Page 1
www.elsevier.com/locate/oregeorev
=Ore Geology Reviews 2
Geology, petrography, and mineral chemistry of the Vazante
non-sulfide and Ambrosia and Fagundes sulfide-rich
carbonate-hosted Zn–(Pb) deposits, Minas Gerais, Brazil
Lena Virgınia Soares Monteiro a,*, Jorge Silva Bettencourt b, Caetano Juliani b,
Tolentino Flavio de Oliveira c
aInstituto de Geociencias, Universidade Estadual de Campinas, R. Joao Pandia Calogeras, 51, CEP 13083-970, Campinas, SP, BrazilbInstituto de Geociencias, Universidade de Sao Paulo, Rua do Lago, 562, CEP 05508-900, Sao Paulo, SP, Brazil
cVotorantim Metais, Rodovia LMG 706, Km, CEP 38780-000, Vazante, Minas Gerais, Brazil
Received 12 February 2005; accepted 28 March 2005
Available online 11 July 2005
Abstract
The Vazante–Paracatu region represents the most important Zn district known in Brazil and includes the Vazante hypogene
non-sulfide Zn deposit composed mainly of willemite (Zn2SiO4) and sphalerite-rich carbonate-hosted Zn–(Pb) deposits.
Fagundes is a stratabound deposit, characterized by strong silicification, dolomitization and a Fe-rich carbonate alteration
halo. The main ore is represented by rhythmically banded, colloform, and zoned pyrite, sphalerite and galena, related to wall
rock dissolution and sulfide infilling, which probably occurs late during the burial diagenesis. Later veins and breccia ore types
reflect epigenetic mobilization, related to brittle–ductile structures. The Ambrosia mineralization is mainly fault-controlled and
related to brecciated dolomite, which is tectonically imbricated with black shales and slates. Typical features include host rock
recrystallization, minor silicification, baroque dolomite and ankerite formation. Pyrite, marcasite, sphalerite and minor galena
occur in brecciated comb-veins and veinlets, which overprint stylolites and tectonic fractures, suggesting an epigenetic origin
for the ore. The Vazante deposit differs from all other deposits of the district due to the presence of willemitic ore, which is
composed of willemite, dolomite, siderite, quartz, hematite, Zn-rich chlorite, barite, franklinite and zincite. The willemitic ore
occurs tectonically imbricate to small sulfide ore bodies, which comprises sphalerite and galena, metabasites and hydrother-
malized dolomites within the Vazante Shear Zone. The relationships between willemite formation and the development of
mylonitic structures suggest that willemitic mineralization and deformation are synchronous episodes closely related to the
Vazante Shear Zone. Low Zn/Cd ratios in sphalerite from Vazante (64 to 98) and Fagundes colloform (96 to 244) and zoned
sphalerite (89 to 305) could reflect the regional role of mineralizing fluids with similar low Zn/Cd ratios and low contents of
reduced sulfur (P
Sred). High Ge (up to 2200 ppm) and the low Fe, Cu, Mn and Ag contents in late-diagenetic Fagundes
sphalerite might suggest that this metal-bearing fluid could be derived from the underlying basin fill, which comprise clastic
sediments and organic matter-rich pelitic sequences. Systematic relationships among sphalerite composition and paragenetic
0169-1368/$ - s
doi:10.1016/j.or
* Correspondi
E-mail addre
8 (2006) 201–234
ee front matter D 2005 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
egeorev.2005.03.005
ng author. Fax: +55 19 37885150.
ss: [email protected] (L.V. Soares Monteiro).
Page 2
L.V. Soares Monteiro et al. / Ore Geology Reviews 28 (2006) 201–234202
evolution of the Fagundes and Ambrosia deposits suggest that progressive fluid mixing processes were important for the genesis
of the sulfide-rich deposits in the district. These mixing processes possibly involved the hot metal-bearing fluid with low
contents of reduced sulfur and moderate-temperature, highly saline fluids, which could represent an important sulfur supply.
The predominance of the highly saline brines in later epigenetic mineralization episodes might be related to episodic migration
of hydrothermal fluids mainly derived from reduced shale sequences during the Brasiliano compressive events. The small
variation in chemical and sulfur isotopic composition of the Vazante sphalerite could imply that the high-temperature metal-
bearing fluid with low Zn/Cd ratios could represent a minor reservoir of reduced sulfur, which permitted only subordinate
sphalerite precipitation in the Vazante deposit. The lack of reduced shale sequences above the Vazante deposit could represent a
limiting factor for H2S supply. Additionally, overall mixture between this hot sulfur-deficient metal-bearing fluid and meteoric
fluids channeled to the Vazante Shear Zone favor the high fO2/S2 conditions responsible for the stability of the Vazante
willemitic assemblage.
D 2005 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
Keywords: Carbonate-hosted Zn–Pb deposit; Non-sulfide zinc deposit; Vazante deposit; Willemite
1. Introduction
The most important Zn-district known in Brazil is
located in the Vazante–Paracatu region, which
extends N–S for up to 250 km in the NW part of
Minas Gerais State (Fig. 1). Within this region,
various carbonate-hosted Zn deposits occur, includ-
ing Vazante, Morro Agudo, Ambrosia, and Fagundes
(Fig. 2). These are currently responsible for all Zn
production in Brazil. Measured reserves have been
estimated at 28.5 Mt with an average grade of 18.3%
Zn (Vazante willemitic ore) and 9.7 Mt with 6.5%
Zn and 2.8% Pb (Morro Agudo sulfide ore) (Viviani
et al., 2001).
The Zn deposits and occurrences are hosted by
metapelitic–dolomitic units of the Vazante Group
(Dardenne et al., 1998). Primary ore types in the
district differ mainly in relative sulfide abundance,
which is a notable feature of the Morro Agudo, Am-
brosia and Fagundes deposits, but is subordinate to
willemitic ore (Zn2SiO4) in the Vazante deposit. Struc-
tural, petrographic, geochemical and stable isotopic
studies carried out in the Vazante mine (Pinho, 1990;
Pinho et al., 1990; Hitzman, 1997; Monteiro, 1997,
2002; Monteiro et al., 1999, 2000, 2003; Hitzman et
al., 2003) have prompted a re-evaluation of the genet-
ic concepts relating to the willemitic mineralization,
which has been, since the 1960s, interpreted to be of
supergene origin. These studies indicate that the will-
emitic ore could have a hydrothermal origin related to
development of the Vazante Shear Zone. Thus, the
Vazante deposit represents the largest known hypo-
gene non-sulfide Zn deposit (Hitzman, 2001; Hitzman
et al., 2003), sharing characteristics with a relatively
small number of other deposits, such as Beltana (Aus-
tralia), Berg Aukus/Abenab (Namibia) and Kabwe
(Zambia).
Furthermore, there is no consensus among workers
about the origin of the carbonate-hosted sulfide depos-
its of this district. The proposed genetic hypotheses
include models similar to the Mississippi Valley Type
(MVT), mainly based on the dolomitic host rocks of
the mineralization and absence of magmatic activity
(Amaral, 1968; Rigobello et al., 1988; Iyer et al.,
1992, 1993). Sulfide textures of the Morro Agudo
ore indicate that mineralization process accompanied
syn-diagenetic, late-diagenetic and epigenetic stages
of the host sequence evolution (Dardenne, 1979;
Dardenne and Schobbenhaus, 2001). The relationship
of sulfide lenses to faults, mineral paragenesis, depo-
sitional temperatures ranging from 100 to 250 8C, andS-isotopic characteristics observed in the Morro
Agudo deposit indicate similarity to Irish-type depos-
its (Hitzman et al., 1995; Hitzman, 1997; Cunha et al.,
2000).
Other deposits in this district, show a predomi-
nance of late-diagenetic (Fagundes) or epigenetic
(Ambrosia) styles of mineralization and evidence of
mobilization, such as partial dissolution, corrosion,
recrystallization, brecciation, and mylonitization, due
to overprinting of later hydrothermal fluids related to
the deformation associated with compressive events
related to the Brasiliano orogeny (Monteiro et al.,
2000; Monteiro and Bettencourt, 2001).
Page 3
N
Crixás
0 250 500 km
0o
16 So
Atla
ntic
Oce
an
Fold Belts
Craton cover
Cratonic areas
Ara
çuai
Bel
t
BFBPhanerozoicsediments
São FranciscoCraton
São FranciscoBasin
Brazil
SouthAmerica
46 Wo50 Wo
Dianópolis
12 So
São Domingos
Phanerozoic
Neoproterozoic
Paleo/Mesoproterozoic
Sedimentary basins
Orthogneiss
Volcano-sedimentarysequences
Meso/Neoproterozoic
Ibiá Formation
Araxá Group
Felsic and mafic granulitesand orthogneisses
Vazante Group
Paranoá Group
Canastra Group
Estrondo Group
Araí Group
Serra da Mesa Group
Mafic-ultramafic complexes
Volcano-sedimentary sequences
Volcano-sedimentary sequence(Santa Terezinha-type)
Granite-gneiss terranes
Greenstone belt
Paleoproterozoic
Archean
Mara Rosa
Niquelândia
Araxá
Piumhi
UnaíCristalina
Brasília
Goiânia
Paracatu
Vazante
Fig. 2
Patos de Minas
20 So
0 100 200 km
Fortalezade Minas
Três Marias FormationParaopeba Subgroup
Bambuí Group
Fig. 1. Location map and geotectonic setting of the Vazante Group, in the Brasılia Fold Belt (Dardenne, 2000).
L.V. Soares Monteiro et al. / Ore Geology Reviews 28 (2006) 201–234 203
Page 4
LAGAMAR
PARACATÚ
N46 35'Wo
VAZANTE
Morrodo Ouro
17 20'So
Canastra Group
Paracatu Formation(carbonaceous phyllitewith quartzite layers)
Serra do Landim Formation(green carbonate phyllite)
Vazante Group
Serra da Lapa Member(gray slate, quartzite,and dolomite lenses)
Serra do Velosinho Member(black carbonaceous slateand shale)
Morro do Calcário andSerra do Poço Verdeformations(stromatolitic bioherm,breccia facies, algal-laminateddolomite, gray to pinkish dolomitewith stromatolitic mats, and slate)
Serra do Garrote Formation(black carbonaceous shaleand gray slate)
Pb anomalies
0 8 16 km
Lapa Formation
Fagundes
Morro Agudo
Ambrósia
Vazante
18 00'So
Fig. 2. Geological map of the Vazante Group and location of the Vazante, Ambrosia, and Fagundes deposits (Cia. Mineira de Metais, Votorantim
Metais).
L.V. Soares Monteiro et al. / Ore Geology Reviews 28 (2006) 201–234204
Page 5
L.V. Soares Monteiro et al. / Ore Geology Reviews 28 (2006) 201–234 205
Despite the fact that a number of base–metal pro-
vinces have been studied in detail (Le Huray et al.,
1987; Sangster, 1990; Leach and Sangster, 1993) the
distinction of carbonate-hosted Zn–Pb deposit genetic
models can be rather difficult. Moreover, in the same
district the integrated local stress, regional scale ther-
mal regime, fluid flow and physicochemical condi-
tions, can provide contrasts in mineralizing fluid
characteristics and mineralization styles (syngenetic,
syn-diagenetic or epigenetic), which are used to ad-
dress the problems of carbonate-hosted ore genesis
and modeling. In the Vazante–Paracatu region, the
result is a puzzle of complex relationships among
non-sulfide and different sulfide ore bodies.
The composition of the mineral phases in the
Vazante, Fagundes and Ambrosia deposits, principally
the different generations of sphalerite, could reflect
the evolution of the hydrothermal system related to
late-diagenetic and epigenetic episodes of mineraliza-
tion. The present study was aimed at the identification
of processes responsible for the genesis of each spe-
cific type of mineralization, which can lead to com-
prehensive metallogenic and exploration models for
the Vazante–Paracatu Zn–Pb deposits.
2. Geological setting
The Vazante–Paracatu region is located in the east-
ern part of the Brasılia Fold Belt (Almeida, 1967),
which extends for more than 1000 km over a width of
300 km along the western margin of the Sao Francisco
Craton (Fig. 1). This fold belt represents an unstable
crustal block, whose final structural differentiation
resulted from the closure of a wide oceanic basin
during the Neoproterozoic Brasiliano Orogeny (~600
Ma; Pimentel et al., 2001). The Brasılia Fold Belt
displays sequences of rock thrusted to the east with
increasing deformation and metamorphism to the
west, reflecting the vergence of the Brasılia Fold
Belt with respect to the Sao Francisco Craton (Dard-
enne, 2000).
The Vazante Group (Dardenne et al., 1998), which
hosts the Zn deposits (Figs. 2 and 3), covers a 250 km
long, N–S-striking region in the southern segment of
the Brasılia Fold Belt. This group was affected by low
greenschist facies metamorphism and has a pervasive
cleavage (S1), related to regional folding, which is
overprinted by S2 and S3 cleavages, related to local
D1 isoclinal and D2 open folds, respectively (Mon-
teiro, 1997).
From base to top, the Vazante Group is divided
into: Santo Antonio do Bonito, Rocinha, Lagamar,
Serra do Garrote, Serra do Poco Verde, Morro do
Calcario and Lapa Formations. The basal Santo Anto-
nio do Bonito and Rocinha formations are composed
of metapelitic units with phosphate concentrations
(Dardenne et al., 1998; Dardenne and Schobbenhaus,
2001). The Lagamar Formation represents a metap-
samo-pelitic unit with basal metaconglomerates, do-
lomitic breccia, dark gray limestone and stromatolitic
bioherm with columnar stromatolites of the Conophy-
ton and Jacutophyton type (Moeri, 1972; Cloud and
Dardenne, 1973). The Serra do Garrote Formation
represents a sequence of pyrite-bearing carbonaceous
gray slate and quartzite layers (Madalosso and Valle,
1978).
The Serra do Poco Verde Formation is made of gray
to pink algal-laminated dolomite, gray to green slates,
sericite phyllite, dark gray dolomite with bird’s-eyes,
marls and pyrite-bearing carbonaceous shale. The
Morro do Calcario Formation is composed of stromat-
olitic bioherm facies, intraformational breccias, dolar-
enite, and subordinate carbonaceous shale. These two
formations correspond to the dominantly dolomitic
sequences (Figs. 3 and 4) that host the Zn–(Pb) depos-
its and can represent a continuously deposited dolo-
mitic sequence, according to Dardenne (2000). The
lithostratigraphic columns for this dolomitic sequence
in the regions of Paracatu (A) and Vazante (B) and its
subdivisions (Morro do Pinheiro and Pamplona mem-
bers) as proposed by Rigobello et al. (1988) and
Dardenne (2000) are shown in Fig. 4.
The dolomitic sequence is overlain by the Lapa
Formation, with black rhythmic carbonaceous slate
and phyllite (Serra do Velosinho Member) and ser-
icite–chlorite phyllite, carbonate-bearing metasilt-
stone, dolomite and quartzite lenses (Serra da Lapa
Member). The Canastra Group metasediments (1200
to 900 Ma; Pimentel et al., 2001), which comprise
chlorite-rich calc-phyllite of the Landim Formation
and carbonaceous phyllites and quartzites of the
Paracatu Formation, overthrusts the rocks of the
Vazante Group (Fig. 3), as consequence of the late
Brasiliano collisional event (~630 Ma; Dardenne,
2000).
