8/13/2019 Fluorescent and colorimetric sensors for detection of lead, cadmium, and mercury ions
1/36
ISSN 0306-0012
0306-0012(2012)41:8;1-P
www.rsc.org/chemsocrev Volume 41 | Number 8 | 21 April 2012 | Pages 301334
Chemical Society Reviews
CRITICAL REVIEW
Ha Na Kim, Wen Xiu Ren, Jong Seung Kim and Juyoung YoonFluorescent and colorimetric sensors for detection of lead, cadmium,and mercury ions
View Online / Journal Homepage / Table of Contents for this issue
http://pubs.rsc.org/en/journals/journal/CS?issueid=CS041008http://pubs.rsc.org/en/journals/journal/CShttp://dx.doi.org/10.1039/c1cs15245a8/13/2019 Fluorescent and colorimetric sensors for detection of lead, cadmium, and mercury ions
2/36
3210 Chem. Soc. Rev.,2012, 41, 32103244 This journal is c The Royal Society of Chemistry 2012
Cite this:Chem. Soc. Rev., 2012, 41, 32103244
Fluorescent and colorimetric sensors for detection of lead, cadmium, and
mercury ions
Ha Na Kim,wa Wen Xiu Ren,wb Jong Seung Kim*b and Juyoung Yoon*a
Received 8th September 2011
DOI: 10.1039/c1cs15245a
Exposure to even very low levels of lead, cadmium, and mercury ions is known to cause
neurological, reproductive, cardiovascular, and developmental disorders, which are more serious
problems for children particularly. Accordingly, great efforts have been devoted to the
development of fluorescent and colorimetric sensors, which can selectively detect lead, cadmium,
and mercury ions. In this critical review, the fluorescent and colorimetric sensors are classified
according to their receptors into several categories, including small molecule based sensors,calixarene based chemosensors, BODIPY based chemosensors, polymer based chemosensors,
DNA functionalized sensing systems, protein based sensing systems and nanoparticle based
sensing systems (197 references).
Introduction
Among various heavy metal ions, lead, cadmium, and mercury
ions are banned in electrical and electronic equipment by
the European Unions Restriction on Hazardous Substances
(RoHS) directive due to their hazardous nature.1 These three
heavy metal ions are not biodegradable, and hence can
accumulate in the environment, which results in contaminated
food and water.2 Therefore, World Health Organization
(WHO) and Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) have
strictly defined the concentration limits of these metal ions that
are allowed in the drinking water.3
Lead is the most abundant and toxic substance of the three, it
is often encountered in the environment due to its use in batteries,
gasoline, and pigments, etc.4 Lead pollution is a persisting
problem and a long-lasting danger to human health and the
environment, as the 300 million tons of lead mined to date are
still circulating mostly in soil and groundwater.5
Even very low
levels of lead exposure can cause neurological, reproductive,
cardiovascular, and developmental disorders, which introduce
particularly serious problems in children including slowed motor
responses, decreased IQs, and hypertension.6
Cadmium is also an extremely toxic and carcinogenic metal.7
A major exposure source is smoking and through food, but
inhalation of cadmium-containing dust is the most dangerous
route. Cadmium can be found in electroplated steel, pigments in
plastics, electric batteries and so on.8 A high exposure level of
a Department of Chemistry and Nano Science and Department ofBioinspired Science (WCU), Ewha Womans University,Seoul 120-750, Korea. E-mail: [email protected];Fax: +82-2-3277-2384; Tel: +82-2-3277-2400
b Department of Chemistry, Korea University, Seoul 130-701, Korea.E-mail: [email protected]; Fax: +82-2-3290-3121;Tel: +82-2-3290-3143
Ha Na Kim
Ha Na Kim was born in Seoul,
Korea, in 1980. She received
BS degree from Department
of Chemistry of Ewha Womans
University and obtained MS
degree in medical science from
Seoul National University in
2006. She is on a doctoral
course in Prof. Juyoung Yoons
laboratory in Ewha Womans
University.
Wen Xiu Ren
Wen Xiu Ren was born in
Changchun, China, in 1981.
In 2009, he obtained his PhD
from Kyungpook National
University under the supervi-
sion of Prof. Sang Chul Shim
and Prof. Chan Sik Cho. He
now works as a postdoctoral
fellow in Prof. Jong Seung
Kims laboratory at Korea
University.
w Contributed equally to this work.
Chem Soc Rev Dynamic Article Links
www.rsc.org/csr CRITICAL REVIEW
View Online
http://dx.doi.org/10.1039/c1cs15245ahttp://dx.doi.org/10.1039/c1cs15245ahttp://dx.doi.org/10.1039/c1cs15245ahttp://dx.doi.org/10.1039/c1cs15245a8/13/2019 Fluorescent and colorimetric sensors for detection of lead, cadmium, and mercury ions
3/36
This journal is c The Royal Society of Chemistry 2012 Chem. Soc. Rev.,2012, 41, 32103244 3211
cadmium is associated with increased risks of cardiovascular
diseases, cancer mortality, and damage to liver and kidneys.9
Mercury is well known as one of the most toxic metals and is
widespread in air, water, and soil, generated by many sources
such as gold production, coal plants, thermometers, baro-
meters, caustic soda, and mercury lamps.10 As it can cause
strong damage to the central nervous system, accumulation of
mercury in the human body can lead to various cognitive and
motor disorders, and Minamata disease.11,12 A major absorp-
tion source is related to daily diet such as fish,13 and thus there
are considerable efforts contributed to the development of the
selective and sensitive detection methods.
Currently, the most common methods to detect heavy metal
ions include atomic absorption spectrometry,14 and induc-
tively coupled plasma mass spectrometry,15 however these
instrumentally intensive methods only measure the total metal
ion content, and often require extensive sample preparation.
Thus, a simple and an inexpensive method that not only
detects but also quantifies heavy metal ions is desirable for
real-time monitoring of environmental, biological, and indus-
trial samples.
Among various detection techniques, optical detections (via
fluorescence changes or colorimetric changes) are the most
convenient methods due to the simplicity and low detection
limit.1619 The most important advantage of a fluorescent
probe would be the intracellular detection. During the last
couple of decades, considerable efforts have been devoted to
the development of fluorescent and colorimetric sensors,
which can selectively detect metal ions.
To date there has been one review for lead analysis pub-
lished in 1998,20
this review is the first paper which system-
atically covers optical probes for lead, cadmium, and mercury
ions. Since Nolans and Lippard have reviewed the optical detec-
tion of mercury ions in 2008,21 we particularly focus on the recent
development of mercury detection between 2009 and 2011.
In this critical review, the fluorescent and colorimetric
sensors are classified according to their receptors into several
categories, including small molecule based sensors, calixarene
based chemosensors, polymer based chemosensors, DNA
functionalized sensing systems and nanoparticle based sensing
systems. Overall we would like to provide a general overview
of the design and application of Pb2+, Cd2+, and Hg2+
selective chemosensors.
Fluorescent and colorimetric sensors for detection of
lead ions
Chemosensors bearing heteroatom containing ligands
Small molecule based chemosensors. Czarnik and coworkers
reported a pioneering work regarding fluorescent chemo-
sensors for Pb2+ in 1996.22 Both 2- and 9-anthracene deriva-
tives bearing the N-methylthiohydroxamate ligand (1 and 2)
were prepared as shown in Fig. 1, which exhibited strongly
quenched fluorescence due to the photo-induced electron trans-
fer (PET). Complexation of 2-derivative1with Pb2+ resulted in
rapid metal ion-catalyzed hydrolysis. Whereas complexation
of 9-derivative 2 with Pb2+ induced a 13-fold fluorescence
enhancement at pH 9, which can be attributed to the steric
protection of the thiocarbonyl group by two peri hydrogens
(Fig. 1). Even though there were few competitive metal ions such
as Ag+, Co2+ and Hg2+, this is still one of the first examples of
fluorescent chemosensors for Pb2+.
Li et al. reported dibromo-p-methyl-methylsulfonazo
(DBM-MSA, 3) as a sensitive and selective chromogenic
Fig. 1 Structures of 2- and 9-anthracene derivatives (1and 2) and the
proposed binding mode of2 with Pb2+.
Jong Seung Kim
Jong Seung Kim was born in
Daejon, Korea, in 1963. He
received PhD from Department
of Chemistry and Biochemistry
at Texas Tech University. After
one-year postdoctoral fellow-ship at University of Houston,
he joined the faculty at Konyang
University in 1994 and trans-
ferred to Dankook University
in 2003. In 2007, he then moved
to Department of Chemistry at
Korea University in Seoul as a
Professor. To date, his research
records 270 scientific publica-
tions and 25 domestic and inter-
national patents.
Juyoung Yoon
Juyoung Yoon was born in
Pusan, Korea, in 1964. He
received his PhD (1994) from
The Ohio State University.
After completing postdoctoral
research at UCLA and atScripps Research Institute, he
joined the faculty at Silla
University in 1998. In 2002,
he moved to Ewha Womans
University, where he is currently
a Professor of Department of
Chemistry and Nano Science
and Department of Bioinspired
Science. His research interests
include investigations of fluores-
cent chemosensors, molecular
recognition and organo EL
materials.
View Online
http://dx.doi.org/10.1039/c1cs15245a8/13/2019 Fluorescent and colorimetric sensors for detection of lead, cadmium, and mercury ions
4/36
3212 Chem. Soc. Rev.,2012, 41, 32103244 This journal is c The Royal Society of Chemistry 2012
reagent for Pb2+ (Fig. 2).23 In 0.24 M phosphoric acid medium,
Pb2+ formed a 2 : 1 blue complex with 3, having a sensitive
absorption peak at 642 nm. Under optimal conditions, Beers
law was obeyed over the range 00.6 mg mL1 of Pb2+. The
lower limit of detection was found to be 2.21 ng mL1.
A similar approach was reported by Meng and coworkers.
A sensitive and selective chromogenic reagent dibromo-
p-methyl-carboxysulfonazo 4 (Fig. 2) was studied for the
spectrophotometric determination of Pb2+.24 In 0.25 M phos-
phoric acid medium, Pb2+
formed a 2 : 1 blue complex with4,having a sensitive absorption peak at 648 nm. Under optimal
conditions, Beers law was obeyed over the range from 0 to
0.8 mg mL1 of Pb2+ with a detection limit of 2.14 ng mL1. This
method was applied to determine the Pb2+ level in vegetables.
Compound5(Fig. 2) showed selective fluorescence enhance-
ment (lmax= 492 nm) with K+
in a mixed solution of CHCl3and CH3CN (9 : 1).
