Top Banner
142

FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

Apr 18, 2015

Download

Documents

sexworkie
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released
Page 2: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

aleo

olPo

Ji:.-t

JOleulpJo-(

:pau6

'o'\

:peuE

ole6 pologdtuo3 | *A)a

:alBO lueulIe6 1:

pepodag luno

peno.rddyluno

ssoJ

eurep dr

.r I f'f i* .*: f t --r

9002/80/Lt

9A0Zlz0lt,L

98/ '

98/'93

90eA/98 t L o l I

eurPqnu

arlrunuuol Suruoddns

Page 3: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

v

r i l t l \ r \ l { l I ) . : l i { l i t i , . l , 1 ; , 1 : , l l r l \ , r . 1 { l l l l l l . l . r r) j I r I i [) .1 (-)r). ) r i l r r ! /r ' ' . r I l ( I . , . , 1 r r . ( t r - {

Ll :aruarqedrs",nor sr) l

Ef:aJua.re-J cN Ierunof te8png

lueuralels pauSrspus soJro^ur pred 'arntrpuedxg pue eurocul

sluaur,{e4 luanbasqn5

:slrel3o f,/v {u"B7-t,;f'

ipat.rod:6 pu;d5 ,rea,1 ,no,n"r6 j

: laru uaeq anuq Surpun3 aql 01 srrollrpuol eld

: uorlErel3aCIB Je-uuoJ pauBr g

{ ;uo luaru, ied

V-'s ,l\ alqecr;dde.;i AHJ ro JJf ruexn:)

EEi-l.lI ^l

' 90/7\ft1qlrresdald) {;ussa:rau aru 3ur,uo11o3 aq1 sluaut{ud IJB rod

tsll{raql luaurfEd

981'9 ?f\tlh 981'9 3 IBIOI

0 ," 6fft89't 0 /r r &'ffig'g 18 t8 c g

0 " 9'!6g'Z 0 ,o{ w&oE'z 98r8 c d

0 , '€s '0 l t 0 A &'orc 98 I8 E B

3alBp

o1 pagodag

IBIOT

3luaruf,ed

slql Jo lunoruv

3sluaru,ted

sno.raard ;e1o;

3pa,lo:ddy

IBIOI

apoJ

fclE:)qns lB:)

Page 4: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

:a!, : Y: :l

: T a a : t t

-- '.L_ I ' a ,

i - j: - o

lii

i t a a6 J , aC l i r a -

x t - : := . ' 7 , C[ : !

0 l tC

r o

. cT

i_-

- r a

1 ' I'-_ f

\' 1, =a! i l i I:a tJ: :! i)! L

n it . -l - t :G !

& i

:< _ -

C]

: : . ! l: " t t : a .

" . L

r - :

1 ' o. d ri)

T

t a a a r ' l:t U) :r ,.

- nt-! r , -

f t , ar Q io .

< ' :v

=

0 0 as D o' q r a

P fa l C * l f ,O o f r , 0q Df r : i

F 0 z qa c of r f i : q

o t a ; a' i - ,l 0 2r D o 0 t

, a u< o c -\ 0 !t . @

o -U A

. r 6 00 , 6 c

c

=0

U ,

3 60 f , rL c f ,: f rn > r !

3 < DO , At r ' ! 03 ' o

I

O , OO P

l o0 ln o l

o , t r 1P P r

c .c > '

o O

f , ' l- P

c - > '0 ' 0! f , o ,o

E P O

C Pc < ' \' o

o , @

N

7 ' C

t

Uo ,

T lF O 'o ra o _ ,

O L P

O o la '

6

a z! j !

T -

!a ! - o c )r.r Lr 7

r\ r \ ) oo o o oa ' - j o ! a

oF

t ! o N< ' \ < \ t ]

O O : if f P

zc o 6

nltF

N T N }O C

( i zD !

t s - 0n . -s

c F o r )u N 7

EN N -O O O Oc ! o ! ao \ o \ c

!O N i , N< \ < \ !

O O ' co s P

zo o 6

E\ E

EI J U

N N

a z0r D

! lF - 0

0a ) t ) . a ( )N U F

F:

o c o ao J - i ! tc : 1 6 \ c

FO N U J N< - - < \ - - j

O O ' nL i U i P

zo c a

!rv

N J N ] >

rj

D

O O

N

Io o

oa

o

Ef,

N \

N O' 0

o 9

o

N O

:o o

oP P C

N

N

:

Ff,

s u' 0

o 1

N

oP P S

O O

C O

6 u

b 6a h

o @F h

a @F T

c-

Page 5: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

a

U.

:( , r' e

:

t r ao f

n o iO o , ' .o 0O : T

p a0- U0 p

0 0fa ) u

< o c0

aU D

0

::: J: t.' ,

- a , r , : , ,! I : :

tl ,'. <I ' c

a r La

\ F -- l l

a ' zr !( r _P t l

D- . - < ) Fi J ! C

UI ] N Oa . r o o Ea r l i _ - i

@ N r 0 N i .< \ < \ r .

u i f a l

I

oz

e

; t l . : : :I a ): - J : I . -L Ia a =L ' J

f , , ' .- \r i na x4 . .

< Fa

- - l i

a za 0! !

r f t s . o 3 lN N ] '

CN N O. - r c c c gc - - j c ) ! a

u N o N r : .< \ < \ : -

c c i cf L r O

I

oz

;

Ef,

s u' 0

O

N

aoa

:

:7 @ !

- t a a zO r n >' ' ' - -

+ - 6e, ( ) c

!C)ra

rf,

T E< p

a! 00

oL P

!I

:oo

:

T'-r

o

0t

U

O ' ', nf,

=o,!

o

: ' Oo li O

o

o

o otr)

5 Po5 J0h 0

CU <

a

F> 6ttsrl

rlEE Ooc r 0

0

o 0a

a zI D' o f

f 0

L ' N Co

N ] U Oc i c c c E

o - : o \

U ] N 6 N : -< \ < \ a

e o os f o

€()z

e

f,

5

' p

ON

uo

I oo

r)

r - U- D

N

: ';

oC

N

O O

O O

a @a aa h

Page 6: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

a

1 . -o

'-- ti i

ili i *

- a la a :

0

- C< c

' ! \a f

>. a

' ot-:

={ ! l -0

l' o

a

-, t -

a)-oCza

c t s iQ I A

L c 40 Hf z. ( )@

@CUc)r! l

a

Dao

!-tr

Oo

;@

>: l c

' a n( :a'

' f 0

l 5c >)

. o f ,

F

C F

J

oF

!

i

. c, a o

qF0 0!

zO q

ca

II

i - !

tro

ac r

) a- o

on l

z

I

\ T ' 1 1 - . a t 7 : ! ! - ; i x i - ; :

7 ? /> : b : .2 z z i a - - Ja ) i . ) . ) - l . - I I

> o > r ) > . > o > . r > i i 0r , c l - o l - . . r . r a ' . 1 i - a l

L ' N N n f . o a . . r a _ cF o : j c ! : o ' , o ! c "Y S r . \' : a - \L C :7 7 72 Z Z c i a )

z z ' z -= -_ -:,

' - i -

\!o

6 a N O U U< o u u r ! o f r J@ 6 @ 6 9 P -

A A 6 A P O 6 A t s O F

o c o o a ; o c ; ; go o o

t - @ L '

u u u c o ' o o o 6n

P :

@ €u o u f u fs s u o u u

o o @ F @ €

@ @ @ 6 6 @l o f J o u

z z z z>

z

@ l h @ @ q 63 3 h ? P Fr r r o r E

Page 7: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

: ) a - : - - . . iar i: :i,

' - : : l ' ' _ ' t )i f.r f-i \r r.r 'r tt ' ) ') :-

I

!- u .: t,_.:, i) .- : 7-r! r \ v , 4 7 ; a . t l

r ' 11f.r Nt \r \r it -.

c i tr _ ! ! ^ . l _ : , - :. r c o . t o a i. : i c c a r z o t )L T : L ' U ] f D C

= ( - . CO ' r ( l a' r 4 0 a o i n -

> , < n T i F F V Z s ' i j .' < o r > F i l E > 7 n = -: < - C U U c q a- = ! j . - { rZ a * , r ! S C' j c o o c o c o = , t !

c E o E c F c p z oc o o c o L , n. : J o p l o F o , OP T r a n o v j a q , oN P 6 P o P 6 | O. \ z 6 z s z E i ,

a a t t 0T E T -r c E , , in F F L f , -

0 l

! t ; t > lF O

C! T ! ! O ' O

O C

, €' -' - ;

-l

z, n

Tpao

-+' o ,O L

6 O! m u D

@ @ @ F ' o , =

9 : , o 1 . i ! o E , o E' r , t r o

o o o o o o o u , 5 0o o a c o o o H f r o

,lu o - ) a o ,

" :,

p, = o '

o d ,t r J

' f , o !, f l n ' t

lo r0 > ' o: ' o

r 0 J ,

, D r, E ' N' C P s

u r

m r' ; o ' U

> P L O

, f r o. U

! '' n o 'o ,, L O ,

' n' 0 0 f' aL P O I U

O , s

@ @ o @u s f of u u u

a a a aa r r ar r q r

Page 8: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released
Page 9: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

il!ejlv ]t4)eilaeg pueleJnA

'Altunuua) ja Tuatuyedaqelq)ellaeg snbe

aqllenl ' l leqod -rPrftgug uulou uv

'6ur;rerL uorletr lddp eq] ul l lnsarplno) pup uotle:t ldde rno{ qltnn 6ur;eap ur s{e1ap ur } lnsar l l rM }uauJssosse rol parrnbaruotleluaLunlop / uollpuJ;o;ur fuessa)au aq] ]noq]lm pantofal suorlerrldde a1e;dluotu1'uJJOjt" uotle:t1dde aq] 6ur1e1dr-uol oio+aq fi;;n;a.rer sautlaptnb auaqrs oql peal aseald

Dt+ selpJ;pt up re qpeadrat qpelppgrl ; ,p sn6e selplrpl ,pal l lgall9pu I tl l l l loul 9u ]q)PUtrsealJur uop rl)euplr.{)?rr ?]p Jnl f peguDlop / slgusteqjue ue6 tealq6teq+ e euglt lorquJpau srplpr;erq al segqq e qpelo] ue g sl 'Lultoq+

ue n] uuoJeu?|qu:o:6 elns llol.l l op al q)euer?r oF oru!?)s eu alullrroaJl q6t?f

t fuoJ Nolrv)rlddvslvlvaaw waror

suolleslueblo ftelunlon g ^llunuuo)paseg-{;lelol Jo} sluelg lo otuuet6ol4

l!,eQod sn6e eq)euoa0elnllry !etq)o!Pr6el,p seluoao tgl)

Page 10: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

. - ] l iL i lu i t r (+;J r :ql l i l i :

t J t : t ! t , . - . r > , , f - _ ! 1 i . . . i t i s : , . . 1 _ r , - i , , , : . ! : . . . . : . : ; ; r r _ _ ! : . . . .t ! . ' t ' : t ' r - , r q ( r ' t L t t s U L r V ! 1 , , , r _ , , , . , . . ^ . ; -

, . - , : . - . . , , ' t ' d n j . l 6 ' - t a L l i € . t t . - t i +

: urJros * u u, " "

n., i''' i, *;;,; rt :;r;;r;i; ;,,r".

, . . : . : , , * ,a1 qpv>eEb j ! f l !p! af ; . .' ' ;

: : , . - t : r . . . i . - F , r r - i v q . +t P l u a t e u l e l p e ? q j , $ -

[ ]n{)ii t r : ; 5 ; no [ U ! SJ i f i * ; g r L r ; o _ t : i q i i ; ; . , , s fPC In . iUb r } n | : ! pn ' r , ^ i - i f O

I

I AH}

rdnrqb oc ' ; ; ipq ;o i j

Paqs! l_q9ls? sPM dnorg aql alpf l , .?rtnrb up qporpr inq'e ei i f l i t

"liil,?j""f f"ii?f .yi#f iiL"ig"",,j*j?,1,?r,r. . hi,.j i g H,! 3 Jtf;uil:L; 3i? :iil iia

.++laqunu a)^uaJA+a, XPI r ,+ Y rl lsue) eque6eql irqurfr (!

atueN lunol)v xl:ureg sreiJil,i;;J,lrt?$ tq

t",'J*"?rii?ir'iiS ru(1ue.rb 1o luaru{ed

(lr{)ole)ol aJP sl telap >;ueg) raq6e :ii req' ;ei";il illJin$"it "?'r'X,l1,?8 0

.ro; pallnba.ruopJtelsPa}

':) t_r;)::: <,- .rfJ!q"#; t"

+auoqd ,_+ u9qlng tr

*uol;es1ue6r0 lo ssa*'d1 qio, e.rd"5,r ilif#[fi ti|$,||li ro*uor;.esrue6.rg fuelur*jeuoa6 "i,fiiilnilr"t I1"#i,i$ r-

Scqnf srr I r ruvd/r ernt

[Tel11dde aq] o] pauJnlar oq 'lt/n pue pa]delre aq ]ou ril&r a]ep srq] ra+e panra)al suor;erl;dde pue suol]errrdde alaldruorugl

sle ie qpetoaqs e pe! Ie,ue?p sn6e oas dlgp ue stg rel realq'rew p slel",relq ar eu ueruorqueau selerrer ,:fiffffilfi

sprolal lno{ "roy {dor e daay (

ruro] srqr 6ur1a;duor arolaq ,ril,Yif%i"iliri]t i:! :pealpqt reur ap dlgt pgawyo2

t";'"",0

tru?tqworp e oas wrtott! ue qwrctff?',:!fli!?;f,::rfiz::;;frt, ::llaql op al

i _ , B. , i

- : l - l I dno.r5 ;no{, ur s lo€}ur};G/\ Jo raqlur lart ) pdn;u6 .op,,

,eiern6T,T"Jj ruH:-- i ;

-Irj_- Jilli'#ioo??:',i,1:Xr,"nl3,il?Hl,Tr."

uo

Page 11: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

. . . r ! { l { ) i i l . ' } i l : : . j l S a . - r t . ^ . t * a ! t n O { t i { ( t . ) a } ) \ , J - ) i ) t | . l 1 } l l l { ) l i l l l | ! . r l i . \ l ) : , i l l ( - 1 - l a ) i l l l \ i l { l l i r . ) . 1 i i ' . , . i L t , ' i 1 f t

i u r l q ue t t t g . t r. S | ) ' i 1 ? o [ l t I 1 l e 3 F j . s . ] l 3 t 1 c i | S s ; : } I c t t 1 ( ) t ] i u t i n ; r u t s j a i ] t ^ o j d e 3 I ] \ l J s ' 1 i ; a i u u . r

{r )tLlo \\

S . l a s i 1 ; l u p 3 ] e s ] ; o ] i s ? | i i | . l t ) U i t l U t l i l 1 i ' i t i p : . l : } r i i l o ' u e t l e | [ o ^ i O i l } . l O 0 o 0 6

sJea, i luarel ur seJl . \ - las e lueqnl l Futsn s leuot luu-uou.]c l puu

A . I l l l n o 3 O l l l o 1 I I I p e I } ' , . i j e ' I } l I e t I l o , \ \ . i o e S t ? a . I ] t l l 1 t l 8 f I l I l I 3 1 S € l I e 3 q S ? l l a . 1 3 l l l . . r } ] l n . ) l L l ( l ( i ]

] t i e J c J U i p u E i J J i u t i u } s n p r " r i - \ e s 3 i i ] . 1 o r i t l t s u , ^ d r 3 p r d e - r u a a q s e q e j 3 L i ] . , i | a l e r i n l , I t , J t l ,-pu?lal l u l pupl st rJo t la io.rd {po cqt sr euel ln5 , teu,rnoiraql Suolp ele i iaqt lo^eloql \ uoddns uetuo^l aqi lef lo ot s}stxe ?Lu?t1l1

sseloclo1 elp puu ,{tarcos lno .lo sur8l?ru aql uo alll orll\ ueujon\ }o dnol8 Siqe:oulru ,'fue,l ? a,t? uoilnltlso:d u} pa.\lo^tlt uoruo,,\\

L t J t uo : \ 1 ssa t t i Jo l u t i t , i i : l r us i j t s J j n i J i - L r l s puE sJ f , l pn l JJd sapn i t i t u J t j l i i u Jn [ i u l o l ) i I oA \ o ] pue uo i l n l t t so r t i puno , r - r ns l eq l

senssr aqlJo sseuole,tre aslel ot uoJa u? ul su8re{iruec erpau 8uruuru'saoua:a-}uot ul Sullsdltluud 'sdno-i8 ol suol}?luasa:d 8uqey1'Iae,\\ e eruo allua.) seqco6 or1] ur ueruo,\\ arll FuIrsr-,\

'\ae^\ q??o ]ti8lu eLIo ]tel-ojd qlle?H s.ual-uo,t\ ul ustllo,Y'' atil StllllslA'ueruo^i pazileur8reu qlri i \ r l lo^\ oq,{r suorlesrueFlo-iotl io pue sJJtruesJo eFueJ il t i}rA\ uost€t-i

'qceordcle cltsrloq ue frursn pooulo tuerussasse-.i les s.rreruo,tt eql uo paseq sauue-r6ol6 uollgollp3/lueuldola^ec leltoslod l?np!^lpul'tsurllesunoc

Bur6ue.r js pus uoddns.{1rrue. ; 1e-raua8'sat-u ' -uetFold uor tscur} .o1:p q8norqt SurUoddns tuout lueduocJu [El ldsoq pue unos ' . { rero. rpu

'Fuipuergeq 6uipnlcur dno,r8 lsF:el jno ui ueuo^\ ol sociileslSl-roddns 3o ,{}etre^ e 8ur:ago - )ijo,t\ os?J qf,eal}no l€npi^ipui' IJe^\ r lJeJ stq; - r t r 979 eJrAreq i { )BrJ lno rq3

:sa!l!^!lf,v u!LY{

,{leroos ur ueruoA\Jo uottelSa}urlJttry eql pu? u?uloiv\ roJ,{ilenba spJer!\ol )lo,\\ oJ'uorlnlrlsord or Surleler slar]?ru ur rl?J?eser ur e8e8ue o1

;;** r, rsu le ro uollnl,lsord ur uauro,,r fiTLn',::"#:':;fiffiiiTT"lffffi ,filLfii,-,li:,xTily:,:"TTJ;':",il''J;uotlnlttsord Jo uotluenard eql sple,4\ol {ro^\ oI

sacl.4'les ,{trunu[uoc

eleudordde Jo esn eqi 3ur€ernmua pue uorieuuo.Jur Ernlurmlressrp ol ,\tet.t B qli.\\ selcuoge l3r{1o illl^{ I:ontleu pus esPII oI

pelsanber se ueuro,&\ eql qlrnn 1-ro,tt dno-r37dpur"J/l€npnrpul ur e3?3ua oJ'sa3ror{c lusregrp eleuJ

ot &Uq" pup l?tluatod leql Jo elervr? erour eu.roceq ol ueuom elq"ue pu? uotlnlllso.rd o1 saan.eu:elp roJ slsenber ol puodsa-r o1

uorlegoldxe f?nxas leioJeuruloc JoJ pelcgell ueeq e^?q oq^., ueluorr\ ol uorlels: ui .{gercedse onui}uot o} pue l:o,teluaudole.Lap pus uol]€onpe rno 8urnurluoo 'secrl-res qcseJlno Jno Awpugdxe soollles Jo le^el ]uoxnc eql a^o:dun pue dolerrep o1

'uor1e1ro1dxe pnxes l€tr:eufluooJo uuoJ,{ue3o >1su }p Jo uol}nlt}sord ur pe,tlo,rul ueuro./t\.IoJ pue qlttr IloA{ oI:sa^[3a[qo pup surlv

I

I

I

I

I

I

I

I

I

I

I

I

'eale Jno/{ ut aoplue^pestp sall)pt dndr6all] r{lrqM o} }ua}xa aq} JPln)rued ur 'dnor6 aq} }o sar}r^r}lP pue suilp aq} aqlj)sao

'ielueoq) op I alsr?]unllqru al lral6u r ednr6 up uuegq] p ptauj upaqi l"r igrJ o6 'ed1uq6 ue lelq)olpquotuqo ie snne euueauqpte Jp splunr i teqqel ' f

lUfiI)nUlS NOlrVSlNV9UO

Z.r-8El7ZTIm5ssarppe pue auPu srrl l ol luas aq l l lM a)uapuodsojro) l lv :aloN

oas qpeloes sn6p uure ue 6rnq: serbeaJqlquo) r. l)e6 Jelloas 06 sleap toel l lpqqel*

l!eurlIsor{d-u

. f i'. z .., J ! ; XPJslpJ{a

{-r r ' , i t{ta a auo$d 6

u9qln9'--!"fift

Page 12: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

' . : | " / ' , r 'j , f ,

'_ :- " '_y

_-_-_E_i_;__i._: _

i l l ii l- f - r ? - - : - r T r , * f t

i -' f ) ' _ , _ : : l , i ! a r ' I . i : r i - :' t . j l - j - i t " i - 71 ' l : i : t i , i \

55.'iE-TTFryr4E- - f - r : - l i ' i t : . . ,

. . ! a

- ! < 1

t \ - r i f - f ' : :I i :i a f r ::(

: /t . '* . i f ./, :.]l:;1-fn{,1 -r 'n ( ' i )_ i . , ;-1^.), ]

j - ' 1 j / : l i j . i ' r

t '-"!1 Lj1-a:' : : : - , 1 ' : . ' i|

' / " , , 1 i t

asflLUqplal

aljnosasuroJ

a *1.'-f

Pataptsuo)aq ue3 luetfr e a)alag JcJ paluno):e aq lsnw steaA snattald ut aruaq>s slql rapun pa^larat spunj..alorvsee{cu.s e asfa'q sE}uosrrF )e sele.uel Jlplgt }elns

eas urla]s t',.r{'ej aJplsr?rue ssvl}Pt'r} e se}uo*F rrot] "?e }Jr€ryEe.J} F s€}{rn.} Jep|.}l!e3;e.reep toe!.t!e.lqe!

t , - ) - ) " } )

:pasn uaaq a^eq daqt nnoq pup leor{ lsel spuni:rlqnd'ur[4uolleslueb]O Jno^ {q panraral s}uern }o allnos pue }unoue }o slle}ap oAtO aspal;

peanlte-l up LlpeaLlltel e Jeuj a] sn6elqlorelbel,p Jtenj p seluoapu eu tsutoj sn6e puueatiJtnqs

qprejnue Jlqlod JlsD PU oJP Ie IUOSUOIU Jteqqel 'g

' uoqn]4soJd uI peAlolut eJe oql\ uetuol\ eJB sgcr,r.res Jno Jo sJesn se sorlrlrlce eg] u! pollo ut esoql'elor ]usl]odrur f-ro.r u ,{e1dgu1s Uoddns

Jo oBII€J e pu€ 'srollesunoc 'sJarlJesl uoBesrue8Jo aql eprslno ruorC 'lceroJd eql Jo lJo.aa aql p1* r""tn:atJo uoISIAord er$ In peAIo^uI II3 ore sraetunlo1 pue JJeIS luarueEeuery 'sreqruehl prsog FnpI lpu1

.sea1sru1

g , - ' .

) r ! Y '

,.{? 3t -:.4

* q r , '

, . " - - r ; , r3r?, ; , . . , . . i * i , . - idnofb aql Jo sal l lAlpb aql ut utol ue) oqM, ^ : D r l n l l t : . . , t n t t ) l t t t t n l r r ^ r r | , r ^ F ^ 6 , r r n n

" r r ^ J * ^ ^ - ^ C _ - _ - _

'sruoll1u€AoleJ uo aleqop pue uolssnoslp 4elIIIcBJ s8mleeurgsls {lq}uour pue tuee} JelnSoU

.sluarrrennbeJ qcns ile leetu o] ac€ld u_r oJB sompecoJd Eurlersdo pJPpuBlS 's}tmo33?

"relrpne l€nuu" Surpnycur suoq€Erlqo ,fuo]ruels sll IIe sledur poford eql fueduoJ polIIuII 3 se 'uolllppe uI'srail€Iu slaole-Ils uo.{es Fug eq} sull sJo}ceJr(lJo prsog ?"r

.,erpqrsuodsal srqt seq rolcenp tuel$ss€ eW muesqe Joq q pue sJaFeru,(ep-o1-.(ep uo {BS leug s"q ro}c3-.--/

ler )ueut l uo uol leuJolut apnl )ut p lnoqs6ur>;eru uolst)ap/ luaulabeueu sdnolg aql

' lo j luo) puP luaulaoeueuuor ldu)sap s[ .11'salnpa]ojdlo uot ldtJ lsap e aAt6 aseald

I , i ' : j : : . : : : j : : ] : : ! : r11!P| leusn6e}q)oj}s|uleqqJesPloal l9q]PB'ednJq9-luoserd }e e gtY st :srealunlo^ EurBqnu

'Jeef oruEs oql'onolo aql lo alnpnjls leuotleslueDjo aql aqulsap aseJld

'ednrq6 ue utgr.ll lrbea Itl lr{lnl}s re llor{} op al se}un) Jleqqel.t

(su]{ryd Z + orilt}Iltu I)JJutsuoq?Islurupv + roleurpJoo3 Sursierpung + rotreulproo3 reetrunlol + Jeryoi& Eu.qcrglrl

+ roIro1\ tuerudole^o6lifrroqecnpg + (E*) JJ4S q3ee.4no + rolutrlproo] gcee.qno .$sfs BIuBqnUrolco4cl tus]slssv + Jolce4Q :IuBeI lueuo8cusl l BItrBqnu

(pesolcue ilodeU ppuelg

q ]SII llnJ) sJeqlo + saArlsluoseJdeu roptmd + Jolcen(l srueqnu + se^qe]uesoJdeU ee]sruI ;srolc{ul(I Jo prBogsrolsrs preqdeqs pooc oql pItB ,{4req33o,{pe1m63o sre}sls :seelsruI

:eJe POAIOAuT leuuosJed egl

m snlsls alqErreqc s1I peule8 pue t(uedwoc po4uql s s€ perqslEer uorlesrueEro ogl t66l uI

, " &

Page 13: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

j

J

I

il u^r =!' :,t*-H,*,'Jffi]]'.j'Jj;:f:'11:i1": " p,,,r*, ,,o,r,*,?";': .=:t,"lt-ff,1T,ti,fTiitTeY

sr slfluelrqq slelunr eu ap dro: 1rn;qq uy s

bursrer punj ,suorleuop ,slsnr] arqpllreqr ,pupr{ ,drt !tl;ltjrt#:fi]1fi;srql Jo] arqprrpAp a,e qlrq* 'spunl Jo sal,nos pue slunoue aql lo sf tplap a^f g';is

ireruosuorur) pt6rtg aqlllleq JeiqloJeqluo,rO ,r, zy.r"T;-,T;:f If :li.::t"T::,'^i,::':lii peao,p';jldureqs reul ,oas ;eperiuorluop f lgj re elp 'rlsr:6 eu Isuror{} re sn6e euupaurnq, ,;l;;;ffi'ffi'qr;

f-

'7Vr':)L/,/7-t:)' ":./'*D-"rt'

i . - . \7 4r - )1??;4 ; , ' i i1 r r ,'=',

K ;4?l?./ '-,'i r, t$t I

:umoul Jr 'uorle)tldde ;o llnsar aql

, ." /7,17-> ',.:lo3 t"*'t:')yJ\ty:yylol

ii'---r-

:lq6nos luer6;o asod.rnd pue slunoure ,arnos arJ] {trr:ads ,sa{,;;:qpreJ,er g gle sreluoap ue rrodsn: sn6e ,rns ,asufoq] rp re,uos Jreqqe] ,g1, sgl^r

l u e, 6 e r or u o, l p, r I d #',il li I'Jt i[,",], I i ,; j;if : ff ,H*

r,,ffiff tI I unr l_J siueqllal,seluoaqp,"u','Ji*:1:Ji:i;X;iJJ:Til::,T:'Jl#;::m;t";

Page 14: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

Jo spsrpunq ut llnssl lll,^A slqJosar{l Jo r{leE .Fururerl er{t tuo{ ..*ii t : r,,,{, * "u i:T3{ :: TIll#*,Tf Ii ;XT: :::i,llf,:Xi ::#:i,:l-"jAlrca'p ]geuaq '1i'r sarcuaSe snollp^

'ruo{ sJ^rJuruassrdar 91 ,{1r1n*rrordde peq,csep ,{pee:

ipaford aqt Luorl lllauaq d;irarrp ;1rnn aldoad,{i,.,u nnogalPpP)suot] up se qlearrp seal qpgu,rqq , autnp ppaqu aJ ,t

p,to pas!^a., aq o7 a*oyctro ,0, ,,,,0,1!#ilfli!rt:;::;;';?:,:;:i, :;:,;;i,';:::t:;,"?if;,::;:;:;,;:,":f;::;f:f:";;:

peruqs pue sdrqs'or1u1ar ,{cua3e-relur Jo luaure,ro:drur ,,," ii:Jffj'.tl"rti;"jj'1,',T'l,,:l:::ti,:,:::"-'::1T::-:11-ro -s8rtpuels'alSuru:qt8ue,us rql eq Il l ,r1 _srrorssas fiururerl ,r". l i *";,;;;;";:. suorruo^rorur aler:dordde 3 o a'uu-r n qir^ prro i, "r-",

"0"" ;""r" :, ;, ;;;-le eq o1 satltledur leql uaqlSuarls a,\\ slepllord ecr,tres

"ql aurllr4rtn , q 1eq1 s,t\oIIoI rI .uonrarrn qTr' rrr rr-cr11r4sdn ,{q teip s,\\olloJ }l .uorlcorrp srql ur dals tsrg e elut rn ̂ \o:1ilffii,",iil::1,"J*, ff:fr'l'"11#,::T:,:i:""*^";*'*::**;'*;;;;#il;,*#i;il1'"1:il1J,'i:"","Th-*"J;aql3o Suirzqs 3ql sees eureqnu 's:epr,ro:d r",-", jo.aun, rp,,i'n;il;;#;;:#;;".#'

outstl's'I w ools IslI^ e sB qcreasax 11roopw4lepprq ur pe4lo1rn aJu ir?6 srrnrrrnrr reD^ ̂ r ir r ,^..e a-^^---

&\ algeJeuin^ esJqlJo,{uery :uorlnl i lsc

;?$f'J,H,:|i:JlT,":j:l',;1'::T.:::^:3^"1i1-,11*'li .u' ," o,i'*;';;;;;'l';JJ; i;#'"'^i,Tifl";"'ff3"T1":il::*'ll"J?ffJ1"":nr,#,;:i::::'ii:',:*:ly iy::iJ;;'"*;#; #iil'#:d'i;::Ul,1ff :fr,,::Hsodex IeruueIB s.e."'rlnu 'uorln1t1sord ur ue,uo^'3o (spuesnoqt riql".ij ,"p"ff;ffi; ilt"t ffl,Tff,,.lil,ll#f,?"m:;X

e'pe'rouqro {oel eq'; palq'rp'rq qcleaso*T*l.fflijilffi'fri?H{i,i}Tifi1;i:i:r:il$#;#:#'ir i:;:!l*4eq1 3uqetr" w uouro'{1

3sal{l uoddns ppo^,\ l3rll:^otrue^r3lul J" l"p;; ; oolenJf, o1 ,;^;;,;""ru puoces s1I .1uaru,,(oldure ry r. :cnpe:ssecce uI uo!ru'sord ut ueuo'tr

"(q pecuerredxa-::ryq "!r

,{rrqnlr, "r';pr;;;;;;il :E^\ hr,ry\a, sIqJ .E002

r t002.__-,,an'ega,'erlnd dq peleurp-ro-oc pue (44g) ernseal^l uoruo/d roJ,q,re;bg'aq1 rq pep,rig *^'rrr*l e^rle4ruJ delg 1xe5i 'qJ :punor'4ruge doleaep o1 'eq1e3o1 {ro^\ III^' ue",o'r\Jo uorlelroldxe renxas pue r"r"i:t_lf-1"'

"'J,fffiiffT1Jd""#:iTii:I"'i;*t;:f;miur JJEIs eureqnu .eldoed 97 go sdnor8 eerril Jo qcee 01 suorsses Fu1ne4 a.ri*ou. o* ,",rri"i,l, peuueld q lI .puelorl .,{en} slueqcreplpue uouns '.puelerl sncoc 'dep^ l5 't"t"t'"'i

"q"-^og :"lr"i ';;;;1" u ,r"orora Iercos sprlo' glleeg .B.e suo4esrue'ro .,{re1un1oapue f:o1n1e1s uorJ JJetrs re1 apnlcur fir''n sdnorS ,"a* ,qr "=r**", eql Jo uoneni'^e r -{rearlep .Buruueld oql pue srerrereru Jo

luerudoyenap er' se^ro^o' lceford "q1

':""p'nora

"r1,,,"r ;i,{t;;ffi pw IIDIS dn',a1acnpe

To*, ol sr lceford eqlJo rure eqJ .9002Jeqolso w Srncuo'ruroc 'poued qlto*-9 u re'ro peerds l"eford ioya n

"q IIp\ sq'gopnrlsorcr uJ ueuro^\ trlr^\ (.eceJrelu,, 1eq1 sercue'epue srept'rord-ecl^ros ol sleu*ues sqqtna:o selros pJo, rearlep p,rn ',r"*Jo1"^;o "qr";^;;;

ayru lsenber e^\ qcrq^\ rog lcetord eqaa^ll'Illur dalg gap eqr luo{ au;,rr""1'"q1 aur]uaura1a,'1i

a q] ],Ja u aq r |*' Mo q ::,^1*.{:fi ,,i llilffl fi i l;iil l::lTfl Tif# il,lT;,uo , ,,uJil:'i,}tJiffi,,3#1,:'lt *l:i:,:t:'fl i:'i1'b" ar se req,os seqod ue qprl-ureqq e seuo: re snbe rlrlre leqoqd,, ori iqrolrrr]'LJ,",i.u;;;J;_'J;r?,'J:ffiril:

r::;-^*M'uo4nlqsord ur uourolr ro qn^^rr ^,1 ^r n..^r^^- ^

']q6nos sr 1uer6 aql Lr)fr,* rol asodrnd aql frerap ur aqr,)sac'iebe qprerrer e seluoap up lrnlqq ep,odsn# ,, .,n ,rru'iqrro1u, Jleqqer .t

s;esodol6 q)Jpasau pue 6ulure{,uot}e)npl of uot}elal ul [;uo asn JoJsluerD q)leasa5 pue 6ulule{,uot}ernpl Jo auaqls $) trIEVaapq6;e1sn6e eupr1,6 r,rqrrrp,g ,rrboir op urgque pfgslq alapqblel snbe euryrtrg ,sreqleapto spluoagu eu ulgl5 (V) E{=m5

Page 15: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

'eroq posn uoeq s€q e^qeqlql ISN oql u{ pa^lo^u lsoc .{cuetlnsuoc eqJ

:eloN

*

ZVz-'Oaz-/dW*6

o.eo:el9s&s*r$

psodo;rd $I!p wl ps+senbe.U fw@o@vleofor4 aql Jo lsoJ papurgsg IEIoI

0993000-T508s'ga0d0Ti508s'8I3

Sutunura.t aour4v{

IBlolqnsparJnos fpue;p lunoru17 ssa.I

uorlucrrddy slql ul lq8nog luno{uv ssafarurusrSor; aql Jo lsoJ palurrrqsg IEIoI

Ja{ro^r uolluJ}sluFupsuolssos 9 llB toJ slnopuBH Tr elnqrorg .3u1gu141 .uo4erlsrururpf

suotsses Suru.roru 9 .ro3 EurloluJ ? onua1,{ep rad 0SZ?@ sdup 69 JoJ luullnsuo3

ruojj suotlelonb asol)ua asPald

9 uteLl)enlInJ ' le6e qpteret g

'lqbnos lueio oq] rol sburlso) r. ,^l;i'lr1tffi:l';r::ol]'seleJjet,p al qupt toel aqltejq]glos eu ou Jltoor4lleJuor D4-....

ele stpluoap ue stetsor.lt re ltoql op al lleopuorru J|eqqqil

0sffeE)

a^oqp paqrr)sap lesgdord oql ol uorlelar ur lr{6nos rueJ6 aq} ro }unoue aq} olpls aseald

-nlsenql er6ol uc slal rlpleu p6e 6ro; g tlnlqq c sreluosp u€ rrrl1s llotll op al so;1 al rleqq#i;

'fu,@f"q '+qoqEnorry'roldc4'c pw Jap.g6{ }s€r"rFG$GI eqt Ed ssrrB.q etFEoq

" Eo peno+iauE oq 1g*r ssa:g@:pue

peieo$Q4 eq gT4a s,eilepead+d p@EEIg #E,q.s Jp s*e.(Wq.wr Isryo ,{q 4_.Ee4a xsq.Er p,qnoddnss(eurBqn Jo uo,gser-xp aq;;rspirn pe.Fo,rd oq1 a8urarew ITr^d Jep.EsI p+ford s,v dolpug {e; .s1ry-$OoH+X'rolcenq

ipabeueru aq lralord riql llrM MoHL Dllsluleqq e lepelsuotl up relueapu e seuo) 't

Page 16: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

01 II€o ot{^\ esoql puB ('sree}unlo,\ JJels '}usr.uedeuer\ 'cog)

leuuoiled etu?qnu :rurpnlcur sesltuelo eql esn oq.!\ IIv :luoruqslqrnJeulsenber slili roJ slseg eqt sr qorq,^A {roM

6ursle; sseuerp,/rte eqlJo enur^ ,rq tgeueq plnoqs uollnlrlsord ur uoruom .rele.r\orl .,{laieu.iri1n (c}e uorleruroJur .Fur11l>1s-dn)tgeuaq 1lr.,ra

sluedrcrued eql pur (cle sleuel€ru firyenb q8rq acnpo:d ot ,qillq€ .s8ur.les leroueug) ]goueq llt^\ uollssruu8ro ue se €tueqnE :luaurdrnbg

::ii ii-'.T,::: :: :: T iill:l:t, I, I i I 1': : :: : : l:i'Ilo,\\ e,{\ tlcltl,4\

ul luaurllo.rr1ua aqt Sur,rordurr ur Surlsrsse snq] splupuetg ,(1a3eg T {t1eeg pelrnber leeur o} leplo trr palnber st }lo,\\ luetuqstq]tgal eqJ

',{aiu*of a.tr *ou,*tir,^ uatuo,\\ otl} }uaueq.{1ate*rr11n ,,,^ ;:,",,:'T;i:ilf}'ssauo,e,\\€ ur uorledrcrued rno leqt sr edoq lno puu .ueruo.nt sso,rddo leql ^]elf ,os ur se.ulJJl l l ls pue sacrpnle'rd'sepnlt l le eql oJuonUut

ol l lo,\ \ e.,n, s.{es luetuolpls LlorssrLu lno sV 'aleudo.rdde alarl .n Sututeol lno a-Ieqs pue uorlelroldxa lJ[[unJ,(uc ol rueql Sursodxa

inoqlr,{\ ,seolo.\ l reql luesa.ldar uec'}cafo;d e se'a,r ier l l lu€uodur st } l

-suotssncredar }noql l ,{ t sacuauadxa l letp lnoqe leads lou rter

,{aql laag ueluo,r\ lsour pue eur8rls palelJosse oqi ol enp,{}atcos lno Luo{ lttesqe al€ uotlnltlsord3o sacuet:adxe q}t,{\ ualuo,\\Jo eclo^ 3qI-qll.\\

I-lo,\\ e^\ uetuo,rn aql lJaJJe qctq,\\

senssl uo ,{1cllqnd 1no >1eads osle ot lnq uolleu"LloJur eleuluassrp o1 ,(1uo 1ou ,{trltqrsuodse.r aql }l qll,\\ satxer uot}tuSooer stqJ 'anssl etll

uo,{1uoq}ne ue se pazruSo3er etuo3eq eleq e,r\'uoqnlrlsord ur po^lolul ueruo,t q}r,tt,{l1ecr3rcads 8ut>lro,tr puelall ur lcafo"rd ̂ luo aql sY

luauldlnbfl

. )

'a6e1uenpes|p6U|l l ]e}o}a]uaJa+al leln]|uedq}iM^i lunuu?{E

aLll l ! ]auaq l l tM it ̂ or. l pue ̂ ] tunuluol le)ol aql ut ̂ ] l l l lej aql lo+ paau al l i { ;realt a':j5eu8rs puu ldeurdrn6a :aqsrn8urlxe 5rg lerrirbeiSurteqjin4 l:keuHrs p:irrnba: qlti\\ tIxa,{cueSraue ue SutqsqqelsE

ar

:SS'''ir r IVSOdOUd rNVU9/SVrNOtHq UV INI)SlUlVr

'uorleluaunrop slrll lnorlllrn passalord oq IOI|UE5 pax$ f;luaueuredoq ol s! leql luaudlnba rol ro tuauqslqrryar rol suoller11ddy:rNvluodrul

'oas Bpegru!)lop ue uP6 lrgaslglqd e uenq ()6

-r'&opu,' e uo srusrueqcaur 3urso1c73"'""1H:[i,:"'ff'1,THiil:liT:::::H*fffj'ip"::3;'i'fif 3rt;'jf[:':ffi""J::::1-eqlJo eruos luaueldrur o1 pe:rnber sr {ro^\ 1u",lrqi,qrry"l'pesolcua - (EOOZ) 1,pny,f1agng T rllleeg JggI eq}Jo s8urpug eqt uo pase}'

luaI'uqslqrnJau

GaOZtIOOZ gode; leruuarg erueqn1 g1 a8e6 salduexe) sasueteJuoJ ut uotledtctlte6(pasolcue - r1AZlnAZ uode; l€tuuerg etueqn1 g1 e8e4

s{'druexe) secuelpn€ l€il-ra}xe Jo uotlcos-ssorr ept^\ e ot sdoqsryol ryJuo}leluessrd .(s3us^ elnpeqss ) s^eo tsulul€l,IJJelS .

("ree,{7s.{up lpU Z + sq}uoru 6 rog 8utuele,,(epsrnql lslg) s,{eq Sururerl realunlon ruoqecrldde

sn{} Jo 6 ryg se8ed uo pellelep :e^I}pttltq de15 1xe51 eq} urorJ Sutureal oq} 8u[uaueldtul ':bUrur€JI/SUISlex SSeuele/Y\Y

Jsuuecs 'E

ereusJ lellSlc 'i

l3lrr.^ eu cJ 't

relnduroJ do1de1 'Z

rolceford Erpell lr l lnlN'I:porlnbau luaurdpbg Jo lslf aql roJ sasn UISIAI :paJlnbau luorudlnDfl

^aoloq alqq aql u! palBclpu! sB {ro^a BuIulErIpug 3u!s!By/ssoueru,!rv.sl! iloddns ol papaau s! Lqql lueurdrnba Io e8uur u Sulsuqr.rnd spru^rol 1'toddns

'l{6nos st }ueJO aq} Ll)tqM lo} asodlnd all} lte}ap ut aqtrlsag'Iene qprerler g seluoap up lrnlqq ep rodsn)5 up J? selunLl)uott i l l leqqet' f

qltslal al gle quelPorql re 9u ryrngrllqle re srelerre! r!p!91!N :11)y1|*)vHgvl

|;l uraroHrsvil/tvsvil^E_____.J

f

f] urrunno/utlNtn'drqsraunno

lo +oold aprnord aseald routrAg lt 'aseal

1o fdor p ]ruqns aseald raploqasea'l ]l 'sasrurard

]o raploqaseal ro laumg ]t a]e)lput asealdleqlglolis e elqleajlauln seul:ll.ilnl) ue?p rlgulfl s9t! sn6e'seal

uap dtg) q)palst ln) lesegl sel^l 'qqlrllg ue Jeseal gu lgutn !l sgu llotll op al soll al llPqqel

slesodord 1uauqsrqrnlag pue luaudlnb:l ol uollelal ut dluo asn to3nuloq)Lllv sn6e queleajl al uueauleqq e jeloor{l op uleLlule plgsfq al

sluerg luauqstqlnlau pue luaudrnbl jo auaqls IiIIETUEInlj|ol{)Ll}v sn6e quelealql op se}uoa0u eu Lulgls mETm

Page 17: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

f - -L/ -/t--\/U

aq l re ] leaB P ie L l io i l l uvsry"/r ry

7oo' /20 uor1eredar6 6 6urddinbjuPqrnqlul ln g l l ls la j

).yFEl/ 6 / eooT 4"5 L luarirqstqrnlau /uotle^ouaun lr I oq)qlv/u e q) e n uLllv

s)aaM +o laqurnNpaleutlslJelsPaqul

e urPlq)eas uollalec ueis

aqlrPsol elec

pauueld tnoii rol alets-ault] papadxa

lo uMoplparq paltelap e anrb asealdaql!PUeaq gle lPpelsuorl

uop relseaqut e eue asqultaj lue re l toql op al nleapuoil .rr Ieqqel

loidI)A

'pCIpu,nJ seM )JoM a,ql ujoqMpu:e pelels UoM aq,l uaqM ale)pur asea;d 'luauqsrqln+ar pasod:ojd uo paruout.rrJo) s€q )JoM tl

Ilu0)H[@SSrif@&c.+@Bnb ssF]e]* #cetd .]qi6nos prut6eql lq s$up*oa 3o ,FeFte+6F ornr6 16616

'seterJ,elrp +l .rB,eB!,,r9,€* _gt#Ip}wgg,s ekr qH JrroawBftlo)

r@og:ruaw.* ,&

:lueuldpbg

,9M9$E6{re961'V? -?

