Approximately 1.4 million emergency department visits per year are for trauma9c brain injuries, which has been thought to underlie a host of problems directly related to neuronal dysfunc9on or death 1, 2 . Different types and severi9es of trauma9c brain injuries (TBI) are differen9ally associated with several neurologic outcomes including seizures, Alzheimer’s demen9a (AD), parkinsonism, Demen’a pugilis’ca (DP), mul9ple sclerosis (MS), amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS), posMrauma9c symptoms, ocular and visual disorders, and endocrine disorders 2 . Data indicates that moderate and severe TBIs increase the risk of demen9a between 2 and 4fold 3 . The terms “punchdrunk” and “slugnuMy” state were first ascribed by Martland et al. in 1928 to describe a neurologic disorder that primarily affected boxers who were exposed to the cumula9ve effects of repe99ve, subconcussive blows to the head 5, 4, 1, 2 . This was successively labeled demen9a pugilis9ca and currently chronic trauma9c encephalopathy (CTE), which are a types of demen9a associated with the high risk factors acquired from mul9ple mild TBIs, as experienced by professional boxers 6 . DP is a collec9on of neurological and neuropsychological symptoms believed to be a result of numerous concussive or subconcussive blows to the head and although most commonly reported in boxers, there have been reports in other sports 6 . DP symptoms emerge anywhere from 7 to 35 years a\er the beginning of a boxer’s career, and manifesta9ons of neurological decline usually do not present un9l a\er a boxer’s career has ended, and worsening may progress over decades 6, 4 . TBI is perhaps the best established environmental risk factor for demen9a. Prevalence is greater in males, individuals of low socioeconomic status, alcohol/drug abusers, and new research is sugges9ng a linkage with the APOEε4 allele 3 . Figure 1A: Famous American professional boxer Muhammad Ali bea9ng Brian London with a knockout punch in 1966 8 . Figure 1B: Brain deteriora9on resul9ng from repe99ve hits to the head 9 . Results from mul9ple studies provide data to indicate a link between suffering mul9ple concussions, regardless of severity, and the development of demen9a or demen9alike symptoms. Despite certain studies proposing that concussions induce earlyonset of demen9a, these results could not be found to be replicable in other studies. The results of this literature review are not surprising because the study findings have been replicated in a variety of other contact sports. Though the skull is naturally designed to protect the brain, it is not built to withstand mul9ple hard impacts to the head 10 . Although analysis methods for the degree of injury in each study varied, they all came to the same result. Based on the results and regarding policy implica9ons, there may be a need in modifying regula9ons to minimize the opportuni9es for injuries. Safeguards such as mandatory res9ng and specialized protec9ve gear for the head should be considered. An outstanding finding was the APOEε4 gene, which predisposes an individual to a higher risk of developing demen9a pugilis9ca. The presence of this gene creates a confounding effect as most of the studies u9lized qualita9ve methods that analyzed cases and controls and disregarded gene9c history. Ethical considera9ons for boxers include pretest scanning for the gene of APOEε4 to assess if there is a heightened risk of contrac9ng DP. Bias And Limita3ons: The literature search was limited to only English text ar9cles from the Medline OVID SP search engine, therefore other suppor9ng or opposing ar9cles were ul9mately not factored into the conclusion of the findings. Furthermore, there appears to be an absence of a standardized study measure in assessing TBIs which may have varied the findings from ar9cle to ar9cle. Among all the possible literature to assess, grey literature were omiMed due to the difficulty in acquiring