7/29/2019 Empedocles Fragments and Commentary
1/24
!"#$%$!%
&'$'%("#)"#"*+,+-"*./012%
'3#!')(#4!'5#)
)#$$6''7#$8'(8!"8*,,+%
''7#$$69#!$$#$8:'#8")0;;*%
!
!(''7#9=#!''!(''7#9=#!''
!(''7#9=#!''
!(''7#9=#!7)'!!!9#!7'=('#(9'=6#$'(#!
!!9#!!'(##7#9'=6#$'(#!
!!9#!#(!!(#>!!#)%!$#'))#$>87'=)(86'(8
##('6#!'!%
##@"6!%*+;.A!#"
=!%*+1+A#9""#(%*+1,A@###"#%@%%(%$%=6#$%#9%*+22A#"'*+.0A)#$#>"43%A%
#(!A43%66%*B**/,A")$%#'(%*++2AC9#"
%*++1"66%.**..;A;%#"%$%('!%%2,+77%A@"
http://history.hanover.edu/project.htmlhttp://history.hanover.edu/project.html7/29/2019 Empedocles Fragments and Commentary
2/24
(#$9##!)##$='9#=#=#!'7#'$8A
$=8###3(!#'(##$9#'7!$'!'9%$9@9'
((#6'''7(7#!'(7#"!>7'=###7#"#8!#$#'#>8
(#!='#"6#!$#$'(8'7'>)#)'#))#!!#!$3#!>8$"#>'(##3(8'!!#!7'$%!#!#9!###!##
'#$$!)(88=#"')'=6##$#$8#=$%$'"'>'
!>$>#"!((#'='#>='(=$!!##%
**%"8#9'$!"3##=$#!!'7'!#=#7'==8'9#"$7'=(6!#'(8)!#6#!#='7('>%$##68"=)>''#$>#=#$=$#
!#">9!!97'#9!'7$8'#"$''"$#8"$39
'#$#)")'$)=#'%'8#!((#7('>#!'7''$#>#((#!##=#$)'=6#(=#'6()#=7'=='($!"')'$'!6#'($(8
='#!'(8$'(8#!'##9!'7>!$'=%
*,%)'=#"#4=#8#3#8=#!#)9'>!)(#"##699##
789!##>!#$"'$#9!'$='##)(#!!#'!'7#'9#"'##67'=!98'7#'#=#=#!>)
##(#!=#!'7'>(#$9#"'>#)9#>8>)!)(#%
02%#!7'#3(!>#3####"$6'#)'9!'($9#!('(#"
!)#7'##('#>(())'=6(!((#!#9!%'!(##6'>#'799(#!>)!99!##('>$'>#)'6!$$#!'8#=A$"
9">##3#'>("'!(9#(!!)A$'!(9
!#!'(#$'9''7$!'=7'=#"$''7!==#$'9'!(9!#=!6'9$'>7'=#3#'####!A$'!((#$''7
$#!#!6'7=!$#$%
11%#7!#7'''!'7((9!9E#!"(7#939#&-"$$'#!
-"$#!!>'='!#!#!69!'7=#>##!%F7%'4%6%,,"%1%G
$%#1B%$!#)'$9>((#((####!''9''789
!='("'8#8#$#7($#A'(8=4#$!#6''7>
!=4#$"=#)((!=7'="'7'=(##)#'7>($#!!''76(!''7$!"#=#!8#!#9!3#)'=#'#9A$
7/29/2019 Empedocles Fragments and Commentary
3/24
>##8#!#6#$"#8)((#=#3(7#A!!##!(!#$6))#"$
=8!#(7(!')((!'))'$)#>#)!'=%
2.%''(!H7'#83#'7#)9!$'!'9!>'>>!'#7'#)'=#!'#9'89$#!$6#!#!#(8%
2+%'7'=>$'#!'#4!((!=6'!!(#89)'=#'#9"$
!##6'!!(#'6#)#3(##9!'($6#!)'=6(##(8A7'9!>((
(>8!!$>##3#'##))!#!((6#=%
$!#.*%='7>!#=$)'($'$3#!)9!!#!#"!'('9!=#(3#>$##$#8)(((7#"!'('9#8#4!$!#>!#3($>!
#4)#((#"#7'##8#7'=#$$7##8#$!!'(3#$"#8##((8'9
((%
..%7'!#=#!$##$6'!!(#'>'($#(#77'=!'96''7!A$'
'(#!#6(#$9#!'7'!#$##"$(8'6##>'$'#3#8)'#%
.+%:'9'##$9''#$!)!!'"')'=6(#9'#6&'7$!)'!#-%
%%7'!9'!8>!#4)#((#>)#$#3#)#%
B;%>'7'($!#!((!6#A7''#=###9#>'#'#('#''7=8"$'#=#"'>#3#"!#6#$!'##>##=8''7#'#%
>'7'($!#)'=9'#9">'7'($#6!!9>8"'76#!(#9!A7'#
(#&%#%6!!9>8-#)'=9'7$((9!'#9#!$$#!'8!"$#7'=#&%#%)'=9'#9-">)>!#$9''76!>##
#9!#6#$"!!#(7!)##$%
BB%$#!#(#=#!-#3#)#!#)996()#)'((8"'>#9((#$8
'3#''#"'>#)'#68##$#9#$##$'77#"(#8#'9'9###8'7#(("$#)'=#!5#)'%!!=)!'#
!##>''!#''7=8$9>#!#6''7#'##=8
!#"!'9!#)'((8)'=9'#9$##!'74#$9#7'#=A$7#!=)!#8F##(#=#!G#3#)#!#)996()#)'((8"!'#8
(>8!#4!>=='3(#))(#%
/2%)'=#"#=8>'$!"7'(8(#9)!#!#=$'9'>%'!!$
#7'#$#)(9##$!'7=8>'$!>'7'($!#!((!6#A7''#
=###9#>'##'#
$"#('#''7=8"$'#=#!#6#$!'##>##=8
''7#'#A7#$>#$#$'$(#!!#9'7"$#7(7#
67'=#!#"()9#)'7#="$'3#='9#="##D((#9$#$%
7/29/2019 Empedocles Fragments and Commentary
4/24
+*%C6'#$''9@#>8=$"'8#!$@#$##8#!A7'!#!>'
'#=6(#$=##=#(#=#!-!!#='3#!'#>8%$'
'(!#'#$#)#39)'!#'7=8>'$!%F7%=#$#!3%**0G%%%
+/%'#!#(#=#!-##D("(('7#="$'7(#)#)#A$'#'($!'#
'77)#"'#'#"$#)!!'>#%%%%''9!$$#$'#="'8#$'#!896!!>87'=#=A7'7#8>##)'((86#!9#8
>'($'('9##4!%%%##!86'7!((#=68"''3#7((%''>
!'($89)!#!((')#!#"$>#)#!'($)'=#I$>#!'($#8#(#=#!-6#!"!)#'6()#!#=68'7#=I$##8
6#3(!#)8)(#)'=#!'$"$#8$!66##7'#%
#)'#"$#8)#!##)!(('#$%#!#(#=#!-#
#!=#A$6##9'9#)'##8#)'=#'#9'#6()#$
'#'#">(##3##8#=(#&%#%#!=#-%
**;%'#8>'&'3#$7#->###7'#$!((#"'8#"">((##
#3###(8('9=#>'#='%
,B%)'=#"9@#'#9!#7#>#!!'=87'=#>'$!"7>>!!$#7'####89$#7#)3#7'=%#'($#!">=$9'
((!$#!"$>#3#!=='($!#$!98"$#'($#
)('$"$$)'($'((!$#!A7'=####6')##$#7'$'!'79!$!'($'$#!%7#((9!#"#$#$>7'=$!#6#7'=#)'#"
#8)'=#'9##'3#$#$#!#$8#)'#%*;2%'7'=#!#
