8/3/2019 Dominic Carolan Revised
1/145
Kjntzwjkjas `l shj swnatljw lzadsf`a `l
n d`kgzts`w jxfs a`}}bj
C`kfafd Dnw`bna
Tzgkfssjc fa s`snb lzblfbbkjas `l shj cjewjj `l Kntsjw `l
Jaefajjwfae Tdfjadj
Mnaznwv >3" 7996
Tzyjw|ft`w=
Cw! K! Gwjnw
Shj Zaf|jwtfsv `l Kjbg`zwaj
Cjynwskjas `l Kjdhnafdnb Jaefajjwfae
8/3/2019 Dominic Carolan Revised
2/145
Ngtswnds
Shj fasjwndsf`a `l d`a|jdsjc jasw`yv cftszwgnadjt ufsh dh`ojc a`}}bjt
hnt gjja th`ua s` gj na fky`wsnas d`aswfgzs`w s` mjs jaefaj a`ftj nac shjw+
k`nd`ztsfd fatsngfbfsv fa ent szwgfaj d`kgzts`wt! Fa `wcjw s` gj ngbj s`
wjczdj a`ftj nac d`asw`b `w jbfkfansj fatsngfbfsv fa ywjkfxjc d`kgzts`wt" n
gjssjw zacjwtsnacfae `l shj yhvtfdnb kjdhnaftkt fa|`b|jc fa shjwk`nd`ztsfd
fatsngfbfsv ft wj~zfwjc! Na fky`wsnas ynws `l shj shjwk`nd`ztsfd tsngfbfsv
yw`gbjk ft shj lwj~zjadv wjty`atj `l shj d`kgzts`w jxfs a`}}bj! Shj yw`+
|ftf`a `l jxyjwfkjasnb j|fcjadj cjk`atswnsfae shj jjds `l n dh`ojc c`ua+
tswjnk g`zacnwv d`acfsf`a hnt gjja bfkfsjc gv shj cfffldzbsfjt ntt`dfnsjc
ufsh knofae cvankfd kjntzwjkjast fa n h`s szwgzbjas ent `u! Shft shjtft
ywjtjast jxyjwfkjasnb wjtzbst s` nbb`u d`kynwft`a ufsh shj jtsngbfthjc bfajnw
shj`wv `l dh`ojc a`}}bj cvankfdt! Na jxyjwfkjasnb ywjkfxjc d`kgzts`w s+
sjc ufsh lnts wjty`atj shjwk`d`zybjt nac ywjttzwj swnatczdjwt unt ztjc l`w
shj jxyjwfkjast! Sjtst ujwj dnwwfjc `zs ufsh g`sh na `yja nac dh`ojc jxfs
a`}}bj fa `wcjw s` cjsjwkfaj shj a`}}bjt wjty`atj s` ywjttzwj nac jasw`yv
cftszwgnadjt ztfae n k`cfjc su` kfdw`yh`aj kjsh`c! Wjtzbst l`w g`sh shj
`yja nac dh`ojc jxfs wjty`atj s` ywjttzwj cftszwgnadjt th`ujc e``c newjj+
kjas ufsh shj shj`wv! Shj nanbvtft `l shj wjtzbst l`w shj `yja nac dh`ojc
jxfs wjty`atj s` jasw`yv cftszwgnadjt wj|jnbjc shj bfkfsnsf`at `l shj kjsh`c!
Tyjdswnb nanbvtft sjdhaf~zjt ujwj tzddjttlzbbv nyybfjc s` shj `yja jxfs cnsns` cjk`atswnsj shj jxftsjadj `l swn|jbfae jasw`yv un|jt k`|fae c`uatswjnk
ns shj d`a|jdsf|j |jb`dfsv `l shj `u! H`uj|jw" shj lwj~zjadv wnaej fa uhfdh
shjtj sjkyjwnszwj cftszwgnadjt ujwj l`zac s` gj tynsfnbbv d`wwjbnsjc unt bfk+
fsjc s` lwj~zjadfjt gjb`u shj u`wofae wnaej `l shj k`cfjc su` kfdw`yh`aj
kjsh`c!
8/3/2019 Dominic Carolan Revised
3/145
Cjdbnwnsf`a
Shft ft s` djwsflv shns shj shjtft ft bjtt shna 49"999 u`wct fa bjaesh" jxdbztf|j
`l u`wct fa sngbjt" ezwjt" gfgbf`ewnyhfjt nac nyyjacfdjt!
>
8/3/2019 Dominic Carolan Revised
4/145
Ndoa`ubjcekjast
F u`zbc bfoj s` shnao kv tzyjw|ft`w" Cw Kfdhnjb Gwjnw l`w hft hjby nac
jad`zwnejkjas! F ufbb nbt` a`sj hjwj kv ewnsfszcj s` nbb sh`tj uh` hjbyjc fa
n |nwfjsv `l unvt= S`av Ofsdhjajw" l`w hft tzyy`ws `l shj wjtjnwdh? C`a" l`w
knofae shj gfst nac yfjdjt nt wj~zfwjc? Cw Yjsjw Hfjbc" Nthbjv Ufjtj nac
Cjaaft l`w shjfw hjby ufsh shj jxyjwfkjast? Ancjw Onwfkf" l`w hft ofac thnwfae
`l shj bng sjts djbb? Ufbb" l`w hft hjby ufsh shj shj`wv nac shj nanbvtft? Cnc nac
M`j" l`w yw``l wjncfae shj cwnls? nac Tzmnsn" l`w hjw hjby nac jad`zwnejkjas!
7
8/3/2019 Dominic Carolan Revised
5/145
D`asjast
> Fasw`czdsf`a >:
>!> Gndoew`zac ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! >:
>!7 Nfkt `l shft shjtft ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! >5
>!4 Dhnysjw tzkknwv ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! >6
7 Bfsjwnszwj Wj|fju 79
7!> Shjwk`nd`ztsfd fatsngfbfsv ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! 79
7!7 Bjna ywjkfxjc d`kgzts`wt ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! 77
7!4 Ywj|f`zt jxyjwfkjasnb u`wo `a a`}}bjt ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! 73
7!3 Nd`ztsfd wjjdsf`a d`jffldfjast ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! 7 Wjjdsf`a lw`k na `yja jac ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! 78
7!3!7 Fadbzcfae shj jjdst `l wncfnsf`a lw`k na `yja jac ! ! 78
7!3!4 Wjjdsf`a lw`k n db`tjc jac ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! 49
7!: Wjjdsf`a lw`k n dh`ojc a`}}bj ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! 49
7!< Jxyjwfkjasnb cjsjwkfansf`a l wjjdsf`a d`jffldfjast ! ! ! ! ! ! 44
7! Shj su` kfdw`yh`aj kjsh`c l Tjvgjws nac W`tt _>[ ! 44
7!
7!
7!5 Tzkknwv `l shj bfsjwnszwj ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! 39
4 Jxyjwfkjasnb kjsh`c 37
4!> Cjtdwfysf`a `l shj jxyjwfkjasnb wfe ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! 37
4
8/3/2019 Dominic Carolan Revised
6/145
4!>!> Nfw nac lzjb ywjynwnsf`a ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! 37
4!>!7 Lbnkj h`bcjw ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! 34
4!>!4 U`wofae tjdsf`a ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! 33
4!7 Shjwk`d`zybjt ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! 3:
4!7!> Nttjkgbv `l shj shjwk`d`zybjt ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! 3:
4!7!7 Shjwk`d`zybj tfeanb d`acfsf`afae ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! 35
4!7!4 Shjwk`d`zybj d`bc d`kyjatnsf a ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! 36
4!7!3 Shjwk`d`zybj sfkj d`atsnas jtsfknsf a ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! 36
4!7!: Jtsfknsfae shj sfkj d`atsnas ztfae gntfd shj`wv ! ! ! ! :9
4!7!< Jtsfknsfae shj shjwk`d`zybj sfkj d`atsnas ztfae Tswnhbjt
_7[ kjsh`c ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! :7
4!7!5 Jtsfknsfae shj shjwk`d`zybj sfkj d`atsnas ztfae Snenunt
_4[ kjsh`c ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! :3
4!7!8 D`kynwfae Tswnhbjt _7[ nac Snenunt _4[ kjsh`ct `a
tfkzbnsjc cnsn ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ::
4!7!6 D`kynwfae Tswnhbjt _7[ nac Snenunt _4[ kjsh`ct `aGzatja gzwajw sjts cnsn ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! :6
4!7!>9 D`kynwfae Tswnhbjt _7[ nac Snenunt _4[ kjsh`ct `a
shj d`kgzts`w wfe cnsn ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! > D`kyjatnsf`a `l shjwk`d`zybj kjntzwjkjast ! ! ! ! !
8/3/2019 Dominic Carolan Revised
7/145
3!> J|fcjadj `l swn|jbfae jasw`yv cftszwgnadjt ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! 56
3!7 Zafl wkfsv `l shj sjkyjwnszwj cftszwgnadjt ns shj jxfs ! ! ! ! 86
3!4 Wjtzbst l`w shj su` kfdw`yh`aj `aj shjwk`d`zybj kjsh`c ! ! 68
3!4!> Wjty`atj `l shj `yja jxfs s` ywjttzwj nac jasw yv cft+
szwgnadjt ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! 68
3!4!7 Wjty`atj `l n dh`ojc jxfs s` n ywjttzwj cftszwgnadj ! ! 66
3!4!4 Wjty`atj `l shj dh`ojc jxfs s` na jasw`yv cftszwgnadj >99
3!4!3 D`hjwjadj nanbvtft `l shj cnsn ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! >9:
3!3 Dhnysjw tzkknwv ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! >95
: D`adbztf`at >96
:!> Wjd`kkjacnsf at l w lzwshjw U`wo ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! >>>
N Nccfsf`anb Cnsn nac Wjtzbst >79
N!> D`kkfttf`afae cnsn ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! >79
N!7 Kjntzwjc kjna cnsn ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! >74
G KNSBNG nac TFKZBFAO bjt >75
G!> Fky`ws ywjttzwj nac shjwk`d`zybj cnsn ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! >75
G!7 Fky`ws Kjna cnsn ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! >78
G!4 Fky`ws W+svyj shjwk`d`zybj b `ozy sngbj ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! >49
G!3 Dnbdzbnsj |nwfngbjt ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! >47
G!: D`kyzsj Tyjdswn ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! >43
G!< Nyybv su` kfdw`yh`aj kjsh`c ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! >48
G!5 A`wknbf}jc dw`tt+d wwjbnsf a ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! >39
G!8 Yb`ssfae shj tyjdsw`ewnk ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! >3>
G!6 Tswnhbj kjsh`c ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! >37
G!>9 Shjwk`d`zybj d`kyjatnsf`a ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! >37
G!>> Shjwk`d`zybj tfkzbnsf`a ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! >34
G!>7 Su` kfdw`yh`aj kjsh`c tfkzbnsf`a ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! >34
:
8/3/2019 Dominic Carolan Revised
8/145
Bfts `l Lfezwjt
7!> Lbnkkngfbfsv bfkfst `l shj jxyjwfkjasnb d`kgzts w cjtfeajc
gv Hfjbc _3[ ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! 73
7!7 Shj`wjsfdnb y`ujw wjjdsf`a d`jffldfjas l`w na `yja jac _:[ ! ! 76
7!4 Su` kfdw`yh`aj kjsh`c l w cjsjwkfafae na zaoa`ua fkyjcnadj
lw`k Tjvgjws nac W`tt _>[ ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! 43
7!3 Su` kfdw yh`aj nac `aj shjwk`d`zybj kjsh`c l`w cjsjwkfa+
fae na zaoa`ua fkyjcnadj lw`k Hfjbc _3[ ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! 4 nac 7 kt ufsh fad`hjwjas a`ftj (TA
wnsf`;7& ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! :5
4!>9 Wf (/&" Ww (& nac 7 (!& |jwtzt lwj~zjadv l`w n tfkzbnsf`a
ufsh sfkj d`atsnast > nac >!7: kt ufsh fad`hjwjas a`ftj (TA
wnsf`;7& ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! :5
4!>> Sfkj d`atsnas l`w tfkzbnsf`a SD>t (/& nac SD7t (& |jwtzt
knxfkzk lwj~zjadv ztjc (TA wnsf`;>9999& ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! :8
4!>7 Jxyjwfkjasnb tjszy ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! 4 SD> nac SD7 tfeanb ns tsnws `l cnsn wjd`wc ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! 3 Tyjdswnb cjatfsv l`w SD> (& nac SD7 (!& nac a`ftj ``w (Gza+
tja sjts : Tyjdswnb cjatfsv l`w SD> (& nac SD7 (!& nac a`ftj ``w (Gza+
tja sjts >7& ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !
4!>< Tyjdswnb cjatfsv l`w SD>N (& nac SD7N (!& nac a`ftj ``w
(Gzatja sjts 74& ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! 5 Wf (/&" Ww (& nac
7 (!& |jwtzt lwj~zjadv l`w SD> (Gzatja
sjts (Gzatja
sjts 74& ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !
8/3/2019 Dominic Carolan Revised
10/145
4!73 Dnbdzbnsjc sfkj d`atsnas SD> (/& nac SD7 (& |jwtzt knxf+
kzk lwj~zjadv ztjc (Gzatja sjts >7& ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! Tyjdsw`ewnk `l ywjttzwj swnatczdjw `zsyzs czwfae shj tyjno+
fae sjts ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! 57
4!47 Cnsn nd~zftfsf a tvtsjk lwj~zjadv wjty`atj l`w shj tnkj tf+azt`fcnb fayzs tfeanb ufsh nbb dhnaajbt wjljwjadjc s` dhnaajb
9 ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! 53
4!44 D`wwjdsjc cnsn nd~zftfsf`a tvtsjk lwj~zjadv wjty`atj l`w shj
tnkj tfazt`fcnb fayzs tfeanb ufsh nbb dhnaajbt wjljwjadjc s`
dhnaajb 9 ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! 5:
4!43 Tyjdswn `l K> l`w shj `yja nac dh`ojc jxfs sjtst d`kynwjc s`
shj a`ftj ``w ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! 5 B`dnsf`at `l shjwk`d`zybjt nac ywjttzwj swnatczdjwt ! ! ! ! ! 89
3!7 Ywjttzwj tyjdswn (`yja jxfs& l`w K ; 9!943" ; >!9! Shj
b`dnsf a `l K> nac K7 ft th`ua fa Lfezwj 3!> ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! 8>
3!4 Ywjttzwj tyjdswn (dh`ojc jxfs& l`w K ; 9!>" ; >!9! Shj
b`dnsf a `l K> nac K7 ft th`ua fa Lfezwj 3!> ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! 8>
3!3 Sjkyjwnszwj tyjdswn d`kynwjc s` shj jtsfknsjc ftjasw`yfd
sjkyjwnszwj tyjdswn jtsfknsjc lw`k ywjttzwj tfeanb (`yja jxfs&!
