An introductory and comprehensive sketch :Epidemiology and research methodology : Dr. Srabana Misra Bhagabaty, MD Department of Preventive Oncology Dr.B.Borooah Cancer Institute
An introductory and comprehensive sketch :Epidemiology and research methodology:
Dr. Srabana Misra Bhagabaty, MDDepartment of Preventive Oncology
Dr.B.Borooah Cancer Institute
Headlines• Definitions of epidemiology• Dawn of epidemiology: history• Aims of epidemiology• Components of basic epidemiology• Types of epidemiological studies and methods• Basic measurements in epidemiology• Association and causation
Dr Srabana Misra Bhagabaty
Classically speaking
Epidemiology derived from the word epidemicWhich is a very old word dating back to 3rd centuryBC• Epi = upon• Demos = people• Ology = science• Epidemiology = the science which deals with what falls
upon people…..• Bridge between biomedical, social and behavioral
sciencesDr Srabana Misra Bhagabaty
Old definitions1.THE BRANCH OF MEDICAL SCIENCE WHICH TREATS
EPIDEMICS (Parkin,1873)
2.The science of the mass phenomena of infectious diseases(Wade Hampton Frost ,1927)
3.The study of disease, any disease,as a mass phenomenon (Greenwood,1934)
4.The study of the distribution and determinants of disease frequency in man(Mac Mahon, 1960)
Dr Srabana Misra Bhagabaty
1988: John M .Last definition
“ The study of the distribution and determinants of health related states or events in specified populations and application of this study to the control of health problems”
Dr Srabana Misra Bhagabaty
A Modern Definition
Study of the occurrence and distribution of health-related diseases or events in specified populations, including the study of the determinants influencing such states, and the application of this knowledge to control the health problem (Porta M, Last J, Greenland S. A Dictionary of Epidemiology, 2008)
Dr Srabana Misra Bhagabaty
Father of modern epidemiology>The first cases of cholera in England were reported in1831>Between 1831 and 1854, tens of thousands of people inEngland died of cholera > “Within 76 meters of the spot where Cambridge Street joins
Broad Street there were upwards of 500 fatal attacks of cholera in 10 days
Dr. Snow worked around the clock to track down information from hospital and public records on when the outbreak began and whether the victims drank water from the Broad Street pump.
Ref:1
Dr Srabana Misra Bhagabaty
Dr Srabana Misra Bhagabaty
Dr Srabana Misra Bhagabaty
Cholera, is a Greek word, which means the gutter of the roof. It is caused by bacteria: Vibrio cholerae, which was discovered in 1883 by Robert Koch during a diarrheal outbreak in Egypt.
Dr Srabana Misra Bhagabaty
Who is an epidemiologist ?A professional who strives to study and control the factors that influence the occurrence of disease or health-related conditions and events in specified populations and
societies, has an experience in population thinking and epidemiologic methods, and is knowledgeable about public health and causal inference in health
(Porta M, Last J, Greenland S. A Dictionary of Epidemiology, 2008)
Dr Srabana Misra Bhagabaty
Aims of EpidemiologyAccording to the International Epidemiological
Association(IEA)
> To describe the distribution and magnitude of health and disease problems in human populations
To identify etiological factors (risk Factors) in the pathogenesis of the disease
To provide data essential to the planning implementation and evaluation of services for the prevention, control and treatment of the disease and to the setting up of priorities amongst those services
Dr Srabana Misra Bhagabaty
Ultimately
To eliminate or reduce the health problem or its consequences
To promote the health and wellbeing of the society as a whole
Dr Srabana Misra Bhagabaty
Three Components epidemiology
Main three components
ofepidemiology
Disease distribution
Disease distribution
Diseasefrequency
Diseasedeterminants
Dr Srabana Misra Bhagabaty
