Top Banner
Environmental Constraints and Species Differences in Establishment and Expansion of Three Freshwater Tidal Marsh Plant Species Taylor Sloey 1 and Mark W. Hester 1 1. University of Louisiana at Lafayette Coastal Plant Ecology Laboratory Lafayette, LA. U.S.A.
47

Environmental Constraints and Species Differences in Establishment and Expansion … ·  · 2012-06-20Species Differences in Establishment and Expansion of ... •% Survival •%

May 25, 2018

Download

Documents

ngoquynh
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: Environmental Constraints and Species Differences in Establishment and Expansion … ·  · 2012-06-20Species Differences in Establishment and Expansion of ... •% Survival •%

Environmental Constraints and

Species Differences in

Establishment and Expansion of

Three Freshwater Tidal Marsh

Plant Species

Taylor Sloey1 and Mark W. Hester1

1. University of Louisiana at Lafayette – Coastal Plant Ecology Laboratory

Lafayette, LA. U.S.A.

Page 2: Environmental Constraints and Species Differences in Establishment and Expansion … ·  · 2012-06-20Species Differences in Establishment and Expansion of ... •% Survival •%

Sacramento-San Joaquin

Page 3: Environmental Constraints and Species Differences in Establishment and Expansion … ·  · 2012-06-20Species Differences in Establishment and Expansion of ... •% Survival •%

Levee Construction

• y

Page 4: Environmental Constraints and Species Differences in Establishment and Expansion … ·  · 2012-06-20Species Differences in Establishment and Expansion of ... •% Survival •%

X

• y

Page 5: Environmental Constraints and Species Differences in Establishment and Expansion … ·  · 2012-06-20Species Differences in Establishment and Expansion of ... •% Survival •%

Liberty Island

Page 6: Environmental Constraints and Species Differences in Establishment and Expansion … ·  · 2012-06-20Species Differences in Establishment and Expansion of ... •% Survival •%

LEV

EE B

REA

CH

Page 7: Environmental Constraints and Species Differences in Establishment and Expansion … ·  · 2012-06-20Species Differences in Establishment and Expansion of ... •% Survival •%

LEV

EE B

REA

CH

Page 8: Environmental Constraints and Species Differences in Establishment and Expansion … ·  · 2012-06-20Species Differences in Establishment and Expansion of ... •% Survival •%

Research Questions

• How might environmental conditions impact

vegetation establishment and expansion?

Page 9: Environmental Constraints and Species Differences in Establishment and Expansion … ·  · 2012-06-20Species Differences in Establishment and Expansion of ... •% Survival •%

Research Questions

• How might environmental conditions impact

vegetation establishment and expansion?

• What differences exist among species

regarding establishment and expansion?

Page 10: Environmental Constraints and Species Differences in Establishment and Expansion … ·  · 2012-06-20Species Differences in Establishment and Expansion of ... •% Survival •%

Seed-Bank Assay Transplant Study

Page 11: Environmental Constraints and Species Differences in Establishment and Expansion … ·  · 2012-06-20Species Differences in Establishment and Expansion of ... •% Survival •%

Seed-Bank Assay

Exposed

Exposed

Protected

Protected

September 2010

June 2011

September 2011

Page 12: Environmental Constraints and Species Differences in Establishment and Expansion … ·  · 2012-06-20Species Differences in Establishment and Expansion of ... •% Survival •%
Page 13: Environmental Constraints and Species Differences in Establishment and Expansion … ·  · 2012-06-20Species Differences in Establishment and Expansion of ... •% Survival •%
Page 14: Environmental Constraints and Species Differences in Establishment and Expansion … ·  · 2012-06-20Species Differences in Establishment and Expansion of ... •% Survival •%

Transplant Study

Page 15: Environmental Constraints and Species Differences in Establishment and Expansion … ·  · 2012-06-20Species Differences in Establishment and Expansion of ... •% Survival •%

Species Selection

Typha

latifolia

Schoenoplectus

acutus

Schoenoplectus

californicus

Page 16: Environmental Constraints and Species Differences in Establishment and Expansion … ·  · 2012-06-20Species Differences in Establishment and Expansion of ... •% Survival •%

Transplant Stages

Rhizome Adult Transplant

Page 17: Environmental Constraints and Species Differences in Establishment and Expansion … ·  · 2012-06-20Species Differences in Establishment and Expansion of ... •% Survival •%

Exposed

Open Water

Exposed

Marsh Fringe

Protected

Open Water

Protected

Marsh Fringe

Page 18: Environmental Constraints and Species Differences in Establishment and Expansion … ·  · 2012-06-20Species Differences in Establishment and Expansion of ... •% Survival •%
Page 19: Environmental Constraints and Species Differences in Establishment and Expansion … ·  · 2012-06-20Species Differences in Establishment and Expansion of ... •% Survival •%

