GIBSON DUNN May 23, 2014 VIA ELECTRONIC MAIL Reid J. Schar, Esq. Jenner & Block LLP 353 North Clark Street Chicago, Illinois 60654-3456 Re: New Jersey Legislative Select Committee on Investigation Dear Mr. Schar: Gibson, Dunn & Crutcher LLP 200 Park Avenue New York, NY 10166-0193 Tel 212.351.4000 www.gibsondunn.com Alexander H. Southwell Direct: +1 212.351.3981 Fax: +1 212.351.6281 [email protected]I write in response to your May 9 letter, and further to my May 12 email, regarding the status of the Office of the Governor of New Jersey's subpoena compliance. As with your May 2 letter, we were disappointed to receive your May 9 letter, given our customary practice of conferring by telephone and my invitation to resume doing so here. You instead chose to send another letter that appears, again, intended for a different audience, ignores or distorts the ample record of the OGNJ's cooperation, and seeks to minimize the evident problems with the SCI' s prior subpoenas. We are therefore compelled to respond in writing to several mischaracterizations in your letter. Rather than acknowledge what is now beyond dispute-that the subpoenas issued by the New Jersey Legislative Select Committee on Investigation ("SCI") are overbroad and impermissible, as Judge Jacobson's April 9 ruling made clear-you offer "guidance" that substantively modifies those subpoenas beyond recognition. Indeed, your May 9 letter demands the production of records that, as you acknowledge, are not even responsive to the subpoenas and that have nothing whatsoever to do with the George Washington Bridge lane realignment (the "lane realignment"). We are also disappointed that-whether intentionally or not-your May 9 letter contains repeated misstatements of fact. I will highlight just a couple of the most egregious ones here. One glaring example: you speculate that there must be more responsive documents from Governor Christie, claiming that he should have more because, according to you, a period of "intense public awareness of the issue [of the lane realignment] ... developed since at least September 13, 2013." All of us know that is not true. The lane realignment was mentioned only once-in a single local newspaper column- as of September 13, 2013. And to be crystal clear, we have produced all such responsive documents. You also erroneously claim that an August 22, 2013 email between Bridget Kelly and Christina Renna was not produced until April 22, 2014, when, in fact, that Beijing· Brussels· Century City· Dallas· Denver· Dubai· Hong Kong· London· Los Angeles· Munich New York· Orange County· Palo Alto • Paris· San Francisco· Sao Paulo· Singapore ·Washington, D.C.
21
Embed
GIBSON DUNN Crutcher LLP 200 Park Avenue · 2014-12-05 · GIBSON DUNN May 23, 2014 VIA ELECTRONIC MAIL Reid J. Schar, Esq. Jenner & Block LLP 353 North Clark Street Chicago, Illinois
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
GIBSON DUNN
May 23, 2014
VIA ELECTRONIC MAIL
Reid J. Schar, Esq. Jenner & Block LLP 353 North Clark Street Chicago, Illinois 60654-3456
Re: New Jersey Legislative Select Committee on Investigation
Dear Mr. Schar:
Gibson, Dunn & Crutcher LLP
200 Park Avenue
New York, NY 10166-0193
Tel 212.351.4000
www.gibsondunn.com
Alexander H. Southwell Direct: +1 212.351.3981 Fax: +1 212.351.6281 [email protected]
I write in response to your May 9 letter, and further to my May 12 email, regarding the status of the Office of the Governor of New Jersey's subpoena compliance. As with your May 2 letter, we were disappointed to receive your May 9 letter, given our customary practice of conferring by telephone and my invitation to resume doing so here. You instead chose to send another letter that appears, again, intended for a different audience, ignores or distorts the ample record of the OGNJ's cooperation, and seeks to minimize the evident problems with the SCI' s prior subpoenas. We are therefore compelled to respond in writing to several mischaracterizations in your letter.