25 However, it was reported that the mixed
CH3CN/water solutions (510% H2O) of5 exhibited an even
larger fluorescence enhancement in the presence of Pb2+.
The emission intensity was increased by a factor of more than
20 and was accompanied by a shift in the emission maximum
from 486 to 498 nm. The Pb2+ complex with 5 formed a
unique structure involving a Pb2(CF3COO)4 unit sandwichedbetween two crown moieties of 5, which was confirmed by
X-ray crystallography.
Chen and Huang reported a new chemosensor 6 (Fig. 3),
which can signal Pb2+ selectively and improve the fluorescence
intensity in CH3CN.26 In fluorescence titration studies (lmaxfor
emission = 491 nm), 6 displayed 40-, 12-, and 18-fold fluores-
cence enhancements for Pb2+ (10 equiv.), Ba2+ (100 equiv.),
and Cu2+ (100 equiv.), respectively, due to the photo-induced
charge transfer (PCT) and metal binding-induced conforma-
tional restriction. As shown in Fig. 3, a 2 : 2 complex of Pb2+
and 6 was proposed since 6 had many advantages including
remarkable selectivity, much improved emission and easy detec-
tion. However, when the aqueous solution of Pb(ClO4)2 was
added to 6 in CH3CN, neither the binding strength nor the
fluorescence yield was affected.
In another study, Hayashitaet al.reported a supramolecular
7/g-cyclodextrin (g-CyD) complex sensor that exhibited the
monomer/dimer emission ratio response with high selectivity
for Pb2+
in 98% water/2% methanol (v/v) at pH 4.3 (Fig. 4).27
No obvious fluorescence was observed in the absence ofg-CyD.
In contrast, significant fluorescence emission appeared in the
presence of 12.0 mM g-CyD, indicating that 7 is dissolved inwater by forming an inclusion complex withg-CyD, which also
enhanced the fluorescence quantum yield. Upon the addition of
Pb2+, the broad emission observed in the longer wavelength
region (471 nm) intensified whereas the pyrene monomer emission
at 370410 nm decreased. The binding constant was calculated to
be 1.17 0.75 109 M2 with the stoichiometry of 2 : 1.
Kavallieratos et al. observed the efficient and selective ion-
exchange extraction of Pb2+
from water into 1,2-dichloroethane
(DCE) with concurrent fluorescence quenching using as an ion-
exchanger, the sulfonamide fluorophore8(Fig. 5).28 This simple
system did not require a secondary co-ligand in order to extract
Pb2+ and showed remarkable extraction selectivity against other
metals withDPb> 130DCuandDPb> 1400DZn. Fluorescencequenching was observed at 516 nm after the addition of
Pb(NO3)2 into a solution of8 and NH(i-Pr)2 in DCE. Specifi-
cally, the fluorescence intensity was reduced by as much as 29%
upon mixing 8 (10 mM) and NH(i-Pr)2 (22 mM) with 5.5 mM
Pb(NO3)2.
Two TTF-pyridyl derivatives9 and 10 (Fig. 5), in which the
TTF moiety and pyridyl group are linked by a double bond,
Fig. 2 Structures of compounds35.
Fig. 3 Structure of6 and its proposed 2 : 2 binding mode with Pb2+.
Fig. 4 Structures of 7 and g-CyD and the proposed binding mode
between 7/g-CyD with Pb2+.
Fig. 5 Structures of compounds811.
View Online
http://dx.doi.org/10.1039/c1cs15245a8/13/2019 Fluorescent and colorimetric sensors for detection of lead, cadmium, and mercury ions
5/36
This journal is c The Royal Society of Chemistry 2012 Chem. Soc. Rev.,2012, 41, 32103244 3213
were studied as Pb2+ selective chemosensors in CH3CN.29 The
interaction between the pyridyl group and Pb2+ improves the
electron-accepting ability of the pyridyl group, which thus
induces the color change of the solution from yellow to deep
purple, the downfield shift of the proton peaks in 1H NMR,
and the increase of the oxidation potentials E1ox and E2ox to
more positive values. These dramatic changes were specific for
Pb2+. The stoichiometry for the9complex was 2 : 1 (9/Pb2+),
while that for the 10 complex was 1 : 1 (10/Pb2+) with the
binding constants (log Ks) of 5.42 and 5.57 for 9 and 10,
respectively.
a,b,g,d-Tetrakis(3,5-dibromo-2-hydroxylphenyl)porphyrin
(11) displayed the selective fluorescence quenching effect on
Pb2+ in the aqueous solution (pH 9.0) based on the chelation
of porphyrin by b-cyclodextrin (b-CD) as reported by Yang
et al. (Fig. 5).30 This caused a large increase of the porphyrin
fluorescence intensity (655 nm) and thus was sensitive to Pb2+
that displayed fluorescence quenching of11. The detection limit
of this system was in the concentration range of 2.8 107 to
7.4 105
M of Pb2+
. The organizing ability of the b-CD medium
and the protection of the ligand from the micro-environment
conferred increased sensitivity, selectivity and detection limit
compared with those obtained in the absence ofb-CD.
The Yoon group reported rhodamine B derivative 12 as a
fluorescent and colorimetric chemosensor for Pb2+ (Fig. 6).31
Among the various metal ions, compound 12 showed signifi-
cant fluorescent enhancement only with Pb2+ in CH3CN,
despite relatively small fluorescent enhancement with Cu2+
and Zn2+. From the fluorescent titrations, the association
constant for Pb2+
was calculated to be 1.95 105
M1. The
spiro-carbon in compound 12 appeared at d 64.7 ppm in
CD3CN : CDCl3 (9 : 1, v/v) and this peak disappeared upon
the addition of Pb2+ or Zn2+ which suggested a reversible
ring-opening mechanism as shown in Fig. 6.
Additionally, the Teramae group reported that the 13/Triton
X-100 complex (Fig. 7) formed below the critical micelle con-
centration (cmc) in water exhibited an amplified fluorescence
response for Pb2+.32 Dynamic light scattering and dark-field
microscope analyses revealed that the 13/Triton X-100 complex
formed pseudo-micelle aggregates, which was triggered by selec-
tive Pb2+
binding with13and resulted in improved fluorescence
intensity with a distinct blue shift of the fluorescence emission
at pH 5.70. The fluorescence color changed from green (lmax=
531 nm) to blue (lmax= 481 nm), which was easily confirmed
by the naked eye. The standard conditions used for fluores-
cence experiments employed 1.25 mM of13 in 0.4% 1,4-dioxane/
99.6% water (v/v) containing 0.08 mM Triton X-100 and
10.0 mM acetate buffer (pH 5.70).
The fluorescent sensor (14) containing the bis(2-pyridyl-
methyl)amine group as a binding moiety for Pb2+ was developed
by Hong and coworkers (Fig. 7).33
Compound 14 also showed
selective fluorescence intensity enhancement (lmaxfor emission =
562 nm) with Pb2+ over other metal ions in pH 7.0 HEPES
buffer solution. This was ascribed to the complex formation
between Pb2+ and14 that blocked the photo-induced electron
transfer process. A linear response as a function of Pb2+
concentration was obtained ranging between 1.9 107
and 6.0 106 M. The lower detection limit was found to
be 1.9 108 M (3.9 mg L1) which is below the maximal
allowed concentration of lead ions (10 mg L1) in drinking
water. Therefore, this indicated the great potential of14 to be
employed as the sensor material for Pb2+
detection.
A new type of synthetic fluorescent sensor 15 has been
studied for probing Pb2+ in living biological samples by the
Chang group (Fig. 7).34 Under simulated physiological con-
ditions (20 mM HEPES, buffer pH 7), a desirable selective
turn-on response for Pb2+ over competing metal ions was
observed. Kd for Pb2+ coordination to 15 was reported as
23 4mM. The addition of 15 ppb Pb2+, the maximum EPA
limit for the allowable level of lead in drinking water, to a 5 mM
solution of15 induced a 15 2% increase in the fluorescence
intensity. This fluorescent sensor 15 was hence successfully
applied to track the changes in Pb2+ levels within living cells.
Basuet al.have designed, synthesized, and characterized the
new turn-on ratiometric fluorescent lead sensor 16 (Fig. 8).35
Compound16 exhibited an absorption band at 415 nm and an
emission band at 465 nm. Upon incubation with lead acetate
solution, the absorption band shifted to 389 nm and the
emission band also shifted to 423 nm with a 5-fold increase
in the fluorescence intensity. Compound 16 was able to detect
Pb2+ in aqueous solution over a wide pH range (410) and
selectively in a mixture of several other metals at a concen-
tration as low as 10 ppb. This sensor is advantageous because
of its sensitivity for Pb2+ at concentrations below the limit
set by the US Environmental Protection Authority (EPA).
Additionally, the dissociation constant (Kd) of16 was calcu-
lated as 23 mM.
Guilard and coworkers reported a new colorimetric mole-
cular sensor based on a 1,8-diaminoanthraquinone signaling
subunit 17 (Fig. 8) as an efficient lead ion sensor in water atFig. 6 Structure of Pb2+ probe 12.
Fig. 7 Structures of1315 and Triton X-100.
View Online
http://dx.doi.org/10.1039/c1cs15245a8/13/2019 Fluorescent and colorimetric sensors for detection of lead, cadmium, and mercury ions
6/36
3214 Chem. Soc. Rev.,2012, 41, 32103244 This journal is c The Royal Society of Chemistry 2012
neutral pH for naked-eye detection.36 The addition of Pb2+
(1 equivalent) induced a dramatic change in color (from violet
to pink) that was blue-shifted by 47 nm and hence suggested a
strong binding of Pb2+ by the triamide 17. In addition, the
naked eye detection limit of Pb2+ was 23 ppm (1015 mM) in
solution, which can be improved to 21 ppb (0.1 mM) by using a
conventional spectrometer.
A fluoroionophore sensor,N-[4(1-pyrene)-butyroyl]-l-trypto-phan (18), was reported as a Pb2+ selective chemosensor by Wu
and colleagues (Fig. 8).37 In the aqueous solution, compound18
exhibited a very high sensitivity (0.15 mM) and the 18Pb2+
complex showed a selective excimer peak at 465 nm. Both
FT-infrared and Raman spectroscopy in addition to DFT
calculations were employed to predict a characteristic inter-
action of lead ions with two carboxylate groups and two
indole rings as well as the hydrogen bonding between two
amide groups with a stiochiometry of 2 : 1 (Pb2+
: 18).
