Voices of Wealth: Canadian Affluent Investor Report What high-net-worth investors say they want from advisers, brokers and information sources.
Voices of Wealth:Canadian Affluent Investor ReportWhat high-net-worth investors say they want from advisers, brokers and information sources.
Canadian Affluent Investor Report
In a recovering market, the most important asset that advisers and wealth managers can offer their clients is this: meaningful financial insight. The critical decisions advisers make and the guidance they offer clients to help them prosper must be informed by timely intelligence on breaking events and emerging market developments. These are the basis for confidence-inspiring insight. More importantly, decisions that result must be based on reliable information.
What Advisers Should KnowWhat’s expected of advisers is clear. But how well do these expectations match the desires and needs of their clients? Since 2002, Dow Jones has commissioned independent, biennial studies of affluent investors in the United States to uncover what they read, what they want and what they expect from their advisers and wealth managers. In 2010, we expanded the study to include research on affluent investors in Canada.
This report reflects the results of the Canadian study completed in October 2010 by the independent firm Opinion Research Corporation, based in Princeton, N.J. The study targeted a random sample of Canadian affluent investors age 25 or older with at least $250,000 in investable assets (excluding RSP and other retirement plan contributions); ultimately, 209 respondents participated.
This report is their voice. In the following pages, you’ll learn more about who they are and what they expect. You’ll see that their opinions on the quality of various news services are remarkably consistent. In addition, you’ll find a few suggestions for improving your contact strategy with survey input that can help you focus your communications on the issues that matter to your most important audience: affluent investors.
High Points At A Glance: • Primary source for helping investors make investment
decisions: The Globe & Mail
• Highest-ranked financial news source for credibility, accuracy, trustworthiness and usefulness: The Wall Street Journal
• News source respondents most prefer their adviser/wealth manager to use: Dow Jones
Who Participated In The Study?The online study was conducted in October 2010 among a random sample of Canadian affluent investors, obtained from an external customer panel. The panel was not aware that Dow Jones had commissioned the study.
• Minimum age for participation was 25 years old.
• Majority of participants (66%) were 50 or older.
The qualifying financial threshold was $250,000 or more in investable assets such as stocks, bonds, mutual funds, etc., excluding retirement vehicles, such as RSP plans.
Extrapolating results across the population of Canadian affluent investors yields a +/- 6.7% margin of error at the 95% confidence level.
Investors identified a wide variety of firms they use to help them make investment decisions, from full-service to independent to online/discount firms. About 50% use more than one type of firm.
By the designated field closing date in October 2010, 209 affluent investors had participated in the study. Here’s a snapshot of who they are:
ASSETS:
• $250,000 - $999,999: 70%• $1 million - $2,999,999: 19% • $3 million or more: 10%
HOUSEHOLD INCOME:
• $99,999 or less: 13%• $100,000 - $249,999: 55%• $250,000 or more: 32%
AGE:
• 49 and under: 33%• 50 and over: 66%
EDUCATION:
University or Higher Degree: 82%
You might select a news service for your advisers’ needs. But what about your clients?
Page 2
Canadian Affluent Investor Report
Goals of the StudyThe aim of the 2010 Canadian Affluent Investor Study was to gain a better understanding of opportunities within three key investment firm categories: Full Service, Independent and Online/Discount investment firms.
Specifically, the study’s key objectives were to:
• Identify affluent investors’ primary sources of financial news, information and advice (figure 1)
• Assess investors’ perceptions of news and information services
• Explore investors’ relationships with their firm and adviser
• Gauge investors’ usage of, and satisfaction with, online/discount services
Key InsightThe 2010 Canadian Affluent Investor Study suggests that the majority of affluent investors, who own a wide array of investments (figure 2), often turn to advisers in full-service and independent firms when making financial decisions. In addition, 61% of affluent investors rely on their adviser when seeking financial or investment advice.
