Top Banner
FAT EMBOLISM AFTER STATIC AND DYNAMIC LOAD , an experimental invest igation. by A.J.M . Sauter, P .J . Klopper, F . van Faassen, J .N . Keeman . Laboratory for experimental surgery of the Un iversity of Amsterdam, The Netherlands. ABSTRACT: Rabbit feora were fractured w ith different stra in rates (stat ic and dynamic) with measurement of the bone marrow pressure . In comparison with prev ious research, th is invest igation easured bone arrow pressure during the actual moent of fractur ing . The results showed that the amount of fat eboli is dependent on the strain rate, and occurs ma inly at the oent of fracture, when elastic strain energy is released in the form of pulse waves. A further group of rabbit feora were subjected to standar ised pulse waves on the bone marrow. The nuber of fat emboli produced is proportional to the strength and number of these waves. Clinica l relevance: High speed accidents tend to produce injuries resulting in the re- lease of fat ebo l i , wh ilst spart injuries do so rarely. Therefore the circustances of trauma lead ing �o long bone fracture shou ld always be evaluated, in v iew of the possible clinica l consequences of fat emboli. For ore than a century the fat ebolis syndrome has been of interest to the traumatologist. Most workers regard the cond it ion as an iportant coplication of fractures, in particular those of the lower limbs. Fat ebolis can be defined as the b lockage of b lood vessels by fat globu les too large to pass through the sma l lest capillaries. Clin ically the class ical syndroe is character ised by a post trau- atic syndroe-free interval of 12 to 36 hours fol lowed by ajor respiratory and cerebral changes , tachycardia, pyrex ia and a cha- racterist ic petech ial rash. Fat embolis is often su bclin ical w ith hypoxaeia as the only feature of pulonary dysfunction (McCarty, 1973; Tachakra, 1975; Shier, 1977; N ixon, 1978, Pollak , 1978) . 248
13

FAT EMBOLISM AFTER STATIC AND DYNAMIC LOAD, · to provoke fat embolism in animal models by inatrogenic fractures. Kuhne (1957) always found fat embolism in post mortem examinations

Aug 04, 2020

Download

Documents

dariahiddleston
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: FAT EMBOLISM AFTER STATIC AND DYNAMIC LOAD, · to provoke fat embolism in animal models by inatrogenic fractures. Kuhne (1957) always found fat embolism in post mortem examinations

FAT EMBOLISM AFTER STATIC AND DYNAMIC LOAD ,

an experimental investigation .

by

A . J . M . Sauter , P . J . Klopper , F . van Faas sen , J . N . Keeman .

Laboratory for experimental surgery of the University of Amsterdam , The Netherlands .

ABSTRACT :

Rabbit fernora were fractured with d i f ferent strain rates ( static and dynamic ) with measurement of the bone marrow pres sure . In compari son with previous research , this inve st igation rneasured bone rnarrow pres sure dur ing the actual mornent of fracturing . The results showed that the amount o f fat ernboli i s dependent on the strain rate , and occurs mainly at the rnornent of fracture , when elastic s train energy i s re leased in the form of pulse wave s . A further group o f rabbi t fernora were s ub j ected to standarised pulse waves on the bone marrow . The nurnbe r of fat embol i produced i s proportional to the strength and number o f these wave s .

C l inical re levance :

H igh speed acc idents tend to produce i n j uries resulting in the re­lease of fat ernboli , whi l s t spart injuries do so rare ly . Therefore the circurnstances of trauma leading �o long bone fracture should always be evaluated , in view of the pos s ible c linical consequences of fat embol i .

For rnore than a century the fat ernbolisrn syndrome has been of interest to the traumato logi s t . Most workers regard the condition as an irnportant cornplication of fractures , in particular those of the lower l imb s . Fat ernbol i srn can be defined as the b lockage o f blood ve ssels by fat globules too large to pass through the smallest capil laries . C l inically the class ical syndrorne is characterised by a post trau­rnatic syndrorne- free interval of 1 2 to 3 6 hours fol lowed by rnaj or respiratory and cerebral changes , tachycardia , pyrexia and a cha­racteristic petechial rash .

Fat embolisrn i s often subc linical with hypoxaernia as the only feature of pulrnonary dys function (McCarty , 1 9 7 3 ; Tachakra , 1 9 7 5 ; Shier , 1 9 7 7 ; N ixon , 1 9 7 8 , Pollak, 1 9 7 8 ) .

