Top Banner
7/30/2019 Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fair-defense-law-dec-2011-tidc 1/76  1<>> FNEQ GIFI@]I DNR \qi|nqig au woi 
76

Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

Apr 04, 2018

Download

Documents

paceminterris
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

7/30/2019 Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fair-defense-law-dec-2011-tidc 1/76

 

1<>> FNEQ GIFI@]I DNR\qi|nqig au woi 

Page 2: Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

7/30/2019 Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fair-defense-law-dec-2011-tidc 2/76

e

WNADI CF MC@WI@W] 

MCGI CF MQEKE@ND \QCMIGYQI 

MON\WIQ C@I8 BI@IQND \QCVE]EC@]  Nqw. >.<9>. Qebow wc Qi|qi}i`wnwec` au Mcy`}id…………………………………………….. >

MON\WIQ IDIVI@8 ONAIN] MCQ\Y] Nqw. >>.<2>. \qcmigyqi e` Ginwo \i`ndwu Mn}i…………………………………………….. 9

MON\WIQ FCYQWII@8 NQQI]W REWOCYW RNQQN@W  Nqw. >7.<6. Ky}w wnji Cffi`giq aifcqi Knbe}wqnwi…………………………………………... . >1

MON\WIQ FEFWII@8 NQQI]W Y@GIQ RNQQN@W Nqw. >9.>2. Gywei} cf Nqqi}we b Cffemiq n`g Knbe}wqnwi………………………………………. >=

 Nqw. >9.>?. Nqqi}w fcq Cyw+cf+Mcy`wu Cffi`}i …………………………………………………>9

MON\WIQ ]IVI@WII@8 ANED  Nqw. >2.<=1. Qidin}i c` \iq}c`nd Ac`g cf Miqwne` Ki`wnddu Edd Gifi`gn`w} ………………>6 Nqw. >2.<==. Qidin}i c` Ac`g cf Miqwne` \iq}c`} Nqqi}wig rewocyw n Rnqqn`w…..……….>2

MON\WIQ WRI@WU ]E_8 NQQNEB@KI@W  Nqw. 16.<>. Nqqneb`ki`w ………………………………………………………………………… >? Nqw. 16.<>>. Rneviq cf Nqqneb`ki`w ……………………………………………………………>? Nqw. 16.<1. \yq|c}i cf Nqqneb`ki`w ……………………...……………………………………>? Nqw. 16.<=. Weki cf Nqqneb`ki`w………………………...……………………………………... >? Nqw. 16.<7. \qcmigyqi} fcq N||ce`we`b Mcy`}id……..……………………………………….. >? Nqw. 16.<77. \yadem Gifi`giq ‟} Cffemi……………………………………………………….… 1= Nqw. 16.<79. \yadem Gifi`giq Cviq}ebow Acnqg…..…………………………………………… 1= Nqw. 16.<72. Kn`nbig N}}eb`ig Mcy`}id \qcbqnk………………………………………….. 12 Nqw. 16.<9. Mck|i`}nwec` cf Mcy`}id N||ce`wig wc Gifi`g………………………………...1? Nqw. 16.<9>. E`gebi`w E`knwi Gifi`}i…………………………………………………………. =< Nqw. 16.<91. N||ce`wki`w cf Mcy`}id e` Ginwo \i`ndwu Mn}i: Qiekayq}iki`w cf E`vi}webnwevi Ix|i`}i}………………………………………………………………………….. =>

 Nqw. 16.<96. Mc`wqeaywec` fqck ]wnwi e` Miqwne` Mcy`wei} …………………………………...=7 Nqw. 16.<92. Mc}w cf Ik|dcuki`w cf Mcy`}id fcq Miqwne` Ke`cq}…………………………...=7 Nqw. 16.<6. Idimwig Cffemend} `cw wc ai N||ce wig…………………………………………….. =7 Nqw. 16.<2. @nki n} }wnwig e` E`gemwki`w……………………………………………………... =7 Nqw. 16.<?. Ef Gifi`gn`w ]ybbi}w} Geffiqi`w @nki…………………………………………... =7 Nqw. 16.<5. Ef Nmmy}ig Qify}i} wc Bevi oe} Qind @nki……………………………………...=7 Nqw. 16.><. Roiqi @nki e} Y`j`cr`…………………………………………………………. =7 Nqw. 16.>>. E`gemwki`w Qing……………………………………………………………………. =7 Nqw. 16.>1. \din cf @cw Byedwu I`wiqig………………………………………………………… =9 Nqw. 16.>=. \din cf Byedwu………………………………………………………………………...=9 Nqw. 16.>7. Hyqu c` \din cf Byedwu………………………………………………………………. =9

Page 3: Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

7/30/2019 Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fair-defense-law-dec-2011-tidc 3/76

 

ee

 Nqw. 16.>9. Mcqqimwe`b @nki…………………………………………………………………… =6

MON\WIQ WOEQWU+IEBOW8 IVEGI@MI E@ MQEKE@ND NMWEC@]  Nqw. =?.=<. E`wiq|qiwiq…………………………………………………………………………… =6 Nqw. =?.=>. E`wiq|qiwiq} fcq Ginf \iq}c`}……………………………………………………... =6

MON\WIQ FCQWU+WRC8 HYGBKI@W N@G ]I@WI@MI  Nqw. 71.>1 Mckky`ewu ]y|iqve}ec`…………………………………………………….……… =2

FNKEDU MCGI

MON\WIQ FEFWU+C@I8 BI@IQND \QCVE]EC@] ]im. 9>.><. Qebow wc N}}e}wn`mi cf Nwwcq`iu: Mck|i`}nwec`……………………………….. =?]im. 9>.><>. N||ce`wki`w cf Nwwcq`iu n`g Mc`we`ynwec` cf Qi|qi}i`wnwec`………………7<]im. 9>.><1. N||ce`wki`w cf Mcy`}id \dn`…………………………………………………...7<

BCVIQ@KI@W MCGI 

MON\WIQ ]IVI@WU+C@I8 BI@IQND \QCVE]EC@] ]im. 2>.<<>. Gife`ewec`}………………………………………………………………………… 7>

MON\WIQ ]IVI@WU+IEBOW8 MN\EWND RQEW] MCKKEWWII N@G CFFEMI CF MN\EWNDRQEW]

]yamon|wiq N. Mn|ewnd Rqew} Mckkewwii]im. 2?.<<>. Gife`ewec`}………………………………………………………………………… 71]im. 2?.<<1. I}wnade}oki`w cf Mckkewwii: Gywei}…………………………………………...71]im. 2?.<<=. N||ce`wki`w n`g Mck|c}ewec` cf Mckkewwii………………………………… 71]im. 2?.<<7. Qimckki`gnwec` n`g N||ce`wki`w cf Geqimwcq cf Cffemi cf Mn|ewnd Rqew}… 7=]yamon|wiq A. Cffemi cf Mn|ewnd Rqew}]im. 2?.<9>. Gife`ewec`}………………………………………………………………………… 7=]im. 2?.<91. I}wnade}oki`w: Fy`ge`b…………………………………………………………. 7=]im. 2?.<9=. Geqimwcq: ]wnf f…………………………………………………………………….. 7=]im. 2?.<97. \criq} n`g Gywei}………………………………………………………………. 77]im. 2?.<99. Mck|i`}nwec` cf Cwoiq N||ce`wig Nwwcq`iu}………………………………… 77]im. 2?.<96. N||ce`wki`w De}w…………………………………………………………………. 77

MON\WIQ ]IVI@WU+@E@I8 WI_N] E@GEBI@W GIFI@]I MCKKE]]EC@ ]yamon|wiq N. Bi`iqnd \qcve}ec`}]im. 25.<<>. Gife`ewec`}………………………………………………………………………… 79]im. 25.<<1. I}wnade}oki`w cf Mckke}}ec`………………………………………………… 79]yamon|wiq A. Ngke`e}wqnwevi \qcve}ec`}]im. 25.<>>. I}wnade}oki`w cf Acnqg: Mck|c}ewec`………………………………………… 76]im. 25.<>1. Iximywevi Geqimwcq ……………………………………………………………….. 76]im. 25.<>=. Ix Cffemec Kikaiq}……………………………………………………………… 76]im. 25.<>7. N||ce`wki`w}…………………………………………………………………….. 76]im. 25.<>9. \qi}ege`b Cffemiq …………………………………………………………………. 72

Page 4: Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

7/30/2019 Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fair-defense-law-dec-2011-tidc 4/76

 

eee

]im. 25.<>6. Ge}mdc}yqi Qi~yeqig……………………………………………………………… 72]im. 25.<>2. Vnmn`mei}………………………………………………………………………… 72]im. 25.<>?. Kiiwe`b}: ^ycqyk: Vcwe b……………………………………………………… 72]im. 25.<>5. Mck|i`}nwec`…………………………………………………………………… 72]im. 25.<1<. Ekky`ewu fqck Denaedewu………………………………………………………….. 72

]im. 25.<1>. Qydi}……………………………………………………………………………… 72]yamon|wiq M. Bi`iqnd \criq} n`g Gywei} cf Mckke}}ec`]im. 25.<=>. Fneq Gifi`}i Nmmcy`w…………………………………………………………… 7?]im. 25.<=1. Nmmi|wn`mi cf Befw}$ Bqn`w}$ n`g Cwoiq Fy`g}: ]wnwi Bqn`w} Wink………. 7?]im. 25.<==. Ngke`e}wqnwevi Nwwnmoki`w: ]y||cqw: Aygbiw…………………………………. 7?]im. 25.<=7. \cdemei} n`g ]wn`gnqg}…………………………………………………………..7?]im. 25.<=9. Mcy`wu Qi|cqwe`b \dn`: Mckke}}ec` Qi|cqw}………………………………... 75]im. 25.<=6. E`gebi`w Gifi`}i E`fcqknwec`………………………………………………….. 9<]im. 25.<=2. Wimo`emnd ]y||cqw: Bqn`w}……………………………………………………… 9>]im. 25.<=5. Ixc`iqnwec` Qi|cqw……………………………………………………………… 9>

DCMND BCVIQ@KI@W MCGI

MON\WIQ C@I OY@GQIG WOEQWU+WOQII8 MQEKE@ND N@G MEVED FII] \NUNADI WCWOI MCK\WQCDDIQ

]im. >==.><1. Mc`}cdegnwig Fii} c` Mc`vemwec`……………………………………………..91]im. >==.><2. Fii fcq ]y||cqw cf E`gebi`w Gifi`}i Qi|qi}i`wnwec`……………………….9=

WI_N] NGKE@E]WQNWEVI MCGI

Wewdi >8 Ngke`e}wqnwec`

\nqw ?8 Hygemend Mcy`med

MON\WIQ C@I OY@GQIG N@G ]IVI@WU+WOQII8 E@GEBI@W GIFI@]I BQN@W]]yamon|wiq N8 Bi`iqnd Fy`ge`b \qcbqnk \qcve}ec`}]im. >2=.><>. N||demnaedewu.……………………………………………………………………..9=]im. >2=.><1. Gife`ewec`}……………………………………………………………………….. 9=]im. >2=.><=. \qcmi}} fcq ]yakewwe`b N||demnwec`} f cq Bqn`w} n`g Cwoiq Fy`g}…………97]im. >2=.><7. Bqn`w Qi}cdywec`}……………………………………………………………… 99]im. >2=.><9. ]idimwec` \q cmi}}……………………………………………………………… 99]im. >2=.><6. Bqn`w Fy`ge`b Gime}ec`}……………………………………………………… 99]im. >2=.><2. Bqn`w Nmmi|wn`mi……………………………………………………………… 99]im. >2=.><?. Ngc|wec`} au Qifiqi`mi………………………………………………………. 99]im. >2=.><5. Y}i cf woi E wiq`iw……………………………………………………………… 96]yamon|wiq A8 Idebeaedewu n`g Fy`ge`b Qi~yeqiki`w}]im. >2=.1<>. Idebeaedewu…………………………………………………………………………. 96]im. >2=.1<1. Y}i cf Fy`g}…………………………………………………………………….96]im. >2=.1<=. Ix|i`gewyqi Mnwibcqei}……………………………………………………….. 96]im. >2=.1<7. \qcbqnk E`mcki………………………………………………………………... 96]im. >2=.1<9. I~ye|ki`w………………………………………………………………………. 96

Page 5: Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

7/30/2019 Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fair-defense-law-dec-2011-tidc 5/76

 

ev

]yamon|wiq M8 Ngke`e}wiqe`b Bqn`w}]im. >2=.=<>. Bqn`w Cffemend}…………………………………………………………………... 92]im. >2=.=<1. Cadebnwec` cf Fy`g}…………………………………………………………….. 92]im. >2=.=<=. Qiwi`wec` cf Qimcqg}…………………………………………………………... 92]im. >2=.=<7. Ix|i`gewyqi Qi|cqw}………………………………………………………….... 92

]im. >2=.=<9. \qcve}ec` cf Fy`g}……………………………………………………………... 9?]im. >2=.=<6. Ge}mqiwec`nqu Bqn`w Ng hy}wki`w}……………………………………………...9?]im. >2=.=<2. Qikigei} fcq @c`mck|den`mi………………………………………………… 9?]im. >2=.=<?. Wiqk cf Bqn`w cq Cwoiq Fy`g}…………………………………………………9?]im. >2=.=<5. Vecdnwec`} cf Dnr}……………………………………………………………… 95]im. >2=.=><. \qcbqi}} qi|cqw} fcq Ge}mqiwec`nqu Bqn`w} n`g Cwoiq Fy`g}……………… 95]yamon|wiq G8 Fe}mnd Kc`ewcqe`b n`g Nygew}]im. >2=.7<>. Fe}mnd Kc`ewcq e`b……………………………………………………………….. 95]im. >2=.7<1. Nygew} @cw \iqfcqkig au woi Wn}j Fcqmi c` E`gebi`w Gifi`}i…………… 95

MON\WIQ C@I OY@GQIG N@G ]IVI@WU+FCYQ8 E@GEBI@W GIFI@]I \CDEMEI] N@G

]WN@GNQG]]yamon|wiq N8 Ke`ekyk Mc`we`ye`b Dibnd Igymnwec` Qi~yeqiki`w}]im. >27.>. N||ce`wki`w e` Mqeke`nd Mn}i}………………………………………………….. 6<]im. >27.1. N||ce`wki`w e` Hyvi`edi Mn}i}…………………………………………………..6<]im. >27.=. Qi|cqwe`b \iqecg…………………………………………………………………... 6<]im. >27.7. Ikiqbi`mu N||ce`wki`w…………………………………………………………. 6<]yamon|wiq A8 Mc`wqnmw Gifi`giq \qcbqnk Qi~yeqiki`w}Geve}ec` >8 Gife`ewec`}]im. >27.><. ]yamon|wiq Gife`ewec`}………………………………………………………….. 6>Geve}ec` 18 N||demnwec` cf ]wn`gnqg} n`g Mc`wqnmwe`b |qcmigyqi}]im. >27.>>. N||demnwec` cf ]yamon|wiq………………………………………………………. 6>]im. >27.>1. N||demnwec` \q cmi}}……………………………………………………………… 6>]im. >27.>=. N||demnwec` Qiveir \qcmi}}……………………………………………………. 6>]im. >27.>7. Nrnqge`b woi Mc`wqnmw…………………………………………………………... 61Geve}ec` =8 Qi~yeqig Idiki`w} cf n Mc`wqnmw fcq E`gebi`w Gifi`}i ]iqvemi} /InmoMck|c`i`w Aidcr ]ondd ai E`mdygig e` n Mc`wqnmw fcq E`gebi`w Gifi`}i ]iqvemi} n`g]ondd ]iqvi n} woi An}e} fcq woi @CN%]im. >27.>9. \nqwei}…………………………………………………………………………….. 61]im. >27.>6. Wiqk cf Mc`wq nmw…………………………………………………………………. 61]im. >27.>2. ]mc|i cf Mc`wq nmw……………………………………………………………….. 61]im. >27.>?. Ke`ekyk Nwwcq`iu ^yndefemnwec`}………………………………………………. 61]im. >27.>5. Gyqnwec` cf Qi|qi}i`wnwec`…………………………………………………….. 61]im. >27.1<. ]ya}wewywec` cf Nwwcq`iu}………………………………………………………... 61]im. >27.1>. Mn}idcng Dekewnwec`}……………………………………………………………. 61]im. >27.11. ]wn`gnqg} cf Qi|qi}i`wnwec`…………………………………………………… 61]im. >27.1=. Mc`fdemw} cf E wiqi}w……………………………………………………………… 6=]im. >27.17. E`vi}webnwcq} n`g Ix|iqw}………………………………………………………. 6=]im. >27.19. Mck|i`}nwec` n`g \nuki`w \qcmi}}i}……………………………………… 6=

Page 6: Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

7/30/2019 Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fair-defense-law-dec-2011-tidc 6/76

 

v

]yamon|wiq M8 \cdemu Kc`ewcqe`b Qi~yeqiki`w}Geve}ec` >8 Gife`ewec`}]im. >27.16. ]yamon|wiq Gife`ewec`}………………………………………………………….. 6=Geve}ec` 18 \cdemu Kc`ewcqe`b \qcmi}} n`g Ai`moknqj}]im. >27.12. Qe}j N}}i}}ki`w………………………………………………………………… 6=

]im. >27.1?. C`+]ewi Kc`ewcqe`b \qcmi}}…………………………………………………….. 67

N\\I@GE_  ” Mon`bi} Nfwiq 1<>> Dibe}dnwevi ]i}}ec`………………………………………………62 SSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS 

Woi Wixn} E`gebi`w Gifi`}i Mckke}}ec` bqnwifyddu nmj`crdigbi} woi n}}e}wn`mi cf Fqn`me}mc Bnqmen$\nyd ]ikaiqn n`g ]nk Vidwqe e` |qi|nqe`b woe} |yademnwec`.

1<5 R. >7

wo

]w.$ Qcck 1<1 /\qemi Gn`eid Ayedge`b%Ny}we`$ Wixn} 2?2<>9>1.5=6.6557rrr.wxmcyqw}.bcv#wegm

Page 7: Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

7/30/2019 Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fair-defense-law-dec-2011-tidc 7/76

>

MCGI CF MQEKE@ND \QCMIGYQI

MON\WIQ C@I8 BI@IQND \QCVE]EC@]

Nqw. >.<9>. Qebow wc Qi|qi}i`wnwec` au Mcy`}id 

/n% N gifi`gn`w e` n mqeke`nd knwwiq e} i`wewdig wc aiqi|qi}i`wig au mcy`}id e` n` ngviq}nqend hygemend|qcmiige`b. Woi qebow wc ai qi|qi}i`wig au mcy`}ide`mdygi} woi qebow wc mc`}ydw e` |qevnwi rewo mcy`}id}yffemei`wdu e` ngvn`mi cf n |qcmiige`b wc nddcrngi~ynwi |qi|nqnwec` fcq woi |qcmiige`b.

/a% Fcq |yq|c}i} cf woe} nqwemdi n`g Nqwemdi} 16.<7n`g 16.<9 cf woe} mcgi$ ’e`gebi`w‖ kin`} n |iq}c`roc e} `cw fe`n`menddu nadi wc ik|dcu mcy`}id.

/m% N` e`gebi`w gifi`gn`w e} i`wewdig wc onvi n`nwwcq`iu n||ce`wig wc qi|qi}i`w oek e` n`ungviq}nqu hygemend |qcmiige`b wonw knu qi}ydw e`

|y`e}oki`w au mc`fe`iki`w n`g e` n`u cwoiq mqeke`nd |qcmiige`b ef woi mcyqw mc`mdygi} wonw woie`wiqi}w} cf hy}wemi qi~yeqi qi|qi}i`wnwec`. Ixmi|w n}cwoiqre}i |qcvegig au woe} }ya}imwec`$ ef n` e`gebi`wgifi`gn`w e} i`wewdig wc n`g qi~yi}w} n||ce`wigmcy`}id n`g ef ngviq}nqend hygemend |qcmiige`b} onviaii` e`ewenwig nbne`}w woi gifi`gn`w$ n mcyqw cq woimcyqw}" gi}eb`ii nywocqeig y`giq Nqwemdi 16.<7 wcn||ce`w mcy`}id fcq e`gebi`w gifi`gn`w} e` woimcy`wu }ondd n||ce`w mcy`}id n} }cc` n} |c}}eadi$ayw `cw dnwiq won` woi i`g cf woi woeqg rcqje`b gnunfwiq woi gnwi c` roemo woi mcyqw cq woi mcyqw}"gi}eb`ii qimievi} woi gifi`gn`w"} qi~yi}w fcq 

n||ce`wki`w cf mcy`}id. E` n mcy`wu rewo n|c|ydnwec` cf 19<$<<< cq kcqi$ woi mcyqw cq woimcyqw}" gi}eb`ii }ondd n||ce`w mcy`}id n} qi~yeqigau woe} }ya}imwec` n} }cc` n} |c}}eadi$ ayw `cw dnwiq won` woi i`g cf woi feq}w rcqje`b gnu nfwiq woi gnwic` roemo woi mcyqw cq woi mcyqw}" gi}eb`ii qimievi}woi gifi`gn`w"} qi~yi}w fcq n||ce`wki`w cf mcy`}id.

/g% N` idebeadi e`gebi`w gifi`gn`w e} i`wewdig wc onviwoi wqend mcyqw n||ce`w n` nwwcq`iu wc qi|qi}i`w oek e`woi fcddcre`b n||iddnwi n`g |c}w+mc`vemwec` onain}mcq|y} knwwiq}8

/>% n` n||ind wc n mcyqw cf n||ind}:

/1% n` n||ind wc woi Mcyqw cf Mqeke`nd N||ind} ef woi n||ind e} kngi geqimwdu fqck woi wqend mcyqw cq ef n |iwewec` fcq ge}mqiwec`nqu qiveir on} aii`bqn`wig:

/=% n onain} mcq|y} |qcmiige`b ef woi mcyqwmc`mdygi} wonw woi e`wiqi}w} cf hy}wemi qi~yeqiqi|qi}i`wnwec`: n`g

/7% n`u cwoiq n||iddnwi |qcmiige`b ef woi mcyqwmc`mdygi} wonw woi e`wiqi}w} cf hy}wemi qi~yeqiqi|qi}i`wnwec`.

/i% N` n||ce`wig mcy`}id e} i`wewdig wc >< gnu} wc|qi|nqi fcq n |qcmiige`b ayw knu rnevi woi|qi|nqnwec` weki rewo woi mc`}i`w cf woi gifi`gn`w e`rqewe`b cq c` woi qimcqg e` c|i` mcyqw. Ef n `c`+e`gebi`w gifi`gn`w n||inq} rewocyw mcy`}id nw n|qcmiige`b nfwiq onve`b aii` bevi` n qin}c`nadic||cqwy`ewu wc qiwne` mcy`}id$ woi mcyqw$ c` >< gnu}"`cwemi wc woi gifi`gn`w cf n ge}|c}ewevi }iwwe`b$ knu|qcmiig rewo woi knwwiq rewocyw }imyqe`b n rqewwi`rneviq cq n||ce`we`b mcy`}id. Ef n` e`gebi`wgifi`gn`w roc on} qify}ig n||ce`wig mcy`}id e`cqgiq wc qiwne` |qevnwi mcy`}id n||inq} rewocywmcy`}id nfwiq onve`b aii` bevi` n` c||cqwy`ewu wcqiwne` mcy`}id$ woi mcyqw$ nfwiq beve`b woi gifi`gn`w nqin}c`nadi c||cqwy`ewu wc qi~yi}w n||ce`wki`w cf 

mcy`}id cq$ ef woi gifi`gn`w idimw} `cw wc qi~yi}wn||ce`wki`w cf mcy`}id$ nfwiq cawne`e`b n rneviq cf woi qebow wc mcy`}id |yq}yn`w wc ]ya}imwec`} /f% n`g/b%$ knu |qcmiig rewo woi knwwiq c` >< gnu}" `cwemiwc woi gifi`gn`w cf n ge}|c}ewevi }iwwe`b.

/f% N gifi`gn`w knu vcdy`wnqedu n`g e`widdebi`wdurnevi e` rqewe`b woi qebow wc mcy`}id. N rneviq cawne`ig e` vecdnwec` cf ]ya}imwec` /f+>% cq /f+1% e}|qi}ykig e`vndeg.

/f+>% E` n`u ngviq}nqu hygemend |qcmiige`b wonw knuqi}ydw e` |y`e}oki`w au mc`fe`iki`w$ woi nwwcq`iu

qi|qi}i`we`b woi }wnwi knu `cw8

/>% e`ewenwi cq i`mcyqnbi n` nwwik|w wc cawne`fqck n gifi`gn`w roc e} `cw qi|qi}i`wig aumcy`}id n rneviq cf woi qebow wc mcy`}id: cq 

/1% mckky`emnwi rewo n gifi`gn`w roc on}qi~yi}wig woi n||ce`wki`w cf mcy`}id$ y`di}}woi mcyqw cq woi mcyqw"} gi}eb`ii nywocqeigy`giq Nqwemdi 16.<7 wc n||ce`w mcy`}id fcq e`gebi`w gifi`gn`w} e` woi mcy`wu on} gi`eig woiqi~yi}w n`g$ }ya}i~yi`w wc woi gi`end$ woigifi`gn`w8

/N% on} aii` bevi` n qin}c`nadic||cqwy`ewu wc qiwne` n`g on} fnedig wc qiwne`|qevnwi mcy`}id: cq 

/A% rnevi} cq on} rnevig woi c||cqwy`ewu wcqiwne` |qevnwi mcy`}id.

/f+1% E` n`u ngviq}nqu hygemend |qcmiige`b wonw knuqi}ydw e` |y`e}oki`w au mc`fe`iki`w$ woi mcyqw knu

Page 8: Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

7/30/2019 Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fair-defense-law-dec-2011-tidc 8/76

 

1

`cw geqimw cq i`mcyqnbi woi gifi`gn`w wcmckky`emnwi rewo woi nwwcq`iu qi|qi}i`we`b woi}wnwi y`wed woi mcyqw ngve}i} woi gifi`gn`w cf woiqebow wc mcy`}id n`g woi |qcmigyqi fcq qi~yi}we`bn||ce`wig mcy`}id n`g woi gifi`gn`w on} aii`bevi` n qin}c`nadi c||cqwy`ewu wc qi~yi}w n||ce`wigmcy`}id. Ef woi gifi`gn`w on} qi~yi}wig n||ce`wigmcy`}id$ woi mcyqw knu `cw geqimw cq i`mcyqnbi woigifi`gn`w wc mckky`emnwi rewo woi nwwcq`iuqi|qi}i`we`b woi }wnwi y`di}} woi mcyqw cq woi mcyqw"}gi}eb`ii nywocqeig y`giq Nqwemdi 16.<7 wc n||ce`wmcy`}id fcq e`gebi`w gifi`gn`w} e` woi mcy`wu on}gi`eig woi qi~yi}w n`g$ }ya}i~yi`w wc woi gi`end$woi gifi`gn`w8

/>% on} aii` bevi` n qin}c`nadi c||cqwy`ewu wcqiwne` n`g on} fnedig wc qiwne` |qevnwi mcy`}id: cq 

/1% rnevi} cq on} rnevig woi c||cqwy`ewu wcqiwne` |qevnwi mcy`}id.

/b% Ef n gifi`gn`w re}oi} wc rnevi woi qebow wcmcy`}id fcq |yq|c}i} cf i`wiqe`b n byedwu |din cq |qcmiige`b wc wqend$ woi mcyqw }ondd ngve}i woigifi`gn`w cf woi `nwyqi cf woi monqbi} nbne`}w woigifi`gn`w n`g$ ef woi gifi`gn`w e} |qcmiige`b wc wqend$woi gn`biq} n`g ge}ngvn`wnbi} cf }idf+qi|qi}i`wnwec`. Ef woi mcyqw giwiqke`i} wonw woirneviq e} vcdy`wnqedu n`g e`widdebi`wdu kngi$ woi mcyqw}ondd |qcvegi woi gifi`gn`w rewo n }wnwiki`w}ya}wn`wenddu e` woi fcddcre`b fcqk$ roemo$ ef }eb`igau woi gifi`gn`w$ }ondd ai fedig rewo n`g aimcki|nqw cf woi qimcqg cf woi |qcmiige`b}8

!E onvi aii` ngve}ig woe} SSSSSS gnu cf  SSSSSSSSSS$ 1SSS$ au woi /`nki cf mcyqw% Mcyqw cf ku qebow wc qi|qi}i`wnwec` au mcy`}id e` woi mn}i|i`ge`b nbne`}w ki. E onvi aii` fyqwoiq ngve}igwonw ef E nk y`nadi wc nffcqg mcy`}id$ c`i redd ain||ce`wig fcq ki fqii cf monqbi. Y`giq}wn`ge`b kuqebow wc onvi mcy`}id n||ce`wig fcq ki fqii cf monqbi ef E nk `cw fe`n`menddu nadi wc ik|dcu mcy`}id$E re}o wc rnevi wonw qebow n`g qi~yi}w woi mcyqw wc|qcmiig rewo ku mn}i rewocyw n` nwwcq`iu aie`bn||ce`wig fcq ki. E oiqiau rnevi ku qebow wcmcy`}id. /}eb`nwyqi cf gifi`gn`w%!

/o% N gifi`gn`w knu rewogqnr n rneviq cf woi qebowwc mcy`}id nw n`u weki ayw e} `cw i`wewdig wc qi|inw n|qcmiige`b |qivecy}du oidg cq rnevig }cdidu c` woibqcy`g} cf woi }ya}i~yi`w n||ce`wki`w cq qiwi`wec`cf mcy`}id. Ef woi gifi`gn`w rewogqnr} n rneviq$ woiwqend mcyqw$ e` ew} ge}mqiwec`$ knu |qcvegi woin||ce`wig mcy`}id >< gnu} wc |qi|nqi.

/e% Ixmi|w n} cwoiqre}i |qcvegig au woe} }ya}imwec`$ef n` e`gebi`w gifi`gn`w e} i`wewdig wc n`g qi~yi}w}

n||ce`wig mcy`}id n`g ef ngviq}nqend hygemend|qcmiige`b} onvi `cw aii` e`ewenwig nbne`}w woigifi`gn`w$ n mcyqw cq woi mcyqw}" gi}eb`ii nywocqeigy`giq Nqwemdi 16.<7 wc n||ce`w mcy`}id fcq e`gebi`wgifi`gn`w} e` woi mcy`wu }ondd n||ce`w mcy`}idekkigenwidu fcddcre`b woi ix|eqnwec` cf woqii rcqje`bgnu} nfwiq woi gnwi c` roemo woi mcyqw cq woi mcyqw}"gi}eb`ii qimievi} woi gifi`gn`w"} qi~yi}w fcq n||ce`wki`w cf mcy`}id. Ef ngviq}nqend hygemend|qcmiige`b} nqi e`ewenwig nbne`}w woi gifi`gn`waifcqi woi ix|eqnwec` cf woi woqii rcqje`b gnu}$ woimcyqw cq woi mcyqw}" gi}eb`ii }ondd n||ce`w mcy`}idn} |qcvegig au ]ya}imwec` /m%. E` n mcy`wu rewo n|c|ydnwec` cf 19<$<<< cq kcqi$ woi mcyqw cq woimcyqw}" gi}eb`ii }ondd n||ce`w mcy`}id n} qi~yeqigau woe} }ya}imwec` ekkigenwidu fcddcre`b woiix|eqnwec` cf c`i rcqje`b gnu nfwiq woi gnwi c`roemo woi mcyqw cq woi mcyqw}" gi}eb`ii qimievi} woigifi`gn`w"} qi~yi}w fcq n||ce`wki`w cf mcy`}id. Ef ngviq}nqend hygemend |qcmiige`b} nqi e`ewenwig nbne`}w

woi gifi`gn`w aifcqi woi ix|eqnwec` cf woi c`ircqje`b gnu$ woi mcyqw cq woi mcyqw}" gi}eb`ii }onddn||ce`w mcy`}id n} |qcvegig au ]ya}imwec` /m%.

/h% @cwrewo}wn`ge`b n`u cwoiq |qcve}ec` cf woe}}imwec`$ ef n` e`gebi`w gifi`gn`w e} qidin}ig fqckmy}wcgu |qecq wc woi n||ce`wki`w cf mcy`}id y`giq woe} }imwec`$ n||ce`wki`w cf mcy`}id e} `cw qi~yeqigy`wed woi gifi`gn`w"} feq}w mcyqw n||inqn`mi cq roi`ngviq}nqend hygemend |qcmiige`b} nqi e`ewenwig$roemoiviq mcki} feq}w.

/j% N mcyqw cq woi mcyqw}" gi}eb`ii knu rewocyw

y``imi}}nqu gidnu n||ce`w `ir mcy`}id wc qi|qi}i`wn` e`gebi`w gifi`gn`w fcq rock mcy`}id e}n||ce`wig y`giq ]ya}imwec` /m% cq /e% ef8

/>% woi gifi`gn`w e} }ya}i~yi`wdu monqbig e`woi mn}i rewo n` cffi`}i geffiqi`w fqck woicffi`}i rewo roemo woi gifi`gn`w rn} e`ewenddumonqbig: n`g

/1% bccg mny}i wc n||ce`w `ir mcy`}id e} }wnwigc` woi qimcqg n} qi~yeqig au Nqwemdi 16.<7/h%/1%.

Mckki`wnqu

 N gifi`gn`w‟} qebow wc mcy`}id y`giq Nqw. >.<9>/m%n`g woi ]exwo Nki`gki`w wc woi Y.]. Mc`}wewywec`ky}w ai nffeqknwevidu rnevig: rneviq knu `cw aiek|deig fqck n gifi`gn`w‟} fnedyqi wc qi~yi}wmcy`}id. Ef n gifi`gn`w n||inq} e` mcyqw rewocywmcy`}id$ woi hygbi$ aifcqi ngviq}nqu hygemend|qcmiige`b} aibe`$ ky}w ixnke`i woi gifi`gn`w wcgiwiqke`i ef oi e} nrnqi wonw oi on} n qebow wc oeqimcy`}id n`g ef oi e`wi`g} wc gc }c. Ef woi gifi`gn`we} e`gebi`w n`g mn``cw oeqi n` nwwcq`iu oek}idf$ woi

Page 9: Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

7/30/2019 Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fair-defense-law-dec-2011-tidc 9/76

 

=

 hygbi ky}w n||ce`w mcy`}id wc qi|qi}i`w woigifi`gn`w aifcqi mc`gymwe`b n`u ngviq}nqu hygemend|qcmiige`b}$ y`di}} woi gifi`gn`w ’j`cre`bdu n`gvcdy`wnqedu qide`~ye}oi}‖ oe} qebow wc mcy`}id. Cdeviq v.]wnwi $ ?21 ].R.1g 2>=$ 2>6 /Wix. Mqek. N||. >557%.

Woi bcnd cf Nqw. >.<9>/i% e} wc i`}yqi wonw n`e`gebi`w gifi`gn`w e} qi|qi}i`wig au mcy`}id wonw e}|qi|nqig fcq woi |qcmiige`b. Knqe` v. ]wnwi $ ?5>].R.1g 162$ 121 /Wix. Mqek. N||. >557%. Roi`gimege`b ef Nqw. >.<9>/i% on} aii` vecdnwig$ mcyqw}fcmy} c` woi nmwynd |qi|nqnwec` weki n`g `cw woi wekiaiwrii` woi fcqknd n||ce`wki`w n`g woi gnwi cf woi|qcmiige`b. Eg. nw 12<. Woi >< gnu} cf |qi|nqnwec`weki knu c`du ai rnevig rewo woi gifi`gn`w‟} rqewwi`mc`}i`w cq e` c|i` mcyqw. Eg. nw 165. Fnedyqi wc }nwe}fu Nqw. >.<9>/i% knu ai qne}ig c` n||ind rewocyw n|qivecy} cahimwec`. Eg. nw 16?. Vecdnwec`} cf Nqw.>.<9>/i% nqi }yahimw wc onqk n`ndu}e}. Knwmoiww v.]wnwi $ 57> ].R.1g 511$ 51? ”15 /Wix. Mqek. N||.

>556% /}y|iq}igig  au }wnwywi$ ayw qin}c`e`bfcddcrig e` Vn`@cqwqemj v. ]wnwi $ 112 ].R.=g 2<6$2<5 ”2>< /Wix. Mqek. N||. 1<<2% Ef n gifi`gn`w e} qi+e`gemwig n`g woi geffiqi`mi e` e`gemwki`w} e}`ibdebeadi$ mcy`}id e} `cw i`wewdig wc >< nggewec`ndgnu} wc |qi|nqi fcq woi `iriq e`gemwki`w. Knqe` $ ?5>].R.1g  nw 12>. Ef woi gifi`gn`w e} qi|qi}i`wig aukcqi won` c`i nwwcq`iu$ Nqw >.<9>/i% e} }nwe}feig ef nwdin}w c`i cf woi nwwcq`iu} e} bevi` >< gnu} wc|qi|nqi. Eg.: Qc`iu v. ]wnwi $ 6=1 ].R.1g 95?$ 6<>/Wix. Mqek. N||. >5?1%. Ef n gifi`gn`w‟} c`dun||ce`wig nwwcq`iu biw} qi|dnmig rewo n`cwoiq n||ce`wig nwwcq`iu$ woi `ir nwwcq`iu ky}w ai bevi`

>< gnu} wc |qi|nqi fcq woi |qcmiige`b. Knqe` $ ?5>].R.1g nw 16?.

Mc`wik|w |qcmiige`b} knu qi}ydw e` woi gi|qevnwec`cf n gifi`gn`w‟} deaiqwu. N} n qi}ydw$ wqend mcyqw} onvin gywu wc e`fcqk gifi`gn`w} cf woieq qebow} wc aiqi|qi}i`wig au mcy`}id n`g wc n||ce`w mcy`}id wcqi|qi}i`w woi gifi`gn`w} ef woiu nqi fcy`g wc aie`gebi`w. Ix |nqwi Bc`ndi} $ 579 ].R.1g ?=<$ ?=6 ”=2 /Wix. Mqek. N||. >552%.

Woi qebow wc mcy`}id bynqn`wiig au woi ]exwo Nki`gki`w n`g Nqw. >.<9> gci} `cw nwwnmo |qecq wc

woi e`ewenwec` cf ngviq}nqend hygemend |qcmiige`b}.Y`ewig ]wnwi} v. Bcyvien $ 762 Y.]. >?<$ >?? />5?7%:nmmcqg Jeqau v. Edde`ce} $ 7<6 Y.]. 6?1$ 6?? ”5 />521%:Fcqwi v. ]wnwi $ 2<2 ].R.1g ?5$ 5> /Wix. Mqek. N||.>5?6%. Woi ]y|qiki Mcyqw on} }e`mi }wnwig wonw n’gifi`gn`w‟} e`ewend n||inqn`mi aifcqi n hygemendcffemiq$ roiqi oi dinq`} woi monqbi nbne`}w oek n`goe} deaiqwu e} }yahimw wc qi}wqemwec`$ knqj} woi }wnqw cf ngviq}nqu hygemend |qcmiige`b}…‖ Qcwobiqu v.Beddi}|ei Mcy`wu $ 997 Y.]. >5>$ 1>= /1<<?%. E`

Qcwobiqu $ woi Mcyqw oidg wonw n` Nqw. >9.>2 oinqe`b~yndefei} n} n` e`ewenwec` cf ngviq}nqend hygemend|qcmiige`b} n`g }eb`nd} nwwnmoki`w. Eg. nw 1>1.\cdemi knu }wedd e`wiqqcbnwi gifi`gn`w} nfwiq woi qebowwc mcy`}id nwwnmoi} n} dc`b n} woi cffemiq} feq}w qingwoi nmmy}ig woieq Keqn`gn qebow} n`g cawne` n rneviq cf mcy`}id n} |iqkewwig y`giq  Keqn`gn . Kc`wihc v.Dcye}en`n $ >15 ]. Mw. 1<25 /1<<5% /cviqqyde`bKemoebn` v. Hnmj}c` $ 729 Y.]. 619$ roemo fcqangi|cdemi wc e`ewenwi e`wiqqcbnwec` cf n mqeke`nd gifi`gn`wc`mi oi ong e`vcjig oe} qebow wc mcy`}id nw n`nqqneb`ki`w cq }ekednq |qcmiige`b%.

Ivi` nfwiq woi e`ewenwec` cf ngviq}nqend hygemend|qcmiige`b} woi qebow wc mcy`}id nwwnmoi} c`du nw’mqewemnd }wnbi}‖ cf ngviq}nqu hygemend |qcmiige`b}.]ii Fcqwi v. ]wnwi $ 295 ].R.1g >1? /Wix. Mqek. N||.>5?6%: Bqii` v. ]wnwi $ ?21 ].R.1g 2>2$ 21< /Wix.Mqek. N||. >557%. Mqewemnd }wnbi} onvi qimi`wdu aii`gife`ig n} ’|qcmiige`b} aiwrii` n` e`gevegynd n`g

nbi`w} cf woi ]wnwi /roiwoiq ’fcqknd cq e`fcqknd$ e`mcyqw cq cyw$‖% wonw nkcy`w wc ’wqend+dejimc`fqc`wnwec`}$‖ nw roemo mcy`}id rcydg oid| woinmmy}ig ’e` mc|e`b rewo dibnd |qcadik} cq . . .kiiwe`b oe} ngviq}nqu.‖ Qcwobiqu $ 997 Y.]. >5> nw1>1 /~ycwe`b Y`ewig ]wnwi} v. Rngi $ =?? Y.]. 1>?$116 />562%$ Y`ewig ]wnwi} v. N}o $ 7>= Y.]. =<<$=>1 ”>= />52=%%.

Woi ]y|qiki Mcyqw on} qydig wonw n |qideke`nquoinqe`b e} n ’mqewemnd }wnbi‖ roi` woi oinqe`b nddcrigwoi gifi`gn`w wc mc`fqc`w n`g mqc}}+ixnke`i|qc}imywec` rew`i}}i}. Biq}wie` v. \ybo $ 71< Y.].

><=$ >11 ”1= />529% /ge}my}}e`b woi Mcyqw‟}qin}c`e`b e` Mcdikn` v. Ndnankn $ =55 Y.]. >/>52<%%. Woi Mcyqw cf Mqeke`nd N||ind} on} mewigBiq}wie`  e` giwiqke`e`b wonw n` ixnke`e`b wqend e`Wixn} e} ’nqbynadu n mqewemnd }wnbi‖ }e`mi ew e}ngviq}nqend e` `nwyqi. Bqii` v. ]wnwi $ ?21 ].R.1g nw21>. Ayw$ woi Mcyqw on} nd}c oidg wonw n |qideke`nquoinqe`b  wonw rn} `c`+ngviq}nqend gci} `cw mcy`w n}n ’mqewemnd }wnbi‖ ivi` ef |qcanadi mny}i e} aie`bgiwiqke`ig. Biq}wie` $ 71< Y.]. nw >11. Nd}c$ e`Bqii` $ woi Mcyqw cf Mqeke`nd N||ind} on} oidg wonw n|qideke`nqu e`ewend n||inqn`mi e} `cw n mqewemnd }wnbiaimny}i8 />% woi gifi`gn`w rn} `iewoiq qi~yeqig `cq 

n}jig wc |din: /1% woi |qcanadi mny}i giwiqke`nwec`rn} `c`+ngviq}nqend: /=% n` ixnke`e`b wqend rn} `cwoidg gyqe`b wonw weki: n`g /7% aned rn} `cw }iw.Bqii` $ ?21 ].R.1g nw 21> ”11

E` Rngi $ woi ]y|qiki Mcyqw on} qydig wonw n |c}w+e`gemwki`w de`iy| roiqi woi nmmy}ig e} |ou}emnddu|qi}i`w e} n ’mqewemnd }wnbi‖ cf |qc}imywec` aimny}iwoi mc`fqc`wnwec` aiwrii` woi nmmy}ig n`g vemwek}n`g rew`i}}i} e`vcdvi} gn`biq} n`g fnmwcq} ’roemo

Page 10: Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

7/30/2019 Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fair-defense-law-dec-2011-tidc 10/76

 

7

kebow }iqecy}du . . . giqcbnwi fqck n fneq wqend.‖ Rngi $1?? Y.]. nw 11?$ 1=6 ”=2. Ayw$ woi Mcyqw on} oidgwonw n |c}w+e`gemwki`w |ocwcbqn|oem ge}|dnu roiqiwoi nmmy}ig e} `cw |ou}emnddu |qi}i`w e} `cw n ’mqewemnd}wnbi‖ }e`mi woi nmmy}ig e} `cw |qi}i`w n`g woi}iwwe`b e} `cw ngviq}nqend. N}o $ 7>= Y.]. =<< nw =>2$=1>.

 N` nmmy}ig‟} gime}ec` c` roiwoiq cq `cw wc }yakewwc n aqinwo wi}w e} `cw n ’mqewemnd }wnbi‖ wonw qi~yeqi}woi n}}e}wn`mi cf mcy`}id. KmMnkaqegbi v. ]wnwi $22? ].R.1g 2<$ 21 /Wix. Mqek. N||. >5?5% /~ycwe`bFcqwi v. ]wnwi $ 295 ].R.1g >1?$ >=5 /Wix. Mqek. N||. >5??%.

E` Rngi $ woi ]y|qiki Mcyqw }wnwig wonw woiBcviq`ki`w‟} }mei`wefem n`ndu}e} cf woi nmmy}ig‟}fe`biq|qe`w}$ adccg }nk|di$ mdcwoe`b$ oneq$ n`g cwoiq }|imeki`} nqi `cw mqewemnd }wnbi} gyi wc woi reginvnednaedewu cf j`crdigbi cf woi }mei`wefem wimo`e~yi}

n`g wimo`cdcbu. Rngi $ 1?? Y.]. nw 112. Aimny}i cf woe} j`crdigbi$ woi nmmy}ig mn` kin`e`bfyddumc`fqc`w woi Bcviq`ki`w‟} mn}i nw wqend. Eg. nw 11?

Roi` n||ce`we`b mcy`}id$ woi mcyqw e} y`giq `ccadebnwec` wc }inqmo fcq n` nwwcq`iu wonw woigifi`gn`w fe`g} nbqiinadi. Riaa v. ]wnwi $ 9==].R.1g 2?<$ 2?7 /Wix. Mqek. N||. >526% /mewe`bVebi} v. ]wnwi $ 9<? ].R.1g 26$ 22 /Wix. Mqek. N||.>527%%. Woi nmmy}ig mnqqei} woi ayqgi` cf |qccf e`}ocre`b wonw oi e} i`wewdig wc n mon`bi cf n||ce`wigmcy`}id. Eg. /mewe`b Je`b v. ]wnwi $ 9>> ].R.1g =1$ =7/Wix. Mqek. N||. >527%%. Woi nmmy}ig gci} `cw onvi

n` na}cdywi qebow wc n mon`bi cf mcy`}id c` woi gnucf wqend. Eg. Ef woi nmmy}ig gci} qi~yi}w n mon`bi cf mcy`}id c` woi gnwi cf wqend$ woi mcyqw />% knun||ce`w cq nddcr woi nmmy}ig wc qiwne` `ir mcy`}id:/1% ky}w nddcr woi nmmy}ig wc qi|qi}i`w oek}idf ef woimcyqw gi`ei} woi nmmy}ig‟} qi~yi}w n`g woi nmmy}ign}}iqw} oe} qebow wc }idf+qi|qi}i`wnwec` ivi` nfwiq n|qc|iq ngkc`e}oki`w fqck woi mcyqw: cq /=% knumck|id woi nmmy}ig wonw gci} `cw rnevi woi qebow wcmcy`}id n`g gci} `cw n}}iqw oe} qebow wc }idf+qi|qi}i`wnwec` wc |qcmiig rewo woi nwwcq`iuqi|qi}i`we`b woi nmmy}ig. Ayqbi}} v. ]wnwi $ ?>6].R.1g 717$ 71? ”15 /Wix. Mqek. N||. >55>%.

Wqend mcyqw} knu `cw fcqmi gifi`gn`w} wc nmmi|wn||ce`wig mcy`}id ef woiu j`cre`bdu n`g e`widdebi`wdurnevi qi|qi}i`wnwec` n`g gifi`g woik}idvi}.Fnqiwwn v. Mndefcq`en $ 711 Y.]. ?<6$ ?>? />529%. ]iind}c Riaa $ 9== ].R.1g nw 2?=. Ayw$ woi ]wnwi knun||ce`w ’}wn`gau mcy`}id‖ wc ai nvnednadi wc n}}e}wgifi`gn`w}$ ivi` cviq woi gifi`gn`w}‟ cahimwec`$ e`’cviqmcke`b qcywe`i |qcmigyqnd cq ivegi`wenquca}wnmdi} . . . }ymo n} e`wqcgyme`b ivegi`mi cq 

cahimwe`b wc wi}wekc`u.‖ KmJn}jdi v. Rebbe`} $ 769Y.]. >6?$ >?= />5?7%: ]ii nd}c Riaa $ 9== ].R.1gnw 2?7 /~ycwe`b Fnqiwwn $ 711 Y.]. nw ?=7%.

E` cqgiq fcq gifi`gn`w} wc qi|qi}i`w woik}idvi} nwwqend$ woi gifi`gn`w} ky}w ’j`cre`bdu n`ge`widdebi`wdu‖ rnevi woieq qebow wc mcy`}id. Fnqiwwn $ 711Y.]. nw ?=9: nmmcqg  Riaa $ 9== nw 2?=. Woe} rneviq gci} `cw onvi wc ai e` rqewe`b. Ayqbi}} $ ?>6 ].R.1gnw 7=<. Roi` gifi`gn`w} n}}iqw woieq qebow wc }idf+qi|qi}i`wnwec`$ woi wqend mcyqw ky}w giwiqke`i wonwwoiu fyddu y`giq}wn`g woi mc`}i~yi`mi} cf rneve`bwoieq qebow wc qi|qi}i`wnwec` cf mcy`}id au rnq`e`bn`g knje`b woi gifi`gn`w} nrnqi cf ’woi gn`biq}n`g ge}ngvn`wnbi} cf }idf+qi|qi}i`wnwec`.‖ Fnqiwwn $711 Y.]. nw ?=9: nmmcqg Ayqwc` v. ]wnwi $ 6=7 ].R.1g651$ 657 /Wix. Mqek. N||. >5?1%$ Riaa $ 9== nw 2?9.Fyqwoiqkcqi$ woi wqend hygbi ky}w e`fcqk gifi`gn`w}wonw ’woiqi nqi wimo`emnd qydi} cf ivegi`mi n`g|qcmigyqi$‖ n`g wonw woi gifi`gn`w} redd `cw ai bevi`

}|imend mc`}egiqnwec` aimny}i woiu n}}iqwig woieq |qc }i qebow}. Reddenk} v. ]wnwi$ 191 ].R.=g =9=$ =96/Wix. Mqek. N||. 1<<?% /~ycwe`b Hco`}c` v. ]wnwi $26< ].R.1g 122$ 125 /Wix. Mqek. N||. >5??%%. E`giwiqke`e`b gifi`gn`w}‟ naedewei} wc qi|qi}i`wwoik}idvi}$ woi wqend mcyqw }ocydg `cw dccj nw roiwoiq woi gifi`gn`w} ’mcydg }ocr ‒}cki }jedd cq ix|iqwe}i$‟‖ ayw qnwoiq nw woi gifi`gn`w‟}anmjbqcy`g$ nbi$ ix|iqei`mi$ n`g igymnwec`.Ayqwc` $ 6=7 ].R.1g nw 657 /mewe`b Fnqiwwn $ 711 Y.].nw ?=9%. Woi wqend mcyqw knu nd}c wnji e`wc nmmcy`w ngifi`gn`w‟} ki`wnd mn|nmewu au ’n}je`b roiwoiq ngifi`gn`w roc }iij} wc mc`gymw oe} cr` gifi`}i nw

wqend e} ki`wnddu mck|iwi`w wc gc }c.‖ E`gen`n v.Igrnqg} $ 997 Y.]. >67$ >22 ”2? /1<<?%.

Ew e} y`dejidu wonw n mcyqw rcydg e`vndegnwi Nqw.>.<9>/m% c` i~ynd |qcwimwec` bqcy`g} aimny}i woige}we`mwec` aiwrii` e`gebi`w |iq}c`} e` |c|ydcy}n`g di}} |c|ydcy} mcy`wei} e} }yahimw c`du wc nqnwec`nd an}e} wi}w$ n`g woi dibe}dnwyqi mcydg onviqin}c`nadu gimegig wonw kcqi |c|ydcy} mcy`wei}onvi kcqi nwwcq`iu} n`g cwoiq qi}cyqmi} `imi}}nquwc nddcr woi n||ce`wki`w cf mcy`}id fcq n` e`gebi`wmqeke`nd gifi`gn`w e` n }ocqwiq |iqecg cf weki won`di}} |c|ydcy} mcy`wei} rewo firiq qi}cyqmi}. C|.

Wix. Nww―u Bi`. HM+<975 /1<<1%.

Ew e} y`dejidu wonw n mcyqw rcydg fe`g woi Nqw. >.<9>e`gebi`mi }wn`gnqg$ aimny}i cf ew} qidnwevi fdixeaedewufqck c`i mcy`wu wc woi `ixw$ vecdnwevi c` ew} fnmi cf woi }wnwi n`g figiqnd bynqn`wii} cf i~ynd |qcwimwec`aimny}i woi e`gebi`mi }wn`gnqg redd `imi}}nqedu vnque` geffiqi`w mcy`wei} gyi wc vnque`b e`mcki} n`g mc}wcf deve`b kin}yqi} e` woi mcy`wei}. Eg .

Page 11: Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

7/30/2019 Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fair-defense-law-dec-2011-tidc 11/76

Page 12: Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

7/30/2019 Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fair-defense-law-dec-2011-tidc 12/76

 

6

mcy`wu e} i`wewdig wc qimievi y`giq woe} }imwec`. Woimck|wqcddiq cf |yadem nmmcy`w} }ondd e}}yi n rnqqn`wwc woi mcy`wu e` woi nkcy`w miqwefeig au woimc`vemwe`b mcyqw$ `cw wc ixmiig '19$<<<.

/m% Woi dekewnwec` ek|c}ig au woe} }imwec` c` woiqiekayq}iki`w au woi }wnwi wc n mcy`wu fcq mck|i`}nwec` cf mcy`}id n`g |nuki`w cf qin}c`nadi ix|i`}i} gci} `cw |qcoeaew n mcy`wufqck mck|i`}nwe`b mcy`}id n`g qiekayq}e`bix|i`}i} e` n` nkcy`w wonw e} e` ixmi}} cf woinkcy`w woi mcy`wu qimievi} fqck woi }wnwi n}qiekayq}iki`w$ n`g n mcy`wu e} }|imefemnddu bqn`wigge}mqiwec` au woe} }ya}imwec` wc knji |nuki`w} e`ixmi}} cf woi }wnwi qiekayq}iki`w.

/g% Woi mck|wqcddiq }ondd qiekayq}i n mcy`wu fcq woimck|i`}nwec` n`g |nuki`w cf ix|i`}i} cf n`nwwcq`iu n||ce`wig au woi mcyqw cf mqeke`nd n||ind}y`giq |qecq dnr. N mc`vemwe`b mcyqw }iije`b

qiekayq}iki`w fcq n mcy`wu n} |iqkewwig au woe}}ya}imwec` }ondd miqwefu woi nkcy`w woi mcy`wu e}i`wewdig wc qimievi y`giq woe} }ya}imwec` fcq n`n||demnwec` fedig y`giq woe} nqwemdi$ `cw wc ixmiig nwcwnd nkcy`w cf '19$<<<.

]im. =. E`vi}webnwec` cf Bqcy`g} fcq N||demnwec`

/n% C` n||ce`wki`w$ mcy`}id }ondd e`vi}webnwiix|igewecy}du$ aifcqi n`g nfwiq woi n||iddnwi qimcqge} fedig e` woi mcyqw cf mqeke`nd n||ind}$ woi fnmwyndn`g dibnd bqcy`g} fcq woi fede`b cf n` n||demnwec` fcq nrqew cf onain} mcq|y}.

/a% @cw dnwiq won` woi =<wo gnu aifcqi woi gnwi woin||demnwec` fcq n rqew cf onain} mcq|y} e} fedig rewowoi mc`vemwe`b mcyqw$ mcy`}id knu fedi rewo woimc`vemwe`b mcyqw n` ix |nqwi$ viqefeig$ n`gmc`fegi`wend qi~yi}w fcq |qi|nuki`w cf ix|i`}i}$e`mdyge`b ix|iqw fii}$ wc e`vi}webnwi n`g |qi}i`w|cwi`wend onain} mcq|y} mdnek}. Woi qi~yi}w fcq ix|i`}i} ky}w }wnwi8

/>% woi mdnek} cf woi n||demnwec` wc aie`vi}webnwig:

/1% }|imefem fnmw} wonw }ybbi}w wonw n mdnek cf |c}}eadi kiqew knu ixe}w: n`g

/=% n` ewikeig de}w cf n`weme|nwig ix|i`}i}fcq inmo mdnek.

/m% Woi mcyqw }ondd bqn`w n qi~yi}w fcq ix|i`}i} e`rocdi cq e` |nqw ef woi qi~yi}w fcq ix|i`}i} e} wekidun`g qin}c`nadi. Ef woi mcyqw gi`ei} e` rocdi cq e`|nqw woi qi~yi}w fcq ix|i`}i}$ woi mcyqw }ondd aqeifdu

}wnwi woi qin}c`} fcq woi gi`end e` n rqewwi` cqgiq |qcvegig wc woi n||demn`w.

/g% Mcy`}id knu e`myq ix|i`}i} fcq onain} mcq|y}e`vi}webnwec`$ e`mdyge`b ix|i`}i} fcq ix|iqw}$ rewocyw|qecq n||qcvnd au woi mc`vemwe`b mcyqw cq woi mcyqw cf mqeke`nd n||ind}. C` |qi}i`wnwec` cf n mdnek fcq qiekayq}iki`w$ roemo knu ai |qi}i`wig ix |nqwi$woi mc`vemwe`b mcyqw }ondd cqgiq qiekayq}iki`w cf mcy`}id fcq ix|i`}i}$ ef woi ix|i`}i} nqiqin}c`nadu `imi}}nqu n`g qin}c`nadu e`myqqig. Ef woi mc`vemwe`b mcyqw gi`ei} e` rocdi cq e` |nqw woiqi~yi}w fcq ix|i`}i}$ woi mcyqw }ondd aqeifdu }wnwi woiqin}c`} fcq woi gi`end e` n rqewwi` cqgiq |qcvegig wcwoi n||demn`w. Woi n||demn`w knu qi~yi}wqimc`}egiqnwec` cf woi gi`end fcq qiekayq}iki`w auwoi mc`vemwe`b mcyqw.

/i% Knwiqend} }yakewwig wc woi mcyqw y`giq woe}}imwec` nqi n |nqw cf woi mcyqw"} qimcqg.

/f% Woe} }imwec` n||dei} wc mcy`}id‟} e`vi}webnwec` cf woi fnmwynd n`g dibnd bqcy`g} fcq woi fede`b cf n`n||demnwec` fcq n rqew cf onain} mcq|y}$ qibnqgdi}} cf roiwoiq mcy`}id e} ik|dcuig au woi cffemi cf mn|ewndrqew}.

]im. 7. Fede`b cf N||demnwec`

/n% N` n||demnwec` fcq n rqew cf onain} mcq|y}$qiwyq`nadi wc woi mcyqw cf mqeke`nd n||ind}$ ky}w aifedig e` woi mc`vemwe`b mcyqw `cw dnwiq won` woi >?<wognu nfwiq woi gnwi woi mc`vemwe`b mcyqw n||ce`w}

mcy`}id y`giq ]imwec` 1 cq `cw dnwiq won` woi 79wognu nfwiq woi gnwi woi }wnwi"} cqebe`nd aqeif e} fedig c`geqimw n||ind rewo woi mcyqw cf mqeke`nd n||ind}$roemoiviq gnwi e} dnwiq.