them within the 9me constraint. The term “Trauma9c Brain Injuries" or "TBI" had mul9ple synonyms such as Demen9a Pugilis9ca, and Chronic Trauma9c Encephalopathy (CTE). Since the literature search was confined to "demen9a" and "pugilis9ca", some instances of CTE may have been omiMed due to the changing of terms throughout 9me. "Pugilis9ca" was in fact, the older term used to define TBIs, but was u9lized as such to address literature searches conducted by each paper. The varia9on in terminology could present a source of informa9on bias in our search strategy. Although samples were chosen on the basis of having TBI, each ar9cle addressed different confounding factors or failed to address extraneous factors that may have caused bias in selec9ng the samples. Felicia Au 1 , Alberto Lee 1 , and Heather Ritchie 1 1 Interdisciplinary School of Health Sciences, Faculty of Health Sciences, University of OMawa, Canada Is there an established associa9on or correla9on between professional boxingrelated cranial injuries and demen9a within studies conducted in the past five years? Search Strategy: A structured literature review was conducted to assess the possible rela9onship between boxingrelated cranial injuries and demen’a pugilis’ca. The literature search was conducted using the Medline Ovid SP database. Inclusion Criteria: Ar9cles with human research containing the keywords “concussion”, “demen9a”, “pugilis9ca”, “boxing”, and “professional”. Exclusion Criteria: Ar9cles published before 2009 were not included in the search and only ar9cles with English text were chosen. Analysis: The abstracts of the resul9ng 54 ar9cles were reviewed by three raters for relevance to the research ques9on, with 100% concurrence. The resul9ng 15 ar9cles were then reviewed by the raters for relevance, again with 100% concurrence. In total, 8 ar9cles were included in the present study. All study types were included that were relevant to the research ques9on. 1 Ling, G.S.F., Marshall, S.A., & Moore, D.F. (2010). Diagnosis and management of trauma9c brain injury. Con’nuum: Lifelong Learning in Neurology 16(6). pp. 2740. 2 Bazarian, J.J., Cernak, I., NobleHaeusslein, L., Potolicchio, S., & Temkin, N. (2009). Longterm neurologic outcomes a\er trauma9c brain injury. Journal of Head Trauma Rehabilita’on 24(6). pp. 439451. 3 Shively, S., Scher, A.I., Perl, D.P., & DiazArras9a, R. (2012). Demen9a resul9ng from trauma9c brain injuries: What is the pathology?. Archives of Neurology, 69(10): pp. 12451251. 4 Mayer, S.A., & Badja9a, N. (2010). Chapter 70: Head Injury. In Rowland, L.P. (Ed.) & Pedley, T.A. (Ed.), MerriL’s Neurology (12th ed.). Philadelphia, PA: LippincoM Williams & Wilkins. 5 Jorge, R., & Robinson, R.G. (2009). 2.5: Neuropsychiatric consequences of trauma9c brain injury. In Sadock, B.J., Sadock, V.A., & Ruiz, P. (Eds.), Kaplan & Sadock’s Comprehensive Textbook of Psychiatry (9th ed.). Philadelphia, PA: LippincoM Williams & Wilkins 6 Noggle, C.A., Dean, R.S., Horton, Jr, A.M. (Eds.). (2012). Demen9a pugilis9ca. In the Encyclopedia of Neuropsychological Disorders (1st ed.). New York, NY: Springer Publishing 7 McCrory, P. (2011). Sports concussion and the risk of chronic neurological impairment. Clinical Journal of Sports Medicine, 21(1): pp. 612. 8 BlaMy, D. (2012, August 7). Muhammad Ali’s Greatest Fights In and Out of the Ring. Retrieved from: hMp://www.biography.com/blog/ muhammadalisgreatestfightsinandoutofthering20906499 9 Shyr, L. (2011, February). The Big Idea: Brain Trauma. Retrieved from: hMp://ngm.na9onalgeographic.com/2011/02/bigidea/concussionstext#closemodal. 10 SpioMa, A.M., Bartsch, A.J., & Benzel, E.C. (2012). Heading in soccer: Dangerous play? Neurosurgery 70(1). pp. 111. 