Shj b`dnsf`a `l shj shjwk`d`zybjt nac ywjttzwj swnatczdjwt ft
th`ua fa Lfezwj 3!> ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! 87
3!: Sjkyjwnszwj tyjdswn d`kynwjc s` shj jtsfknsjc ftjasw`yfd
sjkyjwnszwj tyjdswn jtsfknsjc lw`k ywjttzwj tfeanb (dh`ojc
jxfs&! Shj b`dnsf`a `l shj shjwk`d`zybjt nac ywjttzwj swnat+
czdjwt ft th`ua fa Lfezwj 3!> ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! 84
3!< Nkybfszcj nac yhntj wjbnsf`athfy `lS s` >
Y (`yja jxfs& `l
shj c`uatswjnk kjntzwjkjas tsnsf a th`ua fa Lfezwj 3!> ! ! ! 83
3!5 Nkybfszcj nac yhntj wjbnsf`athfy `lS s`
>
Y (dh`ojc jxfs&`l shj c`uatswjnk kjntzwjkjas tsnsf a th`ua fa Lfezwj 3!> ! 8:
3!8 Dw`tt+d`wwjbnsf a l c`uatswjnk ywjttzwj swnatczdjw (K>& ufsh
c`uatswjnk shjwk`d`zybj (SD3& (`yja jxfs& ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! 8& ufsh
c`uatswjnk shjwk`d`zybj (SD3& (dh`ojc jxfs& ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! 89 Dw`tt+d`wwjbnsf a `l shj zytswjnk (SD7& nac c`uatswjnk (SD4&
shjwk`d`zybj tfeanbt l`w shj `yja nac dh`ojc jxfs sjtst ! ! ! ! 88
3!>> Nkybfszcj nac yhntj `l SD7 wjbnsf|j s SD3 (`yja jxfs& ! ! ! 86
3!>7 Nkybfszcj nac yhntj l SD7 wjbnsf|j s SD3 (dh`ojc jxfs& ! ! 69
3!>4 Dw`tt+d`wwjbnsf`a `l shjwk`d`zybjt SD3 nac SD: (`yja jxfs& ! 6>
3!>3 Dw`tt+d`wwjbnsf a `l shjwk`d`zybjt SD3 nac SD: (dh`ojc jxfs& 6>
3!>: Dw`tt+d`wwjbnsf`a `l shjwk`d`zybjt SD3 nac SD> (`yja jxfs& ! 67
3!>< Dw`tt+d`wwjbnsf a `l shjwk`d`zybjt SD3 nac SD> (dh`ojc jxfs& 67
6
8/3/2019 Dominic Carolan Revised
12/145
3!>5 Dw`tt+d`wwjbnsf`a `l shjwk`d`zybjt SD3 nac SD4 (`yja jxfs& ! 64
3!>8 Dw`tt+d`wwjbnsf a `l shjwk`d`zybjt SD3 nac SD4 (dh`ojc jxfs& 64
3!>6 Nkybfszcj nac yhntj `l SD: wjbnsf|j s SD3 (`yja jxfs& ! ! ! 6:
3!79 Nkybfszcj nac yhntj l SD: wjbnsf|j s SD3 (dh`ojc jxfs& ! ! 6:
3!7> Nkybfszcj nac yhntj `l SD> wjbnsf|j s SD3 (`yja jxfs& ! ! ! 6 wjbnsf|j s SD3 (dh`ojc jxfs& ! ! 6" SD4" SD3& ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! >99
3!75 Jxyjwfkjasnb (!& dh`ojc jxfs wjty`atj s` n ywjttzwj cftszw+
gnadj d`kynwjc s` shj`wv (+& ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! >9>
3!78 Jxyjwfkjasnb dh`ojc jxfs wjty`atj s` na jasw`yv cftszwgnadj
(SD4 `abv& d`kynwjc s` shj`wv (+& ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! >973!76 Jxyjwfkjasnb dh`ojc jxfs wjty`atj s` na jasw`yv cftszwgnadj
(SD3 `abv& d`kynwjc s` shj`wv (+& ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! >97
3!49 Jxyjwfkjasnb dh`ojc jxfs wjty`atj s` na jasw`yv cftszwgnadj
(SD>" SD4" SD3& d`kynwjc s` shj`wv (+& ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! >94
3!4> Jxyjwfkjasnb dh`ojc jxfs wjty`atj s` na jasw`yv cftszwgnadj
(SD9" SD>" SD4" SD3" SD:& d`kynwjc s shj`wv (+& ! ! ! ! ! >94
3!47 @wcfanwv d`hjwjadj lzadsf`at l`w shj `yja jxfs ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! >9995
N!> W+svyj Shjwk`d`zybj |`bsnej |jwtzt sjkyjwnszwj ! ! ! ! ! ! ! >74
N!7 Nkybfjc zytswjnk (SD7& nac c`uatswjnk (SD4& shjwk`+
d`zybj tfeanbt (`yja jxfs& ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! >7:
>9
8/3/2019 Dominic Carolan Revised
13/145
N!4 Nkybfjc zytswjnk (SD7& nac c`uatswjnk (SD4& shjwk`+
d`zybj tfeanbt (dh`ojc jxfs& ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! >7 Shjwk`d`zybj tfkzbnsf a ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! >34
G!7 Su` kfdw`yh`aj kjsh`c tfkzbnsf`a ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! >34
>>
8/3/2019 Dominic Carolan Revised
14/145
Bfts `l Sngbjt
N!> Tdnbj lnds`wt l`w kjna kjntzwjkjast ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! >7>
N!7 ]jw dhjdo l`w kjna kjntzwjkjast ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! >7>
N!4 Tyna dhjdo l w kjna kjntzwjkjast ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! >77
N!3 @yja jxfs sjts kjna |nbzjt ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! >73
N!: @yja jxfs kjna sjkyjwnszwjt (79 t `l cnsn& ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! >73
N!< Dh`ojc jxfs kjna sjkyjwnszwjt (79 t `l cnsn& ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! >73
>7
8/3/2019 Dominic Carolan Revised
15/145
Bfts `l Tvkg`btn Yfyj wncfzt
N C`uatswjnk swn|jbfae ywjttzwj un|j nkybfszcj
G Zytswjnk swn|jbfae ywjttzwj un|j nkybfszcj
Gj Lwj~zjadv gnacufcsh
Gw Hnbl y`ujw y`fas wjt`anas yjno gnacufcsh
d Tyjjc `l t`zacdy Tyjdfd hjns ns d`atsnas ywjttzwj
D Dnyndfsnadj
C Cfnkjsjw
l Lwj~zjadv
h D`a|jdsf|j hjns swnatljw d`jffldfjas
H Lwj~zjadv wjty`atj lzadsf`a
m Fknefanwv azkgjw
o Un|j azkgjw
o Shjwknb d`aczdsf|fsv
K Kntt
A z Azttjbs azkgjw
y Ywjttzwj
Y w Ywnacsb azkgjw
^ ^znbfsv lnds`w
W Ent d`atsnas
W Wjtftsnadj
Wxv Dw`tt+d`wwjbnsf`a
Wxv A`wknbf}jc dw`tt+d`wwjbnsf`a
Wj Wjva`bct azkgjw
>4
8/3/2019 Dominic Carolan Revised
16/145
Bfts `l tvkg`bt d`asfazjc!!!
t Jasw`yv
T Jasw`yv un|j nkybfszcj
T Yfyj dw`tt+tjdsf`anb nwjn
Txv Dw`tt+tyjdswnb cjatfsv
K Kndh azkgjw
s Sfkj
S Sjkyjwnszwj
z \jb`dfsv
Z \`bzkj |jb`dfsv
x Cftsnadj
] Nd`ztsfd fkyjcnadj
Ewjjo Bjssjwt
Wnsf` `l tyjdfd hjnst
7
xv D`hjwjadj lzadsf`a Cjatfsv
Jasw`yv un|j nkybfszcj
Sfkj d`atsnas
Wncfna lwj~zjadv
Tzgtdwfyst nac Tzyjwtdwfyst
> Zytswjnk l a`}}bj
7 C`uatswjnk l a`}}bj
e Ent
f Fadfcjas
w Wjjdsjc
t Jasw`yv
D`kybjx d`amzensj
>3
8/3/2019 Dominic Carolan Revised
17/145
Dhnysjw >
Fasw`czdsf`a
>!> Gndoew`zac
Fa knav hjns jaefajt nac yw`yzbtf`a cj|fdjt" hjns ft nccjc s` n d`asfaz`zt
`u `l d`kywjttjc ent cfwjdsbv gv n nkj fa n d`kgzts w! Shft yw`djtt `l
hjns nccfsf`a knv `ddzw ns nyyw`xfknsjbv d`atsnas ywjttzwj! Shj hjnsjc
entjt dna shja gj jxynacjc shw`zeh n szwgfaj s` `gsnfa ztjlzb kjdhnafdnb
u`wo `w shw`zeh n a`}}bj s` `gsnfa shwzts! Jxnkybjt `l tzdh d`asfaz`zt `u
shjwk`cvankfd cj|fdjt ssfae shft cjafsf`a fadbzcj mjs jaefajt" szwg`lna
jaefajt" ent szwgfajt" nlsjwgzwajwt" wnk mjst nac w`dojs jaefajt!
Nbb `l shjtj d`asfaz`zt `u cj|fdjt dna gj tztdjysfgbj s` t`+dnbbjc shjw+
k`nd`ztsfd fatsngfbfsv nac zaunasjc a`ftj wjtzbsfae lw`k shj fasjwndsf`a `l
zatsjncv hjns nccfsf`a nac ywjttzwj `tdfbbnsf`at fa shj d`kgzts`w! Lzwshjw+
k`wj" `lsja shjtj cj|fdjt `yjwnsj tzdh shns shj `u ft dh`ojc c`uatswjnk
`l shj d`kgzts`w! Shns ft" shj `u ft nddjbjwnsjc s` t`afd |jb`dfsv ns n y`fas
`l kfafkzk `u nwjn!
Shft shjtft nfkt s` cjsjwkfaj shj cvankfd wjty`atj `l tzdh n d`kgzts`w
jxfs s` fadfcjas ywjttzwj cftszwgnadjt nac d`a|jdsjc h`s ty`st fa shj `u!
Ynwsfdzbnw nssjasf`a ft ynfc s` shj fky`wsnadj `l shjtj d`a|jdsjc h`s ty`st"
>:
8/3/2019 Dominic Carolan Revised
18/145
uhfdh knv nbt` gj d`atfcjwjc nt jasw`yv un|jt ejajwnsfae t`zac fatfcj shj
d`kgzts`w nt shjv nwj nddjbjwnsjc shw`zeh shj ywjttzwj ewncfjas ns shj dh`ojc
jxfs!
Knwgbj nac Dnacjbt _6[ bfajnw shj`wv l`w shj wjty`atj `l shj jxfs a`}}bjt
ft ufcjbv dfsjc fa shj bfsjwnszwj nac ztjc nt n c`uatswjnk g`zacnwv d`acfsf`a
l`w azkjwfdnb k`cjbt! H`uj|jw" jxyjwfkjasnb cnsn tzyy`wsfae shj shj`wv ft
bfkfsjc _3[! Lzwshjwk wj" shj ndsznb fky`wsnadj `l d`a|jdsjc jasw`yv cftszw+
gnadjt s` shjwk`nd`ztsfd fatsngfbfsv nac shj ejajwnsf`a `l a`ftj ft dzwwjasbv
na nwjn `l d`asjasf`a _>9[!
Shj knfa cfffldzbsfjt fa snofae cvankfd kjntzwjkjast fa n d`kgzts`w
ufsh n dh`ojc jxfs nwj n wjtzbs `l n azkgjw `l d`kybfdnsfae lnds`wt tzdh nt
shj bfkfsjc |fjufae nddjtt nac shj jbj|nsjc ywjttzwj! Shj wjbnsf|j cfffldzbsv
`l shjtj jxyjwfkjast knv jxybnfa shj ngtjadj `l jxyjwfkjasnb cnsn fa shj
bfsjwnszwj!
Shj nyybfdnsf`a `l n lwj~zjadv wjty`atj kjsh`c s` cjsjwkfaj n dh`ojc
a`}}bjt wjty`atj s` jasw`yv cftszwgnadjt ft n a`|jb nyyw`ndh hn|fae wtsgjja nc`ysjc gv Hfjbc _3[! Hfjbc ztjc su` kfdw`yh`ajt nac n tfaebj shjw+
k`d`zybj! Shj kjsh`c wjbfjt hjn|fbv `a shj ztj `l aj ufwj shjwk`d`zybjt
s` kjntzwj zdsznsf`at fa ent sjkyjwnszwj! Shj ngfbfsv `l shjwk`d`zybjt s`
cfwjdsbv kjntzwj shj ndsznb ent sjkyjwnszwj ft bfkfsjc s` lwj~zjadfjt gjb`u
shj dzs` lwj~zjadv `l shj shjwk`d`zybj! H`uj|jw" fl shj shjwk`d`zybj dzs+
` lwj~zjadv ft oa`ua shja shj lwj~zjadv wjty`atj knv gj d`kyjatnsjc l`w
s` ef|j shj swzj ent sjkyjwnszwj!
Shj ndsznb dzs` lwj~zjadv cjyjact a`s `abv `a shj tf}j `l shj shjwk`+
d`zybj gzs nbt` `a shj d`a|jdsf|j d`acfsf`at `l shj `u! Shjwjl`wj na fa+tfsz
sjdhaf~zj l`w sfkj d`atsnas kjntzwjkjas ft sh`zehs s` gj shj k`ts nyyw`+
ywfnsj! Shj shjwk`d`zybj dzs+ lwj~zjadv ufbb gj cjsjwkfajc ztfae su`
cfjwjas fa+tfsz sjdhaf~zjt! Shj wjtzbst ufbb gj d`kynwjc s` cnsn `gsnfajc
fa sjtst c`aj `zstfcj shj d`kgzts`w ztfae n Gzatja gzwajw nac dhjdojc ztfae
>
8/3/2019 Dominic Carolan Revised
19/145
gntfd jkyfwfdnb wjbnsf`at l`w shj hjns swnatljw d`jffldfjas!
>!7 Nfkt `l shft shjtft
>! S` cjsjwkfaj shj wjty`atj `l na `yja nac dh`ojc d`kgzts`w
jxfs s` ywjttzwj nac jasw`yv cftszwgnadjt ns cfjwjas nkybfszcjt
`l l`wdfae
Ztznbbv fa wjnb shjwk`cvankfd cj|fdjt tzdh nt ent szwgfajt shj `u ft dh`ojc
c`uatswjnk `l shj d`kgzts`w! Hfjbc nac Gwjnw _>>[ hn|j tszcfjc jxyjwfkja+
snbbv shj cvankfdt `l nd`ztsfdnbbv `yja nac dh`ojc jxfst! Shjv hn|j th`ua
shns shj cvankfdt `l n dh`ojc d`kgzts`w jxfs cfjw tfeafdnasbv lw`k na `yja
jxfs! H`uj|jw" shjfw wjtzbst l`w shj wjty`atj s` na jasw`yv cftszwgnadj c`
a`s newjj ufsh shj jtsngbfthjc bfajnw shj`wv l`w dh`ojc c`uatswjnk g`zacnwv
d`acfsf at! Shj jxyjwfkjast ufbb gj wjyjnsjc ztfae n cfjwjas nyyw`ndh fa na
nssjkys s` fkyw`|j `a shj nddzwndv `l shj sjdhaf~zj! Shj kjntzwjkjas `l
tknbbjw nkybfszcj l`wdfae u`zbc nbb`u sjtsfae `l shj hvy`shjtft shns tknbbjw
nkybfszcj l`wdfae ufbb wjtzbs fa n k`wj bfajnw wjty`atj! Ndhfj|fae cfjwjas
nkybfszcjt `l ywjttzwj nac jasw`yfd l`wdfae knv wj~zfwj k`cfdnsf`a `l shj
jxftsfae jxyjwfkjasnb d`kgzts`w nac fkyw`|jkjas fa shj tfeanb s` a`ftj wn+
sf` `l shj fatswzkjasnsf a! @adj `gsnfajc" shj jxyjwfkjas wjtzbst knv gj
d`kynwjc s` shj jtsngbfthjc bfajnw shj`wv!
7! S` fa|jtsfensj shj jxftsjadj `l swn|jbfae jasw`yv un|jt ns shj
d`kgzts`w jxfs
Shj fky`wsnadj `l swn|jbfae jasw`yv un|jt `a d`kgzts`w a`ftj nac shjwk`n+
d`ztsfd fatsngfbfsv ft na nwjn `l d`asjasf`a fa shj bfsjwnszwj! Shj jxftsjadj
`l jasw`yv un|jt swn|jbfae c`uatswjnk lw`k shj nkj fa shj jxyjwfkja+
snb d`kgzts w czwfae shjwk`nd`ztsfd wjt`anadj ft nttzkjc! H`uj|jw" shj
lwj~zjadv nac nkybfszcj `l shjtj un|jt nwj a`s oa`ua! Lzwshjwk wj" shj
>5
8/3/2019 Dominic Carolan Revised
20/145
jasw`yv un|jt nwj jxyjdsjc s` cfttfynsj shw`zeh shj jjdst `l d`a|jdsf`a
nac cfztf`a fa shj szwgzbjas `u nt shjv swn|jb c`uatswjnk _>9[! Shj
wnsj `l cfztf`a ft zaoa`ua nac shjwjl`wj shj tfeafdnadj `l shj wjknfafae
jasw`yv cftszwgnadjt ns shj jxfs a`}}bj ft zadjwsnfa! Shj kjntzwjkjas `l
shj d`a|jdsjc jasw`yv un|jt ft d`kybfdnsjc gv shj tfkzbsnaj`zt jxftsjadj
`l ftjasw`yfd sjkyjwnszwj zdsznsf`at wjtzbsfae lw`k bnwej nkybfszcj ywjt+
tzwj cftszwgnadjt fa shj d`kgzts`w! Shjwjl`wj shj d`a|jdsjc nac ftjasw`yfd
(nd`ztsfd& sjkyjwnszwj zdsznsf`at th`zbc gj tjynwnsjc fa shj nanbvtft t`
shns shjfw wjbnsf|j tfeafdnadj knv gj cjsjwkfajc!
4! S` fa|jtsfensj shj zafl`wkfsv `l shj sjkyjwnszwj yw`bj ns shj
d`kgzts`w jxfs
Ywj|f`zt u`wo gv Hfjbc _3[ nttzkjc nxftvkkjswfd" `aj cfkjatf`anb `u fa+
tfcj shj d`kgzts`w u wofae tjdsf a! N tfaebj shjwk`d`zybj unt ztjc s`
kjntzwj sjkyjwnszwj cftszwgnadjt ns shj d`kgzts`w jxfs! Ztfae n azkgjw `l
shjwk`d`zybjt nwwnaejc ns cfjwjas wncfnb b`dnsf`at nw`zac shj czds ufbb ef|jna facfdnsf`a `l shj nxftvkkjswv `l shj sjkyjwnszwj yw`bj! Lzwshjwk`wj"
ztfae shj fatsnasnaj`zt n|jwnej |nbzj `l shjtj shjwk`d`zybjt fa shj nanbvtft
`l shj l`wdjc wjty`atj `l shj d`kgzts`w jxfs knv fkyw`|j shj nddzwndv `l
shj sjdhaf~zj!