Q1. Please indicate which of the following types of assets/investments, excluding retirement savings plans (RSPs), you or other members of your household now own. Select all that apply. Base: Total (n=209)
Affluent households own a wide variety of assets and investments, and mostly, traditional
investments like stocks and mutual funds.
Assets/Investments Owned by Household
6
Mutual Funds
Money Market Funds
Bonds (excluding Government Securities)
Stocks
Real Estate Investment Trusts (REITs)
Government Securities/Treasuries
Exchange Traded Funds (ETFs)
Certificates of Deposit (CDs)
Futures (stock, currency, etc.)
Non-Domestic Stocks (ADRs, GDRs, etc.)
Options
Alternative Investments
Annuities Variable/Fixed
Hedge Funds
IRAs
Other Foreign Investments
Unit Investment Trusts (UITs)
Commodities
Other Investments
Figure 2: Assets/Investments OwnedRespondent assets represented a wide range of investments, led by stocks, mutual funds, CDs and bonds.
Not only do they want a more collaborative relationship with advisers and wealth managers, but they are choosing more independent channels through which to invest. In fact, close to a third of affluent investors use independent firms.
Affluent investors seek out sources with the highest quality financial information—and expect their advisers/wealth managers to do the same.
Page 3
Q13C. Which one do you consider to be your PRIMARY source of financial news to help inform your investment decisions? Base: Total (n=209) Dow Jones brand comprised of The Wall Street Journal, Dow Jones, MarketWatch, Barron’s, Smart Money and Big Charts.
For their primary source, Globe & Mail is the most frequently cited. One-quarter of affluent
investors use Globe Mail as their primary source, 11% rely on their brokerage firm’s website
and 9% use any Dow Jones brand.
Primary Source of Financial News Used to Help Inform Investment Decisions Total
13
Any Dow Jones Brand
Wall Street Journal
Yahoo! Finance
Your brokerage firm’s website
National Post
Dow Jones
Bloomberg News
Morningstar
CNBC
CNN Money
Reuters
MarketWatch
TMX Money
ROB-TV
Globe & Mail
Sources with < 2%:
Barron’s
Big Charts
Business Week
Forbes
Associated Press
MSN Money
Fox Business News
Smart Money
Fortune
Motley Fool
Thomson
Investor’s Business Daily
Street.com
Briefing.com
Financial Times
Toronto Star
Google Finance
Figure 1: Primary Source of Financial News
“�Affluent�investors�are�choosing�more�independent�channels�through�which�to�invest...”
Canadian Affluent Investor Report
Page 4
Q10. Which of the following do you rely on for financial or investment advice? Select all that apply. Q11. Which do you rely on most for financial or investment advice? Base: Total (n=209)
Affluent investors are, by far, most likely to rely on an advisor/broker for financial and
investment advice. Many also use news and info websites and business/financial
publications.
Sources Rely on for Financial or Investment Advice Total
11
News and Information Websites
Business/Financial Publications
My Brokerage Firm's Website
Financial Adviser/Broker
Financial Planner
Accountant/CPA
Colleague/Friend
Financial TV Programming
Other
Rely On Rely on Most
Spouse/Other Family Member
Figure 4: Sources of Investment Advice
0
Q4a/l. During the past 6 months, with which of the following financial services firms have you invested or traded? Select all that apply. Q4B. Which one of these firms would you consider to be your primary investment firm? Base: Q4 (n=194) Q4I (n=177)
Half of these investors use more than one financial services firm. And, full service firms are
most commonly used with far fewer using independent or online/discount firms.
Types of Investment Firms Used
Any
Full Service
Independent
Online/Discount
Primary
50% use multiple firms
Figure 3: Types of Investment Firms Used
Types of Firms Affluent Investors Use The majority of investors surveyed use Full Service firms (81%). Close to three-quarters of respondents consider full-service firms as their primary investment firm type (71%). Still, half of these investors have used multiple firms (including Independent and Online/Discount firms) but only a small minority (10%) consider Online/Discount firms as their primary choice (figure 3).
