Fundamentals of Prosecuting Nursing Home Abuse and …...Prosecuting Nursing Home Abuse and Neglect Cases Seminar Topic: This material provides an overview of the Nursing Home Care
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Printed in the United States of America. All rights reserved. No part of this monograph may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, recording, or by any information storage and retrieval system, except for citation within legal documents filed with a tribunal, without permission in writing from the publisher.
Disclaimer: The views expressed herein are not a legal opinion. Every fact situation is different and the reader is encouraged to seek legal advice for their particular situation.
The Apex Jurist, www.ApexJurst.com is Published by ApexCLE, Inc.
www.ApexCLE.com
119 South Emerson St., Suite 248
Mount Prospect, Illinois 60056
Ordering Information:
Copies of this monograph may be ordered direct from the publisher for $64.95 plus $4.25 shipping and handling. Please enclose your check or money order and shipping information. For educational, government or multiple copy pricing, please contact the publisher.
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data
ApexCLE, Inc.
1. ApexCLE, Inc. 2. Law-United States – Guide-books.
Barry Doyle is the founder of the Law Offices of Barry G. Doyle, P.C. with offices in Chicago and Orland Park where he is engaged exclusively in the representation of plaintiffs in complex personal injury and wrongful death litigation, with a special emphasis on nursing home abuse and neglect litigation.
A native of Evanston, he attended high school at Evanston Township High School and then went on to the University of Michigan – Ann Arbor where he graduated with a Political Science degree in 1991. He then attended law school at Loyola University of Chicago, where he graduated with honors in 1994. During his time at Loyola, he received American Jurisprudence Awards in 5 classes.
He is a member of the American Association for Justice, the Illinois Trial Lawyers Association, and the Illinois State Bar Association. He belongs to the American Association for Justice Nursing Home Litigation Group. He is a past co-chair of the Tort (Personal Injury) Litigation Committee of the Young Lawyers’ Section of the Chicago Bar Association and a former Adjunct Professor at Loyola University of Chicago School of Law. He has tried over 50 matters to verdict in jury trials, bench trials, and binding arbitration hearings. He and his family live in Evanston.
Table of Contents ............................................................................................ 4 Timed Agenda: ............................................................................................ 6
Fundamentals of Prosecuting Nursing Home Abuse and Neglect Cases ....... 8 AGENDA ...................................................................................................... 8 10,000 foot view ......................................................................................... 8 Nursing Home Care Act ............................................................................... 8 210 ILCS 45/3-601 ....................................................................................... 8 210 ILCS 45/3-602 ....................................................................................... 8 Quirk ............................................................................................................ 9 2-622 Reports .............................................................................................. 9 Arbitration ................................................................................................... 9 Settlement/Liens ......................................................................................... 9 Mindset ....................................................................................................... 9 Rules of the Road ........................................................................................ 9 5 Traits of a Good Rule of the Road .......................................................... 10 Sources of Rules ........................................................................................ 10 Care plan process ...................................................................................... 10 Steps in Care Planning Process ................................................................. 10 Summary ................................................................................................... 11 Written discovery ...................................................................................... 11 Depositions ............................................................................................... 11 Experts....................................................................................................... 11 Paradigm works for other kinds of cases .................................................. 11 Falls ........................................................................................................... 12 Care Planning for Falls - Assessment......................................................... 12 Care planning ............................................................................................ 12 Evaluation/Revision .................................................................................. 12 Discovery ................................................................................................... 12 Consequences of falls ................................................................................ 13 Falls and wrongful death claims ................................................................ 13 Bed sore cases ........................................................................................... 13 Regulation – 42 CFR, Part 483.25 .............................................................. 13 What are bed sores? ................................................................................. 13 Definition of pressure ulcer ...................................................................... 13 Stage 1 Pressure Ulcer .............................................................................. 14 Stage 2 Pressure Ulcer .............................................................................. 14
Fundamentals of Prosecuting Nursing Home Abuse and Neglect Cases
AGENDA
• Statutory and Legal Framework • Approach to Prosecuting Nursing Home Abuse and Neglect Cases • Fall Cases • Bed Sore Cases
10,000 foot view
• One of few places in health care industry that is explicitly for-profit • Revenue model: per patient, per day • Largest expense – staff
• UPSHOT: Failure is baked right in
Nursing Home Care Act
• 210 ILCS 35/1-101, et seq. • Comprehensive licensing and regulatory scheme • Intent of Nursing Home Care Act • Private cause of action with fee and cost shifting • Potential for fee award creates powerful incentive to settle
210 ILCS 45/3-601
• “The owner and licensee are liable to a resident for any negligent or intentional act of their agents or employees which injures the resident”
210 ILCS 45/3-602
• “The licensee shall pay the actual damages and costs and attorney’s fee to a facility resident whose rights, as specified in Part 1 of Article II of this Act, are violated”
• Residents have a right to be free of neglect and abuse (210 ILCS
45/2-107) • Neglect includes failure to provide medical and rehabilitative care
necessary to prevent physical harm to the resident. (210 ILCS 45/1-117)
• No cause of action under Wrongful Death Act for violations of Nursing Home Care Act
2-622 Reports
• Not required for causes of action under Nursing Home Care Act • However, required when there is a claim under Wrongful Death Act • Also required when other health care professionals or individual
nurses are named as party defendants
Arbitration
• Emerging area of law in Illinois, expect to see more litigation and more published court decisions regarding this
• Anti-arbitration provisions in Nursing Home Care Act preempted by Federal Arbitration Act
• Strategic decision – contest arbitration or not? • Defenses: unconscionability, lack of capacity • Wrongful death claims not subject to arbitration
Settlement/Liens
• Very few residents survive and have ability to decide • Need for probate, court approval of settlements • Medicare, Public Aid liens
Mindset
• Nursing home cases are not a “flash moment in time” • Nursing home cases are not medical malpractice cases • Substantial differences in delivery of care nursing home vs. hospital
setting
Rules of the Road
• Book by Rick Friedman and Pat Malone, published by Trial Guides – seminal work on trial practice
• Basic principles of book – complexity is enemy of plaintiff’s verdict • By setting clear standards, you cut through the complexity to lead
juries to favorable verdicts • Complexity still exists on issues of causation, but proper approach
