Draft Copy May 08, 2009 MEDICAL DEVICES: SECTOR ANALYSIS Submitted To Department of Pharmaceuticals Ministry of Chemicals and Fertilizers Government of India, New Delhi By NIPER - AHMEDABAD National Institute of Pharmaceutical Education and Research (NIPER),
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Draft Copy
May 08, 2009
MEDICAL DEVICES: SECTOR ANALYSIS
Submitted To
Department of PharmaceuticalsMinistry of Chemicals and Fertilizers
Government of India, New Delhi
By
NIPER - AHMEDABADNational Institute of Pharmaceutical Education and Research (NIPER),C/o B. V. Patel Pharmaceutical Education and Research Development
(PERD) Centre, Sarkhej-Gandhinagar Highway, Thaltej, Ahmedabad 380054 Gujarat, India
12.0 FEW PREMIER INSTITUTES / ORGANIZATIONS IN INDIA WITH RELEVANT EXPERTISE IN THE AREA...............................................................52
12.1 Sree Chitra Tirunal Institute for Medical Sciences and Technology, Chennai...............52
12.2 Indian Institute of Technology, Mumbai.............................................................................53
12.3 School of Medical Science and Technology, IIT, Kharagpur............................................53
12.4 Other Institutes and Facilities..............................................................................................54
13.0 A HELPING HAND: NIPER AHMEDABAD...........................................................54
13.1 Current Status of Technology and HR Gaps......................................................................54
13.2 Recommendations for NIPER, Ahmedabad.......................................................................55
ANNEXURE
NIPER-Ahmedabad Page 3
Draft Copy
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Medical devices have extended the ability of physicians to diagnose and treat diseases,
making great contributions to health and quality of life and without any doubt, these
technologies have changed the mainstream practice of medicine. These devices include not
only diagnostic technology but also analytical techniques using high-resolution
chromatography, polymerase chain reaction (PCR), and monoclonal antibodies, providing
physicians with new, accurate, and rapid information. On the therapeutic side, devices save
lives and improve quality of life. Dialysis therapy extends lives for end-stage renal disease
patients, orthopedic implants enable patients to walk again, and minimally invasive
technologies allow surgeries that are safer, with less pain and trauma, requiring significantly
shorter hospital stays.
In light of its widespread applicability, the medical device market is experiencing explosive
growth. Currently valued at USD 336 billion, market growth will continue to accelerate as
demographics and market drivers increase their pressure for new and innovative product
offerings at affordable pricing. Market Drivers in the current global scenario includes the
aging population, advancement in technology and worldwide market penetration.
The medical device market is consolidating to respond to market needs. Consolidation will
promote accelerated time to market, greater returns on invested capital, and transformational
innovation while maintaining high quality and patient efficacy. The future is hence extremely
bright for this sector.
Indian medical equipment and supplies market is estimated for USD 1581 million in 2007-
2008. The market for low value medical supplies and disposables is dominated by the
domestic manufacturers, whereas importers dominate the costly and high end medical
equipment.
Historically, most Indians had very limited access to any type of modern medical service.
Today, however, the situation is much improved, for several reasons. First, there is a growing
awareness about health issues within India and an increasing demand for quality care at
affordable prices.
Imports constitute over 50% of the market. Most imported products have high gross margins;
however, the market is becoming increasingly competitive due to low entry barriers (for
MNCs), an increasing number of players and an expanding consumer base.
NIPER-Ahmedabad Page 4
Draft Copy
Some of the issues and constraints that are found to cripple the industry are India’s
dependency on imports for supply of medical devices, strict industry regulatory environment,
low level of healthcare insurance and low levels of healthcare facilities and awareness
especially in rural areas.
The local market is still dominated by either imports or large MNCs whereas the local
manufacturers act as only small players in this market. The primary challenges facing these
local manufacturers include poor infrastructure for R&D and testing facility for efficacy and
safety. Further, there is a clear evidence of lack in trained personnel for serving in this
industry with sufficient technical as well as pharmacy-based knowledge, which is integral for
such a multidisciplinary sector.
Hence, measures to promote such facilities for not only testing and R&D but also for training
of professionals to serve in this segment, is the need of the hour to bring up this Pharma-
Allied Sector at par with the Pharma Sector in the coming years.
Recommendations for NIPER: NIPER(s) could assist the Medical Device Sector in the
following three ways:
Academic centres:
Meet the Technological and Regulatory demands of MD industry.
Introduction of relevant MD related courses (including market and business analysis,
basic engineering, electronics, material sciences and biomaterials, testing and
evaluation, etc.).
Interdisciplinary and combinatory research projects - to work in interdisciplinary
groups
Testing facility for devices:
Establishing a testing facility
Testing models for efficacy and quality control studies
Pre-clinical and clinical studies for medical devices:
Pre-clinical/clinical studies for MD (class 2B and III) as per regulatory guidelines.
For training the personnel and providing necessary facility for the SMEs.
NIPER-Ahmedabad Page 5
Draft Copy
1.0 BACKGROUND
A medical device is defined as any healthcare product that achieves its primary intended
purpose not through chemical action or by being metabolized. Medical devices include
electro-medical equipment and related software, furniture, supplies and consumables,
orthopedic appliances, prosthetics and diagnostic kits, reagents, and equipment.
Medical devices and equipment industry plays a crucial role in a healthcare system. These
devices and equipments are used for diagnosis, therapy and patient monitoring. There has
been a significant growth in pharmaceutical and healthcare sectors in the recent years. In
accordance, therefore, the medical devices and equipments are set for a vibrant growth in
near future.
1.1 Healthcare Industry
Healthcare industry is one of the largest users of technology with its growing trends. The
primary arenas of application of technology in healthcare includes,
Micro-processor based implantable in patients
CPU-driven technology supported by artificial intelligence
Robotics in OTs
Robotics in Path-labs / Research
Laser technology in surgery
Instrumentation in medical and surgical practices
IT tools for net-working examination, diagnostics, treatment rooms and OTs
IT Tools along with artificial intelligence and microprocessor technologies for
equipment maintenance and trouble shooting
IT tools for generation of disease specific data
Biotechnology, Genomics, Molecular Biology and Stem Cell Research
1.2 Development and Current Status
The global medical devices market is estimated at USD 336 billion in 2008 which has grown
at a CAGR of 4.5% post 2000. Globally, medical equipments which include ophthalmic,
dental, imaging and other medical equipment account for about 42% of the total market
followed by Medical disposables (40%) and in-vitro (IV) diagnostics (12%) of the global
market.
Indian medical equipment and supplies market is estimated for USD 1581 million in 2007-
2008 with a growth of 4.7% over previous year. The market for medical supplies and
NIPER-Ahmedabad Page 6
Draft Copy
disposables is dominated by the domestic manufacturers, whereas importers dominate the
costly and high end medical equipment.
The medical device market is about 50 percent of the world pharmaceutical market in terms
of relative size, but is also growing faster than its drug counterpart. It is dominated by U.S.
companies earning over 72 percent of the revenue. MX: Business Strategies for Medical
Technology Executives reported that market reached the size of USD 300 and USD 336
billion in year 2007 and 2008 respectively.
1.2.1 Medical equipments segment
The medical equipment market is presently pegged at Rs.1500 crore with a growth rate of 10-
15 % per annum. Surgeons, gynaecologists, urologists, and doctors are gradually adopting
techniques, which were once a specialty of certain physicians (like radiologists) only.
Increased simplicity of use has resulted in short-term training before commencement and
customer-user friendly operations. These simplistic operations have opened avenues for them
to increase revenues at a faster rate than through conventional business models.
The major promising sub-sectors include:
a) Medical Imaging Equipment
b) Cardiology Equipment
c) Laboratory Instruments/Supplies
d) Cancer Diagnostics and Treatment Equipment
2.0 AVENUES
2.1 Biomaterials
2.2.1 Degradable polymers
Polymers like poly (lactides), poly (glycolides) and their copolymers have excellent
properties and have thus been developed for the applications such as wound closure,
osteosynthesis, nets for support while wound is healing, degradable bandages and surgical
cord for reinforcement, hollow fibres for treatment of damaged nerves as well as prostheses
for anastomoses.
For example, a biodegradable intravascular stent prototype is moulded from a blend of
polylactide and trimethylene carbonate. Furthermore, these polymers are being considered for
the development of products for the treatment of paradontal diseases, fillers for tooth
extraction, artificial vessels and drug carrier systems.
NIPER-Ahmedabad Page 7
Draft Copy
Besides eliminating the need for a second removal surgery, the biodegradation may offer
other advantages. For example, a fractured bone that has been fixated with a rigid, non-
biodegradable stainless implant has a tendency for refracture upon removal of the implant
while, an implant prepared from biodegradable polymer can be engineered to degrade at a
rate that will slowly transfer load to the healing bone.
Advances in polymers for biotechnology are numerous. Now polymers have gone to the
extent that the difference between synthetic and biological polymers has reduced to a great
extent. Genetic engineering methods are being used to produce "artificial" proteins with a
range of designed structures and functions. Traditional polymer synthesis techniques are
being coupled with biochemistry to produce materials that interact and control biological
systems and cells. Various new fields have emerged that club the role of polymer chemistry
with biotechnology.
Environmentally responsive polymers for biotechnological applications
Biological production of polymers (e.g., polystyrene, polyesters)
Biopolymers and protein polymers
Polymers modified with biological -signals (e.g. adhesion peptides growth factors)
Bioactive, biomimetic, and bioinspired polymers
Supramolecular assemblies in biotechnology
Polymers in analytical biotechnology
Polymers scaffolds for tissue engineering
Biopolymer surfactants
Polymer and surface modification of tissue culture
Cell polymer interactions
Polymers for drug delivery and artificial organs
2.2 Cardiovascular and Diabetes
2.2.1 Cardiovascular device sector includes
Pacemakers
Defibrillators
Drug-eluting stents
Catheters
Valves
Grafts
Artificial hearts
NIPER-Ahmedabad Page 8
Draft Copy
Angioplasty
Guidewires
Ventrical support systems
Echocardiography
Furthermore, latest research pertaining to artificial hearts brings hope to patients who are near
death from heart failure.
Artificial hearts work by pumping deoxygenated blood from the body to the lungs. The
device then pumps oxygenated blood through the body. The device newly approved by US
FDA, called AbioCor, made by Massachusetts-based Abiomed, uses an implanted hydraulic
pumping system to simulate a natural heart beat. But an alternative design, conceived by O.H.
"Bud" Frazier, a prominent heart surgeon and pioneer in the development of cardiac devices
at the Texas Heart Institute in Houston, pumps blood through the body continuously, rather
than with the periodic beat of the normal heart. Thus, research directed towards
cardiovascular aids seem to have a promising future.
