Top Banner
Europe’s rendezvous with Titan Arturo Russo University of Palermo
28

Europe’s rendezvous with Titan - NASA · Europe’s rendezvous with Titan Arturo Russo Universityof Palermo. Horizon 2000. Voyager 1 NvemberNovember 1980. Titan ... Grasp Gamma

Aug 27, 2018

Download

Documents

leduong
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: Europe’s rendezvous with Titan - NASA · Europe’s rendezvous with Titan Arturo Russo Universityof Palermo. Horizon 2000. Voyager 1 NvemberNovember 1980. Titan ... Grasp Gamma

Europe’s rendezvouspwith Titan

Arturo RussoUniversity of Palermo

Page 2: Europe’s rendezvous with Titan - NASA · Europe’s rendezvous with Titan Arturo Russo Universityof Palermo. Horizon 2000. Voyager 1 NvemberNovember 1980. Titan ... Grasp Gamma

Horizon20002000

Page 3: Europe’s rendezvous with Titan - NASA · Europe’s rendezvous with Titan Arturo Russo Universityof Palermo. Horizon 2000. Voyager 1 NvemberNovember 1980. Titan ... Grasp Gamma

Voyager 1

N vember 1980November 1980

Page 4: Europe’s rendezvous with Titan - NASA · Europe’s rendezvous with Titan Arturo Russo Universityof Palermo. Horizon 2000. Voyager 1 NvemberNovember 1980. Titan ... Grasp Gamma

TitanTitan

Rhea Tethys Enceladus Dione

Page 5: Europe’s rendezvous with Titan - NASA · Europe’s rendezvous with Titan Arturo Russo Universityof Palermo. Horizon 2000. Voyager 1 NvemberNovember 1980. Titan ... Grasp Gamma

Project CassiniNovember 1982November 1982

Page 6: Europe’s rendezvous with Titan - NASA · Europe’s rendezvous with Titan Arturo Russo Universityof Palermo. Horizon 2000. Voyager 1 NvemberNovember 1980. Titan ... Grasp Gamma

Mission conceptMission concept(1985)

Page 7: Europe’s rendezvous with Titan - NASA · Europe’s rendezvous with Titan Arturo Russo Universityof Palermo. Horizon 2000. Voyager 1 NvemberNovember 1980. Titan ... Grasp Gamma

The time of decisionThe time of decision(Bruges, 25-27 October 1988)

Cassini Saturn and Titan

Vesta Asteroids and comets

Quasat Radio astronomy VLBI

Grasp Gamma ray astronomyGrasp Gamma ray astronomy

Lyman UV astronomyy y

Page 8: Europe’s rendezvous with Titan - NASA · Europe’s rendezvous with Titan Arturo Russo Universityof Palermo. Horizon 2000. Voyager 1 NvemberNovember 1980. Titan ... Grasp Gamma

Th l ti f The selection of a scientific mission in ESA

SPC

SSAC ESA D/SCISSAC

F b l d

ESA D/SCI

AWG SSWG

Feasibiliy studies

ESTEC IndustryProposals

Scientific Community

Page 9: Europe’s rendezvous with Titan - NASA · Europe’s rendezvous with Titan Arturo Russo Universityof Palermo. Horizon 2000. Voyager 1 NvemberNovember 1980. Titan ... Grasp Gamma

Th h i f The choice of the SSWGthe SSWG

Vesta

Cassini / Titan probe

Page 10: Europe’s rendezvous with Titan - NASA · Europe’s rendezvous with Titan Arturo Russo Universityof Palermo. Horizon 2000. Voyager 1 NvemberNovember 1980. Titan ... Grasp Gamma

The choice of the SSACSSAC

GRASP

Cassini / Titan probep

Page 11: Europe’s rendezvous with Titan - NASA · Europe’s rendezvous with Titan Arturo Russo Universityof Palermo. Horizon 2000. Voyager 1 NvemberNovember 1980. Titan ... Grasp Gamma

The Huygens The Huygens mission

Ch HChristiaan Huygens(1629 – 1695)

Page 12: Europe’s rendezvous with Titan - NASA · Europe’s rendezvous with Titan Arturo Russo Universityof Palermo. Horizon 2000. Voyager 1 NvemberNovember 1980. Titan ... Grasp Gamma

O l i A i One year later in America …

M i M k IIMariner Mark II

October 1989: Congress approval of the CRAF/Cassini programCRAF/Cass n program

Page 13: Europe’s rendezvous with Titan - NASA · Europe’s rendezvous with Titan Arturo Russo Universityof Palermo. Horizon 2000. Voyager 1 NvemberNovember 1980. Titan ... Grasp Gamma

The Cassini spacecraft

Planned launch:November 1995

Page 14: Europe’s rendezvous with Titan - NASA · Europe’s rendezvous with Titan Arturo Russo Universityof Palermo. Horizon 2000. Voyager 1 NvemberNovember 1980. Titan ... Grasp Gamma

ESA/NASA collaboration

Memorandum of UnderstandingMemorandum of Understanding(17 december 1990)

Page 15: Europe’s rendezvous with Titan - NASA · Europe’s rendezvous with Titan Arturo Russo Universityof Palermo. Horizon 2000. Voyager 1 NvemberNovember 1980. Titan ... Grasp Gamma

C i i i thCrisis in theUnited States(1991-92)

George Bush Sr.