Component:1 disease frequency
It is to measure the disease or health situation tounderstand gravity/emergency of the issue
How it is measured: by biostatistical tools forbasic measurements in epidemiology in the formof RATES and RATIOS
Dr Srabana Misra Bhagabaty
Component:2 disease distributionDescriptive epidemiology towards
hypothesis formulationIn terms ofTime: to understand disease fluctuation
patterns in relation to time i.e. short term/periodic /long term
Place in terms of international, national, rural-urban, local variations
Person in terms of age, sex, ethnicity, marietal status, occupation, social status, behaviour, stress and migration
Dr Srabana Misra Bhagabaty
Component:3 Disease determinantsThe real substance of epidemiology
analytical epidemiology
• Tests hypothesis • Understanding determinants of diseases from
more solid proofs• For formulating scientifically sound health
programs, interventions and policies
Dr Srabana Misra Bhagabaty
Types of epidemiological studies and methods
Observational studies a) Descriptive b) Analytic >ecological /correlation >cross sectional/prevalence >case control/ case reference
>cohort/follow up
Dr Srabana Misra Bhagabaty
EXPERIMENTAL /INTERVENTION STUDIES
a) Randomized controlled trials /clinical trials
b) Field trials /community intervention trials
c) Community trials
Dr Srabana Misra Bhagabaty
Basic measurements in epidemiology
• Measurements in epidemiology: The scope is very broad, unlimited and includes the following (ref-4)
1. Mortality2. Morbidity 3. Disability 4. Presence/absence or distribution of the characteristics or
attributes as well as suspected environmental and other factors of the disease
5. Medical needs, available facilities and utilization of these medical or other health related services
6. Demographic variables
Dr Srabana Misra Bhagabaty
BASIC REQUREMENTS IN EPIDEMIOLOGICAL TESTS/ MEASUREMENTS
Is the quality control to reduce
errors
Dr Srabana Misra Bhagabaty
By assuring
1.Validity/ accuracy
2.Reliability/precision/reproducibility
Of the epidemiological measurements and tools
Sensitivity
Specificity
Dr Srabana Misra Bhagabaty
VALIDITY
Validity refers to the closeness with which measured values agree with “ true” values
Two components of validity are
A. SensitivityB. Specificity
Dr Srabana Misra Bhagabaty
Sensitivity
Introduced by yerushalmy (ref:5) in 1940 asstatistical index of diagnostic accuracy
IT IS TRUE POSITIVEExample of true positive : for example if a testfor a disease is 90 percent sensitive that means 90 out of 100 diseased people will show a positivetest result where as only 10 out of 100 disesed people will show a negative result (false negative)
90 percent sensitivity
100 People with the disease
90 0ut of 100 diseased shows a positive test 10 out of 100 diseasedshowed a negative result
Dr Srabana Misra Bhagabaty
Specificity
TRUE NEGATIVE
Ability of a test to identifycorrectly those who do nothave the disease
Dr Srabana Misra Bhagabaty
90 percent specificity
100 People without the disease
90 0ut of 100 non- diseased shows a negative test
10 out of 100 non-diseasedshowed a positive result
Dr Srabana Misra Bhagabaty
Calculation of validity
Test Diagnosis TotalDiseased Not Diseased
Positive A ( true positive) B ( false positive) A + B
Negative C ( false negative) D (true Negaive) C+D
Total A+C B+D A+B+C+D
Dr Srabana Misra Bhagabaty
Sensitivity = true positive (A) -------- ------------------------- ---------X 100 true positive (A)+ false negative(C)
Specificity= true negative (D) ------------------------------------------------X 100 false positive( B) + true negative(D)
Dr Srabana Misra Bhagabaty
Tools of measurement expression of disease magnitude
1. Rates2. Ratios3. Proportion
Dr Srabana Misra Bhagabaty
Before going to the basic tools of measurements…
Numerator : Numerator refers to the number of times an
event has occurred in a population, during a specified time period.
