971048627)

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1136

Introduction 10486251048631

superiority or centricity Te term Global South is too limiting given the

breadth of the group I am engaging Majority World seems to work best

In 1048626104862410486241048628 Te Lausanne Forum for World Evangelization in PattayaTailand voted unanimously that the phrase Majority World Church replace

other terms People from all over the globe participated in this forum

imothy C ennent agrees that this is the best phrase ldquoIt helps to highlight

the basic point that Africa Asia and Latin America are where the majority

of the worldrsquos Christians are now locatedrdquo9830891048624 I expand the phrase Majority

World beyond Africa Asia and Latin America to include the Caribbean

Eastern Europe Oceania and the Middle EastIndigenous and First Nations peoples are ldquothose ethnic groups that were

indigenous to a territory prior to being incorporated into a national state

and who are politically and culturally separate from the majority ethnic

identity of the state that they are a part ofrdquo Tis includes people groups like

the Australian Aborigines and American Indians983089983089

Te aim of this book is to help Western churches rediscover what it means

to be salt light and a city by engaging in global missional conversations odo this Western Christians need to enter into conversation with Majority

World and indigenous Christians Listening to others helps us grow in our

understanding and practice of mission and church and theology For far too

long wersquove marginalized or ignored Majority World and indigenous voices

We must truly become a GlobalChurch

Tis aim shapes the bookrsquos structure as summarized below

P983137983154983156 1048625 S983137983148983156 R983141983155983144983137983152983145983150983143 O983157983154 C983151983150983158983141983154983155983137983156983145983151983150983155

ldquoYou are the salt of the earth But if the salt loses its saltiness how can it be made

salty again It is no longer good for anything except to be thrown out and

trampled underfootrdquo Globally and locally you are the salt of the earth Be salt

Salt preserves seasons flavors and purifies We are salt when we glorify

the Father Son and Holy Spirit in our mission worship faith hope truth

and love We are salt when we reject a Eurocentric or Americentric vision

10imothy C ennent Teology in the Context o World Christianity How the Global Church Is

Influencing the Way We Tink About and Discuss Teology (Grand Rapids Zondervan 9830909830889830881048631) xx11Douglas Sanders ldquoIndigenous Peoples Issues o Definitionrdquo International Journal o Cultural

Property 983096 no 1048625 (1048625983097983097983097) 1048628

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1236

10486251048632 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

of the church and become the global missional church Christ envisioned

In part one I show how Western conversations are impoverished and

insufficient in isolation from indigenous and Majority World Christians Weenhance our ldquosaltinessrdquo through local-global ( glocal ) exchanges o do this

we must reshape our conversations We need global and local exchanges that

we characterize by mutuality respect partnership and symbiosis Such ex-

changes help us learn from each other whether wersquore in Western indig-

enous or Majority World settings It helps us stay ldquosaltyrdquo It enables us to

pursue global missional theology and practice Globally and locally we can

pursue missional vitality and truly be ldquothe salt of the earthrdquo

P983137983154983156 1048626 L983145983143983144983156 R983141983150983141983159983145983150983143 O983157983154 M983145983155983155983145983151983150

ldquoYou are the light of the world A city on a hill cannot be hidden Neither do

people light a lamp and put it under a bowl Instead they put it on its stand and

it gives light to everyone in the house In the same way let your light shine

before others that they may see your good deeds and glorify your Father in

heavenrdquo (Mt 104862910486251048628-10486251048631) Globally and locally you are the light of the world Be lightLight illuminates reveals and dispels darkness Te church is light when

it does good deedsmdashhealing and liberating and redemptive deeds Itrsquos light

when its being and faith and deeds bring glorify to the Father Te church

is light when it participates in Godrsquos redemptive mission in the world as a

global missional community

o do this we must renew our mission In part two I explore how indig-

enous and Majority World Christians teach us to renew mission We renew

mission through contextualization liberation hospitality Spirit empow-

erment creation care ethics and the transformation of neighborhoods

P983137983154983156 1048627 C983145983156983161 R983141983158983145983156983137983148983145983162983145983150983143 O983157983154 C983144983157983154983139983144983141983155

You are a city set on a hill ldquoA city on a hill cannot be hiddenrdquo Globally and

locally you are a city set on a hill Be a city set on a hill

Tis means that we are an alternative and countercultural movement We

have a distinct culture and politic and social existence We are a people

gathered from every tribe language people and nation We are in the world

but not of the world We are in the world but distinct from the world We are

within the world and for the sake of the world

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1336

Introduction 10486251048633

o be this kind of alternative city or culture we must renew our mission

community ethics and worship We need to pursue the revitalization of our

churches so that they are distinct And by distinct I mean an alternative city(altera civitas)

We are a ldquocity on a hillrdquo that witnesses to Jesus Christ and his eternal kingdom

when we are a global missional church In part three I demonstrate how indig-

enous and Majority World Christians teach us to revitalize churches We revi-

talize churches by indigenizing faith devouring Scripture renewing education

practicing servantship (servant leadership) recovering community and devel-

oping spirituality and discipleship We inspire our churches when we developour theology and practices relating to beauty and the arts9830891048626

In the final chapter I wrap things up by addressing an important question

In light of all the material covered in this book what would it now look like

to engage in global missional theology ecclesiology interpretation history

pneumatology worship and education

Herersquos how you can get the most out of this book

Community You can read this book alone in a small group with somefriends at home or at a coffee shop or as part of a ministry team However

you get a lot more out of this book when you read it with others ogether

you can think about the bookrsquos implications What do the chapters mean for

your ministry church agency family or team

GlobalChurch Project video series Irsquove made a video series to go along with

this book Appendix one has the details

Study guide Yoursquoll get a lot more out of this book if you spend time

working through the study guide in appendix two ry to do this in a group

Te study guide includes reflection questions suggested practices and

Further Reading

Characters As you read this book yoursquoll come across names and people

yoursquove never heard of before For a glimpse of who they are and what issues

concern them see appendix three

My website o help you get the most out of this book Irsquove included more

resources on my website TeGlobalChurchProjectcom Tese include

videos reading lists important links a glossary and other resources Irsquove

12Irsquove put a separate chapter on the theme o beauty and the arts on my website Itrsquos additional to

this book

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1436

10486261048624 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

also provided ways that you can contact me See appendix four

In my first book Salt Light and a City I developed a missional theology

of the church I did this in conversation with twelve theologians from the fourmajor Christian traditions Tat volume offered a window into the thought of

European and American theologians It showed how they are making sense

of the nature and mission of the church in their Western cultural context

Te book that yoursquore now reading takes a different approach I have

stepped away from European and American voices I now ask What can

those in the Majority World and indigenous cultures teach us in the West

What can they teach us about the churchrsquos mission worship theology andcommunity Te quality and quantity of material coming out of the Ma-

jority World is astonishing Any theology that ignores the insights of indig-

enous and Majority World Christians is deficient and impoverished

White middle-class European North American tertiary-educated men

dominate Western theology Tey dominate the Western missional conver-

sation I know I fit that profile Tis group still monopolizes missional church

conferences and seminars Tey get all the book contracts In fact this groupstill controls theology and the church in many settings But this is changing

New voices are rising Tese include women minorities the poor indigenous

groups and Majority World leaders Missional conversations arenrsquot attentive

to the Spirit and to Godrsquos mission if they ignore these voices Majority World

and indigenous churches oen have extraordinary missional vitality Openness

to other voices needs to happen now It is time for Western churches theol-

ogies and mission to mature and to reflect Godrsquos global mission

In this book I could have consulted the work of many thousands of in-

digenous and Majority World thinkers and writers and practitioners But I

have limited myself to a sample of those who speak directly to its themes

Tese African Asian Eastern European Middle Eastern Caribbean Latin

American First Nation and indigenous thinkers challenge us Tey dare us

to examine our theologies and missions and churches And they inspire us

to renew the worship and community and mission of Jesusrsquo church Tey

stir us to think in fresh ways about what it means to be salt light and a city

Tey help us become a global missional churchmdasha truly GlobalChurch

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1536

PA R T O N E

S A L TReshaping Our Conversations

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1636

G L O C A L I Z I N G

C O N V E R S A T I O N S

H983151983159 D983151 W983141 D983141983158983141983148983151983152

G983148983151983139983137983148 C983151983150983158983141983154983155983137983156983145983151983150983155983103

Rather than taking one contextual version of the Gospel and imposing

it as the Gospel throughout the world via the missionary enterprise

the shapers of Mission as ransformation have recognized the

plurality of localities that has created an intercontextual

ldquopan-localrdquo global phenomenon in theology

AL IZON

The International Society for Urban Mission (ISUM) is a group of urban

missionaries who are passionate about cultivating hope and love and re-newal in cities Irsquove connected with this group for some years ISUM held its

first annual Summit on Integral Urban Mission in Bangkok Tailand Te

team from Urban Neighbours of Hope (UNOH) under the leadership of

my Australian friends Ash and Anj Barker organized much of the summit

UNOH teams covenant with God and each other to ldquolive out our passion for

loving God and neighbour Focus on releasing neighbourhoods from urban

poverty Grow through equipping each other neighbours and the broader

church to radically follow Jesus and join Godrsquos Kingdom coming UNOH

workers live and serve in small responsive neighbourhood-based teamsrdquo983089

1See wwwunohorg

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1736

10486261048628 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

Tis summit involved interactive participatory hands-on immersion op-

portunities keynotes lectures and workshops Keynote speakers came from

Africa Australia Myanmar New Zealand North America the PhilippinesSouth America Tailand and First Nations A few hundred Majority World

and Western thinkers and activists came together for those days Tey explored

the theology and practices of integral transformational and urban mission

Tese thinkers and activists pursued a range of aims1048626 Tis included col-

laboration between urban Christians from a variety of backgrounds (Ma-

jority World and Western theologians activists ecumenicals Pentecostals

evangelicals colleges church movements and development agencies) Teyaimed for collective action and thought in an international and integral

context Tey sought to gain mutual understanding for a comprehensive

picture of urban mission around the globe Tey encouraged information

sharing and best practicesmdashlearning from our mistakes and seeking solu-

tions Tey developed recommendations and calls to action to the broader

church Working groups wrote briefing papers aer each summit based on

key issues in urban mission And they endeavored to build trust wisdomand inspiration to better engage our new urban world

Majority World and Western leaders participated in discussion prayer

integral mission and working groups Te goal was to grapple with key issues

and ask key questions How do we recruit equip and sustain urban mission

today How do we release church movements among the urban poor How

can we immerse ourselves in and transform urban neighborhoods How do

we empower urban children and young people How does the church serve

and liberate the oppressedmdashand others suffering from urban injustice What

needs to happen for poorer urban centers to develop economically socially

and spiritually How do we join God in the challenges and opportunities of

multifaith cities

Workshops included urban gardening child protection and collaborating

with local churches in urban mission Workshops also included organic

church growth and mission as well as developing NGO and government

partnerships Groups considered the good the bad and the ugly of short-

term urban mission teams

2Tese aims are detailed at ldquoInternational Society or Urban Mission Summitrdquo httpnewurbanworld

orgsummit

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1836

Glocalizing Conversations 10486261048629

Te summit was a thrilling example of how Majority World and Western

leaders can cooperate It was a time to come together in an environment of

mutual learning and enrichment It was a window into how local contextsand global themes can enrich each other Tis resulted from ISUMrsquos com-

mitment to ldquosolidarity fellowship and insight between urban Christian

leaders in the Western and Majority Worldsrdquo

Te summit was a success due to ISUMrsquos core values What are they983091 Christ-

honoring urban mission values bottom-up grassroots perspectivesmdashrather

than top-down distanced perspectives It allows local theology to reveal new

insights and perspectives about Godrsquos activity It shares insights and experi-ences through narratives embedded within urban poor communities and cities

It cultivates ongoing practical and personal solidarity with the worldrsquos urban

poor Tis Spirit-empowered urban mission honors networks relationships

and partnerships It sees such relationships as the primary method of serving

together It listens to and amplifies the voices of the urban poormdashespecially

those from the Majority World and in particular the 1048625104862410486281048624 window cities It is

attentive to signs of the kingdom of God Urban mission that glorifies God iswilling to reflect and respond with active and sacrificial commitment It shares

and extends the life of the body of Christ among the urban poor

Tis summit was a milestone in urban missiology It enriched communi-

cation between Western and Majority World thinker-activists Tis resulted

from the aims and values Irsquove mentioned Effective urban mission needs to

be a conversation on many levels It is attentive to context and immersed in

local settings It appreciates global and universal missional themes It culti-

vates dialogue between these local-global (glocal) realities It involves

mutual learning between Western and Majority World thinker-activists

Moreover solidarity between all parties is a defining feature Tis solidarity

is due to a compelling vision of the kingdom of God

Tese collaborative glocal features of the ISUM urban mission summit

in Bangkok are critical for the aims of this book GlobalChurch

Majority World indigenous and Western leaders thinkers and churches

can stretch and enrich each other But they need to be open and attentive to

each other Tey need learning postures and open hearts and minds Tey

3ldquoAbout ISUMrdquo httpnewurbanworldorgabout

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1936

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2036

Glocalizing Conversations 10486261048631

always rooted in the local and particularmdashas local churches embody the

gospel and witness to Christ Tese churches forge their own theological

understandings as they do mission together Tey engage in transformationalpractices among the people in their settings Tey enjoy worship mission

and community in their local and particular context Ideally the result is

unique contextual theologies and missions

Simultaneously global conversations form Tey form because of this

multitude of local theologies and practices Local conversations inform and

enrich other local conversations catalyzing global themes and voices izon

observes that the global ldquoowes its existence to local contexts Sharedconvictions among the theologies and practices of local contextual realities

give shape to its global dimensionsrdquo1048629

Majority World indigenous and Western theologies are equally contextual

Tey are equally culture bound Tey are equally particular to their time and

location At times they are all enlightened or myopic liberating or con-

straining humanizing or objectifying beautiful or offensive prophetic or

tepid Te local particular and cultural shape all these theologies Converselythese particular theologies feed and influence global conversations Tere is

no place then for ethnocentrism colonialism or elitism Tere is no place

for theological missional cultural or institutionalized arrogance

Multiple local contexts and voices come togethermdashintentionally or notmdashto

form global themes and theologies Conversely these global realities shape

local contexts oday local contexts must grapple with ldquoan emerging global

culture ie the interacting realities of modernity postmodernity and the

phenomenon of globalizationrdquo1048630 Hence the interdependent and symbiotic

relationship between the localparticular and the globaluniversal We call this

interdependent relationship between the local and the global glocalization

Te global church needs a thrilling glocal exchange We need one that we

characterize by mutuality respect partnership and symbiosis Such ex-

change helps Majority World indigenous and Western churches learn from

each other It enables them to pursue missional theology and practice o-

gether the church becomes a ldquocity on a hillrdquo

5Ibid 10486259830886Ibid 9830961048628

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2136

10486261048632 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

W983144983137983156 R983141983153983157983145983154983141983155 G983148983151983139983137983148983145983162983137983156983145983151983150983103

Te glocal exchange described above needs to be broader than transforma-

tional mission Tis is necessary if the church is to develop a robust inter-cultural and glocal missional ecclesiology

In my first book Salt Light and a City I outlined the foundational

themes of missional ecclesiology983095 Majority World and Western leaders

need to engage these themes in local and contextual ways Teir insights can

then enrich global conversations Tese global conversations in turn shape

local understandings and practices Tis way a glocal appreciation of these

themes emergesLocal regional and global theologies and practices are thereby enriched

Te church becomes healthier and more missionalmdasha truer expression of

the kingdom Te church becomes a fuller witness to Christ his passion for

the nations and his ability to bring unity in diversity

Stephen Bevans and Roger Schroeder outline the six constants of mission

Tese are our theologies about Jesus the church the end times salvation

human nature and culture Bevans and Schroeder describe the relationshipbetween these six and their historical cultural and theological contexts Tis is

why they call these six constants in context Our understanding of these six

constants develops in relation to local and global movements Sometimes local

voices influence our understandings of these six Other times it is regional or

global voices For all of us local regional and global influences are at play at

once Collectively they form our appreciation of the six constants of mission1048632

Here are eight theological themes that the church can develop through

processes of glocalization I presented these in my book Salt Light and a City

Tey are vital to the churchrsquos health mission community and future We

could add many other themes to these eight but these will suffice for now1048633

Scripture Te Scriptures are the infallible authoritative Word of God

Christrsquos Spirit has inspired them Tey have absolute and final authority in

all aspects of corporate and individual faith ethics conduct and witness

Christians interpret and apply Scripture in local contexts and in particular

7Graham Hill Salt Light and a City Introducing Missional Ecclesiology (Eugene OR Wip and

Stock 9830909830881048625983090) 10486251048628983097-983090104863110486288Stephen B Bevans and Roger Schroeder Constants in Context A Teology o Mission or oday

American Society o Missiology Series (Maryknoll NY Orbis 9830909830889830881048628) part one9Tese points first appeared in my book Salt Light and a City xxii-xxiv

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2236

Glocalizing Conversations 10486261048633

social settings Conversely we learn from the interpretations and readings

of other groups

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our local- global theology of Scripture and biblical interpretation

Evangelicalism Pentecostalism missional movements and so forth I

have charismatic missional and evangelical convictions Glocal conversa-

tions help me understand and practice these convictions better

I will use evangelicalism as an example Michael Horton says that our

beliefs and practices are evangelical when they are ldquocommitted to the suffi-

ciency of Scripture the priesthood of all believers the total lostness ofhumans the sole mediation of Christ the gracious efficacy and finality of

Godrsquos redemptive work in Christ through election propitiation calling and

keeping Te linchpin for all of this was the doctrine of justification by grace

alone through faith alone because of Christ alonerdquo9830891048624

Such convictions are necessary if we are to be faithful to the gospel and

to a biblical vision of church and mission Te gospel defines Godrsquos purposes

for humanity the church and the universe Te triune God controls thechurch He is its Lord and Savior Sanctifier and Liberator Master and King

He is completely sovereign over its nature affairs mission and history God

is the churchrsquos only source of grace election atonement salvation and per-

severance Te churchrsquos justification and hope are by grace alone through

faith alone by Christ alone

Herersquos the challenge I face My understanding of evangelicalism is

Western I am a product of the Western theological tradition and my Western

evangelical heritage Much of this is wonderful But I need indigenous and

Majority World evangelicals and others to help me expand and reshape

these insights Te same would be true if I were a Pentecostal

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of our theological traditions and convictions

Jesus Christ We must center our theology on Jesus Christ the Lord of

the church Te church needs to reflect on the person and work of Christ

and respond to him Tis means gathering and going in the name and power

of Christ It means allowing Christrsquos Spirit to shape our community and

10Michael Horton ldquoEvangelical Arminiansrdquo Modern Reormation 1048625 no 1048627 (1048625983097983097983090) 10486251048631

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2336

10486271048624 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

identity and mission It means developing our Christology ecclesiology and

missiology concurrently Te early church developed these three areas and

more in a concurrent and integrated way Tere was no linear progressionTe same is true in the contemporary global church

How can the glocal church best explore its nature structure mission and

hope Trough the centrality and the lordship of Christ

Majority World and indigenous Christians help us appreciate Jesus and

his mission afresh Tey show us how Jesus identifies with the marginalized

outcast oppressed rejected and broken He prefers them We find him

among ldquothe least of theserdquoGlocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of who Jesus Christ is How does it help us appreciate him better

What has Jesus done for and in his church and his world What does he care

about What individual and corporate responsibilities has he given us How

do we express these at local regional and global levels

Te Spirit Missional ecclesiology is inadequate without pneumatological

foundations In other words our theology of church and Spirit go togetherTe Spirit creates and animates the church He empowers it to witness to

Jesus and his gospel Te Spirit enables the church to be a missional trans-

formational community He shapes the church into an alternative society

embodying the reign of God Te church exists for the glory and mission of

Christ Te power and presence of the Spirit enables this mission worship

and glorification

Te Spirit pours out gis on the local-global church ldquofor the common

goodrdquo and ldquoto equip his people for works of service so that the body of Christ

may be built uprdquo Tis includes but isnrsquot limited to the ministry gis mani-

festation gis and motivational gis (1048625 Cor 104862510486261048631 Eph 104862810486251048625-10486251048626 Rom 104862510486261048630-1048632)

Te Spirit forms the glocal church He empowers it for service and

witness He fills it with Christrsquos empowering presence He leads it into the

missio Deimdashthe mission of the Father Son and Holy Spirit

Recently Pentecostal and renewalist movements have grown dramati-

cally in the Majority World Tey have increased in status size and influence

Many have matured theologically Te churches of the West must take notice

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of the power and presence of the Spirit

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2436

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048625

Te rinity Tere are clear limitations to the analogy between the

church and the rinity Te church can only image the rinity Yet the

church is at its best when it reflects the relational and missional passionof the rinity

What is the source and inspiration of the churchrsquos local-global mission

Ultimately it is the missional nature passion and actions of the Father Son

and Holy Spirit Godrsquos nature is missional His passion is infectious His

actions are historical redemptive and eternal Te rinity invites the

church into a sending community Te Father sends the Son Te Father

and Son send the Spirit Finally the rinity sends the church in missioninto the world

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of the rinity How does it enable our participation in the mission

and community of the triune God

Association and dialogue Tese need to happen across denominational

cultural ethnic gender and theological traditions and divides Authentic

dialogue is indispensable to the health and mission of the church What dothose marginal to the life of the church have to say to us What do ldquoothersrdquo

have to teach us Other ethnicities and cultures Other socioeconomic

groups Other ages and genders Other theological and confessing tradi-

tions Other persons from times long gone

We need to listen Share Be vulnerable Be authentic Open up to crit-

icism correction and change

We need more than dialogue We need communion and association It is

possible in a qualified way to say that God is present in all the various forms

of the church (ie the various theological ecclesiological sociocultural his-

torical and other permutations of the church) We discern this presence

through attention to Scripture history tradition culture and the Spirit Dis-

cernment involves critical dialogue theological exchange biblical study and

real relationship Only the Spirit of Jesus can enable this

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of association and dialogue

Mission and the missio Dei Te church is missional at its core It serves

obeys and images a missionary God David Bosch says ldquoTe churchrsquos mission

is not secondary to its being the church exists in being sent and in building up

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2536

10486271048626 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

itself for its missionrdquo He goes on to say ldquoEcclesiology does not precede missi-

ology there cannot be church without an intrinsic missionary dimensionrdquo983089983089

Jesus is Lord Lord of his church and Lord of his world His mission de-termines and forms the church His mission shapes the nature purposes

structures ministries and activities of his church Majority World and in-

digenous thinkers help us understand the implications of this mission Tey

help us form glocal theologies of mission Tey reveal ldquomission in context

as transformationrdquo9830891048626

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of mission and the missio Dei Church theology and practice Glocal conversations can inform and

enrich many aspects of the church (when practiced well) Teologies and

practices benefit from robust and critical glocal conversations Tese con-

versations enrich many areas (community spirituality discipleship liturgy

worship hospitality eco-justice education social ethics servantship lib-

eration place suffering beauty and so on)

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-standing of these many dimensions of church and mission

Glocal processes shape these eight themes and their practices We need

to facilitate and enable these conversations and processes Tis is urgent It

must be a priority No theology of mission or missional ecclesiology is ad-

equate without glocal conversations983089983091

T983144983141 L983151983139983137983148 983137983150983140 G983148983151983138983137983148 E983150983154983145983139983144 E983137983139983144 O983156983144983141983154

Glocalization takes the localparticular context and globaluniversal themes

seriously Contextual and global conversations enter an enriching and in-

forming relationship Tese two always have an active and symbiotic rela-

tionship Tis is true whether we deliberately put them into conversation or

not Te local shapes the global and the global shapes the local Many local

11David J Bosch Believing in the Future oward a Missiology o Western Culture (New York

rinity 1048625983097983097983093) 104862798309012izon ransormation Afer Lausanne 1048631-98309713Not all o these themes are dealt with in this present volume since either (1048625) I have dealt with them

in my book Salt Light and a City (983090) they are not all key themes in the writings o the thirty-five

Majority World thinkers considered in this volume or (1048627) there is not adequate space in a book

this size

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2636

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048627

voices converge to form global conversations and theologies Using the Phil-

ippines as a case study izon illustrates this by showing the interdepen-

dence between local and global themes in mission983089983092Dialogue between local and global conversations is critical Kōsuke

Koyama wrote an important book on contextual mission called Water Buffalo

Teology Koyama is a Japanese missionary who served in Chiang Mai

Tailand He writes of the joys and challenges of doing local particular water

buffalo theology He considers the relationship between local theology global

missional themes and transforming cultures ldquoWater Buffalo Teology sees

certain specific challenges Contextualization of theology implies two criticalmovements First to articulate Jesus Christ in culturally appropriate com-

municatively apt words and second to criticize reform dethrone or oppose

culture if it is found to be against what the name of Jesus Christ stands forrdquo9830891048629

Kōsuke Koyama challenges us to recognize what we bring to the task of

local theology For him it was doing theology in Tailand while being Jap-

anese We also need to notice the particular culture wersquore located in as we do

the work of theology Tis means we avoid speaking of an ldquoAsian theologyrdquoldquoAfrican theologyrdquo and the like We need to cultivate local theologies that

engage regional and global themes But these theologies must be ldquodistinctly

localrdquo and a ldquotheology from belowrdquo9830891048630

Simultaneously we need to pursue a reformation of theology and

practice ldquoin the global contextrdquo Tis means entering ldquothe disturbing spa-

ciousness of Jesus Christrdquo Jesus calls us to reject enmity and exceptionalism

We seem him present in our culture language stories and relationships

But we also choose to embrace the ldquootherrdquo We choose to see him present

in other culturesmdashshaping a global people to serve and worship him

joining in his mission983089983095

Kōsuke Koyama roots the gospel in the local contextual and particular

Tis is why he roots his water buffalo theology in Northern Tai culture He

is careful not to say ldquoHere is how you contextualize in your settingrdquo Instead

14izon ransormation Afer Lausanne 1048631-10486251048627 10486251048628983097-98309098308898309015Kōsuke Koyama Water Buffalo Teology 983090983093th anniversary ed (Maryknoll NY Orbis 1048625983097983097983097)

xiii-xv16Kōsuke Koyama ldquoTe Asian Approach to Christrdquo Missiology 1048625983090 no 1048628 (10486259830979830961048628) 10486281048627983093-104862798309617Kōsuke Koyama ldquoReormation in the Global Context Te Disturbing Spaciousness o Jesus Christrdquo

Currents in Teology and Mission 1048627983088 no 983090 (9830909830889830881048627) 10486251048625983097-983090983096

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2736

10486271048628 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

he tells us a story Itrsquos the story of how he contextualized theology in northern

Tailand while being open to global conversations Koyama asks us to form

our own local expressions of church mission and theology At the same timewe must stay attentive to what God is saying and doing beyond that context

Tis way local and global and particular and universal become mutually

enriching conversation partners

G983148983151983139983137983148983145983162983137983156983145983151983150 983137983150983140 H983145983155983156983151983154983145983139983137983148983148983161 S983145983148983141983150983139983141983140 V983151983145983139983141983155

Glocal theologies and conversations pay attention to voices that powers in-

stitutions religions and societies have silenced R S Sugirtharajah pushesback a little on izonrsquos ideas Sugirtharajah says that the church should

privilege local conversations He emphasizes the local contextual and post-

colonial reading of biblical texts9830891048632

Te church needs to listen Te church ought to be attentive to the

theologies and biblical interpretations of groups that cultures and reli-

gions have ignored Historically powerful secular and religious forces

have silenced these groups Tey have marginalized oppressed and colo-nized them It is time for the church to address this injustice We must

start listening to important but silenced voices We need to privilege the

voices of the former victims of Western colonialism We need to develop

postcolonial biblical interpretations theologies and expressions of church

and mission

How do we take such perspectives seriously as we develop glocal conver-

sations How do these themes help us foster vital relationships between local

and global voices

It is time for us to embrace values that enable conversations with those

oen ignored by the church We need values that help us learn from these

groups and individuals

Valuing equal partnership Colonizing powers oppressed silenced and

colonized certain groups At times the church was complicit Tese colo-

nized groups have become ldquoconfident indomitable and indispensable

partners in the dialogue and collaboration with the dispossessed and disad-

18R S Sugirtharajah Asian Biblical Hermeneutics and Postcolonialism Contesting the Interpreta-

tions Te Bible and Liberation Series (Maryknoll NY Orbis 1048625983097983097983096) 1048625983093-1048625983094

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2836

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048629

vantaged in the Westrdquo9830891048633 Tis calls for attentiveness to these voices and re-

sponsiveness to their prophetic challenges It also demands a critical evalu-

ation of colonial readings of Scripture Colonial models of theology andchurch and mission are no longer the benchmark Te global church must

examine them afresh

Valuing equal status Tose on the margins have now taken their rightful

place on the global stage Tey have claimed appropriate and equal status at

the table Subaltern readings of theology church and mission are invaluable

contributors to global theological conversations Tis means that we esteem

them But we also test themWhat do we mean by subaltern Subalterns are those who are down-

trodden and silenced (or have been treated this way in the past) Dominant

or colonizing groups treat them as invisible nonentities Tey enjoy limited

or no access to power Sometimes these are women certain tribal and ethnic

groups and those considered ldquountouchablerdquo In Voices from the Margin Su-

girtharajah provides a platform for postcolonial subaltern readings of

Scripture and theology Tese readings challenge colonialmdashoen Westernmdashreadings of Bible and theology and cultures Tey claim equal status with

other ways of doing theology10486261048624

Valuing equal identity People groups need freedom to explore their new

and emerging identities Tese emerge in response to local and global influ-

ences Local culture is not the only thing at work here Global forces also

shape identity as do imported practices ideas readings rituals and tech-

nologies But each group should be free to explore and construct their par-

ticular forms of Christian identity

Valuing equal interpretations ldquoPostcolonialism is concerned with the

question of cultural and discursive dominationrdquo Colonialism led to op-

pressive and controlling forms of culture and discourse Tese were usually

not contextual or indigenous Western powers for instance brought co-

lonial forms of theology church biblical interpretation and mission1048626983089

Postcolonialism calls for alternative ways of approaching these things Tose

19Ibid 104862598309420R S Sugirtharajah Voices rom the Margin Interpreting the Bible in the Tird World (Maryknoll

NY Orbis 10486259830979830971048625)21Sugirtharajah Asian Biblical Hermeneutics and Postcolonialism 10486251048631

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2936

10486271048630 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

who were once marginalized oppressed and silenced need to lead these fresh

approaches in their own settings Tese then influence global conversations

We need to support the new readings and insights and experiments from thesegroups o be genuine this support must be both critical and collegial

Valuing equal empowerment Sugirtharajah says that postcolonialism is

valuable when it empowers actual communities and real people Post-

colonial thought empowers when it addresses the difficulties hopes and

experiences of ordinary people It should never be about power plays and

the clever use of language Itrsquos pointless if itrsquos obsessed with forming newmdash

and ldquocolonizingrdquomdashtheories Itrsquos a waste of time if itrsquos a self-indulgent pursuitof new and hybrid identities Rather ldquothe worth and credibility of post-

colonial criticism will be judged by how it orchestrates the unique and

fragile and imagined claims of one community against anotherrdquo Empow-

erment happens in a variety of ways One way is contributing equally to

global conversations10486261048626

Al izon examines postcolonialism in the Philippines He says that it can

teach the global church a lot about healthy local-global conversations Fil-ipino contextual theology resists many Western forms of mission and the-

ology It finds them patronizing and controlling Tis indigenous theology

values prophetic sociopolitical engagement in institutions and the society

at large It emphasizes ministry to whole persons and communities It con-

structs a Filipino theology of beauty and mission and worship and com-

munity And it fosters indigenous theological approaches to the spirit world

and cosmology

izon says that postcolonial theology has played a constructive role in

the Philippines But he is uncomfortable with the label postcolonialism He

prefers to describe historical events as ldquobeyond colonialismrdquo And he says

that global conversations enrich local theologies and vice versa1048626983091

Postcolonial thought informs our understanding of the relationship be-

tween the local and global It also shows how theology can emerge at the

intersection between the localparticular and the globaluniversal It re-

minds us that worthwhile glocalization listens to all voices Tis includes

heeding those that have been historically silenced

22Ibid 983090104862823izon ransormation Afer Lausanne 1048625983088983090 10486259830941048631-9830961048631

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3036

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048631

G983148983151983139983137983148983145983162983137983156983145983151983150 983137983150983140 983156983144983141 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

C983151983150983139983148983157983140983145983150983143 R983141983142983148983141983139983156983145983151983150983155

How do we go about developing a model for glocal conversations izon hasrecently provided a useful model that is instructive as we seek to learn from

the Majority World It has at least two key features

First the local is in the global (globalization from below) Global theologies

and ideas have origins in many particular local contexts In that sense glo-

balization is from below Global ideas have local roots Ideas about integral

mission liberation theology and missional church have local origins Tey

have their roots in the prayers hopes discoveries mission and theologiesof thousands of local communities ldquoTe global does not cannot exist

without the localmdashbut the coming together of localities creates a global re-

ality that becomes greater than the sum of its parts it creates a gestalt entity

to which localities make themselves accountablerdquo1048626983092

Second the global is in the local (panlocalization from above) Te con-

cerns and voices of multitudes of locales form global conversations Tese

global discussions can provide a ldquopositive accountabilityrdquo back to local con-texts Tis is true when they enrich affirm serve guide and strengthen local

contexts It is also true when they avoid homogenization control impo-

sition and judgment Glocalization is best when it sees itself as interde-

pendent deeply connected with the local10486261048629

Tatrsquos a helpful starting point But we need to go further Besides izonrsquos

proposals Irsquom convinced that robust glocal conversations cultivate six core

practices

983089 Glocal theology practices its values We root glocal theology in core

values Tese values include solidarity understanding and mutual learning

Do we value fellowship with Christians of all cultures Do we value learning

from them

We prove our values through our practices What practices emerge out of

these values We need to collaborate act collectively and share information

We must find ways to foster grassroots perspectives and local theologies We

need to share stories and learnings and cultivate networks relationships and

partnerships We need attentiveness to local voices and global themes We

24Ibid 9830901048625983088-1048625104862825Ibid 98309010486251048628-1048625983096

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3136

10486271048632 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

ought to find ways to put these local and global voices into conversation

Mutual learning humility and solidarity are key Worthwhile glocal con-

versations can never be merely theoretical or academic It is up to us to rootour values in our practices

983090 Glocal theology practices humility (and it tells a new narrative) We

have noted that the local is in the global and the global is in the local Te

two are interdependent Tey form each other reciprocally Since this is the

case we must practice humility Tere is no place for ethnocentrism colo-

nialism or theological and cultural arrogance I have seen these unhealthy

postures far too oen in Western settingsRecently I attended a missional leadership conference On that occasion

the keynote speakermdasha leading missional author and speakermdashsaid that

North American missional conversations and innovations hold the key to

the future of the Western church Tis Euro American view is wrong (Irsquom

being kind o be frank itrsquos complete nonsense) Itrsquos arrogant and Euro

Americanndashcentric And itrsquos completely out of step with what is happening in

the glocal church We need a new narrativeIn June 1048626104862410486251048627 Te Center for the Study of Global Christianity reported

the top 10486261048624 countries where Christianity has the highest percentage growth

rate Nineteen of the top twenty are in Asia and Africa Eleven of them are

in Muslim majority countries Not a single country from Europe or North

America makes the top twenty list10486261048630

Itrsquos time to cultivate a new narrative Te future of the church is emerging

from the Majority World Rather than North America the churches of

Eastern Asia Western Africa the Arabian Peninsula and other parts of the

Majority World reveal the future of the global church We need the contribu-

tions of all contexts Western indigenous and Majority World All con-

tribute to glocal conversations All are important as we learn from each

other about mission theology and faith But letrsquos stop pretending that North

Americans and Europeans will reveal the future of the global church Letrsquos

start listening to what God is saying about the future of the global church

And hersquos speaking to us through the churches of Asia Africa Latin America

26Russ Mitchell ldquoTe op 983090983088 Countries Where Christianity Is Growing the Fastestrdquo Disciple All

Nations (blog) August 983090983093 98309098308810486251048627 httpsdiscipleallnationswordpresscom98309098308810486251048627983088983096983090983093the-top

-983090983088-countries-where-christianity-is-growing-the-astest

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3236

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048633

Muslim majority settings and so on We must cultivate a new glocal nar-

rativemdashone soaked in humility

Glocal theology must be humble theology Meek theology Receptive the-ology Discerning theology Prayerful theology Dialogical theology De-

pendent theology A theology that celebrates the interdependence between

the localparticular and the globaluniversal

983091 Glocal theology practices expansiveness Glocalization is by nature

comprehensive Local and global influences permeate much of our lives Tese

glocal forces shape our theologies and churches whether we like it or not

But intentionality is also important We need to commit to an expansiveapproach to glocal theology How do we deliberately cultivate glocal conver-

sations in our biblical interpretation Do we foster them in our under-

standing of the person and work of Christ How does glocalization shape

the way the Spirit empowers and constitutes the church How can it form

our understanding of the nature and mission of the rinity How does it

influence the way we practice fellowship and conversation across denomi-

national cultural ethnic economic sociocultural political gender andtheological divides How might it shape our theologies of mission com-

munity beauty spirituality suffering discipleship hospitality eco-justice

place education social ethics Christian leadership and so forth

983092 Glocal theology practices attention Glocal theology doesnrsquot need to

accept all the assumptions or assertions of postcolonial or Majority World

thought But it does need to engage with them and take them seriously

Postcolonial theology for instance gives the marginalized and colonized

and forgotten and silenced both dignity and voice Our glocal conversations

must also include and esteem these groups We need to be attentive to

others weak and powerful female and male dominant and downtrodden

old and young rich and poor privileged and marginalized influential and

subaltern educated and illiterate We need to practice the art of attention

being especially attentive to those who are different to us

983093 Glocal theology practices embrace What do colonial ethnocentric or

Western-centric perspectives do Tey silence Tey control Tey com-

modify Tey institutionalize Tey colonize Tey domesticate Tey replace

Tey import Tey exclude Tey do these things to the beliefs experiences

and practices of other cultures A worthwhile glocal theology refuses to do

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3336

10486281048624 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

these things Instead it adopts a responsive humble celebratory open in-

clusive and embracing attitude

983094 Glocal theology practices discernment Finally we need discernmentas we engage these ideas and practices Discernment is a huge topic thatrsquos

hard to cover comprehensively in a few words Discernment happens when

the Spirit of Christ and his Word renew our minds Te Spirit grants us

spiritual wisdom as we meditate on him and his Word and as we practice

discipleship to Jesus Christ Romans 10486251048626 provides guidance we need (1048625) to be

transformed by the renewal of our minds (1048626) to serve Christrsquos body and (1048627)

to put love into action Discernment also happens in conversation both lo-cally and glocally

I pray these core values and six practices come across in the following

chapters of GlobalChurch

Glocalization can never be just theoretical Are we committed to moving

glocalization from an abstract idea to a living communion Are we deter-

mined to construct a missional theology of the church in the context of

glocal conversations Tis must involve dialogue between Majority Worldindigenous and Western scholars activists and groups

Will glocalization be an abstract notion Or will it be a formative and

genuine communion between local regional and global voices Glocal dy-

namics are at play whether we like it or not Teyrsquore in our churches the-

ologies and missions But we can choose to relinquish isolationist colonial

parochial and arrogant approaches Instead we can adopt responsive dia-

logical learning humble and embracing postures

Trough healthy approaches to glocalization the Spirit challenges us to

value local contexts We immerse ourselves in local and particular commu-

nities and conversations He inspires us to open ourselves to global theo-

logical conversations He rouses us to value the symbiotic relationship be-

tween the localparticular and the globaluniversal

Trough glocal relationships the Spirit leads us to put local contextual

theologies into conversation with global ones He prompts us to explore the

ways in which the local is in the glocal and the global is in the local He per-

suades us to pursue collaboration and dialogue and mutual learning We

engage with Christians from different backgrounds and cultures ecumen-

icals Pentecostals evangelicals and so on from Western indigenous and

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3436

Glocalizing Conversations 10486281048625

Majority World contexts He motivates us to express solidarity between all

parties We appreciate our unity in diversity

Trough glocal conversations the Spirit moves us to ensure that unity andsolidarity emerge from a compelling vision of Jesusrsquo kingdom and gospel

and person He challenges us to share information theology and practices

He urges us to learn from each othermdashour successes and mistakes We seek

glocal solutions

Te Spirit calls us to develop glocal conversations about Christian ideas

and practices Tese include Scripture Evangelicalism ecumenism Pente-

costalism Jesus Christ the Holy Spirit God the Father the rinity com-munity spirituality discipleship liturgy worship hospitality prayer eco-

justice education social ethics Christian leadership gospel and culture

beauty place suffering liberation and so forth

Finally through glocal conversations the Spirit leads us to adopt a new

posture Tis is a responsive humble celebratory open inclusive and em-

bracing attitude to the ldquootherrdquo We do this as a new people made up of every

tribe and language and people and nationTere are dangers in glocalization Sugirtharajah warns of the commodi-

fication of local contextual practices and theologies When this happens

they are ldquosmoothed out of their primary contexts concerns and contesta-

tions travel across borders and become objects of analysis and scrutiny

within an alien secondary contextrdquo1048626983095

Itrsquos common for those of us who are Western to make mistakes when we

wrestle with Majority World and indigenous ideas Sugirtharajah mentions

our tendency to commodify reduce and institutionalize these ideas We also

risk doing these things (1048625) We apply them in noncontextual prescriptive ways

(1048626) We ignore their meanings in their original setting (1048627) We glamorize or

idealize their proponents or their contexts (1048628) We demonize those persons or

contexts (1048629) We disregard them as irrelevant rhetorical or minority discourse

Kevin J Vanhoozer says that we can fall into three traps when we glo-

calize theology (1048625) We can underestimate the theological significance of

local cultures (1048626) We can homogenize cultures and theologies exaggerating

27R S Sugirtharajah ldquoextual ake-Aways Tird World exts in Western Metropolitan Centresrdquo

Black Teology in Britain A Journal o Contextual Praxis 983090 (1048625983097983097983097) 10486271048627 10486271048631 Edward W Said Te

World the ext and the Critic (Cambridge MA Harvard University Press 10486259830979830961048627) 9830901048627983097

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3536

10486281048626 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

ldquothe onerdquo (1048627) We can overemphasize cultural particularity exaggerating ldquothe

manyrdquo and pursue ldquotheological ethnificationrdquo10486261048632

My hope is that GlobalChurch does not fall into the traps Sugirtharajahand Vanhoozer describe I hope that what unfolds in the following chapters

is respectful and discerning I hope it leads to further mutually enriching

conversations between people of different cultures

You the reader face the same challenges You face them in your personal

life ministry context and missional engagements

Will you treat the themes in this book as abstract theoretical notions

Will this be a temporary infatuation a flirtation with the ldquootherrdquo that dissi-pates as suddenly as it arrived Or will glocal conversations become an en-

riching and formative orientation in your life Will glocal conversations

bring fresh approaches to theology faith mission church and worship Will

conversations with other cultures and theologies become for you a com-

pelling way of life

My prayer is that glocal conversations will help the church be a global

visible alternative ldquocity set upon a hillrdquo a truly GlobalChurch

28Craig Ott and Harold A Netland Globalizing Teology Belie and Practice in an Era o World

Christianity (Grand Rapids Baker Academic 983090983088983088983094) 1048625983090983093

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3636

Page 8: GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 836

10486251048628 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

and New Zealand) contained more than four times as many Christians as the

Global South (the rest of the world) oday the Pew Forum study finds more

than 10486251048627 billion Christians live in the Global South [10486301048625983077 of all Christians livein Asia Africa and Latin America] compared with about 104863210486301048624 million in the

Global North (10486271048633983077)rdquo1048626 Tat is an astounding shi in only one hundred years983091

Using the World Christian Database Philip Jenkins offers table 10486251048625

ldquoChanging distribution of Christian believersrdquo

Table 983089983089 Changing distribution of Christian believers 983089983097983088983088 to 983090983088983093983088 (number of Christiansin millions)

983089983097983088983088 983089983097983095983088 983090983088983089983088 983090983088983093983088Africa 983089983088 983089983092983091 983092983097983091 983089983088983091983089

Asia 983090983090 983097983094 983091983093983090 983094983088983089

North America 983095983097 983090983089983089 983090983096983094 983091983091983091

Latin America 983094983090 983090983095983088 983093983092983092 983094983093983093

Europe 983091983096983089 983092983097983090 983093983096983096 983093983091983088

Oceania 983093 983089983096 983090983096 983091983096

Total 983093983093983096 983089983090983091983088 983090983090983097983089 983091983089983096983096

Source Philip Jenkins The Next Christendom The Coming of Global Christianity 983091rd ed (Oxford Oxford Uni-

versity Press 983090983088983089983089) 983091 Data is taken from World Christian Database wwwworldchristiandatabaseorgwcd

Christianity in North America Europe and Oceania grew from 104862810486301048629

million in 1048625104863310486241048624 to 104863310486241048626 million in 1048626104862410486251048624983092 Tis number is likely to shrink to

104863310486241048625 million by 1048626104862410486291048624

Christianity in Africa Asia and Latin America grew from 10486331048628 million in

1048625104863310486241048624 to 1048625104862710486321048633 billion in 1048626104862410486251048624 Tis number is likely to grow to 1048626104862610486321048631 billion by

1048626104862410486291048624

Letrsquos take China for example Professor Fenggang Yang of Purdue University

makes an important prediction If current rates of growth continue within one

generation China will have more Christians than any other nation on earth

In 1048625104863310486281048633 Protestant churches in China had one million members In 1048626104862410486251048624 that

number was 10486291048632 million (compare that with 10486281048624 million in Brazil and 10486271048630 million

2Pew Research Center Global Christianity A Report on the Size and Distribution o the Worldrsquos Chris-

tian Population December 1048625983097 98309098308810486251048625 wwwpeworumorg9830909830881048625104862510486259830901048625983097global-christianity-exec3See David B Barrett George Kurian and odd M Johnson World Christian Encyclopedia A

Comparative Survey o Churches and Religions in the Modern World 983090nd ed 983090 vols (New York

Oxord University Press 9830909830889830881048625) 1048625983090-1048625983093 and wwwglobalchristianityorg4Oceania includes Australia and Micronesian Melanesian and Polynesian countries

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 936

Introduction 10486251048629

in South Africa) By 1048626104862410486261048629 there are likely to be 104862510486301048624 million Christians in China

By 1048626104862410486271048624 this number is likely to be 104862610486281048631 million (outnumbering Christians in

Mexico Brazil and the United States) In an interview with the elegraphFenggang Yang says ldquoMao thought he could eliminate religion He thought he

had accomplished this Itrsquos ironicmdashthey didnrsquot Tey actually failed completelyrdquo1048629

Philip Jenkins concludes

We are currently living through one of the transforming moments in the

history of religion worldwide Over the last five centuries the story of Chris-

tianity has been inextricably bound up with that of Europe and European-

derived civilizations overseas above all in North America Until recently theoverwhelming majority of Christians have lived in white nations Over the

last century however the center of gravity in the Christian world has shied

inexorably away from Europe southward to Africa and Latin America and

eastward toward Asia oday the largest Christian communities on the planet

are to be found in those regions1048630

What does all this mean for the mission and theology and worship and

communities of the church worldwide And what does it mean particularlyfor the Western church

In Matthew 104862910486251048627-10486251048630 Jesus provides three remarkable images of the churchmdash

salt light and a city Jesus confronts his disciples with a missional description

of the church Te church in mission is the salt of the earth the light of the

world and a city set on a hill Te churchrsquos purpose is to let its ldquolight shine

before others that they may see your good deeds and glorify your Father in

heavenrdquo Te purpose of the churchrsquos missionary nature is the worship andglorification of the Father and Son and Holy Spirit983095

Te church is another city constituted by every tribe language people

5om Phillips ldquoChina on Course to Become lsquoWorldrsquos Most Christian Nationrsquo Within 1048625983093 Yearsrdquo

elegraph April 1048625983097 98309098308810486251048628 wwwtelegraphcouknewsworldnewsasiachina1048625983088104863110486319830949830889830901048627China-on

-course-to-become-worlds-most-Christian-nation-within-1048625983093-yearshtml See Fenggang Yang and

Joseph B amney eds Conucianism and Spiritual raditions in Modern China and Beyond Re-

ligion in Chinese Societies (Boston Brill 9830909830881048625983090) Fenggang Yang and Graeme Lang eds Social

Scientific Studies o Religion in China Methodology Teories and Findings (Leiden Brill 98309098308810486251048625)

Fenggang Yang Religion in China Survival and Revival Under Communist Rule (Oxord Oxord

University Press 9830909830881048625983090)6Philip Jenkins Te Next Christendom Te Coming o Global Christianity 1048627rd ed (Oxord Ox-

ord University Press 98309098308810486251048625) 10486257J Driver Images o the Church in Mission (Scottdale PA Herald 10486259830979830971048631) 10486251048631983088-9830961048625 Graham Hill Salt

Light and a City Introducing Missional Ecclesiology (Eugene OR Wip and Stock 9830909830881048625983090) xiii

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1036

10486251048630 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

and nation Te church must cultivate a distinct social existence shaping its

community and mission around its commitment to plurality and diversity

and unity1048632 God calls his church to be a global and missional ldquocity on a hillrdquoTis is a church constituted and enriched and represented by Western and

indigenous and Majority World peoples

Tose of us in the West need a new narrative Itrsquos time to abandon our

flawed Eurocentric and Americentric worldviews We need a new global

and missional narrative and for that we must turn to the churches of Ma-

jority World and indigenous cultures Tey can help us explore what it

means to be a global missional community Many Christian communitiesin Majority World and indigenous contexts have been wrestling with these

issues for generations Marginalization and persecution and alienation have

been their lot Yet somehow in spite of or because of that they have flour-

ished In fact theyrsquove grown exponentially

So whom am I talking about when I refer to Majority World and indig-

enous Christians Majority World Christians are those in Africa Asia the

Caribbean Eastern Europe Latin America the Middle East and Oceania

1048633

I use the term Majority World because the majority of the worldrsquos population

is in those cultures today Te majority of the church is in those cultures too

I donrsquot use the terms non-Western or Tird World or Developing World Tese

terms use Western cultures as their point of reference Tey imply Western

8Barry A Harvey Another City An Ecclesiological Primer or a Post-Christian World (New York

rinity 1048625983097983097983097) 9830901048627-9830909830939I donrsquot deal with the diasporas in this book For example Irsquove made no mention o Hispanic

Portuguese or Asian minorities in the United States United Kingdom Canada Europe Austra-lia and so on Irsquom aware that right now Latin American and Chinese diasporas are active in

evangelism and mission in Europe in the same way in which the Filipino or the Salvadoran dias-

poras carry on mission in the United States Irsquove chosen not to include voices rom the diasporas

mainly because there are so many worthy contributors in that group and I donrsquot have the space

to treat them well in this book In the uture I hope that I (or someone else) will write a book

exploring what we can learn rom the diasporas Hispanic minorities or example are making

significant contributions to the theological and missiological conversation in the United States

that are relevant to this subject Methodist historian Justo L Gonzaacutelez and Pentecostal theologian

Eldin Villaantildee are examples In Mantildeana Gonzaacutelez describes the shape and orm o a theology

developed in the Hispanic margin o the United States In Out o Every ribe and Nation he shows

what would be implied in listening to minorities within a denominational setting Villaantildeersquos Te

Liberating Spirit is a milestone in the reflection about the relationship between pneumatology and

social ethics See Justo L Gonzaacutelez Out o Every ribe and Nation Christian Teology at the

Ethnic Roundtable (Nashville Abingdon 1048625983097983097983090) Gonzaacutelez Mantildeana Christian Teology rom a

Hispanic Perspective (Nashville Abingdon 1048625983097983097983088) Eldin Villaantildee Te Liberating Spirit oward

an Hispanic American Pentecostal Social Ethic (Grand Rapids Eerdmans 10486259830979830971048627)

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1136

Introduction 10486251048631

superiority or centricity Te term Global South is too limiting given the

breadth of the group I am engaging Majority World seems to work best

In 1048626104862410486241048628 Te Lausanne Forum for World Evangelization in PattayaTailand voted unanimously that the phrase Majority World Church replace

other terms People from all over the globe participated in this forum

imothy C ennent agrees that this is the best phrase ldquoIt helps to highlight

the basic point that Africa Asia and Latin America are where the majority

of the worldrsquos Christians are now locatedrdquo9830891048624 I expand the phrase Majority

World beyond Africa Asia and Latin America to include the Caribbean

Eastern Europe Oceania and the Middle EastIndigenous and First Nations peoples are ldquothose ethnic groups that were

indigenous to a territory prior to being incorporated into a national state

and who are politically and culturally separate from the majority ethnic

identity of the state that they are a part ofrdquo Tis includes people groups like

the Australian Aborigines and American Indians983089983089

Te aim of this book is to help Western churches rediscover what it means

to be salt light and a city by engaging in global missional conversations odo this Western Christians need to enter into conversation with Majority

World and indigenous Christians Listening to others helps us grow in our

understanding and practice of mission and church and theology For far too

long wersquove marginalized or ignored Majority World and indigenous voices

We must truly become a GlobalChurch

Tis aim shapes the bookrsquos structure as summarized below

P983137983154983156 1048625 S983137983148983156 R983141983155983144983137983152983145983150983143 O983157983154 C983151983150983158983141983154983155983137983156983145983151983150983155

ldquoYou are the salt of the earth But if the salt loses its saltiness how can it be made

salty again It is no longer good for anything except to be thrown out and

trampled underfootrdquo Globally and locally you are the salt of the earth Be salt

Salt preserves seasons flavors and purifies We are salt when we glorify

the Father Son and Holy Spirit in our mission worship faith hope truth

and love We are salt when we reject a Eurocentric or Americentric vision

10imothy C ennent Teology in the Context o World Christianity How the Global Church Is

Influencing the Way We Tink About and Discuss Teology (Grand Rapids Zondervan 9830909830889830881048631) xx11Douglas Sanders ldquoIndigenous Peoples Issues o Definitionrdquo International Journal o Cultural

Property 983096 no 1048625 (1048625983097983097983097) 1048628

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1236

10486251048632 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

of the church and become the global missional church Christ envisioned

In part one I show how Western conversations are impoverished and

insufficient in isolation from indigenous and Majority World Christians Weenhance our ldquosaltinessrdquo through local-global ( glocal ) exchanges o do this

we must reshape our conversations We need global and local exchanges that

we characterize by mutuality respect partnership and symbiosis Such ex-

changes help us learn from each other whether wersquore in Western indig-

enous or Majority World settings It helps us stay ldquosaltyrdquo It enables us to

pursue global missional theology and practice Globally and locally we can

pursue missional vitality and truly be ldquothe salt of the earthrdquo

P983137983154983156 1048626 L983145983143983144983156 R983141983150983141983159983145983150983143 O983157983154 M983145983155983155983145983151983150

ldquoYou are the light of the world A city on a hill cannot be hidden Neither do

people light a lamp and put it under a bowl Instead they put it on its stand and

it gives light to everyone in the house In the same way let your light shine

before others that they may see your good deeds and glorify your Father in

heavenrdquo (Mt 104862910486251048628-10486251048631) Globally and locally you are the light of the world Be lightLight illuminates reveals and dispels darkness Te church is light when

it does good deedsmdashhealing and liberating and redemptive deeds Itrsquos light

when its being and faith and deeds bring glorify to the Father Te church

is light when it participates in Godrsquos redemptive mission in the world as a

global missional community

o do this we must renew our mission In part two I explore how indig-

enous and Majority World Christians teach us to renew mission We renew

mission through contextualization liberation hospitality Spirit empow-

erment creation care ethics and the transformation of neighborhoods

P983137983154983156 1048627 C983145983156983161 R983141983158983145983156983137983148983145983162983145983150983143 O983157983154 C983144983157983154983139983144983141983155

You are a city set on a hill ldquoA city on a hill cannot be hiddenrdquo Globally and

locally you are a city set on a hill Be a city set on a hill

Tis means that we are an alternative and countercultural movement We

have a distinct culture and politic and social existence We are a people

gathered from every tribe language people and nation We are in the world

but not of the world We are in the world but distinct from the world We are

within the world and for the sake of the world

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1336

Introduction 10486251048633

o be this kind of alternative city or culture we must renew our mission

community ethics and worship We need to pursue the revitalization of our

churches so that they are distinct And by distinct I mean an alternative city(altera civitas)

We are a ldquocity on a hillrdquo that witnesses to Jesus Christ and his eternal kingdom

when we are a global missional church In part three I demonstrate how indig-

enous and Majority World Christians teach us to revitalize churches We revi-

talize churches by indigenizing faith devouring Scripture renewing education

practicing servantship (servant leadership) recovering community and devel-

oping spirituality and discipleship We inspire our churches when we developour theology and practices relating to beauty and the arts9830891048626

In the final chapter I wrap things up by addressing an important question

In light of all the material covered in this book what would it now look like

to engage in global missional theology ecclesiology interpretation history

pneumatology worship and education

Herersquos how you can get the most out of this book

Community You can read this book alone in a small group with somefriends at home or at a coffee shop or as part of a ministry team However

you get a lot more out of this book when you read it with others ogether

you can think about the bookrsquos implications What do the chapters mean for

your ministry church agency family or team

GlobalChurch Project video series Irsquove made a video series to go along with

this book Appendix one has the details

Study guide Yoursquoll get a lot more out of this book if you spend time

working through the study guide in appendix two ry to do this in a group

Te study guide includes reflection questions suggested practices and

Further Reading

Characters As you read this book yoursquoll come across names and people

yoursquove never heard of before For a glimpse of who they are and what issues

concern them see appendix three

My website o help you get the most out of this book Irsquove included more

resources on my website TeGlobalChurchProjectcom Tese include

videos reading lists important links a glossary and other resources Irsquove

12Irsquove put a separate chapter on the theme o beauty and the arts on my website Itrsquos additional to

this book

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1436

10486261048624 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

also provided ways that you can contact me See appendix four

In my first book Salt Light and a City I developed a missional theology

of the church I did this in conversation with twelve theologians from the fourmajor Christian traditions Tat volume offered a window into the thought of

European and American theologians It showed how they are making sense

of the nature and mission of the church in their Western cultural context

Te book that yoursquore now reading takes a different approach I have

stepped away from European and American voices I now ask What can

those in the Majority World and indigenous cultures teach us in the West

What can they teach us about the churchrsquos mission worship theology andcommunity Te quality and quantity of material coming out of the Ma-

jority World is astonishing Any theology that ignores the insights of indig-

enous and Majority World Christians is deficient and impoverished

White middle-class European North American tertiary-educated men

dominate Western theology Tey dominate the Western missional conver-

sation I know I fit that profile Tis group still monopolizes missional church

conferences and seminars Tey get all the book contracts In fact this groupstill controls theology and the church in many settings But this is changing

New voices are rising Tese include women minorities the poor indigenous

groups and Majority World leaders Missional conversations arenrsquot attentive

to the Spirit and to Godrsquos mission if they ignore these voices Majority World

and indigenous churches oen have extraordinary missional vitality Openness

to other voices needs to happen now It is time for Western churches theol-

ogies and mission to mature and to reflect Godrsquos global mission

In this book I could have consulted the work of many thousands of in-

digenous and Majority World thinkers and writers and practitioners But I

have limited myself to a sample of those who speak directly to its themes

Tese African Asian Eastern European Middle Eastern Caribbean Latin

American First Nation and indigenous thinkers challenge us Tey dare us

to examine our theologies and missions and churches And they inspire us

to renew the worship and community and mission of Jesusrsquo church Tey

stir us to think in fresh ways about what it means to be salt light and a city

Tey help us become a global missional churchmdasha truly GlobalChurch

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1536

PA R T O N E

S A L TReshaping Our Conversations

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1636

G L O C A L I Z I N G

C O N V E R S A T I O N S

H983151983159 D983151 W983141 D983141983158983141983148983151983152

G983148983151983139983137983148 C983151983150983158983141983154983155983137983156983145983151983150983155983103

Rather than taking one contextual version of the Gospel and imposing

it as the Gospel throughout the world via the missionary enterprise

the shapers of Mission as ransformation have recognized the

plurality of localities that has created an intercontextual

ldquopan-localrdquo global phenomenon in theology

AL IZON

The International Society for Urban Mission (ISUM) is a group of urban

missionaries who are passionate about cultivating hope and love and re-newal in cities Irsquove connected with this group for some years ISUM held its

first annual Summit on Integral Urban Mission in Bangkok Tailand Te

team from Urban Neighbours of Hope (UNOH) under the leadership of

my Australian friends Ash and Anj Barker organized much of the summit

UNOH teams covenant with God and each other to ldquolive out our passion for

loving God and neighbour Focus on releasing neighbourhoods from urban

poverty Grow through equipping each other neighbours and the broader

church to radically follow Jesus and join Godrsquos Kingdom coming UNOH

workers live and serve in small responsive neighbourhood-based teamsrdquo983089

1See wwwunohorg

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1736

10486261048628 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

Tis summit involved interactive participatory hands-on immersion op-

portunities keynotes lectures and workshops Keynote speakers came from

Africa Australia Myanmar New Zealand North America the PhilippinesSouth America Tailand and First Nations A few hundred Majority World

and Western thinkers and activists came together for those days Tey explored

the theology and practices of integral transformational and urban mission

Tese thinkers and activists pursued a range of aims1048626 Tis included col-

laboration between urban Christians from a variety of backgrounds (Ma-

jority World and Western theologians activists ecumenicals Pentecostals

evangelicals colleges church movements and development agencies) Teyaimed for collective action and thought in an international and integral

context Tey sought to gain mutual understanding for a comprehensive

picture of urban mission around the globe Tey encouraged information

sharing and best practicesmdashlearning from our mistakes and seeking solu-

tions Tey developed recommendations and calls to action to the broader

church Working groups wrote briefing papers aer each summit based on

key issues in urban mission And they endeavored to build trust wisdomand inspiration to better engage our new urban world

Majority World and Western leaders participated in discussion prayer

integral mission and working groups Te goal was to grapple with key issues

and ask key questions How do we recruit equip and sustain urban mission

today How do we release church movements among the urban poor How

can we immerse ourselves in and transform urban neighborhoods How do

we empower urban children and young people How does the church serve

and liberate the oppressedmdashand others suffering from urban injustice What

needs to happen for poorer urban centers to develop economically socially

and spiritually How do we join God in the challenges and opportunities of

multifaith cities

Workshops included urban gardening child protection and collaborating

with local churches in urban mission Workshops also included organic

church growth and mission as well as developing NGO and government

partnerships Groups considered the good the bad and the ugly of short-

term urban mission teams

2Tese aims are detailed at ldquoInternational Society or Urban Mission Summitrdquo httpnewurbanworld

orgsummit

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1836

Glocalizing Conversations 10486261048629

Te summit was a thrilling example of how Majority World and Western

leaders can cooperate It was a time to come together in an environment of

mutual learning and enrichment It was a window into how local contextsand global themes can enrich each other Tis resulted from ISUMrsquos com-

mitment to ldquosolidarity fellowship and insight between urban Christian

leaders in the Western and Majority Worldsrdquo

Te summit was a success due to ISUMrsquos core values What are they983091 Christ-

honoring urban mission values bottom-up grassroots perspectivesmdashrather

than top-down distanced perspectives It allows local theology to reveal new

insights and perspectives about Godrsquos activity It shares insights and experi-ences through narratives embedded within urban poor communities and cities

It cultivates ongoing practical and personal solidarity with the worldrsquos urban

poor Tis Spirit-empowered urban mission honors networks relationships

and partnerships It sees such relationships as the primary method of serving

together It listens to and amplifies the voices of the urban poormdashespecially

those from the Majority World and in particular the 1048625104862410486281048624 window cities It is

attentive to signs of the kingdom of God Urban mission that glorifies God iswilling to reflect and respond with active and sacrificial commitment It shares

and extends the life of the body of Christ among the urban poor

Tis summit was a milestone in urban missiology It enriched communi-

cation between Western and Majority World thinker-activists Tis resulted

from the aims and values Irsquove mentioned Effective urban mission needs to

be a conversation on many levels It is attentive to context and immersed in

local settings It appreciates global and universal missional themes It culti-

vates dialogue between these local-global (glocal) realities It involves

mutual learning between Western and Majority World thinker-activists

Moreover solidarity between all parties is a defining feature Tis solidarity

is due to a compelling vision of the kingdom of God

Tese collaborative glocal features of the ISUM urban mission summit

in Bangkok are critical for the aims of this book GlobalChurch

Majority World indigenous and Western leaders thinkers and churches

can stretch and enrich each other But they need to be open and attentive to

each other Tey need learning postures and open hearts and minds Tey

3ldquoAbout ISUMrdquo httpnewurbanworldorgabout

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1936

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2036

Glocalizing Conversations 10486261048631

always rooted in the local and particularmdashas local churches embody the

gospel and witness to Christ Tese churches forge their own theological

understandings as they do mission together Tey engage in transformationalpractices among the people in their settings Tey enjoy worship mission

and community in their local and particular context Ideally the result is

unique contextual theologies and missions

Simultaneously global conversations form Tey form because of this

multitude of local theologies and practices Local conversations inform and

enrich other local conversations catalyzing global themes and voices izon

observes that the global ldquoowes its existence to local contexts Sharedconvictions among the theologies and practices of local contextual realities

give shape to its global dimensionsrdquo1048629

Majority World indigenous and Western theologies are equally contextual

Tey are equally culture bound Tey are equally particular to their time and

location At times they are all enlightened or myopic liberating or con-

straining humanizing or objectifying beautiful or offensive prophetic or

tepid Te local particular and cultural shape all these theologies Converselythese particular theologies feed and influence global conversations Tere is

no place then for ethnocentrism colonialism or elitism Tere is no place

for theological missional cultural or institutionalized arrogance

Multiple local contexts and voices come togethermdashintentionally or notmdashto

form global themes and theologies Conversely these global realities shape

local contexts oday local contexts must grapple with ldquoan emerging global

culture ie the interacting realities of modernity postmodernity and the

phenomenon of globalizationrdquo1048630 Hence the interdependent and symbiotic

relationship between the localparticular and the globaluniversal We call this

interdependent relationship between the local and the global glocalization

Te global church needs a thrilling glocal exchange We need one that we

characterize by mutuality respect partnership and symbiosis Such ex-

change helps Majority World indigenous and Western churches learn from

each other It enables them to pursue missional theology and practice o-

gether the church becomes a ldquocity on a hillrdquo

5Ibid 10486259830886Ibid 9830961048628

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2136

10486261048632 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

W983144983137983156 R983141983153983157983145983154983141983155 G983148983151983139983137983148983145983162983137983156983145983151983150983103

Te glocal exchange described above needs to be broader than transforma-

tional mission Tis is necessary if the church is to develop a robust inter-cultural and glocal missional ecclesiology

In my first book Salt Light and a City I outlined the foundational

themes of missional ecclesiology983095 Majority World and Western leaders

need to engage these themes in local and contextual ways Teir insights can

then enrich global conversations Tese global conversations in turn shape

local understandings and practices Tis way a glocal appreciation of these

themes emergesLocal regional and global theologies and practices are thereby enriched

Te church becomes healthier and more missionalmdasha truer expression of

the kingdom Te church becomes a fuller witness to Christ his passion for

the nations and his ability to bring unity in diversity

Stephen Bevans and Roger Schroeder outline the six constants of mission

Tese are our theologies about Jesus the church the end times salvation

human nature and culture Bevans and Schroeder describe the relationshipbetween these six and their historical cultural and theological contexts Tis is

why they call these six constants in context Our understanding of these six

constants develops in relation to local and global movements Sometimes local

voices influence our understandings of these six Other times it is regional or

global voices For all of us local regional and global influences are at play at

once Collectively they form our appreciation of the six constants of mission1048632

Here are eight theological themes that the church can develop through

processes of glocalization I presented these in my book Salt Light and a City

Tey are vital to the churchrsquos health mission community and future We

could add many other themes to these eight but these will suffice for now1048633

Scripture Te Scriptures are the infallible authoritative Word of God

Christrsquos Spirit has inspired them Tey have absolute and final authority in

all aspects of corporate and individual faith ethics conduct and witness

Christians interpret and apply Scripture in local contexts and in particular

7Graham Hill Salt Light and a City Introducing Missional Ecclesiology (Eugene OR Wip and

Stock 9830909830881048625983090) 10486251048628983097-983090104863110486288Stephen B Bevans and Roger Schroeder Constants in Context A Teology o Mission or oday

American Society o Missiology Series (Maryknoll NY Orbis 9830909830889830881048628) part one9Tese points first appeared in my book Salt Light and a City xxii-xxiv

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2236

Glocalizing Conversations 10486261048633

social settings Conversely we learn from the interpretations and readings

of other groups

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our local- global theology of Scripture and biblical interpretation

Evangelicalism Pentecostalism missional movements and so forth I

have charismatic missional and evangelical convictions Glocal conversa-

tions help me understand and practice these convictions better

I will use evangelicalism as an example Michael Horton says that our

beliefs and practices are evangelical when they are ldquocommitted to the suffi-

ciency of Scripture the priesthood of all believers the total lostness ofhumans the sole mediation of Christ the gracious efficacy and finality of

Godrsquos redemptive work in Christ through election propitiation calling and

keeping Te linchpin for all of this was the doctrine of justification by grace

alone through faith alone because of Christ alonerdquo9830891048624

Such convictions are necessary if we are to be faithful to the gospel and

to a biblical vision of church and mission Te gospel defines Godrsquos purposes

for humanity the church and the universe Te triune God controls thechurch He is its Lord and Savior Sanctifier and Liberator Master and King

He is completely sovereign over its nature affairs mission and history God

is the churchrsquos only source of grace election atonement salvation and per-

severance Te churchrsquos justification and hope are by grace alone through

faith alone by Christ alone

Herersquos the challenge I face My understanding of evangelicalism is

Western I am a product of the Western theological tradition and my Western

evangelical heritage Much of this is wonderful But I need indigenous and

Majority World evangelicals and others to help me expand and reshape

these insights Te same would be true if I were a Pentecostal

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of our theological traditions and convictions

Jesus Christ We must center our theology on Jesus Christ the Lord of

the church Te church needs to reflect on the person and work of Christ

and respond to him Tis means gathering and going in the name and power

of Christ It means allowing Christrsquos Spirit to shape our community and

10Michael Horton ldquoEvangelical Arminiansrdquo Modern Reormation 1048625 no 1048627 (1048625983097983097983090) 10486251048631

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2336

10486271048624 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

identity and mission It means developing our Christology ecclesiology and

missiology concurrently Te early church developed these three areas and

more in a concurrent and integrated way Tere was no linear progressionTe same is true in the contemporary global church

How can the glocal church best explore its nature structure mission and

hope Trough the centrality and the lordship of Christ

Majority World and indigenous Christians help us appreciate Jesus and

his mission afresh Tey show us how Jesus identifies with the marginalized

outcast oppressed rejected and broken He prefers them We find him

among ldquothe least of theserdquoGlocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of who Jesus Christ is How does it help us appreciate him better

What has Jesus done for and in his church and his world What does he care

about What individual and corporate responsibilities has he given us How

do we express these at local regional and global levels

Te Spirit Missional ecclesiology is inadequate without pneumatological

foundations In other words our theology of church and Spirit go togetherTe Spirit creates and animates the church He empowers it to witness to

Jesus and his gospel Te Spirit enables the church to be a missional trans-

formational community He shapes the church into an alternative society

embodying the reign of God Te church exists for the glory and mission of

Christ Te power and presence of the Spirit enables this mission worship

and glorification

Te Spirit pours out gis on the local-global church ldquofor the common

goodrdquo and ldquoto equip his people for works of service so that the body of Christ

may be built uprdquo Tis includes but isnrsquot limited to the ministry gis mani-

festation gis and motivational gis (1048625 Cor 104862510486261048631 Eph 104862810486251048625-10486251048626 Rom 104862510486261048630-1048632)

Te Spirit forms the glocal church He empowers it for service and

witness He fills it with Christrsquos empowering presence He leads it into the

missio Deimdashthe mission of the Father Son and Holy Spirit

Recently Pentecostal and renewalist movements have grown dramati-

cally in the Majority World Tey have increased in status size and influence

Many have matured theologically Te churches of the West must take notice

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of the power and presence of the Spirit

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2436

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048625

Te rinity Tere are clear limitations to the analogy between the

church and the rinity Te church can only image the rinity Yet the

church is at its best when it reflects the relational and missional passionof the rinity

What is the source and inspiration of the churchrsquos local-global mission

Ultimately it is the missional nature passion and actions of the Father Son

and Holy Spirit Godrsquos nature is missional His passion is infectious His

actions are historical redemptive and eternal Te rinity invites the

church into a sending community Te Father sends the Son Te Father

and Son send the Spirit Finally the rinity sends the church in missioninto the world

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of the rinity How does it enable our participation in the mission

and community of the triune God

Association and dialogue Tese need to happen across denominational

cultural ethnic gender and theological traditions and divides Authentic

dialogue is indispensable to the health and mission of the church What dothose marginal to the life of the church have to say to us What do ldquoothersrdquo

have to teach us Other ethnicities and cultures Other socioeconomic

groups Other ages and genders Other theological and confessing tradi-

tions Other persons from times long gone

We need to listen Share Be vulnerable Be authentic Open up to crit-

icism correction and change

We need more than dialogue We need communion and association It is

possible in a qualified way to say that God is present in all the various forms

of the church (ie the various theological ecclesiological sociocultural his-

torical and other permutations of the church) We discern this presence

through attention to Scripture history tradition culture and the Spirit Dis-

cernment involves critical dialogue theological exchange biblical study and

real relationship Only the Spirit of Jesus can enable this

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of association and dialogue

Mission and the missio Dei Te church is missional at its core It serves

obeys and images a missionary God David Bosch says ldquoTe churchrsquos mission

is not secondary to its being the church exists in being sent and in building up

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2536

10486271048626 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

itself for its missionrdquo He goes on to say ldquoEcclesiology does not precede missi-

ology there cannot be church without an intrinsic missionary dimensionrdquo983089983089

Jesus is Lord Lord of his church and Lord of his world His mission de-termines and forms the church His mission shapes the nature purposes

structures ministries and activities of his church Majority World and in-

digenous thinkers help us understand the implications of this mission Tey

help us form glocal theologies of mission Tey reveal ldquomission in context

as transformationrdquo9830891048626

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of mission and the missio Dei Church theology and practice Glocal conversations can inform and

enrich many aspects of the church (when practiced well) Teologies and

practices benefit from robust and critical glocal conversations Tese con-

versations enrich many areas (community spirituality discipleship liturgy

worship hospitality eco-justice education social ethics servantship lib-

eration place suffering beauty and so on)

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-standing of these many dimensions of church and mission

Glocal processes shape these eight themes and their practices We need

to facilitate and enable these conversations and processes Tis is urgent It

must be a priority No theology of mission or missional ecclesiology is ad-

equate without glocal conversations983089983091

T983144983141 L983151983139983137983148 983137983150983140 G983148983151983138983137983148 E983150983154983145983139983144 E983137983139983144 O983156983144983141983154

Glocalization takes the localparticular context and globaluniversal themes

seriously Contextual and global conversations enter an enriching and in-

forming relationship Tese two always have an active and symbiotic rela-

tionship Tis is true whether we deliberately put them into conversation or

not Te local shapes the global and the global shapes the local Many local

11David J Bosch Believing in the Future oward a Missiology o Western Culture (New York

rinity 1048625983097983097983093) 104862798309012izon ransormation Afer Lausanne 1048631-98309713Not all o these themes are dealt with in this present volume since either (1048625) I have dealt with them

in my book Salt Light and a City (983090) they are not all key themes in the writings o the thirty-five

Majority World thinkers considered in this volume or (1048627) there is not adequate space in a book

this size

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2636

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048627

voices converge to form global conversations and theologies Using the Phil-

ippines as a case study izon illustrates this by showing the interdepen-

dence between local and global themes in mission983089983092Dialogue between local and global conversations is critical Kōsuke

Koyama wrote an important book on contextual mission called Water Buffalo

Teology Koyama is a Japanese missionary who served in Chiang Mai

Tailand He writes of the joys and challenges of doing local particular water

buffalo theology He considers the relationship between local theology global

missional themes and transforming cultures ldquoWater Buffalo Teology sees

certain specific challenges Contextualization of theology implies two criticalmovements First to articulate Jesus Christ in culturally appropriate com-

municatively apt words and second to criticize reform dethrone or oppose

culture if it is found to be against what the name of Jesus Christ stands forrdquo9830891048629

Kōsuke Koyama challenges us to recognize what we bring to the task of

local theology For him it was doing theology in Tailand while being Jap-

anese We also need to notice the particular culture wersquore located in as we do

the work of theology Tis means we avoid speaking of an ldquoAsian theologyrdquoldquoAfrican theologyrdquo and the like We need to cultivate local theologies that

engage regional and global themes But these theologies must be ldquodistinctly

localrdquo and a ldquotheology from belowrdquo9830891048630

Simultaneously we need to pursue a reformation of theology and

practice ldquoin the global contextrdquo Tis means entering ldquothe disturbing spa-

ciousness of Jesus Christrdquo Jesus calls us to reject enmity and exceptionalism

We seem him present in our culture language stories and relationships

But we also choose to embrace the ldquootherrdquo We choose to see him present

in other culturesmdashshaping a global people to serve and worship him

joining in his mission983089983095

Kōsuke Koyama roots the gospel in the local contextual and particular

Tis is why he roots his water buffalo theology in Northern Tai culture He

is careful not to say ldquoHere is how you contextualize in your settingrdquo Instead

14izon ransormation Afer Lausanne 1048631-10486251048627 10486251048628983097-98309098308898309015Kōsuke Koyama Water Buffalo Teology 983090983093th anniversary ed (Maryknoll NY Orbis 1048625983097983097983097)

xiii-xv16Kōsuke Koyama ldquoTe Asian Approach to Christrdquo Missiology 1048625983090 no 1048628 (10486259830979830961048628) 10486281048627983093-104862798309617Kōsuke Koyama ldquoReormation in the Global Context Te Disturbing Spaciousness o Jesus Christrdquo

Currents in Teology and Mission 1048627983088 no 983090 (9830909830889830881048627) 10486251048625983097-983090983096

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2736

10486271048628 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

he tells us a story Itrsquos the story of how he contextualized theology in northern

Tailand while being open to global conversations Koyama asks us to form

our own local expressions of church mission and theology At the same timewe must stay attentive to what God is saying and doing beyond that context

Tis way local and global and particular and universal become mutually

enriching conversation partners

G983148983151983139983137983148983145983162983137983156983145983151983150 983137983150983140 H983145983155983156983151983154983145983139983137983148983148983161 S983145983148983141983150983139983141983140 V983151983145983139983141983155

Glocal theologies and conversations pay attention to voices that powers in-

stitutions religions and societies have silenced R S Sugirtharajah pushesback a little on izonrsquos ideas Sugirtharajah says that the church should

privilege local conversations He emphasizes the local contextual and post-

colonial reading of biblical texts9830891048632

Te church needs to listen Te church ought to be attentive to the

theologies and biblical interpretations of groups that cultures and reli-

gions have ignored Historically powerful secular and religious forces

have silenced these groups Tey have marginalized oppressed and colo-nized them It is time for the church to address this injustice We must

start listening to important but silenced voices We need to privilege the

voices of the former victims of Western colonialism We need to develop

postcolonial biblical interpretations theologies and expressions of church

and mission

How do we take such perspectives seriously as we develop glocal conver-

sations How do these themes help us foster vital relationships between local

and global voices

It is time for us to embrace values that enable conversations with those

oen ignored by the church We need values that help us learn from these

groups and individuals

Valuing equal partnership Colonizing powers oppressed silenced and

colonized certain groups At times the church was complicit Tese colo-

nized groups have become ldquoconfident indomitable and indispensable

partners in the dialogue and collaboration with the dispossessed and disad-

18R S Sugirtharajah Asian Biblical Hermeneutics and Postcolonialism Contesting the Interpreta-

tions Te Bible and Liberation Series (Maryknoll NY Orbis 1048625983097983097983096) 1048625983093-1048625983094

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2836

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048629

vantaged in the Westrdquo9830891048633 Tis calls for attentiveness to these voices and re-

sponsiveness to their prophetic challenges It also demands a critical evalu-

ation of colonial readings of Scripture Colonial models of theology andchurch and mission are no longer the benchmark Te global church must

examine them afresh

Valuing equal status Tose on the margins have now taken their rightful

place on the global stage Tey have claimed appropriate and equal status at

the table Subaltern readings of theology church and mission are invaluable

contributors to global theological conversations Tis means that we esteem

them But we also test themWhat do we mean by subaltern Subalterns are those who are down-

trodden and silenced (or have been treated this way in the past) Dominant

or colonizing groups treat them as invisible nonentities Tey enjoy limited

or no access to power Sometimes these are women certain tribal and ethnic

groups and those considered ldquountouchablerdquo In Voices from the Margin Su-

girtharajah provides a platform for postcolonial subaltern readings of

Scripture and theology Tese readings challenge colonialmdashoen Westernmdashreadings of Bible and theology and cultures Tey claim equal status with

other ways of doing theology10486261048624

Valuing equal identity People groups need freedom to explore their new

and emerging identities Tese emerge in response to local and global influ-

ences Local culture is not the only thing at work here Global forces also

shape identity as do imported practices ideas readings rituals and tech-

nologies But each group should be free to explore and construct their par-

ticular forms of Christian identity

Valuing equal interpretations ldquoPostcolonialism is concerned with the

question of cultural and discursive dominationrdquo Colonialism led to op-

pressive and controlling forms of culture and discourse Tese were usually

not contextual or indigenous Western powers for instance brought co-

lonial forms of theology church biblical interpretation and mission1048626983089

Postcolonialism calls for alternative ways of approaching these things Tose

19Ibid 104862598309420R S Sugirtharajah Voices rom the Margin Interpreting the Bible in the Tird World (Maryknoll

NY Orbis 10486259830979830971048625)21Sugirtharajah Asian Biblical Hermeneutics and Postcolonialism 10486251048631

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2936

10486271048630 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

who were once marginalized oppressed and silenced need to lead these fresh

approaches in their own settings Tese then influence global conversations

We need to support the new readings and insights and experiments from thesegroups o be genuine this support must be both critical and collegial

Valuing equal empowerment Sugirtharajah says that postcolonialism is

valuable when it empowers actual communities and real people Post-

colonial thought empowers when it addresses the difficulties hopes and

experiences of ordinary people It should never be about power plays and

the clever use of language Itrsquos pointless if itrsquos obsessed with forming newmdash

and ldquocolonizingrdquomdashtheories Itrsquos a waste of time if itrsquos a self-indulgent pursuitof new and hybrid identities Rather ldquothe worth and credibility of post-

colonial criticism will be judged by how it orchestrates the unique and

fragile and imagined claims of one community against anotherrdquo Empow-

erment happens in a variety of ways One way is contributing equally to

global conversations10486261048626

Al izon examines postcolonialism in the Philippines He says that it can

teach the global church a lot about healthy local-global conversations Fil-ipino contextual theology resists many Western forms of mission and the-

ology It finds them patronizing and controlling Tis indigenous theology

values prophetic sociopolitical engagement in institutions and the society

at large It emphasizes ministry to whole persons and communities It con-

structs a Filipino theology of beauty and mission and worship and com-

munity And it fosters indigenous theological approaches to the spirit world

and cosmology

izon says that postcolonial theology has played a constructive role in

the Philippines But he is uncomfortable with the label postcolonialism He

prefers to describe historical events as ldquobeyond colonialismrdquo And he says

that global conversations enrich local theologies and vice versa1048626983091

Postcolonial thought informs our understanding of the relationship be-

tween the local and global It also shows how theology can emerge at the

intersection between the localparticular and the globaluniversal It re-

minds us that worthwhile glocalization listens to all voices Tis includes

heeding those that have been historically silenced

22Ibid 983090104862823izon ransormation Afer Lausanne 1048625983088983090 10486259830941048631-9830961048631

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3036

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048631

G983148983151983139983137983148983145983162983137983156983145983151983150 983137983150983140 983156983144983141 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

C983151983150983139983148983157983140983145983150983143 R983141983142983148983141983139983156983145983151983150983155

How do we go about developing a model for glocal conversations izon hasrecently provided a useful model that is instructive as we seek to learn from

the Majority World It has at least two key features

First the local is in the global (globalization from below) Global theologies

and ideas have origins in many particular local contexts In that sense glo-

balization is from below Global ideas have local roots Ideas about integral

mission liberation theology and missional church have local origins Tey

have their roots in the prayers hopes discoveries mission and theologiesof thousands of local communities ldquoTe global does not cannot exist

without the localmdashbut the coming together of localities creates a global re-

ality that becomes greater than the sum of its parts it creates a gestalt entity

to which localities make themselves accountablerdquo1048626983092

Second the global is in the local (panlocalization from above) Te con-

cerns and voices of multitudes of locales form global conversations Tese

global discussions can provide a ldquopositive accountabilityrdquo back to local con-texts Tis is true when they enrich affirm serve guide and strengthen local

contexts It is also true when they avoid homogenization control impo-

sition and judgment Glocalization is best when it sees itself as interde-

pendent deeply connected with the local10486261048629

Tatrsquos a helpful starting point But we need to go further Besides izonrsquos

proposals Irsquom convinced that robust glocal conversations cultivate six core

practices

983089 Glocal theology practices its values We root glocal theology in core

values Tese values include solidarity understanding and mutual learning

Do we value fellowship with Christians of all cultures Do we value learning

from them

We prove our values through our practices What practices emerge out of

these values We need to collaborate act collectively and share information

We must find ways to foster grassroots perspectives and local theologies We

need to share stories and learnings and cultivate networks relationships and

partnerships We need attentiveness to local voices and global themes We

24Ibid 9830901048625983088-1048625104862825Ibid 98309010486251048628-1048625983096

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3136

10486271048632 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

ought to find ways to put these local and global voices into conversation

Mutual learning humility and solidarity are key Worthwhile glocal con-

versations can never be merely theoretical or academic It is up to us to rootour values in our practices

983090 Glocal theology practices humility (and it tells a new narrative) We

have noted that the local is in the global and the global is in the local Te

two are interdependent Tey form each other reciprocally Since this is the

case we must practice humility Tere is no place for ethnocentrism colo-

nialism or theological and cultural arrogance I have seen these unhealthy

postures far too oen in Western settingsRecently I attended a missional leadership conference On that occasion

the keynote speakermdasha leading missional author and speakermdashsaid that

North American missional conversations and innovations hold the key to

the future of the Western church Tis Euro American view is wrong (Irsquom

being kind o be frank itrsquos complete nonsense) Itrsquos arrogant and Euro

Americanndashcentric And itrsquos completely out of step with what is happening in

the glocal church We need a new narrativeIn June 1048626104862410486251048627 Te Center for the Study of Global Christianity reported

the top 10486261048624 countries where Christianity has the highest percentage growth

rate Nineteen of the top twenty are in Asia and Africa Eleven of them are

in Muslim majority countries Not a single country from Europe or North

America makes the top twenty list10486261048630

Itrsquos time to cultivate a new narrative Te future of the church is emerging

from the Majority World Rather than North America the churches of

Eastern Asia Western Africa the Arabian Peninsula and other parts of the

Majority World reveal the future of the global church We need the contribu-

tions of all contexts Western indigenous and Majority World All con-

tribute to glocal conversations All are important as we learn from each

other about mission theology and faith But letrsquos stop pretending that North

Americans and Europeans will reveal the future of the global church Letrsquos

start listening to what God is saying about the future of the global church

And hersquos speaking to us through the churches of Asia Africa Latin America

26Russ Mitchell ldquoTe op 983090983088 Countries Where Christianity Is Growing the Fastestrdquo Disciple All

Nations (blog) August 983090983093 98309098308810486251048627 httpsdiscipleallnationswordpresscom98309098308810486251048627983088983096983090983093the-top

-983090983088-countries-where-christianity-is-growing-the-astest

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3236

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048633

Muslim majority settings and so on We must cultivate a new glocal nar-

rativemdashone soaked in humility

Glocal theology must be humble theology Meek theology Receptive the-ology Discerning theology Prayerful theology Dialogical theology De-

pendent theology A theology that celebrates the interdependence between

the localparticular and the globaluniversal

983091 Glocal theology practices expansiveness Glocalization is by nature

comprehensive Local and global influences permeate much of our lives Tese

glocal forces shape our theologies and churches whether we like it or not

But intentionality is also important We need to commit to an expansiveapproach to glocal theology How do we deliberately cultivate glocal conver-

sations in our biblical interpretation Do we foster them in our under-

standing of the person and work of Christ How does glocalization shape

the way the Spirit empowers and constitutes the church How can it form

our understanding of the nature and mission of the rinity How does it

influence the way we practice fellowship and conversation across denomi-

national cultural ethnic economic sociocultural political gender andtheological divides How might it shape our theologies of mission com-

munity beauty spirituality suffering discipleship hospitality eco-justice

place education social ethics Christian leadership and so forth

983092 Glocal theology practices attention Glocal theology doesnrsquot need to

accept all the assumptions or assertions of postcolonial or Majority World

thought But it does need to engage with them and take them seriously

Postcolonial theology for instance gives the marginalized and colonized

and forgotten and silenced both dignity and voice Our glocal conversations

must also include and esteem these groups We need to be attentive to

others weak and powerful female and male dominant and downtrodden

old and young rich and poor privileged and marginalized influential and

subaltern educated and illiterate We need to practice the art of attention

being especially attentive to those who are different to us

983093 Glocal theology practices embrace What do colonial ethnocentric or

Western-centric perspectives do Tey silence Tey control Tey com-

modify Tey institutionalize Tey colonize Tey domesticate Tey replace

Tey import Tey exclude Tey do these things to the beliefs experiences

and practices of other cultures A worthwhile glocal theology refuses to do

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3336

10486281048624 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

these things Instead it adopts a responsive humble celebratory open in-

clusive and embracing attitude

983094 Glocal theology practices discernment Finally we need discernmentas we engage these ideas and practices Discernment is a huge topic thatrsquos

hard to cover comprehensively in a few words Discernment happens when

the Spirit of Christ and his Word renew our minds Te Spirit grants us

spiritual wisdom as we meditate on him and his Word and as we practice

discipleship to Jesus Christ Romans 10486251048626 provides guidance we need (1048625) to be

transformed by the renewal of our minds (1048626) to serve Christrsquos body and (1048627)

to put love into action Discernment also happens in conversation both lo-cally and glocally

I pray these core values and six practices come across in the following

chapters of GlobalChurch

Glocalization can never be just theoretical Are we committed to moving

glocalization from an abstract idea to a living communion Are we deter-

mined to construct a missional theology of the church in the context of

glocal conversations Tis must involve dialogue between Majority Worldindigenous and Western scholars activists and groups

Will glocalization be an abstract notion Or will it be a formative and

genuine communion between local regional and global voices Glocal dy-

namics are at play whether we like it or not Teyrsquore in our churches the-

ologies and missions But we can choose to relinquish isolationist colonial

parochial and arrogant approaches Instead we can adopt responsive dia-

logical learning humble and embracing postures

Trough healthy approaches to glocalization the Spirit challenges us to

value local contexts We immerse ourselves in local and particular commu-

nities and conversations He inspires us to open ourselves to global theo-

logical conversations He rouses us to value the symbiotic relationship be-

tween the localparticular and the globaluniversal

Trough glocal relationships the Spirit leads us to put local contextual

theologies into conversation with global ones He prompts us to explore the

ways in which the local is in the glocal and the global is in the local He per-

suades us to pursue collaboration and dialogue and mutual learning We

engage with Christians from different backgrounds and cultures ecumen-

icals Pentecostals evangelicals and so on from Western indigenous and

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3436

Glocalizing Conversations 10486281048625

Majority World contexts He motivates us to express solidarity between all

parties We appreciate our unity in diversity

Trough glocal conversations the Spirit moves us to ensure that unity andsolidarity emerge from a compelling vision of Jesusrsquo kingdom and gospel

and person He challenges us to share information theology and practices

He urges us to learn from each othermdashour successes and mistakes We seek

glocal solutions

Te Spirit calls us to develop glocal conversations about Christian ideas

and practices Tese include Scripture Evangelicalism ecumenism Pente-

costalism Jesus Christ the Holy Spirit God the Father the rinity com-munity spirituality discipleship liturgy worship hospitality prayer eco-

justice education social ethics Christian leadership gospel and culture

beauty place suffering liberation and so forth

Finally through glocal conversations the Spirit leads us to adopt a new

posture Tis is a responsive humble celebratory open inclusive and em-

bracing attitude to the ldquootherrdquo We do this as a new people made up of every

tribe and language and people and nationTere are dangers in glocalization Sugirtharajah warns of the commodi-

fication of local contextual practices and theologies When this happens

they are ldquosmoothed out of their primary contexts concerns and contesta-

tions travel across borders and become objects of analysis and scrutiny

within an alien secondary contextrdquo1048626983095

Itrsquos common for those of us who are Western to make mistakes when we

wrestle with Majority World and indigenous ideas Sugirtharajah mentions

our tendency to commodify reduce and institutionalize these ideas We also

risk doing these things (1048625) We apply them in noncontextual prescriptive ways

(1048626) We ignore their meanings in their original setting (1048627) We glamorize or

idealize their proponents or their contexts (1048628) We demonize those persons or

contexts (1048629) We disregard them as irrelevant rhetorical or minority discourse

Kevin J Vanhoozer says that we can fall into three traps when we glo-

calize theology (1048625) We can underestimate the theological significance of

local cultures (1048626) We can homogenize cultures and theologies exaggerating

27R S Sugirtharajah ldquoextual ake-Aways Tird World exts in Western Metropolitan Centresrdquo

Black Teology in Britain A Journal o Contextual Praxis 983090 (1048625983097983097983097) 10486271048627 10486271048631 Edward W Said Te

World the ext and the Critic (Cambridge MA Harvard University Press 10486259830979830961048627) 9830901048627983097

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3536

10486281048626 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

ldquothe onerdquo (1048627) We can overemphasize cultural particularity exaggerating ldquothe

manyrdquo and pursue ldquotheological ethnificationrdquo10486261048632

My hope is that GlobalChurch does not fall into the traps Sugirtharajahand Vanhoozer describe I hope that what unfolds in the following chapters

is respectful and discerning I hope it leads to further mutually enriching

conversations between people of different cultures

You the reader face the same challenges You face them in your personal

life ministry context and missional engagements

Will you treat the themes in this book as abstract theoretical notions

Will this be a temporary infatuation a flirtation with the ldquootherrdquo that dissi-pates as suddenly as it arrived Or will glocal conversations become an en-

riching and formative orientation in your life Will glocal conversations

bring fresh approaches to theology faith mission church and worship Will

conversations with other cultures and theologies become for you a com-

pelling way of life

My prayer is that glocal conversations will help the church be a global

visible alternative ldquocity set upon a hillrdquo a truly GlobalChurch

28Craig Ott and Harold A Netland Globalizing Teology Belie and Practice in an Era o World

Christianity (Grand Rapids Baker Academic 983090983088983088983094) 1048625983090983093

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3636

Page 9: GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 936

Introduction 10486251048629

in South Africa) By 1048626104862410486261048629 there are likely to be 104862510486301048624 million Christians in China

By 1048626104862410486271048624 this number is likely to be 104862610486281048631 million (outnumbering Christians in

Mexico Brazil and the United States) In an interview with the elegraphFenggang Yang says ldquoMao thought he could eliminate religion He thought he

had accomplished this Itrsquos ironicmdashthey didnrsquot Tey actually failed completelyrdquo1048629

Philip Jenkins concludes

We are currently living through one of the transforming moments in the

history of religion worldwide Over the last five centuries the story of Chris-

tianity has been inextricably bound up with that of Europe and European-

derived civilizations overseas above all in North America Until recently theoverwhelming majority of Christians have lived in white nations Over the

last century however the center of gravity in the Christian world has shied

inexorably away from Europe southward to Africa and Latin America and

eastward toward Asia oday the largest Christian communities on the planet

are to be found in those regions1048630

What does all this mean for the mission and theology and worship and

communities of the church worldwide And what does it mean particularlyfor the Western church

In Matthew 104862910486251048627-10486251048630 Jesus provides three remarkable images of the churchmdash

salt light and a city Jesus confronts his disciples with a missional description

of the church Te church in mission is the salt of the earth the light of the

world and a city set on a hill Te churchrsquos purpose is to let its ldquolight shine

before others that they may see your good deeds and glorify your Father in

heavenrdquo Te purpose of the churchrsquos missionary nature is the worship andglorification of the Father and Son and Holy Spirit983095

Te church is another city constituted by every tribe language people

5om Phillips ldquoChina on Course to Become lsquoWorldrsquos Most Christian Nationrsquo Within 1048625983093 Yearsrdquo

elegraph April 1048625983097 98309098308810486251048628 wwwtelegraphcouknewsworldnewsasiachina1048625983088104863110486319830949830889830901048627China-on

