7/28/2019 forgings.pdf
1/23
24. FORGINGS
24.1. FORGING PROCESSES
Forging is the controlled plastic deformation of a piece of metal into a useful
shape, usually at an elevated temperature. Pressure or repeated press
strokes may be used. It resembles such mill operations as hot rolling,
blooming, cogging, and hot extrusion except that total deformation is usually
much greater and final part geometry is more complex. All these processes
refine grain structure and improve physical properties of the metal. The
wrought metal in a forging, though, is shaped to become a specific, individual
part.
The machinery used for forging must be capable of applying large
compressive forces. Traditionally, drop hammers, both gravity and power-
assisted, were used and continue to be used. Crank presses and screw
presses have become more prevalent because part dimensions are more
consistent, and automation is facilitated. Power-driven rolls that produce ashape in one revolution may be used as a preliminary forming operation to
develop a rudimentary part shape prior to press or hammer forging.
Hydraulic presses are widely used for forging large, simple shapes.
Open-die and hand forgings are made by forming metal between parallel, flat
dies. In between successive blows, the operator manipulates the workpiece
to gradually form a gross outline of the final machined part. This process is
useful for making very large parts and prototype parts.
Impression-die forging uses a matched set of dies with contoured impression
in each half to form the part in two or three steps. Depending on the
FORGINGS
http://accessengineeringlibrary.com/http://accessengineeringlibrary.com/http://accessengineeringlibrary.com/http://accessengineeringlibrary.com/browse/design-for-manufacturability-handbook-second-edition/p2000af109973_177001?UserEmailParamInPdfDownloadController=rameshsmit@gmail.com#p13n-login-panelhttp://accessengineeringlibrary.com/7/28/2019 forgings.pdf
2/23
forgeability of the metal involved and the geometric complexity of the final
part, an impression-die forging may be made directly from a heated metal
billet or after roll forging to redistribute mass. (Roll forging involves a
relatively long, thin workpiece fed into power-driven rolls, which are shaped
to vary the section of the bar along its length.) Figure 3.13.1 illustrates
conventional impression-die forging.
Figure 3.13.1. Conventional impression-die forging sequence. (Based
on American Machinist, July 1978, Special Report 705, Fig. 3.)
Precision forgings and low-draft or no-draft forgings are refinements of
impression-die forgings. These represent closer approaches to final part
shape, with the last operation performed with dies of high accuracy.
Conversely, blocker-type forgings are less precise, made with larger fillet
radii and thicker cross sections. While extensive final machining is required
with blocker forgings, tooling costs are lower, and the process is thus
attractive for low production quantities.
Ring rolling forms an axisymmetrical shape from a hollow cylindrical preformmade by open-die forging. The preform is placed between two rollers, and as
they rotate, the preform wall thickness is reduced and the ring diameter
increases. Depending on the shape of the rolls, rectangular or contoured
http://accessengineeringlibrary.com/browse/design-for-manufacturability-handbook-second-edition/p2000af109973_177001#p2000af109963_1780017/28/2019 forgings.pdf
3/23
cross sections are produced.
Secondary shaping operations such as twisting, bending, and coining may be
performed on forged parts to develop final part geometry. Forgings also may
be heat-
treated in a separate operation. Most forgings are shot-blasted after forging,and their surfaces may be chemically cleaned.
Cold heading and impact extrusion are cold-forging techniques covered in
this handbook in Chaps. 3.7 and 3.8, respectively.
24.2. TYPICAL CHARACTERISTICS AND APPLICATIONS
Controlled grain structure is the primary benefit of the forging process. With
proper design, it is possible to align grain flow with directions of the
principal stresses that will occur when the part is loaded in service. Grain
flow is the directional pattern that metal crystals assume during plastic
deformation. Strength, ductility, and impact resistance along the grain are
significantly higher than they would be in the randomly oriented crystals of
cast metal or weld metal. Because hot working refines grain structure,
physical properties are also improved across the grain. (See Fig. 3.13.2.)