248

Page 2: FAT EMBOLISM AFTER STATIC AND DYNAMIC LOAD, · to provoke fat embolism in animal models by inatrogenic fractures. Kuhne (1957) always found fat embolism in post mortem examinations

The pathogenesis of fat embolism is still unc lear . Certain puz z l ing features have stimulated many experimental and c l inical studie s . Thus far there has been no good experimental mode l . Although fat embol ism is mos t ly seen after fractures , mos t investigators use other methods to provoke the syndrome in anima l s . This i s probably due to the fact that the results of fracture are very uncer tai n . I n contras t the inj ection o f depot fat or free fatty acids always produces an a lmos t ins tantaneous syndrome ( Moritz , 1 9 7 2 ; Parker , 1 9 7 4 ; Nylen , 1 9 7 6 ; Hechtman , 1 9 7 8 ) . Another method used to provoke fat embolism i s the inj ec tion o f substances into the medul lary c anal under pressure ( Bloomenthal , 1 9 5 2 ; Cuthbertson , 1 9 6 4 ; Breed , 1 9 6 4 ; Marsman , 1 9 7 5 ) . There has been no inve s ti gations explaining why i t i s so difficult to provoke fat embolism in animal mode ls by i na trogenic fractures . Kuhne ( 1 9 5 7 ) always found fat embo lism in post mortem examinations of cats and dogs which rece ived fracture s in road traffic acc idents .

Review of the c l inical l i terature of fat embo l i sm suggests that the syndrome is usually seen after high speed accidents . It is a common finding in severe road traf fic accidents . ( Sachdeva , 1 9 6 9 ; Saldeen , 1 9 7 0 ; Rokkanen , 1 9 7 0 ; C lout ier , 1 9 7 0 ; Moylan , 1 9 7 7 ) . I t i s rarely seen fol lowing sports i n j uries ( Be z e s , 1 9 7 6 } . I t i s obvious that the rate of de formation of bone can be quite d i f f erent under d i f ferent condition s . The purpos e of the pre sent inve s t igation i s to examine the inf luence of the rate of de forma­tion in mechanical trauma on the gene s i s of f at embolism.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

F i f ty-four rabb its ( Chinchilla and bastards , TNO s train) wei gh ing 1 9 5 0 to 3 1 5 0 gram were used in this s tudy . T e n rabbits were s ub­j ected to femur fractures under standar ised static load ( s tatic group ) . Eighteen rabbits were subjected to femur fractures under s tandarised dynamic load (dynamic group ) . Twenty-s ix rabb its were subj ected to s tandar i sed pulse waves of d i fferent magnitude and durat ion on the bone marrow of the f emur ( pu l s e wave group) .

Anae sthesia was induced by i ntravenous pentobarbital ( 2 0 - 3 0 mg/kg) and maintained by on air-halothane mixture . The femur was partly exposed , to measure the bone marrow pressure and to fix the femur during fracturing in the fracture machine s . A lateral incis ion was made from the trochanter ma jor to the knee j o in t . The fascia lata was d ivided and the i l iotibial tract cut near the lateral femur condyle . The vastus lateralis tract cut near the lateral femur condyle . The vastus lateralis muscle and the ab­ductor crutis lateralis were d ivided by blunt d i s s ection . The qua­dratus femoris muscle was dis sected from the femur over a dis tance of about three cent ime ters and the adductor muscles from about 0 . 5 centimeter . A few millimeters above the lateral femur condyle the per ios teum was s tripped and a hole of 3 , 5 mm diameter wa s hand­dril led through the corte x . A 4 mm self-tapping bone canule ( lumen diameter 2 , 5 mm) was f ixed i n the hole . The bone canula was filled with heparinized physiological saline ( 1 0 0 I , E . /kg Heparine NovoR) and the cortex around the c anula was sprayed with plastic wound

249

Page 3: FAT EMBOLISM AFTER STATIC AND DYNAMIC LOAD, · to provoke fat embolism in animal models by inatrogenic fractures. Kuhne (1957) always found fat embolism in post mortem examinations

R spray ( Nobecutane ) . The bone canula was connected by a l mm poly-e thylene tube to a transducer . Blood pres sures in the carotid artery and j ugular ve in were re­corded by separate transducers .

