Top Banner
E.1 Linear Parameter Varying(LPV) System E.3 Gain Scheduling E. LPV System and Gain Scheduling E.4 Design Example Reference: [DP05] G.E. Dullerud and F. Paganini, A Course in Robust Control Theory: A Convex Approach, Text in Applied Mathematics, Springer, 2005. [DP05, Sec. 11] E.2 Quadratic Stabilization Robust and Optimal Control, Spring 2015 Instructor: Prof. Masayuki Fujita (S5-303B)
33

Fujita Laboratory – Website for Fujita Laboratory - E. LPV System … · 2020. 4. 28. · Instructor: Prof. Masayuki Fujita (S5- 303B) 2 J. Shamma A. Packard LPV Systems and Gain

Feb 21, 2021

Download

Documents

dariahiddleston
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: Fujita Laboratory – Website for Fujita Laboratory - E. LPV System … · 2020. 4. 28. · Instructor: Prof. Masayuki Fujita (S5- 303B) 2 J. Shamma A. Packard LPV Systems and Gain

E.1 Linear Parameter Varying(LPV) System

E.3 Gain Scheduling

E. LPV System and Gain Scheduling

E.4 Design Example

Reference:[DP05] G.E. Dullerud and F. Paganini,

A Course in Robust Control Theory: A Convex Approach,Text in Applied Mathematics, Springer, 2005.

[DP05, Sec. 11]

E.2 Quadratic Stabilization

Robust and Optimal Control, Spring 2015Instructor: Prof. Masayuki Fujita (S5-303B)

Page 2: Fujita Laboratory – Website for Fujita Laboratory - E. LPV System … · 2020. 4. 28. · Instructor: Prof. Masayuki Fujita (S5- 303B) 2 J. Shamma A. Packard LPV Systems and Gain

2

J. Shamma

A. Packard

LPV Systems and Gain ScheduleJ. Shamma and M. Athans, “Gain scheduling: Potential hazards and possible remedies,”IEEE Control Systems Magazine, 12-3, pp. 101-107, 1992

M. Athans

A. Packard, “Gain-scheduling via linear fractional transformations,” Systems and Control Letters, 22, pp. 79-92, 1994

Page 3: Fujita Laboratory – Website for Fujita Laboratory - E. LPV System … · 2020. 4. 28. · Instructor: Prof. Masayuki Fujita (S5- 303B) 2 J. Shamma A. Packard LPV Systems and Gain

3

LPV vs. LTI vs. LTV SystemsLTI(Linear Time Invariant) Systems

LTV(Linear Time Varying) Systems

LPV(Linear Parameter Varying) Systems

LPV systems are distinguished from LTV systems in the perspective taken on both analysis and synthesis

Optimization(LMI)LFT,

The exogenous parameters can be measured in real time

Trajectory of

Robustness

System functionStructuredoperator inequalities

1

Page 4: Fujita Laboratory – Website for Fujita Laboratory - E. LPV System … · 2020. 4. 28. · Instructor: Prof. Masayuki Fujita (S5- 303B) 2 J. Shamma A. Packard LPV Systems and Gain

4

LPV System RepresentationStyle 1: Polytope Representation

: non-singular matrix

Mass-Spring-Damper System[Ex.]

,

, ,

,

psys

pols = psys([M1, … ,Mn])

(Descriptor Representation)

(Convexity)

Page 5: Fujita Laboratory – Website for Fujita Laboratory - E. LPV System … · 2020. 4. 28. · Instructor: Prof. Masayuki Fujita (S5- 303B) 2 J. Shamma A. Packard LPV Systems and Gain

5

Style 2: Affine parameter-dependent Representation

: real parameters: affine function

LPV System Representation psys

Mass-Spring-Damper System[Ex.]

affs = psys(pv,[s0,s1, … ,sn])

,

pols = aff2pol( affs )

Page 6: Fujita Laboratory – Website for Fujita Laboratory - E. LPV System … · 2020. 4. 28. · Instructor: Prof. Masayuki Fujita (S5- 303B) 2 J. Shamma A. Packard LPV Systems and Gain

