Top Banner
The anaphoric use of the demonstrative in Saotomense Emmanuel Schang [[email protected]] Université d’Orléans (France) CORAL_UPRES-EA 3850 http://www.univ-orleans.fr/lettres/departements/SDL/
24

Emmanuel Schang [[email protected] ...demonstratives/...Saotomense: a Portuguese- based creole language E_Schang DGfS2007 Spoken on São Tomé island (Gulf of Guinea).

Mar 28, 2021

Download

Documents

dariahiddleston
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: Emmanuel Schang [emmanuel.schang@univ-orleans.fr ...demonstratives/...Saotomense: a Portuguese- based creole language E_Schang DGfS2007 Spoken on São Tomé island (Gulf of Guinea).

Theanaphoricuse ofthe

demonstrativein Saotomense

Em

ma

nu

el S

ch

an

g[e

mm

anue

l.sch

ang@

univ

-orl

eans.f

r]

Un

ive

rsité d

’Orl

éa

ns (

Fra

nce)

CO

RA

L_

UP

RE

S-E

A 3

85

0htt

p:/

/ww

w.u

niv

-orlea

ns.f

r/le

ttre

s/d

epart

em

en

ts/S

DL/

Page 2: Emmanuel Schang [emmanuel.schang@univ-orleans.fr ...demonstratives/...Saotomense: a Portuguese- based creole language E_Schang DGfS2007 Spoken on São Tomé island (Gulf of Guinea).

E_Schang

DGfS2007

Overv

iew

Lo

okin

g a

t th

e a

nap

ho

ric u

se

of

the

Sa

oto

me

nse

de

mo

nstr

ative

art

icle

Co

mp

ari

so

n w

ith

Vie

ira

& a

l. (

20

02

), a

stu

dy o

n

Po

rtu

gu

ese

an

d F

ren

ch

de

mo

nstr

ative

NP

s

Stu

dy o

f th

e d

em

on

str

ative

NP

s w

ith

syn

tactic,

se

ma

ntic a

nd

typ

e o

f u

se

s p

ara

me

ters

.

Page 3: Emmanuel Schang [emmanuel.schang@univ-orleans.fr ...demonstratives/...Saotomense: a Portuguese- based creole language E_Schang DGfS2007 Spoken on São Tomé island (Gulf of Guinea).

E_Schang

DGfS2007

Saoto

mense

: a P

ort

uguese-

based c

reole

lang

ua

ge

Sp

oke

n o

n S

ão

To

isla

nd

(G

ulf o

f

Gu

ine

a).

Po

rtu

gu

ese

is th

e

off

icia

l la

ng

ua

ge

of

the

De

mo

cra

tic

Re

pu

blic

of

o

To

an

d P

rín

cip

e

Page 4: Emmanuel Schang [emmanuel.schang@univ-orleans.fr ...demonstratives/...Saotomense: a Portuguese- based creole language E_Schang DGfS2007 Spoken on São Tomé island (Gulf of Guinea).

E_Schang

DGfS2007

Saoto

mense

: a P

ort

uguese-

based c

reole

lang

ua

ge

A l

ex

ico

nb

ase

d o

n

Po

rtu

gu

es

ea

nd

afr

ica

nla

ng

ua

ge

s

(ma

inly

Ed

o a

nd

Ba

ntu

wo

rds)

A g

ram

ma

r (t

ota

lly?

)

diffe

ren

t fr

om

Po

rtu

gu

ese

Page 5: Emmanuel Schang [emmanuel.schang@univ-orleans.fr ...demonstratives/...Saotomense: a Portuguese- based creole language E_Schang DGfS2007 Spoken on São Tomé island (Gulf of Guinea).

E_Schang

DGfS2007

Saoto

mense

: a P

ort

uguese-

based c

reole

lang

ua

ge

Ma

jor

gra

mm

atica

l fe

atu

res:

TM

A m

ark

ers

(p

rogre

ssiv

e,

ante

rior)

Do

ub

le n

egatio

n:

na

VP

… f

a

No g

end

er

No s

ubje

ct-

verb

agre

em

ent.