To produced s tandari s ed femur fractures under static load ( low strain rate ) a Houns field Tensometer ( Al O ) was used. The tens ile pull was converted to compress ion by means o f a compress ion cage ( B l O ) . The rabbi t was placed on a table above the fracture machine and the partly exposed femur was f ixed between three holders in the com­press ion cage so that a three point load was exerted ( d i s tance between each holder 1 5 mm) . A pneurnatically operati ng fracture machine was con s truc ted to produce s tandar i s ed femur fractures under dynamic load ( high strain rate ) . The partly exposed femur was f ixed in the compre s sion cage which was f ixed to a honed cylinder with a piston . The pi ston was propelled via a high pres sure cylinder . In ten rabbits a three point load was exerted and in e ight the f emur was fractured under d irect compress ive force ( for which the femur was f ixed between an oblong holder and a sma l l block ) . The magnitude of the applied force was measured in both fracture machines by a def lection spring beam connected to a transducer .

In the experiments with standarised pulse waves o f d i f ferent mag­ni tude ( and duration ) on the bone marrow a smal l incis ion was rnade over the lateral femur condyle and the i l iotibial tract was cut to screw in the bone canule . A three-way s topcock was placed on the bone canule and connected by l mm poly-ethy lene tubes to the pres sure transducer and a lOcc syringe of glas s . The system was f i l led with phys iological saline with heparini sed sal i ne in the bone canule . The pi ston of the syringe was propel led by a srnall cylinder and piston , which was connected via a valve (Martonair S 2 1 - 1 /c Rol ) and a pre s sure regulator with a high pres sure cylinder . With this system , pulse waves to the bone marrow of any desired magnitude and duration could be g iven .

The s ignal s of the b lood pres sure s , the bone marrow pres sure and the appl ied force were registered on an Elema 1 6 -channel poly­graph recorder . The s i gnal s of the marrow pres sure and the force were also reqistered on an Ampex recorder ( 1 2 0 inch/sec ) , for a more exact analysi s o f the marrow pres sure during the fracturing of the femur .

After the femur was fractured ( static- and dynamic group ) or pressures to the bone marrow were g iven ( pulse wave group) the animals were sacrif iced after one hour with an overdose o f I . V . pentobarbital . The lungs were removed and f ixed i n ten percent buffered formalin . A s l ic e of the left lung was imbedded in paraf­f i n , sectioned at 6 µ and sta ined with heamtoxylineosin and osmium tetra-oxide . In the section o f the lung stained for fat the number o f fat

250

Page 4: FAT EMBOLISM AFTER STATIC AND DYNAMIC LOAD, · to provoke fat embolism in animal models by inatrogenic fractures. Kuhne (1957) always found fat embolism in post mortem examinations

globules was counted in 0 . 5 cm2 ( 7 fields of 0 . 7 1 mm2 , without over lapping of tissue) .

RESULTS

Static group

The f emur was fractured under a static three point load in ten rabbits ( mean weight 2 4 5 1 + 4 2 0 . 6 gram ) . The mean t ime of load appl ication was 5 7 , 7 + 1 9 . 7 seconds ( s train rate 3 . 1 8 mm/min) . The mean force to �ra� ture the femur was 7 2 8 + 2 4 2 . 0 Newton . Dur ing the load appl ication , the marrow pres sure rose s l ightly ( from 1 0 . 7 + 1 1 . 2 to 1 8 . 9 + 1 3 . 6 mm H g ) in most animal s . On the breaking point the marrow pres sure showed i n four animals the e f fects of mechanical shaking with small pul s e waves (max. va lues + 65 and - 75 mm Hg) and in the other animals the marrow pres sure fell more or less ins tant to zero or sub z ero without peak pre ssures . The mean of the maximal positive ( peak ) pressures was 2 5 . 4 + 2 0 . 4 mm Hg and of the maximal negative pre s sures 2 0 . 8 ± 2 8 . 0 mm-Hg ( see table I ) .

TABLE I

at rest +

static load +

breaking point +

af ter breaking +

BONE MARROW PRESSURE mm Hg

STATI C ( n= l O )

1 0 . 7 + l l , 2 -

1 8 , 9 + 1 3 , 6

2 5 . 4 + 2 0 . 4 I - 2 0 . 8 + 2 8 . 0 4 - -7 . 5 + 1 1 . 3 -

After fracturin g , the marrow pre ssure rose in most cases again to positive value s . Figure I shows an example of the bone marrow pres sure under static load . The arterial and venous blood pressures changed l i ttle during the experiments . 2 I n this group only few fat emboli were found ( 8 0 . 4 + 6 6 . 5 per cm ) .