3! Nyybv jxftsfae sjdhaf~zjt l`w fa+tfsz shjwk`d`zybj sfkj d`a+
tsnas kjntzwjkjas
Shj nddzwnsj kjntzwjkjas `l shj nkybfszcj `l jasw`yv cftszwgnadjt ns hfehjw
lwj~zjadv wj~zfwjt d`kyjatnsf`a l`w shj jjdst `l shj shjwk`d`zybjt sfkj
bne! Kjntzwfae shj ndsznb zdsznsfae ent sjkyjwnszwj dna gj cfffldzbs ns
hfehjw lwj~zjadfjt gjdnztj `l shj bfkfsjc tyjjc `l wjty`atj `l shj shjwk`d`z+
ybj nac shj b`u tjatfsf|fsv `l shjwk`d`zybjt tzfsjc s` shj sjkyjwnszwj wnaej
jxyjdsjc fa n d`kgzts`w! Shj lwj~zjadv wjty`atj `l n shjwk`d`zybj ft n cfffl+
>8
8/3/2019 Dominic Carolan Revised
21/145
dzbs ynwnkjsjw s` jtsfknsj gntjc `a jkyfwfdnb cnsn gjdnztj shj kjdhnaftk `l
hjns swnatljw ft ywfknwfbv d`a|jdsf|j nac shjwjl`wj hfehbv cjyjacjas `a shj
b`dnb yw`yjwsfjt `l shj `u uhfdh cjsjwkfaj shj g`zacnwv bnvjw shfdoajtt
nw`zac shj shjwk`d`zybj _>7[! Fs ft shjwjl`wj ywjljwngbj shns shj lwj~zjadv
wjty`atj gj kjntzwjc fa+tfsz! H`uj|jw jtsfknsfae shj lwj~zjadv wjty`atj `w
sfkj d`atsnas `l shj tvtsjk ft cfffldzbs fl shj fayzs lzadsf`a ft zaoa`ua! Fa
shj ywjtjas dntj shj ndsznb zdsznsfae sjkyjwnszwj ft zaoa`ua! N cfjwjas
nyyw ndh ft shjwjl wj wj~zfwjc! Fl n wts `wcjw tvtsjk wjty`atj ft nttzkjc
l`w n ynfw `l ncmndjas shjwk`d`zybjt kjntzwfae shj tnkj zdsznsfae sjkyjw+
nszwj" gzs ufsh cfjwjas tf}jt" shj sfkj d`atsnast `l g`sh shjwk`d`zybjt dna
gj cjsjwkfajc _7[!
>!4 Dhnysjw tzkknwv
Knav wjnb d`asfaz`zt `u cj|fdjt dna gj tztdjysfgbj s` shjwk`nd`ztsfd fa+
tsngfbfsv nac zaunasjc a`ftj wjtzbsfae lw`k shj fasjwndsf`a `l zatsjncv hjnsnccfsf`a nac ywjttzwj `tdfbbnsf`at fa shj d`kgzts`w! Knav `l shjtj cj|fdjt
ljnszwj n dh`ojc a`}}bj c`uatswjnk `l shj d`kgzts`w! Shft jxyjwfkjasnb
tszcv nfkt s` cjsjwkfaj shj cvankfd wjty`atj `l n dh`ojc d`kgzts`w jxfs
s` fadfcjas ywjttzwj cftszwgnadjt nac d`a|jdsjc h`s ty`st fa shj `u nlsjw
wts fa|jtsfensfae shj jxftsjadj nac zafl`wkfsv `l shjtj d`a|jdsjc h`s ty`st
ns shj d`kgzts`w jxfs! N lwj~zjadv wjty`atj sjdhaf~zj ufbb gj ztjc s` `gsnfa
shj wjty`atj lw`k tfkzbsnaj`zt aj+ufwj shjwk`d`zybj nac kfdw`yh`aj cnsn
snoja fatfcj shj d`kgzts`w! Shj sfkj d`atsnas `l shjtj aj+ufwj shjwk`d`z+
ybjt ufbb gj jtsfknsjc ztfae na fa+tfsz kjntzwjkjas sjdhaf~zj!
>6
8/3/2019 Dominic Carolan Revised
22/145
Dhnysjw 7
Bfsjwnszwj Wj|fju
7!> Shjwk`nd`ztsfd fatsngfbfsv
Shjwk`nd`ztsfd `tdfbbnsf`at hn|j gjja tszcfjc l`w `|jw su` hzacwjc vjnwt!
H`uj|jw" shjwj ft a` ejajwnb l`wkzbnsf`a s` cjtdwfgj shj d`zybfae `l shj un|j
j~znsf`a ufsh shj jajwev j~znsf`a _>4[! Shns cjyjact `a shj cjsnfbt `l shj
hjns wjbjntj kjdhnaftk" uhfdh cfjw l`w jndh tfsznsf`a `w shjwk`nd`ztsfd
cj|fdj!
@aj tzdh shjwk`nd`ztsfd cj|fdj ft shj t`+dnbbjc Wfmoj szgj" ankjc nlsjw
Wfmoj uh` wts wjy`wsjc `gtjw|fae shns n t`zac knv gj yw`czdjc gv ybndfae
n t`zwdj `l hjns fatfcj na `yja |jwsfdnb szgj _>3[! Shj b`dnsf a `l shj hjns
t`zwdj ft oa`ua s` gj |jwv fky`wsnas fa cjsjwkfafae shj `ddzwwjadj `l shj
t`zac nt ujbb nt fst lwj~zjadv nac nkybfszcj! L`w shj wjbnsf|jbv tfkybj dntj
`l shj Wfmoj szgj ufsh n hjnsjc enz}j nt n hjns t`zwdj shj zatsjncv hjns
wjbjntj knv gj d`zybjc s` shj nd`ztsfd |jb`dfsv zdsznsf`a! Shj zatsjncv
|`bzkjswfd jxynatf`a `ddzwwfae nt n wjtzbs `l shj hjns wjbjntj knv cwf|j shj
nd`ztsfd `tdfbbnsf`at!
Tnfs` _>:[ ztjc 7: k cfnkjsjw ybnsfazk ufwjt s` kjntzwj g`sh sjkyjwn+
szwj nac |jb`dfsv fa na jxyjwfkjas s` fa|jtsfensj shj hjns faczdjc |fgwnsf`at
79
8/3/2019 Dominic Carolan Revised
23/145
fa n Wfmoj szgj! Gv ztfae shj tnkj ufwj cfnkjsjw l`w shj |jb`dfsv nac sjk+
yjwnszwj kjntzwjkjast shj lwj~zjadv wjty`atj unt nttzkjc s` gj knsdhjc!
Shj nzsh`w tszcfjc n 39 k cfnkjsjw ybnsfazk ufwj" hjnsjc ufsh n :9 H}
nbsjwansfae dzwwjas s` yw`|fcj sjkyjwnszwj zdsznsf`at `l >99 H} lwj~zjadv!
Tnfs` nbt` wjyjnsjc shj jxyjwfkjas ufsh n ywjkfxjc nkj nac th`ujc jx+
yjwfkjasnbbv shns na nfw d`bzka knv gj jxdfsjc fl hjns ft nccjc s` n y`fas
fa shj yfyj uhjwj shj ywjttzwj bneejc gjhfac shj |jb`dfsv gv `aj ~znwsjw `l
n dvdbj! Shj y`fas `l tsw`aejts jxdfsnsf`a unt l`zac s` gj kfcunv gjsujja
n ywjttzwj a`cj nac nasfa`cj!
C`ubfae _>4[ hnt cjtdwfgjc |nwf`zt k`cjbt l`w shj dnbdzbnsf`a `l shj lwj+
~zjadv `l shjwk`nd`ztsfd `tdfbbnsf`at l`w cfjwjas d`zybfae kjdhnaftkt gj+
sujja shj zatsjncv hjns fayzs nac shj |jb`dfsv yjwszwgnsf`a! Shj shjwk`n+
d`ztsfd ljjcgndo kjdhnaftk knv gj d`kybfdnsjc fa shj dntj `l n ywjkfxjc
nkj gv shj jxftsjadj `l n sfkj bne gjsujja shj |jb`dfsv zdsznsf`a nac
shj hjns wjbjntj czj s` shj afsj wnsj `l shj dhjkftswv nt ujbb nt shj nkjt
cvankfdt" nac fa ynwsfdzbnw fst fasjwndsf`a ufsh |`wsfdjt thjc gv shj nkjh`bcjw! Kns|jj| nac Dzbfdo _>5[" uhfdh ft
n shfa d`aczds`w shns yw`czdjt n t`zac uhja na nbsjwansfae dzwwjas ft ny+
ybfjc s` fs? shj wjcnky cjsjds`w _>8[" n tfaefae nkj cj|fdj ztjc s` cjsjds
jxyb`tf|j kfaj entjt nac shj yvw`yh`aj _>6[ na fatswzkjas yzwy`wsjc s` yw`+
czdj kztfdnb s`ajt gv shj |fgwnsf`a `l n hvcw`eja nkj! K`wj wjdjasbv shj
ywfadfybjt `l shjwk`nd`ztsfdt hn|j gjja nyybfjc s` shj cjtfea `l hjns yzkyt
_79" 7>[!
Nbsh`zeh shjwj knv gj n lju jxnkybjt `l ztjlzb shjk`nd`ztsfd cj|fdjt"
shj k`ts lwj~zjasbv dfsjc k`sf|nsf`a l`w shj tszcv `l shjwk`nd`ztsfdt hnt
7>
8/3/2019 Dominic Carolan Revised
24/145
gjja shj ajensf|j d`atj~zjadjt `l shjwk`nd`ztsfd fatsngfbfsv fa cj|fdjt tzdh
nt w`dojs jaefajt" wnkmjst" nfwdwnls mjs jaefajt" ent szwgfajt" gzwajwt nac
lzwandjt _77[! @l ynwsfdzbnw fasjwjts s` wjtjnwdhjwt ns ywjtjas ft shj `ddzwwjadj
`l shjwk`nd`ztsfd fatsngfbfsv fa bjna ywjkfxjc d`kgzts wt! Shjtj ufbb gj
cftdzttjc fa shj l`bb`ufae tjdsf`a!
7!7 Bjna ywjkfxjc d`kgzts`wt
Fa shj ynts su` cjdncjt ajnwbv nbb knm`w knazlndszwjwt `l facztswfnb ent
szwgfajt hn|j ncnysjc shjfw d`kgzts`wt s` `yjwnsj fa n bjna ywjkfxjc d`a+
ezwnsf`a s` kfafkftj jkfttf`at `l `xfcjt `l afsw`eja (A@X&! Fa n bjna
ywjkfxjc d`kgzts`w shj wnsf` `l lzjb s` nfw ft bjtt shna shj ts`fdhf`kjswfd wn+
sf` nac shj nfw nac lzjb nwj ujbb kfxjc gjl`wj d`kgztsf`a snojt ybndj! Shjwj
hnt gjja n ejajwnb swjac nunv lw`k shj k`wj tsngbj gzs hfehjw A@X jkfs+
sfae cfztf`a nkj d`kgzts`wt" nbsh`zeh shjtj nwj tsfbb ztjc fa nfwdwnls! Shj
c`uatfcj `l bjna ywjkfxjc d`kgzts`wt ft shns shjv nwj k`wj tztdjysfgbj s`shjwk`nd`ztsfd fatsngfbfsv!
Shj knfa dnztj `l afsw`eja `xfcj jkfttf`at fa n d`a|jasf`anb cfztf`a
svyj nkj ft shj t`+dnbbjc Shjwknb A @ kjdhnaftk! Shjwknb A @ wjljwt s`
afswfd `xfcj l`wkjc gv wjndsf`at `l afsw`eja ufsh `xveja ns jbj|nsjc sjkyjw+
nszwj! Shj kjdhnaftk `l shjwknb A@ l`wknsf`a ft nbt` wjljwwjc s` nt shj
jxsjacjc ]jbc`|fdh kjdhnaftk nlsjw Vno`| G! ]jbc`|fdh uh` wts tszcfjc
fs fa >635 _74[! Shj wjndsf`at nwj nt l`bb`ut
@ / A7 A @ / A (7!>&
A / @7 A@ / @ (7!7&
A / @H A @ / H (7!4&
Shj wnsj `l shj shjwknb A@ kjdhnaftk ft bfkfsjc gv shj wts wjndsf`a uhfdh
ft hfehbv jac`shjwkfd! Shj `|jwnbb wjndsf`a ft shjwjl`wj tsw`aebv sjkyjwnszwj
77
8/3/2019 Dominic Carolan Revised
25/145
cjyjacjas t` shns b`ujw nkj sjkyjwnszwjt nac th`wsjw d`kgzts`w wjtfcjadj
sfkjt wjtzbs fa tfeafdnasbv wjczdjc A@ jkfttf`at gv shft kjdhnaftk!
Fa >664" n ZT Ja|fw`akjasnb Yw`sjdsf`a Nejadv wjy`ws _73[ d`kynwjc
shj k`ts d`kk`a kjsh`ct ztjc s` d`asw`b A @X jkfttf at lw`k `yjwnsf`anb
tsnsf`anwv ent szwgfajt! Shj wjy`ws th`ujc shns `a n d`ts yjw zafs ujfehs
`l A @X wjczdsf`a gntft" bjna ywjkfxjc d`kgzts`w (BYK& cjtfea nwj k`wj
jjdsf|j shna tsjnk nac unsjw famjdsf`a + shj `shjw d`kk`a kjsh`c ns
shns sfkj! Ns shj sfkj bjna ywjkfxjc d`kgzts w cjtfeat ujwj t`kjsfkjt
wjljwwjc s` nt cwv b`u jkfttf`a (CBJ& d`kgzts`wt s` cftsfaezfth shjk lw`k
shj tsjnk `w unsjw famjdsf`a svyjt! Fa shft u`wo shj sjwk bjna ywjkfxjc
(BYK& d`kgzts`w ufbb gj ztjc!
Afswfd `xfcj A @X jkfttf`at knv gj wjczdjc fa n bjna ywjkfxjc gzwajw
gv gzwafae n bjna ywjkfxjc lzjb nfw kfxszwj s` ndhfj|j n b`ujw nkj sjk+
yjwnszwj nac gv shj jnwbv nccfsf`a `l cfbzsf`a nfw s` kfafkftj shj sfkj shns
shj d`kgztsf a yw`czdst nwj ns na jbj|nsjc sjkyjwnszwj! H`uj|jw shj tsn+
gbj d`kgztsf`a `l hvcw`dnwg`at ft bfkfsjc s` n wjbnsf|jbv anww`u wnaej `lj~zf|nbjadj wnsf t oa`ua nt shj nkkngfbfsv bfkfst! Lfezwj 7!> th`ut n
yb`s `l j~zf|nbjadj wnsf` |jwtzt d`kgzts`w Kndh azkgjw l`w shj jxyjwfkja+
snb ywjkfxjc gzwajw ztjc gv Hfjbc _3[! Shj nkkngfbfsv bfkfst nwj yb`ssjc
nt n tjwfjt `l y`fast ns uhfdh shj nkj gbju `zs nt shj j~zf|nbjadj wnsf`
unt |nwfjc! Fa `wcjw s` jjdsf|jbv kfafkftj A@X jkfttf at" n bjna ywjkfxjc
d`kgzts`w kzts `yjwnsj db`tj s` shj b`ujw nkkngfbfsv bfkfs (nbt` oa`ua nt
shj bjna gb`u `zs bfkfs&!
BYK gzwajwt nwj k`wj tztdjysfgbj s` fatsngfbfsv dnztjc gv d`zybfae gj+
sujja shj zatsjncv hjns wjbjntj nac ywjttzwj `tdfbbnsf`at fa shj d`kgzts`w!
Shft bjnct s` shj yw`gbjkt `l a`ftj nac fatsngfbfsv! Tjj Bfjzuja _7:[ nac
Dnacjb _7
8/3/2019 Dominic Carolan Revised
26/145
Lfezwj 7!>= Lbnkkngfbfsv bfkfst `l shj jxyjwfkjasnb d`kgzts`w cjtfeajc gv
Hfjbc _3[
7!4 Ywj|f`zt jxyjwfkjasnb u`wo `a a`}}bjt
Shj jxfs a`}}bj cjajt shj c`uatswjnk g`zacnwv d`acfsf`a l`w shj d`kgzt+
s`w nac shzt shj wjty`atj `l shj a`}}bj s` shj fabjs d`acfsf`at njdst shj
shjwk`nd`ztsfd tsngfbfsv `l shj tvtsjk! Shj jnwbfjts jxyjwfkjast fa|jtsfens+
fae shj wjty`atj `l tzyjwt`afd a`}}bjt s` zdsznsfae fabjs d`acfsf`at ujwj
cjtdwfgjc gv ]zo`tof nac Nzjwgndh fa >653 _75[! Shj jxyjwfkjasnb nyyn+
wnszt ztjc unt na jbjdswfdnbbv hjnsjc afsw`eja ent tswjnk! N s`snb `l 45:
afdhw`kj ufwjt `l >99 k cfnkjsjw ujwj y`tfsf`ajc fatfcj n czds nac ujwjyjwf`cfdnbbv hjnsjc s` yw`|fcj n zdsznsfae t`zwdj `l hjns! Shj lwj~zjadv
unt |nwfjc lw`k 799 s` >799 H}! N sjkyjwnszwj zdsznsf`a `l `abv 9!: O
unt yw`czdjc fa n ent tswjnk `l kntt `u wnsj 9!: oet! Shj zdsznsfae ent
sjkyjwnszwj unt kjntzwjc ztfae n >9 k h`s ufwj najk`kjsjw! N w`snsfae
gbjjc |nb|j unt ztjc s` gbjjc ` ywjdftjbv shj wj~zfwjc nk`zas `l ent ns shj
d`wwjds yhntj" lwj~zjadv nac nkybfszcj s` dnadjb `zs shj ywjttzwj fadwjntj
73
8/3/2019 Dominic Carolan Revised
27/145
dnztjc cfwjdsbv gv shj hjns nccfsf`a!
