Final Bunsis Report Stark State

8/10/2019 Final Bunsis Report Stark State

1/97

!"#$%&'$()* ,-" ./)"$0

1) 2)%(3" 4//5 (),/ ,-" 6,785 6,7," 9()7):(7; 6(,


2/97

>/73#7?

@

9()7):(7; A/)3(&/) /' 6,785

6,7,"0 >7&/ 1)7;$%(%

>"B")


3/97

I

F-" 6,7," /' H-(/0

9()7):(7; A/)3(&/) /' ,-" 6,7," J(*-"8 K3


4/97

6,7," 7)3 L7&/)7; M)"#?;/$#"), >7,"%6/


5/97

MST M)"#?;/$#"), >7," N$ 6,7,"6/?2 E;1F;9;5

G>92HI6@

J;I3;F59

K;F3 /0>B5:57


6/97

H-(/ K:/)/#$ 4//5()* G"X"86/


7/97

6,7," /' H-(/0 F/,7; >"B")


8/97

@U=I 6,7," /' H-(/ >"B")',?',+0. 1+3.( @5AA: A8BC.& 1+3.( 75==A


9/97

6,7," /' H-(/0 F7^ >"B")


10/97

F7^ A-7)*"% () H-(/

=U

H;3 2):/#" F7^ >7,"%0

E8/*8"%%(B" 87,"% 87)*()*


11/97

Z"c)* >(3 /' ,-" 2):/#" F7^ () H-(/D

C-"8" C/


12/97

.7Q/8 K^?")3(,

=@

!! #$ %#&'$( ) '* +',-&

%./#0-#/1234 5((#(,-$0. 67899: ;676 ?/30-,#'$ 778:@: 67


13/97

F/,7; J(*-"8 K3 1??8/?8(7&/) '/8 H-(/0

6,7," 6-78" /' 2)%,8


14/97

A/##


15/97

6,785 6,7," 6,7," 6-78" /' 2)%,8


16/97

E"8:"),7*" A-7)*"% () 662 '/8 M)(B"8%(&"%P

A/##


17/97

@U=RS=W E"8'/8#7):" 9


18/97

J/a 6,*+26)2"* ?; 68/ 1)%%/*6 ;/$%E@E F6)&/*6+ /$%*,*3 68/,% G%+6 JA 1"==/3/ =/:/= +/I/+6/% F

HE F6)&/*6+ 1"IK=/2*3 $*; &/:/="KI/*6$= 5*3=,+8 ,* 68/ K%/:,")+ ;/$%$*& $M/IK2*3 $*; 1"==/3/ =/:/= 5*3=,+8 /,68/% ,* 68/ %/I$,*&/% ". 68/K%/:,")+ ;/$% "* $*; 6/%I 68,+ ;/$% /$%* @LJ ". $ K",*6E

NE F6)&/*6+ 1"IK=/2*3 $*; &/:/="KI/*6$= 7$68 ,* 68/ K%/:,")+ ;/$%$*& $M/IK2*3 $*; 1"==/3/ =/:/= 7$68 /,68/% ,* 68/ %/I$,*&/% ". 68/K%/:,")+ ;/$% "* $*; 6/%I 68,+ ;/$% /$%* @LJ ". $ K",*6E

OE F6)&/*6+ /*%"==,*3 ."% 68/ G%+6 2I/ $6 $ 9F> 9*,:/%+,6; I$,*1$IK)+ "% ?%$*18 68,+ ;/$% $*& 8$:/ K%/:,")+=; /$%*/& $6 =/$+6 BH1"==/3/ =/:/= +/I/+6/% F

=]


19/97

E"8'/8#7):" 9


20/97

E"8'/8#7):" 9"%


21/97

E


22/97

E*,,

).+./*;.

72>?2@,A.

