EECERA Prague 2007 1 Improving Language and Literacy Opportunities in an Early Years Setting Annette J. Kearns, IPPA Annette J. Kearns, IPPA Ireland Ireland [email protected] [email protected]
Dec 15, 2015
EECERA Prague 2007
1
Improving Language and
Literacy Opportunities in an Early Years Setting
Annette J. Kearns, IPPA Annette J. Kearns, IPPA IrelandIreland
[email protected]@ippa.ie
2 EECERA Prague 2007
What impact do practical What impact do practical
strategies have on the provision strategies have on the provision
of language and literacy of language and literacy
opportunities in an early years opportunities in an early years
setting?setting?
Research Research Question…Question…
3 EECERA Prague 2007
• What prompted this study?What prompted this study?
• Who was involved?Who was involved?
BackgroundBackground
4 EECERA Prague 2007
• Illiteracy levels in this geographical area are higher Illiteracy levels in this geographical area are higher
than the national average (Eivers et al 2004)than the national average (Eivers et al 2004)
• One third of all households in this area are headed by One third of all households in this area are headed by
a lone parent – over twice the national average a lone parent – over twice the national average
(Dartington Social Research Unit 2004)(Dartington Social Research Unit 2004)
• 29% of the children in this area live with one or both 29% of the children in this area live with one or both
parents who have no educational qualificationsparents who have no educational qualifications
ContextContext
5 EECERA Prague 2007
Vygotsky (1978) Vygotsky (1978)
Bruner (1986)Bruner (1986)
Strickland (1989)Strickland (1989)
Whitehead (1999)Whitehead (1999)
Literature Literature ReviewReview
6 EECERA Prague 2007
Vygotsky Vygotsky (1978)(1978)
… … believed that the child begins to believed that the child begins to
perceive the world not only through perceive the world not only through
their eyes but also through their their eyes but also through their
speechspeech
7 EECERA Prague 2007
Bruner Bruner (1986)(1986)
… … considered storytelling as being considered storytelling as being
important to enable us in important to enable us in
‘understanding self and bringing ‘understanding self and bringing
cognition, emotion and action together cognition, emotion and action together
to give experience ‘cultural relevance’ to give experience ‘cultural relevance’
8 EECERA Prague 2007
… … believed that learning to read and believed that learning to read and
write requires active participation in write requires active participation in
activities that have meaning in the activities that have meaning in the
child’s daily life and are interrelated child’s daily life and are interrelated
processes that develop in concert processes that develop in concert
with oral languagewith oral language
Strickland Strickland (1989)(1989)
9 EECERA Prague 2007
Whitehead Whitehead (1999)(1999)
… … considers that ‘children need considers that ‘children need
adults to be literacy facilitators adults to be literacy facilitators
who provide the time, opportunities who provide the time, opportunities
and materials for literacy to and materials for literacy to
happen and for children and print happen and for children and print
of all kinds to get together’ of all kinds to get together’
10 EECERA Prague 2007
Research Research MethodologyMethodology
Action ResearchAction Research
IdeaIdea reconnaissance plan reconnaissance plan
Action steps 1 2 and 3 Action steps 1 2 and 3
monitor implementationmonitor implementation
revise planrevise plan reconnaissance reconnaissance
STAGE 1 Completed STAGE 1 Completed
11 EECERA Prague 2007
SampleSample
PROFILE OF THE GROUPPROFILE OF THE GROUP 12 practitioners from the one childcare service12 practitioners from the one childcare service All are aged between 19 and 48All are aged between 19 and 48 5 completed primary; 7 started but only 4 completed 5 completed primary; 7 started but only 4 completed
secondary; 6 of the total group have completed a basic secondary; 6 of the total group have completed a basic
childcare qualificationchildcare qualification Poor confidence levels with regard to own literacy which is Poor confidence levels with regard to own literacy which is
at varying levelsat varying levels All from local and surrounding areasAll from local and surrounding areas
Working with children aged between 3 months and 10 yearsWorking with children aged between 3 months and 10 years
12 EECERA Prague 2007
Data Collection Data Collection MethodsMethods
Participant ObservationParticipant Observation
Group members Group members
Throughout programmeThroughout programme
QualitativeQualitative
InterviewInterview
Centre managerCentre manager
End of programmeEnd of programme
Focus GroupFocus Group
Group members Group members
End of programmeEnd of programme
13 EECERA Prague 2007
Programme Programme informationinformation
IPPA/PLN is a 10 hour programme, delivered IPPA/PLN is a 10 hour programme, delivered
over 3 or 4 sessions, and it explores the role over 3 or 4 sessions, and it explores the role
that language and literacy plays in early years that language and literacy plays in early years
services.services.
