Top Banner
Evaluation of Cleaning and Evaluation of Cleaning and Rehabilitation of University of Idaho Well #2 on the Local Groundwater Rehabilitation of University of Idaho Well #2 on the Local Groundwater Well #2 on the Local Groundwater Systems, in the Moscow, Idaho Area Well #2 on the Local Groundwater Systems, in the Moscow, Idaho Area by by Chad C. Opatz Major Professor: James L. Osiensky Ph.D. James L. Osiensky Ph.D.
42

Evaluation of Cleaning and Rehabilitation of … of Cleaning and Rehabilitation of University of Idaho Well #2 on the Local Groundwater ... feasibility study. ¾Attempt to increase

Mar 31, 2018

Download

Documents

lenhan
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: Evaluation of Cleaning and Rehabilitation of … of Cleaning and Rehabilitation of University of Idaho Well #2 on the Local Groundwater ... feasibility study. ¾Attempt to increase

Evaluation of Cleaning and Evaluation of Cleaning and gRehabilitation of University of Idaho Well #2 on the Local Groundwater

gRehabilitation of University of Idaho Well #2 on the Local GroundwaterWell #2 on the Local Groundwater Systems, in the Moscow, Idaho AreaWell #2 on the Local Groundwater Systems, in the Moscow, Idaho Area

byby

Chad C. Opatz

Major Professor:

James L. Osiensky Ph.D.James L. Osiensky Ph.D. 

Page 2: Evaluation of Cleaning and Rehabilitation of … of Cleaning and Rehabilitation of University of Idaho Well #2 on the Local Groundwater ... feasibility study. ¾Attempt to increase

AcknowledgementsAcknowledgements 

PBAC

Jim Osiensky

Tim Link

Gary JohnsonJim Osiensky

Jerry Fairley

J h B h

Gary Johnson

IDWR

John Bush

Hannah Hernandez, Mark Nell, Aaren Fiedler, John Livingston

Page 3: Evaluation of Cleaning and Rehabilitation of … of Cleaning and Rehabilitation of University of Idaho Well #2 on the Local Groundwater ... feasibility study. ¾Attempt to increase

ID

WA

ORID

Page 4: Evaluation of Cleaning and Rehabilitation of … of Cleaning and Rehabilitation of University of Idaho Well #2 on the Local Groundwater ... feasibility study. ¾Attempt to increase

History of Well UI#2History of Well UI#2 

Construction started in 1950 

Completed in 1958Completed in 1958

Sand invasion problems

Production terminated 1964Production terminated 1964

Attempt to place back on line in early 80’s

Page 5: Evaluation of Cleaning and Rehabilitation of … of Cleaning and Rehabilitation of University of Idaho Well #2 on the Local Groundwater ... feasibility study. ¾Attempt to increase

History of Well UI#2History of Well UI#2 

University of Idaho road extension

Proposed well UI#2 abandonmentProposed well UI#2 abandonment

2004 borehole video on well UI#2

Page 6: Evaluation of Cleaning and Rehabilitation of … of Cleaning and Rehabilitation of University of Idaho Well #2 on the Local Groundwater ... feasibility study. ¾Attempt to increase

Well UI#2 Borehole Conditions ‘04Well UI#2 Borehole Conditions  04

Page 7: Evaluation of Cleaning and Rehabilitation of … of Cleaning and Rehabilitation of University of Idaho Well #2 on the Local Groundwater ... feasibility study. ¾Attempt to increase

Proposal of Well UI#2 ProjectProposal of Well UI#2 Project

UI#2 conditions were proposed to PBAC as aUI#2 conditions were proposed to PBAC as a feasibility study.

Attempt to increase flow downward in UI#2 borehole pby cleaning and rehabilitation.

PBAC granted the funding for UI#2 Project starting g g j g2005

Page 8: Evaluation of Cleaning and Rehabilitation of … of Cleaning and Rehabilitation of University of Idaho Well #2 on the Local Groundwater ... feasibility study. ¾Attempt to increase

PurposePurpose

Investigate borehole water movement within the University of Idaho Well #2 to provide a background for comparison to hydraulic effects resulting from the cleaning of the well.

