Page 1
ENVIRONMENT AND COMPUTER LABORATORY I
ESD.EA: ESD, MODULE ON ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT (LAB AND EXERCISES)
Stephan Pfister ETH Zurich, Institute for Environmental Engineering,
Ecological Systems Design Group
ECL 1; introduction
Zurich, September 29, 2015
Page 2
Organisational aspects (I)
• Webpage: http://www.ifu.ethz.ch/ESD/education/master/ECLI/index_EN
• Project description: http://www.ifu.ethz.ch/ESD/education/master/ECLI/Project.pdf
• Google form by September 27, 2015
• Choose case (building / gas) • Choose partner (if any) • Accept SimaPro user agreement • http://goo.gl/forms/g8hIgqlxEM
• Next lab: 20/10/2015 Comparing LCI databases
Rolf Frischknecht
2
Page 3
Responses so far – everyone needs to submit!
3
Topic selection Partner Your name SimaPro Team #
Biogas Laura Iten Phanos Hadjikyriakou Yes 1
Biogas Nadège de Chambrier Rahel Fischer Yes 2
Buildings Chaojie Li Helen Droz-Georget Yes 3
Biogas Joni Dehaspe Marco Statunato No 4
Buildings Droz-Georget Helen Chaojie Li Yes 3
Buildings Kaibin Tang Livia Ramseier Yes 5
Buildings Marc Melliger Elisabeth Güttinger Yes 6
Buildings Raphael Hörler Kevin Flückiger Yes 7
Buildings Fransje Oudshoorn - Yes 8
Biogas Christian Koch John Hensley Yes 9
Buildings Henry Kulla Stefanie Müller Yes 10
Biogas Christian Koch John Hensley Yes 9
Buildings Stefanie Müller Henry Kulla Yes 11
Buildings Ramseier Livia Tang Kaibin Yes 12
Page 4
Continue Lab work
• Database is stored locally
• Same computer as last week
• You can import a database
• Database is on polybox: Professional_2015-09-28_11-23-07_bottle
• Description: How to import and export database in simapro 8
4
Page 5
Import database
5
1: Open Simapro and go to database management -> restore
2. Select the backup file which is on the polybox: Professional_2015-09-28_11-23-07_bottle
Page 6
Import database (II)
6
4. Save the database under a new name:
5. Open the database and create a new project.
3. Agree to restore the database:
Page 7
EXERCISE 1: MODEL WATER BOTTLE USING PROCESSES
Page 8
Model a material
• Material a: 20gr of Plastic bottle • 22gr of PET (RER, S)
• Blow molding of the plastic (RER, S)
• 2 gr waste during production: municipal incineration (treatment)
• Material b: 3gr of plastic cap • 3.75 gr Acrylonitrile-butadiene-styrene copolymer, ABS
• 0.75gr of waste during production: municipal incineration, plastic mixture
Work on your own: 15min
8
www.ifu.ethz.ch/ESD
Use ecoinvent unit processes
Page 9
Combine your materials
• Model the full plastic bottle
• 20gr bottle
• 3gr of cap
• Pumping, purifying & filling process: 0.02 kWh/bottle (UCTE electricity mix, medium voltage)
9
www.ifu.ethz.ch/ESD
Work on your own: 10min
Page 10
Have a look at the network
10
www.ifu.ethz.ch/ESD
Analyze options: tree, network, comparison
Select method
Calculate
Page 11
Have a look at the network
• See how the life cycle is taking form
• Cradle to gate level/ not LC yet
• Main features of the Network
• Take a look at the inventory list
11
www.ifu.ethz.ch/ESD
Page 12
Have a look at the tree
12
www.ifu.ethz.ch/ESD
Page 13
Model the life cycle
• 1 water bottle of 23g
• 2x 50km transport, lorry 20-28 ton
• Disposal to incineration scenario CH
13
www.ifu.ethz.ch/ESD
Use unit processes
Page 14
Modeling details
• Modeling transport
• “ton x km” or “kg x km”
• 50% loaded, full to go & empty on return
14
www.ifu.ethz.ch/ESD
Page 15
Have a look at the network
• See how the life cycle is taking form
• Main features of the network
• Different options
15
www.ifu.ethz.ch/ESD
Page 16
Have a look at the tree
16
www.ifu.ethz.ch/ESD
Page 17
More detailed
17
www.ifu.ethz.ch/ESD
Page 18
Result interpretation:
• Analyse if the flows make sense
• Look at the network with a 0,1 % cut-off
• How much material goes in the system
• How much material goes of the system to the waste scenario?