Dynamic group

The f emur was fractured under dynamic three point load in ten rab­bi ts ( dynarnic I ) . The meantime o f load appl ication was 0 . 1 5 6 + 0 . 0 7 8 . second s . The mean force to fracture the femur was 7 2 8 +

-2 7 2 . 4

Newton . Dur ing the appl ication o f the force the bone marrow pres sure rose s l ightly from 1 9 . 6 + 1 5 . 8 to 28 ± 17 mm Hg ) in most animals as under static load . Ön the breaking point the marrow pressures showed the e f fects of mechanical shak ing in all animals with some­t imes high peak pres sures (max . values + 7 0 0 and - 1 1 3 8 mm Hg) .

251

Page 5: FAT EMBOLISM AFTER STATIC AND DYNAMIC LOAD, · to provoke fat embolism in animal models by inatrogenic fractures. Kuhne (1957) always found fat embolism in post mortem examinations

FI GURE I

a r t e r i a l b l o od p r e s s u r e

h o n e marrow pre s s u r e

v e n o u s b l o o d p r e s s u r e

r e s p i r a t i o n

f o r c e

STATIC LOAD

b r e a k i n g p o i n t

-�-� - --- - --=l ·- ---·--i

The mean of the maximal pos i t ive peak pres sures was 2 4 9 . 1 ± 2 0 7 , 5 mm Hg and o f the maximal negative peak pres sure s 2 1 4 . 8 + 3 3 0 . 6 mm Hg. After fracturing the marrow pres sure remained negative in most cases ( see Table I I ) .

TABLE I I BONE PRESS URE mm HG

DYNAMIC I (n=lO ) DYNAMIC II (n=8)

at rest + 19 . 6 + 15 . . a + 10 , 4 + 9 . 0 - -

dynamic load + . 28 .0 + 17 . 0 + 1 1 . 2 + 9 . 4 - -

breaking point + 249 . 1 + 207 . 5/-214 , 8 + 330 . 6 + ll5 . 4 + 4 8 . 9/-lll . 8 + 76 . 6 - - - -

af ter breaki ng + 2 . 3 + 48 . 8 1 . 0 + 2 . 7 - -

252

Page 6: FAT EMBOLISM AFTER STATIC AND DYNAMIC LOAD, · to provoke fat embolism in animal models by inatrogenic fractures. Kuhne (1957) always found fat embolism in post mortem examinations

F IGURE I I

bo n e marrow pres sure

force

DYNAMIC :.OAD

1-'+ l �! � + ! .. ' :��� ·i-= �� !=!rn ���' : ' 1 ' : ·-r-" ; . ' 1 i : ; i· . ;···-1:·: �--r---� -· i-·---r:- j ·-·1- · ·:- -r-- ! j_: 1: ', ·.' ;_ .• 1 . . 1 ;- . , • „ ' 1 '. 1 . . f=· ; . :r !·--·+-·' ·f-:--+ ··· ·- t -- · . '. . -c- - � - -- +--· -·:--·· · t . . . L�-� • • 1

• • •• --+.--! : : ; ; . . : ' ' -- -t--·t---:- ·: -·- ., -----: . -- . . --·-:---�: ·---'- -1-��----i--,-- -- - � ---;__ --; -�---;---! - ---7---

· : -· ;· _ __ . ! _ _ _ ; ___ � -- -- ----·· -·-------___, __ _

. ! ; - -- .- -. - r-; ·-·;-- ··

----! . _,_ --lt'I++-----.,__

..;. . ! : :

;- -. .. L-. . -

b r e a k i n g p o i n t

F igure I I shows a n example of the bone marrow pres s ure under dy­namic load . The arterial blood pressure showed a s l i ght fall in a l l animal s ( 1 1 . 6 + 8 . 6 ) with a maximum 4 to 1 0 s econds a fter fracturing , .but returned to baseline values in mos t cases and sornetimes to higher values after 5 to 30 seconds . The venous b lood pres sure changed l i ttle during the experiments . 2 I n this group fat emboli were nurnerous ( 5 34 . 2 + 6 7 4 . 8 per cm ) . The femur was fractured under dynarnic d irect cÖmpress ive load in e ight rabbits ( dynamic I I ) . The mean t ime of load application was 0 . 1 5 9 + 0 . 0 4 second s . The mean force was 7 3 4 . 8 + 9 8 . 5 Newton . The changes in bone marrow pres sure dur ing fracturing under dynarnic direct compress ion loads were as under dynarnic thre e point loads , but the pulse waves were less force full ( + 1 1 5 . 4 ± 4 8 . 9 /- 1 1 1 . � ± 7 6 . 6 mm Hg) . The nurnber of fat emboli was 6 0 . 5 ± 4 5 . 0 1 per cm .

