Energy Efficiency: Benchmark Analysis

Network of Excellence

Benchmark analysis

Joint Project Meeting of the Interreg Projects "Efficient Effective Smart" and "Smart Energy".

Klagenfurt, 07.11.2013

SMART ENERGY - Network of Excellence

Smart Energy

• Technology analysis WHAT– Key technologies

– Future technologies

• Competency map WHO at local level– Starting point

• Benchmarking WHO at international level– International competences (make cooperation)

– Identification of niches in order to reinforce the regional know-how

Roadmap Pilots


Benchmark Analysis • Lisbon strategy (Lisbon European Council 2000)

• Aims: compare the internationally existing competecies with the potentials of our region

• Methodology

– Indicators: patents, scientific papers, EU funded projects

– Elaboration of the following patent statistics database: EPO, PCT, USPTO, Triadic

Patent Families)


Benchmark Analysis Technological outputs at international level

Triadic patent families (source: elaboration CETA from OECD statistics)

0

2.000

4.000

6.000

8.000

10.000

12.000

14.000

16.000

2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011

JP

KR

CN

US

EU 27

EU 15



Triadic patent families (source: elaboration CETA from OECD statistics)

0

2.000

4.000

6.000

8.000

10.000

12.000

14.000

16.000

2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011

AT

IT

FR

DE

GB

JP

KR

CN

US



Triadic patent families per million inhabitants (source: elaboration CETA from OECD statistics)

0,0

20,0

40,0

60,0

80,0

100,0

120,0

140,0

2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011

AT

IT

FR

DE

GB

JP

KR

CN

US


Benchmark Analysis Technological outputs at Nuts 3 level

Patent applications to EPO per million inhabitants(source: Eurostat)


Benchmark Analysis Technological

outputs at Nuts 3

level

Patent applications to

EPO per million

inhabitants(source: Eurostat)

2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010

CH031: Basel-Stadt 420 576 541 599 692 703 780 626 624 758 726

DE73: Ostwürttemberg 271 399 455 497 522 602 593 737 696 698 724

DE72: Stuttgart 412 430 461 501 572 543 532 629 556 564 603

FI197: Pirkanmaa 453 504 521 555 706 606 656 586 581 514 597

DE86: Industrieregion Mittelfran. 324 334 372 364 448 501 583 538 493 508 567

DE90: Regensburg 381 322 337 367 442 445 534 600 525 422 560

UKH12: Cambridgeshire CC 659 744 698 714 718 682 718 717 644 555 558

NL41: Noord-Brabant 743 1.046 792 755 775 808 811 751 769 636 524

FI181: Uusimaa 553 506 463 431 506 480 567 543 492 499 503

DE93: München 580 566 512 524 514 546 575 641 511 500 500

SE110: Stockholms län 538 433 367 331 363 391 468 574 573 491 490

CH011: Vaud 331 334 339 304 338 317 358 383 428 487 488

SE121: Uppsala län 537 392 428 395 308 461 442 540 445 523 483

AT342: Rheintal-Bodenseeg. 162 112 132 183 257 273 307 350 343 289 460

SE125: Västmanlands län 459 318 298 245 235 320 395 370 432 464 431

DE70: Mittlerer Oberrhein 272 320 350 311 341 383 403 410 347 428 429

DE66: Rheinpfalz 401 413 477 474 495 583 505 527 473 493 422

CH032: Basel-Landschaft 399 453 424 590 551 650 625 536 484 382 419

FI1A2: Pohjois-Pohjanmaa 303 294 227 248 334 355 404 402 363 419 413

AT221: Graz 173 204 240 308 332 320 396 317 314 416 403

DK013: Nordsjælland .. .. .. .. .. 525 491 537 489 444 401

FR714: Isère 236 295 293 299 284 373 310 346 378 375 401

DE96: Oberland 350 344 301 384 366 352 343 302 308 319 399

CH066: Zug 510 566 543 539 498 404 500 814 831 858 393

DE68: Unterer Neckar 293 360 378 410 346 433 449 447 411 419 386

CH024: Neuchâtel 252 392 370 315 356 346 391 348 341 351 381

CH033: Aargau 235 276 303 267 383 346 367 432 389 381 375

IL031: Haifa Sub-District .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. 374