-a'^gry- pogfl?qap psode;$ aql ol uo-t+tetto! trt++6norug4 aiug tu,pue jrk& o-+,e}s 9ugeru0_f5*&9619,7? :luemqslqrrg-uIgg't't :ueuOron!

:''uer,+epdwoq o+ wfeld.epp #o $soe $$Se:]epl pe+eut4gse enrg

apabeueu aq uaford slql lltm MoHantlstuleLlq e lepplsuoll ue Jeluegpu e seuo] .t

:oihp!'n uftirp l4qq+qet& e }spe].urst] ue ,HE[t+D rcplE*;B$sBt4-{c5 rtFper ea 4,ts]EF[e{ .g

Page 18: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

, a

uolleluaun)op Fuluoddns luenalar raqlo fiuedgqsreuano ;o;oord ro aseal ;o fdor

slrelap lunorre 4ueqale)lliua) a)uereal) xel

Jaqunu rt4reqr Jo xelfdor e qtepe esee;d'rtressarau s! uolssllu.rad Fuluueld ]l

auoq)s slrllrapun sluer6 snonerd ol uolletot u! alnllpuadxe lo luno))e

laaqs alueleq pue sluno))e lua)at lsolu aql lo fdot esrag;ddns ro sroperluo) luoll suollelonb

lurol uollerldde pale;duor Aglnl e

:uo;1erg;dde rnof 6u;g;uqns ato]aq

,/,/,/,/,/,/,/,/,/,/,/,/

O uolleulolu; Fu;rurollol aql'1uena;ar ll 'papnltu! a^eq nor{ 1eq1""ilil;,lj

.? ullqno'pPoU ;;dsap 6i l€n

'u1611qury u46'srlellv lqreilaeg pue lernu 'fillunururo3 lo ]uauyedag

'syoddn5 {lgunruuol j fuepn;o1

:ol papjermolaq plnoqs uolletuaunrop Eugyoddns qlrrn taqtaFol ruro; uo;1er;ldde pala;druo1

M:awauorlesruebrg ut uotllsod

:pau6;5

'asodrnd teql rol fues-sa)au se 'splolal pue sastuatd q! ol ssalle l olle ol pue nuabe sl! Jo ]uauueda6 aq {q paroluoru lesodord eqtburneq o1 alqeaalbe ate sluertldde aql'VgU);o luaupeda6 aql ulo4 slue:6 raqlo {ue o} }uau}ulluro) ou sanlonulil te$'tue.rb e lo ple/\e aql ro; uolllpuo) e se'ldar:e osle l'€002 pup Z66t RrV uorleurolullo rxopaall aqltapun panbal uo alqelte e apeu aq {eu uorgerrldde s1q 6ur{ueduo:re ro ur parlddns uol}eulo}ur }eq} pue}slapunosle I

'6utpun; butptxa a:e1dar ol pasn lou pup palep asod:nd a-ql rol pasn gfl 1snu papre Ae spunl fiue leqy abpa-f^ oulre 1

'a6papnoul {ru;o lsaq aq ol qldldurol pue anl} t wy6{stqtulI upd te paueu palotd aq] sprpMo] ]uerb B rol dldde "'.-rt:.

uo!les!ue6.|oaql u! [1;1;q;suodsar ]o uolllspd e Eulpgoq uosJod e Aq pala;druor aq ol

3ary

NOTIVU\n)lO 't luvd

Page 19: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

slra Inq) qlepeal 'r | t) lorip asteuetqtr uoeplr l lpoJtautn seufqlnjql uap au spgl uop dlo)

)uteq stPlunf, leJuosrl)pupq) q6ll larrut nluqtutap

el.{ leuequeq} ou q)eugq) Jlqutrn

l!orltop al sral q)ealsl ap dror ln) ,elgupa;d pear al 96 -el -eu

eas ruta)s utoP;aquroJ seqljen| p steluoap al Jlptptu slptl)ealre) selun)

rpupgp s! aqlteprotfruo) rglqr uap sn6e stelun) eu ep dlg>aqllerqlglos ou !r loaqlleruo] eu g uleq)enl

upltuotrl oE aqlleugpluro] glp stelelret tul lol

:q)ealst Jnq) e sPlel ler_l ueqlutoj qluea,| le ues spueal p oas seloa-l ue trnlqq o6 l loq1 op al ap al$utl

sra; ptel 6e

VlSOll)lrs

'? qlellf eqlv al!e8' ,Fdseyg ,eqlgg 6V t EV

,elq)elraee sn6e aqlrenr,rlpqod,"#ffiTiXJ:$'llPqod g eq)euoac !elq)o!erel

:6gnqr qpeloaqs e selelret ueslgdlgqr uoeq al uoerelu at{}leugFlruorl} steleJjel rurloq, uE Jrgtl} eg

:p]90

:1q :o ;e rbegues- / -1

(plgsl P Pq)Parlrpolq UPD):aqllu!s

,

.i

'Pl|!elp gP snbe qqtrte-u 9p

'96 st leu 'oas PqloJJ) eu unq) Ur?qqeql e urelqlo; q:eb snbe lut)sl:lpl up Je lll)eajroleuou.r urequlorubP 9u uuroU uP qpleluegpu ob elsgs lllgqurPlt{ pu gI'9ldt auurog eu prnql ap alta seluoap uoe q}tal r se;6uea:

al as uueaulPquJ LllPu'lpeaql e sPluoap qlral r lloJuuroq) leu'ursrajl slal ute)plg't002 sn6e 1661 astaustpllleloeqs un Puuelpvq PuloejltiplPjiel lP jpt{}9loqs s oas SP}PJJPI uP slal }qlPaula ut g}e ou'rt re}6nq} e stgustpql

uqP llple+pealqq o0 ursrarl urtQtqL;teqtql lopJ.uup gle Jlsn al rn) unq) se plgs! lealutpqu q:eu snfu Jeqlglss eure

:lEr_H&P!g.T :,'*t119p..9T,..9;F!f,Y.l-9?rta;qt1e:6 o6 urlequp.y'sPloa-u al epp+ quoqr ayrol sn6e ro4 oas' . . . . . . u a 1 . . . . - l . - . r - . . 1 ' * r * , l - . . i ' ! r ' ! : I I

f"g,Fnht F].-.}&tEsetg.ruigdnlqq ob uLreqqreap snbe I 6p16 | aqtruurure gle lppprsuorl up qlratp-rp selejret q'tffiueb_p 6e"' "' . .. .. asutpl

(edr;rq6 ue urule) uuear Jprll

elq)er6ear+ utqptal llnlqq e aurnp 6e qruggqruot a-l

nHgUV:fOv oln)

gu a61e trqroger6ea ues

Page 20: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

sr!€i lV lqle] la*r j pue

Iptna 'Al tunu!LuoJ

Jo ]uaLulredagelLPellaeg sn6e

aqllenl'l leqod leqlgug uulou uv

druels alegeduets elgq

'suollestue6rg frelun;o11 pue Agunuruo) poseg-rfi1ero1 rol sluerg lo auuer6or6 aqt ol uo;1er1;dde rnofi;o 1d;arar sa6pa;rnoul]e

rtqeraq sulv{Jv rH)vrltvg oNV Tvunu 'AfiNnwwo) to rNll tluvd]o aql

lleqod sn6e eqreuoaq elllfly;e1qro;er6ef,p seluoaq rgpl) uop selertpl,pseqypnlqq rn6 oas slal VI;{)VI13V9 SngV tHlNnI 1tvggd IVHIgND NNTOU ue uuolequpv

syoddn5 [4unuuo) pue Arelun;o11fq pelalduor aq ol uolpas sSlIlleqod sn6e eqreuoa6 lelq)olerel6e quglqruo) al oas plnqr uV

'uogler;;dde

tno{;o ldlarat ;o luaurabpaln oulle s,}uauiledaq aq} se no{ o} pauln}ol aq lln abed srql'a^oqe paprno.rd areds aql ul ssarppe pue aueu tno{ (51y1ldvl ))019) 1u;rd aseold

'fayrel,p sequenlqq tnb auutop pu lrequpp Jeu lebnqr sre re oas q)eue{teal ue Jeaptn) 'spnq}(*J 1-el re equnl g1e sgds es qpploaLls op snbe uute op (VHlVlUIl)Olg) ltoqf op al q6lglJ *'

1ue4;dde aql Aq palelduor aq ol uo4las spll/rlgqyreg ue 6e Dugpltuor al oas plnq, ue gI

luaua6paF ou{)v/elgqupv lurloJluroJ

Page 21: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

8le3t ' i9-C9l+ YeJ l! r ig rx3 teset- i9-a!e. tal

I8f,r-ra13s€Iuotll I

'r{1aia:urs s.r

'eArlJsIIe Fls sr pu? ?-66I dj?nu?f *02 3rll uo pelu?r8.{peu6uo ss^{ uolldlxoxa sIi{I

gtt0I iHJ requnu aluers.;er,fuueqc lsPun (tgot 'lev xel euiorul 'ttt

uorleas dperu:oJ) L66l 1tY uorlepqosuo] sexEuoz uoTlses Jo SuxrEsw sql uil{il&\ ..{po

sasodJnd alq€lueq? roJ peqsrlqelso s€ pepre8a: sr,{poq pauoEuaru-e4oqB elll l?q} lIjr$uos I

',{,raa:goytr slnf JeeC

ffizwqryW

I{OIJ}$S ST&I{YHJ

'9002lsnunv q:0I

'6 ullqnocelpuortun.rg

'pnog qJBd etur3{asno11 Joluas

'aFa11o3 s,raollug IIV'{aaa.rg1141 la.ruB-tu 1,q

ai{3uuErv plHqolql'o3

q3?'.iow uvsiele'H l0f$q eN

sr 03rli!ll?.lBpJV u?. u guuEU

uJrelUol jli?utsRUio38 eu Stttg

fieradd{!'03qSe$ai{

s33!J+0 lUeUJUj0n0suo!srnlG s,lejauaS'i0l3ail03

sraliclssrujuroS srue^au eq: l0 a3i];0

{effij.

' )

3l'3i]U3li3j'i'IiiJrtrl F€ snuaAaH:t-

tt,1?.fF.

Page 22: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

L

900erdv ql6r

oo09s9g !o:seulnbuS

U,3 !L l_ i i F t' t"iUJr\3[f

ssajppe e^oqe aqi oi apcuj aq pii-roqs aiErii luas slqi oi Euriela.i sorjailQ

I3uisrg AttC LIUoN uorOag ullqngqcuAl ppaley\

'pa]tnbal st alecUIUaO acue;eal3 xel e Jo uorlcnpo.rd araqM saouelsLuno:rc {ue ut pasn aq{eul a1ect1llao slq} '( asn st a}e3r1ua3 aleledas e qorqm rot L00e

'}3V ecl}Jo 3llqnd ut sprepuels aql urorl pedy

'JApJO

ul a]e sJtPJJe xPl suos.l?d aq1 1eq1 rrlryuoc oI anoqe paupu uos;ad oql ol penssl sl alecryuaC acupleal3 xet s!ql_

9OOZlZlrL :trlun prtPn:JeqtunN ales!l !ua3 xel

alec!lruac acuBrealS xel

udv

tit

t

VIgUVHgTH6 N I I B N C

CU YUVd f3VU93931103 S, l ' \Ol- lVH l lV

3 S N O H U O I N f SrSSnoud s,Nft /$of i v l^tvHnu 3HI

,)

I ul lqno19 11euuo3,gld6 9976

sestnj 6s Jer!olsnctcptslg AlO qrop uorbeg urlqng

qcu{1 peglreyl

l I l

t t l

rc roN3slloN

-t .orr1 uorretrsroe5:elonb esee;d ecuepuodselioc 11e u;

t l

Page 23: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

, l ;

900e qal ql8

ooossgS LO:seurnbuf

anLrSAaH r, -,

ssajoop a^oqe aur o l aoelu aq ornous a ieSl l ruaS s lq l o l 6ur letar souano

ioulsrg AllC qUoN uor6ag ullqncqcu{1 pealten

pollnDaj sl ale3lJluo3 acuelBalo xel E ]o uorlcnpojd alaqM saouElstxno:rc {ue ut pasn agdeul alectltpao slql'(pesn sr ale3rpuo3 aleredes e qrq^ rot t00Z'l3V aculo qlqnd ur spr€puels aql u_ro.rl yedy

' 'Japja

ul aJP s]leJ+e xe1 suoslad aql leLll ul]lluo3 ol anoqe paueu uos:ad aql ol pensst st aleclllua3 a3ue1Eal3 xel stq_L

LAOZE|S - iriull pilefi

:raqunN aleculue3 xel

ate3!l!ua3 asuerealc xe1

t l -. / -

. 6 "N t tgnocu yuvd f3vu9

f9 f l lOC S i {O l lVH l l v

I3SnOUd S , Nfl lo,tl Vl^lVHnU 3Hl

. r ullqno1g ;1euuo3,g rdn 9116

tcl.rlslg ̂ 1C qyop uolEeg urrenqqcuiil pegLreyy

I | . lt l lt t l

t t l

r E - - v , r J v r 4 v , r

' .' lI) :o1r1 uor1.e'rlsrbeg:e1onb aseald a3uapuddsailo3 lle ul

I II Il l

3

Page 24: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

t00z raquarao lsIE p3ptrg rEaA

sluau.ralBls IB!JuEurd puE uodeu ,srolJaJro

srxEqnu

t.

Page 25: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

0r -6

8

L

9

9 - V

L

I

aBu4

slusruslels l€r3ueuu eq] ot s3loN

leeqs asueleB

lunocov arnypuadxg ry aruooul

serorlod Surlunoccy Jo ]uetuelelS

slaploqaruqs aqt ol godaX,s:olpnv

sarlpqrsuodsa5,slolcell(J Jo tueruelelS

pode6 ,sroloarrCl

uorluuuoJul rsqlo pue slolsellcl

s lualuoJ

utUEqnu

Page 26: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

I a8ud

.Z qIqNC'iaslis to88e6 Ja^{o-I

?uplarlJo lueg

'6 ullqng ,erpuoctumg.peou

{Jed eserc'3SnOH Jotuss

'a3a1yo3 e\{olleH llv'z ullqnc

'peou epl"lspv I I'oJ ? faugr;1 .f Ueqo.U

'6 ullqnc'eJpuoJcrunJC

'peou {red e3ero

, .asnog Joruss'e3+11o3 sinolleg IIV

^rl?c melqlexfre11e1g erelJ -sIAI

ue8ue1q,fteru .rS

IIo toNeclrepsrg.strAi{qftnp olueleru .sil[

,tneorgctr41 pre8re141 .s;41

3r{3ou rsJruuof .sIAi

uoe)Jw ouel.swfeyrrog surpleJsg .JS

,(opeg {e;tr .s141

rorruoS,o eullrroD .rs

. u/t\org.,9llnf -SIAI

..(uue; aJprreg

usqeeqs urlf -rcl

ue,ta suery euuv -JS

ue8roll Buuerlof .JS

euraeg euqdasol .s;rrg

uellnc emetr J .stlJ

uu8rsuol uqol .{Ai

eoqs ,o uoaJoN 'Js

dqdmf,t e11oqs .rS.r3lu?c ale)-ro

JorruoS,o euuv.JCdgegc4 3rrueg .rS

e{mg leretrey4l .rg

rolsT rrrae){ .tfl

uopuruJoJul raqlo prrB srolraJlo

sJe{usB

ssarpp€ sssursng

srollpnv

ocggo psrals€aX

roqumu fuuduro3

sro{Jo1\ pefor;

sJol3srrcl

JolleJrq pue uosradrreq3

srrr.Bqnu

Page 27: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

Z a?v<l

g00z AeN q16l :elBcl

rolcsrr(l Iol3erlC

^qornt{ €ir3r{s 'rs f11egcry orr.ueg 'rS

prBoq aql Jo JIBqaq uo

'tg6l '1oV sarueduro3 eqiJo (Z)0gl uor]oasJo suorsrnord aql qtl,r,r aoueprocoeul aJUJo uI anul luoo o1 ssau8url l r^\ J leql peleorpur eneq ' 'o3

ry.{aupry' f usqog'srolrpnu er lsrolrpnv

'rea,{ letcueug eql Jo pua eql acurs '{ueduoo aql 3ur1ca;3e sluana luecgru8rs ou uasq aner{ elaql

slus^g laaqs aJuBIEg lsod

"6 ullqno 'e:puocuru6

"peo-d {r€d ac€lC "asnog roluas "a8a11o3 s, &olleH 1V le peureluleur ale ,{ueduoc ar{l Jo tunooo€ Juqooq eqJ 'uollounJ

leroueug otll ol saornosar slunbape Jo uorsrnord aqt pue asrgadxa aleudordde qlL\\leuuosred Sutlunocce lualeduroc go luau, oldtua ar{} 'suorlcesuer1 Surprocar roJ selnpeoord pue sercqod,{ressacau Jo uor}€}uetualdrur aql aru }unooou Jo $looq radord Surp;e8ar '066

I '}oV sarueduro3'7g7

uouoas Jo sluetualtnbar aql qlrat eouerlduroc arnsuo ol sroloalrp aql .{q ua4e1 selns€eur aqJspJoJaJ Suglunorcy

'l3V aql q}In acuetldluos 3rnsuo ol uouce fuessecsu aql ue{el seq duedruoc eq} pue s-rafoldueuo slualuajlnber utzgac sasodur 6g6l lrv llolA lB ersJlelA pu€ qtlEaH '.{ia3eg aq1 'splepuBts,Qe3es

pu€ qqueq 01 oouareqpp lculs aqt q8norqt papren8a;es sr sae.,{oldrua s,.{uedruoc eql Jo Sureq 11a.r,r aq;

686I lrv IroA\ lB aruJJadl pue rIlIBaH'dtaJes

'uotlelol fq u8tsar o1 pelnba: lou ere sJoloe:rp aql uorler3ossvJo salcruv aqt JepullsJolJaJIo

'3rnlry slqeaeseJoJat{} uI fuedutoc eqi Jo suorlurado pu€ sarlrlrlle aldrculrd aq} a?ueqc o1 sueld ou ener{ slo}oo-trp eql

-0gg't9 i A se/( rua,,{ aql ro3 sn1fung eq1

'7997 rsn8ny-1o Qll eql uo lcaforg s,uauro1\ eru€qn5 eql uro{ srueqn11 o1 pa?ueqc sum,(ueduo3 aqtJo atu€u eql

'uorlnlrlsord ur uaruol\ ol eoln:as Surpuar-qaqe aleulpro-oo pue astue8ro 'aloruord ol ere sa,ulcafqo ureur aqJ '1e1rde3 eleqs e Sur,req lou pu€aaluerunS,{q paIull ,{ueduro3 € sr puu '.g66l requo^oN rgtz eq} uo palerofuocur se/'\,{ueduroJ aql

sluatuadolaAaO ar nf nd pus Ara-r^eg ssau!sng'f1-r,r.r1ry ledrrur-r4

'?00Zloqui33e(I lslI papue-rea,{aqtJoJ slualuslels lBrcueuu oq} pue podar;raq1 tuasard sJo}oellp aqJ

t00z raquareo lslt papua :eaz(

lrodar ,srolf,erlO

BtuEqnu

Page 28: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

E aAEd

rolseJr(J Jol3errcI

fqd;n6 upeqs 'rS ,{11e51c61 attueg 'rS

prBoq eql Jo JIEqeq uo

'saquuln8arrl Jeqlo

pue pne{ loe}sp pue lusnard o} eouel{ pue fueduros 3t{1 Jo s}ssss aqt pren8a;es ot ruaql o1 uado

ilqn,ro*", er€ se sdals qcns 3ur1e1roJ &lllqlsuodsar leraua8 aneq r(aqJ 'rtueduoc eql o1 alqecqdde

are ,{aql se JEJ os uI sluatus}"1s l?lcueug o1 3ur1u1el slsv ssoqi Jo suotsr,rord 3qj I8I1Y\ serlduroc

asr./$jeqlo fueduror aqi leql Suunsua rog alqrsuodseJ ere ,taq1 's1cy esoql qlvy\ ouo sE peru]suo3

aq 01 suorlglnflag IIe pu? E00Z oi t96I 's13V saueduro3 eql qil/tr ,{lduroc sluilra}€ls lelsu?ug

eql emsue oi uraql elqeue ol pu€ ,{uedruoc aq} Jo uotltsod lelJueuu aql erull "{ue }e fce:ncce

alqeuosear qlLlt osolosrp li3lqia lunooJe Jo s{ooq radord Burdaa>1 ro3 elqrsuodser arB sJo}33'IlP eq,I

'sssulsnq uI enulluos 1lan,{ueduros eI$ l€ql

arunsard ol aleudorddeur sr 1! ssalun srseq tus3uoc Suto8 aql uo sluslualels Islcueug aqt eredard -

iuaprud pu€ alqeuoseal er€ lPql s3]etullsa pu€ sluaura8pnl elEru -

flluolsrsuoc rual{i.,{ldd€ ueql pue senllod 8ur}unorce slqellns losles -

.;o1 partnbar e:e slol3-ellp-aql'slu?t+alels Islsueug asoql Suuedard u1

'Po!.rad ]€q] roJ fuedruoc

er$ Jo ssol lo lliord aql Jo pue ,{ueduroc aqt Jo slI€JJ€ Jo olets eq} Jo ./vroll JIeJ pue srul e ant8

qclq,n, pouad Islcusug qoee JoJ sluslrelels Flcueug aredard ol slol3oltp aql saltnbel me1 fueduro3

sluaurelgls tglJusulJ ,sJaploqaJgqs eql loJ seg[tqlsuodsar ,sJo]JeJ.I(I Jo ]uaulalu]S

Errruqnu

Page 29: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

t r f iEd

'slu3{.u3lels

[?IsuEuq eq] ul uol]€lluoJulJo uol]€luesajd eqiJo,{3enbepe llele^o aql pelEnl€^e osle e,!\ uorurdo Jno SuruuoJul 'loxe lo ^lueln8axl leqio Jo pne{ ,{q pesnec leqlaq,r\ 'lueruelBlssrui

leualelu I'Uo{ oe{ eJe slusruo}Bls

Ietf,ueug eql ]Eq] aouplnsse alqu uosear a,,r3 oi ecuepr^e luet3uJns qlr,4,\ sn eprno:d ol replo ur ,,{,resseceupeleplsuoc e,ry\ qJlq./yr suotleueldxe puz uor]€uiloJu1 eql [[e ur€lqo ol s€ os Jrpne rno pauuo3rad pue pauueid a16

pesolosrp ,{leienbape pue parydde ,{lluelsrsuoc 'secuelsrunorrc s,,,{ueduroceql ol aleudotddu are setctlod Surlunocce eq] reqleqi\{ Jo puu 'sluatuele}s

[ElJu€uU ar.ll Jo uoqereda:d aq1uI slol3ellp eql {q apeu sluauaSpnf puE se}eurlsa luucgruSrs aql Jo luarussasse uB sepnlour osle lJ 's}ualuale}s

letoueug 3q] uI seJnsolosrp pue slunotu€ sql ol lu€^alar ecuoptne 3o 'srsuq lsal p uo 'uorleuRupxe sepnlour lrpn€

uV 'preog seclloeJd Sutltpny aqt .{q panssr sprzpuels Surirpny qlr,4^ eouupJooce ur }rpn€ Jno palcnpuoc elAuolurdo lrpnB Jo slsuB

'lr urqll{\ slueruelElssIruluarzdde {ue 3o ere,!\€ eurooeq ervr ;r godar Jno roJ suorlecrldrur eql reprsuoc pue godar ,sloloaJrp eql p€a: ei

'uooel

Jno uI uolleurloJut qons epnlout 'elqectlcerd eraqrvr 'pue ue'rr8 lou sr suorl3esuell ,sloloelrp pue uorleraunulaJ,srolcallp Surpre8er r're1 ,{q pagrcads uorl€urroJur .{ue 'uorurdo Jno ur Jr sraploqarer{s aql ol godar a16

suJnlsl puE]unooceJo s>looq eql qlr^\ luatuear8e ur eJe lunooJe ssol pue lgord slr pu€ looqs acu€leq s,,{ueduroc eql raq}oq^\pue llpne mo Jo sesodrnd eql JoJ f;esseceu suorleueldxa pue uoquuroJul oql lle peurelqo oneq a,^d. laqler{/t\el?ls 3^'1 'uotltppe uJ -sluar.ualels

lurou€uu: sql qlr^\ lualsrsuoc sr podal ,srolceJrcJ aq] ur uerrr8 uorl€uuoJur aqlJaqleq/t\ pue l,,{uedtuos al{l 3o 3ur1aa1q FleuaC f:eurproerlxA ue Jo Suruenuoc aql Suutnber uorlenlrs lerJueugu slslxe areql 'alep laoqs e3ueleq aql 1e 'raq1sq.r,r l,{uedruoc aq1 ,(q 1de1 ueaq e^eq }unocoe Jo $looq radord:uorutdo -Ino uI taqteq,t no,,( o1 godsr oslE aIA 't002 ot t96l slJV sarueduo3 eql qlL\\ o3uepro3c? ur parederd,,{1;adord eJp pue .&eIA JIeJ pue arul u anr8 s}uetualels lercuuuu eql mqlaq,^A ol se uorurdo rno no,{ o1 godar a7q

'ruop8utll

pallun eql pue puelall uI pleog saollceJd Surlpny eql,{q peleSlnurord sprepuuls Surlrpny pue queualnbarfuo1e1n8ar pue 1z8a1 lu€^eler qll,r aoueploooe ur stueuelels lercu€ug eqt lrpne o1 sr ,{111yq1suodsar rnr

'splepuuls Suqunoccy qslrJ pue me1 alqecrldde q1.nr aJu€plo3o€ ul slusuralels lercueug eqlJo uorleredardeql roJ alqtsuodse: eJu sroloarrp s,.,{ueduroc eql sarlrlrqrsuodsar ,s:o}oalrp Jo lueualu}s el{l ur psqucsap sV

srollpnE puB srolrar!p Jo salll lrqlsuodsar a,rg1cadsa11

'paulloJ a^sq a^\ suorurdo srlt roJ ro 'godar slql loJ '>uo,rrr lrpne rno roJ "{poq

e sE sraploqsjeqs s,xueduroceql puu fueduroc aql u?t{l raq}o auo, ue o1 {lqrqrsuodsar aurnsse ro }dacce }ou op aA 'rlrE1 fq pagruued lue}xa}seilry eql oJ 'asod:nd laqlo ou roJ pue podsr ,sjolrpnE ue ur uroql ol eluls o1 pa:rnbsr ar€ e.& slaileu esoqtsJaqlualu s,.,{uedruoc eq} ol e1e1s lq8tu e/y\ leql os ua{Euapun uaoq seq {Jo/K lrpne JnO '0661 'lcv sarueduo3aql Jo [6 ] uollcas q1r^{ aiu€proJcu ur {r{poq e se 's'taqruour s,r(ueduroc aql o} ,{1a1os ep€u sr godar 'srq1

'9 a8ed uo lno ias sarcrlod Surlunocce aql puu uorluanuoc lsoc IBOUolslq eql repun pareda;d uasq3lerl slualuelsls l€roueuu eseqJ 'selou pelelel eiil puu laaqs ocueleq aql 'luno3ce arnlpuadxe pue euocul aq]asqduroc qolqil t00Z requreoa6 ls i t papua reaf aql roJ eLueqn5 Jo sluatualels leroueug eql pelrpne e^Br{ al6

utuEqn6 Jo slaquralN aql ol l rodag ,srol lpnv luapuadapul

BuJsqnu

Page 30: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

s 33Bd

goaz AelN r{i6I :elucl

'z utlqno'p?ou aprBlepv I I''srolgpny

paralsl3ag ry6sluulunorly paJauuq3

"oJ ry ftypfX 'f uaqo5

=-: V \:.'.;:-\i "'' 4:' "'';-,-f *u'[-,)f

Ll _{ ,! i_t

'slueuralEls lur3uuul] eq] qir/rl luolsrsuoc sr godar ,slolsellp eq] ut ualt8 uolletruoJul eql uotutdo Jno ul

al€ sluauroluls lBrsueuglno Jo sasofund aqi ro;

']unocJe Jo $looq sql l{lv!! luauaot8e ut

aql ',{uedruoo aq} ,{q lda>l ueaq a^sq }unoocu Jo qooq radord 'uorurdo Jno uI '}lpne

,{ressacau Japrsuoo or\ leq} suoqeueldxa pue uolluru-toJul aq} Ite psule}qo a^Eq oi6

qliivr acueproccu ur pa:edard {padord uooq e^eq pue pepuo uelg'

lslE le su srreJJe sfueduroc eqlJo alels aqlJo /v\oIA JIeJ pue arul

't002 ot t96I stov saruedruo3 aqlreaf aqr:o3 sn1funs stl Jo pue t00Z raqur3oe6le anl8 slueueleN luloueug aql uotutdo rno uJ

uoluld6

panuguor EruBqnu Jo sJaploqersqs aql ol lrodar ,sJollpnz loapuadapul

BurBqnu

Page 31: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

g aABd

lgotd aql ol poSreqo eje

'aleleJ,teqt qcrq.r,r o1 po!:ad 3ql uI 1uno33e ssol pue

uorsued 'eIueLIOS uorsuad uoqnquluoc peugsp e sep-rsdo dnor8 oql

slo$nqlJluoJ rolstrad

'lue{Ilel€]s /l\ou qse3

e psredo-rd lou seq I'sluarualels ^\olC qse3:t S)IC qll/v\ asuepJosc€ uI'eloJaJel{l pue 986i }3V(luaurpuaury) ssruedruo3 eril Kq tno les ,{ueduroo llutus e JoJ euotu3 szIS aql s]aolu ̂ ,{ueduroc aq;

'lueural8ls ^rold qsu]

:sit\olloJ se seAII InJesn palcadxe lleql la^o snle^ Ienplse-fue ssel slesse poxg eql Jo uonenl€^ to lsc3 lzur8Fo elil JJo elu/vr ot pei€lnoluc st uotlurca:da6i

slassv paxld a1q$uu;

'puelarl ul sluulunocov potepeqJ Jo elnlllsq aql fq pelelSnruord se 'przog splepusts Suqunoccy

aql Jo sptepu"]s Surgodar lel3ueug sql q4/r\ ,{ldruoc pu? uoquaauoJ lsoJ lecuo]slq aq] Japun.seldrcugd Suqunocce paldecce ,(11e;aua8 qll/$ acueploooe uI parederd eJe slusualels IeI3wuU eqJ

?u-rtrunoeey Jo slsBg

'sluauralels I€tcueug sfueduroc aql o] uollsle-t ut Isgeletu pereptsuoc

el€ q3rq/r stlIelt qlv( Surleap ur ,{1}ue}srsuoc palldde uaeq e^eq satctlod Sutlunocce 3uvno11o3 aql

t00z raqurera0 lslt papua ruea

salrllod Sulyunorry Jo lueuraluls

slsoc

Buruqnu

Page 32: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

'sluaualBls ls!rucuu

t a8sd

eseql Jo lrBd IBrSalq u3 uroJ 0I ol 6 se8ud uo selou eql

s00z,ientr q16l :elecl

ro]3srr(I

fqd:n6 elroqs'rS

'suoqerado Surnurluoc uor;,,{1or4ua sanuep srear{

JolsellCJ

.,{1le51cyr1arureg 'rS

pffoq sqrJoJleqeq uo

leroueug o^al enoq? oq] roJ sn;funs eqg

:

820 '9 t I

bLO, LOI

,96'L

3

g00z

8LS,8L7

8ZO.SI I

0sE's9r

3

v097,

rear{ at.

Jo pua lu tuno3ov arnltpuadxg puu auIoJuI

mef aqlgo

?urur8aq le lunooov arnlryuadxE pue aruoolq

rear( aq1 ro3 snld.rng

'002 requalaq It pepua ruaf aq1 ro;

lunoJJV a-rnlgpuadxg ry arroJul

BruBqnu

Page 33: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

8 a8sd

'slusrrraluls IslJusulJ assql Jo l.Isd IBrSalu! uB tuloJ 0t ol 6 sa8Bd uo salou aql

Jolcorr(I

E002,{BI tr q}6I :ale(I

Jolsorr(l

,{qd:n6 elrorls 'rS .{;1e51c11ertueg 'rS

prEoq 3ql Jo JIBqsq u(,

(1 a8e$ lunoccy arnlrpuadxg puu auro3ul

salresar pua p11dz3

slassu luaJJnJ loN

srrrosul psJleJoc

a1qe,{e6 s}unoccv

rua{ auo uqllna an

3u1J1u3 slunoruu : sJol-Ipa.I J

Pusrl ul pue lueq le qse3srolqecl

slassB lualJnJ

820'9 I I

8ZO.EI I

099'89

TgE,S LL6Z,EI

8L9,EAZ

vzE'g6lvst's

3t00z

8LS,8LT,

:819'8LZ

Z g L , I L

096'8S7AZ'Zl

avL'6vt

66t'ZtElv t 'L l

3vo0z

saloN

?002 requleJao [f ]8 s3paqs aruElsg

BtIIuqnu

Page 34: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

sluasajdal a8r€r.i3 uolsuod ar.{Jar.iJ 'soafoldtua aql 3o lcadsar ul

6 aAEd

'resf auo urqlrA\ anp IIeJ slunorus esoql

srolqa(I

'ggs'te? ol pelunorue puu.,(uzduroo ol{t txo{ enp suollnq!$uoo's;a8eueur luapuadapul fq plaq aJ€ stass€ s}! pue aulaqoser.uor{os uorsued uounqu}uo3 peugep e sslerado r{ueduor oq1

'c

slsoJ uorsued 'i

1.|':E,LLV

L88, Lozv'wlLa'szv

g

Etoz

:L I

g00z

?t00z

8ts'zg?

99S' te899'6tv69'6LE

g

?a0z

' I

vg0z

000'z

3to07,

slsoo uorsued raqlgslsos eleJla/lr lBrsossaueles puu sa8e16

slsor luourr(oldurg

:ala./( reaf sq1 Sugnp (srolcartp aql Sutpnlcut)

saa,{o1dua3o sJaqunu dlqluoui a8eranz eq;saartoldura Jo raqurnN

saafoldrug

'figeqc aqlJo slcefqoelq€lgur.lo e sr 1ca[or4 aql sE sesuz,{lqtqetl uoqexe] oN

sa$.I^!lJs dreulpro uo snldrns uo xEI

.. uorl€rsunr,uer F.rolrpnv:3u6reqc rage petep st snldrns Surluradg

eql 01 psDrujuroc eje

\\

spunJ onlua slt pue ,{poq

'z

:000:z

?002 raqruara11 lslg papua reaf

sltreuel"ls IBlJuErru aql ol saloN

EluEqnll

lgord 8u1luradg 'I

Page 35: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

0 I 33Ed

JolcoJrcI JOlCeJr(I v

,'(qfun4 €lleqs 'rS ^lleNcIN erllJeg'rs

fqgleqeqs1t uo peu8rs pue E00Z ,(elzrl {i6I uo prcog eql ,(q perrorddu ero^\ slusluelels Islclleug eql

sluaueluls IBIJuBuU 3o lu,rorddy '9

penuquos

t00Z raqtllere( lsIE papua ruaz(

slualuelBls IBIruBuu aql ol saloN

uluBqnu

Page 36: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

I I eSEd

::::-v96'L

6LI 'VLL

ftz'?099't08 Itaz'LE9L,V9to'62vtb'?l016 ' t I988 '0 t9 r0 '91tz l ' t Lv6v'v0lvft 'LlL88, Ll6v'69V

ETI,TSL

002'l8S l ' t ?IEZ

vrg'LtL

0s9' t9t

S9S.S99

289' l0 r6 : twZLVZ,V(,61'S

96E'8,v6'vlztb'8lbg's, lz'91;LZ'996EV,VLL L > L

9S9,Ef,z9z'6r,

s0r '628

99L, IZ7a6z

6VA'LAg

6Et 'V lEgV'016E9' t I Il lE '7s

000'00t,LZ '9 r l

lBef aql roJ snldrns Surluradg

irpunssa8-req3 Surseal

sa8req3 4ueg.{cuelunoccv ry }lpnv

$ac leuorssaJoJdIa^erJ T| lolotrAtr

auoqdala.lSursrgarrpl

saqddng ecg;g .---i

luaudrnbg ry sle/rd.eueU'slleda11a3u€rnsul T lusg

luaudolanaq s,ueruolAs1so3 SururzrJJJB1S

slsoJ uorsusdseuelss JJels

. arnl;puedxg

gLg'82

000'zrv l6 '6 t l091'0Ezts'El000'0to9g'v1.t000'9zl

3g00z

etuosur raqlosuoqeuofl

lsoralul itsodaq

sluel9l"lol

uorlepunoc 3ue'I uall

3lnou u3 pu?13{ -/ e-LT.,{trlenbg ''1sn13o ldaguaruoi6 ro3 firlenbg -/v\e'I 4t,ftrlenbg

''1sn13o '1daq

prsog t$l€eH €arv lxelssl(\ {lnoslsrul elqelFeq3 fueu:gq alqelueqf, eLfL

uoltmolau - ecl^lss sreJle1ll pu? uonBqoJd

esr^-rss SJSJIOIA pue uoqcqord

gg uorlres - prEog qllEaH eerv lsuo] ]segsluBJ)

atuoJuJ

3,007

?002 raquaraq lst€ papua -rea,t

lunof,JB arnllpuadxg pus eruoJul paltulag

EtuBqnu

Page 37: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

I

I\l}'!v! rr>J .r- 5-[;i

IIIIIIIIIIIIItIII

.!l"b

IABI trup dlageg zp {r1eag :Ag pa;edar6

:rlB(JZOOZ I]JdV.FZI

6 NI'Igfi(I

YUCNO3hlrruO

g3gT.IOf, SAOTTVH TTV

SSNOH UOINflS

VIAIYHNU

IV

NOIISSdSNI IIqNV OUYZYH

NO

ruodtrut/vaYl

lJruxz

Page 38: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

'ezls srqlJo e3gJo

ue aJBqs ol pe^{olle eq plnoqs see{oldue o/yu /tluo 'erntlurnJ ecgJo Jeqlo pus laulqes

3ul1g Eulpnlrxe tnq leqo pue ISep ecrJJo aqt ,{q perdncco Ber? aq} sepnlcul }eq1 's.le1aur

bssg't st uotlsls)lo/v\ ecuJo ue JoJ luaue'lrnba.I aceds ulnullulul eqJ :uolt8puaurxoJsu

'Irol iB allq,\ ]uatllenol.U Jo ases saa,toldue 3ql slclJlseJ

srq] 'padiuurc,(:en st qolll/!\ (3'ou utoo;) ocg3o uP oreqs seadoldu;e eelqJ :pJezBH

{ro^ aclJJo E 7

(ownqny lo tfi y q t su ods a't

ary s! slttJ)'uos:ad ]ualaduroc u ,(q peurelureul aq] o1 paou llt/i\ Eulnleqs eql

, (a7agloJ slriolloH IIV-{o {.lrpqrsuodsa} ary s! sryJ)

'pecelds; ro pauelq8rl aq ot peeu ropttJoc eql ut sprcoq-Joog eqJ :uollupuotuulof,og

IIB,^A aql o] peJnJes aq ol spe3u

pue lee/rt st sacllJo eqtJo lsoru ut Surnleqs eqJ 'prez€q du1 lelluslod e a:e pue esool

aJE sruooJ Jo Jequnu u ut pue JopIJJoc utetu eql 3uo1e spJeoq-Joog eqJ iplr-zep

8ur,r;aqs pue Joold Z'Z

'ece1d '{'lP ;ooc

B ur perols eq o1slecttueqf, llv '1euos:ad poslloqlne o] palslJlseJ sseoc€ pw pelsol eq

plnoqs tuooJ Jaltoq eq1 'aEe.ro1s JoJ pasn eq lou plnoqs uroo: srqi :uollupuaruruocoll

' l lJJo Eurplq ,(q raltoq 3q1 tllo{ surnq eAlecar ol srequeu

JJBts JoJ leuualod e osle sr eler{J 'pJezeq eJU ler}ue}od e asnec plnoc qclll^ 'LuooJ

str{} ut poro}s e:e slueEe Euluea;c pue sellddns ecUJO 'uo ueq/( sorn}e:adua} qElq {J3^

r.{oeeJ uec reltoq eqJ JJo peuJn} sr Surpaq aql ueq/n sq}uotu Jeuuns aq} Suunp JaIBl*

oq] leoq ol pesn Sl t{cttl/r\'LuooJ aEerols aql ul po}eJol st Jelloq Je}e/t\ V ipJvzep

ruooJ oJols I'z

prszuH lucrsfq6 0'Z

lrpnv pffzeH eueqnu

Page 39: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

.stxalqoJd Surlpueq lBnu?LLt asneJ plnos qslqM d,reaq iran a:e eLueqnu ul st \opulM

or{J 'puei l / raf iug 3urqc1ec3o,{tr l rqrssod qFlq e sr srt lJ 'uedo nopul^\ aql dael oi pasn

sl poo,MJo l3olq e'uedo z(els lou seop slel lo l salpBl eLI] ul ' \ \opul^\ eql :pJEZEH

s^{opuIAA I 'z

(snoy1o11 ilV ryln ssn)st1)

'sert l l l reJ telrol I Ie ul rs l€^\ Suluun; ploc pu€ loq eq plnoqs eraql :papuauuocag

.slellol serpel eqt ur sdet eq] ur lale,/!\ Suruun: loll ou sl eraL{f :prBzEH

slallol L'T

'loltuotu aql Uoddns ol pesn oq plnoqs pusls rolluotu V :papua1IIIuoJaU

'3u111e3 ueelJs eqt ul l lnsel plnoc sl t1l 'salrolsol lp auoqdelal

Jo Jeqtunu e ,(q peuoddns sr a3uJo s.eJnsl ut ueejcs:alndLuoc aq1 :pJBZEH

dn 1ag nqn 9'( .

(uot1o\v1,roet neA ary dn &u\uas uo sauryapm? nO,,l aLfi ol n/av'34 e o1'{1reilurs

dn tas eq plnolls dotdel eqJ 'preoq ,(a1e1e;edas 3 pue uollels Surlcop e qll,\\ papr,to.rd

eq oslB plnoqs dotdel B qlr/r{ parlddns sl or.l,,\\ eefoldura,{uy :papuauluota}J

'ureJls s,{a pue laplnoqs '4ceq ssnec uec doidel

eqtJo asn pe8uolo.l6 'sdofdel qtrrvr perlddns ele see,(o1drua30 requnu V :p.rvzeH

sdoldel S'2.

'c661 suorieln8ag (uorlecr lddy 1e:euag) IroA

te orgJle16 puB r.{lleeH '{1e3eg eq} ut peulB}uoc suotleln8e: nOA eq} q}l^\ eouellduoc

aJnsue ol pessessua"l eq pJnoqs uollels )Joiy\ nCn qc€3 'ere13 pue uol]roger eonpeJ

dleq ot ,srnopur,tt eql lle uo peceld eq plnoqs spu!lq elqersnipy :uollupuauluorau

'losn aql o1 uoJLuocslp sosnBs

uJnl ur Llclt{iv\',ttoput,tt aq} 8urce3 era,rvt seo,{o1due;o Jequnu e oSlV 'ueelcs eqi uo arc18

Sursnec ,(qereqf smoput/v\ or{1 SulceJ ereM s(l^lCA Jo reqLunN V 'seutlepln8

n6n 'V'S'H

eql qll/\\ ocu"ploccg ut dn ies lou eJe,,trr suol]slslJo/!\ 1CIAJo lequnu V :pJBzBH

suorlBls {roAA no^ v'7

F

HHBIBB3IIIII

\-/ IIIIII

I"l

lrpnv pr€zeH €Lueqnu

Page 40: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

aq] ur uepprqroJ {llJtJts 3rB Slueuela r{1t,4 sjeteeq 3tJ}3313

'Surppnq

:papuotuuroJou

(JalDaL! aLF ur tuau,tala u0 sr

araLT{! a'msu11) 'rJoor Surprs aqt ut petou se^\ Jateell 3u}cele elQeuod v :pJEzsH

eq] qll/h snssr

IJo^ etuBqnu

raleoq srrtrolg zI-T

'enssr s!r{t uo s^\oll?H IIV }J€tuo3 ot peeu ,(eu eruuqnu .JarUJo eJU

stqt Sutssncsrp luaserd 1e a:e e8elloo s,ry\olluH llV :papuaruruo)ag

.S?AJE

ur ace;d ur uels,(s uollcatep elg Jo rilJsle eJU ou sr eJeqJ :pJazBH

uollralap erlJ puB tulslB arrd ll-7.

