Energy Audits and Energy Management in buildings

www.meetmed.org

Mitigation Enabling Energy Transition in the MEDiterranean region

Energy Audits and Energy Management in buildings

MeetMed Training course on “Integration of Energy Efficiency (EE) and Renewable Energy Sources (RES) in buildings

27 February 2020, Tunis

Energy Audits and Energy Management in buildings . 2

2

Contents

➢ Introduction to Energy Audits

➢ Procedure for Energy Auditing

➢ Energy Efficiency improvements

➢ Typical tools and time frames for energy audits

➢ Energy Management Systems

➢ Monitoring and Verification of Energy Savings


3

Introduction to Energy Audits


4


5

Energy Audits

Αn energy audit is a systematic inspection and analysis ofenergy use and energy consumption of a site, building, systemor organization with the objective of identifying energy flowsand the potential for energy efficiency improvements andreporting them - EN 16247

EN 16247 specifies the requirements, common methodologyand deliverables for energy audits. It applies to all forms ofestablishments and organizations, all forms of energy and usesof energy, excluding individual private dwellings.


6

What is an Energy Audit

Energy Audit involves

Systematic Record of Energy Data

Analysis of Energy Data

Proposal of potential Energy Saving Measures

Need for Energy Audit:

Minimize Energy Consumption.

Maximize productivity.

Achieve Energy efficiency

. 7

Why carry out an energy audit?

➢ To improve energy performance and minimize theenvironmental impacts of the building’s operations

➢ To identify technical opportunities by evaluatingsignificant process energy-using components orutilities including boilers, refrigeration plant,ventilation systems, building performance, etc.

➢ To gain a greater understanding of a part or all of thebuilding's energy usage patterns

➢ To provide clear financial information regarding energysavings opportunities in order to prioritize these itemsfor the building's decision-making process

. 8

Why carry out an energy audit?

➢ To identify potential for using renewable energy supplytechnologies (e.g. NZEBs)

➢ To identify behavioral change opportunities by evaluatingcurrent operations and maintenance practices

➢ To meet customer and shareholder expectations

➢ To achieve compliance with legal requirements such as theEnergy Efficiency Directive

➢ To contribute to the process for certification to a formalenergy management system, as set out in ISO 50001

. 9

Types of Energy Audits

➢ Walk-Through Audit

➢ Utility Cost Analysis

➢ Standard Energy Audit

➢ Detailed Energy Audit

. 10

Walk-Through Audit

• Short onsite visits for inspection.

• Propose inexpensive and simple actions (housekeeping or of minimum cost).

• Immediate energy savings considered.

• Checking the Operating & Maintenance procedures

✓E.g. Repairing broken windows

✓E.g. Boiler A/F ratios Adjustment

✓E.g. Lowering Cooling Preset Temperatures

. 11

Utility Cost Analysis

• Establish “Relation” between cost & Utility’s services

• Analyze Operating cost of the Utility

• Obtain data from:

• Energy Bills

• Peak Demands.

• Weather effects identified

• Utility Cost analysis steps include:

• Verify energy bills & ensure no mistakes made

• Determine dominant charges

• Peak demand saving measures

• Check if alternative cost effective fuels will help

. 12

Standard Energy Audit

• Comprehensive Analysis of Energy Systems

• Development of Baseline (of the building’s energy use)

• Identification of Energy Uses

• Evaluation of Energy Savings

• Cost Effectiveness of Selected E.E.M.

• Various Mathematical Tools are used

• Degree day methods

• Linear regression Methods

• Simple Pay Back Analysis

. 13

Detailed Energy Audit

• Most Comprehensive & Time Consuming

• Use of hand held / stationary instruments

• Sophisticated Computer Simulations

• Carried out for:

• Evaluating Energy use

• Identifying Potential savings

• Recommending Energy Retrofits

• Evaluating the Cost Effectiveness of Energy Retrofits


General Procedure for an Energy Audit


Energy Audit

15


16

Step 1: Preliminary Contact

a) The energy auditor shall agree with the organization on:

1. aims, needs and expectations concerning the energy audit2. scope and boundaries [EXAMPLE - The whole site and all energy usingsystems or the boiler plant]3. degrees of thoroughness required [EXAMPLE - Proportion ofapartments in a block to be visited; whether accuracy sufficient forinvestment decisions is required].4.timescale to complete the energy audit [depending on complexity ofbuildings]5.criteria for evaluating energy efficiency improvement measures[EXAMPLE - pay back period]6.time commitments and other resources from the organization7.requirement for data to be collected prior to the energy auditcommencing and the availability, validity and format of the energy andactivity data8.foreseeable measurement and/or inspection to be made during theenergy audit.