No a

gre

em

ent

in t

he

NP

Page 6: Emmanuel Schang [emmanuel.schang@univ-orleans.fr ...demonstratives/...Saotomense: a Portuguese- based creole language E_Schang DGfS2007 Spoken on São Tomé island (Gulf of Guinea).

E_Schang

DGfS2007

ST

art

icle

syste

m

Nu

mb

er:

[inen

mosu

] bi

/Pl./b

oys/c

om

e/

The b

oys c

am

e

[ua

mosu] bi

/a/b

oy/c

am

e/

A b

oy c

am

e

Page 7: Emmanuel Schang [emmanuel.schang@univ-orleans.fr ...demonstratives/...Saotomense: a Portuguese- based creole language E_Schang DGfS2007 Spoken on São Tomé island (Gulf of Guinea).

E_Schang

DGfS2007

ST

art

icle

syste

m

Bare

noun:

flo

lisa

gla

vi

/flo

we

r/b

e/b

ea

utifu

l/

1.

Th

e f

low

ers

are

be

au

tifu

l.

2.

Th

e f

low

er

is b

ea

utifu

l.

Page 8: Emmanuel Schang [emmanuel.schang@univ-orleans.fr ...demonstratives/...Saotomense: a Portuguese- based creole language E_Schang DGfS2007 Spoken on São Tomé island (Gulf of Guinea).

E_Schang

DGfS2007

ST

art

icle

syste

m

De

mo

nstr

ative

NP

s :

Occu

rs t

o t

he

imm

ed

iate

rig

ht

of

the N

:

[sete

dja

se]

/seven/d

ay/D

em

./

these s

eve

n d

ays

a k

a p

ega

[kum

ese]

/one/T

MA

/take/e

at/

De

m./

One t

akes this

food

Fro

m A

lexandre

& H

agem

eije

r

(fort

hcom

ing)

Page 9: Emmanuel Schang [emmanuel.schang@univ-orleans.fr ...demonstratives/...Saotomense: a Portuguese- based creole language E_Schang DGfS2007 Spoken on São Tomé island (Gulf of Guinea).

E_Schang

DGfS2007

Co

mp

arison b

etw

een

Port

ug

uese a

nd S

aoto

me

nse

esses/e

ssa

seste

s/e

sta

s

aqu

ele

s/a

que

las

Plu

ral

se

esse/e

ssa

este

/esta

aqu

ele

/aq

uela

Sin

gu

lar

Sao

tom

en

se

Po

rtu

gu

es

e

(masc/fem

)

Page 10: Emmanuel Schang [emmanuel.schang@univ-orleans.fr ...demonstratives/...Saotomense: a Portuguese- based creole language E_Schang DGfS2007 Spoken on São Tomé island (Gulf of Guinea).

E_Schang

DGfS2007

The a

naly

sis

The c

orp

us:

firs

t h

an

d d

ata

ga

the

red

in

oT

om

ésin

ce

19

95

; a

cce

ssib

le a

t:

htt

p://c

rdo

.vjf.c

nrs

.fr:

80

80

/exis

t/crd

o/

2 d

ialo

gu

es (

30

min

ute

s:

“mo

urn

ing

” a

nd

“Alb

ert

o’s

life

”).

Page 11: Emmanuel Schang [emmanuel.schang@univ-orleans.fr ...demonstratives/...Saotomense: a Portuguese- based creole language E_Schang DGfS2007 Spoken on São Tomé island (Gulf of Guinea).

E_Schang

DGfS2007

Types o

f uses

Evalu

ating the c

ore

fere

ntialand a

naphoric

chara

cte

r of dem

onstr

atives.