Page 6
Morro Agudo,Fagundes and
Ambrósia Zn-(Pb)deposits
Vazante non-sulfideZn deposit
Phosphorite 3Lagamar
Phosphorite 2Rocinha
Phosphorite 1Coromandel
VAZ
AN
TE
GR
OU
PLapa
Morro doCalcário
Serra doPoçoVerde
Serra doGarrote
Lagamar
Rocinha
Sto.Antônio
do Bonito
UpperPamplona
MiddlePamplona
LowerPamplona
UpperMorro doPinheiro
Lower Morrodo Pinheiro
Sumidouro
Arrependido
Gray carbonate-rich slate,lenses of dolomite, blackcarbonaceous phyllite
Stromatolitic bioherm,facies of breccia anddolarenite
Gray and pink dolomite withstromatolitic mats
Gray and green slate,gray and pink dolomite
Dark gray dolomite withstromatolitic mats and bird's eyes
Light gray to pink dolomite withlenses of breccia and dolarenite
Gray slate
Stromatolitic bioherm
Dark gray limestoneDolomitic breccia
Conglomerate
Rhythmite
Dark gray pyritic andphosphatic slate
Rhytmites
Layers of quartzite, phosphorite,diamictite and slate
Serra da Lapa
S. Velosinho
Fig. 3. Schematic lithostratigraphic column (not to scale) of the Vazante Group (Dardenne et al., 1998; Dardenne, 2000).
L.V. Soares Monteiro et al. / Ore Geology Reviews 28 (2006) 201–234206
The ages of the Vazante Group and the Zn miner-
alizing episodes are controversial. Stromatolites of the
Vazante Group indicate relative age intervals of 1650
and 950 Ma (Conophyton Cylindricus Maslov; Moeri,
1972) and 1350 and 950 Ma (Conophyton metula
Kirichenko; Cloud and Dardenne, 1973), suggesting
a correlation with the 1200 to 900 Ma Paranoa Group
(Dardenne et al., 1976). The occurrence of diamictite
units at the base of the Vazante Group, similar to those
of the base of the Bambuı Group (900 to 600 Ma;
Thomaz Filho et al., 1998), also suggests correlation
between these groups (Dardenne, 2000).
A Rb–Sr whole rock isochron for shales from the
Vazante Group yielded an age of 600F50 Ma
(Amaral and Kawashita, 1967), which could represent
the last closing of the isotopic systems, during the
Brasiliano metamorphic event. 207Pb/206Pb analyses
of galena from Vazante and Morro Agudo deposits
yielded model ages based on Stacey and Kramers
(1975) ranging between 929 and 600 Ma (Amaral,
1968; Cassedane and Lasserre, 1969; Iyer et al., 1992,
1993; Freitas-Silva and Dardenne, 1997; Misi et al.,
1997; Cunha et al., 2001, 2003), which have been
considered as the time of mineralization (Iyer et al.,
Page 7
21
3
4
56
7
8
9
(1) Serra daLapa
(2) Serra doVelosinho
Ser
rad
oG
arro
teF
orm
atio
n
UpperPamplona
MiddlePamplona
LowerPamplona
UpperPamplona
1 - Slate, quartzite, andlenses of dolomite2 - Black carbonaceousphyllite
3 - Dolorudite and dolarenite
4 - Pyrite-rich black shale
5 - Stromatolitic bioherm
6 - Algal-laminated dolomite
8 - Dark gray dolomitewith bird’s eyes,light gray andpink dolomite
7 - Carbonate-rich slateand dolomite lenses
9 - Gray slate withquartzite lenses
3 - Dolorudite
4 - Dolarenite
5 - Stromatolitic bioherm
6 - Light gray algal-laminated dolomite withdolarenite lenses
7 - Gray and green slate,marls, gray and pinkdolomite with stromatoliticmats
8a - Fine dark gray dolomitewith birds eyes, marl, pyrite-bearing black carbonaceousslate
8b - Light gray to pinkinshalgal-laminated dolomite,dolarenite, lamelar breccia
VAZ
AN
TE
GR
OU
P
PARACATU
Ser
rad
oP
oço
Ver
de
Fo
rmat
ion
Lap
aF
orm
atio
n
LowerPamplona
Morro doPinheiro
UpperMorro doPinheiro
9 - .
(A)
9
8b
8a
7
54
3
6
VAZANTE(B)
LowerMorro doPinheiro 50
0m
500
m20
0m
400
m90
0m
Maximumthickness
Member Member
Mo
rro
do
Cal
cári
oF
orm
atio
n
Gray slate with quartzitelenses
Fig. 4. Correlations between the lithostratigraphic columns of the Vazante Group in the Vazante and Paracatu regions (after Oliveira, 1998;
Dardenne, 2000).
L.V. Soares Monteiro et al. / Ore Geology Reviews 28 (2006) 201–234 207
1992, 1993; Misi et al., 1997) or as the time of lead
separation. However, according to Cunha et al. (2003)
and Babinski et al. (2005), the Pb-isotopic ratios of
galena from the Vazante–Paracatu region characteris-
tically plot above of the evolution curve of Stacey and
Kramers (1975), indicating that the obtained ages lack
geologic significance.
Additional analyses on galena from the Morro
Agudo deposit resulted in Pb–Pb plumbotectonic
model ages of 1200 to 1000 Ma for early fine-
grained galena, which have been interpreted as the
time of lead separation or as the time of the syndia-
genetic mineralization, and of 600 Ma for epigenetic
coarse-grained galena, considered as the time of
epigenetic mobilization processes (Freitas-Silva and
Dardenne, 1997; Dardenne and Schobbenhaus,
2001).
Sm–Nd analyses carried out on metasediments
from the Vazante Group indicate a uniform distribu-
tion of TDM values between 2100 and 1700 Ma,
which, according to Pimentel et al. (2001), reflect
the overlapping of sources associated with the Para-
noa (TDM=2300 to 2000 Ma) and Bambuı groups
(TDM=1900 to 1400 Ma). This is compatible with
an intermediate stratigraphic position of the Vazante
Group, which could correspond to the top of the
Paranoa passive margin sequence (Pimentel et al.,
2001), or could alternatively represent the sedimenta-
tion in a rapidly subsiding zone forming a depression
in the Brasılia Fold Belt initial thrust fronts (Dard-
enne, 2000).
3. Vazante non-sulfide Zn deposit
The bulk of the Vazante non-sulfide Zn ore is
concentrated close to the contact of two units of the
Serra do Poco Verde Formation: the Upper Morro do
Pinheiro Member (footwall sequence) and the over-
lying Lower Pamplona Member (Figs. 4b and 5),
within the Vazante Shear Zone. Small metabasite
bodies occur tectonically imbricated with brecciated
metadolomites and willemitic ore bodies along the
shear zone (Monteiro, 1997). The Upper Morro do
Pinheiro Member includes gray metadolomites, py-
rite-bearing carbonaceous black shale, and marls
with textures indicating an inter- to subtidal flat
environment. The Lower Pamplona Member is
Page 8
NW SE
F-551-65 F-543-65 F-364-60
F-379-75
469.20 m
410.35 m
374.75 m
276.80 m
192.00 m
30 0 30 60 90 m
Gray dolomite with microbialmat and teepee structures
Sericite phyllite and dolomitic slate
Pink dolomite with ooids and pellets,intraformational breccia
Light gray dolomite and quartzsericite phyllite
Marl and argillaceous dolomite
Dark gray dolomite with bird's eyesand stromactatis
Pyrite-bearing carbonaceousblack slate
Marl with pyrite and graphite
Metabasic rock
Willemitic ore
Breccia zone
Llimit of the shear zone
Lower Pamplona Member
Upper Morro do Pinheiro Member
Serra do Poço Verde Formation
VAZANTE GROUP
Fig. 5. Cross-section of the Vazante ore zone showing the spatial relationship between host sequence, willemitic ore, and the Vazante shear zone.
L.V. Soares Monteiro et al. / Ore Geology Reviews 28 (2006) 201–234208
made of slate and sericite phyllite interbedded with
light gray to pink metadolomites, which display
features typical of an inter- to supratidal setting
with periods of subaerial exposure (Monteiro et al.,
1999).
The Vazante Shear Zone is approximately 12 km
long, with strike N508E and dip 608NW. It has been
interpreted as an inverse and transcurrent fault de-
veloped during a compressive phase, which was later
reactivated as a normal fault at the final stages of the
Brasiliano Orogeny (Pinho et al., 1990). The shear
zone is characterized by complex zones of irregular
anastomosing geometry that result from the intersec-
tion of C foliation planes and R, RV, P and T Riedel-
type shear fractures.
The metabasites exhibit sub-ophitic texture relicts
with igneous plagioclase, pyroxene and ilmenite par-
tially to totally recrystallized to chlorite, clinozoizite,
epidote, talc, sericite, quartz, rutile, leucoxene and
apatite in low greenschist facies metamorphism. In
the S–C mylonitic structures and brittle structures are
also present hydrothermal Fe-chlorite, hematite, tita-
nite, and dolomite (Monteiro et al., 1999).
3.1. Hydrothermal alteration
Within the Vazante Shear Zone, the hydrothermal
alteration is largely fracture controlled, producing a
complex zone of net veined and hydraulic breccias.
The metadolomites are also bleached and metaso-
Page 9
L.V. Soares Monteiro et al. / Ore Geology Reviews 28 (2006) 201–234 209
matically altered along the contact with the metaba-
site. The hydrothermalized metadolomite of the
Upper Morro do Pinheiro Member displays color
varying from dark gray to pink mainly related to
Fe-dolomite and siderite formation along the mylo-
nitic planes. The micro- and pseudospar textures of
the Pamplona dolostone are replaced by closely
packed anhedral saddle dolomite with undulatory
extinction, siderite and baroque dolomite, which
exhibit strong zoning that is evidenced by blue,
red and orange cathodoluminescence (CL) zones.
Usually, the baroque dolomite is brecciated.
Within the Pamplona metadolomites and slates,
silicification is associated with strongly brecciated
zones cut by hydrothermal veins. These veins dis-
play a crustiform texture related to progressive
infilling of open fractures by successive layers of
texturally and/or mineralogically different precipi-
tates, which include Fe-dolomite, siderite, jasper,
hematite and chlorite.
Pre-mineralization stage
Minerals
GalenaWillemiteQuartz
Hematite
MagnetiteFrankliniteZincite
SideriteBaroque dolomite
Chlorite
BariteApatiteSmithsoniteTalc
Sphalerite
Microspar to pseudospardolomite
Earlydiageneticassociation Euhedral pyrite
Fibrous dolomite
Quartz
Clay-minerals
Latediageneneticassociation
Pyrite (stylolites)
Epigeneticassociation
Spar dolomite
Saddle dolomite
Jasper
Cloudy saddle dolomite
Fig. 6. General paragenetic association of the sulfide and willemitic ore
Vazante Shear Zone development.
3.2. Vazante willemitic and sulfide ore bodies
The willemitic ore (Fig. 6), the main ore type in the
Vazante deposit, displays podiform morphology and is
tectonically imbricated with small sulfide ore bodies,
metabasites and brecciated metadolomites. This ore
type contains willemite (50% to 70%), dolomite (10%
to 30%), siderite (10% to 20%, quartz (10 to 15%),
hematite (5% to 10%), Zn-rich chlorite (5% to 10%),
barite (b5%), franklinite (b5%), zincite (b5%), be-
sides subordinate concentrations of magnetite and
apatite. The willemite is colloform or occurs as fine
to coarse fibrous-radiated crystals associated mainly
with quartz and baroque dolomite (Fig. 7A). The
brittle–ductile deformation of willemitic ore is respon-
sible for its granoblastic texture and mineral stretching
and is accompanied by the formation of hematite and
Zn-rich chlorite (Fig. 8A). Cataclastic breccia com-
prises willemitic fragments surrounded by cloudy
saddle dolomite with zoning characterized by red
Main mineralization stage Late mineralization stage
Brittle- ductilestructures
Brittle-ductile andbrittle structures
bodies in relation to brittle–ductile and brittle structures related to
Page 10
A
willemite
dolomite
quartz
DC
franklinitefranklinitesiderite
B
barite
sphalerite
sphalerite
sphalerite
willemite
willemite
quartz
quartz
quartz
galena
Fig. 7. (A) Willemitic ore includes willemite, quartz, dolomite, hematite, and zincite. Vazante deposit (width of field=12 cm); (B) replacement
of sphalerite by an assemblage made of willemite, quartz, dolomite, zincite, and barite along mylonitic foliation. Back-scattered electron images,
width of field=6 mm (Vazante deposit); (C) back-scattered electron images in two different contrasts showing franklinite associated to sideritic
and willemitic veins. The willemite is cut by sphalerite veinlets. Width of field, 3.75 mm (Vazante deposit); (D) sphalerite partially corroded,
separated from quartz by a galena film. Franklinite is usually associated with a reaction front. Back-scattered electron images, width of field, 0.6
mm (Vazante deposit).
L.V. Soares Monteiro et al. / Ore Geology Reviews 28 (2006) 201–234210
cathodoluminescence (CL) and non-luminescent
zones, and cut by barite, hematite, and chlorite. Late
veins truncate the breccias and are mainly made of
non-luminescent dolomite.
Sulfide-rich ore occur either as irregular bodies
elongated parallel to C shear planes, with a well-devel-
oped mylonitic fabric, or as late-vein infillings. They
are composed mainly of colorless sphalerite, with ga-
lena, hematite, quartz, and dolomite inclusions. Under
microscope, the sphalerite is brown, quite homoge-
neous, displays strong yellow CL and is strongly de-
formed and stretched along the mylonitic foliation.
The brittle–ductile shear zone development is of
major importance in mechanical mobilization, recrys-
tallization and for the replacement of the sulfides by
the willemitic assemblage (Figs. 6 and 7B). The
initial willemite crystallization in the sulfide bodies
occurs along the mylonitic foliation, as part of two
distinct associations: willemite+sphalerite+ franklini-
te+zincite (without quartz) and willemite+quartz+
dolomite+ franklinite (without sphalerite). Locally,
galena isolated the sphalerite crystals impeding its
total destruction from reaction with quartz (Fig.
7C). These assemblages suggest the formation of
willemite from sphalerite and quartz via reaction
(1), which indicates that fS2 and fO2 may have had
an important role in the stability of this assemblage:
ZnSþ SiO2 þ O2 ¼ ZnSiO4 þ 1=2S2: ð1Þ
The willemite displays strong green CL in all
associations (Fig. 8B). Brittle structures affected wil-
lemite crystals, resulting in cataclastic textures, which
are filled, in turn, by galena and sphalerite. Late
sphalerite veinlets cut all willemite generations
(Figs. 7D and 8B).
The relationship between willemite formation and
the development of microstructures in sulfide orebo-
Page 11
willemite hematite
dolomite
quartzwillemite
and hematite
sphalerite
willemite
sphalerite
quartz
pyrite
dolomite
dolomiteand quartz
sphalerite (III)and phyllosilicates
dolomite
sphalerite (IV)
sphalerite (III)
galena
pyrite
pyritegalena
sphalerite
galenag
sphalerite (I)
pyrite
sphalerite(I) and (II)
sphalerite (III)
galenag
quartz
sphalerite (III)sphalerite (I)
dolomite
quartz
A B
G H
D
E F
C
Fig. 8. (A) Willemitic ore composed of willemite, dolomite and hematite associated with brittle–ductile microstructures. Plane polarized light,
Vazante deposit; (B) willemite with green CL cut by mobilized sphalerite, with strong yellow CL, Vazante deposit; (C) photomicrograph showing
brecciated sphalerite (I) involved with sphalerite (II), and concentration of late sphalerite (III) along mylonitic planes. Plane-polarized light,
Ambrosia deposit; (D) sphalerite (I) cut by sphalerite (III) veinlets. Plane-polarized light, Ambrosia deposit; (E) colloform texture of sphalerite
(orange to brown) and pyrite, associatedwith later galena. Plane polarized light, Fagundes deposit; (F) colloform sphalerite (brown) associatedwith
later galena. Plane polarized light, Fagundes deposit; (G) Sphalerite (III), pyrite, dolomite and quartz associated with brittle–ductile micro-
structures. Plane polarized light, Fagundes deposit; (H) sphalerite (III) cut by yellow clear sphalerite (IV). Plane polarized light, Fagundes deposit.
