8/18/2019 Environmental Dispute Setlement
1/18
F R A N K Y B U T A R B U T A R
Environmental Dispute
Settlement and Right to Sue
8/18/2019 Environmental Dispute Setlement
2/18
Definition in UUPPLH
See in Art 1 (25
Arti!le "#$%&
'o prote!t !ivil rights of parties
8/18/2019 Environmental Dispute Setlement
3/18
EDS
By Court:
Unsuccessful ofNon-Court
Non Court:a. Voluntary
b. Can not apply onEnvron!entalCr!e
c. Can use "e#atonan# Arbtraton
8/18/2019 Environmental Dispute Setlement
4/18
Environmental Dispute Resolution (EDR ) *on$+ourt
,orm and standard indemnit)- !ompensation
Restoration
Spe!ifi! a!tions
Prevention a!tions
8/18/2019 Environmental Dispute Setlement
5/18
EDR ) 'hird Part) (.ediation
*eutral
Approved ) parties
*o famil) or /or0ing relationship
Has- have !ompeten!e in this field*o interest et/een the parties
*on$legall) inding de!ision
8/18/2019 Environmental Dispute Setlement
6/18
EDR ) 'hird Part) (Aritration
Same reuirements /ith mediator ut the de!ision islegall) inding to the parties
8/18/2019 Environmental Dispute Setlement
7/18
Providing Servi!e nstitution to Resolve EDR
People !an estalish
3ov4t a!!ommodate
ndependent and impartiall)
8/18/2019 Environmental Dispute Setlement
8/18
Environmental Servi!e Provider
PP *o 5# 'ahun 2666 (Lemaga Pen)edia 7asaPela)anan PSLH di Luar Pengad
8epmen LH *o 99 'ahun 266&
8epmen LH *o 9" 'ahun 266&Perma *o 2 'ahun 266& tentang prosedur mediasi
pengadilan
8/18/2019 Environmental Dispute Setlement
9/18
*on +ourt EDR
Prevent different de!ision
La/ !ertaint)
+ivil- private la/ pro!edure
+an e spe!ifi! la/ a!tions: repair /aste s)stem;destro) of the sour!e of pollution and environmentaldamage
8/18/2019 Environmental Dispute Setlement
10/18
ndemnit) and Restoration
1 Unla/ful a!tion
2 'ransfer and !hange of usiness form
& Stipulation of !oer!ive sum
8/18/2019 Environmental Dispute Setlement
11/18
Unla/ful A!tion (onrechtmatigdaad
1&
8/18/2019 Environmental Dispute Setlement
12/18
Stri!t Liailit)
Ha=ardous !ase
Serious threat
>ithout an) prove
8/18/2019 Environmental Dispute Setlement
13/18
E?pired
+ivil la/ pro!edure
Sin!e it is 0no/n there is offense- violation
t does not prevail on the ha=ardous environmental
!rime
8/18/2019 Environmental Dispute Setlement
14/18
Legal Su@e!t Plaintiff- Litigant
3overnment and Lo!al 3overnment
So!iet) (!lass a!tion
Environmental *3 (Standing to Sue
Administrative sue
8/18/2019 Environmental Dispute Setlement
15/18
Right to Sue (3overnment and Lo!al 3overnment
ndemnit) B and
spe!ifi! a!tion
8/18/2019 Environmental Dispute Setlement
16/18
+lass A!tion
Represent their right or people interest
Similarit) on the !ase
Similarit) on the legal fa!ts
Similarit) on the !laim- indi!tment
8/18/2019 Environmental Dispute Setlement
17/18
Standing to Sue
Approved as a legal od)
'he statue for environmental preservation
2 )ears minimum environmental a!tivit)
A!!usation onl) the spe!ifi! a!tion; not indemnit)
8/18/2019 Environmental Dispute Setlement
18/18
Administrative +laim- A!!usation
Environmental Li!en!e$ reuire EA
Environmental Li!ense$ reuire U8L- UPL
Cusiness Li!ense$ Environmental Li!ense
Administrative la/ pro!!edure