This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Introduktion3URIHVVRU�3HU�$UQH�%RGLQ�KDU�lJQDW�HQ�VWRU�GHO�DY�VLQ�IRUVNQLQJ�nW�IUnJRU�VRP�U|U�GHQ�U\VND�RUWRGR[D�N\UNDQ��GHVV�KLVWRULD��QXWLG�RFK�LQWH�PLQVW�GHVV�WHRORJLVND�DUY��(WW�DY�GH�SUREOHP�VRP�InQJDW�%RGLQV�LQWUHVVH�lU�UHODWLRQHQ�PHOODQ�GHQ�HVWHWLVND�RFK�GHQ�UHOLJL|VD�GLPHQVLRQHQ�L�GHQ�RUWRGR[D�NXOWXUHQ��%RGLQ�KDU�VNULYLW�RP�VN|QKHWHQ�L�GHQ�U\VND�JXGVWMlQVWHQ��RP�LNRQHQ�RFK�RP�GHQ�DY�UHOLJLRQHQ�LQVSLUHUDGH�NRQVWHQ��/LNVRP�ÀHUD�DQGUD�IRUVNDUH�PHQDU�%RGLQ�DWW�IRNXVHULQJHQ�Sn�GHW�VN|QD�Sn�JRWW�RFK�RQW�lU�LGHQWLWHWVElUDQGH�I|U�GHQ�U\VND�RUWRGR[D�WUDGLWLRQHQ��'HWWD�ELGUDJ�WLOO�DQWRORJLQ�V\IWDU�WLOO�DWW�DQDO\VHUD�QnJUD�DVSHNWHU�DY�GHW�IHQRPHQ�VRP�MDJ�NDOODU�I|U�estetisering av religion och teologi��'HW�KDQGODU�L�I|UVWD�KDQG�RP�DWW�WHRORJLVND�IUnJRU�LQRP�GHQ�U\VND�RUWRGR[D�N\UNDQ�EHDUEHWDV�L�OLWXUJLVND�RFK�NRQVWQlUOLJD�IRUPHU�VQDUDUH�lQ�XWVlWWV�I|U�WHRUHWLVN�JUDQVNQLQJ��0nQJD�KDU�VNULYLW�RP�VNLOGD�KLVWRULVND�I|UNODULQJDU�WLOO�IHQRPHQHW�PHGDQ�IUnJDQ�RP�GHVV�WHRORJLVND�LQQHE|UG�I|UEOLU�UHODWLYW�REHDUEHWDG��)MRGRU�'RVWRMHYVNLM��1821–1881��KDU�InQJDW�XSS�VlUDUWHQ�L�GHQ�U\VND�V\QHQ�Sn�
VN|QKHWHQ�JHQRP�DWW�VWlOOD�Idiotens�KXYXGEXGVNDS�PRW�HWW�KXYXGWHPD�L�Bröderna Karamazov. Medan skönheten i Idioten DQWDV�IUlOVD�YlUOGHQ�KlYGDU�'PLWULM�L�Brö-derna Karamazov DWW�VN|QKHWHQ�lU�VNUlFNLQMDJDQGH�RFK�KHPOLJKHWVIXOO�1�,�YLONHW�DY-VHHQGH�lU�́ GHQ�U\VND�VN|QKHWHQ´�IUlOVDQGH"�1lU�EOLU�GHQ�SUREOHPDWLVN"�0HG�DYVWDPS�i Bröderna Karamazovs DPELYDOHQWD�KnOOQLQJ�WLOO�IUnJDQ�RP�VN|QKHWHQ�NRPPHU�MDJ�DWW�DUJXPHQWHUD�I|U�DWW�GHQ�KLVWRULVNW�P\FNHW�VWDUND�IRNXVHULQJHQ�Sn�UHOLJLRQHQV�HV-
VN|QKHWHQ�L�FLWDWWHFNHQ"�6DQQROLNW�JnU�GHW�LQWH�DWW�GH¿QLWLYW�EHVYDUD�GHQQD�IUnJD��0LQ�HJHQ�XSSIDWWQLQJ�lU�DWW�WHVHQ�NDQ�WRONDV�VRP�HWW�XWU\FN�I|U�GHQ�ElUDQGH�LGpQ�L�'RVWRMHYVNLMV�I|UIDWWDUVNDS�RP�DWW�IUlOVQLQJHQV�YlJ�lU�OLGDQGHWV�YlJ�RFK�DWW�GHQ�NULVWQD��IUlOVDQGH��VN|QKHWHQ��WLOO�VNLOOQDG�IUnQ�GHW�PRGHUQD�KDUPRQLLGHDOHW��lU�HWW�UHVXOWDW�DY�OLGDQGH�RFK�VMlOYXSSRIIULQJ��'HQ�JnWIXOOD�´VN|QKHWHQ´�NRQWUDVWHUDV�PRW�GHW�UDWLRQDOLVWLVND�9lVWV�WLOOWUR�WLOO�PlQQLVNDQV�EHIULHOVH�YLD�WHNQLVN�RFK�VRFLDO�XWYHFNOLQJ��0lQQLVNDQ�YHUNDU�LQWH�NXQQD�IUlOVDV�JHQRP�VRFLDOD�UHIRUPHU�HIWHU-VRP�GHVVD�LQWH�NRPPHU�nW�KHQQHV�LUUDWLRQHOOD�RFK�VMlOYGHVWUXNWLYD�QDWXU��(WW�YlO�RUGQDW�OLY��HQ�VRFLDO�KDUPRQL�OHGHU�LQWH�WLOO�DWW�PlQQLVNDQ�EOLU�KDUPRQLVN��(QOLJW�'RVWRMHYVNLM�UHYROWHUDU�GHQ�IULD�PlQQLVNDQ�PRW�YDUMH�VODJV�RUGQLQJ�RFK�I|UJ|U�VLJ�VMlOY�L�VLQ�OlQJWDQ�HIWHU�´DWW�OHYD�HIWHU�GHQ�HJQD�YLOMDQ´��/LGDQGHW��WLOO�VNLOOQDG�IUnQ�VRFLDOD�UHIRUPHU��EHU|U�PlQQLVNDQV�VMlO��,�RFK�LJHQRP�OLGDQGHW�NDQ�PlQQLVNDQ�I|UYDQGODV�RFK�nWHUHU|YUD�VLQ�*XGVOLNKHW��´VN|QKHWHQ´�lU�L�RFK�PHG�GHW�HWW�VODJV�I|UYDQGODW�OLGDQGH�7 7HPDW�YLGDUHXWYHFNODV�RFK�NRPSOLFHUDV�\WWHUOLJDUH�L�Bröderna Karamazov. I
I|UVWD�GHOHQV�WUHGMH�ERN�P|WV�EU|GHUQD�$OMRVMD�RFK�'PLWULM��'PLWULM�UHFLWHUDU�6FKLO-lers An die Freude!�L�HQ�U\VN�|YHUVlWWQLQJ��/LNVRP�L�GHQ�RYDQ�GLVNXWHUDGH�VFHQHQ�i Idioten DYKDQGODV�lYHQ�KlU�IUnJDQ�RP�PlQQLVNDQV�O\FND��UlGGQLQJ���'PLWULM�WDU�IDVWD�Sn�6FKLOOHUV�´:ROOXVW�ZDUG�GHP�:XUP�JHJHEHQ´�RFK�SURYRFHUDU�$OMRVMD�PHG�WDQNHQ�DWW�VN|QKHWHQ�lU�EnGH�´JnWIXOO�RFK�VNUlFNLQMDJDQGH´��+DQ�KlYGDU�DWW�.DUDPD]RYV�V\QGIXOOD�OXVW��ɫɥɚɞɨɫɬɪɚɫɬɢɟ���VRP�'PLWULM�OLNQDU�PHG�´NU\SHQV�OXVW´��lU�RVNLOMEDU�IUnQ�VN|QKHWHQ�RFK�DWW�GHW�VRP�PlQQLVNDQV�I|UQXIW�XSSIDWWDU�VRP�VNDP�IUDPVWnU�VRP�VN|QKHW�I|U�KHQQHV�KMlUWD�8�/LNVRP�0\VMNLQ�lU�$OMRVMD�
KHWHQ�L�VLQ�NRSSOLQJ�WLOO�OLGDQGH�lU�HQ�IUlOVDQGH�NUDIW�Vn�KDU�LGpQ�WYn�WHRORJLVNW�VHWW�LQWUHVVDQWD�Q\DQVHU��'HQ�I|UVWD�KDQGODU�RP�NULWLNHQ�DY�UDWLRQDOLVP�RFK�GHQ�W\S�DY�VRFLDOD�XWRSLHU�VRP�VHU�P|MOLJKHWHQ�WLOO�PlQQLVNDQV�EHIULHOVH�L�HQ�WHNQLVN�RFK�PDWHULHOO�XWYHFNOLQJ��6RP�EHNDQW�YDU�'RVWRMHYVNLM�NULWLVN�WLOO�VRFLDOLVPHQ�VRP�KDQ�XSSIDWWDGH�VRP�HQ�PDWHULDOLVWLVN�RFK�UDWLRQDOLVWLVN�LGHRORJL�YLONHQ�ERUWVHU�IUnQ�EnGH�PlQQLVNDQV�GHVWUXNWLYLWHW�RFK�KHQQHV�DQGOLJD�EHKRY��'HQ�DQGUD�LQWUHVVDQWD�Q\DQVHQ�L�'RVWRMHYVNLMV�V\Q�Sn�NRSSOLQJHQ�PHOODQ�VN|QKHWHQ�RFK�OLGDQGHW�JlOOHU�I|UHVWlOOQLQJHQ�RP�DWW�VN|QKHWHQV�IUlOVDQGH�NUDIW�LQWH�¿QQV�L�OLGDQGHW�VRP�VnGDQW�XWDQ�L�HWW�VMlOYXSSRIIUDQGH�OLGDQGH��,�Bröderna