Top Banner
Economics 4 / Management 4 Financial Accounting Accounting Policies & Earnings Management Updated 09/02/16 Ugly Puppy Periods 1 - 3
42

Earnings Management - University of California, San Diegoquote.ucsd.edu/willoughby/files/2016/09/Ugly-Puppy-1-3.pdfEarnings Management . Updated 09/02/16 . Ugly Puppy . Periods 1 -

May 23, 2020

Download

Documents

dariahiddleston
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: Earnings Management - University of California, San Diegoquote.ucsd.edu/willoughby/files/2016/09/Ugly-Puppy-1-3.pdfEarnings Management . Updated 09/02/16 . Ugly Puppy . Periods 1 -

Economics 4 / Management 4 Financial Accounting

Accounting Policies &

Earnings Management

Updated 09/02/16

Ugly Puppy Periods 1 - 3

Page 2: Earnings Management - University of California, San Diegoquote.ucsd.edu/willoughby/files/2016/09/Ugly-Puppy-1-3.pdfEarnings Management . Updated 09/02/16 . Ugly Puppy . Periods 1 -

Analyzing Accounting Choices Analysis is a systematic process of comparison.

Using a simple business model, we will systematically compare the financial reporting

results of: • two separate sets of accounting policies for … • one set of business events. This will demonstrate FORM (different reports) over

SUBSTANCE/REALITY (one transactions)

Page 3: Earnings Management - University of California, San Diegoquote.ucsd.edu/willoughby/files/2016/09/Ugly-Puppy-1-3.pdfEarnings Management . Updated 09/02/16 . Ugly Puppy . Periods 1 -

What is the role of Policies?

• Policies are guidelines for dealing with events.

• Policies tell us what we ought to do in general - be nice to others, or in particular - drive slowly around children.

• Policies are especially important when things get confusing or when unusual things happen.

Page 4: Earnings Management - University of California, San Diegoquote.ucsd.edu/willoughby/files/2016/09/Ugly-Puppy-1-3.pdfEarnings Management . Updated 09/02/16 . Ugly Puppy . Periods 1 -

Policies, continued • One’s policies should be evident from

one’s actions.

• Parents teach policies and sometimes even follow them.

• Dating is a process of learning another person’s policies.

• Donald Trump doesn’t seem to have any policies; Hilary seems to change hers’ frequently.

Page 5: Earnings Management - University of California, San Diegoquote.ucsd.edu/willoughby/files/2016/09/Ugly-Puppy-1-3.pdfEarnings Management . Updated 09/02/16 . Ugly Puppy . Periods 1 -
Page 6: Earnings Management - University of California, San Diegoquote.ucsd.edu/willoughby/files/2016/09/Ugly-Puppy-1-3.pdfEarnings Management . Updated 09/02/16 . Ugly Puppy . Periods 1 -

What is the role of an Accounting Policy?

Accounting policies are guidelines for: a) Making estimates – because accurate

measurements are difficult & expense; b) Analyzing & Interpreting transactions – because

some transactions are complex; c) Communicating contingencies (what if’s and

maybe’s) – because life is mostly about dealing with if’s & maybe’s; and

d) Recognizing Revenues & Expenses – answering: when is something completely “earned”.

Page 7: Earnings Management - University of California, San Diegoquote.ucsd.edu/willoughby/files/2016/09/Ugly-Puppy-1-3.pdfEarnings Management . Updated 09/02/16 . Ugly Puppy . Periods 1 -

Our illustrative firm has a Business Model that proposes several Profit

Centers.

1. Consulting services;

2. Retail Sales (of T-shirts);

3. Celebrity appearances and, maybe …

4. … an Instagram Account

Page 8: Earnings Management - University of California, San Diegoquote.ucsd.edu/willoughby/files/2016/09/Ugly-Puppy-1-3.pdfEarnings Management . Updated 09/02/16 . Ugly Puppy . Periods 1 -

What accounting policies do …

Accounting policies (which are adopted by

management) will tell the accounting

department how to measure and classify day-

to-day transactions.

Page 9: Earnings Management - University of California, San Diegoquote.ucsd.edu/willoughby/files/2016/09/Ugly-Puppy-1-3.pdfEarnings Management . Updated 09/02/16 . Ugly Puppy . Periods 1 -

Implications of accounting policies …

• Accounting policies will influence the firm’s financial reporting results;

• Two firms with different accounting policies, even though experiencing the same business activities & transactions, will report different to Sales, Expenses, Profits, Assets, and Liabilities.

