Top Banner
1 Sponsored Research Financial Management: Current Pre and Post- Award Issues
78
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: Financial Management

1

Sponsored Research Financial Management:

Current Pre and Post-Award Issues

Sponsored Research Financial Management:

Current Pre and Post-Award Issues

Page 2: Financial Management

2

Sponsored Research Financial Management: Current Pre and Post-Award Issues

Sponsored Research Financial Management: Current Pre and Post-Award Issues

Moderator/Team Leader:• Jerry Fife

Assistant Vice Chancellor for Research FinanceVanderbilt University

Faculty: • Michelle Fortnam

Associate Director, Internal Audit DepartmentStanford University

• Bob GallowayProfessor of Biomedical EngineeringSchool of EngineeringVanderbilt University

Moderator/Team Leader:• Jerry Fife

Assistant Vice Chancellor for Research FinanceVanderbilt University

Faculty: • Michelle Fortnam

Associate Director, Internal Audit DepartmentStanford University

• Bob GallowayProfessor of Biomedical EngineeringSchool of EngineeringVanderbilt University

Page 3: Financial Management

3

Sponsored Research Financial Management: Current Pre and Post Award Issues

Sponsored Research Financial Management: Current Pre and Post Award Issues

Faculty (continued):• F. Edward Herran

Director, Office of Sponsored ProjectsMemorial Sloan-Kettering Cancer Center

• Cynthia WhiteDirector, Research OfficeWashington University at St. Louis

Faculty (continued):• F. Edward Herran

Director, Office of Sponsored ProjectsMemorial Sloan-Kettering Cancer Center

• Cynthia WhiteDirector, Research OfficeWashington University at St. Louis

Page 4: Financial Management

4

The Basics of A-21 Cost Allowability

The Basics of A-21 Cost Allowability

Page 5: Financial Management

5

A-21 Standards forCost Allowability

A-21 Standards forCost Allowability

• Reasonable• Allocable• Treated Consistently• These standards apply to both

proposals and active projects. If an unallowable cost is included in a proposal, the cost does not become allowable if it is not removed during the review process

• Reasonable• Allocable• Treated Consistently• These standards apply to both

proposals and active projects. If an unallowable cost is included in a proposal, the cost does not become allowable if it is not removed during the review process

Page 6: Financial Management

6

A-21 Standards forCost Allowability (cont’d.)

A-21 Standards forCost Allowability (cont’d.)

• All sponsored project awards contain terms and conditions (T&C's), which supersede all other regulations; therefore it is essential that the Research Administrator read, understand and abide by them

• All sponsored project awards contain terms and conditions (T&C's), which supersede all other regulations; therefore it is essential that the Research Administrator read, understand and abide by them

Page 7: Financial Management

7

Unallowable for Federal Reimbursement

Unallowable for Federal Reimbursement

• Expenses that are unallowable for federal reimbursement may be reasonable and necessary business expenses permitted by the University. Departments may incur these expenses but they must code them as unallowable.

• Expenses that are unallowable for federal reimbursement may be reasonable and necessary business expenses permitted by the University. Departments may incur these expenses but they must code them as unallowable.

Page 8: Financial Management

8

AllowabilityAllowability

• For a cost to be allowable, it must conform to:

Terms and conditions of the agreement

A-21 (federal awards) Institutional policy

• For a cost to be allowable, it must conform to:

Terms and conditions of the agreement

A-21 (federal awards) Institutional policy

Page 9: Financial Management

9

Allowability (cont’d.)Allowability (cont’d.)

• Some costs may be an appropriate University expense but are not allowable to charge to a sponsored project. For example, fund raising is an appropriate expense for a University, but cannot be charged, either directly or indirectly, to the federal government, according to OMB A-21.

• Some costs may be an appropriate University expense but are not allowable to charge to a sponsored project. For example, fund raising is an appropriate expense for a University, but cannot be charged, either directly or indirectly, to the federal government, according to OMB A-21.

Page 10: Financial Management

10

Unallowable Costs can be:Unallowable Costs can be:Unallowableby University

University expenses that are:

• NOT reasonable • NOT necessary • NOT allocable • NOT permitted by

University policy

These expenses will not be paid for by University.

If incurred, they must be paid for by the individual.

Unallowablefor reimbursement by Federal

Government

University expenses that are:• Reasonable • Necessary • Allocable • Permitted by University

policy

but are unallowable for federal reimbursement.