Several years ago, a redox, chromogenic and fluorescent
chemosensor molecule based on a deazapurine ring 19 was
reported by Ta rraga and Molina et al. (Fig. 9).38 Upon the
addition of aqueous Pb2+
, compound19 in CH3CN showed aredox shift (DE1/2= 0.15 V of the Fe(II)/Fe(III) redox couple),
the colorless to orange color change and an emission change of
620-fold with a detection limit of 1.32 108 M. Compound
19 exhibited a very weak fluorescence in CH3CN at 364 and
377 nm and a large chelation-enhanced fluorescence (CHEF)
effect only with aqueous Pb2+
even though there was a relatively
small CHEF effect with Zn2+. From the fluorescence titrations,
the association constants (Ka) for Pb2+ and Zn2+ were calcu-
lated to be 6.1 105 and 2.7 104 M1, respectively.
The same group reported a series of ferrocenyl-containing
imidazopyridine and imidazophenazine receptors 2022 as
Pb2+ selective chemosensors (Fig. 9).39 Imidazophenazine-
ferrocene dyad 20 has also demonstrated its ability for Pb2+
sensing through redox (DE1/2 = 120 mV), absorption (Dl =
23 nm, pale orange to red color), and emission (CHEF = 133)
channels. The resulting Jobs plot suggested a 2 : 1 binding
model between 20 and Pb2+, with the association constant
being 3 108 M2 in CH3CN. The recognition properties of
the two-armed imidazopyridine-ferrocene triad 21 were very
similar to those exhibited by the parent monosubstituted
receptor 19, and the most salient features were a strong pertur-
bation of the redox wave (DE1/2 = 180 mV), the absorption
wavelength (Dl= 23 nm, colorless to yellow color), a dramatic
increase in the fluorescent quantum yield (Fcomplex/Fligand =
890) in the presence of Pb2+, while the optical responses toward
Zn2+
were silent. Binding assays using the continuous variation
method (Jobs plot) suggest a 1 : 1 binding model with a Ka=
1.4 105 M1. The two-armed imidazophenazine-ferrocene
triad 22 sensed Pb2+ through perturbation of the oxidation
potential of the Fe(II)/Fe(III) redox couple (DE1/2= 110 mV),
the important blue shift (Dl= 160 nm) of the high energy band
in the absorption spectrum, and a remarkable increase of the
emission band (CHEF = 220), whereas smaller changes were
observed in the presence of Zn2+. From the titration data, a
1 : 1 binding mode was deduced and the association constant
Ka was found to be 3.5 103
M1
for Pb2+
.
The synthesis and electrochemical, optical, and ion-sensing
properties of ferrocene-imidazophenazine dyads were also pre-
sented by Ta rraga and Molina et al.40 Compound 23 (Fig. 9)
behaved as a highly selective redox/chromogenic/fluorescent
chemosensor molecule for Pb2+ in CH3CN/H2O (9 : 1). The
emission spectrum illustrated a CHEF (47-fold) in the presence
of Pb2+, a new low-energy band appeared at 502 nm in its
UV/vis spectrum (yellow to orange color) and the oxidation
redox peak was anodically shifted (DE1/2 = 230 mV). From
the fluorescence binding isotherm, the association constant
was calculated to be 3.57 106
M1.
Calixarene based chemosensors
Quite a few examples of Pb2+ selective fluorescent chemo-
sensors utilized a unique calixarene template. Lerayet al.reported
a new fluorescent molecular sensor 24 based on a calix[4]arene
bearing four carboxydansyl groups as fluorophores (Fig. 10).41
The complexation of Pb2+ to 24 in the CH3CN/H2O system
induced a noticeable blue shift in the fluorescence spectrum and
an increase in the fluorescence intensity with an unprecedented
detection limit of 4 mg L1.
Kim and coworkers developed a series of calix[4]arene-based
fluorescent chemosensors for Pb2+ detection in the past few
years. In 2004, Kim and Lee et al. reported a new fluorescent
chemosensor with two different types of cation binding sites on
the lower rims of a 1,3-alternate calix[4]arene (25) (Fig. 11).42
Two pyrene moieties linked to a cation recognition unit that is
composed of two amide groups to form a strong excimer in
Fig. 8 Structures of compounds1618.
Fig. 9 Structures of compounds1923.
View Online
http://dx.doi.org/10.1039/c1cs15245a8/13/2019 Fluorescent and colorimetric sensors for detection of lead, cadmium, and mercury ions
7/36
This journal is c The Royal Society of Chemistry 2012 Chem. Soc. Rev.,2012, 41, 32103244 3215
solution. The excimer fluorescence can be quenched by the
addition of Pb2+ ions, and revived by further addition of K+
ions. Thus, metal ion exchange produced anOnOffOnswitch-
able fluorescent chemosensor. Computational results revealed
that the highest occupied molecular orbital (HOMO) and the
lowest unoccupied molecular orbital (LUMO) of the two
pyrene moieties interact under UV irradiation of 25 and its
K+ complex, while such HOMOLUMO interactions were
absent in the Pb2+ complex.
The Kim group also synthesized N-(1-pyrenylmethyl)
amide-appended cone calix[4]crown-5 (26) and its structuralanalogue crown-6 (27) (Fig. 12).43
Judging from the fluores-
cence changes upon the addition of cations, 27 having a
crown-6 ring displayed the higher Pb2+ ion selectivity over
other cations. Coordinating Pb2+ with two amide oxygen atoms
with the aid of a crown ring, a reverse PET occurred in such a
way that electrons transferred from the pyrene groups to the
electron deficient amide oxygen atoms resulting in a quenched
fluorescence. When diazo-phenyl units were modified to
compound27, new sensor 28 was formed which showed weak
fluorescence because of the energy transfer (ET) from the
pyrene groups to the electron deficient azo parts (Fig. 12).44
Upon the addition of Pb2+
, compound 28 revealed the
fluorescent and colorimetric dual changes, which arose from
a hypsochromic shift of the azo units in the UV spectrum as
well as the fluorescence enhancement of the pyrenyl parts
in the fluorescence spectrum via a suppressed fluorescence
resonance energy transfer (FRET).
Kim et al. also tried to replace the crown ring of 25 by a
triazacrown ring to give a new fluorescent chemosensor 29
(Fig. 13).45 When Pb2+ or Co2+ was bound to 29, both
monomer and excimer emissions quenched due to the combi-
nation of heavy metal effect, reverse-PET, and conformational
changes. The association constants (Ka) of 29 for Pb2+ and
Co2+ were 4.65 107 and 4.95 106 M1 in CH3CN,respectively. On the other hand, 29 illustrated the ability to
bind with anions, particularly F anions. Addition of F
anions to 29 formed a selective complex through H-bonding
and produced quenched monomer emission with little excimer
emission change due to the PET effect.
1,3-Alternate calix[4]arene 30 bearing bispyrenylamide on
the two lower rims and two carboxylic acids on the other two
lower rims was also synthesized by the Kim group (Fig. 14).46
When the Pb2+ ion was bound to two amide oxygen atoms
linked to pyrenylamide of30, it exhibited a marked quenched
excimer emission due to its geometrical change during the
complexation. This excimer emission band revived with
further addition of Ca2+ ions, indicating an interesting on/offswitch process.
As shown in Fig. 14, compound31 responded to K+, Pb2+,
or Cu2+ and revealed band shifting in both fluorescence and
absorption spectra with different binding modes.47 With K+,
fluorescence emissions of the ligand were barely affected, while
addition of Pb2+ or Cu2+ produced a remarkable change
in both excimer and monomer emissions. The observed data
indicated that the metal cation was encapsulated by the
crown-5 ring for K+ and by the two facing amide groups in
the latter case, which was verified by a metal ion exchange
experiment. The wavelength shifts in both fluorescence and
absorption spectra upon addition of Cu2+ showed that, in
Fig. 10 Structure of the fluorescent chemosensor 24.
Fig. 11 Structure of fluorescent chemosensor 25 and its proposedbinding models with Pb2+ and K+ ions.
Fig. 12 Structures of the fluorescent chemosensors26, 27 and 28.
Fig. 13 Structure of fluorescent chemosensor 29 and its proposed
binding models with Pb2+ and F ions.
Fig. 14 Structures of fluorescent chemosensors30 and 31.
View Online
http://dx.doi.org/10.1039/c1cs15245a8/13/2019 Fluorescent and colorimetric sensors for detection of lead, cadmium, and mercury ions
8/36
3216 Chem. Soc. Rev.,2012, 41, 32103244 This journal is c The Royal Society of Chemistry 2012
contrast to Pb2+, Cu2+ interacted with the nitrogen atoms of
the amide groups through the PCT mechanism.
In 2006, Kim and Vicens et al. designed an unsymmetrical
1,3-alternate calix[4]biscrown-based chemosensor 32 having
a 1,5-naphthalene unit (Fig. 15).48 The weak fluorescence
intensity of the naphthalene unit suggested that benzene rings
of the calix[4]arene as well as the oxygen atoms of the crown-5
ring take part in PET. Complexation of Pb2+ caused fluores-
cence quenching due to an inverse PET process. On the other
hand, binding of two K+ ions to both crown-5 and 1,5-
naphthalene-crown-6 loops of 32 induced the fluorescenceenhancement of the naphthalene unit by CHEF (chelation-
enhanced fluorescence).
Kim, No and Ham et al. reported the syntheses of C-1,2-
alternate homodioxacalix[4]arene pyreneamides 33 and 34
(Fig. 15). With metal ion complexation, their emission bands
and thermodynamic stabilities of the complexes were changed.49
Upon Pb2+
ion complexation, both 33 and 34 showed a
quenched fluorescence in both monomer and excimer bands.
Upon the addition of Ca2+ ions,33 gave no response while34
provided enhanced excimer and declined monomer emission
with ratiometric response. The excimer spectral changes were
rationalized by the frontier molecular orbital in that the
effective PyPy* interaction induced an emission intensityincrease upon Ca2+ ion complexation, while in contrast there
was no such interaction observed for Pb2+ binding.
1,3-Alternate calix[4]arene-based fluorescent chemosensor
35 containing two-photon absorbing chromophores was repor-
ted by Kim and Cho et al. (Fig. 16).50 The sensing behaviors of
35 toward metal ions were investigated via absorption band
shifts as well as one- and two-photon fluorescence changes.
Free ligands absorb light at 461 nm and weakly emit their
fluorescence at 600 nm when excited by UV-vis radiation
at 461 nm, without any two-photon excited fluorescence at
780 nm. Addition of Al3+ or Pb2+ ions to the ligand solution
caused the blue-shifted absorption and enhanced fluorescence
due to a declined resonance energy transfer (RET) upon
excitation by one- and two-photon processes. Addition of the
Pb2+ ion to a solution of35K+ resulted in a higher fluores-
cence intensity than the original35Pb2+ complex regardless of
the excitation pathway, due to the allosteric effect induced by
the complexation of K+ with a crown loop.