Arsh lxau rraqt anp ilaqt uaqt swolloH llV rltt^ ssnrslp ot

paau 'stt4'ol1o17 pV .to{ starysm&u4xa atgf ary tlddns a4[ rady) 'seare Iro/v\ ar{} lnoq8no"lqt

pellBlsur eq plnoqs sreqsrnSurlxo orrc '3'e lueudtnba 3ur1q8g aI3 :papuauurorau

'sBete

IroA\ BUIBr{ng ur aceld ur lueu;drnbe 3ul1q3g eJU ou st sreq} luase.rd 1y :prazBH

s;aqsrn8urlxgarld AyT.

(smo11o17 IIV Wt^ ssntng) .peurslureu

pue pe)caqc eq plnoqs eusqnu ur sroop 3ql lle uo selpu€q eqJ :papueuuocau'petctrtsar epsu eq plnoc eru eJo lue^e aql ul Sulplrnq eql-loj sser83 .rruda: peau

Iltlyr pue esool st mJ€ ecgJo ?tu?qnd ol ecueJluo Iceq eql ]e elpueq eqJ :pJezEH

srooo 6-7.

(s/t\olloH ilv wt^ ssnc4q) .c13 poo/KJo )coJq e ujo+ acue$rsse ,(ue

lnoqllA\ 'uado,{e}s plnoL{s A\opur/v\ t{c"e pu?'ruooJ qo€e ul A\oputl^ euo lseal le uedo ol

e;qrssod eq plnoqs ll 'esee qll^\ esolc pue uedo plnoqs s^ropur/r llv :papuaurxorau

llpnv pr8zeH el.xeqnu

Page 41: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

'preoq ecl lou aq] uo pe{eldstp eq plnoqs

sl lpn€ aseqlJol lnsel ol lJ ' , { le lerpaurul peul}3al eq plnoqs'pelou eJe qslqm selcuolsuop

,(uy .sqtuoru xrs ,{.rane }seel te ereld a1e1 plnoqs s}lpne,{ta;eg :papuoutllorag

'eculcl elel lou op $lpn€ '{1a3es l€ulelul luase'ld lV o

sl lpnv'{raJeS S'g

'ueql3o ddoc 3 enlocer Plnoqs

;gu1s f.retunlon Surpnlcul JJsls IIe puB uel]rr^\ eq plnoqs selnpecord :papuautl|otell

. Je3 lun lo^pe) loMeuo lce l }e lue lo l^ / }uep |cu lueJo}ue^eeq lu lpe / ! \o l |oJ

aq ol SeJnpeco:d eqt Jo 'u€A aqt ur 8urryOm JoJ se:npeco.tdJo les ueillJ/t\ ou Sl eJaqJ '

uB^ aql u1 3u14ro6 V't.

'ece1d ut tnd eq plnoqs {cr1od ssorls V :papuautuorag

.c}e ,sseu11l pe]eleJ sseJls utoJJ sJeJJns ee,to;drua uB }ue^e eql ul ue)e} 0q o} seJnseeu

eql lno slas pu€ eceldryom eql ul ssa;1s e8eueu-r dleq o1aceld ul Jou sr {cr1od sseJ}s V '

sstrls E'g

's;eert

g-g, { :a , te .ece1de)€}os lePlnoqssututeJ}Jeqse{eu.Sututer ]J lBJo}delSpJoceJpue

eceld e1e1 Plnoqs dn las nCIA pue Surlpueq l€nueur ut Sutute;1 :papuauluorog

'ece1d elet ,{ltuarrnc lou op dn 1es n6n PU€ Surlpueq l€nueu ut Sututerl '

3uru1u,r1 Z't

's:ee,(3o requnu 3 roJ ldel sq plnolls sprmer llv

.,{ltueca: pape}s seqJJets ,{:e1un1on pwJJ€}s 11e jo Surdee) proco1 :popuotrrurorall

JJets

,(,m1un1on pueJJsls :o3 ece;d solel L{3lq,ry\ pJocer SututgJ} 11e3o rdel lou 3Je spJooeu '

as'q*l*(vsp, il)#:::;

""::

t

ttnil

l

ililrLlxi-

I

i

il!

ilililil

.-'/ Iililililil

E

Ipnv prez?H eueqnu

Page 42: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

€002 qcrsIAI

^*- tJ^ - '+

al'?uleqru@u$rp? :llslug Of€mElfru-:ffi :ellsqaA\8920 9t8 [0 :x"C Z6ZA 9t8 I0 :ler

6 ullqn( ?rpuocrurug 'eEe11o3 s1v\oll?H 11y 'esnoll rolues

'uawot ssazddo qoTqt Eqarcos uT saJn?znzaspue seopntazd 'sapn1rl7e aqt acuanTluT o1 eaTzls ail

'auludo7aaep astzd.zalua ao] saTf Tun?zoddo osT.epue sawez6ozd Ouyurezl pue uorlearrpa apz-a.ozd aa laTEqs

-atTT aaeu3alTe ue $LoTTot o1 r|sTt+ oq uaurotL azoddns a4

\ 'uo7lnltlsozd ur paaTotuT

asotn o1 eoT^.ras 6u1pb-T44€g '.6ut7qeua ue za}Jo ail

-.-!r._-_---*.'-.

zTatn :ez'ocsp waq3- dTaquz abe6ua oqt

:€rroir

\_--

o1 lno duTqceaz r?q 'uof3naiaso:d

Jo /tlTTear aql sasserppe auer4ng--

.lNgl{g&\f,ls NOISSII^I

ryT:l|W -rf T1X

7 .' \ i

\t

Page 43: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

e00z qsrBIAtr

'uIqn([ o1sscl^Jes JoJ preav

I?nuuv ullqno Jo ro{?IN pro'I eql Jo lueldlcer € s?^t pelord eql 0002 r?ef eql uI

'666I vl pue uu ol etuet Eurpuq 16ON sqJ 'ltussecons osl? s31y\ p1q tuenbesgns V'uoBnlt$ord

ol elrleruelle ue spJ?,lrol ureql elellllcu; 01 Euruterl-srd pue uollmnpe-erd qlrmdlaq -rog s;ue,{ aql JeAo ueruom {q epew s$enber snorrel eql ol puodse: o1 peford eqlpelqsue sql 'e^rl?rlrul lueru,(oldrug pu€4s (uaruo16 roJ sellrunuoddg r\eeN) '11d,

o'Neql repun 1u€r9 Eurpung ueedornE reed oml e rog peldecce sefi\ utu?qQl 566I uI

'urlqnqJo sleells eql uo uotlnltlso-tdur ue{uo1v\ qtvrr fllecgrceds pu? orull IIry ryolA. o1 'f:O}n}e$ ro f;ulunlol Jsqllepug sll 3o peford ]sru eq] se uorlruEoceJ leuort€u popJuff\e senr, pefo.ld s,ueluoly\€tuer{n'U ;esd awes aq; 'edo-rnE ee{ uol}nq$o.rd ? spJu&\ol 8uqrorn uol}sJepeCueedo:ng e 'dICIE.f

Jo Joqrueu ? aurmeq pe[o-r4 s,ueruolv\ euluqe{ t66I uI

'lcalo.rd orllJo s€er? II€ ut Eunlronr punoJ eq o]eJ? pu? lcefo:d eql Jo sseoons eql 01 l?rluesse eJ? sJeelunloA 'ue{uo^t eql ol seollJeseql puedxa requrg o] lcslord eqt,(q peur€rt are^{ sraetunlonJo uI?el }sJg aql €66I uI

'uotldecul

slr eours os euop el?q pu? srseq ftelunJol e uo >lee^\ qcee cIuIIc euo 8u1ge6-oc ,{q dHA\ eql q}l \ eleroqelloo el6 'oIUIIS l{lleag ur-do:q '-lnoq orwl 'f11eem. eol,v\lu sasuduroc rvrou eorlles sIqJ 'uewoff\ ssel{lJo speeu {tlueq eql JeUu 1oo1 ,{llecgrcedsol (tr{A) pefor4 {}leeg s,uetuod\ eql peqsrlqu$e preog t{}leeg ure$?E eqt Z66I uI

'sBurtno

pue s,{eprloq 'Eurure:l sllpls lelcos 'fceconpu 'Eutlunq 1eg 'EututuJ} slll>ls ',(dereq}

,{11ueg 's}Ist,t uosud pue lelrdsoq "8urr{ueduoc3€ gnoc 'Sutllesunoc '1-lorrt l€Icos

popnlsur q3lq/v\ ,{ep fq ryo./Y\ dn./rlolloJ pnpl^Ipul q}rm eceld lool sql 'speluoc dn1y\OIIOJ Isnpr^rpur Surlsanbe; Jreql 01 pel qcil{ff\ 'ueurolv\ Eurlceluoc Jo sueeru ,{-rclurrdaq1 pephord lq8ru tE lrolr\ qc?orlno 'urlqnqJo slaorts eqt uo uollnlttso-rd ur pa8zEueueruo,ry\ eqlJo speeu passe:dxe eql ol esuodser tooJrp ur dola,nep ol ue8aq socl^Jes aql

prudun ere^\ suortrsod esaqtgo qlog 'lce[o-rd

eql ur lro.^aot peluroddu se^\ JTOJoTeNIs € 0661 ur d1;eE 'repeel lcefo.ld3o elor eq]uo Eur1e1 etuer{nU ur {ro1( o1 pelurodd? seln re}sls SgU € 686I Jo pue eql spl?^loJ

'lq8ru te teerls aqt uo qoeerlnoJo sasod.rnd eql roJ lrun Eurlyesunoo ellqolu 3olur paue^uo3 elleue^ e eprrro:d 01 psprcep s3^1 lI 'eseqd f1.rea stql 13 pstlnsuoc oslsa;eln uorlntrlsord ur pallo^ur uetuol11 '?weqn1

3o eseqd I?t]IuI slq] ecuts Jeq]oEolpalro.r'\ ol?q suolleEe;8uoc qloq pue iq8nos sem (319) s.relsr5 .{1r:eq3 3o ,ipe1rno Jo uorl€roq?lloc eqJ ',{1lc aqt ut ,{cue8e .{-relunlo,r .ro '{:o}n}e}s ,,{ue fq pesse:pp?

lou peeu 8ur,no.tE e leetu o1 pa;rnbar se&\ esuodsa; e 1uVl lueplle atueceq 1I pu€ensst sn{} paqoJ?esel ,{aqt por:ad ;eaf o,ra.} ? JaAO uot}nll}soJd ur penlonul ue{uo.{tqlrlvl lro,tr ol pelsanbar arom ullqne ul (SCU) sre}sts p-laqdaqg poog '1861 t{3rul4 uI

J]gfOUd fHI CO AUOISIH

Page 44: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

e00z q3rBtrAtr

'ssecoJd srql dleq ol sJollesunocpeur?Jlol $lurl epr^oJd ol elq? sr lceford eql 'uo e^orrr u33 deql sJoJeq uorlntrr$oJdJleql tuo{uoc o} peuoddns eg o1 peeu ueuo^{ esaql tuql u^\or.{s s?q acueuedxg

'puHeq

uollerlsord Jo aJII eql e^Bal 01 pu? le>lJeru Jnoqel eql roJ se^lesueql drnba 01 uetuo;vieql elqsue o1 goddns pue EurureJl pnpr^rpur seprloJd puerp luerudolerre61 eql

lu-5ftffipLed'paJelunosua eq,{eru d;lsnpul xes eq} ur Eunl.lorn ueruoft\ ejeq&\

enuel due .ro suosud egl '1ce[o:4 r{t1eeg s,ueruojv\ aqt ur eculd se>l€l osp qceeJ}no

'uorlnlrlsoJd ur penlorrur sq ol enurluoc deqlJIpu? 'lueluleerl Erup Suro8;epun ro uosud ur eJe {eqt ueqm p€luoc Eulurelureru 'gnoc

uI ueruo.ivL Euruoddns sepnlcur srgl 'selel eJll req qled rene }?q^\ uetuo1v\ eqt Uoddnspue qlIA\ >lJo1r{ ol enur}uoc lll1| peford eql stueqnu qtl1| pe8e8ue sr uetuo^4. e ecuo

'tu?el r{ceeJlnos.pe[o:d eq]Jo ecuauadxe eneq uetuolA eq]Jl etuoclno anllrsod ? en?r1 o1d1e>1r1 eroweJe pu? Jors?e eperu e:e Eursearcur eJ? qcFllvr Jo r{loq 'se;1uec luetu}eaJl pue sercue8eJeLIlo tuo{ sl?JJeJe'U 'sloor}s eql uo ecueserd Jreq} esseJcur 01 {use1 qcee4no eqlJOJ peeu u Eurlee:o alurl eIU?s eql l3 lslg1!\ ueruoly\ eql qlrff\ eSeEue 01 llmgJrp eJor.uetuooeq seq 1l leql le^el euo 1e lu€eru s?q esn 8rup ulog Eurlynsa: e1,{1se311 cr}oeqc eql

'crlour{c f:e,t sr e1d6eg11 rleql 'esn Erup s.reugud e Jo pu? u1v\o rreqlrog {ed o18uq:orir &\ou eJB ue1 qcee:lno oql fq perelunocue uetuor*go fluoletu eql

'erueqnU fq pereg3o secrlreseql Jo pewroJur eiu ueruolv\ aql pu? dn qrnq ,{11enpu:8 sr lsnrl u slalunooue oseq}IuoJc 'sJoljo.ryi aql qlr.r ,,1?{c,, € pu? {urJp loq 3 a^er.{ o1 ,(}runuoddo eqt euro3leaol :eadde ueruolv\ oql pu? see:e .1q8rl peJ, eql ur ulrrou{ Jlelvr sr }I 'uorlnlrNord

leejls Ur Eurl-rom ueuroly\ aql loJ eceds eJss € eprrrord o1 ssnurluoc ue^ 3qI

'V002 fq slq8ru ueles 01'{11enpe.r8 srq} eseeJcul o} sl ueld aqt '>1eem e s1q8ru e^g }no seo8 ecn-les qcsellno eql

qJuerlno

'Eursrea sseueJurvr1tr pu?'luerudoleneq 'qcee;lno :spue:ls SurlceuuocJelur lnq lourlsrp eeJql ssq lcafotd aq1

{roa luarrn]

Z00Z qcr€I4 ur e8e11o3 s.lr'olleH IIV ]e ((oruoq,, luese:d str ol pelor.u pafo.rdsqI dols.tap pue eleprlosuoo o1 tcefo:d eql Surlqeue ur rolc€J ,{:o1nqr-r1uoc -rofeurs ss^\ uorlaporutuo3cu sn{} Jo esn aqJ ellual {a1nyc61 aur;aq}?J er{i ur }caio-rdeql roJ uorl€po{uurocoe popr^ord ,{rra141Jo sre}srs aL$'2002 q3r?I4l ot g66l eunl {uor{

Page 45: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

e00z qcrqy\l

olls5oq e Euqel ,{q ueuozlL Jo luerrue&odue eql {ees el6 'luewuoJrlue luerueEpnf-uou 'Euu?c '8uun1rnu e uerrr8 'pqualod s,euo Sulqc?eJ pu? 'ql,lroJE 1uetudolenep'eEueqc JoJ serlrlqrssod ees e16 'u?ruo1y\ qo"e Jo dyuErp pu? quol\ ar{l ur sr JerleqIuluetu€pury Noru rno 'pefor4 eql uo Eurreeq perlp ? el?q senl?A pw sJerleq rno

flll7 AfuU,gNW.sueeru tl :lcefordeqlJo ,{qdosolqd eql satelnsd?cue VI MFUft[ !ce[or4 eqlJo erueu ̂4,arqeH eqJ

sanl8^ pus fqdosollqd

'suorlnquluoc f-relunlorrpu? suol]euop ruo{ seruoo Eurpury Jo ecJnos lueuodtur ,{lEurseercur pu? penle^ V

'tlgeg Erup rreqt peeJ ol uorlnlr$ord ur pellolur aJ? oq,v\ ee-re dlrc Jeuur eqluI ueruolri pelclppu Erup Euno,{ qllry\ {ro,& o} sr tl >1se1 cgrceds esoq.&{ re>lro^r }ca[o-rdqc?erlno etullllqJ e eprrrord ol sn selq?ue {euou NruJ d:eru-rgu1 alqe}rr?r.{J 3r.lJ

'ejns?ew uetuolA-tog dlrlenbg eql pue $ruJ elqetrrer13 .{.reurgu1 elqetrr€rlJ eqt 'pr?og gtpeg tuets?Eeql "eoIAreS eJ€JIeiA pue uorpqoJd eql tuo{ setuoc pelo:d er{l JoJ Eurpurg luerrnJ

Surpung

'su8reduec erpetu 8uruun: pue lueuru:erro8Eut,{qqo1 'secue:sguoc ur Surtedrcrgud 'sdno-lE

IIsurs o} s11e18ur,rr8 sellolur lI 'slool

pu? stuslu?qoetuJo fleusn e Sursn le^el oJcpru pue oJcnu orll qloq 1u eceld se>lel sniJ

duls!Bl{ sseuaJunav

-s.,{eurnoI luerudoJenap leuos.rad Jreq] uo enurluoc ol uetuoAr pesrleur8:eruelq?ua l[,/y\ 1?q1 uor]ue^Jelur Jo lepotu e u8rsep 01 slure qslq/( q3j?eseJ Euru;ee1uorlo? eAIoAur IIr&\ qcrqa e^rl€rlul srqJ 'eArt?rlruI dets rxeN eql 's:ea,{ eerql roJ uruolZO0T, ur elr lurlrur./v\eu e peuels'Eurpun;,{1r1enbe3o secrdsn€ eqlJapun'paford eql

'uor1u1ro1dxe Isnxes go sesofund eqt :o3 puulerl olur

pa>l3lJ?rl ueeq e^?q o{1zrt uetuoulr r{1.ry\ Irol* sr }ce[o.rd eql JoJ lroltrJo ua;u 3ur'vlo:E y

':e8unof Eunuocaq sr elgo:d e8e eqt pu? sresn8rup e.re ,{luoieru eq} 'eseq ulep s.lcefo-rd eqt uo ua{uo1r\ +009 euos A\ou eJe e;eqJ

'sseursnq u^\o Jroql dn Eurpas pue ses:noc ,{1rs;anrun Eurlelduoc ue{uo,tt pepnlcureneq sassaorns oql Jo etuos aJII Jo u-ralled letu;ou eJo{u e qsllqe}so o} uo enotuop uaurozvt ,{uetu s;aolunlol pu? rueal aqt uIo4 uoddns q}r.tr }nq ,AAols eq feu ssarEor4

Page 46: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

t00z qcnhtr

'tsuIeq-lla^l\,

I?uetu pus Imrsdqd pus '{uouolnu 'd1r1enbe ',{lru8rp o1 lq8rr ueunq s,uosred }eqlSurle8orqe ,{q ,{1r1enxes s,uosred e Jo esnqe aqr qEnorql lue{uecuenpeprcE Iertueugro uorlecgrle.rE pnxes elerqo? (s)uosred qolr{1y\ ,{q ecrpurd ? sr uor}elroldxa l?nxes

',{lrunuuoc eql pue,{11ue3 eql 'lenprnrpur eq}Jo er€Jle&\ eq} rsEuepue pus uosred u?unq oqtJo quod\ pu?,{l1u81p eq} qlrt\ elqrleduocur er€ uorlnlrlsord go sesofund aq1 :o3 suos:ed uI cll}eJleql Jo 1r,ne Eurduedruocce eql pue uorlnlrlso.rd .t"ql setuls ',sraqto

{o uogn4gsot1ary {o uo4nrrc1dxV aqt puo suos.tad ug c{{nt1 {o uotssatddng, aql roJ 'uo4ueluoJ

6t6l eql 'uos;ed u?tunq eql Jo flruErp eql r{}Bauoq pu? ueluoly\ go e,l.tsserddopue elrlelroldxe se 1r Eurmen 'uor1n1r1so:d

3:o uorlusrle8el eql lsur?Eu a.le o16

'ue{uo1n pup uer.u qloqJo 'ssocord erl}Jo uor}o?-Jelur aql slee3uocI se tarutlqsotd, Ieqsl eql Eursn ruo4: ur?{eJ el6 'uor}n}r}soJd ur perrlolul uetuoff\Eurp;eEe: secrpnle:d pue sqilu p]ercos eEuelleqc o] Iees eroJerer{l pue uorlnlr6ordolur ueluozvr. eAIJp lsql sJoloe; luqc:er:1ed pue leJn1cruls eql Jo snonsuoo aJe el6

'f1r:o[eu uepplq ? ars uol]ntlnord uI uewolnosn oq,^A uaru aql ellq^a 'Eur11eqe1 pu€ uorlpsrl?urrur:r :raq1 'uorlny6o:d ur paAIoAuIueruoly\ Jo tuarrrleejl oql SurpreEer {lrlenbeur qonu sr aJeql 'se^rl JIeq} go ,{uutu 3odrqsp:eq aql o] elnquluoc ,lt?l eql pue sepnlrltu l?laroos

'seqrunuoddo pue se3loqc Jo{331

'SUOr}Clppe '1uew,{oldweun 'esnqe 'sseussel:arvrod

"(uanod 3o suaJqo:d eldrtlnu

Jreql ol uorlnlos 3 s? po^Io^ur ueruo,ry\ or{lJo ,{1r-ro[uu eqt ,{q parrrec:ed sr uorlnlqsoJd

luaudolerrep asudralua JoJ serlrunuoddo pue 3ururu:l 'uoll€cnpe Eutloruord,{q pue serJ€punoq pu€ spoeu 's1qEr: Jreql ,lroul ol tueql SurEe:nocue 'qceo;dde

Page 47: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

::.:' :..1-':-j{J'1. -;,.:Er::li-r: .i- f.iil;

': ri:t l::lii:, l;i

, i . ;a r . : : f : : t i r : , : : l

::ir.-l:r:.]:

. ' , . l j

'::.r . I .,i '. . " : . a

' , a

\-

b

Page 48: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

*,7

t t ,

f?

r1?at i.;

* a..: ?

.a i.

* i

r t

1 :

$#*?$?1.i: pu# sj*}3s#G $* p.!ss* 'sir*"{3?d 'sjas*333

*Ja?"i*# d n* € s p **r"i j'*taatru nt*p.';:i*39 €i{r{? iJ r3X

iL'a{"il43€?g :*?i*L{B#i*

*ur*re.*p*r'14

*ai"ilotrtJn ls ii rs ffi * s3 *a !*3rq

$.3#S?*fi : l#*

*xrclag $*#ijaic*ny

: *a t i ,$n ta , ra r

: 1 . , . , , , . " , . "' : ' i : " ) l ; i H :

3.11Ue: s*1:**{: ? *li*i

. t ' 1 T : " : t n { ,

t*z** Jz *' ftt-\w, .4 tl*a l4Zg y,\ r ' i ?'1 " 1 -i '" .t : : '

i . j t i : i : : j i * : . { : ; 3 " 1 , : * t } 1 t : i \ q * : ' i * z e - : * t r ? ' " & . . , . ; 1 , . ' " : . l ' " \ : . :

Page 49: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

er€ ue(uo1vl ,(em sq1 ol pepps IIs o^€rl qlqno uI secr^res uorlnlrlsord pe$q-qe^r go ecuaErelue eql puesleqlorq roopu u qUvror8 eql 'sesofund

lunxes roJ ueruo^\ 5o Eur>1c1gerJ 'p?eq? se8uelpqc eje erer{I

'1qge1er8 dro,r sr €tu€qnl{ qclql\ ro; 'ecrnoser u?{unq elq?nplur ue ere ,(eq1lueue8eueru eseq€trEp o1 "8urlyesunoc 01 'ue1 qc€enno eql ur 8urryom ruorg ?rueqn)I3to slcedse 1p urpe^lo^u ere sreeltmlo1 'uorl€srue8ro eqlJo 8uruuru luercllJe eW ol eslgedxe pu? eurrl Jreqt alnquluocsreelunlol Jo suezoq 'es€q reelunlon 8uor1s sll sl etu€qnlI Jo 1ro^\ eql Jo lcedse luegodurr uy

'ecuolollJo srolu4edred eql se pesrl?ur{urJc ere srefnq seeJeqm'eouelorlJostullclA eql eJe ,{eg} se pe$l?wrulJcep eJ€ uorlnlrlsord ur peSe8ue ueruo^\ ,{puenbesuoc luauorrr lsure8eecueJoll se pe^\eln sI uo4nlllsord 'uepern5 u1 'uepeills

Jo leql ol rslrrurs lepour s ol uortrqs18e1 gs1-11ut e8ueqc ? selecolp€ pue uoqnlrlso-rdyo snte1s le8el eqt;o ^lerner,{cr1od e pelelduor osl? seg eueqnll

'S00ZJo deyq uy paqslqnd. r IIIA pue uo4elduroc 8uueeu ./t\ou sl tlolt{r!\ IJolr\ Jo ecerd }uugodrul ue sl sllJ 's,{aurnof

lueurdolarrepleuosred rleql q dels lxeu eql e>pl 01 uetuo \ pezrpur8retu ele1rlrcEl 01 uopuelrelur Jo lepotu e dolanepo1 pauteE slq8rsur pue Sutueal orll esn IILv\ pu? (UVd qceorddy qclee$U uorlcv {rotedrclged € [email protected]\JoJ3ur,roruuogueql1uene. ldpueueqlspeJJe1€q1I"uexepu3

IBuJeluI <s:elx€qJo eEuer eql qsrlqelse ol Jepro rr uorlnlrlsord pacuelredxe eneq oq1( ue{uo./r\Jo uoqoc €

qlLv\ gcreeser tronpuoc o1 (fcuellnsuoJ ser.lceo-rddy suelsds prlqD VSJ peuorssnuruoc ?rueqnU 70OZ aI

'sluepqs e8elyocTserlrsrelrun pu€ sarpoqdromlels 'sgCN ,tueru ol suollslueseJd pue ,{:elueruuoc uedxe sepr'ro-rd ?tueqn11 'enssr eql uo flrroqlneu€ se pastuSocer euoceq seq etuel{e{ 'uor1n1r1sord ur pellonur ueruolr\ qfrm flpcgrceds Eurryomuollestue8ro fluo eql s'V 'Sursrer sseueJe,t,re pue .,{ceconpe sr sdeld etueqnU leq} eloJ luzuodtur Jequrg V

'Eurllesunoc pue goddns leuosred'uoddns8ututer14ueu,{oydrua 'Sururerl relnduroc Surpnlcur 'ueluolv\ JoJ seorn:es lueudola,tep sJeJJo osls €tueqn}I

';eef erp lnoq8no.rql lee,i!\ e s1q3!u rnoJ urlqn(Jo sleerls eql uo sr 'aEe:ene uo

- It{ 1\ <ue^ q333rlno etueqnU eq} ul ep?tu lsrlJ ere slcu}uoo eseq} Jo ,{ue141 'ueruolK ZVZ LILI1Y. s}c€tuoc

'J0'€ reAo peq qteerlno etu€qn11 'V1OZ q uorlu.tudep crruouoceoroos luergru8rs go spuno-r81ceqruor; Suruoc ureql 3io {ueu f:en 'urlqn6l ur uor}ql1so-rd ur pe^lonur oJe ueruon{ Jo speJpunH

'eJnleu enrlulroldxelseJlu€tu Jleql elrdsep 'ecueldecce peerdssprm perrell? eleq ..3urcuep-de1,, s€ qcns '..fr1snpur

xos,, peJl€c-os eqt ;o spedse rer.po 'urlqn61 ul ,{1rnr1ce uepplq .(1e3.ru1 s srr€ruer uoqnlrlsord ellq1\

'uotsseduoc puu lcadser ',{qledue;o lurds € ur 'uor}e}roldxe

Ienxes l?rcJer.uuocJo sr.tuoJ Jeqlo pu€uoqnlrlsord ur pe8eSue ueurolr\ ol seJrl;es qc€el-lno Jo uorsrloJd aql sr etu?qnU Jo {Jo1r{ ,{reuud eq;

'etrreqngJo uodeg ,O0Z-8007, eql ecnpo4ur o1erns€o1d fu sr 11

qor)l)tc io c)yos ywyHnuNoqtd)tyH) 'uotb.l

Nt,4l) )c A€ cuo^41)oj

Page 50: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

srolcerrcJo pr€og'n3q3rolsT ur^e)rc

'suoq?lndod pelroldxe pue pefaJ8eu lsoru s.puele{Jo euo 01 Uoddns pu€ uo;ruoc s8uFq qclqAlIuslleuolssaJord pue uorleorpep penuquor Jreql JoJ errrer1nU Jo JJe}s orp pueunuoc p{re {ueq1 1

',{11eugg

'poued Suluoder eWJo pue e{il sprelyrol de8 8urpury e eSprrq ol pedleq gclqlrn uorlnquluoo snoreue8e aae8 sreNIS figeq3 go ,{pe1 rno ?002 ur uoqrpp€ u1 'pouad eqt lnoqfnorql Sursrerpu4g qEno-rg1pu? secJnos Jelflo Iuo{ pe^recej eje A suorlsuop rellsr.us 'Isru1 alqs}u€r{3 ,truuugul elqsruur.lS erftpus 'euoC

4se1 s8rug lproT ,{il3 ;auu1 qlnos eq} 'uoq€punod eusT uellv eql 'e3r]sn[ 3o 1uau4-rudsq

eq] Jo erns?etrAl ue{rrol[ -ro3 &rJenbg eq] 'preog q1teag eerv ]s€o3 ]s€E eqt epnlour srouop rorllo'uoddns penurluoo sU JoJ 1qe1e:8 eJ€ e&\ puu Jouop luuuodun u? sr ecrrues eJeJIelA

pu? uollsqoJd eldl 'IJoIy\ Jno 01 elnqr4uo3 or{ \ 'll"{us pue afue1 'sJapury s1l 01 lryeler8 sl ?w€qnu

-uor1e1ro1dxe Jenxes l"roletutuorJo s{urlorn eJp oryyl ueruofti ol lno Euqceeryo s,(um rrteu purl

ol pu€ seollJes sll relrlep ol enrnluoo ol sr €ru€qn5 rog eEue11uq3 sqJ 'pelroldxa dlpnxas f,lprc.lauruoc

Page 51: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

rolcerr(Idqug uaalqluy

'pjslvuoJ e^or.u o1qclq A uro+ srseq punos e - Srnureel Jo rpl?e^\? pu€ uo4ue^Jelul lruissescnsJo uorl€punoJ prlose uo Surppnq ere ervr letp e8pelmoul eqt rn pueeruopguoc qlrd\ os op e^r '8ryq .'{eqt se8uelleqceql pu€ sree,( ueeg$ xeu eqt 01 {ool e { se os

'sreef eqt Je^o srseq reln8eruo pelnqr4uoc e^er{ oq1( sl?np!^lpul Au€ru

eq] pue {Jo,t Jno Uoddns 01 panur}uoc elur4 oq./y\srouop ,{ueu eql 01 1rya1er8 eJ? enA 'aunuer8ord

,{ceconpe pu? Sursrer sseuel€A\e u€ pllnq01 pu€ eprno;d o^\ se3rues eqt puedxe ot pedleqe^?q qcrq \ sllr{s Jo e8uer esrelrp ? pu? ,{6reue'usersnqlue

1{3no:q eneq faql sJeq{ueu preoqse pu€ sroolunlo^';3e1s su lJolrl oqlr\ slsnpr^rpurpslll(utuoc ,(ueu fq pegoddns sr €rusqnu

'esnqe elqetdecceunue pue ueruon{ lsrne8e eouelorn se uorlnlrlsordsazruSocer 1r s€ pre8er slq ur {Jurupuellueuodrur u€ selr\ VOOZ ur uatuoiA ]sura?e

ecuelor^ uo 3e$rluruoJ duueels Ieuo4eNeql q €Iu€qnl{ Jo uolsnlcq eqJ 'pelerelo} eq

louuec pue slqEu u€tunq s.uerrJoln Jo esnq€ u€eJe uorlelroldxe lenxes l?rcJeruruoc Jo stuJoJ II€prre uorlqrlsord 1eq1 'e8€sseru eql eluurruessrpo1 8ursrer sseueJed\e crlqnd uo snooJ Suorlse puB pe^lonur ueruolr\ er[ of uorsrno.Id ecr^Jes

lcerrp lsluog oml uo peploel eq tsnru suelqordeseql leql reelc sr 1I

'uatuom eql Jo spesuet[ o1 puodser o] Jnol€epue e./v\ se eur€qnl{ot e8ua11eqc Euro8uo ue sluese:d slql I1y

'Je^oc pu? I'uopeeJJrelea;E qlrzrr eleredo sdno-rE l"urrurJc Eurlqeuepu€ ssecc€ Jers€e Surirrolle 'seuoqd elrqoupue Eursrpenp€ elrs-qe,l 'leruelur eql Jo esneq1 i,tlsnpu eq] Jo suorsusdxe eql pelerlllc€Jseq ,(Solouqcet urepot\l 'pe^lo^I'n esnq? eq] olcqqnd eql Suoure uorlezrlrsue$p € pue frlsnput

luoruurzuelue eq1 urqlrffr ueruo,ry\ 3o uo44roldxe

Ienxes Jo acuelelol Surseercur ue Jo ecuepr^esr .{:}unoc eqt lnoq8norr& sqnlc Surcuep-de1 yopeerds eq1 '696I ul >lJo1y\ Jno ue6eq e r ueq^\peludrcrlue lou se,^ qclqv\ uoueuoueqd e pueuorlpzrl€qo18 go slcedse re{r€p eql Jo elduexep€s ? sr uorlulroldxe Ienxes;o sesodrnd eqt rogpuele{ otur ueruom 3o 8ur>1crger1 'pez1eqo18

flSrnsee.rcur sreef eng lsed eql ul pue pelloJluoopue pezue8-ro aroru owooeq seq lJ

'poqsrlqulse

s€1K eru€qn11 eours puelerl ul {-4snpur xes eq} ulse8ueqc e8nq uaes osl€ e^eq s-lee,{ ueegrJ eser1J

'sJelsrs

&Feql;o , pe1 rno pue sretsls preqdeqg poogoql ?{ueqnx Jo see}sru} ./tlou pu€ suotluSer8uocStnpuno; o1r\1 oql oi tnd lslg s€1v\ uorlnl[sordur ue{.uo1\\ qll,^A lJoly\ o} {cue8e ue dn

las o1 eepr eq] ectns pessed aneq sreaf ueegrg

NO[)nCOX1Nr

Page 52: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

.1ro \ qrdep-u1uue18uoJ pu€ s1celuoc leade.tJo Jaq{unu e Sunlonur '(I:o-1y\ ese3 eeg) xalduoc dran dlpnm eJe ueruoly\ ,(q peluasard senssr eq;

' ' 'arwas qlDa4no-pa&s aqt 4 ,(popcutod 'uawom 8u!{guap1 ut saulncg{tp stoulo alo anql'pa{oJd utrloqny aqt o, uiloutl alo oqh uawot asoqt oi utoyad tluo suodat aqt q paupluoc satn&gf aql :arcN

'V007, u! slJuluoJ 0S ra^o SuJrluru uauroif, ZI .'?rueqnu qltrrr slJsluot 0s raAo pBq €002 ul uaurolf, r[ .

'lceford eql qlFA stceluoc 0S re^o6ur1ew uetuomJo Jequnu luecgruErs s qll^A'pepel ueuron,{q apeur s1ce}uooJo Jeqrunu eql.p007,/€002 uI saJraras qJue4no eql ol uoruo,ra,(q apuru s\cn|uo3lo uoltotn(I puv nqunN aqJ'

.paqsrlqqsa are sdrqsuorleler 8rn1srul pue elqrssodsI ssecce'(uosr.r4'dH \'slee4s

'e'l) eq ,{eu.{eql)elerer{A\ 'ueruo,^A 01}no Suqcee-r,{lelrlceord q8norql

'dno.r8 elqeJeuln^ dlen pue .qceeJ ol preq, slql qllly\ 8ulryorvr flenrpe;;e ur 'lerluesse ere sluauodruoceseql'ue{Ilo1\{ ol,{lr1rqe1re,re pue,{lrFqrxeg 'atuqJo lol e spueuep {Joia gc?e4no s.er.usgnu

Srnrluru uaurolr{. ZlT, ol peruduoc "secrlJes r{oeeJlno q}lrrr

'a"tlual sBIlJoO .

(*t711) lcafor4 rltluaH s6uorrro1\ .qJuarlno loe4s .

{roa\asuJ .iepnlcur qceerlno ur sacrn;es er.lJ

'n007, ur straluoJ L60't.slJsfuo3 glL'Z opuru uaruora 0€Z'EgOZUI

enlg - ,002 F€u = t00z epoc

qWZEWZ 'slruluo3 Jo'oN,tq pednorg 'ueruo l\ Jo'oN

o o

p (rl

o o

a a

! J q J S U t O \ { € \ O C

- 6 + + + + + + 6 +r l ' t 9 t s t s t e t s t e t s DE a o a a a o o a aA + + + 6 + + + + 6- a a 4 0 a b a Q 4

0o Iz0290sqovEoqo0t;oL=08

H)yr)ffo

Page 53: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

'oA11 ere a eraql r€ef equo pue 3ql}e 'sJelJolv\ qc€a4no eturl III'IJ rnoJ ere^\ eJaql '€002

Jo Euluu€eq eql le ereqlv\ gtqs ur dorp eql spager euqcap e(f,f, 'rpuoru rad uewom gI ol t00Z ur d1fq6l1speddorp requnu oW'EOOZ ur sesec el4c? s€ rpuoru red uetuorvr 971o efre:e. e u? p€q sJeIJo^a rpee4ng

{roa esBJ

x * * * * { < * r < * * * * { < * * { < * * * 4 ( * * * * ' i < * * * * * * * * * X < * : r * { < * * * * *

o/oet'sqrn

0I > o/o0z 'squr

?o07qf,"a{no u! uaruolll\ ql!.rapsluoJJo uogsJn(

j .srnoH +[

€002 qcueqnour uaurolv\ qtpr lJ8luo3 Jo uo.rlB.rn(

VO1Z ur seJn8g JoJ u1v\oris sr eE€luecJed repurs y

'salnulur 0 t u8t{l aJolu JoJ lJBluoJ atalA o/o€f .

'a.|Otu JO Jnoq I Jo sltsluoJ oJoA{ o/o0[ .'8002 ur r.l3eerlno uI ueruo/K r.gr1t\ slJBluot g?L,Z eqlJo

:q)oaung u! sacrtJas qqt sr?otuoJ"{o uutt tn(I

'sesr^Jes Jno ur lreluoc leuosJedJo 1ene1 qSrq eqlJo lte^e pu€ enl€AsuorlesJenuoc euoqdelel Jo s:elunooue eceJ 01 acsJ qEnorqt eq uec ualr8 poddns eq1ueruol\r 'lle uI

Page 54: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

trt 6sfq3!u Zlpue'EOOZ eunf ur 6qq31u

qcr?I4i ur eceld lool srr{J 'qqF1u 97

{ < * * { < * r f * * * * * * * * { < * * * * * * * { . * * * * * *

'v002 reqopotI se^\ tno sum UBA eql 'qluoru :ed s1q31u3o requnu lsuol eqJ

't002 requa^oN pue €002servr lno sera uul oql 'qluou rad qq8guyo reqrunu 1saq31q eq1

'sJeelunlol/Irels JoJ s1ueu4rrrrruoc Jorflo ro sfepqoq 'sseu>1crs'ecu?uelul?Iu u€A 'Jeql€el\ su qcns '1no sr uel eql slq8rugo Jagtunu eql ecuenlJ:ur rr?o slolceJ ,{ue141

'sreelunlon ro sra>lrom r{cee4no etu4 1ry eq rrec sre>llo1v\ eseqt leldoed 7 fiqpa#u1s sr u€^ er{J

'lceford eqt q secrrues Jetpo qtr^\ pe8e8ua eruocago1 uo o3,(utu .{eqt pue etuBqnu qlrr\ Jelunocue lsJU Jreq} eq feu srql 'uor}n}r}sord ur uaruorrr etuos Jod

,{1tc uqqnqJo s}clr}slp .rq8r1 par, eqr ul '4aa*t o s7r131u y afentte uo }oeJts eq} uo sr trott ,prraqn7 aqJqruerlno lee4s

+ iF rF++ +++ + rF iF + ++ +++++ + + ++ +++ +++ ++*+

'uo4n1r1sord uorg ,(err,re uor1tsu€J1 Suunp eruoour urdorp tuecgru8rs o18ur1sn[pe'uor]orpp€ ruorg 8ur11nser feuourgo {o?J

'tqe( :ppunuli'luarur{oldrue pred pue ,{:e1un1o^ ssecre ol Jepjo uI :uorroJnpg

'sluauerrnber uorlegord ol Sur.leqpe pue uno3 Surpuape ur pepoddn5 :1u8e1'uoqnlrlsord

t{}I1y\ pe}ercoss€ sseusselquoa pue aweqsJo s8urleeg'ssourleuoT :lBuos.rod'eJ€cpJrr13 pue secrl:es lercos r{lt.e\ uoddns

'eJeo ur ue:plrqc ol sseocv 'ecuelorl crlseuroql'sertlnor#rp drqsuorleleg :Qyaog'1erp:ood'sruelqordlecrs,(q4'uoqcrppv'Wleeqletuel4l :tlnoaH

isreef o,r\1 eql JeAo luelsrsuoc peur€r.ueJ eleq senssr >l;o.ry\ esu]

enlg = 1002 Fou = t00z apoS

nffiagaoz slearlsaql uo su,ra rrsa aq1 s1q3;u Jo Jeqrunu aqf,

u r -E -6lsrE*E5a

; i ox 5

8 v 9o o o

n > a

0

szn T O

z' . o Q

5oz ut

\ L

Page 55: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

'ryo1v\ eql q speeu r"lncqJ€d JnoJo eruos et€lrllc€J ol 'dropeJ

pJod eql urorg fllcerlp tr peropro prre trsrr?rJ pro{ e ,{nq 01 peprcep eA\ '{ro^\ aql petrns }seq elcrqe^Joed$ leqtr petu€el en sree.( eql Je^O 'euo ̂ \eu e ro3r 'uen p1o sree,( 9 rno ur pep€4 em €002 requeoaq uI

uvA qcoagno $zru nfo qcunnT aqJ

's€eJ€ tuereJJlp ul pue lq8ru eqt Surrnp seurq reSuol roJ eorlJes qc€eltno leerts rnouru ol sueld erreq em 'o1 pelotu eleq r{eru ueruolyr eq} eJeryv\ ssesss o} lceford lopd e uru ol edoq eueqng

'eej? eql uro4r ,{eme pa^otu e^sq ue{uorvr 's6e1ord }aeJlsJo llnssJ 3 sv 'eeJe

rleql q s}ueplser fq uo4n1r1so-td tsureEe rfredwec Iqrsseccns eql pue eull SV1T eqlJo uorlon-qsuooeql ol Ernleler $lrolyt peorJo uolpnporlul eqt 01 srrp 8urlnqlme ere em ipFlsrp .lqfir1 par, eprsqgoN eql

uI r€lnolu€d rn slceluoc uI eullsep eql pecrlou e^?q slA 'quellc roJ sleerls eql uo 3uo1 se puels ol e^eqJu op ueurol\{ su€e(u qclqi^ 'seuoqd ellqoluJo esn eql se qcns sJolceJJo Jeqrunu e ol enp sr eurlcep srqJ

'ree,( eql3o sriluoru € JoJ 'JaAo JotI peqs€er ,{po ueuom qlun lqEru:ad slce}uoc Jno uar4 t 'l0OZ ur reqUry uele pewlcep pu€ reef eqlyosqluotu S JoJ eJotu Jo tI peq3€el ueruolv\ qtm lqEru -red s1celuor Jno <€002 ur ees e,l\ eloqe ueqc eql uI

'reef eq13o srguol'u 1 1 lnoqanorql 1q6lu red ueuor',r qlvrrslcsluoc eJoIU lo 713o eSe.ra^? u3 pelv\oqs se.rn6g Jno ueq^\ '2002 01 >lc€q o6 errr eurlcep slt{l le lool oJ

'sreef eql reno peurlcepseq ecIAJoS qo"e:lno-leers eql ur lq6ru red ueruorr,r r4lur\ slceluocJo Jequnu e8e-rene aq;

tt!3t19 nd sqcn1uo3fo nqrunl1aEn"nd.y aqg

E€E I Buquu 09I ol pereduoc ueA r{3"ar}no eq} q}v\^ sfrufuoJ gg9'1 apuur """Lt:tt;l:l"t-#:iunA atlt tflroL spotuoS

anlg - 1002 P€u = t00z apoS

. rsa aqlJo qluotrAl

Fs--gEE-8F-,+etf r :3 i + ; ,8 eE i * 5A 2 6 E i =:

nqg1lEOqZ -ro; uos!-rudruor u 'uopnlpsord laeJls rruetuo1\ q{ia rrlS1u rad slre}uof, Jo roqumN a?urany eqa

Page 56: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

6

'uosrrd eql ulqtl^t Eurlrorrr qeldeq3 pu€ srecrJTo uo4€qord eW qtlm peqsllqetse ueeq e^eq $lrollapN'11sra. red ueruo/d g go aEererru u" t{l! \ eEeEue sJe>lJoa aql

.1ceford

Jno o1 ulrlou>l dpeerle eJ€ oryv\ ueurolv\ {sfl o1 pu€ rrlyloul secrlJes Jno el?tu ol,{ltunuoddo Jel$ouesr 11 'uor1rur1so-rd ur ueruoly\ qglv\ lc"lum e>l€ru ol >leenl ? ecuo e4ue3 s€qcoq eql olul oE sreryorrr or"r;

erlual sBqJo(

',{rerrrlep ecIAJes JoJ suo4solldtut s11 ssncslp 01 elllncexg ecIAJeSr+l"oH aqrJo steqrueru rorues qlrrvr 6tn1eeru ueeq e^?q €w?qnU pue 1ce[o-t4 qrleeH s.ueluol6 eqJ

(c1e 's1eg 'sleqlorg)

uorlnl4sord roopur ulqlyv\ fpelncrged 'uo4n14sord rog pueye{ otul pe{3gJ€4 ueeq el€q oq t ueuo./v\

Jo Jeqrunu eql spogeJ srql e^erloq e16 'd11uerE pesueJcur seq lcelord eq] Ewssecce ue{uo1y\ uErerogsoJequnu eq; 'pefo-ld rtll€eH s.ueurolv\ eql ul srseq dplee^\ ? uo >lJo1r^ ol senuquoc Ja>ljo1r\ qc€e4no euo

r * ri x,i * * * * ii x * x ri x x * rF *.. . :".:

t"J d qllu 3H s 6 u e ruo a\

'€002 rirquacae u! uoA qcoaqno atau aql-{oq"unq atlt ro '(.toqca4q 1uo4ryssy) {aftoy aulptong pun Qotoy,g ptoT tqnda@ auttg utaqqrg qIJ

g &'';, i ;

' " ' -

'u€^ aqlJo {c€q eq} ut Eutryorrr tq8trdnpuels plnos sJe{Jo^\ lueelu qcrqlr\JooJ :eq?rq eql qll ^ ss1\t u€A .A^eu eq}Jo seJruseJ petuosle.{ eqiJo euo

Page 57: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

OI

'3ur1cg3a1Jo srurlcrl eJelvr orllv\ ueruo,tr 1g pegoddns dlen4ce e7y1 .'u?raolr pa4cgffn4 paunsatd gL leru e/v\ .