-course-to-become-worlds-most-Christian-nation-within-1048625983093-yearshtml See Fenggang Yang and

Joseph B amney eds Conucianism and Spiritual raditions in Modern China and Beyond Re-

ligion in Chinese Societies (Boston Brill 9830909830881048625983090) Fenggang Yang and Graeme Lang eds Social

Scientific Studies o Religion in China Methodology Teories and Findings (Leiden Brill 98309098308810486251048625)

Fenggang Yang Religion in China Survival and Revival Under Communist Rule (Oxord Oxord

University Press 9830909830881048625983090)6Philip Jenkins Te Next Christendom Te Coming o Global Christianity 1048627rd ed (Oxord Ox-

ord University Press 98309098308810486251048625) 10486257J Driver Images o the Church in Mission (Scottdale PA Herald 10486259830979830971048631) 10486251048631983088-9830961048625 Graham Hill Salt

Light and a City Introducing Missional Ecclesiology (Eugene OR Wip and Stock 9830909830881048625983090) xiii

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1036

10486251048630 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

and nation Te church must cultivate a distinct social existence shaping its

community and mission around its commitment to plurality and diversity

and unity1048632 God calls his church to be a global and missional ldquocity on a hillrdquoTis is a church constituted and enriched and represented by Western and

indigenous and Majority World peoples

Tose of us in the West need a new narrative Itrsquos time to abandon our

flawed Eurocentric and Americentric worldviews We need a new global

and missional narrative and for that we must turn to the churches of Ma-

jority World and indigenous cultures Tey can help us explore what it

means to be a global missional community Many Christian communitiesin Majority World and indigenous contexts have been wrestling with these

issues for generations Marginalization and persecution and alienation have

been their lot Yet somehow in spite of or because of that they have flour-

ished In fact theyrsquove grown exponentially

So whom am I talking about when I refer to Majority World and indig-

enous Christians Majority World Christians are those in Africa Asia the

Caribbean Eastern Europe Latin America the Middle East and Oceania

1048633

I use the term Majority World because the majority of the worldrsquos population

is in those cultures today Te majority of the church is in those cultures too

I donrsquot use the terms non-Western or Tird World or Developing World Tese

terms use Western cultures as their point of reference Tey imply Western

8Barry A Harvey Another City An Ecclesiological Primer or a Post-Christian World (New York

rinity 1048625983097983097983097) 9830901048627-9830909830939I donrsquot deal with the diasporas in this book For example Irsquove made no mention o Hispanic

Portuguese or Asian minorities in the United States United Kingdom Canada Europe Austra-lia and so on Irsquom aware that right now Latin American and Chinese diasporas are active in

evangelism and mission in Europe in the same way in which the Filipino or the Salvadoran dias-

poras carry on mission in the United States Irsquove chosen not to include voices rom the diasporas

mainly because there are so many worthy contributors in that group and I donrsquot have the space

to treat them well in this book In the uture I hope that I (or someone else) will write a book

exploring what we can learn rom the diasporas Hispanic minorities or example are making

significant contributions to the theological and missiological conversation in the United States

that are relevant to this subject Methodist historian Justo L Gonzaacutelez and Pentecostal theologian

Eldin Villaantildee are examples In Mantildeana Gonzaacutelez describes the shape and orm o a theology

developed in the Hispanic margin o the United States In Out o Every ribe and Nation he shows

what would be implied in listening to minorities within a denominational setting Villaantildeersquos Te

Liberating Spirit is a milestone in the reflection about the relationship between pneumatology and

social ethics See Justo L Gonzaacutelez Out o Every ribe and Nation Christian Teology at the

Ethnic Roundtable (Nashville Abingdon 1048625983097983097983090) Gonzaacutelez Mantildeana Christian Teology rom a

Hispanic Perspective (Nashville Abingdon 1048625983097983097983088) Eldin Villaantildee Te Liberating Spirit oward

an Hispanic American Pentecostal Social Ethic (Grand Rapids Eerdmans 10486259830979830971048627)

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1136

Introduction 10486251048631

superiority or centricity Te term Global South is too limiting given the

breadth of the group I am engaging Majority World seems to work best

In 1048626104862410486241048628 Te Lausanne Forum for World Evangelization in PattayaTailand voted unanimously that the phrase Majority World Church replace

other terms People from all over the globe participated in this forum

imothy C ennent agrees that this is the best phrase ldquoIt helps to highlight

the basic point that Africa Asia and Latin America are where the majority

of the worldrsquos Christians are now locatedrdquo9830891048624 I expand the phrase Majority

World beyond Africa Asia and Latin America to include the Caribbean

Eastern Europe Oceania and the Middle EastIndigenous and First Nations peoples are ldquothose ethnic groups that were

indigenous to a territory prior to being incorporated into a national state

and who are politically and culturally separate from the majority ethnic

identity of the state that they are a part ofrdquo Tis includes people groups like

the Australian Aborigines and American Indians983089983089

Te aim of this book is to help Western churches rediscover what it means

to be salt light and a city by engaging in global missional conversations odo this Western Christians need to enter into conversation with Majority

World and indigenous Christians Listening to others helps us grow in our

understanding and practice of mission and church and theology For far too

long wersquove marginalized or ignored Majority World and indigenous voices

We must truly become a GlobalChurch

Tis aim shapes the bookrsquos structure as summarized below

P983137983154983156 1048625 S983137983148983156 R983141983155983144983137983152983145983150983143 O983157983154 C983151983150983158983141983154983155983137983156983145983151983150983155

ldquoYou are the salt of the earth But if the salt loses its saltiness how can it be made

salty again It is no longer good for anything except to be thrown out and

trampled underfootrdquo Globally and locally you are the salt of the earth Be salt

Salt preserves seasons flavors and purifies We are salt when we glorify

the Father Son and Holy Spirit in our mission worship faith hope truth

and love We are salt when we reject a Eurocentric or Americentric vision

10imothy C ennent Teology in the Context o World Christianity How the Global Church Is

Influencing the Way We Tink About and Discuss Teology (Grand Rapids Zondervan 9830909830889830881048631) xx11Douglas Sanders ldquoIndigenous Peoples Issues o Definitionrdquo International Journal o Cultural

Property 983096 no 1048625 (1048625983097983097983097) 1048628

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1236

10486251048632 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

of the church and become the global missional church Christ envisioned

In part one I show how Western conversations are impoverished and

insufficient in isolation from indigenous and Majority World Christians Weenhance our ldquosaltinessrdquo through local-global ( glocal ) exchanges o do this

we must reshape our conversations We need global and local exchanges that

we characterize by mutuality respect partnership and symbiosis Such ex-

changes help us learn from each other whether wersquore in Western indig-

enous or Majority World settings It helps us stay ldquosaltyrdquo It enables us to

pursue global missional theology and practice Globally and locally we can

pursue missional vitality and truly be ldquothe salt of the earthrdquo

P983137983154983156 1048626 L983145983143983144983156 R983141983150983141983159983145983150983143 O983157983154 M983145983155983155983145983151983150

ldquoYou are the light of the world A city on a hill cannot be hidden Neither do

people light a lamp and put it under a bowl Instead they put it on its stand and

it gives light to everyone in the house In the same way let your light shine

before others that they may see your good deeds and glorify your Father in

heavenrdquo (Mt 104862910486251048628-10486251048631) Globally and locally you are the light of the world Be lightLight illuminates reveals and dispels darkness Te church is light when

it does good deedsmdashhealing and liberating and redemptive deeds Itrsquos light

when its being and faith and deeds bring glorify to the Father Te church

is light when it participates in Godrsquos redemptive mission in the world as a

global missional community

o do this we must renew our mission In part two I explore how indig-

enous and Majority World Christians teach us to renew mission We renew

mission through contextualization liberation hospitality Spirit empow-

erment creation care ethics and the transformation of neighborhoods

P983137983154983156 1048627 C983145983156983161 R983141983158983145983156983137983148983145983162983145983150983143 O983157983154 C983144983157983154983139983144983141983155

You are a city set on a hill ldquoA city on a hill cannot be hiddenrdquo Globally and

locally you are a city set on a hill Be a city set on a hill

Tis means that we are an alternative and countercultural movement We

have a distinct culture and politic and social existence We are a people

gathered from every tribe language people and nation We are in the world

but not of the world We are in the world but distinct from the world We are

within the world and for the sake of the world

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1336

Introduction 10486251048633

o be this kind of alternative city or culture we must renew our mission

community ethics and worship We need to pursue the revitalization of our

churches so that they are distinct And by distinct I mean an alternative city(altera civitas)

We are a ldquocity on a hillrdquo that witnesses to Jesus Christ and his eternal kingdom

when we are a global missional church In part three I demonstrate how indig-

enous and Majority World Christians teach us to revitalize churches We revi-

talize churches by indigenizing faith devouring Scripture renewing education

practicing servantship (servant leadership) recovering community and devel-

oping spirituality and discipleship We inspire our churches when we developour theology and practices relating to beauty and the arts9830891048626

In the final chapter I wrap things up by addressing an important question

In light of all the material covered in this book what would it now look like

to engage in global missional theology ecclesiology interpretation history

pneumatology worship and education

Herersquos how you can get the most out of this book

Community You can read this book alone in a small group with somefriends at home or at a coffee shop or as part of a ministry team However

you get a lot more out of this book when you read it with others ogether

you can think about the bookrsquos implications What do the chapters mean for

your ministry church agency family or team

GlobalChurch Project video series Irsquove made a video series to go along with

this book Appendix one has the details

Study guide Yoursquoll get a lot more out of this book if you spend time

working through the study guide in appendix two ry to do this in a group

Te study guide includes reflection questions suggested practices and

Further Reading

Characters As you read this book yoursquoll come across names and people

yoursquove never heard of before For a glimpse of who they are and what issues

concern them see appendix three

My website o help you get the most out of this book Irsquove included more

resources on my website TeGlobalChurchProjectcom Tese include

videos reading lists important links a glossary and other resources Irsquove

12Irsquove put a separate chapter on the theme o beauty and the arts on my website Itrsquos additional to

this book

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1436

10486261048624 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

also provided ways that you can contact me See appendix four

In my first book Salt Light and a City I developed a missional theology

of the church I did this in conversation with twelve theologians from the fourmajor Christian traditions Tat volume offered a window into the thought of

European and American theologians It showed how they are making sense

of the nature and mission of the church in their Western cultural context

Te book that yoursquore now reading takes a different approach I have

stepped away from European and American voices I now ask What can

those in the Majority World and indigenous cultures teach us in the West

What can they teach us about the churchrsquos mission worship theology andcommunity Te quality and quantity of material coming out of the Ma-

jority World is astonishing Any theology that ignores the insights of indig-

enous and Majority World Christians is deficient and impoverished

White middle-class European North American tertiary-educated men

dominate Western theology Tey dominate the Western missional conver-

sation I know I fit that profile Tis group still monopolizes missional church

conferences and seminars Tey get all the book contracts In fact this groupstill controls theology and the church in many settings But this is changing

New voices are rising Tese include women minorities the poor indigenous

groups and Majority World leaders Missional conversations arenrsquot attentive

to the Spirit and to Godrsquos mission if they ignore these voices Majority World

and indigenous churches oen have extraordinary missional vitality Openness

to other voices needs to happen now It is time for Western churches theol-

ogies and mission to mature and to reflect Godrsquos global mission

In this book I could have consulted the work of many thousands of in-

digenous and Majority World thinkers and writers and practitioners But I

have limited myself to a sample of those who speak directly to its themes

Tese African Asian Eastern European Middle Eastern Caribbean Latin

American First Nation and indigenous thinkers challenge us Tey dare us

to examine our theologies and missions and churches And they inspire us

to renew the worship and community and mission of Jesusrsquo church Tey

stir us to think in fresh ways about what it means to be salt light and a city

Tey help us become a global missional churchmdasha truly GlobalChurch

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1536

PA R T O N E

S A L TReshaping Our Conversations

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1636

G L O C A L I Z I N G

C O N V E R S A T I O N S

H983151983159 D983151 W983141 D983141983158983141983148983151983152

G983148983151983139983137983148 C983151983150983158983141983154983155983137983156983145983151983150983155983103

Rather than taking one contextual version of the Gospel and imposing

it as the Gospel throughout the world via the missionary enterprise

the shapers of Mission as ransformation have recognized the

plurality of localities that has created an intercontextual

ldquopan-localrdquo global phenomenon in theology

AL IZON

The International Society for Urban Mission (ISUM) is a group of urban

missionaries who are passionate about cultivating hope and love and re-newal in cities Irsquove connected with this group for some years ISUM held its

first annual Summit on Integral Urban Mission in Bangkok Tailand Te

team from Urban Neighbours of Hope (UNOH) under the leadership of

my Australian friends Ash and Anj Barker organized much of the summit

UNOH teams covenant with God and each other to ldquolive out our passion for

loving God and neighbour Focus on releasing neighbourhoods from urban

poverty Grow through equipping each other neighbours and the broader

church to radically follow Jesus and join Godrsquos Kingdom coming UNOH

workers live and serve in small responsive neighbourhood-based teamsrdquo983089

1See wwwunohorg

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1736

10486261048628 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

Tis summit involved interactive participatory hands-on immersion op-

portunities keynotes lectures and workshops Keynote speakers came from

Africa Australia Myanmar New Zealand North America the PhilippinesSouth America Tailand and First Nations A few hundred Majority World

and Western thinkers and activists came together for those days Tey explored

the theology and practices of integral transformational and urban mission

Tese thinkers and activists pursued a range of aims1048626 Tis included col-

laboration between urban Christians from a variety of backgrounds (Ma-

jority World and Western theologians activists ecumenicals Pentecostals

evangelicals colleges church movements and development agencies) Teyaimed for collective action and thought in an international and integral

context Tey sought to gain mutual understanding for a comprehensive

picture of urban mission around the globe Tey encouraged information

sharing and best practicesmdashlearning from our mistakes and seeking solu-

tions Tey developed recommendations and calls to action to the broader

church Working groups wrote briefing papers aer each summit based on

key issues in urban mission And they endeavored to build trust wisdomand inspiration to better engage our new urban world

Majority World and Western leaders participated in discussion prayer

integral mission and working groups Te goal was to grapple with key issues

and ask key questions How do we recruit equip and sustain urban mission

today How do we release church movements among the urban poor How

can we immerse ourselves in and transform urban neighborhoods How do

we empower urban children and young people How does the church serve

and liberate the oppressedmdashand others suffering from urban injustice What

needs to happen for poorer urban centers to develop economically socially

and spiritually How do we join God in the challenges and opportunities of

multifaith cities

Workshops included urban gardening child protection and collaborating

with local churches in urban mission Workshops also included organic

church growth and mission as well as developing NGO and government

partnerships Groups considered the good the bad and the ugly of short-

term urban mission teams

2Tese aims are detailed at ldquoInternational Society or Urban Mission Summitrdquo httpnewurbanworld

orgsummit

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1836

Glocalizing Conversations 10486261048629

Te summit was a thrilling example of how Majority World and Western

leaders can cooperate It was a time to come together in an environment of

mutual learning and enrichment It was a window into how local contextsand global themes can enrich each other Tis resulted from ISUMrsquos com-

mitment to ldquosolidarity fellowship and insight between urban Christian

leaders in the Western and Majority Worldsrdquo

Te summit was a success due to ISUMrsquos core values What are they983091 Christ-

honoring urban mission values bottom-up grassroots perspectivesmdashrather

than top-down distanced perspectives It allows local theology to reveal new

insights and perspectives about Godrsquos activity It shares insights and experi-ences through narratives embedded within urban poor communities and cities

It cultivates ongoing practical and personal solidarity with the worldrsquos urban

poor Tis Spirit-empowered urban mission honors networks relationships

and partnerships It sees such relationships as the primary method of serving

together It listens to and amplifies the voices of the urban poormdashespecially

those from the Majority World and in particular the 1048625104862410486281048624 window cities It is

attentive to signs of the kingdom of God Urban mission that glorifies God iswilling to reflect and respond with active and sacrificial commitment It shares

and extends the life of the body of Christ among the urban poor

Tis summit was a milestone in urban missiology It enriched communi-

cation between Western and Majority World thinker-activists Tis resulted

from the aims and values Irsquove mentioned Effective urban mission needs to

be a conversation on many levels It is attentive to context and immersed in

local settings It appreciates global and universal missional themes It culti-

vates dialogue between these local-global (glocal) realities It involves

mutual learning between Western and Majority World thinker-activists

Moreover solidarity between all parties is a defining feature Tis solidarity

is due to a compelling vision of the kingdom of God

Tese collaborative glocal features of the ISUM urban mission summit

in Bangkok are critical for the aims of this book GlobalChurch

Majority World indigenous and Western leaders thinkers and churches

can stretch and enrich each other But they need to be open and attentive to

each other Tey need learning postures and open hearts and minds Tey

3ldquoAbout ISUMrdquo httpnewurbanworldorgabout

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1936

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2036

Glocalizing Conversations 10486261048631

always rooted in the local and particularmdashas local churches embody the

gospel and witness to Christ Tese churches forge their own theological

understandings as they do mission together Tey engage in transformationalpractices among the people in their settings Tey enjoy worship mission

and community in their local and particular context Ideally the result is

unique contextual theologies and missions

Simultaneously global conversations form Tey form because of this

multitude of local theologies and practices Local conversations inform and

enrich other local conversations catalyzing global themes and voices izon

observes that the global ldquoowes its existence to local contexts Sharedconvictions among the theologies and practices of local contextual realities

give shape to its global dimensionsrdquo1048629

Majority World indigenous and Western theologies are equally contextual

Tey are equally culture bound Tey are equally particular to their time and

location At times they are all enlightened or myopic liberating or con-

straining humanizing or objectifying beautiful or offensive prophetic or

tepid Te local particular and cultural shape all these theologies Converselythese particular theologies feed and influence global conversations Tere is

no place then for ethnocentrism colonialism or elitism Tere is no place

for theological missional cultural or institutionalized arrogance

Multiple local contexts and voices come togethermdashintentionally or notmdashto

form global themes and theologies Conversely these global realities shape

local contexts oday local contexts must grapple with ldquoan emerging global

culture ie the interacting realities of modernity postmodernity and the

phenomenon of globalizationrdquo1048630 Hence the interdependent and symbiotic

relationship between the localparticular and the globaluniversal We call this

interdependent relationship between the local and the global glocalization

Te global church needs a thrilling glocal exchange We need one that we

characterize by mutuality respect partnership and symbiosis Such ex-

change helps Majority World indigenous and Western churches learn from

each other It enables them to pursue missional theology and practice o-

gether the church becomes a ldquocity on a hillrdquo

5Ibid 10486259830886Ibid 9830961048628

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2136

10486261048632 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

W983144983137983156 R983141983153983157983145983154983141983155 G983148983151983139983137983148983145983162983137983156983145983151983150983103

Te glocal exchange described above needs to be broader than transforma-

tional mission Tis is necessary if the church is to develop a robust inter-cultural and glocal missional ecclesiology

In my first book Salt Light and a City I outlined the foundational

themes of missional ecclesiology983095 Majority World and Western leaders

need to engage these themes in local and contextual ways Teir insights can

then enrich global conversations Tese global conversations in turn shape

local understandings and practices Tis way a glocal appreciation of these

themes emergesLocal regional and global theologies and practices are thereby enriched

Te church becomes healthier and more missionalmdasha truer expression of

the kingdom Te church becomes a fuller witness to Christ his passion for

the nations and his ability to bring unity in diversity

Stephen Bevans and Roger Schroeder outline the six constants of mission

Tese are our theologies about Jesus the church the end times salvation

human nature and culture Bevans and Schroeder describe the relationshipbetween these six and their historical cultural and theological contexts Tis is

why they call these six constants in context Our understanding of these six

constants develops in relation to local and global movements Sometimes local

voices influence our understandings of these six Other times it is regional or

global voices For all of us local regional and global influences are at play at

once Collectively they form our appreciation of the six constants of mission1048632

Here are eight theological themes that the church can develop through

processes of glocalization I presented these in my book Salt Light and a City

Tey are vital to the churchrsquos health mission community and future We

could add many other themes to these eight but these will suffice for now1048633

Scripture Te Scriptures are the infallible authoritative Word of God

Christrsquos Spirit has inspired them Tey have absolute and final authority in

all aspects of corporate and individual faith ethics conduct and witness

Christians interpret and apply Scripture in local contexts and in particular

7Graham Hill Salt Light and a City Introducing Missional Ecclesiology (Eugene OR Wip and

Stock 9830909830881048625983090) 10486251048628983097-983090104863110486288Stephen B Bevans and Roger Schroeder Constants in Context A Teology o Mission or oday

American Society o Missiology Series (Maryknoll NY Orbis 9830909830889830881048628) part one9Tese points first appeared in my book Salt Light and a City xxii-xxiv

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2236

Glocalizing Conversations 10486261048633

social settings Conversely we learn from the interpretations and readings

of other groups

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our local- global theology of Scripture and biblical interpretation

Evangelicalism Pentecostalism missional movements and so forth I

have charismatic missional and evangelical convictions Glocal conversa-

tions help me understand and practice these convictions better

I will use evangelicalism as an example Michael Horton says that our

beliefs and practices are evangelical when they are ldquocommitted to the suffi-

ciency of Scripture the priesthood of all believers the total lostness ofhumans the sole mediation of Christ the gracious efficacy and finality of

Godrsquos redemptive work in Christ through election propitiation calling and

keeping Te linchpin for all of this was the doctrine of justification by grace

alone through faith alone because of Christ alonerdquo9830891048624

Such convictions are necessary if we are to be faithful to the gospel and

to a biblical vision of church and mission Te gospel defines Godrsquos purposes

for humanity the church and the universe Te triune God controls thechurch He is its Lord and Savior Sanctifier and Liberator Master and King

He is completely sovereign over its nature affairs mission and history God

is the churchrsquos only source of grace election atonement salvation and per-

severance Te churchrsquos justification and hope are by grace alone through

faith alone by Christ alone

Herersquos the challenge I face My understanding of evangelicalism is

Western I am a product of the Western theological tradition and my Western

evangelical heritage Much of this is wonderful But I need indigenous and

Majority World evangelicals and others to help me expand and reshape

these insights Te same would be true if I were a Pentecostal

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of our theological traditions and convictions

Jesus Christ We must center our theology on Jesus Christ the Lord of

the church Te church needs to reflect on the person and work of Christ

and respond to him Tis means gathering and going in the name and power

of Christ It means allowing Christrsquos Spirit to shape our community and

10Michael Horton ldquoEvangelical Arminiansrdquo Modern Reormation 1048625 no 1048627 (1048625983097983097983090) 10486251048631

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2336

10486271048624 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

identity and mission It means developing our Christology ecclesiology and

missiology concurrently Te early church developed these three areas and

more in a concurrent and integrated way Tere was no linear progressionTe same is true in the contemporary global church

How can the glocal church best explore its nature structure mission and

hope Trough the centrality and the lordship of Christ

Majority World and indigenous Christians help us appreciate Jesus and

his mission afresh Tey show us how Jesus identifies with the marginalized

outcast oppressed rejected and broken He prefers them We find him

among ldquothe least of theserdquoGlocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of who Jesus Christ is How does it help us appreciate him better

What has Jesus done for and in his church and his world What does he care

about What individual and corporate responsibilities has he given us How

do we express these at local regional and global levels

Te Spirit Missional ecclesiology is inadequate without pneumatological

foundations In other words our theology of church and Spirit go togetherTe Spirit creates and animates the church He empowers it to witness to

Jesus and his gospel Te Spirit enables the church to be a missional trans-

formational community He shapes the church into an alternative society

embodying the reign of God Te church exists for the glory and mission of

Christ Te power and presence of the Spirit enables this mission worship

and glorification

Te Spirit pours out gis on the local-global church ldquofor the common

goodrdquo and ldquoto equip his people for works of service so that the body of Christ

may be built uprdquo Tis includes but isnrsquot limited to the ministry gis mani-

festation gis and motivational gis (1048625 Cor 104862510486261048631 Eph 104862810486251048625-10486251048626 Rom 104862510486261048630-1048632)

Te Spirit forms the glocal church He empowers it for service and

witness He fills it with Christrsquos empowering presence He leads it into the

missio Deimdashthe mission of the Father Son and Holy Spirit

Recently Pentecostal and renewalist movements have grown dramati-

cally in the Majority World Tey have increased in status size and influence

Many have matured theologically Te churches of the West must take notice

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of the power and presence of the Spirit

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2436

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048625

Te rinity Tere are clear limitations to the analogy between the

church and the rinity Te church can only image the rinity Yet the

church is at its best when it reflects the relational and missional passionof the rinity

What is the source and inspiration of the churchrsquos local-global mission

Ultimately it is the missional nature passion and actions of the Father Son

and Holy Spirit Godrsquos nature is missional His passion is infectious His

actions are historical redemptive and eternal Te rinity invites the

church into a sending community Te Father sends the Son Te Father

and Son send the Spirit Finally the rinity sends the church in missioninto the world

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of the rinity How does it enable our participation in the mission

and community of the triune God

Association and dialogue Tese need to happen across denominational

cultural ethnic gender and theological traditions and divides Authentic

dialogue is indispensable to the health and mission of the church What dothose marginal to the life of the church have to say to us What do ldquoothersrdquo

have to teach us Other ethnicities and cultures Other socioeconomic

groups Other ages and genders Other theological and confessing tradi-

tions Other persons from times long gone

We need to listen Share Be vulnerable Be authentic Open up to crit-

icism correction and change

We need more than dialogue We need communion and association It is

possible in a qualified way to say that God is present in all the various forms

of the church (ie the various theological ecclesiological sociocultural his-

torical and other permutations of the church) We discern this presence

through attention to Scripture history tradition culture and the Spirit Dis-

cernment involves critical dialogue theological exchange biblical study and

real relationship Only the Spirit of Jesus can enable this

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of association and dialogue

Mission and the missio Dei Te church is missional at its core It serves

obeys and images a missionary God David Bosch says ldquoTe churchrsquos mission

is not secondary to its being the church exists in being sent and in building up

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2536

10486271048626 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

itself for its missionrdquo He goes on to say ldquoEcclesiology does not precede missi-

ology there cannot be church without an intrinsic missionary dimensionrdquo983089983089

Jesus is Lord Lord of his church and Lord of his world His mission de-termines and forms the church His mission shapes the nature purposes

structures ministries and activities of his church Majority World and in-

digenous thinkers help us understand the implications of this mission Tey

help us form glocal theologies of mission Tey reveal ldquomission in context

as transformationrdquo9830891048626

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of mission and the missio Dei Church theology and practice Glocal conversations can inform and

enrich many aspects of the church (when practiced well) Teologies and

practices benefit from robust and critical glocal conversations Tese con-

versations enrich many areas (community spirituality discipleship liturgy

worship hospitality eco-justice education social ethics servantship lib-

eration place suffering beauty and so on)

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-standing of these many dimensions of church and mission

Glocal processes shape these eight themes and their practices We need

to facilitate and enable these conversations and processes Tis is urgent It

must be a priority No theology of mission or missional ecclesiology is ad-

equate without glocal conversations983089983091

T983144983141 L983151983139983137983148 983137983150983140 G983148983151983138983137983148 E983150983154983145983139983144 E983137983139983144 O983156983144983141983154

Glocalization takes the localparticular context and globaluniversal themes

seriously Contextual and global conversations enter an enriching and in-

forming relationship Tese two always have an active and symbiotic rela-

tionship Tis is true whether we deliberately put them into conversation or

not Te local shapes the global and the global shapes the local Many local

11David J Bosch Believing in the Future oward a Missiology o Western Culture (New York

rinity 1048625983097983097983093) 104862798309012izon ransormation Afer Lausanne 1048631-98309713Not all o these themes are dealt with in this present volume since either (1048625) I have dealt with them

in my book Salt Light and a City (983090) they are not all key themes in the writings o the thirty-five

Majority World thinkers considered in this volume or (1048627) there is not adequate space in a book

this size

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2636

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048627

voices converge to form global conversations and theologies Using the Phil-

ippines as a case study izon illustrates this by showing the interdepen-

dence between local and global themes in mission983089983092Dialogue between local and global conversations is critical Kōsuke

Koyama wrote an important book on contextual mission called Water Buffalo

Teology Koyama is a Japanese missionary who served in Chiang Mai

Tailand He writes of the joys and challenges of doing local particular water

buffalo theology He considers the relationship between local theology global

missional themes and transforming cultures ldquoWater Buffalo Teology sees

certain specific challenges Contextualization of theology implies two criticalmovements First to articulate Jesus Christ in culturally appropriate com-

municatively apt words and second to criticize reform dethrone or oppose

culture if it is found to be against what the name of Jesus Christ stands forrdquo9830891048629

Kōsuke Koyama challenges us to recognize what we bring to the task of

local theology For him it was doing theology in Tailand while being Jap-

anese We also need to notice the particular culture wersquore located in as we do

the work of theology Tis means we avoid speaking of an ldquoAsian theologyrdquoldquoAfrican theologyrdquo and the like We need to cultivate local theologies that

engage regional and global themes But these theologies must be ldquodistinctly

localrdquo and a ldquotheology from belowrdquo9830891048630

Simultaneously we need to pursue a reformation of theology and

practice ldquoin the global contextrdquo Tis means entering ldquothe disturbing spa-

ciousness of Jesus Christrdquo Jesus calls us to reject enmity and exceptionalism

We seem him present in our culture language stories and relationships

But we also choose to embrace the ldquootherrdquo We choose to see him present

in other culturesmdashshaping a global people to serve and worship him

joining in his mission983089983095

Kōsuke Koyama roots the gospel in the local contextual and particular

Tis is why he roots his water buffalo theology in Northern Tai culture He

is careful not to say ldquoHere is how you contextualize in your settingrdquo Instead

14izon ransormation Afer Lausanne 1048631-10486251048627 10486251048628983097-98309098308898309015Kōsuke Koyama Water Buffalo Teology 983090983093th anniversary ed (Maryknoll NY Orbis 1048625983097983097983097)

xiii-xv16Kōsuke Koyama ldquoTe Asian Approach to Christrdquo Missiology 1048625983090 no 1048628 (10486259830979830961048628) 10486281048627983093-104862798309617Kōsuke Koyama ldquoReormation in the Global Context Te Disturbing Spaciousness o Jesus Christrdquo

Currents in Teology and Mission 1048627983088 no 983090 (9830909830889830881048627) 10486251048625983097-983090983096

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2736

10486271048628 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

he tells us a story Itrsquos the story of how he contextualized theology in northern

Tailand while being open to global conversations Koyama asks us to form

our own local expressions of church mission and theology At the same timewe must stay attentive to what God is saying and doing beyond that context

Tis way local and global and particular and universal become mutually

enriching conversation partners

G983148983151983139983137983148983145983162983137983156983145983151983150 983137983150983140 H983145983155983156983151983154983145983139983137983148983148983161 S983145983148983141983150983139983141983140 V983151983145983139983141983155

Glocal theologies and conversations pay attention to voices that powers in-

stitutions religions and societies have silenced R S Sugirtharajah pushesback a little on izonrsquos ideas Sugirtharajah says that the church should

privilege local conversations He emphasizes the local contextual and post-

colonial reading of biblical texts9830891048632

Te church needs to listen Te church ought to be attentive to the

theologies and biblical interpretations of groups that cultures and reli-

gions have ignored Historically powerful secular and religious forces

have silenced these groups Tey have marginalized oppressed and colo-nized them It is time for the church to address this injustice We must

start listening to important but silenced voices We need to privilege the

voices of the former victims of Western colonialism We need to develop

postcolonial biblical interpretations theologies and expressions of church

and mission

How do we take such perspectives seriously as we develop glocal conver-

sations How do these themes help us foster vital relationships between local

and global voices

It is time for us to embrace values that enable conversations with those

oen ignored by the church We need values that help us learn from these

groups and individuals

Valuing equal partnership Colonizing powers oppressed silenced and

colonized certain groups At times the church was complicit Tese colo-

nized groups have become ldquoconfident indomitable and indispensable

partners in the dialogue and collaboration with the dispossessed and disad-

18R S Sugirtharajah Asian Biblical Hermeneutics and Postcolonialism Contesting the Interpreta-

tions Te Bible and Liberation Series (Maryknoll NY Orbis 1048625983097983097983096) 1048625983093-1048625983094

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2836

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048629

vantaged in the Westrdquo9830891048633 Tis calls for attentiveness to these voices and re-

sponsiveness to their prophetic challenges It also demands a critical evalu-

ation of colonial readings of Scripture Colonial models of theology andchurch and mission are no longer the benchmark Te global church must

examine them afresh

Valuing equal status Tose on the margins have now taken their rightful

place on the global stage Tey have claimed appropriate and equal status at

the table Subaltern readings of theology church and mission are invaluable

contributors to global theological conversations Tis means that we esteem

them But we also test themWhat do we mean by subaltern Subalterns are those who are down-

trodden and silenced (or have been treated this way in the past) Dominant

or colonizing groups treat them as invisible nonentities Tey enjoy limited

or no access to power Sometimes these are women certain tribal and ethnic

groups and those considered ldquountouchablerdquo In Voices from the Margin Su-

girtharajah provides a platform for postcolonial subaltern readings of

Scripture and theology Tese readings challenge colonialmdashoen Westernmdashreadings of Bible and theology and cultures Tey claim equal status with

other ways of doing theology10486261048624

Valuing equal identity People groups need freedom to explore their new

and emerging identities Tese emerge in response to local and global influ-

ences Local culture is not the only thing at work here Global forces also

shape identity as do imported practices ideas readings rituals and tech-

nologies But each group should be free to explore and construct their par-

ticular forms of Christian identity

Valuing equal interpretations ldquoPostcolonialism is concerned with the

question of cultural and discursive dominationrdquo Colonialism led to op-

pressive and controlling forms of culture and discourse Tese were usually

not contextual or indigenous Western powers for instance brought co-

lonial forms of theology church biblical interpretation and mission1048626983089

Postcolonialism calls for alternative ways of approaching these things Tose

19Ibid 104862598309420R S Sugirtharajah Voices rom the Margin Interpreting the Bible in the Tird World (Maryknoll

NY Orbis 10486259830979830971048625)21Sugirtharajah Asian Biblical Hermeneutics and Postcolonialism 10486251048631

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2936

10486271048630 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

who were once marginalized oppressed and silenced need to lead these fresh

approaches in their own settings Tese then influence global conversations

We need to support the new readings and insights and experiments from thesegroups o be genuine this support must be both critical and collegial

Valuing equal empowerment Sugirtharajah says that postcolonialism is

valuable when it empowers actual communities and real people Post-

colonial thought empowers when it addresses the difficulties hopes and

experiences of ordinary people It should never be about power plays and

the clever use of language Itrsquos pointless if itrsquos obsessed with forming newmdash

and ldquocolonizingrdquomdashtheories Itrsquos a waste of time if itrsquos a self-indulgent pursuitof new and hybrid identities Rather ldquothe worth and credibility of post-

colonial criticism will be judged by how it orchestrates the unique and

fragile and imagined claims of one community against anotherrdquo Empow-

erment happens in a variety of ways One way is contributing equally to

global conversations10486261048626

Al izon examines postcolonialism in the Philippines He says that it can

teach the global church a lot about healthy local-global conversations Fil-ipino contextual theology resists many Western forms of mission and the-

ology It finds them patronizing and controlling Tis indigenous theology

values prophetic sociopolitical engagement in institutions and the society

at large It emphasizes ministry to whole persons and communities It con-

structs a Filipino theology of beauty and mission and worship and com-

munity And it fosters indigenous theological approaches to the spirit world

and cosmology

izon says that postcolonial theology has played a constructive role in

the Philippines But he is uncomfortable with the label postcolonialism He

prefers to describe historical events as ldquobeyond colonialismrdquo And he says

that global conversations enrich local theologies and vice versa1048626983091

Postcolonial thought informs our understanding of the relationship be-

tween the local and global It also shows how theology can emerge at the

intersection between the localparticular and the globaluniversal It re-

minds us that worthwhile glocalization listens to all voices Tis includes

heeding those that have been historically silenced

22Ibid 983090104862823izon ransormation Afer Lausanne 1048625983088983090 10486259830941048631-9830961048631

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3036

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048631

G983148983151983139983137983148983145983162983137983156983145983151983150 983137983150983140 983156983144983141 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

C983151983150983139983148983157983140983145983150983143 R983141983142983148983141983139983156983145983151983150983155

How do we go about developing a model for glocal conversations izon hasrecently provided a useful model that is instructive as we seek to learn from

the Majority World It has at least two key features

First the local is in the global (globalization from below) Global theologies

and ideas have origins in many particular local contexts In that sense glo-

balization is from below Global ideas have local roots Ideas about integral

mission liberation theology and missional church have local origins Tey

have their roots in the prayers hopes discoveries mission and theologiesof thousands of local communities ldquoTe global does not cannot exist

without the localmdashbut the coming together of localities creates a global re-

ality that becomes greater than the sum of its parts it creates a gestalt entity

to which localities make themselves accountablerdquo1048626983092

Second the global is in the local (panlocalization from above) Te con-

cerns and voices of multitudes of locales form global conversations Tese

global discussions can provide a ldquopositive accountabilityrdquo back to local con-texts Tis is true when they enrich affirm serve guide and strengthen local

contexts It is also true when they avoid homogenization control impo-

sition and judgment Glocalization is best when it sees itself as interde-

pendent deeply connected with the local10486261048629

Tatrsquos a helpful starting point But we need to go further Besides izonrsquos

proposals Irsquom convinced that robust glocal conversations cultivate six core

practices

983089 Glocal theology practices its values We root glocal theology in core

values Tese values include solidarity understanding and mutual learning

Do we value fellowship with Christians of all cultures Do we value learning

from them

We prove our values through our practices What practices emerge out of

these values We need to collaborate act collectively and share information

We must find ways to foster grassroots perspectives and local theologies We

need to share stories and learnings and cultivate networks relationships and

partnerships We need attentiveness to local voices and global themes We

24Ibid 9830901048625983088-1048625104862825Ibid 98309010486251048628-1048625983096

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3136

10486271048632 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

ought to find ways to put these local and global voices into conversation

Mutual learning humility and solidarity are key Worthwhile glocal con-

versations can never be merely theoretical or academic It is up to us to rootour values in our practices

983090 Glocal theology practices humility (and it tells a new narrative) We

have noted that the local is in the global and the global is in the local Te

two are interdependent Tey form each other reciprocally Since this is the

case we must practice humility Tere is no place for ethnocentrism colo-

nialism or theological and cultural arrogance I have seen these unhealthy

postures far too oen in Western settingsRecently I attended a missional leadership conference On that occasion

the keynote speakermdasha leading missional author and speakermdashsaid that

North American missional conversations and innovations hold the key to

the future of the Western church Tis Euro American view is wrong (Irsquom

being kind o be frank itrsquos complete nonsense) Itrsquos arrogant and Euro

Americanndashcentric And itrsquos completely out of step with what is happening in

the glocal church We need a new narrativeIn June 1048626104862410486251048627 Te Center for the Study of Global Christianity reported

the top 10486261048624 countries where Christianity has the highest percentage growth

rate Nineteen of the top twenty are in Asia and Africa Eleven of them are

in Muslim majority countries Not a single country from Europe or North

America makes the top twenty list10486261048630

Itrsquos time to cultivate a new narrative Te future of the church is emerging

from the Majority World Rather than North America the churches of

Eastern Asia Western Africa the Arabian Peninsula and other parts of the

Majority World reveal the future of the global church We need the contribu-

tions of all contexts Western indigenous and Majority World All con-

tribute to glocal conversations All are important as we learn from each

other about mission theology and faith But letrsquos stop pretending that North

Americans and Europeans will reveal the future of the global church Letrsquos

start listening to what God is saying about the future of the global church

And hersquos speaking to us through the churches of Asia Africa Latin America

26Russ Mitchell ldquoTe op 983090983088 Countries Where Christianity Is Growing the Fastestrdquo Disciple All

Nations (blog) August 983090983093 98309098308810486251048627 httpsdiscipleallnationswordpresscom98309098308810486251048627983088983096983090983093the-top

-983090983088-countries-where-christianity-is-growing-the-astest

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3236

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048633

Muslim majority settings and so on We must cultivate a new glocal nar-

rativemdashone soaked in humility

Glocal theology must be humble theology Meek theology Receptive the-ology Discerning theology Prayerful theology Dialogical theology De-

pendent theology A theology that celebrates the interdependence between

the localparticular and the globaluniversal

983091 Glocal theology practices expansiveness Glocalization is by nature

comprehensive Local and global influences permeate much of our lives Tese

glocal forces shape our theologies and churches whether we like it or not

But intentionality is also important We need to commit to an expansiveapproach to glocal theology How do we deliberately cultivate glocal conver-

sations in our biblical interpretation Do we foster them in our under-

standing of the person and work of Christ How does glocalization shape

the way the Spirit empowers and constitutes the church How can it form

our understanding of the nature and mission of the rinity How does it

influence the way we practice fellowship and conversation across denomi-

national cultural ethnic economic sociocultural political gender andtheological divides How might it shape our theologies of mission com-

munity beauty spirituality suffering discipleship hospitality eco-justice

place education social ethics Christian leadership and so forth

983092 Glocal theology practices attention Glocal theology doesnrsquot need to

accept all the assumptions or assertions of postcolonial or Majority World

thought But it does need to engage with them and take them seriously

Postcolonial theology for instance gives the marginalized and colonized

and forgotten and silenced both dignity and voice Our glocal conversations

must also include and esteem these groups We need to be attentive to

others weak and powerful female and male dominant and downtrodden

old and young rich and poor privileged and marginalized influential and

subaltern educated and illiterate We need to practice the art of attention

being especially attentive to those who are different to us

983093 Glocal theology practices embrace What do colonial ethnocentric or

Western-centric perspectives do Tey silence Tey control Tey com-

modify Tey institutionalize Tey colonize Tey domesticate Tey replace

Tey import Tey exclude Tey do these things to the beliefs experiences

and practices of other cultures A worthwhile glocal theology refuses to do

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3336

10486281048624 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

these things Instead it adopts a responsive humble celebratory open in-

clusive and embracing attitude

983094 Glocal theology practices discernment Finally we need discernmentas we engage these ideas and practices Discernment is a huge topic thatrsquos

hard to cover comprehensively in a few words Discernment happens when

the Spirit of Christ and his Word renew our minds Te Spirit grants us

spiritual wisdom as we meditate on him and his Word and as we practice

discipleship to Jesus Christ Romans 10486251048626 provides guidance we need (1048625) to be

transformed by the renewal of our minds (1048626) to serve Christrsquos body and (1048627)

to put love into action Discernment also happens in conversation both lo-cally and glocally

I pray these core values and six practices come across in the following

chapters of GlobalChurch

Glocalization can never be just theoretical Are we committed to moving

glocalization from an abstract idea to a living communion Are we deter-

mined to construct a missional theology of the church in the context of

glocal conversations Tis must involve dialogue between Majority Worldindigenous and Western scholars activists and groups

Will glocalization be an abstract notion Or will it be a formative and

genuine communion between local regional and global voices Glocal dy-

namics are at play whether we like it or not Teyrsquore in our churches the-

ologies and missions But we can choose to relinquish isolationist colonial

parochial and arrogant approaches Instead we can adopt responsive dia-

logical learning humble and embracing postures

Trough healthy approaches to glocalization the Spirit challenges us to

value local contexts We immerse ourselves in local and particular commu-

nities and conversations He inspires us to open ourselves to global theo-

logical conversations He rouses us to value the symbiotic relationship be-

tween the localparticular and the globaluniversal

Trough glocal relationships the Spirit leads us to put local contextual

theologies into conversation with global ones He prompts us to explore the

ways in which the local is in the glocal and the global is in the local He per-

suades us to pursue collaboration and dialogue and mutual learning We

engage with Christians from different backgrounds and cultures ecumen-

icals Pentecostals evangelicals and so on from Western indigenous and

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3436

Glocalizing Conversations 10486281048625

Majority World contexts He motivates us to express solidarity between all

parties We appreciate our unity in diversity

Trough glocal conversations the Spirit moves us to ensure that unity andsolidarity emerge from a compelling vision of Jesusrsquo kingdom and gospel

and person He challenges us to share information theology and practices

He urges us to learn from each othermdashour successes and mistakes We seek

glocal solutions

Te Spirit calls us to develop glocal conversations about Christian ideas

and practices Tese include Scripture Evangelicalism ecumenism Pente-

costalism Jesus Christ the Holy Spirit God the Father the rinity com-munity spirituality discipleship liturgy worship hospitality prayer eco-

justice education social ethics Christian leadership gospel and culture

beauty place suffering liberation and so forth

Finally through glocal conversations the Spirit leads us to adopt a new

posture Tis is a responsive humble celebratory open inclusive and em-

bracing attitude to the ldquootherrdquo We do this as a new people made up of every

tribe and language and people and nationTere are dangers in glocalization Sugirtharajah warns of the commodi-

fication of local contextual practices and theologies When this happens

they are ldquosmoothed out of their primary contexts concerns and contesta-

tions travel across borders and become objects of analysis and scrutiny

within an alien secondary contextrdquo1048626983095

Itrsquos common for those of us who are Western to make mistakes when we

wrestle with Majority World and indigenous ideas Sugirtharajah mentions

our tendency to commodify reduce and institutionalize these ideas We also

risk doing these things (1048625) We apply them in noncontextual prescriptive ways

(1048626) We ignore their meanings in their original setting (1048627) We glamorize or

idealize their proponents or their contexts (1048628) We demonize those persons or

contexts (1048629) We disregard them as irrelevant rhetorical or minority discourse

Kevin J Vanhoozer says that we can fall into three traps when we glo-

calize theology (1048625) We can underestimate the theological significance of

local cultures (1048626) We can homogenize cultures and theologies exaggerating

27R S Sugirtharajah ldquoextual ake-Aways Tird World exts in Western Metropolitan Centresrdquo

Black Teology in Britain A Journal o Contextual Praxis 983090 (1048625983097983097983097) 10486271048627 10486271048631 Edward W Said Te

World the ext and the Critic (Cambridge MA Harvard University Press 10486259830979830961048627) 9830901048627983097

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3536

10486281048626 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

ldquothe onerdquo (1048627) We can overemphasize cultural particularity exaggerating ldquothe

manyrdquo and pursue ldquotheological ethnificationrdquo10486261048632

My hope is that GlobalChurch does not fall into the traps Sugirtharajahand Vanhoozer describe I hope that what unfolds in the following chapters

is respectful and discerning I hope it leads to further mutually enriching

conversations between people of different cultures

You the reader face the same challenges You face them in your personal

life ministry context and missional engagements

Will you treat the themes in this book as abstract theoretical notions

Will this be a temporary infatuation a flirtation with the ldquootherrdquo that dissi-pates as suddenly as it arrived Or will glocal conversations become an en-

riching and formative orientation in your life Will glocal conversations

bring fresh approaches to theology faith mission church and worship Will

conversations with other cultures and theologies become for you a com-

pelling way of life

My prayer is that glocal conversations will help the church be a global

visible alternative ldquocity set upon a hillrdquo a truly GlobalChurch

28Craig Ott and Harold A Netland Globalizing Teology Belie and Practice in an Era o World

Christianity (Grand Rapids Baker Academic 983090983088983088983094) 1048625983090983093

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3636

Page 10: GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1036

10486251048630 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

and nation Te church must cultivate a distinct social existence shaping its

community and mission around its commitment to plurality and diversity

and unity1048632 God calls his church to be a global and missional ldquocity on a hillrdquoTis is a church constituted and enriched and represented by Western and

indigenous and Majority World peoples

Tose of us in the West need a new narrative Itrsquos time to abandon our

flawed Eurocentric and Americentric worldviews We need a new global

and missional narrative and for that we must turn to the churches of Ma-

jority World and indigenous cultures Tey can help us explore what it

means to be a global missional community Many Christian communitiesin Majority World and indigenous contexts have been wrestling with these

issues for generations Marginalization and persecution and alienation have

been their lot Yet somehow in spite of or because of that they have flour-

ished In fact theyrsquove grown exponentially

So whom am I talking about when I refer to Majority World and indig-

enous Christians Majority World Christians are those in Africa Asia the

Caribbean Eastern Europe Latin America the Middle East and Oceania

1048633

I use the term Majority World because the majority of the worldrsquos population

is in those cultures today Te majority of the church is in those cultures too

I donrsquot use the terms non-Western or Tird World or Developing World Tese

terms use Western cultures as their point of reference Tey imply Western

8Barry A Harvey Another City An Ecclesiological Primer or a Post-Christian World (New York

rinity 1048625983097983097983097) 9830901048627-9830909830939I donrsquot deal with the diasporas in this book For example Irsquove made no mention o Hispanic

Portuguese or Asian minorities in the United States United Kingdom Canada Europe Austra-lia and so on Irsquom aware that right now Latin American and Chinese diasporas are active in

evangelism and mission in Europe in the same way in which the Filipino or the Salvadoran dias-

poras carry on mission in the United States Irsquove chosen not to include voices rom the diasporas

mainly because there are so many worthy contributors in that group and I donrsquot have the space

to treat them well in this book In the uture I hope that I (or someone else) will write a book

exploring what we can learn rom the diasporas Hispanic minorities or example are making

significant contributions to the theological and missiological conversation in the United States

that are relevant to this subject Methodist historian Justo L Gonzaacutelez and Pentecostal theologian

Eldin Villaantildee are examples In Mantildeana Gonzaacutelez describes the shape and orm o a theology

developed in the Hispanic margin o the United States In Out o Every ribe and Nation he shows

what would be implied in listening to minorities within a denominational setting Villaantildeersquos Te

Liberating Spirit is a milestone in the reflection about the relationship between pneumatology and

social ethics See Justo L Gonzaacutelez Out o Every ribe and Nation Christian Teology at the

Ethnic Roundtable (Nashville Abingdon 1048625983097983097983090) Gonzaacutelez Mantildeana Christian Teology rom a

Hispanic Perspective (Nashville Abingdon 1048625983097983097983088) Eldin Villaantildee Te Liberating Spirit oward

an Hispanic American Pentecostal Social Ethic (Grand Rapids Eerdmans 10486259830979830971048627)

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1136

Introduction 10486251048631

superiority or centricity Te term Global South is too limiting given the

breadth of the group I am engaging Majority World seems to work best

In 1048626104862410486241048628 Te Lausanne Forum for World Evangelization in PattayaTailand voted unanimously that the phrase Majority World Church replace

other terms People from all over the globe participated in this forum

imothy C ennent agrees that this is the best phrase ldquoIt helps to highlight

the basic point that Africa Asia and Latin America are where the majority

of the worldrsquos Christians are now locatedrdquo9830891048624 I expand the phrase Majority

World beyond Africa Asia and Latin America to include the Caribbean

Eastern Europe Oceania and the Middle EastIndigenous and First Nations peoples are ldquothose ethnic groups that were

indigenous to a territory prior to being incorporated into a national state

and who are politically and culturally separate from the majority ethnic

identity of the state that they are a part ofrdquo Tis includes people groups like

the Australian Aborigines and American Indians983089983089

Te aim of this book is to help Western churches rediscover what it means

to be salt light and a city by engaging in global missional conversations odo this Western Christians need to enter into conversation with Majority

World and indigenous Christians Listening to others helps us grow in our

understanding and practice of mission and church and theology For far too

long wersquove marginalized or ignored Majority World and indigenous voices

We must truly become a GlobalChurch

Tis aim shapes the bookrsquos structure as summarized below

P983137983154983156 1048625 S983137983148983156 R983141983155983144983137983152983145983150983143 O983157983154 C983151983150983158983141983154983155983137983156983145983151983150983155

ldquoYou are the salt of the earth But if the salt loses its saltiness how can it be made

salty again It is no longer good for anything except to be thrown out and

trampled underfootrdquo Globally and locally you are the salt of the earth Be salt

Salt preserves seasons flavors and purifies We are salt when we glorify

the Father Son and Holy Spirit in our mission worship faith hope truth

and love We are salt when we reject a Eurocentric or Americentric vision

10imothy C ennent Teology in the Context o World Christianity How the Global Church Is

Influencing the Way We Tink About and Discuss Teology (Grand Rapids Zondervan 9830909830889830881048631) xx11Douglas Sanders ldquoIndigenous Peoples Issues o Definitionrdquo International Journal o Cultural

Property 983096 no 1048625 (1048625983097983097983097) 1048628

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1236

10486251048632 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

of the church and become the global missional church Christ envisioned

In part one I show how Western conversations are impoverished and

insufficient in isolation from indigenous and Majority World Christians Weenhance our ldquosaltinessrdquo through local-global ( glocal ) exchanges o do this

we must reshape our conversations We need global and local exchanges that

we characterize by mutuality respect partnership and symbiosis Such ex-

changes help us learn from each other whether wersquore in Western indig-

enous or Majority World settings It helps us stay ldquosaltyrdquo It enables us to

pursue global missional theology and practice Globally and locally we can

pursue missional vitality and truly be ldquothe salt of the earthrdquo

P983137983154983156 1048626 L983145983143983144983156 R983141983150983141983159983145983150983143 O983157983154 M983145983155983155983145983151983150

ldquoYou are the light of the world A city on a hill cannot be hidden Neither do

people light a lamp and put it under a bowl Instead they put it on its stand and

it gives light to everyone in the house In the same way let your light shine

before others that they may see your good deeds and glorify your Father in

heavenrdquo (Mt 104862910486251048628-10486251048631) Globally and locally you are the light of the world Be lightLight illuminates reveals and dispels darkness Te church is light when

it does good deedsmdashhealing and liberating and redemptive deeds Itrsquos light

when its being and faith and deeds bring glorify to the Father Te church

is light when it participates in Godrsquos redemptive mission in the world as a

global missional community

o do this we must renew our mission In part two I explore how indig-

enous and Majority World Christians teach us to renew mission We renew

mission through contextualization liberation hospitality Spirit empow-

erment creation care ethics and the transformation of neighborhoods

P983137983154983156 1048627 C983145983156983161 R983141983158983145983156983137983148983145983162983145983150983143 O983157983154 C983144983157983154983139983144983141983155

You are a city set on a hill ldquoA city on a hill cannot be hiddenrdquo Globally and

locally you are a city set on a hill Be a city set on a hill

Tis means that we are an alternative and countercultural movement We

have a distinct culture and politic and social existence We are a people

gathered from every tribe language people and nation We are in the world

but not of the world We are in the world but distinct from the world We are

within the world and for the sake of the world

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1336

Introduction 10486251048633

o be this kind of alternative city or culture we must renew our mission

community ethics and worship We need to pursue the revitalization of our

churches so that they are distinct And by distinct I mean an alternative city(altera civitas)

We are a ldquocity on a hillrdquo that witnesses to Jesus Christ and his eternal kingdom

when we are a global missional church In part three I demonstrate how indig-

enous and Majority World Christians teach us to revitalize churches We revi-

talize churches by indigenizing faith devouring Scripture renewing education

practicing servantship (servant leadership) recovering community and devel-

oping spirituality and discipleship We inspire our churches when we developour theology and practices relating to beauty and the arts9830891048626

In the final chapter I wrap things up by addressing an important question

In light of all the material covered in this book what would it now look like

to engage in global missional theology ecclesiology interpretation history

pneumatology worship and education

Herersquos how you can get the most out of this book

Community You can read this book alone in a small group with somefriends at home or at a coffee shop or as part of a ministry team However

you get a lot more out of this book when you read it with others ogether

you can think about the bookrsquos implications What do the chapters mean for

your ministry church agency family or team

GlobalChurch Project video series Irsquove made a video series to go along with

this book Appendix one has the details

Study guide Yoursquoll get a lot more out of this book if you spend time

working through the study guide in appendix two ry to do this in a group

Te study guide includes reflection questions suggested practices and

Further Reading

Characters As you read this book yoursquoll come across names and people

yoursquove never heard of before For a glimpse of who they are and what issues

concern them see appendix three

My website o help you get the most out of this book Irsquove included more

resources on my website TeGlobalChurchProjectcom Tese include

videos reading lists important links a glossary and other resources Irsquove

12Irsquove put a separate chapter on the theme o beauty and the arts on my website Itrsquos additional to

this book

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1436

10486261048624 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

also provided ways that you can contact me See appendix four

In my first book Salt Light and a City I developed a missional theology

of the church I did this in conversation with twelve theologians from the fourmajor Christian traditions Tat volume offered a window into the thought of

European and American theologians It showed how they are making sense

of the nature and mission of the church in their Western cultural context

Te book that yoursquore now reading takes a different approach I have

stepped away from European and American voices I now ask What can

those in the Majority World and indigenous cultures teach us in the West

What can they teach us about the churchrsquos mission worship theology andcommunity Te quality and quantity of material coming out of the Ma-

jority World is astonishing Any theology that ignores the insights of indig-

enous and Majority World Christians is deficient and impoverished

White middle-class European North American tertiary-educated men

dominate Western theology Tey dominate the Western missional conver-

sation I know I fit that profile Tis group still monopolizes missional church

conferences and seminars Tey get all the book contracts In fact this groupstill controls theology and the church in many settings But this is changing

New voices are rising Tese include women minorities the poor indigenous

groups and Majority World leaders Missional conversations arenrsquot attentive

to the Spirit and to Godrsquos mission if they ignore these voices Majority World

and indigenous churches oen have extraordinary missional vitality Openness

to other voices needs to happen now It is time for Western churches theol-

ogies and mission to mature and to reflect Godrsquos global mission

In this book I could have consulted the work of many thousands of in-

digenous and Majority World thinkers and writers and practitioners But I

have limited myself to a sample of those who speak directly to its themes

Tese African Asian Eastern European Middle Eastern Caribbean Latin

American First Nation and indigenous thinkers challenge us Tey dare us

to examine our theologies and missions and churches And they inspire us

to renew the worship and community and mission of Jesusrsquo church Tey

stir us to think in fresh ways about what it means to be salt light and a city

Tey help us become a global missional churchmdasha truly GlobalChurch

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1536

PA R T O N E

S A L TReshaping Our Conversations

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1636

G L O C A L I Z I N G

C O N V E R S A T I O N S

H983151983159 D983151 W983141 D983141983158983141983148983151983152

G983148983151983139983137983148 C983151983150983158983141983154983155983137983156983145983151983150983155983103

Rather than taking one contextual version of the Gospel and imposing

it as the Gospel throughout the world via the missionary enterprise

the shapers of Mission as ransformation have recognized the

plurality of localities that has created an intercontextual

ldquopan-localrdquo global phenomenon in theology

AL IZON

The International Society for Urban Mission (ISUM) is a group of urban

missionaries who are passionate about cultivating hope and love and re-newal in cities Irsquove connected with this group for some years ISUM held its

first annual Summit on Integral Urban Mission in Bangkok Tailand Te

team from Urban Neighbours of Hope (UNOH) under the leadership of

my Australian friends Ash and Anj Barker organized much of the summit

UNOH teams covenant with God and each other to ldquolive out our passion for

loving God and neighbour Focus on releasing neighbourhoods from urban

poverty Grow through equipping each other neighbours and the broader

church to radically follow Jesus and join Godrsquos Kingdom coming UNOH

workers live and serve in small responsive neighbourhood-based teamsrdquo983089

1See wwwunohorg

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1736

10486261048628 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

Tis summit involved interactive participatory hands-on immersion op-

portunities keynotes lectures and workshops Keynote speakers came from

Africa Australia Myanmar New Zealand North America the PhilippinesSouth America Tailand and First Nations A few hundred Majority World

and Western thinkers and activists came together for those days Tey explored

the theology and practices of integral transformational and urban mission

Tese thinkers and activists pursued a range of aims1048626 Tis included col-

laboration between urban Christians from a variety of backgrounds (Ma-

jority World and Western theologians activists ecumenicals Pentecostals

evangelicals colleges church movements and development agencies) Teyaimed for collective action and thought in an international and integral

context Tey sought to gain mutual understanding for a comprehensive

picture of urban mission around the globe Tey encouraged information

sharing and best practicesmdashlearning from our mistakes and seeking solu-

tions Tey developed recommendations and calls to action to the broader

church Working groups wrote briefing papers aer each summit based on

key issues in urban mission And they endeavored to build trust wisdomand inspiration to better engage our new urban world

Majority World and Western leaders participated in discussion prayer

integral mission and working groups Te goal was to grapple with key issues

and ask key questions How do we recruit equip and sustain urban mission

today How do we release church movements among the urban poor How

can we immerse ourselves in and transform urban neighborhoods How do

we empower urban children and young people How does the church serve

and liberate the oppressedmdashand others suffering from urban injustice What

needs to happen for poorer urban centers to develop economically socially

and spiritually How do we join God in the challenges and opportunities of

multifaith cities

Workshops included urban gardening child protection and collaborating

with local churches in urban mission Workshops also included organic

church growth and mission as well as developing NGO and government

partnerships Groups considered the good the bad and the ugly of short-

term urban mission teams

2Tese aims are detailed at ldquoInternational Society or Urban Mission Summitrdquo httpnewurbanworld

orgsummit

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1836

Glocalizing Conversations 10486261048629

Te summit was a thrilling example of how Majority World and Western

leaders can cooperate It was a time to come together in an environment of

mutual learning and enrichment It was a window into how local contextsand global themes can enrich each other Tis resulted from ISUMrsquos com-

mitment to ldquosolidarity fellowship and insight between urban Christian

leaders in the Western and Majority Worldsrdquo

Te summit was a success due to ISUMrsquos core values What are they983091 Christ-

honoring urban mission values bottom-up grassroots perspectivesmdashrather

than top-down distanced perspectives It allows local theology to reveal new

insights and perspectives about Godrsquos activity It shares insights and experi-ences through narratives embedded within urban poor communities and cities

It cultivates ongoing practical and personal solidarity with the worldrsquos urban

poor Tis Spirit-empowered urban mission honors networks relationships

and partnerships It sees such relationships as the primary method of serving

together It listens to and amplifies the voices of the urban poormdashespecially

those from the Majority World and in particular the 1048625104862410486281048624 window cities It is

attentive to signs of the kingdom of God Urban mission that glorifies God iswilling to reflect and respond with active and sacrificial commitment It shares

and extends the life of the body of Christ among the urban poor

Tis summit was a milestone in urban missiology It enriched communi-

cation between Western and Majority World thinker-activists Tis resulted

from the aims and values Irsquove mentioned Effective urban mission needs to

be a conversation on many levels It is attentive to context and immersed in

local settings It appreciates global and universal missional themes It culti-

vates dialogue between these local-global (glocal) realities It involves

mutual learning between Western and Majority World thinker-activists

Moreover solidarity between all parties is a defining feature Tis solidarity

is due to a compelling vision of the kingdom of God

Tese collaborative glocal features of the ISUM urban mission summit

in Bangkok are critical for the aims of this book GlobalChurch

Majority World indigenous and Western leaders thinkers and churches

can stretch and enrich each other But they need to be open and attentive to

each other Tey need learning postures and open hearts and minds Tey

3ldquoAbout ISUMrdquo httpnewurbanworldorgabout

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1936

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2036

Glocalizing Conversations 10486261048631

always rooted in the local and particularmdashas local churches embody the

gospel and witness to Christ Tese churches forge their own theological

understandings as they do mission together Tey engage in transformationalpractices among the people in their settings Tey enjoy worship mission

and community in their local and particular context Ideally the result is

unique contextual theologies and missions

Simultaneously global conversations form Tey form because of this

multitude of local theologies and practices Local conversations inform and

enrich other local conversations catalyzing global themes and voices izon

observes that the global ldquoowes its existence to local contexts Sharedconvictions among the theologies and practices of local contextual realities

give shape to its global dimensionsrdquo1048629

Majority World indigenous and Western theologies are equally contextual

Tey are equally culture bound Tey are equally particular to their time and

location At times they are all enlightened or myopic liberating or con-

straining humanizing or objectifying beautiful or offensive prophetic or

tepid Te local particular and cultural shape all these theologies Converselythese particular theologies feed and influence global conversations Tere is

no place then for ethnocentrism colonialism or elitism Tere is no place

for theological missional cultural or institutionalized arrogance

Multiple local contexts and voices come togethermdashintentionally or notmdashto

form global themes and theologies Conversely these global realities shape

local contexts oday local contexts must grapple with ldquoan emerging global

culture ie the interacting realities of modernity postmodernity and the

phenomenon of globalizationrdquo1048630 Hence the interdependent and symbiotic

relationship between the localparticular and the globaluniversal We call this

interdependent relationship between the local and the global glocalization

Te global church needs a thrilling glocal exchange We need one that we

characterize by mutuality respect partnership and symbiosis Such ex-

change helps Majority World indigenous and Western churches learn from

each other It enables them to pursue missional theology and practice o-

gether the church becomes a ldquocity on a hillrdquo

5Ibid 10486259830886Ibid 9830961048628

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2136

10486261048632 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

W983144983137983156 R983141983153983157983145983154983141983155 G983148983151983139983137983148983145983162983137983156983145983151983150983103

Te glocal exchange described above needs to be broader than transforma-

tional mission Tis is necessary if the church is to develop a robust inter-cultural and glocal missional ecclesiology

In my first book Salt Light and a City I outlined the foundational

themes of missional ecclesiology983095 Majority World and Western leaders

need to engage these themes in local and contextual ways Teir insights can

then enrich global conversations Tese global conversations in turn shape

local understandings and practices Tis way a glocal appreciation of these

themes emergesLocal regional and global theologies and practices are thereby enriched

Te church becomes healthier and more missionalmdasha truer expression of

the kingdom Te church becomes a fuller witness to Christ his passion for

the nations and his ability to bring unity in diversity

Stephen Bevans and Roger Schroeder outline the six constants of mission

Tese are our theologies about Jesus the church the end times salvation

human nature and culture Bevans and Schroeder describe the relationshipbetween these six and their historical cultural and theological contexts Tis is

why they call these six constants in context Our understanding of these six

constants develops in relation to local and global movements Sometimes local

voices influence our understandings of these six Other times it is regional or

global voices For all of us local regional and global influences are at play at

once Collectively they form our appreciation of the six constants of mission1048632

Here are eight theological themes that the church can develop through

processes of glocalization I presented these in my book Salt Light and a City

Tey are vital to the churchrsquos health mission community and future We

could add many other themes to these eight but these will suffice for now1048633

Scripture Te Scriptures are the infallible authoritative Word of God

Christrsquos Spirit has inspired them Tey have absolute and final authority in

all aspects of corporate and individual faith ethics conduct and witness

Christians interpret and apply Scripture in local contexts and in particular

7Graham Hill Salt Light and a City Introducing Missional Ecclesiology (Eugene OR Wip and

Stock 9830909830881048625983090) 10486251048628983097-983090104863110486288Stephen B Bevans and Roger Schroeder Constants in Context A Teology o Mission or oday

American Society o Missiology Series (Maryknoll NY Orbis 9830909830889830881048628) part one9Tese points first appeared in my book Salt Light and a City xxii-xxiv

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2236

Glocalizing Conversations 10486261048633

social settings Conversely we learn from the interpretations and readings

of other groups

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our local- global theology of Scripture and biblical interpretation

Evangelicalism Pentecostalism missional movements and so forth I

have charismatic missional and evangelical convictions Glocal conversa-

tions help me understand and practice these convictions better

I will use evangelicalism as an example Michael Horton says that our

beliefs and practices are evangelical when they are ldquocommitted to the suffi-

ciency of Scripture the priesthood of all believers the total lostness ofhumans the sole mediation of Christ the gracious efficacy and finality of

Godrsquos redemptive work in Christ through election propitiation calling and

keeping Te linchpin for all of this was the doctrine of justification by grace

alone through faith alone because of Christ alonerdquo9830891048624

Such convictions are necessary if we are to be faithful to the gospel and

to a biblical vision of church and mission Te gospel defines Godrsquos purposes

for humanity the church and the universe Te triune God controls thechurch He is its Lord and Savior Sanctifier and Liberator Master and King

He is completely sovereign over its nature affairs mission and history God

is the churchrsquos only source of grace election atonement salvation and per-

severance Te churchrsquos justification and hope are by grace alone through

faith alone by Christ alone

Herersquos the challenge I face My understanding of evangelicalism is

Western I am a product of the Western theological tradition and my Western

evangelical heritage Much of this is wonderful But I need indigenous and

Majority World evangelicals and others to help me expand and reshape

these insights Te same would be true if I were a Pentecostal

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of our theological traditions and convictions

Jesus Christ We must center our theology on Jesus Christ the Lord of

the church Te church needs to reflect on the person and work of Christ

and respond to him Tis means gathering and going in the name and power

of Christ It means allowing Christrsquos Spirit to shape our community and

10Michael Horton ldquoEvangelical Arminiansrdquo Modern Reormation 1048625 no 1048627 (1048625983097983097983090) 10486251048631

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2336

10486271048624 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

identity and mission It means developing our Christology ecclesiology and

missiology concurrently Te early church developed these three areas and

more in a concurrent and integrated way Tere was no linear progressionTe same is true in the contemporary global church

How can the glocal church best explore its nature structure mission and

hope Trough the centrality and the lordship of Christ

Majority World and indigenous Christians help us appreciate Jesus and

his mission afresh Tey show us how Jesus identifies with the marginalized

outcast oppressed rejected and broken He prefers them We find him

among ldquothe least of theserdquoGlocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of who Jesus Christ is How does it help us appreciate him better

What has Jesus done for and in his church and his world What does he care

about What individual and corporate responsibilities has he given us How

do we express these at local regional and global levels

Te Spirit Missional ecclesiology is inadequate without pneumatological

foundations In other words our theology of church and Spirit go togetherTe Spirit creates and animates the church He empowers it to witness to

Jesus and his gospel Te Spirit enables the church to be a missional trans-

formational community He shapes the church into an alternative society

embodying the reign of God Te church exists for the glory and mission of

Christ Te power and presence of the Spirit enables this mission worship

and glorification

Te Spirit pours out gis on the local-global church ldquofor the common

goodrdquo and ldquoto equip his people for works of service so that the body of Christ

may be built uprdquo Tis includes but isnrsquot limited to the ministry gis mani-

festation gis and motivational gis (1048625 Cor 104862510486261048631 Eph 104862810486251048625-10486251048626 Rom 104862510486261048630-1048632)

Te Spirit forms the glocal church He empowers it for service and

witness He fills it with Christrsquos empowering presence He leads it into the

missio Deimdashthe mission of the Father Son and Holy Spirit

Recently Pentecostal and renewalist movements have grown dramati-

cally in the Majority World Tey have increased in status size and influence

Many have matured theologically Te churches of the West must take notice

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of the power and presence of the Spirit

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2436

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048625

Te rinity Tere are clear limitations to the analogy between the

church and the rinity Te church can only image the rinity Yet the

church is at its best when it reflects the relational and missional passionof the rinity

What is the source and inspiration of the churchrsquos local-global mission

Ultimately it is the missional nature passion and actions of the Father Son

and Holy Spirit Godrsquos nature is missional His passion is infectious His

actions are historical redemptive and eternal Te rinity invites the

church into a sending community Te Father sends the Son Te Father

and Son send the Spirit Finally the rinity sends the church in missioninto the world

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of the rinity How does it enable our participation in the mission

and community of the triune God

Association and dialogue Tese need to happen across denominational

cultural ethnic gender and theological traditions and divides Authentic

dialogue is indispensable to the health and mission of the church What dothose marginal to the life of the church have to say to us What do ldquoothersrdquo

have to teach us Other ethnicities and cultures Other socioeconomic

groups Other ages and genders Other theological and confessing tradi-

tions Other persons from times long gone

We need to listen Share Be vulnerable Be authentic Open up to crit-

icism correction and change

We need more than dialogue We need communion and association It is

possible in a qualified way to say that God is present in all the various forms

of the church (ie the various theological ecclesiological sociocultural his-

torical and other permutations of the church) We discern this presence

through attention to Scripture history tradition culture and the Spirit Dis-

cernment involves critical dialogue theological exchange biblical study and

real relationship Only the Spirit of Jesus can enable this

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of association and dialogue

Mission and the missio Dei Te church is missional at its core It serves

obeys and images a missionary God David Bosch says ldquoTe churchrsquos mission

is not secondary to its being the church exists in being sent and in building up

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2536

10486271048626 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

itself for its missionrdquo He goes on to say ldquoEcclesiology does not precede missi-

ology there cannot be church without an intrinsic missionary dimensionrdquo983089983089

Jesus is Lord Lord of his church and Lord of his world His mission de-termines and forms the church His mission shapes the nature purposes

structures ministries and activities of his church Majority World and in-

digenous thinkers help us understand the implications of this mission Tey

help us form glocal theologies of mission Tey reveal ldquomission in context

as transformationrdquo9830891048626

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of mission and the missio Dei Church theology and practice Glocal conversations can inform and

enrich many aspects of the church (when practiced well) Teologies and

practices benefit from robust and critical glocal conversations Tese con-

versations enrich many areas (community spirituality discipleship liturgy

worship hospitality eco-justice education social ethics servantship lib-

eration place suffering beauty and so on)

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-standing of these many dimensions of church and mission

Glocal processes shape these eight themes and their practices We need

to facilitate and enable these conversations and processes Tis is urgent It

must be a priority No theology of mission or missional ecclesiology is ad-

equate without glocal conversations983089983091

T983144983141 L983151983139983137983148 983137983150983140 G983148983151983138983137983148 E983150983154983145983139983144 E983137983139983144 O983156983144983141983154

Glocalization takes the localparticular context and globaluniversal themes

seriously Contextual and global conversations enter an enriching and in-

forming relationship Tese two always have an active and symbiotic rela-

tionship Tis is true whether we deliberately put them into conversation or

not Te local shapes the global and the global shapes the local Many local

11David J Bosch Believing in the Future oward a Missiology o Western Culture (New York

rinity 1048625983097983097983093) 104862798309012izon ransormation Afer Lausanne 1048631-98309713Not all o these themes are dealt with in this present volume since either (1048625) I have dealt with them

in my book Salt Light and a City (983090) they are not all key themes in the writings o the thirty-five

Majority World thinkers considered in this volume or (1048627) there is not adequate space in a book

this size

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2636

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048627

voices converge to form global conversations and theologies Using the Phil-

ippines as a case study izon illustrates this by showing the interdepen-

dence between local and global themes in mission983089983092Dialogue between local and global conversations is critical Kōsuke

Koyama wrote an important book on contextual mission called Water Buffalo

Teology Koyama is a Japanese missionary who served in Chiang Mai

Tailand He writes of the joys and challenges of doing local particular water

buffalo theology He considers the relationship between local theology global

missional themes and transforming cultures ldquoWater Buffalo Teology sees

certain specific challenges Contextualization of theology implies two criticalmovements First to articulate Jesus Christ in culturally appropriate com-

municatively apt words and second to criticize reform dethrone or oppose

culture if it is found to be against what the name of Jesus Christ stands forrdquo9830891048629

Kōsuke Koyama challenges us to recognize what we bring to the task of

local theology For him it was doing theology in Tailand while being Jap-

anese We also need to notice the particular culture wersquore located in as we do

the work of theology Tis means we avoid speaking of an ldquoAsian theologyrdquoldquoAfrican theologyrdquo and the like We need to cultivate local theologies that

engage regional and global themes But these theologies must be ldquodistinctly

localrdquo and a ldquotheology from belowrdquo9830891048630

Simultaneously we need to pursue a reformation of theology and

practice ldquoin the global contextrdquo Tis means entering ldquothe disturbing spa-

ciousness of Jesus Christrdquo Jesus calls us to reject enmity and exceptionalism

We seem him present in our culture language stories and relationships

But we also choose to embrace the ldquootherrdquo We choose to see him present

in other culturesmdashshaping a global people to serve and worship him

joining in his mission983089983095

Kōsuke Koyama roots the gospel in the local contextual and particular

Tis is why he roots his water buffalo theology in Northern Tai culture He

is careful not to say ldquoHere is how you contextualize in your settingrdquo Instead

14izon ransormation Afer Lausanne 1048631-10486251048627 10486251048628983097-98309098308898309015Kōsuke Koyama Water Buffalo Teology 983090983093th anniversary ed (Maryknoll NY Orbis 1048625983097983097983097)

xiii-xv16Kōsuke Koyama ldquoTe Asian Approach to Christrdquo Missiology 1048625983090 no 1048628 (10486259830979830961048628) 10486281048627983093-104862798309617Kōsuke Koyama ldquoReormation in the Global Context Te Disturbing Spaciousness o Jesus Christrdquo

Currents in Teology and Mission 1048627983088 no 983090 (9830909830889830881048627) 10486251048625983097-983090983096

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2736

10486271048628 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

he tells us a story Itrsquos the story of how he contextualized theology in northern

Tailand while being open to global conversations Koyama asks us to form

our own local expressions of church mission and theology At the same timewe must stay attentive to what God is saying and doing beyond that context

Tis way local and global and particular and universal become mutually

enriching conversation partners

G983148983151983139983137983148983145983162983137983156983145983151983150 983137983150983140 H983145983155983156983151983154983145983139983137983148983148983161 S983145983148983141983150983139983141983140 V983151983145983139983141983155

Glocal theologies and conversations pay attention to voices that powers in-

stitutions religions and societies have silenced R S Sugirtharajah pushesback a little on izonrsquos ideas Sugirtharajah says that the church should

privilege local conversations He emphasizes the local contextual and post-

colonial reading of biblical texts9830891048632

Te church needs to listen Te church ought to be attentive to the

theologies and biblical interpretations of groups that cultures and reli-

gions have ignored Historically powerful secular and religious forces

have silenced these groups Tey have marginalized oppressed and colo-nized them It is time for the church to address this injustice We must

start listening to important but silenced voices We need to privilege the

voices of the former victims of Western colonialism We need to develop

postcolonial biblical interpretations theologies and expressions of church

and mission

How do we take such perspectives seriously as we develop glocal conver-

sations How do these themes help us foster vital relationships between local

and global voices

It is time for us to embrace values that enable conversations with those

oen ignored by the church We need values that help us learn from these

groups and individuals

Valuing equal partnership Colonizing powers oppressed silenced and

colonized certain groups At times the church was complicit Tese colo-

nized groups have become ldquoconfident indomitable and indispensable

partners in the dialogue and collaboration with the dispossessed and disad-

18R S Sugirtharajah Asian Biblical Hermeneutics and Postcolonialism Contesting the Interpreta-

tions Te Bible and Liberation Series (Maryknoll NY Orbis 1048625983097983097983096) 1048625983093-1048625983094

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2836

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048629

vantaged in the Westrdquo9830891048633 Tis calls for attentiveness to these voices and re-

sponsiveness to their prophetic challenges It also demands a critical evalu-

ation of colonial readings of Scripture Colonial models of theology andchurch and mission are no longer the benchmark Te global church must

examine them afresh

Valuing equal status Tose on the margins have now taken their rightful

place on the global stage Tey have claimed appropriate and equal status at

the table Subaltern readings of theology church and mission are invaluable

contributors to global theological conversations Tis means that we esteem

them But we also test themWhat do we mean by subaltern Subalterns are those who are down-

trodden and silenced (or have been treated this way in the past) Dominant

or colonizing groups treat them as invisible nonentities Tey enjoy limited

or no access to power Sometimes these are women certain tribal and ethnic

groups and those considered ldquountouchablerdquo In Voices from the Margin Su-

girtharajah provides a platform for postcolonial subaltern readings of

Scripture and theology Tese readings challenge colonialmdashoen Westernmdashreadings of Bible and theology and cultures Tey claim equal status with

other ways of doing theology10486261048624

Valuing equal identity People groups need freedom to explore their new

and emerging identities Tese emerge in response to local and global influ-

ences Local culture is not the only thing at work here Global forces also

shape identity as do imported practices ideas readings rituals and tech-

nologies But each group should be free to explore and construct their par-

ticular forms of Christian identity

Valuing equal interpretations ldquoPostcolonialism is concerned with the

question of cultural and discursive dominationrdquo Colonialism led to op-

pressive and controlling forms of culture and discourse Tese were usually

not contextual or indigenous Western powers for instance brought co-

lonial forms of theology church biblical interpretation and mission1048626983089

Postcolonialism calls for alternative ways of approaching these things Tose

19Ibid 104862598309420R S Sugirtharajah Voices rom the Margin Interpreting the Bible in the Tird World (Maryknoll

NY Orbis 10486259830979830971048625)21Sugirtharajah Asian Biblical Hermeneutics and Postcolonialism 10486251048631

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2936

10486271048630 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

who were once marginalized oppressed and silenced need to lead these fresh

approaches in their own settings Tese then influence global conversations

We need to support the new readings and insights and experiments from thesegroups o be genuine this support must be both critical and collegial

Valuing equal empowerment Sugirtharajah says that postcolonialism is

valuable when it empowers actual communities and real people Post-

colonial thought empowers when it addresses the difficulties hopes and

experiences of ordinary people It should never be about power plays and

the clever use of language Itrsquos pointless if itrsquos obsessed with forming newmdash

and ldquocolonizingrdquomdashtheories Itrsquos a waste of time if itrsquos a self-indulgent pursuitof new and hybrid identities Rather ldquothe worth and credibility of post-

colonial criticism will be judged by how it orchestrates the unique and

fragile and imagined claims of one community against anotherrdquo Empow-

erment happens in a variety of ways One way is contributing equally to

global conversations10486261048626

Al izon examines postcolonialism in the Philippines He says that it can

teach the global church a lot about healthy local-global conversations Fil-ipino contextual theology resists many Western forms of mission and the-

ology It finds them patronizing and controlling Tis indigenous theology

values prophetic sociopolitical engagement in institutions and the society

at large It emphasizes ministry to whole persons and communities It con-

structs a Filipino theology of beauty and mission and worship and com-

munity And it fosters indigenous theological approaches to the spirit world

and cosmology

izon says that postcolonial theology has played a constructive role in

the Philippines But he is uncomfortable with the label postcolonialism He

prefers to describe historical events as ldquobeyond colonialismrdquo And he says

that global conversations enrich local theologies and vice versa1048626983091

Postcolonial thought informs our understanding of the relationship be-

tween the local and global It also shows how theology can emerge at the

intersection between the localparticular and the globaluniversal It re-

minds us that worthwhile glocalization listens to all voices Tis includes

heeding those that have been historically silenced

22Ibid 983090104862823izon ransormation Afer Lausanne 1048625983088983090 10486259830941048631-9830961048631

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3036

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048631

G983148983151983139983137983148983145983162983137983156983145983151983150 983137983150983140 983156983144983141 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

C983151983150983139983148983157983140983145983150983143 R983141983142983148983141983139983156983145983151983150983155

How do we go about developing a model for glocal conversations izon hasrecently provided a useful model that is instructive as we seek to learn from

the Majority World It has at least two key features

First the local is in the global (globalization from below) Global theologies

and ideas have origins in many particular local contexts In that sense glo-

balization is from below Global ideas have local roots Ideas about integral

mission liberation theology and missional church have local origins Tey

have their roots in the prayers hopes discoveries mission and theologiesof thousands of local communities ldquoTe global does not cannot exist

without the localmdashbut the coming together of localities creates a global re-

ality that becomes greater than the sum of its parts it creates a gestalt entity

to which localities make themselves accountablerdquo1048626983092

Second the global is in the local (panlocalization from above) Te con-

cerns and voices of multitudes of locales form global conversations Tese

global discussions can provide a ldquopositive accountabilityrdquo back to local con-texts Tis is true when they enrich affirm serve guide and strengthen local

contexts It is also true when they avoid homogenization control impo-

sition and judgment Glocalization is best when it sees itself as interde-

pendent deeply connected with the local10486261048629

Tatrsquos a helpful starting point But we need to go further Besides izonrsquos

proposals Irsquom convinced that robust glocal conversations cultivate six core

practices

983089 Glocal theology practices its values We root glocal theology in core

values Tese values include solidarity understanding and mutual learning

Do we value fellowship with Christians of all cultures Do we value learning

from them

We prove our values through our practices What practices emerge out of

these values We need to collaborate act collectively and share information

We must find ways to foster grassroots perspectives and local theologies We

need to share stories and learnings and cultivate networks relationships and

partnerships We need attentiveness to local voices and global themes We

24Ibid 9830901048625983088-1048625104862825Ibid 98309010486251048628-1048625983096

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3136

10486271048632 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

ought to find ways to put these local and global voices into conversation

Mutual learning humility and solidarity are key Worthwhile glocal con-

versations can never be merely theoretical or academic It is up to us to rootour values in our practices

983090 Glocal theology practices humility (and it tells a new narrative) We

have noted that the local is in the global and the global is in the local Te

two are interdependent Tey form each other reciprocally Since this is the

case we must practice humility Tere is no place for ethnocentrism colo-

nialism or theological and cultural arrogance I have seen these unhealthy

postures far too oen in Western settingsRecently I attended a missional leadership conference On that occasion

the keynote speakermdasha leading missional author and speakermdashsaid that

North American missional conversations and innovations hold the key to

the future of the Western church Tis Euro American view is wrong (Irsquom

being kind o be frank itrsquos complete nonsense) Itrsquos arrogant and Euro

Americanndashcentric And itrsquos completely out of step with what is happening in

the glocal church We need a new narrativeIn June 1048626104862410486251048627 Te Center for the Study of Global Christianity reported

the top 10486261048624 countries where Christianity has the highest percentage growth

rate Nineteen of the top twenty are in Asia and Africa Eleven of them are

in Muslim majority countries Not a single country from Europe or North

America makes the top twenty list10486261048630

Itrsquos time to cultivate a new narrative Te future of the church is emerging

from the Majority World Rather than North America the churches of

Eastern Asia Western Africa the Arabian Peninsula and other parts of the

Majority World reveal the future of the global church We need the contribu-

tions of all contexts Western indigenous and Majority World All con-

tribute to glocal conversations All are important as we learn from each

other about mission theology and faith But letrsquos stop pretending that North

Americans and Europeans will reveal the future of the global church Letrsquos

start listening to what God is saying about the future of the global church

And hersquos speaking to us through the churches of Asia Africa Latin America

26Russ Mitchell ldquoTe op 983090983088 Countries Where Christianity Is Growing the Fastestrdquo Disciple All

Nations (blog) August 983090983093 98309098308810486251048627 httpsdiscipleallnationswordpresscom98309098308810486251048627983088983096983090983093the-top

-983090983088-countries-where-christianity-is-growing-the-astest

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3236

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048633

Muslim majority settings and so on We must cultivate a new glocal nar-

rativemdashone soaked in humility

Glocal theology must be humble theology Meek theology Receptive the-ology Discerning theology Prayerful theology Dialogical theology De-

pendent theology A theology that celebrates the interdependence between

the localparticular and the globaluniversal

983091 Glocal theology practices expansiveness Glocalization is by nature

comprehensive Local and global influences permeate much of our lives Tese

glocal forces shape our theologies and churches whether we like it or not

But intentionality is also important We need to commit to an expansiveapproach to glocal theology How do we deliberately cultivate glocal conver-

sations in our biblical interpretation Do we foster them in our under-

standing of the person and work of Christ How does glocalization shape

the way the Spirit empowers and constitutes the church How can it form

our understanding of the nature and mission of the rinity How does it

influence the way we practice fellowship and conversation across denomi-

national cultural ethnic economic sociocultural political gender andtheological divides How might it shape our theologies of mission com-

munity beauty spirituality suffering discipleship hospitality eco-justice

place education social ethics Christian leadership and so forth

983092 Glocal theology practices attention Glocal theology doesnrsquot need to

accept all the assumptions or assertions of postcolonial or Majority World

thought But it does need to engage with them and take them seriously

Postcolonial theology for instance gives the marginalized and colonized

and forgotten and silenced both dignity and voice Our glocal conversations

must also include and esteem these groups We need to be attentive to

others weak and powerful female and male dominant and downtrodden

old and young rich and poor privileged and marginalized influential and

subaltern educated and illiterate We need to practice the art of attention

being especially attentive to those who are different to us

983093 Glocal theology practices embrace What do colonial ethnocentric or

Western-centric perspectives do Tey silence Tey control Tey com-

modify Tey institutionalize Tey colonize Tey domesticate Tey replace

Tey import Tey exclude Tey do these things to the beliefs experiences

and practices of other cultures A worthwhile glocal theology refuses to do

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3336

10486281048624 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

these things Instead it adopts a responsive humble celebratory open in-

clusive and embracing attitude

983094 Glocal theology practices discernment Finally we need discernmentas we engage these ideas and practices Discernment is a huge topic thatrsquos

hard to cover comprehensively in a few words Discernment happens when

the Spirit of Christ and his Word renew our minds Te Spirit grants us

spiritual wisdom as we meditate on him and his Word and as we practice

discipleship to Jesus Christ Romans 10486251048626 provides guidance we need (1048625) to be

transformed by the renewal of our minds (1048626) to serve Christrsquos body and (1048627)

to put love into action Discernment also happens in conversation both lo-cally and glocally

I pray these core values and six practices come across in the following

chapters of GlobalChurch

Glocalization can never be just theoretical Are we committed to moving

glocalization from an abstract idea to a living communion Are we deter-

mined to construct a missional theology of the church in the context of

glocal conversations Tis must involve dialogue between Majority Worldindigenous and Western scholars activists and groups

Will glocalization be an abstract notion Or will it be a formative and

genuine communion between local regional and global voices Glocal dy-

namics are at play whether we like it or not Teyrsquore in our churches the-

ologies and missions But we can choose to relinquish isolationist colonial

parochial and arrogant approaches Instead we can adopt responsive dia-

logical learning humble and embracing postures

Trough healthy approaches to glocalization the Spirit challenges us to

value local contexts We immerse ourselves in local and particular commu-

nities and conversations He inspires us to open ourselves to global theo-

logical conversations He rouses us to value the symbiotic relationship be-

tween the localparticular and the globaluniversal

Trough glocal relationships the Spirit leads us to put local contextual

theologies into conversation with global ones He prompts us to explore the

ways in which the local is in the glocal and the global is in the local He per-

suades us to pursue collaboration and dialogue and mutual learning We

engage with Christians from different backgrounds and cultures ecumen-

icals Pentecostals evangelicals and so on from Western indigenous and

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3436

Glocalizing Conversations 10486281048625

Majority World contexts He motivates us to express solidarity between all

parties We appreciate our unity in diversity

Trough glocal conversations the Spirit moves us to ensure that unity andsolidarity emerge from a compelling vision of Jesusrsquo kingdom and gospel

and person He challenges us to share information theology and practices

He urges us to learn from each othermdashour successes and mistakes We seek

glocal solutions

Te Spirit calls us to develop glocal conversations about Christian ideas

and practices Tese include Scripture Evangelicalism ecumenism Pente-

costalism Jesus Christ the Holy Spirit God the Father the rinity com-munity spirituality discipleship liturgy worship hospitality prayer eco-

justice education social ethics Christian leadership gospel and culture

beauty place suffering liberation and so forth

Finally through glocal conversations the Spirit leads us to adopt a new

posture Tis is a responsive humble celebratory open inclusive and em-

bracing attitude to the ldquootherrdquo We do this as a new people made up of every

tribe and language and people and nationTere are dangers in glocalization Sugirtharajah warns of the commodi-

fication of local contextual practices and theologies When this happens

they are ldquosmoothed out of their primary contexts concerns and contesta-

tions travel across borders and become objects of analysis and scrutiny

within an alien secondary contextrdquo1048626983095

Itrsquos common for those of us who are Western to make mistakes when we

wrestle with Majority World and indigenous ideas Sugirtharajah mentions

our tendency to commodify reduce and institutionalize these ideas We also

risk doing these things (1048625) We apply them in noncontextual prescriptive ways

(1048626) We ignore their meanings in their original setting (1048627) We glamorize or

idealize their proponents or their contexts (1048628) We demonize those persons or

contexts (1048629) We disregard them as irrelevant rhetorical or minority discourse

Kevin J Vanhoozer says that we can fall into three traps when we glo-

calize theology (1048625) We can underestimate the theological significance of

local cultures (1048626) We can homogenize cultures and theologies exaggerating

27R S Sugirtharajah ldquoextual ake-Aways Tird World exts in Western Metropolitan Centresrdquo

Black Teology in Britain A Journal o Contextual Praxis 983090 (1048625983097983097983097) 10486271048627 10486271048631 Edward W Said Te

World the ext and the Critic (Cambridge MA Harvard University Press 10486259830979830961048627) 9830901048627983097

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3536

10486281048626 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

ldquothe onerdquo (1048627) We can overemphasize cultural particularity exaggerating ldquothe

manyrdquo and pursue ldquotheological ethnificationrdquo10486261048632

My hope is that GlobalChurch does not fall into the traps Sugirtharajahand Vanhoozer describe I hope that what unfolds in the following chapters

is respectful and discerning I hope it leads to further mutually enriching

conversations between people of different cultures

You the reader face the same challenges You face them in your personal

life ministry context and missional engagements

Will you treat the themes in this book as abstract theoretical notions

Will this be a temporary infatuation a flirtation with the ldquootherrdquo that dissi-pates as suddenly as it arrived Or will glocal conversations become an en-

riching and formative orientation in your life Will glocal conversations

bring fresh approaches to theology faith mission church and worship Will

conversations with other cultures and theologies become for you a com-

pelling way of life

My prayer is that glocal conversations will help the church be a global

visible alternative ldquocity set upon a hillrdquo a truly GlobalChurch

28Craig Ott and Harold A Netland Globalizing Teology Belie and Practice in an Era o World

Christianity (Grand Rapids Baker Academic 983090983088983088983094) 1048625983090983093

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3636

Page 11: GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1136

Introduction 10486251048631

superiority or centricity Te term Global South is too limiting given the

breadth of the group I am engaging Majority World seems to work best

In 1048626104862410486241048628 Te Lausanne Forum for World Evangelization in PattayaTailand voted unanimously that the phrase Majority World Church replace

other terms People from all over the globe participated in this forum

imothy C ennent agrees that this is the best phrase ldquoIt helps to highlight

the basic point that Africa Asia and Latin America are where the majority

of the worldrsquos Christians are now locatedrdquo9830891048624 I expand the phrase Majority

World beyond Africa Asia and Latin America to include the Caribbean

Eastern Europe Oceania and the Middle EastIndigenous and First Nations peoples are ldquothose ethnic groups that were

indigenous to a territory prior to being incorporated into a national state

and who are politically and culturally separate from the majority ethnic

identity of the state that they are a part ofrdquo Tis includes people groups like

the Australian Aborigines and American Indians983089983089

Te aim of this book is to help Western churches rediscover what it means

to be salt light and a city by engaging in global missional conversations odo this Western Christians need to enter into conversation with Majority

World and indigenous Christians Listening to others helps us grow in our

understanding and practice of mission and church and theology For far too

long wersquove marginalized or ignored Majority World and indigenous voices

We must truly become a GlobalChurch

Tis aim shapes the bookrsquos structure as summarized below

P983137983154983156 1048625 S983137983148983156 R983141983155983144983137983152983145983150983143 O983157983154 C983151983150983158983141983154983155983137983156983145983151983150983155

ldquoYou are the salt of the earth But if the salt loses its saltiness how can it be made

salty again It is no longer good for anything except to be thrown out and

trampled underfootrdquo Globally and locally you are the salt of the earth Be salt

Salt preserves seasons flavors and purifies We are salt when we glorify

the Father Son and Holy Spirit in our mission worship faith hope truth

and love We are salt when we reject a Eurocentric or Americentric vision

10imothy C ennent Teology in the Context o World Christianity How the Global Church Is

Influencing the Way We Tink About and Discuss Teology (Grand Rapids Zondervan 9830909830889830881048631) xx11Douglas Sanders ldquoIndigenous Peoples Issues o Definitionrdquo International Journal o Cultural

Property 983096 no 1048625 (1048625983097983097983097) 1048628

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1236

10486251048632 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

of the church and become the global missional church Christ envisioned

In part one I show how Western conversations are impoverished and

insufficient in isolation from indigenous and Majority World Christians Weenhance our ldquosaltinessrdquo through local-global ( glocal ) exchanges o do this

we must reshape our conversations We need global and local exchanges that

we characterize by mutuality respect partnership and symbiosis Such ex-

changes help us learn from each other whether wersquore in Western indig-

enous or Majority World settings It helps us stay ldquosaltyrdquo It enables us to

pursue global missional theology and practice Globally and locally we can

pursue missional vitality and truly be ldquothe salt of the earthrdquo

P983137983154983156 1048626 L983145983143983144983156 R983141983150983141983159983145983150983143 O983157983154 M983145983155983155983145983151983150

ldquoYou are the light of the world A city on a hill cannot be hidden Neither do

people light a lamp and put it under a bowl Instead they put it on its stand and

it gives light to everyone in the house In the same way let your light shine

before others that they may see your good deeds and glorify your Father in

heavenrdquo (Mt 104862910486251048628-10486251048631) Globally and locally you are the light of the world Be lightLight illuminates reveals and dispels darkness Te church is light when

it does good deedsmdashhealing and liberating and redemptive deeds Itrsquos light

when its being and faith and deeds bring glorify to the Father Te church

is light when it participates in Godrsquos redemptive mission in the world as a

global missional community

o do this we must renew our mission In part two I explore how indig-

enous and Majority World Christians teach us to renew mission We renew

mission through contextualization liberation hospitality Spirit empow-

erment creation care ethics and the transformation of neighborhoods

P983137983154983156 1048627 C983145983156983161 R983141983158983145983156983137983148983145983162983145983150983143 O983157983154 C983144983157983154983139983144983141983155