Huang and Chen et al. reported a new p-tert-butylcalix[4]-
arene-based chemosensor 36 with threeN,N-diethylacetamide
groups as the recognition site and one methyl 3-ethoxy-
naphthalene-2-carboxylate as the fluorescent group, which
exhibited a highly selective fluorescent response to Pb
2+
ions(Fig. 17).51 The association constant was 6.5 104 M1 in the
CH3CN/H2O system.
The Chung group reported a novel chromogenic calix[4]arene
sensor 37 bearing bistriazoles and azophenols as binding sites
and azo groups as signal transduction units, which displayed
selective coloration with Ca2+ and Pb2+ addition (Fig. 17).52
The association constants for the 1 : 1 complex of37 towards
Ca2+ and Pb2+ ions were determined to be 7.06 104 M1 and
8.57 103 M1, respectively, resulting in a large bathochromic
shift in the absorption spectrum.
Talanova et al.described a new, efficient, and highly selective
fluorescent chemosensor38bearing two pendent proton-ionizable
dansylcarboxamide groups to the calix[4]arene preorganized inthe partial cone conformation for determination of Pb
2+ions
(Fig. 17).53 Complexation of Pb2+ with38 induces a blue shift
as a result of the carboxydansyl fluorophore deprotonation. In
acidic CH3CN/H2O (1 : 1 v/v) solution, 38 allowed for the
detection of Pb2+ at the levels as low as 2.5 ppb.
New fluorescent sensors 3941 based on calix[4]arenes
have been synthesized by Kumar et al. (Fig. 18).54 Interaction
between Pb2+ ions and imino nitrogen of ligands causes
spectrofluorometric changes in the pyrenyl group because of
a reverse PET phenomenon. Compounds 39 and 40 in the
cone conformation showed ratiometric sensing while 41 with
the 1,3-alternate conformation exhibited OnOff signalling
Fig. 15 Structures of compounds3234.
Fig. 16 Structure of compound35.
Fig. 17 Structures of compounds3638.
Fig. 18 Structures of the fluorescent chemosensors3941.
View Online
http://dx.doi.org/10.1039/c1cs15245a8/13/2019 Fluorescent and colorimetric sensors for detection of lead, cadmium, and mercury ions
9/36
This journal is c The Royal Society of Chemistry 2012 Chem. Soc. Rev.,2012, 41, 32103244 3217
with Pb2+ ions. Compounds 40 and 41 also showed a colour
change from colourless to yellow upon the addition of
Pb2+ ions.
Peptide based chemosensors
Deo and Godwin reported a ratiometric fluorescent probe that
is selective for Pb2+.55 This probe consists of a fluorescent dye
(dimethylamino)-naphthalene-1-sulfonamide (dansyl or dns)conjugated to the amino terminus of a tetrapeptide (ECEE)
(glutamate, E, and cysteine, C). The specific amino acids
within the first generation ligand were chosen because their
side chains contain functional groups (carboxylates and thiols)
that are known to coordinate Pb2+ under biologically relevant
conditions. Upon addition of Pb2+, the emission maximum of
dns-ECEE shifts from 557 to 510 nm with the enhancement of
intensity. By plotting the ratio of fluorescence emission inten-
sity at 510 nm versus the fluorescence emission intensity at
557 nm (I510/I557), an EC50for Pb2+ was obtained asB120 mM.
Pb2+ induced hydrolysis
A fluorescent chemodosimeter 42 for Pb2+
was designed and
synthesized by linking resorufin (serving as a fluorophore and
electron acceptor) to p-nitrophenol (serving as a fluorescence
quencher and electron donor) through phosphodiester bonds
(Fig. 19).56 Upon the addition of Pb2+, the phosphate ester
bonds in the probe were cleaved and the fluorophore was
released, accompanying the retrievement of fluorescence.
Although the 5 h heating required for the reaction is its
primary shortcoming, it is directly proportional to the Pb2+
concentration in a range of 50125 nM with a detection limit
of 22 nM in phosphate buffer (pH 8).
Polymer based chemosensors
Compared to small organic compounds, polymer based optical
sensors displayed several important advantages.57 For instance,
signal amplification could be one of the most important
advantages.
Bunz and coworkers reported the simple polymer 43 as a
potent sensing platform for lead salts in the aqueous solution
(Fig. 20).58 The polymer has a strong emission at Imax= 465 nm,
typical for a dialkoxy-PPE. The fluorescence of an aqueous
PIPES-buffered solution (pH 7.2) of43 was efficiently quenched
by Pb2+ with aKSV= 8.8 105.43was by a factor of 1.5 103
more sensitive toward quenching than its model compound 44,
which can be attributed to multivalent binding that is an
important factor in the observed sensitivity.
A series of ethylene glycol (45), triethylene glycol (46) and
pentaethylene glycol (47) esters of 10,12-pentacosadiynoic acid
(PCDA) (Fig. 20) were synthesized by Sukwattanasinitt and
colleagues.59 Even though the glycol ester lipids could not
form polydiacetylenes upon UV irradiation, they however
could be mixed with PCDA up to 30 mol% and polymerized
to form blue sols. The PDA sols with blue to red colorimetricresponse selectively to Pb2+ offered a method for the naked
eye detection of Pb2+ at part per million levels. The color
transition was induced by the selective binding between Pb2+
and carboxylate groups of PCDA causing vesicle aggregation
and fusion. The dynamic range of47/PCDA (30/70 mol%) sol
for Pb2+
detection was determined by varying the concen-
tration of Pb(NO3)2 solution from 5 to 100 mM. Linear
colorimetric response was obtained with Pb2+ concentration
in the range of 530 mM.
Yoonet al. have developed a new PDA-based chemosensor
system for the detection of Pb2+ in the aqueous solution.60 UV
irradiation of the suspensions derived from both DA monomers
(48a: PCDA = 1 : 9) resulted in the formation of stable andblue-colored PDA molecules (48b) (Fig. 21). 48b (200 mM)
displayed a selective and clear blue-to-red transition only with
Pb2+ in HEPES (10 mM, pH 7.4) among various metal ions
tested, including Na+
, K+
, Ca2+
, Cd2+
, Co2+
, Cu2+
, Hg2+
,
Mg2+, Ni2+, Pb2+ and Zn2+. Since the blue-to-red transition
of the PDAs is accompanied by the generation of fluorescence,
the lead-promoted transition was also monitored by fluores-
cence spectroscopy.48b (50 mM) produced a large fluorescence
Fig. 19 Structure of the fluorescent chemodosimeter 42 and its two
possible hydrolytic routes.
Fig. 20 Structures of4347 and PCDA.
Fig. 21 Structure of monomer 48a and polymerization process of
polymer 48b.
View Online
http://dx.doi.org/10.1039/c1cs15245a8/13/2019 Fluorescent and colorimetric sensors for detection of lead, cadmium, and mercury ions
10/36
3218 Chem. Soc. Rev.,2012, 41, 32103244 This journal is c The Royal Society of Chemistry 2012
enhancement with Pb2+. The fluorescence spectra of the PDAs
48bshowed a gradual increase in the presence of 09mM Pb2+
with the detection limit of 0.8 ppm.
Pb2+-dependent DNAzyme based sensing systems
In 2000, Li and Lu reported a novel strategy to convert Pb2+
dependent DNAzyme (817 motif) into a highly selective and
sensitive fluorescence-based Pb2+ sensor.61 6-Carboxytetra-methylrhodamine (TMR) was labelled to the substrate (17DS)
containing a single RNA linkage (ribonucleoside adenosine,
(rA)) as a fluorophore. 4-(40-Dimethylaminophenylazo)benzoic
acid (Dabcyl) was labelled to the enzyme strand (17E-DY) as a
fluorescence quencher (Fig. 22(a)). When the substrate strand
was annealed to the enzyme strand, the TMR fluorescence was
quenched by nearby Dabcyl (Fig. 22(a)). Upon the addition of
Pb2+
, the fluorescence revived due to deoxyribozyme-catalyzed
cleavage of the substrate. The biosensor had a quantifiable detec-
tion range from 10 nM to 4 mM and a selectivity of >80-fold
for Pb2+ over other metal ions at 4 1C. In 2003, Lu and
co-workers optimized their sensing system by introducing
both inter- and intramolecular quenchers to overcome thetemperature limitation (Fig. 22(b)).62 More recently in 2009,
introduction of the mismatches into the DNAzyme to resist
temperature-dependent variations from 4 to 30 1C was explored
(Fig. 22(c)).63 The new sensor was designed with the GR-5
DNAzyme base instead of 8-17 DNAzyme which offered higher
selectivity and a slightly lower detection limit than previously
reported (Fig. 22(d)).64
Moreover, Tan and co-workers linked an 817 DNAzyme
sequence labelled with a quencher and a leaving substrate
fragment labelled with a fluorophore through a DNA hairpin
structure. This modification can bring the quencher in close
proximity to the fluorophore ensuring efficient fluorescence
quenching.65 The new probe showed a selectivity for Pb2+
over other metal ions, where the quantifiable detection range
was from 2 nM to 20 mM.
A similar work was reported by Zhanget al.66 The substrate
strand of the Pb2+-dependent DNAzyme was designed as
a molecular beacon (MB) for highly efficient quenching. Upon
the addition of Pb2+ ions, the DNAzyme catalyzed cleavage
of the MB substrate could convert the intramolecularly stable
hybridized MB stem into two much less stable intermolecularly
hybridized DNA strands, thereby releasing the fluorophore-
labeled DNA strand and finally generated a fluorescence signal
enhancement. The Pb2+ detection limit was 600 pM. In addi-
tion, this strategy is applicable to detect the adenosine with
similarly high sensitivity.
He et al. reported a fluorescent biosensor based on Pb2+-
regulatory protein in Ralstonia metallidurans CH34 with high
selectivity and sensitivity for Pb2+ ions.67 A 25-mer duplex
DNA containing the PbrR-binding sequence was prepared as
a probe (Fig. 23). In the central base pair of this sequence, a
fluorescent base, 2-aminopurine (2AP), was incorporated as
a messenger. Addition of Pb2+ ions and PbrR triggered a
distortion of the duplex DNA to generate an unpaired 2-AP
base, which would emit a strong fluorescence. At room tempera-
ture, the detection limit can reach the nanomolar range (50 nM)
for Pb2+
ions in solution. The probe was also highly selective
towards Pb2+ ions over other metal ions (about 1000-fold) and
could be reversed by the addition of ethylenediaminetetraacetate
(EDTA).