Forging helps ensure structural integrity from piece to piece. Internal
pockets, voids, inclusions, laps, and similar flaws are easier to avoid by good
forging quality control than they are in castings.
In most cases, forgings must be machined before use. Open-die forgings and
parts made of difficult-to-forge metals often have several times as much metal
to machine away as will be left in the finished part. In any case, enough metal
must be left on each machined face so that the part will clean up. An
allowance is added for this purpose during initial design of the part.
Because of high-strength and light-weight requirements, makers of aircraft
engines and structures, along with other aerospace manufacturers, are the
most significant users of forgings on a value basis. However, their use of
forgings is exceeded in numbers and variety by the makers of different kinds
of land-based vehicles and portable equipment.
Moving parts are forged to reduce inertia forces, and parts that must be
supported by other structures are forged to reduce overall weight and
http://accessengineeringlibrary.com/browse/design-for-manufacturability-handbook-second-edition/p2000af109973_177001#p2000af109963_179001http://accessengineeringlibrary.com/browse/design-for-manufacturability-handbook-second-edition/p2000af109973_119001#p2000af109973_119001http://accessengineeringlibrary.com/browse/design-for-manufacturability-handbook-second-edition/p2000af109973_103001#p2000af109973_1030017/28/2019 forgings.pdf
4/23
complexity. Hand tools that people lift and handle are forged to reduce
weight. Parts whose failure would cause injury or expensive damage are
forged for safety. Forgings also seldom have internal flaws to create
blemishes after machining or cause leakage when pressure tightness is a
requirement.
Decorative parts, even when stressed very lightly, may be produced from
forgings to reduce scrap losses and ensure a plateable surface, since forged
or machined surfaces of forgings can be polished and plated without
revealing blemishes or other internal flaws.
Size limits of forgings depend more on the facilities available than on any
inherent limits of the process itself. Small, highly stressed, high-speed-
machine components may weigh less than an ounce. Large, open-die forgingsmay weigh several tons.
Figure 3.13.2. Forging produces parts with an unbroken grain flow
following the contour of the part.
Figure 3.13.3. A collection of typical forgings. Note that some still
have flashing attached. (Courtesy National Machinery Company.)
7/28/2019 forgings.pdf
5/23
Some typical forging applications are the following: landing gear parts for
aircraft, automotive connecting rods, universal joints, crankshafts, off-
highway and farm equipment parts, plumbing valves, tees, elbows, ordinance
components, railroad wheels, axles, gears, oil-field machinery components,
turbine disks and blades, and bearing assemblies. Figure 3.13.3 illustrates a
collection of typical forgings.
24.2.1. Forging Nomenclature
Geometric shapes on an impression-die forging are named for the direction in
which metal must flow to fill the die impressions. Any wall filled by flow
parallel to die motion is a rib, and a projection is called a bosswhen it is filled
parallel to die motion. The wall filled by generally horizontal flow,
perpendicular to die motion and parallel to the parting plane, is the web. A
recess is a small web area surrounded by thicker metal. Figure 3.13.4
illustrates these terms.
It is not practical to forge a through hole in a web. When a hole through a
web or a boss will be needed, a recess may be forged in one or both sides.
The thin web remaining is punched out later, and the hole subsequently may
be cleaned up by machining.
24.2.2. Flash
To be sure that the die cavities will fill completely, excess metal is usually
provided. As the die halves come together, the excess is extruded into a
gutter at the parting line, producing a part with a fringe of flash metal
around it. This flash is trimmed off in a separate operation.
Figure 3.13.4. Forging nomenclature relates all features of a part to
the direction of die motion.
