7/26/2019 Education and Human Rebellion
1/34
Human Rebellion and Education
Michael Goheen
Trinity Western University
Langley, B.C., Canada
7/26/2019 Education and Human Rebellion
2/34
Danger of minimizing sin
Believers often have an inadequate awareness of
their adversary or archene!y who is "near #y$ and"crouching at the door$ %Genesis &'().*
+ur tendency to !ini!ie the gravity, sco-e, and
-ower of sin reducing it to individual diso#edience is!uch !ore than an intellectually deficiency.* t -utsus in urgent -eril* #ecause sin is a very vicious and!ortal ene!y, an irasci#le and -ersistent -ower,which !ust certainly #e knownin order to #e
overcome.* %Ber/ouwer)
7/26/2019 Education and Human Rebellion
3/34
Fall into sin
Tree of /nowledge of good and evil %0.12
1() "3r#itrary$ co!!and4why5
6atanic te!-tation7 8ou#t a#out divine source or fairness
7 Un#elief
7 !aging life in diso#edience to God$s word
7 Willful diso#edience
7/26/2019 Education and Human Rebellion
4/34
Forfeiting the glory of creaturehood
Man has ta/e leave of the relation of de-endence. 9e
has refused to o#ey and has willed to !a/e hi!self
inde-endent. :o longer is o#edience the guiding
-rinci-le of his life, #ut his autono!ous /nowledge and
will. There#y he ceases, in effect, to understand hi!self
as a creature. %;on
7/26/2019 Education and Human Rebellion
5/34
Characterising Sin: Against God
3gainst you, you only, have sinned and
done what is evil in your sight* %=sal! 21'&
T:;).
7/26/2019 Education and Human Rebellion
6/34
Characterising Sin: Idolatry
They e>changed the truth of God for a lie, andworshi-ed and served created things ratherthan the Creator4who is forever -raised*%
7/26/2019 Education and Human Rebellion
7/34
God or an idol
9u!an #eings are inherently religious
creatures. We cannot live without a god,even if it is one of our own !a/ing. We need
a center, an ulti!ate focus, a -oint of
orientation for our lives. We have in fact two
alternatives. @ither we serve the Lord ando#ey his will, or we -ractice idolatry and
diso#edience %Walsh and Middleton).
7/26/2019 Education and Human Rebellion
8/34
Sin as Idolatry
f hu!an #eings are inesca-a#ly
religious, driven always to see/ ano#?ect of worshi-, then the fall cannot
#e characterised solely as revolt
against the rightful Lord' t !ust #edescri#ed further as e>change of
religious allegiance %Cha-lin).
7/26/2019 Education and Human Rebellion
9/34
Idolatry as eitome of sin
dolatry is essentially a declaration of
autono!y and inde-endence fro! ourCreator, our re?ection of his rightful /ingshi-. .
. . dolatry is -ortrayed in the Bi#le not as
!erely one sin a!ong !any, #ut as the
e-ito!e of sin. t is the central act ofdiso#edience which disru-ts Aahweh$s rule
over hu!an life %Walsh and Middleton).
7/26/2019 Education and Human Rebellion
10/34
Sin as idolatry
FAITH CREATURE
Humankind
. . . and you shall earn the penalty for your sinfulidolatry (Exzekiel !."#$.
Idol %&'
Reliious )ature of Human *eins
7/26/2019 Education and Human Rebellion
11/34
Relational dimension of sin
:ot transgression of i!-ersonal standard
Marital analogy' 3gainst e>clusive loyalty of!arriage relationshi- %e.g.,ere!iah ,
9osea)
=aternal analogy' 3gainst /indness,
generosity, goodness of Dather
7/26/2019 Education and Human Rebellion
12/34
Characterising sin: Against creation
3gainst hu!an life, against shalo!, againsthealth, against -ros-erity, against wholeness,against hu!an flourishing.
3! the one they are -rovo/ing5 declares theLord. 3re they not rather har!ing the!selves, totheir own sha!e5* %ere!iah ('1E).
. . . diso#edience goes against the very grain ofcreation itself. 6in is re#ellion against #oth thestructure and the 6tructurer of reality. 6uchre#ellion is inevita#ly selfdefeating and selfdestroying.*
7/26/2019 Education and Human Rebellion
13/34
!ages of sin is death
6ee, set #efore you today life and -ros-erity, death
and destruction. Dor co!!and you today to love the
Lord your God, to wal/ in his ways, and to /ee- his
co!!ands, decrees and lawsF then you will live and
increase, and the Lord your God will #less you in the
land you are entering to -ossess. But if you heart turns
away and you are not o#edient, and if you are drawnaway to #ow down to other gods and worshi- the!,
declare to you this day that you will certainly #e
destroyed. . . . have set #efore you life and death,
#lessings and curses %8euterono!y '120).