You are a city set on a hill ldquoA city on a hill cannot be hiddenrdquo Globally and

locally you are a city set on a hill Be a city set on a hill

Tis means that we are an alternative and countercultural movement We

have a distinct culture and politic and social existence We are a people

gathered from every tribe language people and nation We are in the world

but not of the world We are in the world but distinct from the world We are

within the world and for the sake of the world

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1336

Introduction 10486251048633

o be this kind of alternative city or culture we must renew our mission

community ethics and worship We need to pursue the revitalization of our

churches so that they are distinct And by distinct I mean an alternative city(altera civitas)

We are a ldquocity on a hillrdquo that witnesses to Jesus Christ and his eternal kingdom

when we are a global missional church In part three I demonstrate how indig-

enous and Majority World Christians teach us to revitalize churches We revi-

talize churches by indigenizing faith devouring Scripture renewing education

practicing servantship (servant leadership) recovering community and devel-

oping spirituality and discipleship We inspire our churches when we developour theology and practices relating to beauty and the arts9830891048626

In the final chapter I wrap things up by addressing an important question

In light of all the material covered in this book what would it now look like

to engage in global missional theology ecclesiology interpretation history

pneumatology worship and education

Herersquos how you can get the most out of this book

Community You can read this book alone in a small group with somefriends at home or at a coffee shop or as part of a ministry team However

you get a lot more out of this book when you read it with others ogether

you can think about the bookrsquos implications What do the chapters mean for

your ministry church agency family or team

GlobalChurch Project video series Irsquove made a video series to go along with

this book Appendix one has the details

Study guide Yoursquoll get a lot more out of this book if you spend time

working through the study guide in appendix two ry to do this in a group

Te study guide includes reflection questions suggested practices and

Further Reading

Characters As you read this book yoursquoll come across names and people

yoursquove never heard of before For a glimpse of who they are and what issues

concern them see appendix three

My website o help you get the most out of this book Irsquove included more

resources on my website TeGlobalChurchProjectcom Tese include

videos reading lists important links a glossary and other resources Irsquove

12Irsquove put a separate chapter on the theme o beauty and the arts on my website Itrsquos additional to

this book

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1436

10486261048624 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

also provided ways that you can contact me See appendix four

In my first book Salt Light and a City I developed a missional theology

of the church I did this in conversation with twelve theologians from the fourmajor Christian traditions Tat volume offered a window into the thought of

European and American theologians It showed how they are making sense

of the nature and mission of the church in their Western cultural context

Te book that yoursquore now reading takes a different approach I have

stepped away from European and American voices I now ask What can

those in the Majority World and indigenous cultures teach us in the West

What can they teach us about the churchrsquos mission worship theology andcommunity Te quality and quantity of material coming out of the Ma-

jority World is astonishing Any theology that ignores the insights of indig-

enous and Majority World Christians is deficient and impoverished

White middle-class European North American tertiary-educated men

dominate Western theology Tey dominate the Western missional conver-

sation I know I fit that profile Tis group still monopolizes missional church

conferences and seminars Tey get all the book contracts In fact this groupstill controls theology and the church in many settings But this is changing

New voices are rising Tese include women minorities the poor indigenous

groups and Majority World leaders Missional conversations arenrsquot attentive

to the Spirit and to Godrsquos mission if they ignore these voices Majority World

and indigenous churches oen have extraordinary missional vitality Openness

to other voices needs to happen now It is time for Western churches theol-

ogies and mission to mature and to reflect Godrsquos global mission

In this book I could have consulted the work of many thousands of in-

digenous and Majority World thinkers and writers and practitioners But I

have limited myself to a sample of those who speak directly to its themes

Tese African Asian Eastern European Middle Eastern Caribbean Latin

American First Nation and indigenous thinkers challenge us Tey dare us

to examine our theologies and missions and churches And they inspire us

to renew the worship and community and mission of Jesusrsquo church Tey

stir us to think in fresh ways about what it means to be salt light and a city

Tey help us become a global missional churchmdasha truly GlobalChurch

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1536

PA R T O N E

S A L TReshaping Our Conversations

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1636

G L O C A L I Z I N G

C O N V E R S A T I O N S

H983151983159 D983151 W983141 D983141983158983141983148983151983152

G983148983151983139983137983148 C983151983150983158983141983154983155983137983156983145983151983150983155983103

Rather than taking one contextual version of the Gospel and imposing

it as the Gospel throughout the world via the missionary enterprise

the shapers of Mission as ransformation have recognized the

plurality of localities that has created an intercontextual

ldquopan-localrdquo global phenomenon in theology

AL IZON

The International Society for Urban Mission (ISUM) is a group of urban

missionaries who are passionate about cultivating hope and love and re-newal in cities Irsquove connected with this group for some years ISUM held its

first annual Summit on Integral Urban Mission in Bangkok Tailand Te

team from Urban Neighbours of Hope (UNOH) under the leadership of

my Australian friends Ash and Anj Barker organized much of the summit

UNOH teams covenant with God and each other to ldquolive out our passion for

loving God and neighbour Focus on releasing neighbourhoods from urban

poverty Grow through equipping each other neighbours and the broader

church to radically follow Jesus and join Godrsquos Kingdom coming UNOH

workers live and serve in small responsive neighbourhood-based teamsrdquo983089

1See wwwunohorg

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1736

10486261048628 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

Tis summit involved interactive participatory hands-on immersion op-

portunities keynotes lectures and workshops Keynote speakers came from

Africa Australia Myanmar New Zealand North America the PhilippinesSouth America Tailand and First Nations A few hundred Majority World

and Western thinkers and activists came together for those days Tey explored

the theology and practices of integral transformational and urban mission

Tese thinkers and activists pursued a range of aims1048626 Tis included col-

laboration between urban Christians from a variety of backgrounds (Ma-

jority World and Western theologians activists ecumenicals Pentecostals

evangelicals colleges church movements and development agencies) Teyaimed for collective action and thought in an international and integral

context Tey sought to gain mutual understanding for a comprehensive

picture of urban mission around the globe Tey encouraged information

sharing and best practicesmdashlearning from our mistakes and seeking solu-

tions Tey developed recommendations and calls to action to the broader

church Working groups wrote briefing papers aer each summit based on

key issues in urban mission And they endeavored to build trust wisdomand inspiration to better engage our new urban world

Majority World and Western leaders participated in discussion prayer

integral mission and working groups Te goal was to grapple with key issues

and ask key questions How do we recruit equip and sustain urban mission

today How do we release church movements among the urban poor How

can we immerse ourselves in and transform urban neighborhoods How do

we empower urban children and young people How does the church serve

and liberate the oppressedmdashand others suffering from urban injustice What

needs to happen for poorer urban centers to develop economically socially

and spiritually How do we join God in the challenges and opportunities of

multifaith cities

Workshops included urban gardening child protection and collaborating

with local churches in urban mission Workshops also included organic

church growth and mission as well as developing NGO and government

partnerships Groups considered the good the bad and the ugly of short-

term urban mission teams

2Tese aims are detailed at ldquoInternational Society or Urban Mission Summitrdquo httpnewurbanworld

orgsummit

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1836

Glocalizing Conversations 10486261048629

Te summit was a thrilling example of how Majority World and Western

leaders can cooperate It was a time to come together in an environment of

mutual learning and enrichment It was a window into how local contextsand global themes can enrich each other Tis resulted from ISUMrsquos com-

mitment to ldquosolidarity fellowship and insight between urban Christian

leaders in the Western and Majority Worldsrdquo

Te summit was a success due to ISUMrsquos core values What are they983091 Christ-

honoring urban mission values bottom-up grassroots perspectivesmdashrather

than top-down distanced perspectives It allows local theology to reveal new

insights and perspectives about Godrsquos activity It shares insights and experi-ences through narratives embedded within urban poor communities and cities

It cultivates ongoing practical and personal solidarity with the worldrsquos urban

poor Tis Spirit-empowered urban mission honors networks relationships

and partnerships It sees such relationships as the primary method of serving

together It listens to and amplifies the voices of the urban poormdashespecially

those from the Majority World and in particular the 1048625104862410486281048624 window cities It is

attentive to signs of the kingdom of God Urban mission that glorifies God iswilling to reflect and respond with active and sacrificial commitment It shares

and extends the life of the body of Christ among the urban poor

Tis summit was a milestone in urban missiology It enriched communi-

cation between Western and Majority World thinker-activists Tis resulted

from the aims and values Irsquove mentioned Effective urban mission needs to

be a conversation on many levels It is attentive to context and immersed in

local settings It appreciates global and universal missional themes It culti-

vates dialogue between these local-global (glocal) realities It involves

mutual learning between Western and Majority World thinker-activists

Moreover solidarity between all parties is a defining feature Tis solidarity

is due to a compelling vision of the kingdom of God

Tese collaborative glocal features of the ISUM urban mission summit

in Bangkok are critical for the aims of this book GlobalChurch

Majority World indigenous and Western leaders thinkers and churches

can stretch and enrich each other But they need to be open and attentive to

each other Tey need learning postures and open hearts and minds Tey

3ldquoAbout ISUMrdquo httpnewurbanworldorgabout

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1936

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2036

Glocalizing Conversations 10486261048631

always rooted in the local and particularmdashas local churches embody the

gospel and witness to Christ Tese churches forge their own theological

understandings as they do mission together Tey engage in transformationalpractices among the people in their settings Tey enjoy worship mission

and community in their local and particular context Ideally the result is

unique contextual theologies and missions

Simultaneously global conversations form Tey form because of this

multitude of local theologies and practices Local conversations inform and

enrich other local conversations catalyzing global themes and voices izon

observes that the global ldquoowes its existence to local contexts Sharedconvictions among the theologies and practices of local contextual realities

give shape to its global dimensionsrdquo1048629

Majority World indigenous and Western theologies are equally contextual

Tey are equally culture bound Tey are equally particular to their time and

location At times they are all enlightened or myopic liberating or con-

straining humanizing or objectifying beautiful or offensive prophetic or

tepid Te local particular and cultural shape all these theologies Converselythese particular theologies feed and influence global conversations Tere is

no place then for ethnocentrism colonialism or elitism Tere is no place

for theological missional cultural or institutionalized arrogance

Multiple local contexts and voices come togethermdashintentionally or notmdashto

form global themes and theologies Conversely these global realities shape

local contexts oday local contexts must grapple with ldquoan emerging global

culture ie the interacting realities of modernity postmodernity and the

phenomenon of globalizationrdquo1048630 Hence the interdependent and symbiotic

relationship between the localparticular and the globaluniversal We call this

interdependent relationship between the local and the global glocalization

Te global church needs a thrilling glocal exchange We need one that we

characterize by mutuality respect partnership and symbiosis Such ex-

change helps Majority World indigenous and Western churches learn from

each other It enables them to pursue missional theology and practice o-

gether the church becomes a ldquocity on a hillrdquo

5Ibid 10486259830886Ibid 9830961048628

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2136

10486261048632 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

W983144983137983156 R983141983153983157983145983154983141983155 G983148983151983139983137983148983145983162983137983156983145983151983150983103

Te glocal exchange described above needs to be broader than transforma-

tional mission Tis is necessary if the church is to develop a robust inter-cultural and glocal missional ecclesiology

In my first book Salt Light and a City I outlined the foundational

themes of missional ecclesiology983095 Majority World and Western leaders

need to engage these themes in local and contextual ways Teir insights can

then enrich global conversations Tese global conversations in turn shape

local understandings and practices Tis way a glocal appreciation of these

themes emergesLocal regional and global theologies and practices are thereby enriched

Te church becomes healthier and more missionalmdasha truer expression of

the kingdom Te church becomes a fuller witness to Christ his passion for

the nations and his ability to bring unity in diversity

Stephen Bevans and Roger Schroeder outline the six constants of mission

Tese are our theologies about Jesus the church the end times salvation

human nature and culture Bevans and Schroeder describe the relationshipbetween these six and their historical cultural and theological contexts Tis is

why they call these six constants in context Our understanding of these six

constants develops in relation to local and global movements Sometimes local

voices influence our understandings of these six Other times it is regional or

global voices For all of us local regional and global influences are at play at

once Collectively they form our appreciation of the six constants of mission1048632

Here are eight theological themes that the church can develop through

processes of glocalization I presented these in my book Salt Light and a City

Tey are vital to the churchrsquos health mission community and future We

could add many other themes to these eight but these will suffice for now1048633

Scripture Te Scriptures are the infallible authoritative Word of God

Christrsquos Spirit has inspired them Tey have absolute and final authority in

all aspects of corporate and individual faith ethics conduct and witness

Christians interpret and apply Scripture in local contexts and in particular

7Graham Hill Salt Light and a City Introducing Missional Ecclesiology (Eugene OR Wip and

Stock 9830909830881048625983090) 10486251048628983097-983090104863110486288Stephen B Bevans and Roger Schroeder Constants in Context A Teology o Mission or oday

American Society o Missiology Series (Maryknoll NY Orbis 9830909830889830881048628) part one9Tese points first appeared in my book Salt Light and a City xxii-xxiv

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2236

Glocalizing Conversations 10486261048633

social settings Conversely we learn from the interpretations and readings

of other groups

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our local- global theology of Scripture and biblical interpretation

Evangelicalism Pentecostalism missional movements and so forth I

have charismatic missional and evangelical convictions Glocal conversa-

tions help me understand and practice these convictions better

I will use evangelicalism as an example Michael Horton says that our

beliefs and practices are evangelical when they are ldquocommitted to the suffi-

ciency of Scripture the priesthood of all believers the total lostness ofhumans the sole mediation of Christ the gracious efficacy and finality of

Godrsquos redemptive work in Christ through election propitiation calling and

keeping Te linchpin for all of this was the doctrine of justification by grace

alone through faith alone because of Christ alonerdquo9830891048624

Such convictions are necessary if we are to be faithful to the gospel and

to a biblical vision of church and mission Te gospel defines Godrsquos purposes

for humanity the church and the universe Te triune God controls thechurch He is its Lord and Savior Sanctifier and Liberator Master and King

He is completely sovereign over its nature affairs mission and history God

is the churchrsquos only source of grace election atonement salvation and per-

severance Te churchrsquos justification and hope are by grace alone through

faith alone by Christ alone

Herersquos the challenge I face My understanding of evangelicalism is

Western I am a product of the Western theological tradition and my Western

evangelical heritage Much of this is wonderful But I need indigenous and

Majority World evangelicals and others to help me expand and reshape

these insights Te same would be true if I were a Pentecostal

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of our theological traditions and convictions

Jesus Christ We must center our theology on Jesus Christ the Lord of

the church Te church needs to reflect on the person and work of Christ

and respond to him Tis means gathering and going in the name and power

of Christ It means allowing Christrsquos Spirit to shape our community and

10Michael Horton ldquoEvangelical Arminiansrdquo Modern Reormation 1048625 no 1048627 (1048625983097983097983090) 10486251048631

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2336

10486271048624 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

identity and mission It means developing our Christology ecclesiology and

missiology concurrently Te early church developed these three areas and

more in a concurrent and integrated way Tere was no linear progressionTe same is true in the contemporary global church

How can the glocal church best explore its nature structure mission and

hope Trough the centrality and the lordship of Christ

Majority World and indigenous Christians help us appreciate Jesus and

his mission afresh Tey show us how Jesus identifies with the marginalized

outcast oppressed rejected and broken He prefers them We find him

among ldquothe least of theserdquoGlocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of who Jesus Christ is How does it help us appreciate him better

What has Jesus done for and in his church and his world What does he care

about What individual and corporate responsibilities has he given us How

do we express these at local regional and global levels

Te Spirit Missional ecclesiology is inadequate without pneumatological

foundations In other words our theology of church and Spirit go togetherTe Spirit creates and animates the church He empowers it to witness to

Jesus and his gospel Te Spirit enables the church to be a missional trans-

formational community He shapes the church into an alternative society

embodying the reign of God Te church exists for the glory and mission of

Christ Te power and presence of the Spirit enables this mission worship

and glorification

Te Spirit pours out gis on the local-global church ldquofor the common

goodrdquo and ldquoto equip his people for works of service so that the body of Christ

may be built uprdquo Tis includes but isnrsquot limited to the ministry gis mani-

festation gis and motivational gis (1048625 Cor 104862510486261048631 Eph 104862810486251048625-10486251048626 Rom 104862510486261048630-1048632)

Te Spirit forms the glocal church He empowers it for service and

witness He fills it with Christrsquos empowering presence He leads it into the

missio Deimdashthe mission of the Father Son and Holy Spirit

Recently Pentecostal and renewalist movements have grown dramati-

cally in the Majority World Tey have increased in status size and influence

Many have matured theologically Te churches of the West must take notice

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of the power and presence of the Spirit

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2436

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048625

Te rinity Tere are clear limitations to the analogy between the

church and the rinity Te church can only image the rinity Yet the

church is at its best when it reflects the relational and missional passionof the rinity

What is the source and inspiration of the churchrsquos local-global mission

Ultimately it is the missional nature passion and actions of the Father Son

and Holy Spirit Godrsquos nature is missional His passion is infectious His

actions are historical redemptive and eternal Te rinity invites the

church into a sending community Te Father sends the Son Te Father

and Son send the Spirit Finally the rinity sends the church in missioninto the world

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of the rinity How does it enable our participation in the mission

and community of the triune God

Association and dialogue Tese need to happen across denominational

cultural ethnic gender and theological traditions and divides Authentic

dialogue is indispensable to the health and mission of the church What dothose marginal to the life of the church have to say to us What do ldquoothersrdquo

have to teach us Other ethnicities and cultures Other socioeconomic

groups Other ages and genders Other theological and confessing tradi-

tions Other persons from times long gone

We need to listen Share Be vulnerable Be authentic Open up to crit-

icism correction and change

We need more than dialogue We need communion and association It is

possible in a qualified way to say that God is present in all the various forms

of the church (ie the various theological ecclesiological sociocultural his-

torical and other permutations of the church) We discern this presence

through attention to Scripture history tradition culture and the Spirit Dis-

cernment involves critical dialogue theological exchange biblical study and

real relationship Only the Spirit of Jesus can enable this

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of association and dialogue

Mission and the missio Dei Te church is missional at its core It serves

obeys and images a missionary God David Bosch says ldquoTe churchrsquos mission

is not secondary to its being the church exists in being sent and in building up

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2536

10486271048626 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

itself for its missionrdquo He goes on to say ldquoEcclesiology does not precede missi-

ology there cannot be church without an intrinsic missionary dimensionrdquo983089983089

Jesus is Lord Lord of his church and Lord of his world His mission de-termines and forms the church His mission shapes the nature purposes

structures ministries and activities of his church Majority World and in-

digenous thinkers help us understand the implications of this mission Tey

help us form glocal theologies of mission Tey reveal ldquomission in context

as transformationrdquo9830891048626

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of mission and the missio Dei Church theology and practice Glocal conversations can inform and

enrich many aspects of the church (when practiced well) Teologies and

practices benefit from robust and critical glocal conversations Tese con-

versations enrich many areas (community spirituality discipleship liturgy

worship hospitality eco-justice education social ethics servantship lib-

eration place suffering beauty and so on)

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-standing of these many dimensions of church and mission

Glocal processes shape these eight themes and their practices We need

to facilitate and enable these conversations and processes Tis is urgent It

must be a priority No theology of mission or missional ecclesiology is ad-

equate without glocal conversations983089983091

T983144983141 L983151983139983137983148 983137983150983140 G983148983151983138983137983148 E983150983154983145983139983144 E983137983139983144 O983156983144983141983154

Glocalization takes the localparticular context and globaluniversal themes

seriously Contextual and global conversations enter an enriching and in-

forming relationship Tese two always have an active and symbiotic rela-

tionship Tis is true whether we deliberately put them into conversation or

not Te local shapes the global and the global shapes the local Many local

11David J Bosch Believing in the Future oward a Missiology o Western Culture (New York

rinity 1048625983097983097983093) 104862798309012izon ransormation Afer Lausanne 1048631-98309713Not all o these themes are dealt with in this present volume since either (1048625) I have dealt with them

in my book Salt Light and a City (983090) they are not all key themes in the writings o the thirty-five

Majority World thinkers considered in this volume or (1048627) there is not adequate space in a book

this size

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2636

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048627

voices converge to form global conversations and theologies Using the Phil-

ippines as a case study izon illustrates this by showing the interdepen-

dence between local and global themes in mission983089983092Dialogue between local and global conversations is critical Kōsuke

Koyama wrote an important book on contextual mission called Water Buffalo

Teology Koyama is a Japanese missionary who served in Chiang Mai

Tailand He writes of the joys and challenges of doing local particular water

buffalo theology He considers the relationship between local theology global

missional themes and transforming cultures ldquoWater Buffalo Teology sees

certain specific challenges Contextualization of theology implies two criticalmovements First to articulate Jesus Christ in culturally appropriate com-

municatively apt words and second to criticize reform dethrone or oppose

culture if it is found to be against what the name of Jesus Christ stands forrdquo9830891048629

Kōsuke Koyama challenges us to recognize what we bring to the task of

local theology For him it was doing theology in Tailand while being Jap-

anese We also need to notice the particular culture wersquore located in as we do

the work of theology Tis means we avoid speaking of an ldquoAsian theologyrdquoldquoAfrican theologyrdquo and the like We need to cultivate local theologies that

engage regional and global themes But these theologies must be ldquodistinctly

localrdquo and a ldquotheology from belowrdquo9830891048630

Simultaneously we need to pursue a reformation of theology and

practice ldquoin the global contextrdquo Tis means entering ldquothe disturbing spa-

ciousness of Jesus Christrdquo Jesus calls us to reject enmity and exceptionalism

We seem him present in our culture language stories and relationships

But we also choose to embrace the ldquootherrdquo We choose to see him present

in other culturesmdashshaping a global people to serve and worship him

joining in his mission983089983095

Kōsuke Koyama roots the gospel in the local contextual and particular

Tis is why he roots his water buffalo theology in Northern Tai culture He

is careful not to say ldquoHere is how you contextualize in your settingrdquo Instead

14izon ransormation Afer Lausanne 1048631-10486251048627 10486251048628983097-98309098308898309015Kōsuke Koyama Water Buffalo Teology 983090983093th anniversary ed (Maryknoll NY Orbis 1048625983097983097983097)

xiii-xv16Kōsuke Koyama ldquoTe Asian Approach to Christrdquo Missiology 1048625983090 no 1048628 (10486259830979830961048628) 10486281048627983093-104862798309617Kōsuke Koyama ldquoReormation in the Global Context Te Disturbing Spaciousness o Jesus Christrdquo

Currents in Teology and Mission 1048627983088 no 983090 (9830909830889830881048627) 10486251048625983097-983090983096

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2736

10486271048628 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

he tells us a story Itrsquos the story of how he contextualized theology in northern

Tailand while being open to global conversations Koyama asks us to form

our own local expressions of church mission and theology At the same timewe must stay attentive to what God is saying and doing beyond that context

Tis way local and global and particular and universal become mutually

enriching conversation partners

G983148983151983139983137983148983145983162983137983156983145983151983150 983137983150983140 H983145983155983156983151983154983145983139983137983148983148983161 S983145983148983141983150983139983141983140 V983151983145983139983141983155

Glocal theologies and conversations pay attention to voices that powers in-

stitutions religions and societies have silenced R S Sugirtharajah pushesback a little on izonrsquos ideas Sugirtharajah says that the church should

privilege local conversations He emphasizes the local contextual and post-

colonial reading of biblical texts9830891048632

Te church needs to listen Te church ought to be attentive to the

theologies and biblical interpretations of groups that cultures and reli-

gions have ignored Historically powerful secular and religious forces

have silenced these groups Tey have marginalized oppressed and colo-nized them It is time for the church to address this injustice We must

start listening to important but silenced voices We need to privilege the

voices of the former victims of Western colonialism We need to develop

postcolonial biblical interpretations theologies and expressions of church

and mission

How do we take such perspectives seriously as we develop glocal conver-

sations How do these themes help us foster vital relationships between local

and global voices

It is time for us to embrace values that enable conversations with those

oen ignored by the church We need values that help us learn from these

groups and individuals

Valuing equal partnership Colonizing powers oppressed silenced and

colonized certain groups At times the church was complicit Tese colo-

nized groups have become ldquoconfident indomitable and indispensable

partners in the dialogue and collaboration with the dispossessed and disad-

18R S Sugirtharajah Asian Biblical Hermeneutics and Postcolonialism Contesting the Interpreta-

tions Te Bible and Liberation Series (Maryknoll NY Orbis 1048625983097983097983096) 1048625983093-1048625983094

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2836

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048629

vantaged in the Westrdquo9830891048633 Tis calls for attentiveness to these voices and re-

sponsiveness to their prophetic challenges It also demands a critical evalu-

ation of colonial readings of Scripture Colonial models of theology andchurch and mission are no longer the benchmark Te global church must

examine them afresh

Valuing equal status Tose on the margins have now taken their rightful

place on the global stage Tey have claimed appropriate and equal status at

the table Subaltern readings of theology church and mission are invaluable

contributors to global theological conversations Tis means that we esteem

them But we also test themWhat do we mean by subaltern Subalterns are those who are down-

trodden and silenced (or have been treated this way in the past) Dominant

or colonizing groups treat them as invisible nonentities Tey enjoy limited

or no access to power Sometimes these are women certain tribal and ethnic

groups and those considered ldquountouchablerdquo In Voices from the Margin Su-

girtharajah provides a platform for postcolonial subaltern readings of

Scripture and theology Tese readings challenge colonialmdashoen Westernmdashreadings of Bible and theology and cultures Tey claim equal status with

other ways of doing theology10486261048624

Valuing equal identity People groups need freedom to explore their new

and emerging identities Tese emerge in response to local and global influ-

ences Local culture is not the only thing at work here Global forces also

shape identity as do imported practices ideas readings rituals and tech-

nologies But each group should be free to explore and construct their par-

ticular forms of Christian identity

Valuing equal interpretations ldquoPostcolonialism is concerned with the

question of cultural and discursive dominationrdquo Colonialism led to op-

pressive and controlling forms of culture and discourse Tese were usually

not contextual or indigenous Western powers for instance brought co-

lonial forms of theology church biblical interpretation and mission1048626983089

Postcolonialism calls for alternative ways of approaching these things Tose

19Ibid 104862598309420R S Sugirtharajah Voices rom the Margin Interpreting the Bible in the Tird World (Maryknoll

NY Orbis 10486259830979830971048625)21Sugirtharajah Asian Biblical Hermeneutics and Postcolonialism 10486251048631

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2936

10486271048630 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

who were once marginalized oppressed and silenced need to lead these fresh

approaches in their own settings Tese then influence global conversations

We need to support the new readings and insights and experiments from thesegroups o be genuine this support must be both critical and collegial

Valuing equal empowerment Sugirtharajah says that postcolonialism is

valuable when it empowers actual communities and real people Post-

colonial thought empowers when it addresses the difficulties hopes and

experiences of ordinary people It should never be about power plays and

the clever use of language Itrsquos pointless if itrsquos obsessed with forming newmdash

and ldquocolonizingrdquomdashtheories Itrsquos a waste of time if itrsquos a self-indulgent pursuitof new and hybrid identities Rather ldquothe worth and credibility of post-

colonial criticism will be judged by how it orchestrates the unique and

fragile and imagined claims of one community against anotherrdquo Empow-

erment happens in a variety of ways One way is contributing equally to

global conversations10486261048626

Al izon examines postcolonialism in the Philippines He says that it can

teach the global church a lot about healthy local-global conversations Fil-ipino contextual theology resists many Western forms of mission and the-

ology It finds them patronizing and controlling Tis indigenous theology

values prophetic sociopolitical engagement in institutions and the society

at large It emphasizes ministry to whole persons and communities It con-

structs a Filipino theology of beauty and mission and worship and com-

munity And it fosters indigenous theological approaches to the spirit world

and cosmology

izon says that postcolonial theology has played a constructive role in

the Philippines But he is uncomfortable with the label postcolonialism He

prefers to describe historical events as ldquobeyond colonialismrdquo And he says

that global conversations enrich local theologies and vice versa1048626983091

Postcolonial thought informs our understanding of the relationship be-

tween the local and global It also shows how theology can emerge at the

intersection between the localparticular and the globaluniversal It re-

minds us that worthwhile glocalization listens to all voices Tis includes

heeding those that have been historically silenced

22Ibid 983090104862823izon ransormation Afer Lausanne 1048625983088983090 10486259830941048631-9830961048631

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3036

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048631

G983148983151983139983137983148983145983162983137983156983145983151983150 983137983150983140 983156983144983141 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

C983151983150983139983148983157983140983145983150983143 R983141983142983148983141983139983156983145983151983150983155

How do we go about developing a model for glocal conversations izon hasrecently provided a useful model that is instructive as we seek to learn from

the Majority World It has at least two key features

First the local is in the global (globalization from below) Global theologies

and ideas have origins in many particular local contexts In that sense glo-

balization is from below Global ideas have local roots Ideas about integral

mission liberation theology and missional church have local origins Tey

have their roots in the prayers hopes discoveries mission and theologiesof thousands of local communities ldquoTe global does not cannot exist

without the localmdashbut the coming together of localities creates a global re-

ality that becomes greater than the sum of its parts it creates a gestalt entity

to which localities make themselves accountablerdquo1048626983092

Second the global is in the local (panlocalization from above) Te con-

cerns and voices of multitudes of locales form global conversations Tese

global discussions can provide a ldquopositive accountabilityrdquo back to local con-texts Tis is true when they enrich affirm serve guide and strengthen local

contexts It is also true when they avoid homogenization control impo-

sition and judgment Glocalization is best when it sees itself as interde-

pendent deeply connected with the local10486261048629

Tatrsquos a helpful starting point But we need to go further Besides izonrsquos

proposals Irsquom convinced that robust glocal conversations cultivate six core

practices

983089 Glocal theology practices its values We root glocal theology in core

values Tese values include solidarity understanding and mutual learning

Do we value fellowship with Christians of all cultures Do we value learning

from them

We prove our values through our practices What practices emerge out of

these values We need to collaborate act collectively and share information

We must find ways to foster grassroots perspectives and local theologies We

need to share stories and learnings and cultivate networks relationships and

partnerships We need attentiveness to local voices and global themes We

24Ibid 9830901048625983088-1048625104862825Ibid 98309010486251048628-1048625983096

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3136

10486271048632 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

ought to find ways to put these local and global voices into conversation

Mutual learning humility and solidarity are key Worthwhile glocal con-

versations can never be merely theoretical or academic It is up to us to rootour values in our practices

983090 Glocal theology practices humility (and it tells a new narrative) We

have noted that the local is in the global and the global is in the local Te

two are interdependent Tey form each other reciprocally Since this is the

case we must practice humility Tere is no place for ethnocentrism colo-

nialism or theological and cultural arrogance I have seen these unhealthy

postures far too oen in Western settingsRecently I attended a missional leadership conference On that occasion

the keynote speakermdasha leading missional author and speakermdashsaid that

North American missional conversations and innovations hold the key to

the future of the Western church Tis Euro American view is wrong (Irsquom

being kind o be frank itrsquos complete nonsense) Itrsquos arrogant and Euro

Americanndashcentric And itrsquos completely out of step with what is happening in

the glocal church We need a new narrativeIn June 1048626104862410486251048627 Te Center for the Study of Global Christianity reported

the top 10486261048624 countries where Christianity has the highest percentage growth

rate Nineteen of the top twenty are in Asia and Africa Eleven of them are

in Muslim majority countries Not a single country from Europe or North

America makes the top twenty list10486261048630

Itrsquos time to cultivate a new narrative Te future of the church is emerging

from the Majority World Rather than North America the churches of

Eastern Asia Western Africa the Arabian Peninsula and other parts of the

Majority World reveal the future of the global church We need the contribu-

tions of all contexts Western indigenous and Majority World All con-

tribute to glocal conversations All are important as we learn from each

other about mission theology and faith But letrsquos stop pretending that North

Americans and Europeans will reveal the future of the global church Letrsquos

start listening to what God is saying about the future of the global church

And hersquos speaking to us through the churches of Asia Africa Latin America

26Russ Mitchell ldquoTe op 983090983088 Countries Where Christianity Is Growing the Fastestrdquo Disciple All

Nations (blog) August 983090983093 98309098308810486251048627 httpsdiscipleallnationswordpresscom98309098308810486251048627983088983096983090983093the-top

-983090983088-countries-where-christianity-is-growing-the-astest

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3236

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048633

Muslim majority settings and so on We must cultivate a new glocal nar-

rativemdashone soaked in humility

Glocal theology must be humble theology Meek theology Receptive the-ology Discerning theology Prayerful theology Dialogical theology De-

pendent theology A theology that celebrates the interdependence between

the localparticular and the globaluniversal

983091 Glocal theology practices expansiveness Glocalization is by nature

comprehensive Local and global influences permeate much of our lives Tese

glocal forces shape our theologies and churches whether we like it or not

But intentionality is also important We need to commit to an expansiveapproach to glocal theology How do we deliberately cultivate glocal conver-

sations in our biblical interpretation Do we foster them in our under-

standing of the person and work of Christ How does glocalization shape

the way the Spirit empowers and constitutes the church How can it form

our understanding of the nature and mission of the rinity How does it

influence the way we practice fellowship and conversation across denomi-

national cultural ethnic economic sociocultural political gender andtheological divides How might it shape our theologies of mission com-

munity beauty spirituality suffering discipleship hospitality eco-justice

place education social ethics Christian leadership and so forth

983092 Glocal theology practices attention Glocal theology doesnrsquot need to

accept all the assumptions or assertions of postcolonial or Majority World

thought But it does need to engage with them and take them seriously

Postcolonial theology for instance gives the marginalized and colonized

and forgotten and silenced both dignity and voice Our glocal conversations

must also include and esteem these groups We need to be attentive to

others weak and powerful female and male dominant and downtrodden

old and young rich and poor privileged and marginalized influential and

subaltern educated and illiterate We need to practice the art of attention

being especially attentive to those who are different to us

983093 Glocal theology practices embrace What do colonial ethnocentric or

Western-centric perspectives do Tey silence Tey control Tey com-

modify Tey institutionalize Tey colonize Tey domesticate Tey replace

Tey import Tey exclude Tey do these things to the beliefs experiences

and practices of other cultures A worthwhile glocal theology refuses to do

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3336

10486281048624 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

these things Instead it adopts a responsive humble celebratory open in-

clusive and embracing attitude

983094 Glocal theology practices discernment Finally we need discernmentas we engage these ideas and practices Discernment is a huge topic thatrsquos

hard to cover comprehensively in a few words Discernment happens when

the Spirit of Christ and his Word renew our minds Te Spirit grants us

spiritual wisdom as we meditate on him and his Word and as we practice

discipleship to Jesus Christ Romans 10486251048626 provides guidance we need (1048625) to be

transformed by the renewal of our minds (1048626) to serve Christrsquos body and (1048627)

to put love into action Discernment also happens in conversation both lo-cally and glocally

I pray these core values and six practices come across in the following

chapters of GlobalChurch

Glocalization can never be just theoretical Are we committed to moving

glocalization from an abstract idea to a living communion Are we deter-

mined to construct a missional theology of the church in the context of

glocal conversations Tis must involve dialogue between Majority Worldindigenous and Western scholars activists and groups

Will glocalization be an abstract notion Or will it be a formative and

genuine communion between local regional and global voices Glocal dy-

namics are at play whether we like it or not Teyrsquore in our churches the-

ologies and missions But we can choose to relinquish isolationist colonial

parochial and arrogant approaches Instead we can adopt responsive dia-

logical learning humble and embracing postures

Trough healthy approaches to glocalization the Spirit challenges us to

value local contexts We immerse ourselves in local and particular commu-

nities and conversations He inspires us to open ourselves to global theo-

logical conversations He rouses us to value the symbiotic relationship be-

tween the localparticular and the globaluniversal

Trough glocal relationships the Spirit leads us to put local contextual

theologies into conversation with global ones He prompts us to explore the

ways in which the local is in the glocal and the global is in the local He per-

suades us to pursue collaboration and dialogue and mutual learning We

engage with Christians from different backgrounds and cultures ecumen-

icals Pentecostals evangelicals and so on from Western indigenous and

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3436

Glocalizing Conversations 10486281048625

Majority World contexts He motivates us to express solidarity between all

parties We appreciate our unity in diversity

Trough glocal conversations the Spirit moves us to ensure that unity andsolidarity emerge from a compelling vision of Jesusrsquo kingdom and gospel

and person He challenges us to share information theology and practices

He urges us to learn from each othermdashour successes and mistakes We seek

glocal solutions

Te Spirit calls us to develop glocal conversations about Christian ideas

and practices Tese include Scripture Evangelicalism ecumenism Pente-

costalism Jesus Christ the Holy Spirit God the Father the rinity com-munity spirituality discipleship liturgy worship hospitality prayer eco-

justice education social ethics Christian leadership gospel and culture

beauty place suffering liberation and so forth

Finally through glocal conversations the Spirit leads us to adopt a new

posture Tis is a responsive humble celebratory open inclusive and em-

bracing attitude to the ldquootherrdquo We do this as a new people made up of every

tribe and language and people and nationTere are dangers in glocalization Sugirtharajah warns of the commodi-

fication of local contextual practices and theologies When this happens

they are ldquosmoothed out of their primary contexts concerns and contesta-

tions travel across borders and become objects of analysis and scrutiny

within an alien secondary contextrdquo1048626983095

Itrsquos common for those of us who are Western to make mistakes when we

wrestle with Majority World and indigenous ideas Sugirtharajah mentions

our tendency to commodify reduce and institutionalize these ideas We also

risk doing these things (1048625) We apply them in noncontextual prescriptive ways

(1048626) We ignore their meanings in their original setting (1048627) We glamorize or

idealize their proponents or their contexts (1048628) We demonize those persons or

contexts (1048629) We disregard them as irrelevant rhetorical or minority discourse

Kevin J Vanhoozer says that we can fall into three traps when we glo-

calize theology (1048625) We can underestimate the theological significance of

local cultures (1048626) We can homogenize cultures and theologies exaggerating

27R S Sugirtharajah ldquoextual ake-Aways Tird World exts in Western Metropolitan Centresrdquo

Black Teology in Britain A Journal o Contextual Praxis 983090 (1048625983097983097983097) 10486271048627 10486271048631 Edward W Said Te

World the ext and the Critic (Cambridge MA Harvard University Press 10486259830979830961048627) 9830901048627983097

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3536

10486281048626 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

ldquothe onerdquo (1048627) We can overemphasize cultural particularity exaggerating ldquothe

manyrdquo and pursue ldquotheological ethnificationrdquo10486261048632

My hope is that GlobalChurch does not fall into the traps Sugirtharajahand Vanhoozer describe I hope that what unfolds in the following chapters

is respectful and discerning I hope it leads to further mutually enriching

conversations between people of different cultures

You the reader face the same challenges You face them in your personal

life ministry context and missional engagements

Will you treat the themes in this book as abstract theoretical notions

Will this be a temporary infatuation a flirtation with the ldquootherrdquo that dissi-pates as suddenly as it arrived Or will glocal conversations become an en-

riching and formative orientation in your life Will glocal conversations

bring fresh approaches to theology faith mission church and worship Will

conversations with other cultures and theologies become for you a com-

pelling way of life

My prayer is that glocal conversations will help the church be a global

visible alternative ldquocity set upon a hillrdquo a truly GlobalChurch

28Craig Ott and Harold A Netland Globalizing Teology Belie and Practice in an Era o World

Christianity (Grand Rapids Baker Academic 983090983088983088983094) 1048625983090983093

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3636

Page 12: GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1236

10486251048632 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

of the church and become the global missional church Christ envisioned

In part one I show how Western conversations are impoverished and

insufficient in isolation from indigenous and Majority World Christians Weenhance our ldquosaltinessrdquo through local-global ( glocal ) exchanges o do this

we must reshape our conversations We need global and local exchanges that

we characterize by mutuality respect partnership and symbiosis Such ex-

changes help us learn from each other whether wersquore in Western indig-

enous or Majority World settings It helps us stay ldquosaltyrdquo It enables us to

pursue global missional theology and practice Globally and locally we can

pursue missional vitality and truly be ldquothe salt of the earthrdquo

P983137983154983156 1048626 L983145983143983144983156 R983141983150983141983159983145983150983143 O983157983154 M983145983155983155983145983151983150

ldquoYou are the light of the world A city on a hill cannot be hidden Neither do

people light a lamp and put it under a bowl Instead they put it on its stand and

it gives light to everyone in the house In the same way let your light shine

before others that they may see your good deeds and glorify your Father in

heavenrdquo (Mt 104862910486251048628-10486251048631) Globally and locally you are the light of the world Be lightLight illuminates reveals and dispels darkness Te church is light when

it does good deedsmdashhealing and liberating and redemptive deeds Itrsquos light

when its being and faith and deeds bring glorify to the Father Te church

is light when it participates in Godrsquos redemptive mission in the world as a

global missional community

o do this we must renew our mission In part two I explore how indig-

enous and Majority World Christians teach us to renew mission We renew

mission through contextualization liberation hospitality Spirit empow-

erment creation care ethics and the transformation of neighborhoods

P983137983154983156 1048627 C983145983156983161 R983141983158983145983156983137983148983145983162983145983150983143 O983157983154 C983144983157983154983139983144983141983155

You are a city set on a hill ldquoA city on a hill cannot be hiddenrdquo Globally and

locally you are a city set on a hill Be a city set on a hill

Tis means that we are an alternative and countercultural movement We

have a distinct culture and politic and social existence We are a people

gathered from every tribe language people and nation We are in the world

but not of the world We are in the world but distinct from the world We are

within the world and for the sake of the world

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1336

Introduction 10486251048633

o be this kind of alternative city or culture we must renew our mission

community ethics and worship We need to pursue the revitalization of our

churches so that they are distinct And by distinct I mean an alternative city(altera civitas)

We are a ldquocity on a hillrdquo that witnesses to Jesus Christ and his eternal kingdom

when we are a global missional church In part three I demonstrate how indig-

enous and Majority World Christians teach us to revitalize churches We revi-

talize churches by indigenizing faith devouring Scripture renewing education

practicing servantship (servant leadership) recovering community and devel-

oping spirituality and discipleship We inspire our churches when we developour theology and practices relating to beauty and the arts9830891048626

In the final chapter I wrap things up by addressing an important question

In light of all the material covered in this book what would it now look like

to engage in global missional theology ecclesiology interpretation history

pneumatology worship and education

Herersquos how you can get the most out of this book

Community You can read this book alone in a small group with somefriends at home or at a coffee shop or as part of a ministry team However

you get a lot more out of this book when you read it with others ogether

you can think about the bookrsquos implications What do the chapters mean for

your ministry church agency family or team

GlobalChurch Project video series Irsquove made a video series to go along with

this book Appendix one has the details

Study guide Yoursquoll get a lot more out of this book if you spend time

working through the study guide in appendix two ry to do this in a group

Te study guide includes reflection questions suggested practices and

Further Reading

Characters As you read this book yoursquoll come across names and people

yoursquove never heard of before For a glimpse of who they are and what issues

concern them see appendix three

My website o help you get the most out of this book Irsquove included more

resources on my website TeGlobalChurchProjectcom Tese include

videos reading lists important links a glossary and other resources Irsquove

12Irsquove put a separate chapter on the theme o beauty and the arts on my website Itrsquos additional to

this book

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1436

10486261048624 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

also provided ways that you can contact me See appendix four

In my first book Salt Light and a City I developed a missional theology

of the church I did this in conversation with twelve theologians from the fourmajor Christian traditions Tat volume offered a window into the thought of

European and American theologians It showed how they are making sense

of the nature and mission of the church in their Western cultural context

Te book that yoursquore now reading takes a different approach I have

stepped away from European and American voices I now ask What can

those in the Majority World and indigenous cultures teach us in the West

What can they teach us about the churchrsquos mission worship theology andcommunity Te quality and quantity of material coming out of the Ma-

jority World is astonishing Any theology that ignores the insights of indig-

enous and Majority World Christians is deficient and impoverished

White middle-class European North American tertiary-educated men

dominate Western theology Tey dominate the Western missional conver-

sation I know I fit that profile Tis group still monopolizes missional church

conferences and seminars Tey get all the book contracts In fact this groupstill controls theology and the church in many settings But this is changing

New voices are rising Tese include women minorities the poor indigenous

groups and Majority World leaders Missional conversations arenrsquot attentive

to the Spirit and to Godrsquos mission if they ignore these voices Majority World

and indigenous churches oen have extraordinary missional vitality Openness

to other voices needs to happen now It is time for Western churches theol-

ogies and mission to mature and to reflect Godrsquos global mission

In this book I could have consulted the work of many thousands of in-

digenous and Majority World thinkers and writers and practitioners But I

have limited myself to a sample of those who speak directly to its themes

Tese African Asian Eastern European Middle Eastern Caribbean Latin

American First Nation and indigenous thinkers challenge us Tey dare us

to examine our theologies and missions and churches And they inspire us

to renew the worship and community and mission of Jesusrsquo church Tey

stir us to think in fresh ways about what it means to be salt light and a city

Tey help us become a global missional churchmdasha truly GlobalChurch

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1536

PA R T O N E

S A L TReshaping Our Conversations

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1636

G L O C A L I Z I N G

C O N V E R S A T I O N S

H983151983159 D983151 W983141 D983141983158983141983148983151983152

G983148983151983139983137983148 C983151983150983158983141983154983155983137983156983145983151983150983155983103

Rather than taking one contextual version of the Gospel and imposing

it as the Gospel throughout the world via the missionary enterprise

the shapers of Mission as ransformation have recognized the

plurality of localities that has created an intercontextual

ldquopan-localrdquo global phenomenon in theology

AL IZON

The International Society for Urban Mission (ISUM) is a group of urban

missionaries who are passionate about cultivating hope and love and re-newal in cities Irsquove connected with this group for some years ISUM held its

first annual Summit on Integral Urban Mission in Bangkok Tailand Te

team from Urban Neighbours of Hope (UNOH) under the leadership of

my Australian friends Ash and Anj Barker organized much of the summit

UNOH teams covenant with God and each other to ldquolive out our passion for

loving God and neighbour Focus on releasing neighbourhoods from urban

poverty Grow through equipping each other neighbours and the broader

church to radically follow Jesus and join Godrsquos Kingdom coming UNOH

workers live and serve in small responsive neighbourhood-based teamsrdquo983089

1See wwwunohorg

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1736

10486261048628 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

Tis summit involved interactive participatory hands-on immersion op-

portunities keynotes lectures and workshops Keynote speakers came from

Africa Australia Myanmar New Zealand North America the PhilippinesSouth America Tailand and First Nations A few hundred Majority World

and Western thinkers and activists came together for those days Tey explored

the theology and practices of integral transformational and urban mission

Tese thinkers and activists pursued a range of aims1048626 Tis included col-

laboration between urban Christians from a variety of backgrounds (Ma-

jority World and Western theologians activists ecumenicals Pentecostals

evangelicals colleges church movements and development agencies) Teyaimed for collective action and thought in an international and integral

context Tey sought to gain mutual understanding for a comprehensive

picture of urban mission around the globe Tey encouraged information

sharing and best practicesmdashlearning from our mistakes and seeking solu-

tions Tey developed recommendations and calls to action to the broader

church Working groups wrote briefing papers aer each summit based on

key issues in urban mission And they endeavored to build trust wisdomand inspiration to better engage our new urban world

Majority World and Western leaders participated in discussion prayer

integral mission and working groups Te goal was to grapple with key issues

and ask key questions How do we recruit equip and sustain urban mission

today How do we release church movements among the urban poor How

can we immerse ourselves in and transform urban neighborhoods How do

we empower urban children and young people How does the church serve

and liberate the oppressedmdashand others suffering from urban injustice What

needs to happen for poorer urban centers to develop economically socially

and spiritually How do we join God in the challenges and opportunities of

multifaith cities

Workshops included urban gardening child protection and collaborating

with local churches in urban mission Workshops also included organic

church growth and mission as well as developing NGO and government

partnerships Groups considered the good the bad and the ugly of short-

term urban mission teams

2Tese aims are detailed at ldquoInternational Society or Urban Mission Summitrdquo httpnewurbanworld

orgsummit

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1836

Glocalizing Conversations 10486261048629

Te summit was a thrilling example of how Majority World and Western

leaders can cooperate It was a time to come together in an environment of

mutual learning and enrichment It was a window into how local contextsand global themes can enrich each other Tis resulted from ISUMrsquos com-

mitment to ldquosolidarity fellowship and insight between urban Christian

leaders in the Western and Majority Worldsrdquo

Te summit was a success due to ISUMrsquos core values What are they983091 Christ-

honoring urban mission values bottom-up grassroots perspectivesmdashrather

than top-down distanced perspectives It allows local theology to reveal new

insights and perspectives about Godrsquos activity It shares insights and experi-ences through narratives embedded within urban poor communities and cities

It cultivates ongoing practical and personal solidarity with the worldrsquos urban

poor Tis Spirit-empowered urban mission honors networks relationships

and partnerships It sees such relationships as the primary method of serving

together It listens to and amplifies the voices of the urban poormdashespecially

those from the Majority World and in particular the 1048625104862410486281048624 window cities It is

attentive to signs of the kingdom of God Urban mission that glorifies God iswilling to reflect and respond with active and sacrificial commitment It shares

and extends the life of the body of Christ among the urban poor

Tis summit was a milestone in urban missiology It enriched communi-

cation between Western and Majority World thinker-activists Tis resulted

from the aims and values Irsquove mentioned Effective urban mission needs to

be a conversation on many levels It is attentive to context and immersed in

local settings It appreciates global and universal missional themes It culti-

vates dialogue between these local-global (glocal) realities It involves

mutual learning between Western and Majority World thinker-activists

Moreover solidarity between all parties is a defining feature Tis solidarity

is due to a compelling vision of the kingdom of God

Tese collaborative glocal features of the ISUM urban mission summit

in Bangkok are critical for the aims of this book GlobalChurch

Majority World indigenous and Western leaders thinkers and churches

can stretch and enrich each other But they need to be open and attentive to

each other Tey need learning postures and open hearts and minds Tey

3ldquoAbout ISUMrdquo httpnewurbanworldorgabout

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1936

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2036

Glocalizing Conversations 10486261048631

always rooted in the local and particularmdashas local churches embody the

gospel and witness to Christ Tese churches forge their own theological

understandings as they do mission together Tey engage in transformationalpractices among the people in their settings Tey enjoy worship mission

and community in their local and particular context Ideally the result is

unique contextual theologies and missions

Simultaneously global conversations form Tey form because of this

multitude of local theologies and practices Local conversations inform and

enrich other local conversations catalyzing global themes and voices izon

observes that the global ldquoowes its existence to local contexts Sharedconvictions among the theologies and practices of local contextual realities

give shape to its global dimensionsrdquo1048629

Majority World indigenous and Western theologies are equally contextual

Tey are equally culture bound Tey are equally particular to their time and

location At times they are all enlightened or myopic liberating or con-

straining humanizing or objectifying beautiful or offensive prophetic or

tepid Te local particular and cultural shape all these theologies Converselythese particular theologies feed and influence global conversations Tere is

no place then for ethnocentrism colonialism or elitism Tere is no place

for theological missional cultural or institutionalized arrogance

Multiple local contexts and voices come togethermdashintentionally or notmdashto

form global themes and theologies Conversely these global realities shape

local contexts oday local contexts must grapple with ldquoan emerging global

culture ie the interacting realities of modernity postmodernity and the

phenomenon of globalizationrdquo1048630 Hence the interdependent and symbiotic

relationship between the localparticular and the globaluniversal We call this

interdependent relationship between the local and the global glocalization

Te global church needs a thrilling glocal exchange We need one that we

characterize by mutuality respect partnership and symbiosis Such ex-

change helps Majority World indigenous and Western churches learn from

each other It enables them to pursue missional theology and practice o-

gether the church becomes a ldquocity on a hillrdquo

5Ibid 10486259830886Ibid 9830961048628

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2136

10486261048632 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

W983144983137983156 R983141983153983157983145983154983141983155 G983148983151983139983137983148983145983162983137983156983145983151983150983103

Te glocal exchange described above needs to be broader than transforma-

tional mission Tis is necessary if the church is to develop a robust inter-cultural and glocal missional ecclesiology

In my first book Salt Light and a City I outlined the foundational

themes of missional ecclesiology983095 Majority World and Western leaders

need to engage these themes in local and contextual ways Teir insights can

then enrich global conversations Tese global conversations in turn shape

local understandings and practices Tis way a glocal appreciation of these

themes emergesLocal regional and global theologies and practices are thereby enriched

Te church becomes healthier and more missionalmdasha truer expression of

the kingdom Te church becomes a fuller witness to Christ his passion for

the nations and his ability to bring unity in diversity

Stephen Bevans and Roger Schroeder outline the six constants of mission

Tese are our theologies about Jesus the church the end times salvation

human nature and culture Bevans and Schroeder describe the relationshipbetween these six and their historical cultural and theological contexts Tis is

why they call these six constants in context Our understanding of these six

constants develops in relation to local and global movements Sometimes local

voices influence our understandings of these six Other times it is regional or

global voices For all of us local regional and global influences are at play at

once Collectively they form our appreciation of the six constants of mission1048632

Here are eight theological themes that the church can develop through

processes of glocalization I presented these in my book Salt Light and a City

Tey are vital to the churchrsquos health mission community and future We

could add many other themes to these eight but these will suffice for now1048633

Scripture Te Scriptures are the infallible authoritative Word of God

Christrsquos Spirit has inspired them Tey have absolute and final authority in

all aspects of corporate and individual faith ethics conduct and witness

Christians interpret and apply Scripture in local contexts and in particular

7Graham Hill Salt Light and a City Introducing Missional Ecclesiology (Eugene OR Wip and

Stock 9830909830881048625983090) 10486251048628983097-983090104863110486288Stephen B Bevans and Roger Schroeder Constants in Context A Teology o Mission or oday

American Society o Missiology Series (Maryknoll NY Orbis 9830909830889830881048628) part one9Tese points first appeared in my book Salt Light and a City xxii-xxiv

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2236

Glocalizing Conversations 10486261048633

social settings Conversely we learn from the interpretations and readings

of other groups

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our local- global theology of Scripture and biblical interpretation

Evangelicalism Pentecostalism missional movements and so forth I

have charismatic missional and evangelical convictions Glocal conversa-

tions help me understand and practice these convictions better

I will use evangelicalism as an example Michael Horton says that our

beliefs and practices are evangelical when they are ldquocommitted to the suffi-

ciency of Scripture the priesthood of all believers the total lostness ofhumans the sole mediation of Christ the gracious efficacy and finality of

Godrsquos redemptive work in Christ through election propitiation calling and

keeping Te linchpin for all of this was the doctrine of justification by grace

alone through faith alone because of Christ alonerdquo9830891048624

Such convictions are necessary if we are to be faithful to the gospel and

to a biblical vision of church and mission Te gospel defines Godrsquos purposes

for humanity the church and the universe Te triune God controls thechurch He is its Lord and Savior Sanctifier and Liberator Master and King

He is completely sovereign over its nature affairs mission and history God

is the churchrsquos only source of grace election atonement salvation and per-

severance Te churchrsquos justification and hope are by grace alone through

faith alone by Christ alone

Herersquos the challenge I face My understanding of evangelicalism is

Western I am a product of the Western theological tradition and my Western

evangelical heritage Much of this is wonderful But I need indigenous and

Majority World evangelicals and others to help me expand and reshape

these insights Te same would be true if I were a Pentecostal

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of our theological traditions and convictions

Jesus Christ We must center our theology on Jesus Christ the Lord of

the church Te church needs to reflect on the person and work of Christ

and respond to him Tis means gathering and going in the name and power

of Christ It means allowing Christrsquos Spirit to shape our community and

10Michael Horton ldquoEvangelical Arminiansrdquo Modern Reormation 1048625 no 1048627 (1048625983097983097983090) 10486251048631

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2336

10486271048624 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

identity and mission It means developing our Christology ecclesiology and

missiology concurrently Te early church developed these three areas and

more in a concurrent and integrated way Tere was no linear progressionTe same is true in the contemporary global church

How can the glocal church best explore its nature structure mission and

hope Trough the centrality and the lordship of Christ

Majority World and indigenous Christians help us appreciate Jesus and

his mission afresh Tey show us how Jesus identifies with the marginalized

outcast oppressed rejected and broken He prefers them We find him

among ldquothe least of theserdquoGlocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of who Jesus Christ is How does it help us appreciate him better

What has Jesus done for and in his church and his world What does he care

about What individual and corporate responsibilities has he given us How

do we express these at local regional and global levels

Te Spirit Missional ecclesiology is inadequate without pneumatological

foundations In other words our theology of church and Spirit go togetherTe Spirit creates and animates the church He empowers it to witness to

Jesus and his gospel Te Spirit enables the church to be a missional trans-

formational community He shapes the church into an alternative society

embodying the reign of God Te church exists for the glory and mission of

Christ Te power and presence of the Spirit enables this mission worship

and glorification

Te Spirit pours out gis on the local-global church ldquofor the common

goodrdquo and ldquoto equip his people for works of service so that the body of Christ

may be built uprdquo Tis includes but isnrsquot limited to the ministry gis mani-

festation gis and motivational gis (1048625 Cor 104862510486261048631 Eph 104862810486251048625-10486251048626 Rom 104862510486261048630-1048632)

Te Spirit forms the glocal church He empowers it for service and

witness He fills it with Christrsquos empowering presence He leads it into the

missio Deimdashthe mission of the Father Son and Holy Spirit

Recently Pentecostal and renewalist movements have grown dramati-

cally in the Majority World Tey have increased in status size and influence

Many have matured theologically Te churches of the West must take notice

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of the power and presence of the Spirit

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2436

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048625

Te rinity Tere are clear limitations to the analogy between the

church and the rinity Te church can only image the rinity Yet the

church is at its best when it reflects the relational and missional passionof the rinity

What is the source and inspiration of the churchrsquos local-global mission

Ultimately it is the missional nature passion and actions of the Father Son

and Holy Spirit Godrsquos nature is missional His passion is infectious His

actions are historical redemptive and eternal Te rinity invites the

church into a sending community Te Father sends the Son Te Father

and Son send the Spirit Finally the rinity sends the church in missioninto the world

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of the rinity How does it enable our participation in the mission

and community of the triune God

Association and dialogue Tese need to happen across denominational

cultural ethnic gender and theological traditions and divides Authentic

dialogue is indispensable to the health and mission of the church What dothose marginal to the life of the church have to say to us What do ldquoothersrdquo

have to teach us Other ethnicities and cultures Other socioeconomic

groups Other ages and genders Other theological and confessing tradi-

tions Other persons from times long gone

We need to listen Share Be vulnerable Be authentic Open up to crit-

icism correction and change

We need more than dialogue We need communion and association It is

possible in a qualified way to say that God is present in all the various forms

of the church (ie the various theological ecclesiological sociocultural his-

torical and other permutations of the church) We discern this presence

through attention to Scripture history tradition culture and the Spirit Dis-

cernment involves critical dialogue theological exchange biblical study and

real relationship Only the Spirit of Jesus can enable this

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of association and dialogue

Mission and the missio Dei Te church is missional at its core It serves

obeys and images a missionary God David Bosch says ldquoTe churchrsquos mission

is not secondary to its being the church exists in being sent and in building up

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2536

10486271048626 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

itself for its missionrdquo He goes on to say ldquoEcclesiology does not precede missi-

ology there cannot be church without an intrinsic missionary dimensionrdquo983089983089

Jesus is Lord Lord of his church and Lord of his world His mission de-termines and forms the church His mission shapes the nature purposes

structures ministries and activities of his church Majority World and in-

digenous thinkers help us understand the implications of this mission Tey

help us form glocal theologies of mission Tey reveal ldquomission in context

as transformationrdquo9830891048626

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of mission and the missio Dei Church theology and practice Glocal conversations can inform and

enrich many aspects of the church (when practiced well) Teologies and

practices benefit from robust and critical glocal conversations Tese con-

versations enrich many areas (community spirituality discipleship liturgy

worship hospitality eco-justice education social ethics servantship lib-

eration place suffering beauty and so on)

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-standing of these many dimensions of church and mission

Glocal processes shape these eight themes and their practices We need

to facilitate and enable these conversations and processes Tis is urgent It

must be a priority No theology of mission or missional ecclesiology is ad-

equate without glocal conversations983089983091

T983144983141 L983151983139983137983148 983137983150983140 G983148983151983138983137983148 E983150983154983145983139983144 E983137983139983144 O983156983144983141983154

Glocalization takes the localparticular context and globaluniversal themes

seriously Contextual and global conversations enter an enriching and in-

forming relationship Tese two always have an active and symbiotic rela-

tionship Tis is true whether we deliberately put them into conversation or

not Te local shapes the global and the global shapes the local Many local

11David J Bosch Believing in the Future oward a Missiology o Western Culture (New York

rinity 1048625983097983097983093) 104862798309012izon ransormation Afer Lausanne 1048631-98309713Not all o these themes are dealt with in this present volume since either (1048625) I have dealt with them

in my book Salt Light and a City (983090) they are not all key themes in the writings o the thirty-five

Majority World thinkers considered in this volume or (1048627) there is not adequate space in a book

this size

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2636

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048627

voices converge to form global conversations and theologies Using the Phil-

ippines as a case study izon illustrates this by showing the interdepen-

dence between local and global themes in mission983089983092Dialogue between local and global conversations is critical Kōsuke

Koyama wrote an important book on contextual mission called Water Buffalo

Teology Koyama is a Japanese missionary who served in Chiang Mai

Tailand He writes of the joys and challenges of doing local particular water

buffalo theology He considers the relationship between local theology global

missional themes and transforming cultures ldquoWater Buffalo Teology sees

certain specific challenges Contextualization of theology implies two criticalmovements First to articulate Jesus Christ in culturally appropriate com-

municatively apt words and second to criticize reform dethrone or oppose

culture if it is found to be against what the name of Jesus Christ stands forrdquo9830891048629

Kōsuke Koyama challenges us to recognize what we bring to the task of

local theology For him it was doing theology in Tailand while being Jap-

anese We also need to notice the particular culture wersquore located in as we do

the work of theology Tis means we avoid speaking of an ldquoAsian theologyrdquoldquoAfrican theologyrdquo and the like We need to cultivate local theologies that

engage regional and global themes But these theologies must be ldquodistinctly

localrdquo and a ldquotheology from belowrdquo9830891048630

Simultaneously we need to pursue a reformation of theology and

practice ldquoin the global contextrdquo Tis means entering ldquothe disturbing spa-

ciousness of Jesus Christrdquo Jesus calls us to reject enmity and exceptionalism

We seem him present in our culture language stories and relationships

But we also choose to embrace the ldquootherrdquo We choose to see him present

in other culturesmdashshaping a global people to serve and worship him

joining in his mission983089983095

Kōsuke Koyama roots the gospel in the local contextual and particular

Tis is why he roots his water buffalo theology in Northern Tai culture He

is careful not to say ldquoHere is how you contextualize in your settingrdquo Instead

14izon ransormation Afer Lausanne 1048631-10486251048627 10486251048628983097-98309098308898309015Kōsuke Koyama Water Buffalo Teology 983090983093th anniversary ed (Maryknoll NY Orbis 1048625983097983097983097)

xiii-xv16Kōsuke Koyama ldquoTe Asian Approach to Christrdquo Missiology 1048625983090 no 1048628 (10486259830979830961048628) 10486281048627983093-104862798309617Kōsuke Koyama ldquoReormation in the Global Context Te Disturbing Spaciousness o Jesus Christrdquo

Currents in Teology and Mission 1048627983088 no 983090 (9830909830889830881048627) 10486251048625983097-983090983096

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2736

10486271048628 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

he tells us a story Itrsquos the story of how he contextualized theology in northern

Tailand while being open to global conversations Koyama asks us to form

our own local expressions of church mission and theology At the same timewe must stay attentive to what God is saying and doing beyond that context

Tis way local and global and particular and universal become mutually

enriching conversation partners

G983148983151983139983137983148983145983162983137983156983145983151983150 983137983150983140 H983145983155983156983151983154983145983139983137983148983148983161 S983145983148983141983150983139983141983140 V983151983145983139983141983155

Glocal theologies and conversations pay attention to voices that powers in-

stitutions religions and societies have silenced R S Sugirtharajah pushesback a little on izonrsquos ideas Sugirtharajah says that the church should

privilege local conversations He emphasizes the local contextual and post-

colonial reading of biblical texts9830891048632

Te church needs to listen Te church ought to be attentive to the

theologies and biblical interpretations of groups that cultures and reli-

gions have ignored Historically powerful secular and religious forces

have silenced these groups Tey have marginalized oppressed and colo-nized them It is time for the church to address this injustice We must

start listening to important but silenced voices We need to privilege the

voices of the former victims of Western colonialism We need to develop

postcolonial biblical interpretations theologies and expressions of church

and mission

How do we take such perspectives seriously as we develop glocal conver-

sations How do these themes help us foster vital relationships between local

and global voices

It is time for us to embrace values that enable conversations with those

oen ignored by the church We need values that help us learn from these

groups and individuals

Valuing equal partnership Colonizing powers oppressed silenced and

colonized certain groups At times the church was complicit Tese colo-

nized groups have become ldquoconfident indomitable and indispensable

partners in the dialogue and collaboration with the dispossessed and disad-

18R S Sugirtharajah Asian Biblical Hermeneutics and Postcolonialism Contesting the Interpreta-

tions Te Bible and Liberation Series (Maryknoll NY Orbis 1048625983097983097983096) 1048625983093-1048625983094

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2836

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048629

vantaged in the Westrdquo9830891048633 Tis calls for attentiveness to these voices and re-

sponsiveness to their prophetic challenges It also demands a critical evalu-

ation of colonial readings of Scripture Colonial models of theology andchurch and mission are no longer the benchmark Te global church must

examine them afresh

Valuing equal status Tose on the margins have now taken their rightful

place on the global stage Tey have claimed appropriate and equal status at

the table Subaltern readings of theology church and mission are invaluable

contributors to global theological conversations Tis means that we esteem

them But we also test themWhat do we mean by subaltern Subalterns are those who are down-

trodden and silenced (or have been treated this way in the past) Dominant

or colonizing groups treat them as invisible nonentities Tey enjoy limited

or no access to power Sometimes these are women certain tribal and ethnic

groups and those considered ldquountouchablerdquo In Voices from the Margin Su-

girtharajah provides a platform for postcolonial subaltern readings of

Scripture and theology Tese readings challenge colonialmdashoen Westernmdashreadings of Bible and theology and cultures Tey claim equal status with

other ways of doing theology10486261048624

Valuing equal identity People groups need freedom to explore their new

and emerging identities Tese emerge in response to local and global influ-

ences Local culture is not the only thing at work here Global forces also

shape identity as do imported practices ideas readings rituals and tech-

nologies But each group should be free to explore and construct their par-

ticular forms of Christian identity

Valuing equal interpretations ldquoPostcolonialism is concerned with the

question of cultural and discursive dominationrdquo Colonialism led to op-

pressive and controlling forms of culture and discourse Tese were usually

not contextual or indigenous Western powers for instance brought co-

lonial forms of theology church biblical interpretation and mission1048626983089

Postcolonialism calls for alternative ways of approaching these things Tose

19Ibid 104862598309420R S Sugirtharajah Voices rom the Margin Interpreting the Bible in the Tird World (Maryknoll

NY Orbis 10486259830979830971048625)21Sugirtharajah Asian Biblical Hermeneutics and Postcolonialism 10486251048631

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2936

10486271048630 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

who were once marginalized oppressed and silenced need to lead these fresh

approaches in their own settings Tese then influence global conversations

We need to support the new readings and insights and experiments from thesegroups o be genuine this support must be both critical and collegial

Valuing equal empowerment Sugirtharajah says that postcolonialism is

valuable when it empowers actual communities and real people Post-

colonial thought empowers when it addresses the difficulties hopes and

experiences of ordinary people It should never be about power plays and

the clever use of language Itrsquos pointless if itrsquos obsessed with forming newmdash

and ldquocolonizingrdquomdashtheories Itrsquos a waste of time if itrsquos a self-indulgent pursuitof new and hybrid identities Rather ldquothe worth and credibility of post-

colonial criticism will be judged by how it orchestrates the unique and

fragile and imagined claims of one community against anotherrdquo Empow-

erment happens in a variety of ways One way is contributing equally to

global conversations10486261048626

Al izon examines postcolonialism in the Philippines He says that it can

teach the global church a lot about healthy local-global conversations Fil-ipino contextual theology resists many Western forms of mission and the-

ology It finds them patronizing and controlling Tis indigenous theology

values prophetic sociopolitical engagement in institutions and the society

at large It emphasizes ministry to whole persons and communities It con-

structs a Filipino theology of beauty and mission and worship and com-

munity And it fosters indigenous theological approaches to the spirit world

and cosmology

izon says that postcolonial theology has played a constructive role in

the Philippines But he is uncomfortable with the label postcolonialism He

prefers to describe historical events as ldquobeyond colonialismrdquo And he says

that global conversations enrich local theologies and vice versa1048626983091

Postcolonial thought informs our understanding of the relationship be-

tween the local and global It also shows how theology can emerge at the

intersection between the localparticular and the globaluniversal It re-

minds us that worthwhile glocalization listens to all voices Tis includes

heeding those that have been historically silenced

22Ibid 983090104862823izon ransormation Afer Lausanne 1048625983088983090 10486259830941048631-9830961048631

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3036

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048631

G983148983151983139983137983148983145983162983137983156983145983151983150 983137983150983140 983156983144983141 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

C983151983150983139983148983157983140983145983150983143 R983141983142983148983141983139983156983145983151983150983155

How do we go about developing a model for glocal conversations izon hasrecently provided a useful model that is instructive as we seek to learn from

the Majority World It has at least two key features

First the local is in the global (globalization from below) Global theologies

and ideas have origins in many particular local contexts In that sense glo-

balization is from below Global ideas have local roots Ideas about integral

mission liberation theology and missional church have local origins Tey

have their roots in the prayers hopes discoveries mission and theologiesof thousands of local communities ldquoTe global does not cannot exist

without the localmdashbut the coming together of localities creates a global re-

ality that becomes greater than the sum of its parts it creates a gestalt entity

to which localities make themselves accountablerdquo1048626983092

Second the global is in the local (panlocalization from above) Te con-

cerns and voices of multitudes of locales form global conversations Tese

global discussions can provide a ldquopositive accountabilityrdquo back to local con-texts Tis is true when they enrich affirm serve guide and strengthen local

contexts It is also true when they avoid homogenization control impo-

sition and judgment Glocalization is best when it sees itself as interde-

pendent deeply connected with the local10486261048629

Tatrsquos a helpful starting point But we need to go further Besides izonrsquos

proposals Irsquom convinced that robust glocal conversations cultivate six core

practices

983089 Glocal theology practices its values We root glocal theology in core

values Tese values include solidarity understanding and mutual learning

Do we value fellowship with Christians of all cultures Do we value learning

from them

We prove our values through our practices What practices emerge out of

these values We need to collaborate act collectively and share information

We must find ways to foster grassroots perspectives and local theologies We

need to share stories and learnings and cultivate networks relationships and

partnerships We need attentiveness to local voices and global themes We

24Ibid 9830901048625983088-1048625104862825Ibid 98309010486251048628-1048625983096

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3136

10486271048632 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

ought to find ways to put these local and global voices into conversation

Mutual learning humility and solidarity are key Worthwhile glocal con-

versations can never be merely theoretical or academic It is up to us to rootour values in our practices

983090 Glocal theology practices humility (and it tells a new narrative) We

have noted that the local is in the global and the global is in the local Te

two are interdependent Tey form each other reciprocally Since this is the

case we must practice humility Tere is no place for ethnocentrism colo-

nialism or theological and cultural arrogance I have seen these unhealthy

postures far too oen in Western settingsRecently I attended a missional leadership conference On that occasion

the keynote speakermdasha leading missional author and speakermdashsaid that

North American missional conversations and innovations hold the key to

the future of the Western church Tis Euro American view is wrong (Irsquom

being kind o be frank itrsquos complete nonsense) Itrsquos arrogant and Euro

Americanndashcentric And itrsquos completely out of step with what is happening in

the glocal church We need a new narrativeIn June 1048626104862410486251048627 Te Center for the Study of Global Christianity reported

the top 10486261048624 countries where Christianity has the highest percentage growth

rate Nineteen of the top twenty are in Asia and Africa Eleven of them are

in Muslim majority countries Not a single country from Europe or North

America makes the top twenty list10486261048630

Itrsquos time to cultivate a new narrative Te future of the church is emerging

from the Majority World Rather than North America the churches of

Eastern Asia Western Africa the Arabian Peninsula and other parts of the

Majority World reveal the future of the global church We need the contribu-

tions of all contexts Western indigenous and Majority World All con-

tribute to glocal conversations All are important as we learn from each

other about mission theology and faith But letrsquos stop pretending that North

Americans and Europeans will reveal the future of the global church Letrsquos

start listening to what God is saying about the future of the global church

And hersquos speaking to us through the churches of Asia Africa Latin America

26Russ Mitchell ldquoTe op 983090983088 Countries Where Christianity Is Growing the Fastestrdquo Disciple All

Nations (blog) August 983090983093 98309098308810486251048627 httpsdiscipleallnationswordpresscom98309098308810486251048627983088983096983090983093the-top

-983090983088-countries-where-christianity-is-growing-the-astest

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3236

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048633

Muslim majority settings and so on We must cultivate a new glocal nar-

rativemdashone soaked in humility

Glocal theology must be humble theology Meek theology Receptive the-ology Discerning theology Prayerful theology Dialogical theology De-

pendent theology A theology that celebrates the interdependence between

the localparticular and the globaluniversal

983091 Glocal theology practices expansiveness Glocalization is by nature

comprehensive Local and global influences permeate much of our lives Tese

glocal forces shape our theologies and churches whether we like it or not

But intentionality is also important We need to commit to an expansiveapproach to glocal theology How do we deliberately cultivate glocal conver-

sations in our biblical interpretation Do we foster them in our under-

standing of the person and work of Christ How does glocalization shape

the way the Spirit empowers and constitutes the church How can it form

our understanding of the nature and mission of the rinity How does it

influence the way we practice fellowship and conversation across denomi-

national cultural ethnic economic sociocultural political gender andtheological divides How might it shape our theologies of mission com-

munity beauty spirituality suffering discipleship hospitality eco-justice

place education social ethics Christian leadership and so forth

983092 Glocal theology practices attention Glocal theology doesnrsquot need to

accept all the assumptions or assertions of postcolonial or Majority World

thought But it does need to engage with them and take them seriously

Postcolonial theology for instance gives the marginalized and colonized

and forgotten and silenced both dignity and voice Our glocal conversations

must also include and esteem these groups We need to be attentive to

others weak and powerful female and male dominant and downtrodden

old and young rich and poor privileged and marginalized influential and

subaltern educated and illiterate We need to practice the art of attention

being especially attentive to those who are different to us

983093 Glocal theology practices embrace What do colonial ethnocentric or

Western-centric perspectives do Tey silence Tey control Tey com-

modify Tey institutionalize Tey colonize Tey domesticate Tey replace

Tey import Tey exclude Tey do these things to the beliefs experiences

and practices of other cultures A worthwhile glocal theology refuses to do

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3336

10486281048624 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

these things Instead it adopts a responsive humble celebratory open in-

clusive and embracing attitude

983094 Glocal theology practices discernment Finally we need discernmentas we engage these ideas and practices Discernment is a huge topic thatrsquos

hard to cover comprehensively in a few words Discernment happens when

the Spirit of Christ and his Word renew our minds Te Spirit grants us

spiritual wisdom as we meditate on him and his Word and as we practice

discipleship to Jesus Christ Romans 10486251048626 provides guidance we need (1048625) to be

transformed by the renewal of our minds (1048626) to serve Christrsquos body and (1048627)

to put love into action Discernment also happens in conversation both lo-cally and glocally

I pray these core values and six practices come across in the following

chapters of GlobalChurch

Glocalization can never be just theoretical Are we committed to moving

glocalization from an abstract idea to a living communion Are we deter-

mined to construct a missional theology of the church in the context of

glocal conversations Tis must involve dialogue between Majority Worldindigenous and Western scholars activists and groups

Will glocalization be an abstract notion Or will it be a formative and

genuine communion between local regional and global voices Glocal dy-

namics are at play whether we like it or not Teyrsquore in our churches the-

ologies and missions But we can choose to relinquish isolationist colonial

parochial and arrogant approaches Instead we can adopt responsive dia-

logical learning humble and embracing postures

Trough healthy approaches to glocalization the Spirit challenges us to

value local contexts We immerse ourselves in local and particular commu-

nities and conversations He inspires us to open ourselves to global theo-

logical conversations He rouses us to value the symbiotic relationship be-

tween the localparticular and the globaluniversal

Trough glocal relationships the Spirit leads us to put local contextual

theologies into conversation with global ones He prompts us to explore the

ways in which the local is in the glocal and the global is in the local He per-

suades us to pursue collaboration and dialogue and mutual learning We

engage with Christians from different backgrounds and cultures ecumen-

icals Pentecostals evangelicals and so on from Western indigenous and

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3436

Glocalizing Conversations 10486281048625

Majority World contexts He motivates us to express solidarity between all

parties We appreciate our unity in diversity

Trough glocal conversations the Spirit moves us to ensure that unity andsolidarity emerge from a compelling vision of Jesusrsquo kingdom and gospel

and person He challenges us to share information theology and practices

He urges us to learn from each othermdashour successes and mistakes We seek

glocal solutions

Te Spirit calls us to develop glocal conversations about Christian ideas

and practices Tese include Scripture Evangelicalism ecumenism Pente-

costalism Jesus Christ the Holy Spirit God the Father the rinity com-munity spirituality discipleship liturgy worship hospitality prayer eco-

justice education social ethics Christian leadership gospel and culture

beauty place suffering liberation and so forth

Finally through glocal conversations the Spirit leads us to adopt a new

posture Tis is a responsive humble celebratory open inclusive and em-

bracing attitude to the ldquootherrdquo We do this as a new people made up of every

tribe and language and people and nationTere are dangers in glocalization Sugirtharajah warns of the commodi-

fication of local contextual practices and theologies When this happens

they are ldquosmoothed out of their primary contexts concerns and contesta-

tions travel across borders and become objects of analysis and scrutiny

within an alien secondary contextrdquo1048626983095

Itrsquos common for those of us who are Western to make mistakes when we

wrestle with Majority World and indigenous ideas Sugirtharajah mentions

our tendency to commodify reduce and institutionalize these ideas We also

risk doing these things (1048625) We apply them in noncontextual prescriptive ways

(1048626) We ignore their meanings in their original setting (1048627) We glamorize or

idealize their proponents or their contexts (1048628) We demonize those persons or

contexts (1048629) We disregard them as irrelevant rhetorical or minority discourse

Kevin J Vanhoozer says that we can fall into three traps when we glo-

calize theology (1048625) We can underestimate the theological significance of

local cultures (1048626) We can homogenize cultures and theologies exaggerating

27R S Sugirtharajah ldquoextual ake-Aways Tird World exts in Western Metropolitan Centresrdquo

Black Teology in Britain A Journal o Contextual Praxis 983090 (1048625983097983097983097) 10486271048627 10486271048631 Edward W Said Te

World the ext and the Critic (Cambridge MA Harvard University Press 10486259830979830961048627) 9830901048627983097

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3536

10486281048626 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

ldquothe onerdquo (1048627) We can overemphasize cultural particularity exaggerating ldquothe

manyrdquo and pursue ldquotheological ethnificationrdquo10486261048632

My hope is that GlobalChurch does not fall into the traps Sugirtharajahand Vanhoozer describe I hope that what unfolds in the following chapters

is respectful and discerning I hope it leads to further mutually enriching

conversations between people of different cultures

You the reader face the same challenges You face them in your personal

life ministry context and missional engagements

Will you treat the themes in this book as abstract theoretical notions

Will this be a temporary infatuation a flirtation with the ldquootherrdquo that dissi-pates as suddenly as it arrived Or will glocal conversations become an en-

riching and formative orientation in your life Will glocal conversations

bring fresh approaches to theology faith mission church and worship Will

conversations with other cultures and theologies become for you a com-

pelling way of life

My prayer is that glocal conversations will help the church be a global

visible alternative ldquocity set upon a hillrdquo a truly GlobalChurch

28Craig Ott and Harold A Netland Globalizing Teology Belie and Practice in an Era o World

Christianity (Grand Rapids Baker Academic 983090983088983088983094) 1048625983090983093

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3636

Page 13: GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1336

Introduction 10486251048633

o be this kind of alternative city or culture we must renew our mission

community ethics and worship We need to pursue the revitalization of our

churches so that they are distinct And by distinct I mean an alternative city(altera civitas)

We are a ldquocity on a hillrdquo that witnesses to Jesus Christ and his eternal kingdom

when we are a global missional church In part three I demonstrate how indig-

enous and Majority World Christians teach us to revitalize churches We revi-

talize churches by indigenizing faith devouring Scripture renewing education

practicing servantship (servant leadership) recovering community and devel-

oping spirituality and discipleship We inspire our churches when we developour theology and practices relating to beauty and the arts9830891048626

In the final chapter I wrap things up by addressing an important question

In light of all the material covered in this book what would it now look like

to engage in global missional theology ecclesiology interpretation history

pneumatology worship and education

Herersquos how you can get the most out of this book

Community You can read this book alone in a small group with somefriends at home or at a coffee shop or as part of a ministry team However

you get a lot more out of this book when you read it with others ogether

you can think about the bookrsquos implications What do the chapters mean for

your ministry church agency family or team

GlobalChurch Project video series Irsquove made a video series to go along with

this book Appendix one has the details

Study guide Yoursquoll get a lot more out of this book if you spend time

working through the study guide in appendix two ry to do this in a group

Te study guide includes reflection questions suggested practices and

Further Reading

Characters As you read this book yoursquoll come across names and people

yoursquove never heard of before For a glimpse of who they are and what issues

concern them see appendix three

My website o help you get the most out of this book Irsquove included more

resources on my website TeGlobalChurchProjectcom Tese include

videos reading lists important links a glossary and other resources Irsquove

12Irsquove put a separate chapter on the theme o beauty and the arts on my website Itrsquos additional to

this book

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1436

10486261048624 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

also provided ways that you can contact me See appendix four

In my first book Salt Light and a City I developed a missional theology

of the church I did this in conversation with twelve theologians from the fourmajor Christian traditions Tat volume offered a window into the thought of

European and American theologians It showed how they are making sense

of the nature and mission of the church in their Western cultural context

Te book that yoursquore now reading takes a different approach I have

stepped away from European and American voices I now ask What can

those in the Majority World and indigenous cultures teach us in the West

What can they teach us about the churchrsquos mission worship theology andcommunity Te quality and quantity of material coming out of the Ma-

jority World is astonishing Any theology that ignores the insights of indig-

enous and Majority World Christians is deficient and impoverished

White middle-class European North American tertiary-educated men

dominate Western theology Tey dominate the Western missional conver-

sation I know I fit that profile Tis group still monopolizes missional church

conferences and seminars Tey get all the book contracts In fact this groupstill controls theology and the church in many settings But this is changing

New voices are rising Tese include women minorities the poor indigenous

groups and Majority World leaders Missional conversations arenrsquot attentive

to the Spirit and to Godrsquos mission if they ignore these voices Majority World

and indigenous churches oen have extraordinary missional vitality Openness

to other voices needs to happen now It is time for Western churches theol-

ogies and mission to mature and to reflect Godrsquos global mission

In this book I could have consulted the work of many thousands of in-

digenous and Majority World thinkers and writers and practitioners But I

have limited myself to a sample of those who speak directly to its themes

Tese African Asian Eastern European Middle Eastern Caribbean Latin

American First Nation and indigenous thinkers challenge us Tey dare us

to examine our theologies and missions and churches And they inspire us

to renew the worship and community and mission of Jesusrsquo church Tey

stir us to think in fresh ways about what it means to be salt light and a city

Tey help us become a global missional churchmdasha truly GlobalChurch

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1536

PA R T O N E

S A L TReshaping Our Conversations

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1636

G L O C A L I Z I N G

C O N V E R S A T I O N S

H983151983159 D983151 W983141 D983141983158983141983148983151983152

G983148983151983139983137983148 C983151983150983158983141983154983155983137983156983145983151983150983155983103

Rather than taking one contextual version of the Gospel and imposing

it as the Gospel throughout the world via the missionary enterprise

the shapers of Mission as ransformation have recognized the

plurality of localities that has created an intercontextual

ldquopan-localrdquo global phenomenon in theology

AL IZON

The International Society for Urban Mission (ISUM) is a group of urban

missionaries who are passionate about cultivating hope and love and re-newal in cities Irsquove connected with this group for some years ISUM held its

first annual Summit on Integral Urban Mission in Bangkok Tailand Te

team from Urban Neighbours of Hope (UNOH) under the leadership of

my Australian friends Ash and Anj Barker organized much of the summit

UNOH teams covenant with God and each other to ldquolive out our passion for

loving God and neighbour Focus on releasing neighbourhoods from urban

poverty Grow through equipping each other neighbours and the broader

church to radically follow Jesus and join Godrsquos Kingdom coming UNOH

workers live and serve in small responsive neighbourhood-based teamsrdquo983089

1See wwwunohorg

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1736

10486261048628 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

Tis summit involved interactive participatory hands-on immersion op-

portunities keynotes lectures and workshops Keynote speakers came from

Africa Australia Myanmar New Zealand North America the PhilippinesSouth America Tailand and First Nations A few hundred Majority World

and Western thinkers and activists came together for those days Tey explored

the theology and practices of integral transformational and urban mission

Tese thinkers and activists pursued a range of aims1048626 Tis included col-

laboration between urban Christians from a variety of backgrounds (Ma-

jority World and Western theologians activists ecumenicals Pentecostals

evangelicals colleges church movements and development agencies) Teyaimed for collective action and thought in an international and integral

context Tey sought to gain mutual understanding for a comprehensive

picture of urban mission around the globe Tey encouraged information

sharing and best practicesmdashlearning from our mistakes and seeking solu-

tions Tey developed recommendations and calls to action to the broader

church Working groups wrote briefing papers aer each summit based on

key issues in urban mission And they endeavored to build trust wisdomand inspiration to better engage our new urban world

Majority World and Western leaders participated in discussion prayer

integral mission and working groups Te goal was to grapple with key issues

and ask key questions How do we recruit equip and sustain urban mission

today How do we release church movements among the urban poor How

can we immerse ourselves in and transform urban neighborhoods How do

we empower urban children and young people How does the church serve

and liberate the oppressedmdashand others suffering from urban injustice What

needs to happen for poorer urban centers to develop economically socially

and spiritually How do we join God in the challenges and opportunities of

multifaith cities

Workshops included urban gardening child protection and collaborating

with local churches in urban mission Workshops also included organic

church growth and mission as well as developing NGO and government

partnerships Groups considered the good the bad and the ugly of short-

term urban mission teams

2Tese aims are detailed at ldquoInternational Society or Urban Mission Summitrdquo httpnewurbanworld

orgsummit

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1836

Glocalizing Conversations 10486261048629

Te summit was a thrilling example of how Majority World and Western

leaders can cooperate It was a time to come together in an environment of

mutual learning and enrichment It was a window into how local contextsand global themes can enrich each other Tis resulted from ISUMrsquos com-

mitment to ldquosolidarity fellowship and insight between urban Christian

leaders in the Western and Majority Worldsrdquo

Te summit was a success due to ISUMrsquos core values What are they983091 Christ-

honoring urban mission values bottom-up grassroots perspectivesmdashrather

than top-down distanced perspectives It allows local theology to reveal new

insights and perspectives about Godrsquos activity It shares insights and experi-ences through narratives embedded within urban poor communities and cities

It cultivates ongoing practical and personal solidarity with the worldrsquos urban

poor Tis Spirit-empowered urban mission honors networks relationships

and partnerships It sees such relationships as the primary method of serving

together It listens to and amplifies the voices of the urban poormdashespecially

those from the Majority World and in particular the 1048625104862410486281048624 window cities It is

attentive to signs of the kingdom of God Urban mission that glorifies God iswilling to reflect and respond with active and sacrificial commitment It shares

and extends the life of the body of Christ among the urban poor

Tis summit was a milestone in urban missiology It enriched communi-

cation between Western and Majority World thinker-activists Tis resulted

from the aims and values Irsquove mentioned Effective urban mission needs to

be a conversation on many levels It is attentive to context and immersed in

local settings It appreciates global and universal missional themes It culti-

vates dialogue between these local-global (glocal) realities It involves

mutual learning between Western and Majority World thinker-activists

Moreover solidarity between all parties is a defining feature Tis solidarity

is due to a compelling vision of the kingdom of God

Tese collaborative glocal features of the ISUM urban mission summit

in Bangkok are critical for the aims of this book GlobalChurch

Majority World indigenous and Western leaders thinkers and churches

can stretch and enrich each other But they need to be open and attentive to

each other Tey need learning postures and open hearts and minds Tey

3ldquoAbout ISUMrdquo httpnewurbanworldorgabout

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1936

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2036

Glocalizing Conversations 10486261048631

always rooted in the local and particularmdashas local churches embody the

gospel and witness to Christ Tese churches forge their own theological

understandings as they do mission together Tey engage in transformationalpractices among the people in their settings Tey enjoy worship mission

and community in their local and particular context Ideally the result is

unique contextual theologies and missions

Simultaneously global conversations form Tey form because of this

multitude of local theologies and practices Local conversations inform and

enrich other local conversations catalyzing global themes and voices izon

observes that the global ldquoowes its existence to local contexts Sharedconvictions among the theologies and practices of local contextual realities

give shape to its global dimensionsrdquo1048629

Majority World indigenous and Western theologies are equally contextual

Tey are equally culture bound Tey are equally particular to their time and

location At times they are all enlightened or myopic liberating or con-

straining humanizing or objectifying beautiful or offensive prophetic or

tepid Te local particular and cultural shape all these theologies Converselythese particular theologies feed and influence global conversations Tere is

no place then for ethnocentrism colonialism or elitism Tere is no place

for theological missional cultural or institutionalized arrogance

Multiple local contexts and voices come togethermdashintentionally or notmdashto

form global themes and theologies Conversely these global realities shape

local contexts oday local contexts must grapple with ldquoan emerging global

culture ie the interacting realities of modernity postmodernity and the

phenomenon of globalizationrdquo1048630 Hence the interdependent and symbiotic

relationship between the localparticular and the globaluniversal We call this

interdependent relationship between the local and the global glocalization

Te global church needs a thrilling glocal exchange We need one that we

characterize by mutuality respect partnership and symbiosis Such ex-

change helps Majority World indigenous and Western churches learn from

each other It enables them to pursue missional theology and practice o-

gether the church becomes a ldquocity on a hillrdquo

5Ibid 10486259830886Ibid 9830961048628

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2136

10486261048632 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

W983144983137983156 R983141983153983157983145983154983141983155 G983148983151983139983137983148983145983162983137983156983145983151983150983103

Te glocal exchange described above needs to be broader than transforma-

tional mission Tis is necessary if the church is to develop a robust inter-cultural and glocal missional ecclesiology

In my first book Salt Light and a City I outlined the foundational

themes of missional ecclesiology983095 Majority World and Western leaders

need to engage these themes in local and contextual ways Teir insights can

then enrich global conversations Tese global conversations in turn shape

local understandings and practices Tis way a glocal appreciation of these

themes emergesLocal regional and global theologies and practices are thereby enriched

Te church becomes healthier and more missionalmdasha truer expression of

the kingdom Te church becomes a fuller witness to Christ his passion for

the nations and his ability to bring unity in diversity

Stephen Bevans and Roger Schroeder outline the six constants of mission

Tese are our theologies about Jesus the church the end times salvation

human nature and culture Bevans and Schroeder describe the relationshipbetween these six and their historical cultural and theological contexts Tis is

why they call these six constants in context Our understanding of these six

constants develops in relation to local and global movements Sometimes local

voices influence our understandings of these six Other times it is regional or

global voices For all of us local regional and global influences are at play at

once Collectively they form our appreciation of the six constants of mission1048632

Here are eight theological themes that the church can develop through

processes of glocalization I presented these in my book Salt Light and a City

Tey are vital to the churchrsquos health mission community and future We

could add many other themes to these eight but these will suffice for now1048633

Scripture Te Scriptures are the infallible authoritative Word of God

Christrsquos Spirit has inspired them Tey have absolute and final authority in

all aspects of corporate and individual faith ethics conduct and witness

Christians interpret and apply Scripture in local contexts and in particular

7Graham Hill Salt Light and a City Introducing Missional Ecclesiology (Eugene OR Wip and

Stock 9830909830881048625983090) 10486251048628983097-983090104863110486288Stephen B Bevans and Roger Schroeder Constants in Context A Teology o Mission or oday

American Society o Missiology Series (Maryknoll NY Orbis 9830909830889830881048628) part one9Tese points first appeared in my book Salt Light and a City xxii-xxiv

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2236

Glocalizing Conversations 10486261048633

social settings Conversely we learn from the interpretations and readings

of other groups

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our local- global theology of Scripture and biblical interpretation

Evangelicalism Pentecostalism missional movements and so forth I

have charismatic missional and evangelical convictions Glocal conversa-

tions help me understand and practice these convictions better

I will use evangelicalism as an example Michael Horton says that our

beliefs and practices are evangelical when they are ldquocommitted to the suffi-

ciency of Scripture the priesthood of all believers the total lostness ofhumans the sole mediation of Christ the gracious efficacy and finality of

Godrsquos redemptive work in Christ through election propitiation calling and

keeping Te linchpin for all of this was the doctrine of justification by grace

alone through faith alone because of Christ alonerdquo9830891048624

Such convictions are necessary if we are to be faithful to the gospel and

to a biblical vision of church and mission Te gospel defines Godrsquos purposes

for humanity the church and the universe Te triune God controls thechurch He is its Lord and Savior Sanctifier and Liberator Master and King

He is completely sovereign over its nature affairs mission and history God

is the churchrsquos only source of grace election atonement salvation and per-

severance Te churchrsquos justification and hope are by grace alone through

faith alone by Christ alone

Herersquos the challenge I face My understanding of evangelicalism is

Western I am a product of the Western theological tradition and my Western

evangelical heritage Much of this is wonderful But I need indigenous and

Majority World evangelicals and others to help me expand and reshape

these insights Te same would be true if I were a Pentecostal

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of our theological traditions and convictions

Jesus Christ We must center our theology on Jesus Christ the Lord of

the church Te church needs to reflect on the person and work of Christ

and respond to him Tis means gathering and going in the name and power

of Christ It means allowing Christrsquos Spirit to shape our community and

10Michael Horton ldquoEvangelical Arminiansrdquo Modern Reormation 1048625 no 1048627 (1048625983097983097983090) 10486251048631

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2336

10486271048624 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

identity and mission It means developing our Christology ecclesiology and

missiology concurrently Te early church developed these three areas and

more in a concurrent and integrated way Tere was no linear progressionTe same is true in the contemporary global church

How can the glocal church best explore its nature structure mission and

hope Trough the centrality and the lordship of Christ

Majority World and indigenous Christians help us appreciate Jesus and

his mission afresh Tey show us how Jesus identifies with the marginalized

outcast oppressed rejected and broken He prefers them We find him

among ldquothe least of theserdquoGlocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of who Jesus Christ is How does it help us appreciate him better

What has Jesus done for and in his church and his world What does he care

about What individual and corporate responsibilities has he given us How

do we express these at local regional and global levels

Te Spirit Missional ecclesiology is inadequate without pneumatological

foundations In other words our theology of church and Spirit go togetherTe Spirit creates and animates the church He empowers it to witness to

Jesus and his gospel Te Spirit enables the church to be a missional trans-

formational community He shapes the church into an alternative society

embodying the reign of God Te church exists for the glory and mission of

Christ Te power and presence of the Spirit enables this mission worship

and glorification

Te Spirit pours out gis on the local-global church ldquofor the common

goodrdquo and ldquoto equip his people for works of service so that the body of Christ

may be built uprdquo Tis includes but isnrsquot limited to the ministry gis mani-

festation gis and motivational gis (1048625 Cor 104862510486261048631 Eph 104862810486251048625-10486251048626 Rom 104862510486261048630-1048632)

Te Spirit forms the glocal church He empowers it for service and

witness He fills it with Christrsquos empowering presence He leads it into the

missio Deimdashthe mission of the Father Son and Holy Spirit

Recently Pentecostal and renewalist movements have grown dramati-

cally in the Majority World Tey have increased in status size and influence

Many have matured theologically Te churches of the West must take notice

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of the power and presence of the Spirit

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2436

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048625

Te rinity Tere are clear limitations to the analogy between the

church and the rinity Te church can only image the rinity Yet the

church is at its best when it reflects the relational and missional passionof the rinity

