Top Banner
8/6/2019 Ebert Appraisal Service Inc Office of the Real Estate Appraisers (OREA) Complaint for Appraisal Fraud http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ebert-appraisal-service-inc-office-of-the-real-estate-appraisers-orea-complaint 1/32 WZHZF OM GHLKMOYCKH " IVWKCFWW# ZYHCWPOYZHZKOC HCJ DOVWKCN HNFCG[ FJBVCJ N# IYO^C AY#, NO]FYCOY OMMKGF OM YFHL FWZHZF HPPYHKWFYW 8809 X WZYFFZ, WVKZF :800 WHGYHBFCZO, GH ;6488 " =67; mkkK $;8=+ 669 " ;000 y ~~~#oyfh#gh#no} Bhygd 99, 9088 Ihc+, W# Mhnhc 90:>6 Yogh Gdkgh Jy# Bhlkiv, Ghlkmoyckh ;09=6 Gobplhkcz Co# 880799"0; Jfhy Ihyy{ W# Mhnhc1 Zdkw ~kll hgeco~lfjnf zdf yfgfkpz om {ovy gobplhkcz yfmfyfcgfj hio}f# Zdf kc}fwzknhzk}f wzhmm om zdf Ommkgf om Yfhl Fwzhzf Hppyhkwfyw $OYFH+ yf}kf~w fhgd gobplhkcz oiafgzk}fl{ hcj gocwkjfyw h }hykfz{ ommhgzoyw kc pykoykzkqkcn ghwfw moy kc}fwzknhzkoc# Hlzdovnd ~f hyf vchilf zo jfzfybkcf do~ locn kz bh{ zhef moy zdkw kc}fwzknhzkoc zo if gobplfzfj, {ov ghc if hwwvyfj zdhz ~f ~kll pyogffj kc hw ftpfjkzkovw h bhccfy hw kw powwkilf# Plfhwf cozf zdhz {ov bh{ if goczhgzfj km ~f mkcj zdhz hjjkzkochl kcmoybhzkoc kw ~hyyhczfj hcj {ov bh{ if ghllfj vpoc zo zfwzkm{ hz hc hjbkckwzyhzk}f dfhykcn km kz ifgobfw cfgfwwhy{ hcj kw hppyopykhzf# Kz kw kbpoyzhcz zo vcjfywzhcj zdhz zdf mvcgzkoc om OYFH kw zo pyozfgz zdf pvilkg i{ fcmoygkcn wzhcjhyjw om pyomfwwkochl fzdkgw hcj gobpfzfcg{ hbocn lkgfcwfj hppyhkwfyw# Zdf kc}fwzknhzk}f pyogfww kw gocmkjfczkhl hcj ihwfj wolfl{ oc zdf mhgzvhl f}kjfcgf oizhkcfj# Kz kw coz zdf mzbgzkoc om OYFH zo hgz hw hc hj}oghzf moy fkzdfy zdf gocwvbfy oy zdf hppyhkwfy jvykcn zdf kc}fwzknhzk}f pyogfww# Km {ov hyf wffekcn zo yfgo}fy bocfzhy{ jhbhnfw, fcmoygf h goczyhgz oy oizhkc lfnhl hj}kgf, ~f fcgovyhnf {ov zo goczhgz hc hzzoycf{ oy {ovy loghl Ifzzfy Ivwkcfww Ivyfhv wkcgf OYFH kw vchilf zo pyo}kjf {ov ~kzd zdfwf wfy}kgfw# [ov ~kll if cozkmkfj i{ OYFH ~dfc zdf kc}fwzknhzk}f pyogfww dhw iffc gocglvjfj# Km {ov dh}f hc{ xvfwzkocw, plfhwf goczhgz bf hz zdf hio}f hjjyfww oy i{ ghllkcn $;8=+ 669";090# Plfhwf yfmfyfcgf zdf hio}f gobplhkcz cvbify zo hwwkwz vw kc yfwpocjkcn zo {ovy kcxvky{# Wkcgfyfl{, ,ssgA mB!. Flkqhifzd Wfhzfyw Wvpfy}kwkcn Pyopfyz{ Hppyhkwfy Kc}fwzknhzoy Fcmoygfbfcz Jk}kwkoc
32

Ebert Appraisal Service Inc Office of the Real Estate Appraisers (OREA) Complaint for Appraisal Fraud

Apr 08, 2018

Download

Documents

Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: Ebert Appraisal Service Inc Office of the Real Estate Appraisers (OREA) Complaint for Appraisal Fraud

8/6/2019 Ebert Appraisal Service Inc Office of the Real Estate Appraisers (OREA) Complaint for Appraisal Fraud

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ebert-appraisal-service-inc-office-of-the-real-estate-appraisers-orea-complaint 1/32

WZHZF OM GHLKMOYCKH " IVWKCFWW# ZYHCWPOYZHZKOC HCJ DOVWKCN HNFCG[ FJBVCJ N# IYO^C AY#, NO]FYCOY

OMMKGF OM YFHL FWZHZF HPPYHKWFYW8809 X WZYFFZ, WVKZF :800

WHGYHBFCZO, GH ;6488 " =67;

mkkK $;8=+ 669 " ;000

y ~~~#oyfh#gh#no}

Bhygd 99, 9088

Ihc+, W# Mhnhc

90:>6 Yogh Gdkgh Jy#

Bhlkiv, Ghlkmoyckh ;09=6

Gobplhkcz Co# 880799"0;

Jfhy Ihyy{ W# Mhnhc1

Zdkw ~kll hgeco~lfjnf zdf yfgfkpz om {ovy gobplhkcz yfmfyfcgfj hio}f#

Zdf kc}fwzknhzk}f wzhmm om zdf Ommkgf om Yfhl Fwzhzf Hppyhkwfyw $OYFH+ yf}kf~w fhgd gobplhkcz

oiafgzk}fl{ hcj gocwkjfyw h }hykfz{ ommhgzoyw kc pykoykzkqkcn ghwfw moy kc}fwzknhzkoc# Hlzdovnd

~f hyf vchilf zo jfzfybkcf do~ locn kz bh{ zhef moy zdkw kc}fwzknhzkoc zo if gobplfzfj, {ov ghcif hwwvyfj zdhz ~f ~kll pyogffj kc hw ftpfjkzkovw h bhccfy hw kw powwkilf# Plfhwf cozf zdhz {ov

bh{ if goczhgzfj km ~f mkcj zdhz hjjkzkochl kcmoybhzkoc kw ~hyyhczfj hcj {ov bh{ if ghllfj vpoc

zo zfwzkm{ hz hc hjbkckwzyhzk}f dfhykcn km kz ifgobfw cfgfwwhy{ hcj kw hppyopykhzf#

Kz kw kbpoyzhcz zo vcjfywzhcj zdhz zdf mvcgzkoc om OYFH kw zo pyozfgz zdf pvilkg i{ fcmoygkcn

wzhcjhyjw om pyomfwwkochl fzdkgw hcj gobpfzfcg{ hbocn lkgfcwfj hppyhkwfyw# Zdf kc}fwzknhzk}f

pyogfww kw gocmkjfczkhl hcj ihwfj wolfl{ oc zdf mhgzvhl f}kjfcgf oizhkcfj# Kz kw coz zdf mzbgzkoc

om OYFH zo hgz hw hc hj}oghzf moy fkzdfy zdf gocwvbfy oy zdf hppyhkwfy jvykcn zdf kc}fwzknhzk}f

pyogfww# Km {ov hyf wffekcn zo yfgo}fy bocfzhy{ jhbhnfw, fcmoygf h goczyhgz oy oizhkc lfnhl

hj}kgf, ~f fcgovyhnf {ov zo goczhgz hc hzzoycf{ oy {ovy loghl Ifzzfy Ivwkcfww Ivyfhv wkcgf

OYFH kw vchilf zo pyo}kjf {ov ~kzd zdfwf wfy}kgfw# [ov ~kll if cozkmkfj i{ OYFH ~dfc zdf

kc}fwzknhzk}f pyogfww dhw iffc gocglvjfj#

Km {ov dh}f hc{ xvfwzkocw, plfhwf goczhgz bf hz zdf hio}f hjjyfww oy i{ ghllkcn $;8=+ 669";090#Plfhwf yfmfyfcgf zdf hio}f gobplhkcz cvbify zo hwwkwz vw kc yfwpocjkcn zo {ovy kcxvky{#

Wkcgfyfl{,

, ssgA mB!.Flkqhifzd Wfhzfyw

Wvpfy}kwkcn Pyopfyz{ Hppyhkwfy Kc}fwzknhzoy

Fcmoygfbfcz Jk}kwkoc

Page 2: Ebert Appraisal Service Inc Office of the Real Estate Appraisers (OREA) Complaint for Appraisal Fraud

8/6/2019 Ebert Appraisal Service Inc Office of the Real Estate Appraisers (OREA) Complaint for Appraisal Fraud

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ebert-appraisal-service-inc-office-of-the-real-estate-appraisers-orea-complaint 2/32

LH^ OMMKG FW O M IHYY[ W # MHNHC

OMMKGF OM YFHL FWZHZF HPPYH KWFYW

8809 X WZYFFZ, WV KZF :800

WHGYHBFCZO,GH ;6488¾=67;H zzc 1 F lkq hi fzd W fhzf yw

YF 1 AHBFW FIFYZ

GOBPLH KCZ CO # 880799"0;Bh{ 8=, 900> Hpp yh kwh l mo y1

90:>6 Y ogh G dkgh J y# B hlkiv, G H ;09=6

Ihyy{ W# Mhnhc } ^ fllw Mhyno Ihce5 Fifyz Hppyhkwhl Wfy}kgf Kcg# fz hl#

WGl890::

Hpykl 9;, 9088

Jfhy B w # W fh zf yw5

K Ihyy{ Mhnhc dfyfi{ hgeco~ lfjnf yfgfkpz om {ovy oynhckqhzkocw lfzzfy jhzfj B hygd

99,9088#

K ~ kwd zo wvpplfb fcz b { gob plhkcz ~ kzd hjjkzkochl kcmoyb hzkoc hcj f}kjfcgf om B y#

F if yz.w p yo mfww ko chl b kwgo cj vg z#

Plfhwf mkcj zdf mollo~ kcn z~o vcwolkgkzfj fb hklw zdhz K yfgfk}fj oc Wvcjh{ H pykl 80,9088 myob B y# Ahb fw F ifyz#

FBHKL 81

Dfllo, Ihyy{, myob Ahbfw Fifyz

Oc Wvc, :/80/88, Ahbfw Fifyz <ahbfw@fhw9#gob3 ~yozf1

Myob1 Ahbfw Fifyz #xhbfw@fhw9#gob3

Wviafgz1 Dfllo, Ihyy{, myob Ahbfw Fifyz

Zo1 pfcjkcnlh~wvkz@{hdoo#gob

Jhzf1 Wvcjh{, Hpykl 80, 9088,610= PB

):8088

By# Ihyy{ Mhnhc,

PO IOT 8987, BHLKIV ,GH ;09=6"8987PFCJKCNLH^WVKZ@[HDOO#GOB

ZFL# 780#>8>#8>;0

Page 3: Ebert Appraisal Service Inc Office of the Real Estate Appraisers (OREA) Complaint for Appraisal Fraud

8/6/2019 Ebert Appraisal Service Inc Office of the Real Estate Appraisers (OREA) Complaint for Appraisal Fraud

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ebert-appraisal-service-inc-office-of-the-real-estate-appraisers-orea-complaint 3/32

LH^ OMMKGFW OM IHYY[ W # MHNHC

K ghc wff myob zdf 900% phnfw jogvbfcz jflk}fyfj zo bf, zdhz {ov hyf }fy{ myvwzyhzfj

~kzd zdf ihcekcn kcjvwzy{ hcj zdf ~h{ kz dhw kbphgzfj {ov, {ovy ~kmf hcj {ovy ~ocjfymvl

gdkljyfc# K~kwd {ov zdf ifwz om lvge oc {ovy hzzfbpzw zo nhkc wobfzdkcn myob ^fllw

Mhyno hcj zdf ozdfy mkybw zdhz pyf{ oc dhplfww dobfo~cfyw ghvndz kc zdf yfgfwwkoc#

Ivz kz hppfhyw zdhz yopkcn bf kc oc zdkw, kw h wzyfzgd, hcj kz wffbw zo hgzvhll{ ~fhefc {ovy

ghwf# Mkywzl{, Kdh}f cozdkcn zo nk}f {ov, oy f}fc hc{ hzzoycf{# B{ pyomfwwkoc dhw iffcdkz avwz hw dhyj hw {ovy mkflj# B{ kcgobf dhw jyoppfj zo dhlm om pyf}kovw zkbfw5 Kghc co

locnfy zhef zkbf zo wpfcj hc hmzfycooc ~kzd b{ io{w, plh{kcn h lkzzlf nolm, lkef zdf olj

zkbfw, oy zhekcn zdf ~kmf ovz moy h bojfwz jkccfy# Khb ~oyekcn 800"dovyw fhgd ~ffe,

avwz zo nfz zdf lkzzlf pfcckfw zdhz hyf ovz zdfyf#

Zdkw ~fhefcw {ovy ghwf, ifghvwf {ovy ghwf kw ihwfj oc zdf lohc zdhz ~hw pvwdfj i{ zdf

gobbkwwkoc"ihwfj ^fllw ihcefyw, ~kzdovz hc{ ghyf oy zdovndz om {ovy gocwfxvfcgfw#

Zdf{ bhjf zdfky gobbkwwkoc, hcj zdfc wolj {ovy lohc ovz zo ^hll Wzyffz# [ov dh}f zykfj

zo nfz lohc bojkmkghzkocw, ivz zdfky plhc kw zo avwz h}okj {ov vczkl {ov nk}f vp, hcj zdf{

~kc# Zdf{ nfz myff bocf{ myob zdf Mfjw, zo jo zdfky jfyk}hzk}f zyhjkcn, zdhz bhefw zdfb

boyf bocf{ i{ nhbilkcn ~kzd ozdfy pfoplf.w bocf{, zdhc zdf{ bhef jokcn lohcw#

Wkcgf zdf ihcew o~c dhlm om zdf Hppyhkwhl Bhchnfbfcz Gobphckfw, zdf{ hyf co~ bhekcn

*900 moy fhgd lohc hpplkghzkoc, hw zdf{ gdhynf *600 moy hc hppyhkwhl, zdfc wekb omm :0&

moy zdfky o~c pogefzw, zdfc ommfy *8>6 zo hc ovz"om"hyfh hppyhkwfy zo jo zdf hppyhkwhl#

^dfc zdf }hlvf gobfw ihge lo~, zdf{ joc.z ghyf, zdf{ effp zdf mff, hcj zdf hpplkghcz kw

ovz f}fc boyf bocf{# ^dkgd kw ~d{ hppyhkwfyw hyf wvmmfykcn hw ~fll, bhekcn dhlm zdfky

moybfy mffw, {fz whjjlfj ~kzd 60& boyf ~oye moy fhgd mklf#

Keco~ {ov dh}f wpfcz boczdw oy {fhyw nfzzkcn zdkw yfhj{ zo no, hcj kz dhw iffc dkndl{

jkwzyhgzkcn myob {ovy mhbkl{, zoo# Lkef ~kzd bf hcj b{ mhbkl{, zdkw kw zkbf {ov ~ovlj

yhzdfy if wpfcjkcn dflpkcn zdfb ~kzd dobf~oye, zfhgdkcn zdfb lkmf wekllw, wdhykcn wobfao{ ~kzd do~ lkmf ghc if, lk}kcn kc wvgd h ifhvzkmvl gobbvckz{ ivz zdhz {ov ghccoz,

jvf zo zdf bkwmoyzvcf zdhz dhw wbhgefj kczo {ov hcj {ovy pyomfwwkoc#

Kpolkzfl{ hwe zdhz {ov bojkm{ {ovy gobplhkcz, hcj yfbo}f bf, hcj hlwo ~kzdjyh~ {ovy

gobplhkcz zo zdf wzhzf OYFH# Zdkw kw coz nokcn zo dflp {ov, kz ~kll jklvzf {ovy fcfyn{ hcj

{ovy ghwf# Kjkj h nooj hppyhkwhl moy {ov, hw Khl~h{w jo# [ovy wzhzf gobplhkcz ~kll

jkwzyhgz zdf wzhzf ommkgf5 zdf{ ~kll wpfcj zdfky bfhnfy yfwovygfw oc {ovy ifdhlm, hcj mkcj

zdfyf kw co bfykz zo {ovy gobplhkcz# Bfhc~dklf ozdfy zyvf gykbkchlw hcj vcwgyvpvlovw

hppyhkwfyw ~kll wzkll if yohbkcn zdf wzyffzw, dvyzkcn bhc{ boyf mhbklkfw hcj zdfky gdkljyfc,

~kzd zyvl{ }kgkovw hgzk}kz{# Khb dopkcn zdhz Kghc kcwzfhj wpfcj zdhz zkbf dflpkcn b{ ekjw

~ kzd zdfky dob f~ oye, hcj b h{if wx vffqf kc h jh{ ~ kzd zdfb hz Q vb h I fhgd, yhzdfy zdhcdh}f zo ~oye wo dhyj zo nhkc hjjkzkochl kcgobf zo wpfcj kz oc mkndzkcn h coybhll{ nooj

nv{, h zfyykmkg mfllo~ ~do bfhcw ~fll, ~do dhw iffc dvyz wo ihjl{#

PO IOT 8987, BHLKIV, GH ;09=6"8987

PFCJKCNLH^WVKZ@[HDOO#GOB

ZFL# 780#>8>#8>;0

Page 4: Ebert Appraisal Service Inc Office of the Real Estate Appraisers (OREA) Complaint for Appraisal Fraud

8/6/2019 Ebert Appraisal Service Inc Office of the Real Estate Appraisers (OREA) Complaint for Appraisal Fraud

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ebert-appraisal-service-inc-office-of-the-real-estate-appraisers-orea-complaint 4/32

LH^ O MM KG F W O M IHYY[ W # MHNHC

Mfflmyff zo goczhgz bf hz hc{ zkbf# K ~kwd {ov zdf }fy{ ifwz moy {ov hcj {ovy mhbkl{#

Ifwz Yfnhyjw,

Ahbfw Fifyz

484;;8 ;799)

FBHKL 91

Dfllo, Ihyy{, Dhpp{ Wpykcn, myob Ahbfw

Fifyz• Myob1 Ahbfw Fifyz ahbfw@fhw9#gob

Jhzf1 Wvc, 80 Hpy 9088 0;196196 "0>00

Zo1 ihyy{@ghlkmoyckhfxvkz{yfhlz{#gobWviafgz1 Dfllo,Ihyy{, Dhpp{ Wpykcn, myob Ahbfw Fifyz

):8088

By# Ihyy{ Mhnhc,

Kghc wff myob zdf 900% phnfw jogvbfcz jflk}fyfj zo bf, zdhz {ov hyf }fy{myvwzyhzfj ~kzd zdf ihcekcn kcjvwzy{ hcj zdf ~h{ kz dhw kbphgzfj {ov, {ovy

~kmf hcj {ovy ~ocjfymvl gdkljyfc# K~kwd {ov zdf ifwz om lvge oc {ovyhzzfbpzw zo nhkc wobfzdkcn myob ^fllw Mhyno hcj zdf ozdfy mkybw zdhz pyf{oc

dhplfww dobfo~cfyw ghvndz kc zdf yfgfwwkoc#

Ivz kz hppfhyw zdhz yopkcn bf kc oc zdkw, kw h wzyfzgd, hcj kz wffbw zo

hgzvhll{ ~fhefc {ovy ghwf# Mkywzl{, Kdh}f cozdkcn zo nk}f {ov, oy f}fc hc{

hzzoycf{# B{pyomfwwkoc dhw iffc dkz avwz hw dhyj hw {ovy mkflj# B{kcgobf

dhw jyop pfj zo dhlm om pyf}kovw zkb fw5 K ghc co locnfy zhef zkb f zo wp fcj hchmzfycooc ~kzd b{ io{w, plh{kcn h lkzzlf nolm, lkef zdf olj zkbfw, oy zhekcnzdf ~kmf ovz moy h bojfwz jkccfy# Khb ~oyekcn 800"dovyw fhgd ~ffe, avwz zonfz zdf lkzzlf pfcckfw zdhz hyf ovz zdfyf#

Zdkw ~fhefcw {ovy ghwf, ifghvwf {ovy ghwf kw ihwfj oc zdf lohc zdhz ~hw

POIOT8987, BHLKIV,GH;09=6"8987PFCJKCNLH^WVKZ@[HDOO#GOB

ZFL#780#>8>#8>;0

Page 5: Ebert Appraisal Service Inc Office of the Real Estate Appraisers (OREA) Complaint for Appraisal Fraud

8/6/2019 Ebert Appraisal Service Inc Office of the Real Estate Appraisers (OREA) Complaint for Appraisal Fraud

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ebert-appraisal-service-inc-office-of-the-real-estate-appraisers-orea-complaint 5/32

LH^ OMMKGFW OM IHYY[ W# MHNHC

pvwdfj i{ zdf gobbkwwkoc"ihwfj ^fllw ihcefyw, ~kzdovz hc{ ghyf oy zdovndz

om{ovy gocwfxvfcgfw# Zdf{ bhjf zdfky gobbkwwkoc, hcj zdfc wolj {ovy lohc

ovz

zo ^hll Wzyffz# [ov dh}f zykfj zo nfz lohc bojkmkghzkocw, ivz zdfky plhc kwzo avwz h}okj {ov vczkl {ov nk}f vp, hcj zdf{ ~kc# Zdf{ nfz myff bocf{ myob

zdf Mfjw, zo jo zdfky jfyk}hzk}f zyhjkcn, zdhz bhefw zdfb boyf bocf{ i{

nhbilkcn ~kzd ozdfy pfoplf.w bocf{, zdhc zdf{ bhef jokcn lohcw#

Wkcgf zdf ihcew o~c dhlm om zdf Hppyhkwhl Bhchnfbfcz Gobphckfw, zdf{ hyf

co~bhekcn *900 moy fhgd lohc hpplkghzkoc, hw zdf{ gdhynf *600 moy hc hppyhkwhl,zdfc wekb omm :0& moy zdfky o~c pogefzw, zdfc ommfy *8>6 zo hc ovz"om"hyfh

hppyhkwfy zo jo zdf hppyhkwhl# ^dfc zdf }hlvf gobfw ihge lo~, zdf{ joc.zghyf, zdf{ effp zdf mff, hcj zdf hpplkghcz kw ovz f}fc boyf bocf{# ^dkgd kw~d{ hppyhkwfyw hyf wvmmfykcn hw ~fll, bhekcn dhlm zdfky moybfy mffw, {fz

whjjlfj ~kzd 60& boyf ~oye moy fhgd mklf#

Keco~ {ov dh}f wpfcz boczdw oy {fhyw nfzzkcn zdkw yfhj{ zo no, hcj kz dhwiffc dkndl{ jkwzyhgzkcn myob {ovy mhbkl{, zoo# Lkef~kzd bf hcj b{ mhbkl{,zdkw kw zkbf {ov ~ovlj yhzdfy if wpfcjkcn dflpkcn zdfb ~kzd dobf~oye,

zfhgdkcn zdfb lkmf wekllw, wdhykcn wob f ao{ ~ kzd do~ lkmf ghc if, lk}kcn kcwvgd h ifhvzkmvl gobbvckz{ ##ivz zdhz {ov ghccoz, jvf zo zdf bkwmoyzvcf zdhz

dhw wbhgefj kczo {ov hcj {ovy pyomfwwkoc#

Kpolkzfl{ hwe zdhz {ov bojkm{ {ovy gobplhkcz, hcj yfbo}f bf, hcj hlwo

~kzdjyh~ {ovy gobplhkcz zo zdf wzhzf OYFH# Zdkw kw coz nokcn zo dflp {ov,kz ~kll jklvzf {ovy fcfyn{ hcj {ovy ghwf# Kjkj h nooj hppyhkwhl moy {ov, hw