F igure I I I shows the mean force , the rnean ( pos itive) peak pres sure at breaking point and the mean f at ernboli count under static and dynarnic load .

253

Page 7: FAT EMBOLISM AFTER STATIC AND DYNAMIC LOAD, · to provoke fat embolism in animal models by inatrogenic fractures. Kuhne (1957) always found fat embolism in post mortem examinations

F IGURE I I I

Pulse wave group

Twenty-six rabbits

IMP emtv; N mmHg Am2

1000 500 500

500 250 250

0 0 0

were sub j ected the bone rnarrow. This group can be

A 5 pulse waves o f 1 5 mm Hg ( n=3 )

B 5 pulse waves o f 1 5 0 mm Hg ( n= 3 )

c 5 or 1 0 pulse wave s of 5 0 0 mm Hg

STATIC OYNAMIC I OYNAMIC II CONTROL

to standar i s ed pulse waves on divided a s follows :

( 2 X n=5 )

D 5 or 1 0 pulse waves of 1 0 0 0 mm Hg ( 2 X n=5 ) .

I n subgroup A and B only few fat ernbol i were found ( 2 3 . 3 ± 1 1 and 1 2 6 . 6 · + 1 3 6 . 3 per crn2 ) . The arterial and venous b lood pre s sure s rernained unchanged during the experirnents . I n subgroup C few ernboli were found i f 5 pulse waves were given ( 4 4 . 4 + 3 6 . 3 per crn2 ) , but with 10 pulse wave s fat ernbol i were nurnerous ( 6 4 1 . 8 + 6 58 . 9 per crn2 ) in three anirnals . I n the whole subgroup the arterial blood pres sure showed a sharp fall ( s ee f igUre IV) after 5 to 1 5 seconds after the first pulse wave , but

254

Page 8: FAT EMBOLISM AFTER STATIC AND DYNAMIC LOAD, · to provoke fat embolism in animal models by inatrogenic fractures. Kuhne (1957) always found fat embolism in post mortem examinations

re turned to base l i ne values after 5 to 3 0 seconds . I n subgroup D fat ernboli were nurnerous when 5 pulse waves were g iven ( 2 8 5 7 . 6 + 5 7 4 . 7 per crn2 ) and when ten pulse waves were g iven the nurnber of Iat ernbol i was s t i l l h i gher ( 4 4 7 5 . 6 ± 1 6 3 5 . 2 per crn2 ) All an irnals showed a sharp fall i n arterial b lood pres sure ( see f igure IV) after 10 to 1 8 0 seconds after the first pulse wave .

FIGURE IV

R R 500 R R 1000 mmHg • = 5X mm Hg • = 5X

150 O = 10X 150 o=10X

i 1 • 0 � • • • • • • 100 0 � 0 100 8

0 0 0 0 • 0 • • � 0 •

� 0 0 0 0 0 • • •

50 0 50 0

• 0 • •

0 0 •eooo ttt'tt a b c a b c

a - a t re s t ; b - 5 t o 1 5 s e c . after pu l s e w a v e ;

c - after 6 0 s e c .

Five animal s d i ed , but i n the other cases the arterial b lood pres­sures rose the basel i ne values after 1 to 9 rninutes . At the rnornen t that the arterial b lood pressure fell the venous blood pres sure rose in all anirnals and did not re turn to baseline values during the whole exper irnent ( one hour ) . Five anirnals suffered a respiratory arrest , but two started breathing again after sorne minutes . All animals were cyanotic and the ir ear ve ins were d i lated .

255

Page 9: FAT EMBOLISM AFTER STATIC AND DYNAMIC LOAD, · to provoke fat embolism in animal models by inatrogenic fractures. Kuhne (1957) always found fat embolism in post mortem examinations

F I GURE V MARROW PRESSURE AND FAT EMBOLI COUNT

I M P mm H g 1000

500

0

emb/ /cm2

5000

2500

0 5X

5 x = 5 p u l s e w a v e s

1 0 x = 1 0 pu l s e wav e s

10X 5 X 10X

256

Page 10: FAT EMBOLISM AFTER STATIC AND DYNAMIC LOAD, · to provoke fat embolism in animal models by inatrogenic fractures. Kuhne (1957) always found fat embolism in post mortem examinations

