Top Banner
Discovery, Study, Classification and Modeling of Variable Stars Natalia A. Virnina Department of High and Applied Mathematics, Odessa National Maritime University, Ukraine, [email protected]
42

Discovery, Study, Classification and Modeling of Variable Stars Natalia A. Virnina Department of High and Applied Mathematics, Odessa National Maritime.

Jan 06, 2018

Download

Documents

Avice Barker

5 steps Choosing of the field and observations Searching for new variable stars Selection of comparison stars, photometry Photometric data analysis Publishing of the results
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: Discovery, Study, Classification and Modeling of Variable Stars Natalia A. Virnina Department of High and Applied Mathematics, Odessa National Maritime.

Discovery, Study, Classification and Modeling

of Variable Stars

Natalia A. Virnina

Department of High and Applied Mathematics, Odessa National Maritime University, Ukraine,

[email protected]

Page 2: Discovery, Study, Classification and Modeling of Variable Stars Natalia A. Virnina Department of High and Applied Mathematics, Odessa National Maritime.

I. Discovery of Variable Stars

Page 3: Discovery, Study, Classification and Modeling of Variable Stars Natalia A. Virnina Department of High and Applied Mathematics, Odessa National Maritime.

5 steps

• Choosing of the field and observations• Searching for new variable stars• Selection of comparison stars, photometry• Photometric data analysis • Publishing of the results

Page 4: Discovery, Study, Classification and Modeling of Variable Stars Natalia A. Virnina Department of High and Applied Mathematics, Odessa National Maritime.

1. Choosing of the field and observations

The best choice is rather small telescope with large field of view.

The best region for searching for new variables is the one (nearly) free of variables.

The chosen field could be checked with the “AAVSO variable stars plotter”: www.aavso.org/observing/charts/vsp/

Where to begin to achieve the best results?

Page 5: Discovery, Study, Classification and Modeling of Variable Stars Natalia A. Virnina Department of High and Applied Mathematics, Odessa National Maritime.

2. Search for new variable stars

1. Visual comparison of different frames (ineffective method)

2. Blinking of different frames (weakly effective method)

3. Statistical search (effective method):

VAST – for the Linux platform

C-Munipack – for the Windows platform

Page 6: Discovery, Study, Classification and Modeling of Variable Stars Natalia A. Virnina Department of High and Applied Mathematics, Odessa National Maritime.

Working with C-Munipack…

Page 7: Discovery, Study, Classification and Modeling of Variable Stars Natalia A. Virnina Department of High and Applied Mathematics, Odessa National Maritime.

Checking of the potential candidates

Page 8: Discovery, Study, Classification and Modeling of Variable Stars Natalia A. Virnina Department of High and Applied Mathematics, Odessa National Maritime.

Checking of the potential candidates

Page 9: Discovery, Study, Classification and Modeling of Variable Stars Natalia A. Virnina Department of High and Applied Mathematics, Odessa National Maritime.

Check the discovery using VizieR-service http://vizier.u-strasbg.fr/viz-bin/VizieR

Page 10: Discovery, Study, Classification and Modeling of Variable Stars Natalia A. Virnina Department of High and Applied Mathematics, Odessa National Maritime.

3. Comparison stars selection

•Important! The comparison stars have to be constant.

•Better to use several comparison stars than only one.

The standard stars in the UBVRcIc photometric system were measured in the vicinities of some variable stars by A. Henden and the AAVSO

group.

In the absence of “standard” stars in the field, the SDSS database could be used as well, if to transform u, g, r, i, z photometric data into the

standard BVRcIc

One comparison star

Five comparison stars

Page 11: Discovery, Study, Classification and Modeling of Variable Stars Natalia A. Virnina Department of High and Applied Mathematics, Odessa National Maritime.

4. Photometric data analyzing

1. Heliocentric correction.

2. Search for the period (periodogram analysis).

3. Classification.

4. Determination of extrema timings and the initial epoch.

Page 12: Discovery, Study, Classification and Modeling of Variable Stars Natalia A. Virnina Department of High and Applied Mathematics, Odessa National Maritime.

Search for the period

“Peranso”, “WinEfk”, “Period 04”…

Page 13: Discovery, Study, Classification and Modeling of Variable Stars Natalia A. Virnina Department of High and Applied Mathematics, Odessa National Maritime.