Shj yw`djttfae tyjjc `l shj cnsn nd~zftfsf`a tvtsjk ns shns sfkj unt
bfkfsjc tzdh shns shj cnsn d`zbc `abv gj tnkybjc d`asfaz`ztbv l`w 9!> tjd`ac
yjwf`ct! Yhntj n|jwnejc cnsn unt d`bbjdsjc gv swfeejwfae shj tsnws `l jndh
tnkybj ufsh wjtyjds s` shj yhntj `l shj gbjjc |nb|j `w hjnsjw fayzs tfeanb! N
>9 oH} tnkybfae lwj~zjadv unt ztjc nac shj 9!> t bjaesh `l cnsn ztjc en|j
n lwj~zjadv wjt`bzsf`a `l >9 H}! Wjtzbst ujwj ywjtjasjc `abv l`w shj l`wdfae
lwj~zjadv `l 399 H}! Shj nzsh`wt tsnsjc shns shj wjtzbst `gsnfajc l`w shjtj
|jwv tknbb nkybfszcj cftszwgnadjt fa n tzyjwt`afd a`}}bj ujwj fa newjjkjas
ufsh shj shj`wv `l Knwgbj nac Dnacjb _6[!
Kzshzowfthana nac Tswnhbj fa|jtsfensjc hvcw`cvankfd" jasw`yv" nac d`k+
gztsf`a a`ftj lw`k n ent szwgfaj d`kgzts`w _78[! N lzbb tf}j ent szwgfaj d`k+
gzts`w unt ztjc l`w shj jxyjwfkjast! Shj nzsh`wt dnsje`wf}jc d`wj a`ftj fa n
mjs jaefaj nt cfwjds d`kgztsf`a a`ftj nac facfwjds jasw`yv a`ftj! D`kgztsf`a
a`ftj unt cjajc nt shj a`ftj yw`czdjc gv ywjttzwj zdsznsf`at dnztjc gv
zatsjncv hjns wjbjntj! Jasw`yv a`ftj unt cjajc nt a`ftj dnztjc gv h`s `wd`bc ty`st ynttfae shw`zeh ywjttzwj ewncfjast fa shj szwgfaj! Shj nzsh`wt
l`zac shns fa n dh`ojc d`kgzts`w ns b`u lwj~zjadv shj jasw`yv nac cfwjds
d`kgztsf`a a`ftj ujwj fa yhntj nac fatjynwngbj! H`uj|jw nt shj lwj~zjadv
nyyw`ndhjt shj fa|jwtj `l shj ynwsfdbj wjtfcjadj sfkj fa shj d`kgzts`w shj ja+
sw`yv a`ftj gjdnkj c`kfanas! Fs unt tzeejtsjc shns na`shjw y`ttfgbj kjdh+
naftk `l a`ftj ejajwnsf`a fa n d`kgzts`w unt |`wsfdfsv+a`}}bj fasjwndsf`a
a`ftj! Shj kjntzwjkjas `l a`a+yw`ynensfae hvcw`cvankfd a`ftj `w ytjz+
c`t`zac unt kfafkf}jc gv b`dnsfae shj ywjttzwj swnatczdjwt fa na T+szgj
`zstfcj `l shj `u jbc! Na nbsjwansf|j nyyw ndh s` kfafkftj shj jjds `l
nyynwjas ywjttzwj zdsznsf`at dnztjc gv szwgzbjadj `a shj nanbvtft knv gj
ztfae n ynfw `l kfdw`yh`ajt tjynwnsjc lnw ja`zeh nynws shns shj szwgzbjadj
zdsznsf at nwj zad`wwjbnsjc! N ynyjw gv D`wd`t _76[ yw`|fcjt shj wjbj|nas
l`wkzbn l`w shj cjewjj `l nssjaznsf`a `l gndoew`zac szwgzbjas a`ftj fa tzdh
7:
8/3/2019 Dominic Carolan Revised
28/145
tfsznsf`at!
Wjdjasbv jxyjwfkjast ujwj c`aj s` kjntzwj ywjttzwj nac jasw`yv cft+
szwgnadjt c`uatswjnk `l g`sh n d`kgzts`w nac na jbjdswfdnbbv hjnsjc ewfc
_49[! Gv ztfae n yjwf`cfd dzwwjas yzbtj s` hjns shj ewfc fs unt cjk`atswnsjc
shns c`uatswjnk yw`ynensfae ywjttzwj cftszwgnadjt czj s` shj cfwjds hjns+
fae ujwj l`bb`ujc gv ywjttzwj cftszwgnadjt ejajwnsjc gv shj d`a|jdsjc h`s
ty`s ynttfae shw`zeh shj a`}}bj! Fky`wsnasbv shj nzsh`wt d`adbzcjc shns shj
jasw`yv a`ftj unt k`wj tfeafdnas shna cfwjds d`kgztsf`a a`ftj fa shj jx+
hnzts c`uatswjnk `l shj a`}}bj! Shj jxyjwfkjasnb tjszy unt |jwv tfkfbnw s`
shj jxyjwfkjas `l Tnfs` _>:[ cjtdwfgjc ng`|j! Shj jxyjwfkjasnb nfkt uhjwj
s` kjntzwj shj jxsjwanb a`ftj ejajwnsf`a wnshjw shna shj fasjwanb wjjdsjc
a`ftj!
Shft ywjtjas u`wo l`bb`ut `a lw`k cfwjdsbv lw`k Hfjbct _3" >>[ jxyjwf+
kjast! Hfjbc jxsjacjc shj su` kfdw`yh`aj kjsh`c s` nbt` nbb`u shj cj+
sjwkfansf`a `l shj wjty`atj `l n a`}}bj s` na jasw`yv cftszwgnadj! Hfjbc
nyybfjc shj aju kjsh`c s` na `yja nac dh`ojc jxfs! L`w shj `yja jxfs g`shshj nd`ztsfd nac jasw`yfd wjtzbst th`ujc e``c newjjkjas ufsh dbnttfdnb shj+
`wv! H`uj|jw fa shj dntj `l shj dh`ojc jxfs ajfshjw shj ywjttzwj a`w jasw`yv
wjty`atj newjjc ufsh Knwgbj nac Dnacjbt _6[ shj`wv! Hfjbc d`adbzcjc shns
bnwej nkybfszcj l`wdfae fa shj jxyjwfkjas knv hn|j bjc s` n a`a+bfajnw a`}}bj
wjty`atj nac wjd`kkjacjc shj wjj|nbznsf`a `l shj a`}}bj swnatljw lzadsf`a
zacjw k`wj d`asw`bbjc d`acfsf`at! Shft wjd`kkjacnsf`a unt snoja nt na nfk
`l shft shjtft! Shj nanbvtft ufbb gj jxybnfajc gjb`u!
7!3 Nd`ztsfd wjjdsf`a d`jffldfjast
T`zac ft ztznbbv d`atfcjwjc s` gj ftjasw`yfd gjdnztj shj tynsfnb ywjttzwj ewn+
cfjast nwj t` ewncznb shns hjns swnatljw gjsujja shj d`kywjttjc nac wnwjjc
ent ft tknbb _4>[! H`uj|jw" l`w bnwej ywjttzwj cftszwgnadjt tzdh nt th`do
7
8/3/2019 Dominic Carolan Revised
29/145
un|jt shj ywjttzwj ewncfjast nwj |jwv tsjjy nac shj ftjasw`yfd nttzkysf`a ft
a` b`aejw |nbfc! Fa shft tszcv" shj ywjttzwj cftszwgnadjt nwj nttzkjc s` gj
ftjasw`yfd!
Shj fa|ftdfc k`kjaszk j~znsf`a" `w Jzbjwt j~znsf`a" dna gj uwfssja nt
z
s/ z
z
x;
>
y
x" (7!3&
L`w shj bfkfs `l b`u Kndh azkgjw" shj tjd`ac sjwk fa j~znsf`a7!3 gjd`kjt
}jw`! Fasjewnsf`a vfjbct
z ; >
y
x s " (7!:&
y/ ; Njmox " (7!
Nj
mox
s ;>
Njmox ;
>
y/ ! (7!8&
Tfkfbnwbv shj |jb`dfsv `l shj zytswjnk swn|jbfae un|j ft ef|ja gv
z ; >
y ! (7!6&
@lsja shj |`bzkj |jb`dfsv ft ztjc l`w shj ~znasfsv
Z ; T z " (7!>9&
uhjwj T ft shj yfyj dw`tt+tjdsf`anb nwjn! Shj nd`ztsfd fkyjcnadj knv gj
cjajc nt ywjttzwj cf|fcjc gv |`bzkj |jb`dfsv
] ;y
Z! (7!>>&
Ztfae j~znsf`at 7!9" l`w n yfyj ufsh na fadfcjas nac wjjdsjc ywjttzwj
un|j shj fkyjcnadj shjwjl`wj ft ef|ja gv
] ;d
T(
Njmox / Gjmox
Njmox Gjmox& ! (7!>7&
75
8/3/2019 Dominic Carolan Revised
30/145
Uhjwj d ft shj tyjjc `l t`zac! Cjafae ]9 nt shj fkyjcnadj fa shj yfyj ns
n ynwsfdzbnw y`fas x ; 9" shja j~znsf`a 7!>7 gjd`kjt
]9 ;d
T(
N / G
NG& ! (7!>4&
T`b|fae j~znsf`a 7!>4 l`w shj wjjdsf`a d`jffldfjas G/N vfjbct
G
N;
]9 d/T
]9 / d/T! (7!>3&
Fa shft unv shj wjjdsf`a d`jffldfjas ft wjbnsjc s` shj d`kybjx fkyjcnadj!
Shj wjjdsf`a lw`k `yja nac db`tjc jact `l n yfyj ufbb gj d`atfcjwjc fa shj
l`bb`ufae tjdsf`at!
7!3!> Wjjdsf`a lw`k na `yja jac
L`w n ybnaj un|j fa n yfyj ufsh n dhnaej fa dw`tt+tjdsf`anb nwjn lw`k T> s` T7
shj wjjdsf`a d`jffldfjas knv gj `gsnfajc gv tjssfae ]9 ; d/T7 fa j~znsf`a
7!>7 s` vfjbc
GN
; T> T7T> / T7
! (7!>:&
Fa shj dntj `l na `yja jac shj ybnaj un|j nanbvtft knv gj ztjc ufsh T7 ; !
Shj wjtzbsfae fkyjcnadj ft }jw` nac shj wjjdsf`a d`jffldfjas ft +>! Shft dbnt+
tfdnb nyyw`xfknsf`a ft dbjnwbv a`s yjwljds nt fs fkybfjt shns ns b`u lwj~zjadv
a` t`zac ufbb bjn|j shj yfyj! Shj l`bb`ufae tjdsf`a cjtdwfgjt n k`wj nddzwnsj
wjtzbs uhfdh cjtdwfgjt shj fkyjcnadj czj s` wncfnsf`a lw`k na `yja jac!
7!3!7 Fadbzcfae shj jjdst `l wncfnsf`a lw`k na `yja
jac
Shj shj`wv `l Bj|faj nac Tdhufaejw _:[ l`w shj wncfnsf`a `l t`zac lw`k na
`yja zanaejc dfwdzbnw yfyj unt ztjc s` `gsnfa na nyyw`xfknsf`a l`w shj
fkyjcnadj `l na `yja yfyj ns b`u lwj~zjadv! Lfezwj 7!7 th`ut shj y`ujw
wjjdsf`a d`jffldfjas yb`ssjc nenfats a`a+cfkjatf anb lwj~zjadv `w Hjbkh bs}
78
8/3/2019 Dominic Carolan Revised
31/145
Lfezwj 7!7= Shj`wjsfdnb y`ujw wjjdsf`a d`jffldfjas l`w na `yja jac _:[
azkgjw on l`w na `yja jac" uhjwj o ft shj un|j azkgjw nac n ft shj yfyj
cfnkjsjw nac shj y`ujw wjjdsf`a d`jffldfjas ft cjajc nt shj t~znwj `l shj
wjjdsf`a d`jffldfjas!
Ns b`u lwj~zjadv on 22 > (f!j! lwj~zjadfjt bjtt shna w`zehbv 7999 H} l`w
n :9 kk yfyj nt fa shft tszcv& na nyyw`xfknsf`a l`w shj zanaejc `yja jac
fkyjcnadj ft ef|ja gv _47[ nt
] ;d
T
o7n7
3/ 9!3! Shj wjtzbsfae tvtsjk swnatljw lzadsf`a ft
ef|ja gvG
N;
g>(m&7 / g7m >
g>(m&7 / g7m / >" (7!>5&
uhjwj shj d`atsnast nwj ef|ja gv g> ; n7/3d7 nac g7 ; 9!
8/3/2019 Dominic Carolan Revised
32/145
7!3!4 Wjjdsf`a lw`k n db`tjc jac
Gv bjssfae shj nwjn T7 ; 9 fa j~znsf`a 7!>: l`w n db`tjc jac" shj fkyjcnadj
gjd`kjt faafsj! Shj d`wwjty`acfae wjjdsf`a d`jffldfjas l`w n db`tjc jac ft
>! Zabfoj na `yja jac" wjjdsf`a lw`k n db`tjc jac `ddzwt ufsh`zs dhnaej `l
yhntj!
7!: Wjjdsf`a lw`k n dh`ojc a`}}bj
Knwgbj nac Dnacjb _6[ l`wkzbnsjc n bfajnw shj`wv l`w shj wjty`atj `l a`}}bjt
s` d`a|jdsjc ent a`a+zafl`wkfsfjt nac nd`ztsfd cftszwgnadjt! Dzkytsv nac
Knwgbj _44[ nbt` cjtdwfgjc shj fasjwndsf`a `l shjtj jasw`yv ty`st ufsh szwgfaj
gbncj w`ut fa uhfdh shj tsjncv dhnaej `l ywjttzwj fa shj tswjnk+uftj cfwjdsf`a
ft bnwej!
Shjtj nwj wjljwwjc s` nt jasw`yv zdsznsf`at wnshjw shna sjkyjwnszwj
zdsznsf`at gjdnztj shj sjkyjwnszwj zdsznsf`at nwj kncj zy `l g`sh na
jasw`yv d`ky`ajas nac shj ftjasw`yfd sjkyjwnszwj dhnaej ntt`dfnsjc ufsh n
ywjttzwj zdsznsf a"S
S;
t
dy/ ( >&
y
y! (7!>8&
Shj jasw`yv cftszwgnadj ft nttzkjc s` d`a|jds ufsh shj `u tzdh shns
t
dy;
y
y
; jfs " (7!>6&
uhjwj t(s& ft shj jasw`yv un|j nkybfszcj nac y(x" s& ft shj zdsznsfae ywjt+
tzwj ef|ja gv
y
(x" s& ; jfs(N(s&jmofx / G(s&jmowx& " (7!79&
uhjwj N(s& ft shj fadfcjas ywjttzwj un|j nkybfszcj nac G(s& ft shj wjjdsjc
ywjttzwj un|j nkybfszcj!