Width of field is 1.4 mm in (A), (B) and (H) and 5.5 mm in (C)–(G).
L.V. Soares Monteiro et al. / Ore Geology Reviews 28 (2006) 201–234 211
Page 12
L.V. Soares Monteiro et al. / Ore Geology Reviews 28 (2006) 201–234212
dies, mainly associated with the mylonitic foliation,
suggests that the willemitic mineralization and defor-
mation are synchronous episodes inter-related to the
Vazante Shear Zone development.
The stability of the Vazante willemite assemblage,
in a similar way to willemite and zincite reported
from Sterling Hill and Franklin Furnace (Essene and
Peacor, 1987; Johnson et al., 1990), should be re-
stricted to high fO2/fS2 conditions (Monteiro et al.,
1999). According to Brugger et al. (2003), in the
presence of sulfur, willemite is predicted to form
instead of sphalerite under more oxidizing (at or
above the magnetite–hematite buffer) or alkaline
conditions, especially at temperatures exceeding
150 8C. High fO2/fS2 conditions could explain the
predominance of hematite and absence of pyrite (a
common mineral phase in the majority of base metal
deposits) at Vazante. Additionally, the formation of
early sphalerite, which is replaced by willemite, and
late sphalerite that cuts the willemite, could be relat-
ed to variations of the fO2/fS2 ratio during the fluid
evolution.
4. Ambrosia Zn deposit
Within the Ambrosia area, Zn mineralization is
controlled by a fault zone that strikes N308W and
dips 60 to 808SE and is cut across and displaced by
a N208E trending transverse fault system. To the SE,
the main N308W fault zone intersects the contact
between Lower Pamplona and Upper Morro do Pin-
heiro members (Fig. 4a). To the NW, this fault zone
juxtaposes Lower and Upper Pamplona members.
The host rock of the Ambrosia mineralization is a
brecciated dolomite, intimately associated with the
above fault zone, tectonically imbricated into black
shales and slates of the Lower Pamplona Member
(Fig. 9). Relicts of sedimentary and diagenetic tex-
tures of this dolomite include microbial lamination,
irregular fenestrae and bird’s-eyes. The diagenetic
sequence is represented by: (I) marine cementation,
characterized by micritic zones and non-luminescent
spar cementation associated to fenestrae; (II) reflux,
characterized by fine- to medium-grained euhedral
dolomite rhombs; (III) meteoric diagenesis, repre-
sented by dog tooth and drusy mosaic dolomite ce-
mentation; (IV) burial processes, responsible by
saddle dolomite formation, grain–grain dissolution
and stylolites.
The Upper Morro do Pinheiro Member, lying
below this fault zone, includes fine to medium strat-
ified dark gray dolomites with planar stromatolitic
structures, bird’s-eyes, and fenestrae. The Lower
Pamplona Member comprises rhythmic carbonaceous
shale interbedded with siltstone, sandstone, dolare-
nite, marl, and lenses of gray argillaceous dolomite.
Near the contact with the Upper Pamplona Member,
intraformational breccia layers with fragments of
dolomite, phosphorite, and quartz in a matrix of
dolomite, quartz, microcline, and plagioclase have
been identified. The flat-shaped phosphorite clasts
exhibit chalcedony and apatite crystallization on the
borders. Quartz clasts are either angular or rounded,
with evidence of deformation, such as undulatory
extinction, sub-grain formation, and a mantle–core
texture. The matrix quartz grains display rounded
detrital nucleus and euhedral-shaped authigenic crystal
overgrowths.
The Upper Pamplona Member essentially com-
prises reef dolomite with stromatolitic structures and
evaporitic layers. It has fine layers made of detrital
minerals, such as quartz and microcline, and authi-
genic phases, mainly quartz and euhedral pyrite, in a
dolomitic matrix associated with phosphatic material.
Foliation planes (S1) defined by clay mineral, ser-
icite, phlogopite, and chlorite orientation are observed
in all units and have been considered as the products
of regional deformation. This foliation is folded and
cut by a weak crenulation (S2). Microcrystalline
quartz, carbonates, pyrite, and subordinate sphalerite
fill faults and fractures.
4.1. Hydrothermal alteration
Within the fault zone, the lithotypes of Morro do
Pinheiro and Pamplona Members display brecciated
aspects, due to the interaction of different processes,
such as, recrystallization (I), silicification (II), baroque
dolomite and ankerite formation (III), concentration of
veining and faulting (IV). The recrystallization, char-
acterized by a uniform mosaic of medium-crystalline
equant dolomite crystals with straight intercrystalline
boundaries, represents the main process that affects
the dolomites of the Upper and Lower Pamplona
members. Close to, and within the mineralized zone,
Page 13
PAF - 78 (40 )PAF - 77 (60 )
o
o
PAF - 82
133.70 m
132.80 m
84.70 m
SW NE
0 10 20 30 40 m
VAZANTE GROUPMorro do Calcário FormationUpper Pamplona Member
Lower Pamplona Member
Fault zone
Stromatolitic bioherm
Gray microbial-laminated dolomite
Light gray brecciated dolomite
Pyrite-bearing black shale, slate,phosphatic dolomite, intraformational breccia
Breccia zone
Zn (Pb) ore-
Fig. 9. Cross-section of the Ambrosia ore zone showing the spatial relationship between the mineralization and high-angle fault zone.
L.V. Soares Monteiro et al. / Ore Geology Reviews 28 (2006) 201–234 213
and alongside the recrystallization, are complex vein
systems made of baroque dolomite, ankerite, and
quartz, which are mainly pre-date or are synchronous
with base–metal sulfide mineralization. In the foot-
wall zone, the brecciated aspect of the dolomites is
related to silicification. Networks of fractures filled
with dolomite and ankerite are also responsible for in
situ brecciation of the rock. This sequence of process
postdates early dolomitization and burial diagenetic
features indicating that the hydrothermal alteration is
mainly epigenetic.
4.2. Zinc mineralization
The Ambrosia Zn ore is associated with brecciat-
ed dolomite, tectonically imbricated with metasedi-
ments of the Lower Pamplona Member, within the
Ambrosia Fault Zone (Fig. 9). Iron-sulfides (Fig. 10),
Page 14
Pre-mineralization
stage
Mainmineralization
stage
Latermineralization
stageMineralsBrittle-ductile structures Brittle structures
Earlydiageneticassociation
Saddle dolomiteQuartzClay-minerals
Latediageneneticassociation Pyrite (stylolites)
Baroque dolomiteAnkeriteQuartzChalcedonyPyriteMarcasiteEpigenetic
association Sphalerite (I)Sphalerite (II)Sphalerite (III)GalenaChloriteTalcEuhedral dolomiteApatite
Micritic dolomiteSpar dolomiteEuhedral dolomiteEuhedral pyrite
Fig. 10. General paragenetic association of the Ambrosia sulfide ore.
L.V. Soares Monteiro et al. / Ore Geology Reviews 28 (2006) 201–234214
mainly marcasite and pyrite, are the most abundant
mineral phases near the mineralized zones. The sul-
fides occur in stylolites, in comb-veins, associated
with baroque dolomite and ankerite, and in concen-
tric nodules in dolomites, which were previously
modified by recrystallization, dolomitization and/or
silicification. Within the comb-veins, the Fe-sulfide
textures are rhythmic and coarsen inward, indicating
open-space filling (Fig. 11A). The association be-
tween Fe-sulfides and compaction features, mainly
stylolites, could indicate a burial diagenetic origin for
part of the pyrite.
The orebodies are composed of sphalerite, pyrite,
and lesser galena, all occurring in veins, veinlets and
as fractures fillings. Under the microscope, sphalerite
(I) displays dark brown–reddish color and evidence
of a primary compositional zoning. However, the
predominant granoblastic texture indicates different
recrystallization stages. The sphalerite grain borders
commonly show evidences of partial dissolution and
corrosion, and concentrations of a second fine-
grained and darker sphalerite generation (II). Fre-
quently, the sphalerite (I) and (II) are cut by vein-
bearing yellow and clearer sphalerite (III), associated
with galena (Fig. 8C, D).
Intense mylonitization within the mineralized
zones is responsible for the Fe-dolomite, dolomite,
quartz, pyrite and sphalerite (III) concentrations
along the S–C planes, limiting the more preserved
sphalerite (I) cores. All these features suggest that
significant tectonic transposition cannot be ruled out.
The pyrite associated with sphalerite (I) was affected
by ductile–brittle deformation, which is indicated by
fragmentation, corrosion, dissolution and replace-
ment by sphalerite, galena (Fig. 11B), talc and chlo-
rite. Late ankerite, quartz, euhedric dolomite, apatite
and mobilized sphalerite veins cut the mylonitized
zones (Fig. 10). The base–metal vein sulfides over-
print stylolites and tectonic fractures, suggesting an
epigenetic origin for the primary ore, which was
later mobilized due to fluid-assisted shear zone
transfer.
5. Fagundes Zn deposit
In the Fagundes area, Zn mineralization is hosted
by dolomites of the Upper Pamplona Member (Fig.
12), which is covered by the Serra do Velosinho and
the Serra da Lapa members of the Lapa Formation
Page 15
pyrite
dolomite
pyrite +marcasite
A
sphalerite
pyrite +marcasite
galena
pyrite
C
apatite
galena
sphalerite
pyrite
dolomite
B
galenasphalerite
pyrite
dolomite
D
Fig. 11. (A) Rhythmic textures involving pyrite, marcasite, and dolomite. Reflected light, Ambrosia deposit (width of field, 1.4 mm); (B) Back-
scattered electron images showing rounded pyrite grains, with evidence of dissolution, partially replaced by sphalerite and subordinate galena.
Width of field, 0.15 mm (Ambrosia deposit); (C) colloform texture of pyrite, associated with sphalerite and galena. Reflected light, Fagundes
deposit (width of field, 5.5 mm); (D) Back-scattered electron images showing cataclase of colloform pyrite, replaced by galena and subordinate
sphalerite. Width of field, 1.5 mm (Fagundes deposit).
L.V. Soares Monteiro et al. / Ore Geology Reviews 28 (2006) 201–234 215
(Fig. 4a). The basal Serra do Velosinho Member is
composed of rhythmic graphitic black shale inter-
bedded with argillaceous-carbonate layers, which con-
tain detrital quartz and microcline-rich sub-layers. The
Serra da Lapa Member is made of rhythmic calc-
silicate metapelite interbedded to sericite–chlorite
phyllite and metasiltstone with subordinate quartzite.
Close to the contact with the Upper Pamplona Mem-
ber, these lithotypes display evidence of mylonitiza-
tion, such as strong mineral stretching, ribbon texture
in quartz and carbonates, and extensional fractures
filled with quartz, sericite, phlogopite, chlorite, pyrite,
and ankerite.
The Upper Pamplona Member is represented in
the Fagundes area by a stromatolitic reef complex,
with back and fore-reef facies (Fig. 4a). The fore-
reef facies consists of algal-laminated dolomite,
dolorudite and dolarenite. The dolorudite is com-
posed of a dolarenitic matrix and angular or rounded
fragments of stromatolite dolomite, collophane,
chert, dolomicrite, and dolomicrosparite intraclasts.
The reef facies is composed of gray microbial-lam-
inated dolomite and columnar stromatolite, which
display concave lamination, characterized by dark
lamellae made of cryptocrystalline dolomite and
light lamellae with coarsely crystalline dolomite
and authigenic quartz grains. The back-reef facies
include recrystallized fine-grained gray dolomite
with planar to wavy mats and subordinate layers of
dolarenite and breccia.
The original textures of these lithotypes were
usually obliterated by neomorphism and silicifica-
tion associated with non-planar dolomite, preferen-
tially along the lamination and in the intercolumnar
spaces of the stromatolites. Saddle dolomite and
stylolites with pyrite, chert and clay minerals rep-
resent the burial diagenetic stage. The development
of the S1 foliation took place sub parallel to the
algal lamination, and is accentuated by chert sub-
stitutions along the lamination plans. Mylonitization
and development of S–C structures are also usually
recognized.
Page 16
W E
0 100 200 m
VAZANTE GROUP
Serra do Velosinho Member
Morro do Calcário Formation
Zn-(Pb) ore
Pyrite-bearing shale with meta-arenite layers
Dolorudite with stromatolitic bioherm fragments and laminated dolomite
Fine-gray dolomite with green slate layer;
Dolarenite and microcrystalline dolomite
Laminated dolomite
Fig. 12. Cross-section of the Fagundes ore zone (Cia. Mineira de Metais, Votorantim Metais).
L.V. Soares Monteiro et al. / Ore Geology Reviews 28 (2006) 201–234216
5.1. Hydrothermal alteration
Replacement and hydrothermal alteration process-
es related to the Upper Pamplona Member dolomites
have taken place close to or within the mineralized
zones. The burial saddle dolomite, which precedes the
base–metal sulfide mineralization, occurs as coarse
space-filling cement and corresponds to anhedral
spar dolomite with undulatory extinction. It shows
strong cathodoluminescense (CL) zoning character-
ized by strong red CL on the borders and cores of
the crystals. The intermediate zones display weak CL,
due to their Fe-rich composition, alternating with
yellow CL zones, with compositions that are more
calcitic.
Silicification is a common intense process of open-
space filling and involves, in some cases, total re-
placement of dolomites by chalcedony, as layered
Page 17
L.V. Soares Monteiro et al. / Ore Geology Reviews 28 (2006) 201–234 217
chert concretions with straight borders between adja-
cent nucleus and polygonal limits, and mosaic quartz.
In the strongly silicified zones, concentric nodules of
chalcedony also occur, associated with spar dolomite
and pyrite. The dolomite observed in the silicified
zones displays commonly fibrous or colloform tex-
ture, indicating rhythmic deposition and replacement
of the precursor chalcedony. The silicification is pos-
terior to the burial saddle-dolomite formation and can
represent a relatively late stage in the diagenetic his-
tory of the sequence. This process is linked to the
base–metal sulfide mineralization, but usually repre-
senting a pre-mineralization stage of the hydrothermal
alteration (Fig. 13).
Baroque dolomite crystallization is mainly related
to comb-vein infilling, which crosscut both the par-
tially preserved dolomites as well as the intensely
silicified ones. These carbonates and the quartz com-
monly display undulatory extinction due to the brittle–
ductile deformation. A late-zoned euhedral carbonate
generation with strong pleochroism is observed in the
core of the chalcedony nodules and veins. Impressive
fragmentation, related to brittle deformation, occurs in
MineralsPre-
mineralizationstage
DolomicriteEarlydiageneticassociation
Euhedral pyrite
Saddle dolomite
EpigeneticAssociation
Pyrite (stylolites)Chalcedony/quartzBaroque dolomite
Zoned euhedral dolomite
Colloform pyriteColloform sphalerite (I)Zoned sphalerite (II)
Mobilized sphalerite (III)Late sphalerite (IV)Galena
Galena
TalcChloriteApatitePhyllossilicates
Latediageneticto epigeneticassociation
Pseudospar to spardolomite
Fig. 13. General paragenetic associat
the strongly silicified dolomites, originating breccia
zones with chert, quartz, and dolomite fragments.