24.3. ECONOMIC PRODUCTION QUANTITIES
http://accessengineeringlibrary.com/browse/design-for-manufacturability-handbook-second-edition/p2000af109973_177001#p2000af109963_181001http://accessengineeringlibrary.com/browse/design-for-manufacturability-handbook-second-edition/p2000af109973_177001#p2000af109963_1800017/28/2019 forgings.pdf
6/23
Forging cost is the sum of a number of factors: metal cost including scrap,
labor cost, and overhead expenses of the production facility. The one-time
cost that does not vary in proportion to number of pieces is the die cost.
Even though a forging-die set may require repair or replacement over the
course of a long production run, the cost of this is treated as an operating
expense according to established industry practice. It is initial die cost, then,
that controls the economics of lot size.
By its nature, forging is a high-production process. Its costs grow more
attractive as die cost becomes a smaller fraction of piece cost. This is
especially true for small parts. A minimum economical lot size for 100-g (1/4-
lb) forgings usually ranges around 5000 pieces. Very large forgings weighing
from 50 kg (110 lb) to 1/2 ton may be economical in lots as small as 2 or 3pieces. This approximation assumes ordinary conventional forgings of readily
forgeable alloys. However, when only a few pieces are needed, the forging
buyer can reduce die costs by utilizing a supplier who does prototype work
and has the skills and equipment for such jobs.
One approach is to eliminate die costs entirely by ordering hand forgings
made with open general-purpose dies. The time of a highly skilled person
and the overhead of specialized facilities will then be major cost items. Much
more machining also may be required. However, the parts will have the
advantage of the forged controlled-grain structure, freedom from porosity,
and minimal nonmetallic inclusion content.
Forgings made in blocker-die impressions come closer to conventional forged-
part shapes. They, too, may require extensive machining, but the cost of
finishing dies will be avoided. It is common practice to use open-die forgings
and blocker forgings in prototype models with the anticipation that
conventional or even precision forgings will be justified at a later date in
production.
24.4. SUITABLE MATERIALS FOR FORGING
Most metals and alloys can be forged at elevated temperatures. However, the
ease with which they deform plastically varies widely. Some alloys remain
very strong even when heated almost to their melting temperatures. Some
have high coefficients of friction at forging temperature, and it is difficult to
7/28/2019 forgings.pdf
7/23
make them slide along die surfaces. Some are susceptible to metallurgical
degradation or to the formation of mechanical flaws in the course of hot
working. Differences of this nature are summed up in Table 3.13.1, which
ranks metals and their alloys by forgeability.
For preliminary planning and decision-making purposes, the alloys of
aluminum, magnesium, and copper along with mild steels, may be regarded
as readily forgeable. There are differences among them, but some of these
differences tend to balance out. For example, aluminum can be forged at
lower temperatures than steel, but it flows less readily and requires higher
pressures. There are differences among alloys in each group also.
Nevertheless, concessions from conventional design practice are seldom
necessary when a material from one of the widely used families of alloys is
selected. Steel forgings are usually heat-treated after finish machining to
develop the static and dynamic strength properties needed in service.
The stainless steels are somewhat more resistant to plastic flow, but fully
formed conventional forgings are produced routinely in these alloys.
Superalloy forgings, though, are usually produced only as simpler shapes.
Great care is exercised to establish grain-flow patterns that will suit the
parts for their intended service. If any part will require elaborate contours or
drastic section changes, however, these features must be provided in
subsequent operations.
Some metals require atmospheric control during forging. At the extreme,
beryllium is sometimes forged by first sealing metal powder in an evacuated
welded-steel jacket. The part is formed; then the jacket is removed. Vacuum-
hot-pressed beryllium billets also can be forged in impression dies if suitable
precautions are taken.
24.5. DESIGN RECOMMENDATIONS
24.5.1. Forging Drawings
Good practice dictates that a forging drawing be prepared. Shapes and
dimensions of a part as it will be forged, before any machining is done, areshown on this drawing. Die design and processing requirements are dictated
by the way in which the part is drawn. Grain flow must be aligned with the
direction of highest principal stress. An experienced designer usually can
http://accessengineeringlibrary.com/browse/design-for-manufacturability-handbook-second-edition/p2000af109973_177001#p2000af109963_1830017/28/2019 forgings.pdf
8/23
visualize metal flow from bar stock to final forging and the resulting grain-
flow pattern. A forging manufacturing engineer may have concerns, however,
about potential laps and locally excessive die wear and recommend changes
to the forging drawing that may affect grain flow and the exact shape of the
final part. Flash is not customarily indicated on the forging drawing.