(#=#!-)'=#((9!#'3###'!((#A7'=#!###9#>6##!$=#$>'=#">($#!!$$!$>#'!#$7!#!"$#3#89'$!"('9(3#$"9#!''%
*0*%$!>#6#!#6#69#('#3'3#'77#9!=#>#((98
>!$'=#&%##8#=8)'('#$69=#!'>'>"$
(#$'9##=''!(8='#'7'#$(#!!'7'#((#86'$)#(##!!#!'7((9!A!'(#'#''3#)'=#8=$'=#####!8'#
!')#'7='(9!3#(#>!#)'=#'$!)#4!#)#!6#(#
=#!A'>#!#(#=#!-"7''$$!#7'=9'$#))''7#=%
*1;%)'=#">((#((##'>#7!6)6(#'7#!"#3##!')#!'7((9!'>3!(#"#$(('>8!#$$=6=!$##&%#%-$9
((9!!#=)#%
*1.%###!#9''7#!9###$"'8####!998=9'7#'!#A!"#"#7=3#!!#('7='8!74#$'$"!6##"'$"
#5')9)'=6(##!'($#%
7/29/2019 Empedocles Fragments and Commentary
5/24
&!#*1,%>#=987#>!#$!=#=#!$(#6#$6'
''#)'=6(#''7#=#">)!##$3#'8#='
$#=98'%%%%
*20%'#(=!'7#9'$>##=$#'#=(#"(('7#=%
*21%'((##38-8!#(7"#(98!#(7%
*22%J'77#)'$'=4#$'9##%
*2.%#6#$'9##9##!!%
*2B%7##>##'(='#$#6!'7##$#$"!!6'#$'
7''(!>'$!7'=#='!'7=8='(!>'!##((#'7#((%
*2,%>7$9!$$(8=''%
*.;%9##$'9##$3)#!'$#9##3#!%
*.*%!#!)'(8=6'!>'(#$7)#%
&*.0%#$(8(9!#76#'$'7!9%
*.1%!!(9!9#'$))(#'7#=''%
*.2%''>#$(9"))(7'="#3'(3#!'##"!77'(('>9#)'7)'%
*.B%'!##'($!'66'!#'##!)#$))(#'7#('$%
*./%$!#!)#!!8!'#!8'3#"$!6#$!$#!!'3#!=)'7
##!##$'7#9(#=9#8#$=''%
*B;%$9##=#!8)'=97''7#(9!%
*B*%79"!'(8"($#8#$%
*B0%$=87#!####%
*B1%!#->!!6$)#'77#(#7!#!%
&"#*B2%(!=$#!'($>#!)8#8!'7#!%
*B.%#!#!#!>#'7##%
7/29/2019 Empedocles Fragments and Commentary
6/24
*BB%*!!$'>####>!('9''!%%%%'!66##$
'#9=#"'7#=#!'#>!#%
*B+%$9-!>7(86>$!%
*B,%'>!((9')'3##)'!#'7=83#!#!">)!#''$##7'#"$>9=86#!#$!)'!#7'=$!)'!#%J#7##)#$#
('>#!$#6'7##$$8$'3#)'=#!'##=$!'7#>("#((#!#
9!)'=#'9##!6'!'!'#'#('#"8#'==#$#(8"5'9'9###6(#!#"'#7'='#6()#"'#7'='#%$!#8>##
5'9'9##7#$#6#$'#='!'$8%=89!#=#$
=4#$"'#(#9>'!#>##=4#$"#3#!=8!7#"#=9('7"!((##$A7''8#$##(8$#6#$'#='!'$#!
'7#))(#"!'=#'7!=#=#!>###=9>"$'#!$9'#
'!$#%*+;%"5!!7!!)'!(8!97'"5!!'7###3##6
)'=99#(#=='(!#='76#7#)'3#A$((')#>#7'#(##$
>##=='(>##)'=9'#9!='(9!"*>#7'#>##=4#$!=4#$")99#)'!#!%$!#8#(#=#!->##=9(#$'9####
7('>#$7'#=8$!6#)#!'7='(9!"6##$#3#8!''77'=">'$#'#'($%
*+B%'((9!##$"#=!#(3#!>6!'7#=!#(3#!##=9!$
#$!8$!#>#3#9!#7#$(83#!#6#$='(9!%
$!'"#!=#>8">#3#9!##='#$6#$7'=49"#!##('3#$8#)'#$=$#(#86'$#%>#3#9!#'!(##
!#6#$!7!6'!!(#7'=#)'#"'#'9$#=49$
#7'=!=6#!!#$'#="!'(#(8>'#$'#$3#8#7("#
!99#!''77#"!)#!>'9#%
'%#*,.%!>8"8#9''$73''78)#"((9!3#6'>#'7
'9%
*,B%$!'7!>>!(#!$#!#)=#'9##!#87#((%
*,/%'>#!)#!#$8>#"6=#3(7#87#"$#)!#!!'>!!)#')#!#"$"%
*,,%$#$(8#!'$'(('>!#)#3#$>'''7##96!'7
9#!!"$7''7#6!'!"$#8#)=#>#'#!"7#$'9##=3#(('!(88#9(#!'7='8%
0;1%$##=#>#!#(='!#D(='!">#6!'!$='!$9!9##&%#%-"#9)'#$#6#7#)'!'786!A
##((#='##"'((#(#!!>='#'7#'#!%'=#!#'!#(''$
$3'!$!'77(#!%
7/29/2019 Empedocles Fragments and Commentary
7/24
0;+%%%%9(#9(#8=#('9##>>#%
0;,%&J#-#)'!'3#%
'!#0*;%$78'7#((()9#9$'#!#(#=#!-"'>7'=>#$#$$!&7#->##8#=4#$"'!#!))'('!$
7'=!'7='(9!"!=8!'>3#!#$##96'>#'7
6'$#%
0*2%'>'((##!$7!#!'7#!#&'!#-%
0*.%$!#86!">#!#$='!##$##>>#"##$'$93#'!>77#'#$##$%
0*/%$((#!#9!>)>##>>##=$#$#!#">(#'!#>'>##
=$##"=##9>!)='!##$!'786!%
0*,%$!((##!#7&(%#99!-"7!'7(('(3#!%
00;%J##7'#(#'6'=#9#!$(466(#!%
00*%J#!>#!7#=##$#>''$###%
000%'7'!(74#=((8)('!#=$$>)'3##=9)'!(8
>6##'"((#!#9!!((!#(8##7'#3#"$=8'#!!(
'6'!!#!!7'=#=%'#!##=!#(3#!!(()!##)'9'>'!'>))#">#3#!##*'7#)%7'!(#)'7'9!'7'#
!'"!!#=#'7=#"###4!)'(#!!#3(!'(8'!$'!'9!A
!''#!#(#!(()#!#'(3#!=#9'#!'"$#!9!#8$''3##
('9#$7'9##''7#=!#(3#!%''>((9!3#$#!$9$#!#'7#((9#)#%
010%3'#!#)#!!8"$'#$#%
011%!!##38)#$!#((!7'$#!#"'7(=6#!$66(#7!$
!'#)'3##$''!#!%%%%##!('!###(8966#='!'#!7)#%
'"#01B%$(#3#!$)7##!'7$!##!=#9'9"$#6(#!
7/29/2019 Empedocles Fragments and Commentary
8/24
02;%'7>)$3#6'$#>'9#8#!9%
02*%6'$#7!'9#=)'!(8>'$!'7('3#%
020%J##87!9#>'9###$!'76'$#%
021%#(3#>#((!66(#$>(''$%
022%J##=8#$!9#>6>'#)!"$=!>##>$#9'#$"##7'7!'($#!"$#8#!'=#$'('#>'7'##$!%
02/%!!$##$#=(##=!!'7==#=#!A'#=#((#(=!