News Sources Affluent Investors TrustIt’s not surprising that financial advisers/brokers were the top source of investment advice for affluent investors (figure 4). And given several choices, a significant number of investors indicated that they prefer their adviser use Dow Jones as the source of information when providing investment guidance.
What news sources emerged as most important? When asked to identify the financial news sources they use to inform investment decisions, respondents cited The Globe & Mail most often (56%), followed by “Any Dow Jones Brand” with 43%. Dow Jones led the next most popular choice (The National Post at 34%) by 9 percentage points, and the next financial news media, Bloomberg (23%), by 20 percentage points (figure 5).
Q13A. Which of these sources of financial news do you use to help inform your investment decisions? Select all that apply. Base: Total (n=202) Dow Jones brand comprised of The Wall Street Journal, Dow Jones, MarketWatch, Barron’s, Smart Money and Big Charts.
The majority of these affluent investors use Globe & Mail. Slightly fewer than one-half use a
Dow Jones brand of financial news to help inform their investment decisions.
Any Sources of Financial News Used to Help Inform Investment Decisions Total
12
Brokerage firm’s website
Bloomberg News
Dow Jones
National Post
Wall Street Journal
ROB-TV
CNN Money
Business Week
Yahoo! Finance
Toronto Star
Morningstar
MarketWatch
Forbes
Google Finance
Reuters
The Motley Fool
Fortune
Associated Press
Globe & Mail
Any Dow Jones brand
Sources with < 5%:
MSN Money
Thomson
TMXMoney
Big Charts
Barron’s
Smart Money
Investor’s Business Daily
The Street.com
Briefing.com
Fox Business News
Financial Times
CNBC
Figure 5: Any Sources of Financial News Used to Help Inform Investment Decisions
“�Half�of�the�investors�in�this�report�use�multiple�firms�for�their�investments�but�only�10%�consider�online/discount�firms�as�their�primary�choice...”
Canadian Affluent Investor Report
Page 5
Q20. And which of these financial news sources would you prefer your broker or financial advisor use when they are advising you on investment decisions?
Base: Use full-service or independent firm and have a broker/financial advisor (n=126)
Significantly more affluent investors prefer their broker/advisor use Dow Jones than
other financial news sources when advising them on investment decisions.
Financial News Source Prefer Advisor/Broker Use - Among those who have a financial advisor/broker at a full-service or independent firm -
19
Dow Jones
Yahoo! Finance
The Street.com
Google Finance
Bloomberg
Reuters
Figure 7: Financial News Source Investors Prefer Adviser/Broker Use
Key InsightWhen asked which source they would choose if they were restricted to just one for financial news nearly a third of the randomly selected participants in the 2010 Canadian Affluent Investor Study (30%) chose The Globe & Mail as their source for financial news, with “Any Dow Jones Brand” following (19%). Other competing financial news sources trailed, with Yahoo! Finance at 7%, Bloomberg News at 6%, Financial Times at 5%, and all others at less than 5% (figure 6).
More importantly, investors clearly expect their advisers and wealth managers to use the news sources they themselves rate highly. When asked which financial news source their advisers turned to most often, investors believed Dow Jones was at the top of the list (48%), 33 percentage points ahead of second-place Bloomberg News (15%).
When asked to select the financial news service they would prefer their advisers/wealth managers to use when advising them on investment decisions, affluent investors picked Dow Jones first (47%) among the six choices, ahead of second-place Bloomberg News (29%) by 18 percentage points (figure 7).
The message is unambiguous: the most reliable news, information and analysis comes from Dow Jones.
Measurable ValueRespondents rated eight financial news sources they knew well on a five-point scale from Poor to Excellent. The Wall Street Journal was rated Excellent/Very Good by 58%, while next-best MarketWatch was rated Excellent/Very Good by 51% (figure 8).