Page 10: Earnings Management - University of California, San Diegoquote.ucsd.edu/willoughby/files/2016/09/Ugly-Puppy-1-3.pdfEarnings Management . Updated 09/02/16 . Ugly Puppy . Periods 1 -

Specific Accounting Policies:

1) What costs are Capitalized or Expensed.

2) How “capitalized costs” are Amortized.

3) In what order do “inventory costs” flow through

COGS.

4) How “contingencies” are reported. 5) How strictly is the earnings process is

measured.

6) How “bad things” are reported.

Page 11: Earnings Management - University of California, San Diegoquote.ucsd.edu/willoughby/files/2016/09/Ugly-Puppy-1-3.pdfEarnings Management . Updated 09/02/16 . Ugly Puppy . Periods 1 -

A firm can report different financial results, meaning different Profits, simply by

modifying its accounting policies.

Form versus Substance

Page 12: Earnings Management - University of California, San Diegoquote.ucsd.edu/willoughby/files/2016/09/Ugly-Puppy-1-3.pdfEarnings Management . Updated 09/02/16 . Ugly Puppy . Periods 1 -

Form = Reported Effect

Substance = Cause

Page 13: Earnings Management - University of California, San Diegoquote.ucsd.edu/willoughby/files/2016/09/Ugly-Puppy-1-3.pdfEarnings Management . Updated 09/02/16 . Ugly Puppy . Periods 1 -

Period 1 Ugly Puppy Events 1) Issue 200 shares of stock for $1 each. 2) Acquire an Ugly Puppy for $100, cash. 3) Buy T-shirts in three successive cost layers as: 4) 10 shirts @ $1 each, cash. 5) 10 shirts @ $2 each, cash. 6) 10 shirts @ $3 each, cash. 7) Consult 40 clients and 30 pay the $1 each; 10

promise to pay later. 8) Sell 10 T-shirts at $5 each, cash.

Page 14: Earnings Management - University of California, San Diegoquote.ucsd.edu/willoughby/files/2016/09/Ugly-Puppy-1-3.pdfEarnings Management . Updated 09/02/16 . Ugly Puppy . Periods 1 -

Capitalizing and Amortizing the Puppy’s Cost

Cost is $ 100

If this Cost is Capitalized, i.e. classified as an Asset, then the Cost must be Amortized. This involves two decisions: 1) What is the expected resale value or disposal

cost of this asset? 2) Over how many periods can we expect this

asset to be useful in the firms current business model?

Page 15: Earnings Management - University of California, San Diegoquote.ucsd.edu/willoughby/files/2016/09/Ugly-Puppy-1-3.pdfEarnings Management . Updated 09/02/16 . Ugly Puppy . Periods 1 -

Capitalizing and Amortizing the Puppy’s Cost

Expected cost recovery is $ 0; thus, Amortizable Basis is $ 100 - $ 0 = $100.

• AGG gives the amortizable basis a 4-period life

• CON gives it a 3-period life.

Amortization Schedules:

Period 1 2 3 4

1. AGG $ 25 $ 25 $ 25 $ 25

2. CON $ 33 $ 33 $ 33 $ 0

Page 16: Earnings Management - University of California, San Diegoquote.ucsd.edu/willoughby/files/2016/09/Ugly-Puppy-1-3.pdfEarnings Management . Updated 09/02/16 . Ugly Puppy . Periods 1 -

As we sell T-shirts, we need to expense (as COGS) the cost of “some”, not necessarily “those” specific T-shirts. This is a “cost” issue, not an “item” issue.

Management decides a policy that tells the accounting department what costs to expense.

Inventory Cost Flow Policies

Page 17: Earnings Management - University of California, San Diegoquote.ucsd.edu/willoughby/files/2016/09/Ugly-Puppy-1-3.pdfEarnings Management . Updated 09/02/16 . Ugly Puppy . Periods 1 -

FIFO means First In, First Out The first costs we pay ever, are the first costs that we expense.

LIFO means Last In, First Out The last costs we pay in any accounting period, are the first costs that we expense. Just think about how people get on-and-off an

elevator floor-by-floor.

The Cost Flow policy options? FIFO or LIFO

Page 18: Earnings Management - University of California, San Diegoquote.ucsd.edu/willoughby/files/2016/09/Ugly-Puppy-1-3.pdfEarnings Management . Updated 09/02/16 . Ugly Puppy . Periods 1 -

Use FIFO as the Aggressive choice.

• The $ 1 cost layer goes to COGS first, thus the $ 2 and $ 3 layers are LISH, ending inventory.

