Ethical Reflections on Harm-Benefit Analyses Gillian K. D. Crozier Philosopher and CRC on Environment, Culture and Values Laurentian University, Sudbury ON CCAC National Workshop 2014
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Ethical Reflections on Harm-Benefit Analyses
Gillian K. D. Crozier
Philosopher and CRC on Environment, Culture and Values
Laurentian University, Sudbury ON
CCAC National Workshop 2014
2
3
I.
4
II.
5
6
7
8
Bateson’s Cube
9
0
1
Most Acceptable
Least Acceptable
Importance of Research
0
Animal Suffering
Low
Likelihood of Benefit
High High
High
Low
Low
Bateson Cube – Modification A
10
0
1
Most Acceptable
Least Acceptable
Importance of Research
0
Degree of Valid Dissent
Low
Likelihood of Benefit
High High
High
Low
Low
Bateson Cube – Modification B
High
0
1
Most Acceptable
Least Acceptable
Importance of Research
0
Animal Suffering
Low
Likelihood of Benefit
High High
High
Low
Low
Threshold of Valid Dissent for Species X
11
High
Least Acceptable
0
1
Most Acceptable
Importance of Research
0
Animal Suffering
Low
Likelihood of Benefit
High High
High
Low
Low
Bateson Cube – Modification B
Threshold of Valid Dissent for Species Y
12
Related Documents