6

LPV System via Jacobian LinearizationNonlinear Plant

: Parametric-dependent exogenous inputEquilibrium Family

: trim point

Scheduling variableLinearization

[Ex.] ,

: equilibrium point

Page 7: Fujita Laboratory – Website for Fujita Laboratory - E. LPV System … · 2020. 4. 28. · Instructor: Prof. Masayuki Fujita (S5- 303B) 2 J. Shamma A. Packard LPV Systems and Gain

7

LPV System via Jacobian Linearization[Ex.] Longitudinal dynamics of a missileNonlinear Plant

Output : normalized acceleration

: angle of attack,: pitch rate, : tail-fin deflection

Aerodynamic coefficients: Mach number

Equilibrium Family (parametrized by and )

, ,

Linearization

2

Page 8: Fujita Laboratory – Website for Fujita Laboratory - E. LPV System … · 2020. 4. 28. · Instructor: Prof. Masayuki Fujita (S5- 303B) 2 J. Shamma A. Packard LPV Systems and Gain

8

Quadratic StabilitySystem ,

or differential inclusion:

Polytope Uncertainty

Norm-bounded Uncertainty

The system is quadratically stable if and s.t.,

s.t.

[Ex.]s.t.s.t.

[Ex.]

s.t.

and

( is globally asymptotically stable, which is a hard condition)

Page 9: Fujita Laboratory – Website for Fujita Laboratory - E. LPV System … · 2020. 4. 28. · Instructor: Prof. Masayuki Fujita (S5- 303B) 2 J. Shamma A. Packard LPV Systems and Gain

Suppose . If , such that for ,

If there exists such that for ,

9

Robust Performance

then

,

If is a time-variant,

-norm

-norm

-Stabilitythen , ,

s.t.s.t.

Page 10: Fujita Laboratory – Website for Fujita Laboratory - E. LPV System … · 2020. 4. 28. · Instructor: Prof. Masayuki Fujita (S5- 303B) 2 J. Shamma A. Packard LPV Systems and Gain

10

Quadratic Stabilization with State Feedback

State FeedbackClosed-loop System

Quadratic Stabilization Conditions.t.

and s.t.

Bilinear Matrix Inequality(BMI) (which does not have a feasible method to solve)

BMI to LMI: feasible

Page 11: Fujita Laboratory – Website for Fujita Laboratory - E. LPV System … · 2020. 4. 28. · Instructor: Prof. Masayuki Fujita (S5- 303B) 2 J. Shamma A. Packard LPV Systems and Gain

11

Polytope-based Gain Scheduling: Representation

LPV Plant

: affine functions of: physical parameters

LPV Controller

,

: measurable

Page 12: Fujita Laboratory – Website for Fujita Laboratory - E. LPV System … · 2020. 4. 28. · Instructor: Prof. Masayuki Fujita (S5- 303B) 2 J. Shamma A. Packard LPV Systems and Gain

12

where

, : the base of the null space spanned by ,

Minimize such that for

Convex Optimization Problem(LMI)

Polytope-based Gain Scheduling: -like SynthesisObjectives

The closed-loop system is stable for all admissible trajectoriesFind satisfying

3

Page 13: Fujita Laboratory – Website for Fujita Laboratory - E. LPV System … · 2020. 4. 28. · Instructor: Prof. Masayuki Fujita (S5- 303B) 2 J. Shamma A. Packard LPV Systems and Gain

13

LFT-based Gain Scheduling: Representation

,

: measurable

Closed Loop System

LPV Plant

LPV Controller

,

Page 14: Fujita Laboratory – Website for Fujita Laboratory - E. LPV System … · 2020. 4. 28. · Instructor: Prof. Masayuki Fujita (S5- 303B) 2 J. Shamma A. Packard LPV Systems and Gain

14[HW14] C. Hoffmann and H. Werner, “A Survey of Linear Parameter-Varying Control Applications Validated by Experiments or High-Fidelity Simulations,” IEEE TCST, 23-2, 416/433, 2015.

LPV Systems: Applications and DesignFlight control(Boeing 747, F-14, F-16 and VAAC Harrier)Missile autopilots, Aeroelasticity, Turbofan engines,Magnetic bearings, Automotive systems, Energy

[Ex.]