Monitoring

EDAPHIC • Elevation

• Soil Bulk Density

• Soil Redox

Potential

• Pore Water pH

• Soil % OM

• Soil Particle

Distribution

• Depth to

Compacted Soil

Layer

Initial Planting: June 2010

3 Month: Sept 2010

12 Month: June 2011

24 Month: June 2012

Page 20: Environmental Constraints and Species Differences in Establishment and Expansion … ·  · 2012-06-20Species Differences in Establishment and Expansion of ... •% Survival •%

Monitoring

Initial Planting: June 2010

3 Month: Sept 2010

12 Month: June 2011

24 Month: June 2012

EDAPHIC • Elevation

• Soil Bulk Density

• Soil Redox

Potential

• Pore Water pH

• Soil % OM

• Soil Particle

Distribution

• Depth to

Compacted Soil

Layer

Page 21: Environmental Constraints and Species Differences in Establishment and Expansion … ·  · 2012-06-20Species Differences in Establishment and Expansion of ... •% Survival •%

Monitoring

TRANSPLANT • % Survival

• % Live Cover

• Stem Density

• Stem Height

• Area Vegetative

Expansion

Initial Planting: June 2010

3 Month: Sept 2010

12 Month: June 2011

24 Month: June 2012

Page 22: Environmental Constraints and Species Differences in Establishment and Expansion … ·  · 2012-06-20Species Differences in Establishment and Expansion of ... •% Survival •%

Monitoring

TRANSPLANT • % Survival

• % Live Cover

• Stem Density

• Stem Height

• Area Vegetative

Expansion

Initial Planting: June 2010

3 Month: Sept 2010

12 Month: June 2011

24 Month: June 2012

Page 23: Environmental Constraints and Species Differences in Establishment and Expansion … ·  · 2012-06-20Species Differences in Establishment and Expansion of ... •% Survival •%

ENVIRONMENTAL CONDITIONS

RESULTS

Page 24: Environmental Constraints and Species Differences in Establishment and Expansion … ·  · 2012-06-20Species Differences in Establishment and Expansion of ... •% Survival •%

Elevation

0

0.5

2

1.5

1.0

MHHW

MHW

MTL

MLW

MLLW

Ele

vati

on

NA

VD

88 (

mete

rs)

Exposed Fringe

Exposed Open Water

Protected Fringe

Protected Open Water

Page 25: Environmental Constraints and Species Differences in Establishment and Expansion … ·  · 2012-06-20Species Differences in Establishment and Expansion of ... •% Survival •%

Edaphic Characteristics

1.0

0.5

0

So

il B

ulk

Den

sit

y (

g/c

m3)

EXPOSED

FRINGE

EXPOSED

WATER

PROTECT

FRINGE

PROTECT

WATER

P< 0.0001

Page 26: Environmental Constraints and Species Differences in Establishment and Expansion … ·  · 2012-06-20Species Differences in Establishment and Expansion of ... •% Survival •%

Edaphic Characteristics

0

-10

-20

Dep

th t

o S

oil R

esis

tan

ce (

cm

)

EXPOSED

FRINGE

EXPOSED

WATER

PROTECT

FRINGE

PROTECT

WATER

P< 0.0001

Page 27: Environmental Constraints and Species Differences in Establishment and Expansion … ·  · 2012-06-20Species Differences in Establishment and Expansion of ... •% Survival •%
Page 28: Environmental Constraints and Species Differences in Establishment and Expansion … ·  · 2012-06-20Species Differences in Establishment and Expansion of ... •% Survival •%

TRANSPLANT RESPONSE

RESULTS

Page 29: Environmental Constraints and Species Differences in Establishment and Expansion … ·  · 2012-06-20Species Differences in Establishment and Expansion of ... •% Survival •%

Rhizomes Adult Transplants

S. acutus S. californicus T. latifolia

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100

% Survival (Rhizomes) 2010

S. acutus S. californicus T. latifolia

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100

% Survival (Transplant) 2010

Su

rviv

al (%

)

Survival : Sept 2010

Exposed Fringe Exposed Open Water Protected Fringe Protected Open Water

S. acutus S. californicus T. latifolia S. acutus S. californicus T. latifolia

Life Stage: P<0.0001

Species: P<0.0001

Page 30: Environmental Constraints and Species Differences in Establishment and Expansion … ·  · 2012-06-20Species Differences in Establishment and Expansion of ... •% Survival •%

Adult Transplants Rhizome Transplants

June 2011

Page 31: Environmental Constraints and Species Differences in Establishment and Expansion … ·  · 2012-06-20Species Differences in Establishment and Expansion of ... •% Survival •%

Stem Density : Sept 2010

S. acutus S. californicus T. latifolia

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

Ste

m D

en

sit

y (

per

0.2

5m

2 p

lot)

S. acutus S. californicus T. latifolia

Exposed Fringe

Exposed Open Water

Protected Fringe

Protected Open Water

Species: P=0.0002

Site: P=0.2762

Page 32: Environmental Constraints and Species Differences in Establishment and Expansion … ·  · 2012-06-20Species Differences in Establishment and Expansion of ... •% Survival •%