B.589C*D.8*

E+*F*G*

H*69,038.0

72I*;*

J+./,;*

K20026622

?,66,66,LL,

K2@*6

M/23.0

N2006O+I*0,*

B.589)*/.+,0*

?*66*A9562P6

?,A9,3*0

Q*06*6

:++,0.,6

R8*9

HO.G,03

E/D*06*6

S9.;2:6+*0;

E/,T.0*

72>U./D

E+*6D*

).002AVA58

:.>*

H268*/2

M9,.

MD+*9.G*

H,6A.06,0

W2/62O

72>=*GL69,/2

?*/O+*0;

72F/*6D*

?,0026.8*

Q2085ADO

?,66.5/,

?.08*0*

?*,02

7./89C*D.8*

H-(/ (% IT,--(*-"%, 7, @R`O

M6 7B"87*" (% IR`P #"3(7) (% @[`


23/97

A"),"8 '/8 1#"8(:7) E8/*8"%%

1 Z8"7, >":"%%(/)P 7 Z8"7, >",8"7,H:,/N"8P @U=R

@I

FIGURE 5

Low-income students pay the most for college in states with the

greatest cuts in higher-education funding

Net price by level of state disinvestment in higher education, instititution type, and income

Low-income

2 Year

Low-middle income Middle-income

Cut most 2nd most Middle 2nd least Cut least

0

$2,000

$4,000

$6,000

$8000

$10,000

H-(/ (% ()

,-" #(33;"*8/


24/97

K3


25/97

6,7," /' H-(/ Z")"87; HN;(*7&/) G/)3 >7&)*%

@)3J(*-"%, E/%%(N;" >7&)*%6/


26/97

@T

9()7):(7; A/)3(&/)

/' 66A0>7&/ 1)7;$%(%


27/97

9()7):(7; A/)3(&/) () ,-" M)(B"8%(,$n% Ha) C/83%6/


28/97

66A G7;7):" 6-"",0 rK>l 6,8/)*s6/


29/97

66A 1%%", G8"753/a)P () .(;;(/)%

2):8"3(N;" Z8/a,-s6/


30/97

./8" KB(3"):" /' G7;7):" 6-"", 6,8")*,-0

66A A


31/97


32/97

9(8%, Fa/ A/#?/)"),% /' L", 1%%",%

V%"I 68/ K%,"% 18$%64 #8/* #/ /T$I,*/ */6$++/6+4 68/ 6#" #8,6/ 1$6/3"%,/+ $%/ *"61"*+,&/%/& K$%6 ". 6%)/ %/+/%:/+W

R*:/+6/& ,* 1$K,6$= $++/6+ $%/ 68/ :$=)/ ". 68/

?),=&,*3+4 $*& )*,:/%+,2/+ *//& 68/ ?),=&,*3+ 6""K/%$6/E F,*1/ 68/ )*,:/%+,6; #,== *"6 +/== 68/?),=&,*3+4 68/,% :$=)/ ,+ *"6 1"*+,&/%/& #8/*$*$=;X,*3 68/ G*$*1,$= 8/$=68 ". 68/ ,*+26)2"*

S/+6%,16/& *"*U/TK/*&$?=/ %/K%/+/*6+ .)*&+&"*$6/& 6" 68/ )*,:/%+,6; $*& 68/ K%,*1,K$= 1$**/:/% ?/ +K/*6E

I@


33/97

!"k)(&/) /' >"%,8(:,"3 K^?")37N;" >"%"8B"%

S/+6%,16/&U/TK/*&$?=/ */6 $++/6+ %/K%/+/*6 .)*&+ 68$6 1$*

"*=; ?/ )+/& ."% $ +K/1,G1 K)%K"+/E V"% /T$IK=/4 $ ?"*& +,*Y,*3 .)*& ,+ +/6 )K ."% .)6)%/

K%,*1,K$= $*& ,*6/%/+6 K$;I/*6+4 $*& 68/ 9*,:/%+,6; ,+ *"6$=="#/& 6" )+/ $*; ". 68"+/ .)*&+ ."% $*; K)%K"+/ /T1/K6K$;,*3 "Z 68/ &/?6 [68/ .)*& 1$**"6 ?/ )+/& ."% .$1)=6;

