From Visions to Actions: Social Determinants of Aboriginal Health Forum II Thursday, February 19th, 2009 Dr. Evan Adams Aboriginal Health Physician Advisor.

From Visions to Actions:Social Determinants of

Aboriginal Health Forum II

Thursday, February 19th, 2009

Dr. Evan AdamsAboriginal Health Physician AdvisorOffice of the Provincial Health Officer

BC Ministry of Health Living & Sport, andDirector

Division of Aboriginal People’s Health,UBC Faculty of Medicine

The Report of the Royal Commission on Aboriginal Peoples concluded:

“Aboriginal people are at the bottom of almost every available index of socioeconomic well-being, whether [they] are measuring educational levels, employment opportunities, housing conditions, per capita incomes or any of the other conditions that give non-Aboriginal Canadians one of the highest standards of living in the world.”

The Social Determinants of Indigenous Health

• Poverty• Education• Housing• Self-determination• Culture• Land, Environment, Environmental

Stewardship• Gender• Family & Child Welfare

An Overview of Current Knowledge of the Social Determinants of Indigenous Health (Commission on Social Determinants of Health, WHO)

Historical factors profoundly affecting health 1/2

The Reservation systemLost traditional territoryLost fishing and hunting sitesLost water rightsLoss of fishing and hunting stocksDominance of Canadian foodsAlcohol, cigarettes, drugsHygiene

Historical factors profoundly affecting health 2/2

OvercrowdingStressDecreased social and family structureDecreased wealthIncreased Church controlDecreased economic powerDecreased political power

The Residential School System& Health

Exposure to disease Overwork Underfeeding Overcrowding Physical abuse Cultural abuse Emotional abuse Assimilation Punitive religiosity Separation from parents

OPTIMAL (positive)YOUTH

DEVELOPMENT

Conceptual Framework – Aboriginal adolescent mental healthderived from positive youth-development theory

Basic CONNECTIONExperiences REGULATION(including AUTONOMYcoping w/ SELF ADVOCACYracism &social order)

Covered Adequate NUTRITION,Basic HEALTH, SHELTER,Needs SAFETY & EQUALITY

Adequate & AppropriateSUPERVISION and MOTIVATIONSupportive RELATIONSHIPSSupport for EFFICACY andopportunities for SKILL -BUILDINGIntegration of FAMILY, SCHOOL and COMMUNITYEFFORTS

Parenting NOURISHMENTSAFETYWARMTHDISCIPLINEModeling of HEALTHYBEHAVIORMONITORINGSUPERVISIONPARENTAL SUPPORT

Youth POSITIVELYCONNECTED TOSCHOOL;ACKNOWLEDGEMENT of historical disconnect

Community STRUCTURALInvestments RESOURCESIn Youth Appropriate

Mechanisms of CONTROLCONNECTEDNESSCULTURECOMMUNITY

SURVEILLANCE

Microaggressions Concepts

• Being asked if you are “really Aboriginal” by a non-Aboriginal person?

• Being asked regularly about negative stereotypes around taxes, free housing, treaties, etc.

• Feeling “invisible” to non-Aboriginal people, at work, at school, in public?

• Feeling compelled to teach basic history to non-Aboriginal people to make your viewpoint heard?

• Being asked to change your appearance, practices or apparel by your employer or agency

• Hearing from non-Aboriginal people how surprisingly articulate, well-read, or good your language skills are?

• Hearing discussions by persons in authority about Aboriginal people in a negative light

• Being asked directly – usually indirectly – if you deserve to be here

First Nations & Inuit Health Program (federal)

• Health Canada's role in First Nations and Inuit health goes back to 1945, when Indian health services were transferred from Indian Affairs.

• In 1962, Health Canada provided direct health services to First Nations people on reserve and Inuit in the north.

• By the mid 1980s, work began to have First Nations and Inuit communities control more health services.