A new colorimetric and chemiluminescence detection system
for Pb2+ was reported by the Willner group.68 The probe was
constructed by hybridizing a nucleic acid containing Pb2+-
dependent cleaving DNAzyme and its substrate including
horseradish peroxidase (HRP)-mimicking DNAzyme. Upon
the addition of Pb2+ ions, the HRP-mimicking DNAzyme by
the cleavage of the substrate assembled in the presence of
hemin to a catalytic G-quadruplex. The catalytic G-quadruplex
catalyzed the H2O2-mediated oxidation of 2,20-azino-bis(3-
ethylbenzothiazoline)-6-sulfonate (ABTS2) or luminol, which
results in a color change or generates chemiluminescence (CL),
respectively. Furthermore, this method can be applied to
L-histidine detection by using L-histidine cofactor-dependent
nucleic acid cleaving DNAzyme instead of the Pb2+-dependent
cleaving DNAzyme.
Wang and Dong et al. designed another colorimetric and
CL sensor for Pb2+ based on a similar concept. In the presence
of K+
, a common G-quadruplex DNAzyme PS2.M (with
hemin as a cofactor) can effectively catalyze the H2O2-mediated
Fig. 22 Predicted secondary structures of the fluorescent DNAzyme
lead sensors and schematic representation of the catalytic beacon
sensor: (a) normal 817 DNAzyme sensor; (b) temperature independent
817 DNAzyme sensor; (c) 817 DNAzyme sensor with mismatches;
(d) GR-5 DNAzyme sensor. F represents the fluorophore, FAM, Q1 is
the quencher DABCYL and Q2 is the quencher BHQ-1s. The single
RNA base on the substrate arm is denoted by rA.
Fig. 23 Binding of Pb2+ ions to PbrR691 as revealed by a 2AP-
modified DNA probe. A# = 2-aminopurine = 2AP.
View Online
http://dx.doi.org/10.1039/c1cs15245a8/13/2019 Fluorescent and colorimetric sensors for detection of lead, cadmium, and mercury ions
11/36
This journal is c The Royal Society of Chemistry 2012 Chem. Soc. Rev.,2012, 41, 32103244 3219
oxidation of ABTS2 or luminol accompanied by color change
or CL emission, respectively (Fig. 24).69 Addition of the Pb2+
ion induced a conformational change in the K+-stabilized
PS2.M to Pb2+-stabilized structure which has a higher stability
and a lower DNAzyme activity than the former. Thus, this
system can be applied to colorimetric (ABTS2) and CL
(luminol) detection of Pb2+ in aqueous solution. In addition,
this sensing system provides good selectivity for Pb2+ with a
low detection limit (32 nM per ABTS2 and 1 nM per luminol).
The Chang group also developed a fluorescence approach
for Pb2+ ions detection based on another G-quadruplex
DNAzyme, AGRO100.70 In the presence of hemin, addition
of Pb2+ ions can increase DNAzyme activity of AGRO100 for
H2O2-mediated oxidation of Amplex UltraRed (AUR). The
AGRO100-AUR probe was highly sensitive (LOD = 0.4 nM)
and selective (by at least 100-fold over other metal ions)
toward Pb2+ ions, with a linear detection range from 0 to
1000 nM.
A thrombin-binding aptamer (TBA) labelled with a fluoro-
phore and a quencher was reported by Chang et al. as a
fluorescent sensor for Pb2+ and Hg2+.71 As shown in Fig. 25,
the TBA had a random coil structure that can be changed into
a G-quartet structure in the presence of Pb2+ and into a
hairpin-like structure in the presence of Hg2+ ions. Changes in
the DNA strands conformation caused fluorescence between
the fluorophore and the quencher to decrease via FRET. Pb2+
and Hg2+ ions can be selectively detected at concentrations as
low as 300 pM and 5.0 nM in the presence of phytic acid and a
random DNA/NaCN mixture, respectively.
Wang et al. reported a recoverable DNA molecular device
for the highly selective and sensitive fluorescent detection of
Pb2+ based on DNA duplexquadruplex exchange.72 T30695,
(GGGT)4, and its partly complementary strand were hybrid-
ized to form a DNA duplex. Addition of Pb2+ ions disrupted
the duplex and stabilized the newly formed G-quadruplex. The
Pb2+-stabilized G-quadruplex interacted with zinc proto-
porphyrin IX and enhanced its fluorescence intensity. Further
addition of 1,4,7,10-tetraazacyclododecane-1,4,7,10-tetra-acetic acid (DOTA), a strong Pb2+ chelator, can reset this
DNA molecular device.
Lu and Tong et al. developed a new label-free method
for fluorescent detection of Pb2+
ions.73
They introduced an
abasic site called dSpacer into the duplex regions of the 817
DNAzyme, which can bind to an extrinsic fluorescent com-
pound, 2-amino-5,6,7-trimethyl-1,8-naphthyridine (ATMND),
and quench its fluorescence (Fig. 26). Addition of Pb2+ ions
enabled the DNAzyme to cleave its substrate and to release
ATMND from the DNA duplex, recovering its fluorescence.
Similarly, this method was also used for the fluorescent detec-
tion of adenosine by linking the dSpacer to the adenosine
aptamer. The adenosine-induced structural switching of theaptamer led to the release of ATMND and subsequent fluores-
cence enhancement. The detection limits of Pb2+ and adenosine
were 4 nM and 3.4 mM, respectively.
In 2010, the Lu group reported that DNA can hold ATMND
and quench its fluorescence by extending one end of DNA
with a loop to generate a vacant site (Fig. 27).74 Either metal
Fig. 24 Schematic of utilizing Pb2+-induced allosteric G-quadruplex
DNAzyme, PS2.M, for label-free colorimetric and CL detection of Pb2+.
Fig. 25 Representation of the sensing mechanism of the TBA probe
for the detection of Hg2+ and Pb2+ ions.
Fig. 26 Schematic illustration of label-free fluorescent detection of
(a) Pb2+ and (b) adenosine.
Fig. 27 Fluorescence enhancement response of the functional DNA
sensors specific to (a) Pb2+, (b) UO22+, (c) adenosine, and (d) Hg2+
using unmodified DNA via a vacant site.
View Online
http://dx.doi.org/10.1039/c1cs15245a8/13/2019 Fluorescent and colorimetric sensors for detection of lead, cadmium, and mercury ions
12/36
3220 Chem. Soc. Rev.,2012, 41, 32103244 This journal is c The Royal Society of Chemistry 2012
ion-dependent cleavage by DNAzymes or analyte-dependent
structural-switching by aptamers could release ATMND from
the DNA duplex and recover its fluorescence. As shown in
Fig. 27, label-free fluorescent sensors for Pb2+, UO22+, Hg2+,
and adenosine were developed with high selectivity and sensi-
tivity. The detection limits decreased to 3 nM, 8 nM, 30 nM,
and 6mM for UO22+
, Pb2+
, Hg2+
and adenosine, respectively.
Recently, Liu and Lu reported highly sensitive and selective
colorimetric sensing systems for Pb2+ detection by using
Pb2+-dependent DNAzyme as a target recognition element
and DNA-functionalized gold nanoparticles as a signaling
element.7578 As shown in Fig. 28, the Pb2+-dependent DNA-
zyme was composed of an enzyme (17E) and a substrate strand
(17DS) which was extended on both ends. Hybridization of
the substrate with DNA attached nanoparticles induced
aggregation of nanoparticles to provide a color change from
red to blue.75 In addition, the nanoparticles could be aligned
either in a head-to-tail manner or in a tail-to-tail manner
according to the DNAs attached to the nanoparticles. In the
former case, heating-and-cooling process (annealing) was
required for the aggregation.76,77 However, in the presence
of Pb2+, the substrate was cleaved by the enzyme, which inhibits
the aggregation, and hence the color remains red. Furthermore,
for the tail-to-tail aligned nanoparticles, the aggregation can be
perturbed by further addition of Pb2+ to result in a blue-to-red
color change, whereas the head-to-tail manner cannot.78 This
process could be accelerated by using small pieces of DNA to
invade the cleaved substrate of the DNAzyme.
In 2008, Lu et al. reported a simple label-free colorimetric
sensor for on-site and real-time Pb2+ detection.79 In the absence
of Pb2+, the salt-induced aggregation of gold nanoparticles
resulted in a color change from red to blue. This aggregation
could be prevented by single-stranded DNA, which was released
from the enzyme-complex by Pb2+ induced cleavage. The sensor
exhibited a low detection limit of 3 nM and higher selectivity for
Pb2+ over other metal ions.
Nanoparticle based sensing systems
Hupp et al. reported a simple colorimetric technique for the
detection of aqueous heavy metal ions, such as Pb2+, Cd2+,
and Hg2+. 13.6 0.4 nm diameter gold particles capped with
11-mercaptoundecanoic acid (MUA) were employed as
chromophores (Fig. 29).80 Functionalized gold nanoparticles
were aggregated in solution in the presence of divalent metal
ions by an ion-templated chelation process as shown in Fig. 33,which induced an easily measurable change in the absorption
spectrum of the particles. The aggregation also enhanced the
hyper-Rayleigh scattering (HRS) response from the nanoparticle
solutions, providing an inherently more sensitive method of
detection. The chelation/aggregation process was reversible via
the addition of a strong metal ion chelator such as EDTA.
Thomas and colleagues reported Au and Ag nanoparticles
that can be employed as Pb2+ selective colorimetric sensors,
prepared by mixing the corresponding metal cations (Au3+ or
Ag+) and a naturally occurring bifunctional molecule, gallic
acid (Fig. 30).81 This system is known for its ability to detect
micromolar quantities (ppm level) of Pb2+ ions even in the
presence of other metal cations in water resulting in a visualcolor change from pink to blue for Au nanoparticles and
yellow to red for Ag nanoparticles. Detailed mechanistic
investigations indicated that the hydroxyl group of gallic acid
(Fig. 30) is involved in the reduction of the Au 3+/Ag+ ions
and that the carboxylate group binds strongly to the surface of
the nanoparticles. The newly synthesized nanoparticles are
extremely stable in the pH range between 4.55.0. Under these
pH conditions, it is difficult to bring nanoparticles in proximity
due to strong interparticle electrostatic repulsion. However,
the unique coordination behavior of Pb2+ ions (coordination
number up to 12 with flexible bond length and geometry)
allows the formation of a stable supramolecular complex
resulting in the plasmon coupling and a visual color change.