New strategies are discussed and practitioners New strategies are discussed and practitioners
have an opportunity to engage in the process.have an opportunity to engage in the process.
It supports children’s language development It supports children’s language development
and emergent literacy practices.and emergent literacy practices.
14 EECERA Prague 2007
Strategies being Strategies being used…used…
Before During Before During
and After and After
(BDA) (BDA)
storytelling storytelling
technique technique
16 EECERA Prague 2007
StorytellinStorytellin
g g
and and
Story Story
actingacting
(Vivian Gussin (Vivian Gussin
Paley)Paley)
Strategies being Strategies being used…used…
17 EECERA Prague 2007
The starting The starting point…point…
What does language What does language
mean?mean? ‘‘being able to talk’being able to talk’ ‘‘being able to be being able to be
understood’understood’ ‘‘knowing what to say knowing what to say
and how to say it’and how to say it’
What does literacy What does literacy
mean?mean?
‘‘books and books and
reading’reading’
‘‘being able to read’being able to read’
18 EECERA Prague 2007
‘‘In the pre-school, before they go to school you In the pre-school, before they go to school you should be trying to teach them their letters’should be trying to teach them their letters’
‘‘You could teach them the alphabet when they You could teach them the alphabet when they are about three but reading is for when they are about three but reading is for when they are in school’are in school’
‘‘When the children show an interest in playschool When the children show an interest in playschool you could teach them their letters. Some of you could teach them their letters. Some of them want to know the letters in their names’them want to know the letters in their names’
What is the adult’s What is the adult’s role?role?
19 EECERA Prague 2007
What is current What is current provision like?provision like?
The baby roomThe baby room – –
‘‘we’re with the babies so you can’t really do anything’we’re with the babies so you can’t really do anything’
The toddlers roomThe toddlers room – –
‘‘we try and read them stories but they don’t really listen’we try and read them stories but they don’t really listen’
The pre-school roomThe pre-school room – –
‘‘we have a story time every day and the children have to we have a story time every day and the children have to
sit and listen. They also have to read books for time-out sit and listen. They also have to read books for time-out
when they get too rowdy’when they get too rowdy’
The after-school roomThe after-school room – –
‘‘our children are a mix of ages so we don’t really do any our children are a mix of ages so we don’t really do any
stories but the older ones sometimes look at the books’stories but the older ones sometimes look at the books’
20 EECERA Prague 2007
Programme of Programme of implementationimplementation
Over a period of 6 weeks, the Over a period of 6 weeks, the programme was delivered. programme was delivered.
In each session the practitioners In each session the practitioners engaged in 2 new strategies . engaged in 2 new strategies .
Each practitioner was then expected to Each practitioner was then expected to bring these back to the children they bring these back to the children they work with and try them out in the work with and try them out in the setting.setting.
21 EECERA Prague 2007
‘‘The thing I took from it was to take more time selecting The thing I took from it was to take more time selecting
a story for story time, being more aware of picking a a story for story time, being more aware of picking a
story that they can join in – and it did work!’story that they can join in – and it did work!’
‘‘We made books of photos and the kids told the story of We made books of photos and the kids told the story of
what was happening. ‘Cos its Christmas we put in what was happening. ‘Cos its Christmas we put in
Christmas pictures and then we talked all about the Christmas pictures and then we talked all about the
different things’.different things’.
Focus group Focus group findings…findings…
22 EECERA Prague 2007
‘‘The ones that listened to a story went off and did more, did The ones that listened to a story went off and did more, did
a picture about it’.a picture about it’.
‘‘Storytime wasn’t working out so we changed the seating Storytime wasn’t working out so we changed the seating
and were more careful with the choice of book. We got and were more careful with the choice of book. We got
them to join in and they stayed which was unusual’them to join in and they stayed which was unusual’
‘‘I read the story and then they read it back to me – I read the story and then they read it back to me –
sometimes it does sound like the story and sometimes it’s sometimes it does sound like the story and sometimes it’s
their own little story. But, yea, its really good to hear their own little story. But, yea, its really good to hear
them saying it’them saying it’
Focus group Focus group findings…findings…
23 EECERA Prague 2007
Is there a difference in practice?Is there a difference in practice? Implementing the new strategies and sharing ideas Implementing the new strategies and sharing ideas
from one room to another. from one room to another.