2.2.2 Insulin metering devices
The various designs of insulin metering devices that are now available make diabetics more
independent and improve their quality of life. Using Opti Pen 2 developed by Hoechst
Marion Roussel the patients can inject the requisite amount of insulin into their bodies
themselves. The metering device administers exactly the stipulated amount of insulin,
releasing it on rotation. Acetal copolymers having good mechanical properties, good
mouldability and good slip properties are the best materials for such devices.
Over the past three decades, the disposable medical market has undergone a variety of
changes including the types of devices produced, substrates selected, and sterilization
procedures employed. In the early 1970s, device manufacturers were utilizing materials such
as glass, rubber and metal to assemble syringes, surgical instruments, and other devices. Such
materials were typically assembled and fastened and /or machined or molded in the
appropriate configuration. In the 1980s, as medical technology advanced towards intricate
and high performance medical device designs, the need for engineering plastics became
apparent. During this same period, a shift to single use devices (due to advances in
contagious disease) forced design engineers to evaluate engineering plastics such as acrylic,
polycarbonate, and PVC.
NIPER-Ahmedabad Page 11
Draft Copy
The following facts indicate the recent trends in the use of medical disposables:
Medical devices are becoming lighter, more portable and more user-friendly, with more
functionality.
A steady stream of new and innovative medical devices has been made possible by
advanced polymer research.
Advanced medical polymers are now capable of biological processes and can become a
functional part of living organisms.
A "Slight shift" from commodity thermoplastics has been predicted to engineering
resins, styrencis, thermosets, etc. Major non disposable markets include testing /
diagnostic equipment, surgical instrument and related equipment, prostheses / implants,
and dental / ophthalmics. Disposable products include syringes, lab ware, tubing, blood
bags, utensils, gloves, trays, and catheters.
Medical disposable products are used by practically all hospitals and private nursing homes
in the country, including diagnostic and pathological laboratories. In hospitals, disposables
are used, both in the ward as well as the OPD.
Some of the products being manufactured indigenously include fluid administration sets (I.V.
sets), I.V. cannulae, blood bags and products such as condoms and copper–T . Majority of the
low-end devices and disposables are manufactured by small-scale enterprises.
3.0 GLOBAL INDUSTRY SCENARIO
3.1 Market Size
The global medical devices market is estimated to be USD 330 billion in 2008 (Figure 1).
The market has grown at a compounded annual growth rate of (CAGR) of 4.5% post 2000.
New technological innovation in the treatment and diagnosis front; growing aging population
and shifting disease pattern, which needs long term medical care and diagnosis are some of
the major factors that drive the growth of global medical devices market.
NIPER-Ahmedabad Page 12
Draft Copy
Figure 1: Global medical devices market size
US and Medical Device Market
US produces half of the world’s medical devices – USD 70 billion
Domestic Consumption = 40%
17 Biggest companies account for 65% of the total revenue
Total < 6000 medical device manufacturers
Nine of the top ten in the world are based in the US
Cardio vascular products form the single largest sector
Orthopedics - fastest growing
Spinal & Pain Management and Cosmetic & Elective surgical form the next
3.2 Segmentation
3.2.1 Segmentation by geography
Global medical devices market is classified in the following geographical markets -
a) North America (The US and Canada)
b) Europe (Germany, France, Italy, the UK, Spain, and the Netherlands)
c) Asia-Pacific (Japan, China, Japan, Singapore, India and Taiwan)
d) Rest of the World
North America, which includes the US and Canada accounts for 47% of the global medical
devices market (Figure 2). The US alone accounts for 45% of the total market. European
market, which includes Germany, France, Italy, the UK, Spain and The Netherlands,
accounts for 33% of the total market. Germany alone accounts for 13% of the total market.
Asia-Pacific market, which includes India, China, Japan, Singapore and Taiwan accounts
NIPER-Ahmedabad Page 13
Draft Copy
for 17% of the total market. Japan alone accounts for about 10% of the total market. The rest
of the world, which includes Brazil and Russia accounts for 3% of the total market.
Figure 2: Segmentation of global medical devices market - By geography
3.2.2 Segmentation by application
Globally, medical equipment, which includes ophthalmic, dental, imaging and other medical
equipments account for about 42% of the total market. Among the medical equipment,
ophthalmic equipments account for 18% of the total market and the imaging and other
medical equipment account for 16% of the total market (Figure 3). Medical disposables
account for 40% of the total medical devices market followed by in-vitro (IV) diagnostics
accounting for 12% of the global market.
Figure 3: Segmentation of global medical devices market - By application
NIPER-Ahmedabad Page 14
Draft Copy
3.3 Major players
Multinational manufacturers are consolidating in order to establish greater presence around
the world, and some of the largest medical device companies have a number of subsidiaries.
Examples include Johnson & Johnson (like Ethicon, DePuy, Cordis, J&J Medical, Critikon),
Boston Scientific (like SciMed, Microvasive, Schneider, EP Technologies) and Baxter (like
IV Systems, Edwards Division, Hyland Division, Clintec, Renal Therapy). Yet, many
countries lack access to high-quality devices and equipment that are appropriate for their
specific epidemiological needs. This is particularly true in developing countries, where health
technology assessments are rare and where few regulatory controls exist to prevent the
importation or use of sub-standard devices.
4.0 INDIAN INDUSTRY SCENARIO
Historically, most Indians had very limited access to any type of modern medical service.
Today, however, the situation is much improved, for several reasons. Firstly, there is a
growing awareness about health issues within India and an increasing demand for quality
care at affordable prices. Secondly, the government has made large investments in health
care, as part of a five-year-plan to provide better health-care facilities. And thirdly, a growing
middle class of approximately 200 million Indians are demanding more sophisticated medical
treatment, a demand largely answered by private institutions.
There are four types of Indian health-care facilities that use foreign medical equipment:
primary health centres and rural hospitals, government hospitals, private hospitals, and
teaching institutions. A majority of the Indian hospitals are located in major cities such as
New Delhi, Chennai, Mumbai, Kolkata, Hyderabad, and Bengaluru. Recently these have
spread beyond Metros to 2nd and 3rd tier cities like Lucknow, Ahmedabad, Indore, etc. which
have also developed superior private hospitals. Private hospitals outnumber state facilities by
two to one and purchase 40 to 50% of imported devices. Private hospitals tend to invest in
sophisticated foreign medical devices because the doctors there are mostly trained abroad,
particularly in Europe and the United States. India's Apollo Hospital in New Delhi, for
example, the world's fourth-largest hospital, is well stocked with high-technology medical
equipment from abroad. Indian doctors play an important role in purchasing medical devices
for hospitals and other health-care facilities, and their influence is growing. But their
demands for quality and sophistication in medical products are counterbalanced by another
key factor: price. Because most of the population cannot afford to pay for health care,
institutions in turn pay careful attention to costs in making their purchasing decisions.
NIPER-Ahmedabad Page 15
Draft Copy
Public hospitals lack funds to upgrade their equipment and expand their services, while
domestic medical device manufacturers cannot produce high technology equipment essential
for such procedures. Consequently, the demand for high technology devices is met
predominantly by imports.
4.1 Market Size
The medical equipment industry plays a crucial role in healthcare system. These equipment
are used for diagnosis, therapy and patient monitoring. Apart from the pharmaceutical sector,
the medical devices and equipments are set for a vibrant growth. Medical equipment and
supplies market in India was estimated for USD 1581 million in 2007-08 with a growth of
4.6% over previous year (Figure 4). Market for medical supplies and disposables is
dominated by the domestic manufacturers, most of who are in unorganized market. Whereas
the high end medical equipment market is dominated by the MNCs. Though the demand of
these equipment is in double digit, the local production is only around 5% of the requirement
leading to increased imports.
4.1.1 INDIA – Facts and figures regarding the medical device market
The fastest growing Medical Devices market : Rs. 5750 crores
Growth Rate : 23% annually for next 5-6 yrs
4.1.2 Market segments
Diagnostic Equipment : Rs. 2000 crores
Surgical Equipment supplies : Rs. 1300 crores
Imaging : Rs. 1300 crores
Electronic treatment devices : Rs. 1000 crores
The medical devices market is showing a double-digit growth. In India, the growth of the
market is estimated to be between 10-15 percent. This is because of affordability by patients,
increased awareness on health care, improved hospital infrastructure and the increased
disease patterns. With steady growth in GNP, population numbers and standard of living,
India represents one of the most promising markets. The Indian market for medical
equipment and supplies is expected to reach USD 1.7 billion in 2010.
However, despite strong growth rates, the market remains disproportionately small, ranking
among the top 20 in the world, but with a very low per capita spending.
NIPER-Ahmedabad Page 16
Draft Copy
Favourable factors for high quality medical devices are
Free market environment
A developed industry
Investment in health infrastructure
Firstly, rising income and health consciousness amongst the Indian population are driving
people to seek specialized care. The urban consuming class is expected to grow from 78
million in 2001 to 250 million in 2010. India’s increasingly affluent middle class is
demanding access to better healthcare; many Indians are now choosing to purchase health
insurance with either full or partial coverage, so a large percentage of the population can
afford to receive high technology treatment. Several corporate houses have expanded into the
hospital business, while leading healthcare providers such as Harvard Medical International
and Cleveland Clinic have entered India through joint ventures.
Figure 4: Medical equipment market in India
4.2 Segmentation
4.2.1 Medical equipments
Majority of the Indian medical equipment market is dominated by the medical instruments
and appliances used in specialties such as ophthalmic, dental and other physiological classes.
This segment accounts for 26% of the total market followed by orthopedic/ prosthetic goods
segment accounting for 19% of the total market (Figure 5). Medical supplies such as
bandages and disposables such as syringes, needles and catheters together constituted 21% of
the total market. The other equipments which are in demand are high end speciality electro
NIPER-Ahmedabad Page 17
Draft Copy
medical equipments that accounted for 11% of the total market. X-ray apparatus accounted
for 10% of the total market.
Figure 5: Segmentation of Indian medical equipment market
4.2.2 Diagnostic kits
Diagnostic kits constitute a high growth segment in the medical devices market with a growth
rate of 30% and a market size of USD 133 million in 2005. They include the reagents and the
medical kits. With over fifty companies operating in diagnostic kits, the market has seen
several interesting trends. The market is dominated by Roche diagnostics followed by
Transasia, Bayer and others (Table 1). Indian companies like Nicholas Piramal, Orchid have
significantly consolidated their market position.