18
www.ifu.ethz.ch/ESD
Page 19
ADDITIONAL ASPECTS OF IMPACT ASSESSMENT IN SIMAPRO
Characterisation, normalization,…
Page 20
Analyze impact of plastic bottle
Different impact assessment steps
Presentation
Page 21
Analyze impact of plastic bottle
Process contribution
Inventory
Page 22
EXERCISE 2: MODEL WATER BOTTLE USING PRODUCT STAGES
Page 23
Model an assembly
• Model the full plastic bottle
• bottle
• cap
• Pumping, purifying & filling process
23
www.ifu.ethz.ch/ESD
Page 24
Model an assembly
• Have a look in SimaPro
• Product stages: New assembly
• Several Tabs
• Input/ Output and comment: The data of your assembly
• Parameters: Input of variable data as functions
24
www.ifu.ethz.ch/ESD
Page 25
Model an assembly
• Model 1p of plastic bottle
• 20gr bottle
• 3gr of cap
• pumping, purifying & filling process: 0.02 kWh/bottle (UCTE electricity mix S)
25
www.ifu.ethz.ch/ESD
Use unit processes
Page 26
Have a look at the tree
26
www.ifu.ethz.ch/ESD
Analyze options: tree, network, comparison, monte carlo,…
Select method
Page 27
Have a look at the tree
27
www.ifu.ethz.ch/ESD
Page 28
Model a life cycle
• Have a look in SimaPro
• Product stages: New life cycle
• Several Tabs
• Input/ Output and comment: The data of your assembly
• Parameters: Input of variable data as functions
28
www.ifu.ethz.ch/ESD
Page 29
Model a life cycle
• 1p water bottle
• 2x 50km transport, lorry 20-28 ton
• disposal to incineration scenario CH
29
www.ifu.ethz.ch/ESD
Use unit processes
Page 30
Modeling details
• Modeling transport
• Ton x km or kg x km
• 50% loaded, full to go & empty to return
• Disposal to incineration
• With or without energy recovery
• Avoided product can be used: avoid electricity or heat production
30
www.ifu.ethz.ch/ESD
Page 31
Have a look at the network
31
www.ifu.ethz.ch/ESD
Page 32
EXERCISE 3: GLASS WATER BOTTLE
Page 33
Case study 2: Glass bottle
• Model on your own in SimaPro
• Model the production and use of glass bottled water
• Use system processes
www.ifu.ethz.ch/ESD
Page 34
Model the materials
• Material a: 200gr glass bottle • 210 gr white (virgin) glass
• glass blowing: 0.01kWh
• 10gr waste scenario
www.ifu.ethz.ch/ESD
• Material b: 5gr aluminum cap • 5gr aluminum
• production process
Use unit processes
Page 35
Model Assembly and LC: use product stages
www.ifu.ethz.ch/ESD
• Assembly: bottled water • glass bottle
• aluminum cap
• process bottling: 0.02kWh
• Life cycle: Glass water bottle • bottled water
• transport
• waste
Page 36
36
www.ifu.ethz.ch/ESD
Modeling results
36
Assembly Life cycle
36
Glass bottle Aluminum cap
Page 37
Have a look at the network
37
www.ifu.ethz.ch/ESD
Page 38
EXERCISE 5: COMPARE PLASTIC BOTTLE AND GLASS BOTTLE
Page 39
Compare both products
39
www.ifu.ethz.ch/ESD
Page 40
EXERCISE 6: MODEL WITH PARAMETERS (APPLY TO PLASTIC BOTTLE)
Page 41
Model with parameters
Insert a variable instead of constant data When? • Preliminary data is available, inputs could change if better data is available • Different input values can be used to calculate more versions of the same life
cycle • Reduce the possibility of making calculation mistakes. Easy to check
• Insert calculation rules instead of constant data as input data.
• Available for all processes and product stages • With or without uncertainty distribution
• Calculation rule: • Defined in SimaPro • Based on input parameter
41
www.ifu.ethz.ch/ESD
Page 42
Exercise 6.1: Model bottling with parameters
• Electricity use for bottling • Uncertain value
• Combination of values
• Input parameters (apply to plastic bottle) • ‘pumping&cleaning’: 0.015kWh/l
• ‘filling ’: 0.005kWh/l
• Calculated parameter • bottling=‘pumping&cleaning + filling’
• Process input data • ‘bottling‘
42
www.ifu.ethz.ch/ESD
Page 43
Exercise 6.2: Model transport with parameters
• Use Input parameters for distance and weight
• Use a calculated parameter for transport
• Replace transport within case study 1 by a calculation rule
43
www.ifu.ethz.ch/ESD
Page 44
Switches: • Local: Distance <=50km
• Regional: 50km<distance and distance>150km
• Abroad: Distance=>150km
Exercise 6.3: Different distances-different transport
• Process sheet:
• Parameter tap: Make the necessary switch parameters
which are 1 when the distance is conform the scenario
• In the input for transport: add two lines for the transport with a van and transport with lorry 20-28t. Multiply inputs by the corresponding switches
44
www.ifu.ethz.ch/ESD
Scenario Distance Transport mode
1. Local Smaller or equal than 50km van < 3,5t/RER S
2. Regional Between 50 and 150km Lorry of 16t, fleet average/RER
3. Abroad Bigger or equal than 150km Lorry of 20-28t, fleet average/RER
Page 45
Compare different versions of your model
• First parameters are defined at process/project or database level
• A Calculation setup can be used to define two or more scenarios
• Each scenario considers different values for the parameter
45
www.ifu.ethz.ch/ESD
Page 46
Thank you for your attention.
[email protected]
www.ifu.ethz.ch/ESD