DISCUSS ION

Al though bone rnarrow pres sure had been rneasured in fractured lirnbs ( Bloornentha l , 1 9 5 2 ; Rhern, 1 9 5 7 ; We inberg , 1 9 7 3 } , the changes in bÖne rnarrow pres sure during fracturing under static and dynarnic load has never been inve stigated . This is probab ly partly due to certain concepts of the pathogenes i s of fat emboli and partly to techn ical diff iculties of measuring the marrow pres sure during fracturing . Mos t authors found a negative marrow pres sure in frac­tured bones , so that entry of fat embol i in the b lood a fter frac­tures seemed to be unlikely.

We were interested i n the c hange s in bone marrow pres sure during fracturing . To produce standari sed fracture s under static and dynamic load i n v i vo we used f racture machines and we had no pro­blems in measuring the marrow pres sure dur ing fracturing .

After fracturing under static load the marrow pre s sure f ell quickly to zero or subzero and in some rabbits small pulse waves were seen dur i ng frac turing. I n this group only few fat emboli were found . During fracturing under dynamic load , the marrow pressure always showed the effects of re lat ive ly forceful pu lse waves and in this group numerous fat ernboli were seen . The d i fference between the static and dynamic load groups are s ignificant (p � 0 . 0 5 ) .

When a bone i s loaded , energy will be stored in the bone during the de formation as elas tic strain energy , and energy will be diss ipated as plastic strain energy. When a bone break s , only the elastic s train is freed at once in the form of an explosion . Bone is visco elastic material and its mechanical properties are affected by the rate of de formation ( Evans , 1 9 7 3 ; Re i l ly , 1 9 7 4 ; Carter , 1 9 7 8 ; Park , 1 9 7 9 ) . With increasing rate of de formation the strength and stiffness increases , wµile the total strain be fore fai lure decreases (McElhany , 1 9 6 6 ; Pan j abi , 1 9 7 3 ; Asang , 1 9 7 5 ; Evans , 1 9 7 3 ) . Not only the total strain decreases , but also the plastic strain decreases with increasing rate of de formation (Sedlin , 1 9 6 5 ; Currey , 1 9 7 5 ) .

The important fact i s that the total energy absorbing capacity also increases with increasing rate of de formation . D i f ferent authors found an increase of energy absorb ing capacity varyi ng from 4 5 % to 5 0 0 % by i ncreasing the rate of de formation . (Huelke , 1 9 6 7 ; Mather , 1 9 6 8 ; Sammarco , 1 9 7 1 , Pan j abi , 1 9 7 3 ) .

This together with the decrease of the plastic strain must be the explanation for the fact that we found a more forceful explosion with f rac tur ing under dynamic load than under static load . When the f emur was f ractured under dynamic load the f orce of the ex­plos ions showed a wide variation , but there is a s i gn i f icant (p < 0 . 0 5 ) corre lation between the force of the explosion and the

number of fat embo l i . However , we found less force ful explos ions and l e s s fat emboli with fracturing under direct compres s ive dynami c load than under three point dynamic load . The explanation for this is that the bone is less strong and stif f in a transverse direction than in a

257

Page 11: FAT EMBOLISM AFTER STATIC AND DYNAMIC LOAD, · to provoke fat embolism in animal models by inatrogenic fractures. Kuhne (1957) always found fat embolism in post mortem examinations

longitudinal direction ( bone is an anisotropic material ) .

In the experiments with s tandar ised pulse waves on the marrow we measured the pressures neces sary for marrow de struc tion and e j ect­ion of i ts elements into the c irculation . With puls e waves of about 5 0 0 mm Hg repeated for a short duration ( 5 x ) few fat emboli were found. When the se pulse waves were repeated 10 time s , fat emboli were numerous in three animals , suggestin g that the critical factor in d isorgan i sation and e j ection of marrow e l ements is the duration of the applied forces � when they are of this magni tude . At higher pres sures ( 1 0 0 0 mm H g ) large numbers of fat emboli were always obtained . H igh pressures of long durati on ( 1 0 x ) produced more emboli than short durati on ( 5 x ) pre ssure s . The generation of fat ernboli is thus dependent on both , the strength and durat ion of the distorting forc e s . Comb ination of the data of the fracture experi­rnents and the experiments with the pulse waves shows that embolisa­t ion of bone marrow occurs at the moment of fracture , but not during loading when bone marrow pres sure rises l i ttle . The di agrams of the bone marrow pre ssure and force sugge st that the rise during load ing i s not the result of compress ion of the bone marrow . The mechanism i ncreasing the bone marrow pres sure during load ing is probably of neurological origin . Extraprolation o f our animal data to humans suggests that the inherent s tres ses produced by relative ly low strain rat�, produce explosions at the t ime of fracture which are suf ficient to release fat emboli i nto the circulation . The mechanical properties o f human tibiae and femura are such that the explosion forces in low strain rate fracture will be much greater than in rabb i ts . These emboli are rare ly sufficient in number to produce c linical symptoms . On the otherhaBd in h igh strain rate fractures large numbers of fat emboli can be produced to give the c l inical syndrome of fat em­bolisation .