Fig. 28 (a) Secondary structure of the DNAzyme. (b) Cleavage of
17DS by 17E in the presence of Pb2+. Pb2+-directed assembly of gold
nanoparticles by the DNAzyme when nanoparticles are aligned in a
head-to-tail (c) or a tail-to-tail manner (d). (e) For head-to-tail aligned
aggregates, Pb2+ cannot induce DNAzyme cleavage and no color change
can be observed. (f) For tail-to-tail aligned aggregates, Pb2+ can induce
DNAzyme cleavage and color change can be observed. The rate of color
change can be significantly increased by adding invasive DNA.
Fig. 29 Proposed process for the metal ion induced aggregation of
Au-MUA.
Fig. 30 A general scheme for two electron oxidation of gallic acid to the
corresponding quinine form and a representation of electrostatic inter-
action of carboxylic groups on the nanoparticle surface and the hydrogen
bonding network formed between the surface capped molecules.
View Online
http://dx.doi.org/10.1039/c1cs15245a8/13/2019 Fluorescent and colorimetric sensors for detection of lead, cadmium, and mercury ions
13/36
This journal is c The Royal Society of Chemistry 2012 Chem. Soc. Rev.,2012, 41, 32103244 3221
Positively charged CdTe-QDs capped with cysteamine
(CA-CdTe-QDs) and negatively charged AuNPs capped with
11-mercaptoundecanoic acid (MUA-AuNPs) (Fig. 31) havebeen prepared and used for the determination of Pb2+ by
Wang and Guo.82 These positively charged CACdTe-QDs
formed FRET donoracceptor assemblies with negatively
charged MUA-AuNPs due to electrostatic interactions, which
effectively quenched the PL intensity of the QDs (Fig. 31). A
novel inhibition assay method for Pb2+ detection was proposed
based on the modulation effect of Pb2+ on the FRET efficiency
between QDs and AuNPs (Fig. 31). The response was linearly
proportional to the concentration of Pb2+ in the range of
0.224.51 ppm, and the detection limit was calculated to be
30 ppb of Pb2+.
Meanwhile, Huang and colleagues developed a colorimetric,
label-free gold nanoparticle (Au NP) probe for the detectionof Pb2+ in aqueous solution.83 The unique feature here is that
this system is a nonaggregation-based nanoparticle sensor, in
which Pb2+ ions accelerate the leaching rate of Au NPs by
thiosulfate (S2O32) and 2-mercaptoethanol (2-ME) (Fig. 32).
The formation of PbAu alloys accelerated the Au NPs rapid
dissolution into solution, leading to dramatic decreases in
the surface plasmon resonance (SPR) absorption. The 2-ME/
S2O32-Au NP probe was highly sensitive (LOD = 0.5 nM)
and selective (by at least 1000-fold over other metal ions)
toward Pb2+ ions, with a linear detection range (2.5 nM10 mM).
Glutathione functionalized gold nanoparticles (GSH-GNPs)
were reported by Suet al.as a facile, cost-effective and sensitive
colorimetric detection method for Pb2+
(Fig. 33)84
which canpotentially induce immediate aggregation of these nanoparticles.
Therefore the existence of Pb2+ was able to be detected by
colorimetric response of GNPs monitored from a UV-vis
spectrophotometer or even with the naked eye (red to blue color
change), and the detection limit had the potential to reach
100 nM. The SPR of the GSH-GNPs solution at 700 and
520 nm are related to the quantities of dispersed and aggregated
GSH-GNPs, respectively.
Alkanethiol-bearing monoazacrown ethers were also used to
modify gold nanoparticles (AuNPs) as a simple and fast colori-
metric sensor to selectively detect Pb2+ in aqueous solutions(Fig. 34).85 These AuNPs selectively sensed Pb2+ through color
change from brown to purple, which was visually discernible by
an appearance of the surface plasmon band (SPB) at 520 nm.
The recognition mechanism is attributed to the unique structure
of the monoazacrown ether attached to AuNPs and the metal
sandwich coordination between two azacrown ether moieties
that are attached to separate the nanoparticles.
Han et al. adopted 11-mercaptoundecyl phosphoric acid as
a thiol ligand for AuNPs (Phos-AuNPs) based on the fact
that alkyl phosphates are potentially good ligands for Pb2+
because Pb2+ easily forms solids with phosphates and approxi-
mately 95% of the body burden of lead is stored in the bones as
lead phosphate derivatives.86 Phos-AuNPs were aggregatedby Pb2+, which caused a dramatic red-to-blue color change.
The detection limit of Phos-AuNPs for Pb2+ was reported as
1.637mM from the titration results.
Functional materials based sensing systems
In 2007, the Crego-Calama group developed a new sensing
material for the detection of heavy metal ions.87 The arrays
of 21 different fluorescent sensing monolayers, which were
consisted of 3 different fluorophores and 7 different ligands,
were directly generated by combinatorial methods and immo-
bilized on the wells surface of glass microtiter plates (Fig. 35).
Fig. 31 (a) Schematic representation of the FRET donoracceptor
assembly of positively charged CA-CdTe-QDs and negatively charged
MUA-AuNPs; (b) schematic representation of the inhibition assay
method for Pb2+ determination.
Fig. 32 Sensing mechanism of the 2-ME/S2O32-Au NP probe for
the detection of Pb2+ ions.
Fig. 33 Strategy for the colorimetric detection of Pb
2+
using GSH-GNPs.
Fig. 34 Schematic representation of the Pb2+-induced aggregationvia
sandwich complexation of azacrown ether-capped gold nanoparticles.
View Online
http://dx.doi.org/10.1039/c1cs15245a8/13/2019 Fluorescent and colorimetric sensors for detection of lead, cadmium, and mercury ions
14/36
3222 Chem. Soc. Rev.,2012, 41, 32103244 This journal is c The Royal Society of Chemistry 2012
Upon the addition of metal ions, such as Cu2+, Co2+, Pb2+,
Ca2+ and Zn2+, the monolayers produced various responses
by low selective interactions. These responses could be collected
by laser confocal microscopy and microarray reader fluores-
cence scanner and processed for each analyte as the charac-
teristic fluorescent pattern. The sensing systems can be recovered
by washing with EDTA solution.
As shown in Fig. 36, Asher and coworkers prepared two-
dimensional (2-D) polystyrene particle arrays with a high
diffraction ratio of incident light.88 These 2-D particle arrays
can be immobilized on hydrogel thin films containing different
molecular recognition agents for chemical sensing by polymer-
ization. In the presence of a special analyte, 2-D lattice spacing
of the arrays can be changed by hydrogel swelling/shrinking
caused by analyte-induced alterations of hydrogel osmotic
pressure, resulting in changes in the diffracted wavelength.
When acrylic acid (AAc) was copolymerized, the sensing
system showed high pH dependence in a range of pH 3.22 to
7.91. Furthermore, copolymerization of 4-acryloylamido-
benzo-18-crown-6 (4AB18C6) into the hydrogel produced a new
sensing material which can detect less than 1012 mol of Pb2+.
Fluorescent and colorimetric sensors for detection ofcadmium ions
Small molecule based chemosensors
In 2001, Prodi and Savage et al. designed and synthesized
5-chloro-8-methoxyquinoline appended diaza-18-crown-6 (49)
(Fig. 37) as a chemosensor for Cd2+ detection.89 Compound
49 exhibited extremely weak emission in methanol solution.
The crown ring moiety can bind to various metal ions,
including alkali and alkaline earth but with the exceptions of
Mg2+, transition and post-transition metal ions. Among them
only Cd2+
and Zn2+
could bind with49and give about 30 nm
red shift of lem with high quantum yield. In addition, the
enhancement factor for Cd2+
(94-fold) is larger than for Zn2+
(69-fold).
Three mixed donor phenanthroline-containing macrocycles
(5052) (Fig. 38) as fluorometric chemosensors for toxic heavy
metal ions were reported by Lippolis and coworkers.90 These
macrocycles could interact with Pb2+, Cd2+, and Hg2+ to
generate different complex species depending on the molar
ratios of M/L. In CH3CN solution, addition of Pb2+ and
Hg2+
induced a chelation enhancement of fluorescence
quenching (CHEQ) for all three ligands. In contrast, upon
addition of Cd2+, the CHEQ effect could be observed with 50
and 52 in the low molar ratio range (Cd2+/50 o 1; Cd2+/
52 o 0.5), and then the CHEF occurred in the higher molar
ratios range (1 o Cd2+
/50 o 2; 0.5 o Cd2+
/52 o 1). For51,the Cd2+ induced CHEF effect occurred in the whole range of
molar ratios.
Yoon et al. synthesized two anthracene derivatives bearing
the iminomethyl diacetic acid moiety at 9,10-(53) and 1,8-
positions (54) for selective fluorescent cadmium chemosensors
(Fig. 39). Fluorescence studies of53 indicated a selective and
Fig. 35 (a) The self-assembled monolayers formed in each well of the
glass microtiter plate (MTP); (b) the arrays of 21 different fluorescent
sensing monolayers (TM0-TM6, T0-T6, L0-L6) in MTP. (c) Chemical
composition of each fluorescent sensing monolayer.
Fig. 36 Fabrication of a 2-D photonic crystal for sensing
applications.
Fig. 37 Structure of compound 49 and its proposed binding mode
with Cd2+.
Fig. 38 Structures of compounds5052.
View Online
http://dx.doi.org/10.1039/c1cs15245a8/13/2019 Fluorescent and colorimetric sensors for detection of lead, cadmium, and mercury ions
15/36
This journal is c The Royal Society of Chemistry 2012 Chem. Soc. Rev.,2012, 41, 32103244 3223
large CHEF effect by a PET mechanism with Cd2+
at pH 10,
0.1 M CAPS buffer, even though there was a relatively small
CHEF effect with Zn2+.91 The association constants for Cd2+
and Zn2+ were calculated to be 69100 and 3200 M1,
respectively. The stoichiometry with Cd2+ was 1 : 1 binding
and the selectivity for Cd2+ was 20 times larger than that for
Zn2+. In 100% aqueous solution,54 was heavily quenched by
metal ions via PET.92 Particularly, the Cd2+54 complex
displayed a unique red-shifted broad band due to the chelato-
selective fluorescence perturbation resulted from electrophilic
aromatic cadmiation.