>)7'=#'$8"#$''#8'3#"9'>39''!(8#6=#'7(7#A
8#'#=#"!#6#$8#3(7#"#8>$##)$77##$#)'!('9###!'7#!#'7(7#%:!!'!>"#6(!$>7!#!
$>#((9>#8((!"$#!!>'!#(!#='!"$$!'#'
>9!%
0.2%!$38>!=9(#$8#='#>$38"#!#9!#6)'=9'9##>#3#>8#)=9))#"$=8'#!(!'$$''#!#
)'((8)=#'#9%
0./%8)##!'!#>$'(#7)#!$$'(##!!"'77!69'7'4#>
=7)#!"$9##!696)($#'7=#>'4#)>##=4#$!'=#6!7'==#$!'=#'7##'7>'=#"7!#$
>!#(#=#=#!%
0B*%(#'7(99">$3$#$''7!%
0B0%)'=#'>"#'7#!#9!A'>7#!#69)!#$#$$#'77!69'7=#$>##69>'=#'!#"7'!'(#67'='!5#)"'>(#!!%
#7!6()###!696''7##7'=!9'>''#>'(#"39
!#'7'"'7>#$'77#%#!#7#)!#$'9'>6"$#!9'#)!(#A#8"%#!'>#$!8#'('3#(8'$87'=#$''7#=#=#!"
'3')#'(=!)!!('=#%
0/;%##'7#=#=#!&'7#)($I-!$3$#$"6#=%%%8!9%
0/1%>!6'#$'#6#6!"$!'=#=##9>)'($#)=#7#=(#!%
0/.%#!#6#$'!'76'$#%
7/29/2019 Empedocles Fragments and Commentary
9/24
0/B%!>=#6!#>'=!6'$)3#'7#=(#"$'!))'=##
$$='#=!)($='#8%
0/,%!>#795)#)$(#!$$!>#=(%
0+;%##$8'7##9=')=##>#$!)9#%
0+*%'>9####4('!7'=((9!>))=#'#4!#)#%
0+*%!!>##>!!)9!>##"$#$#$'#"$!6>#'!6"
$')'6(#$>'%
"!#0+2%J#)'=#!##>>#"!>((9')'=#>'(%
0+B%#(''='7#!)(#$8#=9(#!>!9(#%
0+/%'((#9!##$'A((3#(''$(#!!#!'77(#!!6#$'3##'!$#'7#'$8"$#'6#9!'7#!##'#(8#!'7!#6#)#$((
'3#>)('!#!#$)!"!'#(''$#=!>">(#7)(#'6#9!)
7'#'6!!'9%#>##3##!'7(''$!6##$!>87'=#!#"#!6##$!(9>=6#'!>3#"$>##3##(''$(#6!)#!
##$'A!>#9("6(89>(#6!8$'7!9!!"#!#7
$#'>'6#9'7##$$6!#!'7=!!'7!(3#8>#"#
>#$'#!'')#7('>'#3#!!#("#'$8'7>6#!!9'#)('!#!#'(#!)#)!((!#)'3#!#)'=6#!!#$!#=A#>##
93#!>8#$##=#$=''7>###!%&1;0%-$!'#!=#>8>#
#>#'))6#!#$#6!'7#'@#3#!!#("!('9!#'>'6#9$
6!!9#!(')#$68=7(#!"#'!$#!39#9#(8'##'($!)#>#!$##$#9#!'7##!'$9#"##69)''('7!#$"(
!#(#!9'>#$%
"&1;B%-#"'#'#$"#3#8'66'!##!6()#'>66##$#7'#A#$##=#$=''7>#!'77!###!!#
!=#>8>##!'7(''$"!993'(#(8'9#=#=#!"!#!)'
##'"!>7!#='7)'=#!>89>3#"$>##3#(''$-(#6!)"#!##$'9#D(D8%
1*1%J!'!(!!##9'#79=#!'7=(!$!!#8('>$#(9$9
7/29/2019 Empedocles Fragments and Commentary
10/24
'"!=)!!7#>$!-"!#!)'!!##!'($>9
8!A!'##(#=#(7#"!6=#=#!"#6!7#)'3#9!'##
'$66("$#)'3#9!6'#)9!#$##6>#>)7('>!'"#7#$97'"!=)!!7#%%%%
""#10B%##!'#3!')'=97'='#!-%
10/%#-(#!!#!'7(''$>)$!'66'!#$#)'!"$##='!'7
((#((9#)#)##!7'=#A7'(''$'##!#((9#)##)!#'7=#%
11;%'=#!$'=)#!#!>#7##)#'>(#!#7'##=%
11*%!'7!#8)9#$#)'=#$77##"'!#4#'#!'!'79!#
#3#6#!#7'#=''%
111%'!8#>#!###"$8>#>#"$89(''!A!'"''"87#>#!##$#!'897#"$('3#8('3#"$!7#8#7(!7#%''
'7#!#(#=#!-((9!#7#$'9##$#7'=!74#$"$8#!#=#
$7##('6(#!#$6%
()#11+%J'($#(7'76#!(##9!'"=='(!#"=9#!#'9((7'''9')'=#8#!''7')#!H#=#'>$#
6#!#98=8!$#"(('6#"!#'(#$!)'!#'#(#!!#$9'$!%
120%(#!!#$!#>'!)D#$>#('7$3#>!$'="=!#(##>'=###!!$='6')')#9#9'$!%
122%!'6'!!(#'$>#&'9'$-#3#>##8#!"''#'($'7=
>'$!">)!##!9>8'76#!!''#=$'7=A7'
#!'=#$7#$''$8"'$'>'!''!)'7'=#"'!#7##"'!>7(#9!"'86!"#!!)#$$#77(#=$('#"
$9'9#>'(#>'($>!>7'9!%
*
1.0%;7#$!"8#>'#9#)8'7!)#$9!6'#)'6'(!">'!#
)#!9''$$##$!">''!9#!$#!#39'7#!6#)">''>''>'$'
!##!!"(H9''='98'=='(9'$"'('9#='("''#$8(("!!79")'>#$>7((#!$(49($!%J#!#'=8#$"!'
!''!)'=#'7('!9)#!=#3##)#$8=#$8>'=#A$#8
7/29/2019 Empedocles Fragments and Commentary
11/24
7'(('>7#=#)'(#!!=#!"D9'7=#>!#>8'9"!'=#
>'7')(#!"'#!'7#(6$!#!#!"('9=#6#)#$>9#3'!6!"
#8!##'#7'==####$9#$))''7((!'!'79!%
1B2%>8$'(8>#9'#!#9!"!'9>##$'9!'=#9#9"7
#!6#''='("6#!9=#I
()!#1BB%#$!"'>$##$>#(#!#$!)'!#!#A
(8##)#'7!!)#'#=$'7=!$77)($$##$85#('!8%
1B,%##!#)#'7#)#!!8")#$#)##'7#9'$!"##("!#(#$7!>'$'!>##3#8'#$#7(#!!'$8!7((8>(''$89'#'6#5#!
