Ethics Ethics National Judging Advisory National Judging Advisory Committee Committee
Dec 20, 2015
22
Youth Science CanadaSciences jeunesse Canada
YSF Ethics:YSF Ethics:
Developing Awareness, Developing Awareness,
Understanding Understanding
and Complianceand Compliance Judith Soon & Patrick WhippeyJudith Soon & Patrick Whippey
33
Youth Science CanadaSciences jeunesse Canada“We are discussing no small matter,
but how we ought to live”. Socrates
“Knowledge without conscience spells but the destruction of the soul”. Francois Rabelais
“Business in Canada must have a
conscience and ethics”. Lt.-Gen. Roméo Dallaire
44
Youth Science CanadaSciences jeunesse Canada
GoalsGoals
• To present the information that Regional Science Fair To present the information that Regional Science Fair
CommitteesCommittees need need to understandto understand the ethical issues the ethical issues
• To define clearlyTo define clearly the rules that participants must follow the rules that participants must follow
• To make it easyTo make it easy for participants to follow for participants to follow the rulesthe rules
55
Youth Science CanadaSciences jeunesse Canada
BackgroundBackground
• Regional Science Fairs (RSF) need to ensure that Regional Science Fairs (RSF) need to ensure that
projects comply with YSF rules and regulationsprojects comply with YSF rules and regulations
• Need to get out of the mode of Need to get out of the mode of “Backwards “Backwards
Compliance”Compliance” and surprises at the CWSFs and surprises at the CWSFs
• Help us encourage Canada’s young scientists to conduct Help us encourage Canada’s young scientists to conduct
ethical and sound researchethical and sound research
66
Youth Science CanadaSciences jeunesse Canada
National Judging Advisory National Judging Advisory
CommitteeCommittee
The National Judging Advisory Committee The National Judging Advisory Committee
(NJAC) (NJAC) monitors monitors YSF Canada policies and YSF Canada policies and
procedures relating to all aspects of judging procedures relating to all aspects of judging
77
Youth Science CanadaSciences jeunesse Canada
YSF Canada Ethics YSF Canada Ethics
CommitteeCommittee
• RResponsible for the oversight of human and esponsible for the oversight of human and
animal research at RSF and CWSF animal research at RSF and CWSF
• Reviews challenging projects submitted by RSF Reviews challenging projects submitted by RSF
Ethics Committees Ethics Committees
88
Youth Science CanadaSciences jeunesse Canada
Ethics: What Types of Research?Ethics: What Types of Research?
Human ResearchHuman Research
• Ingestion and absorptionIngestion and absorption
• Psychological riskPsychological risk
• Physical activitiesPhysical activities
Animal ResearchAnimal Research
• Inhumane treatmentInhumane treatment
99
Youth Science CanadaSciences jeunesse Canada
Regional Science Fair Regional Science Fair
Ethics CommitteeEthics Committee
Each region is Each region is expectedexpected to set up to set up an Ethics an Ethics
Committee which will become knowledgeable Committee which will become knowledgeable
about the rules and ethical issues related to student about the rules and ethical issues related to student
research research
We propose to change this to required
1010
Youth Science CanadaSciences jeunesse Canada
Ethics Review CommitteeEthics Review Committee
• A group of adults knowledgeable about regulations A group of adults knowledgeable about regulations
concerning experimentation in restricted areasconcerning experimentation in restricted areas
• Role is to educate and supportRole is to educate and support
• Members (1-3 people):Members (1-3 people):
• Ethics Consultant Ethics Consultant
• VeterinarianVeterinarian
• Health care professionalHealth care professional
• RSF Chief JudgeRSF Chief Judge
1111
Youth Science CanadaSciences jeunesse Canada
Ethics Review ProcessEthics Review Process
* All animal research* All animal research
* All human research* All human research
Research proposals must be reviewed by the RSF Research proposals must be reviewed by the RSF
Ethics CommitteeEthics Committee
An Adult and Scientific Supervisor are requiredAn Adult and Scientific Supervisor are required
1212
Youth Science CanadaSciences jeunesse Canada
Adult SupervisorAdult Supervisor