Derive a (in general, sufficient) analysis condition for a desired closed-loop property

STEP 1

Evaluate this condition on the closed-loop LPV system (plant and controller in feedback)

STEP 2

Transform the search for control parameters into a convex searchSTEP 3If the convex search is successful, extract controller parametersSTEP 4

LPV Control Design: LMI approach

Page 15: Fujita Laboratory – Website for Fujita Laboratory - E. LPV System … · 2020. 4. 28. · Instructor: Prof. Masayuki Fujita (S5- 303B) 2 J. Shamma A. Packard LPV Systems and Gain

15

Output argument

MATLAB Command

Input argument

hinfgs

[gopt, pdK, R, S] = hinfgs( pdP, r, gmin, tol, tolred )

option

R

gmin lower limit of gopttol , tolred required relative accuracy on gopt and threshold

S, symmetric matrices satisfying Riccati inequalities

pdKgopt

Polytopic Gain Scheduled controllerFeasible optimal closed-loop quadratic performance gain

pdPr

Parameter-dependent plantnumber of control inputs and outputs

Page 16: Fujita Laboratory – Website for Fujita Laboratory - E. LPV System … · 2020. 4. 28. · Instructor: Prof. Masayuki Fujita (S5- 303B) 2 J. Shamma A. Packard LPV Systems and Gain

16

Missile Model: Model Representation misldemObjective The missile dynamics are strongly dependent on

angle of attack , air speed and altitudeTheir parameters completely define the flight conditions(operating point) of the missile and they are assumed to be measured in real time.

Assumption The pitch, yaw and roll axes are decoupled.Linearized Dynamics of Pitch Channel

: angle of attack, : normalized vertical acceleration: pitch rate, : fin deflection of vertical stabilizer

Aerodynamical coefficients(depending on , and ): available (measurable) in real time

Gulf War(Patriot Missile)

Note: The command misldem does not exist in the newest version.

4

Page 17: Fujita Laboratory – Website for Fujita Laboratory - E. LPV System … · 2020. 4. 28. · Instructor: Prof. Masayuki Fujita (S5- 303B) 2 J. Shamma A. Packard LPV Systems and Gain

0

106

0.5 4 17

Missile Model: Parameter RepresentationAerodynamical coefficients

Oncoming Flow

Define 100 pairs of Specific Parameters for Verification/Analysis

pNum = 100 ; polyc = [ ] ;% Fixed polytopic coordinatespoly1 = [ 1, 0, 0, 0 ] ; poly2= [ 0, 1, 0, 0 ] ;poly3 = [ 0, 0, 1, 0.] ; poly4 = [ 0, 0, 0, 1 ] ;polyc = [ polyc; poly1; poly2; poly3; poly4 ] ;for j = 1 : 9

poly1 = [ 1-j*0.1, j*0.1, 0, 0 ] ; poly2= [ 0, 1-j*0.1, j*0.1, 0 ] ;poly3 = [ 0, 0, 1-j*0.1, j*0.1 ] ; poly4 = [ j*0.1, 0, 0, 1-j*0.1 ] ;poly5 = [ 1-j*0.1, 0, j*0.1, 0 ] ; poly6 = [ 0, 1-j*0.1, 0, j*0.1 ] ;polyc = [ polyc; poly1; poly2; poly3; poly4; poly5; poly6 ] ;

end% random polytopic coordinatesfor j = 1 : pNum-58

poly= rand(1,4) ; poly= poly/sum(poly) ; polyc = [ polyc; poly ] ;

end

MATLAB Command

,

%Specify the range of parameter valuesZmin=.5; Zmax=4; Mmin=0; Mmax=106; pv=pvec('box',[Zmin Zmax; Mmin Mmax]);

MATLAB Command

pvec

Page 18: Fujita Laboratory – Website for Fujita Laboratory - E. LPV System … · 2020. 4. 28. · Instructor: Prof. Masayuki Fujita (S5- 303B) 2 J. Shamma A. Packard LPV Systems and Gain