=!#(7#9$'>'9$'9"'#'7'!#!6!>'##'('9(7#")##
'!$!#!'!!((#>$#67'=#(#!!#$"#9'=#=#((!'!'7='(7'=!")99'##6'7(7#7''#%'=986!#!=
#>$"$#!6#>!=7''##!'($'7"$)!!='#
8!'7#>#89"$'##$$#!'7A'##)#3#!=7'=#'#"$((#=%#'7#!#'>=''"793#7'=#9'$!$
>$##"#=#)8'7997#%
1+1%'#7'#!>!'')#'8"$=$#"$6("$$"$
$97!#!#%1+.%$>#6$!##$'#'($9#>'#$($>###$#$J"$'#!6#)#!'7#!"$>!9$!#!#!"$
6#7)'$7(4#!%
1++%$#!!#8'='3##=#$'>'7#%
1+,%#63#$'7(7#%
1,;%'=>''$'>9#$#9##'7(#!!#$#!!3#7((###'##')'!'>='(#9!H
1,0%J#####!'3#''7#$)3#%
1,1%J##>##'#$7!##9#('6#&%#%$I-"(''$8
'#'$='8'7!#$#7)#"#8$C9(#!!"6##$$'#9"
('3#(8$$#8#$!)8"$#"$(##6$J9"''$(8"=8)'>#$##!!$'>#!!"$(#)#$?')#%
2;;%(!"8#>#)#$"8#(#!!#$)#'7='(#9!"'7>!7#!$'7>
9'!>##8#'H
2;0%#>6!'#=!9#9=#'77(#!%
2;1%!'$9#%
7/29/2019 Empedocles Fragments and Commentary
12/24
2;2%'7'=#9(39#=$##=!!=##7'='7$#8)9#%%%%
2;.%'$#889'$#!"'8$'='!&C6'-"'9E#!"'''!"'
'!#$'"D##86!%##8>'!66#$>(('>#$'77#9!">6#$79#!"$6#7=#!'7!(7((8=$#'$'"$!)7)#!'7=4#$=8$
797)#!#")!9'#9'$('!7'=>8##!%$#(>!'='!##$>6#(''$'7((!">!#9##!$#7(#=#='9=#"'
$#63#=(!'7(7#$'##9''$(8'$#!%
(#2*.%$##>!='9#=='7!('>(#$9#"$=!#
#!6#)((8'7((!'!'7>!#$##$!">'6'!!#!!#$9##!>#('7=$7'
>##3###)#$'>((!=$"#!(8###($#)'#'7((#9!#"#3#7'#$>#89##'!'7=#%
20*%'((>##9#(#$'#$#'>$=#"'=(!$$!"$#8
#$>$(8('3#A$##!9#>>(#3#!$7#3#'#="$##$
>$7((#8#%
20.%!!'(>7(7'!'=#$(>7(7''#!">!(>7(7'((#4#$!')''!(8'9#>$#(9$#'$(#!!(9%
20/%J((8#')#!#7'=#3(!(9#I##8#'8##$#3'9#)'#
##$(#!!#!!'7=$I
21;%7##!6!$#!'>'!)9#$!7'=$!(8!=>68#"!'9#!!7'((8H#8#'#('9#!##)9#!)7)#A#$'#!
'##)#!'7#6')"!(8!#=$=#!#$8##3(7#!%##
!=#=#!'#!7#$$9#!#='#"$$#3'#$#7(#!>##83#$#63#$#='7(7#%
21B%(!'(#!!$8$#!'8#$=##7'#$#3!#$!#$##$!'7$#3'9
>#(6!H
21+%='9#!!#8#)'=#('!9#='!">'!#)')!#
9'$"$='977'(9#$##!#8#)'=#(#(!%
22;%#7##(87'=(#((#3#!%
22*%!#(#=#">'((8=!#(#"#!8'$!7'=#!%
220%'=6'$9#>#7'=73#!69!8#($9!!")(#!##$!%
222%!7'=#3(%
22.%))'$9(88##7)>#3($'#"'#3#!((8##!#8'!'(
7'=#>'#!%
7/29/2019 Empedocles Fragments and Commentary
13/24
22/%(!##86'6#!$8=>#!$68!)!$)#7!='9
=#$>#((9'##A$7'=!#89'>'#9'$!"#)#39#9##!
''!"!9#!=##>#'#=='(!"#(#)'=6'!"7##7'==>'#!"#8'$#6'>#'7$#$=%
,B%!(''$>>)>#"'"'7#%%%I
%2,1%$6#6!>##((8#$#$"!')##7'##$'#'7#>!#=#
!8'>>##$#$"$#'$8''="$6'7#!'("!'66#!">)$#!#!#"!'6#'6#!!'$='3#!6>$$$'>>$%
$$##$)(#3#=6#6!!'=#'7)(8'(8!6#9
((#9')((8"$9#>'$7'=#9"!
5=9#6#)#$>'(#!!9#!=(##)!#'7!!#$#!#!%
"/B)%'8'!8">=6#$'(#!"###)##77(#)#!7'=9!I#(8%
$6'#!"'>)$'9>)##77(#)#!9'I#!$##$%
(!#$!'=#'7##77(#)#!=))#'7#6'#!"$'#!#
!=((#'(9#I!#%
$##!!)9!3!'I#!%
$%%%)'('!##77(#)#'77'=!9##=#>3!'$6#)#6(#8
!#!#I!%
%02%$)#'$)(!#!9##$(#!!7#!'
>#3#'9##''6'!$'!8#9!=8$'#$!)''((#$8#$('3#%'#6!(>8!'#'9##"!8#='#!#3##
'7#!#!%#9#(#)')#$##!#9!#(>8!!"$#8!8"
6"!'=#=#!((!'#$#$##$('3986'$#">(#'#=#!!
=8$#=8>!#(78#!''7!''7!7#%
+
!%%1A*+/0;%$'#!!8#'66'!#!#4!9#8#!#6#$
''7"!4=$'!!8!"$!'!#!8>''($9!#''#$=8"!=6#$'(#!$49'!%
7/29/2019 Empedocles Fragments and Commentary
14/24
%2A*++*+%!##'!!=##(#=#!7#>#=#$(=#$"!
=6#$'(#!$'#!%
%2A*,B0;%=6#$'(#!!8!#!'(>8!!#6#$6>$!"!66#!%
3%*A0.;0/%=6#$'(#!!8!9!#=''6'7#=#$9
#8##!A#8#=''>#'3##$!'=#'#''7=8"'7#
#$!'=#=8''7'#"$##3#9=##8##!&?3%B,/1-%
3%*A0.0B%'!#)#!!8')'!$#!&=''-7!6)6(#">)!##=!=6#$'(#!=#!!89'7#)#!!8'3#$7#)''(9!$
='3##=6'7#=#"$#8##!$9##3#9=#%
($##$0/,*2%'=#!8(##(8'#=###!)'=9'
#9"'#=###!6#!9"$!(>8!)'#!'##)!#A!'
!8=6#$'(#!'799#=$#(#'!'76#!!%
%*A0+202%##)>#!!=#!7#!=#'"9#9
!('>#=''!'>$'>>$='=#='))''7''"!((!6#!#3#$!'('9=#"!=6#$'(#!!8!%
%*1A0,.*.%#8!###)!#>8#=!"$!'=#!87#!=#"
!#$'!@#!#)!#A'#!"!=6#$'(#!"#='3#=#'7#
#3#!#3'(39))(#$='39='#!('>(8"$#!#='''7##"(#>#3#!!#(!%
%0A1;**2%!'9'=#9##!!#6()#''7>!!#6#$$=''%J##7'#=6#$'(#!6!!#!'3#9##!!#)!#'7'3#A7'#)'($'
6##3#'9##6#69''76!$##!#6#$"$=9#)'='8=#!'7'3#A7'#'$#'7##(#=#!!###!(!#$''7
6!$##!#6#$"!'#)#!!(8'!#''7>!'#$
)'=6'$#$%
%0A1;00+%=6#$'(#!!8!7#$#$!!')#$#(#=#!###(#=#!'7'$#!"$((9!#)'=6'!#$'7#!#%
%BA1;.*%7!#6'!((!'=#>8#!'66#$"###'$8>)
!!'66#$>((#$3!(#"'#9!#6(#!'#>((#3##$3$#$"!=6#$'(#!!##=!'=#%
3%0A1;,*,%'=#>'$#83'$#4!!"$''$#7#)#7((8(9$#38"
!49'!$=6#$'(#!%
7/29/2019 Empedocles Fragments and Commentary
15/24
(%%*A1*2/%J##7'#6#$'(#!!6#!7#!=#"
!89'9)'=#!'#9"##!'(8=4#$!#6''7#
=4#$%
*%*A1*.1%=6#$'(#!!##=#$'')'$)9!!#866#"$'
)'$)=!#(7%''#=##!8!''#'7##(#=#!!#!7'='#"(('#9!!#7'=#!#A$'#=##9!(('7
#'9##''#"#4)#67#"$!8!#)9!#!7'=#'#%
*%+A1020B%'=#'9#)!#!#=6#!!'>!#)#3#$'9)#
6'#!7'=#(!$!'9#!9#>)###$"$#8!87#!=#
>#!##$#$6#)#3#8((#'#!#!#!"$7#>#!##'9$>#$!6#!!)#!#)!##83#6'#!#3!(#8#!'