Gv cjafsf`a shj Kndh azkgjw ns shj shw`ns `l n dh`ojc a`}}bj ft j~znb
s` `aj! Shj a`}}bj dna gj nttzkjc s` gj d`kynds! Shjwjl`wj shj Kndh
49
8/3/2019 Dominic Carolan Revised
33/145
azkgjw ns shj a`}}bj jaswnadj kzts nbt` gj d`atsnas s` tnsftlv shj j~znsf`a
`l d`asfazfsv `l kntt shw`zeh shj yfyj"
K
; 9 (7!7>&
T~znwfae j~znsf`a 7!7> nac tzgtsfszsfae
d7 ;y
(7!77&
vfjbct z7
y
; 9 ! (7!74&
J~znsf`a 7!74 knv jxynacjc fas` fst tsjncv nac zdsznsfae ynwst"
z7
y;
z / z
7
/
(y / y&! (7!73&
Wjsnfafae `abv shj wts `wcjw sjwkt shft j~znsf`a knv gj wjnwwnaejc s`
`gsnfa shj bfajnw g`zacnwv d`acfsf`a `l Knwgbj nac Dnacjb _6[ l`w n d`kynds"
tzyjwdwfsfdnb a`}}bjy
y;
/ 7
z
z! (7!7:&
Wjty`atj `l n dh`ojc a`}}bj s` n ywjttzwj cftszwgnadj
Shj ng`|j g`zacnwv d`acfsf`a ufbb wts gj ztjc s` cjsjwkfaj shj wjty`atj
`l n dh`ojc a`}}bj s` n c`uatswjnk swn|jbfae ywjttzwj un|j `l nkybfszcj N
fa shj ngtjadj `l jasw`yv cftszwgnadjt! Shj a`a+cfkjatf`anb ywjttzwj nac
|jb`dfsv ns n y`fas ft ef|ja gv shj tzk `l shj zytswjnk nac c`uatswjnkswn|jbfae nd`ztsfd un|j nt l`bb`ut
y
y; (Njmofx / Gjmowx&jms (7!7
8/3/2019 Dominic Carolan Revised
34/145
Shj bfajnwf}jc j~znsf`a 7!>6 ft
t
dy;
y
y
! (7!78&
Uhja shjwj nwj a` jasw`yv cftszwgnadjt"
;
y
y! (7!76&
Tzgtsfszsf`a l`w
/ fa j~znsf`a 7!7: vfjbct
z
d; K
7y
y( >&
! (7!49&
Tzgtsfszsf`a `l 7!49 fas` j~znsf`a 7!75 nac j~znsf`a 7!7< ns x;9 nac t`b|fae
l`w shj wjty`atj `l n dh`ojc a`}}bj s` n ywjttzwj cftszwgnadj Wy vfjbct
Wy ;G
N;
> >7
( >&K>
> / >7
( >&K>! (7!4>&
L`w tknbb Kndh azkgjwt shft wjjdsf`a d`jffldfjas gjd`kjt shj tnkj nt shns
l`w wjjdsf`a lw`k n db`tjc jac!
Wjty`atj `l n dh`ojc a`}}bj s` na jasw`yv cftszwgnadj
Shj dh`ojc a`}}bj wjty`atj s` na jasw`yv cftszwgnadj `l nkybfszcj ufbb gj
cjwf|jc hjwj! Shj d`a|jdsjc jasw`yv cftszwgnadj ft
t
dy; jm(sx/z& ! (7!47&
Fa shft dntj shj nkybfszcj `l shj fadfcjas ywjttzwj cftszwgnadj N ; 9! Tzg+
tsfszsf`a `l 7!78 fas` 7!7: nbb`ut j~znsf`a 7!7< nac 7!75 s` gj uwfssja nt
y
y; Gjms (7!44&
nacK>
7(y
y
y
y/ jms& ; Gjms ! (7!43&
47
8/3/2019 Dominic Carolan Revised
35/145
T`b|fae j~znsf`at 7!44 nac 7!43 vfjbct shj wjjdsf`a d`jffldfjas Wt" shj wj+
ty`atj `l n dh`ojc a`}}bj s` na jasw`yv cftszwgnadj nt l`bb`ut
Wt ;G
;
>
7(
K>> / >
7( >&K>
& ! (7!4:&
Tzyjwy`tfsf`a `l shj wjtzbst l`w shj ywjttzwj cftszwgnadj dnztjc gv fadfcjas
ywjttzwj un|j nac shj ywjttzwj cftszwgnadj dnztjc gv shj jasw`yv un|j vfjbct
shj s`snb zytswjnk swn|jbfae ywjttzwj un|j G! Nt shj a`}}bj jaswv Kndh
azkgjw nyyw`ndhjt }jw` shj jjds czj s` shj d`a|jdsjc jasw`yv cftszwgnadj
gjd`kjt ajebfefgbj d`kynwjc s` wjjdsjc fadfcjas ywjttzwj cftszwgnadj!
7!< Jxyjwfkjasnb cjsjwkfansf`a `l wjjdsf`a
d`jffldfjast
Shjwj nwj tj|jwnb l`wkt `l t`+dnbbjc su` kfdw`yh`aj kjsh`ct l`w shj jx+
yjwfkjasnb cjsjwkfansf`a `l nd`ztsfd fkyjcnadj `w wjjdsf`a d`jffldfjast _>"
43" 4:[! Shj kjsh`c nttzkjt n tfaebj fayzs tfaebj `zsyzs (TFT@& tvtsjk
ufsh `abv shj jjds `l bfajnw nd`ztsfd cftszwgnadjt d`atfcjwjc! Shj cftdzt+
tf`a `l shft kjsh`c ufbb gj jxsjacjc s` fadbzcj shj wjty`atj s` na jasw`yv
cftszwgnadj swn|jbfae ufsh shj `u fa shj l`bb`ufae tjdsf`a!
7! Shj su` kfdw`yh`aj kjsh`c `l Tjvgjws nac W`tt
_>[
Su` kfdw`yh`ajt nwj b`dnsjc ns y`tfsf`at x> nac x7 nt th`ua fa Lfezwj 7!4!
Shj un|j azkgjwt l`w shj fadfcjas nac wjjdsjc un|jt nwj ef|ja gv
of ;
d / z(7!4
8/3/2019 Dominic Carolan Revised
36/145
Lfezwj 7!4= Su` kfdw`yh`aj kjsh`c l`w cjsjwkfafae na zaoa`ua fkyjcnadjlw`k Tjvgjws nac W`tt _>[
Shj ywjttzwj ns nav y`fas ft ef|ja gv shj tzk `l shj d`aswfgzsf`at czj s`
shj fadfcjas nac wjjdsjc ywjttzwj cftszwgnadjt ns shns y`fas nt l`bb`ut
y
(x" s& ; jms(N(s&jmofx / G(s&jmowx& " (7!48&
uhjwj N(s& ft shj fadfcjas ywjttzwj un|j nkybfszcj nac G(s& ft shj wjjdsjc
ywjttzwj un|j nkybfszcj! Shj ~znasfsv `l fasjwjts ft shj wnsf` `l shj L`zwfjw
swnatl`wkt `l shjtj nkybfszcjt G(& nac N(& ns jndh lwj~zjadv" uhfdh knv
gj l`zac ztfae shj lwj~zjadv wjty`atj kjsh`c
Wy ;TNGTNN
;N GN N
;GN
! (7!46&
Shj L`zwfjw swnatl`wk `l shj ywjttzwj tfeanb lw`k jndh kfdw`yh`aj Y> nac
Y7 nwj ztjc s` `gsnfa shj nzs` tyjdswnb cjatfsv lzadsf`at T>> nac T77 nac shj
dw`tt tyjdswnb cjatfsv lzadsf`at T>7
nac T7>
! Shjtj oa`ua nzs`+tyjdswnb nac
dw`tt+tyjdswnb cjatfsfjt nwj shja ztjc s` t`b|j l`w shj zaoa`uat" TNN" TGG "
TNG nac TGN ns x ; 9! Ztfae
T>> ; Y> Y> ; ( N
jmofx> / Gjmowx>&( Njmofx> / Gjmowx>& " (7!39&
uhfdh knv gj tfkybfjc s` `gsnfa
T>> ; N N / NGjmofx>/mowx> / G Njmofx>mowx> / G G " (7!3>&
43
8/3/2019 Dominic Carolan Revised
37/145
uhfdh knv nbt` gj uwfssja fa sjwkt `l tyjdswnb cjatfsv lzadsf`at nt
T>> ; TNN / TNGjmofx>/mowx> / TGNj
mofx>mowx> / TGG ! (7!37&
Tfkfbnwbv T>7" T7> nac T77 nwj ef|ja gv
T>7 ; TNNjmofx>mo>x7 / TNGj
mofx>/mowx7 / TGNjmofx>mowx7 / TGGj
mofx>/mo>x7 "
(7!34&
T7> ; T
>7 " (7!33&
T77 ; TNN / TNGjmofx7/mowx7
/ TGNjmofx7mowx7
/ TGG ! (7!3:&
J~znsf`at 7!37 s` 7!3: nwj t`b|jc s` `gsnfa TNG nac TNN! Shj ywjttzwj
wjjdsf`a d`jffldfjas Wy" ft j~zf|nbjas s` shj lwj~zjadv wjty`atj lzadsf`a l`w
shj tvtsjk ufsh shj fadfcjas ywjttzwj un|j nkybfszcj N nt shj fayzs nac shj
wjjdsjc ywjttzwj un|j nkybfszcj G nt shj `zsyzs! Shjwjl`wj l`w n tfaebj
fayzs tfaebj `zsyzs (TFT@& tvtsjk shj ywjttzwj wjjdsf`a d`jffldfjas ft ef|ja
gv
Wy ;
TNGTNN ;
G
N ! (7!3Shj wjtzbst `gsnfajc ng`|j l`w shj nkybfszcj `l shj zytswjnk nac c`ua+
tswjnk swn|jbfae ywjttzwj un|jt ns shj jxfs N nac G nwj nbt` |nbfc fa shj
ywjtjadj `l n bfajnw jasw`yv cftszwgnadj fa n h`k`ejaj`zt `u! Shj su`
kfdw`yh`aj tfeanbt knv gj ztjc nb`ae ufsh n tfaebj sjkyjwnszwj tfeanb s`
t`b|j l`w shj dw`tt+tyjdswnb cjatfsfjt ntt`dfnsjc ufsh shj jasw`yv nac ywjttzwjcftszwgnadjt ns shj a`}}bj! Shft kjsh`c hnt gjja cj|jb`yjc gv Hfjbc _3[ nac
ft cftdzttjc hjwj!
Fa n yfyj ufsh na zatsjncv hjns t`zwdj shjwj knv gj na zytswjnk nac
c`uatswjnk swn|jbfae ywjttzwj un|j nac n c`uatswjnk swn|jbfae jasw`yv
un|j nt th`ua fa Lfezwj 7!3! Shj jasw`yv un|j ft nttzkjc s` gj d`a|jdsjc
ns shj kjna |jb`dfsv `l shj `u! N tjd`ac fayzs l`w shj jasw`yv un|jt `w h`s
4:
8/3/2019 Dominic Carolan Revised
38/145
Lfezwj 7!3= Su` kfdw`yh`aj nac `aj shjwk`d`zybj kjsh`c l`w cjsjwkfafae
na zaoa`ua fkyjcnadj lw`k Hfjbc _3[
ty`st ft fadbzcjc fa shj tvtsjk k`cjb! Bfajnw tzyjwy`tfsf`a `l shj wjjdsjc
ywjttzwj un|j nac shj wjty`atj czj s` shj jasw`yv cftszwgnadj ef|jt shj s`snb
zytswjnk swn|jbfae ywjttzwj un|j!
Shj un|j azkgjw" cjtdwfgfae shj d`a|jdsf`a `l shj jasw`yv ufsh shj `u
ft
ot ;
z! (7!35&
L`w shj tfkybj dntj fa uhfdh shj shjwk`d`zybj nac `aj `l shj ywjttzwj swnat+czdjwt nwj b`dnsjc ns shj tnkj cftsnadj x lw`k shj a`}}bj" shj L`zwfjw swnat+
l`wk `l shj a`a+cfkjatf`anb jasw`yv Tx knv gj dnbdzbnsjc cfwjdsbv gv snofae
L`zwfjw swnatl`wkt nac wjnwwnaefae j~znsf`a 7!>8 s` vfjbc
Tx ; Sx ( >&
Yx " (7!38&
uhjwj Sx nac Yx nwj shj L`zwfjw swnatl`wkt `l shj a`a+cfkjatf`anb sjkyjwn+
szwj nac ywjttzwj ns y`fas x! Shj nzs`+tyjdswnb cjatfsv lzadsf`a TTT l`w shj
jasw`yv cftszwgnadj ns shj jxfs (uhjwj x ; 9& knv gj jtsfknsjc s` `gsnfa
TTT Tx Tx ! (7!36&
Shj dw`tt+tyjdswnb cjatfsv lzadsf`at `l shj fadfcjas nac zytswjnk swn|jbfae
ywjttzwj un|jt ufsh shj jasw`yv cftszwgnadj ns shj jxfs" TNT nac TGT" knv
gj `gsnfajc gv t`b|fae
T>4 ; TNTjmofx>motx4 / TGTj
mowx>motx4 " (7!:9&
4
8/3/2019 Dominic Carolan Revised
39/145
Lfezwj 7!:= Su` fayzs tfaebj `zsyzs tvtsjk lw`k Ajubnac _&
Shj `|jwnbb tvtsjk ft nttzkjc s` gj n bfajnw tvtsjk ufsh su` fayzst nac n
tfaebj `zsyzs nt th`ua fa Lfezwj 7!:! Shj wjtzbs l`w shj lwj~zjadv wjty`atj
lzadsf`a l`w n su` fayzs tfaebj `zsyzs tvtsjk _
8/3/2019 Dominic Carolan Revised
40/145
d`wwjdsf`a lnds`wt l`w tsjncv tsnsj jww`wt czj s` wncfnsf`a nac d`aczdsf`a
b`ttjt l`w |nwf`zt ej`kjswfjt ujwj `gsnfajc! Shj Wjva`bct azkgjw wnaej
gntjc `a shj ent yw`yjwsfjt ns shj s`snb sjkyjwnszwj nac shj shjwk`d`zybj
ufwj cfnkjsjw unt na `wcjw `l kneafszcj hfehjw shna shj Wjva`bct azkgjw
wnaej jad`zasjwjc fa shjtj jxyjwfkjast! Shj Kndh azkgjw wnaej `l shj
dzwwjas jxyjwfkjast d`fadfcjt ufsh shj b`ujw bfkfs `l shj wnaej tszcfjc gv
Tdncw`a nac Unwthnutov!
K`ts shjwk`d`zybj tvtsjkt nwj svyfdnbbv k`cjbjc nt n wts `wcjw bne
tvtsjkt h`uj|jw ns b`u lwj~zjadv shj wjty`atj dna gj nssjaznsjc czj s`
d`aczdsf`a nb`ae shj ufwj! Shj jjdst `l d`aczdsf`a nwj swjnsjc fa cjsnfb fa
n wjdjas ynyjw gv O`gzt _4799 H} _78[!Shj Tswnhbj sjdhaf~zj ufbb gj cjk`atswnsjc fa dhnysjw 4! Shj bjaesh tdnbj
unt jtsfknsjc gntjc `a dw`tt+d`wwjbnsf`a nanbvtft `l su` shjwk`d`zybj tfe+
anbt! @aj shjwk`d`zybj unt xjc ns n y`fas nac shj `shjw unt y`tfsf`ajc ns
|nwvfae cftsnadjt lw`k shj xjc shjwk`d`zybj! Shj wjtzbst wj|jnbjc n tsjjy
cw`y fa shj dw`tt+d`wwjbnsf`a d`jffldfjas l`w shj tfeanbt gjv`ac shj tyndfae `l
shj bjaesh tdnbjt `l sjkyjwnszwj zdsznsf`at fa shj wfe!
Dnkgwnv _45[ nbt` dbnfkjc s` hn|j cj|jb`yjc n aju kjsh`c `l kjntzwfae
shjwk`d`zybj sfkj d`atsnast! H`uj|jw shj kjsh`c wj~zfwfae dzw|j ssfae `l
shj ndsznb sfkj tjwfjt ft faljwf`w s` shj Tswnhbj kjsh`c uhfdh tn|jt d`kyz+
snsf`a sfkj czj s` shj ztj `l shj lnts L`zwfjw swnatl`wk!
Snbgv dnbfgwnsjc n aj shjwk`d`zybj ztfae n d`bc ufwj _48[! N :9 kfdw`a
shjwk`d`zybj unt y`tfsf`ajc `a shj jcej `l n h`s szwgzbjas mjs ztfae n 9!
8/3/2019 Dominic Carolan Revised
41/145
knsjc s` gj `l `wcjw >9 oH} l`w shj ynwsfdzbnw szwgzbjas `u! Fs unt l`zac
shns shj d`kyjatnsf`a unt jjdsf|j s` ng`zs > oH}! Ns hfehjw lwj~zjadfjt
d`kynwft`a `l shj d`kyjatnsjc shjwk`d`zybj sjkyjwnszwjt ufsh shj d`bc
ufwj wjtzbst th`ujc shns shj nkybfdnsf`a `l a`ftj gjdnkj tfeafdnas!
Snenun js nb! _4[ d`kynwjc lnts wjty`atj shjwk`d`zybj kjntzwjkjast s`
n aj ufwj wjtftsnadj shjwk`kjsjw (d`bc ufwj& `l 9!< s` 4!> kfdw`at cfnkjsjw
fa shj szwgzbjas unoj `l n hjnsjc dvbfacjw! Su` shjwk`d`zybj d`kgfansf`at
ujwj ztjc! Fa shj wts jxyjwfkjas" n ynfw `l shjwk`d`zybjt `l 39 nac >99 k
cfnkjsjw ujwj ztjc! Fa shj tjd`ac jxyjwfkjas n ynfw `l shjwk`d`zybjt 7:
nac unt jjdsf|j zy s` n lwj~zjadv `l 49 H}! Ufwj cfnkjsjwt `l :9 nac 5: k
ujwj ztjc! Shj d`bc nfw sjkyjwnszwj unt 494 O nac shj h`s nfw sjkyjwnszwj
unt 478 O! Shj nfw |jb`dfsv unt >8 kt! Shj dzs` lwj~zjadv `l shj :9 k
shjwk`d`zybj zacjw shjtj d`acfsf`at unt l`zac s` gj : H}!
