Ecosystem-based fisheries management: an introduction Villy Christensen and Daniel Pauly Fisheries Centre University of British Columbia Vancouver, Canada SUMBER: innri.unuftp.is/pauly/Iceland%202%20Dec%2016%2002.ppt
Dec 28, 2015
Ecosystem-based fisheries management: an introduction
Ecosystem-based fisheries management: an introduction
Villy Christensen and Daniel PaulyFisheries Centre
University of British ColumbiaVancouver, Canada
Villy Christensen and Daniel PaulyFisheries Centre
University of British ColumbiaVancouver, Canada
SUMBER: innri.unuftp.is/pauly/Iceland%202%20Dec%2016%2002.ppt
Under the UN Convention on the Law of the Sea, nations have accepted:
Under the UN Convention on the Law of the Sea, nations have accepted:
• A mutual obligation to consider the impact of their policies on marine ecosystems;
• to take all appropriate actions to preserve the marine environment; and
• to manage ecosystem resources based on the interdependence of the system components...
“in accordance with their capabilities.”
• A mutual obligation to consider the impact of their policies on marine ecosystems;
• to take all appropriate actions to preserve the marine environment; and
• to manage ecosystem resources based on the interdependence of the system components...
“in accordance with their capabilities.”
SUMBER: innri.unuftp.is/pauly/Iceland%202%20Dec%2016%2002.ppt
We cannot and should not replace the top predators
We cannot and should not replace the top predators
• Many examples exist of ecosystem disasters due to fishing down of predators;
• To maintain or improve catches we must maintain functioning ecosystems;
• We already assert major influence over the marine environment:
• Many examples exist of ecosystem disasters due to fishing down of predators;
• To maintain or improve catches we must maintain functioning ecosystems;
• We already assert major influence over the marine environment:
SUMBER: innri.unuftp.is/pauly/Iceland%202%20Dec%2016%2002.ppt
Ecosystem effects of fishingEcosystem effects of fishing
• Removal of large sharks in South Africa more small sharks less of their prey fish;
• Removal of grazers (such as these surgeonfishes) led to Jamaican reefs being overgrown by algae and more susceptible to hurricane damage.
• Removal of large sharks in South Africa more small sharks less of their prey fish;
• Removal of grazers (such as these surgeonfishes) led to Jamaican reefs being overgrown by algae and more susceptible to hurricane damage.
SUMBER: innri.unuftp.is/pauly/Iceland%202%20Dec%2016%2002.ppt
Ecosystem effects of fishingEcosystem effects of fishing• Overfishing triggerfish,
pufferfish, hump-head wrasse, and triton (which all feed on juvenile crown-of-thorns) led to crown-of-thorns outbreaks on coral reefs
• Overfishing triggerfish, pufferfish, hump-head wrasse, and triton (which all feed on juvenile crown-of-thorns) led to crown-of-thorns outbreaks on coral reefs
SUMBER: innri.unuftp.is/pauly/Iceland%202%20Dec%2016%2002.ppt
Ecosystem effects of fishingEcosystem effects of fishing
• Overfishing removed pufferfishes, the predators of sea urchins:
• Overfishing removed pufferfishes, the predators of sea urchins:
SUMBER: innri.unuftp.is/pauly/Iceland%202%20Dec%2016%2002.ppt
Ecosystem effects of fishingEcosystem effects of fishing
Overfishing removes the predators of sea
urchins: pufferfishes.
Obviously, the sea urchins of any given reef will have more than one species of predators. However, the one shown here
was dominant.
Overfishing removes the predators of sea
urchins: pufferfishes.
Obviously, the sea urchins of any given reef will have more than one species of predators. However, the one shown here
was dominant.
SUMBER: innri.unuftp.is/pauly/Iceland%202%20Dec%2016%2002.ppt
Trophic level: the concept Trophic level: the concept T
rop
hic
leve
lT
rop
hic
leve
l
PhytoplanktonPhytoplankton
Top predatorsTop predators
Prey fishPrey fish
ZooplanktonZooplankton
. . . . . . .... .. .. .. .. .. .. .. *.*. ..
.. ... .
..*.*.*.*.*.*.
*.*.*.*.*.*.
*.*.
10% 10%
10% 10%
10% 10%
*.*.