These expenses:• can be paid for by• must be coded as

unallowable

Unallowableby Sponsor

Expenses that do not conform to the sponsors terms and conditions and OMB Circular A-21 (if applicable), or are:

• NOT reasonable • NOT necessary • NOT allocable

These expenses will not be paid for by the sponsor.

University may pay for the expenses, code as appropriate.

Page 11: Financial Management

11

AllowabilityAllowability

Section J of OMB A-21 lists examples of allowable and unallowable costs

Some unallowable expenses include:

Section J of OMB A-21 lists examples of allowable and unallowable costs

Some unallowable expenses include:

Alcoholic beverages Alumni activities Commencement Entertainment (incl. Non-business meals)

Alcoholic beverages Alumni activities Commencement Entertainment (incl. Non-business meals)

Fines and penalties Goods for personal use Social membershipsFund raising

Fines and penalties Goods for personal use Social membershipsFund raising

Page 12: Financial Management

12

ReasonableReasonable

A cost must be reasonable in order to charge it to a sponsored project. Reasonableness is defined as that which reflects the action of a prudent person. The three questions a person must ask to determine reasonableness of cost are: Is it necessary for performance of the award? Does it advance the scope of work? Is it consistent with established institutional

policies and practices?

A cost must be reasonable in order to charge it to a sponsored project. Reasonableness is defined as that which reflects the action of a prudent person. The three questions a person must ask to determine reasonableness of cost are: Is it necessary for performance of the award? Does it advance the scope of work? Is it consistent with established institutional

policies and practices?

Page 13: Financial Management

13

AllocableAllocable

• Allocation is the process of assigning a cost, or a group of costs, to one or more cost objectives.

• Costs may be allocated only if they advance the work of the project.

• The cost must be assigned to the project in proportion to the benefit that the project will receive.

• Fund availability should not be used to determine allocability.

• Allocation is the process of assigning a cost, or a group of costs, to one or more cost objectives.

• Costs may be allocated only if they advance the work of the project.

• The cost must be assigned to the project in proportion to the benefit that the project will receive.

• Fund availability should not be used to determine allocability.

Page 14: Financial Management

14

ConsistentConsistent

• Requires Costs Incurred for the Same Purpose, In Like Circumstances, to be Handled Consistently as Direct or Indirect Costs

• Requires Costs Incurred for the Same Purpose, In Like Circumstances, to be Handled Consistently as Direct or Indirect Costs

Page 15: Financial Management

15

Consistent (cont’d.)Consistent (cont’d.)

• Particularly applicable to costs identified in section F.6.b of A-21 (clerical and administrative salaries, office supplies, postage, memberships and local phone service.

• Particularly applicable to costs identified in section F.6.b of A-21 (clerical and administrative salaries, office supplies, postage, memberships and local phone service.

Page 16: Financial Management

16

A-21 Section F.6.bA-21 Section F.6.b

• Identifies costs that are normally treated as indirectClerical and administrative salariesOffice suppliesPostageLocal phone serviceMemberships

• Identifies costs that are normally treated as indirectClerical and administrative salariesOffice suppliesPostageLocal phone serviceMemberships

Page 17: Financial Management

17

Possible Exceptions to Section F.6.b

Possible Exceptions to Section F.6.b

• Costs that are normally treated as indirect can be treated as direct under exceptional circumstances.

• Must meet all three of the criteria:Major Project (Project with needs beyond

that normally provided by department)Specifically IdentifiedExplicitly Budgeted

• Costs that are normally treated as indirect can be treated as direct under exceptional circumstances.

• Must meet all three of the criteria:Major Project (Project with needs beyond

that normally provided by department)Specifically IdentifiedExplicitly Budgeted

Page 18: Financial Management

18

Specific Identification?Specific Identification?

Criteria for charging an administrative expense directly to a major project

Cost must be specifically tied to

a particular sponsored project

Criteria for charging an administrative expense directly to a major project

Cost must be specifically tied to

a particular sponsored project

Page 19: Financial Management

19

Specific Identification?Specific Identification?

Criteria for charging an administrative expense directly to a major project

Must be able to show how the project benefited from the expense using:•Documentation•Or a system

Criteria for charging an administrative expense directly to a major project

Must be able to show how the project benefited from the expense using:•Documentation•Or a system

Page 20: Financial Management

20

Administrative Charging (Direct)Administrative Charging (Direct)

When all three criteria are met:

The expense can be charged directly to the project

This does not necessarily provide approval to charge any other administrative costs to the project.