• Required for projects involving human and animal Required for projects involving human and animal
researchresearch
• Parent, teacher or scientistParent, teacher or scientist
• Ensures student understands ethical issues at an Ensures student understands ethical issues at an
appropriate levelappropriate level
• Ensures YSF rules are followedEnsures YSF rules are followed
1313
Youth Science CanadaSciences jeunesse Canada
Scientific SupervisorScientific Supervisor
• Involved if there is Involved if there is more than trivial riskmore than trivial risk
• Often located in University or industrial Often located in University or industrial
laboratory settinglaboratory setting
• Usually has professional qualificationsUsually has professional qualifications
• May be the Adult SupervisorMay be the Adult Supervisor
1414
Youth Science CanadaSciences jeunesse Canada
Ethics Review ProcessEthics Review Process
• Can use primarily email and phone discussionsCan use primarily email and phone discussions
• Communicate Ethics Rules and expectations to Communicate Ethics Rules and expectations to
teachers, students and parentsteachers, students and parents
• Be prepared to enforce the rulesBe prepared to enforce the rules
1515
Youth Science CanadaSciences jeunesse Canada
Challenging IssuesChallenging Issues
RSF Chief Judge refers to YSF Ethics CommitteeRSF Chief Judge refers to YSF Ethics Committee
• Chair, Dr. Patrick Whippey Chair, Dr. Patrick Whippey
• After seeking appropriate professional advice, the Committee After seeking appropriate professional advice, the Committee
will will assist studentsassist students where possible so that the methodology can where possible so that the methodology can
meet the ethical rules for animal or human research meet the ethical rules for animal or human research
1616
Youth Science CanadaSciences jeunesse Canada
Human Participation Human Participation
Low Risk ProjectsLow Risk Projects
• Surveys of Surveys of attitudes and beliefsattitudes and beliefs
• Skill testsSkill tests
• Observations of behaviour Observations of behaviour
• 4.1A 4.1A Approval of Low Risk ProjectsApproval of Low Risk Projects
1717
Youth Science CanadaSciences jeunesse Canada
One Minute MomentOne Minute Moment
Examples of a Examples of a low risklow risk survey? survey?
1818
Youth Science CanadaSciences jeunesse Canada
Human Participation Human Participation
High Risk ProjectsHigh Risk Projects
Everything ElseEverything Else
1919
Youth Science CanadaSciences jeunesse Canada
High Risk ProjectsHigh Risk Projects
• Approval required before experiments beginApproval required before experiments begin
• Projects often done in a research laboratoryProjects often done in a research laboratory
• Reviewed by RSF Ethics CommitteeReviewed by RSF Ethics Committee
• 4.1B Application For Review of Research with 4.1B Application For Review of Research with
Human Participants Involving Significant RiskHuman Participants Involving Significant Risk
• 4.1C Human & Animal Research Approval4.1C Human & Animal Research Approval
2020
Youth Science CanadaSciences jeunesse Canada
One Minute MomentOne Minute Moment
Examples of surveys with Examples of surveys with significant risk?significant risk?
2121
Youth Science CanadaSciences jeunesse Canada
Informed ConsentInformed Consent• Is a processIs a process• Ethics committee in placeEthics committee in place• Points student & supporting adults to ethics web sitePoints student & supporting adults to ethics web site• Reviews the Informed Consent FormReviews the Informed Consent Form• Ensures the required elements are present.Ensures the required elements are present.• Monitors compliance by the student & participantsMonitors compliance by the student & participants
2222
Youth Science CanadaSciences jeunesse Canada
Informed Consent FormInformed Consent Form
Low & High Risk projects Low & High Risk projects
• The right to be The right to be informedinformed of risks of risks
• The right to remain The right to remain anonymousanonymous
• The right to The right to withdrawwithdraw::• at any time at any time
• for any reasonfor any reason
• The right to be The right to be informedinformed of the results of the results
• Informed Consent FormInformed Consent Form
2323
Youth Science CanadaSciences jeunesse Canada
What is a Drug?What is a Drug?