Gunnlaugsson et al.reported compounds55and56 (Fig. 39)
as fluorometric chemosensors for Cd2+ based on the PET
principle, using an anthracene fluorophore, connected to either
one or two iminodiacetate receptors by a methylene spacer.93
Both 55 and 56 have good water solubility and are pH-
independent in the physiological pH range. Upon addition of
Cd2+, the formation of charge-transfer complexes (exciplexes)
induced fluorescent enhancement atlmax= 506 and 500 nm for
55 and 56, respectively, whereas addition of Zn2+ only causes
the increase of (monomeric) anthracene emission of 56 and a
red-shifted emission (lmax= 468 nm) of55. Thus, both55 and
56 demonstrated sufficient Cd2+ selectivity over Zn2+ under
physiological conditions.
Compound57 (Fig. 40), a di-substituted bis(anthrylmethyl)
derivative of 1,8-dimethylcyclam, was studied by Youn and
Chang as a Hg2+- and Cd2+-selective fluorogenic sensor in
aqueous CH3CN solution.94 The water content of the aqueous
CH3CN solution can dominate the signaling type of the
recognition of Hg2+ and Cd2+. An OFFON type signaling
was observed for Hg2+ and Cd2+ ions in low water content
solutions (CH3CN : H2O = 90 : 10, v/v), while a selective
ONOFF type signaling toward Hg2+ ions was observed in
50% aqueous CH3CN solution.
Noveron and Stang et al. developed a new chromogenic
phenanthroline-containing supramolecular optical sensor (58)
(Fig. 41) for transition metals such as Ni2+, Cd2+, and
Cr3+.95 The 1 : 1 complexations of58 with Ni2+, Cd2+, and
Cr3+ in methanol solution induced dramatic changes in the
UV-vis spectrum. The binding constants are calculated to be
2.01 0.05 107 M1, 3.39 0.5 104 M1 and 7.53 0.4
103 M1 for Ni2+, Cd2+, and Cr3+, respectively.
Yuasa and coworkers designed and synthesized a carbohydrate-based fluorometric chemosensor (59) (Fig. 42) for Zn2+ and
Cd2+.96 Two amino groups stayed at the 3 and 5 positions of
the carbohydrate component as the recognition group and
two pyrene groups were attached to 2 and 4 positions as the
fluorophore. In the absence of metal ions, the two pyrene
groups were separated apart from each other and therefore
only produced monomer emission. Addition of metal ions
induced ring flip of the carbohydrate that led the pyrene
groups to fold and thus to afford excimer emission. Overall,
59also achieved high selectivity for Zn2+ and Cd2+ over other
metal ions in acetone solution.
Zhang and Yu et al. reported the design and synthesis of a
porphyrin-appended terpyridine (60) (Fig. 43) as a fluorometric
chemosensor for recognition of Cd2+ ions.97 Upon addition of
Fig. 39 Structures of compounds5356.
Fig. 40 Structure of compound57.
Fig. 41 Structure of compound 58 and its proposed binding mode
with Cd2+.
Fig. 42 Structure of compound 59 and its proposed binding mode
with M2+.
Fig. 43 Structure of compound60.
View Online
http://dx.doi.org/10.1039/c1cs15245a8/13/2019 Fluorescent and colorimetric sensors for detection of lead, cadmium, and mercury ions
16/36
8/13/2019 Fluorescent and colorimetric sensors for detection of lead, cadmium, and mercury ions
17/36
8/13/2019 Fluorescent and colorimetric sensors for detection of lead, cadmium, and mercury ions
18/36
8/13/2019 Fluorescent and colorimetric sensors for detection of lead, cadmium, and mercury ions
19/36
This journal is c The Royal Society of Chemistry 2012 Chem. Soc. Rev.,2012, 41, 32103244 3227
This new b-cyclodextrin derivative 88 (Fig. 55) showed very
weak fluorescence because of the intramolecular PET from N
atom in the triazole moiety to the 8-hydroxyquinoline fluoro-
phore. Addition of Cd2+ can recover the fluorescence by
inhibiting the PET process. The Jobs plot analysis suggested
a 1 : 1 stoichiometry of88/Cd2+ complex. Moreover, the limit
of detection (LOD) for88towards Cd2+
was found to be 1.89
103
M. In addition, using sodium adamantine carboxylate as a
co-chelating agent, the binding constant (log Ks) increased from
2.10 0.23 to 3.38 0.09 without affecting the emission
wavelength.
A new fluorescent Cd2+ sensor (89) (Fig. 56) based on
8-hydroxyquinoline containing a 2,8-dithia-5-aza-2,6-pyridino-
phane as an ionophore has been synthesized.118 This chemo-
sensor exhibited a significant CHEF response toward Cd2+ not
only in aqueous solutions but also in sodium dodecyl sulfate
micelles, liposomes, and living cells. The 1 : 1 stoichiometry of
89Cd2+
complex was confirmed by X-ray structure analysis.
Probe 89 was proved to be a good choice for selective imaging
of Cd2+ in living cells owing to its low cytotoxicity and low
background fluorescence.
Li and coworkers reported dipyrrolylquinoxaline (DPQ)
derivatives 90 and 91 as new fluorescent sensors for transition-
metal ions.119 Both 90 and 91 showed good sensitivity toward
Cd2+, Zn2+ with turn-on fluorescence based on the CHEF
mechanism and Cu2+, Hg2+ turn-off fluorescence based on the
CHEQ mechanism. Jobs plot and crystal structure analysis
indicated the formation of M90 (or 91) complex with 1 : 1
stoichiometry.
Compound 92 (Fig. 57), containing a benzoimidazole
moiety as a fluorophore and DPA as an ionophore, was reported
as a ratiometric fluorescent Cd2+ sensor by Guo and Heet al.120
In the HEPES buffer solution (50 mM, 0.1 M KNO3, pH 7.2)
of 92, addition of Cd2+ led to the co-planation of pyridine
and benzoimidazole moieties and also enhanced electron-
withdrawing ability of the acceptor resulting in both absorp-
tion spectra (red shift about 19 nm) and emission spectra
changes (red shift about 53 nm). UV-vis and fluorescence
titrations indicated the 1 : 1 binding stoichiometry of92Cd2+
complex with picomolar sensitivity. Metal-ion selectivity experi-
ments indicated that probe 92 was unaffected by other metal
ions, except Zn2+
. Although Zn2+
addition also induced a red
shift in emission, it has little disturbance to the Cd2+ detection.
Probe 92 also exhibited high cell membrane permeability and good
reversibility with the metal ion chelator TPEN in HeLa cells.
Yoon and co-workers designed a naphthalimide-based
fluorescent chemosensor 93 for ratiometric Zn2+ and Cd2+
detection (Fig. 58).121 Large fluorescent enhancements were
observed upon addition of Zn2+ (22-fold) and Cd2+ (21-fold).
Notably Cd2+ induced a blue shift to 446 nm (blue fluorescence),
while Zn2+ caused a red shift to 514 nm (green fluorescence) in
the aqueous solution (CH3CN/0.5 M HEPES (pH 7.4) = 50 : 50)
via amide tautomerization. The colorimetric changes could
be distinguished by the naked eye and also Jobs plot study
illustrated the 1 : 1 binding mode of 93Cd2+ and 93Zn2+
complexes.
In 2011, Qian and Xu et al. investigated two near-infrared
fluorescent sensors 94 and 95 (Fig. 58) based on a tricarbo-
cyanine fluorophore for detecting Cd2+.122 Both 94 and 95
showed high selectivity and sensitivity to Cd2+ over other
metal ions, in particular95, which can even distinguish Cd2+
in Tris-HCl (12.5 mM) solution (containing 0.05 mM sodium
Fig. 54 Structures of compounds8587.
Fig. 55 Structure of compound 88 and its proposed binding modes
with Cd2+ and sodium adamantane carboxylate.
Fig. 56 Structures of compounds89, 90 and 91.
Fig. 57 Structure of92 and its binding mode with Cd2+.
Fig. 58 Structures of compounds93, 94 and 95.
View Online
http://dx.doi.org/10.1039/c1cs15245a8/13/2019 Fluorescent and colorimetric sensors for detection of lead, cadmium, and mercury ions
20/36
8/13/2019 Fluorescent and colorimetric sensors for detection of lead, cadmium, and mercury ions
21/36
This journal is c The Royal Society of Chemistry 2012 Chem. Soc. Rev.,2012, 41, 32103244 3229
Shiet al.described the complexation of cationic 5,10,15,20-
tetrakis(1-methyl-4-pyridinio)porphyrin (TMPyP) and negatively
charged chemically converted graphene (CCG) sheets and utilized
the TMPyP/CCG complex (Fig. 62) as an optical sensor for
detecting Cd2+ ions in aqueous media.129 Addition of Cd2+
ions to the pure TMPyP solution exhibited a bathochromic
shift of absorption band (ca.22 nm). In the presence of CCG,
the chelating reaction between TMPyP and Cd2+ ions was
greatly accelerated from 20 h to 8 min under ambient condi-
tions with a larger bathochromic shift (ca.40 nm). Overall, the
TMPyP/CCG complex displayed high selectivity towards
Cd2+ ions over other metal ions, including Zn2+ ions.
The design and synthesis of triazole-ester modified silver
nanoparticles (TE-Ag NPs) (Fig. 63) was reported by the Li
group.130 TE-Ag NPs showed high selectivity towards Cd2+
over other metal ions. Addition of Cd2+ ions into TE-Ag NPs
solution induced a dramatic increase of the absorbance intensity
at 550 nm resulting in a significant color change from yellow to
red, which can be observed by the naked eye. The TEM image
indicated that the color change of TE-Ag NPs in the presence of
Cd2+ is attributed to the Cd2+-induced assembly of TE-Ag NPs.
The limit of colorimetric detection for Cd2+ is 2.0 105 M.
Anzenbacher, Jr.et al.reported a fluorescence sensor array,
which was generated by dispersing 9 cross-reactive sensors
(S1S9) (Fig. 64) in a hydrophilic polyurethane carrier.131
Based on the various affinities and selectivities of the sensors,
this array can distinguish metal cations, such as Ca2+, Mg2+,
Cd2+, Hg2+, Co2+, Zn2+, Cu2+, Ni2+, Al3+, Ga3+ at
different ranges of pH and at different cation concentrations
using linear discriminant analysis (LDA). This array was also
used to identify samples from nine different mineral water
brands without any pretreatment.
Based on a similar concept, Feng and Guanet al.reported a
solgel membrane array, which immobilized five commercially
available colorimetric indicators (Fig. 65) for the discrimina-
tion of trace heavy metal ions.132
Color-difference maps weregenerated by comparing the digital red, green, and blue values
in the presence and absence of analytes. Using this array, eight
heavy metal ions, including Pb2+, Hg2+ and Cd2+, can be
differentiated at standard concentrations of wastewater discharge.
