Gil EinzigerRoy Friedman Computer Science Department Technion.

Gil Einziger Roy FriedmanComputer Science Department

Technion

Postman: an Elastic Highly Resilient Pub/Sub Framework for

Self Sustained Service Independent P2P

Networks

Background: Publish/Subscribe

• Publisher: any entity that wishes to publish some event

Look at my new hairstyle

Background: Publish/Subscribe

• Subscriber: any entity that wishes to be notified about events that match its interests (also called subscription)

I want to know

everything about

hairstylesI want to

know everything

about Ariana Grande

I only care about science

fiction

Background: Publish/Subscribe

• The system’s goal is to deliver notifications about events to interested subscribers and only to them– Decoupling of information producers from consumers

• Applications:– Social networking (Twitter and the likes)– Stock quotes– Control systems– Data-center management– Etc.

Background: P2P

• Decentralized systems in which (most of) the communication is performed directly between the end nodes of the system – the peers

• Often, peers are donated users’ machines– But can also be set-top boxes, routers, a large datacenter’s

servers, etc.

• Famous example applications:– Skype, Bittorrent (and other file sharing), IPTV, Bitcoin

It’s a Brave New World Out There

• Most users access online content through their mobiles– Intermittent connectivity– Limited bandwidth– Limited battery life– Limited resources

• We need to decouple the devices used to access the data and the ones serving the P2P network

A Vision for Future P2P Solutions

• Whether ran as a true P2P network between donated machines or inside a data-center:

– Decoupling between devices that consume services and the ones providing the service

• Incentives might be in the form of revenue share with advertisers or paid subscribers

– P2P machines are used for providing multiple services• Not feasible to optimize the P2P overlay for a specific service

Problem Statement

• A scalable and efficient pub/sub system for self-sustained P2P networks– The challenge

• Subscribers might not be present much of the time• Short client sessions• Use the existing overlay

– Quality Goals• High delivery rate• Efficient publication delivery• Reasonable latency• High churn resilience

Our Solution: Overview

Our Solution: Subscribing to Mailbox

• Clients that are aware of mailboxes serving their topics, simply notify these mailboxes about it

• A client that is unaware of such mailboxes, initiates multiple biased random walks– Each mailbox distributes a hint (Bloom filter) with the topics it

subscribes to its overlay neighbors up to some distance– The random walks favor visiting nodes whose hints include a match– The random walks continue for a given TTL trying to find as many

matching mailbox as possible

• If none is found, then the home node becomes a mailbox for these topics

Our Solution: Mailboxes

• An overloaded mailbox can refuse to accept new clients and topics

• Mailboxes disappear naturally due to churn or when they are underutilized

• The important objective is load sharing rather than load balancing

Our Solution: Dissemination

• Spanning tree among mailboxes that know each other

• Random walks to discover new mailboxes and disseminate to them

Our Solution: Dissemination

• Spanning tree among mailboxes that know each other

• Random walks to discover new mailboxes and disseminate to them

Our Solution: Dissemination

• Spanning tree + random walks between mailboxes

• Normally, a mailbox pushes events to corresponding registered clients

• Additionally, out-of-band gossip between mailboxes and clients– Clients poll their set of known mailboxes– Exchange list of known events with each polled mailbox– Occurs periodically plus after re-connection

Implementation

– Written in Java– Open source project

• All code including testing available online

– Can be run on top of real IP networks as well as the PeerSim simulator

• In the real networks case, executed on top of the OpenKAD implementation of the Kademlia DHT

– Measurements confirm similarity between results with similar size networks

• Simulations can be used to explore scalability• Real networks can be used to validate simulation results

Evaluation: Methodology

• Traces:– Synthetic traces

• Subscriptions are spread to clients/home nodes uniformly• Topic publication distribution is Zipf-like with α=0.9

– Twitter traces

• Metrics:– Delivery rate– Communication load– Mailbox subscription pattern vs. users’– Effects of churn

Results: Synthetic Workload

Time (minutes)

Del

iver

y R

ate

Delivery rate over time vs. network size

1) Delivery rate approachs 100% after a few minutes

2) For 1500 nodes, simulation ~ real runs

Results: Twitter Traces

Time (minutes)

Del

iver

y R

ate

Delivery rate over time

Results: Load Distribution

# node

Tota

l Han

dled

Mes

sage

s

Load Distribution (Twitter)

1) Almost all load goes to mailboxes only

2) Even most loaded need to handle fewer than 10 messages per second

Results: Subscription Pattern

# node

Sub

scrip

tion

Num

ber

Twitter (Feb. 7 2010 19:00-20:20)

Subscription pattern of mailboxes much more uniform than of clients=> balanced dissemination trees

Results: Subscription Pattern

Client Subscriptions

Mai

lbox

Sub

scrip

tions

#Registered Clients/#Registered Mailboxes

Only a small number of mailboxes register even to the most popular topics => the dissemination trees are relatively small

Results: Single 10% Churn Event

Time (minutes)

Mis

s R

ate

Churn Recovery Time

Results: Repetitive 10% Churn

Time (minutes)

Mis

s R

ate

Churn Recovery Over Time

Results: Repetitive 100% Churn

Time (minutes)

Mis

s R

ate

Churn Recovery Time (Loosing All Mailboxes)

Summary

• The concept of elastic mailboxes– Self electing, self evaporating, self organizing

• Complementing delivery mechanisms– Spanning tree– Random walks– Out-of-band gossip through clients interaction

• End result:– Mailboxes dramatically reduce the scalability problem– Highly efficient, highly effective, highly robust to failures

and churn

Open Issues

• Exploit subscription similarity• Privacy

Q&A

• Thanks for listening…