Architects of Financial Prosperity Investment Management Consultants Emerging Brokerage Firms in the United States Presented to The Board of Trustees Los Angeles City Employees Retirement System October 6, 2005
Jan 16, 2016
Architects of Financial Prosperity
Investment Management Consultants
Emerging Brokerage Firms in the United States
Presented to The Board of Trustees
Los Angeles City Employees Retirement System
October 6, 2005
2
About the Study: Objectives
– Gain sound understanding of emerging brokerage landscape– Identify emerging brokerage firms– Support the LACERS Board in
determining constructive and informed policy decisions Moving ahead to provide access and opportunity to firms in the marketplace
Basis for the Study– Commissions as Trust Assets– There is ‘alpha’ at the point of trade
Backdrop– Fiduciary responsibility– The Concept of Best Execution
Content– In-depth review and analysis of the current landscape– Quality database
Detailed profiles of each firm– Review of other emerging brokerage programs
3
The Concept of Best Execution– Brokerage commissions are an asset of the Fund– Trustees can direct managers to employ certain brokerage firms
as long as trustees honor fiduciary responsibility and managers obtain best execution.
– Best execution: SEC: “a duty to seek the most favorable execution terms reasonably
available given the specific circumstances.” AIMR: “the trading process firms apply that seeks to maximize the
value of a client’s portfolio within the client’s stated investment objectives and constraints.”
– Why put a name to the concept? SEC: to ensure that brokers and managers trade in the client’s “best
interest”. Trading costs are not limited to commissions on trades. Effective trading = cost containment plus value-added.
4
Best Execution Components
– Explicit Commissions: price change associated with executing a trade:
– Cents per share - Mark up/Mark down– Basis points on total value
– Implicit Market Impact or Liquidity Charge: caused by a trade entering the
marketplace Timing: price change due to information leakage or momentum Opportunity Cost: cost of incomplete orders
Examples of Methodologies for Measurement– Volume weighted Average Price (VWAP)– Implementation Shortfall
Who measures?– Plexus - Quantitative Service Group– ITG - Others
5
Best Execution Why measure?
– Can affect performance– Can impair ability to generate “alpha”– Can be one of the largest erosions in investment value and a
barrier to superior performance A Pro-active Stance…
– Acknowledges and establishes best execution standards– Monitors transaction costs of both managers and brokerage
firms.
6
The Investment Manager’s Perspective
Stated Methods for Brokerage Selection
1. Traders and portfolio managers decide
2. Trading Oversight Committee
3. “Tiers” system– Tier I: Bulge bracket firms - Tier III: Client Mandated– Tier II: New firms, niche players
4. Separate category for sources of “street” research Getting on the “Approved” List: Some Stated Criteria
1. Quality & quantity of proprietary research
2. Ability to execute different types of trades, like directed or programmed.
3. Legal & compliance profile 4. Financial Strength
4. Financial strength 5. Credit Risk
6. Regulatory violations
7
In Search of Emerging Brokerage Firms Definition:
– “Emerging Brokerage Firm” is typically used to refer to relatively “new” companies with a newly developing revenue model.
– A firm is usually considered “emerging” based on its years of experience and its volume of business.
– Such firms are usually established by seasoned professionals with an interest in developing certain working teams and strategies, and with a knack for or interest in executing specific trading strategies.
– These firms seek to compete on equal terms with larger, traditional brokerage firms.
– The term “emerging” is also used in reference to firms whose owners are women, ethnic minorities and/or the physically challenged.
Definition employees:– 51% ownership African American, Hispanic, Asian, Woman and/or Disabled
Veterans – Members of the National Association of Securities Dealers
8
Preparing the list:– Conversations with LACERS– Conversations with LACERS investment managers (10)– Firms known to Consultiva– National Association of Securities Professionals– New America Alliance
Reaching out– In-depth, comprehensive RFI based on
– Brokerage criteria and trading qualifications provided by managers– Existing programs across the US– Covers:
1. Organization and Firm Overview 6. General Trading Capabilities2. Legal & compliance Issues 7. Equity Brokerage3. Company Personnel 8. Fixed Income Brokerage 4. Research Capabilities 9. Emerging Brokerage Experience5. Sales
– 57 firms contacted, 31 responded.– Subsequent tele-conferences with each.– Profiles developed for each.