Khl~h{w jo# [ovy wzhzf gobplhkcz ~kll jkwzyhgz zdf wzhzf ommkgf5 zdf{ ~kllwpfcj zdfky bfhnfy yfwovygfw oc {ovy ifdhlm, hcj mkcj zdfyf kw co bfykz zo

{ovy gobplhkcz# Bfhc~dklf ozdfy zyvf gykbkchlw hcj vcwgyvpvlovw

hppyhkwfyw~kll wzkll if yohbkcn zdf wzyffzw, dvyzkcn bhc{ boyf mhbklkfw hcj zdfky

gdkljyfc, ~kzd zyvl{ }kgkovw hgzk}kz{# Khb dopkcn zdhz Kghc kcwzfhj wpfcj

zdhz zkbf dflpkcn b{ ekjw ~kzd zdfky dobf~oye, hcj bh{if wxvffqf kc h jh{~kzd zdfb hz Qvbh Ifhgd, yhzdfy zdhc dh}f zo ~oye wo dhyj zo nhkchjjkzkochlkcgobf zo wpfcj kz oc mkndzkcn h coybhll{ nooj nv{, h zfyykmkg mfllo~ ~dobfhcw ~fll, ~do dhw iffc dvyz wo ihjl{#

POIOT8987, BHLKIV,GH;09=6"8987PFCJKCNLH^WVKZ@[HDOO#GOB

ZFL#780#>8>#8>;0

Page 6: Ebert Appraisal Service Inc Office of the Real Estate Appraisers (OREA) Complaint for Appraisal Fraud

8/6/2019 Ebert Appraisal Service Inc Office of the Real Estate Appraisers (OREA) Complaint for Appraisal Fraud

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ebert-appraisal-service-inc-office-of-the-real-estate-appraisers-orea-complaint 6/32

LH^ OMMKGFW O M IHYY[ W # MHNHC

Mffl myff zo goczhgz bf hz hc{ zkbf# K ~kwd {ov zdf }fy{ ifwz moy {ov hcj

{ovy mhbkl{#

Ifwz Yfnhyjw,

Ahbfw Fifyz

484 ;;8 ;799)

!Kcglvjfj kc zdfwf fbhklw ~fyf 7 #apn pkgzvyfw om dkw gdkljyfc#

8 ( Wbklfw hz Qvbf JWGC60:0APN

• 9 OB- N ~ zocnvf#apn

• 7 ( Io{w kc zdf#apn

Hw {ov ghc wff, zdfwf fbhklw ~fyf xvkzf jkwzvyikcn hcj kc b{ opkckoc kczfcjfj zo oiwzyvgz

avwzkgf#

Plfhwf hlwo mkcj zdf mollo~kcn mkcjkcnw om mhgz ~dfc yf}kf~kcn zdf hzzhgdfj Bh{ 8=,900>

Hppyhkwhl1

8# Gobphyhilf Whlf '8# 909:7 Pkfjyh Gdkgh Jy# wolj moy *8,4>6,000# Zdf loz wkqf kw

84,8>4 wx# mz# hcj kw oc h bvgd xvkfzfy wzyffz hz zdf fcj om h gvK jf whg ~kzd wvpfykoy ogfhc

}kf~w hlocn ~kzd wvpfykoy nyovcjw#

9# Gobphyhilf Whlf '9# 90468 Ikn Yoge Jy# ~ovlj if gocwkjfyfj hc fwzhzf pyopfyz{ hcj

kw loghzfj ifdkcj pyk}hzf nhzfw ~kzd jyhbhzkg ogfhc }kf~w# Zdf pdozo kc By# Fifyz.w

hppyhkwhl hppfhyw zo if om zdf yfhy {hyj# Zdf pdozo hppfhyw zo if myob zdf BLW oy myob

wobf yfhl fwzhzf ~fiwkzf wvgd hw Dobfw hcj Lhcj# Nk}fc zdhz zdkw kw h nhzfj fwzhzf, kz kw

dkndl{ jovizmvl zdhz By# Fifyz f}fc ~fcz zo zdf pyopfyz{ lfz hlocf zhef zdf jyhbhzkg pdozo

hw wdo~c kc zdf Bh{ 8=,900> hppyhkwhl#

7# Gobphyhilf Whlf '7# By# Fifyz vwfj h pdozo jkyfgzl{ myob zdf BLW# $BLW' 0="

88407>+ 90:>0 Yo{hl Wzocf Jy# wdhyfw h gobboc yfhy {hyj mfcgf ~kzd 90:>6 Yogh Gdkgh

Jy# hcj wolj moy *8,:80,000# Zdkw ~hw *=;0,000 lfww zdhc By# Fifyz Hppyhkwfj 90:>6

Yogh Gdkgh Jy# moy, hcj {fz kw oc h wvpfykoy loz ~kzd ifzzfy ogfhc }kf~w hcj oc h xvkfzfy

wzyffz# Vwkcn pdozow myob h wovygf ozdfy zdhc zdf hppyhkwfy.w o~c ghbfyh kw h wzyocn

PO IOT 8987, BHLKIV, GH ;09=6"8987

PFCJKCNLH^WVKZ@[HDOO#GOB

ZFL# 780#>8>#8>;0

Page 7: Ebert Appraisal Service Inc Office of the Real Estate Appraisers (OREA) Complaint for Appraisal Fraud

8/6/2019 Ebert Appraisal Service Inc Office of the Real Estate Appraisers (OREA) Complaint for Appraisal Fraud

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ebert-appraisal-service-inc-office-of-the-real-estate-appraisers-orea-complaint 7/32

LH^ OMMKG FW O M IHYY[ W # MHNHC

kcjkghzkoc zdhz zdf hppyhkwfy ~hw coz f}fc pyfwfcz hz zdf pyopfyz{ jvykcn zdf govywf om dkw

hppyhkwhl#

:# Gobphyhilf whlf ': 987>0 Yhbilh ]kwzh kcglvjfw dkndl{ jfwkyhilf jffjfj ifhgd hcj

zfcckw ykndzw hcj kw kc h gobplfzfl{ jkmmfyfcz cfkndioydooj# Zdkw dobf ~hw ivklz kc 9009

hcj dhw 7,9;6 wx# mz# om kczfykoy wphgf ~kzd wvpfykoy ogfhc }kf~w#

6# Gobphyhilf Whlf '6 9060: Yogh Gdkgh ~hw ocl{ h gvyyfcz lkwzkcn zdhz cf}fy kc mhgz

wolj# Zdkw dobf kw h ilvmm wkjf wvpfykoy ogfhc }kf~ pyopfyz{,

=# Gobphyhilf Whlf '=# By# Fifyz kjfczkmkfj 90:9= Yogh Gdkg h Jy# hw ifkcn h gvyyfcz

lkwzkcn kc 900> ~kzd h lkwz pykgf om *8,4;6,000#

Do~f}fy, h wfhygd om zdf BLW lkwzkcn dkwzoy{ ocl{ wdo~w zdkw dobf ~hw lkwzfj moy

*8,49;,000 hcj ~hw cf}fy kc mhgz lkwzfj hz *8,4;6,000# $plfhwf wff lkwzkcn dkwzoy{ BLW '

0>"8>4477 hcj BLW' 0>"8>;=0;++

06/0>/900> *8,49;,000 90 0>"8>4477 ::60"087"0>490:9= YOGH GDKGH JY T>9==>

8t=9>40 Hgzk}f 0:/96/900> 0:/8>/900> *8,49;,000 98 0>"8>4477 ::60"087"0>4

90:9= YOGH GDKGH JY T>9==> 8t=9>40 Cf~ Lkwzkcn 0:/84/900>0:/8>/900>

*8,49;,000

0>"8>;=0;! ::60"087"0>4 90:9= YOGH GDKGH JY B9000979 8 L0=9:9 Hgzk}f0:/96/900>0:/8>/900> *8,49;,000 hcj kc mhgz zdf pvilkg yfgoyjw kcjkghzfw h )wfzzlfj

jhzf) om Bh{ 80,900> moy *8,>00,000,= jh{w pykoy zo zdf Bh{ 8=,900> hppyhkwhl moy

*9,800,000#

Hjjkzkochll{1

8# ^kzd yfwpfgz zo Gobp# whlf '=, K jo coz iflkf}f zdf Fifyz hppyhkwhl kcjkghzfj zdhz zdf

pyopfyz{ ~hw vcjfy goczyhgz kc dkw yfpoyz ~kzd h )looekcn moy ihgevp) wzhzvw oy zdf mhgz

zdhz kz ~fcz kczo goczyhgz pfy BLW oc 68>8900>5 iozd om zdfwf mhgzw ~fyf h}hklhilf zo zdf

pvilkg $Fifyz+ hw om zdf jhzf om zdf hppyhkwhl hcj zdvw govlj glhwwkmkfj hw hc fyyoy kc mhgzw

hiovz kzw )lkwz) wzhzvw# Mvyzdfyboyf, ocf govlj wpfgvlhzf zdhz zdf hpphyfcz obkwwkoc om

zdfwf mhgzw govlj powwkil{ bfhc zdhz Fifyz jkj coz zhef zdf zkbf zo pfymoyb hc{ jvf

jklknfcgf kczo zdkw bhzzfy5 jvf jklknfcgf wvgd hw ghllkcn zdf lkwzkcn hnfcz zo mkcj ovz ~dfc

zdf pyopfyz{ kw ftpfgzfj zo glowf fwgyo~ hcj km zdf hnfcz bkndz if gobmoyzhilf jkwglowkcn

zdf pfcjkcn whlfw pykgf oy ommfykcn h pykgf yhcnf dkcz# Mvyzdfyboyf, kz hppfhyw zdhz hc

fyyoy govlj dh}f iffc bhjf hw zdf yfgoyjw jo coz yfmlfgz hc{ f}kjfcgf zdhz zdf pyopfyz{

~hw f}fy lkwzfj moy whlf hz *8,4;6,000, ocl{ *8,49;,000#

0>"8>4477 ::60"087"0>490:9= YOGH GDKGH JY T>9==> / t=9>40 Looekcn Moy Ihgevp 06804/900>

0680>/900> *8,49;,000 90

PO IOT 8987, BHLKIV, GH ;09=6"8987

PFCJKCNLH^WVKZ@[HDOO#GOB

ZFL# 780#>8>#8>;0

Page 8: Ebert Appraisal Service Inc Office of the Real Estate Appraisers (OREA) Complaint for Appraisal Fraud

8/6/2019 Ebert Appraisal Service Inc Office of the Real Estate Appraisers (OREA) Complaint for Appraisal Fraud

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ebert-appraisal-service-inc-office-of-the-real-estate-appraisers-orea-complaint 8/32

LH^ OMMKGFW OM IHYY[ W# MHNHC

9# HC[ fyyoyw, obkwwkocw hcj vcpyomfwwkochl kwb ifdh}koy yfmlfgzfj kc hc hppyhkwhl govlj

if gocwzyvfj hw kchppyopykhzf hcj kczfczkochl hcj bkwlfhjkcn hcj zdvw govlj if

gocwkjfyfj h }kolhzkoc om VWPHP $Vckmoyb Wzhcjhyjw om Pyomfwwkochl Hppyhkwhl Pyhgzkgf+#

Fthbplfw om hgzw zdhz govlj if gocwkjfyfj bkwlfhjkcn hcj cfnlknfcz hyf $vwf om BLW

pdozow ~dkgd govlj kbpl{ zdhz zdf pyopfyz{ ~hw coz pd{wkghll{ oiwfy}fj5 lhge om

hjavwzbfczw moy hyfhw zdhz ~ovlj z{pkghll{ yfxvkyf hjavwzbfczw5 lhge vzkl kqkcn zdf iyoefy.w

om zdf gobphyhilf whlfw hw h jhzh wovygf kc oyjfy zo hwgfyzhkc boyf hggvyhzf pyopfyz{gdhyhgzfykwzkgw5 lhge om gobbfczw kcjkghzkcn ~dfyf zdf )gobpw) vwhilf loz hyfh mknvyfw

ghbf myob $Lf# ~dfyf zdf vwhilf loz hyfh mknvyfw zhefc myob h lfnkzkbhzf hcj hggvyhzf

wovygf oy ~dfyf zdf{ wkbpl{ h yhcjob nvfww bhjf zo kczfczkochll{ gyfhzf hc hjavwzfj

}hlvf zdhz wvkzw zdf pvypowfw om zdf hppyhkwfy.w }hlvf kczfcz+5 hcj, zdf vwf om whlfw zdhz

hyf coz )gobpw) ivz wkbpl{ hyfh whlfw $k#f# pyopfyz{ hz 90468 Ikn Yoge Jyk}f movcj kc

Gobphyhilf Whlf Co#9+ govlj if }fy{ bkwlfhjkcn hw omzfc hjavwzbfczw hpplkfj zo h coc

gobp bh{ coz hggvyhzfl{ yfmlfgz zyvf }hlvf jkmmfyfcgfw#

Zdkw kcgoyyfgz pykgf wdovlj if gocwkjfyfj h nyoww fyyoy ~dkgd hz ifwz kw cfnlknfcgf hcj hz

~oywz kw kczfczkochll{ bkwwzhzfj zo eco~kcnl{ hcj hyzkmkgkhll{ kcmlhzf zdf }hlvf om 90:>6

Yogh Gdkgh Jy# zo *9,800,000# Zhefc hw h ~dolf, b{ gobplhkcz hnhkcwz By# Fifyz

wvnnfwzw zdf )hz ~oywz) wgfchyko#

K hb ocl{ zy{kcn zo yfpyfwfcz zdf mhgzw hw zdf{ yflhzf zo b { B h{ 8=, 900> hppyhkwhl#

B { glhkb w hnhkcwz ^ fllw Mhyno hcj Fifyz Hppyhkwhl Wfy} kgf hyf xvkzf wovcj# Iflo~

plfhwf mkcj hc Hpykl 96, 9088 hyzkglf zdhz ~hw pvilkwdfj i{ C fkl N hymkflj hz

D ZZ P1//L K] KCNLKF W#^OYJPYFWW #GOB go cgfyc kc n zd f mhgzw om b { ghwf#

NOOJ PLFHJKCN " MHNHC ] ^FLLW MHYNO F Z H L

8# Zdf mkywz zdkcn zdhz kw kbpoyzhcz zo cozf kw zdf kjfczkz{ om zdf jfmfcjhczw

wvfj i{ Mhnhc1 Ifwkjfw ^fllw Mhyno, df chbfw Hbfykghc Wfgvykzkfw

Gobphc{, Z#O# Wfy}kgf Gobphc{ hcj Fifyz Hppyhkwhl Wfy}kgf Kcg# Df zdvw

wfzw zdf wzhnf moy hzzhgekcn zdf yfhlkz{ om zdf zyhcwhgzkoc df ~hw zykgefj

kczo# Chbkcn zdf Wfy}kgf Gobphc{ hcj zdf Hppyhkwhl Gobphc{ kw jkmmfyfcz

myob ~dhz bowz pfoplf hyf jokcn hcj df yfhll{ pvywvfw iozd zdfb hcj zdf

wfy}kgf gobphc{ zdhz kckzkhzfj zdf moyfglowvyf pyogffjkcn#

9# Zdf wfgocj zdkcn om kbpoyzhcgf kw zdfmklkcn om zdf oiafgzkoc zo jkwglhkbfyolcoc"bocfzhy{ wzhzvw om Z#J#Wfy}kgf#Zdkw kw zdf mkywz zkbf Kdh}f wffc

wobfocf )nfz kz) hcj yfhlkqf zdhz Z#O#oy hc{ gobphc{ zdhz kckzkhzfwmoyfglowvyfw kw pyoihil{ goczyollfj i{ ocf om zdf ^hll Wzyffz ihceyvpzg{

yfbozf wdfllw, hcj kw COZh phyz{ ~kzdovz hc kczfyfwz kc zdf ovzgobf# Zdhz

kw ~d{ ~f wff wviwzkzvzkocw om zyvwzff f}fy{ zkbf zdfyf kw h moyfglowvyf#

^d{ kw zdhz cfgfwwhy{ """ pyfgkwfl{ ifghvwf, hw Mhnhc pokczw ovz, zdhz hc

hyb.w lfcnzd gobphc{ ~kzd co kczfyfwz kc zdf pyogffjkcn ~ovlj cf}fy jo

PO IOT 898 7, BHL KIV ,GH ; 09 =6 "8 98 7

PFCJKCNLH^WVKZ@[HDOO#GOB

ZFL# 780 #>8> #8>;0

Page 9: Ebert Appraisal Service Inc Office of the Real Estate Appraisers (OREA) Complaint for Appraisal Fraud

8/6/2019 Ebert Appraisal Service Inc Office of the Real Estate Appraisers (OREA) Complaint for Appraisal Fraud

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ebert-appraisal-service-inc-office-of-the-real-estate-appraisers-orea-complaint 9/32

LH^ OMMKGFW OM IHYY[ W# MHNHC

~dhz Z#J#kw jokcn ifghvwf om zdf pozfczkhl ftpowvyf zo lkhiklkz{ """ hcj

ifghvwf Z#0# hcj ozdfyw lkef kz hyf wkpdockcn omm zdf bocf{ zdhz govlj

ozdfy~kwf no zo zdf kc}fwzoy"lfcjfyw#

7# Hw K dh}f yfpfhzfjl{ whkj, zdf gocwfcwvw omlh~{fyw kw zdhz ~kzdovz

oiafgzkcn zo F]FY[ZDKCNov hyf gocgfjkcn zdhz zdfyf bkndz if h wdyfj

omlfnkzkbhg{ zo ~dhz kw glfhyl{ h gobplfzfl{ myhvjvlfcz glhkb, myhvjvlfcz

moyfglowvyf oc h myhvjvlfcz boyznhnf wfgvykcn h myhvjvlfcz cozf# Mhnhc

hggvwfw ZJom pyogffjkcn jfwpkzf zdfky eco~lfjnf zdhz ^fllw Mhyno ~hw

coz zdf gyfjkzoy, coz zdf yfhl phyz{ kc kczfyfwz, lhgefj wzhcjkcn, dhj co

bocf{ kc zdf jfhl, ~hw coz zdf lfcjfy hcj cf}fy pvygdhwfj zdf yfgfk}hilf#

:# Kc hjjkzkoc Mhnhc, oi}kovwl{ eco~lfjnfhilf hiovz zdf hgzvhl pyogfjvyfw

kc vwf, zdyvwzw dkw lkzknhzkoc jhnnfy kczo zdf dfhyz om zdf bhzzfy i{ hllfnkcn

zdhz zdf pfywoc wknckcn zdf phpfyw, ifwkjfw lhgekcn hvzdoykz{, lhgefj hc{

eco~lfjnf om zdf zyhcwhgzkoc, hcj dhj co ~h{ om eco~kcn zdf kjfczkz{ om

zdf yfhl gyfjkzoy ftgfpz zdhz ^fllw Mhyno kw plhkcl{ flkbkchzfj hw h yfhl

gyfjkzoy#

6# Lhwzl{, Mhnhc hzzhgew hz zdf Hgdkllfw dfhl om zdf wfgvykzkqhzkoc kllvwkoc1 zdhz

zdf zyhcwhgzkoc oggvyyfj ifz~ffc zdf ioyyo~fy hcj hc vcjkwglowfj

gyfjkzoy, zdhz zdf glowkcn jogvbfczw yfmlfgzfj cocf om zdf yfhlkzkfw om zdf

yfhl zyhcwhgzkoc, hcj zdhz co hzzfbpz ~hw bhjf zo gocmoyb zo zdf zdf

yfxvkyfbfczw om zdf poolkcn hcj wfy}kgf hnyffbfcz yfnhyjkcn zdf zyhcwmfy

om zdf yfgfk}hilf, zdf cozf $mhzhll{ jfmfgzk}f hc{~h{+ hcj jffj om zyvwz

$mhzhll{ jfmfgzk}f hc{~h{+# Df wpfgkmkghll{ chbfw moy fthbplf zdhz zdf

hllfnfj hwwkncbfczw, f}fc pvzzkcn hll zdf jfmfgzw kc zdf kcwzyvbfcz kzwflm

hwkjf, kw ftfgvzfj mhy phwz zdf gvz"omm jhzf wzhzfj kc zdf poolkcn hcj

wfy}kgf hnyffbfcz# Zdkw gyfhzfw h jovilf }kolhzkoc om zdf PWH,zo ~kz1 zdhz

zdf hwwkncbfcz cffjw zo if yfgoyjfj oy kc yfgoyjhilf moyb ~kzdkc ;0 jh{w

om zdf gyfhzkoc om zdf pool, hcj zdf )hwwfz) bvwz gocwkwz om h yfhl hwwfz

bfhckcn ocf zdhz kw pfymoybkcn hcj coz kc jfmhvlz#

=# Hc{ yfhwochilf pfywoc ghc vcjfywzhcj zdhz zdf yvlfw hggfpzfj i{ zdf

kc}fwzoy"lfcjfyw ~fyf zdhz zdf{ ~ovlj if yfgfk}kcn pfymoybkcn lohcw

gobpl{kcn $hw pfy zdf PWH+~kzd kcjvwzy{ wzhcjhyj vcjfy~ykzkcn

PO IOT 8987, BHLKIV, GH ;09=6"8987

PFCJKCNLH^WVKZ@[HDOO#GOB

ZFL# 780#>8>#8>;0

Page 10: Ebert Appraisal Service Inc Office of the Real Estate Appraisers (OREA) Complaint for Appraisal Fraud

8/6/2019 Ebert Appraisal Service Inc Office of the Real Estate Appraisers (OREA) Complaint for Appraisal Fraud

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ebert-appraisal-service-inc-office-of-the-real-estate-appraisers-orea-complaint 10/32