'Euqcrgge4Jo sesec 00I re^oJo er? \€ sel\ erueqng 'VOeZ,ltO1Z poued eql uI

8u1t1cg[oafo stnucrl o1 {nq1ap a)ltras s.ruoqny uo.tlaa4oy s}ltsltors

'sruqcrl 6u{4uepr pus uorleuuo;:ur 6ur1e11oc;o sfervr el?Jnco€ pug ol preq 8ur1-ro.tr ueeq s€q e{u?qnlI'srql sserppe oI 'ur sles ens$ aql eppsl

o1,{cueceldtuoc pue peztuSocel }ou sr uelqo:d eql so4srte}s lnoq}yrl leql er?^r€ ere €u?qnU .renervroll

'llncggyp erotu uene se{uoceq ISel eql'6ur1c1ger1 Eurpunouns. sropeJ r?lnclUed eql qllllr lnq qSnoue llnorgrp sr pu€le{ ur uortnl4sordSo 1uerye eql Eurleurlsg

'secJnoseJ pu€ uorl€lst8ey etenbepeul .'srurlcln 6ur,!4uepl ur seqlncglp eqJ .

". (.ole .qelJi.qeqlorq

Jo lno 8urleledo 'uo4n1t1sord roopur olur pe>lcgJeJl ere surrlcrn ile Jo o 66)'ern1€u elqrsrnur s<ll .i,(g peredu?g sr puslerl ur enssr eqlJo uoqru8ocer pue luetueEpellvroulcv

ualqord erp Jo elurs eql

-ecIAJes Jno ur uo{uo./y\Jo sJeq{unu pes€eJc{n eql .'secJnos elqlpeJo Jeqlo pu€ erpeu 'sluuorsseJord uor; pereqte8 eoueprle l€lopceuv .

(8ur1crge4Jo ISI: q8rq se pelou suorEer pue serrtunoorerood ruor; fJlensn 'e3treuly 'S pue ecl{V (ersv uro{ eJe uetuo./y\ leuoqeu uou -req1g)

'sJe{clJJsJl JoJ serJ}unoc ecjnos s3 rr.4AoDI 11errl ulEuoJo serJ}unoc-lleq1 'edo:nfl Lu3]seg tuo:3t ele uo4nlqso-rd Joopur ur ue{uo1v\ Ieuoqeu uouJo luec;ed qBIq y .

'l€uorl?u-uou ete ueuo^{ er{}Jo o 00lt'sjoopur/ fpelncrped'.{.l1snpul xes eqlJo s?eJe eruos ur ifrlsnpur xes eql qW$,\ euecs Bur8ueqc eq; .:uo uo4€nlrs aguo luetussess? srql essq elA

'sreef S lsed eql JeAo 'y!uol8 slr pen.lesqo 'uor1n1r1so-rd ur penlonur

ua{uolvr ol f.le,uJep scllres s1r qEnorql 'seq etu?qny pu" ruelqord Eurlcgge4 snolres e se{1 puelerlpuBIerI ur SuDIc1IJurI

uorleltoldxa lsnxesJo esodrnd eql JoJ seulunoc ueenrleq p{ru urr1luy\ ,{11enum pe{crJJeJl eJ? uelplrqc pu€uetuolyl uolllru V WqT 8ut1eu4se NfI eW qlrm a8nq sr enssr eqiJo alms eqI '1r ruog lduexa sr ,tlunoc

ou pue'uouatuouaqd eprrrrpporvr 3 sI uortulroldxE lenxeggo asodrn4 e{1} roJ uaruol6Jo 8ur1cr-ger; eq1uouortroueqd eprnaplroa u 8urycg;ur;

)N I))IJJV/Ul-

Page 58: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

I I

'eJncesur os $ lueuruoJr^ue Jreql elnfyr senssr l€clEoloqc.(sd.(ue qlvrr

Ieep ol elq?un eq,(etu r(eq1 uorlenlrs snou€cerd e ur IIFs sr dcueprser rleqgl aEels 1eql le uelepue ddereql ur EurEeEue eloJoq Burn€r1 I€Hul eW eruocJelo ol aurl peeu ueuo^\ l€rp uorsnlcuot

eqtr rrMeJp e^39 ela '8uqesunoc ssecr? ollu€1yl lou op Euqcgga4;o secueFedxe qllm ueluo^ller{} s:Be,( el{l JOAo pa^Jesqo e^sq e.,vi JeAe \oq 'ueruoz\t ol JeJU:o uo sr EurllesunoJ :8u5qasuno3

lcafor4 q{eeH s.uoruoly\ eql q}yv\ flesolc sryo a}eu etu?qnl{ repcrged uI 'seornres

I?CIpeIuJo eEuur ? ol lueruru?druocce pu? uo4€rruoJur ueuro/yl sresro €Iuegnu:sans$ qllBoH'ev\erl:eltn ro sEtnpeur ol ureql duedurocce

pu€ secllJes p8al ssecce ueruolv\ dleq sre4rorvr qcee4no 'senssr ,(cueprser Jreql qlrl\ Suryeep,{gensn'ecuqsrsse pEel3o rrrJoJ eruos pepeeu eneq ueuo&\;o flrrofeu orf,L :aruulqssu p8el

'speeu AleJ?s Jre[Il sesseJpp" rlcFlly\ uorlspo{ulllocc"elqqrns 8rlpug ur'sseq esec,(q esec e uo ueruolv\ uoddns ol elq€ ueeq seq etueqng

'esnoq eyes pezruSoceJ e '1er{ se 'eneq lou seop pu?le{ elq \ ',{1e3us Jreql ssess€ o1 sr '8ur1cr.11er1

Jo s(u4cl^ er€ oq1yl 'ueruorvr. qlr^\ uorlue^JslurJo s€3J€ lsJrJ equo euo :uollsporuruoJJs eJss'ueruolyr JoJ ssecc€ pu" stusru?qcetu I€rJeJeJ enordur ol JepJo

uI sJeplnord ecn:es JeWo qlr \ $lro ueu 6uo-4s 8urqsrlqelse sreer( erp relo pe>lJo^r s€q €tu€qnl{'sercus8e Jeqlo {uo$ sleJJeJeJ

". q8norql Jo r{c€e4no ur lc€luoc lceJrp qEnoJql €ueqn)I ut secrlJes sseoc€ ueruol6 :ssoJJv .

'o{url pu€ esgedxe 'leuuosred;o suue} ur "ru€qn}I

uro{secJnoseJ uo IIBo e8nq e sueeru Suqcrge4go srurlcrn eJe orfy\ ueruol\ Eurceg senssrJo eEuur esJelrp aqJ

Surneg;urJ Jo srurlrr1 ol {rona Uoddns s.aruuqng

'Stnreguq:o Sursrruggo su8ls ,(uy .'8ur1eeds qs18uE uo51 .

'elry ro ecrreurv ur1€T'ecr{v 'sdo.rng .,,a}s€E uorg,ft1uno" r,*::'if,Jii;lifijl$ :l€e{ .

!8ur4cg[n4Io *ucln o 8ut$t\uapr u, stotnrrpzl'Eumollog er{l sosn sru€qnu

Jersee r{ue uorlecgpueplel?tu l.useop qcll!\t xelduoc frerr eq uec suoqenlrs Jreql pue dno;8 snoeueSoruoq e lou aJe ue{uo \ er.IJ

-uotlepodep cq?tuolns u€eru plnoo ernsoJosrp leqt pue l€uorsseJoJd ,(ue 1sru11ou uec no,{Eurnerleq otul ua{uo./v\ ruoor8 osle sre>lcgJerl 'sdrqsuorleler 8uqsru} Surqsrlqelse {uory ueqg Eurluea.ardlfpuenbe-rg ,{-qunoc eql punoJ? ueruoly\ oloru ol sr sdturd/sJelogJe! fq pesn scr}c€} IoJluoo eqlJo euo

'suorssncreder

Jo JeeJ JoJ uoll?nlrs erul Jrorp I€eAeJ ol q?noue palsrul en€q lou ,(eu uetuo r eql e:eqrvr Jo ryolr qoee4nouI sJelunocueJerJq Surrnp leru eA\ esoql ele sesec pa4cgffn,u parunsa,td w pepnlcu el?r1 e^\ ueuoff\ er1J

'SuqcrgerlJo srurlorl SurSnuepryo fixelduoo eqt ssarpp? dlaq ot pesnsI pu€ ,{11uuot1euro}ur tuJel pezruSocer e sr qcrql\ ', patlcASo.tt pawnsard, go fEoloururot eq} Eursn eJe el6

Page 59: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

z l

'UodeJ sILIl JoJ Jeed qcse uolleuuoJul

-,prnord sr.u?qng 'enssr eql ol esuodsor s.lueuruelog {4c€e re1ncrued ur 8u1qEr1{3tq'Suqcqgerl

Jo ens$ eql uo uoder epr 4.plro^a € so1elloc uorl€rlsrur{upv ele1s SO eq} 6699,{pee ecurs(A$ godog suosrad ur 8uu1rg;u.ra .

'uor1e1sr3e1 qsFI roJsdorlepueuruocer Srnurllno Srnleeu qqt te peluese-rd w \ UeI ruog uorssr{uqns y '8ur1crgg"JJ uouorlelsr8el Surrede:d erem oq \ eortsnf Jo tueuruede( eql q sl?roggo qlrA\ leru UeI

'?002 IIrdV uI

'ruruoJ Sursrer sseueJ? re pue 8ur:eqs uorle{u:oJur u€ s? }t? ol eq plnol dnorE eqlJoesodrnd egl 'Euqcg?r1Jo enssr eqt Wy\r Eurleap scrtuapeoe pue sl€npr^rpur 'sercue8e pelserelur

go drqsraque{u e en€q plno^r UeI }erll peer8e selll 1I 'ue$rr1y\ uo4nlrtsuoJ e pue dn }es s€1vree$rruruoJ 8ur-ree1g e'dnor8 ar{lJo luerudolenap el"llllcEl ol drqsrequretu s}r pesolc UaI €002 uI

'pu€larI

ur Surlcggerl Surleqruoc ur {Jo1vueu,(cue8eralur 8uo.r1s e Srnplrnq tn elo.l de4 e 8ur.{e1d o1peurturuoc peur€uer V1OT,1E00Z ur pue t00Z ul yel8urqslqs}se ur,tcue8e peel eqt s"lyr €ru€qn5

UaI '

$lro./y\leu pue secu€rl1e Eulppnq q8norql sr

'frolnlels uou pue f:olqels qloq suorlezrue?to leqlo qltrvrEurlcggerl Swlequoc ur ecrlce.rd lseq t€ql selerlog ?tu€qng

Surslug sseuerunav/Supgo,rgelgrrf cu Jo^pV

'etuoq peuJQeJ oql\ ueruol\ 3{uos Jo eleJ eql JoJ suJecuos ener1 am pue elqrssodsq sr{ervrle lou feu JeAeA\oq srql 'atuoq uJnlej Jre{.p uo ecrrelsrsseJo Jr€Ae uec feq} }€q} os

'ur?rro go frlunoc Jroql ur ,{cue6e uoddns € pug o1 .(.4 osyu JIr^\ e{u€qng ',{ssequg }u€neleJ eq} Jo(uor1er8r141roJ uoeezrueS.rg 1uuor1eu,re1u1) ntrOI opls SuoJe 8urryo,n ,{1pnsn 'ssacord uorler.qeder

Jraql ur ueruo { eql sgoddns eur€qnl{ e{uoq o? ol esooqc oq \ uatuol^ roC :uo!lu!.4edag'uorler8elur

l€rn1lnt ro lsrcos pue Surpuel{eqJo eere aqt ur goddnsgo Ie^elq3!q ? sepraord ?rueqn11 'eldoed eq} ro e8en8uel eql Suvrnoul tou futunoc u?reroy € ur se^lesueql

fVurS oqly\ uatuo^r,{q pecuauedxa sseurleuol pue uorlelosr eql o} eno :uollu"r8aluypPogsrelnduoc ro qsrlSug ut sesselc ssetce ueur016 :3u1u.ru.r1,tuoJlsJnpfl

a

a

Page 60: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

€ I

pelsenbay goddng Jo ed,t[

tPb

-*""r"tf"-ud**f *f

--truo"^d

*s,- $ #,"*"

V 00Z/ 80 02 lu erudol a,ra g q8norql'u*uor11 r{q p a s s aocy y oddn g

0zvZo '

8 * ror3c r =nLE9 '8 t

'A\OIeq

u€qc eql ur rrly\orls sr eruruerEord qcee ur usrrrolv\Jo Jequnu eql pu? pelsenber goddnsJo e8uer eql

'ecrlJes eql8ussecc€ uetuo/vr E€Wr.M VOO(, ut req8tq fylqStls se./y\ Jeqrunu eq1 lueudolenoq ur uoddns eqlpesseoc€ ue{uo1y\ 6Z'qO0ZvI

'.,{lrpqereuluJo sens$ Jelncrued 'senssr I€rrpeIN luaur,{oldrug

'Sururerl JequnC '8ur}e8png'eJeJIeAN

I?IcoS 's€ qcns 'senssr ur goddns rog luetudole^eq 1c€luoo uetuol6 'sess€lc 8urpuege .re8uol ou

eJ€ oqlr\ ueluoly\ 1nq Sururerl Jo uo4ecnpe ur ,(11uerrn3 eJ€ oq^\ ue{uo./y\ esoq} ol uerrrS 1sn[1.usr uoddnssIgI 'uetuol,\ aqlol uoddns leuosred Suuego sellolur >lJo1$ luerudolerreqgo lunotuu luecgru8rs y

'dlrunuruoc u \o Jrer& ur luaur,{oldure ro Sururetl 'uoq€cnpe Surssecce ueqzvr goddns lsanber ueruolv\

'seturl .{ep11oq Euunp uele 'ueutorrr o1,{11crnb puodser ol flrcedecaql pu? fitlrqrxag nleet? roJ s1v\olle r{c1ytl 'seturu?rEo:d snouen eqt ut 1Joly\Ss}s pue sloelunlo1

'uetUOlY\ Ol

peJeJJo sl tee.,{ eq}Jo eurl ,{ue }u eruurerSord e Suruur8eqgo ,{lryrgrssod eql 'srelserues Jo suue} crrueps3e

I€uolllpe4 qlr^\ qcleru lou IIr^r lueurdoleneq1 qll^A {ull eql s)ptu ol uortelrtoru eql leql8urzruSoceg

'flrunruuoc Iecol Jreql ut Surural Jo uollecnpe Surnsrnd

eJ€ oqrrl ue(uo./v\ ol Uoddns pu€ esnoq-ur ueuro.{\ oi sauurerSord sepr,ro:d pue-r1s luerudoleneq eqJ

IN]LVdOI] AlC

Page 61: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

v l

.__, 'uor1?4${ntupv pue qc€eJ}no'luetudole^eo'lueuFE"u?IAIJo sJegruelu

- J dn epetu ru?el Jels €ru€qng e ,{q peuoddns servl tueel qor"eser eql pouad ree,{ orvrl stq} lnoq8norql

JO enssreCizr:es

'sercue8e eseql 8uorue uorlnl4sordegt Jo e8pelmoul Jo sle^el oql qsqqqse ot pue qcr€eser eqt Jo sEulpug ,{pea eql3:o srepr,rordruroJur ol se \ asofund eql'1002 Jo reque^oN pue,{eru ul pleq arelv\ sreulrues ISN o1y\J

's002 ulpeqsrlqnd eq IIy( uo4uelJelurJo leporu eql pue qcJ€eseJ eqlJo setuoclno egl 'peprocer ere/v\ s/v\ellrelul

Jo sJnor.{ 0S€ pu€ r{cr€eser Eurureel uor}cv fro}edrcrued s?1( dSolopoqreu aqI 'qcr?esar eql q ged 1oo1eruer;erurt eteudordde eq} urqlvr luerudoleneq qlld\ pe^lo ur are^\ leql ueruo,l\ x1s ,,fi:o;;o trno ueeleurN

'qcJ€eser eql lno perrrec seqceorddy srualsfg prlt{I luewfoldure ro 8uure.rl'uoqecnpe Surssecce ur ecueuedxe uoqnlqso;d ur ueruom l?ql sJarxeq eql qsqq?lse ol se/d eJnwetrAlueuoly\ ro3 dlrpnbg slqr Jo tur€ eqJ 'porred srql tnogSnorqt penuquoc (195f onrturlrul de15 ge51 eq1

alqrqrul dalg lxeg

'suorsses eql ul ]uerus^Io^urpue luetrrtruruor rreql ro; sluedlcrued aql {uerll o1 dnor8 eq}Jo pue eq} 1e pazrue?to se^r luene Iercos V

'€lueqnl{ ur Je>lJolyr luerudolarrao er{l{q pe1e1r1rc€J eJe^\ suorsses aser{I 'lueue?euew sserls.ro Surleeq cqsrloq se qcns suorsses pue goddnsread uaemleq pel€uel1e s8urleeu eql JoJ epue8u eql pue rolesunoc e fq pelelrlrteJ ereln sEurlaeu eq;

'sJeq{ueru Z qlFA peure{ue; dno:3 eql'sq}uoru Ieug eql spJe^ro} pu€

relel Sururoleroru Z ql!x\'t q]p ue8eq s]uedrcruedJo reqr.unu elp pue 11e u: s8utleeul LI peq dnor8 aql

'tuaq] qll ^ peu€tueJ p€q l€ql uorlnlrlsord tuo-r; senssl eql qll^\ I€ap ot goddns -raed3 e^?q 01 qsr^\ e pesserdxa IIe peq feq; 'qceerlno pu€ luerudoleneq qSnorqt ?{.u€qnu qlr^\ s>lurl p€g

Ilris pue uorlnlrlsord Uel p?q oq^\ ueuro,t\ ered\ eser1J 'qcreeser eleryul da151xep eq] roJ dnor8 f.rosrnpeuadxe ue pu€ ueruo./y\ rog dno;8 uoddns ? oq ol su \ rure slr pue I00Z ul ue8eq dnorg uoddn5 raed ar{J

dnorg yoddng raad oql

Page 62: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

SI

'VOOT,'qlqnC - stqilw urrranH uo utruod OgN InnuuY s'ttollY ufiatog lo TuaultndalJ aq1

.'VOOZ't7:.t1-oC 'InN - ,[.qsnryI nS paznoqol)

"qt.Yi!(?(:'toOz 'pleuug

- asuodsall rfuunlua3 l1e - plro1\ ropllil, eql puu puBIarI q qtrnqJ eql" etuereJuor arlurorl'1OOZ ',(pe,reur1 - acaanfuoS qnoag lonras

'EOOZuIIqn61 - 4"toortaN sasyo adoy uoadotng aq1

lse qcns'sacuete;uoc le uarrt8 osle eJervr suoll"lueseJd

o3(Isls{surnof luapnls

'sI uopupunod IuvJ '0I

puul8ug Tt puBIarI.raqla8oa saqrrnqJ 'S

uolsslururoJsrqEl5 uBIrrnI{ qslrl 'tl uolu3,{.tuuo1sq141 t1slrl'6 srotlrllos luePnlS

'?

IuuopsuJaluldlseuuy'91

cJn'selpnlss(uoruoa\ T' {roAA,I8ltos

'8(IJO

,t ra11,u,p1tr41 3o a8e11o3' 5

{JI lrro{sluepnls {roa\ IBleos

'zIesI^pY

sselaruoll lq8ulpl '1

sJluetrlntI

Jo looqts qslrl 'z

iaoFuJ's6oaT lssrotslouul IBlroS Sunoa '1

1 erlutorl '9 puulerl snrod'I'll" apnlcu o] ool sr 1$l olvu ls€l ot{lJeAo

'o1 $ll?1Jo suoqqueserd ueru8 en€q e/vr sl€nprlrpul ro sdnor8 eqryo eluos s1y\ol{s u€qc Suvrrollog eql

'$sanber e[uos u1v\op urnl ol pel{ e^?q eff\ secJnosoJ peltull o} enp 1nq Sursre-l

sseueJe \e ur ued e>l"l II€ luetue8euel i pu€ sJeelunlo6'Susturpung1uerudoleleq'qc€aJlno uIJlt"ls

'uo4ello1dxe

JequqJ ,{ue o1 tueql Sursodxe lnoqlr.ra 'socron Jreql luese:der uec '}ca[ord € s? 'e1vl ]eq] ]ueuodtut

,r 11 .uori.ncreder lnoqlr^r secueuedxa rreql lnoq€ leeds tou u€c feqt 1ee3 ueluoln lsotu pue ewEtls

petrercoss€ egl ol anp ,fiercos Jno tuor; luesqe eJe uollnlqso.ldgo secuesedxa q}vY\ ueruoffiJo aoloA eqJ

'qlI1K {Jo'/v\

eA\ ue{uo^\ oql }ceJJ€ rlclq,vr senssr uo ,t1cr1qnd 1no leeds osl? o} }nq uoll€tluoJul elsultuessrp o1f1uo

lou rqrlrqlsuodser aql lr qlr*\ serJJec uollruSoce-l sIqI 'enssl eql uo f1r-roqlne u? s€ pezluSoce; etuooeq

e1€1l e1\ ',rorlrrlilsord ur penyontn ueruo./t\ qtr.nr ,{llecpcads Suqroll pueleJl ur }cefo-rd ,{1uo eqr sy

'uorlnlrlso1d o1 EurleleJ senssr pue 1;o,ry\ Jno ur lseJelul leleet? ? uI pellnseJ s?L{ slql pu" pes"e]cul s€t{

lcefo-ld eqlJo elgord eql 's:eer{ lueceJ Je^O '696I ecuts Srnster sseueJ?,ta uI eAIl3€ ueeq s€q BluBLInU

)Ntslyu sslNlxy/Ay

Page 63: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

9 I

,{poqs(rrrrrrtro4{ o tnq o7 40 tou s(tJ, peerelcrlJ? eEed orvrl eq} uo Etnpeaq er.lJ 'ecuelol^ tnq uru sseluusrl

lou st uorlnlpsord leql e8essetu € tno spues osp lnq sdrurd pue;e,{nq eql sezrTeururuc .{1uo lou r{clql\

. . edorng ur uotleJst8al Jo lepotu A\eu srrll perq€eJ 'ruls eql ur srueqng qlr^\ ̂ rer^relu. ue '1002IgdV uI

'uepe^rs se qsns lepotuentlelst8el e Eurpueruruocer 'uo4e1stEe1 qsul ur e8ueqc e lnoq€ >1eads 01?rporu eqt pesn osle

"tu?qnll

pussseuere^"'ffi ffi lHfr ,ti,t;'i#J:;::xr:fi ilTtrfr""#,'J3i,":il'ilIT#:J#::qnlc Surcuep del e ut Sutryoztr'pu€le{ olur peIclJ3"-r1 u€tuo^A Euno,( u peg eullf:o}s eq} gclq ̂ ur',1[oo,t4,

pell€c AJ if,lu uo etu?rp./$eu eJo u€ls egl qlr/v\ peprcu\or v\oz z{.lenue1 ur spr€r ?pr?D eqlJo euo

to/g/ga{nlpsell s {eN'{4unoe aqt ssonn sqqc t0 stsatto pun spnH s,{opo| gay,q|of ,r.rou pt ,sn a tu"uru,D^og

..-, u%t stns'pauunq aq of Suouop-do\ "rolTsnd aqt u! pailw sot! tlllqdt '|cafol4 \u?uroil turoqnY aqJ

'sesu.yJo snou€A qlvrl pe8:eqc eJe^\ sroleudordpue u1y\op pesolc eJe{\ sqnl3 auos ,{lluenbesqns pu? spreJJo Jequnu € lno perxec lsan} uorleredg

'sqnlc

eseql ul.{ltleuttutrc eleEllsea.ut ol't002 ur JeuorssruruoJ ep;eC eqr,(q ..lsenf uorleredg,, pell?3 ecloJIsei €preg letceds ego dn Ernues eql pue T,00Zu\ feu:e11fteIAI fq srecuep nE uou o1 slrured lrolr\Jo

uotsuedsns eqt ueeq seq u8reduec sn{tJo SuruurEeq eqt ecurs eceld >1oo1qclq \ se8ueqc luecgru8rs eq1

'3ur1c1;yer1

pue uollnt[so.rd ro3 sluo{ ore^\ 'sesuecrl acuep Jepun ,t11u8e1 8ur1e;edo ellq^ 'sqnlo eseq} }eqlurecuoc slt Sutsserdxe u8tedurec srql8uuuru uoeq s?q stu€qn5'ZO1ZecqS 'pu?le{ ur sqnlc Surcuep

delgo qvrrorS eqt tsureEe uEreduec eqt ueeq s€q Iro^\ erpe{.u Jo secerd lrysseccns .{pelncrged eqtJo auo'fitcl1qnd eer3Jo Sutltene pue senssl Eu4q8rlqSrqgo,{e,n e^rtoage u? eq ol uenord seq erporu er{J

0!paw

Page 64: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

L I

'ssecoJd eW q sgq8 uepplq rrrrro Jrarp peJelocsrp erreq dueu pue 'eJIl uo 1oollno u/v\o JIoLp uo {Jo1$ slqlur lueruellolur Jo ecuengw Eu4su1 6uo1 egl o1 ,!4se1 sreetrrmlo1 'Jslunocue e,ta wolyv\ ualuoly\ egl JoJpu€ €rueqnll JoJ sJopess€qure learE eJ€ slealunlol Jno s,{em dueur 'r{uetu uI oS 'uoqqqsord lnoq€ eleqaldoad qclq \ 'sql,{ru pu€ sJe{eq 'sepft}qle e8uelleqc o} lJo1v\ go saceld ul\o Jrerp w uele 'r$runpoddo

u€ ssru Jeleu deql 'elqepcl€cut osp sr lrorrr dcecolpe pue Sursrer sseueJel\e ol uorlngl4uoc JIeqI

unA qcnagno aqt u,4.todrt r'munqng tltyu.oarynlot'uoty rfuom

'ryo1y\ faql uoqrvr JoJ pu€ Jelunosue ,(aqt uog.u ueurolyl eql uo slenpnrpur s€ e^€q.(eqt ne3ge enrltsod pue ecuenlJul eql erns€e(u o1 elqrssodurl aq plno^ lI 'uortesrue8ro eql ol e8uelpqcpue flrnurluoc 'ssauqse-g s8uuq sllr{s lenpr^rpu pu? luetulrurtuoo 'uor}?orpep

Jo esues rreq} '.e1doed-uo-spu€q, se ecJnose; IryJepuo^\ e Eweq Jraql tuor; u€dv 'uorleJlsrurup€ pue Sursrerpury 'sardereql

enlletuell? '8ut11esunoc 'luaudololep 'uetuorvr EurpueuJeq 'qoue-uno uosyd prre leeJls '.teno peerdseJ€ sJnog eseLIJ 'porred sqluoru eAIeA l € telo 1ee.,r,r red slnoq 7y

'e8ercte uo olnqrluoc sreelunlo4

IJOlYl Jreql ur SJeelunlo^Jo eloj

tuecgru8rs eql enl€^ ol sen{rluoo €ur?qnU 'drqsreuged erul pue .{1r1enbe;o ecuupodrur eql SursruSocag

surrl-Nnto/

Page 65: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

8 I

',(11enuue per\erneJ sr lueuqllutuoc sqluow eAIeAl1 V .'utu?qn)I ol dltltqtsuodser s.teelunlon eq] pu€ sJeeluqol eql

o1 flryqrsuodser s,eueqng ssurTlno slp - pet6rs sr uuod lueueer8y Iue lvrelner eq1 3umo11og .

{awwru8o,rd s71lo ssauar4cffi aql uo Dwoqny ot

4coqpaa{ruot,rodwt waqt Eutuolln puo Maatunlot ot ttoddns &u1do1arcp nqur{u1pot ruauodwtuo st mama"t at11| lcelord eql o]ut .eurq ur Surples sqluo{u eeJq}, Jege pleq sI A\eIAeJ V .

JJsts tue^eler fq ue,u6 sr uoddns 8uto8ug ..IT]S

relncrged sllpeq qlr^\ ecrreprooc? ur lJolrr Jo ?er? eqt ot pecnporlut dllenper8 sI Jeetunlo^ eqJ .'acueldecceJo Je$el e senleceJ Jg€lunlon enrltedsor4 .

l{dnos er? secuereJe)I .

eceld elet s rellrelw lenpl^lpul 6utute4 regy .

sJeelunlo^ errrpedsordSo dnorS ? JoJ pesrue8-ro uaql sr euruerSor4 Eututerl y .

1eqc leruJoJur u€ JoJ uosred-lee qlm sleerrr sreelunlo4 Jo rotr?urprooJ eql 'ru-rog uorlecrlddy peleldruoc el{lJo ldrece-r ug .

1no lues sr rruod uorlecrlddy rru qlrm reqleEol Ioed uolleuuoJuJ ue Jsenber ug .

eJnpecoJd

.setueqng 'c1e se3e11oc

' . puele{ 8uuee1un1 oA, uoq€srr.Ie8r o eq1 qEnorql eur oc f ueru'e1rs qervr

ur JJels fq uenr8 $llel '.qlnotu Jo pJoly\, qSnorql e{uoc ,(1ureu sJee}unlo^ JnO

asn ol euroJ sreelunlo^ o( iiloH

'sreef

o^q lssl eqr q pecnpo4rrr oqe se1Y\ sJeslunlo^./treu JoJ secueJeJeJ ol\lJo lueuermbeJ er{J './y\er^eJ er$Jo

llnseJ se moq€ lqSnorq seSueqc pelnber eq] leetu 01 pepuetue prre polrsrneJ ueeq eleq slueun3op ese{,r T,aJnpaJoJd luaruea"r8y /sourloprnC ry ,trr1o4

reln8er rvrou{ ot le8eq1 errrS plno^\ srql

Jeqnu Jo lrolv\ 0r{1

'peqsrlqslse dl*s./v\ou sr puu IIe^{ pelrolrr seq srql 'relteq sre{ro1\tplno./r\ ueruolyl eql leql osl€ pue 'JeDeq ue{,uo1y\ or.$ /y\oDI ol ta8 ot flrunuoddo

leql lleJ s?1yl 1I 'lueel qceerlno eql ur (5e1s Surpnlcur) srelro1v\-oc rrer.p 01 pue

ol pelceuuos erotu IeeJ sJe{Jo1y\ Jeelunlol dlaq o1 dn 1es eJelr €rJe}rJc A\eu eseql

'qluotu e ecuo sSuleeu uoddns Jeelunlol erll pueile ol ou?^ aql ur qluou e qq8ru 7 o1 .

'resd euo JoJ ecrAJeS qc€er1no leeJls er{t ot .

:se^lesueql llturuo3 o] peIS€ eJaAA sJee]unlo^'pelueureldtur pu€ pearSe eJelvr erJeJrJc 3umo11o3 eql 'ecrlJas srql ur sJeelunlonJo

ur 'pe{ool pue eceld lool ecr^res qceerlno leer}S eqtJo rv\erler e E1OZJo eunf uI:aJIAras qJBo4no laarls Jo raarAau

elor eql le 're1nc4.red

'ecuerJeoxe

Surueel poo8 e ?ureq se IIo^\ se ury pue relq8nel 1ee;3 go Surue,te u€ s?1yr 11 '3uurer1-ur-dnot3 eqlqll{\ setueuedxe Jreq} e;eqs ol Srnuene u€ JoJ etuec sleelunJo^ JJe fllecrlcerd ueq \ 'srq} ur uorledrcryedrc1eet8 ','rres

V00Z 'sJealunlon A\eu JoJ euruerSor4 Surure;1 or{} ur ponloltn ueeq 'sreef eql JeAo

'eneq feql .'e^rl?rtrul de15 rye51, otur qcreeser eql ot pelnqquoc sreelunlon eW'rO0Z eunl pu€'yrdy u1:8uru;u.r; tr lrafor4 rIJrBasaU o1u11ndu1

Page 66: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

6 I

'etu€qnl{

tuo{ erueo uorloru slqlJo Eulprorvr eql JoJ lesodord aql 'uepe lS 01r?llruls 8wqleuos o1 uorlelsr8elrls!{,eqr e8ueqc o} uorloru € ur palol ecueraJuoJ s6uerrrod\ &rua JnoqsT IW'VOOZ reqlueceq uI

'Euqcg;u+ pu" uo4n1llsord uo suo4€pueruluocaJsfr petuoclerv\ pue poder sn{Uo uo4epdwoc eql ul pedleq ?ueqnl{ '7OOT, uI pu€larl rog uodar lsrg

rreqg paleldruoc ueruopllsupFy oruelol1 uo Arolu,rrasqo IBuopuN,tqqoT s6ueuoA\ uuodorng eq1

'uor14ro1dxg

I€nxes roJ uerrrod\go 8uqc1g€JJ eql uo uo4elueserd e eneE erueqng dep puooes eql8urrnp pu? uetuo^ .

tsureEe ecuelor^Jo urn:lceds peorq eql pere^oc ecuereJuoc dep orvrl eq;'VOOZ,(e141 u1 ellseC qlqnqur ecueJeJuoJ e pezrue8ro eegnuuo3 6uuee15 I€uorl€N eql 'flg eqlJo dcueprser4 qsgl eql Eurrnq

'uo4n1qsord epnlcw ol psuepeoJq rvrou s€q lIIueJaql ee$rturum eq] uo ?Iu€qnllJo uorsnpq eq] qlyy\1lmss? I?nxes pue edeS'ecueloll c4seluoc s3 \

eeltrruruoc equo sncoJ eql €002 lpun dn 'geOt ur ueruo./y\ lsule8e ecuelol^ uo ecrod Is?I eWJo gode11

.. eqJ ur suo4€pueunuoceJ Surrvrollog 'L66l ur. dn las s?,v\ eellruruoc sIqI 'uoruo&\ lsuguSy aJuololAuo aoflruuro3 Eu.r.reels JuuolluN eqtrJo sJeqtuelu eluoceg o1,(ddeq,(ren ererrr ?tu"qnll EO}ZrrI

'uetuoA\ 01]uelorl dlpcrsuulur $ uoqn$]soJd lsrll eEessaur ftell e 1no se,rr61r se ,t4snput xes eqgo uoqezlpuuou

eqlJo enssr eql qlt.rrr sleep osl? Iepou eql 'ecuelor^Jo sJols-Bedred s€ pezrFuIIuIJc ele sre,{nqeql pu€ ecuelornJo sruqcrl ere deql s€ 'ueruozv\ ogl JoJ pezlern{uucep sr uotlnltlsord tr?tltr st uollsls!8al

Jo lepour qslportrS eqlJo suo4ecqdun sr.{J 'uetuorvr 1surcEe ecuelorl e s€ uorlnI}sord selels dlreelc pues.0661 elel aql w uepe./rtS uI pelceue sem lepotu sql 'uepe1Y\sJo f€ql ol JelItIIIs lepotu e ol uo[nlllso:d

uo uoqelsr8el qsFI ur eEueqc eql sl Z00Z ecurs €ruerlnU,(q pepco^p" d18uor1s suorlseEEns eqlJo eug

'lrorvrerrler3t srql urqlr'l\ uorlnl4sord Eurees spl?^\ol dcrlod qsul8urcuengur uo Suqrorn ueeq eleq pu? uetuolvl lsuru8e ecuelorl e sr uorlnlqso-rd 1egl selelleq €utqnlf

Nl l/Vol4 l-SN tV>V l)Nllol/

sjeelunlo^ JnoJo euoJo spjo^/\ e{.lJ

ittyt o? at antnluos ol ltodilns aul yuo (aunuodilo ayt au sant0 owryfl\

iiou aooy oym, asoyl UIW aJoys ol laau 'anoy oyat. asoyt $ljl

an"gag J ?uo &qtnba w anagag J asnD2ag afia14a1td {o aug af! du anys ot asoor:lr J,

E11z;equeldeg ut uotltsod eI{} relo >1oo1 ue8utr\tr dr?r tr't00z 01 I00z tuolJ roleulproo] reelunlo^ s€1y\ oq^a 'uraeg epleu{ ol seo8 uorlercerdde pu€ qu€ql Jno

'uorledrcrged

pue lueudolalep 'eorrues Jeelunlo^ Jo ,Qrlenb aql seouer4ue eJlueJ srsrJ3 edey '3'e SrnutalJoJ senrunuoddo pue s8urleeru reln8eg uorlusrueSro eql w feld o1 e1o-r lrySurueeru s eleq sJeelunlonr{c1{ A ur rueel enrloe#e ue Surplrnq spr€^\ol {Jo1r\ ol panurluoc seq eru€qng sread oml }ssl aq} uI

Page 67: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

0z

'speeu Jno lseru ol lr SuIJolIel puu u€A LIc€aJtnO eql Eutceldar uo €002 ut lueds servr

lgz'lz?'relnclged u1 ',(aunof em uory\{ qlrlr uetuo&\ eql trJeueq 01 €ueqnUJo {Jo^4, eq1 Eurgoddnsuo4esnreSro eql unDrlvt s€eJ? Jo ,leuen e UI pelse^ur s31Y\ ',v9t',96? 'ernag peulqtuos eI{I 'suoll"uop

ur pe^re3er s? { Isr<tg3 leuo4rppe u€ pu? tog'ov}s? A slue^e eq} II" uro{ peslel lunouJe I€}o1 eqJ

--' 'V002 fe141ur lerpe$eJ s.{cr4?d'}S q pleq lelrcer I€cISn{u s pu€ lueleSur8uerre Je^\o[] e 1r{E1u eSprrq e 8urpnlcur'sdnor8 eprs$o dq pesrue8ro stuata Surstotpury{reqlo fueu

eJed\ ereql ',grc eql ur sJolrsrl pue sreddoqs Eururegetue 'urlqnqJo $eerls eql uo sloreJ seulslJqJ'1002 requeceq ur dn peqsrulJiem pue 's8tnue^o

Jlrec pu? ler€qec pepnlcul $uelo ?tueqn)I regto

-uoqtntory ulqne aqt .taqfo spual{ tq paqrqntol8uoc s! auur,llnf

-uorlesrue8ro eql roJ 00 I9SA peslerpu? uoqlerer{ qlqn61 el\w-gz aql u€J'euusrJnf 'reuoddns eru€qn5 euo VOOZ reqo}co u1 'ree,{ Sutnrollog

eql sluedrcrued 0E pue t1OZ ur Ued SqIq sluedrcrged 08 rpyvr'eunl ur uotll€reIAI-IUIW .sueuolAeql q uorledrcrued;no pepnyrul rOOZlE00Z roJ slqSrlq8rq uretu egl 'swata Sursntpurl{50 suuel ul

ryi:.-*

)NtstrdcNnl

Page 68: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

rc

'reqtunu eclgo aq1 SuruoqdJo JoleulpJo-o3 Eutsterpung eql 01 8urlurrr fq sn peluoc osl€ u€c no^ 'slueluluoc pue suorlse88nsrno , {e ruoc1e r r r I I I ^ ^e^ \pUe@sISseJpp?1cs luoc I I €u -e3u l s re rpungeq1

'elqucrldde ereqa pre-1ua8 roJ suorlecrlddu leurog e>l€rupue goddns JoJ seqlunUoddo gcfieseJ ol enurluoo osl? JIr-/( el6 'ernllJ s.er.u€qnl{ roJ I"}rA os Uoddnsd;e1un1o,r eq1 estuEocer pu€ elueueS o1 s,,(em elrl€^ouur .rog 8uqoo1 eq IIyn tusetr eqt pue sleo8 umoslt Sutnsrnd tn l€Iluesse eq IIp suoqeslue8Jo pue suoq€punoJ 'sdnor8 (slenpr^rpur

3o goddns ?urnurluoceqJ 's1eo8 ctEelerls s.uorl€srue8ro aqlJo uorlelueueldur eqtJo Ued se g00Z ul ,(Eelurls slr esrl€ug olstr.rl€ {ueel Eusrerpuq; eqg Sur8uelleqc pue Surlrcxe qloq sr €ru?qnU ulqtl& Sursm"tpur{ "to{ anar{ aq1

lueure^lo^ut ,(ltunuruoc pu€,Qrlrqrsuodse: eluodroc ur sesrl€rceds teqt uo4esrue8ro ue ',{lrunruuo3

eql uI sseusng Jo t{cu€rq r{sl{ eqt q}vvr qurl eperu osle e16 'dnorg uuoJeU x€I serlrreqJ qsl{ eql uluotludtctged pue drqsreqruau penurluoc rno pu€ gggT \rca ur peqsrlqslse 1rol$eN ,sresrerpund leeq1\oLIJ erel\ trrJal slql Surrnp Sursrerpury JoJ $lurl f-rerurrd eq1 'Ilolv\ Jno Ip 01 I?rluesse sr. 3urytou1a77

's,reuoddns rno IIe ot lryel€J? f;e,t ere el6 'pepuetw IIe.^.r uoeq e^€q sluele IIV

'enue^er

os€ercul ol pelnqlrluoc ueeq e,r.eq sazud o[JJeJ pue tsoc pacnpe; 1e perlddns Jo pe]euop ueoq eAer1 slueleroJ popeeu slcnpo"rd'e?reqcJo eeg sn ol elqelrele ep€w ueeq o^eq (esnog lunowllr141 se qcns) serlrlneJluolllpp€ uI '>lro1v\ Sursrerpury eql dleq o1 f8reue rrCIr{l pue eurl rreq} 'slllls rrer4} petnqrluoc eneq ,(ue141

Page 69: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

7Z

.J

w7.qITNN&zn09€'e08t

t}z'LE9L,T9€0'62wt'tl0€6'l.t988'0t9r0'9tEZ',T,1t6?'?0riT!,LL188,1

,6?'69t

f f i id;ozf

r 891 €iLE?

w9'LeL

8--l0Tz000'zttt6'6tt

09/'09z€gEr

000 0€099'tze

000'92,

t

Gffi'

GFOagT016'e*zLtzl7,SL'99m'8w6'?lzgt'8,t9'9trz'st9LZ'996€??/egE999'EEz9z'6r,

e0r-TA

fipunSse6rqg 6usee1

se6eqg ryegIarqunoccygpny

s€el PuoFsqoup\erl8 Jololl

euoqdepltuFqJa\py

sad&g acggpeurdnb3 3 qenaneg 'sredag

€oueJnsul pue ||raupaudo;ereg s,rcuo11i1

qso3 0uuu1ge6qsoc uoFuadse|ePs$Es

SiiRIJdEEIS:R

eu@ullelsosrpBpuoc

perapl podag

,:.:,. qusjglEol

rcuepunol eusl uallvapo5 ue pup1al - rxroFg nxe'l I ltlpnb3 ecAsnl'p $eg

ueuogl.rol {genb3 - uuopg mel 3 i{1pnb3 acusnf p ?dagp€o€

qpeH €ery ujeFafl\ qnosFruI eFFI.eqO trreuuqul alqepaqg eq1

uorlp3opu -€cr^-E)s epJFM pue uoqeqoueo! ras alEpM flt€ uoqpqojd

99 uolpas' - Pjeog qpaH uaFPf

SlNVUg3n05Ni

:J

991'rZZ062

6t0'/09

mTtEgt 0l,699'Sl.t

ttt'29

000'00e

vrz'9tl

5i emz rmz I

:@a*EEEE

'lAs#ess;pasls ax?a3aa€ee?3

Page 70: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

EZ

Ermon.{1e16sreuoqelg s{euool

uebeg,g;eqe3e qeorSs0o

eEelIoJ s1IroIIeH IIVuullsutloJ utlof

luoo led

x*a[*xd aa{} ** c"&eddaas "fre.*e-*S*l*e ;rp3,t***a**x4..*.e #aea,ra*$q+ #q$,*e,'?srsaasw&aaa $"$?3*{f}d.*ixaqrspanau3. -rr1$ A}€ }g1{si4+ $a a{saq& #,&4

P;4e-d411ePP1eory {uo1

dqd:ny1 esfleql?e0,o ueqqors[p6,9 ueqqog

ue \oopyl Blroqsue6:oyr1 uoieqsp4rls uouueqslpoM ecaeqeu

o4rs e|c|llednleu oqol snuapolrN

usl selowrN{r4t4cy1,{eyrl

ue{g tuey1eoqouo6 fuey1ues;epeg fueyr1

uebueyl peerleyl

{;pg er;eyy,(e1ee3 et06ey1

)HqPdtH eurlopeyl11rqe3 uuAl

done6 euelolu€^rllns,o Bpurl

fu:g auueelsbuqseg etnel

peuue6 i{gryue66ng uqop

tu.renogoyl tnboepllaxel euqoH

/lepulep1uelagpeals ualeHueloN ueleH

uosuqou qeuueHeeg sturilS

uebneg regJeqpJ?c sssuurd

uPuxeuuz acnl ehell,iqdnyl:eqs1Aassng euu3fuee1,g ue16fuee;3 uaelq{e6 eudu{6

uer{51ate6arooyl arpirso

eu{6 apuel eneloCe0eneg etet3

snrlaqr0 ouqsuqS{lreg eule3uoos elleS

{perg,6 etu:egseqOng eleqleg

u,op3 eruoluvueq€uol uuv.raqg elebuy

uollr0 epueulv

$#a#aei|?€s tl,\ e€,aa€;.$g*s

qboo) e^llose1d1g el1eqcry1

dqdnyq aueloyl{puuo3 aneyl

ueOueyl tuey1r{aeergcytr 1erc6:ey1

qcur{1 leLebreyl

--Iot!egIeX ''-- -rouuoc,o euruegll€n\sN sJileparl

uo6uqou s$ueJlsrouuo3 euiurldpeuuey,6lep3

,{uuey eLpLtegfuepelg ere13

{qe1ueelq1eyU/rIrolE etlnl

oqcou.ro]ruuofuooysrl euefunee eplourl

Ielrrog ourperoe

. 1{: 1: : "i,f,i:-iT{g.t v7,3 i4 i''; 3,;3 43&4,j;? 4t\

Page 71: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

v7,

er-ffimIffi :qs,n q'eurpqru@Empe :[eu-s'99209€e ( lO) :xpf '26C09€S ( 1.6) :euoq66 u1qn6 'erpuoorxru6 'peog

ryedoag 'ano;l roueg 'e6e;;o3 s,roilpH llv u! p€seq s! eueqnu

srqsls peqdeqg poog[ueq3 p [pe1 rno lo srolsrs

saa$ruJl

0uudg pr6:yr;llouuoo,o ztl sy{

roJeuas erynog,g fuey1 sy1rol?uss'6'y1 fuue11 fueq sy1

pp:e64r3 seouerl syluuqng e0e11o3 fitsleruup luepsa6 eao6so3 py.ry1

'd'3'l4l ltloueg iteyl sy11$${}.{}'sd

suoqeuog fue1uqo4uoppunol auel uollv

eo:o1 6e1s6ru6 pco1fi3 reuul qlnoserrsesill uau:o114 .ro1 dylenb3

tsrul qqEusr.n fueur4u1 qqEpeq3preoE qFeH eolvFeoS tse:l

ecrrues ore1ol\;1 pue uoqeqoq eq q0no:q1 utoleu /nel pue fi1enb3 '€ollsry p pa4lede6s.8a{r$73$

ueqoeqs urf r0uertg egeyl ouuvls

ueO.euo1 uqof ry1rque9 qe)l r0

uollnS ernen sylBsqgo usaroN.ls{ppy1 srurag rSaryng 1erfuey1 rg

s-lo:Jalrolo preos

su! e0 euqdeop sylAqdnyl elroq5 lS

rouuo3,0 suuv r0ue0:o11 euueqof $

rcpl ur €)lr0

6'11ue6:eg rcnet1-ry1

Page 72: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

F'

5a:I !uni !&ol Sur l joddn! iu lu ju laLcS

\

i tt it lr l

? a : I I : - : i , . r J i . i r a .r . ; J ; : ' " ; - , . . . i : : , . ) ' i . i { . . " j i . . : . . - . . t . . f - .