Published evidence shows a pos i tive corre lat ion between the strain rate and the presence of fracture comminution ( Huelke , 1 9 6 7 ; Cooke , 1 9 6 9 ; Brook s , 1 9 7 0 ; Stalnaker , 1 9 7 6 ) . Our exper iments showed a similar corre lation between strain rate and explosion force . I t seems reasonable to equate comminution with explosion force . Thus rad iographi c evidence o f fracture comminution should alert the radiologist to the possibil ity of fat embol ism, part icularly if there are other c l inical and radiological signs present .

. · . 258

Page 12: FAT EMBOLISM AFTER STATIC AND DYNAMIC LOAD, · to provoke fat embolism in animal models by inatrogenic fractures. Kuhne (1957) always found fat embolism in post mortem examinations

REFERENCES

ASANG , E . , Biomechanik des Beins in der Skitraumato logi e . Ms ch . Unfallhei lkunde , 1 9 7 5 , 2 7 8 ; 5 8 . BEZES , H . , JULLIARD , R . e t al� Les accidents d u s k i a propos d ' une statist ique de 5 2 0 0 observation s . Ann . Chi r . 1 9 7 6 , 3 0 ; 5 8 3 . BLOOMENTHAL , E . D . -,-ALSON , W . H . , NECKELES , H . S tud ies on the bone marrow of the dog : fat embolism and marrow pres sure . S . G . O . , 1 9 5 2 , 1i; 2 1 5 . BREED , A . L . Experimental product ion of vascular hypotens ion , bone marrow and fat embo lism with methylme thacrylate cement . Cl i n . Orth . and Related Research , 1 9 7 4 , 1 0 2 ; 2 2 7 . BROOKS , D . B . The biomechanics o f torsionar-fracture s , the stress concentration e f fect of a dull hole . J . Bone Joint Surg . , 1 9 7 0 , 5 2 A ; 5 0 7 . CARTER , D . R . , SPENGLER , D . M . Mechanical properties and composition of cortical bone . Basic Sci ence and Patho logy Section I I I , 1 9 7 8 , 1 3 5 . CLOUTIER , C . T . Fat embolism i n Vie tnam battle . Casualties in haemorrhagic shock , 1 9 70 , 1 3 5 ; 3 6 9 . COOKE , W . F . , NAGEL , D . A . Biomechanical ana lysis o f the knee impact . Con g. Proc . 1 3 th S tapp , 1 9 6 9 , 1 1 7 . CUTHBERTSON , E . M . , GILF I LLAN , R . S . , BACKMAN , R . P . Spontaneous and induced variations in bone marrow pre ssure i n the dog . Ang iology , 1 9 6 4 , 1 5 ; 1 4 5 . CURRE Y , J . D . The me chanical properties o f bone t i s sue in chi ldren . J . Bone Joint Surg. 1 9 7 5 , 5 7 A ; 8 1 0 . EVANS , F . G . Mechanical properties o f bone . Spring f i e ld I l l inoi s , C . C . Thomas , 1 9 7 3 . HECHTMAN , H , B . , LONERGAN , E . A . e t al . Pulmonary entrapment o f plate­lets during acute respiratory fai lure . Surgery , 1 9 7 8 , l; 2 7 7 . HUELKE , D . F . , BORGE , L . J . , HARGER , J . H ; Bone fractures produced by high veloc i ty impacts . Am . J . Anat . , 1 9 6 7 , 1 2 0 ; 1 2 3 . MARSMAN , A . J . W . , KLOPPER, P . J . et a l . Acryl beencemen t en circu­latiestoorni ssen . Ned . Tijdscr . v . Genees k . , 1 9 7 5 , 1 1 9 ; 8 5 6 . MATHER , B . S . Observations o f the e f fects o f s tatic and impact loading on the human femur . J . Biomech . , 1 9 6 8 , l ; 3 3 1 . McCarty , B . , MANNEN� E . et al . Subcli nical fat ernbolism: a pros­pective s tudy of 50 patients with extremity f ractures . J . of Trauma , 1 9 7 3 , 1 3 , l ; 9 . McE lhany , J . H . Dynamic response of bone and muscle t i ssue . J . Appl . Phys iol . , 1 9 6 6 , 2 1 ; 1 2 3 1 . MORIT Z , E . , BORDER , J . R . e t a l . Experimental pulmonary fat emboli sm. Arch. Surg . , 1 9 7 2 , 1 0 5 ; 2 7 5 . MOYLAN , J . A . , KATZ , J\:"" , EVUSON , M . A . Fat emboli syndrome . J . of Trauma , 1 9 7 6 , l.§_; 3 4 1 . NIXON , J . R . , BROCKE-UTNE , J . G . Free fatty acid and arterial oxygen changes fol lowing ma jor i n j ury. J . of Trauma , 1 9 7 8 , lb ; 2 3 .