Table 1: Top 10 India Players in Diagnostics kits
Rank Players
1 Roche Diagnostics
2 Transasia
3 Bayer Diagnostics
4 Span Diagnostics
5 Nicholas Piramal
6 Orchid
7 Tulip Diagnostics
8 Zephyr Biomedical
9 Biorad
10 LiliacSource: biospectrumindia.com
NIPER-Ahmedabad Page 18
Draft Copy
4.3 Market Trends
4.3.1 Outsourcing of laboratory services by large private hospitals
Large private sector hospitals have started to outsource their laboratory services. For instance,
Mumbai-based Metropolis Health Services manages the laboratory of Chennai based Malar
Hospital. Metropolis also manages the laboratory services of the Dubai-based Gulf Medical
College in Ajman.
4.3.2 Raising of private equity funds
Healthcare organizations in India raise funds through private equity to invest in their
aggressive expansion and infrastructure upgradation plans (Table 2).
Table 2: Equity funds raised by major healthcare organizations
Healthcare organization Equity investorValue of fund raised
(USD million)
Manipal Health Systems Private Ltd.
IDFC Private Equity Fund II 20
Metropolis Health Services Ltd.
ICICI Venture 8
Healthcare Global Enterprises Ltd.
IDFC Private Equity Fund II 11
Apollo Hospitals * - 115Source: Cygnus Research * Announced plans to raise funds
4.3.3 Increasing healthcare awareness
Increasing medical awareness among the urban population, which are the middle and upper
income groups and high dependence of the doctors on the laboratory reports have led to the
development of well-networked medical infrastructure in large Indian cities and urban
centres.
4.3.4 Imports and exports
Imports constitute over 50% of the market. Most imported products have high gross margins;
however, the market is becoming increasingly competitive due to low entry barriers (for
MNCs), an increasing number of players and an expanding consumer base. Currently, the
high value imported products include cancer diagnostic, medical imaging, ultrasonic
scanning, plastic surgery equipment and polymerase chain reaction technologies. Figure 6
gives category wise distribution of medical devices imports and Figure 7 gives year wise
imports of medical equipments by India.
NIPER-Ahmedabad Page 19
Draft Copy
Figure 6: Medical devices import by category
Figure 7: Medical equipment imports by India
The demand of medical devices has greatly influenced its export potential (Figure 8 and 9).
With the growing demand for medical facilities across the country, the market for medical
equipment in India is fast expanding. The Medical devices market for exports from India is
estimated around USD 509 million with a CAGR of 22.15%. The exports mainly consist of
dental instruments, surgical items and other laboratory equipments. Indian manufacturers of
good quality mid tech products struggle with a stigma for unreliability. Indian purchasers are,
however, price-sensitive and seek value for money. The market for medical supplies and
disposable equipment is dominated by domestic manufacturers. Figure 10 gives the estimated
medical equipments export value in India.
NIPER-Ahmedabad Page 20
Draft Copy
Figure 8: Medical devices exports by category
Figure 9: Medical devices exports by different countries
NIPER-Ahmedabad Page 21
Draft Copy
Figure 10: Medical Equipment Exports from India
4.4 Major Players in India
Prominent MNC’s operating in the Indian market include B Braun, Becton, Dickinson and
company, Bayer, Johnson and Johnson, Phillips ,Roche, Siemens and GE. Some of the
domestic players hat have consolidated their market position include, BPL Healthcare,
Godrej Healthcare, Nicholas Piramal India Ltd., Opto Circuits India Ltd. and Advanced
Micronic Devices Ltd.
Moreover, benchmark institutions functioning in India for R & D in medical and surgical
products include Sree Chitra Tirunal Institute of Medical Sciences and Technology,
Thiruvananthapuram and Shriram Institute of Industrial Research, Delhi.
The key local units for manufacture and testing of medical devices in Gujarat are
a) Sahajanand Vascular Technoventions, Surat: Innovative drug eluting stent manufacturer
b) Omni Lens Pvt. Ltd., Ahmedabad: Wide range of quality IOLs from US FDA approved
raw materials using state of the art technology
c) Susruta Instruments, Ahmedabad: Microsurgical tools for Cataract and IOL implants
d) Nidhi Meditech Systems, Ahmedabad: High-tech urology products including
intracorporeal pheumatic lithotripter
e) Inmed Equipments Pvt. Ltd., Ahmedabad: Nerve locator and nerve mapper in locating
nerve joint position during anesthesia, oxygen analyser, high radio frequency bipolar units
f) Online Infocom Pvt. Ltd., Ahmedabad: Software systems for Tele-medicine, Continuous
medical education and complete patient monitoring and management
NIPER-Ahmedabad Page 22
Draft Copy
4.5 Issues and Challenges
Some of the issues and constraints that are found to cripple the industry are India’s
dependency on imports for supply of medical devices, strict industry regulatory environment,
low level of healthcare insurance and low levels of healthcare facilities and awareness
especially in rural areas.
4.5.1 Dependency on imports
Indian medical devices supply is heavily dependant on the imports from other countries like
the US, Japan, the UK, France, Finland, Germany, etc. It is estimated that around 50% of
India’s medical devices sales is through imports. Although imports constitute over half of the
total Indian market, the proliferation of new joint ventures will erode this share slightly.
The Wipro-GE is a successful joint venture in India; foreign players like Roche Diagnostics
India, Johnson & Johnson Medical India (JJMI), B. Braun group are operating through their
subsidiaries. These joint ventures and other business collaboration modes are slowly
changing the landscape of the Indian medical devices industry. The import of some of high-
end technology medical devices and products during 2001- 06 is listed in Table 3.
Table 3: Import of some of high-end technology medical devices and products during 2001- 06
Products Import (INR m) CAGR %
LCDs, laser , other optical appliances & instruments 24.64 34.36
Instruments and appliances used in medical, surgical, dental and veterinary sciences including electro medical apparatus and sight testing instruments
601.96 15.65
Orthopedic appliances, artificial parts of the body: hearing aids & other appliances which are worn/implanted in the body to compensate defect/disability
68.28 23.23
Other appliances of previous class, Beta/Gamma radiation including radiotherapy apparatus, X- ray tube & Generators, high tension generators screens etc.
170.54 26.81
Parts & accessories for machines, appliances, instruments/apparatus
124.48 19.27
Total medical devices import 1116.33 17.69Source: DGFT, GoI
Typically, domestic production consists primarily of low technology products (like surgical
textiles and other medical supplies), whereas the demand for high technology devices is met
predominantly by imports. A further analysis based on the level of technology involved in the
NIPER-Ahmedabad Page 23
Draft Copy
manufacture of devices indicates that the import of high-end technology products have
increased during 2001-06. Similarly, the import of LCDs, laser, other optical appliances &
instruments (34.36%), Instruments and appliances used in medical, surgical, dental sciences
including electro-medical apparatus and sight-testing instruments (15.65%), orthopedic
appliances and artificial parts of body (23.23%), radiotherapy instruments, X-ray generators
and screens (26.81%), parts used for advanced instruments (19.27%) have grown
tremendously. The import of a few other products like spectacles and goggles (50.83%) and
frames & mountings for spectacles (29.38%) during the same period have also increased. The
high volume of imports of medical devices and its consistent double-digit growth indicates
India’s dependence on imports for medical devices. One possible reason for higher
dependence on imports can be traced back to low level of R&D spending by Indian medical
devices industry. Moreover, import duty exemption for devices and technologies that are not
available in India in turn encourages the import rather than investing in domestic R&D and
manufacturing; also, domestic manufacturers cannot offer their products at a competitive
price against that of the imported products that have the benefit of tax exemption.
4.5.2 Low levels of health insurance coverage
The health insurance in the country presently covers only 1% of the population. The share of
health insurance in health financing accounts for a mere 1.2% of the total expenditure on
health.
In terms of high life insurance penetration, measured as % ratio of premium to GDP, South
Africa (11.43%) ranks first in world, whereas India had only 2.53% in 2004. The global
average life insurance penetration is 4.55%, higher than that of India’s. India’s life insurance
penetration is a paltry 15.7%, which is even less compared to the global average of 291.5%.
One of the reasons for low penetration of health insurance in India is the lack of regulations
in the health sector resulting in an exposure of the beneficiaries to various wrong practices
present in the system. Therefore, it is stressed that any regulation on health insurance should
ensure that the patient is provided with the choice of provider and insurer while managing the
cost environment.
Other measures to increase the health insurance coverage in India includes encouraging the
establishment of a stand-alone health insurance company with a minimum capital
requirement of INR500m to make it viable, allowing it to write Personal Accident covers as
combined and add-on covers, permitting them to sell overseas travel policies, to cover the
eventuality of sickness and accident while on overseas travel, allowing the agents of both life
NIPER-Ahmedabad Page 24
Draft Copy
and general insurance companies to take up the agency of stand-alone Health Insurance
companies, and finally permitting foreign direct investment (FDI) in stand-alone health
insurance ventures up to 51%, etc. There is also lack of standardization of medical definitions
across all health insurance products from different companies, as inconsistent definitions by
the insurers result in inconsistent pricing and inconsistent incorporation of health insurance
products. Another reason for the low levels of health insurance coverage in India is the low
levels of awareness about the essentiality of health insurance in India and less popularity of
health insurance.
4.5.3 Recent stringent regulatory amendment
India’s medical devices market has been experiencing a healthy growth of 4.6% over the last
few years. However, this fast growing market has not been regulated until recently. The
controversy over the marketing of faulty imported drug-coated stents in Maharashtra has
forced the Central Drug Standards Controlling Authority of India to draft regulations for the
medical devices industry recently. However, these regulatory changes could have a
significant impact on the industry. While drugs and cosmetics have been regulated in India
since the passage of the Drug and Cosmetic Act in 1940, medical devices (until recently)
were largely unregulated. The issue of marketing of faulty stents prompted the Drug
Controller General of India (DCGI) to issue a notification in October 2005 reclassifying 10
types of medical devices as drugs so that they could also be regulated under the Drugs and
Cosmetics Act. In March 2006, the DCGI issued new guidelines regulating the import and
manufacture of those 10 medical devices mentioned in the October 2005 notification. Under
the new medical device regulations, importers of the notified medical devices are responsible
for applying for import licenses and filing product registrations with the DCGI, as a
pharmaceutical importer would normally do. The re-classified products list includes the
sterile devices such as cardiac stents, drug eluting stents, catheters, intra ocular lenses, I.V.
Cannulae, bone cements, heart valves, scalp vein set, orthopedic implants and internal
prosthetic replacements to be considered as drugs that require central clearance prior to
import, manufacture or marketing in the country with effect from March 1, 2006.