11 Osborn, A.G. (2013). Secondary Effects and Sequelae of CNS Trauma. In Osborn’s: Brain: Imaging, Pathology, and Anatomy (1st ed.). Salt Lake City, UT: Amirsys Publishing, Inc. Limitations • English Text • Human Research • 2009 - Present Initial Search Keywords • Concussion • Dementia • Pugilistica • Boxing • Professional 54 Articles • 3 Researchers Read Abstracts • 100% Concurrence 15 Articles • 3 Researchers Read Articles • 100% Concurrence 8 Articles Background: The Center for Disease Control and Preven9on es9mates that 1.6 to 3.8 million of the trauma9c brain injuries that occur annually in the United States are sportsrelated 3 . Epidemiological studies have suggested a link between cogni9ve decline in the later stages of adulthood and sports concussions received in earlier stages of adulthood. The repe99ve head trauma resul9ng from the many blows a boxer receives in each match may put professional boxers at increased risk of demen’a pugilis’ca (DP) in later life. Purpose/objec9ves: A structured literature review was conducted for the purpose of assessing the rela9onship between boxingrelated cranial injuries and demen9a in later life. Methods: The literature search was conducted using the Ovid SP database, using the keywords “concussion”, “demen9a”, “pugilis9ca”, “boxing”, and “professional”. The search was limited to English text and human research from 2009 to present. Results: The ini9al literature search resulted in 15 relevant ar9cles. A\er careful analysis, only 8 ar9cles we deemed suitable for data extrac9on. Conclusions: The evidence suggests that there may be a correla9on between repe99ve cranial injuries and demen9a in boxers, however there is insufficient evidence to answer the research ques9on. As a result, further research should be conducted to include the implementa9on of a more rigorous standardized set of diagnos9c criteria. Study Yes No Bazarian et al., 2009 ✓ Jorge & Robinson, 2009 Noggle et al., 2012 Stern et al., 2013 McCrory, 2011 Ling, Marshall & Moore 2010 Shively et al., 2012 Osborn, 2014 x The evidence strongly suggests that there is indeed an associa9on between cranial injuries and demen9a, but the limita9ons within all the studies makes it impossible to reach a defini9ve conclusion. Therefore, the insufficient data is unable to answer the research ques9on. This indicates that to establish correla9on, future work should be conducted to include more recent high quality experimental studies as well as the review of grey literature. Moreover, since all the studies reviewed were biased and limited, guidelines should be established to standardize diagnos9c criteria and measurements within studies. For future studies to achieve sta9s9cally significant results, the use of larger sample sizes in longitudinal prospec9ve studies are required as well as more comprehensive procedures for analyzing pa9ents. The appearance of a strong correla9on gives rise to implica9ons for reassessing regula9ons and improving the safety of boxers and other contact sports. Anderson et al. found that 16.67% of concussions were classified as mild, 54.76% were moderate and 28.57% were classified as severe 5 . Another study revealed that 1018% of mild concussion cases, 25% of moderate cases and 33% of severe cases developed demen9alike symptoms 2 . A retrospec9ve study revealed that 29% of demen9a pa9ents reported a history of TBI, when compared to only 3% in the control group 5 . Table 2: Clinical and Pathologic Features Discrimina3ng Between AD and CTE. Abbrevia9ons: AD, Alzheimer disease; CTE, chronic trauma9c encephalopathy; +, mild, ++, moderate, +++, severe; ±, equivocal 4 . Table 1: Associa3on between demen%a pugilis%ca (DP) and boxing related cranial injuries. Summary of studies reviewed in literature review and findings of the presence of an associa9on between boxing and demen9a. Upon analysis, an associa9on was evident in seven out of eight ar9cles. Figure 2: Axial FLAIR (Fluid APenuated Inversion Recovery) scan in a middleaged former professional athlete with earlyonset demen3a. This magne9c resonance imaging shows diffuse bihemispheric volume loss, confluent and punctuate white maMer hyperintensi9es 11 .