17

b) The energy auditor shall request information about:

1. The energy audit context [EXAMPLE Energy audit related to a government agreement/scheme]

2. Strategic wider program (planned projects, outsourcingfacilities management)

3. Management system (environmental, quality, energymanagement system or others)

4. Changes that may have an effect on the energy audit andits conclusions

5. Any existing opinions, ideas and restrictions relating topotential energy efficiency improvement measures

6. Expected deliverables and required format of the report7. Whether a draft of the final report to the organization

should be presented for comment.


18

c) The energy auditor shall inform the organization of any:

1. Special facilities and equipment required to enable the energy audit to be carried out

2. Commercial or other interest which could influence his or her conclusions or recommendations.)


19

Start-up meeting

a) The energy auditor shall request the organization to:

1. Nominate the person ultimately responsible for the energyaudit within the organization

2. Nominate a person to communicate with the energy auditor,where necessary supported by other appropriate individualsconstituted as a team for the purpose

3. Inform affected personnel and other interested parties aboutthe energy audit and requirements placed on them inconnection with and ensure their cooperation

4. Disclose any unusual conditions, maintenance work or otheractivities that will occur during the energy audit


20

b) The energy auditor shall agree with the organization on:

1. Arrangements regarding the access of the energy auditor;2. safety and security rules;3. resources and data to be provided;4. non-disclosure agreements (e.g. tenants in a building);5. proposed schedule of visits with priorities for each;6. requirements for special measurements;7. procedures to be followed for installation of measuring

equipment, if needed.

. 21

Step 2: Site visit

Walk-through inspection of the building in order to:

➢ Check operating and maintenance procedures

➢ Determine the existing energy consuming systems and their operatingconditions

❖ Systems like lighting, HVAC systems, motors, etc.

➢ Estimate the occupancy, and the uses of equipment and lighting

❖ energy use density and hours of operation


22

Collecting Data

During the site visit, the energy auditor shall, in cooperation with theorganization, collect the following (where available):

1. list of energy using systems, processes and equipment;2. detailed characteristics of the audited object(s) including known

adjustment factors and how the organization believes theyinfluence energy consumption;

3. operational history and past events that could have affectedenergy consumption in the period covered by the data collected;

4. design, operation and maintenance documents;5. energy audits or previous studies related to energy and energy

efficiency;6. current and projected tariff, or a reference tariff to be used for the

protection of commercial confidence;7. other relevant economic data;8. the status of the energy management system


23

Collecting Data

Examples:

➢ Collect building geometry data (volume, heating/cooling area, etc.)

❖ To extract specific consumption indicators

➢ Collect energy consumption records of utility data (Optimal 3 years data).

❖ To identify a historical energy use pattern.

➢ Identify the fuel types used

❖ to determine the dominating fuel type.

➢ Determine the patterns of fuel use by fuel type

❖ to identify the peak demand for energy use by fuel type

➢ Analyze the effect of external factors in energy consumption of thebuilding

❖Weather, Occupancy, etc.


24

Step 3: Analysis

During this phase, the energy auditor shall establish the existing energy performance situation of the audited object.

a) The existing energy performance situation becomes a reference against the improvements that can be measured. It shall include:

1. a breakdown of the energy consumption by use and source of energy;

2. energy flows and an energy balance of the audited object;

3. pattern of energy demand through time;4. relationships between energy consumption and

adjustment factors (both routine and non-routine);5. one or more energy performance indicators suitable to

evaluate the audited object.

. 25

The data

➢ Consumption data• fuel consumption (the last three years are needed) and

type of fuel,• electric consumption (the last three years are needed).

➢ Degree days [indices reflecting demand for energy to heat & coolbuildings] of the last three years for the normalization ofconsumption

➢ Use of the building (type and time)

➢ Construction data (if existent)!