The new guidelines concerning the import of medical devices makes it mandatory to make
application for import and registration for the importers for which a period of 60 days would
be provided from the date of publication of these guidelines, which was later extended by
another 60 days. The guidelines also notified that in case of devices, which have not been
imported in the country before the date of notification, no import would be permitted without
NIPER-Ahmedabad Page 25
Draft Copy
an approval of a competent authority. Further, in case of stents or drug eluting stents the
import will not be permitted if the applicant has not sold less than one thousand stents of the
particular specification prior to the date of issue of these guidelines. Such stipulations restrict
the entry of new players into the devices sector. The cause of concern for the industry is the
high cost of obtaining athe required documentation for these regulatory submissions. The
importer has to pay USD 1500 towards the registration of the manufacturer from whom he is
importing; and he has to pay a fee of USD 1000 for registration of a single Medical Device
(which may include variation in sizes or shape without any change in the material or method
of use) and an additional fee of USD 1000 for each additional device. The high fee could
become a burden for smaller manufacturers and also affect the available range of products in
India as the sales per device are usually quite small. It is expected that the cost of devices is
expected to rise primarily because of registration costs, which include the registration fee,
salary of additional staff hired to follow registration process and paperwork and increase in
countervailing duties to 4% announced in the 2006-07 budget. As there are increases in duty
and dollar appreciation, the financial burden will be passed down the value chain to patients,
rendering devices more expensive and treatment unaffordable for those without insurance
coverage. Smaller devices constitute approximately 5% of the total medical bill, so an 8%
increase is marginal and barely noticeable. However, for larger devices such as stents, that
constitute 70% of the total medical bill, any increase in cost will definitely make treatment
significantly more expensive. This should be viewed on the background of price sensitivity of
Indian market and low coverage of health insurance. A high registration fee can create a
barrier to innovation by local and smaller manufacturers to develop low cost devices suited
for the Indian market. Also the requirement for imported devices to conform to local labelling
requirements may create a issue of logistics for supplies while increasing the cost of surgical
products.
4.5.4 High import duties to escalate the cost of medical devices
A 4% Special Additional Duty for medical devices and instruments announced in the Union
Budget 2006-07, is expected to increase the cost of diagnostic scans and high-end tests.
Therefore, after the new impost, medical instruments such as CT Scanners, MRI machines,
Cathlab and ventilators which was earlier under the 5% Customs duty slab will now attract
9% duty while ultrasound machines, patient monitors, defibrillators and blood cell counters
will be charged under the 26.8% Customs duty category. In conjunction with various taxes at
the State-level, the cost on patient will increase by 10-20% in diagnostics. Another point of
NIPER-Ahmedabad Page 26
Draft Copy
contention is that the duty exemption for diagnostic kits used to detect life threatening
diseases continues to only apply to basic techniques that are increasingly replaced by newer
and more precise methods like the Polymerase Chain Reaction (PCR) test. At present only
tests like the ELISA and CLIA enjoy the duty waiver while the PCR kits attracts 37%.
Customs duty in spite of applications in the diagnosis of diseases like TB, Hepatitis or bird
flu, increase the cost of tests done using the advanced technique. These budgetary tax
measures coupled with an already anomalous customs tariff structure are expected to escalate
the cost of treatments and burden the patients and ultimately constraint the delivery of
modern healthcare. Though increased cost of treatments will not affect the insured patients,
but the coverage of health insurance which is less than 1% then becomes a concern.
From a company’s perspective, margins are expected to shrink, as device companies have to
accommodate a 4% increase in custom duties. The other possible fall out is that India may
loose its cost advantage in medical tourism in a country that is mostly dependent on imports
for medical devices supply, if higher investments to sustain the imports for medical tourism
requirements results in higher treatment costs to visitors.
4.5.5 Poor medical infrastructure facilities and low level of awareness in rural India
Major medical infrastructure facilities like hospitals, testing labs and diagnostic centres are
concentrated in urban areas whereas the rural areas do not possess equally such facilities. The
doctors and healthcare specialists are neither well acquainted with the new technologies and
equipments nor afford to purchase such high cost equipments. The affordability by the rural
population of the costly healthcare treatments is also less, hence the scope of establishing and
running costly medical infrastructure facilities and equipments is not bright. Considering the
fact, that 72% of Indian population lives in rural areas, non or underavailability of such
medical infrastructure in rural areas leads to missing opportunity.
4.6 Critical Success Factors
The Indian medical devices industry is a growing sector. Though the strong demand factors
are driving the industry, the criticality of certain factors determines the sustaining demand for
the industry and hence the growth of the industry in the future. The success-determining
factors are as below:
4.6.1 Striking alliances with overseas companies
The high-end, precision technologies and the corresponding device manufacturing
technologies are not readily available in India. Most of medical devices and diagnostics that
NIPER-Ahmedabad Page 27
Draft Copy
are manufactured in India involve low- to mid-end technologies, while majority of high-end
technologies and devices are still imported from countries like the USA, Japan, Germany and
France. Reasons could be technical superiority of foreign companies acquired from their vast
experience spanning over years, lack of R&D in Indian companies, lack of skilled workforce
in high-end R&D in India, apart from other geo-economic considerations of the foreign
companies. Therefore, Indian companies are looking forward to having alliances with foreign
companies either to import and distribute their products in the Indian territory or become
licensed manufacturers and distributors of the foreign companies. Therefore striking an
alliance with foreign manufactures is beneficial in the following ways-
1. Licensed manufacturing and distribution mode virtually eliminates the huge import
logistics and distribution costs incurred by domestic companies.
2. Domestically manufactured products can be priced typical of those of region. The
products can be competitively priced among the other locally manufactured products as
well as against imported products. It also helps to widen penetration of the hitherto less-
penetrated Indian medical devices market.
3. It also helps the foreign companies to reduce their unnecessary costs involved in
importing parts of devices into their country, then assembling and labelling them as
‘foreign-manufactured’ and sending them back to the country of manufacturing in order to
be sold.
4. Domestic companies have better understanding of the local markets and can devise and
implement suitable business strategies than the foreign players.
One of the successful alliances by Indian medical device manufacturers is Wipro-GE, which
distributes GE’s products in Indian territory apart from Wipro’s own products. Philips,
Siemens and Roche Diagnostics are operating through their Indian subsidiaries. Companies
like Trivitron are distributing products of a number of foreign companies like Hamilton
Medical (Switzerland), Bio-Med Devices (USA), Nihon Kohden Corporation (Japan),
Thermo Electron Corporation (Finland), Sebia (France), Radiometer (Denmark), Electra
Medical Corporation (USA), DPC (USA), and INOVA (USA). Nicholas Piramal India Ltd
(NPIL) has R&D alliance with Morvus Technology Limited (UK), and scientific
collaboration agreement with BioSyntech. Span Diagnostics Ltd is the distributor of the
world’s leading diagnostic companies like Associates of Cape Cod Inc., Remel Inc., Hitachi
Chemical Diagnostics Inc., and BBI Biomedica Inc. etc. These alliances and associations are
viewed to be greatly beneficial to Indian companies. Therefore having an alliance with
NIPER-Ahmedabad Page 28
Draft Copy
overseas companies gives an edge to the Indian companies in terms of huge product basket,
advanced products & technologies and technical expertise which actually widen their
business scope. Getting into an alliance with overseas companies gives a competitive edge to
Indian companies and mutually beneficial to both. Hence domestic companies should look
for alliances to harness mutual benefits in the years to come.
4.6.2 Investments in R&D
Medical devices industry is an innovation-driven industry. Advanced medical technology can
not only save and improve patients’ lives, but also lower health care costs, improve the
efficiency of the health care delivery system, improve productivity and reduce the economic
cost of illness. Therefore, to deliver this value to patients, the industry invests heavily in
medical technology R&D. A past study indicates that the level of R&D spending in the
medical device and diagnostics industry, as a percentage of its sales, has been consistently
increasing from 5.4% in 1990, to 8.4% in 1995, to 12.9% post 2000. This level of spending is
on par with spending by the pharmaceutical industry. Generally, it is complained that Indian
medical device manufacturers spend less than their western counterparts. It is also observed
that western companies prefer to have R&D facilities in India- GE and Siemens have set up
their major R&D centres in Bangalore. The share of R&D expenditure to sales of medical
device and diagnostics manufactures in 2005 is listed in Table 4.
Table 4: The share of R&D expenditure to sales of medical device and diagnostics manufactures
R & D expenditure % share R & D expenditure to
net sales in 2005
Johnson & Johnson ( Medical devices division ) 2.05
Roche diagnostics Ltd ( Diagnostic division) 8.72
Bayer AG (Group business) 6.88
Godrej group 1.42
NPIL (Group business) 5.76
Becton and Dickinson ( Group business) 5.02
Beckman Coulter ( Group business) 8.55Source: Respective company website and Cygnus Research
Investing in R&D holds a competitive edge for manufacturers as the advanced technologies
and devices will have a clear value advantage over the existing and competitive
technology/products. It is also realized that making a breakthrough innovation is more
NIPER-Ahmedabad Page 29
Draft Copy
incentivising than making incremental innovation. The R&D efforts also have to be selective;
for products that command premium price ask for a larger pie of the total R&D efforts.
Therefore, investing in R&D is strategic to both domestic and foreign companies, in their
country or in any of the cost-effective locations. More than 50% of India’s medical device
demand is met through imports from overseas companies, which could also be a reason for
laxity on the part of Indian companies to rely on foreign companies for technologies and not
focus on their own R&D. Indian companies need to gear up their R&D efforts in
product/technology development, manufacturing, products designing, so as to sustain their
business and reduce dependency on imports.
4.6.3 Low cost devices
It is a known fact that the cost of medical devices that involves high-end technology and
sophistication are much costlier in India. This is partially attributed to the fact that most of
the medical devices and diagnostics are imported hence logistic cost, cost of technology
import duty and other taxes, which add up the cost of devices, leads to a spiralling of the cost
of the device. The other costs that include technical know-how fees/royalty charges and user
fees in case product/technology are patented. However, from the manufacturers’ point of
view, the present day’s medical devices and diagnostics industry faces intense competition.
Products range from commodities to highly specialized equipment, and each offering must
be manufactured to stringent quality standards, but at the lowest possible cost, which is
almost difficult to balance. Moreover, the industry is precision-centric and needs high levels
of process automation, which also increases the production cost (that includes fixed and
variable costs). Adding to the woes are the new regulations that make it mandatory for the
Indian importers to register their foreign manufacturers as well as the devices with the Indian
authorities, which proves to be too costly for the Indian importers. On the demand side, the
high cost of medical devices and diagnostics devices, affects the level of penetration of
medical devices in India and other developing/less developed countries. It also affects the
affordability of treatments, in a country where the health insurance coverage is already poor.
Moreover, in a country where private healthcare service providers share a larger share of 63%
of total healthcare services with the remaining delivered by public services, efforts to bring
down the cost of medical devices will be a boon to the Indian healthcare industry in a larger
perspective. However, it is also argued that though the cost of devices is brought down by
way of cutting duties and taxes, the benefit is not expected to be passed on to the patients
because test charges are levied based on the number of times the devices can be used.