Denominator : Gives meaning to the numerator
Dr Srabana Misra Bhagabaty
RATE
• Measures occurrence of some particular event in a population during a given time period
• The epidemiologist has to choose an appropriate denominator while calculating a rate.
a) Related to the population b) Related to the total events
Dr Srabana Misra Bhagabaty
Related to the population denominators
• Mid-year population• Population at risk• Person time• Person distance• Population sub groups
Dr Srabana Misra Bhagabaty
Related to the total events
Related to the total events in stead of the totalPopulation
Example : accidents rate calculation may have
denominators like per 100/1000/….vehicles than total population as all population may not use vehicle
Dr Srabana Misra Bhagabaty
Elements of RATE• Numerator• Denominator• Time specification• Multiplier
Expression of rate : as per 1000 or some other round figures selectedaccording to convenience and to avoid fractions
Dr Srabana Misra Bhagabaty
Categories of rate
• Crude rates/ unstandardized rates : actually observed rates. Example: birth and death rates.
• Specific rates : Actually observed rates due to specific cause; specific groups; specific time periods
• Standardized rates: these are obtained by direct or indirect methods of standardization
Dr Srabana Misra Bhagabaty
RATIO
• RELATION IN SIZE OF TWO RANDOM QUANTITIES• THE NEMERATOR IS NOT A PART OF THE
DENOMINATOR
PROPORTION A proportion is a ratio which indicates the
relation of a part of the whole. The numerator is always included in the denominator
Measurement of morbidityIncidence
Number of new cases occurring in a definedpopulation during a specified period of time
Number of spells of sickness starting in a defined period---------------------------------------------------------------------------X 100Mean number of persons exposed to risk in that period
Uses of incidence: a) control disease b) for research : etiology, pathogenesis disease distribution efficiency of preventive and therapeutic measures
Prevalence Prevalence: All current (old and new) cases existing at a given point or over aPeriod of time in a given population.Types of prevalence : POINT PREVELENCE Number of all current cases of a specific disease existing at a given point of
time-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
X100Estimated population at the same point of time
PERIOD PREVELENCE:Number on existing cases during a period----------------------------------------------------------X100Estimated mid-interval population at risk
Uses of prevalence:a) Estimates the magnitude of health/ disease problems in the community b) Identify high risk populationsc) Administrative and planning purposes e.g hospital beds, man powerneeds, rehabilitation facilities etc.
• Relation of incidence to prevalence :• Prevalence= Incidence X Mean Duration • P=IXD
• ASSOCIATION and CAUSATION : concurrence of two variables more often than would be expected by chanceCorrelation determines the degree of associationCorrelation coefficient varies from -1to +1 Correlation may not measure risk.Causation implies correlation but co-relation may not imply causation
ASSOCIATION AND CAUSATION
Types of association:
A) Spurious association:B) Indirect association:C) Direct association:
Criteria for judging causality:
>Temporal association :>Strength of association: >Specificity of association:>Consistency of the association:>Biological plausibility:>Coherence of association:
uses of epidemiology
• History : rise and fall of disease in the population
• Community diagnosis• Planning and evaluation• Evaluation of individuals risks and chances• Syndrome identification• Completing the natural history of disease• Searching for cause and risk factorsDr Srabana Misra Bhagabaty
References
1.Snow J. On the mode of communication of cholera. 2nd ed. In: Snow on Cholera. (Reprint.) New York, New York: Hafner Publishing Co., 1965. Available at http://www.ph.ucla.edu/epi/snow.html.
2. Bumberg, M.S(1966).In:Chronic Diseases and Public Health,Lilienfeld, et al (eds). John Hopkins
3. Park textbook of Preventive and Social Medicine: 21st edition 4.Fox ,J.P etal(1970). Epidemiology : Man and disease, New
York, Macmillan5. WHO(1959) Techn. Rep. Ser.,No. 164
Dr Srabana Misra Bhagabaty
“I keep six honest serving-men (They taught me all I knew);
Their names are What and Why and When
And How and Where and Who”
following the story "Elephant's Child" in "Just So Stories" Poem by Rudyard Kipling:
Dr Srabana Misra Bhagabaty
Thank you Dr Srabana Misra Bhagabaty