For a number of reasons, forging design should be developed in partnership
between the forging user and the forging producer. To neglect technical
contributions that either partner can make is to risk a needless waste of
money and performance.
It is often advisable to use metal-flow simulation software to study blocker
and finisher shapes for forgings. The simulation software shows how a metal
bar changes shape under the action of the forging press or hammer, predicts
total forging loads and tooling stresses, indicates where laps and other
defects may form, and describes grain-flow patterns. A three-dimensional
simulation takes a few hours if the part shape is available in a computer-
aided design (CAD) file. In contrast, the dies for a prototype forging take
several weeks to machine and then may have to be modified after forging
trials are completed.
Table 3.13.1. Relative Forgeability*
Base metal Alloy UNS designation
Aluminum 2104 A92104
2024 A92024
6061 A96061
7075 A97075
Magnesium AZ31B M11311
AZ61A M11610
ZK60A M16600
HM21A M13210
EK31A M13310
Copper, brass, and bronze CA377 C37700
7/28/2019 forgings.pdf
9/23
CA464 C46400
CA485 C48500
CA642 C64200
CA673 C67300
CA675 C67500
CA102 C10200
CA110 C11000
CA147 C14700
CA150 C15000
CA694 C69400
Steel 10101030 G10100G10300
10501095 G10500G10950
4140 G41400
4340 G43400
8740 G87400
1045 G10450
Martensitic stainless steel 430 S43000
405 S40500
450 S45000
431 S43100
410 S41000
455 S45500
420 S42000
440C S4404
Maraging steel 250
200
Austenitic stainless steel 316 S31600
7/28/2019 forgings.pdf
10/23
317 S31700
302 S30200
304 S30400
310 S31000
321 S32100
347 S34700
303 S30300
Nickel Nickel 200 N02200
Monel 400 N04400
Precipitation-hardening
stainless steel
17-7PH S17700
AM 355 S35500
17-4PH S17400
Titanium Ti-6Al-6V-2Sn R56620
T1-6A1-4V R56401
Ti-7Al-4Mo R56740
Ti-5Al-2.5Sn R54521
Ti-13V-11Cr-3Al R59010
Iron-base superalloy 16-25-6
19-9DL
Cobalt-base superalloy S-816
L-605 R30605
V-36 R30036
Niobium Unalloyed
Nb-1Zr R05261
Tantalum Unalloyed
Ta-10W R05255
7/28/2019 forgings.pdf
11/23
More forgings are produced in two-part impression dies. The design of such
forgings is the topic of the following discussions.
24.5.2. Parting Line
As the die halves come together and confine metal in their cavities, their
mating surfaces define a parting line around the edges of the forging. The
parting line is indicated on the forging drawing, and determining its location
is a critical step in forging design.
*These listings, in order of decreasing forgeability, are approximate. There are too many
variables for a precise summation that would fit every case. Also, the least forgeable alloys
of a basic metal may be more difficult to forge than the more forgeable alloys of the next
metal listed. Any tentative choice based on this preliminary guide should be confirmed for
the specific forging operation under consideration.
Molybdenum Unalloyed
Mo-0.5Ti-0.1Zr R03630
Mo-0.5Ti R03620
Nickel-base superalloy Hastelloy X N06002
Inconel 718 N07718
Waspaloy N07001
Incoloy 901 N09901
Inconel X-750 N07750
M-252 N07252
Tungsten Unalloyed
Beryllium Unalloyed
7/28/2019 forgings.pdf
12/23
Figure 3.13.5. Ideally, the parting line should lie in one plane,
perpendicular to the direction of die motion. Jogs in parting linesimpose side-thrust forces on the die halves. It is expensive to absorb
these forces with die counterlocks. Often, symmetry can be achieved
by forging pieces as pairs. If they are right- and left-handed mates,
this approach has extra merit.