- , , , , j r - . " r " t ' , r t ' " , . " r . , - i r c . " ' . : , , " .; : { ; i l t . l . r i . " ' - : 1 } ; v r J i " . ' . ' " , i , ; . ' , i ' 1 i . : . i

d . " 1 -

$ . ! , : " . 1

:,' !:

;;t.xrtlI"".li;'qi:;*€"i f'ii ::;i {}.F'strifi**;'.*.i,"-" E

ee$sss eiffi$$w*$ $ddw &*srs"$d

g&&ffi * m&#ffi

^orr*rrtlff.ff"

\

&1r'4-ry.

lvxorrvx

nl{flJlVDOt r{'!t]dounl

ffiws?ffiwffiffi ruffiffiffiffi MffiS A&$TWffi*ffi

.f"ifi*.

,''#*#F

o1

Page 73: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

alqt0t la ,J i peLraep aQ 1lu i . s t_ro i le3 i ldde a le i lo ipue a]atdLuooul

al-leqod@ntri ao] pal lPt iJa aq p lnoqs t r l jo ] uol le3l lddP pala ldLuo3 aql jo uots len Jtuot l3ala auO

Z U ! IqNC' l s sa l l oH

asnoH ) ioojq loH

leqoda-tnsesr ! uaujoM to j / { ] t lenbf

:o] paujn ls j aq p lnoqs suuot uot le3r ldde pau6ls pue pala ldtuos o i I

u l-d 0O'g W AL1Z aunf urgp Aepsaupetr l :a1eg 6urso13

.a1ep 6urso1: Ournno11o;3ql ^q leqod o] pau:nla.l aq plnoLjs uorieiuourncop 6urpoddns luena;al lle pue Lu-ro3 uorierrlddepalaldLuoc aql jo uorsra^ Jruo;]oalo 5E6 pue sardo: pau6rs punoqun onnl leqi alou aseald

'gg aOed uo is l l \3aqc aqI ut paurl lno se 'urol uor lecr lddeslql ql!^,\ pa]liLuqns aq isnul leq] uolleluaLllnf,op alll 1o alou lelnsrped a>1e1 osle plnoqs sluecrlddy

(atnseary uauaAA n7 fypnbl) at Eqadwv,A/n .leqod

fuo1eue1dx3,:aysqam Ourmolgol alil rxorJ alqeltene are lallooq ,s1urg ;n1d1aH ? saloN

aql pue saloN ssueptnc ? uotleurjojul 'urjoj uorlecr;ddy 1ca[o.r4 aL{} jo serdoc Jaqpnj

'6urpun; lo lelv\BJpqlli!\ aql ut ]lnsa.l ltlm sluatl;alrnbe.i asaql qpm a:uerlduoc

jo asuapt^a fuopelsrles aprno;d o) alnltej 'punj lersos ueado:n3 aq] pue sjieJJV ]q3e]lae3

pue {ir1enb3 'rfirunLlruto3 }o luau.rpedag aq} 'leqod

}o s}uauloltnba.r Ourpodat pue fetsueug eLl]qltnn dldluoc o1 paltnba"r aq llyv\ suor;esrueOlo Ourlou.rold 'lcafold aql Jo aurloltl papafotd aql $uunc

aulrl stql a:ojaq pelJncut slsoc lcafo"rdspje^ ol alqelleAe aq lou 1|tr'n outpunl 'alnj srtll o1 suorldarxa ou eq llt^^ oJaL.lI sarped lue^alaj lledq pau6ts ueaq aneq sloe;luoo aouo pellnour slsoo lcafoLd splen^ol alqeltene aq {1uo 1pm 6urpunS

's1eOte1 lenuue

peel6e-a:d jo iuoLte^arLl3e aql pue 6urpun] elels ,ro rilpqepene Ouro5uo aql ol lcafqns 'slea{ elor-uJo euo JoJ pepueixe eq {eut q3lqM '}3er}uo3 :ead auo ler}rur ue o}ur Ja}ua gilan spaio:d lnJssamns

-txro' uo;;ec;gddeaql u! pautllno suollsenb aql Lll!/n alelsJjo3 asaLll se sloN asuBplne ? uolle(xjolulaql jo g e6ed uo paulllno elralrlJ uollcalas oql ol uotluslle Inlsles Ied asee;d ,uor11ppe u;

u.to] uotleorldde aqyOurlagdu.roc ol,roud lollooq ,s}urp1 lnldgaH g saloN fuo1eue|dx3, aql ol ralar pue e t0z-0t02 srnseortuauroM rol i{11enb1 aq} lo} seioN ooueprng ? uor}eurolul all} peaj o} palsanbal a:e sluecr;dde lM

uorl3npo4ul

Page 74: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

z

sluouairnbaj 6ur i lodal pue 6ur lunocs€ leraueurJ 'JUaura6eueul ]3efo jdJol I lt lrqrsuodsar lenlcelluoc aleuapun o] poleurluou aq lsnur uorlesrue6ro i i:olnleis peal e ateLir pue ]caforde;o fuanrlap oql ul suollestue6;o d.ro1n1e1s uaa^^]aq uorleroqelloc e sr aleql a:aqm sarldde uorlesrueOlo peel ,

686, . luauJqsllqelso s,uoriesrue6io,o elBC

suorlesrue6ro ssautsng B uotun apell 6'arorllo tl uorleslueoro drqs.leuped letcos

? ' l

T

unl l

tr

Japrnold 6ururer l pesru6ocag

uol ln] t lsul uot le3npf

(gy3 '[1uoq]nv leool

'3fN {:o1n1e1g

uorlesrue0:6 letueuJuranoC-uoN

a!'nwognt' rttd,t,.t4. :AllSqsM

89249€9 '0 :oN xel'6 ultqnQ

'eJpuoswnJQ 'a6alp3 slvlolleH ilv 'asnaH Joluasr

eweqna

n duedu.ro3 iuauldolo^s6 le3ol

I uotlestue6lo s,uaulog

n palo:d 1ueudo1ene6,t1tunr.uuo3

tl dno.ig fue1un1o4y,t]runuluto3

at' outoqnt@utsroJ :ltetrf

z6ea9ffi ro :oN auoqdatol

:ssaJppv

:uorlesrua0lo 1o aulep 1ebe1

:uorlesrue6:o :nor{ saqtJosep lsoq sst:o6a}ec butmolloJ aLll }o qcll.lM g't

at'nwnqnt@qons :ltelrrf Z1ZAW7 r0 .oN euoqdagal

oJc :uorlrsod

A/OSN3g HyUyS :eurEN

;esodo.rdsrr.ll uo ser:anb Jemsue oi (s1e1rdec 1co1q ur) uos:od lceluoo;o uorlrsod pE auep Z',

'cp psoo gnJf' uotfi]qsuo7' uo1enossv jo sotcrtJvlu npueJowery' a' r Neunoop 6u uterro} s,uotlexue fu o

tnal uo sJeedde lery eweu eql pqpr ppoqs uarJesuebJo nofi,1o aweu p6ol eqf

1uec1lddy luerg 1. ' l

'1uerO e rol 6ur{gdde uor}estue6Jo peat/iupor;dde 1uel6 aq} of suteped uot}oes stL{f

,NOrl rsrN v 9a o sv:t1/t NV 3 t7 d dv J Nva I

sllelao uollesluBoro- t uoll3os

,raqwnN aaualolaulpo asn aoulo JoJ

Page 75: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

bu!l!r/ ut aq ppoqsp^ardde qens slsod JJels Juoueurad puot\tppe/A^au ile a^oJdde lsnLu pJeoB a{lJ o

'DullulA ut aq plnoL.lspAudde WnS 001'fi raAo oJnilpuedxa pelabpnq-uau pe anofide lsnuJ p.]eog aql o

5uquln & aq pfloqs pnafideLpnS '000'93 ol dn sgunowe Jo a.jnypuedxe pepbpnq-uou anodde uw OjJ oLlf .

'peog aqllq etuenpe u panoLdde aq JSnu Junoue stqJ aAoqe slunouv 6u111ttttt u aq ppaqs yenaLddeWnS

'000'0yg o7 dn sJunaule Jo arnypuadxo palabpnq enotdde Aeru 933 ety o

pnotdde en1tpuadxS

.ace1d ut sfc;;ual pnueuu sureldxa W!Lt/v\ 'Uoaqpueq s,eweqnA wo4 fitecx7

'6ur1eu-uotstoap ontlnooxa pue slo:luo3 lelcueut] ol uollele:ut uollestue6lo;nod ulLlllm aceld ut ele teql ssinionlls yueua6euelu eql aurllno asesld

'uo;1es11dde oql qllm slunos3e palpnp lu€JsJ lsoul,o r{doc e asol3us aseold

60az Lalgelra^e eJe slunossE palfpne L{JlqM Jo} lea^ lue3aj }sour all} s! }EqM B ' !

'paureluteLu sr lo.tluoc letoueu4 jo rllol lelln oleis aseeld ',oN, Jl

I ott I sei

aslunoos€ sl Jo ypne lenuup uE lno fulec uoqesrueB:o .rno{ sao6

'uo;1ec1gdde aql ql!/'l requnN AH3 pue 331iEEiIfr5.rnod go {doa e lltuqns osesld

egnLAHC requrnN f] oru 1' sa1 raqulnN Lt f-l3) sn]e]S €lqe]uerl3

uoqeuydde aq p alep alll6u4e:.slq apcryyao eJueJealo xeJ e n1 perflde seq uayesuebto nai leq] wJrluai aseald ,CIN, Jl

ALA7, rcqura;dag qg :aleg,(lrdx3 il oN I s€A (CCJ alecrlryeC aouereslC xel

:eneq uotlesrueOlo lnod saog

'uo;1ec;gddeotll r1lrtn luaurn3op 6ulu.reno6 sruo$es!ue6ro rnof 1o fdor e asolcus aseald

661602 :iuedwoc parcTa5et g )equrnN OAC

'aaluetenb rtq payw11 luedtuoS

:3le setletxos luept^old ? lptjlsnpul'JepeJI slos 'elnlelg dq peqsrlqelsa uorlesrue6:g 'lsnlf 'uoqercossv page.rod.rocutul'1'aolueJenC fq pepurtl rtueduo3 '6'e ernlcnrls ;e6a1 s,uorlesrue6:o:noA aie3lpul aseald

6',t

L ' L

9 ' t

9 ' ,

Page 76: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

[ l : t ,aq s t . s ; , ro r r r . ] i ; .9

f i i t t r ; te ' i € ) )a i ] ! . ) ia j ro t t i s ; t i ,1 , f iL t t t i te , t j i , ]o t )e : )n i )o leL iuo ] ja l t ta o j DaoL l.t l t t i t ,) f iLuaLr, art i l sl l trs ' l i2r i i t t : t( ' i ct i l i0 {: !Ltcs s'a / /J,, , ,1 s-8 s-r/ i /s let.}oslod cloiei,aD oi 6ttr4aas

i . lS t ,Udde St jS t !OL i f ; S i lY f . l i ) t ! tL , ) t . )5 ( , j ' J \ t t !_ l L i ( ) i )e )e t ia t t l l t i e t ; i , iO i ( t r , tO pUe LJAt jeOlpa .bL t tUreL i

( i t Sg i , ^ t " t l i t i t t ' tL t t i t . !CJ [ ) t te L t tCaJ isu ie t ] r 5^S 'a i3e a l / , lnedea S t , tg ( . -L . ia f i \ aq l sp l ino t l3 r t l , .u4' f i t r t t t te t i i t t t t t t re t i -a tc i p o tu tue , t f ;o " id e psco la^ap aAeq tuec ;1u : , t t . i t c lo laAaO eLUe{ lnA eL lJ

-e U t I e, Ll,] u-a n o 5 u e 4jEi t ] | s o d B t t e -q

W oj5j o I s a | | t u n l t odal oJtatll aluequa pue !f4s-dn oi y/a^.\ attt. alf"l

st ant]1 |€t\a^rcH 't{;atxtte pLte Joptastp ssal,is JqeLur}uJ-lsad aJ Leltuls sat\ln\Ujtp leuotJoLueyqtLlxa Aew ptte so3LtatJadxa JIaLll iq pas4euJneli l lauatlxa Ltaaq a^eq llyn iiuofeLu

eqi uotltppe ul sllt4s aEenbuel ,to lcetayl qst16u3 poJtLutl sr ilaLlJ ssseJ a1t/os ut pueLra&jolA peLjttu aJe stpoia eweLinE ruaq,M QJttM Uowot(r aLll ]o uotl-tocJo,d a6Le1 e aJUeJSLlr

)oJ le.tn]ln7 pue A|ute1 'PstsALld 'lettbc-t1ot1cy',sd'puoslad 'puotJenJts burpnpursla^ai]o JaqLunu e ]e ]stxa souJeq aL!-L la\Jeur Jnagel aql )o 1urure,tlDurssacce LJalerpatuutr

Luo4 LLlaLll ytanaLcl W!]]'/v\ sJau)eq xeldwoc jo a6uet e oJe] dnoL6 lLiatp s,euetlng

uotlrtilSaLd Lq papage uaLuotu\ Joj satyunryoddo yauLdola^ae pue 6utute.t11o ttorstr'oLd s;r t/c) Sn3ol l!t/"l eLueqtlA WM1 aLll o1 uo7ecrpde stLll jo asodLncJ aql Jal

:ftuaudop*ae pue 6uru\etl etueqny) wautla4uf o, ssaJoy ( j - puetls uasoryJ

uawa+ jo suazop LllrM peluac anyoddns pLUJoJssal a\eLu llt^ oot^Jes poseq-lauls q}eaJlno Jno uatJtppe ul uauJo/1^ 0B pue qg uaa/\^laq

to uoddns 5utobuo pue perrp at11 u pabe1ua [yar,tpe s euJeqna 'qseq llqluotu e ug

'a^aqe palelsse uoq7unj 6u[qqa7 ptte 3tt.srcL-ssaua;enne ue seq osp eu]e{Jn6 1uruetl p yautdolartag

pue pp jutllasunot '6usnoL7 'qlpaq pJuaw'sa3rruas uo!]3!ppe 'qlpaq pnxas) soc/^rasrta4 o7 le,uolag

'sarytof'Aasec tlbnoqy lceconpe g yoddns pLtorJouta oua oJ atlo 'sar/ruasjutpttau|ag 'uot1rytpo.td

laeyls ut uautoltn oJ saJJn;as qsea4nO 'apudoLdcle eJoL.yA uaLuoMoJ a3ueJs/sse leapetd aJetpsu[UrI 'uorlepourtxoJ}e eles Acua1Letul 3pnp'Igdc.|/Ueg

-uo1n1rysotd lo llolsttS e ateq oLli uauo/v

pue 'uoryeltoSdxa pnxas 1o asodtnd aq1 n1 6ut4ageL7 p suJt]Jt^ ale oqM uaLrJo/\A 'uoqnypotd

5uryxa ue aLll1 uaLuoM'uoqryrpoLd JaoLJS-Uo pue ]aaJls-uo ur pa^pnut isyattncae oqlA uaulaM sapnput dnofi potp ouf uo4ny6otd [q palcage ueLua^A 1o secuauedxa

So a6uet peaJq aql laauJ ol saJ/ruas ausueqatdutoc p a6ueL e saprttotd etreqnA

'paltoldxepue poryrpafqo eq o] Jou 1t161t 4at11 pue uautol,^ 1a s1q6y ueunq pue fiyu1rp aql ro] Tcadset

p apnuud otlt Luo4 saTetado pue aouapt^ paseq Jepua1 7o uuoJ snouas isoru e salnylsuo1uotlry\sosd 7et11 sauujoca| uo4estue1Lo et11 'uaLuoM ol sasne3 ll leq uJJeq snouos

aql pue uorplrlsoLd /o anssr aq uo 6u61et ssauaje^le pue jwtrqqat ]o pue uo4nylsotdlq pepage uaurat yoddns a] 6peJlp bul4ton acuauodxa sJeai i1uery ja^o setl eueqnA

:{y1enb3 lepuag iloddns o} so!ll^!}re pue sn3oJ etueqnu

'alnseaf{ uauo6 rol ftr1enb3 aql }ostxle llels^o aql pue puejls uasoqc :noA 1o sujre aq] 'r{ylenba rapuao o} uot}elaj ur acuauadxa

1e:r1oe:d ,{ue Ourlectput uorlesrueO:o :noi{ }o so3rn,t oslso!}ll!}3e ulettr aq} ou}llno aseald 0t't

'sJolcarla preoB z $eal p rq pano.tdde aq Jsnr.il a^oqe pue epefi peua\eueutJoj sJre4uoc yautioQLa7 A3O aq| trq paufits aq ]snur s:.r.e4uac patuf,oldutl r

6u4uan u sq ppaLls pnosdde t,rns -pJeog aql iq aJue^peut panofide aq lsnu a00'01) uet11rc1eefi s peJJUoJ atil p anp^ aq] aJaqi sasrNos )ojspeJiuoJ 'OJJ aq] Aq paubts pue panoLdde aq Jsnruu sar!^ras )a! s]eeiJuoJ 'r'ltlu!

1v .

Page 77: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

i l i r j AS - , C i { 1S r .1 i 3 }O iA tA l i i eL i . } eL lnA l JL t i L i t eJ i iS i r t | t L t r ; a ) t t i tE S ; t i J S i J , 1P41O l S4 t . t i t AJ t i ab r l ;O ;L ; tbt l ip ; tnq cSi? Jt i t iA, t iutLt ieel jL)at i ! t iJo[ . ] pue ejer iL- , .e D;. ;e a i j lL l rEtSord s/( l i iSAi l ; ) i , ) a i c i l i . t i j t roS

A ; pOAL i O t \ pUe iS , t ! , aS -O j i 8 L . tOL i lO r 'A pAS i ! aL |5 j r 2 t l , , ( l / . r . l i 416S ' . j e IU t tS e aD iAUC l O j S - t r J { . /ODu,1e4 taqp lJcccjrls ol pob aLil s! l l aiiU/U au;tj e ulas $leJ /i,etLt stul s^otLiJe oi as {)ue

alep o] \Jo/; ', Jno paloddns al.eLl pqj sos jnosat y'teiuny:t pli e sd/{/sr/ot}eial p 4tal aqj aqiet;t ttcipstuebJo jaqiaue jaj abualleLiJ e inq f)auieujsurt]tL] aq ueo leLll lapoLtl e aptnoLcl o1

s i ) l Joh \ s l r / l / o t . u tea leLu t ) ! naq l 0L0zLaqapaUta la ldu toscq i l !Mpa fud1o1 tc l i ua tnca t l 1

atutuesSoLd /nlssa:Ons LaqJoue unL oJ palenlrs Apcaltacl st eLueqndAenatapun Agtta,urtc \loln eql ]o LtoqenleAs aq] Luo.rj 1uruLeal lo4 at17 qJtfu\ 'ppour

luaraqoJ ejo aOJnosaJ aq] aAeLl i l t lA eueqtlA stea,( lueut La1 stseq pinU atout e uo 6ttroSuo uaeq or'.eLl

leql YoM ytawdolonep ]o seo|e utelJoo lLtourn3ap pue astpLu.toj 'ocueque o1 firunyoddo

aLll eLueqn\ paptojJe setl AentLapun IilLlaunJ oututeL1atd 6urureLyatd Warttty etl I

qteotdde ,, i le sllt ozts auo,.e ueql JaqleJ JueotJilJed qjeo JoJ spaa{r pnpt^tpLil Lto paseq st actpetd aql leql po|nsua

setl aJUauadxa s,etueqnA paApALJt tELLlotA q}ea Jo] s.)Luaqno a,uysod pue uotpdtctyec!as:{lttxeLu ol alqelte^e si poddns leuotJoLt to a)nsua ol s/seg Spoau e uo J$Uo/v\aSeJ

e ol osle ssa33e o^eq sJuedoqed ilV 6ttute4 pue 1uruLeal dnofi qlua saceds \ututealauo oJ aL)o jo lypqepene oql iututquioc yodclrts ,punorc-deL/A, ]o q3eudcle ar,tprtouttt

aql 6asn st euteqnA 'sJeof ua] Ja^a Jo] solt^Las aq] ]a pueJls pnruc e uaaq seq Surutetl2 luatudop^aQ uoqnylsotd yxa o1 \utldtuage LlaLua/\ 1urcel saloeisqo eql p \urpuepLapun

daap e sPq os 6BGL aJuts uorynypoLd lq papage ueLuotv\ t11rnn 1uryLoa uaaq se[l eue(lnA

s/a/\4 ffi paacxe lau pflotls fueutusns s1r7t spafo-rd 'tegrrurs 6ulanr1appua 6utu6tsap i . r l s" t { uot lesrue6:o - rnoi { leq i acuauadxe snorna;d due aurglno asealo

'puerls IAIMI slq] repun ;o1 parldde aneq no{ leq} s3i}t^t}3e pasodotd ail} o} p.re6a.r q1r44 Lr-,

a u tuet Sotd p audolane p 6ur tn eL1-atd s|t anutluoJ ol oJnseory uaILaAA n1 lypnb3 aql uJoJj 6u1pun1 \uqeas st eLaetln1

ffimZ eL17 tS1noLqT L LAZ q onu4uoJ o1 papoddns sr lcofoLci aq1y uadaep pue enuqLto3 ppoM pq Al4uoLtnc r{enuapun ssaco;d slLlJ) ,'sdno.tb pasrpu6tetu

reqla qyM pue '6ur4ct1tret7 6wp.npur norp44so.td Iq pe4cage Ltawolu tltrM papJ4dat aque} ]eLJ] 6uurctyed ja ppow e ]o uoqeJueunoap pue yatudolarep lqaJaLl] pue uotlenleAj

guauAoldutapue 5ututetl'uoqeznpa u sleo}.lrcq] auatqre o] Luaq] yoddns pue uo4edrctped

Jtaql alqeuo il!/v\ Ll3lLyA sa3/413s ol ssa3Je aNa}il Lrauto/A arll ilnsua ol sJappqaYelspue SJapho]d actaLas uaalAJoq uoqeJaqeffoc Lcuabe-teJy aJuerlua pue do1ar,,ag

'saryunyoddo pauLloldtua E uoqeznpa '6uueJl weaJJSuew a] uotlsueiJ s7uednrye6

6u14crye4 6u1pnpu1 uorpltlsotd lq pelcege uaLuo/l jo ]uoutJolt^oduta pue yoddng

'yatulo1dutel6u1u1et1p seoJe ^ro)u- liupep arc lat11 uar.lnt aleudotdde se sJeqJaln ase1s,euieqnA utotl yoddns pu4ced pue puoqauta 6uo6ua oJ ssaore pue yoddns \uytopaut

peJo#o aJe pue eae plalJlaqg u1 6u1u1e4 pue uorleJnpa 6urssecce u payaddns aJe uouloMasaL\ 'yoddns 5wwetyatd poau ]ou op pue guatuioydtuo uata to uo4eonpe uneoJJsugu)

JaPa a] rtpeaL aq ieu oq/1A ueulotA JaLllo qy/1 \Ja/n as,r- ueal yautdalaAaA oql

'punJ uotle^ouul svt aq]tuotl 6wpun1 qltrt '0

L)z raqopa o7 iLenue; utoLl pa[oL4 r11u6ig aq] wqttlt^ peppd ilseutol

Page 78: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

{

, , S i eSOdOjd rC ] ?3, rL l - r - i paL l r e l dxa s t , c t 1 l p t , c3 0 j 133 i6 i 5 iES^ eL lo ueL , i ] S i c r l j r o1 6u rp . . r ; ^ , ; ; c 1 !€ r . € l 1 i : ; enbesqns I p . J sd r , o iS

spaau pnp^put uo paseq ,{ytedec Jaq pilnq q3!L}/1/1satlJunlladda 1ututeo1 dnaLb pLte ouo oI suo tlltw LteLuo/vr a.g sopt^olcJ eutueL\oLc| at11

*- pa6eue u s ualleJJadxaaJnsi/a oJ fssaJord tun$se u y) aienSuel qsry}uf 'Aceso1r1 'sLilery ytetudolertep

puostad n isnTe;s aJuaprser q]ffi asottil Sutuueld nateJ Lro srlco] f eut .srye1s a1uap.5a.ts,ueuJa/14 e o7 aleudatdde se lna pe,JleJ puotssasoLd acueptn' -taeleJ e z{q Suau.rssassy

s1eo6 paljlluap!-jlas a\arLpe o1 sien uesd pue ls4uap al Jsr; slqeua ilu$ Jaq q1v'tr t16na41pa4totrtt loolffi .i}ueldltdllce ue elqAA ']aur ue spaau pct\olotlcAsd pue pluaui 'Se1.5t{t4d

iaq Wq aJnsua ol padolanep * ttEld atec e pue Ja\Jon Iay e peu6rsse v yredmyed tlcel

p4reu rnagel uada eq1 u!tlt!/^ pautioSdutao; ssa:6o-rd at Luaql olqeua pue uoqe7npo pue fru1u1e4 jeqlrnj raluo a] spoddns

ssa33P pLle uotJewJolu! 'slllrls slseq 'asuapuuos aql ql!/v\ uraln apaoJd o7 auuetjotd1upynq t{ycedet p oJ ssaoop qyn dnoL7 IeBJet aq1 apmofi aI sr u}p s,aututeL1otd aql

autuset6ot4 yuatudapaeg 6wueLyet4 eueqng :atrieN lcafor6 Uosr.tl

dpnnme paaJxa lou pnoqs iLetuutns vt11lesodo"rd a-rns6ayl uauloM Lol [1rgenb3 :no,{ 1o fuer-uuns l3uoons e oprno;d aseaiJ 9'7,

LLAZ aunr upt\lLoz aun[. urog ajo]3q

io uo oq ysntu) a;eq pu3 pasodor6

'pefo.rd s:nseay11 uauroM .rol dlgenb3pasodo:d aLll Jo .aseqd real ouo ls;tl aL{} ro} sa}ep uorla;du.roc pue ue}s aq1 f};cads aseald rz

pasPq ulnnc st ewutet6at4 fu1unoc aqt ssoj3e tuotl sluedtayed of alqercAe s/ ssa33y

lesodo.rd rnod ur papnl3ur aq o1(s)eare crqde;0oaO aq1$rrads aseald

autwet6ot4 peutdoSaneg 6u1u1etyat4 ewetlnA

1cafo.r6 pesodo:6lo a[U_ ,-Z

"a|eilbpun ol a$odotd nor( leql pafold ainseoyl uauroM ro; {1genb{ oq} ol'sailele"r uot}cas srrl-1

sllela€ l ord - z uoll3as

'ztoz, /LLozut ue6e autwet'otd p {ens uru al e}ep oJ )eoq a1y.sfunog ecuauedxa pue asryadxa 'sfr}s

z'z

alPO 1.tels pasodor6

Page 79: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

, , 1 i 3 i JC3 :1 i ) epL i? : b t i i L j t e ) i i e uC t j e l tA t A j jA \ , . j eL , t i l Aqe t d i t i O l SSd j t e A , ^L7L i O l pAZ t . j o t l l ne Ag l i e t l : ;

, 1 . i o1 | i a ; s ; l i i t u j i i i j i / a f / sa ; l A i I t j t l e i s r . l n t tA [ i J t i . l t . \ j ap i i n so tn i ou l ] ( l ape l t eqs ^ued , 4Je l , .

sapt^ot{ t t }ot lUa,4 i to3 ddoJr}1 Jo l t : r t lu03 aLl l Jo , zL e pt IJV

.leqi srlr?ls 'sirosrad ut 6ut4i4tret1 Lto losaloLd

N[] pue sbutag ueutn]1 ut bur4t41eLl putebe uatjcy/ ua trat]Lta^Lro3 adoLnl 10 ltJLl]oO 6.Llf

ryo/v Strl| ut Ssuppeol sJ(tuaile eue{lnA WtLl^ }o lle

'poutluapt osp atan spoddns jusnotl pue 'ateoplttlJ'uotleottpe ss33Je oJ etielt)3 La|stba.t eNl papnput qJleasu aql ut pary1uapt SJatlJeq taqlJn j

Ggy a}ed) ,. Sututeti pue patu,{otdtue ol ssaJos olpre}at t17rn fitelntrped

'san4euraJp pue saoioqJ ]o looc! pallull e a^eq tllecldtl uorytltlsoLeJut uaLLtalA - dals lxou aul 6up1e1 oi sJauJeq p.tn:;:.nlJs apnput osle' 'uotlnlpolcl ut pa^!o^ut

auosag oq^4 uauoM aLlJ Lto lcedu,tr tl}!q/r pue 'uaqnytsoLd o7 asu ant6 ry3lqM sapel .

LtoLUol,ti ltoclclns oJ pDnn a)a/,^ saryunyaclclo ,urureLl pue uotle'no" "ri?::'j';"::r:;::;Gaoz Actrclynsuo3 ygl,,anrpryuJ da|g lxaN aqf, euteLJna lq pauoissru-rLuoy tpreosaa

lesodotd srql poddns ol alqel le^e e;ep anrlcafqodue 1q6t1q6!q pue por]tluapt seru 1calold pesodo.rd aq] ro] paau aq] ̂ orl outlino oseald Z,-g-Z

'Leaddesrp lou pr* ewtuet\otd e qcns JoJ pLteuJop aq q1naqlp'onuquoJ

Jou llt/\ l! L L0Z olur (s;soc 6utuunt pue salnpoul etoc '11e1s) >lloA| s!ut lo sqatLa€oJai aLll punj o] yoddns Pnueu\ ute6 puuel eueLlnA il

'uouro/u 7a dnoL6 pastseut1Ldtu

isour srqJ LIY/\^ pueprlul os/a arcqtniue papuldat 6uaq lpueunl Jou s! )fJo/tA slqf

aJJopfJaM at11 }uualue sp)et a]5urysorn pue uaelsa-jps rtatil Sulppnq 'ua4ryrpotd \uqtxa Sa st{eta Jlls!leeL pue leqaLua1pny-uau uauoft^ so dno$ paxleu1Leu slql rclJo ol paau pu e s! aJaq ]eql luapr^a s y 'a\oqe

pagrJJsap se 'dnofi sltll to aplotd aq] ]o uo\eJapguos ul 'uo\eyaldxe pnxas ta! puepLloJ polsuleJ] uaeq a^eq oqrn uouloM pue uaaoiA Tuetfruu algelaupt'slaieal potlcs ilLea'Yapuaga-xa 'ueLLto/1 pelJlppe 6ntp rcuto1 's\uarcd auol lo dn epeu aJe LtoLuo/l asaqf'sl14s

letsos pue uo4eJtunwuJoi tood anetl pue uJaalsa-jps pue acuapljua7 u luol aJeLtoular' aril jo lueuL eutne4 pue asnqe )!aLl] Jo ]psal e sv 'Ia>lJea Jnoqe[ pulJoJ eq] ra]uao,r s//r{s alqela\Jeu ou aAeLl Alseqdfi iLSnpulxas 3rl} u palnldxa uaaq aAerl otlM uauatlA

gild/\ mf paeoxa ]ou pfiaLls fueuttuns s.rt11lcafo"rd pasodo.rd alli roj paau B st a;Oql dqm aur;1no oseald ,-g.Z

'papLa3u aQ IFls uec 'paAepp l6e4uapd apqtv 'ssatjotd trcq1 anlanq\ pue yoddns roJ eweqnAoJ palcauuo3 uteuat sasea ]soi..lu u 17tta uLals{s utryAse aql 6u7e4o6au s1uedtcryed asoql .uaqdo ue sawa1eq

sqS acuo luawiolduta pue 6utwe4 n1 uotpLedatd ur pa3uequa uaaq aueq llllvr juowdopAap piosLad pue aseqsllDls t@tllja\elv\aH alglssod t\alelpawuLl aq pu lew yawfolduJa Japue uo4eonpo wea4suarL ol ssa33eeJolaJoql 6ut4cge4 So slu!13!^ se ua7enys tatSS aSydsap ssaco-rd utngsy atg u aq ftq uouroM a111os .aJoN..

++'y so)rnbal aqs se 6uo1 seJoj Yaddns snanuquoc e se ueuoJtt aqj JoJ aceld ut suELuoJ yoddns rc4lom t{,ay s,eutetSny

Uoddns tlyn walsis 7eq1 alebyeu ol rtpeaL s aqs uaq^'aaAras pautialduL3 pcol aql ra/pue aer ./as pautfoldtuS syj ail] o1 'apudotdde se ,rarl

4uil rcrllrnj ilrfiA pue ("'sauletyur paseg fyunwtuoc raqlo 'svl 3,1il saryunyadda 6u1u1e4

pue ua4e3npa aleudoLdde ol iceconpe pue Vult qIM ueulortn at4:. saptrto.td eutwet'ofi et11

Page 80: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

1c ' r s )dno rF 1a0 re1 papua lu t 3q ] acn i Ju t pue l i l r l uap q i cq c ]

jSA C - ( j s i . l i JC j uoLL toA . ipasn aq o1 ssa ro - rd aq ; au l i f nO

( )

i sxJo/\ ]au €, \.,i s p o d d n s 1 e 1 c o g :

S A 3 I ^ J A S i

i - roddns A l l r -ue3 l. j

rl5fronn iEicog --

l r , , ^ , r - - . ^ r r { n r r r , ^ : ' - - - - - - - i Speau UgLUO./u9]l3alo.'_d_Pr!Qc,-

;:*" "II7i_.--

a 6ui}5bpng ',_---t I

------_

r----------- -- -

"ut,Ti l :511"1::_ uo!'r lnN-

_'( s c r u r l c s d cI ' A : : u e u O a l d s r s r - r c ) 1I

I s a c r n J a s L l l l e a F l _ iI\ . - _ . _ - _ _ _ j S a C l n J a S \

| 1 - r o d d n s lr_ gq:l:tgcy_-,

I.,,*=oo*;.".9

/ s a 3 u e u l l

s ; s A l e u e s p a a u - a s e C a ; d u ; e g

,,s'ljo3sa,. se Jo uorJnylsa|djaa4s ut po^loAut 'po4c!Jlu] uaaq a^eLl [et11 rcL,paql s>lJo^ euJer]ny uJaq^A LIIIM uowottt

pnpwput eLll ]a lue qyn pesafi uec leq] (paytu4lou) speau 1o e1uet pealg atg p aldwexaue sr i opB oJJaj4JalA aq1 }utalua pLte ua1nqsotd 5utyxe u sapeJsqo poilaAal4]pur o>e]

ile pue uoulaM esaq] ]o ile Joj Jeyws lgeapet s uognl4saJd ut penlonur 6waq p acuauedxaaq17o spedtut entye5au paJeLls aq1 'dnot6

Juarp JuaJJno s,eueqnA saroj dnofi pfue1attr1

eleuotlea

uo4nypotd Iq peycege uaula/14

6u14qgetl xas /o sujrlltA pa;cadsng

uotleyoflxa pnxas ng Duqcryp4 lo su.uJJrA pa;cadsns pquayad

:dndifiefial-luauiaAloAUt Jtaql

roJ aleuorle: aql pue 1oaford srLli Jo] uauro^ 1o (s)dno:O ]eO-le] papualur aqi ,{1r1uapr aseold g'Z

'yasa.td 7e papnpxa r{yenos pue pazlew5.teu os aJe aq/u uou}ortr

p dno$ yafrrcy aq] o] s,r;oddns alnads popoau ,lznur apnoJd fpueyoduLr JSow llu* pueuotJuatuoJ adotn3 p founoC aq] rapun sluatuaLtnbat sl il!ilnJ puela4 dlaq ylttr dnofi pfuey

oLll Joj auttuet5otd pautdopnep 6u1u1et1 a.td stt117o fuantpp /nlssaoJns atg 'fi4snpu! xasaql pue ua4nypotd u ]uoLlla^pAurlo Ltoprq e qyw uauro^^ pue poplgleJl uaaq aAeq orlAueurota rc1 aututet5osd yoddns frulppng Lycedec e dolanep o1 }uryeas v uo1estfide slql

;,ssa3Je5wutanob suorilpuac aql apnap o1 saryed aLll )oj st il uarleJnpo pue 6up1e4 leuoqeJot';ai,!Jeu Jnoqela{-ll o} ssac3e p y.,16u pnpe ue qsryqe}sa }au seop uatua^uoJ aq}"',,

septnotd (ggt qde:6end p) yoda.t fuo4eueydxS

Page 81: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

)eef ,O i :€34 .UC i r i 3A 'C ; t , 1 e , . q i s iE f r iEA3 CLre Ma iAa j O - paSr r 3C O ; S . l JS ,JE i . l 3ALu A i l i AU I ; l n0 aseS lc l g ' e

aJii ). iL.i pajlg je lt: sass'o.l()./d aLtj a; p.jJLlos slj iAS.]ALl IreLLtO/;\ dLll i?:Lil AlITStiA oi pLle uO!]eJIUtturuOS.teOlS OJ'IS'l/a Ol UCtleJtldnp AStLUilJtLU

oJ sa3.r/losal ale.ls aj (asuauadxa 3tleuLneJ;lo sa-rnsoisstp oldtJlt lu 6 a) si{/als..4s ,fueuiSutiebir'ett oJLtoiladxa,) LtaLua^ Ayncrtrltp otl i ostLututL, ol sl s4L/rl t lons 6ttrTeatt ]o uJte aLll

s.laqia 6ttatue 'rleclnB ttotle)DtLUtlt i leuotl.eN epeg aLil t- l]!A1 sdttisuotplaL sy uat116ua,t6 o1sanLi l ]ua3 pue setsLra6e 6wsnot l pLte puelat l ]o I tJUnoS iLteJ6turLtr l oq l ' (1 tu2 6Ut4ct1|e. t1t l t ty

po{ord qileaH s uatuoTrl JS,q aql ss qons sabe4Lrl 6uto6uo a^etl osle plno/,^ xuednryedaLll ]o luetu uJoLl/1 tlltlA SaOUabe {a>l aLlt ja autos t11n,n 1urpueJsJapun jo epuuautaLLr

6urq*1qe1sa s/ pus paqs4qejsa seLl euleLtnA uoqedrctued JaL! alqeua il!/tl Lplq! sao/Nasoj ssaooe saNa3u ueLuol,A oql elnsua a] yoppLl$le1s pue sLapu,otd acttJas uaaMlaq

uatleloqeiloc Lcua}e-LeJut ooueLlua pue dolenep llt^4 aLuuu6otd Ttoddns 6urure4 afi aq1

sanl ielyul /sa3rnras 6urlsrxa Jaqlo o] anlen ppe/]uauralduro: lcaford:no{ gpnn r(enn leqnn u1

Illtqette^e rtaLll pue slea} pary4uapr-/las 'spaau pnpt^tput )taql uo paseq ebe1ua lF/1^ Ltau,Jo/\A atuutet1o.td ptn7 pue afqtxo# e stslqt arcp ,,pels,, aLll le pels ol ro sJLtouJep ge u a6e6ua ol sTuedrctyed ye to| TuatuaLrnbat

e jou si ]! pue sasjnos dnoL6 Ll]!/1 >tlol auo oJ auo aurquloc o1 paujtsop sr asJnos aLl I

LueaJ JUaudolanap aL11pue pedoyed at77 uoo/AJaq lfnq uaaq seq qtlqll dtqsuotlelaL qldap-ut ue uo paseq apeutaq lluo uei suotsrrap WnS'ta>pu1eryttaql \urlaauj ja Jea]Jo/pue }ut4aSletyuotlnyysoLd 1o

socuatLedxa 4aLil Ll]t/r^ suatletouuoJ sy ol anp Lalua oJ 6ut1ynun ate uoLuo/r^ aruos t1c1t1ttn trycaw ]a seaJe ale iloql -uauaAA Joj unJrJJtp sasjnoJ 5utpuape apeu aAeLl ped eq1 u! r,l}!r-t/A

'sanssr uoqeca! pue sJeJpltlc sr JUauJabe5ua JtaLll Lto pedu ppm qzlq/v rapej Laqlouv

's u otpycad xa J qs t p aJ u njo uoqeilJ aLil )o ssaJls anpun o1 papafqns 6urcq ',pa 6uddotp, s4uednryed sprcAe

srt+l 're^ol lcetayl Ja/pue afrenbuel iraLl] pLte 6wgas dnotb e ut ebebue o1 ssau1utlyrn rc,{l!rce Jtaq} uo paseq sluednryed rcS pa1sa66ns ale salnpau :aPuLexa roJ -ouueJ1ofi aqy

uo ptalpautebebua rct16tt1 e oI speal sltl] pue aute iatll se possoJppe aJe ueuJow LpeanS pesaLd ile qclqrt salee;sqo lenpnrpLil aq] 'uoltnl4sad p slcedwr aql ja ecuauedxa

pannle s,uotpzuebto aq; se ilalA se auLuLet5oLd aql jo alnleu auo a] auo aqt of on7

lesodo.rd tnof ;o sarnlea] anlie^ouut eql lqbrlqDrq aseald g-t

-iyunyodda ISatUea at17 7e a}e1ue o1 tnbaq ,{eut astnoc oL4 u pedntyed anrpedsoLd e

pue Ja4JoM patudolana1 e pue JeULoi ese1 aql 'uewoM aql uaat laq 6u4aaut '{en aett11 edn ps o1 uo ob l!il1 Ja\JaA aseo queuro^A aql -euluel}oLd pawdopAap 5wwetyatd aq aq

ilapudafide f.eu s1t11pue paryJuapr st eutwetbaLd Ewwetl p Tuau.dop^ao peralel e rojf1pqeyns raq ]eLll1u1od sltSl le s! l! os 6uure4 pue pewdoto^ae Jo swra] u speau s,ueuo/r

aqt ssasse ol s/ /lales pue 6uaq-yaf puatpLua 'qlpaq aJepauut rtoJj spaau s,ueruow e1o sTcadse lle raAor ttlM tlolrl+ lilllo^ asei palwale aql qlffL^ iuaulssasse p!ty#!y

.luorrssassv

'al,s qart no tlbnottg se F/1A se 'JJa sJaliaqs sso/aulorl'suosrd oJ qleil]no pue (4aan e s7q6ru no1 u!fin1 ]o seoJp 1t164 pet aq] s]$t^ qcltlM)

ueA Lpee4no s,eueqny tlfrnotgl Jno paueo XJorA Lpeo4no aql uro4Insa osp spJleJs)-JIaS palello saJ/nJas atil jo aJeAAe arc satcuabe leLll aJnsua o1 0utaet-ssauaJeA^e nyn\atut sa6e6ua euJeqnA 'pJJoloJ

Jps E sJalsuJeq/sJolnqas 'so4ual uoqepouJulocoe sso,r.uloLl'Ep.leg 'sJe>poln ptsos JSH

'se qcns lseunos ]o Jagutnu e uo4 spJJalal saNacoJ euteqna.leJJalaa

s 'e

Page 82: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

S i € S c C o l d . C i r € l: e , ^ e { : L s 1 b € S C , t S / , C i - . s c r : . 1

: pouad aynosI qcea ]a pLts oLll

le aqelte^e aq lillnslndlno ageLnseaw

tuanppauJueJbud aql

jo spotJsd olvl aqlWoLf6noJq 6tuobuo

I aq llul suorlsv| " - - i :!

