Top Banner
Copyright © 2016 SCK•CEN Effects of Irradiation on the Tensile and Fracture Properties of 316L Stainless Steel R. Chaouadi, E. Stergar and S. Gavrilov SCK•CEN, Boeretang 200, 2400 Mol, Belgium [email protected] 1 International Light Water Reactors Material Reliability Conference Chicago, 1–4 August 2016
19

Effects of Irradiation on the Tensile and Fracture ......316L Irradiation hardening saturation at high dpa (roughly above 5 dpa) Most significant effects observed at low fluence levels,

Mar 25, 2020

Download

Documents

dariahiddleston
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: Effects of Irradiation on the Tensile and Fracture ......316L Irradiation hardening saturation at high dpa (roughly above 5 dpa) Most significant effects observed at low fluence levels,

Copyright © 2016

SCK•CEN

Effects of Irradiation on the Tensile and Fracture

Properties of 316L Stainless Steel

R. Chaouadi, E. Stergar and S. Gavrilov

SCK•CEN, Boeretang 200, 2400 Mol, Belgium

[email protected]

1

International Light Water Reactors Material Reliability Conference

Chicago, 1–4 August 2016

Page 2: Effects of Irradiation on the Tensile and Fracture ......316L Irradiation hardening saturation at high dpa (roughly above 5 dpa) Most significant effects observed at low fluence levels,

Copyright © 2016

SCK•CEN

Objectives and Motivation

316L Irradiation hardening saturation at high dpa (roughly

above 5 dpa)

Most significant effects observed at low fluence levels,

typically between 0 and 1 dpa

Focus on the 0 – 1 dpa region

Tensile properties evolution

Crack resistance behavior

Correlation between tensile properties and crack resistance

2

Page 3: Effects of Irradiation on the Tensile and Fracture ......316L Irradiation hardening saturation at high dpa (roughly above 5 dpa) Most significant effects observed at low fluence levels,

Copyright © 2016

SCK•CEN

Irradiation Hardening of 316L

3

More significant effects observed in the low dpa range

In particular 0 – 1 dpa RADAMO-12ext Irradiation Program

DATA from

Robertson et al., ASTM

STP 1325 (1999) 671 –

688.

ITER MPH (Material

Properties Handbook)

Elen et al., JNM 191-194

(1992) 766–770.

Maloy et al., OECD/NEA

(2002) 669–680.

Page 4: Effects of Irradiation on the Tensile and Fracture ......316L Irradiation hardening saturation at high dpa (roughly above 5 dpa) Most significant effects observed at low fluence levels,

Copyright © 2016

SCK•CEN

Irradiation ProgramRADAMO–12ext

Irradiation

43=12 tensile specimens: L=24 mm , 2.4 mm (A)

3 microstructural bars: 32 mm long , 8.5 mm (A)

6 PCCv (PreCracked Charpy specimens) (E)

dosimeters : (A) and (E)4

PCCv specimens

tensile specimensmicrostructural bar

Page 5: Effects of Irradiation on the Tensile and Fracture ......316L Irradiation hardening saturation at high dpa (roughly above 5 dpa) Most significant effects observed at low fluence levels,

Copyright © 2016

SCK•CEN

Dosimetry and Test Matrix

5

Tensile specimens corresponding to

5 different dpa levels : 0.15 – 0.83 dpa

PCCv specimens corresponding to 5

different dpa levels : 0.18 – 0.79 dpa

3 tensile specimens/position

Tensile tests at 25°C and 290°C

Crack resistance tests at 25°C and 290°C

Page 6: Effects of Irradiation on the Tensile and Fracture ......316L Irradiation hardening saturation at high dpa (roughly above 5 dpa) Most significant effects observed at low fluence levels,

Copyright © 2016

SCK•CEN

Tensile Test Results

6

Page 7: Effects of Irradiation on the Tensile and Fracture ......316L Irradiation hardening saturation at high dpa (roughly above 5 dpa) Most significant effects observed at low fluence levels,

Copyright © 2016

SCK•CEN

Significant effect on the tensile curve

7

Tensile Test Results

yield strength

From the 3 available

specimens

One test at 25°C

One test at 290°C

One spare specimen

Page 8: Effects of Irradiation on the Tensile and Fracture ......316L Irradiation hardening saturation at high dpa (roughly above 5 dpa) Most significant effects observed at low fluence levels,

Copyright © 2016

SCK•CEN8

Tensile Test Results

Page 9: Effects of Irradiation on the Tensile and Fracture ......316L Irradiation hardening saturation at high dpa (roughly above 5 dpa) Most significant effects observed at low fluence levels,

