7/31/2019 Facts Lessons FUKUGIMA
1/80
All Rights Reserved 2012The Tokyo Electric Power Company, Inc. 0
Facts and Lessons of the Fukushima NuclearAccident and Safety Improvement-The Operator Viewpoints-
February, 2012
Tokyo Electric Power Company
7/31/2019 Facts Lessons FUKUGIMA
2/80
All Rights Reserved 2012The Tokyo Electric Power Company, Inc. 1
What I will present
1Overview of the Earthquake and Tsunami- Damages at Fukushima NPSs
-What made the difference between Fukushima Daiichi(1F) and Fukushimadaini(2F) ?
2. How we responded ?
- How the accident developed
- What difficulties existed
3. Other Relevant Items-Accident Management
-Presumption of Reactor Core State by Analysis Code
-Hydrogen Explosion
-Spent Fuel Pool
4. Current Status and Roadmap toward Decommissioning
5. Lessons Learned and Countermeasures
7/31/2019 Facts Lessons FUKUGIMA
3/80
All Rights Reserved 2012The Tokyo Electric Power Company, Inc. 2
Overview of the Earthquake and Tsunami
Unit 6Unit 5Unit 1Unit 2
Unit 3Unit 4
Unit 1Unit 2
Unit 3Unit 4
Fukushma Daiichi(1F) Fukushma Daini(2F)
7/31/2019 Facts Lessons FUKUGIMA
4/80
All Rights Reserved 2012The Tokyo Electric Power Company, Inc. 3
Overview of Fukushima Daiichi NPS (1F)
and Fukushima Daini NPS (2F)
Plant UnitIn
Operation
Since
Plant
Type
PowerOutput
(MWe)
Main
ContractorPre-earthquake Status
1F
1 1971.3 BWR-3 460 GE Operating
2 1974.7 BWR-4 784 GE/Toshiba Operating
3 1976.3 BWR-4 784 Toshiba Operating
4 1978.10 BWR-4 784 Hitachi
Shutdown for maintenance
Full core offloaded to spent
fuel pool
5 1978.4 BWR-4 784 Toshiba Shutdown for maintenance
6 1979.10 BWR-5 1100 GE/Toshiba Shutdown for maintenance
2F
1 1982.4 BWR-5 1100 Toshiba Operating
2 1984.2 BWR-5 1100 Hitachi Operating
3 1985.6 BWR-5 1100 Toshiba Operating
4 1987.8 BWR-5 1100 Toshiba Operating
7/31/2019 Facts Lessons FUKUGIMA
5/80
All Rights Reserved 2012The Tokyo Electric Power Company, Inc. 4
Seismic Intensity Distribution Hypocenter Distributionby Earthquake Research Institute, the University of Tokyo
Time: 2:46 pm on Fri, March 11, 2011.
Place: Offshore Sanriku coast (northern latitude of 38 degrees, east longitude of 142.9),24km in depth, Magnitude 9.0 Intensity: Level 7 at Kurihara in Miyagi Miyagi prefecture
Upper 6 at Naraha, Tomioka, Okuma, and Futaba in Fukushima pref.Lower 6 at Ishinomaki and Onagawa in Miyagi pref., Tokai in Ibaraki pref.Lower 5 at Kariwa in Niigata pref.Level 4 at Rokkasho, Higashidori, Mutsu and Ohma in Aomori pref., Kashiwazaki in Niigata pref.
Great East Japan Earthquake
1F
2F
epicenter
Issued at 14:53 onMarch 11, 2011
4th-largest magnitude on record in the world
7/31/2019 Facts Lessons FUKUGIMA
6/80
All Rights Reserved 2012The Tokyo Electric Power Company, Inc. 5
Seismic Observed Data
Observation Point
(The lowest basement of
reactor buildings)
Observed dataMaximum Response Acceleration against
Basic Earthquake Ground Motion (Gal)Maximum Response
Acceleration (Gal)
Horizontal
(N-S)
Horizontal
(E-W) VerticalHorizontal
(N-S)
Horizontal
(E-W) Vertical
1F
Unit 1 460 447 258 487 489 412
Unit 2 348 550 302 441 438 420
Unit 3 322 507 231 449 441 429
Unit 4 281 319 200 447 445 422
Unit 5 311 548 256 452 452 427
Unit 6 298 444 244 445 448 415
2F
Unit 1 254 230
305 434 434 512
Unit 2 243 196 232 428 429 504
Unit 3 277 216 208 428 430 504
Unit 4 210 205 288 415 415 504
Comparison between Basic Earthquake Ground Motion and the record of intensity
: The recording time was about 130-150 seconds
7/31/2019 Facts Lessons FUKUGIMA
7/80
All Rights Reserved 2012The Tokyo Electric Power Company, Inc. 6
Height: about 10m
Tsunami observed at 1F
7/31/2019 Facts Lessons FUKUGIMA
8/80
All Rights Reserved 2012The Tokyo Electric Power Company, Inc. 7
Flooding in 1F
2011/3/11 15:43Date2011/3/11 15:43 2011/3/11 15:43Date2011/3/11 15:43 2011/3/11 15:44Date2011/3/11 15:44
2011/3/11 15:42 2011/3/11 15:42 2011/3/11 15:43
Date2011/3/11 15:42 Date2011/3/11 15:42 Date2011/3/11 15:43
Tank(Height:5.5m)
7/31/2019 Facts Lessons FUKUGIMA
9/80
All Rights Reserved 2012The Tokyo Electric Power Company, Inc. 8
Damages by Tsunami at 1F
Heavy oil tank
floated
Large sizecrane moved
7/31/2019 Facts Lessons FUKUGIMA
10/80
All Rights Reserved 2012The Tokyo Electric Power Company, Inc. 9
Sea water pumps are all damaged.
Damages by Tsunami at 1F
7/31/2019 Facts Lessons FUKUGIMA
11/80
All Rights Reserved 2012The Tokyo Electric Power Company, Inc. 10
C)GeoEye
Inundated Areas at 1F
Inundation throughout almost all areas where main buildings sited
Units 1~4: Inundation height in areas where principal buildings sited:OP approx. 11.5m~15.5m
(Localized inundation height in southwest area: OP approx. 16m~17m)
Unit 5 & 6: Inundation height in areas where principal buildings sited: OP approx.
13m~14.5m
Almost whole area was floodedFukushima
Daiichi
Unit1
Unit2
Unit3
Unit4
Unit6
Unit5
RadwasteProcessing
building
Elevation of major
Unit-1-4 buildings:
O.P.10m
Elevation of major
Unit-5,6 buildings:
O.P.13m
7/31/2019 Facts Lessons FUKUGIMA
12/80
All Rights Reserved 2012The Tokyo Electric Power Company, Inc. 11
O.P.+13mO.P.+13mO.P.+13mO.P.+13m
O.P.+10mO.P.+10mO.P.+10mO.P.+10m
O.P.+4mO.P.+4mO.P.+4mO.P.+4m
O.P.+4mO.P.+4mO.P.+4mO.P.+4m
3u Emergency D/Gair inlet louver
Location of Sea Water Ingression into Buildings at 1F
Turbinebuilding
Reactorbuilding
Unit 6 D/G building
Unit 5Unit 6Unit 1 Unit 2 Unit 3 Unit 4
Openings at the ground level fromwhich sea water could flow into buildings
Openings connected to undergroundtrenches/ducts where sea water could flow
into buildings
7/31/2019 Facts Lessons FUKUGIMA
13/80
All Rights Reserved 2012The Tokyo Electric Power Company, Inc. 12
Inundated Areas at 2F
Inundation occurred throughout all areas along the sea, but it was not observed tohave inundated over the slope and into areas where major buildings are sited.