Rather than acknowledge what is now beyond dispute-that the subpoenas issued by the New Jersey Legislative Select Committee on Investigation ("SCI") are overbroad and impermissible, as Judge Jacobson's April 9 ruling made clear-you offer "guidance" that substantively modifies those subpoenas beyond recognition. Indeed, your May 9 letter demands the production of records that, as you acknowledge, are not even responsive to the subpoenas and that have nothing whatsoever to do with the George Washington Bridge lane realignment (the "lane realignment"). We are also disappointed that-whether intentionally or not-your May 9 letter contains repeated misstatements of fact. I will highlight just a couple of the most egregious ones here. One glaring example: you speculate that there must be more responsive documents from Governor Christie, claiming that he should have more because, according to you, a period of "intense public awareness of the issue [of the lane realignment] ... developed since at least September 13, 2013." All of us know that is not true. The lane realignment was mentioned only once-in a single local newspaper columnas of September 13, 2013. And to be crystal clear, we have produced all such responsive documents. You also erroneously claim that an August 22, 2013 email between Bridget Kelly and Christina Renna was not produced until April 22, 2014, when, in fact, that
Beijing· Brussels· Century City· Dallas· Denver· Dubai· Hong Kong· London· Los Angeles· Munich
New York· Orange County· Palo Alto • Paris· San Francisco· Sao Paulo· Singapore ·Washington, D.C.
GIBSON DUNN
Reid J. Schar, Esq. May 23, 2014 Page 2
document was produced to the SCI in March 2014 before our Report was released to the public. See OGNJ-LEG-050258-59.
In furtherance of our continuing cooperation--cooperation that has already resulted in the production of more than 76,000 pages of documents to the SCI-we respond briefly below to some of your stated concerns. But as we did in our May 5 letter, we respectfully request a telephone conference to discuss any outstanding concerns regarding subpoena compliance, particularly given the inaccurate public statements that members of the SCI have made regarding both the status of the OGNJ's document production and the duplicative testimony elicited over three days of public SCI hearings this month that has consisted largely of witnesses repeating what they earlier told us in interviews and we then publicly released, and, apparently, what one witness told you in an interview prior to his testimony.
1. Responsive Records Already Produced By The OGNJ
In your May 9 letter, you continue to be confused about the specific documents we have already produced from Bridget Kelly's and Governor Christie's records. Please find attached, as requested, a Bates-numbered inventory confirming what we have previously and repeatedly represented to you-namely, that we have produced or logged more than 700 documents consisting of more than 5,400 pages sent, received, and/or possessed by Kelly, and more than 150 such documents from the Governor. 1
Your confusion in this regard may have resulted, in part, from the fact that the OGNJ' s initial production did not contain custodian metadata, as discussed with you. As you well know, the SCI's subpoenas as issued did not request the production of custodian metadata. Indeed, I raised this issue during our earliest calls, and you authorized the OGNJ to produce responsive records in PDF form, without custodian metadata. Weeks later, the SCI for the first time modified its document production specifications and requested metadata information, which prompted an additional conversation during which I agreed to provide this newly requested metadata as soon as was possible. In any event, the attached inventory leaves no doubt regarding the volume of responsive records already produced from these individuals.
We also hereby confirm that we have responded to your request for purported "handwritten notes" prepared by Michael Drewniak (see my May 13 email to you), and that OGNJ records
1 Our May 5 letter noted that "we have produced more than 65 [] documents consisting of around 200 pages" that were "maintained by Governor Chris Christie." As the attached inventory confirms, the OGNJ has produced or logged more than 150 documents sent, received, and/or possessed by Governor Christie.
GIBSON DUNN
Reid J. Schar, Esq. May 23, 2014 Page 3
were reviewed to determine responsiveness to both the January 27 and February 10 subpoenas. Furthermore, at various points in your letter you have asked us to confirm the diligence and thoroughness of our review for responsive documents. Rest assured that we are fully aware of and have fulfilled our obligations under the SCI subpoenas.
2. Non-Responsive Records Demanded By The SCI
As previously explained, your May 9 letter demands the production of several categories of records that are not responsive to either your January 27 or February 10 subpoenas. Though we are willing, consistent with our continued cooperation, to discuss a voluntary production of certain requested records, we note our ongoing objection to your unilateral modification of the subpoenas and our reservation of all rights with respect to the production of records.