Karamazov KlYGDV�GHW�DWW�LQVLNWHQ�RP�DWW�DOOD�KDU�DQVYDU��VNXOG��I|U�DOOW�LQI|U�DOOD�RFK�I|U�DOOW�OHGHU�WLOO�SDUDGLVHW�10 Att YDUD�L�SDUDGLVHW��KRV�*XG��L�GHQ�I|UYDQGODGH�WLOOYDURQ��lU�DWW�LQVH�DWW�PDQ�ElU�VNXOG�I|U�DOOW�RFK�LQI|U�DOOD��'HQQD�EHU|PGD�VDWV�NDQ�I|UVWnV�VRP�DWW�HWW�HUNlQQDQGH�DY�GHW�HJQD�UDGLNDOD�DQVYDUHW�EHIULDU�PlQQLVNDQ�IUnQ�VNXOGHQ�VRP�ERWWQDU�L�KHQQHV�HJR��L�MDJHWV�LVROHULQJ�IUnQ�GHQ�DQGUH��'RVWRMHYVNLMV�´VN|QKHWVWHRORJL´�KDU�HQ�VWRU�SRWHQWLDO�PHQ�lU�VDPWLGLJW�DPELYD-
2. Skönhetens teologi i en politisk tid,�ÀHUD�VDPPDQKDQJ�KDU�3HU�$UQH�%RGLQ�DUJXPHQWHUDW�I|U�DWW�GHW�¿QQV�HQ�VSHFLHOO�VRUWV�WHRORJL�L�5\VVODQG��0HGDQ�PDQ�L�9lVW�KDU�XWYHFNODW�HQ�DNDGHPLVN�WHRORJLVN�WUDGLWLRQ�KDU�PDQ�L�5\VVODQG�EHGULYLW�WHRORJL�L�NRQVWlUOLJW�OLWXUJLVND�IRUPHU��%RGLQ�DQ-VOXWHU�VLJ�WLOO�WlQNDUH�VRP�3DYHO�)ORUHQVNLM�RFK�$OH[DQGHU�6MPHPDQ�VRP�|YHUW\JDQGH�YLVDW�DWW�WHRORJLQ�NDQ�XWYHFNODV�Sn�ROLND�VlWW�RFK�DWW�GHW�lU�YLNWLJW�DWW�LQWH�G|PD�DOOD�NULVWQD�WUDGLWLRQHU�HIWHU�GHW�YlVWHUOlQGVND�PnWWHW��,�DQGUD�VDPPDQKDQJ�KDU�lYHQ�MDJ�DUJXPHQWHUDW�I|U�GHQQD�XSSIDWWQLQJ��'HW�MDJ�YLOO�J|UD�QX�lU�DWW�VWlOOD�IUnJDQ�RP�YLOND�XWPDQLQJDU�VRP�P|WHU�HQ�WUDGLWLRQ�VRP�XWYHFNODU�WHRORJLQV�SUDNWLVNW�HVWHWLVND�SR-WHQWLDO�Sn�EHNRVWQDG�DY�DQGUD�W\SHU�DY�WHRORJLVNW�DUEHWH��)UnJDQ�DNWXDOLVHUDV�VlUVNLOW�L�YnU�WLG�QlU�UHOLJL|VD�DNW|UHU�UXQW�RP�L�YlUOGHQ�nWHU�KlYGDU�VLQ�OHJLWLPD�UlWW�DWW�YDUD�HQ�SROLWLVN�NUDIW��'HQ�U\VND�RUWRGR[D�N\UNDQ�J|U�EHVWlPGD�DQVSUnN�Sn�DWW�YDUD�HQ�VnGDQ�NUDIW��3DWULDUNHQ�RFK�DQGUD�UHSUHVHQWDQWHU�I|U�N\UNDQ�IUDPWUlGHU�YLG�ROLND�RI¿FLHOOD�FHUHPRQLHU��\WWUDU�VLJ�L�HQ�GHO�SROLWLVND�IUnJRU��WDU�Sn�VLJ�DQVYDU�I|U�DWW�XWIRUPD�HQ�VWRU�GHO�DY�VNRODQV�UHOLJLRQV��RFK�HWLNXQGHUYLVQLQJ��6DPWLGLJW�I|UEOLU�FHQWUDOD�VRFLDOHWLVND�IUnJRU��VnVRP�W�H[��UlWWYLVDQV�LQQHE|UG��REHDUEHWDGH�Sn�HWW�WHRORJLVNW�SODQ�11 )|U�DWW�I|UVWn�GHQ�UROO�VRP�N\UNDQ�KDU�L�GDJHQV�VDPKlOOH�lU�GHW�DY�YLNW�DWW�UHODWHUD�
VDPWLGLJW�VRP�GHQ�VDNQDU�HQ�JHQRPWlQNW�WHRORJL�L�VRFLDOD�RFK�SROLWLVND�IUnJRU��'HW�I|UV�LQJHQ�WHRORJLVN�GLVNXVVLRQ�L�IUnJRU�VRP�U|U�VRFLDO�UlWWYLVD�RFK�YDUMH�JnQJ�N\UNDQ�XWWDODU�VLJ�L�VRFLDOD�IUnJRU�nEHURSDV�HWW�RFK�VDPPD�NRQVHUYDWLYD�GRNXPHQW�från år 2000�12�8QGHU�GH�RPVWlQGLJKHWHUQD�IUDPVWnU�WUDGLWLRQHOO�SDWULDUNDO�PRUD-OLVP��VnVRP�I|UVYDU�DY�GHQ�WUDGLWLRQHOOD�IDPLOMHQ�RFK�DYYLVDQGH�DY�KRPRVH[XDOLWHW��VRP�N\UNDQV�SROLWLVND�OLQMH��3HU�$UQH�%RGLQ�KDU�DQDO\VHUDW�N\UNDQV�V\PEROLVND�PDNWXW|YQLQJ�YLG�VnGDQD�WLOOIlOOHQ�QlU�N\UNDQV�UHSUHVHQWDQWHU�RFK�VWDWHQV�OHGQLQJ�IUDPWUlGHU�WLOOVDPPDQV�13�'HQ�HVWHWLVND�GLPHQVLRQHQ�lU�VWDUN�KlU�RFK�NDQ�HQOLJW�%RGLQ�UHODWLYLVHUD�EHW\GHOVHQ�DY�GHQ�SROLWLVND�YlUOGVOLJD�PDNWHQ��1lU�VWDWHQV�UH-SUHVHQWDQWHU�IUDPWUlGHU�L�N\UNRUXPPHW�LIUnJDVlWWV�YLNWHQ�DY�GHUDV�PDNW�PHG�KMlOS�DY�OLWXUJLVN�V\PEROLN��SODFHULQJ�L�UXPPHW��NOlGHU��GUDPDWXUJL�HWF���14 Jag delar GHQQD�XSSIDWWQLQJ�PHQ�YLOO�IUDPKnOOD�DWW�GHQ�UHODWLYLVHULQJ�VRP�KlU�lJHU�UXP�JlO-OHU�SROLWLVN�PDNW�VRP�VnGDQ�PHGDQ�GHQ�DNWXHOOD�SROLWLVND�OHGQLQJHQ�IRUWIDUDQGH�EHNUlIWDV�L�VLQ�UROO��'H�V\PEROLVND�PDUNHULQJDUQD�JlOOHU�XSSIDWWQLQJHQ�DWW�*XGV�ULNH�WUDQVFHQGHUDU�NHMVDUHQV�PDNW�YLONHW�LQWH�DXWRPDWLVNW�LQQHElU�NULWLN�DY�GHQ�DNWXHOOD�SROLWLNHQ��3DUDGR[DOW�QRJ�NDQ�XSSIDWWQLQJHQ�RP�GHQ�YlUOGVOLJD�PDNWHQV�SULQFLSLHOOD�RIXOONRPOLJKHW�OHGD�WLOO�DWW�GHQ�SROLWLN�VRP�EHGULYV�DY�GHP�VRP�LQQHKDU�GHQ�SROLWLVND�PDNWHQ�LQWH�NULWLVHUDV�RFK�L�RFK�PHG�GHW�LQGLUHNW�EHNUlIWDV��9LGDUH�PHQDU�MDJ�DWW� MX�QlUPDUH�HWW�VDPDUEHWH�PHOODQ�N\UNDQ�RFK�VWDWHQ�lU�
13� 3��%RGLQ��´/HJLWLPDF\�DQG�6\PSKRQ\��2Q�WKH�5HODWLRQVKLS�%HWZHHQ�6WDWH�DQG�&KXUFK�LQ�3RVW�6RYLHW�5XVVLD´��LQ�3HU�$UQH�%RGLQ��6WHIDQ�+HGOXQG��DQG�(OHQD�1DPOL��HGV����3RZHU�DQG�/HJLWLPDF\�–�&KDO-lenges from Russia, London 2012��SS��220–234��
KDQ�W\GOLJW�WDU�VWlOOQLQJ�I|U�HQ�DJJUHVVLY�SROLWLN�L�I|UKnOODQGH�WLOO�.DXNDVXV�19 Någon XWYHFNOLQJ�DY�VRFLDOHWLNHQ�KLWWDU�PDQ�GlUHPRW�LQWH��6RP�UHGDQ�IUDPKnOOLWV�nEHURSDV�GHQ�U\VND�N\UNDQV�VRFLDOD�GRNWULQ20�DOOW�VRP�
3. Naturrätten som en teologisk resurs'HQ�U\VND�WHRORJLVND�WUDGLWLRQHQ�KDU�ÀHUD�HIIHNWLYD�UHGVNDS�VRP�NDQ�RFK�E|U�YLGD-UHXWYHFNODV�RP�N\UNDQ�Sn�DOOYDU�YLOO�IUDPWUlGD�VRP�HQ�SnOLWOLJ�SROLWLVN�DNW|U��/nW�PLJ�WD�WYn�H[HPSHO�Sn�VnGDQD�UHGVNDS��'HW�HQD�lU�OlUDQ�RP�GHQ�QDWXUOLJD�ODJHQ�RFK�GHW�DQGUD�lU�GHQ�NULVWQD�DQVYDUVHWLNHQ��/lUDQ�RP�GHQ�QDWXUOLJD�ODJHQ��ɟɫɬɟɫɬɜɟɧɧɵɣ�ɧɪɚɜɫɬɜɟɧɧɵɣ�ɡɚɤɨɧ��lU�HQ�
-DJ�lU�|YHUW\JDG�RP�DWW�GHQ�RUWRGR[D�WHRORJLQ�VNXOOH�EHULNDV�RP�PDQ�YnJDGH�DQYlQGD�VLJ�DY�OlUDQ�RP�GHQ�QDWXUOLJD�ODJHQ�RFK�GlUPHG�HUNlQGH�NUDYHW�Sn�HQ�UDWLRQHOO�SU|YQLQJ�DY�WHRORJLVND�RFK�HWLVND�SnVWnHQGHQ��'HOV�VNXOOH�N\UNDQ�EOL�PHU�WURYlUGLJ�LQRP�UDPHQ�I|U�HQ�GHPRNUDWLVN�GLVNXUV��GHOV�VNXOOH�GHQ�In�HWW�WUDQVSDUHQW�UHGVNDS�I|U�DWW�YLGDUHXWYHFNOD�RFK�JUDQVND�VLQ�ULND�WUDGLWLRQ��'H�VRFLDOHWLVND�IUnJRU-QD�NDQ�LQWH�EHG|PDV�XWDQ�KlQV\Q�WLOO�ROLND�KLVWRULVND�NRQWH[WHU�YLONHW�J|U�GHW�VYnUW�DWW�VlJD�KXU�VNLOGD�WUDGLWLRQHOOD�KnOOQLQJDU�VND�WRONDV�RFK�WLOOlPSDV�L�Q\D�WLGHU��8WDQ�HQ�H[SOLFLW�DUJXPHQWHUDQGH�DQDO\V�IUHVWDV�PDQ�WLOO�NRQVHUYDWLYD�ERNVWDYVWRONQLQJDU�VRP�VDNQDU�UHOHYDQV�I|U�GH�LFNH�WURHQGH�PHQ�NDQ�RFNVn�SnYLVDV�YDUD�SUREOHPDWLVND�L�HWW�WHRORJLVNW�DYVHHQGH��/nW�PLJ�WD�EDUD�HWW�H[HPSHO�IUnQ�GDJHQV�5\VVODQG��1lU�IDOOHW�PHG�EDQGHW�3XVV\�5LRWV�I|UDUJHOVHYlFNDQGH�XSSWUlGDQGH�L�)UlOVDUNDWHGUDOHQ�i februari 2012�GLVNXWHUDV�L�5\VVODQG�Vn�nEHURSDU�ÀHUD�VHNXOlUD�NUDIWHU�GHW�IDNWXP�DWW�N\UNDQV�OHGQLQJ�|YHUJHU�VLQ�HJHQ�WHRORJL�JHQRP�DWW�NUlYD�KnUGDUH�VWUDII�I|U�GH�PLVVWlQNWD��.YLQQRUQD��VRP�L�N\UNDQ�SDURGLHUDGH�HQ�RUWRGR[�K\PQ��IUDPI|UGH�VLWW�SROLWLVND�EXGVNDS�Sn�HWW�IHODNWLJW�VlWW��PHQDU�PDQ��PHQ�DWW�NUlYD�IlQJHOVHVWUDII�VRP�SnI|OMG�VWULGHU�PRW�EnGH�\WWUDQGHIULKHWHQ�RFK�HWW�NULVWHW�NlUOHNVLGHDO��7\YlUU�JnU�LQWH�GH�U\VND�WHRORJHUQD�L