. 26

26

0

5 000

10 000

15 000

20 000

25 000

30 000

35 000

40 000

January February March April May June July August September October November December

Co

nsu

mp

tio

n (

kWh

)

Month

Electricity Consumption from electricity bills – Office building

Total yearly electricity consumption:383.812 kWh

. 27

27

0

50000

100000

150000

200000

250000

January February March April May June July August September October November December

Hea

tin

g o

il (k

Wh

)

Month

Heating oil consumption based on invoices – Office Building

Heating oil consumption: 1.959.820 kWh

. 28

Benchmarking

Energy indicator Existing Building Average building*

Specific electricity consumption (kWh/m2/yr)

123 120

Specific heating consumption (kWh/m2/yr)

218 160

Total 341 280

* Statistical data from the National Energy Performance of Building database http://www.ypeka.gr/Default.aspx?tabid=907&language=el-GR

http://www.ypeka.gr/Default.aspx?tabid=907&language=el-GR


29

Breakdown of Energy Consumption – (2)

Energy bills and technical characteristics of the equipmentIn this case where energy bills and installation characteristics are available, an in-depthconversation with the technical personnel of the installation carried out during theenergy audit where the operational hours, usage coefficient etc. where determined.This fact led to the determination of the energy consumption breakdown.

Equipment Electricity consumption

Cooling6,559

Heating10,542

Lighting102,502

Office equipment85,094

Rest equipment52,061

Motors2,541

Heating system3,350

Elevators11,563

Baseline load

consumption 109,517

Total consumption383,730


30

Air compressors 125 8760 0.5 547,500 26.4%

Auxiliary air compressors 50 500 0.7 17,500 0.8%

Chillers 65 8760 0.5 284,700 13.7%

Air Handling Units 20 8760 0.75 131,400 6.3%

Cooling Towers 15 8760 0.45 59,130 2.8%

Refrigerators 5 8760 0.5 21,900 1.1%

Pumps 50 6600 0.6 198,000 9.5%

Fans 20 3300 0.4 26,400 1.3%

Homogenizers 40 3300 0.4 52,800 2.5%

Lighting 69 6600 1 455,400 21.9%

Motors 50 6600 0.4 132,000 6.4%

Other consumptions 150,000 7.2%

0 0.0%

0 0.0%

0 0.0%

0 0.0%

0 0.0%

0 0.0%

0 0.0%

0 0.0%

Total 2,076,730 1.000 100.0%

% Usage

Coefficient (3)

Yearly Energy

Consumption

(kWh) (1x2x3)

System/Devices

Absorbed

Power kW

(1)

Operational

hours/year

(2)

Air compressors; 547,500; 26.4%

Auxiliary air compressors; 17,500; 0.8%

Chillers; 284,700; 13.7%

Air Handling Units; 131,400; 6.3%

Cooling Towers; 59,130; 2.8%

Refrigerators; 21,900; 1.1%

Pumps; 198,000; 9.5%

Fans; 26,400; 1.3%

Homogenizers; 52,800; 2.5%

Lighting; 455,400; 21.9%

Motors; 132,000; 6.4%

Other consumptions; 150,000; 7.2%


Based on assumptions and: (1) energy bills, (2) energy company measurements, (3) existing metering devices, (4) new metering devices


31


Energy company measurements

In the case of installations that have an electrical supply of medium voltage (e.g.20.000 V), the energy companies usually have readily-available yearly measurementsfrom 5-min to 1 hour intervals. These can be very useful to disaggregate energy usages.


32


Existing Building Management System (BMS) measurements

In the case of some modern buildings, a BMS system is sometimesinstalled which allows a better estimation of the breakdown of theenergy consumption. Even in this case however, there are often severaldifficulties. Typical examples include:

• BMS systems that only produce non-workable print-outs which arefiled for EN ISO 14001 procedures (e.g. hotel in Athens).

• BMS systems that only monitor specific sub-circuits which are notalways those required by the energy auditor (e.g. hotel in Athens)

• BMS systems that only give alarms when something doesn’t workbut don’t collect information.