Run up of tsunami centered on the south side of Unit 1Inundation height in sea side area: OP approx. +7.0~7.5m
Inundation height in areas where principal buildings sited: OP approx. 12~14.5m
Inundation height in area south of Unit 1: OP approx. + 15~16m
Limited area was flooded
Inflowed
intensively
C)GeoEye
Unit 2 Unit 1Unit 3Unit 4
Elevation of major
Unit-1-4 buildings:
O.P.12m
7/31/2019 Facts Lessons FUKUGIMA
14/80
All Rights Reserved 2012The Tokyo Electric Power Company, Inc. 13
[Overall view of 2F]
(1)
(2)(3)
(1)Tsunami run-up
(2)Tsunami damage in low-lying areas (shallow draft quay)
(3) No damage to the Unit 3 and 4Turbine Building
Tsunami damage at 2F
C)GeoEye
7/31/2019 Facts Lessons FUKUGIMA
15/80
All Rights Reserved 2012The Tokyo Electric Power Company, Inc. 14
Location of Sea Water Ingression into Buildings at 2F
Inside Unit 1 heat
exchanger building
Units 3 & 4
Sea side of turbinebuilding
Openings at the ground level from which sea water could flow into buildings
Openings connected to underground trenches/ducts where sea water could flow into buildings
Heat exchangerbuilding
Turbinebuilding
Reactorbuilding
Unit
1
Unit
2
Unit
3
Unit
4
7/31/2019 Facts Lessons FUKUGIMA
16/80
All Rights Reserved 2012The Tokyo Electric Power Company, Inc. 15
Tsunami Height 1F v.s. 2F
Base levelO.P.0m
Reactorbuilding
Ocean-sidearea Main building area
breakwater
Design basistsunami heightO.P.+5.2m
Site levelO.P. +12m
Water
intake
Safety measures has takenagainst 5.2m Tsunami heightSite levelO.P. +4m
Turbine building
2F
O.P.Onahama Peil
Hx building
Base levelO.P. 0m
--Inundation height apx. O.P. +7.0 ~ 7.5m
49
1F
Assumed highesttsunami water level
O.P. +5.7m
--
Design basis
tsunami heightO.P.+5.7m
Assumed highest
tsunami water levelO.P. +5.7m
Base levelO.P. 0m
Site levelO.P. +10m(Units 1 -4*)
* Site level on Units 5 and 6 is O.P. +13m
Turbine building
Reactor buildingInundation heightapx. O.P. +14-15m
Ocean-sidearea
Main building area
Water intake
Site levelO.P. +4m
Safety measures hastaken against 5.7m
Tsunami height
breakwater
WaterPump
Assumed highest
tsunami water levelO.P. +6.1m
Base levelO.P. 0m
Site levelO.P. +10m(Units 1 -4*)
* Site level on Units 5 and 6 is O.P. +13m
Turbine building
Reactor building-
Ocean-sidearea
Main building area
Water intake
Site levelO.P. +4m
Safety measures hastaken against 5.7m
Tsunami height
breakwater
WaterPump
Inundation height apx. O.P. +11.5 15.5m
7/31/2019 Facts Lessons FUKUGIMA
17/80
All Rights Reserved 2012The Tokyo Electric Power Company, Inc. 16
Differences in Tsunami between 1F and 2F
1050
100150
0
24
6
8
10
12
14
[m]Sea floor
displacement[m]
Fukushima
Daiichi
Fukushima
Daini
Maximumtsunam
iheightm
Peaks coinciding
Tsunami height: High
Peaks not coinciding
Tsunami height: Low
Same amplification rate
Water level
fluctuation from
each blockTime T
Warm colored blocksgenerated massive
tsunami wave heights
Tsunami of various magnitudes at a depth ofaround 150m were amplified at the same rate
and struck at each nuclear power station
Water depth [m]
Postulated Tsunami Source Model
7/31/2019 Facts Lessons FUKUGIMA
18/80
All Rights Reserved 2012The Tokyo Electric Power Company, Inc. 17
Permitted Design Basis(1) Tsunami assessment
Tsunami assessment in construction permit
Fukushima NPSs
Historical tsunamis of Iwate and Miyagi coast were larger than that of Fukushima
Approved design basis at Fukushima NPS was 3.1-3.7m
Fukushima NPSs
3.11.2011 tsunami heights (m)Historical tsunami heights (m)
Preliminary results by The 2011 Tohoku Earthquake Tsunami Joint SurveyGroup( http://www.coastal.jp/ttjt/) 07 May 2011
Inundation
Run-up
Unit Ground Level Tsunami Heightm
R/B,Tb/B
m
Pumps
m
Design Basis Modified in
2002 (2009)
11 march
2011
1F 1-4 10.2 4 3.1 5.7 (6.1) 14-15
1F 5-6 13.2 4 3.1
2F1-4 12 7 3.7 5.2 7-7.5
7/31/2019 Facts Lessons FUKUGIMA
19/80
All Rights Reserved 2012The Tokyo Electric Power Company, Inc. 18
Permitted Design Basis(2) Tsunami assessment
Earthquake Magnitude Earthquake
#1 8.2 1952 Nemuro-oki
#2 8.4 1968 Tokachi-oki
#3 8.3 1896 Meiji-Sanriku
#4 8.6 1611 Keicho-Sanriku
#5 8.2 1793 Miyagi-oki
#6 7.7 1978 Miyagi-oki
#7 7.9 1938 Fukushima-oki
#8 8.1 1677 Enpo-Bousou
htt ://outreach.eri.u-tok o.ac. /e volc/201103 tohoku/#Inversion 2011/3/182011/3/11 source area
English editionhttp://www.jsce.or.jp/committee/ceofnp/Tsunami/eng/tsuna
mi_eng.html
In JSCE- 2002, assumed 8 earthquakes individually. March11 Earthquake occurred over several areas simultaneously.
Tsunami Assessment was revised based on the JSCE (Japan
Society of Civil Engineers) Method,2002
7/31/2019 Facts Lessons FUKUGIMA
20/80
All Rights Reserved 2012The Tokyo Electric Power Company, Inc. 19
Damages of transmission line
& Shinfukushima substation by earthquake
500kV Disconnector 275kV Circuit Breaker
- About 10 km away from both 1F and 2F site
- Important switchgear station from which electricity of 1F & 2F is transmitted to Tokyo area
Transmission tower collapse
CollapseCGeoEye
Collapse of filled soil & sand
Tower collapse
7/31/2019 Facts Lessons FUKUGIMA
21/80
All Rights Reserved 2012The Tokyo Electric Power Company, Inc. 20
4A4B
4D 4C
4E
DG
4B
DG
4A
DG
3B
DG
3ADG
2B
DG
2A
DG
1B
DG
1A
3A3B
3C3D
3SA3SB
2A2B
2C2D
2E
2SA2SB
1A1B
1C1D
1S
Shutdown by earthquake
Shutdown by Tsunami
Power supply of Unit 1-4 @ 1F after Tsunami
The DG lost the function due to either M/C failure, loss of
sea water system, or DG main unit failure.
Okuma Line 1L, 2L: Receiving circuit breaker damaged in earthquake
Okuma Line 3L: Renovation work in progressOkuma Line 4L: Circuit breaker shutdown by protection relay activation
Ohkuma
4L
Ohkuma
3L
Ohkuma
2L
Ohkuma
1L
7/31/2019 Facts Lessons FUKUGIMA
22/80
All Rights Reserved 2012The Tokyo Electric Power Company, Inc. 21
5A
5C
5B
5D
DG
5A
DG
5B
DG
HPCS
DG
6A
DG6B
5SA-1 5SA-2 5SB-25SB-1 6A-1 6A-2
HPCS6C
6B-1 6B-2
6D
Shutdown by earthquake
Shutdown by Tsunami
Survived after Tsunami
Power supply of Unit 5/6 @ 1F after Tsunami
Futaba1L
Futaba
2L
Yonomori
2LYonomori1L
For transmittinggeneratedpower
For transmittinggeneratedpower
7/31/2019 Facts Lessons FUKUGIMA
23/80
All Rights Reserved 2012The Tokyo Electric Power Company, Inc. 22
2F Offsite Power was secured after the Tsunami
6.9kV 6.9kV
Offsite Power
500kV66kV
H STr
Unit #1, 2 STr Unit #3, 4 STr
/
Emergency
Power for Unit #1
/
1H 1A 1B
6.9kV
/ /
2H 2A 2B
/
3H 3A 3B
6.9kV
/ /
4H 4A 4B
One 500 kV line was available.