Cla

ssific

ation in 3

cate

gories

Dir

ec

t c

ore

fere

nc

e:

d c

ore

fers

with

a

pre

vio

us n

om

ina

l e

xp

ressio

n a

; d

an

d a

ha

ve

th

e s

am

e n

om

ina

l h

ea

d

Exa

mp

le:

a:

xe

sa

me

nku

mo

le…

d:

…a

ka

nte

lam

en

se

/if/be/m

oth

er/

who/d

ie/ /one/T

MA

/bury

/moth

er/

this

/

If the m

oth

er

die

d…

…one b

uries t

his

moth

er

Page 12: Emmanuel Schang [emmanuel.schang@univ-orleans.fr ...demonstratives/...Saotomense: a Portuguese- based creole language E_Schang DGfS2007 Spoken on São Tomé island (Gulf of Guinea).

E_Schang

DGfS2007

Types o

f uses

Ind

ire

ct

co

refe

ren

ce

: d

co

refe

rsw

ith

a

pre

vio

us n

om

ina

l e

xp

ressio

n a

; d

an

d a

ha

ve

diffe

ren

t n

om

ina

l h

ea

ds

a:

e te u

avu

ng

ud:

i to

kise

/there

/have

/a/litany/

/and/s

ong/t

his

/

There

isa litany

and

this

so

ng

Page 13: Emmanuel Schang [emmanuel.schang@univ-orleans.fr ...demonstratives/...Saotomense: a Portuguese- based creole language E_Schang DGfS2007 Spoken on São Tomé island (Gulf of Guinea).

E_Schang

DGfS2007

Types o

f uses

Oth

er

kin

d o

f a

na

ph

ora

: th

e a

nte

ce

de

nt

is

no

t a

no

min

al e

xp

ressio

n o

r th

e r

ela

tio

n

be

twe

en

de

mo

nstr

ative

an

d its

an

teced

en

t is

no

t a

co

refe

ren

ce

rela

tio

n

vid

a,

pro

fison d

i om

e,

mo k

u o

me k

om

esa;

ku k

e idaji

ku

om

e k

om

esa k

a f

e x

tluvis

u s

e i e

andji

om

e k

a t

am

e h

m,

kum

a o

me k

a f

e d

i bi tlaba a

ntê

poson d

jina n

ala

fô d

jina

na

la a

ntê

poson i e

, e, konta

non m

ina

xto

ria s

e(t

his

little s

tory

)

Page 14: Emmanuel Schang [emmanuel.schang@univ-orleans.fr ...demonstratives/...Saotomense: a Portuguese- based creole language E_Schang DGfS2007 Spoken on São Tomé island (Gulf of Guinea).

E_Schang

DGfS2007

The r

esults

Ca

teg

ory

nu

mb

er

of

occu

rren

ces

dir

ect

an

ap

ho

ra6

8

ind

ire

ct

an

ap

ho

ra9

oth

er

44

pro

port

ion o

f th

e c

ate

gories

57%

7%

36%

direct

anaphora

indirect

anaphora

oth

er

Page 15: Emmanuel Schang [emmanuel.schang@univ-orleans.fr ...demonstratives/...Saotomense: a Portuguese- based creole language E_Schang DGfS2007 Spoken on São Tomé island (Gulf of Guinea).

E_Schang

DGfS2007

The r

esults

The r

esults c

onfirm

what has b

een found

in V

ieira &

al. (

2002)

for

Port

uguese a

nd

Fre

nch:

If d

em

on

str

ative

s a

re lik

ely

to

id

en

tify

th

eir

refe

ren

t o

n t

he

ba

se

of

sa

lien

ce

we

exp

ecte

d

the

m t

o b

e n

ece

ssa

rily

re

late

d t

o p

revio

us

dis

co

urs

e,

an

d p

refe

ren

tia

lly c

ore

fere

ntia

l.

The S

Td

em

on

str

ati

ves a

re m

ain

ly

co

refe

ren

tto

pre

vio

us N

Ps.