�QnJRQ�GLDORJ�PHG�VDPKlOOHW�RP�YDG�GHQ�NULVWQD�NlUOHNVWDQNHQ�EHW\GHU�QlU�GHQ�WLOOlPSDV�Sn�VRFLDOHWLVND�SUREOHP��$WW�VHUL|VW�EHP|WD�DUJXPHQW�VRP�NRPPHU�IUnQ�UHOLJLRQVNULWLVND�RFK�N\UNRNULWLVND�PHGERUJDUH�YRUH�EUD�I|U�GHQ�WHRORJLVND�XWYHFNOLQJHQ�RFK�VNXOOH�PLQVND�ULVNHQ�DWW�KLVWRULHQ�XSSUHSDU�VLJ�RFK�GHQ�U\VND�LQWHOOLJHQWLDQ�lQQX�HQ�JnQJ�YlQGHU�GHQ�U\VND�RUWRGR[D�N\UNDQ�U\JJHQ��'H�U\VND�WHRORJHUQD�NDQ�LQWH�IRUWVlWWD�DWW�KlYGD�DWW�LQQHE|UGHQ�DY�GHUDV�NULVWQD�HWLN�lU�HQ�VMlOYNODUKHW�VRP�LQWH�EHK|YHU�GLVNXWHUDV��'H�PnVWH�YnJD�DUJXPHQWHUD�I|U�VLQD�SULRULWHULQJDU�RFK�GH�PnVWH�YnJD�LQVH�VLQ�HJHQ�PlQVNOLJD�IHOEDUKHW��'H�XWPDQLQJDU�VRP�P|WHU�LQRP�UDPHQ�I|U�GHQ�U\VND�RUWRGR[D�WUDGLWLRQHQ�lU�LQWH�
XQLND��bYHQ�DQGUD�UHOLJL|VD�WUDGLWLRQHU��NULVWQD�OLNVRP�LFNH�NULVWQD��NRQIURQWHUDV�PHG�EHKRYHW�DWW�J|UD�XUYDO�RFK�SULRULWHULQJDU�LQRP�VLWW�WHRORJLVND�DUY��'H�VRP�DQVHU�%LEHOQ�YDUD�XSSHQEDUHOVHQV�FHQWUDOD�IRUP�EURWWDV�PHG�IUnJDQ�RP�YDG�L�%LEHOQ�VRP�XWJ|U�GHQ�NULVWQD�XSSHQEDUHOVHQ�RFK�YDG�VRP�E|U�EHWUDNWDV�VRP�WHRORJLVNW�LUUHOH-YDQWD�HOOHU�GLUHNW�RDFFHSWDEOD�KLVWRULVND�RFK�NXOWXUHOOD�XWWU\FN��)|U�HQ�PXVOLPVN�WHRORJ�EOLU�HQ�OLNQDQGH�XWPDQLQJ�DWW�WROND�EHUlWWHOVHUQD�RP�SURIHWHQ�0XKDPPHGV�OLY�RFK�DWW�DYJ|UD�KXU�SURIHWHQV�H[HPSHO�VND�DSSOLFHUDV�L�GDJHQV�NRQWH[WHU�26 För U\VND�RUWRGR[D�WHRORJHU�JlOOHU�GHW�DWW�YLVD�YDG�L�N\UNDQV�PRUDOOlUD�VRP�K|U�WLOO�GHQ�NULVWQD�WUDGLWLRQHQ��6lUVNLOW�NlQVOLJ�lU�IUnJDQ�RP�N\UNRIlGHUQDV�OlUD��0HGDQ�PDQ�VlOODQ�GUDU�VLJ�I|U�DWW�SnSHND�DWW�%LEHOQV�ERNVWDY�LQWH�InU�OLNVVWlOODV�PHG�GHQ�NULVWQD�XSSHQEDUHOVHQ�W|UV�PDQ�LQWH�Sn�OLNQDQGH�VlWW�HIWHUIUnJD�WRONQLQJVDUEHWH�NULQJ�N\UNRIlGHUQDV�DUY��(WW�NULWHULXP�VRP�RIWD�DQYlQGV�QlU�GHW�JlOOHU�GHQ�RUWR-GR[D�SDWULVWLNHQ�lU�consensus patrum. 'HW�EHW\GHU�DWW�GH�XSSIDWWQLQJDU�GlU�GHW�NDQ�
GLWLRQHQ��(Q�DY�GH�VWRUD�DXNWRULWHWHUQD�LQRP�GHQ�U\VND�WHRORJLQ��*HRUJLM�)ORURYVNLM�(1893 – 1979���DUJXPHQWHUDGH�EHVWlPW�I|U�DWW�DUYHW�IUnQ�N\UNRIlGHUQD�LQWH�ERUGH�DQYlQGDV�I|U�DWW�OHJLWLPHUD�HWW�VODJV�WHRORJLVNW�VWDWXV�TXR��)ORURYVNLM�I|UYlQWDGH�VLJ�DWW�GH�U\VND�RUWRGR[D�WHRORJHUQD�VNXOOH�E|UMD�YnJD�JH�VLJ�LQ�L�GLVNXVVLRQ�RP�GH�IUnJRU�VRP�VWlOOV�L�VDPKlOOHW�RFK�LQRP�GHQ�YlVWHUOlQGVND�WHRORJLQ��+DQ�HIWHUO\VWH�PHU�WHRORJLVN�NUHDWLYLWHW�RFK�VNUHY��´¶7LOO�IlGHUQD¶�EHW\GHU�L�YDUMH�IDOO�IUDPnW�RFK�LQWH�WLOOEDND��'HW�KDQGODU�RP�WURIDVWKHWHQ�PRW�fädernas ande och inte bara mot bokstaven. 'HW�KDQGODU�RP�DWW�LQVSLUHUDV�DY�GHUDV�EULQQDQGH�NUHDWLYLWHW�PHQ�LQWH�RP�DWW�J|UD�HWW�KHUEDULXP�DY�GHUDV�WH[WHU��8QGH�DUGHW, inde lucet! $WW�WLOO�IXOOR�I|OMD�N\UNRIlGHUQD�EHW\GHU�DWW�PDQ�VNDOO�YDUD�NUHDWLY´�28
4. Den kristna ansvarsetiken/lUDQ�RP�GHQ�QDWXUOLJD�ODJHQ�O|VHU�LQWH�DOOD�SUREOHP��GHQ�NDQ�RFNVn�PLVVEUXNDV�I|U�DWW�W�H[��IUDPVWlOOD�YLVVD�NRQWH[WXHOOD�XSSIDWWQLQJDU�VRP�UDWLRQHOOW�ELQGDQGH�RFK�DOOPlQJLOWLJD�29�PHQ�GHVV�DQVYDUVIXOOD�WLOOlPSQLQJ�lU�IUXNWEDU�I|U�WHRORJLQ�LQWH�
PnQJD�HWLNHU��'HQ�IUDQVNH�¿ORVRIHQ�(PPDQXHO�/HYLQDV�DQVYDUVHWLN�lU�VWDUNW�LQÀX-HUDG�DY�GHQ�U\VNH�I|UIDWWDUHQV�I|UVWnHOVH�DY�PlQQLVNDQV�RFK�*XGV�UHVSHNWLYH�DQVYDU�I|U�GHW�RQGD��,�/HYLQDV�IDOO�KDU�GHW�PRUDOLVND�DQVYDUHW�VLQ�JUXQG�L�P|WHW�PHG�GHQ�DQGUH�VRP�n�HQD�VLGDQ�lU�UDGLNDOW�DQQRUOXQGD�lQ�MDJHW��PRUDOHQV�VXEMHNW��PHQ�n�DQGUD�VLGDQ�EHURHQGH�DY�GHW��/LNVRP�ÀHUD�DQGUD�MXGLVND�HWLNHU31�PHQDU�/HYLQDV�DWW�PlQQLVNDQV�VLWXDWLRQ�lU�OLN�*XGV�´YLOONRU´�L�GHW�DYVHHQGHW�DWW�KRQ�KDU�HWW�UDGLNDOW�DQVYDU�I|U�den andre �IUlPOLQJHQ��XWDQ�DWW�NXQQD�LGHQWL¿HUD�VLJ�PHG�GHQ�
33 Det ryska zadanije EHVWnU�DY�EnGH�GDQQ\M��YDUDQGH��RFK�za �WLOO���+lUDY�%DFKWLQ¶V�IUHNYHQWD�DQYlQG-QLQJ�DY�RUGHQ�XSSJLIW��zadanije) och tilldragelse (VRE\WLMH��QlU�KDQ�I|UNODUDU�PRUDOLWHWHQV�IHQRPHQR-ORJLVND�VWUXNWXU��
35� ,ELG���V��55�36� 0��%DFKWLQ��Författaren och hjälten i den estetiska verksamheten��*UnER�2000��V��62��37� (��1DPOL��Kamp med förnuftet, Skellefteå 2009��
| 261