Fluorescent and colorimetric sensors for detection of
mercury ions
Small molecule based chemosensors
Ferrocene based small molecules.Ta rraga and Molina et al.
reported ferrocene-based multichannel molecular chemosensors
Fig. 62 Structure of the TMPyP/CCG complex.
Fig. 63 Structure of TE-Ag NPs.
Fig. 64 Structures of the chemosensors S1S9 used in the array.
Fig. 65 Structures of five indicators and color-difference maps of eight
heavy-metal ions at standard concentrations of wastewater discharge.
View Online
http://dx.doi.org/10.1039/c1cs15245a8/13/2019 Fluorescent and colorimetric sensors for detection of lead, cadmium, and mercury ions
22/36
3230 Chem. Soc. Rev.,2012, 41, 32103244 This journal is c The Royal Society of Chemistry 2012
bearing two pyridine rings which have Hg2+ selectivity through
three different channels: the oxidation peak that is anodically
higher shifted (DE1/2= 300 mV for 97 and DE1/2 = 200 mV
for 98), new low-energy bands that appear in the absorption
spectrum at 483 nm and 485 nm, respectively. Also, the
emission bands of 97 and 98 were red-shifted by 28 nm and
32 nm, respectively. Remarkable chelation-enhanced fluores-
cent factors (CHEF = 227 for 97 and 165 for 98) were
accompanied. The changes of compound 97 in absorption
spectra are accompanied by the color change from yellow to
orange, which allows the potential naked eye detection.40,133
The P. Ghosh group reported thiomethoxychalcone-based
ligands99 and 100 as Hg2+ selective chemodosimeters. In the
acetonitrile solution, these two compounds showed selective
color changes from orange to purple with Hg2+, and the UV/vis
titration results indicated the formation of 2 : 1 (99: Hg2+) and
1 : 1 (100: Hg2+) complexes. X-ray crystal structure and cyclic
voltammetric studies supported a selective chemodosimetric
desulfurization between Hg2+ and99 or 100.134
Kim et al. developed a ferrocene-based electrochemical
chemodosimeter for Hg2+ recognition.135 Addition of Hg2+
induced cyclization and desulfurization as shown in Fig. 66. In
addition, an anodic shift of 101s redox potential and a red
shift in UV-vis spectroscopy were observed in CH3CN/H2O
(9 : 1) solution with high selectivity among the various metal ions.
Rhodamine based small molecules. Three sensors bearing the
thiophene group and rhodamine, or thiospirolactam rhodamine,
were synthesized for the selective detection of Hg2+ by Duan
et al.136 Compared to compounds 102 and 103, compound 104
containing two rhodamine carbohydrazone arms exhibited better
selectivity for Hg2+ in fluorescent enhancement and absorption
detection (Fig. 67). The ppb level fluorescent detection limit of
102,103and104for Hg2+ offered their potential applications in
the Hg2+ detection of drinking water.
Recently, Yoon et al. described two rhodamine hydrazone
derivatives bearing a thiol (105) and a carboxylic acid group
(106) as selective fluorescent and colorimetric chemosensors
for Hg2+ (Fig. 68).137 Both the chemosensor samples containing
Hg2+ in aqueous solution induced large fluorescent enhance-
ment and color change by the spirolactam ring-opening process
of the rhodamine moiety. From the detection of Hg2+ in the
microfluidic channel, the linear responses of compounds105and
106 were observed in the range of 1 nM1 mM Hg2+ concen-
tration with the detection limit of 1 nM for 105and 4.2 nM for
106, respectively. Both chemosensors were applied successfully
to detect previously exposed nanomolar concentrations of Hg2+
in the C. elegans.
Lin et al. reported new fluorescence turn-on Hg2+ probe
107 considering the interaction of Hg2+ with both thiol and
alkyne moieties.138 The probe exhibited large fluorescence
enhancement, high selectivity, low detection limit of 39 nM,
and linear fluorescent response to Hg2+ ranging from 5 108
to 4 106 M. Furthermore, the probe 107 is applicable for
Hg2+ imaging in the living cells. The proposed mechanism is
shown in Fig. 69.
Lin and coworkers constructed a novel reversible fluores-
cence turn-on Hg2+ sensor based on a new receptor composed
of a thiol atom and an alkene moiety for living cell fluorescent
imaging.139 Compound 108 showed a 1000-fold fluorescent
enhancement with Hg2+ in PBS buffer (25 mM, pH 7.0,
containing 2.5% CH3CN) and is highly selective to Hg2+
with a detection limit of 27.5 nM. The S atom and the alkene
moiety of compound 108 took part in the 1 : 1 stoichiometry
binding with Hg2+ and the binding is reversible when excess
EDTA was added under the neutral conditions (Fig. 70).
A rhodamine B-based chemosensor containing NS2 for the
reversible binding receptor of Hg2+ in aqueous media was intro-
duced by Qianet al.140Compound109exhibited quick fluorescent
and colorimetric response that allowed for the real-time detection.
Fig. 66 Structures of compounds 97100 and Hg2+ induced intra-
molecular cyclic guanylation of101.
Fig. 67 Structures of compounds102104.
Fig. 68 Structures of compounds105 and 106.
Fig. 69 Proposed mechanism of107 with Hg2+.
View Online
http://dx.doi.org/10.1039/c1cs15245a8/13/2019 Fluorescent and colorimetric sensors for detection of lead, cadmium, and mercury ions
23/36
This journal is c The Royal Society of Chemistry 2012 Chem. Soc. Rev.,2012, 41, 32103244 3231
The 1 : 1 stoichiometry 109/Hg2+ was confirmed by Jobs plot
and the EDTA addition changed the color from pink to colorless
and the fluorescence was turned off (Fig. 71). The binding constant
Kawas calculated to be (1.18 0.13) 106 M1 from the titrationcurve with Hg2+.
Recently, Tang and Nandhakumar et al.reported rhodamine B
hydrazide methyl 5-formyl-1H-pyrrole-2-carboxylate Schiff
base110141 to detect both Cu2+ and Hg2+ using two different
detection modes that are UV-vis spectroscopy for Cu2+ and
selective fluorescent recognition for Hg2+. Despite the copper
ion induced color change with very weak fluorescent emission,
only Hg2+ exhibited fluorescent enhancement by forming the
open-ring form of rhodamine spirolactam in MeOH : H2O
(3 : 1, v/v, HEPES 10 mM, pH 7.4). In addition, compound 110
for sensing Hg2+ is not influenced under neutral pH conditions.
Yuet al.reported compound111 (Fig. 72) as a fluorometric
chemosensor for Hg2+ based on the rhodaminecoumarinconjugate.142 Probe111 showed high sensitivity and selectivity
for Hg2+ sensing with reversible dual-responsive colorimetric
and fluorescent response in 50% water/ethanol buffered at
pH 7.24. The probe 111 can be applied for the recognition of
Hg2+ in both tap and river water samples, and the quantity of
Hg2+
with a linear response ranged from 8.0 108
to 1.0
105 mol L1. The detection limit was 4.0 108 mol L1.
A rhodamine based sensor containing a histidine group was
synthesized for the detection of Hg2+ by the Yoon group.143
As shown in Fig. 72, compound112has two carbonyl oxygens as
well as imidazole nitrogen that can provide a nice storage pocket
for Hg2+. Addition of 100 equiv. Hg2+ caused the fluorescence
increase over 100-fold in 0.02 M, pH 7.4 HEPES : EtOH
(1 : 9, v/v) solution. From the fluorescent titration study with
Hg2+, the association constant of compound 112 was calcu-
lated to be 2.0 103
M1
and thus112 was further applied to
sense the intracellular Hg2+.
Yoonet al.also reported two rhodamine derivatives bearing
mono and bis-boronic acid groups (113and114) as fluorescent
and colorimetric sensors for Hg2+ (Fig. 73). These two
rhodamine derivatives were the first examples of reversible
fluorescent chemosensors, which utilized the boronic acid
group as the binding ligand for metal ions.144 Through the
fluorescent titration with Hg2+ in CH3CNwater (9 : 1, v/v),
the association constants of 114 and 114 with Hg2+ were
calculated to be 3.3 103 M1 and 2.1 104 M1, respectively.
Bis-boronic chemosensor 114 showed 9-fold tighter binding
with Hg2+ than mono-boronic chemosensor 113, due to the
additional boronic acid moiety, which plays an important role
in the recognition of Hg2+
.
The Yoon group introduced rhodamine 6G thiolactone
derivative 115 as a selective and colorimetric sensor for Hg2+
at pH 7.4.145 Offon type fluorescent and colorimetric changes
were observed in the presence of Hg2+ in CH3CNHEPES
buffer (0.01 M, pH 7.4) (1 : 99, v/v). X-Ray structure of
115Hg2+ exhibited the 1 : 2 stoichiometry of 115/Hg2+ and
the sensor 115 could detect Hg2+ in the nanomolar range. In
addition, compound115 could be applied for in vivo imaging of
C. elegans to detect Hg2+. Yoon and Shins group designed a
selenolactone based fluorescent probe 116 for the detection of
inorganic mercury and methylmercury species with unique
fluorescence enhancement and UV-vis spectral change.146 Because
of the extremely high affinity between mercury and selenium,
mercury and methylmercury species induced a deselenation reac-
tion in compound 116 (Fig. 74). In the concentration range of
Hg2+ (030 nM), the fluorescent intensity displayed a linear
response proportionally and the Jobs plot study demonstrated
the binding mode of 1 : 1 stoichiometry between 116 and Hg2+.
This sensing ability was hence successfully applied for the detection
of inorganic mercury/methylmercury species in cells and zebrafish.
Compound 117 (Fig. 75), a tren-spaced rhodamine and
pyrene fluorophore, was reported by the Kim group as a Hg2+
and Cu2+-selective fluorogenic sensor that modulated pyrene
excimer emission.147 The complexation of117with Hg2+ induced
the rhodamine spirolactam ring opening and exhibited dynamic
excimer emission. The different binding mode between Hg2+
and Cu2+ was elucidated from DFT (density functional theory)
Fig. 70 Proposed binding mode of108 with Hg2+.
Fig. 71 Proposed binding mode between109/Hg2+.
Fig. 72 Structures of compounds 110112, and the proposed binding
mode of111 with Hg2+.
Fig. 73 Structures of compounds113 and 114.
Fig. 74 Structures of compounds115 and 116.
View Online
http://dx.doi.org/10.1039/c1cs15245a8/13/2019 Fluorescent and colorimetric sensors for detection of lead, cadmium, and mercury ions
24/36
3232 Chem. S