Ideally, the parting line will lie in one plane perpendicular to the axis of die
motion, as shown in Fig. 3.13.5. Sometimes it can be located so that one die
half will be completely flat, and the line will surround the largest projected
area of the piece. (See Fig. 3.13.6.)
If the parting line cannot lie in one plane, it is desirable to preserve
symmetry so as to prevent high side-thrust forces on the dies and the press.
Such forces can be countered, at extra die cost, if they are unavoidable. No
portion of the parting line should incline more than 75 from the principal
parting plane, and much shallower angles are desirable.
An obvious essential is to select a parting line that will not entail any
undercuts in either die impression, since the forging must come out of the
http://accessengineeringlibrary.com/browse/design-for-manufacturability-handbook-second-edition/p2000af109973_177001#p2000af109963_186001http://accessengineeringlibrary.com/browse/design-for-manufacturability-handbook-second-edition/p2000af109973_177001#p2000af109963_1850017/28/2019 forgings.pdf
13/23
die after it is made.
Because metal flow at the parting line is outward into the flash gutter, grain
flow in the forging has a corresponding pattern. Depending on the way in
which the part will be loaded, it may be desirable to change parting-line
location to control grain flow. (See Fig. 3.13.7.)
Figure 3.13.6. The parting line here is in one plane perpendicular to
die motion, and the impression is entirely in one die half. This is
usually the most economical tooling arrangement for two-part
impression dies.
Figure 3.13.7. (a) When there is a choice, locate the parting line so
that metal will flow horizontally, parallel to the parting line.
24.5.3. Draft
Die impressions are tapered so that forgings can be removed from their dies,
and forged surfaces that lie generally parallel to die motion are
correspondingly tapered. This taper, called draft, also promotes flow into
relatively deep die cavities.
http://accessengineeringlibrary.com/browse/design-for-manufacturability-handbook-second-edition/p2000af109973_177001#p2000af109963_1860027/28/2019 forgings.pdf
14/23
Draft is specified as an angle with respect to the die-motion axis.
Conventionally, a standard draft angle will be specified for all affected
surfaces on a forging, which simplifies tooling for die sinking. It is also
conventional to call for matching draft on both die halves to make surfaces of
unequal depth meet at the parting line. Table 3.13.2 shows typical standard
draft angle ranges for finished forgings in the various alloy families.
Sometimes, a parting-line location presents tapered surfaces automatically
because of a parts shape. For example, a cylinder lying parallel to the
parting plane has such natural draft except for small bands next to the
parting line. The draft needed there will be provided by narrow tapered
tangents, but they need not be indicated on the forging drawing. (See Fig.
3.13.8.)
Figure 3.13.7. (Continued) (b) The parting line location governs when
the constricted grain flow associated with flash will occur on the
http://accessengineeringlibrary.com/browse/design-for-manufacturability-handbook-second-edition/p2000af109973_177001#p2000af109963_188001http://accessengineeringlibrary.com/browse/design-for-manufacturability-handbook-second-edition/p2000af109973_177001#p2000af109963_1870027/28/2019 forgings.pdf
15/23
part. The designer can locate the parting line to achieve the
objectives of each parts function.
Table 3.13.2. Typical Draft Angles
Alloy family Draft angle,
Aluminum 02
Magnesium 02
Brass and copper 03
Steel 57
Stainless steel 58
Titanium 56
7/28/2019 forgings.pdf
16/23
Figure 3.13.8. These shapes have natural draft. Usually, the cylindrical
section will be modified slightly to provide draft in the narrow region
next to the parting line.