18

,

Missile Model: LPV System via Polytopic Approach

psinfo(pdP) % data of polytopic systempvinfo(pv) % data of parameters

MATLAB Command

Plant

%Specify parameter-dependent models0=ltisys([0 1;0 0],[0;1],[-1 0;0 1],[0;0]);s1=ltisys([-1 0;0 0],[0;0],zeros(2),[0;0],0);s2=ltisys([0 0;-1 0],[0;0],zeros(2),[0;0],0); pdPa=psys(pv,[s0 s1 s2]);pdP = aff2pol( pdPa ) ;

MATLAB Command

figureomega = logspace( -2, 2, 200 ) ;for j = 1 : pNum

Pdp = psinfo(pdP,'eval',polyc(j,:)) ;[adp,bdp,cdp,ddp] = ltiss(Pdp) ;sys = ss(adp,bdp,cdp,ddp) ;[vs] = sigma( sys, omega ) ;semilogx( omega, mag2db( vs ) ) ;hold on ; grid on ;

end

MATLAB Command

psys

ltisys, ltiss, pvinfo

Page 19: Fujita Laboratory – Website for Fujita Laboratory - E. LPV System … · 2020. 4. 28. · Instructor: Prof. Masayuki Fujita (S5- 303B) 2 J. Shamma A. Packard LPV Systems and Gain

19

Goal

Mixed Sensitivity Problem

Generalized Plant

Missile Model: Problem Specification

Specifications(Performance/Robustness)To control the vertical acceleration over this operation range

The stringent performance specifications

The bandwidth limitation imposed by unmodeled dynamicsfor the step response of the vertical acceleration Settling Time < 0.5 s

missileautopilot

Page 20: Fujita Laboratory – Website for Fujita Laboratory - E. LPV System … · 2020. 4. 28. · Instructor: Prof. Masayuki Fujita (S5- 303B) 2 J. Shamma A. Packard LPV Systems and Gain

20

Missile Model: Shaping Filters(Weight Functions)

np=2.0101; dp=[1.0000e+00 2.0101e-01];Wp=ltisys('tf',np,dp);nu=[9.6785e+00 2.9035e-02 0 0];du=[1.0000e+00 1.2064e+04 1.1360e+07 1.0661e+10];Wu=ltisys('tf',nu,du);

MATLAB CommandPerformance/Sensitivity Weight

Robustness/Input Weight

2 rad/s 1000 rad/s

Page 21: Fujita Laboratory – Website for Fujita Laboratory - E. LPV System … · 2020. 4. 28. · Instructor: Prof. Masayuki Fujita (S5- 303B) 2 J. Shamma A. Packard LPV Systems and Gain

21

Missile Model: Generalized Plant

missile

(Gaug)

(‘G’)

(‘r’) (‘K:e’)

(‘G:K’)

inputs = 'r' ;outputs = ‘wp;wu' ;Kin = 'K:e=r-G(1);G(2)' ;[Gaug,r]=sconnect(inputs,outputs,Kin,'G:K',...pdP,‘wp:e',Wp,‘wu:K',Wu);

MATLAB Command

figureomega = logspace( -2, 2, 200 ) ;for j = 1 : pNum

Pdg = psinfo(Gaug,'eval',polyc(j,:)) ;[adg,bdg,cdg,ddg] = ltiss(Pdg) ;sys = ss(adg,bdg,cdg,ddg) ;[vs] = sigma( sys, omega ) ;semilogx( omega, mag2db( vs ) ) ;hold on ; grid on ;

end

MATLAB Command

sconnect

Page 22: Fujita Laboratory – Website for Fujita Laboratory - E. LPV System … · 2020. 4. 28. · Instructor: Prof. Masayuki Fujita (S5- 303B) 2 J. Shamma A. Packard LPV Systems and Gain

22

Missile Model: Gain Scheduled Controller

(automatic calculation)

OK

% Minimization of gamma for the loop-shaping criterion[gopt,pdK]=hinfgs(Gaug,r,0,1e-2);gopt

MATLAB Command

hinfgs

MATLAB Command WindowSolver for linear objective minimization under LMI constraints

Iterations : Best objective value so far 11112 8035.93758913 5439.90165343 0.245759