Page 16: Emmanuel Schang [emmanuel.schang@univ-orleans.fr ...demonstratives/...Saotomense: a Portuguese- based creole language E_Schang DGfS2007 Spoken on São Tomé island (Gulf of Guinea).

E_Schang

DGfS2007

Synta

x

I a

na

lyzed

th

e s

ynta

ctic s

tructu

re o

f th

e

de

mo

nstr

ative

NP

s,

ob

se

rvin

g t

he

pre

se

nce

or

no

t o

f a

dje

ctiva

l, p

rep

ositio

na

l a

nd

re

lative

mo

difie

rs.

Th

e h

yp

oth

esis

is th

at

de

mo

nstr

ative

s,

be

ing

ma

inly

co

nte

xtu

al d

ep

en

de

nt

for

the

ir

inte

rpre

tatio

n,

are

re

aliz

ed

th

rou

gh

sim

ple

no

un

ph

rase

str

uctu

res.

Page 17: Emmanuel Schang [emmanuel.schang@univ-orleans.fr ...demonstratives/...Saotomense: a Portuguese- based creole language E_Schang DGfS2007 Spoken on São Tomé island (Gulf of Guinea).

E_Schang

DGfS2007

Synta

x

Mo

dif

ied

De

m.

NP

s(2

2 f

rom

12

1)

N+

se

+R

el :

peka

do s

e k

u s

a la

/pers

on/t

his

/who/b

e/t

here

/

This

pers

on (

who is)

here

nge s

e k

u m

ole

/pers

on/t

his

/who/d

ie/

This

pers

on w

ho d

ied

Page 18: Emmanuel Schang [emmanuel.schang@univ-orleans.fr ...demonstratives/...Saotomense: a Portuguese- based creole language E_Schang DGfS2007 Spoken on São Tomé island (Gulf of Guinea).

E_Schang

DGfS2007

Synta

x

N+

se+

PP

ni te

la s

e d

i m

e m

u

/in/c

ountr

y/this

/of/m

oth

er/

my/

?In

this

countr

y o

f m

y m

oth

er

xtluvis

u s

e d

i p

into

r

/work

/this

/of/(h

ouse)p

ain

ter/

This

work

of house p

ain

ter

Page 19: Emmanuel Schang [emmanuel.schang@univ-orleans.fr ...demonstratives/...Saotomense: a Portuguese- based creole language E_Schang DGfS2007 Spoken on São Tomé island (Gulf of Guinea).

E_Schang

DGfS2007

Synta

x

N+

se

+m

od

ifie

r

(ni) k

wa s

e t

inta

/(in

)/th

ing/t

his

/pa

int/

(In)

the p

ain

ting s

tuff

Nu

m+

N+

se

:

oto

dja

se (t

hese e

igh

t days)

inen d

osu m

anse s

e (

these t

wo p

ers

ons)

Page 20: Emmanuel Schang [emmanuel.schang@univ-orleans.fr ...demonstratives/...Saotomense: a Portuguese- based creole language E_Schang DGfS2007 Spoken on São Tomé island (Gulf of Guinea).

E_Schang

DGfS2007

Synta

x

Co

nclu

sio

n

Lik

e in

Po

rtu

gu

ese

, d

em

on

str

ative

s p

rese

nt

few

mo

dif

ied

str

uc

ture

s(<

20

%).

Th

is lo

w n

um

be

r o

f ca

se

s c

an

be

se

en

as a

co

nfirm

atio

n o

f th

e in

terp

reta

tio

na

l p

rop

ert

y o

f

de

mo

nstr

ative

s t

o r

efe

r to

som

eth

ing

alr

ea

dy

sa

lie

nt

thro

ug

h p

revio

us d

isco

urs

e.

Page 21: Emmanuel Schang [emmanuel.schang@univ-orleans.fr ...demonstratives/...Saotomense: a Portuguese- based creole language E_Schang DGfS2007 Spoken on São Tomé island (Gulf of Guinea).