What is the source and inspiration of the churchrsquos local-global mission

Ultimately it is the missional nature passion and actions of the Father Son

and Holy Spirit Godrsquos nature is missional His passion is infectious His

actions are historical redemptive and eternal Te rinity invites the

church into a sending community Te Father sends the Son Te Father

and Son send the Spirit Finally the rinity sends the church in missioninto the world

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of the rinity How does it enable our participation in the mission

and community of the triune God

Association and dialogue Tese need to happen across denominational

cultural ethnic gender and theological traditions and divides Authentic

dialogue is indispensable to the health and mission of the church What dothose marginal to the life of the church have to say to us What do ldquoothersrdquo

have to teach us Other ethnicities and cultures Other socioeconomic

groups Other ages and genders Other theological and confessing tradi-

tions Other persons from times long gone

We need to listen Share Be vulnerable Be authentic Open up to crit-

icism correction and change

We need more than dialogue We need communion and association It is

possible in a qualified way to say that God is present in all the various forms

of the church (ie the various theological ecclesiological sociocultural his-

torical and other permutations of the church) We discern this presence

through attention to Scripture history tradition culture and the Spirit Dis-

cernment involves critical dialogue theological exchange biblical study and

real relationship Only the Spirit of Jesus can enable this

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of association and dialogue

Mission and the missio Dei Te church is missional at its core It serves

obeys and images a missionary God David Bosch says ldquoTe churchrsquos mission

is not secondary to its being the church exists in being sent and in building up

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2536

10486271048626 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

itself for its missionrdquo He goes on to say ldquoEcclesiology does not precede missi-

ology there cannot be church without an intrinsic missionary dimensionrdquo983089983089

Jesus is Lord Lord of his church and Lord of his world His mission de-termines and forms the church His mission shapes the nature purposes

structures ministries and activities of his church Majority World and in-

digenous thinkers help us understand the implications of this mission Tey

help us form glocal theologies of mission Tey reveal ldquomission in context

as transformationrdquo9830891048626

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of mission and the missio Dei Church theology and practice Glocal conversations can inform and

enrich many aspects of the church (when practiced well) Teologies and

practices benefit from robust and critical glocal conversations Tese con-

versations enrich many areas (community spirituality discipleship liturgy

worship hospitality eco-justice education social ethics servantship lib-

eration place suffering beauty and so on)

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-standing of these many dimensions of church and mission

Glocal processes shape these eight themes and their practices We need

to facilitate and enable these conversations and processes Tis is urgent It

must be a priority No theology of mission or missional ecclesiology is ad-

equate without glocal conversations983089983091

T983144983141 L983151983139983137983148 983137983150983140 G983148983151983138983137983148 E983150983154983145983139983144 E983137983139983144 O983156983144983141983154

Glocalization takes the localparticular context and globaluniversal themes

seriously Contextual and global conversations enter an enriching and in-

forming relationship Tese two always have an active and symbiotic rela-

tionship Tis is true whether we deliberately put them into conversation or

not Te local shapes the global and the global shapes the local Many local

11David J Bosch Believing in the Future oward a Missiology o Western Culture (New York

rinity 1048625983097983097983093) 104862798309012izon ransormation Afer Lausanne 1048631-98309713Not all o these themes are dealt with in this present volume since either (1048625) I have dealt with them

in my book Salt Light and a City (983090) they are not all key themes in the writings o the thirty-five

Majority World thinkers considered in this volume or (1048627) there is not adequate space in a book

this size

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2636

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048627

voices converge to form global conversations and theologies Using the Phil-

ippines as a case study izon illustrates this by showing the interdepen-

dence between local and global themes in mission983089983092Dialogue between local and global conversations is critical Kōsuke

Koyama wrote an important book on contextual mission called Water Buffalo

Teology Koyama is a Japanese missionary who served in Chiang Mai

Tailand He writes of the joys and challenges of doing local particular water

buffalo theology He considers the relationship between local theology global

missional themes and transforming cultures ldquoWater Buffalo Teology sees

certain specific challenges Contextualization of theology implies two criticalmovements First to articulate Jesus Christ in culturally appropriate com-

municatively apt words and second to criticize reform dethrone or oppose

culture if it is found to be against what the name of Jesus Christ stands forrdquo9830891048629

Kōsuke Koyama challenges us to recognize what we bring to the task of

local theology For him it was doing theology in Tailand while being Jap-

anese We also need to notice the particular culture wersquore located in as we do

the work of theology Tis means we avoid speaking of an ldquoAsian theologyrdquoldquoAfrican theologyrdquo and the like We need to cultivate local theologies that

engage regional and global themes But these theologies must be ldquodistinctly

localrdquo and a ldquotheology from belowrdquo9830891048630

Simultaneously we need to pursue a reformation of theology and

practice ldquoin the global contextrdquo Tis means entering ldquothe disturbing spa-

ciousness of Jesus Christrdquo Jesus calls us to reject enmity and exceptionalism

We seem him present in our culture language stories and relationships

But we also choose to embrace the ldquootherrdquo We choose to see him present

in other culturesmdashshaping a global people to serve and worship him

joining in his mission983089983095

Kōsuke Koyama roots the gospel in the local contextual and particular

Tis is why he roots his water buffalo theology in Northern Tai culture He

is careful not to say ldquoHere is how you contextualize in your settingrdquo Instead

14izon ransormation Afer Lausanne 1048631-10486251048627 10486251048628983097-98309098308898309015Kōsuke Koyama Water Buffalo Teology 983090983093th anniversary ed (Maryknoll NY Orbis 1048625983097983097983097)

xiii-xv16Kōsuke Koyama ldquoTe Asian Approach to Christrdquo Missiology 1048625983090 no 1048628 (10486259830979830961048628) 10486281048627983093-104862798309617Kōsuke Koyama ldquoReormation in the Global Context Te Disturbing Spaciousness o Jesus Christrdquo

Currents in Teology and Mission 1048627983088 no 983090 (9830909830889830881048627) 10486251048625983097-983090983096

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2736

10486271048628 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

he tells us a story Itrsquos the story of how he contextualized theology in northern

Tailand while being open to global conversations Koyama asks us to form

our own local expressions of church mission and theology At the same timewe must stay attentive to what God is saying and doing beyond that context

Tis way local and global and particular and universal become mutually

enriching conversation partners

G983148983151983139983137983148983145983162983137983156983145983151983150 983137983150983140 H983145983155983156983151983154983145983139983137983148983148983161 S983145983148983141983150983139983141983140 V983151983145983139983141983155

Glocal theologies and conversations pay attention to voices that powers in-

stitutions religions and societies have silenced R S Sugirtharajah pushesback a little on izonrsquos ideas Sugirtharajah says that the church should

privilege local conversations He emphasizes the local contextual and post-

colonial reading of biblical texts9830891048632

Te church needs to listen Te church ought to be attentive to the

theologies and biblical interpretations of groups that cultures and reli-

gions have ignored Historically powerful secular and religious forces

have silenced these groups Tey have marginalized oppressed and colo-nized them It is time for the church to address this injustice We must

start listening to important but silenced voices We need to privilege the

voices of the former victims of Western colonialism We need to develop

postcolonial biblical interpretations theologies and expressions of church

and mission

How do we take such perspectives seriously as we develop glocal conver-

sations How do these themes help us foster vital relationships between local

and global voices

It is time for us to embrace values that enable conversations with those

oen ignored by the church We need values that help us learn from these

groups and individuals

Valuing equal partnership Colonizing powers oppressed silenced and

colonized certain groups At times the church was complicit Tese colo-

nized groups have become ldquoconfident indomitable and indispensable

partners in the dialogue and collaboration with the dispossessed and disad-

18R S Sugirtharajah Asian Biblical Hermeneutics and Postcolonialism Contesting the Interpreta-

tions Te Bible and Liberation Series (Maryknoll NY Orbis 1048625983097983097983096) 1048625983093-1048625983094

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2836

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048629

vantaged in the Westrdquo9830891048633 Tis calls for attentiveness to these voices and re-

sponsiveness to their prophetic challenges It also demands a critical evalu-

ation of colonial readings of Scripture Colonial models of theology andchurch and mission are no longer the benchmark Te global church must

examine them afresh

Valuing equal status Tose on the margins have now taken their rightful

place on the global stage Tey have claimed appropriate and equal status at

the table Subaltern readings of theology church and mission are invaluable

contributors to global theological conversations Tis means that we esteem

them But we also test themWhat do we mean by subaltern Subalterns are those who are down-

trodden and silenced (or have been treated this way in the past) Dominant

or colonizing groups treat them as invisible nonentities Tey enjoy limited

or no access to power Sometimes these are women certain tribal and ethnic

groups and those considered ldquountouchablerdquo In Voices from the Margin Su-

girtharajah provides a platform for postcolonial subaltern readings of

Scripture and theology Tese readings challenge colonialmdashoen Westernmdashreadings of Bible and theology and cultures Tey claim equal status with

other ways of doing theology10486261048624

Valuing equal identity People groups need freedom to explore their new

and emerging identities Tese emerge in response to local and global influ-

ences Local culture is not the only thing at work here Global forces also

shape identity as do imported practices ideas readings rituals and tech-

nologies But each group should be free to explore and construct their par-

ticular forms of Christian identity

Valuing equal interpretations ldquoPostcolonialism is concerned with the

question of cultural and discursive dominationrdquo Colonialism led to op-

pressive and controlling forms of culture and discourse Tese were usually

not contextual or indigenous Western powers for instance brought co-

lonial forms of theology church biblical interpretation and mission1048626983089

Postcolonialism calls for alternative ways of approaching these things Tose

19Ibid 104862598309420R S Sugirtharajah Voices rom the Margin Interpreting the Bible in the Tird World (Maryknoll

NY Orbis 10486259830979830971048625)21Sugirtharajah Asian Biblical Hermeneutics and Postcolonialism 10486251048631

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2936

10486271048630 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

who were once marginalized oppressed and silenced need to lead these fresh

approaches in their own settings Tese then influence global conversations

We need to support the new readings and insights and experiments from thesegroups o be genuine this support must be both critical and collegial

Valuing equal empowerment Sugirtharajah says that postcolonialism is

valuable when it empowers actual communities and real people Post-

colonial thought empowers when it addresses the difficulties hopes and

experiences of ordinary people It should never be about power plays and

the clever use of language Itrsquos pointless if itrsquos obsessed with forming newmdash

and ldquocolonizingrdquomdashtheories Itrsquos a waste of time if itrsquos a self-indulgent pursuitof new and hybrid identities Rather ldquothe worth and credibility of post-

colonial criticism will be judged by how it orchestrates the unique and

fragile and imagined claims of one community against anotherrdquo Empow-

erment happens in a variety of ways One way is contributing equally to

global conversations10486261048626

Al izon examines postcolonialism in the Philippines He says that it can

teach the global church a lot about healthy local-global conversations Fil-ipino contextual theology resists many Western forms of mission and the-

ology It finds them patronizing and controlling Tis indigenous theology

values prophetic sociopolitical engagement in institutions and the society

at large It emphasizes ministry to whole persons and communities It con-

structs a Filipino theology of beauty and mission and worship and com-

munity And it fosters indigenous theological approaches to the spirit world

and cosmology

izon says that postcolonial theology has played a constructive role in

the Philippines But he is uncomfortable with the label postcolonialism He

prefers to describe historical events as ldquobeyond colonialismrdquo And he says

that global conversations enrich local theologies and vice versa1048626983091

Postcolonial thought informs our understanding of the relationship be-

tween the local and global It also shows how theology can emerge at the

intersection between the localparticular and the globaluniversal It re-

minds us that worthwhile glocalization listens to all voices Tis includes

heeding those that have been historically silenced

22Ibid 983090104862823izon ransormation Afer Lausanne 1048625983088983090 10486259830941048631-9830961048631

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3036

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048631

G983148983151983139983137983148983145983162983137983156983145983151983150 983137983150983140 983156983144983141 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

C983151983150983139983148983157983140983145983150983143 R983141983142983148983141983139983156983145983151983150983155

How do we go about developing a model for glocal conversations izon hasrecently provided a useful model that is instructive as we seek to learn from

the Majority World It has at least two key features

First the local is in the global (globalization from below) Global theologies

and ideas have origins in many particular local contexts In that sense glo-

balization is from below Global ideas have local roots Ideas about integral

mission liberation theology and missional church have local origins Tey

have their roots in the prayers hopes discoveries mission and theologiesof thousands of local communities ldquoTe global does not cannot exist

without the localmdashbut the coming together of localities creates a global re-

ality that becomes greater than the sum of its parts it creates a gestalt entity

to which localities make themselves accountablerdquo1048626983092

Second the global is in the local (panlocalization from above) Te con-

cerns and voices of multitudes of locales form global conversations Tese

global discussions can provide a ldquopositive accountabilityrdquo back to local con-texts Tis is true when they enrich affirm serve guide and strengthen local

contexts It is also true when they avoid homogenization control impo-

sition and judgment Glocalization is best when it sees itself as interde-

pendent deeply connected with the local10486261048629

Tatrsquos a helpful starting point But we need to go further Besides izonrsquos

proposals Irsquom convinced that robust glocal conversations cultivate six core

practices

983089 Glocal theology practices its values We root glocal theology in core

values Tese values include solidarity understanding and mutual learning

Do we value fellowship with Christians of all cultures Do we value learning

from them

We prove our values through our practices What practices emerge out of

these values We need to collaborate act collectively and share information

We must find ways to foster grassroots perspectives and local theologies We

need to share stories and learnings and cultivate networks relationships and

partnerships We need attentiveness to local voices and global themes We

24Ibid 9830901048625983088-1048625104862825Ibid 98309010486251048628-1048625983096

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3136

10486271048632 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

ought to find ways to put these local and global voices into conversation

Mutual learning humility and solidarity are key Worthwhile glocal con-

versations can never be merely theoretical or academic It is up to us to rootour values in our practices

983090 Glocal theology practices humility (and it tells a new narrative) We

have noted that the local is in the global and the global is in the local Te

two are interdependent Tey form each other reciprocally Since this is the

case we must practice humility Tere is no place for ethnocentrism colo-

nialism or theological and cultural arrogance I have seen these unhealthy

postures far too oen in Western settingsRecently I attended a missional leadership conference On that occasion

the keynote speakermdasha leading missional author and speakermdashsaid that

North American missional conversations and innovations hold the key to

the future of the Western church Tis Euro American view is wrong (Irsquom

being kind o be frank itrsquos complete nonsense) Itrsquos arrogant and Euro

Americanndashcentric And itrsquos completely out of step with what is happening in

the glocal church We need a new narrativeIn June 1048626104862410486251048627 Te Center for the Study of Global Christianity reported

the top 10486261048624 countries where Christianity has the highest percentage growth

rate Nineteen of the top twenty are in Asia and Africa Eleven of them are

in Muslim majority countries Not a single country from Europe or North

America makes the top twenty list10486261048630

Itrsquos time to cultivate a new narrative Te future of the church is emerging

from the Majority World Rather than North America the churches of

Eastern Asia Western Africa the Arabian Peninsula and other parts of the

Majority World reveal the future of the global church We need the contribu-

tions of all contexts Western indigenous and Majority World All con-

tribute to glocal conversations All are important as we learn from each

other about mission theology and faith But letrsquos stop pretending that North

Americans and Europeans will reveal the future of the global church Letrsquos

start listening to what God is saying about the future of the global church

And hersquos speaking to us through the churches of Asia Africa Latin America

26Russ Mitchell ldquoTe op 983090983088 Countries Where Christianity Is Growing the Fastestrdquo Disciple All

Nations (blog) August 983090983093 98309098308810486251048627 httpsdiscipleallnationswordpresscom98309098308810486251048627983088983096983090983093the-top

-983090983088-countries-where-christianity-is-growing-the-astest

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3236

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048633

Muslim majority settings and so on We must cultivate a new glocal nar-

rativemdashone soaked in humility

Glocal theology must be humble theology Meek theology Receptive the-ology Discerning theology Prayerful theology Dialogical theology De-

pendent theology A theology that celebrates the interdependence between

the localparticular and the globaluniversal

983091 Glocal theology practices expansiveness Glocalization is by nature

comprehensive Local and global influences permeate much of our lives Tese

glocal forces shape our theologies and churches whether we like it or not

But intentionality is also important We need to commit to an expansiveapproach to glocal theology How do we deliberately cultivate glocal conver-

sations in our biblical interpretation Do we foster them in our under-

standing of the person and work of Christ How does glocalization shape

the way the Spirit empowers and constitutes the church How can it form

our understanding of the nature and mission of the rinity How does it

influence the way we practice fellowship and conversation across denomi-

national cultural ethnic economic sociocultural political gender andtheological divides How might it shape our theologies of mission com-

munity beauty spirituality suffering discipleship hospitality eco-justice

place education social ethics Christian leadership and so forth

983092 Glocal theology practices attention Glocal theology doesnrsquot need to

accept all the assumptions or assertions of postcolonial or Majority World

thought But it does need to engage with them and take them seriously

Postcolonial theology for instance gives the marginalized and colonized

and forgotten and silenced both dignity and voice Our glocal conversations

must also include and esteem these groups We need to be attentive to

others weak and powerful female and male dominant and downtrodden

old and young rich and poor privileged and marginalized influential and

subaltern educated and illiterate We need to practice the art of attention

being especially attentive to those who are different to us

983093 Glocal theology practices embrace What do colonial ethnocentric or

Western-centric perspectives do Tey silence Tey control Tey com-

modify Tey institutionalize Tey colonize Tey domesticate Tey replace

Tey import Tey exclude Tey do these things to the beliefs experiences

and practices of other cultures A worthwhile glocal theology refuses to do

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3336

10486281048624 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

these things Instead it adopts a responsive humble celebratory open in-

clusive and embracing attitude

983094 Glocal theology practices discernment Finally we need discernmentas we engage these ideas and practices Discernment is a huge topic thatrsquos

hard to cover comprehensively in a few words Discernment happens when

the Spirit of Christ and his Word renew our minds Te Spirit grants us

spiritual wisdom as we meditate on him and his Word and as we practice

discipleship to Jesus Christ Romans 10486251048626 provides guidance we need (1048625) to be

transformed by the renewal of our minds (1048626) to serve Christrsquos body and (1048627)

to put love into action Discernment also happens in conversation both lo-cally and glocally

I pray these core values and six practices come across in the following

chapters of GlobalChurch

Glocalization can never be just theoretical Are we committed to moving

glocalization from an abstract idea to a living communion Are we deter-

mined to construct a missional theology of the church in the context of

glocal conversations Tis must involve dialogue between Majority Worldindigenous and Western scholars activists and groups

Will glocalization be an abstract notion Or will it be a formative and

genuine communion between local regional and global voices Glocal dy-

namics are at play whether we like it or not Teyrsquore in our churches the-

ologies and missions But we can choose to relinquish isolationist colonial

parochial and arrogant approaches Instead we can adopt responsive dia-

logical learning humble and embracing postures

Trough healthy approaches to glocalization the Spirit challenges us to

value local contexts We immerse ourselves in local and particular commu-

nities and conversations He inspires us to open ourselves to global theo-

logical conversations He rouses us to value the symbiotic relationship be-

tween the localparticular and the globaluniversal

Trough glocal relationships the Spirit leads us to put local contextual

theologies into conversation with global ones He prompts us to explore the

ways in which the local is in the glocal and the global is in the local He per-

suades us to pursue collaboration and dialogue and mutual learning We

engage with Christians from different backgrounds and cultures ecumen-

icals Pentecostals evangelicals and so on from Western indigenous and

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3436

Glocalizing Conversations 10486281048625

Majority World contexts He motivates us to express solidarity between all

parties We appreciate our unity in diversity

Trough glocal conversations the Spirit moves us to ensure that unity andsolidarity emerge from a compelling vision of Jesusrsquo kingdom and gospel

and person He challenges us to share information theology and practices

He urges us to learn from each othermdashour successes and mistakes We seek

glocal solutions

Te Spirit calls us to develop glocal conversations about Christian ideas

and practices Tese include Scripture Evangelicalism ecumenism Pente-

costalism Jesus Christ the Holy Spirit God the Father the rinity com-munity spirituality discipleship liturgy worship hospitality prayer eco-

justice education social ethics Christian leadership gospel and culture

beauty place suffering liberation and so forth

Finally through glocal conversations the Spirit leads us to adopt a new

posture Tis is a responsive humble celebratory open inclusive and em-

bracing attitude to the ldquootherrdquo We do this as a new people made up of every

tribe and language and people and nationTere are dangers in glocalization Sugirtharajah warns of the commodi-

fication of local contextual practices and theologies When this happens

they are ldquosmoothed out of their primary contexts concerns and contesta-

tions travel across borders and become objects of analysis and scrutiny

within an alien secondary contextrdquo1048626983095

Itrsquos common for those of us who are Western to make mistakes when we

wrestle with Majority World and indigenous ideas Sugirtharajah mentions

our tendency to commodify reduce and institutionalize these ideas We also

risk doing these things (1048625) We apply them in noncontextual prescriptive ways

(1048626) We ignore their meanings in their original setting (1048627) We glamorize or

idealize their proponents or their contexts (1048628) We demonize those persons or

contexts (1048629) We disregard them as irrelevant rhetorical or minority discourse

Kevin J Vanhoozer says that we can fall into three traps when we glo-

calize theology (1048625) We can underestimate the theological significance of

local cultures (1048626) We can homogenize cultures and theologies exaggerating

27R S Sugirtharajah ldquoextual ake-Aways Tird World exts in Western Metropolitan Centresrdquo

Black Teology in Britain A Journal o Contextual Praxis 983090 (1048625983097983097983097) 10486271048627 10486271048631 Edward W Said Te

World the ext and the Critic (Cambridge MA Harvard University Press 10486259830979830961048627) 9830901048627983097

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3536

10486281048626 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

ldquothe onerdquo (1048627) We can overemphasize cultural particularity exaggerating ldquothe

manyrdquo and pursue ldquotheological ethnificationrdquo10486261048632

My hope is that GlobalChurch does not fall into the traps Sugirtharajahand Vanhoozer describe I hope that what unfolds in the following chapters

is respectful and discerning I hope it leads to further mutually enriching

conversations between people of different cultures

You the reader face the same challenges You face them in your personal

life ministry context and missional engagements

Will you treat the themes in this book as abstract theoretical notions

Will this be a temporary infatuation a flirtation with the ldquootherrdquo that dissi-pates as suddenly as it arrived Or will glocal conversations become an en-

riching and formative orientation in your life Will glocal conversations

bring fresh approaches to theology faith mission church and worship Will

conversations with other cultures and theologies become for you a com-

pelling way of life

My prayer is that glocal conversations will help the church be a global

visible alternative ldquocity set upon a hillrdquo a truly GlobalChurch

28Craig Ott and Harold A Netland Globalizing Teology Belie and Practice in an Era o World

Christianity (Grand Rapids Baker Academic 983090983088983088983094) 1048625983090983093

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3636

Page 14: GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1436

10486261048624 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

also provided ways that you can contact me See appendix four

In my first book Salt Light and a City I developed a missional theology

of the church I did this in conversation with twelve theologians from the fourmajor Christian traditions Tat volume offered a window into the thought of

European and American theologians It showed how they are making sense

of the nature and mission of the church in their Western cultural context

Te book that yoursquore now reading takes a different approach I have

stepped away from European and American voices I now ask What can

those in the Majority World and indigenous cultures teach us in the West

What can they teach us about the churchrsquos mission worship theology andcommunity Te quality and quantity of material coming out of the Ma-

jority World is astonishing Any theology that ignores the insights of indig-

enous and Majority World Christians is deficient and impoverished

White middle-class European North American tertiary-educated men

dominate Western theology Tey dominate the Western missional conver-

sation I know I fit that profile Tis group still monopolizes missional church

conferences and seminars Tey get all the book contracts In fact this groupstill controls theology and the church in many settings But this is changing

New voices are rising Tese include women minorities the poor indigenous

groups and Majority World leaders Missional conversations arenrsquot attentive

to the Spirit and to Godrsquos mission if they ignore these voices Majority World

and indigenous churches oen have extraordinary missional vitality Openness

to other voices needs to happen now It is time for Western churches theol-

ogies and mission to mature and to reflect Godrsquos global mission

In this book I could have consulted the work of many thousands of in-

digenous and Majority World thinkers and writers and practitioners But I

have limited myself to a sample of those who speak directly to its themes

Tese African Asian Eastern European Middle Eastern Caribbean Latin

American First Nation and indigenous thinkers challenge us Tey dare us

to examine our theologies and missions and churches And they inspire us

to renew the worship and community and mission of Jesusrsquo church Tey

stir us to think in fresh ways about what it means to be salt light and a city

Tey help us become a global missional churchmdasha truly GlobalChurch

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1536

PA R T O N E

S A L TReshaping Our Conversations

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1636

G L O C A L I Z I N G

C O N V E R S A T I O N S

H983151983159 D983151 W983141 D983141983158983141983148983151983152

G983148983151983139983137983148 C983151983150983158983141983154983155983137983156983145983151983150983155983103

Rather than taking one contextual version of the Gospel and imposing

it as the Gospel throughout the world via the missionary enterprise

the shapers of Mission as ransformation have recognized the

plurality of localities that has created an intercontextual

ldquopan-localrdquo global phenomenon in theology

AL IZON

The International Society for Urban Mission (ISUM) is a group of urban

missionaries who are passionate about cultivating hope and love and re-newal in cities Irsquove connected with this group for some years ISUM held its

first annual Summit on Integral Urban Mission in Bangkok Tailand Te

team from Urban Neighbours of Hope (UNOH) under the leadership of

my Australian friends Ash and Anj Barker organized much of the summit

UNOH teams covenant with God and each other to ldquolive out our passion for

loving God and neighbour Focus on releasing neighbourhoods from urban

poverty Grow through equipping each other neighbours and the broader

church to radically follow Jesus and join Godrsquos Kingdom coming UNOH

workers live and serve in small responsive neighbourhood-based teamsrdquo983089

1See wwwunohorg

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1736

10486261048628 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

Tis summit involved interactive participatory hands-on immersion op-

portunities keynotes lectures and workshops Keynote speakers came from

Africa Australia Myanmar New Zealand North America the PhilippinesSouth America Tailand and First Nations A few hundred Majority World

and Western thinkers and activists came together for those days Tey explored

the theology and practices of integral transformational and urban mission

Tese thinkers and activists pursued a range of aims1048626 Tis included col-

laboration between urban Christians from a variety of backgrounds (Ma-

jority World and Western theologians activists ecumenicals Pentecostals

evangelicals colleges church movements and development agencies) Teyaimed for collective action and thought in an international and integral

context Tey sought to gain mutual understanding for a comprehensive

picture of urban mission around the globe Tey encouraged information

sharing and best practicesmdashlearning from our mistakes and seeking solu-

tions Tey developed recommendations and calls to action to the broader

church Working groups wrote briefing papers aer each summit based on

key issues in urban mission And they endeavored to build trust wisdomand inspiration to better engage our new urban world

Majority World and Western leaders participated in discussion prayer

integral mission and working groups Te goal was to grapple with key issues

and ask key questions How do we recruit equip and sustain urban mission

today How do we release church movements among the urban poor How

can we immerse ourselves in and transform urban neighborhoods How do

we empower urban children and young people How does the church serve

and liberate the oppressedmdashand others suffering from urban injustice What

needs to happen for poorer urban centers to develop economically socially

and spiritually How do we join God in the challenges and opportunities of

multifaith cities

Workshops included urban gardening child protection and collaborating

with local churches in urban mission Workshops also included organic

church growth and mission as well as developing NGO and government

partnerships Groups considered the good the bad and the ugly of short-

term urban mission teams

2Tese aims are detailed at ldquoInternational Society or Urban Mission Summitrdquo httpnewurbanworld

orgsummit

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1836

Glocalizing Conversations 10486261048629

Te summit was a thrilling example of how Majority World and Western

leaders can cooperate It was a time to come together in an environment of

mutual learning and enrichment It was a window into how local contextsand global themes can enrich each other Tis resulted from ISUMrsquos com-

mitment to ldquosolidarity fellowship and insight between urban Christian

leaders in the Western and Majority Worldsrdquo

Te summit was a success due to ISUMrsquos core values What are they983091 Christ-

honoring urban mission values bottom-up grassroots perspectivesmdashrather

than top-down distanced perspectives It allows local theology to reveal new

insights and perspectives about Godrsquos activity It shares insights and experi-ences through narratives embedded within urban poor communities and cities

It cultivates ongoing practical and personal solidarity with the worldrsquos urban

poor Tis Spirit-empowered urban mission honors networks relationships

and partnerships It sees such relationships as the primary method of serving

together It listens to and amplifies the voices of the urban poormdashespecially

those from the Majority World and in particular the 1048625104862410486281048624 window cities It is

attentive to signs of the kingdom of God Urban mission that glorifies God iswilling to reflect and respond with active and sacrificial commitment It shares

and extends the life of the body of Christ among the urban poor

Tis summit was a milestone in urban missiology It enriched communi-

cation between Western and Majority World thinker-activists Tis resulted

from the aims and values Irsquove mentioned Effective urban mission needs to

be a conversation on many levels It is attentive to context and immersed in

local settings It appreciates global and universal missional themes It culti-

vates dialogue between these local-global (glocal) realities It involves

mutual learning between Western and Majority World thinker-activists

Moreover solidarity between all parties is a defining feature Tis solidarity

is due to a compelling vision of the kingdom of God

Tese collaborative glocal features of the ISUM urban mission summit

in Bangkok are critical for the aims of this book GlobalChurch

Majority World indigenous and Western leaders thinkers and churches

can stretch and enrich each other But they need to be open and attentive to

each other Tey need learning postures and open hearts and minds Tey

3ldquoAbout ISUMrdquo httpnewurbanworldorgabout

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1936

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2036

Glocalizing Conversations 10486261048631

always rooted in the local and particularmdashas local churches embody the

gospel and witness to Christ Tese churches forge their own theological

understandings as they do mission together Tey engage in transformationalpractices among the people in their settings Tey enjoy worship mission

and community in their local and particular context Ideally the result is

unique contextual theologies and missions

Simultaneously global conversations form Tey form because of this

multitude of local theologies and practices Local conversations inform and

enrich other local conversations catalyzing global themes and voices izon

observes that the global ldquoowes its existence to local contexts Sharedconvictions among the theologies and practices of local contextual realities

give shape to its global dimensionsrdquo1048629

Majority World indigenous and Western theologies are equally contextual

Tey are equally culture bound Tey are equally particular to their time and

location At times they are all enlightened or myopic liberating or con-

straining humanizing or objectifying beautiful or offensive prophetic or

tepid Te local particular and cultural shape all these theologies Converselythese particular theologies feed and influence global conversations Tere is

no place then for ethnocentrism colonialism or elitism Tere is no place

for theological missional cultural or institutionalized arrogance

Multiple local contexts and voices come togethermdashintentionally or notmdashto

form global themes and theologies Conversely these global realities shape

local contexts oday local contexts must grapple with ldquoan emerging global

culture ie the interacting realities of modernity postmodernity and the

phenomenon of globalizationrdquo1048630 Hence the interdependent and symbiotic

relationship between the localparticular and the globaluniversal We call this

interdependent relationship between the local and the global glocalization

Te global church needs a thrilling glocal exchange We need one that we

characterize by mutuality respect partnership and symbiosis Such ex-

change helps Majority World indigenous and Western churches learn from

each other It enables them to pursue missional theology and practice o-

gether the church becomes a ldquocity on a hillrdquo

5Ibid 10486259830886Ibid 9830961048628

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2136

10486261048632 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

W983144983137983156 R983141983153983157983145983154983141983155 G983148983151983139983137983148983145983162983137983156983145983151983150983103

Te glocal exchange described above needs to be broader than transforma-

tional mission Tis is necessary if the church is to develop a robust inter-cultural and glocal missional ecclesiology

In my first book Salt Light and a City I outlined the foundational

themes of missional ecclesiology983095 Majority World and Western leaders

need to engage these themes in local and contextual ways Teir insights can

then enrich global conversations Tese global conversations in turn shape

local understandings and practices Tis way a glocal appreciation of these

themes emergesLocal regional and global theologies and practices are thereby enriched

Te church becomes healthier and more missionalmdasha truer expression of

the kingdom Te church becomes a fuller witness to Christ his passion for

the nations and his ability to bring unity in diversity

Stephen Bevans and Roger Schroeder outline the six constants of mission

Tese are our theologies about Jesus the church the end times salvation

human nature and culture Bevans and Schroeder describe the relationshipbetween these six and their historical cultural and theological contexts Tis is

why they call these six constants in context Our understanding of these six

constants develops in relation to local and global movements Sometimes local

voices influence our understandings of these six Other times it is regional or

global voices For all of us local regional and global influences are at play at

once Collectively they form our appreciation of the six constants of mission1048632

Here are eight theological themes that the church can develop through

processes of glocalization I presented these in my book Salt Light and a City

Tey are vital to the churchrsquos health mission community and future We

could add many other themes to these eight but these will suffice for now1048633

Scripture Te Scriptures are the infallible authoritative Word of God

Christrsquos Spirit has inspired them Tey have absolute and final authority in

all aspects of corporate and individual faith ethics conduct and witness

Christians interpret and apply Scripture in local contexts and in particular

7Graham Hill Salt Light and a City Introducing Missional Ecclesiology (Eugene OR Wip and

Stock 9830909830881048625983090) 10486251048628983097-983090104863110486288Stephen B Bevans and Roger Schroeder Constants in Context A Teology o Mission or oday

American Society o Missiology Series (Maryknoll NY Orbis 9830909830889830881048628) part one9Tese points first appeared in my book Salt Light and a City xxii-xxiv

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2236

Glocalizing Conversations 10486261048633

social settings Conversely we learn from the interpretations and readings

of other groups

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our local- global theology of Scripture and biblical interpretation

Evangelicalism Pentecostalism missional movements and so forth I

have charismatic missional and evangelical convictions Glocal conversa-

tions help me understand and practice these convictions better

I will use evangelicalism as an example Michael Horton says that our

beliefs and practices are evangelical when they are ldquocommitted to the suffi-

ciency of Scripture the priesthood of all believers the total lostness ofhumans the sole mediation of Christ the gracious efficacy and finality of

Godrsquos redemptive work in Christ through election propitiation calling and

keeping Te linchpin for all of this was the doctrine of justification by grace

alone through faith alone because of Christ alonerdquo9830891048624

Such convictions are necessary if we are to be faithful to the gospel and

to a biblical vision of church and mission Te gospel defines Godrsquos purposes

for humanity the church and the universe Te triune God controls thechurch He is its Lord and Savior Sanctifier and Liberator Master and King

He is completely sovereign over its nature affairs mission and history God

is the churchrsquos only source of grace election atonement salvation and per-

severance Te churchrsquos justification and hope are by grace alone through

faith alone by Christ alone

Herersquos the challenge I face My understanding of evangelicalism is

Western I am a product of the Western theological tradition and my Western

evangelical heritage Much of this is wonderful But I need indigenous and

Majority World evangelicals and others to help me expand and reshape

these insights Te same would be true if I were a Pentecostal

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of our theological traditions and convictions

Jesus Christ We must center our theology on Jesus Christ the Lord of

the church Te church needs to reflect on the person and work of Christ

and respond to him Tis means gathering and going in the name and power

of Christ It means allowing Christrsquos Spirit to shape our community and

10Michael Horton ldquoEvangelical Arminiansrdquo Modern Reormation 1048625 no 1048627 (1048625983097983097983090) 10486251048631

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2336

10486271048624 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

identity and mission It means developing our Christology ecclesiology and

missiology concurrently Te early church developed these three areas and

more in a concurrent and integrated way Tere was no linear progressionTe same is true in the contemporary global church

How can the glocal church best explore its nature structure mission and

hope Trough the centrality and the lordship of Christ

Majority World and indigenous Christians help us appreciate Jesus and

his mission afresh Tey show us how Jesus identifies with the marginalized

outcast oppressed rejected and broken He prefers them We find him

among ldquothe least of theserdquoGlocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of who Jesus Christ is How does it help us appreciate him better

What has Jesus done for and in his church and his world What does he care

about What individual and corporate responsibilities has he given us How

do we express these at local regional and global levels

Te Spirit Missional ecclesiology is inadequate without pneumatological

foundations In other words our theology of church and Spirit go togetherTe Spirit creates and animates the church He empowers it to witness to

Jesus and his gospel Te Spirit enables the church to be a missional trans-

formational community He shapes the church into an alternative society

embodying the reign of God Te church exists for the glory and mission of

Christ Te power and presence of the Spirit enables this mission worship

and glorification

Te Spirit pours out gis on the local-global church ldquofor the common

goodrdquo and ldquoto equip his people for works of service so that the body of Christ

may be built uprdquo Tis includes but isnrsquot limited to the ministry gis mani-

festation gis and motivational gis (1048625 Cor 104862510486261048631 Eph 104862810486251048625-10486251048626 Rom 104862510486261048630-1048632)

Te Spirit forms the glocal church He empowers it for service and

witness He fills it with Christrsquos empowering presence He leads it into the

missio Deimdashthe mission of the Father Son and Holy Spirit

Recently Pentecostal and renewalist movements have grown dramati-

cally in the Majority World Tey have increased in status size and influence

Many have matured theologically Te churches of the West must take notice

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of the power and presence of the Spirit

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2436

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048625

Te rinity Tere are clear limitations to the analogy between the

church and the rinity Te church can only image the rinity Yet the

church is at its best when it reflects the relational and missional passionof the rinity

What is the source and inspiration of the churchrsquos local-global mission

Ultimately it is the missional nature passion and actions of the Father Son

and Holy Spirit Godrsquos nature is missional His passion is infectious His

actions are historical redemptive and eternal Te rinity invites the

church into a sending community Te Father sends the Son Te Father

and Son send the Spirit Finally the rinity sends the church in missioninto the world

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of the rinity How does it enable our participation in the mission

and community of the triune God

Association and dialogue Tese need to happen across denominational

cultural ethnic gender and theological traditions and divides Authentic

dialogue is indispensable to the health and mission of the church What dothose marginal to the life of the church have to say to us What do ldquoothersrdquo

have to teach us Other ethnicities and cultures Other socioeconomic

groups Other ages and genders Other theological and confessing tradi-

tions Other persons from times long gone

We need to listen Share Be vulnerable Be authentic Open up to crit-

icism correction and change

We need more than dialogue We need communion and association It is

possible in a qualified way to say that God is present in all the various forms

of the church (ie the various theological ecclesiological sociocultural his-

torical and other permutations of the church) We discern this presence

through attention to Scripture history tradition culture and the Spirit Dis-

cernment involves critical dialogue theological exchange biblical study and

real relationship Only the Spirit of Jesus can enable this

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of association and dialogue

Mission and the missio Dei Te church is missional at its core It serves

obeys and images a missionary God David Bosch says ldquoTe churchrsquos mission

is not secondary to its being the church exists in being sent and in building up

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2536

10486271048626 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

itself for its missionrdquo He goes on to say ldquoEcclesiology does not precede missi-

ology there cannot be church without an intrinsic missionary dimensionrdquo983089983089

Jesus is Lord Lord of his church and Lord of his world His mission de-termines and forms the church His mission shapes the nature purposes

structures ministries and activities of his church Majority World and in-

digenous thinkers help us understand the implications of this mission Tey

help us form glocal theologies of mission Tey reveal ldquomission in context

as transformationrdquo9830891048626

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of mission and the missio Dei Church theology and practice Glocal conversations can inform and

enrich many aspects of the church (when practiced well) Teologies and

practices benefit from robust and critical glocal conversations Tese con-

versations enrich many areas (community spirituality discipleship liturgy

worship hospitality eco-justice education social ethics servantship lib-

eration place suffering beauty and so on)

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-standing of these many dimensions of church and mission

Glocal processes shape these eight themes and their practices We need

to facilitate and enable these conversations and processes Tis is urgent It

must be a priority No theology of mission or missional ecclesiology is ad-

equate without glocal conversations983089983091

T983144983141 L983151983139983137983148 983137983150983140 G983148983151983138983137983148 E983150983154983145983139983144 E983137983139983144 O983156983144983141983154

Glocalization takes the localparticular context and globaluniversal themes

seriously Contextual and global conversations enter an enriching and in-

forming relationship Tese two always have an active and symbiotic rela-

tionship Tis is true whether we deliberately put them into conversation or

not Te local shapes the global and the global shapes the local Many local

11David J Bosch Believing in the Future oward a Missiology o Western Culture (New York

rinity 1048625983097983097983093) 104862798309012izon ransormation Afer Lausanne 1048631-98309713Not all o these themes are dealt with in this present volume since either (1048625) I have dealt with them

in my book Salt Light and a City (983090) they are not all key themes in the writings o the thirty-five

Majority World thinkers considered in this volume or (1048627) there is not adequate space in a book

this size

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2636

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048627

voices converge to form global conversations and theologies Using the Phil-

ippines as a case study izon illustrates this by showing the interdepen-

dence between local and global themes in mission983089983092Dialogue between local and global conversations is critical Kōsuke

Koyama wrote an important book on contextual mission called Water Buffalo

Teology Koyama is a Japanese missionary who served in Chiang Mai

Tailand He writes of the joys and challenges of doing local particular water

buffalo theology He considers the relationship between local theology global

missional themes and transforming cultures ldquoWater Buffalo Teology sees

certain specific challenges Contextualization of theology implies two criticalmovements First to articulate Jesus Christ in culturally appropriate com-

municatively apt words and second to criticize reform dethrone or oppose

culture if it is found to be against what the name of Jesus Christ stands forrdquo9830891048629

Kōsuke Koyama challenges us to recognize what we bring to the task of

local theology For him it was doing theology in Tailand while being Jap-

anese We also need to notice the particular culture wersquore located in as we do

the work of theology Tis means we avoid speaking of an ldquoAsian theologyrdquoldquoAfrican theologyrdquo and the like We need to cultivate local theologies that

engage regional and global themes But these theologies must be ldquodistinctly

localrdquo and a ldquotheology from belowrdquo9830891048630

Simultaneously we need to pursue a reformation of theology and

practice ldquoin the global contextrdquo Tis means entering ldquothe disturbing spa-

ciousness of Jesus Christrdquo Jesus calls us to reject enmity and exceptionalism

We seem him present in our culture language stories and relationships

But we also choose to embrace the ldquootherrdquo We choose to see him present

in other culturesmdashshaping a global people to serve and worship him

joining in his mission983089983095

Kōsuke Koyama roots the gospel in the local contextual and particular

Tis is why he roots his water buffalo theology in Northern Tai culture He

is careful not to say ldquoHere is how you contextualize in your settingrdquo Instead

14izon ransormation Afer Lausanne 1048631-10486251048627 10486251048628983097-98309098308898309015Kōsuke Koyama Water Buffalo Teology 983090983093th anniversary ed (Maryknoll NY Orbis 1048625983097983097983097)

xiii-xv16Kōsuke Koyama ldquoTe Asian Approach to Christrdquo Missiology 1048625983090 no 1048628 (10486259830979830961048628) 10486281048627983093-104862798309617Kōsuke Koyama ldquoReormation in the Global Context Te Disturbing Spaciousness o Jesus Christrdquo

Currents in Teology and Mission 1048627983088 no 983090 (9830909830889830881048627) 10486251048625983097-983090983096

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2736

10486271048628 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

he tells us a story Itrsquos the story of how he contextualized theology in northern

Tailand while being open to global conversations Koyama asks us to form

our own local expressions of church mission and theology At the same timewe must stay attentive to what God is saying and doing beyond that context

Tis way local and global and particular and universal become mutually

enriching conversation partners

G983148983151983139983137983148983145983162983137983156983145983151983150 983137983150983140 H983145983155983156983151983154983145983139983137983148983148983161 S983145983148983141983150983139983141983140 V983151983145983139983141983155

Glocal theologies and conversations pay attention to voices that powers in-

stitutions religions and societies have silenced R S Sugirtharajah pushesback a little on izonrsquos ideas Sugirtharajah says that the church should

privilege local conversations He emphasizes the local contextual and post-

colonial reading of biblical texts9830891048632

Te church needs to listen Te church ought to be attentive to the

theologies and biblical interpretations of groups that cultures and reli-

gions have ignored Historically powerful secular and religious forces

have silenced these groups Tey have marginalized oppressed and colo-nized them It is time for the church to address this injustice We must

start listening to important but silenced voices We need to privilege the

voices of the former victims of Western colonialism We need to develop

postcolonial biblical interpretations theologies and expressions of church

and mission

How do we take such perspectives seriously as we develop glocal conver-

sations How do these themes help us foster vital relationships between local

and global voices

It is time for us to embrace values that enable conversations with those

oen ignored by the church We need values that help us learn from these

groups and individuals

Valuing equal partnership Colonizing powers oppressed silenced and

colonized certain groups At times the church was complicit Tese colo-

nized groups have become ldquoconfident indomitable and indispensable

partners in the dialogue and collaboration with the dispossessed and disad-

18R S Sugirtharajah Asian Biblical Hermeneutics and Postcolonialism Contesting the Interpreta-

tions Te Bible and Liberation Series (Maryknoll NY Orbis 1048625983097983097983096) 1048625983093-1048625983094

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2836

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048629

vantaged in the Westrdquo9830891048633 Tis calls for attentiveness to these voices and re-

sponsiveness to their prophetic challenges It also demands a critical evalu-

ation of colonial readings of Scripture Colonial models of theology andchurch and mission are no longer the benchmark Te global church must

examine them afresh

Valuing equal status Tose on the margins have now taken their rightful

place on the global stage Tey have claimed appropriate and equal status at

the table Subaltern readings of theology church and mission are invaluable

contributors to global theological conversations Tis means that we esteem

them But we also test themWhat do we mean by subaltern Subalterns are those who are down-

trodden and silenced (or have been treated this way in the past) Dominant

or colonizing groups treat them as invisible nonentities Tey enjoy limited

or no access to power Sometimes these are women certain tribal and ethnic

groups and those considered ldquountouchablerdquo In Voices from the Margin Su-

girtharajah provides a platform for postcolonial subaltern readings of

Scripture and theology Tese readings challenge colonialmdashoen Westernmdashreadings of Bible and theology and cultures Tey claim equal status with

other ways of doing theology10486261048624

Valuing equal identity People groups need freedom to explore their new

and emerging identities Tese emerge in response to local and global influ-

ences Local culture is not the only thing at work here Global forces also

shape identity as do imported practices ideas readings rituals and tech-

nologies But each group should be free to explore and construct their par-

ticular forms of Christian identity

Valuing equal interpretations ldquoPostcolonialism is concerned with the

question of cultural and discursive dominationrdquo Colonialism led to op-

pressive and controlling forms of culture and discourse Tese were usually

not contextual or indigenous Western powers for instance brought co-

lonial forms of theology church biblical interpretation and mission1048626983089

Postcolonialism calls for alternative ways of approaching these things Tose

19Ibid 104862598309420R S Sugirtharajah Voices rom the Margin Interpreting the Bible in the Tird World (Maryknoll

NY Orbis 10486259830979830971048625)21Sugirtharajah Asian Biblical Hermeneutics and Postcolonialism 10486251048631

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2936

10486271048630 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

who were once marginalized oppressed and silenced need to lead these fresh

approaches in their own settings Tese then influence global conversations

We need to support the new readings and insights and experiments from thesegroups o be genuine this support must be both critical and collegial

Valuing equal empowerment Sugirtharajah says that postcolonialism is

valuable when it empowers actual communities and real people Post-

colonial thought empowers when it addresses the difficulties hopes and

experiences of ordinary people It should never be about power plays and

the clever use of language Itrsquos pointless if itrsquos obsessed with forming newmdash

and ldquocolonizingrdquomdashtheories Itrsquos a waste of time if itrsquos a self-indulgent pursuitof new and hybrid identities Rather ldquothe worth and credibility of post-

colonial criticism will be judged by how it orchestrates the unique and

fragile and imagined claims of one community against anotherrdquo Empow-

erment happens in a variety of ways One way is contributing equally to

global conversations10486261048626

Al izon examines postcolonialism in the Philippines He says that it can

teach the global church a lot about healthy local-global conversations Fil-ipino contextual theology resists many Western forms of mission and the-

ology It finds them patronizing and controlling Tis indigenous theology

values prophetic sociopolitical engagement in institutions and the society

at large It emphasizes ministry to whole persons and communities It con-

structs a Filipino theology of beauty and mission and worship and com-

munity And it fosters indigenous theological approaches to the spirit world

and cosmology

izon says that postcolonial theology has played a constructive role in

the Philippines But he is uncomfortable with the label postcolonialism He

prefers to describe historical events as ldquobeyond colonialismrdquo And he says

that global conversations enrich local theologies and vice versa1048626983091

Postcolonial thought informs our understanding of the relationship be-

tween the local and global It also shows how theology can emerge at the

intersection between the localparticular and the globaluniversal It re-

minds us that worthwhile glocalization listens to all voices Tis includes

heeding those that have been historically silenced

22Ibid 983090104862823izon ransormation Afer Lausanne 1048625983088983090 10486259830941048631-9830961048631

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3036

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048631

G983148983151983139983137983148983145983162983137983156983145983151983150 983137983150983140 983156983144983141 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

C983151983150983139983148983157983140983145983150983143 R983141983142983148983141983139983156983145983151983150983155

How do we go about developing a model for glocal conversations izon hasrecently provided a useful model that is instructive as we seek to learn from

the Majority World It has at least two key features

First the local is in the global (globalization from below) Global theologies

and ideas have origins in many particular local contexts In that sense glo-

balization is from below Global ideas have local roots Ideas about integral

mission liberation theology and missional church have local origins Tey

have their roots in the prayers hopes discoveries mission and theologiesof thousands of local communities ldquoTe global does not cannot exist

without the localmdashbut the coming together of localities creates a global re-

ality that becomes greater than the sum of its parts it creates a gestalt entity

to which localities make themselves accountablerdquo1048626983092

Second the global is in the local (panlocalization from above) Te con-

cerns and voices of multitudes of locales form global conversations Tese

global discussions can provide a ldquopositive accountabilityrdquo back to local con-texts Tis is true when they enrich affirm serve guide and strengthen local

contexts It is also true when they avoid homogenization control impo-

sition and judgment Glocalization is best when it sees itself as interde-

pendent deeply connected with the local10486261048629

Tatrsquos a helpful starting point But we need to go further Besides izonrsquos

proposals Irsquom convinced that robust glocal conversations cultivate six core

practices

983089 Glocal theology practices its values We root glocal theology in core

values Tese values include solidarity understanding and mutual learning

Do we value fellowship with Christians of all cultures Do we value learning

from them

We prove our values through our practices What practices emerge out of

these values We need to collaborate act collectively and share information

We must find ways to foster grassroots perspectives and local theologies We

need to share stories and learnings and cultivate networks relationships and

partnerships We need attentiveness to local voices and global themes We

24Ibid 9830901048625983088-1048625104862825Ibid 98309010486251048628-1048625983096

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3136

10486271048632 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

ought to find ways to put these local and global voices into conversation

Mutual learning humility and solidarity are key Worthwhile glocal con-

versations can never be merely theoretical or academic It is up to us to rootour values in our practices

983090 Glocal theology practices humility (and it tells a new narrative) We

have noted that the local is in the global and the global is in the local Te

two are interdependent Tey form each other reciprocally Since this is the

case we must practice humility Tere is no place for ethnocentrism colo-

nialism or theological and cultural arrogance I have seen these unhealthy

postures far too oen in Western settingsRecently I attended a missional leadership conference On that occasion

the keynote speakermdasha leading missional author and speakermdashsaid that

North American missional conversations and innovations hold the key to

the future of the Western church Tis Euro American view is wrong (Irsquom

being kind o be frank itrsquos complete nonsense) Itrsquos arrogant and Euro

Americanndashcentric And itrsquos completely out of step with what is happening in

the glocal church We need a new narrativeIn June 1048626104862410486251048627 Te Center for the Study of Global Christianity reported

the top 10486261048624 countries where Christianity has the highest percentage growth

rate Nineteen of the top twenty are in Asia and Africa Eleven of them are

in Muslim majority countries Not a single country from Europe or North

America makes the top twenty list10486261048630

Itrsquos time to cultivate a new narrative Te future of the church is emerging

from the Majority World Rather than North America the churches of

Eastern Asia Western Africa the Arabian Peninsula and other parts of the

Majority World reveal the future of the global church We need the contribu-

tions of all contexts Western indigenous and Majority World All con-

tribute to glocal conversations All are important as we learn from each

other about mission theology and faith But letrsquos stop pretending that North

Americans and Europeans will reveal the future of the global church Letrsquos

start listening to what God is saying about the future of the global church

And hersquos speaking to us through the churches of Asia Africa Latin America

26Russ Mitchell ldquoTe op 983090983088 Countries Where Christianity Is Growing the Fastestrdquo Disciple All

Nations (blog) August 983090983093 98309098308810486251048627 httpsdiscipleallnationswordpresscom98309098308810486251048627983088983096983090983093the-top

-983090983088-countries-where-christianity-is-growing-the-astest

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3236

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048633

Muslim majority settings and so on We must cultivate a new glocal nar-

rativemdashone soaked in humility

Glocal theology must be humble theology Meek theology Receptive the-ology Discerning theology Prayerful theology Dialogical theology De-

pendent theology A theology that celebrates the interdependence between

the localparticular and the globaluniversal

983091 Glocal theology practices expansiveness Glocalization is by nature

comprehensive Local and global influences permeate much of our lives Tese

glocal forces shape our theologies and churches whether we like it or not

But intentionality is also important We need to commit to an expansiveapproach to glocal theology How do we deliberately cultivate glocal conver-

sations in our biblical interpretation Do we foster them in our under-

standing of the person and work of Christ How does glocalization shape

the way the Spirit empowers and constitutes the church How can it form

our understanding of the nature and mission of the rinity How does it

influence the way we practice fellowship and conversation across denomi-

national cultural ethnic economic sociocultural political gender andtheological divides How might it shape our theologies of mission com-

munity beauty spirituality suffering discipleship hospitality eco-justice

place education social ethics Christian leadership and so forth

983092 Glocal theology practices attention Glocal theology doesnrsquot need to

accept all the assumptions or assertions of postcolonial or Majority World

thought But it does need to engage with them and take them seriously

Postcolonial theology for instance gives the marginalized and colonized

and forgotten and silenced both dignity and voice Our glocal conversations

must also include and esteem these groups We need to be attentive to

others weak and powerful female and male dominant and downtrodden

old and young rich and poor privileged and marginalized influential and

subaltern educated and illiterate We need to practice the art of attention

being especially attentive to those who are different to us

983093 Glocal theology practices embrace What do colonial ethnocentric or

Western-centric perspectives do Tey silence Tey control Tey com-

modify Tey institutionalize Tey colonize Tey domesticate Tey replace

Tey import Tey exclude Tey do these things to the beliefs experiences

and practices of other cultures A worthwhile glocal theology refuses to do

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3336

10486281048624 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

these things Instead it adopts a responsive humble celebratory open in-

clusive and embracing attitude

983094 Glocal theology practices discernment Finally we need discernmentas we engage these ideas and practices Discernment is a huge topic thatrsquos

hard to cover comprehensively in a few words Discernment happens when

the Spirit of Christ and his Word renew our minds Te Spirit grants us

spiritual wisdom as we meditate on him and his Word and as we practice

discipleship to Jesus Christ Romans 10486251048626 provides guidance we need (1048625) to be

transformed by the renewal of our minds (1048626) to serve Christrsquos body and (1048627)

to put love into action Discernment also happens in conversation both lo-cally and glocally

I pray these core values and six practices come across in the following

chapters of GlobalChurch

Glocalization can never be just theoretical Are we committed to moving

glocalization from an abstract idea to a living communion Are we deter-

mined to construct a missional theology of the church in the context of

glocal conversations Tis must involve dialogue between Majority Worldindigenous and Western scholars activists and groups

Will glocalization be an abstract notion Or will it be a formative and

genuine communion between local regional and global voices Glocal dy-

namics are at play whether we like it or not Teyrsquore in our churches the-

ologies and missions But we can choose to relinquish isolationist colonial

parochial and arrogant approaches Instead we can adopt responsive dia-

logical learning humble and embracing postures

Trough healthy approaches to glocalization the Spirit challenges us to

value local contexts We immerse ourselves in local and particular commu-

nities and conversations He inspires us to open ourselves to global theo-

logical conversations He rouses us to value the symbiotic relationship be-

tween the localparticular and the globaluniversal

Trough glocal relationships the Spirit leads us to put local contextual

theologies into conversation with global ones He prompts us to explore the

ways in which the local is in the glocal and the global is in the local He per-

suades us to pursue collaboration and dialogue and mutual learning We

engage with Christians from different backgrounds and cultures ecumen-

icals Pentecostals evangelicals and so on from Western indigenous and

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3436

Glocalizing Conversations 10486281048625

Majority World contexts He motivates us to express solidarity between all

parties We appreciate our unity in diversity

Trough glocal conversations the Spirit moves us to ensure that unity andsolidarity emerge from a compelling vision of Jesusrsquo kingdom and gospel

and person He challenges us to share information theology and practices

He urges us to learn from each othermdashour successes and mistakes We seek

glocal solutions

Te Spirit calls us to develop glocal conversations about Christian ideas

and practices Tese include Scripture Evangelicalism ecumenism Pente-

costalism Jesus Christ the Holy Spirit God the Father the rinity com-munity spirituality discipleship liturgy worship hospitality prayer eco-

justice education social ethics Christian leadership gospel and culture

beauty place suffering liberation and so forth

Finally through glocal conversations the Spirit leads us to adopt a new

posture Tis is a responsive humble celebratory open inclusive and em-

bracing attitude to the ldquootherrdquo We do this as a new people made up of every

tribe and language and people and nationTere are dangers in glocalization Sugirtharajah warns of the commodi-

fication of local contextual practices and theologies When this happens

they are ldquosmoothed out of their primary contexts concerns and contesta-

tions travel across borders and become objects of analysis and scrutiny

within an alien secondary contextrdquo1048626983095

Itrsquos common for those of us who are Western to make mistakes when we

wrestle with Majority World and indigenous ideas Sugirtharajah mentions

our tendency to commodify reduce and institutionalize these ideas We also

risk doing these things (1048625) We apply them in noncontextual prescriptive ways

(1048626) We ignore their meanings in their original setting (1048627) We glamorize or

idealize their proponents or their contexts (1048628) We demonize those persons or

contexts (1048629) We disregard them as irrelevant rhetorical or minority discourse

Kevin J Vanhoozer says that we can fall into three traps when we glo-

calize theology (1048625) We can underestimate the theological significance of

local cultures (1048626) We can homogenize cultures and theologies exaggerating

27R S Sugirtharajah ldquoextual ake-Aways Tird World exts in Western Metropolitan Centresrdquo

Black Teology in Britain A Journal o Contextual Praxis 983090 (1048625983097983097983097) 10486271048627 10486271048631 Edward W Said Te

World the ext and the Critic (Cambridge MA Harvard University Press 10486259830979830961048627) 9830901048627983097

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3536

10486281048626 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

ldquothe onerdquo (1048627) We can overemphasize cultural particularity exaggerating ldquothe

manyrdquo and pursue ldquotheological ethnificationrdquo10486261048632

My hope is that GlobalChurch does not fall into the traps Sugirtharajahand Vanhoozer describe I hope that what unfolds in the following chapters

is respectful and discerning I hope it leads to further mutually enriching

conversations between people of different cultures

You the reader face the same challenges You face them in your personal

life ministry context and missional engagements

Will you treat the themes in this book as abstract theoretical notions

Will this be a temporary infatuation a flirtation with the ldquootherrdquo that dissi-pates as suddenly as it arrived Or will glocal conversations become an en-

riching and formative orientation in your life Will glocal conversations

bring fresh approaches to theology faith mission church and worship Will

conversations with other cultures and theologies become for you a com-

pelling way of life

My prayer is that glocal conversations will help the church be a global

visible alternative ldquocity set upon a hillrdquo a truly GlobalChurch

28Craig Ott and Harold A Netland Globalizing Teology Belie and Practice in an Era o World

Christianity (Grand Rapids Baker Academic 983090983088983088983094) 1048625983090983093

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3636

Page 15: GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1536

PA R T O N E

S A L TReshaping Our Conversations

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1636

G L O C A L I Z I N G

C O N V E R S A T I O N S

H983151983159 D983151 W983141 D983141983158983141983148983151983152

G983148983151983139983137983148 C983151983150983158983141983154983155983137983156983145983151983150983155983103

Rather than taking one contextual version of the Gospel and imposing

it as the Gospel throughout the world via the missionary enterprise

the shapers of Mission as ransformation have recognized the

plurality of localities that has created an intercontextual

ldquopan-localrdquo global phenomenon in theology

AL IZON

The International Society for Urban Mission (ISUM) is a group of urban

missionaries who are passionate about cultivating hope and love and re-newal in cities Irsquove connected with this group for some years ISUM held its

first annual Summit on Integral Urban Mission in Bangkok Tailand Te

team from Urban Neighbours of Hope (UNOH) under the leadership of

my Australian friends Ash and Anj Barker organized much of the summit

UNOH teams covenant with God and each other to ldquolive out our passion for

loving God and neighbour Focus on releasing neighbourhoods from urban

poverty Grow through equipping each other neighbours and the broader

church to radically follow Jesus and join Godrsquos Kingdom coming UNOH

workers live and serve in small responsive neighbourhood-based teamsrdquo983089

1See wwwunohorg

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1736

10486261048628 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

Tis summit involved interactive participatory hands-on immersion op-

portunities keynotes lectures and workshops Keynote speakers came from

Africa Australia Myanmar New Zealand North America the PhilippinesSouth America Tailand and First Nations A few hundred Majority World

and Western thinkers and activists came together for those days Tey explored

the theology and practices of integral transformational and urban mission

Tese thinkers and activists pursued a range of aims1048626 Tis included col-

laboration between urban Christians from a variety of backgrounds (Ma-

jority World and Western theologians activists ecumenicals Pentecostals

evangelicals colleges church movements and development agencies) Teyaimed for collective action and thought in an international and integral

context Tey sought to gain mutual understanding for a comprehensive

picture of urban mission around the globe Tey encouraged information

sharing and best practicesmdashlearning from our mistakes and seeking solu-

tions Tey developed recommendations and calls to action to the broader

church Working groups wrote briefing papers aer each summit based on

key issues in urban mission And they endeavored to build trust wisdomand inspiration to better engage our new urban world

Majority World and Western leaders participated in discussion prayer

integral mission and working groups Te goal was to grapple with key issues

and ask key questions How do we recruit equip and sustain urban mission

today How do we release church movements among the urban poor How

can we immerse ourselves in and transform urban neighborhoods How do

we empower urban children and young people How does the church serve

and liberate the oppressedmdashand others suffering from urban injustice What

needs to happen for poorer urban centers to develop economically socially

and spiritually How do we join God in the challenges and opportunities of

multifaith cities

Workshops included urban gardening child protection and collaborating

with local churches in urban mission Workshops also included organic

church growth and mission as well as developing NGO and government

partnerships Groups considered the good the bad and the ugly of short-

term urban mission teams

2Tese aims are detailed at ldquoInternational Society or Urban Mission Summitrdquo httpnewurbanworld

orgsummit

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1836

Glocalizing Conversations 10486261048629

Te summit was a thrilling example of how Majority World and Western

leaders can cooperate It was a time to come together in an environment of

mutual learning and enrichment It was a window into how local contextsand global themes can enrich each other Tis resulted from ISUMrsquos com-

mitment to ldquosolidarity fellowship and insight between urban Christian

leaders in the Western and Majority Worldsrdquo

Te summit was a success due to ISUMrsquos core values What are they983091 Christ-

honoring urban mission values bottom-up grassroots perspectivesmdashrather

than top-down distanced perspectives It allows local theology to reveal new

insights and perspectives about Godrsquos activity It shares insights and experi-ences through narratives embedded within urban poor communities and cities

It cultivates ongoing practical and personal solidarity with the worldrsquos urban

poor Tis Spirit-empowered urban mission honors networks relationships

and partnerships It sees such relationships as the primary method of serving

together It listens to and amplifies the voices of the urban poormdashespecially

those from the Majority World and in particular the 1048625104862410486281048624 window cities It is

attentive to signs of the kingdom of God Urban mission that glorifies God iswilling to reflect and respond with active and sacrificial commitment It shares

and extends the life of the body of Christ among the urban poor

Tis summit was a milestone in urban missiology It enriched communi-

cation between Western and Majority World thinker-activists Tis resulted

from the aims and values Irsquove mentioned Effective urban mission needs to

be a conversation on many levels It is attentive to context and immersed in

local settings It appreciates global and universal missional themes It culti-

vates dialogue between these local-global (glocal) realities It involves

mutual learning between Western and Majority World thinker-activists

Moreover solidarity between all parties is a defining feature Tis solidarity

is due to a compelling vision of the kingdom of God

Tese collaborative glocal features of the ISUM urban mission summit

in Bangkok are critical for the aims of this book GlobalChurch

Majority World indigenous and Western leaders thinkers and churches

can stretch and enrich each other But they need to be open and attentive to

each other Tey need learning postures and open hearts and minds Tey

3ldquoAbout ISUMrdquo httpnewurbanworldorgabout

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1936

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2036

Glocalizing Conversations 10486261048631

always rooted in the local and particularmdashas local churches embody the

gospel and witness to Christ Tese churches forge their own theological

understandings as they do mission together Tey engage in transformationalpractices among the people in their settings Tey enjoy worship mission

and community in their local and particular context Ideally the result is

unique contextual theologies and missions

Simultaneously global conversations form Tey form because of this

multitude of local theologies and practices Local conversations inform and

enrich other local conversations catalyzing global themes and voices izon

observes that the global ldquoowes its existence to local contexts Sharedconvictions among the theologies and practices of local contextual realities

give shape to its global dimensionsrdquo1048629

Majority World indigenous and Western theologies are equally contextual

Tey are equally culture bound Tey are equally particular to their time and

location At times they are all enlightened or myopic liberating or con-

straining humanizing or objectifying beautiful or offensive prophetic or

tepid Te local particular and cultural shape all these theologies Converselythese particular theologies feed and influence global conversations Tere is

no place then for ethnocentrism colonialism or elitism Tere is no place

for theological missional cultural or institutionalized arrogance

Multiple local contexts and voices come togethermdashintentionally or notmdashto

form global themes and theologies Conversely these global realities shape

local contexts oday local contexts must grapple with ldquoan emerging global

culture ie the interacting realities of modernity postmodernity and the

phenomenon of globalizationrdquo1048630 Hence the interdependent and symbiotic

relationship between the localparticular and the globaluniversal We call this

interdependent relationship between the local and the global glocalization

Te global church needs a thrilling glocal exchange We need one that we

characterize by mutuality respect partnership and symbiosis Such ex-

change helps Majority World indigenous and Western churches learn from

each other It enables them to pursue missional theology and practice o-

gether the church becomes a ldquocity on a hillrdquo

5Ibid 10486259830886Ibid 9830961048628

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2136

10486261048632 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

W983144983137983156 R983141983153983157983145983154983141983155 G983148983151983139983137983148983145983162983137983156983145983151983150983103

Te glocal exchange described above needs to be broader than transforma-

tional mission Tis is necessary if the church is to develop a robust inter-cultural and glocal missional ecclesiology

In my first book Salt Light and a City I outlined the foundational

themes of missional ecclesiology983095 Majority World and Western leaders

need to engage these themes in local and contextual ways Teir insights can

then enrich global conversations Tese global conversations in turn shape

local understandings and practices Tis way a glocal appreciation of these

themes emergesLocal regional and global theologies and practices are thereby enriched

Te church becomes healthier and more missionalmdasha truer expression of

the kingdom Te church becomes a fuller witness to Christ his passion for

the nations and his ability to bring unity in diversity

Stephen Bevans and Roger Schroeder outline the six constants of mission

Tese are our theologies about Jesus the church the end times salvation

human nature and culture Bevans and Schroeder describe the relationshipbetween these six and their historical cultural and theological contexts Tis is

why they call these six constants in context Our understanding of these six

constants develops in relation to local and global movements Sometimes local

voices influence our understandings of these six Other times it is regional or

global voices For all of us local regional and global influences are at play at

once Collectively they form our appreciation of the six constants of mission1048632

Here are eight theological themes that the church can develop through

processes of glocalization I presented these in my book Salt Light and a City

Tey are vital to the churchrsquos health mission community and future We

could add many other themes to these eight but these will suffice for now1048633

Scripture Te Scriptures are the infallible authoritative Word of God

Christrsquos Spirit has inspired them Tey have absolute and final authority in

all aspects of corporate and individual faith ethics conduct and witness

Christians interpret and apply Scripture in local contexts and in particular

7Graham Hill Salt Light and a City Introducing Missional Ecclesiology (Eugene OR Wip and

Stock 9830909830881048625983090) 10486251048628983097-983090104863110486288Stephen B Bevans and Roger Schroeder Constants in Context A Teology o Mission or oday

American Society o Missiology Series (Maryknoll NY Orbis 9830909830889830881048628) part one9Tese points first appeared in my book Salt Light and a City xxii-xxiv

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2236

Glocalizing Conversations 10486261048633

social settings Conversely we learn from the interpretations and readings

of other groups

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our local- global theology of Scripture and biblical interpretation

Evangelicalism Pentecostalism missional movements and so forth I

have charismatic missional and evangelical convictions Glocal conversa-

tions help me understand and practice these convictions better

I will use evangelicalism as an example Michael Horton says that our

beliefs and practices are evangelical when they are ldquocommitted to the suffi-

ciency of Scripture the priesthood of all believers the total lostness ofhumans the sole mediation of Christ the gracious efficacy and finality of

Godrsquos redemptive work in Christ through election propitiation calling and

keeping Te linchpin for all of this was the doctrine of justification by grace

alone through faith alone because of Christ alonerdquo9830891048624

Such convictions are necessary if we are to be faithful to the gospel and

to a biblical vision of church and mission Te gospel defines Godrsquos purposes

for humanity the church and the universe Te triune God controls thechurch He is its Lord and Savior Sanctifier and Liberator Master and King

He is completely sovereign over its nature affairs mission and history God

is the churchrsquos only source of grace election atonement salvation and per-

severance Te churchrsquos justification and hope are by grace alone through

faith alone by Christ alone

Herersquos the challenge I face My understanding of evangelicalism is

Western I am a product of the Western theological tradition and my Western

evangelical heritage Much of this is wonderful But I need indigenous and

Majority World evangelicals and others to help me expand and reshape

these insights Te same would be true if I were a Pentecostal

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of our theological traditions and convictions

Jesus Christ We must center our theology on Jesus Christ the Lord of

the church Te church needs to reflect on the person and work of Christ

and respond to him Tis means gathering and going in the name and power

of Christ It means allowing Christrsquos Spirit to shape our community and

10Michael Horton ldquoEvangelical Arminiansrdquo Modern Reormation 1048625 no 1048627 (1048625983097983097983090) 10486251048631

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2336

10486271048624 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

identity and mission It means developing our Christology ecclesiology and

missiology concurrently Te early church developed these three areas and

more in a concurrent and integrated way Tere was no linear progressionTe same is true in the contemporary global church

How can the glocal church best explore its nature structure mission and

hope Trough the centrality and the lordship of Christ

Majority World and indigenous Christians help us appreciate Jesus and

his mission afresh Tey show us how Jesus identifies with the marginalized

outcast oppressed rejected and broken He prefers them We find him

among ldquothe least of theserdquoGlocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of who Jesus Christ is How does it help us appreciate him better

What has Jesus done for and in his church and his world What does he care

about What individual and corporate responsibilities has he given us How

do we express these at local regional and global levels

Te Spirit Missional ecclesiology is inadequate without pneumatological

foundations In other words our theology of church and Spirit go togetherTe Spirit creates and animates the church He empowers it to witness to

Jesus and his gospel Te Spirit enables the church to be a missional trans-

formational community He shapes the church into an alternative society

embodying the reign of God Te church exists for the glory and mission of

Christ Te power and presence of the Spirit enables this mission worship

and glorification

Te Spirit pours out gis on the local-global church ldquofor the common

goodrdquo and ldquoto equip his people for works of service so that the body of Christ

may be built uprdquo Tis includes but isnrsquot limited to the ministry gis mani-

festation gis and motivational gis (1048625 Cor 104862510486261048631 Eph 104862810486251048625-10486251048626 Rom 104862510486261048630-1048632)

Te Spirit forms the glocal church He empowers it for service and

witness He fills it with Christrsquos empowering presence He leads it into the

missio Deimdashthe mission of the Father Son and Holy Spirit

Recently Pentecostal and renewalist movements have grown dramati-

cally in the Majority World Tey have increased in status size and influence

Many have matured theologically Te churches of the West must take notice

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of the power and presence of the Spirit

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2436

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048625

Te rinity Tere are clear limitations to the analogy between the

church and the rinity Te church can only image the rinity Yet the

church is at its best when it reflects the relational and missional passionof the rinity

What is the source and inspiration of the churchrsquos local-global mission

Ultimately it is the missional nature passion and actions of the Father Son

and Holy Spirit Godrsquos nature is missional His passion is infectious His

actions are historical redemptive and eternal Te rinity invites the

church into a sending community Te Father sends the Son Te Father

and Son send the Spirit Finally the rinity sends the church in missioninto the world

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of the rinity How does it enable our participation in the mission

and community of the triune God

Association and dialogue Tese need to happen across denominational

cultural ethnic gender and theological traditions and divides Authentic

dialogue is indispensable to the health and mission of the church What dothose marginal to the life of the church have to say to us What do ldquoothersrdquo

have to teach us Other ethnicities and cultures Other socioeconomic

groups Other ages and genders Other theological and confessing tradi-

tions Other persons from times long gone

We need to listen Share Be vulnerable Be authentic Open up to crit-

icism correction and change

We need more than dialogue We need communion and association It is

possible in a qualified way to say that God is present in all the various forms

of the church (ie the various theological ecclesiological sociocultural his-

torical and other permutations of the church) We discern this presence

through attention to Scripture history tradition culture and the Spirit Dis-

cernment involves critical dialogue theological exchange biblical study and

real relationship Only the Spirit of Jesus can enable this

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of association and dialogue

Mission and the missio Dei Te church is missional at its core It serves

obeys and images a missionary God David Bosch says ldquoTe churchrsquos mission

is not secondary to its being the church exists in being sent and in building up

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2536

10486271048626 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

itself for its missionrdquo He goes on to say ldquoEcclesiology does not precede missi-

ology there cannot be church without an intrinsic missionary dimensionrdquo983089983089

Jesus is Lord Lord of his church and Lord of his world His mission de-termines and forms the church His mission shapes the nature purposes

structures ministries and activities of his church Majority World and in-

digenous thinkers help us understand the implications of this mission Tey

help us form glocal theologies of mission Tey reveal ldquomission in context

as transformationrdquo9830891048626

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of mission and the missio Dei Church theology and practice Glocal conversations can inform and

enrich many aspects of the church (when practiced well) Teologies and

practices benefit from robust and critical glocal conversations Tese con-

versations enrich many areas (community spirituality discipleship liturgy

worship hospitality eco-justice education social ethics servantship lib-

eration place suffering beauty and so on)

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-standing of these many dimensions of church and mission

Glocal processes shape these eight themes and their practices We need

to facilitate and enable these conversations and processes Tis is urgent It

must be a priority No theology of mission or missional ecclesiology is ad-

equate without glocal conversations983089983091

T983144983141 L983151983139983137983148 983137983150983140 G983148983151983138983137983148 E983150983154983145983139983144 E983137983139983144 O983156983144983141983154

Glocalization takes the localparticular context and globaluniversal themes

seriously Contextual and global conversations enter an enriching and in-

forming relationship Tese two always have an active and symbiotic rela-

tionship Tis is true whether we deliberately put them into conversation or

not Te local shapes the global and the global shapes the local Many local

11David J Bosch Believing in the Future oward a Missiology o Western Culture (New York

rinity 1048625983097983097983093) 104862798309012izon ransormation Afer Lausanne 1048631-98309713Not all o these themes are dealt with in this present volume since either (1048625) I have dealt with them

in my book Salt Light and a City (983090) they are not all key themes in the writings o the thirty-five

Majority World thinkers considered in this volume or (1048627) there is not adequate space in a book

this size

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2636

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048627

voices converge to form global conversations and theologies Using the Phil-

ippines as a case study izon illustrates this by showing the interdepen-

dence between local and global themes in mission983089983092Dialogue between local and global conversations is critical Kōsuke

Koyama wrote an important book on contextual mission called Water Buffalo

Teology Koyama is a Japanese missionary who served in Chiang Mai

Tailand He writes of the joys and challenges of doing local particular water

buffalo theology He considers the relationship between local theology global

missional themes and transforming cultures ldquoWater Buffalo Teology sees

certain specific challenges Contextualization of theology implies two criticalmovements First to articulate Jesus Christ in culturally appropriate com-

municatively apt words and second to criticize reform dethrone or oppose

culture if it is found to be against what the name of Jesus Christ stands forrdquo9830891048629

Kōsuke Koyama challenges us to recognize what we bring to the task of

local theology For him it was doing theology in Tailand while being Jap-

anese We also need to notice the particular culture wersquore located in as we do

the work of theology Tis means we avoid speaking of an ldquoAsian theologyrdquoldquoAfrican theologyrdquo and the like We need to cultivate local theologies that

engage regional and global themes But these theologies must be ldquodistinctly

localrdquo and a ldquotheology from belowrdquo9830891048630

Simultaneously we need to pursue a reformation of theology and

practice ldquoin the global contextrdquo Tis means entering ldquothe disturbing spa-

ciousness of Jesus Christrdquo Jesus calls us to reject enmity and exceptionalism

We seem him present in our culture language stories and relationships

But we also choose to embrace the ldquootherrdquo We choose to see him present

in other culturesmdashshaping a global people to serve and worship him

joining in his mission983089983095

Kōsuke Koyama roots the gospel in the local contextual and particular

Tis is why he roots his water buffalo theology in Northern Tai culture He

is careful not to say ldquoHere is how you contextualize in your settingrdquo Instead

14izon ransormation Afer Lausanne 1048631-10486251048627 10486251048628983097-98309098308898309015Kōsuke Koyama Water Buffalo Teology 983090983093th anniversary ed (Maryknoll NY Orbis 1048625983097983097983097)

xiii-xv16Kōsuke Koyama ldquoTe Asian Approach to Christrdquo Missiology 1048625983090 no 1048628 (10486259830979830961048628) 10486281048627983093-104862798309617Kōsuke Koyama ldquoReormation in the Global Context Te Disturbing Spaciousness o Jesus Christrdquo

Currents in Teology and Mission 1048627983088 no 983090 (9830909830889830881048627) 10486251048625983097-983090983096

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2736

10486271048628 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

he tells us a story Itrsquos the story of how he contextualized theology in northern

Tailand while being open to global conversations Koyama asks us to form

our own local expressions of church mission and theology At the same timewe must stay attentive to what God is saying and doing beyond that context

Tis way local and global and particular and universal become mutually

enriching conversation partners

G983148983151983139983137983148983145983162983137983156983145983151983150 983137983150983140 H983145983155983156983151983154983145983139983137983148983148983161 S983145983148983141983150983139983141983140 V983151983145983139983141983155

Glocal theologies and conversations pay attention to voices that powers in-

stitutions religions and societies have silenced R S Sugirtharajah pushesback a little on izonrsquos ideas Sugirtharajah says that the church should

privilege local conversations He emphasizes the local contextual and post-

colonial reading of biblical texts9830891048632

Te church needs to listen Te church ought to be attentive to the

theologies and biblical interpretations of groups that cultures and reli-

gions have ignored Historically powerful secular and religious forces

have silenced these groups Tey have marginalized oppressed and colo-nized them It is time for the church to address this injustice We must

start listening to important but silenced voices We need to privilege the

voices of the former victims of Western colonialism We need to develop

postcolonial biblical interpretations theologies and expressions of church

and mission

How do we take such perspectives seriously as we develop glocal conver-

sations How do these themes help us foster vital relationships between local

and global voices

It is time for us to embrace values that enable conversations with those

oen ignored by the church We need values that help us learn from these

groups and individuals

Valuing equal partnership Colonizing powers oppressed silenced and

colonized certain groups At times the church was complicit Tese colo-

nized groups have become ldquoconfident indomitable and indispensable

partners in the dialogue and collaboration with the dispossessed and disad-

18R S Sugirtharajah Asian Biblical Hermeneutics and Postcolonialism Contesting the Interpreta-

tions Te Bible and Liberation Series (Maryknoll NY Orbis 1048625983097983097983096) 1048625983093-1048625983094

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2836

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048629

vantaged in the Westrdquo9830891048633 Tis calls for attentiveness to these voices and re-

sponsiveness to their prophetic challenges It also demands a critical evalu-

ation of colonial readings of Scripture Colonial models of theology andchurch and mission are no longer the benchmark Te global church must

examine them afresh

Valuing equal status Tose on the margins have now taken their rightful

place on the global stage Tey have claimed appropriate and equal status at

the table Subaltern readings of theology church and mission are invaluable

contributors to global theological conversations Tis means that we esteem

them But we also test themWhat do we mean by subaltern Subalterns are those who are down-

trodden and silenced (or have been treated this way in the past) Dominant

or colonizing groups treat them as invisible nonentities Tey enjoy limited

or no access to power Sometimes these are women certain tribal and ethnic

groups and those considered ldquountouchablerdquo In Voices from the Margin Su-

girtharajah provides a platform for postcolonial subaltern readings of

Scripture and theology Tese readings challenge colonialmdashoen Westernmdashreadings of Bible and theology and cultures Tey claim equal status with

other ways of doing theology10486261048624

Valuing equal identity People groups need freedom to explore their new

and emerging identities Tese emerge in response to local and global influ-

ences Local culture is not the only thing at work here Global forces also

shape identity as do imported practices ideas readings rituals and tech-

nologies But each group should be free to explore and construct their par-

ticular forms of Christian identity

Valuing equal interpretations ldquoPostcolonialism is concerned with the

question of cultural and discursive dominationrdquo Colonialism led to op-

pressive and controlling forms of culture and discourse Tese were usually

not contextual or indigenous Western powers for instance brought co-

lonial forms of theology church biblical interpretation and mission1048626983089

Postcolonialism calls for alternative ways of approaching these things Tose

19Ibid 104862598309420R S Sugirtharajah Voices rom the Margin Interpreting the Bible in the Tird World (Maryknoll

NY Orbis 10486259830979830971048625)21Sugirtharajah Asian Biblical Hermeneutics and Postcolonialism 10486251048631

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2936

10486271048630 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

who were once marginalized oppressed and silenced need to lead these fresh

approaches in their own settings Tese then influence global conversations

We need to support the new readings and insights and experiments from thesegroups o be genuine this support must be both critical and collegial

Valuing equal empowerment Sugirtharajah says that postcolonialism is

valuable when it empowers actual communities and real people Post-

colonial thought empowers when it addresses the difficulties hopes and

experiences of ordinary people It should never be about power plays and

the clever use of language Itrsquos pointless if itrsquos obsessed with forming newmdash

and ldquocolonizingrdquomdashtheories Itrsquos a waste of time if itrsquos a self-indulgent pursuitof new and hybrid identities Rather ldquothe worth and credibility of post-

colonial criticism will be judged by how it orchestrates the unique and

fragile and imagined claims of one community against anotherrdquo Empow-

erment happens in a variety of ways One way is contributing equally to

global conversations10486261048626

Al izon examines postcolonialism in the Philippines He says that it can

teach the global church a lot about healthy local-global conversations Fil-ipino contextual theology resists many Western forms of mission and the-

ology It finds them patronizing and controlling Tis indigenous theology

values prophetic sociopolitical engagement in institutions and the society

at large It emphasizes ministry to whole persons and communities It con-

structs a Filipino theology of beauty and mission and worship and com-

munity And it fosters indigenous theological approaches to the spirit world

and cosmology

izon says that postcolonial theology has played a constructive role in

the Philippines But he is uncomfortable with the label postcolonialism He

prefers to describe historical events as ldquobeyond colonialismrdquo And he says

that global conversations enrich local theologies and vice versa1048626983091

Postcolonial thought informs our understanding of the relationship be-

tween the local and global It also shows how theology can emerge at the

intersection between the localparticular and the globaluniversal It re-

minds us that worthwhile glocalization listens to all voices Tis includes

heeding those that have been historically silenced

22Ibid 983090104862823izon ransormation Afer Lausanne 1048625983088983090 10486259830941048631-9830961048631

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3036

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048631

G983148983151983139983137983148983145983162983137983156983145983151983150 983137983150983140 983156983144983141 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

C983151983150983139983148983157983140983145983150983143 R983141983142983148983141983139983156983145983151983150983155

How do we go about developing a model for glocal conversations izon hasrecently provided a useful model that is instructive as we seek to learn from

the Majority World It has at least two key features

First the local is in the global (globalization from below) Global theologies

and ideas have origins in many particular local contexts In that sense glo-

balization is from below Global ideas have local roots Ideas about integral

mission liberation theology and missional church have local origins Tey

have their roots in the prayers hopes discoveries mission and theologiesof thousands of local communities ldquoTe global does not cannot exist

without the localmdashbut the coming together of localities creates a global re-

ality that becomes greater than the sum of its parts it creates a gestalt entity

to which localities make themselves accountablerdquo1048626983092

Second the global is in the local (panlocalization from above) Te con-

cerns and voices of multitudes of locales form global conversations Tese

global discussions can provide a ldquopositive accountabilityrdquo back to local con-texts Tis is true when they enrich affirm serve guide and strengthen local

contexts It is also true when they avoid homogenization control impo-

sition and judgment Glocalization is best when it sees itself as interde-

pendent deeply connected with the local10486261048629

Tatrsquos a helpful starting point But we need to go further Besides izonrsquos

proposals Irsquom convinced that robust glocal conversations cultivate six core

practices

983089 Glocal theology practices its values We root glocal theology in core

values Tese values include solidarity understanding and mutual learning

Do we value fellowship with Christians of all cultures Do we value learning

from them

We prove our values through our practices What practices emerge out of

these values We need to collaborate act collectively and share information

We must find ways to foster grassroots perspectives and local theologies We

need to share stories and learnings and cultivate networks relationships and

partnerships We need attentiveness to local voices and global themes We

24Ibid 9830901048625983088-1048625104862825Ibid 98309010486251048628-1048625983096

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3136

10486271048632 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

ought to find ways to put these local and global voices into conversation

Mutual learning humility and solidarity are key Worthwhile glocal con-

versations can never be merely theoretical or academic It is up to us to rootour values in our practices

983090 Glocal theology practices humility (and it tells a new narrative) We

have noted that the local is in the global and the global is in the local Te

two are interdependent Tey form each other reciprocally Since this is the

case we must practice humility Tere is no place for ethnocentrism colo-

nialism or theological and cultural arrogance I have seen these unhealthy

postures far too oen in Western settingsRecently I attended a missional leadership conference On that occasion

the keynote speakermdasha leading missional author and speakermdashsaid that

North American missional conversations and innovations hold the key to

the future of the Western church Tis Euro American view is wrong (Irsquom

being kind o be frank itrsquos complete nonsense) Itrsquos arrogant and Euro

Americanndashcentric And itrsquos completely out of step with what is happening in

the glocal church We need a new narrativeIn June 1048626104862410486251048627 Te Center for the Study of Global Christianity reported

the top 10486261048624 countries where Christianity has the highest percentage growth

rate Nineteen of the top twenty are in Asia and Africa Eleven of them are

in Muslim majority countries Not a single country from Europe or North

America makes the top twenty list10486261048630

Itrsquos time to cultivate a new narrative Te future of the church is emerging

from the Majority World Rather than North America the churches of

Eastern Asia Western Africa the Arabian Peninsula and other parts of the

Majority World reveal the future of the global church We need the contribu-

tions of all contexts Western indigenous and Majority World All con-

tribute to glocal conversations All are important as we learn from each

other about mission theology and faith But letrsquos stop pretending that North

Americans and Europeans will reveal the future of the global church Letrsquos

start listening to what God is saying about the future of the global church

And hersquos speaking to us through the churches of Asia Africa Latin America

26Russ Mitchell ldquoTe op 983090983088 Countries Where Christianity Is Growing the Fastestrdquo Disciple All

Nations (blog) August 983090983093 98309098308810486251048627 httpsdiscipleallnationswordpresscom98309098308810486251048627983088983096983090983093the-top

-983090983088-countries-where-christianity-is-growing-the-astest

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3236

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048633

Muslim majority settings and so on We must cultivate a new glocal nar-

rativemdashone soaked in humility

Glocal theology must be humble theology Meek theology Receptive the-ology Discerning theology Prayerful theology Dialogical theology De-

pendent theology A theology that celebrates the interdependence between

the localparticular and the globaluniversal

983091 Glocal theology practices expansiveness Glocalization is by nature

comprehensive Local and global influences permeate much of our lives Tese

glocal forces shape our theologies and churches whether we like it or not

But intentionality is also important We need to commit to an expansiveapproach to glocal theology How do we deliberately cultivate glocal conver-

sations in our biblical interpretation Do we foster them in our under-

standing of the person and work of Christ How does glocalization shape

the way the Spirit empowers and constitutes the church How can it form

our understanding of the nature and mission of the rinity How does it

influence the way we practice fellowship and conversation across denomi-

national cultural ethnic economic sociocultural political gender andtheological divides How might it shape our theologies of mission com-

munity beauty spirituality suffering discipleship hospitality eco-justice

place education social ethics Christian leadership and so forth

983092 Glocal theology practices attention Glocal theology doesnrsquot need to

accept all the assumptions or assertions of postcolonial or Majority World

thought But it does need to engage with them and take them seriously

Postcolonial theology for instance gives the marginalized and colonized

and forgotten and silenced both dignity and voice Our glocal conversations

must also include and esteem these groups We need to be attentive to

others weak and powerful female and male dominant and downtrodden

old and young rich and poor privileged and marginalized influential and

subaltern educated and illiterate We need to practice the art of attention

being especially attentive to those who are different to us

983093 Glocal theology practices embrace What do colonial ethnocentric or

Western-centric perspectives do Tey silence Tey control Tey com-

modify Tey institutionalize Tey colonize Tey domesticate Tey replace

Tey import Tey exclude Tey do these things to the beliefs experiences

and practices of other cultures A worthwhile glocal theology refuses to do

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3336

10486281048624 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

these things Instead it adopts a responsive humble celebratory open in-

clusive and embracing attitude

983094 Glocal theology practices discernment Finally we need discernmentas we engage these ideas and practices Discernment is a huge topic thatrsquos

hard to cover comprehensively in a few words Discernment happens when

the Spirit of Christ and his Word renew our minds Te Spirit grants us

spiritual wisdom as we meditate on him and his Word and as we practice

discipleship to Jesus Christ Romans 10486251048626 provides guidance we need (1048625) to be

transformed by the renewal of our minds (1048626) to serve Christrsquos body and (1048627)

to put love into action Discernment also happens in conversation both lo-cally and glocally

I pray these core values and six practices come across in the following

chapters of GlobalChurch

Glocalization can never be just theoretical Are we committed to moving

glocalization from an abstract idea to a living communion Are we deter-

mined to construct a missional theology of the church in the context of

glocal conversations Tis must involve dialogue between Majority Worldindigenous and Western scholars activists and groups

Will glocalization be an abstract notion Or will it be a formative and

genuine communion between local regional and global voices Glocal dy-

namics are at play whether we like it or not Teyrsquore in our churches the-

ologies and missions But we can choose to relinquish isolationist colonial

parochial and arrogant approaches Instead we can adopt responsive dia-

logical learning humble and embracing postures

Trough healthy approaches to glocalization the Spirit challenges us to

value local contexts We immerse ourselves in local and particular commu-

nities and conversations He inspires us to open ourselves to global theo-

logical conversations He rouses us to value the symbiotic relationship be-

tween the localparticular and the globaluniversal

Trough glocal relationships the Spirit leads us to put local contextual

theologies into conversation with global ones He prompts us to explore the

ways in which the local is in the glocal and the global is in the local He per-

suades us to pursue collaboration and dialogue and mutual learning We

engage with Christians from different backgrounds and cultures ecumen-

icals Pentecostals evangelicals and so on from Western indigenous and

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3436

Glocalizing Conversations 10486281048625

Majority World contexts He motivates us to express solidarity between all

parties We appreciate our unity in diversity

Trough glocal conversations the Spirit moves us to ensure that unity andsolidarity emerge from a compelling vision of Jesusrsquo kingdom and gospel

and person He challenges us to share information theology and practices

He urges us to learn from each othermdashour successes and mistakes We seek

glocal solutions

Te Spirit calls us to develop glocal conversations about Christian ideas

and practices Tese include Scripture Evangelicalism ecumenism Pente-

costalism Jesus Christ the Holy Spirit God the Father the rinity com-munity spirituality discipleship liturgy worship hospitality prayer eco-

justice education social ethics Christian leadership gospel and culture

beauty place suffering liberation and so forth

Finally through glocal conversations the Spirit leads us to adopt a new

posture Tis is a responsive humble celebratory open inclusive and em-

bracing attitude to the ldquootherrdquo We do this as a new people made up of every

tribe and language and people and nationTere are dangers in glocalization Sugirtharajah warns of the commodi-

fication of local contextual practices and theologies When this happens

they are ldquosmoothed out of their primary contexts concerns and contesta-

tions travel across borders and become objects of analysis and scrutiny

within an alien secondary contextrdquo1048626983095

Itrsquos common for those of us who are Western to make mistakes when we

wrestle with Majority World and indigenous ideas Sugirtharajah mentions

our tendency to commodify reduce and institutionalize these ideas We also

risk doing these things (1048625) We apply them in noncontextual prescriptive ways

(1048626) We ignore their meanings in their original setting (1048627) We glamorize or

idealize their proponents or their contexts (1048628) We demonize those persons or

contexts (1048629) We disregard them as irrelevant rhetorical or minority discourse

Kevin J Vanhoozer says that we can fall into three traps when we glo-

calize theology (1048625) We can underestimate the theological significance of

local cultures (1048626) We can homogenize cultures and theologies exaggerating

27R S Sugirtharajah ldquoextual ake-Aways Tird World exts in Western Metropolitan Centresrdquo

Black Teology in Britain A Journal o Contextual Praxis 983090 (1048625983097983097983097) 10486271048627 10486271048631 Edward W Said Te

World the ext and the Critic (Cambridge MA Harvard University Press 10486259830979830961048627) 9830901048627983097

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3536

10486281048626 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

ldquothe onerdquo (1048627) We can overemphasize cultural particularity exaggerating ldquothe

manyrdquo and pursue ldquotheological ethnificationrdquo10486261048632

My hope is that GlobalChurch does not fall into the traps Sugirtharajahand Vanhoozer describe I hope that what unfolds in the following chapters

is respectful and discerning I hope it leads to further mutually enriching

conversations between people of different cultures

You the reader face the same challenges You face them in your personal

life ministry context and missional engagements

Will you treat the themes in this book as abstract theoretical notions

Will this be a temporary infatuation a flirtation with the ldquootherrdquo that dissi-pates as suddenly as it arrived Or will glocal conversations become an en-

riching and formative orientation in your life Will glocal conversations

bring fresh approaches to theology faith mission church and worship Will

conversations with other cultures and theologies become for you a com-

pelling way of life

My prayer is that glocal conversations will help the church be a global

visible alternative ldquocity set upon a hillrdquo a truly GlobalChurch

28Craig Ott and Harold A Netland Globalizing Teology Belie and Practice in an Era o World

Christianity (Grand Rapids Baker Academic 983090983088983088983094) 1048625983090983093

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3636

Page 16: GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1636

G L O C A L I Z I N G

C O N V E R S A T I O N S

H983151983159 D983151 W983141 D983141983158983141983148983151983152

G983148983151983139983137983148 C983151983150983158983141983154983155983137983156983145983151983150983155983103

Rather than taking one contextual version of the Gospel and imposing

it as the Gospel throughout the world via the missionary enterprise

the shapers of Mission as ransformation have recognized the

plurality of localities that has created an intercontextual

ldquopan-localrdquo global phenomenon in theology

AL IZON

The International Society for Urban Mission (ISUM) is a group of urban

missionaries who are passionate about cultivating hope and love and re-newal in cities Irsquove connected with this group for some years ISUM held its

first annual Summit on Integral Urban Mission in Bangkok Tailand Te

team from Urban Neighbours of Hope (UNOH) under the leadership of

my Australian friends Ash and Anj Barker organized much of the summit

UNOH teams covenant with God and each other to ldquolive out our passion for

loving God and neighbour Focus on releasing neighbourhoods from urban

poverty Grow through equipping each other neighbours and the broader

church to radically follow Jesus and join Godrsquos Kingdom coming UNOH

workers live and serve in small responsive neighbourhood-based teamsrdquo983089

1See wwwunohorg

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1736

10486261048628 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

Tis summit involved interactive participatory hands-on immersion op-

portunities keynotes lectures and workshops Keynote speakers came from

Africa Australia Myanmar New Zealand North America the PhilippinesSouth America Tailand and First Nations A few hundred Majority World

and Western thinkers and activists came together for those days Tey explored

the theology and practices of integral transformational and urban mission

Tese thinkers and activists pursued a range of aims1048626 Tis included col-

laboration between urban Christians from a variety of backgrounds (Ma-

jority World and Western theologians activists ecumenicals Pentecostals

evangelicals colleges church movements and development agencies) Teyaimed for collective action and thought in an international and integral

context Tey sought to gain mutual understanding for a comprehensive

picture of urban mission around the globe Tey encouraged information

sharing and best practicesmdashlearning from our mistakes and seeking solu-

tions Tey developed recommendations and calls to action to the broader

church Working groups wrote briefing papers aer each summit based on

key issues in urban mission And they endeavored to build trust wisdomand inspiration to better engage our new urban world

