Expanding the Use of Precast Concrete in Texas Bridges EXPANDING THE USE OF PRECAST CONCRETE IN TEXAS BRIDGES Graham Bettis, P.E. TxDOT Bridge Division – Construction & Maintenance
Expanding the Use of Precast Concrete in Texas Bridges
EXPANDING THE USE OF PRECAST CONCRETE IN TEXAS BRIDGES
Graham Bettis, P.E.
TxDOT Bridge Division – Construction & Maintenance
Expanding the Use of Precast Concrete in Texas Bridges
Just the Facts
Total Number of On-System Bridges (Excluding Culverts):
– 21,686
Total Number with Prestressed Concrete Superstructures:
– 11,037 (that’s 51%)
About 90% of New Bridges Built with Prestressed Concrete Superstructures
– 92% in FY 2013
2
Expanding the Use of Precast Concrete in Texas Bridges
Standard I-Beam Construction
3
Expanding the Use of Precast Concrete in Texas Bridges
Standard U-Beam and Deck Panel Construction
4
Expanding the Use of Precast Concrete in Texas Bridges
Precast Concrete - How Do We Love Thee?
Owner’s Perspective
– Inexpensive
– Fast
– Durable
– Redundant
Contractor’s Perspective
– Fast
– $$$*
* Sometimes difficult for Primes to let go of cast-in-place.
5
Expanding the Use of Precast Concrete in Texas Bridges
Concrete Production in Texas
Cement
– Lots of Limestone
– 10 Cement Producers
– Coarse Aggregate
• River Rock
• Limestone
Fine Aggregate
– River Beds (Sand)
– Manufactured Sand (Limestone)
Fly Ash
6
Coal Plants in Texas
Expanding the Use of Precast Concrete in Texas Bridges
Precast Concrete Fabricators – Major Prestressed
7
Expanding the Use of Precast Concrete in Texas Bridges
Precast Concrete Fabricators – Minor Prestressed
8
Expanding the Use of Precast Concrete in Texas Bridges
Precast Concrete Fabricators – Nonstressed
9
Expanding the Use of Precast Concrete in Texas Bridges
Average Bridge Costs – FY 2013
Structural Steel*
– Plate Girders: $126/SF
– Trapezoidal Tubs: $153/SF
Prestressed Concrete
– Tx Girders (Bulb Tees): $65/SF
– U54 Beams: $52/SF
* Must take into account that almost all steel spans are long and
continuous, raising the construction cost significantly. But still…
10
Expanding the Use of Precast Concrete in Texas Bridges
Durability
Extremely Low Permeability
– Fly Ash
– Steel Form Finish
Produced in Controlled Environment
– Self-Consolidating Concrete
– Low Water-to-Cement Ratio
– Moist Curing
– QC/QA
– Repair and Rejection – Plant vs. Job Site
11
Expanding the Use of Precast Concrete in Texas Bridges
Curing
12
Expanding the Use of Precast Concrete in Texas Bridges
Permeability
13
Expanding the Use of Precast Concrete in Texas Bridges
Not All Concrete Cracks
14
Expanding the Use of Precast Concrete in Texas Bridges
Conventional Concrete Deterioration
15
Expanding the Use of Precast Concrete in Texas Bridges
Conventional Concrete Deterioration
16
Expanding the Use of Precast Concrete in Texas Bridges
Conventional Concrete Deterioration
17
Expanding the Use of Precast Concrete in Texas Bridges
Conventional Concrete Deterioration
18
Expanding the Use of Precast Concrete in Texas Bridges
Conventional Concrete Deterioration
19
Expanding the Use of Precast Concrete in Texas Bridges
Structural Steel Deterioration
20
Expanding the Use of Precast Concrete in Texas Bridges
Structural Steel Deterioration
21
Expanding the Use of Precast Concrete in Texas Bridges
Structural Steel Deterioration
22
Expanding the Use of Precast Concrete in Texas Bridges
High Performance Concrete
Item 421: Hydraulic Cement Concrete
8 Mix Design Options
HPC = Design Options 1 through 5
In Reality, HPC = Design Option 1
– Replace 25% of Cement with Class F Fly Ash
– Applies to All Precast Concrete
23
Expanding the Use of Precast Concrete in Texas Bridges
Precast Concrete
Current, Widespread Usage
24
Expanding the Use of Precast Concrete in Texas Bridges
Standard Precast Items
Prestressed Piling
25
Railing Traffic Barrier
Bent Cap for Steel Piling
Box Beams
Slab Beams
Tx Girders (Bulb Tees)
U-Beams
I-Beams
Bent Cap for Round Columns
Spread Boxes – X-Beams
Sheet Piling
Prestressed Deck Panels
End Treatments
Culverts
Reinforced Concrete Pipes
Manholes & Inlets
Decked Slab Beams
Expanding the Use of Precast Concrete in Texas Bridges
Prestressed Piling
26
Expanding the Use of Precast Concrete in Texas Bridges
Prestressed Piling
27
Expanding the Use of Precast Concrete in Texas Bridges
Standard I-Girder Shapes
28
Expanding the Use of Precast Concrete in Texas Bridges