Jdotsjfa _>9[ nyybfjc shj su` shjwk`d`zybj kjsh`c s` n ynfw `l shjw+
k`d`zybjt `l :9 nac 5: k s` knoj d`kyjatnsjc cvankfd sjkyjwnszwj
kjntzwjkjast fatfcj na jxyjwfkjasnb d`kgzts`w ns sjkyjwnszwjt zy s` >599
O!
Snthfw`" Gfun nac Vn}nof _46[ hn|j cjtdwfgjc na `wfefanb kjsh`c `l shjw+
k`d`zybj dnbfgwnsf`a ztfae shj ftjasw`yfd sjkyjwnszwj `tdfbbnsf`at dnztjc gv
46
8/3/2019 Dominic Carolan Revised
42/145
Lfezwj 7!8 H}! Shjwj unt a` kjna `u `l
ent fa shj szgj czwfae shj sjts!
7!5 Tzkknwv `l shj bfsjwnszwj
Shjwk`nd`ztsfd `tdfbbnsf`at nwj n y`sjasfnb yw`gbjk fa n wnaej `l d`asfaz`zt
`u shjwk`cvankfd cj|fdjt tzdh nt ywjkfxjc ent szwgfaj d`kgzts`wt" w`dojs
jaefajt nac nlsjw+gzwajwt! S` zacjwtsnac nac jbfkfansj shj yw`gbjk wj~zfwjt
n gjssjw zacjwtsnacfae `l shj yhvtfdnb kjdhnaftkt fa|`b|jc fa shj fasjwndsf`a
gjsujja shj zatsjncv hjns wjbjntj" shj ywjttzwj `tdfbbnsf`at nac shj g`zacnwv
d`acfsf`at `l shj d`kgzts`w!
Shj fasjwndsf`a `l d`a|jdsjc jasw`yv cftszwgnadjt ufsh n dh`ojc c`ua+
tswjnk g`zacnwv d`acfsf`a ft na fky`wsnas lnds`w fa shj nttjttkjas `l shj
39
8/3/2019 Dominic Carolan Revised
43/145
tsngfbfsv `l wjnb d`kgzts`wt! Shj bfajnw shj`wv `l Knwgbj nac Dnacjb _6[
l`w shj wjty`atj `l jxfs a`}}bjt hnt gjd`kj ujbb jtsngbfthjc fa shj bfsjwn+
szwj! H`uj|jw" jxyjwfkjasnb |nbfcnsf`a `l shj shj`wv ft bfkfsjc! Shj su`
kfdw`yh`aj kjsh`c `l Tjvgjws nac W`tt _6[ hnt gjja jxsjacjc gv Hfjbc _3[
s` nbb`u jxyjwfkjasnb cjsjwkfansf`a `l shj wjty`atj `l n dh`ojc d`kgzts`w
jxfs a`}}bj s` g`sh ywjttzwj nac jasw`yv cftszwgnadjt! Fa shft unv shj ywj+
|f`ztbv bfkfsjc jxyjwfkjasnb j|fcjadj knv gj `gsnfajc lw`k tfkzbsnaj`zt
kfdw`yh`aj nac aj+ufwj shjwk`d`zybj cnsn kjntzwjkjast snoja fatfcj n
d`kgzts`w!
3>
8/3/2019 Dominic Carolan Revised
44/145
Dhnysjw 4
Jxyjwfkjasnb kjsh`c
4!> Cjtdwfysf`a `l shj jxyjwfkjasnb wfe
Shj jxyjwfkjasnb ywjkfxjc d`kgzts`w" cjtfeajc nac gzfbs gv Hfjbc _3[ ft
th`ua fa Lfezwj 4!>! Shj ynwst `l shj jxyjwfkjasnb d`kgzts w wfe ufbb gj
jxybnfajc hjwj!
4!>!> Nfw nac lzjb ywjynwnsf`a
N tsjncv `u `l d`kywjttjc nfw unt snoja lw`k n bnwej nfw wjdjf|jw! Lzjb
unt snoja lw`k shwjj bf~zjjc yjsw`bjzk ent dvbfacjwt knafl`bcjc s`ejshjw!
Fs unt nttzkjc shns shj lzjb unt ywfknwfbv d`ky`tjc `l yw`ynaj nbsh`zeh
na nanbvtft unt a`s c`aj! G`sh lzjb nac nfw ujwj famjdsjc zytswjnk `l n
dh`oj ybnsj" uhfdh unt ztjc nt n dnbfgwnsjc t`afd a`}}bj s` kjntzwj shj nfw
nac lzjb kntt `u wnsj nac s` ywj|jas j~zf|nbjadj wnsf zdsznsf at! Shj
d`kgzts`wt jtsfknsjc knxfkzk nfw nac lzjb kntt `u wnsjt ujwj 9!>< oet
nac 9!97 oet wjtyjdsf|jbv _3[!
37
8/3/2019 Dominic Carolan Revised
45/145
Lfezwj 4!>= Shj d`kgzts`w wfe cjtfeajc gv Hfjbc _3[
4!>!7 Lbnkj h`bcjw
Lbnkj tsngfbftnsf`a
N ywjkfxjc nkj knv gj tsngfbftjc fa n azkgjw `l unvt" fadbzcfae y`tf+
sf`afae n gbz g`cv fas` shj `u s` nadh`w shj nkj fa shj wjdfwdzbnsfae
szwgzbjas unoj nac gv fasw`czdfae tufwb fas` shj `u! Lbnkj nthgndo fas`
shj ywjkfxfae tjdsf`a ft `aj y`sjasfnb yw`gbjk shns hnt s` gj d`atfcjwjc
uhja cjtfeafae bjna ywjkfxjc gzwajwt! Zabfoj n cfztf a nkj d`kgzts`w"
fa uhfdh shj nkj ft gzwajc ns jttjasfnbbv shj tnkj y`fas uhjwj shj lzjb ft
famjdsjc" fa n bjna ywjkfxjc d`kgzts`w n nkkngbj kfxszwj jxftst fa shj
ywj+dhnkgjw zytswjnk `l shj nkj!
N tjdsf`a shw`zeh shj gbz g`cv nkj h`bcjw cjtfeajc gv Hfjbc _3[ ft
th`ua fa Lfezwj 4!7! Shj nkj h`bcjw cfnkjsjw unt 7: kk! Shj nkkn+
gfbfsv bfkfst `l shj d`kgzts`w ujwj cjsjwkfajc jkyfwfdnbbv gv Hfjbc l`w `yja
nac dh`ojc d`kgzts`w jxfst! Shj wjtzbst l`w nkkngfbfsv bfkfst l`w shj dntj
34
8/3/2019 Dominic Carolan Revised
46/145
`l na `yja jxfs nwj yb`ssjc fa Lfezwj 7!>!
Shft nkj h`bcjw nwwnaejkjas unt l`zac s` nbb`u d`kgztsf`a s` `ddzw
`|jw n wnaej `l j~zf|nbjadj wnsf`t djasjwjc ng`zs shj ts`fdhf`kjswfd wnsf`! Fa
k`ts dntjt `yjwnsf`a wjtzbsjc fa d`asfaz`zt nac |jwv b`zc shjwk`nd`ztsfd
fatsngfbfsv! Shj wjtzbst th`u shns `yjwnsfae gjb`u na j~zf|nbjadj wnsf `l
9!5 ft fky`ttfgbj l`w shft ynwsfdzbnw djaswj g`cv tsngfbftjc nkj! Ufsh shj
nccfsf`a `l na jxfs a`}}bj `l nwjn wnsf` 9!>" shj wnaej unt jjdsf|jbv wjczdjc
s` n tfaebj `yjwnsfae y`fas! Shft y`fas `ddzwwjc ns w`zehbv ts`fdhf`kjswfd
j~zf|nbjadj wnsf` ns n Kndh azkgjw tzffldfjas s` dnztj shj c`uatswjnk a`}}bj
s` gjd`kj dh`ojc!
Lfezwj 4!7= Tjdsf`a shw`zeh shj nkj h`bcjw
4!>!4 U`wofae tjdsf`a
Shj `wfefanb u`wofae tjdsf`a cjtfeajc gv Hfjbc _3[ unt fasjacjc s` nbb`u
jntv wjybndjkjas ufsh n ebntt |fjufae szgj nt wj~zfwjc! H`uj|jw cfjwjasfnb
hjnsfae nac jxynatf`a `l shj tsnfabjtt tsjjb szgj wjbnsf|j s` shj sfj w`ct bjncs` tfeafdnas ybntsfd cjl`wknsf`a `l shj naejt nac tsjjb szgj! Tjnbfae `l shj
szgj unt nbt` n yw`gbjk! L`w shjtj wjnt`at shj wjk |ngbj u`wofae tjdsf`a
unt wjybndjc ufsh n tfkybjw naejc yfyj tjdsf`a l`w shj jxyjwfkjast! T`dojst
ujwj ujbcjc s` shj szgj s` nbb`u ssfae `l shj shjwk`d`zybjt nac ywjttzwj
swnatczdjwt! Shj jact `l shj shjwk`d`zybjt ujwj y`tfsf`ajc fa shj `u ns
nyyw`xfknsjbv >9 kk lw`k shj fatfcj unbb `l shj yfyj" uhfdh hnc na fasjwanb
33
8/3/2019 Dominic Carolan Revised
47/145
cfnkjsjw `l :9 kk! Lfezwj 4!4 th`ut shj k`cfjc u`wofae tjdsf`a!
Lfezwj 4!4= K`cfjc d`kgzts`w u`wofae tjdsf`a
4!7 Shjwk`d`zybjt
W+svyj shjwk`d`zybjt (ybnsfazkybnsfazk 85 *" wh`cfzk >4*& ujwj ztjc!
Shj kjbsfae sjkyjwnszwj `l yzwj ybnsfkzk ft 793: O! Sngbjt `l W+svyj shjw+
k`d`zybj |`bsnejt l`w n bnwej sjkyjwnszwj wnaej nwj n|nfbngbj l`w c`uab`nc
lw`k shj AFTS `abfaj cnsngntj _39[! Shj sjkyjwnszwjt jad`zasjwjc c`ua+
tswjnk `l shj ywjkfxjc nkj fa shj jxyjwfkjas unt ujbb gjb`u shj shjw+
k`d`zybj kjbsfae y`fas! Shj knxfkzk sjkyjwnszwj `gtjw|jc czwfae shj
jxyjwfkjast unt nyyw`xfknsjbv >599 O!
4!7!> Nttjkgbv `l shj shjwk`d`zybjt
Shj tfkybj ty`s ujbcfae kjsh`c cjtdwfgjc gv Hnws nac Jbofa _3>[ unt ztjc s`
d`aajds shj aj shjwk`d`zybj ufwjt! N CD dfwdzfs ufsh n ewnyhfsj ajensf|j
jbjdsw`cj unt ztjc! Shj shjwk`d`zybj mzadsf`a d`aajdsjc s` shj y`tfsf|j
jbjdsw`cj unt k`kjasnwfbv s`zdhjc ufsh shj ewnyhfsj jbjdsw`cj nt th`ua fa
3:
8/3/2019 Dominic Carolan Revised
48/145
Lfezwj 4!3= Ty`s ujbcfae `l shjwk`d`zybj (N& ztfae ewnyhfsj jbjdsw`cj (G&
Lfezwj 4!3! Hnws nac Jbofa kjasf`ajc shns shj y`bnwfsv `l shj dfwdzfs unt
fky`wsnas l`w ywj|jasfae dnwg`a cjy`tfst fa shj ujbc!
Kzbsf+tswnac d`yyjw ufwjt ujwj yzbbjc shw`zeh djwnkfd szgfae nac sfjc
s` shj :9 kfdw`a cfnkjsjw shjwk`d`zybj ufwjt! Shft unt l`zac s` gj shj
k`ts wjbfngbj kjsh`c `l m`fafae shj ufwjt! Shj d`yyjw ufwjt ujwj shja yzbbjcgndo fatfcj shj djwnkfd szgjt!
Shj tknbb shjwk`d`zybj mzadsf`at ujwj kncj gv suftsfae s`ejshjw shj
ynfw `l 9!997 fadh (:9 kfdw`a& cfnkjsjw ufwjt nac shja ty`s ujbcfae shjk
s`ejshjw! N CD y`ujw tzyybv unt ztjc nac n 9!: kk ewnyhfsj yjadfb bjc
(nssndhjc s` shj ajensf|j sjwkfanb `l shj y`ujw tzyybv& unt k`kjasnwfbv
s`zdhjc `a shj suftsjc ufwjt (nssndhjc s` shj y`tfsf|j jbjdsw`cj&! Fs unt
l`zac shns gv ztfae shft kjsh`c nac ojjyfae shj |`bsnej s` n ng`zs >7\ a`
bnwej gjnct ujwj l`wkjc! Ns hfehjw |`bsnejt (ng`zs 73\& `ddntf`anbbv gjnct
cfc l`wk ns shj jac `l shj ufwjt" nbsh`zeh shft unt a`s wjyjnsngbj nac knv
hn|j hnc bfssbj jjds `a shj sfkj d`atsnas `l shj ufwjt!
Gfeejw shjwk`d`zybj gjnct ujwj kncj gv ztfae na `xvndjsvbjaj nkj
ztfae shj yw`djczwj cjtdwfgjc gv Hfjbc _3[! H`uj|jw shft kjsh`c wjtzbsjc fa
n |jwv tb`u wjty`atj shjwk`d`zybj zabjtt shj gjnct ujwj nssjajc!
3
8/3/2019 Dominic Carolan Revised
49/145
Lfezwj 4!:= Shjwk`d`zybj dfwdzfs lw`k Nanb`e Cj|fdjt _8[
4!7!7 Shjwk`d`zybj tfeanb d`acfsf`afae
Shjwk`d`zybj d`bc mzadsf`a d`kyjatnsf`a knv gj c`aj ztfae hnwcunwj `w
t`lsunwj! Hfts`wfdnbbv na fdj gnsh unt ztjc s` yw`|fcj shj wjljwjadj sjkyjw+
nszwj! L`w ywndsfdnb wjnt`at shjtj hn|j gjja wjybndjc gv jbjdsw`afd fdj y`fast
nac t`lsunwj d`kyjatnsf`a! Shj `g|f`zt nc|nasnej ft shns shjwj ft a` ajjc
s` wjybndj shj fdj! N ztjlzb a`sj `a shj nyybfdnsf`a `l shjwk`d`zybjt fadbzc+fae d`bc mzadsf`a d`kyjatnsf`a ft yw`|fcjc gv Y`ssjw _37[! N shjwk`d`zybj
tfeanb d`acfsf`afae g`nwc unt d`atswzdsjc l`w shj tfx shjwk`d`zybjt! Shj
tvtsjk d`atftsjc `l tfx NC fatswzkjas nkybfjwt ufsh ywjtjs enfa `l >99!
Shj dfwdzfs ft th`ua fa Lfezwj 4!:!
Sjtsfae shj shjwk`d`zybj tfeanb d`acfsf`afae
Shj tfeanb lw`k na nkybfjc shjwk`d`zybj unt d`kynwjc s` shj wnu tfeanb`l na ncmndjas nac ajnwbv fcjasfdnb shjwk`d`zybj s` `gtjw|j shj jjds `l shj
tfeanb d`acfsf`afae! N th`ws sjts tfeanb unt yw`|fcjc gv bfehsfae shj nkj fa
shj d`kgzts`w nac shja szwafae shj lzjb `! Lfezwj 4!< nac Lfezwj 4!5 th`u
shj wnu nac nkybfjc tfeanbt" wjtyjdsf|jbv! Shj jjds `l shj fatswzkjasnsf`a
nkybfjwt fa fkyw`|fae shj tfeanb s` a`ftj wnsf` ft dbjnw!
35
8/3/2019 Dominic Carolan Revised
50/145
Lfezwj 4!
8/3/2019 Dominic Carolan Revised
51/145
4!7!4 Shjwk`d`zybj d`bc d`kyjatnsf`a
Shj sjkyjwnszwj `l shj d`bc mzadsf`at fatfcj shj tfeanb d`acfsf`afae g`x unt
kjntzwjc ztfae n BK44: t`bfc tsnsj sjkyjwnszwj tjat`w! Shj wjtzbsfae d`bc
mzadsf`a sjkyjwnszwj kjntzwjkjas unt d`a|jwsjc s` na j~zf|nbjas shjwk`+
d`zybj |`bsnej ztfae shj AFTS W+svyj shjwk`d`zybj b``ozy sngbj nt unt
ztjc l`w d`a|jwsfae lw`k shjwk`d`zybj | bsnej s` sjkyjwnszwj! Shj shjw+
k`d`zybj d`bc d`kyjatnsf`a ft c`aj nt ynws `l y`ts yw`djttfae gv nccfae
shft d`bc mzadsf`a |`bsnej s` shj shjwk`d`zybj tfeanb gjl`wj d`a|jwtf`a s`
sjkyjwnszwj! Shj KNSBNG d`cj l`w fky`wsfae shj b``ozy sngbj nac d`a+
|jwtf`a gjsujja sjkyjwnszwj nac | bsnej ft fadbzcjc fa Nyyjacfx G! Shj
shjwk`d`zybj |`bsnej ft yb`ssjc nenfats sjkyjwnszwj fa Lfezwj N!>!