9
The Universe
Observation Minimum Maximum Average
Years since Founding
3 34 12
Number of Employees
2 136 26
A Seasoned Group:1. At least 21 (72%) firms are more than 10 years old.2. All founders with over 15 years experience.3. Most have over 20 years experience
10
The Universe
Location Number
New York 8
California 7
Illinois 5
Texas 3
Washington DC 2
Other 4
11
Male Female Total African American 12 3 15 Hispanic 6 1 7 Asian 3 0 3 Disabled Veteran 2 0 2 Caucasian 0 2 2 Total 23 6 29
•52% African American•24% Hispanic•10% Asian•7% Disabled Veteran•7% Woman-owned Caucasian
The Universe
Type of Services # Firms Wealth Management 2 Institutional Brokerage 28 Retail Brokerage 8 Banking/Underwriting 16 Research 16 Asset Management 4
12
Stated Trading Capabilities– Most have average trading experience of over 15 years.– All have electronic trading capability.– Nearly 40% provide either equity or fixed income liquidity.– Nearly 30% have proprietary trading desks, either equity or fixed
income.– 75% have Transition Management capability, either through an
alliance, or through their correspondent.– 13 firms execute trades for soft-dollar credit.– Commission rates are $0.01-$0.06.
13
Existing Emerging and Minority Brokerage Initiatives– Gathered information on 46 initiatives across 16 states– A three level progression
Programs List of “Approved Broker/Dealers” 34 Goals or percentages of allocations of business 1 Predefined goals, milestones,
accountability and monitoring 11
– States with most comprehensive programs: Illinois and Ohio
14
Findings1. Policies without goals, tracking or monitoring are tantamount
to no policy at all.
2. Active communication between plan sponsors, broker/dealers and managers is essential.
3. Strategies should be developed to address the use of small firms versus larger ones.
4. Approved brokerage lists rest on will of managers.
5. “Caps” are counterproductive.
15
Recommendations Create a formal Emerging Brokerage Program with a clear
Statement of Purpose– “Support the development of new and innovative initiatives in
securities brokerage that will enlarge the landscape of providers, while providing increased opportunities for new firms.”
– “Support and promote competition among brokerage firms” A clear description of Eligibility Criteria
– the qualifications, registrations and certifications Specific Implementation Suggestions: Some Best Practices
– Develop and staff¹ a tracking or trade monitoring system;– Establish standards for scoring or grading, gradually awarding more
business to best performing firms;– Standards for volume of trades by asset class, to be executed by the
firms included in the program ;
¹ “Staff” refers to internal or external human resources
16
Statement and Process of Intent to Implement– Staffed mechanism to track:
Investment managers ongoing reporting on – volume of business executed with each emerging firm – verification of the manager’s attempts to trade
Actions and guidelines for investment managers who do not meet policy goals or failure to adequately document reporting requirements.
– Incorporate emerging brokerage policy and guidelines into the investment manager mandates
Support with Governance– Staff the initiative! Assign accountability for success.– Sponsor communication forums between brokers and managers– Engage managers in developing fair trading structures for
allocations, while mindful of managers regulatory circumstances
17
Protect the Integrity of your Intent– Ensure best execution capabilities: Conduct a study on trading
costs and best execution Implicit trading costs contribute more than commissions
– Market Impact– Timing– Opportunity costs
Next Steps– Review best practices for LACERS program options– Develop program recommendations for Board consideration.– Conduct a study on trading practices and best execution.– Follow up with firms to set up formal communication and
introduction with LACERS Managers.
18
Conclusions– A more level playing field today: technological advances
– Today, best execution is indifferent to firm size and ownership structure
– LACERS Database of Emerging Brokers encompasses firms with sound institutional capabilities to service the needs of investment managers.
– Challenges for the emerging firms: Concentrated skill: domestic equity Concentrated source of flow: Directed Brokerage Access to the business: Not being acknowledged by managers
19
Addendum
20
Consultiva Internacional, Inc.– Independent, employee-owned, investment management and
research firm– “Boutique”, specialized in financial architecture, serving the
small-middle market. – Based in San Juan, Puerto Rico and New York, New York– Over 20 years of experience with pension assets– Our job:
To determine appropriate asset allocation and investment strategy,
To advocate on behalf of clients with product designers, vendors and asset managers.
21
Whom we serve: Fund-specific methodologies in place, delivered
in a multi-cultural environment...
Pension Funds
Savings Plans
Corporate Reserves
Endowments & Foundations
Taft Hartley Plans
Insurance Companies
Individuals & Families
The only Hispanic investment consulting firm in the United States.
22
Client
Capital Markets Research
Consultiva Advisory Council
Structured Products
Asset Management
Investment Banking
Investment Management
Research
Investment Strategy Design
Portfolio Design
Consultiva’s Integrated
“Best of Breed” Business Model
Gap Analysis
Yield Enhancement
Strategies
Hedging Strategies
Fiduciary Education