*** new lower bound: 0.22753044 0.23669745 0.23514446 0.234688

*** new lower bound: 0.23183447 0.233905

*** new lower bound: 0.231683

Result: feasible solution of required accuracybest objective value: 0.233905guaranteed absolute accuracy: 2.22e-003f-radius saturation: 2.666% of R = 1.00e+008

Optimal quadratic RMS performance: 2.0544e-001

% Form the closed-loop systempCL=slft(Gaug,pdK);

MATLAB Command

Page 23: Fujita Laboratory – Website for Fujita Laboratory - E. LPV System … · 2020. 4. 28. · Instructor: Prof. Masayuki Fujita (S5- 303B) 2 J. Shamma A. Packard LPV Systems and Gain

23

figureomega = logspace( -4, 4, 300 ) ;for j = 1 : pNum

Pd = psinfo(pdK,'eval',polyc(j,:)) ;[adk,bdk,cdk,ddk] = ltiss(Pd) ;sys = ss(adk,bdk,cdk,ddk) ;[vs] = sigma( sys, omega ) ;semilogx( omega, mag2db( vs ) ) ;hold on ; grid on ;

end

MATLAB Command

Missile Model: LPV Controller

Controller

Elements of Controller

Page 24: Fujita Laboratory – Website for Fujita Laboratory - E. LPV System … · 2020. 4. 28. · Instructor: Prof. Masayuki Fujita (S5- 303B) 2 J. Shamma A. Packard LPV Systems and Gain

24

Missile Model: Frequency Response AnalysisLoop Transfer Function Closed-loop TF

pdPo = psinfo(pdP,'eval',polyc(j,:)) ;pdKo = psinfo(pdK,'eval',polyc(j,:)) ;Pd = smult(pdKo, pdPo ) ;

MATLAB Command

Pd = psinfo(pCL,'eval',polyc(j,:)) ;MATLAB Command

Page 25: Fujita Laboratory – Website for Fujita Laboratory - E. LPV System … · 2020. 4. 28. · Instructor: Prof. Masayuki Fujita (S5- 303B) 2 J. Shamma A. Packard LPV Systems and Gain

25

Missile Model: SensitivitySensitivity Complementary Sensitivity

pdPo = psinfo(pdP,'eval',polyc(j,:)) ;pdKo = psinfo(pdK,'eval',polyc(j,:)) ;Pd = smult(pdKo, pdPo ) ;pdS = sloop( eye(2), Pd ) ;

MATLAB CommandpdPo = psinfo(pdP,'eval',polyc(j,:)) ;pdKo = psinfo(pdK,'eval',polyc(j,:)) ;Pd = smult(pdKo, pdPo ) ;pdT = sloop( Pd, eye(2) ) ;

MATLAB Command

Page 26: Fujita Laboratory – Website for Fujita Laboratory - E. LPV System … · 2020. 4. 28. · Instructor: Prof. Masayuki Fujita (S5- 303B) 2 J. Shamma A. Packard LPV Systems and Gain

Vertical acceleration Control Input

Missile Model: Step Response for vertical acceleration

AZV=[]; U=[]; t=[0:.01:1]';for j=1:pNum

Pcl=psinfo(pCL0,'eval',polyc(j,:));[acl,bcl,ccl,dcl]=ltiss(Pcl);y=step(acl,bcl,ccl,dcl,1,t);AZV=[AZV,1-y(:,1)]; U=[U,y(:,2)/20];

endfigure; grid on; hold on; plot(t,AZV);figure; grid on; hold on; plot(t,U);

MATLAB Command

26

[pdG0,r]=sconnect('r','e=r-G(1);K','K:e;G(2)','G:K',pdP);pCL0=slft(pdG0,pdK);

MATLAB Command

splot

Page 27: Fujita Laboratory – Website for Fujita Laboratory - E. LPV System … · 2020. 4. 28. · Instructor: Prof. Masayuki Fujita (S5- 303B) 2 J. Shamma A. Packard LPV Systems and Gain

27

Missile Model: Assessment of LPV ControllerTransition on parameters

Vertical acceleration Control Input

pdsimul

Note: The command spiralt does not exist in the newest version.