By every measure of value, including credibility, accuracy, trustworthiness and usefulness, investors rated The Wall Street Journal more highly than four other competing sources devoted to financial news, including Bloomberg News, Yahoo! Finance, Reuters and Google Finance. For overall excellence, more than half of respondents rated The Wall Street Journal and MarketWatch Excellent and Very Good overall, ahead of Bloomberg News, Yahoo! Finance, Reuters and Google Finance.
Google Finance (n=97)
Q14A. How would you rate each of the following financial news sources overall? Base: Familiar with each financial news source
More than half give The Wall Street Journal and MarketWatch an “Excellent” or “Very Good”
overall rating.
Overall Rating for Financial News Sources - Among those who are somewhat, very or extremely familiar with each source -
16
Excellent
Very Good
Fair
Poor
Good
1%
“Excellent/Very Good”: 58% 48% 51% 47% 45% 40% 37% 35%
The Wall Street Journal (n=167)
Market-Watch (n=75)
Barron’s (n=74)
Dow Jones (n=170) Reuters
(n=143)
Bloomberg-News
(n=120)
Yahoo! Finance (n=97)
11% 16%
8% 18% 14%
18% 19% 26%
31% 33% 43%
35% 41% 42% 43%
38%
40% 40%
36% 39%
36% 29% 28%
28%
19% 11%
13%
8% 9%
11% 9% 7%
1% 1%
Figure 8: Overall Rating for Financial News SourcesAmong those who are somewhat, very or extremely familiar with each source.
Figure 6: Financial News Source of Choice
Q15A. If you could use only one of these financial news sources, which one would you choose? Base: Total who provided an answer (n=202) Dow Jones brand comprised of The Wall Street Journal, Dow Jones, MarketWatch, Barron’s, Smart Money and Big Charts.
If they could only use one news source for financial news, nearly one-third of affluent
investors would choose Globe & Mail and a fifth would choose a Dow Jones Brand.
Financial News Source of Choice Total
14
ROB-TV
Dow Jones
Google Finance
National Post
Yahoo! Finance
Any Dow Jones Brand
Bloomberg News
Financial Times
CNBC
TMX Money
Morningstar
Wall Street Journal
Globe & Mail
Sources with < 2%:
Market Watch
CNN Money
Toronto Star
Reuters
Big Charts
Forbes
Fox Business News
Canadian Affluent Investor Report
25
Q23. Approximately how many times in the past 6 months has your financial advisor/broker at [FIRM] contacted you (either in person, by phone, or e-mail). Please do not include the times they have sent you financial statements.
Base: Use full-service or independent firm and have an advisor (n=124)
Number of Times Contacted by Financial Advisor/Broker in Past Six Months - Among those who have an advisor/broker at a full-service or independent firm -
Almost all have been contacted by their financial advisor/broker in the past six months,
most often between one and four times.
1-4 times
None
5-9 times
10 times or more
Figure 10: Number of Times Contacted by Financial Adviser/Broker in Past Six MonthsAmong those who have an adviser/broker at a full service or independent firm
Page 6
Credibility of News Sources? When asked to rate the credibility of news sources, the survey revealed that The Wall Street Journal was rated more highly than competitors, with Excellent / Very Good ratings of 58%. The next two rated most credible were Bloomberg (56%) and Dow Jones (52%) (figure 9).
How Can Advisers Improve Their Client Relationships?Overall, the 2010 Canadian Affluent Investor Study offers advisers and wealth managers great news and insights that can help them improve client relationships. More than six in 10 respondents (61%) indicated that they were either Extremely Satisfied or Very Satisfied with their adviser or wealth manager (17% and 44%, respectively). And more respondents cited advisers/wealth managers as the source they turned to for investment advice than any other single source (61%).