5.2. Zinc mineralization
5.2.1. Primary ore
The ore bodies are usually stratabound and struc-
turally and stratigraphically controlled. The Fagundes
mineralization is hosted by dolorudites, and dolomites
with chaotic stromatolite structures of back-reef facies
of the Upper Pamplona Member (Fig. 12), near the
Serra do Velosinho Member contact. In the better
preserved lithologies, pyrite represents the first gen-
eration of sulfides, deposited along stylolitic surfaces,
borders of chalcedony nodules in strongly silicified
zones, and in baroque dolomite veins. Within miner-
alized areas, the primary Zn ore is stratabound and
comprises mainly pyrite, sphalerite and late galena.
The stratabound ore type is represented mainly by
rhythmically banded, colloform, and zoned sulfides
(Fig. 11C). Pyrite is present as colloform or euhedral
crystals nuclei that are coated and overgrown by
concentric colloform sphalerite (I), which shows
Mainmineralization
stage
Latemineralization
stageBritle-ductilestructures
Britlestructures
ion of the Fagundes ore types.
Page 18
Table 1
Main attributes of the Vazante, Ambrosia, Fagundes and Morro Agudo Zn–(Pb) deposits
Deposit Host rocks Ore control Hydrothermal
alteration
Styles of
mineralization
Ore types Mineralogy Salinity (wt.%
equivalent NaCl)/
temperature (8C)
Sulfur source
Ambrosia Brecciated dolomite
(Upper Pamplona
Member)
High-angle fault zone
(N30W/80SW)
Replacement by
baroque dolomite
and ankerite,
silicification
Epigenetic Lode ore py, sp, gn, dol,
qtz, marc, phyll;
apatite
Salinity: 5–22 TH:
122–244(1)Hydrothermal source(2)
Fagundes Dolarenite, dolorudite,
dolarenitic breccia
(Upper Pamplona
Member)
Stratigraphic control;
brittle–ductile
fault zones
Strong silicification
and baroque
dolomite formation
Tardi-diagenetic/
epigenetic
Stratabound ore
(open space filling,
largely replacive),
brecciated ore
py, sp, gn, marc.,
dol, qtz, phyll,
chalcedony
Salinity: 5–15
TH: 120–265(1)Two sulfur sources:
thermochemical
reduction of sulfate
under closed system
conditions and
hydrothermal supply(2)
Vazante Brecciated pink
dolomite and slates
(Lower Pamplona
Member)
Shear zone
(N50/60NW).
Stratigraphic
control
Dolomitization,
silicification,
siderite,
ankerite, hematite,
chlorite formation(3,4)
Epigenetic Willemitic ore
(pods, lode, breccia)
and sulfide ore
(veins, pods)
will, hm, dol, sid,
ank, sp, gn, fk, zc,
qtz, chl barite,
apatite(3,4)
Salinity:3–23(1,5)
TH: 65–232(1,5)
T: 206–294
(stable isotope data)(3,4)
Thermochemical
reduction of seawater
sulfate or hydrothermal
source(3,4)
Morro
Agudo
Breccias, dolarenite
and dolorudites
(Upper Pamplona
Member)
Fault zone
(N10W/75SW);
stratigraphic
control(6,7)
Silicification posterior
to the main
mineralization
Syndiagenetic to
epigenetic
Stratiform ore
breccia
ore, veins(6)
gn, sp, py, cc, dol,
barite, qtz(6)Salinity: 0–23(6);
TH: 80–283(6)
T: 80–386(6)
(stable isotope data)
Two sulfur sources:
from thermochemical
reduction of evaporitic
sulfate and hydrothermal
supply(6,7,8)
Abbreviations: py=pyrite; sp=sphalerite; gn=galena; dol=dolomite; qtz=quartz; marc=marcasite; phyll=phyllossilicate; will =willemite; hm=hematite; sid=siderite; ank=ankerite; fk=franklinite;
zc=zincite; chl=chlorite; cc=calcite; TH: homogenization temperature.
(1) Bettencourt et al. (2001); (2) Monteiro and Bettencourt (2001); (3) Monteiro (1997); (4) Monteiro et al. (1999); (5) Dardenne and Freitas-Silva (1999); (6) Cunha et al., 2000; (7) Misi et al. (1999); (8)
Misi et al. (2000).
L.V.Soares
Monteiro
etal./Ore
GeologyReview
s28(2006)201–234
218
Page 19
L.V. Soares Monteiro et al. / Ore Geology Reviews 28 (2006) 201–234 219
color orange to dark-brown, and by dolomite. Sphal-
erite (II) occurs as medium- to coarse-zoned crystals
on the borders of baroque dolomite infilling. Under
transmitted light sphalerite (II) displays light brown
color in the core of the crystal (Fig. 8E). Red-orange
areas are predominant in intermediate parts of the
crystals, while the borders, in general, have darker
brown color. Galena shows predominantly infilling or
substitution textures (Figs. 8F and 11D), but also
occur in veins and veinlets associated to dolomite,
pyrite and subordinated sphalerite.
The sulfide textures of the stratabound ore indicate
mainly sulfide deposition in open spaces within the
dolomite host rocks, possibly related to fracturing and
dissolution during the mineralizing process. The pri-
mary mineralization postdates the burial saddle-dolo-
mite formation; however it is locally overprinted by
chemical compaction features, such as stylolites (Fig.
13). This could suggest a late-diagenetic to epigenetic
origin for the Fagundes stratabound mineralization.
Table 2
Representative microprobe analyses (wt.%) and calculated cation values f
Sulfide ore Willemiti
Will Frank Mag Hm Will
SiO2 27.16 0.05 0.03 0.02 27.28
Al2O3 0.00 0.61 0.01 0.03 0.00
TiO2 0.02 0.00 0.07
MgO 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.05
CaO 0.03 0.41 0.00 0.00 0.13
MnO 0.02 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.02
FeO 0.19 1.01 29.92 0.29
Cr2O3 0.03 0.00
CdO 0.08 0.00
Fe2O3 65.60 66.48 93.82
ZnO 74.00 32.24 0.02 5.41 72.59
Total 101.47 99.97 99.29 100.36
Catios assuming: 4 (O) for willemite, franklinite and magnetite; 6 (O) for
Si 0.99 0.00 0.00 0.00 1.00
Al 0.00 0.03 0.00 0.00 0.00
Mg 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
Ca 0.00 0.14 0.00 0.00 0.01
Mn 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
Fe2+ 0.01 0.27 1.00 0.01
Cr 0.00 0.00
Cd 0.00 0.00
Fe3+ 1.97 2.00 3.84
Zn 1.99 7.59 0.00 0.21 1.97
Fe2+ and Fe3+ were calculated assuming full site occupancy.
Abbreviations: Will=willemite; Frank=franklinite; Mag=magnetite; Hm=
5.2.2. Mobilized ore
Mobilization of the sulfides is closely related to
local ductile–brittle faults in the mineralized areas.
Interaction with later hydrothermal fluids results in
the partial obliteration of the originally zoned sulfide
textures, mainly in the proximity of fissures and bor-
ders of the crystals, and homogenization of the sphal-
erite color. Mobilized and deformed sphalerite (III)
usually exhibits a dark brown color, without evidence
of zoning.
Brecciated ore associated with brittle–ductile and
brittle processes contains sphalerite (I) and (II) frag-
ments in a fine-grained brown mobilized matrix of
sphalerite (III). In the more intensely deformed areas,
the sulfides associated with quartz and dolomite with
ribbon structure (Fig. 8G) are oriented parallel to the
mylonitic foliation. Late sphalerite (IV) displays a
clear yellow color, and is associated with galena
(Fig. 8H). The sphalerite (IV) veins are concordant
to mylonitic foliation plains, which cut the primary
or mineral phases from the Vazante deposit
c ore Cataclastic breccia
Will Frank Hm Will Hm
27.15 10.71 0.13 27.34 0.04
0.01 0.52 0.08 0.00 0.03
0.00 0.00 0.00
0.01 0.01 0.06 0.09 0.03
0.02 0.02 0.00 0.01 0.00
0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
0.29 7.23 0.10
0.13
0.00 0.00
54.93 99.22 99.78
73.17 27.48 0.66 74.36 0.10
100.65 100.93 100.15 101.88 100.12
hematite
1.00 0.39 0.00 1.00 0.00
0.00 0.02 0.00 0.00 0.00
0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
0.00 0.02 0.00 0.00 0.00
0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
0.01 0.22 0.00
0.00
0.00 0.00
1.49 3.97 3.99
1.99 0.73 0.03 2.00 0.00
hematite.
Page 20
L.V. Soares Monteiro et al. / Ore Geology Reviews 28 (2006) 201–234220
sphalerite (I) and (II) aggregates. In some deformed
domains, the sphalerite and pyrite evidence partial
dissolution, being substituted by phyllosilicates and
euhedral dolomite. Table 1 summarizes the main attri-
butes of the deposits of the Vazante–Paracatu region.
Table 3
Representative chlorite analyses (wt.%) from Vazante
Cataclastic breccia/willemitic ore Metabasite
SiO2 28.11 28.56 28.07 33.83 33.78
MgO 20.28 20.57 20.46 30.72 30.11
Al2O3 16.70 16.36 16.86 13.74 15.09
K2O 0.00 0.00 0.01 0.03 0.00
TiO2 0.69 0.02 0.19 0.00 0.00
FeO 3.00 2.97 2.63 7.91 8.10
Cr2O3 0.01 0.03 0.04 0.02 0.03
NiO 0.03 0.04 0.03 0.04 0.00
CaO 0.14 0.56 0.23 0.05 0.11
MnO 0.00 0.00 0.05 0.09 0.13
ZnO 19.68 18.99 19.1 0.16 0.41
Total 88.64 88.10 87.67 86.59 87.75
Cations assuming 28 (O)
Si 5.86 5.97 5.92 6.53 6.44
AlIV 2.14 2.03 2.08 1.47 1.56
AlVI 1.97 2.00 2.11 1.67 1.84
Ti 0.11 0.00 0.03 0.00 0.00
Cr 0.00 0.00 0.01 0.00 0.00
Fe3+ 0.03 0.00 0.05 0.11 0.16
Fe2+ 0.50 0.53 0.41 1.17 1.13
Mn 0.00 0.00 0.01 0.01 0.02
Mg 6.30 6.41 6.43 8.84 8.56
Ni 0.01 0.01 0.01 0.01 0.00
Zn 3.03 2.93 2.83 0.02 0.06
Ca 0.03 0.13 0.05 0.01 0.02
K 0.00 0.00 0.01 0.01 0.00
OH 16.00 16.00 16.00 16.00 16.00
Fe/Fe+Mg 0.08 0.08 0.07 0.13 0.13
Fe2+, Fe3+ and OH were calculated assuming full site occupancy
6. Mineral chemistry
Chemical compositions of willemite, franklinite,
hematite, dolomite, and chlorite were determined by
a CAMECA 50 electron probe microanalyser at the
Universidade de Brasılia. Sulfide compositions were
analyzed using a JEOL, JXA 8600 SuperProbe at the
Instituto de Geociencias, Universidade de Sao Paulo.
The wavelength dispersive technique was employed,
with accelerating voltages of 20 and 15 kV, and probe
currents of 20 and 30 nA, respectively. Estimated
minimum detection limits (mdl) for trace elements
in sulfides are: Cd, Cu, Mn (100 ppm); Ge, Ga, Ag
(120 ppm); Sb (270 ppm); Co (350 ppm); Ni (390
ppm); As (530 ppm); Pb and Se (575 ppm). Analyzed
elements that carried concentrations below these mdl’s
in N95% of samples are not presented. Mean concen-
trations were calculated only if N50% of the analyses
have values above mdl.
6.1. Vazante non-sulfide assemblage
Representative microprobe analyses from willemi-
tic ore are given in Table 2. The structural formulae of
willemite from different ore associations, including
sulfide ore bodies, ranges within a negligible range
[(Zn2+1.97–2.00Fe2+0.00–0.02Ca0.00–0.01)(Si0.99–1.00)O4]. This
purity can be responsible for the strong green CL
observed in willemite from Vazante (Fig. 8A), be-
cause impurities can inhibit the CL effects, according
to Johnson et al. (1990).
Magnetite and franklinite intergrowths can be
taken as indicating an inverse structure for the
Vazante franklinite (Sclar and Leonard, 1992;
Zheng, 1996), which displays the structural formula
(Zn2+0.73–0.95Fe2+0.22–0.03Ca
2+0.05–0.00)(Fe
3+1.49–1.97Al0.03–0.02
Si0.39–0.00)O4 (Table 2).
Hematite presents variable degrees of replacement
of Fe2+ by Zn2+. The Zn-rich hematite occurs as elon-
gated inclusions within the Vazante sphalerite. The
hematite associated with the willemitic ore, including
cataclastic breccias, displays the lowest amounts of Zn
compared to other hematite occurrences.
Chlorite from veins that cut willemite fragments in
cataclastic breccias is characterized by its unusual Zn
content (up to 19.7% ZnO), previously reported by
Monteiro (1997) [and Alain Blot, pers. comm., 1998].
According to the chlorite nomenclature of Bayliss
(1975), it is a zincian clinochlore. The hydrothermal
chlorite from Vazante metabasite (Table 3) is also
classified as clinochlore, but has lower Zn contents
(up to 0.5% ZnO).
The temperature of Vazante chlorite crystallization
was calculated using the method of Cathelineau and
Nieva (1985). Correction for AlIV-T dependence, as
proposed by Kranidiotis and MacLean (1987) and
Zang and Fyfe (1995), was not adopted due to lack
of correlation between AlIV contents and Fe/(Fe+Mg)
ratios in the Vazante chlorite. The estimated tempera-
.
Page 21
L.V. Soares Monteiro et al. / Ore Geology Reviews 28 (2006) 201–234 221
tures for chlorite from hydrothermalized metabasite
(175 to 190 8C) and from cataclastic breccias with
willemite fragments (230 to 245 8C) reflect conditionsrelated to the development of brittle and brittle–ductile
structures. These conditions are consistent with tem-
peratures calculated from stable isotopes by Monteiro
(1997) and Monteiro et al. (1999), which indicate a
temperature range between 250 and 295 8C for will-
emitic ore and 200 to 260 8C for hydrothermal min-
eral phases of veins and breccias within the shear
zone. The d18O of the fluid in equilibrium with chlo-
rite (+12x), at 250 8C, is similar to the estimated
oxygen isotopic composition of fluids responsible for
the willemitic ore (Monteiro, 1997; Monteiro et al.,
1999). This oxygen isotopic signature and the calcu-
lated yD value (�33.5x) could indicate an affinity
with either metamorphic or diagenetically modified
formational fluids.
6.2. Vazante, Fagundes and Ambrosia sulfide
mineralization
6.2.1. Sphalerite
The Vazante sphalerite is characterized by low Fe
(mean 0.09%) and high Cd contents (mean 8410 ppm)
and displays little compositional variation (Table 4).
However, different sphalerite generations in the
Fagundes and Ambrosia deposits show significant
chemical variations (Figs. 14 and 15), as indicated by
their Fe and total trace metal (P
metals=Cd+Ge+
Ag+Cu) contents.
In the Fagundes deposit, Cd-concentrations as high
as 7000 ppm are found in sphalerite types (I) and (II)
and relatively high amounts of Ge are observed in
colloform (I) (up to 1640 ppm), zoned (II) (up to
2200 ppm) and deformed (III) (up to 2390 ppm) sphal-
erite (Table 5). The late sphalerite (IV), however, dis-
plays characteristically lower Cd, Ge and Cu contents
in relation to earlier phases (Table 5).
Ambrosia epigenetic sphalerite (I) has higher Fe-
content (mean 0.78%) and lower average Cd-content
(257 ppm) than Fagundes andVazante sphalerite (Table
6), resulting in the highest Fe/P
metals ratio (Fig. 15).