Low-draft and no-draft forgings can be produced in some metals, such as
aluminum and brass. This usually applies to selected surfaces for which
reduction or elimination of draft yields significant benefits.
24.5.4. Ribs, Bosses, Webs, and Recesses
Metal flow is relatively easy to manage when ribs and bosses are not too high
and narrow, and it is easiest when the web is relatively thick and uniform in
thickness. (See Fig. 3.13.9.)
Figure 3.13.9. As the web becomes thinner and the ribs become
deeper, forging difficulty increases.
Correspondingly, forging becomes more difficult when large amounts of metal
must be moved out of relatively thin webs into such projections as deep ribs
and high bosses. It is helpful to taper such webs toward the ribs and bosses.
http://accessengineeringlibrary.com/browse/design-for-manufacturability-handbook-second-edition/p2000af109973_177001#p2000af109963_1890017/28/2019 forgings.pdf
17/23
Deep recesses also are easier to forge if they have spherical bottoms. When
successive forging operations are entailed, it can be advantageous to design
for a fairly large punch-out hole in the thin-web section. During finish
forging, after the hole has been punched, flash flows inward at its edges and
helps to relieve excessive die forces.
Surface textures, designs, and lettering on forged surfaces are simply very
small ribs and recesses. Locate these features on surfaces that are as nearly
perpendicular to die motion as possible, and locate them away from zones of
wiping metal flow. Call for raised lettering and numbers, which can be
produced by milling recesses in the die. It is more difficult to achieve die
projections that will form recessed symbols on the forging.
24.5.5. Radii
Forgings are designed with radii on all their external corners except at the
parting line. It would require a sharp internal angle in the die to form a sharp
corner on the forging. This is a vulnerable stress raiser; also, excessive
pressure would be required to fill sharp corners. Both considerations
suggest generous corner radii. A common practice is to call for full radii at
the edges of all ribs and the same radius on each corner of a boss, web, or
other shape.
Fillet radii on a forging correspond to corners in die impressions that metal
must round to fill ribs and bosses. If metal flows past a sharp corner and
then doubles back, the forging may be flawed with a lap or cold shut, and the
die may not fill completely. This is more likely if the sharp die corner or sharp
fillet in the forging is near the edge of the piece.
While all radii should be ample for easy forging, they can be made smaller in
readily forgeable metals whenever there is a good reason for doing so.
Adding forging costs should be justified by the benefits gained.
Table 3.13.3 shows typical radii in terms of forging proportions. The deeper
the impression, the larger the radius should be, both at the fillet around
which metal must flow and at the corner that must fill with metal.
Table 3.13.3. Typical Minimum Radii for Forgings
Minimum radius, mm (in)
http://accessengineeringlibrary.com/browse/design-for-manufacturability-handbook-second-edition/p2000af109973_177001#p2000af109963_1900017/28/2019 forgings.pdf
18/23
24.5.6. Machining Allowance
Design features that promote easy forging add to the metal that must be
machined away. Ample draft angles, large radii, and generous tolerances can
all have this effect. The machining allowance should allow for the worst-case
buildup of draft, radii, and all tolerances. If a part is forged with locating
pads on it for setup reference, calculate tolerance buildup from those points.
See Table 3.13.4 for typical allowances for machined surfaces. Extra metal is
sometimes provided to keep critical machined surfaces away from the grain-
flow pattern that occurs in the flash region near the parting line.
Machining allowances or finishing allowances are added to external
dimensions and subtracted from internal dimensions.
24.5.7. Other Forging Processes
Several of the limitations laid down for impression forgings made in two-part
dies can be bypassed and eliminated by upset- or cored-forging techniques.
Shapes that would constitute undercuts for two-part dies can be forged.