NIPER-Ahmedabad Page 30
Draft Copy
Therefore, to bring down the cost of medical devices or manufacturing low cost devices can
be achieved through intensive and continuous R&D efforts, high levels of process automation
in the manufacturing facilities, striking manufacturing alliances with foreign companies to
manufacture them locally so as to cut logistics and other import-related duties and taxes,
lowering product registration fee and other documentation costs.
5.0 RECENT INDUSTRY TRENDS
Primary areas of research and development pertaining to Medical Devices have shown
consistent growth in the following arenas in the recent years:
5.1 Artificial Limbs Market Set to Grow
The Indian artificial limbs market is estimated to grow by USD 7.5 billion in 2009 from USD
2.5 billion in 2005. The share of artificial limbs and joints in the overall growth of the market
is also expected to be about 80% in the next five years time. One indicator for such a rapid
growth is the rise in orthopedic surgeries registered in the country in the past five years. It has
been estimated that close to 0.5-0.6m orthopedic surgeries per year are being performed in
the country. With a sedentary life-style on the rise, this number is expected to grow by 6%
annually in the next five years.
5.2 Italy Keen to Invest in Bio-Medical Sector
The Italians are collaborating with Indian companies to set up four plants to manufacture
safety syringes, Four Italian companies and seven to eight Indian companies are likely to be
involved in the project and the first batch of 100m syringes would be manufactured.
5.3 Andhra Pradesh to Buy Forty Lakh Disposable Syringes
The Andhra Pradesh Government bought 4m auto disable (AD) syringes for Phase-I
immunization in 22 districts of the State from Hindustan Syringes & Medical Devices Ltd
(HSMD). The State Government would again buy 4m AD syringes for its phase-II
immunization program.
5.4 Vascular Concepts Plans to Enter European Market
Leading stent manufacturer Vascular Concepts is planning to enter the European market with
its `Pronova' brand of drug-coated stents. The company plans to set up a chain of distribution
network in various European countries. Vascular has a 35% share in the Indian stent market.
NIPER-Ahmedabad Page 31
Draft Copy
5.5 New Products
5.5.1 New device for tumor surgery
The Manipal Institute of Neurological Disorders and the Department of Nuclear Medicine at
Manipal Hospital have jointly introduced Radio Guided Neuro Surgery that will benefit
people suffering from brain tumour. A gamma probe is used which localizes the tumour from
the brain and is easy for the doctors to isolate the tumour as it sometimes resembles the brain.
5.5.2 Life- saving device for heart patients
Wockhardt Heart Hospital, which has launched specialize services for heart care in
Hyderabad in association with Kamineni Hospital, has successfully implanted life saving
automatic implantable cardioverter defibillator (AICD) or a pacemaker on a patient. This
device sends alerts if there is any abnormality in heartbeat and would help initiate preventive
care early. This device when implanted in a patient can detect their potentially fatal rhythm
disorders and correct them by delivering a well-synchronized direct current shock directly to
the heart. This is typically done for patients who face high risk of developing ventricular
tachycardia/ fibrillation.
5.5.3 Modern CT scanner installed at Sunrise hospital, Kochi
The Sunrise hospital at Kochi has installed a modern diagnostic system Light Speed Volume
CT Scanner which is the first of its kind in South India. This Scanner can capture images of
any organ in the human body in less than 10 seconds. The significant application of this
technology will be the non-invasive imaging of the heart and coronary arteries.
5.5.4 Single system to diagnose dengue
The Dengue Genotyping kit, developed by the Korean bio-company Seegene, uses a
multiplex Polymerase Chain Reaction (PCR) system based on their trademark Dual Specific
Oligonucleotide technology to detect multiple pathogens at one time. This diagnostic kit not
only detects chikungunya or dengue at an earlier stage of illness than most other kits, but also
identifies if its chikungunya or any one the four stereotypes of dengue, all in a single test.
5.6 Company Developments
5.6.1 GE-health launches hi-definition magnetic resonance system
GE Healthcare's engineering and scientific set-up in Bangalore launched the High Definition
Magnetic Resonance (HDMR) system. The HDMR system has been priced in around INR55-
60m range in India. The HDMR system would provide the doctors high-resolution image
clarity in cases where patients are difficult to manage on account of movement, including
NIPER-Ahmedabad Page 32
Draft Copy
uncontrollable patient motion owing to Parkinson's disease, trauma, stroke and pediatric
patients who do not respond to sedation.
5.6.2 Chitra Tirunal Institute to set up test centre for medical devices
The Thiruvanathapuram based Sree Chitra Tirunal Institute for Medical Sciences and
Technology (SCTIMST) has plans to set up a national test centre for medical devices. The
national test centre for medical devices, which would be established with funds provided by
the Union Government, will provide comprehensive testing services under `good laboratory
practices' to the Indian medical devices industry. Major areas of testing that will be covered at
the facility include functional and safety evaluation of medical devices using in-vitro
simulated systems, functional and safety evaluation using small and large animal models,
evaluation of device packaging including aspects such as shelf life.
5.6.3 Widex launches new hearing aid
Widex India Private Ltd has introduced in India a `user-friendly' digital hearing aid having
certain features to meet the needs of people with hearing loss that are not available in the
relatively cheaper versions. The company, which imports hearing aids from its partner Widex
A/S of Denmark, expects the market for hearing aids, estimated to be around INR300m to
grow at an annual rate of 10% in the country.
5.6.4 Opto Circuits buys German stent company
The Bangalore-based Opto Circuits (India) Ltd has acquired Germany's EuroCOR, a
company that designs and manufactures stents for INR60m. EuroCOR has about 120
employees and a manufacturing facility at Bonn (Germany).
5.6.5 Corning launches distribution channel
Corning India Pvt. Ltd., in collaboration with Prime Ophthalmics Products Ltd, launched a
new distribution channel in Chennai. Corning India is a subsidiary of Corning Inc, a leader in
ophthalmic technology. Prime Ophthalmics will exclusively manufacture glass lens at its
Chennai laboratory for Corning India, which will in turn distribute these products to
opticians, wholesalers, dealers and other distributors in India. The company also launched
prescription lenses under the brand name, Visual Eyes, for the Indian market.
5.6.6 Indo-US venture to launch cancer detection tools
Genetics Specialties' a new Indo-US venture in cancer diagnostic tool kits in cancer
diagnostic tool kits was launched in Bangalore in February 2006. The company introduced a
range of genetic diagnostic kits and reagents to diagnostic labs and medical research
NIPER-Ahmedabad Page 33
Draft Copy
institutions across the country. Genetics Specialties' future plans include manufacturing
reagents in the country after a few years.
5.6.7 Indian medical devices market regulated
The government of India in 2004 constituted an advisory committee which suggested for the
creation of a specific medical devices division within the central drug standard control
organization (CDSCO).This division addresses the management, approval, certification and
quality assurance aspects of the medical devices. The CDSCO has made some guidelines
mandatory since June 29, 2006 in order to regulate the medical devices sector. The rules
specify that all the importers, stockists and retail sellers of medical devices should obtain
appropriate license from the concerned state licensing authorities by September 2006.
5.6.8 US Company develops device to monitor autonomic nervous system
DyAnsys Incorporation, a leading US based company has developed a device called
ANSiscope to monitor the autonomic nervous system (ANS). Its first big application came in
diabetes for the detection of a complication called diabetic autonomic neuropathy (DAN). By
early screening and detection of dysfunction in DAN, it could be possible to take steps to
prevent damage to organs like the heart, kidney etc., which diabetes tends to impact.
5.6.9 GE healthcare plans radio pharmacy centres
Medical diagnostics major GE Healthcare plans is setting up a radio pharmacy centre in Delhi
to provide nuclear medicine for hospitals around the capital. Similar centres would follow in
Mumbai, Bangalore and Hyderabad, according to a release here. The main objective is to
provide the imaging systems based on nuclear medicines which are used to detect a range of
diseases from cancer, coronary artery disease, infection, renal disease, Parkinson's,
Alzheimer's diseases, epilepsy and stroke.
5.6.10 Poly Medicure applies for eight new patents
Poly Medicure Ltd, manufacturers of medical devices and disposables under the brand,
Polymed, applied for 8 new patents and two USFDA (Food and Drug Administration)
approvals for its new range of safety syringes and safety blood collection holders.
5.6.11 GE Healthcare hopes to double revenues
Global healthcare equipments major GE is targeting to double its revenues from its South
Asia operations to USD 800 million in the next three years. About 90-95% of the revenues
come from India. The company would focus on making need-based investments in India in
manpower, manufacturing and technology. The company also plans to increase its manpower
NIPER-Ahmedabad Page 34
Draft Copy
in India. The company has around two thousand employees in India, who form about 40% of
the company's global engineering and technology expertise, and would be employing about
10% more.
5.6.12 Zydus to market diagnostic kits
Sarabhai Zydus Animal Health Ltd is set to launch high-tech diagnostic kits to diagnose and
control newly emerging infectious animal diseases that include avian influenza (bird flu) and
bovine viral diarrhoea. The Immuno-diagnostic Reagent kits will be sourced from Lillidale,
UK, which holds marketing rights for Veterinary Laboratories Agency (VLA) diagnostics
kits. VLA is one of the reputed referral laboratories based in the UK. The diagnostic kits will
enable Indian animal health researchers in differential diagnosis of different of pathogens
present anywhere in the world.
5.6.13 Strides acquires Warsaw-based sterile unit
Strides Arcolab has announced that its Polish subsidiary has acquired a Warsaw-based sterile
manufacturing unit formerly owned by ICN Valeant, a mid-sized US speciality pharma
company. The Bangalore-based Strides group will install additional capacity in sterile dose
form at the Warsaw plant and increase its workforce. Strides Polska will supply globally as
well as in Europe.
5.6.14 EuroCOR gets CE okay for products
EuroCOR, a wholly owned subsidiary of Opto Circuits (India) Ltd (OCIL), has received CE
approval for marketing and sale of Amadeus Super cross, a coronary dilation catheter and
EWire, a guide wire for interventional use. Both products are used in Coronary Angioplasty
(Percutaneous Transluminal Coronary Angioplasty — PTCA). The two products are expected
to add 3-5m and 1m, respectively, per year to Opto's top line.
5.6.15 GE Healthcare ties up with Manipal Health
Medical diagnostics major GE Healthcare has roped in Manipal Health Systems as its India
partner for its ongoing global clinical studies on its diagnostic products. These are imaging
agents being tested for diagnosis in oncology, neurology and cardiology. In the study starting
in September, a GE integrated development centre (IDC) equipped with GE medical devices
is to be set up at Manipal Hospital, Bangalore. Using its doctors as investigators, Manipal
will conduct 1,000 scans a year, initially contracted for three years, and return the raw data
from these imaging’s to GE.