One of the most universal methods is Lafler & Kinman’s (1965) method

Search for the period

Page 14: Discovery, Study, Classification and Modeling of Variable Stars Natalia A. Virnina Department of High and Applied Mathematics, Odessa National Maritime.

Determination of variability type

Classical classification is available on the web-pagehttp://sai.msu.su/groups/cluster/gcvs/gcvs/iii/vartype.txt

intense variable X-ray sources

Groups of types of variability:

eruptive variable stars

pulsating variable stars

rotating variable stars

cataclysmic (explosive and nova-like) variables

eclipsing binary systems

Page 15: Discovery, Study, Classification and Modeling of Variable Stars Natalia A. Virnina Department of High and Applied Mathematics, Odessa National Maritime.

Determination of variability type

The most frequent types

• Eclipsing • Pulsating

Page 16: Discovery, Study, Classification and Modeling of Variable Stars Natalia A. Virnina Department of High and Applied Mathematics, Odessa National Maritime.

4. Determination of extrema timings

Page 17: Discovery, Study, Classification and Modeling of Variable Stars Natalia A. Virnina Department of High and Applied Mathematics, Odessa National Maritime.

4. Determination of extrema timings

Kwee-van Woerden (1956) method

Page 18: Discovery, Study, Classification and Modeling of Variable Stars Natalia A. Virnina Department of High and Applied Mathematics, Odessa National Maritime.

4. Determination of extrema timings

Kwee-van Woerden (1956) method

Page 19: Discovery, Study, Classification and Modeling of Variable Stars Natalia A. Virnina Department of High and Applied Mathematics, Odessa National Maritime.

Referred in the ADS:• «Variable Stars» («Переменные звёзды»)• OEJV (Open European Journal on Variable Stars)• IBVS (International Bulletin of Variable Stars)• Journal of the AAVSO (JAAVSO, eJAAVSO)

Non-Referred• Bulletin de l’AFOEV• BAV Rundbrief• The Astronomer• VSNET Circular

5. Publishing of the results

Page 20: Discovery, Study, Classification and Modeling of Variable Stars Natalia A. Virnina Department of High and Applied Mathematics, Odessa National Maritime.

II. Modeling

Page 21: Discovery, Study, Classification and Modeling of Variable Stars Natalia A. Virnina Department of High and Applied Mathematics, Odessa National Maritime.

Modeling using the Wilson-Devinney (W-D) code, Monte Carlo searching algorithm

Page 22: Discovery, Study, Classification and Modeling of Variable Stars Natalia A. Virnina Department of High and Applied Mathematics, Odessa National Maritime.

How does the W-D code with the Monte Carlo searching

algorithm work?

Page 23: Discovery, Study, Classification and Modeling of Variable Stars Natalia A. Virnina Department of High and Applied Mathematics, Odessa National Maritime.

First (initial) iteration

Page 24: Discovery, Study, Classification and Modeling of Variable Stars Natalia A. Virnina Department of High and Applied Mathematics, Odessa National Maritime.

Convergence of the iterations

Page 25: Discovery, Study, Classification and Modeling of Variable Stars Natalia A. Virnina Department of High and Applied Mathematics, Odessa National Maritime.

BM UMa (V-band)

P=0.27123d

Page 26: Discovery, Study, Classification and Modeling of Variable Stars Natalia A. Virnina Department of High and Applied Mathematics, Odessa National Maritime.

Input parametersMain parameters of the system:

i [80° .. 90°] – inclination

T1 4700 K (fixed) – temperature of the primary component

T2 [4100 K .. 5500 K] – temperature of the secondary component

q [1.5 .. 3.0] – mass ratio

Ω1 [3.95 .. 6.61] – potential of the primary component

Ω2 [3.95 .. 6.61] – potential of the secondary component

g1 0.32 (fixed) – gravity brightening of the primary component

A1 0.5 (fixed) – reflection effect for the primary component

g2 0.32 (fixed) – gravity brightening of the secondary component

A2 0.5 (fixed) – reflection effect for the primary component

e 0 (fixed) – eccentricity

p 90 (fixed) – periastron

[-0.02 .. 0.02] – phase shift

Page 27: Discovery, Study, Classification and Modeling of Variable Stars Natalia A. Virnina Department of High and Applied Mathematics, Odessa National Maritime.