/a% Woi mc`vemwe`b mcyqw$ aifcqi woi fede`b gnwi wonw e}n||demnadi wc woi n||demn`w y`giq ]ya}imwec` /n%$knu fcq bccg mny}i }ocr` n`g nfwiq `cwemi n`g n`c||cqwy`ewu wc ai oinqg au woi nwwcq`iu qi|qi}i`we`bwoi }wnwi bqn`w c`i 5<+gnu ixwi`}ec` wonw aibe`} c`woi fede`b gnwi n||demnadi wc woi gifi`gn`w y`giq ]ya}imwec` /n%. Iewoiq |nqwu knu qi~yi}w wonw woimcyqw ocdg n oinqe`b c` woi qi~yi}w. Ef woi mc`vemwe`b

mcyqw fe`g} wonw woi n||demn`w mn``cw i}wnade}o bccgmny}i hy}wefue`b woi qi~yi}wig ixwi`}ec`$ woi mcyqw}ondd knji n fe`ge`b }wnwe`b wonw fnmw n`g gi`u woiqi~yi}w fcq woi ixwi`}ec`.

/m% N` n||demnwec` fedig nfwiq woi fede`b gnwi wonw e}n||demnadi wc woi n||demn`w y`giq ]ya}imwec` /n% cq /a% e} y`wekidu.

Page 13: Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

7/30/2019 Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fair-defense-law-dec-2011-tidc 13/76

 

2

/g% Ef woi mc`vemwe`b mcyqw qimievi} n` y`wekidun||demnwec` cq giwiqke`i} wonw nfwiq woi fede`b gnwiwonw e} n||demnadi wc woi n||demn`w y`giq ]ya}imwec`/n% cq /a% `c n||demnwec` on} aii` fedig$ woimc`vemwe`b mcyqw ekkigenwidu$ ayw e` n`u ivi`w rewoe`>< gnu}$ }ondd }i`g wc woi mcyqw cf mqeke`nd n||ind}n`g wc woi nwwcq`iu qi|qi}i`we`b woi }wnwi8

/>% n mc|u cf woi y`wekidu n||demnwec`$ rewo n}wnwiki`w cf woi mc`vemwe`b mcyqw wonw woin||demnwec` e} y`wekidu$ cq n }wnwiki`w cf woimc`vemwe`b mcyqw wonw `c n||demnwec` on} aii`fedig rewoe` woi weki |iqecg} qi~yeqig au]ya}imwec`} /n% n`g /a%: n`g

/1% n`u cqgiq woi hygbi cf woi mc`vemwe`bmcyqw giwiqke`i} }ocydg ai nwwnmoig wc n`y`wekidu n||demnwec` cq }wnwiki`w y`giq ]yageve}ec` />%.

/i% N fnedyqi wc fedi n` n||demnwec` aifcqi woi fede`bgnwi n||demnadi wc woi n||demn`w y`giq ]ya}imwec` /n%cq /a% mc`}wewywi} n rneviq cf ndd bqcy`g} fcq qideif wonw riqi nvnednadi wc woi n||demn`w aifcqi woi dn}wgnwi c` roemo n` n||demnwec` mcydg ai wekidu fedig$ixmi|w n} |qcvegig au ]imwec` 7N.

]im. 7N. Y`wekidu N||demnwec`: N||demnwec` @cwFedig

/n% C` mckkn`g cf woi mcyqw cf mqeke`nd n||ind}$ nmcy`}id roc fedi} n` y`wekidu n||demnwec` cq fned} wcfedi n` n||demnwec` aifcqi woi fede`b gnwi n||demnadi

y`giq ]imwec` 7/n% cq /a% }ondd }ocr mny}i n} wc rouwoi n||demnwec` rn} y`wekidu fedig cq `cw fedig aifcqiwoi fede`b gnwi.

/a% Nw woi mc`mdy}ec` cf woi mcy`}id"} |qi}i`wnwec` wcwoi mcyqw cf mqeke`nd n||ind}$ woi mcyqw knu8

/>% fe`g wonw bccg mny}i on} `cw aii` }ocr`n`g ge}ke}} woi n||demnwec`:

/1% |iqkew woi mcy`}id wc mc`we`yiqi|qi}i`wnwec` cf woi n||demn`w n`g i}wnade}on `ir fede`b gnwi fcq woi n||demnwec`$ roemo

knu ai `cw kcqi won` >?< gnu} fqck woignwi woi mcyqw |iqkew} woi mcy`}id wcmc`we`yi qi|qi}i`wnwec`: cq 

/=% n||ce`w `ir mcy`}id wc qi|qi}i`w woin||demn`w n`g i}wnade}o n `ir fede`b gnwi fcq woi n||demnwec`$ roemo knu ai `cw kcqi won`12< gnu} nfwiq woi gnwi woi mcyqw n||ce`w}`ir mcy`}id.

/m% Woi mcyqw cf mqeke`nd n||ind} knu ocdg e`mc`wik|w mcy`}id roc fedi} n` y`wekidu n||demnwec`cq fned} wc fedi n` n||demnwec` aifcqi woi gnwi qi~yeqigau ]imwec` 7/n% cq /a%. Woi mcyqw cf mqeke`nd n||ind}knu |y`e}o n} n }i|nqnwi e`}wn`mi cf mc`wik|winmo gnu nfwiq woi feq}w gnu c` roemo woi mcy`}idfned} wc wekidu fedi woi n||demnwec`. E` nggewec` wc cq e`deiy cf ocdge`b mcy`}id e` mc`wik|w$ woi mcyqw cf mqeke`nd n||ind} knu i`wiq n` cqgiq gi`ue`bmcy`}id mck|i`}nwec` y`giq ]imwec` 1N.

/g% Ef woi mcyqw cf mqeke`nd n||ind} i}wnade}oi} n `irfede`b gnwi fcq woi n||demnwec`$ woi mcyqw cf mqeke`ndn||ind} }ondd `cwefu woi mc`vemwe`b mcyqw cf wonw fnmwn`g woi mc`vemwe`b mcyqw }ondd |qcmiig y`giq woe}nqwemdi.

/i% ]imwec`} 1N n`g = n||du wc mck|i`}nwec` n`gqiekayq}iki`w cf mcy`}id n||ce`wig y`giq ]ya}imwec` /a%/=% e` woi }nki kn``iq n} ef mcy`}id

ong aii` n||ce`wig au woi mc`vemwe`b mcyqw$ y`di}}woi nwwcq`iu e} ik|dcuig au woi cffemi cf mn|ewndrqew}$ e` roemo mn}i woi mck|i`}nwec` cf woinwwcq`iu e} bcviq`ig au ]yamon|wiq A$ Mon|wiq 2?$Bcviq`ki`w Mcgi.

/f% @cwrewo}wn`ge`b n`u cwoiq |qcve}ec` cf woe} nqwemdi$woi mcyqw cf mqeke`nd n||ind} }ondd n||ce`w mcy`}idn`g i}wnade}o n `ir fede`b gnwi fcq n||demnwec`$ roemoknu ai `c dnwiq won` woi 12<wo gnu nfwiq woi gnwi c`roemo mcy`}id e} n||ce`wig$ fcq inmo n||demn`w rocaifcqi ]i|wikaiq >$ >555$ fedig n` y`wekidun||demnwec` cq fnedig wc fedi n` n||demnwec` aifcqi woi

gnwi qi~yeqig au ]imwec` 7/n% cq /a%. ]imwec` 1Nn||dei} wc woi mck|i`}nwec` n`g |nuki`w cf ix|i`}i} cf mcy`}id n||ce`wig au woi mcyqw cf mqeke`nd n||ind} y`giq woe} }ya}imwec`$ y`di}} woinwwcq`iu e} ik|dcuig au woi cffemi cf mn|ewnd rqew}$ e`roemo mn}i woi mck|i`}nwec` cf wonw nwwcq`iu e}bcviq`ig au ]yamon|wiq A$ Mon|wiq 2?$Bcviq`ki`w Mcgi.

]im. 9. ]ya}i~yi`w N||demnwec`

/n% Ef n }ya}i~yi`w n||demnwec` fcq n rqew cf onain}mcq|y} e} fedig nfwiq fede`b n` e`ewend n||demnwec`$ n mcyqw

knu `cw mc`}egiq woi kiqew} cf cq bqn`w qideif an}igc` woi }ya}i~yi`w n||demnwec` y`di}} woi n||demnwec`mc`wne`} }yffemei`w }|imefem fnmw} i}wnade}oe`b wonw8

/>% woi myqqi`w mdnek} n`g e}}yi} onvi `cwaii` n`g mcydg `cw onvi aii` |qi}i`wig|qivecy}du e` n wekidu e`ewend n||demnwec` cq e`n |qivecy}du mc`}egiqig n||demnwec` fedigy`giq woe} nqwemdi cq Nqwemdi >>.<2 aimny}iwoi fnmwynd cq dibnd an}e} fcq woi mdnek rn}

Page 14: Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

7/30/2019 Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fair-defense-law-dec-2011-tidc 14/76

 

?

y`nvnednadi c` woi gnwi woi n||demn`w fedigwoi |qivecy} n||demnwec`:

/1% au n |qi|c`giqn`mi cf woi ivegi`mi$ aywfcq n vecdnwec` cf woi Y`ewig ]wnwi}Mc`}wewywec` `c qnwec`nd hyqcq mcydg onvifcy`g woi n||demn`w byedwu aiuc`g nqin}c`nadi gcyaw: cq 

/=% au mdinq n`g mc`ve`me`b ivegi`mi$ ayw fcq n vecdnwec` cf woi Y`ewig ]wnwi} Mc`}wewywec``c qnwec`nd hyqcq rcydg onvi n`}riqig e` woi}wnwi"} fnvcq c`i cq kcqi cf woi }|imende}}yi} wonw riqi }yakewwig wc woi hyqu e` woin||demn`w"} wqend y`giq Nqwemdi =2.<2>$=2.<2>>$ cq =2.<21.

/a% Ef woi mc`vemwe`b mcyqw qimievi} n }ya}i~yi`wn||demnwec`$ woi mdiqj cf woi mcyqw }ondd8

/>% nwwnmo n `cwnwec` wonw woi n||demnwec` e} n}ya}i~yi`w n||demnwec`:

/1% n}}eb` wc woi mn}i n fedi `ykaiq wonw e}n`meddnqu wc wonw cf woi mc`vemwec` aie`bmonddi`big: n`g

/=% ekkigenwidu }i`g wc woi mcyqw cf mqeke`ndn||ind} n mc|u cf8

/N% woi n||demnwec`:

/A% woi `cwnwec`:

/M% woi cqgiq }moigyde`b woin||demn`w"} iximywec`$ ef }moigydig:n`g

/G% n`u cqgiq woi hygbi cf woimc`vemwe`b mcyqw geqimw} wc ainwwnmoig wc woi n||demnwec`.

/m% C` qimie|w cf woi mc|ei} cf woi gcmyki`w} fqckwoi mdiqj$ woi mcyqw cf mqeke`nd n||ind} }onddgiwiqke`i roiwoiq woi qi~yeqiki`w} cf ]ya}imwec`/n% onvi aii` }nwe}feig. Woi mc`vemwe`b mcyqw knu

`cw wnji fyqwoiq nmwec` c` woi n||demnwec` aifcqi woimcyqw cf mqeke`nd n||ind} e}}yi} n` cqgiq fe`ge`b wonwwoi qi~yeqiki`w} onvi aii` }nwe}feig. Ef woi mcyqw cf mqeke`nd n||ind} giwiqke`i} wonw woi qi~yeqiki`w}onvi `cw aii` }nwe}feig$ woi mcyqw }ondd e}}yi n`cqgiq ge}ke}}e`b woi n||demnwec` n} n` nay}i cf woirqew y`giq woe} }imwec`.

/g% Fcq |yq|c}i} cf ]ya}imwec` /n%/>%$ n dibnd an}e}cf n mdnek e} y`nvnednadi c` cq aifcqi n gnwi

gi}mqeaig au ]ya}imwec` /n%/>% ef woi dibnd an}e} rn}`cw qimcb`eig au cq mcydg `cw onvi aii`qin}c`nadu fcqkydnwig fqck n fe`nd gime}ec` cf woiY`ewig ]wnwi} ]y|qiki Mcyqw$ n mcyqw cf n||ind} cf woi Y`ewig ]wnwi}$ cq n mcyqw cf n||iddnwi hyqe}gemwec`cf woe} }wnwi c` cq aifcqi wonw gnwi.

/i% Fcq |yq|c}i} cf ]ya}imwec` /n%/>%$ n fnmwynd an}e}cf n mdnek e} y`nvnednadi c` cq aifcqi n gnwigi}mqeaig au ]ya}imwec` /n%/>% ef woi fnmwynd an}e}rn} `cw n}miqwne`nadi woqcybo woi ixiqme}i cf qin}c`nadi gedebi`mi c` cq aifcqi wonw gnwi.

/f% Ef n` nki`gig cq }y||diki`wnd n||demnwec` e} `cwfedig rewoe` woi weki }|imefeig y`giq ]imwec` 7/n% cq /a%$ woi mcyqw }ondd wqinw woi n||demnwec` n} n}ya}i~yi`w n||demnwec` y`giq woe} }imwec`.

]im. 6. E}}yn`mi cf Rqew

/n% Ef n wekidu n||demnwec` fcq n rqew cf onain} mcq|y}e} fedig e` woi mc`vemwe`b mcyqw$ n rqew cf onain}mcq|y}$ qiwyq`nadi wc woi mcyqw cf mqeke`nd n||ind}$}ondd e}}yi au c|iqnwec` cf dnr.

/a% Ef woi mc`vemwe`b mcyqw qimievi} `cwemi wonw woiqi~yeqiki`w} cf ]imwec` 9 fcq mc`}egiqnwec` cf n}ya}i~yi`w n||demnwec` onvi aii` kiw$ n rqew cf onain} mcq|y}$ qiwyq`nadi wc woi mcyqw cf mqeke`ndn||ind}$ }ondd e}}yi au c|iqnwec` cf dnr.

/a+>% Ef woi mc`vemwe`b mcyqw qimievi} `cwemi wonw woiqi~yeqiki`w} cf ]imwec` 9/n% fcq mc`}egiqnwec` cf n

}ya}i~yi`w n||demnwec` onvi aii` kiw n`g ef woin||demn`w on} `cw idimwig wc |qcmiig |qc }i n`g e}`cw qi|qi}i`wig au qiwne`ig mcy`}id$ woi mc`vemwe`bmcyqw }ondd n||ce`w$ e` cqgiq cf |qecqewu8

/>% woi nwwcq`iu roc qi|qi}i`wig woin||demn`w e` woi |qcmiige`b} y`giq ]imwec` 9$ ef woi nwwcq`iu }iij} woin||ce`wki`w:

/1% woi cffemi cf mn|ewnd rqew}$ ef woi cffemiqi|qi}i`wig woi n||demn`w e` woi|qcmiige`b} y`giq ]imwec` 9 cq 

cwoiqre}i nmmi|w} woi n||ce`wki`w: cq 

/=% mcy`}id fqck n de}w cf mck|iwi`w mcy`}idkne`wne`ig au woi |qi}ege`b hygbi} cf woi ngke`e}wqnwevi hygemend qibec`} y`giq ]imwec` 2?.<96$ Bcviq`ki`w Mcgi$ ef woi cffemi cf mn|ewnd rqew}8

/N% geg `cw qi|qi}i`w woi n||demn`w n}gi}mqeaig au ]yageve}ec` /1%: cq 

Page 15: Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

7/30/2019 Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fair-defense-law-dec-2011-tidc 15/76

 

5

/A% gci} `cw nmmi|w cq e} |qcoeaewig fqcknmmi|we`b woi n||ce`wki`w y`giq ]imwec` 2?.<97$ Bcviq`ki`w Mcgi.

/a+1% Qibnqgdi}} cf roiwoiq woi }ya}i~yi`wn||demnwec` e} ydweknwidu ge}ke}}ig$ mck|i`}nwec`n`g qiekayq}iki`w cf ix|i`}i} fcq mcy`}idn||ce`wig y`giq ]ya}imwec` /a+>% }ondd ai |qcvegign} gi}mqeaig au ]imwec` 1$ 1N$ cq =$ e`mdyge`bmck|i`}nwec` fcq weki |qivecy}du }|i`w n`gqiekayq}iki`w cf ix|i`}i} |qivecy}du e`myqqig rewoqi}|imw wc woi }ya}i~yi`w n||demnwec`.

/m% Woi mdiqj cf woi mc`vemwe`b mcyqw }ondd8

/>% knji n` n||qc|qenwi `cwnwec` wonw n rqewcf onain} mcq|y} rn} e}}yig:

/1% n}}eb` wc woi mn}i n fedi `ykaiq wonw e}

n`meddnqu wc wonw cf woi mc`vemwec` aie`bmonddi`big: n`g

/=% }i`g n mc|u cf woi n||demnwec` aumiqwefeig kned$ qiwyq` qimie|w qi~yi}wig$ wcwoi nwwcq`iu qi|qi}i`we`b woi }wnwi e` wonwmcyqw.

/g% Woi mdiqj cf woi mc`vemwe`b mcyqw }ondd |qck|wdugideviq mc|ei} cf gcmyki`w} }yakewwig wc woi mdiqjy`giq woe} nqwemdi wc woi n||demn`w n`g woi nwwcq`iuqi|qi}i`we`b woi }wnwi.

]im. 2. N`}riq wc N||demnwec`

/n% Woi }wnwi }ondd fedi n` n`}riq wc woi n||demnwec`fcq n rqew cf onain} mcq|y} `cw dnwiq won` woi >1<wognu nfwiq woi gnwi woi }wnwi qimievi} `cwemi cf e}}yn`mi cf woi rqew. Woi }wnwi }ondd }iqvi woin`}riq c` mcy`}id fcq woi n||demn`w cq$ ef woin||demn`w e} |qcmiige`b |qc }i$ c` woi n||demn`w. Woi}wnwi knu qi~yi}w fqck woi mc`vemwe`b mcyqw n`ixwi`}ec` cf weki e` roemo wc n`}riq woi n||demnwec`au }ocre`b |nqwemydnqeig hy}wefue`b meqmyk}wn`mi}fcq woi ixwi`}ec`$ ayw e` `c ivi`w knu woi mcyqw|iqkew woi }wnwi wc fedi n` n`}riq dnwiq won` woi >?<wo

gnu nfwiq woi gnwi woi }wnwi qimievi} `cwemi cf e}}yn`mi cf woi rqew.

/a% Knwwiq} nddibig e` woi n||demnwec` `cw ngkewwig auwoi }wnwi nqi giikig gi`eig.

]im. ?. Fe`ge`b} cf Fnmw Rewocyw Ivegi`wenquOinqe`b

/n% @cw dnwiq won` woi 1<wo gnu nfwiq woi dn}w gnwi woi

}wnwi n`}riq} woi n||demnwec`$ woi mc`vemwe`b mcyqw}ondd giwiqke`i roiwoiq mc`wqcviqwig$ |qivecy}duy`qi}cdvig fnmwynd e}}yi} knwiqend wc woi dibndewu cf woi n||demn`w"} mc`fe`iki`w ixe}w n`g }ondd e}}yi nrqewwi` cqgiq cf woi giwiqke`nwec`.

/a% Ef woi mc`vemwe`b mcyqw giwiqke`i} woi e}}yi} gc`cw ixe}w$ woi |nqwei} }ondd fedi |qc|c}ig fe`ge`b} cf fnmw n`g mc`mdy}ec`} cf dnr fcq woi mcyqw wc mc`}egiq c` cq aifcqi n gnwi }iw au woi mcyqw wonw e} `cw dnwiq won` woi =<wo gnu nfwiq woi gnwi woi cqgiq e} e}}yig.

/m% Nfwiq nqbyki`w cf mcy`}id$ ef qi~yi}wig au woimcyqw$ woi mc`vemwe`b mcyqw }ondd knji n||qc|qenwirqewwi` fe`ge`b} cf fnmw n`g mc`mdy}ec`} cf dnr `cwdnwiq won` woi >9wo gnu nfwiq woi gnwi woi |nqwei} fedig|qc|c}ig fe`ge`b} cq `cw dnwiq won` woi 79wo gnu nfwiq woi gnwi woi mcyqw"} giwiqke`nwec` e} kngi y`giq ]ya}imwec` /n%$ roemoiviq cmmyq} feq}w.

/g% Woi mdiqj cf woi mcyqw }ondd ekkigenwidu }i`g wc8

/>% woi mcyqw cf mqeke`nd n||ind} n mc|u cf woi8

/N% n||demnwec`:

/A% n`}riq:

/M% cqgiq} i`wiqig au woi mc`vemwe`bmcyqw:

/G% |qc|c}ig fe`ge`b} cf fnmw n`g

mc`mdy}ec`} cf dnr: n`g

/I% fe`ge`b} cf fnmw n`g mc`mdy}ec`}cf dnr i`wiqig au woi mcyqw: n`g

/1% mcy`}id fcq woi n||demn`w cq$ ef woin||demn`w e} |qcmiige`b |qc }i$ wc woin||demn`w$ n mc|u cf8

/N% cqgiq} i`wiqig au woi mc`vemwe`bmcyqw:

/A% |qc|c}ig fe`ge`b} cf fnmw n`g

mc`mdy}ec`} cf dnr: n`g

/M% fe`ge`b} cf fnmw n`g mc`mdy}ec`}cf dnr i`wiqig au woi mcyqw.

]im. 5. Oinqe`b

/n% Ef woi mc`vemwe`b mcyqw giwiqke`i} wonwmc`wqcviqwig$ |qivecy}du y`qi}cdvig fnmwynd e}}yi}knwiqend wc woi dibndewu cf woi n||demn`w"} mc`fe`iki`w

Page 16: Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

7/30/2019 Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fair-defense-law-dec-2011-tidc 16/76

 

><

ixe}w$ woi mcyqw }ondd i`wiq n` cqgiq$ `cw dnwiq won`woi 1<wo gnu nfwiq woi dn}w gnwi woi }wnwi n`}riq} woin||demnwec`$ gi}eb`nwe`b woi e}}yi} cf fnmw wc aiqi}cdvig n`g woi kn``iq e` roemo woi e}}yi} }onddai qi}cdvig. Wc qi}cdvi woi e}}yi}$ woi mcyqw knuqi~yeqi nffegnvew}$ gi|c}ewec`}$ e`wiqqcbnwcqei}$ n`givegi`wenqu oinqe`b} n`g knu y}i |iq}c`ndqimcddimwec`.

/a% Woi mc`vemwe`b mcyqw }ondd ocdg woi ivegi`wenquoinqe`b `cw dnwiq won` woi =<wo gnu nfwiq woi gnwi c`roemo woi mcyqw i`wiq} woi cqgiq gi}eb`nwe`b e}}yi}y`giq ]ya}imwec` /n%. Woi mc`vemwe`b mcyqw knubqn`w n kcwec` wc |c}w|c`i woi oinqe`b$ ayw `cw fcq kcqi won` =< gnu}$ n`g c`du ef woi mcyqw }wnwi}$ c`woi qimcqg$ bccg mny}i fcq gidnu.

/m% Woi |qi}ege`b hygbi cf woi mc`vemwe`b mcyqw }onddmc`gymw n oinqe`b oidg y`giq woe} }imwec` y`di}}n`cwoiq hygbi |qi}egig cviq woi cqebe`nd mn|ewnd

fidc`u wqend$ e` roemo ivi`w wonw hygbi$ ef ~yndefeig fcq n}}eb`ki`w y`giq ]imwec` 27.<97 cq 27.<99$Bcviq`ki`w Mcgi$ knu |qi}egi cviq woi oinqe`b.

/g% Woi mcyqw qi|cqwiq }ondd |qi|nqi n wqn`}mqe|w cf woi oinqe`b `cw dnwiq won` woi =<wo gnu nfwiq woi gnwiwoi oinqe`b i`g} n`g fedi woi wqn`}mqe|w rewo woi mdiqjcf woi mc`vemwe`b mcyqw.

/i% Woi |nqwei} }ondd fedi |qc|c}ig fe`ge`b} cf fnmwn`g mc`mdy}ec`} cf dnr fcq woi mc`vemwe`b mcyqw wcmc`}egiq c` cq aifcqi n gnwi }iw au woi mcyqw wonw e}`cw dnwiq won` woi =<wo gnu nfwiq woi gnwi woi

wqn`}mqe|w e} fedig. Ef woi mcyqw qi~yi}w} nqbyki`w cf mcy`}id$ nfwiq nqbyki`w woi mcyqw }ondd knji rqewwi`fe`ge`b} cf fnmw wonw nqi `imi}}nqu wc qi}cdvi woi|qivecy}du y`qi}cdvig fnmw} n`g knji mc`mdy}ec`} cf dnr `cw dnwiq won` woi >9wo gnu nfwiq woi gnwi woi|nqwei} fedi |qc|c}ig fe`ge`b} cq `cw dnwiq won` woi79wo gnu nfwiq woi gnwi woi mcyqw qi|cqwiq fedi} woiwqn`}mqe|w$ roemoiviq cmmyq} feq}w.

/f% Woi mdiqj cf woi mc`vemwe`b mcyqw }ondd ekkigenwiduwqn`}kew wc8

/>% woi mcyqw cf mqeke`nd n||ind} n mc|u cf8

/N% woi n||demnwec`:

/A% woi n`}riq} n`g kcwec`} fedig:

/M% woi mcyqw qi|cqwiq"} wqn`}mqe|w:

/G% woi gcmyki`wnqu ixoeaew}e`wqcgymig e`wc ivegi`mi:

/I% woi |qc|c}ig fe`ge`b} cf fnmw n`gmc`mdy}ec`} cf dnr:

/F% woi fe`ge`b} cf fnmw n`gmc`mdy}ec`} cf dnr i`wiqig au woimcyqw:

/B% woi }indig knwiqend} }ymo n} nmc`fegi`wend qi~yi}w fcq e`vi}webnweviix|i`}i}: n`g

/O% n`u cwoiq knwwiq} y}ig au woimc`vemwe`b mcyqw e` qi}cdve`b e}}yi}cf fnmw: n`g

/1% mcy`}id fcq woi n||demn`w cq$ ef woin||demn`w e} |qcmiige`b |qc }i$ wc woin||demn`w$ n mc|u cf8

/N% cqgiq} i`wiqig au woi mc`vemwe`b

mcyqw:

/A% |qc|c}ig fe`ge`b} cf fnmw n`gmc`mdy}ec`} cf dnr: n`g

/M% fe`ge`b} cf fnmw n`g mc`mdy}ec`}cf dnr i`wiqig au woi mcyqw.

/b% Woi mdiqj cf woi mc`vemwe`b mcyqw }ondd fcqrnqg n`ixoeaew wonw e} `cw gcmyki`wnqu wc woi mcyqw cf mqeke`nd n||ind} c` qi~yi}w cf woi mcyqw.

]im. ><. Qydi} cf Ivegi`mi

Woi Wixn} Qydi} cf Mqeke`nd Ivegi`mi n||du wc noinqe`b oidg y`giq woe} nqwemdi.

]im. >>. Qiveir au Mcyqw cf Mqeke`nd N||ind}

Woi mcyqw cf mqeke`nd n||ind} }ondd ix|igewecy}duqiveir ndd n||demnwec`} fcq n rqew cf onain} mcq|y}}yakewwig y`giq woe} nqwemdi. Woi mcyqw knu }iw woimny}i fcq cqnd nqbyki`w n`g knu qi~yi}w fyqwoiq aqeife`b cf woi e}}yi} au woi n||demn`w cq woi }wnwi. Nfwiq qiveire`b woi qimcqg$ woi mcyqw }ondd i`wiq ew} hygbki`w qikn`ge`b woi n||demn`w wc my}wcgu cq 

cqgiqe`b woi n||demn`w"} qidin}i$ n} woi dnr n`g fnmw}knu hy}wefu.

Nggewec` cf ]im. 6 /a+>% n`g /a+1% iffimwevi Hn`. >$ 1<>1 /OA >676$¢=%. ]imwec` 1 cf OA >676 |qcvegi}8 —Woi mon`bi e` dnr kngi au woe} Nmw n||dei} wc n }ya}i~yi`w n||demnwec` fcq n rqew cf onain} mcq|y} fedig c` cq nfwiq Hn`. >$ 1<>1. N }ya}i~yi`w n||demnwec` fedig aifcqi Hn`. >$ 1<>1$ e} mcviqig au woi dnr e` iffimw roi` woi n||demnwec` rn} fedig$ n`g woi fcqkiq dnr e} mc`we`yig e` iffimw fcq wonw |yq|c}i.‛  

Page 17: Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

7/30/2019 Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fair-defense-law-dec-2011-tidc 17/76

 

>>

1<>> Dibe}dnwevi @cwiOA >676 ngg} ]im. 6 /a+>% wc qi~yeqi woi mc`vemwe`bmcyqw wc n||ce`w mcy`}id fcq }ymmi}}cq rqew} cf onain} mcq|y} e` ginwo |i`ndwu mn}i}$ |qcvegig wonwwoi Mcyqw cf Mqeke`nd N||ind} giwiqke`i} wonw woirqew kiiw} woi qi~yeqiki`w} nywocqeig au }wnwywin`g ef woi n||demn`w on} `cw idimwig wc |qcmiig |qc}i n`g on} `cw qiwne`ig mcy`}id. Ew |qcvegi} n`cqgiq cf |qecqewu wonw woi mc`vemwe`b mcyqw }ocydg y}ie` n||ce`we`b mcy`}id.

OA >676 ngg} ]im. 6 /a+1% wc qi~yeqi |nuki`w cf fii} n`g ix|i`}i} fcq mcy`}id n||ce`wig wcqi|qi}i`w n||demn`w} y`giq ]im. 6 /a+>%$ ivi` ef woimn}i biw} ge}ke}}ig. Mck|i`}nwec` ky}w nd}c mcviq weki |qivecy}du }|i`w n`g qiekayq}iki`w cf ix|i`}i} |qivecy}du e`myqqig rewo qi}|imw wc woi}ya}i~yi`w n||demnwec`.

Mckki`wnqu

Woiqi e} `c figiqnd cq }wnwi mc`}wewywec`nd qebow wcmcy`}id fcq rqew} cf onain} mcq|y}. Ix |nqwi Bqnvi} $2< ].R.=g ><=$ >>> /Wix. Mqek. N||. 1<<1% /mewe`b\i``}udvn`en v. Fe`diu $ 7?> Y.]. 99>$ 999 />5?2%%.]c$ ew fcddcr} wonw woiqi e} `c mc`}wewywec`nd qebow wconvi iffimwevi mcy`}id fcq onain} |qcmiige`b}. Eg. Ayw$ woi Onain} Mcq|y} Qifcqk Nmw cf >559 mqinwign }wnwywcqu qebow wc ’mck|iwi`w‖ mcy`}id e` onain}|qcmiige`b}. Eg. nw >>=.

]e`mi mck|iwi`mu cf |qecq onain} mcy`}id e} `cw nmcb`enadi e}}yi fcq onain} mcq|y} qiveir$ mdnek}wonw |qivecy} onain} mcy`}id rn} `cw ’mck|iwi`w‖

mn``cw fydfedd woi qi~yeqiki`w} cf Nqw. >>.<2> ]im. 9fcq n }ya}i~yi`w rqew. Eg. nw ><7 ”<9. Ef n` n||demn`waqe`b} }ymo n mck|dne`w$ woi Mcyqw cf Mqeke`nd N||ind} mn` ge}ke}} woi rqew y`giq Nqw. >>.<2> ]im9/m% n} n` nay}i cf woi rqew. Eg. nw ><9.

E` Wixn}$ woi mck|iwi`mu cf mcy`}id e` onain}|qcmiige`b} e} giwiqke`ig au woi mcy`}id‟}~yndefemnwec`}$ ix|iqei`mi$ n`g naedewei} nw woi e`ewendn||ce`wki`w cf mcy`}id n`g `cw au woi fe`nd |qcgymwcf qi|qi}i`wnwec`. Eg. nw >>7: nmmcqg Qei} v.^ynqwiqkn` $ 911 F.=g 9>2$ 916 /9wo Meq. 1<<?%. E`Ix |nqwi Bqnvi} $ woi Mcyqw cf Mqeke`nd N||ind}

}wnwig wonw nddcre`b mdnek} cf e`iffimwevi n}}e}wn`micf woi |qivecy} mcy`}id e` onain} |qcmiige`b}rcydg mqinwi i`gdi}} n`g qi|iwewecy} rqew}. Ix |nqwi Bqnvi} $ 2< ].R.=g nw >>9.

 N||demn`w} fcq n |c}w+mc`vemwec` rqew cf onain}mcq|y} gc `cw onvi wc ai mck|iwi`w wc n}}e}wonain} mcy`}id }e`mi woiu gc `cw onvi kn`u cf woi}nki qebow} n} woiu geg nw wqend. Ix |nqwi Ke`i} $ 16].R.=g 5><$ 5>7 ”>9 /Wix. Mqek. N||. 1<<<%.

]wnwi n`g figiqnd mcyqw} }onqi mc`myqqi`w onain}mcq|y} hyqe}gemwec` wc qiveir woi mc`}wewywec`nddibeweknmu cf n mc`vemwec` cq ginwo }i`wi`micawne`ig e` }wnwi mcyqw. Ix |nqwi Kcqi`c $ 179].R.=g 7>5$ 71? /Wix. Mqek. N||. 1<<?%.

 N||demn`w} knu `cw onvi woieq }ya}i~yi`w rqew}mc`}egiqig au }wnwi mcyqw} y`di}} woiu }ocr `irdunvnednadi fnmw} cq dnr wonw rn} `cw nvnednadi fcq woieq |qivecy} rqew. Ix |nqwi Occg $ =<7 ].R.=g =52$ 7<6/Wix. Mqek. N||. 1<<2%. Ef woi mdnek} e`vcdvi|qivecy}du nvnednadi dnr cq fnmw} woi` woi mcyqw e}qi~yeqig au }wnwywi wc ge}ke}} woi n||demnwec` n} n`nay}i cf rqew. Eg.: nmmcqg Ikiqu v. Hco`}c` $ >=5F.=g >5>$ >59 /9wo Meq. >552%. Figiqnd mcyqw} knubqn`w n||demn`w}‟ mdnek} c`du ef woi Wixn} Mcyqw cf Mqeke`nd N||ind} mdinqdu ke}n||deig i}wnade}oigfigiqnd dnr. Ix |nqwi Occg $ =<7 ].R.=g nw 7<6.

 N kigemnd ixnke`iq‟} e`gemnwec` wonw }mei`wefem

qi}inqmo mc`gymwig nfwiq oi wi}wefeig e` woi onain}n||demn`w‟} kyqgiq wqend rcydg onvi |qivi`wig oekfqck aie`b nadi wc giwiqke`i rewo n qin}c`nadigibqii cf kigemnd miqwne`wu woi mny}i cf ginwo cf woivemwek rn} i`cybo wc }nwe}fu woi qi~yeqiki`w} cf ]imwec` 9/n%. ]ii Ix |nqwi Oi`giq}c` $ 176 ].R.=g65<$ 651 /Wix. Mqek. N||. 1<<2%.

]imwec` 9/n%‟} nay}i cf rqew |qcve}ec` on} aii`veirig n} n` ’ngi~ynwi n`g e`gi|i`gi`w‖|qcmigyqnd bqcy`g fcq |qcmigyqnd gifnydw |yq|c}i} e`figiqnd mcyqw}. Nbyednq v. Gqiwji $ 71? F.=g 916$ ==/9wo Meq. 1<<9%. Figiqnd mcyqw} redd `cw n||du woi

|qcmigyqnd gifnydw y`di}} woi dn}w }wnwi mcyqw wcmc`}egiq woi mdnek ’mdinqdu n`g ix|qi}}du‖ q ideig c`n` e`gi|i`gi`w n`g ngi~ynwi }wnwi bqcy`g. Ix |nqwi Ikiqu $ >=5 F.=g nw >59 /mewe`b Mcdikn` v.Wock|}c` $ 9<> Y.]. 211$ 2=9 />55>%%. Ef woi|qcmigyqnd gifnydw n||dei}$ figiqnd onain} qiveir cf woi mdnek e} anqqig y`di}} woi n||demn`w ’mn`gikc`}wqnwi mny}i fcq woi gifnydw n`g nmwynd|qihygemi n} n qi}ydw cf woi nddibig vecdnwec` cf figiqnd dnr$ cq gikc`}wqnwi wonw fnedyqi wc mc`}egiq woi mdnek} redd qi}ydw e` n fy`gnki`wnd ke}mnqqenbi cf  hy}wemi.‖ Ix |nqwi Nbyednq$ 71? F.=g nw 9=1 ”== /9woMeq. 1<<9% /~ycwe`b Mcdikn` $ 9<> Y.]. nw 29<%.

Woi mcyqw ivndynwi} woi cdg n`g `ir ivegi`mi$roiwoiq cq `cw ew rcydg ai ngkewwig y`giq woi qydi}cf ivegi`mi nw wqend. Ix |nqwi Qiig $ 12> ].R.=g nw2== ”=7 /~ycwe`b Ocy}i v. Aidd $ 972 Y.]. 9>?$ 9=2+=? /1<<6%%. Woi mcyqw$ wnje`b woi `ir qimcqg n`grew`i}} mqigeaedewu e`wc nmmcy`w$ woi` gimegi} ocrqin}c`nadi hyqcq} rcydg gimegi. Eg. /~ycwe`b Ocy}i $972 Y.]. nw 9=? ”=5%.

Page 18: Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

7/30/2019 Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fair-defense-law-dec-2011-tidc 18/76

 

>1

E` onain} |qcmiige`b} roiqi n||demn`w} qne}i n`Nwje`}  mdnek wonw woiu nqi ki`wnddu qiwnqgig n`gmn``cw ai iximywig$ woi n||demn`w} ainq woi ayqgi`cf |qcve`b$ au n |qi|c`giqn`mi cf woi ivegi`mi$ wonwwoiu nqi ki`wnddu qiwnqgig. Ix |nqwi Aqe}i`c  >=9].R.=g >$ 15+=< /Wix. Mqek. N||. 1<<>%.

 N||demn`w} wonw fedi dnwi nfwiq qidue`b e` bccg fnewo c`n ke}wnji` mndmydnwec` cf n gingde`i au n mcyqw knu}wedd onvi woieq |iwewec`} mc`}egiqig. Ix |nqwi Qnkc} $522 ].R.1g 6>6$ 6>2 /Wix. Mqek. N||. >55?%. N`n||demnwec` fcq n` ixwi`}ec` cf n onain} gingde`iky}w ai fedig n`g qydig c` aifcqi woi cqebe`ndgingde`i. Ix |nqwi Qiu`c}c $ 192 ].R.=g 2>9$ 21</Wix. Mqek. N||. 1<<?%. Ef woi cqebe`nd gingde`i fndd}c` n riiji`g cq ocdegnu$ woi n||demn`w knu fedi woionain} rqew c` woi `ixw ay}e`i}} gnu. Eg. nw 211.Ayw$ n||demn`w} wonw riqi bqn`wig n` ixwi`}ec` ky}wfedi woi onain} rqew c` woi nmwynd gnwi cf gingde`i$roiwoiq cq `cw ew fndd} c` n riiji`g cq ocdegnu. Eg. 

 N gifi`gn`w e} `cw i`wewdig wc onvi n hyqu gimegi woi~yi}wec` cf ki`wnd qiwnqgnwec`. ]ii Ix |nqwi Dire} $11= ].R.=g =21 /Wix. Mqek. N||. 1<<6%. Ef n hyqugimegi} woi e}}yi$ woi }nki hyqu fqck woibyedw#e``cmi`mi |on}i knu giwiqke`i roiwoiq ngifi`gn`w e} ki`wnddu qiwnqgig. @ied v. ]wnwi $ 196].R.=g 167$ 121 /Wix. Mqek. N||. 1<<?%.

 Nqw. >>.<2> gci} `cw mc`wne` n`u |qcve}ec`} fcq |qi+rqew ge}mcviqu. ]e`mi mcyqw} onvi `c hyqe}gemwec`cviq |c}w+mc`vemwec` knwwiq} y`wed n` n||demnwec` fcq rqew cf onain} mcq|y} e} fedig$ woi mcyqw} onvi `c

 hyqe}gemwec` wc cqgiq ge}mcviqu aifcqi n` n||demnwec`e} fedig. Ix |nqwi Dcmjonqw $ ?6? ].R.1g =76$ =72/Wix. Mqek. N||. >55=%: ]wnwi ix qid. Vn`mi v.Onwwi` $ 9<? ].R.1g 619$ 61? /Wix. Mqek. N||.>527%.

 N gifi`gn`w‟} qebow wc ge}mcviqu e} bi`iqnddu dekewigwc e`fcqknwec` wonw e} ixmyd|nwcqu$ knwiqend$ngke}}eadi$ e` woi |c}}i}}ec` cf woi ]wnwi$ n`gy`j`cr` wc woi gifi`gn`w. ]ii E`i}} v. ]wnwi $ 6<6].R.1g =<6$ =>= /Wix. Mqek. N||. >5?<%: ]ii nd}cMccj} v. ]wnwi $ ?77 ].R.1g 652$ 2=2 /Wix. Mqek. N||. >551%: ]ii nd}c Onvnqg v. ]wnwi $ ?<< ].R.1g

>59$ 1<7 /Wix. Mqek. N||. >5?5%. \qeknqu qi}cyqmi}cf dnr nywocqee`b ge}mcviqu e` onain} |qcmiige`b}nqi8 >% woi gyi |qcmi}} mdny}i cf woi >7wo  Nki`gki`w: 1% Nqw. >>.<2> ]imwec`} = n`g 5: =% Mo.=5$ Mcgi cf Mqeke`nd \qcmigyqi: 7% woi \yademE`fcqknwec` Nmw$ Bcviq`ki`w Mcgi Mo. 991: n`g 9%woi Fqiigck cf E`fcqknwec` Nmw$ 9 Y.].M. ]imwec`991.

Dnwi fede`b cf n onain} mcq|y} n||demnwec` e` n ginwo|i`ndwu mn}i e} |iqkewwig c`du ef woi mdnek} mcydg `cwonvi aii` |qi}i`wig wekidu cq ef woiqi rn} nvecdnwec` cf woi Y`ewig ]wnwi} Mc`}wewywec`$ ayw fcq woin||demn`w rcydg `cw onvi aii` fcy`g byedwu cq }i`wi`mig wc ginwo. Ix |nqwi ]kewo $ 522 ].R.1g6><$ 6>> /Wix. Mqek. N||. >55?%.

MON\WIQ FCYQWII@8 NQQI]W REWOCYWRNQQN@W

Nqw. >7.<6. Ky}w Wnji Cffi`giq Aifcqi Knbe}wqnwi

/n% Ixmi|w n} cwoiqre}i |qcvegig au woe} nqwemdi$ e`inmo mn}i i`ykiqnwig e` woe} Mcgi$ woi |iq}c`knje`b woi nqqi}w cq woi |iq}c` onve`b my}wcgu cf woi |iq}c` nqqi}wig }ondd wnji woi |iq}c` nqqi}wig cq onvi oek wnji` rewocyw y``imi}}nqu gidnu$ ayw `cwdnwiq won` 7? ocyq} nfwiq woi |iq}c` e} nqqi}wig$aifcqi woi knbe}wqnwi roc knu onvi cqgiqig woi

nqqi}w$ aifcqi }cki knbe}wqnwi cf woi mcy`wu roiqiwoi nqqi}w rn} kngi rewocyw n` cqgiq$ cq$ wc |qcvegikcqi ix|igewecy}du wc woi |iq}c` nqqi}wig woirnq`e`b} gi}mqeaig au Nqwemdi >9.>2 cf woe} Mcgi$aifcqi n knbe}wqnwi e` n`u cwoiq mcy`wu cf woe} }wnwi.Woi knbe}wqnwi }ondd ekkigenwidu |iqfcqk woi gywei}gi}mqeaig e` Nqwemdi >9.>2 cf woe} Mcgi.

/a% N |inmi cffemiq roc e} monqbe`b n |iq}c`$e`mdyge`b n moedg$ rewo mckkewwe`b n` cffi`}i wonw e} nMdn}} M ke}gikin`cq$ cwoiq won` n` cffi`}i y`giq ]imwec` 75.<1$ \i`nd Mcgi$ knu$ e`}wing cf wnje`bwoi |iq}c` aifcqi n knbe}wqnwi$ e}}yi n mewnwec` wc

woi |iq}c` wonw mc`wne`} rqewwi` `cwemi cf woi wekin`g |dnmi woi |iq}c` ky}w n||inq aifcqi nknbe}wqnwi$ woi `nki n`g nggqi}} cf woi |iq}c`monqbig$ woi cffi`}i monqbig$ n`g woi fcddcre`bngkc`e}oki`w$ e` acdgfnmig cq y`giqde`ig wu|i cq e`mn|ewnd diwwiq}8

!Ef ucy nqi mc`vemwig cf n ke}gikin`cq cffi`}i e`vcdve`b vecdi`mi roiqi ucy nqi cq riqi n}|cy}i$ e`weknwi |nqw`iq$ |nqi`w$ cq bynqgen` cf woivemwek cq nqi cq riqi e`vcdvig e` n`cwoiq$ }ekednq qidnwec`}oe| rewo woi vemwek$ ew knu ai y`dnrfyd fcq ucy wc |c}}i}} cq |yqmon}i n feqinqk$ e`mdyge`b n

on`gby` cq dc`b by`$ cq nkky`ewec`$ |yq}yn`w wcfigiqnd dnr y`giq >? Y.].M. ]imwec` 511/b%/5% cq ]imwec` 76.<7/a%$ Wixn} \i`nd Mcgi. Ef ucy onvin`u ~yi}wec`} roiwoiq woi}i dnr} knji ew eddibnd fcq ucy wc |c}}i}} cq |yqmon}i n feqinqk$ ucy }ocydgmc`}ydw n` nwwcq`iu.!

/m% Ef woi |iq}c` qi}egi} e` woi mcy`wu roiqi woicffi`}i cmmyqqig$ n |inmi cffemiq roc e} monqbe`b n|iq}c` rewo mckkewwe`b n` cffi`}i wonw e} n Mdn}} N

Page 19: Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

7/30/2019 Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fair-defense-law-dec-2011-tidc 19/76

 

>=

cq A ke}gikin`cq knu$ e`}wing cf wnje`b woi |iq}c`aifcqi n knbe}wqnwi$ e}}yi n mewnwec` wc woi |iq}c`wonw mc`wne`} rqewwi` `cwemi cf woi weki n`g |dnmi woi|iq}c` ky}w n||inq aifcqi n knbe}wqnwi cf woe} }wnwin} gi}mqeaig au ]ya}imwec` /n%$ woi `nki n`gnggqi}} cf woi |iq}c` monqbig$ n`g woi cffi`}imonqbig.

/g% ]ya}imwec` /m% n||dei} c`du wc n |iq}c` monqbigrewo mckkewwe`b n` cffi`}i y`giq8

/>% ]imwec` 7?>.>1>$ Oindwo n`g ]nfiwu Mcgi$ ef woi cffi`}i e} |y`e}onadi y`giq ]ya}imwec`/a%/>% cq /1% cf wonw }imwec`:

/>+n% ]imwec` 7?>.>>6>$ Oindwo n`g ]nfiwuMcgi$ ef woi cffi`}i e} |y`e}onadi y`giq ]ya}imwec` /a%/>% cq /1% cf wonw }imwec`:

/1% ]imwec` 1?.<=$ \i`nd Mcgi$ ef woi cffi`}i e}

|y`e}onadi y`giq ]ya}imwec` /a%/1% cf wonw}imwec`:

/=% ]imwec` 1?.<?$ \i`nd Mcgi$ ef woi cffi`}i e}|y`e}onadi y`giq ]ya}imwec` /a%/>% cf wonw}imwec`:

/7% ]imwec` =>.<=$ \i`nd Mcgi$ ef woi cffi`}i e}|y`e}onadi y`giq ]ya}imwec` /i%/1%/N% cf wonw}imwec`:

/9% ]imwec` =>.<7$ \i`nd Mcgi$ ef woi cffi`}i e}|y`e}onadi y`giq ]ya}imwec` /i%/1% cf wonw

}imwec`:

/6% ]imwec` =?.>>7$ \i`nd Mcgi$ ef woi cffi`}i e}|y`e}onadi n} n Mdn}} A ke}gikin`cq: cq 

/2% ]imwec` 91>.792$ Wqn`}|cqwnwec` Mcgi.

Nggewec` cf /g%/>+n% iffimwevi ]i|w. >$ 1<>> /]A ==>$ ¢5%. 1<>> Dibe}dnwevi @cwi]A ==> nki`g} }ya}imwec` /g% wc |qcvegi wonw}ya}imwec` /m% n||dei} wc |iq}c`} monqbig rewo n`cffi`}i y`giq ]imwec` 7?>.>>6>$ Oindwo n`g ]nfiwuMcgi$ ef woi cffi`}i e} |y`e}onadi y`giq ]ya}imwec`/a%/>% cq /1% cf wonw }imwec`.

Mckki`wnquWoi Fcyqwo Nki`gki`w qi~yeqi} n |qck|w hygemendgiwiqke`nwec` cf |qcanadi mny}i n} n |qiqi~ye}ewi wcixwi`gig qi}wqne`w c` deaiqwu fcddcre`b nqqi}w rewocywrnqqn`w. Biq}wie` v. \ybo $ 71< Y.]. ><=$ >>7/>529%. Bi`iqnddu$ }wnwi} ky}w knji }ymogiwiqke`nwec`} rewoe` 7? ocyq} cf nqqi}w. Mcy`wu cf Qeviq}egi v. KmDnybode` $ 9<< Y.]. 77 />55>%.

Rewocyw n }ocre`b cf n mny}nd mc``imwec` aiwrii`fnede`b wc wnji n` nmmy}ig aifcqi n knbe}wqnwi n`gwoi nmmy}ig‟} mc`fi}}ec`$ fnede`b wc wnji woi nmmy}igaifcqi n knbe}wqnwi rewocyw y``imi}}nqu gidnu gci}`cw e`vndegnwi woi mc`fi}}ec`. Acug v. ]wnwi $ ?>>].R.1g ><9$ >17 /Wix. Mqek. N||. >55>%. Fnede`b wcwnji n` nmmy}ig e` fqc`w cf n knbe}wqnwi rewocywgidnu gci} `cw e`vndegnwi n vcdy`wnqu mc`fi}}ec` ef woi nmmy}ig qimievig oe} Keqn`gn qebow}. Eg. nw >19.

Woi gifi`gn`w on} woi ayqgi` wc }ocr wonw y`giq Wixn} dnr$ n gidnu e` woi nqqneb`ki`w |qcmi}}qi`giq} n mc`fi}}ec` nm~yeqig gyqe`b woi gidnue`ngke}}eadi n} n knwwiq cf dnr. Riaa v. Aiwc $ 7>9F.1g 7==$ 7=6 /9wo Meq. >565%$ miqw. gi`eig$ =56 Y.].><>5 />52<%.

 N vecdnwec` cf woe} Nqwemdi gci} `cw e`vndegnwi n }inqmokngi e`megi`w wc n dnrfyd nqqi}w }e`mi woi |yq|c}i cf 

woi Nqwemdi e} wc nddcr woi knbe}wqnwi wc bevi woinmmy}ig woi rnq`e`b} n`g ge}monqbi woi gywei}qi~yeqig au Nqwemdi >9.>2$ roemo e} `cw n |qiqi~ye}ewiwc woi }inqmo cf woi nmmy}ig. Mcqae` v. ]wnwi $ 716].R.1g 1=?$ 17< /Wix. Mqek. N||. >56?%.

MON\WIQ FEFWII@8 NQQI]W Y@GIQ RNQQN@W

Nqw. >9.>2. Gywei} cf Nqqi}we`b Cffemiq n`gKnbe}wqnwi

/n% E` inmo mn}i i`ykiqnwig e` woe} Mcgi$ woi|iq}c` knje`b woi nqqi}w cq woi |iq}c` onve`b

my}wcgu cf woi |iq}c` nqqi}wig }ondd rewocywy``imi}}nqu gidnu$ ayw `cw dnwiq won` 7? ocyq} nfwiq woi |iq}c` e} nqqi}wig$ wnji woi |iq}c` nqqi}wig cq onvi oek wnji` aifcqi }cki knbe}wqnwi cf woimcy`wu roiqi woi nmmy}ig rn} nqqi}wig cq$ wc|qcvegi kcqi ix|igewecy}du wc woi |iq}c` nqqi}wigwoi rnq`e`b} gi}mqeaig au woe} nqwemdi$ aifcqi nknbe}wqnwi e` n`u cwoiq mcy`wu cf woe} }wnwi. Woinqqi}wig |iq}c` knu ai wnji` aifcqi woi knbe}wqnwie` |iq}c` cq woi eknbi cf woi nqqi}wig |iq}c` knuai |qi}i`wig wc woi knbe}wqnwi au kin`} cf n`idimwqc`em aqcngmn}w }u}wik. Woi knbe}wqnwi }ondde`fcqk e` mdinq dn`bynbi woi |iq}c` nqqi}wig$ iewoiq 

e` |iq}c` cq woqcybo woi idimwqc`em aqcngmn}w}u}wik$ cf woi nmmy}nwec` nbne`}w oek n`g cf n`unffegnvew fedig woiqirewo$ cf oe} qebow wc qiwne` mcy`}id$cf oe} qebow wc qikne` }edi`w$ cf oe} qebow wc onvi n`nwwcq`iu |qi}i`w gyqe`b n`u e`wiqveir rewo |inmicffemiq} cq nwwcq`iu} qi|qi}i`we`b woi }wnwi$ cf oe}qebow wc wiqke`nwi woi e`wiqveir nw n`u weki$ n`g cf oe} qebow wc onvi n` ixnke`e`b wqend. Woi knbe}wqnwi}ondd nd}c e`fcqk woi |iq}c` nqqi}wig cf woi |iq}c`"}qebow wc qi~yi}w woi n||ce`wki`w cf mcy`}id ef woi

Page 20: Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

7/30/2019 Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fair-defense-law-dec-2011-tidc 20/76

 

>7

|iq}c` mn``cw nffcqg mcy`}id. Woi knbe}wqnwi }ondde`fcqk woi |iq}c` nqqi}wig cf woi |qcmigyqi} fcq qi~yi}we`b n||ce`wki`w cf mcy`}id. Ef woi |iq}c`gci} `cw }|inj n`g y`giq}wn`g woi I`bde}odn`bynbi cq e} ginf$ woi knbe}wqnwi }ondd e`fcqk woi|iq}c` e` n kn``iq mc`}e}wi`w rewo Nqwemdi} =?.=<n`g =?.=>$ n} n||qc|qenwi. Woi knbe}wqnwi }onddi`}yqi wonw qin}c`nadi n}}e}wn`mi e` mck|diwe`b woi`imi}}nqu fcqk} fcq qi~yi}we`b n||ce`wki`w cf mcy`}id e} |qcvegig wc woi |iq}c` nw woi }nki weki.Ef woi |iq}c` nqqi}wig e} e`gebi`w n`g qi~yi}w}n||ce`wki`w cf mcy`}id n`g ef woi knbe}wqnwi e}nywocqeig y`giq Nqwemdi 16.<7 wc n||ce`w mcy`}id fcq e`gebi`w gifi`gn`w} e` woi mcy`wu$ woi knbe}wqnwi}ondd n||ce`w mcy`}id e` nmmcqgn`mi rewo Nqwemdi>.<9>. Ef woi knbe}wqnwi e} `cw nywocqeig wc n||ce`wmcy`}id$ woi knbe}wqnwi }ondd rewocyw y``imi}}nqugidnu$ ayw `cw dnwiq won` 17 ocyq} nfwiq woi |iq}c`nqqi}wig qi~yi}w} n||ce`wki`w cf mcy`}id$ wqn`}kew$cq mny}i wc ai wqn`}kewwig wc woi mcyqw cq wc woi

mcyqw}" gi}eb`ii nywocqeig y`giq Nqwemdi 16.<7 wcn||ce`w mcy`}id e` woi mcy`wu$ woi fcqk} qi~yi}we`bwoi n||ce`wki`w cf mcy`}id. Woi knbe}wqnwi }onddnd}c e`fcqk woi |iq}c` nqqi}wig wonw oi e} `cwqi~yeqig wc knji n }wnwiki`w n`g wonw n`u}wnwiki`w kngi au oek knu ai y}ig nbne`}w oek.Woi knbe}wqnwi }ondd nddcr woi |iq}c` nqqi}wigqin}c`nadi weki n`g c||cqwy`ewu wc mc`}ydw mcy`}idn`g }ondd$ nfwiq giwiqke`e`b roiwoiq woi |iq}c` e}myqqi`wdu c` aned fcq n }i|nqnwi mqeke`nd cffi`}i$ngkew woi |iq}c` nqqi}wig wc aned ef nddcrig au dnr. N qimcqge`b cf woi mckky`emnwec` aiwrii` woinqqi}wig |iq}c` n`g woi knbe}wqnwi }ondd ai kngi.

Woi qimcqge`b }ondd ai |qi}iqvig y`wed woi inqdeiq cf woi fcddcre`b gnwi}8 />% woi gnwi c` roemo woi |qiwqendoinqe`b i`g}: cq /1% woi 5>}w gnu nfwiq woi gnwi c`roemo woi qimcqge`b e} kngi ef woi |iq}c` e} monqbigrewo n ke}gikin`cq cq woi >1<wo gnu nfwiq woi gnwic` roemo woi qimcqge`b e} kngi ef woi |iq}c` e}monqbig rewo n fidc`u. Woi mcy`}id fcq woigifi`gn`w knu cawne` n mc|u cf woi qimcqge`b c`|nuki`w cf n qin}c`nadi nkcy`w wc mcviq mc}w} cf qi|qcgymwec`. Fcq |yq|c}i} cf woe} }ya}imwec`$’idimwqc`em aqcngmn}w }u}wik‖ kin`} n wrc+rnuidimwqc`em mckky`emnwec` cf eknbi n`g }cy`gaiwrii` woi nqqi}wig |iq}c` n`g woi knbe}wqnwi n`g

e`mdygi} }imyqi e`wiq`iw vegicmc`fiqi`me`b.

/a% Nfwiq n` nmmy}ig monqbig rewo n ke}gikin`cq |y`e}onadi au fe`i c`du e} wnji` aifcqi n knbe}wqnwiy`giq ]ya}imwec` /n% n`g woi knbe}wqnwi on}egi`wefeig woi nmmy}ig rewo miqwne`wu$ woi knbe}wqnwiknu qidin}i woi nmmy}ig rewocyw ac`g n`g cqgiq woinmmy}ig wc n||inq nw n dnwiq gnwi fcq nqqneb`ki`w e`woi n||demnadi hy}wemi mcyqw cq ky`eme|nd mcyqw. Woicqgiq ky}w }wnwi e` rqewe`b woi weki$ gnwi$ n`g |dnmi

cf woi nqqneb`ki`w$ n`g woi knbe}wqnwi ky}w }eb` woicqgiq. Woi nmmy}ig }ondd qimievi n mc|u cf woi cqgiq c` qidin}i. Ef n` nmmy}ig fned} wc n||inq n} qi~yeqigau woi cqgiq$ woi hygbi cf woi mcyqw e` roemo woinmmy}ig e} qi~yeqig wc n||inq }ondd e}}yi n rnqqn`wfcq woi nqqi}w cf woi nmmy}ig. Ef woi nmmy}ig e}nqqi}wig n`g aqcybow aifcqi woi hygbi$ woi hygbiknu ngkew woi nmmy}ig wc aned$ n`g e` ngkewwe`b woinmmy}ig wc aned$ woi hygbi }ocydg }iw n} woi nkcy`wcf aned n` nkcy`w gcyadi wonw bi`iqnddu }iw fcq woicffi`}i fcq roemo woi nmmy}ig rn} nqqi}wig. Woe}}ya}imwec` gci} `cw n||du wc n` nmmy}ig roc on}|qivecy}du aii` mc`vemwig cf n fidc`u cq nke}gikin`cq cwoiq won` n ke}gikin`cq |y`e}onadiau fe`i c`du.