I-Girders
29
Expanding the Use of Precast Concrete in Texas Bridges
What We’re Doing Now – Tx Girders
30
Expanding the Use of Precast Concrete in Texas Bridges
Decked Slab Beams
31
Expanding the Use of Precast Concrete in Texas Bridges
Decked Slab Beams
32
Expanding the Use of Precast Concrete in Texas Bridges
U-Beams
33
Expanding the Use of Precast Concrete in Texas Bridges
Precast Deck Panels
34
Expanding the Use of Precast Concrete in Texas Bridges
Precast Deck Panels
35
Expanding the Use of Precast Concrete in Texas Bridges
Precast Deck Panels with PMDF
36
Expanding the Use of Precast Concrete in Texas Bridges
Precast Deck Panels to Joints
37
Expanding the Use of Precast Concrete in Texas Bridges
Precast Overhang Deck Panels with Pockets
38
Expanding the Use of Precast Concrete in Texas Bridges
Precast Overhang Deck Panels with Channel
39
Expanding the Use of Precast Concrete in Texas Bridges
Precast Overhang Deck Panels with Channel
40
Expanding the Use of Precast Concrete in Texas Bridges
Full Depth Panels
41
Expanding the Use of Precast Concrete in Texas Bridges
Full Depth Panels
42
Expanding the Use of Precast Concrete in Texas Bridges
Full Depth Panels
43
Expanding the Use of Precast Concrete in Texas Bridges
MSE Panels
44
Expanding the Use of Precast Concrete in Texas Bridges
Existing Concepts
Desire for Expanded Use
45
Expanding the Use of Precast Concrete in Texas Bridges
Precast Bent Caps
46
Expanding the Use of Precast Concrete in Texas Bridges
Precast Bent Caps
47
Expanding the Use of Precast Concrete in Texas Bridges
Precast Bent Caps
48
Expanding the Use of Precast Concrete in Texas Bridges
Precast Bent Caps
49
Expanding the Use of Precast Concrete in Texas Bridges
Precast Abutments
50
Expanding the Use of Precast Concrete in Texas Bridges
Precast Abutments
51
Expanding the Use of Precast Concrete in Texas Bridges
Precast Segmental
52
Expanding the Use of Precast Concrete in Texas Bridges
New Concepts
Current Implementation
53
Expanding the Use of Precast Concrete in Texas Bridges
Long Spans - Existing
54
Expanding the Use of Precast Concrete in Texas Bridges
Long Spans – Trending Upwards
55
Expanding the Use of Precast Concrete in Texas Bridges
Long Spans – Existing Bridge Construction
56
Expanding the Use of Precast Concrete in Texas Bridges
Spliced Precast Girders
57
Uniform Cross Section (Non-
Haunched): 225’ – 240’
Haunched: 325’
Curved Tubs: 240’ – 260’
Expanding the Use of Precast Concrete in Texas Bridges
Spliced Precast Girders
58
Expanding the Use of Precast Concrete in Texas Bridges
Haunched Section
59
Expanding the Use of Precast Concrete in Texas Bridges
Spliced Precast Girders
60
Expanding the Use of Precast Concrete in Texas Bridges
Spliced Precast Girders with Haunch
61
Expanding the Use of Precast Concrete in Texas Bridges
Spliced Precast Girders with Haunch
62
Expanding the Use of Precast Concrete in Texas Bridges
Post-Tension Anchorage Zones
63
Expanding the Use of Precast Concrete in Texas Bridges
Post-Tension Anchorage Zones
64
Expanding the Use of Precast Concrete in Texas Bridges
Post-Tension Anchorage Zones
65
Expanding the Use of Precast Concrete in Texas Bridges
Post-Tension Anchorage Zones
66
Expanding the Use of Precast Concrete in Texas Bridges
Cylinder Piling
67
Expanding the Use of Precast Concrete in Texas Bridges
Cylinder Piling
68
Expanding the Use of Precast Concrete in Texas Bridges
Cylinder Piling
69
Expanding the Use of Precast Concrete in Texas Bridges
Innovation and
Unique Applications
70
Expanding the Use of Precast Concrete in Texas Bridges
Curved Precast Concrete Tubs
71
Expanding the Use of Precast Concrete in Texas Bridges
Curved Precast Concrete Tubs
72
Expanding the Use of Precast Concrete in Texas Bridges
Curved Precast Concrete Tubs
73
Expanding the Use of Precast Concrete in Texas Bridges
Spliced Concrete Tubs
74
Expanding the Use of Precast Concrete in Texas Bridges
Prestressed Concrete Bent Caps
75
Expanding the Use of Precast Concrete in Texas Bridges
Unique Precast Applications – West 7th Street Arch
76
Expanding the Use of Precast Concrete in Texas Bridges
Unique Precast Applications – West 7th Street Arch
77
Expanding the Use of Precast Concrete in Texas Bridges
Graham Bettis, P.E.
TxDOT Bridge Division - Field Operations Section
Construction & Maintenance Group
Office: 512-416-2526
Mobile: 512-658-1231