+$=$%,/+4 ."% /T$IK=/\E !"#/:/%4 68/ /T,+6/*1/ ". 68/+/ $++/6+ +2== 8/=K+ 68/

,*+26)2"*E ]/6^+ +$; ;") 8$:/ $ 8"I/ I"%63$3/4 $*& $== ".;")% .)6)%/ 8")+/ K$;I/*6+ $%/ 1":/%/& ,* $ .)*&E _")1$**"6 6")18 68,+ .)*& ."% $*;68,*3 ?)6 8")+/ K$;I/*6+E

P8/ /T,+6/*1/ ". 68,+ .)*& +2== 8/=K+ ;")% ":/%$== G*$*1,$=+,6)$2"*E

P8,+ 1$6/3"%; ,+ $ :/%; +I$== $I")*6 ."% F6$%Y F6$6/

II


34/97

!"k)(&/) /' M)8"%,8(:,"3 >"%"8B"%

P8/ $&I,*,+6%$2"* #,== 1=$,I 68$6 )*%/+6%,16/& ,+*"6 )*%/+6%,16/&4 $+ 68/; 8$:/ &/+,3*$6/& 68"+/.)*&+ ."% K$%21)=$% K)%K"+/+ [68/; ?/="*3 6" 68/&/K$%6I/*6+ ,+ "`/* 8/$%&\

!"#/:/%4 68/ ("$%& 1$I %/:/%+/ 68"+/&/+,3*$2"*+E R. 68/ &/+,3*$2"*+ #/%/ $ +/6 ,*+6"*/ a*"U#$;U;")U1$*U3/6U")6U".U68/I1"II,6I/*6+b4 68/ /T6/%*$= $)&,6"%+ #")=& K)6

68/I ,* 68/ %/+6%,16/&U/TK/*&$?=/ "% %/+6%,16/&*"*/TK/*&$?=/ 1$6/3"%,/+E

P8/%/."%/4 )*%/+6%,16/& ,+ %/$==; )*%/+6%,16/&E

IR


35/97

66A L", 1%%", !",7(;6/


36/97

66A >"%"8B" A/#?/)"),% /' L", 1%%",%

IT

!"# %&&"#&' ())* ())+ (),) (),, (),( (),-

./0""1 2/ 3452#46 %&&"#& 789:7-9:-+ ;,9*:89:*8 8,988;9-)( 879-:,9*-; 8;9;;;9*77 :-9;:-97+-


37/97

!(%:


38/97

66A >"%"8B"% Z87?-(:7;;$6/


39/97

66A 6(b" /' >"%"8B"% >";7&B" F/ H?"87&)* K^?")%"%0

E8(#78$ >"%"8B" >7&/

I[

!""# !""$ !"%" !"%% !"%! !"%&

'()*+ -./.01./ %%2#3%245! %323$&23"3 %$234&2#4# !3255&2#66 !626!32!6! &"2%"!2!%#

'()*+ 789.:/./ 532$6&24%" 442##&26#% #42%!$24%5 %"!2$##265& %"#253$2"&" %"&2%!"2!&4

;0

-./.01. -*)


40/97

66A E8(#78$ >"%"8B" >7&/ () A/),"^,

RU

!"

$"

%!"

%$"

&!"

&$"

'!"

'$"

(!"

($"

$!"

&!!) &!!* &!%! &!%% &!%& &!%'

++,

-./011023

4056 7889

7889

+81:9

8;

?82@A10

B58=A10


41/97

66A 6(b" /' >"%"8B"% >";7&B" ,/ !"N,0

r(7N(;(,$ >7&/

R=

!""# !""$ !"%" !"%% !"%! !"%&

'()(*+() %%,#-%,./! %-,-$&,-"- %$,-.&,#.# !-,//&,#00 !0,0!-,!0! &",%"!,!%#

1(23 " " " %$,--&,$$- %#,.&.,!/" %0,#!!,$%0

567268639 '736: ;< ;< ;< %!.= %-$= %.$=

D

F-" B(7N(;(,$ 87&/ (% 3"k)"3 7% 8"%"8B"% 3(B(3"3 N$ (),"8"%,SN"78()* 3"N,

D

98/# @UU] ,/ @U=UP 6,785 -73 )/ 3"N,P %/ ,-" 87&/ (% )/, 7??;(:7N;"P

,-/


42/97

66A r(7N(;(,$ >7&/ () A/),"^,

R@

!"