/m% Roi` n ginf nmmy}ig e} wnji` aifcqi nknbe}wqnwi y`giq woe} nqwemdi cq Nqwemdi >7.<6 cf woe}Mcgi$ n` e`wiq|qiwiq n||ce`wig au woi knbe}wqnwi~yndefeig n`g }rcq` n} |qcvegig e` Nqwemdi =?.=> cf 

woe} Mcgi }ondd e`wiq|qiw woi rnq`e`b qi~yeqig auwoc}i nqwemdi} e` n dn`bynbi wonw woi nmmy}ig mn`y`giq}wn`g$ e`mdyge`b ayw `cw dekewig wc }eb`dn`bynbi.

/g% Ef n knbe}wqnwi giwiqke`i} wonw n |iq}c` aqcybowaifcqi woi knbe}wqnwi nfwiq n` nqqi}w nywocqeig au Nqwemdi >7.<9> cf woe} mcgi rn} nqqi}wig y`dnrfyddu$woi knbe}wqnwi }ondd qidin}i woi |iq}c` fqckmy}wcgu. Ef woi knbe}wqnwi giwiqke`i} wonw woi nqqi}wrn} dnrfyd$ woi |iq}c` nqqi}wig e} mc`}egiqig nfybewevi fqck hy}wemi fcq woi |yq|c}i} cf Nqwemdi 9>.>=cf woe} mcgi$ n`g woi ge}|c}ewec` cf woi |iq}c` e}

mc`wqcddig au wonw nqwemdi.

/i% E` inmo mn}i e` roemo n |iq}c` nqqi}wig e} wnji`aifcqi n knbe}wqnwi n} qi~yeqig au ]ya}imwec` /n%$ nqimcqg }ondd ai kngi cf8

/>% woi knbe}wqnwi e`fcqke`b woi |iq}c` cf woi|iq}c`"} qebow wc qi~yi}w n||ce`wki`w cf mcy`}id:

/1% woi knbe}wqnwi n}je`b woi |iq}c` roiwoiq woi |iq}c` rn`w} wc qi~yi}w n||ce`wki`w cf mcy`}id: n`g

/=% roiwoiq woi |iq}c` qi~yi}wig n||ce`wki`wcf mcy`}id.

/f% N qimcqg qi~yeqig y`giq ]ya}imwec` /i% knumc`}e}w cf rqewwi` fcqk}$ idimwqc`em qimcqge`b}$ cq cwoiq gcmyki`wnwec` n} nywocqeig au |qcmigyqi}ngc|wig e` woi mcy`wu y`giq Nqwemdi 16.<7/n%.

Page 21: Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

7/30/2019 Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fair-defense-law-dec-2011-tidc 21/76

 

>9

/b% Ef n |iq}c` monqbig rewo n` cffi`}i |y`e}onadin} n ke}gikin`cq n||inq} aifcqi n knbe}wqnwi e`mck|den`mi rewo n mewnwec` e}}yig y`giq Nqwemdi>7.<6/a% cq /m%$ woi knbe}wqnwi }ondd |iqfcqk woigywei} ek|c}ig au woe} nqwemdi e` woi }nki kn``iq n}ef woi |iq}c` ong aii` nqqi}wig n`g aqcybow aifcqiwoi knbe}wqnwi au n |inmi cffemiq. Nfwiq woiknbe}wqnwi |iqfcqk} woi gywei} ek|c}ig au woe}nqwemdi$ woi knbe}wqnwi ixmi|w fcq bccg mny}i }ocr`knu qidin}i woi |iq}c` c` |iq}c`nd ac`g. Ef n|iq}c` roc rn} e}}yig n mewnwec` y`giq Nqwemdi>7.<6/m% fned} wc n||inq n} qi~yeqig au wonw mewnwec`$woi knbe}wqnwi aifcqi roemo woi |iq}c` e} qi~yeqig wcn||inq }ondd e}}yi n rnqqn`w fcq woi nqqi}w cf woinmmy}ig.

Mckki`wnqu]ii bi`iqnddu $ mckki`wnqu y`giq Nqw. >7.<6 n`g Nqw. >.<9>$ }y|qn.

\qcmigyqi} `cqknddu qi~yeqig nfwiq nqqi}w cf nmmy}ig|iq}c`} n`g woi |qideke`nqu |qcmiige`b} roemofcddcr$ }ymo n} woi }|imefem qi~yeqiki`w} cf Nqw.>9.>2$ gc `cw n||du wc |iq}c`} monqbig rewo nmckky`ewu }y|iqve}ec` vecdnwec`. Unwi} v. ]wnwi $57> ].R.1g =92$ =61 /Wix. N||.‗Rnmc >552$ rqewqif‟g%.

Roi` iqqcq e} n}}iqwig n`g an}ig c` vecdnwec` cf n}wnwywi }ymo n} Nqw. >9.>2$ woi onqk n`ndu}e} cf Wix.Q. N||. \. 77.1/a% ky}w ai n||deig. Oe`g} v. ]wnwi $52< ].R.1g ==$ =9 /Wix. N||.‗Gnddn} >55?$ `c|iw.%.  Iqqcq} e` mqeke`nd mn}i} wonw gc `cw nffimw

}ya}wn`wend qebow} nqi wc ai ge}qibnqgig c` n||ind.Kcqndi} v. ]wnwi $ =1 ].R.=g ?61$ ?62 /Wix. Mqek. N||. 1<<<%. N }ya}wn`wend qebow e} nffimwig roi` woiiqqcq ong n }ya}wn`wend n`g e`hyqecy} iffimw cq e`fdyi`mi e` giwiqke`e`b n hyqu‟} viqgemw. Eg. /~ycwe`bJe`b v. ]wnwi $ 59= ].R.1g 166$ 12> /Wix. Mqek. N||.>552%%.

Mck|due`b rewo Nqw. >9.>2 redd ideke`nwi mck|den`mie}}yi} rewo Keqn`gn  qi~yeqiki`w}. Mdnqj v. ]wnwi $612 ].R.1g 65=$ 2<7 /Wix. Mqek. N||. >5?1%.

Cffemiq} nqi `cw qi~yeqig wc aqe`b n` nqqi}wig |iq}c`

aifcqi n knbe}wqnwi ekkigenwidu nfwiq nqqi}w$ ivi` ef n knbe}wqnwi e} nvnednadi. ]ii Hi`je`} v. ]wnwi $ 5>1].R.1g 25=$ ?<2 /Wix. Mqek. N||. >559%. E` Hi`je`} $woiqi rn} `c vecdnwec` roi` woi cffemiq} aqcybow woinqqi}wig |iq}c` aifcqi n knbe}wqnwi }exwii` ocyq}nfwiq oe} nqqi}w ivi` wocybo n knbe}wqnwi rn}nvnednadi. Eg. Fnedyqi wc aqe`b n` nqqi}wig |iq}c`aifcqi n knbe}wqnwi e` n wekidu kn``iq redd `cwe`vndegnwi n mc`fi}}ec` y`di}} woiqi e} |qccf cf mny}nd mc``imwec` aiwrii` woi gidnu n`g

mc`fi}}ec`. Mn`wy v. ]wnwi $ ?71 ].R.1g 662$ 6?</Wix. Mqek. N||. >551%.

Woi ]y|qiki Mcyqw on} oidg wonw }wnwi} knu|qivi`w |cdemi cffemiq} fqck qi~yi}we`b e`wiqveir}rewo qi|qi}i`wig gifi`gn`w} ayw woiqi e} `cmc`}wewywec`nd qi~yeqiki`w wc gc }c. Kc`wihc v.Dcye}en`n $ >15 ]. Mw. 1<25$ 1<?5 /1<<5%.

E` Wixn}$ n gifi`gn`w‟} ]exwo Nki`gki`w qebow wcmcy`}id ’nwwnmoi}‖ cq aibe`} roi` oi e} aqcybowaifcqi n knbe}wqnwi n} qi~yeqig au Nqw. >9.>2. Wonwgci} `cw `imi}}nqedu kin` wonw oi }ocydg biw n`nwwcq`iu nw wonw weki$ ayw ew kin`} wonw oi e} i`wewdigwc c`i nw n`u ’mqewemnd }wnbi‖ wonw cmmyq} woiqinfwiq.Qcwobiqu v. Beddi}|ei Mcy`wu $ 997 Y.]. >5>$ 1>> ”>1/1<<?%. N gifi`gn`w‟} e`ewend n||inqn`mi aifcqi nknbe}wqnwi hygbi$ roiqi oi dinq`} woi monqbinbne`}w oek n`g oe} deaiqwu e} }yahimw wc qi}wqemwec`$knqj} woi e`ewenwec` cf ngviq}nqu hygemend |qcmiige`b}

wonw wqebbiq woi ]exwo Nki`gki`w qebow wc mcy`}id. Eg.nw 1>1. 

\cdemi knu }wedd e`wiqqcbnwi gifi`gn`w} nfwiq woi qebowwc mcy`}id nwwnmoi} n} dc`b n} woi cffemiq} feq}w qingwoi gifi`gn`w} woieq  Keqn`gn  qebow} n`g cawne` nrneviq cf mcy`}id n} |iqkewwig y`giq  Keqn`gn .Kc`wihc $ >15 ]. Mw. 1<25 /1<<5% /cviqqyde`bKemoebn` v. Hnmj}c` $ 729 Y.]. 619$ roemo fcqangi|cdemi wc e`ewenwi e`wiqqcbnwec` cf n mqeke`nd gifi`gn`wc`mi oi ong e`vcjig oe} qebow wc mcy`}id nw n`nqqneb`ki`w cq }ekednq |qcmiige`b%.

C`mi n gifi`gn`w e`vcji} woi qebow wc onvi mcy`}id|qi}i`w gyqe`b |cdemi ~yi}wec`e`b$ `c e`wiqqcbnwec`knu wnji |dnmi y`wed mcy`}id e} |qi}i`w. Eg. nw 1<?5 ”5<: Oyboi` v. ]wnwi $ 152 ].R.=g ==<$ ==9 /Wix.Mqek. N||. 1<<5% /`cwe`b wonw woi Fefwo Nki`gki`wanq} |cdemi+e`ewenwig e`wiqqcbnwec` cf gifi`gn`w} wonwonvi n}}iqwig woieq qebow wc mcy`}id y`di}} mcy`}ide} |qi}i`w nw woi e`wiqqcbnwec` roedi woi ]exwo Nki`gki`w gci} `cw.% 

Nqw. >9.>?. Nqqi}w fcq Cyw+cf+Mcy`wu Cffi`}i

/n% N |iq}c` nqqi}wig y`giq n rnqqn`w e}}yig e` n

mcy`wu cwoiq won` woi c`i e` roemo woi |iq}c` e}nqqi}wig }ondd ai wnji` aifcqi n knbe}wqnwi cf woimcy`wu roiqi woi nqqi}w wnji} |dnmi cq$ wc |qcvegikcqi ix|igewecy}du wc woi nqqi}wig |iq}c` woirnq`e`b} gi}mqeaig au Nqwemdi >9.>2$ aifcqi nknbe}wqnwi e` n`u cwoiq mcy`wu cf woe} }wnwi$ e`mdyge`bwoi mcy`wu roiqi woi rnqqn`w rn} e}}yig. Woiknbe}wqnwi }ondd8

Page 22: Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

7/30/2019 Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fair-defense-law-dec-2011-tidc 22/76

 

>6

/>% wnji aned$ ef nddcrig au dnr$ n`g$ ef rewocyw hyqe}gemwec`$ ekkigenwidu wqn`}kew woi ac`g wnji`wc woi mcyqw onve`b hyqe}gemwec` cf woi cffi`}i: cq 

/1% e` woi mn}i cf n |iq}c` nqqi}wig y`giq rnqqn`w fcq n` cffi`}i |y`e}onadi au fe`i c`du$nmmi|w n rqewwi` |din cf byedwu cq `cdcmc`wi`giqi$ }iw n fe`i$ giwiqke`i mc}w}$ nmmi|w|nuki`w cf woi fe`i n`g mc}w}$ bevi mqigew fcq weki }iqvig$ giwiqke`i e`gebi`mu$ cq$ c`}nwe}fnmwec` cf woi hygbki`w$ ge}monqbi woigifi`gn`w$ n} woi mn}i knu e`gemnwi.

/a% Aifcqi woi >>wo ay}e`i}} gnu nfwiq woi gnwi nknbe}wqnwi nmmi|w} n rqewwi` |din cf byedwu cq `cdcmc`wi`giqi e` n mn}i y`giq ]ya}imwec` /n%/1%$ woiknbe}wqnwi }ondd$ ef rewocyw hyqe}gemwec`$ wqn`}kew wc woimcyqw onve`b hyqe}gemwec` cf woi cffi`}i8

/>% woi rqewwi` |din:

/1% n`u cqgiq} i`wiqig e` woi mn}i: n`g

/=% n`u fe`i cq mc}w} mcddimwig e` woi mn}i.

/m% Woi nqqi}wig |iq}c` knu ai wnji` aifcqi nknbe}wqnwi au kin`} cf n` idimwqc`em aqcngmn}w}u}wik n} |qcvegig au n`g }yahimw wc woiqi~yeqiki`w} cf Nqwemdi >9.>2.

/g% Woe} nqwemdi gci} `cw n||du wc n` nqqi}w kngi|yq}yn`w wc n mn|en} |qc fe`i e}}yig y`giq Mon|wiq 7= cq Nqwemdi 79.<79.

Mckki`wnquRoi` n` e`gevegynd nqqi}wig c` n` cyw cf mcy`wurnqqn`w y`giq Nqw. >9.>? e} nd}c nqqi}wig c` n |nqcdiqivcmnwec` rnqqn`w$ woi knbe}wqnwi roc |dnmi} woinqqi}wig |iq}c` e` hned ky}w ekkigenwidu `cwefu woi}oiqeff cf woi mcy`wu e` roemo woi cffi`}i e} nddibigwc onvi aii` mckkewwig cf woi nqqi}w c` acwornqqn`w}. Woi }oiqeff qimieve`b woi `cwemi ky}w wnjimonqbi cf woi nqqi}wig |iq}c` n`g onvi oek aqcybowaifcqi woi |qc|iq mcyqw cq knbe}wqnwi. Woi |qc|iq knbe}wqnwi e} n` cffemiq cf woi mcy`wu egi`wefeig auMM\ Nqw. 1.<5 n} n knbe}wqnwi$ n`g woi |qc|iq mcyqw

e} woi mcyqw cviq roemo woi knbe}wqnwi |qi}egi}. Woi}oiqeff knu wnji woi nqqi}wig |iq}c` aifcqi nknbe}wqnwi cf woi mcy`wu roiqi woi |iq}c` e} oidg$cq$ wc |qcvegi woi knbe}wqnwi‟} rnq`e`b kcqiix|igewecy}du$ aifcqi n knbe}wqnwi e` n`u cwoiq mcy`wu cf woi }wnwi. Woi }oiqeff e} `cw qi~yeqig wcwnji woi nqqi}wig |iq}c` wc n knbe}wqnwi e` woimcy`wu wc roemo woi |iq}c` rn} |nqcdig. Nknbe}wqnwi knu |iqfcqk n knbe}wq nwi‟} gywei} y`giq Mon|wiq >9 fcq n` nddibig cffi`giq ivi` wocybo oi

e} `cw uiw nywocqeig wc wqu woi cffi`}i c` woi kiqew}.C|. Wix. Nww―u Bi`. BN+<6<9 /1<<?%.

MON\WIQ ]IVI@WII@8 ANED

Nqw. >2.<=1. Qidin}i c` \iq}c`nd Ac`g cfMiqwne` Ki`wnddu Edd Gifi`gn`w}

/n% E` woe} nqwemdi$ !vecdi`w cffi`}i! kin`} n` cffi`}iy`giq woi fcddcre`b }imwec`} cf woi \i`nd Mcgi8

/>% ]imwec` >5.<1 /kyqgiq%:

/1% ]imwec` >5.<= /mn|ewnd kyqgiq%:

/=% ]imwec` 1<.<= /jeg`n||e`b%:

/7% ]imwec` 1<.<7 /nbbqnvnwig jeg`n||e`b%:

/9% ]imwec` 1>.>> /e`gimi`mu rewo n moedg%:

/6% ]imwec` 11.<>/n%/>% /n}}nydw%:

/2% ]imwec` 11.<>> /}ixynd n}}nydw%:

/?% ]imwec` 11.<1 /nbbqnvnwig n}}nydw%:

/5% ]imwec` 11.<1> /nbbqnvnwig }ixynd n}}nydw%:

/><% ]imwec` 11.<7 /e`hyqu wc n moedg$ idgiqdue`gevegynd$ cq ge}nadig e`gevegynd%:

/>>% ]imwec` 15.<= /nbbqnvnwig qcaaiqu%: cq 

/>1% ]imwec` 1>.<1 /mc`we`ycy} }ixynd nay}i cf ucy`b moedg cq moedgqi`%.: cq 

/>=% ]imwec` 1<N.<= /mc`we`ycy} wqnffemje`b cf |iq}c`}%.

/a% N knbe}wqnwi }ondd qidin}i n gifi`gn`w c`|iq}c`nd ac`g y`di}} bccg mny}i e} }ocr`cwoiqre}i ef woi8

/>% gifi`gn`w e} `cw monqbig rewo n`g on} `cwaii` |qivecy}du mc`vemwig cf n vecdi`w cffi`}i:

/1% gifi`gn`w e} ixnke`ig au woi dcmnd ki`wndoindwo cq ki`wnd qiwnqgnwec` nywocqewu cq n`cwoiq ki`wnd oindwo ix|iqw y`giq Nqwemdi >6.11 cf woe}mcgi:

/=% n||demnadi ix|iqw$ e` n rqewwi` n}}i}}ki`w}yakewwig wc woi knbe}wqnwi y`giq Nqwemdi >6.118

Page 23: Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

7/30/2019 Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fair-defense-law-dec-2011-tidc 23/76

 

>2

/N% mc`mdygi} wonw woi gifi`gn`w on} nki`wnd edd`i}} cq e} n |iq}c` rewo ki`wndqiwnqgnwec` n`g e} `c`iwoidi}} mck|iwi`w wc}wn`g wqend: n`g

/A% qimckki`g} ki`wnd oindwo wqinwki`w fcq woi gifi`gn`w: n`g

/7% knbe}wqnwi giwiqke`i}$ e` mc`}ydwnwec` rewowoi dcmnd ki`wnd oindwo cq ki`wnd qiwnqgnwec`nywocqewu$ wonw n||qc|qenwi mckky`ewu+an}igki`wnd oindwo cq ki`wnd qiwnqgnwec` }iqvemi} fcq woi gifi`gn`w nqi nvnednadi woqcybo woi Wixn}Gi|nqwki`w cf Ki`wnd Oindwo n`g Ki`wndQiwnqgnwec` y`giq ]imwec` 9=7.<9=$ Oindwo n`g]nfiwu Mcgi$ cq woqcybo n`cwoiq ki`wnd oindwocq ki`wnd qiwnqgnwec` }iqvemi |qcvegiq.

/m% Woi knbe}wqnwi$ y`di}} bccg mny}i e} }ocr` fcq `cw qi~yeqe`b wqinwki`w$ }ondd qi~yeqi n} n mc`gewec`

cf qidin}i c` |iq}c`nd ac`g y`giq woe} nqwemdi wonwwoi gifi`gn`w }yakew wc cyw|nwei`w cq e`|nwei`wki`wnd oindwo cq ki`wnd qiwnqgnwec` wqinwki`w n}qimckki`gig au woi dcmnd ki`wnd oindwo cq ki`wndqiwnqgnwec` nywocqewu ef woi gifi`gn`w"}8

/>% ki`wnd edd`i}} cq ki`wnd qiwnqgnwec` e}moqc`em e` `nwyqi: cq 

/1% naedewu wc fy`mwec` e`gi|i`gi`wdu redd mc`we`yiwc giwiqecqnwi ef woi gifi`gn`w e} `cw wqinwig.

/g% E` nggewec` wc n mc`gewec` cf qidin}i ek|c}ig

y`giq ]ya}imwec` /m% cf woe} nqwemdi$ woi knbe}wqnwiknu qi~yeqi woi gifi`gn`w wc mck|du rewo cwoiq mc`gewec`} wonw nqi qin}c`nadu `imi}}nqu wc |qcwimwwoi mckky`ewu.

/i% E` woe} nqwemdi$ n |iq}c` e} mc`}egiqig wc onviaii` mc`vemwig cf n` cffi`}i ef8

/>% n }i`wi`mi e} ek|c}ig:

/1% woi |iq}c` e} |dnmig c` mckky`ewu}y|iqve}ec` cq qimievi} gifiqqig nghygemnwec`: cq 

/=% woi mcyqw gifiq} fe`nd ge}|c}ewec` cf woi mn}i.

Nki`gki`w wc /n% iffimwevi ]i|w. >$ 1<>> /OA =<<<$ ¢7%.

1<>> Dibe}dnwevi @cwiOA =<<< ngg} }ya}imwec` /n%/>=% wc e`mdygi’mc`we`ycy} wqnffemje`b cf |iq}c`}‖ e` woi de}w cf ’vecdi`w cffi`}i}‖ e` Nqw. >2.<=1. 

Nqw. >2.<==. Qidin}i c` Ac`g cf Miqwne` \iq}c`}Nqqi}wig Rewocyw n Rnqqn`w

/n% Ixmi|w n} |qcvegig au ]ya}imwec` /m%$ n |iq}c`roc e} nqqi}wig rewocyw n rnqqn`w n`g roc e}giwne`ig e` hned ky}w ai qidin}ig c` ac`g$ e` n`nkcy`w `cw wc ixmiig '9$<<<$ `cw dnwiq won` woi 17woocyq nfwiq woi |iq}c`"} nqqi}w ef woi |iq}c` rn}nqqi}wig fcq n ke}gikin`cq n`g n knbe}wqnwi on}`cw giwiqke`ig roiwoiq |qcanadi mny}i ixe}w} wcaideivi wonw woi |iq}c` mckkewwig woi cffi`}i. Ef woi|iq}c` e} y`nadi wc cawne` n }yqiwu fcq woi ac`g cq y`nadi wc gi|c}ew kc`iu e` woi nkcy`w cf woi ac`g$woi |iq}c` ky}w ai qidin}ig c` |iq}c`nd ac`g.

/n+>% @cwrewo}wn`ge`b }ya}imwec` /n% n`g ixmi|w n}|qcvegig au }ya}imwec` /m%$ n |iq}c` roc$ e` nmcy`wu rewo n |c|ydnwec` cf woqii keddec` cq kcqi$ e}nqqi}wig rewocyw n rnqqn`w n`g roc e} giwne`ig e` hnedky}w ai qidin}ig c` ac`g$ e` n` nkcy`w `cw wc

ixmiig '9$<<<$ `cw dnwiq won` woi =6wo ocyq nfwiq woi|iq}c`"} nqqi}w ef woi |iq}c` rn} nqqi}wig fcq nke}gikin`cq n`g n knbe}wqnwi on} `cw giwiqke`igroiwoiq |qcanadi mny}i ixe}w} wc aideivi wonw woi|iq}c` mckkewwig woi cffi`}i.

/a% Ixmi|w n} |qcvegig au ]ya}imwec` /m%$ n |iq}c`roc e} nqqi}wig rewocyw n rnqqn`w n`g roc e}giwne`ig e` hned ky}w ai qidin}ig c` ac`g$ e` n`nkcy`w `cw wc ixmiig '><$<<<$ `cw dnwiq won` woi7?wo ocyq nfwiq woi |iq}c`"} nqqi}w ef woi |iq}c` rn}nqqi}wig fcq n fidc`u n`g n knbe}wqnwi on} `cwgiwiqke`ig roiwoiq |qcanadi mny}i ixe}w} wc aideivi

wonw woi |iq}c` mckkewwig woi cffi`}i. Ef woi |iq}c`e} y`nadi wc cawne` n }yqiwu fcq woi ac`g cq y`nadi wcgi|c}ew kc`iu e` woi nkcy`w cf woi ac`g$ woi|iq}c` ky}w ai qidin}ig c` |iq}c`nd ac`g.

/m% C` woi fede`b cf n` n||demnwec` au woi nwwcq`iuqi|qi}i`we`b woi }wnwi$ n knbe}wqnwi knu |c}w|c`iwoi qidin}i cf n |iq}c` y`giq ]ya}imwec` /n%$ /n+>%$cq /a% fcq `cw kcqi won` 21 ocyq} nfwiq woi |iq}c`"}nqqi}w. N` n||demnwec` fedig y`giq woe} }ya}imwec`ky}w }wnwi woi qin}c` n knbe}wqnwi on} `cwgiwiqke`ig roiwoiq |qcanadi mny}i ixe}w} wc aideiviwonw woi |iq}c` mckkewwig woi cffi`}i fcq roemo woi

|iq}c` rn} nqqi}wig.

/g% Woi weki dekew} ek|c}ig au ]ya}imwec`} /n%$ /n+>%$ n`g /a% gc `cw n||du wc n |iq}c` nqqi}wig rewocywn rnqqn`w roc e} wnji` wc n oc}|ewnd$ mde`em$ cq cwoiq kigemnd fnmedewu aifcqi aie`b wnji` aifcqi nknbe}wqnwi y`giq Nqwemdi >9.>2. Fcq n |iq}c`gi}mqeaig au woe} }ya}imwec`$ woi weki dekew} ek|c}igau ]ya}imwec`} /n%$ /n+>%$ n`g /a% aibe` wc qy` nw woiweki$ n} gcmyki`wig e` woi qimcqg} cf woi oc}|ewnd$

Page 24: Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

7/30/2019 Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fair-defense-law-dec-2011-tidc 24/76

 

>?

mde`em$ cq cwoiq kigemnd fnmedewu$ wonw n |ou}emen` cq cwoiq kigemnd |qcfi}}ec`nd qidin}i} woi |iq}c` fqckwoi oc}|ewnd$ mde`em$ cq cwoiq kigemnd fnmedewu.

/i% ]ya}imwec` /n+>% n`g woe} }ya}imwec` ix|eqi c`]i|wikaiq >$ 1<>=.

Nki`gki`w} cf /m% n`g /g% n`g nggewec`} cf /n+>% n`g /i% iffimwevi ]i|w. >$ 1<>> /OA >>2=$ ¢7%. ]imwec` = cf OA >>2= |qcvegi}8 — Woi mon`bi e` dnr kngi au woe} Nmw e` nki`ge`b Nqwemdi >2.<==$ Mcgi cf Mqeke`nd \qcmigyqi$ n||dei} c`du wc n |iq}c` nqqi}wig fcq n` cffi`}i mckkewwig c` cq nfwiq woi iffimwevi gnwi cf woe} Nmw. N|iq}c` nqqi}wig fcq n` cffi`}i mckkewwig aifcqi woi iffimwevi gnwi cf woe} Nmw e} bcviq`ig au woi dnr e` iffimw c` woi gnwi woi cffi`}i rn} mckkewwig$ n`g woi fcqkiq dnr e} mc`we`yig e` iffimw fcq wonw |yq|c}i. Fcq |yq|c}i} cf woe} }imwec`$ n` cffi`}i rn} mckkewwig aifcqi woi iffimwevi gnwi cf woe} Nmw ef n`u idiki`w cf woi cffi`}i cmmyqqig aifcqi wonw gnwi.‛  

1<>> Dibe}dnwevi @cwiOA >>2= ngg} }ya}imwec` /n+>% wc nddcr mcy`wei}rewo n |c|ydnwec` cf woqii keddec` cq kcqi /Onqqe}

Mcy`wu% wc ocdg n |iq}c` rewocyw n rnqqn`w fcq woeqwu+}ex ocyq}$ e`}wing cf wri`wu+fcyq ocyq}$ aifcqionve`b wc qidin}i woi |iq}c` c` ac`g ef woi |iq}c`rn} nqqi}wig fcq n ke}gikin`cq n`g n knbe}wqnwion} `cw giwiqke`ig roiwoiq |qcanadi mny}i ixe}w}.OA >>2= }wnwi} wonw /n+>% ix|eqi} c` ]i|wikaiq >$1<>=.

MON\WIQ WRI@WU+]E_8 NQQNEB@KI@W

Nqw. 16.<>. Nqqneb`ki`w

E` ndd fidc`u mn}i}$ nfwiq e`gemwki`w$ n`g nddke}gikin`cq mn}i} |y`e}onadi au ek|qe}c`ki`w$woiqi }ondd ai n` nqqneb`ki`w.

Nqw. 16.<>>. Rneviq cf Nqqneb`ki`w

 N` nwwcq`iu qi|qi}i`we`b n gifi`gn`w knu |qi}i`w nrneviq cf nqqneb`ki`w$ n`g woi mdiqj cf woi mcyqw knu`cw qi~yeqi woi |qi}i`mi cf woi gifi`gn`w n} nmc`gewec` cf nmmi|we`b woi rneviq.

Nqw. 16.<1. \yq|c}i cf Nqqneb`ki`w

 N` nqqneb`ki`w wnji} |dnmi fcq woi |yq|c}i cf fexe`boe} egi`wewu n`g oinqe`b oe} |din

Nqw. 16.<=. Weki cf Nqqneb`ki`w

@c nqqneb`ki`w }ondd wnji |dnmi y`wed woi ix|eqnwec`cf nw din}w wrc i`weqi gnu} nfwiq woi gnu c` roemo nmc|u cf woi e`gemwki`w rn} }iqvig c` woi gifi`gn`w$y`di}} woi qebow wc }ymo mc|u cq wc }ymo gidnu airnevig$ cq y`di}} woi gifi`gn`w e} c` aned.

Nqw. 16.<7. \qcmigyqi} fcq N||ce`we`b Mcy`}id

/n% Woi hygbi} cf woi mcy`wu mcyqw}$ }wnwywcqu mcy`wumcyqw}$ n`g ge}wqemw mcyqw} wque`b mqeke`nd mn}i} e`inmo mcy`wu$ au dcmnd qydi$ }ondd ngc|w n`g |yade}orqewwi` mcy`wuregi |qcmigyqi} fcq wekidu n`g fneqdun||ce`we`b mcy`}id fcq n` e`gebi`w gifi`gn`w e` woimcy`wu nqqi}wig fcq$ cq monqbig rewo$ cq wnje`b n`n||ind fqck n mc`vemwec` cf n ke}gikin`cq |y`e}onadi au mc`fe`iki`w cq n fidc`u. Woi|qcmigyqi} ky}w ai mc`}e}wi`w rewo woe} nqwemdi n`g Nqwemdi} >.<9>$ >9.>2$ 16.<9$ n`g 16.<91. N mcyqw}ondd n||ce`w n` nwwcq`iu fqck n |yadem n||ce`wki`wde}w y}e`b n }u}wik cf qcwnwec`$ y`di}} woi mcyqwn||ce`w} n` nwwcq`iu y`giq ]ya}imwec` /f%$ /f+>%$ /o%$cq /e%. Woi mcyqw }ondd n||ce`w nwwcq`iu} fqck nkc`bwoi `ixw fevi `nki} c` woi n||ce`wki`w de}w e` woicqgiq e` roemo woi nwwcq`iu}" `nki} n||inq c` woide}w$ y`di}} woi mcyqw knji} n fe`ge`b cf bccg mny}ic` woi qimcqg fcq n||ce`we`b n` nwwcq`iu cyw cf cqgiq.

 N` nwwcq`iu roc e} `cw n||ce`wig e` woi cqgiq e`roemo woi nwwcq`iu"} `nki n||inq} c` woi de}w }onddqikne` `ixw e` cqgiq c` woi de}w.

/a% \qcmigyqi} ngc|wig y`giq ]ya}imwec` /n% }ondd8

/>% nywocqei c`du woi hygbi} cf woi mcy`wumcyqw}$ }wnwywcqu mcy`wu mcyqw}$ n`g ge}wqemwmcyqw} wque`b mqeke`nd mn}i} e` woi mcy`wu$ cq woi hygbi}" gi}eb`ii$ wc n||ce`w mcy`}id fcq e`gebi`wgifi`gn`w} e` woi mcy`wu:

/1% n||du wc inmo n||ce`wki`w cf mcy`}id kngi

au n hygbi cq woi hygbi}" gi}eb`ii e` woi mcy`wu:

/=% i`}yqi wonw inmo e`gebi`w gifi`gn`w e` woimcy`wu roc e} monqbig rewo n ke}gikin`cq |y`e}onadi au mc`fe`iki`w cq rewo n fidc`u n`groc n||inq} e` mcyqw rewocyw mcy`}id on} n`c||cqwy`ewu wc mc`fiq rewo n||ce`wig mcy`}idaifcqi woi mckki`miki`w cf hygemend|qcmiige`b}:

/7% qi~yeqi n||ce`wki`w} fcq gifi`gn`w} e`mn|ewnd mn}i} e` roemo woi ginwo |i`ndwu e}}cybow wc mck|du rewo n`u n||demnadi

qi~yeqiki`w} y`giq Nqwemdi} >>.<2> n`g 16.<91:

/9% i`}yqi wonw inmo nwwcq`iu n||ce`wig fqck n|yadem n||ce`wki`w de}w wc qi|qi}i`w n` e`gebi`wgifi`gn`w |iqfcqk woi nwwcq`iu"} gywu crig wcwoi gifi`gn`w e` nmmcqgn`mi rewo woi ngc|wig|qcmigyqi}$ woi qi~yeqiki`w} cf woe} mcgi$ n`gn||demnadi qydi} cf iwoem}: n`g

Page 25: Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

7/30/2019 Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fair-defense-law-dec-2011-tidc 25/76

 

>5

/6% i`}yqi wonw n||ce`wki`w} nqi nddcmnwignkc`b ~yndefeig nwwcq`iu} e` n kn``iq wonw e}fneq$ `iywqnd$ n`g `c`ge}mqeke`nwcqu.

/m% Roi`iviq n mcyqw cq woi mcyqw}" gi}eb`iinywocqeig y`giq ]ya}imwec` /a% wc n||ce`w mcy`}idfcq e`gebi`w gifi`gn`w} e` woi mcy`wu giwiqke`i} fcq |yq|c}i} cf n mqeke`nd |qcmiige`b wonw n gifi`gn`wmonqbig rewo cq n||inde`b n mc`vemwec` cf n fidc`u cq n ke}gikin`cq |y`e}onadi au mc`fe`iki`w e}e`gebi`w cq wonw woi e`wiqi}w} cf hy}wemi qi~yeqiqi|qi}i`wnwec` cf n gifi`gn`w e` woi n mqeke`nd|qcmiige`b$ woi mcyqw cq woi mcyqw}" gi}eb`ii }onddn||ce`w c`i cq kcqi |qnmweme`b nwwcq`iu} wcqi|qi}i`w gifi`g woi gifi`gn`w e` nmmcqgn`mi rewowoe} }ya}imwec` n`g woi |qcmigyqi} ngc|wig y`giq ]ya}imwec` /n%. Ef woi mcyqw cq woi mcyqw}" gi}eb`iigiwiqke`i} wonw woi gifi`gn`w gci} `cw }|inj n`gy`giq}wn`g woi I`bde}o dn`bynbi cq wonw woigifi`gn`w e} ginf$ woi mcyqw cq woi mcyqw}" gi}eb`ii

}ondd knji n` iffcqw wc n||ce`w n` nwwcq`iu roc e}mn|nadi cf mckky`emnwe`b e` n dn`bynbi y`giq}wccgau woi gifi`gn`w.

/g% N |yadem n||ce`wki`w de}w fqck roemo n` nwwcq`iue} n||ce`wig n} qi~yeqig au ]ya}imwec` /n% }onddmc`wne` woi `nki} cf ~yndefeig nwwcq`iu}$ inmo cf rock8

/>% n||dei} wc ai e`mdygig c` woi de}w:

/1% kiiw} woi cahimwevi ~yndefemnwec`} }|imefeigau woi hygbi} y`giq ]ya}imwec` /i%:

/=% kiiw} n`u n||demnadi ~yndefemnwec`} }|imefeigau woi Wixn} Wn}j Fcqmi c` E`gebi`w Gifi`}iMckke}}ec`: n`g

/7% e} n||qcvig au n knhcqewu cf woi hygbi} roci}wnade}oig woi n||ce`wki`w de}w y`giq ]ya}imwec` /i%.

/i% E` n mcy`wu e` roemo n mcyqw e} qi~yeqig y`giq ]ya}imwec` /n% wc n||ce`w n` nwwcq`iu fqck n |yademn||ce`wki`w de}w8

/>% woi hygbi} cf woi mcy`wu mcyqw} n`g }wnwywcqumcy`wu mcyqw} wque`b ke}gikin`cq mn}i} e` woimcy`wu$ au fcqknd nmwec`8

/N% }ondd8

/e% i}wnade}o n |yadem n||ce`wki`w de}w cf nwwcq`iu} ~yndefeig wc |qcvegiqi|qi}i`wnwec` e` woi mcy`wu e`

ke}gikin`cq mn}i} |y`e}onadi aumc`fe`iki`w: n`g

/ee% }|imefu woi cahimwevi ~yndefemnwec`}`imi}}nqu fcq n` nwwcq`iu wc ai e`mdygigc` woi de}w: n`g

/A% knu i}wnade}o$ ef giwiqke`ig au woi hygbi} wc ai n||qc|qenwi$ kcqi won` c`in||ce`wki`w de}w bqngynwig nmmcqge`b wc woigibqii cf }iqecy}`i}} cf woi cffi`}i$ n`gwoi nwwcq`iu}" ~yndefemnwec`}$ n`g roiwoiq qi|qi}i`wnwec` redd ai |qcvegig e` wqend mcyqw|qcmiige`b}$ n||iddnwi |qcmiige`b}$ cq acwo:n`g

/1% woi hygbi} cf woi ge}wqemw mcyqw} wque`b fidc`umn}i} e` woi mcy`wu$ au fcqknd nmwec`8

/N% }ondd8

/e% i}wnade}o n |yadem n||ce`wki`w de}w cf nwwcq`iu} ~yndefeig wc |qcvegiqi|qi}i`wnwec` e` fidc`u mn}i} e` woimcy`wu: n`g

/ee% }|imefu woi cahimwevi ~yndefemnwec`}`imi}}nqu fcq n` nwwcq`iu wc ai e`mdygigc` woi de}w: n`g

/A% knu i}wnade}o$ ef giwiqke`ig au woi hygbi} wc ai n||qc|qenwi$ kcqi won` c`in||ce`wki`w de}w bqngynwig nmmcqge`b wc woi

gibqii cf }iqecy}`i}} cf woi cffi`}i$ n`gwoi nwwcq`iu}" ~yndefemnwec`}$ n`g roiwoiq qi|qi}i`wnwec` redd ai |qcvegig e` wqend mcyqw|qcmiige`b}$ n||iddnwi |qcmiige`b}$ cq acwo.

/f% E` n mcy`wu e` roemo n |yadem gifi`giq‟} cffemi e}mqinwig cq gi}eb`nwig gifi`giq e} n||ce`wig y`giq  Nqwemdi 16.<77$ woi mcyqw cq woi mcyqw}" gi}eb`ii knun||ce`w wonw cffemi woi |yadem gifi`giq wc qi|qi}i`wwoi gifi`gn`w e` nmmcqgn`mi rewo byegide`i}i}wnade}oig fcq woi cffemi|yadem gifi`giq.

/f+>% E` n mcy`wu e` roemo n kn`nbig n}}eb`ig

mcy`}id |qcbqnk e} c|iqnwig e` nmmcqgn`mi rewo Nqwemdi 16.<72$ woi kn`nbig n}}eb`ig mcy`}id|qcbqnk knu n||ce`w mcy`}id wc qi|qi}i`w woigifi`gn`w e` nmmcqgn`mi rewo woi byegide`i}i}wnade}oig fcq woi |qcbqnk.

/b% N mcy`wuregi ndwiq`nwevi |qcbqnk fcq n||ce`we`bmcy`}id fcq e`gebi`w gifi`gn`w} e` mqeke`nd mn}i} e}i}wnade}oig au n fcqknd nmwec` e` roemo wrc+woeqg} cf woi hygbi} cf woi mcyqw} gi}eb`nwig y`giq woe}

Page 26: Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

7/30/2019 Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fair-defense-law-dec-2011-tidc 26/76

 

1<

}ya}imwec` vcwi wc i}wnade}o woi ndwiq`nwevi |qcbqnk. N` ndwiq`nwevi |qcbqnk fcq n||ce`we`b mcy`}id e`ke}gikin`cq n`g fidc`u mn}i} knu ai i}wnade}oige` woi kn``iq |qcvegig au woe} }ya}imwec` au woi hygbi} cf woi mcy`wu mcyqw}$ }wnwywcqu mcy`wu mcyqw}$n`g ge}wqemw mcyqw} wque`b mqeke`nd mn}i} e` woi mcy`wu. N` ndwiq`nwevi |qcbqnk fcq n||ce`we`b mcy`}id e`ke}gikin`cq mn}i} knu ai i}wnade}oig e` woikn``iq |qcvegig au woe} }ya}imwec` au woi hygbi} cf woi mcy`wu mcyqw} n`g }wnwywcqu mcy`wu mcyqw} wque`bmqeke`nd mn}i} e` woi mcy`wu. N` ndwiq`nwevi |qcbqnkfcq n||ce`we`b mcy`}id e` fidc`u mn}i} knu aii}wnade}oig e` woi kn``iq |qcvegig au woe}}ya}imwec` au woi hygbi} cf woi ge}wqemw mcyqw} wque`bmqeke`nd mn}i} e` woi mcy`wu. E` n mcy`wu e` roemo n`ndwiq`nwevi |qcbqnk e} i}wnade}oig8

/>% woi ndwiq`nwevi |qcbqnk knu8

/N% y}i n }e`bdi kiwocg fcq n||ce`we`b

mcy`}id cq n mckae`nwec` cf kiwocg}: n`g

/A% y}i n kydwemcy`wu n||ce`wki`w de}w y}e`bn }u}wik cf qcwnwec`: n`g

/1% woi |qcmigyqi} ngc|wig y`giq ]ya}imwec`/n% ky}w i`}yqi wonw8

/N% nwwcq`iu} n||ce`wig y}e`b woindwiq`nwevi |qcbqnk wc qi|qi}i`w gifi`gn`w}e` ke}gikin`cq mn}i} |y`e}onadi aumc`fe`iki`w8

/e% kiiw }|imefeig cahimwevi~yndefemnwec`} fcq wonw qi|qi}i`wnwec`$roemo knu ai bqngynwig nmmcqge`b wcwoi gibqii cf }iqecy}`i}} cf woi cffi`}in`g roiwoiq qi|qi}i`wnwec` redd ai|qcvegig e` wqend mcyqw |qcmiige`b}$n||iddnwi |qcmiige`b}$ cq acwo$ fcq |qcvege`b qi|qi}i`wnwec` e`ke}gikin`cq mn}i} |y`e}onadi aumc`fe`iki`w: n`g

/ee% nqi n||qcvig au n knhcqewu cf woi hygbi} cf woi mcy`wu mcyqw} n`g

}wnwywcqu mcy`wu mcyqw} wque`bke}gikin`cq mn}i} e` woi mcy`wu:

/A% nwwcq`iu} n||ce`wig y}e`b woindwiq`nwevi |qcbqnk wc qi|qi}i`w gifi`gn`w}e` fidc`u mn}i}8

/e% kiiw }|imefeig cahimwevi~yndefemnwec`} fcq wonw qi|qi}i`wnwec`$roemo knu ai bqngynwig nmmcqge`b wc

woi gibqii cf }iqecy}`i}} cf woi cffi`}in`g roiwoiq qi|qi}i`wnwec` redd ai|qcvegig e` wqend mcyqw |qcmiige`b}$n||iddnwi |qcmiige`b}$ cq acwo$ fcq |qcvege`b qi|qi}i`wnwec` e` fidc`u mn}i}:n`g/ee% nqi n||qcvig au n knhcqewu cf woi hygbi} cf woi ge}wqemw mcyqw} wque`b fidc`umn}i} e` woi mcy`wu:

/M% n||ce`wki`w} fcq gifi`gn`w} e` mn|ewndmn}i} e` roemo woi ginwo |i`ndwu e} }cybowmck|du rewo woi qi~yeqiki`w} cf Nqwemdi16.<91: n`g

/G% n||ce`wki`w} nqi qin}c`nadu n`gek|nqwenddu nddcmnwig nkc`b ~yndefeignwwcq`iu}.

/o% E` n mcy`wu e` roemo n` ndwiq`nwevi |qcbqnk fcq 

n||ce`we`b mcy`}id e} i}wnade}oig n} |qcvegig au]ya}imwec` /b% n`g e} n||qcvig au woi |qi}ege`b hygbi cf woi ngke`e}wqnwevi hygemend qibec`$ n mcyqw cq woi mcyqw}" gi}eb`ii knu n||ce`w n` nwwcq`iu wcqi|qi}i`w n` e`gebi`w gifi`gn`w au y}e`b woindwiq`nwevi |qcbqnk. E` i}wnade}oe`b n` ndwiq`nwevi|qcbqnk y`giq ]ya}imwec` /b%$ woi hygbi} cf woimcyqw} i}wnade}oe`b woi |qcbqnk knu `cw$ rewocyw woin||qcvnd cf woi mckke}}ec`iq} mcyqw$ cadebnwi woimcy`wu au mc`wqnmw cq au woi mqinwec` cf `ir|c}ewec`} wonw mny}i n` e`mqin}i e` ix|i`gewyqi cf mcy`wu fy`g}.

/e% N mcyqw cq woi mcyqw}" gi}eb`ii qi~yeqig y`giq ]ya}imwec` /m% wc n||ce`w n` nwwcq`iu wc qi|qi}i`w ngifi`gn`w nmmy}ig cq mc`vemwig cf n fidc`u knun||ce`w n` nwwcq`iu fqck n`u mcy`wu dcmnwig e` woimcyqw"} ngke`e}wqnwevi hygemend qibec`.

/h% N` nwwcq`iu n||ce`wig y`giq woe} nqwemdi }ondd8

/>% knji iviqu qin}c`nadi iffcqw wc mc`wnmw woigifi`gn`w `cw dnwiq won` woi i`g cf woi feq}wrcqje`b gnu nfwiq woi gnwi c` roemo woi nwwcq`iue} n||ce`wig n`g wc e`wiqveir woi gifi`gn`w n}}cc` n} |qnmwemnadi nfwiq woi nwwcq`iu e}

n||ce`wig: n`g

/1% qi|qi}i`w woi gifi`gn`w y`wed monqbi} nqige}ke}}ig$ woi gifi`gn`w e} nm~yewwig$ n||ind}nqi ixony}wig$ cq woi nwwcq`iu e} |iqkewwig cq cqgiqigqideivig cf oe} gywei} au woi mcyqw wcrewogqnr n} mcy`}id fcq woi gifi`gn`w cq qi|dnmig au cwoiq mcy`}id nfwiq n fe`ge`b cf bccgmny}i e} i`wiqig c` woi qimcqg: n`g.

Page 27: Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

7/30/2019 Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fair-defense-law-dec-2011-tidc 27/76

 

1>

/=% rewo qi}|imw wc n gifi`gn`w `cw qi|qi}i`wigau cwoiq mcy`}id$ aifcqi rewogqnre`b n} mcy`}idfcq woi gifi`gn`w nfwiq n wqend cq woi i`wqu cf n|din cf byedwu8

/N% ngve}i woi gifi`gn`w cf woi gifi`gn`w"}qebow wc fedi n kcwec` fcq `ir wqend n`g n`cwemi cf n||ind:

/A% ef woi gifi`gn`w re}oi} wc |yq}yi iewoiq cq acwo qikigei} gi}mqeaig au \nqnbqn|o/N%$ n}}e}w woi gifi`gn`w e` qi~yi}we`b woi|qck|w n||ce`wki`w cf qi|dnmiki`w mcy`}id:n`g

/M% ef qi|dnmiki`w mcy`}id e} `cw n||ce`wig|qck|wdu n`g woi gifi`gn`w re}oi} wc|yq}yi n` n||ind$ fedi n wekidu `cwemi cf n||ind.

/j% N mcyqw knu qi|dnmi n` nwwcq`iu roc vecdnwi}]ya}imwec` /h%/>% rewo cwoiq mcy`}id. N knhcqewu cf woi hygbi} cf woi mcy`wu mcyqw} n`g }wnwywcqu mcy`wumcyqw} cq woi ge}wqemw mcyqw}$ n} n||qc|qenwi$ wque`bmqeke`nd mn}i} e` woi mcy`wu knu qikcvi fqckmc`}egiqnwec` fcq n||ce`wki`w n` nwwcq`iu roce`wi`wec`nddu cq qi|inwigdu vecdnwi} ]ya}imwec` /h%/>%.

/d% \qcmigyqi} ngc|wig y`giq ]ya}imwec` /n% ky}we`mdygi |qcmigyqi} n`g fe`n`mend }wn`gnqg} fcq giwiqke`e`b roiwoiq n gifi`gn`w e} e`gebi`w. Woi|qcmigyqi} n`g }wn`gnqg} }ondd n||du wc inmogifi`gn`w e` woi mcy`wu i~ynddu$ qibnqgdi}} cf 

roiwoiq woi gifi`gn`w e} e` my}wcgu cq on} aii`qidin}ig c` aned.

/k% E` giwiqke`e`b roiwoiq n gifi`gn`w e} e`gebi`w$woi mcyqw cq woi mcyqw}" gi}eb`ii knu mc`}egiq woigifi`gn`w"} e`mcki$ }cyqmi cf e`mcki$ n}}iw}$|qc|iqwu cr`ig$ cyw}wn`ge`b cadebnwec`}$ `imi}}nquix|i`}i}$ woi `ykaiq n`g nbi} cf gi|i`gi`w}$ n`g}|cy}nd e`mcki wonw e} nvnednadi wc woi gifi`gn`w.Woi mcyqw cq woi mcyqw}" gi}eb`ii knu `cw mc`}egiq roiwoiq woi gifi`gn`w on} |c}wig cq e} mn|nadi cf |c}we`b aned$ ixmi|w wc woi ixwi`w wonw ew qifdimw} woigifi`gn`w"} fe`n`mend meqmyk}wn`mi} n} kin}yqig au

woi mc`}egiqnwec`} de}wig e` woe} }ya}imwec`.

/`% N gifi`gn`w roc qi~yi}w} n giwiqke`nwec` cf e`gebi`mu n`g n||ce`wki`w cf mcy`}id }ondd8

/>% mck|diwi y`giq cnwo n ~yi}wec``neqimc`miq`e`b oe} fe`n`mend qi}cyqmi}:

/1% qi}|c`g y`giq cnwo wc n` ixnke`nwec`qibnqge`b oe} fe`n`mend qi}cyqmi} au woi hygbi cq 

knbe}wqnwi qi}|c`}eadi fcq giwiqke`e`b roiwoiq woi gifi`gn`w e} e`gebi`w: cq 

/=% mck|diwi woi ~yi}wec``neqi n`g qi}|c`g wcixnke`nwec` au woi hygbi cq knbe}wqnwi.

/c% Aifcqi knje`b n giwiqke`nwec` cf roiwoiq ngifi`gn`w e} e`gebi`w$ woi mcyqw }ondd qi~yi}w woigifi`gn`w wc }eb` y`giq cnwo n }wnwiki`w}ya}wn`wenddu e` woi fcddcre`b fcqk8 !C` woe} SSSSSSSS gnu cf SSSSSSSSSSSS$ 1< SSS$ E onviaii` ngve}ig au woi /`nki cf woi mcyqw% Mcyqw cf kuqebow wc qi|qi}i`wnwec` au mcy`}id e` mc``imwec` rewowoi wqend cf woi monqbi |i`ge`b nbne`}w ki. E miqwefuwonw E nk rewocyw kin`} wc ik|dcu mcy`}id cf kucr` mocc}e`b n`g E oiqiau qi~yi}w woi mcyqw wcn||ce`w mcy`}id fcq ki. /}eb`nwyqi cf woigifi`gn`w%!

/|% N gifi`gn`w roc e} giwiqke`ig au woi mcyqw wc ai

e`gebi`w e} |qi}ykig wc qikne` e`gebi`w fcq woiqikne`giq cf woi |qcmiige`b} e` woi mn}i y`di}} nknwiqend mon`bi e` woi gifi`gn`w"} fe`n`mendmeqmyk}wn`mi} cmmyq}. Ef woiqi e} n knwiqend mon`bie` fe`n`mend meqmyk}wn`mi} nfwiq n giwiqke`nwec` cf e`gebi`mu cq `c`+e`gebi`mu e} kngi$ woi gifi`gn`w$woi gifi`gn`w"} mcy`}id$ cq woi nwwcq`iu qi|qi}i`we`bwoi }wnwi knu kcvi fcq qimc`}egiqnwec` cf woigiwiqke`nwec`.

/~% N rqewwi` cq cqnd }wnwiki`w idemewig y`giq woe}nqwemdi cq ivegi`mi giqevig fqck woi }wnwiki`w knu`cw ai y}ig fcq n`u |yq|c}i$ ixmi|w wc giwiqke`i

woi gifi`gn`w"} e`gebi`mu cq wc ek|inmo woi geqimwwi}wekc`u cf woi gifi`gn`w. Woe} }ya}imwec` gci}`cw |qcoeaew |qc}imywec` cf woi gifi`gn`w y`giq Mon|wiq =2$ \i`nd Mcgi.

/q% N mcyqw knu `cw woqinwi` wc nqqi}w cq e`mnqmiqnwin |iq}c` }cdidu aimny}i woi |iq}c` qi~yi}w} woin}}e}wn`mi cf mcy`}id.

Nki`gki`w} wc /n%$ /g%$ n`g /f% n`g nggewec` cf /f+>% iffimwevi ]i|w. >$ 1<>> /OA >297$ ¢1<%.

Nki`gki`w} wc /n%$ /m%$ /i%$ /b%$ /e%$ /h%$ n`g /c% iffimwevi ]i|w. >$1<>> /]A >6?>$ ¢7%. ]imwec` = |qcvegi}8 — Woi mon`bi e` dnr kngi au woe} Nmw n||dei} c`du wc n mqeke`nd |qcmiige`b wonw mckki`mi} c` cq nfwiq woi iffimwevi gnwi cf woe} Nmw. N mqeke`nd |qcmiige`b wonw mckki`mi} aifcqi woi iffimwevi gnwi cf woe} Nmw e} bcviq`ig au woi dnr e` iffimw roi` woi |qcmiige`b mckki`mig$ n`g woi fcqkiq dnr e} mc`we`yig e` iffimw fcq wonw |yq|c}i.! 

1<>> Dibe}dnwevi @cwi]A >6?> nki`g} }ya}imwec`} /n%$ /m%$ /i%$ /b%$ /e%$n`g /c% wc qi~yeqi woi mcyqw} wc e`mdygi woi|qcmigyqi} fcq n||ce`we`b mcy`}id fcq e`gebi`wgifi`gn`w} n||inde`b n mc`vemwec` cf fidc`ei} cq 

Page 28: Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

7/30/2019 Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fair-defense-law-dec-2011-tidc 28/76

Page 29: Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

7/30/2019 Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fair-defense-law-dec-2011-tidc 29/76

 

1=

fqck woi fnmi cf woi qimcqg. Ay`wec` v. Onqkc` $ ?12].R.1g 579$ 575 /Wix. Mqek. N||. >551%: ]ii nd}c]wcww} v. Re}}iq $ ?57 ].R.1g =66$ =6? /Wix. Mqek. N||. >559%.

Wqend mcy`}id$ qiwne`ig cq n||ce`wig$ on} woi gywu wcmc`}ydw rewo n`g fyddu wc ngve}i mdei`w} mc`miq`e`bwoi kin`e`b n`g iffimw cf woi hygbki`w qi`giqig auwoi mcyqw$ woieq qebow wc n||ind fqck wonw hygbki`w$n`g woi `imi}}ewu cf beve`b `cwemi cf n||ind n`gwnje`b cwoiq }wi|} wc |yq}yi n` n||ind. Ix |nqwi Nxid $ 292 ].R.1g =65$ =27 /Wix. Mqek. N||. >55?%.Mcy`}id }ocydg nd}c ge}my}} |c}}eadi bqcy`g} fcq n||ind n`g woieq kiqew$ n`g gide`inwi woi ngvn`wnbi}n`g ge}ngvn`wnbi} cf n||ind. Eg. nw =27.Roi` gifi`gn`w‟} wqend mcy`}id gci} `cw rewogqnrfqck qi|qi}i`wnwec` nfwiq }i`wi`me`b n`g e} `cwqi|dnmig au `ir mcy`}id$ n qiaywwnadi |qi}yk|wec`ixe}w} wonw wqend mcy`}id mc`we`yig wc iffimweviduqi|qi}i`w oek gyqe`b woi weki fcq fede`b n kcwec` fcq 

`ir wqend. ]ii ]kewo v. ]wnwi $ >2 ].R.=g 66<$ 661/Wix. Mqek. N||. 1<<<% /~ycwe`b Cdgonk v. ]wnwi $522 ].R.1g =97$ =6= /Wix. Mqek. N||. >55?%%. 

E` cqgiq fcq n gifi`gn`w wc ai mc`}egiqig ’e`gebi`w‖n`g qimievi n fqii n||iddnwi qimcqg$ woi gifi`gn`wky}w knji n |qekn fnmei  }ocre`b cf e`gebi`mi.Wymj v. ]wnwi $ 1>9 ].R.=g 7>>$ 7>9 /Wix. Mqek. N||.1<<2% /~ycwe`b Roewioing v. ]wnwi $ e`fqn%.  Woi Mcyqwcf Mqeke`nd N||ind} ek|deig wonw woi wrc+}wi||qcmi}} }ocydg nd}c ai y}ig wc giwiqke`i roiwoiq wc n||ce`w mcy`}id fcq n` n||ind. ]ii Roewioing v.]wnwi $ >=< ].R.=g ?66$ ?27 /Wix. Mqek. N||. 1<<7%. 

Roedi woi}i e`~yeqei} bi`iqnddu e`vcdvi woi }nkifnmwcq}$ ew e} |c}}eadi fcq n gifi`gn`w wc ai e`gebi`w e`c`i mc`wixw ayw `cw woi cwoiq$ gi|i`ge`b |qe`me|ndduc` woi qi}|imwevi mc}w} cf inmo. Roewioing $ >=<].R.=g nw ?2?: ]ii nd}c Mn}weddc v. ]wnwi $ 959].R.1g 991 /Wix. Mqek. N||. >5?<%.

Woi wqend mcyqw e} `cw mck|diwidu fqii wc ge}aideivi woigifi`gn`w‟} nddibnwec`} mc`miq`e`b oe} cr` fe`n`mend}wnwy} roi` giwiqke`e`b e`gebi`mi$ ayw woi wqendmcyqw knu ge}aideivi n` nddibnwec` ef woiqi e} nqin}c`nadi$ nqwemydnadi an}e} fcq gce`b }c$ iewoiq aimny}i woiqi e} mc`fdemwe`b ivegi`mi cq aimny}i woi

ivegi`mi }yakewwig e} e` }cki kn``iq }y}|imw cq giwiqke`ig au woi mcyqw wc ai e`ngi~ynwi.Roewioing $ >=< ].R.=g nw ?26. N` e`~yequ e`wc woiqin}c`nadi`i}} cf woi gifi`gn`w‟} ix|i`}i} e}n||qc|qenwi e` cqgiq wc giwiqke`i roiwoiq ngifi`gn`w mn` |nu fcq n` n||iddnwi qimcqg. Wymj $1>9 ].R.=g nw 7>6.

]yakewwe`b n` ’e`mcki n`g ix|i`}i }ykknqu‖ n`gn ’`iw rcqwo }wnwiki`w$‖ ndc`b rewo n }eb`ig nffegnvew

nwwi}we`b wc woi wqywo cf woi}i gcmyki`w}$ }iqvig woi}nki |yq|c}i n} n`}riqe`b n rqewwi` ~yi}wec``neqin`g woy} }yffemig wc kiiw woi qi~yeqiki`w} cf Nqw.16.<7/`%/>%. Roewioing $ >=< ].R.=g. nw ?22.