spiralt

t0=[0:.001:.5];pt=spiralt(t0);figure; plot(pt(1,:),pt(2,:));

MATLAB Command[t,x,y]=pdsimul(pCL0,'spiralt',.5);figure; plot(t,1-y(:,1));figure; plot(t,y(:,2)/20);

MATLAB Command

Page 28: Fujita Laboratory – Website for Fujita Laboratory - E. LPV System … · 2020. 4. 28. · Instructor: Prof. Masayuki Fujita (S5- 303B) 2 J. Shamma A. Packard LPV Systems and Gain

28

NMD Systems Hybrid Dynamical Systems

Jump Linear Systems

LPV System: Handling Models

NMD Systems: Non-commuting Multi-Dimensional Systems

Sloop

s.t.

1

Page 29: Fujita Laboratory – Website for Fujita Laboratory - E. LPV System … · 2020. 4. 28. · Instructor: Prof. Masayuki Fujita (S5- 303B) 2 J. Shamma A. Packard LPV Systems and Gain

29

LPV System via quasi-LPVStates divided into two partitions

Tune-varying Parameters

Quasi-LPV form

[Ex.] Longitudinal dynamics of a missile

2

Page 30: Fujita Laboratory – Website for Fujita Laboratory - E. LPV System … · 2020. 4. 28. · Instructor: Prof. Masayuki Fujita (S5- 303B) 2 J. Shamma A. Packard LPV Systems and Gain

30

LFT-based Gain Scheduling: Synthesis

Conservative Design

where

Minimize satisfying that there exist pairs of symmetric matrices

Find an internally stabilizing controller s.t.

in and in such that

3

Page 31: Fujita Laboratory – Website for Fujita Laboratory - E. LPV System … · 2020. 4. 28. · Instructor: Prof. Masayuki Fujita (S5- 303B) 2 J. Shamma A. Packard LPV Systems and Gain

31[AGB95] P. Apkarian, P. Gahinet and G. Becker, “Self-Scheduled Control of Linear Parameter-Varying Systems,” Automatica, Vol. 31, No. 9, pp. 1251-1261, 1995.

2DOF controller

Missile Model: Advanced Model and Controller

ActuatorFlexibility

GyroLPV system(pitch channel)

Frequency Response

4

Page 32: Fujita Laboratory – Website for Fujita Laboratory - E. LPV System … · 2020. 4. 28. · Instructor: Prof. Masayuki Fujita (S5- 303B) 2 J. Shamma A. Packard LPV Systems and Gain

32

P-system and connection commands

G3 = sadd(G1,G2) ; G3 = smult(G1,G2) ;

G3 = sdiag(G1,G2) ;

G3 = sloop(G1,G2) ;

[P, r] = sconnect( inputs, outputs, K_in, G1_in, g1, G2_in, g2, … ) ;

G3 = slft(G1,G2, udim, ydim) ;

r=[r(1),r(2)] number of control inputs ( ) and outputs ( ) respectively

P standard plant

ns number of statesni number of inputsno number of outputs

G = ltisys(A,B,C,D,E) ;G = ltisys(‘tf’,num,den) ; %SISO only[A,B,C,D,E] = ltiss(G) ;[num,den] = ltitf(G) ;[ns,ni,no] = sinfo(G) ;

5

Page 33: Fujita Laboratory – Website for Fujita Laboratory - E. LPV System … · 2020. 4. 28. · Instructor: Prof. Masayuki Fujita (S5- 303B) 2 J. Shamma A. Packard LPV Systems and Gain

33

Data StructureAffine-parameter Representation

LFT Representation

Interconnection

sys = ltisys(A,B,C,D,E) ; sys = ss(A,B,C,D) ;

sconnect sysic

P-system SYSTEM matrix

sys =

USS SYSTEM

Polytopic Representation

[Pnom,delta] = aff2lft(pdP) ;

aff2pol

pvec

Parameter box

-1 2

20

50

pv = pvec('box',[-1 2;20 50]);

Verticespv = pvec('pol',[v1,v2,v3,v4])

6