'7#((##!!"$#)('!#'9##!##!A$#='#!6#!!)#!
3#='#6'#!%8=$#$#7#!#=#!7#!=##9$')#
9!"!$$=6#$'(#!"''(8#9$')3#$6!!3#'$#!"#(!'
!8!'!#'$#!#=9(#$"#6'#!'7>)9##>#)'#%%%%
%+A10.12%'=>!(8'#=(6()8)'($'!#"'8#)'($8!#
7'=>!(8=7'($"7'!!=6'!!(#A!=6#$'(#!$!'=#'#!
!8"#9!#77#)#$'96'#!"!'(()9#$((66#9!#!7#!=#"!#6'$$#!)'96()#'9#3'$"$(#=#
9'>"!'($'$#!)'=99$((8%'!(='!#)#!!87'=6#$'(#!'
!8!#66'!$'#!A7'###!'=#!'($$$3!(#'$#!"(#!!6'#!#!'(#(8)'9'!%
10.*,%!7'=6#$'(#!"!#3$##('#'($!'9##!!$
$#!)'!7!##(#=#!#)')##$"'>#99#9#=!!'7#!#!#!$6#!#!"!'#3$#"'!6'!!(#7''#'!8>'$##!##!#(#=#'77#"$(#=##(#=#'7#)'#9!('>'#
#=#'!%
%1A11;*,%$!'=#!8')####7'#(#=#!"!=6#$'(#!%
(#)'=#!#='>'A7'#!#!((##!'3#9!7#%
%BA1110;%7##$'#!'!#6###(#=#!"'3#!#6#!'!#>)
#'9##7'#9'$A$#!##9'$!%##'%1./02%(#=#
>'($#!$78'#"!89#!#!#!>#'7##"'9#>!
!8989$!)$)(#"!7'!)#=6#$'(#!A7'!)!#=#=96#6!#!77)#7'#66'!#!'76'#8&7'#=#6'!6'#)(-"
'((7'#'>(#$9#'7#%
1B,**%'=#!87#'9#!#)('$!A$=6#$'(#!!8!!!>!#)'=6!!#$8#8!'7#!%
7/29/2019 Empedocles Fragments and Commentary
16/24
#%0A2;2/%!=8!68)#7(#''#7)>!!'(!
=''"#!#!!=#!'(!#='!=6'!')#'7=''A$!=8!
)'!$#'>!$6#)#3#!#9!"#!#!8#7!6)6(#!!'("!'=#=9='#'#7!6)6(#$'#!=9'#"!=6#$'(#!!8!#7!
6)6(#!#6'$)'7((##(#=#!"$#)'7#!#!!'("!89&?3%111
11.-%
%2A2;+*2%$(#=#!!9#!'(!'($##)!#'7#=4#A7'#=4#'7##(#=#!$'#!'3##!=#)!#!7(#!$'#%
##!(#>((####=8("#!'(!'9#>'(#'$8"7
((9!!#''7##(#=#!3###=9(#$'9##A$#)!#'7#=4#!='8$!'(%
%.A2*;0+%'3'(3#!=86#6(#4#!'!8"!=6#$'(#!$'#!"#)
9!'>8#=#(#(#=#!"$(#8(#%%%$!'
=6#$'(#!#9$!9'$!='!()9#6'>#'76#)#6'A7'#('#$'#!
''>'#'7##(#=#!"7#"$)#-((6#!(#9!7'#)'7#!#!7'=((#(#=#!-%
%2A2*.0+%$=6#$'(#!>!)'#)>##>#''!86(!9#>
$'>>$!>#''!'9###)!###9'#!!$#)'((8"$#89#>6>$!#)!#7#9'#!!$#)'%
%/A2*+0;'!#3$#(9!#6#!#)#'7!&7#-%$=6#$'(#!
>!>'9"$8'##(!#>'=83#9##$>="!89#(9='3#!$!#!#>###$>!'$!##"'9#!)6#!'
')#%
#!#!%22*2%!#)#!!8#>#!'($3##7'='77($!
3!(#8#!''7!!=((#!!"!=6#$'(#!!8!%22B0B%=6#$'(#!!8!#(97'=#!7!##!##=#$#!6)##7'#)'=#!'3!'''
##%
##!6%2//10%=6#$'(#!>!)'#)!89#>=#!=(!39
#='!7#>##D)"3'$9##4)#!!'7>=##"'$#!)###>!()'7)'($$>##="#8=9#6#!#3#$8#6'!'%
#=%2+00,%J#7##)#'#9!'=#$''!8>!7'"'(8
$#!)##=#>)#!6()#"!=6#$'(#!$#=''!%
(()#2+21+%=6#$'(#!!8!79#(!!#7'=!#>8$#9%
%*AB2;*,%'=6#$'(#!>!>'9!89=8))#!)!66#=(!#)!#66##$'#!#"!#83#!)
!6##)!##866#'#$#!)#$#$7'='##!#(7)%%%
7/29/2019 Empedocles Fragments and Commentary
17/24
%*AB20*+%$7'==#'=#=6#$'(#!))#!'!"9$#$8#
!#(7"$!)'=6#((#$'!8#9$###!'"5!!>##!
$#)(9>'#!A7'#$'#!'!8!'#'7##(#=#!"'>''##"'(('7#="!##!''7#=4#'7#!#%
#%%A+*.*B%49'!$=6#$'(#!!86(!#='3#$8$#!#"$!!##83#6#)#6'$7##(6(#!#$6%%%%=6#$'(#!'9
!#4$##=4#$#=%&'#+*/*"*;"$1B%-
%A+*.*0%=6#$'(#!#(%!$6(!3##((9#)#$'>(#$9#%
%A+*/1.%=6#$'(#!!$96(!3##7#'>'($
>)!'6#7#)!7(7(=#"$>#!7(7((#$=(!9###$%
%1A,+2+%=6#$'(#!!!=#!7'#(#=#!"$$9#!7'''!#
3###=#'#$A7'#!#(>8!$#$$'')'=#'#9"9##!!
$!=((#!!#8#)'=6'$#$$!#6#$''7'#$''#%
%1A,+210%$!)##'66'!#'#9''$66##$'#4!#"$''(8
'$#$#8(!'$!'$#$9(#!!"$#$66##$'#='##9''$$#9(8='###7("!'!'=#'##(!#'$)#$'3#$7#"
#)#)!#'7'#'7#!#%'7'#>##'((#7'(('>$=##
!!=6'))'$)#>#!'$'))'$)#>>=6#$'(#!
7''(!(8!8!"#>((7$'3#'##)!#'7>!9''$"$7#'7>!$A!'7'#>##'!8=6#$'(#!!6'#7#)#=#$>!#
7!')((#$$#9''$7!6)6(#!"6#6!#>'($!6#9(8"7#
9''$!#(7>###)!#'7((9''$9!"$#$'7(($9!%
"%%2A,*.0*%$=6#$'(#!=#!='#!#'7)!#!49'!"'$##$!77)#(8A'$'#!#7$#=>!##9##$6'%8#('3#
7'=!'7#!#69)!#$!7#9)!#%'>##3##((!
