Page 1 EPA Nonroad Vehicle and Engine Program Society of Automotive Engineers and U.S. Department of Energy Off-Highway Emissions and Systems Efficiency Workshop for Heavy Vehicles U.S. Environmental Protection Agency Office of Transportation and Air Quality April 18, 2001 Cleophas Jackson
41
Embed
EPA Nonroad Vehicle and Engine Program/67531/metadc722362/m2/1/high_re… · Page 1 EPA Nonroad Vehicle and Engine Program Society of Automotive Engineers and U.S. Department of Energy
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1
EPA Nonroad Vehicle and EngineProgram
Society of Automotive Engineers and U.S. Department ofEnergy
Off-Highway Emissions and Systems EfficiencyWorkshop
for Heavy VehiclesU.S. Environmental Protection Agency
Office of Transportation and Air Quality
April 18, 2001
Cleophas Jackson
Page 2
Overview of Briefing
■ Nonroad is a big source of pollution
■ We’ve come a long way
■ We’ve got a ways to go
■ We’re working on it!
Page 3
Overview, continued
■ Background
■ Historical context and statutory authority
■ Inventory
■ Current nonroad programs
■ Future programs
Page 4
Background: What is Nonroad?
■ Non-highway engines, vehicles, & equipment that move or canbe moved
■ More than 80 basic categories (agricultural, construction,marine, etc.)
■ EPA’s NONROAD model covers 462 specific equipment types,not including locomotives, aircraft, commercial marine
■ Complicated industry structure: hundreds of manufacturers,many of them very small
Page 5
Major Nonroad Equipment Types
■ Aircraft
■ Airport service
■ Agricultural
■ Commercial
■ Commercial marine
■ Construction
■ Industrial
■ Lawn & garden (com & res)
■ Locomotives
■ Logging
■ Railroad service
■ Recreational vehicles
■ Recreational marine
Page 6
Historical & Statutory Context
■ No EPA program prior to 1990 Clean Air Act
■ Section 213 of 1990 Act directed EPA to:– evaluate contribution of nonroad sources to urban nonattainment
– adopt standards if warranted
– consider comparable highway standards in determining stringency
– achieve greatest emission reduction possible considering cost, safety, etc.
– regulate any nonroad category that contributes to air pollution
■ Section 209 of 1990 Act:– preempts all state regulation of locomotives and of farm and construction
equipment <175 hp
– allows California to set independent standards for other nonroad sources,with authorization from EPA Administrator
– allows other states to adopt California standards
■ Section 231 covers aircraft separately
Page 7
History, continued
■ 1991 “NEVES” study found nonroad sources significant toozone and CO nonattainment, also major source of PM
■ EPA initiated comprehensive nonroad program
■ Approach: do what makes sense, get big reductions first– model and inventory development
– regulations
– education and voluntary programs» industry
» consumers
■ “Finding” process complete for all categories
Page 8
Nonroad Contributions to TotalInventory (1996)
■ Nonroad sources contributesignificantly to NOx, PM, andVOC emissions
■ Locomotives, construction andfarm equipment are largestsources of NOx
■ Construction and farmequipment are largest sources ofPM
■ Lawn, garden and recreationalmarine equipment are largestsources of VOC
46%
32%
22%
N o n ro a d
H ig h w a y
To ta l
78%
15%
7%
N o n ro a d
H ig h w a y
To ta l
30%
14%
56%
N o n ro a d
H ig h w a y
To ta l
NOx
PM2.5
VOC
Page 9
Impact of Controls on 2000 - 2007Inventory
0102030405060708090
100
N O x P M H C
Per
cent
of 2
000
Em
issi
ons
20002007
Page 10
2007 NOx Inventories
Highway54%
Nonroad46%
Locomotives16%
Marine Diesel21%
Land-based Diesel47%
Large SI8%
Other8%
Mobile Sources Nonroad
~10 million tons per year ~5 million tons per year
Page 11
2007 HC Inventories
Highway44%
Nonroad56%
Rec. Vehicles21%
Marine SI25%
Land-based Diesel7%
Large SI5%
Small SI32%
Other10%
Mobile Sources Nonroad
~5 million tons per year ~2.6 million tons per year
Page 12
2007 PM Inventories
Highway30%
Nonroad70%
Marine Diesel10%
Marine SI8%
Land-based Diesel52%
Locomotives6%
Small SI13%
Other11%
Mobile Sources Nonroad
~600,000 tons per year ~420,000 tons per year
Page 13
2007 CO Inventories
Highway57%
Nonroad43%
Rec. Vehicles13%
Marine SI6%
Large SI8%
Small SI65%
Other8%
Mobile Sources Nonroad
~ 77 million tons per year ~ 30 million tons per year
■ Engine types– Large majority are derived from automotive engines
– A few are air-cooled industrial engines
■ Fuel types– 70 percent of engines use LPG
– Gasoline is the alternative fuel
– Fuel conversions and dual-fuel engines are common
Page 30
Large SI Regulatory History
■ California ARB adopted emission standards in October 1998– 3 g/hp-hr NOx+NMHC standard phases in from 2001 through 2004
– Projected technology includes electronic fuel systems with 3-way catalyst
– Compliance program includes production-line and in-use testing bymanufacturers
■ EPA proposal will likely be consistent with ARB, with a fewremaining issues– Level of emission standards
– Transient duty cycle
– Not-to-exceed provisions
– Basic engine diagnostics
– Evaporative emissions