Although advisers should be pleased with these numbers, they are no cause for complacency. There are still areas that could be better served. The majority of respondents (66%) are 50 or older, but 44% of all respondents have not developed a retirement plan with their adviser. Fully 19% of respondents have had no contact at all with an adviser in the past six months. And one-third of investors (33%) reported they were only Somewhat Satisfied with their adviser. Because the most satisfied clients tend to entrust advisers/wealth managers with more assets, advisers who would like to increase their book of assets under management need strategies to help them shift more clients from Somewhat Satisfied to Very Satisfied.
Adviser Contact StrategiesThe 2010 Canadian Affluent Investor Study suggests greater opportunities for advisers and wealth managers to increase both the volume and value of their client contacts.
When asked how frequently their advisers/wealth managers contacted them, more than half of respondents (56%) reported 1-4 contacts in the last six months (figure 10). Only 14% reported 10 or more contacts in the given six-month period. The most prevalent mode of contact is by telephone, at 76%, with email the second-most popular method at 59%.
When asked for their preferred topics of discussion, respondents cited retirement planning, tax strategies, diversifying investments, estate planning and alternative investments, in that order, as the subjects of greatest interest (figure 11).
Dow Jones (n=92)
43% 39% 39% 40%
29% 29%
The Wall Street
Journal (n=96)
58% 56% 52%
30%
44%
25%
Bloomberg News (n=59)
57%
43% 44%
31% 39%
25%
Q14B. How would you rate the following financial news source on these dimensions? Base: Familiar with each financial news source
The Wall Street Journal enjoys better ratings than all other financial news sources on across all measures.
Attribute Ratings for Financial News Sources
- Among those who are somewhat, very or extremely familiar with each source -
0
Trustworthiness
Credibility
Accuracy
Usefulness
Excellent/Very Good
57% 49%
46%
33% 41%
24%
Yahoo! Finance (n=55)
Reuters (n=67)
Google Finance (n=46)
Figure 9: Attribute Ratings for Financial News SourcesAmong those who are somewhat, very or extremely familiar with each source.
Q29. Does your financial advisor/broker currently advise you on any of the following topics? Select all that apply. Q30. Which of the following topics would you like your financial advisor/broker to discuss with or advise you on? Select all that apply. Base: Use full-service or independent firm and have an advisor (n=126)
They are most likely to get or be interested in getting advice from their advisor/broker on
retirement planning, tax strategies and diversifying investments.
Topics Advised On/Would Like To Be Advised On - Among those who have a financial adviser/broker at a full-service or independent firm -
22
13% 13%
Currently/interested in being advised:
70% 31% 64% 69% 46% 48% 19% 42% 16% 18% 10% 9%
Retirement Planning
Diversifying Investment
Tax Strategies
Estate Planning
Emerging Markets
Alternative Investments
Regulatory Changes
Education Planning
Charitable Giving
My Business/ Profession
Long-term Care
Elder Care
Interested Currently
Figure 11: Topics Advised On/Would Like To Be Advised OnAmong those who have a financial adviser/broker at a full service or independent firm
Canadian Affluent Investor Report
Page 7
27
Q32. Do you regularly receive a newsletter with news and insights from your financial advisor? Q34. How interested would you be in receiving a monthly or quarterly newsletter from your financial advisor at {FIRM) Base: Q32 - Use full-service or independent firm and have an advisor (n=119) Base: Q34 - Do not receive newsletter (n=46)
Interest in Receiving Newsletters - Among those who do not currently receive a newsletter -
Most of those investors who do not receive newsletters from their financial advisor are
somewhat interested in receiving them.
“Extremely/Very” interested: 22%
Regularly Receive Newsletter
Advisor/Broker Provided Newsletters - Among those who have an advisor/broker at a full-service or independent firm -
Extremely interested
Very interested
Not very interested
Not at all interested
Somewhat interested
Do not
receive
33%
Receive
67%
Figure 13: Adviser/Broker Provided NewslettersMost investors have an interest in receiving newsletters
Figure 14: Reasons for Financial Adviser/Broker ContactAmong those who have an adviser/broker at a full-service or independent firm
Sixty-seven percent of respondents said their advisers regularly send them newsletters, which more than three-quarters of those recipients said they read regularly. Of those who do not receive a newsletter, more than half expressed interest in getting one from their adviser (figures 12, 13).