Increases in Fe (up to 2.54%) and Cd (up to 4100 ppm)
are observed in mobilized sphalerite (II) and late sphal-
erite (III) from Ambrosia (Fig. 14; Table 6).
Sphalerite from the different deposits in the
Vazante–Paracatu district shows some compositional
similarities with sphalerite from other Zn–(Pb) depos-
its worldwide. High Cd-contents in sphalerite, similar
to those observed in Vazante and Fagundes, are
reported in MVT deposits (Table 4), veins in carbon-
ate rocks (mean 7260 ppm; Schwartz, 2000) and in
the low-temperature Cd-rich zinc deposit of Niujiao-
tang, China (Liu et al., 1999).
Previous investigations (e.g., Jolly and Heyl,
1968; Barbanson and Geldron, 1983; Liu et al.,
1999) found Ge to be concentrated in sphalerite
from low-temperature epigenetic deposits (e.g.,
MVT deposits and the Ruby Creek, St. Salvy, Niu-
jiaotang deposits), particularly those hosted in sedi-
mentary rocks. Additionally, low Fe, Cu, Mn and Ag
contents in sphalerite, similar to those observed in
the Vazante–Paracatu deposits, are also typical of
MVT deposits (Table 4).
However, available temperature data from fluid in-
clusion (Table 1) and stable isotope data for the depos-
its in Vazante–Paracatu district (Cunha et al., 2000;
Misi et al., 1999, 2000; Bettencourt et al., 2001; Mon-
teiro, 2002; Monteiro et al., 2003) indicate higher
temperatures (i.e., N250 8C) than those usually
reported for MVT deposits. Thus, similarities between
sphalerite composition from the studied deposits and
low-temperature deposits, including theMVT deposits,
could be better explained by a similar source of brines
related to sedimentary sequences. According to Bern-
stein (1985) and Viets et al. (1992), brines leaching
sedimentary sequences would most likely remove as
much loosely bound metal (Fe, Zn, Cd and Ge, etc.)
from clastic or organic-bearing material. Additionally,
the sphalerite composition could indicate lowP
Sredactivities in the mineralizing fluids, which could favor
formation of Cd-rich sphalerite (Schwartz, 2000) and
incorporation of Ge in the sphalerite (Bernstein, 1985).
6.2.2. Galena
Galena from the three studied deposits has rela-
tively elevated Zn contents (Tables 7–9). The Ag
concentration in galena of the three deposits is similar
to that of some MVT deposits (Illinois–Kentucky and
Silesia), but Cd-content in galena is higher than that
described for MVT deposits, showing similarity to the
metamorphic deposit of Cobar, Australia (Table 7).
The main characteristic of the galena in the three
deposits, however, is the uncommon abundance of Ga
(up to 4650 ppm in the Fagundes deposit) and Ge (up
Page 22
Table 4
Average sphalerite composition (Fe in wt.% and trace-elements in ppm) from different Pb–Zn deposits
Deposits/district Fe Cd Mn Ga Ge Ag Cu Co Ni
Ambrosia(1) 0.78 1190 300 120
Fagundes(1) 0.46 3350 540 210 300
Vazante(2) 0.09 8410 130 120 240
Morro Agudo(3) 0.64 7700 825 10 20 72 10
Mississippi Valley-type
Upper Mississippi Valley(4) 1.41 1678 49 95 102 21 76 15 42
Illinois–Kentucky(4) 2.90 6900 170 290
Kentucky–Tennesseee(5) 0.28 13,344 98 269 2
Northern Arkansas(6) 0.14 6342 21 120 31 321 6
Tri-State(6) 0.23 6583 23 130 85 273 6
Viburnum Trend(6)
Main stage 0.79 9310 33 41 141 328 490 191 50
Cubic galena stage 0.27 5333 19 79 86 2.8 242 73 8
West Fork Mine(7)
Red sphalerite 1.96 6700 330 11
Yellow sphalerite 1.47 3200 32 48 97 64
Central Missouri(6) 0.10 5395 22 122 46 1.2 247 1.2 6
Central Tennessee(8) 4000 230 400 8 100 100
East Tennessee(8) 0.36 4185 220 60 36
Pine Point(9) 527 1.5
Silesia(10) 1.85 4616 15 163 6
Fankou(11) 5.49 1900 310 100 210
Berg Aukas(12) 0.37 1542 494 25 149 90 1014 17
Abenab(12) 0.68 2149 631 56 226 140 1200 38
IRISH
Silvermines(13) 0.19 1700 900
SEDEX
Red Dog (Alaska)(14) 2.87 3250 84 34
Texas Gulf(15) 2050 145 135 825 61
Base–metal vein type deposits
West Shropshire(16) 3.80 5200 2500
Metamorphised SEDEX deposits
Aguilar(17) 9.09 1000 22,900 300
Dugald River(18) 8.58 894 53
Metamorphic Pb–Zn–Cu deposits
Cobar (Australia)(19) 8.10 851 633
Other types
Niujiaotang (China)(20) 1.36 13,800 1825 2900 22
(1) This paper; (2) Monteiro (1997); (3) Bez (1980); Dresch (1987); (4) Hall and Heyl (1968); (5) Jolly and Heyl (1968); (6) Viets et al. (1992);
(7) Mavrogenes et al. (1992); (8) Lenker (1962); Maher and Fagan (1970); (9) Kyle (1980); (10) Haranczyk (1979); (11) Song (1984); (12)
Emslie and Beukest (1981); (13) Zakrzewski (1989); (14) Edgerton (1997); (15) Farkas (1973); (16) Pattrick et al. (1993); (17) Gemmel et al.
(1992); (18) Xu (1998); (19) Brill (1989); (20) Liu et al. (1999).
L.V. Soares Monteiro et al. / Ore Geology Reviews 28 (2006) 201–234222
to 8470 ppm in the Ambrosia deposit), which exceed
the contents observed in sphalerite (Tables 8 and 9).
These represent the main trace elements in galena
from the Fagundes and Ambrosia deposits (Fig. 16),
and are unusual because, according to Moller (1987),
the bulk of Ga and Ge present in the mineralizing
Page 23
0.00
0.20
0.40
0.60
0.80
1.00
0.00 0.20 0.40 0.60 0.80 1.00
Fe/(Fe + ∑metals)
∑m
etal
s/(F
e +
∑m
etal
s)
(I)
(II)
(III)
(I)(II) orange zones
(II) light brown zones
(II) brown zones
(III)
(IV)
Ambrósia (II)
Ambrósia (I)
Fagundes (I)
Fagundes(II) and (III)
Fagundes(IV)
Increasing Fe2+Vazante
Ambrósia (III)
Vazante Ambrósia Fagundes
Fig. 14. Fe content vs. total trace metal (Ge+Cd+Cu+Ag) content (P
metals) in sphalerite from Vazante, Ambrosia, and Fagundes deposits.
Cd
Fe (Ag + Ge + Cu)
Vazante
Fagundes
Ambrósia
(I)(II)
(III)
(I)
(II) orange zones
(II) light brown zones
(II) brown zones(III)
(IV)
Vazante
Ambrósia
Fagundes
Fig. 15. Cd–Fe–(Ge+Ag+Cu) atomic ratios for sphalerite from Vazante, Ambrosia and Fagundes deposits.
L.V. Soares Monteiro et al. / Ore Geology Reviews 28 (2006) 201–234 223
Page 24
Table 5
Compositional range and average composition (Fe in wt.%, trace-elements in ppm) of different sphalerite varieties from Fagundes deposit
Fagundes Sphalerite (I) Sphalerite (II) Sphalerite (III) Sphalerite (IV)
All sphalerite
types n =75
Colloform
n =08
Orange zones
n =08
Light brown
zones n =04
Brown zones
n =16
Mobilized/deformed
sphalerite n =29
Late veinlets,
Clearer yellow
n =10
Low High Mean Low High Mean Low High Mean Low High Mean Low High Mean Low High Mean Low High Mean
Fe 0.12 0.84 0.46 0.33 0.54 0.42 0.36 0.80 0.52 0.20 0.40 0.31 0.12 0.72 0.47 0.14 0.78 0.45 0.20 0.84 0.56
Cd 1530 7510 3354 3380 7170 5333 2150 3420 2654 3140 4580 3850 2490 7510 3791 1760 4960 2764 1530 4240 3148
Ge b120 2390 540 b120 1640 672 350 2200 790 b120 400 187 b120 1560 599 b120 2390 552 b120 180 *
Cu b100 2650 300 b100 490 175 400 2650 1616 b100 280 * b100 820 280 b100 550 * b100 260 *
Pb b575 2180 * b575 1950 751 b575 2180 868 b575 b575 b575 b575
Ag b120 930 210 b120 930 366 b120 550 138 b120 220 * b120 630 178 b120 910 256 b120 710 *
Mn b100 530 * b100 60 * b100 530 305 b100 b100 110 * b100 120 * b100
*=Percentage of analyses above the minimum detection limit b50%.
L.V. Soares Monteiro et al. / Ore Geology Reviews 28 (2006) 201–234224
fluid is normally captured by the sphalerite during
crystallization. Exceptions have nevertheless been
reported, such as galena from Apex Ga–Ge Mine,
SW Utah, which has the highest Ga content (mean
1100 ppm) relative to the other sulfides from this
deposit (Mahin, 1990).
Evidence of correlation among Ga, Zn, Cu, and Ag
was observed in Vazante and Ambrosia galena, sug-
gesting that finely disseminated Ga-bearing mineral
phases, such as carnevallite [Cu (Ga,Zn,Fe)S2] or
gallite (CuGaS2), may be present as mineral inclu-
sions in galena, or that coupled substitutions may be
responsible for incorporation of Ga, Zn, Cu and Ag. A
correlation between Ge, Cu, and Ag, which might
suggest the presence of the more common Ge-bearing
Table 6
Compositional range and average composition (Fe in wt.%, trace-elemen
Ambrosia deposit
Vazante Ambrosia
All sphalerite
types n =50
All sphalerite
types n =38
Sphalerite (I)
Brown n =11
Low High Mean Low High Mean Low Hig
Fe 0.00 0.93 0.09 0.21 2.54 0.762 0.21 0.4
Cd b100 10390 8411 b100 4100 1181 b100 440
Ge b120 1030 132 b120 1380 319 b120
Cu b100 2870 241 b100 360 * b100 240
Pb b575 b575 1740 * b575 174
Ag b120 570 * b120 830 * b120 470
Mn b100 b100 150 * b100 150
*=Proportion of analyses above the minimum detection limits b50%.
minerals (e.g., germanite and renierite) was not pres-
ent in any of the three deposits.
6.2.3. Pyrite
Pyrite occurs only in Ambrosia and Fagundes
deposits. In Vazante, pyrite is absent in the willemitic
ore and in the sulfide ore bodies, due to high fO2/fS2conditions of ore deposition (Monteiro, 1997). In Am-
brosia and Fagundes, pyrite contains high Pb and Zn
contents (Table 10), which could be due to submicro-
scopic inclusions of galena and sphalerite. The main
differences in comparison with similar deposits, how-
ever, are the presence of Ga in pyrite (up to 520 ppm in
Ambrosia and 610 ppm in Fagundes) and Ge in Am-
brosia pyrite (up to 4630 ppm).
ts in ppm) of Vazante and from different sphalerite varieties from
Sphalerite (II)
Mobilized/deformed
sphalerite n =11
Sphalerite (III) Late veinlets,
clearer yellow n =16
h Mean Low High Mean Low High Mean
8 0.35 0.35 0.99 0.70 0.54 2.54 1.57
257 720 1770 1225 190 4100 1785
b120 1380 312 b120 1110 330
* b100 160 * b100 360 116
0 * b575 b575
* b120 830 * b120 490 150
* b100 b100 150 *
Page 25
Table 7
Trace-element average contents (in ppm) of galena from different Pb–Zn deposits
Deposits/district Zn As Ga Ge Cd Sb Ag Cu Bi Ni
Ambrosia(1) 1610 3340 7010 420 140
Fagundes(1) 740 3470 4970 420 170
Vazante(2) 3920 120 380 710 230 240
Morro Agudo(3) 10 71 41
Mississippi Valley-type deposits
Tri-State(4) 49 11.2 9.5 52
Missouri SE(5) 340 27 171 85 59 50
Wisconsin–Illinois(6) 7.5 283 15.7 12 1
Illinois–Kentucky (6) 234 15 813 149 105 139
Silesia(7) 609 20 213 173 37 10
Fankou(8) 500 50 1210 1640
Berg Aukas(9) 65,366 220 521
Abenab(9) 22,446 181 320
IRISH type deposits
Silvermines(10) 800 500 400
SEDEX deposits
New Brunswick(11) 3400 850 4100
Metamorphic Pb–Zn–Cu deposit
Cobar(12) 453 491
Other types
Niujiaotang(13) 1770 1.2 1.72 3233 4025
(1) This paper; (2) Monteiro (1997); (3) Bez (1980); Dresch (1987); (4) Hagni (1983); (5) Hall and Heyl (1968); Bhatia and Hagni (1980); (6)
Hall and Heyl (1968); (7) Haranczyk (1979); (8) Song (1984); (9) Emslie and Beukest (1981); (10) Zakrzewski (1989); (11) Boorman (1968);
(12) Brill (1989); (13) Liu et al. (1999).
L.V. Soares Monteiro et al. / Ore Geology Reviews 28 (2006) 201–234 225
6.3. Primary sulfide mineralization processes
In spite of the overlapping deformation observed in
the Fagundes deposit, primary sulfide textures in the
Table 8
Variations in the trace element contents (in ppm) of galena from Fagunde
Fagundes
All types n =29 Galena (I) Open-space
filling, replacements n =12
Low High Mean Low High Mean
Fe b100 520 * b100
Cd b100 860 402 b100 700 400
Ag b120 810 183 b120 810 240
Cu b100 210 * b100 210 *
Zn b100 6790 769 b100 1080 196
Ge 3920 6430 4971 3920 4860 4402
Ga 2740 4650 3454 2940 4650 3576
*=Proportion of analyses above the minimum detection limits b50%.
stratabound sulfide ore deposits are still preserved,
including marked compositional zoning in sphalerite.
In Ambrosia, these textures are rare, and in Vazante
the different sphalerite generations, which were affect-
s
Galena (II) Veins, veinlets
in mobilized ore n =08
Galena (III)
Late galena n =09
Low High Mean Low High Mean
b100 520 * b100 160 *
270 860 441 b100 640 371
b120 810 165 b120 390 123
b100 130 * b100 190 *
b100 2180 475 b100 6790 1794
4000 6430 5288 5010 5250 5130
3110 3650 3358 2740 3750 3418
Page 26
Table 9
Variations in the trace element contents (in ppm) of galena from the Vazante and the Ambrosia deposits
Ambrosia Vazante
Galena All types
n =15
Galena (I) Open-space filling,
veins n =09
Galena (II)
Late galena n =06
Galena All types
n =09
Low High Mean Low High Mean Low High Mean Low High Mean
Fe b100 190 * b100 b100 190 * b100 870 214
Cd 110 660 416 110 620 364 180 660 488 b100 2280 853
Ag b120 720 140 b120 b120 720 300 b120 760 167
Cu b100 280 * b100 280 * b100 b100 740 296
Zn b100 6090 1605 b100 3870 590 b100 6090 3026 b100 3400 1622
Ge 4410 8470 7005 4410 8470 6993 7050 7090 7055 b120 960 382
Ga 3000 3810 3343 3000 3810 3391 3040 3700 3276 b120 400 *
*=Proportion of analyses above the minimum detection limit b50%.