In addition, the cost must meet the allowability criteria

When all three criteria are met:

The expense can be charged directly to the project

This does not necessarily provide approval to charge any other administrative costs to the project.

In addition, the cost must meet the allowability criteria

Page 21: Financial Management

21

Major ProjectMajor Project

• Requires an extensive amount of clerical or administrative support

• Requires effort that is significantly more than is normally provided by the department/unit

• Requires an extensive amount of clerical or administrative support

• Requires effort that is significantly more than is normally provided by the department/unit

Page 22: Financial Management

22

Examples of Possible Major ProjectsExamples of Possible Major Projects

• Large Complex Projects - Center grants, program project grants

• Projects requiring: extensive data accumulation, analysis, reporting, surveying or tabulation

• Projects requiring extensive amounts of travel and meeting arrangements

• Large Complex Projects - Center grants, program project grants

• Projects requiring: extensive data accumulation, analysis, reporting, surveying or tabulation

• Projects requiring extensive amounts of travel and meeting arrangements

Page 23: Financial Management

23

Examples of Major ProjectsExamples of Major Projects

• Projects where the principal focus is preparation and production of manuals, large reports, books, monographs

• Projects that are geographically inaccessible to normal departmental administrative services

• Projects requiring specific database management, manuscript preparation, human or animal Protocols or multiple project-related investigator coordination

• Projects where the principal focus is preparation and production of manuals, large reports, books, monographs

• Projects that are geographically inaccessible to normal departmental administrative services

• Projects requiring specific database management, manuscript preparation, human or animal Protocols or multiple project-related investigator coordination

Page 24: Financial Management

24

Salaries and WagesSalaries and Wages

Page 25: Financial Management

25

Institutional Base Salary (IBS)Institutional Base Salary (IBS)

• Must conform to university policies, consistently applied (A-21)

• Must be paid from the applicant organization and may not be increased as a result of obtaining grant funds (A-21 and NIH Grants Policy Statement)

• Must conform to university policies, consistently applied (A-21)

• Must be paid from the applicant organization and may not be increased as a result of obtaining grant funds (A-21 and NIH Grants Policy Statement)

Page 26: Financial Management

26

Institutional Base Salary (IBS)Institutional Base Salary (IBS)

Current Framework• Paid by the applicant organization• May not be increased as a result of

receiving grant funds• Clinical practice compensation is

considered part of IBS if guaranteed by the university, shown on the appt. form and paid through the university and included in the university’s effort reporting system

Current Framework• Paid by the applicant organization• May not be increased as a result of

receiving grant funds• Clinical practice compensation is

considered part of IBS if guaranteed by the university, shown on the appt. form and paid through the university and included in the university’s effort reporting system

Page 27: Financial Management

27

Institutional Base Salary (IBS)Institutional Base Salary (IBS)

AAMC/COGR Proposal• Institutions with affiliated practice

plans may include salary and effort as part of charges to NIH grants

• Affiliated is defined as those instances where the institution pays or directs the salary decisions for those included in the practice plan.

AAMC/COGR Proposal• Institutions with affiliated practice

plans may include salary and effort as part of charges to NIH grants

• Affiliated is defined as those instances where the institution pays or directs the salary decisions for those included in the practice plan.

Page 28: Financial Management

28

Institutional Base Salary (IBS)Institutional Base Salary (IBS)

• How about VA appointments?• More on this during our effort

reporting discussion

• How about VA appointments?• More on this during our effort

reporting discussion

Page 29: Financial Management

29

Salary and Wage IssuesSalary and Wage Issues

• Salary increases• Supplemental Compensation or

Overloads Additional compensation provided

over and above the IBS

• Bonuses

• Salary increases• Supplemental Compensation or

Overloads Additional compensation provided

over and above the IBS

• Bonuses

Page 30: Financial Management

30

Salary IncreasesSalary Increases

• Pending promotionOk to include if assured

• How should they be applied?Must be fund source neutralMust be applied consistently

• Pending promotionOk to include if assured

• How should they be applied?Must be fund source neutralMust be applied consistently

Page 31: Financial Management

31

Supplemental Compensation or Overloads

Supplemental Compensation or Overloads

A-21 indicates that faculty undertake research as a part of their normal responsibilities; however, it does recognize there are exceptions if:

• The duties are across departmental lines • Involves a separate or remote operation, and

work performed is in addition to regular departmental load and,

• The charges are approved in writing by the sponsoring agency

A-21 indicates that faculty undertake research as a part of their normal responsibilities; however, it does recognize there are exceptions if:

• The duties are across departmental lines • Involves a separate or remote operation, and

work performed is in addition to regular departmental load and,

• The charges are approved in writing by the sponsoring agency

Page 32: Financial Management

32

Salary OverloadsSalary Overloads

• Does disclosing an overload in the proposal constitute approval?