 N` e`gevegynd‟} `ibnwevi `iw rcqwo gci} `cw`imi}}nqedu wqn`}dnwi e`wc e`gebi`mi. Eg. nw ?2?. Woiqind ~yi}wec` e} roiwoiq woi gifi`gn`w e} mn|nadi cf |nue`b fcq dibnd mcy`}id n`g fcq woi n||iddnwi qimcqg.Eg. 

 N |iq}c` knu `cw wqn`}fiq oe} n}}iw} roedi nrnewe`bwqend$ nfwiq nddibe`b e`gebi`mi$ }c wonw oi knu qimievin||ce`wki`w cf mcy`}id$ n fqii wqn`}mqe|w$ n`g fqii}wnwiki`w cf fnmw}. Mnqgc`n v. Knq}ondd $ 6=9 ].R.1g27>$ 27= /Wix. Mqek. N||. >5?1%. N gifi`gn`w$ocriviq$ }ocydg `cw ai gi`eig n||ce`wki`w cf mcy`}id }cdidu aimny}i cwoiq kikaiq} cf oe} fnkeduonvi n}}iw} n`g e`mcki. Eg. nw 27= /~ycwe`b Y`ewig ]wnwi} v. Qyae`}c` $ 97= F.1g 59> /1`g Meq.%$ miqw.

gi`eig%.

Nqw. 16.<77. \yadem Gifi`giq―} CffemiGifi`giq 

/n% E` woe} mon|wiq8

/>% ’Bcviq`ki`wnd i`wewu‖ e`mdygi} n mcy`wu$ nbqcy| cf mcy`wei}$ n gi|nqwki`w aqn`mo cq nbi`mu cf n mcy`wu$ n` ngke`e}wqnwevi hygemendqibec` mqinwig au ]imwec` 27.<71$ Bcviq`ki`wMcgi$ n`g n`u i`wewu mqinwig y`giq woiE`wiqdcmnd Mcc|iqnwec` Nmw n} |iqkewwig auMon|wiq 25>$ Bcviq`ki`w Mcgi.

/1% ’Cffemi cf mn|ewnd rqew}‖ kin`} woi cffemi cf mn|ewnd rqew} i}wnade}oig y`giq ]yamon|wiq A$Mon|wiq 2?$ Bcviq`ki`w Mcgi.

/=% ’Cviq}ebow acnqg‖ kin`} n` cviq}ebow acnqgi}wnade}oig e` nmmcqgn`mi rewo Nqwemdi16.<79.

/7% ’\yadem gifi`giq‟} cffemi‖gifi`giq‖ kin`}n` i`wewu wonw8

/N% e} iewoiq8

/e% n bcviq`ki`wnd i`wewu: cq 

/e%/ee% n `c`|qcfew mcq|cqnwec`c|iqnwe`b y`giq n rqewwi`nbqiiki`w rewo n bcviq`ki`wndi`wewu$ cwoiq won` n` e`gevegynd hygbi cq mcyqw: n`g8

Page 30: Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

7/30/2019 Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fair-defense-law-dec-2011-tidc 30/76

 

17

/N% c|iqnwe`b y`giq n rqewwi` nbqiiki`w rewon bcviq`ki`wnd i`wewu$ cwoiq won` n`e`gevegynd hygbi cq mcyqw:

/A% y}i}y}e`b |yadem fy`g} wc |qcvegi dibndqi|qi}i`wnwec` n`g }iqvemi} wc e`gebi`wgifi`gn`w} nmmy}ig cf n mqeki cq hyvi`edicffi`}i$ n} woc}i wiqk} nqi gife`ig au]imwec` 25.<<>$ Bcviq`ki`w Mcgi.: n`g

/M% |qcvege`b dibnd qi|qi}i`wnwec` n`g}iqvemi} wc e`gebi`w gifi`gn`w} nmmy}ig cf nmqeki cq hyvi`edi cffi`}i$ n} woc}i wiqk} nqigife`ig au ]imwec` 2>.<<>$ Bcviq`ki`wMcgi.

/=% !Cffemi cf mn|ewnd rqew}! kin`} woi cffemi cf mn|ewnd rqew} i}wnade}oig y`giq ]yamon|wiq A$ Mon|wiq 2?$ Bcviq`ki`w Mcgi.

/a% Woi mckke}}ec`iq} mcyqw cf n`u mcy`wu$ c`rqewwi` n||qcvnd cf n hygbi cf n mcy`wu mcyqw$}wnwywcqu mcy`wu mcyqw$ cq ge}wqemw mcyqw wque`b mqeke`ndmn}i} cq mn}i} y`giq Wewdi =$ Fnkedu Mcgi$ e` woimcy`wu$ knu mqinwi n gi|nqwki`w cf woi mcy`wu cq au mc`wqnmw knu gi}eb`nwi n n||ce`w n bcviq`ki`wndi`wewu cq `c`|qcfew mcq|cqnwec` wc }iqvi n} n |yademgifi`giq‟} cffemigifi`giq. Woi mckke}}ec`iq}mcyqw} cf wrc cq kcqi mcy`wei} knu i`wiq e`wc nrqewwi` nbqiiki`w wc hce`wdu mqinwi cq gi}eb`nwin||ce`w n`g hce`wdu fy`g n qibec`nd |yademgifi`giq‟} cffemi gifi`giq . E` mqinwe`b cq gi}eb`nwe`bn||ce`we`b n |yadem gifi`giq‟} cffemi

gifi`giq y`giq woe} }ya}imwec`$ woi mckke}}ec`iq}mcyqw }ondd }|imefu cq woi mckke}}ec`iq} mcyqw} }ondd hce`wdu }|imefu$ ef mqinwe`b cq gi}eb`nwe`b n||ce`we`b nqibec`nd |yadem gifi`giq‟} cffemigifi`giq8

/>% woi gywei} cf woi |yadem gifi`giq‟}cffemigifi`giq:

/1% woi wu|i} cf mn}i} wc roemo woi |yademgifi`giq‟} cffemigifi`giq knu ai n||ce`wigy`giq Nqwemdi 16.<7/f% n`g woi mcyqw} e` roemo n`nwwcq`iu ik|dcuig au woi |yadem gifi`giq‟}cffemigifi`giq knu ai qi~yeqig wc n||inq:

/=% ef woi |yadem gifi`giq"} cffemi e} n `c`|qcfewmcq|cqnwec`$ woi wiqk gyqe`b roemo woi mc`wqnmwgi}eb`nwe`b woi |yadem gifi`giq"} cffemi e}iffimwevi n`g ocr wonw mc`wqnmw knu ai qi`irigc` ix|eqnwec` cf woi wiqkroiwoiq woi |yademgifi`giq e} n||ce`wig wc }iqvi n wiqk cq }iqvi nwwoi |din}yqi cf woi mckke}}ec`iq} mcyqw cq woimckke}}ec`iq} mcyqw}: n`g

/7% ef n` cviq}ebow acnqg e} i}wnade}oig y`giq  Nqwemdi 16.<79 fcq woi |yadem gifi`giq"} cffemi$woi |criq} n`g gywei} wonw onvi aii` gidibnwigwc woi cviq}ebow acnqgwoi |yadem gifi`giq e}n||ce`wig wc }iqvi n wiqk$ woi wiqk cf n||ce`wki`w n`g woi |qcmigyqi} fcq qikcve`bwoi |yadem gifi`giq.

/a+>% Woi n||demnadi mckke}}ec`iq} mcyqw cq mckke}}ec`iq} mcyqw} }ondd qi~yeqi n rqewwi` |dn`fqck n bcviq`ki`wnd i`wewu }iqve`b n} n |yademgifi`giq"} cffemi.

/m% Aifcqi mc`wqnmwe`b rewo n `c`|qcfew mcq|cqnwec` wc}iqvi n} n||ce`we`b n |yadem gifi`giq‟}cffemigifi`giq y`giq ]ya}imwec` /a%$ woimckke}}ec`iq} mcyqw cq mckke}}ec`iq} mcyqw} }ondd}cdemew |qc|c}nd} fcq woi |yadem gifi`giq‟} cffemigifi`giq.

/m+>% N rqewwi` |dn` y`giq ]ya}imwec` /a+>% cq n|qc|c}nd ky}w e`mdygi8

/>% n aygbiw fcq woi |yadem gifi`giq‟} cffemigifi`giq$ e`mdyge`b }ndnqei}:

/1% n gi}mqe|wec` cf inmo |iq}c``id |c}ewec`$e`mdyge`b woi moeif |yadem gifi`giq |c}ewec`:

/=% woi knxekyk nddcrnadi mn}idcng} fcq inmonwwcq`iu ik|dcuig au woi |yadem gifi`giq‟}cffemi|qc|c`i`w:

/7% |qcve}ec`} fcq |iq}c``id wqne`e`b:

/9% n gi}mqe|wec` cf n`weme|nwig cviqoing mc}w}fcq woi |yadem gifi`giq‟} cffemigifi`giq: n`g

/6% |cdemei} qibnqge`b woi y}i cf demi`}ige`vi}webnwcq} n`g ix|iqw rew`i}}i} au woi |yademgifi`giq‟} cffemi: n`g

/2% n |cdemu wc i`}yqi wonw woi moeif |yademgifi`giq n`g cwoiq nwwcq`iu} ik|dcuig au woi|yadem gifi`giq"} cffemi gc `cw |qcvegiqi|qi}i`wnwec` wc n gifi`gn`w ef gce`b }c rcydg

mqinwi n mc`fdemw cf e`wiqi}w wonw on} `cw aii`rnevig au woi mdei`w|qc|c`i`w.

/g% Nfwiq mc`}egiqe`b inmo |qc|c}nd fcq woi |yademgifi`giq‟} cffemigifi`giq }yakewwig au nbcviq`ki`wnd i`wewu cq `c`|qcfew mcq|cqnwec` y`giq ]ya}imwec` /m%$ woi mckke}}ec`iq} mcyqw cq mckke}}ec`iq} mcyqw} }ondd }idimw n |qc|c}nd wonwqin}c`nadu gikc`}wqnwi} wonw woi |yadem gifi`giq‟}cffemi|qc|c`i`w redd |qcvegi ngi~ynwi ~yndewu

Page 31: Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

7/30/2019 Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fair-defense-law-dec-2011-tidc 31/76

 

19

qi|qi}i`wnwec` fcq e`gebi`w gifi`gn`w} e` woi mcy`wucq mcy`wei}.

/i% Woi wcwnd mc}w cf woi |qc|c}nd y`giq ]ya}imwec`/m% knu `cw ai woi }cdi mc`}egiqnwec` e` }idimwe`b n|qc|c}nd.

/f% N Wc ai idebeadi fcq n||ce`wki`w n} n |yademgifi`giq‟} cffemi ky}w ai geqimwig au n moeif |yademgifi`giq roc8

/>% e} n kikaiq cf woi ]wnwi Anq cf Wixn}:

/1% on} |qnmwemig dnr fcq nw din}w woqii uinq}:n`g

/=% on} }ya}wn`wend ix|iqei`mi e` woi |qnmwemi cf mqeke`nd dnr.

/b% N |yadem gifi`giq‟} cffemigifi`giq e} i`wewdig wc

qimievi fy`g} fcq |iq}c``id mc}w} n`g ix|i`}i}e`myqqig e` c|iqnwe`b n} n |yadem gifi`giq‟}cffemigifi`giq e` nkcy`w} fexig au woimckke}}ec`iq} mcyqw n`g |neg cyw cf woi n||qc|qenwimcy`wu fy`g$ cq hce`wdu fexig au woi mckke}}ec`iq}mcyqw} n`g |qc|cqwec`nwidu |neg cyw cf inmon||qc|qenwi mcy`wu fy`g ef woi |yadem gifi`giq‟}cffemigifi`giq }iqvi} kcqi won` c`i mcy`wu.

/o% N |yadem gifi`giq‟} cffemigifi`giq knu ik|dcunwwcq`iu}$ demi`}ig e`vi}webnwcq}$ n`g cwoiq |iq}c``id `imi}}nqu wc |iqfcqk woi gywei} cf woi|yadem gifi`giq‟} cffemigifi`giq n} }|imefeig au woi

mckke}}ec`iq} mcyqw cq mckke}}ec`iq} mcyqw} y`giq ]ya}imwec` /a%/>%.

/e% Ixmi|w n} nywocqeig au woe} nqwemdi$ woi moeif |yadem gifi`giq n`g cwoiq nwwcq`iu} cq n` nwwcq`iuik|dcuig au n |yadem gifi`giq‟} cffemi gifi`giq knu `cw8

/>% i`bnbi e` woi |qevnwi |qnmwemi cf mqeke`nddnr: cq 

/1% nmmi|w n`uwoe`b cf vndyi `cw nywocqeig auwoe} nqwemdi fcq }iqvemi} qi`giqig y`giq woe}

nqwemdi.

/h% N |yadem gifi`giq‟} cffemigifi`giq knu `cw nmmi|wqify}i n` n||ce`wki`w y`giq Nqwemdi 16.<7/f% ef8

/>% n mc`fdemw cf e`wiqi}w ixe}w} wonw on} `cw aii`rnevig au woi mdei`w:

/1% woi |yadem gifi`giq‟} cffemi gifi`giq on}e`}yffemei`w

qi}cyqmi} wc |qcvegi ngi~ynwi qi|qi}i`wnwec`fcq woi gifi`gn`w:

/=% woi |yadem gifi`giq‟} cffemi gifi`giq e}e`mn|nadi cf |qcvege`b qi|qi}i`wnwec` fcq woigifi`gn`w e` nmmcqgn`mi rewo woi qydi} cf |qcfi}}ec`nd mc`gymw: cq 

/7% woi |yadem gifi`giq‟} cffemi gifi`giq }ocr}cwoiq bccg mny}i fcq `cw nmmi|we`b qify}e`b woin||ce`wki`w.

/j% Woi hygbi knu qikcvi fqck n mn}i n |iq}c`|yadem gifi`giq roc vecdnwi} n |qcve}ec` cf ]ya}imwec` /e% .

/d% N |yadem gifi`giq‟} cffemi gifi`giq knue`vi}webnwi woi fe`n`mend mc`gewec` cf n`u |iq}c` woi|yadem gifi`giq‟} cffemigifi`giq e} n||ce`wig wcqi|qi}i`w. Woi |yadem gifi`giq‟} cffemigifi`giq 

}ondd qi|cqw woi qi}ydw} cf woi e`vi}webnwec` wc woin||ce`we`b hygbi. Woi hygbi knu ocdg n oinqe`b wcgiwiqke`i ef woi |iq}c` e} e`gebi`w n`g i`wewdig wcqi|qi}i`wnwec` y`giq woe} nqwemdi.

/k% Ef ew e} `imi}}nqu wonw n` nwwcq`iu roc e} `cwik|dcuig au cwoiq won` n |yadem gifi`giq‟}cffemigifi`giq ai n||ce`wig$ woi nwwcq`iu e} i`wewdigwc woi mck|i`}nwec` |qcvegig au Nqwemdi 16.<9 cf woe}mcgi.

/`% N` nwwcq`iu ik|dcuig au n |yadem gifi`giq"}cffemi knu ai n||ce`wig rewo qi}|imw wc n`

n||demnwec` fcq n rqew cf onain} mcq|y} c`du ef8/>% n` nwwcq`iu ik|dcuig au woi cffemi cf mn|ewnd

rqew} e} `cw n||ce`wig e` woi mn}i: n`g/1% woi nwwcq`iu ik|dcuig au woi |yadem

gifi`giq"} cffemi e} c` woi de}w cf mck|iwi`wmcy`}id kne`wne`ig y`giq ]imwec` 2?.<96$Bcviq`ki`w Mcgi.

Nki`gki`w} cf /n%$ /a%$ /m%$ /g%$ /i%$ /f%$ /b%$ /o%$ /e%$ /h%$ /j%$ /d%$ n`g /k% n`g nggewec` cf /a+>% n`g /m+>% iffimwevi ]i|w. >$ 1<>> /OA >297$ ¢1<%.

1<>> Dibe}dnwevi @cwiOA >297 nki`g} /n% wc e`mdygi gife`ewec`} fcq ’cffemi

cf mn|ewnd rqew}‖ n`g ’cviq}ebow acnqg‖$ qigife`i’bcviq`ki`wnd i`wewu‖$ n`g qi|dnmi woi gife`ewec` cf ’|yadem gifi`giq‖ rewo ’|yadem gifi`giq‟} cffemi‖. 

OA >297 nki`g} /a% wc |qcvegi wonw nmckke}}ec`iq} mcyqw cf n`u mcy`wu knu mqinwi ngi|nqwki`w cf woi mcy`wu cq mn`$ au mc`wqnmw$gi}eb`nwi n `c`|qcfew mcq|cqnwec` wc }iqvi n} n|yadem gifi`giq‟} cffemi$ rewo woi n||qcvnd cf n hygbi

Page 32: Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

7/30/2019 Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fair-defense-law-dec-2011-tidc 32/76

 

16

cf n mcy`wu mcyqw$ }wnwywcqu mcy`wu mcyqw}$ cq ge}wqemwmcyqw wque`b mqeke`nd mn}i} cq mn}i} y`giq Wewdi =$Fnkedu Mcgi$ e` woi mcy`wu n`g |qcvegi}qi~yeqiki`w} wonw woi mckke}}ec`iq} mcyqw ky}w}|imefu e` mqinwe`b n |yadem gifi`giq‟} cffemi. 

OA >297 ngg} /a+>% wc qi~yeqi woi mckke}}ec`iq}mcyqw wc qi~yeqi n rqewwi` |dn` fqck n bcviq`ki`wndi`wewu }iqve`b n} n |yadem gifi`giq‟} cffemi. 

OA >297 nki`g} /m% wc qi~yeqi n mcy`wu wc }cdemew|qc|c}nd} aifcqi i`wiqe`b e`wc n mc`wqnmw rewo n`c`|qcfew mcq|cqnwec` wc }iqvi n} |yadem gifi`giq.Woi }cdemewnwec` qi~yeqiki`w `c dc`biq n||dei} ef nmcy`wu mocc}i} wc mqinwi n mcy`wu gi|nqwki`w wc}iqvi n} woi |yadem gifi`giq‟} cffemi 

OA >297 ngg} /m+>% wc |qcvegi qi~yeqiki`w} fcq nrqewwi` |dn` fcq n mcy`wu gi|nqwki`w y`giq /a+>% cq n|qc|c}nd fqck n `c`|qcfew mcq|cqnwec` fcq n |yadem

gifi`giq‟} cffemi y`giq /m%.

OA >297 nki`g} /f% wc qi~yeqi wonw woi moeif |yademgifi`giq geqimwe`b woi |yadem gifi`giq‟} cffemi onvimiqwne` ~yndefemnwec`}.

OA >297 nki`g} /h% wc |qcoeaew n |yadem gifi`giq‟}cffemi fqck nmmi|we`b n` n||ce`wki`w y`giq Nqw.16.<7/f% ef n mc`fdemw cf e`wiqi}w ixe}w} n`g ew on} `cwaii` rnevig au woi mdei`w.

OA >297 nki`g} /k% wc |qcvegi wonw ef ew e}`imi}}nqu wc n||ce`w n` nwwcq`iu `cw ik|dcuig au n

|yadem nwwcq`iu‟} cffemi$ woi nwwcq`iu e} i`wewdig wc woimck|i`}nwec` |qcvegig au Nqw. 16.<9.

OA>297 knji} mc`fcqke`b n`g `c`}ya}wn`wevimon`bi} wc /a%$ /m%$ /m+>%$ /g%$ /i%$ /f%$ /b%$ /o%$ /e%$ /h%n`g /d% wc ge}we`bye}o aiwrii` n |yadem gifi`giq‟}cffemi n`g n` nwwcq`iu e` }ymo n` cffemi.

Mckki`wnqu Nfwiq woi mckke}}ec`iq} mcyqw on} i}wnade}oig n|yadem gifi`giq‟} cffemi |yq}yn`w wc Nqw. 16.<77$Mcgi cf Mqeke`nd \qcmigyqi$ ew qikne`} cadebnwig wc|nu nwwcq`iu} n||ce`wig au wqend mcyqw} wc qi|qi}i`w

e`gebi`w gifi`gn`w} n`g ky}w geqimw |nuki`w cf woifydd nkcy`w cf nwwcq`iu fii} cqgiqig au n mcyqw y`giq  Nqw. 16.<9 y`di}} ew mn` }ocr wonw woi wqend mcyqw‟}nrnqg e} }c y`qin}c`nadi n} wc nkcy`w wc n` nay}icf ge}mqiwec`. C|. Wix. Nww―u Bi`. DC+<6= />552%.

Nqw. 16.<79. \YADEM GIFI@GIQ CVIQ]EBOWACNQG.

/n% Woi mckke}}ec`iq} mcyqw cf n mcy`wu cq woimckke}}ec`iq} mcyqw} cf wrc cq kcqi mcy`wei} knui}wnade}o n` cviq}ebow acnqg fcq n |yadem gifi`giq"}cffemi mqinwig cq gi}eb`nwig e` nmmcqgn`mi rewo woe}mon|wiq.

/a% Woi mckke}}ec`iq} mcyqw cq mcyqw} wonw i}wnade}on` cviq}ebow acnqg y`giq woe} nqwemdi }ondd n||ce`wkikaiq} cf woi acnqg. Kikaiq} knu e`mdygi c`icq kcqi cf woi fcddcre`b8

/>% n` nwwcq`iu:

/1% woi hygbi cf n wqend mcyqw e woe} }wnwi:

/=% n mcy`wu mckke}}ec`iq:

/7% n mcy`wu hygbi:

/9% n mckky`ewu qi|qi}i`wnwevi: n`g

/6% n fcqkiq mdei`w cq n fnkedu kikaiq cf nfcqkiq mdei`w cf woi |yadem gifi`giq"} cffemifcq roemo woi cviq}ebow acnqg rn}i}wnade}oig y`giq woe} nqwemdi.

/m% Woi mckke}}ec`iq} mcyqw cq mcyqw} knu gidibnwiwc woi acnqg n`u |criq cq gywu cf woi mckke}}ec`iq}mcyqw wc |qcvegi cviq}ebow cf woi cffemi y`giq Nqwemdi16.<77$ e`mdyge`b8

/>% qimckki`ge`b }idimwec` n`g qikcvnd cf n moeif |yadem gifi`giq:

/1% }iwwe`b |cdemu fcq woi cffemi: n`g

/=% gividc|e`b n aygbiw |qc|c}nd fcq woicffemi.

/g% N` cviq}ebow acnqg i}wnade}oig y`giq woe} nqwemdiknu `cw bne` nmmi}} wc |qevedibig cq mc`fegi`wende`fcqknwec`.

Nggewec` cf Nqw. 16.<79 iffimwevi ]i|w. >$ 1<>> /OA >297 ¢1<%.

1<>> Dibe}dnwevi @cwiOA >297 ngg} woe} nqwemdi wc mqinwi n |yadem gifi`giq cviq}ebow acnqg n`g }iw fcqwo roc knu ai n kikaiq cf woi acnqg n`g ronw |criq} woi acnqg knu onvi.

Page 33: Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

7/30/2019 Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fair-defense-law-dec-2011-tidc 33/76

 

12

Nqw. 16.<72. Kn`nbig N}}eb`ig Mcy`}id\qcbqnk/n% E` woe} nqwemdi8

/>% !Bcviq`ki`wnd i`wewu! on} woi kin`e`bn}}eb`ig au Nqwemdi 16.<77./1% !Kn`nbig n}}eb`ig mcy`}id |qcbqnk!cq !|qcbqnk! kin`} n |qcbqnk c|iqnwigrewo |yadem fy`g}8

/N% au n bcviq`ki`wnd i`wewu$`c`|qcfew mcq|cqnwec`$ cq anq n}}cmenwec` y`giq n rqewwi`nbqiiki`w rewo n bcviq`ki`wndi`wewu$ cwoiq won` n` e`gevegynd hygbicq mcyqw: n`g

/A% fcq woi |yq|c}i cf n||ce`we`bmcy`}id y`giq Nqwemdi 16.<7 cf woe}

mcgi cq ]imwec` 9>.><$ Fnkedu Mcgi.

/a% Woi mckke}}ec`iq} mcyqw cf n`u mcy`wu$ c`rqewwi` n||qcvnd cf n hygbi cf woi hyvi`edi mcyqw cf nmcy`wu cq n mcy`wu mcyqw$ }wnwywcqu mcy`wu mcyqw$ cq ge}wqemw mcyqw wque`b mqeke`nd mn}i} e` woi mcy`wu$ knun||ce`w n bcviq`ki`wnd i`wewu$ `c`|qcfew mcq|cqnwec`$cq anq n}}cmenwec` wc c|iqnwi n kn`nbig n}}eb`igmcy`}id |qcbqnk. Woi mckke}}ec`iq} mcyqw} cf wrccq kcqi mcy`wei} knu i`wiq e`wc n rqewwi` nbqiiki`wwc hce`wdu n||ce`w n`g fy`g n bcviq`ki`wnd i`wewu$`c`|qcfew mcq|cqnwec`$ cq anq n}}cmenwec` wc c|iqnwi nkn`nbig n}}eb`ig mcy`}id |qcbqnk. E` n||ce`we`b

n` i`wewu wc c|iqnwi n kn`nbig n}}eb`ig mcy`}id|qcbqnk y`giq woe} }ya}imwec`$ woi mckke}}ec`iq}mcyqw }ondd }|imefu cq woi mckke}}ec`iq} mcyqw} }ondd hce`wdu }|imefu8

/>% woi wu|i} cf mn}i} e` roemo woi |qcbqnkknu n||ce`w mcy`}id y`giq Nqwemdi 16.<7 cf woe} mcgi cq ]imwec` 9>.><$ Fnkedu Mcgi$n`g woi mcyqw} e` roemo woi mcy`}idn||ce`wig au woi |qcbqnk knu ai qi~yeqigwc n||inq: n`g

/1% woi wiqk cf n`u nbqiiki`w i}wnade}oe`b

n |qcbqnk n`g ocr woi nbqiiki`w knu aiwiqke`nwig cq qi`irig.

/m% Woi mckke}}ec`iq} mcyqw cq mckke}}ec`iq}mcyqw} }ondd qi~yeqi n rqewwi` |dn` cf c|iqnwec` fqckn` i`wewu c|iqnwe`b n |qcbqnk y`giq woe} nqwemdi. Woi|dn` cf c|iqnwec` ky}w e`mdygi8

/>% n aygbiw fcq woi |qcbqnk$ e`mdyge`b}ndnqei}:

/1% n gi}mqe|wec` cf inmo |iq}c``id |c}ewec`$e`mdyge`b woi |qcbqnk"} geqimwcq:

/=% woi knxekyk nddcrnadi mn}idcng fcq inmo nwwcq`iu n||ce`wig au woi |qcbqnk:/7% |qcve}ec`} fcq wqne`e`b |iq}c``id cf woi|qcbqnk n`g nwwcq`iu} n||ce`wig y`giq woi|qcbqnk:

/9% n gi}mqe|wec` cf n`weme|nwig cviqoingmc}w} fcq woi |qcbqnk:

/6% n |cdemu qibnqge`b demi`}ig e`vi}webnwcq}n`g ix|iqw rew`i}}i} y}ig au nwwcq`iu}n||ce`wig y`giq woi |qcbqnk:

/2% n |cdemu wc i`}yqi wonw n||ce`wki`w} nqiqin}c`nadu n`g ek|nqwenddu nddcmnwig nkc`b~yndefeig nwwcq`iu}: n`g

/?% n |cdemu wc i`}yqi wonw n` nwwcq`iun||ce`wig y`giq woi |qcbqnk gci} `cwnmmi|w n||ce`wki`w e` n mn}i wonw e`vcdvi} nmc`fdemw cf e`wiqi}w fcq woi nwwcq`iu wonw on}`cw aii` rnevig au ndd nffimwig mdei`w}.

/g% N |qcbqnk y`giq woe} nqwemdi ky}w onvi ngeqimwcq. Y`di}} woi |qcbqnk y}i} n qiveirmckkewwii n||ce`wig y`giq ]ya}imwec` /i%$ n|qcbqnk y`giq woe} nqwemdi ky}w ai geqimwig au n|iq}c` roc8

/>% e} n kikaiq cf woi ]wnwi Anq cf Wixn}:

/1% on} |qnmwemig dnr fcq nw din}w woqiiuinq}: n`g

/=% on} }ya}wn`wend ix|iqei`mi e` woi|qnmwemi cf mqeke`nd dnr.

/i% Woi bcviq`ki`wnd i`wewu$ `c`|qcfew mcq|cqnwec`$cq anq n}}cmenwec` c|iqnwe`b woi |qcbqnk knun||ce`w n qiveir mckkewwii cf woqii cq kcqie`gevegynd} wc n||qcvi nwwcq`iu} fcq e`mdy}ec` c` woi|qcbqnk"} |yadem n||ce`wki`w de}w gi}mqeaig au

]ya}imwec` /f%. Inmo kikaiq cf woi mckkewwii8

/>% ky}w kiiw woi qi~yeqiki`w} gi}mqeaigau ]ya}imwec` /g%:

/1% knu `cw ai ik|dcuig n} n |qc}imywcq:n`g

Page 34: Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

7/30/2019 Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fair-defense-law-dec-2011-tidc 34/76

 

1?

/=% knu `cw ai e`mdygig c` cq n||du fcq e`mdy}ec` c` woi |yadem n||ce`wki`w de}wgi}mqeaig au ]ya}imwec` /f%.

/f% Woi |qcbqnk"} |yadem n||ce`wki`w de}w fqck roemon` nwwcq`iu e} n||ce`wig ky}w mc`wne` woi `nki} cf ~yndefeig nwwcq`iu}$ inmo cf rock8

/>% n||dei} wc ai e`mdygig c` woi de}w:

/1% kiiw} n`u n||demnadi qi~yeqiki`w}}|imefeig au woi |qcmigyqi fcq n||ce`we`bmcy`}id ngc|wig y`giq Nqwemdi 16.<7/n% n`gwoi Wixn} E`gebi`w Gifi`}i Mckke}}ec`:n`g

/=% e} n||qcvig au woi |qcbqnk geqimwcq cq qiveir mckkewwii$ n} n||demnadi.

/b% N mcyqw knu qi|dnmi n` nwwcq`iu n||ce`wig au

woi |qcbqnk fcq woi }nki qin}c`} n`g e` woi }nkikn``iq gi}mqeaig au Nqwemdi 16.<7/j%.

/o% N kn`nbig n}}eb`ig mcy`}id |qcbqnk e}i`wewdig wc qimievi fy`g} fcq |iq}c``id mc}w} n`gix|i`}i} e`myqqig e` nkcy`w} fexig au woimckke}}ec`iq} mcyqw n`g |neg cyw cf woi n||qc|qenwimcy`wu fy`g$ cq hce`wdu fexig au woi mckke}}ec`iq}mcyqw} n`g |qc|cqwec`nwidu |neg cyw cf inmon||qc|qenwi mcy`wu fy`g ef woi |qcbqnk }iqvi} kcqiwon` c`i mcy`wu.

/e% N kn`nbig n}}eb`ig mcy`}id |qcbqnk knu

ik|dcu |iq}c``id n`g i`wiq e`wc mc`wqnmw}`imi}}nqu wc |iqfcqk woi |qcbqnk"} gywei} n}}|imefeig au woi mckke}}ec`iq} mcyqw cq mckke}}ec`iq} mcyqw} y`giq woe} nqwemdi.

Nggewec` cf Nqw. 16.<72 iffimwevi ]i|w. >$ 1<>> /OA >297 ¢1<%.

1<>> Dibe}dnwevi @cwiOA >297 ngg} woe} nqwemdi wc mqinwi n kn`nbign}}eb`ig mcy`}id |qcbqnk n`g }iw fcqwo roc knunywocqei woi |qcbqnk$ roc knu |nqweme|nwi e` woi|qcbqnk$ n`g ronw |criq} woi |qcbqnk knu onvi. 

Nqw. 16.<9. Mck|i`}nwec` cf Mcy`}id N||ce`wig

wc Gifi`g

/n% N mcy`}id$ cwoiq won` n` nwwcq`iu rewo n |yademgifi`giq‟} cffemi gifi`giq cq n` nwwcq`iu ik|dcuigau woi cffemi cf mn|ewnd rqew}$ n||ce`wig wc qi|qi}i`wn gifi`gn`w e` n mqeke`nd |qcmiige`b$ e`mdyge`b nonain} mcq|y} oinqe`b$ }ondd ai |neg n qin}c`nadinwwcq`iu"} fii fcq |iqfcqke`b woi fcddcre`b }iqvemi}$an}ig c` woi weki n`g dnacq qi~yeqig$ woi mck|dixewu

cf woi mn}i$ n`g woi ix|iqei`mi n`g naedewu cf woin||ce`wig mcy`}id8

/>% weki }|i`w e` mcyqw knje`b n` n||inqn`mi c`aiondf cf woi gifi`gn`w n} ivegi`mig au ngcmjiw i`wqu$ weki }|i`w e` wqend$ n`g weki }|i`we` n |qcmiige`b e` roemo }rcq` cqnd wi}wekc`u e}idemewig:

/1% qin}c`nadi n`g `imi}}nqu weki }|i`w cyw cf mcyqw c` woi mn}i$ }y||cqwig au n`ugcmyki`wnwec` wonw woi mcyqw qi~yeqi}:

/=% |qi|nqnwec` cf n` n||iddnwi aqeif n`g|qi|nqnwec` n`g |qi}i`wnwec` cf cqnd nqbyki`w wcn mcyqw cf n||ind} cq woi Mcyqw cf Mqeke`nd N||ind}: n`g

/7% |qi|nqnwec` cf n kcwec` fcq qioinqe`b.

/a% Ndd |nuki`w} kngi y`giq woe} nqwemdi }ondd ai|neg e` nmmcqgn`mi rewo n }moigydi cf fii} ngc|wigau fcqknd nmwec` cf woi hygbi} cf woi mcy`wu mcyqw}$}wnwywcqu mcy`wu mcyqw}$ n`g ge}wqemw mcyqw} wque`bmqeke`nd mn}i} e` inmo mcy`wu. C` ngc|wec` cf n}moigydi cf fii} n} |qcvegig au woe} }ya}imwec`$ nmc|u cf woi }moigydi }ondd ai }i`w wc woimckke}}ec`iq} mcyqw cf woi mcy`wu.

/m% Inmo fii }moigydi ngc|wig }ondd }wnwiqin}c`nadi fexig qnwi} cq ke`ekyk n`g knxekykocyqdu qnwi}$ wnje`b e`wc mc`}egiqnwec` qin}c`nadin`g `imi}}nqu cviqoing mc}w} n`g woi nvnednaedewu cf 

~yndefeig nwwcq`iu} redde`b wc nmmi|w woi }wnwig qnwi}$n`g }ondd |qcvegi n fcqk fcq woi n||ce`wig mcy`}id wcewikei woi wu|i} cf }iqvemi} |iqfcqkig. @c|nuki`w }ondd ai kngi y`giq woe} nqwemdi y`wed woifcqk fcq ewikee`b woi }iqvemi} |iqfcqkig e}}yakewwig wc woi hygbi |qi}ege`b cviq woi|qcmiige`b} cq$ ef woi mcy`wu c|iqnwi} n kn`nbign}}eb`ig mcy`}id |qcbqnk y`giq Nqwemdi 16.<72$ wcwoi geqimwcq cf woi |qcbqnk$ n`g y`wed woi hygbi cq geqimwcq$ n} n||demnadi$ n||qcvi} woi |nuki`w. Ef woi hygbi cq geqimwcq ge}n||qcvi} woi qi~yi}wig nkcy`wcf |nuki`w$ woi hygbi cq geqimwcq }ondd knji rqewwi`fe`ge`b} }wnwe`b woi nkcy`w cf |nuki`w wonw woi

 hygbi cq geqimwcq n||qcvi} n`g inmo qin}c` fcq n||qcve`b n` nkcy`w geffiqi`w fqck woi qi~yi}wignkcy`w. N` nwwcq`iu roc}i qi~yi}w fcq |nuki`w e}ge}n||qcvig cq e} `cw cwoiqre}i nmwig c` au woi 6<wognu nfwiq woi gnwi woi qi~yi}w fcq |nuki`w e}}yakewwig knu n||ind woi ge}n||qcvnd cq fnedyqi wcnmw au fede`b n kcwec` rewo woi |qi}ege`b hygbi cf woingke`e}wqnwevi hygemend qibec`. C` woi fede`b cf nkcwec`$ woi |qi}ege`b hygbi cf woi ngke`e}wqnwevi hygemend qibec` }ondd qiveir woi ge}n||qcvnd cf 

Page 35: Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

7/30/2019 Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fair-defense-law-dec-2011-tidc 35/76

 

15

|nuki`w cq fnedyqi wc nmw n`g giwiqke`i woin||qc|qenwi nkcy`w cf |nuki`w. E` qiveire`b woige}n||qcvnd cq fnedyqi wc nmw$ woi |qi}ege`b hygbi cf woi ngke`e}wqnwevi hygemend qibec` knu mc`gymw noinqe`b. @cw dnwiq won` woi 79wo gnu nfwiq woi gnwin` n||demnwec` fcq |nuki`w cf n fii e} }yakewwigy`giq woe} nqwemdi$ woi mckke}}ec`iq} mcyqw }ondd |nuwc woi n||ce`wig mcy`}id woi nkcy`w wonw e}n||qcvig au woi |qi}ege`b hygbi cf woingke`e}wqnwevi hygemend qibec` n`g wonw e} e`nmmcqgn`mi rewo woi fii }moigydi fcq wonw mcy`wu.

/g% N mcy`}id e` n `c`+mn|ewnd mn}i$ cwoiq won` n`nwwcq`iu rewo n |yadem gifi`giq‟} cffemigifi`giq$n||ce`wig wc qi|qi}i`w n gifi`gn`w y`giq woe} mcgi}ondd ai qiekayq}ig fcq qin}c`nadi n`g `imi}}nquix|i`}i}$ e`mdyge`b ix|i`}i} fcq e`vi}webnwec` n`gfcq ki`wnd oindwo n`g cwoiq ix|iqw}. Ix|i`}i}e`myqqig rewo |qecq mcyqw n||qcvnd }ondd aiqiekayq}ig e` woi }nki kn``iq |qcvegig fcq mn|ewnd

mn}i} au Nqwemdi} 16.<91/f% n`g /b%$ n`g ix|i`}i}e`myqqig rewocyw |qecq mcyqw n||qcvnd }ondd aiqiekayq}ig e` woi kn``iq |qcvegig fcq mn|ewnd mn}i}au Nqwemdi 16.<91/o%.

/i% N knhcqewu cf woi hygbi} cf woi mcy`wu mcyqw} n`g}wnwywcqu mcy`wu mcyqw} cq woi ge}wqemw mcyqw}$ n}n||qc|qenwi$ wque`b mqeke`nd mn}i} e` woi mcy`wu knuqikcvi n` nwwcq`iu fqck mc`}egiqnwec` fcq n||ce`wki`w ef$ nfwiq n oinqe`b$ ew e} }ocr` wonw woinwwcq`iu }yakewwig n mdnek fcq dibnd }iqvemi} `cw|iqfcqkig au woi nwwcq`iu.

/f% Ndd |nuki`w} kngi y`giq woe} nqwemdi }ondd ai |negfqck woi bi`iqnd fy`g cf woi mcy`wu e` roemo woi|qc}imywec` rn} e`}wewywig cq onain} mcq|y} oinqe`boidg n`g knu ai e`mdygig n} mc}w} cf mcyqw.

/b% Ef woi mcyqw giwiqke`i} wonw n gifi`gn`w on}fe`n`mend qi}cyqmi} wonw i`nadi oek wc cff}iw e` |nqwcq e` rocdi woi mc}w} cf woi dibnd }iqvemi} |qcvegig$e`mdyge`b n`u ix|i`}i} n`g mc}w}$ woi mcyqw }onddcqgiq woi gifi`gn`w wc |nu gyqe`b woi |i`gi`mu cf woi monqbi} cq$ ef mc`vemwig$ n} mcyqw mc}w} woinkcy`w wonw ew fe`g} woi gifi`gn`w e} nadi wc |nu.

/o% Qiekayq}iki`w cf ix|i`}i} e`myqqig fcq |yq|c}i} cf e`vi}webnwec` cq ix|iqw wi}wekc`u knuai |neg geqimwdu wc n |qevnwi e`vi}webnwcq demi`}igy`giq Mon|wiq >2<1$ Cmmy|nwec`} Mcgi$ cq wc n`ix|iqw rew`i}} e` woi kn``iq gi}eb`nwig aun||ce`wig mcy`}id n`g n||qcvig au woi mcyqw.

/e% Woi e`gebi`w gifi`}i qi|qi}i`wnwec` fy`g e} n}i|nqnwi nmmcy`w e` woi bi`iqnd qivi`yi fy`g. Woify`g8

/>% mc`}e}w} cf mqeke`nd fii} mcddimwig y`giq ]imwec` >==.><2$ Dcmnd Bcviq`ki`w Mcgi: n`g

/1% knu ai y}ig c`du fcq woi |yq|c}i} fcq roemowoi fneq gifi`}i nmmcy`w i}wnade}oig y`giq ]imwec` 2>.<9?$ Bcviq`ki`w Mcgi$ knu aiy}ig$ e`mdyge`b mck|i`}nwe`b n||ce`wig mcy`}ide` nmmcqgn`mi rewo woe} mcgi.

Nki`gki`w wc /n%$ /m%$ n`g /g% iffimwevi ]i|w. >$ 1<>> /OA >297 ¢1<%.

1<>> Dibe}dnwevi @cwiOA >297 knji} n mc`fcqke`b mon`bi wc}ya}imwec`} /n% n`g /g%.

OA >297 nki`g} /m% wc |qcoeaew n` nwwcq`iu‟} fii}fqck aie`b |neg y`giq woe} nqwemdi y`wed woi fcqk fcq ewikee`b woi }iqvemi} |iqfcqkig e} }yakewwig wc woi hygbi |qi}ege`b cviq woi |qcmiige`b} cq$ ef woimcy`wu c|iqnwi} n kn`nbig n}}eb`ig mcy`}id|qcbqnk$ wc woi geqimwcq cf woi |qcbqnk$ n`g y`wed woi hygbi cq geqimwcq n||qcvi} woi |nuki`w.

OA >297 qi|indig }ya}imwec` /e% wc gidiwi dn`bynbiqidnwig wc woi e`gebi`w qi|qi}i`wnwec` fy`g$ roemorn} `cw iviq fcqknddu mqinwig.

Mckki`wnquWqend mcyqw} knu cqgiq gifi`gn`w} wc |nu mcyqw+n||ce`wig nwwcq`iu fii} ef woiu giwiqke`i wonw ngifi`gn`w on} i`cybo fe`n`mend qi}cyqmi} wc |nu fcq }cki cq ndd woi mc}w} cf n` nwwcq`iu‟} }iqvemi}.

]nymign v. ]wnwi $ =<5 ].R.=g 262$ 22< /Wix. N||.‗Nknqeddc 1<><$ |iw. qif‟g%. N gifi`gn`w‟}qi}cyqmi} n`g naedewu wc |nu nqi mqewemnd idiki`w} e` nwqend mcyqw} giwiqke`nwec` cf roiwoiq n gifi`gn`w}ocydg ai n}}i}}ig nwwcq`iu fii}. Knuiq v. ]wnwi $=<5 ].R.=g 991$ 996 /Wix. Mqek. N||. 1<><%: ]ii nd}c ]nymign $ =<5 ].R.=g nw 22<. Woi Mcyqw cf Mqeke`nd N||ind} qimi`wdu nffeqkig wonw n` cqgiq wcqi|nu n||ce`wig nwwcq`iu fii} e} e`vndeg ef ew e}i`wiqig rewocyw n`u ’giwiqke`nwec` cq fe`ge`b au woiwqend mcyqw wonw n||iddn`w ong n`u fe`n`mend qi}cyqmi}cq rn} ‒nadi wc |nu‟ woi n||ce`wig nwwcq`iu fii}.‖  Knuiq $ =<5 ].R.=g nw 99=.

 N mck|dne`w nacyw woi }yffemei`mu cf ivegi`mi cf n`n||iddn`w‟} fe`n`mend qi}cyqmi} n`g naedewu wc |nu nqi`cw rnevig au woi n||iddn`w‟} fnedyqi wc qne}i woimck|dne`w nw wqend. Knuiq $ =<5 ].R.=g nw 996. Mn}i}rewo mdnek} cf e`}yffemei`w ivegi`mi y}ynddu gc `cwbiw qikn`gig wc nddcr fcq }y||diki`w} wc ai nggigwc woi qimcqg. Eg. nw 992. Woi mdnek} nqi kin}yqigau veire`b woi ivegi`mi e` woi qimcqg e` woi debowkc}w fnvcqnadi wc woi viqgemw. Eg. 

Page 36: Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

7/30/2019 Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fair-defense-law-dec-2011-tidc 36/76

 

=<

Woi n}}i}}ki`w cf fii} fcq n` n||ce`wig nwwcq`iu e}`cw |y`ewevi. Nqk}wqc`b v. ]wnwi $ =7< ].R.=g 295/Wix. Mqek. N||. 1<>>%. Mcyqw mc}w} /e`mdyge`bnwwcq`iu} fii}%$ n} qifdimwig e` n miqwefeig aedd cf mc}w}$ `iig `iewoiq ai cqnddu |qc`cy`mig `cq e`mcq|cqnwig au qifiqi`mi e` woi hygbki`w wc aiiffimwevi. Eg. 

 N||iddn`w} mck|dne`e`b cf ek|qc|iq nmwec` y`giq Nqw.16.<9 ky}w }ocr ocr woiu riqi onqkig cq e`hyqigau }ymo nmwec` woqcybo ivegi`mi e` woi qimcqg. Qiig v. ]wnwi $ 677 ].R.1g 725$ 7?> /Wix. Mqek. N||.>5?=%.

]wnwi fy`gig nwwcq`iu fii} mn``cw ai nrnqgig fcq }iqvemi} qi`giqig |qecq wc woi gnwi mcy`}id e}fcqknddu n||ce`wig wc qi|qi}i`w n` e`gebi`w. Bqnu v.Qcae`}c` $ 277 ].R.1g 6<7$ 6<2 /Wix. Mqek. N||.>5??%.

 N||ce`wki`w cf n` ix|iqw rew`i}} y`giq Nqw. 16.<9qi}w} rewoe` }cy`g ge}mqiwec` cf wqend mcyqw. ^ye` v.]wnwi $ 6<? ].R.1g 5=2$ 5=? /Wix. Mqek. N||. >5?<%. Na}i`w n }ocre`b cf onqk$ `c nay}i cf wonwge}mqiwec` redd ai fcy`g. Eg. 

Ew e} `cw n` e`oiqi`w vecdnwec` cf gyi |qcmi}} fcq woi]wnwi$ |yq}yn`w wc Nqw. 16.<9/b%$ wc wnji qin}c`nadi}wi|} wc mcddimw c` ix|i`gewyqi} kngi c` aiondf cf woc}i roc onvi woi naedewu wc cff+}iw woi ]wnwi‟}ix|i`}i}. Myqqu v. Red}c` $ ?9= ].R.1g 7<$ 76 /Wix.Mqek. N||. >55=%.

Woi wqend mcyqw on} ge}mqiwec` e` giwiqke`e`b woi|qc|iq vndyi cf dibnd fii} ew cqgiq} n gifi`gn`w wc|nu y`giq Nqw. 16.<9/b%$ ayw gyi |qcmi}}mc`}egiqnwec`} qi~yeqi ivegi`mi e` woi qimcqg wc|qcvegi n fnmwynd an}e} fcq woi nkcy`w }iw. Oi}wiq v.]wnwi $ ?95 ].R.1g 59$ 52 /Wix. N||.‗Gnddn} >55=$`c |iw.% /mewe`b Anqjiq v. ]wnwi $ 661 ].R.1g 67<$ 671/Wix. N||.‗Ocy}wc` Z>7wo Ge}w.[ >5?=$ `c |iw.%%. Wqendmcyqw mn``cw |c}w|c`i woi giwiqke`nwec` cf fii}crig e`gife`ewidu wc }cki weki nfwiq woi hygbki`waimcki} fe`nd. Ayqji v. ]wnwi $ 16> ].R.=g 7=?$ 7=5/Wix. N||.‗ Ny}we` 1<<?$ `c |iw.%.

 N` e`gebi`w‟} mcyqw+n||ce`wig nwwcq`iu fcq n mevedmc`wik|w |qcmiige`b knu `cw ai |neg fqck woibi`iqnd fy`g cf n mcy`wu y`giq woi nywocqewu cf Nqw.16.<7. C|. Wix. Nww―u Bi`. HK+7<= />5?9%.

E`gebi`w gifi`gn`w} nqi `cw nywcknwemnddu i`wewdig wcn}}e}wn`mi cf mcyqw+n||ce`wig mcy`}id wc fedi n|iwewec` fcq ge}mqiwec`nqu qiveir. \iwiq}c` v. Hc`i} $?57 ].R.1g =2<$ =2= /Wix. Mqek. N||. >559%. Woiqi

e} `c }wnwywcqu gywu fcq ge}wqemw hygbi} wc nywocqei|nuki`w fcq nwwcq`iu }iqvemi} |iqfcqkig e` fede`b|iwewec`} fcq ge}mqiwec`nqu qiveir. Eg.

Gifi`gn`w} ky}w ai e`fcqkig cf woieq qebow wcqi|qi}i`wnwec`$ n`g ef fcy`g e`gebi`w$ woieq qebow wcn||ce`wki`w cf mcy`}id nw n mc`wik|w |qcmiige`b fcq fnedyqi wc |nu mcyqw cqgiqig nwwcq`iu fii}. Ix |nqwi Bc`ndi} $ 579 ].R.1g ?=< /Wix. Mqek. N||. >552%.

C` ]i|wikaiq 2wo$ 1<>>$ woi nwwcq`iu bi`iqnde}}yig C|e`ec` @c. BN+<??7 qidnwig wc woin||ce`wki`w cf mcy`}id e` mqeke`nd mn}i} fcq `c`+e`gebi`w gifi`gn`w}. Woi c|e`ec` mc`mdygig wonwndwocybo n mcyqw bi`iqnddu on} `c gywu wc n||ce`wmcy`}id wc n `c`+e`gebi`w$ n mcyqw knu gc }c roi`woi e`wiqi}w} cf hy}wemi qi~yeqi. Woi c|e`ec` nd}cnggqi}}ig n||qc|qenwi nkcy`w} cf nwwcq`iu fiiqi|nuki`w cqgiq} roi` woi mcy`wu e} }iqvig au nmc`wqnmw gifi`giq. Woi nwwcq`iu bi`iqnd mc`mdygig n

mcyqw knu qi~yeqi n gifi`gn`w$ e` n` cqgiq cf mckky`ewu }y|iqve}ec`$ wc |nu nwwcq`iu fii}nmmcqge`b wc woi mcy`wu‟} }moigydi cf fii}i}wnade}oig y`giq nqwemdi 16.<9$ Mcgi cf Mqeke`nd\qcmigyqi$ qibnqgdi}} cf woi nkcy`w cf woi mcy`wu‟}mc`wqnmw rewo e`gevegynd nwwcq`iu}. 

Nqw. 16.<9>. E`gebi`w E`knwi Gifi`}i

/n% E` woe} nqwemdi8

/>% !Acnqg! kin`} woi Wixn} Acnqg cf Mqeke`ndHy}wemi.

/1% !Mcqqimwec`nd e`}wewywec`} geve}ec`! kin`} woimcqqimwec`nd e`}wewywec`} geve}ec` cf woi Wixn}Gi|nqwki`w cf Mqeke`nd Hy}wemi.

/a% N mcyqw }ondd8/>% `cwefu woi acnqg ef ew giwiqke`i} wonw ngifi`gn`w aifcqi woi mcyqw e} e`gebi`w n`g e} n`e`knwi monqbig rewo n` cffi`}i mckkewwig roedie` woi my}wcgu cf woi mcqqimwec`nd e`}wewywec`}geve}ec` cq n mcqqimwec`nd fnmedewu nywocqeig au]imwec` 759.<<>$ Bcviq`ki`w Mcgi: n`g/1% qi~yi}w wonw woi acnqg |qcvegi dibnd

qi|qi}i`wnwec` fcq woi e`knwi.

/m% Woi acnqg }ondd |qcvegi dibnd qi|qi}i`wnwec` fcq e`knwi} gi}mqeaig au ]ya}imwec` /g% cf woe} }imwec`.Woi acnqg knu ik|dcu nwwcq`iu}$ }y||cqw }wnff$ n`gn`u cwoiq |iq}c``id qi~yeqig wc |qcvegi dibndqi|qi}i`wnwec` fcq woc}i e`knwi}. Ndd |iq}c``idik|dcuig y`giq woe} nqwemdi nqi geqimwdu qi}|c`}eadiwc woi acnqg e` woi |iqfcqkn`mi cf woieq gywei}. Woi

Page 37: Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

7/30/2019 Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fair-defense-law-dec-2011-tidc 37/76

 

=>

acnqg }ondd |nu ndd fii} n`g mc}w} n}}cmenwig rewo|qcvege`b dibnd qi|qi}i`wnwec` fcq woc}i e`knwi}.

/g% Qi|indig au Nmw} >55=$ 2=qg Dib.$ mo. 5??$ ]im.2.<1$ iff. ]i|w. >$ >55=.

/i% Woi mcyqw }ondd n||ce`w n` nwwcq`iu cwoiq won` n`nwwcq`iu |qcvegig au woi acnqg ef woi mcyqwgiwiqke`i} fcq n`u cf woi fcddcre`b qin}c`} wonw nmc`fdemw cf e`wiqi}w mcydg nqe}i fqck woi y}i cf n`nwwcq`iu |qcvegig au woi acnqg y`giq ]ya}imwec` /i%cf woe} nqwemdi8

/>% woi mn}i e`vcdvi} kcqi won` c`i e`knwi n`gwoi qi|qi}i`wnwec` cf kcqi won` c`i e`knwimcydg ek|neq woi nwwcq`iu"} iffimwevi`i}}:

/1% woi mn}i e} n||indig n`g woi mcyqw e}}nwe}feig wonw mc`fdemw cf e`wiqi}w rcydg |qivi`wwoi |qi}i`wnwec` cf n bccg fnewo nddibnwec` cf 

e`iffimwevi n}}e}wn`mi cf mcy`}id au n wqendnwwcq`iu |qcvegig au woi acnqg: cq 

/=% n`u mc`fdemw cf e`wiqi}w ixe}w} y`giq woi Wixn}Ge}me|de`nqu Qydi} cf \qcfi}}ec`nd Mc`gymw cf woi ]wnwi Anq cf Wixn} wonw |qimdygi}qi|qi}i`wnwec` au n` nwwcq`iu n||ce`wig au woiacnqg.

/f% Roi` woi mcyqw n||ce`w} n` nwwcq`iu cwoiq won`n` nwwcq`iu |qcvegig au woi acnqg8

/>% ixmi|w n} cwoiqre}i |qcvegig au woe} nqwemdi$

woi e`knwi"} dibnd gifi`}i e} }yahimw wc Nqwemdi}>.<9>$ 16.<7$ 16.<9$ n`g 16.<91$ n} n||demnadi:n`g

/1% woi mcy`wu e` roemo n fnmedewu cf woimcqqimwec`nd e`}wewywec`} geve}ec` cq n mcqqimwec`ndfnmedewu nywocqeig au ]imwec` 759.<<>$Bcviq`ki`w Mcgi$ e} dcmnwig }ondd |nu fqck ew}bi`iqnd fy`g woi wcwnd mc}w} cf woi nbbqibnwinkcy`w nddcrig n`g nrnqgig au woi mcyqw fcq nwwcq`iu mck|i`}nwec` n`g ix|i`}i} y`giq  Nqwemdi 16.<9 cq 16.<91$ n} n||demnadi.

/b% Woi }wnwi }ondd qiekayq}i n mcy`wu fcq nwwcq`iumck|i`}nwec` n`g ix|i`}i} nrnqgig y`giq ]ya}imwec` /o%. N mcyqw }iije`b qiekayq}iki`w fcq nmcy`wu }ondd miqwefu wc woi mck|wqcddiq cf |yademnmmcy`w} woi nkcy`w cf mck|i`}nwec` n`gix|i`}i} fcq roemo woi mcy`wu e} i`wewdig wc aiqiekayq}ig y`giq woe} nqwemdi. @cw dnwiq won` woi 6<wognu nfwiq woi gnwi woi mck|wqcddiq qimievi} fqck woimcyqw woi qi~yi}w fcq qiekayq}iki`w$ woi mck|wqcddiq 

}ondd e}}yi n rnqqn`w wc woi mcy`wu e` woi nkcy`wmiqwefeig au woi mcyqw.

Nqw. 16.<91. N||ce`wki`w cf Mcy`}id e` Ginwo\i`ndwu Mn}i: Qiekayq}iki`w cf E`vi}webnweviIx|i`}i}

/n% @cwrewo}wn`ge`b n`u cwoiq |qcve}ec` cf woe}mon|wiq$ woe} nqwemdi i}wnade}oi} |qcmigyqi} e` ginwo|i`ndwu mn}i} fcq n||ce`wki`w n`g |nuki`w cf mcy`}id wc qi|qi}i`w e`gebi`w gifi`gn`w} nw wqend n`gc` geqimw n||ind n`g wc n||du fcq rqew cf miqwecqnqe e`woi Y`ewig ]wnwi} ]y|qiki Mcyqw.

/a% Ef n mcy`wu e} }iqvig au n |yadem gifi`giq"} cffemi$wqend mcy`}id n`g mcy`}id fcq geqimw n||ind cq wcn||du fcq n rqew cf miqwecqnqe knu ai n||ce`wig n}|qcvegig au woi byegide`i} i}wnade}oig au woi |yademgifi`giq"} cffemi. E` ndd cwoiq mn}i} e` roemo woiginwo |i`ndwu e} }cybow$ mcy`}id }ondd ai n||ce`wig

n} |qcvegig au woe} nqwemdi.

/m% N dcmnd }idimwec` mckkewwii e} mqinwig e` inmongke`e}wqnwevi hygemend qibec` mqinwig y`giq ]imwec`27.<71$ Bcviq`ki`w Mcgi. Woi ngke`e}wqnwevi hygbi cf woi hygemend qibec` }ondd n||ce`w woikikaiq} cf woi mckkewwii. N mckkewwii }ondd onvi`cw di}} won` fcyq kikaiq}$ e`mdyge`b8

/>% woi ngke`e}wqnwevi hygbi cf woi hygemend qibec`:

/1% nw din}w c`i ge}wqemw hygbi:

/=% n qi|qi}i`wnwevi fqck woi dcmnd anq n}}cmenwec`: n`g

/7% nw din}w c`i |qnmwewec`iq roc e} acnqgmiqwefeig au woi ]wnwi Anq cf Wixn} e` mqeke`nddnr.

/g% />% Woi mckkewwii }ondd ngc|w }wn`gnqg} fcq woi~yndefemnwec` cf nwwcq`iu} wc ai n||ce`wig wcqi|qi}i`w e`gebi`w gifi`gn`w} e` mn|ewnd mn}i} e`roemo woi ginwo |i`ndwu e} }cybow.