66 kV lines were outage because of scheduled
maintenance and substation trouble but
recovered.
PPPP
Emergency
Power for Unit #2
Emergency
Power for Unit #3
Emergency
Power for Unit #4
/
P : Cooling Pumps
/ : Diesel Generator
/
P/
P/
P/
P
Tomioka Line Iwaido Line
7/31/2019 Facts Lessons FUKUGIMA
24/80
7/31/2019 Facts Lessons FUKUGIMA
25/80
All Rights Reserved 2012The Tokyo Electric Power Company, Inc. 24
1F Unit 1 Schematic System Diagram (After Tsunami )
Sea
TbTbTbTb
Condenser
H/WH/WH/WH/W
GenGenGenGen
CSTCSTCSTCST
FiltratedFiltratedFiltratedFiltrated
WaterWaterWaterWater
TankTankTankTank
SLC
Stack
Sea
CCSCCSCCSCCS
D/GD/GD/GD/GCCSW
SRVSRVSRVSRV
CRD
HPCIHPCIHPCIHPCI
CPCPCPCPRFPRFPRFPRFP
WWWW
CSCSCSCSMUWCMUWCMUWCMUWC
DD FPDD FPDD FPDD FP
ICICICIC
S/CS/CS/CS/Cvent valvevent valvevent valvevent valve
D/W vent valveD/W vent valveD/W vent valveD/W vent valve
RP
V
from
CSTH/W
Sea
::::Operable
::::Inoperative due
to power loss:::: Briefly
Operative
7/31/2019 Facts Lessons FUKUGIMA
26/80
All Rights Reserved 2012The Tokyo Electric Power Company, Inc. 25
1F Unit 2 Schematic System Diagram (After Tsunami)
Sea
TbTbTbTb
Condenser
H/WH/WH/WH/W
GenGenGenGen
CSTCSTCSTCST
FiltratedFiltratedFiltratedFiltrated
WaterWaterWaterWater
TankTankTankTank
SLCSLCSLCSLC
Stack
Sea
RHRRHRRHRRHR
D/GD/GD/GD/GRHRS
SRVSRVSRVSRV
CRDCRDCRDCRD
HPCIHPCIHPCIHPCI
LPCPLPCPLPCPLPCPMDMDMDMD----
RFPRFPRFPRFP
WWWW
CSCSCSCS
MUWCMUWCMUWCMUWC DD FPDD FPDD FPDD FP
S/CS/CS/CS/Cvent valvevent valvevent valvevent valve
D/W vent valveD/W vent valveD/W vent valveD/W vent valve
::::Operable
::::Inoperative due
to power loss
RP
V
TDTDTDTD----
RFPRFPRFPRFP
from
CSTH/W
CSTCSTCSTCST
RCICRCICRCICRCIC
HPCPHPCPHPCPHPCP
Sea
::::Inoperative
7/31/2019 Facts Lessons FUKUGIMA
27/80
All Rights Reserved 2012The Tokyo Electric Power Company, Inc. 26
1F Unit 3 Schematic System Diagram (After Tsunami)
Sea
TbTbTbTb
Condenser
H/WH/WH/WH/W
GenGenGenGen
CSTCSTCSTCST
FiltratedFiltratedFiltratedFiltrated
WaterWaterWaterWater
TankTankTankTank
SLCSLCSLCSLC
Stack
Sea
RHRRHRRHRRHR
D/GD/GD/GD/GRHRS
SRVSRVSRVSRV
CRDCRDCRDCRD
HPCIHPCIHPCIHPCI
LPCPLPCPLPCPLPCPMDMDMDMD----
RFPRFPRFPRFP
WWWW
CSCSCSCS
MUWCMUWCMUWCMUWC DD FPDD FPDD FPDD FP
S/CS/CS/CS/Cvent valvevent valvevent valvevent valve
D/W ventD/W ventD/W ventD/W vent
valvevalvevalvevalve
RP
V
TDTDTDTD----
RFPRFPRFPRFP
from
CSTH/W
CSTCSTCSTCST
RCICRCICRCICRCIC
HPCPHPCPHPCPHPCP
Sea
::::Operable
::::Inoperative dueto power loss
::::Inoperative
7/31/2019 Facts Lessons FUKUGIMA
28/80
All Rights Reserved 2012The Tokyo Electric Power Company, Inc. 27
2. How we responded ?
- How the accident developed
- What difficulties existed
- What were effectively utilized
7/31/2019 Facts Lessons FUKUGIMA
29/80
All Rights Reserved 2012The Tokyo Electric Power Company, Inc. 28
Status of 1F 1-3 immediately after the Tsunami
Fallen into the Station Black Out (SBO):All safety and non-safety systems driven by electricity were unavailable.
No lights in the control rooms, R/Bs, T/Bs, etc.
No important instrumentations for Unit 1 &2 due to loss of AC powersources and DC 125V batteries; the reactor water level/ pressure,drywell pressure, wet-well (S/C) pressure, etc. ; Operators were totallyblind!
The instrumentation of Unit 3 was available immediately after the tsunami but
only lasted for about 30hours.
Almost no communication tools between the Emergency ResponseRoom and workers at the field: only hotline and land-line phone wereavailable between the ERR and each control room.
The sea water systems were totally destroyed: no ultimate heatsink
P d b h l t t d ld h td ( tli )
7/31/2019 Facts Lessons FUKUGIMA
30/80
All Rights Reserved 2012The Tokyo Electric Power Company, Inc. 29
1F Units 1 - 4 1F Units 5 & 6 2F Units 1 - 4
Progress made by each plant towards cold shutdown (outline)
Units 1-3 in operationUnit 4: outage in progress
[Power supply] Total loss of off-sitepower supply and DG
[Sea water system] Total loss
Water injection using IC, RCIC,
HPCI
PCV Venting, SRV operation
& Sea water injection
Switch to freshwater
Heat removal route has been
continuously improved
Currently the closed cyclecooling is in function
Sea water was initially injected intothe spent fuel pool; currentlyinjecting freshwater
Outage in progress
[Power supply] Emergency DG 6Bstart up
[Sea water system] Total loss
3/19
Alternative RHRS wasstarted and the spent fuel
pool and reactor were cooled
Water makeup by MUWC
(DG6B power used for
Units 5, 6)
3/20
Units 5, 6 cold shutdown
Installation of temporary RHRS
Installation of temporary power
supply
In operation
[Power supply] One off-site power
supply system secured
[Sea water system] Total loss apartfrom Unit 3
3/12
Unit 3 coldshutdown
Units 1, 2, 4
Water injection using MUWC
3/14 RHR startup
Water injection using RCIC
3/14 Units 1, 2 cold shutdown
3/15 Unit 4 cold shutdown
RHRC motor was replaced
Installation of temporary powersupply
7/31/2019 Facts Lessons FUKUGIMA
31/80
All Rights Reserved 2012The Tokyo Electric Power Company, Inc.