Sharp external corners are feasi-
Table 3.13.4. Typical Machining Allowances for Forging
Depth of rib or boss, mm (in) Corner Fillet
13 (1/2) 1.6 (1/16) 5 (3/16)
25 (1) 3 (1/8) 6.3 (1/4)
50 (2) 5 (3/16) 10 (3/8)
100 (4) 6.3 (1/4) 10 (3/8)
200 (8) 16 (5/8) 25 (1)
400 (16) 22 (7/8) 50 (2)
Forging size: projected area at parting line, mm (in)
Alloy family To 640 cm (100 To 2600 cm Over 2600 cm2 2 2
http://accessengineeringlibrary.com/browse/design-for-manufacturability-handbook-second-edition/p2000af109973_177001#p2000af109963_1910017/28/2019 forgings.pdf
19/23
ble. Draft can be reduced, and no draft at all may be possible on some
surfaces. Deep recesses also can be forged.
24.6. TOLERANCES
The tolerances summarized below should be regarded as guidelines rather
than as absolutes. Adjustments can be made from these values when it is
advisable for reasons of either manufacturing economy or the components
function. They apply to impression die forgings made in two-part die sets.Aluminum forgings are commonly made to higher precision than listed here.
24.6.1. Len th and Width Tolerances
in ) (400 in ) (400 in )
Aluminum 0.51.5 (0.020
0.060)
1.02.0 (0.040
0.080)
1.53.0 (0.060
0.120)
Magnesium 0.51.5 (0.020
0.060)
1.02.0 (0.040
0.080)
1.53.0 (0.060
0.120)
Brass 0.51.5 (0.020
0.060)
1.02.0 (0.040
0.080)
1.53.0 (0.060
0.120)
Steel 0.51.5 (0.020
0.060)
1.53.0 (0.060
0.120)
3.06.0 (0.120
0.240)
Stainless
steel
0.51.5 (0.020
0.060)
1.52.5 (0.060
0.100)
1.55.0 (0.060
0.200)
Titanium 0.81.5 (0.030
0.060)
1.53.0 (0.060
0.120)
2.06.0 (0.080
0.240)
Niobium 0.82.5 (0.030
0.100)
Tantalum 0.82.5 (0.030
0.100)
Molybdenum 0.82.0 (0.030
0.080)
2.03.0 (0.080
0.120)
2 2 2
7/28/2019 forgings.pdf
20/23
Dimensions generally parallel to the parting plane and perpendicular to die
motion are subject to length and width tolerances. When a forged projection
extends more than 150 mm (6 in) from the parting plane, dimensions to its
extremities, measured parallel to die motion, are also subject to these
tolerances. Length and width tolerances are commonly specified at +0.3
percent of each dimension, rounded off to the next higher 1/2 mm or 1/64 in.
24.6.2. Die-Wear Tolerances
These tolerances apply only to dimensions generally parallel to the parting
plane and perpendicular to die motion. The corresponding variations parallel
to die motion are included in die-closure tolerances.
Die-wear tolerances are plus variations of external dimensions and minus
variations of internal dimensions. They do not affect center-to-center
dimensions. Thus they allow for erosion of die metal and corresponding
enlargement of the forged parts.
Table 3.13.5. Typical Die-Wear Tolerances*
Alloy family %
*Plus variations of external dimensions and minus variations of internal dimensions.
Aluminum, 2014 (UNS-A92014) 0.4
Aluminum, 7075 (UNS-A97075) 0.7
Magnesium 0.6
Brass and copper 0.2
Mild steel 0.4
Alloy steel 0.5
Martensitic stainless steel 0.6
Austenitic stainless steel 0.7
Titanium 0.9
Superalloys 0.8
Refractory alloys 1.2
7/28/2019 forgings.pdf
21/23
While this tolerance is applied routinely to all horizontal dimensions, as a
practical matter, dies are subject to severe wear only in the zones of harsh
metal flow.
Table 3.13.5 shows typical tolerances. Multiply each horizontal dimension by
the appropriate factor, and round off the tolerance to the next higher 1/2 mm
or 1/64 in. These are tolerances on the dimensions themselves. They are
based on die wear at each surface of half these values.