LH^ OMMKGFW OM IHYY[ W# MHNHC

nvkjflkcfw, hcj ~kzdkc zdf zkbf pfykojw pyfwgykifj i{ zdf PWH#Ozdfy~kwf

zdf kc}fwzoy"lfcjfy dhw hj}hcgfj bocf{ moy cozdkcn, ~dkgd kw ~d{ zdf{

hyf co~ hll wvkcn zdf kc}fwzbfcz ihcew hcj COCFom zdf kc}fwzoyw kw

bhekcn hc{ glhkbw hnhkcwz zdf dobfo~cfyw5 kc mhgz zdf kc}fwzoyw hyf

hllfnkcn zdf boyznhnfw ~fyf ihj myob zdf ifnkcckcn hcj hyf

vcfcmoygfhilf# WO~f dh}f zdf hgzvhl lfcjfy hnyffkcn ~kzd zdf hgzvhl

ioyyo~fy zdhz zdf yfhl zyhcwhgzkoc kw coz zdf yfmfyfcgf pokcz om zdf glowkcn

jogvbfczw hcj zdfyfmoyf zdf glowkcn jogvbfczw hyf bfyfl{ phyz om hc

kllvwkoc om vcjfy~ykzkcn boyznhnfw hcj wfgvykzkqkcn zdfb, cfkzdfy om

~dkgd hgzvhll{ oggvyyfj#

># Zdf cftz zdkcn zo cozf kw zdhz Mhnhc mklfj h }fykmkfj gobplhkcz """ yfxvkykcn

kc Ghlkmoyckh, h }fykmkfj yfwpocwf# Zdkw pvzw zdf ozdfy wkjf hz afophyj{ moy

pfyavy{ pyowfgvzkoc ifghvwf km Mhnhc kw ykndz, hcj K hb wvyf df kw, cocf om

zdfwf phyzkfw ghc mklf h }fykmkfj yfwpocwf ~dkgd ~ovlj yfxvkyf zdf

wknchzvyf omh gobpfzfcz ~kzcfww# Hgobpfzfcz ~kzcfww kw ocf ~do zhefw

hc ohzd, dhw pfywochl eco~lfjnf zdyovnd dkw/dfy o~c wfcwfw om zdf mhgzw

oy wzhzfbfczw hllfnfj, dhw pfywochl yfgollfgzkoc om zdowf mhgzw hcj kw hilf

zo gobbvckghzf zdhz eco~lfjnf#

4# Mhnhc hlwo kcglvjfw h gobpfllkcn hynvbfcz hcj plfhjkcn moy xvkfz zkzlf

zdhz K yfgobbfcj yfhjkcn hcj vwkcn moy zdowf kc lkef wkzvhzkocw#

;# Hcj bowz kbpoyzhczl{, Mhnhc nofw hnhkc zo zdf dfhyz om zdf wfgvykzkqhzkoc

kllvwkoc, zdf mhlwkz{ omzdf pyfwfczhzkocw bhjf zo iozd kc}fwzoy"lfcjfyw

hcj dobfo~cfyw, hcj zdf bhccfy kc ~dkgd zdf )mhky bhyefz }hlvf) ~hw

kczfczkochll{ bkwwzhzfj zo avwzkm{ zdf kcmlhzkoc om zdf )}hlvf) om zdf ionvw

boyznhnf iocjw wolj zo kc}fwzoy lfcjfyw# Zdf kbpoyzhcgf om zdkw hzzhge

ghccoz if o}fywzhzfj "#" ifghvwf kz jfivcew, ocgf hcj moy hll, zdf b{zd

zdhz nyffj{ vcwgyvpvlovw ioyyo~fyw ghvwfj zdkw bfww# Kz wzhzfw

vcfxvk}oghll{ zdhz zdf }hlvf omzdf pyopfyz{ ~hw kczfczkochll{ o}fywzhzfj

zo kcjvgf Mhnhc hcj bkllkocw om ozdfy ioyyo~fyw kc boyf zdhc 40 bkllkoc

)lohc) zyhcwhgzkocw zo hwwvbf zdhz zdf }hlvf om zdf pyopfyz{ ~hw ~oyzd mhy

boyf zdhc zdf }hlvf om zdf lohc pyojvgz zdf{ ~fyf pvygdhwkcn myob zdf

boyznhnf iyoefy hcj boyznhnf oyknkchzoy# Cfkzdfy zdf kc}fwzoy"lfcjfy

coy zdf dobfo~cfy ~ovlj dh}f f}fc gocwkjfyfj zdf powwkiklkz{ om

fczfykcn kczo zdkw zyhcwhgzkoc ~kzdovz zdf }hlvf om zdf pyopfyz{ ifkcn yfhl

"""hw zdf vlzkbhzf pyozfgzkoc moy zdf kc}fwzoy"lfcjfy hcj zdf dobfo~cfy#

PO IOT 8987, BHLKIV, GH ;09=6"8987

PFCJKCNLH^WVKZ@[HDOO#GOB

ZFL# 780#>8>#8>;0

Page 11: Ebert Appraisal Service Inc Office of the Real Estate Appraisers (OREA) Complaint for Appraisal Fraud

8/6/2019 Ebert Appraisal Service Inc Office of the Real Estate Appraisers (OREA) Complaint for Appraisal Fraud

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ebert-appraisal-service-inc-office-of-the-real-estate-appraisers-orea-complaint 11/32

LH^ OMMKGFW O M IHYY[ W # MHNHC

Zdkw kw ~d{ zdf yfjvgzkoc om pykcgkphl kw co nkmz# Kzkw bfyfl{ h goyyfgzkoc

zdhz kw jvf zo IOZDzdf kc}fwzoy"lfcjfy hcj zdf ioyyo~fy#

Plfhwf mffl myff zo goczhgz bf wdovlj {ov dh}f hc{ xvfwzkocw oy gocgfycw#

Wkcgfyfl{,

Ihyy{ Mhnhc Fwx#

PO IOT 8987, BHLKIV, GH ;09=6"8987

PFCJKCNLH^WVKZ@[HDOO#GOB

ZFL# 780#>8>#8>;0

Page 12: Ebert Appraisal Service Inc Office of the Real Estate Appraisers (OREA) Complaint for Appraisal Fraud

8/6/2019 Ebert Appraisal Service Inc Office of the Real Estate Appraisers (OREA) Complaint for Appraisal Fraud

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ebert-appraisal-service-inc-office-of-the-real-estate-appraisers-orea-complaint 12/32

Fifyz Hppyh kwhl Wfy}kgf , Kcg#

~~~#fifyzhppyhkwhlw#gob

M kl f C o # >0606BH

"KWVBBHY[ HPPYHKWHL YFPOYZ

OMH

Wkcnlf Mhbkl{ Yfwkjfcgf

LOGHZFJ HZ190:>6 YOGH GDKGH JY

BHLKIV, GH ;09=6

MOY1

^fllw Mhyno Fxvkz{ Jkyfgz HQ, HV'0>:9:

88=08 C Ilhge Ghc{oc D~{ 9cj Mlooy

Pdofckt, HQ 4609;

IOYYO^FY1

IHYY[ MHNHC

HWOM1

Bh{ 8=, 900>

I[ 1

A h b f w F i f y z

~~~#fifyzhppyhkwhlw#gob

:=0> Lhef} kf~ Ghc{oc Yohj, '967, ' 78>, ^fwzlhef ]kllhnf, GH ;87=8 484#;;8#;79988484#;;8#94== mht

Page 13: Ebert Appraisal Service Inc Office of the Real Estate Appraisers (OREA) Complaint for Appraisal Fraud

8/6/2019 Ebert Appraisal Service Inc Office of the Real Estate Appraisers (OREA) Complaint for Appraisal Fraud

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ebert-appraisal-service-inc-office-of-the-real-estate-appraisers-orea-complaint 13/32

Vckmoyb Yfwkjfczkhl Hppyhkwhl Yfpoyz M k lf C o # > 0 60 6BH

Z df p vy po w f o m z dk w w vbb hy { h pp yh kw hl y fp o yz k w z o p yo } kj f z df l fc jf y/ gl kf c z ~ kz d h c h gg vy hz f, h cj h jf x vh zf l { w vp po yz fj , o p kc ko c o m z df b h ye f z } hl vf o m z df w vi af g z p yo p fy z{ #

P yo pf yz{ Hjjyf ww 90:>6 YO GH GDKGH J Y G kz{ BHLKIV Wzhzf GH Q kp Go jf ;09=6

I oyyo ~f y I HY Y[ M HN HC O .B lf y o m Pvilkg Yfgo yj M hhhc Go vcz} Lo w Hchf lf w

Lf xh l Jf wgykp zko cZyhgz 9=9=7 Lo z 70 $P lf hwf Wf f M vll Z kzlf Yf po yz+

Hwwfwwoy .wPhygf l' ::60"086"084 Zht [f hy 900= Y #F# Zhtf w * Pyo p 87

C fk dio ydo o jC hbf I ko Yo ge hyf h G kz{ o m B hlkiv B lp Y f m f yf c gf=9; "A= GfcwvwZyhgz 4006#08

O ggvphcz lTA O .B lf y a Zf chcz L a ]hghcz Wpfg kh lH wwf wwbfc z w* Cocf U RPVJ DOH* U A pf y {f hy UA pf y b oczd

P yo pf yz} Y k d zw H pp yh kw fj yt l M f f W kb pl f y l Lf hw fd ol j UlO zd fy$j fw gyk if +

H ww kx cb f cz Z{ pf L a P vyg dh wf Zyh cw hg zko c L Ta Y fmk ch cg fZ yh cw hg zk oc l a O zd fy $ jf wg yki f+ D ob f F xv kz{ L kc f o m G yf jkz

L fcjf y# g lk f c z^f l k w M h y c o FXvkz{ J kyf g z HQ, HV'0>:9: Hjjyf ww 88=08 C I lhge Ghc{o c D~} 9cj M lo o y, Pdo fc kt , HQ 4609;

K w z d f wvi af g z p y o p f y z{ gv y yf c k a{ o m m f yf j m o y wh lf o y dhw k z i f fc o m mf y f j m o y wh l f k c z d f l .B ( l }f boc z d wp y ko y 80 z d f f m mf g z k} f jh z f o m z d kw hpp yh k whl ? L a [f w LT aC o

Y fp oyz jh zk w ov ygf $w +vw fj# o mmf ykc n pykgf $w+, hc j jh zf $w +# W ovyg f1 B LW /P vilkg Y fgo yj1 W viaf gz c oz gv yyf czl{ l kw zf j# W viaf gz lhw z zyh cwmf yyf j o }f y 8 0k {f hyw hho hcj dhw co z if fc lkw zf j kc zdf phwz 7 {f hyw #

K V j kj V jkj c oz h chl{qf zdf go czyhg z mo y wh l f m o y z d f WVi af g zpv ygdhwf z y hcwhg zk o c #F tp lh k c zd f y f wv lz w o m z d f hch l{ w k w o m z d f goc zy h g z m o y wh l f o y ~ k l{ z d f hch l{ w kw~ hw co z p f y mo cbfj #

C /H

Goczyhgz Pykgf * 0 J hz f o mG o cz yh gz0 6/ 90 0> l cw pz Kw b f p yo pf yz{ w fc fy bf o ~c fy o m p vo yg yf go yo ? l ta[ fw L aC o Jh z h wgv yg f y w + CJG /BLW /PY

K w z d f y f hc{ m kc hcgk h l h w wk w zhc gf $ l o hcgdhy n f w# wh l f g ocgf ww k o c w# n k mz o y jO .B lph{bfc zh ww kw z hc gf # f zg # + 8 0if ph k ji{ hc{ph y z{ o c ifdh lm o m z d f i o y yo~ f y ? V]fw UT aC o

K m [ f w # y f p o y z zdf lO z ll j o l l hy hbovc z hcj jfwg yk i f z d f k z fbw80if ph k j# *C ocf Eco ~c

Cozf# Yhgf hcjzdf yhgkhl gobpowkzkoc oybf cfxiioyiooj hyf coz hppyhkwhl mhgzoyw#

Cf kndioy z lO<T lGdhyhgzfykwvgw Ocf "Vck zDovw k cn Z y fcjw Ocf"Vckz Dovwkcn Pyfwfczlhcj Vwf&

L o gh zk oc L a V yi hc lt W vi vyi hc L a Y vyh l P yo p f yz }] h lv f w L a lcgyfhwzcx TaW zlli lf L a Jf g lkc kcs PYKGF HN F Ocf "Vckz 800& &

Ivks"Vp Ut lO} f y > 6& K 96">6& U A Vc jf y9 6& J fb hc j,w vp pl }K Wdo yzhxf Lta Kc Ihlhcgf L a O }f y Wvpp l} *$gb + $}yw+ 9": Vc kz &

Nyo~ zd L a Yhp kj lT aW ll li lf L aW lo~ B lye fzk cX Z kb f U Uv cj fy 7 b zdw UT l A#= bzdw 8 Uo }f y f b bw >60 Lo~ C f~ BAl z k " Mhbk l &

C f kndio ydo o jIovcjhykf w Bh lkiv hyf h iovcjhykf w hyf go cw kjf yf j zo if Whczh B oc kgh Bo vczh kcw 6000 D ko d 46 Gobbfyg kh l &

K $C +, Zo phcnh Ghc{o c Io vlf }hyj $F+, Phgkmkg Ogfhc $W+, ]f czvyh Go vcz{ l kcf $^ +# 8400 Pyfj # 96 Ozdfy &

C fkndio ydo o jJf wgykp zko c Wviaf gz lo ghzf j kc I kn Yo ge hyf h , ~ kzdkc zdf G kz{ o m Bh lkiv hppyo t kb hzf l{ 6 b klf w f hwz o m G kz{ Gf czf y# Wvi af gz kwlo ghzf j vp kc zdf mo o zd k llw o c h yf wkjf c zkh l wzyf f z, hb ocn w kb klh y w kcn lf "mhb kl{ pyo pf yzkf w # P yo pf yzkf w yhcnf myob b kj"w kqf j wkcnlf w zo y{

dob fw zo lhyxfy f wzh zf pyo pf yzkf w# H ll yf wkjf czkh l wvppo yz mhg kl k zkf w hyf lo ghzf j cf hyi{ hlo cn hyzf ykhlw#

B lyk<f z Go cj kzko cw Oc glv jkc nwv ppo yz mo y zdf hi o}f g oc glv wko cw+ H pp yh kw fy.w e co ~lf jh f o m hyf h kw f tzf cwk}f , hc j ~ fll w vp po yzf j i} B LW - g o b p hy hi lf w

vwf j kc zd kw yf po yz# P yo pf yz{ }h lvf w dh}f if fc bhkczh kckcn }hlvf o }f y zdf phwz {f hy, h mzf y zd yf f {f hyw o m 80"90& nh kcw # Z{p kgh l

b hyef zkch zkbf w yhchf myob 7 " ; bo czdw# C o wh lf w o y mkchcgkch go cgf wwko cw co zf j . mktf j - hj avwzhilf yhzf b oyzo ho fw hyf h}h klhi lf ,

J kb fc wko cw Kyyf nvlhy $P lf hw f w ff p lh z b hp+ Hyfh 8987=/89E Vwhi lf Wdho f Kyyf hv lhy ] kf~ Ogf hc, G kz{ Lkzf w

Wpfg k m kgQoc kcnG lhww k m kgh z koc LGY890000 . Q o c kc xJ f w g yk pz ko cBh k ki v " Y f w kj f c zk h l

Q o ck cn G o b pl kh cg f L ta L f nh l L aL fn hl C o cg oc mo cb kc n$N yh cj mh zd fyf jV wf + l aC o Q oc kc n l a Kl lf nh l $j fW Gyki f+

K w z d f d k ndf w z hcj ifw z v wf o m z d f wvi af g z p y o p f y z{h w kbp yo }fj $ o y h w p y o p o wfjpf y p l h cwhcj wpf g km kg h zk o c w +zdf pyf wfc z vwf ? lTA]f w VC o Km C o# jf wgykif # C ocf

Vzklkzkfw Pvilkg Ozdf y $ j f wg y ki f + Pvilkg Ozdf y $ j f wgy k if + Omm"wkzf lboyo}fbfczw" Z{pf Pvilkg Pyk}hzh

Flfgzy kgkz{ UY A UR ^hzfy Lt a a W z yf f z H wpdhl z lT A L a

Nh w LA LT R Pygphcf/Z}pkghl Whc kz ly { W f~ f y L A TA Wfpzkg Z{p kghl Hllf { C ocf L A L AM FmKB Wof gkh l M lo o j DhqhyjHyf h y l}f w yT lC O M FmKB M lo o j Qocf G M FmKB Blo ' 0=0>:6 " 0>4> G MF m KB B lo Jh zf 88 /86 /8;46

H yf z df v zk lk zk f w h c j o m m" wy zh kb p yo } fb f cz wz }P k gh l mo y z d f bh yk < fz hy f h? L t a} f w l a C o K m C o , j f wg y k if #

H yf z df y f h c { h j } f yw f w k zf g o c jk zk o cw o y f t zfbh l m hg zo y w $ f h wfb f c zw ,f c gy o hg dbf c zw ,f c } ky o cb f c zl ll g o c j kz ko c w ,l hc j v w f w , f z g# +? V ] f w l TA C o K K [ f w , j f wg yk if # C o h j }f y wf

wkzf gocjkzko cw o y hj}f ywf fhwfb fczw hyf eco~c o y o iwf y}f j, C o jf f j o y zkzlf yf po yz ~hw pyo }kjfj zo jf zf cc kcf hc{ vceco~c o yvchpphyf cz f hwfb fczw# P lf hwf yf mf y zo mv l l zkzlf yf po yz#

NFC FYHLJFWGYKPZKOC MOVC JHZKOC FTZFYKOYJFWGYKPZKOC bhzf y kh lwH 1ocp k z koc KCZFYKOY ychzfchlw#gocgkz koc

V ckzw Uk lO cf U A Ocf } # kz dH ggf wwo y {Vc k z " Rg o cg yf zf W lh i K tl G yh }# 8W o hg f Movcjhz koc^hl lw Gocgyf zf I le M loo yw Dj~j/Gpz ]Nj

' o mW lOy kfw 8 A M v ll Ihwfbf cz L a Phyzkh l Ihwfbf cz Ftzf yko y^ hDw Wzvggo ^hllw P lhwzf y ]Nj

Z{pf UT RJf z U AH zz U AW "Jf zmcj Vc5 Ihwfbf czH yf h 0 wx#mz# Yo o mWvymvgf Gobpow kzko c Zykb #mkckwd Dhyj~oo j ]Nj

ltlFtkw zkch U UP yo co wf j U lvcjf y go cwz Ihwf bf czM kc kwd C/H & N vzzf yw - Jo~cwco vzwHjfhvhzf Ihzd M lo o y W zo cf ]Nj

Jf wknc $W z{lf + Zyhjkzko chl aOvzwkjf Fc ll{ ,§t kz l awvbp Pvbp ^ kcjo~ Z{pf ]c l G lhj H lvb Ihzd ^hkcwgo z W zo cf ]Nj

[f hy Iv klz 8;== F} kjf cgf o m L a K cmf wzh zko c W zo yb WhwdHcwv lhzf j C o W zo yb C ff jfj Ghy Wzo yhgf lA CocfFzyf gzl}f HXf $\.yw+6 "80 R Jhbpcf ww U R Wf cAf bf cz Wgyffcw Pyf wfcz tA Jyk}f ~h{ ' 08 Ghyw 7

Hzz kg C o c f Df hzkcn lTAM^H KL aD^IIK L aYhjkhcz Hb fc kzkf w ^ oo jW lO}f $w+' Jy k}f~h{Wvy mhgfGocgyf zf /W zocf

lJ yo f W k ll k y Wzhkyw 8 Ozdfy K M v f l P y o ph c f tl M k yf l hg f $w +' 8 T M f cgf ^o o j t l N hyh hf ' om Ghyw 9

aM loo y T WgvV lf Goo l kcn 8AG fc zy h l H k yG ocj k z ko c k c n TA Ph z koH Af ge T POyzd J fge aGhypo yz Do lfhyw

aM kc kwdfj Dfhzfj a K cj k }k jv h l K L a O zd f y ApOOK Ozdfy TAHzz lJf z U a Ivklzsc

Hpp l khcgfw U 8 Y fbf f yh lJ y K T A YhcffJ }fc T l J kwd~hwdf y UT l J kwpo wh l KT l B gyo ~h}f U 8 ^hwd f y# 8l y} f y K 8 Ozdfy $jfwgy kif +M k c k wd fjh y fhhio}f x y hjf goc zh k c w1 ; Yo obw 7 If jyo obw 7 I hz d$ w+ 9 ,= 0 = W x vh yf M f f z o m N yo w w L k }k ch H y f h H i o }f N y hj f

H jj kzko chl mf hzvyf w $w pf gkh lf cf yn {f mmkg kf czyzh bw , fzg#+, D knd l{ vp nyhj fj o gf hc } kf ~ yh cgd 1 O }f y * 960 ,00 0 kc yf bo jf lkc n, c f~ ekzg df c, dh yj ~o ojmlo oykcn , b ovlj kc nw, lh cj wg hp kcn - f tzf yko y lkndzkcn , hygd kzf gzv yhl n lhww phcf lf j jo o yw, yfbo jf lf j ihzd go ppf y p lvbi kcn , f zg#

c f wgc zf z d f gocj k z ko c o m zdf p yo p fy z{ $ kc jv jk cn c f fj f j yf p hk yw # jf zf yk o yh zk oc , yf c o} hz ko c w# yf b o jf lk cn #f zg #+ # C o p d{ wk gh l m vc gz ko c hl o y f t zf b hl k ch jf h vh gk fw c o zf j #

Zdf wvikf gz hppfhyw zo if kc }fzµ ho oj go cjkzko c# O zdf y vooyhjfw kcglvjf 1 C f~ yo om, go ppf y gvzzfyw hcj jo ~cwpovzw bhyi lf govczf yw,

cf ~ dhcj zyo ~f llf j wbo o zd w zvggo f tzf yko y, kc zf yko y mkc kwdfj ~ kzd iv llco wfj go ycf yw yf gf wwfj lknd zkcn, cf ~ ghi kcf zw , nyhc kzf go vczf yw

wlhzf zk lf po ygd, jyk}f ~h{, ~h lew, hcj f tzf yko y dhyjwgho kco #

H yf zdf yf hc{ pd{w kgh ljf m kg kfcjfw oy hj}fywfgo cj k z kocw zdh z h m mfg z zdf l k}hi kl k ( +. , wovcjcfww,o y wzyvgbyhl Kc zfn l k( + . o m zdf pyopfy z{? J}fw UY lC o K m } f w , j f wg lk i f #

Jofwzdf pyopfyz{ nfcfyhll{ goymoyb zo zdf cfkndiobooj $mvcgzkochl vzl8m ,wz{lf, gocjkzkoc, vwf, gocwzyvgzkoc, fzK1#+? lT A [fw VCo Km Co, jfwgykif#

myfjjkf Bzg Moyb >0Bvgd 9(T6 m f c c f m}^ m o y b 8G0: y # # c c 9 K 1 1 V k

8 $ + . + : # _ 0 6 G F 9 0 G =

Page 14: Ebert Appraisal Service Inc Office of the Real Estate Appraisers (OREA) Complaint for Appraisal Fraud

8/6/2019 Ebert Appraisal Service Inc Office of the Real Estate Appraisers (OREA) Complaint for Appraisal Fraud

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ebert-appraisal-service-inc-office-of-the-real-estate-appraisers-orea-complaint 14/32

Vckmoyb Yfwkjfczkhl Hppyhkwhl Yfpoyz M k lf C o # > 0 60 6BH

Zdf y fh y f 7 goboh y hil f o y o o f y z kf w gv y yf c z l} o m m f y f j m o y wh l f k c z d f woi k f gz c f k h dio y dhoj y hch k ch k c ocgf m yob * 8 =60 ,000 zo * 9 ,7 :; 00 0

Zdf y fh y f 4 gobph yhi l f whl f w k c z d f wvi .f g z c f k h dio yd o oj # #5 zd k c z d f cf w z z~ f l } fboc z d w y hc k ch k c wh l f o cgf m yob * 8 :8 0 000 zo * 7>60000

MFHZVYF K WVIAFGZ GOB .HYHILF WHLF C O#8 GOB .HYHILF WHLF C O#9 GOB .HYHILF WHLF C O#7

90:>6 YOGH GDKGH JY 909:7 P kf jyh Gd kgh Yo hj 90468 I kn Yo ge Jyk}f 90:>0 Yo {h l W zo cf Jyk}f

H j jy f ww BH L KI V HPC 1 ::60"087"0=4 HPC 1 :::;"08="00= H PC 1 : :6 0" 08 6" 09 8

Pyo t kb kz{ zo Wvi af g z 0 #90 B K F 0#:6 B K C ^ 0#0: B K C C F

Wh lf Py kgf * 0 8* 84>6,000 8* 7,>60,000 d 8:80000

Wh lfPy zgf ,Nyoww k l k #H ych * 0 #0 0 W X# z# * >86#;9 WX# z#8 *8,944#== WX# z#8 * 6 >0#7 ; w o# mz#8

Jhzh Wo vygf $w+ Kcwpf gzko c BLWmPvi lkg Yf go yj K cW m+ fg zk oc lB L W lP v il kg Y f go yj B LW mP vi lkg Y fg oyj

]fy k m kgh z kocWovygf$w+ Kcwofgz koc JoG' ;9:440 JoG' 8 0;4=48 Jog' 9>;77==

] HLV FH JA VW ZKl lF CZW J FW GY KP ZKO C JFWGYKPZKOC %+WBvwzcfcz JFWGYKPZKOC ¥#+ * ..._fcz JFWGYKPZKOC %$"+*Bvwzbfcz

Whlf oy M kchcg kcn C ocf Eco~c Go c}f czko ch l C o lw zZJ Goc}fczko chl

Gocgfww kocw C o 8wz ZJ kc mo Kc mo yb hzko c h}f c *8,894,000 8wz

Jhzfo mWh lf l ykbf 06/900> lcwpz 0:/84/900> G lo wf j 06/0> /900> Pf cj kch 89/86 /900= G lo wf j

Loghz koc ]f y{ No oj ]f y{ N o o j Wvo f yko y "900,000 ]f y{ No oj

z f h wfco k g% f f W kbp lf M ff W kb plf M f f W kbp lf M f f W kbp lf M ff W kb olf