/1% Woi }wn`gnqg} ky}w qi~yeqi wonw n wqend

nwwcq`iu n||ce`wig n} ding mcy`}id wc n mn|ewndmn}i8

/N% ai n kikaiq cf woi ]wnwi Anq cf Wixn}:

/A% ixoeaew |qcfemei`mu n`g mckkewki`w wc|qcvege`b ~yndewu qi|qi}i`wnwec` wcgifi`gn`w} e` ginwo |i`ndwu mn}i}:

Page 38: Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

7/30/2019 Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fair-defense-law-dec-2011-tidc 38/76

 

=1

/M% onvi `cw aii` fcy`g au n figiqnd cq }wnwi mcyqw wc onvi qi`giqig e`iffimwevin}}e}wn`mi cf mcy`}id gyqe`b woi wqend cq n||ind cf n`u mn|ewnd mn}i$ y`di}} woi dcmnd}idimwec` mckkewwii giwiqke`i} y`giq }ya}imwec` /`% wonw woi mc`gymw y`giqdue`bwoi fe`ge`b `c dc`biq nmmyqnwidu qifdimw} woinwwcq`iu"} naedewu wc |qcvegi iffimweviqi|qi}i`wnwec`:

/G% onvi nw din}w fevi uinq} cf mqeke`nd dnrix|iqei`mi:

/I% onvi wqeig wc n viqgemw n} ding gifi`}imcy`}id n }eb`efemn`w `ykaiq cf fidc`umn}i}$ e`mdyge`b ockemegi wqend} n`g cwoiq wqend} fcq cffi`}i} |y`e}onadi n} }imc`g cq feq}w gibqii fidc`ei} cq mn|ewnd fidc`ei}:

/F% onvi wqend ix|iqei`mi e`8

/e% woi y}i cf n`g monddi`bi} wc ki`wndoindwo cq fcqi`}em ix|iqw rew`i}}i}: n`g

/ee% e`vi}webnwe`b n`g |qi}i`we`bkewebnwe`b ivegi`mi nw woi |i`ndwu |on}icf n ginwo |i`ndwu wqend: n`g

/B% onvi |nqweme|nwig e` mc`we`ye`b dibndigymnwec` mcyq}i} cq cwoiq wqne`e`b qidnwe`bwc mqeke`nd gifi`}i e` ginwo |i`ndwu mn}i}.

/=% Woi }wn`gnqg} ky}w qi~yeqi wonw n` nwwcq`iu

n||ce`wig n} ding mcy`}id e` woi geqimwn||ind cf n mn|ewnd mn}i8

/N% ai n kikaiq cf woi ]wnwi Anq cf Wixn}:

/A% ixoeaew |qcfemei`mu n`g mckkewki`w wc|qcvege`b ~yndewu qi|qi}i`wnwec` wcgifi`gn`w} e` ginwo |i`ndwu mn}i}:

/M% onvi `cw aii` fcy`g au n figiqnd cq }wnwi mcyqw wc onvi qi`giqig e`iffimwevin}}e}wn`mi cf mcy`}id gyqe`b woi wqend cq n||ind cf n`u mn|ewnd mn}i$ y`di}} woi dcmnd

}idimwec` mckkewwii giwiqke`i} y`giq }ya}imwec` /`% wonw woi mc`gymw y`giqdue`bwoi fe`ge`b `c dc`biq nmmyqnwidu qifdimw} woinwwcq`iu"} naedewu wc |qcvegi iffimweviqi|qi}i`wnwec`:

/G% onvi nw din}w fevi uinq} cf mqeke`nd dnrix|iqei`mi:

/I% onvi nywocqig n }eb`efemn`w `ykaiq cf n||iddnwi aqeif}$ e`mdyge`b n||iddnwi aqeif} fcq ockemegi mn}i} n`g cwoiq mn}i} e`vcdve`bn` cffi`}i |y`e}onadi n} n mn|ewnd fidc`u cq n fidc`u cf woi feq}w gibqii cq n` cffi`}igi}mqeaig au ]imwec` =b/n%/>%$ Nqwemdi 71.>1:

/F% onvi wqend cq n||iddnwi ix|iqei mi e`8

/e% woi y}i cf n`g monddi`bi} wcki`wnd oindwo cq fcqi`}em ix|iqwrew`i}}i}: n`g

/ee% woi y}i cf kewebnwe`b ivegi`mi nwwoi |i`ndwu |on}i cf n ginwo |i`ndwuwqend: n`g

/B% onvi |nqweme|nwig e` mc`we`ye`b dibndigymnwec` mcyq}i} cq cwoiq wqne`e`b qidnwe`bwc mqeke`nd gifi`}i e` n||inde`b ginwo

|i`ndwu mn}i}.

/7% Woi mckkewwii }ondd |qcke`i`wdu |c}w woi}wn`gnqg} e` inmo ge}wqemw mdiqj"} cffemi e` woiqibec` rewo n de}w cf nwwcq`iu} ~yndefeig fcq n||ce`wki`w.

/9% @cw dnwiq won` woi }imc`g n``eviq}nqu cf woignwi n` nwwcq`iu e} |dnmig c` woi de}w cf nwwcq`iu}~yndefeig fcq n||ce`wki`w e` ginwo |i`ndwu mn}i}n`g inmo uinq fcddcre`b woi }imc`g n``eviq}nqu$woi nwwcq`iu ky}w |qi}i`w |qccf wc woi mckkewwiiwonw woi nwwcq`iu on} }ymmi}}fyddu mck|diwig woi

ke`ekyk mc`we`ye`b dibnd igymnwec`qi~yeqiki`w} cf woi ]wnwi Anq cf Wixn}$e`mdyge`b n mcyq}i cq cwoiq fcqk cf wqne`e`bqidnwe`b wc mqeke`nd gifi`}i e` ginwo |i`ndwumn}i} cq e` n||inde`b ginwo |i`ndwu mn}i}$ n}n||demnadi. Woi mckkewwii }ondd qikcvi woinwwcq`iu"} `nki fqck woi de}w cf ~yndefeignwwcq`iu} ef woi nwwcq`iu fned} wc |qcvegi woimckkewwii rewo |qccf cf mck|diwec` cf woimc`we`ye`b dibnd igymnwec` qi~yeqiki`w}.

/i% Woi |qi}ege`b hygbi cf woi ge}wqemw mcyqw e` roemon mn|ewnd fidc`u mn}i e} fedig }ondd n||ce`w wrc

nwwcq`iu}$ nw din}w c`i cf rock ky}w ai ~yndefeigy`giq woe} mon|wiq$ wc qi|qi}i`w n` e`gebi`wgifi`gn`w n} }cc` n} |qnmwemnadi nfwiq monqbi} nqifedig$ y`di}} woi }wnwi bevi} `cwemi e` rqewe`b wonw woi}wnwi redd `cw }iij woi ginwo |i`ndwu.

/f% N||ce`wig mcy`}id knu fedi rewo woi wqend mcyqw n|qiwqend ix |nqwi mc`fegi`wend qi~yi}w fcq ngvn`mi|nuki`w cf ix|i`}i} wc e`vi}webnwi |cwi`wendgifi`}i}. Woi qi~yi}w fcq ix|i`}i} ky}w }wnwi8

Page 39: Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

7/30/2019 Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fair-defense-law-dec-2011-tidc 39/76

 

==

/>% woi wu|i cf e`vi}webnwec` wc ai mc`gymwig:

/1% }|imefem fnmw} wonw }ybbi}w woi e`vi}webnwec`redd qi}ydw e` ngke}}eadi ivegi`mi: n`g

/=% n` ewikeig de}w cf n`weme|nwig ix|i`}i} fcq inmo e`vi}webnwec`.

/b% Woi mcyqw }ondd bqn`w woi qi~yi}w fcq ngvn`mi|nuki`w cf ix|i`}i} e` rocdi cq e` |nqw ef woiqi~yi}w e} qin}c`nadi. Ef woi mcyqw gi`ei} e` rocdicq e` |nqw woi qi~yi}w fcq ix|i`}i}$ woi mcyqw }ondd8

/>% }wnwi woi qin}c`} fcq woi gi`end e` rqewe`b:

/1% nwwnmo woi gi`end wc woi mc`fegi`wend qi~yi}w:n`g

/=% }yakew woi qi~yi}w n`g gi`end n} n }indig

ixoeaew wc woi qimcqg.

/o% Mcy`}id knu e`myq ix|i`}i} rewocyw |qecq n||qcvnd cf woi mcyqw. C` |qi}i`wnwec` cf n mdnek fcq qiekayq}iki`w$ woi mcyqw }ondd cqgiq qiekayq}iki`wcf mcy`}id fcq woi ix|i`}i}$ ef woi ix|i`}i} nqiqin}c`nadu `imi}}nqu n`g qin}c`nadu e`myqqig./e% Ef woi e`gebi`w gifi`gn`w e} mc`vemwig cf n mn|ewndfidc`u n`g }i`wi`mig wc ginwo$ woi gifi`gn`w e}i`wewdig wc ai qi|qi}i`wig au mck|iwi`w mcy`}id c`n||ind n`g wc n||du fcq n rqew cf miqwecqnqe wc woiY`ewig ]wnwi} ]y|qiki Mcyqw.

/h% N} }cc` n} |qnmwemnadi nfwiq n ginwo }i`wi`mi e}ek|c}ig e` n mn|ewnd fidc`u mn}i$ woi |qi}ege`b hygbicf woi mc`vemwe`b mcyqw }ondd n||ce`w mcy`}id wcqi|qi}i`w n` e`gebi`w gifi`gn`w c` n||ind n`g wcn||du fcq n rqew cf miqwecqnqe$ ef n||qc|qenwi.

/j% Woi mcyqw knu `cw n||ce`w n` nwwcq`iu n}mcy`}id c` n||ind ef woi nwwcq`iu qi|qi}i`wig woigifi`gn`w nw wqend$ y`di}}8

/>% woi gifi`gn`w n`g woi nwwcq`iu qi~yi}w woin||ce`wki`w c` woi qimcqg: n`g

/1% woi mcyqw fe`g} bccg mny}i wc knji woin||ce`wki`w.

/d% N` nwwcq`iu n||ce`wig y`giq woe} nqwemdi wcqi|qi}i`w n gifi`gn`w nw wqend cq c` geqimw n||ind e}mck|i`}nwig n} |qcvegig au Nqwemdi 16.<9 fqckmcy`wu fy`g}. Ngvn`mi |nuki`w cf ix|i`}i}n`weme|nwig cq qiekayq}iki`w cf ix|i`}i} e`myqqigfcq |yq|c}i} cf e`vi}webnwec` cq ix|iqw wi}wekc`uknu ai |neg geqimwdu wc n |qevnwi e`vi}webnwcq 

demi`}ig y`giq woi \qevnwi E`vi}webnwcq} n`g \qevnwi]imyqewu Nbi`mei} Nmw /Nqwemdi 77>=/15aa%$ Viq`c`"}Wixn} Meved ]wnwywi}% cq wc n` ix|iqw rew`i}} e` woikn``iq gi}eb`nwig au n||ce`wig mcy`}id n`gn||qcvig au woi mcyqw.

/k% Woi dcmnd }idimwec` mckkewwii }ondd n``yndduqiveir woi de}w cf nwwcq`iu} |c}wig y`giq ]ya}imwec`/g% wc i`}yqi wonw inmo de}wig nwwcq`iu }nwe}fei} woiqi~yeqiki`w} y`giq woe} mon|wiq.

/`% Nw woi qi~yi}w cf n` nwwcq`iu$ woi dcmnd }idimwec`mckkewwii }ondd knji n giwiqke`nwec` y`giq }ya}imwec` /g%/1%/M% cq /=%/M%$ n} n||demnadi$qibnqge`b n` nwwcq`iu"} myqqi`w naedewu wc |qcvegiiffimwevi qi|qi}i`wnwec` fcddcre`b n hygemend fe`ge`bwonw woi nwwcq`iu |qivecy}du qi`giqig e`iffimwevin}}e}wn`mi cf mcy`}id e` n mn|ewnd mn}i.

Nki`gki`w wc /g% n`g nggewec` cf /`% iffimwevi ]i|w. >$ 1<>> /]A 

>=<?$ ¢7%. ]imwec` 1 cf ]A >=<? |qcvegi}8 — Woi mon`bi e` dnrkngi au woe} Nmw n||dei} wc n` nwwcq`iu roc$ aifcqi$ c`$ cq nfwiq woi iffimwevi gnwi cf woe} Nmw$ on} aii` fcy`g au n figiqnd cq }wnwimcyqw wc onvi qi`giqig e`iffimwevi n}}e}wn`mi cf mcy`}id gyqe`bwoi wqend cq n||ind cf n mn|ewnd mn}i.‖ ]imwec` = cf ]A >=<?|qcvegi}8 ’N dcmnd }idimwec` mckkewwii }ondd nki`g ew} }wn`gnqg}n} `imi}}nqu wc mc`fcqk rewo woi qi~yeqiki`w} cf ]ya}imwec` /`%$ Nqwemdi 16.<91$ Mcgi cf Mqeke`nd \qcmigyqi$ n} nggig au woe} Nmw$`cw dnwiq won` woi =<wo gnu nfwiq woi iffimwevi gnwi cf woe} Nmw.‖ 

1<>> Dibe}dnwevi @cwi]A >=<? nki`g} }ya}imwec` /g% wc |qcvegi nwwcq`iu}wonw onvi aii` fcy`g au n figiqnd cq }wnwi mcyqw wconvi qi`giqig e`iffimwevi n}}e}wn`mi cf mcy`}idgyqe`b woi wqend cq n||ind cf n`u mn|ewnd mn}i knu }wedd

ai n||ce`wig wc qi|qi}i`w n gifi`gn`w e` wqend cf nmn|ewnd mn}i cq woi geqimw n||ind cf n mn|ewnd mn}i ef woiu }nwe}fu }ya}imwec` /`% cf woe} }imwec`.

]A >=<? ngg} }ya}imwec` /`% wc qi~yeqi n dcmnd}idimwec` mckkewwii$ nw woi qi~yi}w cf n` nwwcq`iu$ wcknji n giwiqke`nwec` y`giq }ya}imwec` /g%/1%/M% cq /=%/M%$ n} n||demnadi$ qibnqge`b woi nwwcq`iu‟}myqqi`w naedewu wc |qcvegi iffimwevi qi|qi}i`wnwec`}fcddcre`b n hygemend fe`ge`b wonw woi nwwcq`iu|qivecy}du qi`giqig e`iffimwevi cf mcy`}id e` nmn|ewnd mn}i.

Mckki`wnquFnedyqi wc mck|du rewo Nqw. 16.<91 e} }y}mi|weadi wconqkdi}} iqqcq n`ndu}e}. Jeqj v. ]wnwi $ >55 ].R.=g762$ 72= /Wix. N||.‗Fcqw Rcqwo 1<<6$ |iw. qif‟g%.Fnede`b wc n}}eb` wrc nwwcq`iu} ~yndefeig y`giq Nqw.16.<91 rn} onqkdi}} iqqcq roi` woi ]wnwiqi|qi}i`wig wc woi mcyqw n`g woi gifi`gn`w‟} wqendmcy`}id wonw ew rcydg `cw }iij woi ginwo |i`ndwu. Eg. 

Page 40: Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

7/30/2019 Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fair-defense-law-dec-2011-tidc 40/76

 

=7

Ew knu ai onqkdi}} iqqcq fcq n gifi`gn`w wc aiqi|qi}i`wig au mcy`}id `cw }mqii`ig au n`ngke`e}wqnwevi hygemend qibec` nmmcqge`b wc Nqw.16.<91 ef woi nwwcq`iu n||ce`wig e} `c`iwoidi}}~yndefeig n`g mn|nadi. Oyboi} v. ]wnwi $ 17 ].R.=g?== /Wix. Mqek. N||. 1<<<%.

Nqw. 16.<96. Mc`wqeaywec` fqck ]wnwi e` Miqwne`Mcy`wei}

]im. >.

 N mcy`wu e` roemo n }wnwi wqne`e`b }moccd fcq gide`~yi`w moedgqi` e} dcmnwig }ondd |nu fqck ew}bi`iqnd fy`g woi feq}w '19< cf fii} nrnqgig fcq mcyqw+n||ce`wig mcy`}id y`giq Nqwemdi 16.<9 wcrnqggifi`ge`b n moedg mckkewwig wc woi }moccd fqckn`cwoiq mcy`wu roc e} aie`b |qc}imywig fcq n fidc`ucq ke}gikin`cq e` woi mcy`wu roiqi woi wqne`e`b}moccd e} dcmnwig.

]im. 1.

Ef woi fii} nrnqgig fcq mcy`}id mck|i`}nwec` nqi e`ixmi}} cf '19<$ woi mcyqw }ondd miqwefu woi nkcy`w e`ixmi}} cf '19< wc woi Mck|wqcddiq cf \yadem Nmmcy`w} cf woi ]wnwi cf Wixn}. Woi Mck|wqcddiq }ondd e}}yi n rnqqn`w wc woi mcyqw+n||ce`wig mcy`}ide` woi nkcy`w miqwefeig wc woi mck|wqcddiq au woimcyqw.

Nqw. 16.<92. Mc}w cf Ik|dcuki`w cf Mcy`}id fcqMiqwne` Ke`cq}

Ef n hyvi`edi on} aii` wqn`}fiqqig wc n mqeke`nd mcyqwy`giq ]imwec` 97.<1$ Fnkedu Mcgi$ n`g ef n mcyqwn||ce`w} mcy`}id fcq woi hyvi`edi y`giq Nqwemdi 16.<7cf woe} mcgi$ woi mcy`wu wonw |nu} fcq woi mcy`}id on}n mny}i cf nmwec` nbne`}w n |nqi`w cq cwoiq |iq}c`roc e} qi}|c`}eadi fcq woi }y||cqw cf woi hyvi`edi n`ge} fe`n`menddu nadi wc ik|dcu mcy`}id fcq woi hyvi`ediayw qify}i} wc gc }c. Woi mcy`wu knu qimcviq ew}mc}w cf |nuki`w wc woi n||ce`wig mcy`}id n`g knuqimcviq nwwcq`iu"} fii} `imi}}nqu wc |qc}imywi woimny}i cf nmwec` nbne`}w woi |nqi`w cq cwoiq |iq}c`.

Nqw. 16.<6. Idimwig Cffemend} @cw wc Ai N||ce`wig

@c mcyqw knu n||ce`w n` idimwig mcy`wu$ ge}wqemw cq }wnwi cffemend wc qi|qi}i`w n |iq}c` nmmy}ig cf mqeki$y`di}} woi cffemend on} `cwefeig woi mcyqw cf oe}nvnednaedewu fcq n||ce`wki`w. Ef n` cffemend on} `cwefeigwoi mcyqw cf oe} nvnednaedewu n`g e} n||ce`wig n}mcy`}id$ oi knu gimde`i woi n||ce`wki`w ef oigiwiqke`i} wonw ew e} e` woi ai}w e`wiqi}w cf oe} cffemi

wc gc }c. @cwoe`b e` woe} Mcgi }ondd kcgefu n`u}wnwywcqu |qcve}ec` fcq dibe}dnwevi mc`we`yn`mi.

Mckki`wnqu@iewoiq Bcviq`ki`w Mcgi ]imwec` ?1.<67 `cq Nqw.16.<6 |qcoeaew n hy}wemi cf woi |inmi roc e} n`nwwcq`iu fqck nmmi|we`b n` n||ce`wki`w wc qi|qi}i`wn` e`gebi`w mqeke`nd gifi`gn`w nw woi n||iddnwi divid$n`g acwo ek|demewdu qimcb`ei woi hy}wemi‟} nywocqewu wcgc }c. C|. Wix. Nww―u Bi`. BN+<69> /1<<?%.

Nqw. 16.<2. @nki N} ]wnwig e` E`gemwki`w

Roi` woi gifi`gn`w e} nqqneb`ig$ oe} `nki$ n}}wnwig e` woi e`gemwki`w$ }ondd ai ge}we`mwdu mnddig:n`g y`di}} oi }ybbi}w au oek}idf cq mcy`}id wonw oie} `cw e`gemwig au oe} wqyi `nki$ ew }ondd ai wnji` wonwoe} `nki e} wqydu }iw fcqwo$ n`g oi }ondd `cw woiqinfwiq 

ai nddcrig wc gi`u woi }nki au rnu cf gifi`}i.

Nqw. 16.<?. Ef Gifi`gn`w ]ybbi}w} Geffiqi`w @nki

Ef woi gifi`gn`w$ cq oe} mcy`}id fcq oek$ }ybbi}w}wonw oi ainq} }cki `nki geffiqi`w fqck wonw }wnwige` woi e`gemwki`w$ woi }nki }ondd ai `cwig y|c` woike`ywi} cf woi mcyqw$ woi e`gemwki`w mcqqimwig aue`}iqwe`b woiqie` woi `nki cf woi gifi`gn`w n}}ybbi}wig au oek}idf cq oe} mcy`}id fcq oek$ woi}wudi cf woi mn}i mon`big }c n} wc bevi oe} wqyi`nki$ n`g woi mny}i |qcmiig n} ef woi wqyi `nkiong aii` feq}w qimewig e` woi e`gemwki`w.

Nqw. 16.<5. Ef Nmmy}ig Qify}i} wc Bevi Oe} Qind@nki

Ef woi gifi`gn`w nddibi} wonw oi e} `cw e`gemwig au oe}wqyi `nki$ n`g qify}i} wc }nu ronw oe} qind `nki e}$woi mny}i }ondd |qcmiig n} ef woi `nki }wnwig e` woie`gemwki`w riqi wqyi: n`g woi gifi`gn`w }ondd `cw ainddcrig wc mc`wqngemw woi }nki au rnu cf gifi`}i.

Nqw. 16.><. Roiqi @nki E} Y`j`cr` N gifi`gn`w gi}mqeaig n} n |iq}c` roc}i `nki e}y`j`cr` knu onvi woi e`gemwki`w }c mcqqimwig n} wc

bevi woiqie` oe} wqyi `nki.

Nqw. 16.>>. E`gemwki`w Qing

Woi `nki cf woi nmmy}ig onve`b aii` mnddig$ ef `c}ybbi}wec`$ }ymo n} e} }|cji` cf e` woi fcyq |qimige`b Nqwemdi}$ ai kngi$ cq aie`b kngi e}ge}|c}ig cf n} aifcqi geqimwig$ woi e`gemwki`w }onddai qing$ n`g woi gifi`gn`w n}jig roiwoiq oi e}byedwu cq `cw$ n} woiqie` monqbig. 

Page 41: Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

7/30/2019 Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fair-defense-law-dec-2011-tidc 41/76

 

=9

Nqw. 16.>1. \din cf @cw Byedwu I`wiqig

Ef woi gifi`gn`w n`}riq} wonw oi e} `cw byedwu$ }ymo|din }ondd ai i`wiqig y|c` woi ke`ywi} cf woi mcyqw:ef oi qify}i} wc n`}riq$ woi |din cf `cw byedwu }ondd e`deji kn``iq ai i`wiqig.

Nqw. 16.>=. \din cf Byedwu

/n% \qecq wc nmmi|we`b n |din cf byedwu cq n |din cf `cdc mc`wi`giqi$ woi mcyqw }ondd ngkc`e}o woigifi`gn`w cf8

/>% woi qn`bi cf woi |y`e}oki`w nwwnmoig wc woicffi`}i:

/1% woi fnmw wonw woi qimckki`gnwec` cf woi|qc}imywe`b nwwcq`iu n} wc |y`e}oki`w e} `cwae`ge`b c` woi mcyqw. \qcvegig wonw woi mcyqw

}ondd e`~yeqi n} wc woi ixe}wi`mi cf n`u |dinanqbne`e`b nbqiiki`w} aiwrii` woi }wnwi n`gwoi gifi`gn`w n`g$ e` woi ivi`w wonw }ymo n`nbqiiki`w ixe}w}$ woi mcyqw }ondd e`fcqk woigifi`gn`w roiwoiq ew redd fcddcr cq qihimw }ymonbqiiki`w e` c|i` mcyqw n`g aifcqi n`u fe`ge`bc` woi |din. ]ocydg woi mcyqw qihimw n`u }ymonbqiiki`w$ woi gifi`gn`w }ondd ai |iqkewwig wcrewogqnr oe} |din cf byedwu cq `cdc mc`wi`giqi:

/=% woi fnmw wonw ef woi |y`e}oki`w n}}i}}ig gci}`cw ixmiig woi |y`e}oki`w qimckki`gig auwoi |qc}imywcq n`g nbqiig wc au woi gifi`gn`w

n`g oe} nwwcq`iu$ woi wqend mcyqw ky}w bevi ew}|iqke}}ec` wc woi gifi`gn`w aifcqi oi knu|qc}imywi n` n||ind c` n`u knwwiq e` woi mn}iixmi|w fcq woc}i knwwiq} qne}ig au rqewwi`kcwec`} fedig |qecq wc wqend:

/7% woi fnmw wonw ef woi gifi`gn`w e} `cw n mewei`cf woi Y`ewig ]wnwi} cf Nkiqemn$ n |din cf byedwucq `cdc mc`wi`giqi fcq woi cffi`}i monqbig knuqi}ydw e` gi|cqwnwec`$ woi ixmdy}ec` fqckngke}}ec` wc woe} mcy`wqu$ cq woi gi`end cf `nwyqndenwec` y`giq figiqnd dnr: n`g

/9% woi fnmw wonw woi gifi`gn`w redd ai qi~yeqig wckiiw woi qibe}wqnwec` qi~yeqiki`w} cf Mon|wiq 61$ ef woi gifi`gn`w e} mc`vemwig cf cq |dnmig c`gifiqqig nghygemnwec` fcq n` cffi`}i fcq roemo n|iq}c` e} }yahimw wc qibe}wqnwec` y`giq wonwmon|wiq.

/a% @c |din cf byedwu cq |din cf `cdc mc`wi`giqi }onddai nmmi|wig au woi mcyqw y`di}} ew n||inq} wonw woigifi`gn`w e} ki`wnddu mck|iwi`w n`g woi |din e} fqiin`g vcdy`wnqu.

/m% E` ngkc`e}oe`b woi gifi`gn`w n} oiqie`|qcvegig$ }ya}wn`wend mck|den`mi au woi mcyqw e}}yffemei`w$ y`di}} woi gifi`gn`w nffeqknwevidu }ocr}wonw oi rn} `cw nrnqi cf woi mc`}i~yi`mi} cf oe}|din n`g wonw oi rn} ke}dig cq onqkig au woingkc`e}oki`w cf woi mcyqw.

/g% Woi mcyqw knu knji woi ngkc`ewec`} qi~yeqig auwoe} nqwemdi iewoiq cqnddu cq e` rqewe`b. Ef woi mcyqwknji} woi ngkc`ewec`} e` rqewe`b$ ew ky}w qimievi n}wnwiki`w }eb`ig au woi gifi`gn`w n`g woigifi`gn`w"} nwwcq`iu wonw oi y`giq}wn`g} woingkc`ewec`} n`g e} nrnqi cf woi mc`}i~yi`mi} cf oe} |din. Ef woi gifi`gn`w e} y`nadi cq qify}i} wc }eb`woi }wnwiki`w$ woi mcyqw }ondd knji woi ngkc`ewec`}cqnddu.

/i% Aifcqi nmmi|we`b n |din cf byedwu cq n |din cf `cdcmc`wi`giqi$ woi mcyqw }ondd e`~yeqi n} wc roiwoiq n

vemwek ek|nmw }wnwiki`w on} aii` qiwyq`ig wc woinwwcq`iu qi|qi}i`we`b woi }wnwi n`g n}j fcq n mc|u cf woi }wnwiki`w ef c`i on} aii` qiwyq`ig.

/f% Woi mcyqw ky}w }ya}wn`wenddu mck|du rewo]ya}imwec` /i% cf woe} nqwemdi. Woi fnedyqi cf woi mcyqwwc mck|du rewo ]ya}imwec` /i% cf woe} nqwemdi e} `cwbqcy`g} fcq woi gifi`gn`w wc }iw n}egi woimc`vemwec`$ }i`wi`mi$ cq |din.

/b% Aifcqi nmmi|we`b n |din cf byedwu cq n |din cf `cdcmc`wi`giqi n`g c` woi qi~yi}w cf n vemwek cf woicffi`}i$ woi mcyqw knu n}}e}w woi vemwek n`g woi

gifi`gn`w e` |nqweme|nwe`b e` n vemwek+cffi`giq kigenwec` |qcbqnk.

/o% Woi mcyqw ky}w }ya}wn`wenddu mck|du rewo]ya}imwec` /n%/9%. Woi fnedyqi cf woi mcyqw wc mck|durewo ]ya}imwec` /n%/9% e} `cw n bqcy`g fcq woigifi`gn`w wc }iw n}egi woi mc`vemwec`$ }i`wi`mi$ cq |din.

/e% @cwrewo}wn`ge`b woe} nqwemdi$ n mcyqw }ondd `cw cqgiq woi }wnwi cq n`u cf ew} |qc}imywe`b nwwcq`iu} wc|nqweme|nwi e` kigenwec`$ ge}|ywi qi}cdywec`$nqaewqnwec`$ cq cwoiq }ekednq |qcmigyqi} e` qidnwec` wc

n mqeke`nd |qc}imywec` y`di}} y|c` rqewwi` mc`}i`wcf woi }wnwi.

Nqw. 16.>7. Hyqu c` \din cf Byedwu

Roiqi n gifi`gn`w e` n mn}i cf fidc`u |iq}e}w} e`|dinge`b byedwu cq e` i`wiqe`b n |din cf `cdcmc`wi`giqi$ ef woi |y`e}oki`w e} `cw na}cdywidu fexigau dnr$ n hyqu }ondd ai ek|n`idig wc n}}i}} woi|y`e}oki`w n`g ivegi`mi knu ai oinqg wc i`nadi

Page 42: Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

7/30/2019 Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fair-defense-law-dec-2011-tidc 42/76

 

=6

woik wc gimegi woiqiy|c`$ y`di}} woi gifi`gn`w e`nmmcqgn`mi rewo Nqwemdi} >.>= cq =2.<2 }ondd onvirnevig oe} qebow wc wqend au hyqu.

Nqw. 16.>9. Mcqqimwe`b @nki

E` n`u mn}i$ woi }nki |qcmiige`b} }ondd ai ong rewoqi}|imw wc woi `nki cf woi gifi`gn`w n`g woimcqqimwec` cf woi e`gemwki`w cq e`fcqknwec` n}|qcvegig rewo qi}|imw wc woi }nki e` mn|ewnd mn}i}.

MON\WIQ WOEQWU+IEBOW8 IVEGI@MI E@MQEKE@ND NMWEC@]

Nqw. =?.=<. E`wiq|qiwiq

/n% Roi` n kcwec` fcq n||ce`wki`w cf n` e`wiq|qiwiq e} fedig au n`u |nqwu cq c` kcwec` cf woi mcyqw$ e` n`umqeke`nd |qcmiige`b$ ew e} giwiqke`ig wonw n |iq}c`monqbig cq n rew`i}} gci} `cw y`giq}wn`g n`g

}|inj woi I`bde}o dn`bynbi$ n` e`wiq|qiwiq ky}w ai}rcq` wc e`wiq|qiw fcq woi |iq}c` monqbig cq woirew`i}}. N`u |iq}c` knu ai }ya|ci`nig$ nwwnmoigcq qimcb`eig e` n`u mqeke`nd nmwec` cq |qcmiige`b$wc n||inq aifcqi woi |qc|iq hygbi cq mcyqw wc nmw n}e`wiq|qiwiq woiqie`$ y`giq woi }nki qydi} n`g|i`ndwei} n} nqi |qcvegig fcq rew`i}}i}. E` woi ivi`wwonw woi c`du nvnednadi e`wiq|qiwiq e} `cw mc`}egiqigwc |c}}i}} ngi~ynwi e`wiq|qiwe`b }jedd} fcq woi|nqwemydnq }ewynwec` cq woi e`wiq|qiwiq e} `cw fnkedenq rewo y}i cf }dn`b$ woi |iq}c` monqbig cq rew`i}}knu ai |iqkewwig au woi mcyqw wc `cke`nwi n`cwoiq |iq}c` wc nmw n} e`wiqkigenqu aiwrii` woi |iq}c`

monqbig cq rew`i}} n`g woi n||ce`wig e`wiq|qiwiq gyqe`b woi |qcmiige`b}.

/n+>% N ~yndefeig widi|oc`i e`wiq|qiwiq knu ai }rcq`wc e`wiq|qiw fcq woi |iq}c` e` woi wqend cf n mdn}} Mke}gikin`cq cq n |qcmiige`b aifcqi n knbe}wqnwi ef n` e`wiq|qiwiq e} `cw nvnednadi wc n||inq e` |iq}c`aifcqi woi mcyqw cf ef woi c`du nvnednadi e`wiq|qiwiq e}`cw mc`}egiqig wc |c}}i}} ngi~ynwi e`wiq|qiwe`b}jedd} fcq woi |nqwemydnq }ewynwec` cq e} y`fnkedenq rewowoi y}i cf }dn`b. E` woe} }ya}imwec`$ ’~yndefeigwidi|oc`i e`wiq|qiwiq‖ kin`} n widi|oc`i }iqvemiwonw ik|dcu}8

/>% demi`}ig mcyqw e`wiq|qiwiq} n} gife`ig au]imwec` 92.<<>$ Bcviq`ki`w Mcgi: cq 

/1% figiqnddu miqwefeig mcyqw e`wiq|qiwiq}.

/a% Ixmi|w n} |qcvegig au ]ya}imwec` /m% cf woe}nqwemdi$ e`wiq|qiwiq} n||ce`wig y`giq woi wiqk} cf woe}nqwemdi redd qimievi fqck woi bi`iqnd fy`g cf woimcy`wu fcq woieq }iqvemi} n }yk `cw wc ixmiig '><< n

gnu n} fcddcr}8 e`wiq|qiwiq} }ondd ai |neg `cw di}}won` '>9 `cq kcqi won` '><< n gnu nw woi ge}mqiwec`cf woi hygbi |qi}ege`b$ n`g roi` wqnvid cf woie`wiq|qiwiq e} e`vcdvig ndd woi nmwynd ix|i`}i} cf wqnvid$ dcgbe`b$ n`g kind} e`myqqig au woi e`wiq|qiwiq |iqwne`e`b wc woi mn}i woi e`wiq|qiwiq e} n||ce`wig wc}iqvi }ondd ai |neg nw woi }nki qnwi n||demnadi wc}wnwi ik|dcuii}.

/m% N mcy`wu mckke}}ec`iq} mcyqw knu }iw n|nuki`w }moigydi n`g ix|i`g fy`g} fcq woi}iqvemi} cf e`wiq|qiwiq} e` ixmi}} cf woi gnedu nkcy`wcf `cw di}} won` '>9 cq kcqi won` '><< i}wnade}oigau ]ya}imwec` /a% cf woe} nqwemdi.

Nqw. =?.=>. E`wiq|qiwiq} fcq Ginf \iq}c`}

/n% Ef woi mcyqw e} `cwefeig au n |nqwu wonw woigifi`gn`w e} ginf n`g redd ai |qi}i`w nw n`nqqneb`ki`w$ oinqe`b$ ixnke`e`b wqend$ cq wqend$ cq wonw

n rew`i}} e} ginf n`g redd ai mnddig nw n oinqe`b$ixnke`e`b wqend$ cq wqend$ woi mcyqw }ondd n||ce`w n~yndefeig e`wiq|qiwiq wc e`wiq|qiw woi |qcmiige`b} e`n`u dn`bynbi wonw woi ginf |iq}c` mn` y`giq}wn`g$e`mdyge`b ayw `cw dekewig wc }eb` dn`bynbi. C` woimcyqw"} kcwec` cq woi kcwec` cf n |nqwu$ woi mcyqw knucqgiq wi}wekc`u cf n ginf rew`i}} n`g woie`wiq|qiwnwec` cf wonw wi}wekc`u au woi e`wiq|qiwiq ve}ynddu$ idimwqc`emnddu qimcqgig fcq y}i e` viqefemnwec`cf woi wqn`}mqe|wec` cf woi qi|cqwiq"} `cwi}. Woi mdiqjcf woi mcyqw }ondd e`mdygi wonw qimcqge`b e` woin||iddnwi qimcqg ef qi~yi}wig au n |nqwu y`giq Nqwemdi7<.<5 cf woe} Mcgi.

/a% Fcddcre`b woi fede`b cf n` e`gemwki`w$ e`fcqknwec`$cq mck|dne`w nbne`}w n ginf gifi`gn`w$ woi mcyqw c`woi kcwec` cf woi gifi`gn`w }ondd n||ce`w n ~yndefeige`wiq|qiwiq wc e`wiq|qiw e` n dn`bynbi wonw woigifi`gn`w mn` y`giq}wn`g$ e`mdyge`b ayw `cw dekewigwc }eb` dn`bynbi$ mckky`emnwec`} mc`miq`e`b woimn}i aiwrii` woi gifi`gn`w n`g gifi`}i mcy`}id.Woi e`wiq|qiwiq knu `cw ge}mdc}i n mckky`emnwec`aiwrii` woi gifi`gn`w n`g gifi`}i mcy`}id cq nfnmw wonw mnki wc woi nwwi`wec` cf woi e`wiq|qiwiq roedie`wiq|qiwe`b woc}i mckky`emnwec`} ef gifi`}imcy`}id knu `cw ge}mdc}i wonw mckky`emnwec` cq 

fnmw.

/m% E` ndd mn}i} roiqi woi ki`wnd mc`gewec` cf n|iq}c` e} aie`b mc`}egiqig n`g roiqi }ymo |iq}c`knu ai mckkewwig wc n ki`wnd e`}wewywec`$ n`g roiqi}ymo |iq}c` e} ginf$ ndd cf woi mcyqw |qcmiige`b}|iqwne`e`b wc oek }ondd ai e`wiq|qiwig au n ~yndefeige`wiq|qiwiq n||ce`wig au woi mcyqw.

Page 43: Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

7/30/2019 Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fair-defense-law-dec-2011-tidc 43/76

 

=2

/g% N |qcmiige`b fcq roemo n` e`wiq|qiwiq e} qi~yeqigwc ai n||ce`wig y`giq woe} Nqwemdi knu `cwmckki`mi y`wed woi n||ce`wig e`wiq|qiwiq e} e` n|c}ewec` `cw ixmiige`b wi` fiiw fqck n`g e` fydd veircf woi ginf |iq}c`.

/i% Woi e`wiq|qiwiq n||ce`wig y`giq woi wiqk} cf woe} Nqwemdi }ondd ai qi~yeqig wc wnji n` cnwo wonw oi reddknji n wqyi e`wiq|qiwnwec` wc woi |iq}c` nmmy}ig cq aie`b ixnke`ig$ roemo |iq}c` e} ginf$ cf ndd woi|qcmiige`b} cf oe} mn}i e` n dn`bynbi wonw oiy`giq}wn`g}: n`g wonw oi redd qi|inw }neg ginf |iq}c`"} n`}riq wc ~yi}wec`} wc mcy`}id$ mcyqw$ cq  hyqu$ e` woi I`bde}o dn`bynbi$ e` oe} ai}w }jedd n`g hygbki`w.

/f% E`wiq|qiwiq} n||ce`wig y`giq woe} Nqwemdi nqii`wewdig wc n qin}c`nadi fii giwiqke`ig au woi mcyqwnfwiq mc`}egiqe`b woi qimckki`gnwec`} cf woi Wixn}Mckke}}ec` fcq woi Ginf n`g Onqg cf Oinqe`b.

Roi` wqnvid cf woi e`wiq|qiwiq e} e`vcdvig ndd woinmwynd ix|i`}i} cf wqnvid$ dcgbe`b$ n`g kind}e`myqqig au woi e`wiq|qiwiq |iqwne`e`b wc woi mn}i oie} n||ce`wig wc }iqvi }ondd ai |neg nw woi }nki qnwin||demnadi wc }wnwi ik|dcuii}.

/b% E` woe} Mcgi8

/>% !Ginf |iq}c`! kin`} n |iq}c` roc on} noinqe`b ek|neqki`w$ qibnqgdi}} cf roiwoiq woi|iq}c` nd}c on} n }|iimo ek|neqki`w$ wonwe`oeaew} woi |iq}c`"} mck|qioi`}ec` cf woi|qcmiige`b} cq mckky`emnwec` rewo cwoiq}.

/1% !^yndefeig e`wiq|qiwiq! kin`} n` e`wiq|qiwiq fcq woi ginf roc ocdg} n myqqi`w dibnd miqwefemnwie}}yig au woi @nwec`nd Qibe}wqu cf E`wiq|qiwiq}fcq woi Ginf cq n myqqi`w mcyqw e`wiq|qiwiq miqwefemnwi e}}yig au woi Acnqg fcq Ivndynwec` cf E`wiq|qiwiq} nw woi Gi|nqwki`w cf N}}e}wevi cq Qionaedewnwevi ]iqvemi}.

MON\WIQ FCQWU+WRC8 HYGBKI@W N@G]I@WI@MI

Nqw. 71.>1. Mckky`ewu ]y|iqve}ec`.

]im. 1>. Vecdnwec` cf Mckky`ewu ]y|iqve}ec`8Giwi`wec` n`g Oinqe`b

/n% Nw n`u weki gyqe`b woi |iqecg cf mckky`ewu}y|iqve}ec` woi hygbi knu e}}yi n rnqqn`w fcq vecdnwec` cf n`u cf woi mc`gewec`} cf woi mckky`ewu}y|iqve}ec` n`g mny}i n gifi`gn`w mc`vemwig y`giq ]imwec` 7=.<1$ \i`nd Mcgi$ cq y`giq Mon|wiq 7?>$Oindwo n`g ]nfiwu Mcgi$ cq ]imwec`} 7?9.<=>

woqcybo 7?9.<=9$ Oindwo n`g ]nfiwu Mcgi$ cq |dnmigc` gifiqqig nghygemnwec` nfwiq aie`b monqbig rewoc`i cf woc}i cffi`}i}$ wc ai }yahimw wc woi mc`wqcdkin}yqi} cf ]imwec` ?>.<?=$ Oindwo n`g ]nfiwuMcgi$ n`g wc woi mcyqw+cqgiqig+kn`nbiki`w|qcve}ec`} cf ]yamon|wiq B$ Mon|wiq ?>$ Oindwo n`g]nfiwu Mcgi.

/a% Nw n`u weki gyqe`b woi |iqecg cf mckky`ewu}y|iqve}ec` woi hygbi knu e}}yi n rnqqn`w fcq vecdnwec` cf n`u cf woi mc`gewec`} cf woi mckky`ewu}y|iqve}ec` n`g mny}i woi gifi`gn`w wc ai nqqi}wig. N`u }y|iqve}ec` cffemiq$ |cdemi cffemiq cq cwoiq cffemiq rewo |criq cf nqqi}w knu nqqi}w }ymo gifi`gn`w rewocq rewocyw n rnqqn`w y|c` woi cqgiq cf woi hygbi wcai `cwig c` woi gcmjiw cf woi mcyqw. ]yahimw wc]ya}imwec` /a+>%$ n N gifi`gn`w }c nqqi}wig y`giq woe} }ya}imwec` knu ai giwne`ig e` woi mcy`wu hned cq cwoiq n||qc|qenwi |dnmi cf mc`fe`iki`w y`wed oi mn`ai wnji` aifcqi woi hygbi fcq n giwiqke`nwec`

qibnqge`b woi nddibig vecdnwec`. Woi nqqi}we`b]ymocffemiq }ondd ekkigenwidufcqworewo qi|cqw woi}ymonqqi}w n`g giwi`wec` wc woi}ymo hygbi.

/a+>% Rewocyw n`u y``imi}}nqu gidnu$ ayw `cw dnwiq won` 7? ocyq} nfwiq woi |iq}c` e} nqqi}wig$ woinqqi}we`b cffemiq cq woi |iq}c` rewo my}wcgu cf woinqqi}wig |iq}c` }ondd wnji woi nqqi}wig |iq}c`aifcqi woi hygbi roc cqgiqig woi nqqi}w fcq woinddibig vecdnwec` cf n mc`gewec` cf mckky`ewu}y|iqve}ec` cq$ ef woi hygbi e} y`nvnednadi$ aifcqi nknbe}wqnwi cf woi mcy`wu e` roemo woi |iq}c` rn}nqqi}wig. Woi hygbi cq knbe}wqnwi }ondd |iqfcqk ndd

n||qc|qenwi gywei} n`g knu ixiqme}i ndd n||qc|qenwi|criq} n} |qcvegig au Nqwemdi >9.>2 rewo qi}|imw wcn` nqqi}w fcq n `ir mqeke`nd cffi`}i$ ixmi|w wonw c`duwoi hygbi roc cqgiqig woi nqqi}w fcq woi nddibigvecdnwec` knu nywocqei woi |iq}c`"} qidin}i c` aned.Woi nqqi}wig |iq}c` knu ai wnji` aifcqi woi hygbicq knbe}wqnwi y`giq woe} }ya}imwec` au kin`} cf n`idimwqc`em aqcngmn}w }u}wik n} |qcvegig au n`g}yahimw wc woi qi~yeqiki`w} cf Nqwemdi >9.>2.

/a+1% Ef woi gifi`gn`w on} `cw aii` qidin}ig c` anedn} |iqkewwig y`giq ]ya}imwec` /a+>%$ c` kcwec` auwoi gifi`gn`w woi hygbi roc cqgiqig woi nqqi}w fcq 

woi nddibig vecdnwec` cf n mc`gewec` cf mckky`ewu}y|iqve}ec` }ondd mny}i woi gifi`gn`w wc ai aqcybowaifcqi woi hygbi fcq n oinqe`b c` woi nddibigvecdnwec` rewoe` 1< gnu} cf fede`b cf }neg kcwec`$ n`gnfwiq n oinqe`b rewocyw n hyqu$ knu iewoiq mc`we`yi$ixwi`g$ kcgefu$ cq qivcji woi mckky`ewu}y|iqve}ec`. N hygbi knu qivcji woi mckky`ewu}y|iqve}ec` cf n gifi`gn`w roc e} ek|qe}c`ig e` n|i`nd e`}wewywec` rewocyw n oinqe`b ef woi gifi`gn`w e`rqewe`b aifcqi n mcyqw cf qimcqg e` woi hyqe}gemwec`

Page 44: Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

7/30/2019 Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fair-defense-law-dec-2011-tidc 44/76

 

=?

roiqi ek|qe}c`ig rnevi} oe} qebow wc n oinqe`b n`gwc mcy`}id$ nffeqk} wonw oi on} `cwoe`b wc }nu n} wcrou }i`wi`mi }ocydg `cw ai |qc`cy`mig nbne`}woek$ n`g qi~yi}w} woi hygbi wc qivcji mckky`ewu}y|iqve}ec` n`g wc |qc`cy`mi }i`wi`mi. E` n fidc`umn}i$ woi }wnwi knu nki`g woi kcwec` wc qivcjimckky`ewu }y|iqve}ec` n`u weki y| wc }ivi` gnu}aifcqi woi gnwi cf woi qivcmnwec` oinqe`b$ nfwiq roemo weki woi kcwec` knu `cw ai nki`gig ixmi|wfcq bccg mny}i }ocr`$ n`g e` `c ivi`w knu woi}wnwi nki`g woi kcwec` nfwiq woi mckki`miki`w cf wnje`b ivegi`mi nw woi oinqe`b. Woi hygbi knumc`we`yi woi oinqe`b fcq bccg mny}i }ocr` au iewoiq woi gifi`gn`w cq woi }wnwi.

/m% E` n mckky`ewu }y|iqve}ec` qivcmnwec` oinqe`bnw roemo ew e} nddibig c`du wonw woi gifi`gn`w vecdnwigwoi mc`gewec`} cf mckky`ewu }y|iqve}ec` au fnede`b wc|nu mck|i`}nwec` |neg wc n||ce`wig mcy`}id$mckky`ewu }y|iqve}ec` fii}$ cq mcyqw mc}w}$ woi }wnwi

ky}w |qcvi au n |qi|c`giqn`mi cf woi ivegi`mi wonwwoi gifi`gn`w rn} nadi wc |nu n`g geg `cw |nu n}cqgiqig au woi hygbi. Woi mcyqw knu cqgiq nmckky`ewu }y|iqve}ec` n`g mcqqimwec`} gi|nqwki`wwc cawne` e`fcqknwec` |iqwne`e`b wc woi fnmwcq} de}wigy`giq Nqwemdi 71.<=2/o% cf woe} mcgi n`g e`mdygi wonwe`fcqknwec` e` woi qi|cqw qi~yeqig y`giq ]imwec` 5/n%cf woe} nqwemdi cq n }i|nqnwi qi|cqw$ n} woi mcyqwgeqimw}.

/g% N gifi`gn`w on} n qebow wc mcy`}id nw n oinqe`by`giq woe} }imwec`. Woi mcyqw }ondd n||ce`w mcy`}idfcq n` e`gebi`w gifi`gn`w e` nmmcqgn`mi rewo woi

|qcmigyqi} ngc|wig y`giq Nqwemdi 16.<7.

/i% N mcyqw qiwne`} hyqe}gemwec` wc ocdg n oinqe`by`giq ]ya}imwec` /a% n`g wc qivcji$ mc`we`yi$ cq kcgefu mckky`ewu }y|iqve}ec`$ qibnqgdi}} cf roiwoiq woi |iqecg cf mckky`ewu }y|iqve}ec`ek|c}ig c` woi gifi`gn`w on} ix|eqig$ ef aifcqi woiix|eqnwec` woi nwwcq`iu qi|qi}i`we`b woi }wnwi fedi} nkcwec` wc qivcji$ mc`we`yi$ cq kcgefu mckky`ewu}y|iqve}ec` n`g n mn|en} e} e}}yig fcq woi nqqi}w cf woi gifi`gn`w.

Nki`gki`w cf /a% n`g /g% n`g nggewec`} cf /a+>% n`g /a+1%iffimwevi ]i|w. >$ 1<>> /]A >6?>$ ¢7%. ]imwec` = cf ]A >6?>

 |qcvegi}8 —Woi mon`bi e` dnr kngi au woe} Nmw n||dei} c`du wc nmqeke`nd |qcmiige`b wonw mckki`mi} c` cq nfwiq woi iffimwevi gnwi cf woe} Nmw. N mqeke`nd |qcmiige`b wonw mckki`mi} aifcqi woi iffimwevi gnwi cf woe} Nmw e} bcviq`ig au woi dnr e` iffimw roi` woi |qcmiige`b mckki`mig$ n`g woi fcqkiq dnr e} mc`we`yig e` iffimw fcq wonw |yq|c}i.‛  

1<>> Dibe}dnwevi @cwi]A >6?> nki`g} }ya}imwec` /a% n`g ngg} /a+>% n`g/a+1% wc nywocqei gifi`gn`w} nqqi}wig c` kcwec`} wcqivcji |qcanwec` wc ai aqcybow aifcqi n`u

knbe}wqnwi$ qnwoiq won` c`du woi hygbi }y|iqve}e`bwoi |qcanwec`$ wc bevi qi~yeqig rnq`e`b}$ e`mdyge`bnacyw woi qebow wc mcy`}id. Woi rnq`e`b} aifcqi woi hygbi cq knbe}wqnwi ky}w ai |qcvegig rewoe` 7?ocyq} cf nqqi}w. Woi aedd gci} `cw |iqkew knbe}wqnwi}wc qidin}i }ymo |iq}c`} c` aned. ]A >6?> |qcvegi}wonw woi nqqi}wig |iq}c` knu ai wnji` aifcqi woi hygbi cq knbe}wqnwi ven n` idimwqc`em aqcngmn}w}u}wik n} |qcvegig n`g }yahimw wc woi qi~yeqiki`w}cf Nqw. >9.>2.]A >6?> nki`g} }ya}imwec` /g% wc qi~yeqi woi mcyqwwc n||ce`w mcy`}id fcq n` e`gebi`w gifi`gn`w e`nmmcqgn`mi rewo |qcmigyqi} y`giq Nqw. 16.<7$ woidcmnd e`gebi`w gifi`}i |dn`.

Mckki`wnquEf |qcanwec`iq nw qivcmnwec` oinqe`b e} e`gebi`w n`gon} `cw rnevig woi qebow wc mcy`}id$ mcy`}id ky}w ain||ce`wig. Kik|n v. Qonu $ =?5 Y.]. >1?$ >=2/>562%.

FNKEDU MCGI

MON\WIQ FEFWU+C@I8 BI@IQND \QCVE]EC@]

]im. 9>.><. Qebow wc N}}e}wn`mi cf Nwwcq`iu:Mck|i`}nwec` 

/n% N moedg knu ai qi|qi}i`wig au n` nwwcq`iu nwiviqu }wnbi cf |qcmiige`b} y`giq woe} wewdi$ e`mdyge`b8

/>% woi giwi`wec` oinqe`b qi~yeqig au ]imwec`97.<> cf woe} mcgi:

/1% woi oinqe`b wc mc`}egiq wqn`}fiq wc mqeke`ndmcyqw qi~yeqig au ]imwec` 97.<1 cf woe} mcgi:

/=% woi nghygemnwec` oinqe`b qi~yeqig au ]imwec`97.<= cf woe} mcgi:

/7% woi ge}|c}ewec` oinqe`b qi~yeqig au ]imwec`97.<7 cf woe} mcgi:

/9% woi oinqe`b wc kcgefu ge}|c}ewec` qi~yeqig au]imwec` 97.<9 cf woe} mcgi:

/6% oinqe`b} qi~yeqig au Mon|wiq 99 cf woe} mcgi:

/2% onain} mcq|y} |qcmiige`b} monddi`be`b woidibndewu cf giwi`wec` qi}ydwe`b fqck nmwec` y`giq woe} wewdi: n`g

/?% |qcmiige`b} e` n mcyqw cf meved n||ind} cq woiWixn} ]y|qiki Mcyqw qiveire`b |qcmiige`b}y`giq woe} wewdi.

Page 45: Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

7/30/2019 Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fair-defense-law-dec-2011-tidc 45/76

 

=5

/a% Woi moedg"} qebow wc qi|qi}i`wnwec` au n` nwwcq`iu}ondd `cw ai rnevig e`8

/>% n oinqe`b wc mc`}egiq wqn`}fiq wc mqeke`ndmcyqw n} qi~yeqig au ]imwec` 97.<1 cf woe} mcgi:

/1% n` nghygemnwec` oinqe`b n} qi~yeqig au]imwec` 97.<= cf woe} mcgi:

/=% n ge}|c}ewec` oinqe`b n} qi~yeqig au ]imwec`97.<7 cf woe} mcgi:

/7% n oinqe`b |qecq wc mckkewki`w wc woi Wixn}Ucywo Mckke}}ec` n} n kcgefeig ge}|c}ewec` e`nmmcqgn`mi rewo ]imwec` 97.<9/f% cf woe} mcgi: cq 

/9% oinqe`b} qi~yeqig au Mon|wiq 99 cf woe} mcgi.

/m% Ef woi moedg rn} `cw qi|qi}i`wig au n` nwwcq`iu nw

woi giwi`wec` oinqe`b qi~yeqig au ]imwec` 97.<> cf woe} mcgi n`g n giwiqke`nwec` rn} kngi wc giwne`woi moedg$ woi moedg }ondd ekkigenwidu ai i`wewdig wcqi|qi}i`wnwec` au n` nwwcq`iu. Woi mcyqw }ondd cqgiq woi qiwi`wec` cf n` nwwcq`iu nmmcqge`b wc ]ya}imwec`/g% cq n||ce`w n` nwwcq`iu nmmcqge`b wc ]ya}imwec`/f%.

/g% Woi mcyqw }ondd cqgiq n moedg"} |nqi`w cq cwoiq |iq}c` qi}|c`}eadi fcq }y||cqw cf woi moedg wc ik|dcun` nwwcq`iu wc qi|qi}i`w woi moedg$ ef8

/>% woi moedg e} `cw qi|qi}i`wig au n` nwwcq`iu:

/1% nfwiq beve`b woi n||qc|qenwi |nqwei} n`c||cqwy`ewu wc ai oinqg$ woi mcyqw giwiqke`i}wonw woi |nqi`w cq cwoiq |iq}c` qi}|c`}eadi fcq }y||cqw cf woi moedg e} fe`n`menddu nadi wc ik|dcun` nwwcq`iu wc qi|qi}i`w woi moedg: n`g

/=% woi moedg"} qebow wc qi|qi}i`wnwec` au n`nwwcq`iu8

/N% on} `cw aii` rnevig y`giq ]imwec`9>.<5 cf woe} mcgi: cq 

/A% knu `cw ai rnevig y`giq ]ya}imwec` /a%cf woe} }imwec`.

/i% Woi mcyqw knu i`fcqmi cqgiq} y`giq ]ya}imwec`/g% au |qcmiige`b} y`giq ]imwec` 97.<2 cq aun||ce`we`b mcy`}id n`g cqgiqe`b woi |nqi`w cq cwoiq |iq}c` qi}|c`}eadi fcq }y||cqw cf woi moedg wc |nu nqin}c`nadi nwwcq`iu"} fii }iw au woi mcyqw. Woi cqgiq knu ai i`fcqmig y`giq ]imwec` 97.<2.

/f% Woi mcyqw }ondd n||ce`w n` nwwcq`iu wc qi|qi}i`wwoi e`wiqi}w cf n moedg i`wewdig wc qi|qi}i`wnwec` au n`nwwcq`iu$ ef8

/>% woi moedg e} `cw qi|qi}i`wig au n` nwwcq`iu:

/1% woi mcyqw giwiqke`i} wonw woi moedg"} |nqi`w cq cwoiq |iq}c` qi}|c`}eadi fcq }y||cqw cf woi moedge} fe`n`menddu y`nadi wc ik|dcu n` nwwcq`iu wcqi|qi}i`w woi moedg: n`g

/=% woi moedg"} qebow wc qi|qi}i`wnwec` au n`nwwcq`iu8

/N% on} `cw aii` rnevig y`giq ]imwec`9>.<5 cf woe} mcgi: cq 

/A% knu `cw ai rnevig y`giq ]ya}imwec` /a%cf woe} }imwec`.

/b% Woi hyvi`edi mcyqw knu n||ce`w n` nwwcq`iu e` n`umn}i e` roemo ew giik} qi|qi}i`wnwec` `imi}}nqu wc|qcwimw woi e`wiqi}w} cf woi moedg.

/o% N`u nwwcq`iu qi|qi}i`we`b n moedg e` |qcmiige`b}y`giq woe} wewdi e} i`wewdig wc >< gnu} wc |qi|nqi fcq n`u nghygemnwec` cq wqn`}fiq oinqe`b y`giq woe} wewdi.

/e% Ixmi|w n} |qcvegig e` ]ya}imwec` /g% cf woe}}imwec`$ n` nwwcq`iu n||ce`wig y`giq woe} }imwec` wcqi|qi}i`w woi e`wiqi}w} cf n moedg }ondd ai |neg fqckwoi bi`iqnd fy`g cf woi mcy`wu e` roemo woi|qcmiige`b} riqi e`}wewywig nmmcqge`b wc woi

}moigydi e` Nqwemdi 16.<9 cf woi Wixn} Mcgi cf Mqeke`nd \qcmigyqi$ >569. Fcq woe} |yq|c}i$ n ac`nfegi n||ind wc n mcyqw cf meved n||ind} cq |qcmiige`b}c` woi kiqew} e` woi Wixn} ]y|qiki Mcyqw nqimc`}egiqig woi i~yevndi`w cf n ac`n fegi n||ind wcwoi Wixn} Mcyqw cf Mqeke`nd N||ind}.

/h% Woi hyvi`edi acnqg cf n mcy`wu knu knjinvnednadi wc woi |yadem woi de}w cf nwwcq`iu} idebeadi fcq n||ce`wki`w wc qi|qi}i`w moedgqi` e` |qcmiige`b}y`giq woe} wewdi n} |qcvegig e` woi |dn` ngc|wig y`giq ]imwec` 9>.><1. Woi de}w cf nwwcq`iu} ky}w e`gemnwiwoi divid cf mn}i fcq roemo inmo nwwcq`iu e} idebeadi

fcq n||ce`wki`w y`giq ]imwec` 9>.><1/a%/1%.

/j% ]yahimw wc Mon|wiq 6>$ woi hyvi`edi mcyqw knucqgiq woi |nqi`w cq cwoiq |iq}c` qi}|c`}eadi fcq }y||cqw cf woi moedg wc qiekayq}i woi mcy`wu fcq |nuki`w} woi mcy`wu kngi wc mcy`}id n||ce`wig wcqi|qi}i`w woi moedg y`giq ]ya}imwec` /f% cq /b%. Woimcyqw knu8

Page 46: Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

7/30/2019 Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fair-defense-law-dec-2011-tidc 46/76

 

7<

/>% cqgiq |nuki`w fcq inmo nwwcq`iu roc on}qi|qi}i`wig woi moedg nw n`u oinqe`b$ e`mdyge`b ngiwi`wec` oinqe`b$ ge}mqiwec`nqu wqn`}fiq oinqe`b$nghygemnwec` oinqe`b$ ge}|c}ewec` oinqe`b$ cq kcgefemnwec` cf ge}|c}ewec` oinqe`b:/1% e`mdygi nkcy`w} |neg wc cq c` aiondf cf woinwwcq`iu au woi mcy`wu fcq |qi|nqnwec` weki n`ge`vi}webnwevi n`g ix|iqw rew`i}} mc}w}: n`g

/=% qi~yeqi fydd cq |nqwend qiekayq}iki`w wc woimcy`wu.