24.6.3. Die-Closure Tolerances
Dimensions parallel to die motion between opposite sides of a forging are
affected by failure of the two die halves to close precisely. The plus
tolerances on such dimensions are shown in Table 3.13.6. There is no minus
tolerance in this category. Effects of die wear on these vertical dimensions
are included in the die-closure tolerances. An added tolerance of 0.3 percent
applies to any projection that extends more than 150 mm (6 in) from the
parting plane.
24.6.4. Match Tolerances
A lateral shift of one die half with respect to the other moves all features on
opposite sides of the forging correspondingly. Table 3.13.7 shows typical
tolerances in terms of piece weight and material.
24.6.5. Straightness Tolerances
For relatively long, thin parts, a typical straightness tolerance is 0.3 percent
of length. When this aspect of forging accuracy is critical, forged parts are
often straightened in secondary cold operations.
http://accessengineeringlibrary.com/browse/design-for-manufacturability-handbook-second-edition/p2000af109973_177001#p2000af109963_194001http://accessengineeringlibrary.com/browse/design-for-manufacturability-handbook-second-edition/p2000af109973_177001#p2000af109963_193001http://accessengineeringlibrary.com/browse/design-for-manufacturability-handbook-second-edition/p2000af109973_177001#p2000af109963_1920017/28/2019 forgings.pdf
22/23
Figure . TABLE 3.13.6 Typical Die-Closure Tolerances, mm (in)
Figure . TABLE 3.13.7 Typical Match Tolerances, mm (in)
Figure . TABLE 3.13.8 Typical Flash-Extension Tolerances, mm (in)
24.6.6. Flash-Extension Tolerances
Although there are many other possibilities, the most common flash-removal
method is by a punching operation in contoured dies. This may produce
clean, trimmed edges, but a small bead of flash is allowed. Conventional
flash-extension tolerances shown in Table 3.13.8 are appropriate when thisprocedure is acceptable.
24.6.7. Draft Angles
Common tolerances on draft angles are +2 and 1.
24.6.8. Radii
The conventional tolerance on all corner and fillet radii is plus or minus one-
half the radius. On any corner where metal will be removed later, the plus
radius tolerance governs how much metal will be left for producing a sharp
http://accessengineeringlibrary.com/browse/design-for-manufacturability-handbook-second-edition/p2000af109973_177001#p2000af109963_1950017/28/2019 forgings.pdf
23/23
Copyright McGraw-Hill Education. All rights reserved.
Customer Privacy Notice. Any use is subject to the Terms of Use, Privacy Notice and
copyright information.
For further information about this site, contact us.
Designed and built using Scolaris by Semantico.
This product incorporates part of the open source Protg system. Protg is
available at http://protege.stanford.edu//
corner on the finished part. The minus radius tolerance, which would only
limit sharpness of the forged corner, is not enforced.
24.6.9. Total Tolerances
When a forging drawing is being prepared, the tolerances, plus and minus,
for each dimension are arithmetic sums of all individual tolerances that apply
to the surfaces involved. Other tolerances that may appear as notes, such as
those on draft angles, radii, mismatch, die wear, and straightness, are also
additive because they affect these surfaces.
A forging should be dimensioned so that enough metal will be available on
every surface to satisfy all functional requirements of the finished part.
Citation
James G.Bralla: Design for Manufacturability Handbook, Second Edition. FORGINGS,
Chapter (McGraw-Hill Professional, 1999, 1986), AccessEngineering
EXPORT
http://protege.stanford.edu/http://www.theiet.org/inspechttp://www.semantico.com/http://accessengineeringlibrary.com/contacthttp://accessengineeringlibrary.com/privacy-noticehttp://accessengineeringlibrary.com/terms-and-conditionshttp://accessengineeringlibrary.com/ris/design-for-manufacturability-handbook-second-edition/p2000af109973_177001http://accessengineeringlibrary.com/browse/design-for-manufacturability-handbook-second-edition/p2000af109973_177001