Wkzf 8987=/89E Vwi lf 848>4/4 E Vwf :0,000 9=6=>/90E Vw f "40,000 80>8=/6000 >0,000

] kf~ Ogfhc, G kz} Lkzf w W kb klh y Wvo /Phco Ogfhc "900000 Kc m/Ogf hc 800,000

Jfw knc$W z{ lf + Zyhjkz kochl Zyhjkz kochl H ygdkzf g zvyh l "900,000 W kbk lh y

Xvh l k z {o m Gocwz yvG zkoc No o j No o j No oj No o j

HGVAhl o f 8;== 8;== 8;;6 8;>7

Go cjkzko c ]f y}N oo j W K Kc mf yko y 860,000 Wvof yko y "700,000 Kcmf yko y/M ktf y 700000

Hio}fNy hjf Zozh l KIjccwA I h . ) ZOkh KI j c c w a I h # , w Z087KI j c c w # l I h 8 d w 96000 ZOKh KI j c c w a # I h 8 d w

YoobGovc z 48 :8 7 48 :8 7 >8 78 7 48 :8 9 96000

NyowwV}kchHych 800 9,=0= WX# mz# 9,=8; wo # mz# 0 9;80 WX# mz# "70:00 9:>9 wo #mz 87,:00

Ihwfbfc z- M kc kwdfj Cocf C o cf C o cf C o cf

Yo obw If lo~Nyhjf C ocf C o c f C o cf C o cf

MvcGzkochlVz k l k z{ N o o j Noo j No o j No o j

Dfhz kcn ,goo lD lO MHV /C ocf M HV/C o cf M HV/Gfczyhl "6000 M HV/Gfczyhl"6000

F cf yX [Fmmkgkf cz Kzf bw C o cf C o zf j C ocf C ozf j C o cf C o zf j C o cf C o zf j

Nhyhnf ,ghypo yz 9 Ghy Nhyhnf 9 Ghy N hyhhf 9 Ghy N hyhnf 9 Ghy N hyhnf

Po ygdH .h zko H lf ge Po ygd , Phzko Jfge Wkbklhy W kb klh y W kb klh y

E kzgdf c C f~f y Vojhzf j Wllcmfy koy 96 ,000 Wvo /No vybf z "60000 Kcmf yko y 60,000

Po o l Wph C o Po o l, C o Wo h C o P o o l C o W o h Po o l, Wo h "60 ,000 Wo h, C o Po o l "6,000

M kyf p lhgf $w+ 8 M kyf plhgf 8 M k yf p lh g f 8 M kyf o lhgf 8 M kyf o lhgf

Cf z Hj avw zbfcz $ mh zh l + Utl% yk 8* 986000 yl% ytl" 8* 80;0:00 ytl% U l" 8* 6:4:00

Hjavw zfjWh lf Py kgf C f zH ja# 8 8# 6s K C f zH ja# "9; #8 s K C f z H ja # 7 4# ;o /s Ko m G obph yhi l f w N y o wwB # 88 #60 /#& * 9 0; 0,0 00 N yo ww B#7 0#: 0/#& * 9= 6;= 00 N yo wwB #:0 #7o /I i * 8;64:00

K 00 jk j 0 j k jc o z y f w fh ygd z df wh lf o y z yh c w yf y d kW zo y { o m z d f wvi af g z p y o p f y z{hcj gobph yhi l f whl f w # K m c o z f tp l hk c

# B z yfwfhygd L A jkj Ut A j kj c oz y f} fh l h c{ p yk oy w hl fw o y zy hc wmf yw o m zd f w vi kf gz o yo o f yz} mo y zd f zd yf f { f hy w o yk oy zo z df f mm fg zk }f j h zf o m z dk w h c oy hk wh L

J hzh w o vyg f$w + B LW /P vi lk g Y fg oyj

B{ y f w fh ygd U A j kj U T j kj c o zy f }f h l h c } o c g y w h lf w o y c h cw yf y w o m z d f g ob o hy hi lf w h lf w m o y z d f { f h y o yk o y z o z d f j h zf o m w h l f o m z df g ob o hy hi lf w h lf #

J hzh wo vyg fzw + B LW /P vi lk g Y fg oyj

Y fpo y z zd f y f wv lz w o m z d f y f w fh ygdhcjhch l } w kw o m z d f p y ko y wh l f o y z yh c w mf y d k w z o y{ o m z d f wvi kf g z p yo p f y z} hcjgob h y hi l f wh l f w $ yf o o y z h jj k zk o ch lpy koy

w h lf w o c o h o f 7 + #KZFB WVIAFGZ GO B.HYHILF W HLF CO #8 GO B.HYHILF W HLF CO #9 GOB .HYHILF WHLFCO#7

Jhzf 08P y k o y Whlf lmyhcwmf y C o Wh lf Kc O}f y C o o yf }ko vw wh lf kc 8% }yw C o o yf }ko vw wh lf kc 8% }yw C o o yf }ko vw wh lf kc 8% }yw

Py kgf 08 Py ko yWh lf l m yhcwmf y 7 [ fh yw C /H C /H C /H

Jhzh Wo vygf $w+ B LWmPvilkg Yf go yj BLW/Pvilkg Yfgo yj BLW/Pvi lkg Yfgo yj BLWmPvilkg Yfgo yj

Fmmf gzk}f Jhzf o y o h zh Wovygf zw+ 06/86/900> 06/86 /900> 06/86 /900> 06/86 /900>

Hch l{ w kw o m p y o y wh l f o y z yh c w mf y d k w z o y{ 08 zd f wvi af gz pyo pf yz{ hcj go bphyhi lf whlf w. Wvikf gz co z gvyyf czl} lkw zf j# Wvi kf gz lhw z zyhcwmf yyf j o }f y 80 }f hyw hno

hcj dhw co z if f c lkwzf j kc zdf phwz 7 }f hyw # Gobo hyhi lf '9 , 90468 I ko Yo ge Jyk}f ~hw ho o yh kwf j i} zd kw Ho o yh kwf y o c :/87/900> mo y h

Pvygdhwf zyhcwhgzko c h z h Goczyhg zf j Wh lf Pykgf o m *7 ,>60,000 $ Pyk}hzf - Gocmkjfcz khl l# ^ d klf Pvi lkg Yf go yj jo f w co z yf mlf gz zdf whlf

8o ykgf o m zd kw zyhcwhgzko c kz kw yf hwo chilf zo if lkf }f zdh z zd kw kw hc hggvyhzf whlf o ykgf #

Wvbbhy{ o m Whl fw Gobph yk woc Hpp yohgd# Wvikf gz kw gobphzkilf zo zdf cf ko dio ydo o j kc zf ybw o m w kqf , go cjkzko c , hvh lkz)) hcj hco f hl, P lf hwf wf f

hjj kzko ch l gobo hyhi lf w hcj zdf hjjf cjvb gobbf czw# C o zf zdh z wob f hj kvw zb fczw f tgf fj o yf mf yyf j lf }f lw jvf zo zdf ~ kjf yhco f o m

Kpyo pf yzkf w hcj lhge o m wkb klhy gobphyhi lf w kc zdf hyf h# Zd kw jo f w co z f mmf g z zdf }f yhgkz} o m zdf mkchl f wzkb hzf j bhyef z }h lvf #

K c jk gh zf j]h l v fi} Wh l f w gobohcwocHpp y ohgd * 9800000

K cjk gh zf j ]h l vf i{1 Wh l f wG oboh y k w o c Hooyohgc * 9 ,8 0 0 ,0 0 0 N o w zH o o yo h g d O m jf } f lo o f j + * 9 8;0 700 Kcgobf Hooyohgc O m jf}fl opfj+ *

Zdf go wz hppyohgd n k}f c co ~f knd z jvf zo jkmmkgvlzkf w kc hggvyhzf l} jf zf yb kc kcn jfpyf gkhzko c hcj lhcj }h lvf w# Zdf kcgobf ho o yo hgd co z

vwf j jvf zo l kb kzf j wh lf w o m wkb klh y yf c zhl cyopfyzkfw cf f jf j mo y jf zf yb kckch h NYB # Bhyef z ho o yo hgd h k}f c b o wz ~f ko d (#

Zd k whpp y hk wh l kw bhjf lT A )hw kw , ) Vvi af f z z o g obp l f zk o cp f y p l h c whcj wpf g km k gh z ko c woc z d f ihw kw 08 h d{po zd f z kg h l g o cjk zk o c z dh z z d f kbp yo }fbfc z wdh}fif fc gobp l f zf j ,

o wvi af f z z h z d f m o l lo ) 5c ; y f ph ky w o y h l zf y h zk o c woc z d f ihw kw 08 h d{po zd f z kg h l g o cjk zk o c z dh z z d f y f ph ky w o y h l zf y h zk o c wdh}fif fc gobp l f zf j , o y 0vi af f z z h z d f m o l lo ) 5 c; y f xv ky f j

k cw pf g zk oc i h wf j o c z d f f t zy ho yj kc hy{ hw wv b pzk o c zd hz z d f g o c jk zk oc o y j f mk gk fc g{ j o fw c o z y f xv ky f h lzf yh zk oc o y y fp hk y# C o g o cj kz ko c w# Z dk w h o oy hk wh l y fo o yz k w k cz fc jf j

mo y g lkf cz/lf cjf y/o y zdf ky hwwkccf f w mo y vwf oc l} kc h bo yzchcf /mkchcgf zyhcwhgzko c # Zdkw yf co yz co z kc zf cjf j mo y hc} o zdf y vwf #

Ihwfj O c h g o bp lf zf } kw vh l k cw pf g zk oc o mzc f k cz fy ko y h cj f t zf yk o y h yf h w o mz cf w vi af g z p yo p fy z{ , j f mk cf j w go p f o ml l# Oy e, w zh zh b fc zo m h ww vb p zk o cw h cj l kb kz kc n

gocjkzkocw, hcj hppyhkwfy.w gfyzkmkghzkoc, b{ $ovy+ opkckoc om zdf bhyefz }hlvf, hw jfmkcfj, om zdf yfhl pyopfyz{ zdhz kw zdf wviafgz om zdkw yfpoyz kw * 9,800,000

hw o m Bh{ 8= 900> ,^lkgd kwzdf jhzfomkcwcfgzkoc hcjzdf fmmfgzk}f jhzfom zdkw hccyhkwhl,

Myfjjkf B 1 z g Mo yb >0Bz zz k l M h cc kf ^ w f M o yb

Page 15: Ebert Appraisal Service Inc Office of the Real Estate Appraisers (OREA) Complaint for Appraisal Fraud

8/6/2019 Ebert Appraisal Service Inc Office of the Real Estate Appraisers (OREA) Complaint for Appraisal Fraud

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ebert-appraisal-service-inc-office-of-the-real-estate-appraisers-orea-complaint 15/32

Vckmoyb Yfwkjfczkhl Hppyhkwhl Yfpoyz M k lf C o # > 06 06BH

Plf hwf Wf f Hjjf cjvb

G OW Z H PP YO HG D ZO ] HLV F $co z yf xvkyf j i{ M hc ckf B hf +

Pyo} kjfhjfxvh zf kc m occh z koc m o y zdf lfcjf y ,z l k fc z 8Jyfp l k gh zf zdf if lo~ gow z m k ov yfw hcj gh lgvlh z kocw #

W vp po yz m o y z df o pk ck oc o m w kz f } h lv f $ wv bb hy{ o m g o b ph yh il f lh cj w h lf w o y o z df y b f zd o jw m o y f w zk bh zk cn w k zf } hl vf + W kzf } hl vf w j fzf c ck cf j i { f tz yh gz ko c# G o wzw h yf

ihwf j o c z{p kgh l bhyef z pf ygf p zko c o m }h lvf hcj hvxycfczfj i{ Ivkljkcx"Gowz#cfz hcj o zdf y z{p kgh l bhyef z b fzdo jo lo x}#

F WZKB KZF J ltA Y FP YO JV GZKO CO Y U R Y F PL HG F (K# §C Z GO W Z C F^ OP KC KOCOM W K ZF]HLVF # ################# #### , #### 2 * 8,960,000

Wo vygf om go wz jhzh Bhyef z jhzh lo ghl go czyhgzo yw, Ivk lj kcn"G o wz#cf z J~f ll kcn 9,=0= Wx# M z @ * 960#00 ## ######### " * =68 600

Xvhlkz{ yhzkcn myob go wz wf y}kgf F(mf yc}f jhzf o m go wz jhzh Wx# M z @ * # # # # 2 *

Gobbfc zw oc Gow z Hpp yohgd $h y oww l k } kchh y fh gh lGV lh zk ocw #jfp y fg kh zk oc #f z g # +

Pd{wkgh l jf pyf gkhzko c ghlgv lhzf j }kh zdf hgf /lk mf b f zdo j# Go wz Nhyho f #Ghypo yz 64: Wo # M z @ * 66#00# #### ### # 2 * 79,890

f wzkb hzf w ihwf j o c zdf eco~ lf jo f o m h yf h ivk lj lco go wzw - Zo zh l Fw z kbhzfh mGow z "Cf~ ####### #### 2 * =47=90

Ivklj kch"G o wz#cf z# Lhcj }hlvf jf zf yb kcf j zdyo vhd f tzyhgzko c# W kzf Lf ww >6 P d {w kg hl R M v c gz ko c hl R Ftzfychl

}h lvf zo kb pyo }f bfczw yhzko kw xyfhzfy zdhc co cchl mo y zd kw mv l l{ J f pyf gkhzko c *=4,7=9 K K 2 *$ =4,7=9

jf }f lo pf j hyf h ~dkgd dhw o yf hzf y zdhc z}p kgh l lhcj }h lvf w# Jfp y fg kh zfjG ow z o m Kbp yo}fbfc zw # # # # # # # # # # # ######## 2 * =86,964

M vcgzko chl hj avwzb f czw bh{ yf mlf gz j kwgo vczf j }hlvf w o k}f c i} )Hw"kw) ]hlvf o m Wkzf Kb pyo }f bfczw ##### ###### # ## # 2 * >6,000

bhyef z zo po o l, wph, hcj wkb klhy hbfc kzkf w# Ivkljf yw/Jf }f lo pf yw Kcgf czk}f 960,000

Fw m kbh zhj Yfbh kc kcXFgocob kg Lkmf $ DVJhcj]H cc l} + > 0 ] f hy w K CJ KG HZFJ]HLVFI] GOWZ HPPYOHGD # ##### ##### ####### " * 9 8;0 700

KC G O K] F H PP Y OH G D Z O ] HL VF $ co zy fx vk yf j i{ M hc ck f B hf +

Fw zkb h zf j Bb z dl { B l ye f z Y f c z * T N yo w w Y f c zB A lz k l kf y 2* C/ H K cj kgh z fj]h lvf i{ KcgobfHpp yohgd

Wvbbh y{ o m K cg obfHpp y o hg d Oc g lv j kc nw v pp o y z m o y bh ye f z y f c z h c j NYB+

P YO AF GZ K C MO Y m] \l \Z KO C M O Y P VJ w $k mh pp lk xl il f+

K w z df j f} fl op fy# iv kl jf y k c g oc zy ol o m zd f D ob f o~ cf yw . H ww og kh zk oc $ DO H+ ? L a[fw L AC o Vckz z{pf$w+ L aJfzhgdfj L aHz zhgdfj

P y o }k j f z df m o ll o } #k c h k cm o c ch z ko c m o y PVJwOC L[ k m zdf j f } f lo p f y ,o v k lj f y k w k c g o c zy o l o m z df DOH hcj z d f w v o lf g z p y o p f yz { k w h c h z zh g df j j~f l lk cXvc kz

L f n h l c hbf o m p y o af g z

Zo zh l cvbif y o m pdhwf w Zo zh l cvbif y o m vckzw Zo zh l cvbif y o m vckzw wo lj

Z ozh l c vb if y o m v ck zw yf cz fj Zo zh l cvbif y o m vckzw mo y wh lf Jhzh wo v ygf $w+

^h w z d f p yo a f g z g yf h zf j i { z d f g o c }f y wk o c o m h c f t k wz kc x i v k l jk c x$ w+ k c 8Jh PVJ? L A [ fw L a C o K m [ f w , j hz f o m g o c} f yw ko c#

Jo f w zdf p yo af gz g o czh kc h c{ b vlzD 8~ fl lk cXv ckzw ? UA [f w UA C O J hzh w o vyg f$w +

Hy f zdf vc k zw , gobboc f lfbfc zw ,hcj y fg y fh zk oc mhg kl k zk f w gobp lf z f? V[f w VC o K m Co , j f w gc i f z d f w zh z vw o m g obp lf z ko c #

H yf z df g obboc fl fbfcz w lf hw fj z o o y i { z df Dobfo~cfy w. H wwo gk hz koc ? V]f w VC o K m [ f w# j fw gy ki f z df yf cz hl z fy bw h cj o pz ko cw #

Jfwg y kif gobboc f lfbfc zw hcj yfg y fh zk och l m hg k l k zk f w #

Pyol^1 lj vwd5l HG z w o m K ~ h b # 0 G T l 9 # 7 : # 4 > 9 > . l C C y .8 K G K . B ( i #o 1 bPhnf7om=

Mhcczf m} .f # fy fb lOO:B1b1# dhb800z_06XFk9;A5+

Page 16: Ebert Appraisal Service Inc Office of the Real Estate Appraisers (OREA) Complaint for Appraisal Fraud

8/6/2019 Ebert Appraisal Service Inc Office of the Real Estate Appraisers (OREA) Complaint for Appraisal Fraud

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ebert-appraisal-service-inc-office-of-the-real-estate-appraisers-orea-complaint 16/32

113VBBHE[ Hz".z".EHK113HL Ez1z".VE K

Vckmoyb Yfwkjfczkhl Hppyhkwhl Yfpoyz MklfCo# >0606BH

HPPYHKWFY.W GFYZKMKGHZKOC1 Zdf Hppyhkwfy gfyzkmkfw hcj hnyffw zdhz1

8# K dh}f, hz h bkckbvb, jf}flopfj hcj yfpoyzfj zdkw hppyhkwhl kc hggoyjhcgf ~kzd zdf wgopf om ~oye yfxvkyfbfczw wzhzfj kc zdkw

hppyhkwhl yfpoyz#

9# K pfymoybfj h gobplfzf }kwvhl kcwpfgzkoc om zdf kczfykoy hcj ftzfykoy hyfhw om zdf wviafgz pyopfyz{# K yfpoyzfj zdf gocjkzkoc om

zdf kbpyo}fbfczw kc mhgzvhl, wpfgkmkg zfybw# K kjfczkmkfj hcj yfpoyzfj zdf pd{wkghl jfmkgkfcgkfw zdhz govlj hmmfgz zdf lk}hiklkz{,

wovcjcfww, oy wzyvgzvyhl kczfnykz{ om zdf pyopfyz{#

7# K pfymoybfj zdkw hppyhkwhl kc hggoyjhcgf ~kzd zdf yfxvkyfbfczw om zdf Vckmoyb Wzhcjhyjw om Pyomfwwkochl Hppyhkwhl Pyhgzkgf

zdhz ~fyf hjopzfj hcj pyobvlnhzfj i{ zdf Hppyhkwhl Wzhcjhyjw Iohyj om Zdf Hppyhkwhl Movcjhzkoc hcj zdhz ~fyf kc plhgf hz zdfzkbf zdkw hppyhkwhl yfpoyz ~hw pyfphyfj#

:# K jf}flopfj b{opkckoc om zdf bhyefz }hlvf om zdf yfhl pyopfyz{ zdhz kwzdf wviafgz om zdkw yfpoyz ihwfj oc zdf whlfw gobphykwoc

hppyohgd zo }hlvf# K dh}f hjfxvhzf gobphyhilf bhyefz jhzh zo jf}flop h yflkhilf whlfw gobphykwoc hppyohgd moy zdkw hppyhkwhl

hwwkncbfcz# Kmvyzdfy gfyzkm{ zdhz K gocwkjfyfj zdf gowz hcj kcgobf hppyohgdfw zo }hlvf ivz jkj coz jf}flop zdfb, vclfww ozdfy~kwf

kcjkghzfj kc zdkw yfpoyz#

6# K yfwfhygdfj, }fykmkfj, hchl{qfj, hcj yfpoyzfj oc hc{ gvyyfcz hnyffbfcz moy whlf moy zdf wviafgz pyopfyz{, hc{ ommfykcn moy whlf

om zdf wviafgz pyopfyz{ kc zdf z~fl}f boczdw pykoy zo zdf fmmfgzk}f jhzf om zdkw hppyhkwhl, hcj zdf pykoy whlfw om zdf wviafgz pyopfyz{moy h bkckbvb om zdyff {fhyw pykoy zo zdf fmmfgzk}f jhzf om zdkw hppyhkwhl, vclfww ozdfy~kwf kcjkghzfj kc zdkw yfpoyz#

=# K yfwfhygdfj, }fykm kfj, hchl{qfj, hcj yfpoyzfj oc zdf pykoy whlfw om zdf gobphyhilf whlfw moy h bkckbvb om ocf {fhy pykoy zo zdf

jhzf om whlf om zdf gobphyhilf whlf, vclfww ozdfy~kwf kcjkghzfj kc zdkw yfpoyz#

># K wflfgzfj hcj vwfj gobphyhilf whlfw zdhz hyf loghzkochll{, pd{wkghll{, hcj mvcgzkochll{ zdf bowz wkbklhy zo zdf wviafgz pyopfyz{#

4# K dh}f coz vwfj gobphyhilf whlfw zdhz ~fyf zdf yfwvlz om gobikckcn h lhcj whlf ~kzd zdf goczyhgz pvygdhwf pykgf om h dobf

zdhz dhw iffc ivklz oy ~kl l if ivklz oc zdf lhcj#

n# K dh}f yfpoyzfj hjavwzbfczw zo zdf gobphyhilf whlfw zdhz yfmlfgz zdf bhyefz.w yfhgzkoc zo zdf jkmmfyfcgfw ifz~ffc zdf wviafgz

pyopfyz{ hcj zdf gobphyhilf whlfw#

80# K }fykmkfj, myob h jkwkczfyfwzfj wovygf, hll kcmoybhzkoc kc zdkw yfpoyz zdhz ~hw pyo}kjfj i{ phyzkfw ~do dh}f h mkchcgkhl kczfyfwz kc

zdf whlf oy mkchcgkcn om zdf wviafgz pyopfyz{#

88# K dh}f eco~lfjnf hcj ftpfykfcgf kc hppyhkwkcn zdkw z{pf om pyopfyz{ kc zdkw bhyefz hyfh#

89# K hb h~hyf om, hcj dh}f hggfww zo, zdf cfgfwwhy{ hcj hppyopykhzf pvilkg hcj pyk}hzf jhzh wovygfw, wvgd hw bVlzkplflkwzkcn

wfy}kgfw, zht hwwfwwbfcz yfgoyjw, pvilkg lhcj yfgoyjw hcj ozdfy wvgd jhzh wovygfw moy zdf hyfh kc ~dkgd zdf pyopfyz{ kw loghzfj#