$!"

%!!"

%$!"

&!!"

&$!"

&!!' &!!( &!%! &!%% &!%& &!%)

**+

,-./00/12

3/45 6778

6778

*7098

7:

;71?@0/

A47


43/97

66A >"B")


44/97

66A L", 2):/#" >7&/ () A/),"^,0

Hp ,-" A-78,% J(*-

RR

!"#

%#

"#

'#

(#

)%#

)"#

"%%( "%%* "%)% "%)) "%)" "%)+

,,-

./0122134

5167 899:

899:

,92;:

91?@93AB21C69>B21


45/97

66A A7%- 9;/a%0 A7%- 9;/a >7&/

6,8/)* 7)3 E/%(&B" KB"8$ l"786/

A(476(- 078(8A78C 92.)6-D

EEF= &":>! ;>:$>?:>%" #!:&$> >;:


46/97

66A A7%- 9;/a >7&/ () A/),"^,

RT

!"#

%#

"#

'#

(#

"%%( "%%) "%*% "%** "%*" "%*+

,-./00/12

3/45 6778

6778

970:8

7;

?71@A0/

B47=A0/

99C


47/97

C-7, (% ,-" !(p"8"):" G",a"")

F-" A-7)*" () L", 1%%",% 7)3 A7%- 9;/a%D

R\

F-" :-7)*" () )",

7%%",% x F/,7;

>"B")


48/97

6")7," G(;; T >7&/% () H-(/

F"I/ ;/$%+ $3"4 68/ >8," ("$%& ". S/3/*6+$)68"%,X/& 7""&;^+ 6" 1"I/ )K #,68 $ %$2"

."%I)=$2"* 6" $++/++ 68/ G*$*1,$= +6%/*368 ".

8,38/% /&)1$2"* ,*+26)2"*+

P8/+/ %$2"+ $%/ K)?=,+8/& /:/%; ;/$%4 $*&

@ABJ 1$* ?/ .")*& $6W

8MK+WLL###E"8,"8,38/%/&E"%3L+,6/+L

"8,"8,38/%/&E"%3LG=/+L)K="$&+LG*$*1,$=LF(NLV_BJUF(NUF1"%/+EK&.

R]


49/97

.//3$n% >7&/ 1)7;$%(%

7""&;^+ )+/+ 68%// %$2"+ 6" c)&3/ 68/ G*$*1,$=

1"*&,2"* ". K)?=,1 )*,:/%+,2/+E R* .$164 68/ FVF9G*$*1,$= +6$6/I/*6+ %/./% 6" 68/ 7""&;^+ %$2*3+ ".68/ F6$6/ +;+6/IE

P8/* $ 1"IK"+,6/ +1"%/ ,+ 1"IK,=/& ?$+/& "* 68/+/ J

%$2"+W -%,I$%; S/+/%:/ S$2"

0%/ 68/%/ +)d1,/*6 %/+/%:/+e

f,$?,=,6; S$2" R+ 68/%/ 6"" I)18 &/?6e

Q/6 R*1"I/ S$2" 0%/ %/:/*)/+ $*& /TK/*+/+ ,* =,*/ #,68 /$18 "68/%e

R[


50/97

.//3$n% >7&/ !"k)(&/)%

!"#$%"& "()("*( "%+,W 5TK/*&$?=/ */6 $++/6+&,:,&/& ?; 6"6$= "K/%$2*3 /TK/*+/+E

-#%.#/#0& "%+,W 5TK/*&$?=/ */6 $++/6+ &,:,&/&?; &/?6E

1(0 234,$( 5%+,W


51/97

.//3$n% 6


52/97

9(:-,")N77&/% 78" 67#" 7% .//3$n%

W@

D

1 ?"8'":, %:/8" (% W_U

D F/ N" () k)7):(7; "^(*"):$P ,-"8" )""3% ,/ N" ,a/

:/)%":