First, you note that the OGNJ has not produced certain December 6, 2013 emails between Michael Drewniak and Governor Christie to the SCI. But as your May 9 letter explicitly acknowledges one sentence earlier, those non-responsive emails concern "the resignation of former Port Authority official David Wildstein," not the September 2013 lane realignment or any other subject matter called for by your subpoenas. Thus, the emails you demand do not respond-on their face or by any other measure of responsiveness-to the subpoenas the SCI has issued.
Second, your January 27 subpoena requested the production of certain telephone records "regarding the reduction from three to one of the eastbound Fort Lee, New Jersey access lanes to the George Washington Bridge from September 9, 2013 through September 13, 2013." In our May 5 letter, we specified numerous deficiencies in this request, several of which we identified for you months ago in a February 1 telephone call, including the SCI's failure to identify which employees' telephone records in particular we should review, as well as the fact that toll records simply do not identify the substance of any communication. Those deficiencies explain why you agreed to "table" this request during our February 1 call.
The unilateral modifications to the subpoena's request for toll records in your May 2 letter, however, did nothing to cure the subpoena's infirmity in this regard, even as it tacitly acknowledged the deficiencies in the original request. In response to our catalog of the request's numerous deficiencies, you now demand "logs of all calls between or among" 26 individuals, only 14 of whom are current or former employees of the OGNJ. In other words, faced with the manifest infirmities in the request for toll records in the SCI's January 27 subpoena, you respond by simply broadening the category of records demanded, once again confirming Judge Jacobsen's conclusion that the SCI document requests "even as modified remain a fishing expedition." The New Jersey Legislative Select Committee on Investigation v. Kelly and Stepien, Dkts. L-350-14, L-350-15 (Sup. Ct. N.J. Apr. 9, 2014), at 40. The toll
GIBSON DUNN
Reid J. Schar, Esq. May 23, 2014 Page4
records you now seek are overbroad and include records that have nothing whatsoever to do with the lane realignment; they largely concern OGNJ and Port Authority employees who had nothing whatsoever to do with the lane realignment. Not only is this request overbroad, it is unduly burdensome, as it requires the OGNJ to wade through tens of thousands of toll entries. And it remains ambiguous, inexplicably failing to identify the precise Port Authority telephone numbers for which you are asking the OGNJ to search.
Nevertheless, in furtherance of our continuing cooperation, we look forward to discussing this proposal with you, and we intend also to produce the "Poster of Names" requested in your May 9 letter.
3. Calendar Entries
As noted in our May 5 letter, your request for "all calendars, day planers, notes, and/or diaries from September 1, 2012 to the present," with no substantive or custodian restriction or focus, is plainly overbroad and impermissible. Once again, that is presumably why you agreed to "table" this request months ago, during our February 1 call. We did not hear back from you until your recent May correspondence, and you now propose to cure this deficiency by "offering to accept, as an initial matter, calendar items for the same list of 14 current or former employees whose telephone records were of most immediate interest." But this amended request continues to lack a substantive restriction, and thus continues to suffer fatal overbreadth (as Judge Jacobson concluded). Once again, you cannot dispute that this modified request seeks documents that have nothing whatsoever to do with the lane realignment-an overbroad and burdensome demand, particularly given the SCI' s stated focus on the lane realignment issue.
Moreover, as we stated in our May 5 letter, "our review of electronic data in fact included searching for items related to the lane realignment and[] there were no responsive calendar entries, notes, or diary entries related to the lane realignment"-a fact that is "hardly surprising," given our conclusion that no one inside the Office of the Governor other than Bridget Kelly had any involvement in causing the lane realignment or otherwise had advance knowledge of it. In other words, notwithstanding the fatal overbreadth and invalidity of your initial request for all calendar items with no substantive or custodian restrictions, we nevertheless proceeded to search OGNJ electronic records for calendar items responsive to your subpoenas. And, in fact, we already produced several such calendar items from the relevant OGNJ custodians. See OGNJ-LEG-10247; OGNJ-LEG-35447; OGNJ-LEG-17116 - 17117. Thus, our substantial cooperation has mooted this issue, and your effort now to seek documents well beyond the lane realignment issue does not cure the defects we identified long ago in the SCI's January 27 subpoena.