• Does disclosing an overload in the proposal constitute approval?

Page 33: Financial Management

33

BonusesBonuses

Depends on the circumstances – No clear guidance

• What do you think about?Bonuses in lieu of salary increasesBonuses based upon market

competitionBonuses based upon achievement of

departmental goalsBonuses based on financial success

Depends on the circumstances – No clear guidance

• What do you think about?Bonuses in lieu of salary increasesBonuses based upon market

competitionBonuses based upon achievement of

departmental goalsBonuses based on financial success

Page 34: Financial Management

34

Fringe BenefitsFringe Benefits

Page 35: Financial Management

35

Fringe BenefitsFringe Benefits

Some typical fringe benefitcomponents:

• FICA• Retirement• Health Care• Life Insurance• Disability• Worker’s Compensation• Unemployment Insurance

Some typical fringe benefitcomponents:

• FICA• Retirement• Health Care• Life Insurance• Disability• Worker’s Compensation• Unemployment Insurance

Page 36: Financial Management

36

Fringe BenefitsFringe Benefits

Two methods for budgeting and charging:

• Using an estimated rate for budgeting and then charging actual

• Developing, negotiating and charging rates

Accomplished by pooling fringe benefit costs and then comparing to salaries and wages.

Two methods for budgeting and charging:

• Using an estimated rate for budgeting and then charging actual

• Developing, negotiating and charging rates

Accomplished by pooling fringe benefit costs and then comparing to salaries and wages.

Page 37: Financial Management

37

SuppliesSupplies

Page 38: Financial Management

38

SuppliesSupplies

Two Types• Laboratory (chemicals, gases)• Office (printer paper, sharpies, post it

notes)

Two Types• Laboratory (chemicals, gases)• Office (printer paper, sharpies, post it

notes)

Page 39: Financial Management

39

SuppliesSupplies

What does A-21 say about officesupplies?

“In developing the departmental administration cost pool, special care should be exercised to ensure that costs incurred for the same purpose in like circumstances are treated consistently as either direct or F&A costs.”

What does A-21 say about officesupplies?

“In developing the departmental administration cost pool, special care should be exercised to ensure that costs incurred for the same purpose in like circumstances are treated consistently as either direct or F&A costs.”

Page 40: Financial Management

40

SuppliesSupplies

So does A-21 say anything else on thistopic?

“Items such as office supplies, postage, local telephone costs, and memberships shall normally be treated as F&A costs.”

So does A-21 say anything else on thistopic?

“Items such as office supplies, postage, local telephone costs, and memberships shall normally be treated as F&A costs.”

Page 41: Financial Management

41

SuppliesSupplies

Does this mean that office supplies used in a laboratory must meet the major project definition to be direct charged or does the type of usage make the determination?

Does this mean that office supplies used in a laboratory must meet the major project definition to be direct charged or does the type of usage make the determination?

Page 42: Financial Management

42

EquipmentEquipment

Page 43: Financial Management

43

EquipmentEquipment

• What is equipment?• Split funding• Fabricated equipment• Service agreements• Lease/purchase analysis• Already available but underutilized

• What is equipment?• Split funding• Fabricated equipment• Service agreements• Lease/purchase analysis• Already available but underutilized

Page 44: Financial Management

44

What is Equipment?What is Equipment?

A-110 Definition • Nonexpendable tangible personal

property having a useful life of more than one year and an acquisition cost of $5,000 or more per year

• Institutions can set a lower amount consistent with institutional policy

• Remember this when dealing with other universities

A-110 Definition • Nonexpendable tangible personal

property having a useful life of more than one year and an acquisition cost of $5,000 or more per year

• Institutions can set a lower amount consistent with institutional policy

• Remember this when dealing with other universities

Page 45: Financial Management

45

Equipment (Split Funding)Equipment (Split Funding)

Basis for split funding• Equipment benefits more than one

project• Cost sharing

Can non-federal amount be depreciated in your F&A rate?