!#6#$'##(#=#!8!7#"7#$#)'7#'##(#=#!#)'((#)#$''#A$9">##3##8((#'9'9##''#8('3#"6!#
#)#!!(8!#6#$97'=#)9%=6#$'(#!='#'3#$77##$7'='!#
>'>##7'#"#$!)=#$!)!#$'$)#$"'=9#)!#'7='''#"$77##$'66'!#%#"#7!$#!)#$#7'
#(#=#!!6'#'7!#7'='7=#A#$$'!##=!7''(8!
>'"7#8!#(7"$##!'66'!#$'7#!#9'##"#$$
>#%
*%+A,+,0;%$#!=#9!#7'#!!#!#!##='#=#'!
'#"!=6#$'(#!!8!=#!7'!!)#!%'!#)#!!8#!=#
6#)(#!(!!'($'($9''$>#7##)#'=%'>#!####(#=#!!97'=#)'#!=)!7#$#$'')'##!=#!!)#&7'!'
!!$'7#=#3#!#!'#-A$>#7##)#'#)!#'7#=''"
7/29/2019 Empedocles Fragments and Commentary
18/24
>##!#)#!!8'!!=#'#'>'">#=!#)#(8$$'
!6###)'#)'6!#>'8=#%
(((#*%,A,,1*.%'#7!6('!'68!##=!'!6#)(#(8#9$'((9!"!'9>##)($!!)!#!$7!6)6(#">##3#
=6#$'(#!!8!'##4!!8#!'"!">!>>!$>##!!#)#'7#=#>!%#%%2A*;;;0.%$=6#$'(#!>'"'#=9
"!6'#='!)'!!#(8"#3##$#!=##46##)#"7'#!!#!)#7!6)6(#"7#"!#)!#'7$#!)'A'#=9'##(#!!
#3#!)!#!9##'''7#8A7'(('#9!#7'=!!#
!')#"#4)#69'$%
"%2A*;;;10%$67'=#!#3#!#!&33%*;2*;/->'($##3$#"7'
7!7#>##'#4!99!"((>'($#'#"!(#!8!A7'>##8)'=#
'9##"!7#)'=#!'!$(!'7((%J##7'##!(!7'=#='!
(#!!#$'$!(#!!#((9#)#'##9!A7'#$'#!''>((#
#(#=#!A7'#$'#!'3#!7#"$'>(#$9#'7#(#!8#(#%#%%2A*;;;*B%#$'#!'=#)(#8)!#'7#)#!!8%"#3##(#!!"#!8!!
=)('#)'!!#(8"7'#$'#!'=#!'=##9!6#!(#$'#!=6#!(#"#=#!((6#!(##4)#6##(#=#!%$#6'(#='>
$#$!)!!'!>8!'=#9!#4!$'#!$''"7#8#7'=#!=#
(#=#!-%#%4%*;A*;/.0%$=6#$'(#!!6#!=#"7'#=#!7#$!6#9''$%$!!#7!6)6(#"'!#='39)!#"7'9!
9!'9##A$!=#"7'!6'7#=4#%
%3%.A**2/*0%#!#6'>#'!6#((%#''$#!$"!
$#=#6#93#!#!'7=6#$'(#!%%3%0A**../%#!")($9
=6#$'(#!"!8#'66'!#"#(#!##!#(#%
"%**A*0;+**%$#!8!>#$'9>!))!'=#$(>8!'!(##6
'#!=#(#"=6#$'(#!>!!#$>8#$'9(>8!!(##6!'#!=#(#"$
#!>##$#$'9$!'=#(##!!'#(#"!'#(##!!!##!'7'!7#D#9%
%*A*22/*B%'=#$=6#$'(#!3#'9)'=='#=##"!'
#7'=#!'($#)((#$6'#"#(#!'($##)((#$!$#'7
#%
%B.A'9%#%3%./%!'(#"#"!8!=6#$'(#!7!$!)'3##$#')$E#'$(#))%
%BBA'9%#%3%B1%!'(#!8!=6#$'(#!-#)=#7##$#!9#$
7'=#3#87'='7(#"7$##$##7!#$#'8(6'>#>!9#$'="!K'!!8!!))''7="#3$#(8=)6#7#9!!=6()8%
7/29/2019 Empedocles Fragments and Commentary
19/24
,,-.
#%()%%1A#%%0+/%=6#$'(#!'79!"!''7#'"!8!###7'
#(#=#!"7#"">#"#A$>'$8=)7!6)6(#!"('3#$!7#A'#'7#!##$!'#"#'#'!#6#%$#!6#!!7'(('>!#7!#7'
''!'7((9!"9E#!$(7##9#$$'#!"$#!!">'='!#!#!69!'7=#>##!%'>8E#!#=#!#!##9$#
##"8(7##9##='!"((/#$8$'#!##A$8
#!!"!69'7=#"#=#!!>##='!!##$$>#%
%2A0,*%=6#$'(#!#3#!#!'#A''>#3##3#!#!#(("
!'=#((#6'7#(("$##!!=#%%/A1;1%$#'($!#'#!
#)#!!8"$!=#)'!!!'7#7'#(#=#!"$!7'=!#!7#$
('3#%$#)((!##(#=#!9'$!"$#=4#'7#!##3#!#%$!
7'=8>((##!'(3#$'#=A*$#!!'(!#$3#"$6#=#>'6#>83#!#'7#=#(#=#!-#$3#%%*1A1*0%
=6#$'(#!)'7#7'#(#=#!###!=((#!6)(#!"!>###(#=#!#7'##(#=#!"'='#'=##!&!"'$#$!-%%*.A1*1%=6#$'(#!$#)(#$
)'('!#=''!9##=#'73!'>#6'#!%$###7'
#D3(#!'7##(#=#!>#"()"#$"8#(('>%%*BA1*.%=6#$'(#!&$K#'#!-##(#=#!#)'=6'!#$'73#8!=((=!!#!>)##='!
=#6'!!(#"$!>###(#=#!'7#(#=#!%%02A10;%=6#$'(#!#(%$((
>'=##3#!#869'9##'$#!'7!=((6!"'$)#)'='!
$!#6'!"'9##!!$$#!)'!'(#(8A7'#!#)9#!#6()#'#!6#)'D(88!7'='"#!6#)'D8869'9##%
%0BA10*%=6#$'(#!##!!#)#'7#)#!!8!##77#)3#)!#'7#7!6)6(#!$'7##(#=#!%
)%()%%*A#%%10+%=6#$'(#!#)'!#'7#!!#'(#'7#(='7
#3#!#%%2A11*%=6#$'(#!#3#!#6#!#!))'$9'#(#9
(#'7'3#$7#%%BA112%=6#$'(#!###>!7!!#6#$"$
!#)'$(87#"$##"7'=>)"((!#!>!)'=6#!!#$9(88#7')#'7!''">#9!#$7'A$7'=!#'!#!36'"$#
#3#!'!#7'=###"#!7'=#7#"$'$#!'##>##
)'=6#!!#$''7#'#!%%/A11B%=6#$'(#!9!#'74#$6'!''9'#(("'8###6()#!'7##(#=#!$#7#$"((9!6#'7
'#'#%%+A11+%=6#$'(#!J##93#!>8#6$='''7#
!"#'6'(#!#!'##9'!'7#'##(#3#$$#(#9'!'7#!'$#6#!!#$#!6#)'#>'(#3#!#%**%*;A11,%=6#$'(#!#9
!$#!'>$#!==#!'(!)#"$#(#7'>$#>#!'(!)#%%**A11,%
=6#$'(#!##3#!!'($7#$7'=!74#$)8!((#7'=87#"
$#=)#!>6#!'7##'77#$'7##'7#)'7##=!6##!%%*1A12*%=6#$'(#!#!!#7#8'$#!7'=#$'77#8=#"
>)##=)9!#(76#!!#$7'#7!!#6'%120%#74#$!!