NIPER-Ahmedabad Page 35
Draft Copy
6.0 REGULATORY ENVIRONMENT
6.1 Global Perspective
Clinical investigations of medical devices must comply with the Food and Drug
Administration (FDA) informed consent and Institutional Review Board (IRB) regulations.
Federal requirements governing investigations involving medical devices were enacted in the
US, as part of the Medical Device Amendments of 1976 and the Safe Medical Devices Act of
1990. These amendments to the Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act (the Act) define the
regulatory framework for medical device development, testing, approval, and marketing.
6.1.1 Industry classification
Medical devices are generally divided into class I, II and III, based on the level of risk to
users/patients, corresponding to logical risk evaluations conducted by the FDA. Class I
devices are the lowest risk classification and include general consumables such as crutches
and band aids, while class II controls are more specialized, such as wheelchairs. Class III
devices require pre-market approval, as they are known to present hazards requiring clinical
demonstration of safety and effectiveness. Devices in this category include heart valves,
catheters, cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR) devices and various implants.
6.2 Indian Outlook
The regulation of medical devices is often complicated by legal technicalities. In India, the
Department of Health has nominal jurisdiction over medical devices, evident from the illegal
re-processing and re-packaging of used syringes for re-sale and the availability of equipment
that fails minimum safety and quality standards. Unsterilised implants could cause infections
and stents coated with immuno-suppressant drugs are capable of impairing the body’s
immune system.
All devices carry a certain degree of risk therefore, the Global Harmonization Task Force
(GHTF) has identified potential areas of hazard that warrant consideration. These include
degree of invasiveness, duration of contact, the body system affected, and local versus
systemic effects. An invasive device is usually considered to have higher potential hazard
than an equivalent non-invasive one. Similarly, devices that have a long duration of contact
are assigned higher classes of potential hazard or risk.
The Ministry of Health and Family welfare under Gazette notification S.O. 1468 (E) dated
6th October 2005 declared the following sterile devices to be considered as drugs under
Section 3 (b) (iv) of the Act.
NIPER-Ahmedabad Page 36
Draft Copy
1. Cardiac Stents
2. Drug Eluting Stents
3. Catheters
4. Intra Ocular Lenses
5. I.V. Cannulae
6. Bone Cements
7. Heart Valves
8. Scalp Vein Set
9. Orthopedic Implants
10. Internal Prosthetic replacements
It was also notified vide GSR 627 (E) dated 7th October 2005 that control over manufacture
of these devices would be exercised by CLAA (i.e.) DCGI under the said Rules. The Ministry
of Health and Family Welfare have now approved the following procedures to be adopted
with respect to licensing of import as well as manufacture these Medical Devices in the
country.
6.2.1 Current guidelines for manufacturing of medical devices
1. Application for the grant of licence for manufacture of these notified sterile Devices in the
country shall be made in Form 27 to the State Licensing Authority, accompanied by the
requisite fee in the Form and manner as prescribed in the said rules along with a copy to
the office of DCGI.
2. A period of 60 days would be provided for making the application for manufacture from
the date of publication of these guidelines.
3. In case of devices belonging to the above said categories, which have not been
manufactured in the country before the date of notification, no manufacture would be
permitted hence forth without the approval of the competent authority as per norms
prescribed.
4. The applicant shall provide the following information alongwith the application for
consideration of the licensing authority.
6.2.2 Guidelines for import of medical devices
1. For the purpose of import of Devices specified above, the procedure for registration and
import licence as prescribed under the Drugs and Cosmetics Rules shall be followed.
NIPER-Ahmedabad Page 37
Draft Copy
2. A period of 60 days would be provided for the importers to make application for import
and registration from the date of publication of these guidelines. However, on 28/04/2006,
it is further extended by another 60 days (i.e) till 29th June, 2006.
3. In case of devices which have not been imported in the country before the date of
notification no import would be permitted without the approval of the competent
authority.
4. For the time being and for a period upto six months, until an application is approved for
rejected, whichever is earlier, the devices which are currently in use will be permitted to
be sold. In case of stents or drug eluting stents, the import will not be permitted if the
applicant has sold less than one thousand stents of the particular specification prior to the
date of issue of these guidelines.
5. Separate committees consisting of subject experts and representative of DCGI office
would be setup for their expert advice for evaluation of specific categories of devices. The
expert committees would formulate their own benchmarks and procedures for evaluations
and the standards to which such devices should conform.
6.2.3 Sale of medical devices in the country
The importers, stockist and retail sellers of Medical Devices shall obtain appropriate sale
licences from the State Licensing Authorities for these Medical Devices.
7.0 SWOT ANALYSIS OF MEDICAL DEVICE INDUSTRY
7.1 Strengths
Potentially Huge market with growing urban middle class population
Growing private hospital sector aiming to attract health tourists
7.2 Weaknesses
Low per capita expenditure
Lack of implementation of government policies and infrastructure
Untapped rural markets
Excessive dependency on imports
Academic know-how is not well developed in this sector
Support system from R & D not available
7.3 Opportunities
Overseas companies investing in India to set up research units and develop new
products
NIPER-Ahmedabad Page 38
Draft Copy
Increasing Joint ventures and agreements
Overseas aid assisted projects to improve healthcare infrastructure
Regulations to improve market for domestic manufacturers.
7.4 Threats
Regulation policies may slow down the development of the market
Unorganized market for medical disposables
Lack of regulations in Medical disposables and surgical items leading to spurious
products.
8.0 GROWTH DRIVERS
The growth of Indian medical devices and diagnostics industry is driven by a host of factors.
8.1 Booming Economy
The absolute value of GDP for the Indian economy is found to be increasing during the last
decade, while its growth rate over previous year has been fluctuating. The continuous
positive growth of economy (and the correspondingly increasing per capita GDP) has led to
increased personal income and higher standards of life. Moreover, the ever increasing ‘class
shifting’ of Indian population from ‘aspirants and climbers’ (annual per capita income
between USD 100-500) class to ‘consuming’ class (annual per capita income between USD
1000-5000), which is a spill over effect of growing economy, has also increased the demand
for access to better healthcare. These factors have cumulatively pushed up the demand for
medical devices and diagnostic industry in the recent years.
8.2 Increasing Healthcare Expenditure
In India, the role of Central Government is limited to family welfare and disease control
programs, while the state governments are responsible for primary and secondary medical
care with a limited role in specialty care. In India, healthcare expenditure constitutes about
12% of the national annual expenditure. Of this, 82% of the total health expenditure comes
from the self-paid category, while employers account for 9% and insurance covers 5% of the
total healthcare expenses.
There are two types of healthcare expenditure spent by Indian households; payments to the
healthcare providers, which constitute a major 98.5% of total healthcare expenditure while
the rest is the expenditure towards payments to health insurance premiums. Therefore, the
Indian population is spending a majority share of healthcare expenditure towards healthcare
NIPER-Ahmedabad Page 39
Draft Copy
service providers such as hospitals, thus indicating a potential for medical devices industry
for its supply of medical equipments and diagnostics to these healthcare service providers.
8.3 Changing Demographic Profile
Improvement of overall health status and socio-economic pressures has resulted in changes in
the demographic profile. With a decline in birth rates, the population aged 0-14 has declined,
while on the other hand improvement in life expectancy has led to an increase in old age
population in recent years, which is projected to continue in future (Figure 11). On an
average this past trend has led to higher per capita demand for health services, and has had a
positive impact on the demand for medical devices.
Figure 11: Age group-wise percentage distribution of population
8.4 Increasing Incidence of Lifestyle Diseases
The type of healthcare service requirement and thus the demand pattern for medial devices in
India has changed due to a rise of lifestyle-related diseases such as diabetes, cardiovascular
diseases, and diseases of the central nervous system. There are around 0.7 million new cases
of cancer each year and approximately 2.5 million cases. It is estimated that there are around
40 million people in India with diabetes, 5.1 million HIV/AIDS patients, and 14 million
tuberculosis cases. In the past year, the Indian pharmaceutical industry witnessed a growth of
7%, the cardio-vascular segment (15-17%) and the anti-diabetes segment (10-12%). The
increasing incidences of these life style diseases eventually increase the demand for medical
devices and diagnostics.
NIPER-Ahmedabad Page 40
Draft Copy
Ophthalmology: The annual incidence of cataract in India, the cause of 80% of blindness, is
3.8 million cases. The total potential for surgical cataract removal is 1.75 million cases per
year.
Cancer: The total number of cancer cases in India was estimated at 924,790 in 2001. This is
projected to increase to 1.22 million by 2011 and to 1.56 million by 2021.
Cardiovascular diseases: The mortality rate due to cardiac arrest and related causes was
estimated at 2.4 million . With increasing urbanization the problem is on the rise.
Hypertension, diabetes and renal diseases: These stress and lifestyle related disorders are on
the rise. The diabetic population in India is projected to increase from 40 million of 2001 to
47 million people in 2010. Hypertension is lower in rural areas but on an increase in urban
cities. Both hypertension and diabetes further cause renal disorders.
Neurological and psychiatric disorders and addictions: The current prevalence rate for
neurological disorders is 15 to 20 people per thousand. The most common ailments are
epilepsy, migraine, cerebrovascular disorders, Parkinson’s disease and peripheral
neuropathies. It is estimated that 1% of the population is suffering from serious psychiatric
illnesses, 10-15% have neuro-disorders, and 2.5% are mentally retarded.
8.5 Increasing Number of Medical Tourists
India is fast becoming one of preferred destinations for medical tourism- patients going to a
different country for either urgent or elective medical procedures. Reasons vary for medical
tourism; a USA patient seeking treatment at a quarter or sometimes even a 10th of the cost at
home, long waiting times for medical services in Canada or patient who can’t wait for
treatment by the National Health Service but also can't afford to see a physician in private
practice are coming to India for their treatments with a tropical vacation. Patients are coming
from poorer countries like Bangladesh where treatment may not be available. Other countries
that actively promote medical tourism include Cuba, Costa Rica, Hungary, Israel, Jordan,
Lithuania, Malaysia and Thailand. The entrants are Belgium, Poland and Singapore. India's
National Health Policy declares that treatment of foreign patients is legally an "export" and
deemed "eligible for all fiscal incentives extended to export earnings." Given India’s top of
the line hospital facilities, diagnostic facilities and medical practitioners, this has become a
virtual growth sector. According to the Confederation of Indian Industries, India has a
potential to attract 1m health tourists per annum, currently growing at an annual rate of
around 25% that is predicted to bring in at least USD 2 billion within the next 6–7 years.