PRUDOLVND�DQVYDUHW�PRW�MDJHW�RFK�L�RFK�PHG�GHW�UDGLNDOLVHUD�GHW��'HQ�PRUDOLVND�SOLNWHQ�KDU�HQOLJW�%DFKWLQ�EDUD�IRUPHQ�YDG�jag bör�J|UD�PHGDQ�GHQ�DQGUHV�VLWXD-WLRQ�EHP|WV�L�HQ�estetisk�UHODWLRQ�DY�NlUOHN�RFK�I|UOnWHOVH�38�,�VLQ�OlVQLQJ�DY�EnGH�3XVKNLQ�RFK�'RVWRMHYVNLM�DUJXPHQWHUDU�%DFKWLQ�DWW�HVWHWLNHQ�VnVRP�HWW�GHOWDJDQGH��SUDNWLVNW�WLOO�VNLOOQDG�IUnQ�WHRUHWLVNW��I|UKnOOQLQJVVlWW�WLOO�PlQQLVNDQV�YlUOG�NlQ-QHWHFNQDV�DY�HQ�NlUOHNVIXOO�RFK�I|UNODUDQGH�V\Q�Sn�PlQQLVNDQ��KMlOWH�L�HWW�YHUN���)|UOnWHOVH�EOLU�KRV�%DFKWLQ�HQ�HVWHWLVN�NDWHJRUL�LQWH�I|U�DWW�GHQ�WUDQVFHQGHUDU�UlWW�och fel utan för att förlåtelsen, till skillnad från plikten, riktar sig till den andre �HQOLJW�%DFKWLQ�lU�GHW�RP|MOLJW�DWW�lOVND�I|UOnWD�VLJ�VMlOY���-DJHW�lOVNDU�GHQ�DQGUH�RFK�VPHNHU�GHQ�DQGUH�LQWH�I|U�DWW�GHQ�DQGUH�lU�JRG�XWDQ�I|U�DWW�GHQ�lU�PlQQLVNDQ�VRP�MDJHW�HQJDJHUDU�VLJ�L�39 +lU�lU�GHW�LQWUHVVDQW�DWW�QRWHUD�DWW�VN|QKHWHQ�nWHU�YLVDU�VLJ�RFK�DY�%DFKWLQ�XSS-
VWDWVDSSDUDWHQ�KDU�GHW�YDULW�EHNYlPW�DWW�KD�HQ�VWDWVN\UND�PHG�HQ�YlOIXQJHUDQGH�OLWXUJL�RFK�RUJDQLVDWLRQ�PHQ�XWDQ�XWWDODGH�VRFLDOD�RFK�SROLWLVND�DPELWLRQHU��/LNVRP�HQ�N\UND�L�HWW�NRORQLVHUDW�ODQG�KDU�GH�RUWRGR[D�SUlVWHUQD�InWW�HQJDJHUD�VLJ�L�IUnJRU�VRP�IUDPI|U�DOOW�U|U�IDPLOMHQ�RFK�SULYDWPRUDOHQ�41 De riktiga politiska frågorna har HPHOOHUWLG�KDQWHUDWV�DY�VWDWHQ��2P�PDQ�QX�PHQDU�DOOYDU�PHG�DWW�GHQ�U\VND�RUWRGR[D�N\UNDQ�VND�KD�HQ�U|VW�L�HWW�
41� )OHUD�IRUVNDUH�KDU�YLVDW�KXU�NRORQLDOD�PDNWHU�L�ROLND�GHODU�DY�YlUOGHQ�EUXNDGH�|YHUOlPQD�IDPLOMH��RFK�VH[XDOHWLVND�IUnJRU�nW�GH�NRORQLVHUDGHV�HJQD�WURVVDPIXQG��'HWWD�KDU�RIWD�ELGUDJLW�WLOO�HQ�Yl[DQGH�NRQVHUYDWLVP�Gn�I|UVYDUHW�DY�GHQ�HJQD�WUDGLWLRQHQ�SO|WVOLJW�DVVRFLHUDGHV�PHG�MXVW�GHVVD�RPUnGHQ�VDPWLGLJW�VRP�GH�NRORQLVHUDGH�EHU|YDGHV�P|MOLJKHWHQ�DWW�DQYlQGD�VLJ�DY�VLQ�WUDGLWLRQ�I|U�DWW�DUWLNXOHUD�VLQ�YLVLRQ�DY�HQ�UlWWYLV�SROLWLN��6H�W�H[��$��$��$Q�1DLP��Islam and the Secular State, &DPEULGJH�2008, SS��140–180�
9DWWLPR��*��2007��³7RZDUG�D�1RQUHOLJLRXV�&KULVWLDQLW\´��,Q�After the Death of God, E\�-RKQ�'DYLG�&DSXWR��DQG�*LDQQL�9DWWLPR��1HZ�<RUN��&ROXPELD�8QL-YHUVLW\�3UHVV��27–46