33


New measurements

In the majority of cases, new measurements are a necessity if onewants to reliably and accurately break down the energy consumption.

In order to do this, at least one (1) week of multiple measurements isneeded in order to cover the load profiles of both weekdays andweekends.

Optimally, one should aim to have detailed weekly measurements foreach season of the year (i.e. summer, autumn, winter and spring).

Moreover, even if the client has available measurements, in order toreliably propose energy efficiency measures, the energy auditor shouldalso undertake his/her own measurements for verification purposes.


34

Electrical measurements – Electricity meter analyzer

• Familiarity with equipment (e.g. type of clamps, battery functionality, electrical outlet functionality)

• Range of clamps available• Safety issues (e.g. gloves, protection for

gloves, dust)

Optimally, the mains switch should beturned off when connecting thedevice, otherwise it is recommendedthat the building electrician makes thenecessary connections.


35

Thermographic camera


36

Temperature/Humidity/Lighting level loggers

• Remember to set the time before operating


37

Flue gas analyzer

• Familiarity with equipment • Measurement during steady

operation of the boiler.• Check filter• Portable printer with magnet

is very useful


38

Thermal energy measurementsNon-intrusive method

• Ultrasound• Clean surface required• Dimensions of pipe necessary• Two-phase fluid cannot be

measured accurately

Intrusive

• Requires cutting of pipes• Flow rate meter and temperature

sensors


39

Energy Consumption and Baseline


40

Step 4: Energy Efficiency Improvements

Based on the existing energy performance situation of the audited object,the energy auditor shall identify energy efficiency improvementopportunities.

b) The energy auditor shall evaluate the impact of each energy efficiencyimprovement opportunity on the existing energy performance situationbased on:

1. the financial savings enabled by the energy efficiencyimprovement measures;

2. the necessary investments;3. the return on investment or any other economical criteria

agreed with the organization;4. the other possible non-energy gains (such as productivity or

maintenance);5. the comparison in terms of both cost and energy

consumption between alternative energy efficiencyimprovement measures;


41

Energy saving actions shall be ranked upon the agreed criteria.

c) In those cases where it is appropriate to the agreed scope aim andthoroughness of the energy audit, the energy auditor shall complementthese results with:

1. requirements for additional data;2. the definition of need for further analysis.

d) The energy auditor shall:

1. evaluate the reliability of data provided and highlightdefaults or irregularities;

2. use transparent and technically appropriate calculationmethods;

3. document the methods used and any assumption made.4. subject the results of the analysis to appropriate quality

and validity checks5. consider any regulatory or other constraints of the

potential energy efficiency improvement opportunities.

. 42

The Energy Auditor has to draw up an action plan for the in-timeimplementation of the proposed energy efficiency measures, if such a task isforeseen in the audit’s terms, based on the time-programming principles.

This planning should be made for each phase of implementation andincludes:

➢ targets and measures that have to be implemented in each phase,

➢ the time-schedule of each phase,

➢ the requested organization and the budget for the implementation costs,

➢ the determination of the way that the work-progress will be monitored,

➢ the delimitation of the monitoring/measuring or/and evaluation of eachphase results procedure.

Drawing-up of an energy saving action plan


43

References

• European Energy Directive 27/2012

• EN 16247 – part 1. General Requirements

• Guidebook for Energy Audits. 2017. Hellenic Ministry of Energy and

Environment

. 44

Typical tools and time frames for energy audits

. 45

The time taken to perform an energy audit depends on:

❖ the availability of energy data,

❖ the size of the site, and

❖ the complexity of the systems:

➢ A walk-through audit might take only a few hours for a simple site for which information is readily available.

➢ On more complex sites, a week or more could be easily spent simply on analyzing invoices and records.

Time frames


46

ENERGY MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS

. 47

Project-Based Focus on

Technological Change

People?

Overall Energy-Use

Strategy?

What is Missing in the Project-Based Approach to Energy Efficiency?

But what about…

Organizational Barriers?

. 48

Energy & Cost Savings(over time)

Continuous improvement!

A More Comprehensive Approach To Energy

Efficiency Is Needed

Staff at every level of an organization need to be engaged and involved in order

to achieve energy goals!