Another report projected that the industry is to grow by 30% annually. The positive fall out of
NIPER-Ahmedabad Page 41
Draft Copy
this would be an up gradation of medical facilities, in terms of new equipments, diagnostic
lab reports, equipments etc. The growth of medical tourism industry is to complement the
growth the medical devices and diagnostic equipments industry. Orthopedic or arthroscopic
surgeries are some of the medical procedures for which India has become a popular medical
tourism destination. Therefore, the demand for orthopedic devices in India is likely to
increase in future. Many corporate hospitals in India are also entering in to medical tourism
field and offer services to foreign patients. One among them is the Apollo Hospital
Enterprises, which is one of the pioneers in providing medical tourism services in India.
Elective treatments, such as cosmetic surgery, corrective vision surgery, and dental
procedures, generally not covered by insurance, also attract many western citizens to India.
Moreover, some U.S. insurance companies, such as BlueCross BlueShield, have begun
collaborating with some hospitals in India. The recent regulation on medical devices, which
is set to increase the cost of medical devices and the test services, are predicted to be
detrimental to the growth of medical tourism industry earlier. It is argued that India could
lose some cost advantage as a healthcare destination, as medical devices constitute a major
portion of total hospitalisation costs.
However, contrary to perceptions, the medical tourism industry has not been affected as
majority of the hospitals catering to medical tourism are tertiary in nature and have existing
pre-requisites for USFDA/ CE certification, prior to device purchase. In fact, the enforcement
of certification of medical devices will be beneficial, as foreign patients will be able to avail
locally manufactured devices that are certified, expanding the domestic market significantly.
Patients availing of medical tourism are willing to pay higher device costs to ensure safety
and quality, as overall healthcare is considerably cheaper in India. Moreover, a 5-10% cost
increase will not affect medical tourism much, as treatment itself is two to three times
cheaper in India. The regulation has indeed increased the popularity of India as a destination
for medical tourists due to the above reasons.
8.6 Proliferation of Hospitals
Indian healthcare system has two components, public and private services. The public
healthcare system offers three-tier services at primary, secondary and tertiary-levels with
differentiated units like sub-centres, PHCs, CHCs, and at village, block, and district levels.
The subcentres, PHCs and CHCs have grown considerably. The tertiary care service is
provided by 117 medical collages and hospitals in the country. Over 4,049 public sector
hospitals and 11,344 private hospitals are providing services. In India, the private healthcare
NIPER-Ahmedabad Page 42
Draft Copy
service providers delivers 63% total healthcare services while the remaining 37% healthcare
service is delivered by public healthcare system like governmental agencies. The increasing
thrust on private healthcare services results in burgeoning number of private hospitals which
corresponds to an increasing demand for essential medical devices and diagnostics.
Therefore, increasing medical infrastructures like hospitals, specialised diagnostic centres,
tele-medicine centres, laboratories are expected to fuel the demand for medical devices in
future.
8.7 Government Programmes and Support
Though the role of government in the promotion and development of medical devices
industry in India is limited, its welfare programmes and few policy measures are indirectly
supporting the industry.
The central and state government has been operationalizing various health and family
welfare schemes throughout India over years. Schemes to control communicable
(especially AIDS control programmes) and non-communicable diseases (for cancer,
etc), initiatives on telemedicine, National Diabetics programme, modernisation of
hospitals, family welfare schemes like family planning and contraception programmes,
etc are operated by the central government in the secondary and tertiary healthcare
service delivery. The primary healthcare service is the responsibility of the state
governments. The budgetary support for these schemes in both central and state sector
is continually increasing over years mainly due to an increasing span of population to
be covered under these schemes and increasing incidence of diseases. This could be
correlated to corresponding increase in the demand for medical devices and diagnostics,
the trend of which is expected to continue in future.
The National Health Policy (NHP) – 2002 announced by the Government envisages
increasing public health investment to 2% of GDP by the year 2010 from the existing
level of 0.9% and the total health investment to 6% from the current level of 5.2%. The
NHP-2002 welcomes the participation of the private sector in all areas of health
services-primary, secondary and tertiary.
The government is also extending concessions to charity organisations, hospitals in
terms of duty-free import of medical devices, in case if the device/technology is not
available in India and import is unavoidable. The concessions under Export Promotion
Capital Goods (EPCG) are also availed by importers and distributors of medical devices
and diagnostics.
NIPER-Ahmedabad Page 43
Draft Copy
8.8 Outsourcing/Relocating of Medical Devices Manufacturing by Western Companies
European and USA medical devices companies are actively considering outsourcing or
relocating their manufacturing to Asia especially India and China to take advantage of its
significantly lower costs for skilled labour. Moreover, if India could provide these medical
devices that meet quality requirements and international standards, then it would be highly
attractive to an increasing number of healthcare providers in western countries who are
struggling to contain costs and facing tightening budgetary restraints. Another advantage of
relocating manufacturing to India is that it puts them in an ideal location to penetrate the
vastly underdeveloped Asian medical devices market, while also keeping product prices
closer to those typical of the region. In Bangalore, Siemens India Ltd set up a new R&D
facility in 2004 to expand research in the medical and information technology sectors for
developing user-friendly medical imaging systems in order to leverage India’s advantage of
low cost of production and highly skilled manpower. The favoured destinations for
outsourcing the manufacturing of medial devices are China and India. However, there are
certain hiccups like lack of awareness on complying to international manufacturing
guidelines and standards by most of Indian manufacturers, and fear of Intellectual property
protection for devices/technologies, etc. The Asian medical devices market does not have to
follow any particular standards, unlike European companies, which have to comply with the
Conformité Européene Mark (CE Mark). However, increasing number of companies in India
have started to comply with International Organization for Standardization (ISO) and the
good manufacturing practice (GMP) standards and getting certifications like Trivitron and
Wipro-Biomed. Indian Manufacturers in Asia are realising that pursuing CE Mark
certification can help them compete more effectively with companies producing higher-
quality goods for sales into Europe. The other concern of foreign manufacturers outsourcing
to India is regarding Intellectual property rights protection. Of late, contract research
organisations (CROs)- which are research and development (R&D) outsourcing companies-
are starting to introduce intellectual property standards to increase confidence levels of
foreign companies and to promote greater outsourcing interest in both R&D and
manufacturing in Asia. Therefore, with the popularity of being the preferred outsourcing
destination for other services, India can attract more foreign companies for contract
manufacturing of medical devices, once the above-mentioned constraints and apprehensions
are addressed. Indian medical devices manufacturing industry will benefit largely from the
outsourcing activity in future.
NIPER-Ahmedabad Page 44
Draft Copy
8.9 User Friendly and Handy Devices
With the increase incidences of lifestyle diseases and increasing general awareness, the
handheld, simple, convenient, user- friendly devices for measuring and monitoring various
healthcare parameters are on the rise. Medical devices such as blood glucometers, digital BP
meters, digital thermometers, digital weighing machines and nebulisers are few popular
examples of handy devices for monitoring various parameters. These devices are economical,
time-saving and convenient with a user-friendly interface and hence become popular.
8.10 Telemedicine
Telemedicine is a method by which specialist doctors can examine, investigate, monitor and
treat patients in remote areas through satellite video conferencing. Telemedicine is used to
transmit patients' medical images, records, output from medical devices and live two-way
audio and video. With the help of these, specialist doctors can advise, online, the doctors or
paramedics at the patient's end on medical care, or even guide the doctor during a surgery. In
a vast territory like India where rural areas are not having comparable healthcare
infrastructures, telemedicine has come to rescue. Government of India is also interested in
promotion of telemedicine in India, which is evident from budgetary allocation of INR 15
crore for 2006-07. Private healthcare service providers such as Apollo Telemedicine Network
Foundation, and Narayana Hrudayalaya and Heartcare India, etc and charity hospitals like
Amrita Institute of medical sciences and Sankara Nethralaya, are prominent in the Indian
telemedicine scene. Therefore with the public and private sector efforts, the telemedicine is
expected to expand in India. With the growth of telemedicine services in India demand for
diagnostic medical equipment such as X-rays, CT-scanners, Dopplers, ultrasound and
electrocardiographs is also expected to grow. Some of the telemedicine providers are
importing the peripherals like medical film scanner, video microscopy system, ECG machine,
electronic stethoscope, spirometer integrated with the application due to their unavailability
in the Indian market. Therefore, the systematic growth of telemedicine in India is
encouraging the production of high-end technology products like those that have been
mentioned above as technology development is the need of the hour, which ultimately helps
in the further evolution of medical devices industry in India.
8.11 Industry Forecast
In the coming years, the medical equipment market in India is expected to have high growth
rates. The key factors contributing to this are:
Increasing urban middle class population who are demanding better healthcare services
NIPER-Ahmedabad Page 45
Draft Copy
Expansion of corporate hospitals and research institutes in the country India is a key
market for medical equipment devices.
The current trends show that the demand for the medical devices has been going up by 15-
20% in the recent years. Thus, the supply needs to be in proportion to meet this demand and
if the local manufacturers are unable to provide quality products in sufficient quantity at par
with imported devices, then the dependency on imports will increase to an extent wherein the
local companies totally lose the market to the International companies.
Thus, if a condition of minimum value addition and variability in pricing exists for long, the
profits are sure to dwindle soon leading to almost certain downfall of the local manufacturers.
9.0 FUTURE DIRECTION
The Indian market for medical equipment and supplies was valued at USD 1318 million in
2005 and it is estimated the market to become USD 2028 million by 2010 with an annual
growth rate of 9%. The industry has seen tremendous growth over the last decade and the
current development and the pace will trigger the market to reach the estimated market size.
The market has opened up for new entrants with mainly importers dominating the market.
Lot of joint ventures, agreements and loan licensing procedures have influenced the market.
The market is largely dependent on the private sector where investment is not a major
concern. Continuous innovation in developing new products has created high demand in the
market. Many multinational firms import equipment as they see a profitable growth in the
Indian market. Some overseas companies have also established their manufacturing plants in
India. The government has also taken several reforms to develop the market by regulating it
to bring out more transparencies and by allowing foreign investments to participate in the
events. Importers and distributors utilize the opportunity of the events to establish a direct
network with the consumers. These events mainly help in customer awareness, new product
launches and in direct sales of the products.
In a nutshell, continued investment in private sector infrastructure, coupled with increased
healthcare funding from the government, have resulted in a steady increase in the market for
medical equipment and supplies. It is estimated that the market will continue to grow by an
average of 9% over the next five years, driven largely by health tourism and the size of the
Indian middle class. The recent liberalisation of trade and investment laws, together, with a
growing commitment to national healthcare, makes India one of the most promising
emerging markets for medical device manufacturers.