Page 9: Evaluation of Cleaning and Rehabilitation of … of Cleaning and Rehabilitation of University of Idaho Well #2 on the Local Groundwater ... feasibility study. ¾Attempt to increase

General ObjectiveGeneral Objective

Delineate the effects of well cleaning and well development on the groundwater flow systems indevelopment on the groundwater flow systems in the vicinity of well UI#2.

Page 10: Evaluation of Cleaning and Rehabilitation of … of Cleaning and Rehabilitation of University of Idaho Well #2 on the Local Groundwater ... feasibility study. ¾Attempt to increase

Specific ObjectivesSpecific Objectives

Describe the geologic and hydrogeologic controls on groundwater movement in the Moscow Idaho areagroundwater movement in the Moscow, Idaho area.

D l t l h d l i d lDevelop a conceptual hydrogeologic model.

l h ff f l h l lDelineate the effects of UI#2 cleaning on the local groundwater flow environment.

Page 11: Evaluation of Cleaning and Rehabilitation of … of Cleaning and Rehabilitation of University of Idaho Well #2 on the Local Groundwater ... feasibility study. ¾Attempt to increase

Palouse Basin GeologyPalouse Basin Geology

Page 12: Evaluation of Cleaning and Rehabilitation of … of Cleaning and Rehabilitation of University of Idaho Well #2 on the Local Groundwater ... feasibility study. ¾Attempt to increase

Local GeologyLocal Geology

Page 13: Evaluation of Cleaning and Rehabilitation of … of Cleaning and Rehabilitation of University of Idaho Well #2 on the Local Groundwater ... feasibility study. ¾Attempt to increase

UI#2 Site GeologyUI#2 Site Geology

Page 14: Evaluation of Cleaning and Rehabilitation of … of Cleaning and Rehabilitation of University of Idaho Well #2 on the Local Groundwater ... feasibility study. ¾Attempt to increase

Conceptual Hydrologic Model Before Cleaning

C’C

Page 15: Evaluation of Cleaning and Rehabilitation of … of Cleaning and Rehabilitation of University of Idaho Well #2 on the Local Groundwater ... feasibility study. ¾Attempt to increase

Monitoring ProgramMonitoring Program

Monitor ground water levels and ground waterMonitor ground water levels and ground water temperatures in the following:

• Paradise Creek

• Sediments of Bovill

• Lolo basaltLolo basalt

• Vantage sediments

Page 16: Evaluation of Cleaning and Rehabilitation of … of Cleaning and Rehabilitation of University of Idaho Well #2 on the Local Groundwater ... feasibility study. ¾Attempt to increase

Monitoring Program

Page 17: Evaluation of Cleaning and Rehabilitation of … of Cleaning and Rehabilitation of University of Idaho Well #2 on the Local Groundwater ... feasibility study. ¾Attempt to increase

UI#2 Site Geology (Paradise Creek)UI#2 Site Geology (Paradise Creek)N1 N2 N3 fbls

Page 18: Evaluation of Cleaning and Rehabilitation of … of Cleaning and Rehabilitation of University of Idaho Well #2 on the Local Groundwater ... feasibility study. ¾Attempt to increase

Monitoring Program

Page 19: Evaluation of Cleaning and Rehabilitation of … of Cleaning and Rehabilitation of University of Idaho Well #2 on the Local Groundwater ... feasibility study. ¾Attempt to increase

Cleaning ActivitiesCleaning activities began on February 10, 2006 at 08:30 hours 

Cl i i i i d d F b 15 2006Cleaning activities ended on February 15, 2006 at 1700 hours.

Page 20: Evaluation of Cleaning and Rehabilitation of … of Cleaning and Rehabilitation of University of Idaho Well #2 on the Local Groundwater ... feasibility study. ¾Attempt to increase

Cleaning Activities

Conditions in well UI#2 borehole after cleaningcleaning.

Page 21: Evaluation of Cleaning and Rehabilitation of … of Cleaning and Rehabilitation of University of Idaho Well #2 on the Local Groundwater ... feasibility study. ¾Attempt to increase

Problem!Problem!

When did UI#2 start to effect the local groundwaterWhen did UI#2 start to effect the local groundwater flow environment (i.e., injection)?

Total cleaning process was completed over 129 hours g p pspread over the daylight working hours of three days.