IL044: Rehovot Sub-District .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. 373

DE78: Hochrhein-Bodensee 322 373 436 513 433 526 488 455 411 375 368

DE75: Neckar-Alb 210 301 279 265 326 333 366 374 435 381 366

SE224: Skåne län 403 402 345 332 339 394 493 547 476 435 365

DK012: Københavns Omegn .. .. .. .. .. 443 428 450 446 393 355

DE79: Bodensee-Oberschwaben 253 218 235 269 264 292 387 458 334 423 348

CH052: Schaffhausen 221 292 420 255 329 644 365 347 249 293 345

DE74: Donau-Iller (Bw) 235 306 406 378 474 418 447 362 286 300 340

CH040: Zürich 265 266 269 265 299 363 340 397 344 327 340

DE82: Main-Rhön 93 131 147 186 247 302 381 407 313 247 332

DE64: Rheinhessen-Nahe 294 250 242 206 240 230 257 361 405 360 330

FR105: Hauts-de-Seine 243 207 176 209 261 324 346 303 324 357 330

FR724: Puy-de-Dôme 172 178 148 147 138 133 129 186 227 247 327

UKJ14: Oxfordshire 428 474 408 365 397 356 425 410 399 354 324

DE52: Starkenburg 385 302 314 334 333 376 326 370 313 333 323

CH055: St. Gallen 189 188 209 222 248 286 247 321 288 246 321

DE97: Südostoberbayern 235 189 238 234 275 336 338 371 365 268 316

SE123: Östergötlands län 210 263 226 154 195 216 194 281 343 335 315

Source: elaboration CETA from data extracted on 30 Sep 2013 17:28 UTC (GMT) from OECD.Stat


Benchmark Analysis Technological outputs in Interreg Area

Patent applications per million inhabitants (source: elaboration CETA from OECD statistics)

0

50

100

150

200

250A

UT

: A

ust

ria

AT

211

: K

lag

enfu

rt-…

AT

212

: O

ber

kär

nte

n

AT

213

: U

nte

rkär

nte

n

AT

321

: L

ung

au

AT

322

: P

inzg

au-…

AT

323

: S

alzb

urg

un

d…

AT

331

: A

uß

erfe

rn

AT

332

: In

nsb

ruck

AT

333

: O

stti

rol

AT

334

: T

iro

ler…

AT

335

: T

iro

ler…

ITA

: It

aly

ITD

10:

Bolz

ano

-Bo

zen

ITD

32:

Vic

enza

ITD

33:

Bel

luno

ITD

34:

Tre

vis

o

ITD

41:

Pord

eno

ne

ITD

42:

Ud

ine

ITD

43:

Go

rizi

a

FR

A:

Fra

nce

DE

U:

Ger

man

y

JPN

: Ja

pan

KO

R:

Ko

rea

GB

R:

Unit

ed K

ing

do

m

US

A:

Un

ited

Sta

tes

CH

N:

Chin

a

2010



Patent applications per IPC section in Interreg area(source: elaboration CETA from Eurostat data)

• Section A: Human necessities.

• Section B: Performing operations, transporting.

• Section C: Chemistry, metallurgy.

• Section D: Textiles, paper.

• Section E: Fixed constructions.

• Section F: Mechanical engineering, lighting, heating,

wheapons, blasting.

• Section G: Physics.

• Section H: Electricity.

0

200

400

600

800

1.000

1.200

1.400

1.600

1.800

2.000

A

B

C

D

E

F

G

H

Interreg

enlarged interreg

total Interreg

Technological outputs in Interreg Area

Patent applications from 2000 to 2009 in Interreg area per

IPC sub section F(source: elaboration CETA from Eurostat data)