Basis for split funding• Equipment benefits more than one

project• Cost sharing

Can non-federal amount be depreciated in your F&A rate?

Page 46: Financial Management

46

Fabricated EquipmentFabricated Equipment

What is your institutional policy?• Implications of proper budgeting

and chargingProper classifications of costs (CAS

501)F&A budgeted and charged correctly

What is your institutional policy?• Implications of proper budgeting

and chargingProper classifications of costs (CAS

501)F&A budgeted and charged correctly

Page 47: Financial Management

47

Service AgreementsService Agreements

• Direct or F&A cost?• Split funding• What if the equipment was not

purchased from the project?

• Direct or F&A cost?• Split funding• What if the equipment was not

purchased from the project?

Page 48: Financial Management

48

Lease/Purchase Analysis Lease/Purchase Analysis

A-110• “Where appropriate, an analysis is

made of lease and purchase alternatives to determine which would be the most economical and practical procurement for the Federal Government.”

• What is your institutions policy?• When is this addressed?

A-110• “Where appropriate, an analysis is

made of lease and purchase alternatives to determine which would be the most economical and practical procurement for the Federal Government.”

• What is your institutions policy?• When is this addressed?

Page 49: Financial Management

49

Already Available but UnderutilizedAlready Available but Underutilized

A-110 says procurement standards should avoid the purchase of unnecessary items• Is underutilized equipment covered in this

statement?• How do institutions determine what is

available and underutilized?• When is this determined?

During proposal processingBefore purchase

A-110 says procurement standards should avoid the purchase of unnecessary items• Is underutilized equipment covered in this

statement?• How do institutions determine what is

available and underutilized?• When is this determined?

During proposal processingBefore purchase

Page 50: Financial Management

50

Subcontract, Consultant or Vendor?

Subcontract, Consultant or Vendor?

Page 51: Financial Management

51

Subcontract or Sub awardSubcontract or Sub award

Distinguishing Characteristics:

• Performs substantive programmatic work under a grant or contract

• Bears responsibility for programmatic decision making and measurable performance requirements

• Must adhere to Federal compliance requirements if the source is a Federal award

• Retains intellectual property rights if a university

Distinguishing Characteristics:

• Performs substantive programmatic work under a grant or contract

• Bears responsibility for programmatic decision making and measurable performance requirements

• Must adhere to Federal compliance requirements if the source is a Federal award

• Retains intellectual property rights if a university

Page 52: Financial Management

52

VendorVendor

• The procurement of goods or services from an organization which provides the goods and services to many different purchasers as part of its normal business operations within a competitive environment

• Not subject to the same compliance requirements as a subcontractor (if the source is a Federal award)

• The procurement of goods or services from an organization which provides the goods and services to many different purchasers as part of its normal business operations within a competitive environment

• Not subject to the same compliance requirements as a subcontractor (if the source is a Federal award)

Page 53: Financial Management

53

ConsultantConsultant

An individual with the followingcharacteristics:

• Not an employee of your institution• Proven professional or technical competence

and provides this to your organization• Is not controlled with regard to the manner of

performance or the result of the service• Considered a work for hire and does not retain

any rights to the end product

An individual with the followingcharacteristics:

• Not an employee of your institution• Proven professional or technical competence

and provides this to your organization• Is not controlled with regard to the manner of

performance or the result of the service• Considered a work for hire and does not retain

any rights to the end product

Page 54: Financial Management

54

Subcontract, Consultant or Vendor?Subcontract, Consultant or Vendor?

Given the definitions, whatactions are taken to ensure the

proper mechanism is used?

Given the definitions, whatactions are taken to ensure the

proper mechanism is used?