Majority World and Western leaders participated in discussion prayer

integral mission and working groups Te goal was to grapple with key issues

and ask key questions How do we recruit equip and sustain urban mission

today How do we release church movements among the urban poor How

can we immerse ourselves in and transform urban neighborhoods How do

we empower urban children and young people How does the church serve

and liberate the oppressedmdashand others suffering from urban injustice What

needs to happen for poorer urban centers to develop economically socially

and spiritually How do we join God in the challenges and opportunities of

multifaith cities

Workshops included urban gardening child protection and collaborating

with local churches in urban mission Workshops also included organic

church growth and mission as well as developing NGO and government

partnerships Groups considered the good the bad and the ugly of short-

term urban mission teams

2Tese aims are detailed at ldquoInternational Society or Urban Mission Summitrdquo httpnewurbanworld

orgsummit

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1836

Glocalizing Conversations 10486261048629

Te summit was a thrilling example of how Majority World and Western

leaders can cooperate It was a time to come together in an environment of

mutual learning and enrichment It was a window into how local contextsand global themes can enrich each other Tis resulted from ISUMrsquos com-

mitment to ldquosolidarity fellowship and insight between urban Christian

leaders in the Western and Majority Worldsrdquo

Te summit was a success due to ISUMrsquos core values What are they983091 Christ-

honoring urban mission values bottom-up grassroots perspectivesmdashrather

than top-down distanced perspectives It allows local theology to reveal new

insights and perspectives about Godrsquos activity It shares insights and experi-ences through narratives embedded within urban poor communities and cities

It cultivates ongoing practical and personal solidarity with the worldrsquos urban

poor Tis Spirit-empowered urban mission honors networks relationships

and partnerships It sees such relationships as the primary method of serving

together It listens to and amplifies the voices of the urban poormdashespecially

those from the Majority World and in particular the 1048625104862410486281048624 window cities It is

attentive to signs of the kingdom of God Urban mission that glorifies God iswilling to reflect and respond with active and sacrificial commitment It shares

and extends the life of the body of Christ among the urban poor

Tis summit was a milestone in urban missiology It enriched communi-

cation between Western and Majority World thinker-activists Tis resulted

from the aims and values Irsquove mentioned Effective urban mission needs to

be a conversation on many levels It is attentive to context and immersed in

local settings It appreciates global and universal missional themes It culti-

vates dialogue between these local-global (glocal) realities It involves

mutual learning between Western and Majority World thinker-activists

Moreover solidarity between all parties is a defining feature Tis solidarity

is due to a compelling vision of the kingdom of God

Tese collaborative glocal features of the ISUM urban mission summit

in Bangkok are critical for the aims of this book GlobalChurch

Majority World indigenous and Western leaders thinkers and churches

can stretch and enrich each other But they need to be open and attentive to

each other Tey need learning postures and open hearts and minds Tey

3ldquoAbout ISUMrdquo httpnewurbanworldorgabout

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1936

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2036

Glocalizing Conversations 10486261048631

always rooted in the local and particularmdashas local churches embody the

gospel and witness to Christ Tese churches forge their own theological

understandings as they do mission together Tey engage in transformationalpractices among the people in their settings Tey enjoy worship mission

and community in their local and particular context Ideally the result is

unique contextual theologies and missions

Simultaneously global conversations form Tey form because of this

multitude of local theologies and practices Local conversations inform and

enrich other local conversations catalyzing global themes and voices izon

observes that the global ldquoowes its existence to local contexts Sharedconvictions among the theologies and practices of local contextual realities

give shape to its global dimensionsrdquo1048629

Majority World indigenous and Western theologies are equally contextual

Tey are equally culture bound Tey are equally particular to their time and

location At times they are all enlightened or myopic liberating or con-

straining humanizing or objectifying beautiful or offensive prophetic or

tepid Te local particular and cultural shape all these theologies Converselythese particular theologies feed and influence global conversations Tere is

no place then for ethnocentrism colonialism or elitism Tere is no place

for theological missional cultural or institutionalized arrogance

Multiple local contexts and voices come togethermdashintentionally or notmdashto

form global themes and theologies Conversely these global realities shape

local contexts oday local contexts must grapple with ldquoan emerging global

culture ie the interacting realities of modernity postmodernity and the

phenomenon of globalizationrdquo1048630 Hence the interdependent and symbiotic

relationship between the localparticular and the globaluniversal We call this

interdependent relationship between the local and the global glocalization

Te global church needs a thrilling glocal exchange We need one that we

characterize by mutuality respect partnership and symbiosis Such ex-

change helps Majority World indigenous and Western churches learn from

each other It enables them to pursue missional theology and practice o-

gether the church becomes a ldquocity on a hillrdquo

5Ibid 10486259830886Ibid 9830961048628

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2136

10486261048632 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

W983144983137983156 R983141983153983157983145983154983141983155 G983148983151983139983137983148983145983162983137983156983145983151983150983103

Te glocal exchange described above needs to be broader than transforma-

tional mission Tis is necessary if the church is to develop a robust inter-cultural and glocal missional ecclesiology

In my first book Salt Light and a City I outlined the foundational

themes of missional ecclesiology983095 Majority World and Western leaders

need to engage these themes in local and contextual ways Teir insights can

then enrich global conversations Tese global conversations in turn shape

local understandings and practices Tis way a glocal appreciation of these

themes emergesLocal regional and global theologies and practices are thereby enriched

Te church becomes healthier and more missionalmdasha truer expression of

the kingdom Te church becomes a fuller witness to Christ his passion for

the nations and his ability to bring unity in diversity

Stephen Bevans and Roger Schroeder outline the six constants of mission

Tese are our theologies about Jesus the church the end times salvation

human nature and culture Bevans and Schroeder describe the relationshipbetween these six and their historical cultural and theological contexts Tis is

why they call these six constants in context Our understanding of these six

constants develops in relation to local and global movements Sometimes local

voices influence our understandings of these six Other times it is regional or

global voices For all of us local regional and global influences are at play at

once Collectively they form our appreciation of the six constants of mission1048632

Here are eight theological themes that the church can develop through

processes of glocalization I presented these in my book Salt Light and a City

Tey are vital to the churchrsquos health mission community and future We

could add many other themes to these eight but these will suffice for now1048633

Scripture Te Scriptures are the infallible authoritative Word of God

Christrsquos Spirit has inspired them Tey have absolute and final authority in

all aspects of corporate and individual faith ethics conduct and witness

Christians interpret and apply Scripture in local contexts and in particular

7Graham Hill Salt Light and a City Introducing Missional Ecclesiology (Eugene OR Wip and

Stock 9830909830881048625983090) 10486251048628983097-983090104863110486288Stephen B Bevans and Roger Schroeder Constants in Context A Teology o Mission or oday

American Society o Missiology Series (Maryknoll NY Orbis 9830909830889830881048628) part one9Tese points first appeared in my book Salt Light and a City xxii-xxiv

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2236

Glocalizing Conversations 10486261048633

social settings Conversely we learn from the interpretations and readings

of other groups

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our local- global theology of Scripture and biblical interpretation

Evangelicalism Pentecostalism missional movements and so forth I

have charismatic missional and evangelical convictions Glocal conversa-

tions help me understand and practice these convictions better

I will use evangelicalism as an example Michael Horton says that our

beliefs and practices are evangelical when they are ldquocommitted to the suffi-

ciency of Scripture the priesthood of all believers the total lostness ofhumans the sole mediation of Christ the gracious efficacy and finality of

Godrsquos redemptive work in Christ through election propitiation calling and

keeping Te linchpin for all of this was the doctrine of justification by grace

alone through faith alone because of Christ alonerdquo9830891048624

Such convictions are necessary if we are to be faithful to the gospel and

to a biblical vision of church and mission Te gospel defines Godrsquos purposes

for humanity the church and the universe Te triune God controls thechurch He is its Lord and Savior Sanctifier and Liberator Master and King

He is completely sovereign over its nature affairs mission and history God

is the churchrsquos only source of grace election atonement salvation and per-

severance Te churchrsquos justification and hope are by grace alone through

faith alone by Christ alone

Herersquos the challenge I face My understanding of evangelicalism is

Western I am a product of the Western theological tradition and my Western

evangelical heritage Much of this is wonderful But I need indigenous and

Majority World evangelicals and others to help me expand and reshape

these insights Te same would be true if I were a Pentecostal

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of our theological traditions and convictions

Jesus Christ We must center our theology on Jesus Christ the Lord of

the church Te church needs to reflect on the person and work of Christ

and respond to him Tis means gathering and going in the name and power

of Christ It means allowing Christrsquos Spirit to shape our community and

10Michael Horton ldquoEvangelical Arminiansrdquo Modern Reormation 1048625 no 1048627 (1048625983097983097983090) 10486251048631

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2336

10486271048624 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

identity and mission It means developing our Christology ecclesiology and

missiology concurrently Te early church developed these three areas and

more in a concurrent and integrated way Tere was no linear progressionTe same is true in the contemporary global church

How can the glocal church best explore its nature structure mission and

hope Trough the centrality and the lordship of Christ

Majority World and indigenous Christians help us appreciate Jesus and

his mission afresh Tey show us how Jesus identifies with the marginalized

outcast oppressed rejected and broken He prefers them We find him

among ldquothe least of theserdquoGlocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of who Jesus Christ is How does it help us appreciate him better

What has Jesus done for and in his church and his world What does he care

about What individual and corporate responsibilities has he given us How

do we express these at local regional and global levels

Te Spirit Missional ecclesiology is inadequate without pneumatological

foundations In other words our theology of church and Spirit go togetherTe Spirit creates and animates the church He empowers it to witness to

Jesus and his gospel Te Spirit enables the church to be a missional trans-

formational community He shapes the church into an alternative society

embodying the reign of God Te church exists for the glory and mission of

Christ Te power and presence of the Spirit enables this mission worship

and glorification

Te Spirit pours out gis on the local-global church ldquofor the common

goodrdquo and ldquoto equip his people for works of service so that the body of Christ

may be built uprdquo Tis includes but isnrsquot limited to the ministry gis mani-

festation gis and motivational gis (1048625 Cor 104862510486261048631 Eph 104862810486251048625-10486251048626 Rom 104862510486261048630-1048632)

Te Spirit forms the glocal church He empowers it for service and

witness He fills it with Christrsquos empowering presence He leads it into the

missio Deimdashthe mission of the Father Son and Holy Spirit

Recently Pentecostal and renewalist movements have grown dramati-

cally in the Majority World Tey have increased in status size and influence

Many have matured theologically Te churches of the West must take notice

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of the power and presence of the Spirit

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2436

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048625

Te rinity Tere are clear limitations to the analogy between the

church and the rinity Te church can only image the rinity Yet the

church is at its best when it reflects the relational and missional passionof the rinity

What is the source and inspiration of the churchrsquos local-global mission

Ultimately it is the missional nature passion and actions of the Father Son

and Holy Spirit Godrsquos nature is missional His passion is infectious His

actions are historical redemptive and eternal Te rinity invites the

church into a sending community Te Father sends the Son Te Father

and Son send the Spirit Finally the rinity sends the church in missioninto the world

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of the rinity How does it enable our participation in the mission

and community of the triune God

Association and dialogue Tese need to happen across denominational

cultural ethnic gender and theological traditions and divides Authentic

dialogue is indispensable to the health and mission of the church What dothose marginal to the life of the church have to say to us What do ldquoothersrdquo

have to teach us Other ethnicities and cultures Other socioeconomic

groups Other ages and genders Other theological and confessing tradi-

tions Other persons from times long gone

We need to listen Share Be vulnerable Be authentic Open up to crit-

icism correction and change

We need more than dialogue We need communion and association It is

possible in a qualified way to say that God is present in all the various forms

of the church (ie the various theological ecclesiological sociocultural his-

torical and other permutations of the church) We discern this presence

through attention to Scripture history tradition culture and the Spirit Dis-

cernment involves critical dialogue theological exchange biblical study and

real relationship Only the Spirit of Jesus can enable this

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of association and dialogue

Mission and the missio Dei Te church is missional at its core It serves

obeys and images a missionary God David Bosch says ldquoTe churchrsquos mission

is not secondary to its being the church exists in being sent and in building up

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2536

10486271048626 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

itself for its missionrdquo He goes on to say ldquoEcclesiology does not precede missi-

ology there cannot be church without an intrinsic missionary dimensionrdquo983089983089

Jesus is Lord Lord of his church and Lord of his world His mission de-termines and forms the church His mission shapes the nature purposes

structures ministries and activities of his church Majority World and in-

digenous thinkers help us understand the implications of this mission Tey

help us form glocal theologies of mission Tey reveal ldquomission in context

as transformationrdquo9830891048626

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of mission and the missio Dei Church theology and practice Glocal conversations can inform and

enrich many aspects of the church (when practiced well) Teologies and

practices benefit from robust and critical glocal conversations Tese con-

versations enrich many areas (community spirituality discipleship liturgy

worship hospitality eco-justice education social ethics servantship lib-

eration place suffering beauty and so on)

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-standing of these many dimensions of church and mission

Glocal processes shape these eight themes and their practices We need

to facilitate and enable these conversations and processes Tis is urgent It

must be a priority No theology of mission or missional ecclesiology is ad-

equate without glocal conversations983089983091

T983144983141 L983151983139983137983148 983137983150983140 G983148983151983138983137983148 E983150983154983145983139983144 E983137983139983144 O983156983144983141983154

Glocalization takes the localparticular context and globaluniversal themes

seriously Contextual and global conversations enter an enriching and in-

forming relationship Tese two always have an active and symbiotic rela-

tionship Tis is true whether we deliberately put them into conversation or

not Te local shapes the global and the global shapes the local Many local

11David J Bosch Believing in the Future oward a Missiology o Western Culture (New York

rinity 1048625983097983097983093) 104862798309012izon ransormation Afer Lausanne 1048631-98309713Not all o these themes are dealt with in this present volume since either (1048625) I have dealt with them

in my book Salt Light and a City (983090) they are not all key themes in the writings o the thirty-five

Majority World thinkers considered in this volume or (1048627) there is not adequate space in a book

this size

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2636

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048627

voices converge to form global conversations and theologies Using the Phil-

ippines as a case study izon illustrates this by showing the interdepen-

dence between local and global themes in mission983089983092Dialogue between local and global conversations is critical Kōsuke

Koyama wrote an important book on contextual mission called Water Buffalo

Teology Koyama is a Japanese missionary who served in Chiang Mai

Tailand He writes of the joys and challenges of doing local particular water

buffalo theology He considers the relationship between local theology global

missional themes and transforming cultures ldquoWater Buffalo Teology sees

certain specific challenges Contextualization of theology implies two criticalmovements First to articulate Jesus Christ in culturally appropriate com-

municatively apt words and second to criticize reform dethrone or oppose

culture if it is found to be against what the name of Jesus Christ stands forrdquo9830891048629

Kōsuke Koyama challenges us to recognize what we bring to the task of

local theology For him it was doing theology in Tailand while being Jap-

anese We also need to notice the particular culture wersquore located in as we do

the work of theology Tis means we avoid speaking of an ldquoAsian theologyrdquoldquoAfrican theologyrdquo and the like We need to cultivate local theologies that

engage regional and global themes But these theologies must be ldquodistinctly

localrdquo and a ldquotheology from belowrdquo9830891048630

Simultaneously we need to pursue a reformation of theology and

practice ldquoin the global contextrdquo Tis means entering ldquothe disturbing spa-

ciousness of Jesus Christrdquo Jesus calls us to reject enmity and exceptionalism

We seem him present in our culture language stories and relationships

But we also choose to embrace the ldquootherrdquo We choose to see him present

in other culturesmdashshaping a global people to serve and worship him

joining in his mission983089983095

Kōsuke Koyama roots the gospel in the local contextual and particular

Tis is why he roots his water buffalo theology in Northern Tai culture He

is careful not to say ldquoHere is how you contextualize in your settingrdquo Instead

14izon ransormation Afer Lausanne 1048631-10486251048627 10486251048628983097-98309098308898309015Kōsuke Koyama Water Buffalo Teology 983090983093th anniversary ed (Maryknoll NY Orbis 1048625983097983097983097)

xiii-xv16Kōsuke Koyama ldquoTe Asian Approach to Christrdquo Missiology 1048625983090 no 1048628 (10486259830979830961048628) 10486281048627983093-104862798309617Kōsuke Koyama ldquoReormation in the Global Context Te Disturbing Spaciousness o Jesus Christrdquo

Currents in Teology and Mission 1048627983088 no 983090 (9830909830889830881048627) 10486251048625983097-983090983096

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2736

10486271048628 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

he tells us a story Itrsquos the story of how he contextualized theology in northern

Tailand while being open to global conversations Koyama asks us to form

our own local expressions of church mission and theology At the same timewe must stay attentive to what God is saying and doing beyond that context

Tis way local and global and particular and universal become mutually

enriching conversation partners

G983148983151983139983137983148983145983162983137983156983145983151983150 983137983150983140 H983145983155983156983151983154983145983139983137983148983148983161 S983145983148983141983150983139983141983140 V983151983145983139983141983155

Glocal theologies and conversations pay attention to voices that powers in-

stitutions religions and societies have silenced R S Sugirtharajah pushesback a little on izonrsquos ideas Sugirtharajah says that the church should

privilege local conversations He emphasizes the local contextual and post-

colonial reading of biblical texts9830891048632

Te church needs to listen Te church ought to be attentive to the

theologies and biblical interpretations of groups that cultures and reli-

gions have ignored Historically powerful secular and religious forces

have silenced these groups Tey have marginalized oppressed and colo-nized them It is time for the church to address this injustice We must

start listening to important but silenced voices We need to privilege the

voices of the former victims of Western colonialism We need to develop

postcolonial biblical interpretations theologies and expressions of church

and mission

How do we take such perspectives seriously as we develop glocal conver-

sations How do these themes help us foster vital relationships between local

and global voices

It is time for us to embrace values that enable conversations with those

oen ignored by the church We need values that help us learn from these

groups and individuals

Valuing equal partnership Colonizing powers oppressed silenced and

colonized certain groups At times the church was complicit Tese colo-

nized groups have become ldquoconfident indomitable and indispensable

partners in the dialogue and collaboration with the dispossessed and disad-

18R S Sugirtharajah Asian Biblical Hermeneutics and Postcolonialism Contesting the Interpreta-

tions Te Bible and Liberation Series (Maryknoll NY Orbis 1048625983097983097983096) 1048625983093-1048625983094

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2836

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048629

vantaged in the Westrdquo9830891048633 Tis calls for attentiveness to these voices and re-

sponsiveness to their prophetic challenges It also demands a critical evalu-

ation of colonial readings of Scripture Colonial models of theology andchurch and mission are no longer the benchmark Te global church must

examine them afresh

Valuing equal status Tose on the margins have now taken their rightful

place on the global stage Tey have claimed appropriate and equal status at

the table Subaltern readings of theology church and mission are invaluable

contributors to global theological conversations Tis means that we esteem

them But we also test themWhat do we mean by subaltern Subalterns are those who are down-

trodden and silenced (or have been treated this way in the past) Dominant

or colonizing groups treat them as invisible nonentities Tey enjoy limited

or no access to power Sometimes these are women certain tribal and ethnic

groups and those considered ldquountouchablerdquo In Voices from the Margin Su-

girtharajah provides a platform for postcolonial subaltern readings of

Scripture and theology Tese readings challenge colonialmdashoen Westernmdashreadings of Bible and theology and cultures Tey claim equal status with

other ways of doing theology10486261048624

Valuing equal identity People groups need freedom to explore their new

and emerging identities Tese emerge in response to local and global influ-

ences Local culture is not the only thing at work here Global forces also

shape identity as do imported practices ideas readings rituals and tech-

nologies But each group should be free to explore and construct their par-

ticular forms of Christian identity

Valuing equal interpretations ldquoPostcolonialism is concerned with the

question of cultural and discursive dominationrdquo Colonialism led to op-

pressive and controlling forms of culture and discourse Tese were usually

not contextual or indigenous Western powers for instance brought co-

lonial forms of theology church biblical interpretation and mission1048626983089

Postcolonialism calls for alternative ways of approaching these things Tose

19Ibid 104862598309420R S Sugirtharajah Voices rom the Margin Interpreting the Bible in the Tird World (Maryknoll

NY Orbis 10486259830979830971048625)21Sugirtharajah Asian Biblical Hermeneutics and Postcolonialism 10486251048631

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2936

10486271048630 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

who were once marginalized oppressed and silenced need to lead these fresh

approaches in their own settings Tese then influence global conversations

We need to support the new readings and insights and experiments from thesegroups o be genuine this support must be both critical and collegial

Valuing equal empowerment Sugirtharajah says that postcolonialism is

valuable when it empowers actual communities and real people Post-

colonial thought empowers when it addresses the difficulties hopes and

experiences of ordinary people It should never be about power plays and

the clever use of language Itrsquos pointless if itrsquos obsessed with forming newmdash

and ldquocolonizingrdquomdashtheories Itrsquos a waste of time if itrsquos a self-indulgent pursuitof new and hybrid identities Rather ldquothe worth and credibility of post-

colonial criticism will be judged by how it orchestrates the unique and

fragile and imagined claims of one community against anotherrdquo Empow-

erment happens in a variety of ways One way is contributing equally to

global conversations10486261048626

Al izon examines postcolonialism in the Philippines He says that it can

teach the global church a lot about healthy local-global conversations Fil-ipino contextual theology resists many Western forms of mission and the-

ology It finds them patronizing and controlling Tis indigenous theology

values prophetic sociopolitical engagement in institutions and the society

at large It emphasizes ministry to whole persons and communities It con-

structs a Filipino theology of beauty and mission and worship and com-

munity And it fosters indigenous theological approaches to the spirit world

and cosmology

izon says that postcolonial theology has played a constructive role in

the Philippines But he is uncomfortable with the label postcolonialism He

prefers to describe historical events as ldquobeyond colonialismrdquo And he says

that global conversations enrich local theologies and vice versa1048626983091

Postcolonial thought informs our understanding of the relationship be-

tween the local and global It also shows how theology can emerge at the

intersection between the localparticular and the globaluniversal It re-

minds us that worthwhile glocalization listens to all voices Tis includes

heeding those that have been historically silenced

22Ibid 983090104862823izon ransormation Afer Lausanne 1048625983088983090 10486259830941048631-9830961048631

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3036

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048631

G983148983151983139983137983148983145983162983137983156983145983151983150 983137983150983140 983156983144983141 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

C983151983150983139983148983157983140983145983150983143 R983141983142983148983141983139983156983145983151983150983155

How do we go about developing a model for glocal conversations izon hasrecently provided a useful model that is instructive as we seek to learn from

the Majority World It has at least two key features

First the local is in the global (globalization from below) Global theologies

and ideas have origins in many particular local contexts In that sense glo-

balization is from below Global ideas have local roots Ideas about integral

mission liberation theology and missional church have local origins Tey

have their roots in the prayers hopes discoveries mission and theologiesof thousands of local communities ldquoTe global does not cannot exist

without the localmdashbut the coming together of localities creates a global re-

ality that becomes greater than the sum of its parts it creates a gestalt entity

to which localities make themselves accountablerdquo1048626983092

Second the global is in the local (panlocalization from above) Te con-

cerns and voices of multitudes of locales form global conversations Tese

global discussions can provide a ldquopositive accountabilityrdquo back to local con-texts Tis is true when they enrich affirm serve guide and strengthen local

contexts It is also true when they avoid homogenization control impo-

sition and judgment Glocalization is best when it sees itself as interde-

pendent deeply connected with the local10486261048629

Tatrsquos a helpful starting point But we need to go further Besides izonrsquos

proposals Irsquom convinced that robust glocal conversations cultivate six core

practices

983089 Glocal theology practices its values We root glocal theology in core

values Tese values include solidarity understanding and mutual learning

Do we value fellowship with Christians of all cultures Do we value learning

from them

We prove our values through our practices What practices emerge out of

these values We need to collaborate act collectively and share information

We must find ways to foster grassroots perspectives and local theologies We

need to share stories and learnings and cultivate networks relationships and

partnerships We need attentiveness to local voices and global themes We

24Ibid 9830901048625983088-1048625104862825Ibid 98309010486251048628-1048625983096

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3136

10486271048632 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

ought to find ways to put these local and global voices into conversation

Mutual learning humility and solidarity are key Worthwhile glocal con-

versations can never be merely theoretical or academic It is up to us to rootour values in our practices

983090 Glocal theology practices humility (and it tells a new narrative) We

have noted that the local is in the global and the global is in the local Te

two are interdependent Tey form each other reciprocally Since this is the

case we must practice humility Tere is no place for ethnocentrism colo-

nialism or theological and cultural arrogance I have seen these unhealthy

postures far too oen in Western settingsRecently I attended a missional leadership conference On that occasion

the keynote speakermdasha leading missional author and speakermdashsaid that

North American missional conversations and innovations hold the key to

the future of the Western church Tis Euro American view is wrong (Irsquom

being kind o be frank itrsquos complete nonsense) Itrsquos arrogant and Euro

Americanndashcentric And itrsquos completely out of step with what is happening in

the glocal church We need a new narrativeIn June 1048626104862410486251048627 Te Center for the Study of Global Christianity reported

the top 10486261048624 countries where Christianity has the highest percentage growth

rate Nineteen of the top twenty are in Asia and Africa Eleven of them are

in Muslim majority countries Not a single country from Europe or North

America makes the top twenty list10486261048630

Itrsquos time to cultivate a new narrative Te future of the church is emerging

from the Majority World Rather than North America the churches of

Eastern Asia Western Africa the Arabian Peninsula and other parts of the

Majority World reveal the future of the global church We need the contribu-

tions of all contexts Western indigenous and Majority World All con-

tribute to glocal conversations All are important as we learn from each

other about mission theology and faith But letrsquos stop pretending that North

Americans and Europeans will reveal the future of the global church Letrsquos

start listening to what God is saying about the future of the global church

And hersquos speaking to us through the churches of Asia Africa Latin America

26Russ Mitchell ldquoTe op 983090983088 Countries Where Christianity Is Growing the Fastestrdquo Disciple All

Nations (blog) August 983090983093 98309098308810486251048627 httpsdiscipleallnationswordpresscom98309098308810486251048627983088983096983090983093the-top

-983090983088-countries-where-christianity-is-growing-the-astest

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3236

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048633

Muslim majority settings and so on We must cultivate a new glocal nar-

rativemdashone soaked in humility

Glocal theology must be humble theology Meek theology Receptive the-ology Discerning theology Prayerful theology Dialogical theology De-

pendent theology A theology that celebrates the interdependence between

the localparticular and the globaluniversal

983091 Glocal theology practices expansiveness Glocalization is by nature

comprehensive Local and global influences permeate much of our lives Tese

glocal forces shape our theologies and churches whether we like it or not

But intentionality is also important We need to commit to an expansiveapproach to glocal theology How do we deliberately cultivate glocal conver-

sations in our biblical interpretation Do we foster them in our under-

standing of the person and work of Christ How does glocalization shape

the way the Spirit empowers and constitutes the church How can it form

our understanding of the nature and mission of the rinity How does it

influence the way we practice fellowship and conversation across denomi-

national cultural ethnic economic sociocultural political gender andtheological divides How might it shape our theologies of mission com-

munity beauty spirituality suffering discipleship hospitality eco-justice

place education social ethics Christian leadership and so forth

983092 Glocal theology practices attention Glocal theology doesnrsquot need to

accept all the assumptions or assertions of postcolonial or Majority World

thought But it does need to engage with them and take them seriously

Postcolonial theology for instance gives the marginalized and colonized

and forgotten and silenced both dignity and voice Our glocal conversations

must also include and esteem these groups We need to be attentive to

others weak and powerful female and male dominant and downtrodden

old and young rich and poor privileged and marginalized influential and

subaltern educated and illiterate We need to practice the art of attention

being especially attentive to those who are different to us

983093 Glocal theology practices embrace What do colonial ethnocentric or

Western-centric perspectives do Tey silence Tey control Tey com-

modify Tey institutionalize Tey colonize Tey domesticate Tey replace

Tey import Tey exclude Tey do these things to the beliefs experiences

and practices of other cultures A worthwhile glocal theology refuses to do

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3336

10486281048624 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

these things Instead it adopts a responsive humble celebratory open in-

clusive and embracing attitude

983094 Glocal theology practices discernment Finally we need discernmentas we engage these ideas and practices Discernment is a huge topic thatrsquos

hard to cover comprehensively in a few words Discernment happens when

the Spirit of Christ and his Word renew our minds Te Spirit grants us

spiritual wisdom as we meditate on him and his Word and as we practice

discipleship to Jesus Christ Romans 10486251048626 provides guidance we need (1048625) to be

transformed by the renewal of our minds (1048626) to serve Christrsquos body and (1048627)

to put love into action Discernment also happens in conversation both lo-cally and glocally

I pray these core values and six practices come across in the following

chapters of GlobalChurch

Glocalization can never be just theoretical Are we committed to moving

glocalization from an abstract idea to a living communion Are we deter-

mined to construct a missional theology of the church in the context of

glocal conversations Tis must involve dialogue between Majority Worldindigenous and Western scholars activists and groups

Will glocalization be an abstract notion Or will it be a formative and

genuine communion between local regional and global voices Glocal dy-

namics are at play whether we like it or not Teyrsquore in our churches the-

ologies and missions But we can choose to relinquish isolationist colonial

parochial and arrogant approaches Instead we can adopt responsive dia-

logical learning humble and embracing postures

Trough healthy approaches to glocalization the Spirit challenges us to

value local contexts We immerse ourselves in local and particular commu-

nities and conversations He inspires us to open ourselves to global theo-

logical conversations He rouses us to value the symbiotic relationship be-

tween the localparticular and the globaluniversal

Trough glocal relationships the Spirit leads us to put local contextual

theologies into conversation with global ones He prompts us to explore the

ways in which the local is in the glocal and the global is in the local He per-

suades us to pursue collaboration and dialogue and mutual learning We

engage with Christians from different backgrounds and cultures ecumen-

icals Pentecostals evangelicals and so on from Western indigenous and

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3436

Glocalizing Conversations 10486281048625

Majority World contexts He motivates us to express solidarity between all

parties We appreciate our unity in diversity

Trough glocal conversations the Spirit moves us to ensure that unity andsolidarity emerge from a compelling vision of Jesusrsquo kingdom and gospel

and person He challenges us to share information theology and practices

He urges us to learn from each othermdashour successes and mistakes We seek

glocal solutions

Te Spirit calls us to develop glocal conversations about Christian ideas

and practices Tese include Scripture Evangelicalism ecumenism Pente-

costalism Jesus Christ the Holy Spirit God the Father the rinity com-munity spirituality discipleship liturgy worship hospitality prayer eco-

justice education social ethics Christian leadership gospel and culture

beauty place suffering liberation and so forth

Finally through glocal conversations the Spirit leads us to adopt a new

posture Tis is a responsive humble celebratory open inclusive and em-

bracing attitude to the ldquootherrdquo We do this as a new people made up of every

tribe and language and people and nationTere are dangers in glocalization Sugirtharajah warns of the commodi-

fication of local contextual practices and theologies When this happens

they are ldquosmoothed out of their primary contexts concerns and contesta-

tions travel across borders and become objects of analysis and scrutiny

within an alien secondary contextrdquo1048626983095

Itrsquos common for those of us who are Western to make mistakes when we

wrestle with Majority World and indigenous ideas Sugirtharajah mentions

our tendency to commodify reduce and institutionalize these ideas We also

risk doing these things (1048625) We apply them in noncontextual prescriptive ways

(1048626) We ignore their meanings in their original setting (1048627) We glamorize or

idealize their proponents or their contexts (1048628) We demonize those persons or

contexts (1048629) We disregard them as irrelevant rhetorical or minority discourse

Kevin J Vanhoozer says that we can fall into three traps when we glo-

calize theology (1048625) We can underestimate the theological significance of

local cultures (1048626) We can homogenize cultures and theologies exaggerating

27R S Sugirtharajah ldquoextual ake-Aways Tird World exts in Western Metropolitan Centresrdquo

Black Teology in Britain A Journal o Contextual Praxis 983090 (1048625983097983097983097) 10486271048627 10486271048631 Edward W Said Te

World the ext and the Critic (Cambridge MA Harvard University Press 10486259830979830961048627) 9830901048627983097

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3536

10486281048626 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

ldquothe onerdquo (1048627) We can overemphasize cultural particularity exaggerating ldquothe

manyrdquo and pursue ldquotheological ethnificationrdquo10486261048632

My hope is that GlobalChurch does not fall into the traps Sugirtharajahand Vanhoozer describe I hope that what unfolds in the following chapters

is respectful and discerning I hope it leads to further mutually enriching

conversations between people of different cultures

You the reader face the same challenges You face them in your personal

life ministry context and missional engagements

Will you treat the themes in this book as abstract theoretical notions

Will this be a temporary infatuation a flirtation with the ldquootherrdquo that dissi-pates as suddenly as it arrived Or will glocal conversations become an en-

riching and formative orientation in your life Will glocal conversations

bring fresh approaches to theology faith mission church and worship Will

conversations with other cultures and theologies become for you a com-

pelling way of life

My prayer is that glocal conversations will help the church be a global

visible alternative ldquocity set upon a hillrdquo a truly GlobalChurch

28Craig Ott and Harold A Netland Globalizing Teology Belie and Practice in an Era o World

Christianity (Grand Rapids Baker Academic 983090983088983088983094) 1048625983090983093

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3636

Page 17: GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1736

10486261048628 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

Tis summit involved interactive participatory hands-on immersion op-

portunities keynotes lectures and workshops Keynote speakers came from

Africa Australia Myanmar New Zealand North America the PhilippinesSouth America Tailand and First Nations A few hundred Majority World

and Western thinkers and activists came together for those days Tey explored

the theology and practices of integral transformational and urban mission

Tese thinkers and activists pursued a range of aims1048626 Tis included col-

laboration between urban Christians from a variety of backgrounds (Ma-

jority World and Western theologians activists ecumenicals Pentecostals

evangelicals colleges church movements and development agencies) Teyaimed for collective action and thought in an international and integral

context Tey sought to gain mutual understanding for a comprehensive

picture of urban mission around the globe Tey encouraged information

sharing and best practicesmdashlearning from our mistakes and seeking solu-

tions Tey developed recommendations and calls to action to the broader

church Working groups wrote briefing papers aer each summit based on

key issues in urban mission And they endeavored to build trust wisdomand inspiration to better engage our new urban world

Majority World and Western leaders participated in discussion prayer

integral mission and working groups Te goal was to grapple with key issues

and ask key questions How do we recruit equip and sustain urban mission

today How do we release church movements among the urban poor How

can we immerse ourselves in and transform urban neighborhoods How do

we empower urban children and young people How does the church serve

and liberate the oppressedmdashand others suffering from urban injustice What

needs to happen for poorer urban centers to develop economically socially

and spiritually How do we join God in the challenges and opportunities of

multifaith cities

Workshops included urban gardening child protection and collaborating

with local churches in urban mission Workshops also included organic

church growth and mission as well as developing NGO and government

partnerships Groups considered the good the bad and the ugly of short-

term urban mission teams

2Tese aims are detailed at ldquoInternational Society or Urban Mission Summitrdquo httpnewurbanworld

orgsummit

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1836

Glocalizing Conversations 10486261048629

Te summit was a thrilling example of how Majority World and Western

leaders can cooperate It was a time to come together in an environment of

mutual learning and enrichment It was a window into how local contextsand global themes can enrich each other Tis resulted from ISUMrsquos com-

mitment to ldquosolidarity fellowship and insight between urban Christian

leaders in the Western and Majority Worldsrdquo

Te summit was a success due to ISUMrsquos core values What are they983091 Christ-

honoring urban mission values bottom-up grassroots perspectivesmdashrather

than top-down distanced perspectives It allows local theology to reveal new

insights and perspectives about Godrsquos activity It shares insights and experi-ences through narratives embedded within urban poor communities and cities

It cultivates ongoing practical and personal solidarity with the worldrsquos urban

poor Tis Spirit-empowered urban mission honors networks relationships

and partnerships It sees such relationships as the primary method of serving

together It listens to and amplifies the voices of the urban poormdashespecially

those from the Majority World and in particular the 1048625104862410486281048624 window cities It is

attentive to signs of the kingdom of God Urban mission that glorifies God iswilling to reflect and respond with active and sacrificial commitment It shares

and extends the life of the body of Christ among the urban poor

Tis summit was a milestone in urban missiology It enriched communi-

cation between Western and Majority World thinker-activists Tis resulted

from the aims and values Irsquove mentioned Effective urban mission needs to

be a conversation on many levels It is attentive to context and immersed in

local settings It appreciates global and universal missional themes It culti-

vates dialogue between these local-global (glocal) realities It involves

mutual learning between Western and Majority World thinker-activists

Moreover solidarity between all parties is a defining feature Tis solidarity

is due to a compelling vision of the kingdom of God

Tese collaborative glocal features of the ISUM urban mission summit

in Bangkok are critical for the aims of this book GlobalChurch

Majority World indigenous and Western leaders thinkers and churches

can stretch and enrich each other But they need to be open and attentive to

each other Tey need learning postures and open hearts and minds Tey

3ldquoAbout ISUMrdquo httpnewurbanworldorgabout

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1936

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2036

Glocalizing Conversations 10486261048631

always rooted in the local and particularmdashas local churches embody the

gospel and witness to Christ Tese churches forge their own theological

understandings as they do mission together Tey engage in transformationalpractices among the people in their settings Tey enjoy worship mission

and community in their local and particular context Ideally the result is

unique contextual theologies and missions

Simultaneously global conversations form Tey form because of this

multitude of local theologies and practices Local conversations inform and

enrich other local conversations catalyzing global themes and voices izon

observes that the global ldquoowes its existence to local contexts Sharedconvictions among the theologies and practices of local contextual realities

give shape to its global dimensionsrdquo1048629

Majority World indigenous and Western theologies are equally contextual

Tey are equally culture bound Tey are equally particular to their time and

location At times they are all enlightened or myopic liberating or con-

straining humanizing or objectifying beautiful or offensive prophetic or

tepid Te local particular and cultural shape all these theologies Converselythese particular theologies feed and influence global conversations Tere is

no place then for ethnocentrism colonialism or elitism Tere is no place

for theological missional cultural or institutionalized arrogance

Multiple local contexts and voices come togethermdashintentionally or notmdashto

form global themes and theologies Conversely these global realities shape

local contexts oday local contexts must grapple with ldquoan emerging global

culture ie the interacting realities of modernity postmodernity and the

phenomenon of globalizationrdquo1048630 Hence the interdependent and symbiotic

relationship between the localparticular and the globaluniversal We call this

interdependent relationship between the local and the global glocalization

Te global church needs a thrilling glocal exchange We need one that we

characterize by mutuality respect partnership and symbiosis Such ex-

change helps Majority World indigenous and Western churches learn from

each other It enables them to pursue missional theology and practice o-

gether the church becomes a ldquocity on a hillrdquo

5Ibid 10486259830886Ibid 9830961048628

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2136

10486261048632 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

W983144983137983156 R983141983153983157983145983154983141983155 G983148983151983139983137983148983145983162983137983156983145983151983150983103

Te glocal exchange described above needs to be broader than transforma-

tional mission Tis is necessary if the church is to develop a robust inter-cultural and glocal missional ecclesiology

In my first book Salt Light and a City I outlined the foundational

themes of missional ecclesiology983095 Majority World and Western leaders

need to engage these themes in local and contextual ways Teir insights can

then enrich global conversations Tese global conversations in turn shape

local understandings and practices Tis way a glocal appreciation of these

themes emergesLocal regional and global theologies and practices are thereby enriched

Te church becomes healthier and more missionalmdasha truer expression of

the kingdom Te church becomes a fuller witness to Christ his passion for

the nations and his ability to bring unity in diversity

Stephen Bevans and Roger Schroeder outline the six constants of mission

Tese are our theologies about Jesus the church the end times salvation

human nature and culture Bevans and Schroeder describe the relationshipbetween these six and their historical cultural and theological contexts Tis is

why they call these six constants in context Our understanding of these six

constants develops in relation to local and global movements Sometimes local

voices influence our understandings of these six Other times it is regional or

global voices For all of us local regional and global influences are at play at

once Collectively they form our appreciation of the six constants of mission1048632

Here are eight theological themes that the church can develop through

processes of glocalization I presented these in my book Salt Light and a City

Tey are vital to the churchrsquos health mission community and future We

could add many other themes to these eight but these will suffice for now1048633

Scripture Te Scriptures are the infallible authoritative Word of God

Christrsquos Spirit has inspired them Tey have absolute and final authority in

all aspects of corporate and individual faith ethics conduct and witness

Christians interpret and apply Scripture in local contexts and in particular

7Graham Hill Salt Light and a City Introducing Missional Ecclesiology (Eugene OR Wip and

Stock 9830909830881048625983090) 10486251048628983097-983090104863110486288Stephen B Bevans and Roger Schroeder Constants in Context A Teology o Mission or oday

American Society o Missiology Series (Maryknoll NY Orbis 9830909830889830881048628) part one9Tese points first appeared in my book Salt Light and a City xxii-xxiv

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2236

Glocalizing Conversations 10486261048633

social settings Conversely we learn from the interpretations and readings

of other groups

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our local- global theology of Scripture and biblical interpretation

Evangelicalism Pentecostalism missional movements and so forth I

have charismatic missional and evangelical convictions Glocal conversa-

tions help me understand and practice these convictions better

I will use evangelicalism as an example Michael Horton says that our

beliefs and practices are evangelical when they are ldquocommitted to the suffi-

ciency of Scripture the priesthood of all believers the total lostness ofhumans the sole mediation of Christ the gracious efficacy and finality of

Godrsquos redemptive work in Christ through election propitiation calling and

keeping Te linchpin for all of this was the doctrine of justification by grace

alone through faith alone because of Christ alonerdquo9830891048624

Such convictions are necessary if we are to be faithful to the gospel and

to a biblical vision of church and mission Te gospel defines Godrsquos purposes

for humanity the church and the universe Te triune God controls thechurch He is its Lord and Savior Sanctifier and Liberator Master and King

He is completely sovereign over its nature affairs mission and history God

is the churchrsquos only source of grace election atonement salvation and per-

severance Te churchrsquos justification and hope are by grace alone through

faith alone by Christ alone

Herersquos the challenge I face My understanding of evangelicalism is

Western I am a product of the Western theological tradition and my Western

evangelical heritage Much of this is wonderful But I need indigenous and

Majority World evangelicals and others to help me expand and reshape

these insights Te same would be true if I were a Pentecostal

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of our theological traditions and convictions

Jesus Christ We must center our theology on Jesus Christ the Lord of

the church Te church needs to reflect on the person and work of Christ

and respond to him Tis means gathering and going in the name and power

of Christ It means allowing Christrsquos Spirit to shape our community and

10Michael Horton ldquoEvangelical Arminiansrdquo Modern Reormation 1048625 no 1048627 (1048625983097983097983090) 10486251048631

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2336

10486271048624 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

identity and mission It means developing our Christology ecclesiology and

missiology concurrently Te early church developed these three areas and

more in a concurrent and integrated way Tere was no linear progressionTe same is true in the contemporary global church

How can the glocal church best explore its nature structure mission and

hope Trough the centrality and the lordship of Christ

Majority World and indigenous Christians help us appreciate Jesus and

his mission afresh Tey show us how Jesus identifies with the marginalized

outcast oppressed rejected and broken He prefers them We find him

among ldquothe least of theserdquoGlocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of who Jesus Christ is How does it help us appreciate him better

What has Jesus done for and in his church and his world What does he care

about What individual and corporate responsibilities has he given us How

do we express these at local regional and global levels

Te Spirit Missional ecclesiology is inadequate without pneumatological

foundations In other words our theology of church and Spirit go togetherTe Spirit creates and animates the church He empowers it to witness to

Jesus and his gospel Te Spirit enables the church to be a missional trans-

formational community He shapes the church into an alternative society

embodying the reign of God Te church exists for the glory and mission of

Christ Te power and presence of the Spirit enables this mission worship

and glorification

Te Spirit pours out gis on the local-global church ldquofor the common

goodrdquo and ldquoto equip his people for works of service so that the body of Christ

may be built uprdquo Tis includes but isnrsquot limited to the ministry gis mani-

festation gis and motivational gis (1048625 Cor 104862510486261048631 Eph 104862810486251048625-10486251048626 Rom 104862510486261048630-1048632)

Te Spirit forms the glocal church He empowers it for service and

witness He fills it with Christrsquos empowering presence He leads it into the

missio Deimdashthe mission of the Father Son and Holy Spirit

Recently Pentecostal and renewalist movements have grown dramati-

cally in the Majority World Tey have increased in status size and influence

Many have matured theologically Te churches of the West must take notice

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of the power and presence of the Spirit

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2436

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048625

Te rinity Tere are clear limitations to the analogy between the

church and the rinity Te church can only image the rinity Yet the

church is at its best when it reflects the relational and missional passionof the rinity

What is the source and inspiration of the churchrsquos local-global mission

Ultimately it is the missional nature passion and actions of the Father Son

and Holy Spirit Godrsquos nature is missional His passion is infectious His

actions are historical redemptive and eternal Te rinity invites the

church into a sending community Te Father sends the Son Te Father

and Son send the Spirit Finally the rinity sends the church in missioninto the world

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of the rinity How does it enable our participation in the mission

and community of the triune God

Association and dialogue Tese need to happen across denominational

cultural ethnic gender and theological traditions and divides Authentic

dialogue is indispensable to the health and mission of the church What dothose marginal to the life of the church have to say to us What do ldquoothersrdquo

have to teach us Other ethnicities and cultures Other socioeconomic

groups Other ages and genders Other theological and confessing tradi-

tions Other persons from times long gone

We need to listen Share Be vulnerable Be authentic Open up to crit-

icism correction and change

We need more than dialogue We need communion and association It is

possible in a qualified way to say that God is present in all the various forms

of the church (ie the various theological ecclesiological sociocultural his-

torical and other permutations of the church) We discern this presence

through attention to Scripture history tradition culture and the Spirit Dis-

cernment involves critical dialogue theological exchange biblical study and

real relationship Only the Spirit of Jesus can enable this

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of association and dialogue

Mission and the missio Dei Te church is missional at its core It serves

obeys and images a missionary God David Bosch says ldquoTe churchrsquos mission

is not secondary to its being the church exists in being sent and in building up

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2536

10486271048626 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

itself for its missionrdquo He goes on to say ldquoEcclesiology does not precede missi-

ology there cannot be church without an intrinsic missionary dimensionrdquo983089983089

Jesus is Lord Lord of his church and Lord of his world His mission de-termines and forms the church His mission shapes the nature purposes

structures ministries and activities of his church Majority World and in-

digenous thinkers help us understand the implications of this mission Tey

help us form glocal theologies of mission Tey reveal ldquomission in context

as transformationrdquo9830891048626

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of mission and the missio Dei Church theology and practice Glocal conversations can inform and

enrich many aspects of the church (when practiced well) Teologies and

practices benefit from robust and critical glocal conversations Tese con-

versations enrich many areas (community spirituality discipleship liturgy

worship hospitality eco-justice education social ethics servantship lib-

eration place suffering beauty and so on)

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-standing of these many dimensions of church and mission

Glocal processes shape these eight themes and their practices We need

to facilitate and enable these conversations and processes Tis is urgent It

must be a priority No theology of mission or missional ecclesiology is ad-

equate without glocal conversations983089983091

T983144983141 L983151983139983137983148 983137983150983140 G983148983151983138983137983148 E983150983154983145983139983144 E983137983139983144 O983156983144983141983154

Glocalization takes the localparticular context and globaluniversal themes

seriously Contextual and global conversations enter an enriching and in-

forming relationship Tese two always have an active and symbiotic rela-

tionship Tis is true whether we deliberately put them into conversation or

not Te local shapes the global and the global shapes the local Many local

11David J Bosch Believing in the Future oward a Missiology o Western Culture (New York

rinity 1048625983097983097983093) 104862798309012izon ransormation Afer Lausanne 1048631-98309713Not all o these themes are dealt with in this present volume since either (1048625) I have dealt with them

in my book Salt Light and a City (983090) they are not all key themes in the writings o the thirty-five

Majority World thinkers considered in this volume or (1048627) there is not adequate space in a book

this size

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2636

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048627

voices converge to form global conversations and theologies Using the Phil-

ippines as a case study izon illustrates this by showing the interdepen-

dence between local and global themes in mission983089983092Dialogue between local and global conversations is critical Kōsuke

Koyama wrote an important book on contextual mission called Water Buffalo

Teology Koyama is a Japanese missionary who served in Chiang Mai

Tailand He writes of the joys and challenges of doing local particular water

buffalo theology He considers the relationship between local theology global

missional themes and transforming cultures ldquoWater Buffalo Teology sees

certain specific challenges Contextualization of theology implies two criticalmovements First to articulate Jesus Christ in culturally appropriate com-

municatively apt words and second to criticize reform dethrone or oppose

culture if it is found to be against what the name of Jesus Christ stands forrdquo9830891048629

Kōsuke Koyama challenges us to recognize what we bring to the task of

local theology For him it was doing theology in Tailand while being Jap-

anese We also need to notice the particular culture wersquore located in as we do

the work of theology Tis means we avoid speaking of an ldquoAsian theologyrdquoldquoAfrican theologyrdquo and the like We need to cultivate local theologies that

engage regional and global themes But these theologies must be ldquodistinctly

localrdquo and a ldquotheology from belowrdquo9830891048630

Simultaneously we need to pursue a reformation of theology and

practice ldquoin the global contextrdquo Tis means entering ldquothe disturbing spa-

ciousness of Jesus Christrdquo Jesus calls us to reject enmity and exceptionalism

We seem him present in our culture language stories and relationships

But we also choose to embrace the ldquootherrdquo We choose to see him present

in other culturesmdashshaping a global people to serve and worship him

joining in his mission983089983095

Kōsuke Koyama roots the gospel in the local contextual and particular

Tis is why he roots his water buffalo theology in Northern Tai culture He

is careful not to say ldquoHere is how you contextualize in your settingrdquo Instead

14izon ransormation Afer Lausanne 1048631-10486251048627 10486251048628983097-98309098308898309015Kōsuke Koyama Water Buffalo Teology 983090983093th anniversary ed (Maryknoll NY Orbis 1048625983097983097983097)

xiii-xv16Kōsuke Koyama ldquoTe Asian Approach to Christrdquo Missiology 1048625983090 no 1048628 (10486259830979830961048628) 10486281048627983093-104862798309617Kōsuke Koyama ldquoReormation in the Global Context Te Disturbing Spaciousness o Jesus Christrdquo

Currents in Teology and Mission 1048627983088 no 983090 (9830909830889830881048627) 10486251048625983097-983090983096

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2736

10486271048628 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

he tells us a story Itrsquos the story of how he contextualized theology in northern

Tailand while being open to global conversations Koyama asks us to form

our own local expressions of church mission and theology At the same timewe must stay attentive to what God is saying and doing beyond that context

Tis way local and global and particular and universal become mutually

enriching conversation partners

G983148983151983139983137983148983145983162983137983156983145983151983150 983137983150983140 H983145983155983156983151983154983145983139983137983148983148983161 S983145983148983141983150983139983141983140 V983151983145983139983141983155

Glocal theologies and conversations pay attention to voices that powers in-

stitutions religions and societies have silenced R S Sugirtharajah pushesback a little on izonrsquos ideas Sugirtharajah says that the church should

privilege local conversations He emphasizes the local contextual and post-

colonial reading of biblical texts9830891048632

Te church needs to listen Te church ought to be attentive to the

theologies and biblical interpretations of groups that cultures and reli-

gions have ignored Historically powerful secular and religious forces

have silenced these groups Tey have marginalized oppressed and colo-nized them It is time for the church to address this injustice We must

start listening to important but silenced voices We need to privilege the

voices of the former victims of Western colonialism We need to develop

postcolonial biblical interpretations theologies and expressions of church

and mission

How do we take such perspectives seriously as we develop glocal conver-

sations How do these themes help us foster vital relationships between local

and global voices

It is time for us to embrace values that enable conversations with those

oen ignored by the church We need values that help us learn from these

groups and individuals

Valuing equal partnership Colonizing powers oppressed silenced and

colonized certain groups At times the church was complicit Tese colo-

nized groups have become ldquoconfident indomitable and indispensable

partners in the dialogue and collaboration with the dispossessed and disad-

18R S Sugirtharajah Asian Biblical Hermeneutics and Postcolonialism Contesting the Interpreta-

tions Te Bible and Liberation Series (Maryknoll NY Orbis 1048625983097983097983096) 1048625983093-1048625983094

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2836

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048629

vantaged in the Westrdquo9830891048633 Tis calls for attentiveness to these voices and re-

sponsiveness to their prophetic challenges It also demands a critical evalu-

ation of colonial readings of Scripture Colonial models of theology andchurch and mission are no longer the benchmark Te global church must

examine them afresh

Valuing equal status Tose on the margins have now taken their rightful

place on the global stage Tey have claimed appropriate and equal status at

the table Subaltern readings of theology church and mission are invaluable

contributors to global theological conversations Tis means that we esteem

them But we also test themWhat do we mean by subaltern Subalterns are those who are down-

trodden and silenced (or have been treated this way in the past) Dominant

or colonizing groups treat them as invisible nonentities Tey enjoy limited

or no access to power Sometimes these are women certain tribal and ethnic

groups and those considered ldquountouchablerdquo In Voices from the Margin Su-

girtharajah provides a platform for postcolonial subaltern readings of

Scripture and theology Tese readings challenge colonialmdashoen Westernmdashreadings of Bible and theology and cultures Tey claim equal status with

other ways of doing theology10486261048624

Valuing equal identity People groups need freedom to explore their new

and emerging identities Tese emerge in response to local and global influ-

ences Local culture is not the only thing at work here Global forces also

shape identity as do imported practices ideas readings rituals and tech-

nologies But each group should be free to explore and construct their par-

ticular forms of Christian identity

Valuing equal interpretations ldquoPostcolonialism is concerned with the

question of cultural and discursive dominationrdquo Colonialism led to op-

pressive and controlling forms of culture and discourse Tese were usually

not contextual or indigenous Western powers for instance brought co-

lonial forms of theology church biblical interpretation and mission1048626983089

Postcolonialism calls for alternative ways of approaching these things Tose

19Ibid 104862598309420R S Sugirtharajah Voices rom the Margin Interpreting the Bible in the Tird World (Maryknoll

NY Orbis 10486259830979830971048625)21Sugirtharajah Asian Biblical Hermeneutics and Postcolonialism 10486251048631

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2936

10486271048630 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

who were once marginalized oppressed and silenced need to lead these fresh

approaches in their own settings Tese then influence global conversations

We need to support the new readings and insights and experiments from thesegroups o be genuine this support must be both critical and collegial

Valuing equal empowerment Sugirtharajah says that postcolonialism is

valuable when it empowers actual communities and real people Post-

colonial thought empowers when it addresses the difficulties hopes and

experiences of ordinary people It should never be about power plays and

the clever use of language Itrsquos pointless if itrsquos obsessed with forming newmdash

and ldquocolonizingrdquomdashtheories Itrsquos a waste of time if itrsquos a self-indulgent pursuitof new and hybrid identities Rather ldquothe worth and credibility of post-

colonial criticism will be judged by how it orchestrates the unique and

fragile and imagined claims of one community against anotherrdquo Empow-

erment happens in a variety of ways One way is contributing equally to

global conversations10486261048626

Al izon examines postcolonialism in the Philippines He says that it can

teach the global church a lot about healthy local-global conversations Fil-ipino contextual theology resists many Western forms of mission and the-

ology It finds them patronizing and controlling Tis indigenous theology

values prophetic sociopolitical engagement in institutions and the society

at large It emphasizes ministry to whole persons and communities It con-

structs a Filipino theology of beauty and mission and worship and com-

munity And it fosters indigenous theological approaches to the spirit world

and cosmology

izon says that postcolonial theology has played a constructive role in

the Philippines But he is uncomfortable with the label postcolonialism He

prefers to describe historical events as ldquobeyond colonialismrdquo And he says

that global conversations enrich local theologies and vice versa1048626983091

Postcolonial thought informs our understanding of the relationship be-

tween the local and global It also shows how theology can emerge at the

intersection between the localparticular and the globaluniversal It re-

minds us that worthwhile glocalization listens to all voices Tis includes

heeding those that have been historically silenced

22Ibid 983090104862823izon ransormation Afer Lausanne 1048625983088983090 10486259830941048631-9830961048631

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3036

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048631

G983148983151983139983137983148983145983162983137983156983145983151983150 983137983150983140 983156983144983141 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

C983151983150983139983148983157983140983145983150983143 R983141983142983148983141983139983156983145983151983150983155

How do we go about developing a model for glocal conversations izon hasrecently provided a useful model that is instructive as we seek to learn from

the Majority World It has at least two key features

First the local is in the global (globalization from below) Global theologies

and ideas have origins in many particular local contexts In that sense glo-

balization is from below Global ideas have local roots Ideas about integral

mission liberation theology and missional church have local origins Tey

have their roots in the prayers hopes discoveries mission and theologiesof thousands of local communities ldquoTe global does not cannot exist

without the localmdashbut the coming together of localities creates a global re-

ality that becomes greater than the sum of its parts it creates a gestalt entity

to which localities make themselves accountablerdquo1048626983092

Second the global is in the local (panlocalization from above) Te con-

cerns and voices of multitudes of locales form global conversations Tese

global discussions can provide a ldquopositive accountabilityrdquo back to local con-texts Tis is true when they enrich affirm serve guide and strengthen local

contexts It is also true when they avoid homogenization control impo-

sition and judgment Glocalization is best when it sees itself as interde-

pendent deeply connected with the local10486261048629

Tatrsquos a helpful starting point But we need to go further Besides izonrsquos

proposals Irsquom convinced that robust glocal conversations cultivate six core

practices

983089 Glocal theology practices its values We root glocal theology in core

values Tese values include solidarity understanding and mutual learning

Do we value fellowship with Christians of all cultures Do we value learning

from them

We prove our values through our practices What practices emerge out of

these values We need to collaborate act collectively and share information

We must find ways to foster grassroots perspectives and local theologies We

need to share stories and learnings and cultivate networks relationships and

partnerships We need attentiveness to local voices and global themes We

24Ibid 9830901048625983088-1048625104862825Ibid 98309010486251048628-1048625983096

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3136

10486271048632 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

ought to find ways to put these local and global voices into conversation

Mutual learning humility and solidarity are key Worthwhile glocal con-

versations can never be merely theoretical or academic It is up to us to rootour values in our practices

983090 Glocal theology practices humility (and it tells a new narrative) We

have noted that the local is in the global and the global is in the local Te

two are interdependent Tey form each other reciprocally Since this is the

case we must practice humility Tere is no place for ethnocentrism colo-

nialism or theological and cultural arrogance I have seen these unhealthy

postures far too oen in Western settingsRecently I attended a missional leadership conference On that occasion

the keynote speakermdasha leading missional author and speakermdashsaid that

North American missional conversations and innovations hold the key to

the future of the Western church Tis Euro American view is wrong (Irsquom

being kind o be frank itrsquos complete nonsense) Itrsquos arrogant and Euro

Americanndashcentric And itrsquos completely out of step with what is happening in

the glocal church We need a new narrativeIn June 1048626104862410486251048627 Te Center for the Study of Global Christianity reported

the top 10486261048624 countries where Christianity has the highest percentage growth

rate Nineteen of the top twenty are in Asia and Africa Eleven of them are

in Muslim majority countries Not a single country from Europe or North

America makes the top twenty list10486261048630

Itrsquos time to cultivate a new narrative Te future of the church is emerging

from the Majority World Rather than North America the churches of

Eastern Asia Western Africa the Arabian Peninsula and other parts of the

Majority World reveal the future of the global church We need the contribu-

tions of all contexts Western indigenous and Majority World All con-

tribute to glocal conversations All are important as we learn from each

other about mission theology and faith But letrsquos stop pretending that North

Americans and Europeans will reveal the future of the global church Letrsquos

start listening to what God is saying about the future of the global church

And hersquos speaking to us through the churches of Asia Africa Latin America

26Russ Mitchell ldquoTe op 983090983088 Countries Where Christianity Is Growing the Fastestrdquo Disciple All

Nations (blog) August 983090983093 98309098308810486251048627 httpsdiscipleallnationswordpresscom98309098308810486251048627983088983096983090983093the-top

-983090983088-countries-where-christianity-is-growing-the-astest

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3236

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048633

Muslim majority settings and so on We must cultivate a new glocal nar-

rativemdashone soaked in humility

Glocal theology must be humble theology Meek theology Receptive the-ology Discerning theology Prayerful theology Dialogical theology De-

pendent theology A theology that celebrates the interdependence between

the localparticular and the globaluniversal

983091 Glocal theology practices expansiveness Glocalization is by nature

comprehensive Local and global influences permeate much of our lives Tese

glocal forces shape our theologies and churches whether we like it or not

But intentionality is also important We need to commit to an expansiveapproach to glocal theology How do we deliberately cultivate glocal conver-

sations in our biblical interpretation Do we foster them in our under-

standing of the person and work of Christ How does glocalization shape

the way the Spirit empowers and constitutes the church How can it form

our understanding of the nature and mission of the rinity How does it

influence the way we practice fellowship and conversation across denomi-

national cultural ethnic economic sociocultural political gender andtheological divides How might it shape our theologies of mission com-

munity beauty spirituality suffering discipleship hospitality eco-justice

place education social ethics Christian leadership and so forth

983092 Glocal theology practices attention Glocal theology doesnrsquot need to

accept all the assumptions or assertions of postcolonial or Majority World

thought But it does need to engage with them and take them seriously

Postcolonial theology for instance gives the marginalized and colonized

and forgotten and silenced both dignity and voice Our glocal conversations

must also include and esteem these groups We need to be attentive to

others weak and powerful female and male dominant and downtrodden

old and young rich and poor privileged and marginalized influential and

subaltern educated and illiterate We need to practice the art of attention

being especially attentive to those who are different to us

983093 Glocal theology practices embrace What do colonial ethnocentric or

Western-centric perspectives do Tey silence Tey control Tey com-

modify Tey institutionalize Tey colonize Tey domesticate Tey replace

Tey import Tey exclude Tey do these things to the beliefs experiences

and practices of other cultures A worthwhile glocal theology refuses to do

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3336

10486281048624 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

these things Instead it adopts a responsive humble celebratory open in-

clusive and embracing attitude

983094 Glocal theology practices discernment Finally we need discernmentas we engage these ideas and practices Discernment is a huge topic thatrsquos

hard to cover comprehensively in a few words Discernment happens when

the Spirit of Christ and his Word renew our minds Te Spirit grants us

spiritual wisdom as we meditate on him and his Word and as we practice

discipleship to Jesus Christ Romans 10486251048626 provides guidance we need (1048625) to be

transformed by the renewal of our minds (1048626) to serve Christrsquos body and (1048627)

to put love into action Discernment also happens in conversation both lo-cally and glocally

I pray these core values and six practices come across in the following

chapters of GlobalChurch

Glocalization can never be just theoretical Are we committed to moving

glocalization from an abstract idea to a living communion Are we deter-

mined to construct a missional theology of the church in the context of

glocal conversations Tis must involve dialogue between Majority Worldindigenous and Western scholars activists and groups

Will glocalization be an abstract notion Or will it be a formative and

genuine communion between local regional and global voices Glocal dy-

namics are at play whether we like it or not Teyrsquore in our churches the-

ologies and missions But we can choose to relinquish isolationist colonial

parochial and arrogant approaches Instead we can adopt responsive dia-

logical learning humble and embracing postures

Trough healthy approaches to glocalization the Spirit challenges us to

value local contexts We immerse ourselves in local and particular commu-

nities and conversations He inspires us to open ourselves to global theo-

logical conversations He rouses us to value the symbiotic relationship be-

tween the localparticular and the globaluniversal

Trough glocal relationships the Spirit leads us to put local contextual

theologies into conversation with global ones He prompts us to explore the

ways in which the local is in the glocal and the global is in the local He per-

suades us to pursue collaboration and dialogue and mutual learning We

engage with Christians from different backgrounds and cultures ecumen-

icals Pentecostals evangelicals and so on from Western indigenous and

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3436

Glocalizing Conversations 10486281048625

Majority World contexts He motivates us to express solidarity between all

parties We appreciate our unity in diversity

Trough glocal conversations the Spirit moves us to ensure that unity andsolidarity emerge from a compelling vision of Jesusrsquo kingdom and gospel

and person He challenges us to share information theology and practices

He urges us to learn from each othermdashour successes and mistakes We seek

glocal solutions

Te Spirit calls us to develop glocal conversations about Christian ideas

and practices Tese include Scripture Evangelicalism ecumenism Pente-

costalism Jesus Christ the Holy Spirit God the Father the rinity com-munity spirituality discipleship liturgy worship hospitality prayer eco-

justice education social ethics Christian leadership gospel and culture

beauty place suffering liberation and so forth

Finally through glocal conversations the Spirit leads us to adopt a new

posture Tis is a responsive humble celebratory open inclusive and em-

bracing attitude to the ldquootherrdquo We do this as a new people made up of every

tribe and language and people and nationTere are dangers in glocalization Sugirtharajah warns of the commodi-

fication of local contextual practices and theologies When this happens

they are ldquosmoothed out of their primary contexts concerns and contesta-

tions travel across borders and become objects of analysis and scrutiny

within an alien secondary contextrdquo1048626983095

Itrsquos common for those of us who are Western to make mistakes when we

wrestle with Majority World and indigenous ideas Sugirtharajah mentions

our tendency to commodify reduce and institutionalize these ideas We also

risk doing these things (1048625) We apply them in noncontextual prescriptive ways

(1048626) We ignore their meanings in their original setting (1048627) We glamorize or

idealize their proponents or their contexts (1048628) We demonize those persons or

contexts (1048629) We disregard them as irrelevant rhetorical or minority discourse

Kevin J Vanhoozer says that we can fall into three traps when we glo-

calize theology (1048625) We can underestimate the theological significance of

local cultures (1048626) We can homogenize cultures and theologies exaggerating

27R S Sugirtharajah ldquoextual ake-Aways Tird World exts in Western Metropolitan Centresrdquo

Black Teology in Britain A Journal o Contextual Praxis 983090 (1048625983097983097983097) 10486271048627 10486271048631 Edward W Said Te

World the ext and the Critic (Cambridge MA Harvard University Press 10486259830979830961048627) 9830901048627983097

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3536

10486281048626 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

ldquothe onerdquo (1048627) We can overemphasize cultural particularity exaggerating ldquothe

manyrdquo and pursue ldquotheological ethnificationrdquo10486261048632

My hope is that GlobalChurch does not fall into the traps Sugirtharajahand Vanhoozer describe I hope that what unfolds in the following chapters

is respectful and discerning I hope it leads to further mutually enriching

conversations between people of different cultures

You the reader face the same challenges You face them in your personal

life ministry context and missional engagements

Will you treat the themes in this book as abstract theoretical notions

Will this be a temporary infatuation a flirtation with the ldquootherrdquo that dissi-pates as suddenly as it arrived Or will glocal conversations become an en-

riching and formative orientation in your life Will glocal conversations

bring fresh approaches to theology faith mission church and worship Will

conversations with other cultures and theologies become for you a com-

pelling way of life

My prayer is that glocal conversations will help the church be a global

visible alternative ldquocity set upon a hillrdquo a truly GlobalChurch

28Craig Ott and Harold A Netland Globalizing Teology Belie and Practice in an Era o World

Christianity (Grand Rapids Baker Academic 983090983088983088983094) 1048625983090983093

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3636

Page 18: GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1836

Glocalizing Conversations 10486261048629

Te summit was a thrilling example of how Majority World and Western

leaders can cooperate It was a time to come together in an environment of

mutual learning and enrichment It was a window into how local contextsand global themes can enrich each other Tis resulted from ISUMrsquos com-

mitment to ldquosolidarity fellowship and insight between urban Christian

leaders in the Western and Majority Worldsrdquo

Te summit was a success due to ISUMrsquos core values What are they983091 Christ-

honoring urban mission values bottom-up grassroots perspectivesmdashrather

than top-down distanced perspectives It allows local theology to reveal new

insights and perspectives about Godrsquos activity It shares insights and experi-ences through narratives embedded within urban poor communities and cities

It cultivates ongoing practical and personal solidarity with the worldrsquos urban

poor Tis Spirit-empowered urban mission honors networks relationships

and partnerships It sees such relationships as the primary method of serving

together It listens to and amplifies the voices of the urban poormdashespecially

those from the Majority World and in particular the 1048625104862410486281048624 window cities It is

attentive to signs of the kingdom of God Urban mission that glorifies God iswilling to reflect and respond with active and sacrificial commitment It shares

and extends the life of the body of Christ among the urban poor

Tis summit was a milestone in urban missiology It enriched communi-

cation between Western and Majority World thinker-activists Tis resulted

from the aims and values Irsquove mentioned Effective urban mission needs to

be a conversation on many levels It is attentive to context and immersed in

local settings It appreciates global and universal missional themes It culti-

vates dialogue between these local-global (glocal) realities It involves

mutual learning between Western and Majority World thinker-activists

Moreover solidarity between all parties is a defining feature Tis solidarity

is due to a compelling vision of the kingdom of God

Tese collaborative glocal features of the ISUM urban mission summit

in Bangkok are critical for the aims of this book GlobalChurch

Majority World indigenous and Western leaders thinkers and churches

can stretch and enrich each other But they need to be open and attentive to

each other Tey need learning postures and open hearts and minds Tey

3ldquoAbout ISUMrdquo httpnewurbanworldorgabout

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1936

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2036

Glocalizing Conversations 10486261048631

always rooted in the local and particularmdashas local churches embody the

gospel and witness to Christ Tese churches forge their own theological

understandings as they do mission together Tey engage in transformationalpractices among the people in their settings Tey enjoy worship mission

and community in their local and particular context Ideally the result is

unique contextual theologies and missions

Simultaneously global conversations form Tey form because of this

multitude of local theologies and practices Local conversations inform and

enrich other local conversations catalyzing global themes and voices izon

observes that the global ldquoowes its existence to local contexts Sharedconvictions among the theologies and practices of local contextual realities

give shape to its global dimensionsrdquo1048629

Majority World indigenous and Western theologies are equally contextual

Tey are equally culture bound Tey are equally particular to their time and

location At times they are all enlightened or myopic liberating or con-

straining humanizing or objectifying beautiful or offensive prophetic or

tepid Te local particular and cultural shape all these theologies Converselythese particular theologies feed and influence global conversations Tere is

no place then for ethnocentrism colonialism or elitism Tere is no place

for theological missional cultural or institutionalized arrogance

Multiple local contexts and voices come togethermdashintentionally or notmdashto

form global themes and theologies Conversely these global realities shape

local contexts oday local contexts must grapple with ldquoan emerging global

culture ie the interacting realities of modernity postmodernity and the

phenomenon of globalizationrdquo1048630 Hence the interdependent and symbiotic

relationship between the localparticular and the globaluniversal We call this

interdependent relationship between the local and the global glocalization

Te global church needs a thrilling glocal exchange We need one that we

characterize by mutuality respect partnership and symbiosis Such ex-

change helps Majority World indigenous and Western churches learn from

each other It enables them to pursue missional theology and practice o-

gether the church becomes a ldquocity on a hillrdquo

5Ibid 10486259830886Ibid 9830961048628

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2136

10486261048632 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

W983144983137983156 R983141983153983157983145983154983141983155 G983148983151983139983137983148983145983162983137983156983145983151983150983103

Te glocal exchange described above needs to be broader than transforma-

tional mission Tis is necessary if the church is to develop a robust inter-cultural and glocal missional ecclesiology

In my first book Salt Light and a City I outlined the foundational

themes of missional ecclesiology983095 Majority World and Western leaders

need to engage these themes in local and contextual ways Teir insights can

then enrich global conversations Tese global conversations in turn shape

local understandings and practices Tis way a glocal appreciation of these

themes emergesLocal regional and global theologies and practices are thereby enriched

Te church becomes healthier and more missionalmdasha truer expression of

the kingdom Te church becomes a fuller witness to Christ his passion for

the nations and his ability to bring unity in diversity

Stephen Bevans and Roger Schroeder outline the six constants of mission

Tese are our theologies about Jesus the church the end times salvation

human nature and culture Bevans and Schroeder describe the relationshipbetween these six and their historical cultural and theological contexts Tis is

why they call these six constants in context Our understanding of these six

constants develops in relation to local and global movements Sometimes local

voices influence our understandings of these six Other times it is regional or

global voices For all of us local regional and global influences are at play at

once Collectively they form our appreciation of the six constants of mission1048632

Here are eight theological themes that the church can develop through

processes of glocalization I presented these in my book Salt Light and a City

Tey are vital to the churchrsquos health mission community and future We

could add many other themes to these eight but these will suffice for now1048633

Scripture Te Scriptures are the infallible authoritative Word of God

Christrsquos Spirit has inspired them Tey have absolute and final authority in

all aspects of corporate and individual faith ethics conduct and witness

Christians interpret and apply Scripture in local contexts and in particular

7Graham Hill Salt Light and a City Introducing Missional Ecclesiology (Eugene OR Wip and

Stock 9830909830881048625983090) 10486251048628983097-983090104863110486288Stephen B Bevans and Roger Schroeder Constants in Context A Teology o Mission or oday

American Society o Missiology Series (Maryknoll NY Orbis 9830909830889830881048628) part one9Tese points first appeared in my book Salt Light and a City xxii-xxiv

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2236

Glocalizing Conversations 10486261048633

social settings Conversely we learn from the interpretations and readings

of other groups

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our local- global theology of Scripture and biblical interpretation

Evangelicalism Pentecostalism missional movements and so forth I

have charismatic missional and evangelical convictions Glocal conversa-

tions help me understand and practice these convictions better

I will use evangelicalism as an example Michael Horton says that our

beliefs and practices are evangelical when they are ldquocommitted to the suffi-

ciency of Scripture the priesthood of all believers the total lostness ofhumans the sole mediation of Christ the gracious efficacy and finality of

Godrsquos redemptive work in Christ through election propitiation calling and

keeping Te linchpin for all of this was the doctrine of justification by grace

alone through faith alone because of Christ alonerdquo9830891048624

Such convictions are necessary if we are to be faithful to the gospel and

to a biblical vision of church and mission Te gospel defines Godrsquos purposes

for humanity the church and the universe Te triune God controls thechurch He is its Lord and Savior Sanctifier and Liberator Master and King

He is completely sovereign over its nature affairs mission and history God

is the churchrsquos only source of grace election atonement salvation and per-

severance Te churchrsquos justification and hope are by grace alone through

faith alone by Christ alone

Herersquos the challenge I face My understanding of evangelicalism is

Western I am a product of the Western theological tradition and my Western

evangelical heritage Much of this is wonderful But I need indigenous and

Majority World evangelicals and others to help me expand and reshape

these insights Te same would be true if I were a Pentecostal

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of our theological traditions and convictions

Jesus Christ We must center our theology on Jesus Christ the Lord of

the church Te church needs to reflect on the person and work of Christ

and respond to him Tis means gathering and going in the name and power

of Christ It means allowing Christrsquos Spirit to shape our community and

10Michael Horton ldquoEvangelical Arminiansrdquo Modern Reormation 1048625 no 1048627 (1048625983097983097983090) 10486251048631

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2336

10486271048624 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

identity and mission It means developing our Christology ecclesiology and

missiology concurrently Te early church developed these three areas and

more in a concurrent and integrated way Tere was no linear progressionTe same is true in the contemporary global church

How can the glocal church best explore its nature structure mission and

hope Trough the centrality and the lordship of Christ

Majority World and indigenous Christians help us appreciate Jesus and

his mission afresh Tey show us how Jesus identifies with the marginalized

outcast oppressed rejected and broken He prefers them We find him

among ldquothe least of theserdquoGlocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of who Jesus Christ is How does it help us appreciate him better

What has Jesus done for and in his church and his world What does he care

about What individual and corporate responsibilities has he given us How

do we express these at local regional and global levels

Te Spirit Missional ecclesiology is inadequate without pneumatological

foundations In other words our theology of church and Spirit go togetherTe Spirit creates and animates the church He empowers it to witness to

Jesus and his gospel Te Spirit enables the church to be a missional trans-

formational community He shapes the church into an alternative society

embodying the reign of God Te church exists for the glory and mission of

Christ Te power and presence of the Spirit enables this mission worship

and glorification

Te Spirit pours out gis on the local-global church ldquofor the common

goodrdquo and ldquoto equip his people for works of service so that the body of Christ

may be built uprdquo Tis includes but isnrsquot limited to the ministry gis mani-

festation gis and motivational gis (1048625 Cor 104862510486261048631 Eph 104862810486251048625-10486251048626 Rom 104862510486261048630-1048632)

Te Spirit forms the glocal church He empowers it for service and

witness He fills it with Christrsquos empowering presence He leads it into the

missio Deimdashthe mission of the Father Son and Holy Spirit

Recently Pentecostal and renewalist movements have grown dramati-

cally in the Majority World Tey have increased in status size and influence

Many have matured theologically Te churches of the West must take notice

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of the power and presence of the Spirit

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2436

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048625

Te rinity Tere are clear limitations to the analogy between the

church and the rinity Te church can only image the rinity Yet the

church is at its best when it reflects the relational and missional passionof the rinity

What is the source and inspiration of the churchrsquos local-global mission

Ultimately it is the missional nature passion and actions of the Father Son

and Holy Spirit Godrsquos nature is missional His passion is infectious His

actions are historical redemptive and eternal Te rinity invites the

church into a sending community Te Father sends the Son Te Father

and Son send the Spirit Finally the rinity sends the church in missioninto the world

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of the rinity How does it enable our participation in the mission

and community of the triune God

Association and dialogue Tese need to happen across denominational

cultural ethnic gender and theological traditions and divides Authentic

dialogue is indispensable to the health and mission of the church What dothose marginal to the life of the church have to say to us What do ldquoothersrdquo

have to teach us Other ethnicities and cultures Other socioeconomic

groups Other ages and genders Other theological and confessing tradi-

tions Other persons from times long gone

We need to listen Share Be vulnerable Be authentic Open up to crit-

icism correction and change

We need more than dialogue We need communion and association It is

possible in a qualified way to say that God is present in all the various forms

of the church (ie the various theological ecclesiological sociocultural his-

torical and other permutations of the church) We discern this presence

through attention to Scripture history tradition culture and the Spirit Dis-

cernment involves critical dialogue theological exchange biblical study and

real relationship Only the Spirit of Jesus can enable this

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of association and dialogue

Mission and the missio Dei Te church is missional at its core It serves

obeys and images a missionary God David Bosch says ldquoTe churchrsquos mission

is not secondary to its being the church exists in being sent and in building up

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2536

10486271048626 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

itself for its missionrdquo He goes on to say ldquoEcclesiology does not precede missi-

ology there cannot be church without an intrinsic missionary dimensionrdquo983089983089

Jesus is Lord Lord of his church and Lord of his world His mission de-termines and forms the church His mission shapes the nature purposes

structures ministries and activities of his church Majority World and in-

digenous thinkers help us understand the implications of this mission Tey

help us form glocal theologies of mission Tey reveal ldquomission in context

as transformationrdquo9830891048626

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of mission and the missio Dei Church theology and practice Glocal conversations can inform and

enrich many aspects of the church (when practiced well) Teologies and

practices benefit from robust and critical glocal conversations Tese con-

versations enrich many areas (community spirituality discipleship liturgy

worship hospitality eco-justice education social ethics servantship lib-

eration place suffering beauty and so on)

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-standing of these many dimensions of church and mission

Glocal processes shape these eight themes and their practices We need

to facilitate and enable these conversations and processes Tis is urgent It

must be a priority No theology of mission or missional ecclesiology is ad-

equate without glocal conversations983089983091

T983144983141 L983151983139983137983148 983137983150983140 G983148983151983138983137983148 E983150983154983145983139983144 E983137983139983144 O983156983144983141983154

Glocalization takes the localparticular context and globaluniversal themes

seriously Contextual and global conversations enter an enriching and in-

forming relationship Tese two always have an active and symbiotic rela-

tionship Tis is true whether we deliberately put them into conversation or

not Te local shapes the global and the global shapes the local Many local

11David J Bosch Believing in the Future oward a Missiology o Western Culture (New York

rinity 1048625983097983097983093) 104862798309012izon ransormation Afer Lausanne 1048631-98309713Not all o these themes are dealt with in this present volume since either (1048625) I have dealt with them

in my book Salt Light and a City (983090) they are not all key themes in the writings o the thirty-five

Majority World thinkers considered in this volume or (1048627) there is not adequate space in a book

this size

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2636

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048627

voices converge to form global conversations and theologies Using the Phil-

ippines as a case study izon illustrates this by showing the interdepen-

dence between local and global themes in mission983089983092Dialogue between local and global conversations is critical Kōsuke

Koyama wrote an important book on contextual mission called Water Buffalo

Teology Koyama is a Japanese missionary who served in Chiang Mai

Tailand He writes of the joys and challenges of doing local particular water

buffalo theology He considers the relationship between local theology global

missional themes and transforming cultures ldquoWater Buffalo Teology sees

certain specific challenges Contextualization of theology implies two criticalmovements First to articulate Jesus Christ in culturally appropriate com-

municatively apt words and second to criticize reform dethrone or oppose

culture if it is found to be against what the name of Jesus Christ stands forrdquo9830891048629

Kōsuke Koyama challenges us to recognize what we bring to the task of

local theology For him it was doing theology in Tailand while being Jap-

anese We also need to notice the particular culture wersquore located in as we do

the work of theology Tis means we avoid speaking of an ldquoAsian theologyrdquoldquoAfrican theologyrdquo and the like We need to cultivate local theologies that

engage regional and global themes But these theologies must be ldquodistinctly

localrdquo and a ldquotheology from belowrdquo9830891048630

Simultaneously we need to pursue a reformation of theology and

practice ldquoin the global contextrdquo Tis means entering ldquothe disturbing spa-

ciousness of Jesus Christrdquo Jesus calls us to reject enmity and exceptionalism

We seem him present in our culture language stories and relationships

But we also choose to embrace the ldquootherrdquo We choose to see him present

in other culturesmdashshaping a global people to serve and worship him

joining in his mission983089983095

Kōsuke Koyama roots the gospel in the local contextual and particular

Tis is why he roots his water buffalo theology in Northern Tai culture He

is careful not to say ldquoHere is how you contextualize in your settingrdquo Instead

14izon ransormation Afer Lausanne 1048631-10486251048627 10486251048628983097-98309098308898309015Kōsuke Koyama Water Buffalo Teology 983090983093th anniversary ed (Maryknoll NY Orbis 1048625983097983097983097)

xiii-xv16Kōsuke Koyama ldquoTe Asian Approach to Christrdquo Missiology 1048625983090 no 1048628 (10486259830979830961048628) 10486281048627983093-104862798309617Kōsuke Koyama ldquoReormation in the Global Context Te Disturbing Spaciousness o Jesus Christrdquo

Currents in Teology and Mission 1048627983088 no 983090 (9830909830889830881048627) 10486251048625983097-983090983096

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2736

10486271048628 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

he tells us a story Itrsquos the story of how he contextualized theology in northern

Tailand while being open to global conversations Koyama asks us to form

our own local expressions of church mission and theology At the same timewe must stay attentive to what God is saying and doing beyond that context

Tis way local and global and particular and universal become mutually

enriching conversation partners

G983148983151983139983137983148983145983162983137983156983145983151983150 983137983150983140 H983145983155983156983151983154983145983139983137983148983148983161 S983145983148983141983150983139983141983140 V983151983145983139983141983155

Glocal theologies and conversations pay attention to voices that powers in-

stitutions religions and societies have silenced R S Sugirtharajah pushesback a little on izonrsquos ideas Sugirtharajah says that the church should

privilege local conversations He emphasizes the local contextual and post-

colonial reading of biblical texts9830891048632

Te church needs to listen Te church ought to be attentive to the

theologies and biblical interpretations of groups that cultures and reli-

gions have ignored Historically powerful secular and religious forces

have silenced these groups Tey have marginalized oppressed and colo-nized them It is time for the church to address this injustice We must

start listening to important but silenced voices We need to privilege the

voices of the former victims of Western colonialism We need to develop

postcolonial biblical interpretations theologies and expressions of church

and mission

How do we take such perspectives seriously as we develop glocal conver-

sations How do these themes help us foster vital relationships between local

and global voices

It is time for us to embrace values that enable conversations with those

oen ignored by the church We need values that help us learn from these

groups and individuals

Valuing equal partnership Colonizing powers oppressed silenced and

colonized certain groups At times the church was complicit Tese colo-

nized groups have become ldquoconfident indomitable and indispensable

partners in the dialogue and collaboration with the dispossessed and disad-

18R S Sugirtharajah Asian Biblical Hermeneutics and Postcolonialism Contesting the Interpreta-

tions Te Bible and Liberation Series (Maryknoll NY Orbis 1048625983097983097983096) 1048625983093-1048625983094

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2836

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048629

vantaged in the Westrdquo9830891048633 Tis calls for attentiveness to these voices and re-

sponsiveness to their prophetic challenges It also demands a critical evalu-

ation of colonial readings of Scripture Colonial models of theology andchurch and mission are no longer the benchmark Te global church must

examine them afresh

Valuing equal status Tose on the margins have now taken their rightful

place on the global stage Tey have claimed appropriate and equal status at

the table Subaltern readings of theology church and mission are invaluable

contributors to global theological conversations Tis means that we esteem

them But we also test themWhat do we mean by subaltern Subalterns are those who are down-

trodden and silenced (or have been treated this way in the past) Dominant

or colonizing groups treat them as invisible nonentities Tey enjoy limited

or no access to power Sometimes these are women certain tribal and ethnic

groups and those considered ldquountouchablerdquo In Voices from the Margin Su-

girtharajah provides a platform for postcolonial subaltern readings of

Scripture and theology Tese readings challenge colonialmdashoen Westernmdashreadings of Bible and theology and cultures Tey claim equal status with

other ways of doing theology10486261048624

Valuing equal identity People groups need freedom to explore their new

and emerging identities Tese emerge in response to local and global influ-

ences Local culture is not the only thing at work here Global forces also

shape identity as do imported practices ideas readings rituals and tech-

nologies But each group should be free to explore and construct their par-

ticular forms of Christian identity

Valuing equal interpretations ldquoPostcolonialism is concerned with the

question of cultural and discursive dominationrdquo Colonialism led to op-

pressive and controlling forms of culture and discourse Tese were usually

not contextual or indigenous Western powers for instance brought co-

lonial forms of theology church biblical interpretation and mission1048626983089

Postcolonialism calls for alternative ways of approaching these things Tose

19Ibid 104862598309420R S Sugirtharajah Voices rom the Margin Interpreting the Bible in the Tird World (Maryknoll

NY Orbis 10486259830979830971048625)21Sugirtharajah Asian Biblical Hermeneutics and Postcolonialism 10486251048631

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2936

10486271048630 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

who were once marginalized oppressed and silenced need to lead these fresh

approaches in their own settings Tese then influence global conversations

We need to support the new readings and insights and experiments from thesegroups o be genuine this support must be both critical and collegial

Valuing equal empowerment Sugirtharajah says that postcolonialism is

valuable when it empowers actual communities and real people Post-

colonial thought empowers when it addresses the difficulties hopes and

experiences of ordinary people It should never be about power plays and

the clever use of language Itrsquos pointless if itrsquos obsessed with forming newmdash

and ldquocolonizingrdquomdashtheories Itrsquos a waste of time if itrsquos a self-indulgent pursuitof new and hybrid identities Rather ldquothe worth and credibility of post-

colonial criticism will be judged by how it orchestrates the unique and

fragile and imagined claims of one community against anotherrdquo Empow-

erment happens in a variety of ways One way is contributing equally to

global conversations10486261048626

Al izon examines postcolonialism in the Philippines He says that it can

teach the global church a lot about healthy local-global conversations Fil-ipino contextual theology resists many Western forms of mission and the-

ology It finds them patronizing and controlling Tis indigenous theology

values prophetic sociopolitical engagement in institutions and the society

at large It emphasizes ministry to whole persons and communities It con-

structs a Filipino theology of beauty and mission and worship and com-

munity And it fosters indigenous theological approaches to the spirit world

and cosmology

izon says that postcolonial theology has played a constructive role in

the Philippines But he is uncomfortable with the label postcolonialism He

prefers to describe historical events as ldquobeyond colonialismrdquo And he says

that global conversations enrich local theologies and vice versa1048626983091

Postcolonial thought informs our understanding of the relationship be-

tween the local and global It also shows how theology can emerge at the

intersection between the localparticular and the globaluniversal It re-

minds us that worthwhile glocalization listens to all voices Tis includes

heeding those that have been historically silenced

22Ibid 983090104862823izon ransormation Afer Lausanne 1048625983088983090 10486259830941048631-9830961048631

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3036

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048631

G983148983151983139983137983148983145983162983137983156983145983151983150 983137983150983140 983156983144983141 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

C983151983150983139983148983157983140983145983150983143 R983141983142983148983141983139983156983145983151983150983155

How do we go about developing a model for glocal conversations izon hasrecently provided a useful model that is instructive as we seek to learn from

the Majority World It has at least two key features

First the local is in the global (globalization from below) Global theologies

and ideas have origins in many particular local contexts In that sense glo-

balization is from below Global ideas have local roots Ideas about integral

mission liberation theology and missional church have local origins Tey

have their roots in the prayers hopes discoveries mission and theologiesof thousands of local communities ldquoTe global does not cannot exist

without the localmdashbut the coming together of localities creates a global re-

ality that becomes greater than the sum of its parts it creates a gestalt entity

to which localities make themselves accountablerdquo1048626983092

Second the global is in the local (panlocalization from above) Te con-

cerns and voices of multitudes of locales form global conversations Tese

global discussions can provide a ldquopositive accountabilityrdquo back to local con-texts Tis is true when they enrich affirm serve guide and strengthen local

contexts It is also true when they avoid homogenization control impo-

sition and judgment Glocalization is best when it sees itself as interde-

pendent deeply connected with the local10486261048629

Tatrsquos a helpful starting point But we need to go further Besides izonrsquos

proposals Irsquom convinced that robust glocal conversations cultivate six core

practices

983089 Glocal theology practices its values We root glocal theology in core

values Tese values include solidarity understanding and mutual learning

Do we value fellowship with Christians of all cultures Do we value learning

from them

We prove our values through our practices What practices emerge out of

these values We need to collaborate act collectively and share information

We must find ways to foster grassroots perspectives and local theologies We

need to share stories and learnings and cultivate networks relationships and

partnerships We need attentiveness to local voices and global themes We

24Ibid 9830901048625983088-1048625104862825Ibid 98309010486251048628-1048625983096

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3136

10486271048632 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

ought to find ways to put these local and global voices into conversation

Mutual learning humility and solidarity are key Worthwhile glocal con-

versations can never be merely theoretical or academic It is up to us to rootour values in our practices

983090 Glocal theology practices humility (and it tells a new narrative) We

have noted that the local is in the global and the global is in the local Te

two are interdependent Tey form each other reciprocally Since this is the

case we must practice humility Tere is no place for ethnocentrism colo-

nialism or theological and cultural arrogance I have seen these unhealthy

postures far too oen in Western settingsRecently I attended a missional leadership conference On that occasion

the keynote speakermdasha leading missional author and speakermdashsaid that

North American missional conversations and innovations hold the key to

the future of the Western church Tis Euro American view is wrong (Irsquom

being kind o be frank itrsquos complete nonsense) Itrsquos arrogant and Euro

Americanndashcentric And itrsquos completely out of step with what is happening in

the glocal church We need a new narrativeIn June 1048626104862410486251048627 Te Center for the Study of Global Christianity reported

the top 10486261048624 countries where Christianity has the highest percentage growth

rate Nineteen of the top twenty are in Asia and Africa Eleven of them are

in Muslim majority countries Not a single country from Europe or North

America makes the top twenty list10486261048630

Itrsquos time to cultivate a new narrative Te future of the church is emerging

from the Majority World Rather than North America the churches of

Eastern Asia Western Africa the Arabian Peninsula and other parts of the

Majority World reveal the future of the global church We need the contribu-

tions of all contexts Western indigenous and Majority World All con-

tribute to glocal conversations All are important as we learn from each

other about mission theology and faith But letrsquos stop pretending that North

Americans and Europeans will reveal the future of the global church Letrsquos

start listening to what God is saying about the future of the global church

And hersquos speaking to us through the churches of Asia Africa Latin America

26Russ Mitchell ldquoTe op 983090983088 Countries Where Christianity Is Growing the Fastestrdquo Disciple All

Nations (blog) August 983090983093 98309098308810486251048627 httpsdiscipleallnationswordpresscom98309098308810486251048627983088983096983090983093the-top

-983090983088-countries-where-christianity-is-growing-the-astest

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3236

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048633

Muslim majority settings and so on We must cultivate a new glocal nar-

rativemdashone soaked in humility

Glocal theology must be humble theology Meek theology Receptive the-ology Discerning theology Prayerful theology Dialogical theology De-

pendent theology A theology that celebrates the interdependence between

the localparticular and the globaluniversal

983091 Glocal theology practices expansiveness Glocalization is by nature

comprehensive Local and global influences permeate much of our lives Tese

glocal forces shape our theologies and churches whether we like it or not

But intentionality is also important We need to commit to an expansiveapproach to glocal theology How do we deliberately cultivate glocal conver-

sations in our biblical interpretation Do we foster them in our under-

standing of the person and work of Christ How does glocalization shape

the way the Spirit empowers and constitutes the church How can it form

our understanding of the nature and mission of the rinity How does it

influence the way we practice fellowship and conversation across denomi-

national cultural ethnic economic sociocultural political gender andtheological divides How might it shape our theologies of mission com-

munity beauty spirituality suffering discipleship hospitality eco-justice

place education social ethics Christian leadership and so forth

983092 Glocal theology practices attention Glocal theology doesnrsquot need to

accept all the assumptions or assertions of postcolonial or Majority World

thought But it does need to engage with them and take them seriously

Postcolonial theology for instance gives the marginalized and colonized

and forgotten and silenced both dignity and voice Our glocal conversations

must also include and esteem these groups We need to be attentive to

others weak and powerful female and male dominant and downtrodden

old and young rich and poor privileged and marginalized influential and

subaltern educated and illiterate We need to practice the art of attention

being especially attentive to those who are different to us

983093 Glocal theology practices embrace What do colonial ethnocentric or

Western-centric perspectives do Tey silence Tey control Tey com-

modify Tey institutionalize Tey colonize Tey domesticate Tey replace

Tey import Tey exclude Tey do these things to the beliefs experiences

and practices of other cultures A worthwhile glocal theology refuses to do

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3336

10486281048624 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

these things Instead it adopts a responsive humble celebratory open in-

clusive and embracing attitude

983094 Glocal theology practices discernment Finally we need discernmentas we engage these ideas and practices Discernment is a huge topic thatrsquos

hard to cover comprehensively in a few words Discernment happens when

the Spirit of Christ and his Word renew our minds Te Spirit grants us

spiritual wisdom as we meditate on him and his Word and as we practice

discipleship to Jesus Christ Romans 10486251048626 provides guidance we need (1048625) to be

transformed by the renewal of our minds (1048626) to serve Christrsquos body and (1048627)

to put love into action Discernment also happens in conversation both lo-cally and glocally

I pray these core values and six practices come across in the following

chapters of GlobalChurch

Glocalization can never be just theoretical Are we committed to moving

glocalization from an abstract idea to a living communion Are we deter-

mined to construct a missional theology of the church in the context of

glocal conversations Tis must involve dialogue between Majority Worldindigenous and Western scholars activists and groups