TuauIaptueJo/pue uo\esnpa

'6ututet1 ssaJ3e[euL lat17 lAoLl paUtJLtapt

a^eL! llrM (LeeI qceaurgs)syednl ryed tC

I

I srndrnoI

)aLl

ry1rn padalanap ueld e puepassasse aq illM uatlenJts

JuilJnJ S,UeLUO/n ALJI

uLeaJyeuLdoSenoe s,euleqnU

oJ sases olqeyns JaJeJllt^ sJa4jaMases eueL{na

s/seqlenptAtput ue Lrospaa{./ s,ueuJaMLpea jo }utTaatu

aq1 yoddns o1

| :rvos:tulrl. { _ _ sNorr3v i

*=Ti3i53: i

ta )eatpue L rea^ 'a t 's.iea{

lcatold oM} eq} lano3 plnoqs ale3sauirJ aq} ieq} alou o} lue;-lodutr sr 11 slndlnoiuelnsai aLll pue santicafqo eql Jo qJea anatqoe ol ualeyapun oq IpM lel{} suol}oe uteu1 aq} Alcads

asea;d 'uortlppe u1 loafo-rd tno{ 1o santlcafqo crycads aq} alqe} Durnnolloi aL{} ul pro3a; aseold

lcel-o.rd pasodold :no{ 1o utre crOale;1s asrcard

euutet6otd Tuawdalanaq 5u1u1et1 -aJd eLueqnA

aql sur l lno asesld

:ar!pN lrafor4 Uasul

so!lt^tl3v l3aford

'teai srq1 wotS 1uruteallo A arAaJe uo paseq ua\enle^e esueLlua ol s/ool sArleuJa]le/pasueque Jap,suo? oJ os/s pue pasn

6u1aq Eoo] JuoJJnJ oql lo esn panuluoc owwexe o7 sasodo-rd euteqna '21.g7 fuenuer utuJ'awutet6atd utea4suleu of pquapd

' u oqe n le ̂ a pe d rc rye d u allt lApue pqta^ uoqeuquas q6not11 fteuotsseloLd pue puostad) spedwyed nl sautocln6

-suo4n/osye4uelod pue (syedrcryed ol putelxa pue putalul uo4ednryed ol sraureq 6u1l111uap1

pala$utoc se auesJo ua7enle*o sSuedntped pue NaluoJ aslnal ja \wyatuncog:sapnput uoqenleia ]uailm aqf'srolerye^a

Tuepuadapu aq ja s6u1pu17 aqJ Luorj]uauaq ytm auu,tet5afi Buro5uo aqj os aLaz.raqopg o7 fuenue7 ns Tcofotd atil jo sarye^

aq1 6upnpn'a pue 5wmemeJ )a] suJslueqJaw padolanep seq pafofi Topd yettn:t aq1

Page 83: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

'agnac

qseo Jo pua aqlle alqefe^e aq illf^

slndlno alqeJnseaw

fuenpp eutuetdotdp steai 7 at17

poq6nottll 6uro6uoeq luv\ suorlcv

Alru1tp q1u.na1t1 anysocl' alqeueJSns

e n1 uep pueasnqe pue uarJestwtlstA

JtaLlJ ououa4oo1 [1tpqe aq] Lll!^\

pue anleA pue quoA/lJo asuas '33uapflua3

pasuequa qlffA6utfuatua (LeaA tlceaur gy) sluedtayed pg

salesrluaspaypalcse }vllJo/1 ] tllyA 6tu6Lause

syuedruyed ]o %Ag

ale3ryua3palperrse 3vl3J auolspal le rSlu'a 6u6Laua

sluednrped g 1

paryluapt aqllbr^ sJatJJeq 6uueuat

to'lpeat uoqecnpaLo 6tttwe4 uleuJsuEwoq il!/vl s4uedtcryed g9

ytatuloydtue'6u1u1et1 'uo7eznpa

uleuFUteut durssaccespreA ol iurpynq

Aycedec jaj sua7enJrs6u1u1e4 dnoL6

pue L. L ut uot1edntyedlo srnor4 az L

6u1u1eb sluednryed g 1

Tuau$oldtua'uoqecnpa 'fruyupt1

oJ ssaoJe 5wpanatdsJouJeq lenp!^!pu!

pue puosod patpsatpue parJrluap ateqlltrttt syednryed g 7.

saJJLtaSfyuntutuoc pcol Lil sasselc

Lalnduroc 6 a fyuntuuosleSol Jtsrl] ut ue_j sasjnos

1utpuape ut papoddns aqlr/1 uauafa 'oAoqe se ilaA SV

uv'qi leaH lenxos.'plv lsr!J JrseB 'esrnoS

1wypueg pnuery'6uqu1,4aNJe aJO' 1uo usabe u eS11

ssarls 'GSU aqt AqpaJaNloa'asuelotA JtgeuJop

' Llileaq pn xas' uorlcalotdpf Lls 'uotltJ\nu ',{lrntpe

pasAqd'uo4owotd tne€rlpluaw auysod' TuauLabe ue w

ssa-4s .epnput$!daf)qileeH lepeu pue etur.ltrf

'6u1abpng'Ase3 apeyypooS fiqyeag :autuet1oLduo!l!4n N'suoqeaunwuroS'

ftua utdoSanap p uosLad)awwet6ot6 sdalg aql 'si/Iys

puostadtayulE pLtosod

.u1 6uypt7 dnotg

-qseq spaaulenp!^!pul ue ua paljlluap!se '6wuuey4 qJed rcoJeJ

's qpry's:a1nd ulo2' itenylpue e6en6ue1qst16u3

.'ul suo/ssosauo oI auo asnoq-ul

.s/t^ottoj se 6wwet1 euueiLg

Euluptldnot6 pue

SUOJSSAS AUO

oJ auo ttr6no47yeufoldute

Jo/pue 6uyuptl'ua\ecnpa

ueaJlsuteuJ6qssacce

spJe^ ol1wppnq [ycedec

JaNlap ol

Page 84: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

F-

l f ,edtu l ps lPdl3r luV

spaci-f t lo SPLladaC , . . ^ ^ ' , ̂ d ^ n) P o d t l U v J P r l o u a U

^ ^ , , ̂ 4 ^ -> l J d d u u w J l r t r d u o L , i

:_^)^_> P O e u u o J P U d ( ; e ( j

spaair uo spuodac spasu uo spuacaQ

sqlen auc o i 3uo eg

suosse; ja tnoLLjo] auc o i auo pg

a6en6uel qsr lEul auo o i auo

Iceralrl auo o] auo

paprnoldaq ol sasjnos ourure:1 auJD ued Io JaquJnN

6uruue13 JaaJeJ auo ol auo

,fuessacauI sA o_l M3u ppe pue f,g o] e9 s^^ol ut sat]t^rl3e

lua;al1rp aqi fut:ads aseald c1a 'Our-roluauu' uorlet]-l joJUr' r. lSear] no' uollestlt lu aplslgr1s 6 a lcaford aLll rapun sell lnllf,e

raqlo u.Jorj lllauaq lll/rd oq^\ uaLLloA +o laqurnN

SASJNO3

V L aurq-ped alaldiuoc lil/v\ oq/v\ uaLUoA ,o JaquJnNsasrno3

aur]-lln] aleldujo3 ilt^^ orlM ueujoA lo laqtlnN

..,t: i

v Y iY t I:-

9 L

ci

i-p3!]!juap! s,uawo^

al 6upla33e IleAllf'A sasJ na} lenptNpul$o e\efin fpo stnaq

,sJaaJUnp^ fru,snuil aq ]ouue? auros sB

'sas,/no3 )oj aneile^est oupunj PLYA uo

puadap il!tu1sltli ,L

L rea^ qa$Jel ftercgeueg

aulruer6ud weutdap^ao 6u!ule4 *ald eueqnu :strIPN lralojd uasut'

apJSaur4pue]aapngpasadodaq}}aJuno}Je6u14e7WqIoqoqppaqs afiet s$l] ur paJuasild Tcedw paledn\ue pue sJsorel fuercgaueg aql :alou aseard

. : ..-.," srseq fuee/t B. uo.jpafojd pasodo"rd -rno{

lo pedult palEu.rlsa eql pue pa^arq3e aq il!/vl leql slooje} fuengauaq eql ilelap pue arnsea!{ '

ustuoAl rot /qllBnbS otl] ]o puer]s rElncl}JEd rno,{ o} ssltddP }eq} alqe} aq} ol ra}ar oseald g'e

paprno;dsq o] sas.tno3 6urure:1 etur] lln] +o raqLUnN

'aulueJDaJd

Jo pua le sluednlyedqyrA uo*enptapult frwpnput

duto6uo uotlenlets

'aalseld

aJ sluawa\oJdurJoj suolppuauwoJaa a Lu u eJfroJ d a 14 l ale n le A3

uJle s$ Eulqceetut euJuletdotdetp So fisecgaaq, ssasse ol -t

Page 85: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

l le3, aLl l u t peur l lno suor l lpu03 0] lsafqns

il

'JeaA auo ueLll aiouislesodold lol

roJ 6urpunJ Jo lele {l luanbasqns {er:.r sdno.l3 ,

i oNtse1 i it i

i pa . rncas i3 lIEulsrerpu ilbql,Sl- l

asrnos ;

saolnos Jeqlo ulorJ paJncaspo] parldde Ourpunl leuoryppe {ue {ltcads eseeld 'alqecrldde 1g e ' t

paAaftlse aq uej (uauJaMroJ s;soc yodsuetl pue spualew '6'a) s;soc fiuuunJ pue sappotx arco awos 'JJeJs aeJuew oJ

fruypuny pepnofi os op uel pue s/seq udo4luepqd e uo 'sroJnJ/slailasunaoryJeuterl se aw4 syeuopoLfA sJaqJa pue O3A utotl yoddns 1wpnpu saoJnoss't sy 6ursn awwet5otd alol e aleus iltl^

ewelln5 'JeAeMoH 'lsal luesrlru1ts e s! r.lolrtlA'aJetpfi.lc toy-b-e alqercAe 5ulpunl fueyawelddns

Ja JunauJe aLll uo 5upuedep fuen yu'tr ewwefiofi eq7 5wuunt /o s;soo aql :apy Tueyodtul*

000'00 L3 +slso3 icarord lelol

I t ^ . 7v y v u

lo1ler{ se pailrururo3o u o u - A o l a q a a s 3 (egqecrldde p) sac:nos Jalllo uro:l Ourpunl leuotlrppv

00 400'49? y\JM3 rllorj pelsenbar burpun' to lunouv

{.oau6 rpo^ ro} lcafo.rd eq} iol leopnq telo} alll sl}eqM g'CI

areweqru@wilapaJJ :lre$f Z6Z0gtB r0 :oN euoqdaleg

JAIUIS!U!IupV sJunffiev

llail^aN esuspaJj

:uorl'sod

:AUJEN

luecrlddy luereut asueur];ceford ro3 Aplrqrsuodsar qprn (sleydec 1co1q ut) uos.tod 1o uotltsod pue euueS t't

asueull - t uoll3as

'@wn aq] le Awouaoaeql u! yauloldweJo {yyqepeneaq uo puadepasrnoe ]o lllM slLtl ,L

luaurlolduaolul a^oul lll^4 Oqi!\ UaUJO/IA ]o JaquInN L

'(snlels acuaprsal pueileopplo lpecuauedxea^eq '{eq} ewnu\aq o] anp swegofiLlileaq leluaw sesroyeej qcns Iq 4ceqplaq aq illM uawaf^s{l/os Apcldtl ?L

satuurelOo"td 6uture:1 leu.uo1 pue uorleonp€JOqilnJ olul e^oul lllm oq^ uotuo/vr Jo JaqtInN v

Page 86: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

7 '';,

OLAZ,uunlnfit:' Ys Patofixaaq ilyvt suoilerilddv - L L)zJoj a-lneas 6u1pun1 oN

's]so3 Duuuru leuoryppepue srsos aJecprqs 'sJnaqrow n] sv.t."pue '33n aqJ sBq3ns sasJnos Jaqlo uto4 6urpun]fue4uauta$dns taas il,il eueqnA

0L0z aletnun apeu pu uolspap

pue palyulqnsp,t llu uoqeupdy 'plsa aoo'02,9

slsos paJelarpue sappow pappr tllpaqpuedxa a] 6u!pun! ppauta1ddnsta] Aydde illur eweqnA

:Ewpun1fuago1 leua!]eNuoqnguluoc puDl-u f /suotleuoc

Page 87: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

r'' -'

-alnsea!{luaulo6 rol ^lllenbl aLB Japun :.sanbal 6upun4 )o] uwop\eotq p1png pallela"Cl

' euLu-tes60.td peutdopnag 6wute4 -aJd eLueqnbr :arueN lrafor6 pasul

^ or-l Jo JaqunJ e aptno ro saouaJalal apnlf,ut oiTdqLnauLat as

(6upung burqc\eut rq n1pted aq ilyn wlqA 's3soc,,{ue opnpu!pu op asealj arnseawuatxo^n -ro1 {1r1enb3 aq} Japun palsenba-r ourpunl aq} oi sja}aj dluo urtop>1Barq srql

rcqyn! Jo] *,ploog ,slulH pSdplq ? sato' fuoyeue1dxl, aqt , ;:fy:t::::i:paptnold sEutpeaq lso3 aql 6ulsn palord ;noA ]o s]soo aq] ]o u^Aopxealq e aprnotd ..n"16

leFpng t'e

Page 88: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

l { :a }eo

s-rol33jrc Jo pjeog euleqnE r lc :o l l r1 qo f

et'eweqnJ@Lliles

z6z09t8 L0'6 uilqna'etpuo3wnJa 'e6eilo3 st^aileH ilv

',osnoH J0lu6s

:sserppe l !eLU-l

:oN aucL.ldale-L

:ssa-Jppv

W:arn jeubrsi f ,-'"

{stvtravc xoots}l,"r*:,?"1 S -lr t,rn).J:euep1

t-,"qJuJft preog 1o ainleun,g

i,rr I Ja lls:a1eq

oJ} :dnojc ul uorlrsod

:PauOrg

. O" ,'))-NOSNISHyUyS :{StVltaV3X3Ot$'tuo1euFgg

VWVH1A :(SlVItdVO X3O1E) dnorg to otueN

:uorlergldde slql qym uorloouuoo u! ecuapuodsarroc lle ro] aueN lceluo3

'esodlnd lelllroj ',{iessacau se 'sp;oco: pue

sasrruald slt ol ssao3e ̂ olle ol pue puela:l ur punl ler3os ueado-,:n3 cql roJ fiuoqlny 6ur6euey1or.l] pue sJleJ+V ]q3ellaeC pue fit1enb3

'dtrrunu.rr-uo31o luetuyeda6 oql ' leqod ,{q pa.:oyuour gcafo:daL{} aAeL{ o1 alqeae.r6e are slosuods aq1 'leqod ro a:nseal4 uouroM .to; {it1enb3 aq} LUo4 s1uerO.raqlo due o] luaujltulrrtoo ou sanionur lr lel.ll

'1uer6 e jo ple/v\e aql lo uotlpuo3 e sa 'ldacce osle I

'e002 pue /661 s]3v uorlerrrolul +o uopaaljalli Jopun isanbo: uo alqepele apeul eq {eu uo4ectldde stql Out{ueduocce .ro ur perlddnsuotieuJlolul leql puelsJapun osle I

'6utpunl Outistxa ecegdat ol pesn iou pue palels asod.rnd aq1ro] pesn €q ]snur pspreMe spun; ztue 1eq1 o6pa1*roulse I

' ialloq pue aopalrvloul dur Jo isaq oql olalaldruoc pue an:] sr uanr0 uotleuJJoJut oq] tte leql aJelcap puP uotlmrldde srql ul pequ3sap ]cafoldaq] spre/v\ol 0T*0-095 Jo enle^ oLl] ol Ourpunl tol {ldde 'paubls:epun aql '1-Eutaln[

]o lleLloq uO

'pesseJppe aq llyv\ acuepuodsallo3 lle uloq/v\ o1 uosrad aql ^q palaldtuoc oq plnoqs slrll

uollejEl3oo - t uolleas

Page 89: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

/ - i

(paspoqlng ttng)

: uot lestue6JO u tql ! / r^ uot] tsoduosuaEr qeJes

0 L}z aunr ujr, :ol"o :paubrg

slcafo;d len prnr pur Jo uoriBr lsrur ulpe Jo/pue luauua6eueiLr'uorlelado 'uorlcnlisuoc '0uruue1d 'truetudo;anap €ql q]!iA uorlceuuo3 ur 0ursr.:e ranaosleqMralJerrt Aue o1 uorleleJ ur slqer l :o alqrsuodsai plaq aq saouelsun:, l rc due ur aulI Aue 1e 1ou11eqs s1ueOe ro sluetues s]r 'srel1v

lqoel leeC pue d1r1enb3 'A1runuru.ro3lo luaupeda6 el l l - ' l l

uot lect ldde Aue 1o uosear due .ro; uor lcafel aqi (q:uorlecr ldde oL{} }o ra}}eLu icafqns aLi} ro uorlecrpdde eLl} (e

:r-uotl Allcetrpur .ro ,{11ca:rp6ursr:e eJnleu due 1o sisoo.ro ebeu:ep 'sso; i iue 1o lcedser ur dped:aq1o ,{ue:o luecr ldde

aqt ol alqetl eq ]ou lleLls sreJJV lq3elloeC pue d1r1enb3 'dlrunu-riuo3lo luarupedag aLJJ I

:6utirnol;o1aq1 paldaccB pue poolsrspun 'pesr sell luect;dde oL.ll leLll 'arnseay! uauog ro,

r ! t1enb3 aql lo suorlrpuo3 pue sura+ aq] Japun burpunl rol uor lecr;dde Aue ]o uorlrpuoc e oq l lyvl l l

:{11n;erer p?al aseald

JsriJrelssrc

)acrJlo a^qrcax3 jaryJ :uo11esrue6JO unlllA\ uolllsod

tTosuog- r/.e.lgs0L0zaunf , t tLL:aleo m :pau6rg

'i '1sanba.ruorleulolul ;o u,opaail e o1 asuodsal ur pasealer oq 11r*

'perlddns uorleu:ojul aql jo 'lle ro 'rtue

1eq1 sa6pelmoulce pue '€Arlrsuas sr parlddns uorleurrolul aq],o €uou 1eq1 searbe r(qareq eur"qng

'lsanbaL uorleu:olulJ|o LrJopeaJJ e o1 esuodsor ur pesealar aq lllM uorleujjolur q3ns 'l33JJe

leql ol /v\oleq luouralelseq1 alalduoc eseald 'anrlrsuas sr nod riq pargddns uorleuuolur eql ]o auou letll raprsuoe noA 11

'uotleu;dde lno{ 6urgtuiqns uaqinuotlet,t.t.tolur qcns d1.lea1c Alrluapr aseald 'anr1suas sr uolleuJoJul aL1} }o aulos }eq} Japrsuoc nor{ 11

'suoseal 6ulpoddns ql!/n aAlllsuos se uolleurolu!aql Illluapg noA ssa;un 'nort r{}!/vl uor}e}lnsuoo raqpn} }noq1/v\ 'seryed pllql o} uorleul'totu!'lsanbar uo 'asee;or ll$A luaupedag oql 'uollptx;otu! t{Jns }o sspal€r uo uolslcap E6u14eu arolaq uorlprulolul €^!1sues |noqe nof qlrn llnsuoo l]l/v\ luatsyedag aqg 'f1;a;1;suas

sl! Jol suoseoJ aq1 ,{ycads pup autss ittttuapt 'uo!}euJro}ur eq1 burplaord ueqnn 'plnoqs

no{ 'oseo aq} s! slql ll 'fi1n111sues Jo ssne3sq posoloslp aq lou plnoqs aJnseay[ srlt .repun6u1pun; rol 6ur{dde u; nod Aq parlddns uogeuuo}u! org lo r{ue l! Japlsuoo o} po{se sJe no1

'CI002 pue /66 L lov uorleu,rroluljo ulopaa;l oLll Jopun suol1e6r1qo s,lueu4redeg oL{} r.{}m aoueplooce ur 'sar;red p:lLl} o} ';sanbel

uo 'paseala: aq [er"u uor]e]ueulncop Ourpoddns pu? rilrol uoqestldde aq1 ut pargddns uorlerr:o]ulaql lelll siuecrldde puruar ol saqsm sJrBlJV lq3eilaee pue ftt1enb3 '[1unuuo31o lueuyedo6 eql

Jastuo aNlnsoxS ]atq3

l3v uorlPturoJul ;o uopoeu aql Japun aJnsol3slo

Page 90: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

r.::

8 l

urd00's :orurl

0L0z aunr qrg|, ^epsaupaA :albp sulsolS

I ailEqdd€tffi

lo1 paggeure eq plnoqs uuol uolleclgdde pala;duoc or{} }o uolsron cguorlcele ffi ,--,

tt?0t.99 t0xEJ 0oIo0tz L0auoqd

z ulHnols solloH

asnoH loorqloHleqod

aJnseou[ uoutofill.ro; lt1;;enb3 * i, l|

:ol lu33 aq plnoqsuollpluatun3op lue^olsr lle pur rurol uollEclldde pel6ldr[o3 srll;o saldor punoqunq

suorleJepac peu6rg ".n

-*.. .oj . 1,:r.r-r i"1-,i3'.' f,',.i i:'i:;-:-i:r".-,;*1 SUMOp{eAJq }A6png patle}e0 .,J;l

r i) i"af:1 rl.:li-f-i .r'.*; UOtlElUAtiJn3Op oU;pOddns lue^afaj Jaqio r{uv E

lueor$dv lueiC eql ro1 railal AHO pue OOI luarnf, a$ lo r{doc y ..8

-luestgdv

$lei$r-eql--'o*t*o4r+lt!$u€9rd uoqelsossv Jo sep4rv ? unpuPjouay{ }o {doc y /B

'uogeallddernort 6ug1;uqns uorlrrA rnoloq potsll sur€ll aql lo lle pasolJuo alerl no{ }eq} arnsua €sesld

sluesllddy rol lsll{csrt3

Page 91: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

s r0 l r l l n t [ ] ) l J l i t ; . ) ] l

s l u r f l u t r 0 . ] . )Y pJJ J ) . r e r l )

l l l r N , O , i q r . r e 3 L r e u B r n g

66 L60Z rrq tun N uorlu,r lsr8ag

6002 Jrqularaq If papua rea{ aq1.ro.;

sluatueluls lBrJuuurC pue l lodag ,sJolJaJIC

1e1rdu3 a.reqg r 3u;,rcq lou pup

JolueJunC ,(q pelrrurl , tuuduo3 y

EurBqnu

I u r l q n ( l; i pr . r q s11eg1

p l ro l l pus l . r r q run l l l r oN 'Fg

' l l

Page 92: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

t l - 0 1

6

8

L

9 - S

v - t

Z

I

sE?d

i r B e d

sluotuoJ

slustuelpls iersuprrrj oql ol seloN

luaurslels ̂\olc qse:)

]eeqs aruelBB

lunoJrv arnllpuadxq pue auoJul

UodaU ,srolrpnV

UodaU ,srolrsrrC

aaed uonuuuo-]ul

a8ed slualuoJ

suBqnu

Page 93: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

g ,tsBd

-Jeo{ aql f ur.rnp.{uedruoJ eq1 {q ua,,rri a:a,tr suorleuop leourlod oNsuo!lnq!r luoJ lsJl lr lod

'0 t0Z ul ereld ilr eq Ilr,{\ pu€ ueduor aq1 (q p.rge:p Sureq sr lrreruettsls ,{1.1ns y

src,{oydurg.;o fuo;ug pur q;1ua1;

sJrrnos leJr:JJr prrE sFprAoJdaJt'uas reqlo qlrA\ uorlsJoq€llol pu€ sdrqsuollela: r^tlseJJs puu .Suorls r^el{ a,$ lgqJ :Iro^\ Jno roJ uoddns lusurlod Suollsulplrreur a,\1 leql:pe^lo^ur ,Qr,u1ru luururr:J aql pue opErl xos aq1 Jo cjnluu eullsepuulr {18ulsee.rcur aql ua^€ dno:8 tuellcrno ol ssaJ3e ure8 o; enurluoo uer eM lsqJ iqrcpdec pue slllls fiessarau eqt qtr,r sJaolunlol puu JJ€1s ar{} a,r€q rA1 leqJ

:a.re s\srJ lEl3rJeuU uou ledr:ul.rd aq1

'pe^teJol spunJ eql

3o ffurpuads luelrdruo3 ,{q lsrr srql pessalppe o^sq srollarlp eq1 tueuuelog eql ruo{ 8urpury penurluol Jo ,trpqulr?Apaql sJ .{u€duJor aqt SurJeJ lsu lenueu.lJ ludrtuud oql luql peusrles ere sJotJallp aql acueu:oJred pue lueuldole^rpsfuudu-roc eql .Io ^{?l^ar le; u Sutpr,lo:d o1 uorple: ur suorle?rlqo ,to1n1e1s aql Jo ele^\e aJ€ surpqnu Jo sro}Jalrp rq.L

sallululJaJun p us $lslr lrdtrurr.l

'aoi:€ru3lo5 pue luarualieuell liuarudola,raguotleztueSrg iSutsre:pung puu Surpunj :sreelunlo^ Jo elor aq1 Sur.ralsog -: epfllf,ur Esil{I 'paglluopl oJaA\ sa,rrpafqorlFalerts pea:8e aqt ralrlap ol sanrlcafqo Suruoddns rnoj Sulu8reduruc pue ,(recoape 'ssauo.rrl\e crlqnd 'secrrues

Jo sBare{a>1 earqt:no uo Sursnco; (atOZ - 61g7)uorlezrueS:o eqt ro3 ueld cr?alerts reaX aa.rqt e peleldruoc a,n;eal lsed aqr 3uun6

sluawdoJa'roq ernlnC

' lc r3Futpaaoxo 1ou pe.rtnbo.t oq ,(eu se lunouu r.ions 'sall;suJaLli Suor$s selrotnqr.l1uoc cql go stq8rr oql Jo luaulsnlpe .due :ogpue dn Surpur,n aqlJo s;suodxa pue sa8ruqr'slso3 pue Xuedtuor aqlJo sorlrpqerl pue slqop eq1-;o luau{ed roJ'spru*ualturead auo ulqy,\1 ro Joquoru e e.te ,(aqt elrqm dn puno,r Suraq ll Jo luala eqt ut .{ueduot er{l Jo qesse aill ot atnqr{uoxol sa)i?uapun {ueduroc aql go :aquraru ,tre,r3 't4ldec ereqs e an?q lou saop pue aaluerenS ,(g pallull sr .{uedu.roc aq,1

slsaratul rlaql puY srolJarlo

'c)ep leeqs arueleq€ql aruls a8treqc 1er.ra1eu ou sr alor{l pue',fto1re;slps sr {uedruoc aqlJo sJrBJJeJo el€ls eq}'sro1:a:rp aqygo uorurdo aq} u1

sr1BJJY Jo alEtS

'Zfo'084 fq orrurpuadxr s,tr arnper 01 slsor 1nc seq.{ueduroo or{t puu LSL'9t3,{q pesea.rcap sgi{ 6002 ur sruo}ur or{J'G.LZ'LL

o -llcgop 8002) //8'6t 3 ol polunotue :ea,{ aql roJ lrgap aq1spuepr^io puv sllnsou

':ea,( lsed eql relo lro,!\ ;nogo yed da1 € osle s?,\r luaurdole,rap {rr1od acuanguJ ot leAel olletue le pue Jenpr^lpur aql .Jo Jlpqaq uo soJhras cgroads ;o3 ,tceco,rpy 'senssl oJrisnf pua tr.ln1,{se 'uorler8rurur 'uotec!}lune.r

i(1ture.; 'acueloll lerlxas pue f,rlsatuop punorp senssr 'eJ€JIeA\ 'uorl€poulnroJ3e 'sanssr

leprcrns 'ssarls olleulne:l

-lsod 't{llesq lE}ua{x pepnlrur sacl^Jas Jaqlo ot isuojo.r q8no.rq ro uor}?zruB8ro eql {q ,{tlJailp reqtte paprnord se;w poddn5

tlirt{^\ roJ senssr Jo a8uur aq1 'saturueJSo.rd luaurdolanap pue Sururu4 qlr,q prae8ue .;;uq ,{lalaturxorddy '8ur>p1ger1

upulnq Jo srutlf,ll polcodsns ale,t\ utor{.ry\ Jo sp:Iql o,,yq 'uaurom (aorqt ,Qua,res) t, rlll,\\ palJo^\ eueqnu 6993 3ur.rn6'uorlnlpsoJd

ul uauroAr ol asl^Jes Surpuot4aq e rleurpJo-o? puu asrue8ro 'e1ouo.ld o1 sr ,{ueduroc aql Jo &t^$c€ ledour.rd eq1

&!^!lly qud;ru;.r1

6002 raqrrlecec I € popuo ree{ aqt:o3 slurril31E}s [?r]ueuu eq] pus l.loder rlaql tusseld sro]calp er{J

6002 raqulalec Ig Fpue rBo^ oql roj

roda1 rsrolrrJlg

surBqnu

Page 94: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

tr

F aBBd

rotJar!(I^ll€Nct\ erure€l 'rs

JOlrsj!C

tnqlloJ,o Plelrl.rero'rI

pleoS srllJoJlEqaq uo

'i(cuerer

eq] {t$ ol 1ra;q,9 KqUe3 uBufrno p3lrirodd€ sro}calp eq} pue reaX oql Suunp s.rotgpne se peu8rsa.l 'o3 4r faupr;i 'l FqoU

srol!pnv

'6 ullqnc ?puof,urnro 'peoU lredarurC 'esnoH rorua5 'e3o11o3 srAolluH IIV le paurulurcru ere ,{seduror eq} Jo tunoc}s Jo $poq oqJ .uollJury

letsueu$ Jrllol satmossl slenbapE 3o uotsr,ro:d oql pue 'asrusdxa aleudorddu qluw lauuosrsd Suglunoccu lualaduror Jo luaur.doldrua aq1'suollsBsse4 turp;ocat .rog sa:npacord pue soril;od d.ress+cru 3o uoguluaueldurr eql a.re lunorsB Jo s{ooq rodord Eurpre8or?661 13V sarueduro3 <Z0Z uoltoes go slueure.rgnbar sql qlr/r\ acuerJduroc rJnsua ol s:olrerp aqr {q uela selnserul orlJ

lunoJrvJo stoog

's?rlueln8alrr Jaqlo p{rs pne{}o uotlJetep pue uollu$rr$daq1 ro3 sdals olq€uoseal ?ut>pt rog eouoq pue fueduroc eq] Jo slessu eqt Surpren8e3us :og aJqrsuodsal osle arv ,(aq;'600U ot f96t slty soruedruo3 eq1 Eursr.rduroc olnlels qslrl r{lritr pus puelerl ur pelda:ce f1p:ouo6 spr€puels Eu1}unotceqlr^\ etueproJcs ur parudard e.tu $ueurlels lsrcusul;i eql ruq] elnsue ol ueql elqeua puu Iueduroc eqt;o uorlrsod lersrreur3eqt euq due p {rernrce alqeuosusr r.{lr^\ osol3srp leqt lrmocre Jo $iooq ;edord 3u1dea1 ;og elqrsuodsar ere sJo}rerlp eqJ

'Eueursl€ts leroueug aq1 8uuedard q sl$auellnbel eAoqu eql ql!/A perlduoc a,req.,(aqt lsq3 uuUuo' srolrerp oql

'ssoursnq ur enurluor 1[,n,{uedruoc aql }eq} autnsa;d o1 aler:dordduur sr 1tssolun slseq $Jacuot Suro8 sgl {ro passq $uolualuls prcueug eq} e&deJd -

iluapn;d pus eJq?uoseer ele leql saleurls* pue sluerua8pnfe4eu -

: o1 parrnbar ar€ sJolJelrpeql aseql Suueda;d uJ'ree,{ }eq} JoJ;(uuduroc eq}Jo ssol ro lgord aq}Jo pus {uedtuoc ar$Jo srsgsJo 4B}s arpJo.}rrolnrlq pu? on4 ? eAlS qctqm reed lslonerrg qosa roJ $ueuelEls lEloueug arsderd 01 srot}erp rql ssrlnboJ ,rneJ ,(uedr.uoc qsuy

'puetarl quelmomy poralreq3 l(q peqsrlqnd pue preog sprepuslg Surlunomyaq1 r(q penssr splepusls Sugunoccu eq Supnlcur puelerl'u! of,p3srd Eultunoccy padacrv dlursu*g pus mcJ r{srrlelqecqldde qlr,h ecuep;occs ul $ueuepls leliueug eqt puB godeg lenuuy eql 8ur&deJd .rog olqgsuodsar e.re srolcerrp eql

sa;1;gqgsuodsaa rsrolterlq

6002 rsqtrreltg Ig popue l*e,{ aql lo;godea.sroloor!{

sul?qnu

Page 95: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

s e38d

' posolcs{p (loiunbapu pue parldde .{1tu:lsrsuoc'saluelsurnf,;rJsfuudtuor aqt ot aleudo:dde aie sarrrlod Sutlunoclu oql raqrerl.lr. Jo plru 'stuaureluls

Jpr3u€ug aq1 Jo uorleleda.rd aqtu! sJol3eJrp aqt ,{q epeur stuoua.ipni puu selpu-rrlsa luucgru.1rs oq} Jc lueussJsse ue sepnllrrr oslu ll siuaruJlels lelcuuulJeql ut st jnsol3stp pu? slunouE eql o] ]uu.\elar eJuapr^a.+o'srs€q lsoi E uo'uorlEururexa sapnl3ur i lpne uV'pjpo8 s?f, l lJE]dSullrpny aq1 iq panssr (puelerl puu ;1n.) Eurirpny uo sprzpuels l€uorisulrtul rlll.^'r a.u?ploc)e ur lrpne rno patlnpuoc a,.1fr

uoru ldo l tpnEJo s !sBg

'1! ulq]1,{\ sluourelelsslrx1ua:uddu ,(ue .;o e;e,rte euo3aq ar"r ;ir goda: lno loJ suorlcclldrul €qi Jrplsuo3 pue poda.r ,s.rolJaJtp eql pu3l rA\

'poder:no u: uoneurroJur qons epnpur 'alqeonci.rd 3r3q/d'pue plsolcsrp ]ou sr suortoesusl],sloloa.Ilp pue uorierJuntsoJ lsrolJeJrp Sulp:e8a"r mel trq pogrceds uorlzuu.o3ut ,{ue 'uorurdo Jno ul Jr no,{ o1 goda.l osle a,t\

'lunoJcrrJo qooq aql q11,lr luauarrfie ur ele slu?ueleislsrcueurJar{l lar+eqe\ pu€ }rpne :no;o sesod:nd eql .ro3 ,{"rzssacau suolleueldxa pue uorl€[uoJul or{} tp paure}qo a^?q e^\ Jeqleq/r\slels a&l 'uolltppp ul 'sluoix3l€ls

l?r?u9ug aql qll.n luotsrsuoc sr trroder ,sjoloerp aql ug uealt uorlsrruoJut eqr rer{taqA\pue :,(u€dtuol ary ,iq ldaq ueaq slsil lunoi3s Jo slooq rado.rd :uorurdo rno ur loqlaq^\ nod o1 goda: oslp a/r\ '6002

ol E96l 's1cy seruedutol aqi qll,{r f,ruepro3re ur peredsrd .{1rodo:d aJe puu pu?lojl ur 'a)rl3ejd Sugiunoccy prldstov

,{11e.raue5 q}t,tt eJuupro3re uI /rtarl rlEJ pu€ arul e a^lt fluatue}Ets lulJUeuU oql Jaqleqlr o1 su uorurdo rno no{ ol yodar aA\

'per-uroJ e^sq arr\ suorutdo oql JoJ lo 'uodal stql JoJ .Ilo^\

]!pne Jno ro3 ',{poq e se st3qu?u sr{ueduoo ?qt pue dueduioc aql ueql :aqlo auodue o1 .firlrqrsuodsei e[lnss€ ro ldaccelos op a^\ ',ne1 ,{q pepruuad luaDia $allrg. arll o.}, 'esodrnd laqlo ou loJ pue irodar s,ro}rpne ua ur tueql ol alets o1 po:rnbarers 3/r\ sJellEiu asoql sjaqualu sr{uedutos otll ot alets qSlu e,\A lsql os uelsu.pun usaq suq ljo,rl ilpnt tno'0661 '}JV

soluedtuo3 eqlJo f6i uotlres qil^r aru?pro33e u1 ',{poq u se'sroqurau sfueduroc aql o1 {1e;os apuur uoeq suq uoder srqa

'(puelaly pu? )n) Suplpny uo sprepuets lerorlsiualulpue sluauertnbe: ,fio1e1n8er puu 1uFa1 luB^a[3r rlllM oxrippjo3ce rrr s]ueurg]uls tul3ueuu eq] itpne o1 sl ,Qrlrqrsuodsa.l :ng

'pu€lerl sluelunossv P3r4eq3,{q paqstlqnd pue preofl sprepuels Sugunoccy aqt.{q panssr sprBpuels Surlunocce aq1Sulpngrut pueletl ul acrperd Suqunoccy paldaccV Xllereuag pu€ A\el elqecrldde qlr^\ aousplocos ut quaura1uls [urf,ueur;ot{i tut:ederd rog elqtsuodsel oru sro}calrp s,fuedruo3 eql soqrpqrsuodsay ,s:otcarrq Jo lrroweluis aqt ur pequosep sV

sJollpns pus srolJerlp Jo saplgqlsuotlsal aallredsa11

'91 a8ud uo lno ps sarcrlod Surlunorce eql rapun pa.redard uaaqe^eq queuol?ls lertueug asaqJ 'salou p3l?ter eql pue leoqs acusleg aql 'tunoccv ernilpuadxg ? awo?ul eql 3o asr:druocqclq.A'i '6002 raquecec It pepue read aql roJ utu€qnu Jo fl ot 4 se8ed uo sluaual?ls l?rcuuug oql pelrpne o^€r{ )AA

Busqnu Jo sjaqu|atx aql olyrodeA,srollpn11 luapuadapal

surBrlnu

Page 96: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

V;::''

9 '8Bd

srollpny poJslsr8aupus sluslunossv paraFEq3

II!3N,O,tq}.ru3 ilBu8!n{I

0I0Z {EIAI 8Z !etr{

t ullqnc

e?prlqsllrg

pBoU puEF?qtllnqlJoN't8

. 'sluour?l€ls lsroreuu eql qlAr l$alsrsuor sl t pue g sefiud uo uodal ,slolJrlrp oql ur uolt8 uogerlrtoJu! aql 'uotutdo rno u1

'lunorceJo $looqoqr qrll,r lsauaarge ur ale s1uarual€ls lerJueug eq1 ',(ueduroc or{l ,tg }dal uaaq en?q luno3iu Jo qooq redord uorurdorno ul 'lrpne rno;:o sosodrnd aql ro3: ,ftessarsu raprsuor s,r qrrq,il suorpue;dxe pue uorleuuoJul dl$ llu paulelgo a^uil e,46

'6002 ol t96 t 'slcv sarueduiop aqlJo sluewarnbar aq} qlrtr ocuepro:)oe ur pa;edard dl.radord ueaq o,teq -

pus:papuauaqlleedeql loJssol silJopue600zJoquroJac tf lesesr!e.$Es,AueduroceqlJo olels equo 'pselaJl ur ecprer6 Euuunorsv potdoccy,{lprauoD qll/( ocuspjoscs ul '/r'rar^.ll?J pl]e aru1 9 onp -

:queuielels JerJ{rsug aql uolulso Jno ul

uo;u1d6

'slueuro1els plcueug or0 ul uorletruoJur Jo uo!]queserd aqgo ,{cenbep€ llele o3r{} polenle^a osle e/yr uoruldo rno SuruuoS ul 'Jo-ue ro drrelnEa$r Jer$o ro pne4 fq pestl€i J3q}eq fi 'luesJsplssruj