259

Page 13: FAT EMBOLISM AFTER STATIC AND DYNAMIC LOAD, · to provoke fat embolism in animal models by inatrogenic fractures. Kuhne (1957) always found fat embolism in post mortem examinations

NYLEN , S . , SYLVEN , C . Induced fat embolism in rabbits by means o f radio-actively labe lled fat . Acta Chir. Scand . , 1 9 7 6 , 1 4 2 ; 3 6 1 . PANJAB I , M . M. Mechanical properties o f bone a s a function of rate of d e formation . J . Bone Joint Surg . , 1 9 7 3 , 5 5 A ; 3 2 2 . PARK , J . B . Biomaterial s , an introduction . Plenum Pre s s , New York and London , 1 9 7 9 . PARKER , F . B . Hemodynamic and pathological findings i n experimental f at embolism. Arch. Surg . , 1 9 7 4 , 1 0 8 ; 7 0 . POLLAK , R . , MYERS , R . A . M . Early d iagnosis o f the fat embolism syndrom. J . of Trauma , 1 9 7 8 , 1 8 ; 1 2 1 . REILLY , D . T . , BURSTEIN , A. H . The mechanical properties o f cortical bone . Review article . J . Bone Joint Surg . , 1 9 7 4 , 5 6 A ; 1 0 0 1 . RHEM, J . Experimente lle Untersuchungen zur Ents tehung der Fett Embolie beim Knochebruch . Dtch. Z schr . Chir . , 1 9 5 7 , 2 8 5 ; 2 3 0 . ROKKANEN , R . The syndrom of"fat embolism: analy s i s o f thirty consecutive cases compared to trauma patients with s imi l ar injurie s . J . of Trauma , 1 9 7 0 , 1 0 ; 2 9 9 . SACHDEVA , H . S . Fat embo lism : an experimental s tudy ( parts I and I I ) Am . Surg . , 1 9 6 9 , 3 5 ; 2 5 0 . SALDEEN , T . Fat embolism and s igns o f intravascular coagulation in post traumatic autop s ie material . J . of Trauma , 1 9 7 0 , 1 0 ; 2 7 3 . SAMMARCO , G . J . , BURSTEIN , A . H . e t a l . The biome chanics o f torsional fracture s : the e f fect of loading on ultimate properties . J . Biomech. , 1 9 7 1 , 4 ; 1 1 3 . SEDLIN , E . D . A rheoiogical mod e l for cortical bone . Acta Orthop. Scand . , 1 9 6 5 , sup . 8 3 . STALNAKER , R . L . , MELVIN , J . W . Human tolerance to lower extremities impact s . I rcobi , 1 9 7 6 ; 3 6 2 . SHIER , M . R . , WILSON , R . F . et a l . Fat embolism prophylaxi s : a study of four treatment modali tie s . J . o f Trauma , 1 9 7 7 , 1 7 ; 6 2 1 . TACHAKRA , s . s . , SEVITT , S . Hypoxaemia after fractures . J . Bone Joint Surg . , 1 9 7 5 , 57B ; 1 9 7 . WEINBERG , H . , FINSTERBUSH , A . , ROSEMANN , E . Experimental pulmonary fat embolism produced by blunt trauma to bone . I srae l J . Med . S e i . , 1 9 7 3 , � ; 1 0 4 8 .

260