Chronology of Accident (Fukushima Daiichi)
Unit 1 Unit 2 Unit 3 Unit 4 Unit 5-6 Common SF Pool
12thStart injecting
sea water
Start injecting
sea water
Start injecting
sea water
Switch from
seawater to
fresh waterSwitch from sea
water to fresh water
Recover Main
Control Room
lighting
Recover MainControl Room lighting
13th
14th
17th
20th21th
22th
23th
24th
25th
26th
27th
Reactor cooling
shutdown
One D/G
survived
Switched fromD/G
to offsite power
Fresh waterinjection
Received
electricity from
offsite
Start cooling by
existing system
Recover Main
Control Room lighting
Earthquake
31st
Start watering
(sea water, freshwater)
SF Pool Reactor Power Supply
Start watering
fresh water
Switch from sea
water to fresh water
Cooling by injecting fresh water
March 11, 14:46
Switch from
seawater to
fresh water
Switch from
sea water to
fresh water
Recover Main
Control Room
lighting
Start injecting
sea water
Start watering
(sea water,
fresh water)
Switch from sea
water to fresh water
Rx Building Explosion
Rx Building Explosion
Rx Building Explosion
15th
Suppression Chamber
Depressurization
7/31/2019 Facts Lessons FUKUGIMA
32/80
All Rights Reserved 2012The Tokyo Electric Power Company, Inc. 31
0.000
0.200
0.400
0.600
0.800
1.000
3/11
12:00
3/11
18:00
3/12
0:00
3/12
6:00
3/12
12:00
3/12
18:00
3/13
0:00
0.53MPa abs
0.954MPa abs
0.00
2.00
4.00
6.00
8.00
10.00
3/11
12:00
3/11
18:00
3/12
0:00
3/12
6:00
3/12
12:00
3/12
18:00
3/13
0:00
7.2 8,7.35 ,7.41MPa abs
8.7MPa abs
7.0MPa abs
-3000
-1000
1000
3000
5000
3/11
12:00
3/11
18:00
3/12
0:00
3/12
6:00
3/12
12:00
3/12
18:00
3/13
0:00
)(Amm
)(Bmm
In Operation(Over Scale)In Operation(Over Scale)In Operation(Over Scale)In Operation(Over Scale)
RxWater
Level[mm]
IC
HPCI No Operation
SRV No Operation
FP/Fire Engine
PCV Vent
Fuel Range (A) (mm)
Fuel Range (B) (mm)
Rx Pressure (A) (MPa)
Rx Pressure (B) (MPa)
S/C Pressure (A) (MPa)
D/W Pressure (B) (MPa)
19:04Sea Water
Order for Vent Preparation 0:06
4:00 Fresh Water 80t 14:53
18:18 - 2521:3014:52
Earthquake
14:46
Tunami
15:27
Operation Unclear
Order for Vent 8:03 14:30 D/W Pr decrease confirmed
Unit 1 R/B
Explosion 15:36
Core Damage Started due to
MAAP Analysis
RxPressure
[MPa]
D/W&
S/C
Pressure[MPa]
1F Unit 1 Plant Parameter and Operation
0(TAF)
Rx water level data revealed incorrect afterward
7/31/2019 Facts Lessons FUKUGIMA
33/80
All Rights Reserved 2012The Tokyo Electric Power Company, Inc. 32
-4000
-2000
0
2000
4000
6000
3/11
12:00
3/11
18:00
3/12
0:00
3/12
6:00
3/12
12:00
3/12
18:00
3/13
0:00
3/13
6:00
3/13
12:00
3/13
18:00
3/14
0:00
3/14
6:00
3/14
12:00
3/14
18:00
3/15
0:00
3/15
6:00
3/15
12:00
3/15
18:00
3/16
0:00
In Operation (Over Scal e)In O eration (Over ScaleIn O eration (Over ScaleIn Operation (Over Scale)
0.00
2.00
4.00
6.00
8.00
10.00
3/11
12:00
3/11
18:00
3/12
0:00
3/12
6:00
3/12
12:00
3/12
18:00
3/13
0:00
3/13
6:00
3/13
12:00
3/13
18:00
3/14
0:00
3/14
6:00
3/14
12:00
3/14
18:00
3/15
0:00
3/15
6:00
3/15
12:00
3/15
18:00
3/16
0:00
7.44,7.51,7.58MPa abs8.7MPa abs
7.0MPa abs
0.000
0.200
0.400
0.600
0.800
1.000
3/11
12:00
3/11
18:00
3/12
0:00
3/12
6:00
3/12
12:00
3/12
18:00
3/13
0:00
3/13
6:00
3/13
12:00
3/13
18:00
3/14
0:00
3/14
6:00
3/14
12:00
3/14
18:00
3/15
0:00
3/15
6:00
3/15
12:00
3/15
18:00
3/16
0:00
0.53 MPa abs
0.95 4MPa abs
RxWater
Level[mm]
RCIC
HPCI No Operation
SRV
FP/Fire Engine
PCV Vent
Fuel Range (A) (mm)
Fuel Range (B) (mm)
Rx Pressure (A) (MPa)
Rx Pressure (B) (MPa)
S/C Pressure (MPa)
D/W Pressure (MPa)
19:Sea Water
Order for Vent Preparation 17:30
Depressurization~18:00
Earthquake
14:46 Tunami15:27
(2:55) Operation confirmed
(11:00
Vent LineConfiguration Completed
Unit1 R/B
Explosion15:36
Core Damage Started due toMAAP Analysis
RxPressure
[MPa]
D/W&
S/C
Pressure[MPa]
1F Unit 2 Plant Parameter and OperationUnit3 R/B
Explosion11:01 Impact sound6:00-6:10
Valve Condition Unclear
Order for Sea Water InjectionPreparation 12:05
2Valves Open
Small Vent Valves Opened
(13:25)Out of Service Judged
0(TAF)
7/31/2019 Facts Lessons FUKUGIMA
34/80
All Rights Reserved 2012The Tokyo Electric Power Company, Inc. 33
0.000
0.200
0.400
0.600
0.800
1.000
3/11
12:00
3/11
18:00
3/12
0:00
3/12
6:00
3/12
12:00
3/12
18:00
3/13
0:00
3/13
6:00
3/13
12:00
3/13
18:00
3/14
0:00
3/14
6:00
3/14
12:00
3/14
18:00
3/15
0:00
3/15
6:00
3/15
12:00
3/15
18:00
3/16
0:00
0.53MPa
0.954 MPa
0.00
2.00
4.00
6.00
8.00
10.00
3/11
12:00
3/11
18:00
3/12
0:00
3/12
6:00
3/12
12:00
3/12
18:00
3/13
0:00
3/13
6:00
3/13
12:00
3/13
18:00
3/14
0:00
3/14
6:00
3/14
12:00
3/14
18:00
3/15
0:00
3/15
6:00
3/15
12:00
3/15
18:00
3/16
0:00
7 .44MPa,7.5 1MPa,7.58MPa8.7MPa
7.0MPa
-4000
-2000
0
2000
4000
6000
3/11
12:00
3/11
18:00
3/12
0:00
3/12
6:00
3/12
12:00
3/12
18:00
3/13
0:00
3/13
6:00
3/13
12:00
3/13
18:00
3/14
0:00
3/14
6:00
3/14
12:00
3/14
18:00
3/15
0:00
3/15
6:00
3/15
12:00
3/15
18:00
3/16
0:00
In O peration(Over Scale)In O peration(Over Scale )In O peration(Over Scale)In O peration(Over Scale )
RxWater
Level[mm]
RCIC
HPCI
SRV
D/D-FP
FP/Fire Engine
PCV Vent
Fuel Range (A) (mm)
Fuel Range (B) (mm)
Fuel Range (mm)
Wide Range (mm)
Rx Pressure (A) (MPa)
Rx Pressure (B) (MPa)
S/C Pressure (MPa)
D/W Pressure (MPa)
16:30Sea WaterOrder for Vent Preparation 17:30
Earthquake
14:46 Tunami15:27
Unit1 R/B
Explosion15:36
Core Damage Started due to
MAAP Analysis
RxPressure
[MPa]
D/W&
S/C
Pressure[MPa]
1F Unit 3 Plant Parameter and OperationUnit3 R/B
Explosion11:01
Order for Preparation17:12
0(TAF)
(11:36) TripAutomatic Start(12:35)
(16:03)
(2:42) Stop
13:12Sea WaterFresh Water 9:25
(8:41 Vent Line Configuration Completed
~9:08Depressurization
(22:15) Stop due to running out of fuel
After HPCI shut down, water injectionusing D/D FP was implemented, howevernot possible due to high reactor pressure
7/31/2019 Facts Lessons FUKUGIMA
35/80
All Rights Reserved 2012The Tokyo Electric Power Company, Inc. 34
-1000
1000
3000
5000
7000
3/11
12:00
3/11
18:00
3/12
0:00
3/12
6:00
3/12
12:00
3/12
18:00
3/13
0:00
3/13
6:00
3/13
12:00
3/13
18:00
3/14
0:00
3/14
6:00
3/14
12:00
3/14
18:00
3/15
0:00
3/15
6:00
3/15
12:00
3/15
18:00
3/16
0:00
0.00
2.00
4.00
6.00
8.00
10.00
3/11
12:00
3/11
18:00
3/12
0:00
3/12
6:00
3/12
12:00
3/12
18:00
3/13
0:00
3/13
6:00
3/13
12:00
3/13
18:00