GIBSON DUNN
Reid J. Schar, Esq. May 23, 2014 Page 5
In closing, we remain committed to working through the issues raised in your May 9 letter and will make ourselves available for a call to discuss them. Please let me know when you would like to do so.
Alexander H. Southwell
Enclosure
List of Documents Produced or Logged and Possessed by or Sent To or From Bridget KellySubmitted by Office of the Governor of New Jersey to the Select Committee on Investigation, May 23, 2014
*Denotes an email or attachment to an email sent to or received by Bridget Kelly that, unlike the other listed documents, was produced from another individual's custody. Page 1 of 13
List of Documents Produced or Logged and Possessed by or Sent To or From Bridget KellySubmitted by Office of the Governor of New Jersey to the Select Committee on Investigation, May 23, 2014
*Denotes an email or attachment to an email sent to or received by Bridget Kelly that, unlike the other listed documents, was produced from another individual's custody. Page 2 of 13
List of Documents Produced or Logged and Possessed by or Sent To or From Bridget KellySubmitted by Office of the Governor of New Jersey to the Select Committee on Investigation, May 23, 2014
*Denotes an email or attachment to an email sent to or received by Bridget Kelly that, unlike the other listed documents, was produced from another individual's custody. Page 3 of 13
List of Documents Produced or Logged and Possessed by or Sent To or From Bridget KellySubmitted by Office of the Governor of New Jersey to the Select Committee on Investigation, May 23, 2014
*Denotes an email or attachment to an email sent to or received by Bridget Kelly that, unlike the other listed documents, was produced from another individual's custody. Page 4 of 13
List of Documents Produced or Logged and Possessed by or Sent To or From Bridget KellySubmitted by Office of the Governor of New Jersey to the Select Committee on Investigation, May 23, 2014
*Denotes an email or attachment to an email sent to or received by Bridget Kelly that, unlike the other listed documents, was produced from another individual's custody. Page 5 of 13
List of Documents Produced or Logged and Possessed by or Sent To or From Bridget KellySubmitted by Office of the Governor of New Jersey to the Select Committee on Investigation, May 23, 2014
*Denotes an email or attachment to an email sent to or received by Bridget Kelly that, unlike the other listed documents, was produced from another individual's custody. Page 6 of 13
List of Documents Produced or Logged and Possessed by or Sent To or From Bridget KellySubmitted by Office of the Governor of New Jersey to the Select Committee on Investigation, May 23, 2014
*Denotes an email or attachment to an email sent to or received by Bridget Kelly that, unlike the other listed documents, was produced from another individual's custody. Page 7 of 13