Comprehensive Energy

Management

Technological Change

Organizational Change

Behavioral Change

Organizations that target behavioral and organizational barriers, as well as technological, can achieve continuous improvement in energy

performance.

. 49

ISO 50001 - A Key Strategy For Fighting Climate Change

Over +50 countries have worked together

through ISO to create a globally-relevant

standard that countries can leverage to meet

their international climate commitments

ISO 50001 is:

– Ambitious and Quantifiable:

• Relevant to sectors that account for over

50% of global energy use

• Data-driven action to improve energy

performance on a continual basis

– Transparent, comparable and verifiable:

• Globally-harmonized; transparent

certification process; internationally-

relevant

– Business Friendly

~15,000 certified sites

worldwide since 2011

. 50

What Are Energy Management Systems (EnMS)?

• Objectives: – Measure & baseline

– Monitor & plan

– Continually improve energy

efficiency

• Main criteria:– Management System

Approach

→The organization makes

commitment

– Requirement for a corporate

policy to manage energy

efficiency• Plan,Do,Check,Act and

continuous improvement

• Similar structure as ISO

14001 (different

requirements)

. 51

Key Requirements of Energy Management SystemsExamples extracted from EN 16001 and ISO 50001

• Establish, implement and maintain an energy policy with commitment for achieving energy

performance (energy efficiency & use of renewable sources)

• Define priorities and set appropriate objectives and targets using energy performance

indicators and have in place an energy metering plan

• Conduct an initial diagnosis of energy consumption for all activities (including past, present

and future energy consumption)

• Identify the main factors that have an influence on energy consumption

• Establish the relationships between energy consumption and energy factors

• Build a periodic forecast of energy consumption and identify opportunities of energy

savings

• Consider energy consumption in the decision process for design and procurement of all

equipment, raw materials or services

• Identify applicable regulation and/or other requirements (such as clients’ specifications)

• Management review of activities to ensure that the policy is implemented and that the EnMS

remains appropriate.

EnMS concerns …..

• ISO 50001 is applicable to any organization whatever the size,

industry or geographical location.

• It is particularly relevant if the organization operates energy intensive

processes or faces a greenhouse gas emissions challenge.

• Manufacturing (Aerospace, Automotive, Electrical, Electronics…)

• Process industries & Mining (Chemical, Pharmacy, Metals, Paper, Cement, Glass, Wood, Oil&Gas …)

• Power & Utilities (Energy Production, Energy and Water Distribution, Water and Waste Treatment…)

• Food

• Construction & Real estate

• Transportation & Infrastructures

• Retail

• Services (Healthcare, Finance, Insurance, Telecom, Tourism…)

• Government & Public organizations (Public Administration, Public sector service delegation …)

All activities and industries are concerned


53

References

• Advancing Sustainable Energy Cooperation in North America. November

2016. Ms. Graziella Siciliano. Energy Management Working Group. U.S.

Department of Energy

• Energy Management System ISO 50001. Baudouin Hue. Bureau Veritas.


54

MONITORING AND VERIFICATION OF

SAVINGS


55

IPMVP Protocol

The International Performance Measurement and Verification Protocol(IPMVP) Volume I is a guidance document describing common practice inmeasuring, computing and reporting savings achieved.

The IPMVP presents a framework and four measurement and verification(M&V) Options for transparently, reliably and consistently reporting aproject’s saving.

M&V activities include site surveys, metering of energy or water flow(s),monitoring of independent variable(s), calculation, and reporting. Whenadhering to IPMVP’s recommendations, these M&V activities can produceverifiable savings reports.

The IPMVP is intended to be used by professionals as a basis for preparingsavings reports.


56

M&V activities consist of some or all of the following:

• meter installation calibration and maintenance,• data gathering and screening,• development of a computation method and acceptable estimates,• computations with measured data, and• reporting, quality assurance, and third party verification of reports.

When there is little doubt about the outcome of a project, or no need toprove results to another party, M&V may not be necessary. However, it isstill wise to verify that the installed equipment is able to produce theexpected savings.


57

Option A


58

Option B


59

Option C


60

Option D


61

www.meetmed.orgmeetMED Project

@meetmed1

[email protected]

http://www.meetmed.org/

Energy Audits and Energy Management in buildings

Documents