/d% Woi mcyqw knu `cw cqgiq |nuki`w} y`giq ]ya}imwec` /j% wonw ixmiig woi fe`n`mend naedewu cf woi|nqi`w cq cwoiq |iq}c` qi}|c`}eadi fcq }y||cqw cf woimoedg wc kiiw woi |nuki`w }moigydi cqgiqig au woimcyqw.

Mckki`wnquHyvi`edi |qcmiige`b} nqi ~yn}e+mqeke`nd e` `nwyqi

ivi` wocybo woiu nqi mdn}}efeig n} meved |qcmiige`b}.E` qi G.N.].$ 52= ].R.1g 156$ 15? /Wix. >55?%/mewe`b E` qi Bnydw$ =?2 Y.]. >$ =< />562%%. Keqn`gn  rnq`e`b qi~yeqiki`w} n||du wc hyvi`edi} n} ridd n}ngydw}. E` qi Bnydw $ =?2 Y.]. > />562%.

Woi N`giq}  |qcmigyqi }iw fcqwo au woi ]y|qikiMcyqw ixwi`g} wc hyvi`edi n||ind}. E` qi G.N.].$ 52=].R.1g nw 15?.

 N||ce`wki`w cf mcy`}id e} |qcvegig fcq hyvi`edi} nwoinqe`b} e` roemo woi e}}yi cf woi moedg‟} gide`~yi`wmc`gymw e} wqeig$ nw ge}|c}ewec` oinqe`b} ef woi moedg e}

fcy`g wc onvi i`bnbig e` gide`~yi`w mc`gymw$ nwge}|c}ewec`} e`vcdve`b }i`wi`me`b cf n moedg wcmckkewki`w e` woi Wixn} Ucywo Mckke}}ec` rewo n|c}}eadi wqn`}fiq wc woi Wixn} Gi|nqwki`w cf Mqeke`nd Hy}wemi$ n`g nw qidin}i cq wqn`}fiq oinqe`b}.E` qi Ondd $ 1?6 ].R.=g 519$ 515+=< /Wix. 1<<5%.Woiqi e} `c qebow wc n||ce`wig mcy`}id fcq |c}w+nghygemnwec` onain} mcq|y} |qcmiige`b}. Eg. nw 5=<.

]im. 9>.><>. N||ce`wki`w cf Nwwcq`iu n`gMc`we`ynwec` cf Qi|qi}i`wnwec` 

/n% Ef n` nwwcq`iu e} n||ce`wig nw woi e`ewend giwi`wec`

oinqe`b n`g woi moedg e} giwne`ig$ woi nwwcq`iu }onddmc`we`yi wc qi|qi}i`w woi moedg y`wed woi mn}i e}wiqke`nwig$ woi fnkedu qiwne`} n` nwwcq`iu$ cq n `irnwwcq`iu e} n||ce`wig au woi hyvi`edi mcyqw. Qidin}icf woi moedg fqck giwi`wec` gci} `cw wiqke`nwi woinwwcq`iu"} qi|qi}i`wnwec`.

/a% Ef woiqi e} n` e`ewend giwi`wec` oinqe`b rewocyw n`nwwcq`iu n`g woi moedg e} giwne`ig$ woi nwwcq`iun||ce`wig y`giq ]imwec` 9>.></m% }ondd mc`we`yi wc

qi|qi}i`w woi moedg y`wed woi mn}i e} wiqke`nwig$ woifnkedu qiwne`} n` nwwcq`iu$ cq n `ir nwwcq`iu e}n||ce`wig au woi hyvi`edi mcyqw. Qidin}i cf woi moedgfqck giwi`wec` gci} `cw wiqke`nwi woi nwwcq`iu"}qi|qi}i`wnwec`.

/m% Woi hyvi`edi mcyqw }ondd giwiqke`i$ c` woi fede`b cf n |iwewec`$ roiwoiq woi moedg"} fnkedu e} e`gebi`w ef8 />%woi moedg e} qidin}ig au e`wnji: /1% woi moedg e}qidin}ig nw woi e`ewend giwi`wec` oinqe`b: cq /=% woimn}i rn} qifiqqig wc woi mcyqw rewocyw woi moedg e`my}wcgu.

/g% N hyvi`edi mcyqw wonw knji} n fe`ge`b cf e`gebi`miy`giq ]ya}imwec` /m% }ondd n||ce`w n` nwwcq`iu wcqi|qi}i`w woi moedg c` cq aifcqi woi fefwo rcqje`b gnunfwiq woi gnwi woi |iwewec` fcq nghygemnwec` cq ge}mqiwec`nqu wqn`}fiq oinqe`b rn} }iqvig c` woimoedg. N` nwwcq`iu n||ce`wig y`giq woe} }ya}imwec`}ondd mc`we`yi wc qi|qi}i`w woi moedg y`wed woi mn}i e}

wiqke`nwig$ woi fnkedu qiwne`} n` nwwcq`iu$ cq n `irnwwcq`iu e} n||ce`wig au woi hyvi`edi mcyqw. /i% Woi hyvi`edi mcyqw }ondd giwiqke`i roiwoiq woi moedg"}fnkedu e} e`gebi`w ef n kcwec` cq |iwewec` e} fedig y`giq ]imwec` 97.<9 }iije`b wc kcgefu ge}|c}ewec` aumckkewwe`b woi moedg wc woi Wixn} Ucywo Mckke}}ec`cq |dnme`b woi moedg e` n }imyqi mcqqimwec`nd fnmedewu. Nmcyqw wonw knji} n fe`ge`b cf e`gebi`mi }ondd n||ce`wn` nwwcq`iu wc qi|qi}i`w woi moedg c` cq aifcqi woifefwo rcqje`b gnu nfwiq woi gnwi woi |iwewec` cq kcwec`on} aii` fedig. N` nwwcq`iu n||ce`wig y`giq woe}}ya}imwec` }ondd mc`we`yi wc qi|qi}i`w woi moedg y`wedwoi mcyqw qydi} c` woi kcwec` cq |iwewec`$ woi fnkedu

qiwne`} n` nwwcq`iu$ cq n `ir nwwcq`iu e} n||ce`wig.

]im. 9>.><1. N||ce`wki`w cf Mcy`}id \dn` 

/n% Woi hyvi`edi acnqg e` inmo mcy`wu }ondd ngc|w n|dn` wonw8

/>% }|imefei} woi ~yndefemnwec`} `imi}}nqu fcq n`nwwcq`iu wc ai e`mdygig c` n` n||ce`wki`w de}wfqck roemo nwwcq`iu} nqi n||ce`wig wc qi|qi}i`wmoedgqi` e` |qcmiige`b} y`giq woe} wewdi: n`g

/1% i}wnade}oi} woi |qcmigyqi} fcq8

/N% e`mdyge`b nwwcq`iu} c` woi n||ce`wki`wde}w n`g qikcve`b nwwcq`iu} fqck woi de}w: n`g

/A% n||ce`we`b nwwcq`iu} fqck woin||ce`wki`w de}w wc e`gevegynd mn}i}.

/a% N |dn` ngc|wig y`giq ]ya}imwec` /n% ky}w8

Page 47: Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

7/30/2019 Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fair-defense-law-dec-2011-tidc 47/76

 

7>

/>% wc woi ixwi`w |qnmwemnadi$ mck|du rewo woiqi~yeqiki`w} cf Nqwemdi 16.<7$ Mcgi cf Mqeke`nd\qcmigyqi$ ixmi|w wonw8

/N% woi e`mcki n`g n}}iw} cf woi moedg‟}|nqi`w cq cwoiq |iq}c` qi}|c`}eadi fcq woimoedg‟} }y||cqw ky}w ai y}ig e` giwiqke`e`broiwoiq woi moedg e} e`gebi`w: n`g

/A% n`u ndwiq`nwevi |dn` fcq n||ce`we`bmcy`}id e} i}wnade}oig au woi hyvi`edi acnqge` woi mcy`wu: n`g

/1% qimcb`ei woi geffiqi`mi} e` ~yndefemnwec`}n`g ix|iqei`mi `imi}}nqu fcq n||ce`wki`w} wcmn}i} e` roemo8

/N% woi nddibnwec` e}8

/e% mc`gymw e`gemnwe`b n `iig fcq 

}y|iqve}ec` cq gide`~yi`w mc`gymw$ n`gmckkewki`w wc woi Wixn} UcywoMckke}}ec` e} `cw n` nywocqeigge}|c}ewec`: cq 

/ee% gide`~yi`w mc`gymw$ n`g mckkewki`wwc woi Wixn} Ucywo Mckke}}ec` rewocywn giwiqke`nwi }i`wi`mi e} n` nywocqeigge}|c}ewec`: cq 

/A% giwiqke`nwi }i`wi`mi |qcmiige`b} onviaii` e`ewenwig cq |qcmiige`b} fcq ge}mqiwec`nqu wqn`}fiq wc mqeke`nd mcyqw onvi

aii` e`ewenwig.

BCVIQ@KI@W MCGI

MON\WIQ ]IVI@WU+C@I8 BI@IQND\QCVE]EC@]

]im. 2>.<<>. Gife`ewec`} 

E` woe} mon|wiq8

/>% !N}}eb`ig mcy`}id |qcbqnk‖ kin`} n }u}wik

y`giq roemo |qevnwi nwwcq`iu}$ nmwe`b n}e`gi|i`gi`w mc`wqnmwcq} n`g mck|i`}nwig rewo|yadem fy`g}$ nqi e`gevegynddu n||ce`wig wc|qcvegi dibnd qi|qi}i`wnwec` n`g }iqvemi} wc n|nqwemydnq e`gebi`w gifi`gn`w nmmy}ig cf n mqekicq hyvi`edi cffi`}i.

/1% />% ’Moneq‖ kin`} moneq cf woi mcy`med. 

/=% ’Mc`wqnmw gifi`giq |qcbqnk! kin`} n}u}wik y`giq roemo |qevnwi nwwcq`iu}$ nmwe`b n}e`gi|i`gi`w mc`wqnmwcq} n`g mck|i`}nwig rewo|yadem fy`g}$ nqi i`bnbig wc |qcvegi dibndqi|qi}i`wnwec` n`g }iqvemi} wc n bqcy| cf y`}|imefeig e`gebi`w gifi`gn`w} roc n||inq aifcqi n |nqwemydnq mcyqw cq bqcy| cf mcyqw}.

/7%/1% ’Mcy`med‖ kin`} woi Wixn} HygemendMcy`med.

/9% ’Mqeki‖ kin`}8

/N% n ke}gikin`cq |y`e}onadi aumc`fe`iki`w: cq 

/A% n fidc`u.

/=% /6% ’Gifi`gn`w‖ kin`} n |iq}c` nmmy}ig cf n mqeki cq n  hyvi`edi cffi`}i$ n} woc}i wiqk}

nqi gife`ig au ]imwec` 25.<<>.

/2% ’E`gebi`w gifi`}i }y||cqw }iqvemi}‖ kin`}mqeke`nd gifi`}i }iqvemi} wonw8

/N% nqi |qcvegig au demi`}ig e`vi}webnwcq}$ix|iqw}$ cq cwoiq }ekednq }|imende}w}$e`mdyge`b fcqi`}em ix|iqw} n`g ki`wnd oindwoix|iqw}: n`g

/A% nqi qin}c`nadi n`g `imi}}nqu fcq n||ce`wig mcy`}id wc |qcvegi ngi~ynwiqi|qi}i`wnwec` wc e`gebi`w gifi`gn`w}.

/?% ’Hyvi`edi cffi`}i‖ kin`} mc`gymw mckkewwigau n |iq}c` roedi ucy`biq won` >2 uinq} cf nbiwonw mc`}wewywi}8

/N% n ke}gikin`cq |y`e}onadi aumc`fe`iki`w: cq 

/A% n fidc`u.

/7%/5% ’\yadem gifi`giq‟} cffemigifi`giq ‖ on} woikin`e`b n}}eb`ig au Nqwemdi 16.<77/n%$ Mcgi cf Mqeke`nd \qcmigyqi.

Nki`gki`w} wc ]imwec` 2>.<<>$ Bcviq`ki`w Mcgi$ iffimwevi ]i|w. >$ 1<>> /OA >297$ ¢1<%.

1<>> Dibe}dnwevi @cwiOA >297 nki`g} woe} }imwec` au gife`e`b ’|yademgifi`giq‟} cffemi‖ qnwoiq won` ’|yadem gifi`giq‖$qigife`e`b ’gifi`gn`w‖$ gidiwe`b gife`ewec`} cf cwoiq}wiqk}$ roemo nqi kcvig wc `ir ]im. 25.<<>.

Page 48: Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

7/30/2019 Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fair-defense-law-dec-2011-tidc 48/76

 

71

]im. 2>.<=9>. E`gebi`w Gifi`}i E`fcqknwec`

1<>> Dibe}dnwevi @cwi]im. 2>.<=9> qi|dnmig au ]im. 25.<=6 iffimwevi]i|w. >$ 1<>> /OA >297$ ¢1<%.

]im. 2>.<9>. I}wnade}oki`w cf Wn}j Fcqmi:

Mck|c}ewec` 

1<>> Dibe}dnwevi @cwi]im. 2>.<9> qi|dnmig au ]im. 25.<<1 n`g ]im.25.<>> iffimwevi ]i|w. >$ 1<>> /OA >297$ ¢1<%.

]im. 2>.<91. Ix Cffemec Kikaiq} 

1<>> Dibe}dnwevi @cwi]im. 2>.<91 qi|dnmig au ]im. 25.<>= iffimwevi ]i|w.>$ 1<>> /OA >297$ ¢1<%.

]im. 2>.<9=. N||ce`wki`w} 

1<>> Dibe}dnwevi @cwi]im. 2>.<9= qi|dnmig au ]im. 25.<>7 iffimwevi ]i|w.>$ 1<>> /OA >297$ ¢1<%.

]im. 2>.<97. Vnmn`mei}

1<>> Dibe}dnwevi @cwi]im. 2>.<97 qi|dnmig au ]im. 25.<>2 iffimwevi ]i|w.>$ 1<>> /OA >297$ ¢1<%.

]im. 2>.<99. Kiiwe`b}: ^ycqyk: Vcwe`b 

1<>> Dibe}dnwevi @cwi

]im. 2>.<99 qi|dnmig au ]im. 25.<>? iffimwevi ]i|w.>$ 1<>> /OA >297$ ¢1<%.

]im. 2>.<96. Mck|i`}nwec` 

1<>> Dibe}dnwevi @cwi]im. 2>.<96 qi|dnmig au ]im. 25.<>5 iffimwevi ]i|w.>$ 1<>> /OA >297$ ¢1<%.  

]im. 2>.<92. Aygbiw

1<>> Dibe}dnwevi @cwi]im. 2>.<92 qi|dnmig au ]im. 25.<== iffimwevi ]i|w.>$ 1<>> /OA >297$ ¢1<%.

]im. 2>.<9?. Fneq Gifi`}i Nmmcy`w

1<>> Dibe}dnwevi @cwi]im 2>.<9? qi|dnmig au ]im. 25.<=> iffimwevi ]i|w.>$ 1<>> /OA >297$ ¢1<%.

]im. 2>.<95. Nmmi|wn`mi cf befw}$ bqn`w}$ n`gcwoiq fy`g}: ]wnwi Bqn`w} Wink

1<>> Dibe}dnwevi @cwi]im. 2>.<95 qi|dnmig au ]im. 25.<=1 iffimwevi ]i|w.>$ 1<>> /OA >297$ ¢1<%.

]im. 2>.<6<. \cdemei} n`g ]wn`gnqg}

1<>> Dibe}dnwevi @cwi]im. 2>.<6< qi|dnmig au ]im. 25.<=7 iffimwevi ]i|w.>$ 1<>> /OA >297$ ¢1<%. 

]im. 2>.<6>. Mcy`wu qi|cqwe`b |dn`: Wn}j Fcqmiqi|cqw}

1<>> Dibe}dnwevi @cwi]im. 2>.<6> qi|dnmig au ]im. 25.<=9 iffimwevi ]i|w.>$ 1<>> /OA >297$ ¢1<%. 

]im. 2>.<61. Wimo`emnd }y||cqw: Bqn`w} 

1<>> Dibe}dnwevi @cwi]im. 2>.<61 qi|dnmig au ]im. 25.<=2 iffimwevi ]i|w.>$ 1<>> /OA >297$ ¢1<%. 

]im. 2>.<6=. Ekky`ewu fqck denaedewu

1<>> Dibe}dnwevi @cwi]im. 2>.<6= qi|dnmig au ]im. 25.<1< iffimwevi ]i|w.>$ 1<>> /OA >297$ ¢1<%.

MON\WIQ ]IVI@WU+IEBOW8 MN\EWND RQEW]MCKKEWWII N@G CFFEMI CF MN\EWND RQEW]

]yamon|wiq N. Mn|ewnd Rqew} Mckkewwii 

]im. 2?.<<>. Gife`ewec`}.

E` woe} }yamon|wiq8 

/>% !Mckkewwii! kin`} woi mn|ewnd rqew}mckkewwii i}wnade}oig y`giq woe} }yamon|wiq.

/1% !Cffemi cf mn|ewnd rqew}! kin`} woi cffemicf mn|ewnd rqew} i}wnade}oig y`giq ]yamon|wiq A.

]im. 2?.<<1. I}wnade}oki`w cf Mckkewwii: Gywei}

/n% Woi mn|ewnd rqew} mckkewwii e} i}wnade}oig.

/a% Woi mckkewwii }ondd qimckki`g wc woi mcyqw cf mqeke`nd n||ind} n} |qcvegig au ]imwec` 2?.<<7 ngeqimwcq fcq woi cffemi cf mn|ewnd rqew} roi` n vnmn`muixe}w} fcq woi |c}ewec` cf geqimwcq.

]im. 2?.<<=. N||ce`wki`w n`g Mck|c}ewec` cfMckkewwii

Page 49: Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

7/30/2019 Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fair-defense-law-dec-2011-tidc 49/76

 

7=

/n% Woi mckkewwii e} mck|c}ig cf woi fcddcre`b fevikikaiq} roc nqi n||ce`wig au woi |qi}egi`w cf woi]wnwi Anq cf Wixn}$ rewo qnwefemnwec` au woi iximywevimckkewwii cf woi ]wnwi Anq cf Wixn}8

/>% woqii nwwcq`iu} roc nqi kikaiq} cf woi]wnwi Anq cf Wixn} n`g roc nqi `cw ik|dcuig n}|qc}imywcq} cq dnr i`fcqmiki`w cffemend}$ ndd cf rockky}w onvi mqeke`nd gifi`}i ix|iqei`mi rewo ginwo|i`ndwu |qcmiige`b} e` woe} }wnwi: n`g

/1% wrc }wnwi ge}wqemw hygbi}$ c`i cf rock}iqvi} n} |qi}ege`b hygbi cf n` ngke`e}wqnwevi hygemend qibec`.

/a% Woi mckkewwii }ondd idimw c`i kikaiq cf woimckkewwii wc }iqvi n} woi |qi}ege`b cffemiq cf woimckkewwii.

/m% Woi mckkewwii kikaiq} }iqvi nw woi |din}yqicf woi |qi}egi`w cf woi ]wnwi Anq cf Wixn}$ n`g woimckkewwii kiiw} nw woi mndd cf woi |qi}ege`b cffemiq cf woi mckkewwii.

]im. 2?.<<7. Qimckki`gnwec` n`g N||ce`wki`wcf Geqimwcq cf Cffemi cf Mn|ewnd Rqew}

/n% Woi mckkewwii }ondd }yakew wc woi mcyqw cf mqeke`nd n||ind}$ e` cqgiq cf woi mckkewwii"}|qifiqi`mi$ n de}w cf woi `nki} cf `cw kcqi won` fevi|iq}c`} woi mckkewwii qimckki`g} wonw woi mcyqwmc`}egiq e` n||ce`we`b woi geqimwcq cf woi cffemi cf 

mn|ewnd rqew} roi` n vnmn`mu ixe}w} fcq woi |c}ewec`cf geqimwcq. Ef woi mckkewwii fe`g} wonw woqii cq kcqi|iq}c`} y`giq woi mckkewwii"} mc`}egiqnwec` nqi~yndefeig wc }iqvi n} woi geqimwcq cf woi cffemi cf mn|ewnd rqew}$ woi mckkewwii ky}w e`mdygi nw din}wwoqii `nki} e` woi de}w }yakewwig y`giq woe}}ya}imwec`.

/a% Inmo |iq}c` qimckki`gig wc woi mcyqw cf mqeke`nd n||ind} au woi mckkewwii y`giq ]ya}imwec`/n%8

/>% ky}w ixoeaew |qcfemei`mu n`g

mckkewki`w wc |qcvege`b ~yndewu qi|qi}i`wnwec` wcgifi`gn`w} e` ginwo |i`ndwu mn}i}$ n} gi}mqeaig auwoi Byegide`i} n`g ]wn`gnqg} fcq Wixn} Mn|ewndMcy`}id$ n} |yade}oig au woi ]wnwi Anq cf Wixn}:n`g

/1% knu `cw onvi aii` fcy`g au n }wnwi cq figiqnd mcyqw wc onvi qi`giqig e`iffimwevi n}}e}wn`micf mcy`}id gyqe`b woi wqend cq n||ind cf n ginwo|i`ndwu mn}i.

/m% Roi` n vnmn`mu fcq woi |c}ewec` ixe}w}$ woi mcyqwcf mqeke`nd n||ind} }ondd n||ce`w fqck woi de}w cf |iq}c`} }yakewwig wc woi mcyqw y`giq ]ya}imwec` /n%woi geqimwcq cf woi cffemi cf mn|ewnd rqew}.

Z]imwec`} 2?.<<9+2?.<9< qi}iqvig fcq ix|n`}ec`[

]yamon|wiq A. Cffemi cf Mn|ewnd Rqew}

]im. 2?.<9>. Gife`ewec`}.

E` woe} }yamon|wiq8

/>% !Mckkewwii! kin`} woi mn|ewnd rqew}mckkewwii i}wnade}oig y`giq ]yamon|wiq N.

/1% !Cffemi! kin`} woi cffemi cf mn|ewnd rqew}i}wnade}oig y`giq woe} }yamon|wiq.

]im. 2?.<91. I}wnade}oki`w: Fy`ge`b.

/n% Woi cffemi cf mn|ewnd rqew} e} i}wnade}oig n`gc|iqnwi} y`giq woi geqimwec` n`g }y|iqve}ec` cf woigeqimwcq cf woi cffemi.

/a% Woi cffemi }ondd qimievi fy`g} fcq |iq}c``idmc}w} n`g ix|i`}i}8

/>% n} }|imefeig e` woi Bi`iqnd N||qc|qenwec`} Nmw: n`g

/1% fqck woi fneq gifi`}i nmmcy`w y`giq ]imwec` 25.<=> 2>.<9?$ e` n` nkcy`w }yffemei`w wc

mcviq |iq}c``id mc}w} n`g ix|i`}i} `cw mcviqig aun||qc|qenwec`} gi}mqeaig au ]yageve}ec` />%.

Nki`gki`w wc /a%/1% iffimwevi ]i|w. >$ 1<>> /OA >297$ ¢1<%.  

1<>> Dibe}dnwevi @cwiOA >297 knji} n mc`fcqke`b mon`bi wc }ya}imwec`/a%.

]im. 2?.<9=. Geqimwcq: ]wnff.

/n% Woi mcyqw cf mqeke`nd n||ind} }ondd n||ce`w ngeqimwcq wc geqimw n`g }y|iqve}i woi c|iqnwec` cf woicffemi. Woi geqimwcq }iqvi} n fcyq+uinq wiqk n`gmc`we`yi} wc }iqvi y`wed n }ymmi}}cq on} aii`n||ce`wig n`g ~yndefeig. Woi mcyqw cf mqeke`ndn||ind} knu qikcvi woi geqimwcq c`du fcq bccgmny}i. Woi geqimwcq knu ai qin||ce`wig fcq n}imc`g cq }ya}i~yi`w wiqk.

/a% Woi geqimwcq }ondd ik|dcu nwwcq`iu} n`g ik|dcucq qiwne` demi`}ig e`vi}webnwcq} n`g cwoiq |iq}c``id`imi}}nqu wc |iqfcqk woi gywei} cf woi cffemi. Wc ai

Page 50: Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

7/30/2019 Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fair-defense-law-dec-2011-tidc 50/76

 

77

ik|dcuig au woi geqimwcq$ n` nwwcq`iu knu `cw onviaii` fcy`g au n }wnwi cq figiqnd mcyqw wc onviqi`giqig e`iffimwevi n}}e}wn`mi cf mcy`}id gyqe`b woiwqend cq n||ind cf n ginwo |i`ndwu mn}i.

/m% Woi geqimwcq n`g n`u nwwcq`iu ik|dcuig au woicffemi knu `cw8

/>% i`bnbi e` woi |qevnwi |qnmwemi cf mqeke`nddnr: cq 

/1% nmmi|w n`uwoe`b cf vndyi `cw nywocqeigau dnr fcq }iqvemi} qi`giqig y`giq woe} }yamon|wiq.

]im. 2?.<97. \criq} n`g Gywei}

/n% Woi cffemi knu `cw nmmi|w n` n||ce`wki`w y`giq  Nqwemdi >>.<2>$ Mcgi cf Mqeke`nd \qcmigyqi$ ef8

/>% n mc fdemw cf e`wiqi}w ixe}w}:

/1% woi cffemi on} e`}yffemei`w qi}cyqmi} wc|qcvegi ngi~ynwi qi|qi}i`wnwec` fcq woi gifi`gn`w:

/=% woi cffemi e} e`mn|nadi cf |qcvege`bqi|qi}i`wnwec` fcq woi gifi`gn`w e` nmmcqgn`mi rewowoi qydi} cf |qcfi}}ec`nd mc`gymw: cq 

/7% cwoiq bccg mny}i e} }ocr` fcq `cwnmmi|we`b woi n||ce`wki`w.

/a% Woi cffemi knu `cw qi|qi}i`w n gifi`gn`w e` nfigiqnd onain} qiveir. Woi cffemi knu cw qi|qi}i`w

n gifi`gn`w e` n` nmwec` cq |qcmiige`b e` }wnwi mcyqwcwoiq won` n` nmwec` cq |qcmiige`b wonw8

/>% e} mc`gymwig y`giq Nqwemdi >>.<2>$ Mcgicf Mqeke`nd \qcmigyqi:

/1% e} mcddnwiqnd wc woi |qi|nqnwec` cf n`n||demnwec` y`giq Nqwemdi >>.<2>$ Mcgi cf Mqeke`nd\qcmigyqi: cq 

/=% mc`miq`} n`u cwoiq |c}w+mc`vemwec`knwwiq e` n ginwo |i`ndwu mn}i cwoiq won` n geqimwn||ind$ e`mdyge`b n` nmwec` cq |qcmiige`b y`giq 

 Nqwemdi 76.<9 cq Mon|wiq 67$ Mcgi cf Mqeke`nd\qcmigyqi.

/m% @cwrewo}wn`ge`b Nqwemdi 16.<7/|%$ Mcgi cf Mqeke`nd \qcmigyqi$ woi cffemi knu e`gi|i`gi`wdue`vi}webnwi woi fe`n`mend mc`gewec` cf n`u |iq}c` woicffemi e} n||ce`wig wc qi|qi}i`w. Woi cffemi }onddqi|cqw woi qi}ydw} cf woi e`vi}webnwec` wc woin||ce`we`b hygbi. Woi hygbi knu ocdg n oinqe`b wc

giwiqke`i ef woi |iq}c` e} e`gebi`w n`g i`wewdig wcqi|qi}i`wnwec` y`giq woe} }imwec`.

]im. 2?.<99. Mck|i`}nwec` cf Cwoiq N||ce`wigNwwcq`iu}.

Ef ew e} `imi}}nqu wonw n` nwwcq`iu cwoiq won` n`nwwcq`iu ik|dcuig au woi cffemi ai n||ce`wig$ wonwnwwcq`iu }ondd ai mck|i`}nwig n} |qcvegig au Nqwemdi} >>.<2> n`g 16.<9$ Mcgi cf Mqeke`nd\qcmigyqi.

]im. 2?.<96. N||ce`wki`w De}w

/n% Woi |qi}ege`b hygbi} cf woi ngke`e}wqnwevi hygemend qibec`} }ondd kne`wne` n }wnwiregi de}w cf mck|iwi`w mcy`}id nvnednadi fcq n||ce`wki`w y`giq ]imwec` 1/f%$ Nqwemdi >>.<2>$ Mcgi cf Mqeke`nd\qcmigyqi$ ef woi cffemi gci} `cw nmmi|w cq e}|qcoeaewig fqck nmmi|we`b n` n||ce`wki`w y`giq 

]imwec` 2?.<97. Inmo nwwcq`iu c` woi de}w8

/>% ky}w ixoeaew |qcfemei`mu n`gmckkewki`w wc |qcvege`b ~yndewu qi|qi}i`wnwec` wcgifi`gn`w} e` ginwo |i`ndwu mn}i}: n`g

/1% knu `cw onvi aii` fcy`g au n }wnwi cq figiqnd mcyqw wc onvi qi`giqig e`iffimwevi n}}e}wn`micf mcy`}id gyqe`b woi wqend cq n||ind cf n ginwo|i`ndwu mn}i.

/a% Woi Cffemi cf Mcyqw Ngke`e}wqnwec` cf woi Wixn}Hygemend ]u}wik n`g woi Wixn} E`gebi`w Gifi`}i

Mckke}}ec` }ondd |qcvegi ngke`e}wqnwevi }y||cqw`imi}}nqu y`giq woe} }imwec`.

Nki`gki`w} wc /n%$ /g%$ n`g /f% n`g nggewec` cf /f+>% iffimwevi ]i|w. >$ 1<>> /OA >297$ ¢1<%.

1<>> Dibe}dnwevi @cwiOA >297 knji} n mc`fcqke`b mon`bi wc }ya}imwec`/a%.

\qifnmi wc Mon|wiq 25$ Bcviq`ki`w Mcgi8OA >297 mon`bi} woi `nki cf woi Wn}j Fcqmi c`E`gebi`w Gifi`}i wc woi Wixn} E`gebi`w Gifi`}iMckke}}ec`. Woi |criq} n`g gywei} cf woi `ir

Mckke}}ec` nqi dnqbidu woi }nki n} woc}i cf woi|qecq Wn}j Fcqmi. Woi dibe}dnwevi `cwi fcddcre`b inmo}imwec` aidcr de}w} woi mcqqi}|c`ge`b }imwec` fqckwoi qi|indig |qcve}ec`} e` Mon|wiq 2>. WoiMckke}}ec`$ deji woi Wn}j Fcqmi$ qikne`} n|iqkn`i`w }wn`ge`b mckkewwii cf woi Wixn} HygemendMcy`med n`g ngke`e}wqnwevidu nwwnmoig wc woi Cffemi cf Mcyqw Ngke`e}wqnwec` /CMN%. CMN redd |qcvegingke`e}wqnwevi }y||cqw }iqvemi} wc oid| woi

Page 51: Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

7/30/2019 Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fair-defense-law-dec-2011-tidc 51/76

 

79

Mckke}}ec` mnqqu cyw ew} dibe}dnwevi qi}|c`}eaedewei}.Woi Mckke}}ec` redd `cr ai qi}|c`}eadi fcq |qi|nqe`b$ n||qcve`b$ n`g }yakewwe`b ew} Dibe}dnwevi N||qc|qenwec`} Qi~yi}w n`g kne`wne`e`b n aygbiw}wqymwyqi }i|nqnwi fqck wonw cf CMN.

MON\WIQ ]IVI@WU+@E@I8 WI_N] E@GEBI@WGIFI@]I MCKKE]]EC@

]yamon|wiq N. Bi`iqnd \qcve}ec`}

]im. 25.<<>. GIFE@EWEC@]. 

/>% !N}}eb`ig mcy`}id |qcbqnk! kin`} n }u}wiky`giq roemo |qevnwi nwwcq`iu}$ nmwe`b n}e`gi|i`gi`w mc`wqnmwcq} n`g mck|i`}nwig rewo|yadem fy`g}$ nqi e`gevegynddu n||ce`wig wc |qcvegidibnd qi|qi}i`wnwec` n`g }iqvemi} wc n |nqwemydnq e`gebi`w gifi`gn`w nmmy}ig cf n mqeki cq hyvi`edicffi`}i.

/1% !Acnqg! kin`} woi bcviq`e`b acnqg cf woi Wixn}E`gebi`w Gifi`}i Mckke}}ec`.

/=% !Mckke}}ec`! kin`} woi |iqkn`i`w }wn`ge`bmckkewwii cf woi mcy`med j`cr` n} woi Wixn}E`gebi`w Gifi`}i Mckke}}ec`.

/7% !Mc`wqnmw gifi`giq |qcbqnk! kin`} n }u}wiky`giq roemo |qevnwi nwwcq`iu}$ nmwe`b n}e`gi|i`gi`w mc`wqnmwcq} n`g mck|i`}nwig rewo|yadem fy`g}$ nqi i`bnbig wc |qcvegi dibndqi|qi}i`wnwec` n`g }iqvemi} wc n bqcy| cf 

y`}|imefeig e`gebi`w gifi`gn`w} roc n||inq aifcqin |nqwemydnq mcyqw cq bqcy| cf mcyqw}.

/9% !Mcy`med! kin`} woi Wixn} Hygemend Mcy`med.

/6% !Mqeki! kin`}8

/N% n ke}gikin`cq |y`e}onadi aumc`fe`iki`w: cq 

/A% n fidc`u.

/2% !Gifi`gn`w! kin`} n |iq}c` nmmy}ig cf n mqeki

cq n hyvi`edi cffi`}i.

/?% !Iximywevi geqimwcq! kin`} woi iximywevigeqimwcq cf woi Wixn} E`gebi`w Gifi`}i Mckke}}ec`.

/5% !E`gebi`w gifi`}i }y||cqw }iqvemi}! kin`}mqeke`nd gifi`}i }iqvemi} wonw8

/N% nqi |qcvegig au demi`}ig e`vi}webnwcq}$ix|iqw}$ cq cwoiq }ekednq }|imende}w}$ e`mdyge`bfcqi`}em ix|iqw} n`g ki`wnd oindwo ix|iqw}: n`g

/A% nqi qin}c`nadi n`g `imi}}nqu fcq n||ce`wig mcy`}id wc |qcvegi ngi~ynwiqi|qi}i`wnwec` wc e`gebi`w gifi`gn`w}.

/><% !Hyvi`edi cffi`}i! kin`} mc`gymw mckkewwigau n |iq}c` roedi ucy`biq won` >2 uinq} cf nbi wonwmc`}wewywi}8

/N% n ke}gikin`cq |y`e}onadi aumc`fe`iki`w: cq 

/A% n fidc`u.

/>>% !Kn`nbig n}}eb`ig mcy`}id |qcbqnk! on} woikin`e`b n}}eb`ig au Nqwemdi 16.<72$ Mcgi cf Mqeke`nd \qcmigyqi.

/>1% !Cffemi cf mn|ewnd rqew}! kin`} woi cffemi cf mn|ewnd rqew} i}wnade}oig y`giq ]yamon|wiq A$Mon|wiq 2?.

/>=% !\yadem gifi`giq"} cffemi! on} woi kin`e`bn}}eb`ig au Nqwemdi 16.<77/n%$ Mcgi cf Mqeke`nd\qcmigyqi.

Nggewec` cf woe} ]imwec` iffimwevi ]i|w. >$ 1<>> /OA >297$ ¢1<%.

1<>> Dibe}dnwevi @cwiOA >297 ngg} woe} }imwec` wc |qcvegi gife`ewec`} fcq Mon|wiq ]ivi`wu+@e`i$ Bcviq`ki`w Mcgi.

]im. 25.<<1. I]WNADE]OKI@W CF MCKKE]]EC@.

/n% Woi Wixn} E`gebi`w Gifi`}i Mckke}}ec` e}i}wnade}oig n} n |iqkn`i`w }wn`ge`b mckkewwii cf woi mcy`med.

/a% Woi mckke}}ec` c|iqnwi} y`giq woi geqimwec`n`g }y|iqve}ec` cf n bcviq`e`b acnqg.

Z]imwec`} 25.<<=+25.<>< qi}iqvig fcq ix|n`}ec`[

Nggewec` cf woe} ]imwec` iffimwevi ]i|w. >$ 1<>> /OA >297$ ¢1<%.

1<>> Dibe}dnwevi @cwiOA >297 ngg} woe} }imwec` wc qi|dnmi ]im. 2>.<9>.  

Page 52: Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

7/30/2019 Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fair-defense-law-dec-2011-tidc 52/76

 

76

]YAMON\WIQ A. NGKE@E]WQNWEVI\QCVE]EC@]

]im. 25.<>>. I]WNADE]OKI@W CF ACNQG:MCK\C]EWEC@.

/n% Woi mckke}}ec` e} bcviq`ig au n acnqgmc`}e}we`b cf iebow ix cffemec kikaiq} n`g fevin||ce`wevi kikaiq}.

/a% Ixmi|w n} |qcvegig au ]imwec` 25.<==/a%$ woiacnqg }ondd ixiqme}i woi |criq} n`g |iqfcqk woigywei} y`giq woe} mon|wiq e`gi|i`gi`wdu cf woimcy`med.

Nggewec` cf woe} ]imwec` iffimwevi ]i|w. >$ 1<>> /OA >297$ ¢1<%.

1<>> Dibe}dnwevi @cwiOA >297 ngg} woe} }imwec` wc qi|dnmi ]im. 2>.<9>

]im. 25.<>1. I_IMYWEVI GEQIMWCQ.

/n% Woi iximywevi geqimwcq e} n||ce`wig au woiacnqg.

/a% Woi iximywevi geqimwcq8

/>% ky}w ai n demi`}ig nwwcq`iu:

/1% ky}w gikc`}wqnwi n` e`wiqi}w e` woi}wn`gnqg} fcq n`g |qcve}ec` cf mqeke`ndgifi`}i }iqvemi} wc e`gebi`w e`gevegynd}:

/=% knu `cw i`bnbi e` woi |qevnwi |qnmwemicf dnr: n`g

/7% knu `cw nmmi|w kc`iu$ |qc|iqwu$ cq n`ucwoiq woe`b cf vndyi `cw nywocqeig au dnr fcq }iqvemi} qi`giqig y`giq woe} mon|wiq.

Nggewec` cf woe} ]imwec` iffimwevi ]i|w. >$ 1<>> /OA >297$ ¢1<%.

]im. 25.<>=. I_ CFFEMEC KIKAIQ]. 

Woi ix cffemec kikaiq} cf woi acnqg nqi8

/>% woi fcddcre`b }ex kikaiq} cf woi mcy`med8

/N% woi moeif hy}wemi cf woi }y|qiki mcyqw:

/A% woi |qi}ege`b hygbi cf woi mcyqw cf mqeke`nd n||ind}:

/M% c`i cf woi kikaiq} cf woi }i`nwi}iqve`b c` woi mcy`med roc e} gi}eb`nwig auwoi deiywi`n`w bcviq`cq:

/G% woi kikaiq cf woi ocy}i cf qi|qi}i`wnwevi} n||ce`wig au woi }|injiq cf woi ocy}i:

/I% c`i cf woi mcyqw} cf n||ind} hy}wemi}}iqve`b c` woi mcy`med roc e} gi}eb`nwig auwoi bcviq`cq: n`g

/F% c`i cf woi mcy`wu mcyqw cq }wnwywcqumcy`wu mcyqw hygbi} }iqve`b c` woi mcy`medroc e} gi}eb`nwig au woi bcviq`cq cq$ ef nmcy`wu mcyqw cq }wnwywcqu mcy`wu mcyqw hygbie} `cw }iqve`b c` woi mcy`med$ c`i cf woi}wnwywcqu |qcanwi mcyqw hygbi} }iqve`b c` woimcy`med roc e} gi}eb`nwig au woi bcviq`cq:

/1% c`i cwoiq kikaiq cf woi }i`nwi n||ce`wig auwoi deiywi`n`w bcviq`cq: n`g

/=% woi moneq cf woi Ocy}i Mqeke`nd Hyqe}|qygi`miMckkewwii.

Nggewec` cf woe} ]imwec` iffimwevi ]i|w. >$ 1<>> /OA >297$ ¢1<%.

1<>> Dibe}dnwevi @cwiOA >297 ngg} woe} }imwec` wc qi|dnmi ]im. 2>.<91

]im. 25.<>7. N\\CE@WKI@W]. 

/n% Woi bcviq`cq }ondd n||ce`w rewo woi ngvemi n`gmc`}i`w cf woi }i`nwi fevi kikaiq} cf woi acnqg n}fcddcr}8

/>% c`i kikaiq roc e} n ge}wqemw hygbi}iqve`b n} n |qi}ege`b hygbi cf n`ngke`e}wqnwevi hygemend qibec`:

/1% c`i kikaiq roc e} n hygbi cf nmc`}wewywec`nd mcy`wu mcyqw cq roc e} nmcy`wu mckke}}ec`iq:

/=% c`i kikaiq roc e} n |qnmweme`b mqeke`ndgifi`}i nwwcq`iu:

/7% c`i kikaiq roc e} n moeif |yademgifi`giq e` woe} }wnwi cq woi moeif |yademgifi`giq"} gi}eb`ii$ roc ky}w ai n`nwwcq`iu ik|dcuig au woi |yadem gifi`giq"}cffemi: n`g

/9% c`i kikaiq roc e} n hygbi cf nmc`}wewywec`nd mcy`wu mcyqw cq roc e} nmcy`wu mckke}}ec`iq cf n mcy`wu rewo n|c|ydnwec` cf 19<$<<< cq kcqi.

Page 53: Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

7/30/2019 Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fair-defense-law-dec-2011-tidc 53/76

 

72

/a% Woi acnqg kikaiq} }iqvi }wnbbiqig wiqk} cf wrc uinq}$ rewo wrc kikaiq}" wiqk} ix|eqe`bFiaqynqu > cf inmo cgg+`ykaiqig uinq n`g woqiikikaiq}" wiqk} ix|eqe`b Fiaqynqu > cf inmo ivi`+`ykaiqig uinq.

/m% E` knje`b n||ce`wki`w} wc woi acnqg$ woibcviq`cq }ondd nwwik|w wc qifdimw woi bicbqn|oem n`ggikcbqn|oem geviq}ewu cf woi }wnwi.

/g% N |iq}c` knu `cw ai n||ce`wig wc woi acnqg ef woi |iq}c` e} qi~yeqig wc qibe}wiq n} n dcaaue}w y`giq Mon|wiq =<9 aimny}i cf woi |iq}c`"} nmwevewei} fcq mck|i`}nwec` c` aiondf cf n |qcfi}}ec` qidnwig wcwoi c|iqnwec` cf woi mckke}}ec` cq woi mcy`med.

Nggewec` cf woe} ]imwec` iffimwevi ]i|w. >$ 1<>> /OA >297$ ¢1<%.

1<>> Dibe}dnwevi @cwiOA >297 ngg} woe} }imwec` wc qi|dnmi ]im. 2>.<9=  

]im. 25.<>9. \QI]EGE@B CFFEMIQ.

Woi acnqg }ondd }idimw n moneq fqck nkc`b ew}kikaiq}.

Nggewec` cf woe} ]imwec` iffimwevi ]i|w. >$ 1<>> /OA >297$ ¢1<%.

]im. 25.<>6. GE]MDC]YQI QI^YEQIG. 

/n% N acnqg kikaiq roc e} n moeif |yadem gifi`giq cq roc e} n` nwwcq`iu ik|dcuig au n |yademgifi`giq"} cffemi e` n mcy`wu wonw n||dei} fcq fy`g}y`giq ]imwec` 25.<=2 }ondd ge}mdc}i wonw fnmw aifcqin vcwi au woi acnqg qibnqge`b n` nrnqg cf fy`g} wcwonw mcy`wu n`g knu `cw |nqweme|nwi e` }ymo n vcwi.

/a% N acnqg kikaiq"} ge}mdc}yqi y`giq ]ya}imwec`/n% ky}w ai i`wiqig e`wc woi ke`ywi} cf woi acnqgkiiwe`b nw roemo woi ge}mdc}yqi e} kngi cq qi|cqwig$n} n||demnadi.

/m% Woi mckke}}ec` knu `cw nrnqg fy`g} y`giq ]imwec` 25.<=2 wc n mcy`wu }iqvig au n moeif |yademgifi`giq cq cwoiq nwwcq`iu roc fned} wc knji nge}mdc}yqi wc woi acnqg n} qi~yeqig au ]ya}imwec`/n%.

Nggewec` cf woe} ]imwec` iffimwevi ]i|w. >$ 1<>> /OA >297$ ¢1<%.

]im. 25.<>2. VNMN@MEI].  N vnmn`mu c` woi acnqg ky}w ai feddig fcq woiy`ix|eqig wiqk e` woi }nki kn``iq n} woi cqebe`ndn||ce`wki`w.

Nggewec` cf woe} ]imwec` iffimwevi ]i|w. >$ 1<>> /OA >297$ ¢1<%.

1<>> Dibe}dnwevi @cwiOA >297 ngg} woe} }imwec` wc qi|dnmi ]im. 2>.<97

]im. 25.<>?. KIIWE@B]: ^YCQYK: VCWE@B. 

/n% Woi acnqg }ondd kiiw nw din}w fcyq weki} inmouinq n`g nw }ymo cwoiq weki} n} ew mc`}egiq}`imi}}nqu cq mc`vi`ei`w wc |iqfcqk ew} gywei}.

/a% ]ex kikaiq} cf woi acnqg mc`}wewywi n ~ycqykfcq |yq|c}i} cf wqn`}nmwe`b woi ay}e`i}} cf woiacnqg. Woi acnqg knu nmw c`du c` woi mc`myqqi`micf fevi acnqg kikaiq} cq n knhcqewu cf woi acnqgkikaiq} |qi}i`w$ roemoiviq `ykaiq e} bqinwiq.Woi acnqg knu ngc|w |cdemei} n`g }wn`gnqg} y`giq ]imwec` 25.<=7 c`du c` woi mc`myqqi`mi cf }ivi`acnqg kikaiq}.

/m% Ixmi|w n} |qcvegig au ]imwec` 25.<>6$ n acnqgkikaiq e} i`wewdig wc vcwi c` n`u knwwiq aifcqi woi

acnqg$ ixmi|w n} cwoiqre}i |qcvegig au qydi}ngc|wig au woi acnqg.

Nggewec` cf woe} ]imwec` iffimwevi ]i|w. >$ 1<>> /OA >297$ ¢1<%.

1<>> Dibe}dnwevi @cwiOA >297 ngg} woe} }imwec` wc qi|dnmi ]im. 2>.<99  

]im. 25.<>5. MCK\I@]NWEC@. 

 N acnqg kikaiq knu `cw qimievi mck|i`}nwec` fcq }iqvemi} c` woi acnqg ayw e} i`wewdig wc aiqiekayq}ig fcq nmwynd n`g `imi}}nqu ix|i`}i}e`myqqig e` ge}monqbe`b acnqg gywei}. Woi ix|i`}i}nqi |neg fqck fy`g} n||qc|qenwig wc woi acnqg.

Nggewec` cf woe} ]imwec` iffimwevi ]i|w. >$ 1<>> /OA >297$ ¢1<%.

1<>> Dibe}dnwevi @cwiOA >297 ngg} woe} }imwec` wc qi|dnmi ]im. 2>.<96

]im. 25.<1<. EKKY@EWU FQCK DENAEDEWU.

 N kikaiq cf woi acnqg |iqfcqke`b gywei} c` aiondf cf woi acnqg e} `cw denadi fcq gnknbi} nqe}e`b fqck n`nmw cq cke}}ec` rewoe` woi }mc|i cf woc}i gywei}.

Nggewec` cf woe} ]imwec` iffimwevi ]i|w. >$ 1<>> /OA >297$ ¢1<%.

1<>> Dibe}dnwevi @cwiOA >297 ngg} woe} }imwec` wc qi|dnmi ]im. 2>.<6=

]im. 25.<1>. QYDI].

Woi acnqg }ondd ngc|w qydi} n} `imi}}nqu wcek|diki`w woe} mon|wiq.

Page 54: Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

7/30/2019 Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fair-defense-law-dec-2011-tidc 54/76

 

7?

Z]imwec`} 25.<11+25.<=< qi}iqvig fcq ix|n`}ec`[

Nggewec` cf woe} ]imwec` iffimwevi ]i|w. >$ 1<>> /OA >297$ ¢1<%.

]YAMON\WIQ M. BI@IQND \CRIQ] N@GGYWEI] CF MCKKE]]EC@

]im. 25.<=>. FNEQ GIFI@]I NMMCY@W. Woi fneq gifi`}i nmmcy`w e} n` nmmcy`w e` woibi`iqnd qivi`yi fy`g wonw knu ai n||qc|qenwig c`duwc8

/>% woi mckke}}ec` fcq woi |yq|c}i cf ek|diki`we`bwoe} mon|wiq: n`g

/1% woi cffemi cf mn|ewnd rqew} fcq woi |yq|c}i cf ek|diki`we`b ]yamon|wiq A$ Mon|wiq 2?.

Nggewec` cf woe} ]imwec` iffimwevi ]i|w. >$ 1<>> /OA >297$ ¢1<%.

1<>> Dibe}dnwevi @cwiOA >297 ngg} woe} }imwec` wc qi|dnmi ]im. 2>.<9?

]im. 25.<=1. NMMI\WN@MI CF BEFW]$ BQN@W]$N@G CWOIQ FY@G]: ]WNWI BQN@W] WINK. 

/n% Woi mckke}}ec` knu nmmi|w befw}$ bqn`w}$ n`gcwoiq fy`g} fqck n`u |yadem cq |qevnwi }cyqmi wc |nuix|i`}i} e`myqqig e` |iqfcqke`b ew} gywei} y`giq woe}mon|wiq.

/a% Woi ]wnwi Bqn`w} Wink cf woi Bcviq`cq"} Cffemicf Aygbiw$ \dn``e`b$ n`g \cdemu knu n}}e}w woimckke}}ec` e` egi`wefue`b bqn`w} n`g cwoiq qi}cyqmi}nvnednadi fcq y}i au woi mckke}}ec` e` |iqfcqke`b ew}gywei} y`giq woe} mon|wiq.

Nggewec` cf woe} ]imwec` iffimwevi ]i|w. >$ 1<>> /OA >297$ ¢1<%.

1<>> Dibe}dnwevi @cwiOA >297 ngg} woe} }imwec` wc qi|dnmi ]im. 2>.<95  

]im. 25.<==. NGKE@E]WQNWEVI NWWNMOKI@W:]Y\\CQW: AYGBIW.

/n% Woi mckke}}ec` e} ngke`e}wqnwevidu nwwnmoig wcwoi Cffemi cf Mcyqw Ngke`e}wqnwec` cf woi Wixn}

Hygemend ]u}wik.

/a% Woi cffemi cf mcyqw ngke`e}wqnwec` }ondd |qcvegingke`e}wqnwevi }y||cqw }iqvemi}$ e`mdyge`b oykn`qi}cyqmi}$ aygbiwnqu$ nmmcy`we`b$ |yqmon}e`b$|nuqcdd$ e`fcqknwec` wimo`cdcbu$ n`g dibnd }y||cqw}iqvemi}$ wc woi mckke}}ec` n} `imi}}nqu wc mnqqucyw woi |yq|c}i} cf woe} mon|wiq.

/m% Woi mckke}}ec`$ e` nmmcqgn`mi rewo woi qydi}n`g |qcmigyqi} cf woi Dibe}dnwevi Aygbiw Acnqg$}ondd |qi|nqi$ n||qcvi$ n`g }yakew n dibe}dnwevin||qc|qenwec`} qi~yi}w wonw e} }i|nqnwi fqck woidibe}dnwevi n||qc|qenwec`} qi~yi}w fcq woi Cffemi cf Mcyqw Ngke`e}wqnwec` cf woi Wixn} Hygemend ]u}wikn`g e} y}ig wc gividc| woi mckke}}ec`"} aygbiw}wqymwyqi. Woi mckke}}ec` }ondd kne`wne` woidibe}dnwevi n||qc|qenwec`} qi~yi}w n`g aygbiw}wqymwyqi }i|nqnwidu fqck woc}i cf woi cffemi cf mcyqwngke`e}wqnwec`.

Nggewec` cf woe} ]imwec` iffimwevi ]i|w. >$ 1<>> /OA >297$ ¢1<%.

1<>> Dibe}dnwevi @cwiOA >297 ngg} woe} }imwec` wc qi|dnmi ]im. 2>.<92

]im. 25.<=7. \CDEMEI] N@G ]WN@GNQG]. 

/n% Woi mckke}}ec` }ondd gividc| |cdemei} n`g

}wn`gnqg} fcq |qcvege`b dibnd qi|qi}i`wnwec` n`gcwoiq gifi`}i }iqvemi} wc e`gebi`w gifi`gn`w} nwwqend$ c` n||ind$ n`g e` |c}w mc`vemwec` |qcmiige`b}.Woi |cdemei} n`g }wn`gnqg} knu e`mdygi8

/>% |iqfcqkn`mi }wn`gnqg} fcq mcy`}idn||ce`wig wc qi|qi}i`w e`gebi`w gifi`gn`w}:

/1% ~yndefemnwec` }wn`gnqg} y`giq roemonwwcq`iu} knu ~yndefu fcq n||ce`wki`w wcqi|qi}i`w e`gebi`w gifi`gn`w}$ e`mdyge`b8

/N% ~yndefemnwec`} mckki`}yqnwi

rewo woi }iqecy}`i}} cf woi `nwyqi cf woi |qcmiige`b:

/A% ~yndefemnwec`} n||qc|qenwi fcq qi|qi}i`wnwec` cf ki`wnddu eddgifi`gn`w} n`g `c`mewei`gifi`gn`w}:

/M% }ymmi}}fyd mck|diwec` cf qidivn`w mc`we`ye`b dibnd igymnwec`|qcbqnk} n||qcvig au woi mcy`med:n`g

/G% wi}we`b n`g miqwefemnwec`}wn`gnqg}:

/=% }wn`gnqg} fcq i`}yqe`b n||qc|qenwin||ce`wig mn}idcng} fcq mcy`}id n||ce`wigwc qi|qi}i`w e`gebi`w gifi`gn`w}:

/7% }wn`gnqg} fcq giwiqke`e`b roiwoiq n|iq}c` nmmy}ig cf n mqeki cq hyvi`edicffi`}i e} e`gebi`w:

Page 55: Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

7/30/2019 Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fair-defense-law-dec-2011-tidc 55/76

 

75

/9% |cdemei} n`g }wn`gnqg} bcviq`e`b woicqbn`enwec` n`g c|iqnwec` cf n` n}}eb`igmcy`}id |qcbqnk:

/6% |cdemei} n`g }wn`gnqg} bcviq`e`b woicqbn`enwec` n`g c|iqnwec` cf n |yademgifi`giq"} cffemi mc`}e}wi`w rewo qimcb`eig`nwec`nd |cdemei} n`g }wn`gnqg}:

/2% }wn`gnqg} fcq |qcvege`b e`gebi`w gifi`}i}iqvemi} y`giq n mc`wqnmw gifi`giq |qcbqnkmc`}e}wi`w rewo qimcb`eig `nwec`nd |cdemei}n`g }wn`gnqg}:

/?% }wn`gnqg} bcviq`e`b woi qin}c`nadimck|i`}nwec` cf mcy`}id n||ce`wig wcqi|qi}i`w e`gebi`w gifi`gn`w}:

/5% }wn`gnqg} bcviq`e`b woi nvnednaedewu n`g

qin}c`nadi mck|i`}nwec` cf |qcvegiq} cf e`gebi`w gifi`}i }y||cqw }iqvemi} fcq mcy`}id n||ce`wig wc qi|qi}i`w e`gebi`wgifi`gn`w}:

/><% }wn`gnqg} bcviq`e`b woi c|iqnwec` cf ndibnd mde`em cq |qcbqnk wonw |qcvegi} dibnd}iqvemi} wc e`gebi`w gifi`gn`w} n`g e}}|c`}cqig au n dnr }moccd n||qcvig au woi}y|qiki mcyqw:

/>>% |cdemei} n`g }wn`gnqg} bcviq`e`b woin||ce`wki`w cf nwwcq`iu} wc qi|qi}i`w

moedgqi` e` |qcmiige`b} y`giq Wewdi =$ FnkeduMcgi:

/>1% |cdemei} n`g }wn`gnqg} bcviq`e`b woicqbn`enwec` n`g c|iqnwec` cf n kn`nbign}}eb`ig mcy`}id |qcbqnk mc`}e}wi`w rewo`nwec`nddu qimcb`eig |cdemei} n`g}wn`gnqg}: n`g

/>=% cwoiq |cdemei} n`g }wn`gnqg} fcq |qcvege`b e`gebi`w gifi`}i }iqvemi} n}giwiqke`ig au woi mckke}}ec` wc ain||qc|qenwi.

/a% Woi mckke}}ec` }ondd }yakew ew} |qc|c}ig|cdemei} n`g }wn`gnqg} gividc|ig y`giq ]ya}imwec`/n% wc woi acnqg fcq ngc|wec`. Woi acnqg }ondd ngc|wwoi |qc|c}ig |cdemei} n`g }wn`gnqg} n} n||qc|qenwi.

/m% N`u ~yndefemnwec` }wn`gnqg} ngc|wig au woiacnqg y`giq ]ya}imwec` /a% wonw qidnwi wc woin||ce`wki`w cf mcy`}id e` n ginwo |i`ndwu mn}i ky}wai mc`}e}wi`w rewo woi }wn`gnqg} }|imefeig y`giq 

 Nqwemdi 16.<91/g%$ Mcgi cf Mqeke`nd \qcmigyqi. N`nwwcq`iu roc e} egi`wefeig au woi mckke}}ec` n} `cw}nwe}fue`b |iqfcqkn`mi cq ~yndefemnwec` }wn`gnqg}ngc|wig au woi acnqg y`giq ]ya}imwec` /a% knu `cwnmmi|w n` n||ce`wki`w e` n mn|ewnd mn}i.

Nggewec` cf woe} ]imwec` iffimwevi ]i|w. >$ 1<>> /OA >297$ ¢1<%.

1<>> Dibe}dnwevi @cwiOA >297 ngg} woe} }imwec` wc qi|dnmi ]im. 2>.<6<

]im. 25.<=9. MCY@WU QI\CQWE@B \DN@:MCKKE]]EC@ QI\CQW]. 

/n% Woi mckke}}ec` }ondd gividc| n |dn` wonwi}wnade}oi} }wnwiregi qi~yeqiki`w} fcq mcy`wei}qidnwe`b wc qi|cqwe`b e`gebi`w gifi`}i e`fcqknwec`.Woi |dn` ky}w e`mdygi |qcve}ec`} gi}eb`ig wc qigymiqigy`gn`w qi|cqwe`b au mcy`wei} n`g |qcve}ec`} wonwwnji e`wc mc`}egiqnwec` woi mc}w} wc mcy`wei} cf 

ek|diki`we`b woi |dn` }wnwiregi. Woi mckke}}ec`}ondd y}i woi e`fcqknwec` qi|cqwig au n mcy`wu wckc`ewcq woi iffimwevi`i}} cf woi mcy`wu"} e`gebi`wgifi`}i |cdemei}$ }wn`gnqg}$ n`g |qcmigyqi} n`g wci`}yqi mck|den`mi au woi mcy`wu rewo woiqi~yeqiki`w} cf }wnwi dnr qidnwe`b wc e`gebi`wgifi`}i. Woi mckke}}ec` knu qive}i woi |dn` n}`imi}}nqu wc ek|qcvi kc`ewcqe`b cf e`gebi`w gifi`}i|cdemei}$ }wn`gnqg}$ n`g |qcmigyqi} e` woe} }wnwi.