Will glocalization be an abstract notion Or will it be a formative and

genuine communion between local regional and global voices Glocal dy-

namics are at play whether we like it or not Teyrsquore in our churches the-

ologies and missions But we can choose to relinquish isolationist colonial

parochial and arrogant approaches Instead we can adopt responsive dia-

logical learning humble and embracing postures

Trough healthy approaches to glocalization the Spirit challenges us to

value local contexts We immerse ourselves in local and particular commu-

nities and conversations He inspires us to open ourselves to global theo-

logical conversations He rouses us to value the symbiotic relationship be-

tween the localparticular and the globaluniversal

Trough glocal relationships the Spirit leads us to put local contextual

theologies into conversation with global ones He prompts us to explore the

ways in which the local is in the glocal and the global is in the local He per-

suades us to pursue collaboration and dialogue and mutual learning We

engage with Christians from different backgrounds and cultures ecumen-

icals Pentecostals evangelicals and so on from Western indigenous and

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3436

Glocalizing Conversations 10486281048625

Majority World contexts He motivates us to express solidarity between all

parties We appreciate our unity in diversity

Trough glocal conversations the Spirit moves us to ensure that unity andsolidarity emerge from a compelling vision of Jesusrsquo kingdom and gospel

and person He challenges us to share information theology and practices

He urges us to learn from each othermdashour successes and mistakes We seek

glocal solutions

Te Spirit calls us to develop glocal conversations about Christian ideas

and practices Tese include Scripture Evangelicalism ecumenism Pente-

costalism Jesus Christ the Holy Spirit God the Father the rinity com-munity spirituality discipleship liturgy worship hospitality prayer eco-

justice education social ethics Christian leadership gospel and culture

beauty place suffering liberation and so forth

Finally through glocal conversations the Spirit leads us to adopt a new

posture Tis is a responsive humble celebratory open inclusive and em-

bracing attitude to the ldquootherrdquo We do this as a new people made up of every

tribe and language and people and nationTere are dangers in glocalization Sugirtharajah warns of the commodi-

fication of local contextual practices and theologies When this happens

they are ldquosmoothed out of their primary contexts concerns and contesta-

tions travel across borders and become objects of analysis and scrutiny

within an alien secondary contextrdquo1048626983095

Itrsquos common for those of us who are Western to make mistakes when we

wrestle with Majority World and indigenous ideas Sugirtharajah mentions

our tendency to commodify reduce and institutionalize these ideas We also

risk doing these things (1048625) We apply them in noncontextual prescriptive ways

(1048626) We ignore their meanings in their original setting (1048627) We glamorize or

idealize their proponents or their contexts (1048628) We demonize those persons or

contexts (1048629) We disregard them as irrelevant rhetorical or minority discourse

Kevin J Vanhoozer says that we can fall into three traps when we glo-

calize theology (1048625) We can underestimate the theological significance of

local cultures (1048626) We can homogenize cultures and theologies exaggerating

27R S Sugirtharajah ldquoextual ake-Aways Tird World exts in Western Metropolitan Centresrdquo

Black Teology in Britain A Journal o Contextual Praxis 983090 (1048625983097983097983097) 10486271048627 10486271048631 Edward W Said Te

World the ext and the Critic (Cambridge MA Harvard University Press 10486259830979830961048627) 9830901048627983097

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3536

10486281048626 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

ldquothe onerdquo (1048627) We can overemphasize cultural particularity exaggerating ldquothe

manyrdquo and pursue ldquotheological ethnificationrdquo10486261048632

My hope is that GlobalChurch does not fall into the traps Sugirtharajahand Vanhoozer describe I hope that what unfolds in the following chapters

is respectful and discerning I hope it leads to further mutually enriching

conversations between people of different cultures

You the reader face the same challenges You face them in your personal

life ministry context and missional engagements

Will you treat the themes in this book as abstract theoretical notions

Will this be a temporary infatuation a flirtation with the ldquootherrdquo that dissi-pates as suddenly as it arrived Or will glocal conversations become an en-

riching and formative orientation in your life Will glocal conversations

bring fresh approaches to theology faith mission church and worship Will

conversations with other cultures and theologies become for you a com-

pelling way of life

My prayer is that glocal conversations will help the church be a global

visible alternative ldquocity set upon a hillrdquo a truly GlobalChurch

28Craig Ott and Harold A Netland Globalizing Teology Belie and Practice in an Era o World

Christianity (Grand Rapids Baker Academic 983090983088983088983094) 1048625983090983093

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3636

Page 19: GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 1936

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2036

Glocalizing Conversations 10486261048631

always rooted in the local and particularmdashas local churches embody the

gospel and witness to Christ Tese churches forge their own theological

understandings as they do mission together Tey engage in transformationalpractices among the people in their settings Tey enjoy worship mission

and community in their local and particular context Ideally the result is

unique contextual theologies and missions

Simultaneously global conversations form Tey form because of this

multitude of local theologies and practices Local conversations inform and

enrich other local conversations catalyzing global themes and voices izon

observes that the global ldquoowes its existence to local contexts Sharedconvictions among the theologies and practices of local contextual realities

give shape to its global dimensionsrdquo1048629

Majority World indigenous and Western theologies are equally contextual

Tey are equally culture bound Tey are equally particular to their time and

location At times they are all enlightened or myopic liberating or con-

straining humanizing or objectifying beautiful or offensive prophetic or

tepid Te local particular and cultural shape all these theologies Converselythese particular theologies feed and influence global conversations Tere is

no place then for ethnocentrism colonialism or elitism Tere is no place

for theological missional cultural or institutionalized arrogance

Multiple local contexts and voices come togethermdashintentionally or notmdashto

form global themes and theologies Conversely these global realities shape

local contexts oday local contexts must grapple with ldquoan emerging global

culture ie the interacting realities of modernity postmodernity and the

phenomenon of globalizationrdquo1048630 Hence the interdependent and symbiotic

relationship between the localparticular and the globaluniversal We call this

interdependent relationship between the local and the global glocalization

Te global church needs a thrilling glocal exchange We need one that we

characterize by mutuality respect partnership and symbiosis Such ex-

change helps Majority World indigenous and Western churches learn from

each other It enables them to pursue missional theology and practice o-

gether the church becomes a ldquocity on a hillrdquo

5Ibid 10486259830886Ibid 9830961048628

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2136

10486261048632 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

W983144983137983156 R983141983153983157983145983154983141983155 G983148983151983139983137983148983145983162983137983156983145983151983150983103

Te glocal exchange described above needs to be broader than transforma-

tional mission Tis is necessary if the church is to develop a robust inter-cultural and glocal missional ecclesiology

In my first book Salt Light and a City I outlined the foundational

themes of missional ecclesiology983095 Majority World and Western leaders

need to engage these themes in local and contextual ways Teir insights can

then enrich global conversations Tese global conversations in turn shape

local understandings and practices Tis way a glocal appreciation of these

themes emergesLocal regional and global theologies and practices are thereby enriched

Te church becomes healthier and more missionalmdasha truer expression of

the kingdom Te church becomes a fuller witness to Christ his passion for

the nations and his ability to bring unity in diversity

Stephen Bevans and Roger Schroeder outline the six constants of mission

Tese are our theologies about Jesus the church the end times salvation

human nature and culture Bevans and Schroeder describe the relationshipbetween these six and their historical cultural and theological contexts Tis is

why they call these six constants in context Our understanding of these six

constants develops in relation to local and global movements Sometimes local

voices influence our understandings of these six Other times it is regional or

global voices For all of us local regional and global influences are at play at

once Collectively they form our appreciation of the six constants of mission1048632

Here are eight theological themes that the church can develop through

processes of glocalization I presented these in my book Salt Light and a City

Tey are vital to the churchrsquos health mission community and future We

could add many other themes to these eight but these will suffice for now1048633

Scripture Te Scriptures are the infallible authoritative Word of God

Christrsquos Spirit has inspired them Tey have absolute and final authority in

all aspects of corporate and individual faith ethics conduct and witness

Christians interpret and apply Scripture in local contexts and in particular

7Graham Hill Salt Light and a City Introducing Missional Ecclesiology (Eugene OR Wip and

Stock 9830909830881048625983090) 10486251048628983097-983090104863110486288Stephen B Bevans and Roger Schroeder Constants in Context A Teology o Mission or oday

American Society o Missiology Series (Maryknoll NY Orbis 9830909830889830881048628) part one9Tese points first appeared in my book Salt Light and a City xxii-xxiv

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2236

Glocalizing Conversations 10486261048633

social settings Conversely we learn from the interpretations and readings

of other groups

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our local- global theology of Scripture and biblical interpretation

Evangelicalism Pentecostalism missional movements and so forth I

have charismatic missional and evangelical convictions Glocal conversa-

tions help me understand and practice these convictions better

I will use evangelicalism as an example Michael Horton says that our

beliefs and practices are evangelical when they are ldquocommitted to the suffi-

ciency of Scripture the priesthood of all believers the total lostness ofhumans the sole mediation of Christ the gracious efficacy and finality of

Godrsquos redemptive work in Christ through election propitiation calling and

keeping Te linchpin for all of this was the doctrine of justification by grace

alone through faith alone because of Christ alonerdquo9830891048624

Such convictions are necessary if we are to be faithful to the gospel and

to a biblical vision of church and mission Te gospel defines Godrsquos purposes

for humanity the church and the universe Te triune God controls thechurch He is its Lord and Savior Sanctifier and Liberator Master and King

He is completely sovereign over its nature affairs mission and history God

is the churchrsquos only source of grace election atonement salvation and per-

severance Te churchrsquos justification and hope are by grace alone through

faith alone by Christ alone

Herersquos the challenge I face My understanding of evangelicalism is

Western I am a product of the Western theological tradition and my Western

evangelical heritage Much of this is wonderful But I need indigenous and

Majority World evangelicals and others to help me expand and reshape

these insights Te same would be true if I were a Pentecostal

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of our theological traditions and convictions

Jesus Christ We must center our theology on Jesus Christ the Lord of

the church Te church needs to reflect on the person and work of Christ

and respond to him Tis means gathering and going in the name and power

of Christ It means allowing Christrsquos Spirit to shape our community and

10Michael Horton ldquoEvangelical Arminiansrdquo Modern Reormation 1048625 no 1048627 (1048625983097983097983090) 10486251048631

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2336

10486271048624 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

identity and mission It means developing our Christology ecclesiology and

missiology concurrently Te early church developed these three areas and

more in a concurrent and integrated way Tere was no linear progressionTe same is true in the contemporary global church

How can the glocal church best explore its nature structure mission and

hope Trough the centrality and the lordship of Christ

Majority World and indigenous Christians help us appreciate Jesus and

his mission afresh Tey show us how Jesus identifies with the marginalized

outcast oppressed rejected and broken He prefers them We find him

among ldquothe least of theserdquoGlocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of who Jesus Christ is How does it help us appreciate him better

What has Jesus done for and in his church and his world What does he care

about What individual and corporate responsibilities has he given us How

do we express these at local regional and global levels

Te Spirit Missional ecclesiology is inadequate without pneumatological

foundations In other words our theology of church and Spirit go togetherTe Spirit creates and animates the church He empowers it to witness to

Jesus and his gospel Te Spirit enables the church to be a missional trans-

formational community He shapes the church into an alternative society

embodying the reign of God Te church exists for the glory and mission of

Christ Te power and presence of the Spirit enables this mission worship

and glorification

Te Spirit pours out gis on the local-global church ldquofor the common

goodrdquo and ldquoto equip his people for works of service so that the body of Christ

may be built uprdquo Tis includes but isnrsquot limited to the ministry gis mani-

festation gis and motivational gis (1048625 Cor 104862510486261048631 Eph 104862810486251048625-10486251048626 Rom 104862510486261048630-1048632)

Te Spirit forms the glocal church He empowers it for service and

witness He fills it with Christrsquos empowering presence He leads it into the

missio Deimdashthe mission of the Father Son and Holy Spirit

Recently Pentecostal and renewalist movements have grown dramati-

cally in the Majority World Tey have increased in status size and influence

Many have matured theologically Te churches of the West must take notice

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of the power and presence of the Spirit

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2436

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048625

Te rinity Tere are clear limitations to the analogy between the

church and the rinity Te church can only image the rinity Yet the

church is at its best when it reflects the relational and missional passionof the rinity

What is the source and inspiration of the churchrsquos local-global mission

Ultimately it is the missional nature passion and actions of the Father Son

and Holy Spirit Godrsquos nature is missional His passion is infectious His

actions are historical redemptive and eternal Te rinity invites the

church into a sending community Te Father sends the Son Te Father

and Son send the Spirit Finally the rinity sends the church in missioninto the world

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of the rinity How does it enable our participation in the mission

and community of the triune God

Association and dialogue Tese need to happen across denominational

cultural ethnic gender and theological traditions and divides Authentic

dialogue is indispensable to the health and mission of the church What dothose marginal to the life of the church have to say to us What do ldquoothersrdquo

have to teach us Other ethnicities and cultures Other socioeconomic

groups Other ages and genders Other theological and confessing tradi-

tions Other persons from times long gone

We need to listen Share Be vulnerable Be authentic Open up to crit-

icism correction and change

We need more than dialogue We need communion and association It is

possible in a qualified way to say that God is present in all the various forms

of the church (ie the various theological ecclesiological sociocultural his-

torical and other permutations of the church) We discern this presence

through attention to Scripture history tradition culture and the Spirit Dis-

cernment involves critical dialogue theological exchange biblical study and

real relationship Only the Spirit of Jesus can enable this

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of association and dialogue

Mission and the missio Dei Te church is missional at its core It serves

obeys and images a missionary God David Bosch says ldquoTe churchrsquos mission

is not secondary to its being the church exists in being sent and in building up

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2536

10486271048626 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

itself for its missionrdquo He goes on to say ldquoEcclesiology does not precede missi-

ology there cannot be church without an intrinsic missionary dimensionrdquo983089983089

Jesus is Lord Lord of his church and Lord of his world His mission de-termines and forms the church His mission shapes the nature purposes

structures ministries and activities of his church Majority World and in-

digenous thinkers help us understand the implications of this mission Tey

help us form glocal theologies of mission Tey reveal ldquomission in context

as transformationrdquo9830891048626

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of mission and the missio Dei Church theology and practice Glocal conversations can inform and

enrich many aspects of the church (when practiced well) Teologies and

practices benefit from robust and critical glocal conversations Tese con-

versations enrich many areas (community spirituality discipleship liturgy

worship hospitality eco-justice education social ethics servantship lib-

eration place suffering beauty and so on)

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-standing of these many dimensions of church and mission

Glocal processes shape these eight themes and their practices We need

to facilitate and enable these conversations and processes Tis is urgent It

must be a priority No theology of mission or missional ecclesiology is ad-

equate without glocal conversations983089983091

T983144983141 L983151983139983137983148 983137983150983140 G983148983151983138983137983148 E983150983154983145983139983144 E983137983139983144 O983156983144983141983154

Glocalization takes the localparticular context and globaluniversal themes

seriously Contextual and global conversations enter an enriching and in-

forming relationship Tese two always have an active and symbiotic rela-

tionship Tis is true whether we deliberately put them into conversation or

not Te local shapes the global and the global shapes the local Many local

11David J Bosch Believing in the Future oward a Missiology o Western Culture (New York

rinity 1048625983097983097983093) 104862798309012izon ransormation Afer Lausanne 1048631-98309713Not all o these themes are dealt with in this present volume since either (1048625) I have dealt with them

in my book Salt Light and a City (983090) they are not all key themes in the writings o the thirty-five

Majority World thinkers considered in this volume or (1048627) there is not adequate space in a book

this size

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2636

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048627

voices converge to form global conversations and theologies Using the Phil-

ippines as a case study izon illustrates this by showing the interdepen-

dence between local and global themes in mission983089983092Dialogue between local and global conversations is critical Kōsuke

Koyama wrote an important book on contextual mission called Water Buffalo

Teology Koyama is a Japanese missionary who served in Chiang Mai

Tailand He writes of the joys and challenges of doing local particular water

buffalo theology He considers the relationship between local theology global

missional themes and transforming cultures ldquoWater Buffalo Teology sees

certain specific challenges Contextualization of theology implies two criticalmovements First to articulate Jesus Christ in culturally appropriate com-

municatively apt words and second to criticize reform dethrone or oppose

culture if it is found to be against what the name of Jesus Christ stands forrdquo9830891048629

Kōsuke Koyama challenges us to recognize what we bring to the task of

local theology For him it was doing theology in Tailand while being Jap-

anese We also need to notice the particular culture wersquore located in as we do

the work of theology Tis means we avoid speaking of an ldquoAsian theologyrdquoldquoAfrican theologyrdquo and the like We need to cultivate local theologies that

engage regional and global themes But these theologies must be ldquodistinctly

localrdquo and a ldquotheology from belowrdquo9830891048630

Simultaneously we need to pursue a reformation of theology and

practice ldquoin the global contextrdquo Tis means entering ldquothe disturbing spa-

ciousness of Jesus Christrdquo Jesus calls us to reject enmity and exceptionalism

We seem him present in our culture language stories and relationships

But we also choose to embrace the ldquootherrdquo We choose to see him present

in other culturesmdashshaping a global people to serve and worship him

joining in his mission983089983095

Kōsuke Koyama roots the gospel in the local contextual and particular

Tis is why he roots his water buffalo theology in Northern Tai culture He

is careful not to say ldquoHere is how you contextualize in your settingrdquo Instead

14izon ransormation Afer Lausanne 1048631-10486251048627 10486251048628983097-98309098308898309015Kōsuke Koyama Water Buffalo Teology 983090983093th anniversary ed (Maryknoll NY Orbis 1048625983097983097983097)

xiii-xv16Kōsuke Koyama ldquoTe Asian Approach to Christrdquo Missiology 1048625983090 no 1048628 (10486259830979830961048628) 10486281048627983093-104862798309617Kōsuke Koyama ldquoReormation in the Global Context Te Disturbing Spaciousness o Jesus Christrdquo

Currents in Teology and Mission 1048627983088 no 983090 (9830909830889830881048627) 10486251048625983097-983090983096

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2736

10486271048628 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

he tells us a story Itrsquos the story of how he contextualized theology in northern

Tailand while being open to global conversations Koyama asks us to form

our own local expressions of church mission and theology At the same timewe must stay attentive to what God is saying and doing beyond that context

Tis way local and global and particular and universal become mutually

enriching conversation partners

G983148983151983139983137983148983145983162983137983156983145983151983150 983137983150983140 H983145983155983156983151983154983145983139983137983148983148983161 S983145983148983141983150983139983141983140 V983151983145983139983141983155

Glocal theologies and conversations pay attention to voices that powers in-

stitutions religions and societies have silenced R S Sugirtharajah pushesback a little on izonrsquos ideas Sugirtharajah says that the church should

privilege local conversations He emphasizes the local contextual and post-

colonial reading of biblical texts9830891048632

Te church needs to listen Te church ought to be attentive to the

theologies and biblical interpretations of groups that cultures and reli-

gions have ignored Historically powerful secular and religious forces

have silenced these groups Tey have marginalized oppressed and colo-nized them It is time for the church to address this injustice We must

start listening to important but silenced voices We need to privilege the

voices of the former victims of Western colonialism We need to develop

postcolonial biblical interpretations theologies and expressions of church

and mission

How do we take such perspectives seriously as we develop glocal conver-

sations How do these themes help us foster vital relationships between local

and global voices

It is time for us to embrace values that enable conversations with those

oen ignored by the church We need values that help us learn from these

groups and individuals

Valuing equal partnership Colonizing powers oppressed silenced and

colonized certain groups At times the church was complicit Tese colo-

nized groups have become ldquoconfident indomitable and indispensable

partners in the dialogue and collaboration with the dispossessed and disad-

18R S Sugirtharajah Asian Biblical Hermeneutics and Postcolonialism Contesting the Interpreta-

tions Te Bible and Liberation Series (Maryknoll NY Orbis 1048625983097983097983096) 1048625983093-1048625983094

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2836

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048629

vantaged in the Westrdquo9830891048633 Tis calls for attentiveness to these voices and re-

sponsiveness to their prophetic challenges It also demands a critical evalu-

ation of colonial readings of Scripture Colonial models of theology andchurch and mission are no longer the benchmark Te global church must

examine them afresh

Valuing equal status Tose on the margins have now taken their rightful

place on the global stage Tey have claimed appropriate and equal status at

the table Subaltern readings of theology church and mission are invaluable

contributors to global theological conversations Tis means that we esteem

them But we also test themWhat do we mean by subaltern Subalterns are those who are down-

trodden and silenced (or have been treated this way in the past) Dominant

or colonizing groups treat them as invisible nonentities Tey enjoy limited

or no access to power Sometimes these are women certain tribal and ethnic

groups and those considered ldquountouchablerdquo In Voices from the Margin Su-

girtharajah provides a platform for postcolonial subaltern readings of

Scripture and theology Tese readings challenge colonialmdashoen Westernmdashreadings of Bible and theology and cultures Tey claim equal status with

other ways of doing theology10486261048624

Valuing equal identity People groups need freedom to explore their new

and emerging identities Tese emerge in response to local and global influ-

ences Local culture is not the only thing at work here Global forces also

shape identity as do imported practices ideas readings rituals and tech-

nologies But each group should be free to explore and construct their par-

ticular forms of Christian identity

Valuing equal interpretations ldquoPostcolonialism is concerned with the

question of cultural and discursive dominationrdquo Colonialism led to op-

pressive and controlling forms of culture and discourse Tese were usually

not contextual or indigenous Western powers for instance brought co-

lonial forms of theology church biblical interpretation and mission1048626983089

Postcolonialism calls for alternative ways of approaching these things Tose

19Ibid 104862598309420R S Sugirtharajah Voices rom the Margin Interpreting the Bible in the Tird World (Maryknoll

NY Orbis 10486259830979830971048625)21Sugirtharajah Asian Biblical Hermeneutics and Postcolonialism 10486251048631

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2936

10486271048630 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

who were once marginalized oppressed and silenced need to lead these fresh

approaches in their own settings Tese then influence global conversations

We need to support the new readings and insights and experiments from thesegroups o be genuine this support must be both critical and collegial

Valuing equal empowerment Sugirtharajah says that postcolonialism is

valuable when it empowers actual communities and real people Post-

colonial thought empowers when it addresses the difficulties hopes and

experiences of ordinary people It should never be about power plays and

the clever use of language Itrsquos pointless if itrsquos obsessed with forming newmdash

and ldquocolonizingrdquomdashtheories Itrsquos a waste of time if itrsquos a self-indulgent pursuitof new and hybrid identities Rather ldquothe worth and credibility of post-

colonial criticism will be judged by how it orchestrates the unique and

fragile and imagined claims of one community against anotherrdquo Empow-

erment happens in a variety of ways One way is contributing equally to

global conversations10486261048626

Al izon examines postcolonialism in the Philippines He says that it can

teach the global church a lot about healthy local-global conversations Fil-ipino contextual theology resists many Western forms of mission and the-

ology It finds them patronizing and controlling Tis indigenous theology

values prophetic sociopolitical engagement in institutions and the society

at large It emphasizes ministry to whole persons and communities It con-

structs a Filipino theology of beauty and mission and worship and com-

munity And it fosters indigenous theological approaches to the spirit world

and cosmology

izon says that postcolonial theology has played a constructive role in

the Philippines But he is uncomfortable with the label postcolonialism He

prefers to describe historical events as ldquobeyond colonialismrdquo And he says

that global conversations enrich local theologies and vice versa1048626983091

Postcolonial thought informs our understanding of the relationship be-

tween the local and global It also shows how theology can emerge at the

intersection between the localparticular and the globaluniversal It re-

minds us that worthwhile glocalization listens to all voices Tis includes

heeding those that have been historically silenced

22Ibid 983090104862823izon ransormation Afer Lausanne 1048625983088983090 10486259830941048631-9830961048631

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3036

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048631

G983148983151983139983137983148983145983162983137983156983145983151983150 983137983150983140 983156983144983141 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

C983151983150983139983148983157983140983145983150983143 R983141983142983148983141983139983156983145983151983150983155

How do we go about developing a model for glocal conversations izon hasrecently provided a useful model that is instructive as we seek to learn from

the Majority World It has at least two key features

First the local is in the global (globalization from below) Global theologies

and ideas have origins in many particular local contexts In that sense glo-

balization is from below Global ideas have local roots Ideas about integral

mission liberation theology and missional church have local origins Tey

have their roots in the prayers hopes discoveries mission and theologiesof thousands of local communities ldquoTe global does not cannot exist

without the localmdashbut the coming together of localities creates a global re-

ality that becomes greater than the sum of its parts it creates a gestalt entity

to which localities make themselves accountablerdquo1048626983092

Second the global is in the local (panlocalization from above) Te con-

cerns and voices of multitudes of locales form global conversations Tese

global discussions can provide a ldquopositive accountabilityrdquo back to local con-texts Tis is true when they enrich affirm serve guide and strengthen local

contexts It is also true when they avoid homogenization control impo-

sition and judgment Glocalization is best when it sees itself as interde-

pendent deeply connected with the local10486261048629

Tatrsquos a helpful starting point But we need to go further Besides izonrsquos

proposals Irsquom convinced that robust glocal conversations cultivate six core

practices

983089 Glocal theology practices its values We root glocal theology in core

values Tese values include solidarity understanding and mutual learning

Do we value fellowship with Christians of all cultures Do we value learning

from them

We prove our values through our practices What practices emerge out of

these values We need to collaborate act collectively and share information

We must find ways to foster grassroots perspectives and local theologies We

need to share stories and learnings and cultivate networks relationships and

partnerships We need attentiveness to local voices and global themes We

24Ibid 9830901048625983088-1048625104862825Ibid 98309010486251048628-1048625983096

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3136

10486271048632 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

ought to find ways to put these local and global voices into conversation

Mutual learning humility and solidarity are key Worthwhile glocal con-

versations can never be merely theoretical or academic It is up to us to rootour values in our practices

983090 Glocal theology practices humility (and it tells a new narrative) We

have noted that the local is in the global and the global is in the local Te

two are interdependent Tey form each other reciprocally Since this is the

case we must practice humility Tere is no place for ethnocentrism colo-

nialism or theological and cultural arrogance I have seen these unhealthy

postures far too oen in Western settingsRecently I attended a missional leadership conference On that occasion

the keynote speakermdasha leading missional author and speakermdashsaid that

North American missional conversations and innovations hold the key to

the future of the Western church Tis Euro American view is wrong (Irsquom

being kind o be frank itrsquos complete nonsense) Itrsquos arrogant and Euro

Americanndashcentric And itrsquos completely out of step with what is happening in

the glocal church We need a new narrativeIn June 1048626104862410486251048627 Te Center for the Study of Global Christianity reported

the top 10486261048624 countries where Christianity has the highest percentage growth

rate Nineteen of the top twenty are in Asia and Africa Eleven of them are

in Muslim majority countries Not a single country from Europe or North

America makes the top twenty list10486261048630

Itrsquos time to cultivate a new narrative Te future of the church is emerging

from the Majority World Rather than North America the churches of

Eastern Asia Western Africa the Arabian Peninsula and other parts of the

Majority World reveal the future of the global church We need the contribu-

tions of all contexts Western indigenous and Majority World All con-

tribute to glocal conversations All are important as we learn from each

other about mission theology and faith But letrsquos stop pretending that North

Americans and Europeans will reveal the future of the global church Letrsquos

start listening to what God is saying about the future of the global church

And hersquos speaking to us through the churches of Asia Africa Latin America

26Russ Mitchell ldquoTe op 983090983088 Countries Where Christianity Is Growing the Fastestrdquo Disciple All

Nations (blog) August 983090983093 98309098308810486251048627 httpsdiscipleallnationswordpresscom98309098308810486251048627983088983096983090983093the-top

-983090983088-countries-where-christianity-is-growing-the-astest

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3236

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048633

Muslim majority settings and so on We must cultivate a new glocal nar-

rativemdashone soaked in humility

Glocal theology must be humble theology Meek theology Receptive the-ology Discerning theology Prayerful theology Dialogical theology De-

pendent theology A theology that celebrates the interdependence between

the localparticular and the globaluniversal

983091 Glocal theology practices expansiveness Glocalization is by nature

comprehensive Local and global influences permeate much of our lives Tese

glocal forces shape our theologies and churches whether we like it or not

But intentionality is also important We need to commit to an expansiveapproach to glocal theology How do we deliberately cultivate glocal conver-

sations in our biblical interpretation Do we foster them in our under-

standing of the person and work of Christ How does glocalization shape

the way the Spirit empowers and constitutes the church How can it form

our understanding of the nature and mission of the rinity How does it

influence the way we practice fellowship and conversation across denomi-

national cultural ethnic economic sociocultural political gender andtheological divides How might it shape our theologies of mission com-

munity beauty spirituality suffering discipleship hospitality eco-justice

place education social ethics Christian leadership and so forth

983092 Glocal theology practices attention Glocal theology doesnrsquot need to

accept all the assumptions or assertions of postcolonial or Majority World

thought But it does need to engage with them and take them seriously

Postcolonial theology for instance gives the marginalized and colonized

and forgotten and silenced both dignity and voice Our glocal conversations

must also include and esteem these groups We need to be attentive to

others weak and powerful female and male dominant and downtrodden

old and young rich and poor privileged and marginalized influential and

subaltern educated and illiterate We need to practice the art of attention

being especially attentive to those who are different to us

983093 Glocal theology practices embrace What do colonial ethnocentric or

Western-centric perspectives do Tey silence Tey control Tey com-

modify Tey institutionalize Tey colonize Tey domesticate Tey replace

Tey import Tey exclude Tey do these things to the beliefs experiences

and practices of other cultures A worthwhile glocal theology refuses to do

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3336

10486281048624 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

these things Instead it adopts a responsive humble celebratory open in-

clusive and embracing attitude

983094 Glocal theology practices discernment Finally we need discernmentas we engage these ideas and practices Discernment is a huge topic thatrsquos

hard to cover comprehensively in a few words Discernment happens when

the Spirit of Christ and his Word renew our minds Te Spirit grants us

spiritual wisdom as we meditate on him and his Word and as we practice

discipleship to Jesus Christ Romans 10486251048626 provides guidance we need (1048625) to be

transformed by the renewal of our minds (1048626) to serve Christrsquos body and (1048627)

to put love into action Discernment also happens in conversation both lo-cally and glocally

I pray these core values and six practices come across in the following

chapters of GlobalChurch

Glocalization can never be just theoretical Are we committed to moving

glocalization from an abstract idea to a living communion Are we deter-

mined to construct a missional theology of the church in the context of

glocal conversations Tis must involve dialogue between Majority Worldindigenous and Western scholars activists and groups

Will glocalization be an abstract notion Or will it be a formative and

genuine communion between local regional and global voices Glocal dy-

namics are at play whether we like it or not Teyrsquore in our churches the-

ologies and missions But we can choose to relinquish isolationist colonial

parochial and arrogant approaches Instead we can adopt responsive dia-

logical learning humble and embracing postures

Trough healthy approaches to glocalization the Spirit challenges us to

value local contexts We immerse ourselves in local and particular commu-

nities and conversations He inspires us to open ourselves to global theo-

logical conversations He rouses us to value the symbiotic relationship be-

tween the localparticular and the globaluniversal

Trough glocal relationships the Spirit leads us to put local contextual

theologies into conversation with global ones He prompts us to explore the

ways in which the local is in the glocal and the global is in the local He per-

suades us to pursue collaboration and dialogue and mutual learning We

engage with Christians from different backgrounds and cultures ecumen-

icals Pentecostals evangelicals and so on from Western indigenous and

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3436

Glocalizing Conversations 10486281048625

Majority World contexts He motivates us to express solidarity between all

parties We appreciate our unity in diversity

Trough glocal conversations the Spirit moves us to ensure that unity andsolidarity emerge from a compelling vision of Jesusrsquo kingdom and gospel

and person He challenges us to share information theology and practices

He urges us to learn from each othermdashour successes and mistakes We seek

glocal solutions

Te Spirit calls us to develop glocal conversations about Christian ideas

and practices Tese include Scripture Evangelicalism ecumenism Pente-

costalism Jesus Christ the Holy Spirit God the Father the rinity com-munity spirituality discipleship liturgy worship hospitality prayer eco-

justice education social ethics Christian leadership gospel and culture

beauty place suffering liberation and so forth

Finally through glocal conversations the Spirit leads us to adopt a new

posture Tis is a responsive humble celebratory open inclusive and em-

bracing attitude to the ldquootherrdquo We do this as a new people made up of every

tribe and language and people and nationTere are dangers in glocalization Sugirtharajah warns of the commodi-

fication of local contextual practices and theologies When this happens

they are ldquosmoothed out of their primary contexts concerns and contesta-

tions travel across borders and become objects of analysis and scrutiny

within an alien secondary contextrdquo1048626983095

Itrsquos common for those of us who are Western to make mistakes when we

wrestle with Majority World and indigenous ideas Sugirtharajah mentions

our tendency to commodify reduce and institutionalize these ideas We also

risk doing these things (1048625) We apply them in noncontextual prescriptive ways

(1048626) We ignore their meanings in their original setting (1048627) We glamorize or

idealize their proponents or their contexts (1048628) We demonize those persons or

contexts (1048629) We disregard them as irrelevant rhetorical or minority discourse

Kevin J Vanhoozer says that we can fall into three traps when we glo-

calize theology (1048625) We can underestimate the theological significance of

local cultures (1048626) We can homogenize cultures and theologies exaggerating

27R S Sugirtharajah ldquoextual ake-Aways Tird World exts in Western Metropolitan Centresrdquo

Black Teology in Britain A Journal o Contextual Praxis 983090 (1048625983097983097983097) 10486271048627 10486271048631 Edward W Said Te

World the ext and the Critic (Cambridge MA Harvard University Press 10486259830979830961048627) 9830901048627983097

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3536

10486281048626 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

ldquothe onerdquo (1048627) We can overemphasize cultural particularity exaggerating ldquothe

manyrdquo and pursue ldquotheological ethnificationrdquo10486261048632

My hope is that GlobalChurch does not fall into the traps Sugirtharajahand Vanhoozer describe I hope that what unfolds in the following chapters

is respectful and discerning I hope it leads to further mutually enriching

conversations between people of different cultures

You the reader face the same challenges You face them in your personal

life ministry context and missional engagements

Will you treat the themes in this book as abstract theoretical notions

Will this be a temporary infatuation a flirtation with the ldquootherrdquo that dissi-pates as suddenly as it arrived Or will glocal conversations become an en-

riching and formative orientation in your life Will glocal conversations

bring fresh approaches to theology faith mission church and worship Will

conversations with other cultures and theologies become for you a com-

pelling way of life

My prayer is that glocal conversations will help the church be a global

visible alternative ldquocity set upon a hillrdquo a truly GlobalChurch

28Craig Ott and Harold A Netland Globalizing Teology Belie and Practice in an Era o World

Christianity (Grand Rapids Baker Academic 983090983088983088983094) 1048625983090983093

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3636

Page 20: GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2036

Glocalizing Conversations 10486261048631

always rooted in the local and particularmdashas local churches embody the

gospel and witness to Christ Tese churches forge their own theological

understandings as they do mission together Tey engage in transformationalpractices among the people in their settings Tey enjoy worship mission

and community in their local and particular context Ideally the result is

unique contextual theologies and missions

Simultaneously global conversations form Tey form because of this

multitude of local theologies and practices Local conversations inform and

enrich other local conversations catalyzing global themes and voices izon

observes that the global ldquoowes its existence to local contexts Sharedconvictions among the theologies and practices of local contextual realities

give shape to its global dimensionsrdquo1048629

Majority World indigenous and Western theologies are equally contextual

Tey are equally culture bound Tey are equally particular to their time and

location At times they are all enlightened or myopic liberating or con-

straining humanizing or objectifying beautiful or offensive prophetic or

tepid Te local particular and cultural shape all these theologies Converselythese particular theologies feed and influence global conversations Tere is

no place then for ethnocentrism colonialism or elitism Tere is no place

for theological missional cultural or institutionalized arrogance

Multiple local contexts and voices come togethermdashintentionally or notmdashto

form global themes and theologies Conversely these global realities shape

local contexts oday local contexts must grapple with ldquoan emerging global

culture ie the interacting realities of modernity postmodernity and the

phenomenon of globalizationrdquo1048630 Hence the interdependent and symbiotic

relationship between the localparticular and the globaluniversal We call this

interdependent relationship between the local and the global glocalization

Te global church needs a thrilling glocal exchange We need one that we

characterize by mutuality respect partnership and symbiosis Such ex-

change helps Majority World indigenous and Western churches learn from

each other It enables them to pursue missional theology and practice o-

gether the church becomes a ldquocity on a hillrdquo

5Ibid 10486259830886Ibid 9830961048628

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2136

10486261048632 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

W983144983137983156 R983141983153983157983145983154983141983155 G983148983151983139983137983148983145983162983137983156983145983151983150983103

Te glocal exchange described above needs to be broader than transforma-

tional mission Tis is necessary if the church is to develop a robust inter-cultural and glocal missional ecclesiology

In my first book Salt Light and a City I outlined the foundational

themes of missional ecclesiology983095 Majority World and Western leaders

need to engage these themes in local and contextual ways Teir insights can

then enrich global conversations Tese global conversations in turn shape

local understandings and practices Tis way a glocal appreciation of these

themes emergesLocal regional and global theologies and practices are thereby enriched

Te church becomes healthier and more missionalmdasha truer expression of

the kingdom Te church becomes a fuller witness to Christ his passion for

the nations and his ability to bring unity in diversity

Stephen Bevans and Roger Schroeder outline the six constants of mission

Tese are our theologies about Jesus the church the end times salvation

human nature and culture Bevans and Schroeder describe the relationshipbetween these six and their historical cultural and theological contexts Tis is

why they call these six constants in context Our understanding of these six

constants develops in relation to local and global movements Sometimes local

voices influence our understandings of these six Other times it is regional or

global voices For all of us local regional and global influences are at play at

once Collectively they form our appreciation of the six constants of mission1048632

Here are eight theological themes that the church can develop through

processes of glocalization I presented these in my book Salt Light and a City

Tey are vital to the churchrsquos health mission community and future We

could add many other themes to these eight but these will suffice for now1048633

Scripture Te Scriptures are the infallible authoritative Word of God

Christrsquos Spirit has inspired them Tey have absolute and final authority in

all aspects of corporate and individual faith ethics conduct and witness

Christians interpret and apply Scripture in local contexts and in particular

7Graham Hill Salt Light and a City Introducing Missional Ecclesiology (Eugene OR Wip and

Stock 9830909830881048625983090) 10486251048628983097-983090104863110486288Stephen B Bevans and Roger Schroeder Constants in Context A Teology o Mission or oday

American Society o Missiology Series (Maryknoll NY Orbis 9830909830889830881048628) part one9Tese points first appeared in my book Salt Light and a City xxii-xxiv

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2236

Glocalizing Conversations 10486261048633

social settings Conversely we learn from the interpretations and readings

of other groups

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our local- global theology of Scripture and biblical interpretation

Evangelicalism Pentecostalism missional movements and so forth I

have charismatic missional and evangelical convictions Glocal conversa-

tions help me understand and practice these convictions better

I will use evangelicalism as an example Michael Horton says that our

beliefs and practices are evangelical when they are ldquocommitted to the suffi-

ciency of Scripture the priesthood of all believers the total lostness ofhumans the sole mediation of Christ the gracious efficacy and finality of

Godrsquos redemptive work in Christ through election propitiation calling and

keeping Te linchpin for all of this was the doctrine of justification by grace

alone through faith alone because of Christ alonerdquo9830891048624

Such convictions are necessary if we are to be faithful to the gospel and

to a biblical vision of church and mission Te gospel defines Godrsquos purposes

for humanity the church and the universe Te triune God controls thechurch He is its Lord and Savior Sanctifier and Liberator Master and King

He is completely sovereign over its nature affairs mission and history God

is the churchrsquos only source of grace election atonement salvation and per-

severance Te churchrsquos justification and hope are by grace alone through

faith alone by Christ alone

Herersquos the challenge I face My understanding of evangelicalism is

Western I am a product of the Western theological tradition and my Western

evangelical heritage Much of this is wonderful But I need indigenous and

Majority World evangelicals and others to help me expand and reshape

these insights Te same would be true if I were a Pentecostal

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of our theological traditions and convictions

Jesus Christ We must center our theology on Jesus Christ the Lord of

the church Te church needs to reflect on the person and work of Christ

and respond to him Tis means gathering and going in the name and power

of Christ It means allowing Christrsquos Spirit to shape our community and

10Michael Horton ldquoEvangelical Arminiansrdquo Modern Reormation 1048625 no 1048627 (1048625983097983097983090) 10486251048631

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2336

10486271048624 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

identity and mission It means developing our Christology ecclesiology and

missiology concurrently Te early church developed these three areas and

more in a concurrent and integrated way Tere was no linear progressionTe same is true in the contemporary global church

How can the glocal church best explore its nature structure mission and

hope Trough the centrality and the lordship of Christ

Majority World and indigenous Christians help us appreciate Jesus and

his mission afresh Tey show us how Jesus identifies with the marginalized

outcast oppressed rejected and broken He prefers them We find him

among ldquothe least of theserdquoGlocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of who Jesus Christ is How does it help us appreciate him better

What has Jesus done for and in his church and his world What does he care

about What individual and corporate responsibilities has he given us How

do we express these at local regional and global levels

Te Spirit Missional ecclesiology is inadequate without pneumatological

foundations In other words our theology of church and Spirit go togetherTe Spirit creates and animates the church He empowers it to witness to

Jesus and his gospel Te Spirit enables the church to be a missional trans-

formational community He shapes the church into an alternative society

embodying the reign of God Te church exists for the glory and mission of

Christ Te power and presence of the Spirit enables this mission worship

and glorification

Te Spirit pours out gis on the local-global church ldquofor the common

goodrdquo and ldquoto equip his people for works of service so that the body of Christ

may be built uprdquo Tis includes but isnrsquot limited to the ministry gis mani-

festation gis and motivational gis (1048625 Cor 104862510486261048631 Eph 104862810486251048625-10486251048626 Rom 104862510486261048630-1048632)

Te Spirit forms the glocal church He empowers it for service and

witness He fills it with Christrsquos empowering presence He leads it into the

missio Deimdashthe mission of the Father Son and Holy Spirit

Recently Pentecostal and renewalist movements have grown dramati-

cally in the Majority World Tey have increased in status size and influence

Many have matured theologically Te churches of the West must take notice

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of the power and presence of the Spirit

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2436

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048625

Te rinity Tere are clear limitations to the analogy between the

church and the rinity Te church can only image the rinity Yet the

church is at its best when it reflects the relational and missional passionof the rinity

What is the source and inspiration of the churchrsquos local-global mission

Ultimately it is the missional nature passion and actions of the Father Son

and Holy Spirit Godrsquos nature is missional His passion is infectious His

actions are historical redemptive and eternal Te rinity invites the

church into a sending community Te Father sends the Son Te Father

and Son send the Spirit Finally the rinity sends the church in missioninto the world

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of the rinity How does it enable our participation in the mission

and community of the triune God

Association and dialogue Tese need to happen across denominational

cultural ethnic gender and theological traditions and divides Authentic

dialogue is indispensable to the health and mission of the church What dothose marginal to the life of the church have to say to us What do ldquoothersrdquo

have to teach us Other ethnicities and cultures Other socioeconomic

groups Other ages and genders Other theological and confessing tradi-

tions Other persons from times long gone

We need to listen Share Be vulnerable Be authentic Open up to crit-

icism correction and change

We need more than dialogue We need communion and association It is

possible in a qualified way to say that God is present in all the various forms

of the church (ie the various theological ecclesiological sociocultural his-

torical and other permutations of the church) We discern this presence

through attention to Scripture history tradition culture and the Spirit Dis-

cernment involves critical dialogue theological exchange biblical study and

real relationship Only the Spirit of Jesus can enable this

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of association and dialogue

Mission and the missio Dei Te church is missional at its core It serves

obeys and images a missionary God David Bosch says ldquoTe churchrsquos mission

is not secondary to its being the church exists in being sent and in building up

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2536

10486271048626 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

itself for its missionrdquo He goes on to say ldquoEcclesiology does not precede missi-

ology there cannot be church without an intrinsic missionary dimensionrdquo983089983089

Jesus is Lord Lord of his church and Lord of his world His mission de-termines and forms the church His mission shapes the nature purposes

structures ministries and activities of his church Majority World and in-

digenous thinkers help us understand the implications of this mission Tey

help us form glocal theologies of mission Tey reveal ldquomission in context

as transformationrdquo9830891048626

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of mission and the missio Dei Church theology and practice Glocal conversations can inform and

enrich many aspects of the church (when practiced well) Teologies and

practices benefit from robust and critical glocal conversations Tese con-

versations enrich many areas (community spirituality discipleship liturgy

worship hospitality eco-justice education social ethics servantship lib-

eration place suffering beauty and so on)

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-standing of these many dimensions of church and mission

Glocal processes shape these eight themes and their practices We need

to facilitate and enable these conversations and processes Tis is urgent It

must be a priority No theology of mission or missional ecclesiology is ad-

equate without glocal conversations983089983091

T983144983141 L983151983139983137983148 983137983150983140 G983148983151983138983137983148 E983150983154983145983139983144 E983137983139983144 O983156983144983141983154

Glocalization takes the localparticular context and globaluniversal themes

seriously Contextual and global conversations enter an enriching and in-

forming relationship Tese two always have an active and symbiotic rela-

tionship Tis is true whether we deliberately put them into conversation or

not Te local shapes the global and the global shapes the local Many local

11David J Bosch Believing in the Future oward a Missiology o Western Culture (New York

rinity 1048625983097983097983093) 104862798309012izon ransormation Afer Lausanne 1048631-98309713Not all o these themes are dealt with in this present volume since either (1048625) I have dealt with them

in my book Salt Light and a City (983090) they are not all key themes in the writings o the thirty-five

Majority World thinkers considered in this volume or (1048627) there is not adequate space in a book

this size

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2636

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048627

voices converge to form global conversations and theologies Using the Phil-

ippines as a case study izon illustrates this by showing the interdepen-

dence between local and global themes in mission983089983092Dialogue between local and global conversations is critical Kōsuke

Koyama wrote an important book on contextual mission called Water Buffalo

Teology Koyama is a Japanese missionary who served in Chiang Mai

Tailand He writes of the joys and challenges of doing local particular water

buffalo theology He considers the relationship between local theology global

missional themes and transforming cultures ldquoWater Buffalo Teology sees

certain specific challenges Contextualization of theology implies two criticalmovements First to articulate Jesus Christ in culturally appropriate com-

municatively apt words and second to criticize reform dethrone or oppose

culture if it is found to be against what the name of Jesus Christ stands forrdquo9830891048629

Kōsuke Koyama challenges us to recognize what we bring to the task of

local theology For him it was doing theology in Tailand while being Jap-

anese We also need to notice the particular culture wersquore located in as we do

the work of theology Tis means we avoid speaking of an ldquoAsian theologyrdquoldquoAfrican theologyrdquo and the like We need to cultivate local theologies that

engage regional and global themes But these theologies must be ldquodistinctly

localrdquo and a ldquotheology from belowrdquo9830891048630

Simultaneously we need to pursue a reformation of theology and

practice ldquoin the global contextrdquo Tis means entering ldquothe disturbing spa-

ciousness of Jesus Christrdquo Jesus calls us to reject enmity and exceptionalism

We seem him present in our culture language stories and relationships

But we also choose to embrace the ldquootherrdquo We choose to see him present

in other culturesmdashshaping a global people to serve and worship him

joining in his mission983089983095

Kōsuke Koyama roots the gospel in the local contextual and particular

Tis is why he roots his water buffalo theology in Northern Tai culture He

is careful not to say ldquoHere is how you contextualize in your settingrdquo Instead

14izon ransormation Afer Lausanne 1048631-10486251048627 10486251048628983097-98309098308898309015Kōsuke Koyama Water Buffalo Teology 983090983093th anniversary ed (Maryknoll NY Orbis 1048625983097983097983097)

xiii-xv16Kōsuke Koyama ldquoTe Asian Approach to Christrdquo Missiology 1048625983090 no 1048628 (10486259830979830961048628) 10486281048627983093-104862798309617Kōsuke Koyama ldquoReormation in the Global Context Te Disturbing Spaciousness o Jesus Christrdquo

Currents in Teology and Mission 1048627983088 no 983090 (9830909830889830881048627) 10486251048625983097-983090983096

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2736

10486271048628 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

he tells us a story Itrsquos the story of how he contextualized theology in northern

Tailand while being open to global conversations Koyama asks us to form

our own local expressions of church mission and theology At the same timewe must stay attentive to what God is saying and doing beyond that context

Tis way local and global and particular and universal become mutually

enriching conversation partners

G983148983151983139983137983148983145983162983137983156983145983151983150 983137983150983140 H983145983155983156983151983154983145983139983137983148983148983161 S983145983148983141983150983139983141983140 V983151983145983139983141983155

Glocal theologies and conversations pay attention to voices that powers in-

stitutions religions and societies have silenced R S Sugirtharajah pushesback a little on izonrsquos ideas Sugirtharajah says that the church should

privilege local conversations He emphasizes the local contextual and post-

colonial reading of biblical texts9830891048632

Te church needs to listen Te church ought to be attentive to the

theologies and biblical interpretations of groups that cultures and reli-

gions have ignored Historically powerful secular and religious forces

have silenced these groups Tey have marginalized oppressed and colo-nized them It is time for the church to address this injustice We must

start listening to important but silenced voices We need to privilege the

voices of the former victims of Western colonialism We need to develop

postcolonial biblical interpretations theologies and expressions of church

and mission

How do we take such perspectives seriously as we develop glocal conver-

sations How do these themes help us foster vital relationships between local

and global voices

It is time for us to embrace values that enable conversations with those

oen ignored by the church We need values that help us learn from these

groups and individuals

Valuing equal partnership Colonizing powers oppressed silenced and

colonized certain groups At times the church was complicit Tese colo-

nized groups have become ldquoconfident indomitable and indispensable

partners in the dialogue and collaboration with the dispossessed and disad-

18R S Sugirtharajah Asian Biblical Hermeneutics and Postcolonialism Contesting the Interpreta-

tions Te Bible and Liberation Series (Maryknoll NY Orbis 1048625983097983097983096) 1048625983093-1048625983094

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2836

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048629

vantaged in the Westrdquo9830891048633 Tis calls for attentiveness to these voices and re-

sponsiveness to their prophetic challenges It also demands a critical evalu-

ation of colonial readings of Scripture Colonial models of theology andchurch and mission are no longer the benchmark Te global church must

examine them afresh

Valuing equal status Tose on the margins have now taken their rightful

place on the global stage Tey have claimed appropriate and equal status at

the table Subaltern readings of theology church and mission are invaluable

contributors to global theological conversations Tis means that we esteem

them But we also test themWhat do we mean by subaltern Subalterns are those who are down-

trodden and silenced (or have been treated this way in the past) Dominant

or colonizing groups treat them as invisible nonentities Tey enjoy limited

or no access to power Sometimes these are women certain tribal and ethnic

groups and those considered ldquountouchablerdquo In Voices from the Margin Su-

girtharajah provides a platform for postcolonial subaltern readings of

Scripture and theology Tese readings challenge colonialmdashoen Westernmdashreadings of Bible and theology and cultures Tey claim equal status with

other ways of doing theology10486261048624

Valuing equal identity People groups need freedom to explore their new

and emerging identities Tese emerge in response to local and global influ-

ences Local culture is not the only thing at work here Global forces also

shape identity as do imported practices ideas readings rituals and tech-

nologies But each group should be free to explore and construct their par-

ticular forms of Christian identity

Valuing equal interpretations ldquoPostcolonialism is concerned with the

question of cultural and discursive dominationrdquo Colonialism led to op-

pressive and controlling forms of culture and discourse Tese were usually

not contextual or indigenous Western powers for instance brought co-

lonial forms of theology church biblical interpretation and mission1048626983089

Postcolonialism calls for alternative ways of approaching these things Tose

19Ibid 104862598309420R S Sugirtharajah Voices rom the Margin Interpreting the Bible in the Tird World (Maryknoll

NY Orbis 10486259830979830971048625)21Sugirtharajah Asian Biblical Hermeneutics and Postcolonialism 10486251048631

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2936

10486271048630 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

who were once marginalized oppressed and silenced need to lead these fresh

approaches in their own settings Tese then influence global conversations

We need to support the new readings and insights and experiments from thesegroups o be genuine this support must be both critical and collegial

Valuing equal empowerment Sugirtharajah says that postcolonialism is

valuable when it empowers actual communities and real people Post-

colonial thought empowers when it addresses the difficulties hopes and

experiences of ordinary people It should never be about power plays and

the clever use of language Itrsquos pointless if itrsquos obsessed with forming newmdash

and ldquocolonizingrdquomdashtheories Itrsquos a waste of time if itrsquos a self-indulgent pursuitof new and hybrid identities Rather ldquothe worth and credibility of post-

colonial criticism will be judged by how it orchestrates the unique and

fragile and imagined claims of one community against anotherrdquo Empow-

erment happens in a variety of ways One way is contributing equally to

global conversations10486261048626

Al izon examines postcolonialism in the Philippines He says that it can

teach the global church a lot about healthy local-global conversations Fil-ipino contextual theology resists many Western forms of mission and the-

ology It finds them patronizing and controlling Tis indigenous theology

values prophetic sociopolitical engagement in institutions and the society

at large It emphasizes ministry to whole persons and communities It con-

structs a Filipino theology of beauty and mission and worship and com-

munity And it fosters indigenous theological approaches to the spirit world

and cosmology

izon says that postcolonial theology has played a constructive role in

the Philippines But he is uncomfortable with the label postcolonialism He

prefers to describe historical events as ldquobeyond colonialismrdquo And he says

that global conversations enrich local theologies and vice versa1048626983091

Postcolonial thought informs our understanding of the relationship be-

tween the local and global It also shows how theology can emerge at the

intersection between the localparticular and the globaluniversal It re-

minds us that worthwhile glocalization listens to all voices Tis includes

heeding those that have been historically silenced

22Ibid 983090104862823izon ransormation Afer Lausanne 1048625983088983090 10486259830941048631-9830961048631

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3036

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048631

G983148983151983139983137983148983145983162983137983156983145983151983150 983137983150983140 983156983144983141 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

C983151983150983139983148983157983140983145983150983143 R983141983142983148983141983139983156983145983151983150983155

How do we go about developing a model for glocal conversations izon hasrecently provided a useful model that is instructive as we seek to learn from

the Majority World It has at least two key features

First the local is in the global (globalization from below) Global theologies

and ideas have origins in many particular local contexts In that sense glo-

balization is from below Global ideas have local roots Ideas about integral

mission liberation theology and missional church have local origins Tey

have their roots in the prayers hopes discoveries mission and theologiesof thousands of local communities ldquoTe global does not cannot exist

without the localmdashbut the coming together of localities creates a global re-

ality that becomes greater than the sum of its parts it creates a gestalt entity

to which localities make themselves accountablerdquo1048626983092

Second the global is in the local (panlocalization from above) Te con-

cerns and voices of multitudes of locales form global conversations Tese

global discussions can provide a ldquopositive accountabilityrdquo back to local con-texts Tis is true when they enrich affirm serve guide and strengthen local

contexts It is also true when they avoid homogenization control impo-

sition and judgment Glocalization is best when it sees itself as interde-

pendent deeply connected with the local10486261048629

Tatrsquos a helpful starting point But we need to go further Besides izonrsquos

proposals Irsquom convinced that robust glocal conversations cultivate six core

practices

983089 Glocal theology practices its values We root glocal theology in core

values Tese values include solidarity understanding and mutual learning

Do we value fellowship with Christians of all cultures Do we value learning

from them

We prove our values through our practices What practices emerge out of

these values We need to collaborate act collectively and share information

We must find ways to foster grassroots perspectives and local theologies We

need to share stories and learnings and cultivate networks relationships and

partnerships We need attentiveness to local voices and global themes We

24Ibid 9830901048625983088-1048625104862825Ibid 98309010486251048628-1048625983096

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3136

10486271048632 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

ought to find ways to put these local and global voices into conversation

Mutual learning humility and solidarity are key Worthwhile glocal con-

versations can never be merely theoretical or academic It is up to us to rootour values in our practices

983090 Glocal theology practices humility (and it tells a new narrative) We

have noted that the local is in the global and the global is in the local Te

two are interdependent Tey form each other reciprocally Since this is the

case we must practice humility Tere is no place for ethnocentrism colo-

nialism or theological and cultural arrogance I have seen these unhealthy

postures far too oen in Western settingsRecently I attended a missional leadership conference On that occasion

the keynote speakermdasha leading missional author and speakermdashsaid that

North American missional conversations and innovations hold the key to

the future of the Western church Tis Euro American view is wrong (Irsquom

being kind o be frank itrsquos complete nonsense) Itrsquos arrogant and Euro

Americanndashcentric And itrsquos completely out of step with what is happening in

the glocal church We need a new narrativeIn June 1048626104862410486251048627 Te Center for the Study of Global Christianity reported

the top 10486261048624 countries where Christianity has the highest percentage growth

rate Nineteen of the top twenty are in Asia and Africa Eleven of them are

in Muslim majority countries Not a single country from Europe or North

America makes the top twenty list10486261048630

Itrsquos time to cultivate a new narrative Te future of the church is emerging

from the Majority World Rather than North America the churches of

Eastern Asia Western Africa the Arabian Peninsula and other parts of the

Majority World reveal the future of the global church We need the contribu-

tions of all contexts Western indigenous and Majority World All con-

tribute to glocal conversations All are important as we learn from each

other about mission theology and faith But letrsquos stop pretending that North

Americans and Europeans will reveal the future of the global church Letrsquos

start listening to what God is saying about the future of the global church

And hersquos speaking to us through the churches of Asia Africa Latin America

26Russ Mitchell ldquoTe op 983090983088 Countries Where Christianity Is Growing the Fastestrdquo Disciple All

Nations (blog) August 983090983093 98309098308810486251048627 httpsdiscipleallnationswordpresscom98309098308810486251048627983088983096983090983093the-top

-983090983088-countries-where-christianity-is-growing-the-astest

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3236

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048633

Muslim majority settings and so on We must cultivate a new glocal nar-

rativemdashone soaked in humility

Glocal theology must be humble theology Meek theology Receptive the-ology Discerning theology Prayerful theology Dialogical theology De-

pendent theology A theology that celebrates the interdependence between

the localparticular and the globaluniversal

983091 Glocal theology practices expansiveness Glocalization is by nature

comprehensive Local and global influences permeate much of our lives Tese

glocal forces shape our theologies and churches whether we like it or not

But intentionality is also important We need to commit to an expansiveapproach to glocal theology How do we deliberately cultivate glocal conver-

sations in our biblical interpretation Do we foster them in our under-

standing of the person and work of Christ How does glocalization shape

the way the Spirit empowers and constitutes the church How can it form

our understanding of the nature and mission of the rinity How does it

influence the way we practice fellowship and conversation across denomi-

national cultural ethnic economic sociocultural political gender andtheological divides How might it shape our theologies of mission com-

munity beauty spirituality suffering discipleship hospitality eco-justice

place education social ethics Christian leadership and so forth

983092 Glocal theology practices attention Glocal theology doesnrsquot need to

accept all the assumptions or assertions of postcolonial or Majority World

thought But it does need to engage with them and take them seriously

Postcolonial theology for instance gives the marginalized and colonized

and forgotten and silenced both dignity and voice Our glocal conversations

must also include and esteem these groups We need to be attentive to

others weak and powerful female and male dominant and downtrodden

old and young rich and poor privileged and marginalized influential and

subaltern educated and illiterate We need to practice the art of attention

being especially attentive to those who are different to us

983093 Glocal theology practices embrace What do colonial ethnocentric or

Western-centric perspectives do Tey silence Tey control Tey com-

modify Tey institutionalize Tey colonize Tey domesticate Tey replace

Tey import Tey exclude Tey do these things to the beliefs experiences

and practices of other cultures A worthwhile glocal theology refuses to do

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3336

10486281048624 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

these things Instead it adopts a responsive humble celebratory open in-

clusive and embracing attitude

983094 Glocal theology practices discernment Finally we need discernmentas we engage these ideas and practices Discernment is a huge topic thatrsquos

hard to cover comprehensively in a few words Discernment happens when

the Spirit of Christ and his Word renew our minds Te Spirit grants us

spiritual wisdom as we meditate on him and his Word and as we practice

discipleship to Jesus Christ Romans 10486251048626 provides guidance we need (1048625) to be

transformed by the renewal of our minds (1048626) to serve Christrsquos body and (1048627)

to put love into action Discernment also happens in conversation both lo-cally and glocally

I pray these core values and six practices come across in the following

chapters of GlobalChurch

Glocalization can never be just theoretical Are we committed to moving

glocalization from an abstract idea to a living communion Are we deter-

mined to construct a missional theology of the church in the context of

glocal conversations Tis must involve dialogue between Majority Worldindigenous and Western scholars activists and groups

Will glocalization be an abstract notion Or will it be a formative and

genuine communion between local regional and global voices Glocal dy-

namics are at play whether we like it or not Teyrsquore in our churches the-

ologies and missions But we can choose to relinquish isolationist colonial

parochial and arrogant approaches Instead we can adopt responsive dia-

logical learning humble and embracing postures

Trough healthy approaches to glocalization the Spirit challenges us to

value local contexts We immerse ourselves in local and particular commu-

nities and conversations He inspires us to open ourselves to global theo-

logical conversations He rouses us to value the symbiotic relationship be-

tween the localparticular and the globaluniversal

Trough glocal relationships the Spirit leads us to put local contextual

theologies into conversation with global ones He prompts us to explore the

ways in which the local is in the glocal and the global is in the local He per-

suades us to pursue collaboration and dialogue and mutual learning We

engage with Christians from different backgrounds and cultures ecumen-

icals Pentecostals evangelicals and so on from Western indigenous and

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3436

Glocalizing Conversations 10486281048625

Majority World contexts He motivates us to express solidarity between all

parties We appreciate our unity in diversity

Trough glocal conversations the Spirit moves us to ensure that unity andsolidarity emerge from a compelling vision of Jesusrsquo kingdom and gospel

and person He challenges us to share information theology and practices

He urges us to learn from each othermdashour successes and mistakes We seek

glocal solutions

Te Spirit calls us to develop glocal conversations about Christian ideas

and practices Tese include Scripture Evangelicalism ecumenism Pente-

costalism Jesus Christ the Holy Spirit God the Father the rinity com-munity spirituality discipleship liturgy worship hospitality prayer eco-

justice education social ethics Christian leadership gospel and culture

beauty place suffering liberation and so forth

Finally through glocal conversations the Spirit leads us to adopt a new

posture Tis is a responsive humble celebratory open inclusive and em-

bracing attitude to the ldquootherrdquo We do this as a new people made up of every

tribe and language and people and nationTere are dangers in glocalization Sugirtharajah warns of the commodi-

fication of local contextual practices and theologies When this happens

they are ldquosmoothed out of their primary contexts concerns and contesta-

tions travel across borders and become objects of analysis and scrutiny

within an alien secondary contextrdquo1048626983095

Itrsquos common for those of us who are Western to make mistakes when we

wrestle with Majority World and indigenous ideas Sugirtharajah mentions

our tendency to commodify reduce and institutionalize these ideas We also

risk doing these things (1048625) We apply them in noncontextual prescriptive ways

(1048626) We ignore their meanings in their original setting (1048627) We glamorize or

idealize their proponents or their contexts (1048628) We demonize those persons or

contexts (1048629) We disregard them as irrelevant rhetorical or minority discourse

Kevin J Vanhoozer says that we can fall into three traps when we glo-

calize theology (1048625) We can underestimate the theological significance of

local cultures (1048626) We can homogenize cultures and theologies exaggerating

27R S Sugirtharajah ldquoextual ake-Aways Tird World exts in Western Metropolitan Centresrdquo

Black Teology in Britain A Journal o Contextual Praxis 983090 (1048625983097983097983097) 10486271048627 10486271048631 Edward W Said Te

World the ext and the Critic (Cambridge MA Harvard University Press 10486259830979830961048627) 9830901048627983097

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3536

10486281048626 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

ldquothe onerdquo (1048627) We can overemphasize cultural particularity exaggerating ldquothe

manyrdquo and pursue ldquotheological ethnificationrdquo10486261048632

My hope is that GlobalChurch does not fall into the traps Sugirtharajahand Vanhoozer describe I hope that what unfolds in the following chapters

is respectful and discerning I hope it leads to further mutually enriching

conversations between people of different cultures

You the reader face the same challenges You face them in your personal

life ministry context and missional engagements

Will you treat the themes in this book as abstract theoretical notions

Will this be a temporary infatuation a flirtation with the ldquootherrdquo that dissi-pates as suddenly as it arrived Or will glocal conversations become an en-

riching and formative orientation in your life Will glocal conversations

bring fresh approaches to theology faith mission church and worship Will

conversations with other cultures and theologies become for you a com-

pelling way of life

My prayer is that glocal conversations will help the church be a global

visible alternative ldquocity set upon a hillrdquo a truly GlobalChurch

28Craig Ott and Harold A Netland Globalizing Teology Belie and Practice in an Era o World

Christianity (Grand Rapids Baker Academic 983090983088983088983094) 1048625983090983093

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3636

Page 21: GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2136

10486261048632 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

W983144983137983156 R983141983153983157983145983154983141983155 G983148983151983139983137983148983145983162983137983156983145983151983150983103

Te glocal exchange described above needs to be broader than transforma-

tional mission Tis is necessary if the church is to develop a robust inter-cultural and glocal missional ecclesiology

In my first book Salt Light and a City I outlined the foundational

themes of missional ecclesiology983095 Majority World and Western leaders

need to engage these themes in local and contextual ways Teir insights can

then enrich global conversations Tese global conversations in turn shape

local understandings and practices Tis way a glocal appreciation of these

themes emergesLocal regional and global theologies and practices are thereby enriched

Te church becomes healthier and more missionalmdasha truer expression of

the kingdom Te church becomes a fuller witness to Christ his passion for

the nations and his ability to bring unity in diversity

Stephen Bevans and Roger Schroeder outline the six constants of mission

Tese are our theologies about Jesus the church the end times salvation

human nature and culture Bevans and Schroeder describe the relationshipbetween these six and their historical cultural and theological contexts Tis is

why they call these six constants in context Our understanding of these six

constants develops in relation to local and global movements Sometimes local

voices influence our understandings of these six Other times it is regional or

global voices For all of us local regional and global influences are at play at

once Collectively they form our appreciation of the six constants of mission1048632

Here are eight theological themes that the church can develop through

processes of glocalization I presented these in my book Salt Light and a City

Tey are vital to the churchrsquos health mission community and future We

could add many other themes to these eight but these will suffice for now1048633

Scripture Te Scriptures are the infallible authoritative Word of God

Christrsquos Spirit has inspired them Tey have absolute and final authority in

all aspects of corporate and individual faith ethics conduct and witness

Christians interpret and apply Scripture in local contexts and in particular

7Graham Hill Salt Light and a City Introducing Missional Ecclesiology (Eugene OR Wip and

Stock 9830909830881048625983090) 10486251048628983097-983090104863110486288Stephen B Bevans and Roger Schroeder Constants in Context A Teology o Mission or oday

American Society o Missiology Series (Maryknoll NY Orbis 9830909830889830881048628) part one9Tese points first appeared in my book Salt Light and a City xxii-xxiv

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2236

Glocalizing Conversations 10486261048633

social settings Conversely we learn from the interpretations and readings

of other groups

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our local- global theology of Scripture and biblical interpretation

Evangelicalism Pentecostalism missional movements and so forth I

have charismatic missional and evangelical convictions Glocal conversa-

tions help me understand and practice these convictions better

I will use evangelicalism as an example Michael Horton says that our

beliefs and practices are evangelical when they are ldquocommitted to the suffi-

ciency of Scripture the priesthood of all believers the total lostness ofhumans the sole mediation of Christ the gracious efficacy and finality of

Godrsquos redemptive work in Christ through election propitiation calling and

keeping Te linchpin for all of this was the doctrine of justification by grace

alone through faith alone because of Christ alonerdquo9830891048624

Such convictions are necessary if we are to be faithful to the gospel and

to a biblical vision of church and mission Te gospel defines Godrsquos purposes

for humanity the church and the universe Te triune God controls thechurch He is its Lord and Savior Sanctifier and Liberator Master and King

He is completely sovereign over its nature affairs mission and history God

is the churchrsquos only source of grace election atonement salvation and per-

severance Te churchrsquos justification and hope are by grace alone through

faith alone by Christ alone

Herersquos the challenge I face My understanding of evangelicalism is

Western I am a product of the Western theological tradition and my Western

evangelical heritage Much of this is wonderful But I need indigenous and

Majority World evangelicals and others to help me expand and reshape

these insights Te same would be true if I were a Pentecostal

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of our theological traditions and convictions

Jesus Christ We must center our theology on Jesus Christ the Lord of

the church Te church needs to reflect on the person and work of Christ

and respond to him Tis means gathering and going in the name and power

of Christ It means allowing Christrsquos Spirit to shape our community and

10Michael Horton ldquoEvangelical Arminiansrdquo Modern Reormation 1048625 no 1048627 (1048625983097983097983090) 10486251048631

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2336

10486271048624 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

identity and mission It means developing our Christology ecclesiology and

missiology concurrently Te early church developed these three areas and

more in a concurrent and integrated way Tere was no linear progressionTe same is true in the contemporary global church

How can the glocal church best explore its nature structure mission and

hope Trough the centrality and the lordship of Christ

Majority World and indigenous Christians help us appreciate Jesus and

his mission afresh Tey show us how Jesus identifies with the marginalized

outcast oppressed rejected and broken He prefers them We find him

among ldquothe least of theserdquoGlocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of who Jesus Christ is How does it help us appreciate him better

What has Jesus done for and in his church and his world What does he care

about What individual and corporate responsibilities has he given us How

do we express these at local regional and global levels

Te Spirit Missional ecclesiology is inadequate without pneumatological

foundations In other words our theology of church and Spirit go togetherTe Spirit creates and animates the church He empowers it to witness to

Jesus and his gospel Te Spirit enables the church to be a missional trans-

formational community He shapes the church into an alternative society

embodying the reign of God Te church exists for the glory and mission of

Christ Te power and presence of the Spirit enables this mission worship

and glorification

Te Spirit pours out gis on the local-global church ldquofor the common

goodrdquo and ldquoto equip his people for works of service so that the body of Christ

may be built uprdquo Tis includes but isnrsquot limited to the ministry gis mani-

festation gis and motivational gis (1048625 Cor 104862510486261048631 Eph 104862810486251048625-10486251048626 Rom 104862510486261048630-1048632)

Te Spirit forms the glocal church He empowers it for service and

witness He fills it with Christrsquos empowering presence He leads it into the

missio Deimdashthe mission of the Father Son and Holy Spirit

Recently Pentecostal and renewalist movements have grown dramati-

cally in the Majority World Tey have increased in status size and influence

Many have matured theologically Te churches of the West must take notice

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of the power and presence of the Spirit

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2436

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048625

Te rinity Tere are clear limitations to the analogy between the

church and the rinity Te church can only image the rinity Yet the

church is at its best when it reflects the relational and missional passionof the rinity

What is the source and inspiration of the churchrsquos local-global mission

Ultimately it is the missional nature passion and actions of the Father Son

and Holy Spirit Godrsquos nature is missional His passion is infectious His

actions are historical redemptive and eternal Te rinity invites the

church into a sending community Te Father sends the Son Te Father

and Son send the Spirit Finally the rinity sends the church in missioninto the world

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of the rinity How does it enable our participation in the mission

and community of the triune God

Association and dialogue Tese need to happen across denominational

cultural ethnic gender and theological traditions and divides Authentic

dialogue is indispensable to the health and mission of the church What dothose marginal to the life of the church have to say to us What do ldquoothersrdquo

have to teach us Other ethnicities and cultures Other socioeconomic

groups Other ages and genders Other theological and confessing tradi-

tions Other persons from times long gone

We need to listen Share Be vulnerable Be authentic Open up to crit-

icism correction and change

We need more than dialogue We need communion and association It is

possible in a qualified way to say that God is present in all the various forms

of the church (ie the various theological ecclesiological sociocultural his-

torical and other permutations of the church) We discern this presence

through attention to Scripture history tradition culture and the Spirit Dis-

cernment involves critical dialogue theological exchange biblical study and

real relationship Only the Spirit of Jesus can enable this

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of association and dialogue

Mission and the missio Dei Te church is missional at its core It serves

obeys and images a missionary God David Bosch says ldquoTe churchrsquos mission

is not secondary to its being the church exists in being sent and in building up

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2536

10486271048626 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

itself for its missionrdquo He goes on to say ldquoEcclesiology does not precede missi-

ology there cannot be church without an intrinsic missionary dimensionrdquo983089983089

Jesus is Lord Lord of his church and Lord of his world His mission de-termines and forms the church His mission shapes the nature purposes

structures ministries and activities of his church Majority World and in-

digenous thinkers help us understand the implications of this mission Tey

help us form glocal theologies of mission Tey reveal ldquomission in context

as transformationrdquo9830891048626

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of mission and the missio Dei Church theology and practice Glocal conversations can inform and

enrich many aspects of the church (when practiced well) Teologies and

practices benefit from robust and critical glocal conversations Tese con-

versations enrich many areas (community spirituality discipleship liturgy

worship hospitality eco-justice education social ethics servantship lib-

eration place suffering beauty and so on)

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-standing of these many dimensions of church and mission

Glocal processes shape these eight themes and their practices We need

to facilitate and enable these conversations and processes Tis is urgent It

must be a priority No theology of mission or missional ecclesiology is ad-

equate without glocal conversations983089983091

T983144983141 L983151983139983137983148 983137983150983140 G983148983151983138983137983148 E983150983154983145983139983144 E983137983139983144 O983156983144983141983154

Glocalization takes the localparticular context and globaluniversal themes

seriously Contextual and global conversations enter an enriching and in-

forming relationship Tese two always have an active and symbiotic rela-

tionship Tis is true whether we deliberately put them into conversation or

not Te local shapes the global and the global shapes the local Many local

11David J Bosch Believing in the Future oward a Missiology o Western Culture (New York

rinity 1048625983097983097983093) 104862798309012izon ransormation Afer Lausanne 1048631-98309713Not all o these themes are dealt with in this present volume since either (1048625) I have dealt with them

in my book Salt Light and a City (983090) they are not all key themes in the writings o the thirty-five

Majority World thinkers considered in this volume or (1048627) there is not adequate space in a book

this size

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2636

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048627

voices converge to form global conversations and theologies Using the Phil-

ippines as a case study izon illustrates this by showing the interdepen-

dence between local and global themes in mission983089983092Dialogue between local and global conversations is critical Kōsuke

Koyama wrote an important book on contextual mission called Water Buffalo

Teology Koyama is a Japanese missionary who served in Chiang Mai

Tailand He writes of the joys and challenges of doing local particular water

buffalo theology He considers the relationship between local theology global

missional themes and transforming cultures ldquoWater Buffalo Teology sees

certain specific challenges Contextualization of theology implies two criticalmovements First to articulate Jesus Christ in culturally appropriate com-

municatively apt words and second to criticize reform dethrone or oppose

culture if it is found to be against what the name of Jesus Christ stands forrdquo9830891048629

Kōsuke Koyama challenges us to recognize what we bring to the task of

local theology For him it was doing theology in Tailand while being Jap-

anese We also need to notice the particular culture wersquore located in as we do

the work of theology Tis means we avoid speaking of an ldquoAsian theologyrdquoldquoAfrican theologyrdquo and the like We need to cultivate local theologies that

engage regional and global themes But these theologies must be ldquodistinctly

localrdquo and a ldquotheology from belowrdquo9830891048630

Simultaneously we need to pursue a reformation of theology and

practice ldquoin the global contextrdquo Tis means entering ldquothe disturbing spa-

ciousness of Jesus Christrdquo Jesus calls us to reject enmity and exceptionalism

We seem him present in our culture language stories and relationships

But we also choose to embrace the ldquootherrdquo We choose to see him present

in other culturesmdashshaping a global people to serve and worship him

joining in his mission983089983095

Kōsuke Koyama roots the gospel in the local contextual and particular

Tis is why he roots his water buffalo theology in Northern Tai culture He

is careful not to say ldquoHere is how you contextualize in your settingrdquo Instead

14izon ransormation Afer Lausanne 1048631-10486251048627 10486251048628983097-98309098308898309015Kōsuke Koyama Water Buffalo Teology 983090983093th anniversary ed (Maryknoll NY Orbis 1048625983097983097983097)

xiii-xv16Kōsuke Koyama ldquoTe Asian Approach to Christrdquo Missiology 1048625983090 no 1048628 (10486259830979830961048628) 10486281048627983093-104862798309617Kōsuke Koyama ldquoReormation in the Global Context Te Disturbing Spaciousness o Jesus Christrdquo

Currents in Teology and Mission 1048627983088 no 983090 (9830909830889830881048627) 10486251048625983097-983090983096

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2736

10486271048628 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

he tells us a story Itrsquos the story of how he contextualized theology in northern

Tailand while being open to global conversations Koyama asks us to form

our own local expressions of church mission and theology At the same timewe must stay attentive to what God is saying and doing beyond that context

Tis way local and global and particular and universal become mutually

enriching conversation partners

G983148983151983139983137983148983145983162983137983156983145983151983150 983137983150983140 H983145983155983156983151983154983145983139983137983148983148983161 S983145983148983141983150983139983141983140 V983151983145983139983141983155

Glocal theologies and conversations pay attention to voices that powers in-

stitutions religions and societies have silenced R S Sugirtharajah pushesback a little on izonrsquos ideas Sugirtharajah says that the church should

privilege local conversations He emphasizes the local contextual and post-

colonial reading of biblical texts9830891048632

Te church needs to listen Te church ought to be attentive to the

theologies and biblical interpretations of groups that cultures and reli-

gions have ignored Historically powerful secular and religious forces

have silenced these groups Tey have marginalized oppressed and colo-nized them It is time for the church to address this injustice We must

start listening to important but silenced voices We need to privilege the

voices of the former victims of Western colonialism We need to develop

postcolonial biblical interpretations theologies and expressions of church

and mission

How do we take such perspectives seriously as we develop glocal conver-

sations How do these themes help us foster vital relationships between local

and global voices

It is time for us to embrace values that enable conversations with those

oen ignored by the church We need values that help us learn from these

groups and individuals

Valuing equal partnership Colonizing powers oppressed silenced and

colonized certain groups At times the church was complicit Tese colo-

nized groups have become ldquoconfident indomitable and indispensable

partners in the dialogue and collaboration with the dispossessed and disad-

18R S Sugirtharajah Asian Biblical Hermeneutics and Postcolonialism Contesting the Interpreta-

tions Te Bible and Liberation Series (Maryknoll NY Orbis 1048625983097983097983096) 1048625983093-1048625983094

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2836

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048629

vantaged in the Westrdquo9830891048633 Tis calls for attentiveness to these voices and re-

sponsiveness to their prophetic challenges It also demands a critical evalu-

ation of colonial readings of Scripture Colonial models of theology andchurch and mission are no longer the benchmark Te global church must

examine them afresh

Valuing equal status Tose on the margins have now taken their rightful

place on the global stage Tey have claimed appropriate and equal status at

the table Subaltern readings of theology church and mission are invaluable

contributors to global theological conversations Tis means that we esteem

them But we also test themWhat do we mean by subaltern Subalterns are those who are down-

trodden and silenced (or have been treated this way in the past) Dominant

or colonizing groups treat them as invisible nonentities Tey enjoy limited

or no access to power Sometimes these are women certain tribal and ethnic

groups and those considered ldquountouchablerdquo In Voices from the Margin Su-

girtharajah provides a platform for postcolonial subaltern readings of

Scripture and theology Tese readings challenge colonialmdashoen Westernmdashreadings of Bible and theology and cultures Tey claim equal status with

other ways of doing theology10486261048624

Valuing equal identity People groups need freedom to explore their new

and emerging identities Tese emerge in response to local and global influ-

ences Local culture is not the only thing at work here Global forces also

shape identity as do imported practices ideas readings rituals and tech-

nologies But each group should be free to explore and construct their par-

ticular forms of Christian identity

Valuing equal interpretations ldquoPostcolonialism is concerned with the

question of cultural and discursive dominationrdquo Colonialism led to op-

pressive and controlling forms of culture and discourse Tese were usually

not contextual or indigenous Western powers for instance brought co-

lonial forms of theology church biblical interpretation and mission1048626983089

Postcolonialism calls for alternative ways of approaching these things Tose

19Ibid 104862598309420R S Sugirtharajah Voices rom the Margin Interpreting the Bible in the Tird World (Maryknoll

NY Orbis 10486259830979830971048625)21Sugirtharajah Asian Biblical Hermeneutics and Postcolonialism 10486251048631

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2936

10486271048630 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

who were once marginalized oppressed and silenced need to lead these fresh

approaches in their own settings Tese then influence global conversations

We need to support the new readings and insights and experiments from thesegroups o be genuine this support must be both critical and collegial

Valuing equal empowerment Sugirtharajah says that postcolonialism is

valuable when it empowers actual communities and real people Post-

colonial thought empowers when it addresses the difficulties hopes and

experiences of ordinary people It should never be about power plays and

the clever use of language Itrsquos pointless if itrsquos obsessed with forming newmdash

and ldquocolonizingrdquomdashtheories Itrsquos a waste of time if itrsquos a self-indulgent pursuitof new and hybrid identities Rather ldquothe worth and credibility of post-

colonial criticism will be judged by how it orchestrates the unique and

fragile and imagined claims of one community against anotherrdquo Empow-

erment happens in a variety of ways One way is contributing equally to

global conversations10486261048626

Al izon examines postcolonialism in the Philippines He says that it can

teach the global church a lot about healthy local-global conversations Fil-ipino contextual theology resists many Western forms of mission and the-

ology It finds them patronizing and controlling Tis indigenous theology

values prophetic sociopolitical engagement in institutions and the society

at large It emphasizes ministry to whole persons and communities It con-

structs a Filipino theology of beauty and mission and worship and com-

munity And it fosters indigenous theological approaches to the spirit world

and cosmology

izon says that postcolonial theology has played a constructive role in

the Philippines But he is uncomfortable with the label postcolonialism He

prefers to describe historical events as ldquobeyond colonialismrdquo And he says

that global conversations enrich local theologies and vice versa1048626983091

Postcolonial thought informs our understanding of the relationship be-

tween the local and global It also shows how theology can emerge at the

intersection between the localparticular and the globaluniversal It re-

minds us that worthwhile glocalization listens to all voices Tis includes

heeding those that have been historically silenced

22Ibid 983090104862823izon ransormation Afer Lausanne 1048625983088983090 10486259830941048631-9830961048631

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3036

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048631

G983148983151983139983137983148983145983162983137983156983145983151983150 983137983150983140 983156983144983141 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

C983151983150983139983148983157983140983145983150983143 R983141983142983148983141983139983156983145983151983150983155

How do we go about developing a model for glocal conversations izon hasrecently provided a useful model that is instructive as we seek to learn from

the Majority World It has at least two key features

First the local is in the global (globalization from below) Global theologies

and ideas have origins in many particular local contexts In that sense glo-

balization is from below Global ideas have local roots Ideas about integral

mission liberation theology and missional church have local origins Tey

have their roots in the prayers hopes discoveries mission and theologiesof thousands of local communities ldquoTe global does not cannot exist

without the localmdashbut the coming together of localities creates a global re-

ality that becomes greater than the sum of its parts it creates a gestalt entity

to which localities make themselves accountablerdquo1048626983092

Second the global is in the local (panlocalization from above) Te con-

cerns and voices of multitudes of locales form global conversations Tese

global discussions can provide a ldquopositive accountabilityrdquo back to local con-texts Tis is true when they enrich affirm serve guide and strengthen local

contexts It is also true when they avoid homogenization control impo-

sition and judgment Glocalization is best when it sees itself as interde-

pendent deeply connected with the local10486261048629

Tatrsquos a helpful starting point But we need to go further Besides izonrsquos

proposals Irsquom convinced that robust glocal conversations cultivate six core

practices

983089 Glocal theology practices its values We root glocal theology in core

values Tese values include solidarity understanding and mutual learning

Do we value fellowship with Christians of all cultures Do we value learning

from them

We prove our values through our practices What practices emerge out of

these values We need to collaborate act collectively and share information

We must find ways to foster grassroots perspectives and local theologies We

need to share stories and learnings and cultivate networks relationships and

partnerships We need attentiveness to local voices and global themes We

24Ibid 9830901048625983088-1048625104862825Ibid 98309010486251048628-1048625983096

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3136

10486271048632 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

ought to find ways to put these local and global voices into conversation

Mutual learning humility and solidarity are key Worthwhile glocal con-

versations can never be merely theoretical or academic It is up to us to rootour values in our practices

983090 Glocal theology practices humility (and it tells a new narrative) We

have noted that the local is in the global and the global is in the local Te

two are interdependent Tey form each other reciprocally Since this is the

case we must practice humility Tere is no place for ethnocentrism colo-

nialism or theological and cultural arrogance I have seen these unhealthy

postures far too oen in Western settingsRecently I attended a missional leadership conference On that occasion

the keynote speakermdasha leading missional author and speakermdashsaid that

North American missional conversations and innovations hold the key to

the future of the Western church Tis Euro American view is wrong (Irsquom

being kind o be frank itrsquos complete nonsense) Itrsquos arrogant and Euro

Americanndashcentric And itrsquos completely out of step with what is happening in

the glocal church We need a new narrativeIn June 1048626104862410486251048627 Te Center for the Study of Global Christianity reported

the top 10486261048624 countries where Christianity has the highest percentage growth

rate Nineteen of the top twenty are in Asia and Africa Eleven of them are

in Muslim majority countries Not a single country from Europe or North

America makes the top twenty list10486261048630

Itrsquos time to cultivate a new narrative Te future of the church is emerging

from the Majority World Rather than North America the churches of

Eastern Asia Western Africa the Arabian Peninsula and other parts of the

Majority World reveal the future of the global church We need the contribu-

tions of all contexts Western indigenous and Majority World All con-

tribute to glocal conversations All are important as we learn from each

other about mission theology and faith But letrsquos stop pretending that North

Americans and Europeans will reveal the future of the global church Letrsquos

start listening to what God is saying about the future of the global church

And hersquos speaking to us through the churches of Asia Africa Latin America

26Russ Mitchell ldquoTe op 983090983088 Countries Where Christianity Is Growing the Fastestrdquo Disciple All

Nations (blog) August 983090983093 98309098308810486251048627 httpsdiscipleallnationswordpresscom98309098308810486251048627983088983096983090983093the-top

-983090983088-countries-where-christianity-is-growing-the-astest

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3236

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048633

Muslim majority settings and so on We must cultivate a new glocal nar-

rativemdashone soaked in humility

Glocal theology must be humble theology Meek theology Receptive the-ology Discerning theology Prayerful theology Dialogical theology De-

pendent theology A theology that celebrates the interdependence between

the localparticular and the globaluniversal

983091 Glocal theology practices expansiveness Glocalization is by nature

comprehensive Local and global influences permeate much of our lives Tese

glocal forces shape our theologies and churches whether we like it or not

But intentionality is also important We need to commit to an expansiveapproach to glocal theology How do we deliberately cultivate glocal conver-

sations in our biblical interpretation Do we foster them in our under-

standing of the person and work of Christ How does glocalization shape

the way the Spirit empowers and constitutes the church How can it form

our understanding of the nature and mission of the rinity How does it

influence the way we practice fellowship and conversation across denomi-

national cultural ethnic economic sociocultural political gender andtheological divides How might it shape our theologies of mission com-

munity beauty spirituality suffering discipleship hospitality eco-justice

place education social ethics Christian leadership and so forth

983092 Glocal theology practices attention Glocal theology doesnrsquot need to

accept all the assumptions or assertions of postcolonial or Majority World

thought But it does need to engage with them and take them seriously

Postcolonial theology for instance gives the marginalized and colonized

and forgotten and silenced both dignity and voice Our glocal conversations

must also include and esteem these groups We need to be attentive to

others weak and powerful female and male dominant and downtrodden

old and young rich and poor privileged and marginalized influential and

subaltern educated and illiterate We need to practice the art of attention

being especially attentive to those who are different to us

983093 Glocal theology practices embrace What do colonial ethnocentric or

Western-centric perspectives do Tey silence Tey control Tey com-

modify Tey institutionalize Tey colonize Tey domesticate Tey replace

Tey import Tey exclude Tey do these things to the beliefs experiences

and practices of other cultures A worthwhile glocal theology refuses to do

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3336

10486281048624 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

these things Instead it adopts a responsive humble celebratory open in-

clusive and embracing attitude

983094 Glocal theology practices discernment Finally we need discernmentas we engage these ideas and practices Discernment is a huge topic thatrsquos

hard to cover comprehensively in a few words Discernment happens when

the Spirit of Christ and his Word renew our minds Te Spirit grants us

spiritual wisdom as we meditate on him and his Word and as we practice

discipleship to Jesus Christ Romans 10486251048626 provides guidance we need (1048625) to be

transformed by the renewal of our minds (1048626) to serve Christrsquos body and (1048627)

to put love into action Discernment also happens in conversation both lo-cally and glocally

I pray these core values and six practices come across in the following

chapters of GlobalChurch

Glocalization can never be just theoretical Are we committed to moving

glocalization from an abstract idea to a living communion Are we deter-

mined to construct a missional theology of the church in the context of

glocal conversations Tis must involve dialogue between Majority Worldindigenous and Western scholars activists and groups

Will glocalization be an abstract notion Or will it be a formative and

genuine communion between local regional and global voices Glocal dy-

namics are at play whether we like it or not Teyrsquore in our churches the-

ologies and missions But we can choose to relinquish isolationist colonial

parochial and arrogant approaches Instead we can adopt responsive dia-

logical learning humble and embracing postures

Trough healthy approaches to glocalization the Spirit challenges us to

value local contexts We immerse ourselves in local and particular commu-

nities and conversations He inspires us to open ourselves to global theo-

logical conversations He rouses us to value the symbiotic relationship be-

tween the localparticular and the globaluniversal

Trough glocal relationships the Spirit leads us to put local contextual

theologies into conversation with global ones He prompts us to explore the

ways in which the local is in the glocal and the global is in the local He per-

suades us to pursue collaboration and dialogue and mutual learning We

engage with Christians from different backgrounds and cultures ecumen-

icals Pentecostals evangelicals and so on from Western indigenous and

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3436

Glocalizing Conversations 10486281048625

Majority World contexts He motivates us to express solidarity between all

parties We appreciate our unity in diversity

Trough glocal conversations the Spirit moves us to ensure that unity andsolidarity emerge from a compelling vision of Jesusrsquo kingdom and gospel

and person He challenges us to share information theology and practices

He urges us to learn from each othermdashour successes and mistakes We seek

glocal solutions

Te Spirit calls us to develop glocal conversations about Christian ideas

and practices Tese include Scripture Evangelicalism ecumenism Pente-

costalism Jesus Christ the Holy Spirit God the Father the rinity com-munity spirituality discipleship liturgy worship hospitality prayer eco-

justice education social ethics Christian leadership gospel and culture

beauty place suffering liberation and so forth

Finally through glocal conversations the Spirit leads us to adopt a new

posture Tis is a responsive humble celebratory open inclusive and em-

bracing attitude to the ldquootherrdquo We do this as a new people made up of every

tribe and language and people and nationTere are dangers in glocalization Sugirtharajah warns of the commodi-

fication of local contextual practices and theologies When this happens

they are ldquosmoothed out of their primary contexts concerns and contesta-

tions travel across borders and become objects of analysis and scrutiny

within an alien secondary contextrdquo1048626983095

Itrsquos common for those of us who are Western to make mistakes when we

wrestle with Majority World and indigenous ideas Sugirtharajah mentions

our tendency to commodify reduce and institutionalize these ideas We also

risk doing these things (1048625) We apply them in noncontextual prescriptive ways

(1048626) We ignore their meanings in their original setting (1048627) We glamorize or

idealize their proponents or their contexts (1048628) We demonize those persons or

contexts (1048629) We disregard them as irrelevant rhetorical or minority discourse

Kevin J Vanhoozer says that we can fall into three traps when we glo-

calize theology (1048625) We can underestimate the theological significance of

local cultures (1048626) We can homogenize cultures and theologies exaggerating

27R S Sugirtharajah ldquoextual ake-Aways Tird World exts in Western Metropolitan Centresrdquo

Black Teology in Britain A Journal o Contextual Praxis 983090 (1048625983097983097983097) 10486271048627 10486271048631 Edward W Said Te

World the ext and the Critic (Cambridge MA Harvard University Press 10486259830979830961048627) 9830901048627983097

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3536

10486281048626 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

ldquothe onerdquo (1048627) We can overemphasize cultural particularity exaggerating ldquothe

manyrdquo and pursue ldquotheological ethnificationrdquo10486261048632

My hope is that GlobalChurch does not fall into the traps Sugirtharajahand Vanhoozer describe I hope that what unfolds in the following chapters

is respectful and discerning I hope it leads to further mutually enriching

conversations between people of different cultures

You the reader face the same challenges You face them in your personal

life ministry context and missional engagements

Will you treat the themes in this book as abstract theoretical notions

Will this be a temporary infatuation a flirtation with the ldquootherrdquo that dissi-pates as suddenly as it arrived Or will glocal conversations become an en-

riching and formative orientation in your life Will glocal conversations

bring fresh approaches to theology faith mission church and worship Will

conversations with other cultures and theologies become for you a com-

pelling way of life

My prayer is that glocal conversations will help the church be a global

visible alternative ldquocity set upon a hillrdquo a truly GlobalChurch

28Craig Ott and Harold A Netland Globalizing Teology Belie and Practice in an Era o World

Christianity (Grand Rapids Baker Academic 983090983088983088983094) 1048625983090983093

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3636

Page 22: GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2236

Glocalizing Conversations 10486261048633

social settings Conversely we learn from the interpretations and readings

of other groups

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our local- global theology of Scripture and biblical interpretation

Evangelicalism Pentecostalism missional movements and so forth I

have charismatic missional and evangelical convictions Glocal conversa-

tions help me understand and practice these convictions better

I will use evangelicalism as an example Michael Horton says that our

beliefs and practices are evangelical when they are ldquocommitted to the suffi-

ciency of Scripture the priesthood of all believers the total lostness ofhumans the sole mediation of Christ the gracious efficacy and finality of

Godrsquos redemptive work in Christ through election propitiation calling and

keeping Te linchpin for all of this was the doctrine of justification by grace

alone through faith alone because of Christ alonerdquo9830891048624

Such convictions are necessary if we are to be faithful to the gospel and

to a biblical vision of church and mission Te gospel defines Godrsquos purposes

for humanity the church and the universe Te triune God controls thechurch He is its Lord and Savior Sanctifier and Liberator Master and King

He is completely sovereign over its nature affairs mission and history God

is the churchrsquos only source of grace election atonement salvation and per-

severance Te churchrsquos justification and hope are by grace alone through

faith alone by Christ alone

Herersquos the challenge I face My understanding of evangelicalism is

Western I am a product of the Western theological tradition and my Western

evangelical heritage Much of this is wonderful But I need indigenous and

Majority World evangelicals and others to help me expand and reshape

these insights Te same would be true if I were a Pentecostal

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of our theological traditions and convictions

Jesus Christ We must center our theology on Jesus Christ the Lord of

the church Te church needs to reflect on the person and work of Christ

and respond to him Tis means gathering and going in the name and power

of Christ It means allowing Christrsquos Spirit to shape our community and

10Michael Horton ldquoEvangelical Arminiansrdquo Modern Reormation 1048625 no 1048627 (1048625983097983097983090) 10486251048631

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2336

10486271048624 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

identity and mission It means developing our Christology ecclesiology and

missiology concurrently Te early church developed these three areas and

more in a concurrent and integrated way Tere was no linear progressionTe same is true in the contemporary global church

How can the glocal church best explore its nature structure mission and

hope Trough the centrality and the lordship of Christ

Majority World and indigenous Christians help us appreciate Jesus and

his mission afresh Tey show us how Jesus identifies with the marginalized

outcast oppressed rejected and broken He prefers them We find him

among ldquothe least of theserdquoGlocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of who Jesus Christ is How does it help us appreciate him better

What has Jesus done for and in his church and his world What does he care

about What individual and corporate responsibilities has he given us How

do we express these at local regional and global levels

Te Spirit Missional ecclesiology is inadequate without pneumatological

foundations In other words our theology of church and Spirit go togetherTe Spirit creates and animates the church He empowers it to witness to

Jesus and his gospel Te Spirit enables the church to be a missional trans-

formational community He shapes the church into an alternative society

embodying the reign of God Te church exists for the glory and mission of

Christ Te power and presence of the Spirit enables this mission worship

and glorification

Te Spirit pours out gis on the local-global church ldquofor the common

goodrdquo and ldquoto equip his people for works of service so that the body of Christ

may be built uprdquo Tis includes but isnrsquot limited to the ministry gis mani-

festation gis and motivational gis (1048625 Cor 104862510486261048631 Eph 104862810486251048625-10486251048626 Rom 104862510486261048630-1048632)

Te Spirit forms the glocal church He empowers it for service and

witness He fills it with Christrsquos empowering presence He leads it into the

missio Deimdashthe mission of the Father Son and Holy Spirit

Recently Pentecostal and renewalist movements have grown dramati-

cally in the Majority World Tey have increased in status size and influence

Many have matured theologically Te churches of the West must take notice

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of the power and presence of the Spirit

