Energy and Environment factors impacting the competitiveness – case UPM Anja Silvennoinen Vice President, Energy 31.3.2006
Mar 27, 2015
Energy and Environment factors impacting the competitiveness – case UPM
Anja Silvennoinen
Vice President, Energy
31.3.2006
UPM 2
World's leading graphic papers producers
0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14
Stora Enso
UPM
International Paper
Abitibi-Consolidated
Nippon Unipac
Norske Skog
Oji
M-real
Bowater
Capacity, mill. t/a
Source: Jaakko Pöyry, UPM
SAPPI
UPM 3
UPM
UPM's annual electricity consumption is about 18 TWh corresponding with production of 1,5 times of modern new 1600 MW nuclear power plant
Use of mill site fuels and heat is bout 34 TWh
Energy cost are a significant cost factor
UPM 4
INTRODUCTION
UPM cost structure- Energy costs are about 9%
Chemicals and fillers14%
Delivery of own products 12%
Logs and pulpwood 14%
Recovered paper 3%
Personnel expenses
32%
Energy 9 %, 765 M€ Other raw materials 10%
Other costs19%
Total costs € 8,500 million(excluding depreciation)
UPM cost structure (2004)
Not only wood and energy but also labour, chemicals, other raw materials
See also CEPI Sustainability Report 2005 onwww.cepi.org
UPM 5
Use of electricity in 2005
Hydro Power 16%
Mill site CHP 23%
Nuclear power 23%
Condensing power 5%
Purchased electricity from market 33 %
Use of electricity 17 300 TWh
own and co-ownedresources
Biofuels 51% Natural gas 26%
Heat recovery 6% Purchased heat 2%
Peat 3% Oil 3%
Coal 9%
Use of fuels and heat 34 000 TWh
UPM 6
A joint non-profit company for electricity generation
Jointly owned electricity generation company
Shareholder
100% ownership on power plants
Shareholder ShareholderShareholderShareholder Shareholder Shareholder
Each shareholder has an individual amount of sharesShareholder will get electricity at production cost and in accordance to their relative share ownership
Efficient way to shareholders to enter capital intensive electricity generation where electricity to shareholders is on a production cost basis shareholders have the share equity on their balance sheet (equity accounting
method by IFRS)
UPM 7
UPM's CO2 emissions have dropped 25% during last ten years
UPM in Finland UPM globally
UPM has reduced its CO2 emissions by 25 % during last ten years by investing in biofuel based energy generation and in energy efficiency.
Investmentsabout 500 mio. euros
Paper production Paper productionTarget set in Kyoto protocol
UPM 8
70
90
110
130
150
170
190
210
Q1/04 Q2/04 Q3/04 Q4/04 Q1/05 Q2/05 Q3/05 Q4/05
Electricity(EEX)
Coating materials
Chemical Pulp
Electricity(Nordpool)
UPM AND THE NEW BUSINESS ENVIRONMENT
Rapidly increasing cost of production inputs – especially energy
Index 2004=100
Energy market prices have increased significantly more than other costs
UPM 9
ENERGY MARKET DEVELOPMENT IN EUROPE
European electricity markets - Price development
Brent
Nord Pool
EEX = Western Europe electricity exchange
CO2
Source: Reuters Emission Trading
CO2, €/tn Energy, €/MWh
UPM 10
UPM press releaseMarch 8, 2006
UPM to start an extensive programme to restore its profitability, Efficiency improvement will involve all divisions and functions
"At the same time, the cost of production inputs has dramatically increased and Asian and South American competition has entered the market. In this kind of business environment sustainable profitability improvement requires new kind of thinking and more drastic measures than before," says Jussi Pesonen, President and CEO of UPM."
Regarding UPM's plan to invest in a new paper machine producing magazine (SC) papers in Continental Europe, the investment decision has been postponed to a later date. Energy price and availability and other infrastructure issues are still open and UPM will prioritize the company profitability programme launched today .
Big investment project in Europe postponed partly due to unpredictability of energy price development
UPM 11
Promotion of green electricity has increased green power's prices
Measures vary country-by-country but all include guaranteeing high price for green electricity generation paid by all consumers of energy pushing up costs of energy use
• Measures increase energy producers' ability to pay for wood based fuels: this will have an impact to fiber and wood availability.
• Promotion of biofuels will accelerate the price and availability issues further
0,0
20,0
40,0
60,0
80,0
100,0
120,0
Finlan
d
Germ
any,
>20
MW
Estonia
Sweden
Germ
any,
5-20
MW
Franc
e
Austri
aUK
Feed-in tariff
Green certificate
Market price
EUR/MWhe
UPM 12
Using wood in paper production generates more employment than energy use
Source: CEPI, 2004
UPM 13
Analysis
The competition on energy markets is not functioning
– well functioning market needed faster than present idea of completion of liberalisation
– increased competition in production
– more interconnection capacity
– enhance possibilities to independent power production (like industry's JVs)
– re-regulation is not a solution
High uncertainty concerning further development of energy policy
– competition on the market
– access to markets and sites for energy production units
– policy measures that distort competition
– overlapping measures like EUETS, taxation, certificate schemes, feed-in tariffs an other subsidies to renewable energy all aim to same direction i.e. reducing CO2 emissions and all distort the competition on energy markets and together accelerate the unfavorable development
.
Paper and pulp price is global market price and industry cannot transfer EU specific cost increases to end product prices
UPM 14
Analysis 2/2
Promotion of renewable energy can distort both energy and wood raw material market;
– Support mechanisms should be designed so that they don't distort the wood markets and availability of raw material by causing unfair competition and price rise
– Support mechanism should not interfere with competitive price formation on energy markets
Climate change policies and measures that are implemented only at EU level, mainly increase production costs of European industry without having a truly global response to greenhouse gas reduction
– global approach
– based on BAT –type of approach (already in NAPII)
Paper and pulp price is global market price and industry cannot transfer EU specific cost increases to end product prices