Page 55: Financial Management

55

SubcontractsSubcontracts

Actions to be taken• Incorporating into the primes proposal• Cost analysis (rates)• Competition• Monitoring (technical, fiscal)• Billing (approvals)• Recognizing the culture of the

subcontractor

Actions to be taken• Incorporating into the primes proposal• Cost analysis (rates)• Competition• Monitoring (technical, fiscal)• Billing (approvals)• Recognizing the culture of the

subcontractor

Page 56: Financial Management

56

Other Costs Other Costs

Page 57: Financial Management

57

Participant Support CostsParticipant Support Costs

Costs paid on or behalf of participantsin connection with conferences,meetings, symposia, training activitiesand workshops. Includes:

• Transportation costs• Registration fees• Per diem • Stipends• Other related costs

Costs paid on or behalf of participantsin connection with conferences,meetings, symposia, training activitiesand workshops. Includes:

• Transportation costs• Registration fees• Per diem • Stipends• Other related costs

Page 58: Financial Management

58

Participant Support CostsParticipant Support Costs

Participant characteristics:• Not employees of the grantee• Generally not a federal employee

although there are exceptions if there is no duplication of funding

Participant support costs are generally not subject to F&A costs

Participant characteristics:• Not employees of the grantee• Generally not a federal employee

although there are exceptions if there is no duplication of funding

Participant support costs are generally not subject to F&A costs

Page 59: Financial Management

59

Other CostsOther Costs

What other costs should we discuss?• F&A costs

WaiversAs cost sharingOn-campus vs. off campus

• Travel• Others?

What other costs should we discuss?• F&A costs

WaiversAs cost sharingOn-campus vs. off campus

• Travel• Others?

Page 60: Financial Management

60

How about budgeting and modular grants?

How about budgeting and modular grants?

Page 61: Financial Management

61

Procurement CardsProcurement Cards

Page 62: Financial Management

62

Procurement CardsProcurement Cards

Different Models•Which expenses?•Who gets one?•Dollar Limits•Benefits vs. risks

Different Models•Which expenses?•Who gets one?•Dollar Limits•Benefits vs. risks

Page 63: Financial Management

63

Effort ReportingEffort Reporting

Page 64: Financial Management

64

Recent Government ActivitiesRecent Government Activities

Whistleblower Suits • Northwestern University - $5.5

million• Johns Hopkins University – $2.6

million

Whistleblower Suits • Northwestern University - $5.5

million• Johns Hopkins University – $2.6

million

Page 65: Financial Management

65

Recent Government ActivitiesRecent Government Activities

DHHS Office of Inspector General• Review to determine extent that A-133

audits assess and document compliance with time and effort reporting requirements

• Pilot audits focusing on the relationship between effort proposed and effort charged

DHHS Office of Inspector General• Review to determine extent that A-133

audits assess and document compliance with time and effort reporting requirements

• Pilot audits focusing on the relationship between effort proposed and effort charged

Page 66: Financial Management

66

Other Planned DHHS Pilot AuditsOther Planned

DHHS Pilot Audits• Cost Transfers – Were they made in

accordance with federal regulations and were they justified?

• Cost Sharing and Matching – Were the amounts committed provided?

• Subrecipient Monitoring – Were appropriate procedures in place to monitor their expenditures and were site visits made?

• Cost Transfers – Were they made in accordance with federal regulations and were they justified?

• Cost Sharing and Matching – Were the amounts committed provided?

• Subrecipient Monitoring – Were appropriate procedures in place to monitor their expenditures and were site visits made?

Page 67: Financial Management

67

Recent Government Activities

Recent Government Activities

DHHS Office of Inspector General–Fall 2003

• Sought recommendations for developing Compliance Program Guidance (CPG) for recipients of NIH grants to prevent fraud and abuse

• Identified effort reporting as a risk area and sought suggestions

DHHS Office of Inspector General–Fall 2003

• Sought recommendations for developing Compliance Program Guidance (CPG) for recipients of NIH grants to prevent fraud and abuse

• Identified effort reporting as a risk area and sought suggestions

Page 68: Financial Management

68

Recent Government ActivitiesRecent Government Activities

National Institutes of Health (NIH) has issuedan effort reporting “clarification” in itsGrants Policy Statement as follows:

“Clinical compensation may be considered in the institutional base salary as long as all criteria are met: 1) clinical practice compensation must be guaranteed by the university, 2) clinical practice compensation must be reported on the university’s appointment form and paid by the university, and 3) clinical practice effort must be included and accounted for in the university’s effort reporting .”

National Institutes of Health (NIH) has issuedan effort reporting “clarification” in itsGrants Policy Statement as follows:

“Clinical compensation may be considered in the institutional base salary as long as all criteria are met: 1) clinical practice compensation must be guaranteed by the university, 2) clinical practice compensation must be reported on the university’s appointment form and paid by the university, and 3) clinical practice effort must be included and accounted for in the university’s effort reporting .”