Results of modelingparameters:

Inclination 86.815 ± 0.005T2 4510 ± 10

mass ratio 1.858 ± 0.001Ω1 4.986 ± 0.001

Ω2 4.986 ± 0.001

fill-out factor10.7% 0.0017

r1pole 0.31

r1side 0.32

r1back 0.36

r2pole 0.41

r2side 0.44

r2back 0.47

Page 28: Discovery, Study, Classification and Modeling of Variable Stars Natalia A. Virnina Department of High and Applied Mathematics, Odessa National Maritime.

WZ Crv – a binary system with asymmetric phase curves

Page 29: Discovery, Study, Classification and Modeling of Variable Stars Natalia A. Virnina Department of High and Applied Mathematics, Odessa National Maritime.

Temperatures and relative radiuses

Page 30: Discovery, Study, Classification and Modeling of Variable Stars Natalia A. Virnina Department of High and Applied Mathematics, Odessa National Maritime.
Page 31: Discovery, Study, Classification and Modeling of Variable Stars Natalia A. Virnina Department of High and Applied Mathematics, Odessa National Maritime.
Page 32: Discovery, Study, Classification and Modeling of Variable Stars Natalia A. Virnina Department of High and Applied Mathematics, Odessa National Maritime.

+ Spot

Page 33: Discovery, Study, Classification and Modeling of Variable Stars Natalia A. Virnina Department of High and Applied Mathematics, Odessa National Maritime.
Page 34: Discovery, Study, Classification and Modeling of Variable Stars Natalia A. Virnina Department of High and Applied Mathematics, Odessa National Maritime.
Page 35: Discovery, Study, Classification and Modeling of Variable Stars Natalia A. Virnina Department of High and Applied Mathematics, Odessa National Maritime.
Page 36: Discovery, Study, Classification and Modeling of Variable Stars Natalia A. Virnina Department of High and Applied Mathematics, Odessa National Maritime.
Page 37: Discovery, Study, Classification and Modeling of Variable Stars Natalia A. Virnina Department of High and Applied Mathematics, Odessa National Maritime.

Super-WASP observations

Mwasp=0.3528R+0.6472V-0.1213

Mwasp=580nm

Page 38: Discovery, Study, Classification and Modeling of Variable Stars Natalia A. Virnina Department of High and Applied Mathematics, Odessa National Maritime.

Fitting ParametersParameters WASP-2006 WASP-2007 WASP-2008 Our observ.

Inclination, ° 81.23 81.43 81.15 83.84

T1, K 12500 15000 14800 12830

T2, K 5650 5650 5650 5650

1 5.823 6.349 6.185 5.851

2 3.411 3.731 3.585 3.464

Mass ratio 0.796 0.958 0.898 0.807

Third light, % 7.4 11.6 8.7 2.9 (V-band)

Spot parameters

Co-latitude 69 62 30 160

Longitude 151 171 160 212

Radius 48 30 43 56

Temp. factor 0.89 0.53 0.61 0.73

Page 39: Discovery, Study, Classification and Modeling of Variable Stars Natalia A. Virnina Department of High and Applied Mathematics, Odessa National Maritime.

Spot Changes on the Primary Component

Parameters WASP-2006 WASP-2007 WASP-2008

Co-latitude, ° 75±2 51±1 41.5±0.5

Longitude, ° 155±1 167±3 154±1

Radius, ° 45±2 28±1 57±1

Temp. factor 0.874±0.006 0.595±0.002 0.853±0.001

Page 40: Discovery, Study, Classification and Modeling of Variable Stars Natalia A. Virnina Department of High and Applied Mathematics, Odessa National Maritime.

Fitting of WASP Data

2006 2007 2008

Page 41: Discovery, Study, Classification and Modeling of Variable Stars Natalia A. Virnina Department of High and Applied Mathematics, Odessa National Maritime.

ConclusionsAdvantages and Disadvantages of

W-D code with MC searching algorithm

+ – •The searching runs automatically;

•Only the borders of parameters are required;

•From the statistical point of view, the algorithm founds the best solution.

•Some parameters (mass ratio, inclination etc.) are too unsure;

•Sometimes statistically best solution is rather far from the real parameters.

Page 42: Discovery, Study, Classification and Modeling of Variable Stars Natalia A. Virnina Department of High and Applied Mathematics, Odessa National Maritime.

Thanks for attention!