7/26/2019 Education and Human Rebellion
14/34
Sin as co"enant rebellion
%&'+ord
' e a t h ,d e s t r u - t i o n ,- u r s e
. i f e ,p r o s p e r i t y ,/ l e s s i n (
7/26/2019 Education and Human Rebellion
15/34
Sin as a ersonal o#er
7/26/2019 Education and Human Rebellion
16/34
Characterising the o#er of sin
7/26/2019 Education and Human Rebellion
17/34
$arasitic %uality of sin
3 -arasite is an organis! that lives off the life #loodof anotherF it is an uninvited guest that /ee-s
ta--ing its host for sustenance.* %=lantinga) Goodness is, so to s-ea/, itself' #adness is only
s-oiled goodness. 3nd there !ust #e so!ethinggood first #efore it can #e s-oiled.*%C6 Lewis)
6in is nothing and can do nothing a-art fro! thecreatures and the -owers which God has createdFyet it organies all these in o-en re#ellion againsthi!.* %Bavinc/)
7/26/2019 Education and Human Rebellion
18/34
Structure&direction
Good creationalstructure
misdirectedby sin
redirected byredemption
7/26/2019 Education and Human Rebellion
19/34
Scoe of Sin
=ersonal lives
Co!!unal e>-ression:onhu!an creation %
7/26/2019 Education and Human Rebellion
20/34
Culture0 Common +ay of life rooted in a
shared -ore reli(ious /eliefs in form of story.
reli(ious-ore
1T&R2
7/26/2019 Education and Human Rebellion
21/34
Heart of culture
7/26/2019 Education and Human Rebellion
22/34
'hree biblical rules
The first rule is that every !an is serving
god%s) in his life. 6econdly, every !an is transfor!ed into an
i!age of his god.*
Dinally, !an/ind creates and for!s a
structure of society in its own i!age.*
7/26/2019 Education and Human Rebellion
23/34
Creating society in deformed image
n the develo-!ent of hu!an civiliation,
!an for!s, creates and changes thestructure of his society, and in doing so he
-ortrays in his wor/ the intention of his own
heart. 9e gives to the structure of that
society something of his own image andlikeness. n it he #etrays so!ething of his
own lifestyle, of his own god%Goudwaard).
7/26/2019 Education and Human Rebellion
24/34
Goudz#aard on Ideologies
deologies' 9u!anly constructed stories that fillthe s-iritual vacuu! after the @nlighten!ent.
Ma/e an end for hu!an society a#solute %e.g.,!aterial wealth and -ros-erity)
Certain social -owers or forces identified as
!eans #y which the goal can #e achieved %e.g.,freedo! of !ar/et)F saviours* or -owers which-eo-le -ut their faith in.*
=lace ourselves under -ower of these saviours
Transfor! whole of society
7/26/2019 Education and Human Rebellion
25/34
Ideology and Education
9ow has this ideology affected education5
Docus on :eil =ost!an$s End of Education
7/26/2019 Education and Human Rebellion
26/34
Failure of the gods
. . . the crisis in narrative the decline of
oncesturdy gods.* %02). . . #oth students and teachers lac/ a
narrative to -rovide -rofound !eaning to
their lessons.* %21)
"god$' . . . a co!-rehensive narrative a#outwhat the world is li/e, how things got to #e
the way they are, and what lies ahead.* %I)
7/26/2019 Education and Human Rebellion
27/34
!hat god #ill your school ser"e(
The truth is that school cannot e>ist withoutsomereason for its #eing, and in fact there
are several gods our students are -resently
as/ed to serve.* %0()
7/26/2019 Education and Human Rebellion
28/34
God of Economic )tility
f you -ay attention in school, and do your
ho!ewor/, and score well on tests, and#ehave yourself, you will #e rewarded with a
well-aying ?o# when you are done. ts
driving idea is that the -ur-ose of schooling
is to -re-are children for co!-etent entryinto the econo!ic life of a co!!unity.* %0()
7/26/2019 Education and Human Rebellion
29/34
'ransformed into the image of our god
The narrativeJgod of econo!ic utility . . . tells
us that we are first and fore!ost econo!iccreatures, and that our sense of worth and
-ur-ose is to #e found in our ca-acity to
secure !aterial #enefits.* %0H)
7/26/2019 Education and Human Rebellion
30/34
God of Consumershi
+ne !ay wonder, then, why this godKecono!ic utility has so !uch strength, whythe -re-aration for !a/ing a living, which iswell-served by any decent education, should #eassigned a !eta-hysical -osition of such highstation. #elieve the reason is that the god of
@cono!ic Utility is cou-led with another god,one with a s!iling face and one that -rovidesan answer to the question, f get a good ?o#,then what5* %)
7/26/2019 Education and Human Rebellion
31/34
God of Consumershi
8evotion to the god of Consu!ershi- serves
easily as the !eta-hysical #asis of schooling
#ecause it is urged on the young early in
their lives, long #efore they get to school4in
fact, as soon as they are e>-osed to the
-owerful teachings of the advertisingindustry.* %)
7/26/2019 Education and Human Rebellion
32/34
God of 'echnology
. . . That -eo-le #elieve technology wor/s, thatthey rely on it, that it !a/es -ro!ises, that theyare #ereft when denied access to it, that they aredelighted when they are in its -resence, that for!ost -eo-le it wor/s in !ysterious ways, thatthey conde!n -eo-le who s-ea/ against it, that
they stand in awe of it, and that, in the #ornagain !ode, they will alter their lifestyles, theirschedules, their ha#its, and their relationshi-s toacco!!odate it. f this #e not a for! of religious
#elief, what is5* %H)
7/26/2019 Education and Human Rebellion
33/34
'hese gods #ill fail too*
. . . the narratives that underlie our -resentconce-tion of school do not serve us welland !ay lead to the end of -u#licschooling . . .* %I1).
My intention here is to offer an answer in thefor! of five narratives that, singly and inconcert, contain sufficient resonance and-ower to #e ta/en seriously as reasons forschooling.* %I1)
7/26/2019 Education and Human Rebellion
34/34
Another story(
f the tale of ca-italistic -rogress is
#eginning to fray at the edges then -erha-s
this is an evangelistically o--ortune ti!e for
Christian education to offer another story
one that re-laces the selfsalvation of
econo!ic -rogress with the tale of a co!ingingdo! of rede!-tion %Brian Walsh).