7/29/2019 Empedocles Fragments and Commentary
20/24
#'$6>#)8!((#&3(-"#6(#!#!#7##%%0;A1.;%
=6#$'(#!###>'!!A#'#!#)#86#"7##'##=!6##'7
#3#!#">)!7((#$#=!6##"(>8!!#7)9#9#!!>))'#!6'$!'!#(7A#'#!#!66#!"#)'#!6'$99#!!#
'##=!6##!##7((#$>=4#$>#"#)'=9#)8!((#
!8#7(#)'7'=#'$#$#"$$99#$('9>#='''7#7#8#=!6##A'!6##7(8"#!!#9#!!)'#!6'$9'#7#
!'$!##%%0*A1.*%#!>)7)#!#'66'!#9#!!"!'7#
!=#!@#!##%%01A1.1%=6#$'(#!#!'(!)#!#$#'#7)#!!$##$7'=='39(($#(>8!!9(#8#!6###)('!9
"$8#'6)))(#!%%02A1.2%#!!#)(6!#$>##=''6!!#!#7'#
%%0.A1./%=6#$'(#!#=''!'((#$'9##")('$(#"!74#$7'=$#
'7#"!'!=4#%%0/A1.+%#=''!#7'='7$!%%0+A1.+%#=''!!(97'=#!%%1*A1B0%=6#$'(#!#=''!>)#!7
7'=#!!!7'=##&I-1B1%#$!)#)'!!##3#!!9##
##97'=#'#3#.>)!#$!)#'7#=''7'=!A
))'$9'!##3#!='#!6#$'"#)!##3#!#!$!6'!#$#!6#'7#99%
#%()%%1A#%%1B+%=6#$'(#!&$#$(99#-#=6)'7(9
')('$!'#(9!!'#>)$#!A##49!9'7#(9$##96'7#)('$6'$)#!)!"$#$(9'76'$)#!
(99"$#$#'(!#!'$'7#(99%%+A1/.%=6#$'(#!$
#')!J#)'=#!>##!=!#"#97')#$68)'$#!'A$!==#>#7#!=!#">#!7')#$$'>>$!%%*BA1+*%#!#!#
!>#'7##"'9'8##'7#!'))''7)#!#$6#!!#%
#%()%3%1A#'$%3%*+A#%1+,%=6#$'(#!#!'(!=4#'7>!$###!!#)#%3%.A1,0%=6#$'(#!#(%$$!'(##!=#"!'#'6''=(>'($#!'(#(8$#3'$'7#!'%#'$%3%01A1,0%
=6#$'(#!#(%#!'(!=6#!(#%#%3%,A1,B%=6#$'(#!#(%
#!'!#$#)#63#%1,/%#!'!!#686))'$9'#!8==#8'7#6'#!"#)6)('5#)'7!#!##9$6#$'!'=#!#!#&'9-%3%*1A
2;1%((=6#$'(#!?!'#)#3#!=6#!!'!'8=#!'78!$8
=#!'7=9#!%='#8#!#)'$=#'$A7'#)#3#!#77(#)#!%3%*2A2;.%(#)'!7'=='!-#6()#8=#!'7#77(#)#!!#'#!7)#'7
#='"$#8#)'=6(##$8=#!'7#7#8=#!!#6#$7'=#
='"$#!('9#>)(#!#7'##='>)#!#=!7('>%
3%BA2;B=6#$'(#!#9#!6()#8#=6)'7>$'#)(9#'7##">)"#!8!"!96!$###!'!'!>9$#!)7##
=#'7#((%3%*/A2;/%=6#$'(#!=#(!'$)#$>#9!'7#
(9!A>##3###9#)'=#!#38"$'#!'5'#6#)#6''))''7'9#!!"!#)!#'7'!#>'!77#7'=7(4%300A2**%
=6#$'(#!#7!#'7#=(#!6()#>##='!#7!
93#!>8"$#'!$#)'=#!'#3'$'###'6#9'7#(9!#!$#A$7#!#=6(#$>=#'!#7'=>'6#!!#!'7'=
7/29/2019 Empedocles Fragments and Commentary
21/24
#('>#8=#"##9'A$#)'#!6'$9#'#'#
'))!'!)'#!6'$9##9'7#"##9%$>)'>
)''(!#(''$!9'#!'#!7)#$!6#!!#!'#8=#'9#'!(!8!'>)#!'!'>$6!!9#"#)'=#!##9'A$>#
#!)$##!'#7#'6#9!#!)##$'9#(''$"
!(##9%$#=#'!#!)#'7#)(#6!8$%
#%%3%/A2*,%=6#$'(#!(#'7#=(##'))'$9'>=$)'($#!!A>#)###)'$!#7!=(#!>##''##!$!'7'=#
#"$#7#=(#!'#'%3%+A20;%=6#$'(#!'!'!#!#$#'''
=)'(('#''((#!##$&!#=#-"''$!)#'7=''"''$3!''!#3#(6!"''#$9!$#%?%*;A20*%=6#$'(#!>!$6(#!#
$#'#4)#!!'7!##$$$3!''7%3%**A200%=6#$'(#!##!!#!&'7)($#
'6#!-#$#'6'>#'7#77(!##$"$$77##)#!'))>##>=#!##$!$!!6#$%*3%*0A201%=6#$'(#!77!69#7'=#$))'$9'#
7)8'7#>'=#=#'7)')#6'A7''7#=#!>'=#7((('3#>
=9#!$!#!"$97''77!69(##!#%3%*2A20.%=6#$'(#!&(#!#'7#(#-#)!##>'=!!=(($('>$'>"$)#$'##((8
#3#!#=#"!'#!##$$'#!'9''!9"'>'($#)#3##
!##$#3#7!'($#)%3%*.A20.%=6#$'(#!##=8'!F'G(3#"
#4!!>'#9##((8A$#7!#'7#=(#!6()#">##='!#7!93#!>8"$>##8=#7'=>')'=#!'
#3'$"'##'#'6#9!'7#(9!%3%*,A21;%=6#$'(#!#7!
9##'!'7=(!$6(!>###3#)'=6(##">##8'#$>)'9'!6!A$#!#)'$>##7'=!'76!#('9'9##A$#$"'76!
9'>''#>'(#A$#7'>##'('9#7'=(#6!"!7'!)#7'=
#$>#"7'=#(#=#!(#$86#=#9#)'#A7'!')#7''$
#9)'$#!#$"7''#!#7#!!'7#7#=(#!)!=9#4)L#'7#='''7#!##$%$#)(!!#!'7((#=(!>##!#6#$'))''7!)=49!A
'!#='#$6#$'#>#!#$'!"'#!!(#$6'#!=8!
$#='#'77#8=#"$##3##=#$'##"$#D(6''!#=4#!6'#(("###!!'7((%?%00A212%=6#$'(#!(#!!#
6'$)'7#D(6!'7#7'#(#=#!=4#$'9##"$!#>!'7$'(#6''!
'77#$#=4#$'9##"$#)(>!'7=(!##6'$)'7!#>!)((#$8)')>#"$'#!'7>'#D(6!'7>#$'7#$
7'6!'77#=9(#$'9##%$!>#$#!)'=#7'=(''$!>!#!
>8"$7('>!'#)!#!#)'=##7#$%3%02A21.%=6#$'(#!(##6!='$##)''(9'7#>=#(''$"$#)'=6(##)''(9%3%0.A21/%
=6#$'(#!#!!#6''7#7#8=#''7#=4#'7>)#=
!)'=6'!#$A!'7'=!!$6'$#'7#'$8$'7#!'(66#!'9##A$!(##6!!#69'7#7#8=#%3%0BA21+%=6#$'(#!##!7!