87# K oizhkcfj zdf kcmoybhzkoc, fwzkbhzfw, hcj opkckocw mvyckwdfj i{ ozdfy phyzkfw hcj ftpyfwwfj kc zdkw hppyhkwhl yfpoyz myob

yflkhilf wovygfw zdhz K iflkf}f zo if zyvf hcj goyyfgz#

8:# K dh}f zhefc kczo gocwkjfyhzkoc zdf mhgzoyw zdhz dh}f hc kbphgz oc }hlvf ~kzd yfwpfgz zo zdf wviafgz cfkndioydooj, wviafgz

pyopfyz{, hcj zdf pyotkbkz{ om zdf wviafgz pyopfyz{ zo hj}fywf kcmlvfcgfw kc zdf jf}flopbfcz om b{ opkckoc om bhyefz }hlvf# K dh}f

cozfj kc zdkw hppyhkwhl yfpoyz hc{ hj}fywf gocjkzkocw $wvgd hw, ivz coz lkbkzfj zo, cffjfj yfphkyw, jfzfykoyhzkoc, zdf pyfwfcgf om

dhqhyjovw ~hwzfw, zotkg wviwzhcgfw, hj}fywf fc}kyocbfczhl gocjkzkocw, fzg#+ oiwfy}fj jvykcn zdf kcwpfgzkoc om zdf wviafgz pyopfyz{oy zdhz K ifghbf h~hyf om jvykcn zdf yfwfhygd kc}ol}fj kc pfymoybkcn zdkw hppyhkwhl# K dh}f gocwkjfyfj zdfwf hj}fywf gocjkzkocw kcb{ hchl{wkw om zdf pyopfyz{ }hlvf, hcj dh}f yfpoyzfj oc zdf fmmfgz om zdf gocjkzkocw oc zdf }hlvf hcj bhyefzhiklkz{ om zdf wviafgz

pyopfyz{#

86# K dh}f coz eco~kcnl{ ~kzddflj hc{ wknckmkghcz kcmoybhzkoc myob zdkw hppyhkwhl yfpoyz hcj, zo zdf ifwz om b{ eco~lfjnf, hll

wzhzfbfczw hcj kcmoybhzkoc kc zdkw hppyhkwhl yfpoyz hyf zyvf hcj goyyfgz#

8=# K wzhzfj kc zdkw hppyhkwhl yfpoyz b{ o~c pfywochl, vcikhwfj, hcj pyomfwwkochl hchl{wkw, opkckocw, hcj gocglvwkocw, ~dkgd hyf

wviafgz ocl{ zo zdf hwwvbpzkocw hcj lkbkzkcn gocjkzkocw kc zdkw hppyhkwhl yfpoyz#

8># K dh}f co pyfwfcz oy pyowpfgzk}f kczfyfwz kc zdf pyopfyz{ zdhz kw zdf wviafgz om zdkw yfpoyz, hcj K dh}f co pyfwfcz oy pyowpfgzk}f

pfywochl kczfyfwz oy ikhw ~kzd yfwpfgz zo zdf phyzkgkphczw kc zdf zyhcwhgzkoc# K jkj coz ihwf, fkzdfy phyzkhll{ oy gobplfzfl{, b{hchl{wkw hcj/oy opkckoc om bhyefz }hlvf kc zdkw hppyhkwhl yfpoyz oc zdf yhgf, goloy, yflknkoc, wft, hnf, bhykzhl wzhzvw, dhcjkghp,

mhbklkhl wzhzvw, oy chzkochl oyknkc om fkzdfy zdf pyowpfgzk}f o~cfyw oy oggvphczw om zdf wviafgz pyopfyz{ oy om zdf pyfwfcz o~cfyw oy

oggvphczw om zdf pyopfyzkfw kc zdf }kgkckz{ om zdf wviafgz pyopfyz{ oy oc hc{ ozdfy ihwkw pyodkikzfj i{ lh~#

84# B{ fbplo{bfcz hcj/oy gobpfcwhzkoc moy pfymoybkcn zdkw hppyhkwhl oy hc{ mvzvyf oy hczkgkphzfj hppyhkwhlw ~hw coz gocjkzkocfj

o c h c{ h nyf fbf cz o y vc jf yw zh cj kc n, ~ ykzzf c o y o zdf y~ kw f, zdh z K ~ ov lj yf po yz $o y p yf wf cz hc hl{ wkw w vp po yzkc n+ h pyf jf zf yb kc fjwpfgkmkg }hlvf, h pyfjfzfybkcfj bkckbvb }hlvf, h yhcnf oy jkyfgzkoc kc }hlvf, h }hlvf zdhz mh}oyw zdf ghvwf om hc{ phyz{, oy zdf

hzzhkcbfcz om h wpfgkmkg yfwvlz oy oggvyyfcgf om h wpfgkmkg wviwfxvfcz f}fcz $wvgd hw hppyo}hl om h pfcjkcn boyznhnf lohc

hpplkghzkoc+#

8;# K pfywochll{ pyfphyfj hll gocglvwkocw hcj opkckocw hiovz zdf yfhl fwzhzf zdhz ~fyf wfz moyzd kc zdkw hppyhkwhl yfpoyz# Km K yflkfj oc

wknckmkghcz yfhl pyopfyz{ hppyhkwhl hwwkwzhcgf myob hc{ kcjk}kjvhl oy kcjk}kjvhlw kc zdf pfymoybhcgf om zdkw hppyhkwhl oy zdf

pyfphyhzkoc om zdkw hppyhkwhl yfpoyz, K dh}f chbfj wvgd kcjk}kjvhl$w+ hcj jkwglowfj zdf wpfgkmkg zhwew pfymoybfj kc zdkw hppyhkwhl

yfpoyz# K gfyzkm{ zdhz hc{ kcjk}kjvhl wo chbfj kw xvhlkmkfj zo pfymoyb zdf zhwew# K dh}f coz hvzdoykqfj hc{ocf zo bhef h gdhcnf zo

hc{ kzfb kc zdkw hppyhkwhl yfpoyz5 zdfyfmoyf, hc{ gdhcnf bhjf zo zdkw hppyhkwhl kw vchvzdoykqfj hcj K ~kll zhef co yfwpocwkiklkz{ moy kz#

90# K kjfczkmkfj zdf lfcjfy/glkfcz kczdkw hppyhkwhl yfpoyz ~do kw zdf kcjk}kjvhl, oynhckqhzkoc, oy hnfcz moy zdf oynhckqhzkoc zdhz oyjfyfj

hcj ~kll yf g fk }f z dk w h pp yh kw hl yf p oyz #

Page 17: Ebert Appraisal Service Inc Office of the Real Estate Appraisers (OREA) Complaint for Appraisal Fraud

8/6/2019 Ebert Appraisal Service Inc Office of the Real Estate Appraisers (OREA) Complaint for Appraisal Fraud

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ebert-appraisal-service-inc-office-of-the-real-estate-appraisers-orea-complaint 17/32

115VBBHE[ Hz".z".EHK115HL Ez1#z".VEK

Vckmoyb Yfwkjfczkhl Hppyhkwhl Yfpoyz M k lf C o # > 0 60 6 B H

Zdkw yfpoyz moyb kw jfwkncfj zo yfpoyz hc hppyhkwhl om h ocf"vckz pyopfyz{ oy h ocf"vckz pyopfyz{ ~kzd hc hggfwwoy{ vckz5 kcglvjkcn h

vckz kc h plhccfj vckz jf}flopbfcz $PVJ+# Zdkw yfpoyz moyb kw coz jfwkncfj zo yfpoyz hc hppyhkwhl om h bhcvmhgzvyfj dobf oy h vckz

kc h gocjobkckvb oy goopfyhz k}f pyo afgz#

Zdkw hppyhkwhl yfpoyz kw wviafgz zo zdf mollo~kcn wgopf om ~oye, kczfcjfj vwf, kczfcjfj vwfy, jfmkckzkoc om bhyefz }hlvf, wzhzfbfcz om

hwwvbpzkocw hcj lkbkzkcn gocjkzkocw, hcj gfyzkmkghzkocw# Bojkmkghzkocw, hjjkzkocw, oy jflfz kocw zo zdf kczfcjfj vwf, kczfcjfj vwfy,

jfm kckzkoc om bhyefz }hlvf, oy hwwvbpz kocw hcj lkbkzkcn gocjkzkocw hyf coz pfybkzzfj# Zdf hppyhkwfy bh{ ftphcj zdf wgopf om ~oye

zo kcglvjf hc{ hjjkz kochl yfwfhygd oy hchl{wkw cfgfwwhy{ ihwfj oc zdf gobplftkz { om zdkw hppyhkwhl hwwkncbfcz# Bojkmkghzkocw oy

jflfz kocw zo zdf gfy zk mk ghz kocw hyf h lwo coz pfybkz zfj# Do~f}fy, hjj kz kochl gfy zk mk ghz kocw zdhz jo coz gocwzkzvzf bhzfy khl h lzfyhz kocw

zo zdkw hppyhkwhl yfpoyz, wvgd hw zdowf yfxvkyfj i{ lh~ oy zdowf yflhzfj zo zdf hppyhkwfy.w gocz kcvkcn fjvghzkoc oy bfbifywdkp kc hc

hppyhkwhl oynhckqhzkoc, hyf pfybkzzfj#

WGOPF OM ^OYE1 Zdf wgopf om ~oye moy zdkw hppyhkwhl kw jfmkcfj i{ zdf gobplftkz{ om zdkw hppyhkwhl hwwkncbfcz hcj zdf

yfpoyz kcn yfxvk yfbfczw o m zdkw hppyhkwhl yfpoyz moyb, kcg lvjkcn zdf mollo~kcn jfmkck zkoc om bhyefz }hlvf, w zhzfbfcz om hwwvbpz kocw

hcj lkbkz kcn gocjkz kocw, hcj gfyz km kghzkocw# Zdf hppyhkwfy bvwz , hz h bkckbvb1 $8+ pfymoyb h gobplfzf }kwvhl kcwpfgzkoc om zdf

kczfykoy hcj ftzfykoy hyfhw om zdf wviafgz pyopfyz {, $9+ kcwpfgz zdf cfkndioydooj, $7+ kcwpfgz fhgd om zdf gobphyhilf whlfw myob hz

lfhwz zdf wzyffz, $: + yfwfhygd, }fykm{, hcj hchl{qf jhzh myob yflkhilf pvilkg hcj/oy pyk}hzf wovygfw, hcj $6 + yfpoy z dkw oy dfy hchl{w kw ,

op kc kocw, hcj gocglvw kocw kc zdkw hppyh kwhl yfpoy z#

KCZFCJFJ VWF1 Zdf kczfcjfj vwf om zdkw hppyhkwhl yfpoyz kw moy zdf lfcjfy/glkfcz zo f}hlvhzf zdf pyopfyz{ zdhz kw zdf wviafgz om

zdkw hppyhkwhl moy h boy znhnf m kchcgf zyhcwhgzkoc #

KCZFCJFJ VWFY1 Zdf kczfcjfj vwfy om zdkw hppyhkwhl yfpoyz kw zdf lfcjfy/glkfcz #

JFMKCKZKOC OM BHYEFZ ]HLVF1 Zdf bowz pyoihilf pykgf ~dkgd h pyopfyz{ wdovlj iykcn kc h gobpfzkzk}f hcj opfc bhyefz

vcjfy hll gocjkzkocw yfxvkwkzf zo h mhky whlf, zdf iv{fy hcj wfllfy, fhgd hgzkcn pyvjfczl{, eco~lfjnfhil{ hcj hwwvbkcn zdf pykgf kw

coz hmmfgzfj i{ vcjvf wzkbvlvw# Kbplkgkz kc zdkw jfmkckzkoc kw zdf gocwvbbhzkoc om h whlf hw om h wpfgkmkfj jhzf hcj zdf phwwkcn om

zkzlf myob wfllfy zo iv{fy vcjfy gocjkzkocw ~dfyfi{1 $8+ iv{fy hcj wfllfy hyf z{pkghll{ boz k}hzfj5 $9+ iozd phyzkfw hyf ~fll kcmoybfj

oy ~fll hj}kwfj, hcj fhgd hgzkcn kc ~dhz df oy wdf gocwkjfyw dkw oy dfy o~c ifwz kczfyfwz5 $7+ h yfhwochilf zkbf kw hllo~fj moy

ftpowvyf kc zdf opfc bhyefz5 $:+ ph{bfcz kw bhjf kc zfybw om ghwd kc V# W# jollhyw oy kc zfybw om mkchcgkhl hyyhcnfbfczw

gobphyhilf zdfyfzo5 hcj $6+ zdf pykgf yfpyfwfczw zdf coybhl gocwkjfyhzkoc moy zdf pyopfyz { wolj vchmmfgzfj i{ wpfgkhl oy gyfhzk}f

mkchcgkcn oy whlfw gocgfwwkocw. nyhczfj i{ hc{ocf hwwogkhzfj ~kzd zdf whlf#

.Hjavwzbfczw zo zdf gobphyhilfw bvwz if bhjf moy wpfgkhl oy gyfhzk}f mkchcgkcn oy whlfw gocgfwwkocw# Co hjavwzbfczw hyf

cfgfwwhy{ moy zdowf gowzw ~dkgd hyf coybhll{ phkj i{ wfllfyw hw h yfwvlz om zyhjkzkoc oy lh~ kc h bhyefz hyfh5 zdfwf gowzw hyf yfhjkl{

kjfczkmkhilf wkcgf zdf wfllfy ph{w zdfwf gowzw kc }kyzvhll{ hll whlfw zyhcwhgzkocw# Wpfgkhl oy gyfhz k}f mkchcgkcn hjavwzbfczw ghc if

bhjf zo zdf gobphyhilf pyopfyz{ i{ gobphykwocw zo mkchcgkcn zfybw om mfyfj i{ h zdkyj phyz { kcwzkzvz kochl lfcjfy zdhz kw coz hlyfhj{

kc}ol}fj kc zdf pyopfyz{ oy zyhcwhgzkoc# Hc{ hjavwzbfcz wdovlj coz if ghlgvlhzfj oc h bfgdhckghl jollhy moy jollhy gowz om zdf

mkchcgkcn oy gocgfwwkoc ivz zdf jollhy hbovcz om hc{ hjavwzbfcz wdovlj hppyotkbhzf zdf bhyefz. w yfhgzkoc zo zdf mkchcgkcn oy

gocgfwwkocw ihwfj oc zdf hppyhkwfy.w avjnbfcz#

WZHZFBFCZ OM HWWVBPZKOCW HCJ LKBKZKCN GOCJKZKOCW1 Zdf hppyhkwfy.W gfyzkmkghzkoc kc zdkw yfpoyz kw wviafgz zo zdf

mol lo~kcn hwwvbpzkocw hcj l kbkzkcn gocjkzkocw1

8# Zdf hppyhkwfy ~kll coz if yfwpocwkilf moy bhzzfyw om h lfnhl chzvyf zdhz hmmfgz fkzdfy zdf pyopfyz{ ifkcn hppyhkwfj oy zdf zkzlf

zo kz, ftgfpz moy kcmoybhzkoc zdhz df oy wdf ifghbf h~hyf om jvykcn zdf yfwfhygd kc}ol}fj kc pfymoybkcn zdkw hppyhkwhl# Zdfhppyhkwfy hwwvbfw zdhz zdf z kz lf kw nooj hcj bhyefzhilf hcj ~kll coz yfcjfy hc{ opkckocw hiovz zdf z kVf#

9# Zdf hppyhkwfy dhw pyo}kjfj h wefzgd kc zdkw hppyhkwhl yfpoyz zo wdo~ zdf hppyotkbhzf jkbfcwkocw om zdf kbpyo}fbfczw# Zdf

wefzgd kw kcglvjfj ocl{ zo hwwkwz zdf yfhjfy kc }kwvhlkqkcn zdf pyopfyz { hcj vcjfywzhcjkcn zdf hppyhkwfy.w jfzfybkchz koc om kzw wkqf#

7# Zdf hppyhkwfy dhw fthbkcfj zdf h}hklhilf mlooj bhpw zdhz hyf pyo}kjfj i{ zdf Mfjfyhl Fbfynfcg{ Bhchnfbfcz Hnfcg{ $oy

ozdfy jhzh wovygfw+ hcj dhw cozfj kc zdkw hppyhkwhl yfpoyz ~dfzdfy hc{ poyzkoc om zdf wviafgz wkzf kw loghzfj kc hc kjfczkmkfj Wpfgkhl

Mlooj Dhqhyj Hyfh# Ifghvwf zdf hppyhkwfy kw coz h wvy}f{oy, df oy wdf bhefw co nvhyhczffw, ftpyfww oy kbplkfj, yfnhyjkcn zdkw

jfzfybkchzkoc#

:# Zdf hppyhkwfy ~kll coz nk}f zfwzkboc{ oy hppfhy kc govyz ifghvwf df oy wdf bhjf hc hppyhkwhl om zdf pyopfyz{ kc xvfwzkoc,

vclfww wpfgkmkg hyyhcnfbfczw zo jo wo dh}f iffc bhjf ifmoyfdhcj, oy hw ozdfy~kwf yfxvkyfj i{ lh~#

6# Zdf hppyhkwfy dhw cozfj kc zdkw hppyhkwhl yfpoyz hc{ hj}fywf gocjkzkocw $wvgd hw cffjfj yfphkyw, jfzfykoyhz koc, zdf pyfwfcgf om

dhqhyjovw ~hwzfw, zotkg wviwzhcgfw, fzg#+ oiwfy}fj jvykcn zdf kcwpfgzkoc om zdf wviafgz pyopfyz{ oy zdhz df oy wdf ifghbf h~hyf om

jvykcn zdf yfwfhygd kc}ol}fj kc pfymoybkcn zdkw hppyhkwhl# Vclfww ozdfy~kwf wzhzfj kc zdkw hppyhkwhl yfpoyz , zdf hppyhkwfy dhw co

eco~lfjnf om hc{ dkjjfc oy vchpphyfcz pd{wkghl jfm kgkfcgkfw oy hj}fywf gocjkzkocw om zdf pyopfyz{ $wvgd hw, ivz coz lkbkzfj zo,

cffjfj yfphk yw , jf zfy koyhz koc, zdf pyfwfcgf om dhqhyjovw ~hwzfw, zot kg wviwzhcgfw, hj}fywf fc}k yocbfczhl gocjk zkocw, f zg #+ zdh z~ovlj bhef zdf pyopfyz{ lfww }hlvhilf, hcj dhw hwwvbfj zdhz zdfyf hyf co wvgd gocjkzkocw hcj bhefw co nvhyhczffw oy

~hyyhczkfw, ftpyfww oy kbplkfj# Zdf hppyhkwfy ~kll coz if yfwpocwkilf moy hc{ wvgd gocjkzkocw zdhz jo ftkwz oy moy hc{ fcnkcffykcn oy

zfwzkcn zdhz bkndz if yfxvkyfj zo jkwgo}fy ~dfzdfy wvgd gocjkzkocw ftkwz# Ifghvwf zdf hppyhkwfy kw coz hc ftpfyz kc zdf mkflj om

fc}kyocbfczhl dhqhyjw, zdkw hppyhkwhl yfpoyz bvwz coz if gocwkjfyfj hw hc fc}kyocbfczhl hwwfwwbfcz om zdf pyopfyz{#

=# Zdf hppyhkwfy dhw ihwfj dkw oy dfy hppyhkwhl yfpoyz hcj }hlvhzkoc gocglvwkoc moy hc hppyhkwhl zdhz kw wviafgz zo whz kwmhgzoy{

gobplfzkoc, yfphkyw, oy hlzfyhz kocw oc zdf hwwvbpzkoc zdhz zdf gobplfzkoc, yfphkyw, oy hlzfyhzkocw om zdf wviafgz pyopfyz { ~kll if

pfy moybfj kc h pyo mfwwkoch l bhccfy#

""" # """""""" # """)# ## #

Page 18: Ebert Appraisal Service Inc Office of the Real Estate Appraisers (OREA) Complaint for Appraisal Fraud

8/6/2019 Ebert Appraisal Service Inc Office of the Real Estate Appraisers (OREA) Complaint for Appraisal Fraud

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ebert-appraisal-service-inc-office-of-the-real-estate-appraisers-orea-complaint 18/32

woyyo}fy1 IHYY[ MHNHC zklf C O # 1 >0606BH

G hw f C o #1Wzhzf1 GH Qk 1 ;09=6

NYOWW IVKLJKCN HYFH $NIH+ 78;0

NYOWW LK]KCN HYFH $NLH+ 9=0=

Hyf h$w+ Hyf h & omNIH

lk}kcn 9#=0= 48#=;

Lf}f l l 9,=0= 48#=;

L f} fl 9 0 _ _ _ X , X X _

L f} fl 7 0 0#00

Ozdfy :9= 87#76

Ihwfbfcz 0 _ _ _ X , X X _

Nhyhnf 64: 84#78

H yfh K]fhwvyfbfczw Hyfh Z{pf

lKmmkhwvyfbfczw Mhgzoy Zozhl Lf}fll Lf}fl 9 Lf}fl 7 Ozdfy Iwbz Nhyhnf

s t ___8LXX t #A#AlX# 2 s76X U 9 W A 0 0 0 0 0s t _ _ _ _ _L_XX t #A#AlX# 2 >0#00 0 0 0 0 0 0 0=9#00 t 84#60 t 8#00 2 8 8:Q#00 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

s t s t 8#00 2 66#XX 0 0 0 0 0 0 0s t _®AlX t 8#00 2 X>#60 0 0 0 0 0 0 0s t "#8#7##XX t 8 00 2 908#XO U 9 W A 0 0 0 0 089#60 t _ _ _ 8 X , _ 1 k X , t #A#AlX# 2 8s8#.6 U 9 W A 0 0 0 0 0

_ _ _ 8 X , _ 1 k X , t s t 8#00 2 sa#60 0 0 0 0 0 0 0s t s t #A#AlX# 2 669#96 0 0 0 0 0 0 0_ _ t _ _ t _ _ 2 0 0 0 0 0 0_ _ t _ _ t _ _ 2 0 0 0 0 0 0_ _ t _ _ t _ _ 2 0 0 0 0 0 0_ _ t _ _ t _ _ 2 0 0 0 0 0 0_ _ t _ _ t _ _ 2 0 0 0 0 0 0_ _ t _ _ t _ _ 2 0 0 0 0 0 0_ _ t _ _ t _ _ 2 0 0 0 0 0 0_ _ t _ _ t _ _ 2 0 0 0 0 0 0_ _ t _ _ t _ _ 2 0 0 0 0 0 0_ _ # t _ _ t _ _ 2 0 0 0 0 0 0_ _ t _ _ t _ _ 2 0 0 0 0 0 0_ _ t _ _ t _ _ 2 0 0 0 0 0 0_ _ t _ _ t _ _ 2 0 0 0 0 0 0_ _ t _ _ t _ _ 2 0 0 0 0 0 0_ _ t _ _ t _ _ 2 0 0 0 0 0 0_ _ t _ _ t _ _ 2 0 0 0 0 0 0_ _ t _ _ t _ _ 2 0 0 0 0 0 0_ _ t _ _ t _ _ 2 0 0 0 0 0 0_ _ t _ _ t _ _ 2 0 0 0 0 0 0_ _ t _ _ t _ _ 2 0 0 0 0 0 0_ _ t _ _ t _ _ 2 0 0 0 0 0 0_ _ t _ _ t _ _ 2 0 0 0 0 0 0_ _ t _ _ t _ _ 2 0 0 0 0 0 0_ _ t _ _ t _ _ 2 0 0 0 0 0 0_ _ t _ _ t _ _ 2 0 0 0 0 0 0_ _ t _ _ t _ _ 2 0 0 0 0 0 0_ _ t _ _ t _ _ 2 0 0 0 0 0 0_ _ t _ _ t _ _ 2 0 0 0 0 0 0_ _ t _ _ t _ _ 2 0 0 0 0 0 0_ _ t _ _ t _ _ 2 0 0 0 0 0 0_ _ t _ _ t _ _ 2 0 0 0 0 0 0_ _ t _ _ t _ _ 2 0 0 0 0 0 0_ _ t _ _ t _ _ 2 0 0 0 0 0 0_ _ t _ _ t _ _ 2 0 0 0 0 0 0_ _ t _ _ t _ _ 2 0 0 0 0 0 0_ _ t _ _ t _ _ 2 0 0 0 0 0 0_ _ t _ _ t _ _ 2 0 0 0 0 0 0_ _ t _ _ t _ _ 2 0 0 0 0 0 0_ _ t _ _ t _ _ 2 0 0 0 0 0 0_ _ t _ _ t _ _ 2 0 0 0 0 0 0_ _ t _ _ t _ _ 2 0 0 0 0 0 0_ _ t _ _ t _ _ 2 0 0 0 0 0 0__ t __ t __ " 0 0 0 0 0 0_ _ t _ _ t _ _ 2 0 0 0 0 0 0