L.V. Soares Monteiro et al. / Ore Geology Reviews 28 (2006) 201–234226
ed by the ductile–brittle and brittle deformations, are
quite homogeneous; evidence of primary zoning pat-
terns is conspicuously absent.
In general, Fagundes sphalerite crystals belonging
to a single generation of ore deposition display color-
banded growth zones, which can be correlated to
oscillatory variations in the content of the minor ele-
ments (Emslie and Beukest, 1981; Hagni, 1983; Viets
et al., 1992). Light-brown zones in the crystal cores
display lower Fe, Ge and Cu contents and higher Cd
concentration than orange zones in intermediate parts
of the crystals (Fig. 17; Table 5). Brown zones, mainly
on the crystal borders, may exhibit increase in the Ag
and Cd concentrations.
The usual distribution of minor and trace-elements
in sphalerite from MVT deposits (e.g., the Tri-State
district, USA; Hagni, 1983; Viets et al., 1992) is
Table 10
Variations in the trace element contents (in ppm) of pyrite from Fagundes
Fagundes
All types
n =34
Pyrite (I) Colloform,
open-space filling n =19
Low High Mean Low High Mean
Cu b100 430 130 b100 430 157
Pb b575 35,480 4812 b575 35,480 6931
Zn b100 8590 973 b100 2130 266
Cd b100 b100 150 *
Ag b120 620 152 b120 620 172
As b530 3590 * b530 3590 *
Mn b100 5710 652 b100 5710 1058
Ga b120 610 * b120 190 *
Ge b120 360 * b120 360 *
*=Proportion of analyses above the minimum detection limit b50%.
characterized by higher concentrations of compatible
elements in the crystal core and highest concentration
of incompatible elements, such as Ge, Ga and Ag, in
the more external crystal zones (Hagni, 1983). This
pattern is associated with enrichment of incompatible
elements in the residual mineralizing fluid during
crystal formation. However, Fe concentration, which
is relatively more compatible, increases markedly in
the outer crystal zones, reflecting introduction of Fe-
rich fluid pulses in the Tri-State deposits (Hagni,
1983; Viets et al., 1992).
The observed patterns in Fagundes sphalerite could
reflect that Fe and Cd readily substitute for Zn in the
sphalerite lattice during initial crystallization. Howev-
er, the increase in Fe content in intermediate parts of
the crystals may reflect introduction of Fe-rich fluids.
The incorporation of Ge and Cu in intermediate parts
Pyrite (II) Brecciated,
mobilized pyrite n =3
Pyrite (III) Late pyrite
n =12
Low High Mean Low High Mean
b100 b100 290 111
b575 2480 827 b575 13,390 2453
210 2900 1767 b100 8590 1870
b100 b100
b120 200 * b120 480 133
b530 b530
b100 180 117 b100 520 143
b120 140 * b120 610 133
b120 b120
Page 27
Ga Ge
Zn + Cd + Ag
Vazante
FagundesAmbrósia
Fig. 16. Ga–Ge–(Zn+Cd+Ag) atomic ratios for galena from
Vazante, Ambrosia and Fagundes deposits.
100
1000
10000
Lightbrown
Brown
pp
m
Orange
Rim RimCoreOrange
Cd
Ge
Fe
Ag
Cu
Lightbrown
Fig. 17. Trace-element variations in Fagundes zoned sphalerite.
L.V. Soares Monteiro et al. / Ore Geology Reviews 28 (2006) 201–234 227
of the crystal could have consumed a large part of
these elements from the fluid, resulting in their de-
crease on the crystal borders. The final Cd increase
could suggest hydrothermal fluid pulses with varia-
tions in Zn/Cd ratio, reflecting changes in the fluid
source or degree of mixing of hydrothermal fluids.
Colloform pyrite also displays trace element distri-
bution variations, expressed as higher Mn contents in
the core of the structures, an increase of Pb and As in
marginal areas and by oscillations in the Ag and Cu
contents in intermediate parts.
6.4. Deformation, mobilization and related sulfide
mineralization
The Vazante sphalerite textures indicate that ductile
and brittle deformations were quite intense, resulting
in recrystallization, homogenization and mobilization
processes, which were accompanied by the willemitic
mineralization. In the Fagundes and Ambrosia depos-
its, the observed features reflect several intermediate
stages of mobilization, which could be related to
interaction of pre-existing sulfide phases with later
hydrothermal fluids.
Changes in sphalerite chemical composition were
observed in relicts of primary sphalerite from
Fagundes and Ambrosia, which display evidence of
corrosion and partial replacement on the crystal rims.
Decrease of Cu, Ag and Ge concentrations is recorded
along the borders of these relicts. Minor fragments,
with evidence of large fluid interaction, also display
low contents of these elements, even in the crystal
cores. Sphalerite (IV) from Fagundes, which precipi-
tated directly from the later hydrothermal fluid, also
exhibits a decrease of Cu and Ge concentrations rel-
ative to those of the primary phase (Table 5). This
could indicate low concentration of these elements in
the overprinting fluid.
Mobilized sphalerite (II) and late sphalerite (III)
from Ambrosia are significantly richer in Fe and Cd
(Table 6) relative to primary sphalerite (I). In spite of
the similarity in the Fe/P
metals ratios of the late
sphalerite phases from Fagundes and Ambrosia (Fig.
14), the observed sphalerite compositions could re-
flect variations in the concentrations of Fe and Cd in
the overprinting fluids or significant differences in the
temperature, Eh, fS2 or pH in the fluid system, which
may be responsible for the incorporation of Cd and Fe
in mobilized and late Ambrosia sphalerite.
Zn is enriched in galena affected by processes
related to the deformation, mobilization, and in late
galena (Tables 8 and 9). Due to deformation, pyrite is
commonly brecciated or shows evidence of dissolu-
tion. In the Fagundes deposit, there is an increase of
Zn and decrease of Mn contents in mobilized and late
pyrite (Table 10). The Ambrosia late pyrite exhibits an
increase in Pb (Table 11).
6.5. Zn/Cd ratio in sphalerite
Sphalerite Zn/Cd ratio values, (Zn/Cd)sph, for the
studied deposits vary from 64 to 98 (Vazante), 89 to
439 (Fagundes), and 157 to 8269 (Ambrosia). Such
Page 28
Table 11
Variations in the trace element contents (in ppm) of pyrite from Ambrosia
Ambrosia
All types n =28 Pyrite (I) Open-space filling n =17 Pyrite (II) Late pyrite n =12
Low High Mean Low High Mean Low High Mean
Cu b100 300 * b100 300 * b100 120 *
Pb b575 11,720 891 b575 2350 * b575 11,720 1943
Zn b100 2160 334 b100 2160 343 b100 950 320
Cd b100 500 * b100 500 * b100 160 *
Ag b120 1160 140 b120 1160 162 b120 390 *
As b530 5860 * b530 5850 * b530 670 *
Mn b100 800 * b100 800 * b100 300 *
Ga b120 520 * b120 390 * b120 520 129
Ge b120 4630 298 b 120 3046 506 b 120 260 *
*=Proportion of analyses above the minimum detection limit b50%.
Table 12
Zn/Cd ratios in sphalerite from Zn–(Pb) deposits
Mineral (Zn/Cd)sph
Range Average
Fagundes(1)
Colloform sphalerite (I) 96–244 140
Zoned sphalerite (II) 89–305 207
Orange zones 192–305 252
Yellow zones 146–213 178
Brown zones 89–269 192
Mobilized sphalerite (III) 134–384 265
Late sphalerite (IV) 154–439 226
All types 89–439 225
Ambrosia(1)
Sphalerite (I) 1515–8269 3398
Mobilized sphalerite (II) 372–911 615
Late sphalerite (III) 157–3498 1536
All types 157–8269 1510
Vazante(2) 64–98 78
Morro Agudo(3) 68–121 83
Magmatic–hydrothermal deposits(4) 104–214
Sediment-hosted and carbonate-hosted
Pb–Zn deposits (MVT, SEDEX) (4,5,6)
252–330
Volcanogenic deposits(4,5,6) 417–531
Metamorphised/remobilized deposits(6,7) 273–1310
Base–metal vein-type deposit(8) 69–380
Others types (Niujiaotang, China)(9) 31–75
(1) This paper; (2) Monteiro (1997); (3) Bez (1980); (4) Song
(1984); (5) Jonasson and Sangster (1978); (6) Brill (1989); (7) Xu
(1998); (8) Pattrick et al. (1993); (9) Liu et al. (1999).
L.V. Soares Monteiro et al. / Ore Geology Reviews 28 (2006) 201–234228
broad variation in (Zn/Cd)sph has not been previously
reported from the same district (Jonasson and Sang-
ster, 1978; Song, 1984; Brill, 1989; Xu, 1998). In
comparison with available data from other Pb–Zn
deposits (Table 12), the mean Fagundes (Zn/Cd)sph(255) is similar to those observed in carbonate- and
sediment-hosted Pb–Zn deposits, including the meta-
morphosed ones (Song, 1984).
The lowest (Zn/Cd)sph observed in Fagundes–in
colloform (I) (96 to 244) and zoned (II) sphalerite
(89 to 305)–are similar to those of the Vazante (64 to
98) and Morro Agudo sphalerite (Table 12). Mobi-
lized (III) and late (IV) sphalerite from Fagundes
display (Zn/Cd)sph higher than the early sphalerite
phases (Table 12).
Low (Zn/Cd)sph from Vazante and Fagundes
could reflect the regional role of mineralizing fluids
with similar low Zn/Cd ratios and, possibly, with
low contents of reduced sulfur (P
Sred), which
according to Schwartz (2000), shift the total distri-
bution coefficient Kt(ZnS, Cd) to higher values, and
hence favor formation of Cd-rich sphalerite. These
conditions could have major importance for the low
sulfidizing capacity of the Vazante willemitic ore,
but also imply a key role of an additional sulfur
supply for the genesis of the sulfide-rich deposits in
the district.
The mean (Zn/Cd)sph (1510) of Ambrosia epige-
netic sphalerite is the largest described in the litera-
ture. Brill (1989) and Xu (1998) mention Zn/Cd
ratios up to 1300 in the Cu–Pb–Zn Cobar and Zn–
Pb–Ag Dugald River deposits (both Australia),
which are genetically linked to hydrothermal replace-
ment related to metamorphism. Available petrograph-
ic and geochemical evidences indicate that epigenetic
mineralization related to fluid-assisted mobilization
Page 29
L.V. Soares Monteiro et al. / Ore Geology Reviews 28 (2006) 201–234 229
process might have been more intense in Ambrosia
than in Fagundes, which could be related to late
expulsion of hydrothermal fluids during the Brasi-
liano compressive events.
6.6. Geothermometry
The formation temperature of sphalerite–galena
cogenetic pairs from the Vazante deposit, estimated
by Monteiro (1997), based on Cd distribution (Gele-
tii et al., 1979; Bortnikov et al., 1995), range from
317 8C (sulfides related to brittle–ductile structures) to
110 8C (sulfides related to brittle structures). Stable
isotopic geothermometers indicate temperatures of
257 to 330 8C for sulfide bodies (sphalerite–galena),
254 to 294 8C for willemitic ore (willemite–quartz,
hematite–quartz) and 206 to 260 8C for hydrothermal
mineral phases (siderite–quartz) of veins and breccias
(Monteiro, 1997; Monteiro et al., 1999). The lack of
reversals and the agreement of temperatures obtained
by O- and S-isotope- and mineral chemistry
geothermometer were utilized as an indication of
chemical and isotopic equilibrium. Minimum tem-
peratures of the mineralization estimated from fluid
inclusions in willemite (up to 180 8C) and sphalerite
(up to 230 8C) are lower than those indicated by stableisotopic systematic and mineral chemistry (Dardenne
and Freitas-Silva, 1999; Bettencourt et al., 2001;
Monteiro, 2002).
Temperatures calculated from cadmium sphaler-
ite–galena geothermometers from Fagundes and
Ambrosia samples are unreasonably high, ranging
from 573 8C (sphalerite II) to 706 8C (sphalerite IV)
in the Fagundes deposit and between 629 8C (sphal-
erite I) and 802 8C (sphalerite III) in the Ambrosia
deposit. These results are in disagreement with the
fluid inclusion data, which range from 120 to 265
8C (Monteiro, 2002), implying disequilibrium be-
tween coexisting galena and sphalerite with respect
to Cd partition. This could reflect, particularly in the
Fagundes deposit where colloform and zoned tex-
tures are preserved, that equilibrium was not
attained during mineral deposition due to the rapid
crystallization and to diffusion rates slower than
crystal growth rates. Additionally, the lack of equi-
librium is also consistent with textural observations
indicative of incomplete reaction and mobilization
process, similar to those reported by Brill (1989)
and Wagner and Boyce (2001) for base–metal
mineralizations overprinted by hydrothermal–meta-
morphic fluids.
7. Discussion
7.1. Timing of Zn mineralizations in the Vazante–
Paracatu region
The occurrence of different styles of mineralization
in the Vazante–Paracatu region, in a similar way to
those reported for carbonate-hosted deposits of the
Irish Midlands and of the McArthur River district,
could be related to local stress regimes, which repre-
sent a major mineralization style and ore control. In
this case, the compressional regimes favor the epige-
netic end-member styles of mineralizations (Le Huray
et al., 1987).
Despite the intrinsic difficulties concerning the
timing of carbonate-hosted mineralizations, the iden-
tification of the relationships among different miner-
alization styles in the same deposit, could allow the
recognition of the different mineralization episodes in
the district.
Syndiagenetic mineralization stages, represented
by early sulfide cementation of unconsolidated allo-
chemical grains, progressive replacement of diagenet-
ically modified coated grains and relationships
between sulfides and convolute or compactation struc-
tures (Dardenne, 1979; Hitzman, 1997), have been
recognized only in the Morro Agudo deposit. Collo-
form sulfides and coarse-grained zoned sphalerite
associated with pyrite, galena and baroque dolomite
represent a minor late mineralization stage at Morro
Agudo (Dardenne, 1979; Hitzman, 1997), and the
main stage of the Fagundes deposit. This later stage,
related to wall rock dissolution and sulfide infilling,
probably occurs late during the burial history of the
sedimentary sequence.
The Morro Agudo and Fagundes deposits share
some characteristics, besides the late-diagenetic sul-
fide textures, such as the stratigraphic positioning
related to back-reef facies overlaid by reduced carbo-
naceous pyrite-bearing shales, temperature (100 to
N250 8C), low to moderate salinity of mineralizing
fluids and wide variation of sulfur isotopic composi-
tions (d34S=�8x to +40x; Misi et al., 1999; Cunha
Page 30
L.V. Soares Monteiro et al. / Ore Geology Reviews 28 (2006) 201–234230
et al., 2000; Monteiro, 2002; Monteiro et al., 2003).
These characteristics could indicate similarity to Irish-
type deposits (Hitzman, 1995, Hitzman and Beaty,
1996), suggesting a syn- to late-diagenetic replace-
ment origin for these deposits.
The emplacement of epigenetic–hydrothermal
mineralizations and the occurrence of mobilization
of ore phases related to migration of late hydrothermal
fluids during the late Brasiliano collisional event
(~630 Ma; Dardenne, 2000) are also ubiquitous in
the Vazante–Paracatu Zn–(Pb) district.
The Ambrosia deposit represents an example of
epigenetic mineralization, whose characteristics
could reflect the mineralization fluid evolution during
the host sequence deformational history, related to the
continuous transition between burial diagenesis and
low greenschist facies metamorphism. The Vazante
non-sulfide Zn deposit represents also a syntectonic
mineralization episode, synchronous and inter-related
to the Vazante Shear Zone development, which was
subsequent to the low greenschist facies metamor-
phism of the Vazante Group.
