Top Banner
February 20, 2009 Exterior Insulation Foam System (EIFS) - Fire Testing Monte Carlo Casino Fire Item 6.2 Dwayne Sloan
19

Exterior Insulation Foam System (EIFS) - Fire Testing · Exterior Insulation Foam System (EIFS) - Fire Testing ... • UL 790 (ASTM E108, NFPA 256) ... heat fluxes over a 30 minute

Jun 05, 2018

Download

Documents

trankhuong
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: Exterior Insulation Foam System (EIFS) - Fire Testing · Exterior Insulation Foam System (EIFS) - Fire Testing ... • UL 790 (ASTM E108, NFPA 256) ... heat fluxes over a 30 minute

February 20, 2009

Exterior Insulation Foam System (EIFS) -Fire Testing

Monte Carlo Casino Fire

Item 6.2

Dwayne Sloan

Page 2: Exterior Insulation Foam System (EIFS) - Fire Testing · Exterior Insulation Foam System (EIFS) - Fire Testing ... • UL 790 (ASTM E108, NFPA 256) ... heat fluxes over a 30 minute

February 20, 2009p/2

Monte Carlo Casino, Las Vegas - Fire Event

OVERVIEW

• January 25, 2008• 3 Alarm Fire • Estimated $100 million damages• No injuries or deaths associated with this fire event

Page 3: Exterior Insulation Foam System (EIFS) - Fire Testing · Exterior Insulation Foam System (EIFS) - Fire Testing ... • UL 790 (ASTM E108, NFPA 256) ... heat fluxes over a 30 minute

February 20, 2009p/3

Monte Carlo Casino, Las Vegas - Fire Event

Page 4: Exterior Insulation Foam System (EIFS) - Fire Testing · Exterior Insulation Foam System (EIFS) - Fire Testing ... • UL 790 (ASTM E108, NFPA 256) ... heat fluxes over a 30 minute

February 20, 2009p/4

Monte Carlo Casino, Las Vegas - Fire Event

Page 5: Exterior Insulation Foam System (EIFS) - Fire Testing · Exterior Insulation Foam System (EIFS) - Fire Testing ... • UL 790 (ASTM E108, NFPA 256) ... heat fluxes over a 30 minute

February 20, 2009p/5

Monte Carlo Casino, Las Vegas - Fire Event

Page 6: Exterior Insulation Foam System (EIFS) - Fire Testing · Exterior Insulation Foam System (EIFS) - Fire Testing ... • UL 790 (ASTM E108, NFPA 256) ... heat fluxes over a 30 minute

February 20, 2009p/6

Monte Carlo Casino, Las Vegas - Fire Event

Page 7: Exterior Insulation Foam System (EIFS) - Fire Testing · Exterior Insulation Foam System (EIFS) - Fire Testing ... • UL 790 (ASTM E108, NFPA 256) ... heat fluxes over a 30 minute

February 20, 2009p/7

Monte Carlo Casino, Las Vegas - Fire Event

REPORTED CAUSE (based on Clark County, NV Incident Report)

• Fire initiated at the roof surface• Initial investigation revealed that welding and cutting

activities initiated sparks and flames at roof top• Fire involved exterior polystyrene decorative molding• Cause still under investigation

Page 8: Exterior Insulation Foam System (EIFS) - Fire Testing · Exterior Insulation Foam System (EIFS) - Fire Testing ... • UL 790 (ASTM E108, NFPA 256) ... heat fluxes over a 30 minute

February 20, 2009p/8

Monte Carlo Casino, Las Vegas - Fire Event

ADDITIONAL INFORMATION (based on EIMA Investigation)

• Fire involved areas of special shapes & flat wall sections • Fire then involved adjoining EIFS sections

NOTE – The identity of the special shaped material has not yet been determined and made public

Page 9: Exterior Insulation Foam System (EIFS) - Fire Testing · Exterior Insulation Foam System (EIFS) - Fire Testing ... • UL 790 (ASTM E108, NFPA 256) ... heat fluxes over a 30 minute

February 20, 2009p/9

What Is EIFS?

EIF systems (EIFS) consist of:• an adhesive and/or mechanical

attachment of the insulation board to a substrate

• foam insulation board• a base coat on the face of the

insulation• a glass fiber reinforcing mesh • a textured, protective finish coat

Source: EIMA

Page 10: Exterior Insulation Foam System (EIFS) - Fire Testing · Exterior Insulation Foam System (EIFS) - Fire Testing ... • UL 790 (ASTM E108, NFPA 256) ... heat fluxes over a 30 minute

February 20, 2009p/10

UL Standards and Certifications for EIFSExterior• UL 790 (ASTM E108, NFPA 256) - When EIFS used in a

Roofing Assembly and evaluated for External Fire

Interior• UL 723 (ASTM E84, NFPA 255) – Surface Burning

Characteristics• UL1715 (similar to NFPA 286) – Room Corner• UL1256 – When EIFS used in a Roofing Assembly and

evaluated for Internal Fire

Fire Containment• UL 263 (ASTM E119, NFPA 251) – When EIFS Used in

Fire Resistance Assembly

Page 11: Exterior Insulation Foam System (EIFS) - Fire Testing · Exterior Insulation Foam System (EIFS) - Fire Testing ... • UL 790 (ASTM E108, NFPA 256) ... heat fluxes over a 30 minute