Page 19: Ebert Appraisal Service Inc Office of the Real Estate Appraisers (OREA) Complaint for Appraisal Fraud

8/6/2019 Ebert Appraisal Service Inc Office of the Real Estate Appraisers (OREA) Complaint for Appraisal Fraud

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ebert-appraisal-service-inc-office-of-the-real-estate-appraisers-orea-complaint 19/32

JkyfgzHQ# HV'0>:9:

GOm]PHYHILF WHLF '8

909:7 Pkfjyh Gdkgh Yohj

HPC1 ::60"087"0=4

GOm]PHYHILF WHLF '9

90468 Ikn Yoge Jyk}f

HPC1 :::;"08="00=

GOB)HYHILF WHLF '7

90:>0 Yo{hl Wzocf Jyk}f

HPC1 ::60"086"098

Page 20: Ebert Appraisal Service Inc Office of the Real Estate Appraisers (OREA) Complaint for Appraisal Fraud

8/6/2019 Ebert Appraisal Service Inc Office of the Real Estate Appraisers (OREA) Complaint for Appraisal Fraud

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ebert-appraisal-service-inc-office-of-the-real-estate-appraisers-orea-complaint 20/32

Wz GH Qk 1 ;09=6

GOB.HYHILF WHLF':

987>0 Yhbilh ] kw zh Wzyff z

HPC1 ::68"099"067

GOB.HYHILF WHLF'6

9060: Yogh Gdkgh Jyk}f

HPC1 ::60"08="08;

GOy}PHYHILF WHLF '=

90:9= Yogh Gdkgh Jyk}f

HPC1 ::60"087"0>4

Page 21: Ebert Appraisal Service Inc Office of the Real Estate Appraisers (OREA) Complaint for Appraisal Fraud

8/6/2019 Ebert Appraisal Service Inc Office of the Real Estate Appraisers (OREA) Complaint for Appraisal Fraud

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ebert-appraisal-service-inc-office-of-the-real-estate-appraisers-orea-complaint 21/32

I o y y o ~ f y # IHYY[ MHNHC MklfCo#1 >0606BH

Pyopfyz{ Hjjyfww1 90:>6 YOGH GDKGH JY Ghwf Co#1

Wzhzf1 GH Qkp1 ;09=6k yz1 B H LKI V

OssMyGRyOK.(¾YFHL#FW.l¾HkF\PPYHlwzzKzW

YFH#L FWZHZF HPPYHKWFY LKGFCWF

)Yoz 844=

AHsmFW H# 81IFYZ

dhwwsGGz5zwwmvlA{#lcfz zif yfxl+ kyfbfmlzw#m$lU<kl kgfyywf hww yfwkjfczkhl yfhl fwzhzf hppyhkwfy

kykgzdf.Wzhzf1 zymGhlkmxbkz.lhcj# kw,5,0zdfyfmX8>©) fczkzyfgl zo vwf zdf zkzlf )Gfyzzmzf#jYfwkjfczmhl

Yf#hKFwzsz)f#:ppyhkWfy)1# • _ # # # # . G . # < # # , , _

Zdks#lesc®fdhw iffzl (wwvfz1klchgjzAyjsb11f^kkdzB@pyo}kwkocw om zdf Yfhl FwzhzfHppyhk#wsmwyVgfcwkcn hcj GfyzKMkk#1h1zk A c ) U#5h~# #

GO]FY COZF

BHllACN ) (3Y#<5) .kW =74 Vo))) G{c, s#Aa >OA() K.sy).s,$#1,)., .08#8k>

88zv Aa zo g#gckA{ yd(ll zmv )vvz5m##k#Gdsj Kbmz1,s.a.vkzC5j kyA##mzlCyK.G_. 81m#lA,(5,yzl,ssV vzyyzmlu/zk(8. )m.l(zkmk,A

myob s.,V^VKz, uslKlrAhklVlz. zAzV/#/Om KKdzlzz#,#l ####js5#y_

# # M ¾b l 11 1( #k s 55 za ,1b ¾Y,sss88.#1#.+kh#z#51Hppyvywgy

# # G(7d8v#5s##vj g Mvcv1 \D.K ,y,k.V.5.s8D$s1K,¾¾(zss1,

1$1lcl?d)ll¾#.f K+1Kss¾kzuk#¾ A35#+k[8

K ,kb kz w" Pff Ofgg"ygcgg W 8,s,cukA+ma$+ ¾sz18kV,}#,.sn,ysnll511 Wm #O$AO#uVTK

,## z+#5,1jzl._1lkde#s K 7+080

gotcyyzot¥

lA,, , 1_zk 8#ss_ll¾#1 a"\szs),1pLIc)ye"11M l\5(lz1#¾c¾5j Kcj51vlckd

## Ecz, # ####Kssn¾511#ly\]yc(szyVl /.)z.5lP#(kk¾,.lvskk.ll

mh \1fcjkl.8y ####Vsyz.$.8mP)oU. 8,zzknKl11lk#1rz.8 m#tgzVk#k.rY

KADlz.mA h$ )dll#. sccs8L1L 5## #,#d"5 # • c"5#

w#1b ckk#1n\ss._##\A11 K 1 y

lk]1

Page 22: Ebert Appraisal Service Inc Office of the Real Estate Appraisers (OREA) Complaint for Appraisal Fraud

8/6/2019 Ebert Appraisal Service Inc Office of the Real Estate Appraisers (OREA) Complaint for Appraisal Fraud

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ebert-appraisal-service-inc-office-of-the-real-estate-appraisers-orea-complaint 22/32

L]}y\ z lV)K]l).\y

Ioyyo~fy# IHYY[ MHNHC M kl f C o #1 >0606BH

G hwf C o #1y o pf y z{ H j jy f ww 1 90:>6 YOGH GDKGH JY

Wzhzf1 GH Qkp1 ;09=6kz{1 BHLKIV

Pyfphyfj i{ 1 Fifyz Hppyhkwhl Wfy}kgf# Kcg# 484";;8";799

88 0 Hjjy••• Joz# Pykgf YB IY Iozd W;Mz Pyotkbkz{

W 90:>6 YOGH GDKGH JY OW/900> Kcwp _00 ; 7 7 9==6 0#00 DK

8 909:7 PKFJYH GDKGH YJ 0:/84/900> 84>6000 80 : 7 9=8; 0#90 888 F

9 90468 IKN YOGE OY 06/0>/900> 7>60000 ; 7 7 9;80 0#:6 BK C^

7 90:>0 88 YO[HLW ZOCF JY 89/86/900= 8:80000 ; : 9 9:89 0#0: BK CCF

: 987>0 YHBILH ]KWZH WZ 89/04/900= 9860000 W 7 6 79;6 8#: BK ^

6 9 0 6 0 : Y O G H G D K G H J Y L K W Z K C N H J A W 8 = ; 6 0 0 0 4 7 7 9 0 4 = 0 # 0 6 C K Kk

## ## ###) ## #)#) ##)"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""

Page 23: Ebert Appraisal Service Inc Office of the Real Estate Appraisers (OREA) Complaint for Appraisal Fraud

8/6/2019 Ebert Appraisal Service Inc Office of the Real Estate Appraisers (OREA) Complaint for Appraisal Fraud

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ebert-appraisal-service-inc-office-of-the-real-estate-appraisers-orea-complaint 23/32

yLcK K]B

I oyyo ~ fy# I HY Y [ M H NH C M klf C o #1 > 060 6B H

P yo pf yz{ H jj yf ww 1 9 0: >6 Y ON H N DKN H J Y G hw f C o #1

W zh zf 1 G H Q k p 1 ;09=6k z { 1 BHLKIV

Ow

$5 G JKlf cX+

.)Kl

@sozkl

§$A+

okl,11A)K¥ Bgo #

) ) z( # # #B

h 1 sK# ,

$6okl

.) .)## # # # # #X+

hk l5 <J

Ol 1 1 1 5 s<11

¥zkl0

. )_ ,

s1

.0gJlC ¥+

# q # ) .go

5 5 1 1 C C

g #811A y 1 1 1 0 00 # # q qo f 01 1

D8".s}k s \5 (

. ) .)". D8".

__

Page 24: Ebert Appraisal Service Inc Office of the Real Estate Appraisers (OREA) Complaint for Appraisal Fraud

8/6/2019 Ebert Appraisal Service Inc Office of the Real Estate Appraisers (OREA) Complaint for Appraisal Fraud

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ebert-appraisal-service-inc-office-of-the-real-estate-appraisers-orea-complaint 24/32

K L]])yLB,#

Ioyyo~fy1 IHYY[ MHNHC M klf C o ,1 >0606BH

Pyo l8f ( (l Hjjyfww 1 90:>6 YOGH GDKGH JY G hw f C o ,1Gk({1 BHLKIV Wzhzf1 GH Qkl81 ;09=6Lfcjfy1 ^fllw Mhyno Fxvk z{ J kyfg z HQ#, HV'0>:9:

96,W.

^hle"Kc Ihzdx

s

80,0.

Ifjyoob

iIfjyoob

s

Ihzd

,"Ifjyoob

afc Ifjyoob

a #5zos

Go}fyfj Phzko 9#6. s97#6. yc

86#6. B

Ihzd

Nhyhnf

. ) Jkckcn)l

. )s

slk}kcn# # #

Fczy{80#0.

1by K

s Ekzgdfc Cooe K7#6.

Ks sK#6. KK

.) K)Ks. K 8>#0. s9:#0. K

s KIhlgoc{

K99#0.

;I1zl z¦/ kIl^))

Gobbfczw1

HYFH GHLGVLHZKOCW WVBBHY[ LK]KCN HYFH IYFHEJO^CGojf Jfwgykpzkoc Wkqf Cfz Zozhlw Iyfhejo~c Wvizozhlw

NLH8 Mkywz Mlooy 9=06#>6 9=06#>6 Mkywz Mlooy

PKP Ihlgoc{ 700#00 8>#0 t 66#6 ;:7#60

Go}fyfj Phzko 89=#00 :9=#00 >#0 t 80#0 >0#00

NHY Nhyhnf 647#>6 647#>6 84#6 t =9#0 88:>#00

9#6 t 99#0 66#00

6#X t 88#6 6>#60

87#0 T 86#6 908#60

80#6 t 89#6 878#96

ZOZHL LK]HILF $yovcjfj+ 9=0= > Ghlgvlhzkocw Zozhl $yovcjfj+ 9=0=

#"

Page 25: Ebert Appraisal Service Inc Office of the Real Estate Appraisers (OREA) Complaint for Appraisal Fraud

8/6/2019 Ebert Appraisal Service Inc Office of the Real Estate Appraisers (OREA) Complaint for Appraisal Fraud

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ebert-appraisal-service-inc-office-of-the-real-estate-appraisers-orea-complaint 25/32

jocf ~kzd wkbklhy pyopfyzkfw kc zdf yfnkoc, ~kzd gocwkjfyhzkoc nk}fc zo zdf o}fyhll pfygfczhnf ihwkw hw ~fll# Kc hjjkzkoc, wkbklhy

pyopfyzkfw yf}kf~fj ivz coz vwfj moy zdf hppyhkwhl, wvppoyz hcj yfkcmoygf zdf hjavwzbfczw vwfj#

Mollo~kcn hyf bhyefz hjavwzbfczw, kc h jfwgfcjkcn lkcf wfxvfcgf#

LOGHZKOC " Wviafgz kw loghzfj kc h xvkfz yfwkjfczkhl hyfh, gobphyhilfw ~kzd nyfhzfy oy lfwwfy loghzkocw dh}f iffc hjavwzfj

hggoyjkcnl{#

WKZF " Jkmmfyfcgfw kc vwhilf loz wkqf o}fy 8,000 WM ~fyf hjavwzfj hz zdf gobboc mhgzoyom*KO/WM, yovcjfj#

HNF/GOCJbOC " Hgzvhl hcj fmmfgzk}f hnf jkmmfyfcgfw ~fyf kcgoypoyhzfj kczo gocjkzkoc hjavwzbfczw# Gocjkzkoc

hjavwzbfczw ~fyf bhjf hggoyjkcnl{, ihwfj oc hll jhzh h}hklhilf, hw ~fll hw jyk}f i{ hchl{wkw#

LK]KCN HYFHlYOOB GOVCZ " Jkmmfyfcgfw kc lk}kcn hyfh ~fyf hjavwzfj hz *89W/WM, moy jkmmfyfcgfw o}fy *8,000 nyoww

hjavwzbfcz hbovcz # Ifjyoob hcj ihzdyoob govcz jkm mfyfcgfw ~fyf hjavwzfj hz *96,000 pfy yoob, hcj *89,600 pfy dhlm

ihzdyoob#

OZDFY " Ozdfy hjavwzbfczw ~fyf bhjf hw cffjfj hcj hyf wflm ftplhchzoy{#

M kch l Yfgocg kl kh z koc

Zdfyf kw kcwvmm kgkfcz jhzh h}hk lhilf kc zdf wviafgz bhyefz zo jfyk}f h nyoww yfcz bvlzkpl kfy oy h nyoww boczdl{ yfcz bvlzkplkfy# Hw

wvgd, zdf bfzdojolon{ om zdf Kcgobf Hppyohgd ~hw coz jf}flopfj zo fwzkbhzf zdf bhyefz }hlvf om zdf wviafgz pyopfyz{#

Mvyzdfyboyf, zdf Kcgobf Hppyohgd kw coz h nfcfyhll{ hggfpzfj bfzdoj moy fwzkbhzkcn zdf }hlvf om o~cfy oggvpkfj wkcnlf

mhbkl{ yfwkjfcgfw kc zdf wviafgz.w bhyefz#

Om zdf zdyff zyhjkzkochl hppyohgdfw zo }hlvf, ocl{ zdf Whlfw Gobphykwoc Hchl{wkw dhw iffc hpplkfj, hlzdovnd, hz zkbfw, zdf gowz

hppyohgd bh{ hlwo if pyfwfczfj# ^dfc wvmmkgkfcz jhzh kw h}hklhilf, zdf bfzdojolon{ om zdf Whlfw Gobphykwoc Hchl{wkw {kfljw

zdf bowz goc}kcgkcn kcjkghzkoc om }hlvf moy h wkcnlf mhbkl{ yfwkjfcgf kc zdf wviafgz .w bhyefz hyfh# Hlzdovnd wviwzhczkhl

hjavwzbfczw bh{ if hppl kfj zo zdf whlfw pykgfw om zdf gobphyhilf pyopfyzkfw, zdf jhzh kc zdkw hchl{wkw kw gocwkjfyfj zo if om

wvmmkgkfcz xvhlkz{ hcj xvhczk z{ zo pyfwfcz h goc}kcgkcn fwzkbhzf om }hlvf# Zdfyfmoyf, bowz ~fkndz kw plhgfj oc zdf Whlfw

Gobphykwoc Hchl{wkw kc fwzkbhz kcn zdf bhyefz }hlvf om zdf wviafgz pyopfyz{ hw om zdf fmmfgz k}f jhzf om zdf hppyhkwhl # Zdf }hlvf

fwzkbhzfj i{ zdf Gowz Hppyohgd, kmpyfwfcz, kw gocwkjfyfj zo if wvppoyzk}f#

Hll gobphyhilfw ~fyf nk}fc wobf gocwkjfyhzkoc kc jfzfybkckcn zdf wviafgz .w mkchl fwzkbhzfj bhyefz }hlvf# Zdf gobphyhilfw

vwfj kc zdkw hppyhkwhl yfpoyz iyhgefz zdf wviafgz .w bhyefz }hlvf iozd ifmoyf hcj hmzfy hjavwzbfczw ~fyf hpplkfj# Ftzfcwk}f

yfwfhygd ~hw cfgfwwhy{ zo mkcj zdf }fy{ ifwz kcjkghzoyw om bhyefz }hlvf, ~dkgd dh}f kcjkghzfj h gvyyfcz fwzkbhzfj bhyefz }hlvf#

Kc wvbbhy{, zdkw hppyhkwhl yfpoyz, mollo~kcn hppyo}fj hcj chzkochll{ hgeco~lfjnfj hppyhkwhl nvkjflkcfw, ihwfj oc zdf bhyefz

jhzh h}hklhilf, dhw jfzfybkcfj h mkchl fwzkbhzfj bhyefz }hlvf moy zdf pyopfyz{# Zdkw kw ihwfj oc coz ocl{ zdf gobphyhilfw

wdo~c kc zdf yfpoyz, ivz hlwo zdf joqfcw om gobphyhilfw, iozd gvyyfcz hcj phwz, coz kcglvjfj kc zdkw yfpoyz# Zdf{ hlwo wvppoyz

zdf fwzkbhzfj bhyefz }hlvf moy zdf wviafgz#

Hjjfcjvb Phnf : om 6

Page 26: Ebert Appraisal Service Inc Office of the Real Estate Appraisers (OREA) Complaint for Appraisal Fraud

8/6/2019 Ebert Appraisal Service Inc Office of the Real Estate Appraisers (OREA) Complaint for Appraisal Fraud

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ebert-appraisal-service-inc-office-of-the-real-estate-appraisers-orea-complaint 26/32

Jvf zo zkbf hcj yfwovygf gocwzyhkczw, ~dkgd hyf gobboc kc zdf bhyefz plhgf, zdf hppyhkwfy cfgfwwhykl{ yfwfy}fw zdf ykndz zo

pyo}kjf bojkmkghzkocw oy hjjfcjvb zo zdf kckzkhl yfpoyz, ihwfj oc mvyzdfy kcmoybhz koc oy jhzh pyfwfczfj hmzfy zdf yfpoyz kw

wvibkzzfj# Hll fmmoyzw ~fyf bhjf zo }fykm{ hll kcmoybhzkoc vwfj kc zdkw yfpoyz#

Hj}fywf Fc}kyocbfczhl Gocjkzkocw

Zdf ftkwzfcgf om hc{ dhqhyjovw bhzfykhl, kcglvjkcn ivz coz lkbkzfj zo, Vyfh Moybhljfd{jf Mohb Kcwvlhzkoc, yhjoc nhw,

hwifwzow pyojvgzw, lfhj ihwfj phkczw oy zotkg ~hwzf goczhbkchcz, ~dkgd bh{oy bh{ coz if pyfwfcz kc zdf wviafgz

kbpyo}fbfczw, oc zdf wkzf oy kc zdf kbbfjkhzf }kgkckz{ om zdf wviafgz, dhw coz iffc oiwfy}fj i{ zdf hppyhkwfy# Zdf hppyhkwfy

dhw co eco~lfjnf om zdf ftkwzfcgf om wvgd dhqhyjovw bhzfykhl kc oy oc zdf pyopfyz{# Kzwdovlj if cozfj zdhz dobfw ivklz

ifmoyf 8;>4 bh{ goczhkc lfhj ihwfj phkcz hcj zdf glkfcz wdovlj if hj}kwfj om kzw powwkilf ftkwzfcgf# Hlwo, zdf FPH wvnnfwzw

zdhz hll dobfw if zfwzfj moy yhjoc nhw# Km zdf glkfcz dhw h gocgfyc zdfc h xvhl kmkfj ftpfyz wdovlj if goczhgzfj#

Plfhwf cozf zdhz jvf zo zdf gocwzhcz hcj gdhcnkcn mlooj qocfw hcj zdfky yhzkcnw i{ zdf govcz{, zdf yfhjfy kw hj}kwfj zo wffe

kcmoybhzkoc hcj gfyzkmkghzkoc om zdf bowz yfgfcz kcmoybhzkoc myob zdf pyopfy hvzdoykzkfw# Jvf zo zkbf hcj ivjnfzhy{

gocwzyhkcw, zdf kcmoybhzkoc goczhkcfj kc zdkw wvbbhy{ yfpoyz kw pyfwfczfj hw zdf bowz gobbocl{ eco~c hcj yflfhwfj hyfh

kcmoybhzkoc# Plfhwf cozf zdhz jvf jklknfcgf dhw iffc mollo~fj, ivz hggvyhg{ kc hll ghwfw ghccoz if mvll{ nvhyhczffj#

Dkndfwz hcj Ifwz Vwf

Dkndfwz hcj Ifwz Vwf kw zdhz yfhwochilf hcj pyoihilf vwf zdhz ~kll wvppoyz zdf dkndfwz pyfwfcz }hlvf, hw jfmkcfj, hw om zdf

fmmfgzk}f jhzf om zdf hppyhkwhl# Hlzfychzk}fl{, kz kw zdhz vwf, myob hbocn lfnhll{ pfybkwwkilf, pd{wkghll{ hcj yfhwochil{ powwkilf

vwfw, movcj zo if fgocobkghll{ hcj mkchcgkhll{ mfhwkilf, hcj ~dkgd yfwvlzw kc zdf bowz pyomkzhilf om zdf hlzfychzk}fw#

Nk}fc zdf gvyyfcz qockcn, loghzkoc hcj wkqf om zdf wkzf, wvyyovcjkcn lhcj vwfw $yfgonckqkcn zdf pykcgkplf om gocmoybkz{+ hcj

jf}flopbfcz gdhyhgzfykwzkgw om zdf bhyefz hyfh, ovy opkckoc om zdf dkndfwz hcj ifwz vwf om zdf pyopfyz{ )hw }hghcz) kw moy wkcnlf

mhbkl{ yfwkjfczkhl jf}flopbfcz# Mvyzdfy, zdf ftkwzkcn vwf/kbpyo}fbfczw ftgffj zdf }hlvf om zdf wkzf }hghcz5 zdfyfmoyf ovyopkckoc om zdf dkndfwz hcj ifwz vwf om zdf wkzf )hw kbpyo}fj) kw moy gocz kcvfj wkcnlf mhbkl{ yfwkjfcz khl vwf#

Gobbfczw oc zdf Whlfw Gobphykwoc Hchl{wkw

Wkcgf coz f}fy{ wviafgz ghc if gobphyfj zo )kjfhl) gobphyhilf whlfw, zdf hppyhkwfy dhw gdowfc ~dhz hyf iflkf}fj zo if zdf ifwz

gobphyhilf whlfw h}hklhilf myob h zdoyovnd hcj ftzfcwk}f wfhygd moy gobphyhilf whlfw jhzh kc zdf wviafgz .w bhyefz# Zdf whlfw

wflfgzfj moy vwf kc zdf hchl{wkw hyf gocwkjfyfj zo if zdf ifwz kcjkghzoyw om }hlvf moy zdf wviafgz pyopfyz{# Ozdfy whlfw yf}kf~fj

~ovlj dh}f yfxvkyfj ftgfwwk}f hjavwzbfczw hcj ~fyf coz gocwkjfyfj zo if hw yflkhilf hw zdf whlfw gdowfc#

Hjavwzbfczw ~kzdkc zdf Whlfw Gobphykwoc Hchl{wkw hyf ihwfj oc zdf bhyefz whlfw gobphykwoc bfzdoj, nfcfyhll{ fbplo{kcn zdfbhzgdfj phky pyogfww, hcj coz wpfgkmkghll{ ihwfj oc gowz mknvyfw#

F}fy{ fmmoyz dhw iffc bhjf zo gocmoyb zo MDLBGKMCBH Nvkjflkcfw hcj kc bowz ghwfw, hc f}fc wzykgzfy kczfypyfzhzkoc movcj

gobboc zo bowz kc}fwzoyw kc zdf wfgocjhy{ bhyefz#

Ihwfj oc zdf bhyefz jhzh, hw ~fll hw ozdfy wovygfw, kz hppfhyw zdhz hl l gobphyhilf whlfw ~fyf wolj ~kzd co wpfgkhl oy gyfhzk}f

mkchcgkcn oy whlfw gocgfwwkocw, vclfww ozdfy~kwf wpfgkmkghll{ cozfj# Glowkcn gowz phkj i{ zdf wfllfyw om zdf gobphyhilf

pyopfyzkfw hyf fxvk}hlfcz zo z{pkghl mkchcgkcn zfybw ommfyfj i{ zdkyj phyz{ kcwzkzvzkochl lfcjfyw kc zdf loghl bhyefz# Kc zdfhppyhkwfy.w opkckoc, zdfwf whlfw yfpyfwfcz z{pkghl bhyefz mkchcgkcn zyhcwhgzkocw# Zdf whlfw pykgfw hyf coz gocwkjfyfj zo if

kcmlhzfj i{ wpfgkhl oy ftgfwwk}f mkchcgkcn gocgfwwkocw# Zdf kcjkghzfj }hlvfw om zdf gobphyhilf whlfw yfmlfgz zdf }hlvf om zdf

wviafgz yfhl fwzhzf hcj kcglvjf ocl{ zdowf wfllfyw . glowkcn gowzw, coybhl l{ phkj i{ zyhjk zkoc oy lh~ kc zdf bhyefz hyfh#

