Top Banner
Engagement in superannuation - is there really a gender gap? Dr Laura de Zwaan Assoc Prof Mark Brimble Prof Jenny Stewart
12

Engagement in superannuation - is there really a gender gap? Dr Laura de Zwaan Assoc Prof Mark Brimble Prof Jenny Stewart.

Dec 23, 2015

Download

Documents

Brianna Howard
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: Engagement in superannuation - is there really a gender gap? Dr Laura de Zwaan Assoc Prof Mark Brimble Prof Jenny Stewart.

Engagement in superannuation- is there really a gender gap?

Dr Laura de Zwaan

Assoc Prof Mark Brimble

Prof Jenny Stewart

Page 2: Engagement in superannuation - is there really a gender gap? Dr Laura de Zwaan Assoc Prof Mark Brimble Prof Jenny Stewart.

Women and Superannuation

• Women are systematically disadvantaged under the current system– Earnings-based – Less time in the workforce– More conservative– Longer life expectancy

Page 3: Engagement in superannuation - is there really a gender gap? Dr Laura de Zwaan Assoc Prof Mark Brimble Prof Jenny Stewart.

Gender and Engagement

• Super Attitudes Survey, 2012• Only 19% of women are engaged with

their superannuation • Less engagement means

– Default investment options and funds– Minimum contributions– Lower retirement savings outcomes

Page 4: Engagement in superannuation - is there really a gender gap? Dr Laura de Zwaan Assoc Prof Mark Brimble Prof Jenny Stewart.

What is Engagement?

• Cooper Review, 2010• Chetty et al., 2012

• Super Attitudes Survey, 2012• Financial Services Council, 2013

Page 5: Engagement in superannuation - is there really a gender gap? Dr Laura de Zwaan Assoc Prof Mark Brimble Prof Jenny Stewart.

Model – Dependent Variables

• I have changed my investments in the past• I have contacted a financial planner for help with superannuation• I read my member statement every year• I have called my superannuation fund within the last year• I have accessed my super details online within the last year• I know how my fund has performed compared to others• I know how much superannuation I have• I have read the annual report from my superannuation fund• I have read the PDS issued to me by my superannuation fund• I know how much in fees my superannuation fund charges

Page 6: Engagement in superannuation - is there really a gender gap? Dr Laura de Zwaan Assoc Prof Mark Brimble Prof Jenny Stewart.

Model – Explanatory and Controls

• Gender is the explanatory variable• Control variables:

• Age• Household income• Value of superannuation• Financial literacy (self-rated)

• Potential Interactions:• Gender/Value of super• Gender/Income• Income/value of super

Page 7: Engagement in superannuation - is there really a gender gap? Dr Laura de Zwaan Assoc Prof Mark Brimble Prof Jenny Stewart.

Sample

• Respondents sourced from general public and staff (general and academic) of a large university

• Received 551 responses• Women 58.8%; Men 41.2%• Even spread over groups for demographics

– exception is postgraduate degree holders (39.8%)

Page 8: Engagement in superannuation - is there really a gender gap? Dr Laura de Zwaan Assoc Prof Mark Brimble Prof Jenny Stewart.

Findings

• Gender was found to be significant for whether a respondent had changed their investments in the past

• Men are 5.564 times more likely to have changed their investments in the past. (p = 0.041).

• The overall model is significant (p = 0.000). Predicts 69.8% of the responses correctly and has a Nagelkerke R Square of 0.287.

• Also a significant interaction for gender and value of super (p = 0.046). Males with super balances of between $250,000 and $500,000 are 11.254 times more likely to have changed their investments in the past.

Page 9: Engagement in superannuation - is there really a gender gap? Dr Laura de Zwaan Assoc Prof Mark Brimble Prof Jenny Stewart.

Findings

• An interaction between gender and value of super is significant for whether a respondent reads their member statement (p = 0.017, R = 0.376)

• Interaction between gender and income for whether respondents know how their fund performed compared to others (p = 0.021, R = 0.400)

• There were no other significant findings for gender.

Page 10: Engagement in superannuation - is there really a gender gap? Dr Laura de Zwaan Assoc Prof Mark Brimble Prof Jenny Stewart.

Findings

Measure of Engagement Significant variables

Changed investments Gender, financial literacy, gender*value

Financial planner Age

Member statement Financial literacy, gender*value

Called super fund Age

Accessed details online Age, financial literacy

Know how fund performed Financial literacy, gender*income

Know value Financial literacy

Read annual report Age, financial literacy

Read PDS Age, financial literacy

Know fees Age, financial literacy

Page 11: Engagement in superannuation - is there really a gender gap? Dr Laura de Zwaan Assoc Prof Mark Brimble Prof Jenny Stewart.

Findings

• Gender is not a predictor of engagement for a range of engagement measures– It is significant for whether the respondent had

changed investment options– Could indicate risk aversion

• To target engagement, financial literacy is a better approach

• However, as the Cooper Review pointed out, the system should work regardless of the level of engagement

Page 12: Engagement in superannuation - is there really a gender gap? Dr Laura de Zwaan Assoc Prof Mark Brimble Prof Jenny Stewart.

Limitations and Future Research

• Self selection bias• Measure of financial literacy• Relationship status (Gerrans and Clark-Murphy, 2004)• Household role• Level of risk aversion• Family tax benefit payments subject to super guarantee