Increased level of engagement in reading activities Increased level of engagement in reading activities and extending these activities through the BDAand extending these activities through the BDA
Increasing their use of props to aid storytellingIncreasing their use of props to aid storytelling
How they are taking time to figure out what might How they are taking time to figure out what might make something new work.make something new work.
A noted increased level of dialogue with the A noted increased level of dialogue with the children.children.
Interview Interview findings…findings…
24 EECERA Prague 2007
‘‘there is a shift to a positive attitude towards there is a shift to a positive attitude towards
language and literacy. It is no longer regarded language and literacy. It is no longer regarded
as an activity they have to get done and move as an activity they have to get done and move
on, it has become an enjoyable part of the day, on, it has become an enjoyable part of the day,
in fact a major part of the day’.in fact a major part of the day’.
‘‘they are all delighted with all that (the children they are all delighted with all that (the children
wanting lots of books read to them) and they wanting lots of books read to them) and they
are seeing the benefits of doing it all’are seeing the benefits of doing it all’
Interview Interview findings…findings…
25 EECERA Prague 2007
Observation Observation findings…findings…
The Baby RoomThe Baby Room – – are now reading stories to the are now reading stories to the babies and playing talking and singing games babies and playing talking and singing games
The Toddler RoomThe Toddler Room - made the book area attractive - made the book area attractive to the children and placed an adult in the area at all to the children and placed an adult in the area at all times. Children began to look for stories to be read times. Children began to look for stories to be read to them and began to select their own preferences. to them and began to select their own preferences. Adults talk more to the children now.Adults talk more to the children now.
The Pre-school Room The Pre-school Room – Both children and adults – Both children and adults enjoy the BDA. Stories are being extended and enjoy the BDA. Stories are being extended and turned into table-top games and creative activities.turned into table-top games and creative activities.
26 EECERA Prague 2007
Observation Observation findings…findings…
The Pre-school Room The Pre-school Room – Both children and adults – Both children and adults
enjoy the BDA. Stories are being extended and turned enjoy the BDA. Stories are being extended and turned
into table-top games and creative activities. The into table-top games and creative activities. The
children have begun to read books to each other and children have begun to read books to each other and
to the adults ‘they weren’t really reading you know, to the adults ‘they weren’t really reading you know,
they were reading the pictures!’.they were reading the pictures!’.
The Afterschool Room The Afterschool Room - They began to read to each - They began to read to each
other following encouragement from the adults. other following encouragement from the adults.
Adults provided more creative activities and became Adults provided more creative activities and became
more involved with the children, engaging in dialogue.more involved with the children, engaging in dialogue.
27 EECERA Prague 2007
What impact do practical strategies have What impact do practical strategies have
on the provision of on the provision of
language and literacy opportunities language and literacy opportunities
in an early years setting?in an early years setting?
Research Research Question…Question…
28 EECERA Prague 2007
With the Practitioners…With the Practitioners…
A definite increase in confidence A definite increase in confidence
with regard to their own literacywith regard to their own literacy
A willingness to share ideas that A willingness to share ideas that
work within the settingwork within the setting
A willingness to take risks trying out A willingness to take risks trying out
new strategiesnew strategies
Conclusions…
29 EECERA Prague 2007
With the children…With the children…An increased interest in books and An increased interest in books and reading from the childrenreading from the children
An increase in the children’s self An increase in the children’s self esteem with regard to books and esteem with regard to books and bookmakingbookmaking
An increase in dialogue between the An increase in dialogue between the practitioners and the childrenpractitioners and the children
Conclusions…
30 EECERA Prague 2007
Implications for Implications for policy and practicepolicy and practice
More training needed to help continue the More training needed to help continue the
shift towards positive engagementshift towards positive engagement More resources needed to help provide this More resources needed to help provide this
training to services in disadvantaged areas.training to services in disadvantaged areas. More research needed into the language More research needed into the language
and literacy needs within every communityand literacy needs within every community