7.2. Sulfide-rich carbonate-hosted Zn–(Pb) deposits:
fluid mixing evidences
Colloform and zoned sphalerite textures and the
strong silicification observed in Fagundes deposit
might imply in rapid fluid cooling and ore deposition,
which could be explained by fluid mixing processes.
Oscillatory variations in minor and trace-elements of
the Fagundes zoned sphalerite could also suggest
hydrothermal fluid pulses with variations in Zn/Cd
ratio, reflecting changes in the fluid source or degree
of mixing of hydrothermal fluids. Additionally, the
relationship between minor and trace-elements in
sphalerite and the paragenetic evolution of Fagundes
and Ambrosia deposits could also reflect progressive
fluid mixing.
According to Monteiro (2002), chemical variations
in sphalerite may be correlated with d34S values of
sphalerite from these deposits. The Fagundes early
sphalerite (I) is characterized by the highest d34Svalues (+36.3x), low average Fe content (0.42%)
and low (Zn/Cd)sph (140). The decrease in d34S values
(+14.8x) in late sphalerite (IV) is accompanied by
slight increase in mean Fe content (0.56%) and (Zn/
Cd)sph (226), whereas sphalerite associated with epi-
genetic mineralization of Ambrosia is 34S-depleted
(d34S=+12.2x to �5.4x), Fe-rich (up to 1.57%)
and has the highest (Zn/Cd)sph (1510). These relation-
ships are systematic and might suggest that mixing
processes involving two distinct fluid bearing sulfur
sources may be important for the genesis of the sul-
fide-rich deposits of the district. Fluid mixing is also
supported by fluid inclusion studies in Fagundes and
Ambrosia deposits (Monteiro, 2002; Monteiro et al.,
2003). These studies permitted the characterization of
a high-temperature (N250 8C) and moderate salinity
(~15 wt.% NaCl equiv.) fluid, mainly in sphalerite
from early mineralization stages of the Fagundes de-
posit, and a moderate-temperature (140 to 190 8C) andhigh salinity (N23 wt.% NaCl equiv.) fluid, which is
associated mainly with the late mineralization stage of
Fagundes and Ambrosia. Thus, progressive mixing
between hot metal-bearing fluid with low contents
of reduced sulfur (P
Sred) and moderate temperature,
highly saline basinal fluids could be suggested, in a
similar way to that reported for the Morro Agudo
deposit (Hitzman, 1997; Misi et al., 1999; Cunha et
al., 2000).
The predominance of isotopically light sulfur in
epigenetic stages of mineralization, mainly in Am-
brosia deposit, may result from expulsion of moder-
ate temperature, highly saline basinal fluids from the
Vazante basin, related with Brasiliano compressive
events. Alternatively, reduced shales that cover the
host dolostones in Fagundes, Ambrosia and Morro
Agudo deposits might be mobilized by descending
fluids, representing a potential sulfur source. This
could enhance the importance of shale units for
localization of sulfide deposits in the district.
7.3. Vazante non-sulfide Zn deposit
The Vazante sphalerite, which occurs in subordinat-
ed ore-bodies imbricated with the predominant will-
emitic ore, displays chemical homogeneity and also
shows a narrow range of d34S values between
+11.8x and +14.4x (Monteiro, 1997; Monteiro et
al., 1999). This is a distinct sulfur isotopic signature in
relation to sulfides from the other deposits in the dis-
trict, such as Ambrosia (d34S=�5.4x to +12.2x) and
Fagundes (d34S=+14.8x to +36.3x), which display
a remarkable wide sulfur isotopic variation and a com-
plex isotopic distribution related to the textural and
Page 31
L.V. Soares Monteiro et al. / Ore Geology Reviews 28 (2006) 201–234 231
paragenetic evolution of each deposit (Monteiro, 2002;
Monteiro et al., 2003). This could imply that the high-
temperature metal-bearing fluid with low Zn/Cd ratios
could represent a minor reduced sulfur reservoir. Pro-
gressive consumption of sulfur from this fluid would
yield early sphalerite precipitation followed by willem-
ite deposition, explaining the paragenetic sequence
observed at Vazante and in others hypogene non-sul-
fide Zn deposits, such as Berg Aukas, as previously
proposed by Hitzman et al. (2003).
Furthermore, the colloform willemite also sug-
gests rapid mineral precipitation, which could be
induced by mixing between the hot metal-bearing
and meteoric fluids, as indicated by stable isotope
(Monteiro, 1997; Monteiro et al., 1999) and fluid
inclusion studies (Monteiro, 2002; Monteiro et al.,
2003). This could be an important factor for the
establishment of high fO2/fS2 conditions, which are
necessary for the willemite stability (Monteiro, 1997;
Brugger et al., 2003).
8. Conclusions
The carbonate-hosted Zn–(Pb) deposits of the
Vazante–Paracatu district present different mineraliza-
tion styles, which may be attributed to the overprint-
ing of syndiagenetic and epigenetic–hydrothermal
processes, related to the long-term hydrothermal sys-
tem evolution associated to diagenesis and deforma-
tion of the Vazante Group, during the Brasiliano
Orogeny.
These characteristics may reflect common miner-
alizing processes, involving the regional migration of
high temperature metal-bearing brine with low Zn/
Cd ratios and, possibly, with low contents of reduced
sulfur (P
Sred). High Cd- and Ge- and low Fe-, Cu-,
Mn- and Ag-contents, which characterize the late-
diagenetic Fagundes sphalerite, suggest that the
source of this metal-bearing fluid could be, in part,
derived from the underlying basin fill, which com-
prise dolomitic units, clastic sediments and organic
matter-rich pelitic sequences. This could indicate
similarity of this brine with deeply circulating oxi-
dized basinal brines, which have been considered
important in the formation of Irish-type deposits.
According to Cooke et al. (2000), they are the
preferred metal carrier and are more likely to pro-
duce large tonnage Zn–Pb deposits at moderate tem-
peratures (~200 8C).Systematic relationships among sphalerite compo-
sition, S-isotopic composition and paragenetic evo-
lution of the Fagundes and Ambrosia deposits
suggest that progressive fluid mixing processes in-
volving oxidized metal-bearing fluid and sulfur-rich,
saline hydrothermal fluids were important for the
genesis of the sulfide-rich deposits in the district.
The predominance of the highly saline brines in
later epigenetic mineralization episodes, such as in
Ambrosia deposit, might be related to episodic mi-
gration of hydrothermal fluids mainly derived from
reduced shale sequences during the Brasiliano com-
pressive events.
The Vazante non-sulfide Zn deposit results from the
overall mixture between oxidized sulfur-deficient
metal-bearing fluid and meteoric fluids channeled to
the Vazante Shear Zone, which enable the high fO2/S2conditions responsible for the stability of the Vazante
willemitic assemblage and the intense fissural hydro-
thermal alteration, mostly accompanied by hydraulic
breccia and veins infilling by siderite, dolomite, Fe-
dolomite, hematite and jasper. These high fO2/S2 con-
ditions would also be favored by the lack of reduced
sequences above the Vazante deposit, which could
represent a limiting factor for H2S supply.
Acknowledgments
This paper is part of a Doctorate thesis of the first
author. We are grateful to Votorantim Metais for
continuous support and hospitality at the mine and
permission to publish. We are greatly indebted to D.F.
Sangster, S.S. Iyer, Nigel J. Cook, and an anonymous
referee for their reviews of the manuscript, which
significantly improved this paper. Special thanks are
due to the Microprobe laboratories in the Institute de
Geociencias of the Universidade de Sao Paulo and in
the Universidade de Brasılia. The financial support
was provided by Fundacao de Amparo a Pesquisa do
Estado de Sao Paulo, Brazil (Research Grant 96/
3941-3 and Doctorate Scholarship 98/0412-5),
which we acknowledge with appreciation. This
study is a contribution to the IGCP 450—Proterozoic
Sediment-hosted Base Metal Deposits of Western
Gondwana.
Page 32
L.V. Soares Monteiro et al. / Ore Geology Reviews 28 (2006) 201–234232
References
de Almeida, F.F.M., 1967. Origem e evolucao da plataforma brasi-
leira. Boletim-Departamento Nacional da Producao Mineral 243
(36 pp.).
Amaral, G., 1968. Geologia e depositos de minerio na regiao de
Vazante, Estado de Minas Gerais. Unpublished Doctorate thesis,
Escola Politecnica Universidade de Sao Paulo, Brasil, 133 pp.
Amaral, G., Kawashita, K., 1967. Determinacao da idade do Grupo
Bambuı pelo metodo Rb/Sr. Congresso Brasileiro de Geologia,
21, Anais. Sociedade Brasileira de Geologia, 214–217.
Babinski, M., Monteiro, L.V.S., Fetter, A.H., Bettencourt, J.S.,
Oliveira, T.F., 2005. Isotope geochemistry of the mafic dikes
from the Vazante Nonsulfide Zinc Deposit, Brazil. Journal of
South American Earth Sciences 18, 293–304.
Barbanson, L., Geldron, A., 1983. Distribution du germanium, de
l’argent et du cadmium entre les schistes et les mineralisations
stratiformes et filoniennes a blende-siderite de la region de
Saint-Salvy (Tarn). Chronique de la Recherche Miniere 51
(470), 33–42.
Bayliss, P., 1975. Nomenclature of the trioctahedral chlorites. Ca-
nadian Mineralogist 13, 178–180.
Bernstein, L.R., 1985. Germanium geochemistry and mineralogy.
Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta 49, 2409–2422.
Bettencourt, J.S., Monteiro, L.V.S., Bello, R.S., Oliveira, T.F.,
Juliani, C., 2001. Metalogenese do zinco e do chumbo na regiao
de Vazante–Paracatu, Minas Gerais. In: Pinto, C.P., Martins-
Neto, M.A. (Eds.), Bacia do Sao Francisco, Geologia e Recursos
Naturais. SBG-MG, Belo Horizonte, pp. 159–196.
Bez, L., 1980. Evolucao mineralogica e geoquımica do deposito de
zinco e chumbo de Morro Agudo, Paracatu, MG. Congresso
Brasileiro de Geologia, 31, Anais. Sociedade Brasileira de
Geologia, Balneario de Camburiu 3, 1402–1416.
Bhatia, D.M.S., Hagni, R.D., 1980. Laser probe determinations of
trace-element concentrations in sulfide minerals from the Mag-
mont Mine, Viburnum Trend, Southeast Missouri. Transactions
of the American Institute of Mining, Metallurgical, and Petro-
leum Engineers 268, 1847–1855.
Boorman, R.S., 1968. Silver in some New Brunswick galenas. New
Brunswick Production Council Report Note, vol. 11. 11 pp.
Bortnikov, N.S., Dobrovol’skaya, M.G., Genkin, A.D., 1995. Sphal-
erite–galena geothermometers: distribution of cadmium, manga-
nese, and the fractionation of sulfur isotope. Economic Geology
90, 155–180.
Brill, B.A., 1989. Trace-element contents and partitioning of ele-
ments in ore minerals from the CSA Cu–Pb–Zn deposit, Aus-
tralia. Canadian Mineralogist 27, 263–274.
Brugger, J., McPhail, D.C., Wallace, M., Waters, J., 2003. Forma-
tion of willemite in hydrothermal environments. Economic Ge-
ology 98, 819–836.
Cassedane, J., Lasserre, M., 1969. Etude geologique et analyse
isotopique, par la methode au plomb, de quelques galenes du
Bresil. Bulletin du Bureau de Recherches Geologiques et Mini-
eres (Section 2: Geologie des Gites Mineraux) 1, 71–83.
Cathelineau, M., Nieva, D., 1985. A chlorite solid solution
geothermometer: the Los Azufres (Mexico) geothermal system.
Contributions to Mineralogy and Petrology 91, 235–244.
Cloud, P.E., Dardenne, M.A., 1973. Proterozoic age of the Bambuı
Groupe in Brazil. Geological Society of America Bulletin 84,
1673–1676.
Cooke, D.R., Bull, S.W., Large, R.R., Mcgoldrick, P.J., 2000. The
importance of oxidized brines for the formation of Australian
Proterozoic stratiform sediment-hosted Pb–Zn (Sedex) deposits.
Economic Geology 95, 1–18.
Cunha, I.A., Coelho, C.E.S., Misi, A., 2000. Fluid inclusion study
of the Morro Agudo Pb–Zn deposit, Minas Gerais, Brazil.
Revista Brasileira de Geociencias 30, 318–321.
Cunha, I.A., Misi, A., Babinski, M., 2001. Lead isotope signatures
of galenas from Morro Agudo Pb–Zn deposit, Minas Gerais,
Brazil. In: Misi, A., Teixeira, J.B.G. (Eds.), Proterozoic Base
Metal Deposits of Africa and South America. Proceedings of the
First IGCP 450 Field Workshop. CNPq/UNESCO/IUGS, Belo
Horizonte and Paracatu (MG), Brazil, pp. 45–47.
Cunha, I.A., Babinski, M., Misi, A., 2003. Pb isotopic constraints
on the mineralization from the Vazante Group, Minas Gerais,
Brazil. South American Symposium on Isotope Geology, 4,
Salvador, Short Papers, pp. 727–730.
Dardenne M.A., 1979. Les mineralisations plomb-zinc du Groupe
Bambui et leur contexte geologique. Doctorate thesis, Universite
Paris VI, France. 275 pp.
Dardenne, M.A., 2000. The Brasılia fold belt. In: Cordani, U.G.,
Milani, E.J., Thomaz-Filho, A., Campos, D.A. (Eds.), Tectonic
Evolution of South America. 31st International Geological Con-
gress, Rio de Janeiro, pp. 231–263.
Dardenne M.A., Freitas-Silva F.H., 1999. Pb–Zn ore deposits of
Bambui and Vazante Groups, in the Sao Francisco Craton and
Brasılia Fold Belt, Brazil. In: Silva M. da G. da, Misi, A. (Eds.),
Base metal deposits of Brazil. Ministerio de Minas e Energia/
Companhia de Pesquisa de Recursos Minerais Minerais/Depar-
tamento Nacional de Producao Mineral, pp. 75–83.
Dardenne, M.A., Schobbenhaus, C.S., 2001. Metalogenese do Bra-
sil. Editora Universidade de Brasılia/CNPq, Brasılia. 392 pp.
Dardenne, M.A., Faria, A., Andrade, G.F., 1976. Occurrence de
stromatolithes collumnaires dans le Groupe Bambuı (Goias,
Bresil). Anais da Academia Brasileira de Ciencias 48, 555–566.
Dardenne, M.A., Freitas-Silva, F.H., Souza, J.C.F. de, Campos,
J.E.G., 1998. Evolucao tectono-sedimentar do Grupo Vazante
no contexto da Faixa de Dobramentos Brasılia. Congresso
Brasileiro de Geologia, 40, Anais, Sociedade Brasileira de
Geologia, Belo Horizonte, Resumos, 26.
Dresch, R.A.C., 1987. Aspectos geoquımicos da Jazida de Morro
Agudo, Paracatu, MG. Congresso Brasileiro de Geoquımica., 1,
Porto Alegre, Proceedings, vol. 1, pp. 5–27.
Edgerton, D., 1997. Reconstruction of the Red Dog Zn–Pb–Zn–Ba
orebody, Alaska: implications for the vent environment during
the mineralizing event. Canadian Journal of Earth Sciences 34,
1581–1602.
Emslie, D.P., Beukest, G.J., 1981. Minor- and trace-element distri-
bution in sphalerite and galena from the Otavi Mountainland,
South West Africa. Annals of the Geological Survey, Republic
of South Africa 15 (2), 11–28.