Provincial Role

Health care services include insured primary health care (such as the services of physicians & some other health professionals) & care in hospitals The provinces & territories also provide some services & benefits not covered by the Act, such as prescription drug coverage, ambulance services, home care, public health, long term care, etc.Delegations of resources & authority to the health authorities

Community Role

“Transferred” services with heavy admin burden

Band administration with revolving leadership

Social & economic dev’t departments

Embracing traditional heritages to varying degrees

Neighbouring communities with competing & similar interests (e.g. water, land, medical services)

Local “social net” with variable functionality

BC First Nations

*Responsible for assisting in TFNHP implementation including capacity building, service and program delivery and support to First Nations Communities

Closing the GapTRIPARTITE FIRST NATIONS

HEALTH PLAN

Tripartite First Nations Health Plan

• A 10-year health plan (June 2007 to May 2017) that builds on the TCA

• Articulates a shared vision between the federal, provincial and First Nations partners

• Principles include trust, recognition & respect for Aboriginal rights & title, commitment to action, nurturing the relationship, and transparency

18

DIALOGUE: GATHERING WISDOM FORUM

Key Messages: Vision of Wellness - embracing all aspects of wellness of the

individual, family and community. Cultural, Holistic approach to health - need paradigm shift

from the western medical model of health Community-driven process - support what is already

happening in communities – increase connections between communities. Increased desire for community input.

Common challenges - lack of resources – qualified workers and funding

Need for Communication - transparent and easily accessible communication

19

2nd Report on Health and Well-being of Aboriginal Population in BC

Pathways to Health and Healing

2007 Provincial Health Officer’s Annual Report

(Release date: April 2009)

The Social Determinants of Indigenous Health

• Culture• Self-determination• Land, Environment, Environmental

Stewardship• Poverty• Education• Gender• Housing• Family & Child Welfare

An Overview of Current Knowledge of the Social Determinants of Indigenous Health (Commission on Social Determinants of Health, WHO)

Solutions - A role for:

Clinicians

Cultural workers

Community-based workers

Research

Academia

Public health

Leadership

Families

A policy of formal consultation?

22

Solutions - What Actions Can We Take?

 Individuals and families can:

• Actively oppose racism.

• Find out more about self-governance and other self-determination issues.

• Invest in educational opportunities.

• Help monitor those at-risk, maximize self-regulation, autonomy & connectedness

Aboriginal communities and organizations can:

• Work together to overcome disadvantages of small community size, for example, by forming institutional cooperatives to achieve economies of scale.

• Support local housing initiatives

• Research the meanings, barriers & protective factors in housing & environment

23

Solutions - What Actions Can We Take?

 Employers can:• Examine hiring practices to ensure equality of opportunity.• Raise the minimum wage.• Support families, women, and lesser skilled workers with fair practices.

Educators can:• Develop & support culturally-relevant curricula.• Engage communities in school activities.• Connect with disadvantaged and disconnected youth.• Examine admissions, & support services to ensure equality of

opportunity.• Protect equality and equity.

24

Solutions - What Actions Can We Take?

 Governments and communities can:• facilitate the removal of structural impediments to

economic development in First Nations Communities. • Set clear, measurable goals for employment, income,

and education levels of Aboriginal people equal to those within the general population, along with methods for public reporting of results.

• Support efforts by Aboriginal people to achieve self-determination and a collective sense of control over their futures, in both on- and off-reserve communities.

25

Solutions - What Actions Can We Take?

 Governments and communities can:•  Invest in adult education opportunities, skills

upgrading, training, job preparation, financial assistance for work and work clothing, child care, and stable affordable housing.

• Ensure that effective programs are in place to support those who have suffered abuse.

• Encourage participatory research to gain a clearer understanding of the relationship between socio-economic conditions and the health of Aboriginal communities.

26

Solutions - What Actions Can We Take?

• SPEAK UP• SHARE• COLLABORATE• PLAN• TAKE ACTION• AND MANY OTHERS...

27

CONTACT INFORMATION

• Evan Adams, MD,Aboriginal Health Physician AdvisorMinistry of Healthy Living & SportOffice of the Provincial Health [email protected]