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Approximately 1.4 million emergency department visits per year are for trauma9c brain injuries, which has been thought to underlie a host of problems directly related to neuronal dysfunc9on or death1, 2. Different types and severi9es of trauma9c brain injuries (TBI) are differen9ally associated with several neurologic outcomes including seizures, Alzheimer’s demen9a (AD), parkinsonism, Demen'a pugilis'ca (DP), mul9ple sclerosis (MS), amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS), posMrauma9c symptoms, ocular and visual disorders, and endocrine disorders2. Data indicates that moderate and severe TBIs increase the risk of demen9a between 2-‐ and 4-‐fold3. The terms “punch-‐drunk” and “slug-‐nuMy” state were first ascribed by Martland et al. in 1928 to describe a neurologic disorder that primarily affected boxers who were exposed to the cumula9ve effects of repe99ve, subconcussive blows to the head 5, 4, 1, 2. This was successively labeled demen9a pugilis9ca and currently chronic trauma9c encephalopathy (CTE), which are a types of demen9a associated with the high risk factors acquired from mul9ple mild TBIs, as experienced by professional boxers6. DP is a collec9on of neurological and neuropsychological symptoms believed to be a result of numerous concussive or subconcussive blows to the head and although most commonly reported in boxers, there have been reports in other sports6. DP symptoms emerge anywhere from 7 to 35 years a\er the beginning of a boxer’s career, and manifesta9ons of neurological decline usually do not present un9l a\er a boxer’s career has ended, and worsening may progress over decades 6, 4. TBI is perhaps the best established environmental risk factor for demen9a. Prevalence is greater in males, individuals of low socioeconomic status, alcohol/drug abusers, and new research is sugges9ng a linkage with the APOE-‐ε4 allele3.
Figure 1A: Famous American professional boxer Muhammad Ali bea9ng Brian London with a knockout punch in 19668. Figure 1B: Brain deteriora9on resul9ng from repe99ve hits to the head9.
Ø Results from mul9ple studies provide data to indicate a link between suffering mul9ple concussions, regardless of severity, and the development of demen9a or demen9a-‐like symptoms. Despite certain studies proposing that concussions induce early-‐onset of demen9a, these results could not be found to be replicable in other studies. Ø The results of this literature review are not surprising because the study findings have been replicated in a variety of other contact sports. Though the skull is naturally designed to protect the brain, it is not built to withstand mul9ple hard impacts to the head10. Ø Although analysis methods for the degree of injury in each study varied, they all came to the same result. Ø Based on the results and regarding policy implica9ons, there may be a need in modifying regula9ons to minimize the opportuni9es for injuries. Safeguards such as mandatory res9ng and specialized protec9ve gear for the head should be considered. Ø An outstanding finding was the APOE-‐ε4 gene, which predisposes an individual to a higher risk of developing demen9a pugilis9ca. The presence of this gene creates a confounding effect as most of the studies u9lized qualita9ve methods that analyzed cases and controls and disregarded gene9c history. Ø Ethical considera9ons for boxers include pre-‐test scanning for the gene of APOE-‐ε4 to assess if there is a heightened risk of contrac9ng DP. Bias And Limita3ons: Ø The literature search was limited to only English text ar9cles from the Medline OVID SP search engine, therefore other suppor9ng or opposing ar9cles were ul9mately not factored into the conclusion of the findings. Furthermore, there appears to be an absence of a standardized study measure in assessing TBIs which may have varied the findings from ar9cle to ar9cle. Among all the possible literature to assess, grey literature were omiMed due to the difficulty in acquiring them within the 9me constraint. Ø The term “Trauma9c Brain Injuries" or "TBI" had mul9ple synonyms such as Demen9a Pugilis9ca, and Chronic Trauma9c Encephalopathy (CTE). Since the literature search was confined to "demen9a" and "pugilis9ca", some instances of CTE may have been omiMed due to the changing of terms throughout 9me. "Pugilis9ca" was in fact, the older term used to define TBIs, but was u9lized as such to address literature searches conducted by each paper. The varia9on in terminology could present a source of informa9on bias in our search strategy. Ø Although samples were chosen on the basis of having TBI, each ar9cle addressed different confounding factors or failed to address extraneous factors that may have caused bias in selec9ng the samples.