3/14
0:00
3/14
6:00
3/14
12:00
3/14
18:00
3/15
0:00
3/15
6:00
3/15
12:00
3/15
18:00
3/16
0:00
7.47 ,7.54 ,7.61MPa abs
8 .7MPa abs
7.0MPa abs
0.000
0.200
0.400
0.600
0.800
1.000
3/11
12:00
3/11
18:00
3/12
0:00
3/12
6:00
3/12
12:00
3/12
18:00
3/13
0:00
3/13
6:00
3/13
12:00
3/13
18:00
3/14
0:00
3/14
6:00
3/14
12:00
3/14
18:00
3/15
0:00
3/15
6:00
3/15
12:00
3/15
18:00
3/16
0:00
0.38MPa abs
0.723MPa abs
RxWater
Level[mm]
RCIC
HPCS No Operation( Inoperative due to submersion of power source and inoperative auxiliary cooling system)
SRV
MUWC
RHR
PCV Vent
S/C Pressure (MPa)
D/W Pressure (MPa)
Earthquake14:46
Tunami15:23
RxPressure
[MPa]
D/W&
S/C
Pressure[M
Pa]
(Ref.) Fukushima Daini Unit 1 Plant Parameter and Operation
0(TAF)
3:50 ~ DepressurizationPressure Control
0:00 ~
3:45 ~
(18:30 Vent LineConfiguration Completed
Cold Shut Down14:46
Overscale
Restoration of RHR system
Major Activities at 1F
7/31/2019 Facts Lessons FUKUGIMA
36/80
All Rights Reserved 2012The Tokyo Electric Power Company, Inc. 35
Work in complete darkness.
Many scattered objects werealso on the floor.
Connected temporarybatteries to recoverinstrumentations.
j
Factors disturbing the recovery work (inside the building)
Scramresponse
Preparationsfor waterinjection
Preparations
for venting
Waterinjection
started
Venting
Deterioratedoperability
due to thetsunami
Due to lack of power sources, initial recovery activities had to be conducted incomplete darkness, without any instrumentation, and without most
communications means.
Major Activities at 1F
7/31/2019 Facts Lessons FUKUGIMA
37/80
All Rights Reserved 2012The Tokyo Electric Power Company, Inc. 36
Instruments were monitored wearing a full face mask with a flashlight incomplete darkness
Supervising at a deputysupervisors desk wearinga full face mask incomplete darkness
Checking indicated valuesonly with a flashlight in
complete darkness
j
Factors disturbing the recovery work (inside the buildings)
Scramresponse
Preparationsfor waterinjection
Preparations
for venting
Waterinjection
started
Venting
Deterioratedoperability
due to thetsunami
Major Activities at 1F
7/31/2019 Facts Lessons FUKUGIMA
38/80
All Rights Reserved 2012The Tokyo Electric Power Company, Inc. 37
Image of mobile power truck
Used batteries taken from cars for recovery of importantinstrumentations.
Put Engine-Generators to provide power for the control roomlightingsand PCV vent valve actuation.
Tried to connect a mobile power truck to P/C 2C with temporarycable. The hydrogen explosion of Unit 1 caused damage of thetemporary cable.
Scramresponse
Preparationsfor waterinjection
Preparations
for venting
Waterinjection
started
Venting
Deterioratedoperability
due to thetsunami
j
Factors disturbing initial recovery of instrumentations and power supply
Hurdles for the work: Darkness and suspensions due
to aftershocks, tsunami alarms, Puddles, openings of manholes,
debris and other obstacles
caused by the tsunami, Influence of the hydrogen
explosions
Major Activities at 1F
7/31/2019 Facts Lessons FUKUGIMA
39/80
All Rights Reserved 2012The Tokyo Electric Power Company, Inc. 38
1. Tried to inject fresh water using the diesel driven fireprotection pump (DDFP): failed. Unit 1: mechanical problem of the DDFP Unit 2: the DDFP was flooded
Unit 3: the RPV pressure was too high2. Injection of fresh water from underground water tank
(16units/site40m3/unit) using the fire engine pumps :succeeded but did not last for long time
3. Injection of sea water using the fire engine pumps.
Hurdles for the work: Interruptions due to aftershocks and tsunami alarms Damages of the fresh water lines due to the earthquake
Debris and damages of the gates caused by the tsunami R/B explosions (debris, damage of fire engines and other
devices, injury of field workers and fear of another explosion) No lights. Problem with the PHS telephone and radio
communication
Scramresponse
Deterioratedoperability
due to thetsunami
Waterinjection
started
Venting
Preparationsfor waterinjection
Preparations
for venting
Factors disturbing alternative water injection into the reactors
Major Activities at 1F
7/31/2019 Facts Lessons FUKUGIMA
40/80
All Rights Reserved 2012The Tokyo Electric Power Company, Inc. 39
Factors disturbing the recovery work (outside the buildings)
Scramresponse
Deterioratedoperability
due to thetsunami
Waterinjection
started
Venting
Preparationsfor waterinjection
Preparations
for venting
Many obstacles on access routes disturbed access to the field.
Vehicles had to avoid passing over fire protection hoses laid in the field.
Almost no communication tools between the ERC and workers at thefield were available.
Major Activities at 1F
7/31/2019 Facts Lessons FUKUGIMA
41/80
All Rights Reserved 2012The Tokyo Electric Power Company, Inc. 40
Scramresponse
Deterioratedoperability
due to thetsunami
Waterinjection
started
Venting
j
Factors disturbing the Primary Containment Vessel Venting Operation
Self-containedbreathing apparatus
72
AO
210
MO
1
AO
83
AO
90AO
0.549MPabs
RPV
D/W
RPVRPV
D/W
IA
IA
D/W0.528MPabs
0.954MPabs
213
AO
Shift workers operation tomanually open valve
MO
AO
AO
AO
AO
MO
Exhauststack
Closed
Closed
Closed
Closed
Solenoidvalve
Solenoid valve
Cylinder
Cylinder
D/W maximumoperating pressure:
0.528MPaabs
Ruptureddisc Broke at
0.549MPabs
Ventingpressure:0.954MPaabs
Preparationsfor waterinjection
Preparations
for venting
No power source for the MO-valve Manual operation No power source to the solenoid valve Engine driven generator
Low IA pressure to actuate the AO-valve Engine driven air compressor
High radiation level in R/B
7/31/2019 Facts Lessons FUKUGIMA
42/80
All Rights Reserved 2012The Tokyo Electric Power Company, Inc. 41
3.Other Relevant Items
How the Pre-planed Accident Management Worked
7/31/2019 Facts Lessons FUKUGIMA
43/80
All Rights Reserved 2012The Tokyo Electric Power Company, Inc. 42
How the Pre planed Accident Management Worked(The Tsunami was beyond AM )
Facilities Outline Practical use at 1F-13 at 2F-1
Shutdown Recirculation Pump Trip
Alternative Rod Insertion
:CRs are fully inserted
Injecting
water
Alternative Injection by
MUWC /FP
:Injected from AM coupler
:Using Fire engineMUWC & FP aredowned as loss of AC power etc.