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2436

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048625

Te rinity Tere are clear limitations to the analogy between the

church and the rinity Te church can only image the rinity Yet the

church is at its best when it reflects the relational and missional passionof the rinity

What is the source and inspiration of the churchrsquos local-global mission

Ultimately it is the missional nature passion and actions of the Father Son

and Holy Spirit Godrsquos nature is missional His passion is infectious His

actions are historical redemptive and eternal Te rinity invites the

church into a sending community Te Father sends the Son Te Father

and Son send the Spirit Finally the rinity sends the church in missioninto the world

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of the rinity How does it enable our participation in the mission

and community of the triune God

Association and dialogue Tese need to happen across denominational

cultural ethnic gender and theological traditions and divides Authentic

dialogue is indispensable to the health and mission of the church What dothose marginal to the life of the church have to say to us What do ldquoothersrdquo

have to teach us Other ethnicities and cultures Other socioeconomic

groups Other ages and genders Other theological and confessing tradi-

tions Other persons from times long gone

We need to listen Share Be vulnerable Be authentic Open up to crit-

icism correction and change

We need more than dialogue We need communion and association It is

possible in a qualified way to say that God is present in all the various forms

of the church (ie the various theological ecclesiological sociocultural his-

torical and other permutations of the church) We discern this presence

through attention to Scripture history tradition culture and the Spirit Dis-

cernment involves critical dialogue theological exchange biblical study and

real relationship Only the Spirit of Jesus can enable this

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of association and dialogue

Mission and the missio Dei Te church is missional at its core It serves

obeys and images a missionary God David Bosch says ldquoTe churchrsquos mission

is not secondary to its being the church exists in being sent and in building up

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2536

10486271048626 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

itself for its missionrdquo He goes on to say ldquoEcclesiology does not precede missi-

ology there cannot be church without an intrinsic missionary dimensionrdquo983089983089

Jesus is Lord Lord of his church and Lord of his world His mission de-termines and forms the church His mission shapes the nature purposes

structures ministries and activities of his church Majority World and in-

digenous thinkers help us understand the implications of this mission Tey

help us form glocal theologies of mission Tey reveal ldquomission in context

as transformationrdquo9830891048626

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of mission and the missio Dei Church theology and practice Glocal conversations can inform and

enrich many aspects of the church (when practiced well) Teologies and

practices benefit from robust and critical glocal conversations Tese con-

versations enrich many areas (community spirituality discipleship liturgy

worship hospitality eco-justice education social ethics servantship lib-

eration place suffering beauty and so on)

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-standing of these many dimensions of church and mission

Glocal processes shape these eight themes and their practices We need

to facilitate and enable these conversations and processes Tis is urgent It

must be a priority No theology of mission or missional ecclesiology is ad-

equate without glocal conversations983089983091

T983144983141 L983151983139983137983148 983137983150983140 G983148983151983138983137983148 E983150983154983145983139983144 E983137983139983144 O983156983144983141983154

Glocalization takes the localparticular context and globaluniversal themes

seriously Contextual and global conversations enter an enriching and in-

forming relationship Tese two always have an active and symbiotic rela-

tionship Tis is true whether we deliberately put them into conversation or

not Te local shapes the global and the global shapes the local Many local

11David J Bosch Believing in the Future oward a Missiology o Western Culture (New York

rinity 1048625983097983097983093) 104862798309012izon ransormation Afer Lausanne 1048631-98309713Not all o these themes are dealt with in this present volume since either (1048625) I have dealt with them

in my book Salt Light and a City (983090) they are not all key themes in the writings o the thirty-five

Majority World thinkers considered in this volume or (1048627) there is not adequate space in a book

this size

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2636

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048627

voices converge to form global conversations and theologies Using the Phil-

ippines as a case study izon illustrates this by showing the interdepen-

dence between local and global themes in mission983089983092Dialogue between local and global conversations is critical Kōsuke

Koyama wrote an important book on contextual mission called Water Buffalo

Teology Koyama is a Japanese missionary who served in Chiang Mai

Tailand He writes of the joys and challenges of doing local particular water

buffalo theology He considers the relationship between local theology global

missional themes and transforming cultures ldquoWater Buffalo Teology sees

certain specific challenges Contextualization of theology implies two criticalmovements First to articulate Jesus Christ in culturally appropriate com-

municatively apt words and second to criticize reform dethrone or oppose

culture if it is found to be against what the name of Jesus Christ stands forrdquo9830891048629

Kōsuke Koyama challenges us to recognize what we bring to the task of

local theology For him it was doing theology in Tailand while being Jap-

anese We also need to notice the particular culture wersquore located in as we do

the work of theology Tis means we avoid speaking of an ldquoAsian theologyrdquoldquoAfrican theologyrdquo and the like We need to cultivate local theologies that

engage regional and global themes But these theologies must be ldquodistinctly

localrdquo and a ldquotheology from belowrdquo9830891048630

Simultaneously we need to pursue a reformation of theology and

practice ldquoin the global contextrdquo Tis means entering ldquothe disturbing spa-

ciousness of Jesus Christrdquo Jesus calls us to reject enmity and exceptionalism

We seem him present in our culture language stories and relationships

But we also choose to embrace the ldquootherrdquo We choose to see him present

in other culturesmdashshaping a global people to serve and worship him

joining in his mission983089983095

Kōsuke Koyama roots the gospel in the local contextual and particular

Tis is why he roots his water buffalo theology in Northern Tai culture He

is careful not to say ldquoHere is how you contextualize in your settingrdquo Instead

14izon ransormation Afer Lausanne 1048631-10486251048627 10486251048628983097-98309098308898309015Kōsuke Koyama Water Buffalo Teology 983090983093th anniversary ed (Maryknoll NY Orbis 1048625983097983097983097)

xiii-xv16Kōsuke Koyama ldquoTe Asian Approach to Christrdquo Missiology 1048625983090 no 1048628 (10486259830979830961048628) 10486281048627983093-104862798309617Kōsuke Koyama ldquoReormation in the Global Context Te Disturbing Spaciousness o Jesus Christrdquo

Currents in Teology and Mission 1048627983088 no 983090 (9830909830889830881048627) 10486251048625983097-983090983096

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2736

10486271048628 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

he tells us a story Itrsquos the story of how he contextualized theology in northern

Tailand while being open to global conversations Koyama asks us to form

our own local expressions of church mission and theology At the same timewe must stay attentive to what God is saying and doing beyond that context

Tis way local and global and particular and universal become mutually

enriching conversation partners

G983148983151983139983137983148983145983162983137983156983145983151983150 983137983150983140 H983145983155983156983151983154983145983139983137983148983148983161 S983145983148983141983150983139983141983140 V983151983145983139983141983155

Glocal theologies and conversations pay attention to voices that powers in-

stitutions religions and societies have silenced R S Sugirtharajah pushesback a little on izonrsquos ideas Sugirtharajah says that the church should

privilege local conversations He emphasizes the local contextual and post-

colonial reading of biblical texts9830891048632

Te church needs to listen Te church ought to be attentive to the

theologies and biblical interpretations of groups that cultures and reli-

gions have ignored Historically powerful secular and religious forces

have silenced these groups Tey have marginalized oppressed and colo-nized them It is time for the church to address this injustice We must

start listening to important but silenced voices We need to privilege the

voices of the former victims of Western colonialism We need to develop

postcolonial biblical interpretations theologies and expressions of church

and mission

How do we take such perspectives seriously as we develop glocal conver-

sations How do these themes help us foster vital relationships between local

and global voices

It is time for us to embrace values that enable conversations with those

oen ignored by the church We need values that help us learn from these

groups and individuals

Valuing equal partnership Colonizing powers oppressed silenced and

colonized certain groups At times the church was complicit Tese colo-

nized groups have become ldquoconfident indomitable and indispensable

partners in the dialogue and collaboration with the dispossessed and disad-

18R S Sugirtharajah Asian Biblical Hermeneutics and Postcolonialism Contesting the Interpreta-

tions Te Bible and Liberation Series (Maryknoll NY Orbis 1048625983097983097983096) 1048625983093-1048625983094

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2836

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048629

vantaged in the Westrdquo9830891048633 Tis calls for attentiveness to these voices and re-

sponsiveness to their prophetic challenges It also demands a critical evalu-

ation of colonial readings of Scripture Colonial models of theology andchurch and mission are no longer the benchmark Te global church must

examine them afresh

Valuing equal status Tose on the margins have now taken their rightful

place on the global stage Tey have claimed appropriate and equal status at

the table Subaltern readings of theology church and mission are invaluable

contributors to global theological conversations Tis means that we esteem

them But we also test themWhat do we mean by subaltern Subalterns are those who are down-

trodden and silenced (or have been treated this way in the past) Dominant

or colonizing groups treat them as invisible nonentities Tey enjoy limited

or no access to power Sometimes these are women certain tribal and ethnic

groups and those considered ldquountouchablerdquo In Voices from the Margin Su-

girtharajah provides a platform for postcolonial subaltern readings of

Scripture and theology Tese readings challenge colonialmdashoen Westernmdashreadings of Bible and theology and cultures Tey claim equal status with

other ways of doing theology10486261048624

Valuing equal identity People groups need freedom to explore their new

and emerging identities Tese emerge in response to local and global influ-

ences Local culture is not the only thing at work here Global forces also

shape identity as do imported practices ideas readings rituals and tech-

nologies But each group should be free to explore and construct their par-

ticular forms of Christian identity

Valuing equal interpretations ldquoPostcolonialism is concerned with the

question of cultural and discursive dominationrdquo Colonialism led to op-

pressive and controlling forms of culture and discourse Tese were usually

not contextual or indigenous Western powers for instance brought co-

lonial forms of theology church biblical interpretation and mission1048626983089

Postcolonialism calls for alternative ways of approaching these things Tose

19Ibid 104862598309420R S Sugirtharajah Voices rom the Margin Interpreting the Bible in the Tird World (Maryknoll

NY Orbis 10486259830979830971048625)21Sugirtharajah Asian Biblical Hermeneutics and Postcolonialism 10486251048631

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2936

10486271048630 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

who were once marginalized oppressed and silenced need to lead these fresh

approaches in their own settings Tese then influence global conversations

We need to support the new readings and insights and experiments from thesegroups o be genuine this support must be both critical and collegial

Valuing equal empowerment Sugirtharajah says that postcolonialism is

valuable when it empowers actual communities and real people Post-

colonial thought empowers when it addresses the difficulties hopes and

experiences of ordinary people It should never be about power plays and

the clever use of language Itrsquos pointless if itrsquos obsessed with forming newmdash

and ldquocolonizingrdquomdashtheories Itrsquos a waste of time if itrsquos a self-indulgent pursuitof new and hybrid identities Rather ldquothe worth and credibility of post-

colonial criticism will be judged by how it orchestrates the unique and

fragile and imagined claims of one community against anotherrdquo Empow-

erment happens in a variety of ways One way is contributing equally to

global conversations10486261048626

Al izon examines postcolonialism in the Philippines He says that it can

teach the global church a lot about healthy local-global conversations Fil-ipino contextual theology resists many Western forms of mission and the-

ology It finds them patronizing and controlling Tis indigenous theology

values prophetic sociopolitical engagement in institutions and the society

at large It emphasizes ministry to whole persons and communities It con-

structs a Filipino theology of beauty and mission and worship and com-

munity And it fosters indigenous theological approaches to the spirit world

and cosmology

izon says that postcolonial theology has played a constructive role in

the Philippines But he is uncomfortable with the label postcolonialism He

prefers to describe historical events as ldquobeyond colonialismrdquo And he says

that global conversations enrich local theologies and vice versa1048626983091

Postcolonial thought informs our understanding of the relationship be-

tween the local and global It also shows how theology can emerge at the

intersection between the localparticular and the globaluniversal It re-

minds us that worthwhile glocalization listens to all voices Tis includes

heeding those that have been historically silenced

22Ibid 983090104862823izon ransormation Afer Lausanne 1048625983088983090 10486259830941048631-9830961048631

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3036

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048631

G983148983151983139983137983148983145983162983137983156983145983151983150 983137983150983140 983156983144983141 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

C983151983150983139983148983157983140983145983150983143 R983141983142983148983141983139983156983145983151983150983155

How do we go about developing a model for glocal conversations izon hasrecently provided a useful model that is instructive as we seek to learn from

the Majority World It has at least two key features

First the local is in the global (globalization from below) Global theologies

and ideas have origins in many particular local contexts In that sense glo-

balization is from below Global ideas have local roots Ideas about integral

mission liberation theology and missional church have local origins Tey

have their roots in the prayers hopes discoveries mission and theologiesof thousands of local communities ldquoTe global does not cannot exist

without the localmdashbut the coming together of localities creates a global re-

ality that becomes greater than the sum of its parts it creates a gestalt entity

to which localities make themselves accountablerdquo1048626983092

Second the global is in the local (panlocalization from above) Te con-

cerns and voices of multitudes of locales form global conversations Tese

global discussions can provide a ldquopositive accountabilityrdquo back to local con-texts Tis is true when they enrich affirm serve guide and strengthen local

contexts It is also true when they avoid homogenization control impo-

sition and judgment Glocalization is best when it sees itself as interde-

pendent deeply connected with the local10486261048629

Tatrsquos a helpful starting point But we need to go further Besides izonrsquos

proposals Irsquom convinced that robust glocal conversations cultivate six core

practices

983089 Glocal theology practices its values We root glocal theology in core

values Tese values include solidarity understanding and mutual learning

Do we value fellowship with Christians of all cultures Do we value learning

from them

We prove our values through our practices What practices emerge out of

these values We need to collaborate act collectively and share information

We must find ways to foster grassroots perspectives and local theologies We

need to share stories and learnings and cultivate networks relationships and

partnerships We need attentiveness to local voices and global themes We

24Ibid 9830901048625983088-1048625104862825Ibid 98309010486251048628-1048625983096

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3136

10486271048632 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

ought to find ways to put these local and global voices into conversation

Mutual learning humility and solidarity are key Worthwhile glocal con-

versations can never be merely theoretical or academic It is up to us to rootour values in our practices

983090 Glocal theology practices humility (and it tells a new narrative) We

have noted that the local is in the global and the global is in the local Te

two are interdependent Tey form each other reciprocally Since this is the

case we must practice humility Tere is no place for ethnocentrism colo-

nialism or theological and cultural arrogance I have seen these unhealthy

postures far too oen in Western settingsRecently I attended a missional leadership conference On that occasion

the keynote speakermdasha leading missional author and speakermdashsaid that

North American missional conversations and innovations hold the key to

the future of the Western church Tis Euro American view is wrong (Irsquom

being kind o be frank itrsquos complete nonsense) Itrsquos arrogant and Euro

Americanndashcentric And itrsquos completely out of step with what is happening in

the glocal church We need a new narrativeIn June 1048626104862410486251048627 Te Center for the Study of Global Christianity reported

the top 10486261048624 countries where Christianity has the highest percentage growth

rate Nineteen of the top twenty are in Asia and Africa Eleven of them are

in Muslim majority countries Not a single country from Europe or North

America makes the top twenty list10486261048630

Itrsquos time to cultivate a new narrative Te future of the church is emerging

from the Majority World Rather than North America the churches of

Eastern Asia Western Africa the Arabian Peninsula and other parts of the

Majority World reveal the future of the global church We need the contribu-

tions of all contexts Western indigenous and Majority World All con-

tribute to glocal conversations All are important as we learn from each

other about mission theology and faith But letrsquos stop pretending that North

Americans and Europeans will reveal the future of the global church Letrsquos

start listening to what God is saying about the future of the global church

And hersquos speaking to us through the churches of Asia Africa Latin America

26Russ Mitchell ldquoTe op 983090983088 Countries Where Christianity Is Growing the Fastestrdquo Disciple All

Nations (blog) August 983090983093 98309098308810486251048627 httpsdiscipleallnationswordpresscom98309098308810486251048627983088983096983090983093the-top

-983090983088-countries-where-christianity-is-growing-the-astest

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3236

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048633

Muslim majority settings and so on We must cultivate a new glocal nar-

rativemdashone soaked in humility

Glocal theology must be humble theology Meek theology Receptive the-ology Discerning theology Prayerful theology Dialogical theology De-

pendent theology A theology that celebrates the interdependence between

the localparticular and the globaluniversal

983091 Glocal theology practices expansiveness Glocalization is by nature

comprehensive Local and global influences permeate much of our lives Tese

glocal forces shape our theologies and churches whether we like it or not

But intentionality is also important We need to commit to an expansiveapproach to glocal theology How do we deliberately cultivate glocal conver-

sations in our biblical interpretation Do we foster them in our under-

standing of the person and work of Christ How does glocalization shape

the way the Spirit empowers and constitutes the church How can it form

our understanding of the nature and mission of the rinity How does it

influence the way we practice fellowship and conversation across denomi-

national cultural ethnic economic sociocultural political gender andtheological divides How might it shape our theologies of mission com-

munity beauty spirituality suffering discipleship hospitality eco-justice

place education social ethics Christian leadership and so forth

983092 Glocal theology practices attention Glocal theology doesnrsquot need to

accept all the assumptions or assertions of postcolonial or Majority World

thought But it does need to engage with them and take them seriously

Postcolonial theology for instance gives the marginalized and colonized

and forgotten and silenced both dignity and voice Our glocal conversations

must also include and esteem these groups We need to be attentive to

others weak and powerful female and male dominant and downtrodden

old and young rich and poor privileged and marginalized influential and

subaltern educated and illiterate We need to practice the art of attention

being especially attentive to those who are different to us

983093 Glocal theology practices embrace What do colonial ethnocentric or

Western-centric perspectives do Tey silence Tey control Tey com-

modify Tey institutionalize Tey colonize Tey domesticate Tey replace

Tey import Tey exclude Tey do these things to the beliefs experiences

and practices of other cultures A worthwhile glocal theology refuses to do

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3336

10486281048624 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

these things Instead it adopts a responsive humble celebratory open in-

clusive and embracing attitude

983094 Glocal theology practices discernment Finally we need discernmentas we engage these ideas and practices Discernment is a huge topic thatrsquos

hard to cover comprehensively in a few words Discernment happens when

the Spirit of Christ and his Word renew our minds Te Spirit grants us

spiritual wisdom as we meditate on him and his Word and as we practice

discipleship to Jesus Christ Romans 10486251048626 provides guidance we need (1048625) to be

transformed by the renewal of our minds (1048626) to serve Christrsquos body and (1048627)

to put love into action Discernment also happens in conversation both lo-cally and glocally

I pray these core values and six practices come across in the following

chapters of GlobalChurch

Glocalization can never be just theoretical Are we committed to moving

glocalization from an abstract idea to a living communion Are we deter-

mined to construct a missional theology of the church in the context of

glocal conversations Tis must involve dialogue between Majority Worldindigenous and Western scholars activists and groups

Will glocalization be an abstract notion Or will it be a formative and

genuine communion between local regional and global voices Glocal dy-

namics are at play whether we like it or not Teyrsquore in our churches the-

ologies and missions But we can choose to relinquish isolationist colonial

parochial and arrogant approaches Instead we can adopt responsive dia-

logical learning humble and embracing postures

Trough healthy approaches to glocalization the Spirit challenges us to

value local contexts We immerse ourselves in local and particular commu-

nities and conversations He inspires us to open ourselves to global theo-

logical conversations He rouses us to value the symbiotic relationship be-

tween the localparticular and the globaluniversal

Trough glocal relationships the Spirit leads us to put local contextual

theologies into conversation with global ones He prompts us to explore the

ways in which the local is in the glocal and the global is in the local He per-

suades us to pursue collaboration and dialogue and mutual learning We

engage with Christians from different backgrounds and cultures ecumen-

icals Pentecostals evangelicals and so on from Western indigenous and

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3436

Glocalizing Conversations 10486281048625

Majority World contexts He motivates us to express solidarity between all

parties We appreciate our unity in diversity

Trough glocal conversations the Spirit moves us to ensure that unity andsolidarity emerge from a compelling vision of Jesusrsquo kingdom and gospel

and person He challenges us to share information theology and practices

He urges us to learn from each othermdashour successes and mistakes We seek

glocal solutions

Te Spirit calls us to develop glocal conversations about Christian ideas

and practices Tese include Scripture Evangelicalism ecumenism Pente-

costalism Jesus Christ the Holy Spirit God the Father the rinity com-munity spirituality discipleship liturgy worship hospitality prayer eco-

justice education social ethics Christian leadership gospel and culture

beauty place suffering liberation and so forth

Finally through glocal conversations the Spirit leads us to adopt a new

posture Tis is a responsive humble celebratory open inclusive and em-

bracing attitude to the ldquootherrdquo We do this as a new people made up of every

tribe and language and people and nationTere are dangers in glocalization Sugirtharajah warns of the commodi-

fication of local contextual practices and theologies When this happens

they are ldquosmoothed out of their primary contexts concerns and contesta-

tions travel across borders and become objects of analysis and scrutiny

within an alien secondary contextrdquo1048626983095

Itrsquos common for those of us who are Western to make mistakes when we

wrestle with Majority World and indigenous ideas Sugirtharajah mentions

our tendency to commodify reduce and institutionalize these ideas We also

risk doing these things (1048625) We apply them in noncontextual prescriptive ways

(1048626) We ignore their meanings in their original setting (1048627) We glamorize or

idealize their proponents or their contexts (1048628) We demonize those persons or

contexts (1048629) We disregard them as irrelevant rhetorical or minority discourse

Kevin J Vanhoozer says that we can fall into three traps when we glo-

calize theology (1048625) We can underestimate the theological significance of

local cultures (1048626) We can homogenize cultures and theologies exaggerating

27R S Sugirtharajah ldquoextual ake-Aways Tird World exts in Western Metropolitan Centresrdquo

Black Teology in Britain A Journal o Contextual Praxis 983090 (1048625983097983097983097) 10486271048627 10486271048631 Edward W Said Te

World the ext and the Critic (Cambridge MA Harvard University Press 10486259830979830961048627) 9830901048627983097

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3536

10486281048626 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

ldquothe onerdquo (1048627) We can overemphasize cultural particularity exaggerating ldquothe

manyrdquo and pursue ldquotheological ethnificationrdquo10486261048632

My hope is that GlobalChurch does not fall into the traps Sugirtharajahand Vanhoozer describe I hope that what unfolds in the following chapters

is respectful and discerning I hope it leads to further mutually enriching

conversations between people of different cultures

You the reader face the same challenges You face them in your personal

life ministry context and missional engagements

Will you treat the themes in this book as abstract theoretical notions

Will this be a temporary infatuation a flirtation with the ldquootherrdquo that dissi-pates as suddenly as it arrived Or will glocal conversations become an en-

riching and formative orientation in your life Will glocal conversations

bring fresh approaches to theology faith mission church and worship Will

conversations with other cultures and theologies become for you a com-

pelling way of life

My prayer is that glocal conversations will help the church be a global

visible alternative ldquocity set upon a hillrdquo a truly GlobalChurch

28Craig Ott and Harold A Netland Globalizing Teology Belie and Practice in an Era o World

Christianity (Grand Rapids Baker Academic 983090983088983088983094) 1048625983090983093

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3636

Page 23: GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2336

10486271048624 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

identity and mission It means developing our Christology ecclesiology and

missiology concurrently Te early church developed these three areas and

more in a concurrent and integrated way Tere was no linear progressionTe same is true in the contemporary global church

How can the glocal church best explore its nature structure mission and

hope Trough the centrality and the lordship of Christ

Majority World and indigenous Christians help us appreciate Jesus and

his mission afresh Tey show us how Jesus identifies with the marginalized

outcast oppressed rejected and broken He prefers them We find him

among ldquothe least of theserdquoGlocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of who Jesus Christ is How does it help us appreciate him better

What has Jesus done for and in his church and his world What does he care

about What individual and corporate responsibilities has he given us How

do we express these at local regional and global levels

Te Spirit Missional ecclesiology is inadequate without pneumatological

foundations In other words our theology of church and Spirit go togetherTe Spirit creates and animates the church He empowers it to witness to

Jesus and his gospel Te Spirit enables the church to be a missional trans-

formational community He shapes the church into an alternative society

embodying the reign of God Te church exists for the glory and mission of

Christ Te power and presence of the Spirit enables this mission worship

and glorification

Te Spirit pours out gis on the local-global church ldquofor the common

goodrdquo and ldquoto equip his people for works of service so that the body of Christ

may be built uprdquo Tis includes but isnrsquot limited to the ministry gis mani-

festation gis and motivational gis (1048625 Cor 104862510486261048631 Eph 104862810486251048625-10486251048626 Rom 104862510486261048630-1048632)

Te Spirit forms the glocal church He empowers it for service and

witness He fills it with Christrsquos empowering presence He leads it into the

missio Deimdashthe mission of the Father Son and Holy Spirit

Recently Pentecostal and renewalist movements have grown dramati-

cally in the Majority World Tey have increased in status size and influence

Many have matured theologically Te churches of the West must take notice

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of the power and presence of the Spirit

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2436

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048625

Te rinity Tere are clear limitations to the analogy between the

church and the rinity Te church can only image the rinity Yet the

church is at its best when it reflects the relational and missional passionof the rinity

What is the source and inspiration of the churchrsquos local-global mission

Ultimately it is the missional nature passion and actions of the Father Son

and Holy Spirit Godrsquos nature is missional His passion is infectious His

actions are historical redemptive and eternal Te rinity invites the

church into a sending community Te Father sends the Son Te Father

and Son send the Spirit Finally the rinity sends the church in missioninto the world

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of the rinity How does it enable our participation in the mission

and community of the triune God

Association and dialogue Tese need to happen across denominational

cultural ethnic gender and theological traditions and divides Authentic

dialogue is indispensable to the health and mission of the church What dothose marginal to the life of the church have to say to us What do ldquoothersrdquo

have to teach us Other ethnicities and cultures Other socioeconomic

groups Other ages and genders Other theological and confessing tradi-

tions Other persons from times long gone

We need to listen Share Be vulnerable Be authentic Open up to crit-

icism correction and change

We need more than dialogue We need communion and association It is

possible in a qualified way to say that God is present in all the various forms

of the church (ie the various theological ecclesiological sociocultural his-

torical and other permutations of the church) We discern this presence

through attention to Scripture history tradition culture and the Spirit Dis-

cernment involves critical dialogue theological exchange biblical study and

real relationship Only the Spirit of Jesus can enable this

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of association and dialogue

Mission and the missio Dei Te church is missional at its core It serves

obeys and images a missionary God David Bosch says ldquoTe churchrsquos mission

is not secondary to its being the church exists in being sent and in building up

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2536

10486271048626 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

itself for its missionrdquo He goes on to say ldquoEcclesiology does not precede missi-

ology there cannot be church without an intrinsic missionary dimensionrdquo983089983089

Jesus is Lord Lord of his church and Lord of his world His mission de-termines and forms the church His mission shapes the nature purposes

structures ministries and activities of his church Majority World and in-

digenous thinkers help us understand the implications of this mission Tey

help us form glocal theologies of mission Tey reveal ldquomission in context

as transformationrdquo9830891048626

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of mission and the missio Dei Church theology and practice Glocal conversations can inform and

enrich many aspects of the church (when practiced well) Teologies and

practices benefit from robust and critical glocal conversations Tese con-

versations enrich many areas (community spirituality discipleship liturgy

worship hospitality eco-justice education social ethics servantship lib-

eration place suffering beauty and so on)

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-standing of these many dimensions of church and mission

Glocal processes shape these eight themes and their practices We need

to facilitate and enable these conversations and processes Tis is urgent It

must be a priority No theology of mission or missional ecclesiology is ad-

equate without glocal conversations983089983091

T983144983141 L983151983139983137983148 983137983150983140 G983148983151983138983137983148 E983150983154983145983139983144 E983137983139983144 O983156983144983141983154

Glocalization takes the localparticular context and globaluniversal themes

seriously Contextual and global conversations enter an enriching and in-

forming relationship Tese two always have an active and symbiotic rela-

tionship Tis is true whether we deliberately put them into conversation or

not Te local shapes the global and the global shapes the local Many local

11David J Bosch Believing in the Future oward a Missiology o Western Culture (New York

rinity 1048625983097983097983093) 104862798309012izon ransormation Afer Lausanne 1048631-98309713Not all o these themes are dealt with in this present volume since either (1048625) I have dealt with them

in my book Salt Light and a City (983090) they are not all key themes in the writings o the thirty-five

Majority World thinkers considered in this volume or (1048627) there is not adequate space in a book

this size

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2636

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048627

voices converge to form global conversations and theologies Using the Phil-

ippines as a case study izon illustrates this by showing the interdepen-

dence between local and global themes in mission983089983092Dialogue between local and global conversations is critical Kōsuke

Koyama wrote an important book on contextual mission called Water Buffalo

Teology Koyama is a Japanese missionary who served in Chiang Mai

Tailand He writes of the joys and challenges of doing local particular water

buffalo theology He considers the relationship between local theology global

missional themes and transforming cultures ldquoWater Buffalo Teology sees

certain specific challenges Contextualization of theology implies two criticalmovements First to articulate Jesus Christ in culturally appropriate com-

municatively apt words and second to criticize reform dethrone or oppose

culture if it is found to be against what the name of Jesus Christ stands forrdquo9830891048629

Kōsuke Koyama challenges us to recognize what we bring to the task of

local theology For him it was doing theology in Tailand while being Jap-

anese We also need to notice the particular culture wersquore located in as we do

the work of theology Tis means we avoid speaking of an ldquoAsian theologyrdquoldquoAfrican theologyrdquo and the like We need to cultivate local theologies that

engage regional and global themes But these theologies must be ldquodistinctly

localrdquo and a ldquotheology from belowrdquo9830891048630

Simultaneously we need to pursue a reformation of theology and

practice ldquoin the global contextrdquo Tis means entering ldquothe disturbing spa-

ciousness of Jesus Christrdquo Jesus calls us to reject enmity and exceptionalism

We seem him present in our culture language stories and relationships

But we also choose to embrace the ldquootherrdquo We choose to see him present

in other culturesmdashshaping a global people to serve and worship him

joining in his mission983089983095

Kōsuke Koyama roots the gospel in the local contextual and particular

Tis is why he roots his water buffalo theology in Northern Tai culture He

is careful not to say ldquoHere is how you contextualize in your settingrdquo Instead

14izon ransormation Afer Lausanne 1048631-10486251048627 10486251048628983097-98309098308898309015Kōsuke Koyama Water Buffalo Teology 983090983093th anniversary ed (Maryknoll NY Orbis 1048625983097983097983097)

xiii-xv16Kōsuke Koyama ldquoTe Asian Approach to Christrdquo Missiology 1048625983090 no 1048628 (10486259830979830961048628) 10486281048627983093-104862798309617Kōsuke Koyama ldquoReormation in the Global Context Te Disturbing Spaciousness o Jesus Christrdquo

Currents in Teology and Mission 1048627983088 no 983090 (9830909830889830881048627) 10486251048625983097-983090983096

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2736

10486271048628 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

he tells us a story Itrsquos the story of how he contextualized theology in northern

Tailand while being open to global conversations Koyama asks us to form

our own local expressions of church mission and theology At the same timewe must stay attentive to what God is saying and doing beyond that context

Tis way local and global and particular and universal become mutually

enriching conversation partners

G983148983151983139983137983148983145983162983137983156983145983151983150 983137983150983140 H983145983155983156983151983154983145983139983137983148983148983161 S983145983148983141983150983139983141983140 V983151983145983139983141983155

Glocal theologies and conversations pay attention to voices that powers in-

stitutions religions and societies have silenced R S Sugirtharajah pushesback a little on izonrsquos ideas Sugirtharajah says that the church should

privilege local conversations He emphasizes the local contextual and post-

colonial reading of biblical texts9830891048632

Te church needs to listen Te church ought to be attentive to the

theologies and biblical interpretations of groups that cultures and reli-

gions have ignored Historically powerful secular and religious forces

have silenced these groups Tey have marginalized oppressed and colo-nized them It is time for the church to address this injustice We must

start listening to important but silenced voices We need to privilege the

voices of the former victims of Western colonialism We need to develop

postcolonial biblical interpretations theologies and expressions of church

and mission

How do we take such perspectives seriously as we develop glocal conver-

sations How do these themes help us foster vital relationships between local

and global voices

It is time for us to embrace values that enable conversations with those

oen ignored by the church We need values that help us learn from these

groups and individuals

Valuing equal partnership Colonizing powers oppressed silenced and

colonized certain groups At times the church was complicit Tese colo-

nized groups have become ldquoconfident indomitable and indispensable

partners in the dialogue and collaboration with the dispossessed and disad-

18R S Sugirtharajah Asian Biblical Hermeneutics and Postcolonialism Contesting the Interpreta-

tions Te Bible and Liberation Series (Maryknoll NY Orbis 1048625983097983097983096) 1048625983093-1048625983094

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2836

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048629

vantaged in the Westrdquo9830891048633 Tis calls for attentiveness to these voices and re-

sponsiveness to their prophetic challenges It also demands a critical evalu-

ation of colonial readings of Scripture Colonial models of theology andchurch and mission are no longer the benchmark Te global church must

examine them afresh

Valuing equal status Tose on the margins have now taken their rightful

place on the global stage Tey have claimed appropriate and equal status at

the table Subaltern readings of theology church and mission are invaluable

contributors to global theological conversations Tis means that we esteem

them But we also test themWhat do we mean by subaltern Subalterns are those who are down-

trodden and silenced (or have been treated this way in the past) Dominant

or colonizing groups treat them as invisible nonentities Tey enjoy limited

or no access to power Sometimes these are women certain tribal and ethnic

groups and those considered ldquountouchablerdquo In Voices from the Margin Su-

girtharajah provides a platform for postcolonial subaltern readings of

Scripture and theology Tese readings challenge colonialmdashoen Westernmdashreadings of Bible and theology and cultures Tey claim equal status with

other ways of doing theology10486261048624

Valuing equal identity People groups need freedom to explore their new

and emerging identities Tese emerge in response to local and global influ-

ences Local culture is not the only thing at work here Global forces also

shape identity as do imported practices ideas readings rituals and tech-

nologies But each group should be free to explore and construct their par-

ticular forms of Christian identity

Valuing equal interpretations ldquoPostcolonialism is concerned with the

question of cultural and discursive dominationrdquo Colonialism led to op-

pressive and controlling forms of culture and discourse Tese were usually

not contextual or indigenous Western powers for instance brought co-

lonial forms of theology church biblical interpretation and mission1048626983089

Postcolonialism calls for alternative ways of approaching these things Tose

19Ibid 104862598309420R S Sugirtharajah Voices rom the Margin Interpreting the Bible in the Tird World (Maryknoll

NY Orbis 10486259830979830971048625)21Sugirtharajah Asian Biblical Hermeneutics and Postcolonialism 10486251048631

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2936

10486271048630 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

who were once marginalized oppressed and silenced need to lead these fresh

approaches in their own settings Tese then influence global conversations

We need to support the new readings and insights and experiments from thesegroups o be genuine this support must be both critical and collegial

Valuing equal empowerment Sugirtharajah says that postcolonialism is

valuable when it empowers actual communities and real people Post-

colonial thought empowers when it addresses the difficulties hopes and

experiences of ordinary people It should never be about power plays and

the clever use of language Itrsquos pointless if itrsquos obsessed with forming newmdash

and ldquocolonizingrdquomdashtheories Itrsquos a waste of time if itrsquos a self-indulgent pursuitof new and hybrid identities Rather ldquothe worth and credibility of post-

colonial criticism will be judged by how it orchestrates the unique and

fragile and imagined claims of one community against anotherrdquo Empow-

erment happens in a variety of ways One way is contributing equally to

global conversations10486261048626

Al izon examines postcolonialism in the Philippines He says that it can

teach the global church a lot about healthy local-global conversations Fil-ipino contextual theology resists many Western forms of mission and the-

ology It finds them patronizing and controlling Tis indigenous theology

values prophetic sociopolitical engagement in institutions and the society

at large It emphasizes ministry to whole persons and communities It con-

structs a Filipino theology of beauty and mission and worship and com-

munity And it fosters indigenous theological approaches to the spirit world

and cosmology

izon says that postcolonial theology has played a constructive role in

the Philippines But he is uncomfortable with the label postcolonialism He

prefers to describe historical events as ldquobeyond colonialismrdquo And he says

that global conversations enrich local theologies and vice versa1048626983091

Postcolonial thought informs our understanding of the relationship be-

tween the local and global It also shows how theology can emerge at the

intersection between the localparticular and the globaluniversal It re-

minds us that worthwhile glocalization listens to all voices Tis includes

heeding those that have been historically silenced

22Ibid 983090104862823izon ransormation Afer Lausanne 1048625983088983090 10486259830941048631-9830961048631

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3036

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048631

G983148983151983139983137983148983145983162983137983156983145983151983150 983137983150983140 983156983144983141 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

C983151983150983139983148983157983140983145983150983143 R983141983142983148983141983139983156983145983151983150983155

How do we go about developing a model for glocal conversations izon hasrecently provided a useful model that is instructive as we seek to learn from

the Majority World It has at least two key features

First the local is in the global (globalization from below) Global theologies

and ideas have origins in many particular local contexts In that sense glo-

balization is from below Global ideas have local roots Ideas about integral

mission liberation theology and missional church have local origins Tey

have their roots in the prayers hopes discoveries mission and theologiesof thousands of local communities ldquoTe global does not cannot exist

without the localmdashbut the coming together of localities creates a global re-

ality that becomes greater than the sum of its parts it creates a gestalt entity

to which localities make themselves accountablerdquo1048626983092

Second the global is in the local (panlocalization from above) Te con-

cerns and voices of multitudes of locales form global conversations Tese

global discussions can provide a ldquopositive accountabilityrdquo back to local con-texts Tis is true when they enrich affirm serve guide and strengthen local

contexts It is also true when they avoid homogenization control impo-

sition and judgment Glocalization is best when it sees itself as interde-

pendent deeply connected with the local10486261048629

Tatrsquos a helpful starting point But we need to go further Besides izonrsquos

proposals Irsquom convinced that robust glocal conversations cultivate six core

practices

983089 Glocal theology practices its values We root glocal theology in core

values Tese values include solidarity understanding and mutual learning

Do we value fellowship with Christians of all cultures Do we value learning

from them

We prove our values through our practices What practices emerge out of

these values We need to collaborate act collectively and share information

We must find ways to foster grassroots perspectives and local theologies We

need to share stories and learnings and cultivate networks relationships and

partnerships We need attentiveness to local voices and global themes We

24Ibid 9830901048625983088-1048625104862825Ibid 98309010486251048628-1048625983096

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3136

10486271048632 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

ought to find ways to put these local and global voices into conversation

Mutual learning humility and solidarity are key Worthwhile glocal con-

versations can never be merely theoretical or academic It is up to us to rootour values in our practices

983090 Glocal theology practices humility (and it tells a new narrative) We

have noted that the local is in the global and the global is in the local Te

two are interdependent Tey form each other reciprocally Since this is the

case we must practice humility Tere is no place for ethnocentrism colo-

nialism or theological and cultural arrogance I have seen these unhealthy

postures far too oen in Western settingsRecently I attended a missional leadership conference On that occasion

the keynote speakermdasha leading missional author and speakermdashsaid that

North American missional conversations and innovations hold the key to

the future of the Western church Tis Euro American view is wrong (Irsquom

being kind o be frank itrsquos complete nonsense) Itrsquos arrogant and Euro

Americanndashcentric And itrsquos completely out of step with what is happening in

the glocal church We need a new narrativeIn June 1048626104862410486251048627 Te Center for the Study of Global Christianity reported

the top 10486261048624 countries where Christianity has the highest percentage growth

rate Nineteen of the top twenty are in Asia and Africa Eleven of them are

in Muslim majority countries Not a single country from Europe or North

America makes the top twenty list10486261048630

Itrsquos time to cultivate a new narrative Te future of the church is emerging

from the Majority World Rather than North America the churches of

Eastern Asia Western Africa the Arabian Peninsula and other parts of the

Majority World reveal the future of the global church We need the contribu-

tions of all contexts Western indigenous and Majority World All con-

tribute to glocal conversations All are important as we learn from each

other about mission theology and faith But letrsquos stop pretending that North

Americans and Europeans will reveal the future of the global church Letrsquos

start listening to what God is saying about the future of the global church

And hersquos speaking to us through the churches of Asia Africa Latin America

26Russ Mitchell ldquoTe op 983090983088 Countries Where Christianity Is Growing the Fastestrdquo Disciple All

Nations (blog) August 983090983093 98309098308810486251048627 httpsdiscipleallnationswordpresscom98309098308810486251048627983088983096983090983093the-top

-983090983088-countries-where-christianity-is-growing-the-astest

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3236

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048633

Muslim majority settings and so on We must cultivate a new glocal nar-

rativemdashone soaked in humility

Glocal theology must be humble theology Meek theology Receptive the-ology Discerning theology Prayerful theology Dialogical theology De-

pendent theology A theology that celebrates the interdependence between

the localparticular and the globaluniversal

983091 Glocal theology practices expansiveness Glocalization is by nature

comprehensive Local and global influences permeate much of our lives Tese

glocal forces shape our theologies and churches whether we like it or not

But intentionality is also important We need to commit to an expansiveapproach to glocal theology How do we deliberately cultivate glocal conver-

sations in our biblical interpretation Do we foster them in our under-

standing of the person and work of Christ How does glocalization shape

the way the Spirit empowers and constitutes the church How can it form

our understanding of the nature and mission of the rinity How does it

influence the way we practice fellowship and conversation across denomi-

national cultural ethnic economic sociocultural political gender andtheological divides How might it shape our theologies of mission com-

munity beauty spirituality suffering discipleship hospitality eco-justice

place education social ethics Christian leadership and so forth

983092 Glocal theology practices attention Glocal theology doesnrsquot need to

accept all the assumptions or assertions of postcolonial or Majority World

thought But it does need to engage with them and take them seriously

Postcolonial theology for instance gives the marginalized and colonized

and forgotten and silenced both dignity and voice Our glocal conversations

must also include and esteem these groups We need to be attentive to

others weak and powerful female and male dominant and downtrodden

old and young rich and poor privileged and marginalized influential and

subaltern educated and illiterate We need to practice the art of attention

being especially attentive to those who are different to us

983093 Glocal theology practices embrace What do colonial ethnocentric or

Western-centric perspectives do Tey silence Tey control Tey com-

modify Tey institutionalize Tey colonize Tey domesticate Tey replace

Tey import Tey exclude Tey do these things to the beliefs experiences

and practices of other cultures A worthwhile glocal theology refuses to do

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3336

10486281048624 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

these things Instead it adopts a responsive humble celebratory open in-

clusive and embracing attitude

983094 Glocal theology practices discernment Finally we need discernmentas we engage these ideas and practices Discernment is a huge topic thatrsquos

hard to cover comprehensively in a few words Discernment happens when

the Spirit of Christ and his Word renew our minds Te Spirit grants us

spiritual wisdom as we meditate on him and his Word and as we practice

discipleship to Jesus Christ Romans 10486251048626 provides guidance we need (1048625) to be

transformed by the renewal of our minds (1048626) to serve Christrsquos body and (1048627)

to put love into action Discernment also happens in conversation both lo-cally and glocally

I pray these core values and six practices come across in the following

chapters of GlobalChurch

Glocalization can never be just theoretical Are we committed to moving

glocalization from an abstract idea to a living communion Are we deter-

mined to construct a missional theology of the church in the context of

glocal conversations Tis must involve dialogue between Majority Worldindigenous and Western scholars activists and groups

Will glocalization be an abstract notion Or will it be a formative and

genuine communion between local regional and global voices Glocal dy-

namics are at play whether we like it or not Teyrsquore in our churches the-

ologies and missions But we can choose to relinquish isolationist colonial

parochial and arrogant approaches Instead we can adopt responsive dia-

logical learning humble and embracing postures

Trough healthy approaches to glocalization the Spirit challenges us to

value local contexts We immerse ourselves in local and particular commu-

nities and conversations He inspires us to open ourselves to global theo-

logical conversations He rouses us to value the symbiotic relationship be-

tween the localparticular and the globaluniversal

Trough glocal relationships the Spirit leads us to put local contextual

theologies into conversation with global ones He prompts us to explore the

ways in which the local is in the glocal and the global is in the local He per-

suades us to pursue collaboration and dialogue and mutual learning We

engage with Christians from different backgrounds and cultures ecumen-

icals Pentecostals evangelicals and so on from Western indigenous and

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3436

Glocalizing Conversations 10486281048625

Majority World contexts He motivates us to express solidarity between all

parties We appreciate our unity in diversity

Trough glocal conversations the Spirit moves us to ensure that unity andsolidarity emerge from a compelling vision of Jesusrsquo kingdom and gospel

and person He challenges us to share information theology and practices

He urges us to learn from each othermdashour successes and mistakes We seek

glocal solutions

Te Spirit calls us to develop glocal conversations about Christian ideas

and practices Tese include Scripture Evangelicalism ecumenism Pente-

costalism Jesus Christ the Holy Spirit God the Father the rinity com-munity spirituality discipleship liturgy worship hospitality prayer eco-

justice education social ethics Christian leadership gospel and culture

beauty place suffering liberation and so forth

Finally through glocal conversations the Spirit leads us to adopt a new

posture Tis is a responsive humble celebratory open inclusive and em-

bracing attitude to the ldquootherrdquo We do this as a new people made up of every

tribe and language and people and nationTere are dangers in glocalization Sugirtharajah warns of the commodi-

fication of local contextual practices and theologies When this happens

they are ldquosmoothed out of their primary contexts concerns and contesta-

tions travel across borders and become objects of analysis and scrutiny

within an alien secondary contextrdquo1048626983095

Itrsquos common for those of us who are Western to make mistakes when we

wrestle with Majority World and indigenous ideas Sugirtharajah mentions

our tendency to commodify reduce and institutionalize these ideas We also

risk doing these things (1048625) We apply them in noncontextual prescriptive ways

(1048626) We ignore their meanings in their original setting (1048627) We glamorize or

idealize their proponents or their contexts (1048628) We demonize those persons or

contexts (1048629) We disregard them as irrelevant rhetorical or minority discourse

Kevin J Vanhoozer says that we can fall into three traps when we glo-

calize theology (1048625) We can underestimate the theological significance of

local cultures (1048626) We can homogenize cultures and theologies exaggerating

27R S Sugirtharajah ldquoextual ake-Aways Tird World exts in Western Metropolitan Centresrdquo

Black Teology in Britain A Journal o Contextual Praxis 983090 (1048625983097983097983097) 10486271048627 10486271048631 Edward W Said Te

World the ext and the Critic (Cambridge MA Harvard University Press 10486259830979830961048627) 9830901048627983097

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3536

10486281048626 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

ldquothe onerdquo (1048627) We can overemphasize cultural particularity exaggerating ldquothe

manyrdquo and pursue ldquotheological ethnificationrdquo10486261048632

My hope is that GlobalChurch does not fall into the traps Sugirtharajahand Vanhoozer describe I hope that what unfolds in the following chapters

is respectful and discerning I hope it leads to further mutually enriching

conversations between people of different cultures

You the reader face the same challenges You face them in your personal

life ministry context and missional engagements

Will you treat the themes in this book as abstract theoretical notions

Will this be a temporary infatuation a flirtation with the ldquootherrdquo that dissi-pates as suddenly as it arrived Or will glocal conversations become an en-

riching and formative orientation in your life Will glocal conversations

bring fresh approaches to theology faith mission church and worship Will

conversations with other cultures and theologies become for you a com-

pelling way of life

My prayer is that glocal conversations will help the church be a global

visible alternative ldquocity set upon a hillrdquo a truly GlobalChurch

28Craig Ott and Harold A Netland Globalizing Teology Belie and Practice in an Era o World

Christianity (Grand Rapids Baker Academic 983090983088983088983094) 1048625983090983093

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3636

Page 24: GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2436

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048625

Te rinity Tere are clear limitations to the analogy between the

church and the rinity Te church can only image the rinity Yet the

church is at its best when it reflects the relational and missional passionof the rinity

What is the source and inspiration of the churchrsquos local-global mission

Ultimately it is the missional nature passion and actions of the Father Son

and Holy Spirit Godrsquos nature is missional His passion is infectious His

actions are historical redemptive and eternal Te rinity invites the

church into a sending community Te Father sends the Son Te Father

and Son send the Spirit Finally the rinity sends the church in missioninto the world

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of the rinity How does it enable our participation in the mission

and community of the triune God

Association and dialogue Tese need to happen across denominational

cultural ethnic gender and theological traditions and divides Authentic

dialogue is indispensable to the health and mission of the church What dothose marginal to the life of the church have to say to us What do ldquoothersrdquo

have to teach us Other ethnicities and cultures Other socioeconomic

groups Other ages and genders Other theological and confessing tradi-

tions Other persons from times long gone

We need to listen Share Be vulnerable Be authentic Open up to crit-

icism correction and change

We need more than dialogue We need communion and association It is

possible in a qualified way to say that God is present in all the various forms

of the church (ie the various theological ecclesiological sociocultural his-

torical and other permutations of the church) We discern this presence

through attention to Scripture history tradition culture and the Spirit Dis-

cernment involves critical dialogue theological exchange biblical study and

real relationship Only the Spirit of Jesus can enable this

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of association and dialogue

Mission and the missio Dei Te church is missional at its core It serves

obeys and images a missionary God David Bosch says ldquoTe churchrsquos mission

is not secondary to its being the church exists in being sent and in building up

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2536

10486271048626 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

itself for its missionrdquo He goes on to say ldquoEcclesiology does not precede missi-

ology there cannot be church without an intrinsic missionary dimensionrdquo983089983089

Jesus is Lord Lord of his church and Lord of his world His mission de-termines and forms the church His mission shapes the nature purposes

structures ministries and activities of his church Majority World and in-

digenous thinkers help us understand the implications of this mission Tey

help us form glocal theologies of mission Tey reveal ldquomission in context

as transformationrdquo9830891048626

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of mission and the missio Dei Church theology and practice Glocal conversations can inform and

enrich many aspects of the church (when practiced well) Teologies and

practices benefit from robust and critical glocal conversations Tese con-

versations enrich many areas (community spirituality discipleship liturgy

worship hospitality eco-justice education social ethics servantship lib-

eration place suffering beauty and so on)

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-standing of these many dimensions of church and mission

Glocal processes shape these eight themes and their practices We need

to facilitate and enable these conversations and processes Tis is urgent It

must be a priority No theology of mission or missional ecclesiology is ad-

equate without glocal conversations983089983091

T983144983141 L983151983139983137983148 983137983150983140 G983148983151983138983137983148 E983150983154983145983139983144 E983137983139983144 O983156983144983141983154

Glocalization takes the localparticular context and globaluniversal themes

seriously Contextual and global conversations enter an enriching and in-

forming relationship Tese two always have an active and symbiotic rela-

tionship Tis is true whether we deliberately put them into conversation or

not Te local shapes the global and the global shapes the local Many local

11David J Bosch Believing in the Future oward a Missiology o Western Culture (New York

rinity 1048625983097983097983093) 104862798309012izon ransormation Afer Lausanne 1048631-98309713Not all o these themes are dealt with in this present volume since either (1048625) I have dealt with them

in my book Salt Light and a City (983090) they are not all key themes in the writings o the thirty-five

Majority World thinkers considered in this volume or (1048627) there is not adequate space in a book

this size

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2636

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048627

voices converge to form global conversations and theologies Using the Phil-

ippines as a case study izon illustrates this by showing the interdepen-

dence between local and global themes in mission983089983092Dialogue between local and global conversations is critical Kōsuke

Koyama wrote an important book on contextual mission called Water Buffalo

Teology Koyama is a Japanese missionary who served in Chiang Mai

Tailand He writes of the joys and challenges of doing local particular water

buffalo theology He considers the relationship between local theology global

missional themes and transforming cultures ldquoWater Buffalo Teology sees

certain specific challenges Contextualization of theology implies two criticalmovements First to articulate Jesus Christ in culturally appropriate com-

municatively apt words and second to criticize reform dethrone or oppose

culture if it is found to be against what the name of Jesus Christ stands forrdquo9830891048629

Kōsuke Koyama challenges us to recognize what we bring to the task of

local theology For him it was doing theology in Tailand while being Jap-

anese We also need to notice the particular culture wersquore located in as we do

the work of theology Tis means we avoid speaking of an ldquoAsian theologyrdquoldquoAfrican theologyrdquo and the like We need to cultivate local theologies that

engage regional and global themes But these theologies must be ldquodistinctly

localrdquo and a ldquotheology from belowrdquo9830891048630

Simultaneously we need to pursue a reformation of theology and

practice ldquoin the global contextrdquo Tis means entering ldquothe disturbing spa-

ciousness of Jesus Christrdquo Jesus calls us to reject enmity and exceptionalism

We seem him present in our culture language stories and relationships

But we also choose to embrace the ldquootherrdquo We choose to see him present

in other culturesmdashshaping a global people to serve and worship him

joining in his mission983089983095

Kōsuke Koyama roots the gospel in the local contextual and particular

Tis is why he roots his water buffalo theology in Northern Tai culture He

is careful not to say ldquoHere is how you contextualize in your settingrdquo Instead

14izon ransormation Afer Lausanne 1048631-10486251048627 10486251048628983097-98309098308898309015Kōsuke Koyama Water Buffalo Teology 983090983093th anniversary ed (Maryknoll NY Orbis 1048625983097983097983097)

xiii-xv16Kōsuke Koyama ldquoTe Asian Approach to Christrdquo Missiology 1048625983090 no 1048628 (10486259830979830961048628) 10486281048627983093-104862798309617Kōsuke Koyama ldquoReormation in the Global Context Te Disturbing Spaciousness o Jesus Christrdquo

Currents in Teology and Mission 1048627983088 no 983090 (9830909830889830881048627) 10486251048625983097-983090983096

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2736

10486271048628 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

he tells us a story Itrsquos the story of how he contextualized theology in northern

Tailand while being open to global conversations Koyama asks us to form

our own local expressions of church mission and theology At the same timewe must stay attentive to what God is saying and doing beyond that context

Tis way local and global and particular and universal become mutually

enriching conversation partners

G983148983151983139983137983148983145983162983137983156983145983151983150 983137983150983140 H983145983155983156983151983154983145983139983137983148983148983161 S983145983148983141983150983139983141983140 V983151983145983139983141983155

Glocal theologies and conversations pay attention to voices that powers in-

stitutions religions and societies have silenced R S Sugirtharajah pushesback a little on izonrsquos ideas Sugirtharajah says that the church should

privilege local conversations He emphasizes the local contextual and post-

colonial reading of biblical texts9830891048632

Te church needs to listen Te church ought to be attentive to the

theologies and biblical interpretations of groups that cultures and reli-

gions have ignored Historically powerful secular and religious forces

have silenced these groups Tey have marginalized oppressed and colo-nized them It is time for the church to address this injustice We must

start listening to important but silenced voices We need to privilege the

voices of the former victims of Western colonialism We need to develop

postcolonial biblical interpretations theologies and expressions of church

and mission

How do we take such perspectives seriously as we develop glocal conver-

sations How do these themes help us foster vital relationships between local

and global voices

It is time for us to embrace values that enable conversations with those

oen ignored by the church We need values that help us learn from these

groups and individuals

Valuing equal partnership Colonizing powers oppressed silenced and

colonized certain groups At times the church was complicit Tese colo-

nized groups have become ldquoconfident indomitable and indispensable

partners in the dialogue and collaboration with the dispossessed and disad-

18R S Sugirtharajah Asian Biblical Hermeneutics and Postcolonialism Contesting the Interpreta-

tions Te Bible and Liberation Series (Maryknoll NY Orbis 1048625983097983097983096) 1048625983093-1048625983094

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2836

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048629

vantaged in the Westrdquo9830891048633 Tis calls for attentiveness to these voices and re-

sponsiveness to their prophetic challenges It also demands a critical evalu-

ation of colonial readings of Scripture Colonial models of theology andchurch and mission are no longer the benchmark Te global church must

examine them afresh

Valuing equal status Tose on the margins have now taken their rightful

place on the global stage Tey have claimed appropriate and equal status at

the table Subaltern readings of theology church and mission are invaluable

contributors to global theological conversations Tis means that we esteem

them But we also test themWhat do we mean by subaltern Subalterns are those who are down-

trodden and silenced (or have been treated this way in the past) Dominant

or colonizing groups treat them as invisible nonentities Tey enjoy limited

or no access to power Sometimes these are women certain tribal and ethnic

groups and those considered ldquountouchablerdquo In Voices from the Margin Su-

girtharajah provides a platform for postcolonial subaltern readings of

Scripture and theology Tese readings challenge colonialmdashoen Westernmdashreadings of Bible and theology and cultures Tey claim equal status with

other ways of doing theology10486261048624

Valuing equal identity People groups need freedom to explore their new

and emerging identities Tese emerge in response to local and global influ-

ences Local culture is not the only thing at work here Global forces also

shape identity as do imported practices ideas readings rituals and tech-

nologies But each group should be free to explore and construct their par-

ticular forms of Christian identity

Valuing equal interpretations ldquoPostcolonialism is concerned with the

question of cultural and discursive dominationrdquo Colonialism led to op-

pressive and controlling forms of culture and discourse Tese were usually

not contextual or indigenous Western powers for instance brought co-

lonial forms of theology church biblical interpretation and mission1048626983089

Postcolonialism calls for alternative ways of approaching these things Tose

19Ibid 104862598309420R S Sugirtharajah Voices rom the Margin Interpreting the Bible in the Tird World (Maryknoll

NY Orbis 10486259830979830971048625)21Sugirtharajah Asian Biblical Hermeneutics and Postcolonialism 10486251048631

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2936

10486271048630 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

who were once marginalized oppressed and silenced need to lead these fresh

approaches in their own settings Tese then influence global conversations

We need to support the new readings and insights and experiments from thesegroups o be genuine this support must be both critical and collegial

Valuing equal empowerment Sugirtharajah says that postcolonialism is

valuable when it empowers actual communities and real people Post-

colonial thought empowers when it addresses the difficulties hopes and

experiences of ordinary people It should never be about power plays and

the clever use of language Itrsquos pointless if itrsquos obsessed with forming newmdash

and ldquocolonizingrdquomdashtheories Itrsquos a waste of time if itrsquos a self-indulgent pursuitof new and hybrid identities Rather ldquothe worth and credibility of post-

colonial criticism will be judged by how it orchestrates the unique and

fragile and imagined claims of one community against anotherrdquo Empow-

erment happens in a variety of ways One way is contributing equally to

global conversations10486261048626

Al izon examines postcolonialism in the Philippines He says that it can

teach the global church a lot about healthy local-global conversations Fil-ipino contextual theology resists many Western forms of mission and the-

ology It finds them patronizing and controlling Tis indigenous theology

values prophetic sociopolitical engagement in institutions and the society

at large It emphasizes ministry to whole persons and communities It con-

structs a Filipino theology of beauty and mission and worship and com-

munity And it fosters indigenous theological approaches to the spirit world

and cosmology

izon says that postcolonial theology has played a constructive role in

the Philippines But he is uncomfortable with the label postcolonialism He

prefers to describe historical events as ldquobeyond colonialismrdquo And he says

that global conversations enrich local theologies and vice versa1048626983091

Postcolonial thought informs our understanding of the relationship be-

tween the local and global It also shows how theology can emerge at the

intersection between the localparticular and the globaluniversal It re-

minds us that worthwhile glocalization listens to all voices Tis includes

heeding those that have been historically silenced

22Ibid 983090104862823izon ransormation Afer Lausanne 1048625983088983090 10486259830941048631-9830961048631

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3036

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048631

G983148983151983139983137983148983145983162983137983156983145983151983150 983137983150983140 983156983144983141 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

C983151983150983139983148983157983140983145983150983143 R983141983142983148983141983139983156983145983151983150983155

How do we go about developing a model for glocal conversations izon hasrecently provided a useful model that is instructive as we seek to learn from

the Majority World It has at least two key features

First the local is in the global (globalization from below) Global theologies

and ideas have origins in many particular local contexts In that sense glo-

balization is from below Global ideas have local roots Ideas about integral

mission liberation theology and missional church have local origins Tey

have their roots in the prayers hopes discoveries mission and theologiesof thousands of local communities ldquoTe global does not cannot exist

without the localmdashbut the coming together of localities creates a global re-

ality that becomes greater than the sum of its parts it creates a gestalt entity

to which localities make themselves accountablerdquo1048626983092

Second the global is in the local (panlocalization from above) Te con-

cerns and voices of multitudes of locales form global conversations Tese

global discussions can provide a ldquopositive accountabilityrdquo back to local con-texts Tis is true when they enrich affirm serve guide and strengthen local

contexts It is also true when they avoid homogenization control impo-

sition and judgment Glocalization is best when it sees itself as interde-

pendent deeply connected with the local10486261048629

Tatrsquos a helpful starting point But we need to go further Besides izonrsquos

proposals Irsquom convinced that robust glocal conversations cultivate six core

practices

983089 Glocal theology practices its values We root glocal theology in core

values Tese values include solidarity understanding and mutual learning

Do we value fellowship with Christians of all cultures Do we value learning

from them

We prove our values through our practices What practices emerge out of

these values We need to collaborate act collectively and share information

We must find ways to foster grassroots perspectives and local theologies We

need to share stories and learnings and cultivate networks relationships and

partnerships We need attentiveness to local voices and global themes We

24Ibid 9830901048625983088-1048625104862825Ibid 98309010486251048628-1048625983096

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3136

10486271048632 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

ought to find ways to put these local and global voices into conversation

Mutual learning humility and solidarity are key Worthwhile glocal con-

versations can never be merely theoretical or academic It is up to us to rootour values in our practices

983090 Glocal theology practices humility (and it tells a new narrative) We

have noted that the local is in the global and the global is in the local Te

two are interdependent Tey form each other reciprocally Since this is the

case we must practice humility Tere is no place for ethnocentrism colo-

nialism or theological and cultural arrogance I have seen these unhealthy

postures far too oen in Western settingsRecently I attended a missional leadership conference On that occasion

the keynote speakermdasha leading missional author and speakermdashsaid that

North American missional conversations and innovations hold the key to

the future of the Western church Tis Euro American view is wrong (Irsquom

being kind o be frank itrsquos complete nonsense) Itrsquos arrogant and Euro

Americanndashcentric And itrsquos completely out of step with what is happening in

the glocal church We need a new narrativeIn June 1048626104862410486251048627 Te Center for the Study of Global Christianity reported

the top 10486261048624 countries where Christianity has the highest percentage growth

rate Nineteen of the top twenty are in Asia and Africa Eleven of them are

in Muslim majority countries Not a single country from Europe or North

America makes the top twenty list10486261048630

Itrsquos time to cultivate a new narrative Te future of the church is emerging

from the Majority World Rather than North America the churches of

Eastern Asia Western Africa the Arabian Peninsula and other parts of the

Majority World reveal the future of the global church We need the contribu-

tions of all contexts Western indigenous and Majority World All con-

tribute to glocal conversations All are important as we learn from each

other about mission theology and faith But letrsquos stop pretending that North

Americans and Europeans will reveal the future of the global church Letrsquos

start listening to what God is saying about the future of the global church

And hersquos speaking to us through the churches of Asia Africa Latin America

26Russ Mitchell ldquoTe op 983090983088 Countries Where Christianity Is Growing the Fastestrdquo Disciple All

Nations (blog) August 983090983093 98309098308810486251048627 httpsdiscipleallnationswordpresscom98309098308810486251048627983088983096983090983093the-top

-983090983088-countries-where-christianity-is-growing-the-astest

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3236

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048633

Muslim majority settings and so on We must cultivate a new glocal nar-

rativemdashone soaked in humility

Glocal theology must be humble theology Meek theology Receptive the-ology Discerning theology Prayerful theology Dialogical theology De-

pendent theology A theology that celebrates the interdependence between

the localparticular and the globaluniversal

983091 Glocal theology practices expansiveness Glocalization is by nature

comprehensive Local and global influences permeate much of our lives Tese

glocal forces shape our theologies and churches whether we like it or not

But intentionality is also important We need to commit to an expansiveapproach to glocal theology How do we deliberately cultivate glocal conver-

sations in our biblical interpretation Do we foster them in our under-

standing of the person and work of Christ How does glocalization shape

the way the Spirit empowers and constitutes the church How can it form

our understanding of the nature and mission of the rinity How does it

influence the way we practice fellowship and conversation across denomi-

national cultural ethnic economic sociocultural political gender andtheological divides How might it shape our theologies of mission com-

munity beauty spirituality suffering discipleship hospitality eco-justice

place education social ethics Christian leadership and so forth

983092 Glocal theology practices attention Glocal theology doesnrsquot need to

accept all the assumptions or assertions of postcolonial or Majority World

thought But it does need to engage with them and take them seriously

Postcolonial theology for instance gives the marginalized and colonized

and forgotten and silenced both dignity and voice Our glocal conversations

must also include and esteem these groups We need to be attentive to

others weak and powerful female and male dominant and downtrodden

old and young rich and poor privileged and marginalized influential and

subaltern educated and illiterate We need to practice the art of attention

being especially attentive to those who are different to us

983093 Glocal theology practices embrace What do colonial ethnocentric or

Western-centric perspectives do Tey silence Tey control Tey com-

modify Tey institutionalize Tey colonize Tey domesticate Tey replace

Tey import Tey exclude Tey do these things to the beliefs experiences

and practices of other cultures A worthwhile glocal theology refuses to do

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3336

10486281048624 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

these things Instead it adopts a responsive humble celebratory open in-

clusive and embracing attitude

983094 Glocal theology practices discernment Finally we need discernmentas we engage these ideas and practices Discernment is a huge topic thatrsquos

hard to cover comprehensively in a few words Discernment happens when

the Spirit of Christ and his Word renew our minds Te Spirit grants us

spiritual wisdom as we meditate on him and his Word and as we practice

discipleship to Jesus Christ Romans 10486251048626 provides guidance we need (1048625) to be

transformed by the renewal of our minds (1048626) to serve Christrsquos body and (1048627)

to put love into action Discernment also happens in conversation both lo-cally and glocally

I pray these core values and six practices come across in the following

chapters of GlobalChurch

Glocalization can never be just theoretical Are we committed to moving

glocalization from an abstract idea to a living communion Are we deter-

mined to construct a missional theology of the church in the context of

glocal conversations Tis must involve dialogue between Majority Worldindigenous and Western scholars activists and groups

Will glocalization be an abstract notion Or will it be a formative and

genuine communion between local regional and global voices Glocal dy-

namics are at play whether we like it or not Teyrsquore in our churches the-

ologies and missions But we can choose to relinquish isolationist colonial

parochial and arrogant approaches Instead we can adopt responsive dia-

logical learning humble and embracing postures

Trough healthy approaches to glocalization the Spirit challenges us to

value local contexts We immerse ourselves in local and particular commu-

nities and conversations He inspires us to open ourselves to global theo-

logical conversations He rouses us to value the symbiotic relationship be-

tween the localparticular and the globaluniversal

Trough glocal relationships the Spirit leads us to put local contextual

theologies into conversation with global ones He prompts us to explore the

ways in which the local is in the glocal and the global is in the local He per-

suades us to pursue collaboration and dialogue and mutual learning We

engage with Christians from different backgrounds and cultures ecumen-

icals Pentecostals evangelicals and so on from Western indigenous and

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3436

Glocalizing Conversations 10486281048625

Majority World contexts He motivates us to express solidarity between all

parties We appreciate our unity in diversity

Trough glocal conversations the Spirit moves us to ensure that unity andsolidarity emerge from a compelling vision of Jesusrsquo kingdom and gospel

and person He challenges us to share information theology and practices

He urges us to learn from each othermdashour successes and mistakes We seek

glocal solutions

Te Spirit calls us to develop glocal conversations about Christian ideas

and practices Tese include Scripture Evangelicalism ecumenism Pente-

costalism Jesus Christ the Holy Spirit God the Father the rinity com-munity spirituality discipleship liturgy worship hospitality prayer eco-

justice education social ethics Christian leadership gospel and culture

beauty place suffering liberation and so forth

Finally through glocal conversations the Spirit leads us to adopt a new

posture Tis is a responsive humble celebratory open inclusive and em-

bracing attitude to the ldquootherrdquo We do this as a new people made up of every

tribe and language and people and nationTere are dangers in glocalization Sugirtharajah warns of the commodi-

fication of local contextual practices and theologies When this happens

they are ldquosmoothed out of their primary contexts concerns and contesta-

tions travel across borders and become objects of analysis and scrutiny

within an alien secondary contextrdquo1048626983095

Itrsquos common for those of us who are Western to make mistakes when we

wrestle with Majority World and indigenous ideas Sugirtharajah mentions

our tendency to commodify reduce and institutionalize these ideas We also

risk doing these things (1048625) We apply them in noncontextual prescriptive ways

(1048626) We ignore their meanings in their original setting (1048627) We glamorize or

idealize their proponents or their contexts (1048628) We demonize those persons or

contexts (1048629) We disregard them as irrelevant rhetorical or minority discourse

Kevin J Vanhoozer says that we can fall into three traps when we glo-

calize theology (1048625) We can underestimate the theological significance of

local cultures (1048626) We can homogenize cultures and theologies exaggerating

27R S Sugirtharajah ldquoextual ake-Aways Tird World exts in Western Metropolitan Centresrdquo

Black Teology in Britain A Journal o Contextual Praxis 983090 (1048625983097983097983097) 10486271048627 10486271048631 Edward W Said Te

World the ext and the Critic (Cambridge MA Harvard University Press 10486259830979830961048627) 9830901048627983097

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3536

10486281048626 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

ldquothe onerdquo (1048627) We can overemphasize cultural particularity exaggerating ldquothe

manyrdquo and pursue ldquotheological ethnificationrdquo10486261048632

My hope is that GlobalChurch does not fall into the traps Sugirtharajahand Vanhoozer describe I hope that what unfolds in the following chapters

is respectful and discerning I hope it leads to further mutually enriching

conversations between people of different cultures

You the reader face the same challenges You face them in your personal

life ministry context and missional engagements

Will you treat the themes in this book as abstract theoretical notions

Will this be a temporary infatuation a flirtation with the ldquootherrdquo that dissi-pates as suddenly as it arrived Or will glocal conversations become an en-

riching and formative orientation in your life Will glocal conversations

bring fresh approaches to theology faith mission church and worship Will

conversations with other cultures and theologies become for you a com-

pelling way of life

My prayer is that glocal conversations will help the church be a global

visible alternative ldquocity set upon a hillrdquo a truly GlobalChurch

28Craig Ott and Harold A Netland Globalizing Teology Belie and Practice in an Era o World

Christianity (Grand Rapids Baker Academic 983090983088983088983094) 1048625983090983093

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3636

Page 25: GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2536

10486271048626 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

itself for its missionrdquo He goes on to say ldquoEcclesiology does not precede missi-

ology there cannot be church without an intrinsic missionary dimensionrdquo983089983089

Jesus is Lord Lord of his church and Lord of his world His mission de-termines and forms the church His mission shapes the nature purposes

structures ministries and activities of his church Majority World and in-

digenous thinkers help us understand the implications of this mission Tey

help us form glocal theologies of mission Tey reveal ldquomission in context

as transformationrdquo9830891048626

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-

standing of mission and the missio Dei Church theology and practice Glocal conversations can inform and

enrich many aspects of the church (when practiced well) Teologies and

practices benefit from robust and critical glocal conversations Tese con-

versations enrich many areas (community spirituality discipleship liturgy

worship hospitality eco-justice education social ethics servantship lib-

eration place suffering beauty and so on)

Glocal theology asks How does a glocal conversation shape our under-standing of these many dimensions of church and mission

Glocal processes shape these eight themes and their practices We need

to facilitate and enable these conversations and processes Tis is urgent It

must be a priority No theology of mission or missional ecclesiology is ad-

equate without glocal conversations983089983091

T983144983141 L983151983139983137983148 983137983150983140 G983148983151983138983137983148 E983150983154983145983139983144 E983137983139983144 O983156983144983141983154

Glocalization takes the localparticular context and globaluniversal themes

seriously Contextual and global conversations enter an enriching and in-

forming relationship Tese two always have an active and symbiotic rela-

tionship Tis is true whether we deliberately put them into conversation or

not Te local shapes the global and the global shapes the local Many local

11David J Bosch Believing in the Future oward a Missiology o Western Culture (New York

rinity 1048625983097983097983093) 104862798309012izon ransormation Afer Lausanne 1048631-98309713Not all o these themes are dealt with in this present volume since either (1048625) I have dealt with them

in my book Salt Light and a City (983090) they are not all key themes in the writings o the thirty-five

Majority World thinkers considered in this volume or (1048627) there is not adequate space in a book

this size

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2636

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048627

voices converge to form global conversations and theologies Using the Phil-

ippines as a case study izon illustrates this by showing the interdepen-

dence between local and global themes in mission983089983092Dialogue between local and global conversations is critical Kōsuke

Koyama wrote an important book on contextual mission called Water Buffalo

Teology Koyama is a Japanese missionary who served in Chiang Mai

Tailand He writes of the joys and challenges of doing local particular water

buffalo theology He considers the relationship between local theology global

missional themes and transforming cultures ldquoWater Buffalo Teology sees

certain specific challenges Contextualization of theology implies two criticalmovements First to articulate Jesus Christ in culturally appropriate com-

municatively apt words and second to criticize reform dethrone or oppose

culture if it is found to be against what the name of Jesus Christ stands forrdquo9830891048629

Kōsuke Koyama challenges us to recognize what we bring to the task of

local theology For him it was doing theology in Tailand while being Jap-

anese We also need to notice the particular culture wersquore located in as we do

the work of theology Tis means we avoid speaking of an ldquoAsian theologyrdquoldquoAfrican theologyrdquo and the like We need to cultivate local theologies that

engage regional and global themes But these theologies must be ldquodistinctly

localrdquo and a ldquotheology from belowrdquo9830891048630

Simultaneously we need to pursue a reformation of theology and

practice ldquoin the global contextrdquo Tis means entering ldquothe disturbing spa-

ciousness of Jesus Christrdquo Jesus calls us to reject enmity and exceptionalism

We seem him present in our culture language stories and relationships

But we also choose to embrace the ldquootherrdquo We choose to see him present

in other culturesmdashshaping a global people to serve and worship him

joining in his mission983089983095

Kōsuke Koyama roots the gospel in the local contextual and particular

Tis is why he roots his water buffalo theology in Northern Tai culture He

is careful not to say ldquoHere is how you contextualize in your settingrdquo Instead

14izon ransormation Afer Lausanne 1048631-10486251048627 10486251048628983097-98309098308898309015Kōsuke Koyama Water Buffalo Teology 983090983093th anniversary ed (Maryknoll NY Orbis 1048625983097983097983097)

xiii-xv16Kōsuke Koyama ldquoTe Asian Approach to Christrdquo Missiology 1048625983090 no 1048628 (10486259830979830961048628) 10486281048627983093-104862798309617Kōsuke Koyama ldquoReormation in the Global Context Te Disturbing Spaciousness o Jesus Christrdquo

Currents in Teology and Mission 1048627983088 no 983090 (9830909830889830881048627) 10486251048625983097-983090983096

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2736

10486271048628 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

he tells us a story Itrsquos the story of how he contextualized theology in northern

Tailand while being open to global conversations Koyama asks us to form

our own local expressions of church mission and theology At the same timewe must stay attentive to what God is saying and doing beyond that context

Tis way local and global and particular and universal become mutually

enriching conversation partners

G983148983151983139983137983148983145983162983137983156983145983151983150 983137983150983140 H983145983155983156983151983154983145983139983137983148983148983161 S983145983148983141983150983139983141983140 V983151983145983139983141983155

Glocal theologies and conversations pay attention to voices that powers in-

stitutions religions and societies have silenced R S Sugirtharajah pushesback a little on izonrsquos ideas Sugirtharajah says that the church should

privilege local conversations He emphasizes the local contextual and post-

colonial reading of biblical texts9830891048632

Te church needs to listen Te church ought to be attentive to the

theologies and biblical interpretations of groups that cultures and reli-

gions have ignored Historically powerful secular and religious forces

have silenced these groups Tey have marginalized oppressed and colo-nized them It is time for the church to address this injustice We must

start listening to important but silenced voices We need to privilege the

voices of the former victims of Western colonialism We need to develop

postcolonial biblical interpretations theologies and expressions of church

and mission

How do we take such perspectives seriously as we develop glocal conver-

sations How do these themes help us foster vital relationships between local

and global voices

It is time for us to embrace values that enable conversations with those

oen ignored by the church We need values that help us learn from these

groups and individuals

Valuing equal partnership Colonizing powers oppressed silenced and

colonized certain groups At times the church was complicit Tese colo-

nized groups have become ldquoconfident indomitable and indispensable

partners in the dialogue and collaboration with the dispossessed and disad-

18R S Sugirtharajah Asian Biblical Hermeneutics and Postcolonialism Contesting the Interpreta-

tions Te Bible and Liberation Series (Maryknoll NY Orbis 1048625983097983097983096) 1048625983093-1048625983094

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2836

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048629

vantaged in the Westrdquo9830891048633 Tis calls for attentiveness to these voices and re-

sponsiveness to their prophetic challenges It also demands a critical evalu-

ation of colonial readings of Scripture Colonial models of theology andchurch and mission are no longer the benchmark Te global church must

examine them afresh

Valuing equal status Tose on the margins have now taken their rightful

place on the global stage Tey have claimed appropriate and equal status at

the table Subaltern readings of theology church and mission are invaluable

contributors to global theological conversations Tis means that we esteem

them But we also test themWhat do we mean by subaltern Subalterns are those who are down-

trodden and silenced (or have been treated this way in the past) Dominant

or colonizing groups treat them as invisible nonentities Tey enjoy limited

or no access to power Sometimes these are women certain tribal and ethnic

groups and those considered ldquountouchablerdquo In Voices from the Margin Su-

girtharajah provides a platform for postcolonial subaltern readings of

Scripture and theology Tese readings challenge colonialmdashoen Westernmdashreadings of Bible and theology and cultures Tey claim equal status with

other ways of doing theology10486261048624

Valuing equal identity People groups need freedom to explore their new

and emerging identities Tese emerge in response to local and global influ-

ences Local culture is not the only thing at work here Global forces also

shape identity as do imported practices ideas readings rituals and tech-

nologies But each group should be free to explore and construct their par-

ticular forms of Christian identity

Valuing equal interpretations ldquoPostcolonialism is concerned with the

question of cultural and discursive dominationrdquo Colonialism led to op-

pressive and controlling forms of culture and discourse Tese were usually

not contextual or indigenous Western powers for instance brought co-

lonial forms of theology church biblical interpretation and mission1048626983089

Postcolonialism calls for alternative ways of approaching these things Tose

19Ibid 104862598309420R S Sugirtharajah Voices rom the Margin Interpreting the Bible in the Tird World (Maryknoll

NY Orbis 10486259830979830971048625)21Sugirtharajah Asian Biblical Hermeneutics and Postcolonialism 10486251048631

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2936

10486271048630 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

who were once marginalized oppressed and silenced need to lead these fresh

approaches in their own settings Tese then influence global conversations

We need to support the new readings and insights and experiments from thesegroups o be genuine this support must be both critical and collegial

Valuing equal empowerment Sugirtharajah says that postcolonialism is

valuable when it empowers actual communities and real people Post-

colonial thought empowers when it addresses the difficulties hopes and

experiences of ordinary people It should never be about power plays and

the clever use of language Itrsquos pointless if itrsquos obsessed with forming newmdash

and ldquocolonizingrdquomdashtheories Itrsquos a waste of time if itrsquos a self-indulgent pursuitof new and hybrid identities Rather ldquothe worth and credibility of post-

colonial criticism will be judged by how it orchestrates the unique and

fragile and imagined claims of one community against anotherrdquo Empow-

erment happens in a variety of ways One way is contributing equally to

global conversations10486261048626

Al izon examines postcolonialism in the Philippines He says that it can

teach the global church a lot about healthy local-global conversations Fil-ipino contextual theology resists many Western forms of mission and the-

ology It finds them patronizing and controlling Tis indigenous theology

values prophetic sociopolitical engagement in institutions and the society

at large It emphasizes ministry to whole persons and communities It con-

structs a Filipino theology of beauty and mission and worship and com-

munity And it fosters indigenous theological approaches to the spirit world

and cosmology

izon says that postcolonial theology has played a constructive role in

the Philippines But he is uncomfortable with the label postcolonialism He

prefers to describe historical events as ldquobeyond colonialismrdquo And he says

that global conversations enrich local theologies and vice versa1048626983091

Postcolonial thought informs our understanding of the relationship be-

tween the local and global It also shows how theology can emerge at the

intersection between the localparticular and the globaluniversal It re-

minds us that worthwhile glocalization listens to all voices Tis includes

heeding those that have been historically silenced

22Ibid 983090104862823izon ransormation Afer Lausanne 1048625983088983090 10486259830941048631-9830961048631

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3036

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048631

G983148983151983139983137983148983145983162983137983156983145983151983150 983137983150983140 983156983144983141 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

C983151983150983139983148983157983140983145983150983143 R983141983142983148983141983139983156983145983151983150983155

How do we go about developing a model for glocal conversations izon hasrecently provided a useful model that is instructive as we seek to learn from

the Majority World It has at least two key features

First the local is in the global (globalization from below) Global theologies

and ideas have origins in many particular local contexts In that sense glo-

balization is from below Global ideas have local roots Ideas about integral

mission liberation theology and missional church have local origins Tey

have their roots in the prayers hopes discoveries mission and theologiesof thousands of local communities ldquoTe global does not cannot exist

without the localmdashbut the coming together of localities creates a global re-

ality that becomes greater than the sum of its parts it creates a gestalt entity

to which localities make themselves accountablerdquo1048626983092

Second the global is in the local (panlocalization from above) Te con-

cerns and voices of multitudes of locales form global conversations Tese

global discussions can provide a ldquopositive accountabilityrdquo back to local con-texts Tis is true when they enrich affirm serve guide and strengthen local

contexts It is also true when they avoid homogenization control impo-

sition and judgment Glocalization is best when it sees itself as interde-

pendent deeply connected with the local10486261048629

Tatrsquos a helpful starting point But we need to go further Besides izonrsquos

proposals Irsquom convinced that robust glocal conversations cultivate six core

practices

983089 Glocal theology practices its values We root glocal theology in core

values Tese values include solidarity understanding and mutual learning

Do we value fellowship with Christians of all cultures Do we value learning

from them

We prove our values through our practices What practices emerge out of

these values We need to collaborate act collectively and share information

We must find ways to foster grassroots perspectives and local theologies We

need to share stories and learnings and cultivate networks relationships and

partnerships We need attentiveness to local voices and global themes We

24Ibid 9830901048625983088-1048625104862825Ibid 98309010486251048628-1048625983096

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3136

10486271048632 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

ought to find ways to put these local and global voices into conversation

Mutual learning humility and solidarity are key Worthwhile glocal con-

versations can never be merely theoretical or academic It is up to us to rootour values in our practices

983090 Glocal theology practices humility (and it tells a new narrative) We

have noted that the local is in the global and the global is in the local Te

two are interdependent Tey form each other reciprocally Since this is the

case we must practice humility Tere is no place for ethnocentrism colo-

nialism or theological and cultural arrogance I have seen these unhealthy

postures far too oen in Western settingsRecently I attended a missional leadership conference On that occasion

the keynote speakermdasha leading missional author and speakermdashsaid that

North American missional conversations and innovations hold the key to

the future of the Western church Tis Euro American view is wrong (Irsquom

being kind o be frank itrsquos complete nonsense) Itrsquos arrogant and Euro

Americanndashcentric And itrsquos completely out of step with what is happening in

the glocal church We need a new narrativeIn June 1048626104862410486251048627 Te Center for the Study of Global Christianity reported

the top 10486261048624 countries where Christianity has the highest percentage growth

rate Nineteen of the top twenty are in Asia and Africa Eleven of them are

in Muslim majority countries Not a single country from Europe or North

America makes the top twenty list10486261048630

Itrsquos time to cultivate a new narrative Te future of the church is emerging

from the Majority World Rather than North America the churches of

Eastern Asia Western Africa the Arabian Peninsula and other parts of the

Majority World reveal the future of the global church We need the contribu-

tions of all contexts Western indigenous and Majority World All con-

tribute to glocal conversations All are important as we learn from each

other about mission theology and faith But letrsquos stop pretending that North

Americans and Europeans will reveal the future of the global church Letrsquos

start listening to what God is saying about the future of the global church

And hersquos speaking to us through the churches of Asia Africa Latin America

26Russ Mitchell ldquoTe op 983090983088 Countries Where Christianity Is Growing the Fastestrdquo Disciple All

Nations (blog) August 983090983093 98309098308810486251048627 httpsdiscipleallnationswordpresscom98309098308810486251048627983088983096983090983093the-top

-983090983088-countries-where-christianity-is-growing-the-astest

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3236

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048633

Muslim majority settings and so on We must cultivate a new glocal nar-

rativemdashone soaked in humility

Glocal theology must be humble theology Meek theology Receptive the-ology Discerning theology Prayerful theology Dialogical theology De-

pendent theology A theology that celebrates the interdependence between

the localparticular and the globaluniversal

983091 Glocal theology practices expansiveness Glocalization is by nature

comprehensive Local and global influences permeate much of our lives Tese

glocal forces shape our theologies and churches whether we like it or not

But intentionality is also important We need to commit to an expansiveapproach to glocal theology How do we deliberately cultivate glocal conver-

sations in our biblical interpretation Do we foster them in our under-

standing of the person and work of Christ How does glocalization shape

the way the Spirit empowers and constitutes the church How can it form

our understanding of the nature and mission of the rinity How does it

influence the way we practice fellowship and conversation across denomi-

national cultural ethnic economic sociocultural political gender andtheological divides How might it shape our theologies of mission com-

munity beauty spirituality suffering discipleship hospitality eco-justice

place education social ethics Christian leadership and so forth

983092 Glocal theology practices attention Glocal theology doesnrsquot need to

accept all the assumptions or assertions of postcolonial or Majority World

thought But it does need to engage with them and take them seriously

Postcolonial theology for instance gives the marginalized and colonized

and forgotten and silenced both dignity and voice Our glocal conversations

must also include and esteem these groups We need to be attentive to

others weak and powerful female and male dominant and downtrodden

old and young rich and poor privileged and marginalized influential and

subaltern educated and illiterate We need to practice the art of attention

being especially attentive to those who are different to us

983093 Glocal theology practices embrace What do colonial ethnocentric or

Western-centric perspectives do Tey silence Tey control Tey com-

modify Tey institutionalize Tey colonize Tey domesticate Tey replace

Tey import Tey exclude Tey do these things to the beliefs experiences

and practices of other cultures A worthwhile glocal theology refuses to do

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3336

10486281048624 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

these things Instead it adopts a responsive humble celebratory open in-

clusive and embracing attitude

983094 Glocal theology practices discernment Finally we need discernmentas we engage these ideas and practices Discernment is a huge topic thatrsquos

hard to cover comprehensively in a few words Discernment happens when

the Spirit of Christ and his Word renew our minds Te Spirit grants us

spiritual wisdom as we meditate on him and his Word and as we practice

discipleship to Jesus Christ Romans 10486251048626 provides guidance we need (1048625) to be

transformed by the renewal of our minds (1048626) to serve Christrsquos body and (1048627)

to put love into action Discernment also happens in conversation both lo-cally and glocally

I pray these core values and six practices come across in the following

chapters of GlobalChurch

Glocalization can never be just theoretical Are we committed to moving

glocalization from an abstract idea to a living communion Are we deter-

mined to construct a missional theology of the church in the context of

glocal conversations Tis must involve dialogue between Majority Worldindigenous and Western scholars activists and groups

Will glocalization be an abstract notion Or will it be a formative and

genuine communion between local regional and global voices Glocal dy-

namics are at play whether we like it or not Teyrsquore in our churches the-

ologies and missions But we can choose to relinquish isolationist colonial

parochial and arrogant approaches Instead we can adopt responsive dia-

logical learning humble and embracing postures

Trough healthy approaches to glocalization the Spirit challenges us to

value local contexts We immerse ourselves in local and particular commu-

nities and conversations He inspires us to open ourselves to global theo-

logical conversations He rouses us to value the symbiotic relationship be-

tween the localparticular and the globaluniversal

Trough glocal relationships the Spirit leads us to put local contextual

theologies into conversation with global ones He prompts us to explore the

ways in which the local is in the glocal and the global is in the local He per-

suades us to pursue collaboration and dialogue and mutual learning We

engage with Christians from different backgrounds and cultures ecumen-

icals Pentecostals evangelicals and so on from Western indigenous and

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3436

Glocalizing Conversations 10486281048625

Majority World contexts He motivates us to express solidarity between all

parties We appreciate our unity in diversity

Trough glocal conversations the Spirit moves us to ensure that unity andsolidarity emerge from a compelling vision of Jesusrsquo kingdom and gospel

and person He challenges us to share information theology and practices

He urges us to learn from each othermdashour successes and mistakes We seek

glocal solutions

Te Spirit calls us to develop glocal conversations about Christian ideas

and practices Tese include Scripture Evangelicalism ecumenism Pente-

costalism Jesus Christ the Holy Spirit God the Father the rinity com-munity spirituality discipleship liturgy worship hospitality prayer eco-

justice education social ethics Christian leadership gospel and culture

beauty place suffering liberation and so forth

Finally through glocal conversations the Spirit leads us to adopt a new

posture Tis is a responsive humble celebratory open inclusive and em-

bracing attitude to the ldquootherrdquo We do this as a new people made up of every

tribe and language and people and nationTere are dangers in glocalization Sugirtharajah warns of the commodi-

fication of local contextual practices and theologies When this happens

they are ldquosmoothed out of their primary contexts concerns and contesta-

tions travel across borders and become objects of analysis and scrutiny

within an alien secondary contextrdquo1048626983095

Itrsquos common for those of us who are Western to make mistakes when we

wrestle with Majority World and indigenous ideas Sugirtharajah mentions

our tendency to commodify reduce and institutionalize these ideas We also

risk doing these things (1048625) We apply them in noncontextual prescriptive ways

(1048626) We ignore their meanings in their original setting (1048627) We glamorize or

idealize their proponents or their contexts (1048628) We demonize those persons or

contexts (1048629) We disregard them as irrelevant rhetorical or minority discourse

Kevin J Vanhoozer says that we can fall into three traps when we glo-

calize theology (1048625) We can underestimate the theological significance of

local cultures (1048626) We can homogenize cultures and theologies exaggerating

27R S Sugirtharajah ldquoextual ake-Aways Tird World exts in Western Metropolitan Centresrdquo

Black Teology in Britain A Journal o Contextual Praxis 983090 (1048625983097983097983097) 10486271048627 10486271048631 Edward W Said Te

World the ext and the Critic (Cambridge MA Harvard University Press 10486259830979830961048627) 9830901048627983097

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3536

10486281048626 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

ldquothe onerdquo (1048627) We can overemphasize cultural particularity exaggerating ldquothe

manyrdquo and pursue ldquotheological ethnificationrdquo10486261048632

My hope is that GlobalChurch does not fall into the traps Sugirtharajahand Vanhoozer describe I hope that what unfolds in the following chapters

is respectful and discerning I hope it leads to further mutually enriching

conversations between people of different cultures

You the reader face the same challenges You face them in your personal

life ministry context and missional engagements

Will you treat the themes in this book as abstract theoretical notions

Will this be a temporary infatuation a flirtation with the ldquootherrdquo that dissi-pates as suddenly as it arrived Or will glocal conversations become an en-

riching and formative orientation in your life Will glocal conversations

bring fresh approaches to theology faith mission church and worship Will

conversations with other cultures and theologies become for you a com-

pelling way of life

My prayer is that glocal conversations will help the church be a global

visible alternative ldquocity set upon a hillrdquo a truly GlobalChurch

28Craig Ott and Harold A Netland Globalizing Teology Belie and Practice in an Era o World

Christianity (Grand Rapids Baker Academic 983090983088983088983094) 1048625983090983093

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3636

Page 26: GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2636

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048627

voices converge to form global conversations and theologies Using the Phil-

ippines as a case study izon illustrates this by showing the interdepen-

dence between local and global themes in mission983089983092Dialogue between local and global conversations is critical Kōsuke

Koyama wrote an important book on contextual mission called Water Buffalo

Teology Koyama is a Japanese missionary who served in Chiang Mai

Tailand He writes of the joys and challenges of doing local particular water

buffalo theology He considers the relationship between local theology global

missional themes and transforming cultures ldquoWater Buffalo Teology sees

certain specific challenges Contextualization of theology implies two criticalmovements First to articulate Jesus Christ in culturally appropriate com-

municatively apt words and second to criticize reform dethrone or oppose

culture if it is found to be against what the name of Jesus Christ stands forrdquo9830891048629

Kōsuke Koyama challenges us to recognize what we bring to the task of

local theology For him it was doing theology in Tailand while being Jap-

anese We also need to notice the particular culture wersquore located in as we do

the work of theology Tis means we avoid speaking of an ldquoAsian theologyrdquoldquoAfrican theologyrdquo and the like We need to cultivate local theologies that

engage regional and global themes But these theologies must be ldquodistinctly

localrdquo and a ldquotheology from belowrdquo9830891048630

Simultaneously we need to pursue a reformation of theology and

practice ldquoin the global contextrdquo Tis means entering ldquothe disturbing spa-

ciousness of Jesus Christrdquo Jesus calls us to reject enmity and exceptionalism

We seem him present in our culture language stories and relationships

But we also choose to embrace the ldquootherrdquo We choose to see him present

in other culturesmdashshaping a global people to serve and worship him

joining in his mission983089983095

Kōsuke Koyama roots the gospel in the local contextual and particular

Tis is why he roots his water buffalo theology in Northern Tai culture He

is careful not to say ldquoHere is how you contextualize in your settingrdquo Instead

14izon ransormation Afer Lausanne 1048631-10486251048627 10486251048628983097-98309098308898309015Kōsuke Koyama Water Buffalo Teology 983090983093th anniversary ed (Maryknoll NY Orbis 1048625983097983097983097)

xiii-xv16Kōsuke Koyama ldquoTe Asian Approach to Christrdquo Missiology 1048625983090 no 1048628 (10486259830979830961048628) 10486281048627983093-104862798309617Kōsuke Koyama ldquoReormation in the Global Context Te Disturbing Spaciousness o Jesus Christrdquo

Currents in Teology and Mission 1048627983088 no 983090 (9830909830889830881048627) 10486251048625983097-983090983096

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2736

10486271048628 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

he tells us a story Itrsquos the story of how he contextualized theology in northern

Tailand while being open to global conversations Koyama asks us to form

our own local expressions of church mission and theology At the same timewe must stay attentive to what God is saying and doing beyond that context

Tis way local and global and particular and universal become mutually

enriching conversation partners

G983148983151983139983137983148983145983162983137983156983145983151983150 983137983150983140 H983145983155983156983151983154983145983139983137983148983148983161 S983145983148983141983150983139983141983140 V983151983145983139983141983155

Glocal theologies and conversations pay attention to voices that powers in-

stitutions religions and societies have silenced R S Sugirtharajah pushesback a little on izonrsquos ideas Sugirtharajah says that the church should

privilege local conversations He emphasizes the local contextual and post-

colonial reading of biblical texts9830891048632

Te church needs to listen Te church ought to be attentive to the

theologies and biblical interpretations of groups that cultures and reli-

gions have ignored Historically powerful secular and religious forces

have silenced these groups Tey have marginalized oppressed and colo-nized them It is time for the church to address this injustice We must

start listening to important but silenced voices We need to privilege the

voices of the former victims of Western colonialism We need to develop

postcolonial biblical interpretations theologies and expressions of church

and mission

How do we take such perspectives seriously as we develop glocal conver-

sations How do these themes help us foster vital relationships between local

and global voices

It is time for us to embrace values that enable conversations with those

oen ignored by the church We need values that help us learn from these

groups and individuals

Valuing equal partnership Colonizing powers oppressed silenced and

colonized certain groups At times the church was complicit Tese colo-

nized groups have become ldquoconfident indomitable and indispensable

partners in the dialogue and collaboration with the dispossessed and disad-

18R S Sugirtharajah Asian Biblical Hermeneutics and Postcolonialism Contesting the Interpreta-

tions Te Bible and Liberation Series (Maryknoll NY Orbis 1048625983097983097983096) 1048625983093-1048625983094