Nyoww l k}kcn hyfhw wdo~c moy zdf gobphyhilf whlfw, hyf fwzkbhzfw ihwfj oc kcmoybhz koc myob ocf oy boyf om zdf mollo~kcn

wovygfw1 Bvlzkplf Lkwzkcn Wfy}kgf $BLW+, govcz{/gkz{ zht yfgoyjw, yfhl fwzhzf hnfczw, dobfo~cfyw, ivkljfyw, hppyhkwfyw,

kczfyommkgf jhzh ihce oy hgzvhl bfhwvyfbfczw# Wl kndz }hykhzkocw kc wkqf ~kl l dh}f co fmmfgz oc zdf fwzkbhzf om }hlvf# Hll

gobphyhilf whlfw hyf wfzzlfj zo zdf ifwz om zdf hppyhkwfy.w eco~lfjnf# ]fykmkghzkoc kw ~kzd govcz{ yfgoyjw hcj/oy Yfhlzoy#

Wviafgz kw gobphzkilf zo zdf cfkndioydooj kc zfybw om wkqf, gocjkzkoc, xvhlkz{, hcj hppfhl# Co pyflkbkchy{ zkzlf yfpoyz oy

fwgyo~ kcwzyvgzkocw ~fyf pyo}kjfj moy yf}kf~# Goczhgz ~kzd yfwpfgzk}f iyoefyw ~fyf wobfzkbfw yfxvkyfj zo yfwol}f

jkwgyfphcgkfw movcj ifz~ffc pvilkg yfgoyjw hcj BLW# H zdoyovnd wfhygd om zdf bhyefz hyfh kcglvjfj, ivz ~hw coz l kbkzfj zo,

pvilkg yfgoyj, GBJG, ZY , Jhbhy, JhzhXvkge, BLW Iooew hcj Gobpvzfyw, hyfh iyoefyw hcj zkzlf gobphckfw, hcj ozdfy

hppyhkwfyw# Zdf gobphyhilfw vwfj hcj hjavwzbfczw bhjf hyf zdf ifwz h}hklhilf, hcj hggvyhzf kcjkghzoyw om zdf bhyefz }hlvf#

Zdf kcjk}kjvhl lkcf hjavwzbfczw hcj gvbvlhzk}f hnnyfnhzf cfz hjavwzbfczw vzklkqfj bh{ ftgffj zdf pyfmfyyfj z{pkghl hjavwzbfcz

wzhcjhyj# Jvf zo zdf jfbhcj kc zdkw hcj wkbklhy bhyefzw, ~k zd zdf lhge om yfgfcz wkbklhy whlfw kc zdkw gvyyfcz kbbfjkhzf bhyefz

hyfh, zdfwf hjavwzbfczw ~fyf ~hyyhczfj# Zdf hjavwzbfczw hyf vlzkbhzfl{ ihwfj oc iozd pyfwfcz hcj phwz bhzgdfj phky hchl{wkw

"#1Klbhnf 7 om 6

Page 27: Ebert Appraisal Service Inc Office of the Real Estate Appraisers (OREA) Complaint for Appraisal Fraud

8/6/2019 Ebert Appraisal Service Inc Office of the Real Estate Appraisers (OREA) Complaint for Appraisal Fraud

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ebert-appraisal-service-inc-office-of-the-real-estate-appraisers-orea-complaint 27/32

wviafgz pyopfyz{ kw myff om vcjfzfgzfj pyoilfbw, powwkilf jfmfgzw oy fc}kyocbfczhl dhqhyjw zdhz govlj ftkwz#

Gobplfzf }kwvhl kcwpfgzkoc om zdf kczfykoy hyfhw omzdf wviafgz pyopfyz{1 H }kwvhl oiwfy}hzkoc myob

wzhcjkcn dfkndz om zdf hggfwwkilf hyfhw hcj vcoiwzyvgzfj, ftpowfj wvymhgfw om zdf lk}kcn hyfh ~kzdovz yfbo}hl om pfywochl

powwfwwkocw# K z kcglvjfw zdf }kwvhl oiwfy}hzkoc om hzzhgdfj hvzoboiklf wzoyhnf, km hc{, hw ~fll hw om hc{ hzzhgdfj hggfwwoy{

ivkljkcnw avjnfj i{ zdf hppyhkwfy zo dh}f goczykivzoy{ }hlvf#

Gobplfzf }kwvhl kcwpfgzkoc om zdf ftzfykoy om zdf wviafgz pyopfyz{1 H }kwvhl oiwfy}hzkoc om zdf

vcoiwzyvgzfj, ftpowfj, hcj hggfwwkilf pfykbfzfy om zdf yfwkjfczkhl kbpyo}fbfczw myob wzhcjkcn dfkndz# Kz kcglvjfw zdf }kwvhl

oiwfy}hzkoc om hzzhgdfj oy jfzhgdfj hvzoboiklf wzoyhnf, km hc{, hw ~fll hw om hc{ jfzhgdfj hggfwwoy{ ivkljkcnw, pyk}hzf pool,

wph, zfcckw govyz, wpoyz govyz, ihlgockfw, phzkow, fzg# avjnfj i{ zdf hppyhkwfy zo dh}f goczykivzoy{ }hlvf#

Lk}kcn hyfh1 Lk}kcn hyfh kw jfmkcfj hw lfnhl, mkckwdfj, pfybhcfczl{ dfhzfj, lk}kcn wphgf goczknvovw ~kzd ozdfy lk}kcn hyfh

hcj yfnhyjfj i{ h z{pkghl pvygdhwfy hw ifkcn dhikzhilf hcj hw dh}kcn vzk lk z{ # Zdf }kwvhl oiwfy}hzkoc om zdf hzzkg, zdf gyh~l

wphgf, hc{ vcmkckwdfj ihwfbfcz, hcj iflo~ nyhjf wzoyhnf kw ihwfj oc z{pkghll{ hgeco~lfjnfj hppyhkwhl kcwpfgzkoc wzhcjhyjw,

zdhz kw, km zdf hggfww kwyfhjkl{ h}hklhilf , i{ pfybhcfcz wzhkyw hcj oy wzfpw, zdfc kzghc if oiwfy}fj# Zdkw hppyhkwhl yfpoyz

gocmoybw zo bhc{ om zdf wzhcjhyjw wvnnfwzfj i{ Zdf Hbfykghc Chzkochl Wzhcjhyjw Kcwzkzvzf HCWK Q>=6"9007, hppyo}fj

Co}fbify 9007#

Fwzkbhzfj bhyefzkcn zkbf kw ihwfj oc gvyyfcz hcj/oy phwz wzvjkfw om whlfw hgzk} kz{ pyo}kjfj i{ zdf loghl hcj yfnkochl

pyomfwwkochlw, kcglvjkcn zdf Bvlzkplf Lkwzkcn Wfy}kgfw, hw ~fll hw zdf hppyhkwfy.w eco~lfjnf om zdf pyopfyz{.w bhyefz# Zdf

fwzkbhzf hwwvbfw pyopfy pykgkcn hcj bhyefzkcn# Zdf fwzkbhzfj bhyefzkcn zkbf kw z{pkghll{ myob ocf ~ffe zo wkt boczdw#

Zdkw hppyhkwhl vzklkqfw jknkzkqfj flfgzyockg wknchzvyfw zdhz pyf}fcz zdf hlzfykcn om zdf hppyhkwhl yfpoyz kc hc{

bhcoy ~kzd zdf yfbo}hl om zdf hppyhkwfy.w wknchzvyf# Zdfwf wknchzvyfw hyf wfgvyf hcj kyyf}oghilf, ikcjkcn zdf hppyhkwfy$w+ zo

zdf hggvyhg{ hcj gobplfzfcfww om zdf hppyhkwhl yfpoyz#

Hjjkzkochl Gobbfczw

• Zdf wefzgd om zdf wviafgz pyopfyz{ k wp ykbhy kl{ zo hwwkwz zdf yfhjfy $yf}kf~fy+ kc} kwvhlkqkcn zdf pyopfyz{ hw ~f dh}f

wffc kz myob ovy oc wkzf kcwpfgzkoc# Zdf mlooy plhc pyo}kjfj kw coz kczfcjfj zo jvplkghzf zdf ivkljfy .w plhc zo wghlf ,

ivz yhzdfy zo if h nvkjf zo zdf yf}kf~fy kc f}hlvhzkcn coybhl zyhmm kg phzzfycw ~kzdkc zdf pyopfyz{#

• Hyfhw om lkbkzfj hggfww $k#f # h zz kg , gyh~l wphgfw, fh}fw, f zg #+ bh{ coz cfgfwwhyk l{ if kcwpfgzfj jvf zo lkbkzfj hggfww#

Moy pvypowfw om zdkw hppyhkwhl , h gocjkzkoc moy hc{ wvgd hpplkghilf hyfh kw jfzfybkcfj hmzfy h }kwvhl kcwpfgzkoc om

yflhzfj/hjaokckcn phyzw om zdf wzyvgzvyf# Hc hppyhkwfy kw h zyh kcfj hcj ftpfykfcgfj oiwfy}fy om yfhl fwzhzf, ivz

yfgonckqkcn, jfzfgzkcn, oy bfhwvykcn goczhbkchzkoc kw omzfc if{ocj zdf wgopf om zdf hppyhkwfy.w ftpfyzkwf#

Yfbfjkhzkoc hcj gobplkhcgf gowz fwzkbhzkoc kc}ol}fw eco~lfjnf hcj ftpfykfcgf if{ocj zdhz om bowz hppyhkwfyw#

• Zdkw kcwpfgz koc kwcoz kczfcjfj zo wfy}f hw h zfybkzf kcwpfgz koc, hlzdovnd hc{ pyoilfbw oiwfy}fj hyf cozfj kc zdf

hppyhkwhl# Zdf iv{fy oy dobfo~cfy wdovlj goczhgz h xvhlkmkfj kcwpfgzkoc pyomfwwkochl moy zdkw wfy}kgf km wo jfwkyfj#

• K zfbw gocwkjfyfj zo if pfywochl pyopfyz{, kcglvjkcn, ivz coz l kbkzfj zo, mvyckzvyf , zflf}kwkocw, oy ozdfy fhwkl{

yfbo}hilf kzfbw, hyf coz kcglvjfj kc zdf hppyhkwfj }hlvf om zdf wviafgz#

• Kc zdf pyfphyhzkoc om zdkw hppyhkwhl zdf pdozonyhpdw dh}f iffc jknkz kqfj# Hll pdozow hyf hggvyhzf yfpyfwfczhzkocw om

zdf pyopfyzkfw # Jvf zo fxvkpbfcz bhlmvcgzkoc, ihj lkndzkcn, pooy hggfww, oy ozdfy pyoilfbw, wobf pdozow vwfj bh{

gobf myob hppyhkwfy .w o~c wzoge, oy myob loghl yfhlzoyw, hnfczw, BLW, oy ozdfy wovygfw# Hz zkbfw, ~dfc zdf wzyffz

pdozo om h gobphyhilf wdo~w ocl{ h nhzf, h wzoge oy BLW pdozo om zdf hgzvhl dovwf b{ if vwfj, hw kz boyf

hggvyhzfl{ yfmlfgzw zdf pyopfyz{ , hcj hllo~w h ifzzfy hchl{wkw om k zw w kbklhykz kfw hcj jkmmfyfcgfw# Zdkw dhw co fmmfgz oc

zdf }fyhgkz{ oy kczfnykz{ om zdf mkchl fwzkbhzfj bhyefz }hlvf om zdf yfpoyz#

• Zdf Hbfykghcw ~kzd Jkwhiklk zkfw Hgz $HJH+ ifghbf fmmfgzk}f Ahcvhy{ 9=, 8;;9# Zdkw kcwpfgzkoc jofw coz yfpyfwfcz h

wpfgkmkg gobplkhcgf hchl{wkw zo jfzfybkcf km zdf pd{wkghl hwpfgzw bffz zdf HJH hggfwwkiklkz{ nvkjflkcfw# Zdkw

kcwpfgzkoc jofw coz wvnnfwz HJH gobplkhcgf# Wkcgf gobplkhcgf ftpfgzhzkocw ghc gdhcnf ~kzd fhgd o~cfy.w mkchcgkhl

hiklkz{ zo gvyf jfmkgkfcgkfw, zdf }hlvf om zdf wviafgz jofw coz gocwkjfy powwkilf cocgobplkhcgf#

Opkckocw oy fwzkbhzfw ftpyfwwfj dfyfkc yfpyfwfcz ovy ifwz avjnbfcz ivz wdovlj coz if gocwzyvfj hw hj}kgf oy yfgobbfcjhzkoc

z o h gz # Zdf hpp yh kw fy w do vl j i f goc zh gzf j ~ kz d hc{ xvf wzk oc w i fm oy f zd kw y fp oy z k w y f lk fj v poc mo y j fg kw ko c bhe kc n# Zdk whppyhkwhl yfpyfwfczw hc fwzkbhzf om }hlvf ihwfj oc hc hchl{wkw om kcmoybhzkoc eco~c zo vw hz zdf zkbf zdf hppyhkwhl ~hw

gobplfzfj# Kmcf~ jhzh oy jogvbfczhzkoc kw pyo}kjfj, zdf }hlvf kc zdkw yfpoyz bh{ gdhcnf ihwfj oc zdf cf~ jhzh#

Zdf yfhjfy om zdkw yfpoyz wdovlj yfhlkqf zdhz zdf pdozonyhpdw om zdf gobphyhilf whlfw vwfj kc zdkw yfpoyz bh{ yfmlfgz zdfky

gocjkz koc hw om zdf jhzf om jyk}f"i{ hchl{wkw , ivz jo coz cfgfwwhyk l{ yfmlfgz zdfky gocjkzkoc hw om zdfky jhzf om whlf# Kcmoybhzkoc

pyo}kjfj kc zdf yfpoyz yfnhyjkcn zdf gobphyhilfw yfmlfgzw zdfky gocjkzkoc hw om zdfky whlf jhzf#

Zdkw hppyhkwhl hwwkncbfcz kw zo fwzkbhzf zdf bhyefz }hlvf, hw om zdf fmmfgzk}f jhzf, ~kzdovz zdf kcmlvfcgf om hc{ glowkcn gowzw

hyyhcnfbfczw oy zdf kcglvwkoc om hc{ pfywochl pyopfyz{# Zdf hppyhkwhl hwwkncbfcz jofw coz hllo~ zdfwf zo dh}f hc{ }hlvf oy

kcmlvfcgf oc zdf mkchl fwzkbhzfj bhyefz }hlvf om zdf wviafgz pyopfyz{#

HKljfcjKKc Phnf 9 gz 6

Page 28: Ebert Appraisal Service Inc Office of the Real Estate Appraisers (OREA) Complaint for Appraisal Fraud

8/6/2019 Ebert Appraisal Service Inc Office of the Real Estate Appraisers (OREA) Complaint for Appraisal Fraud

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ebert-appraisal-service-inc-office-of-the-real-estate-appraisers-orea-complaint 28/32

Vpnyhjfw hcj Yfbojflkcn zo Wviafgz

Hppyot *960,000 kc vpnyhjfw wkcgf 8;;=#

Hll cf~ ekzgdfc ghikcfzw, govczfyw, mktzvyfwNyhckzf govczfyzopw,

Cf~ Ivklz Kcw

Yfgfww Lkndzkcn#

Nyhckzf Govczfyw

Cf~ Mkyfplhgf

Cf~fy Dhyj~ooj Mlooyw zdyovndovz

Cf~fy Dhcj Zyo~fllfj Wboozd Wzvggo ftzfykoy

Hll Cf~ Lhcjwghpkcn

Bhyilf Govczfyw kc Ihzdw

Goppfy Nvzzfyw - Jo~cwpovzw

Cf~ Yoom

Cf~ ^kcjo~w kc zdf myocz om zdf dobfCf~ Myocz Jooyw hcj Fczy{~h{

Goppfy Plvbikcn Iozd Doykqoczhl - ]fyzkghlOgfhc ]kf~ ihlgoc{/phzko

Hll Wlhzf jyk}f~h{

Hll Wlhzf myocz ~hle~h{, poygd - dhyjwghpkcn

Yfhy Phzko om Goyhl WzocfYfgfww Lkndzkcn kc hll yoobw

Hll Wlhzf Bhkliot

Hll Cf~ Ovzjooy Lkndzkcn myocz hcj ihgeFtzfykoy Z] hcj Ovzjooy Wpfhefyw

Hll ^ooj Wdvzzfyw kc f}fy{ yoob#

Hll Cf~ Jooy hcj Mlooy Bovljkcnw

Glhykmkghzkoc om Wgopf om^oye

Zdf pvypowf om zdkw hppyhkwhl kw zo fwz kbhzf zdf Bhyefz ]hlvf $wff hzzhgdfj+ om zdf wviafgz pyopfyz{ zo hwwkwz kc gollhzfyhl

hwwfwwbfcz# Zdkw hppyhkwhl yfpoyz kwpyfphyfj moy zdf wolf hcj ftglvwk}f vwf om zdf glkfcz $zdf Kczfcjfj Vwfy+ zo hwwkwz ~k zd zdf

boyznhnf lfcjkcn jfgkwkocw#

Zdf Kczfcjfj Vwfy om zdkw hppyhkwhl yfpoyz kw zdf Lfcjfy/Glkfcz # Zdf Kczfcjfj Vwf kw zo f}hlvhzf zdf pyopfyz{ zdhz kwzdf wviafgz

om zdkw hppyhkwhl moy fwzhzf }hlvhzkoc, wviafgz zo zdf wzhzfj Wgopf om ^oye, pvypowf om zdf hppyhkwhl, yfpoyzkcn yfxvkyfbfczw om

zdkw hppyhkwhl yfpoyz moyb, hcj Jfmkckzkoc om Bhyefz ]hlvf# Co hjjkzkochl Kczfcjfj Vwfyw hyf kjfczkmkfj i{ zdf hppyhkwfy#

Zdkw yfpoyz bh{ goczhkc gobbfczw, gocjkzkocw, hcj/oy gfyzkmkghzkocw hjjfj i{ zdf wknckcn hppyhkwfy hcj/oy Fifyz Hppyhkwhl

Wfy}kgf, Kcg# kcglvjkcn, ivz coz lkbkzfj zo, zdkw Wvpplfbfczhl Hjjfcjvb# Zdfwf kzfbw wdhll wvpfywfjf hcj zhef pyfgfjfcgf o}fy

hll ozdfy lhcnvhnf, yfxvkyfbfczw, oy gocjkzkocw goczhkcfj kc hc{ pyfpykczfj hcj/oy zdkyj"phyz{ moybw oy jogvbfczw kcglvjfj kc,

oy kcgoypoyhzfj i{ yfmfyfcgf kczo, zdf hppyhkwhl yfpoyz#

O~cfywdkp om Kczfllfgzvhl Pyopfyz{ hcj/oy Jhzh "Fifyz Hppyhkwhl Wfy}kgf, Kcg# ftpyfwwl{ yfzhkcw hll ykndz, zkzlf,

hcj kczfyfwz kc hll phzfczw, zyhjfbhyew, zyhjf chbfw, zyhjf wfgyfzw, womz~hyf, jhzh, gocglvwkocw, opkckocw, }hlvhzkocw, oy ozdfy

kcmoybhzkoc kcglvjfj kc, hykwkcn ovz om, oy kc hc{ ~h{ yflhzfj zo zdkw hppyhkwhl oy zdf pyo}kwkoc om hppyhkwhl wfy}kgfw zo zdf

chbfj glkfcz hcj/oy Kczfcjfj Vwfy# Zdf yfpoyz hcj kcmoybhzkoc wvpplkfj i{ zdf wzhmm hcjloy hnfczw om Fifyz Hppyhkwhl Wfy}kgf,

Kcg# kw h gvlbkchzkoc om kczfllfgzvhl fjvghzkoc, pyomfwwkochl ftpfykfcgf,- pfywochl kc}fwzknhzkoc, ~dkgd wdhll hz hll zkbfw

yfbhkc zdf pyopfyz{ om Fifyz Hppyhkwhl Wfy}kgf, Kcg# Co pfywoc wdhll if fcz kzlfj zo iyfhe jo~c, wzykp ovz, bkcf, oy jkwwfbkchzf

hc{ gobpocfcz oy phyz om zdkw yfpoyz #

Hjfxvhg{ om Wgopf " Zdf hppyhkwfy dhw pyopowfj hcj zdf Glkfcz dhw hnyffj $pykoy zo wvibkwwkoc+ zdhz zdf lf}fl om

jf}flopbfcz hcj yfpoyzkcn jfzhklfj hio}f kw wvmmkgkfcz zo hjjyfww zdf wviwzhczkhzf gykzfykh om h yfhwochilf Wgopf om ^oye

~kzdkc zdf goczftz om zdf Kczfcjfj Vwfyw hcj Kczfcjfj Vwf# ^kzd zdf ftgfpzkoc om yf}kwkocw bhjf moy zdf pvypowf om

goyyfgzkoc om hc{ fyyoyw, zdf Hppyhkwfy jofw coz hczkgkphzf mvyzdfy jf}flopbfcz oy yfpoyzkcn yfxvkyfbfczw moy zdkw hwwkncbfcz#

Hc{ hjjkzkochl yfxvfwzw myob zdf Glkfcz oy hc{ zdkyj phyzkfw bh{ yfpyfwfcz h gdhcnf kc zdf hwwkncbfcz gocjkzkocw hcj yfxvkyf

zdf jf}flopbfcz om h cf~ hwwkncbfcz#

Zdf hppyhkwhl kw ihwfj oc zdf kcmoybhzkoc nhzdfyfj i{ zdf hppyhkwfy myob pvilkg yfgoyjw, ozdfy kjfczkmkfj wovygfw, gobplfzf

} kwvh l oiwfy}h zkoc o mzdf kczfy ko y hcj ft zf ykoy o m zdf wvi afgz p yopfyz{, k zw cfkndio ydooj, hcj wflfg zkoc o m gobphyhi lf w hlfw~kzdkc zdf wviafgz.w bhyefz hyfh# Zdf oyknkchl wovygf om zdf gobphyhilfw kw wdo~c kc zdf Jhzh Wovygf wfgzkoc omzdf bhyefz

nykj hlocn ~kzd zdf wovygf om gocmkybhzkoc, km h}hklhilf# Zdf wovygfw hcj jhzh hyf gocwkjfyfj yflkhilf# ^dfc gocmlkgzkcn

kcmoybhzkoc ~hw pyo}kjfj, zdf wovygf jffbfj bowz yflkhilf dhw iffc vwfj#

Zdf hppyhkwfy kwcoz h dobf kcwpfgzoy hcj zdf hppyhkwhl yfpoyz kw coz h dobf kcwpfgzkoc# Zdf hppyhkwhl yfpoyz ghccoz if yflkfj

vpoc zo jkwglowf dkjjfc jfmfgzw zdhz hyf coz hpphyfcz myob h }kwvhl oiwfy}hzkoc om zdf wvymhgfw om zdf wviafgz pyopfyz{ myob

wzhcjkcn dfkndz# Zdf zfwzkcn om w{wzfbw $wzyvgzvyhl, flfgzykghl, bfgdhckghl, dfhzkcn, goolkcn, plvbikcn+ hcj gobpocfczw $wvgd

hw hpplkhcgfw, mktzvyfw, jooyw, ~kcjo~w, fzg#+ lkfw ovzwkjf om zdf wgopf om zdkw hppyhkwhl hwwkncbfcz#Zdkw yfpoyz kw coz kczfcjfj

moy vwf i{ zdf ioyyo~fy moy zdf pvypowf om kjfczkm{kcn hc{ hj}fywf gocjkz kocw kc zdf wviafgz. w w{wzfbw hcj gobpocfczw ~dkgd

bkndz if yf}fhlfj i{ hc{ kcwpfgzkocw i{ lkgfcwfj pyomfwwkochlw kc hc{ yflf}hcz mkflj# Zdkw hppyhkwhl jofw coz nvhyhczff zdhz zdf