Automatic ADS :Manual operated as loss of power
.Containment
Cooling
Alternative Cooling byDrywell Cooler
Restoration of CCS
:Inoperable as loss of AC power
Hardened Vent : Manual operated (preparedline up)
Support of
SafetyFacilities
Interchangeability of 6.9kV
& 480V Power Sources
: Inoperable as loss of power including
the next(1~4) plant (But operable 1F-5,6 BUS tie)
Restoration ProcedureGuidelines (RHR & D/G)
: Cooling and Electric supply facilitiesare Inoperable
no relation couldn't apply partially apply apply
Presumption of Reactor Core State by Analysis Code (MAAP ) etc.
7/31/2019 Facts Lessons FUKUGIMA
44/80
All Rights Reserved 2012The Tokyo Electric Power Company, Inc. 43
Unit 1
Almost no fuel was left at the originalposition, and fuel completely moveddownward after it damaged.
The moved fuel likely damaged RPVand is assumed that most of it had
dropped to the bottom of PCV. Dropped fuel is assumed to have
caused core concrete reaction.
As of Nov.21, water injection isconducted through the feed water
system and the temperature at bottomas well as inside the PCV remainstable below 100.
Therefore, it is evaluated that all themoved fuel is expected to be cooled
directly by water injection. It is alsoevaluated that the core concretereaction has been stopped.
Erosion depth by core concrete reaction:0.65m
Presumption of Reactor Core State by Analysis Code (MAAP ) etc.
7/31/2019 Facts Lessons FUKUGIMA
45/80
All Rights Reserved 2012The Tokyo Electric Power Company, Inc. 44
Unit 2 & 3 Even though the fuel was damaged, it
is assumed that there has been no largedamage of the RPV that would make alarge amount of fuel dropped to thebottom of PCV.
There is a range in the evaluation result
from part of damaged fuel dropped tothe bottom of PCV to Almost all thefuel is left inside RPV.
If the part of damaged fuel were tohave dropped to the bottom of PCV, it
can be assumed that core concretereaction was caused.
Currently, water injection is conductedthrough the feed water system and CSsystem. The temperature in the PCV
remain stable below 100. Therefore, it is evaluated that all the
moved fuel is expected to be cooleddirectly by water injection. It is alsoevaluated that the core concrete
reaction has been stopped.
Erosion depth by core concrete reaction:Unit 2: 0.12m
Unit 3: 0.20m
Hydrogen Explosions at Units 1 and 3 R/B
7/31/2019 Facts Lessons FUKUGIMA
46/80
All Rights Reserved 2012The Tokyo Electric Power Company, Inc. 45
Hydrogen Explosions at Units 1 and 3 R/B
Hydrogen is supposed to have leaked through heat affectedseals on the D/W flange, hatch and electric penetrations.Reactor building
D/W flange
Hatch
Electricpenetration
Move to upper floor bystairs or through hatches
1st
floor
2ndfloor
3rdfloor
4thfloor
5thfloor
RPV
Hydrogen Explosion at Units 4 R/B
7/31/2019 Facts Lessons FUKUGIMA
47/80
All Rights Reserved 2012The Tokyo Electric Power Company, Inc. 46
Hydrogen generated in the Unit 3 reactor back-flowed intoUnit 4 through SGTS line.
AO
AO
AO
AO
AO
AO
AO
AO
AO
SGTS
SGTS
SGTS
SGTS
3------4
1F
3F
4F
5F
GL
2F
4
5 4
Ventinggas flow
Unit4 reactorbuilding
4th level east-sideexhaust duct
4th level west-sideexhaust duct
5th floor south-side exhaust duct
Back-flowgas Unit4Unit3
Exhauststa
ck
Hydrogen Explosion at Units 4 R/B
Measurement Result of Unit 4 SGTS Radiation Dose
7/31/2019 Facts Lessons FUKUGIMA
48/80
All Rights Reserved 2012The Tokyo Electric Power Company, Inc. 47
Measurement Result of Unit 4 SGTS Radiation Dose
Number of Stored Fuel Assemblies and Decay Heat
in Spent Fuel Pool (SFP)
7/31/2019 Facts Lessons FUKUGIMA
49/80
All Rights Reserved 2012The Tokyo Electric Power Company, Inc. 48
in Spent Fuel Pool (SFP)
Stored fuel assemblies Decay heat (MW)
Irradiated fuel Fresh fuel As of March 11 As of June 11
Unit 1 SFP 292 100 0.18 0.16
Unit 2 SFP 587 28 0.62 0.52
Unit 3 SFP 514 52 0.54 0.46
Unit 4 SFP 1331 204 2.26 1.58
Unit 5 SFP 946 48 1.01 0.76
Unit 6 SFP 876 64 0.87 0.73
Common SFP 6375 0 1.13 1.12
LOPA caused loss of cooling Largest Heat load in Unit 4, but
Rx well and DS pit was full
Water injected by helicopter, fire
engines, and then concrete pumps
No fuel was uncovered in anypools
Now all pools are cooled by heat
exchangers
Unit 4 Spent Fuel Pool Evaluation
Waterlevel(topoffuelrack=0
m)
Conditions of SFPs
7/31/2019 Facts Lessons FUKUGIMA
50/80
All Rights Reserved 2012The Tokyo Electric Power Company, Inc. 49
Unit 3 SFP (Water surface and underwater)
As many debris have fallen into the SFP,the status of the fuel racks and fuels can
not be confirmed.
Unit 4 SFP (Water surface and underwater)
Although some debris have fallen into the
SFP, it can be confirmed that the status of
the fuel racks and fuels are normal.
7/31/2019 Facts Lessons FUKUGIMA
51/80
All Rights Reserved 2012The Tokyo Electric Power Company, Inc. 50
. Current Status
and Roadmap towardsDecommissioning
Inside of 1F unit 2 PCV
Inside wall
Grating
Accumulated Water Processing Facilities
7/31/2019 Facts Lessons FUKUGIMA
52/80
All Rights Reserved 2012The Tokyo Electric Power Company, Inc. 51
g
Process MainBldg.
Turbine Bldg.
Reactor Bldg.
Condenser
#1:91.2m3/d,FDW#2:187.2m3/d,FDW/CS
#3:288m3/d,FDW /CS
RPV
PCVSPT(B)
CesiumAdsorptionFacility
WastewaterSupply Tk
DesalinationPlant
Conc.SaltwaterReceivingTk
FreshwaterReceiving Tk
FiltrateTk Conc.Waste liq.Storage Tk
EvaporativeConcentrationApparatus
BufferTk
High Temp.Incinerator Bldg.
Sludge
Vessels
Accumulated WaterAccumulated WaterAccumulated WaterAccumulated Waterin Turbine Buildingin Turbine Buildingin Turbine Buildingin Turbine Building
Cumulative treated volume:approx.246,810m3
(As of Feb.21, 2012)
Temperature inside PCV got low and stable
7/31/2019 Facts Lessons FUKUGIMA
53/80
All Rights Reserved 2012The Tokyo Electric Power Company, Inc. 52
Monitoring Data (at Site Boundary of Fukushima Daiichi)
7/31/2019 Facts Lessons FUKUGIMA
54/80
All Rights Reserved 2012The Tokyo Electric Power Company, Inc. 53
:Sv/h as of 0:00 onJan. 16th , 2012Dose Rate Trend at the Site Boundary of
Fukushima Daiichi
Monitoring data at the site boundary of Fukushima Daiichi shows continuous decrease at
each monitoring post.Air dose rate measured at on-
site monitoring posts
WestGate
Main Gate
Unit1Unit2Unit3
Unit4
Monitoring Post(MP-1~8)Temporary Monitoring Post
Unit6Unit5
67
88
32
14
11
12
194
11284
27
7/31/2019 Facts Lessons FUKUGIMA
55/80
Mid-and long term Roadmap towards the Decommissioning(1/2)
7/31/2019 Facts Lessons FUKUGIMA
56/80
All Rights Reserved 2012The Tokyo Electric Power Company, Inc. 55
Period to the commencement of the fuel removal from
the Spent Fuel Pools (Within 2 years)-Commence the removal of fuels from the spent fuel pools(Unit 4 in 2 years)
-Reduce the radiation impact due to additional emissionsfrom the whole site and radioactive waste generated after theaccident (secondary waste materials via water processingand debris etc.) Thus maintain an effective radiation dose of
less than 1 mSv/yr at the site boundaries caused by theaforementioned.