Page 22: Evaluation of Cleaning and Rehabilitation of … of Cleaning and Rehabilitation of University of Idaho Well #2 on the Local Groundwater ... feasibility study. ¾Attempt to increase

Physical EvidencePhysical Evidence

In the morning of February 14, 2006 pieces of steelIn the morning of February 14, 2006 pieces of steel well casing were bailed from the bottom of UI#2.

This evidence was considered to be when a change in gflow occurred in well UI#2 borehole.

Page 23: Evaluation of Cleaning and Rehabilitation of … of Cleaning and Rehabilitation of University of Idaho Well #2 on the Local Groundwater ... feasibility study. ¾Attempt to increase

Conceptual Hydrologic Model as a Result of Cleaning 

Page 24: Evaluation of Cleaning and Rehabilitation of … of Cleaning and Rehabilitation of University of Idaho Well #2 on the Local Groundwater ... feasibility study. ¾Attempt to increase

Analysis

Water level data collected in well UI#2

Analysis

Water level data collected in well UI#2

Data collected in sediments of Bovill and Paradise Creek (T6) adjacent to UI#2( ) j

Data collected in local monitoring wells and USGS gauging station.g g g

Page 25: Evaluation of Cleaning and Rehabilitation of … of Cleaning and Rehabilitation of University of Idaho Well #2 on the Local Groundwater ... feasibility study. ¾Attempt to increase

UI#2 Water Level Data AnalysisUI#2 Water Level Data Analysis

Date of hand measurement of wl in UI#2 Water level elevation

02/01/2006  2502.65 famsl*

02/10/2006 note: after bailing ended 2497.48 famsl

02/14/2006 note: after pumping for  2507 famsl50min at 40 gpm

2/22/2006  2502.65 famsl*

03/03/2006 2502 famsl/ /

D iDarcy equation:Q = KIA

where:Q = discharge rate (l^3/t)K = hydraulic conductivity (l/t)I = hydraulic gradient (l/l)I = hydraulic gradient (l/l)A = cross sectional area (l^2)

Page 26: Evaluation of Cleaning and Rehabilitation of … of Cleaning and Rehabilitation of University of Idaho Well #2 on the Local Groundwater ... feasibility study. ¾Attempt to increase

Analysis of Paradise Creek and Sediments of Bovill Water Level

Page 27: Evaluation of Cleaning and Rehabilitation of … of Cleaning and Rehabilitation of University of Idaho Well #2 on the Local Groundwater ... feasibility study. ¾Attempt to increase

Analysis of Paradise Creek and Sediments of Bovill Water Level

Page 28: Evaluation of Cleaning and Rehabilitation of … of Cleaning and Rehabilitation of University of Idaho Well #2 on the Local Groundwater ... feasibility study. ¾Attempt to increase

Analysis of Paradise Creek and Sediments of Bovill Temperatures

Page 29: Evaluation of Cleaning and Rehabilitation of … of Cleaning and Rehabilitation of University of Idaho Well #2 on the Local Groundwater ... feasibility study. ¾Attempt to increase

Analysis of Water Levels in Local Monitoring W ll

Water level rise in local monitoring wells appeared to 

Wells

g ppcoincide with cleaning activities.

The water level data from local monitoring wells were analyzed in AQTESOLV to show theoretically weather or not cleaning activities were the cause.

Page 30: Evaluation of Cleaning and Rehabilitation of … of Cleaning and Rehabilitation of University of Idaho Well #2 on the Local Groundwater ... feasibility study. ¾Attempt to increase

Analysis of Water Levels in Local Monitoring W ll

Theis Equation (1935) for a confined aquifer system

Wells

Theis Equation (1935) for a confined aquifer system where:s = Drawdown [L]Q = Pumping rate [L^3/T]Q Pumping rate [L 3/T]T = Transmissivity [L^2/T]t = timeS = Storativity [dimensionless]r = Radial distance from

P mping ell [L]

Additi l ti

Pumping well [L]W(u) = The well function of u

Additional assumptions: 1) Injection can be treated as pumping in AQTESOLV by changing the sign of

the water level displacements. 2) D i ti f th Th i (1935) ti d t i ifi tl2) Deviations from the Theis (1935) assumptions do not significantly 

affect the analysis.  