44
33
22
11
SUMBER: innri.unuftp.is/pauly/Iceland%202%20Dec%2016%2002.ppt
• Initially fisheries target the upper-trophic level species, the top predators;
• As these decline in abundance focus is gradually shifted toward the prey of the top predators;
• Ultimately only the lower-trophic level species (small fish and invertebrates) are left to be caught.
• Initially fisheries target the upper-trophic level species, the top predators;
• As these decline in abundance focus is gradually shifted toward the prey of the top predators;
• Ultimately only the lower-trophic level species (small fish and invertebrates) are left to be caught.
Processes involved in ‘fishing down’Processes involved in ‘fishing down’
SUMBER: innri.unuftp.is/pauly/Iceland%202%20Dec%2016%2002.ppt
Fishing down the food web:succession of target organisms
TimeTime
Top
pred
ator
s
Top
pred
ator
s
Prey s
peci
es
Prey s
peci
es
Cat
chC
atch
SUMBER: innri.unuftp.is/pauly/Iceland%202%20Dec%2016%2002.ppt
Fishing down the food web:succession of target organisms
TimeTime
Top
pred
ator
s
Top
pred
ator
s
Prey s
peci
es
Prey s
peci
es
Cat
chC
atch
Sustainability?Sustainability?
SUMBER: innri.unuftp.is/pauly/Iceland%202%20Dec%2016%2002.ppt
Artisa
nal
Artisa
nal
Sem
i-ind
ustri
al
Sem
i-ind
ustri
al
Indu
stria
l
Indu
stria
l
TimeTime
Fis
hing
eff
ort
Fis
hing
eff
ort
Fishing down the food web:succession of fleets
SUMBER: innri.unuftp.is/pauly/Iceland%202%20Dec%2016%2002.ppt
Science March 1998, 279
2.7
2.8
2.9
3.0
3.1
3.2
3.3
3.4
1970 1975 1980 1985 1990
TL
of
lan
din
gs
MarineMarine
FreshwaterFreshwater
Global fishing down the food web
SUMBER: innri.unuftp.is/pauly/Iceland%202%20Dec%2016%2002.ppt
Gulf of Thailand fisheries
3.1
3.2
3.3
3.4
66 67 68 68 70 71 72 73 74 75 76 77 78 79 80 81
Year
Tro
ph
ic l
ev
el
of
ca
tch
Science, October 1998
Fishing down the food web
SUMBER: innri.unuftp.is/pauly/Iceland%202%20Dec%2016%2002.ppt
Gulf of Thailand fisheries
3.1
3.2
3.3
3.4
0 200 400 600 800 1000
Catch (thousand tonnes)
TL
of
catc
h
19661966
19811981
19741974
Science, October 1998SUMBER: innri.unuftp.is/pauly/Iceland%202%20Dec%2016%2002.ppt
Feeding triangles: North Sea
Other fish
KrillKrill
Norwaypout
Norwaypout
CopepodsCopepods
4
1
505
17
100
11
2
SUMBER: innri.unuftp.is/pauly/Iceland%202%20Dec%2016%2002.ppt
Other fish
Other fish
KrillKrill
Norwaypout
Norwaypout
CopepodsCopepods
44
11
505
17
100
11
22
Feeding triangles: North Sea
SUMBER: innri.unuftp.is/pauly/Iceland%202%20Dec%2016%2002.ppt
Other fish
Other fish
KrillKrill
Norwaypout
Norwaypout
CopepodsCopepods
44
11
505055
1717
100100
1111
22
Feeding triangles: North Sea
SUMBER: innri.unuftp.is/pauly/Iceland%202%20Dec%2016%2002.ppt
Requirements for adoption of ecosystem-based approaches:
Requirements for adoption of ecosystem-based approaches:
• A framework for integrating the wealth of information available at the species level;
• Basic understanding of ecosystem structure and function;
• Concepts and software integrating first two items in a transparent, practice-oriented context.
• A framework for integrating the wealth of information available at the species level;
• Basic understanding of ecosystem structure and function;
• Concepts and software integrating first two items in a transparent, practice-oriented context.
SUMBER: innri.unuftp.is/pauly/Iceland%202%20Dec%2016%2002.ppt
Do we have tools for ecosystem-based management?
Do we have tools for ecosystem-based management?