HjjfyjAb Phnf 8om 6

Page 29: Ebert Appraisal Service Inc Office of the Real Estate Appraisers (OREA) Complaint for Appraisal Fraud

8/6/2019 Ebert Appraisal Service Inc Office of the Real Estate Appraisers (OREA) Complaint for Appraisal Fraud

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ebert-appraisal-service-inc-office-of-the-real-estate-appraisers-orea-complaint 29/32

Vckmoyb Yfwkjfczkhl Hppyhkwhl Yfpoyz MklfCo# >0606BH

MFHZVYF K WVIAFGZ GOB.HYHILFHLFCO#: GOB.HYHILFWHLFCO#6 GOB.HYHILFWHLFCO#=

90:>6 YOGH GDKGH JY

HjjyfwwBHLKIV

8#:BK^

987>0 Yhbilh ] kw zh Wzyff z

HPC1 ::68"099"067

9060: Yogh Gdkgh Jyk}f

HPC1 ::60"08="08;

90:9= Yogh Gdkgh Jyk}f

HPC1 ::60"087"0>4

Pyotkbkz/c Wvikfgz 0#0= BK ^ 0#0= BK ^

WhlfPykGf * 0 Kw 9860000 Kw

BLW/Pvilkg Yfgoyj

%$"+ WB_,,,, JFWGYKPZKOC

Gvyyfcz Lkwzkcn

C/H

8,4;6,000 U w 84;6000

WhlfPykgf,Nyowwk}#Hyfh w 0#00 WX# Kz * =69#60 WX# Kzl * ;0>#6> wo#mz l w =4>#0; wo#mz l

c h z h Wovygf$w+ Kcwpfgzkoc BLW/Pvilkg Yfgoyj BLW/Pvilkg Yfgoyj

]fykmkghzkocWovygf$w+ Kcwpfgzkoc Jog' 9>9;:44 Gvyyfcz Lkwzkco Gvyyfcz Lkwzkco

]HLVFHJAVWZCFCZW JFWGYKPZKOC JFWGYKPZKOC #$"+WBv,,,,,,,,,, JFWGYKPZKOC %$"+ *Hj\# lw zbfcz

Whlfoy Mkchcgkcn

Gocgfwwkocw

Cocf Eco~c Goc}fczkochl

*8,>90000 8wz

Gvyyfcz Lkwzkcn

C/H

JhzfomWhlf/mkbf 06/900> Kcwoz 89/04/900=Glowfj LKWZKCN HJAWZ "96,000 LKWZKCN HJAWZ "96,000

Loghzkoc ]fy{ Nooj ]fy{ Nooj ]fy} Nooj ]fy} Nooj

LfhwfdolBffWkbolf Mff Wkbolf Mff Wkbplf MffWkbolf Mff Wkbolf

Wkzf

]kf~

8987=/89E Vwilf

Ogfhc, Gkz} L kzfw

6>6087000

Wkbklhy

; 00 00 9 40 :4 /8 00 00

WK Wvpfykoy

90 000 89;;4/6000

"800 ,000 WK Kcmfy ko y

>0000

800,000

JfwkocWz}lf+ Zyhjkzkochl Bfjkzfyyhcfhc Yhcgd Yhcgd

Ovhlkk.uomGocwzyvgzkoc Nooj Nooj Nooj Nooj

HgzvhlHgf 8;== 9009 8;=4 8;=4

Gocjkzkoc ]fy{ Nooj ]fy{ Nooj Wllcmfykoy 860 000 ]fy} Nooj

Hio}fNyhjf

YoobGovcz

Nyowwk} kcn Hyfh 800

Z O k h K K I . m K l K , a I h ) ) Z 0 K h 8 K I z l c c , a I h . )"60000 4878 7

96 000 Zos8 K I z l c c w # ( I h ) , 96000

9=0= WX# Kz

48 :8 7 48 78 6

7,9;6 WX# Kz "=4 ;00 9,044 wo# Kz

48 78 7

68 400 9,>64 WX Kz "86,900

Ihwfbfc z - Mkc kwdfj

YoobwIflo~Nyhjf

Cocf

Cocf

Cocf

Cocf

Cocf

Cocf

Cocf

Cocf

MvcgzkochlVzklkz/ Nooj Nooj Nooj Nooj

Dfhzkch## goolkch MHV/Cocf MHV/Gfczyhl "6 000 MHV/Gfczyhl "6000 MHV/Cocf

Fcfyn{Fmmkgkfczzfbw Cocf Cozfj Cocf Cozfj Cocf Cozfj Cocf Cozfj

Nhyhxf#Ghypoyz 9 Ghy Nhyhxf 9 GhyNhyhxf

9 Ghy NhyhofWkbklhy Wkbklhy

9 Ghy NhyhhfPoygdH.hzkoHAfge Poygd Phzko Jfge Wkbklhy

Ekzgdfc Cf~fy Vpjhzfj WK Wvp/JfwkXcfy "96,000 Wllcmfykoy 96,000 Wkbklhy

Pool, Wph Co Pool Co Wph Co Pool Co Wph Co Pool, Co Wph Co Pool, Co Wph

Mkyfolhgfzw+ 8 Mkyfplhgf 9 Mkyfplhgfw

CfzHjkvwzbfczZ ozhm+ UA% U t A " 8 *"6,000 9 Mkyfplhgfw "6,000 8 Mkyfplhgf

74,;00 mtl% yl" Kw 87=400 Utl% Ul" K w 86:,400

HjavwzfjWhlfPcgf

omGobohyhilfw

CfzHja# "8#4&& KNyowwB# 89#6)//[o *

CfzHja# >#9& & K CfzHja# 4#9& & K9 888 800 NyowwHjk#98#6,!!, K * 9 078 400 NyowwHjk #89#:,,//[o* 9 0:; 400

WVIAFGZ GOB.HYHILFHLFCO#: GOB.HYHILFWHLFCO#6 GOB.HYHILFWHLFCO#=ZFB

JhzfomPcoyWhlf/myhcwmfy Co Whlf Kc O}fy Co pyf}kovw whlf kc 8% }yw Co pyf}kovw whlf kc 8% }yw Co pyf}kovw whlf kc 8% {yw

PcgfomPykoyWhlf/myhcwmfy 7 [fhyw C/H C/H C/H

c h z h Wovygf$w+ BLW/Pvilkg Yfgoyj BLW/Pvilkg Yfgoyj BLW/Pvilkg Yfgoyj BLW/Pvilkg Yfgoyj

Fmmfgzk}fJhz((omJh8l(Wovygf$w+ 06/86/900> 06/86/900> 06/86/900> 06/86/900>

Wvbbhy{omWhlfwG o yc ph cw o c H pp yo h gd Wviafgz kw gobphzkilf zo zdf cfkodioydooj kc zfybw om wkqf, gocjkzkoc ovhlkz}# hcj hppfhl# Plfhwf wff

hjjkzkochl gobfhyhilfw hcj zdf hjjfcjvb gobbfczw# Cozf zdhz wobf hjkvwzbfczw ftgffj pyfmfyyfj lf}flw jvf zo zdf ~kjf yhcnf om

pyopfyzkfw hcj lhge om wkbklhy gobphyhilfw kc zdf hyfh# Zdkw jofw coz fm mfgz zdf }fyhg kz { om zdf mkchl fwzkbhzfj bhyefz }hlvf#

Myfjj f Blg yfb >0Blygd s Mhcckf Bf Moyb lG0:Bb1d tc5

800:#_X6G§-=

Page 30: Ebert Appraisal Service Inc Office of the Real Estate Appraisers (OREA) Complaint for Appraisal Fraud

8/6/2019 Ebert Appraisal Service Inc Office of the Real Estate Appraisers (OREA) Complaint for Appraisal Fraud

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ebert-appraisal-service-inc-office-of-the-real-estate-appraisers-orea-complaint 30/32

1+VBBHE[ Hz. z)EHK1+HL Ez 1z )VE K

Vckmoyb Yfwkjfczkhl Hppyhkwhl Yfpoyz M kl f C o # >0606BH

98# Zdf lfcjfy/glkfcz bh{ jkwglowf oy jkwzykivzf zdkw hppyhkwhl yfpoyz zo1 zdf ioyyo~fy5 hcozdfy lfcjfy hz zdf yfxvfwz om zdf ioyyo~fy5

zdf boyznhnff oy kzw wvggfwwoyw hcj hwwkncw5 boyznhnf kcwvyfyw5 no}fbbfcz wpocwoyfj fczfypykwfw5 ozdfy wfgocjhy{ bhyefz

phy zkgkphczw5 jh zh gol lfgzkoc oy yfpoy zkcn wfy} kgfw5 pyomfwwkochl hppyhkwh l oynhckqhz kocw5 hc{ jfphy zbfcz , hnfcg{, oy kcwzyvbfczhl kz{

om zdf Vckzfj Wzhzfw5 hcj hc{ wzhzf, zdf Jkwzykgz om Golvbikh, oy ozdfy avykwjkgz kocw5 ~kzdovz dh}kcn zo oizhkc zdf hppyhkwfy. w oy

wvpfy}kwoy{ hppyhkwfy.w $km hpplkghilf+ gocwfcz# Wvgd gocwfcz bvwz if oizhkcfj ifmoyf zdkw hppyhkwhl yfpoyz bh{ if jkwglowfj oy

jkwzykivzfj zo hc{ ozdfy phyz{ $kcglvjkcn, ivz coz lkbkzfj zo, zdf pvilkg zdyovnd hj}fyzkwkcn, pvilkg yflhzkocw, cf~w, whlfw, oy ozdfy

bfjkh+#

99# K hb h~hyf zdhz hc{ jkwglowvyf oy jkwzykivzkoc om zdkw hppyhkwhl yfpoyz i{ bf oy zdf lfcjfy/glkfcz bh{ if wviafgz zo gfyzhkc lh~w

hcj yfnvlhzkocw# Mvyzdfy, K hb hlwo wviafgz zo zdf pyo}kwkocw om zdf Vckmoyb Wzhcjhyjw om Pyomfwwkochl Hppyhkwhl Pyhgz kgf zdhz

pfyzhkc zo jkwglowvyf oy jkwz ykivzkoc i{ bf#

97# Zdf ioyyo~fy, hcozdfy lfcjfy hz zdf yfxvfwz om zdf ioyyo~fy, zdf boyznhnff oy kzw wvggfwwoyw hcj hwwkncw, boyznhnf kcwvyfyw,

no}fycbfcz wpocwoyfj fczfypykwfw, hcj ozdfy wfgocjhy{ bhyefz phyzkgkphczw bh{ yfl{ oc zdkw hppyhkwhl yfpoyz hw phyz om hc{

boyznhnf mkchcgf zyhcwhgzkoc zdhz kc}ol}fw hc{ocf oy boyf om zdfwf phyzkfw#

9:# Km zdkw hppyhkwhl yfpoyz ~hw z yhcwbkzzfj hw hc )flfgz yockg yfgoyj) goczhkckcn b{ )flfgzyockg wknchzvyf, ) hw zdowf zfybw hyf

jfmkcfj kc hpplkghilf mfjfyhl hcj/oy wzhzf lh~w $ftglvjkcn hvjko hcj }kjfo yfgoyjkcnw+, oy h mhgwkbklf zyhcwbkwwkoc om zdkw hppyhkwhl

yfpoyz goczhkckcn h gop{ oy yfpyfwfczhz koc om b{ wknchzvyf, zdf hppyhkwhl yfpoyz wdhll if hw fm mfgz k}f, fcmoygfhilf hcj }hlkj hw km h

phpfy }fyw koc om zdkw hppyhkwhl yfpoy z ~fyf jfl k}fyfj goczh kc kcn b{ oy knkch l dhcj ~yk zzfc w knch zvyf #

96# Hc{ kczfczkochl oy cfnlknfcz bkwyfpyfwfczhz koc$w+ goczhkcfj kc zdkw hppyhkwhl yfpoyz bh{ yfwvlz kc gk}kl lkhiklkz{ hcj/oy gykbkchl

pfchlzkfw kcglvjkcn, ivz coz lkbkzfj zo, mkcf oy kbpykwocbfcz oy iozd vcjfy zdf pyo}kwkocw om Zkzlf 84, Vckzfj Wzhzfw Gojf, Wfgz koc

8008, fz wfx#, oy wkbklhy wzhzf lh~w#

WVPFY]KWOY[ HPPYHKWFY.W GFYZKMKGHZKOC1 Zdf Wvpfy}kwoy{ Hppyhkwfy gfyz km kfw hcj hnyffw zdhz 1

8# K jkyfgzl{ wvpfy}kwfj zdf hppyhkwfy moy zdkw hppyhkwhl hwwkncbfcz, dh}f yfhj zdf hppyhkwhl yfpoyz, hcj hnyff ~kzd zdf hppyhkwfy. w

hch l{wkw , opkckocw, w zhzfbfczw, gocglvwkocw, hcj zdf hppyhkwfy .w gfy zk mk ghz koc#

9# K hggfpz mvll yfwpocwkiklkz{ moy zdf goczfczw om zdkw hppyhkwhl yfpoyz kcglvjkcn, ivz coz lkbkzfj zo, zdf hppyhkwfy.w hchl{wkw,

opkckocw, wzhzfbfczw, gocglvwkocw, hcj zdf hppyhkwfy .w gfyzk mkghzkoc#

7# Zdf hppyhkwfy kjfczkmkfj kc zdkw hppyhkwhl yfpoyz kw fkzdfy h wvi"goczyhgzoy oy hc fbplo{ff om zdf wvpfy}kwoy{ hppyhkwfy $oy zdf

hppyhkwhl mkyb+, kw xvhlkmkfj zo pfymoyb zdkw hppyhkwhl, hcj kw hggfpzhilf zo pfymoyb zdkw hppyhkwhl vcjfy zdf hpplkghilf wzhzf lh~#

:# Zdkw hppyhkwhl yfpoyz gobplkfw ~kzd zdf Vckmoyb Wzhcjhyjw om Pyomfwwkochl Hppyhkwhl Pyhgz kgf zdhz ~fyf hjopzfj hcj

pyobvlnhzfj i{ zdf Hppyhkwhl Wzhcjhyjw Iohyj om Zdf Hppyhkwhl Movcjhzkoc hcj zdhz ~fyf kc plhgf hz zdf zkbf zdkw hppyhkwhl

yfpoyz ~hw pyfphyfj#

6# Km zdkw hppyhkwhl yfpoyz ~hw zyhcwbkz zfj hw hc )flfgzyockg yfgoyj) goczhkckcn b{ )flfgzyockg wknchzvyf,) hw zdowf zfybw hyf

jfmkcfj kc hpplkghilf mfjfyhl hcj/oy wzhzf lh~w $ftglvjkcn hvjko hcj }kjfo yfgoyjkcnw+, oy h mhgwkbklf zyhcwbkwwkoc om zdkw hppyhkwhl

yfpoyz goczhkckcn h gop{ oy yfpyfwfczhzkoc om b{ wknchzvyf, zdf hppyhkwhl yfpoyz wdhll if hw fmmfgzk}f, fcmoygfhilf hcj }hlkj hw km h

phpfy }fywkoc o m zdkw hppyh kwhl yfpoy z ~fyf jf lk}fyfj goczhkckcn b{ oy knkch l dhcj ~yk zzfc w knchzvyf#

HPPYHKWFY WVPFY]KWOY[ HPPYHKWFY $OCL[ KM YFXVKYFJ+

Wknchzvyf s_# o##s Wknchzvyf

Chbf Ahbfu sifyz Chbf

Gobphc{ Ch\ kaf Fifyz H(8(8yh kwhl Wfy} kgf, Kcg# Gobphc{ Chbf

Gobphc{ Hjjyfww =74 Lkcjfyo G{c '78> Gobphc{ Hjjyfww

Ohe Phye, GH ;87>>

Zflfpdocf Cvbify 780#606#6;8= /K 484#;;8#;799 Zflfpdocf Cvbify

Fbhkl Hjjyfww ahbfw@fifyzh(8(8yhkwhlw#gob Fbhkl Hjjyfww

Jhzf o m W knchzvyf hcj Yfpoyz 06/84/900> Jhzf om Wknchzvyf

Fmmfgzk}f Jhzf om Hppyhkwhl Bh{ 8=, 900> Wzhzf Gfyzkmkghzkoc '

Wzhzf Gfyzkmkghzkoc ' HY 088444 oy Wzhzf Lkgfcwf '

oy Wzhzf Lkgfcwf ' Wzhzf

oy Ozdfy $jfwgykif+ Wzhzf ' Ftpkyhzkoc Jhzf om Gfyzkmkghzkoc oy Lkgfcwf

Wzhzf GH

Ftpk yh zkoc Jhzf om Gfyz km kghz koc oy L kgfcwf 80/07 /900>

HJJYFWW OM PYOPFYZ[ HPPYHKWFJ WVIAFGZ PYOPFYZ[

90:>6 YOGH GDKGH JY oJkj coz kcwpfgz wvi afgz pyopfyz{

BHLKIV, GH ;09=6 oJkj kcwpfgz ftzfy koy o m wviafgz pyopfy z{ m yob wzyff z

Jhzf om Kcwpfgzkoc

HPPYHKWFJ ]HLVF OM WVIAFGZ PYOPFYZ[ * 9,800,000 oJkj kcwpfgz kczfy ko y hcj ftzfykoy om wviafgz pyopfy z{

Jhzf om Kcwpfgzkoc

LFCJFY/GLKFCZ

Chbf GOBPHYHILF WHLFW

Gobphc{ Chbf ^fllw Mhbo Fnv((A8 Jkyfg z HQ HV'0>:9: o Jkj coz kcwpfgz ftzfykoy om gobphyhilf whlfw myob wzyffz

Gobphc{ Hjj yf ww 8 8= 08 C I lh ge Ghcso c Ds 9cj M lo o y oJkj kcwpfg z f t zf y ko y o m gobphyhi lf whl f w m yob w zyf f zPdofckt, HQ 4609; Jhzf om Kcwpfgzkoc

Fbhkl Hjjyfww bhykhjfycbf@nbhkl#gob

_ ######### y__ )) ####_ ###,#####) "_ #

s#" " # " " " " ## " " " # " # # # # " ## ""s))# # # # "

Page 31: Ebert Appraisal Service Inc Office of the Real Estate Appraisers (OREA) Complaint for Appraisal Fraud

8/6/2019 Ebert Appraisal Service Inc Office of the Real Estate Appraisers (OREA) Complaint for Appraisal Fraud

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ebert-appraisal-service-inc-office-of-the-real-estate-appraisers-orea-complaint 31/32

YF1 Mhnhc }# Fifyz Hppykwh8 wfy}kgf Kcg fz, hl WGKKQ0::"

YF1 Mhnhc }# Fifyz mz#ppykwhl Wfy}kgf Kcg fz# hl WG8890:: Mykjh{, Bh{ =, 9088 #

Hw {ov eco~ nk}fc b{ bowz yfgfcz mkcjkcnw om mhgz hw pyfwfczfj zo OYFH# hc MHG ghc kcglvjf hjjkzkochl

ghvwfw om hgzkoc ~dkgd ifghvwf om zdf zkbf zdhz kz zooe moy bf zo Jkwgo}fy {ovy glkfcmw myhvj, ~ovlj

goczkcvf zo if }khilf#

JFBHCJ

Plfhwf hlwo gocwkjfy zdf mollo~kcn ~dfc hwwfwwkcn zdf }hlvf om b{ glhkb hnhkcwz {ovy glkfcz5

Wzhcjhyj om Ghyf

Kc Ghlkmoyckh zdfyf kw co wpfgkm kg szhzvzoy{ jfmkckzkoc om zdf wzhcjhyj om ghyf om h lkgfcwfj yfhl fwzhzf

hppyhkwfy# Yhzdfy, Ghlkmoyckh wzhzVzf pyo}kjfw zdhz )Nlf Vckmoyb Wzhcjhyjw om Pyomfwwkochl Hppyhkwhl

Pyhgzkgf gocwzkzvzf zdf bkckbvb wzhcjhyj om gocjvgz hcj pfymoybhcgf moy h lkgfcwff kc hc{ ~oye oy wfy}kgf

pfymoybfj zdhz kw hjjyfwwfj i{ zdowf wzhcjhyjw#) $Ghlkmoyckh Ivwkcfww hcj Pyomfwwkocw Gojf ®8878;#+

Jvz{Hppyhkwfyw o~f h jvz{ zo hgz ~kzd zdhz jfnyff om wekl) pyvjfcgf hcj jklknfcgf ~dkgd yfhl fwzhzf hppyhkwfyw

om oyjkchy{ wekll hcj ghphgkz{ gobbocl{ powwf ww hcj ft),1 f a wf kc zdf pfymoybhcgf o m zdf zhwew zdf{

vcjfyzhef# $Wbkzd }# Lf~kw $8;>6r 87 Ghl#7j 7:;,76= hcj Ivjj }# Cktfc $8;>8+ = Ghl#7j 8;6, 900#+ H

iyfhgd om zdhz wzhcjhyj om ghyf kc zdf pfymoybhcgf om hc hppyhkwfy.w jvz{ bh{ zdvw nk}f ykwf zo lkhiklkz{ moy

pyomfwwkochl cfnlknfcgf#

Cfnlknfcz Bkwyfpyfwfczhzkoc

Hc hppyhkwfy b h{ if lkhilf oc h zdfoy{ om cfnlknfcz bkwyfpyfwfczhzkoc zo zdkyj phyzkfw ~do avwzkmkhil{ yf:{oc

zdf hppyhkwhl yfpoyz kc h phyzkgvlhy zyhcwhgzkoc oy z{pf om zyhcwhgzkoc ~dkgd zdf hppyhkwfy kczfcjfj zokcmlvfcgf# $IV{ }# Hyzdvy [ovcn - Go# $8;;9+ 7 Ghl#:zd 7>0, 7>=5 Wojfyifyn }# BgEkccf{ $8;;=+ ::

Ghl#Hpp#:zd 8>=0, 8>=7#+

Kz cffj coz if wdo~c zdhz zdf hppyhkwfy, ~dfc dkyfj, ecf~ zdf chbfw oy Wpfgkmkg kjfczkzkfw om zdf zdkyj

ph yzk f w# L khi kl kz { bh{ if kbpowfj ~df yf zd f h pp yh kw fy )eco~w ~kzd wviwzhczkhl gfyzhkcz{ zdhz plhkczkmm , oy zdf

phyzkgvlhy glhww om pfywocw zo ~dkgd plhkczkmm iflocnw, ~kll yfl{ oc zdf yfpyfwfczhzkoc kc zdf govywf om zdf

zyhcwhgzkoc# J $Wojfyifyn }# BgEkccf{, wvpyh, :: Ghl#Hpp#:zd hz 8>=4, xvozkcn Ikl{ }#Hyzdvy [ovcn -Go#•

wvpyh, 7 Ghl#:zd hz :8: $fbpdhwkw hjjfj+#+

Coy kw kz fwwfczkhl zdhz zdf hppyhkwfy goczfbplhzfj zdf pyfgkwf jfzhklw om zdf zyhcwhgzkoc kc ~dkgd dkw oy dfy

Page 32: Ebert Appraisal Service Inc Office of the Real Estate Appraisers (OREA) Complaint for Appraisal Fraud

8/6/2019 Ebert Appraisal Service Inc Office of the Real Estate Appraisers (OREA) Complaint for Appraisal Fraud

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ebert-appraisal-service-inc-office-of-the-real-estate-appraisers-orea-complaint 32/32