Use LIFO as the Conservative choice. • The $ 3 cost layer goes to COGS first, thus

the $ 1 and $ 2 layers are FISH ending inventory.

We sold 10 T-shirts

Page 19: Earnings Management - University of California, San Diegoquote.ucsd.edu/willoughby/files/2016/09/Ugly-Puppy-1-3.pdfEarnings Management . Updated 09/02/16 . Ugly Puppy . Periods 1 -

We consulted forty customers, but ten customers who did not pay the $1 fee.

However, each of those customers promised to pay in the future.

We will report $10 in Receivables.

Credit Sales

Page 20: Earnings Management - University of California, San Diegoquote.ucsd.edu/willoughby/files/2016/09/Ugly-Puppy-1-3.pdfEarnings Management . Updated 09/02/16 . Ugly Puppy . Periods 1 -

When a firm makes a credit sale, it sells on-account, it is holding a customer’s debt. • Will the customer pay the debt? • All of it? • When? How should the firm communicate the risk of not getting paid ?

Reporting (or not) the reality of collecting a debt.

Page 21: Earnings Management - University of California, San Diegoquote.ucsd.edu/willoughby/files/2016/09/Ugly-Puppy-1-3.pdfEarnings Management . Updated 09/02/16 . Ugly Puppy . Periods 1 -

A contingency means that A is related to B happening in the future.

• You getting your UCSD diploma is contingent on you passing all of the required courses.

• You getting a job is contingent on someone making a positive hiring decision in your favor.

• You getting married is contingent on someone falling into your trap.

Contingencies

Page 22: Earnings Management - University of California, San Diegoquote.ucsd.edu/willoughby/files/2016/09/Ugly-Puppy-1-3.pdfEarnings Management . Updated 09/02/16 . Ugly Puppy . Periods 1 -

Many of the book values reported on a firm’s Balance Sheet are unlikely to result in exactly

that value in cash.

This is a Book Value versus Market Value question: are we likely to collect the $10 value of the Receivables as $10 in cash?

The correct answer is “it depends”, or “maybe”.

When Reported Values are Contingent?

Page 23: Earnings Management - University of California, San Diegoquote.ucsd.edu/willoughby/files/2016/09/Ugly-Puppy-1-3.pdfEarnings Management . Updated 09/02/16 . Ugly Puppy . Periods 1 -

• How do we say “maybe” in Accounting? • Do we always want to say “maybe”?

Allowances are accrual accounting’s way of

quantifying maybe.

An Allowance is the amount by which we believe that the eventual Market Value of an Asset might

fall below the currently-reported Book Value.

Putting a number on “maybe”?

Page 24: Earnings Management - University of California, San Diegoquote.ucsd.edu/willoughby/files/2016/09/Ugly-Puppy-1-3.pdfEarnings Management . Updated 09/02/16 . Ugly Puppy . Periods 1 -

Layer COGS Layer COGS

$ 10 ( $ 10) $ 10

$ 20 $ 20

$ 30 $ 30 ( $ 30)

Inventory Cost Flows AGG CON

FIFO / LISH LIFO/FISH

Page 25: Earnings Management - University of California, San Diegoquote.ucsd.edu/willoughby/files/2016/09/Ugly-Puppy-1-3.pdfEarnings Management . Updated 09/02/16 . Ugly Puppy . Periods 1 -

The 1st Period - Aggressive policies Starting Rev 90 COGS (10) GP 80 G&A ( 0) EBITDA 80 DA (25) EBIT 55 I ( 0) EBT 55 T ( 0) NI 55

200

0

( 0)

0

0

0

0

(0)

0

0

0

0

200

0

120

10

( 0)

50

0

0

100

(25)

0

0

0

0

200

55

Page 26: Earnings Management - University of California, San Diegoquote.ucsd.edu/willoughby/files/2016/09/Ugly-Puppy-1-3.pdfEarnings Management . Updated 09/02/16 . Ugly Puppy . Periods 1 -

The 1st Period - Conservative policies Starting Rev 90 COGS (30) GP 60 G&A (10) EBITDA 50 DA (33) EBIT 17 I ( 0) EBT 17 T ( 0) NI 17

200

0

( 0)

0

0

0

0

(0)

0

0

0

0

200

0

120

10

(10)

30

0

0

100

(33)

0

0

0

0

200

17

Page 27: Earnings Management - University of California, San Diegoquote.ucsd.edu/willoughby/files/2016/09/Ugly-Puppy-1-3.pdfEarnings Management . Updated 09/02/16 . Ugly Puppy . Periods 1 -

Comparisons

• Period #1

Profits Assets Liabilities

Aggressive $ 55 $ 255 $ 0

Conservative $ 17 $ 217 $ 0

Page 28: Earnings Management - University of California, San Diegoquote.ucsd.edu/willoughby/files/2016/09/Ugly-Puppy-1-3.pdfEarnings Management . Updated 09/02/16 . Ugly Puppy . Periods 1 -

A Few Observations

We have:

a) Two sets of Financials.

b) One business.

c) Two reporting forms

d) One (substance) set of events.

e) One asset, CA$H, that cannot be altered by Accounting Policies.