Page 69: Financial Management

69

What Are the Issues Behind the Recent Problems?

What Are the Issues Behind the Recent Problems?

• The basis for calculating effort• The basis for calculating institutional

base salary (IBS)• Faculty understanding of effort

reporting• How are effort and compensation

estimated, tracked and reconciled?• Are all institutional effort and

compensation systems aligned?

• The basis for calculating effort• The basis for calculating institutional

base salary (IBS)• Faculty understanding of effort

reporting• How are effort and compensation

estimated, tracked and reconciled?• Are all institutional effort and

compensation systems aligned?

Page 70: Financial Management

70

What Are the Issues Behind the Recent Problems?

What Are the Issues Behind the Recent Problems?

• Pre and post award processes are uncoordinated

• Lack of effective training • Unclear and/or undocumented definition

of full time appointment• Appointment letters/annual letters

vague or unclear on effort commitments

• Pre and post award processes are uncoordinated

• Lack of effective training • Unclear and/or undocumented definition

of full time appointment• Appointment letters/annual letters

vague or unclear on effort commitments

Page 71: Financial Management

71

Other Potential Risk AreasOther Potential Risk Areas

• VA Appointments• Supplemental Compensation• Using different IBS for grant budgets vs.

payroll allocation and grant charges• Investigators with greater than 5

awards• Investigators with K awards

• VA Appointments• Supplemental Compensation• Using different IBS for grant budgets vs.

payroll allocation and grant charges• Investigators with greater than 5

awards• Investigators with K awards

Page 72: Financial Management

72

An Example An Example

Dr. Jones Works 70 Hours/Week in the Following Fashion:• 35 Hrs. on NIH Grants• 21 Hrs. in Patient Care Activities• 10 Hrs. on Teaching Activities• 4 Hrs. on Dept./Institutional

Activities

Dr. Jones Works 70 Hours/Week in the Following Fashion:• 35 Hrs. on NIH Grants• 21 Hrs. in Patient Care Activities• 10 Hrs. on Teaching Activities• 4 Hrs. on Dept./Institutional

Activities

Page 73: Financial Management

73

Correct Allocation on Personnel Action Form

Correct Allocation on Personnel Action Form

• NIH/federal grants50%

• Cost of practice 30%• Unrestricted 20%

• NIH/federal grants50%

• Cost of practice 30%• Unrestricted 20%

Page 74: Financial Management

74

The Myth of the 40 Hour WeekThe Myth of the 40 Hour Week

Some assume that faculty are onlyresponsible for reporting 40 hours/week andthus could erroneously report effort asfollows:

NIH/federal grants 88%Unrestricted/cost of practice 12%

* Assumes research comes first

Some assume that faculty are onlyresponsible for reporting 40 hours/week andthus could erroneously report effort asfollows:

NIH/federal grants 88%Unrestricted/cost of practice 12%

* Assumes research comes first

Page 75: Financial Management

75

What can be done tomitigate risk?

What can be done tomitigate risk?

Test to determine if there are problems for:

• Review appointment letters for clarity• Who signs• Faculty with VA appointments• Faculty with >5 awards • Faculty with K awards• Train, train, train

Test to determine if there are problems for:

• Review appointment letters for clarity• Who signs• Faculty with VA appointments• Faculty with >5 awards • Faculty with K awards• Train, train, train

Page 76: Financial Management

76

How Much Money Do I Have Left?

How Much Money Do I Have Left?

Page 77: Financial Management

77

How Much Money Do I Have Left? How Much Money Do I Have Left?

Faculty needs/desires• Budgetary flexibility• The ability to know how much money

is available• Encumbrance system for salaries• Real time encumbrance system for

other purchases

Faculty needs/desires• Budgetary flexibility• The ability to know how much money

is available• Encumbrance system for salaries• Real time encumbrance system for

other purchases

Page 78: Financial Management

78

How Much Money Do I Have Left?How Much Money Do I Have Left?

Given these needs/desires, howcan research administrators helpin the areas of:

• Budgetary flexibility• Balance systems to facilitate vs.

control• Building a departmental system vs.

relying on the general ledger to do it all

Given these needs/desires, howcan research administrators helpin the areas of:

• Budgetary flexibility• Balance systems to facilitate vs.

control• Building a departmental system vs.

relying on the general ledger to do it all