February 20, 2009p/11

Primary Standards for Exterior Walls

• NFPA 285, Standard Fire Test Method for Evaluation of Fire Propagation Characteristics of Exterior Non-Load-Bearing Wall Assemblies Containing Combustible Components, 2006 Edition

• NFPA 268, Standard Test Method for Determining Ignitibility of Exterior Wall Assemblies Using a Radiant Heat Energy Source, 2007 Edition

Page 12: Exterior Insulation Foam System (EIFS) - Fire Testing · Exterior Insulation Foam System (EIFS) - Fire Testing ... • UL 790 (ASTM E108, NFPA 256) ... heat fluxes over a 30 minute

February 20, 2009p/12

NFPA 285 – FIRE PROPAGATION (Brief History)

• Use of foamed plastics in exterior application was proposed (late 1970s)

• Full Scale Test - 26 ft high, two-story wall – Became UBC Test Standard 17-6 in UBC (1988)

• Same test was called UBC Test Standard 26-4 in UBC (1994)

• Reduced-scale multistory was developed. Became UBC Test Standard 26-9 in UBC (1997)

• NFPA 285 published in 1998• Current Edition 2006• NFPA 285 – Referenced in NFPA 5000, International

Building Code, and ICC-ES AC219 for Exterior Walls

Page 13: Exterior Insulation Foam System (EIFS) - Fire Testing · Exterior Insulation Foam System (EIFS) - Fire Testing ... • UL 790 (ASTM E108, NFPA 256) ... heat fluxes over a 30 minute

February 20, 2009p/13

NFPA 285 – FIRE PROPAGATION

• Test Specimen – Non-load bearing wall assembly with combustible components; 17.5 ft high by 13.3 ft wide

• Two-story Test Apparatus – test room @ each story• Two gas-fired burners

One inside the first story roomOne inside the first story window opening of the wall assembly

• Burners are ignited to deliver specified temperatures and heat fluxes over a 30 minute test duration

• Conditions of Acceptance – flame propagation and maximum temperature limits

Page 14: Exterior Insulation Foam System (EIFS) - Fire Testing · Exterior Insulation Foam System (EIFS) - Fire Testing ... • UL 790 (ASTM E108, NFPA 256) ... heat fluxes over a 30 minute

February 20, 2009p/14

NFPA 285 – FIRE PROPAGATION

Page 15: Exterior Insulation Foam System (EIFS) - Fire Testing · Exterior Insulation Foam System (EIFS) - Fire Testing ... • UL 790 (ASTM E108, NFPA 256) ... heat fluxes over a 30 minute

February 20, 2009p/15

NFPA 285 – FIRE PROPAGATION

Page 16: Exterior Insulation Foam System (EIFS) - Fire Testing · Exterior Insulation Foam System (EIFS) - Fire Testing ... • UL 790 (ASTM E108, NFPA 256) ... heat fluxes over a 30 minute

February 20, 2009p/16

NFPA 268 - IGNITIBILITY (Brief History)

• Concerns of fire spreading from building to building & ignition of exterior facades was raised

• Commonly accepted piloted ignition of wood – 12 kW/m2

• Early 1990s Ignitibility Research was conducted – Large-Scale & Laboratory-Scale testing sponsored by EIMA

• NFPA 268 published in 1996• Current Edition 2007• NFPA 268 – Also referenced in NFPA 5000, International

Building Code, and ICC-ES AC219 for Exterior Walls

Page 17: Exterior Insulation Foam System (EIFS) - Fire Testing · Exterior Insulation Foam System (EIFS) - Fire Testing ... • UL 790 (ASTM E108, NFPA 256) ... heat fluxes over a 30 minute

February 20, 2009p/17

NFPA 268 - IGNITIBILITY

• Test Specimen – Minimum 4 ft by 8 ft test specimen• Propane-fired radiant panel (3 ft by 3 ft)• Radiant panel calibrated to deliver a heat flux of 12.5

kW/m2 and 1600 degrees F• 20 minute test duration• Observations for ignition of the test specimen

Page 18: Exterior Insulation Foam System (EIFS) - Fire Testing · Exterior Insulation Foam System (EIFS) - Fire Testing ... • UL 790 (ASTM E108, NFPA 256) ... heat fluxes over a 30 minute

February 20, 2009p/18

Summary

• Monte Carlo Casino fire involved EIFS. • True EIFS is defined by a very specific assembly of

components • The material of the decorative shapes at the top of the

structure has not been determined and made public• There are key code referenced Standards for exterior wall

assemblies – NFPA 285 & NFPA 268• UL has performed tests to NFPA 285• UL does not currently have a certification category for

EIFS to these NFPA Standards• Other fire Standards and UL certification categories exist

for evaluating EIFS for Roofing systems, Surface Burning Characteristics

Page 19: Exterior Insulation Foam System (EIFS) - Fire Testing · Exterior Insulation Foam System (EIFS) - Fire Testing ... • UL 790 (ASTM E108, NFPA 256) ... heat fluxes over a 30 minute

February 20, 2009p/19

QUESTIONS