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

140Machines or engines in general; engine plants in general; steam engines

Combustion engines; hot-gas or combustion-product engine plants

Machines or engines for liquids; wind, spring, or weight motors;

producing mechanical power or a reactive propulsive thrust, not otherwise

provided for

Positive-displacement machines for liquids; pumps for liquids or elastic

fluids

Fluid-pressure actuators; hydraulics or pneumatics in general

Engineering elements or units; general measures for producing and

maintaining effective functioning of machines or installations; thermal

insulation in general

Storing or distributing gases or liquids

Lighting

Steam generationCombustion apparatus; combustion processes

Heating; ranges; ventilating

Refrigeration or cooling; combined heating and refrigeration systems;

heat pump systems; manufacture or storage of ice; liquefaction or

solidification of gases

Drying

Furnaces; kilns; ovens; retorts

Furnaces; kilns; ovens; retorts

Weapons

Ammunition; blasting

Interreg

enlarged

interreg


Benchmark Analysis



Patent applications from 2000 to 2010 in Interreg IV Italia

Austria (source: elaboration CETA from OECD statistics)

ICT Nanotech Biotech Medical Pharma Green Total

AUT: Austria 3.028 76 778 692 742 1.224 6.540

AT211: Klagenfurt-Villach 138 4 3 17 7 48 217

AT212: Oberkärnten 25 0 1 1 0 4 32

AT322: Pinzgau-Pongau 10 0 2 3 3 12 28

AT332: Innsbruck 92 3 47 112 50 20 324

AT333: Osttirol 2 0 0 0 0 3 5

AT334: Tiroler Oberland 6 0 3 5 1 2 17

AT335: Tiroler Unterland 36 0 30 23 56 12 156

AT213: Unterkärnten 19 0 0 2 2 19 42

AT321: Lungau 2 0 0 1 8 2 12

AT323: Salzburg und Umgebung 80 0 17 46 13 106 262

AT331: Außerfern 9 1 0 0 0 14 23

ITA: Italy 5.186 153 1.611 2.295 2.921 2.061 14.227

ITD10: Bolzano-Bozen 28 1 3 18 3 27 81

ITD33: Belluno 14 1 1 7 0 2 25

ITD42: Udine 60 0 13 26 11 26 137

ITD32: Vicenza 65 1 6 39 8 65 184

ITD34: Treviso 88 2 4 36 6 39 174

ITD41: Pordenone 46 0 2 13 6 10 79

ITD43: Gorizia 14 1 4 4 3 3 30

ITD44: Trieste* 27 6 24 15 30 11 114

Interreg 412 9 102 212 130 157 1.021

Enlarged Interreg 324 4 33 140 46 257 805

Total Interreg 735 13 135 352 176 414 1.826

Source: elaboration CETA from OECD Statistics (6)


Benchmark Analysis

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

800

ICT

NANOTECH

BIOTECH

MEDICAL

PHARMA

Green Tot.Interreg

Enlarged Interreg

Total Interreg





Benchmark Analysis

0

50

100

150

200

250

300

350

ICT

NANOTECH

BIOTECH

MEDICAL

PHARMA

Green Tot.

Interreg Austria

Enlarged interreg

Austria

Interreg Italy

Enlarged interreg

Italy







Austria Green technologies(source: elaboration CETA from OECD statistics)

0

20

40

60

80

100

120CLIMATE_MITIGAT

TRANSPORT_EFF

TECH_EMIS_MITIGAT

RESsEE in buildings

GEN_ENV_MANAG

COMBUST_MITIGAT

Interreg

Enlarged Interreg

Total Interreg


Benchmark Analysis Conclusions

Interreg IV area potentials:

• ICT

• Mechanical engineering, heating, cooling

• Energy efficiency in buildings (thermal insulation)

• Energy efficiency

Promising joint research areas:

• Energy management of RES,

• Smart homes, smart grids


Pilot project CETAConstitution of an observatory on Energy Efficiency in buildings in Friuli Venezia Giulia

according to the European Directive 2012/27/EU of the European Parliament and of the Council

of 25 October 2012 on energy efficiency. The main objectives are:

• Overview of the building existing stock in the Region;

• Identification of cost-effective approaches to renovations relevant to the building type and

climatic zone;

• Elaborate hypotheses on how to stimulate cost-effective deep renovations of buildings;

• A perspective to guide investments decisions of individuals, the construction industry and

financial institutions;

• Estimate the expected energy savings and wider benefits;

• Analyse the sustainability impacts of energy efficiency in buildings deployment in our Region

• Promote and set-up research facilities and equipment for technical and scientific analyses.


Via Licinio, 4434170 Gorizia

Telephone 0481 391887Laboratory 0481 537159fax 0481 393882

Email: [email protected]: www.ceta.ts.it