S. acutus S. californicus T. latifolia

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

Stem Density : June 2011

S. acutus S. californicus T. latifolia

Ste

m D

en

sit

y (

per

0.2

5m

2 p

lot)

Exposed Fringe

Exposed Open Water

Protected Fringe

Protected Open Water

Species: P<0.0001

Site: P=0.9547

Page 33: Environmental Constraints and Species Differences in Establishment and Expansion … ·  · 2012-06-20Species Differences in Establishment and Expansion of ... •% Survival •%

Dead Typha on

the West side of

Liberty Island in

June 2011 Photo: Hester 2011

Page 34: Environmental Constraints and Species Differences in Establishment and Expansion … ·  · 2012-06-20Species Differences in Establishment and Expansion of ... •% Survival •%

Transplant Expansion

0

50

100

150

200

250

300

350

0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

T. latifolia

Are

a E

xp

an

sio

n (

cm

2)

TIME (months)

Exposed Fringe

Exposed Open Water

Protected Fringe

Protected Open Water

Site: P=0.2470

Page 35: Environmental Constraints and Species Differences in Establishment and Expansion … ·  · 2012-06-20Species Differences in Establishment and Expansion of ... •% Survival •%

Transplant Expansion

0

500

1000

1500

2000

2500

3000

3500

0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

S. acutus

Are

a E

xp

an

sio

n (

cm

2)

TIME (months)

Exposed Fringe

Exposed Open Water

Protected Fringe

Protected Open Water

Site: P=0.5567

Page 36: Environmental Constraints and Species Differences in Establishment and Expansion … ·  · 2012-06-20Species Differences in Establishment and Expansion of ... •% Survival •%

Transplant Expansion

0

5000

10000

15000

20000

25000

30000

35000

0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

S. californicus

Are

a E

xp

an

sio

n (

cm

2)

Exposed Fringe

Exposed Open Water

Protected Fringe

Protected Open Water

TIME (months)

Site: P=0.0132

Page 37: Environmental Constraints and Species Differences in Establishment and Expansion … ·  · 2012-06-20Species Differences in Establishment and Expansion of ... •% Survival •%

Protected Open Water Exposed Open Water

Page 38: Environmental Constraints and Species Differences in Establishment and Expansion … ·  · 2012-06-20Species Differences in Establishment and Expansion of ... •% Survival •%

Conclusions

Environmental Characteristics

Degree of soil compaction greater on

protected side

Page 39: Environmental Constraints and Species Differences in Establishment and Expansion … ·  · 2012-06-20Species Differences in Establishment and Expansion of ... •% Survival •%

Conclusions

Environmental Characteristics

Degree of soil compaction greater on

protected side

Species Performance

S. californicus best suited to establish and

expand

Page 40: Environmental Constraints and Species Differences in Establishment and Expansion … ·  · 2012-06-20Species Differences in Establishment and Expansion of ... •% Survival •%

S. californicus

Page 41: Environmental Constraints and Species Differences in Establishment and Expansion … ·  · 2012-06-20Species Differences in Establishment and Expansion of ... •% Survival •%

Encyclopedia of Life

S. californicus

Page 42: Environmental Constraints and Species Differences in Establishment and Expansion … ·  · 2012-06-20Species Differences in Establishment and Expansion of ... •% Survival •%

Conclusions

Environmental Characteristics

Degree of soil compaction greater on

protected side

Species Performance

S. californicus best suited to establish and

expand

Area Expansion

Soil compaction may be a limiting factor

Page 43: Environmental Constraints and Species Differences in Establishment and Expansion … ·  · 2012-06-20Species Differences in Establishment and Expansion of ... •% Survival •%
Page 44: Environmental Constraints and Species Differences in Establishment and Expansion … ·  · 2012-06-20Species Differences in Establishment and Expansion of ... •% Survival •%

Restoration Concerns:

1) Successful sexual reproduction

Page 45: Environmental Constraints and Species Differences in Establishment and Expansion … ·  · 2012-06-20Species Differences in Establishment and Expansion of ... •% Survival •%

1) Successful sexual reproduction

2) Ensure amiable edaphic conditions

Restoration Concerns:

Page 46: Environmental Constraints and Species Differences in Establishment and Expansion … ·  · 2012-06-20Species Differences in Establishment and Expansion of ... •% Survival •%

1) Successful sexual reproduction

2) Ensure amiable edaphic conditions

3) Species selection

Restoration Concerns:

Page 47: Environmental Constraints and Species Differences in Establishment and Expansion … ·  · 2012-06-20Species Differences in Establishment and Expansion of ... •% Survival •%

The Wetland Foundation … enhancing wetland education and research

®

Acknowledgements…

UL Lafayette

Coastal Plant Ecology Lab Dr. Mark W. Hester

Dr. Jonathan M. Willis

Mike Dupuis

Christine Pickens