■ Anticipating 80 to 90 percent reduction (NOx + HC)
Page 31
Recreational Vehicles
■ Proposal due September 14, 2001
■ Three main vehicle types:– Off-road motorcycles, snowmobiles, and all-terrain vehicles (ATVs)
■ EPA has not yet set standards for these vehicles. California hasadopted “limited” standards for off-road motorcycles and ATVs
■ We are also concerned about personal exposure to potentially highlevels of CO and toxic emissions from these vehicles
Page 32
Recreational Vehicles
■ EPA also released an ANPRM in November 2000 to start thestandard-setting process
■ EPA requests comment in several areas including:– technologies that may be available to reduce emissions
– the timing and level of new emission standards
– test procedures for measuring emissions from vehicles and engines
– compliance programs
– competition provisions
Page 33
Aircraft Authority
■ CAA section 231 gives EPA authority to setemission standards
■ CAA section 232 gives FAA authority to enforcethese standards
■ CAA section 233 preempts states from settingaircraft standards
Page 34
Aircraft Emission Standards
■ Aircraft engines are international commodities and frequentlytraverse national boundaries– ICAO process used in setting standards
■ HC, NOx, and CO standards for jet engines greater than 26.7kilonewtons of thrust (most mid to large commercial jets)
■ Smoke standards for jet and turboprop engines
■ EPA aligned with international standards (ICAO) in 1997– HC standards for all engines produced after 1983
– CO standards for all engines produced after July 1997
– NOx standards for newly designed engines after 1995 and all engines producedafter 2000
■ More stringent NOx standards adopted by ICAO in 1999, to beimplemented for newly designed engines after 2003– We plan to alight with these standards in the future
Page 35
Aircraft Inventory
Atlant
aBos
ton
Charlo
tteChic
ago
Housto
nLo
s Ang
eles
New Y
ork
Philad
elphia
Phoen
ix
Was
hingt
on, D
C
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
% o
f Mob
ile S
ourc
e E
mis
sion
s
19902010
Atlant
a
Bosto
nCha
rlotte
Chicag
oHou
ston
Los A
ngele
sNew
Yor
kPhil
adelp
hiaPho
enix
Was
hingt
on, D
C0
5
10
15
20
% o
f Mob
ile S
ourc
e E
mis
sion
s
19902010
■ Commercial aircraft componentof regional mobile sourceemissions
■ Nationally, NOx emissionsexpected to increase 25%between 1995 and 2020
■ Aircraft emissions can havevery significant local/regionalimpact
NOx
VOC
Page 36
EPA/FAA Voluntary EmissionReduction Initiative
■ EPA & FAA co-chairing national stakeholder process todevelop voluntary program to reduce pollutants from aircraftand other aviation sources
■ Study underway to assess existing and projected emissions
■ Initative to also evaluate control options– technological feasibility
– cost effectiveness
■ Possible options include retrofitting, low-pollution technology,efficient operating practices, GSE electrification
■ Process to conclude by summer 2001
Page 37
Other Nonroad Program Issues
■ Harmonization– international
– California
■ Toxics– In general, any control that reduces PM and VOC emissions also reduces
toxics
– 202(l) rule calls for research plan to determine whether further, specific,control of nonroad toxics is feasible and warranted
Page 38
Phase-In of Nonroad Control Programs
Current EPA Nonroad Control Program Phase-In Schedule
Nonroad Diesel
Comm ercial Marine
Recreational Marine
Lawn & Garden (sm all SI)
Locomotives
Industrial (large SI)
Recreational Equipm ent
1995 2010
1996 2008
2000 2005
2005
2000 2007
20061998
1997 2007
** rem anu facture s tandards app ly to engines bu illt s ince 1973
Page 39
Summary of Rulemaking Schedule
C a te g o r y S a le s p e r y e a r F in a l R u le s
A ir c ra f t e n g in e s 1 ,0 0 0 1 9 8 2 , 1 9 9 7
L a n d -b a s e d n o n ro a d d ie s e l 3 6 0 ,0 0 0 1 9 9 4 , 1 9 9 8 ,
L o c o m o t iv e s 6 0 0 1 9 9 8
M a r in e d ie s e l - - c o m m e rc ia l 1 5 ,0 0 0 1 9 9 9
M a r in e S I - - o u tb o a rd & P W C 8 0 0 ,0 0 0 1 9 9 6
R e c re a t io n a l m a r in e - - d ie s e l a n d S D / I g a s o lin e
1 2 0 ,0 0 0 S e p te m b e r 2 0 0 2
L a w n & G a rd e n S I < 1 9 k W 1 5 ,0 0 0 ,0 0 0 1 9 9 5 , 1 9 9 9
In d u s t r ia l S I > 1 9 k W 1 5 0 ,0 0 0 S e p te m b e r 2 0 0 2
R e c re a t io n a l v e h ic le s - - s n o w m o b i le s , m o to r c y c le s
8 0 0 ,0 0 0 S e p te m b e r 2 0 0 2
Page 40
Summary - Changing NonroadContribution to Inventory
0
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
3000
3500
Cur ren t 2007 2030
annu
al to
ns (t
hous
ands
)
Nonroad
Highw ay
Other Sourc es
0
5000
10000
15000
20000
Cur ren t 2007 2030
annu
al to
ns (t
hous
ands
)
Nonroad
Highw ay
Other Sourc es
0
10000
20000
30000
Cur ren t 2007 2030annu
al to
ns (
thou
sand
s)
Nonroad
Highw ay
Other Sourc es
■ These trends reflect programsfinalized as of December 2000
■ Rules on books provide some,but not enough control
■ Nonroad diesel Phase 3 and“Pentathalon” rules will becritically important for thefuture
NOx
PM2.5
VOC
Page 41
Contacts
■ For additional information--– www.epa.gov/otaq/nonroad.htm