53/97

9(:-,")N7


54/97

9(:-,")N7


55/97

66A >7&/ !",7(;%

WW

!""# !""$ !"%" !"%% !"%! !"%&

'()*(+(,- /),(0 !1"2 !1"2 !1"2 %!32 %4$2 %3$2

56(7)6- /8986:8 /),(0 !!2 !!2 !&2 !42 !32 !$2

;)9< =+0> /),(0 4?12 1?#2 1?#2 4?#2 &?%2 3?!2

@8, A998, /),(0 #?32 %"?42 %"?&2 B?"2 &?B2 $?%2

'()*(+(,- CD068 4?1" 4?1" 4?1" &?3# &?#& &?$3

56(7)6- /8986:8 CD068 &?!B &?!# &?&4 &?4! &?1! &?3B

;)9< =+0> CD068 4?!4 4?## 4?$! 4?4& &?11 1?""

@8, A998, CD068 1?"" 1?"" 1?"" 1?"" &?#$ 1?""

!""# !""$ !"%" !"%% !"%! !"%&

=(D


56/97

66A >7&/ 6:/8"% () A/),"^,

WT

!"!

!"$

%"!

%"$

&"!

&"$

'"!

'"$

("!

("$

$"!

&!!) &!!* &!%! &!%% &!%& &!%'

+,-.,/0 1/2-,

113 45/60,789:;5>

113 1,790, =5?? @ AB22CD>E

F-2:8?, 1/2-,

6 , G(;; T @U=I i. 3 y j 6 ' 1;;


57/97

6")7," G(;; T0 @U=I i.//3$y%j 6:/8"% '/8 1;;

A/##


58/97


59/97

E8/N;"#% a(,- G


60/97

TU

66A >"B")


61/97

66A @U=I >"B")


62/97

66A @U=I >"B")


63/97

>"B") H1I1,(12 4"3%7!3&$7 75345"3!$4 $43"!63&&5 %%%34%%3$&% %%&345435"6 %%53&66374&

D

2) @U=U 7)3 @U==P ,-"8" a7% 7) ():8"7%" () E";; *87),%P N


64/97

66A >"B")


65/97

66A E"8:"),7*" >"B")


66/97

J"73:/


67/97

J"73:/


68/97

!(p"8"):"% () K)8/;;#"), !7,7

T]

!"#$%&'() *#++ -./- *#++ -./0 *#++ -./1

234& 5$ &7 8"9"(): /;"*"),% (% ,-" /Y:(7; ")8/;;#"), 37,7P 7)3

a7% 8"?/8,"3 N$ ,-" G/783 () 1?8(; /' @U=R

D

F-" 66A 37,7 (% 7 ?8";(#()78$ -"73:/


69/97

K)8/;;#"), A-7)*"% 7, 66A B%_ H,-"8

A/##


70/97

9FK K)8/;;#"),i/);$ 7B7(;7N;" ,-8/


71/97

6,785 6,7," ?78, /' g= #(;;(/) ?8(b" '/8

(#?8/B"#"), () ?/%,%":/)378$ 7X7()#"), 6,785 6,7," ?8"%% 8";"7%"P H:,/N"8 @[P @U=R

F6$%Y F6$6/ 75l\4 ,*K$%6*/%+8,K #,68 68/ Q"%68/$+6 >8,"

,*1%/$+/ ,* 1"==/3/ &/3%// 8"=&/%+ &)%,*3 68/ K$+6 .")% ;/$%+4n +$,&-$%$ 7E o"*/+4 K%/+,&/*6 ". F6$%Y F6$6/


