Top Banner
Is Digital Resistance Reshaping the Public Sphere? Patrick P. Meier The Fletcher School at Tufts & Berkman Center, Harvard University
43

Digital Resistance in Repressive Regimes

Dec 04, 2014

Download

Business

Patrick Meier

Presentation given at the "Digital Media and Repressive Regimes" conference in Copenhagen, November 2008
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: Digital Resistance in Repressive Regimes

Is Digital ResistanceReshaping the Public Sphere?

Patrick P. Meier

The Fletcher School at Tufts &Berkman Center, Harvard University

Page 2: Digital Resistance in Repressive Regimes

1. Examples…

Page 3: Digital Resistance in Repressive Regimes

DigiActive

Page 4: Digital Resistance in Repressive Regimes

Philippines ‘01 - “Coup de Text”

DigiActive

Page 5: Digital Resistance in Repressive Regimes

Philippines ‘01 - “Coup de Text”

Spain ‘04 - “The Night of SMS”

DigiActive

Page 6: Digital Resistance in Repressive Regimes

Philippines ‘01 - “Coup de Text”

Pakistan ‘07 - “Flash Protests”

DigiActive

Spain ‘04 - “The Night of SMS”

Page 7: Digital Resistance in Repressive Regimes

Philippines ‘01 - “Coup de Text”

Tibet - “Media Blackout?”

Spain ‘04 - “The Night of SMS”

Pakistan ‘07 - “Flash Protests”

Page 8: Digital Resistance in Repressive Regimes

Tibet - “Media Blackout?”

Morocco ‘08 - “Exposing Abuse”

Spain ‘04 - “The Night of SMS”

Pakistan ‘07 - “Flash Protests”

Page 9: Digital Resistance in Repressive Regimes

Tibet - “Media Blackout?”

Morocco ‘08 - “Exposing Abuse”

Egypt - “Exposing Torture”

Pakistan ‘07 - “Flash Protests”

Page 10: Digital Resistance in Repressive Regimes

Tibet - “Media Blackout?”

Morocco ‘08 - “Exposing Abuse”

China - “Live-Twittered Arrest”

Egypt - “Exposing Torture”

Page 11: Digital Resistance in Repressive Regimes

2. Question…

Page 12: Digital Resistance in Repressive Regimes

ICT a statistically significant predictor of protests events?

Page 13: Digital Resistance in Repressive Regimes

3. Previous studies…

Page 14: Digital Resistance in Repressive Regimes

Data-driven

Page 15: Digital Resistance in Repressive Regimes

Data-driven

Eyck 2001

Page 16: Digital Resistance in Repressive Regimes

Data-driven

Eyck 2001

Stodden and Meier

2008

Page 17: Digital Resistance in Repressive Regimes

Data-driven

Eyck 2001

Stodden and Meier

2008

Page 18: Digital Resistance in Repressive Regimes

4. Data…

Page 19: Digital Resistance in Repressive Regimes

Parameters

Page 20: Digital Resistance in Repressive Regimes

Parameters

Protests

ICTs

Controls

Page 21: Digital Resistance in Repressive Regimes

Parameters

Protests

ICTs

Controls

Time period

1990-2007

country-year

Page 22: Digital Resistance in Repressive Regimes

Parameters

Protests

ICTs

Controls

Time period

1990-2007

country-year

22 regimes

Page 23: Digital Resistance in Repressive Regimes

Graphs

Page 24: Digital Resistance in Repressive Regimes

Graphs

Protests

Page 25: Digital Resistance in Repressive Regimes

Graphs

Protests

Internet

Page 26: Digital Resistance in Repressive Regimes

Graphs

Protests

InternetMobiles

Page 27: Digital Resistance in Repressive Regimes

Summary Stats

N = 396

Page 28: Digital Resistance in Repressive Regimes

5. Methods…

Page 29: Digital Resistance in Repressive Regimes

Regressions

Page 30: Digital Resistance in Repressive Regimes

Regressions

yi,t = i + 1 Inti,t +2 Mobi,t + 3 Landi,t +4 Autoci,t + 5 Unempi,t +6 GDPi,t +i,t

Page 31: Digital Resistance in Repressive Regimes

Regressions

Observed vs Projected

Page 32: Digital Resistance in Repressive Regimes

Observed vs Projected

Fi = yobs,i - ymodel,i

Page 33: Digital Resistance in Repressive Regimes

6. Findings…

Page 34: Digital Resistance in Repressive Regimes

Results*

*preliminary, subject to change

Page 35: Digital Resistance in Repressive Regimes

Results*

Internet

-0.12 (0.03)

99% sig level

Page 36: Digital Resistance in Repressive Regimes

Results*

Internet

-0.12 (0.03)

99% sig level Mobiles

-0.06 (0.06)

not significant

Page 37: Digital Resistance in Repressive Regimes

Results*

Internet

-0.12 (0.03)

99% sig level Mobiles

-0.06 (0.06)

not significant

Other

variables

not significant

Page 38: Digital Resistance in Repressive Regimes

Results*

Rsq = 0.613Rsq = 0.155

Page 39: Digital Resistance in Repressive Regimes

6. Conclusion & Next

Page 40: Digital Resistance in Repressive Regimes

Thoughts Why?

Page 41: Digital Resistance in Repressive Regimes

Thoughts Why?

Other methods?

Page 42: Digital Resistance in Repressive Regimes

Thoughts Why?

Other methods?

Field research!

Page 43: Digital Resistance in Repressive Regimes

Thank You

[email protected]

www.iRevolution.wordpress.com <- blog

Twitter @patrickmeier