'7(39#9!!697'=##"#7'##!>!7'($#$##3#!$
#7'#$8$9>##!#6#$A$8#!''7#!8==#8'7#=4##8
)'#6)6(#'7=(#$7#=(#A$#89'>"#9!#$8#>=!##"!'#8#6!'7##"5!!#7#!##((8!6'7#
>'=A$#7!#!#)#'!'7#>#$7##6(!A$'!#>)
7/29/2019 Empedocles Fragments and Commentary
22/24
()&!77)#-='!#!#$#(#3#!!===#>#!#36'#$"'!#
>)3#='#='!###6#(#3#!"!#)!#'7#(#($#'(3#$
#$#6(=A$$77##)#!#5)#!#&$#'-3'!#=#'7#)'=6'#6!"$#$77##)#!6(!!##)!##8$#3##
'='#'=##!7'=#>)-'!#!#="!#)!#'796#3#!A7'
!'#$'73#>)=#!>#9''$"#$'7!'(>)#!%3%0BA22;=6#$'(#!=(!##$8#!!)#'7>!'#=
F='!#G"$(%)##89'>>#6#!#)#'7>="$9'>!=((#$
$#>###'7#!#!!#A$=#'7#6#!#=#"!)'=6#$>#7!(39#9!"3####$)#$'#!@#'77!&I-%3%0+A22;%=6#$'(#!
#!#!!#=(!7'=()'7##(#=#!>'($#$##)'#)'=6(##"
$6(#!#!%%%
#'6%!&%1A#%%2/+%=6#$'(#!'799#==#!#=#(#(#=#!7'7#$$>#$#"(('7#=##("$)99
='$!=((#!!8)'=6'!'$!#6'A$#!'(#7!6)6(#!8
>)#!#7'#!#=''"#'3#$7#A7'##(#=#!=!)'#'#='3#$"'#=##9'9'9##8'3#$'#!#6#$8
7#A!'!3#>###!47!6)6(#!A7'!'=#=#!#93#!#)3#
6'>#''3#$7#">##!8!&33%B/B+-#6#)#3#879'#6'#!'7#)!#!#%'#8(%##'(#'$!)#'#'#7'#'5#)'7!#!'"!'!'=#9!9'9'9')#$"$'#!#(#'##)'=6(##(8%$##=6!'$#!)#>
3!'!A$(#!8!>!##8#!7#$>#"$>!'$!!
#$"'9>)(9#97###!"!#(9(#!%'#!'77#$>##!#(##(8"$#7#6'#!#)'9!#>#'5#)!"#>#6'#!
()'5#)!A7'#)'('!='!#>#6'#!%$#)'('!='3#'3!'
8=#!'7#77(#)#!%$#8#')'=6'!#$(#%%%$!'=#'7'66'!##(#=#!A7'!'=##7#!>$7''#!!'#'!$#"!'!'=#=(!
!#####$8=#$'#!9A'!#3#(#!!7#!####8$8"
7'#(9!$##=!()#$8#(9'!$##=A$'!#3#(#!!
>#!####9"7'>!()9!=$#67'#=%$#'66'!#)!##)'8!#A7''!#3##='#7##$=!9#$"!)##7#
)#!96(!#!6$)'3#!#6'#!'7>##$8=#A$7''!#
7/29/2019 Empedocles Fragments and Commentary
23/24
3#>##4)#!!"#!=#966#!9A7'#7#!)'3##$68#
>#%%%C(#)!#'7!'=##>#!!#6#$8#'!$#(9"$#
)!#'7'#!#7#8#A7'#)#'7#)!!'66'!#%>)!)'=6'!#$'7'#D(6!!##!#=6##$$='!#4)#((#3!'%!"
66'4=#(8"!>#!8!)')#93!'%$#9!##!('7'!#
)'=97'='!$#%'>#-!!#=''8!'$"##!#)'>A7'##9!!>###((#)'9>"$###)((!#9"!''!#3#####!!=#((>'!##='3#!='!D)(8A$#!'9#!'$'!#!!
#77(#)#7'=7#$(9'$#!%#=#!')#7($!)='>
#7##)#'!#$')!#6#(8"##'>'8>=#!#8#6()#"
#4)#6#9##(!#=#!#!'#!6()#879'#6'#!A$6(#!#!$#'(##!!#!##(#=#!$#=4#"$6'#
'66'!#%$#!6#!!=((8)')#9'9$9')#9!8
>!(#"$'6#)#39!8>!(#"!)#'9!#!=#9!"'
!'=#9(#"!#!'%'#)'9'>>##)'9!##)98#)"#!$(#9&33%11B11/-'>''7'!#(#=#!-((9!#7#$'9##$
#7'=!74#$"$8#!#=#$7##(6(#!#$6%'!8(''$#!6#)((8>#A7'!#!6#)((8#=9(#$##(#=#!'79!%$
'!#>'=#D($(#6!3###=4#$"'''76"'8#!=((
6!"'#4)##$99#"#!#3##='!#((9#)#$#='!))#!#!#!A$'!#>'66'4=#'!)'=##4A$'!#>'3##'66'!#D(#!
##='!()9#((9#)#%$'!#>'=##(#=#!#!)##$$
#7#$"#'6$$#!(879#$A$'!#>'=##(#=#!#!=(($
'>)('!#'9##"='3#!'6$(8$=##>!'=89!#8))'=6(!((#8#!''7#!>7#!!'7#='''7#(''$%$'!#
>'=##!>#((#=6##$=4#!'=#'#6"#>!#!6'A!'!'=#
#9''$''!"'#!9''$!!"))'$9!#=4#!#(%%#$!'#'9#A$#!=#!#'7#'#6'>#!%
#'6%.,A#%%.*B%$=6#$'(#!!8!'7)'('!>#!$#'
7#"$()'>#%
)%#%4%A'4%=6#$'(#!"('9>=8'#=!#!"=#!!>'!#'!)')#6''7#9'$!%'#7'#9!'7>)#'($!((
9!)'!!"#)'!$#!$3#A!)(##!##'$$#$#
$#3'$'7((!#!#%66%(%1A'4%..+%$=6#$'(#!">'(3#$(#"!$
=))')#9##'7#$3#!"'>#8(3#9#=#!####$=9#9!##%#!$'3#$7#>###7!6)6(#'7#
(("$##((9#7#'7#='$!9'$"$((9!#7'=#$7'=
7#$##!'(3#$'7#A$#')!9##)('!#(8>!#)9"#8#46#)9##()'7(9'%$##(#3#$='!7((8!=9'"7'#!$
#$#'((!'!'7=(!%
7/29/2019 Empedocles Fragments and Commentary
24/24
66%%2A#%..,%###(#'!"6%B2%
(%*;A#%%.+0%=6#$'(#!'799#=##(#=#!#7'7#"
>#"##"#%$#)!#'7#!#!'3#$7#%'=#7!=4#'7##(#=#!#!8!#>!!#6#$$6'#$'$))(#A$7#
##7#'77"$'398'#6()#'9''"67'=$##)#>!'$#%$###>'#=!6##!='39))(#'$#
#"#'#'76#7#"#'#'7$((#7#=4#$">)(#!!9%$=''(%/##9!#!('7#>#9'7#7#>#>!)'((#)#$%
$#!!'7#!#"#7(#)''77#"(#>)#!6()#
>#%$#!8!#='')'!!!'7!##!687#"7'!#)'=#!!'($(#(A$!(99#!7'=#!%#(96A!'#
#$'##!"#(''$A>##7'#>#3#6'7#'$8#='#'7
!!!6#$"6=##4)#(%
66%%%*,A#%.,*%=6#$'(#!'799#="!''7#'"#9$#$
7#$#$>#$!#7'7!#(#=#!"$#!$#=8!#7!'7##(#=#!%'"#!8!"#8>##!#6#$7!"'>#8##$
''#"#)'=9('3#$8#)'#%'!3#>#7!6)6(#!$6'>#!#>'"=8$'3#"'7>)#'##$!'99!'9##$#'#'
!#6##=%