• Yes, using Ecopath with Ecosim we can incorporate ecological, economic and social considerations into a rigorous framework
• Based thereon we can use Ecosim and Ecospace to explore policy options for ecosystem based management
• Yes, using Ecopath with Ecosim we can incorporate ecological, economic and social considerations into a rigorous framework
• Based thereon we can use Ecosim and Ecospace to explore policy options for ecosystem based management
SUMBER: innri.unuftp.is/pauly/Iceland%202%20Dec%2016%2002.ppt
Policy exploration
• Policy may be defined as an approach towards
reaching a broadly defined goal;• In fisheries policies are often implemented via TACs
that are recalculated annually, and through regulation
that affects fleet and deployment;• The task of fisheries scientists is to advise both on
policy formulation and on its implementation;• So far much fisheries research is on implementation
only;• Ecosystem-based policy exploration is in its infancy.
• Policy may be defined as an approach towards
reaching a broadly defined goal;• In fisheries policies are often implemented via TACs
that are recalculated annually, and through regulation
that affects fleet and deployment;• The task of fisheries scientists is to advise both on
policy formulation and on its implementation;• So far much fisheries research is on implementation
only;• Ecosystem-based policy exploration is in its infancy.
SUMBER: innri.unuftp.is/pauly/Iceland%202%20Dec%2016%2002.ppt
Some policy objectives
1 Maximize fisheries rent;2 Maximize social benefits;3 Mandated rebuilding of species;4 Maximize ecosystem ‘health.’
Ecopath with Ecosim offers a method for evaluating the fleet configuration and effort levels that optimizes each of these objectives individually or jointly.
SUMBER: innri.unuftp.is/pauly/Iceland%202%20Dec%2016%2002.ppt
Maximizing profit
1 Profits are calculated as:the value of the landings (landings * price, by species) less the cost of fishing (fixed + variable costs);
2 Often optimization is achieved by: • phasing out most fleets except the most
profitable ones; and • wiping out ecosystems groups competing
with or preying on the more valuable target species.
SUMBER: innri.unuftp.is/pauly/Iceland%202%20Dec%2016%2002.ppt
Maximizing social benefits
1 Social benefits are expressed through the employment supported by each fleet;
2 The benefits are calculated as job / catch value, and is fleet specific;
3 Therefore social benefits are largely proportional to fishing effort;
4 Optimizing efforts often leads to more extreme scenarios than optimizing profit.
SUMBER: innri.unuftp.is/pauly/Iceland%202%20Dec%2016%2002.ppt
Mandated rebuilding1 External pressure (or legal decisions) may force
policy makers to concentrate on preserving or rebuilding the population of a given species in a given area;
2 In Ecosim this corresponds to setting a threshold biomass (relative to the biomass in Ecopath) and optimizing towards the fleet effort structure that will ensure this objective;
3 Implications will be case-specific: consider Monk seal/shark interaction in Hawaii, or Steller sea lion/Alaska pollock in the Eastern Bering Sea.
SUMBER: innri.unuftp.is/pauly/Iceland%202%20Dec%2016%2002.ppt
Maximizing ecosystem ‘health’
1 The ecosystem ‘health’ definition is inspired by Odum’s description of ecosystem ‘maturity’, wherein mature ecosystems are dominated by large, long-lived organisms;
• The group-specific biomass/production ratio provides the default weighting factor for the maximization of overall biomass;
• The ‘health’ optimization often implies:phasing out of all fisheries except those targeting species with low weighting factors.
SUMBER: innri.unuftp.is/pauly/Iceland%202%20Dec%2016%2002.ppt
Balancing economic, social and ecological objectives
1 The starting values of the objective functions have each been standardized relative to their base values (from Ecopath), making them roughly comparable;
2 Two of the measures tend to pull towards increasing fishing, and two pull towards reducing fishing. Care should be taken to consider this balance when giving relative weightings to the objectives;
3 Optimizations should be performed with a range of weighting factors for each objective function.
SUMBER: innri.unuftp.is/pauly/Iceland%202%20Dec%2016%2002.ppt
KESIMPULAN
1. A transition to ecosystem-based management of fisheries is unavoidable, if we are not to lose more of our fisheries resources
2. Such transition if actually happening in some countries, if only in the form of ecosystem consideration informing single-species management;
3. In the longer term, detailed simulation of trophic interactions within exploited ecosystems, along with explicit consideration of environmental effects, may allow for forms of fishing that are compatible with the continued existence of the underlying ecosystem, something we presently do not have.
SUMBER: innri.unuftp.is/pauly/Iceland%202%20Dec%2016%2002.ppt