Page 29: Earnings Management - University of California, San Diegoquote.ucsd.edu/willoughby/files/2016/09/Ugly-Puppy-1-3.pdfEarnings Management . Updated 09/02/16 . Ugly Puppy . Periods 1 -

Period 2 1) Acquire a 2nd Ugly Puppy for $100 cash 2) Borrow $100 @ 7% interest on an interest-only

basis with interest due in subsequent periods 3) Purchase 20 T-shirts @ $4 each, pay cash for 10

and take 10 on-account. 4) Purchase ten 10# bags of dog food for $5 each,

$50 total cash. 5) Take both puppies to a Vet and pay $24 cash. 6) Consult 40 clients and 30 pay $1 each; 10

promise to pay later. 7) Sell 20 T-shirts at $5 each, cash.

Page 30: Earnings Management - University of California, San Diegoquote.ucsd.edu/willoughby/files/2016/09/Ugly-Puppy-1-3.pdfEarnings Management . Updated 09/02/16 . Ugly Puppy . Periods 1 -

Capitalizing or Expensing the Vet & Trainer Costs

Cost is $ 24. This is an accessory to the “puppy”.

Is it betterment or repair? Betterment gets capitalized and amortized; repair gets expensed.

If capitalized, then the usual treatment: • What amount of the cost is recoverable? • What life do we give the cost?

Page 31: Earnings Management - University of California, San Diegoquote.ucsd.edu/willoughby/files/2016/09/Ugly-Puppy-1-3.pdfEarnings Management . Updated 09/02/16 . Ugly Puppy . Periods 1 -

AGG Capitalizing the Costs • Give the 2nd puppy’s cost a 4 period life. • Give the Vet cost a 4-period life.

• AGG Amortization Schedule: • Period 1 2 3 4

$ 100 $ 25 $ 25 $ 25 $ 25 $ 0

$ 100 $ 25 $ 25 $ 25 $ 25

$ 24 $ 6 $ 6 $ 6 $ 6

Total $ 25 $ 56 $ 56 $ 56 $ 31

Page 32: Earnings Management - University of California, San Diegoquote.ucsd.edu/willoughby/files/2016/09/Ugly-Puppy-1-3.pdfEarnings Management . Updated 09/02/16 . Ugly Puppy . Periods 1 -

CON Capitalizing & Expensing the New Costs

• Give the 2nd puppy’s cost a 3 period life. • Expense the Vet Cost in SG&A.

• CON Amortization Schedule: • Period 1 2 3 4

$ 100 $ 33 $ 33 $ 34 $ 0 $ 0

$ 100 $ 33 $ 33 $ 34 $ 0

Total $ 33 $ 66 $ 67 $ 34

Page 33: Earnings Management - University of California, San Diegoquote.ucsd.edu/willoughby/files/2016/09/Ugly-Puppy-1-3.pdfEarnings Management . Updated 09/02/16 . Ugly Puppy . Periods 1 -

Puppy Food

We purchase 10 bags of dog food. $5 per = $50

• Book the food in Supplies; expense it in SG&A.

We don’t want to count, measure, etc how much food each puppy consumes each period - far too complicated for an accountant’s simple life. So we estimate.

• Let’s say one bag per puppy per period.

There really isn’t an AGG versus CON issue here.