-Maintain stable reactor cooling and accumulated waterprocessing and improve their credibility.
-Commence R&D and decontamination towards the removal
of fuel debris-Commence R&D of radioactive waste processing anddisposal
-Condition equivalent tocold shutdown
-Significant Suppression of
Emissions
Step 1,2 Phase 1
Dec. 16th 2011(Step 2 Completed) Within 2 years
Actions towards systematic staff training and allocation, improving motivation, and
securing worker safety will be continuously implemented.
Mid-and long term Roadmap towards the Decommissioning(2/2)
7/31/2019 Facts Lessons FUKUGIMA
57/80
All Rights Reserved 2012The Tokyo Electric Power Company, Inc. 56
Within 2 years
Period to the end of thedecommissioning(In 30-40 years)
Phase 3
Within 10 years Within 30-40 years
Period to the commencement of the removal offuel debris (Within 10 years)
-Complete the fuel removal from the spent fuel
pools at all Units
-Complete preparations for the removal of fuel
debris such as decontaminating the insides of the
buildings, restoring the PCVs and filling the PCVs
with water. Then commence the removal of fueldebris (Target: within 10 years)
-Continue stable reactor cooling
-Complete the processing of accumulated water
-Continue R&D on radioactive waste processing
and disposal, and commence R&D on the reactor
facilities decommission
-Complete the fuel debris removal(in 20-25 years)
-Complete the decommission (in 30-
40 years)
-Implement radioactive waste
Actions towards systematic staff training and allocation, improving motivation, and
securing worker safety will be continuously implemented.
Phase 2
7/31/2019 Facts Lessons FUKUGIMA
58/80
All Rights Reserved 2012The Tokyo Electric Power Company, Inc. 57
5.Lessons Learned and Countermeasures
Lessons Learned and Countermeasures
7/31/2019 Facts Lessons FUKUGIMA
59/80
All Rights Reserved 2012The Tokyo Electric Power Company, Inc. 58
Thorough equipment protection measures against tsunami to prevent powerloss and loss of the heat removal function are important.
Preventing the flooding of buildings
Embankment
Flood Barriers & Walls
Preventing the flooding of important equipment
Water tight doors in R/B etc.
Embankment
Flood Barrier
Wall
WatertightDoors
Lessons Learned and Countermeasures
7/31/2019 Facts Lessons FUKUGIMA
60/80
All Rights Reserved 2012The Tokyo Electric Power Company, Inc. 59
Regardless of the initial cause of the accident, flexible alternative measureswith improved applications and mobility to prevent core damage againstlong simultaneous loss of AC and DC power and long loss of heatremoval function are important.
Enhancing high-pressure & low-pressure cooling water injectionManual startup of steam-driven cooling water injection equipment
Preparation ofmobile power trucks and backup water source
Establishment of water injection means using fire engines
Enhancing reactor depressurization
Preparation ofspare batteries and gas cylinders
Enhancing heat removal and cooling
Backup AC power
Preparation ofspare replacement motor for emergency sea water systems
Preparation of a portable mobile heat exchanger (pump, heat exchanger set) Securing power for monitoring instruments
Mobile power trucks
To RHRTo SFP
Sea
Heat exchanger truck
Lessons Learned and Countermeasures
7/31/2019 Facts Lessons FUKUGIMA
61/80
All Rights Reserved 2012The Tokyo Electric Power Company, Inc. 60
From the perspective of defense-in-depth, it is important to takefurther measures in case core damage does occur.
Preventing hydrogen accumulation in R/B
Opening holes on the roof ofR/B (top vent) etc.
Suppressing the release of radioactive materials
Preparation for water injection to the PCV through fire engines, etc
Backup AC power and modification of design to facilitate PCV
venting
It is important to prepare further equipment and auxiliary facilities for
support of on-site response.
Debris removal equipment
Communication methods
Lighting equipment
Protective equipment (protective wears, masks, APDs etc.)
Top vent
Lessons Learned and Countermeasures
7/31/2019 Facts Lessons FUKUGIMA
62/80
All Rights Reserved 2012The Tokyo Electric Power Company, Inc. 61
Without newly built Emergency Response Center, the post-accidentactivities could not have been carried out.
Measures taken after Niigata Chuetsu Oki Earthquake were effective:
Emergency response center in robust building (Seismic isolation,
Shielding, Communication, etc.)
Underground water tank and Fire Engines (3/site)
SlidingSlidingSlidingSliding
bearingbearingbearingbearing
Seismically Isolated ERCSeismically Isolated ERCSeismically Isolated ERCSeismically Isolated ERC
LaminatedLaminatedLaminatedLaminatedrubber bearingrubber bearingrubber bearingrubber bearing
Embankment (Kashiwazaki-Kariwa NPS)
7/31/2019 Facts Lessons FUKUGIMA
63/80
All Rights Reserved 2012The Tokyo Electric Power Company, Inc. 62
Unit 1Unit 1Unit 1Unit 1----4444
: Reinforced concrete wall (image) :Clay embankment image
Unit 5Unit 5Unit 5Unit 5----7777
T.P.+15.0lene
10.0
3.0
T.P.+5.0
T.P.+15.0
T.P.+12.0
T.P.+15.0
T.P.+15.0
T.P.+15.0m line
Gate
Gate
Access road
Access road
Access road
Flooding barriers
7/31/2019 Facts Lessons FUKUGIMA
64/80
All Rights Reserved 2012The Tokyo Electric Power Company, Inc. 63
Flood barrier wallFlood barrier plate
Watertight door
R/B
R/B
LouverVentilation holeDoor
Louver
Flood barrier plate(balcony type)
Flood barrier plate(closing type)
Watertight doors
7/31/2019 Facts Lessons FUKUGIMA
65/80
All Rights Reserved 2012The Tokyo Electric Power Company, Inc. 64
Penetrations sealed with silicon rubber
7/31/2019 Facts Lessons FUKUGIMA
66/80
All Rights Reserved 2012The Tokyo Electric Power Company, Inc. 65
Backup AC Power (Air Cooling GTG & Mobile Power Truck )
7/31/2019 Facts Lessons FUKUGIMA
67/80
All Rights Reserved 2012The Tokyo Electric Power Company, Inc. 66
M/C 1CEmergencyM/C
Air cooling GTG
66kV BUS
Construction Power Tr
4500KVA
Air cooling GTGMobile power
trucks
500KVA Mobile
power trucks
Enhancing Reactor Depressurization
7/31/2019 Facts Lessons FUKUGIMA
68/80
All Rights Reserved 2012The Tokyo Electric Power Company, Inc. 67
Spare cylindersSpare cylindersSpare cylindersSpare cylinders
2222ndndndnd
floor of R/Bfloor of R/Bfloor of R/Bfloor of R/B