Felicia Au1, Alberto Lee1, and Heather Ritchie1 1Interdisciplinary School of Health Sciences, Faculty of Health Sciences, University of OMawa, Canada
Is there an established associa9on or correla9on between professional boxing-‐related cranial injuries and demen9a within studies conducted in the past five years?
Ø Search Strategy: A structured literature review was conducted to assess the possible rela9onship between boxing-‐related cranial injuries and demen'a pugilis'ca. The literature search was conducted using the Medline Ovid SP database. Ø Inclusion Criteria: Ar9cles with human research containing the keywords “concussion”, “demen9a”, “pugilis9ca”, “boxing”, and “professional”. Ø Exclusion Criteria: Ar9cles published before 2009 were not included in the search and only ar9cles with English text were chosen. Ø Analysis: The abstracts of the resul9ng 54 ar9cles were reviewed by three raters for relevance to the research ques9on, with 100% concurrence. The resul9ng 15 ar9cles were then reviewed by the raters for relevance, again with 100% concurrence. In total, 8 ar9cles were included in the present study. All study types were included that were relevant to the research ques9on.
1Ling, G.S.F., Marshall, S.A., & Moore, D.F. (2010). Diagnosis and management of trauma9c brain injury. Con'nuum: Lifelong Learning in Neurology 16(6). pp. 27-‐40. 2Bazarian, J.J., Cernak, I., Noble-‐Haeusslein, L., Potolicchio, S., & Temkin, N. (2009). Long-‐term neurologic outcomes a\er trauma9c brain injury. Journal of Head Trauma Rehabilita'on 24(6). pp. 439-‐451. 3Shively, S., Scher, A.I., Perl, D.P., & Diaz-‐Arras9a, R. (2012). Demen9a resul9ng from trauma9c brain injuries: What is the pathology?. Archives of Neurology, 69(10): pp. 1245-‐1251. 4Mayer, S.A., & Badja9a, N. (2010). Chapter 70: Head Injury. In Rowland, L.P. (Ed.) & Pedley, T.A. (Ed.), MerriL’s Neurology (12th ed.). Philadelphia, PA: LippincoM Williams & Wilkins. 5Jorge, R., & Robinson, R.G. (2009). 2.5: Neuropsychiatric consequences of trauma9c brain injury. In Sadock, B.J., Sadock, V.A., & Ruiz, P. (Eds.), Kaplan & Sadock’s Comprehensive Textbook of Psychiatry (9th ed.). Philadelphia, PA: LippincoM Williams & Wilkins 6Noggle, C.A., Dean, R.S., Horton, Jr, A.M. (Eds.). (2012). Demen9a pugilis9ca. In the Encyclopedia of Neuropsychological Disorders (1st ed.). New York, NY: Springer Publishing 7McCrory, P. (2011). Sports concussion and the risk of chronic neurological impairment. Clinical Journal of Sports Medicine, 21(1): pp. 6-‐12. 8BlaMy, D. (2012, August 7). Muhammad Ali’s Greatest Fights In and Out of the Ring. Retrieved from: hMp://www.biography.com/blog/ muhammad-‐alis-‐greatest-‐fights-‐in-‐and-‐out-‐of-‐the-‐ring-‐20906499 9Shyr, L. (2011, February). The Big Idea: Brain Trauma. Retrieved from: hMp://ngm.na9onalgeographic.com/2011/02/big-‐idea/concussions-‐text#close-‐modal. 10SpioMa, A.M., Bartsch, A.J., & Benzel, E.C. (2012). Heading in soccer: Dangerous play? Neurosurgery 70(1). pp. 1-‐11. 11Osborn, A.G. (2013). Secondary Effects and Sequelae of CNS Trauma. In Osborn’s: Brain: Imaging, Pathology, and Anatomy (1st ed.). Salt Lake City, UT: Amirsys Publishing, Inc.