List of Documents Produced or Logged and Possessed by or Sent To or From Bridget KellySubmitted by Office of the Governor of New Jersey to the Select Committee on Investigation, May 23, 2014
*Denotes an email or attachment to an email sent to or received by Bridget Kelly that, unlike the other listed documents, was produced from another individual's custody. Page 8 of 13
List of Documents Produced or Logged and Possessed by or Sent To or From Bridget KellySubmitted by Office of the Governor of New Jersey to the Select Committee on Investigation, May 23, 2014
*Denotes an email or attachment to an email sent to or received by Bridget Kelly that, unlike the other listed documents, was produced from another individual's custody. Page 9 of 13
List of Documents Produced or Logged and Possessed by or Sent To or From Bridget KellySubmitted by Office of the Governor of New Jersey to the Select Committee on Investigation, May 23, 2014
*Denotes an email or attachment to an email sent to or received by Bridget Kelly that, unlike the other listed documents, was produced from another individual's custody. Page 10 of 13
List of Documents Produced or Logged and Possessed by or Sent To or From Bridget KellySubmitted by Office of the Governor of New Jersey to the Select Committee on Investigation, May 23, 2014
Number Bates Range Document Custodian601 OGNJ-LEG-072453 - OGNJ-LEG-072453 Bridget Kelly602 OGNJ-LEG-072454 - OGNJ-LEG-072455 Bridget Kelly603 OGNJ-LEG-072456 - OGNJ-LEG-072457 Bridget Kelly604 OGNJ-LEG-072458 - OGNJ-LEG-072458 Bridget Kelly605 OGNJ-LEG-072459 - OGNJ-LEG-072459 Bridget Kelly606 OGNJ-LEG-072460 - OGNJ-LEG-072460 Bridget Kelly607 OGNJ-LEG-072461 - OGNJ-LEG-072470 Bridget Kelly608 OGNJ-LEG-072471 - OGNJ-LEG-072480 Bridget Kelly609 OGNJ-LEG-072481 - OGNJ-LEG-072486 Bridget Kelly610 OGNJ-LEG-072487 - OGNJ-LEG-072489 Bridget Kelly611 OGNJ-LEG-072490 - OGNJ-LEG-072490 Bridget Kelly612 OGNJ-LEG-072491 - OGNJ-LEG-072491 Bridget Kelly613 OGNJ-LEG-072492 - OGNJ-LEG-072492 Bridget Kelly614 OGNJ-LEG-072493 - OGNJ-LEG-072493 Bridget Kelly615 OGNJ-LEG-072494 - OGNJ-LEG-072494 Bridget Kelly616 OGNJ-LEG-072495 - OGNJ-LEG-072499 Bridget Kelly617 OGNJ-LEG-072500 - OGNJ-LEG-072500 Bridget Kelly618 OGNJ-LEG-072501 - OGNJ-LEG-072510 Bridget Kelly619 OGNJ-LEG-007192 - OGNJ-LEG-007194* Christina Renna620 OGNJ-LEG-043787 - OGNJ-LEG-043787* Christina Renna621 OGNJ-LEG-043833 - OGNJ-LEG-043834* Christina Renna622 OGNJ-LEG-043835 - OGNJ-LEG-043835* Christina Renna623 OGNJ-LEG-043836 - OGNJ-LEG-043839* Christina Renna624 OGNJ-LEG-043840 - OGNJ-LEG-043840* Christina Renna625 OGNJ-LEG-043842 - OGNJ-LEG-043844* Christina Renna626 OGNJ-LEG-073984 - OGNJ-LEG-073984* Christina Renna627 OGNJ-LEG-073985 - OGNJ-LEG-073985* Christina Renna628 OGNJ-LEG-073986 - OGNJ-LEG-073987* Christina Renna629 OGNJ-LEG-073988 - OGNJ-LEG-074015* Christina Renna630 OGNJ-LEG-074016 - OGNJ-LEG-074016* Christina Renna631 OGNJ-LEG-074017 - OGNJ-LEG-074017* Christina Renna632 OGNJ-LEG-074018 - OGNJ-LEG-074018* Christina