1. Describes conduct on the part of the defendant – something that a defendant should either do or not do.
2. A rule should be easy for a jury to understand. 3. It should not be one which can be credibly disputed by the
defendant. 4. It must be one which was violated by the defendant. 5. It must be important enough in the context of the case that proof of
the violation will significantly increase the chances of a plaintiff’s verdict.
Sources of Rules
• Federal regulations (42 CFR, Part 483) • State regulations (77 Ill.Admin.Code, Part 300) • Interpretive guidelines • Policies and procedures • Job descriptions • Physician orders • Resident care plans • Medical literature
Care plan process
• Role of care planning in nursing home • Agreement that care planning process is standard of care • Required by regulations • Result written document setting forth what care needs to be
provided and assigns responsibility for delivery of care • Once in place must be delivered day to day, shift to shift • Represents effective framework for prosecuting case
Steps in Care Planning Process
1. Assessment 2. Care Plan 3. Communication 4. Implementation 5. Evaluation 6. Revision
• Care planning process coupled with Rules of Road approach provides powerful framework for prosecuting nursing home abuse and neglect cases
• Showing systemic failures in delivery of care consistent with the Reptile theory developed by David Ball and Don Keenan
• Helps create sense of inevitability of the result and defeat causation-centered defenses
• Applicable for all manner of nursing home cases – not just falls and bed sore cases
Written discovery
• Nursing home cases are document and deposition intensive • Written discovery should be tailored to case type • Interrogatories of limited utility • Recommend aggressive document production practice
Depositions
• Plaintiff/family members • Defendant employees – who to depose/order • Rule 206(a)(1) corporate representative • Attending physician • Subsequent treating physicians
Experts
• Is expert testimony required? • School of medicine requirements • Expert testimony necessary for causation • Physician needed for 2-622
Paradigm works for other kinds of cases
• Choking • Restraints • Side rail entrapment • Resident on resident assaults • Malnutrition/dehydration • Catheter care
• Repeat after me – these are not slip and fall cases! • Key reason families seek admission to a nursing home
o Falling at home o Need rehab after illness or hospitalization
• Falls are foreseeable → triggers duty • Morse, Preventing Patient Falls – anticipated physiological falls • Focus of intense concern in long term care industry and are
specifically care planned for • Use care planning process as tool for analysis, framework for
prosecution
Care Planning for Falls - Assessment
• Should be using standardized form • Key issue – musculoskeletal problems plus intermittent/constant
confusion or poor safety judgment/awareness • A number of other risk factors apply
Care planning
• Supervise • Moderate risk • Alarm usage • Not a solution - restraints
Evaluation/Revision
• Noncompliance • Occurrence/recurrence of falls/near falls
o Definition of fall – unintentional coming to rest on the ground,
floor, or other object, regardless of whether injury has occurred
• Fall as immediate cause of death • “Signature event” following fall • Downward spiral
Bed sore cases
• Common type of nursing home case • Not “flash moment in time” • Aggressively defended on causation
Regulation – 42 CFR, Part 483.25
• (b)Skin integrity - • (1)Pressure ulcers. Based on the comprehensive assessment of a
resident, the facility must ensure that - • (i) A resident receives care, consistent with professional standards
of practice, to prevent pressure ulcers and does not develop pressure ulcers unless the individual's clinical condition demonstrates that they were unavoidable; and
• (ii) A resident with pressure ulcers receives necessary treatment and services, consistent with professional standards of practice, to promote healing, prevent infection and prevent new ulcers from developing.
What are bed sores?
• Synonyms • Staged 1 through 4, with 4 being the worst • Normally appear on the bony prominences • Damage to the skin caused by lack of circulation caused by pressure
Definition of pressure ulcer
A pressure ulcer is localized injury to the skin and/or underlying tissue usually over a bony prominence, as a result of pressure, or pressure in combination with shear. --National Pressure Ulcer Advisory Panel
Definition - Intact skin with a localized area of non-blanchable erythema, which may appear differently in darkly pigmented skin.
Stage 2 Pressure Ulcer
Definition - Partial-thickness loss of skin with exposed dermis. The wound bed is viable, pink or red, moist, and may also present as an intact or ruptured serum-filled blister. Adipose (fat) is not visible and deeper tissues are not visible.
Stage 3 Pressure Ulcer
Full-thickness loss of skin without exposure of fascia, muscle, tendon, ligament, cartilage and/or bone.
Stage 4 Pressure Ulcer
Definition - Full-thickness skin and tissue loss with exposed or directly palpable fascia, muscle, tendon, ligament, cartilage or bone in the ulcer.
Other Types of Bed Sores
• Unstageable pressure ulcer – has dead tissue in the wound bed so , depth cannot be determined; by definition at least Stage 3
• Deep tissue injury - Intact or non-intact skin with localized area of persistent non-blanchable deep red, maroon, purple discoloration or epidermal separation revealing a dark wound bed or blood filled blister. This injury results from intense and/or prolonged exposure to pressure and shear.
Assessment/care planning
• Head to toe inspection done when resident enters facility • 3 key risk factors
o Immobility o Incontinence o Poor nutritional status
Standardized tool – Braden scale
Consequences of bed sores
• Significant change in condition – physician notification required