Top Banner
Evolution (II)
13

Evolution (II). Common Fallacies about Evolution Progressivism Fallacy Teleology Fallacy (Purposivism Fallacy)

Dec 20, 2015

Download

Documents

Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: Evolution (II). Common Fallacies about Evolution Progressivism Fallacy Teleology Fallacy (Purposivism Fallacy)

Evolution (II)

Page 2: Evolution (II). Common Fallacies about Evolution Progressivism Fallacy Teleology Fallacy (Purposivism Fallacy)

Common Fallacies about Evolution

• Progressivism Fallacy

• Teleology Fallacy (Purposivism Fallacy)

<-HUMAN

Page 3: Evolution (II). Common Fallacies about Evolution Progressivism Fallacy Teleology Fallacy (Purposivism Fallacy)

How Fast is Evolution?

• Gradualism Hypothesis

(Charles Darwin)

• Punctuated Equilibrium Hypothesis (Stephen Jay Gould and Niles Eldrege)

Page 4: Evolution (II). Common Fallacies about Evolution Progressivism Fallacy Teleology Fallacy (Purposivism Fallacy)

DARWIN’S FINCHES

Page 5: Evolution (II). Common Fallacies about Evolution Progressivism Fallacy Teleology Fallacy (Purposivism Fallacy)

Natural Selection in Action*

Page 6: Evolution (II). Common Fallacies about Evolution Progressivism Fallacy Teleology Fallacy (Purposivism Fallacy)

Daphne Major

Normal year Drought year

Page 7: Evolution (II). Common Fallacies about Evolution Progressivism Fallacy Teleology Fallacy (Purposivism Fallacy)

The story of the ground finch

• Medium Ground Finch (Geospiza fortis)

• Seed Eater

• Every year on Daphne all the birds are caught and measured

• Their food size is measured

Ground finch

Page 8: Evolution (II). Common Fallacies about Evolution Progressivism Fallacy Teleology Fallacy (Purposivism Fallacy)

Beak Depth is Inherited

Page 9: Evolution (II). Common Fallacies about Evolution Progressivism Fallacy Teleology Fallacy (Purposivism Fallacy)

Figure 01.08

Drought

Seed size and

hardness

Year

What happened to the food ?

Page 10: Evolution (II). Common Fallacies about Evolution Progressivism Fallacy Teleology Fallacy (Purposivism Fallacy)

Drought

What happened to the finches?

Beak size

Year

Page 11: Evolution (II). Common Fallacies about Evolution Progressivism Fallacy Teleology Fallacy (Purposivism Fallacy)

Finch Summary

• Beak depth is a trait that responds to changing environmental conditions

• Beaks appear to be an adaptation for feeding

• Evolution is a process-continually in operation– Sometimes measurable in real time

Page 12: Evolution (II). Common Fallacies about Evolution Progressivism Fallacy Teleology Fallacy (Purposivism Fallacy)

Evidence of Evolution by Natural Selection

• Fossil record

• Age of the Earth

• The mechanisms of heredity

• Molecular biology

• Comparative anatomy

Page 13: Evolution (II). Common Fallacies about Evolution Progressivism Fallacy Teleology Fallacy (Purposivism Fallacy)

The crossing over of alleles between matched pairs of chromosomes during meiosis