NIPER-Ahmedabad Page 46
Draft Copy
Figure 14: Future growth of medical equipment market in India (USD million)
10.0 PHARMA CORRELATION
In 2004, the Mashelkar Committee called for the creation of a specific medical devices
division within the Central Drugs Standard Control Organisation (CDSCO) to address the
management, approval, certification and quality assurance of all medical devices in India.
These regulations work within a similar framework as medical ‘drugs’ (or combination
products) and aim to enhance the requirements for devices that were subject to few or no
controls, reduce duplication of devices previously assessed by foreign regulatory bodies and
place increased emphasis on manufacturer quality, risk management systems and post-market
surveillance.
10.1 Combination Products: The Future of Medical Devices
Combination Products is an emerging innovation that has resulted in benefits to patients &
has attracted many life sciences companies, physicians, and investors. The combination
products combine the benefits of drugs, biologics & medical device by converging
pharmaceutical & medical device manufacturers. Technological advances in drugs, medical
devices, and biologic-based products continue to lead to the development of products aimed
at improving patient outcomes and extending human life. Marrying two or more of these
healthcare products into a combination product, such as a drug-eluting stent, demonstrates
patient benefits like:
NIPER-Ahmedabad Page 47
Draft Copy
Innovative ways to extend lifecycles of existing products for manufacturers
Reduced toxicity in patients
Fewer side effects for patients
Higher rate of efficiency
Improved patient compliance
10.1.1 FDA definition of combination products
The term combination product includes:
1. A product comprised of two or more regulated components, i.e., drug/device,
biologic/device, drug/biologic, or drug/device/biologic, that are physically, chemically, or
otherwise combined or mixed and produced as a single entity
2. Two or more separate products packaged together in a single package or as a unit and
comprised of drug and device products, device and biological products, or biological and
drug products
3. A drug, device, or biological product packaged separately that according to its
investigational plan or proposed labeling is intended for use only with an approved
individually specified drug, device, or biological product where both are required to
achieve the intended use, indication, or effect and where upon approval of the proposed
product the labeling of the approved product would need to be changed, e.g., to reflect a
change in intended use, dosage form, strength, route of administration, or significant
change in dose
4. Any investigational drug, device, or biological product packaged separately that according
to its proposed labeling is for use only with another individually specified investigational
drug, device, or biological product where both are required to achieve the intended use,
indication, or effect.
Technological advances in drugs, medical devices, and biologic-based products continue to
lead to the development of products aimed at improving patient outcomes and extending
human life. Marrying two or more of these healthcare products into a combination product,
such as a drug-eluting stent, demonstrates patient benefits like :
Innovative ways to extend lifecycles of existing products for manufacturers
Reduced toxicity in patients
Fewer side effects for patients
Higher rate of efficiency
Improved patient compliance
NIPER-Ahmedabad Page 48
Draft Copy
10.1.2 Combination products: Categorization
a) Traditional drug-delivery systems combine or package drugs together with injection
devices to improve convenience of administration. This includes prefilled syringes, pen-
based delivery systems, drug pumps, and auto injectors. Because the drug-device interface
is relatively simple in these products, the components can be developed separately and
then integrated during later stages of their development cycles. These components can
also be regulated separately using the established regulatory regimes for drugs and
devices.
b) Novel drug-delivery systems (e.g., patches, transdermal or intradermal injections,
inhalation devices, sprays, and drug-eluting disks) typically combine existing drugs with
new delivery devices. These are designed to improve convenience and comfort of
administration, improve drug effectiveness through localized administration, or enable
delivery of a drug through a non-traditional route (other than oral or subcutaneous and
intramuscular injections). Although the complexity of these products is typically
moderate, changes to administration, drug formulation, and bioavailability can increase
the technology of drug development. Because their primary therapeutic mode of action is
drug related, these products are primarily governed by the regulatory pathway for drugs.
c) Drug-enhanced devices, such as drug-eluting stents, coated catheters, anti-infective
sutures, bone cements with antimicrobial agents, and other devices with antimicrobial
coatings enhance the functionality, efficacy, or performance of devices. In many cases,
these products combine existing devices with existing drugs. Although the complexity of
the device component could vary depending on its function, the drug-device interface is
often novel and is critical to the performance of the combination product. Consequently,
development is much more complicated than similar device-only products. Because the
primary therapeutic action stems from devices, device regulators primarily govern these
products, with a secondary review from drug-related regulatory agencies.
d) Regenerative medicinal products combine devices with biologically active substances to
facilitate healing and regenerate damaged tissues. The device often serves as the
scaffolding for the growth of the biologic component and the product is often an implant.
Examples include Dermagraft (human fibroblast-derived dermal substitute), coated
absorbable meshes for bone growth, spinal fusion cages with recombinant human bone
morphogenic proteins, and the artificial replacement organs (e.g., bioartificial pancreas).
These are the most complex combination products because they have to take into
NIPER-Ahmedabad Page 49
Draft Copy
consideration the interaction between the product and the body's response to it. The
development process for such products is also the most complicated and integrated
because the components under development must be tightly coupled. The primary mode
of action varies on a case-by-case basis, as does the lead review and oversight agency.
In order to help in determining the most appropriate regulatory pathway, the FDA developed
a categorization scheme for combination products. Under this scheme, a product is placed
into one of nine categories:
Convenience kit or co-package
Prefilled drug delivery device/system
Prefilled biologic delivery device/system
Device coated/impregnated/otherwise combined with drug
Device coated or otherwise combined with biologic
Drug/biologic combination
Separate products requiring mutually conforming labelling
Possible combination product based on mutually conforming labelling of separate
products
Other type of combination product
10.1.3 Example of combination product: Drug eluting stent (DES) and targeted drug
delivery
As an alternative to systemic therapy, local drug delivery offers the advantages of allowing
high concentration of drug at the treatment site while minimizing systemic toxic effects.
Delivering medication directly to the site of vascular injury via polymer coated stents is a
rational approach to achieve adequate local drug delivery.
Artificial or natural polymers that are biocompatible and biodegradable are often used for the
preparation of particulate systems. Such polymers include polylactic Acid (PLA), polylactic -
co-glycolic acid (PLGA), Acrylic Polymers or Co-polymers, hyaluronic acid derivatives and
alginates. Among the available biodegradable polymer, the PLA and PLGA are the most
widely used. Drug compounds are mixed in the polymers matrix and gradually become
released as the polymer is dissolved in the tissue.
The drug polymer coating can be applied by dipping or spraying of solution, consisting of
drug and polymer, mixed in desired proportion, using evaporative solvent material of
relatively high vapour pressure to produce the desired viscosity, and quickly established
NIPER-Ahmedabad Page 50
Draft Copy
coating layer thickness. Dip coating is often undesirable for coating complex geometries like
stents, since coating solution may get entrapped, in the device structure which may typically
cause bridging, i.e. forming of a film across the open space between structural members of
the device. This can interfere with the mechanical performance of the stent, such as
expansion during deployment in a vessel lumen. Bridges tend to delaminate and rupture the
coating film during expansion and provide sites that activate platelet deposition by creating
flow disturbances in the adjacent homodynamic environment. In addition, delamination may
cause particles to dislodge from the stent surface, potentially leading to other complications.
Also multiple layer coating of drug - polymer solution is not possible with dip coating
technique, as the freshly coated layer diffuses within the previously coated layers causing
there dissolution.
The research on developing coating technique was made at university of Texas health science
centre at San Antonio, TX, USA, research and development division using stent of
Sahajanand Medical Technology, India, to develop a four layer drug - polymer matrix,
programmed to achieve controlled drug released and that can be spray coated by means of air
suspension technique on the cardiovascular stent. Unlike the multiple layer coating , single
layer coated stents offer constant drug release profile, which is not desirable in the case of
local drug delivery where drug demand decreases from the time of stent implantation.
To ensure the proper coating integrity stents were subjected to balloon expandability test.
Drug coated stents were crimped on the balloon by means of crimping machine. The crimped
stents were expanded by expansion device. Sterile fluid was pumped as an expansion media.
Stent was crimped on the balloon and expanded at rated pressure of 6 atm.
11.0 PRICING ISSUES
Pricing strategies need to balance the demands of the market with the needs of the company.
Pricing objectives need to be closely linked with organizational and marketing objectives, as
well as taking account of cash-flow requirements, profit objectives and return on investment
(ROI). In addition, they must take into account the market’s price sensitivity. In view of the
complexities involved in pricing obtaining an efficient pricing strategy is an important issue
for all medical device and diagnostic companies.
The Government is bringing in a medical devices Act in a bid to regulate prices of healthcare
equipment. Thirty to forty percent of healthcare costs comprise of diagnostic kits and other
medial equipment and hence the Act will ensure an ISO certification procedure for medical
NIPER-Ahmedabad Page 51
Draft Copy
equipment and it will make manufactures of medical devices adhere to proper standards. This
initiative will reduce the cost of healthcare considerably by making it more competitive
because as currently we import them instead of letting our own industry manufacture the
devices. Thus, once we have the demographic advantage of having the lowest cost in
healthcare, then we can take leverage of that in the international market.
Further, industry experts recommend that all devices that are USFDA or CE certified should
be fast-tracked and not have to go through the entire regulatory process in India, as the
amount of regulations and cost of healthcare in a country are directly proportionate. This can
be demonstrated by the example of Japan which is the most regulated market consequently
having the highest cost of healthcare. For example, a certified mechanical bi-leaflet heart
valve sells in India for USD 1000, Europe for USD 4000, US for USD 7000 and in Japan for
USD 12000. Not only are high costs passed down the value chain to patients but also restrict
the availability of devices, as those which do not accrue a minimum revenue to cover costs,
do not make business sense to import.
12.0 FEW PREMIER INSTITUTES / ORGANIZATIONS IN INDIA WITH
RELEVANT EXPERTISE IN THE AREA
12.1 Sree Chitra Tirunal Institute for Medical Sciences and Technology, Chennai
A multidisciplinary team of scientists and engineers along with the supporting staff work here
in multidisciplinary areas from biomaterial development and characterization to medical
device development, testing and evaluation. A technical facility exists for the pilot production
of medical devices as a link between the institute and industry. The biomedical technology
wing has implemented a quality system to meet the requirements of international ISO/IEC
17025 standards and several tests have also received international accreditation. The facilities
available include instruments for Material Characterization, Biomaterials, Biomedical
Engineering, Biological Evaluation and other general facilities like FTIR, Thermal Analyzer,
GC, HPLC, X-Ray Diffractometer, Bio-ceramics laboratory, Scanning Electron Microscopy,
biosurface technology, polymer technology and analysis, Artificial organs development, ,
modelling and prototyping, dental products, polymer processing, precision fabrication