72/97

6,7," 6-78" /' 2)%,8


73/97

662 ?"8 6,


74/97

F


75/97

L


76/97

F"B")


77/97

1)/,-"8 97:,/80 !(%:/7," /) F


78/97

\]

E8(/8(&"% /' ,-"13#()(%,87&/)0

18" F-"$ G"()* F8


79/97

66A @U=I K^?")%" !(%,8(N


80/97

K^?")%" A7,"*/8$ !"k)(&/)%

]U

!"#$%&'$()" *+,+%(-# )/ $0)#- 10) $-+'02 +'+3-4(' +34("# +%- )&$

5'+3-4(' *&66)%$ 7-+"# +"3 8(9%+%(-#2 53:(#(";

5& +$0,-$('#

!"#$($&$()"+, *&66)%$ @66-% ,-:-, +34("(#$%+$()"

*'0),+%#0(6#A*$&3-"$ 5(37(%-'$ +(3 $) #$&3-"$#

B,+"$ C&(,3(";# +"3 ;%)&"3#

*$&3-"$ *-%:('-# 534(##()"#2 #$&3-"$ )%;#

D-#-+%'0 !"',&3-# -


81/97

K^?")%" !/;;78 !(%,8(N>/+* &02330%"! 30%"#02&1 40"2"0241 402%!0&$1 202!10#2! 10!#40&3"

=*,:6(* =6+?.-6) &04&!0$23 30&!!0$$% 40#3#0!!2 1012&0""" 20$440$21 2034!0"1#

'()*.*,*./(7@ =,>>/+* 201220#$2 20#4%0$&2 #0%1403!1 $0!4$0$$1 %%0"2&021$ %"04410%"2A@7(* &012!0#3# 3011!0!!1 40!3$0321 101!30422 10"3"0"22 401&&03%$

=*,:6(* 9.: 20#330&1" %30&%10"$# !!0&$20#!& !#03#!0 !10!1#0#4& !302&"0%33

A,[email protected] =6+?.-6 !0"2&0233 !0"#30%!$ !01""0##" !0"#%0"1! !0!!$04"% %0#11023%

C6>+6-.7*./( %02#102%# %0#33031$ %0$#404&" !0&2$0##4 !0#$20 &0"2#0%22

9,[email protected]+.6) &03230!4# &0$$$0&32 40%"20"%& 10%$!03&! #0$#10"%& $01&"0331'(*6+6)* " " " 2#10"&& #3"01"" #!302!4

E/*7@ FD>6()6) 430$2&01%" 110##&02#% #10%!$01%4 %"&022302#1 %"$0$01&" %"&0$330$1%

K^?")%" E"8:"),7*" !(%,8(N


82/97

? *

F-" E"8:"), !"B/,"3 ,/ 2)%,8"B")


83/97

1


84/97

67;78("% 7)3 G")"k,%0 2)%,8 ?5078 678719:/ ;


85/97

!7,7 G"-()3 2)%,8

64(47.*) 2) 2 ? /7


86/97

2)%,8)( E F.* E 8+9.0 A&BC44BD", AAB4,$B"7$ !$#C%

D

2)%,8


87/97

!":;()" () 2)%,8


88/97

6/


89/97

L


90/97

@U=IS=R 1B"87*" 67;78("% /' K#?;/$"" Z8/


91/97

E"8:"), A-7)*" () K#?;/$""% 7)3 K)8/;;#"),0

@UU] ,/ @U=R

[=

!"#

"%#

&

'%#

(#

)#

')#

&)#

")#

*)#

%)#

+)#

!)#

()#

,-

./012234/5

67 689:25;

71582 689:25; ?7 689:25;


92/97

A/##(,#"), ,/ 7 {


93/97

A/##(,#"), ,/ 7 {


94/97

[R

67;78("%0

97:


95/97

$ *6/


96/97

F/? @W 13#()(%,87&/) 67;78("%P @U=I =R6/


97/97

A/):;

Final Bunsis Report Stark State

Documents