Health Canada definition:Health Canada definition:
““Drug"Drug" includes any substance or mixture of substances manufactured, sold, or includes any substance or mixture of substances manufactured, sold, or
represented for use in:represented for use in:
(a) the diagnosis, treatment, mitigation or prevention of a (a) the diagnosis, treatment, mitigation or prevention of a
disease, disorder, abnormal physical state, or its disease, disorder, abnormal physical state, or its
symptoms, in humans or animals;symptoms, in humans or animals;
(b) Restoring, correcting, or modifying organic functions (b) Restoring, correcting, or modifying organic functions
in human beings or animals; in human beings or animals;
(c) Disinfection in premises food is manufactured, (c) Disinfection in premises food is manufactured,
prepared or kept. prepared or kept.
2424
Youth Science CanadaSciences jeunesse Canada
Questions to ask of Projects Questions to ask of Projects with Human Participation with Human Participation
1. Is the project high or low risk?2. Is there supervision by an appropriate scientific
advisor?3. Is the student familiar with the ethics web site(s).4. Does the informed consent form have all the
required elements?5. Is the student familiar with the definition of a drug?6. Is a drug involved?
2525
Youth Science CanadaSciences jeunesse Canada
Non-Vertebrate AnimalsNon-Vertebrate AnimalsExceptExcept Cephalopods Cephalopods
AllowedAllowed
Youth Science CanadaSciences jeunesse Canada
Vertebrate Animals, Vertebrate Animals, (fishes, amphibians, birds, reptiles, mammals) (fishes, amphibians, birds, reptiles, mammals)
CephalopodsCephalopods(Octopus, Squid, Cuttle Fish)(Octopus, Squid, Cuttle Fish)
Allowed only under Allowed only under fourfour conditions conditions
• Observation onlyObservation only
• Behavioural experiments Behavioural experiments
• Projects conducted in a registered laboratory Projects conducted in a registered laboratory
• Studies of embryos Studies of embryos
• 4.1C Human & Animal Research Approval4.1C Human & Animal Research Approval
2727
Youth Science CanadaSciences jeunesse Canada
Questions to ask if Questions to ask if Animals are involvedAnimals are involved
• Is the animal governed by the rules for vertebrates or invertebrates?
• Is there supervision by an appropriate scientific advisor?
• Is the student familiar with the ethics web site(s)?• Invertebrates – any scientifically legitimate project
is allowed.• Vertebrates – is it one of the four types of projects
allowed?
3030
Youth Science CanadaSciences jeunesse Canada
Off-Side ProjectsOff-Side Projects
Please do not send projects that are in Please do not send projects that are in violationviolation of of the Ethics Rules to the CWSF, the Ethics Rules to the CWSF,
no matter how meritoriousno matter how meritorious
We get two or three a year that are in clear violation
We are raising the bar
3131
Youth Science CanadaSciences jeunesse Canada
ResourcesResources
YSF Web Site Devoted to Ethics - YSF Web Site Devoted to Ethics - New:New:
• http://http://www.ldstf.cawww.ldstf.ca/ethics//ethics/
YSF Policy Manual – the Official Rules:YSF Policy Manual – the Official Rules:
• http://http://www.ysf.ca/Members/policydirectory.aspxwww.ysf.ca/Members/policydirectory.aspx
3232
Youth Science CanadaSciences jeunesse Canada
SummarySummary
• Adopt the YSF Ethics Rules for your Regional Science FairAdopt the YSF Ethics Rules for your Regional Science Fair
• Form a Regional Science Fair Ethics CommitteeForm a Regional Science Fair Ethics Committee
• Developing awareness and understanding of the ethical Developing awareness and understanding of the ethical
issues involved with Science Fairs will empower Canada’s issues involved with Science Fairs will empower Canada’s
young scientists to conduct ethical and sound researchyoung scientists to conduct ethical and sound research