Top Banner
Eradicating stoats from Resolution Island, Fiordland: progress made and what to do next Dean Anderson, Andrea Byrom, Kerri-Anne Edge, Pete McMurtrie Landcare Research Department of Conservation
38

Eradicating stoats from Resolution Island, Fiordland ... · Stoat eradication • 2500 traps spaced 105 m apart • Traps reset Jan, July and Nov.

Sep 14, 2019

Download

Documents

dariahiddleston
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: Eradicating stoats from Resolution Island, Fiordland ... · Stoat eradication • 2500 traps spaced 105 m apart • Traps reset Jan, July and Nov.

Eradicating stoats from Resolution

Island, Fiordland: progress made and

what to do next

Dean Anderson, Andrea Byrom,

Kerri-Anne Edge, Pete McMurtrie Landcare Research

Department of Conservation

Page 2: Eradicating stoats from Resolution Island, Fiordland ... · Stoat eradication • 2500 traps spaced 105 m apart • Traps reset Jan, July and Nov.

Resolution Island

21,000 ha

Page 3: Eradicating stoats from Resolution Island, Fiordland ... · Stoat eradication • 2500 traps spaced 105 m apart • Traps reset Jan, July and Nov.

Stoat eradication

• 2500 traps spaced

105 m apart

• Traps reset Jan,

July and Nov.

Page 4: Eradicating stoats from Resolution Island, Fiordland ... · Stoat eradication • 2500 traps spaced 105 m apart • Traps reset Jan, July and Nov.

Trapping results

Page 5: Eradicating stoats from Resolution Island, Fiordland ... · Stoat eradication • 2500 traps spaced 105 m apart • Traps reset Jan, July and Nov.

Initial knockdown

• 290 stoats captured

• Initial sex ratio =

1 Female : 3 Males

Page 6: Eradicating stoats from Resolution Island, Fiordland ... · Stoat eradication • 2500 traps spaced 105 m apart • Traps reset Jan, July and Nov.

231 captures

Page 7: Eradicating stoats from Resolution Island, Fiordland ... · Stoat eradication • 2500 traps spaced 105 m apart • Traps reset Jan, July and Nov.

27 captures

Page 8: Eradicating stoats from Resolution Island, Fiordland ... · Stoat eradication • 2500 traps spaced 105 m apart • Traps reset Jan, July and Nov.

78 captures

Page 9: Eradicating stoats from Resolution Island, Fiordland ... · Stoat eradication • 2500 traps spaced 105 m apart • Traps reset Jan, July and Nov.

15 captures

Page 10: Eradicating stoats from Resolution Island, Fiordland ... · Stoat eradication • 2500 traps spaced 105 m apart • Traps reset Jan, July and Nov.

Management

questions:

1. What is the on-going objective: eradication or suppression?

2. Where do we put control effort?

3. When and how frequently do we reset traps?

** Budget constraints

Page 11: Eradicating stoats from Resolution Island, Fiordland ... · Stoat eradication • 2500 traps spaced 105 m apart • Traps reset Jan, July and Nov.

What can modelling

contribute?

Two-stage process

1) Analyse data:

a) Trapping dynamics

b) Stoat population dynamics

2) Simulate management scenarios

a) Predict resulting stoat population responses

Page 12: Eradicating stoats from Resolution Island, Fiordland ... · Stoat eradication • 2500 traps spaced 105 m apart • Traps reset Jan, July and Nov.

Data analysis to estimate:

1) Probability of capture

2) Home-range size

3) Population size over time

4) Immigration rate

5) Population growth rate

6) Preferred habitat features

Page 13: Eradicating stoats from Resolution Island, Fiordland ... · Stoat eradication • 2500 traps spaced 105 m apart • Traps reset Jan, July and Nov.

Simulation questions

Given different management scenarios:

1) What is the probability of sustained

eradication?

2) What is the probability of sustained

population suppression below a set

threshold?

• Kokako?

• Saddleback?

• Kakapo?

Page 14: Eradicating stoats from Resolution Island, Fiordland ... · Stoat eradication • 2500 traps spaced 105 m apart • Traps reset Jan, July and Nov.

Simulation questions

Given different management scenarios:

1) What is the probability of sustained

eradication?

2) What is the probability of sustained

population suppression below a set

threshold?

• Add traps

• Reduce trapping sessions

• Reduce immigration

• Improve trap attractiveness

Page 15: Eradicating stoats from Resolution Island, Fiordland ... · Stoat eradication • 2500 traps spaced 105 m apart • Traps reset Jan, July and Nov.

Spatial trapping model

1) Data analysis to fit model

parameters

2) Simulate population dynamics

Page 16: Eradicating stoats from Resolution Island, Fiordland ... · Stoat eradication • 2500 traps spaced 105 m apart • Traps reset Jan, July and Nov.

0 1 2 3 4 5

0.0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

Number of immigrants

Pro

babili

ty

Mean annual number of

immigrants = 0.77

Annual immigration rate?

Results: Data analysis

Page 17: Eradicating stoats from Resolution Island, Fiordland ... · Stoat eradication • 2500 traps spaced 105 m apart • Traps reset Jan, July and Nov.

• Literature: per-capita rate = 4.5

• 9 kits / female

Female reproductive rate?

Results: Data analysis

Page 18: Eradicating stoats from Resolution Island, Fiordland ... · Stoat eradication • 2500 traps spaced 105 m apart • Traps reset Jan, July and Nov.