E_Schang

DGfS2007

Sem

antics

Hyp

oth

es

is:

co

ncre

te d

em

on

str

ative

s h

ave

a

ten

de

ncy t

o h

ave

as a

nte

ce

de

nts

no

un

ph

rase

s

inste

ad

of

mo

re c

om

ple

x s

tru

ctu

res s

uch

as

se

nte

nce

s o

r p

ara

gra

ph

s.

Larg

ely

veri

fie

d

Co

rre

latio

n b

etw

ee

n c

on

cre

te a

nd

ab

str

act

de

mo

nstr

ative

an

d t

he

typ

e o

f u

se

:

Abstr

act

dem

onstr

atives o

ccur

only

in n

on

core

fere

ntialre

latio

ns (

“oth

er”

).

Ex:

kw

ase (

this

thin

g);

dolo

se (

this

pro

ble

m)

Page 22: Emmanuel Schang [emmanuel.schang@univ-orleans.fr ...demonstratives/...Saotomense: a Portuguese- based creole language E_Schang DGfS2007 Spoken on São Tomé island (Gulf of Guinea).

E_Schang

DGfS2007

Sem

antics

A d

iffe

rence w

ith V

ieira &

alii

(2002):

Th

e n

um

be

r o

f a

bstr

act d

em

on

str

ative

is lo

we

r

in S

ao

tom

en

se

th

an

in

Po

rtu

gu

ese

.

on

ly 2

3 f

rom

12

1 in

ST

ne

ar

80

% in

Po

rtu

gu

ese

(E

C jo

urn

al)

Page 23: Emmanuel Schang [emmanuel.schang@univ-orleans.fr ...demonstratives/...Saotomense: a Portuguese- based creole language E_Schang DGfS2007 Spoken on São Tomé island (Gulf of Guinea).

E_Schang

DGfS2007

Conclu

sio

n

In S

T a

s in P

ort

uguese:

De

mo

nstr

ative

s a

re m

ain

ly t

extu

ally

d

ep

en

de

nt

for

the

ir in

terp

reta

tio

n

Co

ncre

te d

em

on

str

ative

s h

ave

a t

en

de

ncy t

o

take

NP

s a

s a

nte

ce

de

nts

;

Diffe

rences w

ith P

ort

uguese

ab

str

act d

em

on

str

ative

s a

re n

ot

in a

co

refe

ren

ce

rela

tio

n (

typ

e o

f te

xts

?)

Lo

we

r n

um

be

r o

f a

bstr

act

de

mo

nstr

ative

s

(id

em

?)

Page 24: Emmanuel Schang [emmanuel.schang@univ-orleans.fr ...demonstratives/...Saotomense: a Portuguese- based creole language E_Schang DGfS2007 Spoken on São Tomé island (Gulf of Guinea).

E_Schang

DGfS2007

Conclu

sio

n

In c

reo

listics,

we

use

to

fo

cus o

n t

he

diffe

ren

ce

s

be

twe

en

a C

reo

le a

nd

its

lexifie

r-la

ng

ua

ge

. T

he

re

su

lts f

ou

nd

he

re a

re s

urp

risin

gly

sim

ilar

be

twe

en

Po

rtu

gu

ese

an

d S

ao

tom

en

se

, re

ga

rdle

ss o

f th

e im

po

rta

nt

diffe

ren

ce

s in

th

eir

g

ram

ma

tica

l syste

ms.

As ‘se

’ is

ety

mo

log

ica

lly lin

ke

d t

o t

he

Po

rtu

gu

ese

d

em

on

str

ative

, a

re t

he

sim

ilari

tie

s d

ue

to

‘u

niv

ers

al p

ara

me

ters

’ o

r to

th

e in

flu

en

ce

of

Po

rtu

gu

ese

?

A lo

t o

f qu

estio

ns…