4!7!3 Shjwk`d`zybj sfkj d`atsnas jtsfknsf`a
Jtsfknsf`a `l shj ndsznb zdsznsfae ent sjkyjwnszwj ns hfehjw lwj~zjadfjt
ft d`kybfdnsjc gv shj afsj tyjjc `l wjty`atj `l shj shjwk`d`zybj! Shj lwj+
~zjadv wjty`atj `l n shjwk`d`zybj ft n cfffldzbs ynwnkjsjw s` jtsfknsj gntjc
`a jkyfwfdnb cnsn gjdnztj shj hjns swnatljw kjdhnaftk ft ywfknwfbv d`a|jd+
sf|j" nac shjwjl`wj shj wnsj `l hjns swnatljw ft cjyjacjas `a shj b`dnb yw`y+
jwsfjt `l shj `u uhfdh cjsjwkfaj shj g`zacnwv bnvjw shfdoajtt nw`zac shj
shjwk`d`zybj! Fs ft ywjljwngbj shja shns shj lwj~zjadv wjty`atj gj kjntzwjc
cfwjdsbv! Swncfsf`anb kjsh`ct ztjc s` kjntzwj lwj~zjadv wjty`atj ztznbbv
wj~zfwj shj nyybfdnsf`a `l n oa`ua fkyzbtj" tsjy lzadsf`a" yjwf`cfd `w j|ja
wnac`k tfeanb s` shj fayzs `l shj tvtsjk! Shj `zsyzs lw`k shj tvtsjk ft
kjntzwjc nac nb`ae ufsh shj fayzs ztjc s` jtsfknsj shj tvtsjkt wjty`atj!
H`uj|jw fa shj dntj `l shj shjwk`d`zybj b`dnsjc fa n `u c`uatswjnk `l
n nkj" shj fayzs lzadsf`a ft zaoa`ua nt shft ft shj ndsznb zdsznsfae ent
sjkyjwnszwj! Shjwjl`wj n cfjwjas nyyw`ndh ft wj~zfwjc! Fl n wts `wcjw tvt+
sjk wjty`atj ft nttzkjc l`w n ynfw `l shjwk`d`zybjt `l cfjwfae tf}jt ztjc
36
8/3/2019 Dominic Carolan Revised
52/145
s` kjntzwj shj sjkyjwnszwj ns n y`fas" shja shj cnsn `gsnfajc lw`k shj
su` shjwk`d`zybjt tzgmjds s` nyyw`xfknsjbv shj tnkj zaoa`ua" wnac`kbv
|nwvfae ent sjkyjwnszwj knv gj ztjc s` t`b|j l`w shj sfkj d`atsnast `l shj
shjwk`d`zybjt _7[! Fa ywndsfdj shj yw`gbjk ft d`kybfdnsjc lzwshjw tfadj shj
tjatfsf|fsv `l shjwk`d`zybj svyjt tzfsjc s` shj sjkyjwnszwj wnaej jxyjdsjc
fa n d`kgzts`w ft tzdh shns jbjdswfdnb a`ftj knv gj tfeafdnas ns hfehjw lwj+
~zjadfjt!
4!7!: Jtsfknsfae shj sfkj d`atsnas ztfae gntfd shj`wv
Shj shjwkd`d`zybjt ztjc fa shj jxyjwfkjas knv gj nttzkjc s` gjhn|j nt n
wts `wcjw tvtsjk! Shzt" shj dhnaej fa sjkyjwnszwj `l shj shjwk`d`zybj S
ft nttzkjc s` l`bb`u shj wts `wcjw cfjwjasfnb j~znsf`a `gsnfajc ztfae shj
wts bnu `l shjwk`cvankfdt
cS
cs/ S ; Se " (4!>&
uhjwj Se ft shj dhnaej fa shj ent sjkyjwnszwj nac ft shj sfkj d`atsnas `lshj tvtsjk cjsjwkfajc gv shj shjwknb wjtftsnadj W nac dnyndfsnadj D `l shj
shjwk`d`zybjent tvtsjk
; WD ! (4!7&
Shj sfkj d`atsnas unt jtsfknsjc ztfae n bzkyjc shjwknb dnyndfsnadj
k`cjb! Shj shjwknb dnyndfsnadj ft czj s` shj cjatfsv nac tyjdfd hjns dy `l
shj shjwk`d`zybj kjsnb nac shj |`bzkj `l shj shjwk`d`zybj! Shj ej`kjswv
`l n shjwk`d`zybj mzadsf`a l`wkjc ufsh`zs n tzgtsnasfnb ujbc gjnc knv gjnyyw xfknsjc nt n dvbfacjw `l tnkj cfnkjsjw nt shj ufwj _34[! Shj shjwknb
dnyndfsnadj l`w n tjdsf`a `l dvbfacwfdnb ufwj `l j~znb bjaesh nac cfnkjsjw ft
ef|ja gv
D ;C4dy
3! (4!4&
Shj shjwknb wjtftsnadj gjsujja shj zfc nac shj ufwj ft czj s` shj d`a|jdsf|j
nac d`aczdsf|j wjtftsnadjt fa tjwfjt! Shj wjtftsnadj s` shjwknb d`aczdsf`a
:9
8/3/2019 Dominic Carolan Revised
53/145
knv gj ajebjdsjc l`w n |jwv tknbb shjwk`d`zybj fa n hfehbv d`a|jdsf|j `u!
Nttzkfae shj shjwk`d`zybj ufwj ft na faafsj dvbfacjw" shj shjwknb wjtftsnadj
`l n tjdsf`a `l ufwj `l j~znb bjaesh nac cfnkjsjw ft
W ;>
hC7" (4!3&
uhjwj h ft shj hjns swnatljw d`jffldfjas uhfdh ufbb cjyjac `a shj yw`yjwsfjt `l
shj zfc nac shj shfdoajtt `l shj shjwknb g`zacnwv bnvjw nt ufbb gj cftdzttjc
fa shj ajxs tjdsf`a! Shj sfkj d`atsnas ft ef|ja gv
; WD ; Cdy
3h! (4!:&
Shj hjns swnatljw d`jffldfjas l`w shj dntj `l shj dh`ojc jxfs unt jtsfknsjc
ztfae n shj`wjsfdnb hjns swnatljw k`cjb! Shj cjafsf`a `l shj Azttjbs azkgjw
A z knv gj wjnwwnaejc s` ef|j shj d`a|jdsf|j hjns swnatljw d`jffldfjas h
h ;oeC
Az " (4!
8/3/2019 Dominic Carolan Revised
54/145
Shj Azttjbs azkgjw wjbnsf`a ztjc hjwj vfjbct n tfkfbnw wjtzbs s` shj wjbn+
sf`a ztjc gv Hfjbc _3[ snoja lw`k Wjljwjadj _3:[ uhfdh ft
A z ; 7 / 9!
7 Y w>
4 " (4!8&
uhjwj Y w ft shj Ywnacsb azkgjw! L`w nfw ns >499 O" Y w ; 9!5>6! Ztfae shft
wjbnsf`a vfjbct n sfkj d`atsnas `l : kt d`wwjty`acfae s` n dzs` lwj~zjadv `l
44 H}! Fs ufbb gj th`ua fa shj ajxs tjdsf`a shns shj sfkj d`atsnas jtsfknsjc
hjwj ft d`atftsjas ufsh shj wnaej `l |nbzjt `gsnfajc jxyjwfkjasnbbv ztfae shj
Tswnhbj kjsh`c!
4!7!< Jtsfknsfae shj shjwk`d`zybj sfkj d`atsnas zt+
fae Tswnhbjt _7[ kjsh`c
Shj sjdhaf~zj cj|jb`yjc gv Tswnhbj nac Kzshzowfthana _7[ unt fkybjkjasjc
s` jtsfknsj shj shjwk`d`zybj sfkj d`atsnas! Shj wjtzbst ujwj d`kynwjc ufsh
shj sjdhaf~zj cjtdwfgjc gv Snenun" Ons` nac @hsn _4[!
Fa g`sh kjsh`ct fs ft nttzkjc shns su` shjwk`d`zybjt `l cfjwjas sfkj
d`atsnas nwj tyndjc db`tjbv ja`zeh shns shjv nwj jxy`tjc s` shj tnkj wna+
c`kbv |nwvfae sjkyjwnszwj! Shj nc|nasnej `l g`sh shj Tswnhbj nac Snenun
kjsh`ct `|jw swncfsf`anb kjsh`ct `l shjwk`d`zybj sfkj d`atsnas kjntzwj+
kjas ft shns shj sfkj d`atsnast nwj jtsfknsjc ztfae cnsn lw`k shj ndsznb
jxyjwfkjas! K`ts `shjw kjsh`ct `l shjwk`d`zybj sfkj d`atsnas jtsfknsf`a
wj~zfwj n tjynwnsj sjts tjszy ufsh d`aswf|jc d`acfsf`at s` wjybfdnsj shj d`a+
cfsf`at `l shj jxyjwfkjas!
Shj gntfd tsjyt `l shj Tswnhbj kjsh`c ufbb gj jxybnfajc hjwj! Shj shjw+
k`d`zybjt nwj nttzkjc s` gjhn|j nt n wts `wcjw tvtsjk! Shj shjwk`d`zybj
tfeanbt lw`k su` db`tjbv tyndjc shjwk`d`zybjt S D> nac S D7" `l cfjwfae
sfkj d`atsnas ujwj ztjc! Shj L`zwfjw swnatl`wk `l shj tfeanbt V> nac V7 nwj
:7
8/3/2019 Dominic Carolan Revised
55/145
wjbnsjc s` shj L`zwfjw swnatl`wk `l shj ent sjkyjwnszwj Se gv
V> ;Se
>V> / >" (4!6&
V7 ;Se
7V7 / >! (4!>9&
Shj L`zwfjw swnatl`wk `l shj shjwk`d`zybj tfeanbt V> nac V7 unt ztjc s`
jtsfknsj shj y`ujw tyjdswzk T>> nac T7> `l shjwk`d`zybjt! Shj wnsf` W `l
T>> s` T7> ft ef|ja gv
W ;T>>T7>
V> V>V7 V> ! (4!>>&
Tzgtsfszsf`a `l j~znsf`at 4!6 nac 4!>9 fas` 4!>> vfjbct
W ;(> 7V7&(> / 7V7&
(> >V>&(> / >V>&! (4!>7&
Snofae shj fknefanwv ynws `l j~znsf`a4!>7 vfjbct
Wf ;(> 7&
> / 77>! (4!>4&
Cfjwjasfnsfae j~znsf`a 4!>4 nac tjssfae shj wjtzbs s` }jw` nbb`ut shj b`dnsf`a
`l shj lwj~zjadv `l shj jxswjkn j (shj dzs` lwj~zjadv `l S D>& gv
(> 7&(> / 7j
7> & 7
7j
7> (> 7&
(> / 77> &7
; 9 ! (4!>3&
Shj jxswjkn ft l`zac ns
j ;>
>! (4!>:&
Shj yw`djczwj ztjc s` cjsjwkfaj shj shjwk`d`zybj sfkj d`atsnas gjena ufsh
yb`ssfae Wf nenfats lwj~zjadv! Shja shj lwj~zjadv ns shj jxswjkzk j `l Wf
unt ztjc s` cjsjwkfaj shj sfkj d`atsnas > `l shj wts shjwk`d`zybj! Fs knv
nbt` gj th`ua shns shj wjnb ynws `l shj wnsf` Ww d`wwjty`act s` shj wnsf` `l
> s` 7 nt ! Shj wjnb ynws unt nbt` yb`ssjc t` shns shj sfkj d`atsnas
`l shj tjd`ac shjwk`d`zybj d`zbc gj `gsnfajc ztfae shj wjtzbs l`w shj wts
shjwk`d`zybj nac shft wnsf`!
:4
8/3/2019 Dominic Carolan Revised
56/145
Shj d`hjwjadj lzadsf`a 7 unt nbt` yb`ssjc l`w jndh sjts! Shj d`hjwjadj
lzadsf`a (nbt` oa`ua nt shj d`hjwjadj t~znwjc lzadsf`a& ft cjajc nt
7 ;T>7T7>T>>T77
! (4!>! Fs knv gj yw`|jc
shns _37T7> T>>T77 ! (4!>5&
N |nbzj l`w shj d`hjwjadj lzadsf`a db`tj s` `aj shjwjl`wj facfdnsjt shns shj
su` tfeanbt nwj wjbnsjc gv n tfaebj fayzs tfaebj `zsyzs (TFT@& bfajnw swnatljw
lzadsf`a! N |nbzj `l d`hjwjadj bjtt shna `aj knv facfdnsj shns wnac`k a`ftj
ft ywjtjas fa shj tfeanbt `w shns n TFT@ k`cjb ft fatzffldfjas s` cjtdwfgj shj
`|jwnbb tvtsjk! Shj yb`st `l d`hjwjadj lzadsf`a |jwtzt lwj~zjadv d`atftsjasbv
th`ujc n |nbzj `l shj d`hjwjadj lzadsf`a ajnw `aj ns shj lwj~zjadv ns uhfdh
shj sfkj d`atsnas unt cjsjwkfajc!
4!7!5 Jtsfknsfae shj shjwk`d`zybj sfkj d`atsnas zt+
fae Snenunt _4[ kjsh`c
Bfoj shj Tswnhbj kjsh`c shj Snenun _4[ kjsh`c nbt` nttzkjt n wts `wcjw
wjty`atj l`w shj shjwk`d`zybj `zsyzs! Shj L`zwfjw swnatl`wk `l jndh `l
shj su` shjwk`d`zybj |`bsnejt nwj `gsnfajc! Shj |nbzjt `l > nac 7 nwj
shja dnbdzbnsjc t` nt s` kfafkf}j shj lwj~zjadv n|jwnejc jww`w gjsujja shj
L`zwfjw swnatl`wkt `l shj jtsfknsjt l`w shj swzj ent sjkyjwnszwj Se> nac
Se7! Shj lwj~zjadv wnaej `|jw uhfdh shj n|jwnefae ft c`aj kzts gj dh tja
dnwjlzbbv t` nt s` jxdbzcj hfeh lwj~zjadv ynwst `l shj tyjdswzk shns nwj d`w+
wzysjc gv a`ftj! Shjwjl`wj shj dh`fdj `l shj knxfkzk lwj~zjadv th`zbc gj
wjbnsjc s` shj tfeanb s` a`ftj wnsf` ns |nwf`zt lwj~zjadfjt! Fs hnt nbt` gjja
th`ua shns shj lwj~zjadv wnaej ztjc fa shj n|jwnefae ajjc a`s jxdjjc shj
dzs` lwj~zjadv! Shj a`ftj ``w unt ztjc nt shj wjljwjadj s` cjsjwkfaj na
:3
8/3/2019 Dominic Carolan Revised
57/145
nyyw`ywfnsj knxfkzk lwj~zjadv! Shj knxfkzk lwj~zjadv knv gj dh`tja
nwgfswnwfbv ns nav y`fas gjb`u shj lwj~zjadv ns uhfdh shj tfeanb dw`ttjt shj
a`ftj ``w! Fs unt l`zac shns wjtzbs l`w shj sfkj d`atsnas unt hfehbv cjyja+
cjas `a shj knxfkzk lwj~zjadv dh`tja fa dntjt ufsh j|ja tknbb nk`zast `l
a`ftj!
Fa shj a`ftj lwjj tfkzbnsf`a shj Av~zfts lwj~zjadv (>9 oH}& unt ztjc nt
shj knxfkzk lwj~zjadv nac shj d`wwjds wjtzbs l`w shj sfkj d`atsnast unt
`gsnfajc! H`uj|jw ztfae shj Av~zfts lwj~zjadv s` fkybjkjas shj Snenun
kjsh`c `a wjnb cnsn wjtzbsjc fa jww`aj`zt wjtzbst! N cfjwjas nyyw`ndh unt
nc`ysjc nt ztjc gv Snenun! Shft nyyw`ndh fa|`b|jc yb`ssfae shj dnbdzbnsjc
sfkj d`atsnas |jwtzt shj knxfkzk lwj~zjadv ztjc l`w shj kjsh`c! Snenun
`gsnfajc shj d`wwjds wjtzbst ztfae n knxfkzk lwj~zjadv `l ng`zs sja sfkjt
shj dnbdzbnsjc sfkj d`atsnas!