Renna633 OGNJ-LEG-074019 - OGNJ-LEG-074019* Christina Renna634 OGNJ-LEG-074020 - OGNJ-LEG-074020* Christina Renna635 OGNJ-LEG-074021 - OGNJ-LEG-074053* Christina Renna636 OGNJ-LEG-074054 - OGNJ-LEG-074054* Christina Renna637 OGNJ-LEG-074055 - OGNJ-LEG-074057* Christina Renna638 OGNJ-LEG-074058 - OGNJ-LEG-074058* Christina Renna639 OGNJ-LEG-074059 - OGNJ-LEG-074085* Christina Renna640 OGNJ-LEG-074267 - OGNJ-LEG-074267* Christina Renna641 OGNJ-LEG-074268 - OGNJ-LEG-074268* Christina Renna642 OGNJ-LEG-074269 - OGNJ-LEG-074272* Christina Renna643 OGNJ-LEG-074273 - OGNJ-LEG-074371* Christina Renna644 OGNJ-LEG-074372 - OGNJ-LEG-074380* Christina Renna645 OGNJ-LEG-074381 - OGNJ-LEG-074386* Christina Renna646 OGNJ-LEG-074387 - OGNJ-LEG-074485* Christina Renna647 OGNJ-LEG-074490 - OGNJ-LEG-074496* Christina Renna648 OGNJ-LEG-074497 - OGNJ-LEG-074499* Christina Renna649 OGNJ-LEG-074500 - OGNJ-LEG-074539* Christina Renna650 OGNJ-LEG-074540 - OGNJ-LEG-074542* Christina Renna651 OGNJ-LEG-074543 - OGNJ-LEG-074641* Christina Renna652 OGNJ-LEG-074744 - OGNJ-LEG-074753* Christina Renna653 OGNJ-LEG-074755 - OGNJ-LEG-074764* Christina Renna654 OGNJ-LEG-074765 - OGNJ-LEG-074765* Christina Renna655 OGNJ-LEG-000001 - OGNJ-LEG-000002* Deborah Gramiccioni656 OGNJ-LEG-000003 - OGNJ-LEG-000003* Deborah Gramiccioni657 OGNJ-LEG-000004 - OGNJ-LEG-000005* Deborah Gramiccioni658 OGNJ-LEG-000006 - OGNJ-LEG-000006* Deborah Gramiccioni659 OGNJ-LEG-000007 - OGNJ-LEG-000008* Deborah Gramiccioni660 OGNJ-LEG-000009 - OGNJ-LEG-000009* Deborah Gramiccioni
*Denotes an email or attachment to an email sent to or received by Bridget Kelly that, unlike the other listed documents, was produced from another individual's custody. Page 11 of 13
List of Documents Produced or Logged and Possessed by or Sent To or From Bridget KellySubmitted by Office of the Governor of New Jersey to the Select Committee on Investigation, May 23, 2014
*Denotes an email or attachment to an email sent to or received by Bridget Kelly that, unlike the other listed documents, was produced from another individual's custody. Page 12 of 13
List of Documents Produced or Logged and Possessed by or Sent To or From Bridget KellySubmitted by Office of the Governor of New Jersey to the Select Committee on Investigation, May 23, 2014
*Denotes an email or attachment to an email sent to or received by Bridget Kelly that, unlike the other listed documents, was produced from another individual's custody. Page 13 of 13
List of Documents Produced or Logged and Possessed by or Sent To or From Governor ChristieSubmitted by Office of the Governor of New Jersey to the Select Committee on Investigation, May 23, 2014
*Denotes an email or attachment to an email sent to or received by Governor Christie that, unlike the other listed documents, was produced from another individual's custody. Page 1 of 3
