Top Banner
Explanati Explanati on on vers us Meaning Meaning
19
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: Explanation versus Meaning. Why? Why did this little girl die?

ExplanatioExplanationnversus

MeaningMeaning

Page 2: Explanation versus Meaning. Why? Why did this little girl die?

Why?

Why did this little girl die?

Page 3: Explanation versus Meaning. Why? Why did this little girl die?

1. Child stepped onto Rte 22.

2. Truck 450 feet away.

3. Speed 61 mph GVW 38,000 lbs.

6. Effective stopping distance 700 feet

4. Rain soaked pavement = Poor traction.

5. Driver’s reaction time = 1.75 sec.

7. Force at impact = 1200 pounds psi

Page 4: Explanation versus Meaning. Why? Why did this little girl die?

Cause of death:

Cause of death:

Massive traumaMassive traumato spinal cordto spinal cord

Coroner’s ReportCoroner’s Report

Page 5: Explanation versus Meaning. Why? Why did this little girl die?

“Explanation”

1. Cause and effect

2. Evidence - data

3. Stays on the surface- Latin “planus” = flat

4. Answers “How?”“How?”

Page 6: Explanation versus Meaning. Why? Why did this little girl die?

The time-space box

t. s. b.

Page 7: Explanation versus Meaning. Why? Why did this little girl die?

The tremendous successes of science and technology in the 18th century led some

scientists and philosophers to think that everything is

explainable in terms of science.

Page 8: Explanation versus Meaning. Why? Why did this little girl die?

They said that anything that is not detectable and

measurable by science --

anything outside time & space -- is “nonsense,” it doesn’t exist.

Page 9: Explanation versus Meaning. Why? Why did this little girl die?

The only things that The only things that reallyreally exist are exist are insideinside the “time- the “time-

space box”space box”God

Angel

s

Heave

nSou

lEverything else, they would say, is nonsense, make-

believe.

t. s. b.

XX

XX

XX

XX

Page 10: Explanation versus Meaning. Why? Why did this little girl die?

Inside the Inside the box is all box is all you getyou get!!

Page 11: Explanation versus Meaning. Why? Why did this little girl die?

““The TSB is a way of The TSB is a way of seeing the world as seeing the world as

made up only of things made up only of things we can experience with we can experience with

our senses. our senses. It does not allow for the It does not allow for the existence of anything existence of anything

outside time and outside time and space.”space.”

DEFINITIONDEFINITION

Page 12: Explanation versus Meaning. Why? Why did this little girl die?

all around usall around usBut...But...

in our in our hearts, hearts,

in our in our experiencexperienc

eses

there are are there are are unsettling hintsunsettling hints

Page 13: Explanation versus Meaning. Why? Why did this little girl die?

of of other thingsother things going going on...on...

unsettling unsettling hintshints

outside

outside

the

the

box!box!

Page 14: Explanation versus Meaning. Why? Why did this little girl die?

falling in falling in

lovelove

a mother’s love

a mother’s love

for her b

aby

for her b

aby

a beautiful sunset

Page 15: Explanation versus Meaning. Why? Why did this little girl die?

There’s more!

These and thousands of other These and thousands of other phenomena are telling us thatphenomena are telling us that

Page 16: Explanation versus Meaning. Why? Why did this little girl die?

“MeaningMeaning”

1. Beneath the “surface”

3. Mystery

2. Intuition - not logic

4. Deals with the deepest““WhyWhy””

Page 17: Explanation versus Meaning. Why? Why did this little girl die?

“MeaningMeaning”

Beneath “surface” appearances

Page 18: Explanation versus Meaning. Why? Why did this little girl die?

“MeaninMeaningg”

Lies Lies outsideoutside the T.S.B. the T.S.B.

God Soul

Heaven

LovLovee

Page 19: Explanation versus Meaning. Why? Why did this little girl die?

EndEnd