Stand-by
System A cylindersSystem A cylindersSystem A cylindersSystem A cylinders
Regular useRegular use
System B System A
SRVs withSRVs withSRVs withSRVs with
ADS functionADS functionADS functionADS function
N2supply
N2supply
Manual switching by lowpressure
Stand-by
System B cylindersSystem B cylindersSystem B cylindersSystem B cylinders
Manual switching by lowpressure
SRVSRVSRVSRV
AccumulatorAccumulatorAccumulatorAccumulator
NO
Temporary switch
TemporaryTemporaryTemporaryTemporary
BatteryBatteryBatteryBattery
Temporary Spare Battery
Low Pressure Injection by Fire Engine
7/31/2019 Facts Lessons FUKUGIMA
69/80
All Rights Reserved 2012The Tokyo Electric Power Company, Inc. 68
Sea water
Fire Engine
FiltratedWaterTankRun outRun outRun outRun out
InoperativeInoperativeInoperativeInoperative
R/B
Coupling for
fire fighting
FPFPFPFP----MUWCMUWCMUWCMUWCTie LineTie LineTie LineTie Line
O O
MCC1C-1-2
MCC1C-1-3
OO
MCC1C-1-5
GTG MobilePowerTruckEmergency M/C
M/C1C
MCC1C-1-2 MCC1C-1-5
P/C1C-1
RHR
MCC1C-1-3
Water Reservoir
7/31/2019 Facts Lessons FUKUGIMA
70/80
All Rights Reserved 2012The Tokyo Electric Power Company, Inc. 69
Fresh water tankFresh water tankFresh water tankFresh water tank
T.P.+13.0mT.P.+13.0mT.P.+13.0mT.P.+13.0m
Water reservoirWater reservoirWater reservoirWater reservoir
T.P+45.0mT.P+45.0mT.P+45.0mT.P+45.0m
18,000m18,000m18,000m18,000m3333Water pipeWater pipeWater pipeWater pipe
Fresh water tankFresh water tankFresh water tankFresh water tank
T.P.+12.0mT.P.+12.0mT.P.+12.0mT.P.+12.0mWellWellWellWell
Alternative Heat Removal
7/31/2019 Facts Lessons FUKUGIMA
71/80
All Rights Reserved 2012The Tokyo Electric Power Company, Inc. 70
Prepared
connector
Temporary Submerged
Pump
75kW
75kW Alternative Heat Exchanger Vehicle
T/BT/BT/BT/B
Sea waterSea waterSea waterSea water
TrTrTrTr
PPPP
To Submerged pumpTo Submerged pumpTo Submerged pumpTo Submerged pump
HxHxHxHx
T/B
Trench
MO
RHRIW Hx (A)
R/B
RHR HxFPC Hx
Alternative HeatExchanger vehicle
TemporarySubmergedPump
Mobile Power Truck
500kVA6600V
Tr Truck
6600V400VTemporarySubmerged
Pump
Sea water
intake channel
R/B
PCV Venting (Ensuring Actuation)
7/31/2019 Facts Lessons FUKUGIMA
72/80
All Rights Reserved 2012The Tokyo Electric Power Company, Inc. 71
IA
IA
Exhauster
SGTS
StackRuptureDisk
SGTS(B
)SGTS(A)
PCVPCVPCVPCV
D/W
S/C
RPV
R/B
MOAO
AO
R/BBF4
Vital UPS
Vital UPSGTG Mobile
powertrucks
P/C1C-1
Emergency M/C
M/C1C
MCC1C-1-1
Vital UPS
MCC1C-1-4
Operation at
Main ControlRoom
MCC1C-1-1
R/BBF1
Manualoperation
SpareSpareSpareSpare
SpareSpareSpareSpare
PCV Venting (Manual Operation at Field)
7/31/2019 Facts Lessons FUKUGIMA
73/80
All Rights Reserved 2012The Tokyo Electric Power Company, Inc. 72
Exhauster
SGTS
Stack
S/C vent prior use
RuptureDisk
SGTS(B)
SGTS(A)
RPV
R/B
OAO
AO
Manual operation possible
R/B
BF1
R/B
BF4 OpenOpenOpenOpen
AO-valvesmodified sothat manualoperation ispossible witha ratchetwrench
PCVPCVPCVPCV
D/W
S/C
ManualOperation
R/B top vent
7/31/2019 Facts Lessons FUKUGIMA
74/80
All Rights Reserved 2012The Tokyo Electric Power Company, Inc. 73
R/BR/BR/BR/B
WireWireWireWire Lever LeverLeverLever blockblockblockblock
Provision of Heavy Machinery
7/31/2019 Facts Lessons FUKUGIMA
75/80
All Rights Reserved 2012The Tokyo Electric Power Company, Inc. 74
Wheel loaderWheel loaderWheel loaderWheel loader
Crawler hydraulicCrawler hydraulicCrawler hydraulicCrawler hydraulicshovelshovelshovelshovel
Wheel loaderWheel loaderWheel loaderWheel loaderWheel loaderWheel loaderWheel loaderWheel loaderWheel loaderWheel loaderWheel loaderWheel loader
Crawler hydraulicCrawler hydraulicCrawler hydraulicCrawler hydraulicshovelshovelshovelshovel
Wheel hydraulicWheel hydraulicWheel hydraulicWheel hydraulicshovelshovelshovelshovel
Image of Light Oil Storage Facility
7/31/2019 Facts Lessons FUKUGIMA
76/80
All Rights Reserved 2012The Tokyo Electric Power Company, Inc. 75
Fixed oilFixed oilFixed oilFixed oilfeed pumpfeed pumpfeed pumpfeed pump
Tank 1Tank 1Tank 1Tank 1 Tank 2Tank 2Tank 2Tank 2 Tank 3Tank 3Tank 3Tank 3
FillerFillerFillerFillerthroatthroatthroatthroat
FillerFillerFillerFillerthroatthroatthroatthroat
FeedFeedFeedFeedthroatthroatthroatthroat
Underground oil storage facilityUnderground oil storage facilityUnderground oil storage facilityUnderground oil storage facility
Other cars andOther cars andOther cars andOther cars and
heavy machineryheavy machineryheavy machineryheavy machineryMiniMiniMiniMini----tanker (900 )tanker (900 )tanker (900 )tanker (900 )
Mobile power truckMobile power truckMobile power truckMobile power truck
PPPP
PPPP
Underground light oil tank(50K:2.4mX11.7m)X3
FillerFillerFillerFillerthroatthroatthroatthroat
FeedFeedFeedFeedthroatthroatthroatthroat
FeedFeedFeedFeedthroatthroatthroatthroat
GTGGTGGTGGTG
GTGGTGGTGGTG
Portable PHS Antenna (Image)
7/31/2019 Facts Lessons FUKUGIMA
77/80
All Rights Reserved 2012The Tokyo Electric Power Company, Inc. 76
650mm300mm
520mm
Storage rack
Door
Fiber cabledrum
IP phone
Cable drum100m
Web camera
(for future)
Junction box
To ERC
PortableGenerator
Switch
Switch
Switch
Switch
IP PHSantenna
Added Monitoring Cars
7/31/2019 Facts Lessons FUKUGIMA
78/80
All Rights Reserved 2012The Tokyo Electric Power Company, Inc. 77
Portable Monitoring PostPortable Monitoring PostPortable Monitoring PostPortable Monitoring PostIonisation chamber type
survey meter
Dust SamplerDust SamplerDust SamplerDust Samplervane anemometer
Portable generatorPortable generatorPortable generatorPortable generator Satellite cell-phone
In Closing
7/31/2019 Facts Lessons FUKUGIMA
79/80
All Rights Reserved 2012The Tokyo Electric Power Company, Inc. 78
Achieved Stable ConditionsCondition equivalent to cold shutdown
Significant suppression of radioactivity emissions
Commenced the phase 1of Mid-and-long-Term Roadmaptowards the Decommissioning of Fukushima Daiichi
Nuclear Power Units 1-4
Phase 1: Period to the commencement of the fuel
removal from the Spent Fuel Pools (Within 2 years)
Implementing measures to enhance safety of Kashiwazaki
Kariwa NPS.
Deployed mobile power trucks, additional fire engines,
spare pumps and motors, etc.
7/31/2019 Facts Lessons FUKUGIMA
80/80
All Rights Reserved 2012The Tokyo Electric Power Company, Inc. 79
Thank you for your attention!