List of Documents Produced or Logged and Possessed by or Sent To or From Governor ChristieSubmitted by Office of the Governor of New Jersey to the Select Committee on Investigation, May 23, 2014
Number Bates Range Document Custodian61 OGNJ-LEG-053295 - OGNJ-LEG-053295 Governor Christie62 OGNJ-LEG-053296 - OGNJ-LEG-053304 Governor Christie63 OGNJ-LEG-053305 - OGNJ-LEG-053306 Governor Christie64 OGNJ-LEG-053307 - OGNJ-LEG-053308 Governor Christie65 OGNJ-LEG-053309 - OGNJ-LEG-053315 Governor Christie66 OGNJ-LEG-072406 - OGNJ-LEG-072407* Bridget Kelly67 OGNJ-LEG-072408 - OGNJ-LEG-072408* Bridget Kelly68 OGNJ-LEG-072409 - OGNJ-LEG-072409* Bridget Kelly69 OGNJ-LEG-072410 - OGNJ-LEG-072415* Bridget Kelly70 OGNJ-LEG-072523 - OGNJ-LEG-072525* Charles McKenna71 OGNJ-LEG-072526 - OGNJ-LEG-072526* Charles McKenna72 OGNJ-LEG-072527 - OGNJ-LEG-072527* Charles McKenna73 OGNJ-LEG-072528 - OGNJ-LEG-072528* Charles McKenna74 OGNJ-LEG-072529 - OGNJ-LEG-072529* Charles McKenna75 OGNJ-LEG-072530 - OGNJ-LEG-072530* Charles McKenna76 OGNJ-LEG-072531 - OGNJ-LEG-072535* Charles McKenna77 OGNJ-LEG-072536 - OGNJ-LEG-072538* Charles McKenna78 OGNJ-LEG-072539 - OGNJ-LEG-072539* Charles McKenna79 OGNJ-LEG-072540 - OGNJ-LEG-072540* Charles McKenna80 OGNJ-LEG-072541 - OGNJ-LEG-072549* Charles McKenna81 OGNJ-LEG-072550 - OGNJ-LEG-072550* Charles McKenna82 OGNJ-LEG-072551 - OGNJ-LEG-072551* Charles McKenna83 OGNJ-LEG-072552 - OGNJ-LEG-072552* Charles McKenna84 OGNJ-LEG-072553 - OGNJ-LEG-072553* Charles McKenna85 OGNJ-LEG-076209 - OGNJ-LEG-076209* Charles McKenna86 OGNJ-LEG-072555 - OGNJ-LEG-072555* Charles McKenna87 OGNJ-LEG-072556 - OGNJ-LEG-072556* Charles McKenna88 OGNJ-LEG-072557 - OGNJ-LEG-072557* Charles McKenna89 OGNJ-LEG-072558 - OGNJ-LEG-072559* Charles McKenna90 OGNJ-LEG-072560 - OGNJ-LEG-072560* Charles McKenna91 OGNJ-LEG-072561 - OGNJ-LEG-072561* Charles McKenna92 OGNJ-LEG-072562 - OGNJ-LEG-072562* Charles McKenna93 OGNJ-LEG-072563 - OGNJ-LEG-072563* Charles McKenna94 OGNJ-LEG-072564 - OGNJ-LEG-072564* Charles McKenna95 OGNJ-LEG-072565 - OGNJ-LEG-072569* Charles McKenna96 OGNJ-LEG-072571 - OGNJ-LEG-072575* Charles McKenna97 OGNJ-LEG-072576 - OGNJ-LEG-072576* Charles McKenna98 OGNJ-LEG-072577 - OGNJ-LEG-072577* Charles McKenna99 OGNJ-LEG-072578 - OGNJ-LEG-072578* Charles McKenna
100 OGNJ-LEG-072579 - OGNJ-LEG-072579* Charles McKenna101 OGNJ-LEG-072580 - OGNJ-LEG-072590* Charles McKenna102 OGNJ-LEG-072591 - OGNJ-LEG-072591* Charles McKenna103 OGNJ-LEG-072592 - OGNJ-LEG-072592* Charles McKenna104 OGNJ-LEG-072593 - OGNJ-LEG-072593* Charles McKenna105 OGNJ-LEG-072594 - OGNJ-LEG-072594* Charles McKenna106 OGNJ-LEG-072595 - OGNJ-LEG-072595* Charles McKenna107 OGNJ-LEG-072596 - OGNJ-LEG-072596* Charles McKenna108 OGNJ-LEG-072648 - OGNJ-LEG-072650* Charles McKenna109 OGNJ-LEG-072651 - OGNJ-LEG-072651* Charles McKenna110 OGNJ-LEG-072652 - OGNJ-LEG-072652* Charles McKenna111 OGNJ-LEG-072653 - OGNJ-LEG-072654* Charles McKenna112 OGNJ-LEG-072655 - OGNJ-LEG-072655* Charles McKenna113 OGNJ-LEG-072656 - OGNJ-LEG-072656* Charles McKenna114 OGNJ-LEG-072657 - OGNJ-LEG-072661* Charles McKenna115 OGNJ-LEG-072662 - OGNJ-LEG-072664* Charles McKenna116 OGNJ-LEG-072665 - OGNJ-LEG-072665* Charles McKenna117 OGNJ-LEG-072666 - OGNJ-LEG-072666* Charles McKenna118 OGNJ-LEG-072667 - OGNJ-LEG-072668* Charles McKenna119 OGNJ-LEG-072669 - OGNJ-LEG-072669* Charles McKenna120 OGNJ-LEG-072670 - OGNJ-LEG-072670* Charles McKenna