Page 34: Earnings Management - University of California, San Diegoquote.ucsd.edu/willoughby/files/2016/09/Ugly-Puppy-1-3.pdfEarnings Management . Updated 09/02/16 . Ugly Puppy . Periods 1 -

Inventory Cost Flows AGG CON

FIFO / LISH LIFO/FISH

Layer COGS Layer COGS $ 10

$ 20 ( $ 20) $ 20 $ 30 ( $ 30) $ 80 $ 80 ( $ 80)

Page 35: Earnings Management - University of California, San Diegoquote.ucsd.edu/willoughby/files/2016/09/Ugly-Puppy-1-3.pdfEarnings Management . Updated 09/02/16 . Ugly Puppy . Periods 1 -

The 2nd Period - Aggressive Starting Rev 140 COGS (50) GP 90 G&A ( 10) EBITDA 80 DA ( 56) EBIT 24 I ( 7) EBT 17 T (0) NI 17

120

10

( 0)

50

0

0

100

(25)

0

0

0

0

200

55

176

20

( 0)

40

0

40

224

( 81)

0

40

7

100

200

72

Page 36: Earnings Management - University of California, San Diegoquote.ucsd.edu/willoughby/files/2016/09/Ugly-Puppy-1-3.pdfEarnings Management . Updated 09/02/16 . Ugly Puppy . Periods 1 -

The 2nd Period - Conservative Starting Rev 140 COGS (80) GP 60 G&A (44) EBITDA 16 DA ( 66) EBIT (50) I ( 7) EBT (57) T ( 0) NI (57)

120

10

(10)

30

0

0

100

( 33)

0

0

0

0

200

17

176

20

(20)

30

0

40

200

( 99)

0

40

7

100

200

(40)

Page 37: Earnings Management - University of California, San Diegoquote.ucsd.edu/willoughby/files/2016/09/Ugly-Puppy-1-3.pdfEarnings Management . Updated 09/02/16 . Ugly Puppy . Periods 1 -

Comparisons

• Period #2

Profits Assets Liabilities

Aggressive $ 17 $ 419 $ 147

Conservative ($ 57) $ 307 $ 147

Page 38: Earnings Management - University of California, San Diegoquote.ucsd.edu/willoughby/files/2016/09/Ugly-Puppy-1-3.pdfEarnings Management . Updated 09/02/16 . Ugly Puppy . Periods 1 -

Period 3 Pay the Payable and the Accrued Interest. 1) Purchase three periods of Advertising for $33

cash; 2) Purchase 10 T-shirts @ $4 each, cash. 3) Consult 40 clients and all pay $1 each, cash. 4) Collect $10 in outstanding Receivables. 5) Sell 25 T-shirts at $ 6 each, cash. 6) Purchase 10 T-shirts @ $5 each, cash. 7) Encounter a person who agrees to $100 for a

celebrity Puppy appearance – next period – and pays $50 cash now with balance due on performance.

8) Declare $ 50 in dividends.

Page 39: Earnings Management - University of California, San Diegoquote.ucsd.edu/willoughby/files/2016/09/Ugly-Puppy-1-3.pdfEarnings Management . Updated 09/02/16 . Ugly Puppy . Periods 1 -

Layer COGS Layer COGS $ 10 $ 20 ( $ 10)

$ 80 ( $ 80) $ 40 ( $ 20) $ 40 ( $ 40) $ 50 $ 50 ( $ 50)

Inventory Cost Flows AGG CON

FIFO / LISH LIFO/FISH

Page 40: Earnings Management - University of California, San Diegoquote.ucsd.edu/willoughby/files/2016/09/Ugly-Puppy-1-3.pdfEarnings Management . Updated 09/02/16 . Ugly Puppy . Periods 1 -

The 3rd Period - Aggressive Starting Rev 240 COGS (100) GP 140 G&A ( 21) EBITDA 119 DA ( 56) EBIT 63 I ( 7) EBT 56 T ( 0) NI 56

136

20

( 0)

80

0

40

224

(81)

0

40

7

100

200

72

226

10

( 0)

70

22

30

224

(137)

0

0

7

100

50

200

( 78)

Page 41: Earnings Management - University of California, San Diegoquote.ucsd.edu/willoughby/files/2016/09/Ugly-Puppy-1-3.pdfEarnings Management . Updated 09/02/16 . Ugly Puppy . Periods 1 -

The 3rd Period - Conservative Starting Rev 190 COGS (100) GP 90 G&A ( 11) +10 EBITDA 79 DA ( 67) EBIT 12 I ( 7) EBT 5 T ( 0) NI 5

136

20

(20)

30

0

40

200

( 99)

0

40

7

100

200

(40)

226

10

(10)

10

22

30

200

(166)

50

0

7

100

50

200

( 85)

Page 42: Earnings Management - University of California, San Diegoquote.ucsd.edu/willoughby/files/2016/09/Ugly-Puppy-1-3.pdfEarnings Management . Updated 09/02/16 . Ugly Puppy . Periods 1 -

Comparisons

• Period #3

Profits Assets Liabilities

Aggressive $ 56 $ 435 $ 157

Conservative $ 5 $ 322 $ 207