Copyright © 2016

SCK•CEN

Tensile Test ResultsStrength

Significant yield strength increase in the 0–1 dpa range

9

Page 10: Effects of Irradiation on the Tensile and Fracture ......316L Irradiation hardening saturation at high dpa (roughly above 5 dpa) Most significant effects observed at low fluence levels,

Copyright © 2016

SCK•CEN

Tensile Test ResultsStrength

10

Significant Yield strength increase in the 0–1 dpa range (damage rate)

onset of plastic flow localization

Page 11: Effects of Irradiation on the Tensile and Fracture ......316L Irradiation hardening saturation at high dpa (roughly above 5 dpa) Most significant effects observed at low fluence levels,

Copyright © 2016

SCK•CEN

Superposition of the irradiated flow curves on the unirradiated one by shifting

in the true strain direction (sy irrad (0.2%)= sy unirrad (0.2%+Deoffset)

Irradiation effect similar to strain hardening

11

Tensile Test Results @ 25°C

yield strength (sy)

Deoffset

Deoffset

Page 12: Effects of Irradiation on the Tensile and Fracture ......316L Irradiation hardening saturation at high dpa (roughly above 5 dpa) Most significant effects observed at low fluence levels,

Copyright © 2016

SCK•CEN

Crack Resistance Characterization

12

Page 13: Effects of Irradiation on the Tensile and Fracture ......316L Irradiation hardening saturation at high dpa (roughly above 5 dpa) Most significant effects observed at low fluence levels,

Copyright © 2016

SCK•CEN

Crack Resistance Test Results

13

Four different techniques are used

Unloading compliance (UC)

Potential drop (PD)

Normalization data reduction (NDR)

Energy normalization

Test temperatures

25°C

290°C

ASTM E1820

used at SCK•CEN

Page 14: Effects of Irradiation on the Tensile and Fracture ......316L Irradiation hardening saturation at high dpa (roughly above 5 dpa) Most significant effects observed at low fluence levels,

Copyright © 2016

SCK•CEN14

Tensile Test Results

Strictly speaking, test results are not valid according to E1820 size

requirement (inadequate specimen size)

Not so critical as we under-estimate actual resistance curve

Page 15: Effects of Irradiation on the Tensile and Fracture ......316L Irradiation hardening saturation at high dpa (roughly above 5 dpa) Most significant effects observed at low fluence levels,

Copyright © 2016

SCK•CEN

Crack Resistance Test Results

15

Based on energy

normalization

technique

Page 16: Effects of Irradiation on the Tensile and Fracture ......316L Irradiation hardening saturation at high dpa (roughly above 5 dpa) Most significant effects observed at low fluence levels,

Copyright © 2016

SCK•CEN

Crack Resistance Test Results

16

No significant effect on

initiation toughness (JQ and

J0.2 mm) and tearing resistance (TM)

J0.2 mm

JQ

TM

Page 17: Effects of Irradiation on the Tensile and Fracture ......316L Irradiation hardening saturation at high dpa (roughly above 5 dpa) Most significant effects observed at low fluence levels,

Copyright © 2016

SCK•CEN17

SEM Examination of the Fracture Surfaces

No significant effect of irradiation on dimple size suggesting a constant critical

void growth rate

TSW4-19 (0.18 dpa) TSW4-18 (0.68 dpa) TSW4-17 (0.79 dpa) DCT6-3-2-13 (2.5 dpa)

Page 18: Effects of Irradiation on the Tensile and Fracture ......316L Irradiation hardening saturation at high dpa (roughly above 5 dpa) Most significant effects observed at low fluence levels,

Copyright © 2016

SCK•CEN

Conclusions

The damage rate increases significantly in the low neutron dose

range (<1 dpa)

Despite the significant changes of the tensile properties

(strength and ductility) in the low dpa range, fracture behavior

remains almost unaffected

Fracture surface examination by SEM show very similar dimple

structure

Ductility loss is compensated by strength increase allowing an

unvariable critical void growth rate

18

Page 19: Effects of Irradiation on the Tensile and Fracture ......316L Irradiation hardening saturation at high dpa (roughly above 5 dpa) Most significant effects observed at low fluence levels,

Copyright © 2016

SCK•CEN

Closing Remarks

Additional tests on specimens irradiated at 300°C to 2.5 dpa (in

progress)

Microstructural examination

Crack resistance tests on specimens irradiated to 5 – 30 dpa

(LEXUR-II) longer term

19