/a% Woi mckke}}ec` }ondd n``ynddu }yakew wc woibcviq`cq$ deiywi`n`w bcviq`cq$ }|injiq cf woi ocy}icf qi|qi}i`wnwevi}$ n`g mcy`med n`g }ondd |yade}o e`

rqewwi` n`g idimwqc`em fcqk n qi|cqw8

/>% mc`wne`e`b n`u e`fcqknwec` }yakewwig wcwoi mckke}}ec` au n mcy`wu y`giq ]imwec`25.<=6: n`g

/1% qibnqge`b8

/N% woi ~yndewu cf dibndqi|qi}i`wnwec` |qcvegig au mcy`}idn||ce`wig wc qi|qi}i`w e`gebi`wgifi`gn`w}:

/A% myqqi`w e`gebi`w gifi`}i|qnmwemi} e` woi }wnwi n} mck|nqigwc }wnwi n`g `nwec`nd }wn`gnqg}:

/M% iffcqw} kngi au woi mckke}}ec`wc ek|qcvi e`gebi`w gifi`}i|qnmwemi} e` woi }wnwi:

Page 56: Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

7/30/2019 Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fair-defense-law-dec-2011-tidc 56/76

 

9<

/G% qimckki`gnwec`} kngi au woimckke}}ec` fcq ek|qcve`b e`gebi`wgifi`}i |qnmwemi} e` woi }wnwi: n`g

/I% woi fe`ge`b} cf n qi|cqw}yakewwig wc woi mckke}}ec` y`giq ]imwec` 25.<=5.

/m% Woi mckke}}ec` }ondd n``ynddu }yakew wc woiDibe}dnwevi Aygbiw Acnqg n`g mcy`med n`g }ondd|yade}o e` rqewwi` n`g idimwqc`em fcqk n giwnedigqi|cqw cf ndd ix|i`gewyqi} kngi y`giq woe}}yamon|wiq$ e`mdyge`b ge}wqeaywec`} y`giq ]imwec`25.<=2.

/g% Woi mckke}}ec` knu e}}yi cwoiq qi|cqw} qidnwe`bwc e`gebi`w gifi`}i n} giwiqke`ig wc ai n||qc|qenwiau woi mckke}}ec`.

Nggewec` cf woe} ]imwec` iffimwevi ]i|w. >$ 1<>> /OA >297$ ¢1<%.

1<>> Dibe}dnwevi @cwiOA >297 ngg} woe} }imwec` wc qi|dnmi ]im. 2>.<6>

]im. 25.<=6. E@GEBI@W GIFI@]I E@FCQKNWEC@. 

/n% E` inmo mcy`wu$ `cw dnwiq won` @cvikaiq > cf inmo cgg+`ykaiqig uinq n`g e` woi fcqk n`gkn``iq |qi}mqeaig au woi mckke}}ec`$ woi fcddcre`be`fcqknwec` }ondd ai |qi|nqig n`g |qcvegig wc woimckke}}ec`8

/>% n mc|u cf ndd fcqknd n`g e`fcqknd qydi}

n`g fcqk} wonw gi}mqeai woi |qcmigyqi}y}ig e` woi mcy`wu wc |qcvegi e`gebi`wgifi`gn`w} rewo mcy`}id e` nmmcqgn`mi rewowoi Mcgi cf Mqeke`nd \qcmigyqi$ e`mdyge`bwoi }moigydi cf fii} qi~yeqig y`giq Nqwemdi16.<9 cf wonw mcgi:

/1% n`u qive}ec`} wc qydi} cq fcqk}|qivecy}du }yakewwig y`giq woe} }imwec`: cq 

/=% viqefemnwec` wonw qydi} n`g fcqk}|qivecy}du }yakewwig y`giq woe} }imwec` }weddqikne` e` iffimw.

/a% Ixmi|w n} |qcvegig au ]ya}imwec` /m%8

/>% woi dcmnd ngke`e}wqnwevi ge}wqemw hygbi e`inmo mcy`wu$ cq woi |iq}c` gi}eb`nwig auwoi hygbi$ }ondd |iqfcqk woi nmwec` qi~yeqigau ]ya}imwec` /n% rewo qi}|imw wc ndd qydi}n`g fcqk} ngc|wig au woi hygbi} cf woige}wqemw mcyqw} wque`b fidc`u mn}i} e` woimcy`wu: n`g

/1% woi dcmnd ngke`e}wqnwevi }wnwywcqu mcy`wumcyqw hygbi e` inmo mcy`wu$ cq woi |iq}c`gi}eb`nwig au woi hygbi$ }ondd |iqfcqk woinmwec` qi~yeqig au ]ya}imwec` /n% rewoqi}|imw wc ndd qydi} n`g fcqk} ngc|wig au woi hygbi} cf woi mcy`wu mcyqw} n`g }wnwywcqumcy`wu mcyqw} wque`b ke}gikin`cq mn}i} e`woi mcy`wu.

/m% Ef woi hygbi} cf wrc cq kcqi divid} cf mcyqw}gi}mqeaig au ]ya}imwec` /a% ngc|w woi }nki fcqkndn`g e`fcqknd qydi} n`g fcqk}$ woi dcmnd ngke`e}wqnwevi hygbi }iqve`b woi mcyqw} onve`b hyqe}gemwec` cviq cffi`}i} rewo woi oeboi}w mdn}}efemnwec` cf |y`e}oki`w$ cq woi |iq}c` gi}eb`nwig au woi hygbi$}ondd |iqfcqk woi nmwec` qi~yeqig au ]ya}imwec` /n%.

/g% Woi moneq cf woi hyvi`edi acnqg e` inmo mcy`wu$cq woi |iq}c` gi}eb`nwig au woi moneq$ }ondd |iqfcqk

woi nmwec` qi~yeqig au ]ya}imwec` /n% rewo qi}|imw wcndd qydi} n`g fcqk} ngc|wig au woi hyvi`edi acnqg.

/i% E` inmo mcy`wu$ woi mcy`wu nygewcq$ cq woi |iq}c`gi}eb`nwig au woi mckke}}ec`iq} mcyqw ef woi mcy`wugci} `cw onvi n mcy`wu nygewcq$ }ondd |qi|nqi n`g}i`g wc woi mckke}}ec` e` woi fcqk n`g kn``iq |qi}mqeaig au woi mckke}}ec` n`g c` n kc`wodu$~ynqwiqdu$ cq n``ynd an}e}$ rewo qi}|imw wc dibnd}iqvemi} |qcvegig e` woi mcy`wu wc e`gebi`wgifi`gn`w} gyqe`b inmo fe}mnd uinq$ e`fcqknwec`}ocre`b woi wcwnd nkcy`w ix|i`gig au woi mcy`wu wc|qcvegi e`gebi`w gifi`}i }iqvemi} n`g n` n`ndu}e} cf 

woi nkcy`w ix|i`gig au woi mcy`wu8

/>% e` inmo ge}wqemw$ mcy`wu$ }wnwywcqu mcy`wu$n`g n||iddnwi mcyqw:

/1% e` mn}i} fcq roemo n |qevnwi nwwcq`iu e}n||ce`wig fcq n` e`gebi`w gifi`gn`w:

/=% e` mn}i} fcq roemo n |yadem gifi`giq e}n||ce`wig fcq n` e`gebi`w gifi`gn`w:

/7% e` mn}i} fcq roemo mcy`}id e} n||ce`wigfcq n` e`gebi`w hyvi`edi y`giq ]imwec`

9>.></f%$ Fnkedu Mcgi: n`g

/9% fcq e`vi}webnwec` ix|i`}i}$ ix|iqwrew`i}} ix|i`}i}$ cq cwoiq dewebnwec`ix|i`}i}.

/f% N} n gywu cf cffemi$ inmo ge}wqemw n`g mcy`wu mdiqj}ondd mcc|iqnwi rewo woi mcy`wu nygewcq cq woi |iq}c`gi}eb`nwig au woi mckke}}ec`iq} mcyqw n`g woimckke}}ec`iq} mcyqw e` qiwqeive`b e`fcqknwec`

Page 57: Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

7/30/2019 Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fair-defense-law-dec-2011-tidc 57/76

 

9>

qi~yeqig wc ai }i`w wc woi mckke}}ec` y`giq woe}}imwec`.

Nggewec` cf woe} ]imwec` iffimwevi ]i|w. >$ 1<>> /OA >297$ ¢1<%.

1<>> Dibe}dnwevi @cwiOA >297 ngg} woe} }imwec` wc qi|dnmi ]im. 2>.<=9>

]im. 25.<=2. WIMO@EMND ]Y\\CQW: BQN@W]. 

/n% Woi mckke}}ec` }ondd8

/>% |qcvegi wimo`emnd }y||cqw wc8

/N% n}}e}w mcy`wei} e` ek|qcve`bwoieq e`gebi`w gifi`}i }u}wik}: n`g

/A% |qckcwi mck|den`mi aumcy`wei} rewo woi qi~yeqiki`w} cf }wnwi dnr qidnwe`b wc e`gebi`w

gifi`}i:

/1% wc n}}e}w mcy`wei} e` |qcvege`b e`gebi`wgifi`}i }iqvemi} e` woi mcy`wu$ ge}wqeaywi e`woi fcqk cf bqn`w} n`u fy`g} n||qc|qenwig fcq woi |yq|c}i} cf woe} }imwec`: n`g

/=% kc`ewcq inmo mcy`wu wonw qimievi} nbqn`w n`g i`fcqmi mck|den`mi au woi mcy`wurewo woi mc`gewec`} cf woi bqn`w$ e`mdyge`bi`fcqmiki`w au8

/N% rewogqnre`b bqn`w fy`g}: cq 

/A% qi~yeqe`b qiekayq}iki`w cf bqn`w fy`g} au woi mcy`wu.

/a% Woi mckke}}ec` }ondd ge}wqeaywi fy`g} n}qi~yeqig au ]ya}imwec` /n%/1% an}ig c` n mcy`wu"}mck|den`mi rewo }wn`gnqg} ngc|wig au woi acnqgn`g woi mcy`wu"} gikc`}wqnwig mckkewki`w wcmck|den`mi rewo woi qi~yeqiki`w} cf }wnwi dnrqidnwe`b wc e`gebi`w gifi`}i.

/m% Woi acnqg }ondd ngc|w |cdemei} wc i`}yqi wonwfy`g} y`giq ]ya}imwec` /n%/1% nqi nddcmnwig n`gge}wqeaywig wc mcy`wei} e` n fneq kn``iq.

/g% N mcy`wu knu `cw qigymi woi nkcy`w cf fy`g}|qcvegig fcq e`gebi`w gifi`}i }iqvemi} e` woi mcy`wuaimny}i cf fy`g} |qcvegig au woi mckke}}ec` y`giq woe} }imwec`.

Nggewec` cf woe} ]imwec` iffimwevi ]i|w. >$ 1<>> /OA >297$ ¢1<%.

1<>> Dibe}dnwevi @cwiOA >297 ngg} woe} }imwec` wc qi|dnmi ]im. 2>.<61

]im. 25.<=5. I_C@IQNWEC@ QI\CQW. 

/n% Inmo dibnd mde`em cq |qcbqnk e` woe} }wnwi wonw e}c|iqnwig au n dnr }moccd n`g wonw qimievi} fe`n`mend}y||cqw fqck woi mckke}}ec` }ondd }yakew wc woimckke}}ec` n` n``ynd qi|cqw qibnqge`b mqeke`ndmn}i}8

/>% e` roemo woi mde`em cq |qcbqnk on}|qcvegig dibnd }iqvemi} wc n` e`gebi`wgifi`gn`w gyqe`b woi |qimige`b mndi`gnq uinq: n`g

/1% e` roemo8

/N% an}ig c` n fe`ge`b cf nmwynde``cmi`mi$ woi mcyqw cf mqeke`nd

n||ind} cviqwyq`} n mc`vemwec`: cq 

/A% woi bcviq`cq e}}yi} n |nqgc`an}ig c` nmwynd e``cmi`mi.

/a% Woi qi|cqw qi~yeqig y`giq ]ya}imwec` /n% ky}w8

/>% egi`wefu inmo dejidu mny}i cf n rqc`bfydmc`vemwec` de}wig e` woi qi|cqw: n`g

/1% qimckki`g wc woi hygemenqu n`g woidibe}dnwyqi ai}w |qnmwemi}$ |cdemei}$ n`g}wnwywcqu mon`bi} wc nggqi}} cq kewebnwi

woc}i dejidu mny}i} rewo qi}|imw wc fywyqimqeke`nd mn}i}.

Nggewec` cf woe} ]imwec` iffimwevi ]i|w. >$ 1<>> /OA >297$ ¢1<%.

1<>> Dibe}dnwevi @cwiOA >297 ngg} woe} }imwec` wc qi~yeqi n y`eviq}ewue``cmi`mi |qchimw wonw qimievi} fe`n`mend n}}e}wn`mifqck woi Mckke}}ec` wc }yakew n qi|cqw c` woimny}i} cf n rqc`bfyd mc`vemwec` roi` n |qchimw‟}mdei`w e} ixc`iqnwig.

Page 58: Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

7/30/2019 Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fair-defense-law-dec-2011-tidc 58/76

 

91

DCMND BCVIQ@KI@W MCGI

MON\WIQ C@I OY@GQIG WOEQWU+WOQII8MQEKE@ND N@G MEVED FII] \NUNADI WC WOIMCK\WQCDDIQ

]im. >==.><1. Mc`}cdegnwig Fii} c` Mc`vemwec` 

/n% N |iq}c` mc`vemwig cf n` cffi`}i }ondd |nu n} nmcyqw mc}w$ e` nggewec` wc ndd cwoiq mc}w}8

/>% '>== c` mc`vemwec` cf n fidc`u:

/1% '?= c` mc`vemwec` cf n Mdn}} N cq Mdn}} Ake}gikin`cq: cq 

/=% '7< c` mc`vemwec` cf n `c`hnednadike}gikin`cq cffi`}i$ e`mdyge`b n mqeke`ndvecdnwec` cf n ky`eme|nd cqge`n`mi$ cwoiq won` nmc`vemwec` cf n` cffi`}i qidnwe`b wc n |igi}wqen`

cq woi |nqje`b cf n kcwcq vioemdi.

/a% Woi mcyqw mc}w} y`giq ]ya}imwec` /n% }ondd aimcddimwig n`g qikewwig wc woi mck|wqcddiq e` woikn``iq |qcvegig au ]yamon|wiq A.

/m% Woi kc`iu mcddimwig y`giq woe} }imwec` n} mcyqwmc}w} ek|c}ig c` cffi`}i} mckkewwig c` cq nfwiq Hn`ynqu >$ 1<<7$ }ondd ai nddcmnwig nmmcqge`b wc woi|iqmi`wnbi} |qcvegig e` ]ya}imwec` /i%.

/g% Woi kc`iu mcddimwig n} mcyqw mc}w} ek|c}ig c`cffi`}i} mckkewwig aifcqi Hn`ynqu >$ 1<<7$ }ondd ai

ge}wqeaywig y}e`b oe}wcqemnd gnwn }c wonw inmo nmmcy`wcq fy`g qimievi} woi }nki nkcy`w cf kc`iu woinmmcy`w cq fy`g rcydg onvi qimievig ef woi mcyqwmc}w} fcq woi nmmcy`w} n`g fy`g} ong aii` mcddimwign`g qi|cqwig }i|nqnwidu.

/i% Woi mck|wqcddiq }ondd nddcmnwi woi mcyqw mc}w}qimievig y`giq woe} }imwec` wc woi fcddcre`b nmmcy`w}n`g fy`g} }c wonw inmo qimievi} wc woi ixwi`w|qnmwemnadi$ ywedee`b oe}wcqemnd gnwn n} n||demnadi$ woi}nki nkcy`w cf kc`iu woi nmmcy`w cq fy`g rcydgonvi qimievig ef woi mcyqw mc}w} fcq woi nmmcy`w} n`gfy`g} ong aii` mcddimwig n`g qi|cqwig }i|nqnwidu$

ixmi|w wonw woi nmmcy`w cq fy`g knu `cw qimievi di}}won` woi fcddcre`b |iqmi`wnbi}8

/>% nay}ig moedgqi`"} mcy`}ide`b <.<<?? |iqmi`w:

/1% mqeki }wc||iq} n}}e}wn`mi <.19?> |iqmi`w:

/=% aqinwo ndmcocd wi}we`b <.99<2 |iqmi`w:

/7% Aedd Adnmjrccg Dnr I`fcqmiki`wKn`nbiki`w E`}wewywi 1.>6?= |iqmi`w:

/9% dnr i`fcqmiki`w cffemiq} }wn`gnqg} n`gigymnwec` 9.<<=7 |iqmi`w:

/6% mck|qioi`}evi qionaedewnwec` 5.?1>? 9.=1>?|iqmi`w:

/2% c|iqnwcq"} n`g monyffiyq"} demi`}i >>.>716|iqmi`w:

/?% mqeke`nd hy}wemi |dn``e`b >1.99=2 |iqmi`w:

/5% n` nmmcy`w e` woi }wnwi wqin}yqu wc ai y}igc`du fcq woi i}wnade}oki`w n`g c|iqnwec` cf woiMi`wiq fcq woi ]wygu n`g \qivi`wec` cf Hyvi`ediMqeki n`g Gide`~yi`mu nw \qneqei Veir N&KY`eviq}ewu >.1<5< |iqmi`w:

/><% mck|i`}nwec` wc vemwek} cf mqeki fy`g=2.6==? |iqmi`w:

/>>% ikiqbi`mu qngec e`fqn}wqymwyqi fybewevin||qioi`}ec` nmmcy`w 9.95<7 >1.<5<7 |iqmi`w:

/>1% hygemend n`g mcyqw |iq}c``id wqne`e`b fy`g7.?=61 |iqmi`w:

/>=% n` nmmcy`w e` woi }wnwi wqin}yqu wc ai y}igfcq woi i}wnade}oki`w n`g c|iqnwec` cf woiMcqqimwec`nd Kn`nbiki`w E`}wewywi cf Wixn} n`gMqeke`nd Hy}wemi Mi`wiq Nmmcy`w >.1<5< |iqmi`w:

n`g

/>7% fneq gifi`}i nmmcy`w ?.<>7=6.<>7= |iqmi`w.

/f% Cf inmo gcddnq mqigewig wc woi dnr i`fcqmiki`wcffemiq} }wn`gnqg} n`g igymnwec` nmmcy`w y`giq ]ya}imwec` /i%/9%8

/>% ==.= mi`w} knu ai y}ig c`du wc |nungke`e}wqnwevi ix|i`}i}: n`g

/1% woi qikne`giq knu ai y}ig c`du wc |nuix|i`}i} qidnwig wc mc`we`ye`b igymnwec` fcq 

|iq}c`} demi`}ig y`giq Mon|wiq >2<>$Cmmy|nwec`} Mcgi.

Nki`gki`w} wc /i%/6%$ /i%/>>%$ n`g /i%/>7% iffimwevi ]i|wikaiq >$1<>> /OA 771$ ¢=%.

1<>> Dibe}dnwevi @cwiOA 771 nki`g} }ya}imwec` /i% wc ngg woiikiqbi`mu qngec e`fqn}wqymwyqi nmmcy`w wc woi de}w cf nmmcy`w} wonw qimievi n |iqmi`wnbi cf mcyqw mc}w}

Page 59: Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

7/30/2019 Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fair-defense-law-dec-2011-tidc 59/76

 

9=

nywocqeig e` woe} }imwec`. Woi }imwec` nd}ce`mqin}i} woi ke`ekyk |iqmi`wnbi cf mcyqw mc}w}nddcmnwig wc woi Fneq Gifi`}i Nmmcy`w fqck 6.<>7=)wc ?.<>7=).

]im. >==.><2. Fii fcq ]y||cqw cf E`gebi`wGifi`}i Qi|qi}i`wnwec`

/n% N |iq}c` mc`vemwig cf n`u cffi`}i$ cwoiq won` n`cffi`}i qidnwe`b wc n |igi}wqen` cq woi |nqje`b cf nkcwcq vioemdi$ }ondd |nu n} n mcyqw mc}w$ e` nggewec`wc cwoiq mc}w}$ n fii cf '1 wc ai y}ig wc fy`g e`gebi`wgifi`}i qi|qi}i`wnwec` woqcybo woi fneq gifi`}inmmcy`w i}wnade}oig y`giq ]imwec` 25.<=>2>.<9?$Bcviq`ki`w Mcgi.

/a% Woi wqin}yqiq }ondd qikew n fii mcddimwig y`giq woe} }imwec` wc woi mck|wqcddiq e` woi kn``iq |qcvegig au ]yamon|wiq A. Woi mck|wqcddiq }onddmqigew woi qikewwig fii} wc woi mqigew cf woi fneq 

gifi`}i nmmcy`w i}wnade}oig y`giq ]imwec` 2>.<9?$Bcviq`ki`w Mcgi.

Nki`gki`w} wc /n%$ /g%$ n`g /f% n`g nggewec` cf /f+>% iffimwevi ]i|w. >$ 1<>> /OA >297$ ¢1<%.

OA >297 knji} n mc`fcqke`b mon`bi wc }ya}imwec`/n%.

@cwi8 Qifiqi`mi} wc woi Wn}j Fcqmi c` E`gebi`w Gifi`}i }ocydg ai qing n} wc woi Wixn} E`gebi`w Gifi`}i Mckke}}ec` n`g }wnwywcqu qifiqi`mi} wc qi|indig }imwec`} }ocydg ai qing n} wc ew} qi|dnmiki`w }imwec` fqck woi 1<>> Dibe}dnwevi @cwi} 

n`g woi monqw aibe``e`b c` |nbi 62.

WI_N] NGKE@E]WQNWEVI MCGI

WEWDI >. NGKE@E]WQNWEC@

\NQW ?. HYGEMEND MCY@MED

MON\WIQ >2=. E@GEBI@W GIFI@]I BQN@W]

]yamon|wiq N. Bi`iqnd Fy`ge`b \qcbqnk\qcve}ec`}

]im. >2=.><>. N||demnaedewu

/n% Woi Wixn} Dibe}dnwyqi nywocqeig woi Wn}j Fcqmic` E`gebi`w Gifi`}i /Wn}j Fcqmi% wc geqimw woiMck|wqcddiq wc ge}wqeaywi Fneq Gifi`}i Nmmcy`wfy`g}$ e`mdyge`b bqn`w}$ wc mcy`wei} wc |qcvegie`gebi`w gifi`}i }iqvemi}. Ew fyqwoiq nywocqeig woiWn}j Fcqmi wc kc`ewcq bqn`w} n`g i`fcqmimck|den`mi au mcy`wei} rewo bqn`w wiqk}.

]yamon|wiq} N + G cf woe} mon|wiq n||du wc ndde`gebi`w gifi`}i bqn`w} n`g cwoiq fy`g} nrnqgig wcmcy`wei} au woi Wn}j Fcqmi. ]yamon|wiq N cf woe}mon|wiq mcviq} woi bi`iqnd |qcve}ec`} fcq fy`ge`b.]yamon|wiq A cf woe} mon|wiq nggqi}}i} fy`ge`bwu|i}$ idebeaedewu$ n`g bi`iqnd |qcve}ec`} cf bqn`wfy`ge`b. ]yamon|wiq M cf woe} mon|wiq }iw} cyw woiqydi} qidnwig wc ngke`e}wiqe`b bqn`w}. ]yamon|wiq Gcf woe} mon|wiq }|imefei} qydi} qibnqge`b fe}mnd n`g|qcbqnk kc`ewcqe`b n`g nygew}.

/a% C`du mcy`wei} e` Wixn} nqi idebeadi wc qimievibqn`w} cq cwoiq fy`g} fqck woi Wn}j Fcqmi.

/m% Woi Wn}j Fcqmi knu ge}wqeaywi fy`g} e`nmmcqgn`mi rewo ew} |cdemei} n`g an}ig c` cffemend}yake}}ec`} n`g qi|cqw} |qcvegig au woi mcy`wei}.Woi}i fy`g} ky}w ai y}ig wc ek|qcvi e`gebi`wgifi`}i }u}wik} e` woi mcy`wu n`g nqi }yahimw wc nddn||demnadi mc`gewec`} mc`wne`ig e` woe} mon|wiq.

]im. >2=.><1. Gife`ewec`}

Woi fcddcre`b rcqg} n`g wiqk}$ roi` y}ig e` woe}mon|wiq$ redd onvi woi fcddcre`b kin`e`b}$ y`di}}cwoiqre}i e`gemnwig8

/>% !N||demn`w! e} n mcy`wu wonw on} }yakewwig nbqn`w n||demnwec`$ bqn`w qi`irnd gcmyki`wnwec`$cq cwoiq qi~yi}w fcq fy`ge`b fqck woi Wn}j Fcqmi.

/1% !N||demnwec`! e} n`u fcqknd qi~yi}w fcq fy`ge`b }yakewwig au n mcy`wu wc woi Wn}j

Fcqmi.

/=% !Mqeki! kin`}

/N% n ke}gikin`cq |y`e}onadi aumc`fe`iki`w: cq 

/A% n fidc`u.

/7% !Gifi`gn`w! kin`} n |iq}c` nmmy}ig cf nmqeki cq n hyvi`edi cffi`}i.

/9% !Geqimw Ge}ayq}iki`w! kin`} fy`g} nvnednadi

fcq qiekayq}iki`w cf e`gebi`w gifi`}i ix|i`}i}wc mcy`wei} wonw gc `cw n||du fcq woi fcqkydnbqn`w.

/6% !Ge}mqiwec`nqu Bqn`w! kin`} fy`ge`bn||qcvig fcq n }|imefem |qcbqnk gi}eb`ig wcek|qcvi woi ~yndewu cf e`gebi`w gifi`}i }iqvemi}.

/2% !I~yndenwec` Ge}ayq}iki`w! kin`} fy`ge`bnddcmnwig wc mcy`wei} woqcybo n fcqkydn an}ig

Page 60: Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

7/30/2019 Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fair-defense-law-dec-2011-tidc 60/76

 

97

c` woi |iqmi`wnbi cf qiekayq}iki`w mcy`wei}qimievi fcq e`mqin}ig e`gebi`w gifi`}i ix|i`}i}cq cwoiq mqewiqen n||qcvig au woi Wn}j Fcqmi.

/?% !Ixwqncqge`nqu Ge}ayq}iki`w! kin`} fy`ge`bwc qiekayq}i n mcy`wu fcq nmwynd ixwqncqge`nquix|i`}i} fcq |qcvege`b e`gebi`w gifi`}i}iqvemi} e` n mn}i cq }iqei} cf mn}i}.

/5% !Fneq Gifi`}i Nmmcy`w! e} n` nmmcy`w e` woibi`iqnd qivi`yi fy`g wonw knu ai n||qc|qenwigc`du wc woi Wn}j Fcqmi c` E`gebi`w Gifi`}i fcq woi |yq|c}i cf ek|diki`we`b woi Wixn} Fneq Gifi`}i Nmw.

/><% !Fcqkydn Bqn`w! kin`} fy`ge`b nddcmnwig wcmcy`wei} woqcybo n fcqkydn an}ig y|c`|c|ydnwec` febyqi} cq cwoiq mqewiqen n||qcvig auwoi Wn}j Fcqmi.

/>>% !Bqn`w! e} n fy`ge`b nrnqg kngi au woiWn}j Fcqmi wc n Wixn} mcy`wu e` woi fcqk cf nfcqkydn bqn`w cq ge}mqiwec`nqu bqn`w.

/>1% !Bqn`wii! kin`} n mcy`wu wonw e} woiqime|ei`w cf n bqn`w cq cwoiq fy`g} fqck woi Wn}jFcqmi.

/>=% !Hyvi`edi cffi`}i! kin`} mc`gymwmckkewwig au n |iq}c` roedi ucy`biq won` >2uinq} cf nbi wonw mc`}wewywi}8

/N% n ke}gikin`cq |y`e}onadi au

mc`fe`iki`w: cq 

/A% n fidc`u.

/>7% !Cwoiq fy`g}! kin`} fy`ge`b nrnqgig auwoi Wn}j Fcqmi wc n mcy`wu cwoiq won` n bqn`wn`g e`mdygi} ayw e} `cw dekewig wc8

/N% Geqimw Ge}ayq}iki`w}:

/A% Ixwqncqge`nqu Ge}ayq}iki`w}:

/M% I~yndenwec` Ge}ayq}iki`w}:

/G% Wnqbiwig ]|imefem fy`ge`b: n`g

/I% Wimo`emnd ]y||cqw.

/>9% !]|imend mc`gewec`! kin`} n qi~yeqiki`w|dnmig c` n mcy`wu au woi Wn}j Fcqmi wonw ky}wai }nwe}feig n} mc`gewec` cf fy`ge`b.

/>6% !Wnqbiwig ]|imefem Fy`g}! kin`} fy`ge`bnrnqgig wc mcy`wei} au woi Wn}j Fcqmi fcq n}|imefem |qcbqnk gi}eb`ig wc |qckcwi n`g n}}e}wmcy`wei}" mck|den`mi rewo woi qi~yeqiki`w} cf }wnwi dnr qidnwe`b wc e`gebi`w gifi`}i.

/>2% !Wimo`emnd ]y||cqw! kin`} fy`ge`bnrnqgig wc mcy`wei} wc ek|qcvi woi ~yndewu cf e`gebi`w gifi`}i }iqvemi}$ qne}i woi j`crdigbian}i nacyw e`gebi`w gifi`}i$ n`g i}wnade}o|qcmi}}i} wonw mn` ai bi`iqndeig wc }ekednq }ewynwec`} e` cwoiq mcy`wei}.

/>?% !Wn}j Fcqmi c` E`gebi`w Gifi`}i! /Wn}jFcqmi% e} woi bcviq`ki`wnd i`wewu i}wnade}oign`g bcviq`ig au ¢2>.<9> cf woi Wixn}Bcviq`ki`w Mcgi.

/>5% !YBK]! kin`} woi Y`efcqk Bqn`wKn`nbiki`w ]wn`gnqg} |qckydbnwig au woi

Bcviq`cq"} Cffemi cf Aygbiw n`g \dn``e`b nw¢¢9.>7> + 9.>9> n`g ¢9.>62 cf woe} wewdi.

]im. >2=.><=. \qcmi}} fcq ]yakewwe`bN||demnwec`} fcq Bqn`w} n`g Cwoiq Fy`g}

/n% Woi Wn}j Fcqmi }ondd |qcvegi `cwemi cf nvnednaedewucf bqn`w} n`g cwoiq fy`g} c` woi E`wiq`iw$ n`g redd|yade}o c` ew} ria}ewi woi qidnwig kiwocg} n`g|cdemei}.

/a% Bqn`w n||demnwec`}. Woi Wn}j Fcqmi redd |qcvegirqewwi` `cwemi wc inmo mcy`wu hygbi cf n`u Qi~yi}w}

fcq N||demnwec`} /QFN% fcq e`gebi`w gifi`}i bqn`w}. N||demn`w} n||due`b |yq}yn`w wc n` QFN ky}w }yakewwoieq n||demnwec`} nmmcqge`b wc woi qi~yeqiki`w}|qcvegig e` woi QFN. Woi QFN redd |qcvegi woifcddcre`b8

/>% e`fcqknwec` qibnqge`b gingde`i} fcq woi}yake}}ec` cf n||demnwec`}:

/1% woi knxekyk n`g ke`ekyk nkcy`w} cf fy`ge`b nvnednadi fcq n bqn`w$ ef n||demnadi:

/=% woi }wnqwe`b n`g i`ge`b gnwi} fcq bqn`w}:

/7% e`fcqknwec` qibnqge`b ocr n||demn`w} knunmmi}} n||demnwec`}:

/9% e`fcqknwec` qibnqge`b roiqi n||demn`w} ky}w}yakew n||demnwec`}:

/6% }yake}}ec` n`g |qcbqnk qi~yeqiki`w}: n`g

Page 61: Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

7/30/2019 Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fair-defense-law-dec-2011-tidc 61/76

 

99

/2% woi |qecqewei} fcq fy`ge`b n} i}wnade}oig auwoi Wn}j Fcqmi.

/m% N||demnwec`} fcq cwoiq fy`g}. Woi Wn}j Fcqmi nd}cknu mc`}egiq n||demnwec`} fcq cwoiq fy`g} wonw onvi`cw aii` }yakewwig |yq}yn`w wc n` QFN. N||demn`w}ky}w }yakew }ymo n||demnwec`} e` nmmcqgn`mi rewowoi Wn}j Fcqmi+|qcvegig byegide`i} fcq cwoiq fy`g}$n`g redd ai }idimwig e` nmmcqgn`mi rewo ¢>2=.><7 cf woe} mon|wiq /qidnwe`b wc Bqn`w Qi}cdywec`}%.

]im. >2=.><7. Bqn`w Qi}cdywec`}

/n% Inmo bqn`w n||demnwec` ky}w e`mdygi n qi}cdywec`fqck woi mcy`wu mckke}}ec`iq}" mcyqw wonw mc`wne`}woi fcddcre`b8

/>% nywocqenwec` fcq woi }yake}}ec` cf woin||demnwec` wc woi Wn}j Fcqmi:

/1% |qcve}ec` beve`b woi nywocqeig cffemend woi|criq wc n||du fcq$ nmmi|w$ gimde`i$ kcgefu$ cq mn`mid woi bqn`w: n`g

/=% rqewwi` n}}yqn`mi wonw$ e` woi ivi`w cf dc}} cq ke}y}i cf Fneq Gifi`}i Nmmcy`w fy`g}$ woibcviq`e`b acgu redd qiwyq` ndd fy`g} n} qi~yeqigau woi Wn}j Fcqmi.

/a% Woi Wn}j Fcqmi knu qi~yeqi n qi}cdywec` fqckmcy`wei} qimieve`b cwoiq fy`g}.

]im. >2=.><9. ]idimwec` \qcmi}}

/n% Woi Wn}j Fcqmi cq ew} gi}eb`ii} redd qiveir nddn||demnwec`} n`g }ondd nrnqg fqck woi Fneq Gifi`}i Nmmcy`w fcqkydn bqn`w}$ ge}mqiwec`nqu bqn`w}$ cq cwoiq fy`g}.

/a% Y|c` qiveire`b n` n||demnwec`$ }wnff knu qi~yeqin` n||demn`w wc }yakew$ rewoe` n }|imefeig weki$nggewec`nd e`fcqknwec` wc mck|diwi woi qiveir cq wcmdnqefu cq hy}wefu woi n||demnwec`. @iewoiq n qi~yi}w fcq nggewec`nd e`fcqknwec` `cq woi e}}yn`mi cf n|qideke`nqu qiveir qi|cqw kin`} wonw woi Wn}j Fcqmiredd fy`g n` n||demnwec`.

/m% Woi Wn}j Fcqmi redd e`fcqk n||demn`w} e` rqewe`b cq au idimwqc`em kin`} cf gime}ec`} wc bqn`w cq gi`un||demnwec`} fcq fy`ge`b.

/g% Ef woi Wn}j Fcqmi giwiqke`i} wonw n` n||demn`won} fnedig wc }yakew woi `imi}}nqu e`fcqknwec` cq on} fnedig wc mck|du rewo n`u Wn}j Fcqmi qydi cq cwoiq qidivn`w }wnwywi$ qydi$ cq qi~yeqiki`w$ woi Wn}jFcqmi knu ocdg n bqn`wii"} fy`g} y`wed woi bqn`wii

on} }nwe}feig woi qi~yeqiki`w} cf n }|imend mc`gewec`ek|c}ig au woi Wn}j Fcqmi. Woi Wn}j Fcqmi knuqihimw woi n||demnwec` n`g gi`u woi bqn`w fcq fnedyqi wc}nwe}fu woi qi~yeqiki`w}.

/i% Ixmi|w n} |qcvegig au dnr$ ndd fy`ge`b gime}ec`}kngi au woi Wn}j Fcqmi cq ew} gi}eb`ii} nqi fe`ndn`g nqi `cw }yahimw wc n||ind.

]im. >2=.><6. Bqn`w Fy`ge`b Gime}ec`}

/n% Woi Wn}j Fcqmi cq ew} gi}eb`ii} redd knjigime}ec`} c` n||demnwec`} fcq fy`ge`b woqcybo woi y}icf cahimwevi wccd} n`g mck|nqnwevi n`ndu}e}. WoiWn}j Fcqmi cq ew} gi}eb`ii} redd feq}w giwiqke`iroiwoiq woi bqn`wii e} idebeadi fcq fy`g} e`nmmcqgn`mi rewo ¢>2=.><> cf woe} mon|wiq /qidnwe`b wc N||demnaedewu% n`g ¢>2=.1<> cf woe} mon|wiq /qidnwe`bwc Idebeaedewu%.

/a% Ndd fy`ge`b gime}ec`} qi}w mck|diwidu rewoe` woige}mqiwec`nqu nywocqewu cf woi Wn}j Fcqmi cq ew}gi}eb`ii}. Woi qimie|w cf n` n||demnwec` fcq fy`ge`bgci} `cw cadebnwi woi Wn}j Fcqmi wc nrnqg fy`ge`b$n`g woi Wn}j Fcqmi knu |nqwenddu fy`g aygbiw ewik}e` bqn`w n||demnwec`}.

/m% Bqn`we`b n` n||demnwec` gci} `cw qi~yeqi woi Wn}jFcqmi wc bevi n }ya}i~yi`w n||demnwec` |qecqewumc`}egiqnwec`.

/g% Wn}j Fcqmi gime}ec`} qibnqge`b fy`ge`b nqi}yahimw wc woi nvnednaedewu cf fy`g}.

]im. >2=.><2. Bqn`w Nmmi|wn`miInmo n||demn`w ky}w nmmi|w cq qihimw n bqn`w nrnqgrewoe` =< gnu} cf woi gnwi y|c` roemo woi Wn}jFcqmi e}}yi} n ]wnwiki`w cf Bqn`w Nrnqg. WoiGeqimwcq cf woi Wn}j Fcqmi knu ndwiq woe} gingde`iy|c` qi~yi}w fqck woi n||demn`w. Woi nywocqeigcffemend gi}eb`nwig y`giq ¢>2=.=<> cf woe} mon|wiq /qidnwe`b wc Bqn`w Cffemend}% ky}w fcqknddu nmmi|w woibqn`w e` rqewe`b aifcqi woi bqn`wii knu qimievi n`ubqn`w fy`g}.

]im. >2=.><?. Ngc|wec`} au Qifiqi`mi

/n% Bqn`wii} ky}w mck|du rewo ndd n||demnadi }wnwi}wnwywi}$ qydi}$ qibydnwec`}$ n`g byegide`i}.

/a% Woi Wn}j Fcqmi ngc|w} au qifiqi`mi woi qydi}$gcmyki`w}$ n`g fcqk} de}wig aidcr wonw qidnwi wc woingke`e}wqnwec` cf bqn`w}.

/>% Y`efcqk Bqn`w Kn`nbiki`w ]wn`gnqg}/YBK]% ngc|wig |yq}yn`w wc woi Y`efcqk Bqn`w

Page 62: Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

7/30/2019 Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fair-defense-law-dec-2011-tidc 62/76

 

96

n`g Mc`wqnmw Kn`nbiki`w Nmw cf >5?>$ Mon|wiq 2?=$ Wixn} Bcviq`ki`w Mcgi. ]ii ¢¢9.>7> +9.>9> n`g ¢9.>62 cf woe} wewdi.

/1% Woi Wn}j Fcqmi fcqk}$ e`mdyge`b woi}wnwiki`w cf bqn`w nrnqg$ bqn`w nghy}wki`w`cwemi$ bqn`wii"} |qcbqi}} qi|cqw$ fe`n`mendix|i`gewyqi qi|cqw$ n`g |qc|iqwu e`vi`wcquqi|cqw.

]im. >2=.><5. Y}i cf woi E`wiq`iw

Woi Wn}j Fcqmi knu qi~yeqi }yake}}ec` cf n||demnwec`} fcq bqn`w} cq cwoiq fy`g}$ |qcbqi}}qi|cqw}$ fe`n`mend qi|cqw}$ n`g cwoiq e`fcqknwec` venwoi E`wiq`iw. Mck|diwec` n`g }yake}}ec` cf n|qcbqi}} qi|cqw cq fe`n`mend qi|cqw ven woi E`wiq`iwkiiw} woi qidivn`w qi~yeqiki`w} mc`wne`ig rewoe`woe} mon|wiq fcq }yakewwe`b qi|cqw} e` rqewe`b. Ef n`n||demnwec` fcq n bqn`w cq cwoiq fy`g} e} }yakewwig ven

woi E`wiq`iw$ woi Wn}j Fcqmi redd `cw mc`}egiq ewmck|diwi y`wed woi bqn`wii |qcvegi} n` E`wiq`iw]yake}}ec` Fcqk wonw e} }eb`ig au woi n||demn`w"}nywocqeig cffemend n`g wonw kiiw} ndd qidivn`wgingde`i} fcq n||demnwec`}. Woe} fcqk miqwefei} wonw woie`fcqknwec` }yakewwig ven woi E`wiq`iw e} wqyi n`gmcqqimw n`g wonw$ ef fy`ge`b e} nrnqgig$ woi bqn`wiiredd naegi au ndd qidivn`w qydi}$ |cdemei}$ n`g|qcmigyqi}. Woi Geqimwcq cf woi Wn}j Fcqmi knubqn`w n mcy`wu n rneviq cf E`wiq`iw }yake}}ec`qi~yeqiki`w} fcq bccg mny}i }ocr`.

]yamon|wiq A. Idebeaedewu n`g Fy`ge`b

Qi~yeqiki`w}

]im. >2=.1<>. Idebeaedewu

/n% Woi Wn}j Fcqmi knu |qcvegi fy`g}$ e`mdyge`bbqn`w} fqck woi Fneq Gifi`}i Nmmcy`w$ wc mcy`wei}wonw onvi mck|deig rewo }wn`gnqg} gividc|ig au woiWn}j Fcqmi n`g wonw onvi gikc`}wqnwigmckkewki`w wc mck|den`mi rewo woi qi~yeqiki`w} cf }wnwi dnr qidnwe`b wc e`gebi`w gifi`}i.

/a% N mcy`wu knu `cw qigymi woi nkcy`w cf fy`g}ix|i`gig fcq e`gebi`w gifi`}i }iqvemi} e` woi mcy`wu

aimny}i cf fy`g} |qcvegig au woi Wn}j Fcqmi.Aimny}i ge}mqiwec`nqu bqn`w} n`g wnqbiwig }|imefemfy`g} nqi nrnqgig wc i`nadi n mcy`wu wc i}wnade}o n`ir }u}wik cq |qcbqnk fcq |qcvege`b e`gebi`wgifi`}i }iqvemi}$ }ymo bqn`w} knu cq knu `cw i`wiq e`wc n mndmydnwec` cf roiwoiq woi mcy`wu on} cq reddqigymi ew} fy`ge`b aimny}i cf Wn}j Fcqmi fy`ge`b.Cwoiq wu|i} cf fy`ge`b$ e`mdyge`b fcqkydn bqn`w}$geqimw ge}ayq}iki`w}$ i~yndenwec` ge}ayq}iki`w}$ixwqncqge`nqu ge}ayq}iki`w}$ cq wimo`emnd }y||cqw$

}ondd ai mc`}egiqig e` giwiqke`e`b mck|den`mi rewowoe} qi~yeqiki`w.

]im. >2=.1<1. Y}i cf Fy`g}

Bqn`w} |qcvegig y`giq woe} mon|wiq knu ai y}ig aumcy`wei} fcq8

/>% Nwwcq`iu fii} fcq e`gebi`w gifi`gn`w}nmmy}ig cf mqeki} cq hyvi`edi cffi`}i}:

/1% Ix|i`}i} fcq demi`}ig e`vi}webnwcq}$ ix|iqw}$fcqi`}em }|imende}w}$ cq ki`wnd oindwo ix|iqw}qidnwig wc woi mqeke`nd gifi`}i cf e`gebi`wgifi`gn`w}:

/=% Cwoiq geqimw dewebnwec` mc}w} qidnwig wc woimqeke`nd gifi`}i cf e`gebi`w gifi`gn`w}: n`g

/7% Cwoiq n||qcvig ix|i`}i} nddcrig au woi

QFN cq `imi}}nqu fcq woi c|iqnwec` cf n fy`gig|qcbqnk.

]im. >2=.1<=. Ix|i`gewyqi Mnwibcqei}

/n% Nddcrnadi ix|i`gewyqi mnwibcqei} n`g n`u`imi}}nqu gife`ewec`} redd ai |qcvegig wc woin||demn`w n} |nqw cf woi n||demnwec` |qcmi}}.

/a% Ix|i`gewyqi} knu ai nddcmnwig wc woi bqn`w e`nmmcqgn`mi rewo woi Y`efcqk Bqn`w Kn`nbiki`w]wn`gnqg}.

]im. >2=. 1<7. \qcbqnk E`mcki

/n% Qydi} bcviq`e`b woi y}i cf |qcbqnk e`mcki nqie`mdygig e` woi |qcve}ec`} cf woi Y`efcqk Bqn`wKn`nbiki`w ]wn`gnqg} ngc|wig au qifiqi`mi e`¢>2=.><? cf woe} mon|wiq /qidnwe`b wc Ngc|wec`} auQifiqi`mi%.

/a% Bqn`wii} ky}w y}i |qcbqnk e`mcki wc}y||diki`w |qcbqnk mc}w} cq qigymi |qcbqnk mc}w}.\qcbqnk e`mcki knu c`du ai y}ig fcq nddcrnadi|qcbqnk mc}w}.

]im. >2=.1<9. I~ye|ki`w

/n% Gime}ec`} au woi Wn}j Fcqmi cq ew} gi}eb`ii}qibnqge`b qi~yi}w} wc |yqmon}i i~ye|ki`w y}e`bWn}j Fcqmi fy`g} redd ai kngi an}ig c` woinvnednaedewu cf fy`g}$ roiwoiq woi bqn`wii on}gikc`}wqnwig wonw woi qi~yi}wig i~ye|ki`w e}`imi}}nqu n`g i}}i`wend wc woi }ymmi}}fyd c|iqnwec`cf woi fy`gig |qcbqnk$ n`g roiwoiq woi i~ye|ki`we} qin}c`nadi e` mc}w.

Page 63: Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

7/30/2019 Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fair-defense-law-dec-2011-tidc 63/76

 

92

/a% Fcq mcy`wei} wonw qimievi n kydwe+uinq bqn`w$ woiWn}j Fcqmi redd c`du fy`g i~ye|ki`w n`g cwoiq c`i+weki mc}w} gyqe`b woi feq}w uinq y`di}} |iqke}}ec` e}bqn`wig e` rqewe`b. Cwoiqre}i$ i~ye|ki`w n`g cwoiq c`i+weki mc}w} redd `cw fnmwcq e` wc woi cviqndd |qchimwmc}w} nfwiq woi feq}w uinq cf woi bqn`w.

/m% Woi Wn}j Fcqmi qi~yeqi} inmo bqn`wii wckne`wne` n` e`vi`wcqu qi|cqw cf ndd i~ye|ki`w|yqmon}ig rewo Wn}j Fcqmi fy`g}. Woe} qi|cqw ky}wmck|cqw rewo woi fe`nd fe`n`mend ix|i`gewyqi qi|cqw. Nwdin}w c`mi inmo uinq gyqe`b woi nrnqg |iqecg$ inmobqn`wii ky}w mck|diwi n |ou}emnd e`vi`wcqu cf ndd|qc|iqwu |yqmon}ig rewo Wn}j Fcqmi fy`g} n`g woibqn`wii ky}w qimc`medi woi qi}ydw} rewo woi|yqmon}ig |qc|iqwu qimcqg}. Fcq }e`bdi+uinq nrnqg}$woi e`vi`wcqu n`g qimc`medenwec` ky}w ai kngi nw woii`g cf woi nrnqg |iqecg n`g }yakewwig rewo woi fe`ndqi|cqw.

/g% I~ye|ki`w |yqmon}ig rewo Wn}j Fcqmi fy`g}ky}w ai dnaidig n`g on`gdig e` nmmcqgn`mi rewo woibqn`wii"} |qc|iqwu kn`nbiki`w |cdemei} n`g|qcmigyqi}.

/i% Y`di}} cwoiqre}i |qcvegig$ i~ye|ki`w|yqmon}ig e} woi |qc|iqwu cf woi bqn`wii nfwiq woii`g cf woi nrnqg |iqecg cq wiqke`nwec` cf woic|iqnwec` cf woi fy`gig |qcbqnk$ roemoiviq cmmyq}dn}w.

]yamon|wiq M. Ngke`e}wiqe`b Bqn`w}

]im. >2=.=<>. Bqn`w Cffemend}

/n% Inmo bqn`w ky}w onvi woi fcddcre`b gi}eb`nwig wc}iqvi n} bqn`w cffemend}8

/>% \qcbqnk geqimwcq. Woe} |iq}c` ky}w ai woicffemiq cq ik|dcuii qi}|c`}eadi fcq |qcbqnkc|iqnwec` n`g roc redd }iqvi n} woi |ce`w+cf+mc`wnmw qibnqge`b woi |qcbqnk"} gnu+wc+gnuc|iqnwec`}.

/1% Fe`n`mend cffemiq. Woe} |iq}c` ky}w ai woi

mcy`wu nygewcq cq mcy`wu wqin}yqiq ef woi mcy`wugci} `cw onvi n mcy`wu nygewcq.

/=% Nywocqeig cffemend. Woe} |iq}c` ky}w ainywocqeig wc n||du fcq$ nmmi|w$ gimde`i$ kcgefu$cq mn`mid woi bqn`w fcq woi n||demn`w mcy`wu. Nmcy`wu hygbi cq n gi}eb`ii nywocqeig au woibcviq`e`b acgu e` ew} qi}cdywec` knu }iqvi n}woi nywocqeig cffemend.

/a% Woi Wn}j Fcqmi knu qi~yeqi n mcy`wu wcgi}eb`nwi n |qcbqnk geqimwcq fcq cwoiq fy`gig|qcbqnk}.

/m% Woi |qcbqnk geqimwcq n`g woi nywocqeig cffemendknu ai woi }nki |iq}c`. Woi fe`n`mend cffemiq knu`cw }iqvi n} woi |qcbqnk geqimwcq cq woi nywocqeigcffemend.

]im. >2=.=<1. Cadebnwe`b Fy`g}

Woi bqn`wii knu `cw cadebnwi bqn`w fy`g} aifcqi woiaibe``e`b cq nfwiq woi i`g cf woi bqn`w |iqecg.

]im. >2=.=<=. Qiwi`wec` cf Qimcqg}

/n% Bqn`wii} ky}w kne`wne` ndd fe`n`mend qimcqg}$}y||cqwe`b gcmyki`w}$ }wnwe}wemnd qimcqg}$ n`g nddcwoiq qimcqg} |iqwe`i`w wc woi nrnqg fcq nw din}w woqiiuinq} fcddcre`b woi mdc}yqi cf woi kc}w qimi`w nygew

qi|cqw cq }yake}}ec` cf woi fe`nd ix|i`gewyqi qi|cqw.Qimcqg} qiwi`wec` e} qi~yeqig fcq woi |yq|c}i} cf }wnwi ixnke`nwec` n`g nygew. Bqn`wii} knu qiwne`qimcqg} e` n` idimwqc`em fcqknw. Ndd qimcqg} nqi}yahimw wc nygew cq kc`ewcqe`b gyqe`b woi i`weqiqiwi`wec` |iqecg.

/a% Bqn`wii} ky}w qiwne` qimcqg} fcq i~ye|ki`w$ `c`+ix|i`gnadi |iq}c`nd |qc|iqwu$ n`g qind |qc|iqwu fcq n |iqecg cf woqii uinq} fqck woi gnwi cf woi ewik"}ge}|c}ewec`$ qi|dnmiki`w$ cq wqn`}fiq.

/m% Ef n`u dewebnwec`$ mdnek$ cq nygew e} }wnqwig aifcqi

woi ix|eqnwec` cf woi woqii+uinq qimcqg} qiwi`wec`|iqecg$ woi bqn`wii ky}w qiwne` woi qimcqg} y`giq qiveir y`wed woi qi}cdywec` cf ndd dewebnwec`$ mdnek}$ cq nygew fe`ge`b}.

]im. >2=.=<7. Ix|i`gewyqi Qi|cqw}

/n% Qime|ei`w} cf bqn`w} n`g cwoiq fy`g} knu aiqi~yeqig wc }yakew ix|i`gewyqi qi|cqw} wc woi Wn}jFcqmi e` nggewec` wc woi n``ynd ix|i`gewyqi qi|cqwqi~yeqig fcq ndd mcy`wei} y`giq Wixn} Bcviq`ki`wMcgi ¢2>.<=9>/i%.

/a% Woi Wn}j Fcqmi redd |qcvegi woi n||qc|qenwifcqk} n`g e`}wqymwec`} fcq woi qi|cqw} ndc`b rewogingde`i} fcq woieq }yake}}ec`. Woi fe`n`mend cffemiq }ondd ai qi}|c`}eadi fcq }yakewwe`b woi ix|i`gewyqiqi|cqw}. Woi Wn}j Fcqmi knu |dnmi n fe`n`mend ocdgc` n bqn`wii"} fywyqi fy`g} ef woi bqn`wii fned} wc}yakew wekidu ix|i`gewyqi qi|cqw} cq }yakew}e`mck|diwi fe`n`mend qi|cqw}.

Page 64: Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

7/30/2019 Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fair-defense-law-dec-2011-tidc 64/76

 

9?

/m% Bqn`wii} ky}w i`}yqi wonw nmwynd ix|i`gewyqi}nqi ngi~ynwidu gcmyki`wig. Gcmyki`wnwec` knue`mdygi$ ayw e} `cw dekewig wc$ digbiq}$ |yqmon}icqgiq}$ wqnvid qimcqg}$ weki }oiiw} cq cwoiq |nuqcddgcmyki`wnwec`$ e`vcemi}$ mc`wqnmw}$ kedinbi qimcqg}$widi|oc`i aedd} n`g cwoiq gcmyki`wnwec` wonw viqefei}woi ix|i`gewyqi nkcy`w n`g n||qc|qenwi`i}} wc woify`gig |qcbqnk.

]im. >2=.=<9. \qcve}ec` cf Fy`g}

/n% Nfwiq n bqn`w on} aii` nmmi|wig n`g ef woiqi nqi`c cyw}wn`ge`b }|imend mc`gewec`} cq cwoiq gifemei`mei}$ woi Wn}j Fcqmi knu fcqrnqg fy`g} wcwoi bqn`wii. Fy`g} redd ai ge}ayq}ig wc woi bqn`wii`c kcqi cfwi` won` ~ynqwiqdu y`di}} }|imefem|iqke}}ec` e} bqn`wig e` rqewe`b fqck woi Geqimwcq.

/a% Ge}ayq}iki`w cf fy`g} e} ndrnu} }yahimw wc woinvnednaedewu cf fy`g}.

/m% Ge}mqiwec`nqu bqn`w fy`g} redd ai |neg c`du nfwiq woi ix|i`gewyqi qi|cqw on} aii` }yakewwig. Fy`g}ky}w ai ix|i`gig$ `cw cadebnwig$ aifcqi aie`be`mdygig e` woi fy`ge`b ix|i`gewyqi qi|cqw.

]im. >2=.=<6. Ge}mqiwec`nqu Bqn`w Nghy}wki`w}

/n% Woi nywocqeig cffemend ky}w }eb` ndd qi~yi}w} fcq bqn`w nghy}wki`w}.

/a% Aygbiw Nghy}wki`w}. Bqn`w nghy}wki`w}mc`}e}we`b cf qinddcmnwec`} cf fy`g} nkc`b cq rewoe`

aygbiw mnwibcqei} e` ixmi}} cf '><$<<< cq wi`|iqmi`w cf woi cqebe`nd bqn`w nrnqg$ roemoiviq e}di}}$ nqi mc`}egiqig aygbiw nghy}wki`w}$ n`g nqinddcrnadi c`du rewo |qecq n||qcvnd cf woi Geqimwcq cf woi Wn}j Fcqmi.

/m% @c`+Aygbiw Bqn`w Nghy}wki`w}. Woi fcddcre`bqydi} n||du wc `c`+aygbiw bqn`w nghy}wki`w}8

/>% Qi~yi}w} wc qive}i woi }mc|i$ wnqbiw$ cq fcmy} cf woi |qchimw$ cq ndwiq |qchimw nmwevewei}qi~yeqi ngvn`mi rqewwi` n||qcvnd fqck woi Wn}jFcqmi cq ew} gi}eb`ii}$ n} giwiqke`ig au woi

Geqimwcq cf woi Wn}j Fcqmi.

/1% Woi bqn`wii redd `cwefu woi Wn}j Fcqmi cq ew}gi}eb`ii} e` rqewe`b cf n`u mon`bi e` woigi}eb`nwig |qcbqnk geqimwcq$ fe`n`mend cffemiq$ cq nywocqeig cffemend rewoe` wi` gnu} fcddcre`b woimon`bi.

]im. >2=.=<2. Qikigei} fcq @c`mck|den`mi

Ef n bqn`wii fned} wc mck|du rewo n`u wiqk cq mc`gewec`cf n bqn`w cq cwoiq fy`g}$ woi Wn}j Fcqmi knu wnjic`i cq kcqi cf woi fcddcre`b nmwec`}8

/>% ge}nddcr ndd cq |nqw cf woi mc}w cf woi nmwevewucq nmwec` wonw e} `cw e` mck|den`mi n`g }iij nqiwyq` cf woi mc}w:

/1% ek|c}i ngke`e}wqnwevi }n`mwec`}$ cwoiq won`fe`i}$ c` woi bqn`wii:

/=% wik|cqnqedu rewoocdg ndd |nuki`w} |i`ge`bmcqqimwec` cf woi gifemei`mu au woi bqn`wii:

/7% rewoocdg fywyqi bqn`w} cq cwoiq fy`g} fqck woi|qcbqnk cq bqn`wii: cq 

/9% wiqke`nwi woi bqn`w cq cwoiq fy`g} e` rocdi cq 

e` |nqw.

]im. >2=.=<?. Wiqk cf Bqn`w cq Cwoiq Fy`g}

/n% Woi wiqk cf n bqn`w cq cwoiq fy`g} }ondd ai}|imefeig e` woi nrnqg }wnwiki`w cq cwoiq fy`ge`bgcmyki`w.

/a% Ef n bqn`wii re}oi} wc wiqke`nwi n bqn`w cq cwoiq fy`g} e` rocdi cq e` |nqw aifcqi woi i`g cf woi nrnqg|iqecg$ woi bqn`wii ky}w `cwefu woi Wn}j Fcqmi e`rqewe`b. Woi Wn}j Fcqmi cq ew} gi}eb`ii redd knjinqqn`biki`w} rewo woi bqn`wii fcq woi inqdu

wiqke`nwec` cf woi nrnqg.

/m% Woi Wn}j Fcqmi knu wiqke`nwi n`u bqn`w cq cwoiq fy`g}$ e` rocdi cq e` |nqw$ roi`8

/>% n bqn`wii fned} wc mck|du rewo n`u wiqk cq mc`gewec` cf woi bqn`w cq cwoiq fy`g} cq woibqn`wii on} fnedig wc mck|du rewo n`u n||demnadiqydi:

/1% woi bqn`wii n`g woi Geqimwcq cf woi Wn}jFcqmi nbqii wc gc }c:

/=% e`gebi`w gifi`}i fy`g} nqi `c dc`biq nvnednadi: cq 

/7% mc`gewec`} ixe}w wonw knji ew y`dejidu wonwbqn`w cq |qcbqnk cahimwevi} redd ainmmck|de}oig.

/g% N bqn`wii knu }yakew n rqewwi` qi~yi}w fcq n`ixwi`}ec` cf woi fy`ge`b |iqecg e` ixwqncqge`nqumeqmyk}wn`mi}. Woi Wn}j Fcqmi ky}w qimievi

Page 65: Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

7/30/2019 Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fair-defense-law-dec-2011-tidc 65/76

Page 66: Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

7/30/2019 Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fair-defense-law-dec-2011-tidc 66/76

 

6<

cf woi nygew qi}ydw} cq `e`i kc`wo} nfwiq woi i`g cf woi nygew |iqecg$ roemoiviq e} inqdeiq.