*Denotes an email or attachment to an email sent to or received by Governor Christie that, unlike the other listed documents, was produced from another individual's custody. Page 2 of 3
List of Documents Produced or Logged and Possessed by or Sent To or From Governor ChristieSubmitted by Office of the Governor of New Jersey to the Select Committee on Investigation, May 23, 2014
Number Bates Range Document Custodian121 OGNJ-LEG-072671 - OGNJ-LEG-072675* Charles McKenna122 OGNJ-LEG-072676 - OGNJ-LEG-072680* Charles McKenna123 OGNJ-LEG-072681 - OGNJ-LEG-072681* Charles McKenna124 OGNJ-LEG-072682 - OGNJ-LEG-072682* Charles McKenna125 OGNJ-LEG-072683 - OGNJ-LEG-072683* Charles McKenna126 OGNJ-LEG-072684 - OGNJ-LEG-072684* Charles McKenna127 OGNJ-LEG-072685 - OGNJ-LEG-072695* Charles McKenna128 OGNJ-LEG-072696 - OGNJ-LEG-072696* Charles McKenna129 OGNJ-LEG-072697 - OGNJ-LEG-072697* Charles McKenna130 OGNJ-LEG-072698 - OGNJ-LEG-072698* Charles McKenna131 OGNJ-LEG-072699 - OGNJ-LEG-072699* Charles McKenna132 OGNJ-LEG-072700 - OGNJ-LEG-072700* Charles McKenna133 OGNJ-LEG-072701 - OGNJ-LEG-072701* Charles McKenna134 OGNJ-LEG-073503 - OGNJ-LEG-073504* Colin Reed135 OGNJ-LEG-073505 - OGNJ-LEG-073506* Colin Reed136 OGNJ-LEG-073507 - OGNJ-LEG-073507* Colin Reed137 OGNJ-LEG-073508 - OGNJ-LEG-073513* Colin Reed138 OGNJ-LEG-073743 - OGNJ-LEG-073744* Colin Reed139 OGNJ-LEG-073745 - OGNJ-LEG-073749* Colin Reed140 OGNJ-LEG-073966 - OGNJ-LEG-073966* Colin Reed141 OGNJ-LEG-073968 - OGNJ-LEG-073972* Colin Reed142 OGNJ-LEG-073973 - OGNJ-LEG-073973* Colin Reed143 OGNJ-LEG-073974 - OGNJ-LEG-073974* Colin Reed144 OGNJ-LEG-073975 - OGNJ-LEG-073975* Colin Reed145 OGNJ-LEG-073976 - OGNJ-LEG-073976* Colin Reed146 OGNJ-LEG-073977 - OGNJ-LEG-073977* Colin Reed147 OGNJ-LEG-073978 - OGNJ-LEG-073978* Colin Reed148 OGNJ-LEG-073979 - OGNJ-LEG-073980* Colin Reed149 OGNJ-LEG-014000 - OGNJ-LEG-014001* Maria Comella150 OGNJ-LEG-071398 - OGNJ-LEG-071398* Maria Comella151 OGNJ-LEG-071403 - OGNJ-LEG-071403* Maria Comella152 OGNJ-LEG-071406 - OGNJ-LEG-071407* Maria Comella153 OGNJ-LEG-071410 - OGNJ-LEG-071410* Maria Comella154 OGNJ-LEG-071411 - OGNJ-LEG-071411* Maria Comella155 OGNJ-LEG-071545 - OGNJ-LEG-071546* Michael Drewniak156 OGNJ-LEG-072349 - OGNJ-LEG-072350* Rosemary Iannacone157 OGNJ-LEG-072351 - OGNJ-LEG-072352* Rosemary Iannacone158 OGNJ-LEG-072353 - OGNJ-LEG-072355* Rosemary Iannacone
*Denotes an email or attachment to an email sent to or received by Governor Christie that, unlike the other listed documents, was produced from another individual's custody. Page 3 of 3