4!7!8 D`kynwfae Tswnhbjt _7[ nac Snenunt _4[ kjsh+
`ct `a tfkzbnsjc cnsn
Shj Tswnhbj kjsh`c unt wts sjtsjc ztfae tfkzbnsjc cnsn! Na nwwnv `l wna+
c`k azkgjwt unt ejajwnsjc s` wjywjtjas shj wnu sjkyjwnszwj tfeanb l`w g`sh
shjwk`d`zybjt! Shft tfeanb unt bsjwjc shw`zeh su` tjynwnsj wts `wcjw b`u
yntt bsjwt ufsh cfjwfae sfkj d`atsnast wjywjtjasfae shj lnts nac tb`u shjw+
k`d`zybj! Shj wncfna lwj~zjadv j `l shj sw`zeh fa shj fknefanwv ynws `l
shj wnsf` W |jwtzt lwj~zjadv fa Lfezwjt 4!8 d`wwjty`act s` shj sfkj d`atsnas
> `l > kfbbftjd`ac `l shj lntsjw shjwk`d`zybj ndd`wcfae s` j~znsf`a 4!>:! L`w
tfeanbt lwjj `l fad`hjwjas a`ftj g`sh kjsh`ct th`ujc e``c newjjkjas l`w shj
jtsfknsjc nac ndsznb sfkj d`atsnas ztjc fa shj tfkzbnsf`a!
Shj yw`djczwj unt wjyjnsjc ztfae n cfjwjas nwwnv `l wnac`k azkgjwt
nccjc s` `aj `l shj tfeanbt s` wjywjtjas fad`hjwjas wnac`k a`ftj! Shft hnt
shj jjds `l `gtdzwfae shj jxswjkn nt th`ua fa Lfezwjt 4!6 nac 4!>9! \nwf`zt
::
8/3/2019 Dominic Carolan Revised
58/145
Lfezwj 4!8= Wf (/&" Ww (& nac 7 (!& |jwtzt lwj~zjadv l`w n tfkzbnsf`a ufsh
sfkj d`atsnast > nac 7 kt ufsh`zs a`ftj
wnsf`t `l shjwk`d`zybj sfkj d`atsnast ujwj sjtsjc! Fa shj dntj `l shjwk`d`z+
ybj ynfwt ufsh |jwv tfkfbnw sfkj d`atsnast shj jxswjkn ft nbk`ts d`kybjsjbv
`gtdzwjc l`w n tfeanb s` a`ftj wnsf` `l 7: nt dna gj tjja fa Lfezwj 4!>9!
Fs unt cjsjwkfajc lw`k shj tfkzbnsf`a wjtzbst shns n bnwej sfkj d`atsnas
wnsf u`zbc gj ywjljwwjc l`w shj ndsznb kjntzwjkjast! Fa ywndsfdj shj sfkj
d`atsnas wnsf` unt cfffldzbs s` d`asw`b ztfae shjwk`d`zybjt `l shj tnkj ufwj
cfnkjsjw! Cfjwjas sjdhaf~zjt ujwj ztjc s` knoj shj bnwej nac tknbb shjw+
k`d`zybj gjnct! Shj sjdhaf~zjt ujwj cjtdwfgjc fa Tjdsf`a 4!7!>!
Ufsh`zs shj nccfsf`a `l a`ftj shj Snenun kjsh`c ef|jt shj d`wwjds sfkj
d`atsnas l`w g`sh shjwk`d`zybjt! H`uj|jw shj kjsh`c ft |jwv tjatfsf|j s`
fad`hjwjas a`ftj! Shft ft th`ua fa Lfezwj 4!>>! Shj tnkj ynfw `l sfkj
d`atsnast > nac >!7: kt ujwj ztjc gzs shj wjtzbs ft |jwv cjyjacjas `a shj
knxfkzk lwj~zjadv ztjc l`w shj d`kyzsnsf`a! Fa shft dntj n wjnt`angbv e``c
jtsfknsj `l shj sfkj d`atsnas u`zbc gj y`ttfgbj gv dh``tfae shj lwj~zjadv
:
8/3/2019 Dominic Carolan Revised
59/145
Lfezwj 4!6= Wf (/&" Ww (& nac 7 (!& |jwtzt lwj~zjadv l`w n tfkzbnsf`a ufsh
sfkj d`atsnast > nac 7 kt ufsh fad`hjwjas a`ftj (TA wnsf`;7&
Lfezwj 4!>9= Wf (/&" Ww (& nac 7 (!& |jwtzt lwj~zjadv l`w n tfkzbnsf`a ufsh
sfkj d`atsnast > nac >!7: kt ufsh fad`hjwjas a`ftj (TA wnsf`;7&
:5
8/3/2019 Dominic Carolan Revised
60/145
Lfezwj 4!>>= Sfkj d`atsnas l`w tfkzbnsf`a SD>t (/& nac SD7t (& |jwtzt
knxfkzk lwj~zjadv ztjc (TA wnsf`;>9999&
wnaej l`w shj d`kyzsnsf`a s` gj ufshfa n cjdncj `l shj dzs` lwj~zjadv!
D`kynwjc s` shj Tswnhbj kjsh`c" shj Snenun kjsh`c d`kyzsjt shj wj+
tzbs cfwjdsbv ufsh`zs shj ajjc s` b`dnsj na jxswjkn fa n yb`s! Shft hnt na
nc|nasnej `l wjk`|fae tzgmjdsf|fsv lw`k shj nanbvtft gzs ft bjtt fbbztswnsf|j
`l shj zadjwsnfasv fa shj wjtzbs! Shj Tswnhbj kjsh`c ft lnw k`wj ztjlzb fa
hfehbfehsfae dntjt ufsh fad`hjwjas a`ftj fa shj tfeanbt uhfdh bjnc s` jww`+
aj`zt wjtzbst! Shj Snenun kjsh`c ft nbt` |jwv tjatfsf|j s` shj lwj~zjadv
wnaej ztjc s` nyybv shj kjsh`c nac shjwjl`wj fs ft d`atfcjwjc faljwf`w s` shj
Tswnhbj kjsh`c!
:8
8/3/2019 Dominic Carolan Revised
61/145
4!7!6 D`kynwfae Tswnhbjt _7[ nac Snenunt _4[ kjsh+
`ct `a Gzatja gzwajw sjts cnsn
N gzatja gzwajw nkj unt ztjc s` hjns n ynfw `l shjwk`d`zybjt `zstfcj
`l shj d`kgzts`w nt n lzwshjw sjts `l shj kjsh`ct! Shj shjwk`d`zybj ynfw
ujwj y`tfsf`ajc ng`|j n Gzatja gzwajw nkj nac n mjs `l nfw unt cfwjdsjc
shw`zeh shj s`y `l shj nkj `as` shj shjwk`d`zybjt nt th`ua fa Lfezwj 4!>7!
Ufsh shj fasw`czdsf`a `l shj nfw mjs shj Gzatja nkj gjdnkj th`wsjw" a`ftfjw
nac |ftfgbv k`wj szwgzbjas! Shj gnacufcsh `l shj kjntzwjc sjkyjwnszwjzdsznsf`at unt nbt` fadwjntjc!
Lfezwj 4!>4 th`ut shj shjwk`d`zybj tfeanbt lw`k shj tsnws `l shj cnsn
wjd`wc! Shj wts tfx tjd`act `l cnsn ujwj snoja gjl`wj shj nkj unt bfs! Shft
cnsn unt ztjc nt shj wjljwjadj l`w shj a`ftj ``w czwfae shj jxyjwfkjast!
Shj Gzatja gzwajw sjtst ujwj wjyjnsjc 73 sfkjt uhfbj |nwvfae shj lzjb nac
d`kywjttjc nfw `u fa na nssjkys `gtjw|j shj jjds `a shj gnacufcsh `l shj
sjkyjwnszwj cftszwgnadjt! Shj tyjdswnb cjatfsv l`w shj shjwk`d`zybj tfeanbt
nwj th`ua fa Lfezwjt 4!>3" 4!>: nac 4!>< l`w shwjj `l shj sjtst! Shj k`ts
szwgzbjas sjts dntj ft th`ua fa Lfezwj 4!>
ujwj tyndjc |jwv db`tjbv s`ejshjw nac shj tyjdswn nwj nbk`ts fcjasfdnb! Shft
sjts ft svyfdnb `l shj knm`wfsv `l sjts wjtzbst uhfdh cfc a`s th`u n ujbb cjajc
jxswjkn fa Wf!
Shj d`wwjty`acfae jxswjkn fa Wf l`w jndh `l shj sjtst nwj th`ua fa Lfezwjt
4!>8" 4!>5 nac 4!>6! Shj su` sjtst ef|fae shj dbjnwjts facfdnsf`a `l na jxswjkn
nwj th`ua fa Lfezwjt 4!>3 nac 4!>:! Fa shj k`ts szwgzbjas dntj" shj yb`s `l
Wf th`ua fa Lfezwj 4!>6 c`jt a`s hn|j na jxswjkzk!
:6
8/3/2019 Dominic Carolan Revised
62/145
Lfezwj 4!>7= Jxyjwfkjasnb tjszy
Lfezwj 4!>4= SD> nac SD7 tfeanb ns tsnws `l cnsn wjd`wc
8/3/2019 Dominic Carolan Revised
63/145
Lfezwj 4!>3= Tyjdswnb cjatfsv l`w SD> (& nac SD7 (!& nac a`ftj ``w (Gzatja
sjts := Tyjdswnb cjatfsv l`w SD> (& nac SD7 (!& nac a`ftj ``w (Gzatja
sjts >7&
8/3/2019 Dominic Carolan Revised
64/145
Lfezwj 4!>N (& nac SD7N (!& nac a`ftj ``w
(Gzatja sjts 74&
Lfezwj 4!>5= Wf (/&" Ww (& nac 7 (!& |jwtzt lwj~zjadv l`w SD> (Gzatja
sjts
8/3/2019 Dominic Carolan Revised
65/145
Lfezwj 4!>8= Wf (/&" Ww (& nac 7 (!& |jwtzt lwj~zjadv l`w SD> (Gzatja
sjts >7&
Lfezwj 4!>6= Wf (/&" Ww (& nac 7 (!& |jwtzt lwj~zjadv l`w SD> (Gzatja
sjts 74&
8/3/2019 Dominic Carolan Revised
66/145
Lfezwj 4!79= Tyjdswnb cjatfsv `l shj shjwk`d`zybj tfeanb ywjkfxjc d`kgzts`w
sjtst d`kynwjc s` shj Gzatja gzwajw sjtst
4!7!>9 D`kynwfae Tswnhbjt _7[ nac Snenunt _4[ kjsh+
`ct `a shj d`kgzts`w wfe cnsn
Fa shft tjdsf`a shj cnsn lw`k shj dh`ojc nac `yja jxfs d`kgzts`w sjtst ft
ztjc s` jtsfknsj shj shjwk`d`zybj sfkj d`atsnas `l `aj `l shj shjwk`d`zybjt
(SD3&!
N cfjwjas ynfw `l shjwk`d`zybjt ujwj ztjc fa shj d`kgzts`w sjtst d`k+
ynwjc s` shj Gzatja gzwajw sjtst! Shj ynfw ztjc fa shj d`kgzts`w sjtst ujwj
`l tfeafdnasbv cfjwjas cfnkjsjw gjnc tf}jt! Shj bnwej nac tknbb gjnct ujwjkncj gv shj ent nkj nac ujbcfae kjsh`ct wjtyjdsf|jbv! Shj nyybfdnsf`a
`l shj Tswnhbj kjsh`c s` shj cnsn l`w shj `yja nac dh`ojc jxfs dntjt en|j
shj dbjnwjts facfdnsf`a `l shj shjwk`d`zybj sfkj d`atsnas! Lfezwj 4!79 th`ut
shj shjwk`d`zybj tyjdswnb cjatfsv l`w shj `yja dh`ojc jxfs sjtst d`kynwjc s`
shj Gzatja gzwajw sjts nac shj a`ftj ``w kjntzwjc ufsh shj shjwk`d`zybjt
fatsnbbjc fa shj d`kgzts`w!
8/3/2019 Dominic Carolan Revised
67/145
Lfezwj 4!7>= Wf (/&" Ww (& nac 7 (!& |jwtzt lwj~zjadv l`w SD3 (`yja jxfs&
G`sh shj `yja nac dh`ojc jxfs dntjt wjtzbsjc fa n cftsfads sw`zeh fa Wf
ns nw`zac 39 H} s` >99 H} nt th`ua fa Lfezwjt 4!7> nac 4!77! Shj |nbzj
shns Ww nyyw`ndhjc ns hfeh lwj~zjadv th`ujc shj wnsf` `l shj shjwk`d`zybj
sfkj d`atsnast unt nyyw`xfknsjbv >!: s` 7! Shjwjl`wj n sfkj d`atsnas `l 39
H} s` >99 H} unt nttzkjc l`w shj lntsjw shjwk`d`zybj nac n sfkj d`atsnas
`l 79 H} unt nttzkjc l`w shj tb`ujw shjwk`d`zybj!
4!7!>> D`kyjatnsf`a `l shjwk`d`zybj kjntzwjkjast
Shj shjwk`d`zybj wjty`atj unt d`kyjatnsjc l`w gv nttzkfae n wts `wcjw
tvtsjk wjty`atj ufsh n sfkj d`atsnas gntjc `a shj wjtzbst `l shj ywj|f`zt
tjdsf`a!
Gnbbnasvaj nac K`tt _35[ cftdztt |nwf`zt cfjwjas kjsh`ct `l shjwk`d`z+
ybj sfkj d`atsnas d`kyjatnsf`a nac shj jww`wt czj s` shj zadjwsnfasv `l shj
sfkj d`atsnas fa shj nkj wjef`a! Hjwj shj shjwk`d`zybjt ujwj d`kyjatnsjc
nt ynws `l y`ts yw`djttfae ufsh shj `gmjdsf|j `l nbb`ufae shj shjwk`d`zybjt
8/3/2019 Dominic Carolan Revised
68/145
Lfezwj 4!77= Wf (/&" Ww (& nac 7 (!& |jwtzt lwj~zjadv l`w SD3 (dh`ojc
jxfs&
Lfezwj 4!74= Dnbdzbnsjc sfkj d`atsnas SD> (/& nac SD7 (& |jwtzt knxfkzk
lwj~zjadv ztjc (Gzatja sjts
8/3/2019 Dominic Carolan Revised
69/145
Lfezwj 4!73= Dnbdzbnsjc sfkj d`atsnas SD> (/& nac SD7 (& |jwtzt knxfkzk
lwj~zjadv ztjc (Gzatja sjts >7&
Lfezwj 4!7:= Dnbdzbnsjc sfkj d`atsnas SD3 (/& nac SD: (& |jwtzt knxfkzk
lwj~zjadv ztjc (@yja jxfs&
8/3/2019 Dominic Carolan Revised
70/145
Lfezwj 4!78&
uhjwj Sd(& ft shj d`wwjdsjc L`zwfjw swnatl`wk nac H(& ft shj wts `wcjw
swnatljw lzadsf`a ef|ja gv
8/3/2019 Dominic Carolan Revised
71/145
H(& ; >
f / >! (4!>6&
Ejajwnbbv shft ufbb hn|j shj jjds `l ewjnsbv nkybflvfae shj a`ftj ``w ns
hfeh lwj~zjadv" gzs shft th`zbc a`s hn|j n tfeafdnas jjds `a shj tfeanb ns
lwj~zjadfjt gjb`u ng`zs >99 H}!
4!4 Ywjttzwj swnatczdjwt
4!4!> Ywjttzwj swnatczdjwt nac tfeanb d`acfsf`afae
Shj ywjttzwj cftszwgnadjt ujwj kjntzwjc ztfae Ozbfsj UDS+4>7K ywjttzwj
swnatczdjwt! Shj Ozbfsj tjat`wt ywjttzwj bfajnw kjntzwjkjas wnaej ft >59
oYn enzej ufsh n knxfkzk `|jw ywjttzwj `l 439 oYn! Shj tjat`wt anszwnb
lwj~zjadv ft 739 oH}" ujbb ng`|j shj wnaej `l shj kjntzwjkjast! Shj tjat`w
ywfadfybj `l `yjwnsf`a ft n l`zw nwk Uhjnsts`aj gwfcej! Fa `wcjw s` kfafkf}j
a`ftj lw`k y`ujw tzyybfjt shj gwfcej y`ujw unt tzyybfjc gv n afaj |`bs
gnssjwv!
Shj ynfw `l ywjttzwj swnatczdjwt ujwj cvankfdnbbv (ND& d`zybjc s` n ynfw
`l NC fatswzkjas nkybfjwt nt th`ua fa Lfezwj 4!75! Shj nkybfjwt enfa
unt ywjtjs s` >99! Cvankfd d`zybfae nbb`ujc l`w gjssjw kjntzwjkjas wjt`bz+
sf`a tfadj shj kjna ywjttzwj unt wjk`|jc lw`k shj tfeanb nac shft nbt` hnc
shj nccfsf`anb jjds `l wjczdfae b`u lwj~zjadv a`ftj! Shj hfeh yntt bsjw wj+
tfts`w nac dnyndfs`w d`kgfansf`a unt jtsfknsjc s` ef|j n (+4cG& gnacufcsh
`l 5 H}! Shj ndsznb lwj~zjadv wjty`atj `l shj bsjw unt kjntzwjc gv shj
lwj~zjadv wjty`atj lzadsf`a sjdhaf~zj! N tfeanb ejajwns`w unt ztjc s` eja+
jwn