Page 31: Evaluation of Cleaning and Rehabilitation of … of Cleaning and Rehabilitation of University of Idaho Well #2 on the Local Groundwater ... feasibility study. ¾Attempt to increase

Analysis of Water Levels in Local Monitoring W ll

INEL‐D

Wells

Page 32: Evaluation of Cleaning and Rehabilitation of … of Cleaning and Rehabilitation of University of Idaho Well #2 on the Local Groundwater ... feasibility study. ¾Attempt to increase

Analysis of Water Levels in Local Monitoring W ll

AQTESOLV parameters:

Wells

Two  hour lag time

Aquifer thickness (b) 225 ft

AQTESOLV parameters:

Aquifer thickness (b) 225 ft

Fully penetrating well

Di ( ) f UI#2 INEL 2000 fDistance (r) from UI#2 to INEL = 2000 ft

Injection rate was estimated by trial‐and‐error for a range of Transmissi it and Storati it al esrange of Transmissivity and Storativity values.

Page 33: Evaluation of Cleaning and Rehabilitation of … of Cleaning and Rehabilitation of University of Idaho Well #2 on the Local Groundwater ... feasibility study. ¾Attempt to increase

Analysis of Water Levels in Local Monitoring W llWells

Type curve match to INEL‐D displacement data

Page 34: Evaluation of Cleaning and Rehabilitation of … of Cleaning and Rehabilitation of University of Idaho Well #2 on the Local Groundwater ... feasibility study. ¾Attempt to increase

Analysis of Water Levels in Local Monitoring W llWells

D19D

Page 35: Evaluation of Cleaning and Rehabilitation of … of Cleaning and Rehabilitation of University of Idaho Well #2 on the Local Groundwater ... feasibility study. ¾Attempt to increase

Analysis of Water Levels in Local Monitoring W llWells

AHC well

Page 36: Evaluation of Cleaning and Rehabilitation of … of Cleaning and Rehabilitation of University of Idaho Well #2 on the Local Groundwater ... feasibility study. ¾Attempt to increase

Analysis of Water Levels in Local Monitoring W llWells

Page 37: Evaluation of Cleaning and Rehabilitation of … of Cleaning and Rehabilitation of University of Idaho Well #2 on the Local Groundwater ... feasibility study. ¾Attempt to increase

Analysis of Water Levels in Local Monitoring W llWells

Page 38: Evaluation of Cleaning and Rehabilitation of … of Cleaning and Rehabilitation of University of Idaho Well #2 on the Local Groundwater ... feasibility study. ¾Attempt to increase

Analysis of Water Levels in Local Monitoring W llWells

Page 39: Evaluation of Cleaning and Rehabilitation of … of Cleaning and Rehabilitation of University of Idaho Well #2 on the Local Groundwater ... feasibility study. ¾Attempt to increase

Analysis of Water Temperature in Local M it i W llMonitoring Wells

Page 40: Evaluation of Cleaning and Rehabilitation of … of Cleaning and Rehabilitation of University of Idaho Well #2 on the Local Groundwater ... feasibility study. ¾Attempt to increase

ConclusionsConclusions

No permanent change in the borehole flowNo permanent change in the borehole flow environment in well UI#2.

Water levels in the sediments of Bovill wereWater levels in the sediments of Bovill were not affected by cleaning.

W l l i i l l i i llWater level rise in local monitoring wells were a result of a recharge event from Paradise C kCreek.

Page 41: Evaluation of Cleaning and Rehabilitation of … of Cleaning and Rehabilitation of University of Idaho Well #2 on the Local Groundwater ... feasibility study. ¾Attempt to increase

RecommendationsRecommendations

Conduct visual dye tracer tests in well UI#2Conduct visual dye tracer tests in well UI#2.

Stress well UI#2 under pumping conditions to verify hydraulic connection between Lolo andverify hydraulic connection between Lolo and sediments of Bovill.

E bli h i l i i kEstablish a continual monitoring network at the UIGFL into order to characterize the 

h di i (i fl )recharge conditions (i.e., flux).

Page 42: Evaluation of Cleaning and Rehabilitation of … of Cleaning and Rehabilitation of University of Idaho Well #2 on the Local Groundwater ... feasibility study. ¾Attempt to increase

Thank you. 

Questions?