Richard Truly

Page 16: Europe’s rendezvous with Titan - NASA · Europe’s rendezvous with Titan Arturo Russo Universityof Palermo. Horizon 2000. Voyager 1 NvemberNovember 1980. Titan ... Grasp Gamma

P t sts in Protests in EuropeEu p

“This is not in the i it f th MOU!”spirit of the MOU!”

J.-M. Luton(ESA DG)

“An intolerable stress … I cannoth h h h h

D. Southwood(Chair SSAC)

emphasize enough the change thiscan easily induce in the climate of cooperation”( ) p

Page 17: Europe’s rendezvous with Titan - NASA · Europe’s rendezvous with Titan Arturo Russo Universityof Palermo. Horizon 2000. Voyager 1 NvemberNovember 1980. Titan ... Grasp Gamma

Protests in EuropeProtests in Europe

“Commiments [must] be honoured”

“It should be impressed upon NASA that It should be impressed upon NASA that international cooperation is a valid

proposition only as long as the partners h n u d th i c mmitm nts”honoured their commitments”

“There is a breaking-point at which it is There is a breaking point at which it is no longer possible to continue, and ESA is very close to this point”

H. Habing(SSAC)

Page 18: Europe’s rendezvous with Titan - NASA · Europe’s rendezvous with Titan Arturo Russo Universityof Palermo. Horizon 2000. Voyager 1 NvemberNovember 1980. Titan ... Grasp Gamma

Crisis in the United StatesCrisis in the United States(1994)

Faster, cheaper,betterbetter

Page 19: Europe’s rendezvous with Titan - NASA · Europe’s rendezvous with Titan Arturo Russo Universityof Palermo. Horizon 2000. Voyager 1 NvemberNovember 1980. Titan ... Grasp Gamma

Cancel Cassini ?Cancel Cassini ?

“If a choice had to be made betweenAXAF and Cassini, internationalcooperation would be a secondarycooperation would be a secondaryconsideration, compared to the relativeweight of the various pressure groups …

The overall impression is one of total uncertainty …It ld b i d t f ESA t d d tIt would be very imprudent for ESA to depend toostrongly on NASA for its long term future projects”

L Woltijer (SSAC chair)L. Woltijer (SSAC chair)

Page 20: Europe’s rendezvous with Titan - NASA · Europe’s rendezvous with Titan Arturo Russo Universityof Palermo. Horizon 2000. Voyager 1 NvemberNovember 1980. Titan ... Grasp Gamma

Reactions in EuropeReactions in Europe

“Europe views any prospect of a unilateral withdrawal from cooperation on the part of the United States as totally unacceptable the United States as totally unacceptable. Such an action would call into question the reliability of the U.S. as a partner in any future major scientific and technological future major scientific and technological cooperation”

J.-M. LutonJ. M. Luton(ESA D.G.)

Al GoreAl Gore(US vice president)

Page 21: Europe’s rendezvous with Titan - NASA · Europe’s rendezvous with Titan Arturo Russo Universityof Palermo. Horizon 2000. Voyager 1 NvemberNovember 1980. Titan ... Grasp Gamma

Reactions in EuropeReactions in Europe

H. Holbein (1533)( )The ambassadors

Page 22: Europe’s rendezvous with Titan - NASA · Europe’s rendezvous with Titan Arturo Russo Universityof Palermo. Horizon 2000. Voyager 1 NvemberNovember 1980. Titan ... Grasp Gamma

Bill Go ahead !Bill Clinton

… but after an independent reviewindependent reviewby external experts

“… An unacceptable… An unacceptableviolation of the cooperative spirit”

R. Bonnet

Page 23: Europe’s rendezvous with Titan - NASA · Europe’s rendezvous with Titan Arturo Russo Universityof Palermo. Horizon 2000. Voyager 1 NvemberNovember 1980. Titan ... Grasp Gamma

A bliAssembling

Page 24: Europe’s rendezvous with Titan - NASA · Europe’s rendezvous with Titan Arturo Russo Universityof Palermo. Horizon 2000. Voyager 1 NvemberNovember 1980. Titan ... Grasp Gamma

Launch(15 t b 1997)(15 october 1997)

Page 25: Europe’s rendezvous with Titan - NASA · Europe’s rendezvous with Titan Arturo Russo Universityof Palermo. Horizon 2000. Voyager 1 NvemberNovember 1980. Titan ... Grasp Gamma

H lHuygens release

24 december 2004

Page 26: Europe’s rendezvous with Titan - NASA · Europe’s rendezvous with Titan Arturo Russo Universityof Palermo. Horizon 2000. Voyager 1 NvemberNovember 1980. Titan ... Grasp Gamma

P h ti t th ldParachuting onto another world

14 January 2005 14 January 2005

Page 27: Europe’s rendezvous with Titan - NASA · Europe’s rendezvous with Titan Arturo Russo Universityof Palermo. Horizon 2000. Voyager 1 NvemberNovember 1980. Titan ... Grasp Gamma

A postcard fromTitanA postcard fromTitan

Page 28: Europe’s rendezvous with Titan - NASA · Europe’s rendezvous with Titan Arturo Russo Universityof Palermo. Horizon 2000. Voyager 1 NvemberNovember 1980. Titan ... Grasp Gamma