Essene, E.J., Peacor, D.R., 1987. Petedunnite (CaZnSi2O6), a new
clinopyroxene from Franklin, New Jersey, and phase equilibria
for zincian pyroxenes. American Mineralogist 72, 157–166.
Page 33
L.V. Soares Monteiro et al. / Ore Geology Reviews 28 (2006) 201–234 233
Farkas, A., 1973. A trace element study of the Texas Gulf ore body,
Timmins, Ontario. Unpublished MSc thesis, University of
Alberta, Edmonton, AB, Canada. 149 pp.
Freitas-Silva, F.H., Dardenne, M.A., 1997. Pb/Pb isotopic patterns
of galenas from Morro do Ouro (Paracatu Formation), Morro
Agudo/Vazante (Vazante Formation) and Bambuı Group depos-
its. South American Symposium on Isotope Geology, Extended
Abstracts, pp. 118–120.
Geletii, V.F., Chernisher, L.V., Pastushkova, T.M., 1979. Distribu-
tion of cadmium and manganese between galena and sphalerite.
Geologiia Rudnykh Mestorozhdenii 21, 66–75.
Gemmel, J.B., Zantop, H., Meinert, L.D., 1992. Genesis of the
Aguilar Zinc–Lead–Silver Deposit, Argentina: contact metaso-
matic vs. sedimentary exhalative. Economic Geology 87,
2085–2112.
Hagni, R.D., 1983. Minor elements in Mississippi Valley-Type ore
deposits. In: Shanks, W.C. (Ed.), Cameron volume on uncon-
ventional mineral deposits. American Institute of Mining, Met-
allurgical and Petroleum Engineers, Society of Mining
Engineers, New York, pp. 71–88.
Hall, W.E., Heyl, A.V., 1968. Distribution of minor elements in ore
and host rock, Illinois–Kentucky fluorine district and upper
Mississippi Valley zinc–lead district. Economic Geology 63,
655–670.
Haranczyk, C., 1979. Development of the Variscan mineral para-
genesis in Poland. Freiberger Forschungshefte, Reihe C: Geo-
wissenschaften, Mineralogie-Geochemie 354, 7–17.
Hitzman, M.W., 1995. Mineralization in the Irish Zn–Pb–(Ba–Ag)
orefield. In: Anderson, K., Ashton, J., Earls, G., Hitzman, M.,
Tear, S. (Eds.), Irish Carbonate-hosted Zn–Pb Deposits, Society
of Economic Geologists Guidebook Series, vol. 21, pp. 25–61.
Hitzman, M.W., 1997. Sediment hosted Zn–Pb and Au deposits in
the Proterozoic Paracatu–Vazante Fold Belt, Minas Gerais, Bra-
zil. Abstracts with Programs-Geological Society of America 29,
A408.
Hitzman, M.W., 2001. Zinc oxide and zinc silicate deposits—a new
look. Abstracts with Programs-Geological Society of America
33, A336.
Hitzman, M.W., Beaty, D.W., 1996. The Irish Zn–Pb–(Ba)
orefield. In: Sangster, D.F. (Ed.), Carbonate-hosted Lead–zinc
Deposits, Society of Economic Geologists Special Publication,
vol. 4, pp. 112–143.
Hitzman, M.W., Thorman, C.H., Romagna, G., Oliveira, T.F., Dard-
enne, M.A., Drew, L.J., 1995. The Morro Agudo Zn–Pb deposit,
Minas Gerais, Brazil: a Proterozoic Irish-type carbonate hosted
sedex replacement deposit. Abstracts with Programs-Geological
Society of America 27, A408.
Hitzman, M.W., Reynolds, N.A., Sangster, D.F., Allen, C.R., Car-
man, C.E., 2003. Classification, genesis, and exploration guides
for nonsulfides zinc deposits. Economic Geology 98, 685–714.
Iyer, S.S., Hoefs, J., Krouse, H.R., 1992. Sulfur and lead isotope
geochemistry of galenas from Bambuı Group, Minas Gerais,
Brazil: implications on ore genesis. Economic Geology 87,
437–443.
Iyer, S.S., Krouse, H.P., Babinski, M., 1993. Isotope investigations
on carbonate rocks hosted lead–zinc deposits from Bambuı
Group, Minas Gerais, Brazil: implications for ore genesis and
prospect evaluation. Simposio do Craton do Sao Francisco, 2,
Anais, Salvador, pp. 338–339.
Johnson, C.A., Rye, D.M., Skinner, B.J., 1990. Petrology and stable
isotope geochemistry of the metamorphosed zinc–iron–manga-
nese deposit at Sterling Hill, New Jersey. Economic Geology
85, 1133–1161.
Jolly, J.L., Heyl, A.V., 1968. Mercury and other trace-elements in
sphalerite and wall-rocks from central Kentucky, Tennessee, and
Appalachian zinc districts. United States Geological Survey
Bulletin 1252-F, 1–29.
Jonasson, I.R., Sangster, D.F., 1978. Zn:Cd ratios for sphalerites
separated from some Canadian sulfide ore samples. Paper-Geo-
logical Survey of Canada 78-1B, 195–201.
Kranidiotis, P., MacLean, W.H., 1987. Systematics of chlorite al-
teration at the Phelps Dodge massive sulfide deposit, Matagami,
Quebec. Economic Geology 8, 1888–1911.
Kyle, J.R., 1980. Controls of lead–zinc mineralization, Pine Point
district, Northwest Territories, Canada. Mining Engineering 32,
1617–1626.
Leach, D.L., Sangster, D.F., 1993. Mississipi Valley-type lead–zinc
deposits. In: Kirkhan, R.V., Sinclair, W.D., Thorpe, R.I., Duke,
J.M. (Eds.), Mineral Deposit Modeling, Geological Association
of Canada Special Paper, vol. 40, pp. 289–314.
Le Huray, A.P., Caulfield, J.B.D., Rye, D.M., Dixon, P.R., 1987.
Basement controls on sediment-hosted Zn–Pb deposits: a Pb
isotope study of Carboniferous mineralization in Central Ireland.
Economic Geology 82, 1695–1709.
Lenker, E.S., 1962. A trace element study of selected sulfide
minerals from the Eastern United States. Unpublished PhD
thesis, Pennsylvania State University, University Park, United
States. 160 pp.
Liu, T., Lin, Y., Chen, G., 1999. Geochemical characteristics of the
independent cadmium deposit, Niujiaotang, Duyun, Guizhou.
Chinese Science Bulletin 44, 61–63.
Madalosso, A., Valle, C.R.O., 1978. Consideracoes sobre a estrati-
grafia e sedimentologia do Grupo Bambuı na Regiao de Para-
catu-Morro Agudo (MG). Congresso Brasileiro de Geologia, 30,
Anais, Sociedade Brasileira de Geologia, vol. 2, pp. 622–631.
Maher, S.W., Fagan, J.M., 1970. Trace element content of some ore
deposits in the southeastern states. Information CircularTennes-
see Department of Conservation, Division of Geology, Nash-
ville, TN, United States. 16 pp.
Mahin, R., 1990. The mineralogy and geochemistry of the Apex
gallium–germanium Mine, Southwestern Utah, MSc thesis, Uni-
versity of Utah. 102 pp.
Mavrogenes, J.A., Hagni, R.D., Dingess, P.R., 1992. Mineralogy,
paragenesis, and mineral zoning of the West Fork mine, Vi-
burnum Trend, Southeast Missouri. Economic Geology 87,
113–124.
Misi, A., Tassinari, C.C.G., Iyer, S.S., 1997. New isotope data from
the Proterozoic lead–zinc (Ag) sediment-hosted sulfide deposits
of Brazil: implications for their metallogenic evolution. South-
American Symposium on Isotope Geology, 1, Extended Ab-
stract, pp. 201–203.
Misi, A., Iyer, S.S., Kyle, J.R., Coelho, C.E.S., Franca-Rocha,
W.J.S., Gomes, A.S.R., Cunha, I.A., Carvalho, I.G., 1999.
Geological and isotopic constraints on the metallogenic evolu-
Page 34
L.V. Soares Monteiro et al. / Ore Geology Reviews 28 (2006) 201–234234
tion of the Proterozoic sediment-hosted Pb–Zn (Ag) deposits of
Brazil. Gondwana Research 2, 47–65.
Misi, A., Iyer, S.S., Kyle, J.R., Coelho, C.E.S., Tassinari, C.C.G.,
Franca-Rocha, W.J.S., Gomes, A.S.R., Cunha, I.A., Toulkeri-
dis, T., Sanches, A.L., 2000. A metallogenic evolution model
for the lead–zinc deposits of the Meso- and Neoproterozoic
sedimentary basins of the Sao Francisco Craton, Bahia and
Minas Gerais, Brazil. Revista Brasileira de Geociencias 30,
302–305.
Moeri, E., 1972. On a columnar stromatolite in the Precambrian
Bambuı Group of Central Brazil. Eclogae Geologicae Helvetiae
65, 185–195.
Moller, P., 1987. Correlation of homogenization temperatures of
accessory minerals from sphalerite-bearing deposits and Ga/Ge
model temperatures. Chemical Geology 61, 153–159.
Monteiro, L.V.S., 1997. Contribuicao a genese das mineralizacoes
de zinco da Mina de Vazante, MG. Unpublished MSc thesis,
Instituto de Geociencias, Universidade de Sao Paulo, Brazil.
159 pp.
Monteiro, L.V.S., 2002. Modelamento metalogenetico dos depositos
de zinco de Vazante, Fagundes e Ambrosia, associados ao
Grupo Vazante, Minas Gerais. Unpublished PhD thesis, Uni-
versidade de Sao Paulo, Brazil. 317 pp.
Monteiro, L.V.S., Bettencourt, J.S., 2001. Genesis of the Vazante,
Ambrosia and Fagundes Zn–(Pb) deposits (Minas Gerais, Bra-
zil): Geologic and stable isotopic constraints. In: Misi, A.,
Teixeira, J.B. (Eds.), Proterozoic base metal of Africa and
South America. CNPq and UNESCO/IUGS, Belo Horizonte,
pp. 79–81.
Monteiro, L.V.S., Bettencourt, J.S., Spiro, B., Graca, R., Oliveira,
T.F., 1999. The Vazante zinc mine, MG, Brazil: constraints on
fluid evolution and willemitic mineralization. Exploration and
Mining Geology 8, 21–42.
Monteiro, L.V.S., Bettencourt, J.S., de Oliveira, T.F., 2000. The
Vazante, Ambrosia, and Fagundes (MG, Brazil) Neoproterozoic
epigenetic zinc deposits: similarities, contrasting features, and
genetic implications. 31st International Geological Congress,
Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, Abstract volume (CD-ROM).
Monteiro, L.V.S., Bettencourt, J.S., Bello, R.M. da S, Juliani, C.,
Oliveira, T.F., 2003. Fluid inclusions and stable isotopic con-
straints on the genesis of the non-sulfide and sulfide zinc deposits
in the Vazante–Paracatu Belt, Brazil. In: Cailteux, J.L.H. (Orga-
nizer), Proterozoic Sediment-hosted Base Metal Deposits of
Western Gondwana, UNESCO/IUGS, pp. 163–167.
Oliveira, T.F. de, 1998. As Minas de Vazante e de Morro Agudo.
Workshop depositos minerais brasileiros de metais base. Uni-
versidade Federal da Bahia e Agencia para o Desenvolvimento
Tecnologico da Industria Mineral Brasileira (ADIMB), Salva-
dor, pp. 48–57.
Pattrick, R.A.D., Dorling, M., Polya, D.A., 1993. TEM study of
indium- and copper-bearing growth-banded sphalerite. Canadian
Mineralogist 31, 105–117.
Pimentel, M.M., Dardenne, M.A., Fuck, R.A., Viana, M.G., Junges,
S.L., Fischel, D.P., Seer, H.J., Dantas, E.L., 2001. Nd isotopes
and the provenance of detrital sediments of the Neoproterozoic
Brasılia Belt, central Brazil. Journal of South American Earth
Sciences 14, 571–585.
Pinho, J.M.M., 1990. Evolucao tectonica da mineralizacao de zinco
de Vazante. Unpublished MSc thesis, Universidade de Brasılia,
Brasil. 180 pp.
Pinho, J.M.M., Dardenne, M.A., Rigobello, A.E., 1990. Caracter-
izacao da movimentacao transcorrente da falha de Vazante,
Vazante, MG. Congresso Brasileiro de Geologia, 36, Anais,
vol. 5. Sociedade Brasileira de Geologia, Natal, pp. 2284–2295.
Rigobello, A.E., Branquinho, J.A., Dantas, M.G. da S., de Oliveira,
T.F., Neves Filho, W., 1988. Mina de zinco de Vazante. In:
Shobbenhaus, C., Coelho, C.E.S. (Eds.), Principais depositos
minerais do Brasil, DNPM 3, pp. 101–110.
Sangster, D.F., 1990. Mississippi Valley-type and sedex lead–zinc
deposits: a comparative examination. Transactions-Institution of
Mining and Metallurgy. Section B. Applied Earth Science 99,
21–42.
Schwartz, M.O., 2000. Cadmium in zinc deposits: economic geol-
ogy of a polluting element. International Geology Review 42,
445–469.
Sclar, C.B., Leonard, B.F., 1992. Quantitative chemical relation-
ship in franklinite–magnetite exsolution intergrowth from
Franklin, Sussex County, New Jersey. Economic Geology 87,
1180–1183.
Song, X.X., 1984. Minor elements and ore genesis of the Fankou
lead–zinc deposit, China. Mineralium Deposita 19, 95–104.
Stacey, J.S., Kramers, J.D., 1975. Approximation of terrestrial lead
isotope evolution by a two-stage model. Earth and Planetary
Science Letters 26, 207–221.
Thomaz Filho, A., Kawashita, K., Cordani, U.G., 1998. A origem
do Grupo Bambuı no contexto da evolucao geotectonica e de
idades radiometricas. Anais da Academia Brasileira de Ciencias
70, 527–548.
Viets, J.G., Hopkins, R.T., Miller, B.M., 1992. Variations in minor
and trace metals in sphalerite from Mississippi Valley-Type
deposits of the Ozark region: genetic implications. Economic
Geology 87, 1897–1905.
Viviani, C., Almeida, D.R., Romagna, G., Lopes, J.A., de Souza,
J.C.F., de Oliveira, T.F., Bessa, V., 2001. The Vazante and
Morro Agudo Zn–Pb mines, Minas Gerais, Brazil. In: Misi,
A., Teixeira, J.B. (Eds.), Proterozoic Base Metal of Africa and
South America. CNPq and UNESCO/IUGS, Belo Horizonte,
pp. 115–132.
Wagner, T., Boyce, A.J., 2001. Sulphur isotope characteristics of
recrystallisation, remobilisation and reaction processes: a case
study from the Ramsbeck Pb–Zn deposit, Germany. Mineralium
Deposita 36, 670–679.
Xu, G., 1998. Geochemistry of sulfide minerals at Dugald River,
NW Queensland, with reference to ore genesis. Mineralogy and
Petrology 63, 119–139.
Zakrzewski, M.A., 1989. Members of the freibergite–argentoten-
nantite series and associated minerals from Silvermines, County
Tipperary, Ireland. Mineralogical Magazine 53, 293–298.
Zang, W., Fyfe, W.S., 1995. Chloritization of the hydrothermally
altered bedrock at the Igarape Bahia gold deposit, Carajas,
Brazil. Mineralium Deposita 30, 30–38.
Zheng, Y.-F., 1996. Oxygen isotope fractionation in zinc oxides and
applications for zinc mineralization in Sterling hill deposit,
USA. Mineralium Deposita 31, 98–103.