Limitations • English Text • Human
Research • 2009 - Present
Initial Search Keywords • Concussion • Dementia • Pugilistica • Boxing • Professional
54 Articles • 3 Researchers
Read Abstracts • 100%
Concurrence
15 Articles • 3 Researchers
Read Articles • 100%
Concurrence 8 Articles
Background: The Center for Disease Control and Preven9on es9mates that 1.6 to 3.8 million of the trauma9c brain injuries that occur annually in the United States are sports-‐related3. Epidemiological studies have suggested a link between cogni9ve decline in the later stages of adulthood and sports concussions received in earlier stages of adulthood. The repe99ve head trauma resul9ng from the many blows a boxer receives in each match may put professional boxers at increased risk of demen'a pugilis'ca (DP) in later life. Purpose/objec9ves: A structured literature review was conducted for the purpose of assessing the rela9onship between boxing-‐related cranial injuries and demen9a in later life. Methods: The literature search was conducted using the Ovid SP database, using the keywords “concussion”, “demen9a”, “pugilis9ca”, “boxing”, and “professional”. The search was limited to English text and human research from 2009 to present. Results: The ini9al literature search resulted in 15 relevant ar9cles. A\er careful analysis, only 8 ar9cles we deemed suitable for data extrac9on. Conclusions: The evidence suggests that there may be a correla9on between repe99ve cranial injuries and demen9a in boxers, however there is insufficient evidence to answer the research ques9on. As a result, further research should be conducted to include the implementa9on of a more rigorous standardized set of diagnos9c criteria.
Study Yes No
Bazarian'et'al.,'2009 ✓
Jorge'&'Robinson,'2009 �
Noggle'et'al.,'2012 �
Stern'et'al.,'2013 �
McCrory,'2011 �
Ling,'Marshall'&'Moore'2010 �
Shively'et'al.,'2012 �
Osborn,'2014
x
Ø The evidence strongly suggests that there is indeed an associa9on between cranial injuries and demen9a, but the limita9ons within all the studies makes it impossible to reach a defini9ve conclusion. Therefore, the insufficient data is unable to answer the research ques9on. This indicates that to establish correla9on, future work should be conducted to include more recent high quality experimental studies as well as the review of grey literature.
Ø Moreover, since all the studies reviewed were biased and limited, guidelines should be established to standardize diagnos9c criteria and measurements within studies. For future studies to achieve sta9s9cally significant results, the use of larger sample sizes in longitudinal prospec9ve studies are required as well as more comprehensive procedures for analyzing pa9ents. The appearance of a strong correla9on gives rise to implica9ons for reassessing regula9ons and improving the safety of boxers and other contact sports.
Ø Anderson et al. found that 16.67% of concussions were classified as mild, 54.76% were moderate and 28.57% were classified as severe5.
Ø Another study revealed that 10-‐18% of mild concussion cases, 25% of moderate cases and 33% of severe cases developed demen9a-‐like symptoms2.
Ø A retrospec9ve study revealed that 29% of demen9a pa9ents reported a history of TBI, when compared to only 3% in the control group5.
Table 2: Clinical and Pathologic Features Discrimina3ng Between AD and CTE. Abbrevia9ons: AD, Alzheimer disease; CTE, chronic trauma9c encephalopathy; +, mild, ++, moderate, +++, severe; ±, equivocal4.
Table 1: Associa3on between demen%a pugilis%ca (DP) and boxing related cranial injuries. Summary of studies reviewed in literature review and findings of the presence of an associa9on between boxing and demen9a. Upon analysis, an associa9on was evident in seven out of eight ar9cles.
Figure 2: Axial FLAIR (Fluid APenuated Inversion Recovery) scan in a middle-‐aged former professional athlete with early-‐onset demen3a. This magne9c resonance imaging shows diffuse bihemispheric volume loss, confluent and punctuate white maMer hyperintensi9es11.
Related Documents