[ErralEuuog oe{ eie sxueure}e5 lelilruug aql leqr ecuernsse elqeuosea.l enr8 o1 oJuaplAe }uerJgJ.rls qli,t sn apno.rd ol Japro urflessocau peltprsrrof, r,r\ qclqAr suorleuuldxa puu uoll€EuoJu: aql Ip urelqo 01 s€ os }rpne rno pau.ro3red pue pauueld 016

uruBqnu Jo sJaqilau eql ol

uodeu,srollpBv tuapuedepul

Btx8qql

".'p3nEgno3

Page 97: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

, c ;Bd

rol)3Jro- XlpeNlr|"',i ernlig"ij

JOIJ?JrO

inairo j/O pr.uui€la'4^l

:,{q;1eqeq s1 uo pau$rs pue 0t0Z llrdy WLZ rro sro1celgJo prsog eqi ̂ q palo:dde )la.{\ stuaur3tu}s lelrueurl oqJ

's:ee,{ lunueurl oml eloqe aql

=;:;;1--- _.. --::1-

Gtz'tt\ (//8'6r)

JoJ trc$ep:o sn1funs eql xeql reqlo sessol ro sure8 posru8oror ou are uarl.1

rua,{ oql JoJ prulslar ttJ$eq

aurosul .r€ltulls puB

alg€^te3al lsotalul

{ lpuaC} SuueradO

sssuadxe ?Arle4sruturpy

7

soloN

auorul

O I

\ U b L

( 8 i l ' r 8 )

97

( LUO ( ) t . '

I tz6'9LL)

9rL't?69

'

8002

(zes'soc)

686'9S9

3

60az

suoglerado SurnurluoJ

6002 reqruelaq tg pepuo.ruo,{ aq1 ro;

lunoJtV ernllpuadxg puB rruof,rrJ

BurBqnu

Page 98: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

I aBEd

pu" 0l0e IFdv qu.z uo stotseilcl Jo prsog

rolr*rlo

N3l/\r .--*fiag xs

rolreJrotngllo],o pleurerc .rl^i

:dqJpr{eqeql {q pa,\ojdde ejgilr s}uaurelsls l€rc.reug eqJql uo peuSls

;:::-snf.'zLl 89t'Ztl I I

0 t

spu$d

lunocc€ srnllPuedxs puE euro)uls*Arrsru po8 lBIdsJ

se$lEqB!.I

ttlerrnJ ssel slessY lEloJ"

stessv luerrrJ loN

JAe,t e$o urqlr,$ rnp3urle; s1u:rourE :sJo].tpeJJ

pueq ur puE luEq lP qsES

srolqec

slesse e1q13ue1stessv pexu

stt'aLl

:9tt'7,1r

sbt'7Ll

89r'ZE I

89V'Zt l

89b'Ztt

t s b t t t l

0ra's0z

f Ez'981L8V'61

(zrs '8zr)

086'092

t1t'zbzLLg,8I

38002

a6S0Z

seloN

6002 requorao Is l? s8loaqs aruElEB

pgdr3 ereqs B EuFrBq lou puB eeluerBng {q pogurg.l ,{ueduro3 y

Busqnu

Page 99: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

E ' Et -Y?

t Ez'98 t

99t'r?2,teo r'ss)

:(zor'ss)

(z0r'8s)

s06'E(roo'eq)

ta{2t7,

€Ee'98 r0s0'9s

:0s0'9s

t r t 9 0 t

(ez r'sr)9t(ol r'ra)

6 a8e6

6002 roqErssac Ifre spunJ laN

' 6g63,fuznue1 I lB $punJ leNrEoA aql u! rIsBJ u! eselrJEl

(p t afop) spxnJ teu ol luarue,roru ot ̂ ro1 qser fru Jo uorlslllruoleg

:red eq; ul qsBJ uf essalJul

aurostrl Pax?J?cSmaueulg

oJtrsu4lo Suplues pue sluatrrlsalur uo suJnla5

$a!l! llru Supu,rodo Ero{ arog}no qsvr pN

luaurelBls tlrolg q$s3

Elll^llre Eugurado Eto,U Aroglno qsuo taN

s:olrpeJr ur asuelcul/ (asee:co6)s$tqep u1 (aseelcul) essolorq

ssol Suue:odo

sag;rtlJB Eurleredo rrrorJ ̂ roillno qsst

1eu o1 ssol 8u1lurodo;o uoll€lllluoret

f t

I I

{;oa'.'lit (;rrwt

96E'6t {SS0'O){bzn, 0r8(srr 'rt) (to6'6t)

3800u

36002

safoN

6602 raqurala(I Ie papue rBaa oq} roJ

loeHrelBls,rrold qseJ

BurBrlnl{

Page 100: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

0l 333d

-::tt,-:t:::t::::::t:-

8 I f ' 9

a8002

,_-.:..--^J::t-l

) C U L

I

6002

uolleleunu?J sl.lolf,ajI(J

uonelSunlt|tJ .srollpnvslrsse elqrSuEl Jo uorlsrcerdac

:Sur8rsr{r rsSE pa}els sl (lngap)7sn1d.rns 3ur1ered6

(llcgaplsngdrns E$!leiedO

'pusJill ur uale$ePun.{11oqm ,(1rir,gce ledrcur"td sll ruo{ p}^!rap ueeq ssq .read aql roJ ,({redsroc eqt Jo }urocul J?lol orl-L

etr|olul

'pelncur sl arnlrpuadxa pelelar eqt se lunosre ssol p{tB }uord rql ol pes?olerare a.rnlrpuadxt snuelar spJeArol querg 'st?sss srll Jo aJrt 1ryasn pelcadxo eql ia^o tunosoe ssol puel$old oql ol pasealor o:u erqrpuadxa p[dec spreA ol slu€]g 'en{ro^or pajraJop ol pelrper. arE slu?lO

slue-r; lBauruJaaoS

3ul1 lqnlerls olo0z sel3rqaA lolow

:silolloJ s?'3JIl Jlgasn Palcadxa sl: r'^o flporleruolsds lese qsedJo 'anle^ Ienplser Pelsuqlsa

ssrl 'uorluttl?A ro lsot ar'Il JJo aliir\ ol pslelnllBc ss3Er ]e stassE pr;-ll a1q18tru1 lp uo sr uopercerdag'1so3 crJolslq 1e prprorer are slasse paxq slqg8uel 11y

uogunardap pue slasss paxg alq5Euea 'f'l

'lrolord relncqrud pqt qt1mpelstcosse errqipuadxe er11 lsuJ€8? las33o sl pue lslueruelsls

lelrueug eql sl peffeJep sr slreford luer8 a.rngg;roJ palrasal owocur leql sarnsua dqlod sry1 'euro:ur tae:t turr;sgsp go dcrlod s fldop€ {ueduroc aq;

're { eql ol peteler suonsuop pue sluer8go lelol eql siuasardar ourooule[rof,trJ

'p:eog sp.lepusls Surlanoo5y oql,{q pensst pue puelarl sluelunoccv psraueq3 iq paqsrJqnd:soql a:e ^rarA lJ€J pue an4 e Bul,u6 $ueuo1els lupseult Sugederd ul pueptl ur psldacce ,{lpreua8sprepuels Sugunoaey '6002 ol g96t 'slry sarueduo3 eq1 Sulsgdrum elnlels qsul prre pu?lert urpaldof,te i(praueS sprepuuls ?ullunocre r{tytr rcu€plocrs ur par?d}Jd ueaq a^€q s1uawa1e$ plcusug eq;

tro:lueluoo tullunocry

salrllod ?uglunocry

6002 raquresaq Ig pepse ree,( aqg.lo;

sluall|alels l8lJrlsuld eql ol soloN

'n'l

'z'l

' t ' I

. I

sttrBqnll

Page 101: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

: a:#?:r.. '7

II aSsd

600u .t'quroorg If prpue rs3^ aqt JoJsluirural8ls lBpsBrlJ eql ol seloN

800zraqrue33c I!]Y

600eraquo33c It lvsanlE^ xooq loN

60oer3qt1l03ac It lv

lee,{ aql roJ a8ruqJsl€sodslp uo

6002 &Enusf t l\iuo.rlEIsardeo

6002 ragtt:erec If tv

s{usodsrcsuo9lpPv

600z,tsnuef I lY]soJ

s$or ereJlsnA lersosssueles puB se8€A\

slsof, lnour,{o[durg

soadolduo llv

:aleh r?o{ er$ ?qrnp (sropalp aqt Eqpnpur)see, oldurago sraqumu,(lqtuoru eSera,re aqj

sas,{o1dua;o.lequrbN

sao,(o1duilI

8rt'02 8r.8'02

ULU U& 818'02

8T8,OE 8/ 8 '0U

818'AZ

3

IE}OI

-et0'8't

,r*'0.

?

olqqt^rolotr i

r slassu tlqr8uel 'g

(gg1g1 :requrnu xer $ueq3) 'snlels

Eqelueqs s,ll ol anp $ottsxsl urog tdurexa st .{uediuor aq1

I|o!lBxaI

-00s't 9'

06c?rft9'S0t

38002

:a::=-J

0 l

raqtllnN

800r

,et'6tgLr',\ZV

36S0?

:::;e t

.l'qunN

6S0Z

surBqnu

" Pnulluor

Page 102: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

zI aSsd

e I0z - 010e ol Suwlar pa^reiar scorlEuop ot s}1?l3l ilrroiul porlaJsc (€)

rsxd 4 3,4,vd:epnlcur slsos dlrJnc"s lerros pue sex?} raqlo

:::::::::;::::::::::::::

o o o ' /

:S O L L L

t8f'6

889'l,928'?.L6t't r

?800u

86E'0r

:-=z rs '8zI

8 r E','&,t't0l86S'0ttaL'T,izt'9

a6fiAZ

slBrumv(e) eu:ocu1 par$Jag

sgot fllJnoas l?!3os pue saxel JorIlOsrotlpalc roqlo$ollperc rPerl

rsef ruo ulqll.ra* n p B u g l u . l s l u n o r u r : s r o t l p o J 3 ' 6

luno$v luexn]lunossv suorlPuoc

p$GH |I! prr )lu8g tE rls83

orrrorul paruJes pue sluaudedertr

raed auo ulqyt enp EurrlsJ sl$noue :$rolqa6 .. L

tsz'g|t- r0g?e

var'eg vL'at6V0'V7J Z€.9'l tz

9 38002 6002 '8

,rrbt

38002

:LLg'81

a6002

6€Ee raqua3oc le papce rBs aqt roJslsoulalBrs Islru8rlH arll ol seloN

EtuBqnu

p?nulloor

Page 103: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

---'-"-

s06'r-

x

800?

-9rt'zLl

-_.....,.......i

t L t t u l

9Z

3600?

ss?Ar *

g1 a3u4

aruo3ul pojreJec?unueurg

PeArsJer lsejeluloJusrltJo Surar,rras puu sluatalsaAul uo suJnla;

srrolc rlssct ssoJc

'srotcorlq Jo pr?og 'rll pue srtqua4 s1r ,(q po;1o:luoc st ,{ueduro: aq1

Suplupopu n lua.r ed e1etu11161

spung 8urso13

spury Suluedgrear( egtr JoJ lrcga6

spunJ q slssrEa^ourJo uo$erlrJuof,eu 'I I

6002 rtquars(J I€ lv

rea,{ eq1 roJ (l:gaq.1

fgg! &enuug 1 11:

8002 raqruasa{ Ig tv.

rea,{ eq}:o,y (gcgaq)gggT drenurg 1 1y

lunoo rya rn l ; puadxgpu ra rno ru l ' 0 I

' s I

'zl

8t9'6rZttlz'LL)

3800u

SbT'ZLI{as'es)

3 .6002

89t'(.tt

ULB'6f.jsbteLl

:;:;=::9rt'7,11

89t'eEI

Utt'ot)Eb{eLr

:9?teLl

$.Lt'LL)8r9 '6VZ

3

ISIOI

$.Lz'LL)8t9'6VZ

'lunotcBarnlgpuadxgpus aulolul

6002 nquart{l tf pepua ruaf eq1 rol

swelr|etsls lB!3u8u!d eql ol seloN

ErxBqnlJ

panuquot

Page 104: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

t l a ;ud

sll uo peuSrs pue 0l0z lrrdv r{lLz uo srot3arc Jo preoB eq} dq

:" i : :a* *

t0t'znz 0s0'9s gEz'981

Jo]3arro

,{iFN3,^r.aruraA ;i

rolrar!o

rnqrro3,o pr€wlerc'rt \

:{qgleqeqpano:dde ara,lr. sluaualels lercu?ug aqJ

sf uaualBls I?rf,usug Jo lu.a.orddy > t

t0t'ztz

3

af,uslBq

3urso1;

0E0'9s

3

sllrog

qs€J

t9z '981

3

eJuBlBq

Suruadg

spu|u ]eN

PU?{{ ur pue ryeq 1€ qssJ

spunJ lou ug sa8uvqr.lo srs,{luuv 'nl

6002 rlqtueclc Ig papila.rua;( oq1 .ro;

sluauralBls lsl]usuld eql ol soloN

BtuEqnu

Penurluof,

Page 105: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

i u o 1 f n 1 1 t s o : d

; r r l t a i l r n f t 9 t r t r c r c c p - r i o S t t r - t

{ i o / f } J o s f s a d s e i T e a f E f J T T s e ; 0 1 s a J ? r u a u ? a p - r . . \ o - r d o I ( q

I uor tn f , 1 f so :d

r T n = l t p a l t a t ! T 1 1v\r+ e.. ,{c-Ipasa.r pue .3:o dpnls aqf alouo:d oJ, (e

:a-re paqsTlq" lsa sT pueqn1 q]1qn ;o3 (s :cafqo

d:eury:d eql o1 dre111cue et? q" iqrr ) s lcafqo f , :epuoras sq.L - t

'u ra r { l ssa :ddo r {cTqf i d la rcos ur

sa :nJrn . f t rs pue saa jpn fe-Td ' sapnf T313 esoqf e le . roT lau lp 03 (q

pue uaqf .roJ uoTla?npa pue pre ?u1prr,o: 'd (^T)

a lde sa ; i r 1

eleufsfTe ue .{ i loTToJ 01 qsTn or{& asoip ?u1l:oddns (TTT)

s d l q s u o t s e l a : B u l t s n : 1 3 u 1 p 1 ; n q ( T T )

' d l T r u e p T

an:f . ITaq? Ia/rocsTP UIaLl1 dlaq ot fno ?u1qcea.: (f )

- :18 pauTp uor1n1T1so:d u1 uauon o f e r rA . ras

?urpualrg:aq E afeuTpro-o? pup aslue?:o 'atrouo:.d 01 (e

- :o1 a;e pogsTTqp?sa sr eureqn1i q"Tq!4:oJ stcafqo u;eur aqtr '1 ,

'?urer{n6 sr dueduro3 aq3 Jo eueu aqJ, 'T

\u{wffilY

d0

rEoI$rcDosE\f ,to ntxtllE|lorElt

TITIAV3 SUYHS V 3NIAVT{ TON ONV SATN]|dVNC AS OSIIHII INVdHO3

7t

066T OJ [96T J3V S3lNvdNO3 3Hr

Page 106: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

Y

I eueqng Jo s f ,?a fqo u teur

aq1 aloulo.rd 01 san.ras !{eTu.,! go asod:nd aq; pue Lg6I

3cV xp3 auro"u l aq1 Jo (TT) (e ) (Z) AeV uo l fcas - repun

paqsT lqe f sa tsn . i l aTqpro^a f lT due Jo aa l .sn- r l se 3ce o i (T

I eureqng Jo sa^Tf"a[o.c uleir.r aq1

8u1:aql:n;: go asod:nd eqe .roJ a.rarfrasTe pup puETarI

uT uos:ed pue salpoq f ,e l1urTs q?l ! r a ie. roqeTToc oI

i s lcaf ,qo

ureu aql 3ul.n a1qce Jo asod:nd aq? f,oJ aIqe.r.Tsap

eq?noqr aq Tleqs sE srrr.ral uo spunJ qcns asrnqslp

o? pue sluaiuded :aqfo ;o TPnuue of acafqns saTuour

.ro slJT? arrT""ar otr pue aulEs aq? ;oJ trsn-rf uT spun;

plor{ ol. pu€ EueqnE aq? Jo.s3cafqo urelu €r{f Sulaourord

Jo esod:nd aql f oJ afe:od.:oc saTpoq -ro suosrad

rtro.rJ suoTfdTfcsgns pue suoTf.euop .(1dde pue a4.Tacal oI

i erueqng ,tq paplrro:d secrr.:as sq? f,oJ spunJ pr:e

suo11d1:csqns 'suoTlnqTr?uoc ?raTToa pue rog ,(1dde oI

iuolg.eulul.rcsTp qcns a"npa"f otr.,{.ressaceu

s3ulqr ITB op oa pue uo11n311so:.d uT ueuon Jo

uoTlesT1EuTg.ze$ pu€ sa"Tlsnfu l 'sac lpnfa:d ?ugr : :acuoc

uoluldo aglqnd tnloJuT pue e?eqap c11qnd afe1rutrTls

01 pu? slcefqo uTBul sql Jo acT^:as pue liSauag

eql :oJ unroJ a se 13r 03 uoTfesTue8:o ue aplaord o;.

:sa;cu.e?e raqlo qlT!{ uosTaTT uT

f,o dltca:Tp :.eqfTa uoTleSTTTqrr{a: }o eairE oqf uT pue

uoTlnf Tlsojd Jo uoTluaAerd ;:o ea.re aql uT lsTsse otr,

: sacTAras ,{l3unuuoc

ITe Jo Eu111ene pue uosTpTT SulSernocua ueuo$ aq1

qlTA >laoll dno.r8 :o ',{11ureJ llenpT^TpuT uT a3e?ua ag

(3

( J

( a

(p

4*

( c

Page 107: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

7{

'BuiEqnN dq ua4el:apun aq de,u qcrq.^r sarcuaSe -lo

' s1sn :1 ' aT tT? ' l ueuanoc Kue g :o f unoocs uo saa lue - ren8

: to spuoq a l r r? o1 pue dr :ado:d qcns due of , :auueu

due uT :o '3o lcnpuoo pue luauaSeueur ,uot1e: ts luaurp€

aq3 03 8ulAe1ar "sTrr]..:aqf,o

.ro d:euo11a:cs1p ,s.ranod

.ro s1q?1: due :o dtgs:aur'ro go slq?1: -{ue asrc-raxa

01 pup 'o61sn_If a-rpq sE ueq1 asrAlaqio euer{nu uT

patsa^ d+-rado:d lsnjr:. due aues aqa ?ulecag:3e palldur

fo pass":dxa lsn.If due qSTA acuepfocce uT 1ua?e

ro ro?ceJ aafsn.al sE lJnpuoc pue a8eueu .:alsTuTu:pe oJ

: dr.radoed

fsnJl q"ns 3o ouoauT ar11 03 .ro 1e11dec aqf 01 sa?.eTa-r

auEs agf .:ar{]'eqA suoTlau?suT Jo suoTaca-rTp q"ns el\i?

of palsffua dpoq paln?Ifsuo" dlnp .due dq e{ueqng of

uaa13 ag de:a qcTqn sureqnE uI pefsan dt:ado:d 1snr1 {ue

01 uoJlEler ur suoTlcnrlsuT .ro suoTlce.rTp InJrrlBl due

1caJJ" olur dr:ea o? pue q?TA acu€r1dtuoc ur -rs^.eosXEr{.tt

lce ro uoTlcunJ 'dfnp '1ngrrre1 due rn:og:.rad ol

!sScefgo ag+ SulSourord u1 pase8ua suos:ed :o uos:ad

jraq?o .f,ue :o saafoldura pue s?tre;rtas Jo acuEuaS.ureru :o

uoJferaunu€: aqx :o3: a:ed uT ro eToqrr u1 Surp;,to"rd pue

Eu38e3ua 03 palTrrlT aou 3nq ?u1pn1au1 BurBqnE J:o {.roa

aq1 uo 9u1^f,r:ea .roJ sluauaguer:e leclace-rd TIp a{€u otr

lerueqng Jo salTleefqo aq+

Sulloruo:d o1 .,tre11;cue ro Jo lT3auaq oq? f,oJ slsn:f

pue spunJ 'uolfnfTtsuT 'suoTl.ETrosse 3:o froddns pu"

auaunlsTlqelsa aql uT pIa fo f.:oddns pue qsrTqe1.sa oI

(ur

( T

({

( [

"+F.

Page 108: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

F:.{t "

' s l . uau l seAuT

qcns f,:e,r oi pue fTJ lofqa

deifi eureqnu se ro pafce.rJp

aq dea i se suJa f qcns uodn pue sa r f r l n3as qcns uo

d11e:aua? ;o uo- i t? fod.roc :o {uedruoc due 3o satntuaq"p

.ro se.rpgs 'slcoas -ro pupl Jo sseq".rnd aqr uT ?sanur

oX .ro (lou :o saaf.sn-rf dq fuaur3sa^ur foJ esTlor{?ne

:aqfaq,'r) dflrncas ,(ue :o ,d11uaueu:ad :o dltre:odural

BurEqnE ,(q pTeq spunJ eqf Jo ?-rpd du" .ro TIe tsa^ur otr

. "lir?qnu

Jo saTlT:ncas fo suog1e331qo . Iar . { to . Io sa3e31:orn

'sa?.ou "(.rossluio-zd

'a8ueqcxa Jo sIIlq , a.rnluaqap

' spuoq uodn ro enssr aqe dq esrr,ueq?o Jo sfuno?"e

8u3>peq uodn ' lsa-rafur 1e i lauour asre: :o 'to.rJoq otr

' suoTlepouilotce

pue sacuaTuaATroc 'sarcueerldd.e . snSe;edde . s8ug111g:

'arnfTuxnJ 'sa:n1x13 d;essacau pue :ado:d IIE

QlTnr a[Ies aql apr^o:d of, pue 3aafqo qcns .(ue f.srsse

Jo e&eqnts dq pTaq aues €qf 3o 1.:ed due .xo ?urp11nq

tag?o :o uoo.: 'aclgigo .lTeq. ,(pnls , TIeq "(lquiasse

due aro lse: [ . ro :1eda: ' : "?Ie .u le3ureur .Jca.ra ot r

'EurEqnU tro sa^.T1ca[qo aqr Jo uorloruo:d aqa

01 r'rarrr B qlTlr lualpadxa peuaop aq .(eru sB puel gans uo

s8u;p11ng ?noqlTt .ro r{fTrr raql1a pue u}a.raqf ?sara?uT

lo afpfsa due. :ogr e.rnlBu .{ue Jo ,{l:adord f,€qlo

lo TBnfcaI IatuT '111l rpoo3 .sasnoq .s?ulp l rnq 'spue1

^{ae Jo esddsTp jro a8e3f-rou .1€T .asruap .aSueilcxa

'TTas 'aao:dqr .a3eueu .plor{ ,elrnbce .eseqcrnd 01

( q

( e

-:pa:a^uodura

acu".raqf.rnJ uIaq TIBr{s (ueduoS aqf sSaaf,qo ureu slT J o

Page 109: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

Y

r o p l E d e q T T B L I S

Jo unPuProuial^l sTql

a q f J o ' u o I f . o t l l o f , d

saAT-iap jlanar,4or{ pi-re

Joa:aq f uoT: ] . rod .

ou puE

uJ q f . . Io f las sz ' Eueqnu Jo

aq i sP:e i ro l {1a1os pa j ldd '

acueqtt Eulerfnu Jo ,h:ado:d pue

u o T J e T J O S S Y

s a ^ J : 3 a r q o

aq TTPqs

auocu-r aql

u o T u n

3P"r1 p 1T a{su plno& eneqnu Jo ff ,arqo ue

Ji r{3Tqlyr uoT?Tpuo) .ro troTSeT.rf sa.r .uot3e1n?a-r

due s-raq?o .ro s-raquau slT ,{q pa^Jaso:

aQ o1 a- lnoo:d :o asodur o f tnoAeapua fo raa fqo

.dus spunJ slT qlTll ?:oddns 1ou TTeqs eueqnU

puP sfsn.ff

t{3ns 03 pze?az ?u1rr.eq irrel dq pa&olIe se -rauueiu

r{"ns uI auBs ]sallrlr jto r{f}r\ Ts_ep dluo lIpqs

arsBr{nE 'trsn-f,? .f,ue o3 3aafqns eq ,{eur qeTqA

f, lrado.rd due ploq .ro a{p?. TTeqs €u€gng ase? uI

(z

:1eq1 paplnotd uaqt Jo auo due .ro euler{n1 g:o saa.lfcafqo

aql Jo uoTl.ouro:d aq1 o3 alT3npuoc punoJ aq deu :o ol

IB3uapTcuT are se s3u1qa InJ:lrpI :eqto q3ns IIB op otr

- as.t}t-Iaq?o :to

saalsn:1 's-xo3.ce:luocqns ,slua3e qfno_rqr -ro dq .r.aq?:a

pua asTrlraqlo .ro aalsn.r3 ,3ue3e .1ed1cu1.rd se rerpTa

pT.roA aqf Jo f:ed .due u; s3u1qr aloqe aq1 Jo TTq op oI

'sTq€: lsap

ro dr?ssaaau punoJ aq deur s? :ei.srgar u?1aro; .ro le"oT

qrns due utr setl:ado:d s3T Jo .Kue ro EupqnE .r"fsTBsJ

01 dJessaoau aq dern qcTqr4 sacue.rnsse .ro , spaep

'slcs 11" auop aq 01 asTfoqlnE pue op o? pu€ .qcns

sE s.racTJ]o sfT :ro Eueqnu 1su:e?e pue dq s?urpaacord

1e3a1 asluro:druoc :o alnf.T?srrr ,puag:ap ,lanpuoc oJ

\ l

( ?

f ' r

( a

ff i4s^" t - .i ' r 4 r y 4 , , 4 F r 4 4 r ! * ! ! r ! G r q ! ! { ! i l ! r a r E 4 ! ! r n Q t ! ! ! n r

Page 110: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

r.F

aqf Jo . laquau q3ns ou :.eu.? os fnq -:oqfne ::ed .ro

foqSne s1 dpoq 8u1u:a.rro? Jo p-r.poq aqf Jo raqurau qcns

tir lq$ Jo {for{ paqsl lqnd due 1o f cadsa: u.r eujeqnU dq

pa^ra?ar sar31e{o . r . {ue 3o 3 :ed fue :o dpoq ?uru :ano?

.fo p:Boq aq3 g:o :aquaur due of eiu€rlng dq luaur{ed

aqf o f , d ldde T lpqs qde:8e :ed s l r l l uT paure fuo" ?u lqaog (q

leua'lded qcns due

3o laadsa-r uJ aATaca: deu aq s11go:d ;:o ereqs due ro;

funot?e of punoq eq fou Tleqs raqur€lu r{"ns pue 1e1.rdec

aq3 Jo luae:ed auo Lreql arour pToq 3ou TTeqs -reguau

qcns qcIqn ur pue .rsquau e aq .{eur dpoq Buluraa.o? f,o

prpog aq? Jo raqurou E qcTq& go dueduroc .{ue o1 luaur(ed

r(ue ot . tTdde 3ou TTer-{s pTBsa-roJp lseT uorsrr ro-rd aqtr

:3Eq1 S-LVfi.IV GgOIAOtsA puet{ng o? }aT -ro pesrurap ses"rnra:d aqf

roJ f.uar dl-radord pue aTqeuos€a.f, ro 1u3t .{auou uo presaroJE

afE.r aq1 f€ 3se-r.a3uT puB sasuadxe 1alcod g:o fno luatnded.*a:

ldacxa .{poq Sulurano? .ro p-rpoq qrns Jo :equrau ,{ue otr eueqnE

dq aaa13 eq l leqs quo& saruolu .:o dauorn uT llJauaq ;raq3o

Io uoTf.Blaun&ar ou iErI3 pu€ saal dq pled euer{nE Jo ec}JJo ,(ue

to Eueqnts Jro ac'JJJo parf,€Ies ,{ue ol palurodde aq TTeqs qu"qnU

gio 3u1aq auTt at{f rog dpoq Sulurano8 -ro ITcunoJ aqf, Jo .laqneur

ou Seql os ?nq Butsqng 01 f,equrau due ,{q fal ro pasruep sasrua:d

ro} luaf, :ado:d to alqeuospaf, .ro luaT ",{auoul uo urnuuE :ad

gg ?u1pee3xa eou ?3EJ € lE asaf,afuT Jo luaurIed €ga Sualard :ou

trllEqnts o+ paraBuer d11en1Cp Sacr^-ras ,(ue roJ urnlal ur Burpqnu

Jo raqurau due of :o ruer{nu 3o aadoldua ro lu?A;ras due 01

uoTlerauriua: rado:d pus elqeuossal Jo ,q1]EJ poo8 u1 1uaurdcd

aqf fua^a.rd rT€qs uraraq 3u1q+ou rvl{J srvlllv (sorAoud Eureqnu

;o s;aqurau ar{f o? eTJo;d g:o de*r, dg :aa€osnoq asTnr-raq?o ro

snuoq 'pueplaTp 3o .r(e.ot dq (lfcarTprtT ro fllaarlp pe.rreJsu?rl

Page 111: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

r,?

' T J ? u r p a a c x a l o u p a f ] n b a . I

eq deur sp funcue qcns ,saA lasuaq? 3s?uoutp s - ro?nqr :3uoo aq?

3o sgq?1: aq l Jo fueu?snfpe aqr roJ pup dn-?u lpu- rn ;o sasuadxa

pue sa8:eqc ' s?soc aq l pup . raquau i e aq o f sasea? aqs a f ,oJaq

PafsP: iuoc eueqnu Jo saT l rTrqeT l puB s fqap o-q t Jo luaurded foJ

' . taquaur e aq o f sesear €qs . ra f3p lead euo u lq f l$ - ro taquraur e

sT aqs aT'IqA dn-punon Suraq aurEs aql Jo lua...a aql ul eEEqnu 30

s?asse aql ol axnqT.:fuoc 01 sa{eqfapun pueqnu Jo .raquaur d:aa.3

'palTurTI sT s.laquaul aq1 Jo ,(r"l lTqelI at{l

'eaafqns sT e96I '1cg saluedrnog aq: g:c

t?z uall,cas Jo esuens;nd ut e?:auuo3 pue f: lsnpul roJ .raSsTuTH

aqa .{q pa3ue:8 acuacTT E qcTq.ri ot suoTfTpuoa 3u1u1e1uoc

uyrpue.rolrap s3ql 'ecueurg jroJi ralsTuTli aqa q11l{ uorJ€?Insuoc

rafJe dluo uaal? aq 1feqs leno.rdde qcns urnpuprour€I^{

aql Jo 6 pue E sasnpl3 go 1cedsa: ur aeqt SlVflTV CAqfAOXa

s.rauoTssTrnlo3 anrraAa1 aq1 .tq pu? ac:oururo3 pue d:tsnpul

ro; :alsTuf1^i aql dq pano-:dde uaaq p{re 03 pal?Trugns dlsnolrra;d

ueaq aAer.l l lerls aures aqa sseTun ac.roJ ur ?u1 aq aurlf aq3 roJ

uoT1eTsossv Jo salaTf.rv fo unpusroilax aql lo suo1s1,ro:d sq1

]o due ol apeu aq TTEqs luaupuarrtg .ro uor?€:el1e ,uo1tr.1ppe oN '9

'polunoc eq fou Tleqs efo^ sTrl 'a3oA

os seop aq JT pue osla.o:d 1.uasatd. sTr{a uT. pauoTfuaut

sT sB luaurded qcns r(ue o1 ?u11e1el Joererll EurEqnN Jo

aa?XTcnnoc due :o 1r?unot aq? ro eueqnU Jo uoTlnlosa-r

.{ue Jo laadsa.r uT al^o TIBqs .(poq 8u;uraao8 :o preoq

5

Page 112: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

' op o f os 3u1: I lA1 uJ f ,s€nba- r - rTaq l uo s lauo l ss . t l i l l l to3

enuaAad aql of aTqelTeAE apsu aq l lBu.s BujEqnx Jo s?€aqs

acueTeq pue s iunoooe er { I ' s fo lTpnB paT l iT lenb d1 :ado:d €ro i r lo

auo .{q pauge:i lacse sf.a"qs orupleq ori t Jo ssaufco].roc aqf pue

pauJupxa aq T leqs eureqng Jo s3unocae aq l :eod d :aa .a u1 fs€a l

?€ aau6 'sf,aquau Jo uoracadsul : .og: uedo aq lTeqs strunocce

qans acro3 u1 3u1aq aurTf arp .roJ erueqnp Jo suol3e1n?aX aqf

q?T$ acupp-rocoe ur epeu aq deur ter{ l suoT?cTrlsa: aTqeucsPa-I

due 03 lcafqns pup eupqnE Jo salf ITTqeII aq? pup slrpa:c

6r {1 'd? . rado:d aq l Jo pue 'aae1d e{s1 arn lTpuadxa pue s3draca:

qcns qtTqlr 3o lcadsa: ur sialfeu aq3 pue errrer{nU ,tq papuadxa

pue pe^Taca: dauour Jo surns aqi Jo rda4 aq Tteqs sJlrnocoa an.r l ' 0 7

'3ca fqo

aTqeSTf,eqc a&os ot uaql 'uo3slr'ord qcns <r1 uaal? aq touuea

l"oJJa 5B .leJosuT pue uT puE uoTlnlossTp Jo auT? aql €roJaq

f,o fe ?rtreqn5 Jo s:"quau .aqe .{q paulru.:alap aq 01 suo}1nlTfsuT

:o uoTfnlT?suT aTqelTreqa t{cns 'Joe.Ieq 6 plle E sesnelS Jo

anfJl^ ,(q :o .r?pun eusqnE uo pesodur sT s? feae8 sE fsea1 1e

fualxa r(ue o1 sraqureu .rToqf ro str Suoue dtradoid pue auo?uT

rTaqt .ro stT Jo uoTtnqTrlsTp at{1 tTqTr{o:d lTeqs qcTq& puE

' eueqnS Jo slJalqo aqr o3 .rETTltrTs s3caf,qo 8u1,req suoTlnfTlsuT

:o uoTfnlJ?suT alqElT.r€r{c raqf o auos otr Parf.aJsuBJl

16 rialtr?-.aq IIBqs lnq EureqnX 3:o sra{uraur aqa Suoruri pelnqj:es1p

ro 03 pT€d aq lou TTeqs €uPs eq? ':raAaosSeqn .{aradord

.(ue' s€TlTIIqetrT ptlp sfqap sr} TTB Jo uoT?cEJSJles aI$ :af.Je

suTaural e:eql erueqnu Jo uoT"nlossTp ro dn-?u1pu1l,r aqtr uodn JI '6

Page 113: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

:a l suT d s

fo f Jo0

ra3 suT ds

-raf suI ds

ar fua3 d11ueg

Peou

pue pITq3

tz uTlqno

1qgPTletr

uo18ugsse1f ; pT0

spot Jo uqor ?s

tI N]'ISnO

uf 'o1sieo3

lieoa pnceurTrx ]ar,o'j gtz

^ ^ - ^ , , J ^ f is l a J s t s p l a q G a q s P o o S

xgs'Ivc!{ u3J

'.ij.r"i 'l

USINV' STVX

, . . [ :*q*) *tdb.Ftrh

socusg N,\TaAs

- - - -A r - - - -c---v L-1 t

-"lrn7r ruL /

.I'HVJ \n39NV

e,H %*V

1}{N3f J.ij - - - - 1 ' ', - \ { a r - |{ t

tT uTTqnO 'uiriofs?aog

psots pnceuTTx .laltlo'l Etz

s. le f sTS p:aqdaqg poog

' 6 u}Tqn(I '?:Puoculnrq

'peo1 4:edace.rg

'>lrad q31g 'rrr'relgJaa_g ?

.(r;;leq3 go dpel .rno Jo s.?alsTs

NOIrdru3saq

sTqa Io eauens:nd u1 duedurog e

aae- suolldlrasap pue sessaJPpe

ssguqqv SSHVN

- :uoTleTcossY J:o Ulnpue:ouran

oluT pouuoJ oq 01 qsTll paqTrcsqns

'sarreu esoqlr suos:ad TB:aAas aqf A$

Page 114: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

_"2-"/4

Y / d ,/ r'r; Y'-" f

t ?6{/p-s?

,r2or,& /'oh vT

/-q, /raSsuldg

.rof."oc

ra lsuldg

s.I?3 5T S

luacs€jr3 aSue:g g

.t1p:eq3 3o .,tpe1

arleq?oe1 unq 'a8uerg aqt to TITX f;.a;r;-,-t - " p / "37y}

:SSUNJ,VN9IS gAOflV SIij, OJ, SSSNIIII

v3HS,0 N33UON

wr"tq iiaz--;;i,'/

,,i2 -

'jl-

<a-

l,/,y

'p. :oJ latef l

peou )1.1o,

p:aqdeqg pooX

l' uTlqno UONNOS.O NNV

uTlqnc oc THdENfi \NISHS

'1uarruo3 a3ue:g

.Ino Jo s.IalsTS

9 uTTqng .il{dEoH 10w3

,#F

Page 115: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

7-

;^'" ' r lt , j . L ,

, \ : snLAeAeH F36i90 A

ssa. rDpe a^oqe aq l o l apeur aq p lno l l s a le f tJ rua3 s rq i o l Eur l r i ie r sa t ranc

]3ulsrO {yr3 q;rog uorOag ullqnCuappej j ue!l l l^^

palnbar sr alec4ya3 e3ue:pal3 xel e ro uotl3npotd alaqla, sacuelsuno:r3 Iue ur pasn aqdeur a1ecr1ya3 srLli '(pasn sr alporllpao aleredas E riolqm Jol) l00Z

'l3V a3qlo rlqnd Llr sprepueis aq1 ruot; ;redy

'Japro

ul ale sltPJlP xel suos]ed aql leql urruuo3 ol a^oqe pauleu uosrad aql ol panssr sr aleorluao aouejealC xEl- slqj

aLo7rcta : Flun pPn

-:JsqrunN alestl tuag xBI

aleclluac a3uelealS xel

500a das qle

OO0999g ig:sauinbu3

6 N t tSnocu vuvd lf ,vu3

f931103 St lo l lvH - l lv

fSNOH UO I NfSrf,fcoud s,NSwoA v!\ivHnu fH_t

I

I ullqnotS llauuo3,O rdn gt.r6

soairuas raurolsnclculsrg dt13 qpo51 uorba6 urgqn6

uappel I uletll{\A

re :oNl3u-oN

|!f :c11 uorle4sr6eg:elcnb asea;d acuepuodsa:;oc ;1e r'

E1

Page 116: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released
Page 117: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

saururEJSor6 Aglenblrateue6g auurertor6

llauuoorw 3lurag

' tv-"'€fi1 Vr*V

'A1ala:urs sJno1

'a!'leqod'nnr$rv1 - altsqan tEqod aq]uo peqsrlqnd aq ;frvr arnseaw uatroA1 .ro1 A1r;enb3 aql ol suo1le:rldde JoJ sllel a;nlnj Aue uouolleuJjolul -uolseflo sltll uo lnlssaf,f,nsun se^\ uo11mr;dde JnoA leql laJgal ann ,ule8e alug

'8rc nrs 19) sr.uo61 auuaqlpl ro (gTZ rrrE r0)Algay eleng raql la pe1ua5'o1 aletrsaLl

lou op aseald uleal. ruM3 aql Jo rsquraLu e q]!/rr uo!]erlldde lnoA ssn:srp ol a{!l plnorn noA;1

'uolsef,fO sltll uo lnlssalf ns lou se,1uotle:t1dde .rnoA leql noA ur-ro;u1 o1 1a;8al aM leql ]xalu03 srr{} ur sr }l 'spunJ

Jo uo!}e}ltlrlaql ol anp 'spue:ls aalql aql ssorfe pa^laf,al suorlergldde aql ,o o7og7 Agaleu.rrxo.rddepun, ol a;qrssod A;uo servr ll AlaleunlJolun pue paqlJlsqnsJano Apneaq sen tsrnseal4aqr -suolte:rldde Surpun; lle lo ssalord lesle.rdde llnl e looilapun leqod

.ajnseay\ uatxoAn.to; A11enb3 aqt to spuerls aalql aql ssojf,p pa^raf,ar ara^A suorlerrldde lrt tp lelol v

'SI0Z,0I0Z (runnl) ornsea!\l uauo6.rol rtlr;enb3 aql o] uorlerr;dde lnoA.ro;noA lueql ol r{sr/v\ sre}}v }qrellaeg pue Aylenbl 'Allunr.uuroJ

}o }uatrluedao aq} pue leqod

uosuag shl reac

gt$W4fig lay / efOZ*rc7 ilnsaary uawol{t nt fig1onh3 :ag

ol0r raqopo qlt

{ar;runtudto) Suriioddns luaururanoE

'rro"utllll:'a8ag1o3 srnolleH llv

'asno11 Jo:uaSeuJeqnu

o3l. uosuag qejes su\l

apl rol uolpalau;o lapa-1Ado3

+ty

Page 118: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

Ul ' l h0 i ' l \ ' \ i ' r : ' l l : i ' i )

' , i i1n:rg ; .q 'u{}sM. l { iX

w1:::r::: ' ir ' :1 .::.: i :::: ! r i;r lr idrf] l lMft&ffi

reilet AH} pue J)l_ ]uaJrns qeweqna lo ldos vuo\enossv Jo seplyv g wnpueJowew s,euJeLJna jo Ad$ v

6AAd slunosoe pnuue qeueqng Ja Id$ V:saJnsolSuf

033uosuog qeJPS.

----*) tZV'

'asJnoo anp ur asuodsel:no[ Euueaq o] pleiv\Jol looleM

- 'sn peiuo3 ol elelseq lou op aseeld uoqecr;dde

aql lo uo[elaplsuoe eruysod rno,{ lsrsse plno.n leq} uortrerxJo}ur Jaqpn} Aue e1r1 HnoA^ no^ }l

€r'leqod@ul ,\a o1{epol pelleulo uaaq osle seq uo4ecr$de aqlp ddor gos V'sluaunf,opFurpoddns palsanbar aql are pasoloue osly 'lueuAoJdur3 o1 ssecov - I puerls 'g

LgZ* 0t0Z alnseaft s,ueurogJo, firlenbg eql Japun uo[mtldde s.Bueqnu pssopua pug €seold

'Jrs/uepeyl Jeacl

0Loz €unr ql?L

'z ultqnc'ls sal|oH

'esnoH looJqloH'leqod

'a:nsea6; uoruog JoI rfi tenbS

t:'Etrlaqn.t'/u .r$ 8910998 l fsf :xed z6[0998 I gEE :ouorldrp;6 ullqnq 'u.rprio3r$ru0 'of,e11or -rxolleH fIV'esnog .rone5 'errreqnll

-.sl

Hcltrllliro.rd ;(q patragy uar*c41

sr4fur+rr?r'\nB

\ , )

3u rt.rodu;rq

Page 119: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

} |o1}. t / f1J '0 ' | ( ] ' } | .17}f1Jan' t , ) } ra i ' i0 '4 i ' t0 iF i |L, i f ] i ! - i1.1Ar| . ja i1?, . l , |d j r10,44/r , ' ' )c t ' iT i | ! , : i i

uodcns irailio,li 3s3ili JsJJO o} s}srx3 erli€i{nH 'ss3la3lo^ }JE puc 'taicos Jno i'o sul3Jetil

eqi uo e1ll orllvr uauronilo dnor6 elqelouln .'\ran e 3l€ uotlnlllso:d ut pollo^ul ueulolA

.uorlecrldde

rnoJo 1g) gued o13ur1e1er ]T4,C;} ]lpnv &eJsS ?9 t{l1es11 33gI u}c'g }3erlxg o'uorlectlddu

rnoJo 1y) gued o1Bur1e1e-r luerunrop rlorrcSaE dalg 1xa51ot{Ilo '{do3 c

lueueluls uotsslJ ry slnqsolg €uleqnts '

v}auc.f,oT irodag IEiuuaIB eiueqnE '3s"ol Jo ,{do3 o

31e3i1lil33 aouereal} XUI o

slunosse 1u33eJ lsolll aqlJo ',{doc y o

s.ratlddns ry slolse:luoc uro4 suorlulon| ?

ru-loJ uollef,rldde psiolduror '{i1n3 y ' .