Online TradingOnly a small portion of respondents said they invest through discount or online brokerage services. In fact, nearly three-quarters of affluent investors (81%) said they manage their investments through Full Service firms, while fewer than a quarter (22%) invest through Discount/Online firms. This underscores the important role of advisers in the decisions made by affluent investors.
By this measure, investors are clearly choosing the value of working with a trusted adviser who knows a client’s needs and can help make sense of the daily barrage of undigested market news and information.
Key InsightAdvisers and wealth managers have a lot to gain by increasing the number of contacts with clients. But to make these contacts meaningful—whether by newsletter, email, phone or in person—communications should be initiated on subjects that clients want to discuss most.
Affluent investors are more likely to contact their adviser in search of broader advice than when making specific trades (figure 14).
About Dow Jones Solutions For Financial Services Firms Dow Jones provides actionable content and access for financial services firms that want to ensure their advisers, wealth managers, online traders, private bankers and investors have the most trusted, credible and timely news and insight to drive business growth. We help our customers gain greater confidence and increase productivity to sustain a competitive advantage.
To learn more about Dow Jones’s Wealth Management Solutions, visit dj.com/wealthmanagement
26
Q32. Do you regularly receive a newsletter with news and insights from your financial adviser? Q33. How often do you read the newsletter? Base: Q32 - Use full-service or independent firm and have an advisor (n=119), Q33 – Use full-service or independent firm and receive newsletter (n=80)
Many receive newsletters from their adviser/broker and most read them ‘usually’ or ‘always’.
Do not
receive
33%
Receive
67%
Regularly Receive Newsletter
Always
Usually
Frequency of Reading Newsletter
- Among those receiving newsletter from adviser/broker -
Occasionally
Never
Adviser/Broker Provided Newsletters - Among those who have an adviser/broker at a full-service or independent firm -
Figure 12: Adviser/Broker Provided NewslettersMost investors read the newsletters they receive from their adviser/broker
Canadian Affluent Investor Report
Resources You Can UseDow Jones provides these solutions to help enhance your value to high-net-worth clients.
Connect with us. Get insight into major wealth management issues: Blog: financialadviserblog.dowjones.com
Twitter: @dowjonesadviser
Facebook: www.facebook.com/dowjonesadviser
Objective Solution
Strengthen client relationships and build business. Stay ahead of the latest news and information that moves the markets and affects clients’ investments and interests.
Dow Jones News Service (North America)Dow Jones Global Equities News (Europe, Asia/Pacific, Africa and South America)Award-winning real-time corporate, economic, market, financial and political news, reported from nearly 90 bureaus across the globe; includes up to 19,000 items each day. Includes Dow Jones NewsPlus, an easy-to-navigate Web-based companion service offering convenient access to Dow Jones news.
Improve, retain and grow business by enhancing communication with clients to gain a competitive advantage.
Dow Jones Adviser Built for the way advisers run their practice, Dow Jones’s journalistic resources and the content of Dow Jones Newswires, SmartMoney, The Wall Street Journal and Barron’s are combined and easily integrated within advisers’ workflow to provide talking points, actionable data, deep analysis and sophisticated tools.
Ensure your trade strategies take advantage of what’s affecting currency trading points, minute by minute.
Dow Jones FX Select Specialist teams of reporters, editors and translators from Hong Kong to London to New York generate news suited to local markets by both writing original news in their language and by selecting and publishing relevant news from English editions of Dow Jones Newswires.
Streamline delivery of market intelligence by customizing the most flexible tools for your platforms and get fast, easy access to news on breaking events.
Total Access at Dow JonesAn integration platform with the capability to deliver news and information in varied formats, from Widgets and Web Services (APIs) to low-latency newsfeeds and tablets. Learn more at dj.com/products/widgets_web_services