• Literature: per-capita rate = 4.5

• 9 kits / female

• Our reproduction parameter estimate:

• Per-capita rate = 11.5 (23 kits / female)

Results: Data analysis

Female reproductive rate?

Page 19: Eradicating stoats from Resolution Island, Fiordland ... · Stoat eradication • 2500 traps spaced 105 m apart • Traps reset Jan, July and Nov.

• Literature: per-capita rate = 4.5

• 9 kits / female

• Our per-capita rate = 11.5

• 23 kits / female

• Recall initial 1 female : 3 male capture ratio

• Indicates a present ratio: 2.56 females : 1 male

Results: Data analysis

Female reproductive rate?

Page 20: Eradicating stoats from Resolution Island, Fiordland ... · Stoat eradication • 2500 traps spaced 105 m apart • Traps reset Jan, July and Nov.

Results: Predictive simulations

What if …?

Page 21: Eradicating stoats from Resolution Island, Fiordland ... · Stoat eradication • 2500 traps spaced 105 m apart • Traps reset Jan, July and Nov.

Current regime

Eradication /

suppression

Page 22: Eradicating stoats from Resolution Island, Fiordland ... · Stoat eradication • 2500 traps spaced 105 m apart • Traps reset Jan, July and Nov.

Current regime

Probability of Eradication = 0.23

Probability of < 11 stoats = 0.40

Page 23: Eradicating stoats from Resolution Island, Fiordland ... · Stoat eradication • 2500 traps spaced 105 m apart • Traps reset Jan, July and Nov.

Stop trapping

Page 24: Eradicating stoats from Resolution Island, Fiordland ... · Stoat eradication • 2500 traps spaced 105 m apart • Traps reset Jan, July and Nov.

Trap 2 times per year

Page 25: Eradicating stoats from Resolution Island, Fiordland ... · Stoat eradication • 2500 traps spaced 105 m apart • Traps reset Jan, July and Nov.

Additional traps

• 164 traps

• 200-m spacing

• Difficult to access

Page 26: Eradicating stoats from Resolution Island, Fiordland ... · Stoat eradication • 2500 traps spaced 105 m apart • Traps reset Jan, July and Nov.

Add 164 traps

Probability of Eradication = 0.28

Probability of < 11 stoats = 0.47

Page 27: Eradicating stoats from Resolution Island, Fiordland ... · Stoat eradication • 2500 traps spaced 105 m apart • Traps reset Jan, July and Nov.

Reduce

immigration

Page 28: Eradicating stoats from Resolution Island, Fiordland ... · Stoat eradication • 2500 traps spaced 105 m apart • Traps reset Jan, July and Nov.

Reduced probability of immigration

0 1 2 3 4 5

0.0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

Number of immigrants

Pro

babili

ty

Decrease mean annual rate:

0.77 to 0.38

Page 29: Eradicating stoats from Resolution Island, Fiordland ... · Stoat eradication • 2500 traps spaced 105 m apart • Traps reset Jan, July and Nov.

Decrease immigration by 0.50

Probability of Eradication = 0.46

Probability of < 11 stoats = 0.53

Page 30: Eradicating stoats from Resolution Island, Fiordland ... · Stoat eradication • 2500 traps spaced 105 m apart • Traps reset Jan, July and Nov.

Equal female : male ratio

Probability of Eradication = 0.33

Probability of < 11 stoats = 0.94

Page 31: Eradicating stoats from Resolution Island, Fiordland ... · Stoat eradication • 2500 traps spaced 105 m apart • Traps reset Jan, July and Nov.

0.047 to 0.094

Increase per-night probability of

capture if trap is at home range

centre

Page 32: Eradicating stoats from Resolution Island, Fiordland ... · Stoat eradication • 2500 traps spaced 105 m apart • Traps reset Jan, July and Nov.

Increase trap attraction x2

Prob. of Eradication = 0.52

Prob. of < 11 stoats = 0.75

Page 33: Eradicating stoats from Resolution Island, Fiordland ... · Stoat eradication • 2500 traps spaced 105 m apart • Traps reset Jan, July and Nov.

Attract females, improve traps, reduce immigration

Probability of Eradication = 0.87

Probability of < 11 stoats = 0.99

Page 34: Eradicating stoats from Resolution Island, Fiordland ... · Stoat eradication • 2500 traps spaced 105 m apart • Traps reset Jan, July and Nov.

Summary

Suppression or eradication is possible

Three major challenges:

• Increase ability to control females

• Increase overall probability of capture

• Decrease immigration

Page 35: Eradicating stoats from Resolution Island, Fiordland ... · Stoat eradication • 2500 traps spaced 105 m apart • Traps reset Jan, July and Nov.

Summary

Suppression

• Increase capture of females

– 1 female : 1 male

– Fertility control

• Probability of suppression = 0.94

Page 36: Eradicating stoats from Resolution Island, Fiordland ... · Stoat eradication • 2500 traps spaced 105 m apart • Traps reset Jan, July and Nov.

Summary

Eradication

• Increase capture of females

– Or fertility control

• Increase probability of capture

• Decrease immigration

• Probability of eradication = 0.95

Page 37: Eradicating stoats from Resolution Island, Fiordland ... · Stoat eradication • 2500 traps spaced 105 m apart • Traps reset Jan, July and Nov.

Thank you

Sam Gillingham assisted with coding

Funding:

• Foundation for Research, Science &

Technology

• Australian Invasive Animals

Cooperative Research Centre

Page 38: Eradicating stoats from Resolution Island, Fiordland ... · Stoat eradication • 2500 traps spaced 105 m apart • Traps reset Jan, July and Nov.

End