:uolleclldde oqt Jo peci su posolsu? sl uol]"lueruncop SuwrolloJ eql

e pue,,'":t";il::&u#H*'::;. .uorl*cnpg

Jo oineqos oI{I Japun 000'013 Jo }unoiu€ eql ul Uoddns Suqoes are aI&

'eurwe:8otd

a^oqe aql repun uoddns pnu"ug JoJ uorpsrldde s.erueqnts pesolsuo pug as"eld

' 'rr€p€I tr lo Jrs reefl

ry ATINnNI^ loJ

996g tsn8nV o,f

s00u sNo ITYSINYSUO AuVrNf i roA

assYsA ' | ' IY : )OTUOts rNvucdos } r l h l vu )oud : f f u

t'ullqncpBoU 11dsep 6VitV

ulSlqulty ung

srr?:$Y $Ctt1aeg pue IemE "trununno33o

luou4redeqsgoddng dlrtmurulo3 ry dru1mlon

l lr l r o H f | : a o u i l u o d d n s

e1

Page 120: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

uorvNl(IuooJ rNIsIYuoNnsA^fftrufl) f,lN rsuvsuvn

',{1pgql1ug srno1

'uoddns rno.,{ elercardde,{lteer8 pFoA\ slA

'oru lcstuoc otr elellseq lou op oseeldseuenb due e,req nod g1 'uorpcqdde oql ul peilo sornlrpuedxe sql Jo eclreAolor oql pu"

{ro1r\ rnoJo onle^ aqlJo osues leote no,{ enl8 lly!\ pep4old uorleuuoSur o{} lsql edoq l

',{pueg rer{ pu?Jlesreg roJ q}oq octoqcslql Jo slcedull err4rsod aql pue uoqnlnsord ruog derrre poAotu e eq oI{ { uouroA\ sosol Euruoueeq dlper sr 11 'lueuruoJraue uro1s.,(s Uos e ur soleredo lcoford eql su .,$puenbpue ernseeur otr preq eJB secrlJes euteqnU Eursn;o u?uloi!\ I€np1lrlpq eII] JoJ slgoueq eqJ

'po^lo^w ,{puenbegeJoru er€ socrllos reqlo 'perspnocue Eureq uoruo/lr po{cgJelr Jo Joqumu Eutsesrcureql qpvr 'erorureqlmg '.,fuessacau sI secIA.IoS eJEIo^\ IsIcoS

'spJ€og qfleeH 'sotcuoEe

ssoloruoq Euypnlcul srepr,rord ecrlJes go eEuer eloqA\ € qlp\ uosrerl 'lroddns JoJ eursqnU

trceluoc orlly\ ueluo \ fo speeu peu"A etll Jo esn€c3g 'dno6 lp,aJtrl mo qll^\ 8uq-lorrrsercue8e Jer$o asrlpe pue poddns 01 m selqeuo 1erll uorruBsordgo eere eql ur esriledxepue $ualJadxeso 1ezre1 enbnm

" suq A\ou elu€qn5 'feu:nofrtoql8uo1e ere '{eql JeAeJeqAt

&t47g -

Page 121: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

'ieqod o] orueu {ueduoc:reql Bur8uer{JJo ssaco:d eql ur ere tr4CV *

T,VLOA'T, I0 : . IEJ

suorlesrueS.rg fuu1un1o4 ry,{punuuroJ poseg_f y1eco1toJ sluuJg Jo eunue;Bo.t6

recgJo uorlerlsrunupv

Ir"lonH "rruus

-tlI5

$

NIIIii&'t

?t

TI

IIt

ttIi

. , z /

'flerecurs sJno1

'uorlecrlddernorolyo'nr",i,",XTffi ;::i";':l",Xr:Tff H'ffJ$nclf 31

'uorlecrlddu,rno,t Surpruse: uorlecgusls Jo uorlsuuoJur rsqgrg ,,{uee;rnber oI\Jr pouad lueurssasse oql SuFnp nof qlrrrr lJeluo3 ur eq r(eru e16

'uorlecrldde tno,{ uo opetu uorsnopeqlJo Euquzr ur pauuoJul eq lll^\ no^ 'uorsr3ep roJ 1u"-gnd"q

"q1ol IAtrCV,{q speru eq IIp\ suo4ecrldde IIe uo suor}epuaunumeu .*I^CVo1 eunuurSo-rd srql ;o uoq€4srurupe eQl :og f$Iqrsuodse-r p"rr"gr,rn4

s€q (VCryU3) s4egy tr{cetlosD pu€ Iernd ,,(lrunururoJJo

luerupedeq eql

S9CA/SSII sr raqrunu acuoraJar uopeolldds rno1

.eururer8or4eloqe eq] roJ uorlucrldde:no,(go ldrecet e8pslnou4ce ol qsra el6

'S00U suoIJBsrueErO@JoJ sluarC ;o aruruurHo@

lsr8ereyq reeq

gggglsnEny 1g

6 UIIqNC. eJpuos{uruc

peog ryedece:9s3e11o3 s/r\olluH II\/

(osnoH rorues

,tuaergcpl t:H:;X

AI

Page 122: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

(iunov) pn lueua8uuery luaudololaq eatv se u,lroul f1:etu:og*

eueur) ,{uoqluy

--n---'-'H l-*1;:v/

Alajosuls slno^

(ggAl gVV -fd le leqod ]celuoo asee;d'Jallol srq] ol uotlelal ur sauanb i{ue enaq noI plnoqg

'sr!e#v lqsellaec

pue leJnu 'Ayunuluo3;o luaupedoc aLll Jo Jleqaq uo euuelboJd oLll oulalsrurr_upe

aje oq^ *leqod uloj] Jollal peq3elle alll ur pourllno suotupuoc pue srilJa] pue uotleluaunsop6utpuelslno 1o uotstnold eqt 6lT5e-]ciFpenordde uaeq seq 0urpunl.ro; uorlecrldde ;no1

:esodlnd 0untol1o; eql JoJ uorlesrueOlo .rnor{ .ro;00'982'93 01 dn lunou.re ue loJ ourpun; penoldde seq sJte}}v lwelloec pue lejnu ,rfirunulu.ro3

Jo luaLuuedao aql le alels Jo Jolsrury\ ''o'l uJaqv laoN lerll no{ u.r.ro;ur o1 paseald uje 1

'9002 ul suoqevueitg fuepnyol pue,,{yunwuto7 poseg _ l11eco1ro! sqerg7o ewwefiot4 s,luaulpedag stql Japun 6urpury.ro1 uorlecr;dde s,uotlestue$.ro "rnof b1rale.r 1

'urepey!/lts Jeoc

EtuBqnu - gg0c^/sgll :JeU

g00z rog{uo3ec u,/

6 UIIqNQeJpuocluruc

peo5 >1.tedecerge8e11o3 s^\oll€H II11

sesnoH rorueseIu"qnu

.,{zree-rg c;41 lere8rey4l

Bp

60't88't3 1uau. id rnb318V'169'23 ]uel.IlLlstqlnjsu

er '0te3 luaudrnbjtiururell l lqsJeosau

Durure;1uorleenpf

3 lunouv ad^l luere

Page 123: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

Lr$#i'i r : 0 3 3, - , . . , i ] :

. . ! . . r r a

s r a l f , a I Q

3 r l e q o o , u M e

a_, i eqOG,OStr lr , .Dua.

l t r a i 9 9 t f - ! t + : l

c( la o?a r" E_c€+ :1

t '2 a r ie| .X gl j tv aireg

:-r :r t iCH tr ?rS ' jOOrqlOH r i :9?. i

o i r s l a t l z u r t o f l c

ia: i i lc EAi lOir "SlroH

t0or ' l tOH

Jo luA{ a aql u! llnseJ As{u J slql Jo alsp eqlz ulq]!,!r uolluruJoJu! /uolluluatunJop aloqE aq@

:(s)uorlpuoc cgrceds 3ur,r,ro11o3 oql r{}r/K ecuerlduo3 tr

'e1qecr1dde3r sasrura;dJo es€ol :o drqsraunoJo ecuoprlg D

'elqecrlddegr lesodo:d rnof ol uorleleJ ur uorssmuad Buruuul4 n

'e1qecr1dde3r s1uur8 snor,re:d3o e:nlrpuedxeJo lunocce IIrIJ V n

'peqoe$e sr e1e1duel u - porreJsu€rleq ol sI tsulpulu eql qolq/t\ ol lunocce {uBq orllJo slrulae /N./'uorl€cgrlou sntu1s elqetueq3 ro (0gt'93.rano s1ue.€ rog)

oleogrgeC octruJ?alJ xuJ luorrno s.uorlestu€8ro rno,{;o,(doc y A

:possecord eq,,(eru 1uaur.,{ed rnor{ 1eq1rapro ur (A.OfEg CSXJIJ gy) uo4eruro;ur SurmcilloJ aql,(yddns eseold

:pesseco:d aqfuru 1ueur,{ud rno,( lur{l JepJo ur uorlerruoJur 3ur,ro11o3r eqt,{1ddns eseeld

'/Koleq pauqlno suorlrpuoc eql qll/v\ acueqduoc pue uorlsluouncopJouorsnord eql ol1calqns 'perrordde uooq s"q uorlecrldde mo,( .posr,rpe sv

' S00 Z ur suor1esrupStg f,-relunl oA pue,tlnmurruo3 pese g-f 11eco1

JoJ slu€rgJo eurure.6o-rd .srluJJv lqc€ils€C pue lprn6 .flrunururo3

Jo luaugedaq eql ropun 8urpury roJ uotl€ctldde -rnof ol roJer I

tuepel^yrrs reeQ

utuBqnu - gs0c^/sgll :Jad

s00z Fqrrre""cl ur4

6 UIIqNCsJpUOCruruQ

peo; lredacerge8e11o3 s/!\olleH IIV

(asnoH rorueseruEqnu

f ,raergc14 1e-re8re;41

1u,toffffi-E@uni

Page 124: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

I

" , r - : ; ' , ' , - - t a i r r ' i : i . 1 i : . . ' l

. , . c , . . . i . . , . , , . . ,

r . r i : i ! . r i - _ - , i I f i J i ! : i t { : j { c t

E : a a C F t : l C t : x i : i L ( , Z l : g i . t

'%mqnT!+tLtd on Turlao7n 4.ftrn0/t4 ,to/yvv t17un vtan aln ,),ftu4L/n w /0 &*fu rw 6at6r"7*n \ry

uorlsrlsrurIUpv,{qfun4 eruelatrN

,(y1ryq11e3 srnol

'euruqnUJo >po.^a er{t Bui}roddns -ro3 nof {ueqJ

('roleurpJo-o3 qces4no s.elu?r{nu 'suruurrJ ercu}ed pue JolcsJro s.eirrBrinu'{r{e.{ ueelq}e) dq peu8rg) 'slrcte6 >Iueg s.Btrr?qng Surlsrp l€qod ruo4 rrlroC

(9002qog ,'ti lllun prlen) 'elecgrgal ecuer€el3 x?J ]uexnc s.eueqngJo r(do3

:srrrslr durl\olloJ er{i posolcue pug sseold

srle;Jv ]qcetlo?D pue I€rnd 'flnmurruo3go

luaurgedeqeql Aq pepre^/iloJ se1Y\ r{cftI1lt reqruooecJo url eq} poiep:e11e1 rnor( o} reqUnC

BruEqnu - gs0J^lsglI :eruereJau lBqod

u?sns Jesc

g00z roqluacecl,,,02

T, UIIqNCItaerls selloH

asnoH >loorqloHsorlrunuruo3 Surpoddns - Ieqod

selse^ rnsns sw

CIz

9002 ]]0 z u

:r ro*r I r d o H I t * _ . o d d n s

Page 125: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

lsqr.unN tunocJV ILIBB

^., . . - t . , f " t :elec !- \r-\ )-a€. :elec

\, ./ ( "--,,\ . \ - ,

uor leslue8ro ur uor lrsod

;r:) 4 'trn 41)J,tc J)

(qe11de3Icolg) atueN

uorlesrueS:O ur uorlrsod

(qe11de3lcotg) arueN

ar leqod eaM

ar teqciciOsar !nl l ra

l - i r 0 1 9 9 - i e E t + : J

ooto ara T 8. ,€+ : l

air_l a Lllerlc 9r_liv atr€gsa|oH prg.rs loojqroH q3eal

puets j ! z u r lqnclaa.']S SalloH aSrrOH )jOo.rf, ltOH

:selrluluasordar posgoqlne 3r{} {q uorlesrueS-ro aql3oSleqoq uo peu8is

',(11ry qlrlr parldruoc aq IIIry\ pu" sn ol elqeldeme oJ",{aqt teqlrruguoc puu luer8 slqlJo suorlrpuoc eql puelsrepun,(11q pue peet a^Bq eiA

s0c^/sgl I :oN eruaraJauErrruqng :erusN uorluquu8rg

suorlrsluuBrgry f1;unururo3 pasug rllyucol roJ slrra.t3;o auurur8or;

eeu4dacey Jo uo-rluJu1cag

9002 u0 z z

l@-:apof uos rue8

jff'rserppv IueB

:oruuN{u€B

{UBB:etUeN lunoscv

lunoJJv {uBg Jo slrBlao

ar}tunuluol Suryoddns

tz

,{r4un1on

Page 126: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

jo iE i j ipJooc

salea^ uesns

i{;otecurs s_rno1

'0urpun1 srLll u-rorl pred sacrrues .ro / puespoo6 oql Jo sjorlddns Jno^ pue so^lasrno^ uaoMlaq ]salalul jo lcruuoc ou sr aroqi leLil e

,{auou roJ onleA ure}qo ol uor}e0rlqo JnoI pue}srapun no^ leLl_L Z]uoul^ed srq] po^ra3or o^ell no^ ieqt L

- : u J J U U o 3 o } a l q l S S o d S e U o o S S e J a } ] a l p o q 3 e u e a q 1 1 o @ a S e e | d

t9l,00rz- r0]e oLU loeluoc aseald 'anoqe aq] ]o ̂ ue Ouuedard aouelsrsse ,{ue arnbal nori 11

'6urpun1 stql uJol1 pred sacrruasjo / pue spooO asaq] 1o srerlddns {ue pue senlasrno^ uaa^ }aq lsala}ut }o }l l}uo3 ou aq osle

plnoqs alaql rerlddns euo ueq] arour r-uo.r1 salonb loes o] aleudoldde aq aroJareql Ier-u 1; 'deuou

Joj anle^ Oururelqo ]o lnlputui oq ]snlu no{ 'Ourpun1 srq} UJoJJ sectruas pue spoo6 Ourseqcrnd uaq4l

'eruurel6o-rd slr{l Japun 6urpun; aJn}n} fue uo.t; dnol6 rnoA opnlcxe ,{eu slql op o} arnlre3

'asodrnd o|.I jes stql ro] pasn lou seM aolnos Jaqlo Aue uoll oulpunl }eq1 .'papreMe se^ ]r t l3rq^ ro] asodlnd aql roj pasn se^ 1uel0 aq1 }eql o

:6urmo11o1 eql 6ur,i1pac rarnseer-1 pue uos.redtteqC oql riq pauDts luaurolels V 'f,

' tgl3 ]seal 1e;o Ourpunl DurqcleLu ur o lno^ pue Oulpun,r ggL'93 'al'1cefo.rd aqt ro anle^ lelolltl] o1 (spelap lvn qlf ) sldtaca; ro soston ut pred ;o ddocoloqd y 'Z

: ]tuqns o] poou os;e no{ 'ale1dLua1 slrl} q}l6'slt-i]

q1r* no,{ lsrsse o} paqoeDe sl 'solou aoueprn0 qlmn raqiaool'a}e1dua] elnltpuadx3 pue atuooul uV

'pred a:nypuadxa pue ldracet 1uel0aql ,{;rea1c our/v\oqs 'peno.rdde atxoq3s q3ea Jol }uno33v arn}lpuadx:l pue ouJocul uV 'L

-:ragal sn1l ;o ldracel raue sllluoulg ueql Jalel ou ]nq

'alqmrlcetd se uoos se uorleluauncop 0utmo1;o1 aLll yurqns o1 pernber a:e no1

'auue:6o.r6

a^oqe aql Japun peple/'^e OulpunJ sluelg luauqsrqrnJag 3 luaudtnb3 ;o aulaqcs aLll lo iJadsal ul

981'9gIrn

eueqnu8909n

I98LL3

lunotr|v

'oN '3td

8 '3 'S ruBS),lueg

lo ssaJppv ? sureN dnolg lo oueN 'ou ol

:s^ olloJ se dnolO aq1 1oluno33e )tueq aql ol paJralsueJl uaaq seq 9gz'93 Jo uins e }eq1 noA esr^pe ol qslM I

suolleslueblg fue1un;o1 pue AlunutuoS paseg-flleoo'l lo; sluslg rto auure.rOord :oU

laJebjey\ Jeoo

gggT tuen:qa3 pu7

6 uilqnoeJpuoctunJC

peou uedaserSa6allo3 s/v\olleH llV'osnoH loluas

eLUeqnu{naargcyl }ore0Jey1

zZ"

Page 127: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

se lea^ UeSnq:a i l l . ; i1 . . i ,-

, ) i ' t !, {1a ta5urs s_rno1

spooo aq1;o sre lddns ,no,{ pue senlasrno,{ ,""^?r':i:l:;iJ T]i,tff.H *:il,iffi ,Aeuocu JoJ an le^ u re lqo o ] uor le0r lqo . rno ,4 pue ls tapun noz{ leqg aIUALUAed Srq l paAto3AJ Aneq no , { 1eqI t. : t ] ] . ] l ] U o c o ] e | q l S s o d S e U o o S s e J o u a l p a q 3 e ] } e a q 1 1 o @ a S e a l d

le aur lcPluoc aseald 'o^oqe aq11o due 0ur-reda:d a3uetsrsse nr" ":,: i3?t"11rl

.6urpun; srq] ruorj pred salruasJo i pue spooo asaql io s lar lddns rue pue sanlasrnor{ uaomlaq }sala}ur Jo }3ruuo3 ou aq os leplnoqs alaql 'rallddns auo ueqi alouJ tiror] salonb xaas o] aler-rdordde aq aroJroreq] ,{eur 11 -,{euou_rroJ anle^ 6ururelqo lo Inlpultlr aq ]snLu noA '0urpun1 srq] ulorJ sacr^ras pue spoo6 6urseqc.rnd ueq,q

'euue:60.rd srq l rapun 6urpun; a ln ln l r {ue u io. r l dno.r6. rno,{ apnlcxa,{er .u srq l 0p o} arnrreJ'esodtnd auJes srq] JoJ pasn lou sem af,lnos .raq1o Aue Luotl Ourpunl 1eq1 .'pepre/v\e se/A ll qsrq^^ to; asodjnd aq] lo] pasn se^ 1uet0 aq1 1eq1 .

: 'ur,rno11oi eql 'urfurpac ra,nsearr pue uoslad:reqo aql {q pau.rs 1u"r"f"1, y .t

.lcarord sql ,o anre^ ,,,"i:'r?:;?:lJ',J;ftXl?i^li[1":,iT",i::i:ffi 35'i"Tfi"1i,?. ? z:ltl.Uqns o] paou os;e no,{ ,ale;dujal slq} q}lM

-s lq]q;rm no,{ }srsse oi paq3elle sr 'sa}ou acueprn0 qlm raqia601,a1e1dua1 a.rnppuadx3 pue atuosul uv

.p!edornupuadxa pue ldracal 1uer0 aq1 ,{pea1c our,rnoqs ,}uno33v a.rnlpuadx3 pr"

"|.uorrl ,y .L

9 ueq] raler ou lnq 'orqeorlcerd se uoos se uorleluaurnrop ou,,*oujr"fii;'Jtfrt:i"r":ffi3:#t::l

a^oqe aql rapun papre*e 6urpun; sluerg ]ueuLlsrqlnrag X luau,rdtnbl Jo aLueq3s "rr;:?::l3:,$

runoroe rueq aq] ol pa.ua,suer] uoaq seq 98/,93 Jo ulns " ,;:il:[?ff^T"T ;:,t;]

suo1les1ueOtg fue1unlol pue fl1unuuo3 paseg_{lleoo-l ro, querg 1o atuurel6oJd :aU

1a:e0;ey1;eag

9967 tuen.rqa1 q111

6 uilqnoeJpu03uinJo

peog ltedece.rga6a11o3 smolleH llv ,osnoH Jotuas

euJeqnuAnaa.r gc y1 1e.r e6.re y1

er: ieq0c Me/i

l : l?aiO{:OS;rr r , i ,u;

! l r C i a r g i - ; , ! l i . !

; , ; a i : C r L - a i e l f , r

: j - ' f a ! t e ' t l s . _ l r y ; l ! ? g

Stl jaH olpJS aoajr taH t fJoel

L,-r t t ; r t ( : rr !e iC

laa. iS s3t:cH a. j i ,aH aaJrr l ioFi

'oN '3fr'

I '3 'S Xueg dnolg lo arueN

sall lunuuo> Surpoddns

"2

Page 128: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

tat t : t ) ! - . . i i i . : t i i t : : : ;J{1.: : i l l t l i l { - l ! r ' - lar. ; i : i r ' : : r ) t i : ' . ' , } i ! r i j - l l i ' 'Oir l iJ:" i ' lJ ; ' l

L iol l j ; i i , : j - i 1J\{ i [ J, ! .J a)1:f , t r i ] jL l i l jc! ' \ i i ( l t r l i l rcFi i luuui;{ : r f i ( uaia tr i j i -1l t rei iuY rS ' i? i ' iDa 3lDi i ral : : l ' i l f ,3 irC

; i D u n u n j , a r i j r f i ; f i L : l l o i i i ; t - r 9 Z 0 9 t E I e E C t D l Z ! : a D q t g i ' L ' a i : 3 i r c l d a i ' r i l ' i . l r i q r ' D r p u c l u n r c ' e e + l l c J s ^ \ c i i D H l i Y ' e s n c i - i

j o r u a { ' c i ! c u ' t i

/ , - - . / / r r . r.44n7n+!4s0td orj WrJaaw 4,rnuz/n /t2j ywv 4'ffin Vlun aln '4'ftut0714 1fv J0 A+.rur/. y 3W Yvtrrynw>Sty

r olsulpro-o 3 Eiir sru.l p u n.tl

onp uI ecuJo lno^ o1 otuss

ol pepre/!\e Eurpun3 aql ol

'uesns Jeoc

' sffisuolluspu8Jo f,rBlunlon ry i{lrunruruoJ pessg [l1uoo1JoJ s]uurCJo aurruurSord :eU

9002 tIcreIAI ur6

z ullqncllee4s selloH

esnoH {oorqloHI"qod

sa]?e^ u?sns sI\l

wltlilfis

27,a'', 7773

pJ€,&\-toJ IIL A pue slusuraJlnbe: Eutgoder

3ur1e1er uiloJ uollureicep pelelduioc eql

'.,{1e;eculs sJno^

'esJnoc

eql pelou e^Pq I 'sn

pesolcue pug eseeld

z7

g0M xvn t t

, r , o * , I r doH I t r oddns

Page 129: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

r/. 'i 'a.at,,-r'.; -'.

, - . ' l i i - ] , t -' 1 2 ' / - " t /

r'' lt- - 1t , :?, ,r ] -r / . ' i

aueu dnotg

{stertde3 xcolg} auler.i

:elec

:pau0rg

'6urpun; slr.ll ruo4pred sa3trussispooo;o s.rarlddns Jno pue sa^laslno uaa^ laq lsajalut Jo l3tlluoo ou st aJaql .n

{auou.r Jo} onle^ utelqo o} uoqeOrlqo lno pue}slapun | .Z

']unoJ3e lueq rno ol paltpajs

uaaq spq e^oqe peltelap se tuau{ed ggZ'ga aql pue lueq aq} q}u\ pal3aqo a^eq I .L

:dnorO a^oqe oql jo lleqaq uo 6uy*o11o; aql ur:lruoo I

uollBJepoo

z ullqnolaa4s salloH

asnoH looJqloHleqod

salea^ uesns

ar'leqod-afiq

er' leqodOsaIrnbua

1 ' I ro 199 1 EE€+ :J

ool0 ord 1 tEt+ :j

arl l e utelt3 eulvstregssltoH prgrs )loojqtoH r.l3ea1

puelarl z urlgnciaarls settoH esnoH r,looJqloH

$Ws

982'9 eueqnusocn/98r !

lunor[v

'oN '311d

8 '31S

ruegrueg

lo sseJppv ? atueN dnorg;o eruep 'ou ol

r2

Page 130: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

ti:,jj; Ii: s!ocr. l r ! ! l r t l :o l3

, 0 , " , i : : a . ' . : : - r , : , , i , r . r a G S S a i ! e i ' P l i l ; . 4 E . a r , r l E J t C J ? A O l O C . C a O - l F t C u p l O l i i - e Si r ' 1 ) : . : a = ) l a . ) l r a . i s , r P j , i : r i ! j u j j ! i i f r c e : r i , c t i . r a j i . a r c ; i | i n t d d a i n 3 u ; 6 j r l s y o o c s e ! ! o u 1 r c

sir iLl0S rr . j - l )a )a, i ! ' ,e i jLrof eleu! i 'g3r i lE ar; ! uostadt ieLiJ) uozEq€rg ut^al i ;srol"ar lc

6 ul lqncBrpuos[unJC

peog lredece.rga8a11o3 s,,lrolleH IIV

asnoH Jorueseuieqnu

,&raar gr 61 tareS.ru y41

suortesr uc8rO .{retun 1on

l.9L00tz l0 : ' t3J-

,p,{tr unru Luo; poseg-i1 1eco1loJ slu€ri) jo eiurue.r3o:.1

roleurpro-oJse-lee^ uesns

-,\leracurs slnoA

'auuer8ord slql repun Fqpung ernln; ,{uu morl dnor8 rno,{ apnlcxa .{eu s-rq1 op ol arnlrBd

-a^oqe aqlqll,\\ ocuelsrsse ,{ue e.rrnbe: :o 'sar.ranb {ue a.,req no,{3r 6g4ggpZ- IOte eurfg,g elepv ]reluor eseold

'tsl,a tszel te.;o Surpuny Surqcleru u,lrro rno.( puu Surpung ggL,y)'o'l'lca[o:d eqlJo enle^ Ietol eql ot (slretap JVA WI,lr) sldrere: ro sacrolul pred-;o,{docoroqd y 'Z

:]luqns ol peau osle no,('e1eldua1 su{l qrl,t\srql qlt.{\ noK }stsse 01 peqceue sr 'se1ou ecueprnS qtr,n reqlaSol 'aleldrual a.rnlrpuedxg pue otuo3ul Iu€lq V

'pe.rrnber sB pegruec puepred a.rnlrpuedxa pue ldracel rue.6 aqt,(1-rea1c 3ur,.'roqs tunoccy a.rryrpuadxg prle auorul uV 'l

1sEny,{q pe4nbe-r eq 11pr,raoleq pe[e]ep uollGurroJq aq] eroJereql

'tuaw,(ed lsrg Jo qtuour

9 urqlr,\\ Ieqod ot lceq pogoder aq lsnru arnlrpuadxe 11u auuerSord aqtJo srllol er11 lopufl ',fteruqeg

prlu lues se,tr ouwe.r8o.rd anoqe eql repun dno,6 rno.( o1 luau,{ed eql splooer rno o1 Surproccy

'1e.re3.re;41 reag

suo.rlBs.ruEdro ArBlrmlo^ lP 4lunwuoJ pesBg-allscol roJ sluBrcJo euruBritoJd :ell

9002 ,{lnf q,/ I

BwBqnlI - s0c/t/s8ll

ar' leqod'affa

ar ' leqod@seutnbua

l t to 199 t r tqe+ : j

OOLOOTa T eg€+: -L

arif z qterlS eqlv 3|egsalloH prgis loorqtoH Ltceaf

pue lar l a u r lqnc

]aarls sailoH asnoH )joolqtoH

sal lunu.ruo: turUoddns

1z

Page 131: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

. . : i - ' r : : I : ; , : , , . ' i r l

r l : l l : : i , t i l ! . r . : 1 , : l i

: a C i ! : , , i r i i . : : ; i ! i

r J i . r . ! i ; : _ i i r ! ! ; l : : r : , : l

A i r : l i i i , i t j i l r : a l i : l i . ; i l

) - : . : . , t - i - " J ' , i :

r l r , i i , : - t i : r i i ; i t i r i ' i _ r _ , . r . ! i a a

-an7n4+50.1(I 1n TurJarw rfftuLl44 .to/yw rytn l.'tun an '1'rvw0/,14 W /, drfu "'U1

6nffa7*(vTr/

'r{lerecurs sJno1

'elu lcsluoc ol ele}Iseq tou op eseeld Uoder eqtr o1Eutlele-r serrenb due enuq no,( plnoqs

'sluerue^oJdlur

eql pel"llllceJ s?q lBql uoddns lBrcu€ug eql roJ urcEE esuo no.,{ ry?ql 'ern}r{urB

pu€ lueudlnbe Jo sruell pepeeu qcnru Jo eseqcJndnueurmeldeJ 'slueruenoJdun , 1e;eg zgqlleeH Surpnlcrn lueruuortnue rno w seperEdn luspodrur ,fien u1 pellnser s?r.{ lu"JA srr{J

'eJqrpuedxeJo luelr qcee JoJ secro^ur ddo3'seloN lceford

'ernlrpuedxe Ielol eql

Jo o Lg pareloc luerE eql ees IIIIv\ nod sV 'uorlnqr4uoc etueqnl{ pu€ Uoddns lu€JEJo u,/v\opleerq erg pu€ lcelord eql Jo lsoc Islol eql Surrv\or{s leeqs ,{reuung y

'froEelec

qcee repun ernlrpuedxe Jo surelr II€ Jo slrqep 8urprnord (seEed Z) peqs sl€O 'Z'tueuqsrqrrge)I

T, ]uetudrnbg]ueuldrnbg II - pe^recer Eulpurygoseuo8elec eerql eql Jo qoee rog 'peuSrs ,{1np ]unoccv eJnllpuodxg T eruoJul uV 'I

:slueuncop 3u1mo1og eql8uspduoc uoder 8ulpury s.eru?gnU esoloue I eueqcs eloq"erp repun peaiecer glP-fi 99993 eql ol 8urqce11e queruerrnbeJ eql qlra ecrrBpJocc" uI

'u"sns Jeec

suorfc$rurr{u(J) ̂.rslur{oA T qlunuruoJ pasBfl -^IIBJOT JoJ sluBJcJo auruBJitoJd

sruurlng - SOOA/S8II :JeU Surpung-lJode5 SUrpUng

9002lsn8ny p,ZZ

9002 9nv s z

.s'v

'e

s2

roteurpJooJ Eursre.rpungf,rearg c141 1ere8re141

*$:esg

rr roHs I r r o * j l uoddns

Page 132: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

6Cf 00tZ-I0 lR ourfg,O alapv auoqdalal asuald seluulsrssu roqpnJ fue atrnba; nof g1

pode.r srql SurlaldruoJ ur no. lsrsse ol salou pug asuald paqJu11y

'3u1pun;;o ,{.ro8a1ur qJBe JoJ pode"r ernlrpuadxf, puu arrroJul uu elalduroJ es"eJd

')*/xlr

uosrefureq3

?'aYg

'Surpuqr srql tuog pred secr^,ues ro / pue spoo8 eql3o sralJddns Jno puu seAIesJno uee^uaq lseJelurJo ]JtUuoo ou sl aJeqf

'r(euou JoJ enlul urulqo o1 uorleSrlqo Jno puplslepun el11

'esodrnd etues sn{} JoJ pesn }ou se,r\ e3lnos ;eq1o fue ruot3 8urpury leq;'popJe^\E sp/r\ 1r r{clq,,K;o3 esodlnd eqlloJ pesn sE^\ 1uur3 eql teql

(1cr1 eseeld) 3urmo11o; eql.Srgec peu8rs:epun eqt ,el[

uorluJ€Icao

,'paqtupu oJB arnllpuedxa;o lunoruu lulol oql o1 sldlaceg puu saego.rul

EL)7lw

5r

Fsa,7.' ' ' J3AHf

ll

.:l 4

Page 133: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

$L001T,-I0ls aur.{g,O alapV auoqdalo} asuald'aluulstssu raqunJ fuu a;tnbar no.{y1

'lroder srql SuualdruoJ rn no,,{ lsrsse ol so}ou pug asueld peqJuDV

'Su.rpun;;o ,tro8alzc qJua JoJ poda.r arnlrpuadxg puu aruoJul uu alaldruoJ asuold

""rpr7 )z" t/

' '

irrv,,J t/l

Iuod [u f,unrlft{fldxg ot{Y flI,\loJt{I

.,1:.:-r, ' j3-,,

i . t . . . j 1 . ' . . . - : , , : 1 . , r r .

*l ,''#C,:,,,,,,'&

Page 134: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

6fr00tz-I0 lB eur,{g,O alapV euoqdalal osueld 6aluulstsse raqunJ .{ue a;tnbar no,{ g1

'1;oda; srql 3u1la1druoJ ur no,( lstssu ol salou pug ssuald paqJB]lV

'Surpuny;o 'fuo8a1ue qf,Ea JoJ podar arnlrpuadxf, pus etuoJul uu aleldruoJ esueld9o/" ,/ 4 / , r

{ ' 1 . "

yCI4vnfv&)/0'

I .:. ti: -,. :ll

: l. l;ti

i . , . l i -, : :1 . : '

Jz.,f; ' /o,, f

Page 135: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

e |xltStzz

-esn JoJ paulelor eJe{r slrun Suqsrxe eqlJo etuos'eseqcrndgo aurt eql ]B elqelre^B slunoJsrp pu" sreJgo lercedsgo Eutltene .(q panrerer ser*onl" luellmxg 'Eursse:Eord;o sueeu eltpeJls tsoc slotu e s€^/r sleqqec Eullg pu€ qlun

Eunlaqs qlv$ luausJelder teqt pepllep se/n lI requn$ peunu"xe uellt\ '8url;aqs ornlas

'euop eq ol slrlelllal slql 'Illeqt qlI/\A pesm3slp

lsoo eqt pue sreu/y\o eqf qlyvr uo4sroqellos uI ueleuapun ?q ol e^eq plno { >lrolt\

qcns sesrruerd peseal e sr elso aql sV -ole $\Aopulr\aJo lelotueJ Sunlourut lcBIusJ rofewe aq ,{1e>y1 ,{re,r 1q8rur IroA! eql }eql punoJ sB r 1l roqurg ps}e8qs^w uel{rry\ 'slylopullyl

ol sreder 1no ,{rrec ol,{ueduoc e Ernpcol ,(lpctgrp peq e1ys4udag ,ropt41!

'sJe{ro1l\

qoeertrno rnoJo euo roJ peseqc;nd se/ llx rec eoJ{-spuq1 euoqdelsl :Iuell I"uoqlppv

].uuslul eql ulpesegcrnd relnduoc eleredes ? qlry\ erue3lI se pertnber reEuol ou s?rv\ reilr \el{ OJ oIII

'ecgo roleulpJooJ tlceer1no eqt loJ peseqcrnd ,5ervr repdruo3 -

ure{ I€uoqlppv

SSION J,JflfOUd

aIrIuqnu

LZ.

flso9^/s8ll IoUropunf, s00z v3uf,c

Page 136: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

rfueuung - saueuurns

900zt80tLzUodau bu rpun3

o/o00L %eyl g/o19 slsoC lplol Jol suollnqUtuog a6eluacra6

00'0 00:0 asuPlPE

t0 'Lzg 'L c0 .L tO ' t 00 '98 / '9 arnypuadx3

to'Lzg'L 00 . t t 0 ' f 00'9gz'9 aluosulsJsoJ Uaraqslgtnle4 g ryaud1nb3 p1o1

, - - l. ":,-

--3 luaurqs!qJnlau loJ suollnquluog e6eluacra6

aJuelEg

L8't06'Z tt 'zLt 8r .169 'Z arnypuadx3r8'e06'z ee'z t t 8V ' t69 'Z atUosul

tuautqs!qtnlaa

iii:i: luatuotnD:l Jol suotlnqUluoC aDe1uaxJad

af,uPIEg

88 . r09 9r'16l et'0 t0 arnlpuadx3

88 '109 9t 'L6 t et '0te atuorulpawdlnEj

luauo!nD:| ll JoI suollnqljluoO aoeluailad

a3uPleg

,t ' tzr ' , 9Z'Ltq 60't88't arnppuetlxSvt ' tzr ' , 9Z'Ltg 60't88'e aluotu

7uawd1i6311

IB}OI uo!lnq!Jluo3euEqnu

luerc veuSo lf,npoJd

urpun oJJU ou etuulns

9002 v9uco

T,r,- "47ttrtri;t -r,9909ru98t! 'JaU rapunJ

lpu

Page 137: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

ono

N)oo(tl

.Tl

a-o

vo:i

@Ctr

ooCtrID

(f

-l

-r'l

onT]czUz.onm-Uon-lUcm

c6)CU)-{t\)ooo,

FJ -T'I

o )c o oh J :o ( Qoa 7

fU'

3:1.(D@

o3(D

Fmx(D=-;

o

-,fi'r'r*fif

NJ \, N' (t 5 (t N)

mxEo

o

t|.n

+|-n

No

o

:

fn

-i

o

rnXo

a-

o

€ r ,o J: of -

o0)

I9o

(aoa

o

oA)

tf

=q)

oao

coa

a

fn

o

Noo

F

o

*t

A)

Irn

o

rnx(D

o

o

3

-o

oA)

o

oI7o{=.o

r

FoU'o

{

o

:3.

o

R '

T

o

o

aIft

F

G

.tt

o

(r)

bO)I--l

@

5

I{@

N)o9o(o

N)o(tl

\(o

htb,CNs,|oo

-ooIoo

o)

bo

I

-(^)oIoo

_-(0Ioa

T=.c)o

O)55b>(J|

@

fo

5t,@(o

5(,i..r

C'ICtrfgrCtr

l\)oI{(o

Cr)P@ I

N)--lG)bos

N)5(oioo

qt

o!\t

s

-5<tt9s,'N't\t

(rro

boqt

Noll.J@@

195!ooo

-5FN'

a.t5

-N

oF{(o

(oi6

'crr{:o5

.F

C^t(oioo

doq)

oov,

F(O

I(nN)

O)hts

('o*(,

@@s

C^t'@

oio(0

f l t /ox3c )o >

5oo3o

{f\)@io

C^t@s

(0

Fctr

l\t;e

C'IC.,l.lht(tr

oo -=*tE A 't r l

3 .6

.It(o

o

I\'

?V74'?,,.},t?27.2'--'

Page 138: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

o

oI\)oogr

.Tl

CL(D

non

@(rr

oo(rrID

IUIIliloln| -r'l

lclzU2onmllon-lUcm

Coca)-{

N)ooO)

;rl..- . (,

mxo

o

No

{gt

m

-1-'

3o

to7(D

6'

o

ooU'

-{

q)

Do

c(tl

o

|nxo

(D

llo1'oo

3.

lu,

o

o

o= 'o'n

o

oq)

anoq,

o

€oF

h

lh

o

1l

a.

N)

())(o10F}|

5oNoo

(to

Ln@

-s(oO)i'.l-{

l nl€l o ,IRl i il {I +

l rI ( Dt <

l 63o)

;G'

U

!:.o(D

(Jros,)(oo)

@

IsN

o!n(r)C,J

(^}5irJ

o

ot\,

s

!.t(l}os.t@

5@o,5l\t

q,oI(o

too5@

ogooo

@(0

sl\tC't(o

Lq,

6oon3oO D

5oo3o

sC.t

1.,(.,ct

oo -= A )T5c r $

6' at

N) 'T1

\ =C r J@ Q -

l.j :o ( . ooa > V

a

ac

g)=.oth

oFmx

!(D

='(D

TctI\t

o

N

Page 139: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released
Page 140: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

.. snlels_ a..F-eueqc- q]f/v\ ̂ueduloc polil.rj|lofnro;iis jeuoiffitGsjo 6t

luauaqllr^ sosrtxaJd eq1 asn oLl/\r osolll l le ']Uauoq

llt^ uotlestueO:o ue se dnol6 eq1

lcefol61o slrlaueg (c) :

' eJauJec 1e1r6r p':alunno: CIO':a1nd u oc do1de1'.lolcalo.rd et po uull nulsopnlcul lueudtnba aql ' luotutlstqJnloJ spJen o] Ourpunl pue IJo^ Ourure:1 pue Oursreg/ssouoJen e

*:I _Uod_dns ol_ Pe_paau sr leq] luaudrnba 1o aOue.r e Ourseqcrnd sple^ ol Uoddns Dulyaes sr dno:6 aql (q)

uolleonpa lreql 6urnurluoc 'saotruos qoeallno sdno.l6aql Outpuedxo saclruas ]o lolol luoJ:nc aq1 eno:dr-ur pue dolanep oI- 'uotleltoldxa

;enxes lerc:aululoc|! qlot ^ug ry )_sl le ro uoqnlrtso.td ut penlo-ny1 y9,yo_l l_ol pue, qll/\^ Xro^/\ ol- :dnor6 oql Jo sule oLlI (e)

neuruns iiJiojJ pue uolluiJieo d;o;g .z

fueuturng uo11ec;lddy -t

:fl lceds asee;d 'suosesl Jorllo Jol elq1611eul I .sau!lop!ng euuel6or6otll Jo t,8 Z', uotlsos ol ocuoJoloj qluvr {g;pqr6!lau! rol uoseaj eq1 fl11uap; esee;d ,se^

Jl

x oN elq;6;1eu1

fiulqlEll 'z

; : i 98/'93 : parlddy lueJg go luno-y .

;: ai

j

peog lredace:Opeou lledace:g : '

a6a11o3 s^ olleH llvasnoH Joruas : ssorppV luec;lddy

ai \--l

eueqnu1Y. i --"l\l :' u :

:''- - ___i __ -r::::-'.--

orueN luec;1ddy

o N i uollecglddy lenq---------..-- i---*

c \J f ! ed[1 1ue;gc I : 'oN 'rou luer9

909A/9Br L ! 'o1r; ' }eg'ddy

. ,

82

fu eururng luorussossy uollecl gddy

IeJauae

Page 141: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

V

pooc tuan poo9 aOero^V IEAMIuasaJo

]oNpoluasoJdaJ Aauou JoJ onlen

6urdno:6 1abte1 qlrnn aceldloo] suotle]lnsuoc auiossluauuJoS

Z

poog tue1 pooc aOerany leaMluasaJd

]oN

^]luntrltuocleool Jo uolled;cqped sen;onurlesodo.rd oql qctq/\ ol lualxf

r@

sluauuJoS

poog fua4 pooe a0e:any TEAM]uasajo

]oNlesodo.rd sLll u! 6u1uueld

pue lqFnoqlarol lo ocuoplll

u.Jro] uotleclldde pele;duroc llaMsluauuloS

I

poog tua1 poo9 eOe:eny leaM luosoJoloN

lesodordaql lo llJoru pue {1l1enb llero^O

dnol6 pe6eluenpe@slusruruoS

vpoog tua1 pooe ebe:any IEAM

luasoJoloN

eFeluenpeslpsallcel dnol6 aql Llolql ol luay;;

1ce[o.rd srq] aosro^o ol serypqedec fuess@sluautUoS

epoog fue1 pooe eDelany leoM

luasard]oN

lesodor6aql Jo 6ug.ro1ruoy11 pue luaurabeue4

pJocal IJeJI olqtpolc fua4sluorxulo3

0

poog tua71 pooe eOerany IEAMJUASOJd

loNlesodoJcl or{l oxeuapun

ol uolles!ue6lo aq1lo {1;cede3sdno.rO

sluaulujo3

vpoog fue1 poo9 eOerany TEAM

luosoJdtoN

a6elue^pEs!psol{ce} ;esodo.rd sqt qclqrvr ol lua}x;1

lcafo.rd slql Joj poou Jealo e sefr1usluauuJo3

t poog fta1 lg poog :z aEeleny !1 1eery1 :o luasald 1o1 i7 ;e1o1

v

poog tua1 pooe eOereny IEAMluosoJo

toN6urpun;1o lcedurl pue roJ pooN

elJoilJ3

epollJc aq1 lsule6e solel uorlecl;dde eq1/noq lo luorussassv -V

Page 142: FOI Request to POBAL re Ruhama, Part 3, Information Released

4.j-..1::";#,.

i

ii

'99 Jo lno 0e soJoss uo[ecrldde oqf i

.\,

slusuuroS uoqepuoluruocou

****--*:

982'9 3 i:-- *-(sudielapisuoS-itulio5$

pUt isftpng Siqetie"VEulpud]I-irapuilu-urocdy'iunoruv '

ssocojd luaussassv eql uo4 uollepuotuutocou 'g

auoN ii ,

p6^or d clv si 6 u r p u n lli?n or C eqilil possar ppV-sq oi Stn s6r -_---'E-'

0t lElol

nberno9uSsluauuroc

sltll roj 009'8ornl Jo ecuepq aql parncas aABq