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2836

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048629

vantaged in the Westrdquo9830891048633 Tis calls for attentiveness to these voices and re-

sponsiveness to their prophetic challenges It also demands a critical evalu-

ation of colonial readings of Scripture Colonial models of theology andchurch and mission are no longer the benchmark Te global church must

examine them afresh

Valuing equal status Tose on the margins have now taken their rightful

place on the global stage Tey have claimed appropriate and equal status at

the table Subaltern readings of theology church and mission are invaluable

contributors to global theological conversations Tis means that we esteem

them But we also test themWhat do we mean by subaltern Subalterns are those who are down-

trodden and silenced (or have been treated this way in the past) Dominant

or colonizing groups treat them as invisible nonentities Tey enjoy limited

or no access to power Sometimes these are women certain tribal and ethnic

groups and those considered ldquountouchablerdquo In Voices from the Margin Su-

girtharajah provides a platform for postcolonial subaltern readings of

Scripture and theology Tese readings challenge colonialmdashoen Westernmdashreadings of Bible and theology and cultures Tey claim equal status with

other ways of doing theology10486261048624

Valuing equal identity People groups need freedom to explore their new

and emerging identities Tese emerge in response to local and global influ-

ences Local culture is not the only thing at work here Global forces also

shape identity as do imported practices ideas readings rituals and tech-

nologies But each group should be free to explore and construct their par-

ticular forms of Christian identity

Valuing equal interpretations ldquoPostcolonialism is concerned with the

question of cultural and discursive dominationrdquo Colonialism led to op-

pressive and controlling forms of culture and discourse Tese were usually

not contextual or indigenous Western powers for instance brought co-

lonial forms of theology church biblical interpretation and mission1048626983089

Postcolonialism calls for alternative ways of approaching these things Tose

19Ibid 104862598309420R S Sugirtharajah Voices rom the Margin Interpreting the Bible in the Tird World (Maryknoll

NY Orbis 10486259830979830971048625)21Sugirtharajah Asian Biblical Hermeneutics and Postcolonialism 10486251048631

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2936

10486271048630 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

who were once marginalized oppressed and silenced need to lead these fresh

approaches in their own settings Tese then influence global conversations

We need to support the new readings and insights and experiments from thesegroups o be genuine this support must be both critical and collegial

Valuing equal empowerment Sugirtharajah says that postcolonialism is

valuable when it empowers actual communities and real people Post-

colonial thought empowers when it addresses the difficulties hopes and

experiences of ordinary people It should never be about power plays and

the clever use of language Itrsquos pointless if itrsquos obsessed with forming newmdash

and ldquocolonizingrdquomdashtheories Itrsquos a waste of time if itrsquos a self-indulgent pursuitof new and hybrid identities Rather ldquothe worth and credibility of post-

colonial criticism will be judged by how it orchestrates the unique and

fragile and imagined claims of one community against anotherrdquo Empow-

erment happens in a variety of ways One way is contributing equally to

global conversations10486261048626

Al izon examines postcolonialism in the Philippines He says that it can

teach the global church a lot about healthy local-global conversations Fil-ipino contextual theology resists many Western forms of mission and the-

ology It finds them patronizing and controlling Tis indigenous theology

values prophetic sociopolitical engagement in institutions and the society

at large It emphasizes ministry to whole persons and communities It con-

structs a Filipino theology of beauty and mission and worship and com-

munity And it fosters indigenous theological approaches to the spirit world

and cosmology

izon says that postcolonial theology has played a constructive role in

the Philippines But he is uncomfortable with the label postcolonialism He

prefers to describe historical events as ldquobeyond colonialismrdquo And he says

that global conversations enrich local theologies and vice versa1048626983091

Postcolonial thought informs our understanding of the relationship be-

tween the local and global It also shows how theology can emerge at the

intersection between the localparticular and the globaluniversal It re-

minds us that worthwhile glocalization listens to all voices Tis includes

heeding those that have been historically silenced

22Ibid 983090104862823izon ransormation Afer Lausanne 1048625983088983090 10486259830941048631-9830961048631

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3036

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048631

G983148983151983139983137983148983145983162983137983156983145983151983150 983137983150983140 983156983144983141 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

C983151983150983139983148983157983140983145983150983143 R983141983142983148983141983139983156983145983151983150983155

How do we go about developing a model for glocal conversations izon hasrecently provided a useful model that is instructive as we seek to learn from

the Majority World It has at least two key features

First the local is in the global (globalization from below) Global theologies

and ideas have origins in many particular local contexts In that sense glo-

balization is from below Global ideas have local roots Ideas about integral

mission liberation theology and missional church have local origins Tey

have their roots in the prayers hopes discoveries mission and theologiesof thousands of local communities ldquoTe global does not cannot exist

without the localmdashbut the coming together of localities creates a global re-

ality that becomes greater than the sum of its parts it creates a gestalt entity

to which localities make themselves accountablerdquo1048626983092

Second the global is in the local (panlocalization from above) Te con-

cerns and voices of multitudes of locales form global conversations Tese

global discussions can provide a ldquopositive accountabilityrdquo back to local con-texts Tis is true when they enrich affirm serve guide and strengthen local

contexts It is also true when they avoid homogenization control impo-

sition and judgment Glocalization is best when it sees itself as interde-

pendent deeply connected with the local10486261048629

Tatrsquos a helpful starting point But we need to go further Besides izonrsquos

proposals Irsquom convinced that robust glocal conversations cultivate six core

practices

983089 Glocal theology practices its values We root glocal theology in core

values Tese values include solidarity understanding and mutual learning

Do we value fellowship with Christians of all cultures Do we value learning

from them

We prove our values through our practices What practices emerge out of

these values We need to collaborate act collectively and share information

We must find ways to foster grassroots perspectives and local theologies We

need to share stories and learnings and cultivate networks relationships and

partnerships We need attentiveness to local voices and global themes We

24Ibid 9830901048625983088-1048625104862825Ibid 98309010486251048628-1048625983096

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3136

10486271048632 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

ought to find ways to put these local and global voices into conversation

Mutual learning humility and solidarity are key Worthwhile glocal con-

versations can never be merely theoretical or academic It is up to us to rootour values in our practices

983090 Glocal theology practices humility (and it tells a new narrative) We

have noted that the local is in the global and the global is in the local Te

two are interdependent Tey form each other reciprocally Since this is the

case we must practice humility Tere is no place for ethnocentrism colo-

nialism or theological and cultural arrogance I have seen these unhealthy

postures far too oen in Western settingsRecently I attended a missional leadership conference On that occasion

the keynote speakermdasha leading missional author and speakermdashsaid that

North American missional conversations and innovations hold the key to

the future of the Western church Tis Euro American view is wrong (Irsquom

being kind o be frank itrsquos complete nonsense) Itrsquos arrogant and Euro

Americanndashcentric And itrsquos completely out of step with what is happening in

the glocal church We need a new narrativeIn June 1048626104862410486251048627 Te Center for the Study of Global Christianity reported

the top 10486261048624 countries where Christianity has the highest percentage growth

rate Nineteen of the top twenty are in Asia and Africa Eleven of them are

in Muslim majority countries Not a single country from Europe or North

America makes the top twenty list10486261048630

Itrsquos time to cultivate a new narrative Te future of the church is emerging

from the Majority World Rather than North America the churches of

Eastern Asia Western Africa the Arabian Peninsula and other parts of the

Majority World reveal the future of the global church We need the contribu-

tions of all contexts Western indigenous and Majority World All con-

tribute to glocal conversations All are important as we learn from each

other about mission theology and faith But letrsquos stop pretending that North

Americans and Europeans will reveal the future of the global church Letrsquos

start listening to what God is saying about the future of the global church

And hersquos speaking to us through the churches of Asia Africa Latin America

26Russ Mitchell ldquoTe op 983090983088 Countries Where Christianity Is Growing the Fastestrdquo Disciple All

Nations (blog) August 983090983093 98309098308810486251048627 httpsdiscipleallnationswordpresscom98309098308810486251048627983088983096983090983093the-top

-983090983088-countries-where-christianity-is-growing-the-astest

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3236

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048633

Muslim majority settings and so on We must cultivate a new glocal nar-

rativemdashone soaked in humility

Glocal theology must be humble theology Meek theology Receptive the-ology Discerning theology Prayerful theology Dialogical theology De-

pendent theology A theology that celebrates the interdependence between

the localparticular and the globaluniversal

983091 Glocal theology practices expansiveness Glocalization is by nature

comprehensive Local and global influences permeate much of our lives Tese

glocal forces shape our theologies and churches whether we like it or not

But intentionality is also important We need to commit to an expansiveapproach to glocal theology How do we deliberately cultivate glocal conver-

sations in our biblical interpretation Do we foster them in our under-

standing of the person and work of Christ How does glocalization shape

the way the Spirit empowers and constitutes the church How can it form

our understanding of the nature and mission of the rinity How does it

influence the way we practice fellowship and conversation across denomi-

national cultural ethnic economic sociocultural political gender andtheological divides How might it shape our theologies of mission com-

munity beauty spirituality suffering discipleship hospitality eco-justice

place education social ethics Christian leadership and so forth

983092 Glocal theology practices attention Glocal theology doesnrsquot need to

accept all the assumptions or assertions of postcolonial or Majority World

thought But it does need to engage with them and take them seriously

Postcolonial theology for instance gives the marginalized and colonized

and forgotten and silenced both dignity and voice Our glocal conversations

must also include and esteem these groups We need to be attentive to

others weak and powerful female and male dominant and downtrodden

old and young rich and poor privileged and marginalized influential and

subaltern educated and illiterate We need to practice the art of attention

being especially attentive to those who are different to us

983093 Glocal theology practices embrace What do colonial ethnocentric or

Western-centric perspectives do Tey silence Tey control Tey com-

modify Tey institutionalize Tey colonize Tey domesticate Tey replace

Tey import Tey exclude Tey do these things to the beliefs experiences

and practices of other cultures A worthwhile glocal theology refuses to do

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3336

10486281048624 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

these things Instead it adopts a responsive humble celebratory open in-

clusive and embracing attitude

983094 Glocal theology practices discernment Finally we need discernmentas we engage these ideas and practices Discernment is a huge topic thatrsquos

hard to cover comprehensively in a few words Discernment happens when

the Spirit of Christ and his Word renew our minds Te Spirit grants us

spiritual wisdom as we meditate on him and his Word and as we practice

discipleship to Jesus Christ Romans 10486251048626 provides guidance we need (1048625) to be

transformed by the renewal of our minds (1048626) to serve Christrsquos body and (1048627)

to put love into action Discernment also happens in conversation both lo-cally and glocally

I pray these core values and six practices come across in the following

chapters of GlobalChurch

Glocalization can never be just theoretical Are we committed to moving

glocalization from an abstract idea to a living communion Are we deter-

mined to construct a missional theology of the church in the context of

glocal conversations Tis must involve dialogue between Majority Worldindigenous and Western scholars activists and groups

Will glocalization be an abstract notion Or will it be a formative and

genuine communion between local regional and global voices Glocal dy-

namics are at play whether we like it or not Teyrsquore in our churches the-

ologies and missions But we can choose to relinquish isolationist colonial

parochial and arrogant approaches Instead we can adopt responsive dia-

logical learning humble and embracing postures

Trough healthy approaches to glocalization the Spirit challenges us to

value local contexts We immerse ourselves in local and particular commu-

nities and conversations He inspires us to open ourselves to global theo-

logical conversations He rouses us to value the symbiotic relationship be-

tween the localparticular and the globaluniversal

Trough glocal relationships the Spirit leads us to put local contextual

theologies into conversation with global ones He prompts us to explore the

ways in which the local is in the glocal and the global is in the local He per-

suades us to pursue collaboration and dialogue and mutual learning We

engage with Christians from different backgrounds and cultures ecumen-

icals Pentecostals evangelicals and so on from Western indigenous and

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3436

Glocalizing Conversations 10486281048625

Majority World contexts He motivates us to express solidarity between all

parties We appreciate our unity in diversity

Trough glocal conversations the Spirit moves us to ensure that unity andsolidarity emerge from a compelling vision of Jesusrsquo kingdom and gospel

and person He challenges us to share information theology and practices

He urges us to learn from each othermdashour successes and mistakes We seek

glocal solutions

Te Spirit calls us to develop glocal conversations about Christian ideas

and practices Tese include Scripture Evangelicalism ecumenism Pente-

costalism Jesus Christ the Holy Spirit God the Father the rinity com-munity spirituality discipleship liturgy worship hospitality prayer eco-

justice education social ethics Christian leadership gospel and culture

beauty place suffering liberation and so forth

Finally through glocal conversations the Spirit leads us to adopt a new

posture Tis is a responsive humble celebratory open inclusive and em-

bracing attitude to the ldquootherrdquo We do this as a new people made up of every

tribe and language and people and nationTere are dangers in glocalization Sugirtharajah warns of the commodi-

fication of local contextual practices and theologies When this happens

they are ldquosmoothed out of their primary contexts concerns and contesta-

tions travel across borders and become objects of analysis and scrutiny

within an alien secondary contextrdquo1048626983095

Itrsquos common for those of us who are Western to make mistakes when we

wrestle with Majority World and indigenous ideas Sugirtharajah mentions

our tendency to commodify reduce and institutionalize these ideas We also

risk doing these things (1048625) We apply them in noncontextual prescriptive ways

(1048626) We ignore their meanings in their original setting (1048627) We glamorize or

idealize their proponents or their contexts (1048628) We demonize those persons or

contexts (1048629) We disregard them as irrelevant rhetorical or minority discourse

Kevin J Vanhoozer says that we can fall into three traps when we glo-

calize theology (1048625) We can underestimate the theological significance of

local cultures (1048626) We can homogenize cultures and theologies exaggerating

27R S Sugirtharajah ldquoextual ake-Aways Tird World exts in Western Metropolitan Centresrdquo

Black Teology in Britain A Journal o Contextual Praxis 983090 (1048625983097983097983097) 10486271048627 10486271048631 Edward W Said Te

World the ext and the Critic (Cambridge MA Harvard University Press 10486259830979830961048627) 9830901048627983097

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3536

10486281048626 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

ldquothe onerdquo (1048627) We can overemphasize cultural particularity exaggerating ldquothe

manyrdquo and pursue ldquotheological ethnificationrdquo10486261048632

My hope is that GlobalChurch does not fall into the traps Sugirtharajahand Vanhoozer describe I hope that what unfolds in the following chapters

is respectful and discerning I hope it leads to further mutually enriching

conversations between people of different cultures

You the reader face the same challenges You face them in your personal

life ministry context and missional engagements

Will you treat the themes in this book as abstract theoretical notions

Will this be a temporary infatuation a flirtation with the ldquootherrdquo that dissi-pates as suddenly as it arrived Or will glocal conversations become an en-

riching and formative orientation in your life Will glocal conversations

bring fresh approaches to theology faith mission church and worship Will

conversations with other cultures and theologies become for you a com-

pelling way of life

My prayer is that glocal conversations will help the church be a global

visible alternative ldquocity set upon a hillrdquo a truly GlobalChurch

28Craig Ott and Harold A Netland Globalizing Teology Belie and Practice in an Era o World

Christianity (Grand Rapids Baker Academic 983090983088983088983094) 1048625983090983093

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3636

Page 27: GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2736

10486271048628 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

he tells us a story Itrsquos the story of how he contextualized theology in northern

Tailand while being open to global conversations Koyama asks us to form

our own local expressions of church mission and theology At the same timewe must stay attentive to what God is saying and doing beyond that context

Tis way local and global and particular and universal become mutually

enriching conversation partners

G983148983151983139983137983148983145983162983137983156983145983151983150 983137983150983140 H983145983155983156983151983154983145983139983137983148983148983161 S983145983148983141983150983139983141983140 V983151983145983139983141983155

Glocal theologies and conversations pay attention to voices that powers in-

stitutions religions and societies have silenced R S Sugirtharajah pushesback a little on izonrsquos ideas Sugirtharajah says that the church should

privilege local conversations He emphasizes the local contextual and post-

colonial reading of biblical texts9830891048632

Te church needs to listen Te church ought to be attentive to the

theologies and biblical interpretations of groups that cultures and reli-

gions have ignored Historically powerful secular and religious forces

have silenced these groups Tey have marginalized oppressed and colo-nized them It is time for the church to address this injustice We must

start listening to important but silenced voices We need to privilege the

voices of the former victims of Western colonialism We need to develop

postcolonial biblical interpretations theologies and expressions of church

and mission

How do we take such perspectives seriously as we develop glocal conver-

sations How do these themes help us foster vital relationships between local

and global voices

It is time for us to embrace values that enable conversations with those

oen ignored by the church We need values that help us learn from these

groups and individuals

Valuing equal partnership Colonizing powers oppressed silenced and

colonized certain groups At times the church was complicit Tese colo-

nized groups have become ldquoconfident indomitable and indispensable

partners in the dialogue and collaboration with the dispossessed and disad-

18R S Sugirtharajah Asian Biblical Hermeneutics and Postcolonialism Contesting the Interpreta-

tions Te Bible and Liberation Series (Maryknoll NY Orbis 1048625983097983097983096) 1048625983093-1048625983094

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2836

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048629

vantaged in the Westrdquo9830891048633 Tis calls for attentiveness to these voices and re-

sponsiveness to their prophetic challenges It also demands a critical evalu-

ation of colonial readings of Scripture Colonial models of theology andchurch and mission are no longer the benchmark Te global church must

examine them afresh

Valuing equal status Tose on the margins have now taken their rightful

place on the global stage Tey have claimed appropriate and equal status at

the table Subaltern readings of theology church and mission are invaluable

contributors to global theological conversations Tis means that we esteem

them But we also test themWhat do we mean by subaltern Subalterns are those who are down-

trodden and silenced (or have been treated this way in the past) Dominant

or colonizing groups treat them as invisible nonentities Tey enjoy limited

or no access to power Sometimes these are women certain tribal and ethnic

groups and those considered ldquountouchablerdquo In Voices from the Margin Su-

girtharajah provides a platform for postcolonial subaltern readings of

Scripture and theology Tese readings challenge colonialmdashoen Westernmdashreadings of Bible and theology and cultures Tey claim equal status with

other ways of doing theology10486261048624

Valuing equal identity People groups need freedom to explore their new

and emerging identities Tese emerge in response to local and global influ-

ences Local culture is not the only thing at work here Global forces also

shape identity as do imported practices ideas readings rituals and tech-

nologies But each group should be free to explore and construct their par-

ticular forms of Christian identity

Valuing equal interpretations ldquoPostcolonialism is concerned with the

question of cultural and discursive dominationrdquo Colonialism led to op-

pressive and controlling forms of culture and discourse Tese were usually

not contextual or indigenous Western powers for instance brought co-

lonial forms of theology church biblical interpretation and mission1048626983089

Postcolonialism calls for alternative ways of approaching these things Tose

19Ibid 104862598309420R S Sugirtharajah Voices rom the Margin Interpreting the Bible in the Tird World (Maryknoll

NY Orbis 10486259830979830971048625)21Sugirtharajah Asian Biblical Hermeneutics and Postcolonialism 10486251048631

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2936

10486271048630 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

who were once marginalized oppressed and silenced need to lead these fresh

approaches in their own settings Tese then influence global conversations

We need to support the new readings and insights and experiments from thesegroups o be genuine this support must be both critical and collegial

Valuing equal empowerment Sugirtharajah says that postcolonialism is

valuable when it empowers actual communities and real people Post-

colonial thought empowers when it addresses the difficulties hopes and

experiences of ordinary people It should never be about power plays and

the clever use of language Itrsquos pointless if itrsquos obsessed with forming newmdash

and ldquocolonizingrdquomdashtheories Itrsquos a waste of time if itrsquos a self-indulgent pursuitof new and hybrid identities Rather ldquothe worth and credibility of post-

colonial criticism will be judged by how it orchestrates the unique and

fragile and imagined claims of one community against anotherrdquo Empow-

erment happens in a variety of ways One way is contributing equally to

global conversations10486261048626

Al izon examines postcolonialism in the Philippines He says that it can

teach the global church a lot about healthy local-global conversations Fil-ipino contextual theology resists many Western forms of mission and the-

ology It finds them patronizing and controlling Tis indigenous theology

values prophetic sociopolitical engagement in institutions and the society

at large It emphasizes ministry to whole persons and communities It con-

structs a Filipino theology of beauty and mission and worship and com-

munity And it fosters indigenous theological approaches to the spirit world

and cosmology

izon says that postcolonial theology has played a constructive role in

the Philippines But he is uncomfortable with the label postcolonialism He

prefers to describe historical events as ldquobeyond colonialismrdquo And he says

that global conversations enrich local theologies and vice versa1048626983091

Postcolonial thought informs our understanding of the relationship be-

tween the local and global It also shows how theology can emerge at the

intersection between the localparticular and the globaluniversal It re-

minds us that worthwhile glocalization listens to all voices Tis includes

heeding those that have been historically silenced

22Ibid 983090104862823izon ransormation Afer Lausanne 1048625983088983090 10486259830941048631-9830961048631

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3036

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048631

G983148983151983139983137983148983145983162983137983156983145983151983150 983137983150983140 983156983144983141 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

C983151983150983139983148983157983140983145983150983143 R983141983142983148983141983139983156983145983151983150983155

How do we go about developing a model for glocal conversations izon hasrecently provided a useful model that is instructive as we seek to learn from

the Majority World It has at least two key features

First the local is in the global (globalization from below) Global theologies

and ideas have origins in many particular local contexts In that sense glo-

balization is from below Global ideas have local roots Ideas about integral

mission liberation theology and missional church have local origins Tey

have their roots in the prayers hopes discoveries mission and theologiesof thousands of local communities ldquoTe global does not cannot exist

without the localmdashbut the coming together of localities creates a global re-

ality that becomes greater than the sum of its parts it creates a gestalt entity

to which localities make themselves accountablerdquo1048626983092

Second the global is in the local (panlocalization from above) Te con-

cerns and voices of multitudes of locales form global conversations Tese

global discussions can provide a ldquopositive accountabilityrdquo back to local con-texts Tis is true when they enrich affirm serve guide and strengthen local

contexts It is also true when they avoid homogenization control impo-

sition and judgment Glocalization is best when it sees itself as interde-

pendent deeply connected with the local10486261048629

Tatrsquos a helpful starting point But we need to go further Besides izonrsquos

proposals Irsquom convinced that robust glocal conversations cultivate six core

practices

983089 Glocal theology practices its values We root glocal theology in core

values Tese values include solidarity understanding and mutual learning

Do we value fellowship with Christians of all cultures Do we value learning

from them

We prove our values through our practices What practices emerge out of

these values We need to collaborate act collectively and share information

We must find ways to foster grassroots perspectives and local theologies We

need to share stories and learnings and cultivate networks relationships and

partnerships We need attentiveness to local voices and global themes We

24Ibid 9830901048625983088-1048625104862825Ibid 98309010486251048628-1048625983096

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3136

10486271048632 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

ought to find ways to put these local and global voices into conversation

Mutual learning humility and solidarity are key Worthwhile glocal con-

versations can never be merely theoretical or academic It is up to us to rootour values in our practices

983090 Glocal theology practices humility (and it tells a new narrative) We

have noted that the local is in the global and the global is in the local Te

two are interdependent Tey form each other reciprocally Since this is the

case we must practice humility Tere is no place for ethnocentrism colo-

nialism or theological and cultural arrogance I have seen these unhealthy

postures far too oen in Western settingsRecently I attended a missional leadership conference On that occasion

the keynote speakermdasha leading missional author and speakermdashsaid that

North American missional conversations and innovations hold the key to

the future of the Western church Tis Euro American view is wrong (Irsquom

being kind o be frank itrsquos complete nonsense) Itrsquos arrogant and Euro

Americanndashcentric And itrsquos completely out of step with what is happening in

the glocal church We need a new narrativeIn June 1048626104862410486251048627 Te Center for the Study of Global Christianity reported

the top 10486261048624 countries where Christianity has the highest percentage growth

rate Nineteen of the top twenty are in Asia and Africa Eleven of them are

in Muslim majority countries Not a single country from Europe or North

America makes the top twenty list10486261048630

Itrsquos time to cultivate a new narrative Te future of the church is emerging

from the Majority World Rather than North America the churches of

Eastern Asia Western Africa the Arabian Peninsula and other parts of the

Majority World reveal the future of the global church We need the contribu-

tions of all contexts Western indigenous and Majority World All con-

tribute to glocal conversations All are important as we learn from each

other about mission theology and faith But letrsquos stop pretending that North

Americans and Europeans will reveal the future of the global church Letrsquos

start listening to what God is saying about the future of the global church

And hersquos speaking to us through the churches of Asia Africa Latin America

26Russ Mitchell ldquoTe op 983090983088 Countries Where Christianity Is Growing the Fastestrdquo Disciple All

Nations (blog) August 983090983093 98309098308810486251048627 httpsdiscipleallnationswordpresscom98309098308810486251048627983088983096983090983093the-top

-983090983088-countries-where-christianity-is-growing-the-astest

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3236

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048633

Muslim majority settings and so on We must cultivate a new glocal nar-

rativemdashone soaked in humility

Glocal theology must be humble theology Meek theology Receptive the-ology Discerning theology Prayerful theology Dialogical theology De-

pendent theology A theology that celebrates the interdependence between

the localparticular and the globaluniversal

983091 Glocal theology practices expansiveness Glocalization is by nature

comprehensive Local and global influences permeate much of our lives Tese

glocal forces shape our theologies and churches whether we like it or not

But intentionality is also important We need to commit to an expansiveapproach to glocal theology How do we deliberately cultivate glocal conver-

sations in our biblical interpretation Do we foster them in our under-

standing of the person and work of Christ How does glocalization shape

the way the Spirit empowers and constitutes the church How can it form

our understanding of the nature and mission of the rinity How does it

influence the way we practice fellowship and conversation across denomi-

national cultural ethnic economic sociocultural political gender andtheological divides How might it shape our theologies of mission com-

munity beauty spirituality suffering discipleship hospitality eco-justice

place education social ethics Christian leadership and so forth

983092 Glocal theology practices attention Glocal theology doesnrsquot need to

accept all the assumptions or assertions of postcolonial or Majority World

thought But it does need to engage with them and take them seriously

Postcolonial theology for instance gives the marginalized and colonized

and forgotten and silenced both dignity and voice Our glocal conversations

must also include and esteem these groups We need to be attentive to

others weak and powerful female and male dominant and downtrodden

old and young rich and poor privileged and marginalized influential and

subaltern educated and illiterate We need to practice the art of attention

being especially attentive to those who are different to us

983093 Glocal theology practices embrace What do colonial ethnocentric or

Western-centric perspectives do Tey silence Tey control Tey com-

modify Tey institutionalize Tey colonize Tey domesticate Tey replace

Tey import Tey exclude Tey do these things to the beliefs experiences

and practices of other cultures A worthwhile glocal theology refuses to do

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3336

10486281048624 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

these things Instead it adopts a responsive humble celebratory open in-

clusive and embracing attitude

983094 Glocal theology practices discernment Finally we need discernmentas we engage these ideas and practices Discernment is a huge topic thatrsquos

hard to cover comprehensively in a few words Discernment happens when

the Spirit of Christ and his Word renew our minds Te Spirit grants us

spiritual wisdom as we meditate on him and his Word and as we practice

discipleship to Jesus Christ Romans 10486251048626 provides guidance we need (1048625) to be

transformed by the renewal of our minds (1048626) to serve Christrsquos body and (1048627)

to put love into action Discernment also happens in conversation both lo-cally and glocally

I pray these core values and six practices come across in the following

chapters of GlobalChurch

Glocalization can never be just theoretical Are we committed to moving

glocalization from an abstract idea to a living communion Are we deter-

mined to construct a missional theology of the church in the context of

glocal conversations Tis must involve dialogue between Majority Worldindigenous and Western scholars activists and groups

Will glocalization be an abstract notion Or will it be a formative and

genuine communion between local regional and global voices Glocal dy-

namics are at play whether we like it or not Teyrsquore in our churches the-

ologies and missions But we can choose to relinquish isolationist colonial

parochial and arrogant approaches Instead we can adopt responsive dia-

logical learning humble and embracing postures

Trough healthy approaches to glocalization the Spirit challenges us to

value local contexts We immerse ourselves in local and particular commu-

nities and conversations He inspires us to open ourselves to global theo-

logical conversations He rouses us to value the symbiotic relationship be-

tween the localparticular and the globaluniversal

Trough glocal relationships the Spirit leads us to put local contextual

theologies into conversation with global ones He prompts us to explore the

ways in which the local is in the glocal and the global is in the local He per-

suades us to pursue collaboration and dialogue and mutual learning We

engage with Christians from different backgrounds and cultures ecumen-

icals Pentecostals evangelicals and so on from Western indigenous and

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3436

Glocalizing Conversations 10486281048625

Majority World contexts He motivates us to express solidarity between all

parties We appreciate our unity in diversity

Trough glocal conversations the Spirit moves us to ensure that unity andsolidarity emerge from a compelling vision of Jesusrsquo kingdom and gospel

and person He challenges us to share information theology and practices

He urges us to learn from each othermdashour successes and mistakes We seek

glocal solutions

Te Spirit calls us to develop glocal conversations about Christian ideas

and practices Tese include Scripture Evangelicalism ecumenism Pente-

costalism Jesus Christ the Holy Spirit God the Father the rinity com-munity spirituality discipleship liturgy worship hospitality prayer eco-

justice education social ethics Christian leadership gospel and culture

beauty place suffering liberation and so forth

Finally through glocal conversations the Spirit leads us to adopt a new

posture Tis is a responsive humble celebratory open inclusive and em-

bracing attitude to the ldquootherrdquo We do this as a new people made up of every

tribe and language and people and nationTere are dangers in glocalization Sugirtharajah warns of the commodi-

fication of local contextual practices and theologies When this happens

they are ldquosmoothed out of their primary contexts concerns and contesta-

tions travel across borders and become objects of analysis and scrutiny

within an alien secondary contextrdquo1048626983095

Itrsquos common for those of us who are Western to make mistakes when we

wrestle with Majority World and indigenous ideas Sugirtharajah mentions

our tendency to commodify reduce and institutionalize these ideas We also

risk doing these things (1048625) We apply them in noncontextual prescriptive ways

(1048626) We ignore their meanings in their original setting (1048627) We glamorize or

idealize their proponents or their contexts (1048628) We demonize those persons or

contexts (1048629) We disregard them as irrelevant rhetorical or minority discourse

Kevin J Vanhoozer says that we can fall into three traps when we glo-

calize theology (1048625) We can underestimate the theological significance of

local cultures (1048626) We can homogenize cultures and theologies exaggerating

27R S Sugirtharajah ldquoextual ake-Aways Tird World exts in Western Metropolitan Centresrdquo

Black Teology in Britain A Journal o Contextual Praxis 983090 (1048625983097983097983097) 10486271048627 10486271048631 Edward W Said Te

World the ext and the Critic (Cambridge MA Harvard University Press 10486259830979830961048627) 9830901048627983097

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3536

10486281048626 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

ldquothe onerdquo (1048627) We can overemphasize cultural particularity exaggerating ldquothe

manyrdquo and pursue ldquotheological ethnificationrdquo10486261048632

My hope is that GlobalChurch does not fall into the traps Sugirtharajahand Vanhoozer describe I hope that what unfolds in the following chapters

is respectful and discerning I hope it leads to further mutually enriching

conversations between people of different cultures

You the reader face the same challenges You face them in your personal

life ministry context and missional engagements

Will you treat the themes in this book as abstract theoretical notions

Will this be a temporary infatuation a flirtation with the ldquootherrdquo that dissi-pates as suddenly as it arrived Or will glocal conversations become an en-

riching and formative orientation in your life Will glocal conversations

bring fresh approaches to theology faith mission church and worship Will

conversations with other cultures and theologies become for you a com-

pelling way of life

My prayer is that glocal conversations will help the church be a global

visible alternative ldquocity set upon a hillrdquo a truly GlobalChurch

28Craig Ott and Harold A Netland Globalizing Teology Belie and Practice in an Era o World

Christianity (Grand Rapids Baker Academic 983090983088983088983094) 1048625983090983093

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3636

Page 28: GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2836

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048629

vantaged in the Westrdquo9830891048633 Tis calls for attentiveness to these voices and re-

sponsiveness to their prophetic challenges It also demands a critical evalu-

ation of colonial readings of Scripture Colonial models of theology andchurch and mission are no longer the benchmark Te global church must

examine them afresh

Valuing equal status Tose on the margins have now taken their rightful

place on the global stage Tey have claimed appropriate and equal status at

the table Subaltern readings of theology church and mission are invaluable

contributors to global theological conversations Tis means that we esteem

them But we also test themWhat do we mean by subaltern Subalterns are those who are down-

trodden and silenced (or have been treated this way in the past) Dominant

or colonizing groups treat them as invisible nonentities Tey enjoy limited

or no access to power Sometimes these are women certain tribal and ethnic

groups and those considered ldquountouchablerdquo In Voices from the Margin Su-

girtharajah provides a platform for postcolonial subaltern readings of

Scripture and theology Tese readings challenge colonialmdashoen Westernmdashreadings of Bible and theology and cultures Tey claim equal status with

other ways of doing theology10486261048624

Valuing equal identity People groups need freedom to explore their new

and emerging identities Tese emerge in response to local and global influ-

ences Local culture is not the only thing at work here Global forces also

shape identity as do imported practices ideas readings rituals and tech-

nologies But each group should be free to explore and construct their par-

ticular forms of Christian identity

Valuing equal interpretations ldquoPostcolonialism is concerned with the

question of cultural and discursive dominationrdquo Colonialism led to op-

pressive and controlling forms of culture and discourse Tese were usually

not contextual or indigenous Western powers for instance brought co-

lonial forms of theology church biblical interpretation and mission1048626983089

Postcolonialism calls for alternative ways of approaching these things Tose

19Ibid 104862598309420R S Sugirtharajah Voices rom the Margin Interpreting the Bible in the Tird World (Maryknoll

NY Orbis 10486259830979830971048625)21Sugirtharajah Asian Biblical Hermeneutics and Postcolonialism 10486251048631

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2936

10486271048630 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

who were once marginalized oppressed and silenced need to lead these fresh

approaches in their own settings Tese then influence global conversations

We need to support the new readings and insights and experiments from thesegroups o be genuine this support must be both critical and collegial

Valuing equal empowerment Sugirtharajah says that postcolonialism is

valuable when it empowers actual communities and real people Post-

colonial thought empowers when it addresses the difficulties hopes and

experiences of ordinary people It should never be about power plays and

the clever use of language Itrsquos pointless if itrsquos obsessed with forming newmdash

and ldquocolonizingrdquomdashtheories Itrsquos a waste of time if itrsquos a self-indulgent pursuitof new and hybrid identities Rather ldquothe worth and credibility of post-

colonial criticism will be judged by how it orchestrates the unique and

fragile and imagined claims of one community against anotherrdquo Empow-

erment happens in a variety of ways One way is contributing equally to

global conversations10486261048626

Al izon examines postcolonialism in the Philippines He says that it can

teach the global church a lot about healthy local-global conversations Fil-ipino contextual theology resists many Western forms of mission and the-

ology It finds them patronizing and controlling Tis indigenous theology

values prophetic sociopolitical engagement in institutions and the society

at large It emphasizes ministry to whole persons and communities It con-

structs a Filipino theology of beauty and mission and worship and com-

munity And it fosters indigenous theological approaches to the spirit world

and cosmology

izon says that postcolonial theology has played a constructive role in

the Philippines But he is uncomfortable with the label postcolonialism He

prefers to describe historical events as ldquobeyond colonialismrdquo And he says

that global conversations enrich local theologies and vice versa1048626983091

Postcolonial thought informs our understanding of the relationship be-

tween the local and global It also shows how theology can emerge at the

intersection between the localparticular and the globaluniversal It re-

minds us that worthwhile glocalization listens to all voices Tis includes

heeding those that have been historically silenced

22Ibid 983090104862823izon ransormation Afer Lausanne 1048625983088983090 10486259830941048631-9830961048631

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3036

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048631

G983148983151983139983137983148983145983162983137983156983145983151983150 983137983150983140 983156983144983141 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

C983151983150983139983148983157983140983145983150983143 R983141983142983148983141983139983156983145983151983150983155

How do we go about developing a model for glocal conversations izon hasrecently provided a useful model that is instructive as we seek to learn from

the Majority World It has at least two key features

First the local is in the global (globalization from below) Global theologies

and ideas have origins in many particular local contexts In that sense glo-

balization is from below Global ideas have local roots Ideas about integral

mission liberation theology and missional church have local origins Tey

have their roots in the prayers hopes discoveries mission and theologiesof thousands of local communities ldquoTe global does not cannot exist

without the localmdashbut the coming together of localities creates a global re-

ality that becomes greater than the sum of its parts it creates a gestalt entity

to which localities make themselves accountablerdquo1048626983092

Second the global is in the local (panlocalization from above) Te con-

cerns and voices of multitudes of locales form global conversations Tese

global discussions can provide a ldquopositive accountabilityrdquo back to local con-texts Tis is true when they enrich affirm serve guide and strengthen local

contexts It is also true when they avoid homogenization control impo-

sition and judgment Glocalization is best when it sees itself as interde-

pendent deeply connected with the local10486261048629

Tatrsquos a helpful starting point But we need to go further Besides izonrsquos

proposals Irsquom convinced that robust glocal conversations cultivate six core

practices

983089 Glocal theology practices its values We root glocal theology in core

values Tese values include solidarity understanding and mutual learning

Do we value fellowship with Christians of all cultures Do we value learning

from them

We prove our values through our practices What practices emerge out of

these values We need to collaborate act collectively and share information

We must find ways to foster grassroots perspectives and local theologies We

need to share stories and learnings and cultivate networks relationships and

partnerships We need attentiveness to local voices and global themes We

24Ibid 9830901048625983088-1048625104862825Ibid 98309010486251048628-1048625983096

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3136

10486271048632 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

ought to find ways to put these local and global voices into conversation

Mutual learning humility and solidarity are key Worthwhile glocal con-

versations can never be merely theoretical or academic It is up to us to rootour values in our practices

983090 Glocal theology practices humility (and it tells a new narrative) We

have noted that the local is in the global and the global is in the local Te

two are interdependent Tey form each other reciprocally Since this is the

case we must practice humility Tere is no place for ethnocentrism colo-

nialism or theological and cultural arrogance I have seen these unhealthy

postures far too oen in Western settingsRecently I attended a missional leadership conference On that occasion

the keynote speakermdasha leading missional author and speakermdashsaid that

North American missional conversations and innovations hold the key to

the future of the Western church Tis Euro American view is wrong (Irsquom

being kind o be frank itrsquos complete nonsense) Itrsquos arrogant and Euro

Americanndashcentric And itrsquos completely out of step with what is happening in

the glocal church We need a new narrativeIn June 1048626104862410486251048627 Te Center for the Study of Global Christianity reported

the top 10486261048624 countries where Christianity has the highest percentage growth

rate Nineteen of the top twenty are in Asia and Africa Eleven of them are

in Muslim majority countries Not a single country from Europe or North

America makes the top twenty list10486261048630

Itrsquos time to cultivate a new narrative Te future of the church is emerging

from the Majority World Rather than North America the churches of

Eastern Asia Western Africa the Arabian Peninsula and other parts of the

Majority World reveal the future of the global church We need the contribu-

tions of all contexts Western indigenous and Majority World All con-

tribute to glocal conversations All are important as we learn from each

other about mission theology and faith But letrsquos stop pretending that North

Americans and Europeans will reveal the future of the global church Letrsquos

start listening to what God is saying about the future of the global church

And hersquos speaking to us through the churches of Asia Africa Latin America

26Russ Mitchell ldquoTe op 983090983088 Countries Where Christianity Is Growing the Fastestrdquo Disciple All

Nations (blog) August 983090983093 98309098308810486251048627 httpsdiscipleallnationswordpresscom98309098308810486251048627983088983096983090983093the-top

-983090983088-countries-where-christianity-is-growing-the-astest

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3236

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048633

Muslim majority settings and so on We must cultivate a new glocal nar-

rativemdashone soaked in humility

Glocal theology must be humble theology Meek theology Receptive the-ology Discerning theology Prayerful theology Dialogical theology De-

pendent theology A theology that celebrates the interdependence between

the localparticular and the globaluniversal

983091 Glocal theology practices expansiveness Glocalization is by nature

comprehensive Local and global influences permeate much of our lives Tese

glocal forces shape our theologies and churches whether we like it or not

But intentionality is also important We need to commit to an expansiveapproach to glocal theology How do we deliberately cultivate glocal conver-

sations in our biblical interpretation Do we foster them in our under-

standing of the person and work of Christ How does glocalization shape

the way the Spirit empowers and constitutes the church How can it form

our understanding of the nature and mission of the rinity How does it

influence the way we practice fellowship and conversation across denomi-

national cultural ethnic economic sociocultural political gender andtheological divides How might it shape our theologies of mission com-

munity beauty spirituality suffering discipleship hospitality eco-justice

place education social ethics Christian leadership and so forth

983092 Glocal theology practices attention Glocal theology doesnrsquot need to

accept all the assumptions or assertions of postcolonial or Majority World

thought But it does need to engage with them and take them seriously

Postcolonial theology for instance gives the marginalized and colonized

and forgotten and silenced both dignity and voice Our glocal conversations

must also include and esteem these groups We need to be attentive to

others weak and powerful female and male dominant and downtrodden

old and young rich and poor privileged and marginalized influential and

subaltern educated and illiterate We need to practice the art of attention

being especially attentive to those who are different to us

983093 Glocal theology practices embrace What do colonial ethnocentric or

Western-centric perspectives do Tey silence Tey control Tey com-

modify Tey institutionalize Tey colonize Tey domesticate Tey replace

Tey import Tey exclude Tey do these things to the beliefs experiences

and practices of other cultures A worthwhile glocal theology refuses to do

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3336

10486281048624 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

these things Instead it adopts a responsive humble celebratory open in-

clusive and embracing attitude

983094 Glocal theology practices discernment Finally we need discernmentas we engage these ideas and practices Discernment is a huge topic thatrsquos

hard to cover comprehensively in a few words Discernment happens when

the Spirit of Christ and his Word renew our minds Te Spirit grants us

spiritual wisdom as we meditate on him and his Word and as we practice

discipleship to Jesus Christ Romans 10486251048626 provides guidance we need (1048625) to be

transformed by the renewal of our minds (1048626) to serve Christrsquos body and (1048627)

to put love into action Discernment also happens in conversation both lo-cally and glocally

I pray these core values and six practices come across in the following

chapters of GlobalChurch

Glocalization can never be just theoretical Are we committed to moving

glocalization from an abstract idea to a living communion Are we deter-

mined to construct a missional theology of the church in the context of

glocal conversations Tis must involve dialogue between Majority Worldindigenous and Western scholars activists and groups

Will glocalization be an abstract notion Or will it be a formative and

genuine communion between local regional and global voices Glocal dy-

namics are at play whether we like it or not Teyrsquore in our churches the-

ologies and missions But we can choose to relinquish isolationist colonial

parochial and arrogant approaches Instead we can adopt responsive dia-

logical learning humble and embracing postures

Trough healthy approaches to glocalization the Spirit challenges us to

value local contexts We immerse ourselves in local and particular commu-

nities and conversations He inspires us to open ourselves to global theo-

logical conversations He rouses us to value the symbiotic relationship be-

tween the localparticular and the globaluniversal

Trough glocal relationships the Spirit leads us to put local contextual

theologies into conversation with global ones He prompts us to explore the

ways in which the local is in the glocal and the global is in the local He per-

suades us to pursue collaboration and dialogue and mutual learning We

engage with Christians from different backgrounds and cultures ecumen-

icals Pentecostals evangelicals and so on from Western indigenous and

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3436

Glocalizing Conversations 10486281048625

Majority World contexts He motivates us to express solidarity between all

parties We appreciate our unity in diversity

Trough glocal conversations the Spirit moves us to ensure that unity andsolidarity emerge from a compelling vision of Jesusrsquo kingdom and gospel

and person He challenges us to share information theology and practices

He urges us to learn from each othermdashour successes and mistakes We seek

glocal solutions

Te Spirit calls us to develop glocal conversations about Christian ideas

and practices Tese include Scripture Evangelicalism ecumenism Pente-

costalism Jesus Christ the Holy Spirit God the Father the rinity com-munity spirituality discipleship liturgy worship hospitality prayer eco-

justice education social ethics Christian leadership gospel and culture

beauty place suffering liberation and so forth

Finally through glocal conversations the Spirit leads us to adopt a new

posture Tis is a responsive humble celebratory open inclusive and em-

bracing attitude to the ldquootherrdquo We do this as a new people made up of every

tribe and language and people and nationTere are dangers in glocalization Sugirtharajah warns of the commodi-

fication of local contextual practices and theologies When this happens

they are ldquosmoothed out of their primary contexts concerns and contesta-

tions travel across borders and become objects of analysis and scrutiny

within an alien secondary contextrdquo1048626983095

Itrsquos common for those of us who are Western to make mistakes when we

wrestle with Majority World and indigenous ideas Sugirtharajah mentions

our tendency to commodify reduce and institutionalize these ideas We also

risk doing these things (1048625) We apply them in noncontextual prescriptive ways

(1048626) We ignore their meanings in their original setting (1048627) We glamorize or

idealize their proponents or their contexts (1048628) We demonize those persons or

contexts (1048629) We disregard them as irrelevant rhetorical or minority discourse

Kevin J Vanhoozer says that we can fall into three traps when we glo-

calize theology (1048625) We can underestimate the theological significance of

local cultures (1048626) We can homogenize cultures and theologies exaggerating

27R S Sugirtharajah ldquoextual ake-Aways Tird World exts in Western Metropolitan Centresrdquo

Black Teology in Britain A Journal o Contextual Praxis 983090 (1048625983097983097983097) 10486271048627 10486271048631 Edward W Said Te

World the ext and the Critic (Cambridge MA Harvard University Press 10486259830979830961048627) 9830901048627983097

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3536

10486281048626 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

ldquothe onerdquo (1048627) We can overemphasize cultural particularity exaggerating ldquothe

manyrdquo and pursue ldquotheological ethnificationrdquo10486261048632

My hope is that GlobalChurch does not fall into the traps Sugirtharajahand Vanhoozer describe I hope that what unfolds in the following chapters

is respectful and discerning I hope it leads to further mutually enriching

conversations between people of different cultures

You the reader face the same challenges You face them in your personal

life ministry context and missional engagements

Will you treat the themes in this book as abstract theoretical notions

Will this be a temporary infatuation a flirtation with the ldquootherrdquo that dissi-pates as suddenly as it arrived Or will glocal conversations become an en-

riching and formative orientation in your life Will glocal conversations

bring fresh approaches to theology faith mission church and worship Will

conversations with other cultures and theologies become for you a com-

pelling way of life

My prayer is that glocal conversations will help the church be a global

visible alternative ldquocity set upon a hillrdquo a truly GlobalChurch

28Craig Ott and Harold A Netland Globalizing Teology Belie and Practice in an Era o World

Christianity (Grand Rapids Baker Academic 983090983088983088983094) 1048625983090983093

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3636

Page 29: GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 2936

10486271048630 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

who were once marginalized oppressed and silenced need to lead these fresh

approaches in their own settings Tese then influence global conversations

We need to support the new readings and insights and experiments from thesegroups o be genuine this support must be both critical and collegial

Valuing equal empowerment Sugirtharajah says that postcolonialism is

valuable when it empowers actual communities and real people Post-

colonial thought empowers when it addresses the difficulties hopes and

experiences of ordinary people It should never be about power plays and

the clever use of language Itrsquos pointless if itrsquos obsessed with forming newmdash

and ldquocolonizingrdquomdashtheories Itrsquos a waste of time if itrsquos a self-indulgent pursuitof new and hybrid identities Rather ldquothe worth and credibility of post-

colonial criticism will be judged by how it orchestrates the unique and

fragile and imagined claims of one community against anotherrdquo Empow-

erment happens in a variety of ways One way is contributing equally to

global conversations10486261048626

Al izon examines postcolonialism in the Philippines He says that it can

teach the global church a lot about healthy local-global conversations Fil-ipino contextual theology resists many Western forms of mission and the-

ology It finds them patronizing and controlling Tis indigenous theology

values prophetic sociopolitical engagement in institutions and the society

at large It emphasizes ministry to whole persons and communities It con-

structs a Filipino theology of beauty and mission and worship and com-

munity And it fosters indigenous theological approaches to the spirit world

and cosmology

izon says that postcolonial theology has played a constructive role in

the Philippines But he is uncomfortable with the label postcolonialism He

prefers to describe historical events as ldquobeyond colonialismrdquo And he says

that global conversations enrich local theologies and vice versa1048626983091

Postcolonial thought informs our understanding of the relationship be-

tween the local and global It also shows how theology can emerge at the

intersection between the localparticular and the globaluniversal It re-

minds us that worthwhile glocalization listens to all voices Tis includes

heeding those that have been historically silenced

22Ibid 983090104862823izon ransormation Afer Lausanne 1048625983088983090 10486259830941048631-9830961048631

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3036

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048631

G983148983151983139983137983148983145983162983137983156983145983151983150 983137983150983140 983156983144983141 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

C983151983150983139983148983157983140983145983150983143 R983141983142983148983141983139983156983145983151983150983155

How do we go about developing a model for glocal conversations izon hasrecently provided a useful model that is instructive as we seek to learn from

the Majority World It has at least two key features

First the local is in the global (globalization from below) Global theologies

and ideas have origins in many particular local contexts In that sense glo-

balization is from below Global ideas have local roots Ideas about integral

mission liberation theology and missional church have local origins Tey

have their roots in the prayers hopes discoveries mission and theologiesof thousands of local communities ldquoTe global does not cannot exist

without the localmdashbut the coming together of localities creates a global re-

ality that becomes greater than the sum of its parts it creates a gestalt entity

to which localities make themselves accountablerdquo1048626983092

Second the global is in the local (panlocalization from above) Te con-

cerns and voices of multitudes of locales form global conversations Tese

global discussions can provide a ldquopositive accountabilityrdquo back to local con-texts Tis is true when they enrich affirm serve guide and strengthen local

contexts It is also true when they avoid homogenization control impo-

sition and judgment Glocalization is best when it sees itself as interde-

pendent deeply connected with the local10486261048629

Tatrsquos a helpful starting point But we need to go further Besides izonrsquos

proposals Irsquom convinced that robust glocal conversations cultivate six core

practices

983089 Glocal theology practices its values We root glocal theology in core

values Tese values include solidarity understanding and mutual learning

Do we value fellowship with Christians of all cultures Do we value learning

from them

We prove our values through our practices What practices emerge out of

these values We need to collaborate act collectively and share information

We must find ways to foster grassroots perspectives and local theologies We

need to share stories and learnings and cultivate networks relationships and

partnerships We need attentiveness to local voices and global themes We

24Ibid 9830901048625983088-1048625104862825Ibid 98309010486251048628-1048625983096

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3136

10486271048632 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

ought to find ways to put these local and global voices into conversation

Mutual learning humility and solidarity are key Worthwhile glocal con-

versations can never be merely theoretical or academic It is up to us to rootour values in our practices

983090 Glocal theology practices humility (and it tells a new narrative) We

have noted that the local is in the global and the global is in the local Te

two are interdependent Tey form each other reciprocally Since this is the

case we must practice humility Tere is no place for ethnocentrism colo-

nialism or theological and cultural arrogance I have seen these unhealthy

postures far too oen in Western settingsRecently I attended a missional leadership conference On that occasion

the keynote speakermdasha leading missional author and speakermdashsaid that

North American missional conversations and innovations hold the key to

the future of the Western church Tis Euro American view is wrong (Irsquom

being kind o be frank itrsquos complete nonsense) Itrsquos arrogant and Euro

Americanndashcentric And itrsquos completely out of step with what is happening in

the glocal church We need a new narrativeIn June 1048626104862410486251048627 Te Center for the Study of Global Christianity reported

the top 10486261048624 countries where Christianity has the highest percentage growth

rate Nineteen of the top twenty are in Asia and Africa Eleven of them are

in Muslim majority countries Not a single country from Europe or North

America makes the top twenty list10486261048630

Itrsquos time to cultivate a new narrative Te future of the church is emerging

from the Majority World Rather than North America the churches of

Eastern Asia Western Africa the Arabian Peninsula and other parts of the

Majority World reveal the future of the global church We need the contribu-

tions of all contexts Western indigenous and Majority World All con-

tribute to glocal conversations All are important as we learn from each

other about mission theology and faith But letrsquos stop pretending that North

Americans and Europeans will reveal the future of the global church Letrsquos

start listening to what God is saying about the future of the global church

And hersquos speaking to us through the churches of Asia Africa Latin America

26Russ Mitchell ldquoTe op 983090983088 Countries Where Christianity Is Growing the Fastestrdquo Disciple All

Nations (blog) August 983090983093 98309098308810486251048627 httpsdiscipleallnationswordpresscom98309098308810486251048627983088983096983090983093the-top

-983090983088-countries-where-christianity-is-growing-the-astest

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3236

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048633

Muslim majority settings and so on We must cultivate a new glocal nar-

rativemdashone soaked in humility

Glocal theology must be humble theology Meek theology Receptive the-ology Discerning theology Prayerful theology Dialogical theology De-

pendent theology A theology that celebrates the interdependence between

the localparticular and the globaluniversal

983091 Glocal theology practices expansiveness Glocalization is by nature

comprehensive Local and global influences permeate much of our lives Tese

glocal forces shape our theologies and churches whether we like it or not

But intentionality is also important We need to commit to an expansiveapproach to glocal theology How do we deliberately cultivate glocal conver-

sations in our biblical interpretation Do we foster them in our under-

standing of the person and work of Christ How does glocalization shape

the way the Spirit empowers and constitutes the church How can it form

our understanding of the nature and mission of the rinity How does it

influence the way we practice fellowship and conversation across denomi-

national cultural ethnic economic sociocultural political gender andtheological divides How might it shape our theologies of mission com-

munity beauty spirituality suffering discipleship hospitality eco-justice

place education social ethics Christian leadership and so forth

983092 Glocal theology practices attention Glocal theology doesnrsquot need to

accept all the assumptions or assertions of postcolonial or Majority World

thought But it does need to engage with them and take them seriously

Postcolonial theology for instance gives the marginalized and colonized

and forgotten and silenced both dignity and voice Our glocal conversations

must also include and esteem these groups We need to be attentive to

others weak and powerful female and male dominant and downtrodden

old and young rich and poor privileged and marginalized influential and

subaltern educated and illiterate We need to practice the art of attention

being especially attentive to those who are different to us

983093 Glocal theology practices embrace What do colonial ethnocentric or

Western-centric perspectives do Tey silence Tey control Tey com-

modify Tey institutionalize Tey colonize Tey domesticate Tey replace

Tey import Tey exclude Tey do these things to the beliefs experiences

and practices of other cultures A worthwhile glocal theology refuses to do

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3336

10486281048624 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

these things Instead it adopts a responsive humble celebratory open in-

clusive and embracing attitude

983094 Glocal theology practices discernment Finally we need discernmentas we engage these ideas and practices Discernment is a huge topic thatrsquos

hard to cover comprehensively in a few words Discernment happens when

the Spirit of Christ and his Word renew our minds Te Spirit grants us

spiritual wisdom as we meditate on him and his Word and as we practice

discipleship to Jesus Christ Romans 10486251048626 provides guidance we need (1048625) to be

transformed by the renewal of our minds (1048626) to serve Christrsquos body and (1048627)

to put love into action Discernment also happens in conversation both lo-cally and glocally

I pray these core values and six practices come across in the following

chapters of GlobalChurch

Glocalization can never be just theoretical Are we committed to moving

glocalization from an abstract idea to a living communion Are we deter-

mined to construct a missional theology of the church in the context of

glocal conversations Tis must involve dialogue between Majority Worldindigenous and Western scholars activists and groups

Will glocalization be an abstract notion Or will it be a formative and

genuine communion between local regional and global voices Glocal dy-

namics are at play whether we like it or not Teyrsquore in our churches the-

ologies and missions But we can choose to relinquish isolationist colonial

parochial and arrogant approaches Instead we can adopt responsive dia-

logical learning humble and embracing postures

Trough healthy approaches to glocalization the Spirit challenges us to

value local contexts We immerse ourselves in local and particular commu-

nities and conversations He inspires us to open ourselves to global theo-

logical conversations He rouses us to value the symbiotic relationship be-

tween the localparticular and the globaluniversal

Trough glocal relationships the Spirit leads us to put local contextual

theologies into conversation with global ones He prompts us to explore the

ways in which the local is in the glocal and the global is in the local He per-

suades us to pursue collaboration and dialogue and mutual learning We

engage with Christians from different backgrounds and cultures ecumen-

icals Pentecostals evangelicals and so on from Western indigenous and

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3436

Glocalizing Conversations 10486281048625

Majority World contexts He motivates us to express solidarity between all

parties We appreciate our unity in diversity

Trough glocal conversations the Spirit moves us to ensure that unity andsolidarity emerge from a compelling vision of Jesusrsquo kingdom and gospel

and person He challenges us to share information theology and practices

He urges us to learn from each othermdashour successes and mistakes We seek

glocal solutions

Te Spirit calls us to develop glocal conversations about Christian ideas

and practices Tese include Scripture Evangelicalism ecumenism Pente-

costalism Jesus Christ the Holy Spirit God the Father the rinity com-munity spirituality discipleship liturgy worship hospitality prayer eco-

justice education social ethics Christian leadership gospel and culture

beauty place suffering liberation and so forth

Finally through glocal conversations the Spirit leads us to adopt a new

posture Tis is a responsive humble celebratory open inclusive and em-

bracing attitude to the ldquootherrdquo We do this as a new people made up of every

tribe and language and people and nationTere are dangers in glocalization Sugirtharajah warns of the commodi-

fication of local contextual practices and theologies When this happens

they are ldquosmoothed out of their primary contexts concerns and contesta-

tions travel across borders and become objects of analysis and scrutiny

within an alien secondary contextrdquo1048626983095

Itrsquos common for those of us who are Western to make mistakes when we

wrestle with Majority World and indigenous ideas Sugirtharajah mentions

our tendency to commodify reduce and institutionalize these ideas We also

risk doing these things (1048625) We apply them in noncontextual prescriptive ways

(1048626) We ignore their meanings in their original setting (1048627) We glamorize or

idealize their proponents or their contexts (1048628) We demonize those persons or

contexts (1048629) We disregard them as irrelevant rhetorical or minority discourse

Kevin J Vanhoozer says that we can fall into three traps when we glo-

calize theology (1048625) We can underestimate the theological significance of

local cultures (1048626) We can homogenize cultures and theologies exaggerating

27R S Sugirtharajah ldquoextual ake-Aways Tird World exts in Western Metropolitan Centresrdquo

Black Teology in Britain A Journal o Contextual Praxis 983090 (1048625983097983097983097) 10486271048627 10486271048631 Edward W Said Te

World the ext and the Critic (Cambridge MA Harvard University Press 10486259830979830961048627) 9830901048627983097

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3536

10486281048626 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

ldquothe onerdquo (1048627) We can overemphasize cultural particularity exaggerating ldquothe

manyrdquo and pursue ldquotheological ethnificationrdquo10486261048632

My hope is that GlobalChurch does not fall into the traps Sugirtharajahand Vanhoozer describe I hope that what unfolds in the following chapters

is respectful and discerning I hope it leads to further mutually enriching

conversations between people of different cultures

You the reader face the same challenges You face them in your personal

life ministry context and missional engagements

Will you treat the themes in this book as abstract theoretical notions

Will this be a temporary infatuation a flirtation with the ldquootherrdquo that dissi-pates as suddenly as it arrived Or will glocal conversations become an en-

riching and formative orientation in your life Will glocal conversations

bring fresh approaches to theology faith mission church and worship Will

conversations with other cultures and theologies become for you a com-

pelling way of life

My prayer is that glocal conversations will help the church be a global

visible alternative ldquocity set upon a hillrdquo a truly GlobalChurch

28Craig Ott and Harold A Netland Globalizing Teology Belie and Practice in an Era o World

Christianity (Grand Rapids Baker Academic 983090983088983088983094) 1048625983090983093

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3636

Page 30: GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3036

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048631

G983148983151983139983137983148983145983162983137983156983145983151983150 983137983150983140 983156983144983141 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

C983151983150983139983148983157983140983145983150983143 R983141983142983148983141983139983156983145983151983150983155

How do we go about developing a model for glocal conversations izon hasrecently provided a useful model that is instructive as we seek to learn from

the Majority World It has at least two key features

First the local is in the global (globalization from below) Global theologies

and ideas have origins in many particular local contexts In that sense glo-

balization is from below Global ideas have local roots Ideas about integral

mission liberation theology and missional church have local origins Tey

have their roots in the prayers hopes discoveries mission and theologiesof thousands of local communities ldquoTe global does not cannot exist

without the localmdashbut the coming together of localities creates a global re-

ality that becomes greater than the sum of its parts it creates a gestalt entity

to which localities make themselves accountablerdquo1048626983092

Second the global is in the local (panlocalization from above) Te con-

cerns and voices of multitudes of locales form global conversations Tese

global discussions can provide a ldquopositive accountabilityrdquo back to local con-texts Tis is true when they enrich affirm serve guide and strengthen local

contexts It is also true when they avoid homogenization control impo-

sition and judgment Glocalization is best when it sees itself as interde-

pendent deeply connected with the local10486261048629

Tatrsquos a helpful starting point But we need to go further Besides izonrsquos

proposals Irsquom convinced that robust glocal conversations cultivate six core

practices

983089 Glocal theology practices its values We root glocal theology in core

values Tese values include solidarity understanding and mutual learning

Do we value fellowship with Christians of all cultures Do we value learning

from them

We prove our values through our practices What practices emerge out of

these values We need to collaborate act collectively and share information

We must find ways to foster grassroots perspectives and local theologies We

need to share stories and learnings and cultivate networks relationships and

partnerships We need attentiveness to local voices and global themes We

24Ibid 9830901048625983088-1048625104862825Ibid 98309010486251048628-1048625983096

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3136

10486271048632 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

ought to find ways to put these local and global voices into conversation

Mutual learning humility and solidarity are key Worthwhile glocal con-

versations can never be merely theoretical or academic It is up to us to rootour values in our practices

983090 Glocal theology practices humility (and it tells a new narrative) We

have noted that the local is in the global and the global is in the local Te

two are interdependent Tey form each other reciprocally Since this is the

case we must practice humility Tere is no place for ethnocentrism colo-

nialism or theological and cultural arrogance I have seen these unhealthy

postures far too oen in Western settingsRecently I attended a missional leadership conference On that occasion

the keynote speakermdasha leading missional author and speakermdashsaid that

North American missional conversations and innovations hold the key to

the future of the Western church Tis Euro American view is wrong (Irsquom

being kind o be frank itrsquos complete nonsense) Itrsquos arrogant and Euro

Americanndashcentric And itrsquos completely out of step with what is happening in

the glocal church We need a new narrativeIn June 1048626104862410486251048627 Te Center for the Study of Global Christianity reported

the top 10486261048624 countries where Christianity has the highest percentage growth

rate Nineteen of the top twenty are in Asia and Africa Eleven of them are

in Muslim majority countries Not a single country from Europe or North

America makes the top twenty list10486261048630

Itrsquos time to cultivate a new narrative Te future of the church is emerging

from the Majority World Rather than North America the churches of

Eastern Asia Western Africa the Arabian Peninsula and other parts of the

Majority World reveal the future of the global church We need the contribu-

tions of all contexts Western indigenous and Majority World All con-

tribute to glocal conversations All are important as we learn from each

other about mission theology and faith But letrsquos stop pretending that North

Americans and Europeans will reveal the future of the global church Letrsquos

start listening to what God is saying about the future of the global church

And hersquos speaking to us through the churches of Asia Africa Latin America

26Russ Mitchell ldquoTe op 983090983088 Countries Where Christianity Is Growing the Fastestrdquo Disciple All

Nations (blog) August 983090983093 98309098308810486251048627 httpsdiscipleallnationswordpresscom98309098308810486251048627983088983096983090983093the-top

-983090983088-countries-where-christianity-is-growing-the-astest

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3236

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048633

Muslim majority settings and so on We must cultivate a new glocal nar-

rativemdashone soaked in humility

Glocal theology must be humble theology Meek theology Receptive the-ology Discerning theology Prayerful theology Dialogical theology De-

pendent theology A theology that celebrates the interdependence between

the localparticular and the globaluniversal

983091 Glocal theology practices expansiveness Glocalization is by nature

comprehensive Local and global influences permeate much of our lives Tese

glocal forces shape our theologies and churches whether we like it or not

But intentionality is also important We need to commit to an expansiveapproach to glocal theology How do we deliberately cultivate glocal conver-

sations in our biblical interpretation Do we foster them in our under-

standing of the person and work of Christ How does glocalization shape

the way the Spirit empowers and constitutes the church How can it form

our understanding of the nature and mission of the rinity How does it

influence the way we practice fellowship and conversation across denomi-

national cultural ethnic economic sociocultural political gender andtheological divides How might it shape our theologies of mission com-

munity beauty spirituality suffering discipleship hospitality eco-justice

place education social ethics Christian leadership and so forth

983092 Glocal theology practices attention Glocal theology doesnrsquot need to

accept all the assumptions or assertions of postcolonial or Majority World

thought But it does need to engage with them and take them seriously

Postcolonial theology for instance gives the marginalized and colonized

and forgotten and silenced both dignity and voice Our glocal conversations

must also include and esteem these groups We need to be attentive to

others weak and powerful female and male dominant and downtrodden

old and young rich and poor privileged and marginalized influential and

subaltern educated and illiterate We need to practice the art of attention

being especially attentive to those who are different to us

983093 Glocal theology practices embrace What do colonial ethnocentric or

Western-centric perspectives do Tey silence Tey control Tey com-

modify Tey institutionalize Tey colonize Tey domesticate Tey replace

Tey import Tey exclude Tey do these things to the beliefs experiences

and practices of other cultures A worthwhile glocal theology refuses to do

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3336

10486281048624 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

these things Instead it adopts a responsive humble celebratory open in-

clusive and embracing attitude

983094 Glocal theology practices discernment Finally we need discernmentas we engage these ideas and practices Discernment is a huge topic thatrsquos

hard to cover comprehensively in a few words Discernment happens when

the Spirit of Christ and his Word renew our minds Te Spirit grants us

spiritual wisdom as we meditate on him and his Word and as we practice

discipleship to Jesus Christ Romans 10486251048626 provides guidance we need (1048625) to be

transformed by the renewal of our minds (1048626) to serve Christrsquos body and (1048627)

to put love into action Discernment also happens in conversation both lo-cally and glocally

I pray these core values and six practices come across in the following

chapters of GlobalChurch

Glocalization can never be just theoretical Are we committed to moving

glocalization from an abstract idea to a living communion Are we deter-

mined to construct a missional theology of the church in the context of

glocal conversations Tis must involve dialogue between Majority Worldindigenous and Western scholars activists and groups

Will glocalization be an abstract notion Or will it be a formative and

genuine communion between local regional and global voices Glocal dy-

namics are at play whether we like it or not Teyrsquore in our churches the-

ologies and missions But we can choose to relinquish isolationist colonial

parochial and arrogant approaches Instead we can adopt responsive dia-

logical learning humble and embracing postures

Trough healthy approaches to glocalization the Spirit challenges us to

value local contexts We immerse ourselves in local and particular commu-

nities and conversations He inspires us to open ourselves to global theo-

logical conversations He rouses us to value the symbiotic relationship be-

tween the localparticular and the globaluniversal

Trough glocal relationships the Spirit leads us to put local contextual

theologies into conversation with global ones He prompts us to explore the

ways in which the local is in the glocal and the global is in the local He per-

suades us to pursue collaboration and dialogue and mutual learning We

engage with Christians from different backgrounds and cultures ecumen-

icals Pentecostals evangelicals and so on from Western indigenous and

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3436

Glocalizing Conversations 10486281048625

Majority World contexts He motivates us to express solidarity between all

parties We appreciate our unity in diversity

Trough glocal conversations the Spirit moves us to ensure that unity andsolidarity emerge from a compelling vision of Jesusrsquo kingdom and gospel

and person He challenges us to share information theology and practices

He urges us to learn from each othermdashour successes and mistakes We seek

glocal solutions

Te Spirit calls us to develop glocal conversations about Christian ideas

and practices Tese include Scripture Evangelicalism ecumenism Pente-

costalism Jesus Christ the Holy Spirit God the Father the rinity com-munity spirituality discipleship liturgy worship hospitality prayer eco-

justice education social ethics Christian leadership gospel and culture

beauty place suffering liberation and so forth

Finally through glocal conversations the Spirit leads us to adopt a new

posture Tis is a responsive humble celebratory open inclusive and em-

bracing attitude to the ldquootherrdquo We do this as a new people made up of every

tribe and language and people and nationTere are dangers in glocalization Sugirtharajah warns of the commodi-

fication of local contextual practices and theologies When this happens

they are ldquosmoothed out of their primary contexts concerns and contesta-

tions travel across borders and become objects of analysis and scrutiny

within an alien secondary contextrdquo1048626983095

Itrsquos common for those of us who are Western to make mistakes when we

wrestle with Majority World and indigenous ideas Sugirtharajah mentions

our tendency to commodify reduce and institutionalize these ideas We also

risk doing these things (1048625) We apply them in noncontextual prescriptive ways

(1048626) We ignore their meanings in their original setting (1048627) We glamorize or

idealize their proponents or their contexts (1048628) We demonize those persons or

contexts (1048629) We disregard them as irrelevant rhetorical or minority discourse

Kevin J Vanhoozer says that we can fall into three traps when we glo-

calize theology (1048625) We can underestimate the theological significance of

local cultures (1048626) We can homogenize cultures and theologies exaggerating

27R S Sugirtharajah ldquoextual ake-Aways Tird World exts in Western Metropolitan Centresrdquo

Black Teology in Britain A Journal o Contextual Praxis 983090 (1048625983097983097983097) 10486271048627 10486271048631 Edward W Said Te

World the ext and the Critic (Cambridge MA Harvard University Press 10486259830979830961048627) 9830901048627983097

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3536

10486281048626 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

ldquothe onerdquo (1048627) We can overemphasize cultural particularity exaggerating ldquothe

manyrdquo and pursue ldquotheological ethnificationrdquo10486261048632

My hope is that GlobalChurch does not fall into the traps Sugirtharajahand Vanhoozer describe I hope that what unfolds in the following chapters

is respectful and discerning I hope it leads to further mutually enriching

conversations between people of different cultures

You the reader face the same challenges You face them in your personal

life ministry context and missional engagements

Will you treat the themes in this book as abstract theoretical notions

Will this be a temporary infatuation a flirtation with the ldquootherrdquo that dissi-pates as suddenly as it arrived Or will glocal conversations become an en-

riching and formative orientation in your life Will glocal conversations

bring fresh approaches to theology faith mission church and worship Will

conversations with other cultures and theologies become for you a com-

pelling way of life

My prayer is that glocal conversations will help the church be a global

visible alternative ldquocity set upon a hillrdquo a truly GlobalChurch

28Craig Ott and Harold A Netland Globalizing Teology Belie and Practice in an Era o World

Christianity (Grand Rapids Baker Academic 983090983088983088983094) 1048625983090983093

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3636

Page 31: GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3136

10486271048632 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

ought to find ways to put these local and global voices into conversation

Mutual learning humility and solidarity are key Worthwhile glocal con-

versations can never be merely theoretical or academic It is up to us to rootour values in our practices

983090 Glocal theology practices humility (and it tells a new narrative) We

have noted that the local is in the global and the global is in the local Te

two are interdependent Tey form each other reciprocally Since this is the

case we must practice humility Tere is no place for ethnocentrism colo-

nialism or theological and cultural arrogance I have seen these unhealthy

postures far too oen in Western settingsRecently I attended a missional leadership conference On that occasion

the keynote speakermdasha leading missional author and speakermdashsaid that

North American missional conversations and innovations hold the key to

the future of the Western church Tis Euro American view is wrong (Irsquom

being kind o be frank itrsquos complete nonsense) Itrsquos arrogant and Euro

Americanndashcentric And itrsquos completely out of step with what is happening in

the glocal church We need a new narrativeIn June 1048626104862410486251048627 Te Center for the Study of Global Christianity reported

the top 10486261048624 countries where Christianity has the highest percentage growth

rate Nineteen of the top twenty are in Asia and Africa Eleven of them are

in Muslim majority countries Not a single country from Europe or North

America makes the top twenty list10486261048630

Itrsquos time to cultivate a new narrative Te future of the church is emerging

from the Majority World Rather than North America the churches of

Eastern Asia Western Africa the Arabian Peninsula and other parts of the

Majority World reveal the future of the global church We need the contribu-

tions of all contexts Western indigenous and Majority World All con-

tribute to glocal conversations All are important as we learn from each

other about mission theology and faith But letrsquos stop pretending that North

Americans and Europeans will reveal the future of the global church Letrsquos

start listening to what God is saying about the future of the global church

And hersquos speaking to us through the churches of Asia Africa Latin America

26Russ Mitchell ldquoTe op 983090983088 Countries Where Christianity Is Growing the Fastestrdquo Disciple All

Nations (blog) August 983090983093 98309098308810486251048627 httpsdiscipleallnationswordpresscom98309098308810486251048627983088983096983090983093the-top

-983090983088-countries-where-christianity-is-growing-the-astest

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3236

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048633

Muslim majority settings and so on We must cultivate a new glocal nar-

rativemdashone soaked in humility

Glocal theology must be humble theology Meek theology Receptive the-ology Discerning theology Prayerful theology Dialogical theology De-

pendent theology A theology that celebrates the interdependence between

the localparticular and the globaluniversal

983091 Glocal theology practices expansiveness Glocalization is by nature

comprehensive Local and global influences permeate much of our lives Tese

glocal forces shape our theologies and churches whether we like it or not

But intentionality is also important We need to commit to an expansiveapproach to glocal theology How do we deliberately cultivate glocal conver-

sations in our biblical interpretation Do we foster them in our under-

standing of the person and work of Christ How does glocalization shape

the way the Spirit empowers and constitutes the church How can it form

our understanding of the nature and mission of the rinity How does it

influence the way we practice fellowship and conversation across denomi-

national cultural ethnic economic sociocultural political gender andtheological divides How might it shape our theologies of mission com-

munity beauty spirituality suffering discipleship hospitality eco-justice

place education social ethics Christian leadership and so forth

983092 Glocal theology practices attention Glocal theology doesnrsquot need to

accept all the assumptions or assertions of postcolonial or Majority World

thought But it does need to engage with them and take them seriously

Postcolonial theology for instance gives the marginalized and colonized

and forgotten and silenced both dignity and voice Our glocal conversations

must also include and esteem these groups We need to be attentive to

others weak and powerful female and male dominant and downtrodden

old and young rich and poor privileged and marginalized influential and

subaltern educated and illiterate We need to practice the art of attention

being especially attentive to those who are different to us

983093 Glocal theology practices embrace What do colonial ethnocentric or

Western-centric perspectives do Tey silence Tey control Tey com-

modify Tey institutionalize Tey colonize Tey domesticate Tey replace

Tey import Tey exclude Tey do these things to the beliefs experiences

and practices of other cultures A worthwhile glocal theology refuses to do

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3336

10486281048624 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

these things Instead it adopts a responsive humble celebratory open in-

clusive and embracing attitude

983094 Glocal theology practices discernment Finally we need discernmentas we engage these ideas and practices Discernment is a huge topic thatrsquos

hard to cover comprehensively in a few words Discernment happens when

the Spirit of Christ and his Word renew our minds Te Spirit grants us

spiritual wisdom as we meditate on him and his Word and as we practice

discipleship to Jesus Christ Romans 10486251048626 provides guidance we need (1048625) to be

transformed by the renewal of our minds (1048626) to serve Christrsquos body and (1048627)

to put love into action Discernment also happens in conversation both lo-cally and glocally

I pray these core values and six practices come across in the following

chapters of GlobalChurch

Glocalization can never be just theoretical Are we committed to moving

glocalization from an abstract idea to a living communion Are we deter-

mined to construct a missional theology of the church in the context of

glocal conversations Tis must involve dialogue between Majority Worldindigenous and Western scholars activists and groups

Will glocalization be an abstract notion Or will it be a formative and

genuine communion between local regional and global voices Glocal dy-

namics are at play whether we like it or not Teyrsquore in our churches the-

ologies and missions But we can choose to relinquish isolationist colonial

parochial and arrogant approaches Instead we can adopt responsive dia-

logical learning humble and embracing postures

Trough healthy approaches to glocalization the Spirit challenges us to

value local contexts We immerse ourselves in local and particular commu-

nities and conversations He inspires us to open ourselves to global theo-

logical conversations He rouses us to value the symbiotic relationship be-

tween the localparticular and the globaluniversal

Trough glocal relationships the Spirit leads us to put local contextual

theologies into conversation with global ones He prompts us to explore the

ways in which the local is in the glocal and the global is in the local He per-

suades us to pursue collaboration and dialogue and mutual learning We

engage with Christians from different backgrounds and cultures ecumen-

icals Pentecostals evangelicals and so on from Western indigenous and

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3436

Glocalizing Conversations 10486281048625

Majority World contexts He motivates us to express solidarity between all

parties We appreciate our unity in diversity

Trough glocal conversations the Spirit moves us to ensure that unity andsolidarity emerge from a compelling vision of Jesusrsquo kingdom and gospel

and person He challenges us to share information theology and practices

He urges us to learn from each othermdashour successes and mistakes We seek

glocal solutions

Te Spirit calls us to develop glocal conversations about Christian ideas

and practices Tese include Scripture Evangelicalism ecumenism Pente-

costalism Jesus Christ the Holy Spirit God the Father the rinity com-munity spirituality discipleship liturgy worship hospitality prayer eco-

justice education social ethics Christian leadership gospel and culture

beauty place suffering liberation and so forth

Finally through glocal conversations the Spirit leads us to adopt a new

posture Tis is a responsive humble celebratory open inclusive and em-

bracing attitude to the ldquootherrdquo We do this as a new people made up of every

tribe and language and people and nationTere are dangers in glocalization Sugirtharajah warns of the commodi-

fication of local contextual practices and theologies When this happens

they are ldquosmoothed out of their primary contexts concerns and contesta-

tions travel across borders and become objects of analysis and scrutiny

within an alien secondary contextrdquo1048626983095

Itrsquos common for those of us who are Western to make mistakes when we

wrestle with Majority World and indigenous ideas Sugirtharajah mentions

our tendency to commodify reduce and institutionalize these ideas We also

risk doing these things (1048625) We apply them in noncontextual prescriptive ways

(1048626) We ignore their meanings in their original setting (1048627) We glamorize or

idealize their proponents or their contexts (1048628) We demonize those persons or

contexts (1048629) We disregard them as irrelevant rhetorical or minority discourse

Kevin J Vanhoozer says that we can fall into three traps when we glo-

calize theology (1048625) We can underestimate the theological significance of

local cultures (1048626) We can homogenize cultures and theologies exaggerating

27R S Sugirtharajah ldquoextual ake-Aways Tird World exts in Western Metropolitan Centresrdquo

Black Teology in Britain A Journal o Contextual Praxis 983090 (1048625983097983097983097) 10486271048627 10486271048631 Edward W Said Te

World the ext and the Critic (Cambridge MA Harvard University Press 10486259830979830961048627) 9830901048627983097

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3536

10486281048626 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

ldquothe onerdquo (1048627) We can overemphasize cultural particularity exaggerating ldquothe

manyrdquo and pursue ldquotheological ethnificationrdquo10486261048632

My hope is that GlobalChurch does not fall into the traps Sugirtharajahand Vanhoozer describe I hope that what unfolds in the following chapters

is respectful and discerning I hope it leads to further mutually enriching

conversations between people of different cultures

You the reader face the same challenges You face them in your personal

life ministry context and missional engagements

Will you treat the themes in this book as abstract theoretical notions

Will this be a temporary infatuation a flirtation with the ldquootherrdquo that dissi-pates as suddenly as it arrived Or will glocal conversations become an en-

riching and formative orientation in your life Will glocal conversations

bring fresh approaches to theology faith mission church and worship Will

conversations with other cultures and theologies become for you a com-

pelling way of life

My prayer is that glocal conversations will help the church be a global

visible alternative ldquocity set upon a hillrdquo a truly GlobalChurch

28Craig Ott and Harold A Netland Globalizing Teology Belie and Practice in an Era o World

Christianity (Grand Rapids Baker Academic 983090983088983088983094) 1048625983090983093

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3636

Page 32: GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3236

Glocalizing Conversations 10486271048633

Muslim majority settings and so on We must cultivate a new glocal nar-

rativemdashone soaked in humility

Glocal theology must be humble theology Meek theology Receptive the-ology Discerning theology Prayerful theology Dialogical theology De-

pendent theology A theology that celebrates the interdependence between

the localparticular and the globaluniversal

983091 Glocal theology practices expansiveness Glocalization is by nature

comprehensive Local and global influences permeate much of our lives Tese

glocal forces shape our theologies and churches whether we like it or not

But intentionality is also important We need to commit to an expansiveapproach to glocal theology How do we deliberately cultivate glocal conver-

sations in our biblical interpretation Do we foster them in our under-

standing of the person and work of Christ How does glocalization shape

the way the Spirit empowers and constitutes the church How can it form

our understanding of the nature and mission of the rinity How does it

influence the way we practice fellowship and conversation across denomi-

national cultural ethnic economic sociocultural political gender andtheological divides How might it shape our theologies of mission com-

munity beauty spirituality suffering discipleship hospitality eco-justice

place education social ethics Christian leadership and so forth

983092 Glocal theology practices attention Glocal theology doesnrsquot need to

accept all the assumptions or assertions of postcolonial or Majority World

thought But it does need to engage with them and take them seriously

Postcolonial theology for instance gives the marginalized and colonized

and forgotten and silenced both dignity and voice Our glocal conversations

must also include and esteem these groups We need to be attentive to

others weak and powerful female and male dominant and downtrodden

old and young rich and poor privileged and marginalized influential and

subaltern educated and illiterate We need to practice the art of attention

being especially attentive to those who are different to us

983093 Glocal theology practices embrace What do colonial ethnocentric or

Western-centric perspectives do Tey silence Tey control Tey com-

modify Tey institutionalize Tey colonize Tey domesticate Tey replace

Tey import Tey exclude Tey do these things to the beliefs experiences

and practices of other cultures A worthwhile glocal theology refuses to do

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3336

10486281048624 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

these things Instead it adopts a responsive humble celebratory open in-

clusive and embracing attitude

983094 Glocal theology practices discernment Finally we need discernmentas we engage these ideas and practices Discernment is a huge topic thatrsquos

hard to cover comprehensively in a few words Discernment happens when

the Spirit of Christ and his Word renew our minds Te Spirit grants us

spiritual wisdom as we meditate on him and his Word and as we practice

discipleship to Jesus Christ Romans 10486251048626 provides guidance we need (1048625) to be

transformed by the renewal of our minds (1048626) to serve Christrsquos body and (1048627)

to put love into action Discernment also happens in conversation both lo-cally and glocally

I pray these core values and six practices come across in the following

chapters of GlobalChurch

Glocalization can never be just theoretical Are we committed to moving

glocalization from an abstract idea to a living communion Are we deter-

mined to construct a missional theology of the church in the context of

glocal conversations Tis must involve dialogue between Majority Worldindigenous and Western scholars activists and groups

Will glocalization be an abstract notion Or will it be a formative and

genuine communion between local regional and global voices Glocal dy-

namics are at play whether we like it or not Teyrsquore in our churches the-

ologies and missions But we can choose to relinquish isolationist colonial

parochial and arrogant approaches Instead we can adopt responsive dia-

logical learning humble and embracing postures

Trough healthy approaches to glocalization the Spirit challenges us to

value local contexts We immerse ourselves in local and particular commu-

nities and conversations He inspires us to open ourselves to global theo-

logical conversations He rouses us to value the symbiotic relationship be-

tween the localparticular and the globaluniversal

Trough glocal relationships the Spirit leads us to put local contextual

theologies into conversation with global ones He prompts us to explore the

ways in which the local is in the glocal and the global is in the local He per-

suades us to pursue collaboration and dialogue and mutual learning We

engage with Christians from different backgrounds and cultures ecumen-

icals Pentecostals evangelicals and so on from Western indigenous and

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3436

Glocalizing Conversations 10486281048625

Majority World contexts He motivates us to express solidarity between all

parties We appreciate our unity in diversity

Trough glocal conversations the Spirit moves us to ensure that unity andsolidarity emerge from a compelling vision of Jesusrsquo kingdom and gospel

and person He challenges us to share information theology and practices

He urges us to learn from each othermdashour successes and mistakes We seek

glocal solutions

Te Spirit calls us to develop glocal conversations about Christian ideas

and practices Tese include Scripture Evangelicalism ecumenism Pente-

costalism Jesus Christ the Holy Spirit God the Father the rinity com-munity spirituality discipleship liturgy worship hospitality prayer eco-

justice education social ethics Christian leadership gospel and culture

beauty place suffering liberation and so forth

Finally through glocal conversations the Spirit leads us to adopt a new

posture Tis is a responsive humble celebratory open inclusive and em-

bracing attitude to the ldquootherrdquo We do this as a new people made up of every

tribe and language and people and nationTere are dangers in glocalization Sugirtharajah warns of the commodi-

fication of local contextual practices and theologies When this happens

they are ldquosmoothed out of their primary contexts concerns and contesta-

tions travel across borders and become objects of analysis and scrutiny

within an alien secondary contextrdquo1048626983095

Itrsquos common for those of us who are Western to make mistakes when we

wrestle with Majority World and indigenous ideas Sugirtharajah mentions

our tendency to commodify reduce and institutionalize these ideas We also

risk doing these things (1048625) We apply them in noncontextual prescriptive ways

(1048626) We ignore their meanings in their original setting (1048627) We glamorize or

idealize their proponents or their contexts (1048628) We demonize those persons or

contexts (1048629) We disregard them as irrelevant rhetorical or minority discourse

Kevin J Vanhoozer says that we can fall into three traps when we glo-

calize theology (1048625) We can underestimate the theological significance of

local cultures (1048626) We can homogenize cultures and theologies exaggerating

27R S Sugirtharajah ldquoextual ake-Aways Tird World exts in Western Metropolitan Centresrdquo

Black Teology in Britain A Journal o Contextual Praxis 983090 (1048625983097983097983097) 10486271048627 10486271048631 Edward W Said Te

World the ext and the Critic (Cambridge MA Harvard University Press 10486259830979830961048627) 9830901048627983097

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3536

10486281048626 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

ldquothe onerdquo (1048627) We can overemphasize cultural particularity exaggerating ldquothe

manyrdquo and pursue ldquotheological ethnificationrdquo10486261048632

My hope is that GlobalChurch does not fall into the traps Sugirtharajahand Vanhoozer describe I hope that what unfolds in the following chapters

is respectful and discerning I hope it leads to further mutually enriching

conversations between people of different cultures

You the reader face the same challenges You face them in your personal

life ministry context and missional engagements

Will you treat the themes in this book as abstract theoretical notions

Will this be a temporary infatuation a flirtation with the ldquootherrdquo that dissi-pates as suddenly as it arrived Or will glocal conversations become an en-

riching and formative orientation in your life Will glocal conversations

bring fresh approaches to theology faith mission church and worship Will

conversations with other cultures and theologies become for you a com-

pelling way of life

My prayer is that glocal conversations will help the church be a global

visible alternative ldquocity set upon a hillrdquo a truly GlobalChurch

28Craig Ott and Harold A Netland Globalizing Teology Belie and Practice in an Era o World

Christianity (Grand Rapids Baker Academic 983090983088983088983094) 1048625983090983093

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3636

Page 33: GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3336

10486281048624 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

these things Instead it adopts a responsive humble celebratory open in-

clusive and embracing attitude

983094 Glocal theology practices discernment Finally we need discernmentas we engage these ideas and practices Discernment is a huge topic thatrsquos

hard to cover comprehensively in a few words Discernment happens when

the Spirit of Christ and his Word renew our minds Te Spirit grants us

spiritual wisdom as we meditate on him and his Word and as we practice

discipleship to Jesus Christ Romans 10486251048626 provides guidance we need (1048625) to be

transformed by the renewal of our minds (1048626) to serve Christrsquos body and (1048627)

to put love into action Discernment also happens in conversation both lo-cally and glocally

I pray these core values and six practices come across in the following

chapters of GlobalChurch

Glocalization can never be just theoretical Are we committed to moving

glocalization from an abstract idea to a living communion Are we deter-

mined to construct a missional theology of the church in the context of

glocal conversations Tis must involve dialogue between Majority Worldindigenous and Western scholars activists and groups

Will glocalization be an abstract notion Or will it be a formative and

genuine communion between local regional and global voices Glocal dy-

namics are at play whether we like it or not Teyrsquore in our churches the-

ologies and missions But we can choose to relinquish isolationist colonial

parochial and arrogant approaches Instead we can adopt responsive dia-

logical learning humble and embracing postures

Trough healthy approaches to glocalization the Spirit challenges us to

value local contexts We immerse ourselves in local and particular commu-

nities and conversations He inspires us to open ourselves to global theo-

logical conversations He rouses us to value the symbiotic relationship be-

tween the localparticular and the globaluniversal

Trough glocal relationships the Spirit leads us to put local contextual

theologies into conversation with global ones He prompts us to explore the

ways in which the local is in the glocal and the global is in the local He per-

suades us to pursue collaboration and dialogue and mutual learning We

engage with Christians from different backgrounds and cultures ecumen-

icals Pentecostals evangelicals and so on from Western indigenous and

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3436

Glocalizing Conversations 10486281048625

Majority World contexts He motivates us to express solidarity between all

parties We appreciate our unity in diversity

Trough glocal conversations the Spirit moves us to ensure that unity andsolidarity emerge from a compelling vision of Jesusrsquo kingdom and gospel

and person He challenges us to share information theology and practices

He urges us to learn from each othermdashour successes and mistakes We seek

glocal solutions

Te Spirit calls us to develop glocal conversations about Christian ideas

and practices Tese include Scripture Evangelicalism ecumenism Pente-

costalism Jesus Christ the Holy Spirit God the Father the rinity com-munity spirituality discipleship liturgy worship hospitality prayer eco-

justice education social ethics Christian leadership gospel and culture

beauty place suffering liberation and so forth

Finally through glocal conversations the Spirit leads us to adopt a new

posture Tis is a responsive humble celebratory open inclusive and em-

bracing attitude to the ldquootherrdquo We do this as a new people made up of every

tribe and language and people and nationTere are dangers in glocalization Sugirtharajah warns of the commodi-

fication of local contextual practices and theologies When this happens

they are ldquosmoothed out of their primary contexts concerns and contesta-

tions travel across borders and become objects of analysis and scrutiny

within an alien secondary contextrdquo1048626983095

Itrsquos common for those of us who are Western to make mistakes when we

wrestle with Majority World and indigenous ideas Sugirtharajah mentions

our tendency to commodify reduce and institutionalize these ideas We also

risk doing these things (1048625) We apply them in noncontextual prescriptive ways

(1048626) We ignore their meanings in their original setting (1048627) We glamorize or

idealize their proponents or their contexts (1048628) We demonize those persons or

contexts (1048629) We disregard them as irrelevant rhetorical or minority discourse

Kevin J Vanhoozer says that we can fall into three traps when we glo-

calize theology (1048625) We can underestimate the theological significance of

local cultures (1048626) We can homogenize cultures and theologies exaggerating

27R S Sugirtharajah ldquoextual ake-Aways Tird World exts in Western Metropolitan Centresrdquo

Black Teology in Britain A Journal o Contextual Praxis 983090 (1048625983097983097983097) 10486271048627 10486271048631 Edward W Said Te

World the ext and the Critic (Cambridge MA Harvard University Press 10486259830979830961048627) 9830901048627983097

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3536

10486281048626 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

ldquothe onerdquo (1048627) We can overemphasize cultural particularity exaggerating ldquothe

manyrdquo and pursue ldquotheological ethnificationrdquo10486261048632

My hope is that GlobalChurch does not fall into the traps Sugirtharajahand Vanhoozer describe I hope that what unfolds in the following chapters

is respectful and discerning I hope it leads to further mutually enriching

conversations between people of different cultures

You the reader face the same challenges You face them in your personal

life ministry context and missional engagements

Will you treat the themes in this book as abstract theoretical notions

Will this be a temporary infatuation a flirtation with the ldquootherrdquo that dissi-pates as suddenly as it arrived Or will glocal conversations become an en-

riching and formative orientation in your life Will glocal conversations

bring fresh approaches to theology faith mission church and worship Will

conversations with other cultures and theologies become for you a com-

pelling way of life

My prayer is that glocal conversations will help the church be a global

visible alternative ldquocity set upon a hillrdquo a truly GlobalChurch

28Craig Ott and Harold A Netland Globalizing Teology Belie and Practice in an Era o World

Christianity (Grand Rapids Baker Academic 983090983088983088983094) 1048625983090983093

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3636

Page 34: GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3436

Glocalizing Conversations 10486281048625

Majority World contexts He motivates us to express solidarity between all

parties We appreciate our unity in diversity

Trough glocal conversations the Spirit moves us to ensure that unity andsolidarity emerge from a compelling vision of Jesusrsquo kingdom and gospel

and person He challenges us to share information theology and practices

He urges us to learn from each othermdashour successes and mistakes We seek

glocal solutions

Te Spirit calls us to develop glocal conversations about Christian ideas

and practices Tese include Scripture Evangelicalism ecumenism Pente-

costalism Jesus Christ the Holy Spirit God the Father the rinity com-munity spirituality discipleship liturgy worship hospitality prayer eco-

justice education social ethics Christian leadership gospel and culture

beauty place suffering liberation and so forth

Finally through glocal conversations the Spirit leads us to adopt a new

posture Tis is a responsive humble celebratory open inclusive and em-

bracing attitude to the ldquootherrdquo We do this as a new people made up of every

tribe and language and people and nationTere are dangers in glocalization Sugirtharajah warns of the commodi-

fication of local contextual practices and theologies When this happens

they are ldquosmoothed out of their primary contexts concerns and contesta-

tions travel across borders and become objects of analysis and scrutiny

within an alien secondary contextrdquo1048626983095

Itrsquos common for those of us who are Western to make mistakes when we

wrestle with Majority World and indigenous ideas Sugirtharajah mentions

our tendency to commodify reduce and institutionalize these ideas We also

risk doing these things (1048625) We apply them in noncontextual prescriptive ways

(1048626) We ignore their meanings in their original setting (1048627) We glamorize or

idealize their proponents or their contexts (1048628) We demonize those persons or

contexts (1048629) We disregard them as irrelevant rhetorical or minority discourse

Kevin J Vanhoozer says that we can fall into three traps when we glo-

calize theology (1048625) We can underestimate the theological significance of

local cultures (1048626) We can homogenize cultures and theologies exaggerating

27R S Sugirtharajah ldquoextual ake-Aways Tird World exts in Western Metropolitan Centresrdquo

Black Teology in Britain A Journal o Contextual Praxis 983090 (1048625983097983097983097) 10486271048627 10486271048631 Edward W Said Te

World the ext and the Critic (Cambridge MA Harvard University Press 10486259830979830961048627) 9830901048627983097

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3536

10486281048626 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

ldquothe onerdquo (1048627) We can overemphasize cultural particularity exaggerating ldquothe

manyrdquo and pursue ldquotheological ethnificationrdquo10486261048632

My hope is that GlobalChurch does not fall into the traps Sugirtharajahand Vanhoozer describe I hope that what unfolds in the following chapters

is respectful and discerning I hope it leads to further mutually enriching

conversations between people of different cultures

You the reader face the same challenges You face them in your personal

life ministry context and missional engagements

Will you treat the themes in this book as abstract theoretical notions

Will this be a temporary infatuation a flirtation with the ldquootherrdquo that dissi-pates as suddenly as it arrived Or will glocal conversations become an en-

riching and formative orientation in your life Will glocal conversations

bring fresh approaches to theology faith mission church and worship Will

conversations with other cultures and theologies become for you a com-

pelling way of life

My prayer is that glocal conversations will help the church be a global

visible alternative ldquocity set upon a hillrdquo a truly GlobalChurch

28Craig Ott and Harold A Netland Globalizing Teology Belie and Practice in an Era o World

Christianity (Grand Rapids Baker Academic 983090983088983088983094) 1048625983090983093

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3636

Page 35: GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3536

10486281048626 G983148983151983138983137983148C983144983157983154983139983144

ldquothe onerdquo (1048627) We can overemphasize cultural particularity exaggerating ldquothe

manyrdquo and pursue ldquotheological ethnificationrdquo10486261048632

My hope is that GlobalChurch does not fall into the traps Sugirtharajahand Vanhoozer describe I hope that what unfolds in the following chapters

is respectful and discerning I hope it leads to further mutually enriching

conversations between people of different cultures

You the reader face the same challenges You face them in your personal

life ministry context and missional engagements

Will you treat the themes in this book as abstract theoretical notions

Will this be a temporary infatuation a flirtation with the ldquootherrdquo that dissi-pates as suddenly as it arrived Or will glocal conversations become an en-

riching and formative orientation in your life Will glocal conversations

bring fresh approaches to theology faith mission church and worship Will

conversations with other cultures and theologies become for you a com-

pelling way of life

My prayer is that glocal conversations will help the church be a global

visible alternative ldquocity set upon a hillrdquo a truly GlobalChurch

28Craig Ott and Harold A Netland Globalizing Teology Belie and Practice in an Era o World

Christianity (Grand Rapids Baker Academic 983090983088983088983094) 1048625983090983093

Copyrighted Material wwwivpresscompermissions

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3636

Page 36: GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

8202019 GlobalChurch By Graham Hill - EXCERPT

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullglobalchurch-by-graham-hill-excerpt 3636