/a% Ndd cwoiq nygew} |iqfcqkig au nygewcq}e`gi|i`gi`w cf woi Wn}j Fcqmi ky}w ai kne`wne`ignw woi bqn`wii"} ngke`e}wqnwevi cffemi} |yq}yn`w wc¢>2=.=<= cf woe} mon|wiq /qidnwe`b wc Qiwi`wec` cf Qimcqg}% n`g ai kngi nvnednadi y|c` qi~yi}w auwoi Wn}j Fcqmi cq ew} qi|qi}i`wnwevi}. Bqn`wii} ky}w`cwefu woi Wn}j Fcqmi cf n`u nygew qi}ydw} wonw knungviq}idu ek|nmw woi Wn}j Fcqmi bqn`w fy`g}.

/m% @cwoe`b e` woe} }imwec` }ocydg ai mc`}wqyig }c n}wc qi~yeqi n }|imend cq |qcbqnk+}|imefem nygew cf nbqn`wii"} E`gebi`w Gifi`}i bqn`w |qcbqnk. 

MON\WIQ >27. E@GEBI@W GIFI@]I \CDEMEI]N@G ]WN@GNQG]

]yamon|wiq N. Ke`ekyk Mc`we`ye`b Dibnd

Igymnwec` Qi~yeqiki`w}

]im. >27.>. N||ce`wki`w e` Mqeke`nd Mn}i}

 N` Nwwcq`iu roc kiiw} woi qi~yeqiki`w} cf woe} qydiknu ai n||ce`wig wc qi|qi}i`w n` e`gebi`w |iq}c`nqqi}wig fcq cq monqbig rewo n mqeki$ ef woi nwwcq`iu e}cwoiqre}i idebeadi y`giq woi |qcmigyqi} gividc|igy`giq Nqwemdi 16.<7$ Mcgi cf Mqeke`nd \qcmigyqi.Mqeki on} woi kin`e`b n}}eb`ig au ¢>2=.1/1%. N`nwwcq`iu knu ai n||ce`wig y`giq woe} qydi c`du ef n`nwwcq`iu8

/>% Mck|diwi} n ke`ekyk cf }ex ocyq} cf mc`we`ye`b dibnd igymnwec` |iqwne`e`b wc mqeke`nddnr gyqe`b inmo >1+kc`wo qi|cqwe`b |iqecg. Woi hygbi} cf mqeke`nd mcyqw} cf woi mcy`wu }ondd }iwwoi >1+kc`wo qi|cqwe`b |iqecg n||demnadi wc woi hyqe}gemwec`. Mc`we`ye`b dibnd igymnwec` knue`mdygi nmwevewei} nmmqigewig y`giq ]imwec` 7$ Nqwemdi _EE$ ]wnwi Anq Qydi}$ }idf+}wygu$ winmoe`bnw n` nmmqigewig mc`we`ye`b dibnd igymnwec`nmwevewu$ nwwi`gn`mi nw n dnr }moccd mdn}} cq dibndqi}inqmo+an}ig rqewe`b. Woi hygbi} knu qi~yeqinwwcq`iu} wc mck|diwi kcqi won` woi ke`ekyk`ykaiq cf ocyq} cf mc`we`ye`b dibnd igymnwec` e`

mqeke`nd dnr e` woi |qcmigyqi} gividc|ig y`giq  Nqwemdi 16.<7$ Mcgi cf Mqeke`nd \qcmigyqi: cq 

/1% E} myqqi`wdu miqwefeig e` mqeke`nd dnr au woiWixn} Acnqg cf Dibnd ]|imendenwec`.

]im. >27.1. N||ce`wki`w e` Hyvi`edi Mn}i}

 N` nwwcq`iu roc kiiw} woi qi~yeqiki`w} cf woe} qydiknu ai n||ce`wig wc qi|qi}i`w n` e`gebi`w hyvi`edi

giwne`ig fcq cq nmmy}ig cf i`bnbe`b e` gide`~yi`wmc`gymw cq mc`gymw e`gemnwe`b n `iig fcq }y|iqve}ec`$ef woi nwwcq`iu e} cwoiqre}i idebeadi y`giq woi |dn`gividc|ig y`giq ]imwec` 9>.><>$ Fnkedu Mcgi. N`nwwcq`iu knu ai n||ce`wig y`giq woe} qydi c`du ef n`nwwcq`iu8

/>% Mck|diwi} n ke`ekyk cf }ex ocyq} cf mc`we`ye`b dibnd igymnwec` |iqwne`e`b wc hyvi`edidnr gyqe`b inmo >1+kc`wo qi|cqwe`b |iqecg. Woi hyvi`edi acnqg }ondd }iw woi >1+kc`wo qi|cqwe`b|iqecg n||demnadi wc woi hyqe}gemwec`. Mc`we`ye`bdibnd igymnwec` knu e`mdygi nmwevewei} nmmqigewigy`giq ]imwec` 7$ Nqwemdi _EE$ ]wnwi Anq Qydi}$}idf+}wygu$ winmoe`b nw n` nmmqigewig mc`we`ye`bdibnd igymnwec` nmwevewu$ nwwi`gn`mi nw n dnr}moccd mdn}} cq dibnd qi}inqmo+an}ig rqewe`b. N hyvi`edi acnqg knu qi~yeqi n` nwwcq`iu wcmck|diwi kcqi won` woi ke`ekyk `ykaiq cf ocyq} cf mc`we`ye`b dibnd igymnwec` e` hyvi`edi

dnr e` woi |dn` gividc|ig y`giq ]imwec` 9>.><>$Fnkedu Mcgi: cq 

/1% E} myqqi`wdu miqwefeig e` hyvi`edi dnr au woiWixn} Acnqg cf Dibnd ]|imendenwec`.

]im. >27.=. Qi|cqwe`b \iqecg

/n% Mc`we`ye`b dibnd igymnwec` nmwevewu mck|diwigrewoe` n c`i+uinq |iqecg ekkigenwidu |qimige`b n`nwwcq`iu"} e`ewend qi|cqwe`b |iqecg knu ai y}ig wckiiw woi igymnwec`nd qi~yeqiki`w fcq woi e`ewend uinq.

/a% Mc`we`ye`b dibnd igymnwec` nmwevewu mck|diwiggyqe`b n`u qi|cqwe`b |iqecg e` ixmi}} cf woike`ekyk }ex+ocyq qi~yeqiki`w fcq }ymo |iqecg knuai n||deig wc woi fcddcre`b |iqecg"} qi~yeqiki`w. Woimnqqucviq |qcve}ec` n||dei} wc c`i uinq c`du.

]im. >27.7. Ikiqbi`mu N||ce`wki`w

Ef `c nwwcq`iu roc kiiw} woi mc`we`ye`b dibndigymnwec` cq acnqg miqwefemnwec` qi~yeqiki`w}mc`wne`ig e` woe} }yamon|wiq e} nvnednadi au woi wekin` nwwcq`iu ky}w ai n||ce`wig e` woi mn}i$ n`cwoiq nwwcq`iu knu ai n||ce`wig. Woi |iq}c` knje`b n`

n||ce`wki`w y`giq woe} }imwec` }ondd bevi |qecqewu wcn` nwwcq`iu rewo ix|iqei`mi e` mqeke`nd cq hyvi`edidnr$ qi}|imwevidu.

Page 67: Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

7/30/2019 Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fair-defense-law-dec-2011-tidc 67/76

 

6>

]yamon|wiq A. Mc`wqnmw Gifi`giq \qcbqnkQi~yeqiki`w}

Geve}ec` >. Gife`ewec`}

]im. >27.><. ]yamon|wiq Gife`ewec`}

Woi fcddcre`b rcqg} n`g wiqk} roi` y}ig e` woe}}yamon|wiq }ondd onvi woi fcddcre`b kin`e`b}$y`di}} woi mc`wixw mdinqdu e`gemnwi} cwoiqre}i.

/>% N||ce`we`b Nywocqewu. Woi n||ce`we`bnywocqewu e} woi8

/N% Hygbi cq hygbi} roc onvi nywocqewu wci}wnade}o n` e`gebi`w gifi`}i |dn` n`gn||qcvi nwwcq`iu} wc qi|qi}i`w e`gebi`wgifi`gn`w} e` mqeke`nd mn}i} y`giq Nqwemdi16.<7$ Mcgi cf Mqeke`nd \qcmigyqi: n`g#cq 

/A% Hyvi`edi acnqg wonw on} nywocqewu wci}wnade}o n` e`gebi`w gifi`}i |dn` n`gn||qcvi nwwcq`iu} wc qi|qi}i`w e`gebi`wqi}|c`gi`w} e` hyvi`edi mn}i} y`giq ¢9>.><1$ Fnkedu Mcgi.

/1% Mc`wqnmw Gifi`giq \qcbqnk. Mc`wqnmwgifi`giq |qcbqnk kin`} n }u}wik y`giq roemo|qevnwi nwwcq`iu}$ nmwe`b n} e`gi|i`gi`wmc`wqnmwcq} n`g mck|i`}nwig rewo |yadem fy`g}$nqi i`bnbig wc |qcvegi dibnd qi|qi}i`wnwec` n`g}iqvemi} wc n bqcy| cf y`}|imefeig e`gebi`wgifi`gn`w} roc n||inq aifcqi n |nqwemydnq mcyqw

cq bqcy| cf mcyqw}.

/=% Mc`wqnmwe`b Nywocqewu. Woi mc`wqnmwe`bnywocqewu e} woi mcy`wu cq mcy`wei} wonw onvi woinywocqewu wc mc`mdygi n mc`wqnmw n`g wc cadebnwify`g} fcq woi |qcve}ec` cf e`gebi`w gifi`}i}iqvemi}.

/7% Mc`wqnmwcq. Woi mc`wqnmwcq e} n` nwwcq`iu$ dnrfeqk$ |qcfi}}ec`nd n}}cmenwec`$ dnruiq"}n}}cmenwec`$ dnr }moccd$ anq n}}cmenwec`$ `c`+|qcfew cqbn`enwec` cq cwoiq i`wewu wonw mn` aiacy`g au mc`wqnmw.

/9% Ewikeig Fii Vcymoiq. N` ewikeig fiivcymoiq e} n`u e`}wqyki`w$ }ymo n} n` e`vcemi$wonw giwned} }iqvemi} |qcvegig au n mc`wqnmwcq |qcvege`b e`gebi`w gifi`}i }iqvemi}. Woiewikeig fii vcymoiq knu ai e` |n|iq cq idimwqc`em fcqk. Ew }ondd e`mdygi nw n ke`ekyk nddwoi e`fcqknwec` `imi}}nqu fcq woi mcy`wu nygewcq cq cwoiq gi}eb`nwig cffemend wc mck|diwi woiix|i`gewyqi qi|cqw qi~yeqig wc ai }yakewwig wc

woi Cffemi cf Mcyqw Ngke`e}wqnwec` au ¢2>.<=9>$Bcviq`ki`w Mcgi.

Geve}ec` 1. N||demnwec` cf ]wn`gnqg} n`gMc`wqnmwe`b \qcmigyqi}

]im. >27.>>. N||demnwec` cf ]yamon|wiq

Woe} }yamon|wiq n||dei} wc ndd mc`wqnmw gifi`giq |qcbqnk}. Woe} }yamon|wiq gci} `cw n||du wc |yademgifi`giq |qcbqnk} i}wnade}oig n`g bcviq`ig auMon|wiq 16$ Mcgi cf Mqeke`nd \qcmigyqi.

]im. >27.>1. N||demnwec` \qcmi}}

Woi n||ce`we`b nywocqewu }ondd }cdemew n`g }idimwmc`wqnmwcq} e` nmmcqgn`mi rewo woi |qcmigyqibcviq`e`b ndwiq`nwevi n||ce`wki`w |qcbqnk}mc`wne`ig e` Nqwemdi 16.<7$ Mcgi cf Mqeke`nd\qcmigyqi.

/>% @cwefemnwec`. Woi `cwefemnwec` cf woic||cqwy`ewu wc n||du /@CN% wc ai n mc`wqnmwcq }ondd ai ge}wqeaywig e` n kn``iq wonw qin}c`nadumcviq} ndd |qnmweme`b kikaiq} cf woi anq rewoe`woi mcy`wu cq cwoiq qibec` gi}eb`nwig au woin||ce`we`b nywocqewu. Woi `cwefemnwec` }ondd e`fcqknwwcq`iu} cf ndd qi~yeqiki`w} fcq }yakewwe`bn||demnwec`}.

/1% C||cqwy`ewu wc Qi}|c`g. Ndd |cwi`wendmc`wqnmwcq} }ondd onvi woi }nki c||cqwy`ewu wcqi}|c`g wc woi @CN n`g ai mc`}egiqig fcq woi

nrnqg cf n mc`wqnmw.

/=% N||demnwec`. Ndd n||demnwec`} ky}w ai}yakewwig e` rqewe`b n`g }ondd ai kne`wne`ig auwoi n||ce`we`b nywocqewu cq mc`wqnmwe`b nywocqewue` nmmcqgn`mi rewo woi Wixn} ]wnwi Deaqnqu n`g Nqmoevi} Mckke}}ec` Qiwi`wec` ]moigydi fcq Dcmnd Qimcqg}+Dcmnd ]moigydi BQ.

]im. >27.>=. N||demnwec` Qiveir \qcmi}}

Fcddcre`b woi qiveir cf ndd n||demnwec`} woin||ce`we`b nywocqewu }ondd au n knhcqewu vcwi }idimw

mc`wqnmwcq/}%$ }|imefu woi wu|i} cf mn}i} inmomc`wqnmwcq e} ~yndefeig wc on`gdi$ n`g nywocqei woimc`wqnmwe`b nywocqewu wc i`wiq e`wc n mc`wqnmw. Woinwwcq`iu} n}}cmenwig rewo woi }idimwig mc`wqnmwcq/}%ky}w kiiw woi nwwcq`iu ~yndefemnwec` qi~yeqiki`w}mc`wne`ig e` woi e`gebi`w gifi`}i |qcmigyqi}ngc|wig |yq}yn`w wc Nqwemdi 16.<7$ Mcgi cf Mqeke`nd\qcmigyqi. Ef woi mc`wqnmw gci} `cw ixmdygi mn|ewndmn}i} e` roemo woi ginwo |i`ndwu e} }cybow$ woinwwcq`iu} n}}cmenwig rewo woi }idimwig mc`wqnmwcq/}%

Page 68: Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

7/30/2019 Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fair-defense-law-dec-2011-tidc 68/76

 

61

ky}w nd}c kiiw woi nwwcq`iu ~yndefemnwec`} }iw au woiqibec`nd }idimwec` mckkewwii n`g ai n||qcvig auwoi qibec`nd }idimwec` mckkewwii wc qi|qi}i`w mdei`w}e` mn|ewnd mn}i}. Woi n||ce`we`b nywocqewu }onddmc`}egiq nw din}w woi fcddcre`b fnmwcq} roi`ivndynwe`b n||demnwec`}8

/>% Ix|iqei`mi n`g ~yndefemnwec`} cf woin||demn`w:

/1% N||demn`w"} |n}w |iqfcqkn`mi e` qi|qi}i`we`bgifi`gn`w} e` mqeke`nd mn}i}:

/=% N||demn`w"} ge}me|de`nqu oe}wcqu rewo woi }wnwianq:

/7% N||demn`w"} naedewu wc mck|du rewo woi wiqk} cf woi mc`wqnmw: n`g

/9% Mc}w cf woi }iqvemi} y`giq woi mc`wqnmw. 

]im. >27.>7. Nrnqge`b woi Mc`wqnmw

E` nmmcqgn`mi rewo Nqwemdi 16.<7/o%$ Mcgi cf Mqeke`nd\qcmigyqi$ woi mc`wqnmwe`b nywocqewu knu n||qcviwoi qimckki`gig mc`wqnmwcq/}% n`g i`wiq e`wc nmc`wqnmw fcq }iqvemi}. Woi mc`wqnmwe`b nywocqewu }onddi`wiq e`wc n mc`wqnmw c`du ef ew mck|dei} rewo woi}i}wn`gnqg} n`g ndd n||demnadi dnr bcviq`e`b|qcfi}}ec`nd }iqvemi} mc`wqnmw} i`wiqig e`wc aumcy`wei}. N mc`wqnmw }ondd `cw ai nrnqgig }cdidu c`woi an}e} cf mc}w.

Geve}ec` =. Qi~yeqig Idiki`w} cf n Mc`wqnmw fcqE`gebi`w Gifi`}i ]iqvemi} /Inmo Mck|c`i`wAidcr ]ondd Ai E`mdygig e` n Mc`wqnmw fcqE`gebi`w Gifi`}i ]iqvemi} n`g ]ondd ]iqvi n} woiAn}e} fcq woi @CN%

]im. >27.>9. \nqwei}

Egi`wefu woi n||ce`we`b nywocqewu$ mc`wqnmwe`bnywocqewu$ n`g mc`wqnmwcq.

]im. >27.>6. Wiqk cf Mc`wqnmw

Woi mc`wqnmw }ondd }|imefu woi wiqk cf woi mc`wqnmw$e`mdyge`b n`u |qcve}ec` fcq ixwi`}ec`}$ n`g n|qcve}ec` fcq wiqke`nwe`b woi mc`wqnmw au iewoiq |nqwu.

]im. >27.>2. ]mc|i cf Mc`wqnmw

Woi mc`wqnmw }ondd }|imefu woi mnwibcqei} cf mn}i} e`roemo woi mc`wqnmwcq e} wc |qcvegi }iqvemi}.

]im. >27.>?. Ke`ekyk Nwwcq`iu yndefemnwec`}

Woi mc`wqnmw }ondd }|imefu ke`ekyk ~yndefemnwec`} fcq nwwcq`iu} mcviqig au woi mc`wqnmw n`g qi~yeqi }ymonwwcq`iu} wc kne`wne` woi ~yndefemnwec`} gyqe`b woiwiqk cf woi mc`wqnmw. Woi ~yndefemnwec`} }ondd i~ynd cq ixmiig woi ~yndefemnwec`} |qcvegig e` woi e`gebi`wgifi`}i |qcmigyqi} ngc|wig |yq}yn`w wc Nqwemdi16.<7$ Mcgi cf Mqeke`nd \qcmigyqi. Ef woi mc`wqnmwgci} `cw ixmdygi mn|ewnd mn}i} e` roemo woi ginwo|i`ndwu e} }cybow$ woi ~yndefemnwec`} }ondd i~ynd cq ixmiig woi ke`ekyk nwwcq`iu ~yndefemnwec`} }iw auwoi qibec`nd }idimwec` mckkewwii n`g woi nwwcq`iu}mcviqig au woi mc`wqnmw }ondd ai qi~yeqig wc ai c`woi de}w cf nwwcq`iu} n||qcvig au woi qibec`nd}idimwec` mckkewwii wc qi|qi}i`w mdei`w} e` mn|ewndmn}i}. Ef n mc`wqnmw mcviq} }iqvemi} |qcvegig aukcqi won` c`i nwwcq`iu$ ~yndefemnwec`} knu aibqngynwig nmmcqge`b wc woi }iqecy}`i}} cf cffi`}in`g inmo nwwcq`iu }ondd ai qi~yeqig wc kiiw n`g

kne`wne` c`du woc}i ~yndefemnwec`} i}wnade}oig fcq woicffi`}i divid/}% fcq roemo woi nwwcq`iu e} n||qcvig wc|qcvegi gifi`}i }iqvemi}.

]im. >27.>5. Gyqnwec` cf Qi|qi}i`wnwec`

Woi mc`wqnmw }ondd }|imefu wonw woi mc`wqnmwcq on} woiqi}|c`}eaedewu wc mck|diwi ndd mn}i} c`miqi|qi}i`wnwec` e} mckki`mig gyqe`b woi wiqk cf woimc`wqnmw$ y`di}} n` nwwcq`iu mcviqig au woi mc`wqnmwe} qideivig cq qi|dnmig e` nmmcqgn`mi rewo Nqwemdi16.<7/h%/1%$ Mcgi cf Mqeke`nd \qcmigyqi.

]im. >27.1<. ]ya}wewywec` cf Nwwcq`iu}

Woi mc`wqnmw }ondd egi`wefu woi nwwcq`iu/}% roc redd|iqfcqk dibnd qi|qi}i`wnwec` e` inmo mnwibcqu cf mn}i mcviqig au woi mc`wqnmw n`g |qcoeaew woi}ya}wewywec` cf cwoiq nwwcq`iu} rewocyw |qecq n||qcvndau n knhcqewu cf woi n||ce`we`b nywocqewu. @cwoe`b e`woi mc`wqnmw }ondd |qcoeaew n` nwwcq`iu mcviqig au woimc`wqnmw fqck aie`b qideivig cq qi|dnmig e`nmmcqgn`mi rewo Nqwemdi 16.<7/h%/1% cf woi Mcgi cf Mqeke`nd \qcmigyqi.

]im. >27.1>. Mn}idcng Dekewnwec`}

Woi mc`wqnmw }ondd }iw woi knxekyk `ykaiq cf mn}i} cq rcqjdcng inmo nwwcq`iu knu ai qi~yeqig wcon`gdi |yq}yn`w wc woi mc`wqnmw. 

]im. >27.11. ]wn`gnqg} cf Qi|qi}i`wnwec`

Woi mc`wqnmw }ondd qi~yeqi wonw woi mc`wqnmwcq |qcvegiindcy} dibnd qi|qi}i`wnwec` wc ndd mdei`w} e` n|qcfi}}ec`nd$ }jeddig kn``iq mc`}e}wi`w rewo ndd

Page 69: Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

7/30/2019 Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fair-defense-law-dec-2011-tidc 69/76

 

6=

n||demnadi dnr} n`g woi Wixn} Ge}me|de`nqu Qydi} cf \qcfi}}ec`nd Mc`gymw.

]im. >27.1=. Mc`fdemw} cf E`wiqi}w

Woi mc`wqnmw }ondd }wnwi n |cdemu wc n}}yqi wonw woimc`wqnmwcq n`g ew} nwwcq`iu} gc `cw |qcvegiqi|qi}i`wnwec` wc gifi`gn`w} roi` gce`b }c rcydge`vcdvi n mc`fdemw cf e`wiqi}w.

]im. >27.17. E`vi}webnwcq} n`g Ix|iqw}

Woi mc`wqnmw }ondd }|imefu ocr e`vi}webnwec` }iqvemi}n`g ix|iqw} wonw nqi `imi}}nqu wc |qcvegi mck|iwi`wqi|qi}i`wnwec` redd ai kngi nvnednadi e` n kn``iq mc`}e}wi`w rewo Nqwemdi 16.<9/g%$ Mcgi cf Mqeke`nd\qcmigyqi.

]im. >27.19. Mck|i`}nwec` n`g \nuki`w\qcmi}}i}

Woi mc`wqnmw }ondd }iw woi nkcy`w cf mck|i`}nwec`wc ai |neg wc woi mc`wqnmwcq n`g woi gi}eb`nwigkiwocg n`g weke`b cf |nuki`w. Woi mc`wqnmw }ondd}wnwi wonw woi mc`wqnmwcq }ondd ai qi~yeqig wc }yakewn` ewikeig fii vcymoiq. Woi vcymoiq ky}w ain||qcvig au n kikaiq cf woi n||ce`we`b nywocqewu|qecq wc aie`b fcqrnqgig wc woi mcy`wu fe`n`mendcffemiq fcq n||qcvnd n`g |nuki`w. Woi mc`wqnmw }onddnd}c }|imefu ocr n mc`wqnmwcq e} wc ai mck|i`}nwigfcq mn}i} n}}eb`ig ayw `cw ge}|c}ig rewoe` woi wiqkcf woi mc`wqnmw n} |qcvegig e` ¢>27.>5 cf woe}}yamon|wiq.

]yamon|wiq M. \cdemu Kc`ewcqe`b Qi~yeqiki`w}

Geve}ec` >. Gife`ewec`}

]im. >27.16. ]yamon|wiq Gife`ewec`}

Woi fcddcre`b rcqg} n`g wiqk} roi` y}ig e` woe}}yamon|wiq }ondd onvi woi fcddcre`b kin`e`b}$y`di}} woi mc`wixw mdinqdu e`gemnwi} cwoiqre}i.

/>% Geqimwcq++Woi geqimwcq cf woi Wn}j Fcqmi.

/1% \qcbqnk Geqimwcq++Woi dcmnd cffemiq cq ik|dcuii gi}eb`nwig y`giq ¢>2=.=<> cf woe}wewdi.

/=% \iqecg cf qiveir++Woi >1 kc`wo} |qimige`bwoi gnwi cf woi kc`ewcqe`b ve}ew.

/7% \cdemei} n`g ]wn`gnqg} Mckkewwii++Nmckkewwii cf woi Wn}j Fcqmi monqbig rewo

gividc|e`b |cdemei} n`g }wn`gnqg} qidnwig wcek|qcve`b e`gebi`w gifi`}i }iqvemi}.

/9% \cdemu Kc`ewcq++Woi ik|dcuii cf woi Wn}jFcqmi roc kc`ewcq} woi iffimwevi`i}} cf nmcy`wu"} e`gebi`w gifi`}i |cdemei}$ }wn`gnqg}$n`g |qcmigyqi}.

/6% Qe}j N}}i}}ki`w++N wccd wc qn`j inmomcy`wu"} |cwi`wend qe}j cf `cw aie`b e` mck|den`mirewo e`gebi`w gifi`}i dnr}.

/2% Wn}j Fcqmi++Wn}j Fcqmi kin`} woi Wn}jFcqmi c` E`gebi`w Gifi`}i.

Geve}ec` 1. \cdemu Kc`ewcqe`b \qcmi}} n`gAi`moknqj}

]im. >27.12. Qe}j N}}i}}ki`w

 N qe}j n}}i}}ki`w cf inmo mcy`wu }ondd aimc`gymwig au woi |cdemu kc`ewcq inmo fe}mnd uinq n}woi |qeknqu kin`} cf giwiqke`e`b roemo mcy`wei} reddai }idimwig fcq c`+}ewi |cdemu kc`ewcqe`b. C`+}ewikc`ewcqe`b ve}ew} wc mcy`wei} }ondd woi` ain||cqwec`ig au ngke`e}wqnwevi hygemend qibec`$ mcy`wu}ei$ qe}j n}}i}}ki`w }mcqi}$ |n}w ve}ew} n`g cwoiq gcmyki`wig fnmwcq}. Woi qe}j n}}i}}ki`w }ondd y}in vnqeiwu cf fnmwcq} qidnwig wc woi |qcve}ec` cf e`gebi`w gifi`}i }iqvemi}$ e`mdyge`b ayw `cw dekewigwc woi fcddcre`b8

/>% Roiwoiq n mcy`wu qi|cqwig e`vi}webnwec` n`g

ix|iqw rew`i}} ix|i`}i}:

/1% Roiwoiq n mcy`wu qi|cqwig qiekayq}iki`w}fcq nwwcq`iu fii}:

/=% Nkcy`w cf |iq mn|ewn e`gebi`w gifi`}iix|i`}i}:

/7% Fidc`u$ ke}gikin`cq$ n`g hyvi`edi nwwcq`iun||ce`wki`w qnwi}:

/9% \c|ydnwec` cf n mcy`wu:

/6% Roiwoiq mck|dne`w} nacyw n mcy`wu onviaii` qimievig au woi Wn}j Fcqmi:

/2% Roiwoiq n mcy`wu qimievig n` i~yndenwec`nrnqg:

/?% Roiwoiq n mcy`wu qi|cqwig n||ind} mn}i}:n`g

Page 70: Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

7/30/2019 Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fair-defense-law-dec-2011-tidc 70/76

 

67

/5% Roiwoiq n mcy`wu mck|diwig n vcdy`wnqu }idf+n}}i}}ki`w.

]im. >27.1?. C`+]ewi Kc`ewcqe`b \qcmi}}

/n% \yq|c}i. Woi |qcmi}} |qckcwi} dcmnd mck|den`mirewo woi qi~yeqiki`w} cf woi Fneq Gifi`}i Nmw n`gWn}j Fcqmi qydi} n`g |qcvegi} wimo`emnd n}}e}wn`miwc ek|qcvi |qcmi}}i} roiqi `iigig.

/a% Kc`ewcqe`b \qcmi}}. Woi |cdemu kc`ewcq ixnke`i}woi dcmnd e`gebi`w gifi`}i |dn`} n`g dcmnd|qcmigyqi} n`g |qcmi}}i} wc giwiqke`i ef woi hyqe}gemwec` kiiw} woi }wnwywcqu qi~yeqiki`w} n`gqydi} ngc|wig au woi Wn}j Fcqmi. Woi |cdemu kc`ewcq nd}c nwwik|w} wc qn`gckdu }idimw }nk|di} cf nmwyndmn}i} fqck woi |iqecg cf qiveir au y}e`b n >9)mc`fegi`mi e`wiqvnd fcq n |c|ydnwec` nw n 59)mc`fegi`mi divid.

/m% Mcqi Qi~yeqiki`w}. C`+}ewi |cdemu kc`ewcqe`bfcmy}i} c` woi }ex mcqi qi~yeqiki`w} cf woi Fneq Gifi`}i Nmw n`g qidnwig qydi}. Woe} qydi i}wnade}oi}woi |qcmi}} fcq ivndynwe`b |cdemu mck|den`mi rewo nqi~yeqiki`w n`g }iw} ai`moknqj} fcq giwiqke`e`broiwoiq n mcy`wu e} e` }ya}wn`wend |cdemu mck|den`mirewo woi qi~yeqiki`w.

/>% \qck|w n`g Nmmyqnwi Knbe}wqnwec`.

/N% Woi |cdemu kc`ewcq }ondd qiveir woi dcmnde`gebi`w gifi`}i |dn`} n`g giwiqke`i ef woiuqi~yeqi8

/e% Knbe}wqnwec` rewoe` 7? ocyq} cf nqqi}w:

/ee% Wonw woi qebow wc mcy`}id aimckky`emnwig wc woi nqqi}wii$ woinqqi}wii ai |qcvegig n` c||cqwy`ewu wcqi~yi}w mcy`}id$ n`g acwo ai qimcqgig:n`g

/eee% Wqn`}kewwnd cf woi qi~yi}w fcq n||ce`wig mcy`}id wc woi n||ce`we`bnywocqewu rewoe` 17 ocyq} cf qi~yi}w.

/A% Woi |cdemu kc`ewcq }ondd moimj fcq gcmyki`wnwec` e`gemnwe`b wonw woi knbe}wqnwicq mcy`wu on}8

/e% E`fcqkig n`g ix|dne`ig wc n`nqqi}wii woi qebow} de}wig e` Nqwemdi>9.>2/n%$ Mcgi cf Mqeke`nd \qcmigyqi$e`mdyge`b woi qebow wc mcy`}id:

/ee% Kne`wne`ig n |qcmi}} wc knbe}wqnwinqqi}wii} rewoe` 7? ocyq} cf nqqi}w:

/eee% Kne`wne`ig n |qcmi}} fcq knbe}wqnwi} `cw nywocqeig wc n||ce`wmcy`}id wc wqn`}kew qi~yi}w} fcq mcy`}idwc woi n||ce`we`b nywocqewu rewoe` 17ocyq} cf woi qi~yi}w: n`g

/ev% Kne`wne`ig knbe}wqnwi |qcmi}}e`bqimcqg} qi~yeqig au Nqwemdi >9.>2/n%$ /i%$n`g /f%$ Mcgi cf Mqeke`nd \qcmigyqi$n`g qimcqg} gcmyki`we`b woi weki cf nqqi}w$ weki cf knbe}wqnwec`$ roiwoiq woi|iq}c` qi~yi}wig mcy`}id$ n`g weki fcq wqn`}fiqqe`b qi~yi}w} fcq mcy`}id wc woin||ce`we`b nywocqewu.

/M% N mcy`wu e} |qi}ykig wc ai e` }ya}wn`wendmck|den`mi rewo woi |qck|w knbe}wqnwec`

qi~yeqiki`w ef knbe}wqnwec` e` nw din}w 5?) cf woi|cdemu kc`ewcq‟} }nk|di e} mc`gymwig rewoe` 7?ocyq} cf nqqi}w.

/1% E`gebi`mi Giwiqke`nwec`. Woi |cdemu kc`ewcq }ondd qiveir woi dcmnd e`gebi`w gifi`}i |dn`} n`ggiwiqke`i ef woiu8

/N% ]|imefu |qcmigyqi} n`g }wn`gnqg} fcq giwiqke`e`b roiwoiq n gifi`gn`w e} e`gebi`w:

/A% N||du woi |qcmigyqi} n`g }wn`gnqg} wc

inmo gifi`gn`w e` woi mcy`wu i~ynddu$qibnqgdi}} cf roiwoiq woi gifi`gn`w e} e`my}wcgu cq on} aii` qidin}ig c` aned: n`g

/M% E` woi mn}i cf hyvi`edi}$ }|imefu wonw woie`mcki n`g n}}iw} cf woi |nqi`w cq cwoiq |iq}c` qi}|c`}eadi fcq woi hyvi`edi }ondd aimc`}egiqig e` giwiqke`e`b woi e`gebi`mi cf woi moedg.

/=% Ke`ekyk Nwwcq`iu ^yndefemnwec`}. Woi |cdemukc`ewcq }ondd qiveir woi dcmnd e`gebi`w gifi`}i|dn`} n`g gcmyki`wnwec` wc giwiqke`i ef woiu8

/N% ]|imefu cahimwevi ~yndefemnwec`} wonwnwwcq`iu} ky}w kiiw wc ai idebeadi fcq n||ce`wki`w$ e`mdyge`b woi mc`we`ye`b dibndigymnwec` /MDI% qi~yeqiki`w} }iw cyw e` ¢¢>27.>+ >27.7 cf woe} wewdi n`g n``ynddu wqnmj nwwcq`iuMDI ocyq}:

/A% Qi~yeqi inmo nwwcq`iu n||due`b wc ai c`n` n||ce`wki`w de}w ai n||qcvig au n

Page 71: Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

7/30/2019 Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fair-defense-law-dec-2011-tidc 71/76

 

69

knhcqewu cf woi hygbi} roc wqu mqeke`nd mn}i}nw woi fidc`u cq ke}gikin`cq cffi`}i divid$qi}|imwevidu$ cq au n knhcqewu vcwi cf woi hyvi`edi acnqg e` hyvi`edi mn}i}: n`g

/M% E` woi mn}i cf hyvi`edi}$ qimcb`ei woigeffiqi`mi} e` ~yndefemnwec`} n`g ix|iqei`mi`imi}}nqu fcq n||ce`wki`w} fcq geffiqi`wcffi`}i divid} n} qi~yeqig au Wixn} FnkeduMcgi ¢9>.><1/a%/1%.

/7% \qck|w N||ce`wki`w cf Mcy`}id.

/N% Woi |cdemu kc`ewcq }ondd qiveir woi dcmnde`gebi`w gifi`}i |dn`} n`g giwiqke`i ef woiuqi~yeqi8

/e% Mcy`}id wc ai n||ce`wig fcq e`gebi`wgifi`gn`w} rewoe` c`i rcqje`b gnu cf qimie|w cf woi qi~yi}w fcq mcy`}id e`

mcy`wei} rewo n |c|ydnwec` cf 19<$<<< cq kcqi$ cq woqii rcqje`b gnu} e` cwoiq mcy`wei}:

/ee% Fcq hyvi`edi} `cw qi|qi}i`wig nw woie`ewend giwi`wec` oinqe`b$ iewoiq ekkigenwi n||ce`wki`w cf mcy`}id cq n`cqgiq qi~yeqe`b woi |iq}c` onve`bmy}wcgu cviq woi moedg wc qiwne` mcy`}idef woi |iq}c` rewo my}wcgu e} `cw fcy`g wcai e`gebi`w:

/eee% Fcq hyvi`edi}$ wonw mcy`}id wc ai

n||ce`wig rewoe` fevi rcqje`b gnu} cf woi}iqvemi c` woi moedg cf woi |iwewec` ef woimoedg"} my}wcgen` e} fcy`g e`gebi`w.

/A% Woi |cdemu kc`ewcq }ondd moimj fcq gcmyki`wnwec` e`gemnwe`b wonw8

/e% Mcy`}id rn} n||ce`wig fcq nqqi}wii}rewoe` c`i rcqje`b gnu cf qimie|w cf woiqi~yi}w fcq mcy`}id e` mcy`wei} rewo n|c|ydnwec` cf 19<$<<< cq kcqi$ cq woqiircqje`b gnu} e` cwoiq mcy`wei}: n`g

/ee% Mcy`}id rn} n||ce`wig rewoe` c`ignu cf woi giwi`wec` oinqe`b fcq e`+my}wcgu hyvi`edi} n`g rewoe` fevi rcqje`bgnu} cf }iqvemi cf woi |iwewec` c` woi hyvi`edi fcq cyw+cf+my}wcgu hyvi`edi}.

/M% N mcy`wu e} |qi}ykig wc ai e`}ya}wn`wend mck|den`mi rewo woi |qck|wn||ce`wki`w cf mcy`}id qi~yeqiki`w ef$ e`inmo divid cf |qcmiige`b} /fidc`u$

ke}gikin`cq$ n`g hyvi`edi mn}i}%$ nw din}w5<) cf e`gebi`mi giwiqke`nwec`} e` woi|cdemu kc`ewcq"} }nk|di nqi wekidu

/9% Nwwcq`iu ]idimwec` \qcmi}}.

/N% Woi |cdemu kc`ewcq }ondd qiveir woi dcmnde`gebi`w gifi`}i |dn`} n`g giwiqke`i ef woiu8

/e% E`mdygi n` nwwcq`iu }idimwec` kiwocg:n`g

/ee% ]|imefu roc e} nywocqeig wc knjin||ce`wki`w}$ ronw n||ce`wki`w de}w}nqi y}ig$ n`g n gi}mqe|wec` cf roi` n`nwwcq`iu c` woi de}w knu ai }je||ig$ ef n||demnadi.

/A% Woi |cdemu kc`ewcq }ondd moimj fcq 

gcmyki`wnwec` e`gemnwe`b8

/e% E` woi mn}i cf n mc`wqnmw gifi`giq |qcbqnk$ wonw ndd qi~yeqiki`w} cf ¢¢>27.>< + >27.19 cf woe} wewdi nqi kiw:

/ee% Wonw nwwcq`iu }idimwec` |qcmi}}nmwynddu y}ig knwmoi} ronw e} }wnwig e`woi e`gebi`w gifi`}i |dn`}: n`g

/eee% Woi `ykaiq cf n||ce`wki`w} e` woi|cdemu kc`ewcq"} }nk|di |iq nwwcq`iu nwinmo divid /fidc`u$ ke}gikin`cq$

 hyvi`edi$ n`g n||ind}% gyqe`b woi |iqecgcf qiveir$ woi |iqmi`wnbi }onqi cf n||ce`wki`w} qi|qi}i`wig au woi wc|><) cf nwwcq`iu} nmmi|we`bn||ce`wki`w}.

/M% N mcy`wu e} |qi}ykig wc ai e`}ya}wn`wend mck|den`mi rewo woi fneq$ `iywqnd$n`g `c`+ge}mqeke`nwcqu nwwcq`iu n||ce`wki`w}u}wik qi~yeqiki`w ef$ e` inmo divid cf |qcmiige`b} /fidc`u$ ke}gikin`cq$ n`g hyvi`edi mn}i}%$ woi |iqmi`wnbi cf n||ce`wki`w} qimievig au woi wc| ><) cf 

qime|ei`w nwwcq`iu} gci} `cw ixmiig woqiiweki} woieq qi}|imwevi }onqi. Ef woi mcy`wumn` wqnmj nwwcq`iu de}w mon`bi}$ woi kc`ewcq redd c`du ixnke`i woi ge}wqeaywec` cf mn}i} fcq nwwcq`iu} wonw riqi c` woi n||ce`wki`w de}wfcq woi i`weqi uinq. Woi wc| ><) cf qime|ei`wnwwcq`iu} e} woi rocdi nwwcq`iu |cqwec` cf woin||ce`wki`w de}w wonw e} mdc}i}w wc ><) cf woiwcwnd de}w.

Page 72: Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

7/30/2019 Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fair-defense-law-dec-2011-tidc 72/76

 

66

/6% \nuki`w \qcmi}}.

/N% Woi |cdemu kc`ewcq }ondd qiveir woi dcmnde`gebi`w gifi`}i |dn`} n`g giwiqke`i ef woiue`mdygi8

/e% N` nwwcq`iu fii }moigydi:

/ee% \qcmigyqi} fcq |nue`b nwwcq`iu}$ix|iqw}$ n`g e`vi}webnwcq} e` nmmcqgn`mirewo woi fii }moigydi: n`g

/eee% \qcmigyqi} wc qiekayq}i ix|iqw n`ge`vi}webnwevi ix|i`}i} e`myqqig rewocyw|qecq mcyqw n||qcvnd roi` woi ix|i`}i}nqi qin}c`nadi n`g `imi}}nqu.

/A% Woi |cdemu kc`ewcq }ondd moimj fcq gcmyki`wnwec` e`gemnwe`b wonw woi mcy`wu on}i}wnade}oig n |qcmi}} fcq mcddimwe`b n`g

qi|cqwe`b ewikeig e`gebi`w gifi`}i ix|i`}in`g mn}i e`fcqknwec`.

/g% Qi|cqw.

/>% Qi|cqw E}}yn`mi. Woi |cdemu kc`ewcq }ondde}}yi n qi|cqw wc woi |qcbqnk geqimwcq rewoe` =<gnu} cf woi c`+}ewi kc`ewcqe`b ve}ew wc n mcy`wu$y`di}} n gcmyki`wig ixmi|wec` e} |qcvegig auwoi geqimwcq$ rewo n` ndwiq`nwevi gingde`i|qcvegig$ `cw dnwiq won` 5< gnu} fqck woi c`+}ewikc`ewcqe`b ve}ew. Woi qi|cqw }ondd mc`wne` inmofe`ge`b cf `c`mck|den`mi.

/1% Mcy`wu Qi}|c`}i. Rewoe` 6< gnu} cf woi gnwiwoi qi|cqw e} e}}yig au woi |cdemu kc`ewcq$ woi|qcbqnk geqimwcq }ondd qi}|c`g e` rqewe`b wc inmofe`ge`b cf `c`mck|den`mi$ n`g }ondd gi}mqeai woi|qc|c}ig mcqqimwevi nmwec` wc ai wnji` au woimcy`wu. Woi mcy`wu knu qi~yi}w woi geqimwcq wcbqn`w n` ixwi`}ec` cf y| wc 6< gnu}.

/=% Fcddcr+y| Ve}ew}. Woi |cdemu kc`ewcq }onddmc`gymw n` nggewec`nd c`+}ewi ve}ew wc mcy`wei}roiqi woi qi|cqw e`mdygig }eb`efemn`w`c`mck|den`mi fe`ge`b}. Woi fcddcr+y| ve}ew }onddcmmyq rewoe` >1 kc`wo} fcddcre`b qimie|w cf nmcy`wu"} qi}|c`}i wc woi qi|cqw. Woi |cdemukc`ewcq }ondd qiveir n mcy`wu"} ek|diki`wnwec`cf mcqqimwevi nmwec`} n`g }ondd qi|cqw wc woimcy`wu n`g Wn}j Fcqmi n`u qikne`e`b e}}yi} `cwmcqqimwig. Rewoe` =< gnu} cf woi gnwi woi fcddcr+y| qi|cqw e} e}}yig au woi |cdemu kc`ewcq$ woi|qcbqnk geqimwcq }ondd qi}|c`g e` rqewe`b wc inmofe`ge`b cf `c`mck|den`mi$ n`g }ondd gi}mqeai woi|qc|c}ig mcqqimwevi nmwec` wc ai wnji` au woimcy`wu. Woi mcy`wu knu qi~yi}w woi geqimwcq wcbqn`w n` ixwi`}ec` cf y| wc =< gnu}.

/7% Fnedyqi wc Qi}|c`g wc Qi|cqw. Ef n mcy`wu fned}wc qi}|c`g wc n kc`ewcqe`b qi|cqw cq fcddcr+y|

qi|cqw rewoe` woi qi~yeqig weki$ woi` n miqwefeigdiwwiq redd ai }i`w wc woi |qcbqnk geqimwcq$fe`n`mend cffemiq$ mcy`wu hygbi$ dcmndngke`e}wqnwevi ge}wqemw mcyqw hygbi$ dcmndngke`e}wqnwevi }wnwywcqu mcy`wu mcyqw hygbi$ n`gmoneq cf woi hyvi`edi acnqg `cwefue`b woik wonw nddfyqwoiq |nuki`w} redd ai rewooidg ef `c qi}|c`}iwc woi qi|cqw e} qimievig au woi Wn}j Fcqmi rewoe`>< gnu} cf qimie|w cf woi diwwiq. Ef fy`g} nqirewooidg y`giq woe} }imwec`$ woi` woi fy`g} redd`cw ai qie`}wnwig y`wed woi Wn}j Fcqmi cq woi\cdemei} n`g ]wn`gnqg} Mckkewwii n||qcvi} woiqidin}i cf woi fy`g}.

/9% @c`mck|den`mi. Ef n mcy`wu fned} wc mcqqimwn`u `c`mck|den`mi fe`ge`b}$ woi Wn}j Fcqmiknu ek|c}i n qikigu y`giq ¢>2=.=<2 cf woe} wewdi. 

Nki`gki`w cf /g%/=% n`g nggewec`} cf /m%/>%/M%$ /m%/7%/M%$/m%/9%/M%$ n`g /g%/7% iffimwevi Hy`i =<$ 1<>< / =9 WI_QIB 99>5%.

 

Page 73: Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

7/30/2019 Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fair-defense-law-dec-2011-tidc 73/76

 

62

N||i`gex ” Mon`bi} Nfwiq 1<>> Dibe}dnwevi ]i}}ec` 

Mon`bi} de}wig au ]wnwywiMCGI CF MQEKE@ND \QCMIGYQI]wnwywi Wc|em Mon`bi} Qi|dnmig au8

 Nqw. >.<9> Qebow wc Qi|qi}i`wnwec` auMcy`}id

@c`i

 Nqw. >>.<2> \qcmigyqi e` Ginwo \i`ndwuMn}i

 Nki`gig au OA >676

 Nqw. >7.<6 Ky}w Wnji Cffi`giq AifcqiKnbe}wqnwi

 Nki`gig au ]A ==>

 Nqw. >9.>2 Gywei} cf Nqqi}we`b Cff emiq n`gKnbe}wqnwi

@c`i

 Nqw. >9.>? Nqqi}w fcq Cyw+cf+Mcy`wuCffi`}i

@c`i

 Nqw. >2.<=1 Qidin}i c` \iq}c`nd Ac`g cf Miqwne` Ki`wnddu Edd Gifi`gn`w}

 Nki`gig au OA =<<<

 Nqw. >2.<== Qidin}i c` Ac`g cf Miqwne`

\iq}c`} Nqqi}wig rewocyw nRnqqn`w

 Nki`gig au OA >>2=

 Nqw. 16.<> Nqqneb`ki`w @c`i Nqw. 16.<>> Rneviq cf Nqqneb`ki`w @c`i Nqw. 16.<1 \yq|c}i cf Nqqneb`ki`w @c`i Nqw. 16.<= Weki cf Nqqneb`ki`w @c`i Nqw. 16.<7 \qcmigyqi} fcq N||ce`we`b

Mcy`}id Nki`gig au OA >297 & ]A>6?>

 Nqw. 16.<77 \yadem Gifi`giq e` Mcy`wu rewoFcyq Mcy`wu Mcyqw} n`g Fcyq Ge}wqemw Mcyqw}

 Nki`gig au OA >297

 Nqw. 16.<79 \yadem Gifi`giq Cviq}ebowAcnqg

 Nggig au OA >297

 Nqw 16.<72 Kn`nbig N}}eb`ig Mcy`}id\qcbqnk

 Nggig au OA >297

 Nqw. 16.<9 Mck|i`}nwec` cf Mcy`}id N||ce`wig wc Gifi`g

 Nki`gig au OA >297

 Nqw. 16.<9> E`gebi`w E`knwi Gifi`}i @c`i Nqw. 16.<91 N||ce`wki`w cf Mcy`}id e`

Ginwo \i`ndwu Mn}i:Qiekayq}iki`w cf E`vi}webnweviIx|i`}i}

 Nki`gig au ]A >=<?

 Nqw. 16.<96 Mc`wqeaywec` fqck ]wnwi e`Miqwne` Mcy`wei}

@c`i

 Nqw. 16.<92 Mc}w cf Ik|dcuki`w cf Mcy`}idfcq Miqwne` Ke`cq}

@c`i

 Nqw. 16.<6 Idimwig Cffemend} `cw wc ai N||ce`wig

@c`i

 Nqw. 16.<2 @nki n} ]wnwig e` E`gemwki`w @c`i Nqw. 16.<? Ef Gifi`gn`w ]ybbi}w} Geffiqi`w

@nki@c`i

 Nqw. 16.<5 Ef Nmmy}ig Qify}i} wc Bevi oe}Qind @nki

@c`i

 Nqw. 16.>< Roiqi @nki e} Y`j`cr` @c`i Nqw. 16.>> E`gemwki`w Qing @c`i

Page 74: Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

7/30/2019 Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fair-defense-law-dec-2011-tidc 74/76

 

6?

 Nqw. 16.>1 \din cf @cw Byedwu I`wiqig @c`i Nqw. 16.>= \din cf Byedwu @c`i Nqw. 16.>7 Hyqu c` \din cf Byedwu @c`i Nqw. 16.>9 Mcqqimwe`b @nki @c`i Nqw. =?.=< E`wiq|qiwiq @c`i Nqw. =?.=> E`wiq|qiwiq} fcq Ginf \iq}c`} @c`i

 Nqw. 71.>1 Mckky`ewu ]y|iqve}ec` Nki`gig au ]A >6?>

FNKEDU MCGI ]wnwywi Wc|em Mon`bi}  Qi|dnmig au8

]im. 9>.>< Qebow wc N}}e}wn`mi cf Nwwcq`iu:Mck|i`}nwec`

@c`i 

]im. 9>.><> N||ce`wki`w cf Nwwcq`iu n`gMc`we`ynwec` cf Qi|qi}i`wnwec`

@c`i

]im. 9>.><1 N||ce`wki`w cf Mcy`}id \dn` @c`i

BCVIQ@KI@W MCGI]wnwywi Wc|em Mon`bi}  Qi|dnmig au8

]im. 2>.<<> Gife`ewec`} Nki`gig au OA >297]im. 2>.<=9> E`gebi`w Gifi`}i E`fcqknwec` Qi|indig au OA >297 ¢25.<=6]im. 2>.<9> I}wnade}oki`w cf Wn}j Fcqmi:

Mck|c}ewec`Qi|indig au OA >297 ¢25.<<1 n`g ¢25.<>>

]im. 2>.<91 Ix Cffemec Kikaiq} Qi|indig au OA >297 ¢25.<>=]im. 2>.<9= N||ce`wki`w} Qi|indig au OA >297 ¢25.<>7]im. 2>.<97 Vnmn`mei} Qi|indig au OA >297 ¢25.<>2]im. 2>.<99 Kiiwe`b}: ^ycqyk: Vcwe`b Qi|indig au OA >297 ¢25.<>?]im. 2>.<96 Mck|i`}nwec` Qi|indig au OA >297 ¢25.<>5]im. 2>.<92 Aygbiw Qi|indig au OA >297 ¢25.<==]im. 2>.<9? Fneq Gifi`}i Nmmcy`w Qi|indig au OA >297 ¢25.<=>]im. 2>.<95 Nmmi|wn`mi cf Befw}$ Bqn`w}$

n`g Cwoiq Fy`g}: ]wnwi Bqn`w}Wink

Qi|indig au OA >297 ¢25.<=1

]im. 2>.<6< \cdemei} n`g ]wn`gnqg} Qi|indig au OA >297 ¢25.<=7]im. 2>.<6> Mcy`wu Qi|cqwe`b \dn`: Wn}j

Fcqmi Qi|cqw}Qi|indig au OA >297 ¢25.<=9

]im. 2>.<61 Wimo`emnd ]y||cqw: Bqn`w} Qi|indig au OA >297 ¢25.<=2]im. 2>.<6= Ekky`ewu fqck Denaedewu Qi|indig au OA >297 ¢25.<1<]im. 2?.<<> Gife`ewec`} @c`i @c`i]im. 2?.<<1 I}wnade}oki`w cf Mckkewwii:

Gywei}@c`i @c`i

]im. 2?.<<= N||ce`wki`w n`g Mck|c}ewec`cf Mckkewwii

@c`i @c`i

]im 2?.<<7 Qimckki`gnwec` n`g N||ce`wki`w cf Geqimwcq cf 

Cffemi cf Mn|ewnd Rqew}

@c`i @c`i

]im. 2?.<91 Gife`ewec`} @c`i @c`i]im. 2?.<91 I}wnade}oki`w: Fy`ge`b Nki`gig au OA >297 @c`i]im. 2?.<9= Geqimwcq: ]wnff @c`i @c`i]im. 2?.<97 \criq} n`g Gywei} @c`i @c`i]im. 2?.<99 Mck|i`}nwec` cf Cwoiq 

 N||ce`wig Nwwcq`iu}@c`i @c`i

]im. 2?.<96 N||ce`wki`w De}w Nki`gig au OA >297 @c`i]im. 25.<<> Gife`ewec`} Mqinwig au OA >297 @c`i]im. 25.<<1 I}wnade}oki`w cf Mckke}}ec` @c`i

Page 75: Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

7/30/2019 Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fair-defense-law-dec-2011-tidc 75/76

 

65

]im. 25.<>> I}wnade}oki`w cf Acnqg:Mck|c}ewec`

@c`i

]im. 25.<>1 Iximywevi Geqimwcq @c`i]im. 25.<>= Ix Cffemec Kikaiq} @c`i]im. 25.<>7 N||ce`wki`w} @c`i]im. 25.<>9 \qi}ege`b Cffemiq @c`i

]im. 25.<>6 Ge}mdc}yqi Qi~yeqig @c`i]im. 25.<>2 Vnmn`mei} @c`i]im. 25.<>? Kiiwe`b}: ^ycqyk: Vcwe`b @c`i]im. 25.<>5 Mck|i`}nwec` @c`i]im. 25.<1< Ekky`ewu fqck Denaedewu @c`i]im. 25.<1> Qydi} @c`i]im. 25.<=> Fneq Gifi`}i Nmmcy`w @c`i]im. 25.<=1 Nmmi|wn`mi cf Befw}$ Bqn`w}$

n`g Cwoiq Fy`g}: ]wnwi Bqn`w}Wink

@c`i

]im. 25.<== Ngke`e}wqnwevi Nwwnmoki`w:]y||cqw: Aygbiw

@c`i

]im. 25.<=7 \cdemei} n`g ]wn`gnqg} @c`i

]im. 25.<=9 Mcy`wu Qi|cqwe`b \dn`:Mckke}}ec` Qi|cqw}

@c`i

]im. 25.<=6 E`gebi`w Gifi`}i E`fcqknwec` @c`i]im. 25.<=2 Wimo`emnd ]y||cqw: Bqn`w} @c`i]im. 25.<=5 Ixc`iqnwec` Qi|cqw @c`i

DCMND BCVIQ@KI@W MCGI ]wnwywi Wc|em Mon`bi}  Qi|dnmig au8

]im. >==.><1 Mc`}cdegnwig Fii} c`Mc`vemwec`

 Nki`gig au OA 771

]im. >==.><2 Fii fcq ]y||cqw cf E`gebi`wGifi`}i Qi|qi}i`wnwec`

 Nki`gig au OA >297

WI_N] NGKE@E]WQNWEVI MCGI]wnwywi Wc|em Mon`bi}  Qi|dnmig au8]im. >2=.><> N||demnaedewu @c`i]im. >2=.><1 Gife`ewec`} @c`i]im. >2=.><= \qcmi}} fcq ]yakewwe`b

 N||demnwec`} fcq Bqn`w} n`gCwoiq Fy`g}

@c`i

]im. >2=.><7 Bqn`w Qi}cdywec`} @c`i]im. >2=.><9 ]idimwec` \qcmi}} @c`i]im. >2=.><6 Bqn`w Fy`ge`b Gime}ec`} @c`i]im. >2=.><2 Bqn`w Nmmi|wn`mi @c`i]im. >2=.><? Ngc|wec`} au Qifiqi`mi @c`i

]im. >2=.><5 Y}i cf woi E`wiq`iw @c`i]im. >2=.1<> Idebeaedewu @c`i]im. >2=.1<1 Y}i cf Fy`g} @c`i]im. >2=.1<= Ix|i`gewyqi Mnwibcqei} @c`i]im. >2=.1<7 \qcbqnk E`mcki @c`i]im. >2=.1<9 I~ye|ki`w @c`i]im. >2=.=<> Bqn`w Cffemend} @c`i]im. >2=.=<1 Cadebnwe`b Fy`g} @c`i]im. >2=.=<= Qiwi`wec` cf Qimcqg} @c`i

Page 76: Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

7/30/2019 Fair Defense Law (Dec 2011) TIDC

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/fair-defense-law-dec-2011-tidc 76/76

 

]im. >2=.=<7 Ix|i`gewyqi Qi|cqw} @c`i]im. >2=.=<9 \qcve}ec` cf Fy`g} @c`i]im. >2=.=<6 Ge}mqiwec`nqu Bqn`w

 Nghy}wki`w}@c`i

]im. >2=.=<2 Qikigei} fcq @c`mck|den`mi @c`i]im. >2=.=<? Wiqk cf Bqn`w cq Cwoiq Fy`g} @c`i

]im. >2=.=<5 Vecdnwec`} cf Dnr} @c`i]im. >2=.=>< \qcbqi}} Qi|cqw} fcq Ge}mqiwec`nqu Bqn`w} n`g Cwoiq Fy`g}

@c`i

]im. >2=.7<> Fe}mnd Kc`ewcqe`b @c`i]im. >2=.7<1 Nygew} @cw \iqfcqkig au woi

Wn}j Fcqmi c` E`gebi`wGifi`}i

@c`i

]im. >27.> N||ce`wki`w e` Mqeke`nd Mn}i} @c`i]im. >27.1 N||ce`wki`w e` Hyvi`edi Mn}i} @c`i]im. >27.= Qi|cqwe`b \iqecg @c`i]im. >27.7 Ikiqbi`mu N||ce`wki`w @c`i]im. >27.>< ]yamon|wiq Gife`ewec`} @c`i

]im. >27.>> N||demnwec` cf ]yamon|wiq @c`i]im. >27.>1 N||demnwec` \qcmi}} @c`i]im. >27.>= N||demnwec` Qiveir \qcmi}} @c`i]im. >27.>7 Nrnqge`b woi Mc`wqnmw @c`i]im. >27.>9 \nqwei} @c`i]im. >27.>6 Wiqk cf Mc`wqnmw @c`i]im. >27.>2 ]mc|i cf Mc`wqnmw @c`i]im. >27.>? Ke`ekyk Nwwcq`iu

^yndefemnwec`}@c`i

]im. >27.>5 Gyqnwec` cf Qi|qi}i`wnwec` @c`i]im. >27.1< ]ya}wewywec` cf Nwwcq`iu} @c`i]im. >27.1> Mn}idcng Dekewnwec`} @c`i]im. >27.11 ]wn`gnqg} cf Qi|qi}i`wnwec` @c`i

]im. >27.1= Mc`fdemw} cf E`wiqi}w @c`i]im. >27.17 E`vi}webnwcq} n`g Ix|iqw} @c`i]im. >27.19 Mck|i`}nwec` n`g \nuki`w

\qcmi}}i}@c`i

]im. >27.16 ]yamon|wiq Gife`ewec`} @c`i]im. >27.12 Qe}j N}}i}}ki`w @c`i]im. >27.1? C`+]ewi Kc`ewcqe`b \qcmi}} Nki`gig au =9 WI_QIB

99>5